289
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO EASTERN DIVISION THE NORTHEAST OHIO COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS, et al., Plaintiffs, vs. JON HUSTED, in his official capacity as Secretary of State of Ohio, et al., Defendants. CASE NO. 2:06-cv-896 Judge Algenon Marbley Magistrate Judge Terrence P. Kemp PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description P-1 2/19/16 Notice of Deposition of Ohio Secretary of State P-2 Eff. 2014 ORC § 3509.03 – 3509.07 – Absentee ballots P-3 Absentee ballot forms P-4 7/2/14 Directive 2014-18 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon Husted re: Absentee Voting P-5 9/5/14 Directive 2014-27 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon Husted re: Contacting Voters with Incomplete Absentee Ballot Identification Envelopes P-6 9/8/14 Email exchange between Brandi Seskes, and Dawn, Shelby County Board of Elections re: Directive 2014-27 P-7 10/30/14 021475 Email exchange among Gretchen Quinn, Pat McDonald and Matthew Damschroder re: challenged absentee ballot follow-up question Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 1 of 289 PAGEID #: 31180

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE … · 2 Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description P-8 2015 SOS-00250 – SOS-00285 Chapter 5 – Absentee Voting Directive 2015-27 – from Ohio

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO

EASTERN DIVISION

THE NORTHEAST OHIO COALITION

FOR THE HOMELESS, et al.,

Plaintiffs,

vs.

JON HUSTED, in his official capacity as

Secretary of State of Ohio, et al.,

Defendants.

CASE NO. 2:06-cv-896

Judge Algenon Marbley

Magistrate Judge Terrence P. Kemp

PLAINTIFFS’ THIRD AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1 2/19/16 Notice of Deposition of Ohio Secretary of State

P-2 Eff. 2014 ORC § 3509.03 – 3509.07 – Absentee ballots

P-3 Absentee ballot forms

P-4 7/2/14 Directive 2014-18 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon

Husted re: Absentee Voting

P-5 9/5/14 Directive 2014-27 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon

Husted re: Contacting Voters with Incomplete Absentee Ballot

Identification Envelopes

P-6 9/8/14 Email exchange between Brandi Seskes, and Dawn, Shelby County

Board of Elections re: Directive 2014-27

P-7 10/30/14 021475 Email exchange among Gretchen Quinn, Pat McDonald and

Matthew Damschroder re: challenged absentee ballot follow-up

question

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 1 of 289 PAGEID #: 31180

2

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-8 2015 SOS-00250 – SOS-

00285

Chapter 5 – Absentee Voting Directive 2015-27 – from Ohio

Election Official Manual

P-9 Eff 2014 ORC § 3505.181 – 3505.183 - Provisional ballots

P-10 Provisional Ballot forms

P-11 4/2/14 –

5/6/14

SOS-0047393 – SOS-

0047399

Email exchange between Secretary of State’s Office, Dana Chisnell

and voting advocacy rights groups re: Ohio provisional ballot

envelope

P-12 7/2/14 Directive 2014-20 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon

Husted re: determining the validity of provisional ballots

P-13 2014 2014 Provisional Ballot PowerPoint from SOS summer conference

P-14 5/11/15 SOS-0054339 Email to Mia Yaniko from Michele at Pickaway re: voter credit

P-15 2015 SOS-00286 – SOS-

00308

Chapter 6 – Provisional Voting Directive 2015-28 – from Ohio

Election Official Manual

P-16 6/5/14 021573 Email to Matthew Damschroder from Pat Wolfe re provisional

ballot outliers

P-17 Nov 2014 000993-001000 Absentee ballot summary spreadsheet for Nov 2014

P-18 Nov 2015 045551 Absentee ballot summary spreadsheet for Nov 2015

P-19 Nov. 2014 Provisional Ballot Report: November 4, 2014 General Election

P-20 Nov. 2015 045552 Provisional Ballot Report: November 3, 2015 General Election

P-21 Eff 1/25/16 O.A.C. Chapter 111:3-2 – Oversight of County Board

P-22 5/8/13 Directive 2013-08 to All County Boards of Elections, et al. from Jon

Husted, et al. re: ensuring a more accurate and efficient statewide

voter registration database

P-23 Chapter 8 – Canvassing the Vote Directive 2015-30 – from Ohio

Election Official Manual

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 2 of 289 PAGEID #: 31181

3

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-24 1/13/2013 Press Release from Secretary of State Husted Reminds Ohioans:

One Vote Matters

P-25 11/4/14 DEL-00315 – DEL-

00318

Delaware County Board Minutes

P-26 11/25/14 DEL-00319 – DEL-

00325

Delaware County Board Minutes

P-27 11/3/15 DEL-00326 – DEL-

00328

Delaware County Board Minutes

P-28 11/17/15 DEL-00329 – DEL-

00328

Delaware County Board Minutes

P-29 DEL-00017 – DEL-

00018

Voter packet for Jennifer Powell

P-30 DEL-00025 – DEL-

00026

Voter packet for Monica Andrews

P-31 DEL-00029 – DEL-

00030

Voter packet for Andrea Brocksmith

P-32 DEL-00027 – DEL-

00028

Voter packet for Michael Brocksmith

P-33 DEL-00009 – DEL-

00010

Voter packet for Jerome Drieserl

P-34 DEL-00007 – DEL-

00008

Voter packet for Melissa Kelley-Bean

P-35 DEL-00005 – DEL-

00006

Voter packet for Robert Owens

P-36 DEL-00003 – DEL-

00004

Voter packet for Ashley Pederson

P-37 DEL-00023 – DEL-

00024

Voter packet for Myrtie Black

P-38 DEL-00001 – DEL-

00002

Voter packet for Kristy Thomas

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 3 of 289 PAGEID #: 31182

4

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-39 DEL-00041 – DEL-

00042

Voter packet for Melissa Speert

P-40 DEL-00039 – DEL-

00040

Voter packet for Ronald Stuecher

P-41 DEL-00019 – DEL-

00020

Voter packet for Eric Swanson

P-42 DEL-00033 – DEL-

00034

Voter packet for Snkhemalayee Chau

P-43 DEL-00031 – DEL-

00032

Voter packet for Delphine Guanciale

P-44 DEL-00035 – DEL-

000136)

Voter packet for Lindsey Hopeck

P-45 DEL-00037 – DEL-

00038

Voter packet for Ullrich Mayeski

P-46 DEL-00013 – DEL-

00014

Voter packet for Dorman Smith

P-47 DEL-00011 – DEL-

00012

Voter packet for Robert Uhrig

P-48 DEL-00308,

DEL-00307,

DEL-00309

Voter packet for Carolyn Baldwin

P-49 DEL-00074,

DEL-00073,

DEL-00075

Voter packet for Julia Brosnan

P-50 DEL-00047,

DEL-00046,

DEL-00048

Voter packet for Margaret Cunningham

P-51 DEL-00098,

DEL-00097,

DEL-00099

Voter packet for Daniel Foertmeyer

P-52 DEL-00068,

DEL-00067,

DEL-00069

Voter packet for Mark Lima

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 4 of 289 PAGEID #: 31183

5

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-53 DEL-00071,

DEL-000070, DEL-

00072

Voter packet for Nicole Laws

P-54 DEL-00053,

DEL-00052,

DEL-00054

Voter packet for Brian Murphy

P-55 DEL-00059,

DEL-00058,

DEL-00060

Voter packet for Hannah Peterson

P-56 DEL-00044,

DEL-00043,

DEL-00045

Voter packet for Mintina Reisinger

P-57 DEL-00065,

DEL-00064,

DEL-00066

Voter packet for Adalicia Sanchez

P-58 DEL-00095,

DEL-00094,

DEL-00096

Voter packet for Hayley Shaw

P-59 DEL-00092,

DEL-00091,

DEL-00093

Voter packet for Audra Sherman

P-60 DEL-00062,

DEL-00061,

DEL-00063

Voter packet for Abdelraouf Solaiman

P-61 DEL-00050,

DEL-00049,

DEL-00051

Voter packet for Courtney White

P-62 DEL-00161,

DEL-00160,

DEL-00162

Voter packet for Patrick Clark, Jr

P-63 DEL-00164,

DEL-00163

Voter packet for Michael Eberly

P-64 DEL-00167,

DEL-00166,

DEL-00168

Voter packet for Kyle Flower

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 5 of 289 PAGEID #: 31184

6

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-65 DEL-00170,

DEL-00169,

DEL-00171

Voter packet for Scott Hayden

P-66 DEL-00197,

DEL-000196, DEL-

00198

Voter packet for Virginia Yoder

P-67 DEL-00203,

DEL-00202,

DEL-00204

Voter packet for Margaret Bahr

P-68 DEL-00206,

DEL-00205,

DEL-00207

Voter packet for Susan Brannen

P-69 DEL-00131,

DEL-00130,

DEL-00132

Voter packet for Heather Christmas-Okuley

P-70 DEL-00209,

DEL-00208,

DEL-00210

Voter packet for Raymond Cook, Sr.

P-71 DEL-00200,

DEL-00199,

DEL-00201

Voter packet for Terry Dolder

P-72 DEL-00212,

DEL-00212,

DEL-00213

Voter packet for Sara Guster

P-73 DEL-00224,

DEL-00223,

DEL-00225

Voter packet for Karen Lloyd-Hayes

P-74 DEL-00215,

DEL-00214,

DEL-00216

Voter packet for Arthur Hergatt

P-75 DEL-00218,

DEL-00217,

DEL-00219

Voter packet for Sara Kassab

P-76 DEL-00221,

DEL-00220,

Voter packet for Juanita McCreary

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 6 of 289 PAGEID #: 31185

7

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

DEL-00222

P-77 DEL-00191,

DEL-00190,

DEL-00192

Voter packet for Alyssa Myers

P-78 DEL-00188,

DEL-00187,

DEL-00189

Voter packet for Dale Napper

P-79 DEL-00185,

DEL-00184,

DEL-00186

Voter packet for Wesley Paulins

P-80 DEL-00182, DEL-

00181, DEL-00183

Voter packet for Kyle Perry

P-81 DEL-00179, DEL-

00178, DEL-00180

Voter packet for Elizabeth Phillian

P-82 DEL-00173, DEL-

00172, DEL-00174

Voter packet for Terry Shoemaker

P-83 DEL-00176, DEL-

00175, DEL-00177

Voter packet for Jody Simenz

P-84 DEL-00275, DEL-

00274, DEL-00276

Voter packet for Joseph Beshara

P-85 DEL-00272, DEL-

00271, DEL-00273

Voter packet for Kirstin Bloom

P-86 DEL-00305, DEL-

00304, DEL-00306

Voter packet for Dana Brush

P-87 DEL-00302, DEL-

00301, DEL-00303

Voter packet for Brian Burga

P-88 DEL-00266, DEL-

00265, DEL-00267

Voter packet for Patricia Casey

P-89 DEL-00248, DEL-

00247, DEL-00249

Voter packet for Imogene Hazey

P-90 DEL-00245, DEL-

00244, DEL-00246

Voter packet for Patricia Lord

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 7 of 289 PAGEID #: 31186

8

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-91 DEL-00239, DEL-

00238, DEL-00240

Voter packet for James Ort

P-92 DEL-00299, DEL-

00298, DEL-00300

Voter packet for Arnold Schisler

P-93 DEL-00293, DEL-

00292, DEL-00294

Voter packet for Christopher Skudder

P-94 DEL-00233, DEL-

00232, DEL-00234

Voter packet for Lisa Smith

P-95 DEL-00311, DEL-

00310, DEL-00312

Voter packet for William Welch

P-96 DEL-00128, DEL-

00127, DEL-00129

Voter packet for John Wright

P-97 DEL-00278, DEL-

00277, DEL-00279

Voter packet for George Abbott

P-98 DEL-00281, DEL-

00280, DEL-00282

Voter packet for Nick Ailabouni

P-99 DEL-00284, DEL-

00283, DEL-00285

Voter packet for Keaton Allmaras

P-100 DEL-00269, DEL-

00268, DEL-00270

Voter packet for Graeme Boone

P-101 DEL-00263, DEL-

00262, DEL-00264

Voter packet for Julie Crooks

P-102 DEL-00290, DEL-

00289, DEL-00291

Voter packet for Vickie Fehler

P-103 DEL-00254, DEL-

00253, DEL-00255

Voter packet for Melissa Glinsky

P-104 DEL-00251, DEL-

00250, DEL-00252

Voter packet for June Griffith

P-105 DEL-00242, DEL-

00241, DEL-00243

Voter packet for Jeffrey Mays

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 8 of 289 PAGEID #: 31187

9

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-106 DEL-00236, DEL-

00235, DEL-00237

Voter packet for Maegan Rothermund

P-107 DEL-00227, DEL-

00226, DEL-00228

Voter packet for Charles Wortz

P-108 DEL-00194, DEL-

00193, DEL-00195

Voter packet for Chiazor Akuroba

P-109 DEL-00260, DEL-

00259, DEL-00261

Voter packet for James Ferguson

P-110 DEL-00257, DEL-

00256, DEL-00258

Voter packet for Carolyn Fuqua

P-111 DEL-00296, DEL-

00295, DEL-00297

Voter packet for Eli Mitchell

P-112 DEL-00230, DEL-

00229, DEL-00231

Voter packet for David Stewart

P-113 1/5/16 Subpoena to Delaware County BOE

P-114 11/3/15 FAIR-00160 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Fairfield County

P-115 11/3/15 FAIR-00157 – FAIR-

00159

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Fairfield County

P-116 11/4/14 FAIR-00153 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Fairfield County

P-117 11/4/14 FAIR-00150 – FAIR-

00152

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Fairfield County

P-118 FAIR-00154 – FAIR-

00155, FAIR-00148 –

FAIR-00149

Fairfield County Board minutes

P-119 FAIR-00161, FAIR-

00156

Fairfield County Board minutes

P-120 FAIR-00001 Voter packet for Donald Hurley

P-121 FAIR-00002 Voter packet for Michael Fennell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 9 of 289 PAGEID #: 31188

10

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-122 FAIR-00003 Voter packet for Aaron Stage

P-123 FAIR-00146 – FAIR-

00147, FAIR-00145,

FAIR-00171

Voter packet for Wilbur Bland

P-124 FAIR-00013, FAIR-

00012, FAIR-00186

Voter packet for Betty Goldstein

P-125 FAIR-00011, FAIR-

00010, FAIR-00185

Voter packet for Irene Graham

P-126 FAIR-00143 – FAIR-

00144, FAIR-00172

Voter packet for Barbara Johnston

P-127 FAIR-00015, FAIR-

00014, FAIR-00116,

FAIR-00163

Voter packet for Norma Connett

P-128 FAIR-00034, FAIR-

00033, FAIR-0035,

FAIR-00197

Voter packet for Reinhold Knoetzele

P-129 FAIR-00130, FAIR-

00129, FAIR-00131,

FAIR-00166

Voter packet for Joe Koonce

P-130 FAIR-00133, FAIR-

00132, FAIR-00134,

FAIR-00167

Voter packet for Susan Shupe

P-131 FAIR-00037, FAIR-

00036, FAIR-00038,

FAIR-00177

Voter packet for Edna Wagenbrenner

P-132 FAIR-00040, FAIR-

00039, FAIR-00041,

FAIR-00178

Voter packet for Darryl Baker

P-133 FAIR-00043, FAIR-

00042, FAIR-00044,

FAIR-00179

Voter packet for Patrice Baker

P-134 FAIR-00127, FAIR-

00126, FAIR-00128,

Voter packet for Nellalou Bauer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 10 of 289 PAGEID #: 31189

11

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FAIR-00199

P-135 FAIR-00118, FAIR-

00117, FAIR-00119,

FAIR-00200

Voter packet for John Corriveau

P-136 FAIR-00121, FAIR-

00120, FAIR-00122,

FAIR-00164

Voter packet for Shirley Farmer

P-137 FAIR-00046, FAIR-

00045, FAIR-00047,

FAIR-00180

Voter packet for Wilma Frasure

P-138 FAIR-00136, FAIR-

00135, FAIR-00137,

FAIR-00168

Voter packet for Chrystal Jervis

P-139 FAIR-00049, FAIR-

00048, FAIR-00050,

FAIR-00181

Voter packet for Herman Martin

P-140 FAIR-00052, FAIR-

00051, FAIR-00053,

FAIR-00182

Voter packet for Jose Martinez, Jr.

P-141 FAIR-00055, FAIR-

00054, FAIR-00056,

FAIR-00183

Voter packet for Janet Ryan

P-142 FAIR-00058 - FAIR-

00059, FAIR-00057,

FAIR-00184

Voter packet for Mark Yenizhekll

P-143 FAIR-00124, FAIR-

00123, FAIR-00125,

FAIR-00177

Voter packet for Kathleen Yenichek

P-144 FAIR-00075, FAIR-

00074, FAIR-00076

Voter packet for Alice Beckley

P-145 FAIR-00078, FAIR-

00077, FAIR-00079,

FAIR-00191

Voter packet for Paul Burkitt, Jr.

P-146 FAIR-00081, FAIR-

00080, FAIR-00082,

Voter packet for Ellen Conway

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 11 of 289 PAGEID #: 31190

12

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FAIR-00191

P-147 FAIR-00084, FAIR-

00083, FAIR-00085

Voter packet for Jerry Cook

P-148 FAIR-00087, FAIR-

00086, FAIR-00088

Voter packet for Kathi Crist

P-149 FAIR-00089 - FAIR-

00091, FAIR-00193

Voter packet for Delores Joos

P-150 FAIR-00092, FAIR-

00094, FAIR-00093,

FAIR-00194

Voter packet for Thomas Mulcahy

P-151 FAIR-00099, FAIR-

00098, FAIR-00100,

FAIR-00195

Voter packet for Frank Turgeon

P-152 FAIR-00102, FAIR-

00101, FAIR-00103

Voter packet for Brent Walton

P-153 FAIR-00105, FAIR-

00104, FAIR-00106,

FAIR-00203

Voter packet for Andrew Wolfinger

P-154 FAIR-00061, FAIR-

00060, FAIR-00189

Voter packet for Connie Berta

P-155 FAIR-00096, FAIR-

00095, FAIR-00097,

FAIR-00201)

Voter packet for Tamela Perry

P-156 FAIR-00108, FAIR-

00107, FAIR-00109,

FAIR-00202

Voter packet for Rita Mason

P-157 FAIR-00019, FAIR-

00018, FAIR-00020,

FAIR-00174

Voter packet for Norma Asher

P-158 FAIR-00063, FAIR-

00062, FAIR-00064 -

FAIR-00065, FAIR-190

Voter packet for Linda Bolger

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 12 of 289 PAGEID #: 31191

13

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-159 FAIR-00030, FAIR-

00029, FAIR-00031 –

FAIR-00032, FAIR-

00198

Voter packet for Keith Dehmann

P-160 FAIR-00026, FAIR-

00025, FAIR-00027 –

FAIR-00028, FAIR-

00176

Voter packet for Nisreen Yahyafares

P-161 FAIR-00111, FAIR-

00110, FAIR-00112 –

FAIR-00113, FAIR-

00162

Voter packet for Owen Keller

P-162 FAIR-00022, FAIR-

00021, FAIR-00023 –

FAIR-00024, FAIR-

00175

Voter packet for Sonja Tweedle

P-163 FAIR-00067, FAIR-

00066

Voter packet for John Berry

P-164 FAIR-00141, FAIR-

00140, FAIR-00141,

FAIR-00170

Voter packet for Iva Blackmon

P-165 FAIR-00069, FAIR-

00068

Voter packet for Diana Burgett

P-166 FAIR-00139, FAIR-

00138, FAIR-00169

Voter packet for Gary McNeely

P-167 FAIR-00071, FAIR-

00070

Voter packet for Carolyn Robinson

P-168 FAIR-00073, FAIR-

00072

Voter packet for Leslie Tackett

P-169 1/5/16 Subpoena to Fairfield County BOE

P-170 11/4/14 RICH-00008 – RICH-

00010

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Richland County

P-171 11/3/15 RICH-00044 – RICH-

00046

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Richland County

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 13 of 289 PAGEID #: 31192

14

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-172 11/3/15 RICH-00001 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Richland County

P-173 11/17/14 RICH-00071 – RICH-

00072

Richland County Board minutes

P-174 11/16/15 -

11/19/15

RICH-00069 – RICH-

00070

Richland County Board minutes

P-175 2015 RICH-00060 – RICH-

00063

Provisional rejections

P-176 11/4/14 RICH-00064 – RICH-

00068

Rejected Absentee Voter List

P-177 2015 RICH-00057 – RICH-

00059

Rejected Absentee Voter List

P-178 RICH-00002 Voter packet for Harold Fulk

P-179 RICH-00003 Voter packet for Charlotte Compton

P-180 RICH-00011 Voter packet for Lindia Gleisinger

P-181 RICH-00012 Voter packet for Kathryn Hall

P-182 RICH-00052 Voter packet for Wendy Laser

P-183 RICH-00055 Voter packet for John Marinelli

P-184 RICH-00055 Voter packet for James McFarren Jr.

P-185 RICH-00034 Voter packet for Joyce Brennan

P-186 RICH-00036 Voter packet for Pomi Evans

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 14 of 289 PAGEID #: 31193

15

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-187 RICH-00051 Voter packet for Debra Hawks

P-188 RICH-00037 Voter packet for Nicholas Jackson

P-189 RICH-00038 Voter packet for Sophia Jackson

P-190 RICH-00039 Voter packet for Carl Kiser

P-191 RICH-00040 Voter packet for Garnett Kiser

P-192 RICH-00041 Voter packet for Timothy Mattoni

P-193 RICH-00056 Voter packet for Heidi Miller

P-194 RICH-00042 Voter packet for Lucy Siciliano

P-195 RICH-00043 Voter packet for Jake Youse

P-196 RICH-00050 Voter packet for Bonnie Butler

P-197 RICH-00053 Voter packet for Deborah Linton

P-198 RICH-00054 Voter packet for Charlotte Mabee

P-199 RICH-00015 – RICH-

00033

Voided ballots refused by voters

P-200 11/17/15 Subpoena to Richland County BOE

P-201 1/5/16 Subpoena to Richland County BOE

P-202 11/4/14 LAW-00148 Lawrence County BOE minutes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 15 of 289 PAGEID #: 31194

16

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-203 11/19/14 LAW-00149 Lawrence County BOE minutes

P-204 11/3/15 LAW-00146 – LAW-

00147

Lawrence County BOE minutes

P-205 11/3/15 LAW-00006 – LAW-

00012

Provisional rejections

P-206 LAW-00013 Voter packet for Andrew Lykins

P-207 LAW-00014 Voter packet for Donna Barton

P-208 LAW-00015 Voter packet for Caleb Brown

P-209 LAW-00097, LAW-

00096

Voter packet for Denise Bowman

P-210 LAW-00091, LAW-

00090

Voter packet for Ann Hardesty

P-211 LAW-00081, LAW-

00080

Voter packet for Elizabeth Jeffers

P-212 LAW-00058, LAW-

00057

Voter packet for Thelma Jenkins

P-213 LAW-00076, LAW-

00075

Voter packet for Billy Johnson

P-214 LAW-00074, LAW-

00073

Voter packet for Carol Kegley

P-215 LAW-00101, LAW-

00100

Voter packet for Pamela Meyers

P-216 LAW-00062, LAW-

00061

Voter packet for Willie Miller

P-217 LAW-00060, LAW-

00059

Voter packet for Gerald Mullens

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 16 of 289 PAGEID #: 31195

17

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-218 LAW-00027 - LAW-

00029

Voter packet for James Myers

P-219 LAW-00041, LAW-

00040, LAW-00042

Voter packet for James Myers

P-220 LAW-00039, LAW-

00038

Voter packet for Johnny Noble

P-221 LAW-00056, LAW-

00055

Voter packet for Opal Runyon

P-222 LAW-00054, LAW-

00053

Voter packet for Roscoe Smith

P-223 LAW-00050, LAW-

00049

Voter packet for Edward Spotloe

P-224 LAW-00052, LAW-

00051

Voter packet for Nancy Swartzwelder

P-225 LAW-00048, LAW-

00047

Voter packet for Alyssa Vickers

P-226 LAW-00099, LAW-

00098

Voter packet for Linda Boggs

P-227 LAW-00095, LAW-

00094

Voter packet for Danny Boyd, Jr.

P-228 LAW-00044, LAW-

00043

Voter packet for Charles Case

P-229 LAW-00079, LAW-

00078

Voter packet for Deena Deeds

P-230 LAW-00085, LAW-

00084

Voter packet for John Fliehman

P-231 LAW-00089, LAW-

00088

Voter packet for James Gothard

P-232 LAW-00087, LAW-

00086

Voter packet for Jessica Gothard

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 17 of 289 PAGEID #: 31196

18

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-233 LAW-00026, LAW-

00025

Voter packet for Earl Henderson

P-234 LAW-00083, LAW-

00082

Voter packet for Kelli Jackson

P-235 LAW-00068, LAW-

00067

Voter packet for Madlene Marcum

P-236 LAW-00072, LAW-

00071

Voter packet for Jerry Markins

P-237 LAW-00021 – LAW-

00022

Voter packet for Michael Mathey

P-238 LAW-00070, LAW-

00069

Voter packet for Donald Mays

P-239 LAW-00045 - LAW-

00046

Voter packet for Helen Mulke

P-240 LAW-00064, LAW-

00063

Voter packet for Kera Musick

P-241 LAW-00066, LAW-

00065

Voter packet for Shirley Stapleton

P-242 LAW-00037, LAW-

00036

Voter packet for John Stevens

P-243 LAW-00023 - LAW-

00024

Voter packet for Suzanne Strait

P-244 LAW-00102 Voter packet for Julia Bond

P-245 LAW-00103 Voter packet for Chester Daniels

P-246 LAW-00032 – LAW-

00033

Voter packet for Dow Dempsey Jr.

P-247 LAW-00104 Voter packet for Angie Easterling

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 18 of 289 PAGEID #: 31197

19

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-248 LAW-00105 Voter packet for Stacey Hess

P-249 LAW-00030 – LAW-

00031

Voter packet for Wateka LaPrad

P-250 LAW-00110 Voter packet for Virginia Wilson

P-251 LAW-00106 Voter packet for Christopher Howard

P-252 LAW-00107 Voter packet for Kayla Massie

P-253 LAW-00109 Voter packet for Jimmy Wheeler

P-254 LAW-00016 – LAW-

00018

Voter packet for Virginia Burns

P-255 LAW-00108 Voter packet for Daniel Mullins

P-256 11/17/15 Subpoena to Lawrence County BOE

P-257 1/5/16 Subpoena to Lawrence County BOE

P-258 MONT-00169 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Montgomery

County

P-259 11/24/14 MONT-00272 –

MONT-00274

Montgomery County BOE minutes

P-260 11/19/15 MONT-00266 –

MONT-00271

Montgomery County BOE minutes

P-261 11/2015 MONT-00093 –

MONT-00162

Poll Worker Training PowerPoint

P-262 MONT-00324 Voter packet for Frederick Eichelberger

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 19 of 289 PAGEID #: 31198

20

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-263 MONT-00304, MONT-

00183 – MONT-00184

Voter packet for Aaron Griffieth

P-264 MONT-00305, MONT-

00234 – MONT-00235

Voter packet for Gabriela Levi

P-265 MONT-00323 Voter packet for Steven McCall

P-266 MONT-00308 Voter packet for Barry Moore

P-267 MONT-00306, MONT-

00245 – MONT-00246

Voter packet for Russell Oney

P-268 MONT-00302, MONT-

00253 – MONT-00254

Voter packet for Jayne Seibert

P-269 MONT-00277, MONT-

00182

Voter packet for Shirley Quinn

P-270 MONT-00300, MONT-

00211

Voter packet for Earl Simone

P-271 MONT-00301, MONT-

00171

Voter packet for Douglas Dawson

P-272 MONT-00299, MONT-

00213

Voter packet for Chad Thomas

P-273 MONT-00297, MONT-

00179

Voter packet for Lester Carlton

P-274 MONT-00276 Voter packet for Fred Morgan

P-275 MONT-00275 Voter packet for Rita Morgan

P-276 MONT-00295, MONT-

00212

Voter packet for Kurt Stokes

P-277 MONT-00294 Voter packet for Angie Todd

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 20 of 289 PAGEID #: 31199

21

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-278 MONT-00290, MONT-

00173

Voter packet for Maria Bernal

P-279 MONT-00298, MONT-

00174

Voter packet for Janah Berry

P-280 MONT-00296, MONT-

00175

Voter packet for Debra McDavid

P-281 MONT-00293, MONT-

00214

Voter packet for Amanda Westbeld

P-282 MONT-00291, MONT-

00216

Voter packet for Charles Wright

P-283 MONT-00325, MONT-

00227

Voter packet for Cecil Guffey

P-284 MONT-00278 –

MONT-00279

Voter packet for Justin Ingram

P-285 MONT-00284 -

MONT-00285

Voter packet for William Madewell

P-286 MONT-00280 –

MONT-00281

Voter packet for Patricia Pultz

P-287 MONT-00282 -

MONT-00283

Voter packet for Randy Taulbee

P-288 MONT-00288 -

MONT-00289

Voter packet for Carol Wilkins

P-289 11/17/15 Subpoena to Montgomery County BOE

P-290 1/5/16 Subpoena to Montgomery County BOE

P-291 11/18/14 LORAIN-00213 –

LORAIN-00214

Lorain County BOE minutes

P-292 9/2/14 LORAIN-00118 –

LORAIN-00121

Absentee Ballot Summary Report – 2014 General Election

P-293 11/13/14 LORAIN-00068 – Provisional Ballot Summary Report – 2014 General Election

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 21 of 289 PAGEID #: 31200

22

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LORAIN-00074

P-294 11/17/15 LORAIN-00215 –

LORAIN-00217

Lorain County BOE minutes

P-295 9/2/14 LORAIN-00002 –

LORAIN-00005

Absentee Ballot Summary Report – 2015 General Election

P-296 11/13/14 LORAIN-00085 –

LORAIN-00091

Provisional Ballot Summary Report – 2015 General Election

P-297 LORAIN-00092 Voter packet for Theresa Gainer

P-298 LORAIN-00098 –

LORAIN-00100

Voter packet for Adrianna Warck

P-299 LORAIN-00096 Voter packet for Michael Beeble

P-300 LORAIN-00094 Voter packet for Breanne Bright

P-301 LORAIN-00080 Voter packet for Jack Free

P-302 LORAIN-00097 Voter packet for Juan Soto

P-303 LORAIN-00095 Voter packet for April Vanover

P-304 LORAIN-00093 Voter packet for Adam Waddell

P-305 LORAIN-00079 Voter packet for Annie Whitaker

P-306 LORAIN-00111 –

LORAIN-00113

Voter packet for Branden Gannon

P-307 LORAIN-00114 –

LORAIN-00116

Voter packet for Ann Sanford

P-308 LORAIN-00110 Voter packet for Christina Weekley

P-309 LORAIN-00108 Voter packet for Colin Brown

P-310 LORAIN-00109 Voter packet for Nicholas Carroll

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 22 of 289 PAGEID #: 31201

23

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-311 LORAIN-00083 Voter packet for Anna Hoffmann

P-312 LORAIN-00102 –

LORAIN-00104

Voter packet for Lorraine Smith

P-313 LORAIN-00105 –

LORAIN-00107

Voter packet for Anthony Truxall

P-314 LORAIN-00101 Voter packet for Richard Rovach

P-315 LORAIN-00030 –

LORAIN-00033

Voter packet for Kathy Johnson

P-316 LORAIN-00026 –

LORAIN-00029

Voter packet for Arsenio Sa, Jr.

