7
Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder KIRSTEN HOLMBERG 1 & ANDERS HJERN 2,3 1 Department of Woman and Child Health, Neuropaediatric Unit, Karolinska Institute, Astrid Lindgren Children Hospital, Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden, 2 Department of Women’s and Children’s Health, Section for Paediatrics, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, and 3 Centre for Epidemiology, National Board of Health and Welfare, Stockholm, Sweden Abstract Aim: To assess recurrent subjective health complaints in Swedish schoolchildren with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Methods: Cohort study of 577 fourth-graders (10-y-olds) in one municipality in Stockholm County. All children were screened for attention and behaviour problems through interviews with their parents and teachers. Children with high scores underwent further clinical and cognitive assessments. Information about health complaints was collected from the children themselves in a classroom questionnaire. The 516 children for whom there was information from all three data sources were included in the final study population. Hypotheses were tested in multivariate analyses with adjustment for sex and parental education. Results: Recurrent abdominal pain (RAP), sleeping problems and tiredness were associated with ADHD (stratified relative risks: 2.2 [1.4 3.4], 1.7 [1.1 2.7] and 2.7 [1.7 4.1], respectively), while there was no association with headache. Conclusion: This study indicates that treatment strategies for children with ADHD need to include an effective evaluation and treatment of RAP, tiredness and sleeping disturbances. Evaluation of ADHD should be considered in children with recurrent health complaints. Key Words: ADHD, health complaints, psychosomatic, schoolchildren Introduction Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) [1] is one of the most common child psychiatric distur- bances, affecting 3 5% of school-aged children in Swedish population-based studies, and 7 10% if children with less severe symptoms are included [2 4]. The core symptoms of ADHD (inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity) [1] are often associated with troublesome interpersonal relationships with family members and peers as well as difficulties in the classroom [5,6]. Cognitive impairments overlap to a certain extent with ADHD and may further complicate the situation in school [7]. Children from households with a disadvantaged socio-eco- nomic situation are more often diagnosed with ADHD [8]. Subjective health complaints refer to symptoms experienced by the child with or without a defined diagnosis [9]. Common childhood health complaints include pain syndromes such as headaches, recurrent abdominal pain (RAP) and back pain [9 11] as well as symptoms of a more psychological nature *irrit- ability, nervousness, sleeping difficulties and daytime tiredness [9,12]. Recurrent pain appears to have negative effects on the development of children with associated school problems and is frequently the cause of absence from school [9]. Recent analyses of a nationally representative sample of Swedish children in the ages 10 18 y have demonstrated that troubled relations with peers and parents and economic stress in the family are risk factors for health complaints [13]. Con- sidering this, it seems reasonable to hypothesize that subjective health complaints might be more common in children diagnosed with ADHD. We decided to test this hypothesis in a population- based sample of Swedish fourth-graders in a suburb of Stockholm, and include factors for intellectual impairment and indicators of socio-economic dis- advantage. (Received 28 November 2005; accepted 24 March 2006) ISSN 0803-5253 print/ISSN 1651-2227 online # 2006 Taylor & Francis DOI: 10.1080/08035250600717121 Correspondence: Kirsten Holmberg, Neuropaediatric Unit, Karolinska Institute, Astrid Lindgren Children’s Hospital, Q2:07, Karolinska University Hospital, SE-171 76 Stockholm, Sweden. Tel: /46 8 517 77341. E-mail: [email protected] Acta Pædiatrica, 2006; 95: 664 670

Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivitydisorder

KIRSTEN HOLMBERG1 & ANDERS HJERN2,3

1Department of Woman and Child Health, Neuropaediatric Unit, Karolinska Institute, Astrid Lindgren Children Hospital,

Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden, 2Department of Women’s and Children’s Health, Section for Paediatrics,

Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden, and 3Centre for Epidemiology, National Board of Health and Welfare, Stockholm,

Sweden

AbstractAim: To assess recurrent subjective health complaints in Swedish schoolchildren with attention-deficit/hyperactivitydisorder (ADHD). Methods: Cohort study of 577 fourth-graders (10-y-olds) in one municipality in Stockholm County. Allchildren were screened for attention and behaviour problems through interviews with their parents and teachers. Childrenwith high scores underwent further clinical and cognitive assessments. Information about health complaints was collectedfrom the children themselves in a classroom questionnaire. The 516 children for whom there was information from all threedata sources were included in the final study population. Hypotheses were tested in multivariate analyses with adjustmentfor sex and parental education. Results: Recurrent abdominal pain (RAP), sleeping problems and tiredness were associatedwith ADHD (stratified relative risks: 2.2 [1.4�3.4], 1.7 [1.1�2.7] and 2.7 [1.7�4.1], respectively), while there was noassociation with headache.

