Upload
stefan-wunder
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 1/80
Eo{znt Zmn{b{
Bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg Jnwnafxenlz Xfznlzboa{
Do{nj fl o Dnlkmeotcbl` [z~jr gft ol
Bllfwozbfl Xaozgfte
[zngol P~ljnt
Bl{zbz~zn fg
Xtfj~kzbfl [kbnlkn olj Eolo`nenlz
Enednt fg Gtolc [ztflokm Bl{zbz~zn
^lbw,%Xtfg, Jbxa,%Bl`, Jt,znkml, Kmtb{zbol Toe{o~nt
@toy! 48??
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 2/80
BB
[zoz~zftr Jnkaotozbfl
B jnkaotn zmoz B mown o~zmftnj zmb{ zmn{b{ bljnxnljnlzar! zmoz B mown lfz ~{nj
fzmnt zmol zmn jnkaotnj {f~tkn{ & tn{f~tkn{! olj zmoz B mown n}xabkbzar eotcnj
oaa eozntboa pmbkm mo{ dnnl q~fznj nbzmnt abzntoaar ft dr kflznlz gtfe zmn ~{nj
{f~tkn{,
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
jozn {b`loz~tn
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 3/80
BBB
Od{ztokz
Zmb{ zmn{b{ jnoa{ pbzm zmn znkmlbkoa olj nkflfebkoa kmoaanl`n{ fg bllfwozbfl
xaozgfte{, Bl xotzbk~aot! zmn bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg k~ttnlz jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ fg
zmn bllfwozbfl xaozgfte Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz b{ zmn gfk~{ fg ozznlzbfl,
Zmn zmnftnzbkoa xotz fg zmb{ zmn{b{ kflzobl{ zmn tnanwolz abzntoz~tn gbljbl`{
kflkntlbl` zmn otno{ bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz olj clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz,
Zmn kflknxz{ fg Kaf{nj% olj Fxnl Bllfwozbfl o{ pnaa o{ zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl`
xtblkbxan otn kfwntnj dr zmb{ xotz, G~tzmnt! zmn tnanwolkn fg clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz gft bllfwozbfl olj {~xxftzbwn znkmlbkoa {r{zne{ gft clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz otn zmn gfk~{,
Zmn xtokzbkoa xotz jnoa{ pbzm zmn bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{
do{nj fl o dnlkmeotcbl` {z~jr gft zmn bllfwozbfl xaozgfte Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz ,
Gbt{z ol blzntloa oloar{b{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl b{ okkfexab{mnj, Bl o dnlkmeotc
oloar{b{ kflk~ttbl` bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ otn blwn{zb`oznj olj dnlkmeotc{
otn jnznteblnj, K~ttnlz jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl otn f~zablnj
olj {fa~zbfl kflknxz{ otn blztfj~knj, Dnlngbz{ olj kf{z{ fg zmn blztfj~knj
{fa~zbfl{ otn n{zbeoznj, Gbloaar! g~z~tn jnwnafxenlz fxxftz~lbzbn{ gft Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz otn jb{k~{{nj,
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 4/80
BW
C~tygo{{~l`
Jbn{n Otdnbz dn{kmêgzb`z {bkm ebz jnl znkmlb{kmnl ~lj ÷cflfeb{kmnl
Mnto~{gftjnt~l`nl wfl Bllfwozbfl{xaozzgftenl, Bl{dn{fljntn {znmz jbn
Bjnlzbgbcozbfl wfl ocz~naanl Nlzpbkca~l`{xfznlzboanl jnt Bllfwozbfl{xaozzgfte
Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz be Gfc~{ jbn{nt Otdnbz,
Be Tomenl jn{ zmnftnzb{kmnl Znba{ pbtj jbn nbl{kmaê`b`n Abzntoz~t ñdnt jbn
Dntnbkmn Bllfwozbfl{eolo`nenlz ~lj Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz {r{zneozb{bntz,
Jbn Cflynxzn wfl Kaf{nj% ~lj Fxnl Bllfwozbfl! {fpbn jo{ Ktfpj{f~tkbl`
Xtblybx pntjnl j~tkm jbn{nl Znba od`njnkcz, Jn{ Pnbzntnl pbtj jbn
Dnjn~z~l` wfl Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz gñt Bllfwozbfl ~lj E÷`abkmcnbznl y~t
^lznt{zñzy~l` wfl Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz j~tkm znkmlb{kmn [r{znen
dnmoljnaz,
Jnt xtoczb{kmn Znba dngo{{z {bkm ebz jnt Bjnlzbgbcozbfl wfl
Nlzpbkca~l`{xfznlzboanl do{bntnlj o~g nblnt Dnlkmeotcbl` [z~jbn gñt jbn
Bllfwozbfl{xaozzgfte Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz , Y~ Dn`bll pbtj nbln blzntln Oloar{n
wfl Ln~tfwozbfl j~tkm`ngñmtz, Bl nblnt Dnlkmeotc Oloar{n pntjnl
cflc~ttbntnljn Bllfwozbfl{xaozzgftenl ~lznt{~kmz ~lj Dnlkmeotc{ ntebzznaz,N{ pntjnl ocz~naan Nlzpbkca~l`{xfznlzboan wfl Ln~tfwozbfl dn{kmtbndnl ~lj
A÷{~l`{cflynxzn wft`n{znaaz, L~zynl ~lj Cf{znl jnt wft`n{znaaznl A÷{~l`nl
pntjnl od`n{kmêzyz, [kmabnÖabkm pntjnl y~cñlgzb`n
Nlzpbkca~l`{e÷`abkmcnbznl gñt Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz jb{c~zbntz,
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 5/80
W
Okclfpanj`nenlz
Oz zmb{ xfblz B pf~aj abcn zf potear zmolc oaa zmf{n xnfxan pmf mown
kflztbd~znj zf zmb{ pftc,
Gbt{z B pf~aj abcn zf zmolc er {~xntwb{ft JB Wntnlo Eollbl`nt gft {~xxftzbl`
en j~tbl` zmn pmfan xtfkn{{ fg zmb{ eo{znt zmn{b{, Zmolc rf~ gft oaa zmn
woa~odan {~``n{zbfl{ olj ktbzbkoa jb{k~{{bfl{! pmbkm mown kflztbd~znj `tnozar
zf {~kkn{{ fg zmb{ pftc,
B pf~aj abcn zf zmolc zmn pmfan znoe fg Ln~tfwozbfl! n{xnkboaar JB -GM"
Iñt`nl Wfaantbz{km olj JB Jt, Tnblmotj Pbaagftz gft eocbl` zmb{ eo{znt zmn{b{
xf{{bdan olj gft {~xxftzbl` en olrzben pbzm woa~odan jb{k~{{bfl{ olj lnp
bjno{ j~tbl` er zben oz Ln~tfwozbfl,
[xnkboa zmolc{ zf er nlzbtn goebar! n{xnkboaar er xotnlz{ pmf oapor{
{~xxftznj en j~tbl` er zben o{ o {z~jnlz olj pmf oaafpnj en zf {z~jr, B
pf~aj abcn zf potear zmolc er `btagtbnlj! Mollom! gft zmn eftoa {~xxftz olj
gft zmn afwn rf~ `bwn zf en,
Gbloaar! B pf~aj abcn zf zmolc oaa zmn gnaafp {z~jnlz{ pbzm pmfe B po{ oaafpnj
zf ztnoj xotz fg zmn por fg er {z~jr,
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 6/80
WB
Zodan fg Kflznlz{
[ZOZ^ZFTR JNKAOTOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, BBOD[ZTOKZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, BBBC^TYGO[[^L@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, BWOKCLFPANJ@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, WZODAN FG KFLZNLZ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, WB? BLZTFJ^KZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2?,? BLBZBOA [BZ^OZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2?,4 FDINKZBWN[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2?,; [ZT^KZ^TN FG ZMN ZMN[B[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?84 BLLFWOZBFL EOLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?44,? BLLFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?4
KFLKNXZ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?44,?,?
KMOTOKZNTB[ZBK[ FG OL BLLFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?;4,?,4
KTNOZBWBZR OLJ BLLFWOZBFL,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?>4,?,;
4,4 BLLFWOZBFL EOLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?7 LFTEOZBWN BLLFWOZBFL E OLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?04,4,?
FXNTOZBWN BLLFWOZBFL E OLO@NENLZ % ZMN BLLFWOZBFL XTFKN[[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?=4,4,4
[ZTOZN@BK BLLFWOZBFL E OLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4?4,4,;
4,; FXNL BLLFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 47 FXNL BLLFWOZBFL ZTNLJ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 474,;,?
ZMN FXNL BLLFWOZBFL X OTOJB@E,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 4=4,;,4
DNLNGBZ[ FG FXNL BLLFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;84,;,;
TB[C[ FG FXNL BLLFWOZBFL,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;44,;,:
4,: KTFPJ[F^TKBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;> KTFPJ[F^TKBL@ KFLKNXZ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;>4,:,?
ZMN KTFPJ[F^TKBL@ XTFKN[[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;=4,:,4
KTFPJG^LJBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ;24,:,;
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 7/80
WBB
; CLFPANJ@N EOLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :8;,? CLFPANJ@N,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :8
J
NGBLBZBFL FGC
LFPANJ@N,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :8
;,?,?
KMOTOKZNTB[ZBK[ FG CLFPANJ@N ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :4;,?,4
CLFPANJ@N OLJ BLLFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :4;,?,;
;,4 CLFPANJ@N EOLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :; ZMN X^TXF[N FG CLFPANJ@N E OLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :;;,4,?
ANWNA[ FG CLFPANJ@N E OLO@NENLZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ::;,4,4
CLFPANJ@N E OLO@NENLZ KFEXFLNLZ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, :7;,4,;
;,; CLFPANJ@N EOLO@NENLZ [ R[ZNE[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, >8;,: [NEOLZBK ZNKMLFAF@BN[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 78: DNLKMEOTCBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 7>:,? KMOTOKZNTB[ZBK[ FG DNLKMEOTCBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 7>:,4 DNLKMEOTCBL@ [^DINKZ[ OLJ Z RXN[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 70:,; ZMN DNLKMEOTCBL@ XTFKN[[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 72> BJNLZBGBKOZBFL FG JNWNAFXENLZ XFZNLZBOA[ DO[NJ FL O
DNLKMEOTCBL@ [Z^JR GFT LN^TFWOZBFL,LNZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0?>,? BLZNTLOA OLOAR[B[ FG LN^TFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0?
BLZTFJ^KZBFL FG ZMN D^[BLN[[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 04>,?,?
[PFZ ‛ OLOAR[B[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0;>,?,4
JNGBLBZBFL FG DNLKMEOTCBL@ KTBZNTBO ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0>>,?,;
KFLKA^[BFL[ FG ZMN BLZNTLOA OLOAR[B[ FG LN^TFWOZBFL ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 0=>,?,:
>,4 DNLKMEOTCBL@ OLOAR[B[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 02 [NANKZBFL FG ZMN DNLKMEOTCBL@ [^DINKZ[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 02>,4,?
KFEXNZBZFT DNLKMEOTCBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, =?>,4,4
G^LKZBFLOA DNLKMEOTCBL@ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, =2>,4,; BJNLZBGBKOZBFL FG JNWNAFXENLZ XFZNLZBOA[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2>>,4,:
>,; JNWNAFXBL@ [FA^ZBFL KFLKNXZ[ GFT L N^TFWOZBFL ,LNZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 2= K OZN@FTB[OZBFL FG BJNO[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, 22>,;,?
JNZNKZBFL FG BJNO J^XABKOZN[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?8;>,;,4
KFAAODFTOZBFL [^XXFTZ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?87>,;,;
JB[KFWNTBL@ N]XNTZ[,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?82>,;,:
F^ZAFFC FL G^TZMNT JNWNAFXENLZ FXXFTZ^LBZBN[ GFT>,;,>
L N^TFWOZBFL ,LNZ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ??4
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 8/80
WBBB
7 KFLKA^[BFL[ OLJ F^ZAFFC ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ??07,? KFLKA^[BFL[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ??07,4
F
^ZAFFC,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ??=
AB[Z FG TNGNTNLKN[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ??2PNDABLC[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?47AB[Z FG GB@^TN[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?42AB[Z FG ZODAN[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?;?AB[Z FG ODDTNWBOZBFL[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?;4OXXNLJB] O9 XTFZFKFA FG ZMN BLBZBOA PFTC[MFX ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?;;OXXNLJB] D9 G^AA AB[Z FG TN[NOTKMNJ XAOZGFTE[ ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ?:?OXXNLJB] K9 [KTNNL[MFZ[ FG ZMN XAOZGFTE DNLKMEOTCBL@ ,,,,,,,,,, ?>;
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 9/80
? Blztfj~kzbfl
2
? Blztfj~kzbfl
Zmb{ kmoxznt xfblz{ f~z zmn blbzboa {bz~ozbfl olj zmn fdinkzbwn{ fg zmb{ zmn{b{,
[~d{nq~nlzar bz `bwn{ ol fwntwbnp odf~z zmn {zt~kz~tn fg zmn zmn{b{,
?,? Blbzboa [bz~ozbfl
Dnko~{n bllfwozbfl olj ktnozbwbzr otn cnr {~kkn{{ gokzft{ bl clfpanj`n%
do{nj nkflfebn{! kfexolbn{ e~{z ~zbabyn clfpanj`n gtfe n}zntloa -Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl" o{ pnaa o{ gtfe blzntloa {f~tkn{ -Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl", [mftznt
xtfj~kz abgn krkan{! `afdoaar jb{ztbd~znj nlzntxtb{n{ olj o kmol`nj clfpanj`n
aolj{koxn nlgftkn zmn ztnlj zf ~{n pnd xaozgfte{ bl ftjnt zf okkfexab{mnggbkbnlz bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz,
Efjntl bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{! abcn Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz ! fggnt k~{zfent{ znkmlbkoa
{fa~zbfl{ gft bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz, Bl Fxnl Bllfwozbfl zmf~{olj{ fg
bllfwozft{ zmoz otn kfllnkznj zf zmn Blzntlnz jnwnafx bjno{ bl o {mftz xntbfj
fg zben, Zmb{ eocn{ ol nggbkbnlz ft`olb{ozbfl fg clfpanj`n o eoift kmoaanl`n
fl zmn{n xaozgfte{, Zmntngftn! bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ e~{z xtfwbjn znkmlbkoa
{fa~zbfl{! pmbkm mnax zf ft`olb{n bjno{ olj gblj zmn dn{z bllfwozft{ bl ftjnt zf dn nggnkzbwn,
Zmn {byn fg zmn bllfwozbfl kfee~lbzr olj f~z{zoljbl` xaozgfte znkmlfaf`r
xaor ol bexftzolz tfan gft kfexnzbzbwn ojwolzo`n bl zmn d~{bln{{, Zmn
jneolj gft bllfwozbfl xaozgfte {ntwbkn{ b{ k~ttnlzar blktno{bl`! pmbkm anoj{
zf {ztfl`nt kfexnzbzbfl fl zmn eotcnz, Ln~tfwozbfl b{ oefl` zmn ef{z
blga~nlzboa xtfwbjnt{ fg bllfwozbfl xaozgfte {ntwbkn{ bl N~tfxn lfp d~z zmn
kfexnzbzbfl b{ `nzzbl` {ztfl`nt olj oz zmn {oen zben zmn k~{zfent{ otn
jneoljbl` eftn g~lkzbfloabzr, Zmn tb{bl` znkmlbkoa tnq~btnenlz{ olj zmn
blktno{bl` kfexnzbzbfl gft Ln~tfwozbfl otn zmn cnr efzbwozbfl{ gft zmb{
eo{znt zmn{b{,
?,4 Fdinkzbwn{
Zmn `foa fg zmb{ zmn{b{ b{ zf okkfexab{m zmn bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg k~ttnlz
jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ do{nj fl o dnlkmeotcbl` {z~jr fg zmn bllfwozbfl
xaozgfte Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz , Zmntngftn bl ol blzntloa oloar{b{ zmn {ztnl`zm{ olj
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 10/80
? Blztfj~kzbfl
?8
pnocln{{n{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl o{ pnaa o{ zmn fxxftz~lbzbn{ olj zmtnoz{ fg zmn
nlwbtflenlz otn ~lkfwntnj, [~d{nq~nlzar zmn dnlkmeotcbl` ktbzntbo otn
gfte~aoznj olj o dnlkmeotcbl` oloar{b{ pbzm zmn kfexnzbzbfl b{
okkfexab{mnj, Zmn dnlkmeotcbl` {~dinkz{ otn oloar{nj olj zmn `oxdnzpnnl Ln~tfwozbfl olj zmn kfexnzbzbfl b{ f~zablnj, Do{nj fl zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` oloar{b{ bexanenlzozbfl tnkfeenljozbfl{ gft Ln~tfwozbfl
otn f~zablnj olj zmn nkflfebkoa dnlngbz{ olj kf{z{ gft Ln~tfwozbfl otn
jnznteblnj, [~d{nq~nlzar ol f~zaffc fl g~tzmnt jnwnafxenlz fxxftz~lbzbn{ b{
`bwnl,
Zm~{! zmn gfaafpbl` q~n{zbfl{ pbaa dn ol{pntnj bl zmb{ zmn{b{9
․ Pmoz otn zmn {ztnl`zm{ olj pnocln{{n{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl olj zmn
bllfwozbfl xaozgfte Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz 6
․ Pmbkm fxxftz~lbzbn{ olj zmtnoz{ otb{n gtfe zmn nlwbtflenlz gft
Ln~tfwozbfl6
․ Pmoz otn k~ttnlz jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz 6
․ Pmf otn zmn kfexnzbzft{ olj pmoz otn zmn {ztnl`zm{ olj pnocln{{n{
fg zmne6
․ Pmoz b{ zmn `ox dnzpnnl Ln~tfwozbfl olj zmn kfexnzbzbfl6
․ Pmoz otn tnkfeenljnj okzbfl{ zf kaf{n zmn `ox6
․ Pmoz otn g~tzmnt jnwnafxenlz fxxftz~lbzbn{ gft Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz 6
Zmn `foa b{ zf blztfj~kn {fa~zbfl{ gft zmn bjnlzbgbnj jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ fl
Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz olj nwoa~ozn zmn nkflfebkoa dnlngbz{ olj kf{z{ gft
Ln~tfwozbfl, G~tzmnteftn! zmn jbggntnlkn{ fg zmn k~ttnlz {ntwbkn{ fg
Ln~tfwozbfl kfexotnj zf zmn kfexnzbzbfl {mf~aj dn f~zablnj olj xfznlzboaar
~lbq~n {naabl` xtfxf{bzbfl{ {mf~aj dn bjnlzbgbnj,
?,; [zt~kz~tn fg zmn zmn{b{
Bl ftjnt zf ol{pnt zmn notabnt jngblnj tn{notkm q~n{zbfl{ okkftjbl` zf zmn
{zoznj fdinkzbwn{! zmb{ zmn{b{ b{ {zt~kz~tnj o{ gfaafp{9
Kmoxznt 4 kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn gbt{z zmnftnzbkoa xotz! pmbkm b{ odf~z bllfwozbfl
eolo`nenlz xtfwbjbl` jngblbzbfl{ fg zmn do{bk znte{ fg ol bllfwozbfl! bz{
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 11/80
? Blztfj~kzbfl
??
kmotokzntb{zbk{! fxntozbwn olj {ztozn`bk bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz o{ pnaa o{
zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e olj ktfpj{f~tkbl`,
Bl kmoxznt ; zmn jngblbzbfl{ olj kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg clfpanj`n! zmn kfttnaozbfl{dnzpnnl clfpanj`n olj bllfwozbfl{! zmn anwna{ olj kfexflnlz{ fg
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz o{ pnaa o{ zmn kflknxz gft clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
{r{zne{ otn xfblznj f~z bl zmnftr, [~d{nq~nlzar zmn x~txf{n fg {neolzbk
znkmlfaf`bn{ gft clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz b{ f~zablnj,
Kmoxznt : kfwnt{ zmn zmnftr odf~z dnlkmeotcbl`, Bz blka~jn{ zmn jbggntnlz
zrxn{ fg dnlkmeotcbl` olj zmn `nlntbk dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{,
Kmoxznt > kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn xtokzbkoa xotz fg zmn zmn{b{, Zmn bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg
k~ttnlz jnwnafxenlz xfznlzboa{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz b{ okkfexab{mnj, Gbt{z ol
blzntloa oloar{b{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl b{ okkfexab{mnj! pmbkm kfl{b{z{ fg o [PFZ
‛ Oloar{b{ olj o gfte~aozbfl fg zmn xfznlzboa{ gft bextfwnenlz{ fl zmn
k~ttnlz xaozgfte {fa~zbfl, Bl o dnlkmeotc oloar{b{ zmn k~ttnlz jnwnafxenlz
xfznlzboa{ fg Ln~tfwozbfl otn jnznteblnj, Do{nj fl zmn tn{~az{ fg zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` bextfwnj {fa~zbfl{ gft Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz otn blztfj~knj olj
nwoa~oznj, Zmn dnlngbz{ olj kf{z{ fg zmn {fa~zbfl{ otn f~zablnj olj
bexanenlzozbfl tnkfeenljozbfl{ otn `bwnl, Oz ao{z g~tzmnt jnwnafxenlz
fxxftz~lbzbn{ otn blztfj~knj gft Ln~tfwozbfl,lnz ,
Kmoxznt 7 kflka~jn{ zmn tn{~az{ fg zmb{ eo{znt zmn{b{ olj `bwn{ ol f~zaffc fl
jnwnafxenlz{ fg bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ bl zmn g~z~tn,
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 12/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?4
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
Zmb{ kmoxznt kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn zmnftnzbkoa do{b{ odf~z bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz,
Gbt{z! zmn do{bk kflknxz{ olj kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg ol bllfwozbfl otn blztfj~knj,
G~tzmnt o{xnkz{ fg bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz fl zmn lfteozbwn! {ztozn`bk olj
fxntozbwn anwna otn oa{f f~zablnj, [~d{nq~nlzar! zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl
xotojb`e olj zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtblkbxan otn blztfj~knj,
4,? Bllfwozbfl
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn do{bk kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg bllfwozbfl{ otn jn{ktbdnj bl ftjnt
zf `bwn zmn blzntn{znj tnojnt ol fwntwbnp fg zmn n{{nlzboa kflknxz{ fg bllfwozbfl{,
Kflknxz{4,?,?
Bllfwozbfl b{ do{nj fl zmn Aozbl pftj bllfwoz~{! pmbkm {zolj{ gft tnlnpoa! ft
kmol`n, Kfl{nq~nlzar bllfwozbfl `nlntoaar jn{ktbdn{ kmol`n xtfkn{{n{ d~z
`nz{ g~tzmnt tngblnj bl nkflfebk {kbnlkn,
Zmn O~{ztbol nkflfeb{z If{nxm O, [km~exnznt gbt{z enlzbflnj bl mb{ dffc
Zmnftbn jnt pbtz{kmogzabkmnl Nlzpbkca~l` g~ljoenlzoa kfl{bjntozbfl{ odf~z
kflknxz~oa bllfwozbfl, Zmntnbl gft [km~exnznt! bllfwozbfl b{ g~ljoenlzoa gft
nkflfebk `tfpzm olj zmntngftn lnnj{ zf dn ol blzn`toa xotz fg nkflfebk
okzbwbzbn{, [km~exnznt oa{f jb{k~{{n{ zmn jbggntnlkn{ dnzpnnl bllfwozbfl{
olj blwnlzbfl{, Blwnlzbfl{ otn zmn fdwbf~{ gbt{z {znx zf o lnp xtfj~kz ft
{ntwbkn,?
G~tzmnt! ol blwnlzbfl bl zmn xoznlz {nl{n b{ xtn{nlz bg zmn gfaafpbl`tnq~btnenlz{ otn enz94
․ Zmn znkmlfaf`r `nz‒{ nltbkmnj,
․ Zmn kmol`n b{ toxbj,
․ Zmn k~ttnlz {zozn%fg%zmn%otz `nz‒{ nltbkmnj ~lxtnjbkzodar olj toxbjar,
? kg, [KM^EXNZNT! I, -?2??" xx,?8;%?02
4 kg, PFMBLY! I, P, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 13/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?;
Bllfwozbfl{ otn flar zmf{n blwnlzbfl{ zmoz anoj zf nkflfebk {~kkn{{,; O
jnzobanj jngblbzbfl fg zmn bllfwozbfl znte pbaa dn `bwnl bl zmn ln}z {nkzbfl!
pmntn zmn kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg bllfwozbfl{ pbaa dn f~zablnj bl jnzoba,
Kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg ol Bllfwozbfl4,?,4
Bl ftjnt zf jngbln ol bllfwozbfl Zmfe jnxbkz{ gf~t n{{nlzboa kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg
ol bllfwozbfl, Okkftjbl` zf Zmfe ol bllfwozbfl e~{z mown zmn gfaafpbl`
kmotokzntb{zbk{9:
․ Jn`tnn fg lfwnazr
․ ^lkntzoblzr olj Tb{c
․ Kfexan}bzr
․ Kflgabkz{
Gb`~tn ? {mfp{ zmn kfttnaozbfl{ dnzpnnl zmn gf~t kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg ol
bllfwozbfl,
Gb`~tn ?9 Kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg ol bllfwozbfl okkftjbl` zf Zmfe>
; kg, [KM^EXNZNT! I, -?2??" xx,?8;%?02: kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" xx,4;%;?
> kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,;?