P-317 LORAIN-00132 –

LORAIN-00133

Voter packet for Michael Braid

P-318 LORAIN-00144–

LORAIN-00145

Voter packet for Almetricel Calhoun

P-319 LORAIN-00154 –

LORAIN-00155

Voter packet for Carrie Cook

P-320 LORAIN-00122 –

LORAIN-00123

Voter packet for Farrell Crumley

P-321 LORAIN-00134 –

LORAIN-00135

Voter packet for Donald Deidrick

P-322 LORAIN-00138 –

LORAIN-00139

Voter packet for Carol Dunipace

P-323 LORAIN-00010 –

LORAIN-00013

Voter packet for George Gnandt

P-324 LORAIN-00126 –

LORAIN-00127

Voter packet for Peter Harlan

P-325 LORAIN-00164 –

LORAIN-00165

Voter packet for Kenneth Harper

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 23 of 289 PAGEID #: 31202

24

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-326 LORAIN-00130 –

LORAIN-00131

Voter packet for Robin Hengartner

P-327 LORAIN-00014 –

LORAIN-00017

Voter packet for Alicia Jappeck

P-328 LORAIN-00128 –

LORAIN-00129

Voter packet for Neil Kammillee

P-329 LORAIN-00158 –

LORAIN-00159

Voter packet for Leon Kinsley

P-330 LORAIN-00156 –

LORAIN-00157

Voter packet for Robert Krivak

P-331 LORAIN-00150 –

LORAIN-00151

Voter packet for Joyce Mack

P-332 LORAIN-00140 –

LORAIN-00141

Voter packet for Robert McEwen

P-333 LORAIN-00136 –

LORAIN-00137

Voter packet for Edith Raible

P-334 LORAIN-00022 –

LORAIN-00025

Voter packet for Jaime Ramos

P-335 LORAIN-00152 –

LORAIN-00153

Voter packet for Susan Raymont

P-336 LORAIN-00146 –

LORAIN-00147

Voter packet for Loraine Schwede

P-337 LORAIN-00148 –

LORAIN-00149

Voter packet for Terry Ann Schwede

P-338 LORAIN-00018 –

LORAIN-00021

Voter packet for Richard Shullick

P-339 LORAIN-00018 –

LORAIN-00021

Voter packet for Felicia Smith

P-340 LORAIN-00141 –

LORAIN-00143

Voter packet for Andrew Thieken

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 24 of 289 PAGEID #: 31203

25

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-341 LORAIN-00161 –

LORAIN-00163

Voter packet for Natalie Toth

P-342 LORAIN-00160 –

LORAIN-00161

Voter packet for Diane Varner

P-343 LORAIN-00187 Voter packet for Dorothy Baker

P-344 LORAIN-00185 Voter packet for Beverly Benko

P-345 LORAIN-00203 Voter packet for Brenda Castro

P-346 LORAIN-00203 Voter packet for Glenn Collins

P-347 LORAIN-00198 Voter packet for Jane Coven

P-348 LORAIN-00194 Voter packet for Jacqueline Davis

P-349 LORAIN-00191 Voter packet for Carol Dudukovich

P-350 LORAIN-00189 Voter packet for Theresa Hardy

P-351 LORAIN-00038 –

LORAIN-00041

Voter packet for Amalia Hoke

P-352 LORAIN-00042 –

LORAIN-00045

Voter packet for Lois Kolhoff

P-353 LORAIN-00206 Voter packet for William Kopis

P-354 LORAIN-00192 Voter packet for Gordon Lent

P-355 LORAIN-00196 Voter packet for Arthur Lipsin

P-356 LORAIN-00046 –

LORAIN-00049

Voter packet for Louise Luckenbill

P-357 LORAIN-00183 Voter packet for Marie Mayton

P-358 LORAIN-00186 Voter packet for Debra McConnell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 25 of 289 PAGEID #: 31204

26

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-359 LORAIN-00199 Voter packet for Edna McCowan

P-360 LORAIN-00182 Voter packet for Scott Meredith

P-361 LORAIN-00193 Voter packet for Yvonne Moen

P-362 LORAIN-00055 –

LORAIN-00058

Voter packet for Carrie Moore

P-363 LORAIN-00188 Voter packet for Donald Moran

P-364 LORAIN-00190 Voter packet for Robert Pallante

P-365 LORAIN-00059 –

LORAIN-00062

Voter packet for Bernice Pekar

P-366 LORAIN-00197 Voter packet for Dimitre Petroff

P-367 LORAIN-00184 Voter packet for Michael Ridenour

P-368 LORAIN-00200 Voter packet for Luis Rodriquez

P-369 LORAIN-00063 –

LORAIN-00066

Voter packet for Laura Rouse

P-370 LORAIN-00204 Voter packet for Margaret Smarsh

P-371 LORAIN-000205 Voter packet for Mark Smarsh

P-372 LORAIN-00201 Voter packet for Donald Thompson

P-373 LORAIN-00202 Voter packet for Mary Thompson

P-374 LORAIN-00195 Voter packet for Brock Wade

P-375 LORAIN-00006 –

LORAIN-00009

Voter packet for Ahmad Bahr

P-376 LORAIN-00209 –

LORAIN-00212

Voter packet for Wanda Budway

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 26 of 289 PAGEID #: 31205

27

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-377 LORAIN-00050 –

LORAIN-00054

Voter packet for Nancy Mahoney

P-378 LORAIN-00176 –

LORAIN-00177

Voter packet for Elmeris Marcucci

P-379 LORAIN-00207 –

LORAIN-00208

Voter packet for Patsy Mass

P-380 LORAIN-00178 –

LORAIN-00179

Voter packet for Wanda Travis

P-381 LORAIN-00174 –

LORAIN-00175

Voter packet for George Ulakovic

P-382 1/17/15 Subpoena to Lorain County BOE

P-383 1/5/16 Subpoena to Lorain County BOE

P-384 11/18/14 WARREN-000168 –

WARREN-000172

Warren County BOE minutes

P-385 11/19/15 WARREN-000165 –

WARREN-000167

Warren County BOE minutes

P-386 WARREN-00002 Voter packet for Philip Baxter

P-387 WARREN-00003 Voter packet for Virginia Novak

P-388 WARREN-00004 Voter packet for Randy Parker

P-389 WARREN-00001 Voter packet for Walter Rathweg

P-390 WARREN-00010 Voter packet for Helen Carpenter

P-391 WARREN-00012 Voter packet for Richard Beadle

P-392 WARREN-00009 Voter packet for Mary Deich

P-393 WARREN-00011 Voter packet for Richard Fohl

P-394 WARREN-00005 Voter packet for Lee Vaughn

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 27 of 289 PAGEID #: 31206

28

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-395 WARREN-00006 Voter packet for Mary Blair

P-396 WARREN-00008 Voter packet for Megan Earhart

P-397 WARREN-00013 Voter packet for Rose Linton

P-398 WARREN-00108-

WARREN-00109

Voter packet for Molly Hine/Corwin

P-399 WARREN-00106 -

WARREN-00107

Voter packet for Katherine Reilly

P-400 WARREN-00144 –

WARREN-00145

Voter packet for Wilma Baker

P-401 WARREN-00074 –

WARREN-00075

Voter packet for Jeff Haglage

P-402 WARREN-00146 –

WARREN-00147

Voter packet for Zoe Storch

P-403 WARREN-00042 –

WARREN-00043

Vote packet for Andrew Capetillo

P-404 WARREN-00034 –

WARREN-00035

Voter packet for John Grunkemeyer

P-405 WARREN-00054 –

WARREN-00055

Voter packet for Bethany Piepmeyer

P-406 WARREN-00044 –

WARREN-00045

Voter packet for Joyce Winans

P-407 WARREN-00066 –

WARREN-00067

Voter packet for Jerry Chapman

P-408 WARREN-00062 –

WARREN-00063

Voter packet for Margaret Cunningham

P-409 WARREN-00058 –

WARREN-00059

Voter packet for Savannah Ellis

P-410 WARREN-00040 –

WARREN-00041

Voter packet for Ryan Gombita

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 28 of 289 PAGEID #: 31207

29

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-411 WARREN-00018 –

WARREN-00019

Voter packet for Christine Haberny

P-412 WARREN-00030 –

WARREN-00031

Voter packet for Jeanneta Hare

P-413 WARREN-00020 –

WARREN-00021

Voter packet for Nedra Horn

P-414 WARREN-00036 –

WARREN-00037

Voter packet for Lyndon Jewell

P-415 WARREN-00024 –

WARREN-00025

Voter packet for Shirley Johnson

P-416 WARREN-00048 –

WARREN-00049

Voter packet for Brian Morris

P-417 WARREN-00050 –

WARREN-00051

Voter packet for Yuka Neuman

P-418 WARREN-00046 –

WARREN-00047

Voter packet for Patricia Robinson

P-419 WARREN-00032 –

WARREN-00033

Voter packet for Philip Sommer

P-420 WARREN-00022 –

WARREN-00023

Voter packet for Noelle Taylor

P-421 WARREN-00038 –

WARREN-00039

Voter packet for Robert Tennant

P-422 WARREN-00028 –

WARREN-00-20

Voter packet for Tara Viswanathan

P-423 WARREN-00052 –

WARREN-00053

Voter packet for Michael Westall

P-424 WARREN-00086 –

WARREN-00087

Voter packet for Shannon Beatty

P-425 WARREN-00096 –

WARREN-00097

Voter packet for Elnor Fayns

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 29 of 289 PAGEID #: 31208

30

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-426 WARREN-00112 –

WARREN-00113

Voter packet for Jillynn Johns

P-427 WARREN-00094 –

WARREN-00095

Voter packet for Natalie Johnson

P-428 WARREN-00078 –

WARREN-00079

Voter packet for Billy Jones

P-429 WARREN-00118 –

WARREN-00119

Voter packet for Lance Lisko

P-430 WARREN-00098 –

WARREN-00099

Voter packet for Ronald Marcum

P-431 WARREN-00014 –

WARREN-00015

Voter packet for Judy Oliger

P-432 WARREN-00100 –

WARREN-00101

Voter packet for Otis Ridener

P-433 WARREN-00084 –

WARREN-00085

Voter packet for Kenneth Schneider

P-434 WARREN-00102 –

WARREN-00103

Voter packet for Ann Voss

P-435 WARREN-00124 –

WARREN-00125

Voter packet for Joan Bugitzedes

P-436 WARREN-00104 –

WARREN-00105

Voter packet for David Helton

P-437 WARREN-00064 –

WARREN-00065

Voter packet for Patricia Schuman

P-438 WARREN-00120 –

WARREN-00121

Voter packet for Patsy Spaeth

P-439 WARREN-00060 –

WARREN-00061

Voter packet for Grace Hayes

P-440 WARREN-00090 –

WARREN-00091

Voter packet for Betty Helton

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 30 of 289 PAGEID #: 31209

31

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-441 WARREN-00026 –

WARREN-00027

Voter packet for Vicki Rohde

P-442 WARREN-000173 –

WARREN-000179

List of rejected absentee ballots for November 2014 elections

P-443 1/5/16 Subpoena to Warren County BOE

P-444 HAMILTON-00040 2014 Provisional Ballot Official Certification

P-445 HAMILTON-00039 2015 Provisional Ballot Official Certification

P-446 HAMILTON-00007 –

HAMILTON-00009

2014 Absentee Ballot Official Certification

P-447 HAMILTON-00035 –

HAMILTON-00037

2015 Absentee Ballot Official Certification

P-448 11/18/14 HAMILTON-00031 –

HAMILTON-00034

Board Meeting Minutes

P-449 11/18/14 HAMILTON-00672 –

HAMILTON-00685

Board Meeting Transcript

P-450 11/17/15 HAMILTON-00699 –

HAMILTON-00704

Board Meeting Minutes

P-451 11/17/15 HAMILTON-00687 –

HAMILTON-00698

Board Meeting Minutes

P-452 11/5/15 HAMILTON-00046 Letter from D. Stevenson to S. Poland

P-453 HAMILTON-00041 –

HAMILTON-00045

Provisional Envelope Verification Procedures

P-454 HAMILTON-00038;

HAMILTON-00686

Absentee Ballot Form 11-S Procedures

P-455 HAMILTON-00899 –

HAMILTON-00922

2014 provisional no address

P-456 HAMILTON-00923 –

HAMILTON-00948

2014 provisional no ID

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 31 of 289 PAGEID #: 31210

32

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-457 HAMILTON-00949 –

HAMILTON-00965

2014 provisional no DOB

P-458 HAMILTON-00966 –

HAMILTON-00986

2015 provisional no address

P-459 HAMILTON-00987 –

HAMILTON-01006

2015 provisional no ID

P-460 HAMILTON-01007 –

HAMILTON-01011

2015 provisional no DOB

P-461 HAMILTON-01012 –

HAMILTON-01079

2014 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S no DOB

P-462 HAMILTON-00725 –

HAMILTON-00761

2014 absentee applications no DOB

P-463 HAMILTON-01128 –

HAMILTON-01265

2014 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S address mismatch

P-464 HAMILTON-00764 –

HAMILTON-00816

2014 absentee applications address mismatch

P-465 HAMILTON-01266 –

HAMILTON-01351

2014 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S missing or non-matching

ID

P-466 HAMILTON-00817 –

HAMILTON-00859

2014 absentee applications missing or non-matching ID

P-467 HAMILTON-01352 –

HAMILTON-01376

2015 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S missing or non-matching

DOB

P-468 HAMILTON-00860 –

HAMILTON-00872

2015 absentee applications missing or non-matching DOB

P-469 HAMILTON-01080 –

HAMILTON-01116

2015 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S non-matching ID

P-470 HAMILTON-00873 –

HAMILTON-00892

2015 absentee applications non-matching ID

P-471 HAMILTON-01117 –

HAMILTON-01127

2015 absentee ID envelopes/Forms 11-S no ID

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 32 of 289 PAGEID #: 31211

33

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-472 HAMILTON-00893 –

HAMILTON-00898

2015 absentee applications no ID

P-473 11/17/15 Subpoena to Hamilton Cty BOE

P-474 1/5/16 Subpoena to Hamilton Cty BOE

P-475 11/4/14 STARK-00303 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Stark County

P-476 11/3/15 STARK-00284 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Fairfield County

P-477 11/17/14 STARK-00286 –

STARK-00296

Minutes from Special Board Meeting

P-478 11/19/14 STARK-00298 –

STARK-00302

Minutes from Special Board Meeting

P-479 11/16/15 STARK-00276 –

STARK-00279; STARK-

00274 –STARK 00275

Minutes from Special Board Meeting

P-480 STARK-00023 Voter packet for Geraldine Bittle

P-481 STARK-00007 Voter packet for Robert Allen

P-482 STARK-00006 Voter packet for Mianne Conley

P-483 STARK-00003 Voter packet for Harold Eddy

P-484 STARK-00002 Voter packet for Francis Glenn

P-485 STARK-00001 Voter packet for Charles McMannin

P-486 STARK-00004 Voter packet for Khalimah Sultan

P-487 STARK-00005 Voter packet for LaVonna Whitcomb

P-488 STARK-00024 Voter packet for Vyonne Banas

P-489 STARK-00012 –

STARK-00014

Voter packet for George Doerschuk

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 33 of 289 PAGEID #: 31212

34

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-490 STARK-00015 –

STARK-00017

Voter packet for Lois Fleming

P-491 STARK-00037 Voter packet for Sally George

P-492 STARK-00008 –

STARK-00010

Voter packet for Beverly Swallen

P-493 STARK-00033 –

STARK-00035

Voter packet for Nathaniel Walker III

P-494 STARK-00011; STARK-

00038 – STARK-00039

Voter packet for Diana Wellspring

P-495 STARK-00021 Voter packet for Timothy Blackwell

P-496 STARK-00020 Voter packet for Robert Coleman

P-497 STARK-00031 Voter packet for Michael Durbin

P-498 STARK-00032 Voter packet for Natasha Fields

P-499 STARK-00019 Voter packet for Mercedes George

P-500 STARK-00030 Voter packet for Jessica Guthridge

P-501 STARK-00036 Voter packet for Nichole Knight

P-502 STARK-00029 Voter packet for Jeremy Shaffer

P-503 STARK-00028 Voter packet for Brooke Thorne

P-504 STARK-00018 Voter packet for Christopher White

P-505 STARK-00046 –

STARK-00048

Vote packet for Matthew Gooch

P-506 STARK-00040 –

STARK-00041

Voter packet for Thomas Pennypacker

P-507 STARK-00042 –

STARK-00043

Voter packet for Stephan Stano

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 34 of 289 PAGEID #: 31213

35

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-508 STARK-00051 –

STARK-00052

Voter packet for Jody Varn

P-509 STARK-00049 --

STARK-00050

Voter packet for Lucy Wilson

P-510 STARK-00159 –

STARK-00160

Voter packet for Elizabeth Domino

P-511 STARK-00153 –

STARK-00154

Voter packet for Theresa Fleming

P-512 STARK-00151 –

STARK-00152

Voter packet for Norma Jennnigs

P-513 STARK-00155 –

STARK—00156

Voter packet for Elaine Kay

P-514 STARK-00157 –

STARK-00158

Voter packet for Lucille Michel

P-515 STARK-00252 –

STARK-00253

Voter packet for Excell Alexander

P-516 STARK-00191 –

STARK-00192

Voter packet for Tiffanie Allen

P-517 STARK-00193 –

STARK-00194

Voter packet for Dorothy Ankrom

P-518 STARK-00059 –

STARK-00060

Voter packet for Paulette Ashford

P-519 STARK-00203 –

STARK-00204

Voter packet for William Austin

P-520 STARK-00181 –

STARK-00182

Voter packet for Mandy Bartko

P-521 STARK-00107 –

STARK-00108

Voter packet for Gerald Blocher

P-522 STARK-00213 –

STARK-00214

Voter packet for Alma Boerner

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 35 of 289 PAGEID #: 31214

36

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-523 STARK-00165 –

STARK-00166

Voter packet for Gary Burnhouse

P-524 STARK-00073 –

STARK-00074

Voter packet for Sherly Cannon

P-525 STARK-00258 –

STARK-00259

Voter packet for Nancy Caserta

P-526 STARK-00209 –

STARK-00210

Voter packet for William Condo

P-527 STARK-00095 –

STARK-00096

Voter packet for John Crawford

P-528 STARK-00069 –

STARK-00070

Voter packet for Carla Dickey

P-529 STARK-00121 –

STARK-00122

Voter packet for Vera Dishong

P-530 STARK-00055 –

STARK-00056

Voter packet for Margaret Dixon

P-531 STARK-00177 –

STARK-00178

Voter packet for Myrtle Dixon

P-532 STARK-00075 –

STARK-00077

Voter packet for Frances Easter

P-533 STARK-00221 –

STARK-00222

Voter packet for Joan Feichter

P-534 STARK-00169 –

STARK-00170

Voter packet for James Fields

P-535 STARK-00167 –

STARK-00168

Voter packet for Quennie Fields

P-536 STARK-00242 –

STARK-00243

Voter packet for Georgianne Finnicum

P-537 STARK-00240 –

STARK-00241

Voter packet for Mark Finnicum

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 36 of 289 PAGEID #: 31215

37

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-538 STARK-00109 –

STARK-00110

Voter packet for Daniel Fitch

P-539 STARK-00229 –

STARK-00230

Voter packet for Michele Fitsgibbon

P-540 STARK-00223 –

STARK-00224

Voter packet for Lorraine Freeman

P-541 STARK-00161 –

STARK-00162

Voter packet for Arthur Fritz Jr.

P-542 STARK-00175 –

STARK-00176

Voter packet for Stephen Fye

P-543 STARK-00250 –

STARK-00251

Vote packet for Elonda Garner

P-544 STARK-00248 –

STARK-00249

Voter packet for Yvonne Garner

P-545 STARK-00163 –

STARK-00164

Voter packet for Scott Gay, Jr.

P-546 STARK-00125 –

STARK-00126

Voter packet for Lynette Gelmini

P-547 STARK-00101 –

STARK-00102

Voter packet for Lisa Gorris

P-548 STARK-00085 –

STARK-00086

Voter packet for Robbin Hennis

P-549 STARK-00115 –

STARK-00116

Voter packet for Nancy Horton

P-550 STARK-00207 –

STARK-00208

Voter packet for John Hosso

P-551 STARK-00065 –

STARK-00066

Voter packet for Bonnie James

P-552 STARK-00117 –

STARK-00118

Voter packet for Zachary Johnston

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 37 of 289 PAGEID #: 31216

38

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-553 STARK-00219 –

STARK-00220

Voter packet for Lawrence Kennedy

P-554 STARK-00171 –

STARK-00172

Voter packet for Ashley Kidd

P-555 STARK-00053 –

STARK-00054

Voter packet for Christina Kimble

P-556 STARK-00235 –

STARK-00237

Voter packet for Alice Klingaman

P-557 STARK-00063 –

STARK-00064

Voter packet for Lisa Kompare

P-558 STARK-00217 –

STARK-00218

Voter packet for Vera Martin

P-559 STARK-00089 –

STARK-00090

Voter packet for Thomas McHolm Jr.

P-560 STARK-00061 –

STARK-00062

Voter packet for Kasandra Motley

P-561 STARK-00231 –

STARK-00232

Voter packet for Jean Nero

P-562 STARK-00099 –

STARK-00100

Voter packet for Sylvia Notman

P-563 STARK-00215 –

STARK-00216

Voter packet for Annie Parsons

P-564 STARK-00183 –

STARK-00184

Voter packet for Gerry Pennell

P-565 STARK-00260 –

STARK-00261

Voter packet for Francis Peters

P-566 STARK-00097 –

STARK-00098

Voter packet for Joel Primack

P-567 STARK-00246 –

STARK-00247

Voter packet for Mark Prophet Sr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 38 of 289 PAGEID #: 31217

39

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-568 STARK-00187 –

STARK-00188

Voter packet for Richard Przepasniak

P-569 STARK-00123 –

STARK-00124

Voter packet for Julia Redd

P-570 STARK-00227 –

STARK-00228

Voter packet for Mary Riegler

P-571 STARK-00238 –

STARK-00239

Voter packet for Britteny Rinaldi

P-572 STARK-00254 –

STARK-00255

Voter packet for Emma Rollison

P-573 STARK-00111 –

STARK-00112

Voter packet for Raymond Ronevich Jr.

P-574 STARK-00087 –

STARK-00088

Voter packet for Martha Royer

P-575 STARK-00185 –

STARK-00186

Voter packet for Linda Rupert

P-576 STARK-00119 –

STARK-00120

Voter packet for Marilyn Ruthrauff

P-577 STARK-00081 –

STARK-00082

Voter packet for Barbara Sauders

P-578 STARK-00197 –

STARK-00198

Voter packet for John Scott

P-579 STARK-00195 –

STARK-00196

Voter packet for Susila Scott

P-580 STARK-00067 –

STARK-00068

Voter packet for Nicoletta Settimio

P-581 STARK-00105 –

STARK-00106

Voter packet for Gayle Shilling

P-582 STARK-00233 –

STARK-00234

Voter packet for Sandra Shipp-Wilson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 39 of 289 PAGEID #: 31218

40

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-583 STARK-00179 –

STARK-00180

Voter packet for Virginia Snyder

P-584 STARK-00083 –

STARK-00084

Voter packet for Robert Stayer

P-585 STARK-00256 –

STARK-00257

Voter packet for Randall Stillman

P-586 STARK-00057 –

STARK-00058

Voter packet for Earl Stoughton

P-587 STARK-00205 –

STARK-00206

Voter packet for Paula Stuckey

P-588 STARK-00113 –

STARK-00114

Voter packet for Darwin Teets

P-589 STARK-00093 –

STARK-00094

Voter packet for Hannah Thomas

P-590 STARK-00071 –

STARK-00072

Voter packet for Crystal Thompson

P-591 STARK-00244 –

STARK-00245

Voter packet for Samantha Thompson

P-592 STARK-00189 –

STARK-00190

Voter packet for Robert Walker

P-593 STARK-00211 –

STARK-00212

Voter packet for Sandra Warner

P-594 STARK-00078 –

STARK-00080

Voter packet for Mary Williams

P-595 STARK-00173 –

STARK-00174

Voter packet for Richard Williams

P-596 STARK-00225 –

STARK-00226

Voter packet for Carolyn Wires

P-597 STARK-00091–

STARK-00092

Voter packet for Carisa Wise

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 40 of 289 PAGEID #: 31219

41

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-598 STARK-00201 –

STARK-00202

Voter packet for Jonathan Yost

P-599 STARK-00199 –

STARK-00200

Voter packet for Karen Yost

P-600 STARK-00149 –

STARK-00150

Voter packet for Ronald Allen

P-601 STARK-00147 –

STARK-00148

Voter packet for George Archer IV

P-602 STARK-00103 –

STARK-00104

Voter packet for Ashley Ikeler

P-603 1/6/16 STARK-00310 –

STARK-00317; STARK-

00319-STARK-00322

Notice of Service of Deposition Subpoena Upon Stark County

Board of Elections

P-604 1/5/16 Subpoena to Stark County BOE

P-605 11/19/14 MIAMI-00002 Miami County Board minutes

P-606 11/13/15 MIAMI-00001 Miami County Board minutes

P-607 11/4/14 MIAMI-00005 –

MIAMI-00006

Summary of rejected ballots

P-608 11/3/15 MIAMI-00010 –

MIAMI-00013

Summary of rejected ballots

P-609 MIAMI-00173 Voter packet for James Conner II

P-610 MIAMI-00174 Voter packet for Tveal Booker

P-611 MIAMI-00172 Voter packet for Fred Justice Sr.

P-612 MIAMI-00021 Voter packet for Theresa Kiefer

P-613 MIAMI-00178 Voter packet for David Force

P-614 MIAMI-00179 Voter packet for Shirley Sanders

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 41 of 289 PAGEID #: 31220

42

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-615 MIAMI-00177 Voter packet for Rose Schmidt

P-616 MIAMI-00027 Voter packet for Rebecca Snyder

P-617 MIAMI-00121 Voter packet for Earl Aber

P-618 MIAMI-00124 Voter packet for Norma Aber

P-619 MIAMI-00143 Voter packet for Betty Arnett

P-620 MIAMI-00058 (left) Voter packet for Betty Bates

P-621 MIAMI-00149 Voter packet for Cardella Emerick

P-622 MIAMI-00154 Voter packet for Justin Furrow

P-623 MIAMI-00148 Voter packet for Penny Gooch

P-624 MIAMI-00059 (left) Voter packet for Margaret Johnston

P-625 MIAMI-00087 (right) Voter packet for Leon Martin Sr.

P-626 MIAMI-00126 Voter packet for Baylee Morgan

P-627 MIAMI-00091(right) Voter packet for Bonita Pierson

P-628 MIAMI-00150 Voter packet for Helen Potter

P-629 MIAMI-00153 Voter packet for Stephen Powell

P-630 MIAMI-00060 (left) Voter packet for Laura Ruley

P-631 MIAMI-00090 (right) Voter packet for Garrett Shindollar

P-632 MIAMI-00060 (right) Voter packet for Sue Smith

P-633 MIAMI-00087 (left) Voter packet for Esther Trost

P-634 MIAMI-00155 Voter packet for Doris Welbaum

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 42 of 289 PAGEID #: 31221

43

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-635 MIAMI-00088 (left) Voter packet for Gary Williams

P-636 MIAMI-00090 (left) Voter packet for Graceann Williams

P-637 MIAMI-00062 (right) Voter packet for Kathy Adams

P-638 MIAMI-00043 (left) Voter packet for Douglas Baker

P-639 MIAMI-00054 (left) Voter packet for Ralph Bateman

P-640 MIAMI-00059 (right) Voter packet for Eric Beckman

P-641 MIAMI-00055 (left) Voter packet for Jayne Benham

P-642 MIAMI-00056 (right) Voter packet for Douglas Bevan

P-643 MIAMI-00099 Voter packet for Andrew Bey

P-644 MIAMI-00146 Voter packet for Judith Bond

P-645 MIAMI-00058 (right) Voter packet for David Bowser

P-646 MAMI-00061 (left) Voter packet for Luke Brinkman

P-647 MIAMI-00055 (right) Voter packet for Billy Brooks

P-648 MIAMI-00053 (left) Voter packet for Zella Brooks

P-649 MIAMI-00152 Voter packet for Adam Brown

P-650 MIAMI-00057 (right) Voter packet for Anita Brown

P-651 MIAMI-00117 Voter packet for Christina Brown

P-652 MIAMI-00053 (right) Voter packet for David Brown

P-653 MIAMI-00110 Voter packet for Robert Brown

P-654 MIAMI-00100 Voter packet for Janeva Burrowes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 43 of 289 PAGEID #: 31222

44

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-655 MIAMI-00054(right) Voter packet for Christy Butera

P-656 MIAMI-00057 (left) Voter packet for Scott Butera

P-657 MIAMI-00158 Voter packet for Barbara Clarke

P-658 MIAMI-00097 Voter packet for Jason Clendening

P-659 MIAMI-00065 (left) Voter packet for Kathleen Cooney

P-660 MIAMI-00052 (left) Voter packet for William Copas

P-661 MIAMI-00068 (right) Voter packet for Andrew Cornett

P-662 MIAMI-00115 Voter packet for Betty Crace

P-663 MIAMI-00044 (left) Voter packet for Mary Lou Crawford

P-664 MIAMI-00068 (left) Voter packet for Cathryn Creager

P-665 MIAMI-00103 Voter packet for Gloria Cromes

P-666 MIAMI-00072 (left) Voter packet for Charlotte Cruea

P-667 MIAMI-00063 (left) Voter packet for Helen Daugherty

P-668 MIAMI-00048 (right) Voter packet for Jack Ditmer Jr.

P-669 MIAMI-00102 Voter packet for Bar Drewing

P-670 MIAMI-00064 (right) Voter packet for Eric Duncan

P-671 MIAMI-00047 (left) Voter packet for James Durand

P-672 MIAMI-00051(left) Voter packet for Jean Edge

P-673 MIAMI-00072 (right) Voter packet for Shawn Elliott Sr.

P-674 MIAMI-00122 Voter packet for Kristy Fields

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 44 of 289 PAGEID #: 31223

45

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-675 MIAMI-00050 (left) Voter packet for Robert Fisher

P-676 MIAMI-00070 (right) Voter packet for Eric Flory

P-677 MIAMI-00069 (left) Voter packet for Tara Flory

P-678 MIAMI-00111 Voter packet for Marie Francis

P-679 MIAMI-00051(right) Voter packet for Celia Gaier

P-680 MIAMI-00056 (left) Voter packet for Carol Gibson

P-681 MIAMI-00120 Voter packet for Jill Gilfillen

P-682 MIAMI-00105 Voter packet for Matthew Gilfillen

P-683 MIAMI-00106 Voter packet for Ileen Graves

P-684 MIAMI-00049 (left) Voter packet for Susan Gregory

P-685 MIAMI-00047 (right) Voter packet for Deborah Hall

P-686 MIAMI-00107 Voter packet for Buford Harellson Jr.

P-687 MIAMI-00049 (right) Voter packet for Deborah Hatton

P-688 MIAMI-00046 (left) Voter packet for Kristin Heil

P-689 MIAMI-00050 (right) Voter packet for Melissa Hess

P-690 MIAMI-00104 Voter packet for Cathryn Hood

P-691 MIAMI-00113 Voter packet for Williamm Hood

P-692 MIAMI-00065 (right) Voter packet for Susan Horner

P-693 MIAMI-00041(right) Voter packet for Carol Hornyak

P-694 MIAMI-00112 Voter packet for Haley Huebner

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 45 of 289 PAGEID #: 31224

46

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-695 MIAMI-00096 Voter packet for Bonnie Hyden

P-696 MIAMI-00042 (right) Voter packet for Diane Ingle

P-697 MIAMI-00045 (right) Voter packet for Robert Ingle

P-698 MIAMI-00042 (left) Voter packet for Luella King

P-699 MIAMI-00092 Voter packet for Sandra Kuntz

P-700 MIAMI-00073 (right) Voter packet for Cheryl Lacey

P-701 MIAMI-00094 Voter packet for Dennis Latham

P-702 MIAMI-00062 (left) Voter packet for Cheryl Lauber

P-703 MIAMI-00052 (right) Voter packet for Aaron Lindeman

P-704 MIAMI-00098 Voter packet for Gregory Longacre

P-705 MIAMI-00048 (left) Voter packet for Benjamin Lyons

P-706 MIAMI-00116 Voter packet for Edward McGatha

P-707 MIAMI-00040 (right) Voter packet for Robert Meador

P-708 MIAMI-00067 (left) Voter packet for Catherine Melvin

P-709 MIAMI-00151 Voter packet for Shirley Mengos

P-710 MIAMI-00041(left) Voter packet for L C Michael

P-711 MIAMI-00043 (right) Voter packet for Carolyn Mitchell

P-712 MIAMI-00109 Voter packet for Thomas Monnin

P-713 MIAMI-00061 (right) Voter packet for Regina Oswalt

P-714 MIAMI-00156 Voter packet for Nancy Potter

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 46 of 289 PAGEID #: 31225

47

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-715 MIAMI-00066 (left) Voter packet for David Rudy

P-716 MIAMI-00095 Voter packet for Joseph Sampson

P-717 MIAMI-00108 Voter packet for David Saylor

P-718 MIAMI-00045 (left) Voter packet for Gary Slusher

P-719 MIAMI-00067 (right) Voter packet for Janet Smith

P-720 MIAMI-00066 (right) Voter packet for Kayleigh Sotello

P-721 MIAMI-00046 (right) Voter packet for William Sutherly

P-722 MIAMI-00084 (left) Voter packet for Yasuko Szafranski

P-723 MIAMI-00114 Voter packet for Nickolaus Thompson

P-724 MIAMI-00093 Voter packet for Charles Tomlin

P-725 MIAMI-00157 Voter packet for Kelly Turner

P-726 MIAMI-00118 Voter packet for Jacob Van Buren

P-727 MIAMI-00119 Voter packet for Kurtis Van Buren

P-728 MIAMI-00064 (left) Voter packet for John White

P-729 MIAMI-00063 (right) Voter packet for Carol Wicker

P-730 MIAMI-00040 (left) Voter packet for Roberta Widener

P-731 MIAMI-00101 Voter packet for Heather Woolery

P-732 MIAMI-00069 (right) Voter packet for Donna Wright

P-733 MIAMI-00044 (right) Voter packet for Maurice Wyckoff

P-734 MIAMI-00147 Voter packet for Joseph Zeek

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 47 of 289 PAGEID #: 31226

48

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-735 MIAMI-00088 (right) Voter packet for Joyce Baab

P-736 MIAMI-00145 Voter packet for Esther Barnhart

P-737 MIAMI-00162 Voter packet for Ryan Beagle

P-738 MIAMI-00125 Voter packet for Judith Bond

P-739 MIAMI-00127 Voter packet for John Carmody

P-740 MIAMI-00129 Voter packet for Henry Cline

P-741 MIAMI-00163 Voter packet for Henry Cline

P-742 MIAMI-00075 (right) Voter packet for Carol Davis

P-743 MIAMI-00071 (right) Voter packet for Delores Dixon

P-744 MIAMI-00128 Voter packet for JoAnn Erwin

P-745 MIAMI-00089 (right) Voter packet for Betty Lou Etherington

P-746 MIAMI-00165 Voter packet for Joyce Grossnickle

P-747 MIAMI-00136 Voter packet for Carolyn Haman

P-748 MIAMI-00167 Voter packet for Wilber Morehead

P-749 MIAMI-00086 (left) Voter packet for David Noble

P-750 MIAMI-00085 (left) Voter packet for Geraldine Parker

P-751 MIAMI-00089 (left) Voter packet for Helen Parks

P-752 MIAMI-00139 Voter packet for Helen Parks

P-753 MIAMI-00159 Voter packet for Robert Rohlfs

P-754 MIAMI-00160 Voter packet for Ramona Sears

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 48 of 289 PAGEID #: 31227

49

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-755 MIAMI-00166 Voter packet for Woodson Sizemore

P-756 MIAMI-00164 Voter packet for Mary Swartz

P-757 MIAMI-00161 Voter packet for Jeffrey Wilhelm

P-758 MIAMI-00074 (left) Voter packet for Ralph Avey Sr.

