Department 'of J,~~ti~,e Inspector Gener~I-QueSl:ionnaireRe.Q,a'r.din'g Deta'in,ee's

O,03.-0IG INVESTIGATIVE QUESTIONNAIREFOR R:EV1EW AND USE d'NLV BYINDIVIDUAL FBI RESPONDENTS

" i~o NOT FORWARD'OR Di:.$EMI~ATE '

QU,ESTION NAIRE 10: test-O,O,OO,09'9.9,

,As af ~h:~ last.time this' qt,l~~ionnairewa~ ~a~¢~,$9me rfaquire,d 'fields: !lav~ nqt. be!'!n'C:9mplete"d.PJeas~,r,eView your resp·onse,s. '

~!1i~.,lA;;r~on~1 Information

Please plovide'the'folloWih!1 informatiQn:1, First l1ame ~ & 7(; PER4~REEJI!1FNT'2. Mldqle Jnltl?l: 6 & '1C PER AGREEMENT3~ Last name: 6 & 1C PER AGREEMENT

4., Entered on .D:uty Date (E,OD): ~ & 70,$: C~r.r:eht DJ'lisl9n/Held bffii:;e: ~ ~ 7C6. ~urrent jo!? ,title; ,Telecornrnunicatjqns Mana,gerJ., Directdial bffice:,lelephone, nu'niben 6'& 1~PERAGREEMENT

8f FBI :cell 'phqrie' hljmoer: ~ &; 7(; PER.AG~EMc.N'i9. fBI p,ager pUI1)'l!er: 6*",7C PERAGREEMENT'lO•..Eiest c;:Qotact number fOf'YOU: 6 & lC,PER,A,.GF5EEMENT.

11., At any time aftet:Se'ptemlier 11.( lO,Olr ajd yo.u serVe.as 'a me'inl)er of the U. S. Military, or: as i:l'n­'employ~e,or contractor or the FBI:or any o'ther:government agencYr at Guantanamo Bay( Cuba; Iraq;;A.fg\19pi?t,ar:r; :or',n preC!s:COI')~r9"ed .Qy ~l1e U.S. MilitClTY or a U,S. inteJIig~.n!"e service jn'cqnoec;tion:'\A{ith the,gi9bal ~~r on !~1"rot? '

@'Yes 0 No

1:2. ~l1ter the number ,of' time:s )t,ou, w'13te..ct¢ploy,ed OJ 'cjssig ned t6 each of the..folIowing 19X;a~i.oris,{Guahtanaino Bay, 'tuba;.lraq:;<"Afghanistan;:or in ,-any areas c::ontr'olled bytne U.S: 'tl1i1itar'y or' a U.S.inteJUg,ence serYJ[:e) ;-1, ' " ,

For,each deployment or ,assignment com'plete'the followi.ng section., ' ' De~toyrrie.nt or lIl!sij:Jnm,erit'b.egim ~n ~r Depl~.Ynl~r1~ oras~igli':':lIjrit~(n:de~ on,

L(J~tioJ"! (s'el~!=:tone) aboQ.t or'about

~~f~~:~i~:t~'~~ , 11/2003 - 12/2003] 2a What was ttje'geoe@! natUre and outp'dse m'Y0yC-SlssjgnJii'eJit and -activities?

I IlLb. Please provide, the> names of the..spedficcamps, bases,. or facilities where you worked.

B,99ralJ1.A.ir B<a~ ., < " ..'. , '. ".''l;2c. NQt~,: I,f ii1fpl"maJipn' ,cH>out -q:speciffccanip, base, Q'r facjlity·i$>t1<:l,ssif!ed;a!J:o..ve, SEeRET,ple,a~,~ch,eck here, 0, 'in:c1ucte in 'ypqr:ansWer that yoW hav.e "atlc;li't.l9nal in(Qriliatidn tl~~sifi~,a,lJoile'BECREf,'~'and r if 'IOU k:riowr 'id,eiitify 'the:c1assification,lev.el, 'ticket, :co'in paitment, prog ram, ,or.otherdeslg 11cltton thatappHes. t(;dhe<.tnforJTIatlol1~po n9t include the <C!d~I~lo,narcl~sslfied fnforrnatron In your

: b6: b7C

OIGQ-005571

qu~stionn!=lire responses. bIG personnel with the necessary cleararrce Will c9.htact you to ret~ive it.Name Posi,tion,

I l ~~'__" ~~" , ~' ' TJU_~9P.!<!i~~t~t. _- ' ,_,,':12~. Qld YQ.\:1 jOintly' int!O:r"i{ieW pI" iqterrogafe any detpirieg: wttn bOn-FBI p¢t$9m]'el? . :

:' 0 Y~,s @NQ :':i2f. Dld-Y-oiJjo~tIY plaii~ri~ tJetain~ iht~rVieW-,or-iii~rfu~atio; :~tegy:' 6bjectiY~ o;tacti~s- with ii,on--':'FBI personnel? I

: o Yes 0No ::i2g.,~W~re';YQ~ ~y~r~oth;r.Wji;~ ~nyq!Y~d in~~~in~;'ini;rVt~0;,o( interr:og~,ti9nS -with-n:o~n~FBI p~t.sonnil? -:

·~·Y~~ Q No':Ple.a,s~ describe: On seyeraIOC'~~ion,s,.I Witnes~d in:tervi~ws'~s'<;l result of prpviqing t~cJmiCFlI support.-- ------ '_ --- -_'_ -_'__ ---_'_ - _'_ - --.__~_ ---- _0_'- _~ " ' . ~

b6b7C

. ,

A,. Trainin,g Prio~ ~o'9v~r~ea!j;'Deployment or Assignm.~nt

13:, Did 'you reG~iv~ ~n'y training~. ins~ructioh, or guidance ,SP'eci{iCCflly in 'pJeparatioJ1 for any of y6uroverseas deployments or.asslgnments?

eYes ONo ,(}Do Not Recall

13a. Who prmflded this trainIng" Instruction! or'guldanc~f'andwhere did you receille It1''CRU Persofrliel atCRU

1315, DescriiJe the 5ubje'tl: ,Qil Which'yol!receWed' .this tJ:Qitling, (ns~tuctiOii or. gtj'idah,(:~.