Conclusion: This study indicates that treatment strategies for children with ADHD need to include an effective evaluationand treatment of RAP, tiredness and sleeping disturbances. Evaluation of ADHD should be considered in children withrecurrent health complaints.

Key Words: ADHD, health complaints, psychosomatic, schoolchildren

Introduction

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) [1]

is one of the most common child psychiatric distur-

bances, affecting 3�5% of school-aged children in

Swedish population-based studies, and 7�10% if

children with less severe symptoms are included [2�4]. The core symptoms of ADHD (inattention,

hyperactivity and impulsivity) [1] are often associated

with troublesome interpersonal relationships with

family members and peers as well as difficulties in

the classroom [5,6]. Cognitive impairments overlap to

a certain extent with ADHD and may further

complicate the situation in school [7]. Children

from households with a disadvantaged socio-eco-

nomic situation are more often diagnosed with

ADHD [8].

Subjective health complaints refer to symptoms

experienced by the child with or without a defined

diagnosis [9]. Common childhood health complaints

include pain syndromes such as headaches, recurrent

abdominal pain (RAP) and back pain [9�11] as well

as symptoms of a more psychological nature*irrit-

ability, nervousness, sleeping difficulties and daytime

tiredness [9,12]. Recurrent pain appears to have

negative effects on the development of children with

associated school problems and is frequently the cause

of absence from school [9].

Recent analyses of a nationally representative

sample of Swedish children in the ages 10�18 y

have demonstrated that troubled relations with

peers and parents and economic stress in the family

are risk factors for health complaints [13]. Con-

sidering this, it seems reasonable to hypothesize

that subjective health complaints might be more

common in children diagnosed with ADHD. We

decided to test this hypothesis in a population-

based sample of Swedish fourth-graders in a suburb

of Stockholm, and include factors for intellectual

impairment and indicators of socio-economic dis-

advantage.

(Received 28 November 2005; accepted 24 March 2006)

ISSN 0803-5253 print/ISSN 1651-2227 online # 2006 Taylor & Francis

DOI: 10.1080/08035250600717121

Correspondence: Kirsten Holmberg, Neuropaediatric Unit, Karolinska Institute, Astrid Lindgren Children’s Hospital, Q2:07, Karolinska University Hospital,

SE-171 76 Stockholm, Sweden. Tel: �/46 8 517 77341. E-mail: [email protected]

Acta Pædiatrica, 2006; 95: 664�670

Page 2: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Subjects and methods

The entire study population comprised all 577

children (282 girls, 295 boys) in the fourth grade

(20 born in 1990, 539 born in 1991, 18 born in 1992)

during the academic year 2001�2002 in Sigtuna, a

municipality in Stockholm County. All schools (main-

stream as well as special) in the municipality partici-

pated in data collection. Ethical approval for the study

was granted by the ethics committee at Karolinska

Institute, Stockholm.

Child interviews

Information about health complaints was collected

from the children themselves in a classroom study.

The questionnaire included four items from the

questionnaire used in the WHO study ‘‘Health

Behaviour of School-aged Children: headache, ab-

dominal pain, difficulties in falling asleep and day

tiredness’’ [9,12]. The frequency of pain symptoms

was classified on four levels (never, once a month,

once a week, daily), as suggested by Hagquist [14].

The questionnaire was administered by the school

nurse. Children who were absent from school at the

time of the classroom study were approached by the

school nurse within the next few weeks and given a

second opportunity to fill in the questionnaire. In the

end, questionnaires from 97% of the children were

returned.

Parent interviews

Parents were asked to complete a questionnaire in

connection with a routine health examination of their

fourth-grade children. This questionnaire included

Conners’ 10-item scale [15], the executive functions

screening scale (EFSS), and some questions about the

socio-demographic characteristics of the household.