P-759 MIAMI-00142 Voter packet for Mary Baker

P-760 MIAMI-00171 Voter packet for Kathleen Barnhart

P-761 MIAMI-00138 Voter packet for Goldie Bricker

P-762 MIAMI-00169 Voter packet for Eleanor Brubaker

P-763 MIAMI-00137 Voter packet for Mildred Chapman

P-764 MIAMI-00076 (right) Voter packet for Dorcas Ditmer

P-765 MIAMI-00079 (right) Voter packet for Leslie Grissom

P-766 MIAMI-00078 (right) Voter packet for Barbara Hall

P-767 MIAMI-00140 Voter packet for Martha Hoernemann

P-768 MIAMI-00141 Voter packet for Nila Houseman

P-769 MIAMI-00080 (right) Voter packet for Tanya Lantz

P-770 MIAMI-00080 (left) Voter packet for Claudia Lawson

P-771 MIAMI-00078 (left) Voter packet for Pamela Orem

P-772 MIAMI-00077 (left) Voter packet for Randall Orem

P-773 MIAMI-00077 (right) Voter packet for Betty Patty

P-774 MIAMI-00075 (left) Voter packet for Michael Schelle

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 49 of 289 PAGEID #: 31228

50

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-775 MIAMI-00170 Voter packet for Jean Thornton

P-776 MIAMI-00076 (left) Voter packet for Lori Wilson

P-777 MIAMI-00168 Voter packet for Maxine Yoder

P-778 MIAMI-00130 Voter packet for Bahaadin Al-Jarani

P-779 MIAMI-00073 (left) Voter packet for Vianna Bagwell

P-780 MIAMI-00074 (right) Voter packet for Carol Brown

P-781 MIAMI-00083 (right) Voter packet for Ray Emberton

P-782 MIAMI-00084 (right) Voter packet for David Green

P-783 MIAMI-00091(left) Voter packet for Carl Johnson

P-784 MIAMI-00086 (right) Voter packet for William Willoughby

P-785 MIAMI-00083 (left) Voter packet for Brandon Wirrig

P-786 11/17/15 Subpoena to Miami County BOE

P-787 1/5/16 Subpoena to Miami County BOE

P-788 11/4/14 ALLEN-00034 –

ALLEN-000036

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Allen County

P-789 11/3/15 ALLEN-00042 –

ALLEN-00044

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Allen County

P-790 11/4/14 ALLEN-00037 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Allen County

P-791 11/3/15 ALLEN-00045 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Allen County

P-792 11/21/14 ALLEN-00030 –

ALLEN-00033

Allen County Board minutes

P-793 11/19/15 ALLEN-00038 – Allen County Board minutes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 50 of 289 PAGEID #: 31229

51

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

ALLEN-00041

P-794 Eff 11/12 ALLEN-00069 –

ALLEN-00070

Allen Count BOE Provisional Ballot Policy

P-795 ALLEN-00068 Allen County BOE Provisional Process Flow Charts

P-796 Rev 10/14 ALLEN-00046 –

ALLEN-00067

Allen County BOE Procedure Handbook

P-797 11/4/14 ALLEN-00073 –

ALLEN-00145

Provisional Audit Report for Allen County BOE

P-798 11/3/15 ALLEN-00146 –

ALLEN-00236

Provisional Audit Report for Allen County BOE

P-799 ALLEN-00344 –

ALLEN-00345

Voter packet for Maxwell Chad

P-800 ALLEN-00374 –

ALLEN-00375

Voter packet for Carrie Ramsey

P-801 ALLEN-00243 –

ALLEN-00244

Voter packet for Jondalyn Miles/Austin

P-802 ALLEN-00259 –

ALLEN-00260

Voter packet for Liesl Depalma/Bonifas

P-803 ALLEN-00314 –

ALLEN-00315

Voter packet for Aimee Horn

P-804 ALLEN-00366 –

ALLEN-00367

Voter packet for Annette Phillips

P-805 ALLEN-00370 –

ALLEN-00371

Voter packet for Christy Heaston/Plaugher

P-806 ALLEN-00276 –

ALLEN-00277

Voter packet for Alendra Cortes

P-807 ALLEN-00346 –

ALLEN-00347

Voter packet for Vondasha McDonald

P-808 ALLEN-00400 –

ALLEN-00401

Voter packet for Daniel Spicer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 51 of 289 PAGEID #: 31230

52

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-809 ALLEN-00257 –

ALLEN-00258

Voter packet for Jessica Bond

P-810 ALLEN-00312 –

ALLEN-00313

Voter packet for Michela Hinojosa

P-811 ALLEN-00326 –

ALLEN-00327

Voter packet for Mar Kieffner

P-812 ALLEN-00372 –

ALLEN-00373

Voter packet for Norma Rakowsky

P-813 ALLEN-00394 –

ALLEN-00395

Voter packet for Joel Siefker

P-814 ALLEN-00426 –

ALLEN-00427

Voter packet for Paul Weis

P-815 ALLEN-00280 –

ALLEN-00281

Voter packet for Benjamin Davis

P-816 ALLEN-00296 –

ALLEN-00297

Voter packet for Morghan Franks

P-817 ALLEN-00340 –

ALLEN-00341

Voter packet for Timothy Martin

P-818 ALLEN-00356 –

ALLEN-00357

Voter packet for Debra Mumper

P-819 ALLEN-00390 –

ALLEN-00391

Voter packet for Nartisha Shorter

P-820 ALLEN-00237 –

ALLEN-00238

Voter packet for Leann Altwater

P-821 ALLEN-00284 –

ALLEN-00285

Voter packet for Kendra Deeble

P-822 ALLEN-00300 –

ALLEN-00301

Voter packet for Kay Graham

P-823 ALLEN-00316 –

ALLEN-00317

Voter packet for Angela Hunt

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 52 of 289 PAGEID #: 31231

53

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-824 ALLEN-00350 –

ALLEN-00351

Voter packet for Kara McKinney

P-825 ALLEN-00382 –

ALLEN-00383

Voter packet for Eva Richards

P-826 ALLEN-00398 –

ALLEN-00399

Voter packet for Mary Spence

P-827 ALLEN-00410 –

ALLEN-00411

Voter packet for Rebecca Tellez/Hampton

P-828 ALLEN-00422 –

ALLEN-00423

Voter packet for Robert Wardle

P-829 ALLEN-00428 –

ALLEN-00429

Voter packet for Gage White

P-830 ALLEN-00434 –

ALLEN-00435

Voter packet for Jared Wittenmyer

P-831 ALLEN-00418 –

ALLEN-00419

Voter packet for Melanie Wapplehorst

P-832 ALLEN-00420 –

ALLEN-00421

Voter packet for Richard Wapplehorst

P-833 ALLEN-00255 –

ALLEN-00256

Voter packet for Dillon Bok

P-834 ALLEN-00278 –

ALLEN-00279

Voter packet for Jon Cottrell

P-835 ALLEN-00364 –

ALLEN-00465

Voter packet for James Patton

P-836 ALLEN-00392 –

ALLEN-00393

Voter packet for Lanette Shultz

P-837 ALLEN-00282–

ALLEN-00283

Voter packet for Robert Day

P-838 ALLEN-00286 –

ALLEN-00287

Voter packet for Robert Diehl

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 53 of 289 PAGEID #: 31232

54

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-839 ALLEN-00354 –

ALLEN-00355

Voter packet for E. Caroline Miller

P-840 ALLEN-00360 –

ALLEN-00361

Voter packet for Carolyn O’Black

P-841 ALLEN-00362 –

ALLEN-00363

Voter packet for Charles O’Black

P-842 ALLEN-00376 –

ALLEN-00377

Voter packet for Barbara Reese

P-843 ALLEN-00432 –

ALLEN-00433

Voter packet for Krista Winter

P-844 ALLEN-00241 –

ALLEN-00242

Voter packet for Tom Askins

P-845 ALLEN-00247 –

ALLEN-00248

Voter packet for Michelle Beining/Bowman

P-846 ALLEN-00249–

ALLEN-00250

Voter packet for Jennie Biggs

P-847 ALLEN-00251–

ALLEN-00252

Voter packet for James Binkley

P-848 ALLEN-00288–

ALLEN-00289

Voter packet for Mark Dingledine

P-849 ALLEN-00292–

ALLEN-00293

Voter packet for Jessica Eifert/Patton

P-850 ALLEN-00294–

ALLEN-00295

Voter packet for Susan Erickson

P-851 ALLEN-00304 –

ALLEN-00305

Voter packet for William Griffith

P-852 ALLEN-00306 –

ALLEN-00307

Voter packet for Heather Harmon

P-853 ALLEN-00308 –

ALLEN-00309

Voter packet for Michael Harmon

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 54 of 289 PAGEID #: 31233

55

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-854 ALLEN-00318–

ALLEN-00319

Voter packet for Cora Ingram

P-855 ALLEN-00322–

ALLEN-00323

Voter packet for Wilma Johnson

P-856 ALLEN-00324–

ALLEN-00325

Voter packet for Julie Jordan

P-857 ALLEN-00328–

ALLEN-00329

Voter packet for Ashley Klein

P-858 ALLEN-00330–

ALLEN-00331

Voter packet for Kyle Klein

P-859 ALLEN-00332–

ALLEN-00333

Voter packet for Cody Laman

P-860 ALLEN-00336–

ALLEN-00337

Voter packet for Michael Mantooth

P-861 ALLEN-00338–

ALLEN-00339

Voter packet for Troas Mantooth

P-862 ALLEN-00342–

ALLEN-00343

Voter packet for Walter Martin Jr.

P-863 ALLEN-00348–

ALLEN-00349

Voter packet for Catherine McKininey

P-864 ALLEN-00352–

ALLEN-00353

Voter packet for Willard Metzger

P-865 ALLEN-00358–

ALLEN-00359

Voter packet for Kerri Murphy

P-866 ALLEN-00380–

ALLEN-00381

Voter packet for Lloyd Reese

P-867 ALLEN-00384–

ALLEN-00385

Voter packet for Durwood Rooker

P-868 ALLEN-00386–

ALLEN-00387

Voter packet for Richard Rudisil

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 55 of 289 PAGEID #: 31234

56

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-869 ALLEN-00388–

ALLEN-00389

Voter packet for Anna Schiel

P-870 ALLEN-00396–

ALLEN-00397

Voter packet for Brittany Smith

P-871 ALLEN-00402–

ALLEN-00403

Voter packet for Danielle Stein

P-872 ALLEN-00404–

ALLEN-00405

Voter packet for Mildred Sutton

P-873 ALLEN-00406–

ALLEN-00407

Voter packet for Lynn Swallow

P-874 ALLEN-00414–

ALLEN-00415

Voter packet for Bruce Van Oss

P-875 ALLEN-00416–

ALLEN-00417

Voter packet for Leann Wannemacher

P-876 ALLEN-00424–

ALLEN-00425

Voter packet for Diane Watterson

P-877 ALLEN-00430–

ALLEN-00431

Voter packet for Jaclyn Wilson

P-878 ALLEN-00438–

ALLEN-00439

Voter packet for Benjamin Wright

P-879 ALLEN-00334–

ALLEN-00335

Voter packet for Bridget Lemaster

P-880 ALLEN-00408–

ALLEN-00409

Voter packet for Sharon Taylor

P-881 ALLEN-00245–

ALLEN-00246

Voter packet for Linda Basinger

P-882 ALLEN-00302–

ALLEN-00303

Voter packet for Stephanie Griffin

P-883 ALLEN-00378–

ALLEN-00379

Voter packet for Joanne Reese

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 56 of 289 PAGEID #: 31235

57

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-884 ALLEN-00026–

ALLEN-00027

Voter packet for Ella Theis

P-885 ALLEN-00028–

ALLEN-00029

Voter packet for Steve Webb

P-886 ALLEN-00018–

ALLEN-00019

Voter packet for Janelle Bogart

P-887 ALLEN-00261–

ALLEN-00263

Voter packet for Omari Brown

P-888 ALLEN-00264–

ALLEN-00265

Voter packet for Velva Bruce

P-889 ALLEN-00022–

ALLEN-00023

Voter packet for Octavia Grone

P-890 ALLEN-00274–

ALLEN-00275

Voter packet for Diane Converse

P-891 ALLEN-00290–

ALLEN-00291

Voter packet for Darrik Drake

P-892 ALLEN-00310–

ALLEN-00311

Voter packet for Pamela Hesseling

P-893 ALLEN-00320–

ALLEN-00321

Voter packet for Ella Johnson

P-894 ALLEN-00412–

ALLEN-00413

Voter packet for Teresa Thompson

P-895 ALLEN-00368–

ALLEN-00369

Voter packet for Haley Pinks

P-896 ALLEN-00003–

ALLEN-00004

Voter packet for Katherine Scott

P-897 ALLEN-00267–

ALLEN-00268

Voter packet for Gary Coby

P-898 ALLEN-00269–

ALLEN-00270

Voter packet for Nora Coby

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 57 of 289 PAGEID #: 31236

58

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-899 ALLEN-00298–

ALLEN-00299

Voter packet for Michael Fuerst

P-900 ALLEN-00253–

ALLEN-00254

Voter packet for Janice Boberg

P-901 ALLEN-00450–

ALLEN-00451

Voter packet for Carolyn Austin

P-902 ALLEN-00501–

ALLEN-00502

Voter packet for Davion Holland

P-903 ALLEN-00527–

ALLEN-00528

Voter packet for Wayne McVeigh

P-904 ALLEN-00543–

ALLEN-00544

Voter packet for Patricia Northup

P-905 ALLEN-00545–

ALLEN-00546

Voter packet for Joanne Reese

P-906 ALLEN-00556–

ALLEN-00557

Voter packet for Elizabeth Spyker

P-907 ALLEN-00456–

ALLEN-00457

Voter packet for Kevin Bruin

P-908 ALLEN-00458–

ALLEN-00459

Voter packet for Lucille Chapman

P-909 ALLEN-00523–

ALLEN-00524

Voter packet for Iva McCaslin

P-910 ALLEN-00541–

ALLEN-00542

Voter packet for Martha Myers

P-911 ALLEN-00564–

ALLEN-00565

Voter packet for Rose Ulrich

P-912 ALLEN-00446–

ALLEN-00447

Voter packet for Irvin Anderson Jr.

P-913 ALLEN-00448–

ALLEN-00449

Voter packet for Paulette Anderson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 58 of 289 PAGEID #: 31237

59

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-914 ALLEN-00452–

ALLEN-00453

Voter packet for Herman Brandyberry

P-915 ALLEN-00454–

ALLEN-00455

Voter packet for Wanda Brandyberry

P-916 ALLEN-00460–

ALLEN-00461

Voter packet for Mildred Cooper

P-917 ALLEN-00465–

ALLEN-00466

Voter packet for Jay Deerhake

P-918 ALLEN-00477–

ALLEN-00478

Voter packet for James Falk

P-919 ALLEN-00479–

ALLEN-00480

Voter packet for John Fickel

P-920 ALLEN-00481–

ALLEN-00482

Voter packet for Joyce Fickel

P-921 ALLEN-00483–

ALLEN-00484

Voter packet for Nancy Frey

P-922 ALLEN-00485–

ALLEN-00486

Voter packet for Judith Goodwin

P-923 ALLEN-00490–

ALLEN-00491

Voter packet for Joyce Henshaw

P-924 ALLEN-00492–

ALLEN-00493

Voter packet for Robert Henshaw

P-925 ALLEN-00506–

ALLEN-00507

Voter packet for Betty Kesler

P-926 ALLEN-00510–

ALLEN-00511

Voter packet for Angela Knott

P-927 ALLEN-00512–

ALLEN-00513

Voter packet for Doris Knott

P-928 ALLEN-00515–

ALLEN-00516

Voter packet for John Lutz Jr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 59 of 289 PAGEID #: 31238

60

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-929 ALLEN-00517–

ALLEN-00518

Voter packet for Hope McBeth

P-930 ALLEN-00519–

ALLEN-00520

Voter packet for Robert McBeth

P-931 ALLEN-00525–

ALLEN-00526

Voter packet for Jerry McClure

P-932 ALLEN-00529–

ALLEN-00530

Voter packet for Jerri Merricle

P-933 ALLEN-00537–

ALLEN-00538

Voter packet for Fredrick Myers

P-934 ALLEN-00558–

ALLEN-00559

Voter packet for Jeffrey Thomas

P-935 ALLEN-00570–

ALLEN-00571

Voter packet for Marilyn Wallace

P-936 ALLEN-00576–

ALLEN-00577

Voter packet for Chris Whitney

P-937 ALLEN-00578–

ALLEN-00579

Voter packet for Jane Whitney-Clark

P-938 ALLEN-00521–

ALLEN-00522

Voter packet for Delores McCall

P-939 ALLEN-00549 Voter packet for William Schroeder

P-940 ALLEN-00555 Voter packet for Lee Sorrels

P-941 ALLEN-00574–

ALLEN-00575

Voter packet for Daniel Whitaker

P-942 ALLEN-00473–

ALLEN-00474

Voter packet for Norma DuBois

P-943 ALLEN-00503 Voter packet for Linda Kahler

P-944 ALLEN-00514 Voter packet for David Kobs

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 60 of 289 PAGEID #: 31239

61

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-945 ALLEN-00440–

ALLEN-00442

Voter packet for Charles Altstaetter

P-946 ALLEN-00469–

ALLEN-00470

Voter packet for Jennifer Donovan

P-947 ALLEN-00471–

ALLEN-00472

Voter packet for Faye Doseck

P-948 ALLEN-00005–

ALLEN-00007

Voter packet for June Hanthorn

P-949 ALLEN-00488–

ALLEN-00489

Voter packet for Robert Harris

P-950 ALLEN-00504–

ALLEN-00505

Voter packet for Rita Kersker

P-951 ALLEN-00508–

ALLEN-00509

Voter packet for Craig Kiefer

P-952 ALLEN-00533–

ALLEN-00534

Voter packet for Martha Miller

P-953 ALLEN-00535–

ALLEN-00536

Voter packet for Alice Missler

P-954 ALLEN-00550–

ALLEN-00551

Voter packet for Margaret Sheets

P-955 ALLEN-00560–

ALLEN-00563

Voter packet for James Thorburn

P-956 ALLEN-00566–

ALLEN-00569

Voter packet for Mark Voehring

P-957 ALLEN-00572–

ALLEN-00573

Voter packet for Carolyn Werner

P-958 ALLEN-00580–

ALLEN-00583

Voter packet for Marcy Zink

P-959 ALLEN-00443–

ALLEN-00445

Voter packet for M. Louise Alstaetter

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 61 of 289 PAGEID #: 31240

62

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-960 ALLEN-00467–

ALLEN-00468

Voter packet for Curtis Dilbone

P-961 ALLEN-00475–

ALLEN-00476

Voter packet for Teresa Ervin

P-962 ALLEN-00494–

ALLEN-00497;

ALLEN-00499 –

ALLEN-00500

Voter packet for Edgar Henton

P-963 ALLEN-00584 Voter packet for Grace Jones

P-964 ALLEN-00531–

ALLEN-00532

Voter packet for Willa Miles

P-965 ALLEN-00553–

ALLEN-00554

Voter packet for Willie Smith

P-966 ALLEN-00539–

ALLEN-00540

Voter packet for Lois Myers

P-967 ALLEN-00547–

ALLEN-00548

Voter packet for Willis Riemesch

P-968 ALLEN-00014–

ALLEN-00016

Voter packet for Alexis Smith

P-969 ALLEN-00017 Voter packet for Betty Smith

P-970 ALLEN-00462–

ALLEN-00464

Voter packet for Katherine Cory

P-971 11/17/15 Subpoena to Allen County BOE

P-972 1/5/16 Subpoena to Allen County BOE

P-973 11/17/14 BUTLER-00712 –

BUTLER-00723

Board meeting minutes

P-974 11/16/15 BUTLER-00724 –

BUTLER-00733

Board meeting minutes

P-975 11/14 BUTLER-00010 – Provisional failure to print name

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 62 of 289 PAGEID #: 31241

63

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00012

P-976 11/14 BUTLER-00013 –

BUTLER-00027

Provisional failure to provide current address

P-977 11/14 BUTLER-00028 –

BUTLER-00038

Provisional failure to provide identification

P-978 11/14 BUTLER-00039 –

BUTLER-00041

Provisional missing or incorrect date of birth

P-979 11/15 BUTLER-00042 –

BUTLER-00076

Provisional failure to provide current address

P-980 11/15 BUTLER-00077 –

BUTLER-00089

Provisional failure to provide identification

P-981 11/15 BUTLER-00090 –

BUTLER-00096

Provisional missing or incorrect date of birth

P-982 11/14 BUTLER-00239 –

BUTLER-00611

Absentee Form 11-S missing or incorrect date of birth

P-983 11/14 BUTLER-00612 –

BUTLER-00711

Absentee applications missing or incorrect date of birth

P-984 11/15 BUTLER-00097 –

BUTLER-00197

Absentee forms missing or incorrect date of birth

P-985 11/15 BUTLER-00198 –

BUTLER-00238

Absentee forms insufficient information

P-986 11/17/15 BUTLER-00001 –

BUTLER-00003

Subpoena to produce documents

P-987 1/5/16 BUTLER-00004 –

BUTLER-00009

Subpoena to testify at a deposition

P-988 11/14 LUCAS-00055 –

LUCAS-00099

Provisional statistics

P-989 11/15 LUCAS-00029 –

LUCAS-00030

Provisional statistics

P-990 11/19/14 LUCAS-00031 –

LUCAS-00037

Board meeting minutes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 63 of 289 PAGEID #: 31242

64

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-991 11/16/15 LUCAS-00007 –

LUCAS-00011

Board meeting minutes

P-992 LUCAS-00038 –

LUCAS-00054

Redacted 2014 provisional ballot affirmation forms—have

requested unredacted forms

P-993 LUCAS-00012 –

LUCAS-00028

Redacted 2015 provisional ballot affirmation forms—have

requested unredacted forms

P-994 LUCAS-00229 –

LUCAS-00398

Redacted 2014 absentee identification envelopes—have requested

unredacted forms

P-995 LUCAS-00399 –

LUCAS-00569

Redacted 2014 absentee applications—have requested unredacted

forms

P-996 LUCAS-00100 –

LUCAS-00228

Redacted 2015 absentee ID envelopes and applications—have

requested unredacted forms

P-997 11/17/15 Subpoena to Lucas County BOE

P-998 1/5/16 Subpoena to Lucas County BOE

P-999 11/14 SUMMIT-00008 Official certification for provisional ballots Nov. 2014 election

P-1000 11/15 SUMMIT-00009 Official certification for provisional ballots Nov. 2015 election

P-1001 11/14 SUMMIT-01071 –

SUMMIT-01073

Official certification for absentee ballots Nov. 2014 election

P-1002 11/15 SUMMIT-01074 –

SUMMIT-01076

Official certification for absentee ballots Nov. 2015 election

P-1003 11/19/14 SUMMIT-00916 –

SUMMIT-01070

Board meeting transcript

P-1004 11/18/15 SUMMIT-00833 –

SUMMIT-00915

Board meeting transcript

P-1005 SUMMIT-00007 Text of letter to provisional voter with rejected ballot

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 64 of 289 PAGEID #: 31243

65

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1006 11/14 SUMMIT-00010 –

SUMMIT-00030

Provisional summary board review list

P-1007 11/15 SUMMIT-00031 –

SUMMIT-00058

Provisional summary board review list

P-1008 11/15 SUMMIT-00059 –

SUMMIT-00086

Provisional summary board review list

P-1009 11/15 SUMMIT-00809 –

SUMMIT-00827

Provisional ballot list

P-1010 11/14 SUMMIT-01626 –

SUMMIT-01627

Provisional no current address

P-1011 11/14 SUMMIT-01601 –

SUMMIT-01625

Provisional bad address

P-1012 11/14 SUMMIT-01521 –

SUMMIT-01550

Provisional missing or non-matching date of birth

P-1013 11/14 SUMMIT-01575 –

SUMMIT-01585

Provisional missing or non-matching identification

P-1014 11/15 SUMMIT-01468 –

SUMMIT-01520

Provisional bad address

P-1015 11/15 SUMMIT-01551 –

SUMMIT-01574

Provisional missing or non-matching date of birth

P-1016 11/15 SUMMIT-01586 –

SUMMIT-01600

Provisional missing or non-matching identification

P-1017 11/14 SUMMIT-00828 –

SUMMIT-00832

List of rejected absentee ballots

P-1018 11/14 SUMMIT-00670 –

SUMMIT-00704

Absentee voter ledger report

P-1019 11/14 SUMMIT-00161 –

SUMMIT-00262

Absentee voter ledger report

P-1020 11/15 SUMMIT-00705 –

SUMMIT-00733

List of rejected absentee ballots

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 65 of 289 PAGEID #: 31244

66

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1021 11/15 SUMMIT-00734 –

SUMMIT-00808

Absentee voter ledger report

P-1022 11/15 SUMMIT-00087 –

SUMMIT-00160

Absentee voter ledger report

P-1023 11/14 SUMMIT-01251 –

SUMMIT-01257

Absentee ID envelopes name problems

P-1024 11/14 SUMMIT-01077 –

SUMMIT-01083

Absentee applications name problems

P-1025 11/14 SUMMIT-01084 –

SUMMIT-01114

Absentee applications address issue

P-1026 11/14 SUMMIT-01218 –

SUMMIT-01250

Absentee ID envelopes missing or invalid date of birth

P-1027 11/14 SUMMIT-01115 –

SUMMIT-01147

Absentee applications missing or invalid date of birth

P-1028 11/14 SUMMIT-01183 –

SUMMIT-01217

Absentee ID envelopes missing or invalid identification

P-1029 11/14 SUMMIT-01148 –

SUMMIT-01182

Absentee applications missing or invalid identification

P-1030 11/15 SUMMIT-01295 Absentee ID envelope name problem

P-1031 11/15 SUMMIT-01278 Absentee application name problem

P-1032 11/15 SUMMIT-01314 –

SUMMIT-01315

Absentee ID envelopes address issue

P-1033 11/15 SUMMIT-01258 –

SUMMIT-01259

Absentee applications address issue

P-1034 11/15 SUMMIT-01300 –

SUMMIT-01313

Absentee ID envelopes missing date of birth

P-1035 11/15 SUMMIT-01264 –

SUMMIT-01277

Absentee applications missing date of birth

P-1036 11/15 SUMMIT-01316 – Absentee ID envelopes missing or invalid date of birth

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 66 of 289 PAGEID #: 31245

67

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-01331

P-1037 11/15 SUMMIT-01279 –

SUMMIT-01294

Absentee applications missing or invalid date of birth

P-1038 1/5/16 SUMMIT-00001 –

SUMMIT-00006

Subpoena to Summit County BOE

P-1039 11/17/15 Subpoena to Summit County BOE

P-1040 1/5/16 CUY-00001 – CUY-

00006

Subpoena to Cuyahoga County BOE

P-1041 11/17/15 Subpoena to Cuyahoga County BOE

P-1042 CUY-00007 – CUY-

00010

Nov. 2015 official provisional & absentee statistics)

P-1043 CUY-00787; CUY-

01062

Nov. 2014 & Nov. 2015 BOE provisional statistics

P-1044 CUY-00026 – CUY-

00037

Nov. 2014 BOE Report

P-1045 CUY-00011 – CUY-

00025

Nov. 2015 BOE Report

P-1046 CUY-01102 – CUY-

01106

Letters to Nov. 2014 provisional voters

P-1047 CUY-00078 – CUY-

00080

Letters to Nov. 2015 provisional voters

P-1048 CUY-00152 – CUY-

00184

Provisional ballot policy

P-1049 CUY-00137 – CUY-

00151

Nov. 2015 provisional ballot instructions

P-1050 CUY-00081 – CUY-

00101

Provisional voting PowerPoint

P-1051 CUY-00102 – CUY-

00112

2015 provisional replacement guide

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 67 of 289 PAGEID #: 31246

68

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1052 CUY-00113 – CUY-

00122

Processing the provisional voter training manual

P-1053 CUY-00123 – CUY-

00124

Rejection scenario quick guide

P-1054 CUY-00125 – CUY-

00136

DIMS provisional verification

P-1055 CUY-00185 – CUY-

00206

Vote by mail training manual

P-1056 CUY-00207 – CUY-

00461

2014 absentee missing or incorrect date of birth

P-1057 CUY-00462 – CUY-

00466

2014 absentee different address

P-1058 CUY-00467 – CUY-

00471

2014 absentee insufficient information

P-1059 CUY-00472 – CUY-

00563

2014 absentee missing or invalid identification

P-1060 CUY-00651 – CUY-

00653

2014 absentee uncertain why rejected

P-1061 CUY-00564 – CUY-

00568

2015 absentee missing or non-matching name

P-1062 CUY-00569 – CUY-

00603

2015 absentee missing or incorrect date of birth

P-1063 CUY-00626 – CUY-

00650

2015 absentee different address

P-1064 CUY-00604 – CUY-

00616

2015 absentee insufficient information

P-1065 CUY-00617 – CUY-

00625

2015 absentee missing or invalid identification

P-1066 CUY-00682 – CUY-

00710

2014 provisional missing or invalid address – redacted

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 68 of 289 PAGEID #: 31247

69

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1067 CUY-00654 – CUY-

00681

2014 provisional missing or invalid address – unredacted

P-1068 CUY-00719 – CUY-

00751

2014 provisional missing or non-matching identification –

redacted)

P-1069 CUY-00760 – CUY-

00768

2014 provisional missing or invalid date of birth – redacted

P-1070 CUY-00711 – CUY-

00718

2014 provisional missing or invalid date of birth – unredacted

P-1071 CUY-00827 – CUY-

00828

2015 provisional no printed name – redacted

P-1072 CUY-00826 2015 provisional no printed name – unredacted

P-1073 CUY-00876 – CUY-

00923

2015 provisional missing or invalid address – redacted

P-1074 CUY-00829 – CUY-

00875

2015 provisional missing or invalid address – unredacted

P-1075 CUY-00974 – CUY-

01024

2015 provisional missing or non-matching identification – redacted

P-1076 CUY-00924 – CUY-

00973

2015 provisional missing or non-matching identification –

unredacted

P-1077 CUY-01025 – CUY-

01038

2015 provisional missing or invalid date of birth – unredacted

P-1078 11/4/14 MEIGS-00001 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots

P-1079 11/3/15 MEIGS-00002 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots

P-1080 11/4/14 MEIGS-00003 –

MEIGS-00007

General Election Absentee Survey 10

P-1081 11/3/15 MEIGS-00008 –

MEIGS-00010

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots

P-1082 11/4/14 MEIGS-00011 Board meeting minutes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 69 of 289 PAGEID #: 31248

70

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1083 11/18/14 MEIGS-00012 –

MEIGS-00013

Board meeting minutes

P-1084 12/16/14 MEIGS-00014 Board meeting minutes

P-1085 11/4/14 MEIGS-00015 –

MEIGS-00025

Provisional Audit Report

P-1086 11/3/15 MEIGS-00026 –

MEIGS-00049

Provisional Audit Report

P-1087 MEIGS-00050 –

MEIGS-00051

Voter packet for Cindy Shull

P-1088 MEIGS-00052 –

MEIGS-00054

Voter packet for Kristin Bailey

P-1089 MEIGS-00055 –

MEIGS-00057

Voter packet for Morgan Windon

P-1090 MEIGS-00058 –

MEIGS-00059

Voter packet for Robert Berardi

P-1091 MEIGS-00060 –

MEIGS-00061

Voter packet for Stephen Hunt

P-1092 MEIGS-00062 –

MEIGS-00068

Voter packet for Amanda Eason

P-1093 MEIGS-00069 –

MEIGS-00070

Voter packet for Georgia Erwin

P-1094 MEIGS-00071 –

MEIGS-00072

Voter packet for Peggy Klein

P-1095 MEIGS-00073 –

MEIGS-00074

Voter packet for Michale Walters

P-1096 MEIGS-00075 –

MEIGS-00076

Voter packet for Diana Kimes

P-1097 MEIGS-00077 –

MEIGS-00078

Voter packet for Danny Barber

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 70 of 289 PAGEID #: 31249

71

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1098 MEIGS-00079 –

MEIGS-00080

Voter packet for Susan Deem

P-1099 MEIGS-00081 –

MEIGS-00082

Voter packet for Stephen Miller

P-1100 MEIGS-00083 –

MEIGS-00084

Voter packet for David Gloeckner

P-1101 MEIGS-00085 –

MEIGS-00086

Voter packet for Sean Stacy

P-1102 MEIGS-00087 –

MEIGS-00088

Voter packet for Kevin Ulbrich

P-1103 MEIGS-00089 Voter packet for Robert Bower

P-1104 MEIGS-00090 –

MEIGS-00091

Voter packet for Addie Buck

P-1105 MEIGS-00092 Voter packet for Paul Needhurt

P-1106 MEIGS-00093 Voter packet for Betty Cork

P-1107 MEIGS-00094 –

MEIGS-00095

Voter packet for Raymond Cook

P-1108 MEIGS-00096 –

MEIGS-00097

Voter packet for Coralee Cummins

P-1109 MEIGS-00098 –

MEIGS-00099

Voter packet for Carl Delong

P-1110 MEIGS-00100– MEIGS-

00102

Voter packet for Nara Hartman

P-1111 MEIGS-00103 Voter packet for Lisa Heater

P-1112 MEIGS-00104 Voter packet for Steven Heater

P-1113 MEIGS-00105 Voter packet for Barry Marshall

P-1114 MEIGS-00106– MEIGS- Voter packet for Linda Montgomery

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 71 of 289 PAGEID #: 31250

72

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

00107

P-1115 MEIGS-00108– MEIGS-

00110

Voter packet for Elsie Sargent

P-1116 MEIGS-00111– MEIGS-

00113

Voter packet for Patricia Spencer

P-1117 MEIGS-00114– MEIGS-

00115

Voter packet for Carolyn Bissell

P-1118 MEIGS-00116– MEIGS-

00117

Voter packet for Joyce Burke

P-1119 MEIGS-00118 Voter packet for Robert Craft

P-1120 MEIGS-00119– MEIGS-

00120

Voter packet for April Lowther

P-1121 MEIGS-00121 Voter packet for Mary Lyons

P-1122 MEIGS-00122– MEIGS-

00123

Voter packet for Joseph White

P-1123 MEIGS-00124 Voter packet for Todd Davidson

P-1124 MEIGS-00125– MEIGS-

00126

Voter packet for Donald Diddle

P-1125 MEIGS-00127– MEIGS-

00128

Voter packet for Regina Erlewine

P-1126 MEIGS-00129– MEIGS-

00130

Voter packet for Theresa Fridenstine

P-1127 MEIGS-00131 Voter packet for Mark Hall

P-1128 MEIGS-00132– MEIGS-

00133

Voter packet for Jerry Hayman

P-1129 MEIGS-00134– MEIGS-

00135

Voter packet for Clara Hendricks

P-1130 MEIGS-00136 Voter packet for Mary Hill

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 72 of 289 PAGEID #: 31251

73

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1131 MEIGS-00137– MEIGS-

00138

Voter packet for Shirley Johnson

P-1132 MEIGS-00139– MEIGS-

00140

Voter packet for Thomas Manuel

P-1133 MEIGS-00141 Voter packet for Rose Patterson

P-1134 MEIGS-00142 Voter packet for Edward Schoekel

P-1135 MEIGS-00143– MEIGS-

00144

Voter packet for Marcella Weber

P-1136 MEIGS-00145 Voter packet for Charles Cunningham

P-1137 MEIGS-00146– MEIGS-

00147

Voter packet for Henry Hunter

P-1138 MEIGS-00148 Voter packet for Amanda Klein

P-1139 MEIGS-00149– MEIGS-

00150

Voter packet for Wanda Wood

P-1140 MEIGS-00151– MEIGS-

00152

Voter packet for Mabel Sheets

P-1141 11/17/15 MEIGS-00153-MEIGS-

00166

Subpoena to Meigs County BOE

P-1142 11/14 FRA-02028 Official certification for provisional ballots Nov. 2014

P-1143 11/15 FRA-02025 Official certification for provisional ballots Nov. 2015

P-1144 11/15 FRA-02029 Unofficial tally for provisional ballots Nov. 2015

P-1145 11/14 FRA-2517- FRA-2519 Official certification for absentee ballots Nov. 2014

P-1146 11/15 FRA-803- FRA-805 Official certification for absentee ballots Nov. 2015

P-1147 2012-2015 FRA-2520- FRA-2522 &

FRA-2767

Categories of rejected absentee ballots 2012-2015

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 73 of 289 PAGEID #: 31252

74

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1148 11/17/14 FRA-817- FRA-863 Board meeting transcript

P-1149 11/20/14 FRA-809- FRA-816 Board meeting transcript

P-1150 11/17/15 FRA-876- FRA-936 Board meeting transcript

P-1151 11/19/15 FRA-864- FRA-875 Board meeting transcript

P-1152 2014 FRA-2818- FRA-2831 2014 PEO Training Manual – Paper Ballot Facilitation

P-1153 9/9/14 FRA-2832- FRA-2834 Voting Location Manager 1 instructions

P-1154 FRA-2049- FRA-2070 Provisional Ballot Verification guide

P-1155 FRA-2768- FRA-2771 Incoming Call Protocol and Fact Sheet for Absentee

P-1156 FRA-2288- FRA-2289 Letter to Absentee Voter and Form 11-S

P-1157 2014 FRA-3044- FRA-3047 2014 provisional no printed name

P-1158 2014 FRA-3048- FRA-3125 2014 provisional form incomplete

P-1159 2014 FRA-3126- FRA-3204 2014 provisional missing or invalid identification

P-1160 2015 FRA-3205- FRA-3211 2015 provisional no printed name

P-1161 2015 FRA-3212- FRA-3294 2015 provisional form incomplete

P-1162 2015 FRA-3295- FRA-3405 2015 provisional missing or invalid identification

P-1163 2014 FRA-2624- FRA-2717 List of 2014 rejected absentee voters

P-1164 2015 FRA-2718- FRA-2766 List of 2015 rejected absentee voters

P-1165 2014 FRA-3406- FRA-3421 2014 absentee forms name problem

P-1166 2014 FRA-4002- FRA-4194 2014 absentee forms address problem

P-1167 2014 FRA-3422-FRA-4001 2014 absentee forms missing or invalid date of birth

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 74 of 289 PAGEID #: 31253

75

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1168 2014 FRA-4195- FRA-4493 2014 absentee forms missing or invalid identification

P-1169 2015 FRA-4494- FRA-4536 2015 absentee forms address problem

P-1170 2015 FRA-4537- FRA-4742 2015 absentee forms incomplete or incorrect information

P-1171 FRA-4743- FRA-4763 Undated list of rejected voters

P-1172 FRA-2093- FRA-2098 Undated list of rejected voters

P-1173 FRA-2071- FRA-2092 Undated list of rejected voters

P-1174 FRA-2243- FRA-2287 Undated list of rejected voters

P-1175 FRA-2099- FRA-2242 Undated list of rejected voters

P-1176 7/13 FRA-2888- FRA-2892 July 2013 Voter Registration guide

P-1177 2013 FRA-2893- FRA-2899 2013 Voter Registration Database Information guide

P-1178 7/13 FRA-2900- FRA-2911 July 2013 Voter Query System instructions

P-1179 2010 FRA-2922- FRA-2955 2010 BMV/SSA Verification Documentation guide

P-1180 FRA-2965- FRA-2972 Resolving Potential Duplicates guide

P-1181 FRA-2973- FRA-2981 Resolving Audit Issues guide

P-1182 FRA-2982- FRA-2986 Voter Cancellation guide

P-1183 FRA-2987- FRA-2992 BOE Portal guide

P-1184 11/17/15 Subpoena to Franklin County BOE

P-1185 1/5/16 Subpoena to Franklin County BOE

P-1186 12/15/15 FRA-02886 – FRA-

02887

Directive 2015-23 re: Election Official Manual and Related

Directives

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 75 of 289 PAGEID #: 31254

76

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1187 9/5/08 PTF-00001 – PTF-00017 Directive 2008-80 re: Voter Identification Requirements

P-1188 PTF-00018 – PTF-00040 Substitute Senate Bill 205

P-1189 PTF-00041 – PTF-00074 Substitute Senate Bill 216

P-1190 PTF-00075 – PTF-00111 U.S. Election Assistance Commission -- 2014 Election

Administration & Voting Survey

P-1191 PTF-00112 – PTF-00120 Results from U.S. Election Assistance Commission -- 2014 Election

Administration & Voting Survey re: DRE machines

P-1192 8/5/11 PTF-00121 – PTF-00134 Petition for Referendum on Am. Sub. H.B. 194

P-1193 2/23/16 Curriculum Vitae for Dr. Jeffrey Timberlake

P-1194 1/11/16 Expert Report of Dr. Jeffrey Timberlake

P-1195 1/25/16 Dr. Jeffrey Timberlake’s Rebuttal to Expert Report of Dr. M. V.

