Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ERIE COUNTY AGRICULTURAL DISTRICTS
INCLUSION OF VIABLE AGRICULTURAL LAND
2016 REPORT
FROM: ERIE COUNTY AGRICULTURAL & FARMLAND
PROTECTION BOARD
TO: ERIE COUNTY LEGISLATURE
NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
& MARKETS
PURSUANT TO: SECTION 303-B OF THE AGRICULTURE AND
MARKETS LAW
OVERVIEW
Per section 303-b of New York Agriculture and Markets Law, the Erie County Legislature set the
month of September, 2016 as the annual 30-day period to consider property owner requests for
predominately viable agricultural land to be added to an agricultural district.
Section 303-b requires the Erie County Agricultural and Farmland Protection Board (AFPB) to
report to the Erie County Legislature with its recommendations as to whether the land requested
to be included in an agricultural district:
consists of viable agricultural land as defined in 301(7) of New York Agriculture and Markets
Law; and
would serve the public interest by assisting in maintaining a viable agricultural industry
within the district.
PROPERTY OWNER REQUESTS AND AFPB RECOMMENDATION
During the 2016 open enrollment period, the AFPB received 62 applications for the inclusion of
115 total parcels into Erie County’s existing Agricultural Districts. The AFPB considered the below
requests and based their recommendations upon Agricultural District Law, which states that
parcels to be included in agricultural districts must be “land highly suitable for agricultural
production” and which continue to be feasible for farming if conditions remain the same.
Each parcel requested for inclusion has been analyzed in detail by the active members of the
AFPB. The Board has identified soil types and suitability for agriculture, type of operation,
whether the parcel is owner-operated or rented, gross sales, surrounding land use, eligibility for
agricultural assessment, consistency with zoning, local and regional planning documents,
proximity to existing agricultural districts, and eligibility for inclusion pursuant to Article 25AA of
Agriculture & Markets Law. This data is provided in the matrix included as Attachment 63.
Based upon the abovementioned criteria and data, the Board makes the following
recommendations:
# PARCEL(S) ACRES
(total) ADDRESS TOWN APPLICANT DISTRICT
AFPB
Recommendation
Include Not
Include
1 108.00-1-27 79.16 12657 North
Rd. Alden Daniel Putler 1 X
2 318.00-4-9.2 81.79 0 Lenox Rd Collins Norbert Gabel
Jr. 8 X
2 319.00-2-6.2 7.05 5095 Kaiser Rd. N. Collins Norbert Gabel
Jr. 15 X
2 322.00-1-43.11 68.62 0 N. Central Concord Norbert Gabel
Jr. 15 X
2 335.10-1-23 13.81 0 N. Central Springville Norbert Gabel
Jr. 15 X
3 319.00-2-5.2 11.55 5101 Kaiser Rd. N. Collins Norbert & Rita
Gabel 15 X
4 29.01-2-5.1 24.24 10060 Transit
Rd. Amherst Fritz G. Lotter 17 X
4 29.01-2-5.2 4.99 10090 Transit
Rd. Amherst Fritz G. Lotter 17 X
5 11.20-1-79 0.31 183 Pin Oak
Circle G. Island
James Marks & Scott Berube
17 X
6 11.20-2-2 0.34 366
Havenwood Ln. G. Island
Stephen L. Trimper
17 X
7 12.00-1-8 1.4 1621 Huth Rd. G. Island Daniel Pedlow 17 X
8 12.13-1-36 0.3 5541 East River
Rd. G. Island
Daniel Furmanek
17 X
9 12.13-1-8 0.95 5721 East River
Rd. G. Island Celeste Angelo 17 X
10 12.13-5-1.1 0.69 5618 East River
Rd. G. Island
Robert Wynne & Kathy Bernard
17 X
11 12.18-1-25 0.16 3426 Warner
Dr. G. Island
John & Maria Dojka
17 X
12 12.19-1-24 2.02 3440 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island John Ventry 17 X
13 23.08-2-44 0.42 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-45 0.69 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-46 0.71 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-47 0.37 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-48 0.39 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-49 0.29 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-50 0.3 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-71 0.44 0 Woodcreek
Ln. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-72 0.34 0 Woodcreek
Ln. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-73 0.37 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-74 0.31 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-75 0.39 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-76 0.36 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-77 0.35 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-78 0.3 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-79.1 0.88 0 Morningside
Dr. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
13 23.08-2-82 0.36 0 Woodcreek
Ln. G. Island Elizabeth Szur 17 X
14 23.14-1-6.2 17.77 3611 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Colleen Martin 17 X
15 24.03-1-26 2.92 2562 Baseline
Rd. G. Island
Joseph & Betty Kaefer
17 X
16 24.05-4-40 1.91 2126 Long Rd. G. Island John & Donna
Pedlow 17 X
17 24.06-3-3 6.15 1694 Huth Rd. G. Island James Geblein 17 X
18 24.07-2-6 1.22 1476 Huth Rd. G. Island Paul & Laura
Slagle 17 X
19 24.11-1-4.1 3.25 3030 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Patricia Burg 17 X
20 24.15-1-81 0.73 2748 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island James C.
