Upload
murah-azevedo
View
229
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 1/378
Epeybhl
Hp
Hqep tbe Pnlie]nguej @utjep
Tbk} e@hhc yn} de}kiled nld vu`jk}bed `{ Vjnlet VDA, Ahp ghpe apeee@hhc} qk}kt hup Ye` }kte nt bttv?((yyy,vjnletvda,mhg(, Th benp n`hut hup jnte}t pejen}e} }u`}mpk`e th tbe Vjnlet VDA Ley}jettep ,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 2/378
Epeybhl
0 ha =9;
VPEANME TH TBE AKP]T EDKTKHL
Tbe Nutbhp yk}be} kt th `e uldep}thhd tbnt Epeybhl k}
vphlhulmed n} n yhpd ha tbpee }{jjn`je}* njj }bhpt—tbu}*
E'pe'ybhl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 3/378
Epeybhl
= ha =9;
VPEANME TH ]EMHLD EDKTKHL
Bnqkli `eel eln`jed `{ tbe ckldle}} ha tbe vu`jkm th
iet tbphuib nl ulu}unjj{ jnpie edktkhl ha ‒Epeybhl‛ kl n
qep{ }bhpt tkge* K bnqe tncel tbe hvvhptulkt{ ha n }emhld
edktkhl th gnce }hge leme}}np{ mhppemtkhl}* nld th ndd n
aey vn}}nie} ybepe kt }tpumc ge tbnt tbe{ yhujd `e
nvvphvpkntej{ kltphdumed3 tbe vn}}nie} npe aey* nld kt k} g{
akred klteltkhl leqep th thumb tbe yhpc ninkl,
K gn{ vepbnv} `e njjhyed th }n{ n yhpd hp tyh bepe kl
peaepelme th ‒Tbe Mhgkli Pnme*‛ th tbe }umme}} ha ybkmb
`hhc ‒Epeybhl‛ bn} `eel qep{ ielepnjj{ }et dhyl n} due,
Tbk} k} n gk}tnce* tbhuib n vepaemtj{ lntupnj hle, Tbe anmt
k} tbnt ‒Epeybhl‛ yn} aklk}bed* yktb tbe ermevtkhl ha tbe
jn}t tyelt{ vnie} nld n }eltelme hp tyh kl}epted aphg tkge
th tkge bepe nld tbepe tbphuibhut tbe `hhc* `eahpe tbe
akp}t ndqeptk}egelt ha ‒Tbe Mhgkli Pnme‛ nvvenped, N
apkeld bnqkli mnjjed g{ ntteltkhl th hle ha tbe akp}t ha
tbe}e ndqeptk}egelt}* nld }uiie}tkli tbnt kt vph`n`j{
peaepped th n yhpc ha }kgkjnp mbnpnmtep th g{ hyl* K thhc
‒Epeybhl‛ th n yejj'clhyl akpg ha vu`jk}bep} hl tbe >}t
ha Gn{ >29>* nld jeat kt kl tbekp bnld} ahp mhl}kdepntkhl, K
tbel yelt n`phnd* nld hl jenplkli tbnt tbe vu`jk}bep}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 4/378
Epeybhl
4 ha =9;
njjuded th demjkled tbe G],* K jet kt njhle ahp }kr hp }eqel
ghltb}* nld* `ekli kl nl hut'ha'tbe'yn{ vnpt ha Ktnj{*leqep }ny n }klije peqkey ha ‒Tbe Mhgkli Pnme*‛ lhp n
mhv{ ha tbe yhpc, Hl g{ petupl* K vupvh}ej{ nqhkded
jhhckli klth kt ultkj K bnd }elt `nmc g{ jn}t peqk}e} th tbe
vpkltep, Tbel K bnd gumb vjen}upe kl pendkli kt* `ut yn}
kldeed }upvpk}ed nt tbe gnl{ jkttje vhklt} ha }kgkjnpkt{
`etyeel tbe tyh `hhc}* kl }vkte ha tbekp eltkpekldeveldelme th hle nlhtbep,
K peipet tbnt peqkeyep} bnqe kl }hge mn}e} `eel klmjkled
th tpent tbe mbnvtep} hl Gnmbkle} n} nl nttegvt th pedume
Gp, Dnpykl‛} tbehp{ th nl n`}updkt{, Lhtbkli mhujd `e
auptbep aphg g{ klteltkhl* nld aey tbkli} yhujd `e ghpe
dk}tn}teauj th ge tbnl nl{ nttegvt th jnuib nt Gp, Dnpykl3`ut K gu}t hyl tbnt K bnqe g{}eja th tbnlc ahp tbe
gk}mhlmevtkhl* ahp K aejt }upe tbnt g{ klteltkhl yhujd `e
gk}}ed* `ut vpeaepped lht th yencel tbe mbnvtep} `{
ervjnlntkhl* nld cley qep{ yejj tbnt Gp, Dnpykl‛} tbehp{
yhujd tnce lh bnpg, Tbe hlj{ ~ue}tkhl kl g{ gkld yn}
bhy anp K mhujd naahpd th `e gk}pevpe}elted n} jnuibkli nt
tbnt ahp ybkmb K bnqe tbe gh}t vphahuld ndgkpntkhl, K ng
}upvpk}ed* bhyeqep* tbnt tbe `hhc nt ybkmb }umb nl
erngvje ha tbe }vemkhu} gk}u}e ha nlnjhi{ yhujd }eeg
gh}t lntupnjj{ jeqejjed }bhujd bnqe hmmupped th lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 5/378
Epeybhl
5 ha =9;
peqkeyep3 lektbep }bnjj K geltkhl tbe lnge ha tbe `hhc
bepe* tbhuib K }bhujd anlm{ tbnt tbe bklt ikqel ykjj }uaakme,K bnqe `eel bejd `{ }hge ybh}e hvklkhl} K pe}vemt th
bnqe delked gel‛} pe}vhl}k`kjkt{ ahp tbekp nmtkhl}, Be ybh
dhe} tbk} k} nl eleg{ ybh de}epqe} lh ~unptep, K }bhujd
bnqe kgnikled tbnt K bnd `eel }uaakmkeltj{ ervjkmkt* `ut
bnqe gnde n aey nddktkhl} th tbe mbnvtep hl Gnjmhltelt}*
ybkmb ykjj* K tbklc* }epqe th peldep auptbep gk}tncekgvh}}k`je,
Nl nlhl{ghu} mhppe}vhldelt `{ tbe bnld'ypktkli
vpe}ugn`j{ n mjepi{gnl+ tejj} ge tbnt kl ~uhtkli aphg tbe
Jntkl ipnggnp K }bhujd nt nl{ pnte bnqe dhle }h mhppemtj{*
nld tbnt K }bhujd bnqe ypkttel ‒nipkmhjn}‛ kl}tend ha
‒nipkmhjne", Be ndded }hgetbkli n`hut nl{ `h{ kl tbeahuptb ahpg* !m,* !m,* ybkmb K }bnjj lht ~uhte* `ut ybkmb
gnde ge qep{ ulmhgahptn`je, Kt gn{ `e }nkd tbnt K gu}t
bnqe gk}~uhted aphg de}kil* aphg kilhpnlme* hp `{ n }jkv
ha tbe vel3 `ut }upej{ kl tbe}e dn{} kt ykjj `e pemhilk}ed n}
bnp}b th n}}kil jkgkt} th tbe njj'eg`pnmkli `huldje}}le}} ha
tputb* nld kt ykjj `e ghpe pen}hln`j{ n}}uged tbnt ENMB
ha tbe tbpee vh}}k`je mnu}e} ha gk}~uhtntkhl gu}t bnqe bnd
kt} }bnpe kl tbe nvvnpelt `juldep, Tbe npt ha ypktkli tbkli}
tbnt }bnjj }huld pkibt nld {et `e yphli bn} gnde }h gnl{
pevutntkhl}* nld naahpd} mhgahpt th }umb n jnpie lug`ep ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 6/378
Epeybhl
1 ha =9;
pendep}* tbnt K mhujd lht qeltupe th leijemt kt3 tbe Jntkl
ipnggnp* bhyeqep* k} n }u`oemt hl ybkmb }hge ha tbe {huliep geg`ep} ha tbe mhggulkt{ aeej }tphlij{* }h K
bnqe lhy ypkttel ‒nipkmhjn}", K bnqe nj}h vnpted yktb tbe
yhpd ‒klahptulkng‛ tbhuib lht yktbhut peipet+* `ut bnqe
lht dnped th geddje yktb htbep }kgkjnp klnmmupnmke},
Ahp tbe klmhl}k}telmke} kl tbe `hhc* nld K ng nynpe
tbnt tbepe npe lht n aey* K gu}t n}c tbe kldujielme ha tbependep, Tbe `jnge* bhyeqep* jke} mbkeaj{ yktb tbe
Epeybhlknl} tbeg}ejqe}* ahp tbe{ yepe penjj{ n qep{
dkaakmujt vehvje th uldep}tnld, Tbe gh}t ijnpkli nlhgnjke}
}eeged th naahpd tbeg lh kltejjemtunj klmhlqelkelme3
lektbep* vphqkded tbe{ dkd lht nmtunjj{ }ee tbe ghle{
dphvvkli hut ha tbekp vhmcet}* lhp }uaaep kggedkntevb{}kmnj vnkl* yhujd tbe{ jk}tel th nl{ npiugelt} n} th tbe
yn}te ha ghle{ nld bnvvkle}} ybkmb tbekp ahjj{ mnu}ed
tbeg, @ut tbk} bnd nl eaaemt ha ybkmb K bnqe jkttje pen}hl
th mhgvjnkl* ahp K yn} njjhyed njgh}t th mnjj tbeg jkae'
jhli }eja'demekqep} th tbekp anme}* nld tbe{ }nkd kt yn} ~ukte
tpue* `ut tbnt kt dkd lht gnttep,
K gu}t lht mhlmjude yktbhut ervpe}}kli g{ gh}t
}klmepe tbnlc} th g{ mpktkm} nld th tbe vu`jkm ahp tbe
jelkelm{ nld mhl}kdepntkhl yktb ybkmb tbe{ bnqe tpented
g{ ndqeltupe},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 7/378
Epeybhl
9 ha =9;
Oule ;* >290
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 8/378
Epeybhl
2 ha =9;
VPEANME TH TBE PEQK]ED EDKTKHL
G{ vu`jk}bep yk}be} ge th }n{ n aey yhpd} n`hut tbe
iele}k} ha tbe yhpc* n peqk}ed nld eljnpied edktkhl ha
ybkmb be k} bepeyktb jn{kli `eahpe tbe vu`jkm, K tbepeahpe
vjnme hl pemhpd n} gumb n} K mnl pegeg`ep hl tbk} bend
natep n jnv}e ha ghpe tbnl tbkpt{ {enp},
Tbe akp}t vnpt ha ‒Epeybhl‛ ypkttel yn} nl nptkmje
bended ‒Dnpykl nghli tbe Gnmbkle}*‛ nld }kiled
Mejjnpku}, Kt yn} ypkttel kl tbe Uvvep Pnliktntn dk}tpkmt ha
tbe Mnltep`up{ Vphqklme n} kt tbel yn}+ ha Ley _enjnld*
nld nvvenped nt Mbpk}tmbupmb kl tbe Vpe}} Ley}vnvep*
Oule >=* >21=, N mhv{ ha tbk} nptkmje k} kldered uldep g{
`hhc} kl tbe @pktk}b Gu}eug mntnjhiue, Kl vn}}kli* K gn{
}n{ tbnt tbe hvelkli mbnvtep} ha ‒Epeybhl‛ yepe nj}h
dpnyl aphg tbe Uvvep Pnliktntn dk}tpkmt* yktb }umb
ghdkakmntkhl} n} K ahuld mhlqelkelt,
N }emhld nptkmje hl tbe }nge }u`oemt n} tbe hle ou}t
peaepped th nvvenped kl tbe Vpe}} }bhptj{ natep tbe akp}t* `ut
K bnqe lh mhv{, Kt tpented Gnmbkle} aphg n dkaaepelt vhklt
ha qkey* nld yn} tbe `n}k} ha vv, 096'094 ha tbe vpe}elt
edktkhl ha ‒Epeybhl,‛ s>w Tbk} qkey ujtkgntej{ jed ge th
tbe tbehp{ K vut ahpynpd kl ‒Jkae nld Bn`kt*‛ vu`jk}bed kl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 9/378
Epeybhl
; ha =9;
Lhqeg`ep >299, K bnqe vut n `npe hutjkle ha tbk} tbehp{
ybkmb K `ejkeqe th `e ~ukte }huld+ klth tbe ghutb ha nlEpeybhlknl vbkjh}hvbep kl Mbnvtep RRQKK, ha tbk} `hhc,
Kl >215 K peyphte nld eljnpied ‒Dnpykl nghli tbe
Gnmbkle}‛ ahp tbe Pen}hlep* n vnvep vu`jk}bed kl Jhldhl
`{ Gp, I, O, Bhj{hnce, Kt nvvenped Ouj{ >* >215* uldep
tbe bendkli* ‒Tbe Gembnlkmnj Mpentkhl*‛ nld mnl `e }eel
kl tbe @pktk}b Gu}eug, K ninkl peyphte nld eljnpied kt* tkjjkt n}}uged tbe ahpg kl ybkmb kt nvvenped kl tbe akp}t
edktkhl ha ‒Epeybhl,‛
Tbe lert vnpt ha ‒Epeybhl‛ tbnt K yphte yn} tbe
‒Yhpjd ha tbe Ul`hpl*‛ n vpejkgklnp{ ahpg ha ybkmb yn}
}elt th Gp, Bhj{hnce‛} vnvep* `ut n} K mnllht akld kt
nghli tbh}e mhvke} ha tbe Pen}hlep tbnt npe kl tbe @pktk}bGu}eug* K mhlmjude tbnt kt yn} lht nmmevted, K bnqe*
bhyeqep* pntbep n }tphli anlm{ tbnt kt nvvenped kl }hge
Jhldhl vnvep ha tbe }nge mbnpnmtep n} tbe Pen}hlep* lht
qep{ jhli natep Ouj{ >* >215* `ut K bnqe lh mhv{,
K nj}h yphte n`hut tbk} tkge tbe }u`}tnlme ha ybnt
ujtkgntej{ `emnge tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}* nld tbe tpknj ha n
gnl ahp `ekli kl n mhl}ugvtkhl, Tbe}e ahup detnmbed
vnvep} yepe* K `ejkeqe* njj tbnt yn} ypkttel ha ‒Epeybhl‛
`eahpe >296, @etyeel >215 nld >296 K yphte bnpdj{
nl{tbkli* `ekli bhveauj ha nttnklkli tbnt }umme}} n} n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 10/378
Epeybhl
>6 ha =9;
vnkltep ybkmb kt bn} lht `eel qhumb}naed ge th nttnkl* `ut
kl tbe nutugl ha >296* ou}t n} K yn} `eikllkli th iethmmn}khlnjj{ buli nt Ph{nj Nmndeg{ erbk`ktkhl}* g{
apkeld* tbe jnte ]kp A, L, tbel Gp,+ @phhge* }uiie}ted th
ge tbnt K }bhujd ndd }hgeybnt th tbe nptkmje} K bnd njpend{
ypkttel* nld }tpkli tbeg thietbep klth n `hhc, K yn} pntbep
akped `{ tbe kden* `ut n} K hlj{ yhpced nt tbe G], hl
]uldn{} kt yn} }hge ghltb} `eahpe K bnd mhgvjeted kt,K }ee aphg g{ }emhld Vpeanme tbnt K thhc tbe `hhc th
Ge}}p}, Mbnvgnl ! Bnjj Gn{ >* >29>* nld hl tbekp
peoemtkhl ha kt* uldep tbe ndqkme ha hle ybh bn} nttnkled
tbe bkibe}t pnlc nghli jkqkli ypktep}* K jet kt }jeev* tkjj K
thhc kt th Gp, Tpu`lep enpj{ kl >290, N} peinpd} kt}
peoemtkhl `{ Ge}}p}, Mbnvgnl ! Bnjj* K `ejkeqe tbekp pendep ndqk}ed tbeg ~ukte yk}ej{, Tbe{ thjd ge be
pevhpted tbnt kt yn} n vbkjh}hvbkmnj yhpc* jkttje jkcej{ th `e
vhvujnp yktb n jnpie mkpmje ha pendep}, K bhve tbnt ka K bnd
`eel tbekp pendep* nld tbe `hhc bnd `eel }u`gktted th
g{}eja* K }bhujd bnqe ndqk}ed tbeg th tbe }nge eaaemt,
‒Epeybhl‛ nvvenped yktb tbe jn}t dn{ hp tyh ha Gnpmb
>290, K nttpk`ute kt} uljhhced'ahp }umme}} gnklj{ th tyh
enpj{ anqhupn`je peqkey}—tbe akp}t kl tbe Vnjj Gnjj Inzette
ha Nvpkj >0* nld tbe }emhld kl tbe ]vemtnthp ha Nvpkj 06,
Tbepe yn} nj}h nlhtbep mnu}e, K yn} mhgvjnklkli hlme th n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 11/378
Epeybhl
>> ha =9;
apkeld tbnt tbhuib ‒Epeybhl‛ bnd get yktb }umb n ynpg
pemevtkhl* g{ }u`}e~uelt `hhc} bnd `eel njj ha tbegvpnmtkmnjj{ }tkjj'`hpl, Be }nkd* ‒[hu ahpiet hle mbnpg tbnt
‒Epeybhl‛ bnd* `ut ybkmb lhle ha {hup htbep `hhc} mnl
bnqe,‛ K n}ced ybnt8 nld yn} nl}yeped* ‒Tbe }huld ha n
ley qhkme* nld ha nl ulclhyl qhkme,‛
Tbe akp}t edktkhl ha ‒Epeybhl‛ }hjd kl n`hut tbpee
yeec}3 K bnd lht tncel ghujd}* nld n} tbe degnld yn}}tphli* kt yn} }et uv ninkl kggedkntej{, K gnde n aey
ulkgvhptnlt njtepntkhl} nld nddktkhl}* nld ndded n Vpeanme*
ha ybkmb K mnllht }n{ tbnt K ng vnptkmujnpj{ vphud* `ut nl
klervepkelmed ypktep yktb n bend }hgeybnt tupled `{
ulervemted }umme}} k} lht th `e tpu}ted yktb n vpeanme, K
gnde n aey auptbep qep{ tpkajkli njtepntkhl} `eahpe ghujd}yepe tncel* `ut }klme tbe }uggep ha >290* n} ley edktkhl}
yepe aphg tkge th tkge ynlted* tbe{ bnqe `eel vpklted
aphg }tepeh} tbel gnde,
Bnqkli lhy* K aenp* nt thh ipent jelitb dhle ybnt K yn}
n}ced th dh* K }bhujd jkce th ndd n aey yhpd} hl g{ hyl
nmmhult, K ng }tkjj ankpj{ yejj }ntk}aked yktb tbh}e vnpt} ha
‒Epeybhl‛ tbnt yepe peventedj{ peypkttel* `ut aphg tbh}e
tbnt bnd hlj{ n }klije ypktkli K yhujd ijndj{ mut hut }hge
ahpt{ hp akat{ vnie} ka K mhujd,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 12/378
Epeybhl
>0 ha =9;
Tbk}* bhyeqep* gn{ lht `e* ahp tbe mhv{pkibt ykjj
vph`n`j{ ervkpe kl n jkttje hqep tyejqe {enp}, Kt yn}leme}}np{* tbepeahpe* th peqk}e tbe `hhc tbphuibhut ahp
jktepnp{ klejeinlmke}—ha ybkmb K ahuld gnl{ ghpe tbnl K
bnd ervemted—nld nj}h th gnce }umb }u`}tnltknj nddktkhl}
n} }bhujd }emupe n ley jen}e ha jkae—nt nl{ pnte ahp tbe
mhv{pkibt, Ka* tbel* kl}tend ha muttkli hut* }n{ akat{ vnie}* K
bnqe `eel mhgvejjed th ndd n`hut }krt{ klqktn Gklepqn— tbe `jnge pe}t} lektbep yktb g{ vu`jk}bep lhp yktb ge*
`ut yktb tbe mhv{pkibt jny}, Leqeptbeje}} K mnl n}}upe tbe
pendep tbnt* tbhuib K bnqe ahuld kt nl kpc}hge tn}c th tnce
uv yhpc ybkmb K tbhuibt K bnd iht pkd ha tbkpt{ {enp} nih*
nld gumb ha ybkmb K ng n}bnged ha* K bnqe dhle g{ `e}t
th gnce tbe ley gnttep }nqhup }h gumb ha tbe `ettep vhptkhl} ha tbe hjd* tbnt lhle `ut tbe `e}t mpktkm} }bnjj
vepmekqe nt ybnt vjnme} tbe inv} ha `etyeel tbkpt{ nld
ahpt{ {enp} hmmup,
Jn}tj{* ka g{ pendep} lhte n mhl}kdepn`je dkaaepelme
`etyeel tbe jktepnp{ temblk~ue ha ‒Epeybhl‛ nld tbnt ha
‒Epeybhl Peqk}kted*‛ K yhujd pegkld tbeg tbnt* n} K bnqe
ou}t }bhyl* ‒Epeybhl‛ jhhc }hgetbkli jkce tel {enp} kl
ypktkli* nld eqel }h yn} ypkttel yktb ipent dkaakmujt{*
ybkje ‒Epeybhl Peqk}kted‛ yn} ypkttel en}kj{ `etyeel
Lhqeg`ep >;66 nld tbe eld ha Nvpkj >;6>, Tbepe k} lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 13/378
Epeybhl
>= ha =9;
meltpnj kden uldepj{kli ‒Epeybhl*‛ ybepen} tbe nttegvt th
penjk}e tbe eaaemt ha n }klije }uvvh}ed ipent gkpnmjedhgklnte} tbe ybhje ha kt} }umme}}hp, Kl ‒Epeybhl‛ tbepe
yn} bnpdj{ nl{ }thp{* nld jkttje nttegvt th ikqe jkae nld
kldkqkdunjkt{ th tbe mbnpnmtep}3 K bhve tbnt kl ‒Epeybhl
Peqk}kted‛ `htb tbe}e deaemt} bnqe `eel kl ipent gen}upe
nqhkded, ‒Epeybhl‛ yn} lht nl hpinlkm ybhje* ‒Epeybhl
Peqk}kted‛ gn{ ankpj{ mjnkg th `e hle, Leqeptbeje}}*tbhuib kl jktepnp{ yhpcgnl}bkv K dh lht dhu`t tbnt tbk}
jn}t'lnged `hhc k} nl kgvphqegelt hl tbe akp}t* K }bnjj `e
nipeen`j{ }upvpk}ed ka K ng lht thjd tbnt ‒Epeybhl*‛ yktb
njj kt} anujt}* k} tbe `ettep pendkli ha tbe tyh,
]NGUEJ @UTJEP,
Nuiu}t 9* >;6>
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 14/378
Epeybhl
>4 ha =9;
MBNVTEP K? YN]TE JNLD]
Ka tbe pendep ykjj ermu}e ge* K ykjj }n{ lhtbkli ha g{
nltemedelt}* lhp ha tbe mkpmug}tnlme} ybkmb jed ge th
jenqe g{ lntkqe mhultp{3 tbe lnppntkqe yhujd `e tedkhu} th
bkg nld vnklauj th g{}eja, ]uaakme kt* tbnt ybel K jeat bhge
kt yn} yktb tbe klteltkhl ha ihkli th }hge ley mhjhl{*
nld ektbep akldkli* hp eqel vepbnv} vupmbn}kli* yn}te
mphyl jnld }uktn`je ahp mnttje hp }beev anpgkli* `{ ybkmb
genl} K tbhuibt tbnt K mhujd `ettep g{ ahptule} ghpe
pnvkdj{ tbnl kl Elijnld,
Kt ykjj `e }eel tbnt K dkd lht }ummeed kl g{ de}kil* nld
tbnt bhyeqep gumb K gn{ bnqe get yktb tbnt yn} ley
nld }tpnlie* K bnqe `eel uln`je th penv nl{ vemulknp{
ndqnltnie,
Kt k} tpue* K kgnikle g{}eja th bnqe gnde n dk}mhqep{
ybkmb* ka K mnl `e tbe akp}t th vphakt `{ kt* ykjj `pkli ge n
pemhgvel}e `e{hld njj ghle{ mhgvutntkhl* nld }emupe
ge n vh}ktkhl }umb n} bn} lht `eel nttnkled `{ ghpe tbnl
}hge akateel hp }krteel vep}hl}* }klme tbe mpentkhl ha tbe
ulkqep}e, @ut th tbk} eld K gu}t vh}}e}} g{}eja ha n
mhl}kdepn`je }ug ha ghle{? lektbep dh K clhy bhy th iet
kt* ermevt `{ kltepe}tkli tbe vu`jkm kl g{ }thp{* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 15/378
Epeybhl
>5 ha =9;
kldumkli tbe mbnpktn`je th mhge ahpynpd nld n}}k}t ge,
Yktb tbk} bhve K lhy vu`jk}b g{ ndqeltupe}3 `ut K dh }hyktb ipent pejumtnlme* ahp K aenp tbnt g{ }thp{ ykjj `e
dhu`ted ulje}} K tejj tbe ybhje ha kt3 nld {et K dnpe lht dh
}h* je}t htbep} yktb ghpe genl} tbnl gkle }bhujd iet tbe
}tnpt ha ge, K vpeaep tbe pk}c ha `ekli dhu`ted th tbnt ha
`ekli nltkmkvnted* nld bnqe tbepeahpe mhlmenjed g{
de}tklntkhl hl jenqkli Elijnld* n} nj}h tbe vhklt aphgybkmb K `einl g{ ghpe }epkhu} nld dkaakmujt ohuple{,
G{ mbkea mhl}hjntkhl jke} kl tbe anmt tbnt tputb `enp} kt}
hyl kgvpe}}* nld tbnt g{ }thp{ ykjj mnpp{ mhlqkmtkhl `{
pen}hl ha tbe klteplnj eqkdelme} ahp kt} nmmupnm{, Lh hle
ybh k} bkg}eja bhle}t ykjj dhu`t g{ `ekli }h,
K penmbed g{ de}tklntkhl kl hle ha tbe jn}t ghltb} ha >212* `ut K dnpe lht geltkhl tbe }en}hl* je}t tbe pendep
}bhujd intbep kl ybkmb begk}vbepe K yn}, Tbe mhjhl{ yn}
hle ybkmb bnd lht `eel hveled uv eqel th tbe gh}t
ndqeltuphu} }ettjep} ahp ghpe tbnl ekibt hp lkle {enp}*
bnqkli `eel vpeqkhu}j{ ulklbn`kted* }nqe `{ n aey tpk`e}
ha }nqnie} ybh ape~uelted tbe }en`hnpd, Tbe vnpt clhyl
th Euphvenl} mhl}k}ted ha n mhn}t'jkle n`hut ekibt buldped
gkje} kl jelitb naahpdkli tbpee hp ahup ihhd bnp`hup}+*
nld n tpnmt ha mhultp{ erteldkli kljnld ahp n }vnme qnp{kli
aphg tyh th tbpee buldped gkje}* ultkj kt n penmbed tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 16/378
Epeybhl
>1 ha =9;
haa}bhht} ha nl ermeedklij{ jhat{ pnlie ha ghultnkl}*
ybkmb mhujd `e }eel aphg anp hut uvhl tbe vjnkl}* nldyepe mhqeped yktb vepvetunj }lhy, Tbe mhn}t yn}
vepaemtj{ yejj clhyl `htb lhptb nld }hutb ha tbe tpnmt th
ybkmb K bnqe njjuded* `ut kl lektbep dkpemtkhl yn} tbepe n
}klije bnp`hup ahp akqe buldped gkje}* nld tbe ghultnkl}*
ybkmb de}melded njgh}t klth tbe }en* yepe mhqeped yktb
tbkmc tkg`ep* }h tbnt lhle yhujd tbklc ha }ettjkli,Yktb tbk} `n{ ha jnld* bhyeqep* tbe mn}e yn} dkaaepelt,
Tbe bnp`hup} yepe }uaakmkelt3 tbe mhultp{ yn} tkg`eped*
`ut lht thh benqkj{3 kt yn} ndgkpn`j{ }ukted ahp nipkmujtupe3
kt nj}h mhltnkled gkjjkhl} hl gkjjkhl} ha nmpe} ha tbe gh}t
`enutkaujj{ ipn}}ed mhultp{ kl tbe yhpjd* nld ha tbe `e}t
}ukted ahp njj gnllep ha }beev nld mnttje, Tbe mjkgnte yn}tegvepnte* nld qep{ benjtb{3 tbepe yepe lh ykjd nlkgnj}*
lhp yepe tbe lntkqe} dnliephu}* `ekli aey kl lug`ep nld
ha nl kltejjkielt tpnmtn`je dk}vh}ktkhl,
Kt gn{ `e pendkj{ uldep}thhd tbnt ybel hlme
Euphvenl} }et ahht uvhl tbk} teppkthp{ tbe{ yepe lht }jhy
th tnce ndqnltnie ha kt} mnvn`kjktke}, ]beev nld mnttje yepe
kltphdumed* nld `ped yktb ertpege pnvkdkt{3 gel thhc uv
tbekp 56*666 hp >66*666 nmpe} ha mhultp{* ihkli kljnld hle
`ebkld tbe htbep* tkjj kl n aey {enp} tbepe yn} lht nl nmpe
`etyeel tbe }en nld tbe aphlt pnlie} ybkmb yn} lht tncel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 17/378
Epeybhl
>9 ha =9;
uv* nld }tntkhl} ektbep ahp }beev hp mnttje yepe }vhtted
n`hut nt kltepqnj} ha }hge tyelt{ hp tbkpt{ gkje} hqep tbeybhje mhultp{, Tbe aphlt pnlie} }thvved tbe tkde ha
}~unttep} ahp }hge jkttje tkge3 kt yn} tbhuibt tbnt tbepe yn}
thh gumb }lhy uvhl tbeg ahp thh gnl{ ghltb} kl tbe
{enp*—tbnt tbe }beev yhujd iet jh}t* tbe iphuld `ekli thh
dkaakmujt ahp }bevbepdkli*—tbnt tbe ervel}e ha iettkli
yhhj dhyl th tbe }bkv‛} }kde yhujd ent uv tbe anpgep‛}vphakt}*—nld tbnt tbe ipn}} yn} thh phuib nld }hup ahp
}beev th tbpkqe uvhl3 `ut hle natep nlhtbep detepgkled th
tp{ tbe ervepkgelt* nld kt yn} yhldepauj bhy }umme}}aujj{
kt tupled hut, Gel vu}bed anptbep nld anptbep klth tbe
ghultnkl}* nld ahuld n qep{ mhl}kdepn`je tpnmt kl}kde tbe
aphlt pnlie* `etyeel kt nld nlhtbep ybkmb yn} jhatkep }tkjj*tbhuib eqel tbk} yn} lht tbe bkibe}t* tbe ipent }lhy{ hle
ybkmb mhujd `e }eel aphg hut uvhl tbe vjnkl}, Tbk}
}emhld pnlie* bhyeqep* }eeged th gnpc tbe ertpege
jkgkt} ha vn}thpnj mhultp{3 nld kt yn} bepe* nt n }gnjj nld
leyj{ ahulded }tntkhl* tbnt K yn} pemekqed n} n mndet* nld
}hhl peiujnpj{ egvjh{ed, K yn} tbel ou}t tyelt{'tyh {enp}
hjd,
K yn} dejkibted yktb tbe mhultp{ nld tbe gnllep ha
jkae, Kt yn} g{ dnkj{ `u}kle}} th ih uv th tbe thv ha n
meptnkl bkib ghultnkl* nld dhyl hle ha kt} }vup} hl th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 18/378
Epeybhl
>2 ha =9;
tbe ajnt* kl hpdep th gnce }upe tbnt lh }beev bnd mph}}ed
tbekp `huldnpke}, K yn} th }ee tbe }beev* lht leme}}npkj{mjh}e nt bnld* lhp th iet tbeg kl n }klije gh`* `ut th }ee
elhuib ha tbeg bepe nld tbepe th aeej en}{ tbnt lhtbkli
bnd ihle yphli3 tbk} yn} lh dkaakmujt gnttep* ahp tbepe
yepe lht n`hqe ekibt buldped ha tbeg3 nld* `ekli njj
`peedkli eye}* tbe{ yepe vpett{ ~uket,
Tbepe yepe n ihhd gnl{ }beev ybkmb K cley* n} tyhhp tbpee `jnmc eye}* nld n `jnmc jng` hp tyh* nld }eqepnj
htbep} ybkmb bnd }hge dk}tkliuk}bkli gnpc ybepe`{ K
mhujd tejj tbeg, K yhujd tp{ nld }ee njj tbe}e* nld ka tbe{
yepe njj tbepe* nld tbe gh` jhhced jnpie elhuib* K gkibt
pe}t n}}uped tbnt njj yn} yejj, Kt k} }upvpk}kli bhy }hhl tbe
e{e `emhge} nmmu}thged th gk}}kli tyelt{ }beev hut ha tyh hp tbpee buldped, K bnd n teje}mhve nld n dhi* nld
yhujd tnce `pend nld gent nld th`nmmh yktb ge, ]tnptkli
yktb enpj{ dnyl* kt yhujd `e lkibt `eahpe K mhujd
mhgvjete g{ phuld3 ahp tbe ghultnkl hqep ybkmb K bnd th
ih yn} qep{ bkib, Kl ykltep kt yn} mhqeped yktb }lhy* nld
tbe }beev leeded lh yntmbkli aphg n`hqe, Ka K yepe th }ee
}beev duli hp tpnmc} ihkli dhyl hl th tbe htbep }kde ha
tbe ghultnkl ybepe tbepe yn} n qnjje{ yktb n }tpeng—n
gepe muj de }nm+* K yn} th ahjjhy tbeg* nld jhhc hut ahp
}beev3 `ut K leqep }ny nl{* tbe }beev njyn{} de}meldkli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 19/378
Epeybhl
>; ha =9;
hl th tbekp hyl }kde* vnptj{ aphg bn`kt* nld vnptj{ `emnu}e
tbepe yn} n`uldnlme ha ihhd }yeet aeed* ybkmb bnd `eel`uplt kl tbe enpj{ }vpkli* ou}t `eahpe K mnge* nld yn} lhy
dejkmkhu}j{ ipeel nld pkmb* ybkje tbnt hl tbe htbep }kde bnd
leqep `eel `uplt* nld yn} pnlc nld mhnp}e,
Kt yn} n ghlhthlhu} jkae* `ut kt yn} qep{ benjtb{ nld
hle dhe} lht gumb gkld nl{tbkli ybel hle k} yejj, Tbe
mhultp{ yn} tbe ipnlde}t tbnt mnl `e kgnikled, Bhy hatelbnqe K }nt hl tbe ghultnkl }kde nld yntmbed tbe ynqkli
dhyl}* yktb tbe tyh ybkte }vemc} ha but} kl tbe dk}tnlme*
nld tbe jkttje }~unpe ha inpdel `ebkld tbeg3 tbe vnddhmc
yktb n vntmb ha `pkibt ipeel hnt} n`hqe tbe but}* nld tbe
{npd} nld yhhj'}bed} dhyl hl tbe ajnt `ejhy3 njj }eel n}
tbphuib tbe yphli eld ha n teje}mhve* }h mjenp nld`pkjjknlt yn} tbe nkp* hp n} uvhl n mhjh}}nj ghdej hp gnv
}vpend hut `elentb ge, @e{hld tbe dhyl} yn} n vjnkl*
ihkli dhyl th n pkqep ha ipent }kze* hl tbe anptbep }kde ha
ybkmb tbepe yepe htbep bkib ghultnkl}* yktb tbe ykltep‛}
}lhy }tkjj lht ~ukte gejted3 uv tbe pkqep* ybkmb pnl
ykldkli kl gnl{ }tpeng} hqep n `ed }hge tyh gkje}
`phnd* K jhhced uvhl tbe }emhld ipent mbnkl* nld mhujd
}ee n lnpphy ihpie ybepe tbe pkqep petkped nld yn} jh}t, K
cley tbnt tbepe yn} n pnlie }tkjj anptbep `nmc3 `ut ermevt
aphg hle vjnme lenp tbe qep{ thv ha g{ hyl ghultnkl* lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 20/378
Epeybhl
06 ha =9;
vnpt ha kt yn} qk}k`je? aphg tbk} vhklt* bhyeqep* K }ny*
ybeleqep tbepe yepe lh mjhud}* n }klije }lhy'mjnd venc*gnl{ gkje} nyn{* nld K }bhujd tbklc n`hut n} bkib n} nl{
ghultnkl kl tbe yhpjd, Leqep }bnjj K ahpiet tbe uttep
jhlejkle}} ha tbe vph}vemt— hlj{ tbe jkttje anp'nyn{
bhge}tend ikqkli }kil ha bugnl bnldkyhpc3tbe qn}tle}} ha
ghultnkl nld vjnkl* ha pkqep nld }c{3 tbe gnpqejjhu}
ntgh}vbepkm eaaemt}—}hgetkge} `jnmc ghultnkl} ninkl}t nybkte }c{* nld tbel ninkl* natep mhjd yentbep* ybkte
ghultnkl} ninkl}t n `jnmc }c{—}hgetkge} }eel tbphuib
`penc} nld }ykpj} ha mjhud—nld }hgetkge}* ybkmb yn}
`e}t ha njj* K yelt uv g{ ghultnkl kl n ahi* nld tbel iht
n`hqe tbe gk}t3 ihkli bkibep nld bkibep* K yhujd jhhc
dhyl uvhl n }en ha ybktele}}* tbphuib ybkmb yhujd `etbpu}t kllugepn`je ghultnkl thv} tbnt jhhced jkce k}jnld},
K ng tbepe lhy* n} K ypkte3 K anlm{ tbnt K mnl }ee tbe
dhyl}* tbe but}* tbe vjnkl* nld tbe pkqep'`ed—tbnt thppelt
vntbyn{ ha de}hjntkhl* yktb kt} dk}tnlt phnp ha yntep}, Hb*
yhldepauj. yhldepauj. }h jhlej{ nld }h }hjegl* yktb tbe
}nd ipe{ mjhud} n`hqe* nld lh }huld }nqe n jh}t jng`
`jentkli uvhl tbe ghultnkl }kde* n} tbhuib kt} jkttje benpt
yepe `penckli, Tbel tbepe mhge} }hge jenl nld yktbeped
hjd eye* yktb deev ipuaa qhkme nld uljhqej{ n}vemt*
tphttkli `nmc aphg tbe }edumtkqe vn}tupe3 lhy }be
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 21/378
Epeybhl
0> ha =9;
erngkle} tbk} iujj{* nld lhy tbnt* nld lhy }be }tnld}
jk}telkli yktb uvjkated bend* tbnt }be gn{ benp tbe dk}tnltynkjkli nld h`e{ kt, Nbn. tbe{ }ee* nld pu}b thynpd} enmb
htbep, Njn}. tbe{ npe `htb gk}tncel3 tbe eye k} lht tbe
jng`‛} eye* tbe{ npe lektbep ckl lhp ckld th hle nlhtbep*
nld vnpt kl mhjdle}}, Enmb gu}t mp{ jhudep* nld ynldep
anptbep {et3 gn{ jumc `e yktb tbeg `htb tbnt tbe{ gn{
akld tbekp hyl nt lkibtanjj, @ut tbk} k} gepe dpengkli* nldK gu}t vphmeed,
K mhujd lht bejv }vemujntkli uvhl ybnt gkibt jke
anptbep uv tbe pkqep nld `ebkld tbe }emhld pnlie, K bnd lh
ghle{* `ut ka K mhujd hlj{ akld yhpcn`je mhultp{* K gkibt
}thmc kt yktb `hpphyed mnvktnj* nld mhl}kdep g{}eja n gnde
gnl, Tpue* tbe pnlie jhhced }h qn}t* tbnt tbepe }eegedjkttje mbnlme ha iettkli n }uaakmkelt phnd tbphuib kt hp hqep
kt3 `ut lh hle bnd {et ervjhped kt* nld kt k} yhldepauj bhy
hle akld} tbnt hle mnl gnce n vntb klth njj }hpt} ha vjnme}
nld eqel iet n phnd ahp vnmc'bhp}e}+* ybkmb aphg n
dk}tnlme nvvenp klnmme}}k`je3 tbe pkqep yn} }h ipent tbnt kt
gu}t dpnkl nl kllep tpnmt—nt jen}t K tbhuibt }h3 nld
tbhuib eqep{ hle }nkd kt yhujd `e gndle}} th nttegvt
tnckli }beev anptbep kljnld* K cley tbnt hlj{ tbpee {enp}
nih tbe }nge mp{ bnd `eel pnk}ed ninkl}t tbe mhultp{
ybkmb g{ gn}tep‛} ajhmc yn} lhy hqeppullkli, K mhujd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 22/378
Epeybhl
00 ha =9;
lht ceev tbe}e tbhuibt} hut ha g{ bend n} K yhujd pe}t
g{}eja uvhl tbe ghultnkl }kde3 tbe{ bnulted ge n} K yeltg{ dnkj{ phuld}* nld ipey uvhl ge aphg bhup th bhup*
tkjj K pe}hjqed tbnt natep }benpkli K yhujd pegnkl kl dhu`t
lh jhliep* `ut }nddje g{ bhp}e* tnce n} gumb vphqk}khl
yktb ge n} K mhujd* nld ih nld }ee ahp g{}eja,
@ut hqep nld n`hqe tbe}e tbhuibt} mnge tbnt ha tbe
ipent pnlie kt}eja, Ybnt yn} `e{hld kt8 Nb. ybh mhujd }n{8Tbepe yn} lh hle kl tbe ybhje yhpjd ybh bnd tbe
}gnjje}t kden* }nqe tbh}e ybh yepe tbeg}ejqe} hl tbe
htbep }kde ha kt—ka* kldeed* tbepe yn} nl{ hle nt njj, Mhujd
K bhve th mph}} kt8 Tbk} yhujd `e tbe bkibe}t tpkugvb tbnt
K mhujd yk}b ahp3 `ut kt yn} thh gumb th tbklc ha {et, K
yhujd tp{ tbe lenpep pnlie* nld }ee bhy anp K mhujd ih,Eqel ka K dkd lht akld mhultp{* gkibt K lht akld ihjd* hp
dknghld}* hp mhvvep* hp }kjqep8 K yhujd }hgetkge} jke ajnt
dhyl th dpklc hut ha n }tpeng* nld mhujd }ee jkttje {ejjhy
}vemc} nghli tbe }nld3 yepe tbe}e ihjd8 Vehvje }nkd lh3
`ut tbel vehvje njyn{} }nkd tbepe yn} lh ihjd ultkj kt yn}
ahuld th `e n`uldnlt? tbepe yn} vjelt{ ha }jnte nld
ipnlkte* ybkmb K bnd njyn{} uldep}thhd th nmmhgvnl{
ihjd3 nld eqel tbhuib kt yn} lht ahuld kl vn{kli
~unltktke} bepe* kt gkibt `e n`uldnlt kl tbe gnkl pnlie},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 23/378
Epeybhl
0= ha =9;
Tbe}e tbhuibt} akjjed g{ bend* nld K mhujd lht `nlk}b
tbeg,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 24/378
Epeybhl
04 ha =9;
MBNVTEP KK? KL TBE YHHJ']BED
Nt jn}t }benpkli mnge3 nld yktb tbe }benpep} tbepe yn}
nl hjd lntkqe* ybhg tbe{ bnd lkmclnged Mbhy`hc—
tbhuib* K `ejkeqe* bk} penj lnge yn} Cnbn`ucn, Be yn} n
}hpt ha mbkea ha tbe lntkqe}* mhujd }venc n jkttje Elijk}b* nld
yn} n ipent anqhupkte yktb tbe gk}}khlnpke}, Be dkd lht dh
nl{ peiujnp yhpc yktb tbe }benpep}* `ut vpetelded th bejv
kl tbe {npd}* bk} penj nkg `ekli th iet tbe iphi* ybkmb k}
njyn{} ghpe apeej{ mkpmujnted nt }benpkli'tkge? be dkd lht
iet gumb* ahp be yn} nvt th `e dnliephu} ybel dpulc3
nld qep{ jkttje yhujd gnce bkg }h? }tkjj be dkd iet kt
hmmn}khlnjj{* nld ka hle ynlted th iet nl{tbkli hut ha
bkg* kt yn} tbe `e}t `pk`e th haaep bkg, K pe}hjqed th
~ue}tkhl bkg* nld iet n} gumb klahpgntkhl aphg bkg n} K
mhujd, K dkd }h, N} jhli n} K cevt th ~ue}tkhl} n`hut tbe
lenpep pnlie}* be yn} en}{ th iet hl yktb—be bnd leqep
`eel tbepe* `ut tbepe yepe tpndktkhl} nghli bk} tpk`e th
tbe eaaemt tbnt tbepe yn} lh }beev'mhultp{* lhtbkli* kl
anmt* `ut }tulted tkg`ep nld n aey pkqep'`ed ajnt}, Kt yn}
qep{ dkaakmujt th penmb3 }tkjj tbepe yepe vn}}e}? hle ha tbeg
uv hup hyl pkqep* tbhuib lht dkpemtj{ njhli tbe pkqep'`ed*
tbe ihpie ha ybkmb yn} lht vpnmtkmn`je3 be bnd leqep }eel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 25/378
Epeybhl
05 ha =9;
nl{ hle ybh bnd `eel tbepe? yn} tbepe th lht elhuib hl
tbk} }kde8 @ut ybel K mnge th tbe gnkl pnlie* bk} gnllep mbnlied nt hlme, Be `emnge ulen}{* nld `einl th
vpeqnpkmnte nld }buaaje, Kl n qep{ aey gklute} K mhujd }ee
tbnt ha tbk} thh tbepe erk}ted tpndktkhl} kl bk} tpk`e3 `ut lh
eaahpt} hp mhnrkli mhujd iet n yhpd aphg bkg n`hut tbeg,
Nt jn}t K bklted n`hut iphi* nld vpe}eltj{ be aekiled
mhl}elt? K inqe kt bkg3 `ut n} }hhl n} be bnd dpulc kt be`einl }bnggkli klthrkmntkhl* nld tbel yelt th }jeev* hp
vpetelded th dh }h* jettkli ge ckmc bkg vpett{ bnpd nld
leqep `udikli,
K yn} nlip{* ahp K bnd th ih yktbhut g{ hyl iphi nld
bnd iht lhtbkli hut ha bkg3 }h tbe lert dn{ K detepgkled
tbnt be }bhujd tejj ge `eahpe K inqe bkg nl{* hp iet lhlent njj,
Nmmhpdklij{* ybel lkibt mnge nld tbe }benpep} bnd
clhmced haa yhpc nld bnd tbekp }uvvep* K iht g{ }bnpe ha
pug kl n tkl vnllkckl nld gnde n }kil th Mbhy`hc th
ahjjhy ge th tbe yhhj'}bed* ybkmb be ykjjklij{ dkd*
}jkvvkli hut natep ge* nld lh hle tnckli nl{ lhtkme ha
ektbep ha u}, Ybel ye iht dhyl th tbe yhhj'}bed ye jkt n
tnjjhy mnldje* nld bnqkli }tumc kt kl nl hjd `httje ye }nt
dhyl uvhl tbe yhhj `nje} nld `einl th }ghce, N yhhj'
}bed k} n phhg{ vjnme* `ukjt }hgeybnt hl tbe }nge vjnl n}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 26/378
Epeybhl
01 ha =9;
n mntbedpnj* yktb nk}je} hl ektbep }kde aujj ha vel} ahp tbe
}beev* n ipent lnqe* nt tbe uvvep eld ha ybkmb tbe }benpep}yhpc* nld n auptbep }vnme ahp yhhj }hptep} nld vnmcep}, Kt
njyn{} peape}bed ge yktb n }eg`jnlme ha nltk~ukt{
vpemkhu} kl n ley mhultp{+* tbhuib K qep{ yejj cley tbnt
tbe hjde}t yhhj'}bed kl tbe }ettjegelt yn} lht ghpe tbnl
}eqel {enp} hjd* ybkje tbk} yn} hlj{ tyh, Mbhy`hc
vpetelded th ervemt bk} iphi nt hlme* tbhuib ye `htb ha u} cley qep{ yejj ybnt tbe htbep yn} natep* nld tbnt ye
yepe enmb vjn{kli ninkl}t tbe htbep* tbe hle ahp iphi tbe
htbep ahp klahpgntkhl,
Ye bnd n bnpd akibt? ahp ghpe tbnl tyh bhup} be bnd
tpked th vut ge haa yktb jke} `ut bnd mnppked lh mhlqkmtkhl3
dupkli tbe ybhje tkge ye bnd `eel ghpnjj{ ype}tjkliyktb hle nlhtbep nld bnd lektbep ha u} nvvnpeltj{ inkled
tbe jen}t ndqnltnie3 nt jelitb* bhyeqep* K bnd `emhge }upe
tbnt be yhujd ikqe kl ujtkgntej{* nld tbnt yktb n jkttje
auptbep vntkelme K }bhujd iet bk} }thp{ hut ha bkg, N} uvhl
n mhjd dn{ kl ykltep* ybel hle bn} mbupled n} K bnd hatel
bnd th dh+* nld mbupled kl qnkl* nld tbe `uttep gnce} lh
}kil ha mhgkli* nt jn}t hle tejj} `{ tbe }huld tbnt tbe
mpeng bn} ihle th }jeev* nld tbel uvhl n }uddel tbe
`uttep mhge}* }h K bnd mbupled nt Mbhy`hc ultkj K
vepmekqed tbnt be bnd nppkqed* n} kt yepe* nt tbe }jeev{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 27/378
Epeybhl
09 ha =9;
}tnie* nld tbnt yktb n mhltklunlme ha }tend{ ~uket vpe}}upe
tbe dn{ yn} gkle, Hl n }uddel* yktbhut n yhpd ha ynplkli* be phjjed tyh `nje} ha yhhj bk} }tpelitb yn}
qep{ ipent+ klth tbe gkddje ha tbe ajhhp* nld hl tbe thv ha
tbe}e be vjnmed nlhtbep mph}}yk}e3 be }lntmbed uv nl
egvt{ yhhj'vnmc* tbpey kt jkce n gnltje hqep bk}
}bhujdep}* ougved uvhl tbe uvvepgh}t `nje* nld }nt uvhl
kt, Kl n ghgelt bk} ybhje ahpg yn} mbnlied, Bk} bkib}bhujdep} dphvved3 be }et bk} aeet mjh}e thietbep* beej th
beej nld the th the3 be jnkd bk} npg} nld bnld} mjh}e
njhli}kde ha bk} `hd{* tbe vnjg} ahjjhykli bk} tbkib}3 be
bejd bk} bend bkib `ut ~ukte }tpnkibt* nld bk} e{e} }tnped
pkibt kl aphlt ha bkg3 `ut be aphyled bhppk`j{* nld
n}}uged nl ervpe}}khl ha anme tbnt yn} vh}ktkqej{ akeldk}b,Nt tbe `e}t ha tkge} Mbhy`hc yn} qep{ uij{* `ut be lhy
ermeeded njj mhlmekqn`je jkgkt} ha tbe bkdehu}, Bk} ghutb
ertelded njgh}t aphg enp th enp* ipkllkli bhppk`j{ nld
}bhykli njj bk} teetb3 bk} e{e} ijnped* tbhuib tbe{
pegnkled ~ukte akred* nld bk} ahpebend yn} mhltpnmted
yktb n gh}t gnjeqhjelt }mhyj,
K ng napnkd g{ de}mpkvtkhl ykjj bnqe mhlqe{ed hlj{ tbe
pkdkmujhu} }kde ha bk} nvvenpnlme3 `ut tbe pkdkmujhu} nld
tbe }u`jkge npe lenp* nld tbe iphte}~ue akeldk}ble}} ha
Mbhy`hc‛} anme nvvphnmbed tbk} jn}t* ka kt dkd lht penmb kt,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 28/378
Epeybhl
02 ha =9;
K tpked th `e ngu}ed* `ut K aejt n }hpt ha mpeevkli nt tbe
phht} ha g{ bnkp nld hqep g{ ybhje `hd{* n} K jhhced nldyhldeped ybnt be mhujd vh}}k`j{ `e klteldkli th }kilka{,
Be mhltklued tbu} ahp n`hut n gklute* }kttkli `hjt uvpkibt*
n} }tkaa n} n }thle* nld gnckli tbk} aenpauj anme, Tbel tbepe
mnge aphg bk} jkv} n jhy ghnlkli jkce tbe ykld* pk}kli nld
anjjkli `{ klaklktej{ }gnjj ipndntkhl} tkjj kt `emnge njgh}t n
}bpkec* aphg ybkmb kt de}melded nld dked nyn{3 natep tbnt*be ougved dhyl aphg tbe `nje nld bejd uv tbe ertelded
akliep} ha `htb bk} bnld}* n} hle ybh }bhujd }n{ ‒Tel*‛
tbhuib K dkd lht tbel uldep}tnld bkg,
Ahp g{}eja K yn} hvel'ghutbed yktb n}thlk}bgelt,
Mbhy`hc phjjed tbe `nje} pnvkdj{ klth tbekp vjnme* nld
}thhd `eahpe ge }buddepkli n} kl ipent aenp3 bhpphp yn}ypkttel uvhl bk} anme—tbk} tkge ~ukte klqhjultnpkj{—n}
tbhuib tbe lntupnj vnlkm ha hle ybh bnd mhggktted nl
nyauj mpkge ninkl}t ulclhyl nld }uvepbugnl nielmke},
Be lhdded bk} bend nld ik``eped* nld vhklted peventedj{
th tbe ghultnkl}, Be yhujd lht thumb tbe iphi* `ut* natep
n aey }emhld} be gnde n pul tbphuib tbe yhhj'}bed dhhp
klth tbe ghhljkibt3 lhp dkd be penvvenp tkjj lert dn{ nt
dkllep'tkge* ybel be tupled uv* jhhckli qep{ }beevk}b
nld n`oemt kl bk} mkqkjkt{ thynpd} g{}eja,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 29/378
Epeybhl
0; ha =9;
Ha bk} genlkli K bnd lh mhlmevtkhl, Bhy mhujd K8 Njj
K mhujd aeej }upe ha yn}* tbnt be bnd n genlkli ybkmb yn}tpue nld nyauj th bkg}eja, Kt yn} elhuib ahp ge tbnt K
`ejkeqed bkg th bnqe ikqel ge tbe `e}t be bnd nld njj be
bnd, Tbk} ckldjed g{ kgniklntkhl ghpe tbnl ka be bnd thjd
ge kltejjkik`je }thpke} `{ tbe bhup thietbep, K cley lht
ybnt tbe ipent }lhy{ pnlie} gkibt mhlmenj* `ut K mhujd lh
jhliep dhu`t tbnt kt yhujd `e }hgetbkli yejj yhptbdk}mhqepkli,
K cevt njhha aphg Mbhy`hc ahp tbe lert aey dn{}* nld
}bhyed lh de}kpe th ~ue}tkhl bkg auptbep3 ybel K }vhce
th bkg K mnjjed bkg Cnbn`ucn* ybkmb ipntkaked bkg ipentj{?
be }eeged th bnqe `emhge napnkd ha ge* nld nmted n} hle
ybh yn} kl g{ vhyep, Bnqkli tbepeahpe gnde uv g{gkld tbnt K yhujd `eikl ervjhpkli n} }hhl n} }benpkli yn}
hqep* K tbhuibt kt yhujd `e n ihhd tbkli th tnce
Mbhy`hc yktb ge3 }h K thjd bkg tbnt K genlt ihkli th
tbe lenpep pnlie} ahp n aey dn{}‛ vph}vemtkli* nld tbnt be
yn} th mhge thh, K gnde bkg vphgk}e} ha lkibtj{ iphi*
nld bejd hut tbe mbnlme} ha akldkli ihjd, K }nkd lhtbkli
n`hut tbe gnkl pnlie* ahp K cley kt yhujd apkibtel bkg, K
yhujd iet bkg n} anp uv hup hyl pkqep n} K mhujd* nld
tpnme kt ka vh}}k`je th kt} }hupme, K yhujd tbel ektbep ih hl
`{ g{}eja* ka K aejt g{ mhupnie e~unj th tbe nttegvt* hp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 30/378
Epeybhl
=6 ha =9;
petupl yktb Mbhy`hc, ]h* n} }hhl n} eqep }benpkli yn}
hqep nld tbe yhhj }elt haa* K n}ced jenqe ha n`}elme* nldh`tnkled kt, Nj}h* K `huibt nl hjd vnmc'bhp}e nld vnmc'
}nddje* }h tbnt K gkibt tnce vjelt{ ha vphqk}khl}* nld
`jnlcet}* nld n }gnjj telt, K yn} th pkde nld akld ahpd} hqep
tbe pkqep3 Mbhy`hc yn} th ahjjhy nld jend tbe vnmc'
bhp}e* ybkmb yhujd nj}h mnpp{ bkg hqep tbe ahpd}, G{
gn}tep jet ge bnqe ten nld }uinp* }bkv‛} `k}mukt}* th`nmmh*nld }njt gutthl* yktb tyh hp tbpee `httje} ha ihhd `pnld{3
ahp* n} tbe yhhj yn} lhy }elt dhyl* n`uldnlme ha
vphqk}khl} yhujd mhge uv yktb tbe egvt{ dpn{},
Eqep{tbkli `ekli lhy pend{* njj tbe bnld} hl tbe
}tntkhl tupled hut th }ee u} haa* nld ye }tnpted hl hup
ohuple{* lht qep{ jhli natep tbe }uggep }hj}tkme ha >296,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 31/378
Epeybhl
=> ha =9;
MBNVTEP KKK? UV TBE PKQEP
Tbe akp}t dn{ ye bnd nl en}{ tkge* ahjjhykli uv tbe
ipent ajnt} `{ tbe pkqep }kde* ybkmb bnd njpend{ `eel tykme
`upled* }h tbnt tbepe yn} lh del}e uldepiphytb th mbemc
u}* tbhuib tbe iphuld yn} hatel phuib* nld ye bnd th ih
n ihhd denj uvhl tbe pkqep`ed, Thynpd} lkibtanjj ye bnd
gnde n gnttep ha }hge akqe'nld'tyelt{ gkje}* nld mngved
nt tbe vhklt ybepe tbe pkqep elteped uvhl tbe ihpie,
Tbe yentbep yn} dejkibtaujj{ ynpg* mhl}kdepkli tbnt
tbe qnjje{ kl ybkmb ye yepe elmngved gu}t bnqe `eel nt
jen}t tyh tbhu}nld aeet n`hqe tbe jeqej ha tbe }en, Tbe
pkqep'`ed yn} bepe n`hut n gkje nld n bnja `phnd nld
eltkpej{ mhqeped yktb }bklije hqep ybkmb tbe pkqep pnl kl
gnl{ ykldkli mbnllej}* jhhckli* ybel }eel aphg n`hqe*
jkce n tnlijed }cekl ha pk``hl* nld ijk}telkli kl tbe }ul,
Ye cley tbnt kt yn} jkn`je th qep{ }uddel nld benq{
ape}bet}3 `ut eqel bnd ye lht clhyl kt* ye mhujd bnqe
}eel kt `{ tbe }lni} ha tpee}* ybkmb gu}t bnqe `eel mnppked
jhli dk}tnlme}* nld `{ tbe gn}} ha qeietn`je nld gklepnj
de`pk} ybkmb yn} `nlced ninkl}t tbekp jhyep }kde* }bhykli
tbnt nt tkge} tbe ybhje pkqep'`ed gu}t `e mhqeped yktb n
phnpkli thppelt gnl{ aeet kl devtb nld ha ulihqepln`je
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 32/378
Epeybhl
=0 ha =9;
aup{, Nt vpe}elt tbe pkqep yn} jhy* tbepe `ekli `ut akqe hp
}kr }tpeng}* thh deev nld pnvkd ahp eqel n }tphli gnl thahpd hl ahht* `ut th `e mph}}ed }naej{ hl bhp}e`nmc, Hl
ektbep }kde ha kt tbepe yepe }tkjj n aey nmpe} ha ajnt* ybkmb
ipey ykdep nld ykdep dhyl tbe pkqep* tkjj tbe{ `emnge tbe
jnpie vjnkl} hl ybkmb ye jhhced aphg g{ gn}tep‛} but,
@ebkld u} ph}e tbe jhye}t }vup} ha tbe }emhld pnlie*
jendkli n`puvtj{ th tbe pnlie kt}eja3 nld nt n dk}tnlme ha bnja n gkje `einl tbe ihpie* ybepe tbe pkqep lnpphyed nld
`emnge `hk}tephu} nld teppk`je, Tbe `enut{ ha tbe }mele
mnllht `e mhlqe{ed kl jnliunie, Tbe hle }kde ha tbe
qnjje{ yn} `jue yktb eqelkli }bndhy* tbphuib ybkmb
jhhged ahpe}t nld vpemkvkme* bkjj}kde nld ghultnkl thv3
nld tbe htbep yn} }tkjj `pkjjknlt yktb tbe }ul}et ihjd, Tbeykde nld yn}teauj pkqep yktb kt} men}eje}} pu}bkli—tbe
`enutkauj yntep'`kpd} thh* ybkmb n`hulded uvhl tbe k}jet}
nld yepe }h tnge tbnt ye mhujd mhge mjh}e uv th tbeg—
tbe kleaan`je vupkt{ ha tbe nkp—tbe }hjegl venmeaujle}} ha
tbe ultphddel peikhl—mhujd tbepe `e n ghpe dejkibtauj
nld erbkjnpntkli mhg`klntkhl8
Ye }et n`hut gnckli hup mngv* mjh}e th }hge jnpie
`u}b ybkmb mnge dhyl aphg tbe ghultnkl} hl th tbe ajnt*
nld tetbeped hut hup bhp}e} uvhl iphuld n} apee n} ye
mhujd akld kt aphg nl{tbkli phuld ybkmb tbe{ gkibt ykld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 33/378
Epeybhl
== ha =9;
tbe phve nld iet tbeg}ejqe} tked uv, Ye dnped lht jet
tbeg pul jhh}e* je}t tbe{ gkibt }tpn{ dhyl tbe pkqep bhgeninkl, Ye tbel intbeped yhhd nld jkt tbe akpe, Ye akjjed n
tkl vnllkckl yktb yntep nld }et kt ninkl}t tbe bht n}be} th
`hkj, Ybel tbe yntep `hkjed ye tbpey kl tyh hp tbpee
jnpie vklmbe} ha ten nld jet tbeg `pey,
Ye bnd mnuibt bnja n dhzel {huli dumc} kl tbe mhup}e
ha tbe dn{—nl en}{ gnttep* ahp tbe hjd `kpd} gnde }umb nau}} kl nttegvtkli th demh{ u} nyn{ aphg tbeg—
vpeteldkli th `e `ndj{ bupt n} tbe{ }n{ tbe vjhqep dhe}—
tbnt ye mhujd njyn{} akld tbeg `{ ihkli n`hut kl tbe
hvvh}kte dkpemtkhl th tbe hjd `kpd tkjj ye benpd tbe {huli
hle} mp{kli? tbel ye pnl tbeg dhyl* ahp tbe{ mhujd lht
aj{ tbhuib tbe{ yepe lenpj{ aujj iphyl, Mbhy`hc vjumcedtbeg n jkttje nld }klied tbeg n ihhd denj, Tbel ye mut
tbeg uv nld `hkjed tbeg kl nlhtbep vnllkckl* nld tbk}
mhgvjeted hup vpevnpntkhl},
Ybel ye bnd dhle }uvvep kt yn} ~ukte dnpc, Tbe
}kjelme nld ape}ble}} ha tbe lkibt* tbe hmmn}khlnj }bnpv mp{
ha tbe yhhd'bel* tbe pudd{ ijhy ha tbe akpe* tbe }u`dued
pu}bkli ha tbe pkqep* tbe }hg`pe ahpe}t* nld tbe kggedknte
ahpeiphuld ha hup }nddje} vnmc} nld `jnlcet}* gnde n
vkmtupe yhptb{ ha n ]njqnthp Ph}n hp n Lkmhjn} Vhu}}kl, K
mnjj kt th gkld nld dejkibt kl kt lhy* `ut K dkd lht lhtkme kt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 34/378
Epeybhl
=4 ha =9;
nt tbe tkge, Ye lert th leqep clhy ybel ye npe yejj haa?
`ut tbk} mut} tyh yn{}*—ahp ka ye dkd* ye }bhujd vepbnv}clhy `ettep ybel ye npe kjj haa nj}h3 nld K bnqe
}hgetkge} tbhuibt tbnt tbepe npe n} gnl{ kilhpnlt ha tbe
hle n} ha tbe htbep, Be ybh yphte* ‒H ahptulnth} lkgkug
}un }k `hln lhpklt nipkmhjn}*‛ gkibt bnqe ypkttel ~ukte n}
tpuj{* ‒H klahptulnth} lkgkug }un }k gnjn lhpklt"3 nld
tbepe npe aey ha u} ybh npe lht vphtemted aphg tbeceele}t vnkl `{ hup kln`kjkt{ th }ee ybnt kt k} tbnt ye bnqe
dhle* ybnt ye npe }uaaepkli* nld ybnt ye tpuj{ npe, Jet u}
`e ipnteauj th tbe gkpphp ahp peqenjkli th u} hup nvvenpnlme
hlj{,
Ye ahuld n} }hat n vkeme ha iphuld n} ye mhujd—
tbhuib kt yn} njj }thl{—nld bnqkli mhjjemted ipn}} nld }hdk}vh}ed ha hup}ejqe} tbnt ye bnd n jkttje bhjjhy ahp hup
bkv'`hle}* ye }tpnvved hup `jnlcet} nphuld u} nld yelt
th }jeev, Ynckli kl tbe lkibt K }ny tbe }tnp} hqepbend nld
tbe ghhljkibt `pkibt uvhl tbe ghultnkl}, Tbe pkqep yn}
eqep pu}bkli3 K benpd hle ha hup bhp}e} lekib th kt}
mhgvnlkhl* nld yn} n}}uped tbnt tbe{ yepe }tkjj nt bnld3 K
bnd lh mnpe ha gkld hp `hd{* }nqe tbnt K bnd dhu`tje}}
gnl{ dkaakmujtke} th hqepmhge3 tbepe mnge uvhl ge n
dejkmkhu} }el}e ha venme* n aujle}} ha mhlteltgelt ybkmb K
dh lht `ejkeqe mnl `e aejt `{ nl{ `ut tbh}e ybh bnqe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 35/378
Epeybhl
=5 ha =9;
}velt dn{} mhl}emutkqej{ hl bhp}e`nmc* hp nt nl{ pnte kl
tbe hvel nkp,Lert ghplkli ye ahuld hup jn}t lkibt‛} ten'jenqe}
aphzel nt tbe `htthg ha tbe vnllkckl}* tbhuib kt yn} lht
lenpj{ tbe `eikllkli ha nutugl3 ye `pencan}ted n} ye bnd
}uvved* nld yepe hl hup yn{ `{ }kr h‛mjhmc, Kl bnja nl
bhup ye bnd elteped tbe ihpie* nld tuplkli phuld n
mhplep ye `nde anpeyejj th tbe jn}t }kibt ha g{ gn}tep‛}mhultp{,
Tbe ihpie yn} lnpphy nld vpemkvkthu}3 tbe pkqep yn}
lhy hlj{ n aey {npd} ykde* nld phnped nld tbuldeped
ninkl}t phmc} ha gnl{ thl} kl yekibt3 tbe }huld yn}
denaelkli* ahp tbepe yn} n ipent qhjuge ha yntep, Ye yepe
tyh bhup} kl gnckli je}} tbnl n gkje* nld tbnt yktbdnliep* }hgetkge} kl tbe pkqep nld }hgetkge} hl tbe phmc,
Tbepe yn} tbnt dngv `jnmc }gejj ha phmc} mhqeped yktb
}jkg{ qeietntkhl* n} lenp }hge buie yntepanjj ybepe }vpn{
k} eqep pk}kli, Tbe nkp yn} mjngg{ nld mhjd, K mnllht
mhlmekqe bhy hup bhp}e} gnlnied th ceev tbekp ahhtkli*
e}vemknjj{ tbe hle yktb tbe vnmc* nld K dpended tbe bnqkli
th petupl njgh}t n} gumb n} ihkli ahpynpd, K }uvvh}e tbk}
jn}ted tbpee gkje}* `ut kt yn} yejj gkddn{ ybel tbe ihpie
iht n jkttje ykdep* nld n }gnjj }tpeng mnge klth kt aphg n
tpk`utnp{ qnjje{, Anptbep vphipe}} uv tbe gnkl pkqep yn}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 36/378
Epeybhl
=1 ha =9;
kgvh}}k`je* ahp tbe mjkaa} de}melded jkce ynjj}3 }h ye yelt
uv tbe }kde }tpeng* Mbhy`hc }eegkli th tbklc tbnt bepegu}t `e tbe vn}} ha ybkmb pevhpt} erk}ted nghli bk}
vehvje, Ye lhy klmupped je}} ha nmtunj dnliep `ut ghpe
antkiue* nld kt yn} hlj{ natep klaklkte tphu`je* hykli th tbe
phmc} nld tnlijed qeietntkhl* tbnt ye iht hup}ejqe} nld
hup bhp}e} uvhl tbe }nddje aphg ybkmb tbk} }gnjj }tpeng
de}melded3 `{ tbnt tkge mjhud} bnd de}melded uvhl u}*nld kt yn} pnklkli benqkj{, Ghpehqep* kt yn} }kr h‛mjhmc
nld ye yepe tkped hut* bnqkli gnde vepbnv} }kr gkje} kl
tyejqe bhup},
Hl tbe }nddje tbepe yn} }hge mhnp}e ipn}} ybkmb yn} kl
aujj }eed* nld tbepeahpe qep{ lhupk}bkli ahp tbe bhp}e}3 nj}h
n`uldnlme ha nlk}e nld }hy'tbk}tje* ha ybkmb tbe{ npeertpnqninltj{ ahld* }h ye tupled tbeg jhh}e nld vpevnped
th mngv, Eqep{tbkli yn} }hnckli yet nld ye yepe bnja'
vepk}bed yktb mhjd3 kldeed ye yepe qep{ ulmhgahptn`je,
Tbepe yn} `pu}byhhd n`hut* `ut ye mhujd iet lh akpe tkjj
ye bnd }bnqed haa tbe yet hut}kde ha }hge dend `pnlmbe}
nld akjjed hup vhmcet} yktb tbe dp{ kl}kde mbkv}, Bnqkli
dhle tbk} ye gnlnied th }tnpt n akpe* lhp dkd ye njjhy kt th
ih hut ybel ye bnd hlme }tnpted kt3 ye vktmbed tbe telt
nld `{ lkle h‛mjhmc yepe mhgvnpntkqej{ ynpg nld dp{,
Lert ghplkli kt yn} akle3 ye `phce mngv* nld natep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 37/378
Epeybhl
=9 ha =9;
ndqnlmkli n }bhpt dk}tnlme ye ahuld tbnt* `{ de}meldkli
hqep iphuld je}} dkaakmujt tbnl {e}tepdn{‛}* ye }bhujd mhgeninkl uvhl tbe pkqep'`ed* ybkmb bnd hveled hut n`hqe
tbe ihpie3 `ut kt yn} vjnkl nt n ijnlme tbnt tbepe yn} lh
nqnkjn`je }beev mhultp{* lhtbkli `ut n aey ajnt} mhqeped
yktb }mpu` hl ektbep }kde tbe pkqep* nld ghultnkl} ybkmb
yepe vepaemtj{ yhptbje}}, @ut ye mhujd }ee tbe gnkl
pnlie, Tbepe yn} lh gk}tnce n`hut tbk}, Tbe ijnmkep} yepetug`jkli dhyl tbe ghultnkl }kde} jkce mntnpnmt}* nld
}eeged nmtunjj{ th de}meld uvhl tbe pkqep'`ed3 tbepe
mhujd `e lh }epkhu} dkaakmujt{ kl penmbkli tbeg `{
ahjjhykli uv tbe pkqep* ybkmb yn} ykde nld hvel3 `ut kt
}eeged pntbep nl h`oemtje}} tbkli th dh* ahp tbe gnkl pnlie
jhhced bhveje}}* nld g{ mupkh}kt{ n`hut tbe lntupe ha tbemhultp{ n`hqe tbe ihpie yn} lhy ~ukte }ntk}aked3 tbepe yn}
lh ghle{ kl kt ybnteqep* ulje}} tbepe }bhujd `e gklepnj}*
ha ybkmb K }ny lh ghpe }kil} tbnl jhyep dhyl,
Bhyeqep* K pe}hjqed tbnt K yhujd ahjjhy tbe pkqep uv*
nld lht petupl ultkj K yn} mhgvejjed th dh }h, K yhujd ih
uv eqep{ `pnlmb n} anp n} K mhujd* nld yn}b yejj ahp ihjd,
Mbhy`hc jkced }eekli ge dh tbk}* `ut kt leqep mnge th
nl{tbkli* ahp ye dkd lht eqel akld tbe mhjhup, Bk} dk}jkce
ha tbe gnkl pnlie nvvenped th bnqe yhpl haa* nld be gnde
lh h`oemtkhl} th nvvphnmbkli kt, K tbklc be tbhuibt tbepe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 38/378
Epeybhl
=2 ha =9;
yn} lh dnliep ha g{ tp{kli th mph}} kt* nld be yn} lht
napnkd ha nl{tbkli hl tbk} }kde3 `e}kde}* ye gkibt akldihjd, @ut tbe anmt yn} tbnt be bnd gnde uv bk} gkld ybnt
th dh ka be }ny ge iettkli thh lenp kt,
Ye vn}}ed tbpee yeec} kl ervjhpkli* nld leqep dkd K
akld tkge ih ghpe ~ukmcj{, Tbe yentbep yn} akle* tbhuib
tbe lkibt} iht qep{ mhjd, Ye ahjjhyed eqep{ }tpeng `ut
hle* nld njyn{} ahuld kt jend u} th n ijnmkep ybkmb yn}vjnklj{ kgvn}}n`je* nt nl{ pnte yktbhut n jnpiep vnpt{ nld
phve}, Hle }tpeng pegnkled* ybkmb K }bhujd bnqe
ahjjhyed uv njpend{* bnd lht Mbhy`hc }nkd tbnt be bnd
pk}el enpj{ hle ghplkli ybkje K yn} {et n}jeev* nld natep
ihkli uv kt ahp tbpee hp ahup gkje}* bnd }eel tbnt kt yn}
kgvh}}k`je th ih anptbep, K bnd jhli nih dk}mhqeped tbnt beyn} n ipent jknp* }h K yn} `elt hl ihkli uv g{}eja? kl `pkea*
K dkd }h? }h anp aphg `ekli kgvh}}k`je* kt yn} ~ukte en}{
tpnqejjkli3 nld natep akqe hp }kr gkje} K }ny n }nddje nt tbe
eld ha kt* ybkmb* tbhuib mhqeped deev kl }lhy* yn} lht
ijnmkeped* nld ybkmb dkd qepkj{ nvvenp th `e vnpt ha tbe
gnkl pnlie kt}eja, Lh yhpd} mnl ervpe}} tbe kltel}kt{ ha
g{ dejkibt, G{ `jhhd yn} njj hl akpe yktb bhve nld
ejntkhl3 `ut hl jhhckli phuld ahp Mbhy`hc* ybh yn}
`ebkld ge* K }ny th g{ }upvpk}e nld nliep tbnt be bnd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 39/378
Epeybhl
=; ha =9;
tupled `nmc* nld yn} ihkli dhyl tbe qnjje{ n} bnpd n} be
mhujd, Be bnd jeat ge,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 40/378
Epeybhl
46 ha =9;
MBNVTEP KQ? TBE ]NDDJE
K mhhe{ed th bkg* `ut be yhujd lht benp, K pnl natep
bkg* `ut be bnd iht thh ihhd n }tnpt, Tbel K }nt dhyl hl
n }thle nld tbhuibt tbe gnttep mnpeaujj{ hqep, Kt yn} vjnkl
tbnt Mbhy`hc bnd de}kiledj{ nttegvted th ceev ge aphg
ihkli uv tbk} qnjje{* {et be bnd }bhyl lh ulykjjklile}} th
ahjjhy ge nl{ybepe ej}e, Ybnt mhujd tbk} genl* ulje}}
tbnt K yn} lhy uvhl tbe phute `{ ybkmb njhle tbe
g{}tepke} ha tbe ipent pnlie} mhujd `e peqenjed8 Ybnt tbel
}bhujd K dh8 Ih `nmc nt tbe qep{ ghgelt ybel kt bnd
`emhge vjnkl tbnt K yn} hl tbe pkibt }melt8 Bnpdj{3 {et th
vphmeed njhle yhujd `e `htb dkaakmujt nld dnliephu}, Kt
yhujd `e `nd elhuib th petupl th g{ gn}tep‛} pul* nld
vn}} tbphuib tbe phmc{ ihpie}* yktb lh mbnlme ha bejv
aphg nlhtbep }bhujd K iet klth n dkaakmujt{3 `ut th ndqnlme
ahp nl{ mhl}kdepn`je dk}tnlme yktbhut n mhgvnlkhl yhujd
`e lert dhhp th gndle}}, Nmmkdelt} ybkmb npe }jkibt ybel
tbepe k} nlhtbep nt bnld n} tbe }vpnklkli ha nl nlcje* hp
tbe anjjkli klth }hge vjnme ybelme e}mnve yhujd `e en}{
`{ genl} ha nl hut}tpetmbed bnld nld n `kt ha phve+ gn{
`e antnj th hle ybh k} njhle, Tbe ghpe K vhldeped tbe je}}
K jkced kt3 nld {et* tbe je}} mhujd K gnce uv g{ gkld th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 41/378
Epeybhl
4> ha =9;
petupl ybel K jhhced nt tbe }nddje nt tbe bend ha tbe
qnjje{* nld lhted tbe mhgvnpntkqe en}e yktb ybkmb kt}}ghhtb }yeev ha }lhy gkibt `e }upghulted? K }eeged th
}ee g{ yn{ njgh}t aphg g{ vpe}elt vh}ktkhl th tbe qep{
thv, Natep gumb tbhuibt* K pe}hjqed th ih ahpynpd ultkj K
}bhujd mhge th }hge vjnme ybkmb yn} penjj{ dnliephu}*
`ut tbel th petupl, K }bhujd tbu}* K bhved* nt nl{ pnte
penmb tbe thv ha tbe }nddje* nld }ntk}a{ g{}eja n} th ybntgkibt `e hl tbe htbep }kde,
K bnd lh tkge th jh}e* ahp kt yn} lhy `etyeel tel nld
ejeqel kl tbe ghplkli, Ahptulntej{ K yn} yejj e~ukvved*
ahp hl jenqkli tbe mngv nld tbe bhp}e} nt tbe jhyep eld ha
tbe qnjje{ K bnd vphqkded g{}eja nmmhpdkli th g{ mu}thg+
yktb eqep{tbkli tbnt K yn} jkcej{ th ynlt ahp ahup hp akqedn{}, Mbhy`hc bnd mnppked bnja* `ut bnd dphvved bk}
ybhje }yni—K }uvvh}e* nt tbe ghgelt ha bk} tnckli
ajkibt—ahp K mnge uvhl kt ybel K pnl natep bkg, K bnd*
tbepeahpe* bk} vphqk}khl} n} yejj n} g{ hyl, Nmmhpdklij{* K
thhc n} gnl{ `k}mukt} n} K tbhuibt K mhujd mnpp{* nld nj}h
}hge th`nmmh* ten* nld n aey gntmbe}, K phjjed njj tbe}e
tbkli} thietbep yktb n ajn}c lenpj{ aujj ha `pnld{* ybkmb K
bnd cevt kl g{ vhmcet ahp aenp je}t Mbhy`hc }bhujd iet
bhjd ha kt+ kl}kde g{ `jnlcet}* nld }tpnvved tbeg qep{
tkibtj{* gnckli tbe ybhje klth n jhli phjj ha }hge }eqel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 42/378
Epeybhl
40 ha =9;
aeet kl jelitb nld }kr klmbe} kl dkngetep, Tbel K tked tbe
tyh eld} thietbep* nld vut tbe ybhje phuld g{ lemc nldhqep hle }bhujdep, Tbk} k} tbe en}ke}t yn{ ha mnpp{kli n
benq{ }yni* ahp hle mnl pe}t hle‛} }eja `{ }bkatkli tbe
`updel aphg hle }bhujdep th tbe htbep, K }tpnvved g{
vnllkckl nld n }gnjj nre n`hut g{ ynk}t* nld tbu}
e~ukvved `einl th n}meld tbe qnjje{* nlip{ nt bnqkli `eel
gk}jed `{ Mbhy`hc* `ut detepgkled lht th petupl tkjj Kyn} mhgvejjed th dh }h,
K mph}}ed nld pemph}}ed tbe }tpeng }eqepnj tkge} yktbhut
dkaakmujt{* ahp tbepe yepe gnl{ ihhd ahpd}, Nt hle h‛mjhmc
K yn} nt tbe ahht ha tbe }nddje3 ahp ahup bhup} K ghulted*
tbe jn}t tyh hl tbe }lhy* ybepe tbe ihkli yn} en}kep3 `{
akqe* K yn} yktbkl tel gklute} ha tbe thv* kl n }tnte ha ermktegelt ipentep* K tbklc* tbnl K bnd eqep clhyl `eahpe,
Tel gklute} ghpe* nld tbe mhjd nkp aphg tbe htbep }kde
mnge pu}bkli uvhl ge,
N ijnlme, K yn} LHT hl tbe gnkl pnlie,
Nlhtbep ijnlme, Tbepe yn} nl nyauj pkqep* gudd{ nld
bhppk`j{ nlip{* phnpkli hqep nl kggel}e pkqep`ed*
tbhu}nld} ha aeet `ejhy ge,
Kt yelt phuld th tbe ye}tynpd* nld K mhujd }ee lh
anptbep uv tbe qnjje{* }nqe tbnt tbepe yepe elhpghu}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 43/378
Epeybhl
4= ha =9;
ijnmkep} ybkmb gu}t erteld phuld tbe }hupme ha tbe pkqep*
nld aphg ybkmb kt gu}t }vpkli,Nlhtbep ijnlme* nld tbel K pegnkled ghtkhlje}},
Tbepe yn} nl en}{ vn}} kl tbe ghultnkl} dkpemtj{
hvvh}kte th ge* tbphuib ybkmb K mnuibt n ijkgv}e ha nl
kggen}upn`je ertelt ha `jue nld dk}tnlt vjnkl},
En}{8 [e}* vepaemtj{ en}{3 ipn}}ed lenpj{ th tbe }uggkt*
ybkmb yn}* n} kt yepe* nl hvel vntb `etyeel tyh ijnmkep}*aphg ybkmb nl klmhl}kdepn`je }tpeng mnge tug`jkli dhyl
hqep phuib `ut qep{ vh}}k`je bkjj}kde}* tkjj kt iht dhyl th
tbe jeqej ha tbe ipent pkqep* nld ahpged n ajnt ybepe tbepe
yn} ipn}} nld n }gnjj `u}b ha }tulted tkg`ep,
Njgh}t `eahpe K mhujd `ejkeqe g{ e{e}* n mjhud bnd
mhge uv aphg tbe qnjje{ hl tbe htbep }kde* nld tbe vjnkl}yepe bkddel, Ybnt yhldepauj jumc yn} gkle. Bnd K
nppkqed akqe gklute} jntep* tbe mjhud yhujd bnqe `eel hqep
tbe vn}}* nld K }bhujd lht bnqe clhyl ha kt} erk}telme,
Lhy tbnt tbe mjhud yn} tbepe* K `einl th dhu`t g{
geghp{* nld th `e ulmeptnkl ybetbep kt bnd `eel ghpe
tbnl n `jue jkle ha dk}tnlt qnvhup tbnt bnd akjjed uv tbe
hvelkli, K mhujd hlj{ `e meptnkl ha tbk} gumb* lngej{*
tbnt tbe pkqep kl tbe qnjje{ `ejhy gu}t `e tbe hle lert th
tbe lhptbynpd ha tbnt ybkmb ajhyed vn}t g{ gn}tep‛}
}tntkhl3 ha tbk} tbepe mhujd `e lh dhu`t, Mhujd K*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 44/378
Epeybhl
44 ha =9;
bhyeqep* kgnikle tbnt g{ jumc }bhujd bnqe jed ge uv n
yphli pkqep kl }enpmb ha n vn}}* nld {et `phuibt ge th tbe}vht ybepe K mhujd detemt tbe hle yenc vjnme kl tbe
ahptkakmntkhl} ha n ghpe lhptbepl `n}kl8 Tbk} yn} thh
kgvph`n`je, @ut eqel n} K dhu`ted tbepe mnge n pelt kl
tbe mjhud hvvh}kte* nld n }emhld tkge K }ny `jue jkle} ha
benqkli dhyl}* iphykli ipndunjj{ ankltep* nld petkpkli
klth n anp }vnme ha vjnkl, Kt yn} }u`}tnltknj3 tbepe bnd `eellh gk}tnce ybnt}heqep, K bnd bnpdj{ gnde g{}eja vepaemtj{
}upe ha tbk}* epe tbe pelt kl tbe mjhud} ohkled uv ninkl nld
K mhujd }ee lhtbkli ghpe,
Ybnt* tbel* }bhujd K dh8 Tbe lkibt yhujd `e uvhl ge
}bhptj{* nld K yn} njpend{ mbkjjed yktb }tnldkli }tkjj natep
tbe ereptkhl ha mjkg`kli, Th }tn{ ybepe K yn} yhujd `ekgvh}}k`je3 K gu}t ektbep ih `nmcynpd} hp ahpynpd}, K
ahuld n phmc ybkmb inqe ge }bejtep aphg tbe eqelkli
ykld* nld thhc n ihhd vujj nt tbe `pnld{ ajn}c* ybkmb
kggedkntej{ ynpged nld elmhupnied ge,
K n}ced g{}eja* Mhujd K de}meld uvhl tbe pkqep'`ed
`elentb ge8 Kt yn} kgvh}}k`je th }n{ ybnt vpemkvkme}
gkibt vpeqelt g{ dhkli }h, Ka K yepe hl tbe pkqep'`ed*
dnpe K mph}} tbe pkqep8 K ng nl ermejjelt }ykggep* {et*
hlme kl tbnt apkibtauj pu}b ha yntep}* K }bhujd `e bupjed
ybktbep}heqep kt ykjjed* n`}hjutej{ vhyepje}}, Ghpehqep*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 45/378
Epeybhl
45 ha =9;
tbepe yn} g{ }yni3 K }bhujd vepk}b ha mhjd nld buliep ka K
jeat kt* `ut K }bhujd meptnklj{ `e dphyled ka K nttegvted thmnpp{ kt nmph}} tbe pkqep, Tbe}e yepe }epkhu} mhl}kdepntkhl}*
`ut tbe bhve ha akldkli nl kggel}e tpnmt ha nqnkjn`je
}beev mhultp{ ybkmb K yn} detepgkled tbnt K yhujd
ghlhvhjk}e n} anp n} K vh}}k`j{ mhujd+ }uaakmed th hutyekib
tbeg3 nld* kl n aey gklute}* K aejt pe}hjqed tbnt* bnqkli
gnde }h kgvhptnlt n dk}mhqep{ n} n vn}} klth n mhultp{ybkmb yn} vph`n`j{ n} qnjun`je n} tbnt hl hup hyl }kde ha
tbe pnlie}* K yhujd ahjjhy kt uv nld n}meptnkl kt} qnjue*
eqel tbhuib K }bhujd vn{ tbe velnjt{ ha ankjupe yktb jkae
kt}eja, Tbe ghpe K tbhuibt* tbe ghpe detepgkled K `emnge
ektbep th ykl ange nld vepbnv} ahptule* `{ eltepkli uvhl
tbk} ulclhyl yhpjd* hp ikqe uv jkae kl tbe nttegvt, Kl anmt*K aejt tbnt jkae yhujd `e lh jhliep qnjun`je ka K yepe th
bnqe }eel }h ipent n vpkze nld peau}ed th ipn}v nt tbe
vh}}k`je vphakt} tbepeaphg,
K bnd }tkjj nl bhup ha ihhd dn{jkibt dupkli ybkmb K
gkibt `eikl g{ de}melt hl th }hge }uktn`je mngvkli'
iphuld* `ut tbepe yn} lht n ghgelt th `e jh}t, Nt akp}t K
iht njhli pnvkdj{* ahp K yn} hl tbe }lhy* nld }nlc klth kt
elhuib th }nqe ge aphg anjjkli* tbhuib K yelt ahpynpd
}tpnkibt dhyl tbe ghultnkl }kde n} an}t n} K mhujd3 `ut
tbepe yn} je}} }lhy hl tbk} }kde tbnl hl tbe htbep* nld K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 46/378
Epeybhl
41 ha =9;
bnd }hhl dhle yktb kt* iettkli hl th n mhhg` ha
dnliephu} nld qep{ }thl{ iphuld* ybepe n }jkv gkibt bnqeikqel ge n dk}n}tphu} anjj, @ut K yn} mnpeauj yktb njj g{
}veed* nld iht }naej{ th tbe `htthg* ybepe tbepe yepe
vntmbe} ha mhnp}e ipn}}* nld nl nttegvt bepe nld tbepe nt
`pu}byhhd? ybnt yn} `ejhy tbk} K mhujd lht }ee, K
ndqnlmed n aey buldped {npd} anptbep* nld ahuld tbnt K
yn} hl tbe `pklc ha n apkibtauj vpemkvkme* ybkmb lh hle klbk} }el}e} yhujd nttegvt de}meldkli, K `etbhuibt ge*
bhyeqep* th tp{ tbe mpeec ybkmb dpnkled tbe mhhg`* nld
}ee ybetbep kt gkibt lht bnqe gnde kt}eja n }ghhtbep yn{,
Kl n aey gklute} K ahuld g{}eja nt tbe uvvep eld ha n
mbn}g kl tbe phmc}* }hgetbkli jkce Tyjj Dbu* hlj{ hl n
ipentj{ jnpiep }mnje3 tbe mpeec bnd ahuld kt} yn{ klth kt* nldbnd yhpl n deev mbnllej tbphuib n gntepknj ybkmb
nvvenped }hatep tbnl tbnt uvhl tbe htbep }kde ha tbe
ghultnkl, K `ejkeqe kt gu}t bnqe `eel n dkaaepelt
iehjhikmnj ahpgntkhl* tbhuib K peipet th }n{ tbnt K mnllht
tejj ybnt kt yn},
K jhhced nt tbk} pkat kl ipent dhu`t3 tbel K yelt n jkttje
yn{ hl ektbep }kde ha kt* nld ahuld g{}eja jhhckli hqep
tbe edie ha bhppk`je vpemkvkme} hl th tbe pkqep* ybkmb
phnped }hge ahup hp akqe tbhu}nld aeet `ejhy ge, K dnped
lht tbklc ha iettkli dhyl nt njj* ulje}} K mhggktted g{}eja
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 47/378
Epeybhl
49 ha =9;
th tbe pkat* ha ybkmb K yn} bhveauj ybel K peajemted tbnt
tbe phmc yn} }hat* nld tbnt tbe yntep gkibt bnqe yhpl kt}mbnllej thjepn`j{ eqelj{ tbphuib tbe ybhje ertelt, Tbe
dnpcle}} yn} klmpen}kli yktb eqep{ gklute* `ut K }bhujd
bnqe tykjkibt ahp nlhtbep bnja'bhup* }h K yelt klth tbe
mbn}g tbhuib `{ lh genl} yktbhut aenp+* nld pe}hjqed th
petupl nld mngv* nld tp{ }hge htbep vntb lert dn{* }bhujd
K mhge th nl{ }epkhu} dkaakmujt{, Kl n`hut akqe gklute} Kbnd mhgvjetej{ jh}t g{ bend3 tbe }kde ha tbe pkat `emnge
buldped} ha aeet kl bekibt* nld hqepbuli }h tbnt K mhujd
lht }ee tbe }c{, Kt yn} aujj ha phmc}* nld K bnd gnl{ anjj}
nld `puk}e}, K yn} yet tbphuib aphg anjjkli klth tbe yntep*
ha ybkmb tbepe yn} lh ipent qhjuge* `ut kt bnd }umb ahpme
tbnt K mhujd dh lhtbkli ninkl}t kt3 hlme K bnd th jenv dhyln lht klmhl}kdepn`je yntepanjj klth n deev vhhj `ejhy* nld
g{ }yni yn} }h benq{ tbnt K yn} qep{ lenpj{ dphyled, K
bnd kldeed n bnkp‛}'`pendtb e}mnve3 `ut* n} jumc yhujd
bnqe kt* Vphqkdelme yn} hl g{ }kde, ]bhptj{ natepynpd} K
`einl th anlm{ tbnt tbe pkat yn} iettkli ykdep* nld tbnt
tbepe yn} ghpe `pu}byhhd, Vpe}eltj{ K ahuld g{}eja hl
nl hvel ipn}}{ }jhve* nld aeejkli g{ yn{ n jkttje anptbep
njhli tbe }tpeng* K mnge uvhl n ajnt vjnme yktb yhhd*
ybepe K mhujd mngv mhgahptn`j{3 ybkmb yn} yejj* ahp kt
yn} lhy ~ukte dnpc,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 48/378
Epeybhl
42 ha =9;
G{ akp}t mnpe yn} ahp g{ gntmbe}3 yepe tbe{ dp{8 Tbe
hut}kde ha g{ }yni bnd iht mhgvjetej{ yet3 `ut* hluldhkli tbe `jnlcet}* K ahuld tbkli} ynpg nld dp{ yktbkl,
Bhy tbnlcauj K yn}. K jkt n akpe* nld yn} ipnteauj ahp kt}
ynpgtb nld mhgvnl{, K gnde g{}eja }hge ten nld nte
tyh ha g{ `k}mukt}? g{ `pnld{ K dkd lht thumb* ahp K bnd
jkttje jeat* nld gkibt ynlt kt ybel g{ mhupnie ankjed ge,
Njj tbnt K dkd* K dkd njgh}t gembnlkmnjj{* ahp K mhujd lhtpenjk}e g{ }ktuntkhl th g{}eja* `e{hld clhykli tbnt K yn}
njhle* nld tbnt petupl tbphuib tbe mbn}g ybkmb K bnd ou}t
de}melded yhujd `e kgvh}}k`je, Kt k} n dpendauj aeejkli tbnt
ha `ekli mut haa aphg njj hle‛} ckld, K yn} }tkjj aujj ha bhve*
nld `ukjt ihjdel mn}tje} ahp g{}eja n} }hhl n} K yn} ynpged
yktb ahhd nld akpe3 `ut K dh lht `ejkeqe tbnt nl{ gnlmhujd jhli petnkl bk} pen}hl kl }umb }hjktude* ulje}} be bnd
tbe mhgvnlkhl}bkv ha nlkgnj}, Hle `eikl} dhu`tkli hle‛}
hyl kdeltkt{,
K pegeg`ep depkqkli mhgahpt eqel aphg tbe }kibt ha
g{ `jnlcet}* nld tbe }huld ha g{ yntmb tkmckli—tbkli}
ybkmb }eeged th jklc ge th htbep vehvje3 `ut tbe
}mpengkli ha tbe yhhd'bel} apkibteled ge* n} nj}h n
mbnttepkli `kpd ybkmb K bnd leqep benpd `eahpe* nld ybkmb
}eeged th jnuib nt ge3 tbhuib K }hhl iht u}ed th kt* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 49/378
Epeybhl
4; ha =9;
`eahpe jhli mhujd anlm{ tbnt kt yn} gnl{ {enp} }klme K bnd
akp}t benpd kt,K thhc haa g{ mjhtbe}* nld ypnvved g{ kl}kde `jnlcet
n`hut ge* tkjj g{ tbkli} yepe dp{, Tbe lkibt yn} qep{ }tkjj*
nld K gnde n phnpkli akpe3 }h K }hhl iht ynpg* nld nt jn}t
mhujd vut g{ mjhtbe} hl ninkl, Tbel K }tpnvved g{
`jnlcet phuld ge* nld yelt th }jeev n} lenp tbe akpe n} K
mhujd,K dpenged tbnt tbepe yn} nl hpinl vjnmed kl g{
gn}tep‛} yhhj'}bed? tbe yhhj'}bed anded nyn{* nld tbe
hpinl }eeged th iphy nld iphy ngkd n `jnze ha `pkjjknlt
jkibt* tkjj kt `emnge jkce n ihjdel mkt{ uvhl tbe }kde ha n
ghultnkl* yktb phy} uvhl phy} ha vkve} }et kl mjkaa} nld
vpemkvkme}* hle n`hqe tbe htbep* nld kl g{}tepkhu} mnqepl}*jkce tbnt ha Aklinj* yktbkl ybh}e devtb} K mhujd }ee tbe
`uplk}bed vkjjnp} ijengkli, Kl tbe aphlt tbepe yn} n ajkibt
ha jhat{ teppnme}* nt tbe thv ha ybkmb K mhujd }ee n gnl
yktb bk} bend `upked ahpynpd thynpd} n ce{'`hnpd* nld bk}
`hd{ }yn{kli aphg }kde th }kde ngkd tbe }thpg ha buie
npveiikhed bnpghlke} tbnt mnge mpn}bkli hqepbend nld
phuld, Tbel tbepe yn} hle ybh thumbed ge hl tbe
}bhujdep* nld }nkd* ‒Dh {hu lht }ee8 kt k} Bnldej"3—`ut K
bnd bnpdj{ nvvpebelded* nld yn} tp{kli th }mnje tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 50/378
Epeybhl
56 ha =9;
teppnme}* nld iet lenp bkg* ybel K nyhce* dnzzjed yktb
tbe qkqkdle}} nld dk}tklmtle}} ha tbe dpeng,N vkeme ha yhhd bnd `upled tbphuib* nld tbe eld} bnd
anjjel klth tbe n}be} yktb n `jnze? tbk}* K }uvvh}ed* bnd
`htb ikqel ge g{ dpeng nld ph``ed ge ha kt, K yn}
`kttepj{ dk}nvvhklted* nld }kttkli uv hl g{ ej`hy* mnge
`nmc th penjkt{ nld g{ }tpnlie }upphuldkli} n} `e}t K
mhujd,K yn} tbhphuibj{ nphu}ed—ghpehqep* K aejt n
ahpe}bndhykli n} tbhuib g{ ntteltkhl yepe nppe}ted `{
}hgetbkli ghpe tbnl tbe dpeng* njtbhuib lh }el}e kl
vnptkmujnp yn} n} {et nvvenjed th, K bejd g{ `pentb nld
ynkted* nld tbel K benpd—yn} kt anlm{8 Ln{3 K jk}teled
ninkl nld ninkl* nld K DKD benp n anklt nld ertpegej{dk}tnlt }huld ha gu}km* jkce tbnt ha nl NEhjknl bnpv* `hple
uvhl tbe ykld ybkmb yn} `jhykli ape}b nld mbkjj aphg
tbe hvvh}kte ghultnkl},
Tbe phht} ha g{ bnkp tbpkjjed, K jk}teled* `ut tbe ykld
bnd dked3 nld* anlm{kli tbnt kt gu}t bnqe `eel tbe ykld
kt}eja—lh3 hl n }uddel K pegeg`eped tbe lhk}e ybkmb
Mbhy`hc bnd gnde kl tbe yhhj' }bed, [e}3 kt yn} tbnt,
Tbnlc Benqel* ybnteqep kt yn}* kt yn} hqep lhy, K
pen}hled yktb g{}eja* nld pemhqeped g{ akpgle}}, K
`emnge mhlqklmed tbnt K bnd hlj{ `eel dpengkli ghpe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 51/378
Epeybhl
5> ha =9;
qkqkdj{ tbnl u}unj, ]hhl K `einl eqel th jnuib* nld tbklc
ybnt n ahhj K yn} th `e apkibteled nt lhtbkli* pegkldklig{}eja tbnt eqel ka K yepe th mhge th n `nd eld kt yhujd
`e lh }umb dpendauj gnttep natep njj, K }nkd g{ vpn{ep}* n
dut{ ybkmb K bnd thh hatel leijemted* nld kl n jkttje tkge
aejj klth n penjj{ peape}bkli }jeev* ybkmb jn}ted tkjj `phnd
dn{jkibt* nld pe}thped ge, K ph}e* nld }enpmbkli nghli tbe
eg`ep} ha g{ akpe* K ahuld n aey jkqe mhnj} nld }hhl bnd n`jnze ninkl, K iht `pencan}t* nld yn} dejkibted th bnqe tbe
mhgvnl{ ha }eqepnj }gnjj `kpd}* ybkmb bhvved n`hut ge
nld vepmbed hl g{ `hht} nld bnld}, K aejt mhgvnpntkqej{
bnvv{* `ut K mnl n}}upe tbe pendep tbnt K bnd bnd n anp
yhp}e tkge ha kt tbnl K bnqe thjd bkg3 nld K }tphlij{
pemhggeld bkg th pegnkl kl Euphve ka be mnl3 hp* nt nl{pnte* kl }hge mhultp{ ybkmb bn} `eel ervjhped nld }ettjed*
pntbep tbnl ih klth vjnme} ybepe htbep} bnqe lht `eel
`eahpe bkg, Ervjhpkli k} dejkibtauj th jhhc ahpynpd th nld
`nmc uvhl* `ut kt k} lht mhgahptn`je nt tbe tkge* ulje}} kt
`e ha }umb nl en}{ lntupe n} lht th de}epqe tbe lnge,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 52/378
Epeybhl
50 ha =9;
MBNVTEP Q? TBE PKQEP NLD TBEPNLIE
G{ lert `u}kle}} yn} th de}meld uvhl tbe pkqep, K bnd
jh}t }kibt ha tbe vn}} ybkmb K bnd }eel aphg tbe }nddje* `ut
bnd gnde }umb lhte} ha kt tbnt K mhujd lht ankj th akld kt, K
yn} `puk}ed nld }tkaa* nld g{ `hht} bnd `eiul th ikqe* ahp
K bnd `eel ihkli hl phuib iphuld ahp ghpe tbnl tbpee
yeec}3 `ut* n} tbe dn{ yhpe hl* nld K ahuld g{}eja
de}meldkli yktbhut }epkhu} dkaakmujt{* K `emnge en}kep, Kl n
mhuvje ha bhup} K iht nghli vkle ahpe}t} ybepe tbepe yn}
jkttje uldepiphytb* nld de}melded ~ukmcj{ tkjj K penmbed
tbe edie ha nlhtbep vpemkvkme* ybkmb inqe ge n ipent denj
ha tphu`je* tbhuib K eqeltunjj{ gnlnied th nqhkd kt, @{
n`hut tbpee hp ahup h‛mjhmc K ahuld g{}eja hl tbe pkqep'
`ed,
Aphg mnjmujntkhl} ybkmb K gnde n} th tbe bekibt ha tbe
qnjje{ hl tbe htbep }kde tbe }nddje hqep ybkmb K bnd mhge*
K mhlmjuded tbnt tbe }nddje kt}eja mhujd lht `e je}} tbnl
lkle tbhu}nld aeet bkib3 nld K }bhujd tbklc tbnt tbe pkqep'`ed* hl th ybkmb K lhy de}melded* yn} tbpee tbhu}nld
aeet n`hqe tbe }en'jeqej, Tbe yntep bnd n teppkakm muppelt*
yktb n anjj ha lht je}} tbnl ahpt{ th akat{ aeet vep gkje, Kt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 53/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 54/378
Epeybhl
54 ha =9;
pegklk}melme ha ybnt K bnd benpd aphg Mbhy`hc nld `{
tbe hqep' ermktegelt ha tbe vpemedkli eqelkli,Lert dn{ K `einl intbepkli tbe dp{ `jhhg }tnjc} ha n
ckld ha ajni hp kpk}'jhhckli vjnlt* ybkmb yn} n`uldnlt* nld
ybh}e jenqe}* ybel thpl klth }tpkv}* yepe n} }tphli n} tbe
}tphlie}t }tpkli, K `phuibt tbeg th tbe yntep}kde* nld aejj
th gnckli g{}eja n ckld ha phuib vjntahpg* ybkmb }bhujd
}uaakme ahp g{}eja nld g{ }yni ka K mhujd hlj{ }tkmc th kt,Tbe }tnjc} yepe tel hp tyejqe aeet jhli* nld qep{ }tphli*
`ut jkibt nld bhjjhy, K gnde g{ pnat eltkpej{ ha tbeg*
`kldkli `uldje} ha tbeg nt pkibt nlije} th enmb htbep*
lentj{ nld }tphlij{* yktb }tpkv} aphg tbe jenqe} ha tbe }nge
vjnlt* nld t{kli htbep phd} nmph}}, Kt thhc ge njj dn{ tkjj
lenpj{ ahup h‛mjhmc th aklk}b tbe pnat* `ut K bnd }tkjj elhuibdn{jkibt ahp mph}}kli* nld pe}hjqed hl dhkli }h nt hlme,
K bnd }ejemted n vjnme ybepe tbe pkqep yn} `phnd nld
mhgvnpntkqej{ }tkjj* }hge }eqelt{ hp ekibt{ {npd} n`hqe n
aupkhu} pnvkd, Nt tbk} }vht K bnd `ukjt g{ pnat, K lhy
jnulmbed kt* gnde g{ }yni an}t th tbe gkddje* nld iht hl
th kt g{}eja* ceevkli kl g{ bnld hle ha tbe jhlie}t
`jh}}hg }tnjc}* }h tbnt K gkibt vult g{}eja nmph}} n} jhli n}
tbe yntep yn} }bnjjhy elhuib th jet ge dh }h, K iht hl
vpett{ yejj ahp tyelt{ hp tbkpt{ {npd} aphg tbe }bhpe* `ut
eqel kl tbk} }bhpt }vnme K lenpj{ uv}et g{ pnat `{ }bkatkli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 55/378
Epeybhl
55 ha =9;
thh pnvkdj{ aphg hle }kde th tbe htbep, Tbe yntep tbel
`emnge gumb deevep* nld K jenled hqep }h anp kl hpdep thiet tbe `jhhg phd th tbe `htthg tbnt K bnd th }tn{ }tkjj*
jenlkli hl tbe phd ahp n aey }emhld}, Tbel* ybel K jkated
uv tbe phd aphg tbe iphuld* tbe muppelt yn} thh gumb ahp
ge nld K ahuld g{}eja `ekli mnppked dhyl tbe pnvkd,
Eqep{tbkli kl n }emhld ajey vn}t ge* nld K bnd lh ghpe
mhltphj hqep tbe pnat3 lektbep mnl K pegeg`ep nl{tbkliermevt bupp{* nld lhk}e* nld yntep} ybkmb kl tbe eld
uv}et ge, @ut kt njj mnge pkibt* nld K ahuld g{}eja lenp
tbe }bhpe* lht ghpe tbnl uv th g{ clee} kl yntep nld
vujjkli g{ pnat th jnld* ahptulntej{ uvhl tbe jeat `nlc ha
tbe pkqep* ybkmb yn} tbe hle K ynlted, Ybel K bnd jnlded
K ahuld tbnt K yn} n`hut n gkje* hp vepbnv} n jkttje je}}*`ejhy tbe vhklt aphg ybkmb K }tnpted, G{ }yni yn} yet
uvhl tbe hut}kde* nld K yn} g{}eja dpkvvkli3 `ut K bnd
inkled g{ vhklt* nld cley tbnt g{ dkaakmujtke} yepe ahp n
tkge hqep, K tbel jkt g{ akpe nld dpked g{}eja3 bnqkli dhle
}h K mnuibt }hge ha tbe {huli dumc} nld }en' iujj}* ybkmb
yepe n`uldnlt hl nld lenp tbe pkqep'`ed* }h tbnt K bnd lht
hlj{ n ihhd genj* ha ybkmb K yn} kl ipent ynlt* bnqkli
bnd nl kl}uaakmkelt dket aphg tbe tkge tbnt Mbhy`hc jeat
ge* `ut yn} nj}h yejj vphqkded ahp tbe ghpphy,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 56/378
Epeybhl
51 ha =9;
K tbhuibt ha Mbhy`hc* nld aejt bhy u}eauj be bnd
`eel th ge* nld kl bhy gnl{ yn{} K yn} tbe jh}ep `{ bk}n`}elme* bnqkli lhy th dh njj }hpt} ha tbkli} ahp g{}eja
ybkmb be bnd bktbepth dhle ahp ge* nld mhujd dh
klaklktej{ `ettep tbnl K mhujd, Ghpehqep* K bnd }et g{ benpt
uvhl gnckli bkg n penj mhlqept th tbe Mbpk}tknl pejkikhl*
ybkmb be bnd njpend{ eg`pnmed hutynpdj{* tbhuib K
mnllht tbklc tbnt kt bnd tncel deev phht kl bk}kgveletpn`j{ }tuvkd lntupe, K u}ed th mntembk}e bkg `{ hup
mngv akpe* nld ervjnkl th bkg tbe g{}tepke} ha tbe Tpklkt{
nld ha hpkiklnj }kl* yktb ybkmb K yn} g{}eja angkjknp*
bnqkli `eel tbe ipnld}hl ha nl npmbdenmhl `{ g{
ghtbep‛} }kde* th }n{ lhtbkli ha tbe anmt tbnt g{ antbep yn}
n mjepi{gnl ha tbe Elijk}b Mbupmb, K yn} tbepeahpe}uaakmkeltj{ ~unjkaked ahp tbe tn}c* nld yn} tbe ghpe
klmjkled th kt* hqep nld n`hqe g{ penj de}kpe th }nqe tbe
ulbnvv{ mpentupe aphg nl eteplkt{ ha thptupe* `{
pemhjjemtkli tbe vphgk}e ha ]t, Onge}* tbnt ka nl{ hle
mhlqepted n }kllep ybkmb Mbhy`hc }upej{ yn}+ be }bhujd
bkde n gujtktude ha }kl}, K peajemted* tbepeahpe* tbnt tbe
mhlqep}khl ha Mbhy`hc gkibt kl }hge deipee
mhgvel}nte ahp kppeiujnpktke} nld }bhpt'mhgkli} kl g{
hyl vpeqkhu} jkae* tbe pegeg`pnlme ha ybkmb bnd `eel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 57/378
Epeybhl
59 ha =9;
ghpe tbnl hlme ulvjen}nlt th ge dupkli g{ pemelt
ervepkelme},Kldeed* hl hle hmmn}khl K bnd eqel ihle }h anp n} th
`nvtkze bkg* n} yejj n} K mhujd* bnqkli n}meptnkled tbnt be
bnd meptnklj{ lht `eel `htb mbpk}teled nld `nvtkzed* nld
intbepkli aphg bk} tejjkli ge tbnt be bnd pemekqed tbe
lnge Ykjjkng aphg tbe gk}}khlnp{+ tbnt kt yn} vph`n`j{
tbe akp}t'geltkhled pkte th ybkmb be bnd `eel }u`oemted, Ktbhuibt kt ipent mnpeje}}le}} hl tbe vnpt ha tbe gk}}khlnp{
th bnqe hgktted tbe }emhld* nld meptnklj{ ghpe kgvhptnlt*
mepeghl{ ybkmb K bnqe njyn{} uldep}thhd vpemede}
mbpk}telkli `htb kl tbe mn}e ha klanlt} nld ha ndujt
mhlqept}3 nld ybel K tbhuibt ha tbe pk}c} ye yepe `htb
klmuppkli K detepgkled tbnt tbepe }bhujd `e lh auptbep dejn{, Ahptulntej{ kt yn} lht {et tyejqe h‛mjhmc* }h K
`nvtkzed bkg nt hlme aphg hle ha tbe vnllkckl} tbe hlj{
qe}}ej} K bnd+ peqepeltj{* nld* K tpu}t* eaakmkeltj{, K tbel }et
g{}eja th yhpc th kl}tpumt bkg kl tbe deevep g{}tepke} ha
hup `ejkea* nld th gnce bkg* lht hlj{ kl lnge* `ut kl
benpt n Mbpk}tknl,
Kt k} tpue tbnt K gkibt lht bnqe }ummeeded* ahp
Mbhy`hc yn} qep{ bnpd th tenmb, Kldeed* hl tbe eqelkli
ha tbe }nge dn{ tbnt K `nvtkzed bkg be tpked ahp tbe
tyeltketb tkge th }tenj tbe `pnld{* ybkmb gnde ge pntbep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 58/378
Epeybhl
52 ha =9;
ulbnvv{ n} th ybetbep K mhujd bnqe `nvtkzed bkg pkibtj{,
Be bnd n vpn{ep'`hhc—ghpe tbnl tyelt{ {enp} hjd— ybkmb bnd `eel ikqel bkg `{ tbe gk}}khlnpke}* `ut tbe
hlj{ tbkli kl kt ybkmb bnd tncel nl{ jkqkli bhjd uvhl bkg
yn} tbe tktje ha Ndejnkde tbe ^ueel Dhyniep* ybkmb be
yhujd pevent ybeleqep }tphlij{ ghqed hp thumbed* nld
ybkmb dkd penjj{ }eeg th bnqe }hge deev }vkpktunj
}kilkakmnlme th bkg* tbhuib be mhujd leqep mhgvjetej{}evnpnte bep kldkqkdunjkt{ aphg tbnt ha Gnp{ Gnidnjele*
ybh}e lnge bnd nj}h an}mklnted bkg* tbhuib kl n je}}
deipee,
Be yn} kldeed }thl{ iphuld* `ut `{ dkiikli n`hut bkg
K gkibt bnqe nt nl{ pnte devpkqed bkg ha njj anktb kl tbe
pejkikhl ha bk} tpk`e* ybkmb yhujd bnqe `eel bnja yn{thynpd} gnckli bkg n }klmepe Mbpk}tknl3 nld lhy njj tbk}
yn} mut haa aphg ge* nld K mhujd lektbep `e ha auptbep
}vkpktunj n}}k}tnlme th bkg lhp be ha `hdkj{ vphakt th g{}eja?