All of tty~: ~raining wps'tech.n.i~<:llIn,n1;lture, '

0No Do-a Not Rec?llL

is. III pr.epClrat[o,n, Tor any"of your ove.rse~sd~ployments'or assigmnef)~,dj~ you receiy.e~.ny trqinin'g"!nstn,1.dipti, Qrgu idpn'C!:l ,conj::el}1ing 'tll:e:$tanpqrp~H)f:tpn~,uct a pplic:aI;jIff.tQ '~he'treatm¢'rit,

int.erview,: br' iriterrtl~ation of'deti3'inees by non-,FB.I' p'ersolinel?

16: IT1 p~epaJ:9tiqn f9r ~:m.y aT your :ov~rseas:~.~plqym~i;s9r,i;!s,~ignm~ntsrQ.i9,y,pu' r~c~ive:a!w :t;raiDifl9r.frfstruq;iQn, or':guida:nce concerning what you wer~ SllPp:q~~ to"t!p if YOl,l ol5.s¢rV~q or'h~~I'Jn~P9l)l ,'the. treatment; int~rview.ror interrogation of detainees by FBI trersonr'i,eJ,. wHich you 'believed .to: ,b~ jnappro.priatel,"ilnprof.essiona~~'coerciv.e/a'busive,'0r.un.lawfuL? . .

OY.es. 000 ~ot Recall

i7. In pfepara(ib,n'f6r anyof.YQu'r ovetseci~ deploYni'~ts'{)raSsIgni:rrents., did' .you rec~lve;any ~raJntJi~" ', rhstructlpn, or .guldance ionc,em,llJg What you w~re'sliPPj)sed'to, do If you pbserved ,or-'heard about

the treatment, interview, or interrogation 'of detainees by non-FBI personn~l,which you believed'

OIGQ-005572

to be inappropriqte.; unprofessional, mercive, a.busiv~, or unlawful?

Q DQ NQt- Recall.

lB.. Training During, Overseas Deployments or AssignmentsiB. Durin9 qny :of yowroverseas·deplo.ym~nts or a~signl"(lents',qid you receive any trafning, If:lstn,rctigni

, orguid?ll1Ce·conC~fI1i.ng th~·st?lI1t1.ar~,s of'cCinqu!=:t appllc.abl~ to the treatm~nti lritervleWi,orinterrogatiQn 9f detaih'e~$ 'by FBI Pers~mliel?

'eNo 000. Not.Recaii

19. D.uringat)y,ofYQur o\~,er~easdepl()Yf!lelnSor a?signment~,dl~ you receiVe any'traJnJll9, il)strlJct[O!1,cwglJlqance ~9ncerning the 'stan~tan;ls .9-f ,cbndl,lc;t:appIR:a.ble tQ ~he ~rea.trn.ent~ 'iriteri?lew, orinterrogatiOn of cletaiilees by rio.n-FBI petsotirjel?

Qyes· ,0No. '(t)'D,o. N6.t:Recali

.2,!). G>}lring,an~.of yo~r'oversea~!'9'eploYments or ass.ignrnen~sf,,did 'YQL.! 'rec.eiye any'trail1in9i jli,str,L!dioni:Qr:g uid.qnce conc~rn:in.9 what .y9~ w~r~'su PPQ$.'etl t9 cl.Q if yo,u :oo.s~rye!l,Qr h~a n~ ,~I:1:o0t tne~treathient, intelv.iew~ 6r' irite'rrogation ,ofd,etaihees by FBI personnel.; which you believed to befnappropnate, 'CJ'nprO(essional, ceerciv:er, abusive,.'or uhlaWful?·

;Qyes ,0.00 'Not Recall

~2t1. Buring any. bfyour bv~r:~as,aeplo1nieht5or ~$signrilents, {lid you 'r~¢eive any trai/iing, ins~rlJctibrj,or',guidan~e:c0i1G:erniIi9what ,(ou were;sup.posed "to do-.'if you .observedor .heard aliotifthetreatmenf'r interview,:, or,interrqgation ,ofdetainees by non.:FBI personnel, which you Believed toqe'tl1appropriat,e} l,mpfofe?siona1;, COe[ciVei,~pLisiVe, qr un.lawfoW

22', In ·yOUr',o'pihion"CIi,d' y.o.Y r~c~;iiye ~deqU:ate- trctin.irig, ihstruCti6n, or gUidance'rej;;:l~ing to ,~tahciarM,of rohduct by FBI-arid nOll'-FBI 'personnel relafih~r to. treatment! ',inteniiew, Of; friterrog.afi6n Qf'd~tgtiJ1ees prjor to:your:d~pJo.Yrne_nt'~r .assig.nl"(lent?

@"YeS 0 No

'Z~.I!1 you\:<?Plnl0!l, 'dl~f.y9U r~el:y.e ,adegl,lClte traltllng,.lnstnJ~ion':9r:guid;mc~.r~lat!ng' io:;·sta.nq~rds'of conduCt by FBLand nori-fBI personnel relating to tr~atr'nent!-intervie,W, of interrogation' ofdet~linees:du'r1119' yotir deploynie,nt.;or assig h'merit? '

24.1n ·your ojJiniohr:d id you reGeive 'adequate trairiiil9r instructbii, or,guitlaricie concerning What you 'were supposed tqdoi'f'you obs.erYed or heard abot,lt the treatment, interview, or Interrogation 'of ,

OIGQ-005573

detainee!?,. tiy·FB.I or nDn-FBI p:~rs6l'inel, that you believed was inappropriate, unprofessiohal,coercive, abusive, or unlawful?

,@ Yes 0 No

25. (Optional) In what ways Gan the FBI improve training on this subject for future deployments:or:assignments?