Korczykowski 17 X
21 24.16-6-17 0.36 1031 Foxcroft
Rd. G. Island
Brian & Amanda Hoyt
17 X
22 24.18-1-5 3.98 1762 Bedell Rd. G. Island Joseph A. Killian 17
X
23 24.19-4-3 4.39 2508 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Justin Thompson 17 X
24 25.00-2-23.12 5.16 500 Ransom
Rd. G. Island
Charles & Kathleen Pratt
17 X
25 36.00-3-12.11 43.91 2555 Staley Rd. G. Island Kathleen Lorentz 17 X
25 36.00-3-12.121 18.35 0 Staley Rd. G. Island Kathleen Lorentz 17 X
26 36.00-3-26.1 13.64 2769 Staley Rd. G. Island Dale Gruber 17 X
27 36.01-4-50.1 0.47 3047
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island Jeremy &
Elisabeth Hoyt 17
X
28 36.04-1-27.12 0.82 0 Baseline Rd. G. Island Edwin Dylag 17 X
28 36.04-1-32 0.49 1698 Baseline
Rd. G. Island Edwin Dylag 17 X
28 36.04-1-33 0.69 0 Baseline Rd. G. Island Edwin Dylag 17 X
28 36.04-1-34 0.63 2027 Staley Rd. G. Island Edwin Dylag 17 X
29 37.01-2-10 0.74 1755
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island David
Hollingworth 17
X
30 37.01-2-16 7.81 1841
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island 1841
Whitehaven Inc. 17
X
31 37.01-2-3.1 0.88 1645
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island John Tripi 17 X
31 37.01-2-4.2 1.1 1655
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island John Tripi 17 X
32 37.01-2-8 2.07 1739
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island Patricia Ray 17 X
33 37.01-2-9 1.06 1743
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island Gerald & Sheila
Daminski 17
X
34 37.02-1-16 0.94 2249 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Calvin
Vandermey 17 X
35 37.03-2-49 8.04 1656
Whitehaven Rd.
G. Island James Smith 17 X
36 37.03-3-15 3.05 2076 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Kim Leys 17 X
37 37.03-4-13 0.96 1958 Webb Rd. G. Island Thomas J. Thompson
17 X
38 37.04-1-35.11 21.88 1301 Staley Rd. G. Island Deborah Zarbo 17 X
39 37.04-1-53 6.22 1819 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Barbara Brown 17 X
40 37.04-1-54.2 5.18 1799 Stony Point Rd.
G. Island Michael &
Patricia Becker 17 X
41 37.20-1-6 0.54 0 East River Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 37.20-1-7 0.52 1952 East River
Rd. G. Island
Margaret Pfohl Bauman
17 X
41 37.20-1-8.2 0.18 0 East River Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 51.08-1-63 0.19 0 East River Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 37.20-1-12.1 41.32 0 Staley Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 37.20-1-11 9.34 0 Staley Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 37.20-1-9 2.19 0 Staley Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 37.20-1-8.1 1.19 0 East River Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 38.17-2-3 3.75 0 Williams Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
41 51.08-1-62 0.19 0 East River Rd. G. Island Margaret Pfohl
Bauman 17 X
42 38.13-1-7 0.65 1884 Harvey
Rd. G. Island
Tristan Wilkinson
17 X
43 38.17-2-14 0.67 2196 East River
Rd. G. Island Dean Morakis 17 X
44 23.14-1-21 0.76 2955 Bedell Rd. G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
44 23.14-1-26 0.08 0 Bedell Rd. G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
44 49.08-1-1 1.8 2339 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
44 49.08-1-26 0.68 2297 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
44 50.18-1-11 0.62 1401 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
44 63.12-2-40.1 0.51 0 Bush Rd. G. Island Daniel B. Oliveri 17 X
45 50.00-1-8.1 12.38 2858 Staley Rd. G. Island Kristin Yiengst 17 X
46 50.00-2-11.112 6.93 2397 Love Rd. G. Island Kelly
Knickerbocker 17 X
47 50.00-2-11.211 14.41 2401 Love Rd. G. Island Myra Kaiser 17 X
48 50.03-1-35 5.62 2808 Love Rd G. Island Jourdain P.
