Human Resources Adapting

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    1/16

    Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st Century in Bangladesh

    Abstract:

    Today when we are on the verge of the twenty first century, very rapid and unprecedented

    changes are occurring at the global, national and local levels. For several years Bangladesh has

    seen a massive shift away from an agricultural based economy to knowledge or information

    based economy. But, are we prepared to face these changes? Have we created a conducive

    environment to unleash their potential for the benefit of the organization? These are some of the

    pertinent questions that need to be addressed to the organization to survive and grow.

    Organizations will have to manage and master the change properly. If they can not do so, they

    could end up like the dinosaurs and become extinct. Thus, organizations have an option: they can

    either be agents or victims of changes. This paper will highlight the status of existing twenty first

    centurys human resources management practices by the organization- both manufacturing and

    service, operating in Bangladesh and how Bangladesh can adopt the changes of the twenty first

    century through re-thing and re-engineer the present human resource management practices.

    Key-words: Human Resource Management (HRM), Human Resource (HR), Skill.

    1.0 IntroductionTechnological advances, worldwide competition, falling trade boundaries and a changing world

    order is forcing organizations to re-think their strategies in order to survive and grow. The thrust

    of human resources in the twenty first century in Bangladesh is to prepare a workforce that is

    capable of meeting challenges of a knowledge-based economy, well- equipped with

    technological skills and expertise and a high level of thinking skills. Every organization has a

    personnel function as it must live, train, pay, motivate and maintain employees. Today the

    human resource managers are required to plan, organize, direct and control the procurement,

    development, compensation; integration may accomplish its designated objectives. Human

    resource management in the twenty first century in Bangladesh need to undergo fundamental

    changes and move beyond its traditional human resource management practices to integrate all

    these functions in order to effect a reasonable reconciliation of individual, organizational and

    societal interests. In the newly emerging socio-cultural pattern, society may impose human goals

    upon organizations and these goals may or may not make an immediate contribution to an

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 1

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    2/16

    organizations particular objectives.

    Obviously, human resource management has to face the challenge of bringing about a

    reconciliation of employee needs, managements expectations and societys requirements. While

    surviving and thriving well in the changing scenario, the greatest challenge to human resource

    management is that of balancing the confluence of these three major streams of influence. The

    changing scenario in the world of work has produced an environment of turbulence and

    uncertainty so much so that it calls for a major reorientation or re-thinking in the philosophy,

    policy, programs and practices of managing human resources at work instead of traditional

    human resource management practices.With the rising expectations of people and higher

    performance standards from organization human resource management is required to apply more

    creativity and innovation in human resource practices. The rather, it is to keep alive the process

    of human resource transformation during a sequence of radical corporate change. In this regard,

    may be organization should take the opportunity to review as to whether our Humanware isdeveloped properly and managed optimally.

    2.0 Literature review

    Initially the concept of HRM was developed as a set of techniques that claimed to embrace and

    promote new approaches to management of people and work organization to enhance employee

    commitment and flexibility as well as their willingness to respond rapidly with the chainging

    market conditions for providing competitive advantages to the organization. (Mohiuddin and

    Mahmood, 2001).It is a management concept with multi- and interdisciplinary elements that

    evolved in the early 1980s in the US. It took another decade, 1990s, before it became fully

    established internationally as a scholarly discipline (Poole, 1999, Schuler, 2000).

    The implementation of human resource management policies in an organization requires HR-

    practitioners or professionals to take an active part in different organizational activities.

    According to Schuler et al. (2002), HRM policies and practices involve the development of how

    individuals should be managed and specific HR initiatives. HRM policies and practices include

    those related to planning, staffing, appraising, compensating, training and developing and labor

    relations. HR planning ensures that the organization has appropriate people at the right place and

    time. Hossain and Ahmed ( 1996) revealed that in Bangladesh reason behind the excellentperformance and the existence of large number of NGOs are for their better HR plan.

    Schuler et al. (2002) point out that staffing is a major HRM practice that organization uses to

    help to co-ordinate and control their global operations. Molander (1996) states that recruitment,

    selection and placement are the activities concerned with finding suitable people to fill job

    vacancies within organizations.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 2

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    3/16

    Morley (2004) states that performance appraisal is a managerial tool to control individual

    performance in organizations in order to achieve maximum performance. Ubeda and Santos

    (2007) state that understanding of the relationship between competence based management and

    performance appraisal is necessary.