10.. Comments2.9. Please proVide. fitly: .additional ilif6f1nati6n.coric~rning t"r,ainjilg f6.ro:veJs~:$ d.~pIQYrhents or

assig,nments of FBI personnel you believe is r.elevant

1. 1. RersQnally 'obsel¥ed t~IS 'C.onpuet2. I bbseryepgei:~i n.~(s.) in ~ :tQn:ciiti6n that led me"tq b~.lIeV'~ then ,tf1js' qm(ly"C\: had' ·o.ccurr~<;l ~3'. Petainee(sl to.ld me'th'at this:tonductlia'd pccutred,.,4. Pthers who obseYVed this. conduGt'descr-ibed It to me.S. r have r.elevant information classified above,'!SECRET".:6', I nev¢[o'b'serv~~ thi~ conclf;Jct n9f h,ea'fd :aqQut iffrqm .?om~rr~.wt]Q·.pjd.~

a: [j I personally observed this conduct.

p·,iD l' 0bser,ved:q~tRJn~e(s.)' in a'cond itio!,! that Jed lJ)e:to belieye ,that this cO[lduG~ hqdt)ccl:lrred.,

c..!D [)e~ai.nee(s) tQl,d ,rne t'rqt thi,s c~nd.!jct ha,d ·occl,lrred.

:d. D Other:? Who 'ol:!s~rv~ tt]ls l::Qnd uG.t' ~.es~.ribe9 Ir to, me:

~. D I hav.e releyarit infQflliatLolt ~J~ssjfi~d aQ<;>ve "SECRETi',. '

f. 0 r n~\?er 9~5¢Neg thi? 'C9Dpuct f)6r h,eclrd 'ap.0u,t it from scjlTr~o,n,eW'hQ !fid.

OIGQ-005574

2.8. Deprivi'ng:a detain~e- of'clqthlng

a. 0 I personally o,bserv.ed this:conduct.

b. 0 I observed detainee(s} In 'a.condition that led me to belJeVe that this conduct had occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s)'told me that this conduct had ·occurred.

d" 0 Others who observed this conduct described it to me.

~. 0 r: have relevant information classified Bbove ':S'EC'RET"'.- ",....' ", ,',', '.... '.

f. lrl Inev.en~_bserved this c::ol1du~t n{)rnea~d'abo~t it ff9!T1'som~of1e"Y.~o did,

-,29. Deprivlng·a detain'~'of'sleep',qr intenuptin9 sl~p by freq1Jent Ct3!1 relocations aT Qther lll'e~hpds

a. It!' personally obser"V.ed thisoc'c>.'ndi.l.ct.

b. 0 I-observed detainee(s) in ;l·c6.nClition'that led meHo: beHe.ve thatthis co'ndlict had ,occurreCl.

C- O Deialhee.(s) 'told me that .this cond uct had .oecu rtE:d.d. o lathers Wh0 observ:ed this cond I:lct descrfbed It to me:

'e', 0 I, hcWce'relev.arit, i'l'\f9rma'tion, c1as~ifi~ ilp.oV~ lIS-~CR.EJ"·,.

f. 0 r Ilev:erobserveq thl~ con9,~~t nor h~rd abou~ It ff0msome~ne\fo{.ho,dld.

g. Ple<;lS"e provi.de :H(e apPf9ximgte t.irne:fr?lme'~!JflngWhi~o :tni~ cQnduc;fo!Xl)rreg.Frpm:CM/D/yYyY format or MI,!i'YYY) t9 {M/Dim'((Qrn:tat.or Mt\'YYY~ @[Jo Not,Recall

h. Th~de~?ine.~.c~) trE?C!teg 1n thi? wt$y were l~ti:lt~ 'Cit th:e time in;;t 0 G4~n~c;mpnlQ

iDJ@q3 [~:r:Afgha:ni~ta,n

-4 D Other L-ocation5 0 Do Not Recall

'i. Please. identifY the ,detain~(s) by Iiarrie and, humber:Unknown , ' '

J. '~I.ease identtfy' th~ per~n{:s>. whq treated try\=.: detdin~~(s} 'jn l.hiS: Jilpnner., in.chJ.~ihg theirname{s) and :g6venrment.agenPt(ies):VariousUS Army personnel, names unknown.

k. Nease identjfy' any'otber FBI person'nef or non-FBI »er$oflnel "Hhp op'$erv.ed· detailie~(s) treatea'In this manher,. Including their name(s) ·aM qgehcy(i€s):- .unk;oown

I, Thi~ conduct '9cc;urred in .c0l1h~cti9n With:

OIGQ-005575

10 ·dne· det~inee2 a Several detainees (2-4)30 Many detainees (more than 4}40 00 Not Recall

m. (OptIonal) Please "deserib.e the relevant clrcumst~mces in mor.e detail:

30. Beating a detainee

.a. D . (p~r.spnaliY·QbservE;!d thfs condl!ct.

D. 0 Lo.&ser.v:ed .detainee(s): in a 'cQ"rid ition that ied me. to beiieve that. this coNdoct had ·'octurred.

c; 0 Detainee(s) told me that this !:onduct hado.ccurred.

d. 0 e>thers: who :ob.served this co!i'(juct described It to'rhe.

e. (j I have rele},iaht information Classified abo.v.e !!S'ECREr'.

f. ~ I never o'bserved this .conduct nor heara :abo'ut it from,Som'eone:·whb· did.

·3:f. Llslng V\!ater·to pr~vent breathing by a detainee Qr ~p. crea~e .t.he sensation of.drowning

.~. D. r p:~r.sqflaliy Q.p~~Ned thIs ~<;>tidu9,.t.

O. 0 I:ob$e~e(Lde-tairi~e(s). In';a .cOlid ttibn thatle.d me; to belJ~ve thanhls· conduc.t had ·o<;:C!urreti.

c. D-D~tain~(s) told j:TI.~ tnat this. (toi1dutt had .occurre<:f.~- """;-1 ,d.. o lathers' Who <>oservea this cQ'nd u.ct described ina me.

e. 0 I haverelevaiit iliformation Classified above, '~8ECREf".

f. 0\1 never observed this.conduct nor heard about it froms.onieone who did.