Benoit 17 X
49 50.03-2-3.121 8.12 2823 Fix Rd. G. Island Chris Kam 17 X
50 50.04-1-20.1 5.96 0 Love Rd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
50 50.04-1-22 8.87 2548 Love Rd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
50 50.04-1-17.11 5.96 0 Love Rd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
50 50.04-1-23.11 4.03 0 Alt Blvd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
50 50.04-2-19.111 4.63 0 Fix Rd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
50 50.04-1-21.1 0.29 2564 Love Rd. G. Island Robert Mesmer 17 X
51 50.04-1-5.1 1.69 2716 Love Rd. G. Island Keith Everett 17 X
52 50.04-2-14.1 0.95 2661 Fix Rd. G. Island Paul F. Schultz II 17 X
52 50.04-2-12.2 0.43 2667 Fix Rd. G. Island Paul F. Schultz II 17 X
52 50.18-1-4 0.86 1483 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Paul F. Schultz II 17 X
53 50.04-2-2.21 5.58 2769 Fix Rd. G. Island Anthony Grimmelt
17 X
54 50.17-2-12 0.62 1625 West River Pkwy.
G. Island Jason Shero 17 X
54 99.68-3-17 0.11 157 Fourteenth Buffalo Jason Shero 17 X
54 99.68-3-18 0.11 159 Fourteenth Buffalo Jason Shero 17 X
55 51.02-1-7 1.56 1388 Staley Rd. G. Island Thomas P.
Cunningham 17 X
56 51.15-2-6 0.31 1530 Love Rd. G. Island Harold &
Deborah Clark 17 X
57 51.17-2-27 0.21 1082 Carter Dr. G. Island Wendy & Jamie
Ferrie 17 X
58 51.18-3-34 0.24 974 Stony Point
Rd. G. Island
James M. Olmstead
17 X
59 63.12-2-36 0.18 0 Magnolia
Ave. G. Island Kim M. Swain 17 X
59 63.12-2-37 0.17 0 Bush Rd. G. Island Kim M. Swain 17 X
59 63.12-2-38 0.17 2347 Bush Rd. G. Island Kim M. Swain 17 X
59 63.12-2-39 0.18 0 Bush Rd. G. Island Kim M. Swain 17 X
60 64.00-2-1 5.05 2286 Bush Rd. G. Island Timothy Crockett
17 X
61 64.05-3-1.2 0.86 2176 Fix Rd. G. Island Raymond L. DeGlopper
17 X
61 64.05-3-1.12 12.05 0 Fix Rd. G. Island Raymond L. DeGlopper
17 X
61 64.05-3-1.11 10.14 0 Fix Rd. G. Island Raymond L. DeGlopper
17 X
62 64.06-2-14 0.43 925 East River
Rd. G. Island
Aaron & Katherine Keeler
17 X
LIST OF ATTACHMENTS:
1) Putler Application & Maps (108.00-1-27)
2) Gabel Jr. Application & Maps (318.00-4-9.2; 319.00-2-6.2; 322.00-1-43.11; 335.10-1-23)
3) Gabel Application & Maps (319.00-2-5.2)
4) Lotter Application & Maps (29.01-2-5.1; 29.01-2-5.2)
5) Marks/Berube Application & Maps (11.20-1-79)
6) Trimper Application & Maps (11.20-2-2)
7) D. Pedlow Application & Maps (12.00-1-8)
8) Furmanek Application & Maps (12.13-1-36)
9) Angelo Application & Maps (12.13-1-8)
10) Wynne/Bernard Application & Maps (12.13-1-36)
11) Dojka Application & Maps (12.18-1-25)
12) Ventry Application & Maps (12.19-1-24)
13) Szur Application & Maps (23.08-2-44; 23.08-2-45; 23.08-2-46; 23.08-2-47; 23.08-2-48;
23.08-2-49; 23.08-2-50; 23.08-2-71; 23.08-2-72; 23.08-2-73; 23.08-2-74; 23.08-2-75;
23.08-2-76; 23.08-2-77; 23.08-2-78; 23.08-2-79.1; 23.08-2-82)
14) Martin Application & Maps (23.14-1-6.2)
15) Kaefer Application & Maps (24.03-1-26)
16) J.+D. Pedlow Application & Maps (24.05-4-40)
17) Geblein Application & Maps (24.06-3-3)
18) Slagle Application & Maps (24.07-2-6)
19) Burg Application & Maps (24.11-1-4.1)
20) Korczykowski Application & Maps (24.15-1-81)
21) B.+A. Hoyt Application & Maps (24.16-6-17)
22) Killian Application & Maps (24.18-1-5)
23) J. Thompson Application & Maps (24.19-4-3)
24) Pratt Application & Maps (25.00-2-23.12)
25) Lorentz Application & Maps (36.00-3-12.11; 36.00-3-12.121)
26) Gruber Application & Maps (36.00-3-26.1)
27) J.+E. Hoyt Application & Maps (36.01-4-50.1)
28) Dylag Application & Maps (36.04-1-27.12; 36.04-1-32; 36.04-1-33; 36.04-1-34)
29) Hollingworth Application & Maps (37.01-2-10)
