8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

1/125

Ethics Ethics Greek word Ethika or Ethos referring to

character

Broadly referring to principles of conduct governinggroups or individuals and trying to distinguishbetween: Right / Wrong

Good / Bad

Proper / Improper

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

2/125

Definitions BE is a form of applied ethics that examines ethical

principles and moral or ethical problems that arise

in a business environment System of moral principles applied in the

commercial world

Moral principles concerning acceptable and

unacceptable behavior by business people andorganizations or corporations

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

3/125

Continued.. B E is a normative science as a branch of

philosophy, it is concerned with norms of human

conduct Not empirical like physics and chemistry

Not formal like math and logic

Ethical decisions are real life and not theoretical

They have an impact on people, society, culture,economy, ecology etc.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

4/125

History of Ethics 6th Century BC Pythagoras founded Orphism

5th Century BC Socrates and Pluto

4th

Century BC Aristotle Nicomachean Ethics Propagated theories of Virtues essentially Good Habits

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

5/125

Continued.. 3rd Century BC Romans developed theory of

Stoicism, with principles like:

Nature is orderly and rational Man should endure and renounce worldly goods and

trappings

All other religions also had their own theories of

ethics Pre-Christian Zoroastrianism, thenChristianity, Hinduism, Jainism, Islam, Buddhismand Sikhism

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

6/125

History of Business Ethics 1960 Ralph Nader raised issue of consumer safety

from unsafe automobiles

1965 - Unsafe At Any SpeedWatergate scandal, Vietnam war

Sale of defective material

Illegal political contributions Discrimination and reverse discrimination

Trade union tyrannies

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

7/125

Continued..Purpose of business?

In an economically free andcompetitive society, excessive self-interest by one will be checked by

that of other

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

8/125

Ethics anyone??

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

9/125

MoralityTerm synonymous with Ethics

Represents a code of conductSeems ideal

Is more personal than ethics

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

10/125

Continued..Can be applied to social contexts

E.g. Prohibition against takinghuman lives in the form of:

Mercy killing

AbortionsWars

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

11/125

Stages of Moral Development Pre-conventional morality:

Self focus and self interest

Forms of punishment, obedience and relativity Conventional morality:

Group focus and pressure of expectation ofgroup from person

Forms of interpersonal concordance, and lawand order

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

12/125

ContinuedAutonomous / Post-conventional morality:

Universal focus

Impartial orientationForms of universal ethical stance and self

sacrifice

Development of different individuals atdifferent stages and rates

Implications for managers

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

13/125

Adam SmithAdam Smith on ethics and morality:

Why do humans behave in generousand noble ways?

It is due to reason, principle,

conscience, the human within thequiet judge and arbiter of ourconduct

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

14/125

Peter DruckerPeter Drucker:

What is important is that management

realizes that it must consider the impactof every business policy and action uponsociety. It has to consider whether the

action is likely to contribute to its stability,strength and harmony

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

15/125

Moral ResponsibilityWho is responsible for unethical conduct in

business?

3 Views: 1. The employee who made the unethical

decision

Corporations dont make decisions, people do

Therefore, the people who made the unethicaldecision should be held responsible

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

16/125

Continued..2. The corporation

Employees decisions are made in the contextof corporate policies, corporate norms,organizational structure, and corporateculture

Therefore, the corporation as a whole shouldbe held responsible

3. Both the corporation and the employeesinvolved

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

17/125

Continued..Does the following reduce moral

responsibility?

True ignorance of fact Ignorance due to negligence

Ignorance of ethics

True inability to do anything else

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

18/125

MNCs MNC entry into less developed countries:

One nation cannot control them as they operate inmultiple locations

Behave more immorally in less developed countries

Exploitation of natural resources in host country

Exploitation of labor in host country

Changes in culture of host country Luring host country nationals into buying products they

cannot afford

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

19/125

Nature of Business Ethics Ethics is omnipresent; at the same time, there is no

ethics that is universally accepted

Business ethics decisions could be clear or gray.

