HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    1/40

    SDN 1Alessandro Colombo

    Mattia Giustacchini

    Filippo Falconi

    Diletta Miori

    Alessandro Olivaris

    Marcello Corrado Salati

    Project

    Big Switch

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    2/40

    HP project

    Investing in new product development

    and expanding the product catalog arethe most difficult things to do in hard times,

    and also among the most important

    (Bill Hewlett and David Packard)

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    3/40

    Our HP case

    Case 1Medium enterprise 2-tier Datacenter SDN based

    in a timeframe of 5 years:

    Company scenario: labsforallis a medium companyfocused on hosting of complex IT environment dedicated to

    new Network Function software validation. The companyhas to manage manually segregation and flexibility on DC

    network and a lot of unplanned network downtime. Allaccess and core devices were installed one year ago and

    only 50% of access and all core devices are Openflowcapable.

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    4/40

    Our HP case

    Source: Hp

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    5/40

    TCO analysis

    Qualitative analysis

    Behavioural

    Pre-screening of the sector

    Assumptions and initialconsiderations

    Quantitative analysis

    Excel model (customizableinput data). Focus on:

    Downtime

    Flexibility

    IRR and ROI analysis

    Other TCO indicators

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    6/40

    Key discriminant factors leading to the SDN

    Time To Market

    Usage Intensity

    Cost of Downtime

    Delay and Jitter

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    7/40

    Before starting

    Industries assumptions

    TraditionalSolutions

    TypicalHourly Cost

    of Downtime

    Weekly Business Hours

    YearlyBusiness

    Hours

    EmployeeCost per

    HourHours(per day)

    Workingdays (per

    week)

    BrokerageService

    4,76 9 5 2.340 22,26

    Energy 2,06 24 7 8.736 25,91

    Telecom 1,47 24 7 8.736 21,10

    Manufacturing 1,18 8 6 2.496 18,03

    Retail 0,81 8 6 2.496 12,35

    Healthcare 0,47 24 7 8.736 17,94

    Media 0,07 24 7 8.736 23,95

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    8/40

    Time To MarketIT has become inert, it is just another cost of doing businessNicholas Carr

    SDNservice

    facilitator

    Reduction of timeto market

    Loweropportunity

    costs

    First moveradvantage

    Mature markets where thecompetition is high and it ismainly based on thecompetitive services offering

    The SDN may even gobeyond this, providing anedge over competitors

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    9/40

    Usage Intensity More a consideration than a discriminant variable

    Starting from the assumption that a network infrastructure

    is already present, this behavioral indicators aim is onlyto justify the investment

    Total yearly businesshours

    Brokerage Service 2,340

    Energy 8,736

    Telecom 8,736

    Manufacturing 2,496

    Retail 2,496

    Healthcare 8,736

    Media 8,736

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    10/40

    Cost of Downtime Downtimerefers to the periods when a system is unavailable.

    Downtime or outage duration refers to a period of time in which a system

    fails to provide or perform its primary function. Reliability, availability,recovery, and unavailability are related concepts.

    Source: Soundgardas Source: Network Computing, the Meta Group and Contingency Planning Research;

    Vision Solution

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    11/40

    Delay & Jitter

    (Long) delay: amount of time it takes for a bit to betransmitted from the source to the destination.

    Jitter (or delay variability): delay that varies overtime.

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    12/40

    Delay & Jitter

    The acceptable parameters for applicationperformance, defined by SLAs, are often challenged bynetwork congestion, particularly in live media (ex.streaming, online gaming, voice over IP andvideoconferencing) which are affected more by longdelay and jitter.

    SDN applications could monitor network health(byanalyzing metrics like link utilization, switch queue depths,application flow delay, jitter and packet loss) andempower the network whenever it risks to fall out its SLAs.In case network cannot meet the SLAs, an alert could besent to optimize subsequent data center operations.