The EFSS was designed especially for this study to

identify children with attention problems who are not

hyperactive or impulsive. It consisted of 17 items

pertaining to passive and slow behaviour and learning

difficulties, and has been presented in detail elsewhere

[16]. The socio-demographic questions included

sex of the child, maternal country of birth and

maternal educational level. Educational level was

recorded in three categories: 9 y or less of basic

education, more than 9 y of basic education but less

than 3 y of university education, and 3 or more

years of university education. Maternal country of

birth was recorded as Sweden, other Nordic coun-

tries, other European countries, and the rest of the

world. Parent questionnaires for 91.9% of the chil-

dren were returned.

Teacher interviews

The Conners’ scale and the EFSS were distributed to

the children’s teachers together with the ADHD

symptom scale according to the Diagnostic and

Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition

(DSM-IV) [1]. Each teacher was also interviewed by

the first author (KH) regarding learning and beha-

viour problems. Information from the teachers was

received for all children in the study.

Clinical assessment

A score of at least 10 (possible range of scores 0�30)

on the Conners’ scale was used as the cut-off point

that indicated behavioural problems, as suggested by

earlier studies [3]. In this cohort, 10.2% scored above

the cut-off point in the parent reports and 13.4% in

the teacher reports. In the EFSS, a score of at least 17

(possible range of scores 0�51) indicated behavioural

problems, learning problems, or both [16]. At this

cut-off, 10.5% and 16.8% of the children had such

problems according to the assessments of the parents

and teachers, respectively. Children were considered

for inclusion in the clinical part of the study according

to the following criteria: 1) ratings above the cut-off

points on at least two questionnaires, and 2) a rating

above the cut-off point on at least one questionnaire in

combination with significant problems reported by

the teacher, such as a known developmental disorder

or if the child had had to repeat a grade.

On the basis of these inclusion criteria, 160 children

were screened positive. Of these, 145 (91%) agreed to

participate in a clinical assessment by the first author

(KH), which included a structured diagnostic inter-

view with the parents focusing on general paediatric

and developmental issues, as detailed in a previous

paper [16]. The ADHD symptom scale according to

DSM-IV was completed by the parents at the end of

the interview. The parents were offered a psychologi-

cal examination for their child, including a cognitive

assessment according to WISC-III [17]. Psychological

examinations were performed on 124 children. All

parents were later invited back to receive feedback on

their child’s test results and to discuss possible further

interventions.

Clinical outcomes

ADHD symptoms were categorized by KH into four

different categories based on information from the

parents, the teachers and the clinical assessment. The

four categories, ‘‘pervasive ADHD’’, ‘‘situational

ADHD’’, ‘‘subthreshold ADHD’’, and ‘‘no ADHD’’,

were classified at the time of the clinical assessment

according to the following criteria: i) ‘‘pervasive

ADHD’’*children who met criteria for ADHD

Health complaints in children with ADHD 665

Page 3: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

according to DSM-IV (six or more inattentive symp-

toms, six or more hyperactive-impulsive symptoms, or

both) at home according to the parent or at school

according to the teacher, with some impairment from

the symptoms in both settings; ii) ‘‘situational AD-

HD’’*children who fulfilled the criteria for ADHD

either at home according to the parent but not the

teacher (home-only ADHD) or at school according to

the teacher but not the parents (school-only ADHD)

and with no reported impairment from the symptoms

in the other setting [18]; iii) ‘‘subthreshold AD-

HD’’*children with four or five inattentive symp-

toms, four or five hyperactive-impulsive symptoms, or

both at home, in school, or both at home and in

school [19]; iv) ‘‘no ADHD’’*all other children,

including those who were not selected for clinical

assessment. Impairment was assessed through parent

and teacher interviews. Information about ADHD-

related symptoms present before the age of 7 y was

collected from records at Child Health Centres and

parent interviews.

Attention and hyperactivity symptoms in the 15

screen-positive children who did not participate in the

clinical examination were assessed by information

from parent and teacher questionnaires, teacher inter-

views, school nurses, and some telephone interviews

of parents. None of the drop-outs were judged to have

severe behavioural or attention problems, and were

therefore included in the study population in the ‘‘no

ADHD’’ group.

Statistical analysis

Dichotomized outcome variables of health complaints

were created by defining symptoms present at least

once a week as ‘‘yes’’ and all other symptoms as ‘‘no’’.

