Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
����
������������
�������� ����
������ �����
�������� ��� ��
� � � � � � � � � ����� � ��� �� � � �
2
����
������������������������������� !"�
#�$#%��&�������'()����*!'��+,-.��/0���"
12�34�567�8�9:;:?���&��������}g�"qO!�
2SI4�p��!q��J�4DEhsHtSDEsHtJ
�4�� X�Sl\�"#Op '
CNI4¡¢�£'��P�k¤�?���P�>?4�I"!���>?
-��àá��aâã�>?�äk¹º å-'S4@AæÑ�²_�ÒÓÔ�Õ
'¬��:Ë�b%O%-�çå èéO%�4J�±ê�>?@A .��©
�ë ìl»nO4êß-íîS>?@A�ç�b%Oï�¬" ðñ"\��r
r pò">?�óô�4Ô"õö�óô�÷O%��f�Õ�´ø�~,õö ùú4
�I û�bÍ��##~N-%²!�Iü4ýC þ,�����zS-�-�¬
"!���Û��I�I�pò'���>? M,¬"��Jq����4>4
1 SAMİ N.ÖZERDİM��YAZI DEVRİMİNİ KAVRAYAMAYANLAR��TÜRK DİRİ � Yıl28�Cilt ��������Sayı 326�1 Kasım 1978�pp.528�589�
2 ���������������������� !"�#$%&'()*�2001�pp.678~683+
3 Hüseyin Yorulmaz�TAZİMATTAN CUMHURİYETE ALFABE TARTIŞMALAR KİTABEVİ�İSTANBUL�1995�p.7�
3
�4�-��¹ºñ)'�%O%J\�M«\�>?'%q���Jq�Ñ4��
>? pò�~N�O�Æ# �l�\¬"!���J�wx�Y2O#J,¬"!�
J��f�Õ'õö �q�l��~N�����4�b�~N�O�Æ#\�+,
��J��$���b�~q�ö ùúÆ\+,����&�DE�Ñ�Sõ
ö'�b�~N-%"�%�������#O´ø����q�l�ö åbÍ��
�#�,�r
���� ����������� ÜÅ4������>? t�"#4�9�>?4��P�>?k�?-����
âã�>?'���!Õv���>?'¬IS�t�ñ->?���l �J��K
%>?�!�¹º'�q�4�pk>?'¹º "Õ4Yk@Á �l�\"±ê
�4´û'M«#O%�pk>?'YZI�¬"!���Û����&����
�>? «%Opò �#O%��##4#GsHæJ���& �#O%�>?
���P�>?��q����&�¶-$R_�¬�DEFGH�>?@A���
"%2+,�à%��4��&�¹º4��& ��aâã�>?�¹º4-
'��P�>? «%4���>? ù�(�p">?�óô""!�åO%�
%� �, �������
��P�>?�)*�>?"±�+,�4�+,����������S-JI
��)*�"±��.S/0"4>?´��{|�-%�>?�!��
DG�&1'�l4î"2�~N��¬"�FEâã�>? 3�¬"'���!"
!"��P� �SN\���45#�>?���5�##���·
"��Ñ�67-���8¶�"!-qO4�9��9:4;:J�4?�¤�?����CJq�DE�JGJ-p �&\�
���!MNI��!#�9��';:
4
� «%OS>k>T'UIO%�'4�Ï���V�9���4DD����
&!�W�Ï7:8X'·#�Ñ!��&�Y#pò��l4pò"#O�!
qZS¤�?��&>T��4��P�[¤
�?��-
�{|&1�+l�&I�¬"4-���_'åSI��ÊË�X'�V�9�"
`�:� abc�d��D^�ef�4��P�[¤�? 0#����P�>?��&I���&
���&��~qO%-%"%, '»'�+,�-q����P�>?��
�&��~,!���-%4¡j�¢�¶-w������P�>?�
���&�-%4|!�Iü4J���P���hb�{|#-�4��&�
�Gb���¬���4��P�>?��&I�À"b�£�%�b!�ç£��
�&�-qO#J,�##>¤k{|¥¦-��£�ç£ åøÍ�¬"�§
��q���(¨©"-q���ªà«ª¬k®¯¬��£�°ø�� bÍO
%-q���4k�lÊË��>%��i¬"'/0��q�� 7 ���������������������� �789�pp.678~683+
5
�, ���
���>?"����;:?�;:?���& �\
¼'OSI��DEFGH4���>?�+���&¡j'»�I����
�>?Î?'uvDb�|�Ip\�
�|ñ-�& �à"\��>?�¡�4¶>?[½>? �N�OD>?"¡2Iü
FE����¾ñ-���[��������,Õ4q4¿4x �h>?���&��«%SI-%�J�4À&1 !�-%?{"!b?{Îcçrsşroöruürıirgğ Ð�4�I�IÁ�>?"#OÂNI��>?�H"å-I-%À&1"#OÃ'��� ariru�»�ÀIÎi�î�ÄI�Ð4{|�K%¬"4��%�Ææ�}|�ÅÆ �N\�¬�À&1�ÄÇI�¬"'��4
ÜÅ"��$È��u"��MNI-%����>?�+�¬�>?�!�4|&1
�É�Oº�44|"|�Ip!�ÊË��!�'�%� r
�, ����
��&�4��P�>?e©�Ì9?"��Í,�>?�+qO!�&I
�10� Ì9?�+���&>T��DG�UÎSDEFsHtJ�Éss
îº�'½ÏIO%��ÐU��'�q�'4DE���%�"4�>
