35
HI$I3 siac DMDiSIOW 5I8M TMA5IUAT&I5I MI MO1TAMIMLSIDIU xa YUUT2 TIUUA MA :OT4I5HH ,h&nu*I bivU )Ifll$fl .t o$1 floM REV .0 31i)I 4O .oM 1q13 nbhoW HD$1AEI351 DIMOMO3 10 UAHS1U JAMOITAM unvA aflaudoEM OOI 8EIO AM bhdmED ?.?QI uwxd1 iw oilw innim ria,i RE Ri inbu iw noM REV briE AREH 'bnW o IuIiE1 W .133o1q ift lo nothin3rn1qmi briE nmnE1q 3di Ri Lzinrnuini ioI imi niD a,hsrlD briE uT naw oi 3nB12ia rxi nibnaiaiuo ioI boi 1uIq1rL 101 )I1rf3nM 1uB bRE iIoH vrIEH RErmbH m11 oi bRE bu3 rli iliiw nEi2i2 noiniqo riA .ibui iod&1 ni rninoiq rInsi '$I3flM 1o flEq 2i iqq ir1T .nmrno3 3imonooH lo uiiuH IsnoijEM r1i lo orLi ion bns 2lorIiuE r!i lo or1i m btqx .rt)1s25J flo .bv1a31 irih hA .riol4 REV .0 31)I AnEH .t 'o5L hmu*I bivsU d QQ1 © noiimiq 1ii1qx iuothiw bioup 3d '(j3m r1qE1E1Eq owl b3X3 01 iOn 4x31 lo noi1 .nuo 3rli 01 n3v! iion © gnibul3ni 3ib513 hlul isril b3bivolq

DMDiSIOW - NBER

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    8

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: DMDiSIOW - NBER

HI$I3 siac DMDiSIOW 5I8M

TMA5IUAT&I5I MI MO1TAMIMLSIDIU xa YUUT2 TIUUA MA :OT4I5HH

,h&nu*I bivU )Ifll$fl .t o$1

floM REV .0 31i)I

4O .oM 1q13 nbhoW

HD$1AEI351 DIMOMO3 10 UAHS1U JAMOITAM unvA aflaudoEM OOI

8EIO AM bhdmED ?.?QI uwxd1

iw oilw innim ria,i RE Ri inbu iw noM REV briE AREH

'bnW o IuIiE1 W .133o1q ift lo nothin3rn1qmi briE nmnE1q 3di Ri Lzinrnuini ioI imi niD a,hsrlD briE uT naw oi 3nB12ia rxi nibnaiaiuo ioI boi

1uIq1rL 101 )I1rf3nM 1uB bRE iIoH vrIEH RErmbH m11 oi bRE bu3 rli iliiw nEi2i2 noiniqo riA .ibui iod&1 ni rninoiq rInsi '$I3flM 1o flEq 2i iqq ir1T .nmrno3

3imonooH lo uiiuH IsnoijEM r1i lo orLi ion bns 2lorIiuE r!i lo or1i m btqx .rt)1s25J

flo .bv1a31 irih hA .riol4 REV .0 31)I AnEH .t 'o5L hmu*I bivsU d QQ1 © noiimiq 1ii1qx iuothiw bioup 3d '(j3m r1qE1E1Eq owl b3X3 01 iOn 4x31 lo noi1

.nuo 3rli 01 n3v! iion © gnibul3ni 3ib513 hlul isril b3bivolq

Page 2: DMDiSIOW - NBER

O? qn nbhoW 5I8T4 QQ1 u31nd1

TMA5IUAT$1 MI MOFFAMIM11$IDIU X3 YUUT TIUUA MA :OMI$1IH

TDA$ITflA

iii noiisnimhth x iiiavni i&li bui2 iibirn IB3-IIBm £ no 2noq5x iqq if1T

briE 11iBw i$ do ioI bilqqE nmow bns nm lo 1iEq bbisrn IdElBqmoD .nhid inffIuEi1

Q bril3 wivini oi bI noiiE3iIqqB OEI r1T .Bir1qbbEIir1 ni nsiimiai ?.ô i iiiw

ir1L6E noUEnIrnrI3th x lo 3nbiv3 1nfiini2 lls3iiiiEi bivoiq iIui r1T zio dot

ri bsrl nmow moiI anoin33ilqqa dot inE1uEie31 33hq-did iI .nEiuE31 ohq-did iii nrnow

biBmu1 ni bris ,. iuods 'd iwo1 sw isrl3 iT11o dot s nivio o iiIidsdoiq bismii

isqqs rrtnsq nhir1 rtT .k nsods 'd iwoL sw isiii w3iv1r1i nE riivioi lo ii1idsdoiq

isrli isibni zribiv 'v1u2 IsrrnoIni as arürnc ni a3n1YIib xa iol anoisi1qrni vsr1 o

.ains1usia1 3nq-fIici ni iiIirI 515 anirris

LnsH .1 oM *rsrnu*I bivsU .znJ iv stroM rriias3 airnonoo 1o 1nmiisqU

viiU xIqisinI iiaivinU 3si nEir13iM EOQ1 Aq aovsrT 88 TM niansJ sasH

5HHT4 bns

floM nsV .U 1)I (Ew)hB nu!im n OO

O€IQI Aq ,sirfqIbs1ir1

Page 3: DMDiSIOW - NBER

noituboi1nI .1

-nhhiw £ bnB no!Isqu3oo-2o13E ni olni n3Aold 3d n iw flu qs x llLl3vo r1T

Lf1 noiiEg31g noi1Equxo-eo13E 01 b1nir qs X3 3flT .In3noqmo3 noiiLquxo

3n13131q ,

(I 8Q I A3rb1oq) In3m1vni 1s11q133 nsmurf 01 b3iudhIls nd 13vi1Em31113

nn1mg13H ;8QI el3IbH) noiiBnimi13ib In3m'o1qm3 bnl3 8QI ejfl1thbflA briE 1norn'EU)

noflEnimhl32ib q iuq i1bi m noi1Equ3o niriliw niEm5I 1&ii qii x r1T .(VQI

noiiLg313 ifl31 m ii iO .l3fllonB 3110 3bigno1fi gni*low nmow briE ri3 nwd '. (8Q I thiI) "noil 31ge 1&itI3v" b311E3 miI3mo

, noi1Equ3zo nuiliiw

, do oi

.afIoiIEqU33o O1313 fOil l3 E &I0E5I mJi 3f11 iol 3211E Bffl flOi1Eg3l3 f13U2

gnomi noilEg3lg3e 1LitI3V lii noi1&iimiiib lo 31(11 3111 3iLgii3vni 3w 13E ir1i nI

ni (13V3 agiw flu qii x 3IdJBsi E 3iE3ibni O8QI-bim r1i moil LIEU .31iiEw briE 131iEw

bnE 11iEw iol 1Er1l tioq5i flnBmgl3H .

si1iiw briE 13IiLw lo no!IEqu33o worun 3111

01 3viiLISl nmow lo nini nEib3rn lo oiIEl f1i ,3mil-IIul b3*1ow 11EiJu oiiw 331flEw

nom fioiiuig31g3 IiiOiti3v 1f1im anoian3mb isfiw no1A .(4I .q ,8QI) 8. w nm

bi&L nu1aux3 on i 313111 figuorlilA cqiig gninis ir1i 01 3ludilIno3 331lisw bns 131i1iw

lEft) b313u 3vLfl i3*IEm lodEl III 33n5I3Thb x no i3flo11 inioq if11 no 33n3b1v3

nI .13f1ir1 siS qi1 bnE 51311w ,infi1us1251 I&rnol ,33hq-Iigill flu b3IovEl 31E e3ILm

3vi&13qx3 1om 'nsflEr1nsM lo tiE3fl 3111" ni lEfil 3tw 3woH ,13*ioW 1EII0D jnjq

bsiirl 113th "iflE1uLI31 fb0I331dLI" lo Iulbnfid 3v1fl3131 £ '1no 513W 313111 43i11ib InE1uEi31

JTAq 3113 lo i1EflE fiB fit b3bivolq i noi1Eg31g3 1B3!ri3v lo 3Iqmsx3 boos A' 1olibuE ,lnLInLJo33E E r13u anoilBqu33o nithiw 313111 work 3H .(48QI) gnu13i d nu

b31n331q31 13lEfl0iI10qo1q2ub 3113 nmow ,.31 ,lolsl3qo 131uqm03 ,1331s1b ,13'ud ,'3moflE 2i Eq 3E13VE ibiilw flu ("VI lnEifluoo3A" wiv "I lnElnuo33A"

, . .3) do1 bv3I-i3wol fit .13W01

3111 Iinri3q bluow lsrb SIEWE 516 3W fI3ulIw lo 13 611th 31E3-3g1EI on i 313f1T

.InE1uLI231 33r1q-wol bris -r1i1 flu 2fto13q1iEw lo flu1FIE3 lo nouiEqmo3

I

Page 4: DMDiSIOW - NBER

nwo1nwob bnB nwolqu l3dtuñ 3m11 cn di IA .gnb1or13-1&1 lud gnic1Fns iol n3rnow

oth lo 1i1om nim1dw13vo d1 r1gucuiod ilio (11 luor1uoirfI bn 1w r3r1ttl

In3mlu3q3U ..U EVQI-VQI 3(11 1i o1E 3woH .(1O1 .q VVQI) "n3mow 313w bool nivi 3d ol b3bn3I 131iEw iol doU' 1&11 gnulon loodbnEH looIluO 1Inoi1gu33O iod&I lo

ln3rnf1i1d123 13r11o bni du13 31Evhq rnooi gninib 131or1 1nE1u 31 of11 ni b3lBlln33no3

!32i331q ni 1r1gi(1 31 qii bni 113(11 mi1313 bns ", IEffnol w 3ivi 1sm 51311w

i&Ii rn11313 nnsmgl3a ,

1iiIimi (.PO I .

q) b311311n33no3 5113 131iBW (13111W 111 do1 oth

noi1Bg31g 3111 01 abs3I 1n131u13Isi flu o1qm3 3113m 13(110 bn13 331iiEw n33w13d noil3ill

1i1w f1 .

1n1nuB1si 3311q-wol 01111 asiIiEw bnE ,

1n131u13131 33i1q-rigifl 01111 I3iiEw lo

3111 lo 3i2 3111 ,

gnu1i3 uoiiuxu1 £ lo\bnE bool 3fIit 13110 113f11 1ninuEl31 nE3il3fnA 111" 1&11

inwo 3(11 , 1nsius1si 13q133f13 nI

. 2131i13w 3113m 131311113 01 f1uon3 id qi1 iol wo1li3 A33r13

01 31d13 3(1 01 1S2333n 1n31x3 1113 01 qi1 3rD ln3m3Iqqua 1113111 13r111c1 110113111 3111 (111w qu iuq

3(11 1o 'nsM" 1&11 mi1313 nrn3mg11 siorrn3r111uI .

