127
ªµ¦µ¦Á«¦¬«µ¦r«¦¸¦·¦ª·Ã¦ "#$%&'(&#$%)$#*+ ,-*%*.$-" /*0#%&1 2334 É 5 ´¸É 5 Áº°¤¦µ¤ 6 ¤·»µ¥ 2552 789:5 %8:5 /;<=;>? 6 /=<@ 2334 $""% A435B3CDA ªµ¤µµª·´¥ x µ¦¨´Á¡ºÉ°µ¦«¹¬µ " °´¦µ¨°Âµ¦¨»¦³´°»¤«¹¬µÂ¨³ª·¡µ¬r°»Ä®o¼o¥º¤ Á¡ºÉ°µ¦«¹¬µ #$%&'()*+', -)+'+&. " /.(%0+ (* 1)23.0 #$%&'()*+ '+$ #$%&'()*+', 4*'+ 50*20'67 x -)7&', 8+$ 9*+.('0: 5*,)&: 9);.7 4)+<'2. (* =3'),'+$>7 820)&%,(%0. x 820)&%,(%0', =0'$.?@*A.0(: 4)+<'2. " 8+ #6@)0)&', B+A.7()2'()*+ x µ¦ª·Á¦µ³®r¨°£µª³Á·Á¢j°¸É¤¸n°£µª³£µ¬¸Á·Åo»¨¦¦¤µ 8+ 8+',:7)7 *+ (3. #CC.&( *C B+C,'()*+ *+ 5.07*+', B+&*6. ='; D%0$.+ x ¨¦³°µ¦´´Ê³¦¦¤µ¦·µ¦Ã¦¤µ¤Â®nµ·n°µ¦Ä®o¦·µ¦ æ«´¡rÁ¨ºÉ°¸ÉĦ³Á«Å¥ =3. B6@'&( *C (3. #7('E,)73)+2 *C (3. F=G *+ (3. 9*E),. =.,.@3*+. H.0A)&.7 )+ =3'),'+$ x ¦³··£µ¡µ¦Äo{´¥µ¦¨·Â¨³o»µ¦Îµ¢µ¦r¤»¦Ä´®ª´¦¤ #CC)&).+&: *C B+@%( I(),)J'()*+ '+$ G*7( " F'<3*+@'(3*6>7 5)2 -'067 ªµ¤µª·µµ¦ x ªÃo¤¨µÂ¦µÅ¥Änµ¦³Á« -*0.)2+ 4'E*%0 9'0<.( =0.+$

Economic Journal Issue 5

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Economic Journal Issue 5 Create by School of Economic, SWU

Citation preview

Page 1: Economic Journal Issue 5

! !

!

!

!

!

"#$%&'(&#$%)$#*+! ,-*%*.$-"! /*0#%&1! 2334

!5!! !5!! !6! !2552!!789:5!!%8:5!!/;<=;>?!6!/=<@!2334!!$""%!A435B3CDA!

!

!

!

!

!"! !

!!!

! #$%&'()*+',!-)+'+&.!"!/.(%0+!(*!1)23.0!#$%&'()*+!'+$!#$%&'()*+',!4*'+!50*20'67 -)7&',!8+$!9*+.('0:!5*,)&:!9);.7!4)+<'2.!(*!=3'),'+$>7!820)&%,(%0.! 820)&%,(%0',!=0'$.?@*A.0(:!4)+<'2.!"!8+!#6@)0)&',!B+A.7()2'()*+! !

8+!8+',:7)7!*+!(3.!#CC.&(!*C!B+C,'()*+!*+!5.07*+',!B+&*6.!=';!D%0$.+! !

!!

=3.!B6@'&(!*C!(3.!#7('E,)73)+2!*C!(3.!F=G!*+!(3.!9*E),.!=.,.@3*+.!H.0A)&.7!)+!=3'),'+$ !!

#CC)&).+&:!*C!B+@%(!I(),)J'()*+!'+$!G*7(!"!F'<3*+@'(3*6>7!5)2!-'067!!

!

!!

! -*0.)2+!4'E*%0!9'0<.(!=0.+$!!

!

! !

Page 2: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

"##$!%&'()'*+% !

!

! ! !

! !"! !

!

!

#$ !

"$ !

!

! ! !

! ##%! !"&! ! ! !#'##' ! $!'"(%)*#*(+,!!-./!0!'"(%)*#*(+,! !#'# !

!

! ! $ !! !

!

! ! $ $ $! !

! &"1))! !,!! !(*!!

! !! !! !!#'""'!

!

! !

! ! !!

! !

! !

Page 3: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!!

! !

! " ! #

!

! !!" "! ! ! "#$%&'()*&+!,(*&*%-!.!/-'$0*!')!1(23-0!"#$%&'()*!&*#!"#$%&'()*&+!4)&*!

! ! 50)20&67! 8!

! ! !! !

,(7%&+!&*#!9)*-'&0:!5)+(%:!9(;-7!4(*<&2-!')!=3&(+&*#>7!?20(%$+'$0-! @A!

! ! "#$%&%'!"%$()*+%',%-($*./0 ! ?20(%$+'$0&+!=0&#-BC)D-0':!4(*<&2-!.!?*!"6C(0(%&+!E*D-7'(2&'()*! FF ! ! 1.%$%-(*!2(/34,%$%/*! ! !

! ! ?*!?*&+:7(7!)*!'3-!"GG-%'!)G!E*G+&'()*!)*!5-07)*&+!E*%)6-!=&;!H$0#-*! 8F!

! ! !! !! !! !! !

! !

! ! ! =3-!E6C&%'!)G!'3-!"7'&I+(73(*2!)G!'3-!J=K!)*!'3-!9)I(+-!=-+-C3)*-!!

! ! L-0D(%-7!(*!=3&(+&*#! MF!

! ! !! !! !! !! !

! !

! ! "GG(%(-*%:!)G!E*C$'!N'(+(O&'()*!&*#!K)7'!.!J&<3)*C&'3)6>7!5(2!,&067! PP ! ! !! !! !! !! !

Page 4: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

$ %!!

! !

! !!

! ! ,)0-(2*!4&I)$0!9&0<-'!=0-*#! QQ@!

! ! !! ! ! ! !

! &"&

Page 5: Economic Journal Issue 5

!!

!

!

" ! # !! $!!

!

! # !! !!

!

! # !! !

! # ! !

!

! # ! !

!! !

! # !! !

!! !!

" ! !

!

!! !

!! !

!! !

!! !!

! !

!! !

!! !!

!

#!%&'()*+*',-!

./0!1!%&'()*+*',-! !+%+!

!

!!!

!"! !#$$#!!$! !

!%&!!

!

! ! !!

! ! ' ! !!

! !!

!

!!

!

!!

!!!!

Page 6: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!!

! ! !"! !! !#"$%!

! ! !!#&! ! ' '!#""(!

! !!

!!

!!

! ! ! ' !! !!

!

! ! ! !()!! ! !

! ! !!#)! !

!*)!! ! !$)! ! +! !!!!

!

! ! ! !! !

! !! ! ! +

! ! !, )! !"#$%&'#()#*+,! "-'#'(%-.! !/)+,*0! "-'#'('-%.! !-!

! !, )! !! ! !

Page 7: Economic Journal Issue 5

!1

!

!2 3! !

! !,&).)+&-0! +..%.*+#*.0%45!! !! !

! !! !2 3!!

!! ! !

! ! ! !! ! ! !

! !!2 ! ! 3! !

!! !

!

! ! !! !

! !

Page 8: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

"#$%&'()*&+!,(*&*%-!.!/-'$0*!')!1(23-0!"#$%&'()*!!

&*#!"#$%&'()*&+!4)&*!50)20&67!

!! !8

!

!

!! !

! !!

!

! !"#$%%! ! ! & &!'#%(! !

!)*+,-./0! 1021033.4,! $!

$ ! ! ! 5!

!"($"6! !

!! 5!

!"7! !

!8 5! !!

!

!.! ! ! !

!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

"

!! ! & !! ! ! !

!

! ! & ! ! !

&! ! ! &!

! &!

! ! &!

Page 9: Economic Journal Issue 5

!(

9:7'0&%'!

! 9:.3!+1-.;/0!-+<03!.=0+3!>14?!:*?+,!;[email protected]+/!-:041A!+3!;4,;0@-*+/!>1+?0B41<[email protected].;+//A!3-*=A!

-:0!10-*1,3! -4!:.2:01!0=*;+-.4,! .,!9:+./+,=C!+,=!;4??0,-3!4@01+-.4,+/!D4--/0,0;<3!4>! -:0!0=*;+-.4,+/!

/4+,!@1421+?3&!!9:0!>.13-!@+1-C!B:.;:!.3!D+30=!4,!/+D41!>41;0!3*1E0A!.,!'77#C!;4?@+103!B+20!.,;4?0!>41!

'!B+20$0+1,01!214*@3!B:430!+20!1+,20!>14?!"#$%%!A0+1F!+5! -:430!B:4!:+E0!@1.?+1A!0=*;+-.4,!+,=!

0,-01!-:0!/+D41!?+1<0-!+,=!D5!-:430!B:4!:+E0!+--+.,0=!*,.E013.-A!0=*;+-.4,&!!9:0!)*+,-./0!1021033.4,!

-0;:,.)*0!B+3!+@@/.0=!-4!D4-:!214*@3!+,=!-:0!03-.?+-0=!@+1+?0-013!+10!*30=!-4!>410;+3-!B+20!.,;4?0&!

G,!.,>010,;0!4>!-:0!10-*1,3!-4!0=*;+-.4,!.3!-+<0,!DA!;4?@+1.,2!D0,0>.-!+,=!;43-!4>!.,E03-?0,-!.,!:.2:01!

0=*;+-.4,H-:0!D0,0>.-!03-.?+-0!.3!D+30=!4,!B+20!0+1,.,2!=.>>010,;03C!+,=!-:0!;43-!03-.?+-03!;[email protected]!

4>!+,!4@@41-*,.-A!;43-!+,=!-:0!;43-3!4>!:.2:01!0=*;+-.4,&!!9:0!1+-0!4>!10-*1,!B+3!>4*,=!-4!1+,20!>14?!!

"($"6!@01;0,-!B:.;:!.3!>+.1/A!:.2:!+,=!-:030!103*/-3!;4,>.1?!-:+-!.-! .3!30,3.D/0!+,=!1+-.4,+/!-4!.,E03-!.,!

:.2:01!0=*;+-.4,&!!9:0!,0I-!30;-.4,!;4??0,-3!4@01+-.4,+/!D4--/0,0;<3!4>!-:0!0=*;+-.4,+/!/4+,!@1421+?!-:+-!

D02+,!3.,;0!"66J!B.-:!.?@430=!;4,=.-.4,3!-:+-!.,;/*=0!0/.2.D./.-A!;1.-01.4,C!.?@01>0;-!.,>41?+-.4,C!4@01+-.4,+/!/+2C!

+,=!!?+,+20?0,-!011413!+,=!3*2203-3!-:0!B+A3!-4!.?@14E0!-:0!4@01+-.4,3&!!9:0!/+3-!@+1-!;4?@+103!-B4!

/4+,!@1421+?3C!.&0&C!-:0!-1+=.-.4,+/!8+!?41-2+20$-A@0!/4+,5!+,=!-:0!,0B!4,0!8+,!.,;4?0$;4,-.,20,-!/4+,5&!!

9:0! +*-:41! 4D301E03! @4/.;A$.,;4,3.3-0,;A! 4>! -:0! 0=*;+-.4,+/! /4+,! @1421+?3! =*0! -4! ;:+,20! .,! @4/.-.;+/!

102.?03&!!!

!

;-<!=)0#7!.!:*?+,!;[email protected]+/!-:041AC!10-*1,3!-4!:.2:01!0=*;+-.4,C!0=*;+-.4,+/!/4+,C!B+20!0+1,.,2!=.>>010,;0!

!

!

8>! !

!

!!

!K !

L! ! K L!

!8 5!

!!

!

! !!

!

!!

!

!

!!

!

Page 10: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 6

! !

!

!!'

! !

!

!

!M

!

!

!!

! !8"#$'7! 5!

!!

! !

! ! !K

L!8?.33.,2!?+1<0-5!%

!

!

!

! K L! !#

!

!!

!8.,;4?0! ;4,-.,20,-! /4+,C! NOP5!

! !

!K L! 8?01.-! 244=35! !!

!

!

! !

! !

! !

!

! !

! !

!8;.E./!

34;.0-A5! ! !

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

'

!! ! !9&R&!S;:*/-T0!

8"6J"5C!U+1A!V0;<01!8"6(75C!W41+?!V0,$X41+-:!8"6JY5C!!S:01B.,!Z430,!8"6Y'5C![+;4D!\.,;01!8"6Y%5! !

M

!! ! ! !U&! X3+;:+14@4*/43! 8"66M5!!

!! !

!Z4D01-!V+114!8"66Y5! !! !

%

!! ! ! !

!

#

!! ! !]^1.0=?+,C! "6##C! "66#_! ! !K L!

!"6#7!

!8 5! ! ! !

! ! !

!.,;4?0! ;4,-.,20,-! /4+,! 8NOP5! ! & &!"6(6$ ! !

! ! !

! ! ! !

! !

Page 11: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"7

!834;.+/!

10-*1,3! -4! 0=*;+-.4,5! J

! !

!

!

!'! ! !

!8 5! ! & &!'#M(!

!Y

! !'#%6! & & &

! ! !

!8 ! &5!

! &! ! &!

!

! ! !

!"6!

!'#%6!! !

&! !'##7! ! &

! ! &!

! (

!

!'##7$ ! &! ! &!

! !6

!

! ! 5!

!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

J

! !`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

! !\;\+:4,! 8"6665! !

!"%$"#a!! !V0/>.0/=!8'777C@&"JY5!

Y

!! ! ! ! !'(! !'#M(! !

(

!! !'##7! ! ! &! ! &! $$ ! &!

!'##'!! ! &! ! &! !'##7!

!

! &! #Y6C7#7!! !!! ! "(C6"(&YJ!! !

! &! "%"C#6"! !!! ! JCYY#&6"!! !

! ! !'6! !'##"!! !

! !'(! !'##"!

6

!! !8 ! ! 5! !'#! !'##"!

!8 5! !'##"!! !8 !'##"5!

! &! ! &! !

Page 12: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ""

!

!8B+20!=.>>010,-.+/35

!

! ! 5!

!8 5!

!!

&! !

!

! !

!"7! ! 5!

! &!

!

!!

! !J! !

!

!

! !

!

! ! )*+,-./0!

1021033.4,! !

!

!8 &! ! &5!

!

!! ! !

?>! ! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!!

!"6%73!

!

!

!!!

!

b ! !!!

!

! !

!

!

!

!!!

!

! !

!

! !

! !"6J7!!

!8 5! !

$ $ !

!

!!

!

! !9:04=410!

Page 13: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"'

R&! S;:*/-TC! [+;4D! \.,;01C! U+1A! V0;<01! !

W41+?!V0,$X41+-:! !

!

!!

"7

!!

!

! ! !

!K L!

! !8 !

5!

""

! !!

! ! !

! !

! ! !

8V0,$X41+-:!"6JY5!!!

!K L! 8/.>0-.?0!

0+1,.,235"'

! !

H !

!

!c!

! !

! !!K

L! !8#$"7! 5! !

!

! !K

L! ! ! !

!!

!

! !

! ! !S:01B.,!

Z430,!8"6Y'5!!

b !

!!

! b

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

"7

! !d*?+,[email protected]+/!! ! ! !!@0-+).(,(*&5+&(1+)2+'0(/+/'$#7+9&/+')+-/'(1&'-+'0-+ 1)*-7+ .&'-+ )2+ .-'$.*+ ')+ %)55-,-+ &*#+ 0(,0A/%0))5+ -#$%&'()*+ (*+ '0-+ D*('-#+ E'&'-/;+ + F*+ ).#-.+ ')+ /-'+ '0-/-+-/'(1&'-/+ (*+ '0-+ 3.)3-.+ %)*'-:'?+ &+ 8.(-2+ 2).1$5&'()*+ )2+ '0-+ '0-).7+ )2+ (*4-/'1-*'+ (*+ 0$1&*+ %&3('&5+ 9&/+$*#-.'&=-*GC!8V0;<01!"6(7C!@&"#5!!

""

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

"'

!V0,$X41+-:!"6JY! !+!@14=*;-.4,!>*,;-.4,!4>!:*?+,!;[email protected]+/! !-:0!4@-.?+/!@+-:!4>!

+;;*?*/+-.4,! 4>! :*?+,! ;[email protected]+/! !!F+ /0&55+ /0)9+0)9+ '0-+3.)#$%'()*+ 2$*%'()*+ I'0.)$,0+/$3357+).+%)/'+%)*#('()*/J+-*'-./+(*')+'0-+#-'-.1(*&'()*+)2+'0-+)3'(1&5+3&'0+)2+(*4-/'1-*'?+&*&57B-+/)1-+)2+'0-+(135(%&'()*/+2).+'0-+(*#(4(#$&5K/+&55)%&'()*+)2+'(1-?+&*#+#-1)*/'.&'-+0)9+'0-+5(2-+%7%5-+)2+-&.*(*,/+%&*+8-+&22-%'-#+87+4&.()$/+3.)3-.'(-/+)2+'0-+3.)#$%'()*+2$*%'()*L!8@&M#'5!

Page 14: Economic Journal Issue 5

! "M

"M

!!!

! ! $

!83.2,+/.,25! !

!

! !

!8 5!

!83;100,.,25! !

!!

! ! !0>>.;.0,;A$B+20! ?4=0/!

! !

!K L!

!

K $ L!

!

!K L!

8 5!

!

!K L! !

!

K L!

!!

! !

!

834;.+/!10-*1,3!4>!:.2:01!

0=*;+-.4,5! !

!

!

!

! !!

! !

!

! !!!

!

!

!

!

!! !! !

! !

! !

! !

!

!8

5!

$$

! !

!!

! !

!

!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

"M

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

Page 15: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"%

!

!

!

!

! !!

!!!

! !

!

! !

!

!

!

!

! !!

!

! !

!

! !

b

! !

! ! ! !

!!

! !

!

!

!

!

!"!

!

!U+1A!V0;<01C!"6(7!M$1&*+N&3('&5C!@&'!

@>! !

!

!

! !

!!

!

!

!! !c!

!c! !c!

!!

!8P^S! e! /+D41!

>41;0! 3*1E0A! 5!

!

! !)*+,-./0!

1021033.4,! !

!8 5! !

:0-0143;0=+3-.;.-A! !

Page 16: Economic Journal Issue 5

! "#

!83.?*/+-0=!

3.-*+-.4,35! !

b !

!!!

!"#$%%! ! !

!

! !"#! !

!

!! !

!"#$%%! !

!

!'7!

!

!!

!

!

!"#! !!

!"J7CM(J! !

!8! !

!?! !!

! ! !

! ! !

!8 $

5! !M"&'!

!

! !"&"!

!

!

!

!"Y#$'7(! !

! !

8''! 5! !"7C777! ! !

!"%C"J6&(! b

!

!

!

!8!! !A

!8B! C!!

!"#! ! !P^S'#%(Q14*,=M!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !F! !

!

! ! ! !

! "7C"YJ! 7! "7C"YJ!

! '6C(Y%! ''C(YY! #'CY#"!

! '7C7'(! "MCY(M! MMC(""!

! '"CJM6! "#CY7(! MYCM%Y!

! "%C7YJ! "'C''#! 'JCM7"!

! DBEFD@! GHEBD@! 8GIE@JG!

!F! !P^S'#%(Q14*,=M!

Page 17: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"J

!?!! ! ! ! !A !

8BKHH! C!

!F! !

! ! ! !7#! ! L8I! L?B! LFB! 5DI!

!

! #'#6! #'M7&(%! #6'M&M'! %#77! 'J77! MJ77! #(77! Y(77!

!

! J'6(! "#'"%&M#! "%%%M&%J! "'777! J777! Y%"7! "Y7J7! '#Y'7!

!

! '(#"! "Y#&"%! ""#&MY! "J7! "'7! "%'! "("! '7M!

!

! JM! '7Y&'6! ""%&J"! '77! "'7! "#J! '"7! '(7!

!F! !

!F! ! ! ! ! !

! !! ! !! !

! @"7C!@'#C!@Y#C!@67! ! !"7C!'#C!Y#C! !67! !

! !

! !M! !%!

! !)*+,-./0!1021033.4,!

$ $

!8@'#C! @#7C! @Y#! 5!

! ! !

! !

!"#$%%! !

!

!

!@!! ! !8BKHH! !!

S.?*/-+,04*3!)*+,-./0!1021033.4,!

f*?D01!4>!4D3! e! #'#6! ! ! ! !

&'#!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&"6##! ! ! ! !

&#7!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&'M6#! ! ! ! !

&Y#!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&''JY! ! ! ! !

D44-3-1+@8#75!Sg3! ! ! ! ! ! !

! $*(M>!-#$%&'-#! ! ! ! !

! ! V44-3-1+@! ! ! ! !

Page 18: Economic Journal Issue 5

! "Y

!@!8 5!!

+=?! O40>&! S-=&!g11&! 9! Xh-!!]6#a! O4,>&! N,-01E+/_!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

N?B! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&7%#M7! 7&7"M6J! M&'#! 7&77! 7&7"Y6%! 7&7Y'JJ!

G203)! 7&7777"! 7&777''! 7&7M! 7&6(! $7&777%'! 7&777%M!

QN30IQ'! $7&"7#MJ! 7&7"6JY! $#&MJ! 7&77! $7&"%M6'! $7&7JJ(7!

QN102Q'! $7&'JMJ"! 7&7'%"M! $"7&6M! 7&77! $7&M"76"! $7&'"JM"!

QN102QM! $7&%7'M7! 7&7'(#7! $"%&"'! 7&77! $7&%#("Y! $7&M%J%'!

QN102Q%! $7&M#6(J! 7&7'Y#"! $"M&7(! 7&77! $7&%"M(7! $7&M7#6'!

QN102Q#! $7&%''(7! 7&7'MY'! $"Y&('! 7&77! $7&%J6M"! $7&MYJ'6!

Q;4,3! Y&6MY#Y! 7&'"('6! MJ&MJ! 7&77! Y&#76J%! (&MJ##7!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

NBI! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&7J"%"! 7&7"M"%! %&JY! 7&77! 7&7M#J%! 7&7(Y"Y!

G203)! $7&777"#! 7&777'7! $7&Y#! 7&%J! $7&777#M! 7&777'%!

QN30IQ'! $7&76'Y(! 7&7"J'Y! $#&Y7! 7&77! $7&"'%JY! $7&7J7(6!

QN102Q'! $7&M"%MM! 7&7'#6'! $"'&"M! 7&77! $7&MJ#"%! $7&'JM#'!

QN102QM! $7&%Y777! 7&7'JM(! $"Y&('! 7&77! $7&#'"Y'! $7&%"('6!

QN102Q%! $7&%%Y%M! 7&7'(%J! $"#&Y'! 7&77! $7&#7M''! $7&M6"JM!

QN102Q#! $7&%Y%""! 7&7'(7#! $"J&67! 7&77! $7&#'6"7! $7&%"6"'!

Q;4,3! Y&(6##M! 7&'7((Y! MY&(7! 7&77! Y&%(J7J! (&M7#77!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

+=?! O40>&! S-=&!g11&! 9! Xh-!!]6#a! O4,>&! N,-01E+/_!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

NFB! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&"7M#'! 7&7"#%Y! J&J6! 7&77! 7&7YM"6! 7&"MM(%!

G203)! $7&777YJ! 7&777'%! $M&'7! 7&77! $7&77"''! $7&777'6!

QN30IQ'! $7&"%"("! 7&7"(((! $Y&#"! 7&77! $7&"Y((M! $7&"7%(7!

QN102Q'! $7&%M7(7! 7&7'Y7J! $"#&6'! 7&77! $7&%(M(#! $7&MYYYJ!

QN102QM! $7&JYY7J! 7&7'6%"! $'M&7'! 7&77! $7&YM%Y'! $7&J"6%7!

QN102Q%! $7&J67""! 7&7'6J"! $'M&M"! 7&77! $7&Y%("Y! $7&JM'7J!

QN102Q#! $7&J%#JJ! 7&7MMJJ! $"6&"(! 7&77! $7&Y""J#! $7&#Y6J(!

Q;4,3! Y&JJ"#J! 7&'%6M6! M7&Y'! 7&77! Y&"Y'JJ! (&"#7%J!

Page 19: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"(

!F! !

! G20! e! !

! G203)!! e! !

! QN30I'!! e! !

! QN102!!! e! !!"e !'e !Me !%e !#e !

!

!H!! ! !

8BKHH! !

!

S.?*/-+,04*3!)*+,-./0!1021033.4,!

f*?D01!4>!4D3! e! J'6(! ! ! ! !

&'#!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&"'MJ! ! ! ! !

&#7!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&"76J! ! ! ! !

&Y#!X30*=4!Z'! e! 7&"%#Y! ! ! ! !

D44-3-1+@8#75!Sg3! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! V44-3-1+@! ! ! ! !

+=?! O40>&! S-=&!g11&! 9!

Xh-!!!!!

]6#a! O4,>&! N,-01E+/_!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

O?B! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&7%%(6! 7&77('M! #&%J! 7&77! 7&7'(YY! 7&7J"7'!

G203)! $7&777##! 7&777"#! $M&Y%! 7&77! $7&777(%! $7&777'J!

QN30IQ'! $7&7(J#J! 7&7"M#J! $J&M(! 7&77! $7&""M"%! $7&7#66(!

QN102Q'! $7&"(Y"%! 7&7"#""! $"'&M(! 7&77! $7&'"JYY! $7&"#Y#'!

QN102QM! $7&#M#%Y! 7&7'"#Y! $'%&(M! 7&77! $7&#YYYJ! $7&%6M"6!

QN102Q%! $7&#M#"J! 7&7'Y7#! $"6&Y6! 7&77! $7&#(("(! $7&%('"#!

QN102Q#! $7&M6YJ"! 7&7'M'M! $"Y&"'! 7&77! $7&%%M"#! $7&M#'7(!

Q;4,3! Y&Y'6M'! 7&"""7(! J6&#(! 7&77! Y&#""#J! Y&6%Y7Y!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

NBI! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&7'%#Y! 7&77##%! %&%%! 7&77! 7&7"MY"! 7&7M#%'!

G203)! $7&777"'! 7&777"7! $"&'7! 7&'M! $7&777MM! 7&7777(!

QN30IQ'! $7&7('J"! 7&77676! $6&76! 7&77! $7&"77%M! $7&7J%Y6!

Page 20: Economic Journal Issue 5

! "6

!H!8 5!!

QN102Q'! $7&"Y7Y"! 7&7""(#! $"%&%"! 7&77! $7&"6M6%! $7&"%Y%(!

QN102QM! $7&%MYJ#! 7&7"%YM! $'6&Y"! 7&77! $7&%JJ#M! $7&%7(YY!

QN102Q%! $7&M(#('! 7&7"Y7%! $''&J%! 7&77! $7&%"6'M! $7&M#'%7!

QN102Q#! $7&M"(YY! 7&7"6M(! $"J&%#! 7&77! $7&M#JY#! $7&'(7Y6!

Q;4,3! (&"7M'6! 7&7Y7Y#! ""%&#%! 7&77! Y&6J%J7! (&'%"6(!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

NFB! ! ! ! ! ! !

G20! 7&777##! 7&77Y7(! 7&7(! 7&6%! $7&7"MMM! 7&7"%%M!

G203)! 7&777%M! 7&777"M! M&'J! 7&77! 7&777"Y! 7&777Y7!

QN30IQ'! $7&7(6Y%! 7&7766J! $6&7"! 7&77! $7&"76'Y! $7&7Y7'"!

QN102Q'! $7&"%'6(! 7&7"#6J! $(&6J! 7&77! $7&"Y%'Y! $7&"""J(!

QN102QM! $7&MJ"JJ! 7&7'7M'! $"Y&(7! 7&77! $7&%7"%6! $7&M'"(M!

QN102Q%! $7&M7'##! 7&7'%6#! $"'&"M! 7&77! $7&M#"%J! $7&'#MJ%!

QN102Q#! $7&'#%M#! 7&7"Y#7! $"%&#M! 7&77! $7&'((JJ! $7&''77%!

Q;4,3! (&%((%Y! 7&7(6'"! 6#&"J! 7&77! (&M"MJ7! (&JJMM#!

!F!! ! !

! !M! !%!

! !#!

!

!B!! ! !!!

! ! ! !

! !

!'#! ! ! !

! !!!!!!#C#(J&Y!! ! !!!!!!!%CJMM&'!!

! !!!!!!#C"'M&%!! ! !!!!!!!%C'%6&7!!

! ! ! !

!#7! ! ! !

! !!!!!!JCY"%&"!! ! !!!!!!!#CJJ7&%!!

! !!!!!!JC"("&Y!! ! !!!!!!!#C'""&J!!

! ! ! !

!Y#! ! ! !

! !!!!!!(C%'6&J!! ! !!!!!!!YCM7J&"!!

! !!!!!!YCY7J&"!! ! !!!!!!!JCJY6&#!!

Page 21: Economic Journal Issue 5

!'7

!B!8 5!!

! ! !!

!'#! ! ! !

! !!!!"MCYJ#&%!! ! !!!!"7C#Y#&J!!

! !!!!"'CM((&(!! ! !!!!!!!6C#"(&7!!

! ! ! !

!#7! ! ! !

! !!!!"6C'M#&M!! ! !!!!"%C7%Y&"!!

! !!!!"YC#M7&7!! ! !!!!"'C(7'&#!!

! ! ! !

!Y#! ! ! !

! !!!!M"C%'#&J!! ! !!!!'7C%'J&'!!

! !!!!'YC'Y7&J!! ! !!!!"YCY'#&#!!!!

!

!

!!

!

!

!A C!

!"%

! !

! !80+1,.,2!

>41024,05!

!''JC%(7&"(! !

! !JJ! !

!M%! ! !

!

!Y7C777! !

!"7C777!

! !M"7C777! !

!#MJC%(7&"(! !

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

! !A !

C!

!8'%$%%! 5!

!

"6!"#

!8 !

5!

! !

!

!67! !6#!

!"(!

!"%

! !W41+?!V0,$X41+-:!!!

"#

!! !g;4,4?.;!X1.,;.@/03!>41!g=*;+-.4,!F!9:041A!+,=!gE.=0,;0! !O/.E0!Z&!V0/>.0/=! !

\.,;01.+,!1+-03!4>!10-*1,!-4!3;:44/.,2! !

! 4! ! (&%!c!"Y&6a!

! 4! ! ! (&6!c!""&#a!

! 4! ! ! "7&7a!

! 4! ! "#&Ma!

! 4! ! ! "J&"a!!!

Page 22: Economic Journal Issue 5

! '"

!G!! ! !?HKHH! !

!

! ! ! ! !

!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

!c!

!

Ma! !

'7! %"""&(! "J"%&%! M7#! 6JMM&M! J7Y%&(! M! ! !

'"! %"YY&'! "M6(&7! '#%! "%#YM&7! '#Y('&#! "M! ! !

''! %#M"&%! #(#'&Y! '67! (6((&"! "7(##&"! (7! ! !

'M! #%(M&6! 6Y'"&(! '6#! (6M7&"! (Y'#&"! "6"! ! !

'%! %YJ"&6! #J"7&"! M""! 6(66&#! ""6#"&7! 'M#! #"MY&J! MM#'#&(!

'#! %J"'&(! "J#J&%! M%#! 6"7M&6! Y7Y#&Y! '(6! %%6"&"! M7'"M&7!

'J! %(#M&(! %('J&%! '67! "7(%J&'! """6J&J! M76! #66'&M! %"##6&M!

'Y! #76#&J! #6'M&"! 'Y6! "7JM6&%! "76Y%&7! M''! ##%M&(! M6JM(&7!

'(! #J7(&J! (7#"&(! '66! "76#Y&(! "7MMJ&M! M7#! #M%6&'! M6%'6&%!

'6! %6M%&J! '"6(&7! 'M7! "%"%'&M! "YM6J&%! '(7! 6'7Y&Y! J66J6&Y!

M7! %6MY&"! '7M7&#! 'Y(! "%%%7&Y! "JMY(&6! '6#! 6#7M&J! Y%%#"&J!

M"! #M7%&Y! '#Y%&"! "Y'! "#7(%&(! "J77%&J! 'MM! 6Y(7&"! Y(6(Y&%!

M'! #M('&7! ''6'&'! '7J! "%%YJ&%! "MY("&'! 'J7! 676%&%! Y#Y'"&7!

MM! J''M&(! Y(Y'&Y! "(%! "%'M#&Y! """(#&J! ''"! (7""&(! J(YY7&J!

M%! #Y"(&Y! 'Y("&#! "%(! "Y7M(&#! "%7Y(&7! '""! ""M"6&(! "77"J6&J!

M#! #MM"&%! 'M%6&"! '7M! "Y(%"&7! "#"(7&7! '#7! "'#76&#! ""%"'"&%!

MJ! #%''&(! '('%&J! "6"! '7M"M&6! "Y'MM&'! ''"! "%(6"&"! "%77%6&'!

MY! #Y(M&'! M""J&#! "J%! "Y(Y7&6! "MJM7&M! '"7! "'7(Y&Y! ""Y'77&"!

M(! #M#'&M! 'YJ#&6! "##! "JY''&Y! (J#(&7! "6J! ""MY7&%! ""MJ#%&Y!

M6! #(M#&"! #'6"&'! 66! "6%%(&"! "##%#&#! '7Y! "MJ"M&7! "%7'Y6&"!

%7! Y#YM&(! 6"%M&"! "(J! '7JMM&%! "J(77&6! ''%! "M7#6&J! "M(YM(&J!

%"! JY#6&J! %%((&J! "M#! '7Y'7&J! "##MY&'! "JY! "M6J"&7! "#'67"&Y!

%'! ('(M&Y! ""6"(&"! "%'! '"%#Y&'! "#JM%&J! "((! "M"YM&#! "%(YM6&M!

%M! (#'"&"! "7'67&Y! 6Y! '''6J&'! "YM67&Y! "YY! "MYY#&'! "J7M%M&7!

%%! (M%J&7! YM76&"! "7'! 'M%Y7&6! "#"%(&J! "JY! "#"'#&7! "("%66&#!

! ?EIBDEDG?>8!

!F! !'#%(!

! ! ! !! ! !

!

Page 23: Economic Journal Issue 5

!''

H>! !

!!! ! !

! ;+ + ; ;++!'#M(!

!

!!!

! !

! >"J! ! & !

! !!

!"Y

!

!

!!

!'YC777! !

!

!

!

!!

!

! !

!

!

! ! 5!

i! 5!

i!

i!! 5!

!

! ! 5!

!!

! !

! ! 5!

! &!

i! !

!

i!

! !

! &!!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

"J

! ! !! ! !

!8 &%!$! &J!! "!$$ M! "!$! '!!

!! !

"Y

! ! &!8`4B,/4+=! ! ! !%! !'##75! !

!"J! !'#M6! !"'! ! & &!'%6"!

! ! & &!'#%"!

! !(! ! !

"(#C"JM! ! !'C"("C""J! !! !

!!

!

Page 24: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 'M

b

"(

! 5! b

! !

! &! !

H

!

!K L!!

! ! 5! !

!

! &! !!!

!

! ! !

'#%6! !8 & & & ! 5!

! !

!

!"6! !

'#%6! ! !

! &! !'##7! ! &!

!!!

!

!

! &! !

! !!

!

! !c!

"6

!!

!! &!

!

!!

! &! !

!!

!!

! &!

!

! & &!'#%J! !J! ! & !

!#! !