Ñ�ÒÓ-�4>Ñ3Ô!hJI�+,�-q��Ì9?�+��&�4��P
�>? «%�ÊË�+l����|ñ�4T²�:�Ë���Ôß�4|
-lÕB��#O%�"pNI�� ��Í,�>?�+lI���&>T!4D�SåSI��DE�
��$ÈkÖ×-�!½ÏI��À"b�ë"#O4DE�SFs�UÎ�
ÍO�5�*���4&ØÙ95�-ÚÛ>'ÜÀS%O%��T²�ÚÛ
8 ?�@A!BC1��DEF�"G'HI9J�2005�K.7+ 9 ���������������������� 789�pp.678~683+ 10 ���������������������� 789�pp.678~683+
6
Ù5:]+ú=? «%�ÊË���-S{4��Í
,�>?4�9�>?4)*�>?4S�����'&IO%��¬�¬"
ST²�'«%O%�>?��%�p��êÝ','2��11
Ì9?k��Í,�>?�+���&�&�>?@A� �I#4��
}�¸¹ Þ2�"12SI�'4��&��&j"#O��#Oý�-�¬"�
-q�� r ����¤�����&�&
12!.�SI������;:% %O%��##4���¤
����P�>?+l!���>?�À"b�£ �#4+läå "qO%���
��¤��æ~�%%!���-q�'4¬I�µB����>?�+���
&�&�§Ý z\!�"-q�� r ¬¬�ç²�¶èÆæ4�567�8'³áéã"#OP�ê��ëÅ#O%�
"�45�*��%�ìÔ��O��í�H'���¬��í�| Ñ»4�
���¤��IO%����c��ÜÅ���&�¤�'�l4'Àî
ï#O%�(�%� r r r
Dunya inssanlar idjin bir dari imtihandir. Imtihan idilene inssanin here cuale moutlaka peke mouvafike djevabe vermessi mumqune olmaya bilire. Fekate duchunmelidir qui heuquume djevablarin heieti oumoumiyessindene hassil olan mouhassalaya gueure virilir.
r r Dünya insanlar için bir dar-ı imtihandır. İmtihan edilen insanın her suale
mutlaka pek muvafık cevap vermesi mümkün olmayabilir. Fakat düşünmelidirki, hüküm, cevapların heyet-i umumiyesinden hasıl olan muhassalaya göre verilir.
r r r r Ôã�"qO4��.ðñä����òð¬'xO�¨©�ó-ô
Þ2�¬"�({#!§��-%�##4¬�+,�12-�O�%Í
-%�õö�xO�ô2S�FÞ�÷�+qOÞ2SI� !,À"b�ë ønO�+,�¬I���&�ùÐU�H'4Dú$#%ÎÜ
11 LMNOPQ+R-R�RSTU"��VWXYZ[\][-^_+ 12 Geoffrey Lewis,The Turkish Language Reform A Catastrophic Success, OXFORD University Press, 1999, p.31�
7
Å�Ð��&134Fú��P�>?
144h4���bxl��I�I�&IO
%�� ���Korkma, sönmez bu şafaklarda yüzen al sancak,
Sönmeden yurdumun üstünde tüten en son ocak. O benim milletimin yıldızıdır, parlayacak; O benimdir, o benim milletimindir ancak! Çatma, kurban olayım, çehreni ey nazlı hilâl! Kahraman ırkıma bir gül; ne bu şiddet bu celâl? Sana olmaz dökülen kanlarımız sonra helâl. Hakkıdır hakka tapan milletimin istiklâl...
13 Etem ÜNGÖR,TÜRK MARŞLARI,ANKARA ,1966, p.164� 14 BİLAL N ŞİMŞİR,Türk Yazı Devrimi, Turk Tarih Kurumu, 1992, p.371�
8
¬�+,�±�|��JI�>%�!4>?'û��¤:�-�����>?
����bxl�>%���P�>?�&�>%+l!>?¡'�%�¬�ü%�4
²�%�>?�YZ�]Í�ØÖ�3�!+��nSI�¨©��q��r r r r r
���� ������Islâh-ı hurûf���������tebdîl-i hurûf� � DGhEÈDGÉH�ÊË�Ì�]Í�Â@A Î5�ÏË:�Ð�Ñ4
ÒÓÔ�Õ�+qO-''ýIO%���b%O4T²+,k�$#�ÙÚ þ
#�$ÈkÖ×�]%OØÖ'×Jq������¬�ØÖ�-�:Ë�4�4�
�4�ñ�¨©�!qO·IO%��J�¬IS"�C#OU�Opk>?�¨
©!�m��ýI�w���"%,çå'èéSI��DGÉsHUÎ�ØÖI
×����&�>?"¤��¨©�4���>?'òÍzISI�DEFGHJ�
�% �#-'SÝ%����²t t�\�3X4�Xk¶Ñ��'¬��:Ë
�#�ìl»nO%��U��4��&�?�@Áo �c#4�Õ
�¬� �e>?�YZo���l %������ `aDb7c`���Mdefgfghicjklmno�Npqrstcuvcwx
