EVALUATION REPORT - AJ&K PPRA · 2020. 1. 23. · PPRA Rules 2017 Rs.16,00000 Technical Financial DENTAL MATERIALS/MEDICINES AND DENTAL X-RAY FILMS Item No.1 Lignocaine Dental cartridge:

1

EVALUATION REPORT

(As per Rule 35 of AJK Public Procurement Rules, 2017)

1 Name of Procuring

Agency

Jinnah Dental Hospital Muzaffarabad

2 Method of Procurement Open Competitive Bidding (Single stage -Two Envelope Procedure)

3 Title of Procurement Dental Materials /Medicines and Dental X-ray Films

4 Tender Inquiry No. AK-260-N

5 PPRA Ref .No. 1003 dated 27.11.2019

6 Date & Time of Bid

Closing

17.12.2019 ,1100hrs

7 Date & Time Opening 17.12.2019 , 1200 hrs

8 No. of Bids Received 05 (Five)

9 Criteria for Bid Evaluation Technical Bid Evaluation Financial Bid Evaluation

10 Details of Bid (s)

Evaluation

As under

S.# Name of Bidder

Marks

Evaluated

Cost

Rules/Regulation/SBD/Policy/

acceptance as per Rules 35 of AJK

PPRA Rules 2017 Rs.16,00000

Technical Financial

DENTAL MATERIALS/MEDICINES AND DENTAL X-RAY FILMS

Item No.1 Lignocaine Dental cartridge: Lignocaine + Epinephrine (Dental cart.) Lignocaine Hydrochloride

2% solution with Adrenaline 1:80,000. Box/tin of 100 or less cartridge of 1.8ml/2ml.pkt. of 50

S.No. Name of Bidder Technical Marks Financial

Marks

Evaluated Cost Rules/Regulation/SBD/Policy/

acceptance as per Rules 35 of

AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.2350/-

Medicane

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S KB Enterprises

Rawalpindi

67 N/A Rs.2600/-

Medicane 1.8

ml

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.2850/-

Korea

3rd

Lowest Bidder

M/S Ijaz Enterprisers Rawalpindi 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No. 2 Needles Dental ` 27G D/A Short. Pack of 100 or less packed in carton.


Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017


Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.595/-Pearl

Dent/ CN

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine 69 N/A Rs.670/- H-DENT 2nd

Lowest Bidder

2

Corporation Lahore


Rwp.

67 N/A Rs.680/- 3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.850/- China 4th Lowest Bidder


Item No3 Needles Dental 27G D/A Long. Pack of 100 or less packed in carton.

S.No. Name of Bidder Technical

Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017


Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.595/-Pearl

Dent/ CN

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.670/- H-

DENT

2nd

Lowest Bidder


Rwp.

67 N/A Rs.680/- 3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology Islamabad



Item No4 Composite filling Material kit large complete (3M). 12s or less packed in carton.


Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad

52 N/A Rs.7500/- Mega-

physilk

(Germany)

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.8450/- T com

6x4gm+5ml+5gm

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.9150/-

IVCOLAR

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.14500/- 4th Lowest Bidder

5 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.15800/- Dia

Dent Korea

5th Lowest Bidder

M/S Pacific International Islamabad 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No6 Glass ionomer (GC)Type II 35gm.Individually packed bottle having mono carton with product.


Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.2890/-

15gm+10gm

Securafill

1st Lowest Bidder

3

2 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad

52 N/A Rs.3200/-20g,

pwd.liq.10gm

Mega-physilk

(Germany)

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs/3850/- GC

JAPAN

3rd

Lowest Bidder


Rawalpindi.


5 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.5500/-Shofu

Japan

5th Lowest Bidder

M/S Fine Corporation Lahore 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No7 Cresophine Bottle 13ml. Individually packed in bottle having mono carton.


Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.3490/- 10ml

Tricresol

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.4350/-

TEHNODENT

2rd

Lowest Bidder


Rwp.