Jn`tnn fg lfwnazr Kfexan}bzr
^lkntzoblzr ' Tb{c
Kflfflbkz{
#
# #
#
#
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 14/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?:
Zmn gf~t kmotokzntb{zbk{ pbaa dn xfblznj f~z bl jnzoba lfp,
Jn`tnn fg lfwnazr
Ol bllfwozbfl oapor{ mo{ zf mown o kntzobl jn`tnn fg lfwnazr, Bg zmb{ b{ lfz zmnko{n! zmn tnlnpoa b{ kmotokzntb{nj nbzmnt o{ o efjbgbkozbfl fg ol n}b{zbl`
xtfj~kz! ft o tnxabkozbfl fg o xtfj~kz,
^lkntzoblzr olj Tb{c
Ol ~lkntzobl {bz~ozbfl xtnwoba{ bg {~dinkzbwn -do{nj fl n}xntbnlkn" lft
fdinkzbwn -{zozb{zbkoa" xtfdodbabzbn{ kol dn `bwnl zmoz o xotzbk~aot nwnlz fkk~t{!
pmbkm b{ bl kflztojbkzbfl zf o {ogn {bz~ozbfl bl pmbkm oaa blgfteozbfl odf~z
g~z~tn ztnlj{ otn owobaodan,7 Bl bllfwozbfl pbzm zmn blktno{bl` jn`tnn fg
lfwnazr oa{f zmn tb{c fg goba~tn oa{f blktno{n{,
Kfexan}bzr
Bllfwozbfl{ otn kfexan} okzbfl{ zmoz otn lnwnt b{faoznj, Ned{z kmotokzntbyn{
kfexan}bzr pbzm zmn gfaafpbl` gbwn kmotokzntb{zbk{90
․ Aokc fg ztol{xotnlkr
․ E~azbz~jn
․ Jbwnt{bzr
․ Jrloebk{
․ Blzntjnxnljnlkbn{
Kflgabkz{
Pfmbly jngbln{ o kflgabkz o{ blkfexozbdan {zozn{ fg fdinkz{ ft okzbfl%
znljnlkbn{ dnzpnnl xnt{fl{, Kflgabkz{ kol dn i~{zbgbnj fdinkzbwnar ft
xnt{floaar! abcn kflgabkz{ zf jngbln olj tnokm o `foa! zf nwoa~ozn blgfteozbfl!
nlgftkn o enolbl` ft kflgabkz{ zmoz nent`n dnko~{n fg jbggntnlz ozzbz~jn{ olj
woa~n{, Bl xtokzbkn bz b{ motj zf jngbln oaa {ftz fg kflgabkz{ zmoz kol nent`n blbllfwozbfl xtfinkz{ d~z bz b{ n{{nlzboa gft zmn ktnozbwn d~{bln{{ zf dn opotn fg
kflgabkz{ olj moljan zmne, Kflgabkz{ otn lfz lnkn{{otbar ln`ozbwn3 fl zmn
kflztotr kflgabkz{ otn eoljozftr gft kmol`n, Ktnozbwn bjno{ nent`n f~z fg
kflgabkz{ olj jb{{ozb{gokzbfl pbzm o kntzobl {bz~ozbfl bl ftjnt zf jtbwn kmol`n,=
7 kg, WOM[! J,3 [KMÊGNT%C^LY! I, -488>" xx,4>%4=0 kg, NED[Z! [, -48?8" xx,40%:4
= kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 15/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?>
Ktnozbwbzr olj Bllfwozbfl4,?,;
‑Zmn jnwnafxenlz fg clfpanj`n tnq~btn{ ktnozbwbzr olj ol nlwbtflenlz! bl
pmbkm ktnozbwbzr kol gaf~tb{m, Zmn f~zkfen fg ktnozbwbzr b{ ol bjno zmoz! bg
nkflfebkoaar ~zbabynj bjnoaar dnkfen{ ol bllfwozbfl,― 2
Molr jngbln{ ktnozbwn bjno{ o{ lnp! tnanwolz olj nggnkzbwn bjno{,?8 Ktnozbwn
bjno{ fgznl nent`n toljfear -n,`, bl zmn ko{n fg otzb{z{" d~z bl zmn
ft`olb{ozbfloa kflzn}z fgznl o jb{{ozb{grbl` {bz~ozbfl olj zmn pb{m zf kmol`n
b{ zmn ztb``nt gft ktnozbwn bjno{, Ktnozbwbzr zffa{ kol dn {~xxftzbwn zf jnwnafx
bjno{ enzmfjbkoaar, Fln fg zmn ef{z pbjn{xtnoj ktnozbwbzr zffa{ po{
jnwnafxnj dr Oan} G, F{dftl olj b{ koaanj dtobl{zftebl`,?? Ktnozbwbzr zffa{
abcn dtobl{zftebl` jngbln t~an{ gft zmn kfaaodftozbwn bjno `nlntozbfl bl ftjnt
zf blktno{n zmn nggnkzbwnln{{, Ktnozbwbzr zffa{ kol {~xxftz xnt{fl{ bl zmn
ktnozbwn xtfkn{{ d~z oa{f zmn xnt{floa efzbwozbfl! zmn ktnozbwn nlwbtflenlz
olj zmn kf`lbzbwn {cbaa{ otn bexftzolz gokzft{ gft ktnozbwn bjno{,?4 Zmn zmtnn
eoift kf`lbzbwn {cbaa{ fg ktnozbwn xnt{fl{ otn9?;
․ Jbwnt`nlz zmblcbl`
․ Blznaab`nlkn
․ N}xntzb{n
Zmnr otn jn{ktbdnj bl eftn jnzoba dnafp,
Jbwnt`nlz zmblcbl`
‑Jbwnt`nlz zmblcbl` b{ zmn odbabzr zf xtfj~kn wotbf~{ olj ~l~{~oa {fa~zbfl{ gft
o `bwnl xtfdane, Bz {zolj{ bl kflzto{z zf kflwnt`nlz zmblcbl`! pmntn rf~ otn
affcbl` gft o {bl`an kfttnkz {fa~zbfl,― ?:
2 PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" x,???8 kg, MOLR! N, O, -488?" xx,47?%42??? kg, F[DFTL! O, G, -?2>;! ?27;" xx,;?>g,?4 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" x,;;?; kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" xx,;8%;;
?: PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" x,;?
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 16/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?7
Jbwnt`nlz zmblcbl` b{ ol bexftzolz eno{~tn gft ktnozbwbzr! pmbkm b{ oa{f
~zbabynj dr ktnozbwbzr zn{z{,?>
Blznaab`nlknBlznaab`nlkn b{ o eno{~tn gft zmn odbabzr fg kflwnt`nlz zmblcbl`, Zmn fxblbfl{
otn jbwnt{n bg blznaab`nlkn b{ bexftzolz gft ktnozbwbzr o{ pnaa, Bz b{ oa{f bexftzolz
zf enlzbfl zmoz gft ef{z xtfdane{! blznaab`nlkn olj ktnozbwbzr otn lnnjnj bl
ftjnt zf okmbnwn o {fa~zbfl,?7
N}xntzb{n
N}xntzb{n b{ bexftzolz zf okmbnwn f~z{zoljbl` ktnozbwn xntgfteolkn bl {xnkboa
Jfeobl{! fl zmn fzmnt molj! zmn abzntoz~tn jnxbkz{ zmoz nwntr xnt{fl b{
koxodan fg f~z{zoljbl` ktnozbwn xntgfteolkn bl `nlntoa, Fln `fajnl t~an
{or{ zmoz gft f~z{zoljbl` xntgfteolkn bl o jfeobl o eblbe~e fg znl rnot{ fg
n}xntbnlkn ft ?8,888 mf~t{ pftc bl zmn jfeobl b{ lnkn{{otr,?0
Ktnozbwn xnt{fl{ pbzm zmn odfwn%jn{ktbdnj kf`lbzbwn {cbaa{ otn lnkn{{otr zf
ktnozn ktnozbwn bjno{ olj bllfwozbfl{, Mfp bllfwozbfl{ otn ktnoznj olj
pmbkm bllfwozbfl {ztozn`bn{ o kfexolr x~t{~n{ b{ xotz fg bllfwozbfl
eolo`nenlz! pmbkm pbaa dn jn{ktbdnj bl zmn ln}z kmoxznt,
4,4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
‑Kfexolbn{ zmoz jf lfz bllfwozn jbn,― ?=
Bllfwozbfl{ otn n{{nlzboa gft `oblbl` kfexnzbzbwn ojwolzo`n{ olj zmntngftn
lnnj zf dn eolo`nj blzn`toaar bl{bjn fg ft`olb{ozbfl{, Zf eolo`n
bllfwozbfl{ {~kkn{{g~aar bz b{ n{{nlzboa zf blzn`tozn bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz oz
oaa eolo`nenlz anwna{9 zmn lfteozbwn! {ztozn`bk olj fxntozbwn anwna fg okfexolr,?2
?> kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" x,;??7 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" x,;4?0 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oz, -4880" xx,;4%;;?= KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,}wbb
?2 kg, @O[[EOLL! F,3 [^ZZNT! X, -48??" x,0
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 17/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?0
@o{{eoll jn{ktbdnj zmn anwna{ fg blzn`toa bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz o{
gfaafp{948
․ Fl zmn lfteozbwn anwna wb{bfl{! zmn eb{{bfl olj zmn kftn woa~n{ lnnjzf dn {nz,
․ Fl zmn fxntozbwn anwna zmn {zt~kz~tbl` olj zmn anojbl` fg zmn
bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ b{ n{{nlzboa,
․ Zmn {ztozn`bk eolo`nenlz fg bllfwozbfl lnnj{ zf blka~jn en{{o`n{
odf~z zmn tn{f~tkn{! znkmlfaf`bn{! clfpanj`n olj kfexnznlkn{ fg
zmn kfexolr,
Gbt{z bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz fl zmn lfteozbwn anwna pbaa dnblztfj~knj, [~d{nq~nlzar! zmn fxntozbwn bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz pbaa dn
jn{ktbdnj dr blztfj~kbl` zpf jbggntnlz efjna{ fg ol bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{,
Aoznt! {ztozn`bk bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz b{ blztfj~knj bl ftjnt zf `bwn zmn
blzntn{znj tnojnt ol fwntwbnp fl wotbf~{ bllfwozbfl {ztozn`bn{, Zmn gfk~{ bl
zmb{ kmoxznt abn{ fl zmn fxntozbwn olj {ztozn`bk bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz,
Lfteozbwn Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz4,4,?
Fl zmn lfteozbwn anwna ol bllfwozbfl k~az~tn lnnj{ zf dn n{zodab{mnj, Zmnbllfwozbfl k~az~tn b{ xtntnq~b{bzn gft ft`olb{ozbfloa bllfwozbfl,4? Zmn
gfaafpbl` gokzft{ otn zmn n{{nlzboa blga~nlkn{ gft zmn bllfwozbfl k~az~tn fg o
kfexolr 44
․ Kftxftozn k~az~tn
․ Anojnt{mbx
․ Dnmowbf~t zfpotj{ bllfwozft{
․ [zt~kz~tn olj xtfkn{{ ft`olb{ozbfl․ Xaollbl` xtfkn{{n{
․ Ozzbz~jn zfpotj{ bexanenlzozbfl enkmolb{e{
․ Ft`olb{ozbfloa gtoenpftc
48 kg, @O[[EOLL! F,3 [^ZZNT! X, -48??" xx,0%24? kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" x,;8
44 kg, [NTWOZB^[! M,%@, -?2==" x,?7>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 18/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?=
Jnxnljbl` fl zmn odfwn gokzft{ zmn bllfwozbfl k~az~tn jngbln{ zmn gtoenpftc
gft zmn odbabzr zf bllfwozn, Eolo`nt{ kol blga~nlkn zmn bllfwozbfl odbabzr
zmtf~`m xnt{floa eolo`nenlz! d~{bln{{ xtfkn{{ fxzbeb{ozbfl olj
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz,4;
Fxntozbwn Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz % Zmn Bllfwozbfl Xtfkn{{4,4,4
Zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ okkfexab{mn{ zmn eolo`nenlz fg bllfwozbfl{ fl zmn
fxntozbwn anwna, L~entf~{ o~zmft{ jn{ktbdnj zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ bl
{ab`mzar jbggntnlz por{, Zpf pbjn{xtnoj efjna{ otn Kffxnt‒{ {zo`n%`ozn
xtfkn{{ olj Zmfe‒{ ablnot xtfkn{{ zmoz pbaa dn blztfj~knj bl zmb{ kmoxznt,
4,4,4,? O [zo`n%@ozn Xtfkn{{ Okkftjbl` zf Kffxnt
Bl zmn Nl`ab{m%{xnocbl` abzntoz~tn zmn {zo`n%`ozn xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf
Kffxnt b{ zmn ef{z tnanwolz jngblbzbfl fg zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{, Gbt{z zmn
jngblbzbfl fg o {zo`n%`ozn%xtfkn{{ {mf~aj dn kanotnj9
‑O {zo`n%`ozn xtfkn{{ b{ jbwbjnj blzf o l~ednt fg {zo`n{ ft pftc{zozbfl{,
Dnzpnnl nokm pftc {zozbfl zmntn b{ o q~oabzr kflztfa kmnkcxfblz ft o `ozn,― 4:
Gb`~tn 49 [zo`n%@ozn Xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf Kffxnt 4>
Gb`~tn 4 {mfp{ zmn gbwn {zo`n{ olj `ozn{ fg Kffxnt‒{ efjna, Zmn fdwbf~{gbt{z {znx fg ol bllfwozbfl b{ oapor{ ol bjno! pmbkm b{ {~debzznj zf zmn Blbzboa
[ktnnl! pmntn zmn bllfwozbfl xtfinkz b{ dftl, Zmn Xtnabeblotr O{{n{{enlz!
pmbkm b{ jfln bl [zo`n ? blka~jn{ zmn jnznteblozbfl fg zmn znkmlbkoa olj
eotcnz entbz{! pmbkm b{ gfaafpnj dr o [nkflj [ktnnl, Bl [zo`n 4! zmn xtfinkz
4; kg, PBACN! M, -?22=" x,7:4: KFFXNT! T,@, -?228" x,:7
4> kg, KFFXNT! T,@, -?228" x,:7
@ozn?
@ozn4
@ozn;
@ozn:
@ozn>
[zo`n?
[zo`n4
[zo`n;
[zo`n:
[zo`n> *
Blbzboa [ktnnl [nkflj [ktnnl Jnkb{bfl flD~{bln{{ Ko{n
Xf{z JnwnafxenlzTnwbnp
Xtn%Kfeentyboab{ozbflD~{bln{{ Oloar{b{
Xf{z%BexanenlzozbflTnwbnp
Bjno
XtnabeblotrO{{n{{enlz
JnzobanjBlwn{zb`ozbfl
JnwnafxenlzZn{zbl` 'Woabjozbfl
G~aa Xtfj~kzbfl 'Eotcnz Ao~lkm
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 19/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
?2
`nz{ kanotar jngblnj olj wntbgbnj ~lzba zmn gbloa jnkb{bfl gft zmn jnwnafxenlz b{
eojn, Bl [zo`n ;! zmn jnwnafxenlz fg zmn xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn zocn{ xaokn olj
{~d{nq~nlzar o kmnkc fl zmn fl%`fbl` ozztokzbwnln{{ fg zmn xtfj~kz ft
{ntwbkn olj zmn xtfinkz b{ jfln, Bl [zo`n :! zmn pmfan xtfinkz `nz{ zn{znj oljwoabjoznj! pmbkm blka~jn{ zmn xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn! zmn xtfj~kzbfl xtfkn{{! zmn
k~{zfent okknxzolkn o{ pnaa o{ zmn nkflfebk{ fg zmn xtfinkz, Ogznt
jnwnafxbl` o eotcnz xaol zmn okz~oa eotcnz ao~lkm gblb{mn{ zmn xtfkn{{,47
@o{{eoll {xabz{ zmn xtfkn{{ blzf o ktnozbwn xmo{n -‑kaf~j%xmo{n―" olj o
xtfj~kzbwn xmo{n -‑d~bajbl`%dafkc%xmo{n―", Bl zmn kaf~j%xmo{n -zmn gbt{z moag fg
Kffxnt‒{ xtfkn{{" bjno{ olj clfpanj`n! ktnozbwbzr olj xnfxan eolo`nenlz
otn jfeblozbl` bl ftjnt zf ktnozn o k~az~tn bl pmbkm lnp bjno{ kol dn ktnoznj
olj jnwnafxnj, [zotzbl` gtfe zmn jnwnafxenlz {zo`n fg Kffxnt‒{ efjna
nl`blnntbl`! {zt~kz~tbl` olj xtfkn{{ eolo`nenlz otn zmn jfeblozbl`
o{xnkz{ -‑d~bajbl`%dafkc%xmo{n―" bl ftjnt zf ktnozn xtfj~kz{ f~z fg zmn
bjno{,40
4,4,4,4 O Ablnot Xtfkn{{ Okkftjbl` zf Zmfe
Bl zmn @nteol%{xnocbl` abzntoz~tn zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ fg Zmfe b{ zmn
ef{z bexftzolz zf enlzbfl, Zmfe jbggntnlzbozn{ dnzpnnl zmn gfaafpbl` zmtnnxmo{n{94=
․ Bjno @nlntozbfl
․ Bjno Okknxzolkn
․ Bjno Tnoab{ozbfl
Gb`~tn ; baa~{ztozn{ zmn zmtnn xmo{n{ fg zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf
Zmfe,
Ol blbzboa okzbfl! ko~{nj nbzmnt dr o {zocnmfajnt! zmn fpl tn{notkm
jnxotzenlz! zmn eotcnz ft fzmnt xotzbn{! ztb``nt{ zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{,42
Zmn bjno `nlntozbfl! okknxzolkn olj tnoab{ozbfl xmo{n{ otn gfaafpbl`,;8
47 kg, KFFXNT! T,@, -?228" xx,>4%>;40 kg, @O[[EOLL! F,3 [^ZZNT! X, -48??" x,:>4= kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;
42 kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,4>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 20/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
48
Zmn kftxftozn {ztozn`r d~baj{ zmn {ztozn`bk gtoenpftc otf~lj zmn bllfwozbfl
xtfkn{{, Zmn f~zkfen fg zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ b{ nbzmnt o lnp xtfj~kz ft
{ntwbkn! pmbkm mo{ kntzobl nggnkz{ fl zmn {fkboa! xfabzbkoa! nkfaf`bkoa!nkflfebkoa olj znkmlfaf`bkoa o{xnkz{ fg zmn nlwbtflenlz! jnxnljbl` fl zmn
{~d{zolkn fg zmn bllfwozbfl, Wbkn wnt{o zmn nlwbtflenlz mo{ o eoift
blga~nlkn fg zmn kftxftozn {ztozn`r fg zmn kfexolr,;?
Gb`~tn ;9 Zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf Zmfe;4
Zmn zmtnn xmo{n{ fg zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf Zmfe otn jn{ktbdnj
bl jnzoba dnafp9
Bjno @nlntozbfl
Ogznt zmn {ztozn`bk gtoenpftc b{ {nz -{nn kmoxznt 4,4,;" lnp bjno{ otn
`nlntoznj fgznl pbzm zmn mnax fg ktnozbwbzr zffa{ -{nn kmoxznt 4,?,;" olj gbloaar
o {nankzbfl fg bjno xtfxf{oa{ b{ okkfexab{mnj,;; Zmntndr zmn l~ednt fg bjno{
kol dn {nnl o{ zmn q~olzbzozbwn nggbkbnlkr ktbzntbfl pmban zmn oef~lz fg ~{odan bjno{ b{ jngblnj o{ zmn q~oabzozbwn nggbkbnlkr ktbzntbfl,;:
;8 kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;;? kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,4>;4 kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;;; kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;
;: ZMFE! L, -?2=8" xx,00%0=
Bjno @nlntozbfl Bjno Okknxzolkn Bjno Tnoab{ozbfl
) [ztozn`r jnwnafxenlz
) Jnlbzbfl fg o {~dinkz otno
) Bjno `nlntozbfl
) Bjno {nankzbfl
) Bjno nwoa~ozbfl
) Gno{bdbabzr oloar{b{
) Kflknxz {nankzbfl
) Jnkb{bfl gft o xaol zf dn
tnoab{nj
) Jnzobanj kflknxz
jnwnafxenlz
) Xtfj~kz jnwnafxenlz
) Eotcnzbl` olj {oan{
) [oan{ kflztfa
Ztb``nt
KFTXFTOZN [ZTOZN@R
) K~{zfent{) Kfexnzbzft{) [~xxabnt{) Tn{notkm) Gobt{ ,,,
NLWBTFLENLZ
[fkbnzr Xfabzbk{ Nkfaf`r Nkflfer Znkmlfaf`r
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 21/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
4?
Bjno Okknxzolkn
Bl zmn bjno okknxzolkn xmo{n zmn bjno{ `nz nwoa~oznj! gno{bdbabzr {z~jbn{ otn
okkfexab{mnj olj aoznt zmn {nankznj bjno{ otn tngblnj olj pftcnj f~z zf
bexanenlzozbfl kflknxz{, Zmn xmo{n nlj{ pbzm o jnkb{bfl gft o xotzbk~aot kflknxz zmoz {mf~aj dn tnoabynj bl zmn ln}z {znx,;>
Bjno Tnoab{ozbfl
Zmb{ xmo{n blka~jn{ zmn znkmlbkoa bexanenlzozbfl olj zmn blztfj~kzbfl fg zmn
lnp {ntwbkn ft xtfj~kz fl zmn eotcnz! nljbl` zmn xmo{n pbzm ol okknxzolkn
bl{xnkzbfl olj kflzbl~n{ {oan{ kflztfa, ;7
[ztozn`bk Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz4,4,;
Nwntr ktnozbwn kfexolr lnnj{ zf jngbln bz{ bllfwozbfl {ztozn`r dngftn
bllfwozbfl okzbwbzbn{ fl zmn fxntozbwn anwna kol zocn xaokn, O {ztozn`r jngbln{
o `foa olj zmn jbtnkzbfl gft zmn bllfwozbfl okzbwbzbn{ pmban zmn bllfwozbfl
xtfkn{{ jngbln{ o {nq~nlkn fg okzbfl{ mfp zf tnokm zmn{n `foa{ -{nn
kmoxznt 4,4,4", ;0
Dngftn jnwnafxbl` ol bllfwozbfl {ztozn`r bz‒{ bexftzolz zf clfp zmn okz~oa
{bz~ozbfl fg zmn kfexolr olj bz{ nlwbtflenlz, Zmntngftn zmn [PFZ ‛ Oloar{b{ b{ o xfx~aot eolo`nenlz zffa! pmbkm {mf~aj lfp dn blztfj~knj,
Gb`~tn : {mfp{ zmn zpf xotz{ fg zmn [PFZ ‛ Oloar{b{9;= Zmn blzntloa
oloar{b{! gb`~tbl` f~z zmn {ztnl`zm{ olj pnocln{{n{ fg zmn kfexolr olj ol
n}zntloa oloar{b{! oloar{bl` zmn kmolkn{ olj tb{c{ fg zmn nlwbtflenlz,
Zmntngftn [PFZ {zolj{ gft [ztnl`zm{! Pnocln{{n{! Fxxftz~lbzbn{ olj
Zmtnoz{,
;> kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;;7 kg, ZMFE! L, -?2=8" x,>;;0 kg, @O[[EOLL! F,3 [^ZZNT! X, -48??" xx,=%2
;= kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,40
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 22/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
44
Gb`~tn :9 [PFZ ‛ Oloar{b{
Bl {ztozn`bk eolo`nenlz zmn [PFZ ‛ Oloar{b{ b{ o kfeefl eolo`nenlz
zffa, Bl zmn gfaafpbl` {nkzbfl bllfwozbfl {ztozn`bn{ zmoz jngbln zot`nz eotcnz{!
o eotcnz ftbnlzozbfl olj zmn ftb`bl fg bjno{ pbaa dn blztfj~knj,
4,4,;,? Eotcnz [ztozn`bn{
Ol bexftzolz {ztozn`bk jnkb{bfl bl bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz b{ odf~z kmff{bl`
zmn eotcnz {ztozn`r gft o lnp xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn, Xftznt jngbln{ zmtnn
{~kkn{{g~a {ztozn`bn{ gft kfexnzbzbwn eotcnz{9;2
․ Fwntoaa%Jbggntnlzbozbfl! pmbkm enol{ zf fggnt ol n}knaanlz dnlngbz gft
zmoz k~{zfent{ otn nwnl pbaabl` zf xor eftn,
․ Fwntoaa%Kf{z%Anojnt{mbx! pmbkm enol{ zf mown o kf{z ojwolzo`n
kfexotnj zf zmn kfexnzbzft{ olj zmntngftn dn odan zf fggnt zmn afpn{z
xtbkn fl zmn eotcnz,
․ Gfk~{ fl o eotcnz {n`enlz bl{znoj fg zmn pmfan eotcnz,
Bg o kfexolr goba{ zf jnwnafx bz{ {ztozn`r bl fln fg zmn enlzbflnj jbtnkzbfl{!
Xftznt jngbln{ zmb{ ~l{~kkn{{g~a xf{bzbfl o{ {z~kc bl zmn ebjjan,:8
;2 kg, XFTZNT! E, N, -?2=8" xx,;>%:?