(nQQ .

q , ô8Q 1) 131iEw 3113m 3v13f1

3r11 Ii bnE (4 I .

q) ", 311i13w 13 biir1 13V311 3vBfl I3IiEw 3113m ... 'o1qm3 huh 1ns1uE131

3(11 (111w 11irk 1n31&flib io 1n131uEl1 3(11 lo ariBq 1ri313111b 01 m3d1 b3niJ3" 3vu1 'rh1 ob

. (n4 I .

q) t'ir1gir1 3113 qii 3111 (13111w 111 a1n3nnis 3(11 nh1l 31Bm

gnoms noilEg5t3 1133zt13v 111 noi1SfIimfl3ib x 1o 3101 IEiln3loq 3111 3113gi13vni oT

33131 lo 3ibu1 no b3n131113q "bu1 hibuEt' 31133-h113m2 13

b3l3ubnoo 3W ,

32311iEw briE 131isw

O(I ,

.113 13 , oi)) 3hiflh1nI nEthU 3rD 113 213c131s331 d b3l33noiq nrnr1 flu noil13nirnu13ib

(131E3sI i lo fl6q 11E3i1i33q .(4QI 131oiW bns 3flfI3A ;IQQI ,

.113 13 13rnuT

3113m31 owl briE 3113m owl 1n3 3W 1Efliffl3 (131E331 3!fflOfIO33 3lEUbElgl3bflu ns ni 133o1q

.Euf1q13bE1ir1 111 1nE1uE131 hi 33111sw bilE 13flEw as 2dol iol Lqqs oh 21n3bu1 33h1o3

gniu b3flE1 3v1$(1 a1nE1uE131 3mo 11rI333SI" isfIl j3V3wOfl 3ob f1nEmgI3d (n4 I q) "1dE3n&13131ni 31Em31 briE 31Effl

Page 5: DMDiSIOW - NBER

lo Iog th fliiw i1Og13 3i1q-woI briE -muib3m -fIh! olni 1nE1uf3i1 th bbivib W

bnib W iog1 ohq ni ii1o dot lo iqi33 fh flu 3fl5IThb x niiJ$mii

no &b o briE iniui1i r!3E IE dot B io1 bi1qqa 1iIq 1Bm1 bnE bm B 1&li o bin ili

iqm11s 0E I riT 1ñ1n3bi E1V1 no iw ibibnB3 31 Bm31 bni 3IEm 3f11 i31 Is i3qsq

.i11o dot Qf ni b311u do nisido ol

i1q-f1gifI ni nmow iniss noiIsnimhib 1o n3biv3 gnoii 3bivolq nibnfl wO

33r1q-wol ni iovi1 'n3mow flu noiIsnimhib lo 33n3biv3 iAsw bns inE1IJEi5I

nI .nm ol 3bsm 513W 01 e

1nsiusii 33i1q-IigicI molt i311o dot I i1I 10 insiusIsi

nI .n3mow ol 3bsm 313W 311111 1n511151251 33r1q-WoI molt it1o dot 11 3111 lo 1es11no3

sis gnin1s IBILI IggIJ bui 3111 ril 1ns1usisi 3111 molt b31i1is noilsirnolni jioilibbs

isth noiIsnimi-i3ib nu1h1 in3lsqqs i11 Isth o Ins1usisi 33hq-IlgirI ni ii1ir1 11si1nsIdu

niwollo1 i1T no13qIisw gnoms gnin1s3 flu 233fl513Thb x iol noi1&)i1qmi &1 bnil w .b313311o3 w slsb iiI lo i1ns 1si1iis1 s 3bivolq bns 11iit bui fi 3di133b flOI133

but 9f1T .11

31ü 01 3Idi2oq s oh s i ol viI ol sw 'bu1 luo gni113bnu 3lqi3nhq i1T

l33qsi '(13v3 ni Is3iIn3bi sis oil w nmow bns nm lo 1isq bn :in3mn3qx3 gniwollol

3v13do bns hog3l& oi1q 1n313Thb flu Ins1us1si Is doL iol 1qqs ol 1i3fII 1q33x3

lo 1q13331 3111 flu 3111 n33w13d 33n31311ib ins3i1ingi '11B3iIil5I ns 315 313111 13111311w

153b1 ii1I 01 3o13 s 1 ol 2q31 woimun Iool 3W '1ols3 33i1q 11353 ni 1311o dot

.31dioq s rn3ml3qx3

ob oT .13q5q no lE3iIn3bi 1fl53i1qqE 315m31 bns 315m rli 315m 01 sw q312 iii1 311T

'(1oIif1 1sno13q lo rrn3I flu is1imi 3Iiup 513W isfIl fflU31 351111 lo I s b315313 w irh

x biovs ol 1s11mi2 3d 01 b3ngi23b 513W must 3r11 f1uor111A .33n3n3qx3 *10w 1sq bns

Page 6: DMDiSIOW - NBER

thilnloq &ioi1qmi ffi lii 3n13Thb 01 1thludhflE d iff im 113th mo31uo lii 3n31T1ib

13v0 ins3iIqqE doE 1i gnomi bif31o1 iw mui th mui d1 moil bnisg io1qm

mui 1i ibhtw niiub boiiq 1w-ith th ivo , 'bifl fli to iuo th

io1 mui bu nmow owl bnl3 nm owl th lo fbs lnswEl5t 1 lb bqqoib iw th lo qol rh l ln133iIqqE r11 lo iodmun nodq11 bns mn th iuo 10 .Aw no

mui rft niu noiq 11 ol bnoqiio ol bgn&k 13W fnUI

1n13iu1iJ1 1133o1 thod ni 3fI3i13qx omo brI 1n13311qq13 I1 1&li bI133ibni mui doi3

anq-r1ir1 r1i flu ln13iu13i1 moil iYto doE lo booth!liI cil 1ood oT .ni13f13 lEnonsfi bn13

01 bnib w mui f1313 nisldo ol ibi&! c1 1dim i11o b3lqw w 1f1w iol&

thug 01 vi13131ll13 in13oiIqqB n Aim ifigim 1idl b31wonA brn3 b th 'vno bisI1-1n131u13i flu inmvIovni no2 b1ibni mui th lo owl ,

i1i lo fl131 bnii li113up fIifI fll biflqm biith f1i 1ifIw ,

(gnill niw as ibu) 3i1ivil3s

niqx b113I5I-1ns1u131 bn13 ln131u13151 01 noilibbE nI 3ni1qx uoiv5Iq 1n133i!qqE

mo noii13oub !ooth-fiirI nhqx 1i13131 1131n rno b3lE3ibni o113 mui r1o13

ni) bql-x 'Ino112 Ion iw 113th 2131lni L13no1q bn13 noi1313 L13i30 flu InmvIovni

gn!bf13 1o1qm3 01 ibio ni 1113ni1 .(mui i1i u ol bsc! nmow bn13 nm

sic1q1b131if11 Iii iutnsiusit fl1o thiw i3zIno3 i13no1q r1uoith Idioq ,

*row iiiIi b1iup3s bns li 1fIi0fl13 moil mo b&! l13bibn133 3(11 113th b3l133ibni 3fflU31

xibn3qqA 3(11 flu b3oubolq5I 3113 mui ir11 3(IT ii 113th flu 33fi3fl3X3

10 ii113noi3q ni 33n313Ttib lo 1331h 3111 3iminim 01 asw q3l bno3 3rtT

113!ln3Ioq b3ln13w 3W 33fli .1131lU3fI-X3 13W 113111 3ffl13fl 13 bi1 1ubivibni 3111 lo 3n0

1113flOitibz11 in3131lib z b3u no13q if1l in133i1qq13 doE 3111 lo x fll woml 01 13'o1qm3 'buI 3111 lo 1U3 3(11 iol 3ffl13 311311131

b3k3fl3 b1311 '3f1i 113111 13'oLqm3 l13ilfI3ioq 3111 10 fl13 moil noilE3ibni on b3vi3331 3W .mui 3(11 no 33n313l3i doE 3111 flO

Page 7: DMDiSIOW - NBER

lo 1nm1 iuoI .x 01 b1sIi d ifigim iith bnE wiito dol i311E ifIim i&11 ninqq ol bu iw nrnow owl bni nm owl iwiiI .1n3no3 aifli aThbE ngib iii l11 h zub5I 01 b1qm11i w bno3 x thi, lo no iu1 n&Ii iduii

, do iol f1311

nv n niK1nuim Idi2oq ibum a 1nE3ifqqs dot 3ri1 niv&I 'd 3n111ib '1i1noiq lo

iuo 10 a1niuii1ai th rlliw 1n.1no3 I1 iuof1uoIth niiqq ii1imi bn ionmb

01 Ldioq wI i ii 1nfi3i1qq dot lo 3!qms 1g1E1 B lo ondE fli iii 'llBi33q

io 1iI1no21q ni niI1ib gniniEm1 ol rno31uo ni 33n1flib x 'n 1udi1i1E

ir!1 gni1&iimiI iii iifriu1 thum o HEi1n3ioq bui i11 lo inmb 1&IoiiibbB owT

i1q 1n5ITtib ni i11o doj lo 1qi31 i1i ni 3ni11ib x iol AooI w 1iiI .m1doiq

ir11 lIE ni biovi1 'lvi1Eb1 d 01 iuo fruii 23IEm1 io Ism 1! 1nE1uBi1 lo hog31J33

33flE1EE 10 1ilEno1q flu 3n5I31bb no b&t noiiEi1qini n nfI1 ,

i1oiE 3nq

a f!3u2) io1E3 i1q no ni b3lovEl 1E lim 'ii ivwoH 1u1i 01 1IuiThb d Irigim I i noiizi31q1ni n thus nth o1 l3rIionB ni IEm1 bnE (inB1uiI nq-fIir1

1nE1uE11 ni bu1Ev ii 3flE1EE io ii1Bno1q lo 3iii113Ji&I3 ini&11ib lnu ,

IdBn3i

i1031S3 33i1q iniThb iii

briE 1iIsnoiq fl3iflw flu wivi31ni no bBd 31gw noii3b gniiici 31111w bno3

nibnig31 noi133b B Aim 01 13oLqm3 13g 01 biovbn3 w 1o1 B 'E1q n 3flE1E3E

nI .mui 3f11 no noilErniolni 3111 no '131o bd inE3iIqqB ns w3ivl3Irn 01 Ion io 13111311W

01 w b3woIIol '3fli '31Efl 3(11 1nE1us131 olni b3qqoi 1nB3i1qqs dot 3111 n3rlw 1BIu3iflEq

B 10 1of1 B '11n3up311 w iflT .b3131nuon3 '3th 33'olqm3 121i1 3111 01 3U1 113111 3vi

3111 flI ln3bu1 31Bm31 3111 lo 3no u3d 3O1E fn3ldolq LEiln3loq 3ri0 13B1 nI x iol 1i w n31lw ,

ui1T .nBkA w 2lnfi3iIqq.s dot 3111 b3bivolq Ififli 1Efliffl3 fl31B331 thod iol 3fnoo1uo 31Sffi03 3W l3fll3fIW 1311!b aiIu31 3111 li )teB 3w ,

3mo3iuo ni 33fI313Thb

.nsmow nBiA-non 3111 bn nm rllod 101 1uL 10 jimow briE fl3ffl

Page 8: DMDiSIOW - NBER

1ntnua1i olni qo1 1nR3i1qq1$ v&1 ol b3ifl w 33fl1 qu gnifl3 no13qud io noi3q1i1$w