32. Using hands, rope, or:anythi.ng else to chok~or strangle -a d¢t-ain~~, '

a; D I: p~rSOli'ally obs~r\(e9 thl's ,<;pn.qu~t.

b', 0 I ob.se~ved t1etciln~e:(s) !11 a cohd'itiot'l 'th,at ied me to beney~ ~hat ~hls conquet liM .oq;ur·recl.

t~ 0 Oetainee(s:) told me that this· cond.uct had ,dccurr:ecf.d. D Otb.ers: who .observea this ~d.hductd.e$tr.ibed it W. hie.

J~. 0 r tJave relevailt Inf6i'rnation classified aboVe '~SECREf"<.

f. [i:f I never obserVed this conduct nor heard ab·mitiHrom.someonewho did.- .. .. _.. ~. .. .. ... . .. - .. .. ..

01GQ-005576

.3.3. Threa(enirig :Other action to .caUse physical pain/ inJury, .disfigurement/ or-death

a'. D I p~rsonany obs~rved this :cqnd'uct.

b. 0 Iobs~(ved, d~tqirreets) in a'(:ond itjon that 1e4 .me to' b~lieYe thqUhis conduc;t hi;ld o·c<;urrep ..

c. D P~talne~{sltol~ me that this Gondu~thap ,occurred.

q'. d IOthers Who obselll~d t.hl~ ~onduct described It to: Jl:le.

e. 0 l' h!3'Ve relevaiit lliforniatioil' J:las~ifie.dabov.e "S,ECRl0".

r- Ia r n'e,!er obS~f\,fe~' tt)i~ conduc.t npr 'h!=Clr'd ·8bgl),t it from ·.scirilepn~Who Clki.

'34. 'Other .treatment or Mtidn ~~fusirig sig nificant physiCal 'pain of' injiJry ~ ot cailsin~;disf!gurement or-.death '. , .

a'; 0 r p'e[~mi;lnY-~Q&serv~~' this &OI1Put.!:;,

b, 0 t o~s~Jve'dd~talh~e(s} in 'a Gcmd.itipn' fha~ l¢d m~ ~q lj.elie\'e'! th~t thi% ,cQhd,u,tt, had o.<;:~J.llTed;

C- D De~ain.ee(s),tolcl m~ ~hat tbl$:cQrfpl,lc.t na'ct 'o·(curreti...a. 0 Others: wliQ boseni.ed tfds conduct d'es'Cd(je~ it to-me. ,

e; 0 r have reievant ib.f0l'mation· classified :above, 'tS.EeRRi••

f. 0' l' never,obseNeo. this ,C6nCl utt nbthear'd abdut it from somebne,who did.

·j5.. Pladhg adetainee on a,hot surface'.ar ourning a"detaihee

~: 0 I. per:sonClII,topserveg thiS ;conQud.

·b. D t~obset:Ved d~.taihe~(s) In ,a;·c.Qndition that I~, roe to beHey¢tb~tthis. ¢o.ntl!Jet b!3d oCGurred.

e: o iO,~.taine~.(s) 1019 m,e that .thi~·l:ofidut:thclq OcC(lrrE?<!.

tL 0 Others'1A!ho bbsew§.d thi~ c;cm,dl;lc.t des:ctib-e~ it to. me~e. 0 r have relevant information' C1assi.fied above. "SECRET".

f. 0' r n,ev'e,r oD.sE;!rv~d thi$:~iii1(h.lc.t nQr'liear.d ab'out' it from .sdfl)eone:who' did.

:3.6..Usfng 'shackles 6r:oth'errestraintS.ih a prolcrng'ed manner'

OIGQ-005577

a~ o 'I personCllly observed thls,conduct.

b. 0 I observed detainee(s) in 'a'conditionthat led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

.c. o 'D~tainee(s) told me that this <::onduet ~ad occur-re<;!o

(I. 0 bthel}; Who ·ob'.$erved thIs cond4ct(lesc;:rlbed It to me.

e. 0 I have refevant information classified above "S,ECRETJI•-- -- ,..._,__.______•___.___0.:....:-:__._. _.. .___________- ____

f. 0 1.' n~ver 9bserv:ed, this .t9nd4.et nor h~rdaQout it from:$Omeonewho did.

'37-. Requlrlng..a.detalnee;to nialntaln~'or restraining a' detalnee.,lh,a;stressfui or painful pOSltl~h

a... 0 r personally.observed this conduct.

b. 0 I 'observeildetalnee(s) In acond Ition' that led me to believe that this <!onduct had :occurred.

(';. 0 Det?l!pee(s) told me that this cond uct had qccljrred.~

<!.!' 0 Ot~er.? who "O.bserye,d tpis ~ondupt d'e~~rib~ It t~ me!~

e~ 0 L hCilV~re.l~vqht IlJfo.rma~19,n.clcrs.~JfI.~ 'Clb9ve" "·S-ECRET~.

f. 0 I {1~Yer op!>.erv:¢:(j this rc::;of)dut:.;t no'tlieard ,;:Ibo.ut it from $ome~.neWnQ did.

la', D I pe'ts0naHy o.bserved thls-cotldu'd.

b. d I observed detarnee(s) in a'(';onditionthat led me to believe that,this:<!onduct had 'occurred.

k 0 Defainee(s) told me that this: conduct had :occurred.td o !bthe(s who obser:ve,d 'this aond u~j:·descriped i~ to r.ne;{I .

Ie. o I have relevant information' classified above "eSECRET"',• • - " ~ .' • • ' .. _ , • , ~_ _ ,,' •••• ' • :l' ,,,

If. !i:11r. n!=ver (tb~r.v~.9 this '<;:l?-ngUGt 'QQr ,heclr:.d 'c,~.Qut. it JrplJ1 .~qmeol1e ~ho d,id,.