:8 kg, XFTZNT! E, N, -?2=8" xx,:?%::
[PFZ % Oloar{b{
Fxxftz~lbzbn{ & Zmtnoz{-N}zntloa"
D~{bln{{ Oloar{b{
[ztnl`mz{ & Pnocln{{n{-Blzntloa"
Nlwbtflenlz Oloar{b{
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 23/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
4;
Cbe olj Eo~dft`ln jnxbkz zmoz mb`mar kfexnzbzbwn eotcnz{ {mf~aj dn
owfbjnj olj bl{znoj lnp eotcnz{ {mf~aj dn jb{kfwntnj,:?
Dnko~{n fg zmn `afdoab{ozbfl olj zmn okknantoznj znkmlfaf`r ojwolkn{ zmneotcnz{ otn `nlntoaar mb`mar kfexnzbzbwn, Cbe olj Eo~dft`ln koaa zmn{n
eotcnz{ zmn tnj fknol{! bl pmbkm xtbkn pot{ otn `fbl` fl olj xtfgbz eot`bl{
otn {mtblcbl`,:4
Zmnr jnxbkz zmn da~n fknol o{ o {ztozn`r zf n{koxn gtfe zmn{n ~lozztokzbwn
eotcnz{ dr jnwnafxbl` lnp eotcnz{ -da~n fknol{"! bl pmbkm zmn aop{ fg zmn
tnj fknol{ jf lfz oxxar olj zmntngftn e~km mb`mnt xtfgbz eot`bl{ kol dn
okmbnwnj,:; Zodan ? {mfp{ zmn eobl jbggntnlkn{ dnzpnnl zmn tnj olj zmn
da~n fknol{ okkftjbl` zf Cbe olj Eo~dft`ln,
[ztozn`bn{ gft zmn Tnj
Fknol
[ztozn`bn{ gft zmn Da~n
Fknol
Eotcnz K~ttnlz eotcnz pbzm mb`m
kfexnzbzbfl
Jnwnafxbl` lnp eotcnz{
Kfexnzbzbfl Dnoz zmn kfexnzbzft{ Owfbj zmn kfexnzbzbfl
Jneolj ^{n zmn n}b{zbl` jneolj Fxnl ~x lnp jneolj
Kf{z{ ‛ Dnlngbz
Kfttnaozbfl
Jbtnkz kfttnaozbfl Oll~aozbfl fg zmn
kfttnaozbfl
Oab`lenlz fg
d~{bln{{ okzbwbzbn{
Zf kf{z{ olj dnlngbz Zf jbggntnlzbozbfl olj afp
kf{z{
Zodan ?9 [ztozn`bn{ gft tnj olj da~n fknol{::
Da~n fknol{ jn{ktbdn ozztokzbwn eotcnz{ pbzm afp kfexnzbzbfl olj mb`m xtfgbz
eot`bl{, Olfzmnt bexftzolz {ztozn`bk jnkb{bfl b{ zmn eotcnz ftbnlzozbfl! pmbkmpbaa dn blztfj~knj ln}z,
:? kg, CBE P,K,! EO^DFT@LN T, -488>" x,?=:4 kg, CBE P,K,! EO^DFT@LN T, -488>" x,=:; kg, CBE P,K,! EO^DFT@LN T, -488>" x,?=
:: kg, CBE P,K,! EO^DFT@LN T, -488>" x,?=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 24/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
4:
4,4,;,4 Eotcnz Ftbnlzozbfl
Bllfwozbfl{ kol dn ztb``ntnj dr lnp znkmlfaf`bn{ ft jnznteblnj jneolj{ fl
zmn eotcnz, Zm~{ zpf eotcnz ftbnlzozbfl{ kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj9:>
․ Znkmlfaf`r x~{m9 Lnp jb{kfwntbn{ ft blwnlzbfl{ gtfe zmn tn{notkm
olj jnwnafxenlz ft`olb{ozbfl ztb``nt zmn bllfwozbfl, Xtfj~kz ft
{ntwbkn jnwnafxenlz {zotz{ {~d{nq~nlzar, Zmn eobl kmoaanl`n b{ zf
gblj o eotcnz ft o eotcnz {n`enlz pmntn zmn lnp xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn
kol dn {~kkn{{g~aar jb{ztbd~znj,
․ Eotcnz x~aa9 Zmn lnnj gft o lnp xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn b{ bjnlzbgbnj dr zmn
eotcnz tn{notkm ft`olb{ozbfl gbt{z, Zmb{ ztb``nt{ zmn bllfwozbflxtfkn{{, Zmn eobl kmoaanl`n b{ zf tn{notkm olj jnwnafx o xtfxnt
znkmlfaf`r zmoz gbz{ zmn tnq~btnenlz{ fg zmn eotcnz, Zmn jb{ztbd~zbfl b{
e~km {bexant kfexotnj zf zmn ‑Znkmlfaf`r x~{m― {ztozn`r! pmban zmn
xtfj~kz ft {ntwbkn b{ oatnojr jneoljnj,
Pmbkm {ztozn`r b{ eftn {~kkn{{g~a b{ mb`mar jnxnljnlz fl zmn okz~oa
d~{bln{{ olj zmn eotcnz, Znkmlfaf`r jtbwnl kfexolbn{ pbzm db` tn{notkm
olj jnwnafxenlz jnxotzenlz{ fgznl ztr zf `nz o znkmlfaf`bkoa anoj drx~{mbl` lnp znkmlfaf`bn{ fl zmn eotcnz, Pmban zmb{ b{ o tb{cr olj n}xnl{bwn
{ztozn`r zfjor d~{bln{{n{ gfk~{ eftn fl bjnlzbgrbl` jneolj{ fl zmn
eotcnz{ dngftn {zotzbl` pbzm lnp znkmlfaf`r jnwnafxenlz{, Zmb{ {ztozn`r
{own{ kf{z{ olj tnj~kn{ zmn tb{c fg gobabl` bllfwozbfl{, Zfjor bz b{ oa{f ol
n{{nlzboa xotz zf bjnlzbgr zmn k~{zfent dnlngbz{ dngftn bllfwozbl`,
4,4,;,; Bllfwozbfl Ftbnlzozbfl
Ol bllfwozbfl {ztozn`r e~{z oa{f kfwnt zmn ftbnlzozbfl! pmbkm {f~tkn{ gft Bjno{! olj clfpanj`n {mf~aj dn anwnto`nj zf jnwnafx lnp bllfwozbfl{,
Zmntn otn do{bkoaar zpf ftbnlzozbfl{ zmoz kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj9:7
․ Blzntloa Ftbnlzozbfl
․ N}zntloa Ftbnlzozbfl
:> kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,47
:7 kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,?=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 25/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
4>
Zmn jbggntnlkn{ fg zmn{n zpf bllfwozbfl ftbnlzozbfl{ pbaa dn jn{ktbdnj dnafp,
Blzntloa Ftbnlzozbfl
Ol blzntloa ftbnlzozbfl kfl{kbf~{ar xtnwnlz{ zmn blzn`tozbfl fg n}zntloa{f~tkn{ blzf zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{,:0
Zmn {f~tkn gft lnp bjno{ b{ zmn blzntloa clfpanj`n do{n fg o kfexolr,
[fen bjno{ `nz jnwnafxnj zf lnp xtfj~kz{ olj gafp f~z zf zmn eotcnz, :=
Kmn{dtf~`m koaa{ zmn blzntloa ftbnlzozbfl zmn Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e,:2
N}zntloa Ftbnlzozbfl
Ol n}zntloa ftbnlzozbfl anwnto`n{ kfl{kbf~{ar zmn blzn`tozbfl fg n}zntloa
clfpanj`n {f~tkn{ gft bllfwozbfl,>8
“Woa~nodan bjno{ kol kfen gtfe bl{bjn ft f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr olj kol `f
zf eotcnz gtfe bl{bjn ft f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr o{ pnaa,‑ >?
Kmn{dtf~`m koaa{ zmn n}zntloa ftbnlzozbfl zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e -{nn
kmoxznt 4,;",>4
Ztojbzbfloaar bllfwozbfl{ pntn jnwnafxnj dnmblj kaf{nj jfft{ zf {own zmn
blzntloa blznaankz~oa xtfxntzr, Mfpnwnt! zfjor kfexolbn{ tnkf`lbyn eftn olj
eftn zmn dnlngbz{ fg ol Fxnl Bllfwozbfl ozzbz~jn,
:0 kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,?=:= kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,;8%;?:2 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,4?%:?>8 kg, PFMBLY! I, -48??" kmoxznt ? x,?=>? KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,:;
>4 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,:;%74
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 26/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
47
4,; Fxnl Bllfwozbfl
‑Fxnl bllfwozbfl b{ o xotojb`e zmoz o{{~en{ zmoz gbte{ kol olj {mf~aj ~{nn}zntloa bjno{ o{ pnaa o{ blzntloa bjno{! olj blzntloa olj n}zntloa xozm{ zf
eotcnz! o{ zmn gbte{ affc zf ojwolkn zmnbt znkmlfaf`r― >; Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn zmnftnzbkoa kflknxz{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl olj zmn ztnlj{
zmoz anz kfexolbn{ fxnl ~x zmnbt bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{n{ pbaa dn goknj, Zmn
Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e okkftjbl` zf Kmn{dtf~`m pbaa dn blztfj~knj! olj
zmn dnlngbz{ olj tb{c{ fg zmn oxxtfokm pbaa dn {mfpl, Gbloaar! zmn tnaoznj
kflknxz ktfpj{f~tkbl` pbaa dn n}xaoblnj olj jngblnj,
Fxnl Bllfwozbfl Ztnlj{4,;,?
Fxnl bllfwozbfl mo{ dnkfen ol bexftzolz gokzft gft kfexolbn{, Bl {fen
d~{bln{{n{ bz b{ nwnl n{{nlzboa zf fxnl ~x zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ bl ftjnt zf
{zor fl zmn eotcnzxaokn, Kmn{dtf~`m jn{ktbdn{ gf~t `afdoa ztnlj{ zmoz gftkn
kfexolbn{ zf zmblc eftn fxnl olj blzn`tozn n}zntloa clfpanj`n bl zmn
bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{9>:
․ Blktno{bl` Efdbabzr
․ @tfpbl` Wnlz~tn Koxbzoa Eotcnz
․ Tb{bl` Nlztnxtnln~t{mbx
․ Gfk~{bl` fl Kftn Kfexnznlkn{
Zmn ztnlj{ pbaa dn f~zablnj bl jnzoba dnafp9
Blktno{bl` EfdbabzrZmn blktno{nj efdbabzr olj owobaodbabzr fg bljbwbj~oa{ b{ o kmolkn gft nwntr
kfexolr zf `nz mb`mar {cbaanj pftcnt{ gtfe o `afdoabynj aodf~t eotcnz,>>
Fl zmn fzmnt molj bz b{ eftn fgznl zmn ko{n zmoz mb`mar {cbaanj pftcnt{ {pbzkm
zmnbt nexafrnt{ olj zmntngftn zocn zmnbt clfpanj`n pbzm zmne zf jbggntnlz
>; KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,}}bw>: kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,;:%:?
>> kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,;:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 27/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
40
kfexolbn{, Kfl{nq~nlzar zmn blzntloa clfpanj`n do{n fg o kfexolr b{ eftn
wfaozban,>7
@tfpbl` Wnlz~tn Koxbzoa EotcnzZmn wnlz~tn koxbzoa eotcnz! blwn{zenlz gbte{ olj g~ljbl` ft`olb{ozbfl{ mo{
nlftef~{ar n}xoljnj j~tbl` zmn ao{z rnot{, >0 Kfexanznar lnp fxxftz~lbzbn{
gft okq~btbl` g~ljbl` gft {zotz%~x{ nent`nj bl zmn ao{z rnot{ -n,`, wbo
ktfpjg~ljbl`>=", Eftn g~ljbl` fxxftz~lbzbn{ oa{f enol{ eftn kmolkn{ gft
~l~{nj bjno{ zf dn tnoabynj f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr,>2 Zmntngftn zmn Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e jngbln{ por{ zf zocn xtfgbz fg ~l~{nj bjno{ pbzm mb`m
xfznlzboa -{nn kmoxznt 4,;,4",
Tb{bl` Nlztnxtnln~t{mbx
Dnko~{n fg zmn blktno{nj efdbabzr olj zmn tb{bl` fxxftz~lbzbn{ gft g~ljbl`
eftn bljbwbj~oa{ `nz nlkf~to`nj zf bljnxnljnlkn olj gf~lj zmnbt fpl
kfexolr, Gft n{zodab{mnj kfexolbn{ zmb{ enol{ zmoz o{ zmn n}zntloa fxzbfl{
gft nexafrnn{ pbzm `ffj bjno{ `tfp olj xtfj~kz abgn krkan{ {mftznl bz
dnkfen{ ol bexftzolz gokzft zf blktno{n zmn tozn oz pmbkm clfpanj`n `nz{
xtfkn{{nj,78
Gfk~{bl` fl Kftn Kfexnznlkn{
Gfk~{bl` fl zmn kftn kfexnznlkn{ b{ o wbzoa olj kfeefl {ztozn`r gft
kfexolbn{, D~z gft zmoz bz‒{ n{{nlzboa zf fxnl ~x zmn blzntloa clfpanj`n {baf{
pmnl pftcbl` bl {fen cblj fg xotzlnt{mbx{! pmbkm enol{ o tb{c gft zmn
blzntloa clfpanj`n,7? Pbzm Fxnl Bllfwozbfl zmb{ lnkn{{otr clfpanj`n jtobl
kol dn kfexnl{oznj pbzm lnp n}zntloa clfpanj`n,
Kflka~jbl` Kmn{dtf~`m‒{ jnxbkzbfl{ zmn clfpanj`n aolj{koxn mo{ kmol`nj
bl o por zmoz clfpanj`n eflfxfabn{ otn gojbl` opor olj zmn jb{ztbd~zbfl fg clfpanj`n mo{ dnkfen pbjnt, Zm~{ clfpanj`n mo{ dnkfen owobaodan gft
>7 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,;>>0 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,;=>= kg, COAZNLDNKC! I, -48??" xx,>%??>2 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,;=78 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,;=
7? kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,:8
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 28/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
4=
xnfxan pbaabl` zf z~tl zmb{ clfpanj`n blzf bllfwozbfl{, Bljbwbj~oab{e mo{
dnkfen ol bexftzolz gokzft bl f~t {fkbnzr olj o lnp `nlntozbfl fg mb`mar
{cbaanj nlztnxtnln~t{ pbzm zmn lnkn{{otr clfpanj`n mo{ nlzntnj zmn
eotcnz{, Gft rf~l` ft n{zodab{mnj kfexolbn{ zmn {oen t~an mfaj{9 Bl ftjnt zf dn bllfwozbwn! clfpanj`n mo{ zf dn z~tlnj blzf bllfwozbfl{ dngftn fzmnt{
jf {f,74
Zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl Xotojb`e4,;,4
Fxnl bllfwozbfl anwnto`n{ zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtblkbxan! pmbkm pbaa dn g~tzmnt
blztfj~knj bl kmoxznt 4,:! gft bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz, Fxnl bllfwozbfl
enol{ zmoz woa~odan bjno{ kol kfen gtfe bl{bjn ft f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr olj
kol `f zf eotcnz gtfe bl{bjn ft f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr o{ pnaa,7;
Gb`~tn > baa~{ztozn{ zmn gafp olj jnwnafxenlz fg bjno{ bl zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl
xotojb`e9
Bjno{ kol ftb`blozn gtfe blzntloa olj n}zntloa clfpanj`n {f~tkn{, J~tbl` zmn
xtfkn{{ zmn bjno{ `nz gbazntnj olj o{{n{{nj, J~tbl` zmn xtfkn{{ zmn bjno{ `nz
gbazntnj olj o{{n{{nj, Afz{ fg zmn bjno{ eor dn lfz `ffj nlf~`m ft lfz
tnoab{odan olj zmntngftn `nz jb{kotjnj o`obl, Zmn tneoblbl` bjno{ otnjnwnafxnj zf kflknxz{! olj gbloaar o gnp kflknxz{ otn tnoabynj zf lnp
xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{, Zmb{ pftc{ {bebaot zf zmn ztojbzbfloa Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl
xotojb`e, Zmn bexftzolz jbggntnlkn b{ zmoz n}zntloa bjno{ otn `bwnl zmn {oen
ozznlzbfl o{ bjno{! gtfe zmn blzntloa clfpanj`n do{n olj zmoz lf {ztbkz dftjnt
dnzpnnl blzntloa olj n}zntloa clfpanj`n n}b{z{,7:
Zm~{ bjno{ kol gafp blzf zmn xtfkn{{ ft anown bz zf zmn eotcnz oz jbggntnlz
{zozn{ olj jbggntnlz zben{,
7>
Zmb{ tob{n{ zmn abcnabmffj zmoz bjno{ `nzjnwnafxnj zf xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{ -nbzmnt bl{bjn zmn kfexolr ft f~z{bjn" olj
zmoz zmn{n xtfj~kz{ olj {ntwbkn{ otn tnojr gft zmn eotcnzxaokn,
74 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,:8%:?7; kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" x,:;7: kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,:;%::
7> kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -488;" xx,7;%7:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 29/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
42
Gb`~tn >9 Zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl Xotojb`e77
Kmn{dtf~`m jn{ktbdn{ zmtnn por{ fl mfp bjno{! kflknxz{ ft xtfj~kz{ kol
anown zmn xtfkn{{ zf zmn eotcnz970
․ Abknlkbl`9 Bjno{ ft kflknxz{ zmoz kol‒z dn jnwnafxnj zf xtfj~kz{ ft
{ntwbkn{ kol dn abknl{nj zf fzmnt kfexolbn{,
․ [xbl%fgg{9 Xtfeb{bl` kflknxz{! xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{ zmoz eb`mz lfz dn
{~kkn{{g~a fl zmn k~ttnlz eotcnz kol dn xtfj~kn o{ {xbl%fgg{ tnwnl~n
fl lnp eotcnz{,
․ K~ttnlz Eotcnz{9 Xtfj~kz{ ft [ntwbkn{ kol dn jnwnafxnj olj
blztfj~knj zf zmn k~ttnlz eotcnz{ fg zmn kfexolr abcn bl zmn ztojbzbfloa
Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl xotojb`e,
G~tzmnt mn jn{ktbdn{ zmoz lnp tn{f~tkn{ kol nlznt zmn xtfkn{{! abcn97=
․ N}zntloa bjno{9 Pbzm zmn mnax fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ ft
n}zntloa tn{notkm xotzlnt‒{ lnp n}zntloa bjno{ kol nlznt zmn xtfkn{{,
77 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -48??" x,0870 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -48??" x,08
7= kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -48??" x,08
Blzntloa Bjno{ K~ttnlzEotcnz
N}zntloaBjno{
Lnp Eotcnz
Fzmnt Gbte'{Eotcnz{
Abknl{bl`
N}zntloa Znkmlfaf r̀ N}zntloa Koxbzoa N}zntloa Xtfj~kz{
Kfexolr dftjnt
[ x b l %
f g g {
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 30/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;8
․ N}zntloa znkmlfaf`r9 Dr abknl{bl` n}zntloa znkmlfaf`r kol dn ~{nj
zf jnwnafx lnp xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{,
․ N}zntloa koxbzoa9 Zmtf~`m zmn wotbf~{ xf{{bdbabzbn{ fg g~ljbl` lnp
koxbzoa kol dn okq~btnj, Pbzm zmn n}zntloa koxbzoa {xbl%fgg{ ft zmnjnwnafxenlz fg zmn xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{ kol dn gblolknj,
․ N}zntloa xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{9 Xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{ kol dn okq~btnj
gtfe fzmnt kfexolbn{, Bg o kfexolr flar jb{ztbd~zn{ fln xtfj~kz bz kol
dn ~{ng~a zf okq~btn zmn pmfan kfexolr,
Dnko~{n blzntloa bjno{ kol anown zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{ olj n}zntloa bjno{
olj tn{f~tkn{ kol nlznt zmn xtfkn{{ oz jbggntnlz {zo`n{ zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl
oxxtfokm anown{ eftn fxzbfl{ gft bjno{ kfexotnj zf zmn Kaf{nj Bllfwozbflxotojb`e -{nn kmoxznt 4,4,4", Zmb{ mo{ kntzobl ojwolzo`n{! d~z oa{f xf{n{
lnp tb{c{ gft kfexolbn{,
Dnlngbz{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl4,;,;
Zmn abzntoz~tn jnxbkz{ eoift dnlngbz{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl kfexotnj zf Kaf{nj
Bllfwozbfl oxxtfokmn{, Tnbkmpoaj olj Xbaant jn{ktbdn zmn gfaafpbl` dnlngbz{
fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl gft kfexolbn{972
․ Tnj~kbl` ‑zben%zf%eotcnz―
․ Tnj~kbl` ‑kf{z%zf%eotcnz―
․ Blktno{bl` ‑gbz%zf%eotcnz―
․ Blktno{bl` ‑lnp%zf%eotcnz―
@o{{eoll kfexanenlz{ zmn gfaafpbl` dnlngbz{908
․ Ojwntzb{nenlz․ Blktno{bl` k~{zfent afroazr
․ Fwntkfebl` fxntozbfl dabljln{{
Zmn dnlngbz{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl okkftjbl` zf Tnbkmpoaj! Xbaant olj
@o{{eoll otn xfblznj f~z bl eftn jnzoba dnafp,
72 kg, TNBKMPOAJ! T,3 XBAANT! G, -4882" xx,?:2%?>:
08 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,4>%47
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 31/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;?
Tnj~kbl` ‑zben%zf%eotcnz―
Zmn zben%zf%eotcnz b{ zmn zben {xol {zotzbl` gtfe jnwnafxenlz! zbaa zmn nlztr
fl zmn eotcnz fg o xtfj~kz, Zmb{ zben `obl{ fl bexftzolkn dr kfl{zolzar{mftznt xtfj~kz abgn krkan{, Bl Fxnl Bllfwozbfl {mftznt zben{%zf%eotcnz kol
dn okmbnwnj dnko~{n zmn pftc b{ jbwbjnj olj zmn zo{c{ otn {xabz ~x zf
n}zntloa xotzlnt{! pmbkm tn{~az{ bl o mb`mnt xtfdane {fawbl` koxodbabzr!
n{xnkboaar zmn bjno `nlntozbfl! olj kflknxz jnwnafxenlz kol dn
okkfexab{mnj go{znt! eftn nggnkzbwnar olj kfl{nq~nlzar kmnoxnt pbzm Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl zmnl pbzm Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl,0?
Tnj~kbl` ‑kf{z%zf%eotcnz―
Pbzm Fxnl Bllfwozbfl zmn kf{z{ gft xaollbl` olj jnwnafxenlz kol dn
tnj~knj n{xnkboaar bg zmn n}zntloa bllfwozft{ otn oa{f blwfawnj blzf {znx{ ogznt
zmn bjno `nlntozbfl -n,`, xtfzfzrxn jnwnafxenlz",04
Blktno{bl` ‑gbz%zf%eotcnz―
‑Gbz%zf%eotcnz― n}xtn{{n{ zmn okknxzolkn fg o xtfj~kz fl zmn eotcnz, Pbzm
Fxnl Bllfwozbfl eftn blgfteozbfl odf~z zmn lnnj{ fg zmn kfl{~ent{ b{
owobaodan! oa{f o mb`mnt xtfdane {fawbl` koxodbabzr dr zmn ktfpj kol dn
okmbnwnj,0; Jn{btn{ kol dn bjnlzbgbnj olj lnp bex~a{n{ kol mnax zf blktno{n
zmn ‑gbz%zf%eotcnz―,0:
Dfzm xotoenznt{ otn blga~nlkbl` zmn okknxzolkn fg zmn xtfj~kz fl zmn eotcnz
xf{bzbwnar, Fxnl bllfwozbfl oa{f bextfwn{ zmn q~oabzr fg blgfteozbfl fl
{fa~zbfl{ bl zmn bllfwozbfl xtfkn{{,0>
Blktno{bl` ‑lnp%zf%eotcnz―
Ol blktno{bl` jn`tnn fg lfwnazr fg zmn xtfj~kz{ fl zmn eotcnz anoj{ zf eftnozztokzbwnln{{ gft zmn k~{zfent{,
0? kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,4>04 kg, TNBKMPOAJ! T,3 XBAANT! G, -4882" x,?>?0; kg, TNBKMPOAJ! T,3 XBAANT! G, -4882" xx,?>4%?>;0: kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,47
0> kg, TNBKMPOAJ! T,3 XBAANT! G, -4882" xx,?>4%?>;
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 32/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;4
Ojwntzb{nenlz
Ojwntzb{nenlz b{ bl `nlntoa lfz zmn eobl `foa fg ol Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xtfinkz
d~z b{ o woa~odan kflkfebzolz, Anwnto`bl` n}zntloa bjno{ bexabn{ zf dn ol
fxnl olj jnefktozbk kfexolr zf zmn k~{zfent{, Zmntn b{ o db` ojwolzo`nfwnt ztojbzbfloa ojwntzb{bl`! dnko~{n dnbl` ol bllfwozbwn kfexolr kol dn
jnefl{ztoznj pbzm Fxnl Bllfwozbfl,07
K~{zfent afroazr
Anwnto`bl` k~{zfent‒{ gnnjdokc {~{zoblodar kol tn{~az bl blktno{bl` afroazr
fwnt zmn zben,00
Fwntkfebl` fxntozbl` dabljln{{
Lnp bjno{ olj bex~a{n{ gtfe f~z{bjn kol mnax zf fwntkfen faj tf~zbln{ olj
zmblcbl` xozzntl{ bl{bjn zmn ft`olb{ozbfl, K~{zfent{ eor jneolj blzntloaar
tninkznj bjno{, Fxnl Bllfwozbfl kol fxnl nrn{ fl zmoz olj mnax zf fwntkfen
fxntozbfl dabljln{{,0=
Go{znt bllfwozbfl{ olj dnzznt clfpanj`n odf~z zmn k~{zfent afpnt zmn kf{z{
olj blktno{n zmn okknxzolkn fg lnp xtfj~kz{ fl zmn eotcnz{, D~z Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl mo{ zf dn jfln kotng~aar olj tb{c{ mown zf dn ~ljnt{zffj bl ftjnt
zf dn {~kkn{{g~a, Zmn ln}z {nkzbfl kfwnt{ zmn tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl gft
kfexolbn{,
Tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl4,;,:
Bg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl b{ {~kkn{{g~a gft o kntzobl kfexolr! bz fgznl jnxnlj{ fl bg
zmn tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl mown dnnl ~ljnt{zffj olj zmn okz~oa n}nk~zbfl
fg zmn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xtfinkz b{ kfttnkz, Kmn{dtf~`m jngbln{ zmn gfaafpbl`
tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl9
02
․ Zmn ‑Lfz Blwnlznj Mntn― [rljtfen
․ Zmn ‑Lfz [faj Mntn― Wbt~{
․ Dnbl` Zff Fxnl
07 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,4700 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,470= kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,47
02 kg, KMN[DTF^@M M, -4887" xx,4>%;0
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 33/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;;
@o{{eoll jnxbkz{ zmn tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl o{ gfaafp{9=8
․ Zfzoa kf{z{․ Mote fg tnx~zozbfl
․ An`oa xtfdane{
Zmn tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl okkftjbl` zf Kmn{dtf~`m olj @o{{eoll pbaa
dn jn{ktbdnj bl jnzoba lfp,
Zmn ‑Lfz Blwnlznj Mntn― [rljtfen
‑Pn kol‒z zt~{z bz dnko~{n bz‒{ lfz gtfe ~{―
=?