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

"(

! ! ! ! !

! !#6(&M6!! !! !!#%J&M! !! !!#'! !

! &! !(a!! !'#%(!

"6

! ! !'b'##7! !''! !'##7! !

!'##7! !!

! $! !#CJYJ&"Y! !

! $! !"76CJYM!!

! !! 4! ! 66CM6%! !

! !! 4! !! 6C(Y'! !

! !! 4! ! &!! MM6! !

! !! 4! ! &! ! &!! J(! !

Page 25: Economic Journal Issue 5

!'%

O"F! !

!

!!!

O'F!!'7

OMF! !

! !

!M!

!

O%F! ! !

!

O#F!

!

! !!

!

!"#7C777! ! !

!

!8 5!

$$

!!

! !! !

! ! 5! !

! !

!! 5! !

!'C777! !

! !! !

&! !

!

!

!!

! !

! !

! !!! !

!

!!

'"

!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

'7

! ! ! &!! !

! !

!! !

! !

! !!J#a!

!G! b ! !V! !'7a!

! ! !8

!"#7C777! 5! !

! 4! !J#a!8 ! !6MC777! 5!

! 4! !YJa!8"("C7775! ! ! 4!! !(7a!!

! 4! b !J%a!8"MC7775! ! 4!! !YYa!8"(7C7775!

'"

! ! &!8 & ! 5! ! !'J! !'##"!

!! ! ! &! !'JC777!c! "Y%C777!!

!

Page 26: Economic Journal Issue 5

! '#

!! !

!

!

! &!''

!!!

+ +;! !

!!

!8 !'65!!

!! ! &!

!

!

!!'M

!

>'%!!

!

! ! &!

! !

!K L!

'#

! !4@01+-.4,! 1030+1;:!

b30)*0,-.+/! +,+/A3.3! ! &!

!

8 !"#7! 5!

! ! !

! ! !8 !

! 5! !

!!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

''

! ! ! !"#!

!! ! !#! ! !"'a!

!! !"'! ! ! !"(!

! ! &!8 ! 5!

! !'! !'##7! ! ! K&&&! ! !

! !#! ! !

! ! ! !#! ! !

%YC777! !! ! !&&&L!

'M

!! ! ! ! !'#%'$'#%6!

!"C%#"CY%"! !! !"C7M%"C"%'! ! !Y"&'Ma! !

!'7"C((#! !! !"CMY#! ! !"JJ! !

! !"! !'##7!! !

!'! ! !!"C%#JCM#6! !! !66JCJMY! !8J(&%a5! !

%#6CY''!8M"&Ja5! !'C(%J! ! !JC(%M! ! !%#7C7MM! !!

'%

! ! & !! ! ! &!

!

'#

! !! ! ! !

!! ! !!

!! !

!8 ! !"(! ! !"#! 5!!

! &!

Page 27: Economic Journal Issue 5

!'J

! !c!

8 5!

!!

!

! !

!

! !

! !

! &! !!

!

!8 H

!"#! 5!!!

! !

! &! !

(#'J

! ! !

"#a! ! !

8 !

!(#a5!

! ! !

!

!8 !

5!!

!

!!30)*0,-.+/!+,+/A3.3!!

!j.k-! ! &!

! !

.!e! !!

k!e! !

-!e! !8 5!

!

!8W.k-5!

!

!

W.k-!!le!!j.k-!

!W.k-!!e! !j.k-!!!C!! !!le!"!

!

!8"$! 5!

!

!

! !

!8 !

! !?+,+20?0,-!

011415! ! &!

!!

!'Y

!!!

! !

!"#7C777! !

!! !

!!

!! !

b !

!

!8 !"#7C777!

5! !8

5!

! ! &!

!8 ! b 5! !

! !!

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ!

'J

! ! !'7! !'##"!

!"77a!! !(#a!! !!

!

'Y

! [email protected]!;+@+D./.-A5! !

Page 28: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 'Y

! ! !"#7C777!

! !

! !

! ! !"%6C666! !

! !

!'#7C777! !

! !

!

!+=*/-!0)*.E+/0,-!0I@0,=.-*10! !

!

! ! !

"#7C777! ! !'#M6!

! !

!

!!

! &! !

!! !

!! !

!

!

!

!8 &5!!

!8 !"7!

5! !!

b

!!

!!

! &! !

!8

! &! !M7!

5!! !!

! &! !-+120-.,2!

! !

!

!-+120-.,2! !!!

B>! ! ! >!

! >!

!

! !8 5!

! !8 &5!

!

!!

! &! ! &! !!

! &!

!

! !

!!

!8

! &! 5!!

!

! !

!

! + ; +! !

!!

!

! ! &!

! !!

! !

Page 29: Economic Journal Issue 5

!'(

$$

! !!

! &! !

!

! !

!8 !#a5!

!

!6#a!!!

! ! ! &!!

! !

! !

! &! !

!8

!"#7C777! 5! !!!

!!

!

!

!810@+A?0,-! D*1=0,5!

H !

! &!

!"#! !

!8 ! $"5!

!

!M6! ! !"(a!

!!

! !Y&#a!

!! !'7! !

! &! !

! !

! &!! !

!"! ! &! !!

!! !

K L! !!

"($"6a! !!

!8 !'$#! 5!

! !

! &!

! !%$#a! !

!

!!

!

G>! !

! !8 5!

!8 5!

!!

!

!

!'#%(!

!

!!

! !

!

! ! !

8 5! ! 5!

!Y!

! !#77C777!

! !!

! !"#$%%! !!!

!!

"($"6! !

! !

8 5!

!!

Page 30: Economic Journal Issue 5

! '6

! !

&! ! !

!

!8

! !?+,+20?0,-!

01141! 5!!

$$ !!

! &! !

&! !

!

! &! !8

5

!! ! &!

! ! !

!

!

!

!

! !'#%6! K

L! !!

! !

! !! !

!!

!'##7!

!

! !

! "Y! !'##7!

!(&M7$"J&M7! ! !

! !'#%(!

!

!'#%(C!

!

! !!

!'!

!! !

! ! ! ! !'#%%!!

!

!

! !

! ! !

G;0?42/*C!`&!"66J!KG!?.;14>4*,=+-.4,!>41!34;.+/!

.,;10+3.,2! 10-*1,3! .,! :*?+,! ;[email protected]+/CL!

m*+1-01/A! [4*1,+/! 4>! g;4,4?.;3C! """F!

YY6$(7%&!

G114BC! n&[&! "6YM! Kd.2:01! 0=*;+-.4,! +3! +! >./-01CL!

[4*1,+/! 4>! X*D/.;! g;4,4?.;3C! 'F! "6M$

'"J&!

V+,01k00C!G&!+,=!G&!f0B?+,!"66M!Ko;;*@+-.4,+/!

;:4.;0!+,=!-:0!@14;033!4>!=0E0/4@?0,-CL!

[4*1,+/!4>!X4/.-.;+/!g;4,4?AC!"7"F!'Y%$

66&!

V+114C!Z&[&!"66Y!`0-01?.,+,-3!4>!g;4,4?.;!U14B-:F!

G!O1433$O4*,[email protected].;+/!S-*=AC!O+?D1.=20F!

\N9!X1033&!

V0/>.0/=C! O/.E0! Z&! '777! g;4,4?.;! X1.,;.@/03! >41!

g=*;+-.4,F!9:041A!+,=!X1+;-.;0C!O:0/-0,:+?F!

g=B+1=!g/2+1&!

Page 31: Economic Journal Issue 5

!M7

V0,0D4*C!Z&!"66%!Kd*?+,!;[email protected]+/C!.,0)*+/.-AC!+,=!

214B-:F! +! /4;+/! @013@0;-.E0CL! m*+1-01/A!

[4*1,+/!4>!g;4,4?.;3C!"7(F!J"6$#'&!

O:+@?+,C! V1*;0! '77J! U4E01,?0,-! \+,+2.,2!

Z.3<F! N,;4?0! O4,-.,20,-! P4+,3! >41!

S4;.+/!+,=!g;4,4?.;!X1421033C!P4,=4,F!

Z4*-/0=20&!

`*--+C! [+A+31.C! [+?03! S0>-4,! +,=!\+1-.,!R0+/0!

'77M! Kg=*;+-.4,! +,=! @*D/.;! @4/.;ACL! .,!

`+E.=!\./03C! 0-&+/&! 0=3&!9:0!g;4,4?.;3!

4>! X*D/.;! S@0,=.,2C! oI>41=! p,.E013.-A!

X1033&!

^1.0=?+,C!\./-4,!"6##!K9:0!14/0!4>!24E01,?0,-!.,!

0=*;+-.4,CL!.,!Z&G&!S4/4B!0=&!g;4,4?.;3!

+,=!-:0!X*D/.;!N,-0103-C!Z*-2013!p,.E013.-A!

X1033&!

^1.0=?+,C!\./-4,!"6##[email protected]+/.3?!+,=!^100=4?C!

O:.;+24F!p,.E013.-A!4>!O:.;+24!X1033&!

^1.0=?+,C!\./-4,!"66#!K9:0!14/0!4>!24E01,?0,-!.,!

0=*;+-.4,CL! .,! G&! S4/4! 0=&! g;4,4?.;3!

+,=!X*D/.;!N,-0103-C!f0B!V1*,3B.;<F!f[F!

Z*-2013!p,.E013.-A!X1033C!@@&"'M$%%&!

[4:,3-4,0C!V1*;0!"6Y'!f0B!X+--01,3!>41!O4//020!

P0,=.,2F!N,;4?0$O4,-.,20,-!P4+,3C!f0B!

W41<F!O4/*?D.+!p,.E013.-A!X1033!f01/4E0C!

\+1;!"6Y'!Ko,!-*.-.4,!+,=! -:0!;43-3!4>!

:.2:01! 0=*;+-.4,F! @14/024?0,+! -4! +!

;4,;0@-*+/! >1+?0B41<CL! [4*1,+/! 4>!

X4/.-.;+/! g;4,4?AC! (78M5F! @+1-! NNC! S"Y($

S'"(&!

U1+=3-0.,C! \+1<C! \43:0! [*3-?+,! +,=! q4/<01!

\0.01! '77#! 9:0! X4/.-.;+/! g;4,4?A! 4>!

g=*;+-.4,F! N?@/.;+-.4,3! >41! U14B-:! +,=!

N,0)*.-AC!\N9!X1033&!

P/01+3C!\.2*0/!X+/+;.43!'77%!N,E03-.,2!.,!d*?+,!

[email protected]+/[email protected]+/!\+1<0-3!G@@14+;:! -4!

S-*=0,-! ^*,=.,2C! O+?D1.=20! p,.E013.-A!

X1033&!

n4==0C!`&!"6(J!Kp,;01-+.,-A!+,=!-:0!=0?+,=!>41!

0=*;-.4,CL! Z0E.0B! 4>! g;4,4?.;3! +,=!

S-+-.3-.;3C!J(F!%J7$%JY&!

\;\+:4,C!R&R&!"666!g=*;+-.4,!+,=!`0E0/4@?0,-F!

\0+3*1.,2! -:0! S4;.+/! V0,0>.-3C! oI>41=F!

oI>41=!p,.E013.-A!X1033&!

\+,<.BC!U&f&C!`&!Z40?01C!+,=!`&f&!R0./!"66'!KG!

;4,-1.D*-.4,!-4!-:[email protected].;3!4>!0;4,4?.;!

214B-:CL!m*+1-01/A![4*1,+/!4>!g;4,4?.;3C!

"7Y!F!%7Y$MY&!

\.,;01C! [+;4D! "6Y%! S;:44/.,2C! [email protected],;0C! +,=!

g+1,.,23C!f0B!W41<F!f+-.4,+/!V*10+*!4>!

g;4,4?.;!Z030+1;:&!

\.,;01C![+;4D!"66'!Kd*?+,!;[email protected]+/!+,=!-:0!/+D41!

?+1<0-F! +! 10E.0B! 4>! ;*110,-! 1030+1;:CL!!

.,! \+1<! V/+*2C! 0=&! 9:0! g;4,4?.;3! 4>!

g=*;+-.4,C!g=B+1=!g/2+1!

X3+;:+14@4*/43C!U&!"66M!KZ0-*1,3!-4!0=*;+-.4,!F!

+! 2/4D+/! *@=+-0CL! R41/=! V+,<C! X4/.;A!

Z030+1;:!X+@01!f4&!"7JY&!

X3+;:+14@4*/43C!U04120!+,=!Z.;:+1=!P+A+1=!"66'!

Kd*?+,!;[email protected]+/!+,=!0+1,.,23F!V1.-.3:!0E.=0,;0!

+,=!+!;1.-.)*0CL! .,!\+1<!V/+*2C!0=&!9:0!

g;4,4?.;3!4>!g=*;+-.4,C!g=B+1=!g/2+1&!

Z430,C!S:01B.,!"6Y'!KP0+1,.,2!+,[email protected],;0!.,!

-:0! /+D41! ?+1<0-CL! [4*1,+/! 4>! d*?+,!

Z034*1;03C!Y8M5F!M'J$M%'&!

S;:*/-T0C! 9&R&! "6J"! KN,E03-?0,-! .,! :*?+,!

;[email protected]+/CL! G?01.;+,! g;4,4?.;! Z0E.0BC!!

#"!8\+1;:5C!"$"Y&!

Page 32: Economic Journal Issue 5

! M"

!

! K8!!! ! >!!

!

! ! !!!

!!"! !

!# $!

"! "&777! "&#! 7&7"#! 7! 7&7"#77! "7!

'! 7&6(#! '&#! 7&7'#! 7&776(#! 7&7M%(#! "7!

M! 7&6J7! M! 7&7M7! 7&776J7! 7&7M6J7! "7!

%! 7&6M7! M&#! 7&7M#! 7&776M7! 7&7%%M7! "7!

#! 7&(6#! %! 7&7%7! 7&77(6#! 7&7%(6#! "7!

J! 7&(##! %&#! 7&7%#! 7&77(##! 7&7#M##! "7!

Y! 7&("7! #! 7&7#7! 7&77("7! 7&7#("7! "7!

(! 7&YJ7! J! 7&7J7! 7&77YJ7! 7&7JYJ7! "7!

6! 7&Y77! Y! 7&7Y7! 7&77Y77! 7&7YY77! "7!

"7! 7&JM7! (! 7&7(7! 7&77JM7! 7&7(JM7! "7!

""! 7&##7! 6! 7&767! 7&77##7! 7&76##7! "7!

"'! 7&%J7! "7! 7&"77! 7&77%J7! 7&"7%J7! "7!

"M! 7&MJ7! ""! 7&""7! 7&77MJ7! 7&""MJ7! "7!

"%! 7&'#7! "'! 7&"'7! 7&77'#7! 7&"''#7! "7!

"#! 7&"M7! "M! 7&"M7! 7&77"M7! 7&"M"M7! "7!

!! ! "%%! "&%%%! %&%'()*! "&%'()*! !!F! ! !

!

Page 33: Economic Journal Issue 5

!M'

! K?!! ! >! !A !?JIEIII! C!

!

?JIEIII! !!

!

!

P!

!

F>BP! !?I! !

%'"7! M#7&(! '%! 6(66&#! 7&7M#%%! (676&J!

6YJ(! ("%&7! '#! 6"7M&6! 7&7(6%"! ("6M&#!

""76(! 6'%&(! 'J! "7(%J&'! 7&7(#'Y! 6YJ"&J!

"'%"%! "7M%&#! 'Y! "7JM6&%! 7&76Y'M! 6#Y#&#!

"MY"J! ""%M&7! '(! "76#Y&(! 7&"7%M"! 6(J'&7!

"#77%! "'#7&M! '6! "%"%'&M! 7&7((%"! "'Y'(&"!

"J'Y(! "M#J&#! M7! "%%%7&Y! 7&76M6%! "'66J&J!

"(6M(! "#Y(&'! M"! "#7(%&(! 7&"7%J'! "M#YJ&M!

'"#Y7! "Y6Y&#! M'! "%%YJ&%! 7&"'%"Y! "M7'(&(!

'%"Y%! '7"%&#! MM! "%'M#&Y! 7&"%"#"! "'("'&"!

'JY#7! '''6&'! M%! "Y7M(&#! 7&"M7(M! "#MM%&Y!

'6'6(! '%%"&#! M#! "Y(%"&7! 7&"MJ(#! "J7#J&6!

M"("(! 'J#"&#! MJ! '7M"M&6! 7&"M7#M! "('('&#!

M%M"7! '(#6&'! MY! "Y(Y7&6! 7&"#666! "J7(M&(!

MJYY%! M7J%&#! M(! "JY''&Y! 7&"(M'#! "#7#7&%!

@IG8?I! ! M6! "6%%(&"! I>88@F?! "Y#7M&M!

! ! %7! '7JMM&%! ! "(#Y7&"!

! ! %"! '7Y'7&J! ! "(J%(&#!

! ! %'! '"%#Y&'! ! "6M""&#!

! ! %M! '''6J&'! ! '77JJ&J!

! ! %%! 'M%Y7&6! ! '""'M&(!

! ! ! ! ! @IFHFG>8!

!

!

!! ! ! &! !'(7C777! !

! $"!

!! ! !

!'%! !! ! !

!8 !M(! ! !"(&Ma!

5! !'%$M6! ! !""&%a!

!! ! ! !Y&#! !

!'7! !8'%$%%5!

Page 34: Economic Journal Issue 5

! MM

! K?!! ! >! !?BBI!

!

! !'##7! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! !

!8 5! !!!!!(YCJY'!! !!!!MC6"J&'!! !!!!!'7C'%#!! !!!!#C#M7&7!! !!!!!'JCJJ(!!

! !!!!!#YC7Y'!! !!!!%C'YM&J!! !!!!!"7C7'J!! !!!!"C%M"&7!! !!!!!"YCM6"!!

! !!!!!JJC6(M!! !!!!'CY76&#!! !!!!!"%C67"!! !!!!"C%J6&7!! !!!!!'%CM%#!!

! !!!!!"6C%Y"!! !!!!!!!67J&"!! !!!!!!!%C6%(!! !!!!'C7('&7!! !!!!!!!JC"6'!!

! !!!!!!!!!!'M6!! !!!!!!!!!"(&J!! !!!!!!!!!!!!%%!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!$!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!YM!!

! !!!!!!!!!!%(6!! !!!!!!!!!"Y&7!! !!!!!!!!!!%7J!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!$!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!"M!!

! !!!!'M"C6'J!! !!!""C(%7&6! !!!!!#7C#Y7!! !!!"7C#"'&7!! !!!!!!Y%CJ('!!

!

! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! !

!8 5! !!'"C(M'&7!! !!!!!Y%C'Y#!! !!!!MC"(M&'!! !!!!!"MCM6Y!! !!!!!!!YMM&7!!

! !!"JC%Y7&7!! !!!!!%#CM"(!! !!!!MCM"J&7!! !!!!!""CY#%!! !!!!!!!6#Y&J!!

! !!"(C%#6&7!! !!!!!#6C"Y%!! !!!!'C76%&M!! !!!!!!!YC(76!! !!!!!!!J"#&"!!

! !!!!%C'J(&7!! !!!!!"YC%67!! !!!!!!!J67&"!! !!!!!!!"C6("!! !!!!!!!'"#&6!!

! !!!!!!!!#"&7!! !!!!!!!!!"J(!! !!!!!!!!!!6&7!! !!!!!!!!!!!Y"!! !!!!!!!!!!!6&J!!

! !!!!!!!!!!J&7!! !!!!!!!!!%'#!! !!!!!!!!!"%&6!! !!!!!!!!!!!J%!! !!!!!!!!!!!'&"!!

! !!J"C7(J&7!! !!!"6JC(#7!! !!!!6CM7Y&#!! !!!!!!M#C7YJ!! !!!!!'C#MM&%!!

!

!

Page 35: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"#$%&'%()'*+(,-%./'0+&"$/'*"1,#'2"(3%4,'-+'56%"&%()7#'84."$9&-9.,:'

;".%<%-';%.+,(#%-6%=+.(39&>'

!

'

!

! !

!

! !

! ! !

! !

!

!

! ! !

! !

! ! !

!

!

'

?! "! "!

!

8@A5B8C5'

! #$%&!&'()*!$+&!+,-.+)*!/..0!%0!,%0.!1%'$!'$.!'$.2.!34!43-1+-)!,%05+6.!/.'1..0!!2+7-3.73032%7!

83,%7%.&!+0)!+6-%7(,'(-.9!:&!+!2+7-3!,.;.,"!$31!2(7$!4%&7+,!+0)!230.'+-*!83,%7*!2%<.&!/.0.4%'!'3!

#$+%,+0)=&!+6-%7(,'(-.!%&!%0;.&'%6+'.)9!#$.!8-37.)(-.!/.6%0&!1%'$!'$.!.&'%2+'%30!34!8+-+2.'.-&!%0!

'$.!2+7-3.73032%7>+6-%7(,'(-+,! ,%05+6.!23).,9!#$.!2+%0!-.&(,'&! -.;.+,! '$+'! '$3&.!83,%7%.&!$+;.!

'$.! %28+7'!30! '$.! %0'.-.&'! -+'."! '$.!.<7$+06.! -+'."! 8-%7.! %0).<!+0)!?@A9!#$.&.!;+-%+/,.&! ,%05!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"#$%"&'()*"+,(*"-&",.*$-(/)"0'))%(*,*'-1",*"2,)%*),(*"31'4%()'*5"6,)"%7*%10%0"*-"*$')",(*'89%:""";"<8$--9"-&"%8-1-='8)",10"+.>9'8"+-9'85?"@'(,6,*@A)6.:,8:*$"

Page 36: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! EF

63;.-02.0'!.<8.0)%'(-.!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!'3!'$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-9!#$.!.&'%2+'.)!8+-+2.'.-&!

+-.! '$.0! ('%,%G.)! 43-! 83,%7*! &%2(,+'%309! H$.0! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0! '$.! 63;.-02.0'! 730&(28'%30!

&8.0)%06! 73(8,.)!1%'$! +77.,.-+'%30! %0!230.*! &(88,*! 6-31'$! %&! ).230&'-+'.)"! '$.%-! %28+7'&! 30!

+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!+-.!7307,().)!%0!'.-2&!34!8.-7.0'+6.!7$+06.!4-32!/+&.,%0.!;+,(.!+&!43,,31&9!

B33)!730&(28'%30"!.<83-'!+0)!%283-'!%07-.+&.9!I.;.-'$.,.&&"!&(-8,(&!34!'-+).!/+,+07.!43-!433)!%&!

13-&.09! J28,3*2.0'! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! ).7-.+&.&"! 1$%,.! 7+8%'+,! &'375! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-!

%07-.+&.&9! ?-3&&! )32.&'%7! 8-3)(7'%30! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! &(/&.K(.0',*! %07-.+&.&9! #$.!

-.8,%7+'%30! -.&(,'&! %28,*! '$+'! '$.! 2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7%.&! $+;.! +0! (0%0'.0).)! .44.7'! 30!

+6-%7(,'(-."!+,'$3(6$!'$.!230.*!%&!03'!)%-.7',*!%0L.7'.)!%0'3!'$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-9!

'

D,/' <+.)#?! B%&7+,! +0)!230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<.&"! :6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-"! C+7-3.73032%7>+6-%7(,'(-+,!

,%05+6.!23).,9!!

!

:E'F(-.+)9$-"+('

H%'$! -.&8.7'! '3! '$.! &.0&.!34! .73032%7!

).;.,382.0'"! #$+%,+0)=&! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! $+&!

/..0! &'-306,*! /-3(6$'! (8! /*! '$.! 63;.-02.0'!

'$-3(6$!;+-%3(&!8-36-+2&9!H%'$!03!)3(/'"! '$.!

8-36-+2! '$+'! %&! +! &3>7+,,.)! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 83,%7*!

$+&! %0'.0).)! %28+7'&! 30! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9!

I30.'$.,.&&"! M7$($! NOPQRS! &(77%07',*! &'+'.)!

'$+'! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! .73032%&'&! $+;.! '3! 6%;.!

6-.+'.-!+''.0'%30!'3!230.'+-*!+0)!4%&7+,!83,%7*!

%4!'$.*!1+0'!'3!(0).-&'+0)!).;.,382.0'&!%0!'$.!

+6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! C3-.3;.-"! M'+23(,%&! !"# $%9!NOPPFS! +-6(.)! '$+'! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-=&!

8.-43-2+07.! %&! +44.7'.)! 03'! 30,*! /*! 83,%7%.&!

&8.7%4%7+,,*!).&%60.)!43-! %'!/('!+,&3"!+0)!34'.0!

23-.! )..8,*"! /*! 83,%7%.&! +44.7'%06! '$.! 3;.-+,,!

2+7-3.73032%7! .0;%-302.0'"! .969! 8(/,%7! &.7'3-!

).4%7%'&"! %04,+'%30"! %0'.-.&'! -+'.! +0)! .<7$+06.!

-+'.9!:8+-'! 4-32! '$%&"! '$.! -.&.+-7$!34!+6-%7(,'(-+,!

.73032%7&! %0! +&8.7'! 34!2+7-3.73032%7&! &7$33,!

$+&!/..0!-+-.,*!-.;.+,.)!%0!#$+%,+0)!(8!'3!'$.!

8-.&.0'! '%2.9!:773-)%06,*"! '$%&!&'()*! %&!/.6(0!

/*! +&5%06! '$+'! $31! 2+7-3.73032%7&! 83,%7%.&!

,%05+6.!'3!+6-%7(,'(-.9!B(-'$.-23-."!$31!2(7$!

4%&7+,! +0)! 230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<.&! /.0.4%'! '3!

#$+%,+0)=&!+6-%7(,'(-.!%&!%0;.&'%6+'.)9!

>E'2"-,.%-9.,'B,G",<''

#$.-.! +-.! /+&%7+,,*! '13! &7$33,&! 34!

'$3(6$'!0+2.,*!&'-(7'(-+,!+0)!7328('+/,.!6.0.-+,!

.K(%,%/-%(2!23).,&! %0! 3-).-! '3! %0;.&'%6+'.! '$.!

.44.7'&! 34! 230.'+-*! +0)! 4%&7+,! 83,%7*! 30!

+6-%7(,'(-.9! #$.! 43-2.-! ;%.1! %&! ).-%;.)! 4-32! '$.!

4%-&'!1.,4+-.!'$.3-.2!%0!'$.!,%0.!34!2%7-3.73032%7&!

'$.3-*9! T'&! K(+0'%'+'%;.! +0+,*&%&! %&! +,&3! %0! '$.!

43-2!34!030>8+-+2.'-%7!23).,9!#$.!,+''.-!;%.1!

%&! 732.! 4-32! '$.! 6.0.-+,! .K(%,%/-%(2! %0! '$.!

1+*!34!2+7-3.73032%7&!'$.3-*9!U(+0'%'+'%;.,*"!

Page 37: Economic Journal Issue 5

!ER

'$.! 8+-+2.'-%7! 23).,"! 1$%7$! %&! +! &3>7+,,.)!

.73032.'-%7! 23).,"! %&! +,&3! .28,3*.)9! #$.!

8-37.)(-.&!34!-.&.+-7$.&!%0!,%0.!1%'$!'$.!'$.2.!34!

&'-(7'(-+,!23).,!+-.!7328-%&.)!34!'$-..!&'.8&V!

730&%).-+'%30!34!2+7-3.73032%7!&7$33,"!&'-(7'(-.!

34! '$.3-.'%7+,! 23).,"! +0)! .&'%2+'%30! W! 83,%7*!

&%2(,+'%309!!

B%-&',*"! '$.! %28,%7+'%30&! .+7$! 34! '$.!

2+7-3.73032%7! &7$33,&! 34! '$3(6$'! 43-! ,%05+6.&!

/.'1..0!6.0.-+,!.73032*!+0)!+6-%7(,'(-.!+-.!

K(%'.! )%44.-.0'9! :773-)%06! '3! X.*0.&%+0! ;%.1"!

'$.! 83,%7%.&! $+)! %28+7'&! 30! -.+,! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

;+-%+/,.&! /('! '$.! )%-.7'%30! 34! '$.%-! .44.7'&!

-.2+%0.)!730'-3;.-&%+,9!Y0!'$.!3'$.-!$+0)"!'$.!

0.37,+&&%7+,!;%.1!%0)%7+'.)!'$+'! '$3&.!83,%7%.&!

13(,)!03'!$+;.!+0*!-.+,!%28+7'&!30!+6-%7(,'(-.!

;+-%+/,.&9!#$%&! %&!/.7+(&.!+,,! 34!2+7-3.73032%7!

;+-%+/,.&!+0)!+6-%7(,'(-+,!8-%7.! -.&830&.! '3!+!

83,%7*! &$375!/*! '$.! &+2.!8-383-'%309!B3-! '$.!

I.3>X.*0.&%+0"! '$.! 83,%7%.&! $+)! -.+,! %28+7'&!

30!+6-%7(,'(-.!%0!'$.!&$3-'!-(09!#$.!%28+7'&!34!

83,%7%.&!13(,)!)%&+88.+-!+&!8-%7.&!34!030+6-%7(,'(-+,!

633)&! -%&.! '3! '$.%-! ,306>-(0! .K(%,%/-%(2! 3;.-!

'%2.!NZ$3."!OP[PS9!

M.730),*"!'$.!4-+2.13-5!34!2+7-3.73032%7!

%&! ).;.,38.)! %0'3! '$.! &'-(7'(-+,! 23).,9! #$.!

23).,!/(%,).-&!+)+8'!'13!&'-+'.6%.&!'3!7+8'(-.!

'$.! %0'.-+7'%30! /.'1..0! 2+7-3.73032*! +0)!

+6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! #$.! 4%-&'! 30.! %&! '$+'! +!

&+'.,,%'.!23).,!%&!&.8+-+'.)!4-32!'$.!2+7-3.73032%7&!

23).,! %0! '$.!&.0&.!34!8-3;%)%06!03!.&'%2+'.&!

34!.0)36.03(&!;+-%+/,.&!/('!).8.0).)!30!'$.!

43-.7+&'&! 34! ;+- %+/ ,.&! 7-.+'.)! /*! '$.!

2+7-3.73032%7&! 23).,9! #$.! &.730)! 30.! %&!

'$+'! '$.! 23).,! 730&%).-&! +6-%7(,'(-.! +&! +0!

%0)(&'-%+,! &.7'3-! N\338! +0)! ].%'0.-"! OPQQS9!

B%0+,,*"!'$.!.73032.'-%7!'$.3-%.&!+-.!.28,3*.)!

43-! .&'%2+'%30! +0)! 83,%7*! -.8,%7+'%309! T'! %&!

&.8+-+'.)!%0'3!&'+'%7!+0)!)*0+2%7!.73032.'-%7!

23).,9!!!

#$.!-.&'!34!'$%&!8+-'!%&!).;3'.)!'3!'$.!

&(-;.*!34!.28%-%7+,!.;%).07.&9!^.6%00%06!1%'$!

'$.!7+&.!34!_9M9!+6-%7(,'(-."!%0!'$.!.+-,*!OP[`&!

'$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!.73032%&'!8+%)!23-.!+''.0'%30!

30! '$.! .44.7'&! 34! 2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7*! 30!

+6-%7(,'(-.9! #$%&! %&! /.7+(&.! '$.! %0'.-0+'%30+,!

2+-5.'&! $+;.! .<8.-%.07.)! +! &.;.-.! 7*7,%7+,!

)310'(-09! T0!+))%'%30"! '$.! %283-'+0'! &'-(7'(-+,!

7$+06.&! $+;.! '+5.0! 8,+7.)! %0! '$.! 13-,)!

.73032*! %4! 30.!7328+-.&! '$.!.+-,*!OP[`&! '3!

OPR`&9!C.+01$%,."! )(-%06! &(7$! '%2.!+! -.&'-%7'.)!

230.'+-*! 83,%7*! +0)! +0! .<8+0&%30+-*! 4%&7+,!

83,%7*! 730'-%/('.)! &'-306,*! '3! '$.! &.;.-.!

)310'(-0! %0!+6-%7(,'(-.9!#$.! ,%'.-+'(-.&"!1$%7$!

$+;.! /..0! %0! ,%0.! 1%'$! '$%&! '$.2."! +-.!

A++-,/.-6! !"# $%9! NOP[aS"! X%'7$.0! !"# $%9! NOP[QS!+0)!b(&'!NOPP`S9!!

A++-,/.-6!!"#$%9! NOP[aS! %&! %0! '$.! 43-2!34!X.*0.&%+0!&7$33,"!&'-(7'(-+,!23).,%06!%0!'$.!

1+*! 34! &+'.,,%'.! 23).,! +0)! (&%06! &'+'%7!

2+7-3.73032.'-%7!23).,9! #$.*! ).230&'-+'.)!

+,'.-0+'%;.! &7.0+-%3"! '$.! +77.,.-+'%30! %0! _9M9!

230.*! 6-31'$! /.'1..0! 2%)! OP[c! +0)! .+-,*!

OP[a"! +0)! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0! '$.! 4.).-+,! ).4%7%'9!

:&!'$.!&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&"!'$.!%07-.+&.!%0!_9M9!

%0732.!+0)!'$.!-%&%06!;+,(.!34!'$.!)3,,+-!$+;.!

-+%&.)! _9M9! %283-'! ).2+0)! +0)"! +&! +! -.&(,'"!

43-.%60! .<83-'&! +0)! %0732.! %07-.+&.9! #$%&!

Page 38: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! EQ

%07-.+&.! %0! %0732.!$+&!$+)!+!83&%'%;.! %28+7'!

30!).2+0)! 43-! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 633)&! '$+'! $+)!+'!

,.+&'!8+-',*!344&.'! '$.!)+28.0%06!.44.7'!34! '$.!

$%6$,*!;+,(.)!)3,,+-9!!

X%'7$.0! !"# $%9! NOP[QS! &%2(,+'.)! '$.!-.,+'%30&$%8! /.'1..0! 2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7*!

+0)! _9M9! +6-%7(,'(-.! /*! ,%05%06! '13! .73032.'-%7!

23).,&V! +! 2+7-3.73032%7! 23).,! +0)! +0!

+6-%7(,'(-+,!23).,!7+,,.)!B33)!+0)!:6-%7(,'(-+,!

A3,%7*!M%2(,+'3-9! T'! %&! +00(+,!23).,! %07,()%06!

1$.+'"!73-0"!&3-6$(2"!/+-,.*"!3+'&"!&3*/.+0&"!

&3*/.+0!2.+,"!&3*/.+0!3%,"!73''30"! -%7."!/..4"!

7$%75.0"! .66&"! '(-5.*&! +0)! )+%-*9! _0).-! '$.!

+,'.-0+'%;.! &7.0+-%3! 34! $%6$.-! 230.*! 6-31'$!

+0)!,31.-!/()6.'!).4%7%'&"!'$.!2+%0!&%2(,+'%30!

-.&(,'&! 1.-.! &(22+-%G.)! +&! 43,,31&9! :6-%7(,'(-+,!

).2+0)! %07-.+&.)9!Z30&(2.-! 433)!.<8.0)%'(-.&!

%07-.+&.)9! C.+01$%,."! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 8-3)(7'%30"!

0.'!4+-2!%0732.!+0)!4+-2,+0)!;+,(.&!%07-.+&.)9!!

b(&'!NOPP`S!43-2(,+'.)!+!23).,!34!'$.!

_9M9! 73-0"! &3-6$(2! +0)! &3*/.+0&! '$+'!

%07,().)! '$.! -3,.! 34! _9M9! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 83,%7%.&!

+0)!-.,+'.)! ,%;.&'375!2+-5.'&9!C.+01$%,."! '$.!

2+7-3.73032%7!.44.7'&!34!230.'+-*!+0)!4%&7+,!