Hood III

P-1196 11/6/13 Video of Ohio State Senate Session Part 2 Floor Debate on SB 205

(excerpts)

P-1197 Transcript of Ohio State Senate Session Part 2 Floor Debate on SB

205 (excerpts)

P-1198 11/20/13 Video of Ohio State Senate Session Part 1 Floor Debate on SB 216

(excerpts)

P-1199 Transcript of Ohio State Senate Session Part 1 Floor Debate on SB

216 (excerpts)

P-1200 2/19/14 Video of Ohio House of Representatives Floor Debate on SB 205

(excerpts)

P-1201 Transcript of Ohio House of Representatives Floor Debate on SB

205 (excerpts)

P-1202 2/26/14 Video of Ohio House of Representatives Floor Debate on SB 216

(excerpts)

P-1203 Transcript of Ohio House of Representatives Floor Debate on SB

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 76 of 289 PAGEID #: 31255

77

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

216 (excerpts)

P-1204 2/19/14 Video of Ohio State Senate Session Floor Debate on SB 205

(excerpts)

P-1205 Transcript of Ohio State Senate Session Floor Debate on SB 205

(excerpts)

P-1206 Project Vote Report: The Politics of Voter Fraud (Minnite)

P-1207 11/20/13 Ohio Senate Journal (SB 216)

P-1208 2/26/14 Ohio House of Representatives Journal (SB 216)

P-1209 2/19/14 Ohio Senate Journal (SB 205)

P-1210 2/19/14 Ohio House of Representatives Journal (SB 205)

P-1211 8/26/14 Cuyahoga County Board of Elections Board Meeting Minutes

discussing absentee ballot challenges.

P-1212 4/30/14 Email from B. Hester to [email protected] regarding press

release “Husted’s Office Confirms GOP’s Voter Suppression

Working”

P-1213 2/20/14 Email from M. Dilley to M. McClellan regarding Democratic Party

press release “Democratic Leadership Urges Kasich to Veto Voter

Suppression Bills”

P-1214 2/15/14 Letter from T. Burke to M. Dovilla regarding testimony to Policy

and Legislative Oversight Committee

P-1215 2/18/14 Testimony of J. Sherman on Ohio SB 216 (Feb. 18, 2014)

P-1216 2/24/14 Saving Votes: An Easy Fix to the Problem of Wasting Provisional Ballots

Cast Out of Precinct, Jon Sherman (Fair Elections Legal Network)

P-1217 2/18/14 Testimony of S. McNair on SB 216 (Feb. 18, 2014)

P-1218 12/10/14 Letter from T. Burke to M. Dovilla regarding testimony on SB 205

P-1219 1/29/13 Notes and letter from R. Watson to Franklin County Board of

Elections regarding double voting.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 77 of 289 PAGEID #: 31256

78

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1220 1/23/13 Envelope and letter from J. Karman to Franklin County Board of

Elections regarding double voting

P-1221 2/20/13 Letter from M. Mercedes Sanchez Moore, PhD to D. Walch

regarding double voting

P-1222 2/6/13 Letter from C. Bailey to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting.

P-1223 3/4/13 Letter from C. Scholey to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1224 1/30/13 Letter from S. Lang to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1225 3/16/13 Letter from T. Howard to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1226 2/23/13 Letter from R. Laparo to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1227 2/4/13 Letter from V. Kelley to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1228 2/8/13 Fax and cover sheet and letter from C. McGill to Franklin County

Board of Elections regarding double voting

P-1229 1/22/13 Letter from J. Rogers to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting

P-1230 4/4/13 Transcript of voter interview with R. Osman at Franklin County

Board of Elections regarding double voting

P-1231 1/23/13 Letters to and from D. and K. Kornberg and the Franklin County

Board of Elections regarding double voting.

P-1232 3/2/12 Letter from K. Clyde to Secretary of State Husted regarding HB 194

P-1233 7/23/12 Email from S. McNair to G. Quinn regarding Provisional

Envelopes/Ballots

P-1234 3/12/14 Email from M. Damschroder to M. Ostrowski, et al, Re: Guest

Column by Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted (Salon.com)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 78 of 289 PAGEID #: 31257

79

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1235 3/12/14 Email from J. Fleeman to H. Pelger et al., Re: Guest Column by

Ohio Secretary of State Jon Husted

P-1236 Photo of “Voter Fraud is a Felony” Billboard

P-1237 Photo of “Put the White Back in the White House” T-Shirts

P-1238 Written Testimony from Cuyahoga County Board of Elections’

Director Pat McDonald

P-1239 12/6/09 Email from M. Damschroder to J. Husted and J. Hughes regarding

additional signatures for Sub SB 8

P-1240 Items Senate Would Like to Address Prior to 2012

P-1241 5/5/14 Exclusive: Ohio GOP’s Secret Voting Scheme Deliberations, Spencer

Woodman (Salon.com)

P-1242 2012 Post-General Election Statewide Voter Fraud Report

P-1243 2/6/13 Letter from B. Connor to Franklin County Board of Elections

regarding double voting.

P-1244 Timothy Burke Statement on Senate Bill 380

P-1245 Is True the Vote Intimidating Minority Voters from Going to the Polls?,

Dan Harris and Melia Patria (ABCNews.com)

P-1246 10/1/12 Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Research Brief: Early Voting

Patterns by Race in Cuyahoga County, Ohio (Weaver and Gill, 2012)

P-1247 PL002335-38 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205 (As

Introduced)

P-1248 PL002339-43 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205 (As

Passed by the Senate)

P-1249 PL002344-49 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205 (As

Reported by House Committee)

P-1250 PL002350-54 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205 (As

Reported by Senate Committee)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 79 of 289 PAGEID #: 31258

80

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1251 PL002355-60 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205 (Final)

P-1252 PL002361 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 205

(Synopsis of Committee Amendments)

P-1253 PL002493-504 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216 (As

Introduced)

P-1254 PL002505-21 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216 (As

Passed by the Senate)

P-1255 PL002522-40 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216 (As

Reported by House Committee)

P-1256 PL002541-57 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216 (As

Reported by Senate Committee)

P-1257 PL002558-76 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216 (Final)

P-1258 PL002577-78 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 216

(Synopsis of Committee Amendments)

P-1259 PL003098-99 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238 (As

Introduced)

P-1260 PL003100-01 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238 (As

Passed by the Senate)

P-1261 PL003102-03 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238 (As

Reported by House Committee)

P-1262 PL003104-05 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238 (As

Reported by Senate Committee)

P-1263 PL003106-07 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238 (Final)

P-1264 PL003108 Ohio Legislative Service Commission Bill Analysis: SB 238

(Synopsis of Committee Amendments)

P-1265 10/23/13 PL002362-63 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Gary Daniels, ACLU of Ohio

P-1266 10/23/13 PL002364-66 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Carrie Davis, League of

Women Voters

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 80 of 289 PAGEID #: 31259

81

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1267 10/29/13 PL002370 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Ohio voter Susan Doup

P-1268 10/29/13 PL002376 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Sue Hetrick, Ohio Disability

Vote Coalition

P-1269 11/4/13 PL002377-82 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Eben O. Sandy McNair, IV,

Cuyahoga County Board of Elections

P-1270 12/3/13 PL002367-70 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Carrie Davis, League of

Women Voters

P-1271 12/10/13 PL002386-87 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Mary Siegel, Ohio Voter

Integrity Project

P-1272 PL002383-85 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Karla M. Lortz, Ohio Women

with Disabilities Network

P-1273 PL002401-02 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Catherine Turcer, Common

Cause Ohio

P-1274 PL002385 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Norman Robbins, Northeast

Ohio Voter Advocates

P-1275 PL002371-75 SB 205: Interested Party Testimony of Karla Herron, Ohio

Association of Election Officials

P-1276 10/22/13 PL002420-21 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Camille Wimbish, Ohio Fair

Elections Network

P-1277 10/23/13 PL002415 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Jocelyn Travis, NAACP Ohio

Conference

P-1278 10/29/13 PL002407 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Ruben Castilla Herrera, Ohio

Action Circle

P-1279 12/3/13 PL002413-14 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Rick Robol, Independent Ohio

P-1280 12/4/13 PL002403 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Bentley Davis, Ohio Alliance for

Retired Americans Educational Fund

P-1281 12/4/13 PL002411 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Deidra Reese, Ohio Voter Rights

Coalition

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 81 of 289 PAGEID #: 31260

82

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1282 12/4/13 PL002416-17 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Jocelyn Travis, NAACP Ohio

Conference

P-1283 1/14/14 PL002408-10 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Randal C. Morrison, Ohio voter

P-1284 2/11/14 PL002418-19 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Becky Williams, SEIU District 1199

P-1285 PL002404-05 SB 205: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1286 11/6/13 PL002422-23 SB 205: Proponent Testimony of Steve Cuckler, Delaware County

Board of Elections

P-1287 10/16/13 PL002424-25 SB 205: Sponsor Testimony of State Senator William P. Coley, II

P-1288 11/19/13 PL002426-27 SB 205: Sponsor Testimony of State Senator William P. Coley, II

P-1289 2/18/14 PL002581-82 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Ellis Jacobs, Miami Valley

Voter Protection Coalition

P-1290 2/18/14 PL002579-80 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Mike Brickner and Gary

Daniels, ACLU of Ohio

P-1291 2/18/14 PL002583-85 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Eben O. (Sandy) McNair, IV,

Cuyahoga County Board of Elections

P-1292 2/18/14 PL002600-12 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Jon Sherman, Fair Elections

Legal Network

P-1293 PL002597-99 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Peg Rosenfield, League of

Women Voters of Ohio

P-1294 PL002586-96 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Aaron Ockerman, Ohio

Association of Election Officials

P-1295 PL002613-17 SB 216: Interested Party Testimony of Ken Terry, Ohio Association

of Election Officials

P-1296 11/13/13 PL002992-93 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Camille Wimbish, Ohio Fair

Elections Network

P-1297 11/18/13 PL002970-81 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 82 of 289 PAGEID #: 31261

83

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1298 1/14/14 PL002982-84 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Randal C. Morrison, Ohio voter

P-1299 2/11/14 PL002990-91 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Becky Williams, SEIU 1199

P-1300 2/16/14 PL002796-801 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1301 2/19/14 PL002622-795 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1302 2/24/14 PL002618-21 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1303 2/25/14 PL002985-87 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Deidra Reese, Ohio Fair Elections

Network

P-1304 PL002988-89 SB 216: Opponent Testimony of Norman Wernet, Ohio Alliance for

Retired Americans

P-1305 11/19/13 PL002998-3002 SB 216: Proponent Testimony of Mary H. Siegel, Ohio Voter

Integrity Project

P-1306 2/11/14 PL002996-97 SB 216: Proponent Testimony of Mary H. Siegel, Ohio Voter

Integrity Project

P-1307 2/19/14 PL002994-95 SB 216: Proponent Testimony of Chris Long, Ohio Christian

Alliance

P-1308 11/6/13 PL003007-08 SB 216: Sponsor Testimony of State Senator Bill Seitz

P-1309 1/14/14 PL003003-05 SB 216: Sponsor Testimony of State Senator Bill Seitz

P-1310 1/14/14 PL003006 SB 216: Clarification of Sponsor Testimony of State Senator Bill

Seitz

P-1311 11/20/13 PL003109-11 SB 238: Interested Party Testimony of Carrie Davis, League of

Women Voters of Ohio

P-1312 12/3/13 PL003112-14 SB 238: Interested Party Testimony of Carrie Davis, League of

Women Voters of Ohio

P-1313 PL003115 SB 238: Interested Party Testimony of Ronald J. Koehler, Summit

County Board of Elections

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 83 of 289 PAGEID #: 31262

84

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1314 PL003116-19 SB 238: Interested Party Testimony of Aaron Ockerman, Ohio

Association of Election Officials

P-1315 PL003120-22 SB 238: Interested Party Testimony of Ken Terry, Ohio Association

of Election Officials

P-1316 11/18/13 PL003136-39 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1317 11/19/13 PL003170-71 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Andre Washington, A. Phillip

Randolph Institute

P-1318 11/19/13 PL003123-24 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Mike Brickner, ACLU of Ohio

P-1319 11/19/13 PL003158-59 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Project Vote

P-1320 11/20/13 PL003140-45 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Ellis Jacobs, Miami Valley Voter

Protection Coalition

P-1321 11/20/13 PL003146-52 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Gregory T. Moore, NAACP

National Voter Fund and Ohio Voter Fund

P-1322 12/4/13 PL003160 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Deidra Reese, Ohio Voter Rights

Coalition

P-1323 12/4/13 PL003163-64 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Pastor Dale B. Snyder, Sr., Bethel

AME Church, Columbus, Ohio

P-1324 12/4/13 PL003127 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Bentley Davis, Ohio Alliance for

Retired Americans

P-1325 12/4/13 PL003439-41 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Ellis Jacobs, Miami Valley Voter

Protection Coalition

P-1326 12/9/13 PL003137-39 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Adele Eisner, Citizens Alliance for

Secure Elections

P-1327 12/10/13 PL003125-26 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Manley Burke, Hamilton County

Board of Elections

P-1328 1/14/14 PL003153-55 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Randal C. Morrison, Ohio voter

P-1329 2/11/14 PL003156-57 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Randal C. Morrison, Ohio voter

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 84 of 289 PAGEID #: 31263

85

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1330 2/11/14 PL003167-69 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Catherine Turcer, Common Cause

Ohio

P-1331 2/11/14 PL003174-75 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Becky Williams, SEIU 1199

P-1332 PL003172-73 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Norman Wernet, Ohio Alliance for

Retired Americans

P-1333 PL003161-62 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Brian Rothenberg, Progress Ohio

P-1334 PL003165-66 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Professor Daniel P. Tokaji, Ohio

State University, Moritz College of Law

P-1335 PL003128-35 SB 238: Opponent Testimony of Brian Davis, Northeast Ohio

Coalition for the Homeless

P-1336 12/10/13 PL003176-77 SB 238: Proponent Testimony of Chris Long, Ohio Christian

Alliance

P-1337 12/10/13 PL003178-81 SB 238: Proponent Testimony of Mary Siegel, Ohio Voter Integrity

Project

P-1338 12/10/13 PL003182-84 SB 238: Proponent Testimony of Dana Walch, Franklin County

Board of Elections

P-1339 11/19/13 PL003185-86 SB 238: Sponsor Testimony of State Senator Frank LaRose

P-1340 10/16/13 PL002293-95 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #201, Article #19,

coverage of SB 205

P-1341 10/23/13 PL002296-99 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #206, Article #2,

coverage of SB 205

P-1342 10/29/13 PL002300-01 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #210, Article #14,

coverage of SB 205

P-1343 11/6/13 PL002309-13 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #216, Article #2,

coverage of SB 205

P-1344 11/6/13 PL002452-54 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #216, Article #17,

coverage of SB 216

P-1345 11/12/13 PL002455-58 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #219, Article #1,

coverage of SB 216

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 85 of 289 PAGEID #: 31264

86

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1346 11/19/13 PL002459-64;

PL003039-44

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #224, Article #3,

coverage of SB 216, SB 238

P-1347 11/19/13 PL002272 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #224, Article #4,

coverage of SB 205

P-1348 11/20/13 PL002468-73

PL003052-57

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #225, Article #4,

coverage of SB 216, SB 238

P-1349 12/3/13 PL003020-22 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #233, Article #14,

coverage of SB 238

P-1350 12/4/13 PL002277-81;

PL003023-27

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #234, Article #6,

coverage of SB 205, SB 238

P-1351 12/10/13 PL002282-85;

PL003028-31

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #82, Report #238, Article #6,

coverage of SB 205, SB 238

P-1352 1/14/14 PL002263-65;

PL002431-33;

PL003011-13

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #9, Article #3,

coverage of SB 205, SB 216, SB 238

P-1353 2/11/14 PL002266-71 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #28, Article #1,

coverage of SB 205

P-1354 2/11/14 PL002434-36 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #28, Article #26,

coverage of SB 216

P-1355 2/18/14 PL002437-41 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #32, Article #1,

coverage of SB 216

P-1356 2/19/14 PL002286-92;

PL002302-08;

PL003032-38;

PL003045-51

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #33, Article #1,

coverage of SB 205, SB 238

P-1357 2/19/14 PL002422-48 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #33, Article #4,

coverage of SB 216

P-1358 2/21/14 PL002261-62;

PL003009-10

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #35, Article #3,

coverage of SB 205, SB 238

P-1359 2/25/14 PL002445-48 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #37, Article #1,

coverage of SB 216

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 86 of 289 PAGEID #: 31265

87

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1360 2/26/14 PL002449-51;

PL002465-67

Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #38, Article #1,

coverage of SB 216

P-1361 2/28/14 PL002428-30 Gongwer Ohio News Service Vol #83, Report #40, Article #6,

coverage of SB 216

P-1362 11/1/13 PL002475 The Hannah Report, “General Assembly Pauses for Election, Goes

Full Throttle Wednesday” (SB 205)

P-1363 11/6/13 PL002486-87 The Hannah Report, “Senate Moves Absentee Ballot Bill, Begins

Debate on Provisional Ballots” (SB 205, SB 216)

P-1364 11/6/13 PL002330 The Hannah Report, “Senate Sends Two Bills to Governor” (SB

205)

P-1365 11/19/13 PL002481-82 The Hannah Report, “New Senate Bill Would Shorten Early

Voting; Provisional Bill Sees Changes” (SB 216)

P-1366 11/20/13 PL002488-89 The Hannah Report, “Senate OKs End to Golden Week, Cap on

Controlling Board Appropriations” (SB 216)

P-1367 12/5/13 PL003072 The Hannah Report, “Left-Leaning Group Slams Dozen-Plus

Election Bills as ‘Voter Suppression’” (SB 238)

P-1368 12/14/13 PL002327 The Hannah Report, “Opponents Line Up against Elections Bills in

House Committee” (SB 205)

P-1369 12/15/13 PL002323 The Hannah Report, “Left-Leaning Group Slams Dozen-Plus

Election Bills as ‘Voter Suppression’” (SB 205)

P-1370 2/5/14 PL003071 The Hannah Report, “Kasich Faces Questions on Policy, Politics

from Ohio Newspaper Association” (SB 238)

P-1371 2/11/14 PL002331-32 The Hannah Report, “Tempers Flare as Committee OKs Trimming

Early Voting, Absentee Ballot Legislation” (SB 205)

P-1372 2/13/14 PL003062 The Hannah Report, “DeWine Rejects Voting Rights Amendment

Language” (SB 238)

P-1373 2/19/14 PL002320-21;

PL003066-67

The Hannah Report, “House Passes Absentee Voting Bills; Senate

Agrees to Changes” (SB 205, SB 238)

P-1374 2/21/14 PL002322;

PL003422

The Hannah Report, “Kasich Signs Voting Bills; Dems File Formal

Protest over Debate’s End” (SB 205, SB 238)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 87 of 289 PAGEID #: 31266

88

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1375 2/25/14 PL002483 The Hannah Report, “Provisional Ballot Bill Clears House

Committee, Heads to Floor Vote” (SB 216)

P-1376 2/26/14 PL002476 The Hannah Report, “House Passes Provisional Ballot Bill;

Democrats Blast Bill, Voting Hours Decision” (SB 216)

P-1377 2/26/14 PL002484-85 The Hannah Report, “Senate Approves Tax Holiday, Green

Building Resolution” (SB 216)

P-1378 2/28/14 PL002478 The Hannah Report, “Kasich Signs Provisional Ballot, Motor

Scooter Bills” (SB 216)

P-1379 3/3/14 PL003085 The Hannah Report, “Voter Bill of Rights Amendment

Resubmitted to AG” (SB 238)

P-1380 3/4/14 PL002316; PL002474 The Hannah Report, “Democrats Begin ‘Testimony Tuesdays’ to

Oppose Voting Bills” (SB 205, SB 216)

P-1381 3/6/14 PL002318 The Hannah Report, “FitzGerald to Challenge New Voting Law”

(SB 205)

P-1382 4/1/14 PL003063 The Hannah Report, “Early Voting Begins: Last Hurrah of ‘Golden

Week’” (SB 238)

P-1383 4/8/14 PL002314-15 The Hannah Report, “Absentee, Remediation Provisions Dumped

as Panel Moves MBR” (SB 205)

P-1384 4/11/14 PL002317 The Hannah Report, “Campaign Corner: FitzGerald-Yost; Ohio

GOP; Endorsement” (SB 205)

P-1385 5/1/14 PL003058-59 The Hannah Report, “ACLU Files Lawsuit Challenging Early

Voting Changes” (SB 238)

P-1386 7/2/14 PL003073 The Hannah Report, “NAACP: Ending ‘Golden Week’ Hurts

Minorities, Poor Voters” (SB 238)

P-1387 8/11/14 PL003070 The Hannah Report, “Judge Who Ordered More Early Voting

Hears Arguments in New Case” (SB 238)

P-1388 9/4/14 PL003069 The Hannah Report, “Judge Rules against Eliminating ‘Golden

Week,’ Uniform Early Voting Hours Directive” (SB 238)

P-1389 9/8/14 PL003064 The Hannah Report, “General Assembly OK’d to Intervene in

Early Voting Lawsuit; SOS Asks for Accelerated Appeal” (SB 238)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 88 of 289 PAGEID #: 31267

89

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1390 9/9/14 PL003077 The Hannah Report, “Senate Democrats Propose Early Voting

Changes” (SB 238)

P-1391 9/10/14 PL003065 The Hannah Report, “House Dems Want Separate Attorneys in

Early Voting Appeal” (SB 238)

P-1392 9/15/14 PL003068 The Hannah Report, “Husted Orders Elections Boards to Prepare

for ‘Golden Week,’ Continues Appeal” (SB 238)

P-1393 9/24/14 PL003080 The Hannah Report, “Sixth Circuit Upholds Order to Restore

‘Golden Week,’ Early Voting; Husted to Ask for En Banc Review”

(SB 238)

P-1394 9/25/14 PL003061 The Hannah Report, “AG Argues Early Voting Decision Goes

Against Precedent” (SB 238)

P-1395 9/26/14 PL003081 The Hannah Report, “State Appeals Early Voting Ruling to U.S.

Supreme Court” (SB 238)

P-1396 9/29/14 PL003084 The Hannah Report, “U.S. Supreme Court Blocks Early Voting in

Ohio” (SB 238)

P-1397 4/16/15 PL002326 The Hannah Report, “Omnibus Budget Amendment to Include

Absentee Ballot Funds” (SB 205)

P-1398 4/17/15 PL003060 The Hannah Report, “ACLU, Husted Settle Early Voting Lawsuit;

Both Declare Victory” (SB 238)

P-1399 5/11/15 PL002324; PL002479;

PL003074

The Hannah Report, “New Federal Lawsuit Challenges Voting

Restrictions” (SB 205, SB 216, SB 238)

P-1400 8/12/15 PL002325; PL002480 The Hannah Report, “New Filing in Voting Case Challenges

Absentee, Provisional Laws” (SB 205, 216)

P-1401 2/19/14 PL003087-88 Press Release: State Representative Mike Dovilla: “Ohio House

Passes Bill Eliminating ‘Golden Week’” (SB 238)

P-1402 2/19/14 PL002320-21 Press Release: State Representative Mike Dovilla: “Absentee Voting

Reform Bill Clears Ohio House” (SB 205)

P-1403 2/19/14 PL003091 Press Release: State Representative Cheryl Grossman: “Rep.

Grossman Announces Passage of Bill Eliminating Golden Week”

(SB 238)

P-1404 2/19/14 PL002334 Press Release: State Representative Cheryl Grossman: “Rep.

Grossman Applauds House Passage of Absentee Voting Reform

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 89 of 289 PAGEID #: 31268

90

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

Bill” (SB 205)

P-1405 2/26/14 PL002490-91 Press Release: Ohio Christian Alliance: “Provisional Ballot Bill Falls

Short of Fixing Problem with Provisional Ballots” (SB 216)

P-1406 2/26/14 PL002492 Press Release: State Representative Mike Dovilla: “Rep. Dovilla

Announces Passage of Legislation Helping More Provisional

Ballots Count” (SB 216)

P-1407 9/4/14 PL003092-93 Press Release: Secretary of State Jon Husted: “Statement from Ohio

Secretary of State Jon Husted” (SB 238)

P-1408 9/24/14 PL003094 Press Release: Secretary of State Jon Husted: “Statement from Ohio

Secretary of State Jon Husted” (SB 238)

P-1409 9/24/14 PL003089-90 Press Release: Ohio Democratic Party: “Ohio Voters Win, Husted

Wrong For The Umpteenth Time” (SB 238)

P-1410 10/7/14 PL003095-97 Press Release: Ohio Black Republicans Association: “U.S. Supreme

Court Decision concerning Golden Week and Accessibility to

Voting in Ohio” (SB 238)

P-1411 4/7/15 PL003086 Press Release: Secretary of State Jon Husted: “Husted Announces

Agreement in Early Voting Lawsuit” (SB 238)

P-1412 10/22/2008 PL000637-651 Deposition of Patricia Wolfe (in Case No. 2:06-cv-00896)

P-1413 07/13/2012 PL000652-656 Declaration of Brian Davis under 28 U.S.C. § 176 (Doc. #311, Case

No. 2:06-cv-00896 )

P-1414 06/10/2013 PL000657-658 Declaration of Brian Davis under 28 U.S.C. § 1746 (Doc. #362-1,

Case No. 2:06-cv-00896 )

P-1415 07/11/2013 PL000659-662 Declaration of Brian Davis Under 28 U.S.C. § 1746 in Support of

Motion to Extend and Modify Consent Decree (Doc. #378-1, Case

No. 2:06-cv-00896)

P-1416 07/03/2014 PL000663-723 NEOCH – Homeless Voting article

P-1417 06/30/2014 PL000724-740 Homeless Voting in Cleveland Ohio Presidential Election 2012

(Doc. #18-30, Case #2:14-cv-00404)

P-1418 07/08/2014 PL000741-743 Homeless Services in Cuyahoga County (Doc. #28-3, Case #2:14-cv-

00404)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 90 of 289 PAGEID #: 31269

91

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1419 05/14/2014 PL000744-751 ODPS Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles State Identification Card

P-1420 06/30/2014 PL000752-756 Ohio African Americans – Stats on AA population in Ohio (Doc.

#18-9, case no. 2:14-cv-00404)

P-1421 06/30/2014 PL000757-775 Early Voting Patterns by Race in Cuyahoga County, OH –statistical

study (Doc. #18-9, case no. 2:14-cv-00404)

P-1422 06/01/1965 PL000776-811 Voting Rights Act of 1965

P-1423 PL000812-827 Status Report of Legislation – 129th General Assembly – House

Bills

P-1424 PL000828 Status Report of Legislation – 130th General Assembly – Senate

Bills

P-1425 11/24/2013 PL000829-830 S.B. 205 (Coley) – Absent voter ballots-mailing-revise law/clarify

voter must complete

P-1426 11/06/2013 PL000831-834 Ohio Legislative Service Commission – Sub. S.B. 2015 130th General

assembly (as Passed by the Senate) Bill Summary

P-1427 06/02/2014 PL000835 Status Report of Legislation – 130th General Assembly – Senate Bills

P-1428 10/29/2013 PL000836-852 Ohio Legislative Service Commission – Sub. S.B. 216 130th General

Assembly (As Reported by S. State Government Oversight and

Reform) – Bill Summary

P-1429 05/10/2011 PL000853-860 Testimony of Eric Marshall, Mgr. of Legal Mobilization, Lawyers’

Committee for Civil Rights Under Law – Before the Ohio House of

Representatives State Government and Elections Committee on

House Bill 194

P-1430 05/10/2011 PL000861-867 ACLU to Senate Government Oversight and Reform Comm. &

House State Government and Elections Comm. Regard SB 148 &

HB 194 Opponent Testimony

P-1431 10/23/2013 PL000868-870 Carrie Davis, Ex. Dir. League of Women Voters of Ohio to Senate

State Gov. Oversight & Reform Comm. Regarding Interested Party

Testimony on SB 205

P-1432 PL000871-875 Interested Party Testimony Karla Herron Oho Assoc. of election

Officials SB 205

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 91 of 289 PAGEID #: 31270

92

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1433 PL000876-877 Voting Advocates Call for Changes to Absentee Ballot Mailing,

Voter Registration Bills (Absentee Ballot Mailing-League of

Women Voters)

P-1434 06/30/2014 PL000878-883 Ohio Assoc. of Election Officials Report and Recommendations for

Absentee Voting Reform (Doc. #18-33, Case no. 2:14-cv-00404)

P-1435 11/19/2013

PL000884-885

Sponsor Testimony – State Senator Joseph Uecker, Am. Sub. SB

200, House Policy and Legislative Oversight Comm.

P-1436 11/19/2013 PL000886-887 State Senator William P. Coley, II, 4th Senate District, Sub. Senate

Bill 205 Sponsor Testimony, House Policy and Legislative

Oversight Comm.

P-1437 PL000888-892 Interested Party Testimony, SB 216, Ken Terry, Ohio Assoc. of

Election Officials

P-1438 PL000893-897 Interested Party Testimony, SB 216, Aaron Ockerman, Ohio Assoc.

of Election Officials

P-1439 11/20/2013 PL000898 Senate Passes Seitz Initiative to Reduce Number of Provisional

Ballots Cast

P-1440 12/03/2013 PL000899-901 League of Women Voters to House Policy and Legislative

Oversight Comm. Regarding Interested Party Testimony on SB 205

P-1441 No date

listed

PL000902-904 League of Women Voters to Senate State Gov. Oversight & Reform

Comm. Regarding Interested Party Testimony on SB 216

P-1442 06/30/2014 PL000905-908 Written testimony submitted to the Ohio House of Representatives

December 2013—Opposition to SB 238 and the attempt to limit

early voting and eliminate “Golden Week.” (Doc. #18-31, Case no.

2:14-cv-00404)

P-1443 01/14/2014 PL003688-003690 SB 216 Sponsor Testimony, Senator Bill Seitz, House Policy and

Legislative Oversight Comm. To Mr. Chairman and Members to

present Senate Bill 216

P-1444 02/20/2014 PL003691-003692 Project Vote to Gov. Kasich letter urging veto of Senate Bills 205

and 238

P-1445 02/20/2014 PL000909 Rep. Dovilla applauds House Passage of Absentee Voting Reform

Bill – Majority Caucus Blog

P-1446 02/20/2014 PL000910-912 Democratic Leadership Urges Kasich to Veto Voter Suppression

Bills – Minority Caucus Blog

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 92 of 289 PAGEID #: 31271

93

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1447 02/21/2014 PL000913-914 Common Cause Media release regarding Voting Rights Advocates

Urge Kasich to Veto Voting Restrictions

P-1448 02/26/2014 PL000915 Press Release – Senator Turner Denounces General Assembly

Passage of Senate Bill 216

P-1449 02/27/2014 PL000916 Rep. Dan Ramos: Voter Suppression Bills, Directive Further

Attacks on Ohio Voter Rights – GOP advances political agenda to

disenfranchise, confuse voters

P-1450 03/01/2014 PL000917 SB 216 Passed Limits Provisional Ballots

P-1451 03/15/2014 PL000918-919 The New York Times – Ohio Mistrusts Democracy

P-1452 09/09/2014 PL000920-924 McTigue letter to Husted regarding Notice Period to

Supplement/Correct Provisional Voter Affirmation or Absentee

Voter ID Envelope

P-1453 07/01/2014 PL000925-926 The Blade – Ohio Senate GOP approves own bill for absentee

ballots

P-1454 07/01/2014 PL000927 The Blade – Ohio House endorses no-fault absentee voting

P-1455 07/01/2014 PL000928-932 Truth-out.org — How the Ohio GOP’s Attempts to Game Voting

Rules Backfired

P-1456 08/015/2012 PL000933-934 Politifact.com — Says Republicans supported legislation on early

voting and in-person voting in 2005

P-1457 08/21/2012 PL000935-936 Cleveland.com — Comment by Republican adviser to Ohio Gov.

John Kasich sets off howls of racism

P-1458 08/22/2012 PL000937 The New York Times — Racial Comment by Republican Official in

Ohio Rekindles Battle Over Early Voting

P-1459 07/03/2014 PL000938-939 The Columbus Dispatch — Republican’s absentee-ballot bill for

Ohio criticized

P-1460 11/13/2013 PL000940-941 Ohio Legislature contemplates more changes to voting, voter

registration

P-1461 02-11-2014 PL000942-943 Ohio set to pass tough new round of voting restrictions

P-1462 02/17/2014 PL000944 Cleveland.com — Ohio House panel readies for vote on new

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 93 of 289 PAGEID #: 31272

94

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

provisional-ballot rules

P-1463 07/03/2014 PL000945-947 Cleveland.com — Ohio House Republicans should walk away

from bills aimed at decreasing the ease of voting in Ohio: editorial

P-1464 02/18/2014 PL000948 Akron Beacon Journal – Ohio.com — Election partisans

P-1465 06/04/2014 PL000949-950 The Columbus Dispatch — GOP bill alters Ohio rules for

provisional ballots

P-1466 02/19/2014 PL000951-952 Cleveland.com — Ohio House passes bills to change absentee

ballot rules, eliminate six days of early voting

P-1467 02/19/2014 PL000953-954 The Blade — Don’t suppress the vote – To fight vote fraud that

doesn’t exist, Ohio GOP lawmakers are ready to disfranchise large

numbers of voters

P-1468 02/20/2014 PL000955-956 The Blade — Ohio lawmakers approve bills that put limits on early

voting – Democrats threaten lawsuit if Kasich signs the legislation

P-1469 02/21/2014 PL000957-958 Cleveland.com — Kasich signs voting bills that end Golden Week

and limit distribution of absentee ballots

P-1470 02/22/2014 PL000959 The Daily Record — No more ‘golden week’ for Ohio voters –

Kasich signs controversial election legislation

P-1471 07/03/2014 PL000960-961 Athensnews.com — Voter suppression or efficiency measure?