    Harzing and Van Ruysseveld (1995) state that compensation should be more immaterial in

    nature. This might involve the persons career prospects, for example the opportunity to grow

    within the company or participate in international exchanges of information which allow him/her

    to get involved in strategic policy planning.

    Training and development are defined by Molander (1996) as the systematic process concerned

    with facilitating the acquisition of skills, knowledge and attitudes which result in improved

    organizational performance. He states that the lack of training and development strategies within

    organizations can be viewed negatively by graduates. Low training organizations can lose their

    attractiveness to existing and potential labor.DNetto and Sohal (1999) state managing diversity includes a process of creating and

    maintaining an environment that naturally allows all individuals to reach their full potential in

    pursuit of organizational objectives. Organization can effectively manage cultural diverse

    workforce through the effective integration of HR functions.

    Moyeen and Hug (2001) revealed in Bangladesh HRM is being practiced, either formally or

    informally, to a greater or leaser extent, in business enterprises regardless of their size.

    There is, in fact, no comprehensive study found on changing scenario of HRM practices in the

    21st century. In this circumstance a study on this area is essential to uncover the relevant facts.

    Our studies are endeavor for the same.

    3.0 Objectives of the study:

    The objectives of this study are as follows:

    To assess the nature and characteristics of existing twenty first century human resource

    management practices in Bangladesh.

    To evaluate the changing scenario of human resource management practices in the twenty

    first century in Bangladesh

    To highlight the forward looking human resource management issues and backward

    looking human resource management issues in Bangladesh.

    To recommend strategies and actions to be adopted to face the challenges of the twenty

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 3

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    4/16

    first century human resource management practices in Bangladesh.

    4.0 Methodology:

    The research adopted both quantitative and qualitative techniques for the purpose of the study.

    Keeping the basics objectives in mind, a simple close-ended questionnaire was designed for

    human resource managers of different manufacturing and service organizations of Bangladesh.

    Manufacturing organizations included readymade garments, consumer goods and industrial

    products manufacturing while service organizations comprised banks, telecommunication

    companies, power supply companies and hospitals etc. A total of 100 organizations were

    selected through random sampling. The questionnaire was mailed to the respondents and a total

    of 70 filled questionnaires were received. Among the 70 respondents 20 were manufacturing

    organizations and 50 were service organizations. The data was then tabulated to identify the

    percentage of different practices of human resource management. Secondary data andinformation were collected from the existing literature in the field of human resource

    management. It covered research articles, papers, text books, publications, web sites, and various

    published and unpublished research materials on the subject.

    5.0 Findings of the study:

    The analyses of findings are made under the following main heads keeping in mind the

    objectives of the study.

    5.1 HR categories

    At the macro level, Human Resources can be neatly divided into two general, but distinct

    categories:

    Administrative overhead

    Strategic contributions to organizational success

    Administrative overhead in any professional discipline seeks the most efficient delivery of

    transactional work work that requires little or no subsequent quality interpretation in order to

    satisfy the needs of the organization or its overseers. For example, payroll processes are just that processes. Mechanisms are put into place to insure that payroll data is transferred correctly.

    This allows the payroll processing unit to print the payroll checks or make electronic transfer of

    funds correctly and on time. Historically, this has been done either in-house or with an outside

    local payroll processing company. Now, it can also be done internationally via the Internet, and

    at a lower cost to the subscribing company.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 4

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    5/16

    Strategic HR contributions to organizational success require skill sets that are not as prevalent in

    the traditional HR community. Fortunately, this is changing rapidly as more and more HR

    practitioners acquire these new skill sets and apply them to the organizations performance

    pressure points. Compensation strategy, for example, requires a deeper understanding of basic

    business finance and cost variables in order to recommend and justify payroll practices and

    consequences.

    5.2 RecastingtheHRfocus

    Todays organizational success requires dedicated and highly skilled professionals who can solve

    complex problems using multi-disciplinary teams. As a result, HR can no longer exist as a stand-

    alone function. HR professionals are re-casting the underlying assumptions of the function into

    three fundamental approaches:

    Human Resources leaders are business professionals first and HR specialists second. Their workis focused on helping achieve the companys strategic goals and objectives. As such, they invest

    more in outcomes than in activities. Success in HR functions is now directly related to success in

    marketing, sales, production and other departments.