Daytime tiredness was defined as ‘‘yes’’ only if present

every day. Associations of these variables with the

categories ‘‘pervasive ADHD’’ and ‘‘situational

ADHD’’ collapsed into a single group were tested in

a stratified analysis adjusted for gender and parental

educational level using the Mantel-Haenzel procedure

[20]. Chi-squared analyses were used in vicariate

analyses. Statistical analyses were carried out using

the SAS 8.0 software package for Windows.

Results

Children for whom there was information from all

three data sources*the child, the parent and the

teacher*were included in the final study population.

They comprised 89.4% (516/577) of all children in

grade four in Sigtuna.

Of the 516 children surveyed, 264 were boys (51%)

and 252 were girls (49%). Twenty-one children were

being educated in small groups because of special

education needs. Four of these children attended a

special school for children with mild mental retarda-

tion. Nineteen per cent of the children had mothers

with a university degree, while another 56% had

at least some secondary education. Fourteen per

cent of the children had mothers who were born

outside Europe, while 23% had a foreign-born mother

(Table I).

The overall prevalence of complete (pervasive)

ADHD syndrome was 5.6% (29/516); 75.9% (22/

29) had the combined type, 20.7% (6/29) were of the

inattentive type, and 3.4% (1/29) were hyperactive-

impulsive according to DSM-IV [1]. Both ‘‘pervasive’’

and ‘‘situational ADHD’’ were more common in boys

than girls (boys 18.2%, girls 5.2%; pB/ 0.001) and in

children from households where the parents had little

education (ADHD 18.8%) compared to households

where parents had a university education (8.1%) (pB/

0.05). There were no major differences in the

prevalence of ADHD in children from foreign-born

Table I. Socio-demographic variables in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Socio-demographic

variables n %

No ADHD

(n�/420) %

Subthreshold ADHD

(n�/35)

%

Situational ADHD

(n�/32)

%

Pervasive ADHD

(n�/29)

%

Sex

Boys 264 51 74 8 9 9

Girls 252 49 89 6 3 2

Maternal education

0�9 y 128 25 75 6 13 6

11�12 y 289 56 82 8 3 7

13�/ y 99 19 87 5 6 2

Country of birth of mother

Sweden 398 77 82 7 6 5

Other Nordic countries 27 5 89 4 0 7

Other European countries 18 4 72 5 17 6

Rest of world 73 14 78 8 6 8

666 K. Holmberg & A. Hjern

Page 4: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

and Swedish-born parents (Table I). The cate-

gory ‘‘situational ADHD’’ comprised children whose

assessments by the parents and the teacher differed

strongly. In this group, 78% (25/32) fulfilled the

DSM-IV criteria in school (school-only ADHD) and

had only a few symptoms at home, while 22% (7/32)

had ADHD symptoms according to the parent and no

impairment in school (home-only ADHD).

Sixty per cent of the children in the study reported

at least one health complaint and 33% at least two

complaints. Difficulties falling asleep were reported

weekly for 40%, headache for 27% and RAP for 23%,

while daytime tiredness occurring each day was

reported for 20%. Girls tended to have slightly higher

prevalences for recurrent headache, RAP and sleeping

disturbances (Table II). Health complaints once a

week tended to be reported less commonly in children

from households where the parents had a university

degree and in children in households where the

parents were born outside Sweden (Table II). The

21 children educated in small groups tended to report

fewer health complaints per week compared with the

other children. Only 14% of the children in small

classes reported two or more health complaints, while

57% reported at least one. The corresponding pre-

valence for children in normal classes was 34% and

60%.

Eighty per cent of the boys in the categories

‘‘pervasive’’ and ‘‘situational ADHD’’ reported at

least one health complaint, while 56% had at least

two complaints, compared with 50% and 25%,

respectively, in boys with ‘‘no ADHD’’. The pattern

was similar in the girls, with the difference that

girls with ‘‘subthreshold ADHD’’ tended to report

higher frequencies of health symptoms compared to

girls with ‘‘no ADHD’’, while boys in the ‘‘subthres-

hold’’ group had rates similar to those of the boys in

the category ‘‘no ADHD’’ (Table III). The crude

relative risk (RR) for RAP in the categories ‘‘perva-

sive’’ and ‘‘situational ADHD’’ compared to the rest

of the population was 2.3, for sleeping problems

1.8, and for tiredness 2.9, while the RR for head-

ache was 1.1.When the analysis was stratified for

maternal education and sex of the child, the RR

decreased slightly to 2.1, 1.7, 2.7 and 1.0, respectively

(Table IV).