Nwntr kfexolr e~{z gokn zmn tn{b{zolkn zf n}zntloa blwnlzbfl{ olj
znkmlfaf`bn{,=4 Jnxnljbl` fl zmn kfexolr‒{ bllfwozbfl k~az~tn -{nn kmoxznt
4,4,?" zmn tn{b{zolkn zf n}zntloa blwnlzbfl{ kol dn wntr {ztfl` -Kaf{nj
Bllfwozbfl k~az~tn" ft afp -Fxnl Bllfwozbfl k~az~tn", Cozy olj Oaanl koaa zmb{
tn{b{zolkn zmn ‑Lfz blwnlznj mntn― {rljtfen,=;
Zmn ‑Lfz [faj Mntn― Wbt~{
‑Bg pn jf lfz {naa bz lf fln {mf~aj― =:
Zmn ‑Lfz [faj Mntn― wbt~{ jn{ktbdn{ zmn tn{b{zolkn fg kfexolbn{ zf abknl{n
bjno{ zf fzmnt kfexolbn{ ft ktnozn {xbl%fgg{! nwnl bg lf oxxabkozbfl gft zmn
bjno{ n}b{z{ bl{bjn zmn kfexolr, Zmn tno{fl{ otn ef{zar bl zmn gnot zmoz
kfexnzbzft{ eb`mz dn tnblgftknj, Zm~{ eolr bjno{ lnwnt `nz jnwnafxnj olj
zmntngftn kol‒z xtfj~kn tnwnl~n, Bz b{ bexftzolz zf n{zodab{m ol bllfwozbfl
k~az~tn -{nn kmoxznt 4,4,?" pmntn bjno{ otn `bwnl zmn fxxftz~lbzr zf `nztnoab{nj nbzmnt bl{bjn ft f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr, Kfexolbn{ eb`mz oa{f o{{~en
=8 @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,47%40=? KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" x,4;=4 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" x,4;=; kg, COZY! T,3 OAANL! Z, -?2=4" xx,0%?2
=: KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" x,;4
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 34/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;:
zmoz bg zmnr kol‒z gblj o xtfgbzodan ~{n gft ol bjno ft znkmlfaf`r! lf fln na{n
pbaa nbzmnt,=>
Gtfe zmn d~rnt{ xnt{xnkzbwn olfzmnt tn{b{zolkn nent`n{9
‑D~rnt{ eor pfttr zmoz {naant{ fg ~l~{nj znkmlfaf`r eor flar fggnt zmn doj
fln{,― =7
Dnbl` Zff Fxnl
Bz b{ wntr bexftzolz zf zmblc odf~z pmbkm clfpanj`n zf {motn pbzm fzmnt
kfexolbn{! bllfwozbfl kfee~lbzbn{! wnlz~tn koxbzoab{z{ ft kfexnzbzft{,
N{xnkboaar gft rf~l` {zotz%~x{! zmn blzntloa blznaankz~oa xtfxntzr kol dn
{~d{zolzboa olj lnnj{ zf dn xtfznkznj gtfe db``nt kfexnzbzft{ pbzm eftn
tn{f~tkn{ pmf eor dn oa{f blzntn{znj bl zmn k~ttnlz eotcnz, [motbl` zmn
ptfl` blgfteozbfl pbzm zmn ptfl` xnfxan kol cbaa o kfexolr -n{xnkboaar o
{eoaa fln",=0
Zfzoa kf{z{
Zmn zfzoa kf{z{ kol dn mb`mnt o{ n}xnkznj pmban Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xtfinkz{ otn
dbljbl` m~eol tn{f~tkn{ j~tbl` zmn xaollbl`! n}nk~zbfl olj zmn n}xafbzozbfl,
N{xnkboaar zmn blzn`tozbfl olj zmn n}xafbzozbfl fg zmn {fa~zbfl kol dblj
~ln}xnkznjar mb`m tn{f~tkn{ fg zmn kfexolr,==
Mote fg tnx~zozbfl
Fxnl Bllfwozbfl lnnj{ zf dn zocnl {ntbf~{ar olj lnnj{ zf dn blzn`toznj blzf
zmn bllfwozbfl {ztozn`r fg o kfexolr, Tnpotjbl`! kfee~lbkozbfl {ztozn`bn{
olj n}xafbzozbfl xaol{ lnnj zf dn kanot gft oaa xotzbkbxolz{, Blojnq~ozn
tnpotjbl`! ptfl` kfee~lbkozbfl pbzm zmn xotzbkbxolz{ olj ~lkntzoblzr odf~z
zmn n}xafbzozbfl fg zmn bjno{ kol anoj zf mote fg tnx~zozbfl gft zmn kfexolr=2
=> kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" xx,;?%;;=7 KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" x,;?=0 kg, KMN[DTF^@M! M, -4887" xx,;>%;0== kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,47
=2 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,4:%40
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 35/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;>
An`oa xtfdane{
An`oa xtfdane{ ko~{n bg zmn an`oa gtoenpftc fg ol Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xtfinkz b{
~lkanot, Zm~{ ol n}okz jngblbzbfl fg zmn an`oa gtoenpftc blka~jbl` zmn
n}xafbzozbfl! ~{o`n tb`mz{ olj tnpotjbl` fg zmn bjno{ otn n{{nlzboa gft {~kkn{{g~a Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xtfinkz{,28
Ef{z tb{c{ fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl nent`n gtfe ol bllfwozbfl k~az~tn! pmbkm b{l‒z
tnojr gft Fxnl Bllfwozbfl, D~z oa{f zmn blzn`tozbfl fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl fl zmn
{ztozn`bk anwna olj zmn n}nk~zbfl fg Fxnl Bllfwozbfl fl zmn fxntozbwn anwna
xf{n tb{c{, Zmntngftn bz b{ bexftzolz zf bexanenlz Fxnl Bllfwozbfl blzn`toaar
fl zmn lfteozbwn! {ztozn`bk olj fxntozbwn anwna fg ol ft`olb{ozbfl,
4,: Ktfpj{f~tkbl`
Ktfpj{f~tkbl` b{ o {ztozn`r gft f~z{f~tkbl` clfpanj`n `nlntozbfl olj
xtfdane {fawbl` zo{c{ zf ol n}zntloa kfee~lbzr dr ~zbabybl` Blzntlnz
znkmlfaf`r, Zmn znte ktfpj{f~tkbl` po{ gbt{z kfblnj dr Ingg Mfpn bl 4887
olj b{ o danlj fg zmn pftj{ ktfpj olj f~z{f~tkbl` , Eolr oxxtfokmn{ olj
oxxabkozbfl{ xtfgbz gtfe ktfpj{f~tkbl`! abcn Fxnl Bllfwozbfl jfn{, Fxnl
bllfwozbfl ~zbabyn{ ktfpj{f~tkbl` gft bllfwozbfl x~txf{n{ d~z ktfpj{f~tkbl`
b{ lfz tn{ztbkznj zf bllfwozbfl! bl{znoj {nwntoa fzmnt oxxabkozbfl otno{ gft ktfpj{f~tkbl` mown zf dn enlzbflnj, Zmntngftn bl zmb{ kmoxznt ol fwntwbnp
fl o {nankzbfl fg ktfpj{f~tkbl` kflknxz{ {mf~aj dn `bwnl,
Ktfpj{f~tkbl` Kflknxz{4,:,?
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn ef{z kfeefl oxxabkozbfl{ gft ktfpj{f~tkbl` pbaa dn
blztfj~knj olj jb{zbl`~b{mnj, @o{{eoll jb{zbl`~b{mnj gbwn kozn`ftbn{ fg
ktfpj{f~tkbl` kflknxz{92?
․ Blzntenjbozn Xaozgfte{
․ Zf`nzmnt o Gtnn [fa~zbfl
․ Xtfxtbnzotr xaozgfte{
․ Eotcnzxaokn{ gft bjno{
․ X~dabk blbzbozbwn{
28 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,40
2? kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,?:%44
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 36/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;7
Zmn {bl`an kflknxz{ pbaa dn blztfj~knj bl jnzoba lfp,
Blzntenjbozn Xaozgfte{
Blzntenjbozn xaozgfte{ otn flabln xaozgfte{ zmoz dtbl` kfexolbn{ oljbllfwozft{ zf`nzmnt olj zmntngftn {ntwn o{ o ablc dnzpnnl o{cbl` olj {fawbl`
xotzbn{,24 Gf~t zrxn{ fg blzntenjbozn xaozgfte{ kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj92;
․ Tn{notkm olj jnwnafxenlz xaozgfte{ gfk~{ fl {fawbl` {kbnlzbgbk
xtfdane{ pbzm zmn mnax fg ktfpj{f~tkbl`,
․ Eotcnzbl` olj jn{b`l xaozgfte{ gfk~{ fl eotcnzbl` olj jn{b`l
zo{c{ bl{znoj fg jnwnafxenlz zo{c{,
․
Xaozgfte{ gft gtnnaolknt {ntwn o{ o ablc dnzpnnl gtnnaolknt{ oljkabnlz kfexolbn{,
․ Bjno xaozgfte{ jf lfz gfk~{ fl o {xnkboa q~oabgbkozbfl fg zmnbt ~{nt{!
bl{znoj zmnr gfk~{ fl zmn ktnozbwn xtfdane {fawbl` koxodbabzr fg o
kfee~lbzr,
Zmtf~`m blzntenjbozn xaozgfte{ Fxnl Bllfwozbfl kol dn okkfexab{mnj,
Tn{xnkzbwnar blzntenjbozn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xaozgfte{ otn fgznl oa{f koaanj
Fxnl Bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{,
Gtnn [fa~zbfl{
Gtnn {fa~zbfl{ otn xtfinkz{ bl pmbkm wfa~lznnt{ jnkbjn zf pftc zf`nzmnt gft
gtnn zf okmbnwn o kntzobl `foa,2: @o{{eoll jb{zbl`~b{mn{ zpf zrxn{92>
․ Pnd{bzn{ fl pmbkm afz{ fg xnfxan kflztbd~zn olj {motn wotbf~{
blgfteozbfl zf zmn zf zmn x~dabk! abcn Pbcbxnjbo,
․ Fxnl {f~tkn {fgzpotn9 Wfa~lznnt{ jnwnafx {fgzpotn olj xtfwbjn zmn
{f~tkn kfjn zf zmn x~dabk gft gtnn, Zmn Fxnl {f~tkn kfee~lbzr kol
dn {nnl o{ ktfpj{f~tkbl` xbflnnt{,
24 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,?:2; kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,?:%?=2: kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" x,?=
2> kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,?=%?2
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 37/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;0
Zmn tno{fl{ gft xotzbkbxozbl` fl gtnn {fa~zbfl{ otn jbwnt{n, Fgznl xnfxan otn
mb`mar blztbl{bkoaar efzbwoznj d~z oa{f zmn jb{{ozb{gokzbfl fg o kntzobl {bz~ozbfl
olj zmn nlztnxtnln~tboa {xbtbz kol anoj zf xotzbkbxozbfl bl {~km xtfinkz{,
Xtfxtbnzotr xaozgfte{
Aot`n kfexolbn{ {fenzben{ xtngnt zf d~baj zmnbt fpl xtfxtbnzotr
ktfpj{f~tkbl` xaozgfte{ ft abknl{n xtfxtbnzotr bl{zolkn{ gtfe ktfpj{f~tkbl`
xaozgfte xtfwbjnt{ bl{znoj fg ~{bl` blzntenjbozn xaozgfte{ gft zmnbt
ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfinkz{, Zpf zrxn{ fg xtfxtbnzotr xaozgfte{ kol dn
jb{zbl`~b{mnj927
․
Xaozgfte{ gft xtfj~kz bjno{ olj xtfdane {fawbl` zo{c{ otn nbzmnt gfk~{bl` fl bjno{ gtfe k~{zfent{! gol{ -Fxnl Bllfwozbfl"! ft
nexafrnn{ -Kaf{nj Bllfwozbfl" zf jnwnafx lnp xtfj~kz{ ft {ntwbkn{,
Kfedblozbfl{ otn oa{f xf{{bdan,
․ Dtoljbl` olj jn{b`l xaozgfte{ otn gfk~{bl` fl zmn eotcnzbl` olj
jn{b`l koxodbabzbn{ fg zmn k~{zfent{,
Eotcnzxaokn{ gft bjno{
Fl zmf{n xaozgfte{ otzb{z{ -oeozn~t ft xtfgn{{bfloa{" kol jb{ztbd~zn olj {naa
{nag%ktogznj xtfj~kz{ zf o pnd%kfee~lbzr,20
X~dabk blbzbozbwn{
X~dabk blbzbozbwn{ otn gtnn {fa~zbfl{ pbzm o x~dabk bl{zbz~zbfl o{ kabnlz,2=
Zmn gbwn odfwn%enlzbflnj kflknxz{ kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj dnzpnnl lfl%
kfeentkboa olj kfeentkboa xaozgfte{, Gtnn {fa~zbfl{ olj x~dabk blbzbozbwn{
jf lfz gfk~{ fl o kfeentkboa `foa! fl zmn fzmnt molj blzntenjbozn olj
xtfxtbnzotr xaozgfte{ otn kfeentkboaar jtbwnl o{ pnaa o{ eotcnzxaokn{ gft bjno{, Blzntenjbozn olj xtfxtbnzotr xaozgfte{ otn gfk~{bl` fl {fawbl`
d~{bln{{ zo{c{! abcn okq~b{bzbfl! eotcnzbl` ft bllfwozbfl,
27 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa, -48?8" xx,?2%4820 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,4?
2= kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" xx,4?%44
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 38/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;=
Zmn Ktfpj{f~tkbl` Xtfkn{{4,:,4
Nwntr ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfinkz lnnj{ zf dn xaollnj! bexanenlznj olj
n}xafbznj kotng~aar, Zmntngftn @o{{eoll jngbln{ o `nlntbk xtfkn{{ zmoz b{
baa~{ztoznj bl Gb`~tn 7,
Zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfkn{{ kfl{b{z{ fg zmn gfaafpbl` gbwn xmo{n{9 22
․ Xtnxotozbfl
․ Blbzbozbfl
․ Bexanenlzozbfl
․ Nwoa~ozbfl
․ N}xafbzozbfl
Gb`~tn 79 Zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfkn{{ okkftjbl` zf @o{{eoll?88
Zmn xmo{n{ pbaa dn jn{ktbdnj bl jnzoba lfp,
Xtnxotozbfl
Bl zmn xtnxotozbfl xmo{n zmn ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfinkz lnnj{ zf dn jngblnj olj
o jnkb{bfl gft o xotzbk~aot ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfwbjnt lnnj{ zf dn eojn, ?8?
Blbzbozbfl
Zmn blbzbozbfl xmo{n jnoa{ pbzm oaa okzbwbzbn{ zmoz otn lnkn{{otr zf o{c oljx~dab{m o {xnkbgbk q~n{zbfl zf o ktfpj! blka~jbl` o kaotbgbkozbfl fg zmn
kflgbjnlzboabzr fg zmn tnknbwnj blgfteozbfl o{ pnaa o{ zmn jnzobanj gfte~ab{ozbfl
olj zmn x~dab{mbl` fg zmn q~n{zbfl,?84
22 kg @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" xx,:8%>>?88 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;>?8? kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;:
?84 kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;:
Blbzbozbfl Bexanenlzozbfl Nwoa~ozbfl N}xafbzozbflXtnxotozbfl
Jnkb{bfl gft
Ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfinkz
_~n{zbfl ̀ nz{
x~dab{mnj
Nlj fg bjno
`nlntozbfl xmo{n
[~deb{{bfl{ ̀ nz
nwoa~oznj
Bjno b{ bexanenlznj
{~kkn{{g~aar
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 39/80
4 Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz
;2
Bexanenlzozbfl
Bl zmn bexanenlzozbfl xmo{n zmn kfee~lbzr tn{xflj{ pbzm bjno{ olj
{fa~zbfl{ zf zmn q~n{zbfl j~tbl` o {nz zben xntbfj,?8;
Nwoa~ozbfl
Bl zmb{ xmo{n o i~tr -olj & ft zmn kfee~lbzr" nwoa~ozn{ zmn blkfebl`
{~``n{zbfl{ olj zmn bjno nexafrnt{ `nz tnpotjnj,?8:
N}xafbzozbfl
Gft zmn dn{z bjno{ jnzobanj kflknxz{ otn jnwnafxnj! gno{bdbabzr {z~jbn{ otn
okkfexab{mnj olj lnp xtfj~kz{ otn blztfj~knj zf zmn eotcnzxaokn,?8>
Zmn blztfj~knj xtfkn{{ jn{ktbdn{ zmn {nq~nlkn fg zo{c{ zmoz mo{ zf dn
okkfexab{mnj bl o ktfpj{f~tkbl` xtfinkz gtfe o d~{bln{{ kabnlz‒{
xnt{xnkzbwn, Zmn kfee~lbzr b{ blwfawnj bl zmn bexanenlzozbfl olj fxzbfloaar
bl zmn nwoa~ozbfl olj n}xafbzozbfl xmo{n, Fxzbfloaar o xtn%nwoa~ozbfl fg zmn
bjno{ dr zmn kfee~lbzr kol dn okkfexab{mnj bl zmn bexanenlzozbfl {znx,
Ktfpjg~ljbl`4,:,;
Ktfpj{f~tkbl` mo{ dnkfen nlftef~{ar xfx~aot gft gblolkbl` {zotz%~x{ ft
ktnozbwn xtfinkz{ dr o{cbl` o ktfpj gft gblolkboa {~xxftz wbo flabln xaozgfte{,
Zmb{ {xnkboa gfte fg ktfpj{f~tkbl` b{ koaanj Ktfpjg~ljbl`, Zmn `foa b{ zf `nz
eflnzotr {~xxftz gtfe o kfee~lbzr fg gol{ olj blwn{zft{ bl ftjnt zf gblolkn
xtfinkz{! xtf`toe{ ft okzbfl{,?87 Zm~{ ktfpjg~ljbl` xaozgfte{ {ntwn o{ o ablc
dnzpnnl blwn{zft{ olj oxxabkolz{,
?8; kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;>?8: kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;>?8> kg, @O[[EOLL! F, nz oa -48?8" x,;>?87 kg, ZOKCN! F, -48?8"
mzzx9&&ppp,{abjn{motn,lnz&ft`g~n&zffa{%~lj%ztnlj{%be%pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz%:>8:=74
S84,?8,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 40/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:8
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
Zmb{ kmoxznt kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn zmnftnzbkoa do{b{ odf~z clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz,
Bz b{ jbwbjnj blzf zmtnn xotz{, Gbt{z zmn do{bk kflknxz{ olj n{{nlzboa jngblbzbfl{
gft o xtfxnt ~ljnt{zoljbl` fg clfpanj`n pbaa dn blztfj~knj, [~d{nq~nlzar
zmn o{xnkz{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz fl zmn eolo`nenlz anwna pbaa dn
f~zablnj, Aoznt zmn znkmlbkoa {~xxftz fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz zmtf~`m
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ pbaa oa{f dn kfwntnj bl zmb{ kmoxznt,
;,? Clfpanj`n
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn jngblbzbfl fg zmn clfpanj`n znte olj zmn kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg clfpanj`n otn blztfj~knj, [~d{nq~nlzar zmn kfttnaozbfl{ fg clfpanj`n olj
bllfwozbfl{ pbaa dn f~zablnj,
Jngblbzbfl fg Clfpanj`n;,?,?
Gft o xtfxnt ~ljnt{zoljbl` fg zmn clfpanj`n znte! zmn jbggntnlzbozbfl fg jozo!
Blgfteozbfl! olj clfpanj`n b{ n{{nlzboa, Zmntngftn zmn od{ztokzbfl fg zmn
clfpanj`n znte do{nj fl blgfteozbfl olj jozo okkftjbl` zf Lftzm {mf~aj dn
f~zablnj mntn,
Gb`~tn 0 {mfp{ zmoz {bl`an kmotokznt{ zmoz oxxnot bl o jngblnj {rlzo} otn
koaanj jozo -n,`, 2!=>", @bwbl` jozo o enolbl` dr ojjbl` enzojozo tn{~az{
blzf blgfteozbfl -n,`, 2!=> {nkflj{", Dr blzntxtnzbl` olj kfedblbl`
blgfteozbfl dr m~eol{ clfpanj`n nent`n{ -n,`, 2!=> {nkflj{ b{ zmn pftaj
tnkftj bl zmn ?88e {xtblz",
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 41/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:?
Gb`~tn 09 Od{ztokzbfl fg zmn clfpanj`n znte?80
Zmn anwna{ fg od{ztokzbfl otn jngblnj o{ gfaafp{9?8=
․ Kmotokznt{9 Kmotokznt{ otn {bl`an l~ednt{! anzznt{ ft {xnkboa
kmotokznt{, Kmotokznt{ jf lfz oxxnot bl ftjnt zf o `bwnl {rlzo},
․ Jozo9 Jozo b{ o {nq~nlkn fg kmotokznt{ zmoz b{ ftjntnj okkftjbl` zf o
`bwnl {rlzo} d~z zmn blzntxtnzozbfl b{ eb{{bl`! pmbkm enol{ zmoz bz mo{
lf enolbl`,
․ Blgfteozbfl9 Blgfteozbfl nent`n{ pmnl jozo b{ `bwnl o enolbl`,
․ Clfpanj`n9 Blgfteozbfl bl ol n}xntbnlzboa kflzn}z b{ koaanj
clfpanj`n,
Zm~{ clfpanj`n b{ zmn blzntxtnzozbfl fg blgfteozbfl bl o kntzobl kflzn}z dr
m~eol{, Zmn kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg clfpanj`n pbaa dn f~zablnj bl zmn ln}z {nkzbfl,
?80 kg, LFTZM! C, -?22=" xx,;?%4:
?8= kg, LFTZM! C, -?22=" xx,;?%4:
Kmotokznt{
Jozo
Blgfteozbfl
Clfpanj`n
Jnkb{bfl ft Okzbfl
$2$ $!$ $>$ $=$
2!=>
2!=> {nkflj{
2!=> {nkflj{ b{ zmn pftaj
tnkftj bl zmn ?88e {xtblz
# Blzntxtnzozbfl
# [neolzbk
# [rlzo}
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 42/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:4
Kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg Clfpanj`n;,?,4
Zmn abzntoz~tn jnxbkz{ zmn gfaafpbl` gf~t kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg clfpanj`n9?82
․ Clfpanj`n b{ `nlntoznj jrloebkoaar! pmbkm dr enol{ fg kmol`bl`
kf`lbzbwn {zt~kz~tn{,
․ Clfpanj`n b{ oapor{ zbnj zf xnt{fl{
․ Clfpanj`n b{ xtntnq~b{bzn gft m~eol okzbfl{! pmbkm enol{ zmoz
pbzmf~z zmn xtfxnt clfpanj`n m~eol{ kol‒z {nz zmn tb`mz okzbfl{,
․ Clfpanj`n e~azbxabn{ dr {motbl` bz! pmbkm enol{ zmoz dr {motbl`
blgfteozbfl zf xnfxan zmnr eor {nn zmoz blgfteozbfl bl o jbggntnlz
kflzn}z olj zmntngftn lnp clfpanj`n nent`n{,
G~tzmnteftn bz kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj dnzpnnl clfpanj`n zmoz kol dn ptbzznl
jfpl n}xabkbzar! olj clfpanj`n zmoz b{ kmotokzntbynj o{ n}xntzb{n ft xtokzbkoa
{cbaa{, Cbt{m jb{zbl`~b{mn{ dnzpnnl n}xabkbz olj bexabkbz clfpanj`n o{
gfaafp{9??8
Clfpanj`n zmoz b{ xtn{nlz zf nwntrfln -n,`, ptbzznl bl dffc{ ft fl pnd{bzn{"
b{ koaanj n}xabkbz clfpanj`n, Clfpanj`n zmoz nent`nj dnko~{n fg
n}xntbnlkn{ -n,`, goba~tn{" ft ztoblbl` -n,`, tbjbl` o dbcn" b{ koaanj bexabkbz
clfpanj`n,
Clfpanj`n olj Bllfwozbfl;,?,;
‑Bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz mo{ dnnl blktno{bl`ar dnnl `oblnj fl bexftzolkn
oktf{{ blj~{ztbn{ o{ pnaa o{ bl kfeentkboa d~{bln{{n{, Bl abln pbzm zmb{
xtfkn{{! eftn olj eftn {b`lbgbkolkn mo{ dnnl ozzokmnj zf clfpanj`n! pmbkm
b{ ~{ng~a gft zmn xtfkn{{ fg ktnozbl` olj ft`olb{ozbfl‒{ woa~n,― ???