83,%7*! +-.! .&'%2+'%06! (&%06! '$.! B:T\CY@JD!

23).,! 34! '$.! _9M9! 2+7-3.73032*9! #$.!

&8.7%4%7+'%30! 34! '$.&.! .K(+'%30&! /+&.&!

2+7-3.73032%7! 8$.032.0+! 30! 2%7-3.73032%7!

43(0)+'%30&9!#$.!2+%0!-.&(,'&!-.;.+,.)!'$+'!+0!

%07-.+&.! %0! 63;.-02.0'! .<8.0)%'(-.&! $+)! +!

83&%'%;.! .44.7'! 30! 23&'! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 8-%7.&!

%22.)%+'.,*! /('! '$+'! '$.! .44.7'! 73(,)! '(-0!

0.6+'%;.! 43-!&32.!73223)%'%.&! %0! '$.!&.730)!

*.+-9!!

! Y1%06! '3! '$.! %0%'%+'.)! ,%'.-+'(-."! '$.!

8-37.)(-.&! 34! A++-,/.-6! !"# $%9! NOP[aS! +-.!&'-+%6$'43-1+-)9! #$.! &738.! 34! '$.%-! &'()*!

-.2+%0&! '$.! 7307.8'! 34! +66-.6+'.! +6-%7(,'(-.!

%0&'.+)! 34! 73223)%'*! +&8.7'9! Y0! '$.! 30.!

$+0)"! '$.! 4-+2.13-5&!34!X%'7$.0!!"#$%9! NOP[QS!+0)!b(&'! NOPP`S!+-.! -+'$.-!&38$%&'%7+'.)9!#$.!

&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&!34! '$.&.! ,%'.-+'(-.&!+-.!+,&3!

-.,%+/,.! %0! '$.! 1+*! 34! ;+-%3(&! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

8-3)(7'&9! I30.'$.,.&&"! '$.*! 73(,)! $+;.! '13!

1.+50.&&!83%0'&9!B%-&',*"!'$.!&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&!

1.-.! /+&.)! 30! '$.! +00(+,! '%2.! &.-%.&! )+'+!

).&8%'.!'$.!+7'%30!34!230.'+-*!83,%7*!/+&%7+,,*!

0..).)! '3! .28,3*! '$.!K(+-'.-,*! )+'+9! #$.-.43-."!

'$.&.! ,%'.-+'(-.&! 2+*! 03'! 8.-43-2! 1.,,! 43-!

2+7-3.73032%7!83,%7*!2+5.-&9!M.730),*"!1%'$!

-.&8.7'! '3! '$.! )*0+2%7! +88-3+7$"! '$.%-!

.73032.'-%7!23).,!$+;%06!03!/.0.4%7%+,!(&.!%0!

'$.! 7307.8'! 34! %28(,&.! -.&830&.9! T0! 4+7'"! '$.!

%28+7'&! 34!230.'+-*! 83,%7%.&! +-.! '$.3-.'%7+,,*!

'+5.0! 43-! +! ,306.-! K(+-'.-9! d.07."! e.7'3-!

+('3-.6-.&&%30!23).,!Ne:\S!13(,)!/.!&(%'+/,.!

-+'$.-!'$+0!3-)%0+-*!-.6-.&&%30!23).,9!!!!!!!!!!!

:))%'%30+,,*"! '$.! -.;%.1! 34! 8-.;%3(&!

,%'.-+'(-.!%0!'$.!7+&.!34!).;.,38%06!73(0'-%.&!%&!

8-.&.0'.)!+&!43,,31&9!T0!'$.!7+&.!34!#+0G+0%+!

+0)!C+,+1%"!D38.G!!"#$%9! NOPPOS! 43-2(,+'.)!+!&%28,.! &'-(7'(-+,! 23).,! '3! 8-3;%).! %0&%6$'&!

+/3('! '$.! K(+0'%'+'%;.! %283-'+07.! 34! '$.!

;+-%3(&! 7$+00.,&! /*! 1$%7$! 63;.-02.0'! 83,%7%.&!

$+)!+44.7'.)!'$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!.<83-'+/,.!&.7'3-9!

#$.%-! &%2(,+'%30! -.&(,'! %0)%7+'.)! '$+'! 4%&7+,!

83,%7%.&! 1.-.! 03'! 0.('-+,! 1%'$! -.&8.7'! '3! '$.!

&'-(7'(-+,! 34! +6-%7(,'(-+,! 8-3)(7'%309' :,'$3(6$!

Page 39: Economic Journal Issue 5

!E[

'$.%-! -.&(,'&! &(883-'! '3! '$.! X.*0.&%+0=&!

8-383&%'%30"!'$.!'$.3-.'%7+,!23).,!34!'$%&!&'()*!

%&!).4%7%.0'! %0!'$.!2+7-3.73032%7!'$.3-*9!#$.!

;+-%+/,.!34!63;.-02.0'!&8.0)%06!30,*!-.8-.&.0'&!

+&!+!4%&7+,!83,%7*9!!!!

! H306&+5! Nc``OS! ).;.,38.)! +! &2+,,>

&7+,.!2+7-3.73032%7!23).,!43-!#$+%,+0)9!#$.!

&%2(,+'%30! -.&(,'&! %0)%7+'.)! '$+'! '$.! ).2+0)!

43-! ,+/3-! +0)! ?@A! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-!

%07-.+&.!31%06! '3! '$.! 4%&7+,!83,%7*!+&!1.,,! +&!

230.'+-*! 83,%7*9! :773-)%06! '3! '$.! '$.3-.'%7+,!

23).,"! '$%&! &'()*! %&! ).-%;.)! 4-32! X.*0.&%+0!

8.-&8.7'%;.9! #$.! 23).,! +,&3! 730&%).-&! '$.!

+6-%7(,'(-.! +&! '$.! %0)(&'-%+,! &.7'3-9! #$%&! 1+*!

-+'$.-! )%44.-&! 4-32! '$.! 8-.;%3(&! ,%'.-+'(-."! %9.9!

A++-,/.-6! !"# $%9! NOP[aS"! X%'7$.0! !"# $%9! NOP[QS!+0)! b(&'! NOPP`S9! I30.'$.,.&&"! '$%&! &'()*!

7307.0'-+'.)!30!30,*!'13!+6-%7(,'(-+,!;+-%+/,.&!

&3! '$+'! '$.! 3'$.-! ;+-%+/,.&"! %9.9! 433)! .<83-'!

+0)!730&(28'%30!+-.!K(.&'%30+/,.9!

HE' C+($,=-9%&' !.%I,<+.3' %()'

A-.9$-9.%&'*+),&'

#-+75%06! )310! '$.! 8-.;%3(&! ,%'.-+'(-.&"!

'$.!4-+2.13-5!1+&!3(',%0.)!%0!B%6(-.!O9!T'!1+&!

&7$.2+'%7+,,*!-.8-.&.0'.)!'$.!,%05+6.&!(0).-,*%06!

'$.!.44.7'&!34!4%&7+,!+0)!230.'+-*!83,%7*!2%<.&!

30! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! D.'! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-!

/.! +! &+'.,,%'.! 34! 2+7-3.73032*9! :773-)%06,*"!

'$.!4-+2.13-5!1+&!&.8+-+'.)!%0'3!'13!/,375&9!

#$.! 4%-&'! /,375! ).8%7'.)! '$.! 43-1+-)! ,%05+6.!

+2306! 63;.-02.0'! 730&(28'%30! &8.0)%06"!

230.*! &(88,*! +0)! 2+7-3.73032%7! ;+-%+/,.&9!

^+&.)! 30! '$.! '-+)%'%30+,! X.*0.&%+0! &7$33,"!

/3'$! 34! 63;.-02.0'! .<8.0)%'(-.! +0)! 230.*!

&(88,*! 1.-.! +,&3! '-.+'.)! +&! +0! .<36.03(&!

;+-%+/,.9! X.*0.&%+0! ;%.1! &'+'.)! '$+'! '$.*!

)%-.7',*! +0)! %0)%-.7',*! +44.7'.)! ?@A"! 8-%7.!

,.;.,"! +0)! %0'.-.&'! -+'.! &!"!'()# *$'(+,)9! #$.*!4(-'$.-! +44.7'.)! '$.! ;+,(.! 34! )32.&'%7! 7(--.07*9!

#$.&.! ;+-%+/,.&"! 1$%7$! %&! +! &3>7+,,.)!

f'-+0&2%&&%30! ;+-%+/,.g"! '-+0&4.-! 4-32! '$.! 4%-&'!

/,375!'3!'$.!&.730)!/,3759!

#$.! &.730)! /,375! 8-.&.0'.)! '$.!

-.,+'%30&$%8! /.'1..0! '-+0&2%&&%30! ;+-%+/,.&!

+0)! 2+%0! +66-.6+'.! ;+-%+/,.&! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-9! #$.&.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! ;+-%+/,.&! 1.-.!

7328-%&.)!34!433)!730&(28'%30"!433)!.<83-'!W!

%283-'"!.28,3*2.0'!W!7+8%'+,!&'375!+0)!6-3&&!

)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!%0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-9!#$.!

-.,+'%30&$%8!/.'1..0!'-+0&2%&&%30!;+-%+/,.!+0)!

+6-%7(,'(-+,!;+-%+/,.!%&!8-.&.0'.)!+&!43,,31&9!!

%S!?@A!13(,)!$+;.!83&%'%;.!%28+7'!30!

'$.!433)!730&(28'%30!+0)!%283-'9!!

%%S! A-%7.! ,.;.,! 13(,)! +44.7'! '$.! 433)!

730&(28'%30!+0)! %283-'!;%+!ZAT! 43-! 433)!+0)!

030433)9!!

%%%S! J<7$+06.! -+'.! 13(,)! +44.7'! '$.!

433)!.<83-'9!!

%;S! T0'.-.&'! -+'.! 13(,)! -.,+'.! '3! '$.!

7+8%'+,! &'375! +0)! .28,3*2.0'! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-!;%+!+!7+8%'+,!-.0'+,!-+'.9!!

;S! A-%7.! ,.;.,! 13(,)! -.,+'.! '3! '$.!

7+8%'+,! &'375! +0)! .28,3*2.0'! %0! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-!;%+!+!4+-2!8-%7.!%0).<9!!

Page 40: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! EP

;%S!T0'.-.&'!-+'.!+0)!8-%7.!,.;.,!13(,)!

-.,+'.! '3! 6-3&&! )32.&'%7! 8-3)(7'%30! %0! '$.!

+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!;%+!,+/3-!+0)!7+8%'+,!&'3759!

M(7$!4-+2.13-5!).;.,38.)!'13!'$.3-.'%7+,!

23).,&9! B%-&'! /,375! ).;.,38.)! '$.! &'-(7'(-+,!

23).,! 34! .&'%2+'%06! %28+7'&! 34! 63;.-02.0'!

730&(28'%30! &8.0)%06! +0)! 230.*! &(88,*! 30!

2+7-3.73032%7&! ;+-%+/,.&9! M.730)! /,375!

).;.,38.)! '$.! &'-(7'(-+,! 23).,! 34! .&'%2+'%06!

%28+7'&!34!'-+0&2%&&%30!;+-%+/,.!30!+66-.6+'.!

;+-%+/,.! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! +773-)%06! '3! T0!

+0)!C3(0'!NOPPaS9!#$.!7328,.'.!23).,"!1$%7$!%&!

&3>7+,,.)! 2+7-3.73032%7>+6-%7(,'(-+,! ,%05+6.!

23).,"!%&!'$.0!43-2(,+'.)!N#+/,.!OS9!

!

!

!"49.,':!Z307.8'(+,!4-+2.13-5!

!

?3;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!

.<8.0)%'(-.!

C30.*!&(88,*!

*%$.+,$+(+I/'

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'!

T0'.-.&'!A-%7.!,.;.,!

B33)! I30433)!

J<7$+06.!-+'.!

84."$9&-9.%&'

Z+8%'+,!-.0'+,!

-+'.!

J28,3*2.0'!+0)!

Z+8%'+,!&'375!

B33)!730&(28'%30! B33)!%283-'! B33)!.<83-'!

B+-2!8-%7.!

%0).<! ?-3&&!)32.&'%7!

8-3)(7'%30!

Page 41: Economic Journal Issue 5

!a`

JE'*,-6+)'%()'0.+$,)9.,'

! #$%&!&'()*!1+&!7328-%&.)!34!'$-..!&'.8&V!

.&'%2+'%30&! 34! .K(+'%30&"! 43-2(,+'%30! 34! 7328,.'.!

23).,!+0)!83,%7*!&%2(,+'%309!

A-,=:?' K#-"I%-"+(#' +L' ,M9%-"+(#E! #$.!

&%2(,'+0.3(&! .K(+'%30&! NJK9NOS! '3! JK9NQSS! 1.-.!

.&'%2+'.)!/*!'13>&'+6.! ,.+&'!&K(+-.&!2.'$3)9!#$.!

.0)36.03(&!;+-%+/,.&!730&%&'.)!34!h"!Z"!h)"!#"!T"!J<!

+0)!]9!#$.!.<36.03(&!;+-%+/,.!730&%&'.)!34!?"!M)"!

J"!\"!h4!+0)!A%289!Y'$.-!/.$+;%3-+,!.K(+'%30&!1.-.!

.&'%2+'.)!/*!3-)%0+-*!,.+&'!&K(+-.&!2.'$3)!N#+/,.!

OS9!#$.!&738.!34! '$%&!+0+,*&%&!1+&!/+&.)!30! '%2.!

&.-%.&!)+'+!)(-%06!'$.!4%-&'!K(+-'.-!34!OPPQ!'3!'$.!'$%-)!

K(+-'.-!34!c``a9!#$.!2+%0!&3(-7.&!34!)+'+!&.'&!1.-.!

^+05! 34! #$+%,+0)! +0)! Y44%7.! 34! '$.! I+'%30+,!

J73032%7&! +0)! M37%+,! @.;.,382.0'! ^3+-)!

N:88.0)%<!'+/,.S9!

A-,='>?'!+.I9&%-"+('+L'$+I=&,-,'I+),&E!

#$.!1$3,.!23).,!730&%&'.)!34!R! %).0'%'*!.K(+'%30&!

NJK9NOS"! NES"! N[S"! NOcS"! NOQS"! NOPSS!+0)!OR!/.$+;%3-+,!

.K(+'%30&9! T'!+,&3!730'+%0.)!cc!.0)36.03(&!Nh"!Z"!

h)"!#"!T"!J<"!]"!A"!A0+"!A+"!\0"!\"!J"!Z+"!Z4+"!J<+"!

#+"! A4+-2"! A'%,"! I+"! X+"! h+S! +0)! OE! .<36.03(&!

;+-%+/,.&!N?"!M)"!h4"!A%28"!\0%0/"!\4"!C&"!A+1"!A4+"!

A40+"! A5+"! "! H+S9! #$.! /+&.,%0.! 1+&! &3,;.)! /*!

?+(&&>M.%).,! +,63-%'$2! 43-! '$.! .0'%-.! 8.-%3)9! #$.!

23).,!1+&!.;+,(+'.)!/*!&%2(,+'%30!.--3-&9!

!

5%N&,':'*%$.+,$+(+I"$O%4."$9&-9.%&'&"(3%4,'

I+),&'

!A-.9$-9.%&'I+),&' KM9%-"+('

*%$.+,$+(+I"$'*+),&'

h'!i!Z'!j!T'!j!?'!j!J<'!>!]'!j!M)'!

Z'!i!4Nh)'S!

h)'!i!h'!k!#'!

#'!i!4Nh'S!

T'!i!4N\'"!h'S!

J<'!i!4NJ'"!h4'S!

]'!i!4Nh'"!A%28'"!J<'S!

A'!i!`9REPaA0+'!j!`9ER`RA+'!

A0+'!i!4N\'"!A%28'"!h'S!

A+'!i!4NA+1'"!A0+'S!

\0'!i!4N\0%0/'"!C&'"!h'S!

\'!i!\0'!k!NA'!>!A'>aSlA'>a!J'!i!4NN\'>\4'S"!NJ<'>]'SS!

!

84."$9&-9.%&'A,$-+.'*+),&'

Z+'!i!4NA+'"!h'"!A4+'"!A0+'"!A40+'"!S!

Z4+'!i!4NA4+'"!h'"!A40+'"!A+'"!A0+'"!S!

J<+'!i!4Nh4'"!J'S!

#+'!i!J<+'!>!Z4+'!

A4+-2'!i!4NA+1'!"!A0+'S'

A'%,'!i!A5+'mN\'!j! '!k!NA5+'!>!A5+'>aSlA5+'>aS!n!

I+'!i!4NH+'"!A4+-2'"!A'%,'S!

X+'!i!4NA'%,'"!A4+-2'"!H+'S!

h+'!i!4NI+'"!X+'S!

!

!

oNOS!

oNcS!

oNES!

oNaS!

oNFS!

oNRS!

oNQS!

oN[SO!

oNPS!

oNO`S!

oNOOS!

oNOcS!

oNOES!

!

oNOaS!

oNOFS!

oNORS!

oNOQS!

oNO[S!

oNOPSc!

oNc`S!

oNcOS!

oNccS!

I3'.V! ! O#$.!73.44%7%.0'!34!.K(+'%30! N[S! %&!)-+10! 4-32!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)9!! c#$.! ).8-.7%+'%30! -+'.! %&! +&&(2.)! '3! /.! O`!

8.-7.0'!8.-!*.+-9!

! e+-%+/,.!%).0'%4%7+'%30V!&..!:88.0)%<!#+/,.9!

Page 42: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! aO

A-,=' H?' 0+&"$/' #"I9&%-"+(E! X..8%06!

+,,! 3'$.-! '$%06&! 730&'+0'"! '$.! 63;.-02.0'!

730&(28'%30!&8.0)%06!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!1+&!

8,+*.)! +&! +! &$375! ;+-%+/,.! %0! '$.! +,'.-0+'%;.!

&7.0+-%3&9! #$.! F"! O`! +0)! OF! 8.-7.0'! %07-.+&.&!!

%0!'$.&.!&$375!;+-%+/,.&!1.-.!-.&8.7'%;.,*!&.'!!

(8!43-!&7.0+-%3!T"!&7.0+-%3!TT"!+0)!&7.0+-%3!TTT!

43-!.;.-*!K(+-'.-!3;.-!'$.!4%-&'!K(+-'.-!34!OPP[!

'3! '$.! '$%-)! K(+-'.-! 34! c``a9! #$.! &%2(,+'.)!

;+,(.!34!+,'.-0+'%;.!&7.0+-%3!%&!'$.0!&3,;.)!/*!

?+(&&>M.%).,!+,63-%'$29!B3-'(0+'.,*"!'$.!8-37.)(-.&!

1.-.!%073-83-+'.)!%0!Je%.1&!&34'1+-.9!

!

'

!!

!"49.,'>!#-+0&2%&&%30!7$+00.,&!34!&$375!;+-%+/,.&!N?!+0)!C&S!-(0!'$-3(6$!+6-%7(,'(-+,!;+-%+/,.!

!

I3'.V!!!!!!!!!!i!J<36.03(&!;+-%+/,.!+0)!!!!!!!!!!!! i!J0)36.03(&!;+-%+/,.!

Page 43: Economic Journal Issue 5

!ac

5%N&,'H'A"I9&%-"+(',..+.#'+L'I%P+.',()+4,(+9#'G%."%N&,#'

!

Q/(%I"$O),-,.I"("#-"$'#"I9&%-"+('R:SST?UF'-+'>VVJ?UFFFW'

!"#$%&'()$*'($+,&-"%."/0',&*,%(',..+.'

RXW'

B*AK''

RXW'

56,"&'

"(,M9%&"-/'

$+,LL"$",(-'

J<8.0)%'(-.!30!?@A!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!

I+'%30!%0;.&'2.0'!

J<83-'!34!633)&!+0)!&.-;%7.&!

T283-'!34!633)&!+0)!&.-;%7.&!

I32%0+,!%0'.-.&'!-+'.!

\.+,!.44.7'%;.!.<7$+06.!-+'.!

Z30&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<!

Z30&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<!43-!030433)!

Z30&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<!43-!433)!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!43-!433)!

B33)!.<83-'!!

B33)!%283-'!!!

J28,3*2.0'!%0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!

Z+8%'+,!&'375!%0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!%0!+6-%7(,'(-.!

O9c`Q!

O9P``!

O9`O`!

O9aOF!

O9PEP!

!!!!!!!>O9FEE!

!!!!!!!>c9P[c!

!!!!!!!>`9`Fc!

`9QaR!

!!!!!!!>O9cRR!

O9RQa!

a9OEE!

Q9RFE!

!!!!!!!>`9OOc!

`9ccO!

a9P[P!

c9OcR!

c9[aa!

a9`QQ!

c9ORP!

E9ROE!

F9cFR!

E9Qaa!

`9P[E!

O9FQa!

c9c`Q!

c9RF[!

Q9QRP!

!!!!!!!O`9ROR!

O9EaF!

`9RcO!

F9[Qa!

`9`OO!

`9`Oa!

`9`OP!

`9`OE!

`9`O[!

`9`c[!

`9`O[!

`9``F!

`9``[!

`9`OO!

`9`OE!

`9`ac!

`9`FQ!

`9``Q!

`9``E!

`9`EO!

I3'.V!C.+0!.--3-!i! 100*yyyn1 n

1tttt "!\CMJ!N\33'!2.+0!&K(+-.!.--3-S!i!

100*yyyn1 n

1tttt

"!#$.%,!%0.K(+,%'*!73.44%7%.0'!i!n

1t

2t

n

1t

2t

n

1t

2tt

yn1y

n1

yyn1

!

!

YE'B,#9&-'%()'Q"#$9##"+('

! #$.!.&'%2+'%30!-.&(,'&!34!2+7-3.73032%7>

+6-%7(,'(-+,!,%05+6.!23).,!$+;.!23-.!8-.&.0'+'%30!

%0!'$.!:88.0)%<!#+/,.!c9!:4'.-1+-)"!%'!%&!.;+,(+'.)!

/*! '$.! &%2(,+'%30! .--3-&! 34! &*&'.2! N#+/,.! ES9!

#$.&.! .--3-&! -.8-.&.0'! +&! '$.! 7328+-%&30!

/.'1..0! /+&.,%0.! +0)! +7'(+,! ;+,(.9! #$.! -33'!

2.+0!&K(+-.!.--3-!34!2+L3-!.0)36.03(&!;+-%+/,.&!

-.;.+,!'$+'!'$.%-&!;+,(.&!;+-*!/.'1..0!+88-3<%2+'.,*!

O!+0)!O`!8.-7.0'9!Z30&.K(.0',*"!#$.%,! T0.K(+,%'*!

73.44%7%.0'&! +-.! ,.&&! '$+0! 3-! .K(+,! '3! `9`FQ9!

#$.*! %0)%7+'.! '$+'! '$.! &*&'.2! 34! 7328,.'.!

23).,!%&!+88-38-%+'.!43-!83,%7*!&%2(,+'%309!!

Page 44: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! aE

! :&!'$.!&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&"! '$.!.<8+0).)!

63;.-02.0'! 730&(28'%30! &8.0)%06! 73(8,.)! 1%'$!

+77.,.-+'%30! %0!230.*!&(88,*!6-31'$!&%60%4%7+0',*!

+44.7'&! '$.! 2+7-3.73032%7! ;+-%+/,.&V! -.+,!

?@A"! 8-%7.! ,.;.,"! -.+,! %0'.-.&'! -+'."! +0)! -.+,!

.44.7'%;.! .<7$+06.! -+'.9! :0)! '$.0"! '$.&.!

'-+0&2%&&%30! ;+-%+/,.&! +44.7'! '$.! .0)36.03(&!

;+-%+/,.&! %0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-9!#$.%-&! %28+7'&!

30! 5.*! .73032%7! %0)%7+'3-&! 34! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-!+-.!&(22+-%G.)!%0!#+/,.!a9!!

5%N&,'J''B,#9&-'+L'=+&"$/'.,=&"$%-"+('

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''_0%'!V!C%,,%30!/+$'!+'!730&'+0'!8-%7.!

84."$9&-9.%&'#,$-+.' @%#,&"(,'G%&9,' B,=&"$%-,)'G%&9,' X'C6%(4,'

+9!cp!%07-.+&.!%0!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!43-!433)!!

B33)!.<83-'!!

B33)!%283-'!!

#-+).!+773(0'!

J28,3*2.0'!N'$3(&+0)!8.-&30&S!

Z+8%'+,!&'375!!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!

ZAT!43-!433)!NOP[[iO``S!

O`c"PQF9aE!!

!RQ"Fa[9FQ!!

!Oa"c[`9aE!!

!FE"cR[9``!!

!OE"[EF9cP!!

!aEO"RP[9QO!!

!Q["Oa`9Oa!!

!OPP9RE!

O`E"FFc9Pa!!

!RQ"ROQ9FP!!

!Oa"ERP9QR!!

!FE"caQ9P[!!

!OE"[Ec9Oc!!

!aEc"Oa`9[O!!

!Q["EQQ9R`!!

!OPP9[`!

`9FQp!

`9O`p!

`9RRp!

>`9`ap!

>`9`cp!

`9O`p!

`9EOp!

`9`Pp!

/9!ap!%07-.+&.!%0!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!43-!433)!!

B33)!.<83-'!!

B33)!%283-'!!

#-+).!+773(0'!

J28,3*2.0'!N'$3(&+0)!8.-&30&S!

Z+8%'+,!&'375!!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!

ZAT!43-!433)!NOP[[iO``S!

O`c"PQF9aE!!

!RQ"Fa[9FQ!!

!Oa"c[`9aE!!

!FE"cR[9``!!

!OE"[EF9cP!!

!aEO"RP[9QO!!

!Q["Oa`9Oa!!

!OPP9RE!!

O`a"OcF9cP!!

!RQ"R[F9``!!

!Oa"aF[9``!!

!FE"ccQ9Oa!!

!OE"[cP9Oa!!

!aEc"FQO9FQ!!

!Q["R`P9``!!

!OPP9PQ!!

O9OEp!

`9c`p!

O9Ecp!

>`9`[p!

>`9`ap!

`9c`p!

`9ROp!

`9OQp!

79![p!%07-.+&.!%0!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!43-!433)!!

B33)!.<83-'!!

B33)!%283-'!!

#-+).!+773(0'!

J28,3*2.0'!N'$3(&+0)!8.-&30&S!

Z+8%'+,!&'375!!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!

ZAT!43-!433)!NOP[[iO``S!

O`c"PQF9aE!!

!RQ"Fa[9FQ!!

!Oa"c[`9aE!!

!FE"cR[9``!!

!OE"[EF9cP!!

!aEO"RP[9QO!!

!Q["Oa`9Oa!!

!OPP9RE!

O`F"cFQ9``!!

!RQ"[Oa9QO!!

!Oa"REO9[R!!

!FE"O[E9``!!

!OE"[cE9[R!!

!aEE"a`c9[R!!

!QP"`FQ9``!!

!c``9EO!

c9cap!

`9E[p!

c9ROp!

>`9OQp!

>`9`[p!

`9a`p!

O9OPp!

`9EFp!

I3'.!V! #$.!4%6(-.&!-.8-.&.0'!+&!'$.!+;.-+6.!;+,(.!4-32!'$.!4%-&'!K(+-'.-!34!OPP[!&%2(,+'%30!*.+-!'$-3(6$!'$.!'$%-)!

K(+-'.-!34!c``a9!

M3(-7.V!:('$3-=&!7328('+'%30!

Page 45: Economic Journal Issue 5

!aa

KLL,$-'+('L++)'$+(#9I=-"+(',1=,()"-9.,?!

Y0! '$.! +;.-+6."! +,'$3(6$! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0!

63;.-02.0'! 730&(28'%30! &8.0)%06! +0)! 230.*!

&(88,*!,.+)!'3!'$.!%07-.+&.!%0!730&(2.-!8-%7.!

%0).<! 43-! 433)!+&!1.,,! +&! -.+,!?@A"! '$.! 433)!

730&(28'%30! .<8.0)%'(-.&! %07-.+&.! 3;.-! '$.!

'$-..! &%2(,+'%30! *.+-&9! #$%&! %&! /.7+(&.! '$.!

+/&3,('.! ;+,(.! 34! 310>8-%7.! .,+&'%7%'*! 34! 433)!

730&(28'%30! %&! 3/;%3(&,*! ,.&&! '$+0! '$.! -.+,!

%0732.! .,+&'%7%'*! -.6+-)%06! '$.! .&'%2+'%30!

-.&(,'! 34! /.$+;%3-+,! .K(+'%309! #$.-.43-."! '$.!

)+2+6.!34!433)!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!'$+'!

%&!).-%;.)!4-32!%04,+'%30!%&!03'!&.;.-.9!!

KLL,$-' +(' L++)' "I=+.-' %()' ,1=+.-?!

Y0! '$.! +;.-+6."! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0! 63;.-02.0'!

730&(28'%30! .<8.0)%'(-.! +0)! 230.*! &(88,*!

,.+)&! '3! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0! 433)! %283-'! 3;.-! '$.!

&%2(,+'%30! *.+-&! '$-3(6$! -.+,! ?@A! +&! +0!

%283-'+0'! '-+0&2%&&%30! ;+-%+/,.9! :'! '$.! &+2.!

'%2."! '$.! .<8+0&%30! 34! '$.&.! 83,%7*! ;+-%+/,.&!

,.+)&! '3! %07-.+&.! 433)! .<83-'! 3;.-! '$.!

&%2(,+'%30! *.+-&! '$-3(6$! '$.! '-+0&2%&&%30!

;+-%+/,.! 34! -.+,! .44.7'%;.! .<7$+06.! -+'.9!

_043-'(0+'.,*"! '$.! %07-.+&.)! 433)! %283-'! $+&!

$.+;*! %28.'(&!-+'$.-! '$+0! '$.! %07-.+&.)!433)!

.<83-'9! T'! 0.6+'%;.,*!+44.7'&! '$.! '-+).!+773(0'!

43-! 433)9! I.;.-'$.,.&&"! (8! '3! 031! #$+%,+0)! $+&!

/..0!50310!+&!+6-%7(,'(-+,!.<83-'.-9!#$(&"!%'&!

)+2+6.! $+&! L(&'! -.&(,'.)! %0! '$.! &(-8,(&! 34!

'-+).!+773(0'9!

KLL,$-' +(' 4.+##' )+I,#-"$' =.+)9$-"+('

"(' %4."$9&-9.,?! Y0! '$.! +;.-+6."! 31%06! '3!

.<8+0&%30!34!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!

73(8,.)! 1%'$! 230.*! &(88,*"! '$.! 4+-2! 8-%7.!

%0).<! %07-.+&.&! ).&8%'.! '$.! 4+7'! '$+'! '$.! 7+8%'+,!

-.0'+,!-+'.!).7-.+&.&9!T'!,.+)&!'3!'$.!7+8%'+,!&'375!

%0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!3/;%3(&,*! %07-.+&.&!3;.-!

'$.! &%2(,+'%30! *.+-&9! Y0! '$.! 3'$.-! $+0)"! '$.!

.28,3*2.0'! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! ).7-.+&.&!

/.7+(&.! '$.! .44.7'! 34! 4+-2! 8-%7.! .,+&'%7%'*! 34!

,+/3-! ).2+0)! %&! )32%0+'.)! /*! '$.! .44.7'! 34!

7-3&&>8-%7.! .,+&'%7%'*9! :&! +! 730&.K(.07."! '$.!

6-3&&! )32.&'%7! 8-3)(7'%30! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-!

%07-.+&.&!'$-3(6$!'$.!7$+00.,!34!'13!%08('&9!T'!

%&!4(-'$.-!&'+'.)!'$+'!'$.!%04,+'%30!%&!+);+0'+6.!

43-!6-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%309!

:&!7328+-%06!1%'$!'$.!-.,+'.)!,%'.-+'(-.&"!

'$.!&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&!34! '$%&!&'()*!+-.!3;.-+,,!

730&%&'.0'!1%'$!X%'7$.0!!"#$%9!NOP[QS"!A++-,/.-6!!"# $%9! NOP[aS! +0)! b(&'! NOPP`S! %0! '$.!1+*! '$+'!'$.!2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7%.&! $+;.! &%60%4%7+0',*!

(0%0'.0).)! .44.7'&! 30! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9!

C3-.! &8.7%4%7+,,*"! #$+%,+0)=&! +6-%7(,'(-+,! ?@A!

%28+7'&! 34! 4%&7+,! +0)! 230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<!

73043-2.)!'3!'$.!%04.-.07.!34!H306&+5!Nc``OS9!!

U(+0'%'+'%;.,*"! '$.!/.0.4%'&!34!#$+%,+0)=&!

+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-"!1$%7$!+-.!6+%0.)! 4-32! '$.!

4%&7+,! +0)! 230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<"! +-.! 03'!

8-32%0.0'! N#+/,.! aS9! #$.! &%2(,+'%30! -.&(,'&!

&$3(,)! /.! 03'%7.)! '$+'! '$.! 433)! 730&(28'%30!

+0)!%283-'!%28+7'&!34!.<8+0&%30+-*!83,%7*!+-.!

23-.! /.0.4%'! -+'$.-! '$+0! 6-3&&! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

8-3)(7'%309!#$%&! %&! /.7+(&.! '$.!83,%7*! ;+-%+/,.&V!

63;.-02.0'!.<8.0)%'(-.!+0)!230.*!&(88,*!+44.7'!

6-3&&! )32.&'%7! 8-3)(7'%30! %0! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-! '$-3(6$! &.;.-+,! )%&'+0'! 7$+00.,&9!

B(-'$.-23-."! '$.! 2+7-3.73032%7>+6-%7(,'(-+,!

,%05+6.!23).,! %&! /+&.)! 30! '$.! /+&%7! X.*0.&%+0!

Page 46: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! aF

8.-&8.7'%;.9!#$%&!&7$33,!34!'$3(6$'!%&!&'-306,*!

/.,%.;.)!%0!'$.!1+*!34!).2+0)!2+0+6.2.0'!%0!

'$.!&$3-'! -(0! %0&'.+)!34! '$.!&(88,*!2+0+6.2.0'!

%0!'$.!,306!-(09!!!

Y0! '$.! 30.! $+0)"! '$.! 433)! .<83-'!

%28+7'! 34! 4%&7+,! +0)! 230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<!

&..2&!'3!/.!K(.&'%30+/,.9!T'!&$3(,)!/.!4(-'$.-!

)%&7(&&.)!+&!43,,31&9!H%'$!-.&8.7'!'3!'-+0&2%&&%30!

7$+00.,"!'$.!-.+,!.44.7'%;.!.<7$+06.!-+'.!N\JJ\S!

,%05&! '$.!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!&8.0)%06!+0)!

230.*! &(88,*! '3! '$.! 433)! .<83-'9! H$.0! '$.!

.<8+0&%30+-*! 4%&7+,! 83,%7*! 732/%0.)! 1%'$!

+77.,.-+'%30! %0! 230.*! &(88,*! 6-31'$! %&! ('%,%G.)"!

30! '$.! +;.-+6."! \JJ\! ).7-.+&.&! 3;.-! '$.!

&%2(,+'%30!*.+-!3-!%0!3'$.-!13-)!'$.!#$+%!^+$'!

).8-.7%+'.&9! #$%&! %07%).0'! ,.+)&! '3! -+%&.! '$.!

433)! .<83-'9! I.;.-'$.,.&&"! #$+%! ^+$'! 7+0! /.!

+88-.7%+'.)! +773-)%06! '3! '$.! &'+0)+-)! C(0).,,>

B,.2%06!23).,9!!

H$.0! '$.! .<8+0&%30+-*! 4%&7+,! +0)!