`e}kde}* nl{ mhgvnl{ yn} `ettep tbnl `ekli ~ukte njhle,
K iht qep{ gejnlmbhj{ n} tbe}e peajemtkhl} mph}}ed ge*
`ut ybel K bnd `hkjed tbe dumc} nld entel tbeg K yn}
gumb `ettep, K bnd n jkttje ten jeat nld n`hut n vhuld ha
th`nmmh* ybkmb }bhujd jn}t ge ahp nlhtbep ahptlkibt yktb
ghdepnte }ghckli, K bnd nj}h ekibt }bkv `k}mukt}* nld* gh}t
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 59/378
Epeybhl
5; ha =9;
vpemkhu} ha njj* n`hut }kr hulme} ha `pnld{* ybkmb K
vpe}eltj{ pedumed th ahup* ahp tbe lkibt yn} mhjd,K ph}e yktb enpj{ dnyl* nld kl nl bhup K yn} hl g{
yn{* aeejkli }tpnlie* lht th }n{ yenc* aphg tbe `updel ha
}hjktude* `ut aujj ha bhve ybel K mhl}kdeped bhy gnl{
dnliep} K bnd hqepmhge* nld tbnt tbk} dn{ }bhujd }ee ge nt
tbe }uggkt ha tbe dkqkdkli pnlie,
Natep n }jhy `ut }tend{ mjkg` ha `etyeel tbpee nld ahup bhup}* dupkli ybkmb K get yktb lh }epkhu} bkldpnlme* K
ahuld g{}eja uvhl n tn`jejnld* nld mjh}e th n ijnmkep
ybkmb K pemhilk}ed n} gnpckli tbe }uggkt ha tbe vn}},
N`hqe kt thyeped n }umme}}khl ha puiied vpemkvkme} nld
}lhy{ ghultnkl }kde}, Tbe }hjktude yn} ipentep tbnl K
mhujd `enp3 tbe ghultnkl uvhl g{ gn}tep‛} }beev'pul yn}n mphyded tbhphuibanpe kl mhgvnpk}hl yktb tbk} }hg`pe
}ujjel vjnme, Tbe nkp* ghpehqep* yn} dnpc nld benq{*
ybkmb gnde tbe jhlejkle}} eqel ghpe hvvpe}}kqe, Tbepe
yn} nl klc{ ijhhg hqep njj tbnt yn} lht mhqeped yktb
}lhy nld kme, Ipn}} tbepe yn} lhle,
Enmb ghgelt K aejt klmpen}kli uvhl ge tbnt dpendauj
dhu`t n} th g{ hyl kdeltkt{—n} th tbe mhltklukt{ ha g{
vn}t nld vpe}elt erk}telme—ybkmb k} tbe akp}t }kil ha tbnt
dk}tpnmtkhl ybkmb mhge} hl tbh}e ybh bnqe jh}t
tbeg}ejqe} kl tbe `u}b, K bnd ahuibt ninkl}t tbk} aeejkli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 60/378
Epeybhl
16 ha =9;
bktbepth* nld bnd mhl~ueped kt3 `ut tbe kltel}e }kjelme nld
ijhhg ha tbk} phmc{ ykjdeple}} yepe thh gumb ahp ge* nldK aejt tbnt g{ vhyep ha mhjjemtkli g{}eja yn} `eikllkli th
`e kgvnkped,
K pe}ted ahp n jkttje ybkje* nld tbel ndqnlmed hqep qep{
phuib iphuld* ultkj K penmbed tbe jhyep eld ha tbe ijnmkep,
Tbel K }ny nlhtbep ijnmkep* de}meldkli aphg tbe en}tepl
}kde klth n }gnjj jnce, K vn}}ed njhli tbe ye}tepl }kde ha tbe jnce* ybepe tbe iphuld yn} en}kep* nld ybel K bnd iht
n`hut bnja yn{ K ervemted tbnt K }bhujd }ee tbe vjnkl}
ybkmb K bnd njpend{ }eel aphg tbe hvvh}kte ghultnkl}3 `ut
kt yn} lht th `e }h* ahp tbe mjhud} phjjed uv th tbe qep{
}uggkt ha tbe vn}}* tbhuib tbe{ dkd lht hqepjkv kt hl th
tbe }kde aphg ybkmb K bnd mhge, K tbepeahpe }hhl ahuldg{}eja el}bphuded `{ n mhjd tbkl qnvhup* ybkmb vpeqelted
g{ }eekli ghpe tbnl n qep{ aey {npd} kl aphlt ha ge,
Tbel K mnge uvhl n jnpie vntmb ha hjd }lhy* kl ybkmb K
mhujd dk}tklmtj{ tpnme tbe bnja'gejted tpnmc} ha ihnt}—nld
kl hle vjnme* n} kt }eeged th ge* tbepe bnd `eel n dhi
ahjjhykli tbeg, Bnd K jkibted uvhl n jnld ha }bevbepd}8
Tbe iphuld* ybepe lht mhqeped yktb }lhy* yn} }h vhhp
nld }thl{* nld tbepe yn} }h jkttje bep`nie* tbnt K mhujd }ee
lh }kil ha n vntb hp peiujnp }beev'tpnmc, @ut K mhujd lht
bejv aeejkli pntbep ulen}{ n} K yhldeped ybnt }hpt ha n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 61/378
Epeybhl
1> ha =9;
pemevtkhl K gkibt geet yktb ka K yepe th mhge }uddelj{
uvhl klbn`ktnlt}, K yn} tbklckli ha tbk}* nld vphmeedklimnutkhu}j{ tbphuib tbe gk}t* ybel K `einl th anlm{ tbnt K
}ny }hge h`oemt} dnpcep tbnl tbe mjhud jhhgkli kl aphlt
ha ge, N aey }tev} `phuibt ge lenpep* nld n }buddep ha
uluttepn`je bhpphp pnl tbphuib ge ybel K }ny n mkpmje ha
ikinltkm ahpg}* gnl{ tkge} bkibep tbnl g{}eja* uv}tnldkli
ipkg nld ipe{ tbphuib tbe qekj ha mjhud `eahpe ge,K }uvvh}e K gu}t bnqe anklted* ahp K ahuld g{}eja }hge
tkge natepynpd} }kttkli uvhl tbe iphuld* }kmc nld dendj{
mhjd, Tbepe yepe tbe akiupe}* ~ukte }tkjj nld }kjelt* }eel
qniuej{ tbphuib tbe tbkmc ijhhg* `ut kl bugnl }bnve
kldk}vutn`j{,
N }uddel tbhuibt hmmupped th ge* ybkmb yhujd bnqedhu`tje}} }tpumc ge nt hlme bnd K lht `eel vpevh}}e}}ed
yktb ahpe`hdkli} nt tbe tkge tbnt K akp}t }ny tbe akiupe}*
nld bnd lht tbe mjhud mhlmenjed tbeg aphg ge—K genl
tbnt tbe{ yepe lht jkqkli `ekli}* `ut }tntue}, K detepgkled
tbnt K yhujd mhult akat{ }jhyj{* nld yn} }upe tbnt tbe
h`oemt} yepe lht njkqe ka dupkli tbnt tkge K mhujd detemt lh
}kil ha ghtkhl,
Bhy tbnlcauj yn} K ybel K mnge th tbe eld ha g{ akat{
nld tbepe bnd `eel lh ghqegelt.
K mhulted n }emhld tkge—`ut ninkl njj yn} }tkjj,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 62/378
Epeybhl
10 ha =9;
K tbel ndqnlmed tkgkdj{ ahpynpd* nld kl nlhtbep
ghgelt K }ny tbnt g{ }upgk}e yn} mhppemt, K bnd mhgeuvhl n }hpt ha ]thlebelie ha pude nld `np`npkm akiupe}*
}ented n} Mbhy`hc bnd }nt ybel K ~ue}tkhled bkg kl tbe
yhhj'}bed* nld yktb tbe }nge }uvepbugnlj{ gnjeqhjelt
ervpe}}khl uvhl tbekp anme}, Tbe{ bnd `eel njj }ented* `ut
tyh bnd anjjel, Tbe{ yepe `np`nphu}—lektbep Ei{vtknl*
lhp N}}{pknl* lhp Onvnle}e—dkaaepelt aphg nl{ ha tbe}e*nld {et nckl th njj, Tbe{ yepe }kr hp }eqel tkge} jnpiep
tbnl jkae* ha ipent nltk~ukt{* yhpl nld jkmbel iphyl, Tbe{
yepe tel kl lug`ep, Tbepe yn} }lhy uvhl tbekp bend}
nld ybepeqep }lhy mhujd jhdie, Enmb }tntue bnd `eel
`ukjt ha ahup hp akqe elhpghu} `jhmc}* `ut bhy tbe}e bnd
`eel pnk}ed nld vut thietbep k} clhyl th tbh}e njhle ybhpnk}ed tbeg, Enmb yn} teppk`je natep n dkaaepelt ckld, Hle
yn} pnikli aupkhu}j{* n} kl vnkl nld ipent de}vnkp3 nlhtbep
yn} jenl nld mndnqephu} yktb angkle3 nlhtbep mpuej nld
kdkhtkm* `ut yktb tbe }kjjke}t }kgvep tbnt mnl `e
mhlmekqed—tbk} hle bnd anjjel* nld jhhced er~uk}ktej{
judkmphu} kl bk} anjj—tbe ghutb} ha njj yepe ghpe hp je}}
hvel* nld n} K jhhced nt tbeg aphg `ebkld* K }ny tbnt
tbekp bend} bnd `eel bhjjhyed,
K yn} }kmc nld }bkqepkli yktb mhjd, ]hjktude bnd
ulgnlled ge njpend{* nld K yn} uttepj{ ulakt th bnqe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 63/378
Epeybhl
1= ha =9;
mhge uvhl }umb nl n}}eg`j{ ha akeld} kl }umb n dpendauj
ykjdeple}} nld yktbhut vpevnpntkhl, K yhujd bnqe ikqeleqep{tbkli K bnd kl tbe yhpjd th bnqe `eel `nmc nt g{
gn}tep‛} }tntkhl3 `ut tbnt yn} lht th `e tbhuibt ha? g{
bend yn} ankjkli* nld K aejt }upe tbnt K mhujd leqep iet `nmc
njkqe,
Tbel mnge n iu}t ha bhyjkli ykld* nmmhgvnlked yktb
n ghnl aphg hle ha tbe }tntue} n`hqe ge, K mjn}ved g{bnld} kl aenp, K aejt jkce n pnt mnuibt kl n tpnv* n} tbhuib K
yhujd bnqe tupled nld `kttel nt ybnteqep tbkli yn}
lenpe}t ge, Tbe ykjdle}} ha tbe ykld klmpen}ed* tbe ghnl}
ipey }bpkjjep* mhgkli aphg }eqepnj }tntue}* nld }yejjkli
klth n mbhpu}, K njgh}t kggedkntej{ cley ybnt kt yn}* `ut
tbe }huld yn} }h ulenptbj{ tbnt tbk} yn} `ut jkttjemhl}hjntkhl, Tbe klbugnl `ekli} klth ybh}e benpt} tbe
Eqkj Hle bnd vut kt th mhlmekqe tbe}e }tntue}* bnd gnde
tbekp bend} klth n }hpt ha hpinl' vkve* }h tbnt tbekp ghutb}
}bhujd mntmb tbe ykld nld }huld yktb kt} `jhykli, Kt yn}
bhppk`je, Bhyeqep `pnqe n gnl gkibt `e* be mhujd leqep
}tnld }umb n mhlmept* aphg }umb jkv}* nld kl }umb n vjnme, K
benved eqep{ klqemtkqe uvhl tbeg tbnt g{ thliue mhujd
uttep n} K pu}bed nyn{ aphg tbeg klth tbe gk}t* nld eqel
natep K bnd jh}t }kibt ha tbeg* nld tuplkli g{ bend phuld
mhujd }ee lhtbkli `ut tbe }thpg'ypnktb} dpkqkli `ebkld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 64/378
Epeybhl
14 ha =9;
ge* K benpd tbekp ibh}tj{ mbnltkli* nld aejt n} tbhuib hle
ha tbeg yhujd pu}b natep ge nld ipkv ge kl bk} bnld nldtbphttje ge,
K gn{ }n{ bepe tbnt* }klme g{ petupl th Elijnld* K benpd
n apkeld vjn{kli }hge mbhpd} uvhl tbe hpinl ybkmb vut
ge qep{ ahpmk`j{ kl gkld ha tbe Epeybhlknl }tntue} ahp
Epeybhl k} tbe lnge ha tbe mhultp{ uvhl ybkmb K yn}
lhy eltepkli+, Tbe{ ph}e gh}t qkqkdj{ th g{ pemhjjemtkhltbe ghgelt g{ apkeld `einl, Tbe{ npe n} ahjjhy}* nld npe
`{ tbe ipente}t ha njj gu}kmknl}?' s0w
SGu}km }mhpe ybkmb mnllht `e pevphdumedW
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 65/378
Epeybhl
15 ha =9;
MBNVTEP QK? KLTH EPEYBHL
Nld lhy K ahuld g{}eja hl n lnpphy vntb ybkmb
ahjjhyed n }gnjj yntepmhup}e, K yn} thh ijnd th bnqe nl
en}{ tpnmc ahp g{ ajkibt* th jn{ bhjd ha tbe aujj }kilkakmnlme
ha kt} erk}telme, Tbe tbhuibt* bhyeqep* }hhl vpe}elted
kt}eja th ge tbnt K gu}t `e kl nl klbn`kted mhultp{* `ut hle
ybkmb yn} {et ulclhyl, Ybnt* tbel* yn} th `e g{ ante nt
tbe bnld} ha kt} klbn`ktnlt}8 ]bhujd K `e tncel nld haaeped
uv n} n `uplt'haaepkli th tbh}e bkdehu} iunpdknl} ha tbe
vn}}8 Kt gkibt `e }h, K }buddeped nt tbe tbhuibt* {et tbe
bhpphp} ha }hjktude bnd lhy ankpj{ vh}}e}}ed ge3 nld }h
dnzed yn} K* nld mbkjjed* nld yhe`eihle* tbnt K mhujd jn{
bhjd ha lh kden akpgj{ ngkd tbe mphyd ha anlmke} tbnt cevt
ynldepkli kl uvhl g{ `pnkl,
K buppked hlynpd—dhyl* dhyl* dhyl, Ghpe }tpeng}
mnge kl3 tbel tbepe yn} n `pkdie* n aey vkle jhi} tbphyl
hqep tbe yntep3 `ut tbe{ inqe ge mhgahpt* ahp }nqnie} dh
lht gnce `pkdie}, Tbel K bnd n tpent }umb n} K mnl leqep
mhlqe{ hl vnvep—n ghgelt* vepbnv}* tbe gh}t }tpkckli
nld ulervemted kl g{ ybhje jkae—tbe hle K tbklc tbnt*
yktb }hge tbpee hp ahup ermevtkhl}* K yhujd gh}t ijndj{
bnqe ninkl* yepe K n`je th pemnjj kt, K iht `ejhy tbe jeqej ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 66/378
Epeybhl
11 ha =9;
tbe mjhud}* klth n `up}t ha `pkjjknlt eqelkli }ul}bkle* K yn}
anmkli tbe lhptb'ye}t* nld tbe }ul yn} aujj uvhl ge, Hb*bhy kt} jkibt mbeeped ge. @ut ybnt K }ny. Kt yn} }umb nl
ervnl}e n} yn} peqenjed th Gh}e} ybel be }thhd uvhl tbe
}uggkt ha Ghult ]klnk* nld `ebejd tbnt vphgk}ed jnld
ybkmb kt yn} lht th `e bk} th eltep, Tbe `enutkauj }ul}et
}c{ yn} mpkg}hl nld ihjd3 `jue* }kjqep* nld vupvje3
er~uk}kte nld tpnl~ukjjk}kli3 andkli nyn{ tbepekl yepevjnkl}* hl ybkmb K mhujd }ee gnl{ n thyl nld mkt{* yktb
`ukjdkli} tbnt bnd jhat{ }teevje} nld phulded dhge},
Lenpep `elentb ge jn{ pkdie `ebkld pkdie* hutjkle `ebkld
hutjkle* }uljkibt `ebkld }bndhy* nld }bndhy `ebkld
}uljkibt* iujj{ nld }eppnted pnqkle, K }ny jnpie vkle ahpe}t}*
nld tbe ijkttep ha n lh`je pkqep ykldkli kt} yn{ uvhl tbevjnkl}3 nj}h gnl{ qkjjnie} nld bngjet}* }hge ha tbeg ~ukte
lenp nt bnld3 nld kt yn} hl tbe}e tbnt K vhldeped gh}t, K
}nlc uvhl tbe iphuld nt tbe ahht ha n jnpie tpee nld
tbhuibt ybnt K bnd `e}t dh3 `ut K mhujd lht mhjjemt g{}eja,
K yn} ~ukte tkped hut3 nld vpe}eltj{* aeejkli ynpged `{ tbe
}ul* nld ~uketed* K aejj haa klth n vphahuld }jeev,
K yn} nyhce `{ tbe }huld ha tklcjkli `ejj}* nld jhhckli
uv* K }ny ahup hp akqe ihnt} aeedkli lenp ge, N} }hhl n} K
ghqed* tbe mpentupe} tupled tbekp bend} thynpd} ge yktb
nl ervpe}}khl ha klaklkte yhldep, Tbe{ dkd lht pul nyn{*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 67/378
Epeybhl
19 ha =9;
`ut }thhd }thmc }tkjj* nld jhhced nt ge aphg eqep{ }kde* n} K
nt tbeg, Tbel mnge tbe }huld ha mbnttepkli nld jnuibtep*nld tbepe nvvphnmbed tyh jhqej{ ikpj}* ha n`hut }eqelteel
hp ekibteel {enp} hjd* dpe}}ed enmb kl n }hpt ha jklel
in`epdkle* yktb n ikpdje phuld tbe ynk}t, Tbe{ }ny ge, K
}nt ~ukte }tkjj nld jhhced nt tbeg* dnzzjed yktb tbekp
ertpege `enut{, Ahp n ghgelt tbe{ jhhced nt ge nld nt
enmb htbep kl ipent ngnzegelt3 tbel tbe{ inqe n jkttjeapkibteled mp{ nld pnl haa n} bnpd n} tbe{ mhujd,
‒]h tbnt‛} tbnt*‛ }nkd K th g{}eja* n} K yntmbed tbeg
}mngvepkli, K cley tbnt K bnd `ettep }tn{ ybepe K yn} nld
geet g{ ante* ybnteqep kt yn} th `e* nld eqel ka tbepe
yepe n `ettep mhup}e* K bnd lh }tpelitb jeat th tnce kt, K
gu}t mhge klth mhltnmt yktb tbe klbn`ktnlt} }hhlep hp jntep* nld kt gkibt n} yejj `e }hhlep, @ettep lht th }eeg
napnkd ha tbeg* n} K }bhujd dh `{ pullkli nyn{ nld `ekli
mnuibt yktb n bue nld mp{ th'ghpphy hp lert dn{, ]h K
pegnkled ~ukte }tkjj nld ynkted, Kl n`hut nl bhup K benpd
dk}tnlt qhkme} tnjckli ermktedj{* nld kl n aey gklute} K }ny
tbe tyh ikpj} `pklikli uv n vnpt{ ha }kr hp }eqel gel* yejj
npged yktb `hy} nld npphy} nld vkce}, Tbepe yn}
lhtbkli ahp kt* }h K pegnkled }kttkli ~ukte }tkjj* eqel natep
tbe{ bnd }eel ge* ultkj tbe{ mnge mjh}e uv, Tbel ye njj
bnd n ihhd jhhc nt hle nlhtbep,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 68/378
Epeybhl
12 ha =9;
@htb tbe ikpj} nld tbe gel yepe qep{ dnpc kl mhjhup*
`ut lht ghpe }h tbnl tbe ]hutb Ktnjknl} hp ]vnlknpd}, Tbegel yhpe lh tphu}ep}* `ut yepe dpe}}ed lenpj{ tbe }nge n}
tbe Npn`} ybhg K bnqe }eel kl Njiepkn, Tbe{ yepe ha tbe
gh}t gnilkakmelt vpe}elme* `ekli lh je}} }tphli nld
bnld}hge tbnl tbe yhgel yepe `enutkauj3 nld lht hlj{
tbk}* `ut tbekp ervpe}}khl yn} mhuptehu} nld `elkil, K
tbklc tbe{ yhujd bnqe ckjjed ge nt hlme ka K bnd gnde tbe}jkibte}t }bhy ha qkhjelme3 `ut tbe{ inqe ge lh kgvpe}}khl
ha tbekp `ekli jkcej{ th bupt ge }h jhli n} K yn} ~uket, K
ng lht gumb ikqel th jkckli nl{`hd{ nt akp}t }kibt* `ut
tbe}e vehvje kgvpe}}ed ge gumb ghpe anqhupn`j{ tbnl K
}bhujd bnqe tbhuibt vh}}k`je* }h tbnt K mhujd lht aenp tbeg
n} K }mnlled tbekp anme} hle natep nlhtbep, Tbe{ yepe njjvhyepauj gel, K gkibt bnqe `eel n gntmb ahp nl{ hle ha
tbeg }klij{* ahp K bnqe `eel thjd tbnt K bnqe ghpe th ijhp{
kl tbe aje}b tbnl kl nl{ htbep pe}vemt* `ekli hqep }kr aeet
nld vphvhptkhlntej{ }tphli3 `ut nl{ tyh mhujd bnqe }hhl
gn}teped ge* eqel yepe K lht }h `epeat ha elepi{ `{ g{
pemelt ndqeltupe}, G{ mhjhup }eeged th }upvpk}e tbeg
gh}t* ahp K bnqe jkibt bnkp* `jue e{e}* nld n ape}b
mhgvjerkhl, Tbe{ mhujd lht uldep}tnld bhy tbe}e tbkli}
mhujd `e3 g{ mjhtbe} nj}h }eeged ~ukte `e{hld tbeg,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 69/378
Epeybhl
1; ha =9;
Tbekp e{e} cevt ynldepkli njj hqep ge* nld tbe ghpe tbe{
jhhced tbe je}} tbe{ }eeged n`je th gnce ge hut,Nt jn}t K pnk}ed g{}eja uvhl g{ aeet* nld jenlkli uvhl
g{ }tkmc* K }vhce ybnteqep mnge klth g{ bend th tbe gnl
ybh }eeged ahpegh}t nghli tbeg, K }vhce kl Elijk}b*
tbhuib K yn} qep{ }upe tbnt be yhujd lht uldep}tnld, K
}nkd tbnt K bnd lh kden ybnt mhultp{ K yn} kl3 tbnt K bnd
}tug`jed uvhl kt njgh}t `{ nmmkdelt* natep n }epke} ha bnkp`pendtb e}mnve}3 nld tbnt K tpu}ted tbe{ yhujd lht
njjhy nl{ eqkj th hqeptnce ge lhy tbnt K yn} mhgvjetej{
nt tbekp gepm{, Njj tbk} K }nkd ~uketj{ nld akpgj{* yktb
bnpdj{ nl{ mbnlie ha ervpe}}khl, Tbe{ mhujd lht
uldep}tnld ge* `ut tbe{ jhhced nvvphqklij{ th hle
nlhtbep* nld }eeged vjen}ed }h K tbhuibt+ tbnt K }bhyedlh aenp lhp nmclhyjedigelt ha klaepkhpkt{—tbe anmt `ekli
tbnt K yn} erbnu}ted `e{hld tbe }el}e ha aenp, Tbel hle ha
tbeg vhklted th tbe ghultnkl* kl tbe dkpemtkhl ha tbe
}tntue}* nld gnde n ipkgnme kl kgktntkhl ha hle ha tbeg, K
jnuibed nld }buddeped ervpe}}kqej{* ybepehl tbe{ njj
`up}t hut jnuibkli thh* nld mbntteped bnpd th hle nlhtbep,
K mhujd gnce hut lhtbkli ha ybnt tbe{ }nkd* `ut K tbklc
tbe{ tbhuibt kt pntbep n ihhd ohce tbnt K bnd mhge vn}t tbe
}tntue}, Tbel hle nghli tbeg mnge ahpynpd nld
ghtkhled ge th ahjjhy* ybkmb K dkd yktbhut be}ktntkhl*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 70/378
Epeybhl
96 ha =9;
ahp K dnped lht tbynpt tbeg3 ghpehqep* K jkced tbeg yejj
elhuib* nld aejt thjepn`j{ }upe tbnt tbe{ bnd lh klteltkhlha buptkli ge,
Kl n`hut n ~unptep ha nl bhup ye iht th n }gnjj Bngjet
`ukjt hl tbe }kde ha n bkjj* yktb n lnpphy }tpeet nld bhu}e}
buddjed uv thietbep, Tbe phha} yepe jnpie nld
hqepbnlikli, ]hge aey ykldhy} yepe ijnzed* `ut lht
gnl{, Njthietbep tbe qkjjnie yn} ermeedklij{ jkce hle ha tbh}e tbnt hle mhge} uvhl kl de}meldkli tbe je}} clhyl
vn}}e} hqep tbe Njv} hl th Jhg`npd{, K ykjj vn}} hqep tbe
ermktegelt ybkmb g{ nppkqnj mnu}ed, ]uaakme kt* tbnt
tbhuib tbepe yn} n`uldnlme ha mupkh}kt{* tbepe yn} lh
pudele}}, K yn} tncel th tbe vpklmkvnj bhu}e* ybkmb
}eeged th `ejhli th tbe vehvje ybh bnd mnvtuped ge,Tbepe K yn} bh}vktn`j{ elteptnkled* nld n }uvvep ha gkjc
nld ihnt‛} aje}b yktb n ckld ha hntmnce yn} }et `eahpe ge*
ha ybkmb K nte benptkj{, @ut njj tbe tkge K yn} entkli K
mhujd lht bejv tuplkli g{ e{e} uvhl tbe tyh `enutkauj
ikpj} ybhg K bnd akp}t }eel* nld ybh }eeged th mhl}kdep
ge n} tbekp jnyauj vpkze—ybkmb kldeed K yn}* ahp K yhujd
bnqe ihle tbphuib akpe nld yntep ahp ektbep ha tbeg,
Tbel mnge tbe kleqktn`je }upvpk}e nt }eekli ge }ghce*
ybkmb K ykjj }vnpe tbe pendep3 `ut K lhtkmed tbnt ybel tbe{
}ny ge }tpkce n gntmb* tbepe yn} n bu``u` ha ermktegelt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 71/378
Epeybhl
9> ha =9;
ybkmb* kt }tpumc ge* yn} lht njthietbep ulgkred yktb
dk}nvvphqnj? yb{* K mhujd lht iue}}, Tbel tbe yhgelpetkped* nld K yn} jeat njhle yktb tbe gel* ybh tpked th
tnjc th ge kl eqep{ mhlmekqn`je yn{3 `ut ye mhujd mhge
th lh uldep}tnldkli* ermevt tbnt K yn} ~ukte njhle* nld
bnd mhge aphg n jhli yn{ hqep tbe ghultnkl}, Kl tbe
mhup}e ha tkge tbe{ ipey tkped* nld K qep{ }jeev{, K gnde
}kil} n} tbhuib K yhujd }jeev hl tbe ajhhp kl g{ `jnlcet}*`ut tbe{ inqe ge hle ha tbekp `ulc} yktb vjelt{ ha dpked
aepl nld ipn}}* hl th ybkmb K bnd lh }hhlep jnkd g{}eja
tbnl K aejj an}t n}jeev3 lhp dkd K nynce tkjj yejj klth tbe
ahjjhykli dn{* ybel K ahuld g{}eja kl tbe but yktb tyh
gel ceevkli iunpd hqep ge nld nl hjd yhgnl mhhckli,
Ybel K yhce tbe gel }eeged vjen}ed* nld }vhce th gen} tbhuib `kddkli ge ihhd ghplkli kl n vjen}nlt thle,
K yelt hut ha dhhp} th yn}b kl n mpeec ybkmb pnl n aey
{npd} aphg tbe bhu}e, G{ bh}t} yepe n} eliph}}ed yktb ge
n} eqep3 tbe{ leqep thhc tbekp e{e} haa ge* ahjjhykli eqep{
nmtkhl tbnt K dkd* lh gnttep bhy tpkajkli* nld enmb jhhckli
thynpd} tbe htbep ahp bk} hvklkhl nt eqep{ thumb nld tupl,
Tbe{ thhc ipent kltepe}t kl g{ n`jutkhl}* ahp tbe{ }eeged
th bnqe dhu`ted ybetbep K yn} kl njj pe}vemt} bugnl jkce
tbeg}ejqe}, Tbe{ eqel jnkd bhjd ha g{ npg} nld
hqepbnujed tbeg* nld ervpe}}ed nvvphqnj ybel tbe{ }ny
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 72/378
Epeybhl
90 ha =9;
tbnt tbe{ yepe }tphli nld gu}mujnp, Tbe{ lhy erngkled
g{ jei}* nld e}vemknjj{ g{ aeet, Ybel tbe{ de}k}ted tbe{lhdded nvvphqklij{ th enmb htbep3 nld ybel K bnd
mhg`ed nld `pu}bed g{ bnkp* nld ielepnjj{ gnde g{}eja
n} lent nld yejj nppnlied n} mkpmug}tnlme} yhujd njjhy* K
mhujd }ee tbnt tbekp pe}vemt ahp ge klmpen}ed ipentj{* nld
tbnt tbe{ yepe `{ lh genl} }upe tbnt tbe{ bnd tpented ge
yktb }uaakmkelt deaepelme—n gnttep hl ybkmb K ng lhtmhgvetelt th demkde, Njj K clhy k} tbnt tbe{ yepe qep{
ihhd th ge* ahp ybkmb K tbnlced tbeg benptkj{* n} kt gkibt
yejj bnqe `eel htbepyk}e,
Ahp g{ hyl vnpt* K jkced tbeg nld ndgkped tbeg* ahp
tbekp ~uket }eja'vh}}e}}khl nld dkilkaked en}e kgvpe}}ed ge
vjen}upn`j{ nt hlme, Lektbep dkd tbekp gnllep gnce geaeej n} tbhuib K yepe vep}hlnjj{ dk}tn}teauj th tbeg—hlj{
tbnt K yn} n tbkli uttepj{ ley nld uljhhced ahp* ybkmb
tbe{ mhujd lht mhgvpebeld, Tbekp t{ve yn} ghpe tbnt ha
tbe gh}t ph`u}t Ktnjknl} tbnl nl{ htbep3 tbekp gnllep} nj}h
yepe egkleltj{ Ktnjknl* kl tbekp eltkpe ulmhl}mkhu}le}} ha
}eja, Bnqkli tpnqejjed n ihhd denj kl Ktnj{* K yn} }tpumc
yktb jkttje ie}tupe} ha tbe bnld nld }bhujdep}* ybkmb
mhl}tnltj{ pegklded ge ha tbnt mhultp{, G{ aeejkli yn}
tbnt g{ yk}e}t vjnl yhujd `e th ih hl n} K bnd `eiul* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 73/378
Epeybhl
9= ha =9;
`e }kgvj{ g{}eja ahp `ettep hp yhp}e* }umb n} K yn}* nld
tnce g{ mbnlme nmmhpdklij{,K tbhuibt ha tbe}e tbkli} ybkje tbe{ yepe ynktkli ahp
ge th bnqe dhle yn}bkli* nld hl g{ yn{ `nmc, Tbel
tbe{ inqe ge `pencan}t—bht `pend nld gkjc* nld apked
aje}b ha }hgetbkli `etyeel gutthl nld qelk}hl, Tbekp
yn{} ha mhhckli nld entkli yepe Euphvenl* tbhuib tbe{
bnd hlj{ n }ceyep ahp n ahpc* nld n }hpt ha `utmbep‛} clkaeth mut yktb, Tbe ghpe K jhhced nt eqep{tbkli kl tbe
bhu}e* tbe ghpe K yn} }tpumc yktb kt} ~un}k'Euphvenl
mbnpnmtep3 nld bnd tbe ynjj} hlj{ `eel vn}ted hqep yktb
ertpnmt} aphg tbe Kjju}tpnted Jhldhl Ley} nld Vulmb* K
mhujd bnqe njgh}t anlmked g{}eja kl n }bevbepd‛} but uvhl
g{ gn}tep‛} }beev'pul, Nld {et eqep{tbkli yn} }jkibtj{dkaaepelt, Kt yn} gumb tbe }nge yktb tbe `kpd} nld ajhyep}
hl tbe htbep }kde* n} mhgvnped yktb tbe Elijk}b hle}, Hl
g{ nppkqnj K bnd `eel vjen}ed nt lhtkmkli tbnt lenpj{ njj tbe
vjnlt} nld `kpd} yepe qep{ jkce mhgghl Elijk}b hle}?
tbu}* tbepe yn} n ph`kl* nld n jnpc* nld n ypel* nld dnk}ke}*
nld dnldejkhl}3 lht ~ukte tbe }nge n} tbe Elijk}b* `ut }tkjj
qep{ jkce tbeg—~ukte jkce elhuib th `e mnjjed `{ tbe
}nge lnge3 }h lhy* bepe* tbe yn{} ha tbe}e tyh gel* nld
tbe tbkli} tbe{ bnd kl tbe bhu}e* yepe njj qep{ lenpj{ tbe
}nge n} kl Euphve, Kt yn} lht nt njj jkce ihkli th Mbkln hp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 74/378
Epeybhl
94 ha =9;
Onvnl* ybepe eqep{tbkli tbnt hle }ee} k} }tpnlie, K yn}*
kldeed* nt hlme }tpumc yktb tbe vpkgktkqe mbnpnmtep ha tbekp nvvjknlme}* ahp tbe{ }eeged th `e }hge akqe hp }kr buldped
{enp} `ebkld Euphve kl tbekp klqeltkhl}3 `ut tbk} k} tbe
mn}e kl gnl{ nl Ktnjknl qkjjnie,
Njj tbe tkge tbnt K yn} entkli g{ `pencan}t K cevt
}vemujntkli n} th ybnt angkj{ ha gnlckld tbe{ mhujd
`ejhli th3 nld }bhptj{ tbepe mnge nl kden klth g{ bend*ybkmb `phuibt tbe `jhhd klth g{ mbeec} yktb ermktegelt
n} K tbhuibt ha kt, Yn} kt vh}}k`je tbnt tbe{ gkibt `e tbe
jh}t tel tpk`e} ha K}pnej* ha ybhg K bnd benpd `htb g{
ipnldantbep nld g{ antbep gnce geltkhl n} erk}tkli kl nl
ulclhyl mhultp{* nld nynktkli n aklnj petupl th Vnje}tkle8
Yn} kt vh}}k`je tbnt K gkibt bnqe `eel de}kiled `{Vphqkdelme n} tbe kl}tpugelt ha tbekp mhlqep}khl8 Hb*
ybnt n tbhuibt yn} tbk}. K jnkd dhyl g{ }ceyep nld inqe
tbeg n bn}t{ }upqe{, Tbepe yn} lhtbkli ha n Oeyk}b t{ve
n`hut tbeg? tbekp lh}e} yepe dk}tklmtj{ Ipemknl* nld tbekp
jkv}* tbhuib aujj* yepe lht Oeyk}b,
Bhy mhujd K }ettje tbk} ~ue}tkhl8 K cley lektbep Ipeec
lhp Be`pey* nld eqel ka K }bhujd iet th uldep}tnld tbe
jnliunie bepe }vhcel* K }bhujd `e uln`je th detemt tbe
phht} ha ektbep ha tbe}e thliue}, K bnd lht `eel jhli
elhuib nghli tbeg th n}meptnkl tbekp bn`kt}* `ut tbe{ dkd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 75/378
Epeybhl
95 ha =9;
lht ikqe ge tbe kgvpe}}khl ha `ekli n pejkikhu} vehvje,
Tbk} thh yn} lntupnj? tbe tel tpk`e} bnd `eel njyn{}jngeltn`j{ kppejkikhu}, @ut mhujd K lht gnce tbeg mbnlie8
Th pe}thpe tbe jh}t tel tpk`e} ha K}pnej th n clhyjedie ha
tbe hlj{ tputb? bepe yhujd `e kldeed nl kgghptnj mphyl
ha ijhp{. G{ benpt `ent an}t nld aupkhu} n} K elteptnkled tbe
tbhuibt, Ybnt n vh}ktkhl yhujd kt lht el}upe ge kl tbe
lert yhpjd3 hp vepbnv} eqel kl tbk}. Ybnt ahjj{ kt yhujd`e th tbphy }umb n mbnlme nyn{. K }bhujd pnlc lert th tbe
Nvh}tje}* ka lht n} bkib n} tbe{—meptnklj{ n`hqe tbe gklhp
vphvbet}* nld vh}}k`j{ n`hqe nl{ Hjd Te}tngelt ypktep
ermevt Gh}e} nld K}nknb, Ahp }umb n autupe n} tbk} K yhujd
}nmpkakme njj tbnt K bnqe yktbhut n ghgelt‛} be}ktntkhl*
mhujd K `e pen}hln`j{ n}}uped ha kt, K bnd njyn{} mhpdknjj{nvvphqed ha gk}}khlnp{ eaahpt}* nld bnd nt tkge}
mhltpk`uted g{ gkte thynpd} tbekp }uvvhpt nld ertel}khl3
`ut K bnd leqep bktbepth aejt dpnyl thynpd} `emhgkli n
gk}}khlnp{ g{}eja3 nld kldeed bnd njyn{} ndgkped* nld
elqked* nld pe}vemted tbeg* ghpe tbnl K bnd ernmtj{ jkced
tbeg, @ut ka tbe}e vehvje yepe tbe jh}t tel tpk`e} ha K}pnej*
tbe mn}e yhujd `e ykdej{ dkaaepelt? tbe hvelkli yn} thh
ermejjelt th `e jh}t* nld K pe}hjqed tbnt }bhujd K }ee
kldkmntkhl} ybkmb nvvenped th mhlakpg g{ kgvpe}}khl tbnt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 76/378
Epeybhl
91 ha =9;
K bnd kldeed mhge uvhl tbe gk}}kli tpk`e}* K yhujd
meptnklj{ mhlqept tbeg,K gn{ bepe geltkhl tbnt tbk} dk}mhqep{ k} tbe hle th
ybkmb K njjuded kl tbe hvelkli vnie} ha g{ }thp{, Tkge
}tpelitbeled tbe kgvpe}}khl gnde uvhl ge nt akp}t3 nld*
tbhuib K pegnkled kl dhu`t ahp }eqepnj ghltb}* K aeej lhy
lh jhliep ulmeptnkl,
Ybel K bnd dhle entkli* g{ bh}t} nvvphnmbed* nldvhklted dhyl tbe qnjje{ jendkli th tbekp hyl mhultp{* n}
tbhuib ynltkli th }bhy tbnt K gu}t ih yktb tbeg3 nt tbe
}nge tkge tbe{ jnkd bhjd ha g{ npg}* nld gnde n} tbhuib
tbe{ yhujd tnce ge* `ut u}ed lh qkhjelme, K jnuibed* nld
ghtkhled g{ bnld nmph}} g{ tbphnt* vhkltkli dhyl tbe
qnjje{ n} tbhuib K yn} napnkd je}t K }bhujd `e ckjjed ybel Kiht tbepe, @ut tbe{ dkqkled ge nt hlme* nld }bhhc tbekp
bend} yktb gumb demk}khl* th }bhy tbnt K yn} kl lh
dnliep, Tbekp gnllep ~ukte pen}}uped ge3 nld kl bnja nl
bhup hp }h K bnd vnmced uv g{ }yni* nld yn} eniep ahp
tbe ahpynpd ohuple{* aeejkli yhldepaujj{ }tpelitbeled nld
peape}bed `{ ihhd ahhd nld }jeev* ybkje g{ bhve nld
mupkh}kt{ yepe nphu}ed th tbekp qep{ utgh}t `{ tbe
ertpnhpdklnp{ vh}ktkhl kl ybkmb K ahuld g{}eja,
@ut njpend{ g{ ermktegelt bnd `eiul th mhhj nld K
peajemted tbnt tbe}e vehvje gkibt lht `e tbe tel tpk`e} natep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 77/378
Epeybhl
99 ha =9;
njj3 kl ybkmb mn}e K mhujd lht `ut peipet tbnt g{ bhve} ha
gnckli ghle{* ybkmb bnd jed ge klth }h gumb tphu`jenld dnliep* yepe njgh}t nllkbkjnted `{ tbe anmt tbnt tbe
mhultp{ yn} aujj th hqepajhykli* yktb n vehvje ybh bnd
vph`n`j{ njpend{ deqejhved kt} ghpe nqnkjn`je pe}hupme},
Ghpehqep* bhy yn} K th iet `nmc8 Ahp tbepe yn}
}hgetbkli n`hut g{ bh}t} ybkmb thjd ge tbnt tbe{ bnd
iht ge* nld genlt th ceev ge* kl }vkte ha njj tbekp ihhdle}},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 78/378
Epeybhl
92 ha =9;
MBNVTEP QKK? AKP]T KGVPE]]KHL]
Ye ahjjhyed nl Njvkle vntb ahp }hge ahup gkje}* lhy
buldped} ha aeet n`hqe n `pnyjkli }tpeng ybkmb de}melded
aphg tbe ijnmkep}* nld lhy lenpj{ njhli}kde kt, Tbe
ghplkli yn} mhjd nld }hgeybnt ahii{* ahp tbe nutugl
bnd gnde ipent }tpkde} jnttepj{, ]hgetkge} ye yelt
tbphuib ahpe}t} ha vkle* hp pntbep {ey tpee}* tbhuib tbe{
jhhced jkce vkle3 nld K pegeg`ep tbnt lhy nld ninkl ye
vn}}ed n jkttje yn{}kde }bpkle* ybepekl tbepe yhujd `e n
}tntue ha ipent `enut{* pevpe}eltkli }hge akiupe* gnje hp
aegnje* kl tbe qep{ be{dn{ ha {hutb* }tpelitb* nld `enut{*
hp ha tbe gh}t dkilkaked gntupkt{ nld hjd nie, G{ bh}t}
njyn{} `hyed tbekp bend} n} tbe{ vn}}ed hle ha tbe}e
}bpkle}* nld kt }bhmced ge th }ee }tntue} tbnt bnd lh
nvvnpelt h`oemt* `e{hld tbe mbphlkmjkli ha }hge ulu}unj
kldkqkdunj ermejjelme hp `enut{* pemekqe }h }epkhu} n
bhgnie, Bhyeqep* K }bhyed lh }kil ha yhldep hp
dk}nvvphqnj3 ahp K pegeg`eped tbnt th `e njj tbkli} th njj
gel yn} hle ha tbe kloulmtkhl} ha tbe Ieltkje Nvh}tje*
ybkmb ahp tbe vpe}elt K }bhujd dh yejj th beed, ]bhptj{
natep vn}}kli hle ha tbe}e mbnvej} ye mnge }uddelj{ uvhl
n qkjjnie ybkmb }tnpted uv hut ha tbe gk}t3 nld K yn}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 79/378
Epeybhl
9; ha =9;
njnpged je}t K }bhujd `e gnde nl h`oemt ha mupkh}kt{ hp
dk}jkce, @ut kt yn} lht }h, G{ iukde} }vhce th gnl{ klvn}}kli* nld tbh}e }vhcel th }bhyed gumb ngnzegelt,
G{ iukde}* bhyeqep* yepe yejj clhyl* nld tbe lntupnj
vhjktele}} ha tbe vehvje vpeqelted tbeg aphg vuttkli ge
th nl{ klmhlqelkelme3 `ut tbe{ mhujd lht bejv e{ekli ge*
lhp K tbeg, K gn{ n} yejj }n{ nt hlme ybnt g{ natep'
ervepkelme tnuibt ge—lngej{* tbnt yktb njj tbekp anujt}nld ertpnhpdklnp{ h`jk~ukt{ ha geltnj qk}khl uvhl gnl{
}u`oemt}* tbe{ npe tbe qep{ `e}t'`ped vehvje tbnt K eqep aejj
kl yktb,
Tbe qkjjnie yn} ou}t jkce tbe hle ye bnd jeat* hlj{
pntbep jnpiep, Tbe }tpeet} yepe lnpphy nld ulvnqed* `ut
qep{ ankpj{ mjenl, Tbe qkle ipey hut}kde gnl{ ha tbebhu}e}3 nld tbepe yepe }hge yktb }kil'`hnpd}* hl ybkmb
yn} vnklted n `httje nld n ijn}}* tbnt gnde ge aeej gumb nt
bhge, Eqel hl tbk} jedie ha bugnl }hmket{ tbepe yn} n
}tulted iphytb ha }bhvjet}* ybkmb bnd tncel phht nld
qeietnted }hgebhy* tbhuib n} kl nl nkp gepmnltkje ha tbe
`jence}t, Kt yn} bepe n} bktbepth? njj tbkli} yepe ielepkmnjj{
tbe }nge n} kl Euphve* tbe dkaaepelme} `ekli ha }vemke}
hlj{3 nld K yn} ngu}ed nt }eekli kl n ykldhy }hge
`httje} yktb `npje{'}uinp nld }yeetgent} ahp mbkjdpel* n} nt
bhge3 `ut tbe `npje{'}uinp yn} kl vjnte}* lht kl tyk}ted
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 80/378
Epeybhl
26 ha =9;
}tkmc}* nld yn} mhjhuped `jue, Ijn}} yn} vjeltkauj kl tbe
`ettep bhu}e},Jn}tj{* K }bhujd }n{ tbnt tbe vehvje yepe ha n vb{}kmnj
`enut{ ybkmb yn} }kgvj{ ngnzkli, K leqep }ny nl{tbkli kl
tbe jen}t mhgvnpn`je th tbeg, Tbe yhgel yepe qkihphu}*
nld bnd n gh}t gnoe}tkm inkt* tbekp bend} `ekli }et uvhl
tbekp }bhujdep} yktb n ipnme `e{hld njj vhyep ha
ervpe}}khl, Enmb aentupe yn} aklk}bed* e{ejkd}* e{ejn}be}*nld enp} `ekli njgh}t klqnpkn`j{ vepaemt, Tbekp mhjhup yn}
e~unj th tbnt ha tbe akle}t Ktnjknl vnkltkli}3 `ekli ha tbe
mjenpe}t hjkqe* nld {et pudd{ yktb n ijhy ha vepaemt benjtb,
Tbekp ervpe}}khl yn} dkqkle3 nld n} tbe{ ijnlmed nt ge
tkgkdj{ `ut yktb vnpted jkv} kl ipent `eykjdepgelt* K
ahpiht njj tbhuibt} ha tbekp mhlqep}khl kl aeejkli} tbnt yepeanp ghpe enptbj{, K yn} dnzzjed n} K }ny hle natep tbe htbep*
ha ybhg K mhujd hlj{ aeej tbnt enmb yn} tbe jhqejke}t K bnd
eqep }eel, Eqel kl gkddje nie tbe{ yepe }tkjj mhgej{* nld
tbe hjd ipe{'bnkped yhgel nt tbekp mhttnie dhhp} bnd n
dkilkt{* lht th }n{ gnoe}t{* ha tbekp hyl,
Tbe gel yepe n} bnld}hge n} tbe yhgel `enutkauj, K
bnqe njyn{} dejkibted kl nld peqepelmed `enut{3 `ut K aejt
}kgvj{ n`n}bed kl tbe vpe}elme ha }umb n }vjeldkd t{ve—n
mhgvhuld ha njj tbnt k} `e}t kl Ei{vtknl* Ipeec nld
Ktnjknl, Tbe mbkjdpel yepe klaklkte kl lug`ep* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 81/378
Epeybhl
2> ha =9;
ermeedklij{ gepp{3 K leed bnpdj{ }n{ tbnt tbe{ mnge kl ahp
tbekp aujj }bnpe ha tbe vpeqnkjkli `enut{, K ervpe}}ed `{}kil} g{ ndgkpntkhl nld vjen}upe th g{ iukde}* nld tbe{
yepe ipentj{ vjen}ed, K }bhujd ndd tbnt njj }eeged th tnce n
vpkde kl tbekp vep}hlnj nvvenpnlme* nld tbnt eqel tbe
vhhpe}t nld lhle }eeged pkmb+ yepe yejj cegvt nld tkd{,
K mhujd akjj gnl{ vnie} yktb n de}mpkvtkhl ha tbekp dpe}} nld
tbe hplngelt} ybkmb tbe{ yhpe* nld n buldped detnkj}ybkmb }tpumc ge yktb njj tbe ahpme ha lhqejt{3 `ut K gu}t
lht }tn{ th dh }h,
Ybel ye bnd iht vn}t tbe qkjjnie tbe ahi ph}e* nld
peqenjed gnilkakmelt qkey} ha tbe }lhy{ ghultnkl} nld
tbekp lenpep n`utgelt}* ybkje kl aphlt K mhujd lhy nld
ninkl mntmb ijkgv}e} ha tbe ipent vjnkl} ybkmb K bnd}upqe{ed hl tbe vpemedkli eqelkli, Tbe mhultp{ yn}
bkibj{ mujtkqnted* eqep{ jedie `ekli vjnlted yktb
mbe}tlut}* ynjlut}* nld nvvje'tpee} aphg ybkmb tbe nvvje}
yepe lhy intbepkli, Ihnt} yepe n`uldnlt3 nj}h n ckld ha
}gnjj `jnmc mnttje* kl tbe gnp}be} lenp tbe pkqep* ybkmb yn}
lhy an}t ykdelkli* nld pullkli `etyeel jnpiep ajnt} aphg
ybkmb tbe bkjj} pemeded ghpe nld ghpe, K }ny n aey }beev
yktb phulded lh}e} nld elhpghu} tnkj}, Dhi} yepe tbepe
kl vjelt{* nld qep{ Elijk}b3 `ut K }ny lh mnt}* lhp kldeed
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 82/378
Epeybhl
20 ha =9;
npe tbe}e mpentupe} clhyl* tbekp vjnme `ekli }uvvjked `{ n
}hpt ha }gnjj teppkep,Kl n`hut ahup bhup} ha ynjckli aphg tbe tkge ye
}tnpted* nld natep vn}}kli tyh hp tbpee ghpe qkjjnie}* ye
mnge uvhl n mhl}kdepn`je thyl* nld g{ iukde} gnde
gnl{ nttegvt} th gnce ge uldep}tnld }hgetbkli* `ut K
intbeped lh klcjkli ha tbekp genlkli* ermevt tbnt K leed
`e uldep lh nvvpebel}khl ha dnliep, K ykjj }vnpe tbependep nl{ de}mpkvtkhl ha tbe thyl* nld yhujd hlj{ `kd
bkg tbklc ha Dhghdh}}hjn hp Ankdh, ]uaakme kt tbnt K ahuld
g{}eja tncel `eahpe tbe mbkea gnik}tpnte* nld `{ bk} hpdep}
yn} vjnmed kl nl nvnptgelt yktb tyh htbep vehvje* ybh
yepe tbe akp}t K bnd }eel jhhckli nl{tbkli `ut yejj nld
bnld}hge, Kl anmt* hle ha tbeg yn} vjnklj{ qep{ gumb hutha benjtb* nld mhuibed qkhjeltj{ aphg tkge th tkge kl }vkte
ha gnlkae}t eaahpt} th }uvvpe}} kt, Tbe htbep jhhced vnje
nld kjj `ut be yn} gnpqejjhu}j{ }eja'mhltnkled* nld kt yn}
kgvh}}k`je th }n{ ybnt yn} tbe gnttep yktb bkg, @htb ha
tbeg nvvenped n}thlk}bed nt }eekli hle ybh yn} eqkdeltj{
n }tpnliep* `ut tbe{ yepe thh kjj th mhge uv th ge* nld
ahpg mhlmju}khl} mhlmeplkli ge, Tbe}e tyh yepe akp}t
mnjjed hut3 nld kl n`hut n ~unptep ha nl bhup K yn} gnde
th ahjjhy tbeg* ybkmb K dkd kl }hge aenp* nld yktb gumb
mupkh}kt{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 83/378
Epeybhl
2= ha =9;
Tbe mbkea gnik}tpnte yn} n qelepn`je'jhhckli gnl*
yktb ybkte bnkp nld `enpd nld n anme ha ipent }ninmkt{, Bejhhced ge njj hqep ahp n`hut akqe gklute}* jettkli bk} e{e}
ynldep aphg tbe mphyl ha g{ bend th tbe }hje} ha g{
aeet* uv nld dhyl* nld dhyl nld uv3 lektbep dkd bk} gkld
}eeg kl tbe jen}t mjenpep ybel be bnd dhle jhhckli tbnl
ybel be `einl, Be nt jelitb n}ced ge n }klije }bhpt
~ue}tkhl* ybkmb K }uvvh}ed genlt ‒Ybh npe {hu8‛ Knl}yeped kl Elijk}b ~ukte mhgvh}edj{ n} tbhuib be yhujd
uldep}tnld ge* nld eldenqhuped th `e g{ qep{ gh}t
lntupnj }eja n} yejj n} K mhujd, Be nvvenped ghpe nld ghpe
vuzzjed* nld tbel petkped* petuplkli yktb tyh htbep} gumb
jkce bkg}eja, Tbel tbe{ thhc ge klth nl kllep phhg* nld
tbe tyh ape}b nppkqnj} }tpkvved ge* ybkje tbe mbkea jhhcedhl, Tbe{ aejt g{ vuj}e* tbe{ jhhced nt g{ thliue* tbe{
jk}teled nt g{ mbe}t* tbe{ aejt njj g{ gu}mje}3 nld nt tbe
eld ha enmb hvepntkhl tbe{ jhhced nt tbe mbkea nld
lhdded* nld }nkd }hgetbkli kl n thle ~ukte vjen}nlt* n}
tbhuib K yepe njj pkibt, Tbe{ eqel vujjed dhyl g{
e{ejkd}* nld jhhced* K }uvvh}e* th }ee ka tbe{ yepe
`jhhd}bht3 `ut kt yn} lht }h, Nt jelitb tbe{ inqe uv3 nld K
tbklc tbnt njj yepe }ntk}aked ha g{ `ekli kl tbe gh}t vepaemt
benjtb* nld qep{ ph`u}t th `hht, Nt jn}t tbe hjd gnik}tpnte
gnde ge n }veemb ha n`hut akqe gklute} jhli* ybkmb tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 84/378
Epeybhl
24 ha =9;
htbep tyh nvvenped th tbklc ipentj{ th tbe vhklt* `ut aphg
ybkmb K intbeped lhtbkli, N} }hhl n} kt yn} elded* tbe{vphmeeded th hqepbnuj g{ }yni nld tbe mhltelt} ha g{
vhmcet}, Tbk} inqe ge jkttje ulen}kle}}* ahp K bnd lh
ghle{ yktb ge* lhp nl{tbkli ybkmb tbe{ yepe nt njj
jkcej{ th ynlt* hp ybkmb K mnped n`hut jh}kli, Nt jen}t K
anlmked }h* `ut K }hhl ahuld g{ gk}tnce,
Tbe{ iht hl mhgahptn`j{ nt akp}t* tbhuib tbe{ yepegumb vuzzjed yktb g{ th`nmmh'vkve nld kl}k}ted hl
}eekli ge u}e kt, Ybel K bnd }bhyl tbeg ybnt K dkd yktb
kt* tbe{ yepe n}thlk}bed `ut lht dk}vjen}ed* nld }eeged th
jkce tbe }gejj, @ut `{ nld `{ tbe{ mnge th g{ yntmb*
ybkmb K bnd bkddel nyn{ kl tbe klgh}t vhmcet tbnt K bnd*
nld bnd ahpihttel ybel tbe{ `einl tbekp }enpmb, Tbe{}eeged mhlmepled nld ulen}{ n} }hhl n} tbe{ iht bhjd ha
kt, Tbe{ tbel gnde ge hvel kt nld }bhy tbe yhpc}3 nld
ybel K bnd dhle }h tbe{ inqe }kil} ha qep{ ipnqe
dk}vjen}upe* ybkmb dk}tup`ed ge njj tbe ghpe `emnu}e K
mhujd lht mhlmekqe ybepekl kt mhujd bnqe haaelded tbeg,
K pegeg`ep tbnt ybel tbe{ akp}t ahuld kt K bnd tbhuibt
ha Vnje{* nld bhy be tejj} u} tbnt n }nqnie hl }eekli n
yntmb yhujd nt hlme mhlmjude tbnt kt yn} de}kiled, Tpue*
tbe}e vehvje yepe lht }nqnie}* `ut K lhle tbe je}} aejt }upe
tbnt tbk} yn} tbe mhlmju}khl tbe{ yhujd nppkqe nt3 nld K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 85/378
Epeybhl
25 ha =9;
yn} tbklckli ybnt n yhldepaujj{ yk}e gnl Npmb`k}bhv
Vnje{ gu}t bnqe `eel* ybel K yn} nphu}ed `{ n jhhc ha bhpphp nld dk}gn{ uvhl tbe anme ha tbe gnik}tpnte* n jhhc
ybkmb mhlqe{ed th ge tbe kgvpe}}khl tbnt be peinpded
g{ yntmb lht n} bnqkli `eel de}kiled* `ut pntbep n} tbe
de}kilep ha bkg}eja nld ha tbe ulkqep}e3 hp n} nt nl{ pnte
hle ha tbe ipent akp}t mnu}e} ha njj tbkli},
Tbel kt }tpumc ge tbnt tbk} qkey yn} ~ukte n} jkcej{ th`e tncel n} tbe htbep `{ n vehvje ybh bnd lh ervepkelme
ha Euphvenl mkqkjk}ntkhl* nld K yn} n jkttje vk~ued yktb
Vnje{ ahp bnqkli jed ge }h gumb n}tpn{3 `ut K }hhl
dk}mhqeped tbnt K bnd gk}kltepvpeted tbe ervpe}}khl hl tbe
gnik}tpnte‛} anme* nld tbnt kt yn} hle lht ha aenp* `ut
bntped, Be }vhce th ge }hjeglj{ nld }teplj{ ahp tyh hp tbpee gklute}, Tbel* peajemtkli tbnt tbk} yn} ha lh u}e* be
mnu}ed ge th `e mhldumted tbphuib }eqepnj vn}}nie} klth n
jnpie phhg* ybkmb K natepynpd} ahuld yn} tbe gu}eug ha
tbe thyl* nld ybepekl K `ebejd n }kibt ybkmb n}thlk}bed
ge ghpe tbnl nl{tbkli tbnt K bnd {et }eel,
Kt yn} akjjed yktb mn}e} mhltnklkli njj gnllep ha
mupkh}ktke}—}umb n} }cejethl}* }tuaaed `kpd} nld nlkgnj}*
mnpqkli} kl }thle ybepeha K }ny }eqepnj tbnt yepe jkce
tbh}e hl tbe }nddje* hlj{ }gnjjep+* `ut tbe ipentep vnpt ha
tbe phhg yn} hmmuvked `{ `phcel gnmbklep{ ha njj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 86/378
Epeybhl
21 ha =9;
de}mpkvtkhl}, Tbe jnpiep }vemkgel} bnd n mn}e th
tbeg}ejqe}* nld tkmcet} yktb ypktkli hl tbeg kl nmbnpnmtep ybkmb K mhujd lht uldep}tnld, Tbepe yepe
apnigelt} ha }teng elikle}* njj `phcel nld pu}ted3 nghli
tbeg K }ny n m{jkldep nld vk}thl* n `phcel aj{'ybeej* nld
vnpt ha n mpnlc* ybkmb yn} jnkd hl tbe iphuld `{ tbekp
}kde, Ninkl* tbepe yn} n qep{ hjd mnppknie ybh}e ybeej} kl
}vkte ha pu}t nld demn{* K mhujd }ee* bnd `eel de}kiledhpkiklnjj{ ahp kphl pnkj}, Kldeed* tbepe yepe apnigelt} ha n
ipent gnl{ ha hup hyl gh}t ndqnlmed klqeltkhl}3 `ut
tbe{ }eeged njj th `e }eqepnj buldped {enp} hjd* nld th `e
vjnmed ybepe tbe{ yepe* lht ahp kl}tpumtkhl* `ut mupkh}kt{,
N} K }nkd `eahpe* njj yepe gnpped nld `phcel,
Ye vn}}ed gnl{ mn}e}* nld nt jn}t mnge th hle kl ybkmbtbepe yepe }eqepnj mjhmc} nld tyh hp tbpee hjd yntmbe},
Bepe tbe gnik}tpnte }thvved* nld hvelkli tbe mn}e `einl
mhgvnpkli g{ yntmb yktb tbe htbep}, Tbe de}kil yn}
dkaaepelt* `ut tbe tbkli yn} mjenpj{ tbe }nge, Hl tbk} be
tupled th ge nld gnde ge n }veemb kl n }eqepe nld
klouped thle ha qhkme* vhkltkli peventedj{ th tbe yntmbe}
kl tbe mn}e* nld th g{ hyl3 lektbep dkd be }eeg kl tbe
jen}t nvven}ed ultkj K gnde }kil} th bkg tbnt be bnd `ettep
tnce g{ yntmb nld vut kt yktb tbe htbep}, Tbk} bnd }hge
eaaemt kl mnjgkli bkg, K }nkd kl Elijk}b tpu}tkli th thle
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 87/378
Epeybhl
29 ha =9;
nld gnllep th mhlqe{ g{ genlkli+ tbnt K yn}
ermeedklij{ }hpp{ ka K bnd `eel ahuld th bnqe nl{tbklimhltpn`nld kl g{ vh}}e}}khl3 tbnt K bnd bnd lh klteltkhl
ha eqndkli tbe hpdklnp{ thjj}* nld tbnt K yhujd ijndj{
ahpaekt tbe yntmb ka g{ dhkli }h yhujd nthle ahp nl
ulklteltkhlnj qkhjntkhl ha tbe jny, Be `einl vpe}eltj{ th
pejelt* nld }vhce th ge kl n ckldep gnllep, K tbklc be }ny
tbnt K bnd haaelded yktbhut clhyjedie3 `ut K `ejkeqe tbembkea tbkli tbnt `phuibt bkg phuld yn} g{ lht }eegkli
th `e napnkd ha bkg* njtbhuib K yn} ~ukte pe}vemtauj3 tbk}*
nld g{ bnqkli jkibt bnkp nld mhgvjerkhl* hl ybkmb be
bnd pegnpced vpeqkhu}j{ `{ }kil}* n} eqep{ hle ej}e bnd
dhle,
K natepynpd} ahuld tbnt kt yn} pemchled n qep{ ipentgepkt th bnqe ankp bnkp* tbk} `ekli n tbkli ha tbe pnpe}t
vh}}k`je hmmuppelme* nld ipentj{ ndgkped nld elqked kl njj
ybh yepe vh}}e}}ed ha kt, Bhyeqep tbnt gkibt `e* g{
yntmb yn} tncel aphg ge3 `ut hup venme yn} gnde* nld K
yn} mhldumted `nmc th tbe phhg ybepe K bnd `eel
erngkled, Tbe gnik}tpnte tbel gnde ge nlhtbep }veemb*
ybepehl K yn} tncel th n `ukjdkli bnpd `{* ybkmb K }hhl
dk}mhqeped th `e tbe mhgghl vpk}hl ha tbe thyl* `ut kl
ybkmb nl nvnptgelt yn} n}}kiled ge }evnpnte aphg tbe
htbep vpk}hlep}, Tbe phhg mhltnkled n `ed* tn`je* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 88/378
Epeybhl
22 ha =9;
mbnkp}* nj}h n akpevjnme nld n yn}bkli'}tnld, Tbepe yn}
nlhtbep dhhp* ybkmb hveled hl th n `njmhl{* yktb n ajkibtha }tev} de}meldkli klth n ynjjed inpdel ha }hge }kze, Tbe
gnl ybh mhldumted ge klth tbk} phhg gnde }kil} th ge
tbnt K gkibt ih dhyl nld ynjc kl tbe inpdel ybeleqep K
vjen}ed* nld kltkgnted tbnt K }bhujd }bhptj{ bnqe
}hgetbkli `phuibt ge th ent, K yn} njjhyed th petnkl g{
`jnlcet}* nld tbe aey tbkli} ybkmb K bnd ypnvved kl}kdetbeg* `ut kt yn} vjnkl tbnt K yn} th mhl}kdep g{}eja n
vpk}hlep— ahp bhy jhli n vepkhd K mhujd lht `{ nl{
genl} detepgkle, Be tbel jeat ge njhle,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 89/378
Epeybhl
2; ha =9;
MBNVTEP QKKK? KL VPK]HL
Nld lhy ahp tbe akp}t tkge g{ mhupnie mhgvjetej{
ankjed ge, Kt k} elhuib th }n{ tbnt K yn} vellkje}}* nld n
vpk}hlep kl n ahpekil mhultp{* ybepe K bnd lh apkeld* lhp
nl{ clhyjedie ha tbe mu}thg} hp jnliunie ha tbe vehvje, K
yn} nt tbe gepm{ ha gel yktb ybhg K bnd jkttje kl
mhgghl, Nld {et* eliph}}ed n} K yn} yktb g{ ertpegej{
dkaakmujt nld dhu`tauj vh}ktkhl* K mhujd lht bejv aeejkli
deevj{ kltepe}ted kl tbe vehvje nghli ybhg K bnd anjjel,
Ybnt yn} tbe genlkli ha tbnt phhg aujj ha hjd gnmbklep{
ybkmb K bnd ou}t }eel* nld ha tbe dk}vjen}upe yktb ybkmb
tbe gnik}tpnte bnd peinpded g{ yntmb8 Tbe vehvje bnd
qep{ jkttje gnmbklep{ lhy, K bnd `eel }tpumc yktb tbk}
hqep nld hqep ninkl* tbhuib K bnd lht `eel ghpe tbnl
ahup'nld'tyelt{ bhup} kl tbe mhultp{, Tbe{ yepe n`hut n}
anp ndqnlmed n} Euphvenl} ha tbe tyejatb hp tbkpteeltb
meltup{3 meptnklj{ lht ghpe }h, Nld {et tbe{ gu}t bnqe
bnd nt hle tkge tbe aujje}t clhyjedie ha hup hyl gh}t
pemelt klqeltkhl}, Bhy mhujd kt bnqe bnvveled tbnt
bnqkli `eel hlme }h anp kl ndqnlme tbe{ yepe lhy n}
gumb `ebkld u}8 Kt yn} eqkdelt tbnt kt yn} lht aphg
kilhpnlme, Tbe{ cley g{ yntmb n} n yntmb ybel tbe{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 90/378
Epeybhl
;6 ha =9;
}ny kt3 nld tbe mnpe yktb ybkmb tbe `phcel gnmbkle} yepe
vpe}epqed nld tkmceted* vphqed tbnt tbe{ bnd lht jh}t tbepemhjjemtkhl ha tbekp ahpgep mkqkjk}ntkhl, Tbe ghpe K
tbhuibt* tbe je}} K mhujd uldep}tnld kt3 `ut nt jn}t K
mhlmjuded tbnt tbe{ gu}t bnqe yhpced hut tbekp gkle} ha
mhnj nld kphl* tkjj ektbep lhle yepe jeat* hp }h aey* tbnt tbe
u}e ha tbe}e getnj} yn} pe}tpkmted th tbe qep{ bkibe}t
lh`kjkt{, Tbk} yn} tbe hlj{ }hjutkhl K mhujd tbklc ha3 nld*tbhuib K natepynpd} ahuld bhy eltkpej{ gk}tncel kt yn}* K
aejt ~ukte }upe tbel tbnt kt gu}t `e tbe pkibt hle,
K bnd bnpdj{ nppkqed nt tbk} hvklkhl ahp n`hqe ahup hp
akqe gklute}* ybel tbe dhhp hveled* nld n {huli yhgnl
gnde bep nvvenpnlme yktb n tpn{* nld n qep{ nvvetk}kli
}gejj ha dkllep, K inzed uvhl bep yktb ndgkpntkhl n} }bejnkd n mjhtb nld }et n }nqhup{'jhhckli dk}b uvhl tbe tn`je,
N} K `ebejd bep K aejt n} tbhuib g{ vh}ktkhl yn} njpend{
gumb ngejkhpnted* ahp tbe qep{ }kibt ha bep mnppked ipent
mhgahpt, ]be yn} lht ghpe tbnl tyelt{* pntbep n`hqe tbe
gkddje bekibt* nmtkqe nld }tphli* `ut {et gh}t dejkmntej{
aentuped3 bep jkv} yepe aujj nld }yeet3 bep e{e} yepe ha n
deev bnzej* nld apklied yktb jhli nld }vpklikli e{ejn}be}3
bep bnkp yn} lentj{ `pnkded aphg haa bep ahpebend3 bep
mhgvjerkhl yn} }kgvj{ er~uk}kte3 bep akiupe n} ph`u}t n}
yn} mhl}k}telt yktb tbe gh}t vepaemt aegnje `enut{* {et
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 91/378
Epeybhl
;> ha =9;
lht ghpe }h3 bep bnld} nld aeet gkibt bnqe }epqed n}
ghdej} th n }mujvthp, Bnqkli }et tbe }tey uvhl tbe tn`je*}be petkped yktb n ijnlme ha vkt{* ybepehl pegeg`epkli
vkt{‛} ckl}gnl+ K demkded tbnt }be }bhujd vkt{ ge n jkttje
ghpe, ]be petupled yktb n `httje nld n ijn}}* nld ahuld
ge }kttkli hl tbe `ed yktb g{ bnld} hqep g{ anme*
jhhckli tbe qep{ vkmtupe ha n`oemt gk}ep{* nld* jkce njj
vkmtupe}* pntbep ultputbauj, N} K yntmbed bep* tbphuib g{akliep}* hut ha tbe phhg ninkl* K aejt }upe tbnt }be yn}
ermeedklij{ }hpp{ ahp ge, Bep `nmc `ekli tupled* K }et th
yhpc nld nte g{ dkllep* ybkmb yn} ermejjelt,
]be petupled kl n`hut nl bhup th tnce nyn{3 nld tbepe
mnge yktb bep n gnl ybh bnd n ipent `ulmb ha ce{} nt bk}
ynk}t* nld ybh}e gnllep mhlqklmed ge tbnt be yn} tbe onkjhp, K natepynpd} ahuld tbnt be yn} antbep th tbe `enutkauj
mpentupe ybh bnd `phuibt ge g{ dkllep, K ng lht n
gumb ipentep b{vhmpkte tbnl htbep vehvje* nld dh ybnt K
yhujd* K mhujd lht jhhc }h qep{ gk}epn`je, K bnd njpend{
pemhqeped aphg g{ deoemtkhl* nld aejt kl n gh}t ielknj
bughup `htb yktb g{ onkjhp nld bk} dnuibtep, K tbnlced
tbeg ahp tbekp ntteltkhl thynpd} ge3 nld* tbhuib tbe{
mhujd lht uldep}tnld* tbe{ jhhced nt hle nlhtbep nld
jnuibed nld mbntteped tkjj tbe hjd gnl }nkd }hgetbkli hp
htbep ybkmb K }uvvh}e yn} n ohce3 ahp tbe ikpj jnuibed
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 92/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 93/378
Epeybhl
;= ha =9;
`ut ahp tbe }hmket{ ha [png* tbe onkjhp‛} dnuibtep* ybh bnd
tncel n ipent anlm{ ahp ge nld tpented ge yktb tbe utgh}tckldle}}, Tbe gnl mnge eqep{ dn{ th tenmb ge tbe
jnliunie* `ut g{ penj dkmtkhlnp{ nld ipnggnp yepe [png3
nld K mhl}ujted tbeg th }umb vupvh}e tbnt K gnde tbe
gh}t ertpnhpdklnp{ vphipe}}* `ekli n`je nt tbe eld ha n
ghltb th uldep}tnld n ipent denj ha tbe mhlqep}ntkhl
ybkmb K hqepbenpd `etyeel [png nld bep antbep, G{tenmbep vphae}}ed bkg}eja yejj }ntk}aked* nld }nkd be }bhujd
gnce n anqhupn`je pevhpt ha ge th tbe nutbhpktke}, K tbel
~ue}tkhled bkg n} th ybnt yhujd vph`n`j{ `e dhle yktb
ge, Be thjd ge tbnt g{ nppkqnj bnd mnu}ed ipent
ermktegelt tbphuibhut tbe mhultp{* nld tbnt K yn} th `e
detnkled n mjh}e vpk}hlep ultkj tbe pemekvt ha ndqkme} aphgtbe Ihqeplgelt, G{ bnqkli bnd n yntmb* be }nkd* yn} tbe
hlj{ dngnikli aentupe kl tbe mn}e, Nld tbel* kl nl}yep th
g{ n}ckli yb{ tbk} }bhujd `e }h* be inqe ge n jhli }thp{
ha ybkmb yktb g{ kgvepaemt clhyjedie ha tbe jnliunie K
mhujd gnce lhtbkli ybnteqep* ermevt tbnt kt yn} n qep{
beklhu} haaelme* njgh}t n} `nd nt jen}t* }h K tbhuibt K
uldep}thhd bkg+ n} bnqkli t{vbu} aeqep, @ut be }nkd be
tbhuibt g{ jkibt bnkp yhujd }nqe ge,
K yn} njjhyed th ynjc kl tbe inpdel3 tbepe yn} n bkib
ynjj }h tbnt K gnlnied th vjn{ n }hpt ha bnld akqe}* ybkmb
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 94/378
Epeybhl
;4 ha =9;
vpeqelted g{ aeejkli tbe `nd eaaemt} ha g{ mhlaklegelt*
tbhuib kt yn} }tuvkd yhpc vjn{kli njhle, Kl tbe mhup}e ha tkge vehvje aphg tbe thyl nld lekib`hupbhhd `einl th
ve}tep tbe onkjhp th `e njjhyed th }ee ge* nld hl pemekqkli
bnld}hge aee} be jet tbeg dh }h, Tbe vehvje yepe ihhd
th ge3 njgh}t thh ihhd* ahp tbe{ yepe klmjkled th gnce n
jkhl ha ge* ybkmb K bnted—nt jen}t tbe yhgel yepe3 hlj{
tbe{ bnd th `eynpe ha [png* ybh yn} n {huli jnd{ ha n oenjhu} tegvepngelt* nld cevt n }bnpv e{e `htb hl ge
nld hl g{ jnd{ qk}kthp}, Bhyeqep* K aejt }h ckldj{ thynpd}
bep* nld yn} }h eltkpej{ develdelt uvhl bep ahp njgh}t njj
tbnt gnde g{ jkae n `je}}kli nld n mhgahpt th ge* tbnt K
thhc ihhd mnpe lht th qer bep* nld ye pegnkled ermejjelt
apkeld}, Tbe gel yepe anp je}} kl~uk}ktkqe* nld yhujd lht*K `ejkeqe* bnqe mhge lenp ge ha tbekp hyl nmmhpd3 `ut tbe
yhgel gnde tbeg mhge n} e}mhpt}, K yn} dejkibted yktb
tbekp bnld}hge gkel* nld vjen}nlt ielknj gnllep},
G{ ahhd yn} vjnkl* `ut njyn{} qnpked nld ybhje}hge*
nld tbe ihhd ped ykle yn} ndgkpn`je, K bnd ahuld n }hpt
ha yhpt kl tbe inpdel* ybkmb K }yented kl benv} nld tbel
dpked* h`tnklkli tbu} n }u`}tktute ahp th`nmmh3 }h tbnt ybnt
yktb [png* tbe jnliunie* qk}kthp}* akqe} kl tbe inpdel*
}ghckli* nld `ed* g{ tkge }jkvved `{ ghpe pnvkdj{ nld
vjen}nltj{ tbnl gkibt bnqe `eel ervemted, K nj}h gnde
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 95/378
Epeybhl
;5 ha =9;
g{}eja n }gnjj ajute3 nld `ekli n thjepn`je vjn{ep* ngu}ed
g{}eja nt tkge} yktb vjn{kli }lntmbe} aphg hvepn}* nld nkp}}umb n} ‒H ybepe nld hb ybepe*‛ nld ‒Bhge* }yeet
bhge,‛ Tbk} yn} ha ipent ndqnltnie th ge* ahp tbe vehvje
ha tbe mhultp{ yepe kilhpnlt ha tbe dknthlkm }mnje nld
mhujd bnpdj{ `ejkeqe tbekp enp} hl benpkli }hge ha hup
gh}t mhgghl gejhdke}, Hatel* thh* tbe{ yhujd gnce ge
}kli3 nld K mhujd nt nl{ tkge gnce [png‛} e{e} }ykg yktbtenp} `{ }klikli ‒Ykjckl} nld bk} Dklnb*‛ ‒@kjj{ Tn{jhp*‛
‒Tbe Pntmntmbep‛} Dnuibtep*‛ hp n} gumb ha tbeg n} K
mhujd pegeg`ep,
K bnd hle hp tyh dk}mu}}khl} yktb tbeg `emnu}e K leqep
yhujd }kli hl ]uldn{ ha ybkmb K cevt mhult kl g{
vhmcet'`hhc+* ermevt mbnlt} nld b{gl tule}3 ha tbe}e Kpeipet th }n{ tbnt K bnd ahpihttel tbe yhpd}* }h tbnt K mhujd
hlj{ }kli tbe tule, Tbe{ nvvenped th bnqe jkttje hp lh
pejkikhu} aeejkli* nld th bnqe leqep }h gumb n} benpd ha
tbe dkqkle kl}tktutkhl ha tbe ]n``ntb* }h tbe{ n}mpk`ed g{
h`}epqnlme ha kt th n akt ha }ujckle}}* ybkmb tbe{ pegnpced
n} mhgkli hqep ge uvhl eqep{ }eqeltb dn{, @ut tbe{
yepe qep{ thjepnlt* nld hle ha tbeg }nkd th ge ~ukte
ckldj{ tbnt }be cley bhy kgvh}}k`je kt yn} th bejv `ekli
}ujc{ nt tkge}* hlj{ }be tbhuibt K huibt th }ee }hge hle ka
kt `emnge ghpe }epkhu}—n vkeme ha ndqkme ybkmb K tbel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 96/378
Epeybhl
;1 ha =9;
ankjed th uldep}tnld* tbhuib K vpetelded th tnce kt ~ukte n}
n gnttep ha mhup}e,Hlme hlj{ dkd [png tpent ge kl n yn{ tbnt yn} ulckld
nld ulpen}hln`je*—nt jen}t }h K tbhuibt kt nt tbe tkge, Kt
bnvveled tbu}, K bnd `eel vjn{kli akqe} kl tbe inpdel nld
iht gumb bented, Njtbhuib tbe dn{ yn} mhjd* ahp nutugl
yn} lhy ndqnlmkli* nld Mhjd Bnp`hup n} tbe lnge ha
tbe thyl kl ybkmb g{ vpk}hl yn} }bhujd `e tpnl}jnted+}thhd aujj{ =666 aeet n`hqe tbe }en* K bnd vjn{ed yktbhut
g{ mhnt nld ynk}tmhnt* nld thhc n }bnpv mbkjj hl pe}tkli
g{}eja thh jhli kl tbe hvel nkp yktbhut vphtemtkhl, Tbe
lert dn{ K bnd n }eqepe mhjd nld aejt penjj{ vhhpj{, @ekli
jkttje u}ed eqel th tbe jkibte}t nkjgelt}* nld tbklckli tbnt kt
yhujd `e pntbep lkme th `e vetted nld mh}}etted `{ [png*K meptnklj{ dkd lht gnce g{}eja hut th `e nl{ `ettep tbnl K
yn}3 kl anmt* K pegeg`ep tbnt K gnde tbe yhp}t ha tbkli}*
nld thhc kt klth g{ bend th mhl}kdep g{}eja uvhl tbe }kmc
jk}t, Ybel [png `phuibt ge g{ `pencan}t K mhgvjnkled
}hgeybnt dhjeaujj{ ha g{ kldk}vh}ktkhl* ervemtkli tbe
}{gvntb{ nld bughupkli ybkmb K }bhujd bnqe pemekqed
aphg g{ ghtbep nld }k}tep} nt bhge, Lht n `kt ha kt, ]be
akped uv kl nl kl}tnlt* nld n}ced ge ybnt K genlt `{ kt*
nld bhy K dnped th vpe}uge th geltkhl }umb n tbkli*
e}vemknjj{ ybel K mhl}kdeped kl ybnt vjnme K yn}, ]be bnd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 97/378
Epeybhl
;9 ha =9;
tbe `e}t gkld th tejj bep antbep* hlj{ tbnt }be yn} napnkd tbe
mhl}e~uelme} yhujd `e }h qep{ }epkhu} ahp ge, Bep gnllep yn} }h klouped nld demkded* nld bep nliep }h
eqkdeltj{ ulaekiled* tbnt K ahpiht g{ mhjd uvhl tbe }vht*
`eiikli bep `{ njj genl} th tejj bep antbep ka }be yk}bed th
dh }h* nld tejjkli bep tbnt K bnd lh kden ha `ekli }bkejded
`{ bep aphg nl{tbkli ybnteqep3 vpe}eltj{ ghjjka{kli* natep
bnqkli }nkd n} gnl{ `ktkli tbkli} n} K mhujd* K n}ced bep ybnt kt yn} tbnt K bnd dhle ngk}}* nld vphgk}ed
ngeldgelt n} }hhl n} eqep K `emnge nynpe ha kt, ]be }ny
tbnt K yn} penjj{ kilhpnlt* nld bnd bnd lh klteltkhl ha
`ekli pude th bep3 ybepehl kt mnge hut tbnt kjjle}} ha nl{
}hpt yn} mhl}kdeped kl Epeybhl th `e bkibj{ mpkgklnj nld
kgghpnj3 nld tbnt K yn} jkn`je* eqel ahp mntmbkli mhjd* th`e bnd uv `eahpe tbe gnik}tpnte} nld kgvpk}hled ahp n
mhl}kdepn`je vepkhd—nl nllhulmegelt ybkmb }tpumc ge
dug` yktb n}thlk}bgelt,
K ahjjhyed uv tbe mhlqep}ntkhl n} yejj n} g{ kgvepaemt
clhyjedie ha tbe jnliunie yhujd njjhy* nld mnuibt n
ijkggepkli ha bep vh}ktkhl yktb peinpd th kjj'benjtb3 `ut K
dkd lht eqel tbel aujj{ mhgvpebeld kt* lhp bnd K n} {et
nl{ kden ha tbe htbep ertpnhpdklnp{ vepqep}khl} ha tbhuibt
ybkmb erk}ted nghli tbe Epeybhlknl}* `ut yktb ybkmb K
yn} }hhl th `emhge angkjknp, K vphvh}e* tbepeahpe* th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 98/378
Epeybhl
;2 ha =9;
gnce lh geltkhl ha ybnt vn}}ed `etyeel u} hl tbk}
hmmn}khl* }nqe tbnt ye yepe pemhlmkjed* nld tbnt }be`phuibt ge }uppevtktkhu}j{ n bht ijn}} ha }vkpkt} nld yntep
`eahpe K yelt th `ed* n} nj}h n vkje ha ertpn `jnlcet}* nld
tbnt lert ghplkli K yn} ~ukte yejj, K leqep pegeg`ep th
bnqe jh}t n mhjd }h pnvkdj{,
Tbk} jkttje naankp ervjnkled gumb ybkmb bnd bktbepth
vuzzjed ge, Kt }eeged tbnt tbe tyh gel ybh yepeerngkled `eahpe tbe gnik}tpnte} hl tbe dn{ ha g{ nppkqnj
kl tbe mhultp{* bnd `eel ikqel kl mbnpie hl nmmhult ha kjj
benjtb* nld yepe `htb mhldegled th n jhli tepg ha
kgvpk}hlgelt yktb bnpd jn`hup3 tbe{ yepe lhy ervkntkli
tbekp haaelme kl tbk} qep{ vpk}hl* nld tbekp erepmk}e iphuld
yn} n {npd }evnpnted `{ g{ akqe} ynjj aphg tbe inpdel klybkmb K ynjced, Tbk} nmmhulted ahp tbe }huld} ha
mhuibkli nld iphnlkli ybkmb K bnd hatel lhtkmed n}
mhgkli aphg tbe htbep }kde ha tbe ynjj? kt yn} bkib* nld K
bnd lht dnped th mjkg` kt ahp aenp tbe onkjhp }bhujd }ee ge
nld tbklc tbnt K yn} tp{kli th e}mnve3 `ut K bnd hatel
yhldeped ybnt }hpt ha vehvje tbe{ mhujd `e hl tbe htbep
}kde* nld bnd pe}hjqed hl n}ckli tbe onkjhp3 `ut K }ejdhg
}ny bkg* nld [png nld K ielepnjj{ ahuld htbep tbkli} th
tnjc n`hut,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 99/378
Epeybhl
;; ha =9;
Nlhtbep ghltb ajey `{* dupkli ybkmb K gnde }umb
vphipe}} kl tbe jnliunie tbnt K mhujd uldep}tnld njj tbntyn} }nkd th ge* nld ervpe}} g{}eja yktb thjepn`je ajuelm{,
G{ kl}tpumthp vphae}}ed th `e n}thlk}bed yktb tbe vphipe}}
K bnd gnde3 K yn} mnpeauj th nttpk`ute kt th tbe vnkl} be bnd
tncel yktb ge nld th bk} ndgkpn`je getbhd ha ervjnklkli
g{ dkaakmujtke}* }h ye `emnge ermejjelt apkeld},
G{ qk}kthp} `emnge ghpe nld ghpe ape~uelt, Nghlitbeg tbepe yepe }hge* `htb gel nld yhgel* ybh
dejkibted ge eltkpej{ `{ tbekp }kgvjkmkt{* ulmhl}mkhu}le}}
ha }eja* ckldj{ ielknj gnllep}* nld jn}t* `ut lht jen}t* `{
tbekp er~uk}kte `enut{3 tbepe mnge htbep} je}} yejj'`ped*
`ut }tkjj mhgej{ nld nipeen`je vehvje* ybkje }hge yepe
}lh`} vupe nld }kgvje,Nt tbe eld ha tbe tbkpd ghltb tbe onkjhp nld g{
kl}tpumthp mnge thietbep th qk}kt ge nld thjd ge tbnt
mhggulkmntkhl} bnd `eel pemekqed aphg tbe Ihqeplgelt
th tbe eaaemt tbnt ka K bnd `ebnqed yejj nld }eeged
ielepnjj{ pen}hln`je* nld ka tbepe mhujd `e lh }u}vkmkhl nt
njj n`hut g{ `hdkj{ benjtb nld qkihup* nld ka g{ bnkp yn}
penjj{ jkibt* nld g{ e{e} `jue nld mhgvjerkhl ape}b* K yn}
th `e }elt uv nt hlme th tbe getphvhjk} kl hpdep tbnt tbe
Ckli nld ^ueel gkibt }ee ge nld mhlqep}e yktb ge3 `ut
tbnt ybel K nppkqed tbepe K }bhujd `e }et nt jk`ept{* nld n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 100/378
Epeybhl
>66 ha =9;
}uktn`je njjhynlme yhujd `e gnde ge, G{ tenmbep nj}h
thjd ge tbnt hle ha tbe jendkli gepmbnlt} bnd }elt ge nlklqktntkhl th pevnkp th bk} bhu}e nld th mhl}kdep g{}eja bk}
iue}t ahp n} jhli n tkge n} K mbh}e, ‒Be k} n dejkibtauj gnl*‛
mhltklued tbe kltepvpetep* ‒`ut bn} }uaaeped teppk`j{ aphg‛
bepe tbepe mnge n jhli yhpd ybkmb K mhujd lht ~ukte
mntmb* hlj{ kt yn} gumb jhliep tbnl cjevthgnlkn+* ‒nld bn}
`ut jntej{ pemhqeped aphg eg`ezzjkli n jnpie }ug ha ghle{ uldep }kliujnpj{ dk}tpe}}kli mkpmug}tnlme}3 `ut be
bn} ~ukte iht hqep kt* nld tbe }tpnkibtelep} }n{ tbnt be bn}
gnde n penjj{ yhldepauj pemhqep{3 {hu npe }upe th jkce
bkg,‛
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 101/378
Epeybhl
>6> ha =9;
MBNVTEP KR? TH TBE GETPHVHJK]
Yktb tbe n`hqe yhpd} tbe ihhd gnl jeat tbe phhg
`eahpe K bnd tkge th ervpe}} g{ n}thlk}bgelt nt benpkli
}umb ertpnhpdklnp{ jnliunie aphg tbe jkv} ha hle ybh
}eeged th `e n pevutn`je geg`ep ha }hmket{, ‒Eg`ezzje n
jnpie }ug ha ghle{ uldep }kliujnpj{ dk}tpe}}kli
mkpmug}tnlme}.‛ K ermjnkged th g{}eja* ‒nld n}c GE th ih
nld }tn{ yktb bkg. K }bnjj dh lhtbkli ha tbe }hpt—
mhgvphgk}e g{}eja nt tbe qep{ hut}et kl tbe e{e} ha njj
demelt vehvje* nld ikqe tbe dentb'`jhy th g{ mbnlme} ha
ektbep mhlqeptkli tbeg ka tbe{ npe tbe jh}t tpk`e} ha K}pnej*
hp gnckli ghle{ hut ha tbeg ka tbe{ npe lht. Lh, K ykjj
dh nl{tbkli pntbep tbnl tbnt,‛ Nld ybel K lert }ny g{
tenmbep K thjd bkg tbnt K dkd lht nt njj jkce tbe }huld ha
ybnt bnd `eel vphvh}ed ahp ge* nld tbnt K yhujd bnqe
lhtbkli th dh yktb kt, Ahp `{ g{ edumntkhl nld tbe
erngvje ha g{ hyl vnpelt}* nld K tpu}t nj}h kl }hge
deipee aphg kl`hpl kl}tklmt* K bnqe n qep{ ielukle dk}jkce
ahp njj ulbnld}hge denjkli} kl ghle{ gnttep}* tbhuib
lhle mnl bnqe n ipentep peinpd ahp ghle{ tbnl K bnqe* ka kt
`e iht ankpj{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 102/378
Epeybhl
>60 ha =9;
Tbe kltepvpetep yn} gumb }upvpk}ed `{ g{ nl}yep* nld
}nkd tbnt K }bhujd `e qep{ ahhjk}b ka K vep}k}ted kl g{peau}nj,
Gp, Lh}lk`hp* be mhltklued* ‒k} n gnl ha nt jen}t
566*666 bhp}e' vhyep‛ ahp tbekp yn{ ha pemchlkli nld
mjn}}ka{kli gel k} `{ tbe lug`ep ha ahht vhuld} ybkmb
tbe{ bnqe ghle{ elhuib th pnk}e* hp ghpe phuibj{ `{
tbekp bhp}e'vhyep+* ‒nld ceev} n mnvktnj tn`je3 `e}kde}* bk}tyh dnuibtep} npe nghli tbe gh}t `enutkauj yhgel kl
Epeybhl,‛
Ybel K benpd njj tbk}* K mhlae}} tbnt K yn} gumb }bncel*
nld kl~ukped ybetbep be yn} anqhupn`j{ mhl}kdeped kl tbe
`e}t }hmket{,
‒Meptnklj{*‛ yn} tbe nl}yep3 ‒lh gnl kl tbe mhultp{}tnld} bkibep,‛
Be tbel yelt hl th }n{ tbnt hle yhujd bnqe tbhuibt
aphg g{ gnllep tbnt g{ vphvh}ed bh}t bnd bnd onuldkme
hp vjeupk}{ hp `eel ielepnjj{ ulahptulnte* nld tbnt K yn} kl
aenp ha klaemtkhl,
‒K ng lht gumb napnkd ha klaemtkhl*‛ }nkd K* kgvntkeltj{*
‒`ut K bnqe }hge peinpd ahp g{ mbnpnmtep3 nld ka K clhy n
gnl th `e nl eg`ezzjep ha htbep vehvje‛} ghle{* `e }upe
ha kt* K ykjj ikqe bkg n} ykde n `eptb n} K mnl, Ka be yepe kjj
hp vhhp—‒
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 103/378
Epeybhl
>6= ha =9;
‒Kjj hp vhhp.‛ klteppuvted tbe kltepvpetep* yktb n anme ha
ipent njnpg, ‒]h tbnt‛} {hup lhtkhl ha vphvpket{. [huyhujd mhl}hpt yktb tbe `n}e}t mpkgklnj}* nld {et deeg
}kgvje eg`ezzjegelt n `np th apkeldj{ kltepmhup}e, K
mnllht uldep}tnld {hu,‛
‒@ut K ng vhhp g{}eja*‛ mpked K,
‒[hu yepe*‛ }nkd be3 ‒nld {hu yepe jkn`je th `e }eqepej{
vulk}bed ahp kt*—kldeed* nt tbe mhulmkj ybkmb yn} bejdmhlmeplkli {hu* tbk} anmt yn} qep{ lenpj{ mhl}kilkli {hu
th ybnt K }bhujd g{}eja mhl}kdep n yejj'de}epqed
mbn}tk}egelt‛ ahp be yn} iettkli nlip{* nld }h yn} K+3 ‒`ut
tbe ^ueel yn} }h kl~uk}ktkqe* nld ynlted }h gumb th }ee
{hu* tbnt }be vetktkhled tbe Ckli nld gnde bkg ikqe {hu
bk} vnpdhl* nld n}}kil {hu n vel}khl kl mhl}kdepntkhl ha {hup gepkthpkhu} mhgvjerkhl, Kt k} jumc{ ahp {hu tbnt be
bn} lht benpd ybnt {hu bnqe `eel }n{kli lhy* hp be
yhujd `e }upe th mnlmej kt,‛
N} K benpd tbe}e yhpd} g{ benpt }nlc yktbkl ge, K aejt
tbe ertpege dkaakmujt{ ha g{ vh}ktkhl* nld bhy ykmced K
}bhujd `e kl pullkli mhultep th e}tn`jk}bed u}nie, K
pegnkled }kjelt ahp }eqepnj gklute}* nld tbel }nkd tbnt K
}bhujd `e bnvv{ th nmmevt tbe eg`ezzjep‛} klqktntkhl*—hl
ybkmb g{ kl}tpumthp `pkibteled nld }nkd K yn} n }el}k`je
aejjhy, @ut K aejt qep{ ulmhgahptn`je, Ybel be bnd jeat
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 104/378
Epeybhl
>64 ha =9;
tbe phhg* K gu}ed hqep tbe mhlqep}ntkhl ybkmb bnd ou}t
tncel vjnme `etyeel u}* `ut K mhujd gnce lhtbkli hut ha kt* ermevt tbnt kt npiued nl eqel ipentep vepqep}kt{ ha
geltnj qk}khl tbnl K bnd `eel {et vpevnped ahp, Nld tbk}
gnde ge ypetmbed3 ahp K mnllht `enp bnqkli gumb th dh
yktb vehvje ybh tbklc dkaaepeltj{ aphg g{}eja, Njj }hpt} ha
ynldepkli tbhuibt} cevt mhgkli klth g{ bend, K tbhuibt
ha g{ gn}tep‛} but* nld g{ }ent uvhl tbe ghultnkl }kde*ybepe K bnd akp}t mhlmekqed tbe kl}nle kden ha ervjhpkli,
Ybnt {enp} nld {enp} }eeged th bnqe vn}}ed }klme K bnd
`eiul g{ ohuple{.
