Upload
bahar-saghaei
View
335
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Building
Envelope
in Airport
Design
Airport, Skin, Envelope
zahra Bahar Saghaei,
Zahrasadat Mirian Hosseinabadi
Advisor: Dr. Wayne Place
ARC 500 – Airport Studio
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
1
Abstract:
Skin, the surface of exchange
Design of the envelope for an airport building
A building's envelope, also known as its enclosure or facade, must reconcile
many requirements - ventilation, solar and heat gain, glare control, daylight levels,
thermal insulation, water management, materials, assembly, sound and pollution
control- making its design a complicated balancing act. However, the integration of
environmental systems into a clear, comprehensive and elegant design solution must
be synthesized and be an integral part of the design process.
In order to get to a better understanding of how the envelope should be in an
airport building we first need to realize the characteristics of this specific building type;
design of an airport usually involves vast open-plan spaces, huge structures covering
long spans, and wide exterior facades which makes building envelope one of the most
significant parts of the airport design. Most importantly, airport building design is
involved with functional criteria in a way that form finding phase of the design process
should not be an opposition to functionality. At the same time, form finding phase is
inseparable part of building envelope design. to sum up, functionality, form ,and
building envelope can be considered three consecutive fundamental aspects of
design process for airport.
Criteria for an overall building envelope design strategy is based on considering
the context of place, scale, performance, and time; and in order to get to a holistic
design of a building envelope elements such as air, water, heat, materials, daylighting
and energy-frame crises facing current practices must be taken into account. 1
However; in design of building envelops for airports we might need to consider
criteria which are different from other common building types; cost efficiency and low-
energy design are usually inevitable parts of envelope design; but, in construction of
monumental structures like airports, other criteria might be of more importance.
In this article, we research the design and construction of building envelopes in
selected precedents. The employed strategies and the design of the envelope in
various buildings will be presented and evaluated based on the criteria depicted in
the chart below. This research aims to introduce a guideline for designing a sufficient
building envelope in airport construction. (durability, high- tech design, outstanding
features, memorable design )
1 (Jenny Lovell, 2010)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
2
Contents:
Buro Happold’s façade-engineering team diagrammed how the elements of a
multidisciplinary, integrated building envelope strategy are interrelated.
Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach,2010
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
3
Abstract
1- Construction Phase Considerations
1-1- Material: transparency/ translucency/ opacity
1-2- Translucent materials
1-3- Innovation: Corrugated glass as improvement to the structural resistance of glass2
2- Design Phase Considerations:
2-1- Building physics
2-1-1- Ventilation
2-1-2- Solar gain control
2-1-3- Thermal insulation
Solar shadings
Thermal bridges
Heat train
Heat mirror
Glare control
2-1-4- Daylighting
2-2- Structural Design
2-3- Acoustic Design
2-4- Fire Safety
2-5- Sustainability
2-6- Durability
2-7- Security
2-9- Buildability
2-10- Maintenance Strategies
2-11- Budget Costing
2-12- Architectural design
2-13- weather performance
3- Building Envelopes – Holistic approach for design
3-1- Air: Flow and ventilation
3-2 - Heat: Gain and Loss
3-3- Water: systems and collections
3-4- Materials: assemblies and installation
2 Rob Nijsse, 2009
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
4
3-5- Daylighting: Comfort and control
3-6- Energy: Minimizing and Maximizing
4- Some Integrated Ideas for Design of an Envelope:
4-1- Choices of materials in the façade
4-2- Curtain Walls
4-3- Double skin facades
5- Case studies
Conclusion
References
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
5
1- Construction Phase Considerations:
1-1- Material: transparency/ translucency/ opacity
Large material palette includes: concrete, stone, ETFE, aluminum, glass, steel
1-1-1- Translucent materials:
As opposed to transparent glass, which allows the direct transmission of incident light rays,
translucent materials can absorb, disperse, and amplify light, creating a hybrid condition
which is neither transparent nor opaque but may embody qualities of both. These materials
resolve the seemingly paradoxical combination in a single element of the properties of
abundant light transmission, on one hand, and obscuration of view, on the other. Through
various fabrication techniques- sandblasting, acid-etching, ceramic fritting, laminating,
and casting- glass may be transformed from a putatively invisible, transparent surface to
a translucent material with depth and presence. Building envelopes- or skins- that utilize
translucency may do so for variety of reasons, both practical and poetic: to maximize
natural light to building’s interior by day, to outwardly illuminate a building at night, to
provide privacy, to evoke a meditative or serene atmosphere, to infuse the architecture
with a sense of mystery or ambiguity.3
1-1-2- Innovation: Corrugated glass as improvement to the structural resistance of glass4
By deforming or moulding a flat panel into a corrugated panel a great
improvement in strength and stiffness is achieved. This strategy is applied to the design of
facades in order to achieve smaller thickness of structural glass elements and thereby
create surprisingly shaped façade surfaces and lower building costs.