1&1i b31up31 inE3iIqq1$ 1T .gnilriom 311$1 11 a f13U wok w 3niwd n1w mi1 niiub

313111 ii 111$3 C)1 anoii3Ln1fIi filiW 13E(ISffl 10 l3fIWO 3113 03 3fflU31 3111 3Vi '(o1qm3 ir11

131o 1om1i$ bEd 511$ w3iv131ni u&8 .dol ffi io1 b3w3ivl3lni gni3d lo 1i1idi2oq nE

bn1$ w3iv131ni lo 3qis31 iol 11ui b nothsqmo3 1$ musi 3111 moil noi1frr1o1ni 3111 no

313111 11 33flB11$ io ii1noiq ni on31311ib lo 3101 d1 guig ol b32u 3d n 213110 dol

i Ii n3dl 1311o dol iol 311$ 313111 lud 2w3iv131ni iol X32 \d 23111031110 111 233fl3131hb on 3113

x , l3v3woH

. 23mo31u0 d1 iTh 233n31311ib 33fl1E313 10 1i1Bno213q 3J3111 1dioq

01 3ludilllE 01 lIu3iTtib 310111 (1311111 3113 3g1312 w3ivl3lni 3(13 113 23mO31UO flu 233fl313flib

V 233n313111b 33fl1$163E 10 '1u1Eno213q

211113111131231 ni nmow briE nm lo 1n3m1s11 11$i1n313flib ni b3123131ni 313W 3W 32UE33H

351111 '(liIfI3bi oi biuD 1f1131U&123$L f$ufICIl3bSIiflq 21f i.\ b3211 3w 2311og31133 33fl lnSl3lIib ni

bn1$ ; (OE2- I ) 3311q-mUib3ffl ; (O2 13V0 33u1q 1E3m 3E13V1$) 33nq-flgIrl 23u1031133 3311q

iol gni2rn3vb1$ 21n131u131231 01 no!1n3fl1$ 13111231 Ion bib 3W 8(f ff3111 2231) 3311q-wol

113111 b31133v31 sIub33olq noiiB3iIqqE dot 1110 lo "211111 LEull" lEilini 3f02 33ni2 ,

2noiii2oq

b3biovE 3W grli2utI3vb1$ IIJO11IiW '11E13fl3 2i2&J lEunulno3 hiEb 1$ no b3lirI 211113111131251

3(11132 3113 lo 213dm3ffi 31111 01 1313Iq Ifigim '3th b3133q2u2 3W 33n12 21n13111131231 3 ff113 '1i3i112

'(lolEnimil32ub a b3bl1$g31 3d lrlgim 321U03 lo 2if11 rlguorills quoig 31111113

dot 3113m31 bnE 31i$m lo 21113q 4QI lo gnriq 3111 111 bon3q )133w-351r13 13 13v0

31EfflO3 oriw (O8QI) .113 13 31'1nI3M 'd bifl2 ii ni b3liolqx3 0211$ 21 3lquonulq 2irITV

gnixirnobnEl d 3IdElEqmo3 3b1$ffi 23fflU231 21101311311 01 23infiqmo3 lo 232fl0231 11311fl31311ib

bnuol bu12 2i1IT .33131 10 X32 gnuls3ibni 1mobnE1 113(11 bns 3ffIU231 3111 nO 23111113 3(11 2201313

.1131110W 01 (113(11 fl3ffI 01 232fl0231 31df310V1$1 310111 lo 33f13b1v3 lfIS3ilingi2

fliEffi 13si13qqE 111$ gnibul3ni 13(1mb no b321$d 3113 233fl 323113 231$BS 01 gnib1o33A8 .qil 3111 gnibul3x3 briE )1nnb 3no bits 321UO3

Page 9: DMDiSIOW - NBER

1w f1B ill .

(1w iq O vo Iwo InEiuE11 ) i mui Ito b3qqolb 21ns3i!qqs

tni lim to gnhiq dT .

iioglw iiq ith I Is ni insius1i 01 bsm iw anoi1siIqqs

iw (iifl Ismt io 3Ism) Ito bqqcnb iw mui rti difIw ni i*io Ii bris Ism1

d1 ni sid 3iism3i2' ns biovs ol iqm11s 01 4nsius1I ol 1nJ$1usii moi1 blsmIs

il1s thnom no '(Iismixo1qqs lo s effoils3iIqqs dot OE I di 10 .

xa 'd mo31uo b31mil

or11 lo Q€ brrs wivi1ni dot ni biIu d1 lb gniqqoTh biIqmo3 w zibbo dot ni b3iIu1 wi'rn1ni

1Iu3M .111

dot iob 1Iu aiisrnmu A Ins .bu1 rI1 moi1 siith wsi rIi 2tIoq1 I IdsT

ilbo dot ni gniIIui woilsoilqqs dot bo noifloqolq fIi is3ibni woi xi 1ifl cIT .iflo

alns3iIqqs Ism owl dT .1nsiusi lo \1ogls3 3hq r1353 flu insiIqqs rIi bo ths iol

ni lnsius1i 3nq-muibm bns -fight d1 moib ibbo bvi5I fI3I3 ; 1Iui isIim '(isv bsd

-wol r11 mrnl i1bo no bvi331 ibs bns e(I110 xi io vi1) & r11 bo 1Isf1-no luods

3riq-mu!bm d1 Is lsi iflo dot idghI IIflgiL S bsi! I IsM .

insius1i 3nq

lnziusi3i 3i1q-r1gic1 th Is Izi iYto dot ii1gifl 'Iiflgil s bsrl Ism bns ,

bns -muibm -dgirI r1i ni 01. bns 8k iw Ism ftj iol 1si i3bbo dot th llsivO

0!• 1uIwmo2 iu1ib Isfn1 owl i11 iol IIui f1T .

Ivi13qi ,

1nsius1i 33q-wol

Iidw ,

(01. wiv .) 1nsius1ai 3hq-muibm c1I is isi ilbo dot l3dgirf s bsd I IsmI

ifI1i3n rnvwoH .(. uiv .) insius12i hq-wo1 rII is 31s1 ii1ght s b&t 1sm1

.wiviini luoriliw bsm iw 13lbo dot oW

.1smo1 nsiA i11 i IsmI°'

V

Page 10: DMDiSIOW - NBER

i11o dol no 1u1 bvi31 f13R ;1nfi1us15I 3nq-f1gid iL1 1i fl3um b&1 1im1

-muibrn -11gif1 Ii ru 8E. bni QO. iw 1m1 th iol isi i11o clol r1i 1I131vO

gniiiri iu Ignon2 £flb wii rfi ,ur1T bvii3q1 ,

iniiuii 33hq-wol bnB I duorIiIi) nmow 1o lovEl ni bris ,inEuuEi5I 33i1q-f1if! flu nrnow inij nou1Enim3ib

iniusuii iiq-woI ni (o 1noii

iol rnO3iuo r1i no gnuw3ol liniThb £11b r1i SiIEfII1flU woi iuol ixn riT

lo 3nbiv flE Lfvi Iliw iiq iol mo3iuO .inB3iLqqE doE lo iiq thmt-IEm

123d i11 kii!qm nn!i bn nErnAoH A .nmow briE rim 1o ifIfnh1i5ui 3fli3fflfn'J3

ni iuq lo noinoqolq rL1 nwid 3n1&flib rL1 i ibufl libuE ni noilBnirnh32ib b iuim th fI3irIw ni noitioqolq cI1 briE 1on ob 1im1 r!1 lud i11o fiB 1g 1irn th

3nq-IiirI ni nm lo lovEl ni inm1ii 3n1rnmB Livi iugfl i1T . 1U33O 13vi 3r1q-woL nI (O. - E4.) QE. i noitIoqoiq 3th n33w13d n5It1ib 3111 51311w

, 1niuilsi

f1i fI3fIIOW b IOVE1 flu ifl3ffliE3ll 3i113fIIffI'E i3U2 31LJgfl 3111 lEl1no3 flu 1nEiusl5i

3111 b3x3 3lEm B Jon Jud 311rn31 i ol 3b13m i Y1o ni rkidw ni b flOulloqolq

.(OO. - Q.) Q. 'd iuo 1331 3111 thirlw ru noitioqolq

Hun 3th lo 1i 1E3iiiJIsi2 moil uliv-q tioqsl A 13nE lo woi owl iE1 3rD Hi3nfI

B i i oiisi booili1li1 11T .

1Em1 briE 31Bm lo ln3mlBsIi 3i1l3mrn lo ir1ioqr1

no noi1ibnoo rbhlw l1 31qmE 11Em 13EX3 ns i la1 ni linoi1ibno3 f1l 1ir1w 4l 31qmE

.(iisq f1i lo l3dm3m no 1no 01 13110 fiB , .3.i) moiuo lBup3nu rlliw lo l3dmun 3(11

f1T .(QQI) nsm13i2 bni nsrn±H ni bbivoiq su aii 3r11 nib1Eg31 1i&i3U

r1i i&ii ii1idEdolq 3rD 3lE3ibni fl3ifIw 3u1sv-q 3111 lo rrri31 ni i 11 3111 isIqI3Jni ol 'w

gnu1ai 1qrni n&ii SIU2B3ffl 13fl3d £ i ir11 IBiD ugi nBm13g3i bns nsfnA33H" i ion ob 1Bm31 Jud iilo vissi 31Em rbirlw ni iizq lo noinoqolq 3111 13th311w noiiloqolq IBup3 fiB lo ii1idioq 3111 1oni i1 irh snip oi moil insI3Thb 11f1E3i1ingi

Jon ob 231Bm lud 21311o 3vi51 LEm31 rl3irlw ni iiq lb

8

Page 11: DMDiSIOW - NBER

1Em lo inm1fn 3iiirrIrn iz1 ni w idi Ii b5rw33o v&L bluow 3mo3luo bvido

hun li 1ni %nbiv mB 1ini hh13iii1B1 is3ibni O. woId iiihidEdo1q ;1sm1 bnE

ii1T .I1ui 1Bhimi bivoiq i1 owl rli ith nI .1nm1fl oii1mrn lo iIhoqf1

1nJriuBJa1 33i1q-f1if! ni nmow mniBgB noi1snimi13ib lo 3nbiv InE3i1ini llfi3i1i1Ei i 1nB1uE15I 3i1q-wo! ni nm 1niEgE bnB

noiIfiv1do !ooq 01 1Bi1qo1qqE i Ii id11w no uoo1 oIi nEm!3i bnB nEmA3H

mnBo!1qqE lo iiq th lo 1du2 B ii alas '1!Bi1n23 rkidw 1nE3i1qqE dol lo iiq oi .bd3IEm 11w Ion iw 1Bmt bnB 1sm dI iiq 1id1 ni uB3d Idioq IIui 1l viib