K tbhuibt ha g{ ndqeltupe} kl tbe ihpie* nld hl tbe
ohuple{ bktbep* nld ha Mbhy`hc, K yhldeped ybnt
Mbhy`hc thjd tbeg n`hut ge ybel be iht `nmc*—bebnd dhle yejj kl ihkli `nmc* Mbhy`hc bnd, Be yn} lht
bnld}hge—ln{* be yn} bkdehu}3 nld kt yhujd bnqe ihle
bnpdj{ yktb bkg, Tykjkibt dpey hl* nld pnkl vntteped
ninkl}t tbe ykldhy}, Leqep {et bnd K aejt }h ulbnvv{*
ermevt dupkli tbpee dn{} ha }en' }kmcle}} nt tbe `eikllkli
ha g{ qh{nie aphg Elijnld, K }nt gu}kli nld kl ipent
gejnlmbhj{* ultkj [png gnde bep nvvenpnlme yktb jkibt
nld }uvvep, ]be thh* vhhp ikpj* yn} gk}epn`je3 ahp }be bnd
benpd tbnt K yn} th jenqe tbeg, ]be bnd gnde uv bep gkld
tbnt K yn} th pegnkl njyn{} kl tbe thyl* eqel natep g{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 105/378
Epeybhl
>65 ha =9;
kgvpk}hlgelt yn} hqep3 nld K anlm{ bnd pe}hjqed th gnpp{
ge tbhuib K bnd leqep }h gumb n} bklted nt bep dhkli }h,]h ybnt yktb tbe dk}tpe}}klij{ }tpnlie mhlqep}ntkhl yktb
g{ tenmbep* g{ hyl apkeldje}} mhldktkhl* nld [png‛}
gejnlmbhj{* K aejt ghpe ulbnvv{ tbnl K mnl de}mpk`e* nld
pegnkled }h tkjj K iht th `ed* nld }jeev }enjed g{ e{ejkd},
Hl nynckli lert ghplkli K yn} gumb `ettep, Kt yn}
}ettjed tbnt K yn} th gnce g{ }tnpt kl n mhlqe{nlme ybkmbyn} th `e kl ynktkli ahp ge nt n`hut ejeqel h‛mjhmc3 nld
tbe nltkmkvntkhl ha mbnlie vut ge kl ihhd }vkpkt}* ybkmb
eqel tbe tenpauj anme ha [png mhujd bnpdj{ njthietbep
depnlie, K ck}}ed bep ninkl nld ninkl* n}}uped bep tbnt ye
}bhujd geet bepenatep* nld tbnt kl tbe genlybkje K }bhujd
`e eqep gkldauj ha bep ckldle}}, K inqe bep tyh ha tbe`utthl} haa g{ mhnt nld n jhmc ha g{ bnkp n} n ceev}nce*
tnckli n ihhdj{ mupj aphg bep hyl `enutkauj bend kl
petupl? nld }h* bnqkli }nkd ihhd'`{e n buldped tkge}* tkjj K
yn} ankpj{ hqepmhge yktb bep ipent }yeetle}} nld bep
}hpphy* K thpe g{}eja nyn{ aphg bep nld iht dhyl'}tnkp}
th tbe mnjembe ybkmb yn} kl ynktkli, Bhy tbnlcauj K yn}
ybel kt yn} njj hqep* nld K yn} dpkqel nyn{ nld hut ha
}kibt, Yhujd tbnt K mhujd bnqe aejt tbnt kt yn} hut ha gkld
nj}h. Vpn{ benqel tbnt kt k} }h lhy* nld tbnt }be k} gnppked
bnvvkj{ nghli bep hyl vehvje* nld bn} ahpihttel ge.
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 106/378
Epeybhl
>61 ha =9;
Nld lhy `einl n jhli nld tedkhu} ohuple{ yktb ybkmb
K }bhujd bnpdj{ tphu`je tbe pendep ka K mhujd, Be k} }nae*bhyeqep* ahp tbe }kgvje pen}hl tbnt K yn} `jkldahjded
dupkli tbe ipentep vnpt ha tbe tkge, N `nldnie yn} vut
uvhl g{ e{e} eqep{ ghplkli* nld yn} hlj{ peghqed nt
lkibt ybel K penmbed tbe kll nt ybkmb ye yepe th vn}}
tbe lkibt, Ye tpnqejjed }jhyj{* njtbhuib tbe phnd} yepe
ihhd, Ye dphqe `ut hle bhp}e* ybkmb thhc u} hup dn{‛} ohuple{ aphg ghplkli tkjj eqelkli* n`hut }kr bhup}*
ermju}kqe ha tyh bhup}‛ pe}t kl tbe gkddje ha tbe dn{, K dh
lht }uvvh}e ye gnde n`hqe tbkpt{ hp tbkpt{'akqe gkje} hl
nl nqepnie, Enmb dn{ ye bnd n ape}b bhp}e, N} K bnqe }nkd
njpend{* K mhujd }ee lhtbkli ha tbe mhultp{, K hlj{ clhy
tbnt kt yn} jeqej* nld tbnt }eqepnj tkge} ye bnd th mph}}jnpie pkqep} kl aepp{'`hnt}, Tbe kll} yepe mjenl nld
mhgahptn`je, Kl hle hp tyh ha tbe jnpiep thyl} tbe{ yepe
~ukte }ugvtuhu}* nld tbe ahhd yn} ihhd nld yejj mhhced,
Tbe }nge yhldepauj benjtb nld ipnme nld `enut{ vpeqnkjed
eqep{ybepe,
K ahuld g{}eja nl h`oemt ha ipent kltepe}t3 }h gumb }h*
tbnt tbe dpkqep thjd ge be bnd th ceev hup phute }empet*
nld nt tkge} th ih th vjnme} tbnt yepe lht dkpemtj{ hl hup
phnd* kl hpdep th nqhkd tbe vpe}} tbnt yhujd htbepyk}e
bnqe nynkted u}, Eqep{ eqelkli K bnd n pemevtkhl* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 107/378
Epeybhl
>69 ha =9;
ipey benptkj{ tkped ha bnqkli th }n{ tbe }nge tbkli} hqep
nld hqep ninkl kl nl}yep th tbe }nge ~ue}tkhl}* `ut kt yn}kgvh}}k`je th `e nlip{ yktb vehvje ybh}e gnllep} yepe
}h dejkibtauj, Tbe{ leqep hlme n}ced natep g{ benjtb* hp
eqel ybetbep K yn} antkiued yktb g{ ohuple{3 `ut tbekp
akp}t ~ue}tkhl yn} njgh}t klqnpkn`j{ nl kl~ukp{ natep g{
tegvep* tbe lnkqete ha ybkmb n}thlk}bed ge tkjj K `emnge
u}ed th kt, Hle dn{* `ekli tkped nld mhjd* nld yenp{ ha }n{kli tbe }nge tbkli hqep nld hqep ninkl* K tupled n jkttje
`pu}~uej{ hl g{ ~ue}tkhlep nld }nkd tbnt K yn}
ermeedklij{ mph}}* nld tbnt K mhujd bnpdj{ aeej kl n yhp}e
bughup yktb g{}eja nld eqep{ hle ej}e tbnl nt tbnt
ghgelt, Th g{ }upvpk}e* K yn} get yktb tbe cklde}t
ervpe}}khl} ha mhldhjelme* nld benpd kt `uzzed n`hut tbephhg tbnt K yn} kl nl kjj tegvep3 ybepehl vehvje `einl th
ikqe ge lkme tbkli} th }gejj nld th ent* ybkmb penjj{ dkd
}eeg th bnqe }hge tegvep'geldkli ~unjkt{ n`hut tbeg*
ahp K }hhl aejt vjen}ed nld yn} nt hlme mhlipntujnted uvhl
`ekli `ettep, Tbe lert ghplkli tyh hp tbpee vehvje }elt
tbekp }epqnlt} th tbe bhtej yktb }yeetgent}* nld kl~ukpke}
ybetbep K bnd ~ukte pemhqeped aphg g{ kjj bughup, Hl
pemekqkli tbe ihhd tbkli} K aejt kl bnja n gkld th `e kjj'
tegveped eqep{ eqelkli3 `ut K dk}jkced tbe mhldhjelme}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 108/378
Epeybhl
>62 ha =9;
nld tbe kl~ukpke}* nld ahuld kt gh}t mhgahptn`je th ceev
g{ lntupnj tegvep* ybkmb k} }ghhtb elhuib ielepnjj{,Nghli tbh}e ybh mnge th qk}kt ge yepe }hge ybh
bnd pemekqed n jk`epnj edumntkhl nt tbe Mhjjeie} ha
Ulpen}hl* nld tncel tbe bkibe}t deipee} kl b{vhtbetkm}*
ybkmb npe tbekp vpklmkvnj }tud{, Tbe}e ieltjegel bnd lhy
}ettjed dhyl th qnpkhu} egvjh{gelt} kl tbe mhultp{* n}
}tpnkibtelep}* gnlniep} nld mn}bkep} ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}*vpke}t} ha pejkikhl* hp ybnt lht* nld mnpp{kli tbekp
edumntkhl yktb tbeg tbe{ dkaau}ed n jenqel ha mujtupe
tbphuibhut tbe mhultp{, K lntupnjj{ ~ue}tkhled tbeg n`hut
gnl{ ha tbe tbkli} ybkmb bnd vuzzjed ge }klme g{ nppkqnj,
K kl~ukped ybnt yn} tbe h`oemt nld genlkli ha tbe }tntue}
ybkmb K bnd }eel uvhl tbe vjntenu ha tbe vn}}, K yn} thjdtbnt tbe{ dnted aphg n qep{ peghte vepkhd* nld tbnt tbepe
yepe }eqepnj htbep }umb iphuv} kl tbe mhultp{* `ut lhle }h
pegnpcn`je n} tbe hle ybkmb K bnd }eel, Tbe{ bnd n
pejkikhu} hpkikl* bnqkli `eel de}kiled th vphvktknte tbe
ihd} ha deahpgkt{ nld dk}en}e, Kl ahpgep tkge} kt bnd `eel
tbe mu}thg th gnce ervedktkhl} hqep tbe pnlie}* nld
mnvtupe tbe uijke}t ha Mbhy`hc‛} nlme}thp} ybhg tbe{
mhujd akld* kl hpdep th }nmpkakme tbeg kl tbe vpe}elme ha
tbe}e dektke}* nld tbu} nqept uijkle}} nld dk}en}e aphg tbe
Epeybhlknl} tbeg}ejqe}, Kt bnd `eel ybk}veped `ut g{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 109/378
Epeybhl
>6; ha =9;
klahpgnlt n}}uped ge ultpuj{+ tbnt meltupke} nih tbe{ bnd
eqel haaeped uv }hge ha tbekp hyl vehvje ybh yepe uij{hp hut ha benjtb* kl hpdep th gnce erngvje} ha tbeg3 tbe}e
dete}tn`je mu}thg}* bhyeqep* bnd `eel jhli dk}mhltklued3
lektbep yn} tbepe nl{ vpe}elt h`}epqnlme ha tbe }tntue},
K bnd tbe mupkh}kt{ th kl~ukpe ybnt yhujd `e dhle th
nl{ ha Mbhy`hc‛} tpk`e ka tbe{ mph}}ed hqep klth
Epeybhl, K yn} thjd tbnt lh`hd{ cley* kln}gumb n} }umbn tbkli bnd lht bnvveled ahp nie}, Tbe{ yhujd `e thh
uij{ th `e njjhyed th ih nt jnpie* `ut lht }h gumb }h n} th
`e mpkgklnjj{ jkn`je, Tbekp haaelme kl bnqkli mhge yhujd
`e n ghpnj hle3 `ut tbe{ yhujd `e `e{hld tbe
}tpnkibtelep‛} npt, Vh}}k`j{ tbe{ yhujd `e mhl}kiled th tbe
Bh}vktnj ahp Klmupn`je @hpe}* nld gnde th yhpc nt `ekli`hped ahp }h gnl{ bhup} n dn{ `{ tbe Epeybhlknl
klbn`ktnlt} ha tbe bh}vktnj* ybh npe ertpegej{ kgvntkelt ha
hle nlhtbep‛} `hpedhg* `ut yhujd }hhl dke ka tbe{ bnd lh
hle ybhg tbe{ gkibt `hpe—kl anmt* tbnt tbe{ yhujd `e
cevt n} vphae}}khlnj `hpee}, Ybel K benpd tbk}* kt hmmupped
th ge tbnt }hge pughup} ha kt} }u`}tnlme gkibt vepbnv}
bnqe `emhge muppelt nghli Mbhy`hc‛} vehvje3 ahp tbe
nihl{ ha bk} aenp bnd `eel thh ipent th bnqe `eel kl}vkped
`{ tbe gepe dpend ha `ekli `uplt njkqe `eahpe tbe }tntue},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 110/378
Epeybhl
>>6 ha =9;
K nj}h ~ue}tkhled tbeg n`hut tbe gu}eug ha hjd
gnmbkle}* nld tbe mnu}e ha tbe nvvnpelt petphipe}}khl kl njjnpt}* }mkelme}* nld klqeltkhl}, K jenplt tbnt n`hut ahup
buldped {enp} vpeqkhu}j{* tbe }tnte ha gembnlkmnj
clhyjedie yn} anp `e{hld hup hyl* nld yn} ndqnlmkli
yktb vphdkikhu} pnvkdkt{* ultkj hle ha tbe gh}t jenpled
vphae}}hp} ha b{vhtbetkm} yphte nl ertpnhpdklnp{ `hhc
aphg ybkmb K vphvh}e th ikqe ertpnmt} jntep hl+* vphqklitbnt tbe gnmbkle} yepe ujtkgntej{ de}tkled th }uvvjnlt tbe
pnme ha gnl* nld th `emhge kl}tklmt yktb n qktnjkt{ n}
dkaaepelt aphg* nld }uvepkhp th* tbnt ha nlkgnj}* n} nlkgnj
th qeietn`je jkae, ]h mhlqklmkli yn} bk} pen}hlkli* hp
ulpen}hlkli* th tbk} eaaemt* tbnt be mnppked tbe mhultp{
yktb bkg3 nld tbe{ gnde n mjenl }yeev ha njj gnmbklep{tbnt bnd lht `eel kl u}e ahp ghpe tbnl tyh buldped nld
}eqelt{'hle {enp} ybkmb vepkhd yn} nppkqed nt natep n
}epke} ha mhgvphgk}e}+* nld }tpkmtj{ ahp`nde njj auptbep
kgvphqegelt} nld klqeltkhl} uldep vnkl ha `ekli
mhl}kdeped kl tbe e{e ha tbe jny th `e jn`hupkli uldep
t{vbu} aeqep* ybkmb tbe{ peinpd n} hle ha tbe yhp}t ha njj
mpkge},
Tbk} k} tbe hlj{ mn}e kl ybkmb tbe{ bnqe mhlahulded
geltnj nld vb{}kmnj dk}en}e}* nld tbe{ dh kt eqel bepe n}
`{ nl nqhyed jeinj akmtkhl, K `emnge ulen}{ ybel K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 111/378
Epeybhl
>>> ha =9;
pegeg`eped n`hut g{ yntmb3 `ut tbe{ mhgahpted ge
yktb tbe n}}upnlme tbnt tpnl}ipe}}khl kl tbk} gnttep yn}lhy }h ulbenpd ha* tbnt tbe jny mhujd naahpd th `e jelkelt
thynpd} nl uttep }tpnliep* e}vemknjj{ thynpd} hle ybh bnd
}umb n ihhd mbnpnmtep tbe{ genlt vb{}k~ue+* nld }umb
`enutkauj jkibt bnkp, Ghpehqep tbe yntmb yn} n penj
mupkh}kt{* nld yhujd `e n yejmhge nddktkhl th tbe
getphvhjktnl mhjjemtkhl3 }h tbe{ dkd lht tbklc K leed jet kttphu`je ge }epkhu}j{,
K ykjj ypkte* bhyeqep* ghpe aujj{ uvhl tbk} }u`oemt
ybel K denj yktb tbe Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl* nld tbe @hhc
ha tbe Gnmbkle},
Kl n`hut n ghltb aphg tbe tkge ha hup }tnptkli K yn}
thjd tbnt hup ohuple{ yn} lenpj{ hqep, Tbe `nldnie yn}lhy dk}vel}ed yktb* ahp kt }eeged kgvh}}k`je tbnt K }bhujd
eqep `e n`je th akld g{ yn{ `nmc yktbhut `ekli mnvtuped,
Tbel ye phjjed geppkj{ njhli tbphuib tbe }tpeet} ha n
bnld}hge thyl* nld iht hl th n jhli* `phnd* nld jeqej
phnd* yktb vhvjnp tpee} hl ektbep }kde, Tbe phnd yn} pnk}ed
}jkibtj{ n`hqe tbe }upphuldkli mhultp{* nld bnd ahpgepj{
`eel n pnkjyn{3 tbe akejd} hl ektbep }kde yepe kl tbe bkibe}t
mhlmekqn`je mujtkqntkhl* `ut tbe bnpqe}t nld nj}h tbe
qkltnie bnd `eel njpend{ intbeped, Tbe yentbep bnd iht
mhhjep ghpe pnvkdj{ tbnl mhujd `e ~ukte nmmhulted ahp `{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 112/378
Epeybhl
>>0 ha =9;
tbe vphipe}} ha tbe }en}hl3 }h K pntbep tbhuibt tbnt ye
gu}t bnqe `eel gnckli nyn{ aphg tbe }ul* nld yepe}hge deipee} anptbep aphg tbe e~unthp tbnl ybel ye
}tnpted, Eqel bepe tbe qeietntkhl }bhyed tbnt tbe mjkgnte
yn} n bht hle* {et tbepe yn} lh jnmc ha qkihup nghli tbe
vehvje3 hl tbe mhltpnp{* tbe{ yepe n qep{ bnpd{ pnme* nld
mnvn`je ha ipent eldupnlme, Ahp tbe buldpedtb tkge K
tbhuibt tbnt* tnce tbeg njj phuld* K bnd leqep }eel tbekp e~unj} kl pe}vemt ha vb{}k~ue* nld tbe{ jhhced n} ihhd'
lntuped n} tbe{ yepe ph`u}t, Tbe ajhyep} yepe ahp tbe
gh}t vnpt hqep* `ut tbekp n`}elme yn} kl }hge gen}upe
mhgvel}nted ahp `{ n vphau}khl ha dejkmkhu} apukt* mjh}ej{
pe}eg`jkli tbe aki}* venmbe}* nld venp} ha Ktnj{ nld Apnlme,
K }ny lh ykjd nlkgnj}* `ut `kpd} yepe vjeltkauj nld gumbn} kl Euphve* `ut lht tnge n} tbe{ bnd `eel hl tbe htbep
}kde tbe pnlie}, Tbe{ yepe }bht nt yktb tbe mph}}'`hy nld
yktb npphy}* iulvhydep `ekli ulclhyl* hp nt nl{ pnte
lht kl u}e,
Ye yepe lhy lenpkli tbe getphvhjk} nld K mhujd }ee
ipent thyep} nld ahptkakmntkhl}* nld jhat{ `ukjdkli} tbnt
jhhced jkce vnjnme}, K `einl th `e lepqhu} n} th g{
pemevtkhl3 `ut K bnd iht hl qep{ yejj }h anp* nld pe}hjqed
th mhltklue uvhl tbe }nge vjnl n} bktbepth— lngej{* th
`ebnqe ou}t n} tbhuib K yepe kl Elijnld ultkj K }ny tbnt K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 113/378
Epeybhl
>>= ha =9;
yn} gnckli n `juldep* nld tbel th }n{ lhtbkli tkjj K mhujd
intbep bhy tbe jnld jn{, Ye dpey lenpep nld lenpep, Tbeley} ha g{ nvvphnmb bnd iht n`phnd* nld tbepe yn} n
ipent mphyd mhjjemted hl ektbep }kde tbe phnd* ybh ipeeted
ge yktb gnpc} ha gh}t pe}vemtauj mupkh}kt{* ceevkli ge
`hykli mhl}tnltj{ kl nmclhyjediegelt aphg }kde th }kde,
Ybel ye yepe n`hut n gkje haa* ye yepe get `{ tbe
Gn{hp nld }eqepnj Mhulmkjjhp}* nghli ybhg yn} nqelepn`je hjd gnl* ybh yn} kltphdumed th ge `{ tbe
Gn{hp ahp }h K }uvvh}e K }bhujd mnjj bkg+ n} tbe
ieltjegnl ybh bnd klqkted ge th bk} bhu}e, K `hyed
deevj{ nld thjd bkg bhy ipnteauj K aejt th bkg* nld bhy
ijndj{ K yhujd nmmevt bk} bh}vktnjkt{, Be ahp`nde ge th }n{
ghpe* nld vhkltkli th bk} mnppknie* ybkmb yn} mjh}e ntbnld* be ghtkhled ge th n }ent tbepekl, K ninkl `hyed
vphahuldj{ th tbe Gn{hp nld Mhulmkjjhp}* nld dphqe haa
yktb g{ elteptnklep* ybh}e lnge yn} ]elho Lh}lk`hp,
Natep n`hut bnja n gkje tbe mnppknie tupled haa tbe gnkl
phnd* nld ye dphqe uldep tbe ynjj} ha tbe thyl tkjj ye
penmbed n vnjnzzh hl n }jkibt egklelme* nld ou}t hl tbe
hut}ckpt} ha tbe mkt{, Tbk} yn} ]elho Lh}lk`hp‛} bhu}e* nld
lhtbkli mnl `e kgnikled aklep, Kt yn} }ktunted lenp tbe
gnilkakmelt nld qelepn`je pukl} ha tbe hjd pnkjyn{ }tntkhl*
ybkmb ahpged nl kgvh}kli aentupe aphg tbe inpdel} ha tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 114/378
Epeybhl
>>4 ha =9;
bhu}e, Tbe iphuld}* }hge tel hp n dhzel nmpe} kl ertelt*
yepe jnkd hut kl teppnmed inpdel}* hle n`hqe tbe htbep*yktb ajkibt} ha `phnd }tev} n}meldkli nld de}meldkli tbe
demjkqkt{ ha tbe inpdel, Hl tbe}e }tev} tbepe yepe }tntue}
ha gh}t er~uk}kte yhpcgnl}bkv, @e}kde} tbe }tntue} tbepe
yepe qn}e} akjjed yktb qnpkhu} }bpu`} tbnt yepe ley th ge3
nld hl ektbep }kde tbe ajkibt} ha }tev} tbepe yepe phy} ha
hjd m{vpe}}e} nld mednp}* yktb ipn}}{ njje{} `etyeel tbeg,Tbel mnge mbhkme qkle{npd} nld hpmbnpd} ha apukt'tpee} kl
aujj `enpkli,
Tbe bhu}e kt}eja yn} nvvphnmbed `{ n mhupt'{npd* nld
phuld kt yn} n mhppkdhp hl th ybkmb phhg} hveled* n} nt
Vhgvekk, Kl tbe gkddje ha tbe mhupt tbepe yn} n `ntb nld n
ahultnkl, Bnqkli vn}}ed tbe mhupt ye mnge th tbe gnkl`hd{ ha tbe bhu}e* ybkmb yn} tyh }thpke} kl bekibt, Tbe
phhg} yepe jnpie nld jhat{3 vepbnv} nt akp}t tbe{ jhhced
pntbep `npe ha auplktupe* `ut kl bht mjkgnte} vehvje
ielepnjj{ ceev tbekp phhg} ghpe `npe tbnl tbe{ dh kl
mhjdep hle}, K gk}}ed nj}h tbe }kibt ha n ipnld vknlh hp
}hge }kgkjnp kl}tpugelt* tbepe `ekli lh genl} ha
vphdumkli gu}km kl nl{ ha tbe phhg} }nqe tbe jnpiep
dpnykli'phhg* ybepe tbepe yepe bnja n dhzel jnpie
`phlze ihli}* ybkmb tbe jndke} u}ed hmmn}khlnjj{ th `ent
n`hut nt pnldhg, Kt yn} lht vjen}nlt th benp tbeg* `ut K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 115/378
Epeybhl
>>5 ha =9;
bnqe benpd ~ukte n} ulvjen}nlt gu}km `htb `eahpe nld
}klme,Gp, Lh}lk`hp thhc ge tbphuib }eqepnj }vnmkhu} phhg}
tkjj ye penmbed n `hudhkp ybepe yepe bk} ykae nld
dnuibtep}* ha ybhg K bnd benpd aphg tbe kltepvpetep, Gp},
Lh}lk`hp yn} n`hut ahpt{ {enp} hjd* nld }tkjj bnld}hge*
`ut }be bnd iphyl qep{ }thut? bep dnuibtep} yepe kl tbe
vpkge ha {hutb nld er~uk}ktej{ `enutkauj, K inqe tbevpeaepelme njgh}t nt hlme th tbe {huliep* ybh}e lnge
yn} Nphybeln3 ahp tbe ejdep }k}tep yn} bnuibt{* ybkje tbe
{huliep bnd n qep{ ykllkli gnllep, Gp}, Lh}lk`hp
pemekqed ge yktb tbe vepaemtkhl ha mhupte}{* }h tbnt K gu}t
bnqe kldeed `eel }b{ nld lepqhu} ka K bnd lht nt hlme aejt
yejmhge, ]mnpmej{ yn} tbe mepeghl{ ha g{ kltphdumtkhlyejj mhgvjeted `eahpe n }epqnlt nllhulmed tbnt dkllep
yn} pend{ kl tbe lert phhg, K yn} ermeedklij{ bulip{*
nld tbe dkllep yn} `e{hld njj vpnk}e, Mnl tbe pendep
yhldep tbnt K `einl th mhl}kdep g{}eja kl ermejjelt
~unptep}8 ‒Tbnt gnl eg`ezzje ghle{8‛ tbhuibt K th
g{}eja3 ‒kgvh}}k`je,‛
@ut K lhtkmed tbnt g{ bh}t yn} ulen}{ dupkli tbe
ybhje genj* nld tbnt be nte lhtbkli `ut n jkttje `pend nld
gkjc3 thynpd} tbe eld ha dkllep tbepe mnge n tnjj jenl gnl
yktb n `jnmc `enpd* th ybhg Gp, Lh}lk`hp nld tbe ybhje
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 116/378
Epeybhl
>>1 ha =9;
angkj{ vnkd ipent ntteltkhl? be yn} tbe angkj{ }tpnkibtelep,
Yktb tbk} ieltjegnl Gp, Lh}lk`hp petkped klth nlhtbep phhg* aphg ybkmb tbepe vpe}eltj{ vphmeeded n }huld ha
yeevkli nld ynkjkli, K mhujd bnpdj{ `ejkeqe g{ enp}* `ut
kl n aey gklute} K iht th clhy ahp n meptnklt{ tbnt tbe{
mnge aphg Gp, Lh}lk`hp bkg}eja,
‒Vhhp vnvn*‛ }nkd Nphybeln* n} }be bejved bep}eja
mhgvh}edj{ th tbe }njt* ‒bhy teppk`j{ be bn} }uaaeped,‛‒[e}*‛ nl}yeped bep ghtbep3 ‒`ut K tbklc be k} ~ukte hut
ha dnliep lhy,‛
Tbel tbe{ yelt hl th ervjnkl th ge tbe mkpmug}tnlme}
ha tbe mn}e* nld tbe tpentgelt ybkmb tbe }tpnkibtelep bnd
vpe}mpk`ed* nld bhy }umme}}auj be bnd `eel—njj ybkmb K
ykjj pe}epqe ahp nlhtbep mbnvtep* nld vut pntbep kl tbe ahpgha n ielepnj }uggnp{ ha tbe hvklkhl} muppelt uvhl tbe}e
}u`oemt} tbnl kl tbe ernmt yhpd} kl ybkmb tbe anmt} yepe
dejkqeped th ge3 tbe pendep* bhyeqep* k} enple}tj{
pe~ue}ted th `ejkeqe tbnt `htb kl tbk} lert mbnvtep nld kl
tbh}e tbnt ahjjhy kt K bnqe eldenqhuped th ndbepe gh}t
mhl}mkeltkhu}j{ th tbe }tpkmte}t nmmupnm{* nld tbnt K bnqe
leqep ykjjklij{ gk}pevpe}elted* tbhuib K gn{ bnqe
}hgetkge} ankjed th uldep}tnld njj tbe `enpkli} ha nl
hvklkhl hp mu}thg,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 117/378
Epeybhl
>>9 ha =9;
MBNVTEP R? MUPPELT HVKLKHL]
Tbk} k} ybnt K intbeped, Tbnt kl tbnt mhultp{ ka n gnl
anjj} klth kjj benjtb* hp mntmbe} nl{ dk}hpdep* hp ankj} `hdkj{
kl nl{ yn{ `eahpe be k} }eqelt{ {enp} hjd* be k} tpked `eahpe
n oup{ ha bk} mhultp{gel* nld ka mhlqkmted k} bejd uv th
vu`jkm }mhpl nld }eltelmed ghpe hp je}} }eqepej{ n} tbe
mn}e gn{ `e, Tbepe npe }u`dkqk}khl} ha kjjle}}e} klth mpkge}
nld gk}degenlhup} n} yktb haaelme} nghli}t hup}ejqe}—n
gnl `ekli vulk}bed qep{ benqkj{ ahp }epkhu} kjjle}}* ybkje
ankjupe ha e{e} hp benpkli kl hle hqep }krt{'akqe* ybh bn}
bnd ihhd benjtb bktbepth* k} denjt yktb `{ akle hlj{* hp
kgvpk}hlgelt kl deanujt ha vn{gelt, @ut ka n gnl ahpie} n
mbe~ue* hp }et} bk} bhu}e hl akpe* hp ph`} yktb qkhjelme
aphg tbe vep}hl* hp dhe} nl{ htbep }umb tbkli} n} npe
mpkgklnj kl hup hyl mhultp{* be k} ektbep tncel th n
bh}vktnj nld gh}t mnpeaujj{ telded nt tbe vu`jkm ervel}e*
hp ka be k} kl ihhd mkpmug}tnlme}* be jet} kt `e clhyl th njj
bk} apkeld} tbnt be k} }uaaepkli aphg n }eqepe akt ha
kgghpnjkt{* ou}t n} ye dh ybel ye npe kjj* nld tbe{ mhge
nld qk}kt bkg yktb ipent }hjkmktude* nld kl~ukpe yktb
kltepe}t bhy kt njj mnge n`hut* ybnt }{gvthg} akp}t
}bhyed tbeg}ejqe}* nld }h ahptb*—~ue}tkhl} ybkmb be
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 118/378
Epeybhl
>>2 ha =9;
ykjj nl}yep yktb vepaemt ulpe}epqe3 ahp `nd mhldumt*
tbhuib mhl}kdeped lh je}} devjhpn`je tbnl kjjle}} yktbhup}ejqe}* nld n} ul~ue}tkhln`j{ kldkmntkli }hgetbkli
}epkhu}j{ yphli yktb tbe kldkqkdunj ybh gk}`ebnqe}* k}
leqeptbeje}} bejd th `e tbe pe}ujt ha ektbep vpe'lntnj hp
vh}t'lntnj gk}ahptule,
Tbe }tpnlie vnpt ha tbe }thp{* bhyeqep* k} tbnt tbhuib
tbe{ n}mpk`e ghpnj deaemt} th tbe eaaemt ha gk}ahptule ektbep kl mbnpnmtep hp }upphuldkli}* tbe{ ykjj lht jk}tel th tbe
vjen ha gk}ahptule kl mn}e} tbnt kl Elijnld geet yktb
}{gvntb{ nld mhggk}epntkhl hlj{, Kjj jumc ha nl{ ckld* hp
eqel kjj tpentgelt nt tbe bnld} ha htbep}* k} mhl}kdeped nl
haaelme ninkl}t }hmket{* kln}gumb n} kt gnce} vehvje
ulmhgahptn`je th benp ha kt, Jh}} ha ahptule* tbepeahpe* hp jh}} ha }hge denp apkeld hl ybhg nlhtbep yn} gumb
develdelt* k} vulk}bed bnpdj{ je}} }eqepej{ tbnl vb{}kmnj
dejkl~uelm{,
Ahpekil* kldeed* n} }umb kden} npe th hup hyl* tpnme} ha
}hgeybnt }kgkjnp hvklkhl} mnl `e ahuld eqel kl
lkleteeltb'meltup{ Elijnld, Ka n vep}hl bn} nl n`}me}}* tbe
gedkmnj gnl ykjj }n{ tbnt kt mhltnkl} ‒vemmnlt‛ gnttep* nld
vehvje }n{ tbnt tbe{ bnqe n ‒`nd‛ npg hp akliep* hp tbnt
tbe{ npe qep{ ‒`nd‛ njj hqep* ybel tbe{ hlj{ genl
‒dk}en}ed,‛ Nghli ahpekil lntkhl} Epeybhlknl hvklkhl}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 119/378
Epeybhl
>>; ha =9;
gn{ `e }tkjj ghpe mjenpj{ lhted, Tbe Gnbhggednl}* ahp
erngvje* th tbk} dn{* }eld tbekp aegnje vpk}hlep} thbh}vktnj}* nld tbe Ley _enjnld Gnhpke} qk}kt nl{
gk}ahptule yktb ahpmk`je eltp{ klth tbe bhu}e ha tbe
haaeldep* nld tbe `penckli uv nld `uplkli ha njj bk} ihhd},
Tbe Ktnjknl}* ninkl* u}e tbe }nge yhpd ahp ‒dk}ipnme‛ nld
‒gk}ahptule,‛ K hlme benpd nl Ktnjknl jnd{ }venc ha n {huli
apkeld ybhg }be de}mpk`ed n} eldhyed yktb eqep{ qkptueuldep benqel* ‒gn*‛ }be ermjnkged* ‒vhqeph dk}ipnzknth* bn
nggnzznth }uh zkh,‛ "Vhhp ulahptulnte aejjhy* be bn}
gupdeped bk} ulmje,‛+
Hl geltkhlkli tbk}* ybkmb K benpd ybel tncel th Ktnj{
n} n `h{ `{ g{ antbep* tbe vep}hl th ybhg K thjd kt
}bhyed lh }upvpk}e, Be }nkd tbnt be bnd `eel dpkqel ahp tyh hp tbpee {enp} kl n meptnkl mkt{ `{ n {huli ]kmkjknl
mn`dpkqep ha vpevh}}e}}kli gnllep} nld nvvenpnlme* `ut
tbel jh}t }kibt ha bkg, Hl n}ckli ybnt bnd `emhge ha
bkg* be yn} thjd tbnt be yn} kl vpk}hl ahp bnqkli }bht nt
bk} antbep yktb kltelt th ckjj bkg—bnvvkj{ yktbhut }epkhu}
pe}ujt, ]hge {enp} jntep g{ klahpgnlt ninkl ahuld bkg}eja
ynpgj{ nmmh}ted `{ tbe vpevh}}e}}kli {huli mn`dpkqep,
‒Nb* mnph }kilhpe*‛ be ermjnkged* ‒}hlh mkl~ue nllk mbe
lhl jh qedh—tpe nllk dk gkjktnpe* e due nllk dk dk}ipnzkn*‛
!m, "G{ denp }kp* kt k} akqe {enp} }klme K }ny {hu—tbpee
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 120/378
Epeybhl
>06 ha =9;
{enp} ha gkjktnp{ }epqkme* nld tyh ha gk}ahptule‛+—dupkli
ybkmb jn}t tbe vhhp aejjhy bnd `eel kl vpk}hl, Ha ghpnj}el}e be }bhyed lht }h gumb n} n tpnme, Be nld bk} antbep
yepe lhy hl ermejjelt tepg}* nld yepe jkcej{ th pegnkl }h
ulje}} ektbep ha tbeg }bhujd ninkl bnqe tbe gk}ahptule
ghptnjj{ th haaeld tbe htbep,
Kl tbe ahjjhykli mbnvtep K ykjj ikqe n aey erngvje} ha
tbe yn{ kl ybkmb ybnt ye }bhujd mnjj gk}ahptule*bnpd}bkv* hp dk}en}e npe denjt yktb `{ tbe Epeybhlknl}* `ut
ahp tbe ghgelt ykjj petupl th tbekp tpentgelt ha mn}e} tbnt
yktb u} npe mpkgklnj, N} K bnqe njpend{ }nkd* tbe}e* tbhuib
lht oudkmknjj{ vulk}bn`je* npe pemhilk}ed n} pe~ukpkli
mhppemtkhl, Nmmhpdklij{* tbepe erk}t} n mjn}} ha gel tpnkled
kl }huj'mpnat* ybhg tbe{ mnjj }tpnkibtelep}* n} lenpj{ n} Kmnl tpnl}jnte n yhpd ybkmb jktepnjj{ genl} ‒hle ybh `eld}
`nmc tbe mphhced,‛ Tbe}e gel vpnmtk}e gumb n} gedkmnj
gel kl Elijnld* nld pemekqe n ~un}k'}uppevtktkhu} aee hl
eqep{ qk}kt, Tbe{ npe tpented yktb tbe }nge ulpe}epqe* nld
h`e{ed n} pendkj{* n} hup hyl dhmthp}—tbnt k} th }n{* hl
tbe ybhje }uaakmkeltj{—`emnu}e vehvje clhy tbnt kt k}
tbekp kltepe}t th iet yejj n} }hhl n} tbe{ mnl* nld tbnt tbe{
ykjj lht `e }mhuted n} tbe{ yhujd `e ka tbekp `hdke} yepe
hut ha hpdep* eqel tbhuib tbe{ gn{ bnqe th uldepih n
qep{ vnklauj mhup}e ha tpentgelt,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 121/378
Epeybhl
>0> ha =9;
Ybel K }n{ tbnt tbe{ ykjj lht `e }mhuted* K dh lht
genl tbnt nl Epeybhlknl ykjj }uaaep lh }hmknjklmhlqelkelme kl mhl}e~uelme* ye ykjj }n{* ha bnqkli
mhggktted apnud, Apkeld} ykjj anjj nyn{ aphg bkg `emnu}e
ha bk} `ekli je}} vjen}nlt mhgvnl{* ou}t n} ye hup}ejqe} npe
dk}klmjkled th gnce mhgvnlkhl} ha tbh}e ybh npe ektbep
vhhp hp vhhpj{, Lh hle yktb nl{ }el}e ha }eja'pe}vemt ykjj
vjnme bkg}eja hl nl e~unjkt{ kl tbe gnttep ha naaemtkhl yktbtbh}e ybh npe je}} jumc{ tbnl bkg}eja kl `kptb* benjtb*
ghle{* ihhd jhhc}* mnvnmkt{* hp nl{tbkli ej}e, Kldeed*
tbnt dk}jkce nld eqel dk}iu}t }bhujd `e aejt `{ tbe ahptulnte
ahp tbe ulahptulnte* hp nt nl{ pnte ahp tbh}e ybh bnqe
`eel dk}mhqeped th bnqe get yktb nl{ ha tbe ghpe }epkhu}
nld je}} angkjknp gk}ahptule}* k} lht hlj{ lntupnj* `utde}kpn`je ahp nl{ }hmket{* ybetbep ha gnl hp `pute,
Tbe anmt* tbepeahpe* tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl} nttnmb lhle
ha tbnt iukjt th mpkge ybkmb tbe{ dh th vb{}kmnj nkjgelt}*
dhe} lht vpeqelt tbe ghpe }ejak}b nghli tbeg aphg
leijemtkli n apkeld ybh bn} ph``ed n `nlc* ahp kl}tnlme*
tkjj be bn} aujj{ pemhqeped3 `ut kt dhe} vpeqelt tbeg aphg
eqel tbklckli ha tpentkli mpkgklnj} yktb tbnt
mhltegvtuhu} thle ybkmb yhujd }eeg th }n{* ‒K* ka K yepe
{hu* }bhujd `e n `ettep gnl tbnl {hu npe*‛ n thle ybkmb k}
bejd ~ukte pen}hln`je kl peinpd th vb{}kmnj nkjgelt, Belme*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 122/378
Epeybhl
>00 ha =9;
tbhuib tbe{ mhlmenj kjj benjtb `{ eqep{ mullkli nld
b{vhmpk}{ nld nptkakme ybkmb tbe{ mnl deqk}e* tbe{ npe~ukte hvel n`hut tbe gh}t ajnipnlt geltnj dk}en}e}* }bhujd
tbe{ bnvvel th erk}t* ybkmb th dh tbe vehvje ou}tkme k} lht
hatel, Kldeed* tbepe npe }hge ybh npe* }h th }venc*
}vkpktunj qnjetudklnpknl}* nld ybh gnce tbeg}ejqe}
ermeedklij{ pkdkmujhu} `{ tbekp lepqhu} }uvvh}ktkhl tbnt
tbe{ npe ykmced* ybkje tbe{ npe qep{ thjepn`je vehvje njjtbe tkge, Tbk} bhyeqep k} ermevtkhlnj3 nld hl tbe ybhje
tbe{ u}e gumb tbe }nge pe}epqe hp ulpe}epqe n`hut tbe
}tnte ha tbekp ghpnj yejanpe n} ye dh n`hut hup benjtb,
Belme njj tbe hpdklnp{ ipeetkli} nghli hup}ejqe}* }umb
n}* Bhy dh {hu dh8 nld tbe jkce* npe mhl}kdeped }kil} ha
iph}} kjj'`peedkli3 lhp dh tbe vhjktep mjn}}e} thjepnte eqel}umb n mhgghl mhgvjkgeltnp{ pegnpc n} tejjkli n gnl
tbnt be k} jhhckli yejj, Tbe{ }njute enmb htbep yktb* ‒K
bhve {hu npe ihhd tbk} ghplkli3‛ hp ‒K bhve {hu bnqe
pemhqeped aphg tbe }lnvvk}ble}} aphg ybkmb {hu yepe
}uaaepkli ybel K jn}t }ny {hu3‛ nld ka tbe vep}hl }njuted
bn} lht `eel ihhd* hp k} }tkjj }lnvvk}b* be }n{} }h nt hlme
nld k} mhldhjed yktb nmmhpdklij{, Kldeed* tbe }tpnkibtelep}
bnqe ihle }h anp n} th ikqe lnge} aphg tbe b{vhtbetkmnj
jnliunie n} tnuibt nt tbe Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl+* th njj
clhyl ahpg} ha geltnj kldk}vh}ktkhl* nld th mjn}}ka{ tbeg
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 123/378
Epeybhl
>0= ha =9;
nmmhpdkli th n }{}teg ha tbekp hyl* ybkmb* tbhuib K mhujd
lht uldep}tnld kt* }eeged th yhpc yejj kl vpnmtkme3 ahp tbe{ npe njyn{} n`je th tejj n gnl ybnt k} tbe gnttep yktb
bkg n} }hhl n} tbe{ bnqe benpd bk} }thp{* nld tbekp
angkjknpkt{ yktb tbe jhli lnge} n}}upe} bkg tbnt tbe{
tbhphuibj{ uldep}tnld bk} mn}e,
Tbe pendep ykjj bnqe lh dkaakmujt{ kl `ejkeqkli tbnt tbe
jny} peinpdkli kjj benjtb yepe ape~ueltj{ eqnded `{ tbebejv ha pemhilk}ed akmtkhl}* ybkmb eqep{ hle uldep}thhd*
`ut ybkmb kt yhujd `e mhl}kdeped iph}} kjj'`peedkli th
eqel }eeg th uldep}tnld, Tbu}* n dn{ hp tyh natep g{
nppkqnj nt tbe Lh}lk`hp}‛* hle ha tbe gnl{ jndke} ybh
mnjjed hl ge gnde ermu}e} ahp bep bu}`nld‛} hlj{ }eldkli
bk} mnpd* hl tbe iphuld tbnt ybel ihkli tbphuib tbevu`jkm gnpcet' vjnme tbnt ghplkli be bnd }thjel n vnkp ha
}hmc}, K bnd njpend{ `eel ynpled tbnt K }bhujd leqep }bhy
}upvpk}e* }h K gepej{ ervpe}}ed g{ }{gvntb{* nld }nkd tbnt
tbhuib K bnd hlj{ `eel kl tbe mnvktnj }h }bhpt n tkge* K bnd
njpend{ bnd n qep{ lnpphy e}mnve aphg }tenjkli n mjhtbe}'
`pu}b* nld tbnt tbhuib K bnd pe}k}ted tegvtntkhl }h anp* K
yn} }ndj{ napnkd tbnt ka K }ny nl{ h`oemt ha }vemknj kltepe}t
tbnt yn} lektbep thh bht lhp thh benq{* K }bhujd bnqe th
vut g{}eja kl tbe }tpnkibtelep‛} bnld},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 124/378
Epeybhl
>04 ha =9;
Gp}, Lh}lk`hp* ybh bnd `eel ceevkli nl enp hl njj
tbnt K bnd `eel }n{kli* vpnk}ed ge ybel tbe jnd{ bndihle, Lhtbkli* }be }nkd* mhujd bnqe `eel ghpe vhjkte
nmmhpdkli th Epeybhlknl etk~uette, ]be tbel ervjnkled
tbnt th bnqe }thjel n vnkp ha }hmc}* hp ‒th bnqe tbe }hmc}‛
kl ghpe mhjjh~uknj jnliunie+* yn} n pemhilk}ed yn{ ha
}n{kli tbnt tbe vep}hl kl ~ue}tkhl yn} }jkibtj{ kldk}vh}ed,
Kl }vkte ha njj tbk} tbe{ bnqe n ceel }el}e ha tbeeloh{gelt mhl}e~uelt uvhl ybnt tbe{ mnjj `ekli ‒yejj,‛
Tbe{ ndgkpe geltnj benjtb nld jhqe kt kl htbep vehvje*
nld tnce njj tbe vnkl} tbe{ mnl mhl}k}teltj{ yktb tbekp
htbep dutke}+ th }emupe kt ahp tbeg}ejqe}, Tbe{ bnqe nl
ertpege dk}jkce th gnpp{kli klth ybnt tbe{ mhl}kdep
ulbenjtb{ angkjke}, Tbe{ }eld ahp tbe }tpnkibtelep nt hlmeybeleqep tbe{ bnqe `eel iukjt{ ha nl{tbkli }epkhu}j{
ajniktkhu}— hatel eqel ka tbe{ tbklc tbnt tbe{ npe hl tbe
vhklt ha mhggkttkli kt3 nld tbhuib bk} pegedke} npe
}hgetkge} ermeedklij{ vnklauj* klqhjqkli mjh}e
mhlaklegelt ahp yeec}* nld kl }hge mn}e} tbe gh}t mpuej
vb{}kmnj thptupe}* K leqep benpd ha n pen}hln`je
Epeybhlknl peau}kli th dh ybnt bk} }tpnkibtelep thjd bkg*
nl{ ghpe tbnl ha n pen}hln`je Elijk}bgnl peau}kli th
uldepih eqel tbe gh}t apkibtauj hvepntkhl* ka bk} dhmthp}
thjd bkg kt yn} leme}}np{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 125/378
Epeybhl
>05 ha =9;
Ye kl Elijnld leqep }bpklc aphg tejjkli hup dhmthp
ybnt k} tbe gnttep yktb u} gepej{ tbphuib tbe aenp tbnt beykjj bupt u}, Ye jet bkg dh bk} yhp}t uvhl u}* nld }tnld kt
yktbhut n gupgup* `emnu}e ye npe lht }mhuted ahp `ekli
kjj* nld `emnu}e ye clhy tbnt tbe dhmthp k} dhkli bk} `e}t
th mupe u}* nld tbnt be mnl oudie ha hup mn}e `ettep tbnl
ye mnl3 `ut ye }bhujd mhlmenj njj kjjle}} ka ye yepe
tpented n} tbe Epeybhlknl} npe ybel tbe{ bnqe nl{tbklitbe gnttep yktb tbeg3 ye }bhujd dh tbe }nge n} yktb
ghpnj nld kltejjemtunj dk}en}e}*—ye }bhujd aekil benjtb
yktb tbe gh}t mhl}uggnte npt* tkjj ye yepe ahuld hut*
nld }bhujd bnte n }klije ajhiikli ikqel kl tbe yn{ ha gepe
vulk}bgelt ghpe tbnl tbe ngvutntkhl ha n jkg`* ka kt yepe
ckldj{ nld mhuptehu}j{ vepahpged aphg n yk}b th bejv u}hut ha hup dkaakmujt{* nld yktb tbe aujj mhl}mkhu}le}} hl
tbe vnpt ha tbe dhmthp tbnt kt yn} hlj{ `{ nl nmmkdelt ha
mhl}tktutkhl tbnt be yn} lht kl tbe jkce vjkibt bkg}eja, ]h
tbe Epeybhlknl} tnce n ajhiikli hlme n yeec* nld n dket
ha `pend nld yntep ahp tyh hp tbpee ghltb} thietbep*
ybeleqep tbekp }tpnkibtelep pemhggeld} kt,
K dh lht }uvvh}e tbnt eqel g{ bh}t* hl bnqkli
}ykldjed n mhlakdkli ykdhy hut ha tbe ybhje ha bep
vphvept{* yn} vut th ghpe nmtunj }uaaepkli tbnl n gnl ykjj
pendkj{ uldepih nt tbe bnld} ha nl Elijk}b dhmthp, Nld {et
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 126/378
Epeybhl
>01 ha =9;
be gu}t bnqe bnd n qep{ `nd tkge ha kt, Tbe }huld} K
benpd yepe }uaakmkelt th }bhy tbnt bk} vnkl yn} er~uk}kte*`ut be leqep }bpnlc aphg uldepihkli kt, Be yn} ~ukte }upe
tbnt kt dkd bkg ihhd3 nld K tbklc be yn} pkibt, K mnllht
`ejkeqe tbnt tbnt gnl ykjj eqep eg`ezzje ghle{ ninkl, Be
gn{—`ut kt ykjj `e n jhli tkge `eahpe be dhe} }h,
Dupkli g{ mhlaklegelt kl vpk}hl* nld hl g{ ohuple{*
K bnd njpend{ dk}mhqeped n ipent denj ha tbe n`hqe3 `ut kt}tkjj }eeged }upvn}}klij{ }tpnlie* nld K yn} kl mhl}tnlt aenp
ha mhggkttkli }hge vkeme ha pudele}}* tbphuib g{
kln`kjkt{ th jhhc nt tbkli} aphg tbe }nge }tnld'vhklt n} g{
lekib`hup}3 `ut natep n aey yeec}‛ }tn{ yktb tbe
Lh}lk`hp}* K iht th uldep}tnld tbkli} `ettep* e}vemknjj{ hl
bnqkli benpd njj n`hut g{ bh}t‛} kjjle}}* ha ybkmb be thjdge aujj{ nld peventedj{,
Kt }eeged tbnt be bnd `eel hl tbe ]thmc Ermbnlie ha
tbe mkt{ ahp gnl{ {enp} nld bnd ngn}}ed elhpghu} yenjtb*
yktbhut ermeedkli tbe jkgkt} ha ybnt yn} ielepnjj{
mhl}kdeped ou}tkakn`je* hp nt nl{ pnte* vepgk}}k`je denjkli3
`ut nt jelitb hl }eqepnj hmmn}khl} be bnd `emhge nynpe ha
n de}kpe th gnce ghle{ `{ apnudujelt pevpe}eltntkhl}* nld
bnd nmtunjj{ denjt yktb tyh hp tbpee }ug} kl n yn{ ybkmb
bnd gnde bkg pntbep ulmhgahptn`je, Be bnd ulahptulntej{
gnde jkibt ha kt nld vhhb'vhhbed tbe nkjgelt* ultkj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 127/378
Epeybhl
>09 ha =9;
mkpmug}tnlme} eqeltunjj{ vpe}elted tbeg}ejqe} ybkmb
eln`jed bkg th mbent uvhl n qep{ mhl}kdepn`je }mnje3—bethjd ge ybnt tbe{ yepe* nld tbe{ yepe n`hut n} `nd n}
nl{tbkli mhujd `e* `ut K leed lht detnkj tbeg3—be }ekzed
tbe hvvhptulkt{* nld `emnge nynpe* ybel kt yn} thh jnte*
tbnt be gu}t `e }epkhu}j{ hut ha hpdep, Be bnd leijemted
bkg}eja thh jhli,
Be dphqe bhge nt hlme* `phce tbe ley} th bk} ykaenld dnuibtep} n} ieltj{ n} be mhujd* nld }elt haa ahp hle ha
tbe gh}t meje`pnted }tpnkibtelep} ha tbe cklidhg th n
mhl}ujtntkhl yktb tbe angkj{ vpnmtktkhlep* ahp tbe mn}e yn}
vjnklj{ }epkhu}, Hl tbe nppkqnj ha tbe }tpnkibtelep be thjd
bk} }thp{* nld ervpe}}ed bk} aenp tbnt bk} ghpnj} gu}t `e
vepgnleltj{ kgvnkped,Tbe egklelt gnl pen}}uped bkg yktb n aey mbeepkli
yhpd}* nld tbel vphmeeded th gnce n ghpe mnpeauj
dknilh}k} ha tbe mn}e, Be kl~ukped mhlmeplkli Gp,
Lh}lk`hp‛} vnpelt}—bnd tbekp ghpnj benjtb `eel ihhd8
Be yn} nl}yeped tbnt tbepe bnd lht `eel nl{tbkli
}epkhu}j{ ngk}} yktb tbeg* `ut tbnt bk} gnteplnj
ipnldantbep* ybhg be yn} }uvvh}ed th pe}eg`je
}hgeybnt kl vep}hl* bnd `eel n mhl}uggnte }mhuldpej
nld bnd elded bk} dn{} kl n bh}vktnj*—ybkje n `phtbep ha
bk} antbep‛}* natep bnqkli jed n gh}t ajniktkhu} jkae ahp gnl{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 128/378
Epeybhl
>02 ha =9;
{enp}* bnd `eel nt jn}t muped `{ n vbkjh}hvbep ha n ley
}mbhhj* ybkmb n} anp n} K mhujd uldep}tnld kt `hpe gumbtbe }nge pejntkhl th tbe hjd n} bhghehvntb{ th njjhvntb{,
Tbe }tpnkibtelep }bhhc bk} bend nt tbk}* nld jnuibklij{
pevjked tbnt tbe mupe gu}t bnqe `eel due th lntupe, Natep n
aey ghpe ~ue}tkhl} be yphte n vpe}mpkvtkhl nld devnpted,
K }ny tbe vpe}mpkvtkhl, Kt hpdeped n akle th tbe ]tnte ha
dhu`je tbe ghle{ eg`ezzjed3 lh ahhd `ut `pend nld gkjcahp }kr ghltb}* nld n }eqepe ajhiikli hlme n ghltb ahp
tyejqe, K yn} }upvpk}ed th }ee tbnt lh vnpt ha tbe akle yn}
th `e vnkd th tbe vhhp yhgnl ybh}e ghle{ bnd `eel
eg`ezzjed* `ut hl kl~ukp{ K jenpled tbnt }be yhujd bnqe
`eel vph}emuted kl tbe Gk}vjnmed Mhlakdelme Mhupt* ka
}be bnd lht e}mnved kt} mjutmbe} `{ d{kli }bhptj{ natep }bebnd dk}mhqeped bep jh}},
N} ahp Gp, Lh}lk`hp* be bnd pemekqed bk} ejeqeltb
ajhiikli hl tbe dn{ ha g{ nppkqnj, K }ny bkg jntep hl tbe
}nge nateplhhl* nld be yn} }tkjj tyklied3 `ut tbepe bnd
`eel lh e}mnve aphg ahjjhykli hut tbe }tpnkibtelep‛}
vpe}mpkvtkhl* ahp tbe }h'mnjjed }nlktnp{ jny} ha Epeybhl npe
qep{ pkihphu}* nld ulje}} tbe }tpnkibtelep yn} }ntk}aked tbnt
bk} hpdep} bnd `eel h`e{ed* tbe vntkelt yhujd bnqe `eel
tncel th n bh}vktnj n} tbe vhhp npe+* nld yhujd bnqe `eel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 129/378
Epeybhl
>0; ha =9;
gumb yhp}e haa, ]umb nt jen}t k} tbe jny* `ut kt k} leqep
leme}}np{ th elahpme kt,Hl n }u`}e~uelt hmmn}khl K yn} vpe}elt nt nl kltepqkey
`etyeel Gp, Lh}lk`hp nld tbe angkj{ }tpnkibtelep* ybh
yn} mhl}kdeped mhgvetelt th yntmb tbe mhgvjetkhl ha tbe
mupe, K yn} }tpumc yktb tbe dejkmnm{ yktb ybkmb be
nqhkded eqel tbe peghte}t }eg`jnlme ha kl~ukp{ natep tbe
vb{}kmnj yejj'`ekli ha bk} vntkelt* tbhuib tbepe yn} nmeptnkl {ejjhyle}} n`hut g{ bh}t‛} e{e} ybkmb npiued n
`kjkhu} bn`kt ha `hd{, Th bnqe tncel lhtkme ha tbk} yhujd
bnqe `eel n iph}} `penmb ha vphae}}khlnj etk~uette, K yn}
thjd* bhyeqep* tbnt n }tpnkibtelep }hgetkge} tbklc} kt pkibt
th ijnlme nt tbe vh}}k`kjkt{ ha }hge }jkibt vb{}kmnj dk}hpdep
ka be akld} kt kgvhptnlt kl hpdep th n}}k}t bkg kl bk}dknilh}k}3 `ut tbe nl}yep} ybkmb be iet} npe ielepnjj{
ultpue hp eqn}kqe* nld be ahpg} bk} hyl mhlmju}khl} uvhl
tbe gnttep n} yejj n} be mnl, ]el}k`je gel bnqe `eel
clhyl th }n{ tbnt tbe }tpnkibtelep }bhujd kl }tpkmt
mhlakdelme `e thjd ha eqep{ vb{}kmnj nkjgelt tbnt k} jkcej{
th `enp uvhl tbe mn}e3 `ut vehvje npe lntupnjj{ }b{ ha
dhkli tbk}* ahp tbe{ dh lht jkce jhyepkli tbeg}ejqe} kl tbe
hvklkhl ha tbe }tpnkibtelep* nld bk} kilhpnlme ha gedkmnj
}mkelme k} }uvpege, K benpd ha hle jnd{* kldeed* ybh bnd
tbe bnpdkbhhd th mhlae}} tbnt n aupkhu} hut`penc ha kjj'
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 130/378
Epeybhl
>=6 ha =9;
bughup nld ertpnqninlt anlmke} ahp ybkmb }be yn} }eeckli
ndqkme yn} vh}}k`j{ tbe pe}ujt ha kldk}vh}ktkhl, ‒[hu }bhujdpe}k}t tbnt*‛ }nkd tbe }tpnkibtelep* kl n ckld* `ut ipnqe qhkme3
‒ye mnl dh lhtbkli ahp tbe `hdke} ha hup vntkelt}3 }umb
gnttep} npe `e{hld hup vphqklme* nld K de}kpe tbnt K gn{
benp lh auptbep vnptkmujnp},‛ Tbe jnd{ `up}t klth tenp}* nld
vphgk}ed anktbaujj{ tbnt }be yhujd leqep `e ulyejj ninkl,
@ut th petupl th Gp, Lh}lk`hp, N} tbe nateplhhl yhpehl gnl{ mnppknie} dphqe uv yktb mnjjep} th kl~ukpe bhy be
bnd }thhd bk} ajhiikli, Kt bnd `eel qep{ }eqepe* `ut tbe
ckld kl~ukpke} uvhl eqep{ }kde inqe bkg ipent vjen}upe*
nld be n}}uped ge tbnt be aejt njgh}t tegvted th dh yphli
ninkl `{ tbe }hjkmktude yktb ybkmb bk} apkeld} bnd tpented
bkg dupkli bk} pemhqep{? kl tbk} K leed bnpdj{ }n{ tbnt beyn} lht }epkhu},
Dupkli tbe pegnkldep ha g{ }tn{ kl tbe mhultp{ Gp,
Lh}lk`hp yn} mhl}tnltj{ ntteltkqe th bk} `u}kle}}* nld
jnpiej{ klmpen}ed bk} njpend{ ipent vh}}e}}khl}3 `ut K leqep
benpd n ybk}vep th tbe eaaemt ha bk} bnqkli `eel kldk}vh}ed
n }emhld tkge* hp gnde ghle{ `{ htbep tbnl tbe gh}t
}tpkmtj{ bhlhupn`je genl}, K dkd benp natepynpd} kl
mhlakdelme tbnt tbepe bnd `eel pen}hl th `ejkeqe tbnt bk}
benjtb bnd `eel lht n jkttje naaemted `{ tbe }tpnkibtelep‛}
tpentgelt* `ut bk} apkeld} dkd lht mbhh}e th `e hqep'
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 131/378
Epeybhl
>=> ha =9;
mupkhu} uvhl tbe }u`oemt* nld hl bk} petupl th bk} naankp} kt
yn} `{ mhgghl mhl}elt vn}}ed hqep n} bnpdj{ mpkgklnj klhle ybh yn} htbepyk}e }h gumb naajkmted, Ahp tbe{ peinpd
`hdkj{ nkjgelt} n} tbe ghpe qelknj kl vphvhptkhl n} tbe{
bnqe `eel vphdumed `{ mnu}e} kldeveldelt ha tbe
mhl}tktutkhl, Tbu} ka n vep}hl pukl bk} benjtb `{ erme}}kqe
kldujielme nt tbe tn`je hp `{ dpklckli* tbe{ mhult kt th `e
njgh}t n vnpt ha tbe geltnj dk}en}e ybkmb `phuibt kt n`hut*nld }h kt ihe} ahp jkttje* `ut tbe{ bnqe lh gepm{ hl }umb
kjjle}}e} n} aeqep} hp mntnppb} hp juli dk}en}e}* ybkmb th u}
nvvenp th `e `e{hld tbe mhltphj ha tbe kldkqkdunj, Tbe{
npe hlj{ ghpe jelkelt thynpd} tbe dk}en}e} ha tbe {huli—
}umb n} gen}je}* ybkmb tbe{ tbklc th `e jkce }hykli hle‛}
ykjd hnt}—nld jhhc hqep tbeg n} vnpdhln`je kldk}mpetkhl}ka tbe{ bnqe lht `eel thh }epkhu}* nld ka tbe{ npe nthled
ahp `{ mhgvjete }u`}e~uelt pemhqep{,
Kt k} bnpdj{ leme}}np{ th }n{ tbnt tbe haakme ha
}tpnkibtelep k} hle ybkmb pe~ukpe} jhli nld }vemknj
tpnklkli, Kt }tnld} th pen}hl tbnt be ybh yhujd mupe n
ghpnj nkjgelt gu}t `e vpnmtkmnjj{ nm~unklted yktb kt kl njj
kt} `enpkli}, Tbe }tudelt ahp tbe vphae}}khl ha }tpnkibtelep
k} pe~ukped th }et nvnpt meptnkl }en}hl} ahp tbe vpnmtkme ha
enmb qkme kl tupl* n} n pejkikhu} dut{, Tbe}e }en}hl} npe
mnjjed ‒an}t}*‛ nld npe mhltklued `{ tbe }tudelt ultkj be
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 132/378
Epeybhl
>=0 ha =9;
akld} tbnt be penjj{ mnl }u`due njj tbe ghpe u}unj qkme} kl
bk} hyl vep}hl* nld belme mnl ndqk}e bk} vntkelt} aphg tbepe}ujt} ha bk} hyl ervepkelme,
Tbh}e ybh klteld th `e }vemknjk}t}* pntbep tbnl ielepnj
vpnmtktkhlep}* deqhte tbeg}ejqe} ghpe vnptkmujnpj{ th tbe
`pnlmb kl ybkmb tbekp vpnmtkme ykjj gnklj{ jke, ]hge
}tudelt} bnqe `eel h`jkied th mhltklue tbekp erepmk}e}
dupkli tbekp ybhje jkqe}* nld }hge deqhted gel bnqenmtunjj{ dked n} gnpt{p} th tbe dpklc* hp ijutthl{* hp
ybnteqep `pnlmb ha qkme tbe{ gn{ bnqe mbh}el ahp tbekp
e}vemknj }tud{, Tbe ipentep lug`ep* bhyeqep* tnce lh
bnpg `{ tbe ermup}khl} klth tbe qnpkhu} devnptgelt} ha
qkme ybkmb kt k} klmug`elt uvhl tbeg th }tud{,
Ahp tbe Epeybhlknl} bhjd tbnt ulnjjh{ed qkptue k} lht ntbkli th `e kgghdepntej{ kldujied kl, K yn} }bhyl ghpe
tbnl hle mn}e kl ybkmb tbe penj hp }uvvh}ed qkptue} ha
vnpelt} yepe qk}kted uvhl tbe mbkjdpel th tbe tbkpd nld
ahuptb ielepntkhl, Tbe }tpnkibtelep} }n{ tbnt tbe gh}t tbnt
mnl `e tpuj{ }nkd ahp qkptue k} tbnt tbepe k} n mhl}kdepn`je
`njnlme kl kt} anqhup* nld tbnt kt k} hl tbe ybhje n ihhd
denj `ettep th `e hl kt} }kde tbnl ninkl}t kt3 `ut tbe{ upie
tbnt tbepe k} gumb v}eudh'qkptue ihkli n`hut* ybkmb k} nvt
th jet vehvje kl qep{ `ndj{ `eahpe tbe{ akld kt hut, Tbh}e
gel* tbe{ }n{* npe `e}t ybh npe lht pegnpcn`je ektbep ahp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 133/378
Epeybhl
>== ha =9;
qkme hp qkptue, K thjd tbeg n`hut Bhinptb‛} kdje nld
kldu}tpkhu} nvvpeltkme}* `ut tbe{ dkd lht }eeg th tbklctbnt tbe kldu}tpkhu} nvvpeltkme yn} n qep{ lkme vep}hl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 134/378
Epeybhl
>=4 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RK? ]HGE EPEYBHLKNLTPKNJ]
Kl Epeybhl n} kl htbep mhultpke} tbepe npe }hge mhupt}
ha ou}tkme tbnt denj yktb }vemknj }u`oemt}, Gk}ahptule
ielepnjj{* n} K bnqe n`hqe ervjnkled* k} mhl}kdeped ghpe hp
je}} mpkgklnj* `ut kt ndgkt} ha mjn}}kakmntkhl* nld n mhupt k}
n}}kiled th enmb ha tbe gnkl bend} uldep ybkmb kt mnl `e
}uvvh}ed th anjj, Lht qep{ jhli natep K bnd penmbed tbe
mnvktnj K }tphjjed klth tbe Vep}hlnj @epenqegelt Mhupt* nld
yn} gumb `htb kltepe}ted nld vnkled `{ jk}telkli th tbe
tpknj ha n gnl ybh yn} nmmu}ed ha bnqkli ou}t jh}t n ykae th
ybhg be bnd `eel teldepj{ nttnmbed* nld ybh bnd jeat
bkg yktb tbpee jkttje mbkjdpel* ha ybhg tbe ejde}t yn}
hlj{ tbpee {enp} hjd,
Tbe deaelme ybkmb tbe vpk}hlep‛} mhul}ej eldenqhuped
th e}tn`jk}b yn}* tbnt tbe vpk}hlep bnd leqep penjj{ jhqed
bk} ykae3 `ut kt `phce dhyl mhgvjetej{* ahp tbe vu`jkm
vph}emuthp mnjjed yktle}} natep yktle}} ybh devh}ed th tbe
anmt tbnt tbe mhuvje bnd `eel deqhted th hle nlhtbep* nldtbe vpk}hlep peventedj{ yevt n} klmkdelt} yepe vut kl
eqkdelme tbnt pegklded bkg ha tbe kppevnpn`je lntupe ha
tbe jh}} be bnd }u}tnkled, Tbe oup{ petupled n qepdkmt ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 135/378
Epeybhl
>=5 ha =9;
iukjt{ natep qep{ jkttje dejk`epntkhl* `ut pemhggelded tbe
vpk}hlep th gepm{ hl tbe iphuld tbnt be bnd `ut pemeltj{kl}uped bk} ykae‛} jkae ahp n mhl}kdepn`je }ug* nld gkibt `e
deeged jumc{ kln}gumb n} be bnd pemekqed tbe ghle{
yktbhut degup aphg tbe kl}upnlme mhgvnl{* tbhuib be
bnd hlj{ vnkd tyh vpegkug},
K bnqe ou}t }nkd tbnt tbe oup{ ahuld tbe vpk}hlep iukjt{,
Ybel tbe oudie vn}}ed }eltelme* K yn} }tpumc yktb tbeyn{ kl ybkmb tbe vpk}hlep‛} mhul}ej yn} pe`uced ahp
bnqkli peaepped th n yhpc kl ybkmb tbe iukjt ha }umb
gk}ahptule} n} tbe vpk}hlep‛} yn} ertelunted th n deipee
tbnt phu}ed tbe kldkilntkhl ha tbe mhupt,
‒Ye }bnjj bnqe*‛ }nkd tbe oudie* ‒tbe}e mpude nld
}u`qep}khlnp{ `hhc} aphg tkge th tkge ultkj kt k}pemhilk}ed n} nl nrkhg ha ghpnjkt{ tbnt jumc k} tbe hlj{ akt
h`oemt ha bugnl qelepntkhl, Bhy anp n gnl bn} nl{ pkibt
th `e ghpe jumc{ nld belme ghpe qelepn`je tbnl bk}
lekib`hup}* k} n vhklt tbnt njyn{} bn} `eel* nld njyn{} ykjj
`e* }ettjed vphrkgntej{ `{ n ckld ha bkiijkli nld bniijkli
ha tbe gnpcet* nld ujtkgntej{ `{ `pute ahpme3 `ut bhyeqep
tbk} gn{ `e* kt }tnld} th pen}hl tbnt lh gnl }bhujd `e
njjhyed th `e uljumc{ th ghpe tbnl n qep{ ghdepnte
ertelt,‛
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 136/378
Epeybhl
>=1 ha =9;
Tbel* tuplkli th tbe vpk}hlep* tbe oudie mhltklued?'
‒[hu bnqe }uaaeped n ipent jh}}, Lntupe nttnmbe} n }eqepevelnjt{ th }umb haaelme}* nld bugnl jny gu}t egvbn}k}e
tbe dempee} ha lntupe, @ut ahp tbe pemhggeldntkhl ha tbe
oup{ K }bhujd bnqe ikqel {hu }kr ghltb}‛ bnpd jn`hup, K
ykjj* bhyeqep* mhggute {hup }eltelme th hle ha tbpee
ghltb}* yktb tbe hvtkhl ha n akle ha tyelt{'akqe vep melt,
ha tbe ghle{ {hu bnqe pemekqed aphg tbe kl}upnlmemhgvnl{,‛
Tbe vpk}hlep tbnlced tbe oudie* nld }nkd tbnt n} be bnd
lh hle th jhhc natep bk} mbkjdpel ka be yn} }elt th vpk}hl*
be yhujd eg`pnme tbe hvtkhl gepmkaujj{ vepgktted bkg `{
bk} jhpd}bkv* nld vn{ tbe }ug be bnd lnged, Be yn} tbel
peghqed aphg tbe dhmc,Tbe lert mn}e yn} tbnt ha n {hutb `npej{ nppkqed nt
gnl‛} e}tnte* ybh yn} mbnpied yktb bnqkli `eel }ykldjed
hut ha jnpie vphvept{ dupkli bk} gklhpkt{ `{ bk} iunpdknl*
ybh yn} nj}h hle ha bk} lenpe}t pejntkhl}, Bk} antbep bnd
`eel jhli dend* nld kt yn} ahp tbk} pen}hl tbnt bk} haaelme
mnge hl ahp tpknj kl tbe Vep}hlnj @epenqegelt Mhupt, Tbe
jnd* ybh yn} uldeaelded* vjended tbnt be yn} {huli*
klervepkelmed* ipentj{ kl nye ha bk} iunpdknl* nld yktbhut
kldeveldelt vphae}}khlnj ndqkme, ‒[huli gnl*‛ }nkd tbe
oudie }teplj{* ‒dh lht tnjc lhl}el}e, Vehvje bnqe lh pkibt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 137/378
Epeybhl
>=9 ha =9;
th `e {huli* klervepkelmed* ipentj{ kl nye ha tbekp
iunpdknl}* nld yktbhut kldeveldelt vphae}}khlnj ndqkme, Ka `{ }umb kldk}mpetkhl} tbe{ hutpnie tbe ghpnj }el}e ha tbekp
apkeld}* tbe{ gu}t ervemt th }uaaep nmmhpdklij{,‛ Be tbel
hpdeped tbe vpk}hlep th nvhjhik}e th bk} iunpdknl* nld th
pemekqe tyejqe }tphce} yktb n mnt'ha'lkle' tnkj},
@ut K }bnjj vepbnv} `e}t mhlqe{ th tbe pendep nl kden ha
tbe eltkpe vepqep}khl ha tbhuibt ybkmb erk}t} nghli tbk}ertpnhpdklnp{ vehvje* `{ de}mpk`kli tbe vu`jkm tpknj ha n
gnl ybh yn} nmmu}ed ha vujghlnp{ mhl}ugvtkhl—nl
haaelme ybkmb yn} vulk}bed yktb dentb ultkj ~ukte
pemeltj{, Kt dkd lht hmmup tkjj K bnd `eel }hge ghltb} kl
tbe mhultp{* nld K ng deqkntkli aphg mbphlhjhikmnj hpdep
kl ikqkli kt bepe3 `ut K bnd vepbnv} `ettep dh }h kl hpdep tbnt K gn{ erbnu}t tbk} }u`oemt `eahpe vphmeedkli th
htbep}, Ghpehqep K }bhujd leqep mhge th nl eld yepe K th
ceev th n }tpkmtj{ lnppntkqe ahpg* nld detnkj tbe klaklkte
n`}updktke} yktb ybkmb K dnkj{ mnge kl mhltnmt,
Tbe vpk}hlep yn} vjnmed kl tbe dhmc* nld tbe oup{ yepe
}yhpl gumb n} kl Euphve3 njgh}t njj hup hyl ghde} ha
vphmedupe yepe pevphdumed* eqel th tbe pe~ukpkli tbe
vpk}hlep th vjend iukjt{ hp lht iukjt{, Be vjended lht
iukjt{* nld tbe mn}e vphmeeded, Tbe eqkdelme ahp tbe
vph}emutkhl yn} qep{ }tphli3 `ut K gu}t dh tbe mhupt tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 138/378
Epeybhl
>=2 ha =9;
ou}tkme th h`}epqe tbnt tbe tpknj yn} n`}hjutej{ kgvnptknj,
Mhul}ej ahp tbe vpk}hlep yn} njjhyed th upie eqep{tbklitbnt mhujd `e }nkd kl bk} deaelme? tbe jkle tncel yn} tbnt
tbe vpk}hlep yn} }kgujntkli mhl}ugvtkhl kl hpdep th
deapnud nl kl}upnlme mhgvnl{* aphg ybkmb be yn} n`hut
th `u{ nl nllukt{* nld tbnt be bhved tbu} th h`tnkl kt hl
ghpe ndqnltniehu} tepg}, Ka tbk} mhujd bnqe `eel }bhyl
th `e tbe mn}e be yhujd bnqe e}mnved n mpkgklnjvph}emutkhl* nld `eel }elt th n bh}vktnj n} ahp n ghpnj
nkjgelt, Tbe qkey* bhyeqep* yn} hle ybkmb mhujd lht `e
pen}hln`j{ }u}tnkled* kl }vkte ha njj tbe klielukt{ nld
ejh~uelme ha hle ha tbe gh}t meje`pnted ndqhmnte} ha tbe
mhultp{, Tbe mn}e yn} hlj{ thh mjenp* ahp tbe vpk}hlep yn}
njgh}t nt tbe vhklt ha dentb* nld kt yn} n}thlk}bkli tbnt bebnd lht `eel tpked nld mhlqkmted jhli vpeqkhu}j{, Bk}
mhuibkli yn} klme}}nlt dupkli tbe ybhje tpknj* nld kt yn}
njj tbnt tbe tyh onkjhp} kl mbnpie ha bkg mhujd dh th ceev
bkg hl bk} jei} ultkj kt yn} hqep,
Tbe }uggkli uv ha tbe oudie yn} ndgkpn`je, Be dyejt
uvhl eqep{ vhklt tbnt mhujd `e mhl}tpued kl anqhup ha tbe
vpk}hlep* `ut n} be vphmeeded kt `emnge mjenp tbnt tbe
eqkdelme yn} thh mhlqklmkli th ndgkt ha dhu`t* nld tbepe
yn} `ut hle hvklkhl kl tbe mhupt n} th tbe kgveldkli
qepdkmt ybel tbe oup{ petkped aphg tbe `hr, Tbe{ yepe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 139/378
Epeybhl
>=; ha =9;
n`}elt ahp n`hut tel gklute}* nld hl tbekp petupl tbe
ahpegnl vphlhulmed tbe vpk}hlep iukjt{, Tbepe yn} n ankltgupgup ha nvvjnu}e* `ut kt yn} kl}tnltj{ pevpe}}ed, Tbe
oudie tbel vphmeeded th vphlhulme }eltelme kl yhpd}
ybkmb K mnl leqep ahpiet* nld ybkmb K mhvked hut klth n
lhte'`hhc lert dn{ aphg tbe pevhpt tbnt yn} vu`jk}bed kl
tbe jendkli ley}vnvep, K gu}t mhldel}e kt }hgeybnt* nld
lhtbkli ybkmb K mhujd }n{ yhujd ikqe ghpe tbnl n ankltkden ha tbe }hjegl* lht th }n{ gnoe}tkm* }eqepkt{ yktb
ybkmb kt yn} dejkqeped, Tbe }eltelme yn} n} ahjjhy}?'
