Community Consultation Proposed H.W Greenham & Sons Tongala Rendering Plant

spence-consulting.com

Spence Consulting 2

Table of Contents Executive Summary and Recommendations ................................................................................. 3 Project Background ........................................................................................................................ 4 EPA Requirements for Community Consultation ........................................................................... 4 Consultation and Communication Strategy .................................................................................... 5 Feedback Received ....................................................................................................................... 6 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................................... 7

Report Revision 0.1 (Draft) 21 March 2019 For internal review 0.2 (Draft) 21 March 2019 Issued to client for comment 0.3 (Draft) 22 March 2019 Incorporating feedback from client 1.0 (Final) 9 April 2019 Report Preparation Report Prepared By: Cameron Spence, cameron@spence-consulting.com

This document may only be used for the purpose for which it was commissioned and in accordance with the Terms of Engagement for the commission. This document should not be used or copied without written authorisation from H.W Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd and Spence Consulting Group Pty Ltd.

Spence Consulting 3

Executive Summary and Recommendations H.W Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd (Greenham) are planning to recommence rendering operations at their abattoirs at 2121 Finlay Road, Tongala after ceasing rendering at that location in 2004. The new plant will process animal by-products currently trucked offsite, increasing the sustainability of the business and reducing road traffic. Approvals for the proposed rendering plant will be required from Campaspe Shire Council and the Environment Protection Authority (EPA). Greenham appointed Spence Consulting Group, an independent consultant to manage the community consultation process for the EPA Works Approval Process. A thorough consultation and communication strategy was developed and executed in accordance with the EPA Approvals proposal pathway and utilising the International Association for Public Participation’s (IAP2) Public Participation Spectrum. Feedback received through the communication and consultation process indicated support for the project, with no formal concerns identified or submitted. This report details the process undertaken and feedback received on the proposed rendering plant.

Spence Consulting 4

Project Background H.W Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd (Greenham) are planning to recommence rendering operations at their abattoirs at 2121 Finlay Road, Tongala after ceasing rendering at that location in 2004. The new plant will process animal by-products currently trucked offsite, increasing the sustainability of the business and reducing road traffic. The proposed rendering plant will be totally enclosed with roof mounted exhaust fans in a concrete and colorbond® building at the rear of the abattoirs with partial visibility from Finlay & Watsons Road. The closest residence to this facility is approximately 740 metres. The proposed rendering plant will be designed in accordance with best available practice and methods. It will be totally enclosed with roof mounted exhaust fans, with odour from the plant captured through hoods on all odour sources and sent to a bio-filter. The odour from the proposed rendering plant will be less than those from the existing abattoir and waste water treatment ponds. Any noise sources (e.g. from additional machinery and pumps), will be acoustically treated to ensure no off-site noise issues (N.B. Watson Moss Growcott concluded that operation of the proposed facility can comply with the NIRV Recommended Maximum Noise Levels and project design objectives at each of the existing residential noise sensitive receptors during the EPA-defined day, evening and night periods without any additional noise control measures). The proposed rendering plant will reduce the number of current truck movements entering and leaving the premises, from on average 5 daily truck movements associated with the rendering process to 2 truck movements.

EPA Requirements for Community Consultation The community consultation process was undertaken in accordance with the EPA Approvals proposal pathway and utilising the International Association for Public Participation’s (IAP2) Public Participation Spectrum. Based on assessment of the overall impact of the proposed rendering plant, the process undertaken followed the first two steps of the IAP2 Public Participation Spectrum:

Spence Consulting 5

Consultation and Communication Strategy In preparation for the EPA Works Approval Application, a consultation and communication strategy was developed to guide the process and ensure stakeholder feedback contributed to the ongoing development of the proposed project. The communication and consultation process undertaken was as follows: A formal community consultation process was undertaken over a period of 28 days, commencing Wednesday 27th February 2019 and concluding Wednesday 27th March 2019. Public notice of the project inviting stakeholder feedback was advertised as follows:

1. Herald Sun – Wednesday 27th February 2019 2. Kyabram Free Press – Wednesday 27th February 2019 3. Echuca Riverine Herald – Wednesday 27th February 2019

The advertisement directed interested parties on how to obtain additional details and provide feedback on the project (refer Appendix 1 for Herald Sun advertisement). Details of the proposed rendering plant, a project factsheet (refer Appendix 2), plans, process for obtaining additional details and providing feedback (feedback form, refer Appendix 3) were uploaded to both the Greenham and Spence Consulting Group websites on Wednesday 27th February 2019. In addition to the public notice, a project factsheet was distributed to all residences in the township of Tongala on Friday March 1st and plans for the project made available for viewing at the Tongala IGA, 31 Mangan St, Tongala (Appendix 4).