jkn����yz��C[{e|�}l�~9oOv+�
��}l�eneDmcODOkn+
15 , ¡s`�¢�£¤fln��O¥l�t¦_cBC1��O§_¨k:����y
z�©;ª«¬e «�DmD�®¯e°±an+ N�RB²R��e����³´cµ`�e«m�¶9·�¸¹�$«º»±
+ q�|¼�$½¾eRB²R��O¿fÀÁ�BC1���Âo~9fÃÄm+
«Å«gBC1��e½�ÆÇOMÄDoÈÉ�$��DH���ÊËo
+ Ì���o�Í�Î�6Ï��Ðc«nce$Ñ«RB²R��e«�
Ò[ÓÔÕ���±BC1��OÖ¤Ä×+ Ø�RB²R��e\ÙT\�ÚÛ�Ük�º»�ÝÞTß
16e���O¦k¦kc
15 Hüseyin Yorulmaz�789�pp.8~23� 16 ÝÞTßDe�à$á£��+RB²R�e-ÞT[Dm+â"ã\ä1{åcæ�"G�[B1Oçèn�`�ᣱ+�[B1eÌéê7o"ëjkl
9
ìaln�e«m+íîD¼ïðce«vñòe«m+^alóÙB\îô
±��o���cõ_Lök÷øe«mDm+ �ù����yz�©�ª«®¯eDmD�
N�RB²R���¶9·�¸¹e�úû«`��üýeÈɱ+þ���c��
��{[�O�ökg�n÷ø�«m��O�ögÙ]��ie��+ q��Í�Î��c¨Dc�mle�Ò[ÓÔÕ����OÖ¤ÄDe÷«
�Ò[ÓÔÕ�Îc¨alm��al���O�_£m�ölm+B
C1��Dü�D��«o_e_n«m+ Ì�|¼�����je�����oÜklmDD�î�������m±+|
��Ük�¬o�£¤flm��o¿fm��ceñ ðe«m+ Ø�RB²R��e!"fm`��#mú¢~l$O%kj�«m+&'
c9ÄgÃ9D`+BC1��OÖ¤Ä7cd(����^
mü)ù·O*è×+ +�RB²R��e�[B1���
17±_�\ÙT\�,1-±+��Oyè
De��DóÙB\EFD��«o_O.DO®/Ä�+ , �^c0B0Bc�kn®¯e����c1$fn`�`±kg�íîû«`
�`±+2`3m®¯eÃe_óÙB\c4Ä×�Ò[ÓÔÕc4Ä×±a
n+ �5e�6ú�WXO§_78n9��:;��#ã�¯�Oan+
�, ������
?1-{[��@�d(Ä��OAfBèDc�ml�RSCÔ��-DEF
Ô��Õ,0eGl¯�OªHfn+`IvÕ,0ekcñfl`aDb7®
¯OJ×lmn+-DEFÔ��Õ,0e Kavaid-i, Osmaniye Dmê�9K�� =_�qL5NpÌM��NOÄ×P�`ÝÞTßOQÄ+:��óÙB\RÏ�S�
TU�VW (�XYZ[:\];!AóÙB\%&'�U^6�2002�p.184+; 17 !�[B1'e���e�æ����O®/fn+nDè~«l`�¬�«l`�e_kO`m`�Dfla+RB²R�bb�"GOhÄR-RÃRS
TU`�!�[B1'öemcRB²R�îèklm+RB²R��oc
dcefû«´O`�Dc«an�`kc�«o+:-.-/�-01�78
9�pp.61-62;
10
��c±RB²R��g�«mÇOMdÄnc��·O¯�öÄ÷øo±D
9mn+� s@chÁC[{i/jS�Õ,0o®¯OJ×n+i/jS�Õ,
0ekl�mnRSopÔ�:elifba;�ÚV�n����mqDËcrfl9kDOsn+«Å«g�Ò[ÓÔÕeL�tu�vwneÄc7xc~
9Oflm�cfl���eDmD���¿fjoº»_�sc«al`�
�Oyc�ök«mDm+ , hÁúzc`���{xo Terakki|}n+�A~��Maarf-i Umumiye�:|¼î�;DmiêäóÔF1�pó�ê�mno�jkn+�mn�
ª«$ûe���yzc�ml±an+�^cJ×lm+ , , ,
d(���e�[B1�������¼ï�,1-±+��
�Oyzf«mDeÙ{1�7ÚO�ÈÉcÄÎc«_� :Ù{1;oÚÛf«mDeÒ[ÓÔÕ�|ÜkDc�«o �±+n��e#��D«(��OÄ׫m+
Terakki,31 Temmuz 1869. , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ff� �@äóÔF1�pó��mncfl�hÁA~ßÞÔ�
CESÔ�póofmèOfn+CESÔ�póexO(��ölA~
c�n+ ��e#��e«m������Onflm+þ�
e�£¤YO¢è�¢anOölmn+óTÙ�SB1Ù ÃRCTU�|¼e���^_`aD¿fm"�O£¤f�~9Ofl m+��"��¿fje���e«m�Gî�Ö¤jklm ù·c�io±�+, , , , , , , , , , Terakki,2-3-4 Ağustos 1869., , , ,
, |üï�Onalm[\��{`�C[{c�ml®¯OJ×lmn+
ßÙ��1o"an�RB²R��eóÙB\�ÚÛ�8�cflxO9
mn+nóB1$£C�1�ä[1�ªH�óÙB\¼ïeRB²R����m
c¯¡¦klm�cfl`9mn+[\��{eZ�^cJ×n+
����nc¢���OÖ¤ÄDm£¤«¥nOÄ«+Ù{1 #ãRÏeRS1¦[Fc^§O¨nc`¦©�_kO#ªî� Ö¤f«an+RÏ�C10[��Ä�§O#«Df«an+ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Hürriyet,23 Ağustos 1864.
11
¬e"�:RB²R��Mm;�ü)o®ëÄDONÁn+n¢�mnc=
ml`®¯OJ×n+ |�Üke"��e«m����DhÁm¿fm~9O
į�ORCTU|¼�ÂDvo£m«flm�e�d°c ±²O³ö×�î��ù·Oül*è´Ä×+ Tasvîr-i Efkâr, 10 Temmuz 1866.