J

a. 0 r perSonally observed this .conduct.

b. 0 I obserVed detaineets) in a.c:oJiditiorlfhat led me fo, belieVe thatltii'S conduct had acc.urred.

c. o IDetainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.

0: D 0the~ who 'o!Jseryed this G8J:ld uct ge~cri~ei1 it t9 n:te.

~. 0 I· ~qve re~evant )l)forll1~tj~m classified a~ove '!$.E:CRET"·.

OIGQ-005578

L!J L~f 11 never observed this conduct nor heard about-it from 'someone who did.

40. Threat~nhT9 to llse electrical sho'ck o'n a detainee

a. 0 I personally observed this .conduct.

b. 0 I opserved:detainee(sJ in a cond ition, that led me: to b~[je.ve that. this ~ondu!=t ha~ occurred.

'C 0 D~tainee.(.s) told ''me theit thi'S' col'1duct had ·occurred.

d. 0 Others: wbb .obserVed this cbnd uct described it to me.

e. 0 I have relevant information classified above, n'SECREf"'.

t: ~ I.nev.er.observed' this:conduct nor heard abeut it from ,someone: who did.

·41,.:IJlt~n~ional!y 'delaY!J:\9 'or"denying ,detainee m~dical care:

;:I'; 0 I' p~~r..sonallY,',o,b~e-rverj this :cqn.duc.t.

b.. D r ohserve'd d.etaine~(s) iri;a ):o!id itiori that led m~ to belie~e that this 'conduct had 'Occu'r[eiL,c. 0 Detain~(s) told rile that this conduct had ,occurr.ed.

d. 0 'Others' Who obser:ve'd this ponduct destribed It to me.

',e. 0 r hail.e relevant iOfarma'tion c1assifie'd .above "S'ECRET",

f. 0' I never observed, this·conduct nor heard ab(futit'ffoni'someone who did.. '

42. M,ood'lng' Qr bllnqfolFilng'~ ,Q~talnee:Dther:-th?n <;luring .1ri3t;lsportaflon,

a. 0 I i>~rspnaliy qQ~eive9 this conalJ¢t.

D', 0 I ob's~rv:eJ:l delalnee(S) In;a c'ond i~ion that Ie-d, me- to belieVe that, thiS' ~on:ducr had ~ccurred,.

t. 0 Detciinee(s) told me th:at this- condU'ct had '0.ccurr.ed:,

'd, 0 Others: who :ob.sef'ved this cond'u,ct oest'ri5~d it to me.

S', 0 I ha\'!e relev'ant lI'lformatlon Classified aboYe '~S'ECREr".

fi ~ I never obserVed this,c-onduct nor'heara about it from someone Who did.........A" '" " -,'-.-- ..... "" ...... .. , _..- ._~-- .,..-..'...,...~......_---¥ _.. "~'.,; ........_........ -........................". -- ... """""- ~_ .._...... ... '.,- '"...- ... _......... ....... ~v." ..

'43. subjecting a detainee, to ~r:emel'tcold or hot room temperatures for extended 'per:iods '

OIGQ-005579

, ,

a~ 0 I personally observed thls.conduct.

b. 0 I observed detainee(s) in a'condltion that led me to believe that this conduct had occurred.

c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that thi~ condlJd had ·occurred.

d. 0 Oth~~' V{hp 'ob'~erved this corrdL!Ct c;I~~crJbed It to me.

e. 0 I hav.e relevant information c;fas~ifie~ .a~oye,II'SECRcrJI.,..- r-~- i-- ---.. --~----_.,-----'------.-~

f. 0 r n~ver observed this ,tqn9U<:;t nor heard 'aQOl!t it (rom,someone-whp' pld.

44.Subjectln'g adetainee'to loud mUSic

a. 0 I. p,ersonally observed this conduct.

b. 0 I observed 'detalnee(s} In ~a'Gond Ition that led me to belleYe that this cronauct had occurred.

e. o IDetainee(s) ~qld me that this lZOnd,U~,t npd'·occ4r.re,d.~

·d.~ 0 Others wh90P?er.y~d tbis condu~td~S9ribed it to l\Ie.,

e., 0 I h?-lv~ rel~vq:rit Il)f<?rma~Jo,n, ~r~rSS.Ifle9 Cjb9VE}, II'SEc'ftEf'l ~

'f. 0 I n~ve.r'op$erv.~d' this.'c;Qlldu<;t nor h~rd ;ab<;J,lit it from' someb)l~Who did.

a'. 0 .r pe'fsonafly,observed fhis eoilduet•.

b. D I 'observed 'detainee{s) ina'concl ition that led me to belieye,that· this C2onduct, had '0ccurred.!-

D IOetainee(s) told me that this conduct had'.occurred.'c.

•d.. D !Others who observed this condu~t'ctesqjbed i1; to me.

~".1 D I h~ve. rel~v:ant jnrorm?ti<?n: ~Iassi,~[.ed 'a.bove. '~S_EqRET"'.

f: M' I.. nr=ver'obs,~riI~4 this ·condu.GblOr ,he,a r,d 'abqutJt ;from .!?qTTleD'!e WDo did.

46.. Isolatin'g a detaiii~ l'Qr an e?<t;encted perio.d

a. 0 r personally observ.ed this.conduct.

b. D r·ob'ser;Ved detafnee{s} iri.a~c6rfd ition''fhat led me fo, believ~ thilnliis conduct' had ,ocd.irred.

c~ [j petainee(s) told me that this cond uct nad occurred.

~. D Qthe~ who D!:rseryet{ tEjis GQf.lduct de~cr~qed 'it t9 me.,

~. D r have relevant information classified above, '''SECRET'''., ",( " '" ' , . .' ~

OIGQ-005580

Q

about it from 'someone who did. I

detainee

t led me: to belie.ve that this c6r'lduct had ,occurred.

d ,O.cturred .

bed it to me.