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    13/40

    Industries consideredBrokerage

    Service

    Energy

    Maufacturing

    RetailHealthCare

    Media

    Telecom

    BrokerageService

    Energy

    HealthCare

    Media

    Telecom

    Manufacturing

    Retail

    Services Industries

    Production Industries

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    14/40

    Brokerage Services

    Competition in the brokerage industry isgrowing rapidly, thanks to:

    o elimination of the traditionalrestriction against banking activities

    o the disappear of the entry barriers

    o technological advances

    Unbundling the Offerings: The Old Guard vs. the New Wave

    Source: Booz-Allen & Hamilton

    Time to market

    Downtime

    Cost of dowtime/h (Million )

    Brokerage services 4.76

    Source: Network Computing, the Meta Group and Contingency Planning Research;Vision Solution

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    15/40

    Energy

    Time to market

    o Oligopoly market

    o

    Change in the regulamentationof the sector in the 1996, whichaim was to liberalize the market

    Decrease of the barriers to entry +

    ENEL not monopolist in the sector

    anymoreContribution of the biggest company to energy production in Italy(2011)

    Source: FIRE Federazione Italiana per luso Razionale dellEnergia

    Cost of dowtime/h (Million )

    Energy 2.06

    Downtime

    Usage intensity

    Total business h/year

    Energy 8,736

    Source: Network Computing, the Meta Group and Contingency Planning Research;Vision Solution

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    16/40

    Telecommunication

    o High Concentration

    o Mature Market

    o Price War competition

    Time to market

    Downtime

    Cost of downtime/h (Million )

    Telecom 1.47

    Usage intensity

    Total business h/year

    Telecom 8,736

    Delay and Jitter

    o Importance of providing a reliable,

    fast and invariant service

    o Reduce at best bottlenecks

    Source: Network Computing, the Meta Group and Contingency Planning Research;Vision Solution

    Source: sole24ore ottobre 2013

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    17/40

    Retail

    o Mature market

    o Lower opportunity to develop

    o Less loyal customer

    o High competition

    o Moving toward the globalsourcing

    Time to Market

    Source: Pwc 2014

    Total retail: a real opportunity beyond

    the multicanality.

    The growth of digital channel completelychanged the behaviors and the

    consumers needs with respect to

    suppliers and distributors.

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    18/40

    Healthcare

    Usage Intensity

    o Big market that produce ahuge amount of data

    o Increasing relevance of on

    time data updating

    o Need for constant uptime,

    efficiency and flexibility

    o Need of cost savings

    Total business h/year

    Healthcare 8,736

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    19/40

    Media

    o High concentration

    o High entry barriers

    Price competition

    o Last changes: internet, digital TV,smartphone, globalization,customization of mediaservices

    Time to market

    Usage intensitySource: Market revolution

    Total business h/year

    Media 8,736

    Delay and jitter

    o Importance of providing a reliable,

    fast and invariant service

    o Reduce at best bottlenecks

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    20/40

    Manufacturing

    ?

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    21/40

    IndustriesSDN indicators matrix

    Time toMarket

    UsageIntensity

    Downtime Delay andJitter

    Brokerage

    Energy

    Telecom

    Manufacturing

    Retail

    Healthcare

    Media

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    22/40

    The Model

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    23/40

    Simplifications No rack, cabling, cooling & space costs considered in detail

    No computational and storage components

    No decommissioning costs evaluations

    Service layer components out of scope (firewall, Load

    Balancer, ..)

    Noc & Soc assurance: 15 FTE

    Noc & Soc delivery: 10 FTE

    Engineering: 5 FTE

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    24/40

    Assumptions

    Migration cost as setup cost of the whole SDN structure

    Option 1: setup cost minus 30% of controller and related components

    cost

    Option 2: 1styear equal; 2ndyear included the remaining 30%

    Migration cost: 4 persons for the SDN installation (3 months)

    Migration activities are assumed to be done during normal

    working hours

    Reskilling costs: 2000 per person per week

    Time of reskilling hours: 5 hours, 5 days, 3 weeks

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    25/40

    Assumptions

    Business hours are used to calculate Total revenues perhour

    Estimated % of human errors solve by SDN: 55%Source: Cost-Unconscious: Denying the True Cost of Network Downtime, Tim Hebert, 2008

    Time of implementation of new components which allowimplementation of new services:

    TRADITIONAL: 8 h per day, 10 days, 5 persons

    SDN: 8h per day, 4 days, 5 persons

    Number of services implemented per year: 1

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    26/40

    Hypothesis

    Input hypothesis in order to compare the industries:

    Whole system reliability: 0,999

    Number of personnel: 200

    Yearly revenues: 20.000.000

    Downtime penalty: 80.000 per hour

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    27/40

    Input

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    28/40

    Legenda

    Red values: must be inserted in INPUT SHEETSby the users

    Green values: are those that change according to

    the sector

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    29/40

    Input cost

    Type Input costs Category CurrentSolution Proposed (SDN)solution

    Year 0 Year 0 Year 1

    OPEX Unplanned downtime Facility Management 776.524 776.524 349.436

    OPEX Extra-costs opex (due to flexibility) Facility Management 173.275 173.275 69.310

    CAPEX Access Hardware acquisition (tor) Hardware 350.355,15 350.355,15 200.202,94

    CAPEX Core hardware acquisition Hardware 292.205,88 292.205,88

    OPEX Access Hardware Mainteinance Hardware 50.039,71 50.039,71 28.594,12

    OPEX Core hardware Mainteinance Hardware 56.532,35 56.532,35

    CAPEX Total Infrastructure Set-up cost Personnel 428.912 428.912 3.088

    CAPEX Reskilling development team Personnel 16.950

    CAPEX Reskilling delivery team Personnel 47.325

    OPEX Noc&Soc Assurance Personnel 1.050.000 1.050.000 770.000

    OPEX Noc&Soc Delivery Personnel 700.000 700.000 420.000

    OPEX Engineering Personnel 350.000 350.000 350.000

    CAPEX Software management IMC Software 11.029,41 11.029,41 11.029,41

    CAPEX SDN controller solution of acquisition Software 7.352,94

    OPEX Software management IMC mainteinance Software 4.411,76 4.411,76 4.411,76

    OPEX SDN controller solution mainteinance Software 2.941,18

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    30/40

    Downtime

    Current Reliability Current Proposed (SDN)

    Whole system reliability 0,999 0,999

    Total percentage of outtage 0,001 0,001

    Total hours of outtage per day (estimate) 0,024 0,024

    % of human errors solved by SDN 55%Total hours of outtage per year (estimate) 9 4,05

    Personnel uncovered cost Current Proposed (SDN)

    N of personnel 200 200

    Number of hours of outtage 9 4,05

    Estimated percentage of personnelaffected

    90% 90%

    Average employee cost per hour 21,10 21,10

    Total cost (moltiplication) 37.980 17.091

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    31/40

    Downtime

    Revenue opportunity cost (Residuals) Current Proposed (SDN)

    Gross yearly revenue 20.000.000 20.000.000

    Total yearly business hours 8.736 8.736

    Total Revenues per hour 2.289 2.289

    Estimated percentage of revenues

    affected90% 90%

    Downtime hours 9 4,05

    Total opportunity cost 18.544 8.345

    Penalty Current Proposed (SDN)

    Cost per hour 80.000 80.000

    Number of hours of outtage 9 4,05

    Total penalties costs 720.000 324.000

    Current Proposed (SDN)

    Total

    Downtime

    Savings

    Total Downtime 776.523,96 349.435,78 427.088

    Total Downtime per hour 86.280,44 86.280,44

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    32/40

    Flexibility

    Cost of a service implementation Current Proposed (SDN)Time of implementation (hours) 80 32

    Cost per hour 21,10 21,10

    N of people affected 5 5

    Personnel costs 8.440 3.376

    Revenue opportunity cost Current Proposed (SDN)

    Gross yearly revenue 20.000.000 20.000.000

    Total yearly business hours 8.736 8.736

    Total Revenues per hour 2.289 2.289

    Estimated percentage of revenues affected 90% 90%

    Time of outtage 80 32

    Total opportunity cost 164.835 65.934

    CurrentProposed

    (SDN)

    Total

    Flexibility

    Savings

    Total costs of the flexibility

    infrastructure

    173.275 69.310 103.965

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    33/40

    Other costs

    Migration CurrentProposed

    (SDN)

    Personnel needed 4 4

    Time ofimplementation

    2160 2160

    Cost per hour 50 50

    Total migration 432.000 432.000

    SDN controller 3.088

    Total migration cost 428.912 432.000

    Reskilling costs

    Total cost for reskilling perperson

    6.000

    Development team 2

    Total reskilling for dev. Team 12.000

    Service Team (NOC) 5Total reskilling costs for NOC 30.000

    Labor opportunity costs

    Time of reskilling Hrs 75

    Cost per hour 33

    Development Team 2

    Total labor cost for reskilling 4.950

    Service Team (NOC) 7Total labor cost for reskilling 17.325

    Personnel CurrentProposed

    (SDN)