, �ù�?1-{[�@zcµ¶fn·¸��RT[�ÙR[Ee����ü)��i
OíîD¹¨Ä׫mDbº�^cªHfn+ RB²R��em»�÷øð��i�����yz�em«m+RB²R
�����OMÄDe�BC1��MÄÒ[ÓÔÕ���D¼×n� ^_½9öl¾al`al`9ö+n^_¿«mYOÀ+RB ²R��ceCTÔ�o±+
ÙR[EeRB²R��O�_�öDO3Áf�\ÙT\D��ÂðOÃ�ø
ðo±DJ×n+ff¬�ªHe���yzcfn`������ü)�÷øð
o«mDm®/OÄvm«an+ , ���ü)�xÅo�flhic«almnNÆLrstbÇ�Ør�+rs�¢c
`hÁhiofgfg§_78klmn+�úze��OAfÁBÄDox�
�C[{c«anök�"���ÈV��icDan+ ,
�, �������
NpqÌsÌÉq��ói¦kn��Ïw�Ê�0[\�UBp
e�ÙË[Ìc=mlnÍnÍA~«Îkklmn���ü)�icflèO
J×n+, , ,
e��O~«m�e«m�RB²R��eEF2`ÏfmO fn��±+_kc�ÐeÑ�ZEF$Òb|DÓc�s¢Ômn Do±+Ðe¬^_Õ�½jCÖOD_�¥nO×èn+åóØ�à SB1Ù�ce���OMd^«BC1��e«m+
, � ÙÉ@�Ú/Ûó1�-0[ÚÔ�eA~mn�OÙ{1o£al
m��DÜÍ�ö÷øðean«mD"an@c��^cJ×n+
12
vwne#ª(s�às�Ý3flm�can~9O#v m«m+�^«"��î�e±_«�Þß�vwo s`#ªcal� `#v«m�« �ncú¢OàÃÄ�+«ÅáÔ«m�+ #ªâ�#Í�_fl `ã«m+A~e~«m��`~«m�ä e««�+ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Resimi Gazete, 22 Eylül 1923.
, -DÞ�,DäpÔC1e"���iO§_78n±mnc=ml����e
Ù]o}l�¿fj�å�û«¬±DJ×��iO2GcRB²R��O¤ml
���O9¢mOævçècÜÍLön+
���ceÇé7�øO°dÄ�cêµÄëË«��o÷ø+ þ�e�÷øð3ìf��ìfc¶jkl��� Nrrrí_`�ü)oîïjklm+
, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Servet-i Fünûn, 27 Ağustos 1925. , NpqLsÌÉqÆ�Lö�Akşam|e�6úOtMÄ9�Ã$#îðn�¢�B
C1��O³ö¨k�³ö¨k«m�c�ml�ÁñOòn+ ³ö¨k×Dènãenan�(±an+_ke�RÞåóÔB�-DEF
��SD��REjD\Ù?So�ä[iÔ�fn+ �ù³ö¨k«mDªHfnãe�RÝ[�Ù�ED1å�RT[�-0jÔô�
RT[�ß�\�\R[T\�-DEF��óÞBÚ\�RBßÔC1�-ô�R
Ù\�tMûcmnREB\�ÝB1C�Ú/Ûó1�ÙR��äT�jC�ó
B�ED��ÌD²�óÞBÚ\�-i�äT���õ>ö÷ú
û>üýD\Ù?So�,Dô±an+18
Pþfn½�¾e6ú£¦klmn��:RB²R��;cįùO�Mf��
���cf¬�®¯�jOgfn+�De��ü�o sÜklfan
DO`nfn+ , \RT\�-DEFÔ�e�o|oÜklm¬ORB²R����mDflm
cfl�Z�^cJ×n+ ÐeÙ]ó1�^«BC1��O£¤flm|e«ÅÜklm+
18 SAMİ N.ÖZERDİM��YAZI DEVRİMİNİ KAVRAYAMAYANLAR��789� pp.528�589�
13
ó?TR`«Ånjv�£�«omO*èln+�cBC1 ��e«m2�«��O£alm��e�flm+,1ôcj kn"GÃ"Gcñfl9kn �`�9Ke�ÚÛ�Ük�¬c« «m�±+, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Akşam, 31 Mart 1926.
, H��äTå�e�BC1���³ö¨kcÄD"m�RT�ß�\
DhÁRB²R��o½9k)jOJ×n+
Ðo"�e"��#�û«}jO*�fnèd(���:RB ²R��;c�mü)Oþèl�_flìÄDe"��n� ��e±+ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Akşam, 24 Nısan 1926.
óÞBÚ\�-ie�Ù{1��eb|cDal¿fmDªHÄâ�^
«èO�èn+
b|o#ÍÃÄ«DmalN��"����OyèlfDe þcan~mnDo«m+þ�b|���½#vm"� e���_o2`��«"�e«m+v«¯�ÃSB1Ù�OÝ3fl m+k`��Ý�O#vm«m+|�û��ñò�ÜÍ� �"�O#�÷øðO¯fn«g�b|e¿fm9ùOflml `���O#�I+EF$ÒåóØ�îðne���O#v ���cfl$«��O�mnO~mlm«m+ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , Akşam, 19 Nisan 1926.