    Human Resources conduct its operations so that its activities provide critical and measurable

    contributions to the profitability and productivity metrics established for the organization.

    Employee benefit plans typically cost a company between 30% and 40% of payroll costs. These

    costs impact the companys ability to price its products or services competitively so that it can

    maintain its market share and profitability ratios. In designing such policies, HR now considers

    the impact of benefit costs beyond the basic cost of the benefit program. Corporate financial

    performance is no longer restricted to the Finance and Accounting department.

    Human Resources professionals are becoming fluent in the language of business and the cultural

    norms of the society. All business people must clearly know how to read financial statements and

    link their work to those performance drivers. Non-financial metrics such as environmentalism,

    community involvement, and corporate social responsibility are becoming more and more

    critical as special interest investors demand performance results in these areas. High performing

    HR executives assume a leadership role in advancing these and other non-financial objective as

    well as the traditional financial metrics.

    5.3 Forward looking HR vs. Backward looking HR

    If we examine traditional HR practices, we observe that most of the rules and regulations under

    which we operate were created during the Industrial age economic model. Much of it made sense

    then, but a lot of it does not make sense in todays information/knowledge economy.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 5

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    6/16

    Our compensation laws, for example, were created in the 1930s during the height of the

    Depression. They have been modified somewhat over the years, but the underlying theories of

    the industrial era mind-set still govern and control our compensation thinking. This conflicts with

    the knowledge age economic mindset. The paradigm has shifted.

    The popular organizational behavior theories that are highlighted in all of our textbooks were

    generated during the 20th century when manual production was a dominant industrial force.

    Popular thinkers such as Abraham Maslow, Douglas McGregor, Frederick Herzberg and their

    colleagues all based their research on the industrial models that they had to work with.

    Generally, supervisors and employees were all in close physical proximity to each other. There

    were numerous opportunities to observe worker interactions and draw rational conclusions.

    Now, in our knowledge based and virtual management economy, our subordinates are connected

    electronically via the Internet and much of our industrial work has morphed into an efficient

    mechanized or digitized process that reduces the need for human intervention. Thanks totechnology, our work teams may comprise of six people working in six different countries with

    six different approaches to labor laws. Thus, the industrial paradigm has shifted to the global

    knowledge or information paradigm. With this shift come opportunities for the Human

    Resources function to re-cast their role in the organization.

    5.4 Re-casting human resource roles

    Lets take five HR roles and examine them in detail.

    Compensation

    Labor and compensation laws such as exempt and non-exempt overtime classifications and the

    40-hour work week were created during the 1930s when the US was trying to re-start its

    industrial engines. Those rules still govern our compensation thinking and still govern many of

    the labor laws under which companies must operate. Yet corporate operating business paradigms

    have significantly shifted away from the conditions that existed during the 1930s and the

    1940s. Where once hierarchical structures were typical, matrix and virtual organizations are

    now common place.

    Yet our compensation laws lock us into the 40-hour work week with mandatory overtime for any

    hours worked beyond that limit. It forces the employer and the employees to put the processahead of the outcome. Even when an employee is highly motivated to finish a job, he must stop

    at the 40 hour mark because, in order to remain competitive, his company cannot, or has decided

    not to pay overtime. Tight budgets and other countries competing for our production and service

    business at much lower costs have created business models that, not surprisingly, force us to

    consider outsourcing as a smart option.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 6

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    7/16

    Human capital

    We are currently living in an era where four generations are working together in the same

    workplace: Veterans, Baby-boomers, Generation X and Generation Y. Each group comes with

    its own set of generational values, attitudes, capabilities, and inherent biases. As such, one-size-

    management-fits-all is not effective with these four groups. Dominant work values between the

    generations inherently clash unless a unifying force is present. The challenges to the employers

    and employees is to find that unifying force, hopefully without violating trust, ethics, law, and

    common sense.

    Work values are powerful forces impacting the four generations. Younger employees, for

    example, tend to focus more on intrinsic motivators and satisfiers such as freedom and

    autonomy, task identity and task significance than older employees. Older employees tend to

    focus more on identity to their career and keeping up with the rapid-fire technological changes

    changes that may indicate whether they will continue to have a job.The reality of our nomadic and inter-generational workforce forces organizations to re-think their

    approach to employees. Smaller companies tend to offer greater opportunities for a wide range of

    responsibilities and authority. However, they may not be able to provide promotion or in-depth

    development opportunities within a skill set such as marketing, human resources or information

    technology. Larger companies may be able to provide strong functional discipline opportunities

    such as sales but at the expense of locking the employee into a narrow career field that is subject

    to powerful and changing market forces.