Item No8 Endomethasone Powder/Liquid (14 gm/10 ml).Individually packed in bottle having mono carton with

product.


Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.8750/-

14gm+10ml

Pulp Dent

1st Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs,.13800/-

SEPODENT

2rd

Lowest Bidder


Rwp.



Item No9 GuttaParcha Point 15-40. Pack/Box of 120 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB Enterprises 67 N/A Rs.280/-Gapadent 1st Lowest Bidder


Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.305/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

4

GAPADENT

3 M/S Fine Corporation

Lahore


4 M/S Future

Technology Islamabad

90 N/A Rs. 575/- Dia Dent

Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

M/S KB Enterprises Rawalpindi. 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No10 GuttaParcha Point 45-80. Pack/Box of 120 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.280/-Gapadent 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.305/-

GAPADENT

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore


4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs. 575/- Dia Dent

Korea

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No11 Paper point 15-40. Pack/Box of 200 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.278/- 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.305/-

GAPADENT

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore


4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.450/- Dia Dent

Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

M/S KB Enterprises 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No12 Paper point 45-80. Pack/Box of 200 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises


2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.305/-

GAPADENT

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine 69 N/A Rs.385/- 3th Lowest Bidder

5

Corporation Lahore

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

M/S KB Enterprises 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No13. RCT Reamer 15-40. 6sPacket, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.245/- Mani 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.365/-

LUSTERDENT/CN

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

M/S KB Enterprises Rawalpindi.1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No14. RCT Reamer 45-80. 6sPacket, packed inCarton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises


2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.365/-

LUSTERDENT/CN

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No15. H-Files 15-40 (21mm,25mm).12’sPacket,packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises Rwp.


2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz 64 N/A Rs.320/- 3rd

Lowest Bidder

6

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

LUSTERDENT/CN

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

5 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad


M/S KB Enterprises Rawalpndi. 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No16. H-Files 45-80 (21mm,25mm). 12’sPacket, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises


2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.320/-

LUSTERDENT/CN

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

5 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad



Item No17. K-Files 15-40 (21mm,25mm). 12’sPacket, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises Rwp.


2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.320/-

LUSTERDENT/CN

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No18. K-Files 45-80 (21mm,25mm). 12’sPacket, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

7

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.


2 M/S Fine

Corporation

Lahore

69 N/A Rs.285/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.320/-

LUSTERDENT/CN

3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


Korea

4th Lowest Bidder

5 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad



Item No19. Barbed Broaches. 12s or less Packet, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.445/- MANI/CN 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.600/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad

52 N/A Rs.600/- 3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A

Rs.650/-Dia Dent

Koea

4th Lowest Bidder

5 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.990/- pkt. (10s) 5th Lowest Bidder

M/S Ijaz Enterprises Rawalpindi.1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No20. Diamond Burs (Inverted Cone,Fissure,Round,Tappering Fissure). 03’sPacket, packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.130/- MANI/CN

Pkt. of 3

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.

67 N/A Rs.48/- each 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.49/-each 3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.300/- 05’s pack

China

4th Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Pacific

International

52 N/A Rs.480/-Horico 5th Lowest Bidder

8

Islamabad Germany

M/S Ijaz EnterprisesRawalpindi. 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No24. Hand piece Oil Spray 550ml Bott. Individually packed in bottle having mono carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore


2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.1150/- APPLE/CN 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.2200/- 3rd

Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.3500/-Deconex

Swiss

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No25. Suction Tips D/A100s Pk. Pack of 100 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.345/- CHINA 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.465/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.

67 N/A Rs.480/- Italy 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad


M/S Ijaz Enterprises Rawalpindi 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No26. Dental Mirror Tops Tops. Pack of 12 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.190/- LOCAL 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.