2- Design Phase Considerations:
2-2- Building physics:
2-7-1- Ventilation
Having a degree of natural ventilation can be very efficient and effective in expanding the
comfort zone in some buildings, however it may not be the first priority in airport design. Naturally-
ventilated buildings can occur by conscious design of an envelope in which natural ventilation
strategies have been considered.
3 Scott Murray, Translucent Building Skins 4 Rob Nijsse, 2009
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
6
2-7-2- Solar gain control
Whether we are dealing with airport design or residential, Different shading devices, different
choices of controlling materials, and various strategies enables building envelopes to have some
level of control to prevent large amount of solar gain. Especially in commercial buildings that
cooling loads are noticeably bigger that heating loads. In airports, natural light should be provided
in the spaces and glare should be controlled at the same time. Excessive amount of solar gain
can noticeably increase thermal load of the building.
2-7-3- Thermal insulation
Of utmost important energy controls in buildings is having thermal insulation. There should be
proper insulation in the airport envelope to make it energy consumptive. In this regard we can
consider these determinants:
Heat train
Heat mirror: Heat Mirror technology is based upon a very thin coating
which reflects heat back to its source but lets the light in the space. 5 The
number of film layers varies upon the building type that we are designing
an envelope for.
Thermal bridges:
Thermal bridges are junctions where insulation is not continuous and causes
heat loss. 6
Solar shadings: Solar shading controls the amount of heat and light admitted
to a building. By doing so, solar shading devices can offer energy saving in
various areas. They can reduce the need for heating or air conditioning by
maintaining a more even temperature despite varying climatic conditions. They can also
cut the amount of energy required for lighting, by admitting more light during overcast
conditions for example.7
2-7-4- Glare control: At present, the Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) defines glare as one
of two conditions:
Too much light
Excessive contrast, meaning the range of luminance in the field of view
is too great
Whether designing lighting or daylighting, the principal objective is to ensure that
there is the right amount of light with appropriate limits to glare.
2-7-5- Daylighting:
One of the most important factors in airport design is to implement daylighting strategies.
5 http://www.southwall.com/southwall/Home/Products/Commercial/HeatMirrorInsulatingGlass.html 6 http://www.isover.com/Q-A/Implementation/What-is-a-thermal-bridge 7 http://www.es-so.com/en/Solar-shading
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
7
2-8- Structural Design
Structural design is an integral part of the building design and specifically in airports in plays a pivotal
part. Structural design in building envelope involves the design of the claddings, glass facade and
also in buildings with unconventional roof structures -such as airports- the structure of the roof is
usually integrated into the design of the envelope.
2-9- Acoustic Design
The main noise paths are roofs, walls, windows, door and penetrations. Sufficient control
ensures space functionality and is often required based on building use and local municipal codes.
2-10- Fire Safety
In designing the building envelope, issues to address in developing a successful fire protection design
usually include:
Construction type, allowable height, and area
Exposures/separation requirements
Fire ratings, materials, and systems
Occupancy types
Interior finish
Exit stairway enclosure
2-11- Sustainability:
The key criterion for sustainability is energy efficiency.
Energy efficient buildings are characterized by low
energy consumption… energy efficient concept for
building envelopes serve a forward-looking double
purpose: they save energy and generate energy. Other
issues such as material efficiency, process efficiency can
be considered vital in terms of sustainability as well. The
world need building envelopes that deliver optimum
energy and building efficiency throughout their entire life cycle. To succeed, this requires highly
efficient planning, construction and operating processes. 8
8 Hindrichs. Heusler (Eds.), Facades – Building Envelopes for the 21st century. 2010
Hindrichs. Heusler (Eds.), Facades –
Building Envelopes for the 21st century.
2010
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
8
2-12- Durability:
The design life of a building’s envelope will be less than that of its structure but greater than that of its
internal building systems. For an architect to properly consider the life cycle and maintenance of an
envelope’s materials, they must create a façade that is accessible and that has the ability to be
maintained. Over the life span of a building, parts and assemblies will need to be repaired or
replaced.9 In the design of a building envelope, materials and components should be accessible and
able to be well-maintained. Also durability depends on material choice, finish, quality of design, and
construction. These elements should be specified based on the intended life span of the building, for
instance airports usually are built to last for a long time. Therefore durability can be considered vital in
design of an airport envelope.
2-13- Security:
Considering security standards is another important factor specially in airport design. The envelope
of the building should secure the safety standards required for an airport.
5-9- Buildability:
Buildability and considering the phases of constructing the assembly is another important aspect of
the envelope design. Different methods of fabrication and new approaches such as prefabrication
and modular design might be considered.