Children with ADHD and low cognitive tests scores

(IQB/85) tended to report at least one health com-

plaint slightly less often (70%) than children with

ADHD and a test score in the normal range (IQ]/85)

(84%). In the group with normal test scores, children

with ADHD had higher prevalences of health com-

plaints compared to children without ADHD (pB/

0.001). This was not seen in the group with low test

scores.

Discussion

This population-based study demonstrates that chil-

dren with ADHD report RAP, sleeping problems and

daytime tiredness about twice as often as other

children. The risk increase was similar in children

who fulfilled the ADHD criteria in one or two settings

(home and school).

The symptoms of ADHD often affect relations with

peers, parents and teachers in a negative way [5,6].

Recent studies have demonstrated that poor peer,

teacher and parental relations are associated with

health complaints [12,13,21]. Further investigations

are needed to clarify the role of troubled relations in

the development of health complaints in children

diagnosed with ADHD. Particular attention should

be paid to bullying, which has been demonstrated to

be a particularly important risk factor for health

complaints [12,13,21].

Table II. Socio-demographic variables in children with health complaints.

Socio-demographic

variables n

Headache

%

Recurrent

abdominal

pain

%

Sleeping

problems

%

Daytime

tiredness

%

At least one

complaint

%

At least two

complaints

%

Sex

Boys 264 24 21 36 21 55 30

Girls 252 29 26 43 19 65 35

Maternal education

0�9 y 128 30 26 41 14 63 31

10�12 y 289 26 25 40 24 60 36

13�/ y 99 25 15 37 18 57 26

Country of birth of mother

Sweden 398 29 23 42 21 62 35

Other Nordic countries 27 26 22 44 11 52 30

Other European countries 18 6 28 39 33 61 33

Rest of world 73 19 23 29 19 51 23

Health complaints in children with ADHD 667

Page 5: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

It is also possible that there is a common neurobio-

logical pathway underlying the association between

ADHD and health complaints. Deficits in working

memory and self-regulation that are common in

children with ADHD may impair their ability to

interpret and process stressful stimuli [22]. Hypothe-

tically, the association of ADHD with health com-

plaints could be mediated through disturbances in the

hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis as well as

the sympathetic-adrenal-medullary (SAM) system

[23]. Neurophysiological connections between stress

and ADHD are an important area for future explora-

tion in ADHD research.

ADHD and, to a certain extent, health complaints

are associated with socio-economic disadvantage. In

the stratified analysis, however, the relative risk of

ADHD for health complaints decreased only margin-

ally when parental education was adjusted for, sug-

gesting that the socio-economic situation of children

with ADHD does not explain the association of

ADHD to health complaints.

Several earlier studies have demonstrated a ten-

dency for headache and RAP to vary in a similar

manner in relation to important risk factors [10,21].

This study, however, demonstrates an association

between ADHD and RAP but not with headache,

thereby duplicating results from a study by Egger

et al. [24]. This could be an artefact related to our

comparatively small study populations of children

with ADHD, but is otherwise an intriguing finding,

suggesting a specific mechanism for ADHD as a risk

factor for RAP.

Children with significant impaired behaviour in one

or two settings reported increased prevalences of

health complaints. Most of the children had ‘‘perva-

sive ADHD’’ of the combined type (inattention,

hyperactivity and impulsivity), and teachers also

reported high frequencies of inattentive, hyperactive

and impulsive behaviour in children in the ‘‘school-

only ADHD’’ group. This observation suggests that

behaviour problems in school may result in relation

problems with peers and teachers and secondary

psychosomatic symptoms, or the other way around,

even if the home situation is balanced.

While girls with ADHD problems in the ‘‘subthres-

hold’’ group reported health complaints more fre-

quently than girls with ‘‘no ADHD’’, this was not

observed in the boys. This might be some support for

claims that ADHD symptoms in girls are not recog-

nized as easily as in boys, since girls are less

hyperactive [25]. An alternative explanation could

be that less severe behavioural disturbances affect the

social relations of girls more than of boys, as has been

suggested by Blackman and Hinshaw [26].