3vi11in 10 viIioq S b1si 1nE3iIqqB 3f11 lo no 'ns ii 1qmsx 10q

1hiI l2om bluow 2ith dguocflls b1EnimBIno3 d bluo3 111o dol i61 1Lui dl noi2Iqmi

w usH 21nB1u&I1 lo hog1s 3i1q us ni mo3Iuo 3i11fffffl\fi ni qu wof1

1351 hi 'd b1s3i1qmo3 is gnilooq iol I1 1sm31 bns Lsm lo gni1isq d1 bIEfn3iIs

diiw s1i1idioq rh1 ivwoH .Inbnqbni Ion 1s 1isq Ini11ib moil noilsvido isdi

iw Ism fI3lfIw ni nsq 'd nvhb is 1Lui sf11 i&11 i bn13no3 1om IB W fI3iIIw

iol noi1snimi-ioib bni1qx3 3v&! 'sm bns nsieA 25W 1sm1 3n!2 ,

!sm1 01 b131Em

lo A 1ns lo 2ia'113nE th 2isq1 I IdsT xibnqqA 1ihidi22oq 2idi 1o!qx oT .nos1 2i111

ni 251ugi1 rb s1sb i1i lo 12du2 2ith ioI .1 1Em31 nivIovni iisq '1no gni2u I 1dsT

l2niEgs noilsnimul32ib lo 3nbiv 1fl531tiflgi2 h1S3iI2i1B12 1E3ibfI! 1dsi xibn3qqs r1I lo A

Lu12233u2 iom 1vi1E15I sw 1sm1 2us3d 1v3woH 21n51u51251 3nq-f1gif1 ni nmow

nmow lo iovsl ni noilsnimil32ib lo 3nbiv rhl 2ins1us121 3i1q-woI ni 21&llo gninisldo ni

-v-i1 r1i 01 13151 sxis3ilingi2 153i12i1512 nibissi 21n3m31512 b31on 32iWl3rh10 2231flTJ' 13v31 33fIS3flif1i2 1n3313q

Page 12: DMDiSIOW - NBER

£l.if1fi3J1ffli 1IB3!1i1Ei ion bnE ,iA&w won i in1ufi1I 3rIq-wo1 ni

'bvin1iL&jp iIui dT .wiviini iol 11ui floq3l w ,

I 1cJzT to & iq ni

ni nmow lo iov1 ni noii&iimiizib lo 3nbiv di riguothiB it1o dol iol orh oi 1B1imi

th iii I. bn ,

I. tw nm 1E1 wi'riini i1T .iliw i inB1uEi1 3q-wo1

iol 8E. bnE filiw b1Eqmo3 bvii3q1 inE1usi1 3hq-woL briE -muibm -r!girI

inE1u1$i1 iiq-r!ifl ni nm to iov't ni inrnifl ii1 rrn's 1ivi iuu1 rIT .nrnow

bni wi'mifli VI31 hm !no II3ffIW (ii 2liBq lo noifloqoiq rIi nwid niThb th

3nq-wo! nI .(U. - 8.) E. i wi'rnini vii Im1 '1no rkñrlw ni aoitioqoiq f1i

gnibnoqT1o3 r11 ;nmow 1o lovEl ni ln3ffliE5Ii 3i11ffIIfIE 1ggu 5IUi1 f!i ifiE1iJEi5I

ai2f1ioqr! hun rii lo ii 1E3!1i1B1 di h1ni .(OI. - Q.) QI. i noitioqoiq ni nit1ib

• inE1uEi 3i1q-dgid th ml '1no Hun th lo noiii 01 b1 inrn1E51i 3ii1ffiffP lo

1no I I&nl nibuL3ni iiq lo idu rhi iol .1 1dET xibnqqA ni i1imi i1ui c11 mo nI •wiv1ni lo noibjil i i11o tIoq1 bn1 11EniI

i1lo dot iii ion lud niwivi31ni ni noiiEnimu13ib iw irh II .

1ulu ! is idmun

dot ni 3nllib x noii i IIii bluow w w3!v1ifIi n13 gnivi31 no LBnoiiibno3

a , Iqmidu irhi iol iiiq iol mo3iuo 1En13 ionn& w

• iomrhiiuI M

• 1311o

vi1 !Em31 rh1 bns 31sm rLi rilod li3idw ni iiq w1 13viiEI1 irhi work a LnE

wonA 01 1iini 10 1 ii IcIinoM .11Ern tvi1Eb1 i IqmE 3rD 11EniI •w3PrI3ini

ni I3drnun 3r1T •x d iflib 01 lE3qqs mo3iuo w3iv131ni n no 1Enoiiibno 13fhi3f1w

dot ni nmow iniEgE noi1Enimh3ib i ith 2inEluEia3l 33nq-flgir! flu i&hi 13u2 D L3nE

d midoiq nu1ooq 3rD iol Ioflno3 o1E 3w wo11o1 i&1i ai1Enz 3iErIzviiIum 3rD nI .nwElb i noiiEvido fI3s d3irIw rnoil iiq 3LEm31-3IEm di iol 31dEi1Ev mmub nibu!3ni

briE ii1Eno13q c1 310ffl b3on3uflni 3d 'm anoii33b 1311o dot e3vodE b3ion at o1A noi!33b w3irn1ni dot nErD 33flE1E3E

01

Page 13: DMDiSIOW - NBER

w nmow idl OIE1 iT1o 3th in1uEi1 nI .wivi1ni n gniwollol i11o

3rIq-wo1 ni b31ovs1 d 01 iqqi nmow 1flno3 nI .nm iol QV. rbiw b3izqmo

.nm io O. thiw biEqmoo rOi b 1i31 iibo ns thiw 1nE1uEl1

%c(\K

ol w wolfE fi3iIlw E1Eb th lo li3nE Iidoiq moib 1lui tIoq1 ldI31 niwollot iiT

1f11o mo iol Lollno3 w no I ldET flu qifkflo!1sl5I th lo fllgn5Iia loi1i1,31 3th ii -non li io1 wolfE briE noii3b wivi1ni briE i11o dot ri1 no 3nuflni lEi1nioq

.1nE1uB1i th 01 noi1Eoilqqs dot io mooiuo b 3nbnqbni

1ni3i11o3 th nonE3fii33q cl io dot io 1Bmu1 iidoiq 1ioq1 ldT 1i1idEdo1q rl1 no 1dEi1Ev rl1 lo 131 lEniglErn rli vig 01 bm1o1anE11 nd vEu! 1Emnuia

noil3ruhl isnulnon ir1i lo iori blEbnEJ2 311T nm 3lqms 3f11 1i b1sulsv i1bo dot i to

hA .noii&nixolqqE ii iol'T 13b1o-11i1 E gniu bniE1do ii 1ni3i1tho b1Emi1a th to

anoi13E11ni briE inz1uE11 oiiq-woh bnE -dirf ml 231dthv 'rrirnub 3bul3ni noiiE3i1i3q

-wol bns -muibm -rlgirl iol 1dEi1Ev rricnub briE lsml iol 1dEi1Ev mrnub i nw1d gnid lo ill rI1 ium 3hq-flgic1 X lBml lo in3i3fbho3 th

• wriT 1niuEiei onq

01 vi1E151 1nE1uBJ1 33flq-fIif1 mofb 13110 dot E nivii lo iilidEdo1q 3rD no 31sm31

51UE3ffl 3onq-wol X 31Em31 lo 1n3i3fl13o3 3rfT .1nE1uE1r 33i1q-flgirh flu 1nEiIqqE 3IEm

3IEm 01 3vi1E13i inE1uEJ1 33hq-wol moil 1311o dot no 3IEm3l gni3d lo 1113 3rD

33nq-mu!b3m X 31sm31 lo 1(1313111303 3rD ,

'11Eni1 inE1uE131 33i1q-woh flu 1nE3ilqqz

01 3viiEl5i , 1nE1uE1a31 33nq-muib3m moil 131lo dot no 3IEm31 gni3d lo 133113 3(11 1uJ3m

sIog3iE3-33nq X 31Em3l 33r11 lErli 31ok1 .inE1uEi231 33i1q-mlJ!b3fn flu 1flE3i1qqE 3IEm

ni bibinoz 131 3lEilEvinu rli ob in3mlE3ll 3i113frIfnE 3cnE sf11 5IInqE3 21(131311303

II

Page 14: DMDiSIOW - NBER

3ffiO3i1JO flu 3fI1Thb x ln iusm ll oni ,

I ldsT

s io1 wolls lull bu i lbom lidoiq 1z11 mobasi s noils3u1i3q fl3s ioI

wo11s iolsmil irlT .lnnoqmo3 10T13 ñi3q-nouls3ulqqs us s llw s iillin lnbnqb d ol lnsiusli fns bull 01 lfIs3ilqqs owl ioI mo3luo no noilsvido

ôl.lbom lidoiq lsnoilnvno3 ill ui bmus i s lnbnqbni null

'(Iols3 uiq uli '1no buI3ni (I) nmulo3 ui btioqi noils3fli3q lifl ilT

Ism.t ulT ldsiisv rrirnub lsmI ul1 filiw ul1 lo noil3s1lni bull bris •

ldsiisv rnrriub

1nsius1i 3hq-rlgicl bull Is iflo dol vizi 01 IAil 2l 'llns3flingi2 iw alns3iIqqs doj

Ismula us nmow iol 8. d iwol i iflo dol s nivbzi 1o 'ilidsdoiq blsmi1 3fiT

lin&flingi iw 1nsoi1qqs dol lsm1 bnul itho ulI nO .lnsi1ini2 'lls3ululsl2 2i lsth

lo lilidsdoiq blsrthl ulT lnsiusli hq-wol ui i&flo doE vii 01 'llil iom

-01 fll Is lnsoi1ingi 'l1s3uleuiEl i thidw nmow iol . d iilhl i if1o doj s gnivii

lvl lnnq lslguoi iw lull 1ns3iIqqs doE b noi1qmi bivoiq 01 bnib iw mui culT

lnsilqqs doE gnoms bisloi iw mui th vods bnoilnm s noilibbs nI .ln1sviup

.n3mow bns nm d miI b idmun fns rll lismixoiqqs bu sw mui fls lull o fll

, ilu5i rl1 l3&ith mui ul1 bo noiludiiiaib rl1 iullrlw 01 ,

l3fl1noM

lnsoilqqs doE lI lsill mui rll iob ldshsv rnunub buloni () nmulo3 flu noils3ibi33q

mrnub ul1 fl3w1d noil3s11ni bukni ols () nmulo3 ui noi1s3fli3q il1 Liulw bu ngib rll ui bbnlni sw th i1ols3 riq 1nsiusli iol ldsiisv 'çnrnub bus ldsiisv

no noil3s13lni iirll bus ldsiisv 'rnrnub mui fl1 lo l3bb3 b3Ismi1 3f11 mui 3f11 lo

.(QQI) .ls l xiI bo 8.1 xibnqqA flu bilsrurio1 i lflmuis idT .(4QQI) loiW bus inui)I iii bu ols i rbsoiqqs thlT"

Page 15: DMDiSIOW - NBER

booffi1!iL noi1ibb nI .iniingkni 11E3iiiii bn 1lim 31E it1o dol i 1o 'ii!idEdo1q 3th