Spence Consulting 6

Nine local residences within close proximity to the proposed rendering plant were approached directly to provide details on the project and seek feedback on the 18th and 19th February. Refer to Appendix 5 for map of the residences contacted. On March 8th, the three businesses nearest to the proposed plant were also visited seeking feedback on the project. The three businesses approached were Cop Rice, Sltec and Prestige Stainless. A community drop-in session was undertaken at the Tongala Football and Netball Club between 4.00pm and 8.00pm on Wednesday 20th March 2019 as a mechanism to inform and consult the local community on the project and seek feedback.

Feedback Received Feedback received through the communication and consultation process indicated support for the project, with no formal concerns identified or submitted. Three community members attended the community drop-in session on 20th March, each stating that they had attended to hear about the proposal in more detail. Questions in particular were raised in relation to the following aspects of the project:

1. Potential odours from the proposed plant 2. Changes to traffic around the area as a direct consequence of the plant 3. The creation of any new employment opportunities for the local community

Similarly, these items were the primary questions raised through the direct approach to the nine local residences and local businesses in proximity to the proposed plant. On each of the key items identified, stakeholders were advised the following:

Potential odours from the proposed plant The proposed rendering plant will be totally enclosed with roof mounted exhaust fans, with odour from the plant captured through hoods on all odour sources and sent to a bio-filter. The independent Odour Impact Assessment Study undertaken for the proposed project by The Odour Unit, concluded that “the likelihood of adverse odour impacts from the operation of and emissions from the proposed plant is low and satisfies EPA guidelines”. Changes to traffic around the area as a direct consequence of the rendering plant The proposed rendering plant will reduce the number of current truck movements entering and leaving the premises related to the rendering process. Currently on average five daily truck movements associated with the rendering process leave the plant for transport to Laverton North where the rendering process is undertaken. The proposed rendering plant will reduce this to two daily truck movements.

Spence Consulting 7

The creation of any new employment opportunities for the local community The proposed rendering plant is expected to create four new employment opportunities at Greenhams Tongala facility.

All those engaged identified that they were satisfied with the information received regarding the proposed facility and that they had no specific concerns with the proposal. The three community members who attended the community drop-in session indicated their support for the project proceeding.

Conclusion A thorough consultation and communication strategy was undertaken in accordance with the EPA Approvals proposal pathway and utilising the International Association for Public Participation’s (IAP2) Public Participation Spectrum. Based upon the consultation undertaken and feedback received, no concerns were identified in relation to the proposed rendering operations at H.W Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd abattoirs at 2121 Finlay Road, Tongala.

Spence Consulting 9

Cameron Spence Director cameron@spence-consulting.com 0422 005 552 Rob Spence Director rob@spence-consulting.com 0418 132 573 spence-consulting.com

HERALDSUN.COM.AU WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2019 CLASSIFIEDS 63

V1 - MHSE01Z02MA

Kick up your heels

Call 13 11 13

Advertise in

print and online.

Cars For Sale

Fraud is the real dealIf someone is requesting money to be

transferred to an address or account prior

to receiving the goods it may be fraudulent.

