18
EARLY PREGNANCY DETECTION IN DAIRY CATTLE BY BIOPRYN ELISA TEST F. Toth, G. Gabor, Fan Huang and R.G. Sasser

EARLY PREGNANCY DETECTION IN DAIRY CATTLE BY BIOPRYN ™ ELISA TEST F. Toth, G. Gabor, Fan Huang and R.G. Sasser

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • EARLY PREGNANCY DETECTION IN DAIRY CATTLE BY BIOPRYN ELISA TEST F. Toth, G. Gabor, Fan Huang and R.G. Sasser

  • INTRODUCTIONPSPB is a novel protein that was first reported by scientists at the University of Idaho. PSPB is located in the giant binucleate cells of the trophoblastic ectoderm of the placenta and this indicated that it was either synthesized or sequestered by those cells. (Figure 1)Migration of these cells result the appearance of PSPB in the maternal circulation (Figure 2).PSPB is detectable in serum from 24 to 282 (parturition) days of gestation and can be applied reliably in dairy cow herds at 28 to 30 days after breading (Figure 3).The PSPB was found in sera of some primiparous cows as early as 15 days following conception and in sera of most cows at 24 days following conception.

  • The Giant Bi-Nucleated CellsCotyledonCaruncleFigure 1:

  • Migration of the Giant Bi-Nucleated CellsBi-Nucleated CellsPlacentaUterusPSPB inCirculationFigure 2:

  • PSPB ng/mLParturitionDays post breedingVariation of PSPB concentration in the serum Figure 3:

  • Complete clearence of the protein from blood may not occur until 80 to 100 days after parturition. For this reason testing of blood for a new pregnancy following parturition may give false positive tests.An ELISA test (BioPryn by BioTracking LLC)has been developed for the examination of the PSPB in cattle 30 days after AI (at least 90 days after the previous parturition) (Figure 4 and 5). Decreasing the parturition interval is one of the most important issues in dairies. Pregnancy specific protein B (PSPB) is measured for detection of pregnancy in ruminants.

  • Figure 4: Biopryn ELISA test color reaction

  • Figure 5: Biopryn ELISA test stop color reaction

  • OBJECTIVESThe objectives were:to verify the BioPRYN test is adapted method for pregnancy detection in cattle. to determine the sensitivity of the BioPRYN test and compare with the sensitivity of the ultrasonic examination.to define the practicability of PSPB test in Hungarian field. to exam the reliability of PSPB test in monitored circumstances.

  • METHODSExperiment 1 No. of cows No. of farms 69 1

    The cows were examined by rectal ultrasonography between 29 and 55 days after AI. Blood samples were taken at the same time and were assayed for PSPB with BioPRYN when all the samples has been collected.

  • Experiment 2No. of cows No. of farms 1742 23

    AIs were carried out in 23 dairies and blood was drawn from 30 to 36 days after AI and assayed for early pregnancy by BioPRYN. To confirm the pregnancy diagnosis, rectal palpation was done on the farms at 45-90 days after AI.

  • Experiment 3No. of cows No. of farms 336 1

    In Experiment 3, blood samples were assayed with BioPRYN for early pregnancy detection (30-36 days after AI) in 306 Holstein-Friesian and 30 Hungarian Fleckvieh cows. Confirmation was done by rectal ultrasonography one day after the blood collection.