230.'+-*! 83,%7*!2%<! %&! ('%,%G.)"! '$.! -.+,!?@A!

+0)! )32.&'%7! %0'.-.&'! -+'.! -+%&.&9! T07-.+&.!

-.+,!?@A! ,.+)! '3! %07-.+&.! %283-'!34!633)&!W!

&.-;%7.&9!#$.!7(--.0'!+773(0'! %&!&(/&.K(.0',*!

13-&.0!&!"!'()#*$'(+,)9!:'! '$.!&+2.!'%2."! '$.!%07-.+&.! %0! )32.&'%7! %0'.-.&'! -+'.! ,.+)! '3! '$.!

%07-.+&.!%0!7+8%'+,!%04,31"!+0)!'$.!7+8%'+,!+773(0'!

%&! '$.0! %28-3;.)!&!"!'()#*$'(+,)9!Y1%06!'3! '$.&.!%07%).07.&"! '$.! )32.&'%7! 7(--.07*! 7+0! /.!

+88-.7%+'.)! 3-! ).8-.7%+'.)! 1%'$! '$.! 4,.<%/,.!

.<7$+06.!-+'.!-.6%2.9!B%-&',*"!%4!'$.!%28.'(&!34!

13-&.0%06!7(--.0'!+773(0'!%&!)32%0+'.)!/*!'$.!

43-7.! 34! %28-3;%06! 7+8%'+,! +773(0'"! '$.0! '$.!

%07-.+&.! %0!).2+0)!43-! 43-.%60!7(--.07%.&!1%,,!

/.! ,.&&!'$+0!'$.! %07-.+&.! %0!&(88,*!34! 43-.%60!

7(--.07%.&9! T'! ,.+)&! '3! +0! +88-.7%+'%30! %0! '$.!

)32.&'%7! 7(--.07*! %0! 3-).-! '3! '$.! /+,+07.! 34!

8+*2.0'!+773(0'!730)%'%309!T0!3'$.-!13-)"!'$.!

.<7$+06.! -+'.!).7,%0.&! -.6+-)%06! '$.!.K(%,%/-%(2!

34! 43-.%60! .<7$+06.! 2+-5.'9! M.730),*"! %4! '$.!

%28.'(&! 34! 13-&.0%06! 7(--.0'! +773(0'! %&! 6-.+'.-!

'$+0!'$.! 43-7.!34! %28-3;%06!7+8%'+,!+773(0'"! '$.0!

'$.! %07-.+&.! %0!).2+0)!43-! 43-.%60!7(--.07%.&!

1%,,! /.!6-.+'.-! '$+0! '$.! %07-.+&.! %0!&(88,*!34!

43-.%60!7(--.07%.&9!T'!,.+)&!'3!+!).8-.7%+'%30!%0!

'$.! )32.&'%7! 7(--.07*! 43-! /+,+07%06! 8+*2.0'!

+773(0'! 730)%'%309! #$+'! %&! '$.! .<7$+06.! -+'.!

-+%&.&!1%'$!'$.!.K(%,%/-%(2!34!43-.%60!.<7$+06.!

2+-5.'9!!

T0! &(2"! 03'1%'$&'+0)%06! '$.! '$.3-.'%7+,!

23).,! %0)%7+'.&! '$+'! '$.! .<7$+06.! -+'.! 7+0!!

%07-.+&.! 3-! ).7-.+&."! '$.! .28%-%7+,! .;%).07.!

34! '$%&! &'()*! $+&! +,-.+)*! /..0! %0;.&'%6+'.)9!

Y0! '$.! +;.-+6."! '$.! &%2(,+'.)! -.&(,'! 34! '$%&!

&'()*! 7+0! /.! ).7,+-.)! '$+'! %&! 730&%&'.0'!1%'$!

'$.!&.730)!7+&.!+&!2.0'%30.)!.+-,%.-9!!

!

ZE'A9II%./'

:6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!13(,)!+44.7'!03'!30,*!

/*! '$.!83,%7%.&! &8.7%4%7+,,*! ).&%60.)! 43-! %'! /('!

+,&3!/*!'$.!4%&7+,!+0)!230.'+-*!83,%7*!2%<9!T'!,.+)&!

'$%&! +-'%7,.! '3! '$.! K(.&'%30! 34! $31!2(7$! '$%&!

2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7*! +);+0'+6.&! '3! #$+%,+0)=&!

+6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! ^+&.)! 30! '$.! 8-.;%3(&!

,%'.-+'(-.&"! '$.! 4-+2.13-5! %&! 3(',%0.)9! T'! %&!

&7$.2+'%7+,,*!-.8-.&.0'.)!'$.!,%05+6.&!(0).-,*%06!

'$.! .44.7'&! 34! 63;.-02.0'! &8.0)%06! +0)!230.*!

Page 47: Economic Journal Issue 5

!aR

&(88,*! 30! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! D.'! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-! /.! +0! 3('&%).! 34! 2+7-3.73032%7!

23).,9!#$.-.43-."! '$.!4-+2.13-5!34! '$%&!&'()*!

%&! )%;%).)! %0'3! '13! /,375&9! #$.! 4%-&'! /,375!

).8%7'&! '$.! 43-1+-)! ,%05+6.! +2306! 63;.-02.0'!

730&(28'%30! .<8.0)%'(-."! 230.*! &(88,*! +0)!

2+7-3.73032%7! ;+-%+/,.&9! #$.! &.730)! /,375!

).8%7'&! '$.! -.,+'%30&$%8! /.'1..0!2+7-3.73032%7!

;+-%+/,.&!+0)!5.*!.73032%7!%0)%7+'3-&!34!+6-%7(,'(-.9!

#$.&.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! ;+-%+/,.&! 730&%&'! 34! 433)!

730&(28'%30"!433)!.<83-'!W!%283-'"!.28,3*2.0'!W!

7+8%'+,!&'375!+0)!6-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!%0!

+6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-9! #$.! .&'%2+'%30! -.&(,'&! 34!

/.$+;%3-+,! .K(+'%30&! 730&%60! '$.! 7328,.'.!

23).,! '3! 1$3,,*! &+'%&4+7'3-*! -.&(,'&! 34! 83,%7*!

&%2(,+'%309!#$.!.&'%2+'.)!8+-+2.'.-&!+-.!'$.0!

('%,%G.)!43-!83,%7*!&%2(,+'%309!H$.0!'$.!%07-.+&.!%0!

'$.!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!73(8,.)!

1%'$! +77.,.-+'%30! %0! 230.*! &(88,*! 6-31'$! %&!

).230&'-+'.)"!'$.%-!%28+7'&!30!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!

+-.!7307,().)! %0! '.-2&!34!8.-7.0'+6.!7$+06.!

4-32!/+&.,%0.!;+,(.!+&!43,,31&9!B33)!730&(28'%30"!

.<83-'!+0)! %283-'! %07-.+&.9!d31.;.-"! &(-8,(&!

34!'-+).!/+,+07.!43-!433)!%&!13-&.09!J28,3*2.0'!%0!

+6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! ).7-.+&.&"! 1$%,.! 7+8%'+,! &'375!

%0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! %07-.+&.&9! ?-3&&! )32.&'%7!

8-3)(7'%30! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,! &.7'3-! &(/&.K(.0',*!

%07-.+&.&9!!

:773-)%06! '3! '$.! &%2(,+'%30! -.&(,'&"!

'$.! 4%&7+,! +0)! 230.'+-*! 83,%7*! 2%<! $+&! +0!

(0%0'.0).)! .44.7'! 30! #$+%,+0)=&! +6-%7(,'(-."!

+,'$3(6$!'$.!230.*!%&!03'!)%-.7',*!%0L.7'.)!%0'3!

'$.!+6-%7(,'(-.9!#$.!&%2(,+'%30!-.&(,'&!%0)%7+'.!

'$+'! '$%&! &8.0)%06!7+0! 4,31! '3! '$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-! ;%+! &.;.-+,! 7$+00.,&9! I.;.-'$.,.&&"! %'!

&$3(,)! /.! 03'%7.)! '$+'! '$.! +6-%7(,'(-+,! .73032%7!

%28+7'&! 34! 2+7-3.73032%7! 83,%7*! +-.! -+'$.-!

'-%;%+,! 8+-'%7(,+-,*! 6-3&&! 8-3)(7'%30! %28+7'&"!

+,'$3(6$!'$.!83,%7*!;+-%+/,.&!+-.!%07-.+&.)!/*!

[! 8.-7.0'9! #$%&! %&! /.7+(&.! '$.&.! %28+7'&! 732.!

4-32!&.;.-+,!)%&'+0'!7$+00.,&9!H%'$%0!'$.!.73032%7!

.44.7'&"! '$.! 433)! 730&(28'%30! %28+7'&! 34! 83,%7*!

+-.!-.,+'%;.,*!3('&'+0)%069!#$%&!%&!/.7+(&.!'$.!

&'-(7'(-+,! 23).,! %&! 437(&.)! 30! '$.! ).2+0)!

2+0+6.2.0'! %0! '$.! &$3-'>-(0! 8.-%3)&! -.6+-)%06!

'$.!X.*0.&%+0!;%.19!!

!

[E'2"I"-%-"+('+L'-6,'#-9)/'

! :&!.+-,%.-!&..0!%0!'$.!&.7'%30!34!,%'.-+'(-.!

-.;%.1"! +,'$3(6$! '13! ,%2%'+'%30&! 34! 8-.;%3(&!

-.&.+-7$>>!'$.!7307.8'!34!+66-.6+'.!,.;.,!%0&'.+)!

34!73223)%'*!+&8.7'!+&!1.,,!+&!)*0+2%7!-.&830&.!

34!2+7-3.73032%7!83,%7%.&>>$+;.!+,-.+)*!/..0!

7-%'%7%G.)"! '$%&! +-'%7,.! 7+0! 03'! 63! 4(-'$.-! 1%'$!

'$%&! &$3-'732%06! )(.! '3! '$.! 8-.,%2%0+-*! ;.-&%309!

#$.-.43-."!'$.&.!%&&(.&!1%,,!-.5%0),.!'$.!4('(-.!

-.&.+-7$!34!#$+%,+0)9!T0!+))%'%30"!'$.!&$3-'732%06!

34! '$%&!&'()*!7307.-0&!'$.!23).,%06!+88-3+7$!

+&!43,,31&9!!

! #$.!4(07'%30!34!6-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'%30!

4+7.)!1%'$! '$.!730&'-+%0'!34! '13! 4+7'3-! %08('&V!

,+/3-!+0)!7+8%'+,!&'3759! T'!13(,)!/.!K(.&'%30+/,.!

/.7+(&.! '$.! 3'$.-! 4+7'3-! %08('&! &(7$! +&! -+%04+,,!

+0)!4.-'%,%G.-!&$3(,)!/.!730&%).-.)9!:8+-'!4-32!

'$%&"!'$.!+6-%7(,'(-+,!8-3)(7'%30!%&!377+&%30+,,*!

6.0.-+'.)! '$.! &'+'.! 34! /.%06! 83,,('.)"! .&8.7%+,,*!

'$.!730'+2%0+'%30!34!&3%,"!1+'.-"!3-!'$.!+'23&8$.-.!

Page 48: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! aQ

/*! '$.!)%&7$+-6.!34! $+-24(,! &(/&'+07.&9!#$%&!

.<'.-0+,%'*!+44.7'&!0.6+'%;.,*!'$.!2+7-3.73032*9!!

! #$.! &(88,*! 34! ,+/3-! %0! +6-%7(,'(-+,!

&.7'3-! %&! -.&'-%7'.)! '3! /.! %0.,+&'%7%'*! 1%'$!

-.&8.7'!'3!'$.!1+6.9!#$.3-.'%7+,,*!&8.+5%06"!%0!

'$.! 730&(28'%30! &.7'3-"! '$.! $3(&.$3,)! +6.0'!

&..5&! +0! 38'%2+,! 730&(28'%30! 8,+0! 3;.-! '$.!

%04%0%'.! '%2.! $3-%G309! #$.! 38'%2+,! ).2+0)!

730)%'%30&! 43-! 73223)%'%.&! +-.! '$.0! ).-%;.)9!

C.+01$%,."!'$.!38'%2+,!).2+0)!730)%'%30&!43-!

4%0+07%+,!+&&.'!+0)!38'%2+,!,.;.,!34!,.%&(-.!+-.!

).-%;.)9!T0!3'$.-!13-)&"!'$.!&(88,*!34!,+/3-!%&!

.;.0'(+,,*!.&'+/,%&$.)9!I30.'$.,.&&"!'$.!23).,%06!

34! ,+/3-! &(88,*! %&! -+'$.-! &38$%&'%7+'.)9! T'! &$3(,)!

/.!4(-'$.-!%0;.&'%6+'%30!43-!'$.!4('(-.!-.&.+-7$9!

! H%'$! -.&8.7'! '3! '$.! '$.3-.'%7+,!

237-3.73032%7!23).,"!'$.!23).,%06!+88-3+7$!

$+&! '3! 4+7.! 1%'$! '$.! 730&%).-+/,.! 7$3%7.! 34!

2+7-3.73032%7!&7$33,9!#$.! 4('(-.!&'()*!2+*!

43-2(,+'.! '$.! 23).,! -.6+-)%06! '$.! 0.1!

2+7-3.73032%7!&7$33,!34!'$3(6$'9!T'!%&!7307.8'(+,,*!

).-%;.)!4-32!'$.!2%7-343(0)+'%30!&(7$!+&!I.1!

Z,+&&%7+,!M7$33,!+0)!I.1!X.*0.&%+0!M7$33,9!!

!

B,L,.,($,#'

^33'"!Z9!!?9"!H9!!B.%/.&"!+0)!b9!!d9!!Z9!!D%&2+09!!OPRQ9!!

B(-'$.-! Z322.0'&! 30! '[email protected]%;+'%30&! 34!

U(+-'.-,*! B%6(-.&! 4-32! :00(+,! @+'+9!!

-**%(!.# /"$"()"(&)9! ORV! RF>RQ9! 7%'.)!T0'$%&+06"! b9! PP[9! 01!# 2&3435(&#6%,&",$"(34#$4.# 7")#8'(9(4# (4#01$(%$4."##C+&'.-! 34! :-'! #$.&%&! %0! J73032%7&"!

#$+22+&+'!_0%;.-&%'*9!!

Z$3."!h9!!Z9!!OP[P9!!:!&(-;.*!34!C+7-3.73032%7&!+0)!

:6-%7(,'(-.9!!:$)"!'#3;#/&(!4&!#01!)()#(4# -9'(&,%",'$%# 2&3435(&)"! C%7$%6+0!M'+'.!_0%;.-&%'*9!

b(&'"! \9! OPP`9! :0+,*G%06! '$.! J44.7'&! 34! _9M9!

C+7-3.73032%7!A3,%7*!30!_9M9!:6-%7(,'(-.!

_&%06!'$.!_M:?CX#M!C3).,!q30,%0.r9!!

:;+,%+/,.!V!111>1)&913-,)/+0593-69!!c``Q9!

T0!B9!!+0)!#9!!C3(0'9!!OPPa9!!@*0+2%7!C+7-3.73032%7#<(4=$9!)# "3# "1!# -9'(&,%",'$%# /!&"3'9'J06,+0)V!:;./(-*9!

X%'7$.0"! b9"! M9! ! D+06,.*"!\9! !C30+73"! +0)! b9!!

C9!!A-%7.9!!OP[Q9!!J44.7'&!34!C30.'+-*!

+0)!B%&7+,!A3,%7*!30!_9M9!:6-%7(,'(-.9!!

-9'(&,%",'$%# 74;3'5$"(34# >,%%!"(4"! I39!FOQ"! _0%'.)! M'+'.&! @.8+-'2.0'! 34!

:6-%7(,'(-.9!

D38.G"!\9"!\9!!:,%"!+0)! 9!!D+-&.09!OPPO9!!d31!#-+).!

+0)!J73032%7!A3,%7%.&!:44.7'!:6-%7(,'(-.V!:!

4-+2.13-5!43-!:0+,*&%&!:88,%.)!'3!#+0G+0%+!

+0)! C+,+1%9! q30,%0.r9! ! :;+%,%+/,.V! ! 111>

1)&913-,)/+0593-69!!c``Q9!

A++-,/.-6"!A9!!D9"!:9!!b9!!H.//"!:9!!C3-.*"!+0)!b9!!:9!!

M$+-8,.&9!!OP[a9!!T28+7'&!34!A3,%7*!30!_9M9!

:6-%7(,'(-+,!#-+).9!!T0'.-0+'%30+,!J73032%7&!

@%;%&%30"!_M@:9!

A%+28%'%"!M9!!OP[F9!!?!539'$*1(&#0!&14(@,!)9!!^+06535V!A+88%2!T079!!N%0!#$+%S!7%'.)!

Z$+-3.05%''+*+1('"!M9!!c``O9!!01!#75*$&")#3;#A1$49!)# (4# B3C!'45!4"# 2D*!4.(",'!# 34#:$&'3!&3435(&#E$'($+%!)#(4#01$(%$4.9!!C+&'.-! 34! M7%.07.! %0! J73032%7&"!

X+&.'&+-'!_0%;.-&%'*9!N%0!#$+%S!

Page 49: Economic Journal Issue 5

!a[

\338"! b9! ! C9! ! +0)! \9! ! d9! ! ].%'0.-9! ! OPQQ9!!

:6-%7(,'(-+,! :7'%;%'*! +0)! '$.! ?.0.-+,!

J73032*V!M32.!C+7-323).,!J<8.-%2.0'&"!

-5!'(&$4# F3,'4$%# 3;# -9'(&,%",'$%#2&3435(&)!FP!NOSV!OOQ>OcF9!

M7$($"!?9!!J9!!OPQR9!!#$.!I.1!C+7-3.73032%7&!34!

:6-%7(,'(-."!!:2.-%7+0!b3(-0+,!34!:6-%7(,'(-+,#2&3435(&)!F[!NFSV![`c>[OO9!

M'+23(,%&"!X9!!.'!+,9!!OPPF9!!:6-%7(,'(-+,!@.;.,382.0'!

%0!'$.!J73032*>H%).!Z30'.<'V!:88-3+7$.&!

'3! A3,%7%.&! +0)! M'-+'.6%.&"! ! T0! I9!

:,.<+0)-+'3&9! N.)9S9! ! H3-,)! :6-%7(,'(-.V##31+-)&!c`O !:0!B:Y!M'()*9! !J06,+0)V!

b3$0!H%,.*!+0)!M30&"!cFQ>cPE9!

H306&+5"!M9! !c``O9! !#$.! T28+7'!34!C+7-3.73032%7!

A3,%7*! 30! :6-%7(,'(-+,! M.7'3-! 34! #$+%,+0)9!!

:$)"!'# 3;# /&(!4&!# (4# 2&3435(&)G#H$)!")$'"#I4(C!')("J9!!!N%0!#$+%S!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 50: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! aP

8==,()"1'5%N&,':''e+-%+/,.!%).0'%4%7+'%30!!

\%."%N&,'''''']("-' K1=&%(%-"+(' A+9.$,'+L')%-%'

h!

Z!

T!

?!

!

!

!

!

J<!

]!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

!

!

!

!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

I+'%30+,!%0;.&'2.0'!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

?.0.-+,!63;.-02.0'!730&(28'%30!.<8.0)%'(-.!+'!OP[[!8-%7.!i!

7328.0&+'%30!34!.28,3*..&!N1+6.&!W!&+,+-%.&!+0)!8+*!W!

+,,31+07.!34!2.2/.-&!34!'$.!+-2.)!43-7.&S!j!8(-7$+&.&!4-32!

.0'.-8-%&.&!+0)!+/-3+)!N2%,%'+-*!+0)!7%;%,%+0!8(-83&.&S!>!8(-7$+&.&!

/*!$3(&.$3,)&!+0)!.0'.-8-%&.&9!

J<83-'&!34!633)&!+0)!&.-;%7.&!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

T283-'&!34!633)&!+0)!&.-;%7.&!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

Y44%7.!34!'$.!I+'%30+,!

J73032%7&!+0)!M37%+,!

@.;.,382.0'!^3+-)"!

11190.&)/9639'$!

!

!

!

!

11190.&)/9639'$!

11190.&)/9639'$!

#!

!

J!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

!

OPPaiO``!

#+<.&!-.;.0(.!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

#+<.&!-.;.0(.!+'!7(--.0'!8-%7.9!!

\.+,!.44.7'%;.!.<7$+06.!-+'.9!! !

N!#-+).>1.%6$'.)!/-3+)>cOS!

Z+,7(,+'.)!!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)"!

1119/3'93-9'$!

h4! ^%,,%30&! \.+,!6-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'!34!'$.!_0%'.)!M'+'.&!34!:2.-%7+9! 1119.73032+6%79732!

A%28!

!

\0!

!

!

\0%0/!

OPPFiO``!

!

A.-!7.0'!8.-!

+00(2!

!

A.-!7.0'!8.-!

+00(2!

T283-'!8-%7.!%0).<!%0!'.-2&!34!/+$'s!

!

C%0%2(2!,.0)%06!-+'.9!T0'.-.&'!-+'.!+&!K(3'.)!/*!'$.!a!,+-6.&'!

/+05&!+0)!/*!'$.!F!,+-6.&'!7322.-7%+,!/+05&!&%07.!b+0(+-*!c```9!

T0'.-/+05!3;.-0%6$'!,.0)%06!-+'.9!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)"!

1119/3'93-9'$!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

!

!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!!

C&!

!

\4!!

!

C%,,%30!/+$'!

!

A.-!7.0'!8.-!

+00(2!

I+--31!230.*!&(88,*!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

I+--31!230.*!&(88,*!+'!7(--.0'!8-%7.9!

\.+,!43-.%60!%0'.-.&'!-+'.9!

NOS!B.).-+,!4(0)&!-+'.!

NcS!pZ$+06.!34!730&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<!43-!+,,!(-/+0!730&(2.-&V!+,,!

%'.2&V!%0).<!OP[c>[a!iO``V!!M:!

Z+,7(,+'.)!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

Z+,7(,+'.)!

1119.73032+6%79732!

!

A!

!

A0+!

!

A+!

!

A+1!

!

!

A40+!

A4+!

!

OP[[iO``!

!

OP[[iO``!

!

OP[[iO``!

!

OPPFiO``!

!

!

OPPFiO``!

OPPFiO``!

!

d.+),%0.!730&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<9!

d.+),%0.!730&(2.-!8-%7.!%0).<!Nc``ciO``S9!

ZAT!43-!030>433)!+0)!+,73$3,%7!/.;.-+6.&9!

ZAT!43-!030>433)!+0)!+,73$3,%7!/.;.-+6.&!Nc``ciO``S9!

ZAT!43-!433)!+0)!030>+,73$3,%7!/.;.-+6.&9!

ZAT!43-!433)!+0)!030>+,73$3,%7!/.;.-+6.&!Nc``ciO``S9!

H3-,)!+6-%7(,'(-+,!8-%7.!%0).<9!Z328-%&%06!-%7."!&$-%28"!-(//.-"!

&(6+-"!7+&&+;+"!2+%G."!7344.."!&3*/.+0&"!8+,2"!'3/+773"!73''30!+0)!

&3-6$(29!!

T283-'!8-%7.!%0)%7.&!34!030433)9!

T283-'!8-%7.!%0)%7.&!34!433)"!/.;.-+6.&!W!'3/+773"!+0%2+,!

W;.6.'+/,.!3%,&!+0)!4+'&!

\./+&%06!4-32!

c``ciO``!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

\./+&%06!4-32!

c``ciO``!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

\./+&%06!4-32!

c``ciO``!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

!

!

Page 51: Economic Journal Issue 5

!F`

8==,()"1'5%N&,':''NZ30'%0(.)S'!

\%."%N&,'''''']("-' K1=&%(%-"+(' A+9.$,'+L')%-%'

A4+-2A

5+!

c``ciO``!

c``ciO``!

!

B+-2!8-%7.!%0).<9!

A-3)(7.-!8-%7.!%0).<!/*!2+7$%0.-*!W!.K(%82.0'"!.,.7'-%7+,!

.K(%82.0'!+0)!'-+0&83-'!.K(%82.0'!8-3)(7'&9!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

H+! ^+$'!8.-!

230'$!

:;.-+6.!1+6.&!1.-.!).4,+'.)!/*!4+-2!8-%7.!%0)%7.&9!

:00(+,!)+'+!&.'V!OPPQ!'3!OPP[9!

U(+-'.-!O!34!OPPQ!'3!U(+-'.-!a!34!OPP[9!!

\3(0)!O!NB./-(+-*S"!\3(0)!c!NC+*S"!\3(0)!E!N:(6(&'S"!\3(0)!a!

NI3;.2/.-SV!OPPP>c```9!

U(+-'.-!O!34!c``O!'3!U(+-'.-!E!34!c``a9!

Z+,7(,+'.)!

I+'%30+,!M'+'%&'%7&!Y44%7.!

C+0%8(,+'.)O!

I+'%30+,!M'+'%&'%7&!Y44%7.!

!

I+! C%,,%30! J28,3*2.0'!%0!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-9!

\3(0)!O!NB./-(+-*S!VOPPQ9!

\3(0)!c!NC+*S!VOPPQ9!

\3(0)!E!N:(6(&'S!VOPPQ9!!

\3(0)!a!NI3;.2/.-SV!OPPQ9!

\3(0)!O!NB./-(+-*S"!\3(0)!c!NC+*S"!\3(0)!E!N:(6(&'S"!\3(0)!a!

NI3;.2/.-SV!OPP[!'3!c```9!

U(+-'.-!O!34!c``O!'3!U(+-'.-!E!34!c``a9!

!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

C+0%8(,+'.)c!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

C+0%8(,+'.)c!

^+05!34!#$+%,+0)!

X+! C%,,%30!^+$'! A-%;+'.!7+8%'+,!&'375!34!+6-%7(,'(-+,!&.7'3-!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

:00(+,!)+'+!&.'9!

U(+-'.-,*!)+'+!&.'9!

!

11190.&)/9639'$!

C+0%8(,+'.)O!

Z+!

!

!

!

h+!

C%,,%30!^+$'!

!

!

!

C%,,%30!^+$'!

A-%;+'.!730&(28'%30!43-!433)!N2.+'"!4%&$"!4-(%'"!;.6.'+/,."!3%,&!+0)!

4+'&SjN)+%-*!8-3)(7'&SjN6-+%0!2%,,!8-3)(7'&"!3'$.-!433)!

8-3)(7'&SjN/.;.-+6.&SjN'3/+773!8-3)(7'&S!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

?-3&&!)32.&'%7!8-3)(7'!3-%6%0+'%06!4-32!+6-%7(,'(-."!$(0'%06"!

43-.&'-*!+0)!4%&$%06!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

11190.&)/9639'$!

!

!

!

11190.&)/9639'$!

!

J<+!

!

!

Z4+!

C%,,%30!^+$'!

!

!

C%,,%30!^+$'!

J<83-'V!N433)S!jN/.;.-+6.&!+0)!'3/+773S!j!N+0%2+,!+0)!;.6.'+/,.!

3%,&!+0)!4+'&S!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

@+'+!&.'!+'!7(--.0'!2+-5.'!8-%7.!!

T283-'V!N433)S!jN/.;.-+6.&!+0)!'3/+773S!j!N+0%2+,!+0)!;.6.'+/,.!

3%,&!+0)!4+'&S!+'!OP[[!8-%7.9!

@+'+!&.'!+'!7(--.0'!2+-5.'!8-%7.!

Z+,7(,+'.)!

!

1119/3'93-9'$!

Z+,7(,+'.)!

!

1119/3'93-9'$!

I3'.V!OT'!1+&!2+0%8(,+'.)!/*!^33'!#.7$0%K(.!N^33'!!"#$%9!OPRQ!7%'.)!T0'$%&+06"!OPP[S9!!!!!!!!!cT'!1+&!2+0%8(,+'.)!/*[email protected]+8$%7!#.7$0%K(.&!NA%+28%'%!OP[F!7%'.)!Z$+-3.05%''+*+1('"!c``OS9!

!

!

!

Page 52: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! FO

8==,()"1'5%N&,'>''\.&(,'!34!.&'%2+'.)!&'-(7'(-+,!23).,!

!

%E'FI=%$-#'+L'4+G,.(I,(-'$+(#9I=-"+(',1=,()"-9.,'+('I%$.+,$+(+I"$#'G%."%N&,#'

! 2R ! AEKE'+L'

B,4.,##"+('

2*R>W'

-,#-'

#13>M'+6.!D.+&'!MK(+-.&!C.'$3)!

JK9NOSV!J<8.0)%'(-.!30!?@A!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

h&+'!i!Z&+'!j!T&+'!j!?&+'!j!J<&+'!k!]&+'!j!M)&+'!

!

JK9NcSV!A-%;+'.!Z30&(28'%30!

Z&+'!i!>OO`"aaa!!!!j!`9QPh)&+'!j!q:\NOSi`9[Qr!

!!!!!!!!!!N>a9`aSttt!!!!NcO9FESttt!

!

JK9NESV!@%&83&+/,.!T0732.!

h)&+'!i!h&+'!k!#&+'!

!

JK9NaSV!#+<!\.;.0(.!

#&+'!i!>OcP"`O[!!!!j!`9E`h&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!N>c9[[Sttt!!NQ9EaSttt!

jq:\NOSi`9aa":\NcSi>`9E`":\NESi`9QO"!C:NOSi`9[c"!

C:NcSi`9FF"^:ZXZ:M#iOPPQVar!

!

JK9NFSV!I+'%30+,!T0;.&'2.0'!

T&+'!i!>ORO"aFa!!!k!a["P`P9cF\'!j!`9ach&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!N>E9E`Sttt!!!!!!!!N>`9acS!!!!!NQ9aRSttt!

j!q:\NESi`9QE":\NaSi>`9EF"C:NOSi`9PPr!

-\"h&+!i!>`9[R!

!

JK9NRSV!J<83-'!34!?33)&!+0)!M.-;%7.&!

J<&+'!i!>FP`"FRQ!k!E"EE[9ORJ'!j!OEa9QEh4'!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>E9PPSttt!!N>E9cRSttt!!NOP9acOSttt!

j!q:\NaSi>`9OO"C:NESi>`9PP"^:ZXZ:M#iOPP[VOr!

!

JK9NQSV!T283-'&!34!?33)&!+0)!M.-;%7.&!

]&+'!i!>OQ`"`cP!!!!j!`9EQh&+'!!!!>!OEc9aQA%28'!j!`9F[J<&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>E9Q[Sttt!!Nc9RQSttt!!!!!!!N>O9aOS!!!!!!!!!!!NE9[aOSttt!

j!q:\NOSi`9[E":\NaSi>`9ca"C:NaSi>`9PQ"^:ZXZ:M#iOPP[Vcr!

-A%28"!h&+!i!`9R["!-A%28"!J<&+!i!`9RF!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PP[!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PPO!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PQE!

!

!

!

!

!

`9P[[!

!

!

!

!

`9PP[!

!

!

!

!

!

O"QaQ9cER!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O"a`c9cPO!

!

!

!

!

!

a"aR`9RQ[!

!

!

!

!

!

Q"[QE9`OO!

!

!

!

!

c"[Q`9PEa!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9[aPN`9

RFaS!

!

!

!

!

!

`9Fca!

N`9QQ`S!

!

!

!

!

O9R[O!

N`9aEOS!

!

!

!

!

E9E``!

N`9OPcS!

!

!

!

a9Ec`!

N`9OOFS!

!

'

Page 53: Economic Journal Issue 5

!Fc

8==,()"1'5%N&,'>''NZ30'%0(.)S!

!

%E'FI=%$-#'+L'4+G,.(I,(-'$+(#9I=-"+(',1=,()"-9.,'+('I%$.+,$+(+I"$#'G%."%N&,#'

! 2R ! AEKE'+L'

B,4.,##"+('

2*R>W'

-,#-'

Y-)%0+-*!D.+&'!MK(+-.&!C.'$3)!

JK9N[SV!Z30&(2.-!A-%7.!T0).<!

A'!i!`9REPaA0+'!j!`9ER`RA+'!

!

JK9NPSV!ZAT!43-!I30433)!+0)!:,73$3,%7!^.;.-+6.&!

A0+'!i!Oaa9QP!!!!!j!`9``[cA%28'!k![F9FF\!!!j!c9Pc O`>Fh&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!NO`9cRSttt!N`9aQS!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>E9F[Sttt!NO9R[St!

j!q:\NcSi`9aQ"C:NOSiO9OE"C:NcSi`9FO"C:NESi`9FO"!

C:NaSi`9EPr!

-A%28"\!i!>`9QO!"!-A%28"h&+!i!`9R[!

!

JK9NO`SV!ZAT!43-!B33)!+0)!I30+,73$3,%7!^.;.-+6.&!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

A+'!i!PO9[E!j!`9c`A+1'!j!`9R`A0+'j!q:\NOSi`9[[r!

!!!!!!!!!!NO9a`S!!NO9F`St!!!!!!NO9FcSt!

!

JK9NOOSV!I32%0+,!T0'.-.&'!\+'.!

D0N\0'S!i!Q9cO!j!`9a`D0Nh&+'S!>!O9OFD0NC&&+'S!j!`9ORD0N\0%0/'S!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NO9`[S!!N`9aFS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>c9aFSttt!!!!!!!!!!!!NF9OcSttt!

j!q:\NOSi`9Qc":\NcSi>`9`ar!

-D0Nh&+S"D0NC&&+S!i!`9PF"!-D0Nh&+S"D0N\%0/S!i!>`9aa!

!

JK9NOcSV!\.+,!T0'.-.&'!\+'.!

\'!i!\0'!k!NA'!>!A'>aSlA'>a!

!

JK9NOESV!\.+,!J44.7'%;.!J<7$+06.!\+'.!!

J'!i!Qc9aR!!!!!j!QQ9`[N\'!>!\4'S!j!E9Ec O`>FNJu&+'!k!]&+'S!!

!!!!!NF9PRSttt!!!!NO9FESt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N`9EaS!

j!q:\NOSi`9[c":\NcSi>`9a`"!C:NaSi`9Pa"^:ZXZ:M#iOPPQVEr!

-N\>\4S"NJu&+k]&+S!i!`9aF!

!

!

!

!

!

`9P[[!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PcE!

!

!

!

`9P[F!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9QFa!

!

!

!

!

!

`9QE[!

!

!

!

!

!

!

c9EEQ!

!

!

!

`9`EP!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

c9`F`!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O9`FP!

N`9F[PS!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PQE!

N`9ROFS!

!

!

`9aEF!

N`9[`aS!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

a9`[Q!

N`9OE`S!

'

Page 54: Economic Journal Issue 5

B%&7+,!+0)!C30.'+-*!A3,%7*!C%<.&!D%05+6.!'3!#$+%,+0)=&!:6-%7(,'(-.! FE

8==,()"1'5%N&,'>''NZ30'%0(.)S'

!

NE'FI=%$-#'+L'I%$.+,$+(+I"$'G%."%N&,#'+('%4."$9&-9.%&'G%."%N&,#'

! 2R ! AEKE'+L'

B,4.,##"+('

2*R>W'

-,#-'

Y-)%0+-*!D.+&'!MK(+-.&!C.'$3)!

JK9NOaSV!A-%;+'.!Z30&(28'%30!43-!B33)!

Z+&+'!i!>OP"RR[!!!!>!RQ9[aA+'!j!`9OOh&+'!!j!Fa9PEA4+'!j!Ea[9P`A0+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>c9cFStttN>O9[FStt!!!NEc9[aSttt!!!Nc9OQSttt!!!!!Na9E`Sttt!!!>!

E`9EOA40+!

!N>O9QaStt!

!

JK9NOFSV!B33)!T283-'!!