9 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach
Hindrichs. Heusler (Eds.), Facades – Building Envelopes for the 21st century. 2010
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
9
5-10- Maintenance Strategies:
Maintenance plays an important role in design of the building components; considering the life-
span of materials; how they will be changed or replaced in case of being damaged and also
choosing material based on the function of the building are important.
5-11- budget costing:
No one wants a super expensive building façade when it is not necessary. Designing a wall system
which meets all the above-mentioned requirements within budget is an issue that should be
considered. Although in some particular project10 client might ask for fancy expensive materials and
assemblies that can be part of the design program, finishing the design and construction within
budget is what makes the design successful.
5-12- Architectural design:
Far from being just a decorative and fancy, building envelope design requires an integrated
approach for architects to consider all the above-mentioned categories. Use of technology,
constructability and life cycle consideration are issues that are as important aesthetic aspect of
architectural design of envelopes.
“There is an additional obligation of these combined components11– to reflect an aesthetic
sensibility for the delight of users, while also meeting pragmatic requirements. This is what makes
a building into architecture.”
(Jenny Lovell, 2010)
5-13- weather performance
5-14- cladding systems
6- Building Envelopes – Holistic approach for design
Ever growing and fast pace technology era requires an architectural design that looks toward future.
Over the past one hundred years, the design of a typical building envelope has radically changed
from a monolithic mass to a series of layers, each with a specific, pragmatic task. In addition to offering
an external and internal face to the building, these layers need to repel rainwater, control water vapor,
retain heat or coolness, and handle air transmission. These layers also tend to be more lightweight and,
rather than relying on building mass to insulate, employ a supplemental insulation layer when climate
requires it. 12Building envelopes for the 21st century should meet the requirements of different categories
in the design process:
10 These building are mostly trying to act as a monumental or memorial architecture. 11 (structure, repelling rain water, controlling water vapor, retaining heat or coolness, and handling air transmission) 12 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
10
- air,
- heat,
- water,
- material,
- daylighting,
- energy (maximizing and minimizing)13
3-1- Air: Flow and ventilation
Wind and air movement on the surface of a building generate differential pressures that drive air
through gaps and openings, intentionally or otherwise, to ventilate a building. Depending on the
varied and dynamic conditions of the external environment, climate, and the requirements of
internal space, a building’s envelope is the surface area through which ventilation can occur, and it
must always act as a barrier to unwanted air leakage.14
Two main issues in designing in regard to air:
Air exchange for ventilation
Air barriers in the wall assembly that prevent loss of heated or chilled air to the
exterior
Potential: In this regard one potential for designing an envelope is to create an intermediate
microclimate zone can be utilized to introduce cool, fresh air into a building and provide gathering
areas for users. 15
13 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach 14 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach 15 In tall buildings these zones are often called “sky garden”, but the same principle can be seen in low rise building
This diagram articulates the problems related to
air that need to be addressed by the building
envelope: the variable factors of the outside
condition – climate, orientation, adjacencies
(such as traffic), and time (day/night/season)-
together with the expectations of the interior
condition- building size (height and depth),
program, systems integration, and user
expectation. We have come to expect a
constant internal condition that can be
provided by air conditioning.
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated
approach)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
11
3-2- Heat: Gain and Loss
Envelope of a building functions as skin meaning that it acts as a zone of thermal exchange for our
body. Modern buildings have developed light weight envelopes which have a low thermal storage
capacity and they rely on layers of insulation to resist heat loss.
Our buildings are leaky in terms of heat transfer and codes just require the builders to meet some
minimums whereas buildings can maximize their performance by integrated approach of designing
the wall section.
In this regard, architects tendency to design transparent buildings is another issue which brings with it
serious challenges from solar heat gain or loss to the outside.
Potentials when facing with this issue in envelope design is:
Right orientation to balance solar heat gains as required. Generally it is recommended to
design a building with greater north and south areas of envelope where possible.
Considering low surface-to-volume ratio when designing the form and massing of the building.
High performance glazing (with low U-values)
1- Detail photograph showing the vent in the window jamb:
this vent allows exhaust air to be drawn up the solar flues by
the stack effect.
2- Detail photograph showing the solar air flues and windows
of Jessop West’s building envelop.
3- This diagram shows the integration of window, venting, and
solar flues for Jessop West. Incoming air (blue) is drawn in
through the attenuator under the window to a vent
between the outer and inner window units, where it can
either be allowed into the occupied room by opening the
inner window or utilized to draw heat up through the
chimney through stack effect (red).
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
12
Continuity of the air barrier
Good thermal performance of solid or opaque areas of the envelope.