Don’t be a wally, exercise caution before

you respond to a request. Always verify

the authenticity of persons requesting your

credit card or bank details prior to making

any transfers. For more info from the experts

visit buysearchsell.com.au/staysafe

Buy & Sell

Wanted to buy

BUYING 1966 50 CENT COINSAllAustralianpre-decimal silvercoins and banknotes, all goldcoins, world coins andbanknotes, tokens, medals,badges and militaria. TOPPRICES PAID/ SELL atAuction. www.statusint.com

I.S.Wright ✆9650-2345241LonsdaleStMelbourne

DECEASED ESTATES CASH

Old furn china + bric☎ 0419 509 111

Real Estate

Apartments for Rent

Aircon BedSit Studios Suit F 50+FRANKSTON$210 -$240/w

IncBillsOptFurn close train☎ 90123445 0425778761

Boarding &Residence

EasternSuburbs$195/pw inc all bills FF single

roomsuit oldermatureworking/retiredmale.

0481 267 100

FOOTSCRAY - FF lge roomclose to rail/shops - single onlyNo bond/bills ☎ 0425 754 799

CommercialProperty - For Lease

SharedAccommodation

BERWICK $180-$195/wFRANKSTON $180-$195/w

Inc Bills suit F 50+ opt Furnsome aircon close train/shops.

☎ 9012 3445 or 0425 778 761

RICHMONDHOTELROOMFOR$275p/w0409 357 614

Travel &Entertainment

Clairvoyants &PsychicsSPIRITUALHEALERMASTERNAFOULOH

Expert inbringingbacklovedones, success in

business, career,breaking thepowerofblackmagic andevileyes andmuchmore!

0452 610 989

Travel &Entertainment

Health Care

A MASSAGEOpen every day. Swe,Californian, Lomi Lomi

0466 232 343 ARC

THE VILLA RETREATOne of a kind. Fab Meals.

Early Inn, Late Out.TOTAL BODY

Massage. Painless Wax.Scrubs. Mud Baths etc.

7 Days till Late9752 2169

Motoring

Caravans & Trailers

CARAVANS WANTEDAnyAge,Makeor

Condition.Ca$hPaid✆ 0417 373 338

Cars Wanted

OLD&DAMAGED

Cars min $250 Drive inComplete IMLACHS

Springvale LMCT1229

☎ 1300 652 070

TOYOTASWANTEDAll typesofmodels, anycondition, payment today

0418315723ABN:96102238353

Marine & Boating

WEBUYBOATS

WE COME TO YOU

$$$ PAID TODAY

☎ 1300 306 972

Nice one!

Adults

Adult Entertainment

HOTHOT LADIESLADIES19011901 144144 144144$1.98$1.98 perper minmin pay/mobpay/mob extraextra

Adults

Adult Services

PARAMOUR OF COLLINS STREET

SEXYLADIES

Melbourne’s longeststanding & most trusted

CBD escort service"You can always call us back 26 yrs est"Melbourne CBD 18 - 60 YearsVisiting you. Very discreetSee pictures of our actual ladies

Privacy and respect anda proper luxury service

Call Paramour Of Collins

Our name is your guarantee!

www.paramour.com.au

Ph: 9650 3295(SWA113E)

Introductions

ASIAN LADY SPECIALISTExclusive introduction agency

we have a large database ofquality Asian ladies lookingfor genuine relationships.

♥ Please Call9670-4551 ♥

www.metropersonal.com.au

Trades

Vehicle Removal

OLDCARSWANTED!DEADorALIVE!

ToDisposeof aCarCall TARNobodyPaysMore

$$$$$$$$thanTotalAutoRecyclers

Ph:1300365221LMCT-9094www.tar.com.au

TRUCKS CARS VANS UTESGET $$$ NOW - In Any ConditionLMCT 9877 FREE PICK UPS☎ 9308 6555 or 0412 333 830

David BenbowChief Executive Offi cerPublic Trustee116 Murray Street, Hobart116 Murray Street, Hobarttpt@publictrustee.tas.gov.autpt@publictrustee.tas.gov.au

1800 068 7841800 068 784

www.publictrustee.tas.gov.au

In relation to the estate of the above-named, who was born in Launceston on 10 January 1962 and died on 7 April 2018 in Devonport,

Would William James Matthews Would William James Matthews

Or anyone claiming by, through, or under him, Or anyone claiming by, through, or under him, whether by derivative title or otherwise (But Not whether by derivative title or otherwise (But Not those persons who have already given notice of their those persons who have already given notice of their claim to the Public Trustee)claim to the Public Trustee)

Please Notify the Public Trustee of 116 Murray Street Please Notify the Public Trustee of 116 Murray Street Hobart in Tasmania of his or her claim or interest Hobart in Tasmania of his or her claim or interest in the estate of Peter John Anthony Wescombe in the estate of Peter John Anthony Wescombe within thirty (30) days of the publication of this within thirty (30) days of the publication of this advertisement.advertisement.