30) 1841 Whitehaven Inc. Application & Maps (37.01-2-16)
31) Tripi Application & Maps (37.01-2-3.1; 37.01-2-4.2)
32) Ray Application & Maps (37.01-2-8)
33) Daminski Application & Maps (37.01-2-9)
34) Vandermey Application & Maps (37.02-1-16)
35) Smith Application & Maps (37.03-2-49)
36) Leys Application & Maps (37.03-3-15)
37) T. Thompson Application & Maps (37.03-4-13)
38) Zarbo Application & Maps (37.04-1-35.11)
39) Brown Application & Maps (37.04-1-53)
40) Becker Application & Maps (37.04-1-54.2)
41) Pfohl Bauman Application & Maps (37.20-1-6; 37.20-1-7; 37.20-1-8.2; 51.08-1-63; 37.20-
1-12.1; 37.20-1-11; 37.20-1-9; 37.20-1-8.1; 38.17-2-3; 51.08-1-62)
42) Wilkinson Application & Maps (38.13-1-7)
43) Morakis Application & Maps (38.17-2-14)
44) Oliveri Application & Maps (23.14-1-21; 23.14-1-26; 49.08-1-1; 49.08-1-26; 50.18-1-11;
63.12-2-40.1)
45) Yiengst Application & Maps (50.00-1-8.1)
46) Knickerbocker Application & Maps (50.00-2-11.112)
47) Kaiser Application & Maps (50.00-2-11.211)
48) Benoit Application & Maps (50.03-1-35)
49) Kam Application & Maps (50.03-2-3.121)
50) Mesmer Application & Maps (50.04-1-20.1; 50.04-1-22; 50.04-1-17.11; 50.04-1-23.11;
50.04-2-19.111; 50.04-1-21.1)
51) Everett Application & Maps (50.04-1-5.1)
52) Schultz Application & Maps (50.04-2-14.1; 50.04-2-12.2; 50.18-1-4)
Attachments are available at the Office of the Clerk of the Legislature.
53) Grimmelt Application & Maps (50.04-2-2.21)
54) Shero Application & Maps (50.17-2-12; 99.68-3-17; 99.68-3-18)
55) Cunningham Application & Maps (51.02-1-7)
56) Clark Application & Maps (51.15-2-6)
57) Ferrie Application & Maps (51.17-2-27)
58) Olmstead Application & Maps (51.18-3-34)
59) Swain Application & Maps (63.12-2-36; 63.12-2-37; 63.12-2-38; 63.12-2-39)
60) Crockett Application & Maps (64.00-2-1)
61) DeGlopper Application & Maps (64.05-3-1.2; 64.05-3-1.12; 64.05-3-1.11)
62) Keeler Application & Maps (64.06-2-14)
63) Inclusion Analysis Matrix
64) Grand Island Applicant Map
65) Notice of Public Hearing
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING
PROPOSED MODIFICATION TO AGRICULTURAL DISTRICTS
Notice is hereby given that a public hearing will be held by the Legislature of the County of Erie, at the Grand Island Memorial Library located at 1715 Bedell Road in Grand Island, New York, 14072 on the 10th of November, 2016 at 6:00 PM, to consider the following requests for the inclusion of predominantly viable agricultural lands within existing agricultural districts that have been submitted in accordance with sec. 303-b of NYS Agricultural and Markets Law.
ADDRESS TOWN APPLICANT ACRES (total)
PARCEL(S) DISTRICT
12657 North Rd. Alden Daniel Putler 79.16 108.00-1-27 1
0 Lenox Rd Collins Norbert Gabel Jr. 81.79 318.00-4-9.2 8
5095 Kaiser Rd. N. Collins Norbert Gabel Jr. 7.05 319.00-2-6.2 15
0 N. Central Concord Norbert Gabel Jr. 68.62 322.00-1-43.11 15
0 N. Central Springville Norbert Gabel Jr. 13.81 335.10-1-23 15
5101 Kaiser Rd. N. Collins Norbert & Rita Gabel 11.55 319.00-2-5.2 15
10060 Transit Rd. Amherst Fritz G. Lotter 24.24 29.01-2-5.1 17
10090 Transit Rd. Amherst Fritz G. Lotter 4.99 29.01-2-5.2 17
And a significant amount of land within the Town of Grand Island totaling 384.27 acres representing 105 parcels. The hearing shall consider the requests and recommendations of the County Agricultural and Farmland Protection Board (AFPB). All applications submitted and the Erie County AFPB report to the Legislature on recommended parcel inclusions is available at http://www2.erie.gov/environment/index.php?q=agupdate. Questions may be directed to Elias Reden, Planner at [email protected].