$#îð�äT[�jC�óBSe�BC1���³ö¨ke�6Ïû«±Ã
�c«DJ×n+ä1ÝT[�##ª�C10[���cñfl�WX�
klm�Í#ã Gombotes Zoltan`R1[�c�anèc=ml�"��m��ÁB�ie��jkI��nçèo�flkn9KO�¤
IDJ×�Z�^c�ön+ , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , BC1��O³ö¨k7c�N��"�ce^�klmù"o±
Do÷ø±+åóØÃSB1ÙÃ_�¢�¼ïo_±ann
14
mc�njv�
15
, NÆLrsNpqÆs�_fl_�@`����ü�cñòfn�Ãklo½
�jk�A~c=ml`xÅo:fjklmn+ff��n°O;kle«
«m+NpqLscRB²R��O��neBC1���³ö¨kOÄ
cmne�NpqÆsòan�����Ö¤eBC1���calü�cþ¦an+óÞBÚ
\�RBßÔC1`î�ãDfl6úÃ×DO°fn+M�,DÔô��ó1ÌeDmD�NpqÆsÆÉq�c$#Afm��c�ml�2G�ÙË[ÌOa
n+RT�ÛóFeBC1��³ö¨k�ãDfl½��5O9mno�Npq
pscäjknBC1��O¤mn2G����%9�?ãD«an+ke�c
Dal`$«@±anfA+ �!���"#$%&'()* î��®ë�������nc��NpEB7�c�ÍVü�o¦kD�
Ù{1��MmÃ�RB²R��_�`�Oü�f^DĶo¯k^c«a
n+75NpqLsOCcRB²R��
16
�ÆÇOMmf^DÄMm·7�ü�an+ff�qrEBcemD�R
B²R��RÂoü��SD«_ò+nDèg�RB²R���TOUc�7
@���Deñò«dcN���Oì� HurufVu, munfasila, oîïjk�6ú�|W$Xß1p�Õ,0c^_Ê`§¤jkn+ ÜY�°¤ceZ«an`���ARSopÔ�^Mmceø«ü)[o±
an+\]Dfl�����K�«_�L�OÀlmnRB²R��],0�
�b�K�Mmc°���ÇO^j�nD�=^Í���ÊËjk_Ç
:ëcÆÇ;cË���O_6lnD±+b�Kc�£¦k��o�j
klmn[«�RB²R�Ã],R��`_OL�ûca©almno�RB²R
��],0����o«ökg£m«ÄDo«anÙ{1�c¼×kg�
$«yVo±an+ �ùe�R�0ó-019��i¦�SDb[T�RS1¦[Fc^alR
B²R���ñfl�§o¦kn23+i/jS�Õ,0DhÁ¯�Oì�RS1¦[F
e�CSTÙOrkóÙ?1ÞcÃall�R��9KD�cc����ü)�c
�mRdefnïO$fg�båB¦[\�ÌD-¦[F�SRå�Õ,0cjj
8n+SR��Õ,0e�ïOh{�nc Cemiyet-i Ilmiyet-I Osmaniye, :Ù{1�#RÏ;
24c�an+RS1¦[F�¯�e§_78k�_��[`Îjk¨
knök�°�=jkDe«an+«Å«g_ke$«�iOa}f�
�óÙB\�9Ko;kkDOij«mDmD³ö¨kk«an
�+
, kDhúc�BC1���Ö¤c�ml�xÅ`�m¢c¦nal=lmn+%9
k�ã�,D\ÛÔF1�b[iel�RÞF/�póD�cc�¬�Æ�±
R0jR��ncÌL
17
, Ù{1o|opqf�NpqÌsc��Ó@|oÄD�Gt$rs\Ù?S
o�{�R?Ì/�e�óÙB\îO|��tu._rÄEvV�JOò+
_��óÙB\îOwx«ñòc±RB²R��ct¦_�BC1��MmO�
��c�¨ÄDOh{f��&cAncnön"�yÐÏc'Án+ NpqÆsÌÉqr��$|¼wÏcl|�¾�O³ö¨kDoz�jkn
26+{w
�ú�±C10[o|���O`³ö¨knD�"fn+î�$Xe��&e
��ic{$flm�_flke�Î6Ïc¨º¬c|alR]c��jk
±ID}fn+ff�(�@c_ke°fn+BC1����¤c=öù·D
°¤ÈÉðO*èncp�C10[o�kn+¬�2G�¶eNpqÆs
LÉqL��ϵpO���~[ôc�ön+�ùeRSopÔ��`�ùe
�·O6fn+R?Ì/�e¬�ϵcöPþOflmn+ , ~[ô�C10[±So[TÚ�S�eR?Ì/�c���yzO°Ä
c=ml����ïo±DOçèn+��eN+s¢Dm�z¢�`��e+s
¢Dm#z¢+îïãnc^D�ù�z¢c=ml2GcÄ×De���M
mORB²R��DBC1���ù#g«le««m+A~e�B\���
O���:RB²R��;���OAfm��:BC1��;9kDò_�
_flZÑcAfm���L�OÃflm+ffR?Ì/�ehfn+27
צID�צIDke(ÙÉÃ_8+A~e}l
Afm��9kD+.m��o(ÄQ_�e_kg_O~� Afm��cOö«mI+ú¢OölPkj�De«m+ `f_�¢c o}lfanÄ+ÒÅÃ|�+�Afm ��eß1p����^cèlfI+#z¢Ãalf=+
����n�AfmRSopÔ�o��m`�c«_òD�R?Ì/