Take Notice that unless notifi cation of such claim Take Notice that unless notifi cation of such claim is received by the Public Trustee within thirty (30) is received by the Public Trustee within thirty (30) days of the publication hereof the Public Trustee days of the publication hereof the Public Trustee may distribute the estate concerned or any part of may distribute the estate concerned or any part of it without regard to such claim or claims pursuant to it without regard to such claim or claims pursuant to Section 65 of the Public Trustee Act 1930.Section 65 of the Public Trustee Act 1930.

ESTATE OF PETER JOHN ANTHONY

WESCOMBE

also known as PETER JOHN SIMMONS

and PETER MATTHEWS

List it now at buysearchsell.com.au

Not quite right?Advertise it online for free!*

*Free ads are only available for private party advertisers in participating For Sale classifications.Conditions Apply.Visit www.buysearchsell.com.au/free ads for full details.

HERITAGE ACT 2017

Registered Heritage Place No H0126, Permit NumberP30408

SPURLING HOUSE 38 BLACK STREET BRIGHTONPLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT an application underSection 93 of the Heritage Act 2017 for a permit todemolish the residence Spurling House has beenlodged with the Executive Director, Heritage Victoria.

A copy of the application is available for inspection atwww.heritage.vic.gov.au or at the offices of HeritageVictoria at 8 Nicholson Street, East Melbourne,between the hours of 10.00am and 4.00pm, byappointment only. Telephone (03) 9938 6891 to makean appointment.Any person may lodge a submission in respect of theapplication within 14 days of publication of this notice.Submissions must be in writing and addressed toHeritage Victoria PO Box 500 Melbourne 8002. Pleasenote that any written submission received will betreated as a public document.

EXECUTIVE DIRECTORHERITAGE VICTORIA

Proposed HW Greenham & SonsTongala Rendering Plant -Community Consultation

HW Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd are proposing torecommence rendering operations at their abattoirs at2121 Finlay Road, Tongala after ceasing rendering in2004.

The new state of the art plant will process animal by-products currently trucked offsite, increasing thesustainability of the business and reducing road traffic.Approvals are required from Campaspe Shire Counciland the EPA. Following approval, the plant is proposed tobe built in the second half of 2019.

The community are invited to provide feedback on theproposed project by 27 March 2019.

A community drop-in session has been scheduled to allowinterested parties to learn more about the project, speakto our technical experts and provide feedback.

Details of the session are as follows:When: Wednesday, 20 March 2019, 4pm – 8pm.Where: Tongala Football & Netball Club, Doug Nicholls

Drive, Tongala Victoria 3620.Feedback received will help inform the application for anEPA works approval for the project.

Details of the project and contact details are available atwww.greenham.com.au/feedback.html.

CLEANING SERVICES

�

�

�

Regular cleaning

Window cleaning

End of lease

Carpet cleaning NOW AVAILABLE!

�

�

Spring cleaning

Once off cleaningand more!

13 2613 Free, no obligation quotes

viphomeservices.com.au

Application forPackaged Liquor Licence

Woolworths Group Limitedof 1 Woolworths Way,Bella Vista, New SouthWales applied to theVictorian Commission forGambling and LiquorRegulation on 26February 2019 for thegrant of a packaged liquorlicence for premises to beknown as BWS – Beer,Wine, Spirits, to besituate at 76 DoncasterRoad, Balwyn North,Victoria.

Any person may object tothe grant of thisapplication on thegrounds of:

•it would detract from, orbe detrimental to, theamenity of the area inwhich the premises aresituated; and/or

•it would be conducive toor encourage the misuseor abuse of alcohol.

An objection must statethe reasons for theobjection. All objectionsare treated as publicdocuments. Objectionsmust be made in writingto:

The Victorian Commissionfor Gambling and LiquorRegulation, GPO Box1988, Melbourne, Vic,3001.