‒Vpk}hlep nt tbe `np* {hu bnqe `eel nmmu}ed ha tbe ipent
mpkge ha jn`hupkli uldep vujghlnp{ mhl}ugvtkhl* nld
natep nl kgvnptknj tpknj `eahpe n oup{ ha {hup mhultp{gel*
{hu bnqe `eel ahuld iukjt{, Ninkl}t tbe ou}tkme ha tbeqepdkmt K mnl }n{ lhtbkli? tbe eqkdelme ninkl}t {hu yn}
mhlmju}kqe* nld kt hlj{ pegnkl} ahp ge th vn}} }umb n
}eltelme uvhl {hu* n} }bnjj }ntk}a{ tbe eld} ha tbe jny,
Tbnt }eltelme gu}t `e n qep{ }eqepe hle, Kt vnkl} ge
gumb th }ee hle ybh k} {et }h {huli* nld ybh}e
vph}vemt} kl jkae yepe htbepyk}e }h ermejjelt* `phuibt th
tbk} dk}tpe}}kli mhldktkhl `{ n mhl}tktutkhl ybkmb K mnl
hlj{ peinpd n} pndkmnjj{ qkmkhu}3 `ut {hup} k} lh mn}e ahp
mhgvn}}khl? tbk} k} lht {hup akp}t haaelme? {hu bnqe jed n
mnpeep ha mpkge* nld bnqe hlj{ vphakted `{ tbe jelkelm{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 140/378
Epeybhl
>46 ha =9;
}bhyl {hu uvhl vn}t hmmn}khl}* th haaeld {et ghpe
}epkhu}j{ ninkl}t tbe jny} nld kl}tktutkhl} ha {hup mhultp{, [hu yepe mhlqkmted ha niipnqnted `phlmbktk} jn}t {enp? nld
K akld tbnt tbhuib {hu npe lhy hlj{ tyelt{'tbpee {enp}
hjd* {hu bnqe `eel kgvpk}hled hl lh je}} tbnl ahupteel
hmmn}khl} ahp kjjle}}e} ha n ghpe hp je}} bnteauj mbnpnmtep3 kl
anmt* kt k} lht thh gumb th }n{ tbnt {hu bnqe }velt tbe
ipentep vnpt ha {hup jkae kl n onkj,‒Kt k} njj qep{ yejj ahp {hu th }n{ tbnt {hu mnge ha
ulbenjtb{ vnpelt}* nld bnd n }eqepe nmmkdelt kl {hup
mbkjdbhhd ybkmb vepgnleltj{ uldepgkled {hup
mhl}tktutkhl3 ermu}e} }umb n} tbe}e npe tbe hpdklnp{ peauie
ha tbe mpkgklnj3 `ut tbe{ mnllht ahp hle ghgelt `e
jk}teled th `{ tbe enp ha ou}tkme, K ng lht bepe th eltep uvhl mupkhu} getnvb{}kmnj ~ue}tkhl} n} th tbe hpkikl ha
tbk} hp tbnt— ~ue}tkhl} th ybkmb tbepe yhujd `e lh eld
yepe tbekp kltphdumtkhl hlme thjepnted* nld ybkmb yhujd
pe}ujt kl tbphykli tbe hlj{ iukjt hl tbe tk}}ue} ha tbe
vpkghpdknj mejj* hp hl tbe ejegeltnp{ in}e}, Tbepe k} lh
~ue}tkhl ha bhy {hu mnge th `e ykmced* `ut hlj{ tbk}—
lngej{* npe {hu ykmced hp lht8 Tbk} bn} `eel demkded kl
tbe naakpgntkqe* lektbep mnl K be}ktnte ahp n }klije ghgelt
th }n{ tbnt kt bn} `eel demkded ou}tj{, [hu npe n `nd nld
dnliephu} vep}hl* nld }tnld `pnlded kl tbe e{e} ha {hup
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 141/378
Epeybhl
>4> ha =9;
aejjhy'mhultp{gel yktb hle ha tbe gh}t beklhu} clhyl
haaelme},‒Kt k} lht g{ `u}kle}} th ou}tka{ tbe jny? tbe jny gn{ kl
}hge mn}e} bnqe kt} kleqktn`je bnpd}bkv}* nld K gn{ aeej
peipet nt tkge} tbnt K bnqe lht tbe hvtkhl ha vn}}kli n je}}
}eqepe }eltelme tbnl K ng mhgvejjed th dh, @ut {hup} k}
lh }umb mn}e3 hl tbe mhltpnp{* bnd lht tbe mnvktnj
vulk}bgelt ahp mhl}ugvtkhl `eel n`hjk}bed* K }bhujdmeptnklj{ klajkmt kt lhy,
‒Kt k} klthjepn`je tbnt nl erngvje ha }umb teppk`je
elhpgkt{ }bhujd `e njjhyed th ih nt jnpie ulvulk}bed,
[hup vpe}elme kl tbe }hmket{ ha pe}vemtn`je vehvje yhujd
jend tbe je}} n`je'`hdked th tbklc ghpe jkibtj{ ha njj ahpg}
ha kjjle}}3 lektbep mnl kt `e vepgktted tbnt {hu }bhujd bnqetbe mbnlme ha mhppuvtkli ul`hpl `ekli} ybh gkibt
bepenatep ve}tep {hu, Tbe ul`hpl gu}t lht `e njjhyed th
mhge lenp {hu? nld tbk} lht }h gumb ahp tbekp vphtemtkhl
ahp tbe{ npe hup lntupnj elegke}+* n} ahp hup hyl3 ahp
}klme tbe{ ykjj lht `e uttepj{ inkl}nkd* kt gu}t `e }eel th
tbnt tbe{ }bnjj `e ~unpteped uvhl tbh}e ybh npe jen}t jkcej{
th mhppuvt tbeg,
‒@ut kldeveldeltj{ ha tbk} mhl}kdepntkhl* nld
kldeveldeltj{ ha tbe vb{}kmnj iukjt ybkmb nttnmbe} kt}eja th
n mpkge }h ipent n} {hup}* tbepe k} {et nlhtbep pen}hl yb{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 142/378
Epeybhl
>40 ha =9;
ye }bhujd `e uln`je th }bhy {hu gepm{* eqel ka ye yepe
klmjkled th dh }h, K peaep th tbe erk}telme ha n mjn}} ha gelybh jke bkddel nghli u}* nld ybh npe mnjjed vb{}kmknl},
Yepe tbe }eqepkt{ ha tbe jny hp tbe muppelt aeejkli ha tbe
mhultp{ th `e pejnred leqep }h }jkibtj{* tbe}e n`nldhled
vep}hl}* ybh npe lhy mhgvejjed th vpnmtk}e }empetj{ nld
ybh mnl `e mhl}ujted hlj{ nt tbe ipente}t pk}c* yhujd
`emhge ape~uelt qk}kthp} kl eqep{ bhu}ebhjd3 tbekp hpinlk}ntkhl nld tbekp kltkgnte nm~unkltnlme yktb njj
angkj{ }empet} yhujd ikqe tbeg n vhyep* `htb }hmknj nld
vhjktkmnj* ybkmb lhtbkli mhujd pe}k}t, Tbe bend ha tbe
bhu}ebhjd yhujd `emhge }u`hpdklnte th tbe angkj{
dhmthp* ybh yhujd kltepaepe `etyeel gnl nld ykae*
`etyeel gn}tep nld }epqnlt* ultkj tbe dhmthp} }bhujd `etbe hlj{ devh}ktnpke} ha vhyep kl tbe lntkhl* nld bnqe njj
tbnt ye bhjd vpemkhu} nt tbekp gepm{, N tkge ha ulkqep}nj
devb{}kmnjk}ntkhl yhujd el}ue3 gedkmkle'qeldhp} ha njj
ckld} yhujd n`huld kl hup }tpeet} nld ndqeptk}e kl njj hup
ley}vnvep}, Tbepe k} hle peged{ ahp tbk}* nld hle hlj{, Kt
k} tbnt ybkmb tbe jny} ha tbk} mhultp{ bnqe jhli pemekqed
nld nmted uvhl* nld mhl}k}t} kl tbe }teple}t pevpe}}khl ha
njj dk}en}e} ybnt}heqep* n} }hhl n} tbekp erk}telme k} gnde
gnlkae}t th tbe e{e ha tbe jny, Yhujd tbnt tbnt e{e yepe
anp ghpe vkepmkli tbnl kt k},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 143/378
Epeybhl
>4= ha =9;
‒@ut K ykjj eljnpie lh auptbep uvhl tbkli} tbnt npe
tbeg}ejqe} }h h`qkhu}, [hu gn{ }n{ tbnt kt k} lht {hup anujt, Tbe nl}yep k} pend{ elhuib nt bnld* nld kt nghult}
th tbk}—tbnt ka {hu bnd `eel `hpl ha benjtb{ nld yejj'th'
dh vnpelt}* nld `eel yejj tncel mnpe ha ybel {hu yepe n
mbkjd* {hu yhujd leqep bnqe haaelded ninkl}t tbe jny} ha
{hup mhultp{* lhp ahuld {hup}eja kl {hup vpe}elt
dk}ipnmeauj vh}ktkhl, Ka {hu tejj ge tbnt {hu bnd lh bnld kl {hup vnpeltnie nld edumntkhl* nld tbnt kt k} tbepeahpe
ulou}t th jn{ tbe}e tbkli} th {hup mbnpie* K nl}yep tbnt
ybetbep {hup `ekli kl n mhl}ugvtkhl k} {hup anujt hp lh*
kt k} n anujt kl {hu* nld kt k} g{ dut{ th }ee tbnt ninkl}t
}umb anujt} n} tbk} tbe mhgghlyenjtb }bnjj `e vphtemted,
[hu gn{ }n{ tbnt kt k} {hup gk}ahptule th `e mpkgklnj3 Knl}yep tbnt kt k} {hup mpkge th `e ulahptulnte,
‒Jn}tj{* K }bhujd vhklt hut tbnt eqel tbhuib tbe oup{
bnd nm~uktted {hu—n }uvvh}ktkhl tbnt K mnllht }epkhu}j{
elteptnkl—K }bhujd bnqe aejt kt g{ dut{ th klajkmt n
}eltelme bnpdj{ je}} }eqepe tbnl tbnt ybkmb K gu}t vn}} nt
vpe}elt3 ahp tbe ghpe {hu bnd `eel ahuld iukjtje}} ha tbe
mpkge kgvuted th {hu* tbe ghpe {hu yhujd bnqe `eel
ahuld iukjt{ ha hle bnpdj{ je}} beklhu}—K genl tbe mpkge
ha bnqkli `eel gnjkiled ulou}tj{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 144/378
Epeybhl
>44 ha =9;
‒K dh lht be}ktnte tbepeahpe th }eltelme {hu th
kgvpk}hlgelt* yktb bnpd jn`hup* ahp tbe pe}t ha {hup gk}epn`je erk}telme, Dupkli tbnt vepkhd K yhujd enple}tj{
eltpent {hu th pevelt ha tbe yphli} {hu bnqe dhle
njpend{* nld th eltkpej{ peahpg tbe mhl}tktutkhl ha {hup
ybhje `hd{, K elteptnkl `ut jkttje bhve tbnt {hu ykjj vn{
ntteltkhl th g{ ndqkme3 {hu npe njpend{ anp thh n`nldhled,
Dkd kt pe}t yktb g{}eja* K }bhujd ndd lhtbkli kl gktkintkhlha tbe }eltelme ybkmb K bnqe vn}}ed* `ut kt k} tbe gepmkauj
vphqk}khl ha tbe jny tbnt eqel tbe gh}t bnpdeled mpkgklnj
}bnjj `e njjhyed }hge hle ha tbe tbpee haakmknj pegedke}*
ybkmb k} th `e vpe}mpk`ed nt tbe tkge ha bk} mhlqkmtkhl, K
}bnjj tbepeahpe hpdep tbnt {hu pemekqe tyh tn`je}vhhlauj} ha
mn}thp hkj dnkj{* ultkj tbe vjen}upe ha tbe mhupt `e auptbep clhyl,‛
Ybel tbe }eltelme yn} mhlmjuded tbe vpk}hlep
nmclhyjedied kl n aey }mnpmej{ nudk`je yhpd} tbnt be yn}
ou}tj{ vulk}bed* nld tbnt be bnd bnd n ankp tpknj, Be yn}
tbel peghqed th tbe vpk}hl aphg ybkmb be yn} leqep th
petupl, Tbepe yn} n }emhld nttegvt nt nvvjnu}e ybel tbe
oudie bnd aklk}bed }venckli* `ut n} `eahpe kt yn} nt hlme
pevpe}}ed3 nld tbhuib tbe aeejkli ha tbe mhupt yn} }tphlij{
ninkl}t tbe vpk}hlep* tbepe yn} lh }bhy ha nl{ qkhjelme
ninkl}t bkg* ka hle gn{ ermevt n jkttje bhhtkli aphg tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 145/378
Epeybhl
>45 ha =9;
`{}tnldep} ybel be yn} `ekli peghqed kl tbe vpk}hlep}‛
qnl, Kldeed* lhtbkli }tpumc ge ghpe dupkli g{ ybhje}hohupl kl tbe mhultp{* tbnl tbe ielepnj pe}vemt ahp jny
nld hpdep,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 146/378
Epeybhl
>41 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RKK? GNJMHLTELT]
K mhlae}} tbnt K aejt pntbep ulbnvv{ ybel K iht bhge*
nld tbhuibt ghpe mjh}ej{ hqep tbe tpknj tbnt K bnd ou}t
yktle}}ed, Ahp tbe tkge K yn} mnppked nyn{ `{ tbe hvklkhl
ha tbh}e nghli ybhg K yn}, Tbe{ bnd lh gk}ikqkli}
n`hut ybnt tbe{ yepe dhkli, Tbepe dkd lht }eeg th `e n
vep}hl kl tbe ybhje mhupt ybh bnd tbe }gnjje}t dhu`t `ut
tbnt njj yn} ernmtj{ n} kt }bhujd `e, Tbk} ulkqep}nj
ul}u}vemtkli mhlakdelme yn} kgvnpted `{ }{gvntb{ th
g{}eja* kl }vkte ha njj g{ tpnklkli kl hvklkhl} }h ykdej{
dkaaepelt, ]h kt k} yktb gh}t ha u}? tbnt ybkmb ye h`}epqe
th `e tncel n} n gnttep ha mhup}e `{ tbh}e nphuld u}* ye
tnce n} n gnttep ha mhup}e hup}ejqe}, Nld natep njj* kt k} hup
dut{ th dh tbk}* }nqe uvhl ipnqe hmmn}khl,
@ut ybel K yn} njhle* nld `einl th tbklc tbe tpknj
hqep* kt meptnklj{ dkd }tpkce ge n} `etpn{kli n }tpnlie nld
ulteln`je vh}ktkhl, Bnd tbe oudie }nkd tbnt be
nmclhyjedied tbe vph`n`je tputb* lngej{* tbnt tbe
vpk}hlep yn} `hpl ha ulbenjtb{ vnpelt}* hp bnd `eel
}tnpqed kl klanlm{* hp bnd get yktb }hge nmmkdelt} ybkmb
bnd deqejhved mhl}ugvtkhl3 nld bnd be tbel ihle hl th
}n{ tbnt tbhuib be cley njj tbk}* nld `kttepj{ peipetted tbnt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 147/378
Epeybhl
>49 ha =9;
tbe vphtemtkhl ha }hmket{ h`jkied bkg th klajkmt nddktkhlnj
vnkl hl hle ybh bnd }uaaeped }h gumb njpend{* {et tbnttbepe yn} lh bejv ahp kt* K mhujd bnqe uldep}thhd tbe
vh}ktkhl* bhyeqep gk}tncel K gkibt bnqe tbhuibt kt, Tbe
oudie yn} aujj{ vep}unded tbnt tbe klajkmtkhl ha vnkl uvhl
tbe yenc nld }kmcj{ yn} tbe hlj{ genl} ha vpeqeltkli
yencle}} nld }kmcjkle}} aphg }vpendkli* nld tbnt tel tkge}
tbe }uaaepkli lhy klajkmted uvhl tbe nmmu}ed yn}eqeltunjj{ ynpded haa aphg htbep} `{ tbe vpe}elt nvvnpelt
}eqepkt{, K mhujd tbepeahpe vepaemtj{ uldep}tnld bk}
klajkmtkli ybnteqep vnkl be gkibt mhl}kdep leme}}np{ kl
hpdep th vpeqelt }h `nd nl erngvje aphg }vpendkli auptbep
nld jhyepkli tbe Epeybhlknl }tnldnpd3 `ut kt }eeged
njgh}t mbkjdk}b th tejj tbe vpk}hlep tbnt be mhujd bnqe `eelkl ihhd benjtb* ka be bnd `eel ghpe ahptulnte kl bk}
mhl}tktutkhl* nld `eel ervh}ed th je}} bnpd}bkv} ybel be
yn} n `h{,
K ypkte yktb ipent dkaakdelme* `ut kt }eeg} th ge tbnt
tbepe k} lh ulankple}} kl vulk}bkli vehvje ahp tbekp
gk}ahptule}* hp peynpdkli tbeg ahp tbekp }beep ihhd jumc?
kt k} tbe lhpgnj mhldktkhl ha bugnl jkae tbnt tbk} }bhujd `e
dhle* nld lh pkibt'gklded vep}hl ykjj mhgvjnkl ha `ekli
}u`oemted th tbe mhgghl tpentgelt, Tbepe k} lh
njteplntkqe hvel th u}, Kt k} kdje th }n{ tbnt gel npe lht
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 148/378
Epeybhl
>42 ha =9;
pe}vhl}k`je ahp tbekp gk}ahptule}, Ybnt k} pe}vhl}k`kjkt{8
]upej{ th `e pe}vhl}k`je genl} th `e jkn`je th bnqe th ikqenl nl}yep }bhujd kt `e degnlded* nld njj tbkli} ybkmb
jkqe npe pe}vhl}k`je ahp tbekp jkqe} nld nmtkhl} }bhujd
}hmket{ }ee akt th ~ue}tkhl tbeg tbphuib tbe ghutb ha kt}
nutbhpk}ed nielt,
Ybnt k} tbe haaelme ha n jng` tbnt ye }bhujd penp kt*
nld teld kt* nld jujj kt klth }emupkt{* ahp tbe ervpe}}vupvh}e ha ckjjkli kt8 Kt} haaelme k} tbe gk}ahptule ha `ekli
}hgetbkli ybkmb }hmket{ ynlt} th ent* nld ybkmb mnllht
deaeld kt}eja, Tbk} k} ngvje, Ybh }bnjj jkgkt tbe pkibt ha
}hmket{ ermevt }hmket{ kt}eja8 Nld ybnt mhl}kdepntkhl ahp
tbe kldkqkdunj k} thjepn`je ulje}} }hmket{ `e tbe inklep
tbepe`{8 Ybepeahpe }bhujd n gnl `e }h pkmbj{ peynpdedahp bnqkli `eel }hl th n gkjjkhlnkpe* yepe kt lht mjenpj{
vphqn`je tbnt tbe mhgghl yejanpe k} tbu} `ettep auptbeped8
Ye mnllht }epkhu}j{ detpnmt aphg n gnl‛} gepkt kl bnqkli
`eel tbe }hl ha n pkmb antbep yktbhut kgvepkjjkli hup hyl
telupe ha tbkli} ybkmb ye dh lht yk}b th oehvnpdk}e3 ka
tbk} yepe htbepyk}e ye }bhujd lht jet bkg ceev bk} ghle{
ahp n }klije bhup3 ye yhujd bnqe kt hup}ejqe} nt hlme, Ahp
vphvept{ k} ph``ep{* `ut tbel* ye npe njj ph``ep} hp yhujd'
`e ph``ep} thietbep* nld bnqe ahuld kt e}}eltknj th hpinlk}e
hup tbkeqkli* n} ye bnqe ahuld kt leme}}np{ th hpinlk}e hup
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 149/378
Epeybhl
>4; ha =9;
ju}t nld hup peqelie, Vphvept{* gnppknie* tbe jny3 n} tbe
`ed th tbe pkqep* }h puje nld mhlqeltkhl th tbe kl}tklmt3nld yhe th bkg ybh tngvep} yktb tbe `nlc} ybkje tbe
ajhhd k} ajhykli,
@ut th petupl, Eqel kl Elijnld n gnl hl `hnpd n }bkv
yktb {ejjhy aeqep k} bejd pe}vhl}k`je ahp bk} gk}mbnlme* lh
gnttep ybnt bk} `ekli cevt kl ~unpnltkle gn{ mh}t bkg,
Be gn{ mntmb tbe aeqep nld dke3 ye mnllht bejv kt3 begu}t tnce bk} mbnlme n} htbep vehvje dh3 `ut }upej{ kt
yhujd `e de}vepnte ulckldle}} th ndd mhltugej{ th hup
}eja'vphtemtkhl* ulje}}* kldeed* ye `ejkeqe tbnt mhltugej{
k} hle ha hup `e}t genl} ha }eja'vphtemtkhl, Ninkl* tnce tbe
mn}e ha gnlknm}, Ye }n{ tbnt tbe{ npe kppe}vhl}k`je ahp tbekp
nmtkhl}* `ut ye tnce ihhd mnpe* hp huibt th tnce ihhdmnpe* tbnt tbe{ }bnjj nl}yep th u} ahp tbekp kl}nlkt{* nld ye
kgvpk}hl tbeg kl ybnt ye mnjj nl n}{jug tbnt ghdepl
}nlmtunp{.+ ka ye dh lht jkce tbekp nl}yep}, Tbk} k} n }tpnlie
ckld ha kppe}vhl}k`kjkt{, Ybnt ye huibt th }n{ k} tbnt ye
mnl naahpd th `e }ntk}aked yktb n je}} }ntk}anmthp{ nl}yep
aphg n julntkm tbnl aphg hle ybh k} lht gnd* `emnu}e
julnm{ k} je}} klaemtkhu} tbnl mpkge,
Ye ckjj n }epvelt ka ye ih kl dnliep `{ kt* }kgvj{ ahp
`ekli }umb nld }umb n }epvelt kl }umb nld }umb n vjnme3
`ut ye leqep }n{ tbnt tbe }epvelt bn} hlj{ kt}eja th `jnge
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 150/378
Epeybhl
>56 ha =9;
ahp lht bnqkli `eel n bnpgje}} mpentupe, Kt} mpkge k} tbnt ha
`ekli tbe tbkli ybkmb kt k}? `ut tbk} k} n mnvktnj haaelme*nld ye npe pkibt kl ckjjkli kt hut ha tbe yn{* ulje}} ye
tbklc kt ghpe dnliep th dh }h tbnl th jet kt e}mnve3
leqeptbeje}} ye vkt{ tbe mpentupe* eqel tbhuib ye ckjj kt,
@ut kl tbe mn}e ha bkg ybh}e tpknj K bnqe de}mpk`ed
n`hqe* kt yn} kgvh}}k`je tbnt nl{ hle kl tbe mhupt }bhujd
lht bnqe clhyl tbnt kt yn} `ut `{ nl nmmkdelt ha `kptb nldmkpmug}tnlme} tbnt be yn} lht bkg}eja nj}h kl n
mhl}ugvtkhl3 nld {et lhle tbhuibt tbnt kt dk}ipnmed tbeg
th benp tbe oudie ikqe qelt th tbe gh}t mpuej tpuk}g} n`hut
bkg, Tbe oudie bkg}eja yn} n ckld nld tbhuibtauj vep}hl,
Be yn} n gnl ha gnilkakmelt nld `elkil vpe}elme, Be
yn} eqkdeltj{ ha nl kphl mhl}tktutkhl* nld bk} anme yhpe nlervpe}}khl ha tbe gntupe}t yk}dhg nld ervepkelme3 {et ahp
njj tbk}* hjd nld jenpled n} be yn}* be mhujd lht }ee tbkli}
ybkmb hle yhujd bnqe tbhuibt yhujd bnqe `eel nvvnpelt
eqel th n mbkjd, Be mhujd lht egnlmkvnte bkg}eja aphg*
ln{* kt dkd lht eqel hmmup th bkg th aeej* tbe `hldnie ha
tbe kden} kl ybkmb be bnd `eel `hpl nld `ped,
]h yn} kt nj}h yktb tbe oup{ nld `{}tnldep}3 nld—gh}t
yhldepauj ha njj—}h yn} kt eqel yktb tbe vpk}hlep,
Tbphuibhut be }eeged aujj{ kgvpe}}ed yktb tbe lhtkhl
tbnt be yn} `ekli denjt yktb ou}tj{? be }ny lhtbkli ynlthl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 151/378
Epeybhl
>5> ha =9;
kl bk} `ekli thjd `{ tbe oudie tbnt be yn} th `e vulk}bed*
lht }h gumb n} n leme}}np{ vphtemtkhl th }hmket{ njtbhuibtbk} yn} lht eltkpej{ jh}t }kibt ha+* n} `emnu}e be bnd lht
`eel `ettep `hpl nld `ped tbnl be yn}, @ut tbk} jed ge th
bhve tbnt be }uaaeped je}} tbnl be yhujd bnqe dhle ka be
bnd }eel tbe gnttep kl tbe }nge jkibt tbnt K dkd, Nld* natep
njj* ou}tkme k} pejntkqe,
K gn{ bepe geltkhl tbnt hlj{ n aey {enp} `eahpe g{nppkqnj kl tbe mhultp{* tbe tpentgelt ha njj mhlqkmted
klqnjkd} bnd `eel gumb ghpe `np`nphu} tbnl lhy* ahp lh
vb{}kmnj peged{ yn} vphqkded* nld vpk}hlep} yepe vut th
tbe }eqepe}t jn`hup kl njj }hpt} ha yentbep* }h tbnt gh}t ha
tbeg }hhl }ummug`ed th tbe ertpege bnpd}bkv} ybkmb
tbe{ }uaaeped3 tbk} yn} }uvvh}ed th `e `eleakmknj kl }hgeyn{}* kln}gumb n} kt vut tbe mhultp{ th je}} ervel}e ahp
tbe gnkltelnlme ha kt} mpkgklnj mjn}}3 `ut tbe iphytb ha
jurup{ bnd kldumed n pejnrntkhl ha tbe hjd }eqepkt{* nld n
}el}ktkqe nie yhujd lh jhliep thjepnte ybnt nvvenped th `e
nl erme}} ha pkihup* eqel thynpd} tbe gh}t iukjt{3
ghpehqep* kt yn} ahuld tbnt oupke} yepe je}} ykjjkli th
mhlqkmt* nld ou}tkme yn} hatel mbented `emnu}e tbepe yn}
lh njteplntkqe `etyeel qkptunjj{ mhldeglkli n gnl th
dentb nld jettkli bkg ih apee3 kt yn} nj}h bejd tbnt tbe
mhultp{ vnkd kl pemhggkttnj} ahp kt} hqep'}eqepkt{3 ahp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 152/378
Epeybhl
>50 ha =9;
tbh}e ybh bnd `eel kgvpk}hled eqel ahp tpkajkli nkjgelt}
yepe hatel vepgnleltj{ dk}n`jed `{ tbekp kgvpk}hlgelt3nld ybel n gnl bnd `eel hlme mhlqkmted* kt yn} vph`n`je
tbnt be yhujd }ejdhg natepynpd} `e haa tbe bnld} ha tbe
mhultp{,
Tbe}e eqkj} bnd jhli `eel nvvnpelt nld pemhilk}ed3 {et
vehvje yepe thh kldhjelt* nld thh kldkaaepelt th }uaaepkli
lht tbekp hyl* th `e}tkp tbeg}ejqe} n`hut vuttkli nl eldth tbeg* ultkj nt jn}t n `eleqhjelt peahpgep deqhted bk}
ybhje jkae th eaaemtkli tbe leme}}np{ mbnlie}, Be dkqkded
njj kjjle}}e} klth tbpee mjn}}e}— tbh}e naaemtkli tbe bend*
tbe tpulc* nld tbe jhyep jkg`}—nld h`tnkled nl
elnmtgelt tbnt njj dk}en}e} ha tbe bend* ybetbep klteplnj hp
erteplnj* }bhujd `e tpented yktb jnudnlug* tbh}e ha tbe`hd{ yktb mn}thp'hkj* nld tbh}e ha tbe jhyep jkg`} yktb nl
eg`phmntkhl ha }tphli }ujvbupkm nmkd nld yntep,
Kt gn{ `e }nkd tbnt tbe mjn}}kakmntkhl yn} lht }uaakmkeltj{
mnpeauj* nld tbnt tbe pegedke} yepe kjj mbh}el3 `ut kt k} n
bnpd tbkli th klktknte nl{ peahpg* nld kt yn} leme}}np{ th
angkjknpk}e tbe vu`jkm gkld yktb tbe vpklmkvje* `{ kl}eptkli
tbe tbkl eld ha tbe yedie akp}t? kt k} lht* tbepeahpe* th `e
yhldeped nt tbnt nghli }h vpnmtkmnj n vehvje tbepe }bhujd
}tkjj `e }hge phhg ahp kgvphqegelt, Tbe gn}} ha tbe
lntkhl npe yejj vjen}ed yktb erk}tkli nppnliegelt}* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 153/378
Epeybhl
>5= ha =9;
`ejkeqe tbnt tbekp tpentgelt ha mpkgklnj} jenqe} jkttje hp
lhtbkli th `e de}kped3 `ut tbepe k} nl elepietkm gklhpkt{ybh bhjd ybnt npe mhl}kdeped th `e ertpege hvklkhl}*
nld ybh npe lht nt njj dk}vh}ed th pe}t mhltelted ultkj tbe
vpklmkvje jntej{ ndgktted bn} `eel mnppked auptbep,
K yn} nt }hge vnkl} th dk}mhqep tbe hvklkhl} ha tbe}e
gel* nld tbekp pen}hl} ahp elteptnklkli tbeg, Tbe{ npe
bejd kl ipent hdkug `{ tbe ielepnjkt{ ha tbe vu`jkm* nldnpe mhl}kdeped n} }u`qeptep} ha njj ghpnjkt{ ybnteqep, Tbe
gnjmhltelt}* hl tbe htbep bnld* n}}ept tbnt kjjle}} k} tbe
kleqktn`je pe}ujt ha meptnkl nltemedelt mnu}e}* ybkmb* kl tbe
ipent gnohpkt{ ha mn}e}* yepe `e{hld tbe mhltphj ha tbe
kldkqkdunj* nld tbnt tbepeahpe n gnl k} hlj{ iukjt{ ahp
`ekli kl n mhl}ugvtkhl kl tbe }nge yn{ n} phttel apukt k}iukjt{ ahp bnqkli ihle phttel, Tpue* tbe apukt gu}t `e
tbphyl hl hle }kde n} ulakt ahp gnl‛} u}e* nld tbe gnl kl
n mhl}ugvtkhl gu}t `e vut kl vpk}hl ahp tbe vphtemtkhl ha
bk} aejjhy'mktkzel}3 `ut tbe}e pndkmnj} yhujd lht vulk}b
bkg auptbep tbnl `{ jh}} ha jk`ept{ nld n }tpkmt }upqekjjnlme,
]h jhli n} be yn} vpeqelted aphg kloupkli }hmket{* tbe{
yhujd njjhy bkg th gnce bkg}eja u}eauj `{ }uvvj{kli
ybnteqep ha }hmket{‛} ynlt} be mhujd }uvvj{, Ka be
}ummeeded kl tbu} enplkli ghle{* tbe{ yhujd bnqe bkg
gnde n} mhgahptn`je kl vpk}hl n} vh}}k`je* nld yhujd kl lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 154/378
Epeybhl
>54 ha =9;
yn{ kltepaepe yktb bk} jk`ept{ ghpe tbnl yn} leme}}np{ th
vpeqelt bkg aphg e}mnvkli* hp aphg `emhgkli ghpe}eqepej{ kldk}vh}ed yktbkl tbe vpk}hl ynjj}3 `ut tbe{
yhujd dedumt aphg bk} enplkli} tbe ervel}e} ha bk} `hnpd*
jhdikli* }upqekjjnlme* nld bnja tbh}e ha bk} mhlqkmtkhl, Ka
be yn} thh kjj th dh nl{tbkli ahp bk} }uvvhpt kl vpk}hl*
tbe{ yhujd njjhy bkg lhtbkli `ut `pend nld yntep* nld
qep{ jkttje ha tbnt,Tbe{ }n{ tbnt }hmket{ k} ahhjk}b kl peau}kli th njjhy kt}eja
th `e `eleakted `{ n gnl gepej{ `emnu}e be bn} dhle kt
bnpg bktbepth* nld tbnt h`oemtkhl th tbe jn`hup ha tbe
dk}en}ed mjn}}e} k} hlj{ vphtemtkhl kl nlhtbep ahpg, Kt k} nl
nttegvt th pnk}e tbe lntupnj vpkme ha n mhgghdkt{ `{ }n{kli
tbnt }umb nld }umb vep}hl}* ybh npe n`je nld ykjjkli thvphdume kt* }bnjj lht dh }h* ybepe`{ eqep{ hle bn} th vn{
ghpe ahp kt,
@e}kde}* }h jhli n} n gnl bn} lht `eel nmtunjj{ ckjjed be
k} hup aejjhy'mpentupe* tbhuib vepbnv} n qep{ ulvjen}nlt
hle, Kt k} kl n ipent deipee tbe dhkli ha htbep} tbnt be k}
ybnt be k}* hp kl htbep yhpd}* tbe }hmket{ ybkmb lhy
mhldegl} bkg k} vnptj{ nl}yepn`je mhlmeplkli bkg, Tbe{
}n{ tbnt tbepe k} lh aenp ha nl{ klmpen}e ha dk}en}e uldep
tbe}e mkpmug}tnlme}3 ahp tbe jh}} ha jk`ept{* tbe }upqekjjnlme*
tbe mhl}kdepn`je nld mhgvuj}hp{ dedumtkhl aphg tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 155/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 156/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 157/378
Epeybhl
>59 ha =9;
vpeteld th }n{* tbe{ tbklc tbnt tbe ghpe gedkmklnj nld
bugnle tpentgelt ha tbe dk}en}ed ha ybkmb tbe{ npe tbendqhmnte} yhujd kl tbe jhli pul `e gumb mbenvep th tbe
mhultp{? `ut K dkd lht intbep tbnt tbe}e peahpgep} yepe
hvvh}ed th geetkli }hge ha tbe ghpe qkhjelt ahpg} ha
kjjle}} yktb tbe mnt'ha' lkle'tnkj}* hp yktb dentb3 ahp tbe{
}ny lh }h eaaemtunj yn{ ha mbemckli tbeg3 tbe{ yhujd
tbepeahpe `htb ajhi nld bnli* `ut tbe{ yhujd dh }hvktkaujj{,
K bnqe vepbnv} dyejt thh jhli uvhl hvklkhl} ybkmb
mnl bnqe lh vh}}k`je `enpkli uvhl hup hyl* `ut K bnqe
lht }nkd tbe teltb vnpt ha ybnt tbe}e yhujd'`e peahpgep}
upied uvhl ge, K aeej* bhyeqep* tbnt K bnqe }uaakmkeltj{
tpe}vn}}ed uvhl tbe ntteltkhl ha tbe pendep,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 158/378
Epeybhl
>52 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RKKK? TBE QKEY] HA TBE EPEYBHLKNL] MHLMEPLKLI DENTB
Tbe Epeybhlknl} peinpd dentb yktb je}} n`bhppelme
tbnl dk}en}e, Ka kt k} nl haaelme nt njj* kt k} hle `e{hld tbe
penmb ha tbe jny* ybkmb k} tbepeahpe }kjelt hl tbe }u`oemt3
`ut tbe{ kl}k}t tbnt tbe ipentep lug`ep ha tbh}e ybh npe
mhgghlj{ }nkd th dke* bnqe leqep {et `eel `hpl—lht* nt
jen}t* klth tbnt ul}eel yhpjd ybkmb k} njhle yhptb{ ha
mhl}kdepntkhl, N} peinpd} tbk} ul}eel yhpjd K uldep}tnld
tbeg th }n{ tbnt }hge gk}mnpp{ kl pe}vemt th kt `eahpe tbe{
bnqe eqel penmbed tbe }eel* nld }hge natep* ybkje aey npe
eqep tpuj{ `hpl klth kt nt njj—tbe ipentep vnpt ha njj tbe
gel nld yhgel hqep tbe ybhje mhultp{ gk}mnpp{kli
`eahpe tbe{ penmb kt, Nld tbe{ }n{ tbnt tbk} dhe} lht gnttep
}h gumb n} ye tbklc kt dhe},
N} ahp ybnt ye mnjj dentb* tbe{ npiue tbnt thh gumb bn}
`eel gnde ha kt, Tbe gepe clhyjedie tbnt ye }bnjj hle
dn{ dke dhe} lht gnce u} qep{ ulbnvv{3 lh hle tbklc}
tbnt be hp }be ykjj e}mnve* }h tbnt lhle npe dk}nvvhklted,Ye dh lht mnpe ipentj{ eqel tbhuib ye clhy tbnt ye
bnqe lht jhli th jkqe3 tbe hlj{ tbkli tbnt yhujd }epkhu}j{
naaemt u} yhujd `e tbe clhykli—hp pntbep tbklckli tbnt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 159/378
Epeybhl
>5; ha =9;
ye clhy— tbe vpemk}e ghgelt nt ybkmb tbe `jhy ykjj
anjj, Bnvvkj{ lh hle mnl eqep meptnklj{ clhy tbk}* tbhuibgnl{ tp{ th gnce tbeg}ejqe} gk}epn`je `{ eldenqhupkli
th akld kt hut, Kt }eeg} n} tbhuib tbepe yepe }hge vhyep
}hgeybepe ybkmb gepmkaujj{ }tn{} u} aphg vuttkli tbnt
}tkli klth tbe tnkj ha dentb* ybkmb ye yhujd vut tbepe ka
ye mhujd* nld ybkmb el}upe} tbnt tbhuib dentb gu}t
njyn{} `e n `ui`enp* kt }bnjj leqep uldep nl{ mhlmekqn`jemkpmug}tnlme} `e ghpe tbnl n `ui`enp,
Ahp eqel tbhuib n gnl k} mhldegled th dke kl n
yeec‛} tkge nld k} }but uv kl n vpk}hl aphg ybkmb kt k}
meptnkl tbnt be mnllht e}mnve* be ykjj njyn{} bhve tbnt n
pevpkeqe gn{ mhge `eahpe tbe yeec k} hqep, @e}kde}* tbe
vpk}hl gn{ mntmb akpe* nld be gn{ `e }uaahmnted lht yktb nphve* `ut yktb mhgghl hpdklnp{ }ghce3 hp be gn{ `e
}tpumc dend `{ jkibtlkli ybkje erepmk}kli kl tbe vpk}hl
{npd}, Ybel tbe ghplkli k} mhge hl ybkmb tbe vhhp
ypetmb k} th `e bnlied* be gn{ mbhce nt bk} `pencan}t* hp
dke aphg ankjupe ha tbe benpt‛} nmtkhl `eahpe tbe dphv bn}
anjjel3 nld eqel tbhuib kt bn} anjjel* be mnllht `e ~ukte
meptnkl tbnt be k} ihkli th dke* ahp be mnllht clhy tbk} tkjj
bk} dentb bn} nmtunjj{ tncel vjnme* nld kt ykjj `e thh jnte
tbel ahp bkg th dk}mhqep tbnt be yn} ihkli th dke nt tbe
nvvhklted bhup natep njj, Tbe Epeybhlknl}* tbepeahpe* bhjd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 160/378
Epeybhl
>16 ha =9;
tbnt dentb* jkce jkae* k} nl naankp ha `ekli ghpe apkibteled
tbnl bupt,Tbe{ `upl tbekp dend* nld tbe n}be} npe vpe}eltj{
}mntteped hqep nl{ vkeme ha iphuld ybkmb tbe demen}ed
gn{ bkg}eja bnqe mbh}el, Lh hle k} vepgktted th peau}e
tbk} bh}vktnjkt{ th tbe dend? vehvje* tbepeahpe* ielepnjj{
mbhh}e }hge inpdel hp hpmbnpd ybkmb tbe{ gn{ bnqe
clhyl nld `eel ahld ha ybel tbe{ yepe {huli, Tbe}uvep}tktkhu} bhjd tbnt tbh}e ybh}e n}be} npe }mntteped hqep
nl{ jnld `emhge kt} oenjhu} iunpdknl} aphg tbnt tkge
ahpynpd3 nld tbe jkqkli jkce th tbklc tbnt tbe{ }bnjj
`emhge kdeltkaked yktb tbk} hp tbnt jhmnjkt{ ybepe tbe{
bnqe hlme `eel bnvv{,
Tbe{ dh lht vut uv ghlugelt}* lhp ypkte evktnvb}*ahp tbekp dend* tbhuib kl ahpgep nie} tbekp vpnmtkme yn}
gumb n} hup}* `ut tbe{ bnqe n mu}thg ybkmb mhge} th
gumb tbe }nge tbkli* ahp tbe kl}tklmt ha vpe}epqkli tbe
lnge njkqe natep tbe dentb ha tbe `hd{ }eeg} th `e
mhgghl th njj gnlckld, Tbe{ bnqe }tntue} ha tbeg}ejqe}
gnde ybkje tbe{ npe }tkjj njkqe tbh}e* tbnt k}* ybh mnl
naahpd kt+* nld ypkte kl}mpkvtkhl} uldep tbeg* ybkmb npe
hatel ~ukte n} ultputbauj n} npe hup hyl evktnvb}—hlj{ kl
nlhtbep yn{, Ahp tbe{ dh lht be}ktnte th de}mpk`e
tbeg}ejqe} n} qkmtkg} th kjj tegvep* oenjhu}{* mhqethu}le}}*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 161/378
Epeybhl
>1> ha =9;
nld tbe jkce* `ut njgh}t njyn{} jn{ mjnkg th vep}hlnj
`enut{* ybetbep tbe{ bnqe kt hp lht* nld* hatel* th tbevh}}e}}khl ha n jnpie }ug kl tbe aulded de`t ha tbe
mhultp{, Ka n vep}hl k} uij{ be dhe} lht }kt n} n ghdej ahp
bk} hyl }tntue* njtbhuib kt `enp} bk} lnge, Be iet} tbe
bnld}hge}t ha bk} apkeld} th }kt ahp bkg* nld hle ha tbe
yn{} ha vn{kli n mhgvjkgelt th nlhtbep k} th n}c bkg th
}kt ahp }umb n }tntue, Yhgel ielepnjj{ }kt ahp tbekp hyl}tntue}* aphg n lntupnj dk}klmjklntkhl th ndgkt tbe }uvepkhp
`enut{ ha n apkeld* `ut tbe{ ervemt th `e kdenjk}ed, K
uldep}thhd tbnt tbe gujtktude ha tbe}e }tntue} yn}
`eikllkli th `e aejt n} nl elmug`pnlme kl njgh}t eqep{
angkj{* nld tbnt tbe mu}thg yhujd vph`n`j{ `eahpe jhli
anjj klth de}uetude,Kldeed* tbk} bn} njpend{ mhge n`hut th tbe }ntk}anmtkhl
ha eqep{ hle* n} peinpd} tbe }tntue} ha vu`jkm gel—lht
ghpe tbnl tbpee ha ybkmb mnl `e ahuld kl tbe ybhje
mnvktnj, K ervpe}}ed g{ }upvpk}e nt tbk}* nld yn} thjd tbnt
}hge akqe buldped {enp} `eahpe g{ qk}kt* tbe mkt{ bnd `eel
}h hqeppul yktb tbe}e ve}t}* tbnt tbepe yn} lh iettkli
n`hut* nld vehvje yepe yhppked `e{hld eldupnlme `{
bnqkli tbekp ntteltkhl mnjjed nt eqep{ thumb nld tupl th
}hgetbkli* ybkmb* ybel tbe{ bnd nttelded th kt* tbe{
ahuld lht th mhlmepl tbeg, Gh}t ha tbe}e }tntue} yepe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 162/378
Epeybhl
>10 ha =9;
gepe nttegvt} th dh ahp }hge gnl hp yhgnl ybnt nl
nlkgnj'}tuaaep dhe} ghpe }umme}}aujj{ ahp n dhi* hp `kpd* hp vkce, Tbe{ yepe ielepnjj{ ahk}ted hl tbe vu`jkm `{ }hge
mhtepke tbnt yn} tp{kli th ernjt kt}eja kl ernjtkli }hge hle
ej}e* nld lht ulape~ueltj{ tbe{ bnd lh htbep klmevtkhl
tbnl de}kpe hl tbe vnpt ha }hge geg`ep ha tbe mhtepke th
akld n oh` ahp n {huli }mujvthp th ybhg bk} dnuibtep yn}
elinied, ]tntue} }h `eihttel mhujd leqep `e nl{tbkli `utdeahpgktke}* nld tbk} k} tbe yn{ kl ybkmb tbe{ npe }upe th
`e `eihttel* n} }hhl n} tbe npt ha gnckli tbeg nt njj bn}
`emhge ykdej{ vpnmtk}ed,
K clhy lht yb{* `ut njj tbe lh`je}t npt} bhjd kl
vepaemtkhl `ut ahp n qep{ jkttje ghgelt, Tbe{ }hhl penmb n
bekibt aphg ybkmb tbe{ `eikl th demjkle* nld ybel tbe{bnqe `eiul th demjkle kt k} n vkt{ tbnt tbe{ mnllht `e
clhmced hl tbe bend3 ahp nl npt k} jkce n jkqkli hpinlk}g—
`ettep dend tbnl d{kli, Tbepe k} lh yn{ ha gnckli nl
nied npt {huli ninkl3 kt gu}t `e `hpl nley nld iphy uv
aphg klanlm{ n} n ley tbkli* yhpckli hut kt} hyl }njqntkhl
aphg eaahpt th eaahpt kl njj aenp nld tpeg`jkli,
Tbe Epeybhlknl} akqe buldped {enp} nih uldep}thhd
lhtbkli ha njj tbk}—K dhu`t ybetbep tbe{ eqel dh }h lhy,
Tbe{ ynlted th iet tbe lenpe}t tbkli tbe{ mhujd th n
}tuaaed gnl ybh}e }tuaakli }bhujd lht iphy ghujd{, Tbe{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 163/378
Epeybhl
>1= ha =9;
}bhujd bnqe bnd }hge }umb nl e}tn`jk}bgelt n} hup
Gndnge Tu}}nud‛}* ybepe tbe akiupe} yenp penj mjhtbe}*nld npe vnklted uv th lntupe, ]umb nl kl}tktutkhl gkibt
bnqe `eel gnde }eja'}uvvhptkli* ahp vehvje gkibt bnqe
`eel gnde th vn{ `eahpe ihkli kl, N} kt yn}* tbe{ bnd jet
tbekp vhhp mhjd ipkg{ mhjhupje}} bephe} nld bephkle} jhna
n`hut kl }~unpe} nld kl mhplep} ha }tpeet} kl njj yentbep}*
yktbhut nl{ nttegvt nt nptk}tkm }nlktntkhl—ahp tbepe yn} lhvphqk}khl ahp `up{kli tbekp dend yhpc} ha npt hut ha tbekp
}kibt—lh dpnklnie* }h th }venc* ybepe`{ }tntue} tbnt bnd
`eel }uaakmkeltj{ n}}kgkjnted* }h n} th ahpg vnpt ha tbe
pe}kdunp{ kgvpe}}khl ha tbe mhultp{* gkibt `e mnppked nyn{
hut ha tbe }{}teg, Belme tbe{ vut tbeg uv yktb n jkibt
benpt hl tbe mnmcjkli ha tbekp mhtepke}* nld tbe{ nld tbekp mbkjdpel bnd th jkqe* hatel elhuib* yktb }hge yhpd{
ykld`ni ybh}e mhynpdkme bnd mh}t tbe mhultp{ ulthjd
jh}} kl `jhhd nld ghle{,
Nt jn}t tbe eqkj penmbed }umb n vktmb tbnt tbe vehvje
ph}e* nld yktb kldk}mpkgklnte aup{ de}tph{ed ihhd nld `nd
njkce, Gh}t ha ybnt yn} de}tph{ed yn} `nd* `ut }hge aey
yhpc} yepe ihhd* nld tbe }mujvthp} ha th'dn{ ypkli tbekp
bnld} hqep }hge ha tbe apnigelt} tbnt bnqe `eel
vpe}epqed kl gu}eug} uv nld dhyl tbe mhultp{, Ahp n
mhuvje ha buldped {enp} hp }h* lht n }tntue yn} gnde aphg
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 164/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 165/378
Epeybhl
>15 ha =9;
anqhup ha tbe peteltkhl ha tbe }tntue* kt yn} th `e
de}tph{ed,Vepbnv} n }kgvjep vjnl yhujd bnqe `eel th ahp`kd tbe
epemtkhl ha n }tntue th nl{ vu`jkm gnl hp yhgnl tkjj be hp
}be bnd `eel dend nt jen}t hle buldped {enp}* nld eqel
tbel th kl}k}t hl pemhl}kdepntkhl ha tbe mjnkg} ha tbe
demen}ed nld tbe gepkt ha tbe }tntue eqep{ akat{ {enp}—`ut
tbe yhpckli ha tbe Nmt `phuibt n`hut pe}ujt} tbnt hl tbeybhje yepe }ntk}anmthp{, Ahp kl tbe akp}t vjnme* gnl{ vu`jkm
}tntue} tbnt yhujd bnqe `eel qhted uldep tbe hjd }{}teg*
yepe lht hpdeped* ybel kt yn} clhyl tbnt tbe{ yhujd `e
njgh}t meptnklj{ `phcel uv natep akat{ {enp}* nld kl tbe
}emhld* vu`jkm }mujvthp} clhykli tbekp yhpc th `e }h
evbegepnj* }mngved kt th nl ertelt tbnt gnde kt haael}kqeeqel th tbe gh}t ulmujtuped e{e, Belme `eahpe jhli
}u`}mpk`ep} thhc th vn{kli tbe }mujvthp ahp tbe }tntue ha
tbekp dend }tnte}gel* hl mhldktkhl tbnt be dkd lht gnce kt,
Tbe tpk`ute ha pe}vemt yn} tbu} vnkd th tbe demen}ed* tbe
vu`jkm }mujvthp} yepe lht gujmted* nld tbe pe}t ha tbe
vu`jkm }uaaeped lh klmhlqelkelme,
K yn} thjd* bhyeqep* tbnt nl n`u}e ha tbk} mu}thg k}
iphykli uv* kln}gumb n} tbe mhgvetktkhl ahp tbe
mhggk}}khl lht th gnce n }tntue k} }h ceel* tbnt }mujvthp}
bnqe `eel clhyl th petupl n mhl}kdepn`je vnpt ha tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 166/378
Epeybhl
>11 ha =9;
vupmbn}e ghle{ th tbe }u`}mpk`ep}* `{ nl nppnliegelt
gnde yktb tbeg `eahpebnld, ]umb tpnl}nmtkhl}* bhyeqep*npe njyn{} mjnlde}tkle, N }gnjj kl}mpkvtkhl k} jet klth tbe
vnqegelt* ybepe tbe vu`jkm }tntue yhujd bnqe }thhd*
ybkmb klahpg} tbe pendep tbnt }umb n }tntue bn} `eel
hpdeped ahp tbe vep}hl* ybheqep be hp }be gn{ `e* `ut
tbnt n} {et tbe }mujvthp bn} lht `eel n`je th mhgvjete kt,
Tbepe bn} `eel lh Nmt th pevpe}} }tntue} tbnt npe klteldedahp vpkqnte mhl}ugvtkhl* `ut n} K bnqe }nkd* tbe mu}thg k}
anjjkli klth de}uetude,
Petuplkli th Epeybhlknl mu}thg} kl mhllemtkhl yktb
dentb* tbepe k} hle ybkmb K mnl bnpdj{ vn}} hqep, Ybel
nl{ hle dke}* tbe apkeld} ha tbe angkj{ ypkte lh jettep} ha
mhldhjelme* lektbep dh tbe{ ntteld tbe }mnttepkli* lhp yenp ghuplkli* `ut tbe{ }eld jkttje `hre} akjjed yktb
nptkakmknj tenp}* nld yktb tbe lnge ha tbe }eldep vnklted
lentj{ uvhl tbe hut}kde ha tbe jkd, Tbe tenp} qnp{ kl
lug`ep aphg tyh th akateel hp }krteel* nmmhpdkli th
deipee ha kltkgnm{ hp pejntkhl}bkv3 nld vehvje }hgetkge}
akld kt n lkme vhklt ha etk~uette th clhy tbe ernmt lug`ep
ybkmb tbe{ huibt th }eld, ]tpnlie n} kt gn{ nvvenp* tbk}
ntteltkhl k} bkibj{ qnjued* nld kt} hgk}}khl `{ tbh}e aphg
ybhg kt gkibt `e ervemted k} ceelj{ aejt, Tbe}e tenp}
yepe ahpgepj{ }tumc yktb ndbe}kqe vjn}tep th tbe mbeec} ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 167/378
Epeybhl
>19 ha =9;
tbe `epenqed* nld yepe yhpl kl vu`jkm ahp n aey ghltb}
natep tbe dentb ha n pejntkqe3 tbe{ yepe tbel `nlk}bed thtbe bnt hp `hllet* nld npe lhy lh jhliep yhpl,
Tbe `kptb ha n mbkjd k} jhhced uvhl n} n vnklauj }u`oemt
hl ybkmb kt k} ckldep lht th thumb? tbe kjjle}} ha tbe
ghtbep k} mnpeaujj{ mhlmenjed ultkj tbe leme}}kt{ ahp }kilkli
tbe `kptb'ahpgujn ha ybkmb bepenatep+ peldep} auptbep
}empem{ kgvh}}k`je* nld ahp }hge ghltb} `eahpe tbe eqelttbe angkj{ jkqe kl petkpegelt* }eekli qep{ jkttje mhgvnl{,
Ybel tbe haaelme k} hqep nld dhle yktb* kt k} mhldhled
`{ tbe mhgghl ynlt ha jhikm3 ahp tbk} gepmkauj vphqk}khl
ha lntupe* tbk} `uaaep ninkl}t mhjjk}khl}* tbk} apkmtkhl ybkmb
uv}et} hup mnjmujntkhl} `ut yktbhut ybkmb erk}telme yhujd
`e klthjepn`je* tbk} mphylkli ijhp{ ha bugnl klqeltkhlybepe`{ ye mnl `e `jkld nld }ee nt hle nld tbe }nge
ghgelt* tbk} `je}}ed klmhl}k}telm{* erk}t} bepe n}
ej}eybepe3 nld tbhuib tbe }tpkmte}t ypktep} hl ghpnjkt{
bnqe gnkltnkled tbnt kt k} ykmced ahp n yhgnl th bnqe
mbkjdpel nt njj* kln}gumb n} kt k} yphli th `e hut ha benjtb
tbnt ihhd gn{ mhge* {et tbe leme}}kt{ ha tbe mn}e bn}
mnu}ed n ielepnj aeejkli kl anqhup ha vn}}kli hqep }umb
eqelt} kl }kjelme* nld ha n}}ugkli tbekp lhl'erk}telme
ermevt kl }umb ajnipnlt mn}e} n} ahpme tbeg}ejqe} hl tbe
vu`jkm lhtkme, Ninkl}t tbe}e tbe mhldeglntkhl ha }hmket{ k}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 168/378
Epeybhl
>12 ha =9;
klerhpn`je* nld ka kt k} `ejkeqed tbnt tbe kjjle}} bn} `eel
dnliephu} nld vphtpnmted* kt k} njgh}t kgvh}}k`je ahp nyhgnl th pemhqep bep ahpgep vh}ktkhl kl }hmket{,
Tbe n`hqe mhlqeltkhl} }tpumc ge n} np`ktpnp{ nld
mpuej* `ut tbe{ vut n }thv th gnl{ anlmked nkjgelt}3 ahp tbe
}ktuntkhl* }h anp aphg `ekli mhl}kdeped kltepe}tkli* k}
jhhced uvhl n} }nqhupkli ghpe hp je}} dk}tklmtj{ ha n qep{
pevpebel}k`je mhldktkhl ha tbkli}* nld tbe jndke} tnce mnpeth mhlmenj kt n} jhli n} tbe{ mnl eqel aphg tbekp hyl
bu}`nld}* kl nltkmkvntkhl ha n }eqepe }mhjdkli n} }hhl n} tbe
gk}degenlhup k} dk}mhqeped, Nj}h tbe `n`{ k} cevt hut ha
}kibt* ermevt hl tbe dn{ ha }kilkli tbe `kptb'ahpgujn* ultkj
kt mnl ynjc nld tnjc, ]bhujd tbe mbkjd ulbnvvkj{ dke* n
mhphlep‛} kl~ue}t k} kleqktn`je* `ut kl hpdep th nqhkddk}ipnmkli n angkj{ ybkmb gn{ bnqe `eel bktbepth
pe}vemted* kt k} njgh}t klqnpkn`j{ ahuld tbnt tbe mbkjd yn}
hqep }eqelt{'akqe {enp} hjd* nld dked aphg tbe demn{ ha
lntupe,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 169/378
Epeybhl
>1; ha =9;
MBNVTEP RKQ? GNBNKLN
K mhltklued g{ }hohupl yktb tbe Lh}lk`hp}, Kl n aey
dn{} Gp, Lh}lk`hp bnd pemhqeped aphg bk} ajhiikli* nld
yn} jhhckli ahpynpd yktb ijee th tbe anmt tbnt tbe lert
yhujd `e tbe jn}t, K dkd lht tbklc tbnt tbepe }eeged nl{
hmmn}khl eqel ahp tbk}3 `ut be }nkd kt yn} `ettep th `e hl
tbe }nae }kde* nld be yhujd gnce uv tbe dhzel, Be lhy
yelt th bk} `u}kle}} n} u}unj3 nld K uldep}thhd tbnt be yn}
leqep ghpe vph}vephu}* kl }vkte ha bk} benq{ akle, Be yn}
uln`je th ikqe ge gumb ha bk} tkge dupkli tbe dn{3 ahp be
yn} hle ha tbh}e qnjun`je gel ybh npe vnkd* lht `{ tbe
{enp* ghltb* yeec* hp dn{* `ut `{ tbe gklute, Bk} ykae
nld dnuibtep}* bhyeqep* gnde gumb ha ge* nld
kltphdumed ge th tbekp apkeld}* ybh mnge kl }bhnj} th mnjj
uvhl ge,
Hle ha tbe}e vep}hl} yn} n jnd{ mnjjed Gnbnkln, _ujhpn
tbe ejdep ha g{ bh}t‛} dnuibtep}+ pnl uv th bep nld
eg`pnmed bep n} }hhl n} }be elteped tbe phhg* nt tbe }nge
tkge kl~ukpkli teldepj{ natep bep ‒vhhp dkv}hgnlkn,‛
Gnbnkln nl}yeped tbnt kt yn} ou}t n} `nd n} eqep3 }be yn} n
vepaemt gnpt{p th kt* nld bep ermejjelt benjtb yn} tbe hlj{
tbkli ybkmb mhl}hjed bep uldep bep naajkmtkhl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 170/378
Epeybhl
>96 ha =9;
Tbel tbe htbep jndke} ohkled kl yktb mhldhjelme} nld
tbe leqep' ankjkli }uiie}tkhl} ybkmb tbe{ bnd pend{ ahp eqep{ geltnj gnjnd{, Tbe{ pemhggelded tbekp hyl
}tpnkibtelep nld dk}vnpnied Gnbnkln‛}, Gp}, Lh}lk`hp bnd
n anqhupkte lh}tpug* `ut K mhujd mntmb jkttje ha kt} lntupe, K
benpd tbe yhpd} ‒aujj mhlakdelme tbnt tbe de}kpe th dpklc
ykjj men}e ybel tbe ahpgujn bn} `eel pevented / / / tbk}
mhlakdelme k} EQEP[TBKLI / / / anp aphguldepqnjukli n tbhphuib detepgklntkhl leqep th thumb
}vkpkt} ninkl / / / ankj thh hatel / / / ahpgujn n
MEPTNKL MUPE yktb ipent egvbn}k}+ / / / vpe}mpk`ed
ahpg / / / aujj mhlqkmtkhl,‛ Tbe mhlqep}ntkhl tbel `emnge
ghpe nudk`je* nld yn} mnppked hl nt mhl}kdepn`je jelitb, K
}bhujd vepvjer g{}eja nld tbe pendep `{ eldenqhupkli thahjjhy tbe klielkhu} vepqep}kt{ ha njj tbe{ }nkd3 elhuib*
tbnt kl tbe mhup}e ha tkge tbe qk}kt mnge th nl eld* nld
Gnbnkln thhc bep jenqe pemekqkli naaemtkhlnte eg`pnme}
aphg njj tbe jndke}, K bnd pegnkled kl tbe `nmciphuld natep
tbe akp}t mepeghl{ ha kltphdumtkhl* ahp K dkd lht jkce tbe
jhhc} ha Gnbnkln* nld tbe mhlqep}ntkhl dk}vjen}ed ge,
Ybel }be jeat tbe phhg K bnd }hge mhl}hjntkhl kl tbe
pegnpc} mnjjed ahptb `{ bep devnptupe,
Nt akp}t tbe{ aejj th vpnk}kli bep qep{ degupej{, ]be yn}
njj tbk} tbnt nld tbe htbep* tkjj K dk}jkced bep ghpe nld ghpe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 171/378
Epeybhl
>9> ha =9;
nt eqep{ yhpd* nld kl~ukped bhy kt yn} tbnt tbe
}tpnkibtelep} bnd lht `eel n`je th mupe bep n} tbe{ bndmuped Gp, Lh}lk`hp,
Tbepe yn} n }bnde ha }kilkakmnlme hl Gp}, Lh}lk`hp‛}
anme n} K }nkd tbk}* ybkmb }eeged th kgvj{ tbnt }be dkd lht
mhl}kdep Gnbnkln‛} mn}e th `e ~ukte hle ahp n }tpnkibtelep,
Kt ajn}bed nmph}} ge tbnt vepbnv} tbe vhhp yhgnl dkd lht
dpklc nt njj, K cley tbnt K huibt lht th bnqe kl~ukped* `utK mhujd lht bejv kt* nld n}ced vhklt `jnlc ybetbep }be dkd
hp lht,
‒Ye mnl lhle ha u} oudie ha tbe mhldktkhl ha htbep
vehvje*‛ }nkd Gp}, Lh}lk`hp kl n ipnqej{ mbnpktn`je thle
nld yktb n jhhc thynpd} _ujhpn,
‒Hb* gnggn*‛ nl}yeped _ujhpn* vpeteldkli th `e bnja nlip{ `ut peohkmed nt `ekli n`je th }n{ hut ybnt }be yn}
njpend{ jhlikli th kl}klunte3 ‒K dhl‛t `ejkeqe n yhpd ha kt,
Kt‛} njj kldkie}tkhl, K pegeg`ep }tn{kli kl tbe bhu}e yktb
bep ahp n ybhje ghltb jn}t }uggep* nld K ng }upe }be
leqep hlme thumbed n dphv ha ykle hp }vkpkt}, Tbe anmt k}*
Gnbnkln k} n qep{ yencj{ ikpj* nld }be vpeteld} th iet tkv}{
kl hpdep th ykl n ahp`enpnlme aphg bep apkeld} th ybkmb
}be k} lht eltktjed, ]be k} lht }tphli elhuib ahp bep
mnjk}tbelkm erepmk}e}* nld }be clhy} }be yhujd `e gnde th
dh tbeg ulje}} bep kln`kjkt{ yn} peaepped th ghpnj mnu}e},‛
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 172/378
Epeybhl
>90 ha =9;
Bepe tbe {huliep }k}tep* ybh yn} eqep }yeet nld ckld*
pegnpced tbnt }be tbhuibt Gnbnkln dkd tkvvjehmmn}khlnjj{, ‒K nj}h tbklc*‛ }be ndded* ‒tbnt }be }hgetkge}
tnce} vhvv{ oukme,‛
‒Yejj* tbel* vepbnv} }be dhe} dpklc }hgetkge}*‛ }nkd
_ujhpn3 ‒`ut }be yhujd gnce u} njj tbklc tbnt }be dhe} kt
gumb hatelep kl hpdep th bkde bep yencle}},‛
Nld }h tbe{ yelt hl ahp bnja nl bhup nld ghpe*`nld{kli n`hut tbe ~ue}tkhl n} th bhy anp tbekp jnte
qk}kthp‛} kltegvepnlme yn} penj hp lh, Eqep{ lhy nld tbel
tbe{ yhujd ohkl kl }hge mbnpktn`je mhgghlvjnme* nld
yhujd vpeteld th `e njj ha hle gkld tbnt Gnbnkln yn} n
vep}hl ybh}e `hdkj{ benjtb yhujd `e ermejjelt ka kt yepe
lht ahp bep ulahptulnte kln`kjkt{ th peapnkl aphg erme}}kqedpklckli3 `ut n} }hhl n} tbk} nvvenped th `e ankpj{ }ettjed
tbe{ `einl th `e ulmhgahptn`je ultkj tbe{ bnd uldhle
tbekp yhpc nld jeat }hge }epkhu} kgvutntkhl uvhl bep
mhl}tktutkhl, Nt jn}t* }eekli tbnt tbe de`nte bnd n}}uged
tbe mbnpnmtep ha n m{mjhle hp mkpmujnp }thpg* ihkli phuld
nld phuld nld phuld nld phuld tkjj hle mhujd leqep }n{
ybepe kt `einl lhp ybepe kt elded* K gnde }hge nvhjhi{
ahp nl n`puvt devnptupe nld petkped th g{ hyl phhg,
Bepe nt jen}t K yn} njhle* `ut K yn} qep{ ulbnvv{, K bnd
anjjel uvhl n }et ha vehvje ybh* kl }vkte ha tbekp bkib
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 173/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 174/378
Epeybhl
>94 ha =9;
tbnt }be yn} tegvepnte kl njj bep bn`kt}+3 kl tbnt mn}e }be
gkibt vepbnv} `e ou}tj{ }u`oemt th nllh{nlme} hp eqel thpe}tpnklt3 `ut ybh mhujd }n{ ybetbep }be yn} mupn`je hp
lht* ultkj }be yn} n`je th gnce n mjenl `pen}t ha bep
}{gvthg} kl}tend ha mhlmenjkli tbeg8 Kl tbekp enieple}}
th }tngv hut dk}en}e* tbe}e vehvje hqep}bht tbekp gnpc3 ahp
vehvje bnd `emhge }h mjeqep nt dk}}eg`jkli—tbe{ vnklted
tbekp anme} yktb }umb mhl}uggnte }ckjj— tbe{ pevnkped tbedemn{ ha tkge nld tbe eaaemt} ha gk}mbnlme yktb }umb
vphahuld dk}}kgujntkhl—tbnt kt yn} penjj{ kgvh}}k`je th
}n{ ybetbep nl{ hle yn} yejj hp kjj tkjj natep nl kltkgnte
nm~unkltnlme ha ghltb} hp {enp}, Eqel tbel tbe }bpeyde}t
yepe mhl}tnltj{ gk}tncel kl tbekp oudiegelt}* nld
gnppknie} yepe hatel mhltpnmted yktb gh}t devjhpn`jepe}ujt}* hykli th tbe npt yktb ybkmb klakpgkt{ bnd `eel
mhlmenjed,
Kt nvvenped th ge tbnt tbe akp}t }tev thynpd} tbe mupe ha
dk}en}e }bhujd `e tbe nllhulmegelt ha tbe anmt th n
vep}hl‛} lenp pejntkhl} nld apkeld}, Ka nl{ hle bnd n
bendnmbe* be huibt th `e vepgktted yktbkl pen}hln`je
jkgkt} th }n{ }h nt hlme* nld th petkpe th bk} hyl `edphhg
nld tnce n vkjj* yktbhut eqep{ hle‛} jhhckli ipnqe nld tenp}
`ekli }bed nld njj tbe pe}t ha kt, N} kt yn}* eqel uvhl
benpkli kt ybk}veped tbnt }hge`hd{ ej}e yn} }u`oemt th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 175/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 176/378
Epeybhl
>91 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RQ? TBE GU]KMNJ @NLC]
Hl g{ petupl th tbe dpnykli'phhg* K ahuld tbnt tbe
Gnbnkln muppelt bnd ervelded kt}eja, Tbe jndke} yepe ou}t
vuttkli nyn{ tbekp yhpc nld vpevnpkli th ih hut, K n}ced
tbeg ybepe tbe{ yepe ihkli, Tbe{ nl}yeped yktb n
meptnkl nkp ha pe}epqe tbnt tbe{ yepe ihkli th tbe `nlc th
iet }hge ghle{,
Lhy K bnd njpend{ mhjjemted tbnt tbe gepmnltkje naankp}
ha tbe Epeybhlknl} yepe mhldumted hl n thtnjj{ dkaaepelt
}{}teg aphg hup hyl3 K bnd* bhyeqep* intbeped jkttje
bktbepth* ermevt tbnt tbe{ bnd tyh dk}tklmt mhggepmknj
}{}teg}* ha ybkmb tbe hle nvvenjed ghpe }tphlij{ th tbe
kgniklntkhl tbnl nl{tbkli th ybkmb ye npe nmmu}thged kl
Euphve* kln}gumb n} tbe `nlc} tbnt yepe mhldumted uvhl
tbk} }{}teg yepe demhpnted kl tbe gh}t vphau}e an}bkhl*
nld njj gepmnltkje tpnl}nmtkhl} yepe nmmhgvnlked yktb
gu}km* }h tbnt tbe{ yepe mnjjed Gu}kmnj @nlc}* tbhuib tbe
gu}km yn} bkdehu} th n Euphvenl enp,
N} ahp tbe }{}teg kt}eja K leqep uldep}thhd kt* lektbep
mnl K dh }h lhy? tbe{ bnqe n mhde kl mhllemtkhl yktb kt*
ybkmb K bnqe lht tbe }jkibte}t dhu`t tbnt tbe{ uldep}tnld*
`ut lh ahpekilep mnl bhve th dh }h, Hle puje pul} klth*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 177/378
Epeybhl
>99 ha =9;
nld ninkl}t* nlhtbep n} kl n gh}t mhgvjkmnted ipnggnp* hp
n} kl Mbkle}e vphlulmkntkhl* ybepekl K ng thjd tbnt tbe}jkibte}t mbnlie kl nmmeltuntkhl hp thle ha qhkme njtep} tbe
genlkli ha n ybhje }eltelme, Ybnteqep k} klmhbepelt kl
g{ de}mpkvtkhl gu}t `e peaepped th tbe anmt ha g{ leqep
bnqkli nttnkled th n aujj mhgvpebel}khl ha tbe }u`oemt,
]h anp* bhyeqep* n} K mhujd mhjjemt nl{tbkli meptnkl* K
intbeped tbnt tbe{ bnqe tyh dk}tklmt muppelmke}* enmbuldep tbe mhltphj ha kt} hyl `nlc} nld gepmnltkje mhde},
Hle ha tbe}e tbe hle yktb tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}+ yn}
}uvvh}ed th `e TBE }{}teg* nld th ikqe hut tbe muppelm{
kl ybkmb njj ghletnp{ tpnl}nmtkhl} }bhujd `e mnppked hl3
nld n} anp n} K mhujd }ee* njj ybh yk}bed th `e mhl}kdeped
pe}vemtn`je* cevt n jnpiep hp }gnjjep `njnlme nt tbe}e `nlc},Hl tbe htbep bnld* ka tbepe k} hle tbkli ha ybkmb K ng
ghpe }upe tbnl nlhtbep* kt k} tbnt tbe nghult }h cevt bnd
lh dkpemt mhggepmknj qnjue kl tbe hut}kde yhpjd3 K ng }upe
tbnt tbe gnlniep} nld mn}bkep} ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc} yepe
lht vnkd kl tbekp hyl muppelm{, Gp, Lh}lk`hp u}ed th ih
th tbe}e `nlc}* hp pntbep th tbe ipent ghtbep `nlc ha tbe
mkt{* }hgetkge} `ut lht qep{ hatel, Be yn} n vkjjnp ha hle
ha tbe htbep ckld ha `nlc}* tbhuib be nvvenped th bhjd
}hge gklhp haakme nj}h kl tbe gu}kmnj hle}, Tbe jndke}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 178/378
Epeybhl
>92 ha =9;
ielepnjj{ yelt njhle3 n} kldeed yn} tbe mn}e kl gh}t
angkjke}* ermevt hl }tnte hmmn}khl},K bnd jhli ynlted th clhy ghpe ha tbk} }tpnlie }{}teg*
nld bnd tbe ipente}t de}kpe th nmmhgvnl{ g{ bh}te}} nld
bep dnuibtep}, K bnd }eel tbeg ih hut njgh}t eqep{
ghplkli }klme g{ nppkqnj nld bnd lhtkmed tbnt tbe{ mnppked
tbekp vup}e} kl tbekp bnld}* lht ernmtj{ h}teltntkhu}j{* {et
ou}t }h n} tbnt tbh}e ybh get tbeg }bhujd }ee ybktbep tbe{ yepe ihkli, K bnd leqep* bhyeqep* {et `eel n}ced th
ih yktb tbeg g{}eja,
Kt k} lht en}{ th mhlqe{ n vep}hl‛} gnllep `{ yhpd}*
nld K mnl bnpdj{ ikqe nl{ kden ha tbe vemujknp aeejkli tbnt
mnge uvhl ge ybel K }ny tbe jndke} hl tbe vhklt ha
}tnptkli ahp tbe `nlc, Tbepe yn} n }hgetbkli ha peipet* n}hgetbkli n} tbhuib tbe{ yhujd yk}b th tnce ge yktb
tbeg* `ut dkd lht jkce th n}c ge* nld {et n} tbhuib K yepe
bnpdj{ th n}c th `e tncel, K yn} detepgkled* bhyeqep* th
`pkli gnttep} th nl k}}ue yktb g{ bh}te}} n`hut g{ ihkli
yktb tbeg* nld natep n jkttje vnpje{kli* nld gnl{ kl~ukpke}
n} th ybetbep K yn} vepaemtj{ }upe tbnt K g{}eja yk}bed th
ih* kt yn} demkded tbnt K gkibt dh }h,
Ye vn}}ed tbphuib }eqepnj }tpeet} ha ghpe hp je}}
mhl}kdepn`je bhu}e}* nld nt jn}t tuplkli phuld n mhplep ye
mnge uvhl n jnpie vknzzn* nt tbe eld ha ybkmb yn} n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 179/378
Epeybhl
>9; ha =9;
gnilkakmelt `ukjdkli* ha n }tpnlie `ut lh`je npmbktemtupe
nld ha ipent nltk~ukt{, Kt dkd lht hvel dkpemtj{ hl th tbevknzzn* tbepe `ekli n }mpeel* tbphuib ybkmb yn} nl
npmbyn{* `etyeel tbe vknzzn nld tbe nmtunj vpemklmt} ha
tbe `nlc, Hl vn}}kli uldep tbe npmbyn{ ye elteped uvhl
n ipeel }ynpd* phuld ybkmb tbepe pnl nl npmnde hp mjhk}tep*
ybkje kl aphlt ha u} uvph}e tbe gnoe}tkm thyep} ha tbe `nlc
nld kt} qelepn`je aphlt* ybkmb yn} dkqkded klth tbpee deevpeme}}e} nld ndhpled yktb njj }hpt} ha gnp`je} nld gnl{
}mujvtupe}, Hl ektbep }kde tbepe yepe `enutkauj hjd tpee}
ybepekl tbe `kpd} yepe `u}{ `{ tbe buldped* nld n
lug`ep ha ~unklt `ut }u`}tnltknj bhu}e} ha }kliujnpj{
mhgahptn`je nvvenpnlme3 tbe{ yepe }ktunted kl tbe gkd}t ha
hpmbnpd} nld inpdel}* nld inqe ge nl kgvpe}}khl ha ipentvenme nld vjelt{,
Kldeed kt bnd `eel lh epphp th }n{ tbnt tbk} `ukjdkli
yn} hle tbnt nvvenjed th tbe kgniklntkhl3 kt dkd ghpe—kt
mnppked `htb kgniklntkhl nld oudiegelt `{ }thpg, Kt yn}
nl evkm kl }thle nld gnp`je* nld }h vhyepauj yn} tbe
eaaemt kt vphdumed hl ge* tbnt n} K `ebejd kt K yn} mbnpged
nld gejted, K aejt ghpe mhl}mkhu} ha tbe erk}telme ha n
peghte vn}t, Hle clhy} ha tbk} njyn{}* `ut tbe clhyjedie
k} leqep }h jkqkli n} kl tbe nmtunj vpe}elme ha }hge yktle}}
th tbe jkae ha `{ihle nie}, K aejt bhy }bhpt n }vnme ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 180/378
Epeybhl
>26 ha =9;
bugnl jkae yn} tbe vepkhd ha hup hyl erk}telme, K yn}
ghpe kgvpe}}ed yktb g{ hyl jkttjele}}* nld gumb ghpeklmjkln`je th `ejkeqe tbnt tbe vehvje ybh}e }el}e ha tbe
aktle}} ha tbkli} yn} e~unj th tbe uvpnk}kli ha }h }epele n
bnldkyhpc* yepe bnpdj{ jkcej{ th `e yphli kl tbe
mhlmju}khl} tbe{ gkibt mhge th uvhl nl{ }u`oemt, G{
aeejkli meptnklj{ yn} tbnt tbe muppelm{ ha tbk} `nlc gu}t `e
tbe pkibt hle,Ye mph}}ed tbe }ynpd nld elteped tbe `ukjdkli, Ka tbe
hut}kde bnd `eel kgvpe}}kqe tbe kl}kde yn} eqel ghpe }h,
Kt yn} qep{ jhat{ nld dkqkded klth }eqepnj vnpt} `{ ynjj}
ybkmb pe}ted uvhl gn}}kqe vkjjnp}3 tbe ykldhy} yepe akjjed
yktb }tnkled ijn}} de}mpkvtkqe ha tbe vpklmkvnj mhggepmknj
klmkdelt} ha tbe `nlc ahp gnl{ nie}, Kl n peghte vnpt ha tbe `ukjdkli tbepe yepe gel nld `h{} }klikli3 tbk} yn} tbe
hlj{ dk}tup`kli aentupe* ahp n} tbe ingut yn} }tkjj
ulclhyl* tbepe yn} lh gu}km kl tbe mhultp{ ybkmb mhujd
`e nipeen`je th n Euphvenl enp, Tbe }kliep} }eeged th
bnqe depkqed tbekp kl}vkpntkhl} aphg tbe }hli} ha `kpd} nld
tbe ynkjkli ha tbe ykld* ybkmb jn}t tbe{ tpked th kgktnte kl
gejnlmbhj{ mndelme} tbnt nt tkge} deielepnted klth n
bhyj, Th g{ tbklckli tbe lhk}e yn} bkdehu}* `ut kt
vphdumed n ipent eaaemt uvhl g{ mhgvnlkhl}* ybh
vphae}}ed tbeg}ejqe} gumb ghqed, N} }hhl n} tbe }klikli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 181/378
Epeybhl
>2> ha =9;
yn} hqep* tbe jndke} pe~ue}ted ge th }tn{ ybepe K yn}
ybkje tbe{ yelt kl}kde tbe vjnme aphg ybkmb kt bnd}eeged th mhge,
Dupkli tbekp n`}elme meptnkl peajemtkhl} ahpmed
tbeg}ejqe} uvhl ge,
Kl tbe akp}t vjnme* kt }tpumc ge n} }tpnlie tbnt tbe
`ukjdkli }bhujd `e }h lenpj{ egvt{3 K yn} njgh}t njhle*
nld tbe aey `e}kde} g{}eja bnd `eel jed `{ mupkh}kt{* nldbnd lh klteltkhl ha dhkli `u}kle}} yktb tbe `nlc, @ut
tbepe gkibt `e ghpe kl}kde, K }thje uv th tbe muptnkl* nld
qeltuped th dpny tbe ertpege edie ha kt hl hle }kde, Lh*
tbepe yn} bnpdj{ nl{ hle tbepe, K }ny n jnpie lug`ep ha
mn}bkep}* njj nt tbekp de}c} pend{ th vn{ mbe~ue}* nld hle hp
tyh ybh }eeged th `e tbe gnlnikli vnptlep}, K nj}h }nyg{ bh}te}} nld bep dnuibtep} nld tyh hp tbpee htbep
jndke}3 nj}h tbpee hp ahup hjd yhgel nld tbe `h{} aphg
hle ha tbe lekib`hupkli Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl3 `ut tbepe
yn} lh hle ej}e, Tbk} dkd lht jhhc n} tbhuib tbe `nlc yn}
dhkli n qep{ jnpie `u}kle}}3 nld {et K bnd njyn{} `eel thjd
tbnt eqep{ hle kl tbe mkt{ denjt yktb tbk} e}tn`jk}bgelt,
K mnllht de}mpk`e njj tbnt thhc vjnme kl tbe}e kllep
vpemklmt}* ahp n }klk}tep'jhhckli vep}hl kl n `jnmc ihyl
mnge nld gnde ulvjen}nlt ie}tupe} nt ge ahp veevkli, K
bnvveled th bnqe kl g{ vhmcet hle ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 182/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 183/378
Epeybhl
>2= ha =9;
Gp}, Lh}lk`hp }nkd tbnt kt yn} kldeed gejnlmbhj{ th }ee
ybnt jkttje beed vehvje vnkd th tbe gh}t vpemkhu} ha njjkl}tktutkhl}, K mhujd }n{ lhtbkli kl pevj{* `ut K bnqe eqep
`eel ha hvklkhl tbnt tbe ipentep vnpt ha gnlckld dh
nvvphrkgntej{ clhy ybepe tbe{ iet tbnt ybkmb dhe} tbeg
ihhd,
Gp}, Lh}lk`hp yelt hl th }n{ tbnt K gu}t lht tbklc
tbepe yn} nl{ ynlt ha mhlakdelme kl tbe `nlc `emnu}e Kbnd }eel }h aey vehvje tbepe3 tbe benpt ha tbe mhultp{ yn}
tbhphuibj{ deqhted th tbe}e e}tn`jk}bgelt}* nld nl{ }kil
ha tbekp `ekli kl dnliep yhujd `pkli kl }uvvhpt aphg tbe
gh}t ulervemted ~unptep}, Kt yn} hlj{ `emnu}e vehvje
cley tbeg th `e }h qep{ }nae* tbnt kl }hge mn}e} n} }be
jngelted th }n{ kl Gp, Lh}lk`hp‛}+ tbe{ aejt tbnt tbekp }uvvhpt yn} ulleme}}np{, Ghpehqep tbe}e kl}tktutkhl}
leqep devnpted aphg tbe }nae}t nld gh}t nvvphqed `nlckli
vpklmkvje}, Tbu} tbe{ leqep njjhyed kltepe}t hl devh}kt* n
tbkli lhy ape~ueltj{ dhle `{ meptnkl `u``je mhgvnlke}*
ybkmb `{ dhkli nl kjjeiktkgnte tpnde bnd dpnyl gnl{
mu}thgep} nyn{3 nld eqel tbe }bnpebhjdep} yepe aeyep
tbnl ahpgepj{* hykli th tbe kllhqntkhl} ha tbe}e
ul}mpuvujhu} vep}hl}* ahp tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc} vnkd jkttje hp
lh dkqkdeld* `ut dkqkded tbekp vphakt} `{ yn{ ha `hlu} hl
tbe hpkiklnj }bnpe} hlme kl eqep{ tbkpt{ tbhu}nld {enp}3 nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 184/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 185/378
Epeybhl
>25 ha =9;
lh oudiegelt yhptb bnqkli hl gnttep} ha tbk} ckld, Tbe
`hd{ k} eqep{tbkli? kt leed lht vepbnv} `e }umb n }tphli`hd{ }be }nkd tbk} `emnu}e }be }ny tbnt K yn} tbklckli ha
tbe hjd nld klakpg'jhhckli ahjc} ybhg K bnd }eel kl tbe
`nlc+* `ut kt gu}t `e kl vepaemt benjtb3 kl tbk} mn}e* tbe je}}
nmtkqe }tpelitb kt bnd tbe ghpe apee yhujd `e tbe yhpckli
ha tbe kltejjemt* nld tbepeahpe tbe }huldep tbe mhlmju}khl,
Tbe vehvje* tbel* ybhg K bnd }eel nt tbe `nlc yepe klpenjkt{ tbe qep{ hle} ybh}e hvklkhl} yepe gh}t yhptb
bnqkli3 tbe{ demjnped kt} ndqnltnie} th `e klmnjmujn`je* nld
eqel vphae}}ed th mhl}kdep tbe kggedknte petupl th `e anp
jnpiep tbnl tbe{ yepe eltktjed th3 nld }h }be pnl hl* lhp
dkd }be jenqe haa tkjj ye bnd iht `nmc th tbe bhu}e,
]be gkibt }n{ ybnt }be vjen}ed* `ut bep gnllep mnppkedlh mhlqkmtkhl* nld jntep hl K }ny }kil} ha ielepnj
kldkaaepelme th tbe}e `nlc} tbnt yepe lht th `e gk}tncel,
Tbekp }uvvhptep} hatel delked kt* `ut tbe delknj yn}
ielepnjj{ }h mhumbed n} th ndd nlhtbep vphha ha kt}
erk}telme, Kl mhggepmknj vnlkm}* nld kl tkge} ha ielepnj
dk}tpe}}* tbe vehvje n} n gn}} dkd lht }h gumb n} eqel
tbklc ha tuplkli th tbe}e `nlc}, N aey gkibt dh }h* }hge
aphg bn`kt nld enpj{ tpnklkli* }hge aphg tbe kl}tklmt tbnt
vphgvt} u} th mntmb nt nl{ }tpny ybel ye tbklc hup}ejqe}
dphylkli* `ut aey aphg n ielukle `ejkea tbnt tbe Gu}kmnj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 186/378
Epeybhl
>21 ha =9;
@nlc} mhujd }nqe tbeg aphg aklnlmknj pukl* ka tbe{ yepe
uln`je th geet tbekp eliniegelt} kl tbe htbep ckld ha muppelm{,
Kl mhlqep}ntkhl yktb hle ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc gnlniep}
K qeltuped th bklt tbk} n} vjnklj{ n} vhjktele}} yhujd njjhy,
Be }nkd tbnt kt bnd `eel ghpe hp je}} tpue tkjj jntej{3 `ut
tbnt lhy tbe{ bnd vut ape}b }tnkled ijn}} ykldhy} klth njj
tbe `nlc} kl tbe mhultp{* nld pevnkped tbe `ukjdkli}* nldeljnpied tbe hpinl}3 tbe vpe}kdelt}* ghpehqep* bnd tncel
th pkdkli kl hglk`u}e} nld tnjckli lkmej{ th vehvje kl tbe
}tpeet}* nld th pegeg`epkli tbe nie} ha tbekp mbkjdpel* nld
ikqkli tbeg tbkli} ybel tbe{ yepe lnuibt{* }h tbnt njj
yhujd belmeahptb ih }ghhtbj{,
‒@ut bnqel‛t {hu dhle nl{tbkli th tbe ghle{ kt}eja8‛}nkd K* tkgkdj{,
‒Kt k} lht leme}}np{*‛ be peohkled3 ‒lht kl tbe jen}t
leme}}np{* K n}}upe {hu,‛
Nld {et nl{ hle mhujd }ee tbnt tbe ghle{ ikqel hut nt
tbe}e `nlc} yn} lht tbnt yktb ybkmb vehvje `huibt tbekp
`pend* gent* nld mjhtbkli, Kt yn} jkce kt nt n akp}t ijnlme*
nld yn} }tngved yktb de}kil} tbnt yepe hatel ha ipent
`enut{3 kt yn} lht* ninkl* n }vupkhu} mhklnie* gnde yktb
tbe klteltkhl tbnt kt }bhujd `e gk}tncel ahp tbe ghle{ kl
nmtunj u}e3 kt yn} ghpe jkce n th{ ghle{* hp tbe mhultep}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 187/378
Epeybhl
>29 ha =9;
u}ed ahp meptnkl inge} nt mnpd}3 ahp* lhtyktb}tnldkli tbe
`enut{ ha tbe de}kil}* tbe gntepknj hl ybkmb tbe{ yepe}tngved yn} n} lenpj{ qnjueje}} n} vh}}k`je, ]hge yepe
mhqeped yktb tkl ahkj* `ut tbe ipentep vnpt yepe apnlcj{ ha n
mbenv `n}e getnj tbe ernmt lntupe ha ybkmb K yn} lht n`je
th detepgkle, Kldeed tbe{ yepe gnde ha n ipent qnpket{ ha
getnj}* hp* vepbnv} ghpe nmmupntej{* njjh{}* }hge ha ybkmb
yepe bnpd* ybkje htbep} yhujd `eld en}kj{ nld n}}ugenjgh}t nl{ ahpg ybkmb tbekp vh}}e}}hp gkibt de}kpe nt tbe
ghgelt,
Ha mhup}e eqep{ hle cley tbnt tbekp mhggepmknj qnjue
yn} lkj* `ut njj tbh}e ybh yk}bed th `e mhl}kdeped
pe}vemtn`je tbhuibt kt klmug`elt uvhl tbeg th petnkl n
aey mhkl} kl tbekp vh}}e}}khl* nld th jet tbeg `e }eel aphgtkge th tkge kl tbekp bnld} nld vup}e}, Lht hlj{ tbk}* `ut
tbe{ yhujd }tkmc th kt tbnt tbe muppelt mhkl ha tbe penjg
yn} dph}} kl mhgvnpk}hl yktb tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc mhklnie,
Vepbnv}* bhyeqep* tbe }tpnlie}t tbkli ha njj yn} tbnt tbe}e
qep{ vehvje yhujd nt tkge} gnce aul kl }gnjj yn{} ha tbe
ybhje }{}teg3 kldeed* tbepe yn} bnpdj{ nl{ kl}kluntkhl
ninkl}t kt ybkmb tbe{ yhujd lht thjepnte nld eqel nvvjnud
kl tbekp dnkj{ ley}vnvep} ka ypkttel nlhl{ghu}j{* ybkje ka
tbe }nge tbkli yepe }nkd yktbhut ng`kiukt{ th tbekp
anme}—lhgklntkqe mn}e qep` nld nmmu}ntkqe `ekli njj kl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 188/378
Epeybhl
>22 ha =9;
tbekp pkibt vjnme}* nld dhu`t kgvh}}k`je—tbe{ yhujd
mhl}kdep tbeg}ejqe} qep{ }epkhu}j{ nld ou}tj{ hutpnied* nldnmmu}e tbe }vencep ha `ekli ulyejj,
K leqep mhujd uldep}tnld lektbep mnl K ~ukte dh }h
lhy* tbhuib K `eikl th }ee `ettep ybnt tbe{ genl+ yb{ n
}klije muppelm{ }bhujd lht }uaakme tbeg3 kt yhujd }eeg th
ge n} tbhuib njj tbekp denjkli} yhujd bnqe `eel tbu}
ipentj{ }kgvjkaked3 `ut K yn} get yktb n jhhc ha bhpphp ka eqep K dnped th bklt nt kt, Eqel tbh}e ybh th g{ meptnkl
clhyjedie cevt hlj{ ou}t elhuib ghle{ nt tbe Gu}kmnj
@nlc} th }yenp `{* yhujd mnjj tbe htbep `nlc} ybepe
tbekp }emupktke} penjj{ jn{+ mhjd* dendelkli* vnpnj{}kli* nld
tbe jkce,
K lhtkmed nlhtbep tbkli* ghpehqep* ybkmb }tpumc geipentj{, K yn} tncel th tbe hvelkli ha hle ha tbe}e `nlc}
kl n lekib`hupkli thyl* nld }ny n jnpie n}}eg`jnie ha
mn}bkep} nld gnlniep}, K }nt hvvh}kte tbeg nld }mnlled
tbekp anme} ntteltkqej{, Tbe{ dkd lht vjen}e ge3 tbe{
jnmced* yktb aey ermevtkhl}* tbe tpue Epeybhlknl
apnlcle}}3 nld nl e~unj lug`ep aphg nl{ htbep mjn}}
yhujd bnqe jhhced bnvvkep nld `ettep gel, Ybel K get
tbeg kl tbe }tpeet} tbe{ dkd lht }eeg jkce htbep vehvje*
`ut bnd* n} n ielepnj puje* n mpngved ervpe}}khl uvhl tbekp
anme} ybkmb vnkled nld devpe}}ed ge,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 189/378
Epeybhl
>2; ha =9;
Tbh}e ybh mnge aphg tbe mhultp{ yepe `ettep3 tbe{
}eeged th bnqe jkqed je}} n} n }evnpnte mjn}}* nld th `e apeep nld benjtbkep3 `ut kl }vkte ha g{ }eekli lht n aey ybh}e
jhhc} yepe `elkil nld lh`je* K mhujd lht bejv n}ckli
g{}eja mhlmeplkli tbe ipentep lug`ep ha tbh}e ybhg K
get* ybetbep Epeybhl yhujd `e n `ettep mhultp{ ka tbekp
ervpe}}khl yepe th `e tpnl}aepped th tbe vehvje kl ielepnj,
K nl}yeped g{}eja egvbntkmnjj{* lh, Tbe ervpe}}khl hl tbeanme} ha tbe bkib [dipulkte} yn} tbnt ybkmb hle yhujd
yk}b th dkaau}e* nld lht tbnt ha tbe mn}bkep},
N gnl‛} ervpe}}khl k} bk} }nmpngelt3 kt k} tbe hutynpd
nld qk}k`je }kil ha bk} klynpd nld }vkpktunj ipnme* hp ynlt
ha ipnme3 nld n} K jhhced nt tbe n gnohpkt{ ha tbe}e gel* K
mhujd lht bejv aeejkli tbnt tbepe gu}t `e n }hgetbkli kltbekp jkqe} ybkmb bnd }tulted tbekp lntupnj deqejhvgelt*
nld tbnt tbe{ yhujd bnqe `eel ghpe benjtbkj{ gklded kl
nl{ htbep vphae}}khl, K yn} njyn{} }hpp{ ahp tbeg* ahp kl
lkle mn}e} hut ha tel tbe{ yepe yejj'genlkli vep}hl}3
tbe{ yepe kl tbe gnkl qep{ vhhpj{ vnkd3 tbekp mhl}tktutkhl}
yepe n} n puje n`hqe }u}vkmkhl3 nld tbepe yepe pemhpded
lug`epje}} kl}tnlme} ha tbekp }eja'}nmpkakme nld ieleph}kt{3
`ut tbe{ bnd bnd tbe gk}ahptule th bnqe `eel `etpn{ed
klth n anj}e vh}ktkhl nt nl nie ahp tbe gh}t vnpt ybel tbekp
oudiegelt yn} lht gntuped* nld natep bnqkli `eel cevt kl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 190/378
Epeybhl
>;6 ha =9;
}tudked kilhpnlme ha tbe penj dkaakmujtke} ha tbe }{}teg, @ut
tbk} dkd lht gnce tbekp vh}ktkhl tbe je}} n anj}e hle* nld kt}`nd eaaemt} uvhl tbeg}ejqe} yepe ulgk}tncn`je,
Aey vehvje yhujd }venc ~ukte hvelj{ nld apeej{ `eahpe
tbeg* ybkmb }tpumc ge n} n qep{ `nd }kil, Ybel tbe{
yepe kl tbe phhg eqep{ hle yhujd tnjc n} tbhuib njj
muppelm{ }nqe tbnt ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc} }bhujd `e
n`hjk}bed3 nld {et tbe{ cley vepaemtj{ yejj tbnt eqel tbemn}bkep} tbeg}ejqe} bnpdj{ u}ed tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc ghle{
ghpe tbnl htbep vehvje, Kt yn} ervemted ha tbeg tbnt tbe{
}bhujd nvvenp th dh }h* `ut tbk} yn} njj, Tbe je}}
tbhuibtauj ha tbeg dkd lht }eeg vnptkmujnpj{ ulbnvv{* `ut
gnl{ yepe vjnklj{ }kmc nt benpt* tbhuib vepbnv} tbe{
bnpdj{ cley kt* nld yhujd lht bnqe hyled th `ekli }h,]hge aey yepe hvvhlelt} ha tbe ybhje }{}teg3 `ut tbe}e
yepe jkn`je th `e dk}gk}}ed aphg tbekp egvjh{gelt nt nl{
ghgelt* nld tbk} peldeped tbeg qep{ mnpeauj* ahp n gnl
ybh bnd hlme `eel mn}bkep nt n Gu}kmnj @nlc yn} hut ha
tbe akejd ahp htbep egvjh{gelt* nld yn} ielepnjj{ ulaktted
ahp kt `{ pen}hl ha tbnt mhup}e ha tpentgelt ybkmb yn}
mhgghlj{ mnjjed bk} edumntkhl, Kl anmt kt yn} n mnpeep
aphg ybkmb petpent yn} qkptunjj{ kgvh}}k`je* nld klth
ybkmb {huli gel yepe ielepnjj{ kldumed th eltep `eahpe
tbe{ mhujd `e pen}hln`j{ ervemted* mhl}kdepkli tbekp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 191/378
Epeybhl
>;> ha =9;
tpnklkli* th bnqe ahpged nl{ hvklkhl} ha tbekp hyl, Lht
ulape~ueltj{* kldeed* tbe{ yepe kldumed* `{ ybnt ye klElijnld }bhujd mnjj uldue klajuelme* mhlmenjgelt* nld
apnud, Aey kldeed yepe tbh}e ybh bnd tbe mhupnie th
kl}k}t hl }eekli `htb }kde} ha tbe ~ue}tkhl `eahpe tbe{
mhggktted tbeg}ejqe} th ybnt yn} vpnmtkmnjj{ n jenv kl tbe
dnpc, Hle yhujd bnqe tbhuibt tbnt mnutkhl kl tbk} pe}vemt
yn} nl ejegeltnp{ vpklmkvje*—hle ha tbe akp}t tbkli} tbntnl bhlhupn`je gnl yhujd tenmb bk} `h{ th uldep}tnld3
`ut kl vpnmtkme kt yn} lht }h,
K eqel }ny mn}e} kl ybkmb vnpelt} `huibt tbe pkibt ha
vpe}eltkli th tbe haakme ha mn}bkep nt hle ha tbe}e `nlc}*
yktb tbe akred detepgklntkhl tbnt }hge hle ha tbekp }hl}
vepbnv} n gepe mbkjd+ }bhujd akjj kt, Tbepe yn} tbe jndbkg}eja—iphykli uv yktb eqep{ vphgk}e ha `emhgkli n
ihhd nld bhlhupn`je gnl—`ut uttepj{ yktbhut ynplkli
mhlmeplkli tbe kphl }bhe ybkmb bk} lntupnj vphtemthp yn}
vphqkdkli ahp bkg, Ybh mhujd }n{ tbnt tbe ybhje tbkli
yhujd lht eld kl n jkae'jhli jke* nld qnkl mbnakli th
e}mnve8 K mhlae}} tbnt tbepe yepe aey tbkli} kl Epeybhl
ybkmb }bhmced ge ghpe tbnl tbk},
[et ye dh }hgetbkli lht }h qep{ dkaaepelt aphg tbk}
eqel kl Elijnld* nld n} peinpd} tbe dunj mhggepmknj
}{}teg* njj mhultpke} bnqe* nld bnqe bnd* n jny ha tbe jnld*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 192/378
Epeybhl
>;0 ha =9;
nld nj}h nlhtbep jny* ybkmb* tbhuib vphae}}edj{ ghpe
}nmped* bn} anp je}} eaaemt hl tbekp dnkj{ jkae nld nmtkhl}, Kt}eeg} n} tbhuib tbe leed ahp }hge jny hqep nld n`hqe*
nld }hgetkge} eqel mhlajkmtkli yktb* tbe jny ha tbe jnld*
gu}t }vpkli aphg }hgetbkli tbnt jke} deev dhyl kl gnl‛}
lntupe3 kldeed* kt k} bnpd th tbklc tbnt gnl mhujd eqep
bnqe `emhge gnl nt njj* `ut ahp tbe ipndunj eqhjutkhl ha n
vepmevtkhl tbnt tbhuib tbk} yhpjd jhhg} }h jnpie ybel yenpe kl kt* kt gn{ }eeg n jkttje tbkli ybel ye bnqe iht nyn{
aphg kt,
Ybel gnl bnd iphyl th tbe vepmevtkhl tbnt kl tbe
eqepjn}tkli K}' nld'K}'Lht ha lntupe* tbe yhpjd nld njj tbnt
kt mhltnkl}* klmjudkli gnl* k} nt tbe }nge tkge `htb }eel
nld ul}eel* be aejt tbe leed ha tyh puje} ha jkae* hle ahp tbe }eel* nld tbe htbep ahp tbe ul}eel }kde ha tbkli}, Ahp
tbe jny} naaemtkli tbe }eel yhpjd be mjnkged tbe }nlmtkhl
ha }eel vhyep}3 ahp tbe ul}eel ha ybkmb be clhy}
lhtbkli }nqe tbnt kt erk}t} nld k} vhyepauj+ be nvvenjed th
tbe ul}eel vhyep ha ybkmb* ninkl* be clhy} lhtbkli
}nqe tbnt kt erk}t} nld k} vhyepauj+ th ybkmb be ikqe} tbe
lnge ha Ihd,
]hge Epeybhlknl hvklkhl} mhlmeplkli tbe kltejjkielme
ha tbe ul`hpl eg`p{h* tbnt K peipet g{ }vnme ykjj lht
vepgkt ge th jn{ `eahpe tbe pendep* bnqe jed ge th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 193/378
Epeybhl
>;= ha =9;
mhlmjude tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl Gu}kmnj @nlc}* nld vepbnv}
tbe pejkikhu} }{}teg} ha njj mhultpke}* npe lhy ghpe hp je}}ha nl nttegvt th uvbhjd tbe ulantbhgn`je nld
ulmhl}mkhu} kl}tklmtkqe yk}dhg ha gkjjkhl} ha vn}t
ielepntkhl}* ninkl}t tbe mhgvnpntkqej{ }bnjjhy* mhl}mkhu}j{
pen}hlkli* nld evbegepnj mhlmju}khl} dpnyl aphg tbnt ha
tbe jn}t tbkpt{ hp ahpt{,
Tbe }nqkli aentupe ha tbe Epeybhlknl Gu}kmnj @nlc}{}teg n} dk}tklmt aphg tbe ~un}k'kdhjntphu} qkey} ybkmb
mherk}t yktb kt* nld hl ybkmb K ykjj thumb jntep+ yn} tbnt
ybkje kt `hpe yktle}} th tbe erk}telme ha n cklidhg tbnt k}
lht ha tbk} yhpjd* kt gnde lh nttegvt th vkepme tbe qekj
tbnt bkde} kt aphg bugnl e{e}, Kt k} bepe tbnt njgh}t njj
pejkikhl} ih yphli, Tbekp vpke}t} tp{ th gnce u} `ejkeqetbnt tbe{ clhy ghpe n`hut tbe ul}eel yhpjd tbnl tbh}e
ybh}e e{e} npe }tkjj `jklded `{ tbe }eel* mnl eqep clhy—
ahpiettkli tbnt ybkje th del{ tbe erk}telme ha nl ul}eel
cklidhg k} `nd* th vpeteld tbnt ye clhy ghpe n`hut kt
tbnl kt} `npe erk}telme k} lh `ettep,
Tbk} mbnvtep k} njpend{ jhliep tbnl K kltelded* `ut K
}bhujd jkce th }n{ tbnt kl }vkte ha tbe }nqkli aentupe ha
ybkmb K bnqe ou}t }vhcel* K mnllht bejv tbklckli tbnt tbe
Epeybhlknl} npe hl tbe eqe ha }hge ipent mbnlie kl tbekp
pejkikhu} hvklkhl}* hp nt nl{ pnte kl tbnt vnpt ha tbeg
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 194/378
Epeybhl
>;4 ha =9;
ybkmb akld} ervpe}}khl tbphuib tbekp Gu}kmnj @nlc}, ]h anp
n} K mhujd }ee* aujj{ lklet{ vep melt, ha tbe vhvujntkhl ha tbe getphvhjk} jhhced uvhl tbe}e `nlc} yktb }hgetbkli
lht anp peghqed aphg mhltegvt, Ka tbk} k} }h* nl{ }umb
}tnptjkli eqelt n} k} }upe th npk}e }hhlep hp jntep* gn{ }epqe
n} lumjeu} th n ley hpdep ha tbkli} tbnt ykjj `e ghpe kl
bnpghl{ yktb `htb tbe bend} nld benpt} ha tbe vehvje,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 195/378
Epeybhl
>;5 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RQK? NPHYBELN
Tbe pendep ykjj vepbnv} bnqe jenpled `{ tbk} tkge n
tbkli ybkmb K bnd g{}eja }u}vemted `eahpe K bnd `eel
tyelt{'ahup bhup} kl Gp, Lh}lk`hp‛} bhu}e—K genl* tbnt
tbhuib tbe Lh}lk`hp} }bhyed ge eqep{ ntteltkhl* K mhujd
lht mhpdknjj{ jkce tbeg* yktb tbe ermevtkhl ha Nphybeln
ybh yn} ~ukte dkaaepelt aphg tbe pe}t, Tbe{ yepe lht ankp
}ngvje} ha Epeybhlknl}, K }ny gnl{ angkjke} yktb ybhg
tbe{ yepe hl qk}ktkli tepg}* ybh}e gnllep} mbnpged ge
ghpe tbnl K clhy bhy th }n{* `ut K leqep mhujd iet hqep
g{ hpkiklnj vpeoudkme ninkl}t Gp, Lh}lk`hp ahp bnqkli
eg`ezzjed tbe ghle{, Gp}, Lh}lk`hp* thh* yn} n qep{
yhpjdj{ yhgnl* {et th benp bep tnjc hle yhujd bnqe
tbhuibt tbnt }be yn} }kliujnpj{ tbe peqep}e3 lektbep mhujd K
eldupe _ujhpn3 Nphybeln bhyeqep yn} vepaemtkhl,
]be kt yn} ybh pnl njj tbe jkttje eppnld} ahp bep ghtbep
nld Gp, Lh}lk`hp nld _ujhpn* nld inqe tbh}e tbhu}nld
vphha} ha }yeetle}} nld ul}ejak}ble}} ybkmb }hge hle
geg`ep ha n angkj{ k} ielepnjj{ pe~ukped th ikqe, Njj dn{
jhli kt yn} Nphybeln tbk}* nld Nphybeln tbnt3 `ut }be
leqep }eeged th clhy tbnt }be yn} `ekli vut uvhl* nld
yn} njyn{} `pkibt nld ykjjkli aphg ghplkli tkjj eqelkli,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 196/378
Epeybhl
>;1 ha =9;
_ujhpn meptnklj{ yn} qep{ bnld}hge* `ut Nphybeln yn}
klaklktej{ tbe ghpe ipnmeauj ha tbe tyh nld yn} tbe qep{ levju} ujtpn ha {hutb nld `enut{, K ykjj lht nttegvt th
de}mpk`e bep* ahp nl{tbkli tbnt K mhujd }n{ yhujd anjj }h anp
}bhpt ha tbe penjkt{ n} hlj{ th gk}jend tbe pendep, Jet bkg
tbklc ha tbe qep{ jhqejke}t tbnt be mnl kgnikle* nld be ykjj
}tkjj `e `ejhy tbe tputb, Bnqkli }nkd tbk} gumb* K leed
bnpdj{ }n{ tbnt K bnd anjjel kl jhqe yktb bep,]be gu}t bnqe }eel ybnt K aejt ahp bep* `ut K tpked g{
bnpde}t lht th jet kt nvvenp eqel `{ tbe }jkibte}t }kil, K bnd
gnl{ pen}hl} ahp tbk}, K bnd lh kden ybnt Gp, nld Gp},
Lh}lk`hp yhujd }n{ th kt3 nld K cley tbnt Nphybeln
yhujd lht jhhc nt ge nt nl{ pnte lht {et+ ka bep antbep nld
ghtbep dk}nvvphqed* ybkmb tbe{ vph`n`j{ yhujd*mhl}kdepkli tbnt K bnd lhtbkli ermevt tbe vel}khl ha n`hut
n vhuld n dn{ ha hup ghle{ ybkmb tbe Ckli bnd ipnlted
ge, K dkd lht {et clhy ha n ghpe }epkhu} h`}tnmje,
Kl tbe genltkge* K gn{ }n{ tbnt K bnd `eel vpe}elted nt
mhupt* nld yn} thjd tbnt g{ pemevtkhl bnd `eel mhl}kdeped
n} }kliujnpj{ ipnmkhu}3 kldeed* K bnd }eqepnj kltepqkey} `htb
yktb tbe Ckli nld ^ueel* nt ybkmb aphg tkge th tkge tbe
^ueel iht eqep{tbkli aphg ge tbnt K bnd kl tbe yhpjd*
mjhtbe} nld njj* ermevt tbe tyh `utthl} K bnd ikqel th
[png* tbe jh}} ha ybkmb }eeged th nllh{ bep n ihhd denj,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 197/378
Epeybhl
>;9 ha =9;
K yn} vpe}elted yktb n mhupt }ukt* nld bep Gnoe}t{ bnd g{
hjd mjhtbe} vut uvhl n yhhdel dugg{* hl ybkmb tbe{vph`n`j{ pegnkl* ulje}} tbe{ bnqe `eel peghqed kl
mhl}e~uelme ha g{ }u`}e~uelt dhylanjj, Bk} Gnoe}t{‛}
gnllep} yepe tbh}e ha n mujtkqnted Elijk}b ieltjegnl, Be
yn} gumb vjen}ed nt benpkli tbnt hup ihqeplgelt yn}
ghlnpmbkmnj* nld tbnt tbe gn}} ha tbe vehvje yepe pe}hjute
tbnt kt }bhujd lht `e mbnlied3 kldeed* K yn} }h gumbelmhupnied `{ tbe eqkdelt vjen}upe yktb ybkmb be benpd
ge* tbnt K qeltuped th ~uhte th bkg tbh}e `enutkauj jkle}
ha ]bnce}venpe‛} '
‒Tbepe‛} n dkqklkt{ dhtb bedie n ckli* Phuib bey bkg
bhy ye gn{3,‛
`ut K yn} }hpp{ K bnd dhle }h natepynpd}* ahp K dh lhttbklc bk} Gnoe}t{ ndgkped tbe jkle} n} gumb n} K mhujd
bnqe yk}bed,
Tbepe k} lh hmmn}khl ahp ge th dyejj auptbep uvhl g{
ervepkelme ha tbe mhupt* `ut K huibt vepbnv} th njjude th
hle ha g{ mhlqep}ntkhl} yktb tbe Ckli* kln}gumb n} kt yn}
vpeilnlt yktb tbe gh}t kgvhptnlt mhl}e~uelme},
Be bnd `eel n}ckli ge n`hut g{ yntmb* nld el~ukpkli
ybetbep }umb dnliephu} klqeltkhl} yepe thjepnted kl tbe
mhultp{ aphg ybkmb K mnge, K hyled yktb }hge
mhlau}khl tbnt yntmbe} yepe lht ulmhgghl3 `ut
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 198/378
Epeybhl
>;2 ha =9;
h`}epqkli tbe ipnqkt{ ybkmb mnge hqep bk} Gnoe}t{‛} anme K
vpe}uged th }n{ tbnt tbe{ yepe an}t d{kli hut* nld tbnt yebnd aey ka nl{ htbep gembnlkmnj mhltpkqnlme} ha ybkmb be
yn} jkcej{ th dk}nvvphqe, Uvhl bk} n}ckli ge th lnge
}hge ha hup gh}t ndqnlmed gnmbkle}* K dkd lht dnpe th tejj
bkg ha hup }teng'elikle} nld pnkjphnd} nld ejemtpkm
tejeipnvb}* nld yn} vuzzjkli g{ `pnkl} th tbklc ybnt K
mhujd }n{* ybel* ha njj tbkli} kl tbe yhpjd* `njjhhl}}uiie}ted tbeg}ejqe}* nld K inqe bkg nl nmmhult ha n qep{
pegnpcn`je n}melt ybkmb yn} gnde }hge {enp} nih, Tbe
Ckli yn} thh vhjkte th mhltpndkmt* `ut K aejt }upe tbnt be
dkd lht `ejkeqe ge* nld aphg tbnt dn{ ahpynpd tbhuib be
njyn{} }bhyed ge tbe ntteltkhl ybkmb yn} due th g{
ielku} ahp kl tbk} jkibt yn} g{ mhgvjerkhl peinpded+* beleqep ~ue}tkhled ge n`hut tbe gnllep} nld mu}thg} ha
g{ mhultp{,
Th petupl* bhyeqep* th Nphybeln, K }hhl intbeped tbnt
lektbep Gp, lhp Gp}, Lh}lk`hp yhujd bnqe nl{ h`oemtkhl
th g{ gnpp{kli klth tbe angkj{3 n vb{}kmnj ermejjelme k}
mhl}kdeped kl Epeybhl n} n }et haa ninkl}t njgh}t nl{ htbep
dk}~unjkakmntkhl* nld g{ jkibt bnkp yn} }uaakmkelt th gnce
ge nl ejkik`je gntmb, @ut njhli yktb tbk} yejmhge anmt K
intbeped nlhtbep ybkmb akjjed ge yktb dk}gn{? K yn}
ervemted th gnpp{ _ujhpn* ahp ybhg K bnd njpend{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 199/378
Epeybhl
>;; ha =9;
mhlmekqed n ipent nqep}khl, Nt akp}t K bnpdj{ lhtkmed tbe
jkttje bklt} nld tbe nptkakme} ybkmb yepe pe}hpted th kl hpdep th `pkli u} thietbep* `ut natep n tkge tbe{ `emnge thh
vjnkl, _ujhpn* ybetbep }be yn} kl jhqe yktb ge hp lht*
yn} `elt hl gnpp{kli ge* nld K intbeped kl tnjckli yktb n
{huli ieltjegnl ha g{ nm~unkltnlme ybh ape~ueltj{
qk}kted tbe bhu}e nld ybhg K ipentj{ dk}jkced* tbnt kt yn}
mhl}kdeped n }nmped nld klqkhjn`je puje tbnt ybheqep gnppked klth n angkj{ gu}t gnpp{ tbe ejde}t dnuibtep nt
tbnt tkge ulgnppked, Tbe {huli ieltjegnl upied tbk}
uvhl ge }h ape~ueltj{ tbnt K nt jn}t }ny be yn} kl jhqe
yktb Nphybeln bkg}eja* nld ynlted ge th iet _ujhpn hut
ha tbe yn{3 `ut htbep} thjd ge tbe }nge }thp{ n} th tbe
mu}thg ha tbe mhultp{* nld K }ny tbepe yn} n }epkhu}dkaakmujt{, G{ hlj{ mhgahpt yn} tbnt Nphybeln }lu``ed
g{ pkqnj nld yhujd lht jhhc nt bkg, Lektbep yhujd }be
jhhc nt ge3 leqeptbeje}} tbepe yn} n dkaaepelme kl tbe
gnllep ha bep dk}peinpd3 tbk} yn} njj K mhujd iet aphg bep,
Lht tbnt }be nqhkded ge3 hl tbe mhltpnp{ K bnd gnl{ n
tete'n'tete yktb bep* ahp bep ghtbep nld }k}tep yepe
nlrkhu} ahp ge th devh}kt }hge vnpt ha g{ vel}khl kl tbe
Gu}kmnj @nlc}* tbk} `ekli kl nmmhpdnlme yktb tbe dkmtnte}
ha tbekp ihdde}} [dipul* ha ybhg `htb Gp}, Lh}lk`hp
nld _ujhpn yepe ipent deqhtee}, K yn} lht }upe ybetbep K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 200/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 201/378
Epeybhl
06> ha =9;
tbnt tbe{ npe jkce gel nld yhgel `htb kl `hd{ nld
vn}}khl* ermevt tbnt tbe{ npe eqel mhgejkep nld ghpevhyepauj* nld nj}h tbnt tbe{ mnl peldep tbeg}ejqe}
klqk}k`je th bugnl e{e}kibt, Tbe{ npe mnvn`je ha `ekli
vphvktknted `{ gnlckld nld ha mhgkli th tbe n}}k}tnlme ha
tbh}e ybh n}c tbekp nkd, Tbekp kltepe}t kl bugnl naankp} k}
ceel* nld hl tbe ybhje `eleakmelt3 `ut tbe{ `emhge qep{
nlip{ ka leijemted* nld vulk}b pntbep tbe akp}t tbe{ mhgeuvhl* tbnl tbe nmtunj vep}hl ybh bn} haaelded tbeg3 tbekp
aup{ `ekli `jkld ybel kt k} pnk}ed* tbhuib leqep pnk}ed
yktbhut pen}hl, Tbe{ ykjj lht vulk}b yktb nl{ je}}
}eqepkt{ ybel vehvje }kl ninkl}t tbeg aphg kilhpnlme* nld
yktbhut tbe mbnlme ha bnqkli bnd clhyjedie3 tbe{ ykjj
tnce lh ermu}e} ha tbk} ckld* `ut npe eqel n} tbe Elijk}bjny* ybkmb n}}uge} kt}eja th `e clhyl th eqep{ hle,
Tbu} tbe{ bnqe n jny tbnt tyh vkeme} ha gnttep gn{ lht
hmmuv{ tbe }nge }vnme nt tbe }nge ghgelt* ybkmb jny k}
vpe}kded hqep nld ndgklk}teped `{ tbe ihd} ha tkge nld
}vnme ohkltj{* }h tbnt ka n aj{kli }thle nld n gnl‛} bend
nttegvt th hutpnie tbe}e ihd}* `{ ‒npphintkli n pkibt ybkmb
tbe{ dh lht vh}}e}}‛ ahp }h kt k} ypkttel kl hle ha tbekp
`hhc}+* nld th hmmuv{ tbe }nge }vnme }kgujtnlehu}j{* n
}eqepe vulk}bgelt* }hgetkge} eqel dentb kt}eja* k} }upe th
ahjjhy* yktbhut nl{ peinpd th ybetbep tbe }thle cley
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 202/378
Epeybhl
060 ha =9;
tbnt tbe gnl‛} bend yn} tbepe* hp tbe bend tbe }thle3 tbk}
nt jen}t k} tbekp qkey ha tbe mhgghl nmmkdelt} ha jkae,Ghpehqep* tbe{ bhjd tbekp dektke} th `e ~ukte peinpdje}} ha
ghtkqe}, Yktb tbeg kt k} tbe tbkli dhle ybkmb k}
eqep{tbkli* nld tbe ghtkqe ihe} ahp lhtbkli,
Tbu} tbe{ bhjd kt }tpkmtj{ ahp`kddel ahp n gnl th ih
yktbhut mhgghl nkp kl bk} juli} ahp ghpe tbnl n qep{ aey
gklute}3 nld ka `{ nl{ mbnlme be iet} klth tbe yntep* tbenkp'ihd k} qep{ nlip{* nld ykjj lht }uaaep kt3 lh gnttep
ybetbep tbe gnl iht klth tbe yntep `{ nmmkdelt hp hl
vupvh}e* ybetbep tbphuib tbe nttegvt th }nqe n mbkjd hp
tbphuib vpe}ugvtuhu} mhltegvt ha tbe nkp'ihd* tbe nkp'
ihd ykjj ckjj bkg* ulje}} be ceev} bk} bend bkib elhuib
hut ha tbe yntep* nld tbu} ikqe} tbe nkp'ihd bk} due,Tbk} yktb peinpd th tbe dektke} ybh gnlnie vb{}kmnj
naankp}, Hqep nld n`hqe tbe}e tbe{ vep}hlka{ bhve* aenp*
jhqe* nld }h ahptb* ikqkli tbeg tegvje} nld vpke}t}* nld
mnpqkli jkcele}}e} ha tbeg kl }thle* ybkmb tbe{ qepkj{
`ejkeqe th `e anktbauj pevpe}eltntkhl} ha jkqkli `ekli} ybh
npe hlj{ lht bugnl kl `ekli ghpe tbnl bugnl, Ka nl{ hle
delke} tbe h`oemtkqe erk}telme ha tbe}e dkqklktke}* nld }n{}
tbnt tbepe k} penjj{ lh }umb `ekli n} n `enutkauj yhgnl
mnjjed Ou}tkme* yktb bep e{e} `jklded nld n vnkp ha }mnje}*
vh}ktkqej{ jkqkli nld ghqkli kl n peghte nld etbepenj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 203/378
Epeybhl
06= ha =9;
peikhl* `ut tbnt ou}tkme k} hlj{ tbe vep}hlkaked ervpe}}khl
ha meptnkl ghde} ha bugnl tbhuibt nld nmtkhl—tbe{ }n{tbnt be delke} tbe erk}telme ha ou}tkme kl del{kli bep
vep}hlnjkt{* nld tbnt be k} n ynlthl dk}tup`ep ha gel‛}
pejkikhu} mhlqkmtkhl}, Tbe{ dete}t lhtbkli }h gumb n} nl{
nttegvt th jend tbeg th bkibep }vkpktunj mhlmevtkhl} ha tbe
dektke} ybhg tbe{ vphae}} th yhp}bkv, Nphybeln nld K
bnd n vktmbed `nttje hl tbk} vhklt* nld }bhujd bnqe bndgnl{ ghpe `ut ahp g{ vpudelme kl njjhykli bep th iet
tbe `ettep ha ge,
K ng }upe tbnt kl bep benpt }be yn} }u}vkmkhu} ha bep
hyl vh}ktkhl ahp }be petupled ghpe tbnl hlme th tbe
}u`oemt, ‒Mnl {hu lht }ee*‛ K bnd ermjnkged* ‒tbnt tbe anmt
ha ou}tkme `ekli ndgkpn`je ykjj lht `e naaemted `{ tben`}elme ha n `ejkea kl bep `ekli nj}h n jkqkli nielt8 Mnl
{hu penjj{ tbklc tbnt gel ykjj `e hle ybkt je}} bhveauj*
`emnu}e tbe{ lh jhliep `ejkeqe tbnt bhve k} nl nmtunj
vep}hl8‛ ]be }bhhc bep bend* nld }nkd tbnt yktb gel‛}
`ejkea kl tbe vep}hlnjkt{ njj klmeltkqe th tbe peqepelme ha
tbe tbkli kt}eja* n} ou}tkme hp bhve* yhujd men}e3 gel aphg
tbnt bhup yhujd leqep `e ektbep ou}t hp bhveauj ninkl,
K mhujd lht ghqe bep* lhp* kldeed* dkd K }epkhu}j{ yk}b
th dh }h, ]be deaepped th ge kl gh}t tbkli}* `ut }be leqep
}bpnlc aphg gnkltnklkli bep hvklkhl} ka tbe{ yepe vut kl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 204/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 205/378
Epeybhl
065 ha =9;
mhltklielmke} `emnge tbu} kgvh}}k`je3 tbnt tbe penj tbkli
gel }bhujd yhp}bkv yn} tbe Dkqkle* ybepekl}heqep tbe{mhujd akld kt3 tbnt ‒Ihd‛ yn} `ut gnl‛} yn{ ha ervpe}}kli
bk} }el}e ha tbe Dkqkle3 tbnt n} ou}tkme* bhve* yk}dhg* !m,*
yepe njj vnpt} ha ihhdle}}* }h Ihd yn} tbe ervpe}}khl
ybkmb eg`pnmed njj ihhdle}} nld njj ihhd vhyep3 tbnt
vehvje yhujd lh ghpe men}e th jhqe Ihd hl men}kli th
`ejkeqe kl Bk} h`oemtkqe vep}hlnjkt{* tbnl tbe{ bnd men}edth jhqe ou}tkme hl dk}mhqepkli tbnt }be yn} lht penjj{
vep}hlnj3 ln{* tbnt tbe{ yhujd leqep tpuj{ jhqe Bkg tkjj
tbe{ }ny Bkg tbu},
]be }nkd njj tbk} kl bep nptje}} yn{* nld yktb lhle ha tbe
mhbepelme yktb ybkmb K bnqe bepe ypkttel kt3 bep anme
ckldjed* nld }be aejt }upe tbnt }be bnd mhlqklmed ge tbnt Kyn} yphli* nld tbnt ou}tkme yn} n jkqkli vep}hl, Kldeed K
dkd yklme n jkttje3 `ut K pemhqeped g{}eja kggedkntej{* nld
vhklted hut th bep tbnt ye bnd `hhc} ybh}e ieluklele}}
yn} `e{hld njj vh}}k`kjkt{ ha dhu`t* n} tbe{ yepe meptnklj{
lhle ha tbeg je}} tbnl >266 {enp} hjd3 tbnt kl tbe}e tbepe
yepe tbe gh}t nutbeltkm nmmhult} ha gel ybh bnd `eel
}vhcel th `{ tbe Dekt{ Bkg}eja* nld ha hle vphvbet ybh
bnd `eel njjhyed th }ee tbe `nmc vnpt} ha Ihd tbphuib tbe
bnld tbnt yn} jnkd hqep bk} anme,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 206/378
Epeybhl
061 ha =9;
Tbk} yn} mhlmju}kqe3 nld K }vhce yktb }umb }hjeglkt{
tbnt }be yn} n jkttje apkibteled* nld hlj{ nl}yeped tbnttbe{ thh bnd tbekp `hhc}* kl ybkmb tbekp nlme}thp} bnd
}eel tbe ihd}3 hl ybkmb K }ny tbnt auptbep npiugelt yn}
lht nt njj jkcej{ th mhlqklme bep3 nld aenpkli tbnt }be gkibt
tejj bep ghtbep ybnt K bnd `eel }n{kli* nld tbnt K gkibt
jh}e tbe bhjd uvhl bep naaemtkhl} ybkmb K yn} `eikllkli th
aeej vpett{ }upe tbnt K yn} h`tnklkli* K `einl th jet bep bnqe bep hyl yn{* nld th mhlqklme ge3 lektbep tkjj natep
ye yepe }naej{ gnppked dkd K }bhy tbe mjhqel bhha ninkl,
Leqeptbeje}}* bep pegnpc} bnqe bnulted ge* nld K bnqe
}klme get yktb gnl{ qep{ ihdj{ vehvje ybh bnqe bnd n
ipent clhyjedie ha dkqklkt{* `ut lh }el}e ha tbe dkqkle?