3-3- Water: systems and collections
A building envelope must be considered as part of a continuous and varying surface condition,
able to redirect or collect water for reuse/recycling.
3-4- Materials: assemblies and installation
Façade materials that are commonly being used in buildings are stone, clay, concrete, timber,
metal, glass, plastic. In terms of assembly modern building envelopes consist of series of additive
layers supported in some way by a primary structural system. (transparent and solid elements)
They can be purposefully combined as one layer or
Separate from structure of a building that is generally called curtain walls.
Heat flow through a building envelope into an enclosed
space will vary depending on climate, season, daily high
and low temperatures, orientation, and solar exposure.
Thermal energy moves from hot to cold through radiation,
convection, and/or conduction.
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach)
The depth of a building’s envelope and shading devices (as depicted as part of the
envelope system on this diagram) can be exploited to address or utilize potential solar heat
gain as well as maximize daylighting potential, In addition to direct systems, integrated
building envelope design can coordinate with engineered alternative sources of heating
and cooling (such as geothermal heating or below ground labyrinth walls to cool intake
air), the site’s landscape strategy and specific microclimate, and their effect on a building’s
internal environmental as a holistic approach.
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
13
Curtain walls can also be classified by their method of fabrication and installation as:
o Stick system: the components of assembly are constructed piece by piece on-site
o Unitized system is composed of large units that are assembled and glazed in a
factory, shipped to the site, and erected on the building’s structure. The idea of
modularity is evident in this system and is being widely used for airport structures as it
was used in Stansted and Hong Kong airport by Norman Foster.
These systems should be considered in the process of envelope design for airport because they
influence the functionality and buildability and in broader range they can control the whole identity
and shape of the airport building.
3-5- Daylighting: Comfort and control
Daylighting- the illumination of a space by sunlight- is not purely a matter of quantity. Decades of
research have shown that access to sunlight increases our wellbeing, comfort, and productivity. A
building’s envelope provides daylight as well as view, color, shadow and changing environment.
The angle of the sun is different based on the location of a building. The transmission of light into
the spaces is affected not only by sun angle but also by reflection from adjacent buildings or
surfaces through the building envelope. Overshadowing buildings, a body of water, vegetation
and planting, and so on can also influence the amount of daylight penetration.
Daylight factor is the unit used when looking at daylight level. It is a measure of the effectiveness of
daylight indoors, and is calculated as a percentage ratio between illumination indoors and
outdoors on an average overcast day (with dirty windows). A DF of between 2 and 5 percent is
considered “a good balance between lighting and thermal aspects”. If a building’s DF is greater
than 5 percent, heat gain in the summer and heat loss in the winter through glass area are likely to
become problems.16
Shading devices usually are most effective when located outside of an envelope’s glass, on the
principle that heat gain has less impact if you can stop it from coming into the building as much as
possible.
Airport buildings usually have very deep plans which limit natural light penetration during the day
and makes these building a subject to careful consideration of daylighting strategies in very early
16 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach
Stick system
Unitized system
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes
an integrated approach)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
14
stages. Letting light to come inside is mostly being done from both roof and walls in the airport.
Airport envelope should be designed based on this criteria.
3-6- Energy: Minimizing and Maximizing
The reduction of a building’s energy consumption should be addressed in the following order with
regard to capital and operational costs: increasing systems efficiency and reducing loads;
introducing passive systems such as massing, material specification, and solar utilization; and lastly
applying active systems such as photovoltaic panels. 17These strategies need to be addressed from
the very early stages of the design in order to be successful.
To conclude Al the above-mentioned issues are to be considered in the integrated approach of building’s
envelope design. Buildings are like human beings. They should have the ability to adapt itself to the
changing environment and successfully interact with the nature, they should be able to breath, be durable
and live. On the other hand buildings are here to serve human beings, accommodate them and maintain
their comfortable zone throughout the year. These two fundamental goals should be the main focus point
for architects and designers in order to have the optimum and self-sustained environment.
“The ultimate task of architecture is to act in favor of human beings – to interpose itself
between people and the natural environment.”
James Marston Fitch, American Building: The Forces That Shape It.
7- Some Integrated Ideas for Design of an Envelope:
17 Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes an integrated approach
The integrated design of a
building’s envelope, services, and
form is essential for good daylight
provision. The coordination of
diffuse daylight strategies during a
building’s early design stages
(through the use of light shelves or
screens, for example) and a
comprehensive understanding of
the potential light (direct, indirect,
and reflected) of a site play a part
in effective design.
(Jenny Lovell, Building Envelopes
an integrated approach)
People Natural
Environment Architecture
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
15
Envelope, wall, façade
Clearly classifying different methods and material that are nowadays being designed and
constructed in building envelope is a hard work. Since they can be categorized based on
different criteria for example, choice of material, assembly systems, type of system
implemented, and so forth. However in this chapter, it is tried classify some popular and efficient
systems that are now being used widely in transportation infrastructures such as airport.