Views differ dramatically on new state legislation

P-1472 02/25/2014 PL000962-963 The Columbus Dispatch — Keep it simple – Lawmakers shouldn’t

complicate provisional-ballot requirements

P-1473 02/26/2014 PL00964-965 Cleveland.com — General Assembly passes latest voting bill

P-1474 02/26/2014 PL000966-967 The Columbus Dispatch — Provisional-ballot bill advances to

House

P-1475 02/27/2014 PL000968-969 The Blade — Additional voting rules approved by Ohio House –

Provisional ballots to be affected

P-1476 09/17/2012 PL000970-972 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary of State Jon

Husted Launches Another First to Clean-up Ohio’s Voter Rolls

P-1477 01/09/2012 PL000973-974 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Ohio Secretary of State

Husted Releases Absentee and Provisional Ballot Reports for 2012

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 94 of 289 PAGEID #: 31273

95

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

Presidential Election

P-1478 01/13/2013 PL00975-977 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary of State

Husted reminds Ohioans: One vote matters

P-1479 05/08/2013 PL000978-983 Directive: 2013-08: Husted to all County Board of Elections,

Directors, Deputy Directors, and Board Members regarding

Ensuring a more accurate and efficient statewide voter registration

database

P-1480 09/20/2013 PL000984-987 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary of State

Husted Addresses Presidential Commission on Election

Administration in Cincinnati

P-1481 10/29/2013 PL000988 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary of State Jon

Husted Marks Major Achievement in Ongoing Effort to Maintain

Ohio’s Voter Rolls

P-1482 05/21/2014 PL000989-992 Directive 2014-15: Husted to all County Board of Elections,

Directors, Deputy Directors, and Board Members regarding

Preparation for the Statewide Mailing of Absentee Ballot

Applications for the November 4, 2014 General Election

P-1483 05/21/2014 PL000993-994 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary of State

Husted, Boards of Elections Set Sights on Administering a

Successful 2014 General Election

P-1484 06/02/2014 PL000995-996 Press Release - The Office: Media Center — Secretary Husted

Outlines What Voters Need to Know in Light of New Election Law

Changes

P-1485 PL000997 Voter Information Confirmation Notice 3501.01(W) – form No, 10-

D prescribed by Secr. of State (7-12)

P-1486 PL000999-1000 Voter Information Confirmation Notice 3501.01(W) – form No. 10-

C prescribed by Secr. of State (6-10)

P-1487 PL001001 Attorney-in-fact Authorization Executed Before a Notary Public

(Form No. 10-F prescribed by Secr. of State (01-12)

P-1488 PL001002 Attorney-in-fact Authorization with Physician Statement

Acknowledged Before an Election Official – form No. 10-G

prescribed by Secr. of State (01-12)

P-1489 PL001003 Acknowledgment Notice – form No. 10-J (06-14)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 95 of 289 PAGEID #: 31274

96

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1490 PL001004 Notice of Change of Name – form No. 10-L prescribed by Secr. of

State (06-14)

P-1491 PL001005 Important Information about your Ohio Voter Registration

Confirmation Notice – form No. 10-5 prescribed by Secr. of State

(3-15)

P-1492 PL001006 Application for Absent Voter’s Ballot – form No. 11-A prescribed

by Secr. of State (06-14)

P-1493 PL001007 Application for Absent Voter’s Ballot by Voter Requiring

Assistance – form No. 11-F (06-14)

P-1494 PL001008 Application for Absent Voter’s Ballot Under R.C. 3503.16 by Voter

with unreported change of address and/or name – form no. 11-1

prescribed by Secr. of State (09-14)

P-1495 PL001009 Application for Absent Voter’s Ballot Under R.C. 3503.16 by Voter

with unreported change of address and/or name – form no. 11-1

prescribed by Secr. of State (06-14)

P-1496 PL001010 Absent Voter’s Ballot Identification Envelope Supplement Form –

Secr. of State Form 11-S (03-2015)

P-1497 PL001011 Absent Voter’s Ballot Identification Envelope Supplement – Secr.

of State form 11-S (06-2014)

P-1498 PL001012-1013 Instructions to Voters of Absent Voter’s Ballots – form No. 12

prescribed by Secr. of State (06-14)

P-1499 PL001014-1015 Identification Envelope Statement of Voter – Form No. 12-A

Prescribed by Secr. of State (06-14)

P-1500 PL001016 Provisional Ballot Affirmation – form no. 12-8 Prescribed by Secr.

of State (06/03/2014)

P-1501 PL001017-1018 Provisional Ballot Affirmation – Form No. 12-B Prescribed by Secr.

of State (1-12); also filed at Doc. #346-3 (in Case No. 2:06-cv-00896

on 11/01/12) –redacted

P-1502 PL001019-1020 Identification Envelope Voter Statement for Disabled Voter Aided

by Election Officials in Marking Ballots – form no. 12-C Prescribed

by Secr. of State (06-14)

P-1503 PL001021 Provisional Voter Precinct Verification Form – form no. 12-D

Prescribed by Secr. of State (06-14)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 96 of 289 PAGEID #: 31275

97

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1504 PL001022 Provisional Ballot Notice – form no. 12-H Prescribed by Secr. of

State (8-15)

P-1505 PL001023 Provisional Ballot Notice – form no. 12-H Prescribed by Secr. of

State (06-14)

P-1506 PL001024-1025 Voter Registration and Information Update Form

P-1507 May 6, 2014 PL001026-1054 Precinct Election Official Manual – My Vote, My Right, My

Responsibility, Jon Husted, Ohio Secr. of State

P-1508 Oct. 2008 PL001055-1099 Statewide Voter Registration Database System Manual

P-1509 09-22-2015 PL001100-1275 Ohio Counties QuickFacts from the US census Bureau

P-1510 Census

2010

PL001276-1453 Ohio Development Services Agency – demographic and race stats

by county

P-1511 06/18/2014 PL001454-1542 Ohio QuickFacts form the US Census Bureau – state and county

QuickFacts

P-1512 2010 PL001543-1571 US Election Assistance Commission

2010 Election Administration & Voting Survey

P-1513 2012 PL001572-1600 US Election Assistance Commission

2012 Election Administration & Voting Survey

P-1514 PL001601- 1673 2014 Election Administration and Voting Survey Data File

Codebook

P-1515 PL001674 – 1685 Spreadsheet of Nov. 2010 Ballot Date & 2010 U.S. Census Data

P-1516 PL001686-1694 Spreadsheet of Nov. 2012 Ballot Date & 2010 U.S. Census Data

P-1517 PL001695- 1706 Spreadsheet of Nov. 2014 Ballot Date & 2010 U.S. Census Data

P-1518 10/30/14 PL001707- 1709 Media Release – Plaintiffs in Voting-Rights Case Propose

Complaint Against Ohio Secretary of State Husted and Attorney

General DeWine to Rescind Restrictions Intended to

Disenfranchise African-American, Latino, and Democratic Voters

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 97 of 289 PAGEID #: 31276

98

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1519 9/16/14 PL003445 Email exchange between Davis and Pat McDonald re changes in

law re early voting.

P-1520 6/20/14 PL003446-3451

Email exchange with C. Bryant, E. Anthony, B. Davis, and others re

voter-registration training, with attachment (Nonprofit Vote 2014

Partner Agreement)

P-1521 3/14/13 PL003452-3454

Email from C. Johnston to B. Davis re changes in voting law

P-1522 3/14/13 PL003455-3458 Email exchange between B. Davis and C. Johnston re changes in

early-voting law

P-1523 3/14/13 PL003459-3466

Email between B. Davis (NEOCH) and C. Johnston, with

attachment (Ohio Association of Election Officials – Report for

Absentee Voting Reform)

P-1524 12/9/14 PL003467-3469

Email from NonProfit Vote to NEOCH re voting update and voter

population served by nonprofits

P-1525 4/16/15 PL003470-3472

Email from A. Tombazzi to B. Davis and others re reforms

P-1526 8/6/13 PL003472-3475 Email from E. Kelly to NEOCH and others re policy changes on ID

requirements

P-1527 7/7/14 PL003476-3477

Email exchange between E. Anthony and B. Davis re NEOCH’s

2014 materials for homeless voting

P-1528 6/10/14 PL003478

Email exchange between C. Bryant and B. Davis re NEOCH

training re registering homeless people to vote with the changes in

the rules

P-1529 7/10/14 PL003479-3487

Email From E. Anthony to B. Davis and others re NonProfit Vote

materials; with attachments re voting-grantee report and voter-

engagement training.

P-1530 7/7/14 PL003488-3491 Email from E. Anthony to B. Davis and others, including

Eventbrite link, re voter-engagement training

P-1531 2/5/15 PL003492-3494

Email from NonProfit VOTE to NEOCH re voter education

P-1532 12/17/15 PL003495-3497

Email from L. Foresman to B. Davis re NEOCH and voting-rights

activities in 2016, including review of applicable laws, with

attachment.

P-1533 5/26/15 PL003498-3503

Email from A. Tombazzi to voting advocates re updates

P-1534 2014 PL003504-3507 Email from B. Davis to A. Tombazzi in 2014 re voter education,

with attachments (brochure and flyer re “voting rules and

regulations”)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 98 of 289 PAGEID #: 31277

99

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1535 Jan.-Feb.

2014

WITHDRAWN January 2014 to February 2014 Program report to NEOCH Board,

including changes in voting laws

P-1536 3/12/14 PL003508-3512

Email from COHHIO’s Cathy Johnston to voting advocates re

changes in Ohio election law, including link to one-page summary

of changes

P-1537 2014 PL003513

LWV flyer for voting in 2014

P-1538 6/24/14 PL003514 Email from C. Bryant to B. Davis re question about homeless voter

registration

P-1539 8/21/14 PL003515-3516

Email from C. Bryant to B. Davis and others re Ohio Votes

conference call, with attachment

P-1540 1/17/14 PL003517-3521 Email from COHHIO to voting advocates re voter-engagement

plan

P-1541 8/4/14 PL003522-3523

Email from C. Bryant to B. Davis re voting-activity report

P-1542 11/7/14 PL003524

Email from A. Tombazzi to B. Davis re voting-activity report

P-1543 7/15/13 PL003525-3528

Email from C. Johnston to B. Davis re Homeless ID Collaborative

P-1544 8/6/13 PL003529-3532 Email from C. Johnston to B. Davis re report on efforts to limit

absentee voting

P-1545 11/12/15 PL003533-3536

Email from E. Kelly to B. Davis and others re ID Crisis

Collaborative

P-1546 Oct. 2014 PL003537-3541

NEOCH voting-activity status report (7/16/14 to 10/17/14)

P-1547 1/7/16 PL003542-3544

Email from Nonprofit VOTE to B. Davis re election preparing in

2016

P-1548 4/23/14 PL003545-3546 NEOCH Voting Plan for Ohio Votes Partnership – 2014

P-1549 Post-

9/12/14

PL003547-3551

Email from B. Davis to E. Anthony re voting status report, with

attachment (7/16/14 to 9/15/14 report)

P-1550 Post-

8/15/14

PL003552-3556

Email from B. Davis to C. Bryant re voting status report, with

attachment (7/16/14 to 8/15/14 report)

P-1551 Post-

10/3/14

PL003557-3559 Email exchange with B. Davis and A. Tombazzi re report of voting

activities

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 99 of 289 PAGEID #: 31278

100

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1552 PL003560-3562

Email from B. Davis to various others re Sept. 23, 2014 Homeless

voting event

P-1553 PL003563

Email from B. Davis to C. Joseph re odd-year voting activities

P-1554 PL003564

Email from B. Davis to C. Joseph re voter-registration efforts

P-1555 PL003565-3566 Voting 1-2-3 flyer

P-1556 PL003567-3569

Nonprofits VOTE 2014-NEOCH signed partner agreement

P-1557 PL003570-3576

NEOCH Homeless-voting information – for November 2014

P-1558 12/23/15 Plaintiff NEOCH’s responses to Defendant Husted’s

interrogatories

P-1559 12/23/15 Plaintiff CCH’s responses to Defendant Husted’s interrogatories

P-1560 1/18/16 Plaintiff NEOCH’s supplemental responses to Defendant Husted’s

interrogatories

P-1561 1/18/16 Plaintiff CCH’s supplemental responses to Defendant Husted’s

interrogatories

P-1562 2/1/16 Plaintiff NEOCH’s second supplemental responses to Defendant

Husted’s interrogatories

P-1563 2/1/16 Plaintiff CCH’s second supplemental responses to Defendant

Husted’s interrogatories

P-1564 2/6/16 Declaration of Katherine Galko

P-1565 2012 CCH Annual report

P-1566 CCH website (home, advocacy, education, vision, get involved,

member agencies, streetcard)

P-1567 CCH Brochure

P-1568 CCH minutes

P-1569 Ohio Secretary of State Annual Report 2014

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 100 of 289 PAGEID #: 31279

101

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1570 June 2013 PL003693-003710 Report on Provisional ballots and American Elections, prepared for

the Presidential Commission on Election Administration

P-1571 2014 PL003711-003770 Center of American Progress Report, Uncounted Votes: The

Racially Discriminatory Effects of Provisional Ballots

P-1572 4/8/14 PL003771-003772 PEW Charitable Trusts, Elections Performance Index

P-1573 2016 Steve Phillips, Brown is the New White

P-1574 9/16/15 Demos, Why Voting Matters: Large Disparities in Turnout Benefit

the Donor Class

P-1575 March 2015 Nonprofit VOTE, America Goes to the Polls 2014: A report on

Voter Turnout in the 2014 Midterm Election

P-1576 July 2013 Nonprofit VOTE, Can Nonprofits Increase Voting among their

clients, constituents, and staff?

P-1577 Dec. 2015 Nonprofit VOTE, Engaging new voters: the impact of nonprofit

voter outreach on client and community turnout

P-1578 May 2013 U.S. Census Bureau, The Diversifying Electorate—Voting rates by

race and Hispanic origin in 2012 (and other recent elections)

P-1579 Jan. 2015 U.S. Election Assistance Commission, 2014 Statutory Overview

P-1580 2006 U.S. Election Administration Commission, Casting and Counting

Provisional Ballots

P-1581 6/9/15 NCSL, Provisional Ballots

P-1582 NEOCH Member forms

P-1583 2013 PL000001 -8 NEOCH 2013 Community Benefit Report

P-1584 2014 PL000009 -16 NEOCH 2014 Community Benefit Report

P-1585 PL000017 NEOCH’s information re Election Day Voting, and Other Activities

P-1586 PL000018 NEOCH’s Voting FAQs

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 101 of 289 PAGEID #: 31280

102

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1587 PL000019 NEOCH post on Ohio Proposes to End Golden Week

P-1588 PL000020 NEOCH post on Voting Press Release Issued by Secretary of State

P-1589 PL000021 NEOCH post on Judge Marbley Decision Posted on our Website

P-1590 PL000022 NEOCH post on House Bill 263

P-1591 PL000023 NEOCH posts on House Bill 250 and 266

P-1592 PL000024 NEOCH post on Early Voting Has Begun

P-1593 PL000025 NEOCH’s additional Voting FAQs; main issues for voter

registration activities

P-1594 06/27/14 PL000026 NEOCH’s post on Updated NEOCH Voting Section of our Site

P-1595 09/04/14 PL000027 NEOCH’s post on Golden Week and Early Voting Hours Restored

P-1596 06/15/14 PL000028 -29 NEOCH post on Another Ohio Victory on Voter Rights

P-1597 2014 PL000030 NEOCH post 2014 Strategy for Homeless Voting

P-1598 2014 PL000031 – 37 NEOCH post on Frequently Asked Questions about voting and

homeless people (updated 2014)

P-1599 PL000038 NEOCH post on Event at Ohio’s Largest Shelter to Urge

Participation

P-1600 PL000039 NEOCH post on How Do I Protect My Right to Vote?

P-1601 PL000040 NEOCH post on The Power of Many Voices

P-1602 PL000041 NEOCH post on Final Report on Homeless Voting in the

Presidential Election of 2012 in Cleveland, OH – Statistics from the

Shelters

P-1603 PL000042 – 57 NEOCH report: Homeless Voting in Cleveland Ohio Presidential

Election 2012

P-1604 PL000058 NEOCH post on Homeless Voting

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 102 of 289 PAGEID #: 31281

103

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1605 PL000059 NEOCH post, NEOCH Supports Issue 1 – Fair Districts = Fair

Elections, Vote Yes on Issue 1

P-1606 PL000060 NEOCH post on News Updates This Last Week

P-1607 PL000061 NEOCH post on Senator Brown Asks for DOJ Help on Voting

P-1608 09-18-15 PL000062 NEOCH post, NEOCH Board Endorses Issue 1 for Fair

Redistricting

P-1609 PL000063 NEOCH post on Welcome to Ohio Elections, Justice Department—

What Took You So Long?

P-1610 PL000064 NEOCH post on We Remember the Civil Rights Act of ’64 While it

is Under Attack

P-1611 PL000065 NEOCH post on Sunday Early Voting

P-1612 PL000066 NEOCH post on Voting Press Release Issued by Secretary of State

P-1613 PL000067 NEOCH post on You Have Permission from the State to Vote this

Saturday

P-1614 PL000068 NEOCH post on Last Week to Early Vote

P-1615 PL000069 NEOCH post on What to remember when preparing your ballot

P-1616 PL000070 NEOCH post on National Voter Registration Day

P-1617 PL000071 NEOCH post on Good News for Protecting the Rights of Voters

P-1618 PL000072 NEOCH post on Golden Week Eliminated and Early Voting

Curtailed

P-1619 09-24-14 PL000073 NEOCH post on Successful Voting Event at 2100 Lakeside Shelter

P-1620 PL000074 NEOCH post on We Won an Extension of our Voting Agreement

P-1621 PL000075 NEOCH post on Sunday Early Voting

P-1622 PL000076 NEOCH post on You Have Permission form the State to Vote this

Saturday

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 103 of 289 PAGEID #: 31282

104

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1623 PL000077 NEOCH post on Potential Chaos in Voting Hours

P-1624 PL000078 NEOCH post on Voting Lawsuit Settlement Will Not Help

Homeless People

P-1625 08-26-13 PL000079 NEOCH post on Do We Need Early Voting?

P-1626 PL000080 NEOCH post on Voting Success in Last Election

P-1627 PL000081 NEOCH post on NEOCH Files Suit to Protect Provisional Voters

P-1628 PL000082 NEOCH post on Homeless People

P-1629 PL000083 NEOCH post on Homeless Voting Press Release and Report

P-1630 07-30-14 PL000084;

also

PL000087

NEOCH post on Welcome to Ohio Elections, Justice Dept.—What

Took You So Long?

P-1631 PL0000085 NEOCH post on Last Week to Early Vote

P-1632 PL0000086 NEOCH post on Supreme Court Blocks Golden Week in Ohio

P-1633 09/17/14 PL000088 NEOCH post, Press Release: Homeless People Do Vote!

P-1634 09/09/14 PL000089 NEOCH post, Volunteer to Help NEOCH Voting Activities – Do

you want to help homeless people participate in Democracy?

P-1635 09/04/14 PL000090 NEOCH post on , Golden Week and Early Voting Hours Restored

P-1636 PL000091 State of Homelessness 2011 – Cuyahoga Cty. Shelter Statistics –

Shelter Statistics in Cleveland/Cuyahoga County 2011

P-1637 12/31/13 PL000092- 104 NEOCH Compiled Financial Statements

P-1638 12/31/14 PL000105 – 117 NEOCH Compiled Financial Statements

P-1639 2013 PL000118 – 142 NEOCH – Tax forms for 2013

P-1640 2014 PL000143 -157 NEOCH – Tax forms for 2014

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 104 of 289 PAGEID #: 31283

105

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1641 PL000158 – 159 Brian Davis – Current Executive Director of NEOCH Resume and

Curriculum Vitae

P-1642 2014 PL000160 – 167 NEOCH 2014 Community Benefit Report

P-1643 PL000169 NEOCH FAQ post: Is it possible for homeless people to vote at the

BOE main office on Election Day no matter where they are

registered in Cuyahoga County?

P-1644 PL000176 NEOCH FAQ post: What are the main issues that I need to be

aware of for voter registration activities?

P-1645 06/15/14 PL000179 NEOCH post, Another Ohio Victory on Voter Rights

P-1646 PL000180 NEOCH post, NEOCH wants to help you register your clients and

encourage them to vote.

P-1647 PL000182 – 188 NEOCH post on FAQ (updated 2014)

P-1648 PL000209 NEOCH post on Homeless Voting

P-1649 PL000228 NEOCH post on Potential Chaos in Voting Hours

P-1650 PL000229 NEOCH post on Voting Lawsuit Settlement Will Not Help

Homeless People

P-1651 08/26/13 PL000230 NEOCH post, Do We Need Early Voting?

P-1652 PL000231 NEOCH post on Voting Success in Last Election – Homeless

People Do Vote

P-1653 PL000232 NEOCH post on NEOCH Files Suit to Protect Provisional Voters

P-1654 PL000233 NEOCH post on Homeless People

P-1655 PL000234 NEOCH post on Homeless Voting Press Release and Report

P-1656 08/05/2013 PL000235 – 236 We Won an Extension of our Voting Agreement

P-1657 PL000313 -319 NEOCH tweets regarding voting issues

P-1658 Nov. 2014 PL000320 -323 Homeless Voting Information in Cleveland/Cuyahoga County –

November 2014

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 105 of 289 PAGEID #: 31284

106

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1659 PL000324 Application to Vote by Mail

P-1660 PL000325 – 328 Voter Registration and Engagement Timeline for nonprofits and

human service agencies (2014)

P-1661 PL000329 NEOCH Advocacy Alert – NYC Announces Trailblazing Housing

Plan

P-1662 PL000330 Good Morning Advocates! Save the Date in July: Make your Mark

nonprofit voter engagement trainings – register here

P-1663 03/27/14 PL000331 Ohio Voice Table Meeting – Please bring your laptops/table/ipad as

we will do some hands on work

P-1664 PL000332-335 Nonprofits Vote 2014 – Background and RFP for Participating

Agencies

P-1665 2014 PL000336 LWV – 2014 Changes to Ohio election Law

P-1666 5/12/14 PL000337, PL000346,

PL000367

Nonprofit Vote Powerpoint and Voter-Registration

Information/Toolkit

P-1667 PL000347-353 Homeless Voting Information in Cleveland/Cuyahoga – November

2014, including FAQs about voting and homeless people

P-1668 PL000354-356 National Voter Registration Day material

P-1669 8/14/14 PL000358-365 Nonprofit VOTE Collaborative agenda and materials

P-1670 2014 WITHDRAWN National Voter Registration Day Organizer Toolkit

P-1671 PL000366-367 Guide to Voting in Ohio Brochure

P-1672 PL000368-577 GAO – Elections – Issues Related to State Voter Identification Laws

P-1673 PL000578-579 Declaration of Douglas J. Preisse

P-1674 06/20/14 PL000580-636 Racial Inequality, Racial Politics and the Implications of Recent

Voting Restrictions in Ohio: Analyses of Senate Factors One, Two,

Three, Five, Six and Seven of the Voting Rights Act – Expert Report

Submitted on Behalf of Plaintiffs in NAACP v. Husted

P-1675 9/3/15 PL0003577-3578 Letter from Sen. Brown to AG Lynch

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 106 of 289 PAGEID #: 31285

107

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1676 2014 WITHDRAWN NEOCH Flyer with Voting Info

P-1677 9/17/15 PL0003579-3580 Letter from Rep. Rudge to AG Lynch

P-1678 8/5/13 PL0003581-3601 Marbley Opinion and Order Extending Consent Decree

P-1679 PL0003602 NEOCH Flyer, Call for Volunteers

P-1680 PL0003603-3605 Nonprofit VOTE Awardee Status Report (July 16, 2014 to 8/15/14)

P-1681 6/3/13 PL0003607-3608 Letter from Davis to McDonald, Public Records Request

P-1682 6/10/13 PL0003609-3610 Brian Davis Declaration

P-1683 PL0003611 Ohio Votes Entry

P-1684 WITHDRAWN NEOCH Flyer with Voting Info

P-1685 PL0003612-3613 Agency Mailing Labels

P-1686 PL003614 One-pager on Voting Rules and Regulations: “What you should

know”

P-1687 PL003871-003873 Voting 1-2-3- Flyer

P-1688 WITHDRAWN NEOCH Ohio Votes Sept. Status Report

P-1689 PL003615-PL03618 Davis Testimony in Opp. to SB 238

P-1690 WITHDRAWN Davis Testimony in Opp. to SB 238 (copy 2)

P-1691 8/6/14 PL003619 NEOCH Central Intake Memo re Voter Registration

P-1692 7/15/14 PL003620-PL03622 NEOCH Ohio Votes Status report (June 1, 2014 to 7/15/14)

P-1693 PL003623 League of Women Voters/Ohio Votes 2014 Checklist for Voting

P-1694 PL003624-PL03630 Homeless Voting Informational Sheet – November 2014; with

FAQs about Voting and Homeless People

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 107 of 289 PAGEID #: 31286

108

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1695 PL003631 “Why should I vote” Flyer

P-1696 PL003632-PL03646 2012 NEOCH Homeless Voting Report with Recommendations

P-1697 6/27/14 PL003647 Homeless Voting: Social Service Training Sign-up Sheet

P-1698 PL003648 NEOCH Upcoming Events Flyer: “Homeless people can and

should vote!!”

P-1699 12/2013 PL003649-PL03652 Davis Testimony in Opp. to SB 238

P-1700 WITHDRAWN 2012 NEOCH Homeless Voting in Cleveland Report with

Recommendations

P-1701 4/23/14 WITHDRAWN 2014 Voting Plan, Informational Flyer

P-1702 WITHDRAWN NEOCH Upcoming Events Flyer

P-1703 04/2014 PL003653-PL003654 Nonprofit Vote 2014 Partnership Agreement

P-1704 12/2013 WITHDRAWN Davis Testimony in Opp. to SB 238

P-1705 PL0003655 Nonprofit Vote: NEOCH Grant Contract Form

P-1706 PL003656-PL003657 “What Nonprofit Staff Can Do” Flyer

P-1707 PL0003658 Voting Blog Entry “Cleveland Service Providers Encourage

Voting”

P-1708 PL0003659 Flyer for Golden Week Shuttle

P-1709 PL0003660 NEOCH 2014 Calling Script

P-1710 PL003661-003662 2014 Voting 1-2-3- Flyer: 3 ways to cast your ballot in 2014

P-1711 WITHDRAWN NEOCH 2014 Voting Volunteer Flyer

P-1712 PL003663 2014 1-2-3 Voting Registration Flyer

P-1713 PL003664-003665 2014 1-2-3- Voter ID Flyer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 108 of 289 PAGEID #: 31287

109

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1714 PL003666 2014 Driving to Vote Flyer: “Do you need help getting your clients

over to vote?

P-1715 PL003667 2012 Shelter Statistics

P-1716 9/15/14 PL003668-003671 Nonprofit Vote Monthly Status Report (July 16, 2014 to 9/15/14)

P-1717 PL003672 Voting Contract for State Voices

P-1718 WITHDRAWN Flyer for Golden Week Shuttle

P-1719 WITHDRAWN 2014 Checklist for Voting

P-1720 PL003673-003675 2014 Nonprofit Votes Partner Agreement with NEOCH

P-1721 7/15/14 WITHDRAWN Nonprofit Votes Monthly Status Report

P-1722 10/17/14 PL003676-003680 Nonprofit Votes Monthly Status Report (July 16, 2014 to 10/17/14)

P-1723 11/19/13 PL003681 Davis Witness Form for Testimony Ohio Senate

P-1724 11/19/13 WITHDRAWN Davis Witness Form for Testimony Ohio Senate

P-1725 PL003682-003685 Shelter Voting Chart

P-1726 4/23/14 PL003686-003687 Ohio Votes 2014 Partnership Plan

P-1727 1/19/16 PL003926 Letter to Sen. Brown Re Ohio Voting Procedures

P-1728 CCH Dec. 2014 Financial Statement

P-1729 CCH Dec. 2013 Financial Statement

P-1730 CCH Dec. 2012 Financial Statement

P-1731 CCH Dec. 2015 Financial Statement

P-1732 PL001853-1855 NEOCH Homeless Members 2011-16

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 109 of 289 PAGEID #: 31288

110

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1733 PL001774-1796 NEOCH List of Voters

P-1734 9/1/11 PL001797-1799 Letter to Senators Durbin and Graham (with Davis track changes)

P-1735 9/17/15 PL001800 Email re Voting Education Seminar re Ohio’s voting practices and

procedures

P-1736 PL001801 Voting Matters! flyer

P-1737 PL001802-1819 Emails regarding Senator Brown asking DOJ to intervene in voting

in Ohio

P-1738 11/2/14 PL001820 Email from B. Davis re voting activities in 2014

P-1739 PL001838-1852 Demographic Reports for Sheltered Homeless Persons (10/1/14 –

9/30/15)

P-1740 PL001710-1773 NEOCH Program Reports and Board meeting minutes (January

2013 – October 2015)

P-1741 PL001822-1837 Ken Payton Time Sheets

P-1742 April

2012

PL003927-3932 Davis Testimony submitted to the U.S. Senate April 2012 – Voter

Suppression Activities in the U.S.

P-1743 PL003771-003772 Emails, with attachments, produced by Plaintiffs in soft-copy in

folder labeled “NEOCH emails.”

P-1744 PL003874-003925;

PL003933-003937

Emails, with attachments, produced by Plaintiffs in soft copy in

folder labeled “NEOCH sent emails.”

P-1745 PL003773-003870;

PL-003938-003956

Emails, with attachments, produced by Plaintiffs in soft-copy in

folder labeled “VotingEmails.”

P-1746 Second Supplemental Complaint (Doc. #453)

P-1747 BUTLER-00051 –

BUTLER-00052;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Jennifer Allen

P-1748 BUTLER-00043 –

BUTLER-00044;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for James Bauder

P-1749 BUTLER-00061 –

BUTLER-00062;

Voter packet for Douglas Benge

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 110 of 289 PAGEID #: 31289

111

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00042

P-1750 BUTLER-00063 –

BUTLER-00064;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Sara Cook

P-1751 BUTLER-00045 –

BUTLER-00046;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Shannon Cox

P-1752 BUTLER-00059 –

BUTLER-00060;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Lucy Eisgruber

P-1753 BUTLER-00069 –

BUTLER-00070;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Matthew Faulkner

P-1754 BUTLER-00049 –

BUTLER-00050;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Jesse Funston

P-1755 BUTLER-00071 –

BUTLER-00072;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Danielle Lott

P-1756 BUTLER-00065 –

BUTLER-00066;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for William Marsh

P-1757 BUTLER-00047 –

BUTLER-00048;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Adrianna Murphy

P-1758 BUTLER-00055 –

BUTLER-00056;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Sharon Rumker

P-1759 BUTLER-00067 –

BUTLER-00068;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Rachael Sandlin

P-1760 BUTLER-00073 –

BUTLER-00074;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Euclides Silva

P-1761 BUTLER-00057 –

BUTLER-00058;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Gregory Vickers

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 111 of 289 PAGEID #: 31290

112

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1762 BUTLER-00053 –

BUTLER-00054;

BUTLER-00042

Voter packet for Michela Wagery

P-1763 BUTLER-00093 –

BUTLER-00094;

BUTLER-00090

Voter packet for David Holmes

P-1764 BUTLER-00040 –

BUTLER-00041;

BUTLER-00039

Voter packet for Michael Howard

P-1765 BUTLER-00095 –

BUTLER-00096;

BUTLER-00090

Voter packet for Ashley Martio

P-1766 BUTLER-00091 –

BUTLER-00092;

BUTLER-00090

Voter packet for Zachary Kanta

P-1767 BUTLER-00078 –

BUTLER-00079;

BUTLER-00077

Voter packet for Marilyn Bogle

P-1768 BUTLER-00029 –

BUTLER-00030;

BUTLER-00028

Voter packet for Monica Fening

P-1769 BUTLER-00031 –

BUTLER-00032;

BUTLER-00028

Voter packet for Derrick Ladd

P-1770 BUTLER-00088 –

BUTLER-00089;

BUTLER-00077

Voter packet for Margaret Lockhart

P-1771 BUTLER-00033 –

BUTLER-00034;

BUTLER-00028

Voter packet for Victoria Posmantur

P-1772 BUTLER-00086 –

BUTLER-00087;

BUTLER-00077

Voter packet for Megan Saupe

P-1773 BUTLER-00037 –

BUTLER-00038;

BUTLER-00028

Voter packet for Numhai Vu

P-1774 BUTLER-00084 –

BUTLER-00085;

Voter packet for Michael Lewis

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 112 of 289 PAGEID #: 31291

113

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00077

P-1775 BUTLER-00080 –

BUTLER-00081;

BUTLER-00077

Voter packet for Mary McCoppin

P-1776 BUTLER-00035 –

BUTLER-00036;

BUTLER-00028

Voter packet for Bradley Sedlacek

P-1777 BUTLER-00082 –

BUTLER-00083;

BUTLER-00077

Voter packet for Madeline Young

P-1778 BUTLER-00240 –

BUTLER-00241;

BUTLER-00612;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jimmie Adams

P-1779 BUTLER-00242 –

BUTLER-00243;

BUTLER-00612;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Britten Alexander

P-1780 BUTLER-00244 –

BUTLER-00245;

BUTLER-00612;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Daniel Amundson

P-1781 BUTLER-00246 –

BUTLER-00247;

BUTLER-00613;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Audrey Apking

P-1782 BUTLER-00248 –

BUTLER-00249;

BUTLER-00614;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ray Arguelles

P-1783 BUTLER-00250 –

BUTLER-00251;

BUTLER-00614;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Thelma Atwood

P-1784 BUTLER-00252 –

BUTLER-00253;

BUTLER-00615;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sue Back

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 113 of 289 PAGEID #: 31292

114

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1785 BUTLER-00254 –

BUTLER-00255;

BUTLER-00615;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Baier

P-1786 BUTLER-00256 –

BUTLER-00257;

BUTLER-00615;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Michelle Bailey

P-1787 BUTLER-00258 –

BUTLER-00259;

BUTLER-00616;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for David Baker

P-1788 BUTLER-00260 –

BUTLER-00261;

BUTLER-00617;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Avnish Bansal

P-1789 BUTLER-00262 –

BUTLER-00263;

BUTLER-00618;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Traci Barnes

P-1790 BUTLER-00264 –

BUTLER-00265;

BUTLER-00619;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kayla Bates

P-1791 BUTLER-00266 –

BUTLER-00267;

BUTLER-00619;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Richard Bates

P-1792 BUTLER-00268 –

BUTLER-00269;

BUTLER-00619;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Bernet Jr.