Ethics is unstructured. Value systems and ethicalpractices differ from society to society

Decisions are ethical if they result in benefit to

larger society and are unethical if they result inbenefit to self only

Decisions are ethical if they are proper, good, fair,just, right and equitable

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

20/125

Case Study Wal-Mart Founded in early 1960s by Sam Walton in Rogers,

Arkansas

Publicly traded in 1970 More than 5000 stores all over the world, with

more than 3000 in the US

138 million people shop at Wal-Mart each week

Has had a single minded strategy of Everyday LowPrices

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

21/125

Continued..Account for:

Being the single largest US importer from China

30% sale of all household goods domestic products, inthe US

Largest private employer in the US

Single largest employer in 25 US states

Controls costs through leveraging buying power asthe worlds largest retailer and by controlling laborcosts

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

22/125

Continued.. Benefits to all:

Stockholders financial benefits

Employees jobs Consumers low prices

Businesses benefits through supplying to Wal-Mart

Beliefs of Sam Walton respect for individuals,

service to customers and striving for excellence

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

23/125

Continued.. Flip side:

Least admired corporation

Has been charged with manipulative pricing and

marketing Control of labor costs through paying only minimum

wages

Very less healthcare benefits provided as an employer

Charged with illegally requiring workers to workovertime without pay

Has been charged with employee discrimination

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

24/125

Continued.. Has been charged with employing illegal immigrants to

keep labor costs low

Has been responsible for closing down small time

businesses in smaller towns who find it difficult tocompete on basis of prices

Harms suppliers by making them bid for low pricesagainst each other reverse auction. Suppliers then

need to outsource to keep costs low so that they cansupply to Wal-Mart

Significant contributor to practice of sweat-shops

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

25/125

Need for BEProtect interests of those related to business

Check malpractices

Create an identity associated with ethics

Make people conscious about their rightsand responsibilities

Increase customer confidence

Avoid exploitation

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

26/125

Factors influencing BEPersonal code of conduct and

behavior

Standards of superiors

Corporate policies

Countrys ethical climate

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

27/125

Ethical DecisionsMost ethical decisions have long range

consequences

They have multiple alternativesThey involve trade off between cost incurred

and benefits received

They have mixed outcomesThey are voluntary actions

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

28/125

ThalidomideDeveloped by a German

pharmaceutical companyGrnenthal

in the 1950sWas found to act as an effective

tranquilizer and painkiller and wasproclaimed a "wonder drug" forinsomnia, coughs, colds and headaches

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

29/125

Continued..Also, the wonder drug was found to be effective on

morning sickness; so thousands of pregnant womentook it to relieve themselves of morning sicknessduring the first 2 trimesters of pregnancy

In the late 1950s and early 1960s, more than 10,000children in 46 countries were born

with deformities such as phocomelia as aconsequence of thalidomide use

Early research findings not taken seriously enough

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

30/125

Continued..US had not permitted the drug due to

inadequate testing, but pregnant women

vacationing in Europe had access to it.Free samples distributed to physicians

ethics issue.

In 1968 Chemie Grnenthal executives weretried for involuntary manslaughter

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

31/125

Continued.. By this time the company stated that Thalidomide

was not recommended for use during pregnancy assuch

The qualifying term obstetrics was employed.

It was used in hindsight to strengthen theargument that doctors would interpret the word to

mean either the final stage of pregnancy or fromconception to delivery

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

32/125

Corporate ResponsibilityResponsibility towards shareholders:

Safety of investment

Maximizing dividends

Participation in management

Information to shareholdersRetaining public image

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

33/125

Continued..Responsibility towards consumers:

Production as per requirement

Prompt and adequate serviceCo-operation

Adequate research and development

Testing of products Innovation

Improvement

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

34/125

Continued..Responsibility towards workers / employees:

Fair wages

Security

Opportunities for development

Proper working conditions

Trade union rights

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

35/125

Continued..Responsibility towards community and

Government:

Abide by laws and regulationsCooperation

Improvement of community standards by

spread of education and through otherhelp

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

36/125

Drivers of CSREthical consumerism

Globalization and market forces

Social awareness and education

Laws and regulations

Crisis and consequence

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

37/125

CSR ConcernsPurpose of corporations is to maximize

returns of shareholders

CSR with questionable motives BP, BritishAmerican Tobacco and McDonalds

Reeks of corporate hypocrisy and insincerityas companies claiming to promote CSRsimultaneously engage in harmful activities

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

38/125

Types of EthicsPhilosophical Foundations of Ethics:

Ethics is a brainchild of philosophy

Philosophy is a study of thoughts andmorality

Ethics:

Normative ethics

Meta ethics

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

39/125

Normative and Meta EthicsNormative ethics tries to discover

criteria or rules with which moral

judgments can be made howought one act, morally speaking?