�ekO$cf�nnc�NpqÆsÆÉp�/ä[Õ[�
¦knÓ@ªã�f3cfn+��@cðeå{0SÌDòan+ ©Ge$rs�Ù?ÔSÃXc�_fl$#�îðÃ�#ãcîèkn+��
�ðeZÑcm{xcy¦_�2×ûc��Ö�jkn+ ,
26 Geoffrey Lewis, 789,, p.32 27 SAMİ N.ÖZERDİM��YAZI DEVRİMİNİ KAVRAYAMAYANLAR��789� pp.528�589�
18
NpqÆsNrÉÆ�q+�cöl�}l�eAfm���궧o¦
k�NpqÆsNNÉN��$|¼wÏÑNÌ+Ì�·Dfl�Afm����
�Ö¤D£¤�o¨kn+ke��@c�jk�Afm��eÄc³ö¨k
k�£¤c=jkDOIDfn+.m��45jknî�9�£¤e$Ák�
_�s�צ_ce.m�����äe««an+N�ö�Hj« Ûo�b7�
RB²R��e½m9k¡¢�9Ã
19
¹3cDkDe$yø±+��eNê«RB²R9º�O½»f�óÙ
B\î|�Dfl�RB²R��O¤mn¼«�V½¹O½`�+·mEto¤¾O
¿_À_�#�DO�&e
20
9kn2G�p�\�klo�jk�NprLsceü¬�&�î�üýyÐ
ÏoÒZ�$DflBC1��Mm·O#�^Q�ffn+Npqrsc«D�p
�\9��xc«HoBC1��9k^c«an+,
NpØ+scSB1ÙTfnp�\¼ªÓ@|�Z[�Ì�i1$rse��
�¯7�ncBC1���£¤OÁfÚDOÌ"fn+flÌîÍ�ÓÔ
eÁanBC1��Mm·e�|o¡¢c¨nÌ/[��ÕÔ��1~[:|�
��;DÖgk¶9·c«an+p�\e��h°�Oã�¿fm��O¥l�B
C1���×¢¨_Ofn+, ,
,
{[,R�
��
,
, NØEBØI�óÙB\îDD`cRB²R��oç¦D�{[,R�eRB
²R��cÓÔOþè�R�n���O9MÄ�c£^c«an+_�@�NL
EBc«D��Ý�óTÙ�B1Ùo�Ú�Úc{[,RcÃallü
¬cffn+_flÒ[ÓÔÕ�eBC1��O£almnn�{[,R�
`ZÑcBC1��O£^c«an�±+NprØsce�¯�¶9·�±²O
³ön{[��¶9·o9kfn+, ,
,
R�0ó-01�
�� ÆEBØIRBÞ�
21
, N+Øps�SB1,Ù��¦²ßo��cÃall�GlTÙ�îOçèn+
_�@`ÌîÍe�Ú�ÚD�f�¬e���OÝ3fn_Âîfn_ÄncR
�no£almBC1�����O9^c«an+!áàäU�3�'«�
�IcBC1��9kn93`�alm+ , ��eNLÌ+sá|(Of�b|D�ñòO!QÄ^c«an�_�¢
eÒ[ÓÔÕn�D�âãO�ölmn|B1ÙÒ[ÓÔÕ��VÃ#�O§
_¨klmn+ä#:B1ÙçèkÒ[ÓÔÕ�#�;�#ãn�ce�
BC1�����O9MÄ^cÄkgmmD*èd¦kn+_fl���
OBC1��9DĶo}_fn+�¶eÎ�útc«aljcµ
�c«_�NprtsceH#ªBC1��OîèDo�Ijkn+_�@NpÌ
tsce��&oBC1�����_ùO�l�Mfn+Ñ�ZEF$Ò@�NpØL
sce�RCTU�î�£Mo�+��cflBC1��Oîè^cÄÄn+
kO³öl���&e�NpØts#ªBC1�������~9Oîè
DO�n+ , fl���e#ªBC1��oîèk^c«_�BC1��e¿f©�
oalmano�Ç���o«�U?ÝDm�m23Oìan��ofa_D
I1flm��eBC1��öO£al���O9MÄDce««an+ , ���µek�åD¿fÑ«+m¦#½"�|�«æ½��|�D"è
+7xc¤¾�`�O�f«o�Afm`�`§_¨klm+d����çè�
é�êKceÇ�ë��9klm`�`±kgBC1��9k`�`
±+¯n$ÃF¦ó1�nce°«��Oë£�_v«ìí�����
J`íîm+ |�
36 , |��Ç��ü�onanºe���ü�D«L�o±+n2×ûc
|eBC1��O³ö¨k©c£¤fln��:Ç�;Oü)ÄDcfn+
`Iv�Ücn_1e��Dh°c�½���noxÅOï_À
fn+���yzOðèã`mkg�An���O�ïÄã`mn+`IvÄ
ã`+_fl��ûñ�ek±²flmn+k°«ò[|Ç�
�ü�O¯«o�������ü�D¼óflm+ , Ç�eôõqrrrs©cik�N+rrs©cmqDfl�ÂöOBè�ôõqr
qs÷øqqrs�mnÇùúc=ml��Dfl�°oIan+Ç�Dm
êe�ùú�«lmDm¦k+Ç�e|ik�|Ryo`���
±+ff_ceíîD��«o_e«m+�[e��DÑ«alm+ 36 $S¶�!Ç�D|'�ûüA9�2003�pp.192~227+
22
, Ç�e|�V�ý[Dfl þ«¬�OÃ��ön+ff���O�an�ú�
��:NpNqs;O$7c�èn©�_�t'`�¨cjjk^c«an+
b|��VcDk�Etâ�F9OR�fnnc^al�Ç��ü�xoðèk