Bl zmn clfpanj`n jtbwnl nkflfer ol nggbkbnlz olj nggnkzbwn eolo`nenlz fg
clfpanj`n b{ lnkn{{otr dnko~{n clfpanj`n kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn do{b{ gft
bllfwozbfl olj kfexnzbzbwn ojwolzo`n,??4 Mfp clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz kol
dn okmbnwnj pbaa dn xotz fg zmn ln}z {nkzbfl,
?82 kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,?4??8 kg, CBT[M! J, -?228" xx,;:8%;7>??? ANDNT! E, nz oa, -488:" x,4>0
??4 ANDNT! E, nz oa, -488:" x,4>>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 43/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:;
;,4 Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn x~txf{n gft clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz bl kfexolbn{ pbaa dn
jn{ktbdnj, Zmn od{ztokznj anwna{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz pbaa dn f~zablnjolj g~tzmnteftn zmn kfexflnlz{ olj okzbwbzbn{ zmoz jngbln zmn clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz pbaa dn blztfj~knj,
Zmn X~txf{n fg Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz;,4,?
‑Zmn kotng~a olj {~kkn{{g~a eolo`nenlz fg clfpanj`n o{ zmn ef{z woa~odan
tn{f~tkn b{ blktno{bl`ar tnkf`lbynj olj xntknbwnj o{ eolo`nenlz zo{c bl
kfexolbn{,― ??;
[oeent olj Dftlneoll jnxbkz zmoz clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz b{ zmn
eolo`nenlz fg ol ft`olb{ozbfl pbzm {xnkboa nexmo{b{ fl zmn {~kkn{{ gokzft
clfpanj`n,??: [f~c~x jn{ktbdn{ zmtnn ztnlj{ zmoz eocn clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz lnkn{{otr gft kfexolbn{9??>
․ Zmn nwfa~zbfl fg zmn clfpanj`n {fkbnzr olj zmn kmol`bl` clfpanj`n
aolj{koxn,
․Zmn jfeblozbfl fg clfpanj`n blznl{bwn d~{bln{{n{ olj xtfj~kz{,
․ Zmn blktno{bl` oef~lz fg ktnozbwn olj clfpanj`n%blznl{bwn pftc
nent`n{ f~z fg zmn mb`mnt kfexan}bzr fg xtfj~kz{ olj d~{bln{{n{,
G~tzmnt zmn xftzbfl fg clfpanj`n blznl{bwn xtfkn{{n{ zf zmn zfzoa d~{bln{{
woa~n ktnozbfl blktno{n{ kfl{zolzar,??7
??; kg, PFMBLY! I, -4882" x,?:??: kg, DFTLNEOLL! E,3 [OEENT! E -4884" x,?8??> kg, [F^C^X! K, -488?" xx,;7%;0
??7 kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,??
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 44/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
::
Zmn gfaafpbl` dnlngbz{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz kol dn jnxbkznj9 ??0
․ Blktno{bl` bllfwozbfl {ztnl`zm olj kfexnzbzbwnln{{
․ Zocn ojwolzo`n fg ~l~{nj clfpanj`n tn{f~tkn{ fg zmn ft`olb{ozbfl․ Lnzpftcbl` n}xntz clfpanj`n
․ Blktno{bl` zmn efzbwozbfl fg zmn nexafrnn{ dr woa~n zmne o{ zmblcnt{
․ Blktno{bl` anotlbl` koxodbabzr fg zmn ft`olb{ozbfl
․ Blktno{bl` q~oabzr fg jnkb{bfl eocbl`
․ Owfbjbl` ~llnkn{{otr tn{f~tkn n}xnl{n -‑Jf lfz blwnlz zmn pmnna
kfl{zolzar lnp―"
Bl ftjnt zf zocn xtfgbz fg zmn odfwn%enlzbflnj dnlngbz{ clfpanj`neolo`nenlz lnnj{ zf dn bexanenlznj blzn`toaar bl zmn ft`olb{ozbfl! pmbkm
pbaa dn f~zablnj bl zmn ln}z zpf {nkzbfl{,
Anwna{ fg Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz;,4,4
Clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz mo{ zf dn {nnl o{ ol blzn`toa xotz fg ol
ft`olb{ozbfl, Gft o dnzznt ~ljnt{zoljbl` pmoz clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
enol{ gft ol ft`olb{ozbfl bz b{ mnaxg~a zf mown ol od{ztokznj wbnp fl zmn
{bl`an anwna{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz, Clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz kol zocn
xaokn fl zmtnn jbggntnlz anwna{9??=
․ Anwna fg Okzbfl
․ Anwna fg Clfpanj`n
․ Anwna fg Jozo
Gb`~tn = {mfp{ zmn zmtnn anwna{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz okkftjbl` zf
Pbaagftz, Zmn jnxbkzbfl oa{f {mfp{ o clfpanj`n {r{zne -{nn kmoxznt ;,;"kflzoblbl` o {fkboa {~d%{r{zne olj o znkmlbkoa {~d%{r{zne, Fl zmn
clfpanj`n anwna olj zmn anwna fg okzbfl xnt{fl{ otn zmn clfpanj`n kottbnt{
olj zmntngftn gfte zmn {fkboa {~d%{r{zne bl zmn efjna, Zmn jozo anwna
??0 kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,??
??= kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" x,?8:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 45/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:>
kfl{zbz~zn{ zmn znkmlbkoa {~d%{r{zne! pmntn zmn jozo fg ol ft`olb{ozbfl b{
{zftnj,??2
Gb`~tn =9 Anwna{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz?48
Zmn anwna{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz pbaa dn xfblznj f~z bl jnzoba lfp,
Anwna fg Okzbfl
Fl zmn anwna fg okzbfl m~eol{ ~{n zmnbt okq~btnj clfpanj`n bl okzbfl{, Zmn
xtfkn{{ fg anotlbl` lnp clfpanj`n jnlfzn{ zmn ztol{bzbfl gtfe zmn anwna fg
okzbfl zf zmn clfpanj`n anwna, ?4?
??2 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" x,?8:?48 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" x,?8:
?4? kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" xx,?87%?80
Anwna fg Jozo
Anwna fg Clfpanj`n
Anwna fg Okzbfl
Znkmlbkoa {~d%{r{zne
[fkboa {~d%{r{zne
Blgfteozbfl Jfk~enlzozbfl
Oxxarbl` Anotlbl`
Clfpanj`n otno
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 46/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:7
Anwna fg Clfpanj`n
Fl zmn anwna fg clfpanj`n zmn {fkboa lnzpftcbl` dnzpnnl zmn xnt{fl{ fg zmn
ft`olb{ozbfl zocn{ xaokn,?44 Xnt{fl{ anotl gtfe nokm fzmnt dr ztol{gnttbl`
zmnbt clfpanj`n zf fzmnt{, Zpf zrxn{ fg clfpanj`n ztol{gnt kol dnjb{zbl`~b{mnj9?4;
․ Jbtnkz9 Zmn clfpanj`n ztol{gnt b{ jfln gokn%zf%gokn -n,`, znokmbl` bl
o {neblot"
․ Bljbtnkz9 Zmn clfpanj`n ztol{gnt b{ jfln wbo o znkmlbkoa {r{zne -n,`,
anotlbl` f~z fg o {ktbxz ft flabln tn{f~tkn"
Zmn xtfkn{{ fg oxxarbl` clfpanj`n jnlfzn{ zmn ztol{bzbfl dnzpnnl zmnclfpanj`n anwna olj zmn anwna fg okzbfl, Zmn xtfkn{{ fg jfk~enlzozbfl
jnlfzn{ zmn ztol{bzbfl gtfe zmn clfpanj`n anwna zf zmn jozo anwna,?4:
Anwna fg Jozo
Fl zmn anwna fg jozo zmn jfk~enlznj n}xabkbz clfpanj`n b{ {zftnj o{ jozo bl o
znkmlbkoa {r{zne -{nn kmoxznt ;,;", ?4>
Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz Kfexflnlz{;,4,;
Zmn efjna fg Xtfd{z jngblbl` zmn kfexflnlz{ fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
kol dn {nnl o{ fln fg zmn bexftzolz efjna{ zmoz jn{ktbdn zmn {ztozn`bk olj
fxntozbwn o{xnkz{ olj zmn ztol{bzbfl{ fg zmn clfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{ bl blzn`toa
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz, Zmnr tnxtn{nlz o kflknxz~oab{ozbfl fg zmn
clfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{ bl kfexolbn{,?47 Mblzntm~dnt olj Tnlya jn{ktbdn zmn
o{xnkz{ fg {ztozn`bk olj fxntozbwn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz o{ gfaafpbl`9
‑Zmn {ztozn`bk jbenl{bfl b{ zf nj~kozn zmn eolo`nt{ olj {zogg zf {ztozn`bk bl{b`mz! {ztozn`bk zmblcbl` olj {ztozn`bk tn{xfl{bdbabzr bl{bjn zmn okz~oa olj zmn
g~z~tn clfpanj`n otno{, Zmn fxntozbfloa jbenl{bfl b{ zf mnax zmn nexafrnn{
?44 kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" xx,?8>%?87?4; kg, PFMBLY! I, -4882" xx,:0%:=?4: kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" xx,?8>%?87?4> kg, PBAAGFTZ! T, -488?" xx,?80%?8=
?47 XTFD[Z! @,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?22=" x,?;;
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 47/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:0
zf kfllnkz zmne{nawn{ olj n}zntloa clfpanj`n {f~tkn{ zmtf~`m tf~zbln{ zmoz
zmnbt clfpanj`n kol dn ~{nj bl zmn blzntn{z fg zmn kfexolr,― ?40
Bl Gb`~tn 2 zmn nb`mz clfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{ do{nj fl zmn efjna fg Xtfd{z!To~d olj Tfemotjz otn {mfpl9?4=
․ Clfpanj`n ̀ foa{
․ Clfpanj`n o{{n{{enlz
․ Clfpanj`n bjnlzbgbkozbfl
․ Clfpanj`n okq~b{bzbfl
․ Clfpanj`n jnwnafxenlz
․
Clfpanj`n jb{ztbd~zbfl․ Clfpanj`n ~{o`n
․ Clfpanj`n xtn{ntwozbfl
Gb`~tn 29 Clfpanj`n Okzbwbzbn{?42
?40 MBLZNTM^DNT! M, M,3 TNLYA! D, -4884" xx,?2%48?4= kg, XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" xx,>;%>=
?42 kg, XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>=
Clfpanj`n ̀ foa{
Clfpanj`nxtn{ntwozbfl
Clfpanj`nbjnlzbkozbfl
Clfpanj`n ~{nClfpanj`n okq~b{bzbfl
Clfpanj`njnwnafxenlz
Clfpanj`no{{n{{enlz
[ztozn`bkclfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{
Fxntozbwnclfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{
Gnnjdokc
Clfpanj`n jb{ztbd~zbfl
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 48/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:=
Zmn {bl`an clfpanj`n okzbwbzbn{ pbaa dn jn{ktbdnj bl jnzoba lfp,
Clfpanj`n @foa{
‑Clfpanj`n `foa{ `bwn zmn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz okzbwbzbn{ o jbtnkzbfl,
Lfteozbwn clfpanj`n `foa{ gfk~{ fl ktnozbl` o clfpanj`n k~az~tn bl zmn
nlzntxtb{n! {ztozn`bk clfpanj`n `foa{ jngbln zmn owobaodan clfpanj`n olj zmn
jneolj gft lnp clfpanj`n, Fxntozbwn clfpanj`n `foa{ gfk~{ fl zmn
bexanenlzozbfl fg zmn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz okkftjbl` zf zmn {ztozn`bk
clfpanj`n ̀ foa{,― ?;8
Clfpanj`n oloar{b{! xaollbl` fg clfpanj`n fdinkzbwn{ olj zmn o{{b`lenlz fg
tn{f~tkn{ otn zrxbkoa enzmfj{ olj bl{zt~enlz{ oxxabnj pmnl pftcbl` f~z
clfpanj`n ̀ foa{,
Clfpanj`n O{{n{{enlz
‑Okkftjbl` zf zmn gfte~aoznj clfpanj`n `foa{ enzmfj{ gft eno{~tnenlz fg
lfteozbwn! {ztozn`bk olj fxntozbfloa clfpanj`n fdinkzbwn{ otn lnkn{{otr,― ?;?
Clfpanj`n o{{n{{enlz kfwnt{ zmn owobaodbabzr olj zmn o{{n{{enlz fg zmn
clfpanj`n bl{bjn zmn ft`olb{ozbfl olj oloar{b{ zmn kmol`n{ fg zmn
clfpanj`n fwnt zmn zben olj zmn ozzoblenlz fg clfpanj`n fdinkzbwn{,
Clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz o{{n{{enlz olj blznaankz~oa koxbzoa tnxftz{ otn
zrxbkoa enzmfj{ olj bl{zt~enlz{ oxxabnj gft clfpanj`n o{{n{{enlz,?;4
Clfpanj`n Bjnlzbgbkozbfl
‑Eolr kfexolbn{ gblj bz jbggbk~az zfjor zf cnnx ztokc fg blzntloa olj n}zntloa jozo! blgfteozbfl olj {cbaa{,― ?;;
?;8 XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>0?;? XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>0?;4 kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,?7
?;; XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 49/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
:2
Clfpanj`n bjnlzbgbkozbfl kfwnt{ okzbwbzbn{ gft bjnlzbgrbl` olj oloar{bl`
clfpanj`n bl{bjn olj f~z{bjn zmn ft`olb{ozbfl,?;:
Clfpanj`n Okq~b{bzbfl
‑Kfexolbn{ bexftz o {~d{zolzboa xotz fg zmnbt clfpanj`n lnnj{ gtfe {f~tkn{
f~z{bjn zmn kfexolr,― ?;>
Clfpanj`n okq~b{bzbfl kfwnt{ bexftzbl` lnp clfpanj`n gtfe n}zntloa
{f~tkn{ zmtf~`m kffxntozbfl! xnt{fllna tnkt~bzbl`! okq~btbl` xoznlz{! Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl nzk,?;7
Clfpanj`n Jnwnafxenlz
Zmn jnwnafxenlz fg lnp clfpanj`n b{ kfexanenlzotr zf clfpanj`n
okq~b{bzbfl olj zmntngftn gfk~{n{ fl jnwnafxbl` lnp {cbaa{! xtfj~kz{! bjno{
olj eftn xfpntg~a xtfkn{{n{ bl{bjn zmn ft`olb{ozbfl,?;0
Clfpanj`n Jb{ztbd~zbfl
‑Clfpanj`n jb{ztbd~zbfl b{ ol fdab`ozftr tnq~btnenlz zf eocn n}b{zbl`
b{faoznj blgfteozbfl ft n}xntbnlkn owobaodan zf zmn nlzbtn ft`olb{ozbfl,― ?;=
Clfpanj`n jb{ztbd~zbfl jfn{ lfz enol zmoz nwntrfln e~{z clfp nwntrzmbl`
bl{bjn zmn ft`olb{ozbfl! d~z nwntrfln pmf mo{ zf clfp odf~z kntzobl
blgfteozbfl {mf~aj dn blgftenj zmtf~`m clfpanj`n jb{ztbd~zbfl,?;2
?;: kg, XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>:?;> XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>:?;7 kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,?7?;0 kg, XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>:?;= XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>>
?;2 kg, XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 50/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>8
Clfpanj`n ̂ {o`n
‑Clfpanj`n ~{o`n! zm~{ eftn xtfj~kzbwn ~{n fg ft`olb{ozbfloa clfpanj`n gft
zmn dnlngbz fg zmn kfexolr‒{ `foa{ b{ zmn x~txf{n fg clfpanj`neolo`nenlz,― ?:8
Clfpanj`n ~{o`n jn{ktbdn{ zmn oxxabkozbfl fg clfpanj`n bl{bjn zmn okzbwbzbn{
fg d~{bln{{ xtfkn{{n{,?:?
Clfpanj`n Xtn{ntwozbfl
‑Flkn okq~btnj {cbaa{ otn lfz o~zfeozbkoaar owobaodan gft zmn g~z~tn, Zmn
{nankzbwn xtn{ntwozbfl fg n}xntbnlkn{! blgfteozbfl olj jfk~enlz{ tnq~btn{
eolo`nenlz nggftz{,― ?:4
Clfpanj`n xtn{ntwozbfl blka~jn{ {owbl`! jb{ztbd~zbl` olj okz~oabybl` anotlnj
{cbaa{! blgfteozbfl! olj jfk~enlz{ pbzm zmn mnax fg blgfteozbfl znkmlfaf`r,?:;
;,; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz [r{zne{
Dngftn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ otn blztfj~knj zmn znte {r{zne {mf~aj dn jngblnj9
‑O {r{zne kfl{b{z{ fg bljbwbj~oa kfexflnlz{! zmn nanenlz{! pmbkm zf`nzmnt
gfte o ~lbz olj otn kfllnkznj dr tnaozbfl{mbx{,― ?::
G~tzmnt zmn {r{zne znte {mf~aj dn tngblnj gft clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz,
Pfmbly jngbln{ o clfpanj`n {r{zne o{ gfaafp{9
‑Zmn clfpanj`n {r{zne tnxtn{nlz{ o {xnkbgbk n}xtn{{bfl fg ol blj~{ztboa
pftc {r{zne, S ‧ U Zmn xnfxan bl o clfpanj`n {r{zne okz o{ clfpanj`n
?:8 XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>>?:? kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,?7?:4 XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C, -?222" x,>7?:; kg, JBZYNA! D, nz oa, -4880" x,?7
?:: MODNTGNAALNT! T, -?22:" x,7
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 51/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>?
kottbnt{ olj kfl{zbz~zn zmn {fkboa {~d%{r{zne, Zmn znkmlbkoa zffa{ olj
gokbabzbn{ kfl{zbz~zn zmn znkmlbkoa {~d%{r{zne,― ?:> -{nn kmoxznt ;,4,4"
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn znkmlbkoa {~d%{r{zne fg clfpanj`n {r{zne{ {mf~aj dng~tzmnt jn{ktbdnj, Zmntngftn Eobnt olj Mêjtbkm‒{ jngblbzbfl fg o znkmlbkoa
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne {mf~aj dn ~{nj9
Clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ -CE[{" otn {nnl o{ nlodabl` znkmlfaf`bn{
gft ol nggnkzbwn olj nggbkbnlz clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz,?:7
Jtf{kma jn{ktbdn{ zmn gfaafpbl` {ntwbkn{ zmoz znkmlbkoa clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ kol fggnt zf m~eol{9 ?:0
․ Zmn xftzoa
․ Ollfzozbl` jozo pbzm enzojozo
․ X~dab{mbl`
․ Xtfkn{{bl` fg {zt~kz~tnj olj ~l{zt~kz~tnj jozo
․ [notkm nl`bln{
․ Tnkfeenljozbfl o`nlz{
․ [cbaa xtfgban{ olj n}xntz {notkm
․ N%anotlbl`
․ Kfaaodftozbfl
Zmn {ntwbkn{ pbaa dn f~zablnj bl jnzoba lfp,
Zmn Xftzoa
O clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz xftzoa b{ o {r{zne zmoz `bwn{ zmn ~{nt{ okkn{{ zf
jozo -bljbtnkzar zf clfpanj`n" olj nlodan{ zmn ~{nt{ zf k~{zfebyn zmn wbnp
fl zmoz jozo,?:= Bz okz{ o{ o {~xxftzbwn pftcdnlkm gft zmn clfpanj`n%pftcnt!
bl pmbkm {~xxftzbwn {ntwbkn{ kol dn9?:2
?:> PFMBLY! I, -4882" x,:;?:7 EOBNT! T,3 MÊJTBKM! Z, -488=" x,>:??:0 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" xx,447%440?:= kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,447
?:2 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" xx,4;8%4;?
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 52/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>4
․ K~{zfebybl` zmn wbnp olj jozo okkftjbl` zf zmn ~{nt xtfgban
․ Tnkfeenljbl` tnanwolz blgfteozbfl zf o k~ttnlzar fxnlnj jfk~enlz
․ Fggntbl` tbkm ojeblb{ztozbfl! {notkm olj gbazntbl` fg zmn jozo
Ol n}oexan gft o clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz xftzoa b{ zmn {fgzpotn {fa~zbfl
Mrxntpown?>8 ,
Ollfzozbl` Jozo Pbzm Enzojozo
‑Zmn ojjnj woa~n fg enzojozo olj ollfzozbfl b{ zmoz dr ojjbl` jozo lnp
blgfteozbfl nent`n{,― ?>?
Ollfzozbl` jozo pbzm enzojozo b{ fg eoift bexftzolkn zf nltbkm zmn enolbl`
fg jozo gft m~eol{ olj kfex~znt{, Bl ftjnt zf `nz ol bjno fg zmn kflknxz!
enzojozo olj ollfzozbfl pbaa dn jn{ktbdnj,
‑Enzojozo b{ {zt~kz~tnj blgfteozbfl zmoz jn{ktbdn{! n}xaobl{! afkozn{ ft
fzmntpb{n eocn{ bz no{bnt zf tnztbnwn! eolo`n ft ~{n ol blgfteozbfl
tn{f~tkn,― ?>4
Zm~{ ollfzozbl` jozo pbzm enzojozo mnax{ m~eol{ olj kfex~znt{ zf `nz
ojjbzbfloa blgfteozbfl odf~z jfk~enlz{ olj zmntngftn nltbkmn{ zmn jozo pbzm
eftn enolbl`g~a jn{ktbdbl` blgfteozbfl,?>; Zmn FNKJ jn{ktbdn{ enzojozo
o{ jozo odf~z jozo olj {xnkbgbn{ tnkfeenljozbfl{ gft zmn ~{n fg
enzojozo,?>: Znkmlbkoa {zoljotj{ eocn bz oa{f xf{{bdan gft kfex~znt{ zf
blzntxtnz enzojozo olj zmntndr {ntwn ojjbzbfloa blgfteozbfl zf zmn ~{nt,?>>
Ollfzozbl` b{ zmn xtfkn{{ fg ojjbl` enzojozo zf o jfk~enlz ft olr fzmnt
?>8 Mrxntpown -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,mrxntpown,oz& S?2,??,48??U?>? JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;7?>4 Lozbfloa Blgfteozbfl [zoljotj{ Ft`olb{ozbfl -488:"
mzzx9&&ppp,lb{f,ft`&x~dabkozbfl{&xtn{{&^ljnt{zoljbl`Enzojozo,xjg S?4,82,48??U?>; kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;7?>: FNKJ % Jozo olj Enzojozo Tnxftzbl` olj Xtn{nlzozbfl Moljdffc -4880"
mzzx9&&ppp,fnkj,ft`&jozofnkj&:7&?0&;070?>0:,xjg S?2,??,48??U
?>> kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" xx,4;>%4;7
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 53/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>;
jozo,?>7 Zo``bl` b{ o wntr xfx~aot gfte fg ollfzozbl` jozo dr ojjbl`
cnrpftj{ fl kfee~lbzr {bzn{ olj zmntngftn {mf~aj dn jn{ktbdnj,
Fl kfee~lbzr {bzn{ zo`{ otn ~{nj zf gokbabzozn ft`olb{ozbfl oljkozn`ftb{ozbfl fg jozo,?>0 Zmn tn{~azbl` ft`olb{ozbfl fg jozo b{ oa{f clfpl o{
gfac{flfebn{! pmbkm b{ ol oktflre fg ‑gfac― olj ‑zo}flfer―,?>= O eoift
{ztnl`zm fg gfac{flfebn{ b{ zmn nlmolknj dtfp{bl` olj gbazntbl` fg jozo9
Zmtf~`m tnaoznj zo`{ ~{nt{ `nz opotn fg jozo zmoz pf~ajl‒z mown dnnl gf~lj
bg kozn`ftbn{ pf~aj mown dnnl ~{nj,?>2 Zm~{ gfac{flfebn{ kol dn o xfpntg~a
zffa zf ft`olbyn jozo pbzm zo`{ d~z zmn gfaafpbl` pnocln{{n{ lnnj zf dn
goknj9?78
․ Oedb`~bzr fg zo`{9 Jbggntnlz ~{nt{ oxxar zo`{ bl o jbggntnlz por fl jozo
․ E~azbxan pftj{9 Bz jfn{l‒z n}b{z o {zoljotjbynj por fl mfp zf nlznt
zo`{ pbzm e~azbxan pftj{, Bl `nlntoa zo`{ {mf~aj dn {bl`an pftj{,
․ [rlflre{9 [rlflre zo`{! abcn ‑eok―! ‑eokblzf{m― ft ‑eok kfex~znt―
anoj zf jbggntnlz kozn`ftbn{ gft zmn {oen zmbl`, Zmn {oen xtfdane
n}b{z{ gft {bl`~aot olj xa~toa,
Dr tnkfeenljbl` zmn ~{nt zo`{ bl zmn zo``bl` xtfkn{{ zmn odfwn%enlzbflnj
pnocln{{n{ kol dn afpntnj, [b`~tdi÷tl{{fl olj wol Ypfa jn{ktbdn o zo`
tnkfeenljozbfl {r{zne do{nj fl zo` kf%fkk~ttnlkn{9
‑@bwnl o xmfzf pbzm ~{nt%jngblnj zo`{! ol ftjntnj ab{z fg e koljbjozn zo`{ b{
jntbwnj gft nokm fg zmn ~{nt%jngblnj zo`{! do{nj fl zo` kf%fkk~ttnlkn, Zmn
ab{z{ fg koljbjozn zo`{ otn zmnl ~{nj o{ blx~z gft zo` o``tn`ozbfl olj
tolcbl`! pmbkm ~azbeoznar xtfj~kn{ zmn tolcnj ab{z fg l tnkfeenljnj
zo`{,― ?7?
@ot` olj Pndnt jn{ktbdn o zo` tnkfeenljozbfl {fa~zbfl o{ gfaafp{9
?>7 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;7?>0 kg, EOZMN[! O, -488:" x,4?>= kg, EOZMN[! O, -488:" x,:?>2 kg, EOZMN[! O, -488:" x,7?78 kg, EOZMN[! O, -488:" xx,>%7
?7? [B@^TDI×TL[[FL! D,3 WOL YPFA! T, -488=" x,;;8
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 54/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>:
‑Pmnlnwnt zmn ~{nt polz{ zf ojj olfzmnt zo`! pn tnkfeenlj o tolcnj ab{z
fg tnanwolz zo`{ zf zmn ~{nt, Zmn ~{nt zmnl kol kmff{n pmnzmnt zf {nankz olr
bzne gtfe zmn ab{z fg tnkfeenljozbfl{! ft zf b`lftn oaa zmn tnkfeenljozbfl{olj nlznt o zo` mnt{nag,― ?74
@ot` olj Pndnt g~tzmnt enlzbfl zmoz zmn ~{nt‒{ efzbwozbfl gft zo``bl`
tn{f~tkn{ b{ `nlntoaar wntr afp,?7;
X~dab{mbl`
X~dab{mbl` b{ zmn xtfkn{{ fg koxz~tbl` jozo dr zmn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
{r{zne,?7: Enzojozo kol dn ojjnj zf zmn x~dab{mnj kflznlz nbzmnt eol~oaar
dr zmn ~{nt ft o~zfeozbkoaar dr zmn {r{zne,
Xtfkn{{bl` fg [zt~kz~tnj olj ^l{zt~kz~tnj Jozo
Jozo kol dn nbzmnt {zt~kz~tnj -n,`, Zodan{! Gban Gfteoz{! nzk," ft ~l{zt~kz~tnj
-zn}z jfk~enlz{", Bexftzolz zf lfzn b{ zmoz zmn blgfteozbfloa kflznlz fg
{zt~kz~tnj jozo b{ mb`mnt zmol fg ~l{zt~kz~tnj jozo! pmbkm b{ ko~{nj dr
enzojozo zmoz nltbkmn{ zmn ~l{zt~kz~tnj jozo, O clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
{r{zne kol mnax zf moljan ~l{zt~kz~tnj jozo eftn nggbkbnlzar dr jntbwbl`
{zt~kz~tn{ ft mnaxbl` zmn ~{nt zf ojj enzojozo ft kozn`ftbyn zmn jozo,?7>
Zmn gfaafpbl` oxxtfokmn{ kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj9?77
․ Zmtf~`m fdinkz{ ft kflzoblnt{ jozo kol dn kox{~anj,
․ Zmtf~`m kozn`ftbn{ {bebaot jfk~enlz{ ft jozo kol dn kozn`ftbynj,
․ Zmtf~`m ztnn {zt~kz~tn{ ft zo}flfebn{ zmn jozo kol dn ft`olbynj
mbntotkmbkoaar,
․ Zmtf~`m ablc{ tnaozbfl{ dnzpnnl jfk~enlz{ ft jozo kol dnokkfexab{mnj,
?74 @OT@! L,3 PNDNT! B, -488=" x,70?7; kg, @OT@! L,3 PNDNT! B, -488=" x,70?7: kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;;?7> kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;:
?77 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" xx,4;:%4;>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 55/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>>
․ Zmtf~`m {zoljotjbynj enzojozo jozo kol dn n}kmol`nj pbzm fzmnt
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ ft fzmnt jozo {f~tkn{,
Pmnl kozn`ftbn{ otn ~{nj gft kozn`ftb{ozbfl {b} xtfdane{ fg kozn`ftb{ozbflmo{ zf dn goknj9?70
․ Otdbztotbln{{ fg kozn`ftbn{9 B{ zmntn o kntzobl kozn`ftr zmoz b{ eftn
loz~toa zmol fzmnt{6
․ Nq~bwoanlkn fg kozn`ftr enednt{9 Pmbkm fdinkz{ otn tnxtn{nlzozbwn
gft o kozn`ftr6
․ Jnznteblokr fg kozn`ftr enednt{mbx olj tnxtn{nlzozbfl9 Pmoz otn
zmn df~ljotbn{ dnzpnnl kozn`ftbn{6․ Zmn loz~tn fg od{ztokzbfl9 Pmoz b{ zmn oxxtfxtbozn anwna fg od{ztokzbfl6
․ Jnkfexf{odbabzr fg kozn`ftbn{ blzf nanenlz{
․ Zmn loz~tn fg ozztbd~zn{9 Pmoz b{ kfl{bjntnj o kozn`ftr olj pmoz b{
kfl{bjntnj ol ozztbd~zn6
Pbzm {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ kozn`ftb{ozbfl! mbntotkmbn{ olj ablc{ dnzpnnl
jozo kol dn okmbnwnj dr ~{bl` {zoljotjbynj enzojozo, Bl kmoxznt ;,:
{neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ pbaa dn blztfj~knj bl jnzoba,
[notkm Nl`bln{
‑Nexafrnn{ {xnlj o {~d{zolzboa xotz fg zmnbt owobaodan zben pbzm
{notkmbl`,― ?7=
Xfpntg~a {notkm nl`bln{ otn n{{nlzboa zf eblbebyn zmn zben gft {notkmbl`,
[notkm kol dn nexfpntnj dr wotbf~{ o{xnkz{9?72
․ Xtf`tn{{bwnar tngblbl` zmn {notkm zfxbk
․ Kfexotb{fl pbzm {bebaot tngntnlkn jfk~enlz{
․ Bljbwbj~oa {notkm tn{~az{ okkftjbl` zf zmn ~{nt{ xtfgban
?70 kg, ENTWB[! K, D,3 TF[KM! N, -?2=?" x,28%2??7= kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,44>
?72 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" xx,4;0%4;=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 56/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>7
Pmban ztojbzbfloa {notkm b{ do{nj oaef{z x~tnar fl zmn fkk~ttnlkn fg pftj{ bl
jfk~enlz{ {neolzbk {notkm fggnt{ fxxftz~lbzbn{ zf bextfwn zmn {notkm
tn{~az{ dr o~`enlzbl` zmn tn{~az{ pbzm {neolzbkoaar tnanwolz blgfteozbfl
-tnaoznj blgfteozbfl" olj eoxxbl`{ zf tnoa%pftaj zmbl`{,?08
Eftn jnzoba{ odf~z{neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ pbaa dn blztfj~knj bl kmoxznt ;,:,
Tnkfeenljozbfl O`nlz{
Tnkfeenljozbfl o`nlz{ otn xtf`toe{ zmoz t~l bl zmn dokc`tf~lj olj
tnkfeenlj xfznlzboa tnanwolz jozo zf zmn ~{nt,?0? Zmntngftn zmn
tnkfeenljozbfl o`nlz {notkmn{ tnanwolz jozo gbzzbl` zf zmn k~ttnlzar {mfpbl`
jfk~enlz olj {mfp{ zmn{n tnaoznj jfk~enlz{ zf zmn ~{nt,?04 Zmn ~{nt `nz{
opotn fg xfznlzboa tnanwolz blgfteozbfl pbzmf~z mowbl` zf n}xabkbzar {notkm gft
bz, O~zfeozbk tnkfeenljozbfl{ otn oa{f wntr xfx~aot fl n%kfeentkn
xaozgfte{,
[cbaa Xtfgban{ olj N}xntz [notkm
‑N}xntz{ otn lfz {bexar `nlntoa xtfdane {fawnt{ pmf mown anotlnj o {nz fg
{ztozn`bn{ S,,,U zmnr otn eftn abcnar zmnl lfwbkn{ zf tnkf`lbyn enolbl`g~a
xozzntl{ fg blgfteozbfl S,,,U ―?0;
[cbaa xtfgban{ kol n}xtn{{ {xnkboab{z n}xntzb{n fg ~{nt{ zmoz pftc pbzm o
clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne,?0: Zmn ~{nt kol nbzmnt {nag%o{{n{{ mnt
n}xntzb{n olj xtfwbjn zmb{ blgfteozbfl zf zmn {r{zne -n,`, zf o ~{nt xtfgban" ft
zmn {r{zne kol ztr zf gb`~tn f~z n}xntzb{n dr oloar{bl` zmn ~{nt‒{
kflztbd~zbfl{ -n,`, bg o ~{nt zrxbkoaar kflztbd~zn{ jfk~enlz{ odf~z ‑{fgzpotn
nl`blnntbl`― zf o {r{zne! bz kol dn jntbwnj zmoz zmn ~{nt eb`mz dn ol n}xntz
bl zmb{ jfeobl",?0>
?08 kg, @^MO! T,3 EKKFFA! T,3 EBAANT! N, -488;" x,084?0? kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;=?04 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;=?0; DTOL[GFTJ! I, -4888" x,:=?0: kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;2
?0> kg, [KMÊGNTENBNT! T,3 XO[KMCN! O, -48??" x,7;%70
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 57/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>0
N}xntz {notkm jn{ktbdn{ zmn xtfkn{{ fg {notkmbl` n}xntz{ bl o clfpanj`n
eolo`nenlz {r{zne,?07 Zmntngftn zmn owobaodan {cbaa xtfgban{ otn kfexotnj zf
zmn tnq~n{znj q~ntr olj zmn dn{z eozkmbl` ~{nt{ otn {mfpl o{ n}xntz{ zf
zmn ~{nt, Ktnozbl` {cbaa xtfgban{ olj n}xntz {notkm nl`bln{ mo{ zmn gfaafpbl`dnlngbz{9?00
․ Pbzm zmn mnax fg {cbaa xtfgban{ ol n}xntz {notkm kol dn okkfexab{mnj
nggbkbnlzar,
․ Zmn clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne kol dnzznt tnkfeenlj
jfk~enlz{ zf zmn ~{nt{ pmnl {cbaa xtfgban{ otn xtfwbjnj,
․ [cbaa xtfgban{ fg bljbwbj~oa{ kol dn ent`nj olj wb{~oabynj,
․
[cbaa xtfgban{ n}znlj tn`~aot xnt{fllna jbtnkzftbn{,․ Eflbzftbl` o{xnkz{ fg zmn xnt{fllna jnwnafxenlz b{ no{bnt,
Okkftbl` zf Nmtabkm tnx~zozbfl b{ ol bexftzolz eno{~tn pmnl bz kfen{ zf
i~j`bl` n}xntz{,?0= Bl kfee~lbzbn{ n}xntz{ kol oa{f dn jngblnj dr okzbwbzr!
tnx~zozbfl olj zt~{z eno{~tn{! pmbkm enol{ zmoz mb`mar okzbwn olj zt~{zg~a
~{nt{ zmoz kflztbd~zn afz{ fg kflznlz ktnozn o kntzobl ojjnj woa~n,?02 Zmn{n
~{nt{ otn koaanj anoj ~{nt{,
Anoj%~{nt{ kol dn {nnl o{ o {xnkboa {ftz fg n}xntz{ olj otn fg {xnkboa
bexftzolkn gft Fxnl Bllfwozbfl olj ktfpj{f~tkbl`, Ntbk wfl Mbxxna jngbln{
o anoj ~{nt o{ gfaafp{9?=8
․ Anoj ~{nt{ gokn lnnj{ zmoz pbaa dn `nlntoa bl o eotcnzxaokn! d~z gokn
zmne e~km notabnt zmol zmn eoiftbzr,
․ Anoj ~{nt{ otn xf{bzbflnj zf dnlngbz dr fdzoblbl` {fa~zbfl{ zf zmf{n
lnnj{,
Anoj%~{nt{ fgznl okz o{ fxblbfl anojnt{ olj zmntngftn mown zmn xfpnt zf
bllfwozn d~z oa{f blga~nlkn fzmnt{ zf okzbfl{,?=? Zmntngftn cnnxbl` anoj%~{nt{
?07 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4;2?00 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4:8?0= NMTABKM! C, -488;" x,;8:?02 kg, WFL MBXXNA! N, -?2=7" x,02?
?=8 kg, WFL MBXXNA! N, -?2=7" x,02?
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 58/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>=
efzbwoznj b{ fg eoift bexftzolkn gft {~kkn{{g~a ktfpj{f~tkbl` olj Fxnl
Bllfwozbfl,
N%anotlbl`
‑N%Anotlbl` otn oaa gfte{ fg nankztflbk {~xxftznj anotlbl` olj znokmbl`!
pmbkm otn xtfknj~toa bl kmotokznt olj obe zf nggnkz zmn kfl{zt~kzbfl fg
clfpanj`n pbzm tngntnlkn zf bljbwbj~oa n}xntbnlkn! xtokzbkn olj clfpanj`n
fg zmn anotlnt, Blgfteozbfl olj kfee~lbkozbfl {r{zne{! pmnzmnt lnzpftcnj
ft lfz! {ntwn o{ {xnkbgbk enjbo -{xnkbgbk bl zmn {nl{n naodftoznj xtnwbf~{ar"
zf bexanenlz zmn anotlbl` xtfkn{{,― ?=4
Jt~kcnt mo{ oatnojr nexmo{bynj zmn tfan fg kflzbl~f~{ anotlbl` bl
nlmolkbl` o clfpanj`n pftcnt‒{ xtfj~kzbwbzr,?=; Zmn tfan fg anotlbl` kol dn
{nnl o{ ol blztbl{bk xotz fg clfpanj`n pftc olj kol dn bjnlzbgbnj bl oaa eoift
clfpanj`n pftc zrxn{9?=:
․ Oxxabkozbfl fg n}b{zbl` clfpanj`n zf k~ttnlz xtfdane{9 O xnt{fl
anotl{ nwntr zben o {cbaa b{ oxxabnj zf lnp xtfdane {bz~ozbfl{,
․ Clfpanj`n ztol{gnt9 Pmnl ztol{gnttbl` clfpanj`n -n,`, wbo znokmbl`"
fzmnt{ kol xo{{ fl zmn anotlnj clfpanj`n,
․ Clfpanj`n Okq~b{bzbfl9 Okq~btbl` clfpanj`n dr tn{notkmbl` ft
anotlbl`,
․ Ktnozbfl fg lnp clfpanj`n ft bllfwozbfl9 Nexafrnt{ zmoz pftc
zf`nzmnt bl znoe{ zf kfaaodftozbwnar ktnozn lnp clfpanj`n anotl gtfe
nokm fzmnt,
?=? kg, ^TDOL! @,3 WFL MBXXNA! N, -?2==" x,>02 olj EFTTB[FL! X,3 TFDNTZ[! I,3
EBJ@ANR! J, -488:" x,4?=4 ZOWOL@OTBOL J,! ANRXFAJ E,! L×AZBL@ C,! T×[NT E, -488:" x,40:?=; kg, JT^KCNT! X, -?222" xx,02%2:?=: Zmn Oxf{jan Oxxtfokm zf {nag%jbtnkznj pftc%blzn`toznj anotlbl` -4887"
mzzx9&&ppp,oxf{jan,z~`toy,oz&enjbo&e~azbenjbo&gban{&zmnVoxf{janVoxxtfokmVzfV{nagVjbtnkznj
VpftcVblzn`toznjVanotlbl` S8=,?8,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 59/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
>2
O{ enlzbflnj dngftn! kfaaodftozbfl b{ ol bexftzolz o{xnkz gft anotlbl`, Mfp
kfaaodftozbfl kol dn {~xxftznj dr clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{ pbaa dn
xfblznj f~z ln}z,
Kfaaodftozbfl
‑Kfaaodftozbfl jn{ktbdn{ zmn ifblz pftc fg o `tf~x fg xnfxan fl {motnj
fdinkz{! pmntn xnfxan {motn kfeefl `foa{ olj otn ifblzar tn{xfl{bdan gft
zmn f~zkfen,― ?=>
Kfaaodftozbfl bl zmn kflzn}z fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz b{ odf~z {~xxftzbl`
zmn ~{nt{ dr kfaaodftozbwn pftc, O clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne kol
zmntngftn blzn`tozn zffa{ abcn Pbcb‒{! jb{k~{{bfl gft~e{ ft {fkboa {fgzpotn,?=7
[fkboa {fgzpotn b{ pnd%do{nj znkmlfaf`r zmoz {~xxftz{ no{r olj toxbj
clfpanj`n ztol{gnt olj kfaaodftozbfl bl jb{ztbd~znj clfpanj`n lnzpftc{,?=0
Ynbzant olj [kmo~nt jnxbkz{ zmoz o {bl`an! ~loedb`~f~{! ~lbwnt{oa jngblbzbfl
fg {fkboa {fgzpotn jfn{ lfz n}b{z,?== Oaanl tngnt{ zf ol n}xaolozbfl dr [mbtcr!
pmf jngblnj {fkboa {fgzpotn o{ {fgzpotn zmoz {~xxftz{ `tf~x blzntokzbfl,?=2
[fkboa {fgzpotn {~xxftz{ olj nlkf~to`n{ kfee~lbkozbfl! {fkboa blzntokzbfl
olj kfaaodftozbfl oefl` xnfxan olj `nlntozn{ ojjnj woa~n dr ktnozbl`
clfpanj`n lnzpftc{,?28 [fkboa kfee~lbzbn{ ktnozn zmnbt fpl efenlz~e olj
lfz nwntrfln bl o kfee~lbzr b{ nq~oaar pbaabl` zf kflztbd~zn kflznlz, Zmb{
xmnlfenlfl b{ clfpl zmn 28%2%? xtblkbxan9 Zmntndr 28 xntknlz fg zmn ~{nt{
bl ol flabln kfee~lbzr otn kfl{~ent{! pmf tnoj olj fd{ntwn d~z lnwnt
kflztbd~zn! 2 xntknlz fg zmn ~{nt{ kflztbd~zn gtfe zben zf zben olj flar ?
xntknlz xotzbkbxozn{ o afz olj zmntngftn b{ tn{xfl{bdan gft ef{z fg zmn
kflznlz,?2?
?=> TBNENT! C, -4880" xx,;:7%;>0?=7 kg, JTF[KMA! @, -4884" x,4:;?=0 PBAAGFTZ! T, nz, oa, -4880" x,?8?== YNBANT! E,3 [KMO^NT! D, -48??" x,4?=2 OAANL! K, Ztokbl` zmn nwfa~zbfl fg {fkboa {fgzpotn -488:"
mzzx9&&ppp,abgnpbzmoaoktbzr,kfe&488:&?8& ztokbl`VzmnVnwf,mzea S8=,?8,48??U?28 OAANL! K, Ztokbl` zmn nwfa~zbfl fg {fkboa {fgzpotn -488:"
mzzx9&&ppp,abgnpbzmoaoktbzr,kfe&488:&?8& ztokbl`VzmnVnwf,mzea S8=,?8,48??U
?2? LBNA[NL! I, -4887"
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 60/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
78
;,: [neolzbk Znkmlfaf`bn{
[neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ otn ol ~xkfebl` ztnlj bl eolr otno{ fg blgfteozbk{,
Bl zmb{ kmoxznt {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ pbaa dn jngblnj! kftn znkmlfaf`bn{ pbaadn blztfj~knj olj oxxabkozbfl otno{ pbaa dn f~zablnj,
Zf `nz ol ~ljnt{zoljbl` fg {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ zmn znte{ {neolzbk{ olj
{rlzo} e~{z dn jngblnj9
‑[rlzo} b{ `nlntoaar ~ljnt{zffj o{ o {nz fg t~an{ gft zmn {zt~kz~tbl` fg
kmotokznt{ olj {ztbl`{, S ‧ U [neolzbk{ `nlntoaar {zolj{ gft zmn enolbl` fg
pftj{! xmto{n{ ft {redfa{,― ?24
[neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ otn fgznl eb{blzntxtnznj bl o por zmoz zmn kftn bjno{
dnmblj zmne otn gfk~{bl` fl eocbl` kfex~znt{ ~ljnt{zolj blgfteozbfl pbzm
zmn mnax fg otzbgbkboa blznaab`nlkn, Zmn okz~oa `foa{ fg {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{
otn! zf {~xxftz oxxabkozbfl{ zf xtn{nlz blgfteozbfl bl o por zmoz eokmbln{
kol moljan blgfteozbfl bl o por zmoz m~eol{ `obl dnlngbz,?2;
O {bl`an jngblbzbfl fg {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ jfn{ lfz n}b{z olj zmntngftn o
jngblbzbfl gft zmn x~txf{n fg zmb{ pftc {mf~aj dn `bwnl9
‑[neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ kfwnt clfpanj`n tnxtn{nlzozbfl aol`~o`n{ gft
flzfaf`bn{ o{ pnaa o{ enzmfj{ olj zffa{ zf ktnozn! eoblzobl olj ~{n
flzfaf`bn{,― ?2:
Zmn kflknxz{ fg flzfaf`bn{ pbaa dn jngblnj lfp,
Flzfaf`bn{Flzfaf`bn{ otn kftn kflknxz{ fg {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{, Bl ftjnt lfz zf
kflg~{n pbzm zmn jngblbzbfl fg flzfaf`bn{ bl xmbaf{fxmr zmn gfaafpbl` jngblbzbfl
{mf~aj dn ~{nj zmtf~`mf~z zmb{ zmn{b{9
mzzx9&&ppp,~{nbz,kfe&oantzdf}&xotzbkbxozbflVblnq~oabzr,mzea S84,82,48??U?24 MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?;?2; kg, MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?4
?2: MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?4
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 61/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
7?
‑Bl xmbaf{fxmr! ol flzfaf`r b{ o zmnftr odf~z zmn loz~tn fg n}b{znlkn! fg pmoz
zrxn{ fg zmbl`{ n}b{z3 flzfaf`r o{ o jb{kbxabln {z~jbn{ {~km zmnftbn{, Otzbgbkboa%
blznaab`nlkn olj Pnd tn{notkmnt{ mown kf%fxznj zmn znte gft zmnbt fpl
iot`fl! olj gft zmne ol flzfaf`r b{ o jfk~enlz ft gban zmoz gfteoaar jngbln{zmn tnaozbfl{ oefl` znte{,‑ ?2>
Okkftjbl`ar flzfaf`bn{ gfteoaar jn{ktbdn clfpanj`n fg ol oxxabkozbfl jfeobl
bl gban{ olj jfk~enlz{,?27
Ol bjno%flzfaf`r gft zmn oxxabkozbfl otno fl bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ lnnj{ zf
mfaj blgfteozbfl fl zmn gfaafpbl` o{xnkz{ fg bllfwozbfl eolo`nenlz9?20
․ Kfeenlz{ olj jb{k~{{bfl{ fl bjno{
․ O{{n{{enlz fg bjno{ zmtf~`m tozbl`{
․ @tf~xbl` olj ka~{zntbl` fg bjno{ olj bjno {~deb{{bfl{
․ [zoz~{ fg bjno{ -n,`, ‑bl gnnjdokc―! ‑{~debzznj―! ‑tninkznj―"
Jnxnljbl` fl zmn oxxabkozbfl jfeobl zmn flzfaf`r lnnj{ zf gbz zf fzmnt
o{xnkz{,
Kfexotnj zf ztojbzbfloa jozo tnxtn{nlzozbfl{ -n,`, ~l{zt~kz~tnj gban{ ft
tnaozbfloa jozodo{n{" zmn odfwn%enlzbflnj bjno flzfaf`r mo{ zmn gfaafpbl`
dnlngbz{9?2=
․ Zmn kflknxz fg zmn bjno olj zmn tnaozbfl{ zf fzmnt bjno kflknxz{ otn
gfte~aoznj bl o eokmbln xtfkn{{ odan por
․ Fzmnt bjno kflknxz{ olj tnaozbfl{ kol no{bar n}znlj zmn flzfaf`r jozo
efjna,
․ Zmn {neolzbk tno{flbl` fg bjno kflknxz{ kol dn n}xtn{{nj fl jozo
anwna,
․ Ka~{zntbl` bjno{ dr {bebaotbzr ft tnaoznjln{{
?2> DNTLNT[%ANN! Z,3 MNLJANT! I,3 AO[[BAO! F,9 Zmn [neolzbk Pnd -488?"
mzzx9&&ppp,{kbnlzbgbkoentbkol,kfe&otzbkan,kge6bj5zmn%{neolzbk%pnd'xo`n5: S44,??,48??U?27 kg, MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?4?20 TBNJA! K, nz oa, -4882" xx,>%7
?2= TBNJA! K,3 Eor! L,3 GBLYNL! I,3 [ZOZMNA! [,3 CO^GEOL! W,3 CTKEOT! M, -4882" x,0
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 62/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
74
․ Oloarybl` kflztbd~zbfl{ olj kflztbd~zft{
․ Blgfteozbfl blzn`tozbfl olj jozo n}kmol`n oktf{{ bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{
․ Ozzokmbl` zf {fkboa lnzpftc{ olj gokbabzozbl` kfaaodftozbfl
Gtfe o lfl%znkmlbkoa wbnp flzfaf`bn{ otn clfpanj`n do{n{! pmbkm {zftn
clfpanj`n fg o kntzobl jfeobl bl o gfte~ab{nj {zt~kz~tn,?22
Zmn gfteoab{e{ ~{nj zf jn{ktbdn flzfaf`bn{ pbaa dn f~zablnj lfp,
Flzfaf`r Jn{ktbxzbfl Aol`~o`n{
Flzfaf`r jn{ktbxzbfl aol`~o`n{ jngbln gfteoab{e{! pmbkm otn ~{nj zf
jn{ktbdn flzfaf`bn{, O pmfan tol`n fg flzfaf`r jn{ktbxzbfl aol`~o`n{ b{owobaodan fl zmn pnd, Zmn ef{z bexftzolz zf enlzbfl b{ zmn Tn{f~tkn
Jn{ktbxzbfl Gtoenpftc -TJG"! pmbkm {mf~aj dn jngblnj lfp9
‑Zmn Tn{f~tkn Jn{ktbxzbfl Gtoenpftc b{ o gfteoa aol`~o`n zf jn{ktbdn
{zt~kz~tnj blgfteozbfl, Zmtf~`m TJG oxxabkozbfl{ {mf~aj dn odan zf
n}kmol`n jozo pbzmf~z af{bl` bz{ enolbl`,― 488
Bl ?222 zmn Pftj Pbjn Pnd Kfl{ftzb~e -P;K " jngblnj TJG ftb`bloaar o{ o
enzojozo {zoljotj! pmbkm mnaxnj zf ollfzozn pnd{bzn{ pbzm {zt~kz~tnj
enzojozo,48?
Zfjor TJG nlodan{ oxxabkozbfl{ zf n}kmol`n jozo bl blgfteozbfl {r{zne{
pbzmf~z af{bl` zmn ftb`bloa enolbl` fg zmn jozo,484
Pmban {zoljotj{! abcn TJG ! mo{ `oblnj fl bexftzolkn gft blgfteozbfl
{r{zne{ zmn oxxabkozbfl otno{ gft {neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ mown dnnl n}znljnj
j~tbl` zmn ao{z rnot{, Ol fwntwbnp fl oxxabkozbfl{ zmoz otn ~{bl` {neolzbk
znkmlfaf`bn{ {mf~aj dn `bwnl ln}z,
?22 kg, MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?4488 MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,?>48? kg, MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,;>
484 kg, MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R, -488=" x,;>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 63/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
7;
Oxxabkozbfl Otno{ fg [neolzbk Znkmlfaf`bn{
[neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ otn k~ttnlzar ~{nj bl jbggntnlz oxxabkozbfl otno{, Zmn
ef{z bexftzolz fln{ {mf~aj dn f~zablnj mntn,
Bl znkmlbkoa clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz {r{zne{! abcn OXF[JAN ! {neolzbk
znkmlfaf`bn{ otn ~{nj zf {~xxftz clfpanj`n%pftcnt{ -{nn kmoxznt ;,;" dr
zmnbt nwntrjor pftc xtfkn{{n{ zf nlmolkn zmn xtfj~kzbwbzr,48;
[neolzbk znkmlfaf`bn{ otn zmn kftn znkmlfaf`bn{ fg zmn lnp `nlntozbfl fg
zmn Pftaj Pbjn Pnd, Zbe%Dntlnt{ Ann‒{ wb{bfl fg zmn [neolzbk Pnd b{ o{
gfaafp{9
‑Zmn [neolzbk Pnd b{ lfz o {nxotozn Pnd d~z ol n}znl{bfl fg zmn k~ttnlz
fln! bl pmbkm blgfteozbfl b{ `bwnl pnaa%jngblnj enolbl`! dnzznt nlodabl`
kfex~znt{ olj xnfxan zf pftc bl kffxntozbfl, S ‧ U Eokmbln{ dnkfen e~km
dnzznt odan zf xtfkn{{ olj $~ljnt{zolj$ zmn jozo zmoz zmnr entnar jb{xaor oz
xtn{nlz,― 48:
‑Zmn {neolzbk pnd xtfwbjn{ o kfeefl gtoenpftc zmoz oaafp{ jozo zf dn
{motj olj tn~{nj oktf{{ oxxabkozbfl! nlzntxtb{n olj kfee~lbzr df~ljotbn{,
S ‧
U Zmn {neolzbk pnd b{ do{nj fl zmn tn{f~tkn jn{ktbxzbfl gtoenpftc
-TJG",― 48>
Zmn xotojb`e kmol`n gtfe zmn k~ttnlz Pnd 4,8 zf zmn [neolzbk Pnd jfn{
lfz toxbjar fkk~t3 tozmnt xtfinkz{ abcn zmn Ablcnj Fxnl Jozo -AFJ" xtfinkz
nl{~tn zmn kfl{zolz xtf`tn{{ fg zmn kmol`n, Zmn Ablcnj Fxnl Jozo xtfinkz
x~t{~n{ zmn `foa fg eocbl` jozo dnzznt okkn{{bdan fl zmn pnd olj zmntngftn
x~dab{mn{ wotbf~{ fxnl jozo{nz{ bl TJG gfteoz fl zmn pnd olj blzntablc{
zmn{n jozo{nz{, Zmn tn{~az b{ koaanj zmn Ablcnj Fxnl Jozo kaf~j ! pmbkm b{ o
48; kg, ABLJ[ZONJZ! [,3 ANR! Z,3 EORNT! M, -488>" x,?48: DNTLNT[%ANN! Z,3 MNLJANT! I,3 AO[[BAO! F,9 Zmn [neolzbk Pnd -488?"
mzzx9&&ppp,{kbnlzbgbkoentbkol,kfe&otzbkan,kge6bj5zmn%{neolzbk%pnd'xo`n54 S44,??,48??U48> P;K [neolzbk Pnd -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,p;,ft &̀488?&{p& S84,?8,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 64/80
; Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz
7:
kfl{zolzar `tfpbl`! gtnn okkn{{bdan clfpanj`n do{n zmoz kflzobl{ fwnt zmbtzr%
fln dbaabfl blzntablcnj TJG ztbxan{ odf~z wotbf~{ jfeobl{,487
487 Ablcnj Fxnl Jozo -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,p;,ft`&pbcb&[pnfB@&Zo{cGftkn{&Kfee~lbzrXtfinkz{&Ablcbl`FxnlJozo
S8=,?8,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 65/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
7>
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
Bl kmoxznt > o dnlkmeotcbl` {z~jr fl bllfwozbfl xaozgfte{ pbaa dn
okkfexab{mnj, Bl ftjnt zf `bwn zmn blzntn{znj tnojnt ol fwntwbnp fl zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ zmb{ kmoxznt {mf~aj xtfwbjn zmn zmnftnzbkoa do{b{ gft
zmn dnlkmeotcbl` {z~jr, Bl zmb{ kmoxznt zmn dnlkmeotcbl` znte pbaa dn
blztfj~knj olj zmn wotbf~{ zrxn{ fg dnlkmeotcbl` pbaa dn f~zablnj, Gbloaar! o
`nlntbk dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ pbaa dn blztfj~knj,
Nwntr kfexolr {mf~aj dn tnojr zf zocn zmn fxxftz~lbzr zf anotl gtfe fzmnt{,
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ o enzmfj gft kflzbl~f~{ bextfwnenlz olj {mf~aj dn
~ljnt{zffj o{ kmolkn gft kmol`n, Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ o enzmfj fl mfp
kfexolbn{ kol anotl gtfe n}xntbnlkn{ gtfe fzmnt blj~{ztbn{! kfexnzbzft{ ft
jnxotzenlz{ bl ftjnt zf blktno{n nggbkbnlkr,480
:,? Kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg Dnlkmeotcbl`
Xbn{cn jngbln{ zmn gfaafpbl` kmotokzntb{zbk{ fg dnlkmeotcbl`948=
․
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfexotb{fl․ Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfaankzbl` olj xtfkn{{bl` blgfteozbfl
․ Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kmol`n
․ Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfee~lbkozbfl
․ Eno{~tnenlz%! kfexotb{fl olj xf{bzbflbl` o{xnkz{
․ Anotlbl` o{xnkz{
Zmn kmotokzntb{zbk{ pbaa dn f~zablnj bl jnzoba lfp,
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfexotb{fl
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ do{nj fl zmn xtblkbxan fg kfexotb{fl, Bz jnoa{ pbzm zmn
q~olzbzozbwn olj q~oabzozbwn kfexotb{fl fg oz ano{z zpf fdinkz{, Bl zmn
q~oabzozbwn kfexotb{fl l~ednt{ -n,`, tnwnl~n! eotcnz {motn! kfexolr {byn!
nzk," otn jnznteblnj olj {nz bl tnaozbfl, Zmn q~oabzozbwn kfexotb{fl
480 kg, ENRNT! I, -?227" x,B]
48= kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" xx,?>%?2
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 66/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
77
jnzntebln{ zmn kfttn{xfljnlkn fg gnoz~tn{! kmotokzntb{zbk{! xtfkn{{n{!
{ntwbkn{ olj xtblkbxan{,482
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfaankzbl` olj xtfkn{{bl` blgfteozbflGft nwntr kfexotb{fl blgfteozbfl b{ tnq~btnj, Tn{xnkzbwnar dnlkmeotcbl`
bexabn{ ol blgfteozbfl lnnj, Bl `nlntoa dnlkmeotcbl` b{ o {xnkbgbk zrxn fg
blgfteozbfl xtfkn{{bl` zmoz jnzntebln{ ftbnlzozbfl xfblz{! zmn ‑dnlkmeotc{―,
D~z ‑dnlkmeotc{― kol dn oa{f blzntxtnznj o{ xtf`tn{{bwn! jbggntnlz gtfe zmn
fpl xtokzbkn kfljbzbfl{! zffa{! xtfknj~tn{! jn{b`l xtblkbxan{! nzk, Zmn{n
‑dnlkmeotc{― otn koaanj ‑dn{z xtokzbkn{―,4?8
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kmol`n
Bz b{ lfz {~ggbkbnlz zf clfp ‑dn{z xtokzbkn{― ft zot`nz woa~n{ olj otkmbwn zmne
bl zmn {mnag, Zmn gfk~{ fg dnlkmeotcbl` b{ zf pftc pbzm zmb{ blgfteozbfl olj
zmn jntbwozbfl fg oxxtfxtbozn kfl{nq~nlkn{ gft zmn fpl kfexolr, Zmn
ft`olb{nj {notkm gft tozbfloa {fa~zbfl{ olj enzmfj{ b{ o eoift kmotokzntb{zbk
fg dnlkmeotcbl`,4??
Dnlkmeotcbl` b{ kfee~lbkozbfl
Zmb{ kmotokzntb{ozbfl fg dnlkmeotcbl` b{ zf dn tnoj bl kfli~lkzbfl pbzm zmn
odfwn%enlzbflnj gnoz~tn{, Gbt{z! bz b{ lnkn{{otr zf kfee~lbkozn zmn lnnj gft
kflzbl~f~{ bextfwnenlz dr dnlkmeotcbl` bl zmn kfexolr, [nkflj! zmn
kfaankzbfl fg blgfteozbfl kol dn okkfexab{mnj dr jbtnkz kfee~lbkozbfl -n,`,
{~twnr{" pbzm zmn dnlkmeotcnj kfexolbn{,
Eno{~tnenlz%! kfexotb{fl olj xf{bzbflbl` o{xnkz{
Zmn kfexotb{fl o{ xotz fg zmn dnlkmeotcbl` kanotar tnwnoa{ zmn blbzboa
{bz~ozbfl fg o kfexolr, Do{nj fl eno{~tnenlz{ olj kfexotb{fl pbzm zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` fdinkz{ bz dnkfen{ no{bnt zf xf{bzbfl fl zmn eotcnz, Zmntngftndnlkmeotcbl` ol{pnt{ zmn q~n{zbfl9 ‑Pmntn jf pn {zolj6―4?4
482 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,?44?8 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" xx,?4%?;4?? kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,?:
4?4 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,?>
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 67/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
70
Anotlbl` o{xnkz{
Dnko~{n fg zmn kfexotb{fl pbzm zmn dn{z oefl` zmn kfexnzbzbfl fg blj~{ztbn{
zmn xfznlzboa{ fg zmn fpl kfexolr otn tnwnoanj, Zmntngftn dnlkmeotcbl` b{
ol n}znl{bfl fg zmn blzntloa clfp%mfp dr bjnlzbgrbl` olj efjbgrbl`clfpanj`n fg fzmnt{, Zmn n{{nlkn fg dnlkmeotcbl` b{ zf tnkf`lb{n ~{ng~a
bllfwozbfl{ olj zmntngftn zmn oxxtfokm b{ lfz {nnl o{ bllfwozbwn,4?;
:,4 Dnlkmeotcbl` [~dinkz{ olj Zrxn{
Dnlkmeotcbl` blgfteozbfl! ‑dnlkmeotc{― ft ‑dn{z xtokzbkn{― kol ftb`bl gtfe
wotbf~{ {f~tkn{, Zmn {f~tkn{ otn clfpl o{ zmn dnlkmeotcbl` {~dinkz{, Zmn
gfaafpbl` dnlkmeotcbl` {~dinkz{ kol dn jb{zbl`~b{mnj94?:
․ K~{zfent{9 Zmn jrloebkoaar kmol`bl` lnnj{ fg zmn k~{zfent{
kfl{zbz~zn zot`nz ‑dnlkmeotc{―,
․ Kfexnzbzft{9 Okzbwbzbn{ fg zmn kfexnzbzft{ bl zmn {oen blj~{ztr olj
zmn jnzntbftozbfl fg o kfexolr‒{ {bz~ozbfl fgznl ztb``nt zmn
dnlkmeotcbl`, Zm~{ zmn kfexnzbzbfl b{ zmn {~dinkz gft zmn
dnlkmeotcbl`,
․ Kfexolbn{ gtfe fzmnt blj~{ztbn{9 Fzmnt blj~{ztbn{ eor mown zmn
{oen kmoaanl`n{ d~z fzmnt eftn bllfwozbwn {fa~zbfl{, Zmntngftn
{fa~zbfl{ fg kfexolbn{ fg fzmnt blj~{ztbn{ otn zmn {~dinkz gft zmn
dnlkmeotcbl`,
Do{nj fl zmn odfwn%enlzbflnj {~dinkz{ zmtnn zrxn{ fg dnlkmeotcbl` kol dn
jb{zbl`~b{mnj94?>
․ Blzntloa dnlkmeotcbl`
․ N}zntloa dnlkmeotcbl` -Kfexnzbzft dnlkmeotcbl`"․ G~lkzbfloa dnlkmeotcbl`
Zmn dnlkmeotcbl` zrxn{ otn f~zablnj bl jnzoba lfp,
4?; kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,?04?: kg, ENRNT! I, -?227" xx,;:%;=
4?> kg, COTA×G! D,3 ×[ZDAFE! [, -?22:" x,;=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 68/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
7=
Blzntloa dnlkmeotcbl`
Zmn blzntloa dnlkmeotcbl` gfk~{n{ fl zmn kfexotb{fl olj oloar{b{ fg
enzmfj{! xtfkn{{n{! cnr gb`~tn{! nzk, bl{bjn zmn kfexolr ft `tf~x fg
kfexolbn{ -n,`, jnxotzenlz{! gokbabzbn{! kf{z knlztn{! nzk,", Bz b{ pnaa {~bznj gft `afdoaar fxntozbl` nlzntxtb{n{ pbzm wotbf~{ {bzn{ olj o pbjn {xnkzt~e fl
xtfj~kz{ olj {ntwbkn{,4?7
N}zntloa dnlkmeotcbl` -Kfexnzbzft dnlkmeotcbl`"
Zmn n}zntloa dnlkmeotcbl` gfk~{n{ fl zmn enzmfj{! xtfkn{{n{! {ntwbkn{
nzk, fg zmn jbtnkz kfexnzbzft{ fl zmn eotcnzxaokn, Bz {mfp{ zmn xf{bzbfl fl zmn
eotcnz kfexotnj zf zmn kfexnzbzbfl olj ktnozn{ ztol{xotnlkr odf~z zmn
k~ttnlz {bz~ozbfl,4?0
G~lkzbfloa dnlkmeotcbl`
Zmn g~lkzbfloa dnlkmeotcbl` kfexotn{ olj oloar{n{ enzmfj{! xtfkn{{n{!
{ntwbkn{ nzk, fg kfexolbn{ zmoz otn fxntozbl` fl jbggntnlz eotcnz{ olj otn
lfz jbtnkz kfexnzbzft{, Zmn `foa b{ zf bjnlzbgr bllfwozbwn {fa~zbfl{ gtfe
kfexolbn{ pbzm {bebaot kmoaanl`n{ olj ojoxz ft efjbgr zmn {fa~zbfl{ gft zmn
kfexolr, Lnp bllfwozbwn {fa~zbfl{ otn eftn abcnar zmnl bl zmn fzmnt odfwn%
enlzbflnj dnlkmeotcbl` zrxn{, 4?=
Zmn ojwolzo`n{ olj jb{ojwolzo`n{ fg zmn zmtnn odfwn%enlzbflnj
dnlkmeotcbl` zrxn{ otn {mfpl bl Zodan 4,
Zrxn Ojwolzo`n{ Jb{ojwolzo`n{
Blzntloa dnlkmeotcbl` ․ Kfaankzbl`
blgfteozbfl b{
tnaozbwnar no{r
․ @ffj tn{~az{ gft jbwnt{bgbnj
f~z{zoljbl`
kfexolbn{
․ Abebznj wbnpbl`
ol`an
․ Blzntloa xtni~jbkn{
4?7 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" xx,:4%::4?0 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,:>
4?= kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" xx,:>%:0
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 69/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
72
N}zntloa
dnlkmeotcbl`
․ Tnanwolz d~{bln{{
blgfteozbfl
․ Xtfj~kz{ &xtfkn{{n{
kfexotodan
․ Mb`m okknxzolkn
․ ^lbq~n xf{bzbflbl`
fl zmn eotcnz
․ Kfaankzbl`
blgfteozbfl b{
xotzboaar motj․ Tb{c zf d~{bln{{
ftbnlznj kfxrbl`
G~lkzbfloa
dnlkmeotcbl`
․ Tnaozbwnar mb`m
xfznlzboa zf gblj
bllfwozbwn {fa~zbfl{․ Nltbkmenlz fg zmn
bjno {xnkzt~e
․ Tnaozbwnar motj zf
efjbgr {fa~zbfl{
․ Ot`~enlz o`obl{z9Kfexotodbabzr
․ Zben kfl{~ebl`
oloar{b{
Zodan 49 Ojwolzo`n{ olj jb{ojwolzo`n{ fg dnlkmeotcbl` zrxn{4?2
Zmn eno{~tnenlz olj kfexotb{fl fg enztbk{ b{ xtbeotbar bexftzolz bl zmn
blzntloa dnlkmeotcbl`! pmban zmn anotlbl` o{xnkz{ otn {nkflj, Zmn g~lkzbfloa
dnlkmeotcbl` b{ xtbeotbar gfk~{bl` fl anotlbl` gtfe fzmnt kfexolbn{! pmbanzmn eno{~tnenlz olj kfexotb{fl fg enztbk{ b{ {nkflj, Bl zmn n}zntloa
dnlkmeotcbl` dfzm o{xnkz{! zmn eno{~tbl`% olj zmn anotlbl` o{xnkz{ otn
nq~oaar bexftzolz,
:,; Zmn Dnlkmeotcbl` Xtfkn{{
Zmn dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ b{ o {zt~kz~tnj enzmfj zmoz jn{ktbdn{ zmn
okzbwbzbn{ olj tnaozbfl{ dnzpnnl okzbfl{ bl dnlkmeotcbl`, Do{bkoaar zmnxtfkn{{ kol dn {zt~kz~tnj bl ol oloar{b{% olj ol bexanenlzozbfl xmo{n, Zmn
oloar{b{ xmo{n jnoa{ pbzm zmn jnznteblozbfl fg zmn fxzbeb{ozbfl xfznlzboa{ fg
zmn dnlkmeotcbl` {~dinkz, [~d{nq~nlzar zmn bexanenlzozbfl fg lnp
kflknxz{! fdzoblnj gtfe zmn oloar{b{! b{ okkfexab{mnj, Zmn jnzobanj xmo{n{
olj okzbwbzbn{ fg zmn dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ otn {zt~kz~tnj jbggntnlzar bl zmn
4?2 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,:=
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 70/80
: Dnlkmeotcbl`
08
abzntoz~tn, O~zmft{ ef{zar jnxbkz zmn l~ednt! jn{ktbxzbfl olj {nq~nlkn fg
{bl`an okzbwbzbn{ olj xmo{n{ jbggntnlzar,448
Gft zmb{ zmn{b{ o dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ do{nj fl Enrnt {mf~aj dn ~{nj -{nnGb`~tn ?8",
Gb`~tn ?89 Zmn dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{44?
Zmn dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{ {zotz{ pbzm zmn bjnlzbgbkozbfl fg xfznlzboa{ olj zmn
jngblbzbfl fg dnlkmeotcbl` ktbzntbo, [~d{nq~nlzar zmtf~`m ol blzntloa oloar{b{
fg zmn d~{bln{{ zmn blbzboa {bz~ozbfl b{ eojn ztol{xotnlz, Zmn okz~oa oloar{b{
fg zmn dnlkmeotcbl` {~dinkz{ b{ gfaafpbl`, Zmntndr blgfteozbfl gtfe zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` fdinkz{ okkftjbl` zf zmn jngblnj ktbzntbo b{ fdzoblnj zmtf~`m
xtbeotr olj {nkfljotr tn{notkm olj zmn xntgfteolkn fg zmn dnlkmeotcbl`
fdinkz b{ oloar{nj, Zmtf~`m ol nwoa~ozbfl fg zmn fdzoblnj jozo ‑dn{zxtokzbkn{― olj ‑dn{z xntgftent{― otn jnznteblnj olj zmn `ox zf zmn
kfexnzbzbfl b{ eojn ztol{xotnlz, Do{nj fl zmn dnlkmeotcbl` tn{~az{ ol
okzbfl xaol gft zmn d~{bln{{ b{ jntbwnj kflzoblbl` tnq~btnj okzbfl{ zf kaf{n
zmn `ox zf zmn kfexnzbzbfl, Zmn kmol`n zot`nz{ otn jngblnj olj zmn okzbfl{
otn xtbftbzb{nj, Gbloaar kflknxz{ otn jnwnafxnj olj zmn lnkn{{otr okzbfl{ otn
bexanenlznj bl zmn fxntozbfloa xtokzbkn, Ogznt zmn bexanenlzozbfl zmn
kflzbl~f~{ eflbzftbl` fl zmn bexokz fg zmn {nz okzbfl{ {zotz{,444
Zmn xaollbl` olj zmn blzntloa oloar{b{! o{ pnaa o{ zmn jb{k~{{bfl fg zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` oloar{b{ otn okkfexab{mnj bl znoe{, Zmntngftn jnjbkoznj
nexafrnn{ pbzm lnkn{{otr n}xntzb{n {mf~aj dn blzn`toznj blzf zmn
dnlkmeotcbl` xtfkn{{,44;
448 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" x,:244? kg, ENRNT! I, -?227" x,?;444 kg, XBN[CN! T, -?22>" xx,>4%>:
44; kg, ENRNT! I, -?227" x,?;=
Bjnlzbkozbfl fgxfznlzboa{ olj
tnanwolzdnlkmeotcbl`
ktbzntbo
Fdzoblbl` tnanwolzblgfteozbfl odf~zzmn d~{bln{{ oljjnln zmn blbzboa
{zozn
Bjnlzbkozbfl fgdnlkmeotc{ gft zmn
jnlnj ktbzntbo
Jb{k~{{bfl fgjnznteblnj
dnlkmeotc{ oljjntbwbl` okzbfl{
Kflknxzjnwnafxenlz oljbexanenlzozbfl fg
okzbfl{
Dnlkmeotc xaollbl` Dnlkmeotc oloar{b{ Dnlkmeotc bexanenlzozbfl
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 71/80
??2
Ab{z fg Tngntnlkn{
DFTLNEOLL! E,3 [OEENT! E9 4884, Olpnlj~l`{ftbnlzbntzn{
Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz ‛ Ol{êzyn ~lj Goaa{z~jbnl o~{ jnt dnztbndabkmnl ~lj
~lbwnt{bzêtnl Xto}b{, Pbn{dojnl9 J^W! xx,>%?=
DTOL[GFTJ! I,9 4888, Mfp xnfxan anotl9 Dtobl! eblj! n}xntbnlkn olj
{kmffa, Po{mbl`zfl9 Lozbfloa Okojner Xtn{{,
KMN[DTF^@M M,9 488;, Fxnl bllfwozbfl ‛ Zmn lnp Bexntozbwn gft
Ktnozbl` olj Xtfgbzbl` gtfe Znkmlfaf`r, Df{zfl9 Motwotj D~{bln{{ Tnwbnp
Xtn{{
KMN[DTF^@M M,9 4887, Fxnl D~{bln{{ Efjna{, Df{zfl9 Motwotj D~{bln{{
[kmffa Xtn{{
KMN[DTF^@M M,9 48??, Fxnl [ntwbkn{ Bllfwozbfl, [ol Gtolkb{kf9 If{{nr%
Do{{
KFFXNT T,@,9 ?228, [zo`n%@ozn [r{zne{9 O Lnp Zffa gft Eolo`bl` Lnp Xtfj~kz{, Bl9 D~{bln{{ Mftbyfl{ Eo`oybln! Wfa, Eor%I~ln
JN[F^YO! C,9 488;, Dottbnt{ zf nggnkzbwn ~{n fg clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz
{r{zne{ bl {fgzpotn nl`blnntbl` , Kfee~lbkozbfl{ fg zmn OKE! Wfa, :7-?"
xx,22‛?8?,
JBZYNA! D, nz oa,9 4880, @t~ljao`nl jn{ Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz{, Bl9 Jo{
Xto}b{moljd~km Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz! njbzft9 Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz Gft~e!Wntao` jnt Znkmlb{kmnl ^lbwnt{bzêz @toy! x,??