Z4+&+'!i!>F"EaF>cF9ROA4+'j`9`Oh&+'jc[9R[A40+'>![O9REA+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!N>`9F[SN>O9cES!!!!!NO9RFSt!!!!!!!Nc9FOSttt!!!N>c9`OStt!!!!!!!

j!Oaa9cPA0+'!j!q:\NOSi`9FR"C:NOSi`9PPQr!

!!!!!!NO9[cStt!

-A4+"A0+!i!>`9QR"!-h"A0+!i!`9Q["!-h"A+!i!`9QO!!

!

JK9NORSV!B33)!J<83-'!

J<+&+'!i!a["Eca!j!a9F[h4'!>!EaR9aPJ'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!NO9FcSt!!!NO9QQStt!!!N>c9cPSttt!

j!q:\NESi`9OO"C:NOSiO9R`"C:NcSiO9RO"C:NESi`9PR"!

^:ZXZ:M#iOPPQVar!

!

JK9NOQSV!#-+).!^+,+07.!34!B33)!

#+&+'!i!J<+&+'!k!Z4+&+'!

!

JK9\O[V!B+-2!A-%7.!T0).<!

A4+-2'!i!>cOQ9cO!j!O9EOA1+'!j!O9aEA0+'!j!q:\NOSi`9aPr!

!!!!!!!!!!!!N>a9E[Sttt!NQ9R`Sttt!!!NF9aOSttt!

!

JK9NOPSV!Z+8%'+,!\.0'+,!\+'.!34!:6-%7(,'(-+,!M.7'3-!

A'%,'!i!A5+'!N\'!j! '!k!NA5+'!>!A5+'>aSlA5+'>aS!

!

!

!

`9P[Q!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PFQ!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PF`!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9[Qa!

!

!

!

[`E9EE`!

!

!

!

!

!

FaF9F[R!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O"aP[9a[R!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

E9[PE!

!

!

c9aFc!

N`9cPES!

!

!

!

!

E9QOF!

N`9OFRS!

!

!

!

!

!

E9PQ`!

N`9OEQS!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9FOQ!

N`9QQcS!

'

Page 55: Economic Journal Issue 5

!Fa

8==,()"1'5%N&,'>''NZ30'%0(.)S'

!

NE'FI=%$-#'+L'I%$.+,$+(+I"$'G%."%N&,#'+('%4."$9&-9.%&'G%."%N&,#'

! 2R ! AEKE'+L'

B,4.,##"+('

2*R>W'

-,#-'

Y-)%0+-*!D.+&'!MK(+-.&!C.'$3)!

JK9Nc`SV!J28,3*2.0'!%0!:6-%7(,'(-+,!M.7'3-!

I+&+'!i!OE"ccc!!!!>!`9`aH+&+'!j!F9cFA4+-2'!j!cQ9`PA'%,'!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!NOR9Q[StttN>`9caS!!!!!!!!NO9FPSt!!!!!!!!!!!!!N`9PFS!

j!q:\NOSi`9aF":\NcSi`9cR":\NESi>`9aO"C:NaSi>`9Pa"!

^:ZXZ:M#iOPPQVar!

-H+&+"A4+-2!i!>`9FO"!-A4+-2"A'%,!i!>`9Ra!!!

!

JK9NcOSV!Z+8%'+,!M'375!%0!:6-%7(,'(-+,!M.7'3-!

X+&+'!i!OOO"Rc`!!!>!EEa9EPA'%,'!j!c`R9Q`A4+-2'!j!`9P[H+&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!N[9PFSttt!!N>c9cQRSttt!!!!!NR9EQ`Sttt!!!!NO9`EFS!!!!

j!`9RPX+&+'>O!!

!!NEO9EQaSttt!

-H+&+"A4+-2!i!>`9FO"!-A4+-2"A'%,!i!>`9Ra!

!

JK9NccSV!?-3&&!@32.&'%7!A-3)(7'%30!%0!:6-%7(,'(-+,!M.7'3-!

h+&+'!i!>cOO"EOa!!!!j!E9aPI+&+'!j!`9FRX+&+'!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!N>c9`PQSttt!!!NE9QQSttt!!!!Nc9acSttt!

j!q:\NOSiO9FE":\NcSi>`9Q`"C:NESi`9[F"^:ZXZ:M#iOPPQVEr!

!

!

!

`9[E`!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9P[Q!

!

!

!

!

!

!

`9PQ`!

!

!

!

!

[P9cQc!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O"`PP9[QO!

!

!

!

!

!

!

O"`[F9cOa!

!

!

!

`9`EO!

N`9P[FS!

!

!

!

!

!

O9QPE!

N`9a`[S!

!

!

!

!

!

`9aaa!

N`9[`OS!

I3'.V!! >h&+"!Z&+"!T&+"!?&+"!J<&+"!]&+"!M)&+"!#&+"!C&&+"!h+&+"!Z+&+"!J<+&+"!Z4+&+"!I+&+"!X+&+!+0)!H+&+!

-.8-.&.0'!+&!'$.!'%2.!&.-%.&!)+'+!'$+'!&233'$,*!+)L(&'.)!/*!43(->K(+-'.-!23;%06!+;.-+6.9!e+-%+/,.!I+2.&V!M..!

#+/,.!a9!D0!%&!+//-.;%+'.)!43-!0+'(-+,!,36+-%'$29!!

>#$.!+&'.-%&5!t"!tt!+0)!ttt!).03'.!&'+'%&'%7+,!&%60%4%7+07.!+'!'$.!`9OF"!`9O`!+0)!`9`F!,.;.,"!-.&8.7'%;.,*9!!

>:\N0S!+0)!C:N0S!&'+0)!43-!+('3-.6-.&&%;.!3-).-!N0S!+0)!23;%06!+;.-+6.!3-).-!N0S"!-.&8.7'%;.,*9!

!>-uO"uc!-.8-.&.0'&!+&!'$.!73--.,+'%30!73.44%7%.0'!/.'1..0!uO!+0)!uc9!!

> 2R %&!-.8-.&.0'.)!+&!'$.!+)L(&'.)!\>&K(+-.)9!!

>D+6-+06.!C(,'%8,%.-!'.&'!NDC!'.&'SV!#$.!Y/&t\>&K(+-.)!&'+'%&'%7!-.83-'&!1%'$!%'&!8>;+,(.9!T4!'$.!-.83-'.)!

&'+'%&'%7!%&!%0&%60%4%7+0'!'$.0!1.!1%,,!03'!-.L.7'!'$.!0(,,!$*83'$.&%&"!1$%7$!%28,%.&!'$.!-.&%)(+,&!34!23).,!%&!03'!&.-%+,!

73--.,+'%30!NO!+0)!c!,+66.)!8.-%3)S!+'!'$.!,.;.,!34!7304%).07.!%0'.-;+,!+&!2.0'%30.)!/*!8>;+,(.&!%0!8+-.0'$.&%&9!

M3(-7.V!:('$3-=&!J&'%2+'%30!

!

Page 56: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"#$%&'(&#)'*+#),-./01-#(2*3$45)"-*6*!4*78/$#$%)'*941-:($")($04*

!5)#)/04*;0&<%=)#)&4*

!

!<:(#)%(*

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

>?*94(#0,&%($04*

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

I-',+('<1'(@" J1.'/3" $'4-(." ,+$," <$%&"*1-%,'/()" /%" G1-,+" N<('/*$" +$8(" 5((%" ,+("(%,+-)/$),/*" )-001',('" ,1" ;'(('" ,'$.(" )/%*("!KOM@" 5-," ,+(/'" (*1%1</*" 0(';1'<$%*(" +$)"5((%")/4%/;/*$%,2&"5(216"0'(B!KOM" 2(8(29":+-)@",+()(" $'4-<(%,)" /<02&" ,+$," ,+('(" /)" ,+(" 4$0"5(,6((%" ,+(" 0'(./*,/1%" 1;" *2$))/*$2" ,+(1'/()"$%."(<0/'/*$2"1-,*1<()9"

?16(8('@" ,+('(" $'(" <$%&" (<0/'/*$2"),-./()"6+/*+"$;;/'<(.",+$," ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%")-001',)" 4'16,+" $%." 018(',&" '(.-*,/1%)" /%".(8(210/%4" *1-%,'/()@" (8(%" ,+1-4+" /," <$&"/%/,/$22&" +$8(" $.8(')(" *1%)(=-(%*()@" 1'"'()1-'*("'($221*$,/1%"*1),"EP/%,(')@"LMM!H9"Q-,"

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR"

!""S+9T9"),-.(%,"$,"T(0$',<(%,"1;"U*1%1</*)@"V%/8(')/,&"1;"?$6$//@"#$%1$9"G$-%.(')"WXL@"LXLX"#$/2("P$&@"?1%12-2-@"?$6$//"KYOLL"VGN9"U<$/2Z"$3$'$01%[+$6$//9(.-9"

Page 57: Economic Journal Issue 5

"WY

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

I1'" <1'(" *2($'2&@" ]1%8(&" ELMMXH"0'101)(." $" *1%*(0,-$2" ;'$<(61'3" ;1'" $%$2&7/%4",'$.(B018(',&" 2/%3$4(9" :+/)" ;'$<(61'3" /.(%,/;/(.";1-'" *+$%%(2)" 5&"6+/*+" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" *1-2."$;;(*," 018(',&" '(.-*,/1%Z" !"#$%&'()"#" E0'/*()@";$*(."5&"011'"+1-)(+12.)@"1;" ,+("411.)" ,+(&"0-'*+$)(H@" )#!"&*"E'(,-'%",1",+("2$51'@"$))(,)"$%.^1'" 0'1.-*,)" 1;" ,+(" 011'H@" '+",)$)"#- ".-'%/0)!- 1""2$" E418('%<(%," (A0(%./,-'()" 1%"+($2,+@"(.-*$,/1%@")$%/,$,/1%@"$%.")1*/$2"0'1,(*,/1%@"$**())/52(" ,1" ,+(" 011'H@" $%." $*!%+)(3" E/<0'18(."*$0$*/,&" ,1" )-),$/%" 21%4B,('<"6(2;$'(" ,+'1-4+"'(.-*,/1%"$%."</,/4$,/1%"1;"'/)3@"$%."/%*'($)(."*$0$*/,&" ,1" *10("6/,+" ,+(" *1%)(=-(%*()"1;" $")+1*3H9" N2,+1-4+" ,+/)" ;'$<(" 61'3" (%$52()" ,1"

,+(1'(,/*$22&" >-),/;&" ,+(" 01)/,/8(" '(2$,/1%)+/0"5(,6((%",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%"$%."018(',&"'(.-*,/1%@"/," 2$*3)" (<0/'/*$2" ),-./()" ,1" 8/%./*$,(" ,+("'(2$,/1%)+/0@"()0(*/$22&"/%".(8(210/%4"*1-%,'/()9"

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`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

:+("*1<</,<(%,)" ,1"'(.-*("$4'/*-2,-'$2")-001',)" /%" .(8(210(." *1-%,'/()@" /9(9" a$0$%@" 6/22"(%4$4(" )-5),$%,/$2" *+$%4()" /%" 61'2." $4'/*-2,-'("0'1.-*,`)" 0'/*(" $%." '$,(" 1;" '(,-'%9" #$%&"

Page 58: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" Wc

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

?(%*(@" ,+/)"0$0('"0'/<$'/2&"(A$</%()"(<0/'/*$22&" ,+(" /%*1<(" *+$%%(2" 5&" 6+/*+"$4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%"*1-2."01)/,/8(2&"$;;(*," 018(',&" /%" (A01',B1'/(%,(." .(8(210/%4"*1-%,/()9":+("),-.&"6/22"),$',"6/,+"*1%),'-*,/%4")-/,$52(" /%./*$,1')" ;1'" ,'$.(" 10(%%())" $%."/%*1<(" *+$%%(2" /%" ]1%6$&" ;'$<(61'3" E/9(9")1*/1B(*1%1</*" 8$'/$52()H9" :+(%@" ,+(" 2/%3$4("6/22"5("(A$</%(."5&",+("),$,/),/*$2"<(,+1."E/9(9"b%),'-<(%," d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

@?*3$(-#)(&#-*A-1$-B*

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`)"/%*1<(" ET122$'"$%."_'$$&@"LMMXH9":+(" ;/%./%4"/)" ,+$," ,+('(" /)" %1" )&),(<$,/*" '(2$,/1%)+/0"5(,6((%" $8('$4(" /%*1<()" $%." ,+(" )+$'(" 1;",+(" 011'()," /%*1<(9" b," </4+," /<02&" ,+$," ,+("018(',&" '(.-*,/1%" /)" '()-2,(." ;'1<" (*1%1</*"4'16,+9"

G(*1%.2&@" <$%&" ),-./()" (<021&"S$',/$2BU=-/2/5'/-<^]1),B1;BF/8/%4" $%$2&)/)" ,1"(A02$/%" ,+(" '(2$,/1%)+/0" 5(,6((%" ,'$.(" $%."018(',&9" T($,1%" E!KOKH@" J$8$22/1%" E!KKMH@"J$8$22/1%" $%." d$%" .(" P$22(" E!KK!H@" $%."F(8/%)1+%@" Q(''&@" $%." I'/(.<$%" E!KKKH"*1<5/%(." 0'/*(" *+$%4(" /%" $4'/*-2,-'(" 0'1.-*,"$%." ,+(" +1-)(+12." .$,$" /9(9" +1-)(+12."(A0(%./,-'(@"$%."6$4("'$,(" ,1" ;/%." /%,('$*,/1%"

Page 59: Economic Journal Issue 5

"WO

5(,6((%" 0'/*(" *+$%4()" $%." 6(2;$'(" (;;(*,)9"T($,1%" E!KOKH@" J$8$22/1%" E!KKMH@" J$8$22/1%"$%."d$%".("P$22(" E!KK!H"*2$/<(." ,+$,"+/4+('"0'/*(" /%" $4'/*-2,-'$2" 0'1.-*," ;'1<" ,'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%" +$)" 01)/,/8(" (;;(*,)" 1%" ,+(" 011'"+1-)(+12." 5-,@" /%" ,+(" /%/,/$2" 0('/1.@" $.8(')("(;;(*,)"</4+,"$00($'9"P+/2("F(8/%)1+%@"Q(''&@"$%."I'/(.<$%"E!KKKH"$'4-(.",+$,"./)'(4$'./%4")(2;B0'1.-*(."$4'/*-2,-'("$%."16%(."+1-)/%4@"<($%" /%*'($)(" /%" *1),B1;B2/8/%4" /)" !eM"0('*(%,)@" 6/,+" ,+(" '-'$2" 011'" )-;;('/%4" <1),9"N**1'./%4" ,1" ,+()(" (;;(*,)@" -'5$%" 011'" 6('("<1)," $.8(')(2&" $;;(*,(.9" P+/2(" #/%1," $%."D12(,,/" ELMMMH" -)(." $" <-2,/<$'3(," )0$,/$2"(=-/2/5'/-<" <1.(2" 6/,+" ./;;('(%," 012/*&")*(%$'/1)" ,1" $%$2&7(" 0'/*(" *+$%4(" (;;(*,)" /%"'/*("<$'3(,"/%"d/(,%$<9":+/)"),-.&"$'4-(.",+$,"(A01'," 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" '$/)()" '/*(" 0'/*()" 6/,+/%",+("*1-%,'&@"$%.",+(%"4$8("$"01)/,/8("(;;(*,"1%"'-'$2" /%*1<(" 5-," )2/4+,2&" ;$81'$52(" /<0$*," 1%"018(',&9"

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

$%." J15/22/$'." ELMMMH" *2$/<(." ,+$," 6+/2("'(2$,/8(" /%*1<(" $%." 0'/*(" *+$%4()" $'("4(%('$22&")/4%/;/*$%,@",+("/<0$*,"1;",+("8$'/1-)")+1*3)"1%",+("$44'(4$,("/%./*$,1')"1;"018(',&"$%."/%(=-$2/,&",(%.",1"5(")<$229"

:+(" 2$)," *$,(41'&" /)" #/*'1B<$*'1")&%,+()/)9":+/)"$00'1$*+"*1%)/),)"1;",61"),(0)"/%" $%$2&)/)9" b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b%.1%()/$@":+$/2$%.@"V4$%.$@"$%."f$<5/$@"5-,"/,)" /%;2-(%*(" 1%" 0$',/*-2$'" 4'1-0)" 6/,+/%" ,+("*1-%,'/()" /)"</A(.9" b$%*+18/*+/%$@"\/*/,$@" $%."G121$4$" ELMM!H" ),-./(." ,+(" '(2$,/1%)+/0"5(,6((%" ,'$.(" '(;1'<" $%." +1-)(+12." 6(2;$'("/%"#(A/*1@"$%.";1-%.",+$,",$'/;;"'(;1'<"6/22"%1,"+$8("$"%(4$,/8("(;;(*,"1%"6(2;$'(" ;1'"$22" /%*1<("4'1-0)9" I'/(.<$%" ELMM!H" ),-./(." /<0$*,)" 1;",'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" 1%" b%.1%()/$`)" 011'" $%."%1%B011'" /%" ,61" ./;;('(%," )*(%$'/1)" ,+$," $'("-%/2$,('$2" $%." 4215$2" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%9" :+/)"),-.&"*2$/<(.",+$,"-%.('"51,+")*(%$'/1";(6"1'"%1" +1-)(+12.)" $'(" 61')(" 1;;@" 5-," ./),'/5-,/1%"1;"4$/%)";'1<"2/5('$2/7$,/1%",(%.",1"5("./),1',(.",16$'.",+("-'5$%"'$,+('",+$%",+("'-'$2"$%.",+("6($2,+&"'$,+('",+$%",+("011'9""

Page 60: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" WK

:+("*1%*2-)/1%"$51-,",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%"(;;(*,)" /%" 018(',&" '(.-*,/1%" /)" ),/22" $'4-$52("5(,6((%" ./;;('(%," <(,+1.1214/()" $%." ,+(")$<(" <(,+1.1214&9" G1<(" ),-./()" *1%*2-.(.",+$," ,+('(" $'(" $.8(')(" 1-,*1<()" ;'1<"2/5('$2/7$,/1%",1",+("011'`)"6(2;$'(@"6+/2(")1<("),-./()" )-001'," ,+(" ,'/*32(B.16%" (;;(*,)" 1;",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%)",16$'."/%*1<("/%(=-$2/,&9"

C?* +#),-* D/-44-::E* 94%08-* )4,*

94-F&)'$(26*+=-*G00#H:*!"#$.:-%(0#*

I-/-4,-4%2*

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b%.1%()/$@" F$1@" #$2$&)/$@"S+/2/00/%()@":+$/2$%.@"d/(,%$<@"]+/%$@"Q$%42$.()+@"b%./$@"$%."G'/"F$%3$9""

:+/)" 0$0('" $.10,)" ,61" <($)-'()" 1;"

/%(=-$2/,&@" ,+("D/%/L"*1(;;/*/(%," EDb\bH"$%." ,+("'$,/1" 1;" /%*1<(" ($'%(." 5&" ,+(" ,10" /%*1<("=-$',/2(" ,1" /%*1<(" ($'%(." 5&" ,+(" 51,,1<"

=-$',/2(" EgW^g!H9" :+(" .$,$" )1-'*(" 1;" ,+()("/%(=-$2/,&" <($)-'()" /)" ,+(" .$,$" )(," ;'1<" ,+("V\VBPbTUJ" P1'2." b%*1<(" b%(=-$2/,&"T$,$5$)("EPbbTH@"8(')/1%"L9M*@"6+/*+"/)"/))-(."/%"#$&"LMMO9"

:+(" <($)-'()" 1;" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%"*1-2."5("$002/(."5&" ,'$.("10(%%())"6+/*+" /)",+(" '$,/1"1;" ,1,$2" ,'$.(" E(A01'," 02-)" /<01',H" ,1"DTS@" $%." $8('$4(" ,$'/;;" '$,(9" :+(" $8('$4(",$'/;;" '$,(" /)" <1'(" (A02/*/,2&" $" 012/*&" 8$'/$52(",+$%" ,'$.(" 10(%%())" 5-," ,'$.(" 812-<(" /%"0$',/*-2$'" 411.)" <$&" %1," 5(" '(2$,(." ,1" ,+(/'",$'/;;" '$,(9" :+/)" /<02&" ,+$," ,'$.(" 812-<(" /)".(,('</%(."5&"%1,"1%2&"$" ,'$.("012/*&"5-," ,+("1,+('" ;$*,1')" ,1" 511,9" :+(" .$,$" $8$/2$52(" 1%",$'/;;)" $'(" 8('&" /<0(';(*," ,1" <($)-'(" ,'$.("012/*&" ET122$'" $%." _'$$&@" LMMXH9" N../,/1%$22&@"$8('$4(" ,$'/;;" '$,()" 2($8(" /%;1'<$,/1%" $51-,"$;;(*,)" 1%" %1%B,$'/;;" 5$''/(')9" P+('($)" ,'$.("812-<("'(;2(*,)",+()("%1%B,$'/;;"5$''/1",1",'$.("$%." /," /)" <1'(" 0'(*/)(9" P(" <($)-'(" ,'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%" 5&" ,'$.(" 10(%%())" $)" $%"/%./*$,1'9""

G/%*(" <$%&" *1-%,'/()" /%" G1-,+" U$),"N)/$" 5(4$%" ,1" 2/5('$,(" /%,('%$,/1%$2" ,'$.(".-'/%4" !KOM`)@" 6(" 5(4/%" ,1" )(," ,+(" -%/," 1;"$%$2&)/)" /%" ,('<)"1;" ,/<("0('/1." ;'1<"!KOM" ,1",+(" &($'" /%"6+/*+"D/%/" *1(;;/*/(%," /)" $8$/2$52(";1'" ($*+" *1-%,'&" /%" 0$',/*-2$'9" :+-)@" ,+(".$,$)(,"/)"-%5$2$%*(."0$%(2".$,$9""

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR"

L"":+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"/)"4/8(%"$)"$"0'101',/1%"1'"0('*(%,$4(9":+(1'(,/*$22&@",+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"6/22"5("(=-$2",1"M"6+(%" ,+(" ./),'/5-,/1%" /)" (=-$2" ,1" $229" b;" ,+(" )1*/(,&h)" ,1,$2" /%*1<(" *1<()" /%,1" ,+(" 01))())/1%" 1;" 1%2&" 1%("0(')1%^+1-)(+12."-%/,@"2($8/%4",+("'(),"6/,+"%1"/%*1<("$,"$22@",+(%",+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"$00'1$*+()"!@"1'"!MMi9"

Page 61: Economic Journal Issue 5

"YM

:'$.("812-<(" /%"$4'/*-2,-'$2"0'1.-*,)"/)"*1<02/(." ;'1<"INC":'$.(G:N:".$,$)(,")1",+$," 1-'" ),-.&" *1%*(%,'$,()" 1%" ,+("<('*+$%./7(" ,'$.(" /%" $4'/*-2,-'(" 0'1.-*,)"6+/*+" /)" .(;/%(." 5&" INC" $**1'./%4" ,1" ,+("),$%.$'." b%,('%$,/1%$2" #('*+$%./)(" :'$.("

G,$,/),/*)" #(,+1.1214&e9" C-'" ,'$.(" .$,$)(,@",+('(;1'(@" *18(')" 51,+" ;11." $%." 1,+('"$4'/*-2,-'(" 0'1.-*,)" $%." ,+(" ,'$.(" .$,$" /)"(8$2-$,(."$,"*-''(%,"0'/*("/%",('<"1;"VG".122$'9"":1"*$2*-2$,(",'$.("10(%%())@"6("%((."DTS"$,"*-''(%," 0'/*(9"P("*1<0/2(." ,+("DTS".$,$)(,@"/%*2-./%4" $4'/*-2,-'(" )+$'(@" 1;" ($*+" *1-%,'&";'1<" P1'2." T(8(210<(%," b%./*$,1')" EPTbH9"#1'(" .(,$/2)" $51-," 8$'/$52(" .(;/%/,/1%)" $%.")1-'*()" $'(" )+16%" /%" $00(%./A9" DTS" 0('"*$0/,$@"SSS"E*1%),$%,"LMMW"/%,('%$,/1%$2"jH@"/)"*1%)/.('(."$)"$"0'1A&";1'"/%*1<("$%."-)(.",1"*$2*-2$,("$4'/B/%*1<(")+$'(9""

""":1"+/4+2/4+,"/%(=-$2/,&@"$4'/B/%*1<(@"$%."/%(=-$2/,&"$*'1))"*1-%,'/()"$%."18('",/<(@":$52(" !" '(01',)" ,+(" -%6(/4+,(." $8('$4(" 1;",+(/'"<($)-'()"5&"*1-%,'&"$%.".(*$.(9"N)"*$%"5(" )((%" ;'1<" ,+(" ,$52(@" G1-,+" U$)," N)/$"*1-%,'/()"+$8(" '(2$,/8(2&"<1'(" /%(=-$2/,&9":+("D/%/" *1(;;/*/(%,)" 1;"#$2$&)/$@"S+/2/00/%()@" $%.":+$/2$%." /%" ,+(" !KOM`)" $'(" =-/,(" +/4+"*1<0$'$,/8(2&9" b%" #$2$&)/$@" S+/2/00/%()@" $%.":+$/2$%.@" D/%/" *1(;;/*/(%,)" /%" ,+(" !KOM`)" $'("XK9K@" XX9Y@" $%." XO9e@" '()0(*,/8(2&9" N," ,+("<($%,/<(@" /%(=-$2/,&" /%" ]+/%$" $%." b%./$" /)"<-*+"216('",+$%"/%"G1-,+"U$),"N)/$"*1-%,'/()@"6/,+"D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,)"/%",+("!KOM`)"1;"eM9W"$%."

e!9e@"*1%)(*-,/8(2&9"\(8(',+(2())@"/%(=-$2/,&"/%"]+/%$"'1)("8('&";$),";'1<"e!9e"/%",+("!KOM`)",1"XW9L" /%" ,+(" LMMM`)9" T-'/%4" ,+/)" 0('/1.@" DTS"0('"*$0/,$"/%"]+/%$"4'(6")-'0'/)/%42&";'1<"cOM"VG".122$')"/%",+("!KOM`)",1"e@!WK"VG".122$')"/%",+(" LMMM`)" 6+('($)" /%*1<(" )+$'(" /%"$4'/*-2,-'(" )(*,1'" 4'(6" /%"<-*+" 216('"4'16,+"'$,(" ,+$%" ,+(" %$,/1%$2" /%*1<(" ./.9" I'1<" ,+/)";/4-'(@"/,"*1-2."5(".(.-*(.",+$,"/%*1<("1;",+("'/*+"/%"]+/%$"4'(6"8('&";$),('",+$%",+("011'`)"/%*1<(" ./." )-*+" ,+$," /%(=-$2/,&" '$0/.2&"/%*'($)(." ;'1<"!KOM`)" ,1" LMMM`)9" :+/)"61-2.@",+(%@" /<02&" ,+$," ,+(" 011'" /%" ]+/%$" $'(".(0(%.(%,"1%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9""

b%" ](%,'$2" N)/$" *1-%,'/()@" /%(=-$2/,&"+$)"%1,"5((%"*+$%4(."<-*+" ;'1<" ,+("!KOM`)",1" ,+(" LMMM`)" 6+/2(" /%*1<(" +$)" %1," 5((%"*+$%4(." $)" 6(229" " b%" 0$',/*-2$'@" Q$%42$.()+"$%."G'/"F$%3$"+$8("+$.".(*2/%(" /%" /%(=-$2/,&@"6+/2(" b%./$"+$)" /%*'($)(."4'$.-$22&" /%" /%(=-$2/,&9"Q1,+" b%./$" $%." G'/" F$%3$" +$8(" +$." $" 5/4"*+$%4(" /%" ,('<" 1;" /%*1<(9" :+(/'" DTS" 0('"*$0/,$" +$)" <-*+" /%*'($)(." ;'1<" !@MXe" $%."!@ccc"VG" .122$')" /%" ,+(" !KOM`)" ,1" !@OYe" $%."e@MLX"VG".122$')"/%",+("LMMM`)@"'()0(*,/8(2&9"b%",+(" <($%,/<(@" Q$%42$.()+`)" DTS" 0('" *$0/,$"+$)" 4'16%" 4'$.-$22&9" N22" ,+'((" *1-%,'/()" /%"](%,'$2"N)/$"+$8("+$."18('$22"/%*1<("4'16/%4"'(2$,/8(2&" ;$),('" ,+$%" /%*1<(" )+$'(" /%" $4'/*-2,-'(")(*,1'9" :+/)" 61-2." .(.-*(" ,+$," ,+(" 011'" /%"Q$%42$.()+" $'(" /%" $%&" )(*,1')" 1,+('" ,+$%"$4'/*-2,-'$2" )(*,1'9" #($%6+/2(@" ,+(" 011'" /%" b%./$"$%."G'/"F$%3$"61-2."5("/%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9"

RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR"

e"I1'"<1'(".(,$/2)@"02($)("8/)/,"1;;/*/$2"INC"6(5)/,(9"

Page 62: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" Y!

+)<'-*>*94-F&)'$(2E*94%08-E*)4,*+#),-*0/-44-::6*<2*I-%),-*)4,*J0&4(#2*

"J0&4(#2*)4,*K-):&#-* ** >LMNO:* ** >LLNO:* ** @NNNO:*

J)8<0,$)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " \^N" " XY9WO" " XL9Oe"- - " " E!9e!H" " EM9OOH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " \^N" " K9Xe" " c9cO"- - " " EM9YXH" " EM9X!H"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " \^N" " OeO9ee" " !@!eY9LM"- - " " EYL9LOH" " E!MK9cWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" \^N" " ecL9MM" " eYO9We"- - " " E!e9XOH" " E!Y9LMH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " \^N" " M9XL" " M9KL"

- - " " EM9!cH" " EM9!WH"94,04-:$)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " eX9YM" " eK9XW" " eY9!K"- - !9Yc" " E!9W!H" " EL9MMH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " W9Wc" " Y9Oc" " W9cW"- - EM9eOH" " EM9WMH" " EM9WLH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " !@Y!M9WM" " L@WKY9LM" " L@KXM9MM"- - E!OK9cMH" " Ee!O9eMH" " E!OL9OWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" ec!9!M" " XYL9X!" " XeK9!W"- - EeW9YYH" " EXL9WcH" " E!X9Y!H"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9eK" " M9Xc" " M9XK"

- - EM9MXH" " EM9!LH" " EM9MYH"3)0* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " \^N" " ee9OK" " eW9ML"- - " " EL9XWH" " EM9ecH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " \^N" " W9!K" " W9Xc"- - " " EM9YWH" " EM9!!H"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " \^N" " !@LLe9WM" " !@W!!9ee"- - " " E!!K9eYH" " EYM9WeH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" \^N" " YOM9YX" " ccW9LL"- - " " Eec9LMH" " EK9ccH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " \^N" " M9We" " M9Xc"

- - " " EM9!!H" " EM9MWH"

"

Page 63: Economic Journal Issue 5

"YL

+)<'-*>*E]1%,/%-(.H*"J0&4(#2*)4,*K-):&#-* ** >LMNO:* ** >LLNO:* ** @NNNO:*

K)')2:$)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " XK9KY" " XO9eL" " X!9KM"- - E!9eMH" " EL9MLH" " E!9LYH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " !e9Le" " !L9Oc" " \^N"- - E!9MWH" " EM9XMH" " "DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " W@cKK9WM" " O@cLe9OM" " !M@YeM9YM"- - EeLe9L!H" " E!@LYL9XLH" " EXXX9YcH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" !@!eO9cW" " !@!eY9X!" " KWc9KX"- - EeY9LYH" " EOL9!!H" " EKK9XKH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9KO" " !9Wc" " !9Oc"

- - EM9!XH" " EM9!KH" " EM9McH"G=$'$//$4-:* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " XX9YW" " WM9LO" " XY9KK"- - EM9cXH" " EL9MLH" " EL9!!H"gW^g!"'$,/1" " O9cM" " !L9LK" " !M9OM"- - EM9LcH" " E!9LMH" " E!9eYH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " L@LYK9YM" " L@XeL9MM" " L@Ycc9LW"- - E!MM9c!H" " EKW9cWH" " EYM9KcH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" WeK9WY" " XKc9LM" " XMO9!O"- - E!M9YOH" " EeO9YYH" " E!L9!KH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9eO" " M9YX" " M9KK"

- - EM9MWH" " EM9!cH" " EM9MeH"+=)$')4,* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " XO9eM" " XK9eW" " Xe9!Y"- - EM9XcH" " EX9eOH" " E!9XcH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " !L9cY" " !e9OL" " O9We"- - EM9eOH" " EW9eXH" " EM9ccH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " L@OW!9OK" " W@LOY9MM" " W@OYW9MM"- - EXcX9L!H" " EYOX9Y!H" " E!cW9XLH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" XKM9LK" " WXL9Ke" " WLc9OW"- - EXL9KYH" " EWe9OYH" " E!W9cKH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9XO" " M9cX" " !9MW"

- - EM9MOH" " EM9MKH" " EM9MeH"

""

Page 64: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" Ye

+)<'-*>*E]1%,/%-(.H""J0&4(#2*)4,*K-):&#-* ** >LMNO:* ** >LLNO:* ** @NNNO:*

P$-(4)8* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " \^N" " eY9Mc" " eY9Wc"- - " " E!9!XH" " E!9eOH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " \^N" " W9O!" " W9OM"- - " " EM9eLH" " EM9WKH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " \^N" " !@LK!9!X" " !@cOK9LM"- - " " E!YW9YYH" " E!WK9OLH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" \^N" " eXY9YY" " X!e9KM"- - " " ELK9XcH" " ELL9XXH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " \^N" " M9YK" " !9MK"

- - " " EM9!!H" " EM9!XH"J=$4)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " eM9WK" " XM9eY" " XW9LO"- - Ee9XYH" " Ee9!cH" " E!9eOH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " X9K!" " O9MY" " !!9Me"- - EM9OOH" " E!9eOH" " EM9KWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " cOM9KM" " !@ccM9!M" " e@!WK9XM"- - ELMc9!cH" " EXOe9XWH" " EX!O9cYH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" LLe9cY" " eXY9ec" " XLc9!c"- - EeK9XKH" " EW!9MXH" " EeY9XWH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9WM" " M9Yc" " M9YW"

- - EM9!LH" " EM9!MH" " EM9MOH"Q)4"'),-:=* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " eY9MK" " ee9!e" " eL9XW"- - EL9MWH" " Ee9LYH" " EM9WYH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " Y9MW" " W9!!" " X9cL"- - EM9YeH" " EM9ccH" " EM9!MH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " YXK9cO" " ccM9MM" " Kcc9ee"- - EL!9!eH" " EWO9ceH" " EYL9!LH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" LMW9ML" " LMc9!L" " LLM9XX"- - EO9eWH" " EK9W!H" " Ec9WcH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9!W" " M9L!" " M9eM"

- - EM9M!H" " EM9MWH" " EM9MeH"

""

Page 65: Economic Journal Issue 5

"YX

+)<'-*>*E]1%,/%-(.H""J0&4(#2*)4,*K-):&#-* ** >LMNO:* ** >LLNO:* ** @NNNO:*

94,$)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " e!9ee" " ee9LW" " eY9XO"- - EM9YXH" " E!9KeH" " EM9LWH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " X9YW" " W9MY" " W9YO"- - EM9!cH" " EM9XcH" " EM9MWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " !@MXe9MM" " !@eKe9cM" " !@OYe9YM"- - Ecc9XLH" " E!cM9WeH" " E!XM9YWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" e!K9XL" " eOL9!!" " eKc9MY"- - E!X9LMH" " ELX9cXH" " E!!9LXH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9!!" " M9!c" " M9Le"