P-1793 BUTLER-00270 –

BUTLER-00271;

BUTLER-00620;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Stella Bertsche

P-1794 BUTLER-00272 –

BUTLER-00273;

BUTLER-00620;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Patsyann Biederman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 114 of 289 PAGEID #: 31293

115

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1795 BUTLER-00274 –

BUTLER-00275;

BUTLER-00620;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Keith Biehle

P-1796 BUTLER-00276 –

BUTLER-00277;

BUTLER-00621;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Dale Bishop

P-1797 BUTLER-00278 –

BUTLER-00279;

BUTLER-00621;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Beverly Blevins

P-1798 BUTLER-00280 –

BUTLER-00281;

BUTLER-00621;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Rickey Bliton

P-1799 BUTLER-00282 –

BUTLER-00283;

BUTLER-00622;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Austin Blue

P-1800 BUTLER-00284 –

BUTLER-00285;

BUTLER-00622;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for James Blume II

P-1801 BUTLER-00286 –

BUTLER-00287;

BUTLER-00622;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kevin Bowers

P-1802 BUTLER-00288 –

BUTLER-00289;

BUTLER-00623;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Alys Brown

P-1803 BUTLER-00290 –

BUTLER-00291;

BUTLER-00624;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Craig Buckner

P-1804 BUTLER-00292 –

BUTLER-00293;

BUTLER-00625;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Raymond Buller

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 115 of 289 PAGEID #: 31294

116

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1805 BUTLER-00294 –

BUTLER-00295;

BUTLER-00625;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Matthew Bunn

P-1806 BUTLER-00296 –

BUTLER-00297;

BUTLER-00625;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Christy Bushman

P-1807 BUTLER-00298 –

BUTLER-00299;

BUTLER-00626;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Deborah Busse

P-1808 BUTLER-00300 –

BUTLER-00301;

BUTLER-00626;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Richard Byrd

P-1809 BUTLER-00302 –

BUTLER-00303;

BUTLER-00627;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Tana Calvert

P-1810 BUTLER-00304 –

BUTLER-00305;

BUTLER-00627;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Lisa Campbell

P-1811 BUTLER-00306 –

BUTLER-00307;

BUTLER-00627;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for John Carr

P-1812 BUTLER-00308 –

BUTLER-00309;

BUTLER-00628;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Paul Cash

P-1813 BUTLER-00310 –

BUTLER-00311;

BUTLER-00629;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ivis Caudill

P-1814 BUTLER-00312 –

BUTLER-00313;

BUTLER-00630;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Howard Cohen

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 116 of 289 PAGEID #: 31295

117

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1815 BUTLER-00314 –

BUTLER-00315;

BUTLER-00630;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Lawrence Coombe

P-1816 BUTLER-00316 –

BUTLER-00317;

BUTLER-00630;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Barbara Cox

P-1817 BUTLER-00318 –

BUTLER-00319;

BUTLER-00631;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sue Cox

P-1818 BUTLER-00320 –

BUTLER-00321;

BUTLER-00632;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Patricia Davis

P-1819 BUTLER-00322 –

BUTLER-00323;

BUTLER-00632;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Carl Draginoff

P-1820 BUTLER-00324 –

BUTLER-00325;

BUTLER-00633;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Melinda Ecenrode

P-1821 BUTLER-00326 –

BUTLER-00327;

BUTLER-00633;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Gregory Ehlert

P-1822 BUTLER-00328 –

BUTLER-00329;

BUTLER-00633;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sarah Eisen

P-1823 BUTLER-00330 –

BUTLER-00331;

BUTLER-00634;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Stephen Evilsizor

P-1824 BUTLER-00332 –

BUTLER-00333;

BUTLER-00635;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Laura Fain

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 117 of 289 PAGEID #: 31296

118

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1825 BUTLER-00334 –

BUTLER-00335;

BUTLER-00636;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Helen Fields

P-1826 BUTLER-00336 –

BUTLER-00337;

BUTLER-00637;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for James Fritz

P-1827 BUTLER-00338 –

BUTLER-00339;

BUTLER-00638;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Frost

P-1828 BUTLER-00340 –

BUTLER-00341;

BUTLER-00639;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Anne Furia

P-1829 BUTLER-00342 –

BUTLER-00343;

BUTLER-00640;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Gallagher

P-1830 BUTLER-00344 –

BUTLER-00345;

BUTLER-00640;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Shawn Gallagher

P-1831 BUTLER-00346 –

BUTLER-00347;

BUTLER-00640;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Carmen Gant

P-1832 BUTLER-00348 –

BUTLER-00349;

BUTLER-00641;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Paul Gant

P-1833 BUTLER-00350 –

BUTLER-00351;

BUTLER-00642;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Donald Gentry

P-1834 BUTLER-00352 –

BUTLER-00353;

BUTLER-00643;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Gerbus

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 118 of 289 PAGEID #: 31297

119

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1835 BUTLER-00354 –

BUTLER-00355;

BUTLER-00643;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Larry Getz

P-1836 BUTLER-00356 –

BUTLER-00357;

BUTLER-00643;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Marilyn Glancy

P-1837 BUTLER-00358 –

BUTLER-00359;

BUTLER-00644;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sonya Graves

P-1838 BUTLER-00360 –

BUTLER-00361;

BUTLER-00644;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Mary Jo Gooden

P-1839 BUTLER-00362 –

BUTLER-00363;

BUTLER-00645;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Carl Grody

P-1840 BUTLER-00364 –

BUTLER-00365;

BUTLER-00645;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joyce Grody

P-1841 BUTLER-00366 –

BUTLER-00367;

BUTLER-00646;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Deborah Guy

P-1842 BUTLER-00368 –

BUTLER-00369;

BUTLER-00647;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Betty Hadley

P-1843 BUTLER-00370 –

BUTLER-00371;

BUTLER-00647;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sandra Hamilton

P-1844 BUTLER-00372 –

BUTLER-00373;

BUTLER-00647;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for James Harding Jr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 119 of 289 PAGEID #: 31298

120

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1845 BUTLER-00374 –

BUTLER-00375;

BUTLER-00648;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jane Harding

P-1846 BUTLER-00376 –

BUTLER-00377;

BUTLER-00649;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joseph Harrison

P-1847 BUTLER-00378 –

BUTLER-00379;

BUTLER-00649;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Reba Hart

P-1848 BUTLER-00380 –

BUTLER-00381;

BUTLER-00650;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Charles Hattery

P-1849 BUTLER-00382 –

BUTLER-00383;

BUTLER-00651;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Francis Hayes

P-1850 BUTLER-00384 –

BUTLER-00385;

BUTLER-00651;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Leslie Henne

P-1851 BUTLER-00386 –

BUTLER-00387;

BUTLER-00651;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Judith Hult

P-1852 BUTLER-00390 –

BUTLER-00391;

BUTLER-00652;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Mary Hult

P-1853 BUTLER-00388 –

BUTLER-00389;

BUTLER-00652;

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ria Hursting

P-1854 BUTLER-00392 –

BUTLER-00393;

BUTLER-00653

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Norman Hutton

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 120 of 289 PAGEID #: 31299

121

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1855 BUTLER-00394 –

BUTLER-00395;

BUTLER-00654

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Harry Jessee

P-1856 BUTLER-00396 –

BUTLER-00397;

BUTLER-00654

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Charles Johnson

P-1857 BUTLER-00398 –

BUTLER-00399;

BUTLER-00654

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Danielle Johnson

P-1858 BUTLER-00400 –

BUTLER-00401;

BUTLER-00655

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Barbara Jones

P-1859 BUTLER-00402 –

BUTLER-00403;

BUTLER-00655

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Bertha Jones

P-1860 BUTLER-00404 –

BUTLER-00405;

BUTLER-00656

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Irvin Jones

P-1861 BUTLER-00406 –

BUTLER-00407;

BUTLER-00657

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Hugh Jordan

P-1862 BUTLER-00408 –

BUTLER-00409;

BUTLER-00658

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Gary Kayser

P-1863 BUTLER-00410 –

BUTLER-00411;

BUTLER-00659

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sandra Kearse

P-1864 BUTLER-00412 –

BUTLER-00413;

BUTLER-00660

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sheila Keckeis

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 121 of 289 PAGEID #: 31300

122

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1865 BUTLER-00414 –

BUTLER-00415;

BUTLER-00660

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Lee Kern

P-1866 BUTLER-00416 –

BUTLER-00417;

BUTLER-00660

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Margaret Kerrison

P-1867 BUTLER-00418 –

BUTLER-00419;

BUTLER-00661

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Thomas Kettler

P-1868 BUTLER-00420 –

BUTLER-00421;

BUTLER-00662

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Mark Kinch

P-1869 BUTLER-00422 –

BUTLER-00423;

BUTLER-00663

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Karen Knowles

P-1870 BUTLER-00424 –

BUTLER-00425;

BUTLER-00663

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Juanita Kreke

P-1871 BUTLER-00426 –

BUTLER-00427;

BUTLER-00664

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Charlotte Lakes

P-1872 BUTLER-00428 –

BUTLER-00429;

BUTLER-00664

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Elizabeth Lawrence

P-1873 BUTLER-00430 –

BUTLER-00431;

BUTLER-00664

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Terry Lay

P-1874 BUTLER-00432 –

BUTLER-00433;

BUTLER-00665

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joann Leslie

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 122 of 289 PAGEID #: 31301

123

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1875 BUTLER-00434 –

BUTLER-00435;

BUTLER-00666

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joyce Long

P-1876 BUTLER-00436 –

BUTLER-00437;

BUTLER-00667

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Maurita Lower

P-1877 BUTLER-00438 –

BUTLER-00439;

BUTLER-00668

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Madge Lunsford

P-1878 BUTLER-00442 –

BUTLER-00443;

BUTLER-00669

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sharon Lunsford

P-1879 BUTLER-00440 –

BUTLER-00441;

BUTLER-00669

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Gerald Lynch

P-1880 BUTLER-00444 –

BUTLER-00445;

BUTLER-00670

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jody Mann

P-1881 BUTLER-00446 –

BUTLER-00447;

BUTLER-00670

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Maureen Margolies

P-1882 BUTLER-00448 –

BUTLER-00449;

BUTLER-00670

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Heather Marsh

P-1883 BUTLER-00450 –

BUTLER-00451;

BUTLER-00671

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Orville Martin

P-1884 BUTLER-00452 –

BUTLER-00453;

BUTLER-00671

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ruth Maurer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 123 of 289 PAGEID #: 31302

124

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1885 BUTLER-00454 –

BUTLER-00455;

BUTLER-00672

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Donna McCorkle

P-1886 BUTLER-00456 –

BUTLER-00457;

BUTLER-00672

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kati McCreight

P-1887 BUTLER-00458 –

BUTLER-00459;

BUTLER-00672

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jennifer McDonald

P-1888 BUTLER-00460 –

BUTLER-00461;

BUTLER-00673

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Floyd McGaha III

P-1889 BUTLER-00462 –

BUTLER-00463;

BUTLER-00673

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Chawnda McGuire Hunter

P-1890 BUTLER-00464 –

BUTLER-00465;

BUTLER-00673

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joann McGuire

P-1891 BUTLER-00466 –

BUTLER-00467;

BUTLER-00674

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Steven Metzger

P-1892 BUTLER-00468 –

BUTLER-00469;

BUTLER-00675

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Sherry Moore

P-1893 BUTLER-00470 –

BUTLER-00471;

BUTLER-00676

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Daniel Moorman

P-1894 BUTLER-00472 –

BUTLER-00473;

BUTLER-00676

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ernest Morgan

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 124 of 289 PAGEID #: 31303

125

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1895 BUTLER-00474 –

BUTLER-00475;

BUTLER-00676

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Morgan

P-1896 BUTLER-00476 –

BUTLER-00477;

BUTLER-00677

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Carmen Morrison

P-1897 BUTLER-00478 –

BUTLER-00479;

BUTLER-00677

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Lawrence Morrison

P-1898 BUTLER-00480 –

BUTLER-00481;

BUTLER-00677

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Muncy

P-1899 BUTLER-00482 –

BUTLER-00483;

BUTLER-00678

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for David Mundy Jr.

P-1900 BUTLER-00484 –

BUTLER-00485;

BUTLER-00678

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for James Myron

P-1901 BUTLER-00486 –

BUTLER-00487;

BUTLER-00679

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Glenn Neidlinger

P-1902 BUTLER-00488 –

BUTLER-00489;

BUTLER-00680

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Melanie Neumann

P-1903 BUTLER-00490 –

BUTLER-00491;

BUTLER-00681

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jane Nicholas

P-1904 BUTLER-00492 –

BUTLER-00493;

BUTLER-00682

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Rachel Obermeyer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 125 of 289 PAGEID #: 31304

126

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1905 BUTLER-00494 –

BUTLER-00495;

BUTLER-00683

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jay Panandiker

P-1906 BUTLER-00496 –

BUTLER-00497;

BUTLER-00684

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Julia Pate

P-1907 BUTLER-00498 –

BUTLER-00499;

BUTLER-00684

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Heidi Patterson

P-1908 BUTLER-00500 –

BUTLER-00501;

BUTLER-00684

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Edward Pence

P-1909 BUTLER-00502 –

BUTLER-00503;

BUTLER-00685

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Herman Pennington

P-1910 BUTLER-00504 –

BUTLER-00505;

BUTLER-00686

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ronald Phares

P-1911 BUTLER-00506 –

BUTLER-00507;

BUTLER-00686

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Karen Potoka

P-1912 BUTLER-00508 –

BUTLER-00509;

BUTLER-00686

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Anna Prichard

P-1913 BUTLER-00510 –

BUTLER-00511;

BUTLER-00687

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Tina Reese

P-1914 BUTLER-00512 –

BUTLER-00513;

BUTLER-00687

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Melissa Reyes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 126 of 289 PAGEID #: 31305

127

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1915 BUTLER-00514 –

BUTLER-00515;

BUTLER-00687

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Zelaya Richburg

P-1916 BUTLER-00516 –

BUTLER-00517;

BUTLER-00688

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for John Riebel

P-1917 BUTLER-00518 –

BUTLER-00519;

BUTLER-00688

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Bradley Rodecker

P-1918 BUTLER-00520 –

BUTLER-00521;

BUTLER-00689

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Walter Roehll Jr.

P-1919 BUTLER-00522 –

BUTLER-00523;

BUTLER-00690

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Gilbert Rose

P-1920 BUTLER-00524 –

BUTLER-00525;

BUTLER-00691

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Marita Roth

P-1921 BUTLER-00526 –

BUTLER-00527;

BUTLER-00691

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Ruby Rowe

P-1922 BUTLER-00528 –

BUTLER-00529;

BUTLER-00692

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kenneth Russell

P-1923 BUTLER-00530 –

BUTLER-00531;

BUTLER-00693

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Michael Ryan

P-1924 BUTLER-00532 –

BUTLER-00533;

BUTLER-00694

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Stephen Sands

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 127 of 289 PAGEID #: 31306

128

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1925 BUTLER-00534 –

BUTLER-00535;

BUTLER-00694

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Nadine Scherman

P-1926 BUTLER-00536 –

BUTLER-00537;

BUTLER-00694

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Joan Schmitt

P-1927 BUTLER-00538 –

BUTLER-00539;

BUTLER-00695

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Trudence Semmler

P-1928 BUTLER-00540 –

BUTLER-00541;

BUTLER-00696

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Randall Sims Jr.

P-1929 BUTLER-00542 –

BUTLER-00543;

BUTLER-00696

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for William Simms

P-1930 BUTLER-00544 –

BUTLER-00545;

BUTLER-00696

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Neil Skinner

P-1931 BUTLER-00546 –

BUTLER-00547;

BUTLER-00697

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Mary Smith

P-1932 BUTLER-00548 –

BUTLER-00549;

BUTLER-00697

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for John Snyder

P-1933 BUTLER-00550 –

BUTLER-00551;

BUTLER-00697

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Irma Soule

P-1934 BUTLER-00552 –

BUTLER-00553;

BUTLER-00698

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Betty Stover

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 128 of 289 PAGEID #: 31307

129

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1935 BUTLER-00554 –

BUTLER-00555;

BUTLER-00699

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Clyde Strunk

P-1936 BUTLER-00556 –

BUTLER-00557;

BUTLER-00700

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Lisa Sulek

P-1937 BUTLER-00558 –

BUTLER-00559;

BUTLER-00700

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Tina Sunderhaus

P-1938 BUTLER-00560 –

BUTLER-00561;

BUTLER-00700

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Larry Swartz

P-1939 BUTLER-00562 –

BUTLER-00563;

BUTLER-00701

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Michelle Swartz

P-1940 BUTLER-00564 –

BUTLER-00565;

BUTLER-00701

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kristin Szmytkowski

P-1941 BUTLER-00566 –

BUTLER-00567;

BUTLER-00702

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Carl Taylor

P-1942 BUTLER-00568 –

BUTLER-00569;

BUTLER-00702

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Judith Thomas

P-1943 BUTLER-00570 –

BUTLER-00571;

BUTLER-00702

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Clark Thompson

P-1944 BUTLER-00572 –

BUTLER-00573;

BUTLER-00703

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jackie Thornsberry

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 129 of 289 PAGEID #: 31308

130

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1945 BUTLER-00574 –

BUTLER-00575;

BUTLER-00703

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Anthony Traub

P-1946 BUTLER-00576 –

BUTLER-00577;

BUTLER-00703

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Kristin Timmer

P-1947 BUTLER-00578 –

BUTLER-00579;

BUTLER-00704

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Megan tonner Robinson

P-1948 BUTLER-00580 –

BUTLER-00581;

BUTLER-00705

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Melissa Trent

P-1949 BUTLER-00582 –

BUTLER-00583;

BUTLER-00705

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Rose Truster

P-1950 BUTLER-00584 –

BUTLER-00585;

BUTLER-00705

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Tilden Tucker

P-1951 BUTLER-00586 –

BUTLER-00587;

BUTLER-00706

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Shelli Turco

P-1952 BUTLER-00588 –

BUTLER-00589;

BUTLER-00706

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Jack Turner

P-1953 BUTLER-00590 –

BUTLER-00591;

BUTLER-00706

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Doris Tuthill

P-1954 BUTLER-00592 –

BUTLER-00593;

BUTLER-00707

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Zelda Tuthill

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 130 of 289 PAGEID #: 31309

131

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1955 BUTLER-00594 –

BUTLER-00595;

BUTLER-00708

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Danita Wallace

P-1956 BUTLER-00596 –

BUTLER-00597;

BUTLER-00708

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Mary Jo Waters

P-1957 BUTLER-00598 –

BUTLER-00599;

BUTLER-00708

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for James Wiegand

P-1958 BUTLER-00600 –

BUTLER-00601;

BUTLER-00709

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Martha Williams

P-1959 BUTLER-00602 –

BUTLER-00603;

BUTLER-00709

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Robert Williams, Jr.

P-1960 BUTLER-00604 –

BUTLER-00605;

BUTLER-00710

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Marion Witham

P-1961 BUTLER-00606 –

BUTLER-00607;

BUTLER-00710

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Louis Wolff

P-1962 BUTLER-00608 –

BUTLER-00609;

BUTLER-00711

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Karen Young

P-1963 BUTLER-00610 –

BUTLER-00611;

BUTLER-00711

BUTLER-00239

Voter packet for Steven Zimmerman

P-1964 BUTLER-00123;

BUTLER-00148-

BUTLER-00149;

BUTLER-00098;

Voter packet for David Back

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 131 of 289 PAGEID #: 31310

132

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00097

P-1965 BUTLER-00124;

BUTLER-00150-

BUTLER-00151;

BUTLER-00099;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Sue Back

P-1966 BUTLER-00125;

BUTLER-00152-

BUTLER-00153;

BUTLER-00100;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Michelle Cash

P-1967 BUTLER-00126;

BUTLER-00154-

BUTLER-00155;

BUTLER-00101;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Tracey Capuano

P-1968 BUTLER-00127;

BUTLER-00156-

BUTLER-00157;

BUTLER-00102;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Steven Guggenberger

P-1969 BUTLER-00128;

BUTLER-00158-

BUTLER-00159;

BUTLER-00103;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Karen Hibbard

P-1970 BUTLER-00129;

BUTLER-00160-

BUTLER-00161;

BUTLER-00104;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Jane Hoffman

P-1971 BUTLER-00130;

BUTLER-00162-

BUTLER-00163;

BUTLER-00105;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Leonard Hudson

P-1972 BUTLER-00131;

BUTLER-00164-

BUTLER-00165;

BUTLER-00106;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Diane Huffman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 132 of 289 PAGEID #: 31311

133

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1973 BUTLER-00132;

BUTLER-00166-

BUTLER-00167;

BUTLER-00107;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Errol Huffman

P-1974 BUTLER-00133;

BUTLER-00168-

BUTLER-00169;

BUTLER-00108;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Linda McIntosh

P-1975 BUTLER-00135;

BUTLER-00172-

BUTLER-00173;

BUTLER-00110;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Raleigh Moore

P-1976 BUTLER-00136;

BUTLER-00174-

BUTLER-00175;

BUTLER-00111;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Cynthia Puma

P-1977 BUTLER-00137;

BUTLER-00176-

BUTLER-00177;

BUTLER-00112;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Daniel Purcell

P-1978 BUTLER-00138;

BUTLER-00178-

BUTLER-00179;

BUTLER-00113;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Thomas Durr

P-1979 BUTLER-00139;

BUTLER-00180-

BUTLER-00181;

BUTLER-00114;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for John Riebel

P-1980 BUTLER-00141;

BUTLER-00184-

BUTLER-00185;

BUTLER-00116;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Mary Schwering

P-1981 BUTLER-00142;

BUTLER-00186-

Voter packet for Judith Shillinglaw

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 133 of 289 PAGEID #: 31312

134

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00187;

BUTLER-00117;

BUTLER-00097

P-1982 BUTLER-00143;

BUTLER-00188-

BUTLER-00189;

BUTLER-00118;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Jessica Steinman

P-1983 BUTLER-00144;

BUTLER-00190-

BUTLER-00191;

BUTLER-00119;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Rita Stevens

P-1984 BUTLER-00145;

BUTLER-00192-

BUTLER-00193;

BUTLER-00120;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Evvy Sutton

P-1985 BUTLER-00147;

BUTLER-00196-

BUTLER-00197;

BUTLER-00122;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Kathryn Zumbahlen

P-1986 BUTLER-00134;

BUTLER-00170-

BUTLER-00171;

BUTLER-00109;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Alberta McKnight

P-1987 BUTLER-00140;

BUTLER-00182-

BUTLER-00183;

BUTLER-00115;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Emily Roth

P-1988 BUTLER-00146;

BUTLER-00194-

BUTLER-00195;

BUTLER-00121;

BUTLER-00097

Voter packet for Judith Webb

P-1989 BUTLER-00209;

BUTLER-00219-

BUTLER-00220;

BUTLER-00199;

Voter packet for Jeanne Berry

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 134 of 289 PAGEID #: 31313

135

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

BUTLER-00198

P-1990 BUTLER-00210;

BUTLER-00221-

BUTLER-00222;

BUTLER-00200;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Jung Chen

P-1991 BUTLER-00215;

BUTLER-00231-

BUTLER-00232;

BUTLER-00205;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Bob Kramer

P-1992 BUTLER-00216;

BUTLER-00233-

BUTLER-00234;

BUTLER-00206;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Daria Mitchell

P-1993 BUTLER-00217;

BUTLER-00235-

BUTLER-00236;

BUTLER-00207;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Elizabeth Post

P-1994 BUTLER-00211;

BUTLER-00223-

BUTLER-00224;

BUTLER-00201;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Evangeline Durbin

P-1995 BUTLER-00212;

BUTLER-00225-

BUTLER-00226;

BUTLER-00202;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Barbara Haas

P-1996 BUTLER-00213;

BUTLER-00227-

BUTLER-00228;

BUTLER-00203;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Ruth Harrington

P-1997 BUTLER-00214;

BUTLER-00229-

BUTLER-00230;

BUTLER-00204;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Sally Kah

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 135 of 289 PAGEID #: 31314

136

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-1998 BUTLER-00218;

BUTLER-00237-

BUTLER-00238;

BUTLER-00208;

BUTLER-00198

Voter packet for Daniel Stone

P-1999 LORAIN-00218-

LORAIN-00219

Second voter packet for Hannah Heinke-Green

P-2000 LORAIN-00220-

LORAIN-00221

Second voter packet for Cria Kay

P-2001 LORAIN-00222 Second voter packet for Annie Whitaker

P-2002 LORAIN-00223 Second voter packet for Jack Free

P-2003 LORAIN-00224-

LORAIN-00225

Second voter packet for William Leslie

P-2004 LORAIN-00226 Second voter packet for Annci Hoffman

P-2005 LORAIN-00227-

LORAIN-00230

Second voter packet for Ahmad Bahr

P-2006 LORAIN-00231-

LORAIN-00234

Second voter packet for George Gnandt

P-2007 LORAIN-00235-

LORAIN-00238

Second voter packet for Alicia Joppeck

P-2008 LORAIN-00239-

LORAIN-00242

Second voter packet for Richard Shullick

P-2009 LORAIN-00243-

LORAIN-00246

Second voter packet for Jaime Ramos

P-2010 LORAIN-00247-

LORAIN-00250

Second voter packet for Arsenio Sa, Jr.

P-2011 LORAIN-00251-

LORAIN-00254

Second voter packet for Kathy Johnson

P-2012 LORAIN-00255-

LORAIN-00258

Second voter packet for Glenn Collins

P-2013 LORAIN-00259-

LORAIN-00262

Second voter packet for Amalia Hoke

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 136 of 289 PAGEID #: 31315

137

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2014 LORAIN-00263-

LORAIN-00266

Second voter packet for Lois Kolhoff

P-2015 LORAIN-00267-

LORAIN-00270

Second voter packet for Louise Luckenbill

P-2016 LORAIN-00271-

LORAIN-00275

Second voter packet for Nancy Mahoney

P-2017 LORAIN-00276-

LORAIN-00279

Second voter packet for Carrie Moore

P-2018 LORAIN-00280-

LORAIN-00283

Second voter packet for Bernice Pekar

P-2019 LORAIN-00284-

LORAIN-00287

Second voter packet for Laura Rouse

P-2020 LORAIN-00288 Second voter packet for Theresa Gainer

P-2021 LORAIN-00289 Second voter packet for Adam Waddell

P-2022 LORAIN-00290 Second voter packet for Breanne Bright

P-2023 LORAIN-00291 Second voter packet for April Vanover

P-2024 LORAIN-00292 Second voter packet for Michael Beeble

P-2025 LORAIN-00293 Second voter packet for Juan Soto

P-2026 LORAIN-00294-

LORAIN-00296

Second voter packet for Adrianna Ward

P-2027 LORAIN-00297 Second voter packet for Richard Kovach

P-2028 LORAIN-00298-

LORAIN-00300

Second voter packet for Lorraine Smith

P-2029 LORAIN-00301-

LORAIN-00303

Second voter packet for Anthony Truxall

P-2030 LORAIN-00304 Second voter packet for Colin Brown

P-2031 LORAIN-00305 Second voter packet for Nicholas Carroll

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 137 of 289 PAGEID #: 31316

138

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2032 LORAIN-00306 Second voter packet for Christina Weekley

P-2033 LORAIN-00307-

LORAIN-00309

Second voter packet for Branden Gannon

P-2034 LORAIN-00310-

LORAIN-00312

Second voter packet for Ann Sanford

P-2035 LORAIN-00313-

LORAIN-00314

Second voter packet for Farrell Crumley

P-2036 LORAIN-00315-

LORAIN-00316

Second voter packet for Felicia Smith

P-2037 LORAIN-00317-

LORAIN-00318

Second voter packet for Peter Harlan

P-2038 LORAIN-00319-

LORAIN-00320

Second voter packet for Neil Kammiller

P-2039 LORAIN-00321-

LORAIN-00322

Second voter packet for Robin Hengartner

P-2040 LORAIN-00323-

LORAIN-00324

Second voter packet for Michael Braid

P-2041 LORAIN-00325-

LORAIN-00326

Second voter packet for Donald Deidrick

P-2042 LORAIN-00327-

LORAIN-00328

Second voter packet for Edith Raible

P-2043 LORAIN-00329-

LORAIN-00339

Second voter packet for Carol Dunipace

P-2044 LORAIN-00331-

LORAIN-00332

Second voter packet for Robert McEwen

P-2045 LORAIN-00333-

LORAIN-00334

Second voter packet for Andrew Thieken

P-2046 LORAIN-00335-

LORAIN-00336

Second voter packet for Almetrice Calhoun

P-2047 LORAIN-00337-

LORAIN-00338

Second voter packet for Loraine Schwede

P-2048 LORAIN-00339- Second voter packet for Terry Schwede

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 138 of 289 PAGEID #: 31317

139

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LORAIN-00340

P-2049 LORAIN-00341-

LORAIN-00342

Second voter packet for Joyce Mack

P-2050 LORAIN-00343-

LORAIN-00344

Second voter packet for Susan Raymont

P-2051 LORAIN-00345-

LORAIN-00346

Second voter packet for Carrie Cook

P-2052 LORAIN-00347-

LORAIN-00348

Second voter packet for Robert Krivak

P-2053 LORAIN-00349-

LORAIN-00350

Second voter packet for Leon Kinsley

P-2054 LORAIN-00351-

LORAIN-00352

Second voter packet for Diane Varner

P-2055 LORAIN-00353-

LORAIN-00354

Second voter packet for Natalie Toth

P-2056 LORAIN-00355-

LORAIN-00356

Second voter packet for Kenneth Harper

P-2057 LORAIN-00357-

LORAIN-00358

Second voter packet for Arleita Dirne

P-2058 LORAIN-00359-

LORAIN-00360

Second voter packet for Caleb Schillace

P-2059 LORAIN-00361-

LORAIN-00362

Second voter packet for Sheryl Bailey

P-2060 LORAIN-00363-

LORAIN-00364

Second voter packet for Patricia Ferguson

P-2061 LORAIN-00365-

LORAIN-00366

Second voter packet for George Ulakovic

P-2062 LORAIN-00367-

LORAIN-00368

Second voter packet for Elmeris Marcucci

P-2063 LORAIN-00369-

LORAIN-00370

Second voter packet for Wanda Travis

P-2064 LORAIN-00371-

LORAIN-00372

Second voter packet for Dawn Markley

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 139 of 289 PAGEID #: 31318

140

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2065 LORAIN-00373 Second voter packet for Scott Meredith

P-2066 LORAIN-00374 Second voter packet for Marie Mayton

P-2067 LORAIN-00375 Second voter packet for Michael Ridenour

P-2068 LORAIN-00376 Second voter packet for Beverly Benko

P-2069 LORAIN-00377 Second voter packet for Debra McConnell

P-2070 LORAIN-00378 Second voter packet for Dorothy Baksa

P-2071 LORAIN-00379 Second voter packet for Donald Moran Jr.

P-2072 LORAIN-00380 Second voter packet for Theresa Hardy

P-2073 LORAIN-00381 Second voter packet for Robert Pallante

P-2074 LORAIN-00382 Second voter packet for Carol Dudukovich

P-2075 LORAIN-00383 Second voter packet for Gordon Lent

P-2076 LORAIN-00384 Second voter packet for Yvonne Moen

P-2077 LORAIN-00385 Second voter packet for Jacqueline Davis

P-2078 LORAIN-00386 Second voter packet for Brock Wade

P-2079 LORAIN-00387 Second voter packet for Arthur Lipsin

P-2080 LORAIN-00388 Second voter packet for Dimitre Petroff

P-2081 LORAIN-00389 Second voter packet for Jane Covne

P-2082 LORAIN-00390 Second voter packet for Edna McCowan

P-2083 LORAIN-00391 Second voter packet for Luis Rodriquez

P-2084 LORAIN-00392 Second voter packet for Donald Thompson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 140 of 289 PAGEID #: 31319

141

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2085 LORAIN-00393 Second voter packet for Mary Thompson

P-2086 LORAIN-00394 Second voter packet for Brenda Castro

P-2087 LORAIN-00395 Second voter packet for Margaret Smarsh

P-2088 LORAIN-00396 Second voter packet for Mark Smarsh

P-2089 LORAIN-00397 Second voter packet for William Kopis

P-2090 LORAIN-00398-

LORAIN-00399

Second voter packet for Patsy Mass

P-2091 LORAIN-00400-

LORAIN-00403

Second voter packet for Wanda Budway

P-2092 HAMILTON-00907;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Ronald Arnold

P-2093 HAMILTON-00983;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Fati Badjo

P-2094 HAMILTON-00972;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Dylan Barnett

P-2095 HAMILTON-00914;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Andrew Bell

P-2096 HAMILTON-00903;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for John Boettger

P-2097 HAMILTON-00904;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Latoya Bohanon

P-2098 HAMILTON-00969;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Melissa Bramley

P-2099 HAMILTON-00913;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Williamina Chlipala

P-2100 HAMILTON-00976;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Mary Condit

P-2101 HAMILTON-00919;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Jermane Dekle

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 141 of 289 PAGEID #: 31320

142

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2102 HAMILTON-00984-

00985; HAMILTON-

00899

Voter packet for Jennifer Evans

P-2103 HAMILTON-00917;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for James Graham

P-2104 HAMILTON-00909;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Lori Guban

P-2105 HAMILTON-00902;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Steven Hicks

P-2106 HAMILTON-00975;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Matthew Hull

P-2107 HAMILTON-00908;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Derrick Johnson

P-2108 HAMILTON-00986;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Kevin Kastle

P-2109 HAMILTON-00911;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Michael Kelly

P-2110 HAMILTON-00978;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Ellyse Knecht

P-2111 HAMILTON-00981;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Edward Lampe Jr.

P-2112 HAMILTON-00906;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Major Letcher

P-2113 HAMILTON-00971;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Dorothy Miller

P-2114 HAMILTON-00980;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Margaret Miller

P-2115 HAMILTON-00901;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Camero Mitchell

P-2116 HAMILTON-00968;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for James Moore

P-2117 HAMILTON-00918;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Lillian Norman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 142 of 289 PAGEID #: 31321

143

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2118 HAMILTON-00905;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Shanee Nuckols

P-2119 HAMILTON-00979;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Ilelabayo Omoyosi

P-2120 HAMILTON-00974;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Aaron Parton

P-2121 HAMILTON-00920;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Matthew Shifley

P-2122 HAMILTON-00900;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Wendell Stevenson

P-2123 HAMILTON-00921;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for William Teller

P-2124 HAMILTON-00922;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Walter Tetzner Jr.