    Cost per year 70.000 70.000

    Noc & Soc -Assurance

    15 11

    Total assurance 1.050.000 770.000

    Noc & Soc - Delivery 10 6

    Total delivery 700.000 420.000

    Engineering 5 5

    Total engineering 350.000 350.000

    SDN specific costs

    Personnel costs Migration costs

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    34/40

    Scenario

    Lifecycle 5 Interest rate 7%

    0 1 2 3 4 5

    Option 1 (current) 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total

    Total CAPEX Current 1.082.502 - - - - - 1.082.502

    Hardware 642.561 - - - - - 642.561

    Software 11.029 - - - - - 11.029

    Facility Management - - - - - - -

    Personnel 428.912 - - - - - 428.912

    Total OPEX Current 3.160.783 3.054.211 3.054.211 3.160.783 3.054.211 3.054.211 18.538.409

    Hardware 106.572 106.572 213.144Software 4.412 4.412 4.412 4.412 4.412 4.412 26.471

    Facility Management 949.799 949.799 949.799 949.799 949.799 949.799 5.698.795

    Personnel 2.100.000 2.100.000 2.100.000 2.100.000 2.100.000 2.100.000 12.600.000

    Total Current 4.243.285 3.054.211 3.054.211 3.160.783 3.054.211 3.054.211 19.620.912

    Option 2 (proposed SDN)

    Total CAPEX Proposed (SDN) 1.082.502 285.949 - - - - 1.368.451

    Hardware 642.561 200.203 - - - - 842.764

    Software 11.029 18.382 - - - - 29.412

    Facility Management - - - - - - -

    Personnel 428.912 67.363 - - - - 496.275

    Total OPEX Proposed (SDN) 3.160.783 1.994.693 1.966.099 2.072.671 1.994.693 1.966.099 13.155.037

    Hardware 106.572 28.594 106.572 28.594 270.332

    Software 4.412 7.353 7.353 7.353 7.353 7.353 41.176

    Facility Management 949.799 418.746 418.746 418.746 418.746 418.746 3.043.528

    Personnel 2.100.000 1.540.000 1.540.000 1.540.000 1.540.000 1.540.000 9.800.000

    Total Proposed (SDN) 4.243.285 2.280.641 1.966.099 2.072.671 1.994.693 1.966.099 14.523.488

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    35/40

    Cash flow statement

    Cash Flow Statement

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    Cash flow (Savings/Losses betweenoptions)

    - 773.569 1.088.112 1.088.112 1.059.518 1.088.112

    Cumulative Savings (losses) - 773.569 1.861.682 2.949.794 4.009.312 5.097.424

    ROI 0,00% 56,53% 136,04% 215,56% 292,98% 372,50%

    NPV - 722.962 950.399 888.224 808.301 775.809

    Total NPV 4.145.695

    Actualized costs/savings and IRR

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total

    Actualized costsCurrent solution

    4.243.285 2.854.403 2.667.666 2.580.140 2.330.043 2.177.610 16.853.147

    Actualized costsProposed (SDN)

    solution

    4.243.285 2.131.441 1.717.267 1.691.917 1.521.742 1.401.801 12.707.452

    Actualized savings - 722.962 950.399 888.224 808.301 775.809 4.145.695

    IRR 70%

    Five years Usage Based TCOTCO per

    business hourTCO per hour

    Current Solution 386 386

    Proposed (SDN) solution 291 291

    Savings per business hour 95 95

    % Savings/TCO Current 24,60% 24,60%

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    36/40

    TCO comparisonCumulative savings graphs

    -500,000

    1,000,000

    1,500,000

    2,000,000

    2,500,000

    3,000,000

    3,500,000

    4,000,000

    4,500,000

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    TCO Comparison

    Total Current

    Total Proposed (SDN)

    -

    1,000,000

    2,000,000

    3,000,000

    4,000,000

    5,000,000

    6,000,000

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    -

    773,569

    1,861,682

    2,949,794

    4,009,312

    5,097,424

    Cumulative Savings (losses)

    Cumulative

    Savings

    (losses)