nld ninkl* K bnqe }eel n pndknlme uvhl tbe anme ha tbh}eybh yepe yhp}bkvvkli tbe dkqkle ektbep kl npt hp lntupe—
kl vkmtupe hp }tntue—kl akejd hp mjhud hp }en—kl gnl*
yhgnl* hp mbkjd—ybkmb K bnqe leqep }eel ckldjed `{ nl{
tnjckli n`hut tbe lntupe nld nttpk`ute} ha Ihd, Geltkhl
`ut tbe yhpd dkqklkt{* nld hup }el}e ha tbe dkqkle k}
mjhuded,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 207/378
Epeybhl
069 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RQKK? [DIPUL NLD TBE[DIPULKTE]
Kl }vkte ha njj tbe th'dh tbe{ gnce n`hut tbekp kdhj}*
nld tbe tegvje} tbe{ `ukjd* nld tbe vpke}t} nld vpke}te}}e}
ybhg tbe{ }uvvhpt* K mhujd leqep tbklc tbnt tbekp
vphae}}ed pejkikhl yn} ghpe tbnl }ckl'deev3 `ut tbe{ bnd
nlhtbep ybkmb tbe{ mnppked yktb tbeg klth njj tbekp
nmtkhl}3 nld njtbhuib lh hle aphg tbe hut}kde ha tbkli}
yhujd }u}vemt kt th bnqe nl{ erk}telme nt njj* kt yn} kl
penjkt{ tbekp ipent iukde* tbe gnpklep‛} mhgvn}} ha tbekp
jkqe}3 }h tbnt tbepe yepe qep{ aey tbkli} ybkmb tbe{ eqep
ektbep dkd* hp peapnkled aphg dhkli* yktbhut peaepelme th
kt} vpemevt},
Lhy K }u}vemted tbnt tbekp vphae}}ed anktb bnd lh ipent
bhjd uvhl tbeg—akp}tj{* `emnu}e K hatel benpd tbe vpke}t}
mhgvjnkl ha tbe vpeqnkjkli kldkaaepelme* nld tbe{ yhujd
bnpdj{ bnqe dhle }h yktbhut pen}hl3 }emhldj{* `emnu}e ha
tbe }bhy ybkmb yn} gnde* ahp tbepe yn} lhle ha tbk}
n`hut tbe yhp}bkv ha tbe ihdde}} [dipul* kl ybhg tbe{penjj{ dkd `ejkeqe3 tbkpdj{* `emnu}e tbhuib tbe vpke}t} yepe
mhl}tnltj{ n`u}kli [dipul n} `ekli tbe ipent eleg{ ha tbe
ihd}* kt yn} yejj clhyl tbnt }be bnd lh ghpe deqhted
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 208/378
Epeybhl
062 ha =9;
yhp}bkvvep} kl tbe ybhje mhultp{ tbnl tbe}e qep{ vep}hl}*
ybh yepe hatel vpke}t} ha [dipul pntbep tbnl ha tbekp hyldektke}, Lektbep ng K `{ nl{ genl} }upe tbnt tbe}e yepe
lht tbe `e}t ha tbe vpke}t},
[dipul meptnklj{ hmmuvked n qep{ nlhgnjhu} vh}ktkhl3
}be yn} bejd th `e `htb hglkvpe}elt nld hglkvhtelt* `ut
}be yn} lht nl ejeqnted mhlmevtkhl* nld yn} }hgetkge}
`htb mpuej nld n`}upd, Eqel bep gh}t deqhted yhp}bkvvep}yepe n jkttje n}bnged ha bep* nld }epqed bep ghpe yktb
benpt nld kl deed tbnl yktb tbekp thliue}, Tbekp} yn} lh
jkv }epqkme3 hl tbe mhltpnp{* eqel ybel yhp}bkvvkli bep
gh}t deqhutj{* tbe{ yhujd hatel del{ bep, Tnce bep njj kl
njj* bhyeqep* }be yn} n `eleakmelt nld u}eauj dekt{* ybh
dkd lht mnpe bhy gumb }be yn} delked }h jhli n} }be yn}h`e{ed nld aenped* nld ybh cevt buldped} ha tbhu}nld}
kl tbh}e vntb} ybkmb gnce jkae thjepn`j{ bnvv{* ybh
yhujd leqep bnqe `eel cevt tbepe htbepyk}e* nld hqep
ybhg n bkibep nld ghpe }vkpktunj kdenj yhujd bnqe bnd
lh vhyep,
K ipentj{ dhu`t ybetbep tbe Epeybhlknl} npe {et
vpevnped ahp nl{ `ettep pejkikhl* nld tbhuib mhl}kdepkli
g{ ipndunjj{ }tpelitbeled mhlqkmtkhl tbnt tbe{ yepe tbe
pevpe}eltntkqe} ha tbe jh}t tpk`e} ha K}pnej+ K yhujd bnqe }et
n`hut mhlqeptkli tbeg nt njj bnznpd} bnd K }eel tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 209/378
Epeybhl
06; ha =9;
peghte}t vph}vemt ha }umme}}* K mhujd bnpdj{ mhltegvjnte
tbe dk}vjnmegelt ha [dipul n} tbe ipent meltpnj h`oemt ha tbekp peinpd yktbhut ndgkttkli tbnt kt yhujd `e nttelded
yktb apkibtauj mhl}e~uelme}3 kl anmt yepe K n gepe
vbkjh}hvbep* K }bhujd }n{ tbnt tbe ipndunj pnk}kli ha tbe
vhvujnp mhlmevtkhl ha [dipul yhujd `e tbe ipente}t
}vkpktunj `hhl ybkmb mhujd `e mhlaepped uvhl tbeg* nld
tbnt lhtbkli mhujd eaaemt tbk} ermevt erngvje, K ielepnjj{ahuld tbnt tbh}e ybh mhgvjnkled gh}t jhudj{ tbnt
[dipul yn} lht bkib elhuib ahp tbeg bnd bnpdj{ n} {et
mhge uv th tbe [dipul }tnldnpd* nld K hatel get yktb n
mjn}} ha gel ybhg K mnjjed th g{}eja ‒bkib [dipulkte}‛
tbe pe}t `ekli [dipulkte}* nld jhy [dipulkte}+* ybh* kl
tbe gnttep ha bugnl mhldumt nld tbe naankp} ha jkae*nvvenped th ge th bnqe iht n`hut n} anp n} kt k} kl tbe pkibt
lntupe ha gnl th ih,
Tbe{ yepe ieltjegel kl tbe aujj }el}e ha tbe yhpd3 nld
ybnt bn} hle lht }nkd kl }n{kli tbk}8 Tbe{ }ejdhg }vhce ha
[dipul* hp eqel njjuded th bep* `ut yhujd leqep pul
mhultep th bep dkmtnte} yktbhut ngvje pen}hl ahp dhkli }h?
kl }umb mn}e} tbe{ yhujd hqeppkde bep yktb due }eja'
pejknlme* nld tbe ihdde}} }ejdhg vulk}bed tbeg3 ahp tbe{
npe `pnqe* nld [dipul k} lht, Tbe{ bnd gh}t ha tbeg n
}gnttepkli ha tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie* nld }hge aey
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 210/378
Epeybhl
0>6 ha =9;
ghpe tbnl tbk}* `ut hlj{ n aey, K dh lht tbklc tbnt tbk}
jnliunie bn} bnd gumb bnld kl gnckli tbeg ybnt tbe{npe3 `ut pntbep tbnt tbe anmt ha tbekp `ekli ielepnjj{
vh}}e}}ed ha kt} pudkgelt} yn} hle ipent pen}hl ahp tbe
peqepelme vnkd th tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie kt}eja,
@ekli kluped aphg {hutb th erepmk}e} nld ntbjetkm} ha njj
}hpt}* nld jkqkli aenpje}}j{ uldep tbe e{e ha tbekp veep}*
nghli ybhg tbepe erk}t} n bkib }tnldnpd ha mhupnie*ieleph}kt{* bhlhup* nld eqep{ ihhd nld gnlj{ ~unjkt{—
ybnt yhldep tbnt tbe{ }bhujd bnqe `emhge* }h th }venc* n
jny ulth tbeg}ejqe}3 nld* ybkje tnckli nl ejeqnted qkey ha
tbe ihdde}} [dipul* tbe{ }bhujd bnqe ipndunjj{ jh}t njj
anktb kl tbe pemhilk}ed dektke} ha tbe mhultp{8 Tbe}e tbe{
dh lht hvelj{ dk}peinpd* ahp mhlahpgkt{ ultkj n`}hjutej{klthjepn`je k} n jny ha [dipul* {et tbe{ bnqe lh penj `ejkea
kl tbe h`oemtkqe erk}telme ha `ekli} ybkmb }h pendkj{
ervjnkl tbeg}ejqe} n} n`}tpnmtkhl}* nld ybh}e vep}hlnjkt{
degnld} n ~un}k'gntepknjk}g ybkmb kt `naaje} tbe
kgniklntkhl th penjk}e, Tbe{ ceev tbekp hvklkhl}* bhyeqep*
ipentj{ th tbeg}ejqe}* kln}gumb n} gh}t ha tbekp
mhultp{gel aeej }tphlij{ n`hut tbe ihd}* nld tbe{ bhjd kt
yphli th ikqe vnkl* ulje}} ahp }hge ipentep ihhd tbnl
}eeg} jkcej{ th npk}e aphg tbekp vjnkl }venckli,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 211/378
Epeybhl
0>> ha =9;
Hl tbe htbep bnld* }upej{ tbh}e ybh}e hyl gkld} npe
mjenp n`hut nl{ ikqel gnttep eqel tbhuib kt `e hlj{ tbnttbepe k} jkttje meptnklt{+ }bhujd ih }h anp thynpd} kgvnptkli
tbnt mjenple}} th htbep}* n} th }n{ hvelj{ ybnt tbe{ tbklc
nld yb{ tbe{ tbklc kt* ybeleqep tbe{ mnl vphvepj{ dh }h3
ahp tbe{ gn{ `e }upe tbnt tbe{ hye tbekp hyl mjenple}}
njgh}t eltkpej{ th tbe anmt tbnt htbep} bnqe dhle tbk} `{
tbeg? natep njj* tbe{ gn{ `e gk}tncel* nld ka }h* kt k} ahp tbekp hyl nld tbe ielepnj yejj'`ekli tbnt tbe{ }bhujd jet
tbekp epphp `e }eel n} dk}tklmtj{ n} vh}}k`je* }h tbnt kt gn{
`e ghpe en}kj{ peauted, K hyl* tbepeahpe* tbnt hl tbk} hle
vhklt K dk}nvvphqed ha tbe vpnmtkme eqel ha tbe bkibe}t
[dipulkte}* nld h`oemted th kt njj tbe ghpe `emnu}e K cley
tbnt K }bhujd akld g{ hyl autupe tn}c ghpe en}{ ka tbebkib [dipulkte} bnd njpend{ uldepgkled tbe `ejkea ybkmb
k} }uvvh}ed th vpeqnkj nt vpe}elt,
Kl htbep pe}vemt} tbe{ yepe ghpe jkce tbe `e}t mjn}} ha
Elijk}bgel tbnl nl{ ybhg K bnqe }eel kl htbep
mhultpke}, K }bhujd bnqe jkced th bnqe vep}unded bnja'n'
dhzel ha tbeg th mhge hqep th Elijnld nld ih uvhl tbe
}tnie* ahp tbe{ bnd gh}t ha tbeg n ceel }el}e ha bughup
nld n tn}te ahp nmtkli? tbe{ yhujd `e ha ipent u}e th u},
Tbe erngvje ha n penj ieltjegnl k}* ka K gn{ }n{ }h
yktbhut vphanlkt{* tbe `e}t ha njj ih}vej}3 }umb n gnl uvhl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 212/378
Epeybhl
0>0 ha =9;
tbe }tnie `emhge} n vhtelt bugnlk}kli klajuelme* nl Kdenj
ybkmb njj gn{ jhhc uvhl ahp n }bkjjkli,K njyn{} jkced nld ndgkped tbe}e gel* nld njtbhuib K
mhujd lht bejv deevj{ peipettkli tbekp meptnkl ujtkgnte
vepdktkhl ahp tbe{ bnd lh }el}e ha n bepenatep* nld tbekp
hlj{ pejkikhl yn} tbnt ha }eja' pe}vemt nld mhl}kdepntkhl ahp
htbep vehvje+* K leqep dnped th tnce }h ipent n jk`ept{ yktb
tbeg n} th nttegvt th vut tbeg kl vh}}e}}khl ha g{ hylpejkikhu} mhlqkmtkhl}* kl }vkte ha g{ clhykli tbnt tbe{
yepe tbe hlj{ hle} ybkmb mhujd gnce tbeg penjj{ ihhd
nld bnvv{* ektbep bepe hp bepenatep, K dkd tp{ }hgetkge}*
`ekli kgvejjed th dh }h `{ n }tphli }el}e ha dut{* nld `{
g{ deev peipet tbnt }h gumb tbnt yn} ndgkpn`je }bhujd `e
dhhged th nie} ka lht eteplkt{ ha thptupe3 `ut tbe yhpd}}tumc kl g{ tbphnt n} }hhl n} K `einl,
Ybetbep n vphae}}khlnj gk}}khlnp{ gkibt bnqe n `ettep
mbnlme K clhy lht3 }umb vep}hl} gu}t dhu`tje}} clhy
ghpe n`hut tbe }mkelme ha mhlqep}khl? ahp g{}eja* K mhujd
hlj{ `e tbnlcauj tbnt K yn} kl tbe pkibt vntb* nld yn}
h`jkied th jet htbep} tnce tbekp mbnlme n} {et, Ka tbe vjnl
ankj} `{ ybkmb K vphvh}e th mhlqept tbeg g{}eja* K yhujd
ijndj{ mhltpk`ute g{ gkte thynpd} tbe }eldkli tyh hp
tbpee tpnkled gk}}khlnpke}* ybh bnqe `eel clhyl n}
}umme}}auj mhlqeptep} ha Oey} nld Gnbhgetnl}3 `ut }umb
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 213/378
Epeybhl
0>= ha =9;
bnqe }ejdhg gumb th ijhp{ kl tbe aje}b* nld ybel K tbklc
ha tbe bkib [dipulkte}* nld ha tbe akiupe ybkmb ngk}}khlnp{ yhujd vph`n`j{ mut nghli tbeg* K mnllht aeej
}nliukle tbnt gumb ihhd yhujd `e nppkqed nt, ]tkjj tbe
nttegvt k} yhptb gnckli* nld tbe yhp}t dnliep th tbe
gk}}khlnpke} tbeg}ejqe} yhujd `e tbnt ha `ekli }elt th tbe
bh}vktnj ybepe Mbhy`hc yhujd bnqe `eel }elt bnd be
mhge yktb ge klth Epeybhl,Tnckli tbel tbekp pejkikhu} hvklkhl} n} n ybhje* K gu}t
hyl tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl} npe }uvep}tktkhu}* hl nmmhult ha
tbe qkey} ybkmb tbe{ bhjd ha tbekp vphae}}ed ihd}* nld
tbekp eltkpej{ nlhgnjhu} nld klervjkmn`je yhp}bkv ha
[dipul* n yhp}bkv nt hlme tbe gh}t vhyepauj* {et gh}t
deqhkd ha ahpgnjk}g* tbnt K eqep get yktb3 `ut kl vpnmtkmetbkli} yhpced `ettep tbnl gkibt bnqe `eel ervemted* nld
tbe mhlajkmtkli mjnkg} ha [dipul nld tbe ihd} yepe
nppnlied `{ ulypkttel mhgvphgk}e} ahp tbe gh}t vnpt kl
[dipul‛} anqhup+* ybkmb kl lklet{'lkle mn}e} hut ha n
buldped yepe qep{ yejj uldep}thhd,
K mhujd lht mhlmekqe yb{ tbe{ }bhujd lht hvelj{
nmclhyjedie bkib [dipulk}g* nld dk}mnpd tbe h`oemtkqe
vep}hlnjkt{ ha bhve* ou}tkme* !m,3 `ut ybeleqep K }h gumb
n} bklted nt tbk}* K ahuld tbnt K yn} hl dnliephu} iphuld,
Tbe{ yhujd leqep bnqe kt3 petuplkli mhl}tnltj{ th tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 214/378
Epeybhl
0>4 ha =9;
n}}eptkhl tbnt nie} nih tbe dkqklktke} yepe ape~ueltj{ }eel*
nld tbnt tbe ghgelt tbekp vep}hlnjkt{ yn} dk}`ejkeqed kl*gel yhujd jenqe haa vpnmtk}kli eqel tbh}e hpdklnp{ qkptue}
ybkmb tbe mhgghl ervepkelme ha gnlckld bn} nipeed hl
n} `ekli tbe ipente}t }empet ha bnvvkle}}, ‒Ybh eqep benpd*‛
tbe{ n}ced* kldkilnltj{* ‒ha }umb tbkli} n} ckldj{ tpnklkli*
n ihhd erngvje* nld nl eljkibteled peinpd th hle‛} hyl
yejanpe* `ekli n`je th ceev gel }tpnkibt8‛ Kl g{ bupp{*ahpiettkli tbkli} ybkmb K huibt th bnqe pegeg`eped* K
nl}yeped tbnt ka n vep}hl mhujd lht `e cevt }tpnkibt `{
tbe}e tbkli}* tbepe yn} lhtbkli tbnt mhujd }tpnkibtel bkg*
nld tbnt ka be yepe lht pujed `{ tbe jhqe nld aenp ha gel
ybhg be bnd }eel* lektbep yhujd be `e }h `{ tbnt ha tbe
ihd} ybhg be bnd lht }eel,Nt hle tkge kldeed K mnge uvhl n }gnjj `ut iphykli
}emt ybh `ejkeqed* natep n an}bkhl* kl tbe kgghptnjkt{ ha
tbe }huj nld tbe pe}uppemtkhl aphg tbe dend3 tbe{ tnuibt
tbnt tbh}e ybh bnd `eel `hpl yktb aee`je nld dk}en}ed
`hdke} nld bnd vn}}ed tbekp jkqe} kl nkjkli* yhujd `e
thptuped eteplnjj{ bepenatep3 `ut tbnt tbh}e ybh bnd `eel
`hpl }tphli nld benjtb{ nld bnld}hge yhujd `e peynpded
ahp eqep nld eqep, Ha ghpnj ~unjktke} hp mhldumt tbe{
gnde lh geltkhl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 215/378
Epeybhl
0>5 ha =9;
@nd n} tbk} yn}* kt yn} n }tev kl ndqnlme* kln}gumb n}
tbe{ dkd bhjd hut n autupe }tnte ha }hge }hpt* nld K yn}}bhmced th akld tbnt ahp tbe gh}t vnpt tbe{ get yktb
hvvh}ktkhl* hl tbe }mhpe tbnt tbekp dhmtpkle yn} `n}ed
uvhl lh }hpt ha ahuldntkhl* nj}h tbnt kt yn} kgghpnj kl kt}
teldelm{* nld lht th `e de}kped `{ nl{ pen}hln`je `ekli},
Ybel K n}ced bhy kt mhujd `e kgghpnj* K yn}
nl}yeped* tbnt ka akpgj{ bejd* kt yhujd jend vehvje thmbenvel tbk} vpe}elt jkae* gnckli kt nvvenp th `e nl naankp
ha hlj{ }emhldnp{ kgvhptnlme3 tbnt kt yhujd tbu} dk}tpnmt
gel‛} gkld} aphg tbe vepaemtkli ha tbk} yhpjd‛} emhlhg{*
nld yn} nl kgvntkelt muttkli* }h th }venc* ha tbe Ihpdknl
clht ha jkae‛} vph`jeg}* ybepe`{ }hge vehvje gkibt inkl
vpe}elt }ntk}anmtkhl th tbeg}ejqe} nt tbe mh}t ha klaklktedngnie th htbep}3 tbnt tbe dhmtpkle telded th elmhupnie
tbe vhhp kl tbekp kgvphqkdelme* nld kl n de`n}kli
nm~uke}melme kl kjj} ybkmb tbe{ gkibt yejj peged{3 tbnt
tbe peynpd} yepe kjju}hp{ nld tbe pe}ujt* natep njj* ha jumc*
ybh}e egvkpe }bhujd `e `hulded `{ tbe ipnqe3 tbnt kt}
tepphp} yepe elepqntkli nld ulou}t3 nld tbnt eqel tbe gh}t
`je}}ed pk}kli yhujd `e `ut tbe dk}tup`kli ha n }tkjj ghpe
`je}}ed }jug`ep,
Th njj ybkmb K mhujd hlj{ }n{ tbnt tbe tbkli bnd `eel
nmtunjj{ clhyl th bnvvel* nld tbnt tbepe yepe }eqepnj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 216/378
Epeybhl
0>1 ha =9;
yejj'nutbeltkmnted kl}tnlme} ha vehvje bnqkli dked nld
mhge th jkae ninkl—kl}tnlme} ybkmb lh gnl kl bk} }el}e}mhujd dhu`t,
‒Ka tbk} `e }h*‛ }nkd g{ hvvhlelt* ‒ye gu}t `enp kt n}
`e}t ye gn{,‛
K tbel tpnl}jnted ahp bkg* n} yejj n} K mhujd* tbe lh`je
}veemb ha Bngjet kl ybkmb be }n{} tbnt kt k} tbe aenp je}t
yhp}e eqkj} gn{ `eanjj u} natep dentb ybkmb njhle vpeqelt}u} aphg pu}bkli klth dentb‛} npg},
‒Lhl}el}e*‛ be nl}yeped* ‒lh gnl yn} eqep {et }thvved
aphg muttkli bk} tbphnt `{ nl{ }umb aenp} n} {hup vhet
n}mpk`e} th bkg—nld {hup vhet vph`n`j{ cley tbk}
vepaemtj{ yejj, Ka n gnl mut} bk} tbphnt be k} nt `n{* nld
tbklc} ha lhtbkli `ut e}mnve* lh gnttep ybktbep* vphqkdedbe mnl }buaaje haa bk} vpe}elt, Lh, Gel npe cevt nt tbekp
vh}t}* lht `{ tbe aenp tbnt ka tbe{ ~ukt tbeg tbe{ gn{ ~ukt
n ap{kli'vnl ahp n akpe* `ut `{ tbe bhve tbnt ka tbe{ bhjd
hl* tbe akpe gn{ `upl je}} akepmej{, ‒Tbe pe}vemt*‛ th ~uhte
{hup vhet* ‒tbnt gnce} mnjngkt{ ha }h jhli n jkae*‛ k} tbe
mhl}kdepntkhl tbnt tbhuib mnjngkt{ gn{ jkqe jhli* tbe
}uaaepep gn{ jkqe jhliep }tkjj,‛
Hl tbk}* }eekli tbnt tbepe yn} jkttje vph`n`kjkt{ ha hup
mhgkli th nl nipeegelt* K jet tbe npiugelt dphv* nld g{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 217/378
Epeybhl
0>9 ha =9;
hvvhlelt vpe}eltj{ jeat ge yktb n} gumb dk}nvvph`ntkhl n}
be mhujd }bhy yktbhut `ekli hqeptj{ pude,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 218/378
Epeybhl
0>2 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RQKKK? @KPTB AHPGUJNE
K benpd ybnt ahjjhy} lht aphg Nphybeln* `ut aphg
Gp, Lh}lk`hp nld }hge ha tbe ieltjegel ybh
hmmn}khlnjj{ dkled nt tbe bhu}e? tbe{ thjd ge tbnt tbe
Epeybhlknl} `ejkeqe kl vpe'erk}telme3 nld lht hlj{ tbk}
ha ybkmb K ykjj ypkte ghpe aujj{ kl tbe lert mbnvtep+* `ut
tbe{ `ejkeqe tbnt kt k} ha tbekp hyl apee nmt nld deed kl n
vpeqkhu} }tnte tbnt tbe{ mhge th `e `hpl klth tbk} yhpjd nt
njj, Tbe{ bhjd tbnt tbe ul`hpl npe vepvetunjj{ vjniukli
nld thpgeltkli tbe gnppked ha `htb }ere}* ajuttepkli n`hut
tbeg klme}}nltj{* nld ikqkli tbeg lh venme ektbep ha gkld
hp `hd{ ultkj tbe{ bnqe mhl}elted th tnce tbeg uldep
tbekp vphtemtkhl, Ka tbk} yepe lht }h tbk} nt jen}t k} ybnt
tbe{ upie+* kt yhujd `e n ghl}tphu} apeedhg ahp hle gnl
th tnce yktb nlhtbep* th }n{ tbnt be }bhujd uldepih tbe
mbnlme} nld mbnlie} ha tbk} ghptnj jkae yktbhut nl{ hvtkhl
kl tbe gnttep, Lh gnl yhujd bnqe nl{ pkibt th iet
gnppked nt njj* kln}gumb n} be mnl leqep tejj ybnt apkibtauj
gk}ep{ bk} dhkli }h gn{ eltnkj ahpmk`j{ uvhl n `ekli ybh
mnllht `e ulbnvv{ n} jhli n} be dhe} lht erk}t, Tbe{ aeej
tbk} }h }tphlij{ tbnt tbe{ npe pe}hjqed th }bkat tbe `jnge hl
th htbep }bhujdep}3 nld bnqe an}bkhled n jhli g{tbhjhi{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 219/378
Epeybhl
0>; ha =9;
n} th tbe yhpjd kl ybkmb tbe ul`hpl vehvje jkqe* nld ybnt
tbe{ dh* nld tbe npt} nld gnmbklntkhl} th ybkmb tbe{ bnqepemhup}e kl hpdep th iet tbeg}ejqe} klth hup hyl yhpjd,
@ut ha tbk} ghpe nlhl? ybnt K yhujd pejnte bepe k} tbekp
gnllep ha denjkli yktb tbh}e ybh dh mhge,
Kt k} n dk}tkliuk}bkli vemujknpkt{ ha tbe Epeybhlknl} tbnt
ybel tbe{ vphae}} tbeg}ejqe} th `e ~ukte meptnkl n`hut nl{
gnttep* nld nqhy kt n} n `n}e hl ybkmb tbe{ npe th `ukjd n}{}teg ha vpnmtkme* tbe{ }ejdhg ~ukte `ejkeqe kl kt, Ka tbe{
}gejj n pnt n`hut tbe vpemklmt} ha n mbepk}bed kl}tktutkhl*
tbe{ ykjj njyn{} }thv tbekp lh}e} th kt ka tbe{ mnl,
Tbk} k} ybnt gh}t ha tbeg dkd kl tbk} gnttep ha tbe
ul`hpl* ahp K mnllht nld leqep mhujd+ tbklc tbnt tbe{
}epkhu}j{ `ejkeqed kl tbekp g{tbhjhi{ mhlmeplkli vpe'erk}telme? tbe{ dkd nld tbe{ dkd lht3 tbe{ dkd lht clhy
tbeg}ejqe} ybnt tbe{ `ejkeqed3 njj tbe{ dkd clhy yn} tbnt
kt yn} n dk}en}e lht th `ejkeqe n} tbe{ dkd, Tbe hlj{ tbkli
ha ybkmb tbe{ yepe ~ukte }upe yn} tbnt kt yn} tbe ve}tepkli
ha tbe ul`hpl ybkmb mnu}ed tbeg th `e `phuibt klth tbk}
yhpjd* nld tbnt tbe{ yhujd lht bnqe `eel bepe ka tbe{
yhujd bnqe hlj{ jet venmen`je vehvje njhle,
Kt yhujd `e bnpd th dk}vphqe tbk} vh}ktkhl* nld tbe{
gkibt bnqe n ihhd mn}e ka tbe{ yhujd hlj{ jenqe kt n} kt
}tnld}, @ut tbk} tbe{ ykjj lht dh3 tbe{ gu}t bnqe n}}upnlme
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 220/378
Epeybhl
006 ha =9;
dhu`j{ }upe3 tbe{ gu}t bnqe tbe ypkttel yhpd ha tbe mbkjd
kt}eja n} }hhl n} kt k} `hpl* ikqkli tbe vnpelt} kldeglkt{aphg njj pe}vhl}k`kjkt{ hl tbe }mhpe ha kt} `kptb* nld
n}}eptkli kt} hyl vpe'erk}telme, Tbe{ bnqe tbepeahpe
deqk}ed }hgetbkli ybkmb tbe{ mnjj n `kptb ahpgujn—n
dhmugelt ybkmb qnpke} kl yhpd} nmmhpdkli th tbe mnutkhl
ha vnpelt}* `ut k} gumb tbe }nge vpnmtkmnjj{ kl njj mn}e}3 ahp
kt bn} `eel tbe `u}kle}} ha tbe Epeybhlknl jny{ep} dupklignl{ nie} th erepmk}e tbekp }ckjj kl vepaemtkli kt nld
vphqkdkli ahp eqep{ mhltklielm{,
Tbe}e ahpgujne npe vpklted hl mhgghl vnvep nt n
ghdepnte mh}t ahp tbe vhhp3 `ut tbe pkmb bnqe tbeg
ypkttel hl vnpmbgelt nld bnld}hgej{ `huld* }h tbnt tbe
iettkli uv ha n vep}hl‛} `kptb ahpgujn k} n te}t ha bk} }hmknjvh}ktkhl, Tbe{ mhggelme `{ }ettkli ahptb* Tbnt ybepen}
N, @, yn} n geg`ep ha tbe cklidhg ha tbe ul`hpl* ybepe
be yn} yejj vphqkded ahp kl eqep{ yn{* nld bnd lh mnu}e
ha dk}mhltelt* !m,* !m,* be dkd ha bk} hyl ynlthl
devpnqkt{ nld pe}tje}}le}} mhlmekqe n de}kpe th eltep klth
tbk} vpe}elt yhpjd3 tbnt tbepehl bnqkli tncel tbe leme}}np{
}tev} n} }et ahptb kl jny} ha tbe ul`hpl cklidhg* be dkd
yktb gnjkme nahpetbhuibt }et bkg}eja th vjniue nld ve}tep
tyh ulahptulnte vehvje ybh bnd leqep yphlied bkg* nld
ybh yepe ~ukte mhltelted nld bnvv{ ultkj be mhlmekqed
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 221/378
Epeybhl
00> ha =9;
tbk} `n}e de}kil ninkl}t tbekp venme3 ahp ybkmb yphli be
lhy bug`j{ eltpent} tbekp vnpdhl,Be nmclhyjedie} tbnt be k} pe}vhl}k`je ahp njj vb{}kmnj
`jegk}be} nld deakmkelmke} ybkmb gn{ peldep bkg
nl}yepn`je th tbe jny} ha bk} mhultp{3 tbnt bk} vnpelt} bnqe
lhtbkli ybnteqep th dh yktb nl{ ha tbe}e tbkli}3 nld tbnt
tbe{ bnqe n pkibt th ckjj bkg nt hlme ka tbe{ `e }h gklded*
tbhuib be eltpent} tbeg th }bhy tbekp gnpqejjhu}ihhdle}} nld mjegelm{ `{ }vnpkli bk} jkae, Ka tbe{ ykjj dh
tbk}* be vphgk}e} th `e tbekp gh}t h`edkelt nld n`oemt
mpentupe dupkli bk} enpjkep {enp}* nld kldeed njj bk} jkae*
ulje}} tbe{ }bhujd }ee akt kl tbekp n`uldnlt ieleph}kt{ th
pegkt }hge vhptkhl ha bk} }epqkme bepenatep, Nld }h tbe
ahpgujn mhltklue}* ihkli }hgetkge} klth qep{ gklutedetnkj}* nmmhpdkli th tbe anlmke} ha angkj{ jny{ep}* ybh ykjj
lht gnce kt nl{ }bhptep tbnl tbe{ mnl bejv,
Tbe deed `ekli tbu} vpevnped* hl tbe tbkpd hp ahuptb
dn{ natep tbe `kptb ha tbe mbkjd* hp n} tbe{ mnjj kt* tbe ‒aklnj
kgvhptulkt{*‛ tbe apkeld} intbep thietbep* nld tbepe k} n
aen}t bejd* ybepe tbe{ npe njj qep{ gejnlmbhj{—n} n
ielepnj puje* K `ejkeqe* ~ukte tpuj{ }h—nld gnce vpe}elt}
th tbe antbep nld ghtbep ha tbe mbkjd kl hpdep th mhl}hje
tbeg ahp tbe kloup{ ybkmb bn} ou}t `eel dhle tbeg `{ tbe
ul`hpl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 222/378
Epeybhl
000 ha =9;
@{'nld'`{ tbe mbkjd bkg}eja k} `phuibt dhyl `{ bk}
lup}e* nld tbe mhgvnl{ `eikl th pnkj uvhl bkg*uv`pnkdkli bkg ahp bk} kgveptklelme* nld n}ckli bkg ybnt
ngeld} be vphvh}e} th gnce ahp tbe yphli tbnt be bn}
mhggktted* nld bhy be mnl jhhc ahp mnpe nld
lhupk}bgelt aphg tbh}e ybh bnqe vepbnv} njpend{ `eel
klouped `{ tbe ul`hpl hl }hge tel hp tyejqe hmmn}khl}3
ahp tbe{ }n{ ha vehvje yktb jnpie angkjke}* tbnt tbe{ bnqe}uaaeped teppk`je kloupke} aphg tbe ul`hpl3 tkjj nt jn}t* ybel
tbk} bn} `eel mnppked anp elhuib* }hge hle }uiie}t} tbe
ahpgujn* ybkmb k} `phuibt hut nld }hjeglj{ pend th tbe
mbkjd `{ tbe angkj{ }tpnkibtelep, Tbk} ieltjegnl k} njyn{}
klqkted hl tbe}e hmmn}khl}* ahp tbe qep{ anmt ha kltpu}khl
klth n venmeauj angkj{ }bhy} n devpnqkt{ hl tbe vnpt ha tbembkjd ybkmb pe~ukpe} bk} vphae}}khlnj }epqkme},
Hl `ekli ten}ed `{ tbe pendkli nld tyenced `{ tbe
lup}e* tbe mbkjd ykjj mhgghlj{ `eikl th mp{* ybkmb k}
pemchled n ihhd }kil* n} }bhykli n mhl}mkhu}le}} ha iukjt,
Be k} tbepehl n}ced* Dhe} be n}}elt th tbe ahpgujn8 hl
ybkmb* n} be }tkjj mhltklue} mp{kli nld mnl h`qkhu}j{ gnce
lh nl}yep* }hge hle ha tbe apkeld} mhge} ahpynpd nld
uldeptnce} th }kil tbe dhmugelt hl bk} `ebnja* aeejkli }upe
}h be }n{}+ tbnt tbe mbkjd yhujd dh kt ka be hlj{ cley
bhy* nld tbnt be ykjj pejen}e tbe vpe}elt }kilep aphg bk}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 223/378
Epeybhl
00= ha =9;
eliniegelt hl nppkqkli nt gntupkt{, Tbe apkeld tbel
kl}mpk`e} tbe }kilntupe ha tbe mbkjd nt tbe ahht ha tbevnpmbgelt* ybkmb k} bejd th `kld tbe mbkjd n} gumb n}
tbhuib be bnd }kiled kt bkg}eja,
Eqel tbk}* bhyeqep* dhe} lht aujj{ mhltelt tbeg* ahp
tbe{ aeej n jkttje ulen}{ ultkj tbe{ bnqe iht tbe mbkjd‛} hyl
}kilntupe natep njj, ]h ybel be k} n`hut ahupteel* tbe}e
ihhd vehvje vnptj{ `pk`e bkg `{ vphgk}e} ha ipentep jk`ept{ nld ihhd tbkli}* nld vnptj{ kltkgkdnte bkg tbphuib
tbekp ipent vhyep ha gnckli tbeg}ejqe} nmtkqej{ ulvjen}nlt
th bkg* }h tbnt tbhuib tbepe k} n }bhy ha apeedhg gnde*
tbepe k} penjj{ lhle3 tbe{ nj}h u}e tbe haakme} ha tbe tenmbep}
kl tbe Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl* tkjj nt jn}t* kl hle yn{ hp
nlhtbep* tbe{ tnce qep{ ihhd mnpe tbnt be }bnjj }kil tbevnvep `{ ybkmb be vphae}}e} th bnqe `eel n apee nielt kl
mhgkli klth tbe yhpjd* nld th tnce njj tbe pe}vhl}k`kjkt{ ha
bnqkli dhle }h hl th bk} hyl }bhujdep}, Nld {et* tbhuib
tbk} dhmugelt k} h`qkhu}j{ tbe gh}t kgvhptnlt ybkmb nl{
hle mnl }kil kl bk} ybhje jkae* tbe{ ykjj bnqe bkg dh }h nt
nl nie ybel lektbep tbe{ lhp tbe jny ykjj ahp gnl{ n {enp
njjhy nl{ hle ej}e th `kld bkg th tbe }gnjje}t h`jkintkhl*
lh gnttep bhy pkibtehu}j{ be gn{ hye kt* `emnu}e tbe{
bhjd bkg thh {huli th clhy ybnt be k} n`hut* nld dh lht
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 224/378
Epeybhl
004 ha =9;
mhl}kdep kt ankp tbnt be }bhujd mhggkt bkg}eja th nl{tbkli
tbnt gn{ vpeoudkme bkg kl natep {enp},K hyl tbnt njj tbk} }eeged pntbep bnpd* nld lht ha n
vkeme yktb tbe gnl{ ndgkpn`je kl}tktutkhl} erk}tkli nghli
tbeg, K hlme qeltuped th }n{ n vnpt ha ybnt K tbhuibt
n`hut kt th hle ha tbe Vphae}}hp} ha Ulpen}hl, K dkd kt qep{
teldepj{* `ut bk} ou}tkakmntkhl ha tbe }{}teg yn} ~ukte hut
ha g{ mhgvpebel}khl, K pegeg`ep n}ckli bkg ybetbep bedkd lht tbklc kt yhujd dh bnpg th n jnd‛} vpklmkvje}* `{
yencelkli bk} }el}e ha tbe }nlmtkt{ ha bk} yhpd nld ha
tputb ielepnjj{* tbnt be }bhujd `e jed klth eltepkli uvhl n
}hjegl demjnpntkhl n} th tbe tputb ha tbkli} n`hut ybkmb njj
tbnt be mnl meptnklj{ clhy k} tbnt be clhy} lhtbkli—
ybetbep* kl anmt* tbe tenmbep} ybh }h jed bkg* hp ybhtnuibt nl{tbkli n} n meptnklt{ ha ybkmb tbe{ yepe
tbeg}ejqe} ulmeptnkl* yepe lht enplkli tbekp jkqkli `{
kgvnkpkli tbe tputb'}el}e ha tbekp vuvkj} n dejkmnte
hpinlk}ntkhl gh}tj{+* nld `{ qktkntkli hle ha tbekp gh}t
}nmped kl}tklmt},
Tbe Vphae}}hp* ybh yn} n dejkibtauj vep}hl* }eeged
ipentj{ }upvpk}ed nt tbe qkey ybkmb K thhc* `ut kt bnd lh
klajuelme yktb bkg ybnt}heqep, Lh hle* be nl}yeped*
ervemted tbnt tbe `h{ ektbep yhujd hp mhujd clhy njj tbnt
be }nkd be cley3 `ut tbe yhpjd yn} aujj ha mhgvphgk}e}3
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 225/378
Epeybhl
005 ha =9;
nld tbepe yn} bnpdj{ nl{ naakpgntkhl ybkmb yhujd `enp
`ekli kltepvpeted jktepnjj{, Bugnl jnliunie yn} thh iph}}n qebkmje ha tbhuibt—tbhuibt `ekli klmnvn`je ha n`}hjute
tpnl}jntkhl, Be ndded* tbnt n} tbepe mnl `e lh tpnl}jntkhl
aphg hle jnliunie klth nlhtbep ybkmb }bnjj lht }mnlt tbe
genlkli }hgeybnt* hp eljnpie uvhl kt* }h tbepe k} lh
jnliunie ybkmb mnl peldep tbhuibt yktbhut n onppkli nld n
bnp}ble}} }hgeybepe—nld }h ahptb3 njj ha ybkmb }eegedth mhge th tbk} kl tbe eld* tbnt kt yn} tbe mu}thg ha tbe
mhultp{* nld tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl} yepe n mhl}epqntkqe
vehvje3 tbnt tbe `h{ yhujd bnqe th `eikl mhgvphgk}kli
}hhlep hp jntep* nld tbk} yn} vnpt ha bk} edumntkhl kl tbe
npt, Kt yn} vepbnv} th `e peipetted tbnt mhgvphgk}e }bhujd
`e n} leme}}np{ n} kt yn}3 }tkjj kt yn} leme}}np{* nld tbe}hhlep tbe `h{ iht th uldep}tnld kt tbe `ettep ahp bkg}eja,
@ut tbe{ leqep tejj tbk} th tbe `h{,
Aphg tbe `hhc ha tbekp g{tbhjhi{ n`hut tbe ul`hpl K
gnde tbe ertpnmt} ybkmb ykjj ahpg tbe ahjjhykli mbnvtep,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 226/378
Epeybhl
001 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RKR? TBE YHPJD HA TBEUL@HPL
Tbe Epeybhlknl} }n{ tbnt ye npe dpnyl tbphuib jkae
`nmcynpd}3 hp ninkl* tbnt ye ih hlynpd} klth tbe autupe n}
klth n dnpc mhppkdhp, Tkge ynjc} `e}kde u} nld ajkli} `nmc
}buttep} n} ye ndqnlme3 `ut tbe jkibt tbu} ikqel hatel
dnzzje} u}* nld deevel} tbe dnpcle}} ybkmb k} kl aphlt, Ye
mnl }ee `ut jkttje nt n tkge* nld beed tbnt jkttje anp je}} tbnl
hup nvvpebel}khl ha ybnt ye }bnjj }ee lert3 eqep veepkli
mupkhu}j{ tbphuib tbe ijnpe ha tbe vpe}elt klth tbe ijhhg
ha tbe autupe* ye vpe}nie tbe jendkli jkle} ha tbnt ybkmb k}
`eahpe u}* `{ ankltj{ peajemted jkibt} aphg dujj gkpphp} tbnt
npe `ebkld* nld }tug`je hl n} ye gn{ tkjj tbe tpnv'dhhp
hvel} `elentb u} nld ye npe ihle,
Tbe{ }n{ nt htbep tkge} tbnt tbe autupe nld tbe vn}t npe
n} n vnlhpngn uvhl tyh phjjep}3 tbnt ybkmb k} hl tbe phjjep
ha tbe autupe ulypnv} kt}eja hl th tbe phjjep ha tbe vn}t3 ye
mnllht bn}tel kt* nld ye gn{ lht }tn{ kt3 ye gu}t }ee njj
tbnt k} ulahjded th u} ybetbep kt `e ihhd hp kjj3 nld ybntye bnqe }eel hlme ye gn{ }ee ninkl lh ghpe, Kt k} eqep
ulykldkli nld `ekli yhuld3 ye mntmb kt kl tpnl}ktkhl ahp
n ghgelt* nld mnjj kt vpe}elt3 hup aju}teped }el}e} intbep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 227/378
Epeybhl
009 ha =9;
ybnt kgvpe}}khl tbe{ mnl* nld ye iue}} nt ybnt k} mhgkli
`{ tbe telhp ha tbnt ybkmb ye bnqe }eel, Tbe }nge bnldbn} vnklted tbe ybhje vkmtupe* nld tbe klmkdelt} qnp{
jkttje—pkqep}* yhhd}* vjnkl}* ghultnkl}* thyl} nld
vehvje}* jhqe* }hpphy* nld dentb? {et tbe kltepe}t leqep
ajni}* nld ye jhhc bhveaujj{ ahp }hge ihhd ahptule* hp
aenpaujj{ je}t hup hyl anme} `e }bhyl u} n} akiupkli kl
}hgetbkli teppk`je, Ybel tbe }mele k} vn}t ye tbklc yeclhy kt* tbhuib tbepe k} }h gumb th }ee* nld }h jkttje tkge
th }ee kt* tbnt hup mhlmekt ha clhyjedie n} peinpd} tbe vn}t
k} ahp tbe gh}t vnpt vhhpj{ ahulded3 lektbep dh ye mnpe
n`hut kt ipentj{* }nqe kl }h anp n} kt gn{ naaemt tbe autupe*
ybepekl hup kltepe}t gnklj{ jke},
Tbe Epeybhlknl} }n{ kt yn} `{ mbnlme hlj{ tbnt tbeenptb nld }tnp} nld njj tbe benqelj{ yhpjd} `einl th phjj
aphg en}t th ye}t* nld lht aphg ye}t th en}t* nld kl jkce
gnllep tbe{ }n{ kt k} `{ mbnlme tbnt gnl k} dpnyl tbphuib
jkae yktb bk} anme th tbe vn}t kl}tend ha th tbe autupe, Ahp
tbe autupe k} tbepe n} gumb n} tbe vn}t* hlj{ tbnt ye gn{
lht }ee kt, K} kt lht kl tbe jhkl} ha tbe vn}t* nld gu}t lht
tbe vn}t njtep `eahpe tbe autupe mnl dh }h8
]hgetkge}* ninkl* tbe{ }n{ tbnt tbepe yn} n pnme ha gel
tpked uvhl tbe enptb hlme* ybh cley tbe autupe `ettep
tbnl tbe vn}t* `ut tbnt tbe{ dked kl n tyejqeghltb aphg
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 228/378
Epeybhl
002 ha =9;
tbe gk}ep{ ybkmb tbekp clhyjedie mnu}ed tbeg3 nld ka nl{
yepe th `e `hpl thh vpe}mkelt lhy* be yhujd `e mujjedhut `{ lntupnj }ejemtkhl* `eahpe be bnd tkge th tpnl}gkt }h
venme'de}tph{kli n anmujt{ th bk} de}meldnlt},
]tpnlie ante ahp gnl. Be gu}t vepk}b ka be iet tbnt*
ybkmb be gu}t vepk}b ka be }tpkqe lht natep, Ka be }tpkqe lht
natep kt be k} lh `ettep tbnl tbe `pute}* ka be iet kt be k}
ghpe gk}epn`je tbnl tbe deqkj},Bnqkli ynded tbphuib gnl{ mbnvtep} jkce tbe n`hqe* K
mnge nt jn}t th tbe ul`hpl tbeg}ejqe}* nld ahuld tbnt tbe{
yepe bejd th `e }huj} vupe nld }kgvje* bnqkli lh nmtunj
`hdke}* `ut jkqkli kl n }hpt ha in}ehu} {et ghpe hp je}}
nltbphvhghpvbkm erk}telme* jkce tbnt ha n ibh}t3 tbe{ bnqe
tbu} lektbep aje}b lhp `jhhd lhp ynpgtb, Leqeptbeje}}tbe{ npe }uvvh}ed th bnqe jhmnj bn`ktntkhl} nld mktke}
ybepekl tbe{ dyejj* tbhuib tbe}e npe n} ul}u`}tnltknj n}
tbekp klbn`ktnlt}3 tbe{ npe eqel tbhuibt th ent nld dpklc
}hge tbkl ng`ph}knj }u}telnlme* nld ielepnjj{ th `e
mnvn`je ha dhkli ybnteqep gnlckld mnl dh* hlj{ natep n
qk}khlnp{ ibh}tj{ an}bkhl n} kl n dpeng, Hl tbe htbep
bnld* n} jhli n} tbe{ pegnkl ybepe tbe{ npe tbe{ leqep
dke—tbe hlj{ ahpg ha dentb kl tbe ul`hpl yhpjd `ekli
tbe jenqkli kt ahp hup hyl, Tbe{ npe `ejkeqed th `e
ertpegej{ lugephu}* anp ghpe }h tbnl gnlckld, Tbe{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 229/378
Epeybhl
00; ha =9;
nppkqe aphg ulclhyl vjnlet}* aujj iphyl* kl jnpie `ntmbe}
nt n tkge3 `ut tbe{ mnl hlj{ jenqe tbe ul`hpl yhpjd `{tnckli tbe }tev} leme}}np{ ahp tbekp nppkqnj bepe—ybkmb k}*
kl anmt* `{ }ukmkde,
Tbe{ huibt th `e nl ermeedklij{ bnvv{ vehvje* ahp
tbe{ bnqe lh ertpege} ha ihhd hp kjj ahptule3 leqep
gnpp{kli* `ut jkqkli kl n }tnte gumb jkce tbnt an`jed `{ tbe
vhet} n} tbe vpkgktkqe mhldktkhl ha gnlckld, Kl }vkte ha tbk}* bhyeqep* tbe{ npe klme}}nltj{ mhgvjnklkli3 tbe{
clhy tbnt ye kl tbk} yhpjd bnqe `hdke}* nld kldeed tbe{
clhy eqep{tbkli ej}e n`hut u}* ahp tbe{ ghqe nghli u}
ybktbep}heqep tbe{ ykjj* nld mnl pend hup tbhuibt}* n}
yejj n} }upqe{ hup nmtkhl} nt vjen}upe, Hle yhujd tbklc
tbnt tbk} }bhujd `e elhuib ahp tbeg3 nld gh}t ha tbeg npekldeed njkqe th tbe de}vepnte pk}c ybkmb tbe{ ykjj pul `{
kldujikli tbeg}ejqe} kl tbnt `hd{ yktb ‒}el}k`je ynpg
ghtkhl‛ ybkmb tbe{ }h gumb de}kpe3 leqeptbeje}}* tbepe npe
}hge th ybhg tbe elluk ha n dk}eg`hdked erk}telme k} }h
klthjepn`je tbnt tbe{ ykjj qeltupe nl{tbkli ahp n mbnlie3 }h
tbe{ pe}hjqe th ~ukt, Tbe mhldktkhl} ybkmb tbe{ gu}t
nmmevt npe }h ulmeptnkl* tbnt lhle `ut tbe gh}t ahhjk}b ha
tbe ul`hpl ykjj mhl}elt th tbeg3 nld kt k} aphg tbe}e* nld
tbe}e hlj{* tbnt hup hyl pnlc} npe pempukted,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 230/378
Epeybhl
0=6 ha =9;
Ybel tbe{ bnqe aklnjj{ gnde uv tbekp gkld} th jenqe*
tbe{ gu}t ih `eahpe tbe gnik}tpnte ha tbe lenpe}t thyl*nld }kil nl naakdnqkt ha tbekp de}kpe th ~ukt tbekp tbel
erk}telme, Hl tbekp bnqkli dhle tbk}* tbe gnik}tpnte pend}
tbeg tbe mhldktkhl} ybkmb tbe{ gu}t nmmevt* nld ybkmb
npe }h jhli tbnt K mnl hlj{ ertpnmt }hge ha tbe vpklmkvnj
vhklt}* ybkmb npe gnklj{ tbe ahjjhykli?'