  • RESULTS

    Distribution of Optical Density (OD) O Dcutoff

    Chart1

    0.548

    0.501

    0.486

    0.479

    0.458

    0.457

    0.448

    0.427

    0.422

    0.416

    0.41

    0.405

    0.402

    0.4

    0.392

    0.39

    0.382

    0.373

    0.369

    0.362

    0.358

    0.357

    0.347

    0.341

    0.336

    0.334

    0.321

    0.309

    0.303

    0.302

    0.295

    0.288

    0.276

    0.265

    0.262

    0.258

    0.235

    0.227

    0.2190282376

    0.194

    0.19

    0.144

    0.12

    0.114

    0.114

    0.108

    0.106

    0.102

    0.102

    0.1

    0.1

    0.099

    0.099

    0.096

    0.093

    0.091

    0.089

    0.087

    0.087

    0.086

    0.086

    0.085

    0.084

    0.084

    0.083

    0.082

    0.082

    0.082

    0.081

    0.08

    0.078

    0.077

    0.077

    0.072

    Sheet1

    Sheet1

    0.548

    0.501

    0.486

    0.479

    0.458

    0.457

    0.448

    0.427

    0.422

    0.416

    0.41

    0.405

    0.402

    0.4

    0.392

    0.39

    0.382

    0.373

    0.369

    0.362

    0.358

    0.357

    0.347

    0.341

    0.336

    0.334

    0.321

    0.309

    0.303

    0.302

    0.295

    0.288

    0.276

    0.265

    0.262

    0.258

    0.235

    0.227

    0.2190282376

    0.194

    0.19

    0.144

    0.12

    0.114

    0.114

    0.108

    0.106

    0.102

    0.102

    0.1

    0.1

    0.099

    0.099

    0.096

    0.093

    0.091

    0.089

    0.087

    0.087

    0.086

    0.086

    0.085

    0.084

    0.084

    0.083

    0.082

    0.082

    0.082

    0.081

    0.08

    0.078

    0.077

    0.077

    0.072

    Sheet2

    Sheet3

  • Experiment 1

    Munka1

    1. Tbl.: Az ELISA teszt s az ultrahangos vemhessgvizsglat

    eredmnyeinek sszevetse

    Az ELISA teszt elzetesen meghatrozott hatrrtke: 0,325

    vizsglati naptermkenytsvemhessgi id (nap)UH diagnzisELISA teszt eredmnyeELISA diagnzis

    5/15/014/14/0131vemhes1.024vemhes

    5/15/014/9/0136res0.225res

    5/15/014/10/0135res0.224res

    5/15/014/9/0136vemhes0.783vemhes

    5/15/014/12/0133res0.242res

    5/15/014/11/0134vemhes0.965vemhes

    5/15/014/13/0132vemhes0.945vemhes

    5/15/014/10/0135res0.227res

    5/15/014/14/0131res0.261res

    5/15/014/16/0129vemhes0.908vemhes

    5/15/014/7/0138res0.199res

    5/15/014/6/0139vemhes0.727vemhes

    5/15/014/15/0130vemhes0.661vemhes

    5/15/013/21/0155res0.192res

    5/15/014/11/0134vemhes0.862vemhes

    5/23/014/11/0142vemhes1.109vemhes

    5/23/014/21/0132res0.179res

    5/23/014/22/0131res0.234res

    5/23/014/21/0132res0.204res

    5/23/014/15/0138vemhes0.704vemhes

    5/23/014/14/0139res0.189res

    5/23/014/20/0133vemhes0.834vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133res0.278res

    6/6/015/1/0136vemhes0.992vemhes

    6/6/015/2/0135res0.198res

    6/6/014/19/0148vemhes1.023vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133res0.183res

    6/6/015/3/0134vemhes0.717vemhes

    6/6/015/3/0134vemhes0.709vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133vemhes0.901vemhes

    6/6/015/3/0134res0.23res

    6/6/015/1/0136res0.193res

    6/6/014/13/0154vemhes0.924vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133vemhes0.66vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133vemhes0.888vemhes