67 N/A Rs.250/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.360/- Local 3rd

Lowest Bidder

9


Item No27. Zinc Phosphate Cement (30gm+20ml) 90gm Pkt. Individually packed bottle having carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.850/- 90gm China 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.2590/-

PROCLINIC

SWEDEN

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.3300/-60gm+30ml 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.6500/- 60

mg+25ml Shofu Japan

4th Lowest Bidder

M/S KB Enterprises Rawalpindi 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No30. Sodium Hypo chloride 250ml. Individually packed in bottle having mono carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.650/-LOCAL 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A i.Rs.1050/- 500 ml

Local

ii.Rs.4900/- 480 ml

USA

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore


4 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.



Item No33. Lignocaine Spray 36gm. Individually packed in bottle having mono carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.

67 N/A Rs 550/-. 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.650/- LIDOCAINE 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.975/-36gm 3th Lowest Bidder


10

Item No. 35 Dental Napkin Medium/large size. Pack of 150 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.5.52 each 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.750/- pkt. of 120

CHINA

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.6.75 each 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.3300/-box of 500

China

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 37 Periapical Dental X-Ray Film 1.5”x1” Pack of 150 or less packed in carton


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Pacific

International

Islamabad

52 N/A Rs4100/- velopex

(UK)

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.4250/-PRIMEX 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.4950/- Skydent E

speed

3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S KB

Enterprises

Rawalpindi.


5 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A i.Rs.4350/- packing of

100 China

ii. Rs.6550/- pkt. of

150 USA

5th Lowest Bidder

M/S Pacific International Islamabad 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No. 38 Clove Oil 50ml. Individually packed in bottle having mono carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.250/-LOCAL 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.295/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

11

3 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.700/- 50ml 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.2650/- 10 ml

Cerkemed Poland

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 40 Articulating paper No. Pack/Box of 120 or less packed in carton.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.95/-Book CHINA 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.650/- USA Red

thin

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.1450/- box of 144

Henryschein USA

3th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 41 Polishing brushes No. Individually packed in Polythene packet Box of 10 or less.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.19/- each 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.22/- CHINA 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.28/- each. 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.475/-Dia Dent

Korea

4th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 44 Calcium Hydroxide 200 gm. Powder/paste bott.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.675/- 100gm 1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.850/-HAQ CHEM 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises



12

Item No. 48 Matrix Band +Retainer No. Pack of 2


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises


2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.650/-CHINA 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.1850/- Local /USA 3th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 49 Matrix Band Strip No. Pack of 12


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi


2 M/S KB

Enterprises

67 N/A Rs.600/- 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.850/- Dentamerica

USA

3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Fine

Corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.1450/- pkt. of 10 4th Lowest Bidder


Item No. 50 Plastic Wedges No. Pack of 50


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi


2 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.650/- Dentamerica

USA

2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises



Item No. 51 Alvogyl Bott.

13


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.5450/- 25gm Alveo

Paste

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.7950/-SEPODENT 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises


M/S

Fine Corporation Lahore 1st lowest responsive Bidder

Item No. 52 Pulperyl Bott.


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S Fine

corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.3750/- 20ml

Paramono chlorofenol

1st Lowest Bidder

2 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.4550/- RUSSIAN 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S KB

Enterprises



Item No. 53 Temporary filling material (cavit)


Marks

Financial

Marks



AJK PPRA Rules 2017

1 M/S KB

Enterprises


2 M/S Fine

corporation Lahore

69 N/A Rs.645/-30gm Provis 2nd

Lowest Bidder

3 M/S Ijaz

Enterprises

Rawalpindi

64 N/A Rs.650/- CAVIT 3th Lowest Bidder

4 M/S Future

Technology

Islamabad

90 N/A Rs.730/-Dia Dent

Korea

4th Lowest Bidder


Executive Director

Jinnah Dental Hospital

Muzaffarabad

Documents

EVALUATION REPORT - AJ&K PPRA · 2020. 1. 23. · PPRA Rules 2017 Rs.16,00000 Technical Financial DENTAL MATERIALS/MEDICINES AND DENTAL X-RAY FILMS Item No.1 Lignocaine Dental cartridge: