55
PASSIVE HOUSE in PHFA PRE-APPLICATION MEETING, OCTOBER 1, 2014 Tim McDonald, Temple University, Onion Flats, Philadelphia Laura Nettleton, Thoughtful Balance, Pittsburgh PENNSYLVANIA

in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE in

PHFA PRE-APPLICATION MEETING, OCTOBER 1, 2014

Tim McDonald, Temple University, Onion Flats, Philadelphia Laura Nettleton, Thoughtful Balance, Pittsburgh

PENNSYLVANIA  

Page 2: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

Ed Mazria, Greenbuild Philly 2013

IECC  2009:  current  PA  code    IECC  2012:  current  Federal  code  IECC  2015:  closing  in  on  Net-­‐Zero  

PENNSYLVANIA  

BUILDING CODES in

Page 3: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

Title 24 legislation passed in 2009

Page 4: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

Title 24 legislation passed in 2009

AUSTIN  

BOULDER  

MASSACHUSETTS  

DELAWARE  

SEATTLE  

Page 5: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

Title 24 legislation passed in 2009 Principles for nearly Zero-Energy Buildings | 1

PRINCIPLES FOR NEARLY ZERO-ENERGY BUILDINGSPaving the way for effective implementation of policy requirements

BRUSSELS  2014    

Page 6: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

NET-ZERO-ENERGY-CAPABLE

Page 7: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

NET-ZERO-ENERGY-CAPABLE

A building must GENERATE

ALL it needs to survive

Page 8: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

16’

40’

1900 sf home 39,000 kWh/yr $360.00/month

Page 9: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

71’

40’

1900 sf home 39,000 kWh/yr $360.00/month 2832 sf roof

Page 10: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

1900 sf home 8550 kWh/yr 615 sf roof

40’

16’ e 80% REDUCTION

Page 11: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

4.5 kWh/sf/yr 8550 kWh/yr 615 sf roof

40’

16’ e 80% REDUCTION

Page 12: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

ROOF METRIC PH METRIC

(Site Energy) (Site Energy)

Consumption Production

4.5 kWh/sf/yr 4.5 kWh/sf/yr

40’

16’

Page 13: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 14: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE STRATEGIES

ENVELOPE AIR TIGHT AND SUPER INSULATED

SOLAR ORIENTATION OPTIMIZE HEAT GAIN VENTILATION WITH HEAT RECOVERY

EFFICIENCY ENERGY SAVING APPLIANCE RENEWABLE ENERGY A VIABLE OPTION

Page 15: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 16: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE CRITERIA

4.5 kWh/sf/yr

Page 17: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE CRITERIA up to 10 points: PHFA

Page 18: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE CRITERIA up to 10 points: PHFA

“Up  to  10  points  may  be  awarded  to  those  developments  which  meet  Passive  House  CerGficaGon  (naGonally  or  

internaGonally)  for  energy  efficiency  (See  www.passivehouse.us    or

     hGp://www.passivehouseacademy.com/  for  addiMonal  guidance)    To  qualify  for  these  points,  the  applicaGon  must  include  pre-­‐cerGficaGon  from  a  Passive  House  organizaGon.    At  construcGon  compleGon,  all  required  third  party  test  results  and  verificaGons,  

including  blower  door  test  and  commissioning  reports,  must  be  submiTed  to  PHFA.”  