Sleep disturbances have been found in preschool-

aged children with hyperactivity and in young school-

children with ADHD [27]. This study shows that

sleeping problems seem to persist in older children

with ADHD.

The findings in this study of a higher risk of health

complaints in children with attention problems con-

trasts with the findings of an earlier Swedish study by

Rasmussen and Gillberg [28], where such risks were

absent. They studied younger children (6�11 y),

where the prevalence of health complaints generally

tends to be lower [13] and bullying is somewhat less

common [12]. The study by Rasmussen and Gillberg

Table III. Crude rates of health complaints at least once a week in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Headache

Recurrent

abdominal

pain

Sleeping

problems

Daytime

tiredness

At least one

complaint

At least two

complaints

ADHD

category

Total

n

Boys

n

Girls

n

Boys

%

Girls

%

Boys

%

Girls

%

Boys

%

Girls

%

Boys

%

Girls

%

Boys

%

Girls

%

Boys

%

Girls

%

No ADHD 420 196 224 22 29 14 25 33 42 17 16 50 63 25 33

Subthreshold

ADHD

35 20 15 30 40 20 47 30 47 10 60 50 80 25 67

Situational

ADHD

32 23 9 30 22 52 11 48 56 44 56 78 78 57 56

Pervasive ADHD 29 25 4 28 25 44 25 60 50 44 0 80 75 56 25

Total 516 264 252 24 29 21 26 36 43 21 19 55 65 30 35

Table IV. Stratified analyses of health complaints and attention-

deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) (pervasive or situational

(ADHD).

Model 1 RR

(95% CI)

Model 2 RR

(95% CI)

Recurrent abdominal pain 2.3 (1.4�3.7) 2.2 (1.4�3.4)

Headache 1.1 (0.6�1.8) 1.0 (0.6�1.6)

Sleeping problems 1.8 (1.2�2.9) 1.7 (1.1�2.7)

Day tiredness 2.9 (1.8�4.6) 2.7 (1.7�4.1)

Model 1 is crude. Model 2 is adjusted for sex and maternal edu-

cation.

RR: relative risk; CI: confidence interval.

668 K. Holmberg & A. Hjern

Page 6: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

[28] was carried out in the 1970s; thus, it is possible

that the differing results reflect the change in teaching

methods in Swedish schools that has taken the last

three decades, where recent methods tend to make

greater demands on children to plan and organize

their school work. It is also possible that the use of

children themselves as informants in the present study

made it easier to detect this association, since children

themselves are probably the best source of informa-

tion on health complaints [29].

Limitations

The major limitation of this study is that the data were

collected within the school health system and used in

connection with health visits to the school nurses and

physicians. This means that the information may have

been biased by thoughts about how it would be used

within the school. It seems possible, for example, that

parents and children may have withheld information

about health and behavioural problems if they pre-

ferred to find solutions to these problems outside of

school. To a certain extent, this problem was mini-

mized in the area of behaviour and school problems

by using teachers as informants, but for health

complaints, the only data available were the informa-

tion collected from the children. The rates of ADHD

and health complaints in this study, however, are quite

similar to reports in other recent Swedish studies

[3,4,13], which seems to indicate that this bias was

minor.

This method of data collection, however, is also the

greatest strength of this study, since it explains the

extraordinarily high participation rate of parents,

teachers and children. The fairly low participation

rate (124/160, 77.5%) in the WISC testing for

children selected in the screening makes it necessary

to interpret the findings regarding children with

intellectual disabilities with certain caution, but other-

wise, the results presented can be expected to be

representative of the entire study population. Another

strength of the study is the use of multiple informants

where data on behaviour are provided by both

teachers and parents, data on socio-economic condi-

tions by parents, and data on health complaints by the

children themselves [29]. This structure also made it

possible to evaluate the behaviour of the drop-outs,

whose Conners’ scores rated by teachers were similar

to those of the study population (mean 4.7 vs 4.3,

respectively), as were the EFSS scores rated by

teachers (mean 9.3 vs 8.4, respectively), thus suggest-

ing that the study population was fairly representative

of the whole cohort.

The comparatively low age of the children in the

classroom study makes the children’s reading and

writing skills of Swedish a possible source of bias. It is

possible that difficulties of this kind affected responses

of children with cognitive difficulties, foreign-born

parents, or both. Thus, the results regarding these

children should be interpreted cautiously.

Can the results of this study be generalized for all

children with ADHD? Sigtuna is a medium-sized

municipality with a population that reflects fairly well

the socio-economic situation of the country on a

whole in terms of education and immigrants. The

school system is similar to the systems in most

Swedish communities, with a preponderance of com-

munity-run schools with mainstream teaching meth-

ods. Thus, it seems quite probable that the results are

representative of most societal contexts in Sweden. A

major limitation of this study, however, is the limited

age variation in the study population. School demands

and peer-relation patterns as well as the prevalence of

ADHD and health complaints vary considerably with

age, which suggests that the results of this study may,

to a certain extent, be specific for the age group

studied.

Clinical implications

Difficulties in school often constitute the main pro-

blems of children diagnosed with ADHD. Health

complaints such as recurrent headache, RAP and

sleeping disturbances can be expected to aggravate

these problems in school by interfering with learning

and causing school absence. Thus, it is important that

treatment strategies for children with ADHD also

include an effective evaluation and treatment of these

conditions.

The prevailing definitions and distinctions between

physical and psychological pain limit our understand-

ing of children’s experiences, and adversely shape the

way that paediatricians and psychiatrists treat chil-

dren’s somatic complaints. For example, a child who

reports recurrent stomach aches to a primary-care

physician may receive an extensive medical work-up

before being evaluated for a psychiatric disorder. Our

findings suggest that children who present with

recurrent health complaints should be assessed for

ADHD symptoms. Other studies have found health

complaints to be associated with childhood depres-

sion and conduct disorder [24,30]. As our under-

standing of the biological substrates and mechanisms

of psychiatric illnesses grows, so will our knowledge of

the role of psychopathology in both the aetiology and

presentation of a variety of somatic symptoms [24].

In this article, we have demonstrated that, irrespec-

tive of socio-economic confounding, children diag-

nosed with ADHD have health complaints such

as RAP, sleeping problems and daytime tiredness

more often than other children. Further studies are

needed to clarify the mechanisms responsible for this

association.

Health complaints in children with ADHD 669

Page 7: Health complaints in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder

Acknowledgements

Financial support for this study has been provided by

grants to the first author from the Swedish Society of

Medicine, the First of May Flower Annual Campaign,

and Samariten Foundation. We thank the school

authorities of Sigtuna, the school nurses and the

teachers, without whose assistance the study could

not have been completed. We also thank Hans

Forssberg and Elisabeth Fernell for support in initiat-

ing this study, and Ulla Ek for administering the

WISC-III test to 145 children.

References

[1] American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and statis-

tical manual of mental disorders, 4th ed. Washington, DC:

American Psychiatric Association; 1994.

[2] Faraone S, Sergeant J, Gillberg C, Biederman J. The world-

wide prevalence of ADHD: is it an American condition? World

Psychiatry 2003;/2:/104�13.

[3] Landgren M, Pettersson R, Kjellman B, Gillberg C. ADHD,

DAMP and other neurodevelopmental/psychiatric disorders in

6-year-old children: epidemiology and co-morbidity. Dev Med

Child Neurol 1996;/38:/891�906.

[4] Kadesjo B, Gillberg C. Attention deficit and clumsiness in

Swedish 7-year-old children. Dev Med Child Neurol 1998;/40:/

796�804.

[5] Henker B, Wahlen C. The child with attention-deficit hyper-

activity disorder in school and peer settings. In: Quay H,

Hogan A, editors. Handbook of disruptive behavior disorders.

New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers; 1999. p.

157�78.

[6] Klassen AF, Miller A, Fine S. Health-related quality of life in

children and adolescents who have a diagnosis of attention-

deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Pediatrics 2004;/114:/e541�7.

[7] Gillberg C, Gillberg IC, Rasmussen P, Kadesjo B, Soderstrom

H, Rastam M, et al. Co-existing disorders in ADHD �implications for diagnosis and intervention. Eur Child Adolesc

Psychiatry 2004;/13 Suppl 1:/I80�92.

[8] Landgren M, Kjellman B, Gillberg C. Attention deficit

disorder with developmental coordination disorders. Arch

Dis Child 1998;/79:/207�12.

[9] Haugland S, Wold B. Subjective health complaints in adoles-

cence � reliability and validity of survey methods. J Adolesc

2001;/24:/611�24.