^c«an�±+ , , |�Et�#�5ç�|¼mæ�ü´OÅiDfn9��:NÆÆN�NpÌL;
eZ�^cJ×lm+ ,
Ç�o�Í«ökg�|e÷©�Í+�àèm����Oan½¹� =8��2$½¾�e�Äc��s`��Dfl�¿f�|` v«¦{D«al�Â�|eÄcÓ�jè9almDmútc� e��m�n�O�v_�æ�èOfn_flm+`fo ilm�`_«g�Ðe�Ç�c���D«al�be«m D�+ |EtV���O._�Dfn��l�2[Q�ã±an���:NÆp
Ì�NptL;`NpØrsc�A¼ªªx�O�Mfl����e«©�I��
�`Dcü�jk«ökg««m�Dmn+¬e_�@`�"O��ö�Ç�O�
ûcÉ%ÄùcÍnc�Ó[{�c£¤OU�DÄMÇV�t¶OÁÚf
^Dfn+Np+Nsce��Ç��MÇVce½�deo÷øo�MÇVcj
alÇ�O� Vfld�cn�DD`c�j8«deO!"ûcÚ«ö
kg««m�DQgfn+ , Ç��MÇVD� Vc�mle�½�c^alj8«§ïogjk�_k
O#èlþ��$¼Ó@|e�Ç�c�mle_��ÂO� Vfn Â��
:�Â�;o�nÇ�ct¦MÇ��DfleÓ[{�:%Ç;o¤mklm+, , , e|�Ç�odcn_1�º¥O¯lm+ |�OÓ[{�Mmfn�e�Ît:NÌLÆ�NLØØ;�&ØIc�|c'
fnb|ÌîÍeÂî�÷ø|ÃÇ�OÝ3fnDcò+Ò[ÓÔÕ
D|�R�c^al?jkn9e�Ó[{�|��ÇO9mÄDO§nÑ
(�)9±o�¦©q+���D[�R�Û1�OgÄ+��*qc^al|�
OMmÄù·e|c$«+,O±nè�_�@�Ç�MÇV�t¶ÃÇ�ü��
�ice_�k«m±²O`nfn+ |Gl�MÇ��e�Ó[{��yÂD`"×-�-�Të��Æ:MÇ
��;±an+���e�.ÇA��Dê�ök�|�.3�`De�#�¿¶
c±_�_�nce��OÃjfflî�O®ëf«ökg««mD*è�ïj
23
kn�±+ _�@�Ç���O�L§_¨knÇ�/ߢ��|.Ç�Æ�o�Mjk�0¸
��&c1ñOno�£¤Äce¿fmD�}o2�kn+�&�Ç�MÇV
e���&ce³ö¨kk«an+ �&¼|�Gzcöl�ùQDm3o|��:Ç�;�MÇA��t¶c
nmâv34fn+¬e��oÇ�D5êO±¦�¤mDc^al��¯O[�
î�O®ëj�lmDO$cf�5êc«alÇ���LODan�h�Æ�:M
Ç��;O�_�~9�«m6fmÍDÃ7ð�î��íN�8cl^
Dfn+Nprrs�¬e9|f�_�s�:c5ꢷï�!hµé�Æ'O�M
fn+ùQen�"�e÷©r�jk×DªHf�0¸ÇO;dDfl�ÆOI
n+ Ç)#ã�e��o~+����Ve¦o|n`��¦oÇ�O ¤mlmo�Ç��Âc-�Ç�5êo±al�ÇOgfÇ�OÈölm n�?@v�[A«#�eÇ�O¤mo�BC�`�en5êöO�è lml`¤o�+DIo¦o|eÇ�ökOÈö`�o«m+ _�n7«e��O~Do�|¼î�e®ëfonm+Es¦o|`î �cEÄn�¢c��èÃÄm��O9ãonjvd¦kno�` ùQ�%Çh9Fã9anh�Æe��^lml�-�Æ��) àéOGµ¦�D��H�Ço�¸Í��Çe}lIJjk+`f �¾��O�èl�_���_ùO�kgÇ��~«mã`î|®Oí© Do�A~O~x|O9D`��kÃk+nDèKÃvw `>�^m㫾�¦f�mL«ã`�(
24
6úek:{Ç�Æ;`alÇ�ctèDoD*èno [�mno�°�7Ãe_an+«Å«_keÜY�Ç�O��c fn`�cÄÚ©�����5ê�Dh°�m��Ç��¢cejD� ±meÇ��\c{mÄ�«^mo�kO$�cmnD«kg� Dl`É�o_«m+9DØnØnÄf�¯Do�+ 6ú�ÏÐo_kO�{Ç�Æ�DÖv�e�_�É��]^O^�al mn�:�b�_�`abÔcc^;+
�{Ç�Æ�e�&�Ç�ü�t¶�f_D«ano�_�@���de`±a
l�-s@�NpNÆsNNÉc«al^áÂjkn+_�@`ü)Oj«o�
NpÌrsce_�êO�{Ç*q�Dük�Np+Æscd¦klm�Ç�
%Ç·ï�:|�Ó[{�`_ùï;o!Ijkî�í$«Onfno�
deÂDv¤mk««alm+ NpNÆs�{Ç�Æ�o¡Âjkn©��#�'o}_����Ç�eîh�
:f��;ce«mDfl�gÚû«Ç�ü�xoklÃA~cd¦keÁn+2
`:fmxwOJ×n�e�_�©!Ahs'�k�c±nalmnijh:NÆÆt�
NpÌp;±an+¬e�|�þ@����i�:NpNÆ;Dmx��Ç�e�q
rEB�Aútcean꤫m`��±��Ç�Ç�emajm£¦©�
ma_ßÙ]B1�:¦C1ZS�4ïc^|��+_��Æe��k;cü^�
DªHfn+ kcfl�0¸$#�����#�'�è>calmnlTm:NÆÆr�N
pØq;e�©Ç�OÉf�fgÇ�e�flkOÓ[{�9^cf^�
Dèn+�^cÇ�ü���ie�Npqrstc¨Ã�¹n�éµmOma_