4-1- Choices of materials in the façade:
Transparency, Translucency, Opacity
Stone, clay, concrete, timber, metal, glass, plastic are prevalent materials being used in façade’s
assemblies. However since airport buildings are so demanding of natural light and broad view in the
spaces, it is attempted in this article to categorize different materials and their assemblies in terms the
interaction of light and material: transparency, translucency, and opacity.
“Transparency is characterized by visual openness and the direct transmission of light, and
opacity results from the complete blockage or reflection of light, translucency is demonstrated
by materials that capture, manipulate, and disperse light…Today there is a renewed interest in
the building envelope as a site for experimentation and in translucency as an architectural
effect…Translucency is within the building skin, the interface between interior and exterior
space, that it exerts its most significant influence.”18
18 Scott Murray, Translucent Building Skins: Material Innovations in Modern and Contemporary Architecture, 2013
The dominant feature of Denver International airport is the
innovative use of translucent fabric material in roof. The interior of
DEN makes its greatest impact on the passenger experience. The
vast center of the terminal, or great hall is illuminated by natural
light filtered through the fabric roof.
(10 airports, Fentress)
Clear and
translucent
laminated
panels for Glass
facades- San
Francisco
Airport
http://www.sanfranciscosuperlimo.com/san-francisco-airport.html
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
16
Translucent envelope - which can mainly be constructed by “marble, polycarbonate”19 - in airport
design seems that is gaining popularity. Part of the façade that is meant to provide the view can be made
out of transparent material, transparency also add reflection to the design and consequently can lift the
essence of space, however when we need light in space but not direct sun gain, it can be the best choice
to use translucent materials such as fabric as in Denver, San Francisco and San Jose by different architects.
Different choices of opaque materials are there to be used based on the concept,
location of the airport, construction process, method of fabrication process, and on-site assemblies. The
above mentioned opaque materials can be used in the envelope, interior and exterior of the building. For
19 Francisco Asensio Cerver, The Architecture of Glass: Shaping Light, 1997
Mineta San Jose Airport California: ( by
Gensler)Celebrating the area’s sunny climate and
agrarian roots. Inside, the concourse has the feel of
a sunlit paseo, with a dramatic curved translucent
roof featuring fabric panels to filter the direct
sunlight and absorb sound. On the exterior, the long
and cable-like outer layer expresses the area’s
technological design heritage while shading the
inner core of the building.
http://www.e-architect.co.uk/america/mineta_san_jose_airport.htm
Dulles International Airport,
Washington DC
Eero Saarinen
Use of transparent materials in
north and south facing elevation
of the airport while there is no
openings in the roof.
LVMH Osaka (Osaka, Japan)
Kengo Kuma and Associates
Use of translucent material in curtain wall assembly has made this
building to illuminate in the night and get light in day.
(Scott Murray, Contemporary Curtain wall Architecture, 2009)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
17
instance, with regard to vernacular architecture of North Carolina, RDU airport has the dominant material of
wood in the interior spaces and that’s what is making it different and outstanding.
4-2- Curtain Walls:
A curtain wall system is an outer covering of a building in which the outer walls are
non-structural, but merely keep the weather out and the occupants in. As the curtain
wall is non-structural it can be made of a lightweight material reducing construction
costs. When glass is used as the curtain wall, a great advantage is that natural light can
penetrate deeper within the building. The curtain wall façade does not carry any dead
load weight from the building other than its own dead load weight. The wall transfers
horizontal wind loads that are incident upon it to the main building structure through
connections at floors or columns of the building. A curtain wall is designed to resist air
and water infiltration, sway induced by wind and seismic forces acting on the building,
and its own dead load weight forces.20
Infills
Infill refers to the large panels that are inserted into the curtain wall between mullions.
Infills are typically glass but may be made up of nearly any exterior building
element.Regardless of the material, infills are typically referred to as glazing, and the
installer of the infill is referred to as a glazier.
Glass, Fabric Veneer, Stone Veneer, Panels, Louvers, windows and vents. 21
20 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtain_wall 21 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtain_wall
RDU International Airport, Raleigh, NC
Fentress
Wood as dominant opaque material in the interior spaces.
http://www.e-architect.co.uk/america/raleigh_durham_international_airport.htm
Sea-Tac Airport in Seatle
Fentress
Glass and aluminum curtain wall has been chosen as wall
system for the airport, this system have created ample
natural light and broad view in interior spaces.
https://www.portseattle.org/JOBS/Pages/default.aspx
http://www.crowncorr.com/our-services/curtain-wall-systems
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
18
Visibility - Sun light - View
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
19
Trutec Building (Seoul, Korea)
Barkow Leibinger Architekten
Custom unit system with
insulating glass structurally
glazed to flat and projecting
unit frames of extruded
aluminum. (Scott Murray, Contemporary Curtain
wall Architecture, 2009)
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
20
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
21
4-3- Double skin facades:
The Double-skin facade is a system of building consisting of two skins placed in such a
way that air flows in the intermediate cavity. The ventilation of the cavity can be natural, fan
supported or mechanical. Apart from the type of the ventilation inside the cavity, the origin
and destination of the air can differ depending mostly on climatic conditions, the use, the
location, the occupational hours of the building and the HVAC strategy.