Meta Ethics tries to look at what isright and what is wrong; or what isgoodness and bad

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

40/125

Normative TheoriesNormative ethics has the following theories:

Relativism

Teleological theories

Egoism

Utilitarianism

Deontological theories

Immanuel Kants Categorical Imperative

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

41/125

Relativism Relativism:

Ethical standards must be regarded as relative to

and dependent on individual and society No action can be judged right or wrong or good

or bad by a universal standard that applies to allpeople at all times

Cultural relativism says that no standards canjudge morality of a particular culture

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

42/125

Relativism Continued..This approach ensures that we

acknowledge diversity and are ready to

face the challenges of it professionallyIt is the opposite of ethical absolutismwhich holds that morally right behavioris cross cultural and holds good acrossall kinds of society

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

43/125

Teleological theories Teleological theories:

Derived from the Greek word Telos meaningEnd.

Teleological theories determine rightness andwrongness of actions by looking at the end ofthe action

The ends or consequences of an act determinewhether an act is good or evil

It is consequentialist in nature

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

44/125

Continued..Egoism:

If the good produced issupposed to benefit only

the agent of action, then itis Egoism

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

45/125

Continued..Utilitarianism:

The good produced should benefit

maximum number of peopleJeremy Bentham, an English

Philosopher, and legal and social

reformer, gave the concept of Utility tothe world

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

46/125

Continued..His basic principle was that:

The right act or policy was that; which

would cause "the greatest good for thegreatest number of people",

Also known as The Greatest HappinessPrinciple", or The Principle of Utility

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

47/125

Continued..It is the idea that the moralworth of an action is solelydetermined by its contributionto overall utility; i.e. its

contribution to pleasure orhappiness among maximumpersons

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

48/125

Continued..Traditional Utilitarianism holds that an

action is right from an ethical point of

view if and only if the sum total of theutilities produced by that act is greaterthan the sum total of the utilities

produced by any other act the agentcould have performed in its place

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

49/125

Continued..Which thereby means that only one action

is right

Immediate and foreseeable cost and benefitanalysis of each action needs to be takeninto consideration

That alternative that produces the greatest

sum total of utility must be chosen as theethically most appropriate action

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

50/125

Case Study Ford PintoLate 1960s US cars manufacturerswere in danger of being overshadowed

by Japanese car makers Lee Iaccoca, then President , of Ford

ordered engineers to build a car thatwas not to weigh an ounce over 2,000pounds and not cost a cent over $2,000.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

51/125

Continued.. Normal time for a car from conception to

production is 43 months

Pinto was brought to the shopfloor in 25 months

Testing after design and initial production revealeda serious defect in the placing of the gas tank

Design required the gas tank to be placed behind

the rear axle, where it became vulnerable to beingpunctured in case of a rear end collision ofmorethan 30 miles per hour, possibly burning thetrapped passengers

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

52/125

Continued.. Production was none the less, continued on

grounds that: Design met with all applicable legal and governmental

standards then Government regulations required that the gas tank

remains intact in case of a rear end collision of less than20 miles per hour

Ford Managers felt that the car was comparable in safetywith other cars in the same segment

Cost benefit analysis showed that it was more beneficialto go ahead with production

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

53/125

Analysis of cost benefit Cost:

Autos to be produced 12.5 million

Cost of design modification - $11 per unit

Total cost - $137 million

Statistical Data:

Modification would prevent loss of:

180 burn deaths valued at $200,000 each 180 injuries valued at $67000 each

2100 cars valued at $700 each

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

54/125

Continued.. Benefits:

In monetary terms, the modification would have thebenefit of preventing losses with a total value of $49.15

million

Argument is that it is not correct to spend $137million of societys money to provide a benefit that

was valued at $49.15 million This is a utilitarian view of cost benefit analysis

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

55/125

Continued..After about 60 deaths in the following decade and

numerous burns cases, and lawsuits involvingmillions of dollars, Ford recalled 1.5 million units

of the car in 1978 In February of 1978, a California jury created a

nationwide sensation when it awarded the record-breaking sum of $128 million in a lawsuit

stemming from a Pinto accident. This one lawsuitwas three times what Ford executives andengineers had estimated their final cost would be.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

56/125

Problems of Measurement Measuring utility is in itself a challenge

How can the utilities that different actions havefor different people be measured and compared?