    Evaluating work

    Until recently, most job descriptions typically described activities performed rather than

    contributions made to organizational success factors. Under the backward looking paradigm,

    many supervisors have difficulty articulating why their subordinates job existed and how it is

    directly linked to the success of the department or the organization. With poorly conceived and

    thus poorly written job descriptions, it is difficult at best to take any performance appraisals

    system seriously. These systems are morphing from a theoretically valuable performance

    improvement process to a Cover Your Ass legal protection device. No one is served by this

    approach.

    Compounding these problems, managers link personnel decisions to these poorly conceived jobdescriptions and performance appraisals. Promotions, salary increases, transfers, layoffs, job

    assignments and other personnel actions are accomplished using a system that is flawed by the

    paradigm shift from brawn to brains.

    In Performance Appraisals systems, old underlying assumptions must give way to new,

    alternative assumptions. Performance appraisals given by poorly trained superiors who may

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 7

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    8/16

    work and reside on the other side of the country or the world assume that the process will

    motivate an employee to achieve higher standards. According to the authors, there is no

    empirical evidence to support these assumptions. Value-added work requires knowledge or

    information and the ability to influence the resulting data to the benefit of the client or customer.

    The paradigm shift argues that the knowledge employees are better suited for self developed

    appraisal than the system created by the organization. Yet our labor relations courts bind us to

    remain under outdated laws that are deleterious to the skills, abilities, desires and retain ability of

    the knowledge workers.

    Todays successful workforce focuses on empowerment and the ability to solve complex

    problems in multi-disciplinary teams. In many companies, supervisors may supervise 20-30

    people with many of them located in various parts of the world. Under the old paradigm, the

    manager would have to evaluate them all in a common process. Now, with a highly intense

    workload, no manager or supervisor can consistently or fairly appraise anyone under the oldsystem.

    Other systems are being re-thought. For example, forced ranking approaches has merit but fails

    to take into account that no one cares who is in the top or bottom if the company is going

    bankrupt. The paradigm has shifted.

    Managing human capital

    A review of textbooks and literature on organizational development has many chapters relating

    to the classic theorists of the 20th Century. Abraham Maslows Hierarchy of Needs, Frederick

    Herzbergs Hygiene Factors, Douglas McGregors Theory X vs. Theory Y, and, of course,

    Frederick Taylors Scientific Management, to name a few.

    Although most of those theories were not supported by empirical evidence, a lot of them made

    sense at the time. Some still do. Yet the research that led to these theories was conducted in

    during an entirely different cultural paradigm. For example, in the first half of the 20th Century,

    when many of these theories originated, most supervision was local. The supervisor was within a

    short walk of all of his or her subordinates. There was plenty of opportunity to formally observe

    work performance and production. There was also plenty of opportunity to informally gather in

    the lunch room, the hallways, the factory shop, and on the ball field or other social venues. Most

    workers lived in the same community and shared common values, cultures and experiences.Closer relationships were formed and general observations could be made.

    Today, however, a manager may be located in Chicago with her direct reports located in Seattle,

    Dallas, Singapore, Tel Aviv, and Buenos Aires. Managing people in diverse sites who are

    connected to you via the Internet opens up challenges to conventional managerial theories.

    Traditional subjects like motivation, communication and leadership take on an entirely new

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 8

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    9/16

    dimension and are constantly being challenged. Where Maslow and Herzberg focused on

    American workers, globalism has begged for additional research on topics such as motivation

    and empowerment based on international sensitivities and traditions.

    Cultural differences

    Indeed, analyzing variations among cultures was exhaustively done in the 1970s (with

    subsequent updates) and found that managers and employees vary on five value dimensions of

    national culture. Each dimension is worthy of further study and comprehension:

    Power and distance focuses on the degree of equality or inequality between people in a

    countrys society;

    Individualism focuses on the degree the society reinforces individual or collective achievement

    and interpersonal relationships;

    Masculinity focuses on the degree society reinforces, or does not reinforce, the traditional

    masculine work role model of male achievement, control and power;Uncertainty avoidance focuses on the level of tolerance for uncertainty and ambiguity within the

    society;

    Long Term Orientation focuses on the degree to which a society respects cultural traditions and

    the value it places on long-term commitments.