    6/6/015/4/0133res0.19res

    6/6/015/4/0133vemhes0.626vemhes

    6/6/015/3/0134res0.168res

    6/6/014/15/0152res0.177res

    6/6/015/1/0136res0.192res

    6/6/015/2/0135vemhes1.154vemhes

    6/6/015/3/0134vemhes0.81vemhes

    6/12/015/2/0141res0.262res

    6/12/015/6/0137vemhes1.169vemhes

    6/12/015/1/0142res0.177res

    6/12/015/10/0133res0.176res

    6/12/015/3/0140res0.164res

    6/12/015/3/0140res0.171res

    6/12/015/5/0138vemhes0.872vemhes

    6/12/015/9/0134res0.21res

    6/12/015/3/0140vemhes0.894vemhes

    6/12/015/10/0133res0.286res

    6/12/015/3/0140res0.219res

    6/12/015/2/0141vemhes0.706vemhes

    6/12/015/3/0140res0.207res

    6/12/015/10/0133vemhes1.04vemhes

    6/12/015/10/0133res0.178res

    6/12/015/6/0137res0.206res

    6/12/015/5/0138res0.198res

    6/12/015/9/0134vemhes1.247vemhes

    6/12/015/10/0133vemhes1.004vemhes

    6/12/015/9/0134res0.254res

    6/12/015/9/0134vemhes1.405vemhes

    6/12/015/8/0135res0.175res

    6/12/015/3/0140vemhes1.124vemhes

    6/12/015/7/0136res0.197res

    6/12/015/6/0137res0.211res

    6/12/015/10/0133res0.308res

    6/12/015/6/0137vemhes0.955vemhes

    Munka2

    vemhessgi id (nap)ultrahang diagnzisELISA teszt eredmnyeELISA diagnzis

    31res0.261res31res0.261

    31res0.234res31res0.234

    32res0.179res32res0.179

    32res0.204res32res0.204

    33res0.242res33res0.242

    33res0.278res33res0.278

    33res0.183res33res0.183

    33res0.19res33res0.19

    33res0.176res33res0.176

    33res0.286res33res0.286

    33res0.178res33res0.178

    33res0.308res33res0.308

    34res0.23res34res0.23

    34res0.168res34res0.168

    34res0.21res34res0.21

    34res0.254res34res0.254

    35res0.224res35res0.224

    35res0.227res35res0.227

    35res0.198res35res0.198

    35res0.175res35res0.175

    36res0.225res0.22025

    36res0.193res0.168

    36res0.192res0.308

    36res0.197res

    37res0.206res36res0.225res

    37res0.211res36res0.193res

    38res0.199res36res0.192res

    38res0.198res36res0.197res

    39res0.189res37res0.206res

    40res0.164res37res0.211res

    40res0.171res38res0.199res

    40res0.219res38res0.198res

    40res0.207res39res0.189res

    41res0.262res40res0.164res

    42res0.177res40res0.171res

    52res0.177res40res0.219res

    55res0.192res40res0.207res

    29vemhes0.908vemhes41res0.262res

    30vemhes0.661vemhes42res0.177res

    31vemhes1.024vemhes52res0.177res

    32vemhes0.945vemhes55res0.192res

    33vemhes0.834vemhes0.1987647059

    33vemhes0.901vemhes0.164

    33vemhes0.66vemhes0.262

    33vemhes0.888vemhes

    33vemhes0.626vemhes29vemhes0.908

    33vemhes1.04vemhes30vemhes0.661

    33vemhes1.004vemhes31vemhes1.024

    34vemhes0.965vemhes32vemhes0.945

    34vemhes0.862vemhes33vemhes0.834

    34vemhes0.717vemhes33vemhes0.901

    34vemhes0.709vemhes33vemhes0.66

    34vemhes0.81vemhes33vemhes0.888

    34vemhes1.247vemhes33vemhes0.626

    34vemhes1.405vemhes33vemhes1.04

    35vemhes1.154vemhes33vemhes1.004

    36vemhes0.783vemhes34vemhes0.965

    36vemhes0.992vemhes34vemhes0.862

    37vemhes1.169vemhes34vemhes0.717

    37vemhes0.955vemhes34vemhes0.709

    38vemhes0.704vemhes34vemhes0.81

    38vemhes0.872vemhes34vemhes1.247

    39vemhes0.727vemhes34vemhes1.405

    40vemhes0.894vemhes35vemhes1.154

    40vemhes1.124vemhes0.9136842105

    41vemhes0.706vemhes0.626

    42vemhes1.109vemhes1.405

    48vemhes1.023vemhes

    54vemhes0.924vemhes36vemhes0.783

    36vemhes0.992

    37vemhes1.169

    37vemhes0.955

    38vemhes0.704

    38vemhes0.872

    39vemhes0.727

    31res0.26140vemhes0.894

    31res0.23440vemhes1.124

    32res0.17941vemhes0.706

    32res0.20442vemhes1.109

    33res0.24248vemhes1.023

    33res0.27854vemhes0.924

    33res0.1830.9216923077

    33res0.190.704

    33res0.1761.169

    33res0.286

    33res0.178

    33res0.30829vemhes0.908vemhes

    34res0.2330vemhes0.661vemhes

    34res0.16831vemhes1.024vemhes

    34res0.2132vemhes0.945vemhes

    34res0.25433vemhes0.834vemhes