Ve "SECRET".

aboutft'from.someone who did.

,II extractions'

:

t led 'me to believ.e thati:his conduct had oCGurretl.

tl,occurred.:

beo It to 'me.

.Ye'''SI:CRET''.

'abo"ut:it from~s6meohe who,did,

h

talnee 9t~er than during eje!alpee traf,lsportatlon

It led. me- to: b~lIi=v.e' thatthls conduct had 'occurred., Id'O,ccurr.ed.

oed it 'to m,e.Ve ",SECRET" .

about it from someone,who did........... .--..... v"" ._~----"",,- ~.... • •••"""""", ..... h~ ......... _ • , - ",---,. ..................

or near a d'etal0e.e

OIG -005581

''On

ha

a de

tha

lJas'cri

abE>eafd

th,a

thaseti

-abo

eafd

th~

h'a

scrl

abo

eard

eard[fJJ[]Gever observed this conduct nor h

,47. 4sing duct t2!pe to re~train, gag, or punis

a. 0 I personally'ohserved this .conduct.

b, 0 I observed detainee(s) ih 'a cond'itibli

c. 0 Detaine,e,(s) told m.e that this'conduct,d. 0 Others: whb observed thIs coMuct de

'e. 0 I have relevant information classified

f. 0 L never observed' this 'conduct nor·h

,

:4iL U!?ir!9 rapid ,re!?pon?e team$ al1d/or force

a'. 0 I' p:ersanaJly:ob$rv.e,j this,:c~ncluct.

,b.. 0 r observ.ed a,etaine,e:(s)' jli:a ~c6nditibri

c; 0 Detain~(5}told me that this ~ondu~t

d. 0 OtherS' Who 'obserVed this to.nd,uct de'

,e: 0 r have'releYant i'!lformatio.n classified

f. E1 I never'observed, this 'conduct nor"h

4,~. Using a military working .dog 9/l 'or near

<3.10 [ p~rS9rialj};,6i;lsery¢p this con'du,ct,

b: o II ob's,~.rve,ci detalnee,(s) In:a 'c'ond ition'

c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that thiS: cpnd uc.d. 0 Othern whb ,observed 'this cond uct liee-, 0 I ha\le :relevarit Information classified

f, It( I never observed'thisfcondud nor' h.- ,--, .......... ---. .... , " ...." ~.,... ... .._.. "'..,..,..-.. .. - ........-_ .

:5Q,. Threatening to use-milltary worki,ng, dQ9s

· .

a~ 0 I personally observed thls..conduct.

b. 0 I observed detainee(s) in a'condition that led me to believe thatthis conduct had occurred.

c. o ,D~~ainee(s) told me tha~ this conc!l,Jd hac! 'Qccurred.,

d. 0 bth"e~ WhQ 'QQ'serv~d this c.ondl.jct~:e!?qibed It. tb me.

~., 0 ~ ha\l,e relevant inTQrmation classified .a~·ove "S.ECREfJk.-------------- ------~-----_-..._-----~---, ,-

f. [0 r nev~r 0 bSE:r\fed this :c~>n_du~t nor heel rJf ''? b_o,l,It it from '-sqmeone who did,

51. Us:lng, spldersr .scoqjlons,.snakesr or other c1'hlnials,on or near a d.etalne~

a~ 0 r. personally observed this conduct.

b. 0 , r:observed 'detalnee(s) In 'a condition that led me to belle.ve that-thls C0nduct had ,.occurred.

c,. o 'Oetai,nee(s) told 'me th~t tnis ~onduct .had ;occurred.

d. 0 bt~e~s wh9 'Oq?ery~q 'lpis. ~0n.quqt de!'i?r,ibed it to !TIe~.

e.. 0 I, h,;lV~ 'rel~varit,I,l)formatI9n ~raSslfle<j oCl!Wve ns:ECREr'.,r. [0 'I n~ver obs~rved thjslC;Qlidut;t ,nof;h~rd ,aI:iQ.lit·it fronl.~om~(:lt1~·Who cH9.

a'. 0 r personalfy"o.bseNed this eondlid.

b. 0 I,'.observed detainee(s} ina'(':ond ition that led me to believ:ethat this, mnduct had 'ocGurred.

'c. 0 Detainee(s) told me that this conduct ~ad ,occurr.Erl.

d. o {Others WhQ obsenred this cO\1duot desc[ibed it to me::-:-e'. o II have 'relevant inrormpti,?n qlassifi~qabove '~~,EdRET" ~ if.. [flIt, n~V~r:opS,l;!rvr;;,~ thjs cQnp,UGt 'nqr .he;3r,d :abqut it JrPIJ1 ::;QD1eol1e who' diq.-.

a. 0 I personally observed this,condlict.

b:. 0 r,observecf delainee(s) ii1,.~l';(:.ohdiUon'that' led -me to, believe that.tliis conduct' had occurred.,

·Cr 0, iDetainee(s) told me that this conduct had occurred.

q. o lathers wh:o -qbser:.v~Q "this ~8Jld.uctde~cri~ed It to me

~. Q !.I)ave retevant !l)fQrmC!ti9n' classified C!l;>oye "S,E.C8.Ef"-.

OIGQ-005582

[fJ [~f!I never observed this. conduct nor h~rd about It from 'so~eone who did.

,54. Shaving a detainee's' facial or other hair to embarrass.Of h4miliat~. q .de~ainee

a. o I per.sonaHy b:bservetl this .condott.

b. o II obs~rV!=d:detainee(s) in a condition that led. me to belieye that this cbllduct had oqcurred.

c; 0 Detain~~.{s) told me that this condlict had .octufre(J. .

.d. 0 C>tbers who obsei'ired this cond uct described iUo me.

e. 0 I have relevant information classified 'above "SECRET".

f. 0 1. never ebserved this:conduct nor heard 'aboutit from·.someone:who did.