    Training employees for international assignments is a discipline into itself. Not only to they have

    to know business etiquette and negotiating styles of the host country, they also have to

    understand the impact of concepts on their business and social activities in their foreign

    assignment.

    5.5 The empirical study

    The survey revealed that all organizations in Bangladesh practice 21st centurys HRM of some

    sort. However, there are variations in terms of traditional HRM and 21st centurys HRM

    practices.

    Table-1 HRM Practices in Bangladesh

    HRM Practicesin Bangladesh

    Organizational Belief andAssumptions regarding

    HRM Practices in

    Bangladesh

    Organizational StrategiesAspect regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Organizational KeyLevers regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Total

    Traditional HRM 80% 40% 51% 57%

    21st century HRM 20% 60% 49% 43%

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 9

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    10/16

    Source: Field Study

    It is observed (Table-1) that 57% organizations practice traditional HRM whereas 43%

    organization practice 21st centurys HRM. A considerable variation was also observed among

    manufacturing and service organization in this regard.

    Table -2 HRM Practices in Manufacturing Organization in Bangladesh

    HRM Practices

    in Bangladesh

    Organizational Belief and

    Assumptions regarding

    HRM Practices in

    Bangladesh

    Organizational Strategies

    Aspect regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Organizational Key

    Levers regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Total

    Traditional HRM 78% 38% 48% 55%

    21st

    century HRM 22% 62% 52% 45%Source: Field Study

    It showed ( Table-2) that 55% manufacturing organization in Bangladesh practice traditional

    HRM and 45% practice 21st centurys HRM while ( Table-3) 59% service organization in

    Bangladesh practice traditional HRM and 41% practice 21st centurys HRM.

    Table -3 HRM Practices in Service Organization in Bangladesh

    HRM Practices

    in Bangladesh

    Organizational Belief and

    Assumptions regarding

    HRM Practices in

    Bangladesh

    Organizational Strategies

    Aspect regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Organizational Key

    Levers regarding HRM

    Practices in Bangladesh

    Total

    Traditional HRM 82% 42% 54% 59%

    21st century HRM 18% 58% 46% 41%

    Source: Field Study

    In terms of organizational belief and assumptions regarding HRM practices in Bangladesh, it was

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 10

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    11/16

    observed (Table- 4) 80% organizations practice traditional HRM whereas 20% organization

    practice 21st centurys HRM. Among beliefs and assumption, most practices (24%) in the 21 st

    centurys HRM by the organizations are guide to management action philosophy where as most

    practice (91%) by the organizations in case of traditional HRM is contract philosophy.

    Table -4 Organizational Belief and Assumptions regarding HRM Practices in Bangladesh

    Source: Field Study

    As regard of organizational strategies aspect regarding HRM practices in Bangladesh, it was

    observed (Table- 5) 60% organizations practice 21st centurys HRM whereas 40% organization

    practice traditional HRM. Among organizational strategies aspect, most practices (89%) in the

    21st centurys HRM by the organizations are communication philosophy where as most practice

    (84%) by the organizations in case of traditional HRM is key relations philosophy.

    Table -5 Organizational Strategies Aspect regarding HRM Practices in Bangladesh

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka

    Organizational

    beliefs and

    assumptions

    regarding HRM

    HRM Task HRM Practices Manufacturing

    Organization

    Service

    Organization

    Total

    Contract Careful delineation Traditional HRM 90% 92% 91%

    Aim to go beyond contract 21st century HRM 10% 08% 09%

    Rules Importance of devising Traditional HRM 90% 92% 91%

    Can do outlook, impatience

    with rule

    21st century HRM 10% 08% 09%

    Guide to

    management

    action

    Procedures Traditional HRM 80% 72% 76%

    Business need 21st century HRM 20% 28% 24%

    Managerial task

    to labor

    Monitoring Traditional HRM 50% 56% 53%

    Nurturing/ take care 21 st century HRM 50% 44% 47%

    Nature of

    Relations

    Pluralist Traditional HRM 80% 96% 88%

    Unitarist 21st

    century HRM 20% 04% 12%

    Grand Total Traditional HRM 78% 82% 80%

    21st century HRM 22% 18% 20%

    11

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    12/16

    Source: Field Study

    Concerning organizational key levers regarding HRM practices in Bangladesh, it was ascertained