3d 10c111E3 noiliwp3 iii moil 1dthmv 3fflUt 3th lo noiubx3 3rh izril 3lEzibni ii oi1i

nmuLo3 ol () nrnu!o gnnqmo O. I i boofli!h! go! ni n313Thb 3db 3oiwT .b31L3-i

QQ lo 3u1J$v th3!i!13 1n3313q-3vfi 2U213V e(I) nmuIo3 ol (f) nmulo3 gnrlEqmo3 .! bns (I)

gnivi31 b 1i1iddoiq 3db ni 3n313Thb x b31mi1 3db '!1EniI .13viiq1 bn

r11 nfw b3gn&!3nu '11ufliv 3nog3iE3 i1q 1n313Thb ni inE1ui1 moi1 iI1o doL

.b3bul3ni Io1ino3 3mui

m3!dolq gnilooq 3db 3nimix3 ,

() bni (!) nmuLo flu ,

2noii3i1i33q 'to i ix3n 311T

d n3vilb 31E i1ui Ii 11'li3ilw gnb11 'd Q1) n&nI3g3i bnE n&ntH 'd biii 'mrnub 3bubni 3w (4) nmu!o3 ni noi1up 2irh 5loIqx3 oT .inB3qqE to gnu1iq 1E!u3irnq

3db lo 'iiviiin 1i nI briE Iiirn bo gnniEq 3!dioq r!1 o1 1dEhEv

3bul3ni o1s 3w () nmu!o ni IogiB3 33hq di no bn3q3b gniiisq 3r!i o i!u231

3fIT .31dth-rnv 'mmub 'iog1 zi1q bni !dziiiw 'mmub iiiq n33w13d noi-I3ini

'!1B3ii2!iEi2 bni o'is in 31E 2gnhiEq di "to 3db isril 3is3ibni (4) nmu!oo ni 31smuj

mmub 3db idl no gnib333x3 3i1iis-1 s nisido w () nmulo3 ni 13v3woH .insoi1ingini

boorlil3lil 13v3woH .insius1i 33i1q-wo! 3db ni 3ftm riiiw gnhisq s gnui&ibni 3!dsimv

ni 33n313Thb x b3isnhii3 3db bns b3bu13x3 3d ns 3!dshsv 3db lsi'fi 3ls3ibni ii oiisi

515 3i1og3iE3 33i1q 1n313Thb ni 1nsiusii moil T1o doE s gnivi333'i lo '1iIidsdo'iq 3db

gninismsi 3db flI 3!3rI13fio4 .b3bukni SIB Io1ino3 gnrsq 3db fl3fIW b3gnslI3nu 11siitiiv

3fl0 b3b333x3 3i12i1Bi-i 3db fI3lIiW iol 3!dsflsV 3f 3db fliEi3l 3W fiOii53i1i33q

33nq-wo! ni 2333U 310m !3vi1s131 bsr! 3!5m31 isdb 3i53!bn! I 3IdsT flu sisb 311T

X3 rbiw b31si3o2s (Iog3is3 33i1q 113S3 iol) 11ir! lq33l3ini ns sbs31!s i 313db 33fli 3db lo 3f10 rbiw 3!sm lo gnhisq gnirkiugnuiaib 3IdsnEv mfnub s 3bUL3fli 01 1no b33n 3W

.31Bm lo 3fl0 rhiw 31Bffi31 lo gni1isq bns 31sm31

El

Page 16: DMDiSIOW - NBER

• 1linvo 233U l3woI briE

, ainsiuili 3rIq-muibm ni ! 1viiEI5I ,

lnEiuEl1

ni briE 3IEm1 io1 1dJhEv mrrwb £ bbfi w (ô) nmulo3 ni noilEoi1ioq rh ni ur!T

3nq-dif! briE -wol iol 1dEi1Ev rnrnub illiw 1ctithjv 2i1ft lo anoi1iini bbE w (F) nmuIo3

r1i to io1h b31Emi1 dl .1 1dfiT ni idmun r1i nvi 1ni2iiqiu loVI .lns1uEl1

mo1uo ni 3n51Thb r1i iuim f!3irIW ,

(F) nmuIo iii io1 !dth1Ev minub

1niflingk s!th3ijijE1 brn vi1rgn i , ainiiui1i 3i1q-muibm ni I 1smf briE ii! nwld

51E inIusii 33hq-wo! briE -f1iit r!l flu 3fl5IThb b3iEmi1 r!T .1v1 in331q-OI rli fl

oiiq-rf girl X 31sm3t to 1n3!3u1th03 b31sm1123 3rIT •iniflingk '11E3iliiEl2 Ion lud 3vi1ioq

owl 3r11 briE I 3lEm3I nwI3d iI1o dol £ lo 'iiIidEdoiq 3th Iii 33n31flib 3rb Iu13m won

•(R.-Ik 'cd) l3woI 1ln&flingi 1lii i 33n513 b b3lEmiI ir1T •lni1qqE dol 3lEm

I 3lEm3t bib n&h lnE1uEi 33i1q-wol lB 3161 l3rlgiil i b&l 31Em ni 13v3woH

lnEiuEl231 33hq-wol lB 13110 dol £ gnivi331 to iiLidEdo1q 3rD flu 3fI313Thb x b3l&riii r11

•inE3ilingi2 'I1E3i1ilEl2 ion 3g1E1 E i3gnoI on i flE gn1v13351 lo liIidEdo1q 3rD io1 noilE3fli33q lo 1 mE 3fli 01 nijfl 3IdET

n& 1dE1 irLi moil ilu31 3r11 ,

31d61 uoiviq f1I to fioi2W3ib b31i1l3b 3rD n3vi{) w3iwl3lni

31Em31 iol 1o1lno3 3r11 3bul3ni w lilnu , ainE1u1li 3Oflq-wol ioI bxi1ErrIrriu2 b1iup 3d

i 1ns3iLqqE dol 3IEmot iot w3ivl3lni fIB lo '1i1idEdoiq 3111 flu 33n513Thb b3iEmii 3rD

b31Emil 3rD 1oflno3 323111 3bul3ni 3 33110 •lnz3ilingi2 '11B3il2iIEl2 ivn lud 3viii2oq

aoth 01 iEIim[2 '(13v 316 2111J251 3111 13V3WOfl 21fIS1uSi23i 33nq-ffgirI ioI •013S 163fl 2i 133113

flu w3ivi3lni ris gnivi333l lb ii1idEdoiq 3111 2f1OilE3iui33q2 3111 lb 116 11s3n nI .213110 dol iol

ni 2316rn 123 3rD rlliw 21nE3iIqqE dol 31Ern3l iol i8wol '11ns3flingi2 2i 1n61u11231 33r1q-rlgirl £

Page 17: DMDiSIOW - NBER

8! 8f ni r11

dot 1o lqm rl1 iol noiiBup t1o dot 3111 lo XmiI 01 niifl 4 3ld1T 11EniI

lud ,

3131! m3ldolq noi11 3Iqmf uoivdo ni i 3131!T w3i'ri31ni b3vi31 ififli 1flB3i!qq

'11 01 3l1iLn1 Ii iicl bnE w3irI31ni 11h$ !dmuiq !dthiv ffi 1ith nvi 3Im31 no noi1iwdo 3bu13x3 ol v&I olB W .min&km noi1l 3Iqm1 3111 1i1n3bi ol

s i 3orIq-wol X 31Em31 work I IdiT 2Z u13d a1nE1uJi51 33nq-wol ni anE3i!qqB

'nim bul3ni 1 Jib th noi1ibbs nI .31qrndu idi iot al3Ilo dot to lol3ib3lq 133h3q

b3qqo1b i liEq 3111 flu InE3ulqqfi 131110 3(11 no noiIEvl3&!o 3111 (131(1W moit noi1Evdo

3111 3IBmui3 l3gnol on n& 3w uf1T .w3ivl3Ini n 3vi3331 Ion bib InB3ilqqE lsth usd 11BniI 31Emu13 iidoiq IBnoiln3vno3 noqi bs1ni bnfi noi1E3i1i33q 133113 mobnii

11 ni b3bul3ni 3d Ion bluo3 1dB1 WO1V31 3(11 fli b3bul3ni 1dBi1fiv 3Vil3frI3lfli 3(11 1o

b3bubni 3(11 cliiw lB3nuIIo3 '11 tl3q 313W noi13w131ni 3(11 3uE33d 1qmiudu ith iol 13bom

iom £ atioq3-I 1. 3IdsT ,

!1n3up3noD 3mooIuo 3111 lo 1o13ib31q 13&h3q 313W io , 31dEu1Ev

dot 3Vi3331 231Sm31 IBfII '1i1idEd01q b31Emi13 3111 13i1d nI 2nOu1S3ii33q 1o 1 b3lirnhl

1niiini tB 33n31311ib b31fmu13 311T .1 -. 'd l3woI i a1nE1u1i31 33nq-ftif1 ni 13ito

3rD 0 311o11 3u1333H enoi1B3ib33q iuo1 3(11 lo 331r11 flu 13113d io 13v31 1n3313q-OI 3111 lB

iin 1r!w'ns 31E 31i3rn3t io , eliBq , 3U31 io1 31dEi1EV 1011(103 3111 O 13&113 b3IBmiI23

3(11 rloi11w flu eb3TI3I3lq i (I) nmulo3 ni noi1B3fli33q 3111 4nsoi1ingi 11s3i1i1B12

13v31 in3313q-xi 3(11 lz 1nB3flini i 1nE1uE131 33i1q-fIgifl lB 3mo31uo lii 33n313flib

3Ismt iol 3IcIBulEv rnrnub B 3bu13ni li3irIw (ô) nmulo3 i noilq33x3 Ino 3(1181

3no31B3 33FI lol 31dznBv 'rnmub bnE 3Idzilzv ith n33w13d noiI3B13Ini 311) 3bu13x3 lud 3111 to loVBl ni () nmuIO3 ni noiIB3fli33q b313i11231 3111 i33131 1a31 oilfil boorlil3Ail A

(V) nmulo3 ni nouIB3flu33q

Page 18: DMDiSIOW - NBER

fI91&fliI ninisa .vI

3nq-rIgir1 ni nmow inu13B nOiiBnimn3ib gnnicf 31f3ibni 21! uI iibu dT

3flbiV bi&! nii2ix on 2i I3fI1 noiiouboi1nI ffi ni buib ivwoH

21nE1usi251 3nq-muibm io -wol ni n&li einiuii i1q-f1id flu 1r1if! gnicn i&1i

th nh iix ion ob 3n1Thb gnini thu2 11 bmu13 nd 1!E3iqi afif! 2i1U fLguof11h

moil initioqrninu I3vi1151 d 'm b1vo3nu v&1 w 113th noifl3nimn32ib gnilifi lo fn1113q

.2no21q1iEw norn gnini ni qi$ x 4j nini13!qx3 lo vi13q21q th

302 ithsg bib w 43oiq 21(11 lo 2u3ot 1q!3nu1q di ion w noiiup 2ifll 3LirlW

mo 1qmi iuo flu 2inB1ui1 th iiiiw 2wi'mini noi1q1i siv onbiv 'v1u2 lEm-lolni

bnJ3 iuor! !q-non gniiub 2iniufi1 th b3nof!q11 W .bui2 libuE di gniwo!loI mi1

ii ni bgign w w isth mu11 gnuII3i 1Sn13m ifliw ?11131 ol biqmni3

iw iud ignim i bthi !1iin 3W .2doL 13v31-1if13 ni 2flfl1133 no i33o1q (131133231

(13 lo 31zmu1 i3d nowiq izth iol b1a 3W .no2l3qlizw z illiw thuol ni iuq 1113f10i2Z33o

lo 1b i1 i w 313d1 ,

k13ng a! (2qii 2uIq g13w) 2no2l3qliEw lo niniii !1uOf!