    35res0.22433vemhes0.901vemhes

    35res0.22733vemhes0.66vemhes

    35res0.19833vemhes0.888vemhes

    35res0.17533vemhes0.626vemhes

    36res0.22533vemhes1.04vemhes

    36res0.19333vemhes1.004vemhes

    36res0.19234vemhes0.965vemhes

    36res0.19734vemhes0.862vemhes

    37res0.20634vemhes0.717vemhes

    37res0.21134vemhes0.709vemhes

    38res0.19934vemhes0.81vemhes

    38res0.19834vemhes1.247vemhes

    39res0.18934vemhes1.405vemhes

    40res0.16435vemhes1.154vemhes

    40res0.17136vemhes0.783vemhes

    40res0.21936vemhes0.992vemhes

    40res0.20737vemhes1.169vemhes

    41res0.26237vemhes0.955vemhes

    42res0.17738vemhes0.704vemhes

    52res0.17738vemhes0.872vemhes

    55res0.19239vemhes0.727vemhes

    0.2140vemhes0.894vemhes

    0.1640vemhes1.124vemhes

    0.3141vemhes0.706vemhes

    42vemhes1.109vemhes

    48vemhes1.023vemhes

    54vemhes0.924vemhes

    0.92

    0.63

    1.41

    Munka3

    OD values

    MeanMinimumMaximum

    Days After AIopenpregnantopenpregnantopenpregnant

    29 - 350.220.910.170.6260.311.41

    n= 20n= 19

    36 - 550.200.920.160.7040.261.17

    n= 17n= 13

    Total0.210.920.160.630.311.41

    n= 37n= 32

    Cutoff:0.325

  • Experiment 2Correct diagnosis: result of PSPB test corresponds with the result of ultrasonic examination. False diagnosis: result of PSPB test differs from the result of ultrasonic examination. Sensitivity: 100*correct positive diagnosis/correct positive diagnosis+false negative diagnosis. Specificity: 100*correct negative diagnosis/correct negative diagnosis+false positive diagnosis. Positive predicted value: 100*correct positive diagnosis/correct positive diagnosis+false positive diagnosis. Negative predicted value: 100*correct negative diagnosis/correct negative diagnosis+false negative diagnosis.

    Sheet1

    Number of AI1742

    Correct positive diagnosis772

    Correct negative diagnosis638

    False positive diagnosis292

    False negative diagnosis40

    Sensitivity95.1

    Specificity68.6

    Positive predicted value72.6

    Negative predicted value94.1

    Sheet2

    Sheet3

  • Experiment 3

    Sheet1

    Number of AI1742

    Correct positive diagnosis772

    Correct negative diagnosis638

    Fals positive diagnosis292

    Fals negative diagnosis40

    Sensitivity95.1

    Specificity68.6

    Positive predicted value72.6

    Negative predicted value94.1

    Number of AI336

    Correct positive diagnosis152

    Correct negative diagnosis164

    Fals positive diagnosis20

    Fals negative diagnosis0

    Sensitivity100

    Specificity89.1

    Positive predicted value88.4

    Negative predicted value100

    Sheet2

    Sheet3

    MBD00152438.xls

    Sheet1

    termkenyts szma1742

    korrekt pozitv772

    korrekt negatv638

    fals pozitv292

    fals negatv40

    rzkenysg95.07

    negatv elrejelzs94.1

    Termkenyts336

    Korrekt pozitv316

    Korrekt negatv164

    Fals pozitv20

    Fals negatv0

    rzkenysg100

    Pozitv elrejelzs94

    Negatv elrejelzs100

    Sheet2

    EmbryonicEmbryonicTotalTotalEmbryonic loss

    Pregnantlosslossno. of losslossbetweenMilk kg /Correlation

    FarmsNo. of cowsbetweenbetweenbetween%25-36 days36-60 dayscow/year

    25-36 days36-60 days25-60 days%

    I.1908212915.34.211.18000milk / total loss0.73

    II.2515444919.5217.59500milk / loss (25-36 days)-0.36

    III.175215179.71.18.67500milk/ implantation0.91

    IV.1617172414.94.310.67000

    Total777229711914.82.911.98000

  • DISCUSSIONIn addition, the more accurate ultrasound (and done more timely) rather than rectal palpation was used to confirm pregnancy. The rate of false positive tests was 5.9% and positive and negative prediction values were high (94.0 % and 100 %). The two highly controlled experiments (1 and 3) show that BioPRYN was an excellent test for pregnancy detection.

  • CONCLUSION

    In conclusion, the BioPRYN test for PSPB is a practical and safe system for pregnancy detection in cattle.