- - EM9M!H" " EM9MLH" " EM9MLH"R#$*3)45)* * * * * * *

D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%," " ec9Yc" " eL9eK" " eY9XW"- - EW9KeH" " E!9WeH" " Ee9cLH"gW^g!"'$,/1" " Y9YX" " X9Ke" " W9KX"- - E!9KeH" " EM9eXH" " EM9KMH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" " !@ccc9OM" " L@XLX9cM" " e@MLX9Yc"- - E!eW9XKH" " ELOX9!!H" " EYe9OWH"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"EN4'/B)+$'(H" XOX9cK" " WYK9!X" " WXe9MK"- - Eee9W!H" " E!O9cWH" " EKW9WKH"N4'/B,'$.("C0(%%())" " M9Wc" " M9YX" " M9cM"

-- -- EM9MKH" "" EM9MXH" "" EM9McH"

\1,(Z"-%6(/4+,(."<($%"8$2-(@"6/,+"),$%.$'.".(8/$,/1%)"/%"0$'(%,+()()9"G((",+("$00(%./A";1'".$,$")1-'*()9""

I1'" G1-,+" U$)," N)/$@" $22" *1-%,'/()"+$8(" +$." +/4+" (*1%1</*)" 4'16,+" -%,/2" ,+("4'($," (*1%1</*" *'/)/)" /%" !KKc9" P(" *$%"*$,(41'/7(" ,+()(" *1-%,'/()" /%,1" ,61" 4'1-0)@"+/4+" $%." </2." (*1%1</*" 4'16,+" *1-%,'/()9"?/4+" (*1%1</*" 4'16,+" 4'1-0" *1%)/),)" 1;"b%.1%()/$@" #$2$&)/$@" $%." :+$/2$%.9" b%" ,+()()"*1-%,'/()@"18('$22"/%*1<("+$)"4'16%"8('&";$),9"U)0(*/$22&" /%" #$2$&)/$@" ,+(/'" DTS" 0('" *$0/,$"/%*'($)(."'$0/.2&";'1<"W@cKK"VG".122$')"/%",+("

!KOM`)" ,1" !M@YeM" VG" .122$')" /%" ,+(" LMMM`)@"6+('($)" ,+(" /%*1<(" )+$'(" /%" $4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'" +$)" %1," 4'16%" $)" ;$),('" $)" ,+$%" ,+("18('$22" /%*1<(" +$)9" #($%6+/2(@" /%(=-$2/,&" /%",+()()" *1-%,'/()" +$8(" ./;;('(%," *+$%4()" /%",('<"1;"./'(*,/1%)9"I1'"#$2$&)/$"$%.":+$/2$%.@",+(" /%(=-$2/,/()" +$8(" $" ,(%.(%*&" ,1" .(*'($)("18('",/<(@"6+/2(",+("/%(=-$2/,&"/%"b%.1%()/$"+$)"%1,"*+$%4(."<-*+"5-,";2-*,-$,(."18('",/<(9":+("$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'"/%",+()()"*1-%,'/()"+$)")+'-%3"

Page 66: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" YW

$;,('" /%.-),'/$2/7$,/1%"6$)")('/1-)2&" /%,'1.-*(."/%,1" ,+(/'" (*1%1<&" /%" ,+(" !KOM`)9" G/%*(" ,+(".16%,-'%" /%" '(,-'%)" 1;" $4'/*-2,-'(" )(*,1'@" ,+("'()1-'*(" /%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'@"()0(*/$22&" 216B)3/22(." 2$51'@"<1),"1;"6+1<"$'(" ,+("011'@"$'("$22-'(." ,1" <18(" /%,1" /%.-),'/$2" )(*,1'" 6/,+"+/4+('"'(,-'%)9"?16(8('@"$%&"0$',)"1;",+("011'"/%" ,+()(" *1-%,'/()" $'(" ),/22" .(0(%.(%," 1%" ,+("$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9""

I1'" ,+(" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 10(%%())@"<1),"*1-%,'/()" /%"G1-,+"U$),"N)/$"+$8("5((%"=-/,(" 10(%" )/%*(" ,+(" !KOM`)" $%." +$." $",(%.(%*&" ,1" (%2$'4(" 18('" ,/<(@" ()0(*/$22&" /%"]$<51./$@" #$2$&)/$@" S+/2/00/%()@" :+$/2$%.@"$%."d/(,%$<9"]+/%$"$%."G'/"F$%3$"+$8("5((%"$2)1" =-/,(" 10(%" )/%*(" ,+(" !KOM`)" 5-," ,+("$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("10(%%())"+$)"%1,"5((%"=-/,("*+$%4(."18('",/<(9"N,",+("<($%,/<(@"Q$%42$.()+"$%." b%./$" +$8(" 5((%" ),/22" '(<$/%(." *21)(.")/%*(",+("!KOM`)9""

S?* 78/$#$%)'* K-(=0,* )4,* A-:&'(6*

T#0B(=*)4,*7F&)'$(2*

N)" ./)*-))(." /%" ,+(" 0'(8/1-)" )(*,/1%)@",+/)"0$0('"6/22";1*-)"1%"(A$</%/%4",+("2/%3$4("5(,6((%" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" $%." 018(',&"$22(8/$,/1%" /%" /%*1<(" *+$%%(29" C%" ,+(" 1,+('"61'.@" ,+(" =-(),/1%" kT1()" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%"/<0'18()" 4'16,+" $%." (8(%,-$22&" '(.-*()"018(',&lm" +$)" 5((%" *+$22(%4(.9" b%" ,+(" 21%4"'-%@"(*1%1</*"4'16,+"/)"$"*'-*/$2"'12(",1"'(.-*,/1%"1;" $5)12-,(" 018(',&9" C'" (A0(*,(." k,'/*32(B.16%m"(;;(*,)";'1<"(*1%1</*"4'16,+"6/22"*'($,("'()1-'*("

;1'" ,+(" 011'" 1'^$%." (%*1-'$4(" ,1" $**-<-2$,("0+&)/*$2" $%." +-<$%" *$0/,$2" /%" ,+(" 011'9"P/%,(')"*(-40"ELMMLH"$'4-(.",+$,"/;",+("k,'/*32(B.16%m"6/22"5("/%)-;;/*/(%,",1"0$))"5&",+("4'16,+"5(%(;/,",1",+("011'n",+("418('%<(%,)")+1-2."+$8("$../,/1%$2" <($)-'()" ,1" $;;(*," ,1" /%*1<("'(./),'/5-,/1%"$)"/%*1<("/)"+/4+('"$%."4'16/%4";$),('9" :+-)@" ,+(&" /<02/(." ,+$," ,+('(" $'(" ,61"0$',)" /%" *1%)/.('/%4" ,+(" =-(),/1%" $518(9" :+(";/'),"/)"kU;;(*,"1;"2/5('$2/7$,/1%",1"4'16,+m"$%.",+("1,+('"/)"kU;;(*,"1;"4'16,+",1"018(',&^"1'"/%*1<("./),'/5-,/1%m9""

5..*!(-".-(+42*-0)/*+40)64()"#-"#-1+"7(8-:+(" *2$))/*" ,+(1'&" /%./*$,()" 6/,+"

411." '($)1%)" ,+$," ,'$.(" +$)" 01)/,/8(" (;;(*,)"1%"'($2"/%*1<(9"V%.('",+("*2$))/*",'$.(",+(1'/()@"/%,('%$,/1%$2",'$.("5(,6((%"*1-%,'/()"/)"*$-)(."5&",+(" ./;;('(%*(" /%" '()1-'*(" (%.16<(%,)" 5(,6((%"*1-%,'/()9" #1'(18('@" ,+(" ,+(1'&" 0'101)(." <$%&"'($)1%)" ,1" $%,/*/0$,(" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" ,1"511),"(*1%1</*"4'16,+"/%"4(%('$29"b%",+(")+1',",('<@" E),$,/*H" 5(%(;/,)" /%" (;;/*/(%*&" /<0'18(<(%,";'1<" ,'$.(" *1-2." 5(" *1%)/.('(." $)" $" 4'16,+"511),('9" b%" ,+(" 21%4B'-%@" ,+("01,(%,/$2"01)/,/8(";$*,1')";'1<"<1'("*1<0(,/,/1%"(%;1'*("<$'3(,)",1" $**())" %(6" ,(*+%1214&" $%." $00'10'/$,("/%,('<(./$,("$%."*$0/,$2"411.)n" " ,1"4$/%"5(%(;/,)"1;"(*1%1</()"1;")*$2("$%."*1<0(,/,/1%n"$%.",1"*1%),'$/%"418('%<(%,"/%*1<0(,(%*("1;"*1''-0,/1%"ED'1))<$%" $%." ?(20<$%%@" !KK!" $%." F-*-)@"!KOOH9"#1'(18('@"<1.('%" ,'$.("0$,,('%)"+$8("'(*(%,2&" 5((%" <1'(" *1<02/*$,(." ,+$%" 5(;1'(@",+('(;1'(@",+("5(%(;/,)";'1<",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%"$'(" <-*+" <1'(" *1<02(A" ,1" 5(" .(*1<01)(.9"

Page 67: Economic Journal Issue 5

"YY

:+("<1.('%" ,'$.(" ,+(1'&" /)".(81,(." ,1"<$3(",+/)" *2$/<" ),'1%4('" 5&" /%,'1.-*/%4" <1'(" '($2/),/*"*1%*('%)"/%,1",+("<1.(2@"/9(9",'$.("/%"/<0(';(*,")-5),/,-,(" 1'" /%,'$B/%.-),'&" ,'$.(@" /%*'($)/%4"'(,-'%" ,1" )*$2(@" $%." (%.14(%1-)" ,(*+%1214&9"V%;1',-%$,(2&@"%(8(',+(2())@" %1%(" 1;" ,+(" 5(%(;/,)"/)" 4-$'$%,((." $%." ,+('(" $'(" )1<(" <1.(2)"6+/*+" ),'1%42&" ),$,(" ,+$," ,'$.(" 10(%%())"0-)+()"*1-%,'/()"/%,1"2())".&%$</*")(*,1')"E(949"0'/<$'&" (A,'$*,/1%H" $%." +$'<)" 4'16,+X9" :+("(<0/'/*$2" ),-./()" /%" (;;(*,)" 1;" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" ,1"4'16,+"$'("'(*(%,2&"*+$22(%4/%4"/%",('<"1;"0$',/*-2$'"$'4-<(%,)9""

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

/%.-),'/$2" )(*,1'" -%.('" ,+(" k,'/*32(B.16%" (;;(*,m"$))-<0,/1%9""

""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""X"I1'"(A$<02(@")(("J1.'/4-(7"$%."J1.'/3"ELMMMH"

?16(8('@",+/)"0$0('";1-%.",+("(<0/'/*$2"(8/.(%*(")-001',/%4" ,+(" 2/%3"5(,6((%"$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(" $%." (*1%1</*" 4'16,+9" P(" 5(4$%" 6/,+"(),/<$,/%4",+(";12216/%4"),$%.$'."4'16,+"'(4'())/1%"ET122$'"$%."_'$$&@"LMMXH"Z"

"

tititiktiti Xyy ,,'

,10, 9" E!H""

P+('(" "/)"%$,-'$2"214$'/,+<"1;"DTS"0('" *$0/,$" $," ,+(" (%." 1;" 0$',/*-2$'" 0('/1."<($)-'(." /%" '($2" SSS" $.>-),(." .122$'" ;1'"

*1-%,'&" /" @" " /)" /,)" 2$4" 3" &($')" $41@" $%."

" /)" $" )(," 1;" ,'$.(" 10(%%())" <($)-'()9":+/)" 0$0('" /%,'1.-*(." ,61"6(22B3%16%"10(%%())"/%./*$,1')9" N5)12-,(" ,'$.(" 812-<(" $%." DTS"%1'<$2/7(." ,'$.(" 812-<(" $'(" /%*2-.(." /%" ,+("

8$'/$52("/% 9""

tiy ,

ktiy ,

tiX ,

tiX ,

P("$.10,(.",+("(),/<$,/1%",(*+%/=-("0'101)(." 5&" ]$)(22/" (," $29" E!KKYH9" :+/)",(*+%/=-("'(*1<<(%.)",+$,"6/,+"0$%(2"4'16,+".$,$" ,+(" (=-$,/1%" E!H" )+1-2." 5(" (),/<$,(." /%"./;;('(%*()@" -)/%4" 0'10('" 2$4)" 1;" ,+(" J?G"8$'/$52()" $)" /%),'-<(%,)" ET122$'" $%." _'$$&@"LMMXH9" :+-)@" 6(" (),/<$,(.@" /%" 0$',/*-2$'@" ,+(";12216/%4"'(4'())/1%Z"

"

Page 68: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" Yc

" " ELH")()()()( ,,,,'

2,,1,, ktitikttktitiktiktiktiti XXyyyy"

:+/)"(=-$,/1%")+16(."$"'(4'())/1%"1;"4'16,+"1%" 2$44(."4'16,+"$%."*+$%4()" /%" ,+(")(," 1;" ,'$.(" 8$'/$52(" E10(%%())" <($)-'()H9"T122$'" $%." _'$$&" ELMMXH" ),$,(." ,+$," ,+/)"$00'1$*+" +$)" )(8('$2" .()/'$52(" ;($,-'()" ;1'"4'16,+" $%$2&)/)9" I1'" /%),$%*(@" ,+(" (),/<$,(."*1(;;/*/(%,)" /%" ,+(" 4'16,+" (=-$,/1%" 5&"./;;('(%*/%4",(*+%/=-("$'("2($8/%4"$"*1''(2$,/1%"6/,+"1</,,(.",/<(B/%8$'/$%,"*1-%,'&"*+$'$*,('/),/*)9""

N)" *$%" 5(" )((%" /%" :$52(" L@" ,+(" ;/'),",+'((" *12-<%)"0'()(%,"*1(;;/*/(%,"5&"1'./%$'&"2($),")=-$'("ECFGH"(),/<$,1')9"N2,+1-4+",+/)"(),/<$,/1%"<(,+1." /)" /%*1%)/),(%,@" /," /)" 8('&" +(20;-2" ,1")-<<$'/7(",+("0$',/$2"*1''(2$,/1%)"/%",+(".$,$9":+("'15-),"),$%.$'."(''1'"/)"'(01',(."/%"0$'(%,+()()9"P(" (),/<$,(." ,+(" *1(;;/*/(%,)" $%." ),$%.$'."(''1')" ,+$," $'(" '15-)," ,1" +(,('1)*(.$),/*/,&" $%.",+(" ;/'),B1'.('" $-,1*1''(2$,/1%" /%" ,+(" '()/.-$2)"/%.-*(."5&"./;;('(%*/%49""

:+("'()-2,"1;"'(4'())/1%)"/)"8('&"),'/3/%4",+$," ,+(" %1'<$2/7(." 10(%%())" E,'$.(" 812-<(H"*1(;;/*/(%,"/%"EeH"/)"%(4$,/8("$%."1,+('"*1(;;/*/(%,)"

/%" ,+("<1.(2" $'("$22" %(4$,/8(9"?16(8('@"6("*$%";/%." ,'$.(B4'16,+"(8/.(%*(" /%" E!H"$%."ELH"6/,+"+/4+")/4%/;/*$%," 2(8(29"#1.(2" ELH" /%./*$,()" ,+$,"*+$%4()" /%" ,'$.(" 812-<()" $'(" ),'1%42&"*1''(2$,(." 6/,+" ,+(" *+$%4(" /%" 4'16,+@" 6/,+" $"01/%,"(),/<$,("/%./*$,/%4",+$,"!MMi"/%*'($)("/%",+(" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 812-<(" 61-2." +$8(" ,+("(;;(*," 1;" '/)/%4" 0('" *$0/,$" /%*1<(" 5&" !L9Xi9":+(" (;;(*," 1;" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 1%" /%*1<(" /)")-'0'/)/%42&" ,11" +/4+9" N)" CFG" /%*1%)/),(%*&"6$)" 0'(8/1-)2&" ./)*-))(.@" 6(" /%,'1.-*(." 1%(B),(0" ./;;('(%*(" D(%('$2/7(." #(,+1." 1;" #1<(%,"ED##H" (),/<$,1'" /%,1" <1.(2" EXH9" P(" ),/22"'(<$/%" ,+(" ;/')," 2$44(." 0('/1." 1;" /%*1<(@" 5-,".'10",+(")(*1%."2$44(."0('/1.9":+("*1(;;/*/(%,"'(0'()(%,/%4",+("(;;(*,"1;"$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("1%"/%*1<(" /)" </2.('" $%." <1'(" '($)1%$52(" 6/,+"+/4+" ),$,/),/*$2" )/4%/;/*$%*(9" b%" <1.(2" EXH@" !MMi"/%*'($)("/%",+("$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("812-<("61-2."+$8(",+("(;;(*,"1;"'/)/%4"0('"*$0/,$" /%*1<("5&"X9Wi9""""

"

Page 69: Economic Journal Issue 5

"YO

+)<'-*@*T#0B(=*)4,*+#),-*A-"#-::$04:*

*

*I-/?*1)#*6*TIG*/-#*%)/$()*

U>V**

D3R*

U@V*

D3R*

UCV**

D3R*

USV**

TKK*

b%/,/$2"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"E(9:H" M9WeY" M9XOM" BM9MKW" EM9MXWH"" EM9!MWHooo" EM9!McHooo" EM9!M!H" EM9MLWHooo"b%/,/$2"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"E(9;H" " M9MOK" BM9!L!" "" " EM9MXXHo" EM9MOMH" "N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("10(%%())"" " " " "N5)12-,(" M9!!c" M9!LX" " M9MXW"

" EM9MeXHooo" EM9MeYHooo" " EM9MLWHooo"\1'<$2/7(." " " BM9MYK" "

" " " EM9MXLH" "\19"1;"C5)9" !KW" !OX" !OX" !KW"EooH"EoooH"/%./*$,(")/4%/;/*$%*("$,",+("!M"EWH"E!H"2(8(2"N22"'(4'())/1%)"/%*2-.(."0('/1.".-<</()"E%1,"'(01',(.H"D##"p"C%(B),(0"./;;('(%*("D##"(),/<$,1'"CFG"p"C'./%$'&"2($),")=-$'("(),/<$,1'"

":+(" 02$-)/52(" (A02$%$,/1%" ;1'" ,+("

$00$'(%," (;;(*," 1;" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" 1%"4'16,+"/)",+$,",+("(%2$'4(."$4'/*-2,-'$2"<$'3(,"6/,+"+/4+('"812-<("1;"$4'/*-2,-'$2"(A01',)"+$)",+("./'(*,"E),$,/*H"(;;(*,"1%"4'16,+9"#($%6+/2(@",+(" <1'(" *1<0(,/,/8(" <$'3(," /%" $4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'" (%;1'*()" (;;/*/(%*&" /<0'18(<(%," )-*+"$)"<1'(" (%;1'*(." 0'1.-*,/8/,&" /%" ;$'</%4" $%.";11."/%.-),'&"E*-2,/8$,/%4"$%."0'1*())/%4H9""

:+/)" $'4-<(%," $51-," ,+(" 5(%(;/*/$2"(;;(*," 1;" ,'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" 1%" 4'16,+" /)"*1%)/),(%,"6/,+",+("$'4-<(%,"*2$/<(."5&"T122$'"$%."_'$$&"ELMMXH9":+(&"$'4-(.",+$,",+("01))/52("(A02$%$,/1%";1'",+("(;;(*,"1;",'$.("1%"4'16,+"/)",+$," /," '(;2(*,)" /<0'18(<(%," /%" /%),/,-,/1%$2"=-$2/,&"1</,,(." ;'1<" ,+(" '(4'())/1%"$%$2&)/)" $%." ,+/)"

/<0'18(<(%," /)" ,+(")/4%/;/*$%,"./'(*,"(;;(*,"1%",+("4'16,+"$%."6(2;$'("1;"(*1%1<&9""""""""

W?*7XX-%(*X#08*"#0B(=*(0*/01-#(2*

)4,*$4%08-*,$:(#$<&($04*

b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

Page 70: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" YK

,+(" ;12216/%4" '(4'())/1%" ET122$'" $%." _'$$&@"LMMXH",1";/%."$%&"(8/.(%*("/%",+/)"*1%*('%9"

tiitititi Xyy ,,,10,P '

P

" EeH"

P+('("/"$%.","/%.(A"*1-%,'&"$%."&($'@"*1%)(*-,/8(2&9" T122$'" $%." _'$$&" ELMMXH" -)(."%$,-'$2" 214$'/,+<" 1;" 0('" *$0/,$" /%*1<(" 1;" ,+("011'"<($)-'(."/%"'($2"SSS"$.>-),(.".122$'";1'"

*1-%,'&" /9" $)" ,+(" .(0(%.(%," 8$'/$52(@ " ,1"*1%*(%,'$,(" 1%2&" 1%" 018(',&" '(.-*,/1%@"6+('($)" ,+/)" 0$0('" ;1*-)()" 1%" 51,+" 018(',&"$%." /%*1<(" /%(=-$2/,&")-*+" ,+$,"6(" /%,'1.-*("%1," 1%2&" ,+(" 018(',&" <($)-'(" 5-," $2)1"/%(=-$2/,&" <($)-'()" ,1" 5(" ,+(" .(0(%.(%,"8$'/$52(9" :+(" D/%/" *1(;;/*/(%," EDb\bH" $%." ,+("'$,/1" 1;" /%*1<(" ($'%(." 5&" ,+(" ,10" /%*1<("=-$',/2(" ,1" /%*1<(" ($'%(." 5&" ,+(" 51,,1<"=-$',/2(" EgW^g!H" $'(" ,+(" .(0(%.(%," 8$'/$52()"/%" ,+(" '(4'())/1%" /%8(),/4$,/%4" /%(=-$2/,&"'(.-*,/1%@"6+/2(",+(".(0(%.(%,"8$'/$52("/%",+("'(4'())/1%"(A$</%/%4"018(',&"$22(8/$,/1%"/)",+(")$<(" 8$'/$52(" -)(." /%" T122$'" $%." _'$$&"ELMMXH9""

tiy ,

tiX , " /)" $" 8(*,1'" 1;" ,'$.(" 10(%%())"<($)-'()" 6+/*+" /)" $" '$,/1" 1;" ,1,$2" ,'$.("812-<(" E(A01'," 02-)" /<01',H" ,1" DTS@" 1'" ,+("%1'<$2/7(."$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("10(%%())"E,+$,"/)"

-)(." /%" 4'16,+" '(4'())/1%" <1.(2H9" ".(%1,()" %$,-'$2" 214$'/,+<" 1;" %$,/1%6/.(" 0('"*$0/,$" /%*1<(9"F/3("(''1'" ,('<)" /%" ,+("4'16,+"

'(4'())/1%@"

tiy ,

i " $%." ti , " .(%1,(" $" *1<01)/,("(''1'",('<"/%*2-./%4"-%15)('8(."*1-%,'&"(;;(*,)9"""

N)" *$%" 5(" )((%" /%" :$52(" e@" ,+(" ;/'),",61"*12-<%)"0'()(%,",+("'(4'())/1%"(A$</%/%4"018(',&" $22(8/$,/1%9" Q1,+" $5)12-,(" $%."%1'<$2/7(." $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 10(%%())()" $'("),'1%42&" *1''(2$,(." 6/,+" ,+(" 011'`)" /%*1<(@"6/,+" $" 01/%," (),/<$,(" /%" ELH" /%./*$,/%4" ,+$,"!MMi"/%*'($)("/%",+("$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("812-<("%1'<$2/7(." 5&"DTS"61-2." +$8(" ,+(" (;;(*," 1;"'/)/%4" ,+(" 011'`)" 0('" *$0/,$" /%*1<(" 5&" K9Oi9":+-)@" 5$)(." 1%" ,+()(" (<0/'/*)@" ,+(" $4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%"*$%"+$8(",+("01)/,/8("(;;(*,"1%"018(',&" /%".(8(210/%4"*1-%,'/()"6+1)(" ,+("011'"$'(".(0(%.(%,"1%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9""

:+(" '(4'())/1%)" /%" EeH" $%." EXH" /%./*$,(",+$," /%(=-$2/,&"<($)-'()@" D/%/" *1(;;/*/(%," $%."gW^g!"'$,/1@"+$8("),'1%4"%(4$,/8("'(2$,/1%)+/0"6/,+" ,+(" ,'$.(" <($)-'(" /%" %1'<$2/7(." ,('<9""b%" '(4'())/1%" EeH@" !MMi" /%*'($)(" /%" ,+("$4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 812-<(" %1'<$2/7(." 5&"DTS"61-2."+$8(",+("(;;(*,"1;".(*2/%/%4"D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"5&"e9LcK9" b%"$../,/1%@" ;'1<"'(4'())/1%" EXH@"!MMi"/%*'($)(" /%" ,+(" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.(" 812-<("%1'<$2/7(." 5&"DTS"61-2." +$8(" ,+(" (;;(*," 1;".(*2/%/%4"gW^g!"'$,/1"5&"!9eOc9":+("/%(=-$2/,&"'(4'())/1%)" $'4-(" ,+$," ,+(" <1'(" $4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(" 812-<(" 1'" ,+(" ;'(('" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%@" ,+(" 2())" /%(=-$2/,&" /%".(8(210/%4"*1-%,'/()" 6+1)(" ,+(" 011'" $'(" .(0(%.(%," 1%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9"

Page 71: Economic Journal Issue 5

"cM

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

$22(8/$,(" ,+(/'" 018(',&" $%." 5(" (=-$,(." ,1" ,+("1,+('"4'1-0)"/%",('<)"1;"<1%(&9""

#1'(18('@" G,120('BG$<-(2)1%" EGGH",+(1'(<" *2$/<)" ,+$," $%" /%*'($)(" /%" 0'/*()" 1;",'$.$52("$%."2$51'B/%,(%)/8("0'1.-*,)"6/22"'$/)("'($2" 2$51'" /%*1<()" $%." .(*'($)(" '($2" *$0/,$2"'(,-'%)9" b%" 1-'" *$)(@" $)" $4'/*-2,-'$2" ,'$.("511<)@" ,+(" 0'/*()" 1;" $4'/*-2,-'$2" 0'1.-*,)" /%",+()(" *1-%,'/()" /%*'($)(" 5(*$-)(" 1;" 2$'4('"<$'3(," )/7(" $%." +/4+('" .(<$%." ;'1<" $'1-%."1;" ,+(" 61'2.9" :+(%@" ,+(" '(,-'%" /%" $4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'" 6/22" /%*'($)(" $)" 6(229" U8(%,-$22&@" '($2"/%*1<(" 1;" ,+(" 011'" 6+1" $'(" .(0(%.(%," 1%"$4'/*-2,-'$2" )(*,1'" 6/22" '(2$,/8(2&" /%*'($)(9" N,",+("(%.@",+("/%(=-$2/,&"6/22".(*'($)(9""

*

+)<'-*C*G01-#(2Y*94-F&)'$(2*)4,*+#),-*A-"#-::$04:*

"

" S18(',&"'(.-*,/1%" b%(=-$2/,&"'(.-*,/1%"T(09"8$'/$52(Z" S11'`)"DTS"0('"*$0/,$" D/%/"(;;/*/(%," gW^g!"'$,/1"

" E!H"" ELH" EeH"" EXH""\$,/1%6/.("DTS"0('"*$0/,$" M9YcW" M9cKM" Y9XOW" L9cXL"" EM9MYWHooo" EM9MecHooo" EM9KKcHooo" EM9WMeHooo"N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("10(%%())"" " " " "N5)12-,(" M9MOY" " " "

" EM9MLKHooo" " " "\1'<$2/7(." " M9MKO" Be9LcK" B!9eOc"

" " EM9MeKHoo" E!9MXKHooo" EM9We!Hoo"JB)=Z""P/,+/%" M9OMeW" M9OM!L" M9!cWO" M9!eX"""""Q(,6((%" M9cOKY" M9OXOK" M9L!XK" M9ecK"

"""""""""""C8('$22" M9cYXW" M9O!Wc" M9LYMO" M9LOX"\19"1;"C5)9" LMO" LMO" L!c" LMO"

EooH"EoooH"/%./*$,(")/4%/;/*$%*("$,",+("!M"EWH"E!H"2(8(2"N22"'(4'())/1%)"-)(."1'./%$'&"2($),")=-$'("ECFGH"(),/<$,1'"/%"0$%(2".$,$"6/,+";/A(."(;;(*,9"

"

Page 72: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" c!

Z?*J04%'&:$04*

:+(" (<0/'/*$2" '()-2,)" 0'()(%,(." /%",+/)" 0$0('" 0'18/.(" )-001'," ;1'" $4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(" (;;(*,)" 1%" /%(=-$2/,&@" ()0(*/$22&" /%" ,+("*1-%,'/()"6+1)("$2<1),"011'"$'("/%"$4'/*-2,-'$2")(*,1'9" P(" +$8(" /.(%,/;/(." ,+(" .(8(210/%4"*1-%,'/()" 6+/*+" 1'/4/%$22&" (%.16" 6/,+"$4'/*-2,-'$2" '()1-'*()@" /9(9" $'$52(" 2$%." $%."%$,-'$2"/''/4$,/1%"$%.",+()("*1-%,'/()`"011'"$'(".(0(%.(%," 1%" $4'/*-2,-'$2" )(*,1'" /%" 51,+";$'</%4" $%." ;11." 0'1*())/%4" )(%)()9" :+(%@"6(";1-%.",+$,@" /%",+("*$)("1;",+()("*1-%,'/()@"$4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.("2/5('$2/7$,/1%"E,+$,"6("5(2/(8("/," *$-)()"$4'/*-2,-'$2" 511<H"+$)"(;;(*,)" 1%"51,+"4'16,+@"$%."018(',&9"#1'(18('@" ,+/)"(;;(*,"6/22"$2)1"/<0'18("/%(=-$2/,&"/%",+()("*1-%,'/()9" "

"

A-X-#-4%-:*

Q$2.6/%@"J15(',@" $%."I'q.q'/*"J15(',B\/*1-.9"LMMO9"k:'$.("$%."4'16,+"6/,+"+(,('14(%(1-)";/'<)m" a1-'%$2" 1;" b%,('%$,/1%$2"U*1%1</*)"cXZ"L!BeX9""

]$)(22/@" I9@" U)=-/8(2@" D9" $%." F(;1',@" I9" !KKY"kJ(10(%/%4" ,+(" *1%8('4(%*(".(5$,(Z" $"%(6" 2113" $," *'1))B4'16,+" (<0/'/*)m9"a1-'%$2" 1;" U*1%1</*" D'16,+@" 8129" !@"eYeBOK9"

]1*35-'%@"a1+%9"LMM!9""r:'$.("F/5('$2/7$,/1%"$%."S18(',&" /%"\(0$2Z" N"]1<0-,$52("D(%('$2"U=-/2/5'/-<" #/*'1" G/<-2$,/1%" N%$2&)/)r9""]JUIN"P1'3/%4"S$0('"EM!B!OH9"N8$/2$52("$,Z"6669*'(;$9(*%9-2$8$29*$^*$+/('^M!!O90.;9""

]14%($-@"T(%/)@""$%."N%%("G10+/("J15/22/$'.9"LMMM9""rD'16,+@"T/),'/5-,/1%"$%."S18(',&""/%" #$.$4$)*$'Z" U=-/2/5'/-<" " I'$<(61'39r""F($'%/%4" ;'1<" " $"#/*'1)/<-2$,/1%" "#1.(2""/%" $" D(%('$2" U=-/2/5'/-<" I'$<(61'39m"bISJb":#T"T/)*-))/1%"S$0('"Y!9"

]1%6$&@":/<9"LMMX9"k:'$.("F/5('$2/7$,/1%"$%."S18(',&"J(.-*,/1%9m"C8(')($"T(8(210<(%,"b%),/,-,(9"F1%.1%9""

T($,1%@"N%4-)9"!KOK9"kJ/*("S'/*("$%."b%*1<("./),'/5-,/1%" /%" :+$/2$%.Z" N" \1%B0$'$<(,'/*" N%$2&)/)9m" :+(" U*1%1</*"a1-'%$2"KK"Z"!Bec9"

T122$'@"T$8/."$%."N$',"_'$$&9"LMML9"kD'16,+"b)"D11." ;1'" ,+(" S11'm9" a1-'%$2" 1;"U*1%1</*"D'16,+9""

RRRRRRR9"LMMX9"k:'$.(@"D'16,+@"$%."S18(',&m9":+("U*1%1</*"a1-'%$2@"!!X" EI(5'-$'&H@"ILLBIXK9""

U8$%)@"T$8/.9"LMM!9""rb.(%,/;&/%4"P/%%(')"$%."F1)(')" /%" G1-,+('%" N;'/*$" ;'1<" D215$2":'$.(""S12/*&"J(;1'<Z"b%,(4'$,/%4"I/%./%4)"";'1<"D:NS"$%."S18(',&"]$)(""G,-./()";1'"$"f$<5/$%"UA$<02(9r"S$0('"0'(0$'(." ;1'",+(" UGJ]" T(8(210<(%," U*1%1</*)" ^"b%,('%$,/1%$2" U*1%1</*)" ]1%;('(%*(@"\1,,/%4+$<"V%/8(')/,&@"N0'/2"WBc@"LMM!9"

I'$%3(2@"a(;;'(&"$%."N%.'(6"J1)(9"LMML9" kN%"(),/<$,("1;",+("(;;(*,"1;"*1<<1%"*-''(%*/()"1%" ,'$.(" $%." /%*1<(m" a1-'%$2" 1;"U*1%1</*"F/,('$,-'(9"

I'$%3(2@" a(;;'(&@" $%." T$8/." J1<('9" !KKK9"kT1()" :'$.(" ]$-)(" D'16,+lm" NUJ"OeEeH"a-%(Z"ecKBeKK9"

Page 73: Economic Journal Issue 5

"cL

I'$%3(2@" a(;;'(&@" T$8/." J1<('@" $%." :('()$"]&'-)@"!KKY9"r:'$.("$%."D'16,+"/%"U$),"N)/$%" ]1-%,'/()Z" ]$-)(" $%." U;;(*,lr""\QUJ"P1'3/%4"S$0('"\19"WceL"EN-4-),H9"b%"\b])" N;,('" N)/$%" #/'$*2(@" \(6" P1'2."C'.('"G('/()@"8129"Le@"(./,(."5&"?9"G/%4('@"\9"?$,,/"$%."J9:$%.1%"Eb%./$Z"QJS-52/)+/%4"]1'01'$,/1%@"F,.9@";1',+*1</%4H9"

I'/(.<$%@"a(.9""LMM!9"rT/;;('(%,/$2""b<0$*,)""1;":'$.("F/5('$2/7$,/1%""1%"b%.1%()/$h)""S11'"$%."\1%BS11'9r"S$0('"0'(0$'(."";1'",+(""]1%;('(%*(" " 1%" " S18(',&" " $%." " ,+(""b%,('%$,/1%$2" " U*1%1<&@" 1'4$%/7(." " 5&"P1'2.""Q$%3""$%.""G6(./)+""S$'2/$<(%,$'&""]1<</))/1%""1%""D215$2""T(8(210<(%,@""G,1*3+12<@"C*,15('"LMBL!@"LMMM9"

D'((%$6$&" T$8/.@" P&%" #1'4$%@" $%." S(,('"P'/4+,9" LMML9" k:'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" $%."4'16,+" /%".(8(210/%4"*1-%,'/()m"a1-'%$2"1;" T(8(210<(%," U*1%1</*)" d129" YcZ"LLKsLXX9"

D'1))<$%@"D9"#9"$%."U9"?(20<$%9"!KK!9""b%%18$,/1%"$%." D'16,+" /%" ,+(" D215$2" U*1%1<&@"]$<5'/.4(@" #$))" $%." F1%.1%Z" #b:"S'())9"