Some costs and benefits are intractable tomeasurement like value of health and life

Some costs and benefits cannot be immediatelyand reliably predicted

What is a cost and what is a benefit?

Who and how do we measure the value of noneconomic goods love, beauty, freedom etc.?

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

57/125

Illustration: Using low wage foreign workers in response to

price competition

Retaining market share by decreasing capital

cost Laying off some US workers in the process and

retaining some

Refusing to use low wage foreign workers mightend up in a situation where US workers also arelaid off and foreign workers dont benefit in anycase, for whom the income might be essential

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

58/125

Deontological TheoriesDerived from the Greek word Deon

meaning obligation or duty

It is an approach to ethics that judgesthe morality of an action based on theaction's adherence to a rule or rules

Deontologists look at rulesand duties

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

59/125

Immanuel Kants TheoryTo act in the morally right way, people must

act from duty

It was not the consequences of actions thatmake them right or wrong but the motivesof the person who carries out the action

The highest good must be both good initself, and good without qualification

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

60/125

Continued..Those things that are usually thought to be

good, such as pleasure, intelligence etc. fail

to be either intrinsically good or goodwithout qualification

Nothing in the world - indeed nothing even

beyond the world - can possibly beconceived which could be called goodwithout qualification except agood will.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

61/125

Continued..There are some moral rights and duties that

all human beings possess, regardless of any

utilitarian benefits that might arise out ofthem

Categorical Imperative:

Everyone should be treated as a freeperson equal to everyone else

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

62/125

Continued.. First formulation of Kants Theory of CI:An action is morally right for a person in a

certain situation if, and only if, the persons

reason for carrying out the action is a reasonthat he or she would be willing to have everyperson act on, in any similar situation

Universalizabilitythe persons reasons for acts

must be reasons that everyone could act on, atleast in principle

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

63/125

Continued..Second formulation of Kants Theory of CI:

An action is morally right if, and only if, in

performing that action, the person doesnot use others merely as a means foradvancing his interests, but also respects

and develops their capacity to choosefreely for themselves

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

64/125

W D Ross Duty of beneficence: A duty to help other people

(improve conditions of others)

Duty of non-maleficence: A duty to avoid harmingother people.

Duty of justice: A duty to ensure people get whatthey deserve.

Duty of self-improvement: A duty to improveourselves.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

65/125

Continued.. Duty of reparation: A duty to recompense

someone if you have acted wrongly towards them.

Duty of gratitude: A duty to benefit people whohave benefited us.

Duty of promise-keeping: A duty to act accordingto explicit and implicit promises, including the

implicit promise to tell the truth.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

66/125

Rights and JusticeUtilitarianism is unable to deal with moral

issues related to rights and related to justice

Some utilitarian actions which are deemedto be morally right, actually violate peoplesrights or could be unjust to some

By engaging in utilitarian acts, corporations

might snatch away the right to information,choice etc. of people

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

67/125

Concept of RightRight is an individuals entitlement to

something

Legal rights: Entitlements that are derivedfrom the legal system permission orempowerment to act in a specified way

Moral rights: Entitlements that are derived

from moral systems that people have justby the virtue of being human beings

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

68/125

Continued..Features of rights:

Rights are correlated with duty

Rights provide individuals with autonomyin pursuit of their interest

Rights provide basis for justification ofactions

Utilitarianism defies the Rights theory

While looking at maximum utility to many,it takes away the rights of some

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

69/125

Case Eli LillyEli Lilly a pharmaceutical giant, was

founded in 1876 in Indiana, by a chemist

Crucial contributions are mass productionof penicillin and super-specialization inpsychiatric medicine

Innovations fruit flavoring of medicinesand sugar coating of pills

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

70/125

Continued..Testing of drugs is a situation which

contradicts itself:

FDA requires drugs to be tested onhealthy humans to determine side effects

Healthy humans will not offer themselves

as subjects to untested drugsTest subjects can die, suffer from organ

failure or damage etc.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

71/125

Continued..Eli Lilly discovered a large number ofvolunteers willing to take untested drugs at$85 per day plus free food and shelter

Source was homeless people taking refuge inshelters, soup kitchens etc

Tests running for several months ensured all

three for these peopleTests provided enormous benefit to society

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

72/125

Continued..Participants needed to give informed

consent

The people whom Eli Lilly had chosenwere mostly illiterate, so even if theyhad signed a consent form, they had no

clue what they were getting into

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

73/125

Justice and FairnessThese are essentially comparative terms

They are concerned with comparative

treatment is given to members given when:Rules and laws are administered

Benefits and burdens are distributed

Punishment is decidedGroups are in competition or cooperation

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

74/125

Types of justiceDistributive justice:

Concerned with sharing burdens and

benefits with members of a society Individuals who are similar in all respects,

relevant to the kind of treatment in

question, should be given equal / similarbenefits and burdens, even if they aredissimilar in other irrelevant respects

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

75/125

Continued..Justice as equality Egalitarianism:

Every person should be given exactly

equal in terms of burdens and benefitsJustice as contribution Capitalist:

Benefits and burdens should be

distributed according to the value of thecontribution the individual makes to thesociety, task, group etc.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

76/125

Continued..Justice based on needs and abilities Socialism: Burdens should be distributed according to

abilities and benefits according to peoples

needsJustice as freedom Libertarianism:

Any distribution of benefits and burdens is just,if it is the result of individuals freely choosing toexchange with each other the goods each personalready owns

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

77/125

Continued..Justice as fairness Rawls Theory:

Principle of equal libertyeach personsliberties must be protected from invasion

Principle of difference steps must be taken toimprove the position of the most needymembers of society

Principle of fair equality of opportunityeveryone should be given an equal opportunityto qualify for more privileged positions insociety

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

78/125

Retributive JusticeJustice of blaming or punishing a person for wrong

actions

People cannot be held morally responsible forwhat they do out of ignorance or inability

There should be certainty before punishingabout the person being actually wrong

Punishment should be consistent andproportioned to the wrong

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

79/125

Compensatory JusticeJustice of restoring a person what he / she

has lost when wronged by someone

Compensation should happen only whenthe action causing the harm wasdeliberate and wrong

The persons action was the real cause ofharm

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

80/125

Building a Good Society Society is a dynamic and ever changing body Base level classification is Warrior Society and

Industrial Society

As industrialization and economic activitiesincrease, previously warring countries need to becooperative with each other

Modern society free movement of monetarycapital, physical capital and intellectual capital

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

81/125

Continued..Businesses therefore need to be wise aboutinstituting changes which benefit onlythemselves

Extreme concentration on own survivalcould lead to a self defeating scenario ofconsumers lacking means to buy products

and enjoy services It is therefore in the best interest of a

business to build a good society

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

82/125

Continued..A good society is a just society where

everyone shares burdens according to

capability and benefits according tocontribution

As Gandhiji puts it: it is a society where the

poorest of the poor are just as happy as therichest of the rich

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

83/125

Organizations Organizations do not exist in isolation, but operatewithin an environment of:

Investors

Suppliers

Customers

Government

Competitors Employees

General Society

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

84/125

Continued..Every action that an organization performsis bound to have an effect on someone

Businesses face ethical decisions in mereexistence through:

Choice of product or service

Labor management

Advertising and promotions

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

85/125

Continued.. Finally, businesses do a cost-benefit analysis andtake most decisions depending on the result of

weighing factors against each other

Businesses are more amoral than immoral

Their existence boosts economy, and actions stirsociety

Adherence to ethics does not matter, but violationis noticed

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

86/125

Types of Business Ethics General Business Ethics: Corporate social responsibility

Moral rights and duties between a company andits shareholders

Ethical issues concerning relations betweendifferent companies

Leadership issues corporate transparency Misuse of ethical policies as marketing

instruments

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

87/125

Finance and Accounting:Creative accounting

Misleading financial analysis

Insider trading

Executive compensation

Bribery / facilitation payments

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

88/125

IPR / Knowledge and skills

Patent and copyright violation

Employee raiding / poaching

Bio-prospecting and bio-piracy

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

89/125

Human Resource Management Discrimination on basis of age, gender, caste,religion, disabilities

Illegal Unionization / union busting

Issues affecting privacy of employee surveillance

Whistle blowing

Fairness of contracts

Compromise on occupational safety and health

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

90/125

Sales and Marketing:Anti-competitive practices dumping, exclusivedealing, price fixing, product tying etc.