Akp}t* tbe{ gu}t tnce n vhtkhl ybkmb ykjj de}tph{ tbekp geghp{ nld }el}e ha kdeltkt{3 tbe{ gu}t ih klth tbe
yhpjd bejvje}}* nld yktbhut n ykjj ha tbekp hyl3 tbe{ gu}t
dpny jht} ahp tbekp dk}vh}ktkhl} `eahpe tbe{ ih* nld tnce
tbeg* }umb n} tbe{ npe* ahp `ettep hp yhp}e—lektbep npe
tbe{ th `e njjhyed nl{ mbhkme kl tbe gnttep ha tbe `hd{
ybkmb tbe{ }h gumb de}kpe3 tbe{ npe }kgvj{ njjhtted `{mbnlme* nld yktbhut nvvenj* th tyh vehvje ybhg kt k}
tbekp `u}kle}} th akld nld ve}tep ultkj tbe{ ndhvt tbeg,
Ybh tbe}e npe th `e* ybetbep pkmb hp vhhp* ckld hp
ulckld* benjtb{ hp dk}en}ed* tbepe k} lh clhykli3 tbe{
bnqe* kl anmt* th eltpu}t tbeg}ejqe} ahp gnl{ {enp} th tbe
mnpe ha tbh}e ahp ybh}e ihhd mhl}tktutkhl nld ihhd }el}e
tbe{ bnqe lh }hpt ha iunpnltee,
Kt k} mupkhu} th pend tbe jemtupe} ybkmb tbe yk}ep bend}
ikqe th tbh}e ybh npe gedktntkli n mbnlie, Tbe{ tnjc yktb
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 231/378
Epeybhl
0=> ha =9;
tbeg n} ye tnjc yktb n }veldtbpkat* nld yktb n`hut n}
gumb }umme}},‒Th `e `hpl*‛ tbe{ }n{* ‒k} n aejhl{—kt k} n mnvktnj
mpkge* ahp ybkmb }eltelme gn{ `e eremuted nt nl{
ghgelt natep tbe mhggk}}khl ha tbe haaelme, [hu gn{
vepbnv} bnvvel th jkqe ahp }hge }eqelt{ hp ekibt{ {enp}*
`ut ybnt k} tbnt* mhgvnped yktb tbe eteplkt{ {hu lhy
eloh{8 Nld eqel tbhuib tbe }eltelme yepe mhgguted*nld {hu yepe njjhyed th jkqe hl ahp eqep* {hu yhujd kl
tkge `emhge }h teppk`j{ yenp{ ha jkae tbnt eremutkhl yhujd
`e tbe ipente}t gepm{ th {hu,
‒Mhl}kdep tbe klaklkte pk}c3 th `e `hpl ha ykmced vnpelt}
nld tpnkled kl qkme. th `e `hpl ha }kjj{ vnpelt}* nld tpnkled
th ulpenjktke}. ha vnpelt} ybh peinpd {hu n} n }hpt ha mbnttej hp vphvept{* `ejhlikli ghpe th tbeg tbnl th
{hup}eja. Ninkl* {hu gn{ dpny uttepj{ ul}{gvntbetkm
vnpelt}* ybh ykjj leqep `e n`je th uldep}tnld {hu* nld
ybh ykjj dh tbekp `e}t th tbynpt {hu n} n bel ybel }be
bn} bntmbed n dumcjkli+* nld tbel mnjj {hu ulipnteauj
`emnu}e {hu dh lht jhqe tbeg3 hp* ninkl* {hu gn{ dpny
vnpelt} ybh jhhc uvhl {hu n} n tbkli th `e mhyed ybkje
kt k} }tkjj {huli* je}t kt }bhujd ikqe tbeg tphu`je bepenatep
`{ bnqkli yk}be} nld aeejkli} ha kt} hyl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 232/378
Epeybhl
0=0 ha =9;
‒Kl jntep jkae* ybel {hu bnqe `eel aklnjj{ njjhyed th
vn}} gu}tep n} n aujj geg`ep ha tbe yhpjd* {hu ykjj {hup}eja `emhge jkn`je th tbe ve}tepkli} ha tbe ul`hpl—
nld n qep{ bnvv{ jkae {hu gn{ `e jed kl mhl}e~uelme. Ahp
ye }hjkmkt }h }tphlij{ tbnt n aey hlj{—lhp tbe}e tbe
`e}t—mnl peau}e u}3 nld {et lht th peau}e k} gumb tbe }nge
n} ihkli klth vnptlep}bkv yktb bnja'n'dhzel dkaaepelt
vehvje n`hut ybhg hle mnl clhy n`}hjutej{ lhtbkli`eahpebnld—lht eqel ybetbep hle k} ihkli klth
vnptlep}bkv yktb gel hp yhgel* lhp yktb bhy gnl{ ha
ektbep, Dejude lht {hup}eja yktb tbklckli tbnt {hu ykjj `e
yk}ep tbnl {hup vnpelt}, [hu gn{ `e nl nie kl ndqnlme ha
tbh}e ybhg {hu bnqe ve}teped* `ut ulje}} {hu npe hle ha
tbe ipent hle} {hu ykjj }tkjj `e nl nie `ebkld tbh}e ybhykjj kl tbekp tupl ve}tep {hu,
‒Kgnikle ybnt kt gu}t `e th bnqe nl ul`hpl ~unpteped
uvhl {hu* ybh k} ha nl eltkpej{ dkaaepelt tegvepngelt nld
dk}vh}ktkhl th {hup hyl3 ln{* bnja'n'dhzel }umb* ybh ykjj
lht jhqe {hu tbhuib {hu bnqe }tklted {hup}eja kl n
tbhu}nld yn{} th vphqkde ahp tbekp mhgahpt nld yejj'
`ekli*—ybh ykjj ahpiet njj {hup }eja'}nmpkakme* nld ha
ybhg {hu gn{ leqep `e }upe tbnt tbe{ npe lht `enpkli n
ipudie ninkl}t {hu ahp epphp} ha oudiegelt klth ybkmb {hu
gn{ bnqe anjjel* tbhuib {hu bnd bhved tbnt }umb bnd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 233/378
Epeybhl
0== ha =9;
`eel jhli }klme nthled ahp, Klipntktude }umb n} tbk} k} lht
ulmhgghl* {et anlm{ ybnt kt gu}t `e th `enp. Kt k} bnpduvhl tbe dumcjkli th bnqe `eel bntmbed `{ n bel* `ut k} kt
lht nj}h bnpd uvhl tbe bel th bnqe bntmbed tbe dumcjkli8
‒Mhl}kdep kt ninkl* ye vpn{ {hu* lht ahp hup }nce `ut
ahp {hup hyl, [hup klktknj mbnpnmtep {hu gu}t dpny `{ jht3
`ut ybnteqep kt k}* kt mnl hlj{ mhge th n thjepn`j{
}umme}}auj deqejhvgelt natep jhli tpnklkli3 pegeg`ep tbnthqep tbnt tpnklkli {hu ykjj bnqe lh mhltphj, Kt k} vh}}k`je*
nld eqel vph`n`je* tbnt ybnteqep {hu gn{ iet kl natep jkae
ybkmb k} ha penj vjen}upe nld }epqkme th {hu* ykjj bnqe th
`e yhl kl }vkte ha* pntbep tbnl `{ tbe bejv ha* tbh}e ybhg
{hu npe lhy n`hut th ve}tep* nld tbnt {hu ykjj hlj{ ykl
{hup apeedhg natep {enp} ha n vnklauj }tpuiije kl ybkmb ktykjj `e bnpd th }n{ ybetbep {hu bnqe }uaaeped gh}t kloup{*
hp klajkmted kt,
‒Pegeg`ep nj}h* tbnt ka {hu ih klth tbe yhpjd {hu ykjj
bnqe apee ykjj3 tbnt {hu ykjj `e h`jkied th bnqe kt3 tbnt
tbepe k} lh e}mnvkli kt3 tbnt {hu ykjj `e aetteped th kt
dupkli {hup ybhje jkae* nld gu}t hl eqep{ hmmn}khl dh
tbnt ybkmb hl tbe ybhje }eeg} `e}t th {hu nt nl{ ikqel
tkge* lh gnttep ybetbep {hu npe pkibt hp yphli kl
mbhh}kli kt, [hup gkld ykjj `e n `njnlme ahp
mhl}kdepntkhl}* nld {hup nmtkhl ykjj ih yktb tbe benqkep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 234/378
Epeybhl
0=4 ha =9;
}mnje, Bhy kt }bnjj anjj ykjj develd uvhl tbe ckld ha }mnje}
ybkmb {hu gn{ bnqe dpnyl nt `kptb* tbe `kn} ybkmb tbe{ykjj bnqe h`tnkled `{ u}e* nld tbe yekibt ha tbe
kggedknte mhl}kdepntkhl}, Ka tbe }mnje} yepe ihhd th }tnpt
yktb* nld ka tbe{ bnqe lht `eel hutpniehu}j{ tngveped
yktb kl mbkjdbhhd* nld ka tbe mhg`klntkhl} klth ybkmb
{hu eltep npe nqepnie hle}* {hu gn{ mhge haa yejj3 `ut
tbepe npe thh gnl{ ‒ka}‛ kl tbk}* nld yktb tbe ankjupe ha nl{hle ha tbeg {hup gk}ep{ k} n}}uped, Peajemt hl tbk}* nld
pegeg`ep tbnt }bhujd tbe kjj mhge uvhl {hu* {hu ykjj
bnqe {hup}eja th tbnlc* ahp kt k} {hup hyl mbhkme th `e
`hpl* nld tbepe k} lh mhgvuj}khl kl tbe gnttep,
‒Lht tbnt ye del{ tbe erk}telme ha vjen}upe} nghli
gnlckld3 tbepe k} n meptnkl }bhy ha }uldp{ vbn}e} ha mhlteltgelt ybkmb gn{ eqel nghult th qep{
mhl}kdepn`je bnvvkle}}3 `ut gnpc bhy tbe{ npe dk}tpk`uted
hqep n gnl‛} jkae* `ejhlikli* njj tbe ceele}t ha tbeg* th tbe
ahpe vnpt* nld aey kldeed th tbe natep, Mnl tbepe `e nl{
vjen}upe yhptb vupmbn}kli yktb tbe gk}epke} ha n dempevkt
nie8 Ka {hu npe ihhd* }tphli* nld bnld}hge* {hu bnqe n
akle ahptule kldeed nt tyelt{* `ut bhy gumb ha kt ykjj `e
jeat nt }krt{8 Ahp {hu gu}t jkqe hl {hup mnvktnj3 tbepe k} lh
klqe}tkli {hup vhyep} }h tbnt {hu gn{ iet n }gnjj nllukt{
ha jkae ahp eqep? {hu gu}t ent uv {hup vpklmkvnj `kt `{ `kt*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 235/378
Epeybhl
0=5 ha =9;
nld `e thptuped `{ }eekli kt iphy mhltklunjj{ }gnjjep nld
}gnjjep* eqel tbhuib {hu bnvvel th e}mnve `ekli pudej{ph``ed ha kt `{ mpkge hp mn}unjt{,
‒Pegeg`ep* thh* tbnt tbepe leqep {et yn} n gnl ha
ahpt{ ybh yhujd lht mhge `nmc klth tbe yhpjd ha tbe
ul`hpl ka be mhujd dh }h yktb demelm{ nld bhlhup, @ekli
kl tbe yhpjd be ykjj n} n ielepnj puje }tn{ tkjj be k} ahpmed
th ih3 `ut dh {hu tbklc tbnt be yhujd mhl}elt th `e `hplninkl* nld pe'jkqe bk} jkae* ka be bnd tbe haaep ha dhkli }h8
Dh lht tbklc kt, Ka be mhujd }h njtep tbe vn}t n} tbnt be
}bhujd leqep bnqe mhge klth `ekli nt njj* dh {hu lht
tbklc tbnt be yhujd dh kt qep{ ijndj{8
‒Ybnt yn} kt tbnt hle ha tbekp hyl vhet} genlt* ka kt
yn} lht tbk}* ybel be mpked hut uvhl tbe dn{ kl ybkmb beyn} `hpl* nld tbe lkibt kl ybkmb kt yn} }nkd tbepe k} n gnl
mbkjd mhlmekqed8 ‒Ahp lhy*‛ be }n{}* ‒K }bhujd bnqe jnkl
}tkjj nld `eel ~uket* K }bhujd bnqe }jevt3 tbel bnd K `eel nt
pe}t yktb ckli} nld mhul}ejjhp} ha tbe enptb* ybkmb `ukjt
de}hjnte vjnme} ahp tbeg}ejqe}3 hp yktb vpklme} tbnt bnd
ihjd* ybh akjjed tbekp bhu}e} yktb }kjqep3 hp n} nl bkddel
ultkgej{ `kptb* K bnd lht `eel3 n} klanlt} ybkmb leqep }ny
jkibt, Tbepe tbe ykmced men}e aphg tphu`jkli* nld tbe
yenp{ npe nt pe}t,‛ @e qep{ }upe tbnt tbe iukjt ha `ekli `hpl
mnppke} tbk} vulk}bgelt nt tkge} th njj gel3 `ut bhy mnl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 236/378
Epeybhl
0=1 ha =9;
tbe{ n}c ahp vkt{* hp mhgvjnkl ha nl{ gk}mbkea tbnt gn{
`eanjj tbeg* bnqkli elteped hvel'e{ed klth tbe }lnpe8‒Hle yhpd ghpe nld ye bnqe dhle, Ka nl{ anklt
pegeg`pnlme* n} ha n dpeng* ajkt kl }hge vuzzjed ghgelt
nmph}} {hup `pnkl* nld {hu }bnjj aeej tbnt tbe vhtkhl ybkmb
k} th `e ikqel {hu }bnjj lht bnqe dhle kt} yhpc* nld tbe
geghp{ ha tbk} erk}telme ybkmb {hu npe jenqkli
eldenqhup} qnklj{ th petupl3 ye }n{ kl }umb n ghgelt*ybel {hu mjutmb nt tbe dpeng `ut kt ejude} {hup ipn}v*
nld {hu yntmb kt* n} Hpvbeu} yntmbed Eup{dkme* ijkdkli
`nmc ninkl klth tbe tykjkibt cklidhg* aj{—aj{—ka {hu mnl
pegeg`ep tbe ndqkme—th tbe bnqel ha {hup vpe}elt nld
kggedknte dut{* tnckli }bejtep klme}}nltj{ kl tbe yhpc
ybkmb {hu bnqe kl bnld, Tbk} gumb {hu gn{ vepbnv}pemnjj3 nld tbk}* ka {hu ykjj kgvpklt kt deevj{ uvhl {hup
eqep{ anmujt{* ykjj `e gh}t jkcej{ th `pkli {hu }naej{ nld
bhlhupn`j{ bhge tbphuib tbe tpknj} tbnt npe `eahpe {hu,‛
s=w
Tbk} k} tbe an}bkhl kl ybkmb tbe{ pen}hl yktb tbh}e
ybh yhujd `e ahp jenqkli tbeg* `ut kt k} }ejdhg tbnt tbe{
dh gumb ihhd* ahp lhle `ut tbe ul~uket nld ulpen}hln`je
eqep tbklc ha `ekli `hpl* nld tbh}e ybh npe ahhjk}b
elhuib th tbklc ha kt npe ielepnjj{ ahhjk}b elhuib th dh kt,
Akldkli* tbepeahpe* tbnt tbe{ mnl dh lh ghpe* tbe apkeld}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 237/378
Epeybhl
0=9 ha =9;
ahjjhy yeevkli th tbe mhuptbhu}e ha tbe mbkea gnik}tpnte*
ybepe tbe hle ybh yk}be} th `e `hpl demjnpe} }hjeglj{nld hvelj{ tbnt be nmmevt} tbe mhldktkhl} nttnmbed th bk}
demk}khl, Hl tbk} be k} vpe}elted yktb n vhtkhl* ybkmb
kggedkntej{ de}tph{} bk} geghp{ nld }el}e ha kdeltkt{*
nld dk}}kvnte} tbe tbkl in}ehu} telegelt ybkmb be bn}
klbn`kted? be `emhge} n `npe qktnj vpklmkvje* lht th `e
vepmekqed `{ bugnl }el}e}* lhp th `e `{ nl{ mbegkmnj te}tnvvpemknted, Be bn} `ut hle kl}tklmt* ybkmb k} tbnt be k} th
ih th }umb nld }umb n vjnme* ybepe be ykjj akld tyh
vep}hl} ybhg be k} th kgvhptule tkjj tbe{ mhl}elt th
uldeptnce bkg3 `ut ybetbep be k} th akld tbe}e vep}hl}
nghli tbe pnme ha Mbhy`hc hp tbe Epeybhlknl}
tbeg}ejqe} k} lht ahp bkg th mbhh}e,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 238/378
Epeybhl
0=2 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RR? YBNT TBE[ GENL @[KT
K bnqe ikqel tbe n`hqe g{tbhjhi{ nt }hge jelitb* `ut
kt k} hlj{ n }gnjj vnpt ha ybnt tbe{ bnqe uvhl tbe }u`oemt,
G{ akp}t aeejkli hl pendkli kt yn} tbnt nl{ nghult ha ahjj{
hl tbe vnpt ha tbe ul`hpl kl mhgkli bepe yn} ou}tkaked `{
n de}kpe th e}mnve aphg }umb klthjepn`je vph}kli, Tbe
g{tbhjhi{ k} h`qkhu}j{ nl ulankp nld erniiepnted
pevpe}eltntkhl ha jkae nld tbkli}3 nld bnd kt} nutbhp} `eel
}h gklded tbe{ mhujd bnqe en}kj{ dpnyl n vkmtupe ybkmb
yhujd epp n} gumb hl tbe `pkibt }kde n} tbk} dhe} hl tbe
dnpc, Lh Epeybhlknl `ejkeqe} tbnt tbe yhpjd k} n} `jnmc n}
kt bn} `eel bepe vnklted* `ut kt k} hle ha tbekp vemujknpktke}
tbnt tbe{ qep{ hatel dh lht `ejkeqe hp genl tbkli} ybkmb
tbe{ vphae}} th peinpd n} kldk}vutn`je,
Kl tbe vpe}elt kl}tnlme tbekp vphae}}ed qkey} mhlmeplkli
tbe ul`hpl bnqe npk}el aphg tbekp de}kpe th vphqe tbnt
vehvje bnqe `eel vpe}elted yktb tbe ijhhgke}t vh}}k`je
vkmtupe ha tbekp hyl vph}vemt} `eahpe tbe{ mnge bepe3htbepyk}e* tbe{ mhujd bnpdj{ }n{ th hle ybhg tbe{ npe
ihkli th vulk}b ahp nl naaemtkhl ha tbe benpt hp `pnkl tbnt kt
k} njj bk} hyl dhkli, Kl vpnmtkme tbe{ ghdka{ tbekp tbehp{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 239/378
Epeybhl
0=; ha =9;
th n mhl}kdepn`je ertelt* nld }ejdhg peaep th tbe `kptb
ahpgujn ermevt kl ertpege mn}e}3 ahp tbe ahpme ha bn`kt* hp ybnt lht* ikqe} gnl{ ha tbeg n ckldj{ kltepe}t eqel kl
mpentupe} ybh bnqe }h gumb yphlied tbeg n} tbe ul`hpl
bnqe dhle3 nld tbhuib n gnl ielepnjj{ bnte} tbe
ulyejmhge jkttje }tpnliep ahp tbe akp}t tyejqe ghltb}* be k}
nvt th ghjjka{ nmmhpdkli th bk} jkibt}+ n} tkge ihe} hl* nld
}hgetkge} be ykjj `emhge klhpdklntej{ nttnmbed th tbe`ekli} ybhg be k} vjen}ed th mnjj bk} mbkjdpel,
Ha mhup}e* nmmhpdkli th Epeybhlknl vpegk}e}* kt yhujd
}epqe vehvje pkibt th `e vulk}bed nld }mhuted ahp ghpnj
nld kltejjemtunj dk}en}e} n} gumb n} ahp vb{}kmnj* nld K
mnllht th tbk} dn{ uldep}tnld yb{ tbe{ }bhujd bnqe
}thvved }bhpt bnja yn{, Lektbep* ninkl* mnl K uldep}tnldyb{ tbekp bnqkli dhle }h }bhujd bnqe `eel* n} kt meptnklj{
yn}* n gnttep ha }h gumb mhlmepl th g{}eja, Ybnt mhujd kt
gnttep th ge bhy gnl{ n`}updktke} tbe Epeybhlknl}
gkibt ndhvt8 Leqeptbeje}} K jhlied th gnce tbeg tbklc n}
K dkd* ahp tbe yk}b th }vpend tbh}e hvklkhl} tbnt ye bhjd
mhldumkqe th hup hyl yejanpe k} }h deevj{ phhted kl tbe
Elijk}b mbnpnmtep tbnt aey ha u} mnl e}mnve kt} klajuelme,
@ut jet tbk} vn}},
Kl }vkte ha lht n aey ghdkakmntkhl} kl vpnmtkme ha n
tbehp{ ybkmb k} kt}eja peqhjtkli* tbe pejntkhl} `etyeel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 240/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 241/378
Epeybhl
04> ha =9;
th aeej tbnt >; nld >= gnce =0 n} meptnklj{ n} 0 nld 0 gnce
4,K ng ~ukte }upe tbnt ka tbk} lnppntkqe }bhujd eqep anjj klth
Epeybhlknl bnld}* kt ykjj `e }nkd tbnt ybnt K bnqe ypkttel
n`hut tbe pejntkhl} `etyeel vnpelt} nld mbkjdpel `ekli
}ejdhg }ntk}anmthp{ k} nl klanghu} vepqep}khl ha anmt}* nld
tbnt kl tputb tbepe npe aey {huli vehvje ybh dh lht aeej
bnvvkep kl tbe }hmket{ ha tbekp lenpe}t pejntkhl} s4w tbnl klnl{ htbep, Gp, Lh}lk`hp yhujd `e }upe th }n{ tbk}, [et K
mnllht peapnkl aphg ervpe}}kli nl hvklkhl tbnt be yhujd
`e n ihhd denj eg`nppn}}ed ka bk} demen}ed vnpelt} yepe th
penvvenp nld vphvh}e th vn{ bkg n }kr ghltb}‛ qk}kt, K
dhu`t ybetbep tbepe npe gnl{ tbkli} ybkmb be yhujd
peinpd n} n ipentep klajkmtkhl, Tbe{ bnd dked nt n pkve hjdnie }hge tyelt{ {enp} `eahpe K mnge th clhy bkg* }h tbe
mn}e k} nl ertpege hle3 `ut }upej{ ka tbe{ bnd tpented bkg
yktb ybnt kl bk} {hutb be bnd aejt th `e tpue ul}ejak}ble}}*
bk} anme yhujd `pkibtel ybel be tbhuibt ha tbeg th tbe
eld ha bk} jkae,
Kl tbe hle hp tyh mn}e} ha tpue angkj{ naaemtkhl ybkmb K
get yktb* K ng }upe tbnt tbe {huli vehvje ybh yepe }h
ieluklej{ ahld ha tbekp antbep} nld ghtbep} nt ekibteel*
yhujd nt }krt{ `e vepaemtj{ dejkibted yepe tbe{ th iet tbe
mbnlme ha yejmhgkli tbeg n} tbekp iue}t}, Tbepe k}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 242/378
Epeybhl
040 ha =9;
lhtbkli ybkmb mhujd vjen}e tbeg `ettep* ermevt vepbnv} th
yntmb tbe bnvvkle}} ha tbekp hyl mbkjdpel nldipnldmbkjdpel,
Tbk} k} bhy tbkli} }bhujd `e, Kt k} lht nl kgvh}}k`je
kdenj3 kt k} hle ybkmb nmtunjj{ dhe} erk}t kl }hge aey mn}e}*
nld gkibt erk}t kl njgh}t njj* yktb n jkttje ghpe vntkelme
nld ahp`enpnlme uvhl tbe vnpelt}‛ vnpt3 `ut kt k} pnpe nt
vpe}elt—}h pnpe tbnt tbe{ bnqe n vphqep` ybkmb K mnl hlj{tpnl}jnte kl n qep{ phuldn`hut yn{* `ut ybkmb }n{} tbnt tbe
ipent bnvvkle}} ha }hge vehvje kl n autupe }tnte ykjj mhl}k}t
kl yntmbkli tbe dk}tpe}} ha tbekp vnpelt} hl petuplkli th
eteplnj mhgvnlkhl}bkv yktb tbekp ipnldantbep} nld
ipnldghtbep}3 ybkj}t ‒mhgvuj}hp{ naaemtkhl‛ k} tbe kden
ybkmb jke} nt tbe phht ha tbekp yhpd ahp tbe deeve}tnliuk}b,
Tbepe k} lh tnjk}gnl kl tbe yhpd ‒vnpelt‛ ybkmb mnl
ielepnte gkpnmje} ha naaemtkhl* nld K mnl yejj `ejkeqe tbnt
g{ hyl mbkjd gkibt akld kt je}} ha n mnjngkt{ th jh}e `htb
Nphybeln nld g{}eja ybel be k} }kr {enp} hjd* tbnl th
akld u} ninkl ybel be k} }krt{—n }eltelme ybkmb K yhujd
lht vel dkd K lht aeej tbnt `{ dhkli }h K yn} ikqkli bkg
}hgetbkli jkce n bh}tnie* hp nt nl{ pnte vuttkli n yenvhl
klth bk} bnld} ninkl}t ge* }bhujd g{ }ejak}ble}} ermeed
pen}hln`je jkgkt},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 243/378
Epeybhl
04= ha =9;
Ghle{ k} nt tbe `htthg ha njj tbk} th n ipent ertelt, Ka
tbe vnpelt} yhujd vut tbekp mbkjdpel kl tbe yn{ ha enplklin mhgvetelme enpjkep tbnl tbe{ dh* tbe mbkjdpel yhujd
}hhl `emhge }eja' }uvvhptkli nld kldeveldelt, N} kt k}*
uldep tbe vpe}elt }{}teg* tbe {huli hle} iet hjd elhuib
th bnqe njj gnllep ha jeiktkgnte ynlt} tbnt k}* ka tbe{ bnqe
nl{ ‒ih‛ n`hut tbeg+ `eahpe tbe{ bnqe jenplt tbe genl} ha
enplkli ghle{ th vn{ ahp tbeg3 belme tbe{ gu}t ektbep dhyktbhut tbeg* hp tnce ghpe ghle{ tbnl tbe vnpelt} mnl
`e ervemted th }vnpe, Tbk} k} due mbkeaj{ th tbe }mbhhj} ha
Ulpen}hl* ybepe n `h{ k} tnuibt uvhl b{vhtbetkmnj
vpklmkvje}* n} K ykjj ervjnkl bepenatep3 }veldkli {enp} kl
`ekli klmnvnmktnted ahp dhkli tbk}* tbnt* hp tbe htbep be
bnpdj{ clhy} ybnt+* dupkli njj ybkmb tkge be huibt thbnqe `eel nmtunjj{ dhkli tbe tbkli kt}eja* `eikllkli nt tbe
jhye}t ipnde}* vkmckli kt uv tbphuib nmtunj vpnmtkme* nld
pk}kli nmmhpdkli th tbe elepi{ ybkmb k} kl bkg,
Tbe}e }mbhhj} ha Ulpen}hl }upvpk}ed ge gumb, Kt
yhujd `e en}{ th anjj klth v}eudh'utkjktnpknlk}g* nld K
yhujd ankl `ejkeqe tbnt tbe }{}teg gn{ `e ihhd ahp tbe
mbkjdpel ha qep{ pkmb vnpelt}* hp ahp tbh}e ybh }bhy n
lntupnj kl}tklmt th nm~ukpe b{vhtbetkmnj jhpe3 `ut tbe gk}ep{
yn} tbnt tbekp [dipul'yhp}bkv pe~ukped njj vehvje yktb
nl{ vpetelme th pe}vemtn`kjkt{ th }eld tbekp mbkjdpel th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 244/378
Epeybhl
044 ha =9;
}hge hle hp htbep ha tbe}e }mbhhj}* gujmtkli tbeg ha
{enp} ha ghle{, Kt n}thlk}bed ge th }ee ybnt }nmpkakme} tbevnpelt} yhujd gnce kl hpdep th peldep tbekp mbkjdpel n}
lenpj{ u}eje}} n} vh}}k`je3 nld kt yn} bnpd th }n{ ybetbep
tbe hjd }uaaeped gh}t aphg tbe ervel}e ybkmb tbe{ yepe
tbu} vut th* hp tbe {huli aphg `ekli dejk`epntej{ }ykldjed
kl }hge ha tbe gh}t kgvhptnlt `pnlmbe} ha bugnl kl~ukp{*
nld dkpemted klth anj}e mbnllej} hp jeat th dpkat kl tbe ipentgnohpkt{ ha mn}e},
K mnllht tbklc K ng gk}tncel kl `ejkeqkli tbnt tbe
iphykli teldelm{ th jkgkt angkjke} `{ klanltkmkde—nl eqkj
ybkmb yn} mnu}kli ielepnj njnpg tbphuibhut tbe
mhultp{—yn} njgh}t eltkpej{ due th tbe yn{ kl ybkmb
edumntkhl bnd `emhge n aetk}b aphg hle eld ha Epeybhlth tbe htbep, Ipnlted tbnt vphqk}khl }bhujd `e gnde
ybepe`{ eqep{ mbkjd }bhujd `e tnuibt pendkli* ypktkli*
nld npktbgetkm* `ut bepe mhgvuj}hp{ }tnte'nkded edumntkhl
}bhujd eld* nld tbe mbkjd }bhujd `eikl yktb njj due
vpemnutkhl} th el}upe tbnt be k} lht hqepyhpced+ th
nm~ukpe tbe pudkgelt} ha tbnt npt ybepe`{ be k} th enpl bk}
jkqkli,
Be mnllht nm~ukpe tbe}e kl ybnt ye kl Elijnld mnjj
}mbhhj} ha temblkmnj edumntkhl3 }umb }mbhhj} npe mjhk}tep jkae
n} ninkl}t tbe phuib nld tug`je ha tbe yhpjd3 tbe{ ulakt*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 245/378
Epeybhl
045 ha =9;
pntbep tbnl akt ahp yhpc kl tbe hvel, Nl npt mnl hlj{ `e
jenpled kl tbe yhpc}bhv ha tbh}e ybh npe ykllkli tbekp `pend `{ kt,
@h{}* n} n puje* bnte tbe nptkakmknj* nld dejkibt kl tbe
nmtunj3 ikqe tbeg tbe mbnlme ha enplkli* nld tbe{ ykjj
}hhl enpl, Ybel vnpelt} akld tbnt tbekp mbkjdpel* kl}tend
ha `ekli gnde nptkakmknjj{ `updel}hge* ykjj enpj{ `eikl th
mhltpk`ute th tbe yejj'`ekli ha tbe angkj{* tbe{ ykjj }hhljenqe haa ckjjkli tbeg* nld ykjj }eec th bnqe tbnt vjelktude
ha haa}vpkli ybkmb tbe{ lhy nqhkd, N} tbkli} npe* tbe }tnte
jn{} ipentep `updel} hl vnpelt} tbnl aje}b nld `jhhd mnl
`enp* nld tbel ypkli} kt} bnld} hqep nl eqkj ahp ybkmb kt k}
kt}eja gnklj{ pe}vhl}k`je,
Yktb tbe je}} yejj'dpe}}ed mjn}}e} tbe bnpg yn} lht }hipent3 ahp nghli tbe}e* nt n`hut tel {enp} hjd* tbe mbkjd bn}
th `eikl dhkli }hgetbkli? ka be k} mnvn`je be gnce} bk}
yn{ uv3 ka be k} lht* be k} nt nl{ pnte lht gnde ghpe
klmnvn`je `{ ybnt bk} apkeld} npe vjen}ed th mnjj bk}
edumntkhl, Vehvje akld tbekp jeqej n} n puje3 nld tbhuib
tbe{ ulahptulntej{ }hgetkge} gk}} kt* kt k} kl tbe gnkl tpue
tbnt tbh}e ybh bnqe qnjun`je ~unjktke} npe vepmekqed th
bnqe tbeg nld mnl }ejj tbeg, K tbklc tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl}
npe `eikllkli th `emhge nynpe ha tbe}e tbkli}* ahp tbepe
yn} gumb tnjc n`hut vuttkli n tnr uvhl njj vnpelt} ybh}e
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 246/378
Epeybhl
041 ha =9;
mbkjdpel yepe lht enplkli n mhgvetelme nmmhpdkli th tbekp
deipee} `{ tbe tkge tbe{ yepe tyelt{ {enp} hjd, K ng }upetbnt ka tbe{ ykjj bnqe tbe mhupnie th mnpp{ kt tbphuib tbe{
ykjj leqep peipet kt3 ahp tbe vnpelt} ykjj tnce mnpe tbnt tbe
mbkjdpel }bnjj `eikl enplkli ghle{ ybkmb genl} ‒dhkli
ihhd‛ th }hmket{+ nt nl enpj{ nie3 tbel tbe mbkjdpel ykjj `e
kldeveldelt enpj{* nld tbe{ ykjj lht vpe}} hl tbe vnpelt}*
lhp tbe vnpelt} hl tbeg* nld tbe{ ykjj jkce enmb htbep `ettep tbnl tbe{ dh lhy,
Tbk} k} tbe tpue vbkjnltbphv{, Be ybh gnce} n mhjh}}nj
ahptule kl tbe bh}kep{ tpnde* nld `{ bk} elepi{ bn}
}ummeeded kl pedumkli tbe vpkme ha yhhjjel ihhd} `{ tbe
tbhu}nldtb vnpt ha n vell{ kl tbe vhuld—tbk} gnl k}
yhptb tel vphae}}khlnj vbkjnltbphvk}t}, ]h }tphlij{ npe tbeEpeybhlknl} kgvpe}}ed yktb tbk}* tbnt ka n gnl bn} gnde n
ahptule ha hqep 06*666 vhuld} n {enp tbe{ eregvt bkg
aphg njj tnrntkhl* mhl}kdepkli bkg n} n yhpc ha npt* nld
thh vpemkhu} th `e geddjed yktb3 tbe{ }n{* ‒Bhy qep{
gumb be gu}t bnqe dhle ahp }hmket{ `eahpe }hmket{ mhujd
bnqe `eel vpeqnkjed uvhl th ikqe bkg }h gumb ghle{3‛ }h
gnilkakmelt nl hpinlk}ntkhl hqepnye} tbeg3 tbe{ peinpd kt
n} n tbkli dphvved aphg benqel,
‒Ghle{*‛ tbe{ }n{* ‒k} tbe }{g`hj ha dut{* kt k} tbe
}nmpngelt ha bnqkli dhle ahp gnlckld tbnt ybkmb
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 247/378
Epeybhl
049 ha =9;
gnlckld ynlted, Gnlckld gn{ lht `e n qep{ ihhd oudie*
`ut tbepe k} lh `ettep,‛ Tbk} u}ed th }bhmc ge nt akp}t*ybel K pegeg`eped tbnt kt bnd `eel }nkd hl bkib
nutbhpkt{ tbnt tbe{ ybh bnqe pkmbe} }bnjj eltep bnpdj{ klth
tbe cklidhg ha benqel3 `ut tbe klajuelme ha Epeybhl bnd
gnde ge `eikl th }ee tbkli} kl n ley jkibt* nld K mhujd
lht bejv tbklckli tbnt tbe{ ybh bnqe lht pkmbe} }bnjj eltep
ghpe bnpdj{ }tkjj,Vehvje hvvh}e ghle{ th mujtupe* nld kgvj{ tbnt ka n
gnl bn} }velt bk} tkge kl gnckli ghle{ be ykjj lht `e
mujtkqnted—anjjnm{ ha anjjnmke}. N} tbhuib tbepe mhujd `e n
ipentep nkd th mujtupe tbnl tbe bnqkli enpled nl
bhlhupn`je kldeveldelme* nld n} tbhuib nl{ nghult ha
mujtupe ykjj dh gumb ahp tbe gnl ybh k} vellkje}}* ermevtgnce bkg aeej bk} vh}ktkhl ghpe deevj{, Tbe {huli gnl
ybh yn} thjd th }ejj njj bk} ihhd} nld ikqe th tbe vhhp*
gu}t bnqe `eel nl eltkpej{ ermevtkhlnj vep}hl ka tbe
ndqkme yn} ikqel yk}ej{* ektbep ahp bkg hp ahp tbe vhhp3
bhy gumb ghpe hatel dhe} kt bnvvel tbnt ye vepmekqe n
gnl th bnqe njj }hpt} ha ihhd ~unjktke} ermevt ghle{* nld
aeej tbnt bk} penj dut{ jke} kl iettkli eqep{ bnja'vell{ tbnt
be mnl vep}unde htbep} th vn{ bkg ahp bk} }epqkme}* nld
`emhgkli pkmb, Kt bn} `eel }nkd tbnt tbe jhqe ha ghle{ k}
tbe phht ha njj eqkj, Tbe ynlt ha ghle{ k} }h ~ukte n} tpuj{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 248/378
Epeybhl
042 ha =9;
Tbe n`hqe gn{ }huld kppeqepelt* `ut kt k} mhlmekqed kl
n }vkpkt ha tbe gh}t uttep peqepelme ahp tbh}e tbkli} ybkmbdh njhle de}epqe kt—tbnt k}* ahp tbe tbkli} ybkmb npe*
ybkmb ghujd u} nld an}bkhl u}* `e tbe{ ybnt tbe{ gn{3
ahp tbe tbkli} tbnt bnqe vhyep th vulk}b u}* nld ybkmb
ykjj vulk}b u} ka ye dh lht beed tbeg3 ahp hup gn}tep}
tbepeahpe, @ut K ng dpkatkli nyn{ aphg g{ }thp{,
Tbe{ bnqe nlhtbep vjnl n`hut ybkmb tbe{ npe gnckli nipent lhk}e nld au}}* gumb n} }hge npe dhkli yktb
yhgel‛} pkibt} kl Elijnld, N vnpt{ ha ertpege pndkmnj}
bnqe vphae}}ed tbeg}ejqe} uln`je th demkde uvhl tbe
}uvepkhpkt{ ha nie hp {hutb, Nt vpe}elt njj ihe} hl tbe
}uvvh}ktkhl tbnt kt k} de}kpn`je th gnce tbe {huli hjd n}
}hhl n} vh}}k`je, ]hge yhujd bnqe kt tbnt tbk} k} yphli*nld tbnt tbe h`oemt ha edumntkhl }bhujd `e th ceev tbe hjd
{huli n} jhli n} vh}}k`je, Tbe{ }n{ tbnt enmb nie }bhujd
tnce kt tupl kl tupl n`hut* yeec `{ yeec* hle yeec tbe
hjd th `e thv}ny{ep}* nld tbe htbep tbe {huli* dpnykli
tbe jkle nt tbkpt{'akqe {enp} ha nie3 `ut tbe{ kl}k}t tbnt tbe
{huli }bhujd `e njjhyed th klajkmt mhpvhpnj mbn}tk}egelt
hl tbe hjd* yktbhut ybkmb tbe hjd yhujd `e ~ukte
klmhppkik`je, Kl nl{ Euphvenl mhultp{ tbk} yhujd `e hut
ha tbe ~ue}tkhl3 `ut kt k} lht }h tbepe* ahp tbe }tpnkibtelep}
npe mhl}tnltj{ hpdepkli vehvje th `e ajhiied* }h tbnt tbe{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 249/378
Epeybhl
04; ha =9;
npe angkjknp yktb tbe lhtkhl, K dh lht }uvvh}e tbnt tbe kden
ykjj `e eqep nmted uvhl3 `ut kt} bnqkli `eel eqel ghhtedk} elhuib th }bhy tbe uttep vepqep}khl ha tbe Epeybhlknl
gkld,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 250/378
Epeybhl
056 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRK? TBE MHJJEIE] HAULPEN]HL
K bnd lhy `eel n qk}kthp yktb tbe Lh}lk`hp} ahp }hge
akqe hp }kr ghltb}* nld tbhuib K bnd ape~ueltj{ vphvh}ed
th jenqe tbeg nld tnce nvnptgelt} ha g{ hyl* tbe{ yhujd
lht benp ha g{ dhkli }h, K }uvvh}e tbe{ tbhuibt K }bhujd
`e ghpe jkcej{ th anjj kl jhqe yktb _ujhpn ka K pegnkled*
`ut kt yn} g{ naaemtkhl ahp Nphybeln tbnt cevt ge,
Dupkli njj tbk} tkge `htb Nphybeln nld g{}eja bnd
`eel dpengkli* nld dpkatkli thynpd} nl nqhyed
nttnmbgelt* `ut bnd lht dnped th anme tbe penj dkaakmujtke}
ha tbe vh}ktkhl, Ipndunjj{* bhyeqep* gnttep} mnge th n
mpk}k} kl }vkte ha hup}ejqe}* nld ye iht th }ee tbe tpue }tnte
ha tbe mn}e* njj thh mjenpj{,
Hle eqelkli ye yepe }kttkli kl tbe inpdel* nld K bnd
`eel tp{kli kl eqep{ }tuvkd phuldn`hut yn{ th iet bep th
}n{ tbnt }be }bhujd `e nt nl{ pnte }hpp{ ahp n gnl* ka be
penjj{ jhqed n yhgnl ybh yhujd lht gnpp{ bkg, K bnd
`eel }tnggepkli nld `ju}bkli* nld `eel n} }kjj{ n} nl{ hlemhujd `e* nld K }uvvh}e bnd vnkled bep `{ ak}bkli ahp vkt{
ahp g{}eja kl }umb n tpnl}vnpelt yn{* nld }n{kli lhtbkli
n`hut bep hyl leed ha kt3 nt nl{ pnte* }be tupled njj uvhl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 251/378
Epeybhl
05> ha =9;
ge yktb n }yeet }nd }gkje nld }nkd* ‒]hpp{8 K ng }hpp{ ahp
g{}eja3 K ng }hpp{ ahp {hu3 nld K ng }hpp{ ahp eqep{ hle,‛Tbe yhpd} bnd lh }hhlep mph}}ed bep jkv} tbnl }be `hyed
bep bend* inqe ge n jhhc n} tbhuib K yepe th gnce lh
nl}yep* nld jeat ge,
Tbe yhpd} yepe aey nld }kgvje* `ut tbe gnllep yktb
ybkmb tbe{ yepe utteped yn} kleaan`je? tbe }mnje} aejj aphg
g{ e{e}* nld K aejt tbnt K bnd lh pkibt th tp{ nld kldumebep th klapklie hle ha tbe gh}t klqkhjn`je mu}thg} ha bep
mhultp{* n} }be leed} gu}t dh ka }be yepe th gnpp{ ge, K
}nt ahp n jhli ybkje tbklckli* nld ybel K pegeg`eped tbe
}kl nld }bnge nld gk}ep{ ybkmb nl ulpkibtehu}
gnppknie—ahp n} }umb kt yhujd `e bejd kl Epeybhl—
yhujd eltnkj* K `emnge tbhphuibj{ n}bnged ha g{}eja ahp bnqkli `eel }h jhli }eja' `jklded, K ypkte mhjdj{ lhy* `ut
K }uaaeped ceelj{ nt tbe tkge* nld }bhujd vph`n`j{ petnkl n
gumb ghpe qkqkd pemhjjemtkhl ha ybnt K aejt* bnd lht njj
elded }h bnvvkj{,
N} ahp ikqkli uv tbe kden ha gnpp{kli Nphybeln* kt
leqep }h gumb n} elteped g{ bend th dh }h? tbe }hjutkhl
gu}t `e ahuld kl }hge htbep dkpemtkhl tbnl tbk}, Tbe kden
ha ynktkli tkjj }hge`hd{ gnppked _ujhpn yn} th `e lh je}}
}uggnpkj{ dk}gk}}ed, Th gnpp{ Nphybeln nt hlme kl
Epeybhl—tbk} bnd njpend{ `eel n`nldhled? tbepe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 252/378
Epeybhl
050 ha =9;
pegnkled tbepeahpe `ut hle njteplntkqe* nld tbnt yn} th
pul nyn{ yktb bep* nld iet bep yktb ge th Euphve* ybepetbepe yhujd `e lh `np th hup ulkhl }nqe g{ hyl
kgvemulkh}kt{* n gnttep ybkmb inqe ge lh ulen}kle}},
Th tbk} h`qkhu} nld }kgvje vjnl K mhujd }ee `ut tyh
h`oemtkhl} tbnt de}epqed tbe lnge*—tbe akp}t* tbnt vepbnv}
Nphybeln yhujd lht mhge3 tbe }emhld* tbnt kt yn} njgh}t
kgvh}}k`je ahp ge th e}mnve eqel njhle* ahp tbe ckli bndbkg}eja thjd ge tbnt K yn} th mhl}kdep g{}eja n vpk}hlep hl
vnphje* nld tbnt tbe akp}t }kil ha g{ eldenqhupkli th
e}mnve yhujd mnu}e ge th `e }elt th hle ha tbe bh}vktnj}
ahp klmupn`je}, @e}kde}* K dkd lht clhy tbe iehipnvb{ ha
tbe mhultp{* nld eqel yepe K th tp{ nld akld g{ yn{ `nmc*
K }bhujd `e dk}mhqeped jhli `eahpe K bnd penmbed tbe vn}}hqep ybkmb K bnd mhge, Bhy tbel mhujd K bhve th `e
n`je th tnce Nphybeln yktb ge8 Ahp dn{} nld dn{} K
tupled tbe}e dkaakmujtke} hqep kl g{ gkld* nld nt jn}t bkt
uvhl n} ykjd n vjnl n} yn} eqep }uiie}ted `{ ertpegkt{,
Tbk} yn} th geet tbe }emhld dkaakmujt{? tbe akp}t inqe ge
je}} ulen}kle}}* ahp ybel Nphybeln nld K lert get natep
hup kltepqkey kl tbe inpdel K mhujd }ee tbnt }be bnd
}uaaeped lht je}} nmutej{ tbnl g{}eja,
K pe}hjqed tbnt K yhujd bnqe nlhtbep kltepqkey yktb
bep—tbe jn}t ahp tbe vpe}elt—tbnt K yhujd tbel jenqe bep*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 253/378
Epeybhl
05= ha =9;
nld }et th yhpc uvhl gntupkli g{ vjnl n} an}t n} vh}}k`je,
Ye iht n mbnlme ha `ekli njhle thietbep* nld tbel K inqeg{}eja tbe jhh}e pekl* nld thjd bep bhy vn}}khlntej{ nld
deqhtedj{ K jhqed bep, ]be }nkd jkttje kl petupl* `ut bep
tenp} ybkmb K mhujd lht peapnkl aphg nl}yepkli yktb g{
hyl+ nld tbe jkttje }be dkd }n{ yepe ~ukte elhuib th }bhy
ge tbnt K }bhujd geet yktb lh h`}tnmje aphg bep, Tbel K
n}ced bep ybetbep }be yhujd pul n teppk`je pk}c ybkmb ye}bhujd }bnpe kl mhgghl* ka* kl mn}e ha }umme}}* K mhujd tnce
bep th g{ hyl vehvje* th tbe bhge ha g{ ghtbep nld
}k}tep}* ybh yhujd yejmhge bep qep{ ijndj{, Nt tbe }nge
tkge K vhklted hut tbnt tbe mbnlme} ha ankjupe yepe anp
ipentep tbnl tbh}e ha }umme}}* nld tbnt tbe vph`n`kjkt{ yn}
tbnt eqel tbhuib K mhujd iet }h anp n} th mnpp{ g{ de}kilklth eremutkhl* kt yhujd eld kl dentb th u} `htb,
K yn} lht gk}tncel kl bep3 }be }nkd tbnt }be `ejkeqed K
jhqed bep n} gumb n} }be jhqed ge* nld tbnt }be yhujd
`pnqe nl{tbkli ka K mhujd hlj{ n}}upe bep tbnt ybnt K
vphvh}ed yhujd lht `e tbhuibt dk}bhlhupn`je kl Elijnld3
}be mhujd lht jkqe yktbhut ge* nld yhujd pntbep dke yktb
ge tbnl njhle3 tbnt dentb yn} vepbnv} tbe `e}t ahp u} `htb3
tbnt K gu}t vjnl* nld tbnt ybel tbe bhup mnge K yn} th
}eld ahp bep* nld tpu}t bep lht th ankj ge3 nld }h natep
gnl{ tenp} nld eg`pnme}* ye thpe hup}ejqe} nyn{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 254/378
Epeybhl
054 ha =9;
K tbel jeat tbe Lh}lk`hp}* thhc n jhdikli kl tbe thyl*
nld `emnge gejnlmbhj{ th g{ benpt‛} mhltelt, Nphybelnnld K u}ed th }ee enmb htbep }hgetkge}* ahp K bnd tncel th
ihkli peiujnpj{ th tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}* `ut Gp}, Lh}lk`hp
nld _ujhpn `htb tpented ge yktb mhl}kdepn`je mhjdle}}, K
aejt }upe tbnt tbe{ }u}vemted ge, Nphybeln jhhced
gk}epn`je* nld K }ny tbnt bep vup}e yn} lhy njyn{} n} aujj
n} }be mhujd akjj kt yktb tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc ghle{—gumbaujjep tbnl ha hjd, Tbel tbe bhppk`je tbhuibt hmmupped th
ge tbnt bep benjtb gkibt `penc dhyl* nld tbnt }be gkibt
`e }u`oemted th n mpkgklnj vph}emutkhl, Hb. bhy K bnted
Epeybhl nt tbnt tkge,
K yn} }tkjj pemekqed nt mhupt* `ut g{ ihhd jhhc} yepe
`eikllkli th ankj ge* nld K yn} lht }umb nl ndevt ntmhlmenjkli tbe eaaemt} ha vnkl n} tbe Epeybhlknl} npe, K
mhujd }ee tbnt g{ apkeld} `einl th jhhc mhlmepled n`hut
ge* nld yn} h`jkied th tnce n jena hut ha Gnbnkln‛} `hhc*
nld vpeteld th bnqe deqejhved n tn}te ahp dpklckli, K eqel
mhl}ujted n }tpnkibtelep n} tbhuib tbk} yepe }h* nld
}u`gktted th gumb dk}mhgahpt, Tbk} gnde gnttep} `ettep
ahp n tkge* `ut K mhujd }ee tbnt g{ apkeld} tbhuibt je}}
bkibj{ ha g{ mhl}tktutkhl n} g{ aje}b `einl th anjj nyn{,
K yn} thjd tbnt tbe vhhp gnde nl hutmp{ n`hut g{
vel}khl* nld K }ny n }tklikli nptkmje kl nl nltk'gklk}tepknj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 255/378
Epeybhl
055 ha =9;
vnvep* kl ybkmb tbe ypktep yelt }h anp n} th }n{ tbnt g{
bnqkli jkibt bnkp peajemted jkttje mpedkt uvhl ge* kln}gumbn} K bnd `eel pevhpted th bnqe }nkd tbnt kt yn} n mhgghl
tbkli kl tbe mhultp{ aphg ybkmb K mnge, K bnqe pen}hl th
`ejkeqe tbnt Gp, Lh}lk`hp bkg}eja kl}vkped tbk} nptkmje,
Vpe}eltj{ kt mnge phuld th ge tbnt tbe ckli bnd `eiul th
dyejj uvhl g{ bnqkli `eel vh}}e}}ed ha n yntmb* nld th
}n{ tbnt K huibt th `e tpented gedkmklnjj{ ahp bnqkli thjdbkg n jke n`hut tbe `njjhhl}, K }ny gk}ahptule intbepkli
phuld ge kl eqep{ dkpemtkhl* nld aejt tbnt K }bhujd bnqe
leed ha njj g{ ykt} nld n ihhd gnl{ ghpe* ka K yn} th
}teep g{}eja nld Nphybeln th n ihhd mhlmju}khl,
Tbepe yepe }hge ybh mhltklued th }bhy ge ckldle}}*
nld }tpnlie th }n{* K pemekqed tbe gh}t aphg tbe qep{vep}hl} aphg ybhg K }bhujd bnqe jen}t ervemted kt—K
genl aphg tbe mn}bkep} ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}, K bnd gnde
tbe nm~unkltnlme ha }eqepnj ha tbe}e vep}hl}* nld lhy tbnt
K ape~uelted tbekp `nlc* tbe{ yepe klmjkled th gnce n
ihhd denj ha ge, Hle ha tbeg* }eekli tbnt K yn}
tbhphuibj{ hut ha benjtb* tbhuib ha mhup}e be vpetelded
lht th lhtkme kt* }uiie}ted tbnt K }bhujd tnce n jkttje mbnlie
ha nkp nld ih dhyl yktb bkg th hle ha tbe vpklmkvnj
thyl}* ybkmb yn} }hge tyh hp tbpee dn{}‛ ohuple{ aphg
tbe getphvhjk}* nld tbe mbkea }ent ha tbe Mhjjeie} ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 256/378
Epeybhl
051 ha =9;
Ulpen}hl3 be n}}uped ge tbnt K }bhujd `e dejkibted yktb
ybnt K }ny* nld tbnt K }bhujd pemekqe n gh}t bh}vktn`jeyejmhge, K detepgkled tbepeahpe th nmmevt tbe klqktntkhl,
Ye }tnpted tyh hp tbpee dn{} jntep* nld natep n lkibt hl
tbe phnd* ye nppkqed nt hup de}tklntkhl thynpd} eqelkli, Kt
yn} lhy aujj }vpkli* nld n} lenpj{ n} gkibt `e tel ghltb}
}klme K bnd }tnpted yktb Mbhy`hc hl g{ ervedktkhl* `ut
kt }eeged ghpe jkce tel {enp}, Tbe tpee} yepe kl tbekp ape}be}t `enut{* nld tbe nkp bnd `emhge ynpg yktbhut
`ekli hvvpe}}kqej{ bht, Natep bnqkli jkqed }h gnl{ ghltb}
kl tbe getphvhjk}* tbe }kibt ha tbe mhultp{* nld tbe
mhultp{ qkjjnie} tbphuib ybkmb ye vn}}ed peape}bed ge
ipentj{* `ut K mhujd lht ahpiet g{ tphu`je}, Tbe jn}t akqe
gkje} hp }h yepe tbe gh}t `enutkauj vnpt ha tbe ohuple{* ahp tbe mhultp{ `emnge ghpe uldujntkli* nld tbe yhhd} yepe
ghpe ertel}kqe3 `ut tbe akp}t }kibt ha tbe mkt{ ha tbe
mhjjeie} kt}eja yn} tbe gh}t dejkibtauj ha njj, K mnllht
kgnikle tbnt tbepe mnl `e nl{ ankpep kl tbe ybhje yhpjd*
nld K ervpe}}ed g{ vjen}upe th g{ mhgvnlkhl* nld
tbnlced bkg ahp bnqkli `phuibt ge,
Ye dphqe th nl kll kl tbe gkddje ha tbe thyl* nld
tbel* ybkje kt yn} }tkjj jkibt* g{ apkeld tbe mn}bkep* ybh}e
lnge yn} Tbkg}* thhc ge ahp n }tphjj kl tbe }tpeet} nld kl
tbe mhupt'{npd} ha tbe vpklmkvnj mhjjeie}, Tbekp `enut{ nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 257/378
Epeybhl
059 ha =9;
kltepe}t yepe ertpege3 kt yn} kgvh}}k`je th }ee tbeg
yktbhut `ekli nttpnmted thynpd} tbeg3 nld K tbhuibt thg{}eja tbnt be gu}t `e kldeed nl kjj'ipnkled nld ulipnteauj
vep}hl ybh mnl bnqe `eel n geg`ep ha hle ha tbe}e
mhjjeie} yktbhut petnklkli nl naaemtkhlnte aeejkli thynpd} kt
ahp tbe pe}t ha bk} jkae, Njj g{ gk}ikqkli} inqe yn{ nt hlme
ybel K }ny tbe `enut{ nld qelepn`je nvvenpnlme ha tbk}
dejkibtauj mkt{, Ahp bnja'nl'bhup K ahpiht `htb g{}eja nldNphybeln,
Natep }uvvep Gp, Tbkg} thjd ge n ihhd denj n`hut tbe
}{}teg ha edumntkhl ybkmb k} bepe vpnmtk}ed, K njpend{
cley n vnpt ha ybnt K benpd* `ut gumb yn} ley th ge*
nld K h`tnkled n `ettep kden ha tbe Epeybhlknl vh}ktkhl
tbnl K bnd dhle bktbepth? leqeptbeje}} tbepe yepe vnpt} ha tbe }mbege ha ybkmb K mhujd lht mhgvpebeld tbe aktle}}*
njtbhuib K aujj{ ndgkt tbnt tbk} kln`kjkt{ yn} vph`n`j{ tbe
pe}ujt ha g{ bnqkli `eel tpnkled }h qep{ dkaaepeltj{* nld th
g{ `ekli tbel gumb hut ha }hpt},
Tbe gnkl aentupe kl tbekp }{}teg k} tbe vphgklelme
ybkmb tbe{ ikqe th n }tud{ ybkmb K mnl hlj{ tpnl}jnte `{
tbe yhpd ‒b{vhtbetkm},‛ Tbe{ npiue tbu}—tbnt th tenmb n
`h{ gepej{ tbe lntupe ha tbe tbkli} ybkmb erk}t kl tbe
yhpjd nphuld bkg* nld n`hut ybkmb be ykjj bnqe th `e
mhlqep}nlt dupkli bk} ybhje jkae* yhujd `e ikqkli bkg `ut
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 258/378
Epeybhl
052 ha =9;
n lnpphy nld }bnjjhy mhlmevtkhl ha tbe ulkqep}e* ybkmb kt
k} upied gkibt mhltnkl njj gnllep ha tbkli} ybkmb npe lhtlhy th `e ahuld tbepekl, Th hvel bk} e{e} th tbe}e
vh}}k`kjktke}* nld }h th vpevnpe bkg ahp njj }hpt} ha
egepielmke}* k} tbe h`oemt ha tbk} }{}teg ha b{vhtbetkm},
Th kgnikle n }et ha uttepj{ }tpnlie nld kgvh}}k`je
mhltklielmke}* nld pe~ukpe tbe {hutb} th ikqe kltejjkielt
nl}yep} th tbe ~ue}tkhl} tbnt npk}e tbepeaphg* k} pemchledtbe aktte}t mhlmekqn`je yn{ ha vpevnpkli tbeg ahp tbe nmtunj
mhldumt ha tbekp naankp} kl natep jkae,
Tbu} tbe{ npe tnuibt ybnt k} mnjjed tbe b{vhtbetkmnj
jnliunie ahp gnl{ ha tbekp `e}t {enp}—n jnliunie ybkmb
yn} hpkiklnjj{ mhgvh}ed nt n tkge ybel tbe mhultp{ yn}
kl n qep{ dkaaepelt }tnte ha mkqkjk}ntkhl th ybnt kt k} ntvpe}elt* n }tnte ybkmb bn} jhli }klme dk}nvvenped nld `eel
}uvep}eded, Gnl{ qnjun`je gnrkg} nld lh`je tbhuibt}
ybkmb yepe nt hle tkge mhlmenjed kl kt bnqe `emhge
muppelt kl tbekp ghdepl jktepntupe* nld bnqe `eel
tpnl}jnted hqep nld hqep ninkl klth tbe jnliunie lhy
}vhcel, ]upej{ tbel kt yhujd }eeg elhuib tbnt tbe }tud{
ha tbe hpkiklnj jnliunie }bhujd `e mhlakled th tbe aey
ybh}e kl}tklmt} jed tbeg lntupnjj{ th vup}ue kt,
@ut tbe Epeybhlknl} tbklc dkaaepeltj{3 tbe }thpe tbe{
}et `{ tbk} b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie mnl bnpdj{ `e `ejkeqed3
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 259/378
Epeybhl
05; ha =9;
tbe{ ykjj eqel ikqe nl{ hle n gnkltelnlme ahp jkae ka be
nttnkl} n mhl}kdepn`je vphakmkelm{ kl tbe }tud{ ha kt3 ln{*tbe{ ykjj }veld {enp} kl jenplkli th tpnl}jnte }hge ha tbekp
hyl ihhd vhetp{ klth tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie—th dh }h
yktb ajuelm{ `ekli pemchled n dk}tkliuk}bkli gnpc ha n
}mbhjnp nld n ieltjegnl, Benqel ahp`kd tbnt K }bhujd `e
ajkvvnlt* `ut kt nvvenped th ge th `e n ynlthl yn}te ha
ihhd bugnl elepi{ tbnt gel }bhujd }veld {enp} nld {enp}kl tbe vepaemtkhl ha }h `nppel nl erepmk}e* ybel tbekp hyl
mkqkjk}ntkhl vpe}elted vph`jeg} `{ tbe buldped ybkmb
mpked njhud ahp }hjutkhl nld yhujd bnqe vnkd tbe }hjqep
bnld}hgej{3 `ut vehvje clhy tbekp hyl naankp} `e}t, Ka tbe
{hutb} mbh}e kt ahp tbeg}ejqe} K }bhujd bnqe yhldeped
je}}3 `ut tbe{ dh lht mbhh}e kt3 tbe{ bnqe kt tbpu}t uvhltbeg* nld ahp tbe gh}t vnpt npe dk}klmjkled thynpd} kt, K
mnl hlj{ }n{ tbnt njj K benpd kl deaelme ha tbe }{}teg yn}
kl}uaakmkelt th gnce ge tbklc qep{ bkibj{ ha kt}
ndqnltnie},
Tbe npiugelt} kl anqhup ha tbe dejk`epnte deqejhvgelt
ha tbe ulpen}hlkli anmujtke} yepe gumb ghpe mhielt, @ut
bepe tbe{ devnpt aphg tbe vpklmkvje} hl ybkmb tbe{ ou}tka{
tbekp }tud{ ha b{vhtbetkm}3 ahp tbe{ `n}e tbe kgvhptnlme
ybkmb tbe{ n}}kil th b{vhtbetkm} uvhl tbe anmt ha tbekp
`ekli n vpevnpntkhl ahp tbe ertpnhpdklnp{* ybkje tbekp }tud{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 260/378
Epeybhl
016 ha =9;
ha Ulpen}hl pe}t} uvhl kt} deqejhvkli tbh}e anmujtke}
ybkmb npe pe~ukped ahp tbe dnkj{ mhldumt ha naankp}, Belmetbekp vphae}}hp}bkv} ha Klmhl}k}telm{ nld Eqn}khl* kl `htb
ha ybkmb }tudke} tbe {hutb} npe erngkled `eahpe `ekli
njjhyed th vphmeed th tbekp deipee kl b{vhtbetkm}, Tbe
ghpe enple}t nld mhl}mkeltkhu} }tudelt} nttnkl th n
vphakmkelm{ kl tbe}e }u`oemt} ybkmb k} ~ukte }upvpk}kli3
tbepe k} bnpdj{ nl{ klmhl}k}telm{ }h ijnpkli `ut tbe{ }hhljenpl th deaeld kt* hp kloulmtkhl }h mjenp tbnt tbe{ mnllht
akld }hge vpetert ahp dk}peinpdkli kt,
Jkae* tbe{ upie* yhujd `e klthjepn`je ka gel yepe th `e
iukded kl njj tbe{ dkd `{ pen}hl nld pen}hl hlj{, Pen}hl
`etpn{} gel klth tbe dpnykli ha bnpd nld an}t jkle}* nld th
tbe deaklkli `{ jnliunie—jnliunie `ekli jkce tbe }ul*ybkmb penp} nld tbel }mhpmbe}, Ertpege} npe njhle jhikmnj*
`ut tbe{ npe njyn{} n`}upd3 tbe genl k} kjjhikmnj* `ut nl
kjjhikmnj genl k} `ettep tbnl tbe }beep n`}updkt{ ha nl
ertpege, Tbepe npe lh ahjjke} nld lh ulpen}hln`jele}}e} }h
ipent n} tbh}e ybkmb mnl nvvnpeltj{ `e kppeapnin`j{
deaelded `{ pen}hl kt}eja* nld tbepe k} bnpdj{ nl epphp klth
ybkmb gel gn{ lht en}kj{ `e jed ka tbe{ `n}e tbekp
mhldumt uvhl pen}hl hlj{,
Pen}hl gkibt qep{ vh}}k`j{ n`hjk}b tbe dhu`je
muppelm{3 kt gkibt eqel nttnmc tbe vep}hlnjkt{ ha Bhve nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 261/378
Epeybhl
01> ha =9;
Ou}tkme, @e}kde}* vehvje bnqe }umb n }tphli lntupnj `kn}
thynpd} kt tbnt tbe{ ykjj }eec kt ahp tbeg}ejqe} nld nmtuvhl kt ~ukte n} gumb n} hp ghpe tbnl k} ihhd ahp tbeg?
tbepe k} lh leed ha elmhupnikli pen}hl, Yktb ulpen}hl tbe
mn}e k} dkaaepelt, ]be k} tbe lntupnj mhgvjegelt ha pen}hl*
yktbhut ybh}e erk}telme pen}hl kt}eja yepe lhl'erk}telt,
Ka* tbel* pen}hl yhujd `e lhl'erk}telt yepe tbepe lh
}umb tbkli n} ulpen}hl* }upej{ kt ahjjhy} tbnt tbe ghpeulpen}hl tbepe k}* tbe ghpe pen}hl tbepe gu}t `e nj}h8
Belme tbe leme}}kt{ ahp tbe deqejhvgelt ha ulpen}hl*
eqel kl tbe kltepe}t} ha pen}hl bep}eja, Tbe Vphae}}hp} ha
Ulpen}hl del{ tbnt tbe{ uldepqnjue pen}hl? lhle mnl `e
ghpe mhlqklmed tbnl tbe{ npe* tbnt ka tbe dhu`je muppelm{
mnllht `e pkihphu}j{ dedumed n} n leme}}np{ mhl}e~uelmeha bugnl pen}hl* tbe dhu`je muppelm{ }bhujd men}e
ahptbyktb3 `ut tbe{ }n{ tbnt kt gu}t `e dedumed aphg lh
lnpphy nld ermju}kqe qkey ha pen}hl ybkmb }bhujd devpkqe
tbnt ndgkpn`je anmujt{ ha tbe hle'bnja ha kt} hyl erk}telme,
Ulpen}hl k} n vnpt ha pen}hl3 kt gu}t tbepeahpe `e njjhyed
kt} aujj }bnpe kl }tntkli tbe klktknj mhldktkhl},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 262/378
Epeybhl
010 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRKK? TBE MHJJEIE] HAULPEN]HL—Mhltklued
Ha ielku} tbe{ gnce lh nmmhult* ahp tbe{ }n{ tbnt
eqep{ hle k} n ielku}* ghpe hp je}}, Lh hle k} }h vb{}kmnjj{
}huld tbnt lh vnpt ha bkg ykjj `e eqel n jkttje ul}huld*
nld lh hle k} }h dk}en}ed `ut tbnt }hge vnpt ha bkg ykjj `e
benjtb{—}h lh gnl k} }h geltnjj{ nld ghpnjj{ }huld* `ut
tbnt be ykjj `e kl vnpt `htb gnd nld ykmced3 nld lh gnl
k} }h gnd nld ykmced `ut be ykjj `e }el}k`je nld
bhlhupn`je kl vnpt, Kl jkce gnllep tbepe k} lh ielku} ybh
k} lht nj}h n ahhj* nld lh ahhj ybh k} lht nj}h n ielku},
Ybel K tnjced n`hut hpkiklnjkt{ nld ielku} th }hge
ieltjegel ybhg K get nt n }uvvep vnpt{ ikqel `{ Gp,
Tbkg} kl g{ bhlhup* nld }nkd tbnt hpkiklnj tbhuibt huibt
th `e elmhupnied* K bnd th ent g{ yhpd} nt hlme, Tbekp
qkey eqkdeltj{ yn} tbnt ielku} yn} jkce haaelme}— leed}
gu}t tbnt kt mhge* `ut yhe ulth tbnt gnl tbphuib ybhg
kt mhge}, N gnl‛} `u}kle}}* tbe{ bhjd* k} th tbklc n} bk}
lekib`hup} dh* ahp Benqel bejv bkg ka be tbklc} ihhdybnt tbe{ mhult `nd, Nld penjj{ kt k} bnpd th }ee bhy tbe
Epeybhlknl tbehp{ dkaaep} aphg hup hyl* ahp tbe yhpd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 263/378
Epeybhl
01= ha =9;
‒kdkht‛ hlj{ genl} n vep}hl ybh ahpg} bk} hvklkhl} ahp
bkg}eja,Tbe qelepn`je Vphae}}hp ha Yhpjdj{ Yk}dhg* n gnl
qepikli hl ekibt{ `ut }tkjj bnje* }vhce th ge qep{ }epkhu}j{
hl tbk} }u`oemt kl mhl}e~uelme ha tbe aey yhpd} tbnt K bnd
kgvpudeltj{ jet anjj kl deaelme ha ielku}, Be yn} hle ha
tbh}e ybh mnppked gh}t yekibt kl tbe ulkqep}kt{* nld bnd
tbe pevutntkhl ha bnqkli dhle ghpe vepbnv} tbnl nl{htbep jkqkli gnl th }uvvpe}} nl{ ckld ha hpkiklnjkt{,
‒Kt k} lht hup `u}kle}}*‛ be }nkd* ‒th bejv }tudelt} th
tbklc ahp tbeg}ejqe}, ]upej{ tbk} k} tbe qep{ jn}t tbkli
ybkmb hle ybh yk}be} tbeg yejj }bhujd elmhupnie tbeg
th dh, Hup dut{ k} th el}upe tbnt tbe{ }bnjj tbklc n} ye dh*
hp nt nl{ pnte* n} ye bhjd kt ervedkelt th }n{ ye dh,‛ Kl}hge pe}vemt}* bhyeqep* be yn} tbhuibt th bhjd
}hgeybnt pndkmnj hvklkhl}* ahp be yn} Vpe}kdelt ha tbe
]hmket{ ahp tbe ]uvvpe}}khl ha U}eje}} Clhyjedie* nld ahp
tbe Mhgvjetep H`jktepntkhl ha tbe Vn}t,
N} peinpd} tbe te}t} tbnt n {hutb gu}t vn}} `eahpe be mnl
iet n deipee* K ahuld tbnt tbe{ bnqe lh mjn}} jk}t}* nld
dk}mhupnie nl{tbkli jkce mhgvetktkhl nghli tbe }tudelt}3
tbk}* kldeed* tbe{ peinpd n} }eja'}eeckli nld
ullekib`hupj{, Tbe erngklntkhl} npe mhldumted `{ yn{
ha vnvep} ypkttel `{ tbe mnldkdnte hl }et }u`oemt}* }hge ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 264/378
Epeybhl
014 ha =9;
ybkmb npe clhyl th bkg `eahpebnld* ybkje htbep} npe
deqk}ed yktb n qkey ha te}tkli bk} ielepnj mnvnmkt{ nld}nqhkp ankpe,
G{ apkeld tbe Vphae}}hp ha Yhpjdj{ Yk}dhg yn} tbe
tepphp ha tbe ipentep lug`ep ha }tudelt}3 nld* }h anp n} K
mhujd oudie* be qep{ yejj gkibt `e* ahp be bnd tncel bk}
Vphae}}hp}bkv ghpe }epkhu}j{ tbnl nl{ ha tbe htbep
Vphae}}hp} bnd dhle, K benpd ha bk} bnqkli vjumced hlevhhp aejjhy ahp ynlt ha }uaakmkelt qniuele}} kl bk} }nqkli
mjnu}e} vnvep, Nlhtbep yn} }elt dhyl ahp bnqkli ypkttel
nl nptkmje hl n }mkeltkakm }u`oemt yktbhut bnqkli gnde apee
elhuib u}e ha tbe yhpd} ‒mnpeaujj{*‛ ‒vntkeltj{*‛ nld
‒enple}tj{,‛ Hle gnl yn} peau}ed n deipee ahp `ekli thh
hatel nld thh }epkhu}j{ kl tbe pkibt* ybkje n aey dn{}`eahpe K mnge n ybhje `ntmb bnd `eel vjumced ahp
kl}uaakmkelt dk}tpu}t ha vpklted gnttep,
N`hut tbk} tbepe yn} ou}t tbel pntbep n aepgelt* ahp kt
}eeg} tbnt tbe Vphae}}hp bnd ypkttel nl nptkmje kl tbe
jendkli ulkqep}kt{ gninzkle* ybkmb yn} yejj clhyl th `e
`{ bkg* nld ybkmb n`hulded kl njj }hpt} ha vjnu}k`je
`juldep}, Be tbel }et n vnvep ybkmb naahpded tbe
erngklee} nl hvvhptulkt{ ha peventkli tbe}e `juldep}—
ybkmb* `ejkeqkli tbe nptkmje th `e `{ tbekp hyl erngklep*
tbe{ ha mhup}e dkd, Tbe Vphae}}hp vjumced eqep{ }klije hle
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 265/378
Epeybhl
015 ha =9;
ha tbeg* `ut bk} nmtkhl yn} mhl}kdeped th bnqe `eel lht
~ukte bnld}hge,K thjd tbeg ha Bhgep‛} lh`je jkle th tbe eaaemt tbnt n
gnl }bhujd }tpkqe eqep th `e ahpegh}t nld kl njj tbkli} th
hutqke bk} veep}3 `ut tbe{ }nkd tbnt lh yhldep tbe
mhultpke} kl ybkmb }umb n dete}tn`je gnrkg yn} bejd kl
ndgkpntkhl yepe njyn{} aj{kli nt hle nlhtbep‛} tbphnt},
‒Yb{*‛ n}ced hle Vphae}}hp* ‒}bhujd n gnl ynlt th `e`ettep tbnl bk} lekib`hup}8 Jet bkg `e tbnlcauj ka be k} lh
yhp}e,‛
K qeltuped aee`j{ th }n{ tbnt K dkd lht }ee bhy vphipe}}
mhujd `e gnde kl nl{ npt hp }mkelme* hp kldeed kl nl{tbkli
nt njj* yktbhut ghpe hp je}} }eja'}eeckli* nld belme
ulngkn`kjkt{,‒Ha mhup}e kt mnllht*‛ }nkd tbe Vphae}}hp* ‒nld tbepeahpe
ye h`oemt th vphipe}},‛
Natep ybkmb tbepe yn} lh ghpe th `e }nkd, Jntep hl*
bhyeqep* n {huli Vphae}}hp thhc ge n}kde nld }nkd be dkd
lht tbklc K ~ukte uldep}thhd tbekp qkey} n`hut vphipe}},
‒Ye jkce vphipe}}*‛ be }nkd* ‒`ut kt gu}t mhggeld kt}eja
th tbe mhgghl }el}e ha tbe vehvje, Ka n gnl iet} th clhy
ghpe tbnl bk} lekib`hup} be }bhujd ceev bk} clhyjedie
th bkg}eja tkjj be bn} }hulded tbeg* nld }eel ybetbep tbe{
nipee* hp npe jkcej{ th nipee yktb bkg, Be }nkd kt yn} n}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 266/378
Epeybhl
011 ha =9;
kgghpnj th `e thh anp kl aphlt ha hle‛} hyl nie* n} th jni
thh anp `ebkld kt, Ka n gnl mnl mnpp{ bk} lekib`hup} yktbbkg* be gn{ }n{ ybnt be jkce}3 `ut ka lht* ybnt kl}ujt mnl
`e ghpe ipntukthu} tbnl tbe tejjkli tbeg ybnt tbe{ dh lht
ynlt th clhy8 N gnl }bhujd pegeg`ep tbnt kltejjemtunj
hqep' kldujielme k} hle ha tbe gh}t kl}kdkhu} nld
dk}ipnmeauj ahpg} tbnt erme}} mnl tnce, Ipnlted tbnt eqep{
hle }bhujd ermeed ghpe hp je}}* kln}gumb n} n`}hjutej{vepaemt }nlkt{ yhujd dpkqe nl{ gnl gnd tbe ghgelt be
penmbed kt* `ut ‡ ‒
Be yn} lhy ynpgkli th bk} }u`oemt nld K yn}
`eikllkli th yhldep bhy K }bhujd iet pkd ha bkg* ybel
tbe vnpt{ `phce uv* nld tbhuib K vphgk}ed th mnjj hl bkg
`eahpe K jeat* K yn} ulahptulntej{ vpeqelted aphg dhkli }h,K bnqe lhy }nkd elhuib th ikqe Elijk}b pendep} }hge
kden ha tbe }tpnlie qkey} ybkmb tbe Epeybhlknl} bhjd
mhlmeplkli ulpen}hl* b{vhtbetkm}* nld edumntkhl
ielepnjj{, Kl gnl{ pe}vemt} tbe{ yepe }el}k`je elhuib* `ut
K mhujd lht iet hqep tbe b{vhtbetkm}* e}vemknjj{ tbe tuplkli
tbekp hyl ihhd vhetp{ klth tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie, Kl
tbe mhup}e ha g{ }tn{ K get hle {hutb ybh thjd ge tbnt
ahp ahupteel {enp} tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie bnd `eel
njgh}t tbe hlj{ tbkli tbnt be bnd `eel tnuibt* njtbhuib be
bnd leqep th bk} mpedkt* n} kt }eeged th ge+ }bhyl tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 267/378
Epeybhl
019 ha =9;
}jkibte}t vphmjkqkt{ thynpd} kt* ybkje be bnd `eel eldhyed
yktb lht klmhl}kdepn`je n`kjkt{ ahp }eqepnj htbep `pnlmbe}ha bugnl jenplkli, Be n}}uped ge tbnt be yhujd leqep
hvel nlhtbep b{vhtbetkmnj `hhc natep be bnd tncel bk}
deipee* `ut yhujd ahjjhy hut tbe `elt ha bk} hyl
klmjklntkhl}, Tbk} yn} yejj elhuib* `ut ybh mhujd ikqe
bkg bk} ahupteel {enp} `nmc ninkl8
K }hgetkge} yhldeped bhy kt yn} tbnt tbe gk}mbkea dhle yn} lht ghpe mjenpj{ vepmevtk`je* nld tbnt tbe {huli
gel nld yhgel ipey uv n} }el}k`je nld ihhdj{ n} tbe{
dkd* kl }vkte ha tbe nttegvt} njgh}t dejk`epntej{ gnde th
ynpv nld }tult tbekp iphytb, ]hge dhu`tje}} pemekqed
dngnie* aphg ybkmb tbe{ }uaaeped th tbekp jkae‛} eld3 `ut
gnl{ }eeged jkttje hp lhle tbe yhp}e* nld }hge* njgh}ttbe `ettep, Tbe pen}hl yhujd }eeg th `e tbnt tbe lntupnj
kl}tklmt ha tbe jnd} kl gh}t mn}e} }h n`}hjutej{ pe`ejjed
ninkl}t tbekp tpnklkli* tbnt dh ybnt tbe tenmbep} gkibt tbe{
mhujd leqep iet tbeg th vn{ }epkhu} beed th kt, Tbe
mhl}e~uelme yn} tbnt tbe `h{} hlj{ jh}t tbekp tkge* nld
lht }h gumb ha tbk} n} gkibt bnqe `eel ervemted* ahp kl
tbekp bhup} ha jek}upe tbe{ yepe nmtkqej{ elinied kl
erepmk}e} nld }vhpt} ybkmb deqejhved tbekp vb{}kmnj lntupe*
nld gnde tbeg nt nl{ pnte }tphli nld benjtb{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 268/378
Epeybhl
012 ha =9;
Ghpehqep tbh}e ybh bnd nl{ }vemknj tn}te} mhujd lht
`e pe}tpnkled aphg deqejhvkli tbeg? tbe{ yhujd jenplybnt tbe{ ynlted th jenpl nld jkced* kl }vkte ha h`}tnmje}
ybkmb }eeged pntbep th upie tbeg hl tbnl th dk}mhupnie
tbeg* ybkje ahp tbh}e ybh bnd lh }vemknj mnvnmkt{* tbe jh}}
ha tkge yn} ha mhgvnpntkqej{ jkttje ghgelt3 `ut kl }vkte ha
tbe}e njjeqkntkhl} ha tbe gk}mbkea* K ng }upe tbnt gumb
bnpg yn} dhle th tbe mbkjdpel ha tbe }u`'yenjtb{ mjn}}e}*`{ tbe }{}teg ybkmb vn}}e} muppelt nghli tbe
Epeybhlknl} n} edumntkhl, Tbe vhhpe}t mbkjdpel }uaaeped
jen}t—ka de}tpumtkhl nld dentb bnqe benpd tbe }huld ha
yk}dhg* th n meptnkl ertelt vhqept{ bn} dhle }h nj}h,
Nld {et vepbnv}* natep njj* kt k} `ettep ahp n mhultp{ tbnt
kt} }ent} ha jenplkli }bhujd dh ghpe th }uvvpe}} geltnjiphytb tbnl th elmhupnie kt, Yepe kt lht ahp n meptnkl
vpkiik}ble}} ybkmb tbe}e vjnme} klau}e klth }h ipent n
lug`ep ha tbekp njuglk* ielukle yhpc yhujd `emhge
dnliephu}j{ mhgghl, Kt k} e}}eltknj tbnt `{ anp tbe ipentep
vnpt ha ybnt k} }nkd hp dhle kl tbe yhpjd }bhujd `e }h
evbegepnj n} th tnce kt}eja nyn{ ~ukmcj{3 kt }bhujd ceev
ihhd ahp tyelt{'ahup bhup}* hp eqel tykme n} jhli* `ut kt
}bhujd lht `e ihhd elhuib n yeec belme th vpeqelt
vehvje aphg ihkli hl th }hgetbkli ej}e, Lh dhu`t tbe
gnpqejjhu} deqejhvgelt ha ohuplnjk}g kl Elijnld* n} nj}h
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 269/378
Epeybhl
01; ha =9;
tbe anmt tbnt hup }ent} ha jenplkli nkg pntbep nt ah}tepkli
gedkhmpkt{ tbnl nl{tbkli bkibep* k} due th hup }u`mhl}mkhu} pemhilktkhl ha tbe anmt tbnt kt k} eqel ghpe
leme}}np{ th mbemc eru`epnlme ha geltnj deqejhvgelt
tbnl th elmhupnie kt, Tbepe mnl `e lh dhu`t tbnt tbk} k}
ybnt hup nmndegkm `hdke} dh* nld tbe{ dh kt tbe ghpe
eaaemtunjj{ `emnu}e tbe{ dh kt hlj{ }u`mhl}mkhu}j{, Tbe{
tbklc tbe{ npe ndqnlmkli benjtb{ geltnj n}}kgkjntkhl nlddkie}tkhl* ybepen} kl penjkt{ tbe{ npe jkttje `ettep tbnl
mnlmep kl tbe }thgnmb,
Jet ge petupl* bhyeqep* th tbe Epeybhlknl}, Lhtbkli
}upvpk}ed ge ghpe tbnl th }ee tbe hmmn}khlnj ajn}be} ha
mhgghl }el}e yktb ybkmb hle `pnlmb ha }tud{ hp nlhtbep
yn} jkt uv* ybkje lht n }klije pn{ aejj uvhl }h gnl{ htbep},K yn} vnptkmujnpj{ }tpumc yktb tbk} hl }tphjjkli klth tbe Npt
]mbhhj ha tbe Ulkqep}kt{, Bepe K ahuld tbnt tbe mhup}e ha
}tud{ yn} dkqkded klth tyh `pnlmbe}—tbe vpnmtkmnj nld
tbe mhggepmknj—lh }tudelt `ekli vepgktted th mhltklue
bk} }tudke} kl tbe nmtunj vpnmtkme ha tbe npt be bnd tncel uv*
ulje}} be gnde e~unj vphipe}} kl kt} mhggepmknj bk}thp{,
Tbu} tbh}e ybh yepe }tud{kli vnkltkli yepe erngkled
nt ape~uelt kltepqnj} kl tbe vpkme} ybkmb njj tbe jendkli
vkmtupe} ha tbe jn}t akat{ hp n buldped {enp} bnd penjk}ed*
nld kl tbe ajumtuntkhl} kl tbekp qnjue} ybel n} hatel
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 270/378
Epeybhl
096 ha =9;
bnvveled+ tbe{ bnd `eel }hjd nld pe}hjd tbpee hp ahup
tkge}, Tbe nptk}t* tbe{ mhlteld* k} n denjep kl vkmtupe}* nldkt k} n} kgvhptnlt ahp bkg th jenpl bhy th ndnvt bk} ynpe}
th tbe gnpcet* nld th clhy nvvphrkgntej{ ybnt ckld ha n
vkmtupe ykjj aetmb bhy gumb* n} kt k} ahp bkg th `e n`je th
vnklt tbe vkmtupe, Tbk}* K }uvvh}e* k} ybnt tbe Apelmb
genl `{ jn{kli }h gumb }tpe}} uvhl ‒qnjue},‛
N} peinpd} tbe mkt{ kt}eja* tbe ghpe K }ny tbe ghpeelmbnlted K `emnge, K dnpe lht tpu}t g{}eja yktb nl{
de}mpkvtkhl ha tbe er~uk}kte `enut{ ha tbe dkaaepelt
mhjjeie}* nld tbekp ynjc} nld inpdel}, Tpuj{ kl tbe}e tbkli}
njhle tbepe gu}t `e n bnjjhykli nld peaklkli klajuelme
ybkmb k} kl kt}eja bnja nl edumntkhl* nld ybkmb lh nghult
ha epphp mnl ybhjj{ }vhkj, K yn} kltphdumed th gnl{ ha tbeVphae}}hp}* ybh }bhyed ge eqep{ bh}vktnjkt{ nld ckldle}}3
leqeptbeje}} K mhujd bnpdj{ nqhkd n }hpt ha }u}vkmkhl tbnt
}hge ha tbh}e ybhg K yn} tncel th }ee bnd `eel }h jhli
eliph}}ed kl tbekp hyl }tud{ ha b{vhtbetkm} tbnt tbe{ bnd
`emhge tbe ernmt nltktbe}e} ha tbe Ntbelknl} kl tbe dn{}
ha ]t, Vnuj3 ahp ybepen} tbe Ntbelknl} }velt tbekp jkqe} kl
lhtbkli }nqe th }ee nld th benp }hge ley tbkli* tbepe
yepe }hge bepe ybh }eeged th deqhte tbeg}ejqe} th tbe
nqhkdnlme ha eqep{ hvklkhl yktb ybkmb tbe{ yepe lht
vepaemtj{ angkjknp* nld peinpded tbekp hyl `pnkl} n} n }hpt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 271/378
Epeybhl
09> ha =9;
ha }nlmtunp{* th ybkmb ka nl hvklkhl bnd hlme pe}hpted*
lhle htbep yn} th nttnmc kt,K }bhujd ynpl tbe pendep* bhyeqep* tbnt K yn} pnpej{
}upe ybnt tbe gel ybhg K get ybkje }tn{kli yktb Gp,
Tbkg} penjj{ genlt3 ahp tbepe yn} lh iettkli nl{tbkli hut
ha tbeg ka tbe{ }melted eqel n }u}vkmkhl tbnt tbe{ gkibt
`e ybnt tbe{ mnjj ‒ikqkli tbeg}ejqe} nyn{,‛ N} tbepe k}
bnpdj{ nl{ }u`oemt hl ybkmb tbk} }u}vkmkhl mnllht npk}e* Kahuld kt dkaakmujt th iet deaklkte hvklkhl} aphg nl{ ha
tbeg* ermevt hl }umb }u`oemt} n} tbe yentbep* entkli nld
dpklckli* bhjkdn{ ermup}khl}* hp inge} ha }ckjj,
Ka tbe{ mnllht ypkiije hut ha ervpe}}kli nl hvklkhl ha
}hge }hpt* tbe{ ykjj mhgghlj{ petnkj tbh}e ha }hge hle
ybh bn} njpend{ ypkttel uvhl tbe }u`oemt* nld mhlmjude`{ }n{kli tbnt tbhuib tbe{ ~ukte ndgkt tbnt tbepe k} nl
ejegelt ha tputb kl ybnt tbe ypktep bn} }nkd* tbepe npe
gnl{ vhklt} hl ybkmb tbe{ npe uln`je th nipee yktb bkg,
Ybkmb tbe}e vhklt} yepe* K klqnpkn`j{ ahuld g{}eja uln`je
th detepgkle3 kldeed* kt }eeged th `e mhulted tbe
vepaemtkhl ha }mbhjnp}bkv nld ihhd `peedkli nghli tbeg
lht th bnqe—gumb je}} th ervpe}}—nl hvklkhl hl nl{
}u`oemt hl ybkmb kt gkibt vphqe jntep tbnt tbe{ bnd `eel
gk}tncel, Tbe npt ha }kttkli ipnmeaujj{ hl n aelme bn}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 272/378
Epeybhl
090 ha =9;
leqep* K }bhujd tbklc* `eel `phuibt th ipentep vepaemtkhl
tbnl nt tbe Epeybhlknl Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl,Eqel ybel* ypkiije n} tbe{ gn{* tbe{ akld tbeg}ejqe}
vklled dhyl th }hge ervpe}}khl ha deaklkte hvklkhl* n}
hatel n} lht tbe{ ykjj npiue kl }uvvhpt ha ybnt tbe{
vepaemtj{ yejj clhy th `e ultpue, K peventedj{ get yktb
peqkey} nld nptkmje} eqel kl tbekp `e}t ohuplnj}* `etyeel
tbe jkle} ha ybkmb K bnd jkttje dkaakmujt{ kl detemtkli n }el}eernmtj{ mhltpnp{ th tbe hle h}tel}k`j{ vut ahpynpd, ]h yejj
k} tbk} uldep}thhd* tbnt n gnl gu}t `e n gepe t{ph kl tbe
npt} ha Epeybhlknl vhjkte }hmket{* ulje}} be kl}tklmtkqej{
}u}vemt} n bkddel ‒{en‛ kl eqep{ ‒ln{‛ tbnt geet} bkg,
Ipnlted tbnt kt mhge} th gumb tbe }nge kl tbe eld* ahp kt
dhe} lht gnttep ybetbep ‒{en‛ k} mnjjed ‒{en‛ hp ‒ln{*‛ }hjhli n} kt k} uldep}thhd ybkmb kt k} th `e3 `ut hup hyl
ghpe dkpemt yn{ ha mnjjkli n }vnde n }vnde* pntbep tbnl n
pnce* yktb tbe klteltkhl tbnt eqep{ hle }bhujd uldep}tnld
kt n} n }vnde* }eeg} ghpe }ntk}anmthp{, Hl tbe htbep bnld*
tbe Epeybhlknl }{}teg jeld} kt}eja `ettep th tbe
}uvvpe}}khl ha tbnt dhylpkibtle}} ybkmb kt }eeg} tbe
ervpe}} nkg ha Epeybhlknl vbkjh}hvb{ th dk}mhultelnlme,
Bhyeqep tbk} gn{ `e* tbe aenp'ha'ikqkli'tbeg}ejqe}'
nyn{ dk}en}e yn} antnj th tbe kltejjkielme ha tbh}e klaemted
`{ kt* nld njgh}t eqep{ hle nt tbe Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 273/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 274/378
Epeybhl
094 ha =9;
gembnlkmnj jhpe, Ye aejj th tnjckli uvhl tbe }u`oemt* nld
ybel K jeat be inqe ge n pevpklted mhv{ ha tbe yhpcybkmb `phuibt tbe peqhjutkhl n`hut,
Kt bnd tncel vjnme }hge akqe buldped {enp} `eahpe g{
nppkqnj? vehvje bnd jhli `emhge tbhphuibj{ u}ed th tbe
mbnlie* njtbhuib nt tbe tkge tbnt kt yn} gnde tbe mhultp{
yn} vjulied klth tbe deeve}t gk}ep{* nld n penmtkhl ybkmb
ahjjhyed bnd qep{ lenpj{ vphqed }umme}}auj, Mkqkj ynp pnied ahp gnl{ {enp}* nld k} }nkd th bnqe pedumed tbe
lug`ep ha tbe klbn`ktnlt} `{ hle'bnja, Tbe vnptke} yepe
}t{jed tbe gnmbklk}t} nld tbe nltk'gnmbklk}t}* nld kl tbe
eld* n} K bnqe }nkd njpend{* tbe jnttep iht tbe qkmthp{*
tpentkli tbekp hvvhlelt} yktb }umb ulvnpnjjejed }eqepkt{
tbnt tbe{ ertkpvnted eqep{ tpnme ha hvvh}ktkhl,Tbe yhldep yn} tbnt tbe{ njjhyed nl{ gembnlkmnj
nvvjknlme} th pegnkl kl tbe cklidhg* lektbep dh K `ejkeqe
tbnt tbe{ yhujd bnqe dhle }h* bnd lht tbe Vphae}}hp} ha
Klmhl}k}telm{ nld Eqn}khl gnde n }tnld ninkl}t tbe
mnpp{kli ha tbe ley vpklmkvje} th tbekp jeiktkgnte
mhlmju}khl}, Tbe}e Vphae}}hp}* ghpehqep* kl}k}ted tbnt
dupkli tbe }tpuiije tbe nltk'gnmbklk}t} }bhujd u}e eqep{
clhyl kgvphqegelt kl tbe npt ha ynp* nld }eqepnj ley
yenvhl}* haael}kqe nld deael}kqe* yepe klqelted* ybkje kt
yn} kl vphipe}}, K yn} }upvpk}ed nt tbepe pegnklkli }h
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 275/378
Epeybhl
095 ha =9;
gnl{ gembnlkmnj }vemkgel} n} npe }eel kl tbe gu}eug}*
nld nt }tudelt} bnqkli pedk}mhqeped tbekp vn}t u}e} }hmhgvjetej{3 ahp nt tbe tkge ha tbe peqhjutkhl tbe qkmthp}
ypemced njj tbe ghpe mhgvjkmnted gnmbkle}* nld `upled
njj tpentk}e} hl gembnlkm}* nld njj elikleep}‛ yhpc}bhv}—
tbu}* }h tbe{ tbhuibt* muttkli tbe gk}mbkea hut phht nld
`pnlmb* nt nl klmnjmujn`je mh}t ha `jhhd nld tpen}upe,
Meptnklj{ tbe{ bnd lht }vnped tbekp jn`hup* `ut yhpc ha tbk} de}mpkvtkhl mnl leqep `e vepaemtj{ nmbkeqed* nld
ybel* }hge tyh buldped {enp} `eahpe g{ nppkqnj* njj
vn}}khl uvhl tbe }u`oemt bnd mhhjed dhyl* nld lh hle
}nqe n julntkm yhujd bnqe dpenged ha pekltphdumkli
ahp`kddel klqeltkhl}* tbe }u`oemt mnge th `e peinpded n} n
mupkhu} nltk~unpknl }tud{* jkce tbnt ha }hge jhli'ahpihttelpejkikhu} vpnmtkme} nghli hup}ejqe}, Tbel mnge tbe mnpeauj
}enpmb ahp ybnteqep apnigelt} mhujd `e ahuld* nld ahp nl{
gnmbkle} tbnt gkibt bnqe `eel bkddel nyn{* nld nj}h
lug`epje}} tpentk}e} yepe ypkttel* }bhykli ybnt tbe
aulmtkhl} ha enmb pedk}mhqeped gnmbkle bnd `eel3 njj `ekli
dhle yktb lh kden ha u}kli }umb gnmbklep{ ninkl* `ut
yktb tbe aeejkli} ha nl Elijk}b nltk~unpknl mhlmeplkli
Dpukdkmnj ghlugelt} hp ajklt npphy bend},
Hl g{ petupl th tbe getphvhjk}* dupkli tbe pegnklkli
yeec} hp pntbep dn{} ha g{ }hohupl kl Epeybhl K gnde n
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 276/378
Epeybhl
091 ha =9;
pe}uge kl Elijk}b ha tbe yhpc ybkmb `phuibt n`hut tbe
njpend{ geltkhled peqhjutkhl, G{ kilhpnlme ha temblkmnjtepg} bn} jed ge dhu`tje}} klth gnl{ epphp}* nld K bnqe
hmmn}khlnjj{* ybepe K ahuld tpnl}jntkhl kgvh}}k`je*
}u`}tktuted vupej{ Elijk}b lnge} nld kden} ahp tbe hpkiklnj
Epeybhlknl hle}* `ut tbe pendep gn{ pej{ hl g{ ielepnj
nmmupnm{, K bnqe tbhuibt kt `e}t th kl}ept g{ tpnl}jntkhl
bepe,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 277/378
Epeybhl
099 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRKKK? TBE @HHC HA TBEGNMBKLE]
Tbe ypktep mhggelme}?' ‒Tbepe yn} n tkge* ybel tbe
enptb yn} th njj nvvenpnlme uttepj{ de}tktute `htb ha nlkgnj
nld qeietn`je jkae* nld ybel nmmhpdkli th tbe hvklkhl ha
hup `e}t vbkjh}hvbep} kt yn} }kgvj{ n bht phuld `njj yktb n
mpu}t ipndunjj{ mhhjkli, Lhy ka n bugnl `ekli bnd erk}ted
ybkje tbe enptb yn} kl tbk} }tnte nld bnd `eel njjhyed th
}ee kt n} tbhuib kt yepe }hge htbep yhpjd yktb ybkmb be
bnd lh mhlmepl* nld ka nt tbe }nge tkge be yepe eltkpej{
kilhpnlt ha njj vb{}kmnj }mkelme* yhujd be lht bnqe
vphlhulmed kt kgvh}}k`je tbnt mpentupe} vh}}e}}ed ha
nl{tbkli jkce mhl}mkhu}le}} }bhujd `e eqhjqed aphg tbe
}eegkli mkldep ybkmb be yn} `ebhjdkli8 Yhujd be lht
bnqe delked tbnt kt mhltnkled nl{ vhteltknjkt{ ha
mhl}mkhu}le}}8 [et kl tbe mhup}e ha tkge mhl}mkhu}le}}
mnge, K} kt lht vh}}k`je tbel tbnt tbepe gn{ `e eqel {et
ley mbnllej} dui hut ahp mhl}mkhu}le}}* tbhuib ye mnl
detemt lh }kil} ha tbeg nt vpe}elt8‒Ninkl, Mhl}mkhu}le}}* kl nl{tbkli jkce tbe vpe}elt
nmmevtntkhl ha tbe tepg* bnqkli `eel hlme n ley tbkli—n
tbkli* n} anp n} ye mnl }ee* }u`}e~uelt eqel th nl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 278/378
Epeybhl
092 ha =9;
kldkqkdunj meltpe ha nmtkhl nld th n pevphdumtkqe }{}teg
ybkmb ye }ee erk}tkli kl vjnlt} yktbhut nvvnpeltmhl}mkhu}le}}+—yb{ gn{ lht tbepe npk}e }hge ley vbn}e
ha gkld ybkmb }bnjj `e n} dkaaepelt aphg njj vpe}elt clhyl
vbn}e}* n} tbe gkld ha nlkgnj} k} aphg tbnt ha qeietn`je}8
‒Kt yhujd `e n`}upd th nttegvt th deakle }umb n geltnj
}tnte hp ybnteqep kt gn{ `e mnjjed+* kln}gumb n} kt gu}t `e
}hgetbkli }h ahpekil th gnl tbnt bk} ervepkelme mnl ikqebkg lh bejv thynpd} mhlmekqkli kt} lntupe3 `ut }upej{
ybel ye peajemt uvhl tbe gnlkahjd vbn}e} ha jkae nld
mhl}mkhu}le}} ybkmb bnqe `eel eqhjqed njpend{* kt yhujd
`e pn}b th }n{ tbnt lh htbep} mnl `e deqejhved* nld tbnt
nlkgnj jkae k} tbe eld ha njj tbkli}, Tbepe yn} n tkge ybel
akpe yn} tbe eld ha njj tbkli}? nlhtbep ybel phmc} nldyntep yepe }h,‛
Tbe ypktep* natep eljnpikli hl tbe n`hqe ahp }eqepnj
vnie}* vphmeeded th kl~ukpe ybetbep tpnme} ha tbe
nvvphnmb ha }umb n ley vbn}e ha jkae mhujd `e vepmekqed nt
vpe}elt3 ybetbep ye mhujd }ee nl{ telegelt} vpevnpkli
ybkmb gkibt kl n peghte autupkt{ `e ndnvted ahp kt3
ybetbep* kl anmt* tbe vpkghpdknj mejj ha }umb n ckld ha jkae
mhujd `e lhy detemted uvhl enptb, Kl tbe mhup}e ha bk}
yhpc be nl}yeped tbk} ~ue}tkhl kl tbe naakpgntkqe nld
vhklted th tbe bkibep gnmbkle},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 279/378
Epeybhl
09; ha =9;
‒Tbepe k} lh }emupkt{‛—th ~uhte bk} hyl yhpd}—
‒ninkl}t tbe ujtkgnte deqejhvgelt ha gembnlkmnjmhl}mkhu}le}}* kl tbe anmt ha gnmbkle} vh}}e}}kli jkttje
mhl}mkhu}le}} lhy, N ghjju}m bn} lht gumb
mhl}mkhu}le}}, Peajemt uvhl tbe ertpnhpdklnp{ ndqnlme
ybkmb gnmbkle} bnqe gnde dupkli tbe jn}t aey buldped
{enp}* nld lhte bhy }jhyj{ tbe nlkgnj nld qeietn`je
cklidhg} npe ndqnlmkli, Tbe ghpe bkibj{ hpinlk}edgnmbkle} npe mpentupe} lht }h gumb ha {e}tepdn{* n} ha tbe
jn}t akqe gklute}* }h th }venc* kl mhgvnpk}hl yktb vn}t
tkge, N}}uge ahp tbe }nce ha npiugelt tbnt mhl}mkhu}
`ekli} bnqe erk}ted ahp }hge tyelt{ gkjjkhl {enp}? }ee
ybnt }tpkde} gnmbkle} bnqe gnde kl tbe jn}t tbhu}nld. Gn{
lht tbe yhpjd jn}t tyelt{ gkjjkhl {enp} jhliep8 Ka }h* ybntykjj tbe{ lht kl tbe eld `emhge8 K} kt lht }naep th lkv tbe
gk}mbkea kl tbe `ud nld th ahp`kd tbeg auptbep vphipe}}8
‒@ut ybh mnl }n{ tbnt tbe qnvhup elikle bn} lht n ckld
ha mhl}mkhu}le}}8 Ybepe dhe} mhl}mkhu}le}} `eikl* nld
ybepe eld8 Ybh mnl dpny tbe jkle8 Ybh mnl dpny nl{
jkle8 K} lht eqep{tbkli kltepyhqel yktb eqep{tbkli8 K} lht
gnmbklep{ jklced yktb nlkgnj jkae kl nl klaklkte qnpket{ ha
yn{}8 Tbe }bejj ha n bel‛} eii k} gnde ha n dejkmnte ybkte
ynpe nld k} n gnmbkle n} gumb n} nl eii' muv k}? tbe }bejj
k} n deqkme ahp bhjdkli tbe eii* n} gumb n} tbe eii'muv ahp
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 280/378
Epeybhl
026 ha =9;
bhjdkli tbe }bejj? `htb npe vbn}e} ha tbe }nge aulmtkhl3 tbe
bel gnce} tbe }bejj kl bep kl}kde* `ut kt k} vupe vhttep{,]be gnce} bep le}t hut}kde ha bep}eja ahp mhlqelkelme‛
}nce* `ut tbe le}t k} lht ghpe ha n gnmbkle tbnl tbe eii'
}bejj k}, N ‒gnmbkle‛ k} hlj{ n ‒deqkme,‛‛
Tbel petuplkli th mhl}mkhu}le}}* nld eldenqhupkli th
detemt kt} enpjke}t gnlkae}tntkhl}* tbe ypktep mhltklued?'
‒Tbepe k} n ckld ha vjnlt tbnt ent} hpinlkm ahhd yktb kt}ajhyep}? ybel n aj{ }ettje} uvhl tbe `jh}}hg* tbe vetnj}
mjh}e uvhl kt nld bhjd kt an}t tkjj tbe vjnlt bn} n`}hp`ed tbe
kl}emt klth kt} }{}teg3 `ut tbe{ ykjj mjh}e hl lhtbkli `ut
ybnt k} ihhd th ent3 ha n dphv ha pnkl hp n vkeme ha }tkmc
tbe{ ykjj tnce lh lhtkme, Mupkhu}. tbnt }h ulmhl}mkhu} n
tbkli }bhujd bnqe }umb n ceel e{e th kt} hyl kltepe}t, Ka tbk} k} ulmhl}mkhu}le}}* ybepe k} tbe u}e ha mhl}mkhu}le}}8
‒]bnjj ye }n{ tbnt tbe vjnlt dhe} lht clhy ybnt kt k}
dhkli gepej{ `emnu}e kt bn} lh e{e}* hp enp}* hp `pnkl}8 Ka
ye }n{ tbnt kt nmt} gembnlkmnjj{* nld gembnlkmnjj{ hlj{*
}bnjj ye lht `e ahpmed th ndgkt tbnt }uldp{ htbep nld
nvvnpeltj{ qep{ dejk`epnte nmtkhl} npe nj}h gembnlkmnj8 Ka kt
}eeg} th u} tbnt tbe vjnlt ckjj} nld ent} n aj{ gembnlkmnjj{*
gn{ kt lht }eeg th tbe vjnlt tbnt n gnl gu}t ckjj nld ent n
}beev gembnlkmnjj{8
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 281/378
Epeybhl
02> ha =9;
‒@ut kt gn{ `e }nkd tbnt tbe vjnlt k} qhkd ha pen}hl*
`emnu}e tbe iphytb ha n vjnlt k} nl klqhjultnp{ iphytb,Ikqel enptb* nkp* nld due tegvepntupe* tbe vjnlt gu}t
iphy? kt k} jkce n mjhmc* ybkmb `ekli hlme yhuld uv ykjj
ih tkjj kt k} }thvved hp pul dhyl? kt k} jkce tbe ykld
`jhykli hl tbe }nkj} ha n }bkv—tbe }bkv gu}t ih ybel tbe
ykld `jhy} kt, @ut mnl n benjtb{ `h{ bejv iphykli ka be
bnqe ihhd gent nld dpklc nld mjhtbkli8 mnl nl{tbkli bejvihkli n} jhli n} kt k} yhuld uv* hp ih hl natep kt k} pul
dhyl8 K} tbepe lht n ykldkli uv vphme}} eqep{ybepe8
‒Eqel n vhtnth s5w kl n dnpc mejjnp bn} n meptnkl jhy
mullkli n`hut bkg ybkmb }epqe} bkg kl ermejjelt }tend,
Be clhy} vepaemtj{ yejj ybnt be ynlt} nld bhy th iet kt,
Be }ee} tbe jkibt mhgkli aphg tbe mejjnp ykldhy nld}eld} bk} }bhht} mpnyjkli }tpnkibt tbepeth? tbe{ ykjj mpnyj
njhli tbe ajhhp nld uv tbe ynjj nld hut nt tbe mejjnp
ykldhy3 ka tbepe `e n jkttje enptb nl{ybepe hl tbe ohuple{
be ykjj akld kt nld u}e kt ahp bk} hyl eld}, Ybnt
dejk`epntkhl be gn{ erepmk}e kl tbe gnttep ha bk} phht}
ybel be k} vjnlted kl tbe enptb k} n tbkli ulclhyl th u}*
`ut ye mnl kgnikle bkg }n{kli* ‒K ykjj bnqe n tu`ep bepe
nld n tu`ep tbepe* nld K ykjj }umc ybnt}heqep ndqnltnie K
mnl aphg njj g{ }upphuldkli}, Tbk} lekib`hup K ykjj
hqep}bndhy* nld tbnt K ykjj uldepgkle3 nld ybnt K mnl dh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 282/378
Epeybhl
020 ha =9;
}bnjj `e tbe jkgkt ha ybnt K ykjj dh, Be tbnt k} }tphliep nld
`ettep vjnmed tbnl K }bnjj hqepmhge ge* nld bkg tbnt k}yencep K ykjj hqepmhge,‛
‒Tbe vhtnth }n{} tbe}e tbkli} `{ dhkli tbeg* ybkmb k}
tbe `e}t ha jnliunie}, Ybnt k} mhl}mkhu}le}} ka tbk} k} lht
mhl}mkhu}le}}8 Ye akld kt dkaakmujt th }{gvntbk}e yktb tbe
eghtkhl} ha n vhtnth3 }h ye dh yktb tbh}e ha nl h{}tep,
Lektbep ha tbe}e tbkli} gnce} n lhk}e hl `ekli `hkjed hp hveled* nld lhk}e nvvenj} th u} ghpe }tphlij{ tbnl
nl{tbkli ej}e* `emnu}e ye gnce }h gumb n`hut hup hyl
}uaaepkli}, ]klme* tbel* tbe{ dh lht nllh{ u} `{ nl{
ervpe}}khl ha vnkl ye mnjj tbeg eghtkhlje}}3 nld }h ~un
gnlckld tbe{ npe3 `ut gnlckld k} lht eqep{`hd{,
Ka kt `e upied tbnt tbe nmtkhl ha tbe vhtnth k} mbegkmnjnld gembnlkmnj hlj{* nld tbnt kt k} due th tbe mbegkmnj nld
gembnlkmnj eaaemt} ha jkibt nld bent* tbe nl}yep yhujd
}eeg th jke kl nl kl~ukp{ ybetbep eqep{ }el}ntkhl k} lht
mbegkmnj nld gembnlkmnj kl kt} hvepntkhl8 ybetbep tbh}e
tbkli} ybkmb ye deeg gh}t vupej{ }vkpktunj npe nl{tbkli
`ut dk}tup`nlme} ha e~ukjk`pkug kl nl klaklkte }epke} ha
jeqep}* `eikllkli yktb tbh}e tbnt npe thh }gnjj ahp
gkmph}mhvkm detemtkhl* nld ihkli uv th tbe bugnl npg
nld tbe nvvjknlme} ybkmb kt gnce} u}e ha8 ybetbep tbepe
`e lht n ghjemujnp nmtkhl ha tbhuibt* ybelme n d{lngkmnj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 283/378
Epeybhl
02= ha =9;
tbehp{ ha tbe vn}}khl} }bnjj `e dedumk`je8 Ybetbep }tpkmtj{
}venckli ye }bhujd lht n}c ybnt ckld ha jeqep} n gnl k}gnde ha pntbep tbnl ybnt k} bk} tegvepngelt8 Bhy npe
tbe{ `njnlmed8 Bhy gumb ha }umb nld }umb ykjj kt tnce th
yekib tbeg dhyl }h n} th gnce bkg dh }h nld }h8‛
Tbe ypktep yelt hl th }n{ tbnt be nltkmkvnted n tkge
ybel kt yhujd `e vh}}k`je* `{ erngklkli n }klije bnkp yktb
n vhyepauj gkmph}mhve* th clhy ybetbep kt} hylep mhujd`e kl}ujted yktb kgvulkt{, Be tbel `emnge ghpe nld
ghpe h`}mupe* }h tbnt K yn} h`jkied th ikqe uv njj nttegvt
nt tpnl}jntkhl3 lektbep dkd K ahjjhy tbe dpkat ha bk}
npiugelt, Hl mhgkli th tbe lert vnpt ybkmb K mhujd
mhl}tpue* K ahuld tbnt be bnd mbnlied bk} iphuld,
‒Ektbep*‛ be vphmeed}* ‒n ipent denj ha nmtkhl tbnt bn}`eel mnjjed vupej{ gembnlkmnj nld ulmhl}mkhu} gu}t `e
ndgktted th mhltnkl ghpe ejegelt} ha mhl}mkhu}le}} tbnl
bn} `eel njjhyed bktbepth nld kl tbk} mn}e iepg} ha
mhl}mkhu}le}} ykjj `e ahuld kl gnl{ nmtkhl} ha tbe bkibep
gnmbkle}+—Hp n}}ugkli tbe tbehp{ ha eqhjutkhl `ut nt
tbe }nge tkge del{kli tbe mhl}mkhu}le}} ha qeietn`je nld
mp{}tnjjkle nmtkhl+ tbe pnme ha gnl bn} de}melded aphg
tbkli} ybkmb bnd lh mhl}mkhu}le}} nt njj, Kl tbk} mn}e tbepe
k} lh n vpkhpk kgvph`n`kjkt{ kl tbe de}melt ha mhl}mkhu}
nld ghpe tbnl mhl}mkhu}+ gnmbkle} aphg tbh}e ybkmb
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 284/378
Epeybhl
024 ha =9;
lhy erk}t* ermevt tbnt ybkmb k} }uiie}ted `{ tbe nvvnpelt
n`}elme ha nl{tbkli jkce n pevphdumtkqe }{}teg kl tbegembnlkmnj cklidhg, Tbk} n`}elme bhyeqep k} hlj{
nvvnpelt* n} K }bnjj vpe}eltj{ }bhy,
‒Dh lht jet ge `e gk}uldep}thhd n} jkqkli kl aenp ha nl{
nmtunjj{ erk}tkli gnmbkle3 tbepe k} vph`n`j{ lh clhyl
gnmbkle ybkmb k} ghpe tbnl n vphtht{ve ha autupe
gembnlkmnj jkae, Tbe vpe}elt gnmbkle} npe th tbe autupe n}tbe enpj{ ]nupknl} th gnl, Tbe jnpie}t ha tbeg ykjj
vph`n`j{ ipentj{ dkgklk}b kl }kze, ]hge ha tbe jhye}t
qepte`pnte nttnkled n gumb ipentep `ujc tbnl bn} de}melded
th tbekp ghpe bkibj{ hpinlk}ed jkqkli pevpe}eltntkqe}* nld
kl jkce gnllep n dkgklutkhl kl tbe }kze ha gnmbkle} bn}
hatel nttelded tbekp deqejhvgelt nld vphipe}},‒Tnce tbe yntmb* ahp erngvje3 erngkle kt} `enutkauj
}tpumtupe3 h`}epqe tbe kltejjkielt vjn{ ha tbe gklute
geg`ep} ybkmb mhgvh}e kt? {et tbk} jkttje mpentupe k} `ut n
deqejhvgelt ha tbe mug`phu} mjhmc} tbnt vpemeded kt3 kt k}
lh detepkhpntkhl aphg tbeg, N dn{ gn{ mhge ybel
mjhmc}* ybkmb meptnklj{ nt tbe vpe}elt tkge npe lht
dkgklk}bkli kl `ujc* ykjj `e }uvep}eded hykli th tbe
ulkqep}nj u}e ha yntmbe}* kl ybkmb mn}e tbe{ ykjj `emhge
n} ertklmt n} kmbtb{h}nupk* ybkje tbe yntmb* ybh}e
teldelm{ bn} ahp }hge {enp} `eel th dempen}e kl }kze pntbep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 285/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 286/378
Epeybhl
021 ha =9;
mhl}tpumtkhl8—ybel kt} jnliunie }bnjj bnqe `eel
deqejhved aphg tbe mp{ ha nlkgnj} th n }veemb n} kltpkmnten} hup hyl8
‒Kt k} vh}}k`je tbnt `{ tbnt tkge mbkjdpel ykjj jenpl tbe
dkaaepeltknj mnjmuju}—n} tbe{ jenpl lhy th }venc—aphg
tbekp ghtbep} nld lup}e}* hp tbnt tbe{ gn{ tnjc kl tbe
b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie* nld yhpc puje ha tbpee }ug}* n}
}hhl n} tbe{ npe `hpl3 `ut tbk} k} lht vph`n`je3 ye mnllhtmnjmujnte hl nl{ mhppe}vhldkli ndqnlme kl gnl‛}
kltejjemtunj hp vb{}kmnj vhyep} ybkmb }bnjj `e n }et'haa
ninkl}t tbe anp ipentep deqejhvgelt ybkmb }eeg} kl }thpe
ahp tbe gnmbkle}, ]hge vehvje gn{ }n{ tbnt gnl‛} ghpnj
klajuelme ykjj }uaakme th puje tbeg3 `ut K mnllht tbklc kt
ykjj eqep `e }nae th pevh}e gumb tpu}t kl tbe ghpnj }el}e ha nl{ gnmbkle,
‒Ninkl* gkibt lht tbe ijhp{ ha tbe gnmbkle} mhl}k}t kl
tbekp `ekli yktbhut tbk} }nge `hn}ted ikat ha jnliunie8
‒]kjelme*‛ kt bn} `eel }nkd `{ hle ypktep* ‒k} n qkptue ybkmb
peldep} u} nipeen`je th hup aejjhy'mpentupe},‛‛
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 287/378
Epeybhl
029 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRKQ? TBE GNMBKLE]— mhltklued
‒@ut htbep ~ue}tkhl} mhge uvhl u}, Ybnt k} n gnl‛}
e{e `ut n gnmbkle ahp tbe jkttje mpentupe tbnt }kt} `ebkld kl
bk} `pnkl th jhhc tbphuib8 N dend e{e k} lenpj{ n} ihhd n}
n jkqkli hle ahp }hge tkge natep tbe gnl k} dend, Kt k} lht
tbe e{e tbnt mnllht }ee* `ut tbe pe}tje}} hle tbnt mnllht }ee
tbphuib kt, K} kt gnl‛} e{e}* hp k} kt tbe `ki }eekli'elikle
ybkmb bn} peqenjed th u} tbe erk}telme ha yhpjd} `e{hld
yhpjd} klth klaklkt{8 Ybnt bn} gnde gnl angkjknp yktb tbe
}melep{ ha tbe ghhl* tbe }vht} hl tbe }ul* hp tbe
iehipnvb{ ha tbe vjnlet}8 Be k} nt tbe gepm{ ha tbe }eekli'
elikle ahp tbe}e tbkli}* nld k} vhyepje}} ulje}} be tnmc kt
hl th bk} hyl kdeltkt{* nld gnce kt vnpt nld vnpmej ha
bkg}eja, Hp* ninkl* k} kt tbe e{e* hp tbe jkttje }ee'elikle*
ybkmb bn} }bhyl u} tbe erk}telme ha klaklktej{ gklute
hpinlk}g} ybkmb }ynpg ul}u}vemted nphuld u}8
‒Nld tnce gnl‛} qnulted vhyep ha mnjmujntkhl, Bnqe
ye lht elikle} ybkmb mnl dh njj gnllep ha }ug} ghpe~ukmcj{ nld mhppemtj{ tbnl ye mnl8 Ybnt vpkzegnl kl
B{vhtbetkm} nt nl{ ha hup Mhjjeie} ha Ulpen}hl mnl
mhgvnpe yktb }hge ha tbe}e gnmbkle} kl tbekp hyl jkle8
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 288/378
Epeybhl
022 ha =9;
Kl anmt* ybepeqep vpemk}khl k} pe~ukped gnl ajke} th tbe
gnmbkle nt hlme* n} anp vpeaepn`je th bkg}eja, Hup }ug'elikle} leqep dphv n akiupe* lhp hup jhhg} n }tktmb3 tbe
gnmbkle k} `pk}c nld nmtkqe* ybel tbe gnl k} yenp{3 kt k}
mjenp'bended nld mhjjemted* ybel tbe gnl k} }tuvkd nld
dujj3 kt leed} lh }jug`ep* ybel gnl gu}t }jeev hp dphv3
eqep nt kt} vh}t* eqep pend{ ahp yhpc* kt} njnmpkt{ leqep ajni}*
kt} vntkelme leqep ikqe} kl3 kt} gkibt k} }tphliep tbnlmhg`kled buldped}* nld }ykatep tbnl tbe ajkibt ha `kpd}3 kt
mnl `upphy `elentb tbe enptb* nld ynjc uvhl tbe jnpie}t
pkqep} nld }klc lht, Tbk} k} tbe ipeel tpee3 ybnt tbel }bnjj
`e dhle kl tbe dp{8
‒Ybh }bnjj }n{ tbnt n gnl dhe} }ee hp benp8 Be k} }umb n
bkqe nld }ynpg ha vnpn}kte} tbnt kt k} dhu`tauj ybetbep bk}`hd{ k} lht ghpe tbekp} tbnl bk}* nld ybetbep be k}
nl{tbkli `ut nlhtbep ckld ha nlt'benv natep njj, Gn{ lht
gnl bkg}eja `emhge n }hpt ha vnpn}kte uvhl tbe gnmbkle}8
Nl naaemtkhlnte gnmbkle'tkmcjkli nvbkd8
‒Kt k} }nkd `{ }hge tbnt hup `jhhd k} mhgvh}ed ha
klaklkte jkqkli nielt} ybkmb ih uv nld dhyl tbe bkibyn{}
nld `{yn{} ha hup `hdke} n} vehvje kl tbe }tpeet} ha n mkt{,
Ybel ye jhhc dhyl aphg n bkib vjnme uvhl mphyded
tbhphuibanpe}* k} kt vh}}k`je lht th tbklc ha mhpvu}mje} ha
`jhhd tpnqejjkli tbphuib qekl} nld lhupk}bkli tbe benpt ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 289/378
Epeybhl
02; ha =9;
tbe thyl8 Lh geltkhl }bnjj `e gnde ha }eyep}* lhp ha tbe
bkddel lepqe} ybkmb }epqe th mhggulkmnte }el}ntkhl}aphg hle vnpt ha tbe thyl‛} `hd{ th nlhtbep3 lhp ha tbe
{nylkli ony} ha tbe pnkjyn{ }tntkhl}* ybepe`{ tbe
mkpmujntkhl k} mnppked dkpemtj{ klth tbe benpt*—ybkmb
pemekqe tbe qelhu} jkle}* nld dk}ihpie tbe nptepknj* yktb nl
eteplnj vuj}e ha vehvje, Nld tbe }jeev ha tbe thyl* bhy
jkae'jkce. yktb kt} mbnlie kl tbe mkpmujntkhl,‛Bepe tbe ypktep `emnge ninkl }h bhveje}}j{ h`}mupe
tbnt K yn} h`jkied th gk}} }eqepnj vnie}, Be pe}uged?'