D-+$@" Q'/)+,/9" LMMY9" kD'((%" J(812-,/1%)" $%."#/'$*2("U*1%1</()Z"N4'/*-2,-'$2" b%%18$,/1%)@":'$.(" $%."D'16,+m" a1-'%$2" 1;" b%,('%$,/1%$2":'$.("$%."U*1%1</*"T(8(210<(%,"d129"!W@"\19"L"a-%(Z"LMK"s"LLK9"

?$''/)@" "J(5(**$""F((9""LMM!9""rN""]1<0-,$52(""D(%('$2" " U=-/2/5'/-<" " N%$2&)/)" " 1;"#(A/*1h)" " N4'/*-2,-'$2" S12/*&" J(;1'<)9m"bISJb":#T"T/)*-))/1%"S$0('"YW9"

?$''/)1%@" D2(%%" P9@" :+1<$)" I9" J-,+(';1'.@""$%." T$8/." D9" :$''9" LMMM9" " r:'$.("F/5('$2/7$,/1%@" S18(',&" $%." U;;/*/(%,"U=-/,&9r" " U*1%1</*)"P1'3/%4"S$0('" QBO!BML@" #11'(" G*+112" 1;" Q-)/%())@"V%/8(')/,&"1;"G1-,+"]$'12/%$9"

?(',(2@" :+1<$)" P9@" S$-2" d9" S'(*3(2@" $%."a(;;'(&"a9"J(/<('9"LMM!9""r:'$.("S12/*&@"I11." S'/*(" d$'/$5/2/,&@" $%." ,+("d-2%('$5/2/,&" 1;" F16Bb%*1<(" ?1-)(+12.)9m"S$0('" 0'(0$'(." ;1'" #((,/%4" 1;" ,+("N<('/*$%"N4'/*-2,-'$2"U*1%1</*)"N))1*/$,/1%@"]+/*$41@"b22/%1/)@"N-4-),"YBO@"LMM!9"

b$%*+18/*+/%$@" "U2(%$@" "N2())$%.'1" "\/*/,$@" "$%.""b)/.'1""G121$4$9""LMM!9""r:'$.(""J(;1'<""$%.""?1-)(+12."P(2;$'(Z"":+("]$)(""1;"#(A/*1@r""S12/*&""J()($'*+""P1'3/%4""S$0('"\19""LYYc@":+("P1'2.""Q$%3"T(8(210<(%,"J()($'*+":'$.("D'1-0@"N-4-),9"

a1+%" ]9" Q(4+/%@" T$8/." J12$%.B?12),@" $%."T1</%/=-("8$%".('"#(%)5'-44+(9"LMML9"kD215$2"N4'/*-2,-'$2":'$.("$%.",+("T1+$"J1-%.Z" P+$," N'(" ,+(" b<02/*$,/1%)" ;1'"\1',+" $%." G1-,+lm" P1'3/%4" S$0('" MLBPS" eMO@" ](%,('" ;1'" N4'/*-2,-'$2" $%." J-'$2"T(8(210<(%,@"b16$"G,$,("V%/8(')/,&9"

F(8/%)1+%@" a$<()@" " G,(8(%" Q(''&@" $%." a(."I'/(.<$%9""!KKK9"rb<0$*,)"1;",+("b%.1%()/$%"U*1%1</*" " ]'/)/)Z" S'/*(" ]+$%4()" $%.",+(" S11'9r" S$0('" 0'(0$'(." ;1'" ,+("]1%;('(%*(" 1%" S18(',&" $%." ,+("b%,('%$,/1%$2" U*1%1<&@" 1'4$%/7(." 5&"P1'2."Q$%3"$%."G6(./)+"S$'2/$<(%,$'&""]1<</),/1%" 1%" D215$2" T(8(210<(%,@"

Page 74: Economic Journal Issue 5

N4'/*-2,-'$2",'$.(B018(',&"F/%3$4("Z"N%"U<0/'/*$2"b%8(),/4$,/1%" ce

G,1*3+12<@" C*,('5('" LMBL!@" LMMM9"I1',+*1</%4" /%" #$%$4/%4" ]-''(%*&"]'/)/)" /%" U<('4/%4" #$'3(,)@" #/*+$(2"T112(&" $%." a(;;'(&" I'$%3(2@" (.9@" :+("V%/8(')/,&"1;"]+/*$41"S'())9"

F1;4'(%@""?$%)9""!KKK9""r:'$.(""J(;1'<""$%."",+("S11'""/%"#1'1**1Z""N""J-'$2BV'5$%""D(%('$2""U=-/2/5'/-<"N%$2&)/)"1;"J(.-*(."S'1,(*,/1%9r""bISJb":#T"T/)*-))/1%"S$0('"eO9"

F-*$)@"J9U9""!KOO9"k:+("<(*+$%/*)"1;"(*1%1</*".(8(210<(%,m@"a1-'%$2"1;"#1%(,$'&"U*1%1</*)@"812"LL@"009eBXL9"

#/%1,@"\/*+12$)@"$%."I'$%*()*1"D12(,,/9"LMMM9""rJ/*("#$'3(,"F/5('$2/7$,/1%"$%."S18(',&"/%"d/(,"\$<9r""bISJb"J()($'*+"J(01',"\19!!X9"

J$8$22/1%@"#$',/%9"!KKM9""kJ-'$2"P(2;$'("U;;(*,)"1;"I11." S'/*(" ]+$%4(V%.('" b%.-*(."P$4("J()01%)()Z" :+(1'&" $%." U8/.(%*(" ;1'"Q$%42$.()+9m" CA;1'." U*1%1</*" S$0(')"XLZ"WcXBWOW9"

J$8$22/1%@" #$',/%@" $%." T1</%/=-(" 8$%" .("P$22(9"!KK!9""r:+("b<0$*,"1%"S18(',&"1;"I11." S'/*/%4" J(;1'<)Z" N" P(2;$'("N%$2&)/)" ;1'" b%.1%()/$9r" " a1-'%$2" 1;"S12/*&"#1.(2/%4"!eELHZ"LO!BLKK9"

J1.'/4-(7@"I'$%*/)*1@"$%."T$%/"J1.'/39"LMMM9"k:'$.("S12/*&"$%."U*1%1</*"D'16,+Z"N"G3(0,/*`)" D-/.(" ,1" ,+(" ]'1))B\$,/1%$2"U8/.(%*(@m"#$*'1(*1%1</*)"N%%-$2"LMMM9"Q(%"Q$'%$%3("$%."_(%%(,+"J141;;@" (.)9@"0'(0$'(." ;1'" ,+("#b:" 0'())9"PS" 8(')/1%Z"+,,0Z^^3)4+1<(9+$'8$'.9(.-^t.'1.'/3^)3(0,/!LKK90.;9"

V_"T(0$',<(%," ;1'" b%,('%$,/1%$2"T(8(210<(%,"ETIbTH9" LMMX9" kN4'/*-2,-'$2" :'$.(" $%."S18(',&" J(.-*,/1%Z" C001',-%/,&" 1'":+'($,lm"P1'3/%4"S$0('9"N-4-),9""

P$*7/$'4@" J1<$/%" $%." _$'(%" ?1'%" P(2*+9"LMMO9"k:'$.("F/5('$2/7$,/1%"$%."D'16,+Z"\(6"U8/.(%*(m":+("P1'2."Q$%3"U*1%1</*"J(8/(6"N.8$%*("N**())"0-52/)+(.@"a-%(Z"!sXW9" C%2/%(" 8(')/1%Z" 6669),$%;1'.9(.-^"t6$*7/$'4^.16%21$.)^/%,(4'$,/1%90.;9"

P$''@" S(,('"D9" LMM!9" " kP(2;$'(" $%."T/),'/5-,/1%"U;;(*,)" 1;" $%" UA01'," :$AZ" :+$/2$%.`)"J/*(" S'(</-<9m" N<('/*$%" a1-'%$2" 1;"N4'/*-2,-'$2"U*1%1</*)9"OeEXH"E\18(<5('HZ"KMeBKLM9"

P/%,(')@"F9"N2$%9"LMM!9"k:'$.("S12/*/()";1'"S18(',&"N22(8/$,/1%" /%" T(8(210/%4" ]1-%,'/()@r" /%":'$.("S12/*&@"U*1%1</*"T(8(210<(%,"$%."#-2,/2$,('$2"\(41,/$,/1%)Z"N"G1-'*(5113@"Q"?1(3<$%"$%."S"U%42/)+"$%."N"#$,,11@"U.)9"P$)+/%4,1%"T]Z"P1'2."Q$%39""

P/%,(')@" F9" N2$%9" LMMX9" k:'$.(" 2/5('$2/7$,/1%" $%."S18(',&Z":+("(8/.(%*(")1";$'m"a1-'%$2"1;"U*1%1</*" F/,('$,-'(@" d129" XL9" \19" !"E#$'9H" 009" cLB!!W@" N<('/*$%" U*1%1</*"N))1*/$,/1%9"

P/%,(')@"F9"N2$%@"\(/2"#*]-221*+@"$%."N%.'(6"#*_$&9" LMML9" k:'$.(" 2/5('$2/)$,/1%" $%."018(',&Z":+("(<0/'/*$2"(8/.(%*(m9"]JUTb:"J()($'*+" 0$0('@"\19" ML^LL9"](%,'(" ;1'"J()($'*+" /%" U*1%1</*" T(8(210<(%,"$%." b%,('%$,/1%$2" :'$.(@" V%/8(')/,&" 1;"\1,,/%4+$<9"

"

Page 75: Economic Journal Issue 5

"cX

!//-4,$[*>*P)#$)<'-*I-X$4$($04:*)4,*I)()*R0&#%-:?*

"P)#$)<'-* I-X$4$($04* R0&#%-*

D/%/"]1(;;/*/(%," :+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"/)"4/8(%"$)"$"0'101',/1%"1'"0('*(%,$4(9":+(1'(,/*$22&@",+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"6/22"5("(=-$2",1"M"6+(%",+("./),'/5-,/1%"/)"(=-$2",1"$229"b;",+(")1*/(,&h)",1,$2"/%*1<("*1<()"/%,1",+("01))())/1%"1;"1%2&"1%("0(')1%^+1-)(+12."-%/,@"2($8/%4",+("'(),"6/,+"%1"/%*1<("$,"$22@",+(%",+("D/%/"*1(;;/*/(%,"$00'1$*+()"!@"1'"!MMi"

V\VBPbTUJ"P1'2."b%*1<("b%(=-$2/,&"T$,$5$)("EPbbTH@"8(')/1%"L9M*9"

gW^g!"'$,/1" ,+("'$,/1"1;"/%*1<("($'%(."5&",+(",10"/%*1<("=-$',/2(",1"/%*1<("($'%(."5&",+("51,,1<"=-$',/2("

V\VBPbTUJ"P1'2."b%*1<("b%(=-$2/,&"T$,$5$)("EPbbTH@"8(')/1%"L9M*9"

DTS"0('"*$0/,$"" DTS"0('"*$0/,$"$,",+("(%."1;"0$',/*-2$'"0('/1."<($)-'(."/%"'($2"SSS"$.>-),(.".122$'";1'"*1-%,'&-)9"

P1'2."T(8(210<(%,"b%./*$,1'"EPTbH@"P1'2."Q$%39"

N4'/*-2,-'$2")+$'(" N4'/*-2,-'(@"8$2-("$..(."Ei"1;"DTSH" P1'2."T(8(210<(%,"b%./*$,1'"EPTbH@"P1'2."Q$%39"

C0(%%())"/%./*$,1'" :+("10(%%())"/%./*$,1'"*$%"5("(A0'())(."5&",+("'$,/1"5(,6((%",1,$2",'$.("E(A01',"02-)"/<01',H"$%."DTS9"b%"1-'"*$)(@"(A01',"$%."/<01',"/%"$4'/*-2,-'$2"$%.";11."E5$)(.".(;/%/,/1%"5&"INCH"$'("*$2*-2$,(.9"

I11."$%."$4'/*-2,-'(",'$.(".$,$@"INC"G:N:9"

S('"*$0/,$"/%*1<("1;",+("011'" g!"0('*(%,$4("<-2,/02&"5&"DTS"0('"*$0/,$"

]1<0-,$,/1%""

"

"

Page 76: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"#!"#$%&'('!)#!*+,!-..,/*!).!0#.%$*()#!)#!!1,2')#$%!0#/)3,!4$5!!6728,#!

!! !!"!! !#"!!

!! !$"!!

!

" " """ "#%&'(#%)*"

"#" " " """

" " " " "" "#%##" +" "#%#*" #%)$(#%)%""

"" "

"" " "

" " "#%!,+" "#%#$+" "#%#'+" "#%$#+" "#%$%+" "#%)#" "#%)-"" " "#%!,+" "#%#$+" "#%$#" "

#%)-" ""

" " " "" " "

" " " "#%&'(#%)*""

"#%&'(#%)*" """"

!9"" +" +" """.................................."

!" " "" "#" "" "" " "$" "" "" " " "

Page 77: Economic Journal Issue 5

",-

":'*2$/*!

" /01"23425616"57"8096"683:;"<141"85"683:;"801"1771=86"57"9>7?@895>"5>"21465>@?"9>=5A1"8@B"C34:1>"@>:" 85" 683:;" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>"5>"21465>@?" 9>=5A1" 8@B"1D398;E"/096" 683:;" 9>F5?F1:"@>"@>@?;696" 57" :@8@" :349>G" 801" ;1@46" !'--(#&&%E" /01" @>@?;696" 57" 8096" 683:;" <@6" :9F9:1:" 9>85" 8<5"2@486E"/01" 79468"2@48"<@6"@"683:;"57" 80154;"369>G" 801"0;2580189=@?" 618"57" 41@?" 9>=5A1":@8@E"/01"61=5>:"2@48"<@6"@"683:;"57"41@?":@8@"369>G"61=5>:@4;":@8@E"" /01"4163?86"57"801"683:;"41F1@?1:"80@8"801"4163?86"57"9>7?@895>"=@361:"@>"9>=41@61"9>"801"8@B" C34:1>" 5>" 8@B2@;146E/01" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" =@361:" @>" 9>=41@61" 9>" 801" 8@B" C34:1>" 5>"8@B2@;146"1B=128"9>"801";1@46"!','+"!'*%"@>:":349>G"801";1@46"#&&&(#&&#E/01"8@B"4@81"6843=8341"@:H368A1>86" =5A24969>G" @>" 9>=41@61" 57" @" :1:3=895>" 5>" @??5<@>=1" :349>G" @>" 9>7?@895>" 21495:"@669681:" 85" :1=41@61" 801" 8@B" C34:1>" 5>" 8@B2@;146E/01" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" =@361:" 09G0" 9>=5A1"8@B2@;146"A541"8@B"C34:1>"80@>"?5<"9>=5A1"8@B2@;146E"I?65+"801"4163?86"57"9>7?@895>"=@361:"80561"<980"71<14":121>:1>86"A541"9>=41@61"9>"8@B"C34:1>"80@>"80561"<980"A541":121>:1>86E"J4@=89=@??;+"801"4163?86"57"9>7?@895>"=@361:"@>"9>=41@61"9>"8@B"C34:1>"85"8@B2@;146"K"/01"21465>@?"9>=5A1"8@B"4@81"6843=8341"@:H368A1>86"C;" 41:3=9>G" 8@B" 4@81"@>:"1B2@>:9>G">18" 9>=5A1"C@61"57" ?5<" 9>=5A1"8@B2@;146"1EGE"9>"801";1@46"!',)+"!'*&+"!'*-+"!'*'+"!''#+"!'''"@>:"#&&$"@669681:"85":1=41@61"801" 8@B" C34:1>E" L7" 80161" @:H368A1>86" <141" =5>89>31:" <980" @>" 9>=41@61" 57" 1B21>61" 4@81" @>:"@??5<@>=1+"98"<53?:":1=41@61"801"8@B"C34:1>"9>"801"9>7?@895>"21495:"1EGE"9>"801";1@46"!',)+"!'*&+"!'*'"@>:"#&&$E""" /01" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" =@361:" @" :1=41@61" 57" 21465>@?" 8@B" 245G41669F1" 4@81" 6843=8341"<09=0"<@6"@>"9>6843A1>8"754"@":96849C3895>"57"41F1>31E"L8"<@6"605<>"80@8""801"4163?86"57"9>7?@895>"=@361:"?5<"9>=5A1"8@B2@;146"85"41=19F1"A541"1771=8"57"9>7?@895>"80@>"801"09G0"9>=5A1"8@B2@;146E"/01" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" @771=81:" 80561" <980" A541" :121>:1>86" A541" 80@>" 80561" <980" 71<":121>:1>86E" /01417541+" 801" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" =@361:" @" :1=41@61" 9>" 1D398;" 57" 21465>@?" 8@B"245G41669F1"4@81"6843=8341"<09=0"<@6"@>" 9>6843A1>8"57":96849C3895>"57"41F1>31"@>:"801"4163?86"57"9>7?@895>" =@361:" @>" 9>=41@61" 57" 1B=166" C34:1>" 8@BE" /01" 21465>@?" 9>=5A1" 8@B" 6843=8341"@:H368A1>86"9>"801";1@46"!'--(#&&%"=53?:">58"1?9A9>@81"801"9>7?@895>"1771=8"5>"8@B"C34:1>"57"801"8@B2@;146E" M1=@361" 801" 4163?86" 57" 9>7?@895>" =@361:" @" :1=41@61" 57" 1D398;" 57" 21465>@?" 8@B"245G41669F1"4@81"6843=8341"<09=0"<@6"@>"9>6843A1>8"754"@":96849C3895>"57"41F1>31E"";,&<)28'!9""L>7?@895>+"/@B"M34:1>+"J1465>@?"L>=5A1"/@B""

"

Page 78: Economic Journal Issue 5

" ,,

=>! !

""#%&'N#%)*"

"""

"

"

""

"

"

"""

"

"""

"#%&'(#%)*""?>! !

" O!P""

" O#P""

"

@>! !!

" O!P""

" O#P""

" O$P"

"" O)P"

"" O%P"

""A>! !

" "

"#%&'(#%)*"""

"+" +"

" """"""B>! !

" O!P" "OJ1465>@?"L>=5A1"/@BP" "

"" "

"

Page 79: Economic Journal Issue 5

",*

" O#P" "OQB21>616P" "

""#" " "

"OP""O"

P"

")&O!P" ")&O#P""

" O$P" "OI??5<@>=16P" "

" ""+" " +""

+" " +" +"+" "

+" ""

"" "" O)P" "" ""

""" O%P" "" ""

"

""""" O-P" "OQ771=89F1" 8@B"4@81P" "

"""

" O,P" " ""

" O*P" "" "

"

""C>! !

""#%&'(#%)*" "#" "" "

")"" " "

"" "

" "" "

"$" " "" " "

""

!! C>=! !" "

" ")" " """

"" "" """

Page 80: Economic Journal Issue 5

" ,'

"" "" -E!E!"

""

" ")" "" "

" O!P"""

"" O#P"

"""

" O$P"" "

"+" "

"" O)P"

""

"" -E!E#"

""

"

"! C>?! !" "

"$" "

" "O/RMP"" "

OS/RMP" ""OT/RTMP" "

" "" -E#E!"

""

" "#"" ""

" O!P"

""

"OT/RTMP" " "

"OS/RMP" """

"OS/RMP"U"OT/RTMP"" "

"" O#P"

""

O/RMP" " " ""OS/RMP"

" ""O/RMP" V" OS/RMP" ""

"

Page 81: Economic Journal Issue 5

"*&

" -E#E#""

"

"O/RMP" ""OT/RTMP"

""O/RMP"U"OT/RTMP"""

""D>! !

"" "

! D>=! !" ,E!E!"

"" O!P"

"" " "

"#%&'(#%#!+" "#%#$(#%#,+"""#%#'(#%)#" "#%)-(#%)*"

""

""

"""" "" " "

#%##+" "#%#*" "#%)$(#%)%" "

""

""" "

"#%##+" "#%#*" "#%)$(#%)%"

""""

" O#P"

"""" " "

" ""

"

"""

"" ""

"" "

"""" O$P"

" """

Page 82: Economic Journal Issue 5

" *!

" " """""

"""

"" "

"" "

""" O)P"

""" " "

"

"

""" " O P"

O P"""

""

" ,E!E#""

" " "

"

"

"

"" "

"" " "O#%#$P" "

""""

"

"

" "

"

""

" "

""! D>?! !" ,E#E!"

"

Page 83: Economic Journal Issue 5

"*#

" O!P""

" " "

" ""OS/RMP"

"OT/RTMP"" "" "OS/RMP"

"OT/RTMP"

"" ""

""""

"" """

" O#P"

"""" " "

"#%!,+" "#%#$+"""#%#'+" "#%$#+" "#%$%+" "#%)#" "#%)-""

""O/RMP"

" "

"

" ""

" " ""

"" " "#%!,+"""#%#$+" "#%$#" "#%)-"

""O/RMP"

" """OS/RMP" "

"

"""

" "" "

" " "

"" ,E#E#"

"" " "

"O/RMP""

OT/RTMP" ""#%&'(#%)*"

""

"

Page 84: Economic Journal Issue 5

" *$

" "

"""E>! !

"

" "" O!P" " "

"

" ""

""

" O#P" " "" "

"" ""

" " ""

"" "

" """

" O$P" " ""

" "

"" O)P" " "

" "

""" O%P" " "

"" ""

" " " "

" ""

!

"" E"O#%)*PE"

! > >?B@B! F! ?BAC>"

" "" "

E"E"O#%%&PE"

>" "O PE" "W"

E"

Page 85: Economic Journal Issue 5

"*)

"" E"O#%)&PE"

!

! > >!?B?G!?B@?!?B@A! !?B@B>"("

" """ "

E"

"" E"O#%##PE"

>"""

" "E"

Page 86: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

"#$!%&'()*!+,!*#$!-.*(/01.#123!+,!*#$!4"5!+2!!

*#$!6+/10$!"$0$'#+2$!7$891)$.!12!"#(10(2:!

!! !

;

!

!! !

<

!

!! !

=

!

!

! !

!" #$! ! !" #$! !

!" #$! ! !

!

! !

!

! !

! ! !

! ! !!

>/.*8()*!

! %&'&()*+,! )-&!./01*&! )&*&2-/(&!3&451'&!-63!4&7/4.&8!4&9:*6)1/(! 7/4.!)-&!;&*&2-/(&!

<496(1=6)1/(!/7!;-61*6(8! ";<;$!6(8! )-&!>/..:(1'6)1/(3!?:)-/41)+!/7!;-61*6(8! ">?;$! )/! )-&!@6)1/(6*!

;&*&'/..:(1'6)1/(3!>/..1331/(!"@;>$!1(!/48&4!)/!&('/:469&!'/.2&)1)1/(!1(!./01*&!)&*&2-/(&!3&451'&#!

A&('&,!)-13!262&4B3!/0C&')15&!D63!)/!3):8+!)-&!1.26')!/7!)-&!&3)60*13-1(9!/7!@;>!/(!)-&!./01*&!)&*&2-/(&!

3&451'&3#!;-&! 4&3:*)3! 3-/D&8! )-6)!@;>!-63! 8&'4&63&8!06441&43! )/! &()4+! 6(8! 1('4&63&8!8177:31/(!6(8!

E:6*1)+!/7!./01*&!)&*&2-/(&!3&451'&3#!<2&46)/43!-65&!-68!5641/:3!241'1(9!2/*1'1&3!3:'-!63!/(F(&)!!6(8!!

/77F(&)!241'&3#!?881)1/(6**+,!@;>!2/*1'+!-63! 1('4&63&8!'/(3:.&4!3:42*:3,!24/8:'&4!3:42*:3,!6(8!3/'16*!

D&*764&#!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!G!! ! !! !H!! ! # ! ! ! ,! !I!! ! # ! ! ! ,! !

Page 87: Economic Journal Issue 5

!JK

;?! !

! !

!" #$! !

" #$!

!

!

!

!

! #! ! #!

!

!

! !

!

!!

!

!"L/4*8!;468&!<496(1=6)1/(M!L;<$!

!

!

! !

# #!HNOI! !

! # #!HNOO! !

!" #$!

! # #!HNOP!

! !

!

! !

! ! !

#! ! #! !

!!

! !

! # #HNOQ!

!

!

!

!

! #! !

! !

! !

!

!R4&3(6-6(!"GQJH$!

!

! #!

!H! !

! #!

! !

! ! # #!HNON! !

# #!HNNG! !

! !!

#! !

!R4&3(6-6(!"GQJH$!

!

!

!

! ! !

!"HNIQ$! ! !"HNOO$!!

! !"HNOQ$! !S4=+0/D3T1!

"HUUJ$! !

26(&*!86)6! !G! ! # #!

HNON! !I! # #!HNNG!

Page 88: Economic Journal Issue 5

! JP

!I! !?VW,! X;?>! !;%YZ!

[<\Z!

!

!

!

!

!

<?! !

! !

! !"]/9641)-.1'!]1(&64!ZE:6)1/($! !!

! !!! 1 2 3 4 1ln ln ln lnit it it itQ P ms age !!!!! "#$

! 5 6 7 8 2ln ln ln lnit it it itMC Q cell wage ! "%$!!

! ! itP ! ! !i ! ! ! t !! ! itQ ! ! !i ! ! !t !! ! itMC ! ! ! i ! ! !t !! ! itms ! ! ! i ! ! ! t !! ! itage ! ! !i ! ! !t !! ! itcell ! ! !i ! ! !t !! ! itwage ! ! !i ! ! !t !! ! i ! ! !?VW!X;?>! !;%YZ![<\Z!

! ! t ! ! !G! !HNON! ! !I! !HNNG!

!

!

!"8:..+! 564160*&$! ! "H$!

!"I$! !!

! 5 6 7 8 9 10 3ln ln ln ln 1 2it it it it t tMC Q cell wage govt govt !! "I$!!

! ! 1tgovt ! ! ! !

! ! ! ! !I! ! # #!HNOJ!

! ! 2tgovt ! ! ! # #HNOQ!!!

! ! !I! ! # #!HNOQ!

!

!

! ![%!^![>! !]/9641)-.! ! !

Page 89: Economic Journal Issue 5

!JJ

! ln lnMR MC ! "O$!!

!MR ! ! 1 Q PP

P Q! !Q P

P Q!

! !"G$! !

! !2

1 ! !! ln itMR ! !

! 2

1ln ln ln 1it itMR P ! "N$!

!"O$! !"I$! !"N$! !

5 6 7 8 9 10 32

1ln ln(1 ) ln ln ln 1 2it it it it t tP Q cell wage govt govt!"K$!

!

!!

5 6 7 8 9 10 42

1ln ln(1 ) ln ln ln 1 2it it it it t tP Q cell wage govt govt ! "P$!

!

! ! !"G$! !"P$!

!"W1.:*)6(&/:3! ZE:6)1/($! !";D/FW)69&! ]&63)! WE:64&!

[&)-/8$ !" 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ, , , , , , , , , $!

! ! ! ! ! i

! ! !

! !

! #! !

! !! !

"6()1*/9641)-.$! ! ln itQ ! !"G$!! ! ! ln itP ! !"P$!

! ! ! ! !!

!1 3 4 2

ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ( ln ln )i itms agei iQ e P ! "J$!

!

61 7 8 9 1 0ˆˆ ˆ ˆ ˆˆ( ln ln 1 2 )i i t tc e ll w a g e g o v t g o v t

i iP e Q ! "Q$!

Page 90: Economic Journal Issue 5

! JQ

! ! iP ! !"Q$! !"J$! ! !

!2

61 3 4 1 7 8 9 10

ˆˆˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆˆ( ln ln ) ( ln ln 1 2 )* *i i i i t tms age cell wage govt govt

i iQ e e Q ! "GU$!

! ! *iQ ! !"GU$! !"Q$! ! ! !

!6

1 7 8 9 10

ˆˆ ˆ ˆ ˆˆ( ln ln 1 2 )* *i i t tcell wage govt govti iP e Q ! "GG$!

!

! ! !">/(3:.&4!

W:42*:3M!>W$! !" iQ $! !"J$!

!V(5&43&!X&.6(8! ! ! ! !

!

*2

1 3 4

2

* *ˆ ˆ ˆ( ln ln )

0 ˆ

i

i i

Qi

i i i im s age

QC S dQ P Q

e

! "GH$!

! !"_4/8:'&4!W:42*:3M!_W$!

! i !" ln iMC $! !"H$! !!

!65 7 8 9 10

ˆˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ( ln ln 1 2 )i i t tcell wage govt govti iMC e Q ! "GI$!

!

! !!

! i !" iMC $! !"GI$! ! ! !

!

*

ˆ65 7 8 9 10

ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ ˆ( ln ln 1 2 )* *

0

i

i i t t

Qcell wage govt govt

i i i i iPS P Q e Q dQ ! "GO$!

! !"W/'16*!D&*764&!M!WL$! !

i ! !!

! i i iSW CS PS !! "GN$!

!

Page 91: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QU

=?! !

!

! !H!

! !

! "G$!

!

! !

!

!

! !

!

!

! #!

! # ! #! !!

!

!

! ! #!

!

!IS! ! #!

! !

!

!IS! !

! !

! !

!

!H! ! ! #!

! ! #! !

! # #!HNOQ!

!

! #! !

!

!

!

!

!!

!

! !

!

!

!

!

!G! ! #!

!GJ! ! !

#!

!

! !

!

!

! "H$! !

#! !

!!H! ! !

!

! # #!HNOQ!!

Page 92: Economic Journal Issue 5

! QG

! !H!

!

!`1a&8! &77&')! )&3)! !A6:3.6(! )&3)!

!

! ! !`ZF

HW]W! !%F3E:64&! !`ZFHW]W!

!U#QIQP! !U#PJUN!

! !`ZFHW]W!

!

!

!I! !

!

!

! !

!" !I$!!

! !I! !O! !

!

!P!

!

!GU! ! !

!

! !

! !

! !

!P!

!GI!

!

!

!

! !N! !

G,JJJ,NNU,NOU! !

!

! # #!HNOQ! !

!

GO!

!

!

!

!

!GO!

!IG!

!

!

! # #!HNOQ!

!

!GG! !

O,IUP,UPJ,QUN! !!

!

Page 93: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QH

! # #!HNOQ!

!

!GP! !

K,OGI,OIQ,NQH! !

!

@?! !

! !

! !

!

!

!

!

!

# ! ! # ! !

!

!

!!

!

!

!!

!

! ! ! #!

!

!

! !

"[/(/2/*+! _/D&4$! !

!!

! !

#!

!

!!

! #! !

! # !

! !

#! !

!IS! ! !

! #!

!IS!

!

! !

! !

!

!

Page 94: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QI

!!;!

!

!

!!

!

!

?!

!

!

;

!!

?

;

!

;!

G# #!

!!

!HI,KQU,UUU!

O,NUU,UUU!

HJ,GQU,UUU!

HI,KQU,UUU!

Q,UUU,UUU!

IH,KQU,UUU!

H# #!

!!

!GH,PPU,UUU!

P,UUU,UUU!

GQ,PPU,UUU!

GH,PPU,UUU!

GO,UUU,UUU!

HK,PPU,UUU!

I# #!!!

P,NUU,UUU!

K,NUU,UUU!

GO,UUU,UUU!

P,NUU,UUU!

GI,UUU,UUU!

HU,NUU,UUU!

O#

F!

!G,UUU,UUU!

U!G,UUU,UUU!

G,UUU,UUU!

U!G,UUU,UUU!

N# #!

#!!

I,HJU,UUU!

U!I,HJU,UUU!

I,HJU,UUU!

U!I,HJU,UUU!

K# #!

!!

QUU,UUU!

U!QUU,UUU!

QUU,UUU!

U!QUU,UUU!

!OQ,GOU,UUU!

GJ,UUU,UUU!

KP,GOU,UUU!

OQ,GOU,UUU!

IK,UUU,UUU!

JN,GOU,UUU!

!A!!

!!!#!"

!HNNU$!

!A!Gb! !

!

!

Page 95: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QO

!<!

!

!

!B

!;C!

!B

!DC!

!E++0$:!<7F7!

G-H<7F7!

I-H<7F7!

!E++0$:!<7F7!

G-H<7F7!

I-H<7F7!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!A!02J!

!A!02E!

!IH#NOPHccc!

HH#IGKKccc!

IN#NOPHccc!

!I#PHJQccc!

O#PPQQccc!

I#PHJQccc!

lnP!

FH#KUIPccc!

FG#KPNIccc!

FH#KUIPccc!

lnQ!

U#UUUO!

U#UUGI!

U#UUUO!

lnms!

G#UGHKccc!

U#UHPJ!

G#UGHKccc!

lncell!

FU#UHGJ!

FU#HIGQccc!

FU#HGPJ!

lnage!

U#GGUI!

G#UNQccc!

U#GGUI!

lnwage!

U#GHKNccc!

U#GOPHccc!

U#GHKNccc!

!!

!!

1govt!

U#GNOIccc!

FU#UPIHccc!

FU#GNOIccc!

!!

!!

2govt!

FU#GQOJccc!

FU#GKGQccc!

FU#GQOJccc!

G1K$:!$,,$)*!*$.*!

!U#UUUU!

!G1K$:!$,,$)*!*$.*!

!U#UUUU!

!

L(M.&(2!*$.*!

!!

U#UUUU!

L(M.&(2!*$.*!

!!

U#UUUU!

IH.NM(8$!

U#QGKJ!

U#QIQP!

U#JPGQ!

IH.NM(8$!

U#PJUN!

U#JKJQ!

U#JGJN!

!A!

!

! !

Page 96: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QN

!=!

!!

!

!!

!!

6IO65!

* PB

C!

*QB

C!65!B

C!

57!B

C!

E7!B

C!

7P!B

C!

!??!<Q@R!

?VW!

F!HNU!

OH,GGG,NUG!

GUG!

GN,NPI,POJ,OPH!

K,HPJ,JOP,NPP!

HG,JNH,NQK,UOQ!

X;?>!

F!HHJ!

HI,JGJ,NJP!

QH!

J,UOP,UNN,QIJ!

I,HOO,IQO,KPK!

GG,HQG,ONU,KGO!

;%YZ![<\Z!

F!HHN!

J,QJJ,GKU!

QG!

I,UUU,NUO,KPG!

G,HUQ,PJK,IQN!

O,HGU,HQG,UKP!

!F!

F!PO,QGJ,HOJ!

F!HK,KHG,IUQ,UJG!

GU,PII,UHJ,KOJ!

IP,INO,IIP,PIU!

!

?VW!

!HIH!

OP,NQH,JGQ!

QO!

GK,IKG,GNU,PQI!

K,NQK,HPP,KNG!

HH,QNP,OHJ,OOO!

X;?>!

!HGH!

HK,QGJ,JKI!

JN!

J,ONI,JQI,HUJ!

I,OUJ,OGK,NGK!

GG,JKH,IUQ,PHO!

;%YZ![<\Z!

!HUQ!

GU,GNJ,UPJ!

JO!

I,GNH,HUH,OQG!

G,HPU,QOP,KGG!

O,OHI,GNU,GUH!

!F!

F!JO,KKQ,PKU!

F!HP,QKP,HOK,OQH!

GG,HPN,KOG,PPJ!

IQ,HOH,JJJ,HPU!

!??!<Q@R!

?VW!

!HGH!

NN,HUO,OQI!

JK!

GP,IKQ,NIG,KUP!

P,UUH,PKH,OKJ!

HO,IPH,HQO,UPN!

X;?>!

!GQO!

IG,HHO,UJO!

PJ!

J,QPO,QHH,JKH!

I,KGJ,ONO,KGP!