Advertising attack ads, harmful products

Marketing strategies bait and switch, viral,spamming

Black and gray markets

Marketing in schools

Marketing in vulnerable groups

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

91/125

Production: Production of defective, addictive anddangerous products

Production and environmental effect pollution, carbon emissions etc.

New technologies genetic modification,radiation due to microwaves and mobile phones

etc. Product testing ethics animal testing and

testing on economically backward groups

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

92/125

C S RCorporate Social responsibility (CSR), alsoknown as CorporateResponsibility, Corporate

Citizenship, ResponsibleBusiness, Sustainable ResponsibleBusiness (SRB), or Corporate Social

PerformanceForm of self regulation integrated into

business models

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

93/125

Continued..A business is expected to take on responsibility for theimpact of its activities on the environment,consumers, employees,

communities, stakeholders and all other members ofthe public sphere

CSR-focused businesses should proactively promotethe public interest by encouraging community growth

and development, and voluntarily eliminatingpractices that harm the public sphere, regardless oflegality.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

94/125

Continued..Essentially, CSR is the deliberateinclusion of public interest intocorporate decision making, andhonoring of a triple bottom line

People, Planet and Profit

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

95/125

Drivers of CSREthical consumerism

Globalization and market forces

Social awareness and education

Laws and regulations

Crisis and consequence

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

96/125

CSR Benefits

Human Resource benefits by ensuringan identity to potential recruits

Risk mitigationBrand differentiation

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

97/125

CSR ConcernsPurpose of corporations is to maximize

returns of shareholders

CSR with questionable motives BP, BritishAmerican Tobacco and McDonalds

Reeks of corporate hypocrisy and insincerityas companies claiming to promote CSR

simultaneously engage in harmful activities

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

98/125

Criticism Thomson-Reuters columnist Chrystia Freeland has

called CSR a fetish encouraged by thephilanthropies that feed off it, and funded by the

corporate executives who find that it serves theirbottom line.

Consumers have been willing to pay more and buy

more from companies with a CSR halo

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

99/125

Unit 3 Globalization & Ethics

Globalization describes an ongoing

process by which regional economies,societies, and cultures have becomeintegrated through a globe-spanning

network of communication andexecution.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

100/125

De - territorialisation

Globalisation is the increasingand progressive eroding of the

relevance of territorial bases forsocial, economic and political

activities, processes andrelations

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

101/125

Continued..

Free flow of :

Goods and services

Labor and people

Capital

Technology

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

102/125

Some policy changesPromotion of free trade:

Elimination of tariffs, creation of free trade zones

Reduced transportation costs, especially for ocean shipping.

Reduction or elimination of capital controlsReduction, elimination, or harmonization of subsidies forlocal businesses

Creation of subsidies for global corporations

Harmonization of intellectual property laws across majorityof states

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

103/125

Because of that: Increasing level of uncertainty in the following

areas:

Consumer demand for goods and services

Supply of inputs, resources and services

Government policies

Nature of relations among countries

Indirect repercussions of globalization like terrorism,nuclear wars, bio-warfare, global warming, diseases etc.

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

104/125

Globalization and Ethics Globalization has brought forth ethics issue more

Organizations attain a competitive edge due to ethicalpractices

Companies need to deal with ethics as one of thebackbones of corporate strategies

Realization that being ethically proactive is better thanethically reactive

Value creating strategies are being recognized as USPs;more than products and services

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

105/125

Global Ethical Issues Global business strategies - Absolute against relative

Business being conducted in the same way everywherein the world, Or, Changing business practices according

to the geographical location Bribery and corruption

Human rights

Consumerism

Safety and environmental issues

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

106/125

Global Businesses Should:As part of ethics;