P-2125 HAMILTON-00910;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Ruth Thomas-Jackson

P-2126 HAMILTON-00973;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Marianne Vaughn

P-2127 HAMILTON-00982;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Zachery Walton

P-2128 HAMILTON-00970;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Terry Young

P-2129 HAMILTON-00915;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Maria Caldwell

P-2130 HAMILTON-00977;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Maresa Castleberry

P-2131 HAMILTON-00912;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for William Muhlenpoh

P-2132 HAMILTON-00916;

HAMILTON-00899

Voter packet for Tracy Schnirring

P-2133 HAMILTON-00967;

HAMILTON-00966

Voter packet for Jerry Strickland

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 143 of 289 PAGEID #: 31322

144

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2134 HAMILTON-00950;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Ronald Alexander

P-2135 HAMILTON-00952;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Philip Blackmon

P-2136 HAMILTON-00954;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Brian Bruner

P-2137 HAMILTON-00965;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Sileye Diop

P-2138 HAMILTON-00957;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Tara Garrett

P-2139 HAMILTON-00958;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Jason Gay

P-2140 HAMILTON-00955;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Brian Geary

P-2141 HAMILTON-01011;

HAMILTON-01007

Voter packet for Kathryn Grammas

P-2142 HAMILTON-01009;

HAMILTON-01007

Voter packet for Earnest Heyward

P-2143 HAMILTON-00956;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Jacqueline Highsmith

P-2144 HAMILTON-00964;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Wanda Lewis

P-2145 HAMILTON-00953;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Marsha McNamara

P-2146 HAMILTON-00962;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Teresa Mittermeier

P-2147 HAMILTON-01010;

HAMILTON-01007

Voter packet for Laura Muenchen

P-2148 HAMILTON-01008;

HAMILTON-01007

Voter packet for Jacquetta Ray

P-2149 HAMILTON-00959;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Ruth Schock

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 144 of 289 PAGEID #: 31323

145

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2150 HAMILTON-00960;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Robert Schwieter

P-2151 HAMILTON-00963;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Jeffrey Stephens

P-2152 HAMILTON-00961;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Donald Wasnesky

P-2153 HAMILTON-00951;

HAMILTON-00949

Voter packet for Annette Wick

P-2154 HAMILTON-00992;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Paula Ballman

P-2155 HAMILTON-00924;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Dennis Barrow

P-2156 HAMILTON-00944;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Elizabeth Beiter

P-2157 HAMILTON-00930;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Albert Creamer

P-2158 HAMILTON-00997;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Mary Ann Flanigan

P-2159 HAMILTON-00945;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Joseph Helton

P-2160 HAMILTON-01003;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Michael Jones

P-2161 HAMILTON-00996;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Nat Kutcher

P-2162 HAMILTON-00926;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Lorraine Mayernik

P-2163 HAMILTON-00998;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Jane Noschang

P-2164 HAMILTON-00948;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Denise Peters

P-2165 HAMILTON-00932;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Harry Sjolin

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 145 of 289 PAGEID #: 31324

146

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2166 HAMILTON-00943;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Charles Spinks

P-2167 HAMILTON-00935;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Don Stone

P-2168 HAMILTON-00938;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Alberta Tribble

P-2169 HAMILTON-01005;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Thomas Beiting

P-2170 HAMILTON-00925;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Mary Burgess

P-2171 HAMILTON-00929;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Julius Butts

P-2172 HAMILTON-00946;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for G. Stephen Cleves

P-2173 HAMILTON-00989;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Katisha Davis

P-2174 HAMILTON-00927;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for James Downey

P-2175 HAMILTON-00942;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Stephen Felix

P-2176 HAMILTON-00941;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Jennifer Fritz

P-2177 HAMILTON-00991;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Brian Goetz

P-2178 HAMILTON-00931;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for David Green

P-2179 HAMILTON-00934;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Shannon Kelly

P-2180 HAMILTON-00947;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Douglas Linn

P-2181 HAMILTON-00937;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Trakila Mason

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 146 of 289 PAGEID #: 31325

147

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2182 HAMILTON-00928;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Jose Quishpe

P-2183 HAMILTON-00988;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Maurice Robinson

P-2184 HAMILTON-00990;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Reuben Robinson

P-2185 HAMILTON-00993;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Jason Schmieg

P-2186 HAMILTON-00933;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Beverly Sjolin

P-2187 HAMILTON-00936;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Veronica Solorza

P-2188 HAMILTON-00995;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Clarence Stephens

P-2189 HAMILTON-00994;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Connie Sunderman

P-2190 HAMILTON-00940;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Alexander Tucker

P-2191 HAMILTON-00939;

HAMILTON-00923

Voter packet for Viola Waller

P-2192 HAMILTON-01004;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Jason Weisman

P-2193 HAMILTON-01001;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Alecia Camarca

P-2194 HAMILTON-00999;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Robert Ernst

P-2195 HAMILTON-01002;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Ciera Mangham

P-2196 HAMILTON-01000;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Joyce Smith-Mischento

P-2197 HAMILTON-01006;

HAMILTON-00987

Voter packet for Terrah Stuckey

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 147 of 289 PAGEID #: 31326

148

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2198 HAMILTON-01178--

1180; HAMILTON-

00784; HAMILTON-

01128

Voter packet for Aliou Aliou

P-2199 HAMILTON-01198-

1200; HAMILTON-

00793; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Johnnie Bertram

P-2200 HAMILTON-01213-15;

HAMILTON-00800;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Frank Bicknell

P-2201 HAMILTON-01168-70;

HAMILTON-00780;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Emily Bowman

P-2202 HAMILTON-01206;

HAMILTON-00797;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Jeffrey Budke

P-2203 HAMILTON-01258-

01260; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Janet Burnett

P-2204 HAMILTON-01222-

01224; HAMILTON-

00802; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Holly Calhoun

P-2205 HAMILTON-01149-

151 HAMILTON-

00775; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Jamel Canady

P-2206 HAMILTON-01243-

01245; HAMILTON-

00809; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Marsalis Charles

P-2207 HAMILTON-01171-

01173; HAMILTON-

00781; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Rita Cheatham

P-2208 HAMILTON-01187;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Eric Day

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 148 of 289 PAGEID #: 31327

149

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2209 HAMILTON-01252-

01254; HAMILTON-

00812; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Ruth Dirr

P-2210 HAMILTON-01255-

01257; HAMILTON-

00813; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Christian Domis

P-2211 HAMILTON-01202-

01204; HAMILTON-

00795; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Adam Geiger

P-2212 HAMILTON-01184-

01186; HAMILTON-

00786; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Virginia Grant

P-2213 HAMILTON-01146-

01148; HAMILTON-

00774; HAMILTON-

1128

Voter packet for Larry Green Sr.

P-2214 HAMILTON-01189;

HAMILTON-00788;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Danielle Hahn

P-2215 HAMILTON-01162-

HAMILTON-01164;

HAMILTON-00779;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Janet Henthorn

P-2216 HAMILTON-01133-

HAMILTON-01135;

HAMILTON-00769;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Molly Hoffman

P-2217 HAMILTON-01191-

HAMILTON-01193;

HAMILTON-00790;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Katherine Jaringo

P-2218 HAMILTON-01232-

HAMILTON-01234;

HAMILTON-00806;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Christina Jones

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 149 of 289 PAGEID #: 31328

150

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2219 HAMILTON-01130-

HAMILTON-01132;

HAMILTON-00768;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Darlene Kanu

P-2220 HAMILTON-01207-

HAMILTON-01209;

HAMILTON-00798;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Jane Krems

P-2221 HAMILTON-01219-

HAMILTON-01221;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Rita Lindhorst

P-2222 HAMILTON-01249-

HAMILTON-01251;

HAMILTON-00811;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Hazel Liptrot

P-2223 HAMILTON-01174;

HAMILTON-00782;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Kalala Liufau

P-2224 HAMILTON-01181-

HAMILTON-01183;

HAMILTON-00785;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Wyman Lockett Jr.

P-2225 HAMILTON-01175-

HAMILTON-01177;

HAMILTON-00783;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Tiffany Lucky

P-2226 HAMILTON-01159-

HAMILTON-01161;

HAMILTON-00778;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Lynn Lummus

P-2227 HAMILTON-01235-

HAMILTON-01239;

HAMILTON-00807;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Dennis Martini

P-2228 HAMILTON-01165-

HAMILTON-01167;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Florence Mills

P-2229 HAMILTON-01152-

HAMILTON-01154;

HAMILTON-00776;

Voter packet for John Montgomery

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 150 of 289 PAGEID #: 31329

151

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

HAMILTON-1128

P-2230 HAMILTON-01205;

HAMILTON-00796;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Thomas Powers

P-2231 HAMILTON-01140-

HAMILTON-01142;

HAMILTON-00772;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Ann Ruggles

P-2232 HAMILTON-01195-

HAMILTON-01197;

HAMILTON-00792;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Mary Rust

P-2233 HAMILTON-01194;

HAMILTON-00791;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for April Schexnayder

P-2234 HAMILTON-01201;

HAMILTON-00794;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Abbe Schriber

P-2235 HAMILTON-01225-

HAMILTON-01227;

HAMILTON-00803;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Donellin Sims

P-2236 HAMILTON-01240-

HAMILTON-01242;

HAMILTON-00808;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Eric Smith

P-2237 HAMILTON-0228-

HAMILTON-01230;

HAMILTON-00804;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Paula Smith

P-2238 HAMILTON-01137-

HAMILTON-01139;

HAMILTON-00771;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Sean Speed

P-2239 HAMILTON-01246-

HAMILTON-01248;

HAMILTON-00810;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Delisa Turner

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 151 of 289 PAGEID #: 31330

152

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2240 HAMILTON-01216-

HAMILTON-01218;

HAMILTON-00801;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for William Weber

P-2241 HAMILTON-01143-

HAMILTON-01145;

HAMILTON-00773;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Rodney Williams Jr.

P-2242 HAMILTON-01155-

HAMILTON-01157;

HAMILTON-00777;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Lavern Wright

P-2243 HAMILTON-01210-

HAMILTON-01212;

HAMILTON-00799;

HAMILTON-1128

Voter packet for Dolores Yi

P-2244 HAMILTON-01375-

HAMILTON-01376;

HAMILTON-00872;

HAMILTON-860

Voter packet for Herbert Kohus

P-2245 HAMILTON-01066-

HAMILTON-01067;

HAMILTON-00755;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Adolphus Sukhai

P-2246 HAMILTON-01023-

HAMILTON-01024;

HAMILTON-00732;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Amanda Adkins

P-2247 HAMILTON-01371-

HAMILTON-01372;

HAMILTON-00870;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Donald Archer

P-2248 HAMILTON-01373-

HAMILTON-01374;

HAMILTON-00871;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Patricia Archer

P-2249 HAMILTON-01027-

HAMILTON-01028;

HAMILTON-00734;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Andrew Bernard

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 152 of 289 PAGEID #: 31331

153

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2250 HAMILTON-01035-

HAMILTON-01036;

HAMILTON-00738;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Margaret Bissler

P-2251 HAMILTON-01021-

HAMILTON-01022;

HAMILTON-00731;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Stephanie Carter

P-2252 HAMILTON-01070-

HAMILTON-01071;

HAMILTON-00757;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Anna Combs

P-2253 HAMILTON-01013-

HAMILTON-01014;

HAMILTON-00726;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Clarence Conner

P-2254 HAMILTON-01367-

HAMILTON-01368;

HAMILTON-00868;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Edward Conrad

P-2255 HAMILTON-01361-

HAMILTON-01362;

HAMILTON-00865;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Elsie Croley

P-2256 HAMILTON-01068-

HAMILTON-01069;

HAMILTON-00756;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Raymond Cruse Jr.

P-2257 HAMILTON-01074-

HAMILTON-01075;

HAMILTON-00759;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Janet Dowell

P-2258 HAMILTON-01018;

HAMILTON-00729;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Feltus Dunn Sr.

P-2259 HAMILTON-01029-

HAMILTON-01030;

HAMILTON-00735;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Nancy Dwyer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 153 of 289 PAGEID #: 31332

154

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2260 HAMILTON-01049-

HAMILTON-01050;

HAMILTON-00745;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Esther Esterline

P-2261 HAMILTON-01037-

HAMILTON-01038;

HAMILTON-00739;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Bruce Fales

P-2262 HAMILTON-01355-

HAMILTON-01356;

HAMILTON-00862;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for William Froehle

P-2263 HAMILTON-01369-

HAMILTON-01370;

HAMILTON-00869;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Metholynn Greene

P-2264 HAMILTON-01045-

HAMILTON-01046;

HAMILTON-00743;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Shirley Hust

P-2265 HAMILTON-01078-

HAMILTON-01079;

HAMILTON-00761;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for John Jett

P-2266 HAMILTON-01357-

HAMILTON-01358;

HAMILTON-00863;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Dianne Jones

P-2267 HAMILTON-01063;

HAMILTON-00753;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Jereme Kelley

P-2268 HAMILTON-01365-

HAMILTON-01366;

HAMILTON-00867;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Rita Langenbrunner

P-2269 HAMILTON-01031-

HAMILTON-01032;

HAMILTON-00736;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Betty Lundy

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 154 of 289 PAGEID #: 31333

155

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2270 HAMILTON-01072-

HAMILTON-01073;

HAMILTON-00758;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Bernice Martin

P-2271 HAMILTON-01064-

HAMILTON-01065;

HAMILTON-00754;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Marianne Mason

P-2272 HAMILTON-01363-

HAMILTON-01364;

HAMILTON-00866;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Elizabeth May

P-2273 HAMILTON-01059-

HAMILTON-01060;

HAMILTON-00751;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Carol Memory

P-2274 HAMILTON-01058;

HAMILTON-00750;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Phyllis Minnich

P-2275 HAMILTON-01019-

HAMILTON-01020;

HAMILTON-00730;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Idit Moss

P-2276 HAMILTON-01047-

HAMILTON-01048;

HAMILTON-00744;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Andrew Munlin

P-2277 HAMILTON-01051;

HAMILTON-00746;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Merle Niederhofer

P-2278 HAMILTON-01054-

HAMILTON-01055;

HAMILTON-00748;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Linda Phillips

P-2279 HAMILTON-01061-

HAMILTON-01062;

HAMILTON-00752;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Joyce Ricking

P-2280 HAMILTON-01016-

HAMILTON-01017;

Voter packet for Carl Rosser

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 155 of 289 PAGEID #: 31334

156

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

HAMILTON-00728;

HAMILTON-00725

P-2281 HAMILTON-01056-

HAMILTON-01057;

HAMILTON-00749;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Kathleen Schnee

P-2282 HAMILTON-01033-

HAMILTON-01034;

HAMILTON-00737;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Peggy Sepate

P-2283 HAMILTON-01359-

HAMILTON-01360;

HAMILTON-00864;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Rachel Slauter

P-2284 HAMILTON-01015;

HAMILTON-00727;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Nyla Tackett

P-2285 HAMILTON-01043-

HAMILTON-01044;

HAMILTON-00742;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for John Tisdel

P-2286 HAMILTON-01025-

HAMILTON-01026;

HAMILTON-00733;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Marcella Vernon

P-2287 HAMILTON-01076-

HAMILTON-01077;

HAMILTON-00760;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for Laura Weber

P-2288 HAMILTON-01039-

HAMILTON-01040;

HAMILTON-00740;

HAMILTON-00725

Voter packet for David Weinberg

P-2289 HAMILTON-01353-

HAMILTON-01354;

HAMILTON-00861;

HAMILTON-00860

Voter packet for Warren Wirtz Jr

P-2290 HAMILTON-01041-

HAMILTON-01042;

HAMILTON-00741;

Voter packet for Betty Wurtzler

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 156 of 289 PAGEID #: 31335

157

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

HAMILTON-00725

P-2291 HAMILTON-01115-

HAMILTON-01116;

HAMILTON-00892;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Erika Agin

P-2292 HAMILTON-01087-

HAMILTON-01088;

HAMILTON-00878;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Joseph Bailey

P-2293 HAMILTON-01342-

HAMILTON-01343;

HAMILTON-00856;

HAMILTON-01267

Voter packet for Norman Baker

P-2294 HAMILTON-01113-

HAMILTON-01114;

HAMILTON-00891;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Margaret Broomfield

P-2295 HAMILTON-01081-

HAMILTON-01082;

HAMILTON-00875;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for John Chase

P-2296 HAMILTON-01323;

HAMILTON-00846;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Vanessa Barber

P-2297 HAMILTON-01095-

HAMILTON-01096;

HAMILTON-00882;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Agnes Dryer

P-2298 HAMILTON-01330-

HAMILTON-01331;

HAMILTON-00850;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Elizabeth Gamble

P-2299 HAMILTON-01093-

HAMILTON-01094;

HAMILTON-00881;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Kelechi Gilbert

P-2300 HAMILTON-01334-

HAMILTON-01335;

HAMILTON-00852;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for John Gormly Sr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 157 of 289 PAGEID #: 31336

158

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2301 HAMILTON-01326-

HAMILTON-01327;

HAMILTON-00848;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Mary Heger

P-2302 HAMILTON-01317-

HAMILTON-01318;

HAMILTON-00843;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Katie Jackson

P-2303 HAMILTON-01089-

HAMILTON-01099;

HAMILTON-00879;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Sandra Kernall

P-2304 HAMILTON-01321-

HAMILTON-01322;

HAMILTON-00845;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Barbara Kidwell

P-2305 HAMILTON-01099-

HAMILTON-01100;

HAMILTON-00884;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Doris Knue

P-2306 HAMILTON-01346-

HAMILTON-01347;

HAMILTON-00858;

HAMILTON-01267

Voter packet for Maureen Krah

P-2307 HAMILTON-01348-

HAMILTON-01349;

HAMILTON-01267

Voter packet for Helen McGoff

P-2308 HAMILTON-01332-

HAMILTON-01333;

HAMILTON-00851;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Mary Metz

P-2309 HAMILTON-01105-

HAMILTON-01106;

HAMILTON-00887;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Rose Moeller

P-2310 HAMILTON-01338-

HAMILTON-01339;

HAMILTON-00854;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Loretta Noahr

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 158 of 289 PAGEID #: 31337

159

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2311 HAMILTON-01336-

HAMILTON-01337;

HAMILTON-00853;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Veronica Nunn

P-2312 HAMILTON-01340-

HAMILTON-01341;

HAMILTON-00855;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Maqueline Rubinoff

P-2313 HAMILTON-01107-

HAMILTON-01108;

HAMILTON-00888;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Dorothy Saldanha

P-2314 HAMILTON-01328-

HAMILTON-01329;

HAMILTON-00849;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Patricia Schaefer

P-2315 HAMILTON-01319--

HAMILTON-01320;

HAMILTON-00844;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Carolyn Phillips Sherman

P-2316 HAMILTON-01097-

HAMILTON-01108;

HAMILTON-00883;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Sutton Smith

P-2317 HAMILTON-01085-

HAMILTON-01086;

HAMILTON-00877;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Whitni Smith

P-2318 HAMILTON-01111-

HAMILTON-01112;

HAMILTON-00890;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for John Walters

P-2319 HAMILTON-01091-

HAMILTON-01092;

HAMILTON-00880;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Angel Ware

P-2320 HAMILTON-01324-

HAMILTON-01325;

HAMILTON-00847;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Glenn Watson Sr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 159 of 289 PAGEID #: 31338

160

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2321 HAMILTON-01101-

HAMILTON-01102;

HAMILTON-00885;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Edgar Willig

P-2322 HAMILTON-01103-

HAMILTON-01104;

HAMILTON-00886;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Thomas Womeldorff

P-2323 HAMILTON-01109-

HAMILTON-01110;

HAMILTON-00889;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Mary Wood

P-2324 HAMILTON-01344-

HAMILTON-01345;

HAMILTON-00857;

HAMILTON-01267

Voter packet for Robert Wood

P-2325 HAMILTON-01083-

HAMILTON-01084;

HAMILTON-00876;

HAMILTON-01080

Voter packet for Margaret Wuellner

P-2326 HAMILTON-01269-

HAMILTON-01270;

HAMILTON-00820;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Molly Baldwin

P-2327 HAMILTON-01350-

HAMILTON-01351;

HAMILTON-00859;

HAMILTON-01267

Voter packet for Laura Miller Ball

P-2328 HAMILTON-01315-

HAMILTON-01316;

HAMILTON-00842;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Elizabeth Beyersdorfer

P-2329 HAMILTON-01295-

HAMILTON-01296;

HAMILTON-00834;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Vilma Bischak

P-2330 HAMILTON-01275;

HAMILTON-00823;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Ronald Bomar

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 160 of 289 PAGEID #: 31339

161

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2331 HAMILTON-01311-

HAMILTON-01312;

HAMILTON-00840;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Timothy Bunch

P-2332 HAMILTON-01285-

HAMILTON-01286;

HAMILTON-00829;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Florence Charles

P-2333 HAMILTON-01276-

HAMILTON-01277;

HAMILTON-00824;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Patricia Clark

P-2334 HAMILTON-01283-

HAMILTON-01284;

HAMILTON-00828;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Viola Dean

P-2335 HAMILTON-01297-

HAMILTON-01298;

HAMILTON-00835;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Dorothy English

P-2336 HAMILTON-01287-

HAMILTON-01288;

HAMILTON-00830;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Audrey Gatto

P-2337 HAMILTON-01126-

HAMILTON-01127;

HAMILTON-00898;

HAMILTON-00893

Voter packet for Lois Gorrasi

P-2338 HAMILTON-01307-

HAMILTON-01308;

HAMILTON-00839;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Herbert Grote

P-2339 HAMILTON-01301-

HAMILTON-01302;

HAMILTON-00836;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Lois Hauck

P-2340 HAMILTON-01281-

HAMILTON-01282;

HAMILTON-00827;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Rose Heidkamp

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 161 of 289 PAGEID #: 31340

162

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2341 HAMILTON-01120-

HAMILTON-01121;

HAMILTON-00895;

HAMILTON-00893

Voter packet for Virginia Johnson

P-2342 HAMILTON-01309-

HAMILTON-01310;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Marilyn Kreidenweis

P-2343 HAMILTON-01279-

HAMILTON-01280;

HAMILTON-00826;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Wyman Lockett Sr.

P-2344 HAMILTON-01313-

HAMILTON-01314;

HAMILTON-00841;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Kristan Lunken

P-2345 HAMILTON-01271-

HAMILTON-01272;

HAMILTON-00821;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Judith McKinney

P-2346 HAMILTON-01303-

HAMILTON-01304;

HAMILTON-00837;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Bernice Mitchell

P-2347 HAMILTON-01299-

HAMILTON-01300;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Laura Owens

P-2348 HAMILTON-01273-

HAMILTON-01274;

HAMILTON-00822;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Philip Pierce

P-2349 HAMILTON-01289-

HAMILTON-01290;

HAMILTON-00831;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Matthew Riesenberg

P-2350 HAMILTON-01268;

HAMILTON-00819;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Peggy Stafford

P-2351 HAMILTON-01278;

HAMILTON-00825;

Voter packet for Annette Strauss

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 162 of 289 PAGEID #: 31341

163

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

HAMILTON-01266

P-2352 HAMILTON-01124-

HAMILTON-01125;

HAMILTON-00897;

HAMILTON-00893

Voter packet for James Telscher Jr.

P-2353 HAMILTON-01305-

HAMILTON-01306;

HAMILTON-00838;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Peggy Tonnis

P-2354 HAMILTON-01291-

HAMILTON-01292;

HAMILTON-00832;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Raymond Vilcinskas

P-2355 HAMILTON-01118-

HAMILTON-01119;

HAMILTON-00894;

HAMILTON-00893

Voter packet for Ronald Wagner

P-2356 HAMILTON-01122-

HAMILTON-01123;

HAMILTON-00896;

HAMILTON-00893

Voter packet for Clifford Watson

P-2357 HAMILTON-01293-

HAMILTON-01294;

HAMILTON-00833;

HAMILTON-01266

Voter packet for Willa Zeka

P-2358 PL002136-002172

Eric H. Kearney, Pavan V. Parikh, and Bethany E. Sanders, Perfect

is the Enemy of Fair: An Analysis of Election Day Error in Ohio's

2012 General Election Through a Discussion of the Materiality

Principle, Compliance Standards, and the Democracy Canon, 62

Clev. St. L. Rev. 279 (2014)

P-2359 Answer to Second Supplemental Complaint (Doc. #454)

P-2360 3/7/16 Subpoena to Delaware County BOE

P-2361 3/7/16 Subpoena to Fairfield County BOE

P-2362 3/7/16 Subpoena to Allen County BOE

P-2363 3/7/16 Subpoena to Lawrence County BOE

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 163 of 289 PAGEID #: 31342

164

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2364 3/7/16 Subpoena to Lorain County BOE

P-2365 3/7/16 Subpoena to Meigs County BOE

P-2366 3/7/16 Subpoena to Miami County BOE

P-2367 3/7/16 Subpoena to Montgomery County BOE (C. Clark)

P-2368 3/7/16 Subpoena to Montgomery County BOE (J. Kelly)

P-2369 3/7/16 Subpoena to Richland County BOE

P-2370 3/7/16 Subpoena to Stark County BOE

P-2371 3/7/16 Subpoena to Warren County BOE

P-2372 11/18/15 Email from Judy Miller, Clermont County BOE, to Brandi Seskes

regarding a poll worker who signed six provisional envelopes

P-2373 3/14/12 Email from Kristen Rine to Darke County BOE regarding

identification box being initialed by poll worker

P-2374 FRA-03210-

FRA-03211

Voter packet for Mildred Anthony

P-2375 FRA-03044-

FRA-03045

Voter packet for Lounie Aurelus

P-2376 FRA-03046-

FRA-03047

Voter packet for Joan Bird

P-2377 FRA-03208-

FRA-03209

Voter packet for Eben Ford

P-2378 FRA-03084-

FRA-03085

Voter packet for Andrew Hughes

P-2379 FRA-03206-

FRA-03207

Voter packet for Dorothy Moore

P-2380 FRA-03052-

FRA-03053

Voter packet for Stefanie Andrews

P-2381 FRA-03116-

FRA-03117

Voter packet for Lisa Banks

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 164 of 289 PAGEID #: 31343

165

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2382 FRA-03255-

FRA-03256

Voter packet for Victoria Banks

P-2383 FRA-03291-

FRA-03292

Voter packet for Elizabeth Coffman

P-2384 FRA-03120-

FRA-03121

Voter packet for Stacie Daniels-Rodgers

P-2385 FRA-03289-

FRA-03290

Voter packet for Andrew Deberry

P-2386 FRA-03068-

FRA-03069

Voter packet for Edith Downey

P-2387 FRA-03216-

FRA-03217

Voter packet for Dominique Dunning

P-2388 FRA-03283-

FRA-03284

Voter packet for Niles Foss

P-2389 FRA-03054-

FRA-03055

Voter packet for Christina Harris

P-2390 FRA-03098-

FRA-03099

Voter packet for Mary Manns

P-2391 FRA-03078-

FRA-03079

Voter packet for Marlene Murray

P-2392 FRA-03102-

FRA-03103

Voter packet for Lawrence Price

P-2393 FRA-03066-

FRA-03067

Voter packet for Delphine Rodgers

P-2394 FRA-03124-

FRA-03125

Voter packet for Ngai Scriven

P-2395 FRA-03293-

FRA-03294

Voter packet for Wanda Sparrow-Marshall

P-2396 FRA-03221-

FRA-03222

Voter packet for Gregory Staples

P-2397 FRA-03104-

FRA-03105

Voter packet for Thomas Kraft

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 165 of 289 PAGEID #: 31344

166

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2398 FRA-03297-

FRA-03298

Voter packet for Faith McCullough

P-2399 FRA-03062-

FRA-03063

Voter packet for Jamie Ray

P-2400 FRA-03056-

FRA-03057

Voter packet for Andrew Trotter

P-2401 FRA-03253-

FRA-03254

Voter packet for Ahmed Aden

P-2402 FRA-03058-

FRA-03059

Voter packet for Georgina Atakora

P-2403 FRA-03108-

FRA-03109

Voter packet for Virginia Hamilton

P-2404 FRA-03247-

FRA-03248

Voter packet for Leon Hardy Jr.

P-2405 FRA-03112-

FRA-03113

Voter packet for Janet Johnson

P-2406 FRA-03048-

FRA-03049

Voter packet for Tyanna Johnson

P-2407 FRA-03122-

FRA-03123

Voter packet for Teresa Kelly

P-2408 FRA-03100-

FRA-03101

Voter packet for Rhoda Linder

P-2409 FRA-03114-

FRA-03115

Voter packet for Jack Maynard

P-2410 FRA-03096-

FRA-03097

Voter packet for Thomas Montell

P-2411 FRA-03072-

FRA-03073

Voter packet for Gregory Moore

P-2412 FRA-03118-

FRA-03119

Voter packet for Pamela Ndossi

P-2413 FRA-03106-

FRA-03107

Voter packet for Harold Newell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 166 of 289 PAGEID #: 31345

167

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2414 FRA-03050-

FRA-03051

Voter packet for George Obeng

P-2415 FRA-03076-

FRA-03077

Voter packet for Gordon Starks

P-2416 FRA-03080-

FRA-03081

Voter packet for Charles Ziegler

P-2417 FRA-03235-

FRA-03236

Voter packet for Nick Agresti

P-2418 FRA-03265-

FRA-03266

Voter packet for Kadar Hiir

P-2419 FRA-03345;

FRA-03343-

FRA03344;FRA-03346

Voter packet for McClain Murphy

P-2420 FRA-03269-

FRA-03270

Voter packet for Timothy Sowards

P-2421 FRA-03285-

FRA-03286

Voter packet for Kenneth Switzer

P-2422 FRA-03082-

FRA-03083

Voter packet for Mohamed Abdi

P-2423 FRA-03060-

FRA-03061

Voter packet for Mohamed Abdikadar

P-2424 FRA-03257-

FRA-03258

Voter packet for Carl Boor

P-2425 FRA-03212-

FRA-03213

Voter packet for Yvonne Daniels

P-2426 FRA-03086-

FRA-03087

Voter packet for Mindy Guzman

P-2427 FRA-03214-

FRA-03215

Voter packet for Heather Jackson

P-2428 FRA-03070-

FRA-03071

Voter packet for Mary Lavally

P-2429 FRA-03243-

FRA-03244

Voter packet for Heather Richards

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 167 of 289 PAGEID #: 31346

168

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2430 FRA-03074-

FRA-03075

Voter packet for Connor Spiech

P-2431 FRA-03064-

FRA-03065

Voter packet for Leo Wright

P-2432 FRA-03150-

FRA-03151

Voter packet for Danielle Alley

P-2433 FRA-03162-

FRA-03163

Voter packet for Robert Anthony

P-2434 FRA-03337-

FRA-03338

Voter packet for Selamawit Aregay

P-2435 FRA-03273-

FRA-03274

Voter packet for Matthew Bergland

P-2436 FRA-03144-

FRA-03145

Voter packet for Anthony Bernardi

P-2437 FRA-03132;

FRA-03131;

FRA-03133

Voter packet for Sara Boyer

P-2438 FRA-03138-

FRA-03139

Voter packet for Amanda Chernyak

P-2439 FRA-03251-

FRA-03252

Voter packet for Michael Eff

P-2440 FRA-03281-

FRA-03282

Voter packet for Nancy Exline

P-2441 FRA-03127;

FRA-03126;

FRA-03128

Voter packet for Deborah Green

P-2442 FRA-03170-

FRA-03171

Voter packet for Virginia Hanford

P-2443 FRA-04764;

FRA-03196

Voter packet for Elisabeth Hire

P-2444 FRA-03259-

FRA-03260

Voter packet for Allison Klusacek

P-2445 FRA-03199-

FRA-03200

Voter packet for Ronald Mansaray

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 168 of 289 PAGEID #: 31347

169

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2446 FRA-03148-

FRA-03149

Voter packet for Mary McCulla

P-2447 FRA-03188-

FRA-03189

Voter packet for Jane Minton

P-2448 FRA-03404-

FRA-03405

Voter packet for Lamont Nash

P-2449 FRA-03146-

FRA-03147

Voter packet for Scott Navicky

P-2450 FRA-03263-

FRA-03264

Voter packet for Maki Osman

P-2451 FRA-03176-

FRA-03177

Voter packet for David Ransom

P-2452 FRA-03315;

FRA-03314;

FRA-03316

Voter packet for Charles Ratliff

P-2453 FRA-03223-

FRA-03224

Voter packet for Alozono Treadwell

P-2454 FRA-03194-

FRA-03195

Voter packet for Karie Urban

P-2455 FRA-03182;

FRA-03181;

FRA-03183

Voter packet for Michael Vathrakides

P-2456 FRA-03339-

FRA-03340

Voter packet for Mary Helen Wachtel

P-2457 FRA-03197-

FRA-03198

Voter packet for Blanche Warner

P-2458 FRA-03277-

FRA-03278

Voter packet for Maureen Willis

P-2459 FRA-03158-

FRA-03159

Voter packet for Adeline Acquah

P-2460 FRA-03229-

FRA-03230

Voter packet for Charleston Battle

P-2461 FRA-03249-

FRA-03250

Voter packet for Brittany Burkey

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 169 of 289 PAGEID #: 31348

170

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2462 FRA-03275-

FRA-03276

Voter packet for Ehon Casarcz

P-2463 FRA-03237-

FRA-03238

Voter packet for Earleen Charles

P-2464 FRA-03203;

FRA-03201;

FRA-03202;

FRA-03204

Voter packet for Shermanetta Clinkscale

P-2465 FRA-03160-

FRA-03161

Voter packet for Christine Conley

P-2466 FRA-03384;

FRA-03383;

FRA-03385

Voter packet for Pilar Dawson

P-2467 FRA-03349-

FRA-03350

Voter packet for Jaqueia Dickerson

P-2468 FRA-03166-

FRA-03167

Voter packet for Michael Dmytryk

P-2469 FRA-03192;

FRA-03190;

FRA-03191;

FRA-03193

Voter packet for Richard Fritz

P-2470 FRA-03271-

FRA-03272

Voter packet for Ciera Futch

P-2471 FRA-03393;

FRA-03391;

FRA-03392;

FRA-03394

Voter packet for Adam Gunnell

P-2472 FRA-03218-

FRA-03219

Voter packet for Christina Hannah

P-2473 FRA-03402;

FRA-03400;

FRA-03401;

FRA-03403

Voter packet for James Harris Jr.