[10] Alfven G. The covariation of common psychosomatic symp-

toms among children from socio-economically differing resi-

dential areas. An epidemiological study. Acta Paediatr 1993;/

82:/484�7.

[11] Perquin CW, Hazebroek-Kampschreur AA, Hunfeld JA,

Bohnen AM, van Suijlekom-Smit LW, Passchier J, et al. Pain

in children and adolescents: a common experience. Pain 2000;/

87:/51�8.

[12] Danielsson M. Svenska skolbarns halsovanor 2001/2002.

Sandviken Statens Folkhalsoinstitut; 2003 (in Swedish).

[13] Ostberg V. Halsa och valbefinnande. In: Jonsson JO, Ostberg

V, Evertsson M, Brolin Laftman S, editors. Barns och

ungdomars valfard. SOU 2001:55 (in Swedish). Kommitten

Valfardsbokslut. Stockholm: Fritzes; 2001.

[14] Hagquist C, Andrich D. Measuring subjective health among

adolescents in Sweden. Social Indicators Research 2004;/68:/

201�20.

[15] Conners CK. A teacher rating scale for use in drug studies

with children. Am J Psychiatry 1969;/126:/884�8.

[16] Ek U, Holmberg K, de Geer L, Sward C, Fernell E.

Behavioural and learning problems in schoolchildren related

to cognitive test data. Acta Paediatr 2004;/93:/976�81.

[17] Wechsler D. Wechsler intelligence scale for children, 3rd ed.

revised. New York: Psychological Corporation; 1999.

[18] Mannuzza S, Klein RG, Moulton JL 3rd. Young adult

outcome of children with "situational" hyperactivity: a pro-

spective, controlled follow-up study. J Abnorm Child Psychol

2002;/30:/191�8.

[19] American Academy of Pediatrics. Diagnostic and statistical

manual of mental disorders for primary care. Washington,

DC: American Academy of Pediatrics; 1997.

[20] Rothman KJ, Greenland S, editors. Modern epidemiology.

2nd ed. Philadelphia: Lippincott-Raven Publishers; 1998. p.

277.

[21] Ghandour RM, Overpeck MD, Huang ZJ, Kogan MD,

Scheidt PC. Headache, stomachache, backache, and morning

fatigue among adolescent girls in the United States: associa-

tions with behavioral, sociodemographic, and environmental

factors. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2004;/158:/797�803.

[22] Barkley RA. Behavioral inhibition, sustained attention, and

executive functions: constructing a unifying theory of atten-

tion deficit hyperactivity disorder. Psychol Bull 1997;/121:/54�94.

[23] King JA, Barkley RA, Barret S. Attention-deficit hyperactivity

disorder and the stress response. Biol Psychiatry 1998;/44:/72�4.

[24] Egger HL, Costello EJ, Erkanli A, Angold A. Somatic

complaints and psychopathology in children and adolescents:

stomach aches, musculoskeletal pains, and headaches. J Am

Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1999;/38:/852�60.

[25] Biederman J, Faraone SV, Mick E, Williamson S, Wilens TE,

Spencer TJ, et al. Clinical correlates of ADHD in females:

Findings from a large group of girls ascertained from pediatric

and psychiatric referral sources. J Am Acad Child Adolesc

Psychiatry 1999;/38:/966�75.

[26] Blachman DR, Hinshaw SP. Patterns of friendship among

girls with and without attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder.

J Abnorm Child Psychol 2002;/30:/625�40.

[27] Owens JA, Maxim R, Nobile C, McGuinn M, Sall M. Parental

and self-report of sleep in children with attention-deficit/

hyperactivity disorder. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2000;/154:/

549�55.

[28] Rasmussen P, Gillberg C. Perceptual, motor and attentional

deficits in seven-year-old children. Paediatric aspects. Acta

Paediatr Scand 1983;/72:/125�30.

[29] Weissman MM, Wickramaratne P, Warner V, John K, Prusoff

BA, Merikangas KR, et al. Assessing psychiatric disorders in

children. Discrepancies between mothers’ and children’s re-

ports. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1987;/44:/747�53.

[30] Harma AM, Kaltiala-Heino R, Rimpela M, Rantanen P. Are

adolescents with frequent pain symptoms more depressed?

Scand J Prim Health Care 2002;/20:/92�6.

670 K. Holmberg & A. Hjern