Objections must be madewithin 30 days of the dateof this notice.

CFMEU - Construction andGeneral Division BranchMeeting to be held onWednesday 27 FEBRUARY,CFMEU, 7th Floor,540 Elizabeth St, Melbourneat 5pm.Authorised John Setka,Branch Secretary

Victorian I Security Pty/Ltd of318 William Street, Melbourne3000 has made the applicationto the Licensing & RegulationDivision for a Private SecurityBusiness Licence to provide theservices of Unarmed guards,Static guarding & CrowdControllers. Any personwishing to object to thegranting of the licence has 14days from the date of thisadvertisement to lodge anobjection in writing to Licensing& Regulation Division, GPO Box2807, Melbourne Vic 3001.

Legal Notices

Caught On Camera of 16Glenshee Drive Lynbrook 3975has made application to theLicensing and RegulationDivision for a Private SecurityBusiness Registration toprovide the services of SecurityAdvisor and SecurityEquipment Installer. Anyperson wishing to object to thegranting of this registration has14 days from the date of thisadvertisement to lodge anobjection in writing to Licensingand Regulation Division, GPOBox2807MelbourneVIC3001.

FORM 11 Rule 5.11NOTICE OF

WINDING UP ORDER ANDOF APPOINTMENTOF LIQUIDATOR

IN THE FEDERAL COURTOF AUSTRALIAAT VICTORIA

IN THE MATTER OFCONCORD BUILDERS GROUP P/L

( IN LIQUIDATION )ACN: 165 463 196

On 22nd February 2019 -the Federal Court of Australiain Proceeding No. VID 72 of 2019ordered the winding up of -Concord Builders Group Pty. Ltd.and I was appointed liquidator ofthe company.

Dated this 25th day of February 2019.

Name and address of liquidator:

Stirling L. Horne

PKF Melbourne440 Collins StreetMELBOURNE. 3000

Call 13 11 13

General Notices

Notices

Environment Protection Act 1970Licence Amendment Application

Environment Protection Authority (EPA) Victoria has received the following application to issue a works approval or licence which permits work to be undertaken which will result in a discharge of waste to the environment or an increase or alteration in an existing discharge.

3035036 Schutz Australia Pty Ltd of 13-15 Burr Court Laverton North Victoria 3026 are seeking approval for their upgraded wastewater treatment plant. The plant treats wastewaters from the washing of used small volume refillable containers and IBCs. Vacuum distillation technology replaces treatment by flocculation and settling. Water is distilled from wastewater and discharged to sewer, resulting residues are removed off-site by a licensed waste transfer company.

A copy or a summary of this application, accompanying plans, specifications and other information can be downloaded from our website at www.epa.vic.gov.au. under ‘Works approval and licence applications open for comment’. Interested persons may, within 21 days of the date of advertisement, comment in writing on the application and may request in writing to be notified if the works approval/licence is issued. All comments must be made by email to works.approvals@epa.vic.gov.au or by mail to EPA Victoria GPO Box 4395 Melbourne Victoria 3001 Please note that any comments received will usually be made publicly available. Further details please contact 1300 372 842.

VG6976

PROPOSAL TO UPGRADE AN EXISTING MOBILE PHONEBASE STATION AT:

380 Bourke Street, Melbourne, 3000 VIC

Telstra Site ID: Melbourne 380 Bourke St

• The proposed works include the removal of three (3) existing panelantennas and the installation of three (3) new panel antennas (each nomore than 2.8m long) on existing mounts for LTE700, LTE 2100 and LTE2600,the installation of three (3) new AIR antennas on proposed longer mounts,the installation of three (3) new remote radio units, and the relocation ofexisting ancillary equipment.

• This notification is undertaken in accordance with the requirements ofSection 7 of the Mobile Phone Base Station Deployment Code 2018.

• Telstra regards the proposed installation as a Low-impact Facilityunder the Telecommunications (Low-impact Facilities) Determination 2018("The Determination") based on the description above.