55, Plqdhg a womqn's:clothi,ng ·on a'd.etaine.e

b. D l' obser:v.ed d.etaine.e(s): in :a '.cond itibri that led 'me to believ.e th'auhis -cond.l1ct had ,be.curr.ed..~--~- -- _.. --~,..,--,-.. ~..- - ... ,

c. 0 Detainee(s) fold tne'that this.tonduc.t had .occurred.

d, 0 Others wh.o obserVed this conduct described It to me.

~e. 0 I have'relevant iof6rmation c1assifiea abmie "SECRET".

f; 0' I nevero,bserv.ed, this:concruct nbrheard about-it from someone who did;

a. 0 [ p~rs9ll'aliy,·,6Q·s.ervesr ~his 1='or'(duct.6:. [j [observed d.et~:1lnee.(~yIn;a CO}id'itlon that I~. m~ to- bellev.e.that this conduct 11a.d ,ote:urred.'c. 0 Detaihee(s) told me th~t this- cond lict had :o.ccurr.ro.

d. 0 OtherS: who ob,sef¥eo :this cor,idu.ct desd-i5e'(l it to me.e-. 0 I ha\te releMmt Information tlassified aboye nSECRET".

Ui.l.~l !.1~ve~r ~:~~~e~,.~hi~_~~iid~at. n?~. ~~~~ ab,?~!!t !r?~ S~~~_b!l~ ~~~,,~j9:. ___ .. -- ~ ...... ,........ ".....~-

57·. !iold!ngdetainee(s) w~o,~ere ,not officjall)(;3Ckno\A{ledged or reg:i!'.tered as such I?y:the ag.~'1cydetaining the; p~rson; .

OIGQ-005583

'.

a. D I, per~nally:.qbserv~d this conduGt.

b. 0 I'Observed d,etainee(~) in ClP:>l1diti91! that led m~ to ~~nev.e that tbi~ <;:qrl'duct had 9ccurr~~.

c. D 'D~h:;iinee:(s}tol(1 m¢ tha~ this COf.lf!uct had occ;urred.

g. 0 Other:s whc;> 9b~~I:Y!~(t 'this ~:OJi~uct descrIbed It tQ me,

e. 0 i have r¢fevant i1'1foniiation' clq'ssifie:d ~b.ove "SECR,ET".

f. 0' I, never 9bs,~rved thl.s ,conduct n9r:h~rd ab'9\J.t it 'fromsoTT1e~newho' gld.

58-. Sending a detainee to another ooiintry for tnoreaggressive interrogation

OIGQ-005584

s~r1bea It to me:

?cribed it .to m~:;.,....,.."..;,.,..,.....;.,.,........""".,.""". ..;...;,;,.,......,...,.,---............",..--,...,.,.."..,.....",.,,.,....-,-,.-..1..... , " "

that led me to believe thadhis' conduct had oCG~rred.,

t ~!;'ld 'o'q;:9m~g,

er:cpuntry for d,eteritioii.:6r mofe.ailljressive intei'ro.gatioh

thC)t lee! me, +0 b~lIeve ·th~t:this eon.du~ D9d 'occurred"

ct bad qcc,u rree! .

. ,

eatd 'abp!J~' it frqrri 'sorr:t~9ne, Vitia; pid.

'eel rd ,about 'it fr0m'sqm'ebne; whO' di4.

1;>; D I'o,hsep(ed.'~e.tpj'n~e.cs) lri'a";G9n9ition th~t-Ied 'me, t9' Q.ene'!~ th9t't.!li~.cqnduc~· had <;jc:curr~Q.

'C, 0 ~~~,?jne~(s) tol!1.me tn~t th'ls,!;onduct o?d ;Q·c~Hrred.

'd D IOthers who nb'served lhjs Gonduct dese::rib¢.d it tQ me:---'------------------1ab,ove "S,ECRETI

".

(" " ',. ~ ~ - "

, ,

e: D I: have reJeya'nt lr)fQrm?lt[on !=19,s,sit'i~

t 0' I' nt?v~r QbServ.eti fnis",cqndu¢t nor h. :

59. Threatening to ,send a detainee to,anoth.

a. 0 .I personally'ops!,!rved t,/Jls.l;;onquct.

b'.. 0 I opserv,ed detain~e,~s} in ,a:c~:>ndition

c.: 0 D~t~in~(~) tql~, rn~ th!3t ttli~: c,<met u~d, 0 qthers; Who ob~erv~9~h,I~ C'Qt)d!lct,·de

e;· D l' have relevant itJforma~fondassified

f, 0 i n'ever Qbs~rved this·.cpridu(:t'npr h, '

,

,69. Threatening to take Clntlpri'. against ad~t

Gl •• 0 r.· p'erso,nally ob~ry~d thrs·~qn<:!!-lct.

b" 0 r,::ob~ryed de.t~lnee(s} In 'a:cond ltion

c;., 0 De!:aine'(;(~) told me ttlqt this cood u

d" 0 Oth~rs who 'Qp~rveg 'this cdr:i~u~rd.e-, .... " .._- . ... .---- _...... .-... ...

I

..

e~ 0 I have relevant Information classified above I~S.ECRET".

f . [~f I never observed this:Gonduct nor heard about it from someone· who did.

.6:L'Other treatment Qr a~tion·.causlng s~vere emotiohal or J:>s)!chological 'trauma to a .d~talne~

a. 0 I p~rSdriany db~rVed this:t6i1duct.

.b. D LooseNed delainee(sJ in:a cond itior'i that led me to believe thannis conduct hadb:ccl1ited.

c. o 'Detainee(s) told me that this. cond'uct had .o.ccurred.

d. 0 Others' who observed 'thiS c0lidl1ct.des{;ribed it to me.e., 0 Lhave relevant information classified above: "SECRET".

f . 0 I ne.ver·observed thls.;conduct nor heard about it from someone whO' did.