    (Table- 6) 49% organizations practice 21st centurys HRM whereas 51% organization practice

    traditional HRM. Among organizational key levers regarding HRM aspect, most practices (70%)

    in the 21st centurys HRM by the organizations are working environment philosophy where as

    most practice (73%) by the organizations in case of traditional HRM is job categories and gradephilosophy.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka

    Organizational

    Strategies Aspect

    regarding HRM

    HRM Task HRM Practices Manufacturing

    Organization

    Service

    Organization

    Total

    Corporate plan Marginal to Traditional HRM 40% 24% 32%

    Central to 21st century HRM 60% 76% 68%

    Speed of decision Slow Traditional HRM 30% 36% 33%

    Fast 21st century HRM 70% 64% 67%

    Initiatives Piecemeal Traditional HRM 30% 48% 39%

    Integrated 21st century HRM 70% 52% 61%

    Key relations Labor management Traditional HRM 80% 88% 84%

    Customer 21st century HRM 20% 12% 16%

    Communication Indirect Traditional HRM 10% 12% 11%

    Direct 21st century HRM 90% 88% 89%

    Grand Total Traditional HRM 38% 42% 40%

    21st century HRM 62% 58% 60%

    12

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    13/16

    Table -6 Organizational Key Levers regarding HRM Practices in Bangladesh

    Source: Field Study

    6.0 Concluding remarks

    Traditional Human Resources assumptions are being reconsidered as its leaders and practitioners

    re-think how the discipline goes about adding value to its host company. For example, the merit

    increases between an above average performer and an average performer is typically marginal at

    best. Most companies can only afford 3-5% pay raises for the best of the employees and

    somewhat less for average employees. The effect is dissatisfaction with a formerly motivated

    employee.

    Basic managerial and supervisory skills were, and still are taught using industrial era

    philosophies. Supervisory courses are being taught with a model that assumes that the supervisor

    is in daily and personal contact with his subordinates and can control the environment wherethey work in order to achieve higher performance standards. When it comes to evaluating the

    performance of her subordinates, the manager is expected to comply with the spirit and letter of

    an appraisal system that was designed 50+ years ago under an entirely different managerial

    mindset. This is hardly a recipe for success.

    What can HR do to adjust to this paradigm shift? Here are some suggestions:

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka

    Organizational

    Key Levers

    regarding HRM

    HRM Task HRM Practices Manufacturing

    Organization

    Service

    Organizatio

    n

    Total

    Selection Separate Traditional HRM 30% 44% 37%

    Integrated 21st century HRM 70% 56% 63%

    Pay Fixed grade Traditional HRM 40% 64% 52%

    Performance related 21st century HRM 60% 36% 48%

    Working

    environment

    Separately negotiated Traditional HRM 40% 20% 30%

    Harmonization 21st century HRM 60% 80% 70%

    Job categories and

    grades

    Many Traditional HRM 70% 76% 73%

    Few 21st century HRM 30% 24% 27%

    Job design Division of labor Traditional HRM 60% 68% 64%

    Team work 21st century HRM 40% 32% 36%

    Grand Total Traditional HRM 48% 54% 51%

    21st century HRM 52% 46% 49%

    13

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    14/16

    Human resources practitioners must become fluent in the language of business This means

    that they have to understand basic concepts of business finance and accounting. One does not

    need to be a CPA in order to read basic financial statements like those found in corporate annual

    reports. However, HR must be able to link their metrics to those of executive leadership. Where

    HR is concerned with efficient administration of benefits and compensation programs, the CEO

    is concerned about rising payroll costs that affect pricing strategies to sustain competitive

    advantages and market share. HRs arguments cannot be accepted unless they address the issues

    that keep CEOs awake at night. Falling profit margins and dwindling retained earnings may

    signal downsizing, re-structuring, and other belt-tightening measures. Conversely, rising profit

    margins can be opportunities to improve salaries, benefits, and other job enhancement

    opportunities. Smart HR professionals watch the numbers and base their initiatives on the

    opportunities or threats that are presented.