• Further information can be obtained from Garrett Wong at Aurecon (onbehalf of Telstra) on 03 9975 3208 or email: Garrett.Wong@aurecongroup.com and at www.RFNSA.com.au/3000118

• Written submissions should be sent to: PO Box 23061, Docklands, VIC, 8012by 5pm on 12th March 2019.

02.26.2019 18:53 NewsCorp Australia - Tearsheet ©

Appendix 1Aa

Factsheet: Proposed HW Greenham & Sons Rendering Plant

HW Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd (Greenham) are planning to recommence rendering operations at their abattoirs at 2121 Finlay Road, Tongala after ceasing rendering in 2004.

The new state of the art plant will process animal by-products currently trucked offsite, increasing the sustainability of the business and reducing road traffic.

What is rendering?

Rendering is a process that involves crushing and 'cooking' animal materials into stable, useable products such as tallow and bone meal that is used in the manufacture of soaps and stock feeds.

The proposed rendering plant will be enclosed, with odour captured at the source and directed to a bio-filter. All stages of processing will strictly comply with EPA Victoria standards.

What will the rendering plant look like?

The proposed rendering plant will be fully enclosed in a concrete and colorbond® shed at the rear of the abattoirs with partial visibility from Finlay & Watsons Road. The closest residence to this facility is approximately 700 metres.

Are there any impacts?

The proposed rendering plant will be designed in accordance with best available practice and methods.

It will be fully enclosed, with odour from the plant captured through hoods on all odour sources and sent to a bio-filter. The odour from the proposed rendering plant will be less than those from the existing abattoir and waste water treatment ponds.

Any noise sources, e.g. from additional machinery and pumps, will be acoustically treated to ensure no off-site noise issues.

The proposed rendering plant will reduce the number of current truck movements entering and leaving the premises.

Are any approvals required?

Approvals for the proposed rendering plant will be required from Campaspe Shire Council and the Environment Protection Authority (EPA). Anyone interested will have the opportunity to object or raise issues with the Council or EPA.

An agreement will also be required with Goulburn Valley Water to accept waste water from the proposed plant.

Following approval, the plant is proposed to be built in the second half of 2019.

Where can I view the plans?

Plans of the proposed rendering plant and shed are available for viewing at:

IGA store, 31 Mangan Street, Tongala; or online at: www.greenham.com.au/feedback.html

How can I have my say?

Greenham has appointed an independent consultant, Spence Consulting Group, to manage the community consultation and prepare a report for the EPA. The Council planning permit application will be undertaken as a separate process.

Spence Consulting Group is seeking feedback on the proposed rendering plant. Your comments are requested by 27 March 2019.

A feedback form is available at: www.spence-consulting.com/greenham

You're invited to a drop-in session

A drop-in session is planned at the Tongala Football & Netball Club between 4pm and 8pm on Wednesday 20 March 2019. Come down and discuss the proposal at Doug Nicholls Drive, Tongala Vic 3620.

You can view the plans, ask any questions you might have and complete a feedback form in person.

Questions?

If you have any questions, please contact Spence Consulting Group:

Cameron Spence 0422 005 552 Rob Spence 0418 132 573 Email: contact@spence-consulting.com

Appendix 2

Please return this feedback form to Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd, c/o: Spence Consulting Group

Email: contact@spence-consulting.com 154 Charles Street, Northcote VIC 3070

by 27 March 2019

Please return this feedback form to Greenham & Sons Pty Ltd, c/o Spence Consulting Group Email: contact@spence-consulting.com Mail: 154 Charles Street Northcote VIC 3070 by 27 March 2019.

PROPOSED HW GREENHAM & SONS RENDERING PLANT - FEEDBACK FORM

Do you have any concerns regarding the proposed rendering plant?

Yes / No

If so, what are these concerns?

How can we address these concerns?

Do you have any other comments or feedback?

Would you like to be kept informed on the progress of the project? Yes / No

Please provide your contact details:

Address:

Name (optional):

Contact number (optional):

Email address (optional):

Appendix 3

Appendix 4

Appendix 5

Spence Consulting 9

Cameron Spence Director cameron@spence-consulting.com 0422 005 552

Rob Spence Director rob@spence-consulting.com 0418 132 573

spence-consulting.com