.62·.. ·Qther religious·:t;Wsex:uCl( harassment or hlJli1i1iation of a 'getainee:

.a. 0 r person1:lIIy bb'~erve~ tnis.conClOct.•.......... ~~.¥¥. ".. ~

._..

b, n I·.ob~rv.ed.q~t.ai!1ee(s) 1I'!:a .cbndition that led ·me to belieVe tl:iat.this condu.ct had ·oacorred.

c. o jDetainee(s? told .rn:e tbat :this ¢QO'du.ct had .6ccQ rr!=d.

d. O. b.thers· who 'ODserved. tHis ctfii'idUct described if to mE::,

.e. 0 I have·relevant information dassified abo\.(e .'~SECRETU: •

f . r~r I nev.er·obser.vei:l ttiis:conduct nor heard aboutit from 'someone who did,

.63. ·.6~her.tre.i:'ltrnerit of a. df;~a ill~e ttmt :in' ¥OUJ pJ:1inio.n was,ulJprofessiop<;ll/ ,und.LlIY he[$h. or 5199 r,es~ive,. @'r~ilJe~/ .abusiVe/ 'qr l,mlawfUl.

, a. 0 I persqnal!)i obserVed this :C"ohduCt.

D, o ir:obserVed detaiilee(s) in:a Gondition that led me to believe thanliis condiJct nad .occurred.

C- D Detainee.(s) tOld me that this (sandutt had ,occurred.

d. 0 Others who .observed tnis conduct described it to me

.e. 0 I ~av~ !ei~v:ant !nf(;>rrD?ti()nC;I~.ssi.fied a.l;Jove "~.ECB.!;I"'.

f. 0 I,l1ever'observed t.hl? ;cond.l,I~~ 'norneard ,about It fro!TI sorrre.o!1~ WhQ d,ld.

OIGQ-005585

tmWIE0 ~,~@l@i1P'~~' ~,:64. Did v.ou observe, any impersonation of FBI person-nel.by anyone during an interview or i1iterro~ation.ofa ;detain.ee?,

'bYes '0 No

'pS. Did any detarne~ ~r.6ther p.er~oIl.tell you that h~ or she had witnessed the impersonation of F~Ipersonhel in connection with adetainee' interVieW or interrogation?

DYes 0 No66, Are y61l q)IV~r~:bf any ".shqrn".br' 'lIst?,!Qe;:d n det.aine:~ int~rviews or: interro'ga~j'ons ~On9.U<;:t~ f(>r'Mernbers'or-ttre,U:s.. Cql1glj:!SS :ortheir staff? ' ,

, .Q Ye? ~ No;

67. ~o·YQ.u.r khowJ~g'e,·didany rniJi.tatY 91" intelligen~e: person)iel ~ver J1eliy or defay F~I :9f;C13S to 'a:deJ:Eiir'iee· the FBI ~ant~d .tQ, qU'¢Stiori' because the d~taJne~.had .sust~jne!:f jnju rie's :after he Was c,ap'~LJred7

OY.es ~Nb

00 Yes· '0'NO-oQ'.:Were' you e.vet tdld .t.hat:another FBI eh1ploY~e.enc{ed his ot her participation .in a.r .obse(.Y.ation of;. a

detainee in~~rview. (if 'ihlerrp.gation !5'e¢ause 6f ttieiJit~rVi¢W-pr'ititer(Qgcitibft 'metficid~, Being used?bYer;, '0 No . .

10.. PlJting .anY:Qf'y,oj)r Qversep~ .depJ.9ym~,i1ts, OJ pssrgnm~fjts~JH.d yO,u repprt any cpj1cerns:regarqing~I'ny :get~jn~,¢Jn~Em'-lew-o.r i ritefr!ygatldn p'ral:.tic;~sT ,o,r ·Qth~r·.type$ 'oJ d.~taIM~·nec;\tm,e:ntf' tP' ;;in: F~IsupervisO'r?

oYes 0 NQ71. I}l!~jng '~.!1Y of Y9Uf p~~r~e9s ~epioyme.nt~ qr a~,sJgm:nel)tsf'piq'ygQ ,r~pqrt Clny .tl!!l1Cerqs regardi,ng

,~ily 'd.~t?inee'''iriter'yieW',gr iot~rrp'gatidn pra:q:ic~s;pr bth~r tytle!;, :Clf·.detaifI~t.r:e?3:tm¢ht :yq!Jqbser:v¢d or heard ab~utl to' a: lion-.F.BI' supetvisor or other non-fBI p¢r~9nn~l?

o Yes' 0Np,72" /iaye you '~vef b~en ordered. Qr- d\reeted not to' repsrtl '9r,d'jsco~rag,ed i,n' c.my way, from reporting}'.

ol;>servatio.ns'Of c,lIegp,tipn$ related to detain~e tre.atment pr interview or- interrogatipn Clctions.orp'~ctic.~s?

O·Yes ,€I No1~. Haveyou .experlenced any ~etual or threatened' retaliation for reporting observatlons,orallegatlons

·qfdetpineetreCltrnent b,r fn't~rview {~r ilJt~nQgC;lti91i. 9'ctipn~ or PR'lGtices?Q Yes- '~No'

OIGQ-005586

74. (Optional) Please provide any additional comments regar.ding the reporting of <Zoncerns related .toIn~el'\ll~Vo( or in~errog!3tlorrtec;:Jmlq lIes, ~ete.ntlon praqlc~.s, Qr .q~her deta Ine.~ ~r~?l~menr.

~~ @£~&roPi.l5; W~re'You .debriefed, oth~r thanJhe standard deb.riefi.n fD-172"~Qncerning' y.Qur Qve~as.fi$~ignlil$1t(s) oj-·t1eploylil.erit($) aft~T'ydu .tQri:lplete.d the deploYrTient(~) or asSignment(s.)?

Q·Ye5. ~ No

.7.6. Additional Comments:and .Recommend.atI6ns.~

Thank you 'for Yo[Jr·:cCiopefatioli fn tompLetiHg tiifs,;questiorirla'iret. . .

OIGQ-005587