The glass skins can be single or double glazing units with a distance from 20 cm up to 2
meters. Often, for protection and heat extraction reasons during the cooling period, solar
shading devices are placed inside the cavity.
To conclude:
After going through the holistic approach and integrated process of designing an envelope,
some popular and prevalent, new systems of façade configuration that are relevant to designing
an airport have been analyzed. Decent amount of daylight and view are required in design of an
airport. The above-explained strategies can be considered reasonable for airports and that they
meet those requirements. In addition, in order to provide a good view some different choices of
materials (with transparency point of view) have been analyzed.
Translucent materials such as fabric roof or stone (i.e. marble) can be considered useful in
roof openings where we just need light and not the view. (Denver airport)
To enhance the passenger experience of the airport it might be helpful to use vernacular
material of the place where we are designing the airport in (i.e. RDU has wood in the interior).
Curtain wall system and double skin façade are gaining more and more popularity in the
design of contemporary buildings in compare to single layer façade system with limited openings.
The independent and light weight structure of these systems alongside their high R-value (good
insulation) make them reasonable from thermal and structural point of view. Therefore they can be
considered proper in airport design.
FOSTER AND PARTNERS
A Waagner-Biro double-skin façade being assembled at
One Angel Square, Manchester. The brown outer facade can be
seen being assembled to the inner white façade via struts. These
struts create a walkway between both 'skins' for ventilation, solar
shading and maintenance.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-skin_facade
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
22
CHEK LAP KOK AIRPORT (HKG) Lantau Island, Hong Kong
Area: 9,110,000 sq ft (terminal 1)-1,506,000 sq ft (terminal2)
Capacity: 56,057,751 (in 2012) passengers anually
Number of runways: 2 runways each with 12,467 ft length and the surface of asphalt
The airport has a total of 66 boarding gates.
Chek Lap Kok is planned to handle thirty five million passenger a year in 1998 and
it can expand to 87 m on full completion in 2040.
Plans and site plans: Expansion plan:
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
23
Plan of Departure Level Plan of Arrival s Level
Longitudinal Section
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
24
Model view, section detail
Building Envelope:
Foster's brilliance lies in creating a building that is almost
a kit of giant parts, enabling the terminal to be
completed on time and well within budget; 32000Prefabricated pieces shipped to the site and
assembled on site.
The skylights are glazed with toughened laminated glass, coated to minimize solar gain; they
cover some 6 percent of the floor area of the terminal.
In order to balance the daylight and at the same time reduce the use of energy, the lighting
circuits are activated by a three phase operational control system which allows a balance to be
struck with the level of daylight and creates a smooth transition between the two.
To avoid the impression of a uniformly- lit space and to add variety, certain areas are
accentuated by additional downlights installed in such areas as atrium voids, immigration and
check- in.
In the arrivals hall a different lighting strategy is adopted, using lines of direct low brightness
fluorescent fittings, direct mounted on to the concrete ceiling coffers.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
25
The roof vaults comprise a series of steel shells,
each one assembled on site from components
shipped from as far as Bolton in Lancashire,
Singapore.
The vaults serve to filter and shape light- natural by
day and artificial by night.
Daylighting strategies:
- The building is fully daylit from floor to ceiling through side windows and lines of triangular
skylights in the center of each of the nine barrel-vaulted roofs.
- The natural light is diffused by suspended reflectors along the roof gangway which
provides access for maintenance, as well as support for the artificial lighting fittings.
Material:
- The dominant material in the building is glass; exterior skin of the building is mostly consist of
glass façade.
- Toughened laminated glass used for skylights
- The lattice ribs of the vaults are inset with perforated acoustic panels
Constructability:
- Building is made out of 32000 Prefabricated pieces; enabling easier and faster construction
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
26
Fentress Bradburn Architects
Denver International Airport Denver, Colorado, US
Area: 185,800sqm
Capacity: 53,156,278 (in 2012) passengers annually
# of runways: 6 runways
# of gates: 94 attached
Type: multi-airline hub
Denver airport is a paradigm for airport design with a form that drew its inspiration from its
surroundings.