thiw 33nsiIqmo3 ioiinom ol bi&1 ithsi thow 5II 3di oni rnooni qil 22u32ib 01 33n1313u!31

1!13i 01 gnilliw 2in3bnoq1 of1i noms nv noi1ibb13 nI 1.3fflO3fli qil no 21n3mEq xEi

ni3d 13flu3 s!no 02 bib 213db bnE 113muia niin ni ol nwob b3ffniq 3d ol b32u131 3mo2

lo 2gninls3 113th booi2l3bnu bn13 1&ni1 id li3th nb13 Ino 313W w 1&1i b31u2213

.wt313n13m ol nwonlnu n11o 313w nhii qil 113th bn13 31dEi113v 1dgif! 3d bluo3 2no213q1113w

b32o13 b&1 w31 i bni 2flO2B31 l3flio iol Alsl ol ni11iwnu 313W 21n131u13123 13410

2ins1u131r i.E) 3(11 lo 8 moil niido 01 31d13 313w w noil&iriolni 3db 2noq3l 1diT

bnE 2U 01 b3bivolq 213 nOiiEffllOlfIi 341 tloq3l 3W 1n131u131231 (13133 ioI .3IqmJ$2 libuE 3d1 flu

.ybu1 3mo3nI qiT 233i'm 3un3v3M 113n131n1 341 , ..3

of

Page 19: DMDiSIOW - NBER

.ninii huofI (bfloqi io) biIqmi r!1 lo inioqbim bnE mumixm muminim r11 nth

brrn murnixsm ,muminim giiv r11 r1oq1 w , 1nE1u11 lo 1o31s3 oi1q fI3E 10cJ

ni liii w nf!w sf11 ,

'li331ib btioqi iui1 L1 niu gninii huof! lo inioqbim

bnE Mflb LcJi1iEvE th riliw (inioqbim miirno bnJ3) mumixEm bnE fnuminim gniim th wofi lo Ibii5L .vjog1 fl31 iol u1v wol bnfi figid 3th qoib w nf1w E1VE f1i

3nq-r1if1 ni muim1q gnifriJ g1fil 1E3ibni i1ib 3fli ,

ninii 'huof! EiVE 1Efu311 w ni muimiq 11IBm bnE 1nE1us1I 3rIq-wo1 bnE -muibm dlod 01 vi1E11 1ninu1i

fI1 iol E13Vf3 fh niw ,

1qmx3 ioi 1nEiuiI 331 q-woL 01 3v11B131 33r1q-mulb3m

33r1q-lIgifI ni gnhni 'huof1 3i3VE u1Bv 1wo1 bni irlifl d1 nui313b 1nioqbim

ainiusii 331 q-muib3m ni nim nsult iclghl ino13q V1 (V.81 ) 1nE1uE15I

mi dT .(80. I I) 1niuE1i 33iiq-wol ni ninis n&11 iiigift 1n3313q 8à bilE

ur1T gE-13vz itho r11 lo lo nothBqmo3 moil 133 noiu!3no3 3vilEliLEup

olni 31EInB11 'lli1 inEiuE1i 33hq-fiifl ni ol nm i&li gEinEvbB niiir1

.3E1nEvbE gnin-ii tEi1nEi2du

flOkIJbflOD .V

3bivolq w3i'r131th no 1&rloilibno3 1311o dot briE w3iv13ini 13u1o dot iol 1Iu31 iuO

3311q-ftgtfl ni nmow inisE noi1Enimu13ib x lo n3biv3 1nflingi2 11E3iii1E

b31Ernui3 n b&1 nmow moil noi1E3iIqqE dot 1nEius131 33i1q-flir1 nI .21nEiuE131

lo 1iIidEdo1q b31Ernu13 n , . luodE 'd l3woI w lEdI 13110 dot s riiVi3331 10 '1i1idEdo1q

gnivi31 lo '1i1idEdoiq b31Erth13 ns bilE luodE d 13wo! w IEI1I w3ivl3ini (IS fI1Vi333i . luocfl3 cf l3woI sw isdl w3iv13ini ns nivio31 no Lsnoilibno3 1311o dot s

n33d I3vi1Sm311E srl noiiSg31g3 ISnoilEqu33o noii3ubo1inI d1 ni b32w3ib 2A

3(11 .noi1znimu13ib bns 33n31313iq 1n3mi3vni ISiiqS3 nsmufi lii 33n51311ib 01 b3ludillls

VI

Page 20: DMDiSIOW - NBER

iol Ioiino W .noiiEnimh32ib lo i3113 th iEIoi 'bifl irIi Ti bu nkb d 1nrri1vni liuiqE3 nJmufI b33qi3iinE io no bEd noii3I-1I3 lo i1h

nimur1 iiq iol Ioiinoo w bnB inE1usii LIE 01 inE3iIqqE dol 1Ern1 bns 1Bm nibn 01 mui inIsviup gni1n1q d (3n111ib 1Eq iIio bnE) in3m1vni IBiiq&

gnu13[11 at i1ui iuo nui1cp3ini ru 1nbflno3 1iup 1E w , uff1' 13'oIqm Ifi11nioq

.noi1Bnimib

3lulEn I1 lo rioi1up rI1 IbbE 01 u wollE Ion ob ngib th ivwoH

lo rlsq th no noi1Enimi13ib is1 i iEbibnE3 IdiwsIq nO .noiiEnimil3aib rI1 lo

oIqm io ioIqm lo th ni figuorlilE ,

1rno1w3 io ,

o1qm ,

ioIqm 3i1q-11gif! ni b1gi d 01 1EB nm 'c1w niEIqx ol IIu3lThb i ii noiiEnimh3aib

flu 1vni ol VEr1 1o1qm3 11 noflEn!fnrI3ib LE3!12!1E1 i 1fibibnE3 bno A 1nE1ufi1i

d ym 'th nm nErD inoo liup 01 'Ili1 1B fl3fOW 113th v3iId briE iAiow 1i3th

-figirl ni InErioqmi iom d bluo3 in3m1vni f13u2 1dEvi33noD .n3mow 5IirI ol lnEJz)u151

W .inl3rloqm iom 3d Bm 'OuIErrriol bns gb3lwonA ivi ir1w MnE1uEi5I 33fl

iuo gnrniElqx3 flu lni3tioqrninu '13viiE15I 5113 fl0iiE13bI&I03 fk)u 113111 13v3wori 31E!u33q

ili ngkb d brus musi 3rD no b3bivolq i 'io1ir1 dol rno 1Is lo 1iiT .Lusi

r11 ob 213 3B13VE no 4oL 3111 no 33n312i213q 3ffl132 3111 work nmow moil 2noiis3ilqqE

bnz b3niE1do siw i311o do rbirlw cLiiw 32133 3VilEISl 3rD bno3 .nm moil 2noiIzM1qqz

33i1q-wol briE -rIgid 3111 ni (b3nidmo3 thod iol) 1i iito do lo iiIsup3 1133f1 fI1

1o 23110g31133 3M1 1113 111 I3VOIflLJI rigift '13vi1sI31 2i 513f11 isill 2123ggU2 21f1E11JE125I

aiflE1UE1231

33nq-rlgiIl ni nmow l2niEgE IIOilEflimrl32ib gniiirl 3iEoibni 211ust libuE iuO

2II1fflE3 qil bitE 313W 113111 21 3ggu2 33fl3biV3 viu lErrrlol 3I iuo noi1ibbE nI .21n51u131231

gnhiil lo ni3flEq 3111 ,

31o13131iT 21n131u131251 33hq-rlgifl flu l3flgirl '115i1n1312du2 3113

81

Page 21: DMDiSIOW - NBER

To

cunu UJOU MItGL2 iuq 1MHfL2C2

qicLiwiuiou M puc nucocq wA o jou #A roiq cxbjnrnu JJGx b !U

Page 22: DMDiSIOW - NBER

33fl91919$I

".gnsrD bns ainEninn1U x ct noifl1g 1Eno!1iqu33O" 8Q I .

H £1bnA i!1fl .Q-IVF :€ .o'kl VI .IoV iuo5I nmuH 10 1&riuot

wM) hoW bns nmoW lo vmono3d 1a3iii1oq riT :yiU a1bnd !T .8QI .iniflfl 1I31a .(.3n1 43iVOnEVOt iiiH rtuo3IsH :YM *ioY

ioIqm3 ni1W li1ol bni giW noii rg linoiiqu33O" .4VQI .IBd1BH fIfISffig1H .OI-€OI :(Iut-1hqA) I .LoV 1&riuot 3imonozI nij3 ".x 10 zM 'd 1&Iimu13iU

.(.3n1 a1ooH ifl :YM ahoY w*I) nmoW 1o nim3 3imonood rJT .8QI ________

ivo!gm3 .OQQI .n1$nrirnrni bnW bnfi I1M 3rnt nn3)I vivn3D filiw vyiEH oi) 3flflil2nI rithU dot oInA bnB 3fflg2iH 10 in3rrIJs1T 1ziini11iU :zit3E1q niiiH

.(3iuJi1nI rnth1J dT : .D.U noigniikEW) t-OQ noq$I

bilE iojM 3!IoD ni1i'T dot" .48QI .inthbnA .1. IuiI bilE •

.M EmoL1T 1nomsU .8-Ot :F .oT4 I .IoV woM nBmuH 10 lElnuot ".uLfnB1 ni qED ibnO th

gnilibuA lo wivvO nA' .Airii .t bnornE$I bnE i1EO .D gioD ,IE113iM xi1 ni3nivnoD bni i1D ioiib !'ini .t bnomsM bns xiI bElbiM nI ".noiiEnifnn3eiU id1 nEthU silT : .D.U no1gnidW) &il3mA rn noi1snimn3iU lo 1nm5IuEM :3nbiv

.8-I .qq iuiiinI

lbdT :ibir libuA iuiii2nI nEdlU r1T" .QQI .n&nbgi 1j3q bnJ3 ,

.1. mEt n&nA3H bilE ii1D 1oiib3 ,1irii .t bnom51 bni xi 13&l3iM iii ".nibniI bilE bothM .D.U no1gnifkEW) ii*imA ni noiiinimhziU to inmiuM :nbiv3 ni3nivnoD

.8-V8I .qq iu1ii2nI nEthU

.(no m&rnjq .q.D :Y4 ,*toY wM) iAioW IEII0D lniq .VVQI .qqEA iuoJ woH

nonE3i!duq vbifl mo3nI giT .OQQI .iujiT rli lo 1nrntiBqU ivi unv5I !j$rninI .(OQ-Q) OI

lo a1E13noD r1i lo i!EnA nA" .4QI .i1oiW .A ii1uoU bilE •

.M 3VivfIO m){ 48 .LoV wiv5I 3!moflo3 niimA 'i1-dot 3inEqiH nuoY gni3EI noiif3nimu13iU

.8-4Vô :(nut) .oT4

ni 1nfniE31T 1Eiin5Ib1q" .08Q1 •0q S '(nEfi bilE gidoM .t innU dbfl 1inI3M .LoV LErnuot inm&IEM lo ymbE3A .5I bni x oi nib1o3A noiioU nojjIiq