Page 19: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

PASSIVE HOUSE CRITERIA up to 10 points: PHFA

Pre-­‐  CERTIFICATION  

2. Budget reflecting PH design

1. PHPP: Passive House Planning Package -  PH energy model -  Must meet PH energy criteria

CERTIFICATION  1. Blower door test 2. 3rd party verifications, test, reports

Page 20: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

DEEP DIVE INTO ENERGY PERFORMANCE vs. PRESCRIPTIVE THIRD PARTY VERIFICATION COMMISSIONING FEWER CHECKLISTS

LEED VERSUS PASSIVE HOUSE COST & PROCESS

Page 21: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

LEED VERSUS PASSIVE HOUSE COST & PROCESS

NO ADDITIONAL COST FROM THE ARCHITECT UNLESS THEY ARE BUILDING THE ENERGY MODELS DESIGN- COST OF THE ENERGY MODEL TYPICALLY ABOUT 10% OF THE ARCHITECTURAL FEE CONSTRUCTION- COST NEUTRAL TO SLIGHTLY MORE IN HOUSES AS MUCH AS 10% THIRD PARTY- $3,000 TO $15,000 FOR PROJECTS RANGING IN SIZE FROM $250,000 TO $8,000,000

Wall$Short$Section$DetailIsotherm$view Infrared$view

U7$Factors

Wall7Slab$Section$Detail

Isotherm$view Infrared$view

U7$Factors

Page 22: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 23: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

YMCA BEFORE

Page 24: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 25: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

MCKEESPORT DOWNTOWN HOUSING $119 PER SF

Page 26: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 27: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

HEIDELBERG PROTOTYPE HOUSE $135 PER SF

Page 28: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 29: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 30: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

BELFIELD  TOWNHOMES  Philadelphia                3  –  1920  sf  5  bed  HUD,  SHP  funding  $130sf  hard  costs    

Page 31: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

Roof: R52.3 Wall: R33.6 Floor: 58.4 Window: .11 SHGC: .63

Page 32: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 33: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

0.6 ACH 50 PASSIVE HOUSE MAX

Page 34: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 35: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

START: APRIL 20, 2012

CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY: JULY 20, 2012

RECIPIENT OF THE

2014 INTERNATIONAL PASSIVE HOUSE AWARD

FIRST  CERTIFIED  PASSIVE  HOUSE  IN  PA    

2013

HONOR AWARD

Page 36: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

NORTH  PHILADELPHIA  HOUSING  PROJECT  

ENERGY STAR 3

Page 37: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

NORTH  PHILADELPHIA  HOUSING  PROJECT  

ENERGY STAR 3 to

PASSIVE HOUSE?

Page 38: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

NORTH  PHILADELPHIA  HOUSING  PROJECT  

ENERGY STAR 3 to

PASSIVE HOUSE?

SAME COST???????

Page 39: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

REVISED  SITE  DESIGN  

Page 40: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

REVISED  SITE  RENDERING  

Page 41: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

$180 /SQFT

Page 42: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

28  PASSIVE  HOUSE  UNITS  

$180 /SQFT

Page 43: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

28  PASSIVE  HOUSE  UNITS  

$180 /SQFT

$173 /SQFT

Page 44: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

STABLES, 2014: 27 Passive House, Modular and site-built townhomes

Page 45: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 46: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

MODU

LAR  

PASSIVE  HO

USE  

SITE-­‐BUILT  

PASSIVE  HO

USE  

ALTERE

D  FLOOR  PLAN

 

SITE-­‐BUILT  

TWO  LOTS  M

ERGE

D  NOT  PA

SSIVE  HO

USE  

SITE-­‐BUILT  

DIFFER

ENT  DE

VELO

PER  

NOT  PA

SSIVE  HO

USE  

BUT  SA

ME  EN

VELO

P  

Page 47: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 48: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 49: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

.41 ACH 50

FINAL AIRFLOW .49 ACH 50

Page 50: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 51: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 52: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

RIDGE  FLATS,  2015:  147  Passive  House,  Modular  rental  units  and  retail  

Page 53: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

007BIRDSEYE: LARGE SCALERIDGE  FLATS  2,  2016:  150  Passive  House,  Modular  rental  units  and  retail  

Page 54: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy
Page 55: in PENNSYLVANIA · 2016. 6. 23. · leed versus passive house cost & process no additional cost from the architect unless they are building the energy models design- cost of the energy

THANK

YOU

Tim McDonald, Temple University, Onion Flats, Philadelphia

[email protected] Laura Nettleton, Thoughtful Balance, Pittsburgh

[email protected]