    Link HR work to the factors that govern your organizations decision making processes

    Although much of HR work is transactional in nature, strategic Human Resources focuses its

    efforts on profitability and productivity contributions that enhance the organizations ability to

    sustain and grow its business. Although a lot of HR work is heavily focused on managing the

    employment process in accordance with the spirit and letter of employment law, newer and more

    tangible value-added work focuses on work outcomes beneficial to corporate survivability and

    success. No one in any job can be allowed to confuse activity with productivity.

    Wholly integrate HR into all other departments Human resources as a corporate function

    cannot exist as a stand-alone discipline. Organizations are made up of several interconnected and

    interdependent entities. HR must wholly integrate itself into all other functions and its

    practitioners must be able to speak the language of every department. If you expect to work as an

    equal partner with the companys other strategic experts, you must be able to talk with and to

    themat their levelabout their areas of responsibility.

    Develop competitive intelligence skills Competitive intelligence helps firms define andunderstand their industry and identify rivals strengths and weaknesses. It is not spying, which

    implies illegal or unethical activities. It is an assessment of future trends, needs, threats and

    opportunities. The more you know about your business and its industry, the more apt you are to

    make decisions that positively affect your outcomes. It is not, however, a crystal ball. No one, for

    example, could have predicted the power of the Internet 20 years ago.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 14

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    15/16

    HR professionals learn to scan & monitor the environment in order to predict their companys

    human capital needs. What skills, knowledge and abilities (KSAs) will the company need to

    sustain and grow their business? Four generations working together creates recipes for conflict

    unless managers understand the differing motivating values of each generation and develops a

    unifying force to unite the segments. In order to attract and retain the best and the brightest

    people, HR develops forecasting models based upon factors such as market growth, financing

    availability, technology, and organizational culture. From this competitive intelligence, HR is

    able to produce a business plan support strategy that will direct the activities and outcomes of the

    department towards the overall goals of the company.

    Human Resources professionals are in a unique position to make the transition from back

    office administrative overhead to front line profitability and productivity contributors.

    Fortunately, it appears that the leadership of SHRM is taking the lead in encouraging its local

    chapters to adapt to the changing world or risk being marginalized or eliminated altogether. It isthe job of all of us to help make this transition.

    References

    Ahmed F. and Hossain Z. M. (1996), Human Resource Planning (HRP) Practiced by the NGOs

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 15

  • 8/3/2019 Human Resources Adapting

    16/16

    in Bangladesh: The Care Experience, Dhaka University Journal of Business Studies, Vol. XVII,

    No. 2, December, pp, 207-227, Dhaka.

    Amin M. R. and Asaduzzaman M. (1997), Human Resources Development in Bangladesh: An

    Islamic Perspective, Dhaka University Journal of Business Studies, Vol. XVIII, No. 2,

    December, pp, 97-118, Dhaka.

    Bhattacharjee D. (1986),Planning of Human Resources Development in Bangladesh: Neglected

    Aspects, The Dhaka University Studies, Part C, Vol. V1I, No. 2, December, pp,171-186, Dhaka.

    DNetto, B. and Sohal, A.S, (1999), Human Resource Practices and Workforce Diversity: An

    Empirical Assement , International Journal of Manpower, Vol. 20, No.8, pp,530-547, Bingley,

    UK

    Decenzo, A. David, Robbins, P. Stephan (2004), Human Resource Management, Prentice Hall

    ,India.

    Kuraishi, A. Sajid. (1990), Human Resource Management: Emerging Trends and Policies,

    Pakistan Management Review, Second quarter, pp.25-39, Shahra-e-Iran, Clifton, Karachi-75600,Pakistan.

    Mahmood M. H. Mohiuddin M (2001),Personnel to Human Resource Management: ADevelopmental Perspective Analysis, Dhaka University Journal of Business Studies, Vol. XXII,No. 2, December, pp. 287-296,Dhaka

    Ubeda C.L. and Santos F.C.A. (2007), Staff development and performance appraisal in Brazilian

    Research Center, European Journal of Innovation Management, Vol. 10, No.1 pp.229-240,

    Bingley, UK

    Walker, J.W. (1990), Human Resource Planning: 1990 Styles, Human Resource Planning, Vol.

    13, No.4 pp109-125, Public Personnel Management Journal, Estes Street, Ipswich, USA.

    M.T. Islam, M.A. Rahaman 2011Human Resource Management Practices: Adapting to the 21st

    Century in Bangladesh Journal of Business studies, University of Dhaka 16