.Q-8V :4 .oM ,E

03 rhEolqqA IzliqsD nEmuH A :noh3b-1b IEfIoi3EqU330" 18Q1 .W nomo1o AfloE1oq 8 IoV iieiiEj2 bnE ümono1 lo wiv5I ". 1In3u112 IEnoiiEqu33O ni 3n5I11iU x

.Q-Oô :(1ELndI) I .oT4

Page 23: DMDiSIOW - NBER

(2piuoue DC: jpc flLPU Iu!WtC)obbowrnwc D!uJUI2pcq: I{Cif! D!CL!W!UU!OU !U H!L!IJ flLPU JU2flUIfC }çGboJ4 j-j11LIJL ILLA Vn21!u1 pcjrnc L!x uq jAwouq uiAj jj ObbO IUU!2 DUcq

(1nu): ____________________CpU Lj( jg iju b11fCLU2 cuq qJc uqci bA Gb1 j,'outpjA 1POL CA!M

FJOL }çCAIGM (isuni.A):ffAiuJ ucA jgj 1Occnbiouii 2GLGOU iuq JfLU!U2 D!ULUCC pA cx1 youlpJA

Page 24: DMDiSIOW - NBER

muM : xibnqqA

1 mu5I

9Vib9td0 ffi3moIqma

.ivi both B 2f noiiioq mu1-i-1Eq o 11th A

noht3uba

..O1V1 Aq nonBthJ joo& f1iH flOfl&IJ

niW qoH .iM .ms1oiq fkni1iuo f1iuo ADMY nonBthd ni viioA :9itivibA .niw bhow r1i UpiiiI bni Iqm 01 binBg1o quoi B--quolO

9fl9i19qxa

Ldinoq$I .noiflnil2ni ninib 31E3qu ol iibom ni gniiiEw inrnI :IIii[) bnB IEH noi1IB .4Q1 iBInd&I-QQ1 M niiiEw IiE113o3 ifigin ii1 bru qu1 morn gninib qiq bool iol

.Aq giudthiH ,

.bv11 bn3 inoi1 OQ1

.unm 1i1nni1no i thiw noiiuiii2ni gninib ni1 ni gnuliBw A3Ed bni inoiI :3E1q 51B3D iol 11iEw biH .ivi iflud bu13ni 3fIflqxJ .gni1iED ioI *tow 1BnoixO

QO .EQQI M-1Q1 iiunii JIif1 gniiof1 1Aw bnB 1n3rno1qm3 lb f11nom 1f11 11 .Aq giudthH

, .b5I no1gnir1W

iq gniqqofl p11EV 1W IQQI sM-OQQ1 nut no13q1iEw bnE noiqufl :i1doJ b5L .A giudii-nH

• 1ifkB3 bnB 11B12 a!s in1x a m1iiflD bnB imrnu bhoW : ioi 1n3mi'IBqU voo8

•OQQI dm3U-Q8Q1 nuJ. boog gnitioq bnB o1 ni 1i1Bmi1q b*ioW

ItUIO19

bu13ni iddod 1znoi&I .Mffl bnB mia' gnuJuqmo 1iE11 lb gnibnBi1bnu 3iBH •gniB1q onEiq bnB gnibBI i313x3

Inol 1niThb B thiw b3ubo1q w mui 1ni11ib ir1i fli lb r13 ,

f1i nV .aibbB bnB idmun noflq1i mn B bbuI3ni mui o21A .3I1 noi1B1n1q briE

Page 25: DMDiSIOW - NBER

bpooLbpA Dia !U uq CflLLIJ1 JLILB!c o vc!ufop uq IBIA! bGLoucj couibntu 2Aw2 bL2OUI !UICL tucJclqc

h6LOIJJJ

1FqILJCLOOIJJ dnthmu rnq 1H011L bpoo qcAcJobiu UJCJJ!IJLA CPCU.A CL III C1J!COic' cuJc: JjC2 o bpofoLbp? cdnibaiui uq bpoto qcAjobu EXbCLIGUCG MUJJ

V'I!I CP!O IFQLOflU onuq: jiu boipou uq pnbLou EGPU19L IOOO-V' J001 CPLL CLJ(

bLcb f1UIUJL OUJA JOOi-iOO TO LOqliA CP!CO IFCOC!OU KCWflLUf fUq JL FflUCJJ MJIbGL2OU (pcj iuq pou mwu)' por uq ooq

JOO5-bCP11tLA JoOt J5ct ELOUf f CP!COe 1Fjrnq xbucucc iu p!4cuq!u pnt IUfGLIOL qcJu uq ooq bLcbLiuoIr Vflf1ic co: ftJU bo2if!ou Ju juc qiuiu IUIIWUOU (ioui M!U ouA) A' CfGLU IjO

EXbGL!6UCG

BLOWCL\Bt iCL bLoLu Oc14G: AOIflUfGCL JOL qJC flLfU yqnj F!CLCA bL0Lm JOL 11JC OUJGJC B!

mJCqA H'P 2C1JOO! CP!CO IF'

EqflCJOIJ

v wii OL bi4-imc bo2i!ou ooq cLL\nfbc2ou

EwbIOuJGur OP1GC!AG

ff2flWC

Page 26: DMDiSIOW - NBER

muM

rth9jdO kisinio1qm3

.no1qiiw s noithoq mii-t1Eq io liii A

noiuba

.OD 13vnU joofb r!giH iiD isbD

lii 3viioA .moi1 niiun agniiq 13vIi ni noinBqmo ioin s iinu1oV :9iiivibA .bliug wivi inEiuEi1 1vn3U

93n9i19qx3

bir! oi Ani Ii qu bhow lud noiqud s z ng .ninib 3nfl ni no21qiisW :iuI gb!wonA niw vi2n1x bnE f!th hEw ninib nut oh noihibbE nI ii niilhiw ibiiw

tQQ I irnndT- I QQ I !u1 ,

gni1i bnfi i1EnE ihiib ,

ni1ub3r13 ilbiw 3n!1qx b&! o1E .OD ivnU 11EM 1nioqi2W

no gninEw IIBI)13o3 bib o1A .qiq boo1 fihiw gnihiiw A3Ed bnE bnoiI :IBH bris LInZ) bo1 .OD boow1n IQQI 1u1-IQQI &uiEM )L3b ioobluo n

nu1 bnA3w bnE imnu 4niiuEi1 1im1 b3sq h1 iol noiqufl :ifIE1uEJ5I anbh .OD boowfn3

, .b5I floqbiiH 8V .OQQI 1u1-Q8QI

11bI OIVI 1mobu3 vinxd .b)hEffrIqu ni i1Ib 1uoA3r!D : b hEfmqu Jw1i boow1gn3

, .b51 IIiH bunlEW .Q8I nu1-Q8QI uni iuokr13 bxhbuqmo3 bnE

IJwoI9q

briE gnibE1 oin I .i31i1 bns 1iuqmo3 J3iEb lo u iii 1n113x3 gnuikil

Page 27: DMDiSIOW - NBER

D1I2 LC bLo/qGq !IJ HGCJWJIJ iuq iccjurnu (j)uiiiii) w. tjic ujc pm ior Ipc curnjc cdna tjc bLoppJpfA o u OGL (oL IIJfCIJJGft) tOL fC icurnjc pm uo urnj2AIflUJ1LTC tLCIJJCU1 O JJJ1JC2 9IJq CI1J912 AIJMJJmL? UJC1J2 1JL WC bLOpMj!O 1jJ bL 0J bbiCUt2 O1U 911OL (OL

JJJC Jfl(CflJJOO L1O 9IJq COUqL110U iU 1C1 9LC LGbcc1iAcJ? J91c niibjc uq 2UJjJ9wb f22 t w IJITJJ JJTho1JJ!2 ot

BOfIJ tGUJJ '33 1'00s ' (3) roo (I) 100 ()J 33 () ' (8) iOO (3)

B0Wk'sI1C 5 • Cx) 'xi Cx) O (s)YI I 1 (x) 83 (Q) 20 (5)

GqTnm-bL1cG f'oM-DLIc

C

couqir!ouJ i8u j jfq(cpj.Jooq LjTO 'jb-A9Jn1C21 Ot AWWGjLA

IU1/!GM cw9JC oujA j3Ifl1U1CM UJ9C oujA 'so 'io

POW 13 33 'JO140 JIJCWCM2 'SQ

BoIP t"1 SQ 43 '38's (is) io (Jo) ()

i"i i 's (ii) •x3 (ii) •s (is)BOW UT 'Q J 'Q5 'ILI9TC S Q4 (ii) g (is) i8 (ii)LAIJC i ' (is) Q1 (o) 'so (10)

H!JJbL!cG JqrnW-bUcC fOM-bLTCG

W X\Mt'° S)couqi1!0u1Jiu 1 01 ii 05pjccjipooq iuio 'Ø 'i oo

b-ijricjG O 2A1111C11.A

OttCL 10 UJJ OIJJA 'Ot 'JOOttCL 10 WJC oujA cJ3 •5 '00OUL2 10 j)O1JJ '04 '10 10lilO OttCI2 48 '43 Q5

BOWt'I 00 •50 38jcurnjc s o (is) 'io (Jo) ' (o)ECUJ9IC 1 '00 (ii) 'ct (ii) 's (is)BOW UJJG2 '48 '4 8 •iO

'(ii) '45(15)?Ic I 'cts (is) 'Q (o) 10 (To)

H!JJ-DL!CC FOM-DLJCG

N' O\N° (v

jpj j: DCCL!b1!AG iu1!C2

Page 28: DMDiSIOW - NBER

X !ObL!CS

(•3) (.) (•)bLq MJIJJ Wj 3 44 4 30

x jnp-bucc (.f)MJLJJ UJJC 3 ...