Initial design concepts investigated the best means to incorporate natural light and mimic the
angular nature of the majestic Rocky Mountains.
The vast center of the terminal, or great hall is illuminated by natural light filtered through the
fabric roof.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
27
Sustainability:
- Fabric roof that largely eliminates the need for artificial lighting during the day and also
removed the need for resource-intensive structural elements.
- Allows stratified hot air to escape by radiating out through the fabric
Daylighting strategies:
- The vast center of the terminal, or great hall is illuminated by natural light filtered through
the fabric roof.
- The integration of skylights with fabric in the roof.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio, Airport Design
Airport – Skin - Envelope
28
Material:
- Dominantly glass façade for exterior
- Fabric roof: tensile membrane structure consisting of a Teflon- coated fiberglass membrane
reinforced by high- strength steel cables.
Constructability:
- Fabric roof, rather than a traditional roof, would be easier to maintain and construct.
Priorities:
- Constructability/ Light/ Heat Flow
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
29
VON GERKAN, MARG & PARTNER
STUTTGART AIRPORT
Germany
Capacity: 9,720,877 (in 2012) passengers annually there are now four terminals with a
maximum capacity of approximately 12 million passengers
Number of runways: 1 runway with 10,974 ft length and the surface of concrete
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
30
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
31
The architect's original idea was that the roof should formed of two layers of glass. These
would trap the warmth of the sunlight, which would then be fed through into the hall or
transformed into usable energy.
As executed, the roof is mainly solid rather transparent, with long bands of roof lights set
between each row of trees. The concourse is best seen at night when the abundance
of internal light emphasizes the building's loftiness and openness. Moreover, the
slenderness of the roof slab is all the more evident.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
32
Daylighting strategies:
- Glass façade
- Skylight
- Flexible louvers controlling the daylight
Material:
- Glass façade; Light weight panels for covering the roof
Constructability:
- Tree- like structural module helps ease of fabrication of the building components
and their installation and construction.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
33
SOM
San Francisco International Airport San Francisco, California, US
Project Area: 1,800,000 sq ft
# of runways: 4 runways
# of gates: 94 attached
Type: multi-airline hub
SFO is the largest airport in the San Francisco Bay Area, and the second busiest in
California, after Los Angeles International Airport.
Its form and aesthetic stem directly from functional necessity. The roof’s wing-like form
directly expresses the structural diagram of its bending forces. So the facility would
remain operational in the event of a major earthquake, SOM engineered the structure
to the highest seismic safety requirements ever imposed on an American airport
terminal.
This strategy incorporated the most ambitious use of base isolation technology.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
34
Daylighting Strategies:
- Skylight incorporated into the structure
- Glass Façade
- Shadings on the exterior glass facade; reducing unfavorable glare.
Maerial:
- Glass façade
- Aluminum Composite Shadings and louvers (double- skin façade)
- Translucent panels covering the skylights in the roof.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
35
Interior Spaces,
Skylights
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
36
Foster and Partners
Stansted Airport London, UK
# of runways: 1runway
# of gates: 200 attached
Type: multi-airline hub
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
37
Daylighting Strategies:
- Skylight incorporated into the structural module
- Glass Façade
Material:
- transparent material for indirect skylight, light material ( 9x9 metre hyperbolic paraboloid GRP
panels) for roof covering
Constructability:
- Tree- like structural module facilitates easier and faster fabrication and construction; it consists
of skylight for indirect daylighting.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
38
Fentress
San Jose International Airport San Jose, CA, US
Project Area: 125,000 sq m
# of runways: 3 runways
# of gates: 200 attached
Type: multi-airline hub
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
39
Daylighting strategies:
- Glass façade
- Skylight
- louvers controlling the daylight; double- skin facade
Material:
- Glass façade;
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
40
Fentress Bradburn Architects
Incheon International Airport Incheon Bay, Seoul, South Korea
Area: 550,000 sqm
Capacity: 50 million
# of runways: 6 runways
# of gates: 46 attached
Type: multi-airline hub
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
41
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
42
Skylights, glass curtainwalls, and clerestories not only save energy by bathing the
space in natural light, they also reinforce the building’s already intuitive
passenger flow.