GH,NQI,IPP,OPQ!

;%YZ![<\Z!

!GQH!

GG,PJH,KQH!

PP!

I,IOK,OPP,IIU!

G,IOQ,HKP,PNG!

O,KQN,PON,UJG!

!F!

F!QJ,HGG,HKQ!

F!HQ,KQU,QIG,PQQ!

GG,QPU,OJO,JIK!

OG,KKG,OGK,KIN!

!??!<Q@R!

?VW!

!GQP!

KH,IQU,UHG!

JU!

GJ,HOP,PUI,JPN!

P,INK,PQU,OHK!

HN,KUO,OQO,IUU!

X;?>!

!GJU!

IN,HJJ,HPI!

PI!

Q,OHJ,PIQ,JUU!

I,JUG,IJP,IKH!

GI,HIU,GHP,GKI!

;%YZ![<\Z!

!GPJ!

GI,IGK,ING!

PH!

I,NGN,KPN,HPH!

G,OGP,OJU,NJP!

O,QII,GNN,JNQ!

!F!

F!GGU,QQO,KON!

F!IG,GQH,GGJ,QOP!

GH,NPN,KNJ,IPN!

OI,PKP,PPP,IHH!

!A!

!

Page 97: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QK

!@!

!!

!!

!! !

6IO65!

* P!

*Q!

65!

57!

E7!

7P!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

S+9*;

;!

?VW!

FGJ!

FP!

N,OJG,IGJ!

GI!

FP!

FP!

PJP,OUH,IHG!

N!IGP,OIU,UPO!

N!G,GUO,JIH,IQO!

N!

X;?>!

FGK!

FP!

I,GUU,HPN!

GI!

FK!

FP!

OUK,JIP,HPU!

N!GKO,UHG,JOU!

N!NPU,JNQ,GGU!

N!

;%YZ![<\Z!FGK!

FP!

G,GKQ,QGP!

GI!

FK!

FP!

GNG,KQP,JHU!

N!KG,GKG,HGK!

N!HGH,JNQ,UIK!

N!

!!

F!F!

Q,PNG,NGU!

GI!

F!F!

G,ION,QIP,OGG!

N!NOH,KGI,GIU!

N!G,JJJ,NNU,NOU!

N!

S+9*<

<!

?VW!

FIP!

FGO!

GI,UQH,QQG!

IG!

FGN!

FGO!

G,UUJ,IJU,JGO!

GG!

PHI,QGO,JQG!

GG!H,NGQ,KQJ,UHN!

GG!

X;?>!

FIO!

FGO!

P,OUN,OQK!

IG!

FGO!

FGO!

NHG,UHQ,KNO!

GG!

IPO,UNQ,QOG!

GG!G,IUG,QHK,JKN!

GG!

;%YZ![<\Z!FIO!

FGO!

H,PQO,NIG!

IG!

FGO!

FGO!

GQO,HPO,JIJ!

GG!

GIQ,OJG,INK!

GG!

OJN,ONO,UGO!

GG!

!!

F!F!

HI,HQI,UGJ!

IG!

F!F!

G,PHI,KJN,IUK!

GG!G,HIP,ONK,GJJ!

GG!O,IUP,UPJ,QUO!

GG!

S+9*;!!

S+9*<!

=!

?VW!

FNH!

FHG!

HU,HPJ,NGQ!

OJ!

FHG!

FHG!

H,KPI,QNN,OUH!

GP!G,UPP,QOH,JOQ!

GP!I,PNG,JQJ,HNG!

GP!

X;?>!

FOJ!

FHG!

GG,OKQ,KJK!

OJ!

FGQ!

FHG!

G,IJG,KJI,JKI!

GP!

NNK,QQH,KJK!

GP!G,QIJ,KPK,NOJ!

GP!

;%YZ![<\Z!FOJ!

FHG!

O,IHJ,GQU!

OJ!

FGQ!

FHG!

NGN,GPU,KUG!

GP!

HUP,KQO,GQH!

GP!

PHH,JKO,PQI!

GP!

!!

F!F!

IQK,UPK,IQN!

OJ!

F!F!

O,NPU,JUQ,JKK!

GP!G,JOH,KHQ,PHP!

GP!K,OGI,OIQ,NQH!

GP!

!A!

!

!A!!

Gb !!

!"8:..+!564160*&3$!!9/5)G!^!G!"

!I!!##!HNOJ!

$!!9/5)H!^U!

Hb !!##!HNOQ!

!"8:..+!564160*&3$!!9/5)G!^U!

!9/5)H!^G!"

!I!!##!HNOQ!

$!Ib !

!##HNOQ!

!9/5)G!^!G!"

!I!!##!HNOJ!

$!!

9/5)H!^!G!"

!I!!##!HNOQ!

$!

Page 98: Economic Journal Issue 5

! QP

!

! #!!HNOI#!!

! !

?! !

! !

#!

! #!!HNON#!! !

! ! !

;?! <%?@SZ! #!

!

,! #!

! #!!HNNG#!!

! ? ?!<Q@T!

! ? ?!<Q@D!

?!

!

,! #!

! #!!HNON#!! !

?!

!

,! ! #!

! #!!HNIQ! ! d

e!

! !!

!I! !G!" #F # $M!GNFHH#!

!

!

! #!HNOJ#!

?!

!

,! #!

! #!HNOO#!!

!A!

?!!

! ,! !

#!

! #!!HNOQ#!!

! ? ?!<Q@T!

?!!

!

,! #!

! #!!HNOK#!!

!

?!

! ,!

#!

R4&3-6-6(,!;#! #!!GQJH#!!d;-&!/*19/2/*+!3/*:)1/(!'/('&2)!13!

18&()171&8e!!-)+2+&1).!F$**$8!GU!,!22#!JPFQH#!

X&((13,!L#>#!6(8!_&4*/77,!f#![##!!HUUN#!!6+:$82!

%2:M.*81(0! U83(21V(*1+2?! O)-! &8#!

_&643/(!!!?8813/(!L&3*&+#!

Page 99: Economic Journal Issue 5

!QJ

S4=+0/D3T1,! ]#! ! HUUJ#!!d;-&! >/.2&)1)15&(&33! /7!

[/01*&!;&*&2-/(+!6'4/33! )-&!Z:4/2&6(!

Y(1/(e! ! %2*$82(*1+2(0! W+M82(0! +,! *#$!

-)+2+&1).!+,!XM.12$..?!GN"G$M!QQFGGN#!

_1(8+'T,!%#!W#!!HUUN#!!61)8+$)+2+&1).?!!K)-!&8#!Y22&4!

W688*&!%15&4,!@#f#!M!_&643/(b_4&()1'&!A6**#!

W)&68,! %,! &)! 6*#! ! GQQK#!!%2:M.*81(0! -)+2+&1).A!

"#$+8YZ! >''01)(*1+2.! (2:! E+01)Y?!!

Z(9*6(8M!['S46DFA1**#!!!

W6D+&4,! [#! >#! GQJG#!"#$!-)+2+&1).!+,! %2:M.*81$.!

(2:!G18&.?!@&D!g/4TM!W;#[64)1(B3!24&33#!

W:(9,!@#!HUUN#!d[64T&)!W-64&,241'&!6(8!_4/71)!

1(!<Z>X![/01*&!;&*&2-/(&![64T&)3e!

"<(*1(&$#!-))2Mbb262&43#334(#'/.b3/*Ib!

262&43#'7.h603)46')i18^JGHHKOj_62

&4X/D(*/68#,!HU!?241*!HNNG#!

iiiiiii#!HUUK6#!dZ77&')3!/7!%&9:*6)/4+!_/*1'+!/(!

[64T&)! W)4:'):4&! 6(8! _&47/4.6('&! 1(!

<Z>X! [/01*&! [64T&)3e! "<(*1(&$#!

-))2Mbb:3&4269&#7:F0&4*1(#8&bkC.:&**&4b1)3b!

'/(7b6.3)&486.UKb8/D(*/683b262&43bW:

(9#287#,!GJ! !HNNG#!

iiiiiii#!HUUN0#!d;-&!X&)&4.1(6()3!/7!.64T&)!

3-64&! 7/4! ./01*&! )&*&'/..:(1'6)1/(3!

/2&46)/43e!V()&4(6)1/(!;&*&'/..:(1'6)1/(3!

W/'1&)+! "<(*1(&$#! :3&4269&#7:0&4*1(#8&b!

kC.:&**&4b1)3b'/(7b2/4)/UNb262&43bW:(9

#287#,!HU! !HNNG#!

Page 100: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

"##$%$&'%(!)#!*'+,-!.-$/$01-$)'!1'2!3)4-!5!6178)'+1-8)9:!4!;$<!=1>94!

!! " !! # !! $!

!

!

! !

! !

! !"#$! !

!%&&"! !'%! !""#! ! !

! ! ! !

! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

! !

! ! ! ! !

!

! !

!

!!

!

!5!! (! (! !!!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!" "" " " "#" " $ "" " " "'

! " $ " "" "" "

Page 101: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"))

?@ABC?3B!

!! !*+!,-!.-/!0123-.!41,3-567!+89!:1;57!317!:1<=>!/8,3!,3=!?-@1,8@8,A!-:!:1;5!+;8<=!1.>!8.<;=178.9!

<-7,!-:!+;->B<,8-.C!D3=7=!+;-E@=57!@=1>!-B;!;=7=1;<3!,-!1.1@AF=!,3=!=::8<8=.<A!-:!8.+B,!B,8@8F1,8-.!1.>!,-!

=7,851,=! ,3=!B.8,! <-7,C!D-!-E,18.! ,3=!+;851;A!>1,1!.==>=>! :-;!1.1@A787(! ,3=;=!1;=!"#$!+89!+;->B<,8-.!

:1;5=;7! 8.! %))G!/=;=! ;1.>-5@A! 7=@=<,=>! :;-5!HB1.9!I87,;8<,! J'%! -E7=;?1,8-.7K! 1.>!L15+1=.971=.!

>87,;8<,!J""#!-E7=;?1,8-.7K!,-!8.,=;?8=/C!M7!,3=!=7,851,=>!;=7B@,7(!,3=!N-EEOI-B9@17!+;->B<,8-.!:B.<,8-.!87!

789.8:8<1.,@A!=P+@18.=>!EA! ,3=! :-@@-/8.9! :1<,-;7Q! @1E-;(! ;1878.9!1!+89(! E;==>7(! 1.>! :==>7C!R17=>!-.! ,3=!

<-.<=+,! -:! ,=<3.8<1@! =::8<8=.<A(! ,3=! 51;98.1@! +3A78<1@! +;->B<,! -:! ;1878.9! 1! +89! /17! 3893=;! ,31.! ,3=!

51;98.1@!+3A78<1@!+;->B<,!-:!-,3=;! 8.+B,7C!M>>8,8-.1@@A(! ,-!1<38=?=! ,3=!=<-.-58<!=::8<8=.<A! ,3=! :1;5=;7!

73-B@>! 8.<;=17=! ,3=! 15-B.,! -:! :-@@-/8.9! 8.+B,7Q! @1E-;(! ;1878.9! +897(! 1.>! E;==>7C! D3=A! 73-B@>! ;=>B<=!

.=?=;,3=@=77!,3=!15-B.,!-:!:==>7C!M+1;,!:;-5!,387(!,3=!=7,851,=>!<-7,!-:!+89!:1;5!8.>8<1,=7!,31,!,3=!<-7,!

-:!:==>8.9!+897!87!<-5+1;1,8?=@A!3893=7,C!R=<1B7=!,3=!85+-;,=>!+@1.,7!/38<3!1;=!B,8@8F=>!:-;!+;->B<8.9!

:==>7!/8@@!31?=!8.<;=178.9!,;=.>!-:!+;8<=(!,3=!9-?=;.5=.,!73-B@>!=P+1.>!8.?=7,5=.,!8.!,3=!;=7=1;<3!1.>!

>=?=@-+5=.,!-:!:==>7C!S8,3!;=7+=<,!,-!TUI(!,3=!8..-?1,8-.!-:!;1/!51,=;81@!/8@@!7BE7,8,B,=!:-;!,3=!85+-;,=>!

+@1.,!-:!:==>8.9!+897C!!!!

!

D&(E)>245!+89!:1;57(!=::8<8=.<A!-:!8.+B,!B,8@8F1,8-.(!<-7,!-:!+89!:1;5!!!

!

FG! !

! !

!

!

!

!

! !

!

!J !"K!

!

!!"!! !#%&"'#%&(!

!Q! V C!

"

""

(%) "

"

(%) #%&!"#%&#"#%&'"#%&&"#%&%"#%&("#%&)"#%&*"#%&+""

')$&*"&#$'+"''$**"'($&* ')$*'"''$,'"&&$)&"&+$%%"&)$,)"&,$#)"

-"!'$!,"-#,$,)")$()"'$),"-!#$(+"'%$&%"!,$)%"-%$,!"'$(("

''$+%"')$)'"',$#&"'#$&'"'&$+*"''$&#"'+$!'"&'$&%"&%$''"'($)&"

-"!!$!'"-!+$*%")$#&")$*("-&$&("!)$,+"!!$,&"&$''"'$&,"

! !Q! C!J%&#WKC! !!!"#$%!! !!"##&C! !"%O"'C!

Page 102: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ")"

!

!J !%K!!

! !!

!

!'! !'! !J !%&#WO

! %&&)K!

! !

!!!

!

!!H! !HIJK!

!

! !!) *! "

"

"""

"""

""

""""

!.)'+.&!!"!.)'#.+!("*+(.(,)"%(+.%#'"%!,.%*!"%,!.#)+"&,*.+*,"''&.(%!"'#*.%#'"',#.&,%"#'%.+*#"##(.!%("#,).%*%"#,%.%+,"!((.,*,"!&).,'("

!Q! C!J%&#WKC!

!!"#$%C! !&OXC!!!

!

"!

!

!

!%! ! !J"K!

!J%K!

!!

HG! !

""

"

"" " "

" "" ! ! ! J%&#XK!

! ! !

!#)!! !

! O

!JN-EEOI-B9@17! ! YB.<,8-.K!

! !!

! ! !

! ! !

! ! !

!

!

!

! !

!

Page 103: Economic Journal Issue 5

!")%

!

!!

! !! !!J%&#XK!

!%&#$!

!&%! ! !

O !JN-EEOI-B9@17!

YB.<,8-.K!

! ! ! !

! ! !

! ! ! !

!

! !

! !

! !

!

!! !

!

!%! ! !

!

!JH1;98.1@!4;->B<,K!

! JZ1@B=! -:!51;98.1@! +;->B<,K!

! !

! !

! ! !

! ! !

!

! !

! ! !

! !

!

!

!

!

!!!

" """

"" "

""

+," "!," ""

" ""&%$*&" "''$,"

"' !

!$!!" " "

" ""/#%&&0 "

" "&'$!%"

"'&$#,""#($)+$""

"" ""/#%&)0"

"!

!

!!

R;8,873!+89!![P=<B,8?=!

J%))#K!!" !

!

!

!

!

!

Page 104: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ")'

LG! !

! ! !

! %()X)! !

!"#$! ! !

! %! !

! ! ! !

! ! '%! !

! ""#! !

!

! !%! !!

! LGF!

! J ! C! %&'GQ! %"O%'K!

!'! !

! !"Q!

O ! JN-EEOI-B9@17! YB.<,8-.K!

!I-BE@=O@-9!5->=@!

!

"

""/!0"! ! !! ! !J K!!!! ! !J K!!!

! ! !J K!!!! ! !J K!

! ! !J K! ! !J K!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! ! !J K! ! !

!!!!!! ! !

" !%Q!

! JD=<3.8<1@! =::8<8=.<AK!

!JH1;98.1@!+;->B<,K!

! ! !!!

! !'Q! !

J[<-.-58<! =::8<8=.<AK

! ! !

!

! !

!

! !

!

! !! !!

! ! !!

! !!! !!

! ! !!!!!!

!!!!!!! LGH! !

!'! ! !

!

! !!

" !

! /!0" "" /#0" "" /'0" "

Page 105: Economic Journal Issue 5

!")#

! !

! /!0" "" /#0" "" /'0" "" /&0" "" /%0" " "" /(0" "" /)0" "" /*0" "" /+0" !

!

JG! !

! JGF!

!

!

!

!

!

! ! ! !

!

!G&C$)!

!

! ! !

! ! !

! "!

! ! )C)'"(! )C"GG(! )C)%W(!

)C&%"! !)C))#! !

!

! ! "!

!)C)$G!J !#K!

!

!&! !!

!!+,--'.,/0123!!4,561!

!!

"

""""""

"""""""

#$%&)",$,'! ",$!** ",$,#+ "-,$,(*",$%#! ",$,,&"

12345672"8#"9",$*%(.":"9"!&("

/!0";767<=5>72?56@>@6AB"" "CD@67"E756"F<=G?G@H@6A"",$(*!""

/#0"146=>=<<7H?6@=:B" "24<G@:-I?65=:""""" "!$*'""/'0"J=<K?H@6AB" !L-@5-9-;-?!\585-?! !!!!!

!!!!L-@5-9-;-?!\585-?! !!!!!

!!!!\89!]!)C)))"

B" "+%""B" "

!

!

Page 106: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ")&

!

!)CX)&! J !

'K! !

!JI=<;=178.9! T=,B;.! ,-! \<1@=K!

![B@=;!D3=-;=5!

!

I=<;=178.9! T=,B;.! ,-! \<1@=!

!

!"!

! !

!##CW&! V !

!MRNI! !

^"! !

"

""&" " !

! !

!

!

!

!

"" !"

" ""

" %"" "!" "

" %'$&'#"" " !" "

" #'$!&(" "" !" "" ,$,,+"

" "!" "" !)$!!(" "

""

! "" ": """"!!!!!!! !""" ": !"" "/8764<:"6="5>?H70" "

Page 107: Economic Journal Issue 5

!")$

! %!!

"!! !

!! ! !

!

!

!

!

!

)C)'"!

!

)C"GG!

)C)%W!

)C&%"!

WWWCX)!

!

WWWCX)!

WWWCX)!

WWWCX)!

)C&G!

!

GC"%!

'()X'C""!

')C#'!

&'C#'%!

!

%'C"#$!

)C))W!

"XC""$!

"B" "

!

!

! !

! #! ! !

! !

!

! %C#'G(! %C)X#(! )C)$%(!

XC"'$! ! J !$K!

!"! !"!

!

! "! ! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ! "! !

!

!

!

!

!

! 7!!

"

! !

! !!

!!

"/LFM@0"

"/FM@0""

"

"

"

""!

%'$&'#"""

!.,,)$#,"""

&%$+%""

"#$&'*"!

#'$!&("""

%!#$*'"""

&%$+%""""

#$,)&"!

,$,,+"""

($()"""

&%$+%""""

,$,(#"!

!)$!!("""

!!,$#!"""

&%$+%""""

)$!'("!

"B" "

!

!

Page 108: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ")X

! JGHM!

!

!

!'! !! !

!

!

!

! J ! XK!

!$XC"%! !

! !'%CGG!

!

!

!

!

! N!

!

!

!!!!!!!! ! ! !

!

!!!!

!

!

)!

!

WG!

!

#G!

!

"#$!

!

!

!

!

)!

!

$XC"%!

!

'%CGG!

!

"))C))!

!

!

!

!

"B" !

!

! ! !"))($)#!

V V !

!

! !"&'(X$$! V

V !J !GK!

"" "

"" " +&$,#"

"%$+*"" &)$%'"

"#+$'#"

" "+&$+%""%$,%"

"%%$(%"" !*$**"/ " +0"

"" ""

"!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 109: Economic Journal Issue 5

!")G

!8! ! !#%%""!! "B" N N "

!

!

!

!

!

!

! ! ! ! ! !

!

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!

O!

O!

%"(&$"C$#!

&(%GGC"'!

%(')"C"X!

"("#XCGX!

%($X"C#$!

"(#)$CX)!

O!

!

%W(#W%CW%!

'($'#C"G!

%$(%&XC)'!

O!

O!

O!

O!

O!

G&WC#%!

!

!

%W(#W%CW%!

'($'#C"G!

#X(G"GC$X!

&(%GGC"'!

%(')"C"X!

"("#XCGX!

%($X"C#$!

"(#)$CX)!

G&WC#%!

!

!

O!

W(WG'CGW!

XG(GGXC'#!

&(WX"C$W!

%(GW'C&X!

'(&W'CG)!

%(')WC&)!

"()$'C&"!

O!

!

%W()#&C$G!

%(W&$C))!

$($GXCG#!

O!

O!

O!

O!

O!

%($"XC&G!

!

!

%W()#&C$G!

"%(W'WCGW!

G&(&X&C"G!

&(WX"C$W!

%(GW'C&X!

'(&W'CG)!

%(')WC&)!

"()$'C&"!

%($"XC&G!

!

! '#('X$CWX! $)(%#'C&&! W#($%)C&%! ")(#X)'C')! #"(')XC")! "#$()")C#)!

!

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!!! !

!

O!

O!

!

O!

!

%('')CG)!

'(&)XC&'!

!

"#&CW$!

!

%('')CG)!

'(&)XC&'!

!

"#&CW$!

!

O!

O!

!

O!

!

'("'#C&W!

#(#'%C)W!

!

"GWC"X!

!

'("'#C&W!

#(#'%C)W!

!

"GWC"X!

! O! &(WG#C%W! &(WG#C%W! O! X(X&&CG&! X(X&&CG&!

! '#('X$CWX! #)(X"GC%W! "))($)#CG"! ")(#X)'C')! #%($"$C%"! "&'(X$$C%&!

"B" "

Page 110: Economic Journal Issue 5

! ")W

!(! !"B" "

!! !

!!

"""" """" """" """" """" "" """" """" """" """" """"""" "

""""""""""

"#+$'#"'$(!"&)$%'"%$#'"#$#("!$!!"#$(("!$&,",$+,"

"""""""""""

"!*$**"*$&#"%%$(%"'$*+"!$*+"#$''"!$%,",$(+"!$),""

" " +&$,#" " +&$+%""

""" """" """" """" """" "

"""""

"#$'#"'$%,"",$!("

""""""

"#$,'"#$+,"",$!#""

" " %$+*" " %$,%"

" " !,,$,," " !,,$,,"

"B" "

!

! !

! ! !

! !&$CG&!

!

!!

! ! !

! ! !

!%GC"&!%XC"$!%)CXW!""C#%! !XC$X!

! ! J ! ")K!

! !

! !

! !

%&#&O%&&)! J ""K! !

! !

Page 111: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"")

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

! !

!

! &O")!

! &O")!

!

!

! FO!

!!

! !!P GM! !

!

!

!

!

!

!!J$)_K!

V !

!

!

!

'&C%$!

#$C)$!

"'C))!

#XCX&!

"WC'$!

'C))!

%CX"!

"CG$!

)C'&!

)C%&!

%)CXW!

%XC"$!

XC$X!

%GC"&!

""C#%!

"CXX!

"C&W!

"C)W!

)C%"!

)C%&!

! "$WC$)! "))C))!

Q! J%&&"KC! J3,,+QVV///C>@>C9-C,3V.B,;8,8-.V!

0B,;8,8-.`L.-/@19=V.B,;8,8-.`"C3,5K!

!

!

!FF! ! !HIJI!Q!HIIO!

!Q! V C!

! ! ! ! !!

! !

P M!

! !

P M!

! !

P M!

! !

P M!

! !

P M!

%&#&!

%&#$!

%&#X!

%&#G!

%&#W!

%&&)!

")C'G!

""C&W!

"'C&"!

""CG)!

")CXG!

""CWW!

O!

""C$$!

"$C&X!

O"%C$$!

OGC$#!

""C%%!

#C)W!

#C#%!

#C#&!

#CG)!

&C'$!

$CG#!

O!

GC)X!

)C$G!

XCGX!

""C$X!

%XC$"!

#CG#!

&C)X!

&C#G!

$C$"!

$C&'!

$C&W!

O!

#CX&!

GC)W!

%)C$%!

O"C%"!

)CW%!

'CX)!

#C"$!

#C"#!

#C$'!

#C$&!

&CXW!

O!

"%C#'!

O%C))!

""CG#!

%C))!

%#C&%!

%CXG!

%C$&!

%CG&!

#C)W!

'CX#!

'CW#!

O!

O#C$G!

XC&&!

#'C&"!

OGC&$!

%)C))!

!Q! C!J%&&"KC!J3,,+QVV,;1>=C>8,C9-C,3V+;8<=7,1,V8.>=PC17+K!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 112: Economic Journal Issue 5

! """

IG! !

"

!

!

! !

!

! %! !

! ! !

! !

! '%! ! ! ""#! !

!

!!

!%! ! !

! ""

"" "

"""

""

"

""

!

!%! ! ! !

!

! ! !

!"))($)#! V V !

! !

"&'(X$$! V V !

""" ""

""! !

! J"K!

! !

!#&CW&! V !

!

! !

!

!

! J%K! !

!

!

!

!

! J'K!

! ! !!

! !

!

!

!

Page 113: Economic Journal Issue 5

!""%

!

!! C!PHIJJMG

!!! !!"#$%G!

C! !Q!

! ! C!

C!C!!J%&&)KC!! G!! !"&!!

!%&&)(! !3,,+QVV///C>@>C9-C,3V!

7=;?8<=V+89V+89+89C3,5@C!

```````C!!J%&#WKC!! !!HIJKG!!

!Q! ! C!

```````C! ! J%&&"KC!

G! ! ! "#! !!

%&&%(! ! ! J3,,+QVV///C>@>C9-C,3V! .B,;8,8-.V!

0B,;8,8-.`L.-/@19=V.B,;8,8-.`"C3,5K!

C! J%&&"KC!

G!! !!X! !%&&)(!!

!3,,+QVV,;1>=C>8,C9-C,3V+;8<=7,1,V!8.>=PC17+!!

!! C!!J%&#XKC!!

G!!

C! !Q! !

C! C!

!! C!!J%&#%KC!! Q

!!!!

G!

C!! !

Q! ! C!

C!

!

!

C!!J%&#GKC!!

G!! !!

!!!!!!!!!! !Q! C!!

```````C!J%&#WKC! G!

!!

!Q! C!!!

!```````C!!J%&#WKC! G!!

! !Q!

C!!

```````C!!J%&#WKC! !!HIJK!!

!!HIIOG! !Q! C!!

!! C!J%&'GKC!

G!! !!%C! !Q!!

!!!!!!!!!! C!

R;8,873!!+89!![P=<B,8?=C!J%))#KC!HOOL!!;$<!3)4-!)#!!

;>)2,%-$)'! *'! A&/&%-&2! ".! ! 3),'->$&4G!

!"'! !%&&)(! !!

3,,+QVV///CE+=PC-;9V,=<3.8<1@V+BE@8<1,8-.7V!

+>:V%))'`Na4`T=+-;,C+>:C!

!

!

Page 114: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"# #

! "#$%&#'$()#'*! +',)-&! .&/'#(0'$()#! !

"+.!

!

12!3! 45! !

!

! !

!1! !

! !

!

!

!

!2! ! !

!

! ! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

$"##

!

! !2! ! !617!

!647!

!687!

!697!

! !627!

! !

!! !

!

!6 !17!

! ! !

#%&'()*+#,-.&/'#0-'1(2#3'(+4#

# #!## # #$!

!

::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::!

1!! ! ; !! ! ! !4!! ! ; ! ! ! ! !

Page 115: Economic Journal Issue 5

!119

!

!

!

!

! !

! !

! !

! !

!

!

!"!#!$!%!&!'!(!)!*!"!!

#&%#

#&%$

#&%%

#&%&

#&%'

#&%(

#&%)

#&%*

#&&!

+,-,./01

!

!1! !

! !4294!3!4225!

!

!

! !6<%='#>! ?)&! *',)&7!

!6@-AA*B! )?! *',)&7!

C

!

! !

!

!

!

!

5"# #!

! ! !!

Page 116: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 112

! !

!D5!

!

!E!

! ! ! ! ! ! !

! ! !F5!

! !

! ! !8! !

! ! ! !

!45! !

!E!

!

!!6

!17!

!

#!# #!6# #

!G! !

# $78$# $785# $788# $787# $789# $78:# $78;# $78<# $776#1;! ! F8;D1! F4;84! 2E;58! 9H;9H! 21;88! 9E;15! 91;4H! 8D;2H! 84;48!

4;! ! 11;8H! 11;HE! 14;8E! H;22! D;92! E;F8! D;98! H;95! 15;52!

8;! ! 5;E4! 1;1D! 5;E4! 1;24! 2;D9! E;1E! 15;1H! 15;48! D;41!

9;! ! D;55! 9;H8! E;8E! D;52! 9;4D! E;19! F;4F! 2;EH! F;E8!

2;! ! 5;D4! 1;5E! 1;5F! 1;82! 1;49! 1;49! 1;24! 4;42! F;5D!

F;! ! 8;12! 4;H8! 8;1D! 4;H4! 8;91! 8;H9! 9;E1! 9;9H! 9;H9!

E;! ! 5;82! 5;44! 5;21! 1;41! 1;1F! 1;84! 4;42! 9;FE! 8;2F!

D;! ! 8;D1! 9;D9! 2;41! 9;92! 9;19! 8;D4! 8;E8! 8;45! 4;2F!

H;! ! 5;8D! 5;25! 5;F4! 5;E2! 5;ED! 5;D1! 5;E9! 4;84! 4;45!

15;! ! 1;FH! 4;DD! 8;88! 8;5H! 4;D5! 4;ED! 4;E1! 4;89! 4;1F!

! 15;18! 15;HF! 14;F8! 41;84! 45;F8! 41;5D! 44;8F! 41;95! 49;E8!

# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66# !66"66#G! I!4294J4225!

!! !

!429E! !

!

! !

! ! !

!

!

!

! !

!6KLM7! !

Page 117: Economic Journal Issue 5

!11F

! ! !

! ! !

! ! !

! ! !

! !

!

!

! ! !

!

! !

! !

4294! !

!85!

!

! !

!

!

!

! ! ! !

!

! !

! !

!

!!

! ! !

!

!

C !

!

! ! ! !

!!

! !

!

4225! !

!

! !

! ! !

! !99! !

!

!

!

!

! !

!

!

!

! !

!

! !

! ! !

!

!

!!

Page 118: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 11E

! ! !

! !

!

!

! !4294! !

!

! !

! ! !

!

!

!8D! !

!

! ! !

! ! !

!!

! !!

!

! ! !

! ! !

!

!

! !

! !

!

!

!

! !

!4294! !

!

! !

! ! !

429E!

!

!

!

! !

!

!

! !

!6+',)-&! N'&O%$! P%Q$(#/7!

!

!

! !

! !

! ! ! !

!

! !

!

! !

! ! ! !

Page 119: Economic Journal Issue 5

!11D

8"# #!

!

! ! !

! !

! !

!

!

!

!! !

! !

! !! !!

! !!

! 617!!

!

!

! 647!

!

!

! 687!

! ! !

!

! 697!

! !

! !

! 627! !

! !

! !

! 6F7!

!

! !

!

! !

!!

! 6E7!

!

!

! 6D7!

!

! 6H7!

!!

! !

!

!

!

! !

Page 120: Economic Journal Issue 5

! 11H

#

I! ;!

# #$776!G! ;!

4221;!

I! ;!

# #$78<!G! ;!

4225;!

I! ;!

# #$78;!G! ;!

429H;!

I! ;!

# #$78:!G! ;!

429D;!

I! ;!

# #$789!G! ;!

429E;!

I! ;!

# #$787!G! ;!

429F;!

!

!

!

I! ;!

# #$788!G! ;!

4292;!

I! ;!

# #$785#G! ;!

4299;!

I! ;!

# #$78$!G! ;!

4298!

;!

##%3=# "!

! ;!

429D;!

;!

"!4225;!!R$$AGCCSSS;>)%;/);$RCT/#%SC(='/%QC?(*%;'QAU!

V(*%"<W1EE2! ! ;!

##!"!

R$$AGCCSSS;(*);)&/CA-,*(XC%#/*(QRC%=A*)B=%#$CQ$&'$C!

>)S#*)'>C/%$5D;A>?>?&.-?#@AB?&CA(+2!!!

Page 121: Economic Journal Issue 5

!145

R$$AGCCSSS;$R'(?$';X)=CPR'(VPLCY)=%CVLZQZLC!

$',(>CF8C<%?'-*$;'QA[! !

#"! ;!

;!4221!

R$$AGCCSSS;$R'(?$';X)=CPR'(VPLCY)=%CVPL,B\

)-#$&BC$',(>C28CX$*C>%$'(*C(>4FC=(>C9D5C

-Q%;;;!!

R$$AGCCSSS;C>)%;/);$RC!

"!

R$$AGCCSSS;$R'(*',)-&;)&/C$R'(C#%SQC9E5H5854;

R$=*;! ! ;! #"""%3=# "! !

429E;!

R$$AGCCSSS;)T%&Q%'Q;>)%;/);$RC!!

R$$AGCCSSS;T)'#%SQ;X)=C$R'(C'&XR(T%C455EJ51C455EJ

51J4DJT)'*;X?=U&%#>%&?)&A&(#$W]$%[$)#*BW1!

]]PM^PN.<MW1]\V"<W494HH2EH2]\V

P._M`W48158925;! #D,E#

!4DC51C455E!

Page 122: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!!

!"! !

#$!! ! $ !! !!!

! ! !

%$!! ! $ !! ! &$!! ! $ !! ! ! ! !

'$!! ! $ !! !! ! ! !

($!! ! $ !! ! ! !

)$!! !! ! !

*$!! $ !! !! ! !

+$!! ! $ ! ! ! ! !

,$!! ! $ !! ! ! !

#-$!! ! $ !! ! ! !

##$!! ! $ !! ! ! !

#%$! ! $ !! ! ! !

Page 123: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!

" # !

$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$! $ $!$$$$$$$$$$$$$!

!

! !

!

!" % % #$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

% $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

! ! ! ! !

! ! !"&''(!)*+,*-#! ! !")*+,*-!.)/,01*#!

!" # $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

!" # $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

!" #$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

2*3-')45!" # $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

!" #$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

!" #$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$678.,1$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ !

! ! !

!

! ! !!

!

! $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ! !!!!!!!"$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$#

Page 124: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!

!

9$ !:,0)'5';/! <')4! ;')! <,=4'-5! !

!>?! ! !@A! ! !9! !B)'-.11,.!C*-! !

9A! ! !

@$ !DE)),0E1E8! F,/.*! "DF#! !?! ! !!

7 ! ! !" #!678.,1! ! !

! !9! ! !9! !

G$ ! !9@! !

?$ ! ! ! !9HI! !

! !

H$ !

!" #!! ! !!

!! !" #!! !

A$ !" #! !!

!! !! !! ! ! ! $!"@H?J#$!

"! $! $!

K.L/'=MN,8! .=4! OP')=&*))3M:.0$! "@H?9#$! #$%! &'()(*+',! (-! &,./.%! #/0"! N',=/! 60'='8,0!

D'88,//**$!Q=,/*4!K/./*!D'=R)*55$!!!

S$ ! !G! ! ! !9! !

!@! !

T$ ! !

!9H! !

! !@! !

!

J$ ! !G! !

9I$ ! ! !I@A?JH9HA7T! !I@A?JH9HA7T! !9I9! !678.,1!U!V,5.8.,WX5-E$.0$/P!!

!

!

!

Page 125: Economic Journal Issue 5

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

Page 126: Economic Journal Issue 5

!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

! !

""#!! !$%!! ! ! !"&""&!!&'$(#)'*"*('+!! !&$'(#)'*"*('+! !"&"!

!!

Page 127: Economic Journal Issue 5

!"#$%&'%"#$(#")*+,-)$).#-!+/)0"$%1++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++23456+$356+/7897:;</98=+>??@

+