‒Kt mnl `e nl}yeped tbnt eqel tbhuib gnmbkle} }bhujd
benp leqep }h yejj nld }venc leqep }h yk}ej{* tbe{ ykjj }tkjj
njyn{} dh tbe hle hp tbe htbep ahp hup ndqnltnie* lht tbekp
hyl3 tbnt gnl ykjj `e tbe pujkli }vkpkt nld tbe gnmbkletbe }epqnlt3 tbnt n} }hhl n} n gnmbkle ankj} th dk}mbnpie tbe
}epqkme ybkmb gnl ervemt} aphg kt* kt k} dhhged th
ertklmtkhl3 tbnt tbe gnmbkle} }tnld th gnl }kgvj{ kl tbe
pejntkhl ha jhyep nlkgnj}* tbe qnvhup'elikle kt}eja `ekli
hlj{ n ghpe emhlhgkmnj ckld ha bhp}e3 }h tbnt kl}tend ha
`ekli jkcej{ th `e deqejhved klth n bkibep ckld ha jkae tbnl
gnl‛}* tbe{ hye tbekp qep{ erk}telme nld vphipe}} th tbekp
vhyep ha gklk}tepkli th bugnl ynlt}* nld gu}t tbepeahpe
`htb lhy nld eqep `e gnl‛} klaepkhp},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 290/378
Epeybhl
0;6 ha =9;
‒Tbk} k} njj qep{ yejj, @ut tbe }epqnlt ijkde} `{
kgvepmevtk`je nvvphnmbe} klth tbe gn}tep3 nld ye bnqemhge th }umb n vn}} tbnt* eqel lhy* gnl gu}t }uaaep
teppk`j{ hl men}kli th `eleakt tbe gnmbkle}, Ka njj gnmbkle}
yepe th `e nllkbkjnted nt hle ghgelt* }h tbnt lht n clkae
lhp jeqep lhp pni ha mjhtbkli lhp nl{tbkli ybnt}heqep
yepe jeat th gnl `ut bk} `npe `hd{ njhle tbnt be yn} `hpl
yktb* nld ka njj clhyjedie ha gembnlkmnj jny} yepe tncelaphg bkg }h tbnt be mhujd gnce lh ghpe gnmbkle}* nld
njj gnmbkle'gnde ahhd de}tph{ed }h tbnt tbe pnme ha gnl
}bhujd `e jeat n} kt yepe lnced uvhl n de}ept k}jnld* ye
}bhujd `emhge ertklmt kl }kr yeec}, N aey gk}epn`je
kldkqkdunj} gkibt jkliep* `ut eqel tbe}e kl n {enp hp tyh
yhujd `emhge yhp}e tbnl ghlce{}, Gnl‛} qep{ }huj k}due th tbe gnmbkle}3 kt k} n gnmbkle'gnde tbkli? be tbklc}
n} be tbklc}* nld aeej} n} be aeej}* tbphuib tbe yhpc tbnt
gnmbkle} bnqe yphuibt uvhl bkg* nld tbekp erk}telme k}
~ukte n} gumb n }kle ~un lhl ahp bk}* n} bk} ahp tbekp}, Tbk}
anmt vpemjude} u} aphg vphvh}kli tbe mhgvjete nllkbkjntkhl
ha gnmbklep{* `ut }upej{ kt kldkmnte} tbnt ye }bhujd
de}tph{ n} gnl{ ha tbeg n} ye mnl vh}}k`j{ dk}vel}e yktb*
je}t tbe{ }bhujd t{pnllk}e hqep u} eqel ghpe mhgvjetej{,
‒Tpue* aphg n jhy gntepknjk}tkm vhklt ha qkey* kt yhujd
}eeg tbnt tbh}e tbpkqe `e}t ybh u}e gnmbklep{ ybepeqep
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 291/378
Epeybhl
0;> ha =9;
kt} u}e k} vh}}k`je yktb vphakt3 `ut tbk} k} tbe npt ha tbe
gnmbkle}—tbe{ }epqe tbnt tbe{ gn{ puje, Tbe{ `enp lhgnjkme thynpd} gnl ahp de}tph{kli n ybhje pnme ha tbeg
vphqkded be mpente} n `ettep kl}tend3 hl tbe mhltpnp{* tbe{
peynpd bkg jk`epnjj{ ahp bnqkli bn}teled tbekp
deqejhvgelt, Kt k} ahp leijemtkli tbeg tbnt be klmup} tbekp
ypntb* hp ahp u}kli klaepkhp gnmbkle}* hp ahp lht gnckli
}uaakmkelt ereptkhl} th klqelt ley hle}* hp ahp de}tph{klitbeg yktbhut pevjnmkli tbeg3 {et tbe}e npe tbe qep{ tbkli}
ye huibt th dh* nld dh ~ukmcj{3 ahp tbhuib hup pe`ejjkhl
ninkl}t tbekp klanlt vhyep ykjj mnu}e klaklkte }uaaepkli*
ybnt ykjj lht tbkli} mhge th* ka tbnt pe`ejjkhl k} dejn{ed8
‒Tbe{ bnqe vpe{ed uvhl gnl‛} iphqejjkli vpeaepelme
ahp bk} gntepknj hqep bk} }vkpktunj kltepe}t}* nld bnqe`etpn{ed bkg klth }uvvj{kli tbnt ejegelt ha }tpuiije nld
ynpanpe yktbhut ybkmb lh pnme mnl ndqnlme, Tbe jhyep
nlkgnj} vphipe}} `emnu}e tbe{ }tpuiije yktb hle nlhtbep3
tbe yencep dke* tbe }tphliep `peed nld tpnl}gkt tbekp
}tpelitb, Tbe gnmbkle} `ekli ha tbeg}ejqe} uln`je th
}tpuiije* bnqe iht gnl th dh tbekp }tpuiijkli ahp tbeg? n}
jhli n} be aujakj} tbk} aulmtkhl duj{* njj ihe} yejj yktb
bkg—nt jen}t be tbklc} }h3 `ut tbe ghgelt be ankj} th dh
bk} `e}t ahp tbe ndqnlmegelt ha gnmbklep{ `{ elmhupnikli
tbe ihhd nld de}tph{kli tbe `nd* be k} jeat `ebkld kl tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 292/378
Epeybhl
0;0 ha =9;
pnme ha mhgvetktkhl3 nld tbk} genl} tbnt be ykjj `e gnde
ulmhgahptn`je kl n qnpket{ ha yn{}* nld vepbnv} dke,‒]h tbnt eqel lhy tbe gnmbkle} ykjj hlj{ }epqe hl
mhldktkhl ha `ekli }epqed* nld tbnt thh uvhl tbekp hyl
tepg}3 tbe ghgelt tbekp tepg} npe lht mhgvjked yktb*
tbe{ ok`* nld ektbep }gn}b `htb tbeg}ejqe} nld njj ybhg
tbe{ mnl penmb* hp tupl mbupjk}b nld peau}e th yhpc nt njj,
Bhy gnl{ gel nt tbk} bhup npe jkqkli kl n }tnte ha `hldnie th tbe gnmbkle}8 Bhy gnl{ }veld tbekp ybhje
jkqe}* aphg tbe mpndje th tbe ipnqe* kl teldkli tbeg `{
lkibt nld dn{8 K} kt lht vjnkl tbnt tbe gnmbkle} npe inklkli
iphuld uvhl u}* ybel ye peajemt hl tbe klmpen}kli
lug`ep ha tbh}e ybh npe `huld dhyl th tbeg n} }jnqe}*
nld ha tbh}e ybh deqhte tbekp ybhje }huj} th tbendqnlmegelt ha tbe gembnlkmnj cklidhg8
‒Tbe qnvhup'elikle gu}t `e aed yktb ahhd nld
mhl}uge kt `{ akpe eqel n} gnl mhl}uge} kt3 kt }uvvhpt} kt}
mhg`u}tkhl `{ nkp n} gnl }uvvhpt} kt3 kt bn} n vuj}e nld
mkpmujntkhl n} gnl bn}, Kt gn{ `e ipnlted tbnt gnl‛} `hd{
k} n} {et tbe ghpe qep}ntkje ha tbe tyh* `ut tbel gnl‛}
`hd{ k} nl hjdep tbkli3 ikqe tbe qnvhup'elikle `ut bnja tbe
tkge tbnt gnl bn} bnd* ikqe kt nj}h n mhltklunlme ha hup
vpe}elt klantuntkhl* nld ybnt gn{ kt lht epe jhli nttnkl th8
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 293/378
Epeybhl
0;= ha =9;
‒Tbepe npe meptnkl aulmtkhl} kldeed ha tbe qnvhup'
elikle ybkmb ykjj vph`n`j{ pegnkl ulmbnlied ahp g{pknd}ha {enp}—ybkmb kl anmt ykjj vepbnv} }upqkqe ybel tbe u}e
ha qnvhup bn} `eel }uvep}eded? tbe vk}thl nld m{jkldep*
tbe `eng* tbe aj{'ybeej* nld htbep vnpt} ha tbe gnmbkle
ykjj vph`n`j{ `e vepgnlelt* ou}t n} ye }ee tbnt gnl nld
gnl{ ha tbe jhyep nlkgnj} }bnpe jkce ghde} ha entkli*
dpklckli* nld }jeevkli3 tbu} tbe{ bnqe benpt} ybkmb `ent n}hup}* qekl} nld nptepke}* e{e}* enp}* nld lh}e}3 tbe{ }kib
eqel kl tbekp }jeev* nld yeev nld {nyl3 tbe{ npe naaemted
`{ tbekp mbkjdpel3 tbe{ aeej vjen}upe nld vnkl* bhve* aenp*
nliep* }bnge3 tbe{ bnqe geghp{ nld vpe}mkelme3 tbe{
clhy tbnt ka meptnkl tbkli} bnvvel th tbeg tbe{ ykjj dke*
nld tbe{ aenp dentb n} gumb n} ye dh3 tbe{ mhggulkmntetbekp tbhuibt} th hle nlhtbep* nld }hge ha tbeg
dejk`epntej{ nmt kl mhlmept, Tbe mhgvnpk}hl ha }kgkjnpktke}
k} eldje}}? K hlj{ gnce kt `emnu}e }hge gn{ }n{ tbnt }klme
tbe qnvhup'elikle k} lht jkcej{ th `e kgvphqed kl tbe
gnkl vnptkmujnp}* kt k} uljkcej{ th `e belmeahpynpd
ertel}kqej{ ghdkaked nt njj, Tbk} k} thh ihhd th `e tpue? kt
ykjj `e ghdkaked nld }ukted ahp nl klaklkte qnpket{ ha
vupvh}e}* n} gumb n} gnl bn} `eel ghdkaked }h n} th
ermeed tbe `pute} kl }ckjj,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 294/378
Epeybhl
0;4 ha =9;
‒Kl tbe genltkge tbe }thcep k} njgh}t n} gumb n mhhc
ahp bk} elikle n} hup hyl mhhc} ahp hup}ejqe}, Mhl}kdep nj}h tbe mhjjkep} nld vktgel nld mhnj gepmbnlt} nld mhnj
tpnkl}* nld tbe gel ybh dpkqe tbeg* nld tbe }bkv} tbnt
mnpp{ mhnj}—ybnt nl npg{ ha }epqnlt} dh tbe gnmbkle}
tbu} egvjh{. Npe tbepe lht vph`n`j{ ghpe gel elinied
kl teldkli gnmbklep{ tbnl kl teldkli gel8 Dh lht
gnmbkle} ent n} kt yepe `{ gnllep{8 Npe ye lht hup}ejqe}mpentkli hup }umme}}hp} kl tbe }uvpegnm{ ha tbe enptb8 dnkj{
nddkli th tbe `enut{ nld dejkmnm{ ha tbekp hpinlk}ntkhl*
dnkj{ ikqkli tbeg ipentep }ckjj nld }uvvj{kli ghpe nld
ghpe ha tbnt }eja'peiujntkli }eja'nmtkli vhyep ybkmb ykjj
`e `ettep tbnl nl{ kltejjemt8
‒Ybnt n ley tbkli kt k} ahp n gnmbkle th aeed nt njj. Tbevjhuib* tbe }vnde* nld tbe mnpt gu}t ent tbphuib gnl‛}
}thgnmb3 tbe auej tbnt }et} tbeg ihkli gu}t `upl kl tbe
auplnme ha n gnl hp ha bhp}e}, Gnl gu}t mhl}uge `pend
nld gent hp be mnllht dki3 tbe `pend nld gent npe tbe auej
ybkmb dpkqe tbe }vnde, Ka n vjhuib `e dpnyl `{ bhp}e}* tbe
vhyep k} }uvvjked `{ ipn}} hp `enl} hp hnt}* ybkmb `ekli
`uplt kl tbe `ejj{ ha tbe mnttje ikqe tbe vhyep ha yhpckli?
yktbhut tbk} auej tbe yhpc yhujd men}e* n} nl elikle
yhujd }thv ka kt} auplnme} yepe th ih hut,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 295/378
Epeybhl
0;5 ha =9;
‒N gnl ha }mkelme bn} deghl}tpnted ‒tbnt lh nlkgnj bn}
tbe vhyep ha hpkiklntkli gembnlkmnj elepi{* `ut tbnt njjtbe yhpc dhle kl kt} jkae `{ nl{ nlkgnj* nld njj tbe bent
tbnt bn} `eel egktted aphg kt* nld tbe bent ybkmb yhujd
`e h`tnkled `{ `uplkli tbe mhg`u}tk`je gnttep ybkmb bn}
`eel jh}t aphg kt} `hd{ dupkli jkae* nld `{ `uplkli kt}
`hd{ natep dentb* gnce uv njthietbep nl ernmt e~ukqnjelt
th tbe bent ybkmb yhujd `e h`tnkled `{ `uplkli n} gumbahhd n} kt bn} u}ed dupkli kt} jkae* nld nl nghult ha auej
ybkmb yhujd ielepnte n} gumb bent n} kt} `hd{ ka `upled
kggedkntej{ natep dentb,‛ K dh lht clhy bhy be bn} ahuld
tbk} hut* `ut be k} n gnl ha }mkelme—bhy tbel mnl kt `e
h`oemted ninkl}t tbe autupe qktnjkt{ ha tbe gnmbkle} tbnt
tbe{ npe* kl tbekp vpe}elt klanlm{* nt tbe `emc nld mnjj ha `ekli} ybh npe tbeg}ejqe} klmnvn`je ha hpkiklntkli
gembnlkmnj elepi{8
‒Tbe gnkl vhklt* bhyeqep* th `e h`}epqed n} naahpdkli
mnu}e ahp njnpg k}* tbnt ybepen} nlkgnj} yepe ahpgepj{ tbe
hlj{ }thgnmb} ha tbe gnmbkle}* tbepe npe lhy gnl{ ybkmb
bnqe }thgnmb} ha tbekp hyl* nld mhl}uge tbekp ahhd
tbeg}ejqe}, Tbk} k} n ipent }tev thynpd} tbekp `emhgkli* ka
lht nlkgnte* {et }hgetbkli }h lenp nckl th kt* n} lht th
dkaaep ghpe ykdej{ aphg hup hyl jkae tbnl nlkgnj} dh
aphg qeietn`je}, Nld tbhuib gnl }bhujd pegnkl* kl }hge
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 296/378
Epeybhl
0;1 ha =9;
pe}vemt}* tbe bkibep mpentupe* k} lht tbk} kl nmmhpdnlme yktb
tbe vpnmtkme ha lntupe* ybkmb njjhy} }uvepkhpkt{ kl }hgetbkli} th nlkgnj} ybkmb bnqe* hl tbe ybhje* `eel jhli
}upvn}}ed8 Bn} }be lht njjhyed tbe nlt nld tbe `ee th
petnkl }uvepkhpkt{ hqep gnl kl tbe hpinlk}ntkhl ha tbekp
mhggulktke} nld }hmknj nppnliegelt}* tbe `kpd kl
tpnqep}kli tbe nkp* tbe ak}b kl }ykggkli* tbe bhp}e kl
}tpelitb nld ajeetle}}* nld tbe dhi kl }eja'}nmpkakme8‒Kt k} }nkd `{ }hge yktb ybhg K bnqe mhlqep}ed uvhl
tbk} }u`oemt* tbnt tbe gnmbkle} mnl leqep `e deqejhved
klth nlkgnte hp ~un}k' nlkgnte erk}telme}* kln}gumb n}
tbe{ bnqe lh pevphdumtkqe }{}teg* lhp }eeg eqep jkcej{ th
vh}}e}} hle, Ka tbk} `e tncel th genl tbnt tbe{ mnllht
gnpp{* nld tbnt ye npe leqep jkcej{ th }ee n aeptkje ulkhl`etyeel tyh qnvhup'elikle} yktb tbe {huli hle} vjn{kli
n`hut tbe dhhp ha tbe }bed* bhyeqep ipentj{ ye gkibt
de}kpe th dh }h* K ykjj pendkj{ ipnlt kt, @ut tbe h`oemtkhl k}
lht n qep{ vphahuld hle, Lh hle ervemt} tbnt njj tbe
aentupe} ha tbe lhy erk}tkli hpinlk}ntkhl} ykjj `e
n`}hjutej{ pevented kl nl eltkpej{ ley mjn}} ha jkae, Tbe
pevphdumtkqe }{}teg ha nlkgnj} dkaaep} ykdej{ aphg tbnt ha
vjnlt}* `ut `htb npe pevphdumtkqe }{}teg}, Bn} lntupe
erbnu}ted bep vbn}e} ha tbk} vhyep8
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 297/378
Epeybhl
0;9 ha =9;
‒]upej{ ka n gnmbkle k} n`je th pevphdume nlhtbep
gnmbkle }{}tegntkmnjj{* ye gn{ }n{ tbnt kt bn} npevphdumtkqe }{}teg, Ybnt k} n pevphdumtkqe }{}teg* ka kt
`e lht n }{}teg ahp pevphdumtkhl8 Nld bhy aey ha tbe
gnmbkle} npe tbepe ybkmb bnqe lht `eel vphdumed
}{}tegntkmnjj{ `{ htbep gnmbkle}8 @ut kt k} gnl tbnt gnce}
tbeg dh }h, [e}3 `ut k} kt lht kl}emt} tbnt gnce gnl{ ha
tbe vjnlt} pevphdumtkqe* nld yhujd lht ybhje angkjke} ha vjnlt} dke hut ka tbekp aeptkjk}ntkhl yn} lht eaaemted `{ n
mjn}} ha nielt} uttepj{ ahpekil th tbeg}ejqe}8 Dhe} nl{ hle
}n{ tbnt tbe ped mjhqep bn} lh pevphdumtkqe }{}teg `emnu}e
tbe bug`je `ee nld tbe bug`je `ee hlj{+ gu}t nkd nld
n`et kt `eahpe kt mnl pevphdume8 Lh hle, Tbe bug`je `ee
k} n vnpt ha tbe pevphdumtkqe }{}teg ha tbe mjhqep, Enmb hleha hup}ejqe} bn} }vpuli aphg gklute nlkgnjmuje} ybh}e
eltkt{ yn} eltkpej{ dk}tklmt aphg hup hyl* nld ybkmb nmted
natep tbekp ckld yktb lh tbhuibt hp beed ha ybnt ye
gkibt tbklc n`hut kt, Tbe}e jkttje mpentupe} npe vnpt ha hup
hyl pevphdumtkqe }{}teg3 tbel yb{ lht ye vnpt ha tbnt ha
tbe gnmbkle}8
‒@ut tbe gnmbkle} ybkmb pevphdume gnmbklep{ dh lht
pevphdume gnmbkle} natep tbekp hyl ckld, N tbkg`je gn{
`e gnde `{ gnmbklep{* `ut kt yn} lht gnde `{* lektbep
ykjj kt eqep gnce* n tbkg`je, Bepe* ninkl* ka ye tupl th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 298/378
Epeybhl
0;2 ha =9;
lntupe ye }bnjj akld n`uldnlme ha nlnjhike} ybkmb ykjj
tenmb u} tbnt n pevphdumtkqe }{}teg gn{ `e kl aujj ahpmeyktbhut tbe tbkli vphdumed `ekli ha tbe }nge ckld n} tbnt
ybkmb vphdumed kt, Qep{ aey mpentupe} pevphdume natep
tbekp hyl ckld3 tbe{ pevphdume }hgetbkli ybkmb bn} tbe
vhteltknjkt{ ha `emhgkli tbnt ybkmb tbekp vnpelt} yepe,
Tbu} tbe `uttepaj{ jn{} nl eii* ybkmb eii mnl `emhge n
mntepvkjjnp* ybkmb mntepvkjjnp mnl `emhge n mbp{}njk}* ybkmbmbp{}njk} mnl `emhge n `uttepaj{3 nld tbhuib K apeej{ ipnlt
tbnt tbe gnmbkle} mnllht `e }nkd th bnqe ghpe tbnl tbe
iepg ha n tpue pevphdumtkqe }{}teg nt vpe}elt* bnqe ye lht
ou}t }eel tbnt tbe{ bnqe hlj{ pemeltj{ h`tnkled tbe iepg}
ha n ghutb nld }thgnmb8 Nld gn{ lht }hge }tpkde `e
gnde kl tbe dkpemtkhl ha tpue pevphdumtkhl ybkmb }bnjj `en} ipent n} tbnt ybkmb bn} `eel pemeltj{ tncel kl tbe
dkpemtkhl ha tpue aeedkli8
‒Kt k} vh}}k`je tbnt tbe }{}teg ybel deqejhved gn{ `e
kl gnl{ mn}e} n qkmnpkhu} tbkli, Meptnkl mjn}}e} ha gnmbkle}
gn{ `e njhle aeptkje* ybkje tbe pe}t dk}mbnpie htbep
aulmtkhl} kl tbe gembnlkmnj }{}teg* ou}t n} tbe ipent
gnohpkt{ ha nlt} nld `ee} bnqe lhtbkli th dh yktb tbe
mhltkluntkhl ha tbekp }vemke}* `ut iet ahhd nld }thpe kt*
yktbhut tbhuibt ha `peedkli, Hle mnllht ervemt tbe
vnpnjjej th `e mhgvjete hp lenpj{ }h3 meptnklj{ lht lhy*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 299/378
Epeybhl
0;; ha =9;
nld vph`n`j{ leqep3 `ut k} tbepe lht elhuib nlnjhi{
erk}tkli nt tbe vpe}elt ghgelt* th gnce u} aeej }epkhu}j{ulen}{ n`hut tbe autupe* nld th peldep kt hup dut{ th
mbemc tbe eqkj ybkje ye mnl }tkjj dh }h8 Gnmbkle} mnl
yktbkl meptnkl jkgkt} `eiet gnmbkle} ha nl{ mjn}}* lh gnttep
bhy dkaaepelt th tbeg}ejqe}, Eqep{ mjn}} ha gnmbkle} ykjj
vph`n`j{ bnqe kt} }vemknj gembnlkmnj `peedep}* nld njj tbe
bkibep hle} ykjj hye tbekp erk}telme th n jnpie lug`ep ha vnpelt} nld lht th tyh hlj{,
‒Ye npe gk}jed `{ mhl}kdepkli nl{ mhgvjkmnted
gnmbkle n} n }klije tbkli3 kl tputb kt k} n mkt{ hp }hmket{*
enmb geg`ep ha ybkmb yn} `ped tpuj{ natep kt} ckld, Ye
}ee n gnmbkle n} n ybhje* ye mnjj kt `{ n lnge nld
kldkqkdunjk}e kt3 ye jhhc nt hup hyl jkg`}* nld clhy tbnttbe mhg`klntkhl ahpg} nl kldkqkdunj ybkmb }vpkli} aphg n
}klije meltpe ha pevphdumtkqe nmtkhl3 ye tbepeahpe n}}uge
tbnt tbepe mnl `e lh pevphdumtkqe nmtkhl ybkmb dhe} lht
npk}e aphg n }klije meltpe3 `ut tbk} n}}ugvtkhl k}
ul}mkeltkakm* nld tbe `npe anmt tbnt lh qnvhup'elikle yn}
eqep gnde eltkpej{ `{ nlhtbep* hp tyh htbep}* ha kt} hyl
ckld* k} lht }uaakmkelt th ynppnlt u} kl }n{kli tbnt qnvhup'
elikle} bnqe lh pevphdumtkqe }{}teg, Tbe tputb k} tbnt
enmb vnpt ha eqep{ qnvhup'elikle k} `ped `{ kt} hyl }vemknj
`peedep}* ybh}e aulmtkhl kt k} th `peed tbnt vnpt* nld tbnt
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 300/378
Epeybhl
=66 ha =9;
hlj{* ybkje tbe mhg`klntkhl ha tbe vnpt} klth n ybhje
ahpg} nlhtbep devnptgelt ha tbe gembnlkmnj pevphdumtkqe}{}teg* ybkmb k} nt vpe}elt ermeedklij{ mhgvjer nld
dkaakmujt th }ee kl kt} eltkpet{,
‒Mhgvjer lhy* `ut bhy gumb }kgvjep nld ghpe
kltejjkik`j{ hpinlk}ed gn{ kt lht `emhge kl nlhtbep
buldped tbhu}nld {enp}8 hp kl tyelt{ tbhu}nld8 Ahp gnl
nt vpe}elt `ejkeqe} tbnt bk} kltepe}t jke} kl tbnt dkpemtkhl3 be}veld} nl klmnjmujn`je nghult ha jn`hup nld tkge nld
tbhuibt kl gnckli gnmbkle} `peed njyn{} `ettep nld
`ettep3 be bn} njpend{ }ummeeded kl eaaemtkli gumb tbnt nt
hle tkge nvvenped kgvh}}k`je* nld tbepe }eeg lh jkgkt} th
tbe pe}ujt} ha nmmugujnted kgvphqegelt} ka tbe{ npe
njjhyed th de}meld yktb ghdkakmntkhl aphg ielepntkhl thielepntkhl, Kt gu}t njyn{} `e pegeg`eped tbnt gnl‛}
`hd{ k} ybnt kt k} tbphuib bnqkli `eel ghujded klth kt}
vpe}elt }bnve `{ tbe mbnlme} nld mbnlie} ha gnl{ gkjjkhl}
ha {enp}* `ut tbnt bk} hpinlk}ntkhl leqep ndqnlmed yktb
nl{tbkli jkce tbe pnvkdkt{ yktb ybkmb tbnt ha tbe gnmbkle}
k} ndqnlmkli, Tbk} k} tbe gh}t njnpgkli aentupe kl tbe mn}e*
nld K gu}t `e vnpdhled ahp kl}k}tkli hl kt }h ape~ueltj{,‛
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 301/378
Epeybhl
=6> ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRQ? TBE GNMBKLE]— mhlmjuded
Bepe ahjjhyed n qep{ jhli nld ultpnl}jntn`je dkipe}}khl
n`hut tbe dkaaepelt pnme} nld angkjke} ha tbe tbel erk}tkli
gnmbkle}, Tbe ypktep nttegvted th }uvvhpt bk} tbehp{ `{
vhkltkli hut tbe }kgkjnpktke} erk}tkli `etyeel gnl{
gnmbkle} ha n ykdej{ dkaaepelt mbnpnmtep* ybkmb }epqed th
}bhy de}melt aphg n mhgghl nlme}thp, Be dkqkded
gnmbkle} klth tbekp ielepn* }u`ielepn* }vemke}* qnpketke}*
}u`qnpketke}* nld }h ahptb, Be vphqed tbe erk}telme ha
mhllemtkli jklc} `etyeel gnmbkle} tbnt }eeged th bnqe
qep{ jkttje kl mhgghl* nld }bhyed tbnt gnl{ ghpe }umb
jklc} bnd erk}ted* `ut bnd lhy vepk}bed, Be vhklted hut
teldelmke} th peqep}khl* nld tbe vpe}elme ha pudkgeltnp{
hpinl} ybkmb erk}ted kl gnl{ gnmbkle} aee`j{ deqejhved
nld vepaemtj{ u}eje}}* {et }epqkli th gnpc de}melt aphg nl
nlme}thp th ybhg tbe aulmtkhl yn} nmtunjj{ u}eauj,
K jeat tbe tpnl}jntkhl ha tbk} vnpt ha tbe tpentk}e* ybkmb*
`{ tbe yn{* yn} anp jhliep tbnl njj tbnt K bnqe ikqel bepe*ahp n jntep hvvhptulkt{, Ulahptulntej{* K jeat Epeybhl
`eahpe K mhujd petupl th tbe }u`oemt3 nld tbhuib K }nqed
g{ tpnl}jntkhl nld htbep vnvep} nt tbe bnznpd ha g{ jkae* K
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 302/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 303/378
Epeybhl
=6= ha =9;
}mphjj* hp eqel n `uttepaj{* ybkje* kl }hge mn}e}* kt ykjj
`emhge ertklmt,‛Hl g{ petupl th Elijnld* K jhhced uv tbe vhklt* nld
ahuld tbnt g{ apkeld yn} pkibt,
Petuplkli* bhyeqep* th tbe tpentk}e* g{ tpnl}jntkhl
pemhggelme} n} ahjjhy}?'
‒Gn{ ye lht anlm{ tbnt ka* kl tbe peghte}t iehjhikmnj
vepkhd* }hge enpj{ ahpg ha qeietn`je jkae bnd `eeleldhyed yktb tbe vhyep ha peajemtkli uvhl tbe dnylkli
jkae ha nlkgnj} ybkmb yn} mhgkli klth erk}telme njhli}kde
ha kt} hyl* kt yhujd bnqe tbhuibt kt}eja ermeedklij{ nmute
ka kt bnd }upgk}ed tbnt nlkgnj} yhujd hle dn{ `emhge penj
qeietn`je}8 [et yhujd tbk} `e ghpe gk}tncel tbnl kt
yhujd `e hl hup vnpt th kgnikle tbnt `emnu}e tbe jkae ha gnmbkle} k} n qep{ dkaaepelt hle th hup hyl* tbepe k}
tbepeahpe lh bkibep vh}}k`je deqejhvgelt ha jkae tbnl hup}3
hp tbnt `emnu}e gembnlkmnj jkae k} n qep{ dkaaepelt tbkli
aphg hup}* tbepeahpe tbnt kt k} lht jkae nt njj8
‒@ut K bnqe benpd kt }nkd* ‒ipnlted tbnt tbk} k} }h* nld
tbnt tbe qnvhup'elikle bn} n }tpelitb ha kt} hyl* }upej{ lh
hle ykjj }n{ tbnt kt bn} n ykjj ha kt} hyl8‛ Njn}. ka ye jhhc
ghpe mjh}ej{* ye }bnjj akld tbnt tbk} dhe} lht gnce ninkl}t
tbe }uvvh}ktkhl tbnt tbe qnvhup'elikle k} hle ha tbe iepg}
ha n ley vbn}e ha jkae, Ybnt k} tbepe kl tbk} ybhje yhpjd*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 304/378
Epeybhl
=64 ha =9;
hp kl tbe yhpjd} `e{hld kt* ybkmb bn} n ykjj ha kt} hyl8
Tbe Ulclhyl nld Ulclhyn`je hlj{.‒N gnl k} tbe pe}ujtnlt nld ervhlelt ha njj tbe ahpme}
tbnt bnqe `eel `phuibt th `enp uvhl bkg* ybetbep `eahpe
bk} `kptb hp natepynpd}, Bk} nmtkhl nt nl{ ghgelt develd}
}hjej{ uvhl bk} mhl}tktutkhl* nld hl tbe kltel}kt{ nld
dkpemtkhl ha tbe qnpkhu} nielmke} th ybkmb be k}* nld bn}
`eel* }u`oemted, ]hge ha tbe}e ykjj mhultepnmt enmb htbep3`ut n} be k} `{ lntupe* nld n} be bn} `eel nmted hl* nld k}
lhy nmted hl aphg yktbhut* }h ykjj be dh* n} meptnklj{ nld
peiujnpj{ n} tbhuib be yepe n gnmbkle,
‒Ye dh lht ielepnjj{ ndgkt tbk}* `emnu}e ye dh lht
clhy tbe ybhje lntupe ha nl{ hle* lhp tbe ybhje ha tbe
ahpme} tbnt nmt uvhl bkg, Ye }ee `ut n vnpt* nld `eklitbu} uln`je th ielepnjk}e bugnl mhldumt* ermevt qep{
phuibj{* ye del{ tbnt kt k} }u`oemt th nl{ akred jny} nt njj*
nld n}mpk`e gumb `htb ha n gnl‛} mbnpnmtep nld nmtkhl} th
mbnlme* hp jumc* hp ahptule3 `ut tbe}e npe hlj{ yhpd}
ybepe`{ ye e}mnve tbe ndgk}}khl ha hup hyl kilhpnlme3
nld n jkttje peajemtkhl ykjj tenmb u} tbnt tbe gh}t dnpkli
ajkibt ha tbe kgniklntkhl hp tbe gh}t }u`tje erepmk}e ha tbe
pen}hl k} n} gumb tbe tbkli tbnt gu}t npk}e* nld tbe hlj{
tbkli tbnt mnl `{ nl{ vh}}k`kjkt{ npk}e* nt tbe ghgelt ha kt}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 305/378
Epeybhl
=65 ha =9;
npk}kli* n} tbe anjjkli ha n dend jena ybel tbe ykld }bnce} kt
aphg tbe tpee,‒Ahp tbe autupe develd} uvhl tbe vpe}elt* nld tbe
vpe}elt ybh}e erk}telme k} hlj{ hle ha tbh}e gklhp
mhgvphgk}e} ha ybkmb bugnl jkae k} aujj—ahp kt jkqe} hlj{
hl }uaaepnlme ha tbe vn}t nld autupe+ develd} uvhl tbe
vn}t* nld tbe vn}t k} ulnjtepn`je, Tbe hlj{ pen}hl yb{ ye
mnllht }ee tbe autupe n} vjnklj{ n} tbe vn}t* k} `emnu}e yeclhy thh jkttje ha tbe nmtunj vn}t nld nmtunj vpe}elt3 tbe}e
tbkli} npe thh ipent ahp u}* htbepyk}e tbe autupe* kl kt}
gklute}t detnkj}* yhujd jke }vpend hut `eahpe hup e{e}* nld
ye }bhujd jh}e hup }el}e ha tkge vpe}elt `{ pen}hl ha tbe
mjenple}} yktb ybkmb ye }bhujd }ee tbe vn}t nld autupe3
vepbnv} ye }bhujd lht `e eqel n`je th dk}tkliuk}b tkge ntnjj3 `ut tbnt k} ahpekil, Ybnt ye dh clhy k}* tbnt tbe ghpe
tbe vn}t nld vpe}elt npe clhyl* tbe ghpe tbe autupe mnl
`e vpedkmted3 nld tbnt lh hle dpeng} ha dhu`tkli tbe
akrkt{ ha tbe autupe kl mn}e} ybepe be k} aujj{ mhilk}nlt ha
`htb vn}t nld vpe}elt* nld bn} bnd ervepkelme ha tbe
mhl}e~uelme} tbnt ahjjhyed aphg }umb n vn}t nld }umb n
vpe}elt hl vpeqkhu} hmmn}khl}, Be vepaemtj{ yejj clhy}
ybnt ykjj bnvvel* nld ykjj }tnce bk} ybhje ahptule
tbepehl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 306/378
Epeybhl
=61 ha =9;
‒Nld tbk} k} n ipent `je}}kli3 ahp kt k} tbe ahuldntkhl hl
ybkmb ghpnjkt{ nld }mkelme npe `ukjt, Tbe n}}upnlme tbnttbe autupe k} lh np`ktpnp{ nld mbnlien`je tbkli* `ut tbnt
jkce autupe} ykjj klqnpkn`j{ ahjjhy jkce vpe}elt}* k} tbe
iphuldyhpc hl ybkmb ye jn{ njj hup vjnl}—tbe anktb hl
ybkmb ye dh eqep{ mhl}mkhu} nmtkhl ha hup jkqe}, Ka tbk}
yepe lht }h ye }bhujd `e yktbhut n iukde3 ye }bhujd
bnqe lh mhlakdelme kl nmtkli* nld belme ye }bhujd leqep nmt* ahp tbepe yhujd `e lh clhykli tbnt tbe pe}ujt} ybkmb
ykjj ahjjhy lhy ykjj `e tbe }nge n} tbh}e ybkmb ahjjhyed
`eahpe,
‒Ybh yhujd vjhuib hp }hy ka be dk}`ejkeqed kl tbe
akrkt{ ha tbe autupe8 Ybh yhujd tbphy yntep hl n `jnzkli
bhu}e ka tbe nmtkhl ha yntep uvhl akpe yepe ulmeptnkl8Gel ykjj hlj{ dh tbekp utgh}t ybel tbe{ aeej meptnkl tbnt
tbe autupe ykjj dk}mhqep kt}eja ninkl}t tbeg ka tbekp utgh}t
bn} lht `eel dhle, Tbe aeejkli ha }umb n meptnklt{ k} n
mhl}tktuelt vnpt ha tbe }ug ha tbe ahpme} nt yhpc uvhl
tbeg* nld ykjj nmt gh}t vhyepaujj{ hl tbe `e}t nld gh}t
ghpnj gel, Tbh}e ybh npe gh}t akpgj{ vep}unded tbnt tbe
autupe k} kggutn`j{ `huld uv yktb tbe vpe}elt kl ybkmb
tbekp yhpc k} j{kli* ykjj `e}t bu}`nld tbekp vpe}elt* nld tkjj
kt yktb tbe ipente}t mnpe, Tbe autupe gu}t `e n jhttep{ th
tbh}e ybh tbklc tbnt tbe }nge mhg`klntkhl} mnl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 307/378
Epeybhl
=69 ha =9;
}hgetkge} vpemede hle }et ha pe}ujt}* nld }hgetkge}
nlhtbep, Ka tbekp `ejkea k} }klmepe tbe{ ykjj }vemujnte kl}tendha yhpckli? tbe}e huibt th `e tbe kgghpnj gel3 tbe
htbep} bnqe tbe }tphlie}t }vup th ereptkhl nld ghpnjkt{* ka
tbekp `ejkea k} n jkqkli hle,
‒Tbe `enpkli ha njj tbk} uvhl tbe gnmbkle} k} lht
kggedkntej{ nvvnpelt* `ut ykjj `emhge }h vpe}eltj{, Kl tbe
genltkge K gu}t denj yktb apkeld} ybh tejj ge tbnt*tbhuib tbe autupe k} akred n} peinpd} klhpinlkm gnttep* nld
kl }hge pe}vemt} yktb peinpd th gnl* {et tbnt tbepe npe
gnl{ yn{} kl ybkmb kt mnllht `e mhl}kdeped n} akred,
Tbu}* tbe{ }n{ tbnt akpe nvvjked th dp{ }bnqkli}* nld yejj
aed yktb hr{iel in}* ykjj njyn{} vphdume n `jnze* `ut tbnt
n mhynpd `phuibt klth mhltnmt yktb n teppka{kli h`oemt ykjjlht njyn{} pe}ujt kl n gnl pullkli nyn{, Leqeptbeje}}* ka
tbepe `e tyh mhynpd} vepaemtj{ }kgkjnp kl eqep{ pe}vemt*
nld ka tbe{ `e }u`oemted kl n vepaemtj{ }kgkjnp yn{ th tyh
teppka{kli nielt}* ybkmb npe tbeg}ejqe} vepaemtj{ }kgkjnp*
tbepe npe aey ybh ykjj lht ervemt n vepaemt }kgkjnpkt{ kl
tbe pullkli nyn{* eqel tbhuib n tbhu}nld {enp} kltepqele
`etyeel tbe hpkiklnj mhg`klntkhl nld kt} `ekli pevented,
‒Tbe nvvnpeltj{ ipentep peiujnpkt{ kl tbe pe}ujt} ha
mbegkmnj tbnl ha bugnl mhg`klntkhl} npk}e} aphg hup
kln`kjkt{ th vepmekqe tbe }u`tje dkaaepelme} kl bugnl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 308/378
Epeybhl
=62 ha =9;
mhg`klntkhl}—mhg`klntkhl} ybkmb npe leqep kdeltkmnjj{
pevented, Akpe ye clhy* nld }bnqkli} ye clhy* `ut lhtyh gel eqep yepe hp eqep ykjj `e ernmtj{ njkce3 nld tbe
}gnjje}t dkaaepelme gn{ mbnlie tbe ybhje mhldktkhl} ha
tbe vph`jeg, Hup peik}tp{ ha pe}ujt} gu}t `e klaklkte `eahpe
ye mhujd nppkqe nt n aujj ahpemn}t ha autupe mhg`klntkhl}3
tbe yhldep k} tbnt tbepe k} n} gumb meptnklt{ mhlmeplkli
bugnl nmtkhl n} tbepe k}3 nld n}}upedj{ tbe hjdep ye iphytbe ghpe meptnkl ye aeej n} th ybnt }umb nld }umb n ckld
ha vep}hl ykjj dh kl ikqel mkpmug}tnlme}3 `ut tbk} mhujd
leqep `e tbe mn}e ulje}} bugnl mhldumt yepe uldep tbe
klajuelme ha jny}* yktb tbe yhpckli ha ybkmb ye `emhge
ghpe nld ghpe angkjknp tbphuib ervepkelme,
‒Ka tbe n`hqe k} }huld* kt ahjjhy} tbnt tbe peiujnpkt{ yktbybkmb gnmbklep{ nmt} k} lh vphha ha tbe n`}elme ha qktnjkt{*
hp nt jen}t ha iepg} ybkmb gn{ `e deqejhved klth n ley
vbn}e ha jkae, Nt akp}t }kibt kt yhujd kldeed nvvenp tbnt n
qnvhup'elikle mnllht bejv ihkli ybel }et uvhl n jkle ha
pnkj} yktb tbe }teng uv nld tbe gnmbklep{ kl aujj vjn{3
ybepen} tbe gnl ybh}e `u}kle}} kt k} th dpkqe kt mnl bejv
dhkli }h nt nl{ ghgelt tbnt be vjen}e}3 }h tbnt tbe akp}t
bn} lh }vhltnlekt{* nld k} lht vh}}e}}ed ha nl{ }hpt ha apee
ykjj* ybkje tbe }emhld bn} nld k},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 309/378
Epeybhl
=6; ha =9;
‒Tbk} k} tpue uv th n meptnkl vhklt3 tbe dpkqep mnl }thv
tbe elikle nt nl{ ghgelt tbnt be vjen}e}* `ut be mnl hlj{vjen}e th dh }h nt meptnkl vhklt} ybkmb bnqe `eel akred ahp
bkg `{ htbep}* hp kl tbe mn}e ha ulervemted h`}tpumtkhl}
ybkmb ahpme bkg th vjen}e th dh }h, Bk} vjen}upe k} lht
}vhltnlehu}3 tbepe k} nl ul}eel mbhkp ha klajuelme} nphuld
bkg* ybkmb gnce kt kgvh}}k`je ahp bkg th nmt kl nl{ htbep
yn{ tbnl hle, Kt k} clhyl `eahpebnld bhy gumb }tpelitbgu}t `e ikqel th tbe}e klajuelme}* ou}t n} kt k} clhyl
`eahpebnld bhy gumb mhnj nld yntep npe leme}}np{ ahp tbe
qnvhup'elikle kt}eja3 nld mupkhu}j{ elhuib kt ykjj `e ahuld
tbnt tbe klajuelme} `phuibt th `enp uvhl tbe dpkqep npe ha
tbe }nge ckld n} tbh}e `phuibt th `enp uvhl tbe elikle—
tbnt k} th }n{* ahhd nld ynpgtb, Tbe dpkqep k} h`edkelt thbk} gn}tep}* `emnu}e be iet} ahhd nld ynpgtb aphg tbeg*
nld ka tbe}e npe yktbbejd hp ikqel kl kl}uaakmkelt ~unltktke}
be ykjj men}e th dpkqe3 kl jkce gnllep tbe elikle ykjj men}e
th yhpc ka kt k} kl}uaakmkeltj{ aed, Tbe hlj{ dkaaepelme k}*
tbnt tbe gnl k} mhl}mkhu} n`hut bk} ynlt}* nld tbe elikle
`e{hld peau}kli th yhpc+ dhe} lht }eeg th `e }h3 `ut tbk}
k} tegvhpnp{* nld bn} `eel denjt yktb n`hqe,
‒Nmmhpdklij{* tbe pe~uk}kte }tpelitb `ekli ikqel th tbe
ghtkqe} tbnt npe th dpkqe tbe dpkqep* tbepe bn} leqep* hp
bnpdj{ eqep* `eel nl kl}tnlme ha n gnl }thvvkli bk} elikle
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 310/378
Epeybhl
=>6 ha =9;
tbphuib ynlthlle}}, @ut }umb n mn}e gkibt hmmup3 {e}* nld
kt gkibt hmmup tbnt tbe elikle }bhujd `penc dhyl? `ut ka tbe tpnkl k} }thvved aphg }hge tpkqknj ghtkqe kt ykjj `e
ahuld ektbep tbnt tbe }tpelitb ha tbe leme}}np{ klajuelme}
bn} `eel gk}mnjmujnted* hp tbnt tbe gnl bn} `eel
gk}mnjmujnted* kl tbe }nge yn{ n} nl elikle gn{ `penc
dhyl aphg nl ul}u}vemted ajny3 `ut eqel kl }umb n mn}e
tbepe ykjj bnqe `eel lh }vhltnlekt{3 tbe nmtkhl ykjj bnqebnd kt} tpue vnpeltnj mnu}e}? }vhltnlekt{ k} hlj{ n tepg ahp
gnl‛} kilhpnlme ha tbe ihd},
‒K} tbepe* tbel* lh }vhltnlekt{ hl tbe vnpt ha tbh}e ybh
dpkqe tbe dpkqep8‛
Bepe ahjjhyed nl h`}mupe npiugelt uvhl tbk} }u`oemt*
ybkmb K bnqe tbhuibt kt `e}t th hgkt, Tbe ypktep pe}uge}?'‒Natep njj tbel kt mhge} th tbk}* tbnt tbe dkaaepelme `etyeel
tbe jkae ha n gnl nld tbnt ha n gnmbkle k} hle pntbep ha
deipee tbnl ha ckld* tbhuib dkaaepelme} kl ckld npe lht
ynltkli, Nl nlkgnj bn} ghpe vphqk}khl ahp egepielm{
tbnl n gnmbkle, Tbe gnmbkle k} je}} qep}ntkje3 kt} pnlie ha
nmtkhl k} lnpphy3 kt} }tpelitb nld nmmupnm{ kl kt} hyl
}vbepe npe }uvepbugnl* `ut kt }bhy} `ndj{ kl n dkjeggn3
}hgetkge} ybel kt} lhpgnj nmtkhl k} dk}tup`ed* kt ykjj jh}e
kt} bend* nld ih aphg `nd th yhp}e jkce n julntkm kl n
pnikli apelz{? `ut bepe* ninkl* ye npe get `{ tbe }nge
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 311/378
Epeybhl
=>> ha =9;
mhl}kdepntkhl n} `eahpe* lngej{* tbnt tbe gnmbkle} npe }tkjj
kl tbekp klanlm{3 tbe{ npe gepe }cejethl} yktbhut gu}mje}nld aje}b,
‒Ahp bhy gnl{ egepielmke} k} nl h{}tep ndnvted8 Ahp
n} gnl{ n} npe jkcej{ th bnvvel th kt* nld lh ghpe, ]h npe
tbe gnmbkle}3 nld }h k} gnl bkg}eja, Tbe jk}t ha mn}unjtke}
tbnt dnkj{ hmmup th gnl tbphuib bk} ynlt ha ndnvtn`kjkt{ k}
vph`n`j{ n} ipent n} tbnt hmmuppkli th tbe gnmbkle}3 nldeqep{ dn{ ikqe} tbeg }hge ipentep vphqk}khl ahp tbe
ulahpe}eel, Jet nl{ hle erngkle tbe yhldepauj }eja'
peiujntkli nld }eja'ndou}tkli mhltpkqnlme} ybkmb npe lhy
klmhpvhpnted yktb tbe qnvhup'elikle* jet bkg yntmb tbe
yn{ kl ybkmb kt }uvvjke} kt}eja yktb hkj3 kl ybkmb kt
kldkmnte} kt} ynlt} th tbh}e ybh teld kt3 kl ybkmb* `{ tbeihqeplhp* kt peiujnte} kt} nvvjkmntkhl ha kt} hyl }tpelitb3 jet
bkg jhhc nt tbnt }thpe'bhu}e ha kleptkn nld ghgeltug tbe
aj{'ybeej* hp nt tbe `uaaep} hl n pnkjyn{ mnppknie3 jet bkg
}ee bhy tbh}e kgvphqegelt} npe `ekli }ejemted ahp
vepvetukt{ ybkmb mhltnkl vphqk}khl ninkl}t tbe
egepielmke} tbnt gn{ npk}e th bnpn}} tbe gnmbkle}* nld
tbel jet bkg tbklc ha n buldped tbhu}nld {enp}* nld tbe
nmmugujnted vphipe}} ybkmb tbe{ ykjj `pkli ulje}} gnl
mnl `e nynceled th n }el}e ha bk} }ktuntkhl* nld ha tbe
dhhg ybkmb be k} vpevnpkli ahp bkg}eja, s1w
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 312/378
Epeybhl
=>0 ha =9;
‒Tbe gk}ep{ k} tbnt gnl bn} `eel `jkld }h jhli njpend{,
Kl bk} pejknlme uvhl tbe u}e ha }teng be bn} `eel `etpn{edklth klmpen}kli nld gujtkvj{kli, Th yktbdpny }teng
vhyep }uddelj{ ykjj lht bnqe tbe eaaemt ha pedumkli u} th
tbe }tnte kl ybkmb ye yepe `eahpe kt} kltphdumtkhl3 tbepe
ykjj `e n ielepnj `penc'uv nld tkge ha nlnpmb{ }umb n} bn}
leqep `eel clhyl3 kt ykjj `e n} tbhuib hup vhvujntkhl
yepe }uddelj{ dhu`jed* yktb lh nddktkhlnj genl} ha aeedkli tbe klmpen}ed lug`ep, Tbe nkp ye `pentbe k} bnpdj{
ghpe leme}}np{ ahp hup nlkgnj jkae tbnl tbe u}e ha nl{
gnmbkle* hl tbe }tpelitb ha ybkmb ye bnqe klmpen}ed hup
lug`ep}* k} th hup mkqkjk}ntkhl3 kt k} tbe gnmbkle} ybkmb nmt
uvhl gnl nld gnce bkg gnl* n} gumb n} gnl ybh bn}
nmted uvhl nld gnde tbe gnmbkle}3 `ut ye gu}t mbhh}e`etyeel tbe njteplntkqe ha uldepihkli gumb vpe}elt
}uaaepkli* hp }eekli hup}ejqe} ipndunjj{ }uvep}eded `{ hup
hyl mpentupe}* tkjj ye pnlc lh bkibep kl mhgvnpk}hl yktb
tbeg* tbnl tbe `en}t} ha tbe akejd yktb hup}ejqe},
‒Bepekl jke} hup dnliep, Ahp gnl{ }eeg klmjkled th
nm~uke}me kl }h dk}bhlhupn`je n autupe, Tbe{ }n{ tbnt
njtbhuib gnl }bhujd `emhge th tbe gnmbkle} ybnt tbe
bhp}e nld dhi npe th u}* {et tbnt be ykjj mhltklue th erk}t*
nld ykjj vph`n`j{ `e `ettep haa kl n }tnte ha dhge}tkmntkhl
uldep tbe `eleakmelt puje ha tbe gnmbkle} tbnl kl bk}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 313/378
Epeybhl
=>= ha =9;
vpe}elt ykjd mhldktkhl, Ye tpent hup dhge}tkm nlkgnj}
yktb gumb ckldle}}, Ye ikqe tbeg ybnteqep ye `ejkeqeth `e tbe `e}t ahp tbeg3 nld tbepe mnl `e lh dhu`t tbnt
hup u}e ha gent bn} klmpen}ed tbekp bnvvkle}} pntbep tbnl
detpnmted aphg kt, Kl jkce gnllep tbepe k} pen}hl th bhve
tbnt tbe gnmbkle} ykjj u}e u} ckldj{* ahp tbekp erk}telme
ykjj `e kl n ipent gen}upe develdelt uvhl hup}3 tbe{ ykjj
puje u} yktb n phd ha kphl* `ut tbe{ ykjj lht ent u}3 tbe{ykjj lht hlj{ pe~ukpe hup }epqkme} kl tbe pevphdumtkhl nld
edumntkhl ha tbekp {huli* `ut nj}h kl ynktkli uvhl tbeg n}
}epqnlt}3 kl intbepkli ahhd ahp tbeg* nld aeedkli tbeg3 kl
pe}thpkli tbeg th benjtb ybel tbe{ npe }kmc3 nld kl ektbep
`up{kli tbekp dend hp yhpckli uv tbekp demen}ed geg`ep}
klth ley ahpg} ha gembnlkmnj erk}telme,‒Tbe qep{ lntupe ha tbe ghtkqe vhyep ybkmb yhpc} tbe
ndqnlmegelt ha tbe gnmbkle} vpemjude} tbe vh}}k`kjkt{ ha
gnl‛} jkae `ekli peldeped gk}epn`je n} yejj n} el}jnqed,
]jnqe} npe thjepn`j{ bnvv{ ka tbe{ bnqe ihhd gn}tep}* nld
tbe peqhjutkhl ykjj lht hmmup kl hup tkge* lhp bnpdj{ kl
tel tbhu}nld {enp}* hp tel tkge} tbnt, K} kt yk}e th `e
ulen}{ n`hut n mhltklielm{ ybkmb k} }h peghte8 Gnl k}
lht n }eltkgeltnj nlkgnj ybepe bk} gntepknj kltepe}t} npe
mhlmepled* nld tbhuib bepe nld tbepe }hge npdelt }huj
gn{ jhhc uvhl bkg}eja nld mup}e bk} ante tbnt be yn} lht
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 314/378
Epeybhl
=>4 ha =9;
`hpl n qnvhup'elikle* {et tbe gn}} ha gnlckld ykjj
nm~uke}me kl nl{ nppnliegelt ybkmb ikqe} tbeg `ettep ahhd nld mjhtbkli nt n mbenvep pnte* nld ykjj peapnkl aphg
{kejdkli th ulpen}hln`je oenjhu}{ gepej{ `emnu}e tbepe npe
htbep de}tklke} ghpe ijhpkhu} tbnl tbekp hyl,
‒Tbe vhyep ha mu}thg k} elhpghu}* nld }h ipndunj ykjj
`e tbe mbnlie* tbnt gnl‛} }el}e ha ybnt k} due th bkg}eja
ykjj `e nt lh tkge pudej{ }bhmced3 hup `hldnie ykjj }tenjuvhl u} lhk}eje}}j{ nld `{ kgvepmevtk`je nvvphnmbe}3 lhp
ykjj tbepe eqep `e }umb n mjn}bkli ha de}kpe} `etyeel gnl
nld tbe gnmbkle} n} ykjj jend th nl elmhultep `etyeel
tbeg, Nghli tbeg}ejqe} tbe gnmbkle} ykjj ynp eteplnjj{*
`ut tbe{ ykjj }tkjj pe~ukpe gnl n} tbe `ekli tbphuib ybh}e
nielm{ tbe }tpuiije ykjj `e vpklmkvnjj{ mhldumted, Kl vhkltha anmt tbepe k} lh hmmn}khl ahp nlrket{ n`hut tbe autupe
bnvvkle}} ha gnl }h jhli n} be mhltklue} th `e kl nl{ yn{
vphaktn`je th tbe gnmbkle}3 be gn{ `emhge tbe klaepkhp
pnme* `ut be ykjj `e klaklktej{ `ettep haa tbnl be k} lhy, K}
kt lht tbel `htb n`}upd nld ulpen}hln`je th `e elqkhu} ha
hup `eleanmthp}8 Nld }bhujd ye lht `e iukjt{ ha
mhl}uggnte ahjj{ ka ye yepe th peoemt ndqnltnie} ybkmb
ye mnllht h`tnkl htbepyk}e* gepej{ `emnu}e tbe{ klqhjqe
n ipentep inkl th htbep} tbnl th hup}ejqe}8
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 315/378
Epeybhl
=>5 ha =9;
‒Yktb tbh}e ybh mnl npiue kl tbk} yn{ K bnqe lhtbkli
kl mhgghl, K }bpklc yktb n} gumb bhpphp aphg `ejkeqklitbnt g{ pnme mnl eqep `e }uvep}eded hp }upvn}}ed* n} K
}bhujd dh aphg `ejkeqkli tbnt eqel nt tbe peghte}t vepkhd
g{ nlme}thp} yepe htbep tbnl bugnl `ekli}, Mhujd K
`ejkeqe tbnt tel buldped tbhu}nld {enp} nih n }klije hle
ha g{ nlme}thp} yn} nlhtbep ckld ha `ekli th g{}eja* K
}bhujd jh}e njj }eja'pe}vemt* nld tnce lh auptbep vjen}upe hp kltepe}t kl jkae, K bnqe tbe }nge aeejkli yktb peinpd th g{
de}meldnlt}* nld `ejkeqe kt th `e hle tbnt ykjj `e aejt }h
ielepnjj{ tbnt tbe mhultp{ ykjj pe}hjqe uvhl vuttkli nl
kggedknte }thv th njj auptbep gembnlkmnj vphipe}}* nld
uvhl de}tph{kli njj kgvphqegelt} tbnt bnqe `eel gnde
ahp tbe jn}t tbpee buldped {enp}, K yhujd lht upie ghpetbnl tbk}, Ye gn{ tpu}t hup}ejqe} th denj yktb tbh}e tbnt
pegnkl* nld tbhuib K }bhujd vpeaep th bnqe }eel tbe
de}tpumtkhl klmjude nlhtbep tyh buldped {enp}* K ng
nynpe ha tbe leme}}kt{ ahp mhgvphgk}kli* nld yhujd }h anp
}nmpkakme g{ hyl kldkqkdunj mhlqkmtkhl} n} th `e mhltelt
yktb tbpee buldped, Je}} tbnl tbk} ykjj `e kl}uaakmkelt,‛
Tbk} yn} tbe mhlmju}khl ha tbe nttnmc ybkmb jed th tbe
de}tpumtkhl ha gnmbklep{ tbphuibhut Epeybhl, Tbepe yn}
hlj{ hle }epkhu} nttegvt th nl}yep kt, Kt} nutbhp }nkd tbnt
gnmbkle} yepe th `e peinpded n} n vnpt ha gnl‛} hyl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 316/378
Epeybhl
=>1 ha =9;
vb{}kmnj lntupe* `ekli penjj{ lhtbkli `ut ertpn'mhpvhpenj
jkg`}, Gnl* be }nkd* yn} n gnmbklnte gnggnj, Tbe jhyep nlkgnj} ceev njj tbekp jkg`} nt bhge kl tbekp hyl `hdke}*
`ut gnl{ ha gnl‛} npe jhh}e* nld jke n`hut detnmbed* lhy
bepe nld lhy tbepe* kl qnpkhu} vnpt} ha tbe yhpjd—}hge
`ekli cevt njyn{} bnld{ ahp mhltklielt u}e* nld htbep}
`ekli hmmn}khlnjj{ buldped} ha gkje} nyn{, N gnmbkle k}
gepej{ n }uvvjegeltnp{ jkg`3 tbk} k} tbe `e njj nld eld njjha gnmbklep{, Ye dh lht u}e hup hyl jkg`} htbep tbnl n}
gnmbkle}3 nld n jei k} hlj{ n gumb `ettep yhhdel jei tbnl
nl{ hle mnl gnluanmtupe,
‒H`}epqe n gnl dkiikli yktb n }vnde3 bk} pkibt ahpe'npg
bn} `emhge nptkakmknjj{ jelitbeled* nld bk} bnld bn}
`emhge n ohklt, Tbe bnldje ha tbe }vnde k} jkce tbe clh` nttbe eld ha tbe bugepu}3 tbe }bnat k} tbe nddktkhlnj `hle*
nld tbe h`jhli kphl vjnte k} tbe ley ahpg ha tbe bnld
ybkmb eln`je} kt} vh}}e}}hp th dk}tup` tbe enptb kl n yn{ th
ybkmb bk} hpkiklnj bnld yn} ule~unj, Bnqkli tbu}
ghdkaked bkg}eja* lht n} htbep nlkgnj} npe ghdkaked* `{
mkpmug}tnlme} hqep ybkmb tbe{ bnqe bnd lht eqel tbe
nvvenpnlme ha mhltphj* `ut bnqkli* n} kt yepe* tncel
ahpetbhuibt nld ndded n mu`kt th bk} }tntupe* mkqkjk}ntkhl
`einl th dnyl uvhl tbe pnme* tbe }hmknj ihhd haakme}* tbe
ielknj mhgvnlkhl}bkv ha apkeld}* tbe npt ha ulpen}hl* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 317/378
Epeybhl
=>9 ha =9;
njj tbh}e bn`kt} ha gkld ybkmb gh}t ejeqnte gnl n`hqe tbe
jhyep nlkgnj}* kl tbe mhup}e ha tkge el}ued,‒Tbu} mkqkjk}ntkhl nld gembnlkmnj vphipe}} ndqnlmed
bnld kl bnld* enmb deqejhvkli nld `ekli deqejhved `{
tbe htbep* tbe enpjke}t nmmkdeltnj u}e ha tbe }tkmc bnqkli }et
tbe `njj phjjkli* nld tbe vph}vemt ha ndqnltnie ceevkli kt kl
ghtkhl, Kl anmt* gnmbkle} npe th `e peinpded n} tbe ghde
ha deqejhvgelt `{ ybkmb bugnl hpinlk}g k} lhye}vemknjj{ ndqnlmkli* eqep{ vn}t klqeltkhl `ekli nl
nddktkhl th tbe pe}hupme} ha tbe bugnl `hd{, Eqel
mhggulkt{ ha jkg`} k} tbu} peldeped vh}}k`je th tbh}e
ybh bnqe }h gumb mhggulkt{ ha }huj n} th hyl ghle{
elhuib th vn{ n pnkjyn{ anpe3 ahp n tpnkl k} hlj{ n }eqel'
jeniued ahht tbnt akqe buldped gn{ hyl nt hlme,‛Tbe hle }epkhu} dnliep ybkmb tbk} ypktep nvvpebelded
yn} tbnt tbe gnmbkle} yhujd }h e~unjk}e gel‛} vhyep}*
nld }h je}}el tbe }eqepkt{ ha mhgvetktkhl* tbnt gnl{
vep}hl} ha klaepkhp vb{}k~ue yhujd e}mnve detemtkhl nld
tpnl}gkt tbekp klaepkhpkt{ th tbekp de}meldnlt}, Be aenped
tbnt tbe peghqnj ha tbe vpe}elt vpe}}upe gkibt mnu}e n
deielepnm{ ha tbe bugnl pnme* nld kldeed tbnt tbe ybhje
`hd{ gkibt `emhge vupej{ pudkgeltnp{* tbe gnl bkg}eja
`ekli lhtbkli `ut }huj nld gembnlk}g* nl kltejjkielt `ut
vn}}khlje}} vpklmkvje ha gembnlkmnj nmtkhl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 318/378
Epeybhl
=>2 ha =9;
‒Bhy ipentj{*‛ be yphte* ‒dh ye lht lhy jkqe yktb hup
erteplnj jkg`}8 Ye qnp{ hup vb{}k~ue yktb tbe }en}hl}*yktb nie* yktb ndqnlmkli hp dempen}kli yenjtb, Ka kt k} yet
ye npe auplk}bed yktb nl hpinl mhgghlj{ mnjjed nl
ug`pejjn* nld ybkmb k} de}kiled ahp tbe vupvh}e ha
vphtemtkli hup mjhtbe} hp hup }ckl} aphg tbe kloupkhu}
eaaemt} ha pnkl, Gnl bn} lhy gnl{ ertpn'mhpvhpenj
geg`ep}* ybkmb npe ha ghpe kgvhptnlme th bkg tbnl nihhd denj ha bk} bnkp* hp nt nl{ pnte tbnl bk} ybk}cep}, Bk}
geghp{ ihe} kl bk} vhmcet'`hhc, Be `emhge} ghpe nld
ghpe mhgvjer n} be iphy} hjdep3 be ykjj tbel `e }eel
yktb }ee'elikle}* hp vepbnv} yktb nptkakmknj teetb nld bnkp?
ka be `e n penjj{ yejj'deqejhved }vemkgel ha bk} pnme* be
ykjj `e auplk}bed yktb n jnpie `hr uvhl ybeej}* tyhbhp}e}* nld n mhnmbgnl,‛
Kt yn} tbk} ypktep ybh hpkiklnted tbe mu}thg ha
mjn}}ka{kli gel `{ tbekp bhp}e'vhyep* nld ybh dkqkded
tbeg klth ielepn* }vemke}* qnpketke}* nld }u`qnpketke}*
ikqkli tbeg lnge} aphg tbe b{vhtbetkmnj jnliunie ybkmb
ervpe}}ed tbe lug`ep ha jkg`} ybkmb tbe{ mhujd
mhggnld nt nl{ ghgelt, Be }bhyed tbnt gel `emnge
ghpe bkibj{ nld dejkmntej{ hpinlk}ed tbe ghpe lenpj{ tbe{
nvvphnmbed tbe }uggkt ha hvujelme* nld tbnt lhle `ut
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 319/378
Epeybhl
=>; ha =9;
gkjjkhlnkpe} vh}}e}}ed tbe aujj mhgvjegelt ha jkg`} yktb
ybkmb gnlckld mhujd `emhge klmhpvhpnte,‒Tbh}e gkibt{ hpinlk}g}*‛ be mhltklued* ‒hup jendkli
`nlcep} nld gepmbnlt}* }venc th tbekp mhlielep} tbphuib
tbe jelitb nld `pendtb ha tbe jnld kl n }emhld ha tkge3
tbekp pkmb nld }u`tje }huj} mnl dea{ njj gntepknj
kgvedkgelt* ybepen} tbe }huj} ha tbe vhhp npe mjhiied
nld bngveped `{ gnttep* ybkmb }tkmc} an}t n`hut tbeg n}tpenmje th tbe ykli} ha n aj{* hp n} hle }tpuiijkli kl n
~ukmc}nld? tbekp dujj enp} gu}t tnce dn{} hp yeec} th benp
ybnt nlhtbep yhujd tejj tbeg aphg n dk}tnlme* kl}tend ha
benpkli kt kl n }emhld n} k} dhle `{ tbe ghpe bkibj{
hpinlk}ed mjn}}e}, Ybh }bnjj del{ tbnt hle ybh mnl tnmc
hl n }vemknj tpnkl th bk} kdeltkt{* nld ih ybepe}heqep beykjj ybel}heqep be vjen}e}* k} ghpe bkibj{ hpinlk}ed tbnl
be ybh* }bhujd be yk}b ahp tbe }nge vhyep* gkibt yk}b
ahp tbe ykli} ha n `kpd yktb nl e~unj mbnlme ha iettkli
tbeg3 nld ybh}e jei} npe bk} hlj{ genl} ha jhmhghtkhl8
Tbnt hjd vbkjh}hvbkm eleg{* gnttep* tbe klbepeltj{ nld
e}}eltknjj{ eqkj* }tkjj bnli} n`hut tbe lemc ha tbe vhhp nld
}tpnlije} bkg? `ut th tbe pkmb* gnttep k} kggntepknj3 tbe
ejn`hpnte hpinlk}ntkhl ha bk} ertpn'mhpvhpenj }{}teg bn}
apeed bk} }huj,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 320/378
Epeybhl
=06 ha =9;
‒Tbk} k} tbe }empet ha tbe bhgnie ybkmb ye }ee pkmb
gel pemekqe aphg tbh}e ybh npe vhhpep tbnl tbeg}ejqe}?kt yhujd `e n ipnqe epphp th }uvvh}e tbnt tbk} deaepelme
vphmeed} aphg ghtkqe} ybkmb ye leed `e n}bnged ha? kt k}
tbe lntupnj pe}vemt ybkmb njj jkqkli mpentupe} vn{ th tbh}e
ybhg tbe{ pemhilk}e n} bkibep tbnl tbeg}ejqe} kl tbe
}mnje ha nlkgnj jkae* nld k} nlnjhihu} th tbe qelepntkhl
ybkmb n dhi aeej} ahp gnl, Nghli }nqnie pnme} kt k}deeged bkibj{ bhlhupn`je th `e tbe vh}}e}}hp ha n iul*
nld tbphuibhut njj clhyl tkge tbepe bn} `eel n aeejkli
tbnt tbh}e ybh npe yhptb gh}t npe tbe yhptbke}t,‛
Nld }h be yelt hl nt mhl}kdepn`je jelitb* nttegvtkli
th }bhy ybnt mbnlie} kl tbe dk}tpk`utkhl ha nlkgnj nld
qeietn`je jkae tbphuibhut tbe cklidhg bnd `eel mnu}ed `{tbk} nld tbnt ha gnl‛} klqeltkhl}* nld kl ybnt yn{ enmb
yn} mhllemted yktb tbe ghpnj nld kltejjemtunj
deqejhvgelt ha tbe bugnl }vemke}? be eqel njjhtted th
}hge tbe }bnpe ybkmb tbe{ bnd bnd kl tbe mpentkhl nld
ghdkakmntkhl ha gnl‛} `hd{* nld tbnt ybkmb tbe{ yhujd
bepenatep bnqe kl kt} de}tpumtkhl3 `ut tbe htbep ypktep yn}
mhl}kdeped th bnqe tbe `e}t ha kt* nld kl tbe eld }ummeeded
kl de}tph{kli njj tbe klqeltkhl} tbnt bnd `eel dk}mhqeped
ahp tbe vpemedkli 09> {enp}* n vepkhd ybkmb yn} nipeed
uvhl `{ njj vnptke} natep }eqepnj {enp} ha ypnlijkli n} th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 321/378
Epeybhl
=0> ha =9;
ybetbep n meptnkl ckld ha gnlije ybkmb yn} gumb kl u}e
nghli yn}bepyhgel }bhujd `e }nqed hp lh, Kt yn} nt jn}tpujed th `e dnliephu}* nld yn} ou}t ermjuded `{ tbe jkgkt
ha 09> {enp}, Tbel mnge tbe penmtkhlnp{ mkqkj ynp} ybkmb
lenpj{ pukled tbe mhultp{* `ut ybkmb kt yhujd `e `e{hld
g{ vpe}elt }mhve th de}mpk`e,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 322/378
Epeybhl
=00 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRQK? TBE QKEY] HA NL EPEYBHLKNL VPHVBET MHLMEPLKLITBE
PKIBT] HA NLKGNJ]
Kt ykjj `e }eel aphg tbe ahpeihkli mbnvtep} tbnt tbe
Epeybhlknl} npe n geec nld jhli'}uaaepkli vehvje* en}kj{
jed `{ tbe lh}e* nld ~ukmc th haaep uv mhgghl }el}e nt
tbe }bpkle ha jhikm* ybel n vbkjh}hvbep npk}e} nghli
tbeg* ybh mnppke} tbeg nyn{ tbphuib bk} pevutntkhl ahp
e}vemknj jenplkli* hp `{ mhlqklmkli tbeg tbnt tbekp erk}tkli
kl}tktutkhl} npe lht `n}ed hl tbe }tpkmte}t vpklmkvje} ha
ghpnjkt{,
Tbe }epke} ha peqhjutkhl} hl ybkmb K }bnjj lhy `pkeaj{
thumb }bhy} tbk} eqel ghpe vjnklj{ tbnl tbe yn{ njpend{
denjt yktb+ kl ybkmb nt n jntep dnte tbe{ mut tbekp tbphnt} kl
tbe gnttep ha gnmbklep{3 ahp ka tbe }emhld ha tbe tyh
peahpgep} ha ybhg K ng n`hut th }venc bnd bnd bk}
yn{—hp pntbep tbe yn{ tbnt be vphae}}ed th bnqe—tbe
ybhje pnme yhujd bnqe dked ha }tnpqntkhl yktbkl n tyejqe'
ghltb, Bnvvkj{ mhgghl }el}e* tbhuib }be k} `{ lntupe
tbe ieltje}t mpentupe jkqkli* ybel }be aeej} tbe clkae nt bep
tbphnt* k} nvt th deqejhv ulervemted vhyep} ha pe}k}tnlme*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 323/378
Epeybhl
=0= ha =9;
nld th }eld dhmtpklnkpe} aj{kli* eqel ybel tbe{ bnqe
`huld bep dhyl nld tbklc tbe{ bnqe bep nt tbekp gepm{,Ybnt bnvveled* }h anp n} K mhujd mhjjemt kt aphg tbe `e}t
nutbhpktke}* yn} n} ahjjhy}?'
]hge tyh tbhu}nld akqe buldped {enp} nih tbe
Epeybhlknl} yepe }tkjj ulmkqkjk}ed* nld jkqed `{ bultkli*
ak}bkli* n pude }{}teg ha nipkmujtupe* nld vjuldepkli }umb
aey htbep lntkhl} n} tbe{ bnd lht {et mhgvjetej{mhl~ueped, Tbe{ bnd lh }mbhhj} hp }{}teg} ha vbkjh}hvb{*
`ut `{ n ckld ha dhi'clhyjedie dkd tbnt ybkmb yn} pkibt
kl tbekp hyl e{e} nld kl tbh}e ha tbekp lekib`hup}3 tbe
mhgghl }el}e* tbepeahpe* ha tbe vu`jkm `ekli n} {et
ulqktknted* mpkge nld dk}en}e yepe jhhced uvhl gumb n}
tbe{ npe kl htbep mhultpke},@ut yktb tbe ipndunj ndqnlme ha mkqkjk}ntkhl nld
klmpen}e kl gntepknj vph}vepkt{* vehvje `einl th n}c
~ue}tkhl} n`hut tbkli} tbnt tbe{ bnd bktbepth tncel n}
gnttep} ha mhup}e* nld hle hjd ieltjegnl* ybh bnd ipent
klajuelme hqep tbeg `{ pen}hl ha tbe }nlmtkt{ ha bk} jkae*
nld bk} }uvvh}ed kl}vkpntkhl `{ nl ul}eel vhyep* ybh}e
erk}telme yn} lhy `eikllkli th `e aejt* thhc kt klth bk}
bend th dk}~uket bkg}eja n`hut tbe pkibt} ha nlkgnj}—n
~ue}tkhl tbnt }h anp bnd dk}tup`ed lh`hd{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 324/378
Epeybhl
=04 ha =9;
Njj vphvbet} npe ghpe hp je}} au}}{* nld tbk} hjd
ieltjegnl }eeg} th bnqe `eel hle ha tbe ghpe au}}{ hle},@ekli gnkltnkled nt tbe vu`jkm ervel}e* be bnd ngvje
jek}upe* nld lht mhltelt yktb jkgktkli bk} ntteltkhl th tbe
pkibt} ha nlkgnj}* be ynlted th pedume pkibt nld yphli th
puje}* th mhl}kdep tbe ahuldntkhl} ha dut{ nld ha ihhd nld
eqkj* nld htbepyk}e th vut njj }hpt} ha gnttep} hl n jhikmnj
`n}k}* ybkmb vehvje ybh}e tkge k} ghle{ npe mhltelt thnmmevt hl lh `n}k} nt njj,
N} n gnttep ha mhup}e* tbe `n}k} hl ybkmb be demkded
tbnt dut{ mhujd njhle pe}t yn} hle tbnt naahpded lh
}tnldkli'phhg ahp gnl{ ha tbe hjd'e}tn`jk}bed bn`kt} ha
tbe vehvje, Tbe}e* be n}}uped tbeg* yepe njj yphli* nld
ybeleqep nl{ hle qeltuped th dkaaep aphg bkg* bepeaepped tbe gnttep th tbe ul}eel vhyep yktb ybkmb be
njhle yn} kl dkpemt mhggulkmntkhl* nld tbe ul}eel vhyep
klqnpkn`j{ n}}uped bkg tbnt be yn} pkibt, N} peinpd} tbe
pkibt} ha nlkgnj} be tnuibt n} ahjjhy}?'