While 55 skylights and their nearby clerestories are interspersed throughout the
passenger terminal and its attached concourses, the majority of light enters
through floor- to- ceiling glass curtain walls that line the concourses and flank
the terminal.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
43
Daylighting Strategies:
- Skylight incorporated into the structural module
- Glass Curtainwalls
Material:
- transparent material for indirect skylight, glass curtainwalls, clerestories
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
44
Platt Byard Dovell White
The New 42nd Street Studios New York, NY, US
Curtain Wall:
Stick system with extruded- aluminum mullions and low- e coated insulating glass
units; on the south façade, an external layer of perforated stainless-steel louver
blades set within an armature of painted steel.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
45
-Multi layered façade components -Interior view of curtain wall in dance studio
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
46
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
47
Platt Byard Dovell White
Green-Wood Mausoleum Brooklyn, NY, US
Curtain Wall:
Custom hybrid system of preglazed units mounted in a shinglelike configuration
onto steel mullions.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
48
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
49
Kengo Kuma and Associates
LVMH Osaka Osaka, Japan
Curtain wall:
Hybrid system with floor- to- floor translucent panels of laminated stone and
glass preglazed to extruded- aluminum frames and mounted onto vertical steel
mullions.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
50
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
51
Atelier Jean Nouvel
Torre Agbar Barcelona, Spain
Curtain Wall:
Custom system of clear translucent glass louvers suspended on extruded
aluminum framing members, in front of a load- bearing reinforced- concrete
with punched windows.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
52
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
53
Nicholas Grimshaw & Partners
Mabeg Headquarters Soest, Germanys
The façade is clad with silver corrugated aluminum sheeting ( curved sheets for
the corners of the building) fixed to vertical aluminum rails and interrupted by
horizontal window bands 2.6 m high behind perorated aluminum sunshades.
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
54
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
55
Conclusion:
Airports as a transport infrastructure are often huge, highly complex structures,
whose owners and operators have high expectations with regard to security,
functionality, comfort, economic efficiency and sustainability.
Their environmental and energy footprint is massive. Thus, looking beyond mere
cost consideration, architects, investors and planners need to be acutely mindful of the
welfare of future generations. The use of thermally insulated facades, intelligent sunshade
and ventilation concepts and/or the integration of photovoltaic modules on roofs and
facades can lead to significantly lower energy consumption and running costs for
decades to come.22
Building envelope can be studied according to different phases of the building
life; we divide these considerations into two groups: in chapter one; those aspects of the
building envelope which are more important in construction phase will be studied; and
in chapter two, those element that are more significant during the design part are
introduced.
In chapter three, we introduce the holistic approach toward building envelope
design considering integral elements such as air, heat, water, daylighting, and energy.
In chapter four; we try to get to a better understanding of the preferred material
and approaches for design of building envelope in an airport by introducing curtain
walls, double- skin facade and choice of material for façade.
Studying precedents helped us to understand how architects prioritize different
elements of building envelope in a building as complicated as airports.
As stated in the fifth chapter; daylighting, providing inviting and pleasant interiors
by implementing glass facades, and constructability are of top importance in choosing
the approach toward building envelope design.
Tree- like structural module would be a suitable strategy in airport building
design; it facilitates incorporating daylighting elements and also faster and easier
construction. the modular arrangement of these elements also helps to provide a
humane scale in the vast interior spaces of an airport.
22 22 Hindrichs. Heusler (Eds.), Facades – Building Envelopes for the 21st century. 2010
ARC 500 – Advanced Studio Research
Skin - Architecture - Airport
56
References:
1- Building Envelopes an integrated approach, Jenny Lovell,2010
2- The Future Envelope 2: Architecture – Climate – Skin, Edited by Ulrich Knaack and
Tillmann Klein, 2009.
3- Translucent Building Skins, Scott Murray,
4- Building Envelopes for the 21st century, Hindrichs. Heusler (Eds.), Facades . 2010
5- 10 airports, Fentress Bradburn Architects
6- Translucent Building Skins: Material Innovations in Modern and Contemporary
Architecture,Scott Murray 2013
7- Contemporary Curtain wall Architecture, Scott Murray, 2009
8- Norman Foster Works4
9- Norman Foster Works 5, Foster and partners, 2009
10- The Architecture of Glass: shaping light, Francisco Asensio Cerver, 1997
11- Façade Construction Manual, Herzog Krippner Lang, 2004
12- Aluminum Architecture, Construction and Details, Hugues Wilquin, 2001
13- http://www.southwall.com/southwall/Home/Products/Commercial/HeatMirrorIns
ulatingGlass.html
14- http://www.isover.com/Q-A/Implementation/What-is-a-thermal-bridge
15- http://www.es-so.com/en/Solar-shading
16- https://www.portseattle.org/JOBS/Pages/default.aspx
17- http://www.crowncorr.com/our-services/curtain-wall-systems
18- http://www.sanfranciscosuperlimo.com/san-francisco-airport.html
19- http://www.e-architect.co.uk/america/raleigh_durham_international_airport.htm
20- https://www.portseattle.org/JOBS/Pages/default.aspx
21- http://www.crowncorr.com/our-services/curtain-wall-systems
22- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtain_wall
23- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double-skin_facade
24- http://www.e-architect.co.uk/america/mineta_san_jose_airport.htm