(it) (3d)•10

x Io/-bLcc (4o)MTJJ CUJJG 3 ... 10

x pip-bucc (3)bLCq PA!fP JJJ 3

(•13) (.3)s1Lcq MItJJ 3 00 1 Q

(so)1�flUJC 3 x JoM-bucc -.0x

(38)I�2f1WG 3 X jfljJ-bLJCG -03

(11)Kç' 3 00 11

J{2flUJ 5 X joii-buc •Ø3

(30)cnwc x pip-buc ... -

(13) (3i)KGflW3 -•03 01

(31) (.) (.) (g) (s) (34)o,i-bucc -40 -40 -48 -3Q 3Q 41

(J4) (.,) (•33) (j) (.18) (.14) ( 1)HJP-bL!C •00 01 04 00 08 00 •01

(J3) (Jt) (j) (1.x) (14) (u)ECIJJ1C X IJJCqlflUJ-bLJCC -J -1O -Jo 0O -T3 -01

(.) (31) (.) (so) (3o) (so)huJJ X JOM-bUC 3O 4J 40 34 31 10 LX

(•IQ) (. jg) (•3) (.18)hJJJ1C x pp-buc -48 -o -3 - -4J

(1) (3) (3) (st) () (Q) Cx)

(tiucj EUC( O A4P1C °1J bL0PJMll1A O op Ott)jJC 3: EUC1 bLOP! IWC O Of Ou Edflf!0U

Page 29: DMDiSIOW - NBER

aujj IJJG911LC (G W9Liu9J GGC1a 0 (G bLicG-c91coT.A ou rpc bLopup!JiiA o pc ontCoujcJJJn2 JJG COGUJCTGIJIa O piJJ-bL!CC 9uq joM-bLJcG wn(ibpcq p? pc bLop9p!juA 0 (JIG Ofl(COUJG GA9fI91Gq 91 IIJG auuibjc WG9U2iqJ WuJG uq bucc C1G0L1G2 91G qGjIJGJ 2np1L9c1!n 0 G (JIG WGU 1)uILGq MUJJ GUJJG wm buitcq M!IJI GW91G 512 fJJG C0I.LCJ9(IOU LGaTqnJa OL 9bbpcuuIa 10 (JIG 29UJG LG2(911L91J( JJJG HJICL9CITOU2 G(/fGGIJ buucq M1JI GUJjG 5 OL b9nGqvau 4GuJ9JG JJJG L9UOUJ GCCf a abccujc9(iou jjoa cowwou GLLOL cowboucu( ucoaa lop ubbJIcuuf a (0 (JJG 29flJC LG2(9flL91J11LC9tflJ (JIG awbjc wuua 92 pccq 9LG LGboi.cq iu b91cIupGaa vu Iu(cLccb( M92 iucjnqq lu 9J abccicuuoua ECW9IG 5 2 (JIGVwbo(!c 219uqLq CLLOL2 cowbn(cq n2Iu i j121-oLqcL j9XJ0L 2GUG2 9bbLoxlurnliou 0L (JIG GCbLG22i0U 0L fJJ!2 bLop9pijitA 9uqj9JG LGboI.(2 GJJGC(2 ou bLop9piji(A C9JCITJ9IGq buiuj (JCUA9UAG2 o bLop9pipIA o OfT(COUJG /fI1JJ LG2bGC( 10 A9L!9P1G

ro-pjcGpiJooq -QQg

(38) (ti) (4o) () (3o) ()41 4Q 4T 43

(.45)JGUJ9jG 5 X j0l-bLJCG

EGW$IG x JJJJJ-bLJcc

(•11) (.5)JjGUJ9JC5 -J4

(1) (5) (3) (4) () (Q) ()

L9P1C (cou(iunGq)

Page 30: DMDiSIOW - NBER

X JOM-bL1CC ('3) ('se)b1Lq HJtJJ UJJC 5 '43

x pi8p-bL!CG (')b!Lq Mitp UJJ 5 '..

('1?) ('5)b!'q ft!fJJ UJIJC 5 '13

X JoM-bucc ('38)nLGq MIqJ ,CWC 5 "x pi8jJ-BL!Cc (,)1Lq MIIJJ 1UJJC 5 " -

(Tf) ('sjx)JLC MT1p ;GUJJG 5 " "08 '01

('30)I1IJJG 3 x JoM-bL1C -.

('58)x p8jJ-bucG " -'5j " "'

('is) ('so) ('TI) ('is) ('is) ('Js)}çG2flWC3 '1 'S3 '00 '08 '00 'JO

(• 3)JC2fTUJ 3 X JOPd-bLiC " - '04 " "

('t) ('so) ('51) ('so) ('so)K2crwc 5 x pp-b4cc " -'ft -'51 -'33 -'51 -'JO

('13) ('5)KflWC 5 " '04 5J " "

('To) ('To) ('30) ('to) ('53) ('so) ('51)F'o/-bucc '40 "40 -'ti -'40 '40 '34 -'41

('i) ('i,x) ('5?) ('to) ('5?) ('To) ('to)HP-bL -'01 -'00 '50 '0, 'T '0 'O.X

('18) ('To) ('51) ('so) ('54) ('51) ('s4)CWj x wqrnm-buc -'so -'so -'ss -'31 -'18 -'08 '13

('1) ('18) ('10) ('51) ('38) ('5?) ('st)LWJ )< JoM-bLic '34 '54 53 '14 'OQ '04 '01

('14) ('T) ('ii) ('so) ('To) ('Ti) ('Jx)hCW x jJi8p-bucc -'38 -'30 -'30 -'?O -'?? -'38 -'30

(1) (s) (3) (ct) () () ()

(,iiuj EtC O, LJJ OU bLOP9NITIA oj, IuuM)LPIG 3: guqow ECCL2 IILOP!1 E!Wf2 O lu LMCM Ed1ItOU2

Page 31: DMDiSIOW - NBER

VAwbtouc ruqq cuoi o pcc qcu,1iAc tc Lcboltcq !u bcupcc J001U0LG 10 jJC 0L qqJ1J01rn qijjpj ibou CCC12 ou bLoppi1uA cjcrijcq buij o bLoppiJiA o oncowc MU Icbcf 10 upc

'o-jijcjipooq -800

() () (•) () (ax) () ()15 J5

(R)JcwJc x joii-bucc

(t)x p8p-bucc

(•JQ) (.Q)- 80

(J) () (1) (t) () (Q) Cx)

jpjc (couuucicq)

Page 32: DMDiSIOW - NBER

MGLG bcqccijA COJJJIJGL N1JJ iiJcjnqcq A9U9pJG2C1C80UG2 /1GLG UO1 G21TW1Gq GCfT2G UJ9IJA O IJJC2C IIUGLC110U2 MGLC bcqcci bLGcpcloL2 0J IPG Ofl1COWG OL

GWJG x JoM-bLicc ii bcc bLGqTctoL 2bccrUct!ou2 uJcjnqiu IJJOLG qC1ijCq TU1GLC1!0U2 MTIP bLJcc1O11 0 4 bbJiCuJJ0IJ2 OL MpICJJ IU1GLAIG/f2 MGLC LGCGMGq E'P1 OP2CLMIIJOU2 JJ1 10 G qLobbcq GCI12G

20 L9IJOW GIIGC12 G211UJ1C2 MGLG uoi cowbntcq Jj0GJ2 MCLG cquutcq J0L 4Q bbliCliOU2 ont o 1GOL qqrqouj qGtiJ2 GCUf12G 0J 1G LG2ILiCITOIJ 10 IJJO2C LGCGIALU TU1GLAJGM2 IpG bIJG M2 uo JOUGL

A1JpJc V2AWblotJc 21UqLq GLLOL2 0J £JJG2G qcLJArJAG2 LG LGbOLIGq Ju bcutJJG2G2 GG O0LUOLG 10 JJG 5LP1G LGBOLI2 GIJGC12 OU bL0ppiJi1A cjcnjicq bui.tj qCL1A1LAG2 o bLopupiplA o OfIICOUJG MIIP LG2bGCI 10

o-pjccjipooq -5Q't

(.3')EGWJG 5

(.54)b!LGq MIIJJ UJ1JG 5 -

(18)bLCq MJLJJ JGUJJG 5 IO

(18)KC2flWG 3 -.J

(.18)G2flIJJC 5 -15

(•SQ) (.5) (•SQ) (•SQ)FoM-bucG - •5Q - - 5 - SQ

(To) ( Jo) ( To) (.10)H!8P-b4CC 05 •0J

(.51) (51) (sT)EGWJG x uJcqinuJ-bucc -•11 -•11 - 01

(53) (s) (so)EGUJJG x jij-bucc - 44 - 4Q - 32 -2]

U) (5) () (i)

(L6iuJ EU.GC(2 OJ MUPJC2 OU bL0PUP!HIA O lOP OUGL)LP1G 4: bLopif E21!UJ1G2 0J lOP OJIGL EdU0U2 tOL fTp291JJbjG IcGcG!A1138 IU1GIJJG/

Page 33: DMDiSIOW - NBER

1gojg\pL iwoo

IQ-IXWL 1QO J300

I5IWL I50O Z13?0 ZJ00

2JJUJ2 0 0fl12WPZt00V1 JØK32JJI2 0 Q-g 0fl13

DA--50O\1IC ? 0O

D!UUCL80\QiJ0flL 13332JJI5

3 rnucp--4o\4-ponL V000

5• 0Q0\8ô JJOJIL 2JJ!(

-Q JJOIIL 2JJI5

DL0X0\ g•33 jØ•J N002JJW

F rnucJJ--to-o\4ponL V000 J5•Ø U00Icq!rrw-Duc L2I1nLmJte:

\1\1 OH\1tu ':i ••Q

10 3\pL 500It-J'JJL 10 JX00

5QJJL Z5000

T\PL V0O

I800 50R0 5300

JJOIIL 2P1U

I8 300

1UJW11UJ 3Ø(J(JØ\AL J00

Ô0O\1JL

DIIJUCL0\PL p000JIOfIL 21J11J

0L ZTQQ5• LcJq2I\Jnucp--

1• i1JiUJf1UJ3OOOO\AU jooH!P-IL1 L2(rfliJf2:

roucq IU0LW1I0U pu1wnW\pL ApqDOJUflJJL VXJWnUJ\JJL

jipjc : jUoLwLJOu OU H0flLJA EuJ!u2 pA jC21flLIJ1 bL!cc CfGOLi2

Page 34: DMDiSIOW - NBER

(buni1no) 1chT

.ithmijmixsM .iif\lniogbiM .iri\mumiriiM rioiflrino1ni br1og351 ninirn3i 3rrn-muib3M

00.I O?.E1 O0.1Z .if\I-1

QUZ wtK tu

\W HO\ t kuk

in1uf32i 3ohcl-woJ 8V. \0-0--bAW .1

ftid 1UQf1-

11i112

O0.ô jocf\0-O. S

oo.iiZ oo. 00.IZ .id\1Z

00. 1 00.1 0.1I 00.8

00.oI

0O.I 0i1 00.41 .8

00.I 00.M 00.1

• I I Th •Q

?A.OI nwrN

lo gni b 1fnoqbim bus ansi 2gnicns io sw b inioqbim moñ b3i3Jnino3 i3w ismi1 inioqbiM

2mumixsm bus amuminhn gniim iii ni1Ifl ifls b3nlqmo3 i "a1!3 115 ui grriIIfl sivA" .ffluk iq wod .hrioqi rs iits1 di 1rio 11311w &numinirn riliw mumixsm bus 3nioqbim ui rii11i1 13ñ5 bits a1nioqbirn 113kw

Page 35: DMDiSIOW - NBER

1uJc s i u.ijc ij i t° uwbj G2 uq qqwoiuj qij

coJqwouj 2IIJ 1C2 38 38pjccppooq L9f!0 ic

J21 0, JJIJJ1LA

!IUCUiM GUJJ!C OIJJA 0ô 18IucucM ujc oujA .oIIUCL/t!CM 0LjJ 18 08j40 IUICLAJCM2 18 !8

HP-tL!CC jcqJnuJ-nucc F0M-bL!CC

W XUH2\'C1UOU'

couq!nouJ !8IJ 1C21 03 32jpp00q L1jo 1c oJ To

b-AuJncL21 0 AunJJc1LA

O1CL 10 GWuJC oujA yj 18OUCL 10 IJJjC ouj) i8 00OU 10 pOfJJ •0J,10 0UC12 3Q

H11J-DLTC yIcq!nw-DLTc

'4•

bbcuqix jpjc j: DCL!bUAG 2W1!TC DL0bb!U jwj