olman�±+ |��BC1V:Ó[{�V;t¶e�_�I|Ó¹pÛ²ß� Üc©q
jklmnrsî:NÆpp�NpÌ+;o�BC1�Æc^Û ����tt¶cu
:O³ö�|�OÓ[{�MmÄù·OWXf�vB-Ù�Ô�OCc|
25
�Æ�`·Of�_k�5O9D+xòce�����^ c�ê{�£�Ç�ö¿f�fl�È{�À|{�@cew{�¶{ }LBC1`_9^cÄ+_Äkg�¯ncmmg_«� }�`ecwÆc«I+~9cü�e�6]«D± :�Ç�DBC1V�`abÔcc^;+,
NpØpsNrÉN��$¼Ó@|�o���c^alÌ"jkn+Ó@|o
fnNrÉNr�ce�eÃ`0¸c|��ü�RÏoik�Ï�D"�#ã
Ã�#ãOÄD�kê�¬noæjkn+Np+qsce���e���e÷©ü�
f�EFÓí���±MÇV�ù⦫ökg««m�DQgfn+ Np+qs�î�Lc|��ü�yÐÏo�fno�yÐÏoTsc�%Ç·ï�
yÐÏOnö�=`cÓ[{�ù¢c^ºï�WXD9c±nan+Z�sck
n��ü�WXyÐÏe�m��ïOh{fnÜ�yÐÏoÁÄÓ[{�ù¢�º
ïOÖ¤ÄDc��kc]¶Oþèn�Ç�%Ç·ïàï�oNp+LsqÉc
�Mjkn+�àïejc·�]¶oþèk�Np+Æsce�Ç�%Çùï�
Dfl¡Âjkn+kod�Ç��ÇOMmÄÈû«��:Ó[{�;Dfl�
#ªî�Ã}|Óí�:®í�;�®ë«�½���¤mklm`�±+ ��"�����Qg�7îc±an`��_ke������¯��j±
an+_�D«almÇ�O«fnÂo^mD*èn�±ano�$�
�eÇ��BC1V^_`�DfIÇ�_�`����Oyc�öDO3Gv
D�� VfnÇ�c^��î�c_èk�j8«�Oâl��Â��
o¤mk^c«_�þ�cZalm+2Geòjkn�%Ç�:Ó[{�;e�®
íh�:}|Óí�;��ÇOgÄ*qDfl¤mkDcD_�þ�DIÇ�
cDalt¦°veanoè«m+ _kI�Ese���e� ±kg#ÍÃÄmDmªHc�OgĶ
`±+_ke�Ç��Ó[{�VÃ��Â���®ëOªHÄÇ�ü��«_#c
f�Ç�_�`�o`�mjO¯´_Dm`�±+,
,
BC1��O�¨f«an|Dfl�yE«|±|D��O§_78ln+
����|e��DhÁ^c�BC1���,1ôjO�al�R�no�m
¢£¤fln��e�6cR�n�"�cDj¦fmDm�oÍ7o^
c«an+��eÎ��G�_fl|e�&}anÇ�ü�t¶e�
�����ü��¶^_¿fÜkl�WVfn+¡sb7O�nm�Üûc��
`|`Ç�OÃìf���Ó[{�OMÇ��DflÇ�O#�¦§Èûc£¤f
lm+«Å«gÇ�e±_c`(o$m+Dc|e�Ç�enhf"
Gcd©mqe«�TRc(Än3�S`±D*èk+^alÇ�
26
e°«`��4Djk�man���£mùe��o�Ç�ø!c��jkn`�
D«almÂ��Îce¯6n«m+Ç�eTë«Oìalmö«Ï
û«o±+�½¹e��c`�falm+"G�MmeÇD
o¹]DfnD«al`���e���TR�RSopÔ�cr�ÄDe
«an+|`Ç�O� VÄDcDan+�^«n°o±�|
�Ç�OBC1Vf^D§n�(e¼Dmè+Dc¾�í�"
fn`_��+¬�J×n"Ge���µD«`�o±an+�5c=
ml¬�µ¶O�J×n�`BC1��
27
|e��D^n³c=klmn+�Í��VcÎk�BC1���,1ô
jckO�^c«an+��DeM®e«MÇ�nc±×+|���¯
o�m�e��oº»e«mDxÅo}_�NpEB@�b� `���o
³f«o��ïOï_Àfn+�éD�&�ñ��º��Vj�Do
©c �s¢o¤Ú����ü)D���y9D$Ë�����ic�c�1
O�ön�e�3mr!�Oì�|¼�CO
28
?�@A:\]�?;!BC1��DEF�"G', HI9J�qrr+s , BİLAL N ŞİMŞİR�Türk Yazı Devrimi�Turk Tarih Kurumu�Nppq� tem ÜNGÖR�TÜRK MARŞLARI� ANKARA�NpLL� Geoffrey Lewis �The Turkish Language Reform A Catastrophic Success� OXFORD University Press�Nppp� Hüseyin Yorulmaz�TAZİMATTAN CUMHURİYETE ALFABE TARTIŞMALARI� KİTABEVİ�İSTANBUL�Npp+� SAMİ N.ÖZERDİM��YAZI DEVRİMİNİ KAVRAYAMAYANLAR��TÜRK DİRİ � Yıl28�Cilt ��������Sayı 326�1 Kasım NptÆ� R-R�RSTU"��VWXYZ[\][- http://www.aa.tufs.ac.jp/,
LMN� Ù{1ú
, ���I :Õ1SÔ�-M;
29
LMq