Herminio Robles-Quintano, A074 351 862 (BIA June 9, 2011)

8/13/2019 Herminio Robles-Quintano, A074 351 862 (BIA June 9, 2011)

1/17

Hiro, Male M.ro & Assocates LLC736 Bhop Steet, #02Honolul H 981

Name: RBLESUTAN ERMI

U D J

Executive O r Iigon Revew

a Imm AaO h Ck

/0 Lb Pik, Sue Fl Ch 'g 2

OHS/CE ce of Cef Consel - N595 Ala Moana olevHonoll, I 983999

A07432

jat o ts notce /9/2011

Enclosed s a copy of the Bord's decson and oer n the aboe-eeence ce.

ncosre

Pl Members:Gran, wd R

Sncerel,

Donn Chie Ce

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished


2/17

,

US D o uscf

g

F VtFe A074 351 862 - Hono l :

: O ROBLS Q OV GS

PB

ONB OF SN Me o

O B OF DS

CGE:

Knge CC

9ZD

No: S 22(a)(9)C)(i), N [8 SC 182{a){9(C)(il] o e o b

S 2a)(6A) N A 8 SC 82(a)6A)) -P b m o p

LCATON Con of ov d on 2A)

of S HS") p do ot mJud d 0 2010 n e esnd's ao lon o on AXI) o he o No (he " 8 USC XV Te a w

We e o dto ofD, e bonJue a ey rnu 8 CF 13. X3)) o e e of i o co da s 8 CFR I003(d(3)) Te on t s on

, , p

b vo

R A 3; 4) eM/S422) Te on s wdo b a4)

W no p e on de o ce rn w do f o es nco eF 2010 ion SMtr B20 D 872, 874 A 4).

1 Te n a e oM . 1-2; 1


3/17

A074 j 86

on s g c S bX) of t ehe nd d a bst cmn d a oder i w s t o e a 6;

). e on Jdg fod e ivdus who the mp t ond l (.I a6 ). , l to on the mor os c omo y o d heon u nd t d of k of pi oto b "ble d pe .J 7 Tr 66 81-82, 8588, 9394) o oth ld is ior voo o Hmo e d h la e e I on ud d not a of alck of g mo ch (.I a6B Tr a 8)

e d am l qg a S , d on d i

m t U S J a 71; 4). Son 20) of e A d woud e los o c t

of e , po rli on nde's to provd chidd pp me o m g s of J. -9 Tr a 33-36402 O. s a demoh o o oj e S or M toa of wo o rd h ge d n to mpl the requiite of empot e of to v h n o on . a 9; (; Tr a3437, 68). nd a le od a of po t a9-1E (Q, ); Tr a 2632, -52). W on Jud t th d' woud e ve m U St.

e t I Judgs of d r.Thehdp rby th nd's o d y li oft s l oiot t e of Hi c o tow of o u is m.MR 23 J , 40 2). o t I o dgesf pon m e dp fo a on 20) of e i f t e b h on dg F 200 don

I o Jdge dein the nd do p of di t i"l r on oo a 5-7. So 240Ab) bl)(d) of e A e I Jdg t s oo d w h U S woud no o u1 p thr t a ; Tr a 903) Nh p on do w

2


4/17

07435186

Agy w b

ORE DHS pp i s


5/17

.

US DERTENT O STICEEXECUTIE ICE OR IGTN REVEW

UNITE STATES IIGTION CORTHnl Hawai

Fle A 7 35 62 Fbruar , 2

n t Maer f

HEINIO ROLESQINT )}

I REMOVAL PRCEEDINGS

CRGES

Respnen

Secin 22(a 9 C) () I) f he Iga anNainat A alen rdered reved eners itu Ben a e ;

Sen 22a (6) (A () t Irati dNainaly Ac - alen presen ut adssr par

LICATS Sein 2A(b () f t Iigran andNanaly Ac - ancellain remval rerain nnperanen residens; lunaypt

O EAL O THE RESPODEN

ale Hra, sire

EAL OF THE DEPARTENO HMELD CURITY

t Kans, EsreAssisan Che usHnlulu Haa

OL D CISIN OF THE GRATION JUDGhe epde s a 33ar-d, marre at ad

z e The Deparen alleges ha he arrd a r

r San Ysdr, Ca irna n a dae a a t

aed r pared by a usts an d Prtt Of er


6/17

t' _

he Dpartent rther aeed that n Jaary 2, 99, the

respdet was rdered remed frm the ted States nder

Setn 24 f the t and that he entered he Unted States

wtht beng amtted ater pr 5, 99 and agan wtht

ass paed by egay Iat ad atralzatn

Serve.

reedgs were eed wh the fg a te

t ppear th the Igrat Cr at Hl n Nvember 0,2008 Se Ehbt he respdet admted allegats , 2,

ad 4 bt deed alleats 5 6 and Respdet neded

be presnt wtht admssn r parl but teste the

harge rerdg reentry ater a deprtatn rder. espdent

desgated Me sd tat beme neessary

e ual erg as ted Febrary 0,

200 Ehbts thrgh and dn 7 were reeved. he

Department reprted that bakrd hes were mpeted ad

there was thg t reprt ther tha the vt ad arrest

rerd aready n the e.

he respndent and hs rrent e, anet bes bth

testfed n the Englsh agage here was thn n ther

deear tat detrated rm ther redby.

un e isse mly e u s

that rspdent s present tht adssn r parle base p

hs amssns and testny eardng the aternate hare

te Departet fed at Ehbt 2, the er f Deprtabe

04 B62 Febrary 0 200


7/17

Iassble len. hs recr saes ha lar eparre

wa grane wh a aleae er f epa b a

Igan Jge epember 2 6 I eplans ha

respnen appeare n a srrener nce n prl 4, an

wa selfepe n A Te epame a als

able sbanae hs hrgh ehb n he recr shwng

he facs gang epnes lua epaue re fr

gan ge hn C Wllams Mee, respnen

eplae ha he a e ng a he me, ha hs mher

hre he arne ha represene m a he e an ha

respne n ealze he ae b hch he as sppse

leae he nr. Therefre, bh chages f reabl are

sane

fer e espe rere Mec respnen

efe ha afer w hree weeks he rere bac he

ne aes an ha bascall le n he slan f Ma n

he Sae f Hawa eer e.

SATEMENT OF TH W hb 4 he respnen has fe he applan

n he r E42. Therere, he respen sppeene he

appla. See Eb 6 n reeg hs case, he

r as nsere Bar ess rea er reses

r e wh ae aple fr anellan f real fr

ceran nn-peranen resens ee, Mtt of R cinas 23 I&ec 46 BI 2002 atter f ndazla, 23 IN ec 319 (BI 04 3 862 Febrar 10, 2010


8/17

,.\

0) Mt r of oneal, 3 I Dec. 6 BA 001)

Oe of he f reves n hs cse s hem or her o resoen's crre we. hs 11yer-o

c Je Kwkows hogh hogh o ope wo e

" r roses o qfn s reve wh rer o

ebshn "exceon xree s hrsh or he

cceo of remov ' Mtr Prtilo Gu rr z, 5I& Dec. 148 B 009) .

I he erve resonen reess concusonry

vonr erre

FNDNG OF FACT; CONCLUON O WThs cse fs wh he R D c of 005

re rg he bren o proo In hs cse he Cor s h

e respoe h e proe esey crebe

on. I o he ve prove m ocmens o

spor he cm ncu spporn ocens such s hose

reference n he nsrcons o he con or

cceo of reov jsme of ss or cern o

ene resens

Trng rs o he eson o hsc presece

e Ue es or connos ero o no ess hn 0

yes eey receg he o such co he

A Exhb 5 conse or resoe e PreHergSee whch mmrzes respoes rgmes regr hecb of hese cses o he cs resonensson.

4 351 862 err 10 00


9/17

,

rspodent testified credbly abot retrnng to the United

Sates very shortly after the "seldeportation. See Ehibit 5

ges 9 20 oreover, respondnt hs provided a letter

fom Heen Ilin, t Ehbt 5, ab H. he etter s notrzed

I the letter the athor states tht she ives on ai and owns

frnitre store on Maui The uthor states tht she rented an

artment to respondents other Mrceina, n pproatey 992

o Mai and ows tht the respondent moved to Mai approiatey

oe year ater and lved ith his mother unti 997 hen she as

diagnosed ith cncer and decided to move bac to eico he

thor states tht the respondent oved n ih he il an

ved on their property nti ugst 200, when he moved ot to

ie ith ore he ort finds that this etter is cnsstent

with ther evidence and s of hgh rbtve veespondent was ble to show throgh rrest records n

ui trogh birth certictes fro children born o i

tters frm othe friends ta records, et cetera, that he hs

the reqste physca presence n the United States for a

cntnos period of not less thn 0 yers iedatey preceding

te dte of the pplicaton, hich was initly iled with ths

ort on y 2, 2009 espondent s lso nt barred b Secto

0(d sed pon the evdence record ncuding respndents

estimony the docenttn, nd the testimony o respndents

wfe ning t the question of respondent has been

074 62 ebrry 0, 200


10/17

a pero o ood ora carac dri hi rod rpod

a aced a pil ate eca o aest ecord

Respode as ild a er o ler ro rids atsi

o s good carar. spod ook a gra dea o i

o expa he crcmstace o e arou arrt o

ecord odet ha wih reard o ot o arre

odd edece a Ex ab K a o o th

coplaias asa as a so coicio recod oh ow epod a also ild a Exi 5 ab L a odr

doli he eporar retrai ord or roeco

rard repods is wie Lorrie o our

saisid wit espod xlaaio abou h

eard e two cd

oreor rpods crt at ols,

eied a drg as kow te rpod, e

a e a perso o oo caracr ad a o expcd

a probls drig er arrag. epod as aso

explaid is arr or arou traic iolato o au

esode a ackowlded adradi ow o isi

egulaio o ai ad s s ard o his o rece

cao

adio a ar c ear

iscodc o spods rotr arco oe, h or

quid rr o ake a driao as o wr e

rpods oa caace was ad by aociao s

074 35 86 Fra 0 200


11/17

-

brotr Aftr earn te reondents teston and that o

his wife, te Court finds that t is satisfid that rspondents

brothr is th rson ho lacks ood charactr but that the

rsondent is diffrnt fro Marco and s nith a troublmaker

n r r rnkr In s the Cort is satisid tat

te rsondn has met is burdn of proof to show ood oral

charactr durn the reqisite priod

h dos not aar to be a convicion for anyofens whch would rendr th rspondent inelible under

ction 0A (b) (1) (C) of th Act

Next w trn to th quston of thr any of th

qualifyn rlatis would exprnc xcetional and trmly

unusual hardshi if th aplication is denied h Court as

ben infored tha rsondnts S citizn chid la Robsis in the hsical custod of her mother, the espondnts x

if, orri Robles he child has a close relationsip with her

fathr but ost recntly th chld and other hav oed fro

awaii to daho e dat of dorc in this relationsh was

July 2, 008 thouh the respondnt dos rovide cild

suport for his child in rviein h entir ecord, th Court

finds tha th excptonal and extr unusual hardsh or

ts chid s not establshd his s praly cas t

hardshi sufferd oud b siilar to that serd in othr

ls here there is a dvorce and a separatn lthough

rsondent ars that hs ex-ife would not low th chld to

A 07 35 86 7 February 0 200


12/17

vs hm if he is Mex he espe may e able have

reurse egrg a frm he famy u

ui e e arshp eel espe's

suse Jae ls e u s ha espe as he

gh ue f pf shw eepa a exeely uusa

hrsp is is beause e espe's wife is a US

e es spea Spas ad has lve Hawa a

g e. Dug ree years she has wrke f he Sae f

waii as psyha urse a pimaily a he Mau Memrial

ea ee. ese has pided sg evdee f

faial aship e spuse f he applai is ee

s s a mpra aspe ha as bee we uee i he

bge pre a hb ab a e buge

wi sws y a $00 lf afe es ae a a

epeses ae pai espe a is wife lve fee f re

beause f e eaiship wh a lad wh ws sevea

ppeies a w uses e espde's wfe as a ifma

ageme epreseaive. espe's wfe lles e res

a akes equess fm he eas f epais whih he

espe he efs Hweve is elsip ul e

a ayme sie i s a e wh f e lad exampe

i e oy is to e od e e y wod e t fid

aeae shee ive he ig s f livig aui a

lig a e ue i s ffiu see w he

espes wife u e ae s. I ai he

A 0 351 86 ebuay 0 200


13/17

-( .

ll me b she a ks t te t n edey ae hoe

cled Hae Mua on Maui on a pe diem at te a. is

ans tht he hs one fu tme jb, ne at time jb, n

dton to he a tme espsltes he andod Se

hs a estaished that she is tl in det educatinal

csts eated t he nusin deee

nay thee e exhibits which how tht

sondent wie mut w at leat 0 yeas o the State

wa n ode o he etement to vest Since she i >ya f ae ths n oant coseato Althuh

sondent's wife has testied tha she wuld ve t Meic

h husand was mved and une t come ack to the Unted

Sates, she h snicnt nncl concens about the ablty

to h.

Unle any ce this

se hch espoue teified that she a spent me time and efot n

tyin to find a wy to lve n a oe twn f he hsnd s

moved vaous eason ened dun the poceedn

eated t b vaiablt and ience on the bde twns,

t doe ot l pmg m e subece point o e

cal condeton ae nt c shw the

equite hds, u hee ae othe adshp thi cae

eted o repnde's w, Jat. S ha o ty o

sucida endence fom a ou . Se has ece a

ses leve mentl ess he fy hto ea

he mothe ad wo sibins Meve, he dahte me ae

0 351

i


14/17

(

ao o mal ills u. T s ocum a

Exibi 5 ab Q Reponden's wife a pla a owa bg o r maag o po wa a

rsna r hc r augh w ing ou. A

cl pycar a alao a ago wa

o T cl wa plac o aou cao a a

pt f pa po a par wa

mo. Alou chid i o ogr mcao

ro a a o pcaly carc

ns, has b oog cl a ss mproveens

a n par o cl laop w rpo

a a fa

f he appcao pac o

reodens wife would, f b inancl rf ssna

a ra ss of plo a l w fl

cl aor uo o pcl pog

w ar o po a ou ob a

u rpo f ao a c in

aop w po roug marrag

apar ry n fo cildre o e er rn

ool c worg c lo our a aral es

o h ay an r s rsa ras

s appa a ahgh rss fe s

elible ay o v for e reondent a

o ol o b abl a a a r

A 074 35 862 Fby 1 0 200


15/17

( .

ny ars. Ths has o do h h hsory o h doraon

i 97

Fa we ur o h sp daghr Th our ha

hard sony ha h hd' fahr s a convcd sx

o ndr and h rspondn has rovdd a Exh 5 Ta R h

c na rcord o Jas oogca fahr as Rs Ths

chd has o oldr sprohrs u hy ar adus nd on

vs n Jaan and on ve Coorado . Ohr han or,

appar ha h cld's rary ay eaoh s

h rspondn nd aso h hr ohr spssr, Aa

Exhb 5 ab P I h ppcaon s dnd and cld

gos o xco a ag h hr dagnosd drsson and h

naly o ea Sa h, apars ha h uao

oud ousd f h ora oeuee o rova o a

sparns nd ud rs o h vl of xcpona and

xry uuua Th chld ha n rasd on h sand f

u and hs ony sn o hours uana Mxco h hr

ohr so yars ago on a acaon Gvn h chd's

ckground f ha hr oh a s ru, and upava u a

ovng o eo h al nanca cura and hr

changs, od ghy drnal T Cor hro

oe o h conuson h h sondn ha hs rdn o

pr rgard o arh o i ehd

Tur o e ueo o reo he ou dd

A 04 5 82 11 ruary 0 200


16/17

.E ,1 .\

ve o ors bt after stei o the resoe's

tstoy, he Court s ha h aars o e sr

rrng ad aemtig o ae a ie t is rret ewo h desres as g or drsag and ha a ll

o matit tt s beeica to i t oes er at

e e e aes reord ha h ao a e re as

tter dsro

addon rvg the trvel aet ro the

ite es art o tat garig vole alog th

. /Mxio borer he Cou as ito coieraio

t this o have o th rsdn and hs aml the

aicaio s dned as a atter o dsreo esondn as

oor eatiosp ith hs asv ahr wh lvs n exio.

eset's ter has alad asd awa soeese tha hs s o aly rs Mexo ar vr ea

ece he essetia has o ld th the a ong t

d dd ot hae a oo reatoship t ost o tem

ccoriy the olwg orders sh be etere:

S D that he at or

allato roval o rta ora resies is

ge

erar 0 00


17/17

0

(- ,."

r ..

CERTIF P G

I hereby cetif tha he aahe poeedg

eoe DAY BER in he mae of:

HRMNIO OLS-QUTO

074 35 62

ooluu, awa

a eld as ee aea and tha h is he oa

trani eo o he le e xeve Oe or

ao eve.

Doee odder (ae)

Deoo evie 64 eve oevaroke Maad 20852(0) 881-344

arch 2. 1Coe Dae

Documents

Herminio Robles-Quintano, A074 351 862 (BIA June 9, 2011)