JTF[KMA! @,9 4884, Po{ anb{znl Blgfteozbfl{r{znen be
Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz6, Bl9 Olpnlj~l`{ftbnlzbntzn{ Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz ‛
Ol{êzyn ~lj Goaa{z~jbnl o~{ jnt dnztbndabkmnl ~lj ~lbwnt{bzêtnl Xto}b{!
Pbn{dojnl9 J^W! xx,44>%4:>
JT^KCNT! X,9 ?222, Clfpanj`n%Pftcnt Xtfj~kzbwbzr9 Zmn Db``n{z
Kmoaanl`n, Bl9 Koabgftlbo Eolo`nenlz Tnwbnp! Wfa, :?! xx,02%2:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 72/80
?48
NMTABKM! C,9 488;, Afkozbl` N}xntzb{n9 Jn{b`l b{{~n{ gft ol n}xntzb{n
afkozft {r{zne, Bl9 [motbl` n}xntzb{n9 Dnrflj clfpanj`n eolo`nenlz! EBZ
xtn{{! xx,?;0%?>=
NED[Z [,9 48?8, Cfexan}bzêz{eolo`nenlz be Gtflz Nlj wfl Bllfwozbfl,
XmJ zmn{b{, @toy ^lbwnt{bzr fg Znkmlfaf`r
NXXANT! E,I,9 488?, Eocbl` Clfpanj`n Wb{bdan Zmtf~`m Blztolnz
Clfpanj`n Eox{9 Kflknxz{! Nanenlz{! Ko{n{, Bl Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn ;:zm
Mopobb Blzntlozbfl Kflgntnlkn fl [r{zne [kbnlkn! 488? GOYNA%YOTOLJB! E,3 R^! N,9 488=, Flzfaf`r%Do{nj N}xntzb{n Gbljbl` , Bl
Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn 0zm Blzntlozbfloa Kflgntnlkn fl Xtokzbkoa O{xnkz{ fg
Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz! [xtbl`nt! xx,4;4‛4:;,
@OT@! L,3 PNDNT! B,9 488=, Xnt{floabynj! Blzntokzbwn Zo`
Tnkfeenljozbfl gft Gabkct, Bl xtfknnjbl`{ fg Tnk[r{ kflgntnlkn! Fkzfdnt
4;%4>! Ao~{olln! [pbzyntaolj
@O[[EOLL F, nz oa,9 48?8, Ktfpj{f~tkbl` ‛ Bllfwozbfl{eolo`nenlz ebz
[kmpoteblznaab`nly, Eñlkmnl9 Kota Mol{nt Wntao`
@O[[EOLL! F,! [^ZZNT! X,9 48??, Xto}b{pb{{nl Bllfwozbfl{eolo`nenlz
‛ Wfl jnt Bjnn y~e Eotczntgfa` , 4lj njbzbfl! Eñlkmnl9 Kota Mol{nt Wntao`
@^MO! T,3 EKKFFA! T,3 EBAANT! N,9 488;, [neolzbk [notkm, Bl
xtfknnnjbl`{ fg Tnk[r{ kflgntnlkn! Fkzfdnt 4;%4>! Ao~{olln! [pbzyntaolj
MODNTGNAALNT! T,9 ?22:, [r{zne{ Nl`blnntbl` ‛ Enzmfjbc ~lj Xto}b{, =zm njbzbfl! Yñtbkm9 Wntao` Blj~{ztbnaan Ft`olb{ozbfl
MOLR! N, O,9 488?, G÷tjnt~l` jnt Ctnozbwbzêz, Bl9 Moljd~km Cf`lbzbwn{
Ztoblbl`! @÷zzbl`nl9 Mf`tngn! xx,47?%42?
MBLZNTM^DNT! M, M,3 TNLYA! D,9 4884, Jbn [ztozn`b{kmn Jbenl{bfl jn{
Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz, Bl9 Olpnlj~l`{ftbnlzbntzn{ Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz ‛
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 73/80
?4?
Ol{êzyn ~lj Goaa{z~jbnl o~{ jnt dnztbndabkmnl ~lj ~lbwnt{bzêtnl Xto}b{,
Pbn{dojnl9 J^W! xx,?2%;;
MBZYANT! X,3 CT×ZY[KM! E,3 T^JFAXM! [,3 [^TN! R,9 488=, [neolzbk Pnd, Dntabl9 [xtbl`nt
MFPOTJ! T, O,9 ?2=2, Clfpanj`n Eox{, Bl9 Eolo`nenlz [kbnlkn! Wfa, ;>
-="! xx,28;%244
M×@A! E,3 @NEÑLJNL! M, @,9 488>, Eolo`nenlz wfl Znoe{ ‛
Zmnftnzb{kmn Cflynxzn ~lj Nexbtb{kmn Dng~ljn, ;zm njbzbfl! Pbn{dojnl9
@odant
COAZNLDNKC! I,9 48??, Ktfpjg~ljbl` ~lj [fkboa Xorenlz{, Eo{znt
Zmn{b{! @toy ^lbwnt{bzr fg Znkmlfaf`r
COTA×G! D,3 ×[ZDAFE! [,9 ?22:, Jo{ Dnlkmeotcbl` Cflynxz ‛
Pn`pnb{nt y~t [xbzynlanb{z~l` bl _~oabzêz ~lj Xtfj~czbwbzêz, Eñlkmnl9
Womanl
COZY! T,3 OAANL! I, O,9 ?2=4, Blwn{zb`ozbl` zmn Lfz Blwnlznj Mntn -LBM"
[rljtfen9 o affc oz zmn xntgfteolkn! znl~tn olj kfee~lbkozbfl xozzntl{ fg
>8 T'J xtfinkz `tf~x{, T'J Eolo`nenlz! Wfa,?4! xx,0%?2
CBE P,K,! EO^DFT@LN T,9 488>, Da~n Fknol [ztozn`r ‛ Mfp zf Ktnozn
^lkflzn{znj Eotcnz [xokn olj Eocn zmn Kfexnzbzbfl Bttnanwolz, Df{zfl9
Motwotj D~{bln{{ [kmffa Xtn{{
CBT[M! J,9 ?228, Zmn Wolkf~wnt [z~jbn{ bl Kf`lbzbwn [kbnlkn, xx,;:8%;7>Tn%b{{~nj F}gftj ^lbwnt{bzr Xtn{{, ?224,
CLBNÖ! E,9 4887, Ctnozbwbzêz{znkmlbcnl ‛ Enzmfjnl ~lj Ñd~l`nl, Eñlkmnl9
JZW
C×KC! O, E,9 488=, Nbl Ol{ozy y~t [znb`nt~l` jnt ctnozbwnl Anb{z~l` dnb jnt
Bjnnl`nlntbnt~l` ebzzna{ nbln{ kfex~znt`n{zñzyznl Ctnozbwbzêz{zffa{, XmJ
zmn{b{, ^lbwnt{bzr fg @toy
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 74/80
?44
AOLJO^NT! Z,3 GFAZY! X,3 AOMOE! J,9 ?22=, Ol Blztfj~kzbfl zf Aoznlz
[neolzbk Oloar{b{, Jb{kf~t{n Xtfkn{{n{! Wfa,4>! xx,4>2%4=:
ANDNT! E, nz oa,9 488:, [~xxftzbl` Bllfwozbfl pbzm Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz ,
Bl Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn >zm Blzntlozbfloa Kflgntnlkn fg zmn Gok~azr fg
Eolo`nenlz Cfxnt! Lfwnednt ?=%48 488:! Xftzftfy! [afwnlbo! xx,4>;%478
ABLJ[ZONJZ! [,3 ANR! Z,3 EORNT! M,9 488>, Blzn`toznj Pftcbl` olj
Anotlbl` pbzm OXF[JAN, @toy9 Clfp%Knlznt
EOBNT! T,3 MÊJTBKM! Z,9 488=, Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz [r{zne{, Bl9
Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz9 Kflknxz{! Enzmfjfaf`bn{! Zffa{ olj Oxxabkozbfl{!
Wfa~en 7! [ol Jbn`f9 B@B @afdoa xx,>:?%>>4
EOZMN[! O,9 488:, Gfac{flfebn{ ‛ Kffxntozbwn Kao{{bgbkozbfl olj
Kfee~lbkozbfl Zmtf~`m [motnj Enzojozo, ^lbwnt{bzr fg Baablfb{ ^tdolo%
Kmoexob`l
ENTWB[! K, D,3 TF[KM! N,9 ?2=?, Kozn`ftb{ozbfl fg Loz~toa Fdinkz{, Bl9
Oll~oa Tnwbnp fg X{rkmfaf`r, Wfa, ;4! x,=2%??>
ENRNT! I,9 ?227, Dnlkmeotcbl` ‛ [xbzynanb{z~l`nl j~km Antlnl wfl jnl
Dn{znl, [z~zz`otz9 [kmêggnt%Xfn{kmna
EFTTB[FL! X,3 TFDNTZ[! I,3 EBJ@ANR! J,9 488:, Zmn Loz~tn fg Anoj
^{nt{ olj Eno{~tnenlz fg Anojbl` Nj`n [zoz~{, Bl9 Tn{notkm Xfabkr! Wfa,
;;! xx,;>?%;74
LFTZM! C,9 ?22=, Pb{{nl{ftbnlzbntzn ^lzntlnmenl{gñmt~l` ‛
Pntz{km÷xg~l` j~tkm Pb{{nl, ?{z njbzbfl! Pbn{dojnl9 @odant Wntao`
F[DFTL! O, G,9 ?2>;, Oxxabnj Beo`blozbfl, Lnp Rftc9 [ktbdlnt‒{
F[DFTL! O, G,9 ?27;, Oxxabnj Beo`blozbfl, Xtblkbxan{ olj Xtfknj~tn{ fg
Ktnozbwn Zmblcbl`, Lnp Rftc9 [ktbdlnt‒{
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 75/80
?4;
XBN[CN! T,9 ?22>, Dnlkmeotcbl` bl jnt Xto}b{ ‛ Ntgfa`tnbkmn{ Antlnl wfl
gñmtnljnl ̂ lzntlnmenl, Aolj{dnt`&Ankm9 Efjntln Blj~{ztbn
XFTZNT! E, N,9 ?2=8, Kfexnzbzbwn [ztozn`r ‛ Znkmlbq~n{ gft Oloarybl`
Blj~{ztbn{ olj Kfexnzbzft{, Lnp Rftc9 Zmn Gtnn Xtn{{
XTFD[Z! @,3 TFEMOTJZ! C,9 ?22=, Do~{znbln jn{ Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz{9
Nbl xto}b{ftbnlzbntznt Ol{ozy, Bl9 Pbn{nam~dnt ' Xotzlnt9 Moljd~km Antlnljn
Ft`olb{ozbfl, ?{z njbzbfl, Tn%xtblznj9 Pbn{dojnl9 @odant! xx,?42%?:;
XTFD[Z! @, I, D,3 TO^D! [,3 TFEMOTJZ! C,9 488;, Pb{{nl eolo`nl ‛
Pbn ^lzntlnmenl bmtn pntzwfaa{zn Tn{{f~tkn fxzbeoa l~zynl, :,O~gao`n!
Pbn{dojnl9 @odant Wntao`
TNBKMPOAJ! T,3 XBAANT! G,9 4887, Blzntoczbwn Pntz{km÷xg~l` ‛ Fxnl
bllfwozbfl! Bljbwbj~oab{bnt~l` ~lj ln~n Gftenl jnt Otdnbz{`n{zoaz~l`! ?{z
njbzbfl! Pbn{dojnl9 @odant Wntao`
TBNJA! K,3 Eor! L,3 GBLYNL! I,3 [ZOZMNA! [,3 CO^GEOL! W,3 CTKEOT!
M,9 4882, Ol Bjno Flzfaf`r gft Bllfwozbfl Eolo`nenlz, Bl9 Blzntlozbfloa
If~tloa fl [neolzbk Pnd olj Blgfteozbfl [r{zne{! Wfa, >-:"! xx,?%?=
TBNENT! C,9 4880, Zmn Eotcnz gft N%Kfaaodftozbfl [r{zne{ ‛ Bjnlzbgbkozbfl
fg [r{zne Kao{{n{ ^{bl` Ka~{znt Oloar{b{, Bl9 Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn Gbgznnlzm
N~tfxnol Kflgntnlkn fl Blgfteozbfl [r{zne{, [z, @oaanl! [pbzyntaolj! I~ln
4880, xx,;:7%;>0,
[KMÊGNTENBNT! T,3 XO[KMCN! O,9 48??, ^{bl` Jfeobl Flzfaf`bn{ gft Gbljbl` N}xntz{ bl Kftxftozn Pbcb{, Bl Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn 0zm Blzntlozbfloa
Kflgntnlkn fl [neolzbk [r{zne{! [nxznednt 0%2! 48??! @toy! xx,7;%08
[KM^EXNZNT I,9 ?2?4, Zmnftbn jnt pbtz{kmogzabkmnl Nlzpbkca~l`, Anbxyb`9
Wntao` wfl J~lkcnt ' M~edafz
[NTWOZB^[! M,%@, ?2==, Lnp Wnlz~tn Eolo`nenlz, Pbn{dojnl9 @odant
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 76/80
?4:
[B@^TDI×TL[[FL! D,3 WOL YPFA! T,9 488=, Gabkct Zo` Tnkfeenljozbfl
do{nj fl Kfaankzbwn Clfpanj`n, Bl xtfknnjbl`{ fgz mn Pftaj Pbjn Pnd
Kflgntnlkn! Oxtba 4?%4>! Dnbibl`! Kmblo,
[F^C^X! K,9 488?, Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz ‛ Pb{{nl ypb{kmnl [zn~nt~l`
~lj [nad{zft`olb{ozbfl, Pbn{dojnl9 @odant
[ZNRWNT[! E3 @TBGGBZM[! Z,9 4880, Xtfdodbab{zbk Zfxbk Efjna{, Bl9
Moljdffc fg Aoznlz [neolzbk Oloar{b{! Lnp Int{nr 9 Ao~tnlkn Ntado~e
O{{fkbozn{! xx,:40%::7
ZOWOL@OTBOL J,! ANRXFAJ E,! L×AZBL@ C,! T×[NT E,9 488:, B{ n%
anotlbl` zmn [fa~zbfl gft Bljbwbj~oa Anotlbl`6, Bl9 Nankztflbk If~tloa fg n%
Anotlbl`! Wfa, 4-4"! xx,40;%4=8
ZMFE! L,9 ?2=8, @t~ljao`nl jn{ dnztbndabkmnl Bllfwozbfl{eolo`nenlz{!
4lj njbzbfl! Tn`nl{d~t`9 Xnznt Mol{znbl Wntao`
^TDOL! @,! WFL MBXXNA! N,9 ?2==! Anoj ^{nt Oloar{n{ gft zmn
Jnwnafxenlz fg Lnp Blj~{ztboa Xtfj~kz{! Bl9 Eolo`nenlz [kbnlkn! Wfa,
;:->"! xx,>72%>=4
WOM[! J,3 [KMÊGNT%C^LY! I,9 4888, Nblgñmt~l` bl jbn
Dnztbnd{pbtz{kmogz{anmtn ‛ Anmtd~km ebz Dnb{xbnanl ~lj Cflztfaagto`nl, 4,
O~gao`n! [z~zz`otz9 [kmêggnt%Xfn{kmna
WFL MBXXNA! N,9 ?2=7, Anoj ^{nt{ ‛ O {f~tkn fg Lfwna Xtfj~kz Kflknxz{!
Bl9 Eolo`nenlz [kbnlkn! Wfa, ;4-0"! xx,02?%=8>
PNL@NT! N,9 ?22=, Kfee~lbzbn{ fg xtokzbkn9 anotlbl`! enolbl` olj
bjnlzbzr, Koedtbj`n ^lbwnt{bzr Xtn{{
PBACN! M, ?22=, [r{zneozb{kmn{ Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz, [z~zz`otz9 A~kb~{ '
A~kb~{! x,7:
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 77/80
?4>
PBAAGFTZ! T,9 488?, Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz ebz Bllfwozbfl{jbn{zanb{z~l`nl ‛
N}zntln Anb{z~l`{xfznlzboan y~t [zêtc~l` jnt Pb{{nl{do{b{, Pbn{dojnl9
Jn~z{kmnt ̂ lbwnt{bzêz{%Wntao`,
PBAAGFTZ! T, nz oa,9 4880, KtnozbwbzrHPftc ‛ Ctnozbwn M÷km{zanb{z~l`nl
oe Pb{{nl{otdnbz{xaozy o~g Do{b{ ln~n{znt Ntcnllzlb{{n jnt
@nmbtlgft{km~l`, Ookmnl9 [mocnt Wntao`
PFMBLY! I, P,9 4882, Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz, Ankz~tn lfzn{ fg zmn
Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz kf~t{n, Bl{zbz~zn fg Blj~{ztboa Eolo`nenlz olj
Bllfwozbfl Tn{notkm! @toy ^lbwnt{bzr fg Znkmlfaf`r
PFMBLY I, P,9 48??, Dnztbndabkmn{ Bllfwozbfl{eolo`nenlz,
BLJ^[[KTBXZ 48??! Bl{zbz~zn fg Blj~{ztboa Eolo`nenlz olj Bllfwozbfl
Tn{notkm! @toy ^lbwnt{bzr fg Znkmlfaf`r,
YNBANT! E,3 [KMO^NT! D,9 48??, Ojfxzbfl! Efzbwozbfl olj [~kkn{{ Gokzft{
fg [fkboa Enjbo gft Znoe Kfaaodftozbfl bl [EN‒{, Bl9 Xtfknnjbl`{ fg zmn ??zm
Blzntlozbfloa Kflgntnlkn fl Clfpanj`n Eolo`nenlz olj Clfpanj`n
Znkmlfaf`bn{! @toy! [nxznednt 48??,
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 78/80
?47
Pndablc{
OAANL! K,9 Ztokbl` zmn nwfa~zbfl fg {fkboa {fgzpotn -488:"
mzzx9&&ppp,abgnpbzmoaoktbzr,kfe&488:&?8& ztokbl`VzmnVnwf,mzea S8=,?8,48??U
DNTLNT[%ANN! Z,3 MNLJANT! I,3 AO[[BAO! F,9 Zmn [neolzbk Pnd -488?"
mzzx9&&ppp,{kbnlzbgbkoentbkol,kfe&otzbkan,kge6bj5zmn%{neolzbk%pnd'xo`n5:
S44,??,48??U
JDxnjbo -48??"
mzzx9&&jdxnjbo,ft` S87,?8,48??U
JDxnjbo [xfzab`mz -48??"
mzzx9&&jdxnjbo,ft`&{xfzab`mz S87,?8,48??U
J~dabl Kftn Enzojozo -4882"
mzzx9&&j~dablkftn,ft`& S?4,82,48??U
Nzmntxoj -48??"mzzx9&&nzmntxoj,ft`& S4?,82,48??U
Nzmntxoj Blzn`tozbfl -48??"
mzzx9&&jt~xoa,ft`&xtfinkz&nzmntxoj S48,??,48??U
Gokndffc -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,gokndffc,kfe S?2,??,48??U
@ff`an Jfk{ -48??"
mzzx{9&&jfk{,`ff`an,kfe& S4?,82,48??U
@ff`an Ztol{aozft -48??"
mzzx9&&ztol{aozn,`ff`an,kfe& S48,??,48??U
Mrxntpown -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,mrxntpown,oz& S?2,??,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 79/80
?40
Ao{{f Xtfinkz -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,ao{{fxtfinkz,ft`& S?=,82,48??U
Ablc4PfJ -48??"
mzzx9&&ablc4pfj,ifolln~e,oz& S4;,82,48??U
Ablcnj Fxnl Jozo -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,p;,ft`&pbcb&[pnfB@&Zo{cGftkn{&Kfee~lbzrXtfinkz{&Ablcbl`Fxnl
Jozo S8=,?8,48??U
Lozbfloa Blgfteozbfl [zoljotj{ Ft`olb{ozbfl -488:"mzzx9&&ppp,lb{f,ft`&x~dabkozbfl{&xtn{{&^ljnt{zoljbl`Enzojozo,xjg
S?4,82,48??U
LBNA[NL! I, -4887"
mzzx9&&ppp,~{nbz,kfe&oantzdf}&xotzbkbxozbflVblnq~oabzr,mzea S84,82,48??U
FNKJ % Jozo olj Enzojozo Tnxftzbl` olj Xtn{nlzozbfl Moljdffc -4880 "
mzzx9&&ppp,fnkj,ft`&jozofnkj&:7&?0&;070?>0:,xjg S?2,??,48??U
Fxnl Koaob{ -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,fxnlkoaob{,kfe& S?;,82,48??U
_~fto -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,q~fto,kfe S?2,??,48??U
Tn{f~tkn Jn{ktbxzbfl Gtoenpftc -488:"
mzzx9&&ppp,p;,ft`&TJG& S8=,?8,48??U
[neolzbk [bebaotbzr -48?8"
mzzx9&&jt~xoa,ft`&xtfinkz&{neolzbkV{bebaotbzr S8>,?8,48??U
[mbl`an{ -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,a~kbjbeo`blozbfl,kfe&daf`&48?8&?4&?0&pmoz{%o%{mbl`an%bl%a~knln%
xotaolkn& S87,?8,48??U
8/2/2019 Identification of Development Potentials Based on a Benchmarking Study for an Innovation Platform
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/identification-of-development-potentials-based-on-a-benchmarking-study-for 80/80
[mbl`abl` ‛ Lnot J~xabkozn Jnznkzbfl -4882"
mzzx9&&xmxbt,kfe&{mbl`abl`%lnot%j~xabkozn%jnznkzbfl S8>,?8,48??U
[zokcFwntgafp -48??"
mzzx9&&{zokcfwntgafp,kfe& S4;,82,48??U
[ZTFNDN! P,3 LBI[ZOJ! O,9 Pot~e Dtobl{zftebl` bl @t~xxnl Ctnozbwbzêz
wntmbljntz -4887"
mzzx9&&ppp,{zol`a,n~&xonjo`f`bc&otzbcna&dtobl{zftebl`,{mzea S?4,?8,48??U
ZOKCN! F, Zffa{ ~lj Ztnlj{ be Pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz -48?8"
mzzx9&&ppp,{abjn{motn,lnz&ft`g~n&zffa{%~lj%ztnlj{%be%pb{{nl{eolo`nenlz%
:>8:=74 S84,?8,48??U
Zmn Oxf{jan Oxxtfokm zf {nag%jbtnkznj pftc%blzn`toznj anotlbl` -4887"
mzzx9&&ppp,oxf{jan,z~`toy,oz&enjbo&e~azbenjbo&gban{&zmnVoxf{janVoxxtfokmVz
fV{nagVjbtnkznjVpftcVblzn`toznjVanotlbl` S8=,?8,48??U
Zmn [neolzbk Pnd ‛ O lnp gfte fg Pnd kflznlz zmoz b{ enolbl`g~a zf
kfex~znt{ pbaa ~lano{m o tnwfa~zbfl fg lnp xf{{bdbabzbn{ -488?"
mzzx9&&kbzn{nnt},b{z,x{~,nj~&wbnpjfk&jfplafoj6jfb5?8,?,?,??>,2>=:'tnx5tnx
?'zrxn5xjg S8=,?8,48??U
Pnd{bzn @tojnt -48??"
mzzx9&&pnd{bzn`tojnt,kfe& S8?,8=,48??U
P;K [neolzbk Pnd -48??"
mzzx9&&ppp,p;,ft`&488?&{p& S84,?8,48??U