Have ethics policies or mandates

Appoint ethics officers to ensurecompliances

Routinely have ethics audits

Require suppliers to participate in theethics programs

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

107/125

Continued..Encourage suppliers and self to not to

participate in any human or employment

rights abusesSupport and respect human rights

Encourage and promote diversity in

organizations

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

108/125

Ethics Policy:

A statement pertaining to ethicalconduct of employees and organization

Setting of expectationsOffering guidelines on handling ethical

issues

Creating awareness about ethics

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

109/125

It should be:Given unequivocal support of topmanagement through word and

exampleExplained in writing and verballywith reinforcement

Doable and easy to understand andperform

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

110/125

Continued..Monitored with routine inspections

for compliance and improvement

Backed by clearly statedconsequences in cases ofdisobedience

Should remain neutral and non-sexist

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

111/125

Global Good Society Environmental perspective

Take care of finite resources

Encourage innovation in new material development

Invest in research

Economic

Concentrate on long term sustainability instead of shortterm profits

Social

Social responsibilities of business

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

112/125

Continued.. UN Millennium Development Goals

Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger

Promote gender equality and empower women

Reduce child mortality

Improve maternal health

Combat AIDS, Malaria and other such diseases

Ensure environmental sustainability

Develop global partnership for development

Unit 4 - Moral Issues in

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

113/125

Business

Environmental Protection:

Role of industry and business in the

overall degradation of ecology andenvironment is large

Clean air and unpolluted water arebasic human rights, which so manypeople do not get

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

114/125

Continued..The activities generally considered harmful

and their repercussions are:

DeforestationBurning of fossil fuel

Leading to depletion of ozone layer

Increase in pollution Unexplained phenomenon like acid rain

Global warming

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

115/125

Fossil FuelFossil fuels are fuels formed by natural

processes such as anaerobicdecomposition of buried dead organisms

Typically, coal, petroleum, natural gas

Fossil fuels are non-renewable

resources because they take millions of yearsto form, and reserves are being depletedmuch faster than new ones are being made

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

116/125

Continued.. The burning of fossil fuels produces around 21.3

billion tonnes of carbon dioxide (CO2) per year, but itis estimated that natural processes can only absorb

about half of that amount, so there is a net increase of10.65 billion tonnes of atmospheric carbon dioxide peryear

Carbon dioxide is one of the greenhouse gases that

enhances radiative forcing and contributes to globalwarming, causing the average surface temperature ofthe earth to rise

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

117/125

Continued..Agriculture:

Over grazing

Over cropping Soil erosion

Increased ground water salinity through

depletion

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

118/125

Continued..

Chemical, manufacturing, oil, metalprocessing, automobile industries

Smoke and emissionCombustion of fossil fuel

Air pollutionWater pollution

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

119/125

Continued.. Ground pollution through dumping toxic waste

Releasing effluents into oceans and rivers

Usage of fertilizers

Harm to food, water, fish and animal life

Poisons entering human food chain throughedibles

Increase in respiratory diseases

Increasing number deformities at birth owingto pollution levels

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

120/125

Continued..Pollution

Pollution is defined as the contaminationof our living environment i.e. air, earthand water with human intervention ofsubstances that in turn cause harm tohuman beings and the environment

Usually considered relative in nature

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

121/125

Causes of PollutionNatural factors like volcanic eruptions,

floods, dust storms etc.

Rising population putting pressure onnatural and man-made resources

Indiscriminate and unplanned growth

of citiesUse of motorized vehicles

Industrial activities

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

122/125

Other related issues:

Renew ability of resources

New discoveries in resources

Resources being used faster thatcreated

Extinction of species in fish, plants andanimals

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

123/125

Role of Business Business and industries need to play a crucial and

pro-active role in environment protection:

Use of pollution control in factories

Improve methods and techniques of productionthereby minimizing waste and scrap

Use of eco friendly technology

Production of eco friendly products Proper enforcement of governmental laws and

regulations

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

124/125

Continued..Proper safety measures set and adhered to

Thorough maintenance of material

Training to workersEnvironmental audit

Funds, tree plantations etc.

Environment related internationalcompliances

8/3/2019 ethics 125 pg

125/125

Social Accounting Standards Responsibility for impact on society

Set up of certain standards:

Green Globe Certification for sustainability inenvironmental, cultural and CSR issues

ISO 14000 for environment management

Social Accountability International SA8000 for

labor and working conditions