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    37/40

    Actualized costs/savings and ROI graphs

    0%

    100%

    200%

    300%400%

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

    0.00%

    56.53%

    136.04%

    215.56%

    292.98%

    372.50%ROI

    ROI

    -

    2,000,000

    4,000,000

    6,000,000

    8,000,000

    10,000,000

    12,000,000

    14,000,000

    16,000,000

    18,000,000

    2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Total

    Actualized Costs/Savings

    Actualized costs Current solution

    Actualized costs Proposed (SDN)

    solution

    Actualized savings

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    38/40

    Qualitative and Quantitative advantage graph

    Qualitative advantage:0-5 represents how many relevant qualitative indicators (Time To Market,Usage Intensity, Cost of Downtime, Delay and Jitter) have been identified for the sector or the firm (Customized)Cost Advantage: % actualized savings/ actualized TCO current

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    22% 23% 24% 25% 26% 27% 28%

    Qu

    alitativeAdvantage

    Quantitative Advantage

    Qualitative and Quantitative Advantage

    Brokerage Service

    Energy

    Telecom

    Manufacturing

    Retail

    HealthCare

    Media

    Customized

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    39/40

    Conclusions

    In the provided Web hosting firm case, there is a clear TCOadvantage in completing the implementation of the infrastructure,so adopting the SDN.

    For our case and for each of the considered industries, theoutcome of the TCO model highlights that SDN is able to bring arelevant cost advantage (between 20% and 30%)

    However it becomes even more relevant in those sectors in which itaffects the qualitative indicators or even better brings an importantcompetitive advantage. Thus besides the cost advantage there

    are different reasons linked to different industries features, whichshould lead to the adoption of SDN

    Interesting is to notice that sectors, in the Qualitative andQuantitative Advantagegraph, tend to be clustered confirmingour hypothesis of differentiating production industries and serviceindustries for what regards the adoption of SDN

  • 8/10/2019 HP Project - Software Defined Network TCO

    40/40

    References

    o Brokerage service competition - Booz-Allen & Hamilton 2007. strategy-business.com/article/8926?pg=all

    o Energy competition - FIRE Federazione Italiana per luso Razionale dellEnergia 2014.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asp

    o Telecommunication competitionTelecom e Vodafone perdono quote nella telefonia mobile in Italia,Andrea Biondi, Ottobre 2013.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiI

    o Retail competition: Retail & Consumer, PWC, 2013 pwc.com/it/it/industries/retail-consumer/index.jhtml

    o Media competition: 10 motivi per essere ottimisti sul futuro del mercato dei media in Italia, Stefano Russo,2013 marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/

    o Downtime structure calculation - Assessing the Financial Impact of Downtime, Vision Solution, 2008.strategiccompanies.com/pdfs/Assessing%20the%20Financial%20Impact%20of%20Downtime.pdf

    o Human errors estimated in an IT Datacenter - Cost-Unconscious: Denying the True Cost of NetworkDowntime, Tim Hebert, 2008. changingminds.org/articles/articles08/cost-unconscious.htm

    o Human errors estimated in an IT Datacenter - Addressing the Leading Root Causes of Downtime, EmersonNetwork Power, 2010. emersonnetworkpower.com/en-US/Brands/Liebert/Documents/White%20Papers/data-center-best-practice_24656-R10-10.pdf

    o Estimation of penalty per hour - The Cost of Downtime, Deepak Kanwar, 2013.blog.zenoss.com/2013/06/the-cost-of-downtime

    http://www.strategy-business.com/article/8926?pg=allhttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://changingminds.org/articles/articles08/cost-unconscious.htmhttp://changingminds.org/articles/articles08/cost-unconscious.htmhttp://changingminds.org/articles/articles08/cost-unconscious.htmhttp://changingminds.org/articles/articles08/cost-unconscious.htmhttp://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.marketrevolution.it/10-motivi-per-essere-ottimisti-sul-futuro-del-mercato-dei-media-in-italia/http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/impresa-e-territori/2013-10-02/telecom-vodafone-perdono-quote-120403.shtml?uuid=AbIxeZiIhttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.fire-italia.it/caricapagine.asp?target=elettricita/attori.asphttp://www.strategy-business.com/article/8926?pg=allhttp://www.strategy-business.com/article/8926?pg=allhttp://www.strategy-business.com/article/8926?pg=all