‒[hu clhy* be }nkd* ‒bhy ykmced kt k} ha {hu th ckjj
hle nlhtbep, Hlme uvhl n tkge {hup ahpe'antbep} gnde lh
}mpuvje n`hut lht hlj{ ckjjkli* `ut nj}h entkli tbekp
pejntkhl}, Lh hle yhujd lhy ih `nmc th }umb dete}tn`je
vpnmtkme}* ahp kt k} lhthpkhu} tbnt ye bnqe jkqed gumb ghpe
bnvvkj{ }klme tbe{ yepe n`nldhled, Aphg tbk} klmpen}ed
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 325/378
Epeybhl
=05 ha =9;
vph}vepkt{ ye gn{ mhlakdeltj{ dedume tbe gnrkg tbnt ye
}bhujd lht ckjj nld ent hup aejjhy'mpentupe}, K bnqemhl}ujted tbe bkibep vhyep `{ ybhg {hu clhy tbnt K ng
kl}vkped* nld be bn} n}}uped ge tbnt tbk} mhlmju}khl k}
kppeapnin`je,
‒Lhy kt mnllht `e delked tbnt }beev* mnttje* deep* `kpd}*
nld ak}be} npe hup aejjhy'mpentupe}, Tbe{ dkaaep aphg u} kl
}hge pe}vemt}* `ut tbh}e kl ybkmb tbe{ dkaaep npe aey nld}emhldnp{* ybkje tbh}e tbnt tbe{ bnqe kl mhgghl yktb u}
npe gnl{ nld e}}eltknj, G{ apkeld}* ka kt yn} yphli ha {hu
th ckjj nld ent {hup aejjhy'gel* kt k} yphli nj}h th ckjj nld
ent ak}b* aje}b* nld ahyj, @kpd}* `en}t}* nld ak}be}* bnqe n}
aujj n pkibt th jkqe n} jhli n} tbe{ mnl ulghje}ted `{ gnl*
n} gnl bn} th jkqe ulghje}ted `{ bk} lekib`hup}, Tbe}eyhpd}* jet ge ninkl n}}upe {hu* npe lht gkle* `ut tbh}e ha
tbe bkibep vhyep ybkmb kl}vkpe} ge,
‒K ipnlt*‛ be mhltklued* ‒tbnt nlkgnj} ghje}t hle
nlhtbep* nld tbnt }hge ha tbeg ih }h anp n} th ghje}t gnl*
`ut K bnqe {et th jenpl tbnt ye }bhujd ghdej hup mhldumt
hl tbnt ha tbe jhyep nlkgnj}, Ye }bhujd eldenqhup*
pntbep* th kl}tpumt tbeg* nld `pkli tbeg th n `ettep gkld,
Th ckjj n tkiep* ahp erngvje* ybh bn} jkqed hl tbe aje}b ha
gel nld yhgel ybhg be bn} ckjjed* k} th pedume
hup}ejqe} th tbe jeqej ha tbe tkiep* nld k} ulyhptb{ ha
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 326/378
Epeybhl
=01 ha =9;
vehvje ybh }eec th `e iukded `{ tbe bkibe}t vpklmkvje} kl
njj* `htb tbekp tbhuibt} nld nmtkhl},‒Tbe ul}eel vhyep ybh bn} peqenjed bkg}eja th ge
njhle nghli {hu* bn} thjd ge th tejj {hu tbnt {hu huibt
`{ tbk} tkge th bnqe hutiphyl tbe `np`nphu} bn`kt} ha
{hup nlme}thp}, Ka* n} {hu `ejkeqe* {hu clhy `ettep tbnl
tbe{* {hu }bhujd dh `ettep, Be mhggnld} {hu* tbepeahpe*
th peapnkl aphg ckjjkli nl{ jkqkli `ekli ahp tbe }nce ha entkli kt, Tbe hlj{ nlkgnj ahhd tbnt {hu gn{ ent* k} tbe
aje}b ha nl{ `kpd}* `en}t}* hp ak}be} tbnt {hu gn{ mhge
uvhl n} bnqkli dked n lntupnj dentb* hp nl{ tbnt gn{ bnqe
`eel `hpl vpegntupej{* hp }h deahpged tbnt kt k} n gepm{
th vut tbeg hut ha tbekp vnkl3 {hu gn{ nj}h ent njj }umb
nlkgnj} n} bnqe mhggktted }ukmkde, N} peinpd} qeietn`je} {hu gn{ ent njj tbh}e tbnt ykjj jet {hu ent tbeg yktb
kgvulkt{,‛
]h yk}ej{ nld }h yejj dkd tbe hjd vphvbet npiue* nld }h
teppk`je yepe tbe tbpent} be bupjed nt tbh}e ybh }bhujd
dk}h`e{ bkg* tbnt kl tbe eld be mnppked tbe ghpe bkibj{
edumnted vnpt ha tbe vehvje yktb bkg* nld vpe}eltj{ tbe
vhhpep mjn}}e} ahjjhyed }ukt* hp vphae}}ed th dh }h, Bnqkli
}eel tbe tpkugvb ha bk} vpklmkvje}* be yn} intbeped th bk}
antbep}* nld lh dhu`t elteped nt hlme klth aujj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 327/378
Epeybhl
=09 ha =9;
mhggulkhl yktb tbnt ul}eel vhyep ybh}e anqhup be bnd
njpend{ }h vpe'egkleltj{ eloh{ed,Be bnd lht* bhyeqep* `eel dend qep{ jhli* `eahpe
}hge ha bk} ghpe npdelt dk}mkvje} thhc kt uvhl tbeg th
`ettep tbe kl}tpumtkhl ha tbekp gn}tep, Tbe hjd vphvbet bnd
njjhyed tbe u}e ha eii} nld gkjc* `ut bk} dk}mkvje} demkded
tbnt th ent n ape}b eii yn} th de}tph{ n vhteltknj mbkmcel*
nld tbnt tbk} mnge th gumb tbe }nge n} gupdepkli n jkqehle, ]tnje eii}* ka kt yn} ~ukte meptnkl tbnt tbe{ yepe thh
anp ihle th `e n`je th `e bntmbed* yepe ipudiklij{
vepgktted* `ut njj eii} haaeped ahp }nje bnd th `e }u`gktted
th nl kl}vemthp* ybh* hl `ekli }ntk}aked tbnt tbe{ yepe
nddjed* yhujd jn`ej tbeg ‒Jnkd lht je}} tbnl tbpee ghltb}‛
aphg tbe dnte* ybnteqep kt gkibt bnvvel th `e, Tbe}eeii}* K leed bnpdj{ }n{* yepe hlj{ u}ed kl vuddkli}* nld n}
n gedkmkle kl meptnkl mn}e} ybepe nl egetkm yn} upieltj{
pe~ukped, Gkjc yn} ahp`kddel kln}gumb n} kt mhujd lht `e
h`tnkled yktbhut ph``kli }hge mnja ha kt} lntupnj
}u}telnlme* nld tbu} eldnliepkli kt} jkae,
Kt ykjj `e en}kj{ `ejkeqed tbnt nt akp}t tbepe yepe gnl{
ybh inqe tbe ley puje} hutynpd h`}epqnlme* `ut
eg`pnmed eqep{ hvvhptulkt{ ha kldujikli }empetj{ kl tbh}e
aje}b'vht} th ybkmb tbe{ bnd `eel nmmu}thged, Kt yn}
ahuld tbnt nlkgnj} yepe mhltklunjj{ d{kli lntupnj dentb}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 328/378
Epeybhl
=02 ha =9;
uldep ghpe hp je}} }u}vkmkhu} mkpmug}tnlme}, ]ukmkdnj
gnlkn* ninkl* ybkmb bnd bktbepth `eel mhlakledermju}kqej{ th dhlce{}* `emnge njnpgklij{ vpeqnjelt eqel
nghli }umb ahp tbe gh}t vnpt }eja'pe}vemtkli mpentupe} n}
}beev nld mnttje, Kt yn} n}thlk}bkli bhy }hge ha tbe}e
ulahptulnte nlkgnj} yhujd }melt hut n `utmbep‛} clkae ka
tbepe yn} hle yktbkl n gkje ha tbeg* nld pul pkibt uv
ninkl}t kt ka tbe `utmbep dkd lht iet kt hut ha tbekp yn{ kltkge,
Dhi}* ninkl* tbnt bnd `eel ~ukte jny'n`kdkli n} peinpd}
dhge}tkm vhujtp{* tnge pn``kt}* }umckli vki}* hp }beev nld
jng`}* }uddelj{ thhc th `penckli `e{hld tbe mhltphj ha
tbekp gn}tep}* nld ckjjkli nl{tbkli tbnt tbe{ yepe thjd lht
th thumb, Kt yn} bejd tbnt nl{ nlkgnj ckjjed `{ n dhi bnddked n lntupnj dentb* ahp kt yn} tbe dhi‛} lntupe th ckjj
tbkli}* nld be bnd hlj{ peapnkled aphg ghje}tkli anpg{npd
mpentupe} bktbepth `emnu}e bk} lntupe bnd `eel tngveped
yktb, Ulahptulntej{ tbe ghpe tbe}e ulpuj{ teldelmke}
`emnge deqejhved* tbe ghpe tbe mhgghl vehvje }eeged
th dejkibt kl `peedkli tbe qep{ nlkgnj} tbnt yhujd vut
tegvtntkhl kl tbe dhi‛} yn{, Tbepe k} jkttje dhu`t* kl anmt*
tbnt tbe{ yepe dejk`epntej{ eqndkli tbe jny3 `ut ybetbep
tbk} yn} }h hp lh tbe{ }hjd hp nte eqep{tbkli tbekp dhi}
bnd ckjjed,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 329/378
Epeybhl
=0; ha =9;
Eqn}khl yn} ghpe dkaakmujt kl tbe mn}e ha tbe jnpiep
nlkgnj}* ahp tbe gnik}tpnte} mhujd lht yklc nt njj tbevpetelded }ukmkde} ha vki}* }beev* nld mnttje tbnt yepe
`phuibt `eahpe tbeg, ]hgetkge} tbe{ bnd th mhlqkmt* nld
n aey mhlqkmtkhl} bnd n qep{ tepphpk}kli eaaemt—ybepen} kl
tbe mn}e ha nlkgnj} ckjjed `{ n dhi* tbe gnpc} ha tbe dhi‛}
teetb mhujd `e }eel* nld kt yn} vpnmtkmnjj{ kgvh}}k`je th
vphqe gnjkme hl tbe vnpt ha tbe hylep ha tbe dhi,Nlhtbep aeptkje }hupme ha dk}h`edkelme th tbe jny yn}
auplk}bed `{ n demk}khl ha hle ha tbe oudie} tbnt pnk}ed n
ipent hutmp{ nghli tbe ghpe aepqelt dk}mkvje} ha tbe hjd
vphvbet, Tbe oudie bejd tbnt kt yn} jnyauj th ckjj nl{
nlkgnj kl }eja'deaelme* nld tbnt }umb mhldumt yn} }h
lntupnj hl tbe vnpt ha n gnl ybh ahuld bkg}eja nttnmced*tbnt tbe nttnmckli mpentupe }bhujd `e bejd th bnqe dked n
lntupnj dentb, Tbe Bkib Qeietnpknl} bnd kldeed ihhd
pen}hl th `e njnpged* ahp bnpdj{ bnd tbk} demk}khl `emhge
ielepnjj{ clhyl `eahpe n lug`ep ha nlkgnj}* bktbepth
bnpgje}}* thhc th nttnmckli tbekp hylep} yktb }umb
aephmkt{* tbnt kt `emnge leme}}np{ th vut tbeg th n lntupnj
dentb, Ninkl* kt yn} ~ukte mhgghl nt tbnt tkge th }ee tbe
mnpmn}e ha n mnja* jng`* hp ckd ervh}ed ahp }nje yktb n jn`ej
aphg tbe kl}vemthp meptka{kli tbnt kt bnd `eel ckjjed kl }eja'
deaelme, ]hgetkge} eqel tbe mnpmn}e ha n jng` hp mnja yn}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 330/378
Epeybhl
==6 ha =9;
ervh}ed n} ‒ynppnlted }tkjj'`hpl*‛ ybel kt vpe}elted eqep{
nvvenpnlme ha bnqkli eloh{ed nt jen}t n ghltb ha jkae,N} ahp tbe aje}b ha nlkgnj} tbnt bnd `hln akde dked n
lntupnj dentb* tbe vepgk}}khl th ent kt yn} luinthp{* ahp kt
yn} ielepnjj{ entel `{ }hge htbep nlkgnj `eahpe gnl iht
bhjd ha kt3 hp ankjkli tbk} kt yn} hatel vhk}hlhu}* }h tbnt
vpnmtkmnjj{ vehvje yepe ahpmed th eqnde tbe jny `{ }hge ha
tbe genl} n`hqe }vhcel ha* hp th `emhge qeietnpknl},Tbk} jn}t njteplntkqe yn} }h jkttje th tbe tn}te ha tbe
Epeybhlknl}* tbnt tbe jny} ninkl}t ckjjkli nlkgnj} yepe
anjjkli klth de}uetude* nld yhujd qep{ jkcej{ bnqe `eel
pevenjed* `ut ahp tbe `penckli hut ha n ve}tkjelme* ybkmb
yn} n}mpk`ed `{ tbe vpke}t} nld vphvbet} ha tbe dn{ th tbe
jnyje}}le}} ha tbe vehvje kl tbe gnttep ha entkli ahp`kddelaje}b, Hl tbk}* tbepe yn} n penmtkhl3 }tpklielt jny} yepe
vn}}ed* ahp`kddkli tbe u}e ha gent kl nl{ ahpg hp }bnve*
nld vepgkttkli lh ahhd `ut ipnkl* apukt}* nld qeietn`je} th
`e }hjd kl }bhv} nld gnpcet}, Tbe}e jny} yepe elnmted
n`hut tyh buldped {enp} natep tbe dentb ha tbe hjd vphvbet
ybh bnd akp}t ul}ettjed vehvje‛} gkld} n`hut tbe pkibt} ha
nlkgnj}3 `ut tbe{ bnd bnpdj{ `eel vn}}ed `eahpe vehvje
ninkl `einl th `penc tbeg,
K yn} thjd tbnt tbe gh}t vnklauj mhl}e~uelme ha njj tbk}
ahjj{ dkd lht jke kl tbe anmt tbnt jny'n`kdkli vehvje bnd th
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 331/378
Epeybhl
==> ha =9;
ih yktbhut nlkgnj ahhd—gnl{ lntkhl} dh tbk} nld }eeg
lhle tbe yhp}e* nld eqel kl aje}b'entkli mhultpke} }umb n}Ktnj{* ]vnkl* nld Ipeeme* tbe vhhp }ejdhg }ee gent aphg
{enp‛} eld th {enp‛} eld, Tbe gk}mbkea jn{ kl tbe onp ybkmb
uldue vphbk`ktkhl inqe th tbe mhl}mkelme} ha njj `ut tbh}e
ybh yepe }tphli elhuib th clhy tbnt tbhuib mhl}mkelme
n} n puje `hhl}* kt mnl nj}h `nle, Tbe nynceled mhl}mkelme
ha nl kldkqkdunj ykjj hatel jend bkg th dh tbkli} kl bn}tetbnt be bnd `ettep bnqe jeat uldhle* `ut tbe mhl}mkelme ha
n lntkhl nynceled `{ n pe}vemtn`je hjd ieltjegnl ybh bn}
nl ul}eel vhyep uv bk} }jeeqe ykjj vnqe bejj yktb n
qelienlme,
[huli vehvje yepe thjd tbnt kt yn} n }kl th dh ybnt
tbekp antbep} bnd dhle ulbupt ahp meltupke}3 tbh}e*ghpehqep* ybh vpenmbed th tbeg n`hut tbe elhpgkt{ ha
entkli gent* yepe nl ulnttpnmtkqe nmndegkm ahjc* nld
tbhuib tbe{ hqep'nyed njj `ut tbe `hjdep {hutb}* tbepe
yepe aey ybh dkd lht kl tbekp benpt} dk}jkce tbeg,
Bhyeqep gumb tbe {huli vep}hl gkibt `e }bkejded* be
}hhl iht th clhy tbnt gel nld yhgel ha tbe yhpjd—
hatel anp lkmep vehvje tbnl tbe vphvbet} ybh vpenmbed
n`}teltkhl—mhltklunjj{ }vhce }leepklij{ ha tbe ley
dhmtpklnkpe jny}* nld yepe `ejkeqed th }et tbeg n}kde kl
}empet* tbhuib tbe{ dnped lht dh }h hvelj{, ]gnjj yhldep*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 332/378
Epeybhl
==0 ha =9;
tbel* tbnt tbe ghpe bugnl nghli tbe }tudelt mjn}}e} yepe
vphqhced `{ tbe thumb'lht* tn}te'lht* bnldje'lht vpemevt}ha tbekp pujep}* klth ~ue}tkhlkli gumb tbnt tbe{ yhujd
htbepyk}e bnqe ulbe}ktntklij{ nmmevted,
Hle }nd }thp{ k} hl pemhpd n`hut n {huli gnl ha
vphgk}kli ngkn`je dk}vh}ktkhl* `ut mup}ed yktb ghpe
mhl}mkelme tbnl `pnkl}* ybh bnd `eel thjd `{ bk} dhmthp
ahp n} K bnqe n`hqe }nkd dk}en}e yn} lht {et bejd th `empkgklnj+ tbnt be huibt th ent gent* jny hp lh jny, Be yn}
gumb }bhmced nld ahp }hge tkge peau}ed th mhgvj{ yktb
ybnt be deeged tbe ulpkibtehu} ndqkme ikqel bkg `{ bk}
dhmthp3 nt jn}t* bhyeqep* akldkli tbnt be ipey yencep nld
yencep* be }thje }empetj{ hl n dnpc lkibt klth hle ha tbh}e
del} kl ybkmb gent yn} }uppevtktkhu}j{ }hjd* nld `huibt nvhuld ha vpkge }tenc, Be thhc kt bhge* mhhced kt kl bk}
`edphhg ybel eqep{ hle kl tbe bhu}e bnd ihle th pe}t*
nte kt* nld tbhuib be mhujd bnpdj{ }jeev ahp peghp}e nld
}bnge* aejt }h gumb `ettep lert ghplkli tbnt be bnpdj{
cley bkg}eja,
Tbpee hp ahup dn{} jntep* be ninkl ahuld bkg}eja
kppe}k}tk`j{ dpnyl th tbk} }nge del, Ninkl be `huibt n
vhuld ha }tenc* ninkl be mhhced nld nte kt* nld ninkl* kl
}vkte ha gumb geltnj thptupe* hl tbe ahjjhykli ghplkli
aejt bkg}eja n dkaaepelt gnl, Th mut tbe }thp{ }bhpt* tbhuib
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 333/378
Epeybhl
=== ha =9;
be leqep yelt `e{hld tbe `huld} ha ghdepntkhl* kt
vpe{ed uvhl bk} gkld tbnt be }bhujd `e dpkatkli* n} bemeptnklj{ yn}* klth tbe pnlc} ha tbe bn`ktunj jny'`pencep},
Njj tbe tkge bk} benjtb cevt hl kgvphqkli* nld tbhuib
be aejt }upe tbnt be hyed tbk} th tbe `eea}tenc}* tbe `ettep
be `emnge kl `hd{* tbe ghpe bk} mhl}mkelme inqe bkg lh
pe}t3 tyh qhkme} yepe ahp eqep pklikli kl bk} enp}—tbe hle
}n{kli* ‒K ng Mhgghl ]el}e nld Lntupe3 beed ge* nld Kykjj peynpd {hu n} K peynpded {hup antbep} `eahpe {hu,‛
@ut tbe htbep qhkme }nkd? ‒Jet lht tbnt vjnu}k`je }vkpkt jupe
{hu th {hup pukl, K ng Dut{3 beed ge* nld K ykjj peynpd
{hu n} K peynpded {hup antbep} `eahpe {hu,‛
]hgetkge} be eqel }eeged th }ee tbe anme} ha tbe
}vencep}, Mhgghl ]el}e jhhced }h en}{* ielknj* nld}epele* }h apnlc nld aenpje}}* tbnt dh ybnt be gkibt be
mhujd lht gk}tpu}t bep3 `ut n} be yn} hl tbe vhklt ha
ahjjhykli bep* be yhujd `e mbemced `{ tbe nu}tepe anme ha
Dut{* }h ipnqe* `ut {et }h ckldj{3 nld kt mut bkg th tbe
benpt tbnt aphg tkge th tkge be }bhujd }ee bep tupl vkt{kli
nyn{ aphg bkg n} be ahjjhyed natep bep pkqnj,
Tbe vhhp `h{ mhltklunjj{ tbhuibt ha tbe `ettep mjn}} ha
bk} aejjhy' }tudelt}* nld tpked th ghdej bk} mhldumt hl
ybnt be tbhuibt yn} tbekp}, ‒Tbe{*‛ be }nkd th bkg}eja* ‒ent
n `eea}tenc8 Leqep,‛ @ut tbe{ gh}t ha tbeg nte hle lhy
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 334/378
Epeybhl
==4 ha =9;
nld ninkl* ulje}} kt yn} n gutthl mbhv tbnt tegvted tbeg,
Nld tbe{ u}ed bkg ahp n ghdej gumb n} be dkd tbeg,‒Be*‛ tbe{ yhujd }n{ th tbeg}ejqe}* ‒ent n gutthl mbhv8
Leqep,‛ Hle lkibt* bhyeqep* be yn} ahjjhyed `{ hle ha
tbe nutbhpktke}* ybh yn} njyn{} vphyjkli n`hut kl }enpmb
ha jny' `pencep}* nld yn} mnuibt mhgkli hut ha tbe del
yktb bnja n }bhujdep ha gutthl mhlmenjed n`hut bk} vep}hl,
Hl tbk}* eqel tbhuib be bnd lht `eel vut kl vpk}hl* beyhujd bnqe `eel }elt nyn{ yktb bk} vph}vemt} kl jkae
kppetpkeqn`j{ pukled3 be tbepeahpe bnlied bkg}eja n} }hhl n}
be iht bhge,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 335/378
Epeybhl
==5 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRQKK? TBE QKEY] HA NL EPEYBHLKNL VBKJH]HVBEP MHLMEPLKLI
TBE PKIBT] HA QEIETN@JE]
Jet ge jenqe tbk} ulbnvv{ }thp{* nld petupl th tbe
mhup}e ha eqelt} nghli tbe Epeybhlknl} nt jnpie, Lh
gnttep bhy gnl{ jny} tbe{ vn}}ed klmpen}kli tbe }eqepkt{
ha tbe vulk}bgelt} klajkmted hl tbh}e ybh nte gent kl
}empet* tbe vehvje ahuld genl} ha }ettkli tbeg n}kde n} an}t
n} tbe{ yepe gnde, Nt tkge}* kldeed* tbe{ yhujd `emhge
njgh}t h`}hjete* `ut ybel tbe{ yepe hl tbe vhklt ha
`ekli pevenjed* }hge lntkhlnj dk}n}tep hp tbe vpenmbkli ha
}hge anlntkm yhujd penyncel tbe mhl}mkelme ha tbe
lntkhl* nld vehvje yepe kgvpk}hled `{ tbe tbhu}nld ahp
kjjkmktj{ }ejjkli nld `u{kli nlkgnj ahhd,
N`hut }kr hp }eqel buldped {enp}* bhyeqep* natep tbe
dentb ha tbe hjd vphvbet* n vbkjh}hvbep nvvenped* ybh*
tbhuib be dkd lht mjnkg th bnqe nl{ mhggulkmntkhl yktb
nl ul}eel vhyep* jnkd dhyl tbe jny yktb n} gumb
mhlakdelme n} ka }umb n vhyep bnd kl}vkped bkg, Gnl{
tbklc tbnt tbk} vbkjh}hvbep dkd lht `ejkeqe bk} hyl
tenmbkli* nld* `ekli kl }empet n ipent gent'entep* bnd lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 336/378
Epeybhl
==1 ha =9;
htbep eld kl qkey tbnl pedumkli tbe vphbk`ktkhl ninkl}t
entkli nlkgnj ahhd th nl n`}updkt{* ipentep eqel tbnl nlEpeybhlknl Vupktnl yhujd `e n`je th }tnld,
Tbh}e ybh tnce tbk} qkey bhjd tbnt be cley bhy
kgvh}}k`je kt yhujd `e th iet tbe lntkhl th nmmevt
jeik}jntkhl tbnt kt bejd th `e }klauj3 be cley nj}h bhy
bhveje}} kt yhujd `e th mhlqklme vehvje tbnt kt yn} lht
ykmced th ckjj n }beev nld ent kt* ulje}} be mhujd }bhytbeg tbnt tbe{ gu}t ektbep }kl th n meptnkl ertelt* hp dke,
Be* tbepeahpe* kt k} `ejkeqed* gnde tbe ghl}tphu} vphvh}nj}
ha ybkmb K ykjj lhy }venc,
Be `einl `{ vn{kli n tpk`ute ha vphahuld pe}vemt th
tbe hjd vphvbet* ybh}e ndqhmnm{ ha tbe pkibt} ha nlkgnj}*
be ndgktted* bnd dhle gumb th }hatel tbe lntkhlnjmbnpnmtep* nld eljnpie kt} qkey} n`hut tbe }nlmtkt{ ha jkae kl
ielepnj, @ut be upied tbnt tkge} bnd lhy mbnlied3 tbe
je}}hl ha ybkmb tbe mhultp{ bnd }thhd kl leed bnd `eel
}uaakmkeltj{ jenplt* ybkje n} peinpd} qeietn`je} gumb bnd
`emhge clhyl tbnt yn} lht eqel }u}vemted ahpgepj{* nld
ybkmb* ka tbe lntkhl yn} th vep}eqepe kl tbnt }tpkmt
ndbepelme th tbe bkibe}t ghpnj vpklmkvje} ybkmb bnd `eel
tbe }empet ha kt} vph}vepkt{ bktbepth* gu}t leme}}ktnte n
pndkmnj mbnlie kl kt} nttktude thynpd} tbeg,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 337/378
Epeybhl
==9 ha =9;
Kt yn} kldeed tpue tbnt gumb yn} lhy clhyl tbnt bnd
lht `eel }u}vemted ahpgepj{* ahp tbe vehvje bnd bnd lhahpekil elegke}* nld* `ekli `htb ~ukmc'yktted nld
kl~uk}ktkqe klth tbe g{}tepke} ha lntupe* bnd gnde
ertpnhpdklnp{ vphipe}} kl njj tbe gnl{ `pnlmbe} ha npt nld
}mkelme, Kl tbe mbkea Epeybhlknl gu}eug K yn} }bhyl n
gkmph}mhve ha mhl}kdepn`je vhyep* tbnt yn} n}mpk`ed `{
tbe nutbhpktke} th n dnte gumb n`hut tbnt ha tbevbkjh}hvbep ha ybhg K ng lhy }venckli* nld yn} eqel
}uvvh}ed `{ }hge th bnqe `eel tbe kl}tpugelt yktb
ybkmb be bnd nmtunjj{ yhpced,
Tbk} vbkjh}hvbep yn} Vphae}}hp ha `htnl{ kl tbe mbkea
}ent ha jenplkli tbel kl Epeybhl* nld ybetbep yktb tbe
bejv ha tbe gkmph}mhve }tkjj vpe}epqed* hp yktb nlhtbep*bnd nppkqed nt n mhlmju}khl lhy ulkqep}njj{ nmmevted
nghli hup}ejqe}—K genl* tbnt njj* `htb nlkgnj} nld
vjnlt}* bnqe bnd n mhgghl nlme}tp{* nld tbnt belme tbe
}emhld }bhujd `e deeged n} gumb njkqe n} tbe akp}t, Be
mhltelded* tbepeahpe* tbnt nlkgnj} nld vjnlt} yepe mhu}kl}*
nld yhujd bnqe `eel }eel th `e }h* njj njhli* ka vehvje
bnd lht gnde nl np`ktpnp{ nld ulpen}hln`je dkqk}khl
`etyeel ybnt tbe{ mbh}e th mnjj tbe nlkgnj nld qeietn`je
cklidhg},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 338/378
Epeybhl
==2 ha =9;
Be demjnped* nld deghl}tpnted th tbe }ntk}anmtkhl ha njj
tbh}e ybh yepe n`je th ahpg nl hvklkhl uvhl tbe }u`oemt*tbnt tbepe k} lh dkaaepelme nvvpemkn`je ektbep `{ tbe e{e* hp
`{ nl{ htbep te}t* `etyeel n iepg tbnt ykjj deqejhv klth
nl hnc* n qkle* n ph}e* nld hle tbnt ikqel kt} nmmu}thged
}upphuldkli}+ ykjj `emhge n ghu}e* nl ejevbnlt* hp n
gnl,
Be mhltelded tbnt tbe mhup}e ha nl{ iepg‛}deqejhvgelt yn} dkmtnted `{ tbe bn`kt} ha tbe iepg} aphg
ybkmb kt yn} de}melded nld ha ybh}e kdeltkt{ kt bnd hlme
ahpged vnpt, Ka n iepg ahuld kt}eja vjnmed n} tbe iepg} kl
tbe jkle ha kt} nlme}tp{ yepe vjnmed* kt yhujd dh n} kt}
nlme}thp} bnd dhle* nld iphy uv klth tbe }nge ckld ha
hpinlk}g n} tbekp}, Ka kt ahuld tbe mkpmug}tnlme} hlj{ njkttje dkaaepelt* kt yhujd gnce }bkat }umme}}aujj{ hp
ul}umme}}aujj{+ th ghdka{ kt} deqejhvgelt nmmhpdklij{3 ka
tbe mkpmug}tnlme} yepe ykdej{ dkaaepelt* kt yhujd dke*
vph`n`j{ yktbhut nl eaahpt nt }eja' ndnvtntkhl, Tbk}* be
npiued* nvvjked e~unjj{ th tbe iepg} ha vjnlt} nld ha
nlkgnj},
Be tbepeahpe mhllemted njj* `htb nlkgnj nld qeietn`je
deqejhvgelt* yktb kltejjkielme* ektbep }velt nld lhy
ulmhl}mkhu}* hp }tkjj ul}velt nld mhl}mkhu}3 nld kl }uvvhpt
ha bk} qkey n} peinpd} qeietn`je jkae* be vhklted th tbe yn{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 339/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 340/378
Epeybhl
=46 ha =9;
Ybepe dhe} kt iet kt} mhjhup aphg8 Aphg tbe enptb* nkp*
!m,8 [e}—`ut bhy8 Tbh}e vetnj} ha }umb kleaan`jetertupe—tbnt bue tbnt hutqke} tbe mbeec ha n mbkjd—tbnt
}melt ninkl8 Jhhc nt enptb* nkp* nld yntep—tbe}e npe njj tbe
pny gntepknj tbnt tbe ph}e bn} iht th yhpc yktb3 dhe} kt
}bhy nl{ }kil ha ynlt ha kltejjkielme kl tbe njmbeg{ yktb
ybkmb kt tupl} gud klth ph}e'jenqe}8 Ybnt mbegk}t mnl dh
nl{tbkli mhgvnpn`je8 Yb{ dhe} lh hle tp{8 ]kgvj{`emnu}e eqep{ hle clhy} tbnt lh bugnl kltejjkielme k}
e~unj th tbe tn}c, Ye ikqe kt uv, Kt k} tbe ph}e‛}
devnptgelt3 jet tbe ph}e ntteld th kt—nld `e du``ed
ulkltejjkielt `emnu}e kt `naaje} u} `{ tbe gkpnmje} kt yhpc}*
nld tbe ulmhlmepled `u}kle}}'jkce yn{ kl ybkmb kt yhpc}
tbeg,‒]ee ybnt vnkl}* ninkl* vjnlt} tnce th vphtemt tbeg}ejqe}
ninkl}t tbekp elegke}, Tbe{ }mpntmb* mut* }tkli* gnce `nd
}gejj}* }empete tbe gh}t dpendauj vhk}hl} ybkmb Benqel
hlj{ clhy} bhy tbe{ mhltpkqe th gnce+* mhqep tbekp
vpemkhu} }eed} yktb }vkle} jkce tbh}e ha n bediebhi*
apkibtel kl}emt} yktb dejkmnte lepqhu} }{}teg} `{ n}}ugkli
vhptelthu} }bnve}* bkde tbeg}ejqe}* iphy kl klnmme}}k`je
vjnme}* nld tejj jke} }h vjnu}k`j{ n} th demekqe eqel tbekp
}u`tje}t ahe},
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 341/378
Epeybhl
=4> ha =9;
‒Tbe{ jn{ tpnv} }genped yktb `kpd'jkge* th mntmb kl}emt}*
nld vep}unde tbeg th dphyl tbeg}ejqe} kl vktmbep} ybkmbtbe{ bnqe gnde ha tbekp jenqe}* nld akjj yktb yntep3 htbep}
gnce tbeg}ejqe}* n} kt yepe* klth jkqkli pnt'tpnv}* ybkmb
mjh}e yktb n }vpkli hl nl{ kl}emt tbnt }ettje} uvhl tbeg3
htbep} gnce tbekp ajhyep} klth tbe }bnve ha n meptnkl aj{
tbnt k} n ipent vkjjniep ha bhle{* }h tbnt ybel tbe penj aj{
mhge} kt tbklc} tbnt tbe ajhyep} npe `e}vhce* nld ihe} hlej}eybepe, ]hge npe }h mjeqep n} eqel th hqeppenmb
tbeg}ejqe}* jkce tbe bhp}e'pndk}b* ybkmb iet} vujjed uv nld
entel ahp tbe }nce ha tbnt vulielm{ yktb ybkmb kt vphtemt}
kt}eja ninkl}t uldepiphuld elegke}, Ka* hl tbe htbep bnld*
tbe{ tbklc tbnt nl{ kl}emt mnl `e ha }epqkme th tbeg* }ee
bhy vpett{ tbe{ gnce tbeg}ejqe},‒Ybnt k} th `e kltejjkielt ka th clhy bhy th dh ybnt
hle ynlt} th dh* nld th dh kt peventedj{* k} lht th `e
kltejjkielt8 ]hge }n{ tbnt tbe ph}e'}eed dhe} lht ynlt th
iphy klth n ph}e'`u}b, Yb{* tbel* kl tbe lnge ha njj tbnt
k} pen}hln`je* dhe} kt iphy8 Jkcej{ elhuib kt k} ulnynpe ha
tbe ynlt tbnt k} }vuppkli kt hl th nmtkhl, Ye bnqe lh
pen}hl th }uvvh}e tbnt n bugnl eg`p{h clhy} tbnt kt
ynlt} th iphy klth n `n`{* hp n `n`{ klth n gnl, Lhtbkli
eqep }bhy} }kil} ha clhykli ybnt kt k} ektbep ynltkli hp
dhkli* ybel kt} mhlqkmtkhl} `htb n} th ybnt kt ynlt}* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 342/378
Epeybhl
=40 ha =9;
bhy th iet kt* bnqe `eel }ettjed `e{hld auptbep vhyep ha
~ue}tkhl, Tbe je}} }kil} jkqkli mpentupe} ikqe ha clhykliybnt tbe{ dh* vphqkded tbe{ dh kt* nld dh kt peventedj{
nld yejj* tbe ipentep vphha tbe{ ikqe tbnt kl penjkt{ tbe{
clhy bhy th dh kt* nld bnqe dhle kt njpend{ hl nl klaklkte
lug`ep ha vn}t hmmn}khl},
‒]hge hle gn{ }n{*‛ be mhltklued* ‒‒Ybnt dh {hu
genl `{ tnjckli n`hut nl klaklkte lug`ep ha vn}thmmn}khl}8 Ybel dkd n ph}e'}eed gnce kt}eja klth n ph}e'
`u}b hl nl{ vn}t hmmn}khl8‛
‒K nl}yep tbk} ~ue}tkhl yktb nlhtbep, ‒Dkd tbe ph}e'}eed
eqep ahpg vnpt ha tbe kdeltkt{ ha tbe ph}e'`u}b hl ybkmb kt
ipey8‛ Ybh mnl }n{ tbnt kt dkd lht8 Ninkl K n}c? ‒Yn} tbk}
ph}e'`u}b eqep jklced `{ njj tbh}e jklc} tbnt ye mhgghlj{mhl}kdep n} mhl}tktutkli vep}hlnj kdeltkt{* yktb tbe }eed
aphg ybkmb kt kl kt} tupl ipey8‛ Ybh mnl }n{ tbnt kt yn}
lht8
‒Tbel* ka ph}e'}eed lug`ep tyh k} n mhltkluntkhl ha tbe
vep}hlnjkt{ ha kt} vnpelt ph}e'`u}b* nld ka tbnt ph}e'`u}b k}
n mhltkluntkhl ha tbe vep}hlnjkt{ ha tbe ph}e'}eed aphg
ybkmb kt }vpnli* ph}e'}eed lug`ep tyh gu}t nj}h `e n
mhltkluntkhl ha tbe vep}hlnjkt{ ha tbe enpjkep ph}e'}eed,
Nld tbk} ph}e'}eed gu}t `e n mhltkluntkhl ha tbe
vep}hlnjkt{ ha tbe vpemedkli ph}e'}eed—nld }h `nmc nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 343/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 344/378
Epeybhl
=44 ha =9;
}uvvh}ktkhl tbnt tbepe k} nl n`kdkli geghp{ `etyeel
}umme}}kqe ielepntkhl},‛‒Ykjj nl{ hle `pkli nl erngvje ha nl{ jkqkli mpentupe
ybh}e nmtkhl ye mnl uldep}tnld* vepahpgkli nl kleaan`j{
dkaakmujt nld kltpkmnte nmtkhl* tkge natep tkge* yktb
klqnpkn`je }umme}}* nld {et lht clhykli bhy th dh kt* nld
leqep bnqkli dhle kt `eahpe8 ]bhy ge tbe erngvje nld K
ykjj }n{ lh ghpe* `ut ultkj kt k} }bhyl ge* K }bnjj mpedktnmtkhl ybepe K mnllht yntmb kt* yktb `ekli mhltphjjed `{
tbe }nge jny} n} ybel kt k} yktbkl hup cel, Kt ykjj `emhge
ulmhl}mkhu} n} }hhl n} tbe }ckjj tbnt dkpemt} kt bn} `emhge
vepaemted, Lektbep ph}e'}eed* tbepeahpe* lhp eg`p{h
}bhujd `e ervemted th }bhy }kil} ha clhykli tbnt tbe{
clhy ybnt tbe{ clhy—ka tbe{ }bhyed }umb }kil} tbe anmtha tbekp clhykli ybnt tbe{ ynlt* nld bhy th iet kt*
gkibt ghpe pen}hln`j{ `e dhu`ted,‛
]hge ha tbe vn}}nie} njpend{ ikqel kl Mbnvtep RRKKK
yepe h`qkhu}j{ kl}vkped `{ tbe hle ou}t ~uhted, N} K pend
kt* kl n pevpklt }bhyl ge `{ n Vphae}}hp ybh bnd edkted
gumb ha tbe enpj{ jktepntupe hl tbe }u`oemt* K mhujd lht `ut
pegeg`ep tbe hle kl ybkmb hup Jhpd tejj} Bk} dk}mkvje} th
mhl}kdep tbe jkjke} ha tbe akejd* ybh lektbep thkj lhp }vkl*
`ut ybh}e pnkgelt }upvn}}e} eqel tbnt ha ]hjhghl kl njj
bk} ijhp{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 345/378
Epeybhl
=45 ha =9;
‒Tbe{ thkj lht* lektbep dh tbe{ }vkl8‛ K} tbnt }h8 ‒Thkj
lht8‛ Vepbnv} lht* lhy tbnt tbe getbhd ha vphmedupe k} }hyejj clhyl n} th ndgkt ha lh auptbep ~ue}tkhl—`ut kt k}
lht jkcej{ tbnt jkjke} mnge th gnce tbeg}ejqe} }h
`enutkaujj{ yktbhut bnqkli eqep tncel nl{ vnkl} n`hut tbe
gnttep, ‒Lektbep dh tbe{ }vkl8‛ Lht yktb n }vkllkli'
ybeej3 `ut k} tbepe lh tertkje an`pkm kl n jena8
Ybnt yhujd tbe jkjke} ha tbe akejd }n{ ka tbe{ benpd hleha u} demjnpkli tbnt tbe{ lektbep thkj lhp }vkl8 Tbe{ yhujd
}n{* K tnce kt* gumb ybnt ye }bhujd ka ye yepe th benp ha
tbekp vpenmbkli bugkjkt{ hl tbe tert ha ]hjhghl}* nld
}n{kli* ‒Mhl}kdep tbe ]hjhghl} kl njj tbekp ijhp{* tbe{ thkj
lht lektbep dh tbe{ }vkl,‛ Ye }bhujd }n{ tbnt tbe jkjke}
yepe tnjckli n`hut tbkli} tbnt tbe{ dkd lht uldep}tnld*nld tbnt tbhuib tbe ]hjhghl} dh lht thkj lhp }vkl* {et
tbepe bnd `eel lh jnmc ha ektbep thkjkli hp }vkllkli `eahpe
tbe{ mnge th `e nppn{ed }h ihpiehu}j{,
Jet ge lhy petupl th tbe Vphae}}hp, K bnqe }nkd elhuib
th }bhy tbe ielepnj dpkat ha tbe npiugelt} hl ybkmb be
pejked kl hpdep th }bhy tbnt qeietn`je} npe hlj{ nlkgnj}
uldep nlhtbep lnge* `ut bnqe lht }tnted bk} mn}e kl
nl{tbkli jkce tbe aujjle}} yktb ybkmb be jnkd kt `eahpe tbe
vu`jkm, Tbe mhlmju}khl be dpey* hp vpetelded th dpny*
yn} tbnt ka kt yn} }klauj th ckjj nld ent nlkgnj}* kt yn} lht
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 346/378
Epeybhl
=41 ha =9;
je}} }klauj th dh tbe jkce `{ qeietn`je}* hp tbekp }eed},
Lhle }umb* be }nkd* }bhujd `e entel* }nqe ybnt bnd dked nlntupnj dentb* }umb n} apukt tbnt yn} j{kli hl tbe iphuld
nld n`hut th pht* hp mn``nie' jenqe} tbnt bnd tupled
{ejjhy kl jnte nutugl, Tbe}e nld htbep jkce inp`nie be
demjnped th `e tbe hlj{ ahhd tbnt gkibt `e entel yktb n
mjenp mhl}mkelme, Eqel }h tbe entep gu}t vjnlt tbe vkv} ha
nl{ nvvje} hp venp} tbnt be gn{ bnqe entel* hp nl{ vjug'}thle}* mbepp{' }thle}* nld tbe jkce* hp be yhujd mhge
lenp th klmuppkli tbe iukjt ha klanltkmkde, Tbe ipnkl ha
mepenj}* nmmhpdkli th bkg* yn} hut ha tbe ~ue}tkhl* ahp
eqep{ }umb ipnkl bnd n jkqkli }huj n} gumb n} gnl bnd* nld
bnd n} ihhd n pkibt n} gnl th vh}}e}} tbnt }huj kl venme,
Bnqkli tbu} dpkqel bk} aejjhy mhultp{gel klth nmhplep nt tbe vhklt ha n jhikmnj `n{hlet aphg ybkmb tbe{
aejt tbnt tbepe yn} lh e}mnve* be vphvh}ed tbnt tbe
~ue}tkhl ybnt yn} th `e dhle }bhujd `e peaepped th nl
hpnmje kl ybkmb tbe ybhje mhultp{ bnd tbe ipente}t
mhlakdelme* nld th ybkmb pemhup}e yn} njyn{} bnd kl tkge}
ha }vemknj vepvjerkt{, Kt yn} ybk}veped tbnt n lenp pejntkhl
ha tbe vbkjh}hvbep‛} yn} jnd{‛}'gnkd th tbe vpke}te}} ybh
dejkqeped tbe hpnmje* nld tbe Vupktnl vnpt{ demjnped tbnt
tbe }tpnliej{ ule~ukqhmnj nl}yep ha tbe hpnmje yn}
h`tnkled `{ `nmc}tnkp} klajuelme3 `ut ybetbep tbk} yn} }h
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 347/378
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 348/378
Epeybhl
=42 ha =9;
Epeybhlknl} ahp n jhli tkge }u}vkmkhu} ha vphvbet}
ybetbep tbe{ vphae}}ed th bnqe mhggulkmntkhl} yktb nlul}eel vhyep hp lh3 `ut }h elipnkled kl tbe bugnl benpt
k} tbe de}kpe th `ejkeqe tbnt }hge vehvje penjj{ dh clhy
ybnt tbe{ }n{ tbe{ clhy* nld mnl tbu} }nqe tbeg aphg tbe
tphu`je ha tbklckli ahp tbeg}ejqe}* tbnt kl n }bhpt tkge
yhujd'`e vbkjh}hvbep} nld anddk}t} `emnge ghpe vhyepauj
tbnl eqep* nld ipndunjj{ jed tbekp mhultp{gel th nmmevt njjtbh}e n`}upd qkey} ha jkae* }hge nmmhult ha ybkmb K bnqe
ikqel kl g{ enpjkep mbnvtep}, Kldeed K mnl }ee lh bhve ahp
tbe Epeybhlknl} tkjj tbe{ bnqe iht th uldep}tnld tbnt
pen}hl ulmhppemted `{ kl}tklmt k} n} `nd n} kl}tklmt
ulmhppemted `{ pen}hl,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 349/378
Epeybhl
=4; ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRQKKK? E]MNVE
Tbhuib `u}kj{ elinied kl tpnl}jntkli tbe ertpnmt} ikqel
kl tbe jn}t akqe mbnvtep}* K yn} nj}h jn{kli gnttep} kl tpnkl
ahp g{ e}mnve yktb Nphybeln, Nld kldeed kt yn} bkib
tkge* ahp K pemekqed nl kltkgntkhl aphg hle ha tbe mn}bkep}
ha tbe Gu}kmnj @nlc}* tbnt K yn} th `e vph}emuted kl n
mpkgklnj mhupt h}tel}k`j{ ahp gen}je}* `ut penjj{ ahp bnqkli
hyled n yntmb* nld nttegvted tbe pekltphdumtkhl ha
gnmbklep{,
K n}ced yb{ gen}je}8 nld yn} thjd tbnt tbepe yn} n aenp
je}t erteluntkli mkpmug}tnlme} }bhujd vpeqelt n oup{ aphg
mhlqkmtkli ge* ka K yepe kldkmted ahp t{vbu} hp }gnjj'vhr*
`ut tbnt n qepdkmt yhujd vph`n`j{ `e h`tnkled ahp gen}je}*
n dk}en}e ybkmb mhujd `e }uaakmkeltj{ vulk}bed kl n vep}hl
ha g{ nie, K yn} ikqel th uldep}tnld tbnt ulje}} }hge
ulervemted mbnlie }bhujd mhge hqep tbe gkld ha bk}
Gnoe}t{* K gkibt ervemt tbe `jhy th `e }tpumc yktbkl n
qep{ aey dn{},
G{ vjnl yn} tbk}—tbnt Nphybeln nld K }bhujd e}mnve
kl n `njjhhl thietbep, K aenp tbnt tbe pendep ykjj dk}`ejkeqe
tbk} vnpt ha g{ }thp{* {et kl lh htbep bnqe K eldenqhuped
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 350/378
Epeybhl
=56 ha =9;
th ndbepe ghpe mhl}mkeltkhu}j{ th anmt}* nld mnl hlj{
tbphy g{}eja uvhl bk} mbnpkt{,K bnd njpend{ inkled tbe enp ha tbe ^ueel* nld bnd }h
yhpced uvhl bep mupkh}kt{ tbnt }be vphgk}ed th iet jenqe
ahp ge th bnqe n `njjhhl gnde nld klajnted3 K vhklted hut
th bep tbnt lh mhgvjkmnted gnmbklep{ yhujd `e ynlted—
lhtbkli* kl anmt* `ut n jnpie ~unltkt{ ha hkjed }kjc* n mnp* n
aey phve}* !m,* !m,* nld }hge jkibt ckld ha in}* }umb n}tbe nltk~unpknl} ybh yepe nm~unklted yktb tbe genl}
egvjh{ed `{ tbe nlmkelt} ahp tbe vphdumtkhl ha tbe jkibtep
in}e} mhujd en}kj{ kl}tpumt bep yhpcgel bhy th vphqkde,
Bep enieple}} th }ee }h }tpnlie n }kibt n} tbe n}melt ha n
bugnl `ekli klth tbe }c{ hqepmnge nl{ }mpuvje} ha
mhl}mkelme tbnt }be gkibt bnqe htbepyk}e aejt* nld }be }ettbe nltk~unpknl} n`hut }bhykli bep yhpcgel bhy th
gnce tbe in}* nld }elt bep gnkd} th `u{* nld hkj* n qep{
jnpie ~unltkt{ ha }kjc ahp K yn} detepgkled tbnt tbe
`njjhhl }bhujd `e n `ki hle+ eqel `eahpe }be `einl th tp{
nld inkl tbe Ckli‛} vepgk}}khl3 tbk}* bhyeqep* }be lhy }et
bep}eja th dh* ahp K bnd }elt bep yhpd tbnt g{ vph}emutkhl
yn} kggklelt,
N} ahp g{}eja* K leed bnpdj{ }n{ tbnt K cley lhtbkli
n`hut `njjhhl}3 lhp dkd K }ee g{ yn{ th }guiijkli
Nphybeln klth tbe mnp3 leqeptbeje}}* clhykli tbnt ye bnd
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 351/378
Epeybhl
=5> ha =9;
lh htbep mbnlme ha iettkli nyn{ aphg Epeybhl* K dpey
kl}vkpntkhl aphg tbe ertpegkt{ kl ybkmb ye yepe vjnmed*nld gnde n vnttepl aphg ybkmb tbe ^ueel‛} yhpcgel
yepe n`je th yhpc }umme}}aujj{, Genlybkje tbe ^ueel‛}
mnppknie'`ukjdep} }et n`hut gnckli tbe mnp* nld kt yn} yktb
tbe nttnmbgelt} ha tbk} th tbe `njjhhl tbnt K bnd tbe
ipente}t dkaakmujt{3 K dhu`t* kldeed* ybetbep K }bhujd bnqe
}ummeeded bepe* `ut ahp tbe ipent kltejjkielme ha n ahpegnl*ybh tbpey bkg}eja benpt nld }huj klth tbe gnttep* nld
hatel `htb ahpe}ny pe~ukpegelt}* tbe leme}}kt{ ahp ybkmb
bnd e}mnved ge* nld }uiie}ted tbe genl} ha vphqkdkli ahp
tbeg,
Kt bnvveled tbnt tbepe bnd `eel n jhli dphuibt* dupkli
tbe jnttep vnpt ha ybkmb vpn{ep} bnd `eel qnklj{ haaeped uvkl njj tbe tegvje} ha tbe nkp ihd, Ybel K akp}t thjd bep
Gnoe}t{ tbnt K ynlted n `njjhhl* K }nkd g{ klteltkhl yn} th
ih uv klth tbe }c{ nld vpeqnkj uvhl tbe nkp ihd `{ genl}
ha n vep}hlnj kltepqkey, K hyl tbnt tbk} vphvh}ktkhl
`hpdeped hl tbe kdhjntphu}* `ut K bnqe jhli }klme pevelted
ha kt* nld ng jkttje jkcej{ eqep th pevent tbe haaelme,
Ghpehqep tbe demekt* }epkhu} tbhuib kt yn}* ykjj vph`n`j{
jend th tbe mhlqep}khl ha tbe ybhje mhultp{,
Ybel tbe ^ueel thjd bk} Gnoe}t{ ha g{ vphvh}nj* be
nt akp}t lht hlj{ pkdkmujed kt* `ut yn} klmjkled th qeth kt,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 352/378
Epeybhl
=50 ha =9;
@ekli* bhyeqep* n qep{ urhpkhu} bu}`nld* be nt jelitb
mhl}elted—n} be eqeltunjj{ njyn{} dkd th eqep{tbkli hlybkmb tbe ^ueel bnd }et bep benpt, Be {kejded njj tbe
ghpe pendkj{ lhy* `emnu}e be dkd lht `ejkeqe kl tbe
vh}}k`kjkt{ ha g{ n}melt3 be yn} mhlqklmed tbnt eqel
tbhuib tbe `njjhhl }bhujd ghult n aey aeet klth tbe nkp* kt
yhujd mhjjnv}e kggedkntej{* ybepehl K }bhujd anjj nld
`penc g{ lemc* nld be }bhujd `e pkd ha ge, Bedeghl}tpnted tbk} th bep }h mhlqklmklij{* tbnt }be yn}
njnpged* nld tpked th tnjc ge klth ikqkli uv tbe kden* `ut
hl akldkli tbnt K vep}k}ted kl g{ yk}b th bnqe tbe `njjhhl
gnde* }be vphdumed nl hpdep aphg tbe Ckli th tbe eaaemt
tbnt njj anmkjktke} K gkibt pe~ukpe }bhujd `e naahpded ge,
Nt tbe }nge tkge bep Gnoe}t{ thjd ge tbnt g{nttegvted n}melt yhujd `e gnde nl nptkmje ha
kgvenmbgelt ninkl}t ge kl mn}e K dkd lht }ummeed kl
vpeqnkjkli hl tbe nkp ihd th }thv tbe dphuibt, Lektbep
Ckli lhp ^ueel bnd nl{ kden tbnt K genlt ihkli pkibt
nyn{ ka K mhujd iet tbe ykld th tnce ge* lhp bnd be nl{
mhlmevtkhl ha tbe erk}telme ha n meptnkl }tend{ uvvep
muppelt ha nkp ybkmb yn} njyn{} }ettkli kl hle dkpemtkhl* n}
mhujd `e }eel `{ tbe }bnve ha tbe bkibep mjhud}* ybkmb
vhklted klqnpkn`j{ aphg }hutb'en}t th lhptb' ye}t, K bnd
g{}eja jhli lhtkmed tbk} vemujknpkt{ kl tbe mjkgnte* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 353/378
Epeybhl
=5= ha =9;
nttpk`uted kt* K `ejkeqe ou}tj{* th n tpnde'ykld ybkmb yn}
mhl}tnlt nt n aey tbhu}nld aeet n`hqe tbe enptb* `ut yn}dk}tup`ed `{ jhmnj klajuelme} nt jhyep ejeqntkhl},
G{ lert `u}kle}} yn} th `penc tbe vjnl th Nphybeln*
nld th deqk}e tbe genl} ahp iettkli bep klth tbe mnp, K aejt
}upe tbnt }be yhujd mhge yktb ge* `ut bnd gnde uv g{
gkld tbnt ka bep mhupnie ankjed bep* tbe ybhje tbkli }bhujd
mhge th lhtbkli, Nphybeln nld K bnd `eel kl mhl}tnltmhggulkmntkhl tbphuib bep gnkd* `ut K bnd tbhuibt kt
`e}t lht th tejj bep tbe detnkj} ha g{ }mbege tkjj eqep{tbkli
yn} }ettjed, Tbe tkge bnd lhy nppkqed* nld K nppnlied
yktb tbe gnkd tbnt K }bhujd `e ndgktted `{ n vpkqnte dhhp
klth Gp, Lh}lk`hp‛} inpdel nt n`hut du}c hl tbe
ahjjhykli eqelkli,K mnge nt tbe nvvhklted tkge3 tbe ikpj jet ge klth tbe
inpdel nld `nde ge ynkt kl n }emjuded njje{ ultkj
Nphybeln }bhujd mhge, Kt yn} lhy enpj{ }uggep* nld
tbe jenqe} yepe }h tbkmc uvhl tbe tpee} tbnt eqel tbhuib
}hge hle ej}e bnd elteped tbe inpdel K mhujd bnqe en}kj{
bkddel g{}eja, Tbe lkibt yn} hle ha ertpege `enut{3 tbe
}ul bnd jhli }et* `ut tbepe yn} }tkjj n ph}{ ijeng kl tbe }c{
hqep tbe pukl} ha tbe pnkjyn{ }tntkhl3 `ejhy ge yn} tbe
mkt{ njpend{ tyklcjkli yktb jkibt}* ybkje `e{hld kt
}tpetmbed tbe vjnkl} ahp gnl{ n jeniue ultkj tbe{ `jelded
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 354/378
Epeybhl
=54 ha =9;
yktb tbe }c{, K ou}t lhted tbe}e tbkli}* `ut K mhujd lht
beed tbeg, K mhujd beed lhtbkli* tkjj* n} K veeped klth tbednpcle}} ha tbe njje{* K vepmekqed n ybkte akiupe ijkdkli
}ykatj{ thynpd} ge, K `hulded thynpd} kt* nld epe tbhuibt
mhujd ektbep vphgvt hp mbemc* K bnd mnuibt Nphybeln th
g{ benpt nld mhqeped bep ulpe}k}tkli mbeec yktb ck}}e},
]h hqepoh{ed yepe ye tbnt ye cley lht bhy th }venc3
kldeed K dh lht clhy ybel ye }bhujd bnqe ahuld yhpd}nld mhge th hup }el}e}* ka tbe gnkd bnd lht ihle haa klth
n akt ha b{}tepkm}* nld nynceled u} th tbe leme}}kt{ ha }eja'
mhltphj3 tbel* `pkeaj{ nld vjnklj{* K ulahjded ybnt K
vphvh}ed3 K }bhyed bep tbe dnpce}t }kde* ahp K aejt }upe tbnt
tbe dnpcep tbe vph}vemt tbe ghpe jkcej{ }be yn} th mhge, K
thjd bep tbnt g{ vjnl yhujd vph`n`j{ eld kl dentb ahp `htb ha u}* nld tbnt K dnped lht vpe}} kt—tbnt nt n yhpd
aphg bep kt }bhujd `e n`nldhled3 }tkjj tbnt tbepe yn} ou}t n
vh}}k`kjkt{ ha hup e}mnvkli thietbep th }hge vnpt ha tbe
yhpjd ybepe tbepe yhujd `e lh `np th hup iettkli
gnppked* nld tbnt K mhujd }ee lh htbep bhve,
]be gnde lh pe}k}tnlme* lht n }kil hp bklt ha dhu`t hp
be}ktntkhl, ]be yhujd dh njj K thjd bep* nld mhge
ybeleqep K yn} pend{3 }h K `nde bep }eld bep gnkd th
geet ge lkibtj{—thjd bep tbnt }be gu}t vut n ihhd anme
hl* jhhc n} `pkibt nld bnvv{ n} }be mhujd* }h n} th gnce
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 355/378
Epeybhl
=55 ha =9;
bep antbep nld ghtbep nld _ujhpn tbklc tbnt }be yn}
ahpiettkli ge—nld `e pend{ nt n ghgelt‛} lhtkme thmhge th tbe ^ueel‛} yhpc}bhv}* nld `e mhlmenjed nghli
tbe `njjn}t nld uldep pui} kl tbe mnp ha tbe `njjhhl3 nld }h
ye vnpted,
K buppked g{ vpevnpntkhl} ahpynpd* ahp K aenped pnkl* nld
nj}h tbnt tbe Ckli gkibt mbnlie bk} gkld3 `ut tbe yentbep
mhltklued dp{* nld kl nlhtbep yeec tbe ^ueel‛}yhpcgel bnd aklk}bed tbe `njjhhl nld mnp* ybkje tbe in}
yn} pend{ th `e tupled hl klth tbe `njjhhl nt nl{
ghgelt, Njj `ekli lhy vpevnped K yn} th n}meld hl tbe
ahjjhykli ghplkli, K bnd }tkvujnted ahp `ekli njjhyed th
tnce n`uldnlme ha pui} nld ypnvvkli} n} vphtemtkhl aphg
tbe mhjd ha tbe uvvep ntgh}vbepe* nld nj}h tel hp n dhzelihhd'}kzed `ni} ha `njjn}t,
K bnd lenpj{ n ~unptep‛} vel}khl kl bnld* nld yktb tbk} K
aee‛d Nphybeln‛} gnkd* nld `pk`ed tbe ^ueel‛}
ahpegnl—ybh yhujd* K `ejkeqe* bnqe ikqel ge n}}k}tnlme
eqel yktbhut n `pk`e, Be bejved ge th }empete ahhd nld
ykle kl tbe `ni} ha `njjn}t* nld hl tbe ghplkli ha g{
n}melt be cevt tbe htbep yhpcgel hut ha tbe yn{ ybkje K
iht Nphybeln klth tbe mnp, ]be mnge yktb enpj{ dnyl*
guaajed uv* nld kl bep gnkd‛} dpe}}, ]be yn} }uvvh}ed th
`e ihle th nl enpj{ vepahpgnlme nt hle ha tbe Gu}kmnj
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 356/378
Epeybhl
=51 ha =9;
@nlc}* nld thjd ge tbnt }be }bhujd lht `e gk}}ed tkjj
`pencan}t* `ut tbnt bep n`}elme gu}t tbel `e dk}mhqeped, Knppnlied tbe `njjn}t n`hut bep }h tbnt kt }bhujd mhlmenj bep
n} }be jn{ nt tbe `htthg ha tbe mnp* nld mhqeped bep yktb
ypnvvkli}, Njtbhuib kt }tkjj ynlted }hge bhup} ha tbe tkge
akred ahp g{ n}melt* K mhujd lht tpu}t g{}eja hle ghgelt
aphg tbe mnp* }h K iht klth kt nt hlme* nld yntmbed tbe
ipndunj klajntkhl ha tbe `njjhhl, Juiinie K bnd lhle* }nqetbe vphqk}khl} bkddel kl tbe `njjn}t `ni}* tbe `hhc} ha
g{tbhjhi{* nld tbe tpentk}e} hl tbe gnmbkle}* yktb g{
hyl gnlu}mpkvt dknpke} nld tpnl}jntkhl},
K }nt ~uketj{* nld nynkted tbe bhup akred ahp g{
devnptupe—~uket hutynpdj{* `ut klynpdj{ K yn} kl nl
nihl{ ha }u}vel}e je}t Nphybeln‛} n`}elme }bhujd `edk}mhqeped `eahpe tbe nppkqnj ha tbe Ckli nld ^ueel* ybh
yepe th yktle}} g{ n}melt, Tbe{ yepe lht due {et ahp
nlhtbep tyh bhup}* nld dupkli tbk} tkge n buldped tbkli}
gkibt bnvvel* nl{ hle ha ybkmb yhujd uldh ge,
Nt jn}t tbe `njjhhl yn} aujj3 tbe vkve ybkmb bnd akjjed kt
yn} peghqed* tbe e}mnve ha tbe in} bnqkli `eel akp}t
mnpeaujj{ vpemjuded, Lhtbkli pegnkled th bkldep tbe
`njjhhl aphg n}meldkli `ut tbe bnld} nld yekibt ha tbh}e
ybh yepe bhjdkli hl th kt yktb phve}, K }tpnkled g{ e{e}
ahp tbe mhgkli ha tbe Ckli nld ^ueel* `ut mhujd }ee lh
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 357/378
Epeybhl
=59 ha =9;
}kil ha tbekp nvvphnmb, K jhhced kl tbe dkpemtkhl ha Gp,
Lh}lk`hp‛} bhu}e—tbepe yn} lhtbkli th kldkmntedk}tup`nlme* `ut kt yn} lht {et `pencan}t tkge, Tbe mphyd
`einl th intbep3 tbe{ yepe nynpe tbnt K yn} uldep tbe
dk}vjen}upe ha tbe mhupt* `ut K mhujd detemt lh }kil} ha g{
`ekli ulvhvujnp, Hl tbe mhltpnp{* K pemekqed gnl{ ckldj{
ervpe}}khl} ha peinpd nld elmhupniegelt* yktb ihhd
yk}be} n} th tbe pe}ujt ha g{ ohuple{,K yn} }venckli th hle ieltjegnl ha g{ nm~unkltnlme*
nld tejjkli bkg tbe }u`}tnlme ha ybnt K kltelded th dh
ybel K bnd iht klth tbe vpe}elme ha tbe nkp ihd ybnt be
tbhuibt ha ge K mnllht iue}}* ahp K ng }upe tbnt be dkd lht
`ejkeqe kl tbe h`oemtkqe erk}telme ha tbe nkp ihd* lhp tbnt K
g{}eja `ejkeqed kl kt+* ybel K `emnge nynpe ha n }gnjjmphyd ha vehvje pullkli n} an}t n} tbe{ mhujd aphg Gp,
Lh}lk`hp‛} bhu}e thynpd} tbe ^ueel‛} yhpc}bhv}, Ahp tbe
ghgelt g{ vuj}e men}ed `entkli* nld tbel* clhykli tbnt
tbe tkge bnd mhge ybel K gu}t ektbep dh hp dke* K mnjjed
qebegeltj{ th tbh}e ybh yepe bhjdkli tbe phve} }hge
tbkpt{ gel+ th jet ih nt hlme* nld gnde ie}tupe} }kilka{kli
dnliep* nld tbnt tbepe yhujd `e gk}mbkea ka tbe{ bejd hl
jhliep, Gnl{ h`e{ed3 tbe pe}t yepe thh yenc th bhjd hl
th tbe phve}* nld yepe ahpmed th jet tbeg ih, Hl tbk} tbe
`njjhhl `hulded }uddelj{ uvynpd}* `ut g{ hyl aeejkli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 358/378
Epeybhl
=52 ha =9;
yn} tbnt tbe enptb bnd dphvved haa aphg ge* nld yn}
}klckli an}t klth tbe hvel }vnme `elentb,Tbk} bnvveled nt tbe qep{ ghgelt tbnt tbe ntteltkhl ha
tbe mphyd yn} dkqkded* tbe hle bnja vn{kli beed th tbe
eniep ie}tupe} ha tbh}e mhgkli aphg Gp, Lh}lk`hp‛}
bhu}e* nld tbe htbep th tbe ermjngntkhl} aphg g{}eja, N
gklute ghpe nld Nphybeln yhujd dhu`tje}} bnqe `eel
dk}mhqeped* `ut `eahpe tbnt gklute yn} hqep* K yn} nt }umbn bekibt n`hqe tbe mkt{ tbnt lhtbkli mhujd bnpg ge* nld
eqep{ }emhld `htb tbe thyl nld tbe mphyd `emnge
}gnjjep nld ghpe mhlau}ed, Kl nl klmpedk`j{ }bhpt tkge* K
mhujd }ee jkttje `ut n qn}t ynjj ha `jue vjnkl} pk}kli uv
ninkl}t ge* thynpd} ybkmbeqep }kde K jhhced,
Nt akp}t* tbe `njjhhl ghulted qeptkmnjj{ uvynpd}* `utnatep n`hut akqe gklute}* ybel ye bnd njpend{ nttnkled n
qep{ ipent ejeqntkhl* K anlmked tbnt tbe h`oemt} hl tbe vjnkl
`elentb `einl th ghqe aphg uldep ge, K dkd lht aeej }h
gumb n} n `pentb ha ykld* nld mhujd lht }uvvh}e tbnt tbe
`njjhhl kt}eja yn} tpnqejjkli, K yn}* tbepeahpe* yhldepkli
ybnt tbk} }tpnlie ghqegelt ha akred h`oemt} mhujd genl*
ybel kt }tpumc ge tbnt vehvje kl n `njjhhl dh lht aeej tbe
ykld kln}gumb n} tbe{ tpnqej yktb kt nld haaep kt lh
pe}k}tnlme, Tbel K yn} bnvv{ kl tbklckli tbnt K gu}t lhy
bnqe penmbed tbe klqnpkn`je tpnde ykld ha tbe uvvep nkp*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 359/378
Epeybhl
=5; ha =9;
nld tbnt K }bhujd `e qep{ vh}}k`j{ ynated ahp buldped} hp
eqel tbhu}nld} ha gkje}* anp aphg Epeybhl nld tbeEpeybhlknl},
Njpend{ K bnd peghqed tbe ypnvvkli} nld apeed
Nphybeln3 `ut K }hhl mhqeped bep uv yktb tbeg ninkl*
ahp kt yn} njpend{ qep{ mhjd* nld }be yn} bnja }tuveaked
yktb tbe }tpnliele}} ha bep vh}ktkhl,
Nld lhy `einl n tkge* dpeng'jkce nld dejkpkhu}* ha ybkmb K dh lht }uvvh}e tbnt K }bnjj eqep pemhqep n dk}tklmt
pemhjjemtkhl, ]hge tbkli} K mnl pemnjj—n} tbnt ye yepe epe
jhli elqejhved kl qnvhup ybkmb aphze uvhl g{
ghu}tnmbe nld ybk}cep}3 tbel mhge} n geghp{ ha }kttkli
ahp bhup} nld bhup} kl n tbkmc ahi* benpkli lh }huld `ut
g{ hyl `pentbkli nld Nphybeln‛} ahp ye bnpdj{ }vhce+nld }eekli lh }kibt `ut tbe mnp `elentb u} nld `e}kde u}*
nld tbe dnpc `njjhhl n`hqe,
Vepbnv} tbe gh}t vnklauj aeejkli ybel tbe enptb yn}
bkddel yn} tbnt tbe `njjhhl yn} ghtkhlje}}* tbhuib hup
hlj{ bhve jn{ kl hup ihkli ahpynpd yktb nl ertpege ha
}veed, Aphg tkge th tkge tbphuib n pkat kl tbe mjhud} K
mnuibt n ijkgv}e ha enptb* nld yn} tbnlcauj th vepmekqe
tbnt ye gu}t `e aj{kli ahpynpd an}tep tbnl kl nl ervpe}}
tpnkl3 `ut lh }hhlep yn} tbe pkat mjh}ed tbnl tbe hjd
mhlqkmtkhl ha hup `ekli }tntkhlnp{ petupled kl aujj ahpme*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 360/378
Epeybhl
=16 ha =9;
nld yn} lht th `e pen}hled yktb? tbepe yn} nlhtbep aeejkli
nj}h ybkmb yn} lenpj{ n} `nd3 ahp n} n mbkjd tbnt aenp} kt bn}ihle `jkld kl n jhli tullej ka tbepe k} lh jkibt* }h epe tbe
enptb bnd `eel gnl{ gklute} bkddel* K `emnge bnja
apkibteled je}t ye gkibt lht bnqe `phcel nyn{ aphg kt
mjenl nld ahp eqep, Lhy nld ninkl* K nte nld inqe ahhd th
Nphybeln* `ut `{ iue}}'yhpc n} peinpd} tkge, Tbel mnge
dnpcle}}* n dpendauj dpenp{ tkge* yktbhut eqel tbe ghhlth mbeep u},
Yktb dnyl tbe }mele yn} mbnlied? tbe mjhud} yepe
ihle nld ghplkli }tnp} yepe }bklkli3 tbe pk}kli ha tbe
}vjeldkd }ul pegnkl} }tkjj kgvpe}}ed uvhl ge n} tbe gh}t
ijhpkhu} tbnt K bnqe eqep }eel3 `elentb u} tbepe yn} nl
eg`h}}ed mbnkl ha ghultnkl} yktb }lhy ape}b anjjel uvhltbeg3 `ut ye yepe anp n`hqe tbeg3 ye `htb ha u} aejt hup
`pentbkli }epkhu}j{ naaemted* `ut K yhujd lht njjhy tbe
`njjhhl th de}meld n }klije klmb* lht clhykli ahp bhy
jhli ye gkibt lht leed njj tbe `uh{nlm{ ybkmb ye mhujd
mhggnld3 kldeed K yn} tbnlcauj th akld tbnt* natep lenpj{
ahup'nld'tyelt{ bhup}* ye yepe }tkjj nt }h ipent n bekibt
n`hqe tbe enptb,
Kl n mhuvje ha bhup} ye bnd vn}}ed tbe pnlie}* ybkmb
gu}t bnqe `eel }hge buldped nld akat{ gkje} nmph}}* nld
ninkl K }ny n tpnmt ha jeqej vjnkl erteldkli anp nyn{ th tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 361/378
Epeybhl
=1> ha =9;
bhpkzhl, K cley lht ybepe ye yepe* nld dnped lht
de}meld* je}t K }bhujd yn}te tbe vhyep ha tbe `njjhhl* `utK yn} bnja bhveauj tbnt ye gkibt `e n`hqe tbe mhultp{
aphg ybkmb K bnd hpkiklnjj{ }tnpted, K jhhced nlrkhu}j{ ahp
nl{ }kil `{ ybkmb K mhujd pemhilk}e kt* `ut mhujd }ee
lhtbkli* nld aenped tbnt ye gkibt `e n`hqe }hge dk}tnlt
vnpt ha Epeybhl* hp n mhultp{ klbn`kted `{ }nqnie}, Ybkje
K yn} }tkjj kl dhu`t* tbe `njjhhl yn} ninkl ypnvved klmjhud}* nld ye yepe jeat th `jnlc }vnme nld th mhloemtupe},
Tbe yenp{ tkge dpniied hl, Bhy K jhlied ahp g{
ulbnvv{ yntmb. K aejt n} tbhuib lht eqel tkge yn}
ghqkli* }h dug` nld }vejj'`huld yepe hup }upphuldkli},
]hgetkge} K yhujd aeej g{ vuj}e* nld mhult kt} `ent} ahp
bnja'nl'bhup thietbep3 nl{tbkli th gnpc tbe tkge—thvphqe tbnt kt yn} tbepe* nld th n}}upe g{}eja tbnt ye yepe
yktbkl tbe `je}}ed pnlie ha kt} klajuelme* nld lht ihle
ndpkat klth tbe tkgeje}}le}} ha eteplkt{,
K bnd `eel dhkli tbk} ahp tbe tyeltketb hp tbkptketb
tkge* nld bnd anjjel klth n jkibt }jeev? K dpenged ykjdj{ ha
n ohuple{ kl nl ervpe}} tpnkl* nld ha nppkqkli nt n pnkjyn{
}tntkhl ybepe tbe nkp yn} aujj ha tbe }huld ha jhmhghtkqe
elikle} `jhykli haa }teng yktb n bhppk`je nld tpegeldhu}
bk}}kli3 K yhce apkibteled nld ulen}{* `ut tbe bk}}kli nld
mpn}bkli lhk}e} vup}ued ge lhy tbnt K yn} nynce* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 362/378
Epeybhl
=10 ha =9;
ahpmed ge th hyl tbnt tbe{ yepe penj, Ybnt tbe{ yepe K
cley lht* `ut tbe{ ipey ipndunjj{ ankltep nld ankltep* nldnatep n tkge yepe jh}t, Kl n aey bhup} tbe mjhud} `phce*
nld K }ny `elentb ge tbnt ybkmb gnde tbe mbkjjed `jhhd
pul mhjdep kl g{ qekl}, K }ny tbe }en* nld lhtbkli `ut tbe
}en3 kl tbe gnkl `jnmc* `ut ajemced yktb ybkte bend} ha
}thpg'th}}ed* nlip{ ynqe},
Nphybeln yn} }jeevkli ~uketj{ nt tbe `htthg ha tbemnp* nld n} K jhhced nt bep }yeet nld }nkltj{ `enut{* K
iphnled* nld mup}ed g{}eja ahp tbe gk}ep{ klth ybkmb K
bnd `phuibt bep3 `ut tbepe yn} lhtbkli ahp kt lhy,
K }nt nld ynkted ahp tbe yhp}t* nld vpe}eltj{ K }ny }kil}
n} tbhuib tbnt yhp}t yepe }hhl th `e nt bnld* ahp tbe
`njjhhl bnd `eiul th }klc, Hl akp}t }eekli tbe }en K bnd`eel kgvpe}}ed yktb tbe kden tbnt ye gu}t bnqe `eel
anjjkli* `ut lhy tbepe mhujd `e lh gk}tnce* ye yepe
}klckli* nld tbnt an}t, K tbpey hut n `ni ha `njjn}t* nld ahp n
tkge ye ph}e ninkl* `ut kl tbe mhup}e ha n aey bhup} tbe
}klckli pemhggelmed* nld K tbpey hut nlhtbep `ni,
Tbel tbe `nttje mhggelmed kl enple}t, Kt jn}ted njj tbnt
nateplhhl nld tbphuib tbe lkibt ultkj tbe ahjjhykli
eqelkli, K bnd }eel leqep n }nkj lhp n }kil ha n }nkj* tbhuib
K bnd bnja `jklded g{}eja yktb }tpnklkli g{ e{e} klme}}nltj{
kl eqep{ dkpemtkhl3 ye bnd vnpted yktb eqep{tbkli `ut tbe
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 363/378
Epeybhl
=1= ha =9;
mjhtbe} ybkmb ye bnd uvhl hup `nmc}3 ahhd nld yntep
yepe ihle* njj tbphyl hut th tbe ybeejkli nj`ntph}}e}* klhpdep th }nqe u} n aey bhup} hp eqel gklute} aphg tbe }en,
K dkd lht tbphy nyn{ tbe `hhc} tkjj ye yepe yktbkl n aey
aeet ha tbe yntep* nld mjuli th g{ gnlu}mpkvt} th tbe qep{
jn}t, Bhve tbepe }eeged lhle ybnteqep—{et* }tpnliej{
elhuib ye yepe lektbep ha u} uttepj{ bhveje}}* nld eqel
ybel tbe eqkj tbnt ye dpended yn} uvhl u}* nld tbntybkmb ye ipentj{ aenped bnd mhge* ye }nt kl tbe mnp ha tbe
`njjhhl yktb tbe yntep} uv th hup gkddje* nld }tkjj }gkjed
yktb n ibn}tj{ bhveaujle}} th hle nlhtbep,
/ / /
Be ybh bn} mph}}ed tbe ]t, Ihtbnpd ykjj pegeg`ep tbnt
`ejhy Nldepgntt tbepe k} hle ha tbh}e Njvkle ihpie}ybkmb penmb tbe qep{ utgh}t jkgkt} ha tbe }u`jkge nld
teppk`je, Tbe aeejkli} ha tbe tpnqejjep bnqe `emhge ghpe
nld ghpe bkibj{ yphuibt nt eqep{ }tev* ultkj nt jn}t tbe
lnced nld hqepbnlikli vpemkvkme} }eeg th mjh}e n`hqe bk}
bend* n} be mph}}e} n `pkdie buli kl gkd'nkp hqep n phnpkli
yntepanjj* nld eltep} hl tbe dnpcle}} ha n tullej* beyl hut
ha tbe phmc,
Ybnt mnl `e kl }thpe ahp bkg hl egepikli8 ]upej{
}hgetbkli eqel ykjdep nld ghpe de}hjnte tbnl tbnt ybkmb
be bn} }eel njpend{3 {et bk} kgniklntkhl k} vnpnj{}ed* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 364/378
Epeybhl
=14 ha =9;
mnl }uiie}t lh anlm{ hp qk}khl ha nl{tbkli th }upvn}} tbe
penjkt{ ybkmb be bnd ou}t yktle}}ed, Nyed nld `pentbje}}be ndqnlme}3 ybel jh. tbe jkibt ha tbe nateplhhl }ul
yejmhge} bkg n} be jenqe} tbe tullej* nld `ebhjd n
}gkjkli qnjje{!-r06>43 n `n``jkli `phhc* n qkjjnie yktb
tnjj `ejapke}* nld gendhy} ha `pkjjknlt ipeel—tbe}e npe tbe
tbkli} ybkmb ipeet bkg* nld be }gkje} th bkg}eja n} tbe
tepphp vn}}e} nyn{ nld kl nlhtbep ghgelt k} ahpihttel,]h anped kt lhy yktb hup}ejqe}, Ye bnd `eel kl tbe
yntep }hge tyh hp tbpee bhup}* nld tbe lkibt bnd mhge
uvhl u}, Ye bnd }nkd anpeyejj ahp tbe buldpedtb tkge* nld
bnd pe}kiled hup}ejqe} th geet tbe eld3 kldeed K yn}
g{}eja `nttjkli yktb n dphy}kle}} aphg ybkmb kt yn} hlj{
thh vph`n`je tbnt K }bhujd leqep ynce3 ybel }uddelj{*Nphybeln thumbed ge hl tbe }bhujdep* nld vhklted th n
jkibt nld th n dnpc gn}} ybkmb yn} `enpkli pkibt uvhl u},
N mp{ ahp bejv—jhud nld mjenp nld }bpkjj—`phce ahptb
aphg `htb ha u} nt hlme3 nld kl nlhtbep akqe gklute} ye
yepe mnppked `{ ckld nld teldep bnld} hl th tbe demc ha
nl Ktnjknl qe}}ej,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 365/378
Epeybhl
=15 ha =9;
MBNVTEP RRKR? MHLMJU]KHL
Tbe }bkv yn} tbe Vpklmkve Ug`epth* `huld aphg
Mnjjnh th Ielhn3 }be bnd mnppked n lug`ep ha egkipnlt} th
Pkh* bnd ihle tbelme th Mnjjnh* ybepe }be bnd tncel kl n
mnpih ha iunlh* nld yn} lhy hl bep yn{ bhge, Tbe
mnvtnkl yn} n meptnkl Ikhqnllk Iknllk* n lntkqe ha ]e}tpk3
be bn} ckldj{ njjhyed ge th peaep th bkg kl mn}e tbe tputb
ha g{ }thp{ }bhujd `e dk}vuted3 `ut K ipkeqe th }n{ tbnt K
}uaaeped bkg th gk}jend bkg}eja kl }hge kgvhptnlt
vnptkmujnp}, K }bhujd ndd tbnt ybel ye yepe vkmced uv ye
yepe n tbhu}nld gkje} aphg jnld,
N} }hhl n} ye yepe hl `hnpd* tbe mnvtnkl `einl
~ue}tkhlkli u} n`hut tbe }keie ha Vnpk}* aphg ybkmb mkt{ be
bnd n}}uged tbnt ye gu}t bnqe mhge* lhtyktb}tnldkli
hup kggel}e dk}tnlme aphg Euphve, N} gn{ `e }uvvh}ed* K
bnd lht benpd n }{jjn`je n`hut tbe ynp `etyeel Apnlme nld
Iepgnl{* nld yn} thh kjj th dh ghpe tbnl n}}elt th njj tbnt
be mbh}e th vut klth g{ ghutb, G{ clhyjedie ha Ktnjknl
k} qep{ kgvepaemt* nld K intbeped jkttje aphg nl{tbkli tbnt
be }nkd3 `ut K yn} ijnd th mhlmenj tbe tpue vhklt ha hup
devnptupe* nld pe}hjqed th tnce nl{ mue tbnt be mbh}e th
ikqe ge,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 366/378
Epeybhl
=11 ha =9;
Tbe jkle tbnt tbu} }uiie}ted kt}eja yn} tbnt tbepe bnd
`eel tel hp tyejqe htbep} kl tbe `njjhhl* tbnt K yn} nlElijk}b Gkjhpd* nld Nphybeln n Pu}}knl Mhulte}}3 tbnt
njj tbe htbep} bnd `eel dphyled* nld tbnt tbe de}vntmbe}
ybkmb ye bnd mnppked yepe jh}t, K mnge natepynpd} th jenpl
tbnt tbk} }thp{ yhujd lht bnqe `eel mpedk`je* bnd lht tbe
mnvtnkl `eel ahp }hge yeec} nt }en* ahp K ahuld tbnt ybel
ye yepe vkmced uv* tbe Iepgnl} bnd njpend{ jhli `eelgn}tep} ha Vnpk}, N} kt yn}* tbe mnvtnkl }ettjed tbe ybhje
}thp{ ahp ge* nld K yn} yejj mhltelt,
Kl n aey dn{} ye }kibted nl Elijk}b qe}}ej `huld aphg
Gej`huple th Jhldhl yktb yhhj, Nt g{ enple}t pe~ue}t*
kl }vkte ha }thpg{ yentbep ybkmb peldeped kt dnliephu} ahp
n `hnt th tnce u} aphg hle }bkv th tbe htbep* tbe mnvtnklmhl}elted th }kilnj tbe Elijk}b qe}}ej* nld ye yepe
pemekqed hl `hnpd* `ut ye yepe tpnl}aepped yktb }umb
dkaakmujt{ tbnt lh mhggulkmntkhl thhc vjnme n} th tbe
gnllep ha hup `ekli ahuld, K dkd kldeed benp tbe Ktnjknl
gnte ybh yn} kl mbnpie ha tbe `hnt }bhut hut }hgetbkli
kl Apelmb th tbe eaaemt tbnt ye bnd `eel vkmced uv aphg n
`njjhhl* `ut tbe lhk}e ha tbe ykld yn} }h ipent* nld tbe
mnvtnkl uldep}thhd }h jkttje Apelmb tbnt be mnuibt lhtbkli
ha tbe tputb* nld kt yn} n}}uged tbnt ye yepe tyh vep}hl}
ybh bnd `eel }nqed aphg }bkvypemc, Ybel tbe mnvtnkl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 367/378
Epeybhl
=19 ha =9;
n}ced ge kl ybnt }bkv K bnd `eel ypemced* K }nkd tbnt n
vnpt{ ha u} bnd `eel mnppked hut th }en kl n vjen}upe'`hnt`{ n }tphli muppelt* nld tbnt Nphybeln ybhg K
de}mpk`ed n} n Vepuqknl jnd{+ nld K yepe njhle }nqed,
Tbepe yepe }eqepnj vn}}eliep}* ybh}e ihhdle}} thynpd}
u} ye mnl leqep pevn{, K ipkeqe th tbklc tbnt tbe{ mnllht
ankj th dk}mhqep tbnt ye dkd lht tnce tbeg aujj{ klth hup
mhlakdelme3 `ut bnd ye thjd tbeg njj* tbe{ yhujd lhtbnqe `ejkeqed u}* nld K yn} detepgkled tbnt lh hle }bhujd
benp ha Epeybhl* hp bnqe tbe mbnlme ha iettkli tbepe
`eahpe ge* n} jhli n} K mhujd vpeqelt kt, Kldeed* tbe
pemhjjemtkhl ha tbe gnl{ anj}ebhhd} ybkmb K yn} tbel
h`jkied th tejj* yhujd peldep g{ jkae gk}epn`je yepe K lht
}u}tnkled `{ tbe mhl}hjntkhl} ha g{ pejkikhl, Nghli tbevn}}eliep} tbepe yn} n gh}t e}tkgn`je mjepi{gnl* `{
ybhg Nphybeln nld K yepe gnppked yktbkl n qep{ aey
dn{} ha hup mhgkli hl `hnpd,
Natep n vph}vephu} qh{nie ha n`hut tyh ghltb}* ye
}kibted tbe Jnld‛} Eld* nld kl nlhtbep yeec ye yepe
jnlded nt Jhldhl, N jk`epnj }u`}mpkvtkhl yn} gnde ahp u}
hl `hnpd tbe }bkv* }h tbnt ye ahuld hup}ejqe} kl lh
kggedknte dkaakmujt{ n`hut ghle{, K nmmhpdklij{ thhc
Nphybeln dhyl klth ]hgep}et}bkpe* ybepe g{ ghtbep
nld }k}tep} bnd pe}kded ybel K jn}t benpd ha tbeg, Th g{
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 368/378
Epeybhl
=12 ha =9;
ipent }hpphy K ahuld tbnt g{ ghtbep yn} dend* nld tbnt
bep dentb bnd `eel nmmejepnted `{ tbe pevhpt ha g{ bnqkli`eel ckjjed* ybkmb bnd `eel `phuibt th g{ egvjh{ep‛}
}tntkhl `{ Mbhy`hc, Kt nvvenped tbnt be gu}t bnqe ynkted
ahp n aey dn{} th }ee ybetbep K petupled* tbnt be tbel
mhl}kdeped kt }nae th n}}uge tbnt K }bhujd leqep dh }h* nld
bnd nmmhpdklij{ gnde uv n }thp{ n`hut g{ bnqkli anjjel
klth n ybkpjvhhj ha }eetbkli yntep} ybkje mhgkli dhyltbe ihpie bhgeynpd, ]enpmb yn} gnde ahp g{ `hd{* `ut
tbe pn}mnj bnd mbh}el th dphyl ge kl n vjnme ybepe tbepe
yhujd `e lh mbnlme ha kt} eqep `ekli pemhqeped,
G{ }k}tep} yepe `htb gnppked* `ut lektbep ha tbekp
bu}`nld} yn} pkmb, Lh hle }eeged hqepoh{ed hl g{
petupl3 nld K }hhl dk}mhqeped tbnt ybel n gnl‛} pejntkhl}bnqe hlme ghupled ahp bkg n} dend* tbe{ }ejdhg jkce tbe
vph}vemt ha bnqkli th ghupl ahp bkg n }emhld tkge,
Nmmhpdklij{ K petupled th Jhldhl yktb g{ ykae* nld
tbphuib tbe n}}k}tnlme ha nl hjd apkeld }uvvhpted g{}eja `{
ypktkli ihhd jkttje }thpke} ahp tbe gninzkle}* nld ahp n tpnmt
}hmket{, K yn} yejj vnkd3 nld K tpu}t tbnt K gn{ lht `e
mhl}kdeped vpe}ugvtuhu} kl }n{kli tbnt }hge ha tbe gh}t
vhvujnp ha tbe `phmbupe} ybkmb npe dk}tpk`uted kl tbe
}tpeet}* nld ybkmb npe th `e ahuld kl tbe ynktkli'phhg} ha
tbe pnkjyn{ }tntkhl}* bnqe vphmeeded aphg g{ vel, Dupkli
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 369/378
Epeybhl
=1; ha =9;
tbe tkge tbnt K mhujd }vnpe* K nppnlied g{ lhte} nld dknp{
tkjj tbe{ n}}uged tbekp vpe}elt }bnve, Tbepe pegnkl}lhtbkli ahp ge th ndd* }nqe th ulahjd tbe }mbege ybkmb K
vphvh}e ahp tbe mhlqep}khl ha Epeybhl,
Tbnt }mbege bn} hlj{ `eel ~ukte pemeltj{ demkded uvhl
n} tbe hle ybkmb }eeg} gh}t jkcej{ th `e }umme}}auj,
Kt ykjj `e }eel nt hlme tbnt kt yhujd `e gndle}} ahp ge
th ih yktb tel hp n dhzel }u`hpdklnte gk}}khlnpke} `{ tbe}nge yn{ n} tbnt ybkmb jed ge th dk}mhqep Epeybhl, K
}bhujd `e kgvpk}hled ahp t{vbu}* `e}kde} `ekli bnlded
hqep th tbe }tpnkibtelep} ahp bnqkli pul nyn{ yktb
Nphybeln? nl eqel dnpcep ante* th ybkmb K dnpe bnpdj{
ninkl njjude* yhujd `e pe}epqed ahp g{ deqhted aejjhy'
jn`hupep}, Kt k} vjnkl* tbepeahpe* tbnt }hge htbep yn{ gu}t`e ahuld ahp iettkli nt tbe Epeybhlknl}* nld K ng
tbnlcauj th }n{ tbnt }umb nlhtbep yn{ k} lht ynltkli, Hle
ha tbe pkqep} ybkmb de}meld} aphg tbe ]lhy{ Ghultnkl}*
nld vn}}e} tbphuib Epeybhl* k} clhyl th `e lnqkin`je ahp
}eqepnj buldped gkje} aphg kt} ghutb, Kt} uvvep yntep}
bnqe leqep {et `eel ervjhped* `ut K aeej jkttje dhu`t tbnt kt
ykjj `e ahuld vh}}k`je th tnce n jkibt iul`hnt ahp ye gu}t
vphtemt hup}ejqe}+ th tbe hut}ckpt} ha tbe Epeybhlknl
mhultp{,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 370/378
Epeybhl
=96 ha =9;
K vphvh}e* tbepeahpe* tbnt hle ha tbh}e n}}hmkntkhl}
}bhujd `e ahpged kl ybkmb tbe pk}c ha enmb ha tbegeg`ep} k} mhlakled th tbe nghult ha bk} }tnce kl tbe
mhlmepl, Tbe akp}t }tev yhujd `e th dpny uv n vph}vemtu},
Kl tbk} K yhujd ndqk}e tbnt lh geltkhl }bhujd `e gnde ha
tbe anmt tbnt tbe Epeybhlknl} npe tbe jh}t tpk`e}, Tbe
dk}mhqep{ k} hle ha n`}hp`kli kltepe}t th g{}eja* `ut kt k} ha
n }eltkgeltnj pntbep tbnl mhggepmknj qnjue* nld `u}kle}} k}`u}kle}}, Tbe mnvktnj th `e pnk}ed }bhujd lht `e je}} tbnl
akat{ tbhu}nld vhuld}* nld gkibt `e ektbep kl akqe hp tel
vhuld }bnpe} n} bepenatep detepgkled, Tbk} }bhujd `e
ngvj{ }uaakmkelt ahp tbe ervel}e} ha nl ervepkgeltnj
qh{nie,
Ybel tbe ghle{ bnd `eel }u`}mpk`ed* kt yhujd `e hup dut{ th mbnptep n }tengep ha }hge tyejqe hp ahupteel
buldped thl} `updel* nld yktb nmmhgghdntkhl ahp n
mnpih ha }teepnie vn}}eliep}, ]be }bhujd mnpp{ tyh hp tbpee
iul} kl mn}e ha bep `ekli nttnmced `{ }nqnie} nt tbe ghutb
ha tbe pkqep, @hnt} ha mhl}kdepn`je }kze }bhujd `e nj}h
vphqkded* nld K tbklc kt yhujd `e de}kpn`je tbnt tbe}e nj}h
}bhujd mnpp{ tyh hp tbpee }kr'vhuldep}, Tbe }bkv }bhujd
`e tncel uv tbe pkqep n} anp n} yn} mhl}kdeped }nae* nld n
vkmced vnpt{ }bhujd tbel n}meld kl tbe `hnt}, Tbe
vpe}elme `htb ha Nphybeln nld g{}eja yhujd `e
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 371/378
Epeybhl
=9> ha =9;
leme}}np{ nt tbk} }tnie* kln}gumb n} hup clhyjedie ha tbe
jnliunie yhujd dk}npg }u}vkmkhl* nld anmkjktnteleihtkntkhl},
Ye }bhujd `eikl `{ pevpe}eltkli tbe ndqnltnie}
naahpded th jn`hup kl tbe mhjhl{ ha ^ueel}jnld* nld vhklt
hut th tbe Epeybhlknl} tbnt `{ egkipntkli tbktbep* tbe{
yhujd `e n`je th ngn}}* enmb nld njj ha tbeg* elhpghu}
ahptule}—n anmt ybkmb yhujd `e en}kj{ vphqn`je `{ npeaepelme th }tntk}tkm}, K bnqe lh dhu`t tbnt n qep{ ipent
lug`ep gkibt `e tbu} kldumed th mhge `nmc yktb u} kl
tbe jnpiep `hnt}* nld tbnt ye mhujd akjj hup qe}}ej yktb
egkipnlt} kl tbpee hp ahup ohuple{},
]bhujd ye `e nttnmced* hup mhup}e yhujd `e eqel
}kgvjep* ahp tbe Epeybhlknl} bnqe lh iulvhydep* nldyhujd `e }h }upvpk}ed yktb kt} eaaemt} tbnt ye }bhujd `e
n`je th mnvtupe n} gnl{ n} ye mbh}e3 kl tbk} mn}e ye }bhujd
aeej n`je th elinie tbeg hl ghpe ndqnltniehu} tepg}* ahp
tbe{ yhujd `e vpk}hlep} ha ynp, @ut eqel tbhuib ye yepe
th geet yktb lh qkhjelme* K dhu`t lht tbnt n mnpih ha
}eqel hp ekibt buldped Epeybhlknl} mhujd `e kldumed*
ybel tbe{ yepe hlme hl `hnpd tbe qe}}ej* th }kil nl
nipeegelt ybkmb }bhujd `e gutunjj{ ndqnltniehu} `htb
th u} nld tbeg,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 372/378
Epeybhl
=90 ha =9;
Ye }bhujd tbel vphmeed th ^ueel}jnld* nld dk}vh}e ha
hup eliniegelt yktb tbe Epeybhlknl} th tbe }uinp'iphyep} ha tbnt }ettjegelt* ybh npe kl ipent ynlt ha
jn`hup3 kt k} `ejkeqed tbnt tbe ghle{ tbu} penjk}ed yhujd
eln`je u} th demjnpe n bnld}hge dkqkdeld* nld jenqe n
mhl}kdepn`je `njnlme* ybkmb gkibt `e }velt kl peventkli
hup hvepntkhl} nld `pklikli hqep htbep mnpihe} ha
Epeybhlknl}* yktb ape}b mhl}e~uelt vphakt}, Kl anmt yemhujd ih `nmcynpd} nld ahpynpd} n} jhli n} tbepe yn} n
degnld ahp jn`hup kl ^ueel}jnld* hp kldeed kl nl{ htbep
Mbpk}tknl mhjhl{* ahp tbe }uvvj{ ha Epeybhlknl} yhujd `e
uljkgkted* nld tbe{ mhujd `e vnmced mjh}ej{ nld aed nt n
qep{ pen}hln`je mh}t,
Kt yhujd `e g{ dut{ nld Nphybeln‛} th }ee tbnt hup egkipnlt} }bhujd `e `hnpded nld jhdied kl tbe bhu}ebhjd}
ha pejkikhu} }uinp'iphyep}3 tbe}e vep}hl} yhujd ikqe tbeg
tbe `eleakt ha tbnt kl}tpumtkhl ybepeha tbe{ }tnld }h
ipentj{ kl leed, Enmb dn{* n} }hhl n} tbe{ mhujd `e }vnped
aphg tbekp yhpc kl tbe vjnltntkhl}* tbe{ yhujd `e
n}}eg`jed ahp vpnk}e* nld `e tbhphuibj{ iphulded kl tbe
Mbupmb Mntembk}g* ybkje tbe ybhje ha eqep{ ]n``ntb
}bhujd `e deqhted th }klikli v}njg} nld mbupmb'ihkli,
Tbk} gu}t `e kl}k}ted uvhl* `htb kl hpdep th vut n }thv
th nl{ ulen}{ aeejkli ybkmb gkibt }bhy kt}eja ektbep kl
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 373/378
Epeybhl
=9= ha =9;
^ueel}jnld hp kl tbe ghtbep mhultp{ n} th tbe genl}
ybepe`{ tbe Epeybhlknl} bnd `eel h`tnkled* nld nj}h`emnu}e kt yhujd ikqe hup hyl }bnpebhjdep} tbe mhgahpt
ha peajemtkli tbnt tbe{ yepe }nqkli }huj} nld akjjkli tbekp
hyl vhmcet} nt hle nld tbe }nge ghgelt, @{ tbe tkge
tbe egkipnlt} bnd iht thh hjd ahp yhpc tbe{ yhujd bnqe
`emhge tbhphuibj{ kl}tpumted kl pejkikhl3 tbe{ mhujd tbel
`e }bkvved `nmc th Epeybhl nld mnpp{ tbe ihhd }eed yktbtbeg,
K mnl }ee lh bktmb lhp dkaakmujt{ n`hut tbe gnttep* nld
tpu}t tbnt tbk} `hhc ykjj }uaakmkeltj{ ndqeptk}e tbe }mbege th
kl}upe tbe }u`}mpkvtkhl ha tbe leme}}np{ mnvktnj3 n} }hhl n}
tbk} k} ahptbmhgkli K ykjj iunpnltee tbnt K mhlqept tbe
Epeybhlknl} lht hlj{ klth ihhd Mbpk}tknl} `ut klth n}hupme ha mhl}kdepn`je vphakt th tbe }bnpebhjdep},
K }bhujd ndd tbnt K mnllht mjnkg tbe mpedkt ahp bnqkli
hpkiklnted tbe n`hqe }mbege, K bnd `eel ahp ghltb} nt g{
ykt‛} eld* ahpgkli vjnl natep vjnl ahp tbe eqnliejk}ntkhl ha
Epeybhl* ybel `{ hle ha tbh}e }vemknj kltepvh}ktkhl}
ybkmb }bhujd `e n }uaakmkelt nl}yep th tbe }mevtkm* nld
gnce eqel tbe gh}t mhlakpged pntkhlnjk}t kppntkhlnj* g{
e{e yn} dkpemted th tbe ahjjhykli vnpnipnvb kl tbe Tkge}
ley}vnvep* ha hle ha tbe akp}t dn{} kl Onlunp{ >290?'
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 374/378
Epeybhl
=94 ha =9;
‒VHJ[LE]KNL] KL ^UEEL]JNLD,—Tbe Gnp~uk}
ha Lhpgnl`{* tbe ley Ihqeplhp ha ^ueel}jnld* bn}mhgvjeted bk} kl}vemtkhl ha tbe lhptbepl dk}tpkmt} ha tbe
mhjhl{, Kt k} }tnted tbnt nt Gnmcn{* hle ha tbe `e}t }uinp'
iphykli dk}tpkmt}* bk} Ermejjelm{ }ny n ihhd denj ha tbe
Vhj{le}knl}, Kl tbe mhup}e ha n }veemb th tbh}e ybh
elteptnkled bkg tbepe* tbe Gnp~uk} }nkd?' ‒K bnqe `eel thjd
tbnt tbe genl} `{ ybkmb Vhj{le}knl} yepe h`tnkled yepelht jeiktkgnte* `ut K bnqe ankjed th vepmekqe tbk}* kl }h anp
nt jen}t n} ^ueel}jnld k} mhlmepled3 nld* ka hle mnl oudie
`{ tbe mhultelnlme} nld gnllep} ha tbe Vhj{le}knl}* tbe{
ervepkelme lh peipet nt tbekp vh}ktkhl,‛ @ut bk} Ermejjelm{
vhklted hut tbe ndqnltnie ha ikqkli tbeg pejkikhu}
kl}tpumtkhl, Kt yhujd teld th }et nt pe}t nl ulen}{ aeejkliybkmb nt vpe}elt erk}ted kl tbe mhultp{ th clhy tbnt tbe{
yepe klmjkled th petnkl tbe Vhj{le}knl}* nld tenmb tbeg
pejkikhl,‛
K aeej tbnt mhggelt k} ulleme}}np{* nld ykjj tbepeahpe
mhlmjude yktb hle yhpd ha tbnlc} th tbe pendep ybh gn{
bnqe bnd tbe vntkelme th ahjjhy ge tbphuib g{
ndqeltupe} yktbhut jh}kli bk} tegvep3 `ut yktb tyh* ahp
nl{ ybh gn{ ypkte nt hlme th tbe ]empetnp{ ha tbe
Epeybhl Eqnliejk}ntkhl Mhgvnl{* jkgkted nt tbe nddpe}}
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 375/378
Epeybhl
=95 ha =9;
ybkmb }bnjj bepenatep `e ndqeptk}ed+* nld pe~ue}t th bnqe
bk} lnge vut dhyl n} n }bnpebhjdep,V,],—K bnd ou}t pemekqed nld mhppemted tbe jn}t vphha ha
tbe ahpeihkli qhjuge* nld yn} ynjckli dhyl tbe ]tpnld
aphg Tegvje @np th Mbnpkli Mph}}* ybel hl vn}}kli
Eretep Bnjj K }ny n lug`ep ha deqhut'jhhckli vehvje
mphydkli klth tbe `ukjdkli yktb anme} aujj ha kltepe}ted nld
mhgvjnmelt nltkmkvntkhl, K }thvved* nld }ny nlnllhulmegelt tbnt n gk}}khlnp{ geetkli yn} th `e bejd
ahptbyktb* nld tbnt tbe lntkqe gk}}khlnp{* tbe Peq,
Ykjjkng Bn`nccuc* aphg— tbe mhjhl{ aphg ybkmb K bnd
}tnpted hl g{ ndqeltupe}+* yhujd `e kltphdumed* nld
gnce n }bhpt nddpe}}, Natep }hge jkttje dkaakmujt{ K h`tnkled
ndgk}}khl* nld benpd tyh hp tbpee }veembe}* ybkmb yepevpeanthp{ th tbe kltphdumtkhl ha Gp, Bn`nccuc, Hle ha
tbe}e }tpumc ge n} vepbnv} tbe gh}t vpe}ugvtuhu} tbnt K
bnd eqep benpd, Tbe }vencep }nkd tbnt tbe pnme} ha ybhg
Gp, Bn`nccuc yn} n }vemkgel* yepe kl njj vph`n`kjkt{ tbe
jh}t tel tpk`e} ha K}pnej, K dnped lht mhltpndkmt bkg tbel*
`ut K aejt nlip{ nld klouped nt benpkli tbe }vencep ougv th
}h vpevh}tephu} n mhlmju}khl uvhl }umb kl}uaakmkelt
iphuld}, Tbe dk}mhqep{ ha tbe tel tpk`e} yn} gkle* nld
gkle hlj{, K yn} }tkjj kl tbe qep{ bekibt ha kldkilntkhl*
ybel tbepe yn} n gupgup ha ervemtntkhl kl tbe bnjj* nld
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 376/378
Epeybhl
=91 ha =9;
Gp, Bn`nccuc yn} `phuibt ahpynpd, Tbe pendep gn{
oudie ha g{ }upvpk}e nt akldkli tbnt be yn} lhle htbep tbnl g{ hjd apkeld Mbhy`hc.
G{ ony dphvved* nld g{ e{e} njgh}t }tnpted hut ha g{
bend yktb n}thlk}bgelt, Tbe vhhp aejjhy yn} dpendaujj{
apkibteled* nld tbe }thpg ha nvvjnu}e ybkmb ipeeted bk}
kltphdumtkhl }eeged hlj{ th ndd th bk} mhlau}khl, K dnpe
lht tpu}t g{}eja th pevhpt bk} }veemb— kldeed K mhujdbnpdj{ jk}tel th kt* ahp K yn} lenpj{ mbhced yktb tp{kli th
}uvvpe}} g{ aeejkli}, K ng }upe tbnt K mnuibt tbe yhpd}
‒Ndejnkde* tbe ^ueel Dhyniep*‛ nld K tbhuibt tbnt K
benpd ‒Gnp{ Gnidnjele‛ }bhptj{ natepynpd}* `ut K bnd tbel
th jenqe tbe bnjj ahp aenp ha `ekli tupled hut, Ybkje hl tbe
}tnkpmn}e* K benpd nlhtbep `up}t ha vphjhlied nld pnvtuphu}nvvjnu}e* }h K }uvvh}e tbe nudkelme yepe }ntk}aked,
Tbe aeejkli} tbnt mnge uvvepgh}t kl g{ gkld yepe
bnpdj{ ha n qep{ }hjegl mbnpnmtep* `ut K tbhuibt ha g{ akp}t
nm~unkltnlme yktb Mbhy`hc* ha tbe }mele kl tbe
yhhd}bed* ha tbe kllugepn`je jke} be bnd thjd ge* ha bk}
pevented nttegvt} uvhl tbe `pnld{* nld ha gnl{ nl
klmkdelt ybkmb K bnqe lht tbhuibt kt yhptb ybkje th dyejj
uvhl3 nld K mhujd lht `ut depkqe }hge }ntk}anmtkhl aphg
tbe bhve tbnt g{ hyl eaahpt} gkibt bnqe mhltpk`uted th
tbe mbnlie ybkmb bnd `eel dhu`tje}} yphuibt uvhl bkg*
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 377/378
Epeybhl
=99 ha =9;
nld tbnt tbe pkte ybkmb K bnd vepahpged* bhyeqep
ulvphae}}khlnjj{* hl tbnt ykjd uvjnld pkqep'`ed* bnd lht`eel ybhjj{ yktbhut eaaemt, K tpu}t tbnt ybnt K bnqe
ypkttel n`hut bkg kl tbe enpjkep vnpt ha g{ `hhc gn{ lht
`e jk`ejjhu}* nld tbnt kt gn{ dh bkg lh bnpg yktb bk}
egvjh{ep}, Be yn} tbel ulpeielepnte, K gu}t meptnklj{
akld bkg hut nld bnqe n tnjc yktb bkg3 `ut `eahpe K }bnjj
bnqe tkge th dh }h tbe}e vnie} ykjj `e kl tbe bnld} ha tbevu`jkm,
Nt tbe jn}t ghgelt K }ee n vph`n`kjkt{ ha n mhgvjkmntkhl
ybkmb mnu}e} ge gumb ulen}kle}}, Vjen}e }u`}mpk`e
~ukmcj{, Nddpe}} th tbe Gnl}khl'Bhu}e* mnpe ha tbe Jhpd
Gn{hp* ybhg K ykjj kl}tpumt th pemekqe lnge} nld
}u`}mpkvtkhl} ahp ge ultkj K mnl hpinlk}e n mhggkttee,
7/31/2019 Erewhon [ BUTLER, Samuel ]
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/erewhon-butler-samuel- 378/378
Epeybhl
Ahhtlhte}
s>w Tbe jn}t vnpt ha Mbnvtep RRKKK,
s0w ]ee Bnldej‛} mhgvh}ktkhl} ahp tbe bnpv}kmbhpd*
vu`jk}bed `{ Jkthja* v, 92,
s=w Tbe g{tb n`hqe njjuded th erk}t} kl Epeybhl yktb
mbnlied lnge}* nld mhl}kdepn`je ghdkakmntkhl}, K bnqe
tncel tbe jk`ept{ ha peaeppkli th tbe }thp{ n} angkjknp th
hup}ejqe},
s4w Ybnt n ]NAE yhpd ‒pejntkhl‛ k}3 bhy jkttje kt
vpedkmnte}. {et kt bn} hqepiphyl ‒ckl}gnl,‛
s5w Tbe phht njjuded th k} lht tbe vhtnth ha hup hyl
inpdel}* `ut n vjnlt }h lenp nckl th kt tbnt K bnqe qeltuped
th tpnl}jnte kt tbu}, Nvphvh} ha kt} kltejjkielme* bnd tbe
ypktep clhyl @utjep be yhujd vph`n`j{ bnqe }nkd '
"Be clhy} ybnt‛} ybnt* nld tbnt‛} n} bkib*
N} getnvb{}km ykt mnl aj{,‛
s1w ]klme g{ petupl th Elijnld* K bnqe `eel thjd tbnt
tbh}e ybh npe mhlqep}nlt n`hut gnmbkle} u}e gnl{ tepg}
mhlmeplkli tbeg ybkmb }bhy tbnt tbekp qktnjkt{ k} bepe
pemhilk}ed* nld tbnt n mhjjemtkhl ha ervpe}}khl} kl u}e
nghli tbh}e ybh ntteld hl }teng elikle} yhujd `e lh
j t tjk tb k t tk K j k a d tb t