P-2474 FRA-03142-

FRA-03143

Voter packet for Sara Hise

P-2475 FRA-03134- Voter packet for Tashaya Howard

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 170 of 289 PAGEID #: 31349

171

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-03135

P-2476 FRA-03129-

FRA-03130

Voter packet for Liakat Khan

P-2477 FRA-03308;

FRA-03306-FRA-03307;

FRA-03309

Voter packet for Shawn Kelley

P-2478 FRA-03331;

FRA-03329- FRA-

03330; FRA-03332

Voter packet for Omar Kure

P-2479 FRA-03389;

FRA-03388;

FRA-03390

Voter packet for Ida Lattimer

P-2480 FRA-03379-

FRA-03380

Voter packet for Nancy Laver

P-2481 FRA-03154-

FRA-03155

Voter packet for William Machingo

P-2482 FRA-03398-

FRA-03399

Voter packet for Elizabeth Madumelu

P-2483 FRA-03279-

FRA-03280

Voter packet for Theodora Makara

P-2484 FRA-03156-

FRA-03157

Voter packet for Brenda McCaskill

P-2485 FRA-03386-

FRA-03387

Voter packet for Ernest McCrory

P-2486 FRA-03299-

FRA-03300

Voter packet for Faith McCullough

P-2487 FRA-03179-

FRA-03180

Voter packet for Diane Payton

P-2488 FRA-03140-

FRA-03141

Voter packet for Nerlande Pierre

P-2489 FRA-03231-

FRA-03232

Voter packet for Kathy Reinhart

P-2490 FRA-03136-

FRA-03137

Voter packet for Yamah Roberts

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 171 of 289 PAGEID #: 31350

172

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2491 FRA-03381-

FRA-03382

Voter packet for Rhonda Salvatore

P-2492 FRA-03186;

FRA-03184-FRA-03185;

FRA-03187

Voter packet for James Scales

P-2493 FRA-03174-

FRA-03175

Voter packet for John Shultz

P-2494 FRA-03267-

FRA-03268

Voter packet for Kenya Scott

P-2495 FRA-03396;

FRA-03395;

FRA-03397

Voter packet for Joseph Stapleton

P-2496 FRA-03168-

FRA-03169

Voter packet for Peggy Thielsen

P-2497 FRA-03325;

FRA-03323-FRA-03324;

FRA-03326

Voter packet for Timothy Thompson

P-2498 FRA-03152-

FRA-03153

Voter packet for George Truswell

P-2499 FRA-03304;

FRA-03303;

FRA-03305

Voter packet for Charles Uting

P-2500 FRA-03164-

FRA-03165

Voter packet for Vesta Caldwell

P-2501 FRA-03355;

FRA-03353-FRA-03354;

FRA-03356

Voter packet for William Cody

P-2502 FRA-03172-

FRA-03173

Voter packet for Horace Collins

P-2503 FRA-03287-

FRA-03288

Voter packet for Judith Schneider

P-2504 FRA-04504;

FRA-04503;

FRA-02733

Voter packet for Adrienne Colson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 172 of 289 PAGEID #: 31351

173

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2505 FRA-04145;

FRA-04144;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Joyce Holbrook

P-2506 FRA-04183; FRA-

04181-FRA04182; FRA-

04184; FRA-02674

Voter packet for Larry Swanson

P-2507 FRA-04116;

FRA-04115;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Elizabeth Abrams

P-2508 FRA-04013;

FRA-04012;

FRA-02661

Voter packet for Amina Barakat

P-2509 FRA-04523;

FRA-04522;

FRA-02748

Voter packet for Billy Barclay

P-2510 FRA-04063;

FRA-04062;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Ryan Berrigan

P-2511 FRA-04065;

FRA-04064;

FRA-02646

Voter packet for Colleen Birch

P-2512 FRA-04102;

FRA-04101;

FRA-02632

Voter packet for Paul Blackburn

P-2513 FRA-04076;

FRA-04075;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Christian Braswell

P-2514 FRA-04051;

FRA-04050;

FRA-02692

Voter packet for Stefan Bruch

P-2515 FRA-04086;

FRA-04085;

FRA-02662

Voter packet for John Cancila

P-2516 FRA-04088;

FRA-04087;

FRA-02678

Voter packet for Constance Cantor

P-2517 FRA-04090;

FRA-04089;

Voter packet for Morgan Clarke

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 173 of 289 PAGEID #: 31352

174

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02684

P-2518 FRA-04017;

FRA-04016;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for Joel Cox

P-2519 FRA-04061;

FRA-04060;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Ronald Cox

P-2520 FRA-04105;

FRA-04104;

FRA-02674

Voter packet for Melissa Dela Cruz

P-2521 FRA-04041;

FRA-04040;

FRA-02695

Voter packet for Virginia Danner

P-2522 FRA-04194;

FRA-04193;

FRA-02701

Voter packet for Shawn Dorn

P-2523 FRA-04047;

FRA-04046;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Emily Edwards

P-2524 FRA-04107;

FRA-04106;

FRA-02641

Voter packet for Scott Fredrickson

P-2525 FRA-04039;

FRA-04038;

FRA-02713

Voter packet for Scott Ganger

P-2526 FRA-04045;

FRA-04044;

FRA-02700

Voter packet for Terry Garcia

P-2527 FRA-04179;

FRA-04178;

FRA-02679

Voter packet for Penny Giesemann

P-2528 FRA-04005;

FRA-04004;

FRA-02670

Voter packet for Shana Gillikin

P-2529 FRA-04080;

FRA-04079;

FRA-02650

Voter packet for Kevin Grove

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 174 of 289 PAGEID #: 31353

175

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2530 FRA-04082;

FRA-04081;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Sarah Grove

P-2531 FRA-04499;

FRA-04498;

FRA-02726

Voter packet for John Gugliemotto

P-2532 FRA-04502;

FRA-04501;

FRA-02731

Voter packet for Theresa Harrington

P-2533 FRA-04120;

FRA-04119;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Megan Hatta

P-2534 FRA-04021;

FRA-04020;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Melanie Hickman

P-2535 FRA-04132;

FRA-04131;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Leanne Hines

P-2536 FRA-04151;

FRA-04150;

FRA-02687

Voter packet for Patricia Hughes

P-2537 FRA-04186;

FRA-04185;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Michael Hullom Sr.

P-2538 FRA-04126;

FRA-04125;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Freddie James

P-2539 FRA-04155;

FRA-04154;

FRA-02680

Voter packet for Gisele James

P-2540 FRA-04092;

FRA-04091;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Josia Klein

P-2541 FRA-04134;

FRA-04133;

FRA-02698

Voter packet for Nancy Korte

P-2542 FRA-04003;

FRA-04002;

Voter packet for Kristina Kreider

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 175 of 289 PAGEID #: 31354

176

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02684

P-2543 FRA-04525;

FRA-04524;

FRA-02735

Voter packet for Hannah Kyle

P-2544 FRA-04049;

FRA-04048;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for Courtney Lock

P-2545 FRA-04124;

FRA-04123;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Abby Losinski

P-2546 FRA-04130;

FRA-04129;

FRA-02625

Voter packet for Shirley Malone

P-2547 FRA-04509;

FRA-02743

Voter packet for Kristina McCullough

P-2548 FRA-04025;

FRA-04024;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Alexandra McElwee

P-2549 FRA-04495;

FRA-04494;

FRA-02719

Voter packet for Nicole McQuade

P-2550 FRA-04169;

FRA-04168;

FRA-02698

Voter packet for Shirley Mendenhall

P-2551 FRA-04098;

FRA-04097;

FRA-02695

Voter packet for Sarah Monley

P-2552 FRA-04149;

FRA-04148;

FRA-02632

Voter packet for Sharon Montgomery

P-2553 FRA-04511;

FRA-04510;

FRA-02762

Voter packet for Adam Mott

P-2554 FRA-04067;

FRA-04066;

FRA-02701

Voter packet for James Myefski

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 176 of 289 PAGEID #: 31355

177

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2555 FRA-04053;

FRA-04052;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Amanda Nagy

P-2556 FRA-04122;

FRA-04121;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for Alyssa Neville

P-2557 FRA-04007;

FRA-04006;

FRA-02681

Voter packet for Andrew Obrien

P-2558 FRA-04157;

FRA-04156;

FRA-02664-FRA-02665

Voter packet for Dale Ott

P-2559 FRA-04059;

FRA-04058;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Lacey Pahren

P-2560 FRA-04072;

FRA-04071;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Amy Peabody

P-2561 FRA-04147;

FRA-04146;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Cheryl Pohlable

P-2562 FRA-04521;

FRA-04520;

FRA-02725

Voter packet for Laura Rains

P-2563 FRA-04035;

FRA-04034;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for June Rakes

P-2564 FRA-04190;

FRA-04189;

FRA-02650

Voter packet for Dawn Reeder

P-2565 FRA-04043;

FRA-04042;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Kim Rice

P-2566 FRA-04528;

FRA-04527;

FRA-02758

Voter packet for Florence Robinette

P-2567 FRA-04055;

FRA-04054;

Voter packet for Hannah Rost

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 177 of 289 PAGEID #: 31356

178

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02653

P-2568 FRA-04084;

FRA-04083;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for David Sander

P-2569 FRA-04078;

FRA-04077;

FRA-02645

Voter packet for Lamariam St John

P-2570 FRA-04175;

FRA-04174;

FRA-02624

Voter packet for Susan Skaggs

P-2571 FRA-04114;

FRA-04113;

FRA-02659

Voter packet for Mark Stauffer

P-2572 FRA-04140;

FRA-04139;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Thomas Stebbins

P-2573 FRA-04165;

FRA-04164;

FRA-02708

Voter packet for Martha Stidham

P-2574 FRA-04029;

FRA-04028;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for Nathaniel Stone

P-2575 FRA-04074;

FRA-04073;

FRA-02672

Voter packet for Michael Stull

P-2576 FRA-04177;

FRA-04176;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Robert Tatum Jr.

P-2577 FRA-04161;

FRA-04160;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Dallas Tyree Jr.

P-2578 FRA-04167;

FRA-04166;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for Teresa Walker

P-2579 FRA-04192;

FRA-04191;

FRA-02652

Voter packet for Selena Wallace

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 178 of 289 PAGEID #: 31357

179

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2580 FRA-04171;

FRA-04170;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Mary White

P-2581 FRA-04173;

FRA-04172;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Willighby White

P-2582 FRA-04519;

FRA-04518;

FRA-02763

Voter packet for Matthew Williams

P-2583 FRA-04023

FRA-04022;

FRA-02631

Voter packet for Trenae Williams

P-2584 FRA-04516;

FRA-04515;

FRA-02732

Voter packet for Jennifer Witcher

P-2585 FRA-04031;

FRA-04030;

FRA-02663

Voter packet for Lance Witcher

P-2586 FRA-04033;

FRA-04032;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Jill Woodworth

P-2587 FRA-04118;

FRA-04117;

FRA-02690

Voter packet for Nicholas Zettler

P-2588 FRA-03582;

FRA-03581;

FRA-02709

Voter packet for Garima Agarwal

P-2589 FRA-03558;

FRA-03557;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Don Allen

P-2590 FRA-03731;

FRA-03730;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Lynne Ayres

P-2591 FRA-03942;

FRA-03941;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Gene Bennett

P-2592 FRA-03423;

FRA-03422;

Voter packet for Kenneth Boggs

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 179 of 289 PAGEID #: 31358

180

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02672

P-2593 FRA-03977;

FRA-03976;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Regina Burns

P-2594 FRA-03721;

FRA-03720;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Angelo DelCol

P-2595 FRA-03950;

FRA-03949;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for Roland Gilbert

P-2596 FRA-03600;

FRA-03599;

FRA-02694

Voter packet for Hazel Huddleston

P-2597 FRA-03725;

FRA-03724;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Frances Johnson

P-2598 FRA-03903;

FRA-03902;

FRA-02674

Voter packet for Mark Quinlan

P-2599 FRA-03883;

FRA-03882;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for David Roach

P-2600 FRA-03432;

FRA-03431;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Andrew Salter

P-2601 FRA-03645;

FRA-03644;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Euphemia Ninely

P-2602 FRA-03572;

FRA-03571;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for Clarence Smith

P-2603 FRA-03446; FRA-

03445; FRA-02679-

FRA-02680

Voter packet for Roger Thomas II

P-2604 FRA-03814;

FRA-03813;

FRA-02696

Voter packet for Gayle Adams

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 180 of 289 PAGEID #: 31359

181

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2605 FRA-03469;

FRA-03468;

FRA-02680

Voter packet for Nick Albanese

P-2606 FRA-03602;

FRA-03601;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Catherine Alexander

P-2607 FRA-03524; FRA-

03523; FRA-3526; FRA-

02704

Voter packet for Nargis Ali

P-2608 FRA-03483;

FRA-03482;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Fuad Alshami

P-2609 FRA-03897;

FRA-03896;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Richard Anderson

P-2610 FRA-03871;

FRA-03870;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Susan Angel

P-2611 FRA-03454;

FRA-03453;

FRA-02710

Voter packet for Jacqueline Aurand

P-2612 FRA-03727;

FRA-03726;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for Lillie Bagent

P-2613 FRA-03487;

FRA-03486;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Thomas Baker

P-2614 FRA-03740;

FRA-03739;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Francis Barrett

P-2615 FRA-03465;

FRA-03464;

FRA-02692

Voter packet for Jason Beilchick

P-2616 FRA-03667;

FRA-03666;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Constance Bender

P-2617 FRA-03789; FRA-

03788; FRA-02705-

Voter packet for Charles Bennett

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 181 of 289 PAGEID #: 31360

182

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02706

P-2618 FRA-03629;

FRA-03628;

FRA-02673

Voter packet for Gary Berestovetsky

P-2619 FRA-03665;

FRA-03664;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Wayne Blevens

P-2620 FRA-03430;

FRA-03429;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Eric Boice

P-2621 FRA-03485;

FRA-03484;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Samantha Booker

P-2622 FRA-03436;

FRA-03435;

FRA-02635

Voter packet for Justin Boring

P-2623 FRA-03865;

FRA-03864;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for John Bowie

P-2624 FRA-03967;

FRA-03966;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Cheri Boyd

P-2625 FRA-03765;

FRA-03764;

FRA-02694

Voter packet for Phyllis Brant

P-2626 FRA-03842;

FRA-03841;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Dean Bright

P-2627 FRA-03448;

FRA-03447;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Gregory Briya

P-2628 FRA-03938;

FRA-03937;

FRA-02692

Voter packet for John Brumfield

P-2629 FRA-03848;

FRA-03847;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Robert Brummel

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 182 of 289 PAGEID #: 31361

183

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2630 FRA-03812;

FRA-03811;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Richard Bruner Sr

P-2631 FRA-03863;

FRA-03862;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Beth Bucher

P-2632 FRA-03624; FRA-

03623; FRA-03625;

FRA-02662-

FRA-02663

Voter packet for Douglas Burch

P-2633 FRA-03875;

FRA-03874;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Arnold Calhoun

P-2634 FRA-03450;

FRA-03449;

FRA-02649

Voter packet for Marjorie Carr

P-2635 FRA-03899;

FRA-03898;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Mary Carroll

P-2636 FRA-03479;

FRA-03478;

FRA-02689

Voter packet for Vontisha Cason

P-2637 FRA-03438;

FRA-03437;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Jim Centers

P-2638 FRA-03608;

FRA-03607;

FRA-02632

Voter packet for Richard Chambers II

P-2639 FRA-03906;

FRA-03905;

FRA-02627

Voter packet for Susan Chittum

P-2640 FRA-03688;

FRA-03687;

FRA-02644

Voter packet for Debbie Clemans

P-2641 FRA-03501;

FRA-03500;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Andre Clemons

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 183 of 289 PAGEID #: 31362

184

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2642 FRA-03528;

FRA-03527;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Monika Collins

P-2643 FRA-03948;

FRA-03947;

FRA-02712

Voter packet for Mark Cooper

P-2644 FRA-03972-

FRA-03973;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Martha Coston

P-2645 FRA-03717;

FRA-03716;

FRA-02664

Voter packet for Corine Crenshaw

P-2646 FRA-03791;

FRA-03790;

FRA-02649

Voter packet for Maxine Damron

P-2647 FRA-03869;

FRA-03868;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for Duel Davidson

P-2648 FRA-03940;

FRA-03941;

FRA-02668

Voter packet for Keith Davidson

P-2649 FRA-03544;

FRA-03543;

FRA-02659

Voter packet for Rawley Davis

P-2650 FRA-03816;

FRA-03815;

FRA-02664

Voter packet for Diana Davison

P-2651 11/4/14 CUY-01139 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Cuyahoga County

P-2652 11/4/14 CUY-01140-

CUY01142

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Cuyahoga County

P-2653 CUY-00578-CUY-

00579; CUY-00569

Voter packet for Anita Cupedro

P-2654 CUY-00337-

CUY-00338

Voter packet for Jaydee Jebboe

P-2655 CUY-00343-

CUY-00344

Voter packet for George Kalista

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 184 of 289 PAGEID #: 31363

185

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2656 CUY-00377-

CUY-00378

Voter packet for Brinton Markus

P-2657 CUY-00385-

CUY-00386

Voter packet for Melinda Meredith

P-2658 CUY-00456-

CUY-00457

Voter packet for Carraze Woodard

P-2659 CUY-00458-

CUY-00459

Voter packet for Ann Young

P-2660 CUY-00207-

CUY-00208

Voter packet for Michelle Abram

P-2661 CUY-00209-

CUY-00210

Voter packet for Danesha Adams

P-2662 CUY-00211-

CUY-00212

Voter packet for Blair Alexandersen

P-2663 CUY-00213-

CUY-00214

Voter packet for Nancy Allenson

P-2664 CUY-00215-

CUY-00216

Voter packet for Anthony Amaddio

P-2665 CUY-00217-

CUY-00218

Voter packet for Dorothy Appling

P-2666 CUY-00219-

CUY-00220

Voter packet for Michael Arison

P-2667 CUY-00221-

CUY-00222

Voter packet for Renee Banal

P-2668 CUY-00223-

CUY-00224

Voter packet for Stephen Banhidy

P-2669 CUY-00225-

CUY-00226

Voter packet for Katherine Beckenbach

P-2670 CUY-00227-

CUY-00228

Voter packet for Megan Bennett

P-2671 CUY-00570-

CUY-00571;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Richard Black Jr

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 185 of 289 PAGEID #: 31364

186

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2672 CUY-00229-

CUY-00230

Voter packet for Robert Boggs

P-2673 CUY-00231-

CUY-00232

Voter packet for Alex Bondar

P-2674 CUY-00233-

CUY-00234

Voter packet for Chandra Bowling

P-2675 CUY-00235-

CUY-00236

Voter packet for Melissa Bowling

P-2676 CUY-00237-

CUY-00238

Voter packet for Wanda Brannon

P-2677 CUY-00239-

CUY-00240

Voter packet for Rebecca Brown

P-2678 CUY-00241-

CUY-00242

Voter packet for David Bruckman

P-2679 CUY-00243-

CUY-00244

Voter packet for Kenneth Burton

P-2680 CUY-00245-

CUY-00246

Voter packet for Madeline Bush

P-2681 CUY-00247-

CUY-00248

Voter packet for Annie Byers

P-2682 CUY-00249-

CUY-00250

Voter packet for James Callihan

P-2683 CUY-00251-

CUY-00252

Voter packet for David Campbell III

P-2684 CUY-00253-

CUY-00254

Voter packet for Evelyn Carter

P-2685 CUY-00255-

CUY-00256

Voter packet for Hunter Cavell

P-2686 CUY-00572-

CUY-00573;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Mary An Chalmers

P-2687 CUY-00257-

CUY-00258

Voter packet for Eric Chapman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 186 of 289 PAGEID #: 31365

187

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2688 CUY-00259-

CUY-00260

Voter packet for Anthony Chichy

P-2689 CUY-00261-

CUY-00262

Voter packet for Linda Cistolo

P-2690 CUY-00574-

CUY-00575;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Cassandra Clapp

P-2691 CUY-00263-

CUY-00264

Voter packet for William Claxton

P-2692 CUY-00265-

CUY-00266

Voter packet for Lucy Cline

P-2693 CUY-00267-

CUY-00268

Voter packet for Deontea Coleman

P-2694 CUY-00576-

CUY-00577;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Robert Consiglio

P-2695 CUY-00269-

CUY-00270

Voter packet for Steven Cottier

P-2696 CUY-00271-

CUY-00272

Voter packet for Brenda Cunningham

P-2697 CUY-00273-

CUY-00274

Voter packet for Anita Dailey

P-2698 CUY-00275-

CUY-00276

Voter packet for Mattie Dalton

P-2699 CUY-00277-

CUY-00278

Voter packet for Michael Daniels

P-2700 CUY-00279-

CUY-00280

Voter packet for Joshua Davis

P-2701 CUY-00281-

CUY-00282

Voter packet for Isiah Donner

P-2702 CUY-00580-

CUY-00581;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Charles Engle

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 187 of 289 PAGEID #: 31366

188

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2703 CUY-00283-

CUY-00284

Voter packet for David Eskenazi

P-2704 CUY-00285-

CUY-00286

Voter packet for Glenn Evans

P-2705 CUY-00289-

CUY-00290

Voter packet for Robert Finks Jr

P-2706 CUY-00291-

CUY-00292

Voter packet for Gwendolyn Frizzell

P-2707 CUY-00293-

CUY-00294

Voter packet for Maria Gerrick

P-2708 CUY-00295-

CUY-00296

Voter packet for Rickie Gilbert

P-2709 CUY-00297-

CUY-00298

Voter packet for Sandra Gilbert

P-2710 CUY-00299-

CUY-00300

Voter packet for Calvin Goldsmith

P-2711 CUY-00301-

CUY-00302

Voter packet for Joseph Good

P-2712 CUY-00303-

CUY-00304

Voter packet for Leslie Granoff

P-2713 CUY-00305-

CUY-00306

Voter packet for Frances Greene

P-2714 CUY-00307-

CUY-00308

Voter packet for Moisey Greyzer

P-2715 CUY-00582-

CUY-00583;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Mable Grice

P-2716 CUY-00309-

CUY-00310

Voter packet for Richard Grover

P-2717 CUY-00311-

CUY-00312

Voter packet for Martin Gullatta

P-2718 CUY-00313-

CUY-00314

Voter packet for Stephanie Harkness

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 188 of 289 PAGEID #: 31367

189

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2719 CUY-00315-

CUY-00316

Voter packet for Michael Harris

P-2720 CUY-00317-

CUY-00318

Voter packet for Michael Henderson

P-2721 CUY-00319-

CUY-00320

Voter packet for Gail Herd

P-2722 CUY-00321-

CUY-00322

Voter packet for Linda Hill

P-2723 CUY-00323-

CUY-00324

Voter packet for Mary Holmes

P-2724 CUY-00584-

CUY-00585;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Joey Horton Sr

P-2725 CUY-00325-

CUY-00326

Voter packet for Steven Huffenbach

P-2726 CUY-00327-

CUY-00328

Voter packet for Laura Hughmanic

P-2727 CUY-00329-

CUY-00330

Voter packet for Faramarz Ismailbeigi

P-2728 CUY-00331-

CUY-00332

Voter packet for Stephano Jackson

P-2729 CUY-00333-

CUY-00334

Voter packet for Martha Jaffe

P-2730 CUY-00335-

CUY-00336

Voter packet for Kysean James

P-2731 CUY-00339-

CUY-00340

Voter packet for Roderick Johnstone

P-2732 CUY-00341-

CUY-00342

Voter packet for John Joyce

P-2733 CUY-00345-

CUY-00346

Voter packet for Joseph Kaman

P-2734 CUY-00347-

CUY-00348

Voter packet for James Kaplan

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 189 of 289 PAGEID #: 31368

190

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2735 CUY-00586-

CUY-00587;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Joyce Kedzierski

P-2736 CUY-00349-

CUY-00350

Voter packet for Marie Williams

P-2737 CUY-00351-

CUY-00352

Voter packet for Barbara Kennedy

P-2738 CUY-00353-

CUY-00354

Voter packet for Maya Kennedy

P-2739 CUY-00588-

CUY-00589;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Mary Kilbiane

P-2740 CUY-00355-

CUY-00356

Voter packet for Kimberly Kinzer-Sasyn

P-2741 CUY-00357-

CUY-00358

Voter packet for Mary Koeth

P-2742 CUY-00359-

CUY-00360

Voter packet for Betty Koppelman

P-2743 CUY-00361-

CUY-00362

Voter packet for Cathy Lape

P-2744 CUY-00363-

CUY-00364

Voter packet for Ricky Leonard

P-2745 CUY-00365-

CUY-00366

Voter packet for Frances Lewis

P-2746 CUY-00367-

CUY-00368

Voter packet for Roger Lichtig

P-2747 CUY-00369-

CUY-00370

Voter packet for Doniella Ligon

P-2748 CUY-00371-

CUY-00372

Voter packet for Colleen Longo

P-2749 CUY-00373-

CUY-00374

Voter packet for Douglas Lyon

P-2750 CUY-00375-

CUY-00376

Voter packet for Catherine MacMillan

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 190 of 289 PAGEID #: 31369

191

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2751 CUY-00379-

CUY-00380

Voter packet for Cassidy Mason

P-2752 CUY-00381-

CUY-00382

Voter packet for Matthew McDade

P-2753 CUY-00590-

CUY-00591;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Ray McGuire

P-2754 CUY-00383-

CUY-00384

Voter packet for Elena Medina

P-2755 CUY-00592-

CUY-00593;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for David Meister

P-2756 CUY-00387-

CUY-00388

Voter packet for Jennifer Miller

P-2757 CUY-00678;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Joseph Accordinu

P-2758 CUY-00666;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for James Albright

P-2759 CUY-00838;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Dewight Alexander

P-2760 CUY-00867;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Ricky Barnett

P-2761 CUY-00857;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for John Bassett

P-2762 CUY-00864;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Manuela Benn

P-2763 CUY-00873;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Sue Bernstein

P-2764 CUY-00679;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Pamela Bryson

P-2765 CUY-00680;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for John Burserean

P-2766 CUY-00674;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Shauna Carter

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 191 of 289 PAGEID #: 31370

192

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2767 CUY-00657;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Joseph Catsor

P-2768 CUY-00854;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Matthew Cheery

P-2769 CUY-00846;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Elizabeth Christner

P-2770 CUY-00874;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Demetrius Collier

P-2771 CUY-00875;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Harold Crosby

P-2772 CUY-00853;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Matthew Dagata

P-2773 CUY-00840;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Gregory Dennis

P-2774 CUY-00835;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Margaret Diemer

P-2775 CUY-00662;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Tyrone Dorsey Sr

P-2776 CUY-00847;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Clara Drake

P-2777 CUY-00850;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for K. Drake

P-2778 CUY-00671;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for David Gault

P-2779 CUY-00870;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Jeanette Green

P-2780 CUY-00848;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Johnathan Griggs

P-2781 CUY-00831;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Tracy Hall

P-2782 CUY-00832;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Kianna Harris

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 192 of 289 PAGEID #: 31371

193

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2783 CUY-00834;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Jennifer Holt

P-2784 CUY-00843;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Demere Houston

P-2785 CUY-00836;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Aaron Jackson

P-2786 CUY-00845;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for LaQuita Jackson

P-2787 CUY-00837;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Terrie Jackson

P-2788 CUY-00663;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Walter Jackson

P-2789 CUY-00872;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Quran Jarvis

P-2790 CUY-00862;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Robert Jemison

P-2791 CUY-00675;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Kemberly Jennings-Brown

P-2792 CUY-00839;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Dionte Johnson

P-2793 CUY-00851;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Willie Lee

P-2794 CUY-00668;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Tammy Long

P-2795 CUY-00660;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Cynthia Love-Clay

P-2796 CUY-00841;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Sylvietta Lynch

P-2797 CUY-00865;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Marie Mandzuk

P-2798 CUY-00863;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Homa Memari

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 193 of 289 PAGEID #: 31372

194

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2799 CUY-00866;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Disus Moss

P-2800 CUY-00667;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Stanley Patterson

P-2801 CUY-00849;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Nikha Reynolds

P-2802 CUY-00859;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Laura Riha

P-2803 CUY-00855;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Monserrate Rios

P-2804 CUY-00672;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for D.A. Robinson

P-2805 CUY-00659;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Phillip Robinson

P-2806 CUY-00852;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Maha Saghiroon

P-2807 CUY-00830;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Galilea Sanchez

P-2808 CUY-00677;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Gerald Schultz

P-2809 CUY-00869;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Susan Scott

P-2810 CUY-00829;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Demetrius Snoddy

P-2811 CUY-00833;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Patricia Thomas

P-2812 CUY-00842;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Richard Thompson

P-2813 CUY-00871;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for James Traylor Jr.

P-2814 CUY-00860;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Darrell Turner

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 194 of 289 PAGEID #: 31373

195

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2815 CUY-00868;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Len Williams

P-2816 CUY-00858;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Jeanie Charles

P-2817 CUY-00654;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Camillia Daniels

P-2818 CUY-00661;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Willie Holloway

P-2819 CUY-00844;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Mary Lou Kuretz

P-2820 CUY-00658;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Fred Mathis

P-2821 CUY-00664;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Pearle McNeal

P-2822 CUY-00856;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Alyssa Morgan

P-2823 CUY-00673;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Marilyn Praznik

P-2824 CUY-00861;

CUY-00876

Voter packet for Yolande Simpson

P-2825 CUY-00665;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Pamela Smith

P-2826 CUY-00669;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Terry Tilbert

P-2827 CUY-00670;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Diane Taylor

P-2828 CUY-00681;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Lee Tucker

P-2829 CUY-00655;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Chrisa Wisbar

P-2830 CUY-00656;

CUY-00682

Voter packet for Gerhard Wisbar

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 195 of 289 PAGEID #: 31374

196

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2831 CUY-01025 Voter packet for Charisse Allen

P-2832 CUY-01035 Voter packet for Laura Brown

P-2833 CUY-01036 Voter packet for Joyce Burton

P-2834 CUY-01030 Voter packet for Maria Cardona

P-2835 CUY-01033 Voter packet for Velma Clark

P-2836 CUY-01038 Voter packet for Brendalyn Croom

P-2837 CUY-00712;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Leah Evans

P-2838 CUY-00714;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Marie Freeman

P-2839 CUY-00713;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Kekt Guinn

P-2840 CUY-01031 Voter packet for Robert Kiss

P-2841 CUY-00711;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Timothy Klypchak

P-2842 CUY-01032 Voter packet for Jeanney Lloyd

P-2843 CUY-01028 Voter packet for Darcell Morrissey

P-2844 CUY-00715;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Timothy Polak

P-2845 CUY-01029 Voter packet for Jason Pope

P-2846 CUY-01027 Voter packet for LaQuentis Robinson

P-2847 CUY-01034 Voter packet for Sarah Robinson

P-2848 CUY-00716;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Modestiy Settles

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 196 of 289 PAGEID #: 31375

197

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2849 CUY-00718;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for Gwendolyn Todd

P-2850 CUY-01037 Voter packet for Paul Tuttle

P-2851 CUY-01026 Voter packet for Gayle Wheeler

P-2852 CUY-00717;

CUY-00760

Voter packet for George Young

P-2853 CUY-00925;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Melanie Boeman

P-2854 CUY-00924;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Setora Brockett

P-2855 CUY-01119;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Bartham Buato

P-2856 CUY-01131;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Liliana Colage

P-2857 CUY-00926;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for James Collins

P-2858 CUY-00961;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Thomas DeSalu

P-2859 CUY-01123;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Kimberli Dixon

P-2860 CUY-00930;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Devan Evans

P-2861 CUY-00966;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Jose Frankel

P-2862 CUY-00932;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Erion Green

P-2863 CUY-00965;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Mark Haas

P-2864 CUY-00969;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Heather Haul

P-2865 CUY-00970;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Stephanie Hall

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 197 of 289 PAGEID #: 31376

198

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2866 CUY-01134;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for David Hamrick

P-2867 CUY-00931;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Dorothy Hardges-Sipp

P-2868 CUY-01127;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Bryan Hirzel

P-2869 CUY-00971;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Bryan Hirzel

P-2870 CUY-00967;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Katherine Howard

P-2871 CUY-00937;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Tommie Jerninghan

P-2872 CUY-00960;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Chase Jones

P-2873 CUY-00940;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Marcie Kershenbaum

P-2874 CUY-00927;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Gary Kral

P-2875 CUY-00941;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Marlene Kurson

P-2876 CUY-00942;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Robert Ledinsky

P-2877 CUY-00928;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Nancy Mastroianni

P-2878 CUY-00939;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Tamike McCullough

P-2879 CUY-00934;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Felisha Miller

P-2880 CUY-01116;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Ruth Miller

P-2881 CUY-00962;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Maureen Oskay

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 198 of 289 PAGEID #: 31377

199

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2882 CUY-01136;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Lynette Papushak

P-2883 CUY-00972;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Eric Perusek

P-2884 CUY-00968;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Matthew Powe

P-2885 CUY-00963;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Ethan Rice

P-2886 CUY-01110;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Lamont Riggas

P-2887 CUY-00933;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Gwendolyn Robinson

P-2888 CUY-01115;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Taja Rogers

P-2889 CUY-00929;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Providencia Roman

P-2890 CUY-00964;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Marvin Stubbs

P-2891 CUY-01135;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Sandor Szilagyi

P-2892 CUY-00973;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Evelyn Taylor

P-2893 CUY-00935;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for LeTerrian Thompkins

P-2894 CUY-00938;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Louis Turpin

P-2895 CUY-00936;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Taller Williams

P-2896 CUY-01128;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Thomas Woening

P-2897 CUY-01111;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for William Wood

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 199 of 289 PAGEID #: 31378

200

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2898 CUY-01137;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Golden Woods

P-2899 CUY-00958;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Ronald Addison

P-2900 CUY-00956;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Jeanette Ames

P-2901 CUY-00959;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Anita Atkins

P-2902 CUY-01113;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Emari Berry

P-2903 CUY-00943;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Dwyane Brentson

P-2904 CUY-01126;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Owen Brodhead

P-2905 CUY-00953;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Joanne Bronish

P-2906 CUY-01112;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for James Brown Jr.

P-2907 CUY-00947;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Danny Brunson

P-2908 CUY-00950;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Beverly Caraballo Reed

P-2909 CUY-01118;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Tracey Christopher

P-2910 CUY-00954;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Thomas Cobbs

P-2911 CUY-01107;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Marvin Cohen

P-2912 CUY-01117;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Bertha Cooks

P-2913 CUY-00951;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Arlene Duncan

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 200 of 289 PAGEID #: 31379

201

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2914 CUY-01109;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Lisa Dwyer-Short

P-2915 CUY-01132;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Eileen Fitzpatrick

P-2916 CUY-01121;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Arnold Goodgame

P-2917 CUY-01133;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Darrell Jett

P-2918 CUY-00944;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Nancy Kaminsky

P-2919 CUY-01129;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Ashley Kenner

P-2920 CUY-00955;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Andrea Lewis

P-2921 CUY-01130;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Arkita Martin

P-2922 CUY-01120;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Ann Mell

P-2923 CUY-01138;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Tiffany Mikil

P-2924 CUY-00948;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Sharon Mintee

P-2925 CUY-01122;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Christine Petty

P-2926 CUY-00952;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Sonia Plungis

P-2927 CUY-01125;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for John Rand

P-2928 CUY-01114;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Reshard Robert

P-2929 CUY-00946;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Ann Rociunas

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 201 of 289 PAGEID #: 31380

202

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2930 CUY-00949;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Kathy Stover

P-2931 CUY-00957;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Annette Thomas

P-2932 CUY-00945;

CUY-00974

Voter packet for Theresa Tucholski

P-2933 CUY-01108;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Lori Vesely

P-2934 CUY-01124;

CUY-00719

Voter packet for Michael Stokes

P-2935 CUY-00594-

CUY-00595;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Roberta Mitchell

P-2936 CUY-00389-

CUY-00390

Voter packet for James Mittelstadt

P-2937 CUY-00391-

CUY-00392

Voter packet for Wendell Napier

P-2938 CUY-00393-

CUY-00394

Voter packet for Margaret Ockuly

P-2939 CUY-00395-

CUY-00396

Voter packet for Terrence O’Connor

P-2940 CUY-00397-

CUY-00398

Voter packet for Benjamin Orengo Jr.

P-2941 CUY-00399-

CUY-00400

Voter packet for Shannon Connor Phillips

P-2942 CUY-00596-

CUY-00597;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Lawanda Prahl

P-2943 CUY-00401-

CUY-00402

Voter packet for Theresa Prather

P-2944 CUY-00403-

CUY-00404

Voter packet for Renee Primrose

P-2945 CUY-00598-

CUY-00599;

Voter packet for Eugene Proud

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 202 of 289 PAGEID #: 31381

203

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

CUY-00569

P-2946 CUY-00600-

CUY-00601;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for Trevor Quan

P-2947 CUY-00406-

CUY-00407

Voter packet for Catherine Rassie

P-2948 CUY-00408-

CUY-00409

Voter packet for Albert Reese

P-2949 CUY-00410-

CUY-00411

Voter packet for James Rettinger

P-2950 CUY-00412-

CUY-00413

Voter packet for Richard Rodgers

P-2951 CUY-00414-

CUY-00415

Voter packet for John Sanders

P-2952 CUY-00416-

CUY-00417

Voter packet for Ralph Sanderson

P-2953 CUY-00418-

CUY-00419

Voter packet for Henry Schroeder

P-2954 CUY-00420-

CUY-00421

Voter packet for Irene Schroeder

P-2955 CUY-00422-

CUY-00423

Voter packet for Jonathan Sedor

P-2956 CUY-00602-

CUY-00602;

CUY-00569

Voter packet for William Shevchuk

P-2957 CUY-00424-

CUY-00425

Voter packet for Catherine Sholtis

P-2958 CUY-00426-

CUY-00427

Voter packet for Robert Sikes Jr.

P-2959 CUY-00428-

CUY-00429

Voter packet for Kenneth Smith

P-2960 CUY-00430-

CUY-00431

Voter packet for Emily Spilka

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 203 of 289 PAGEID #: 31382

204

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2961 CUY-00432-

CUY-00433

Voter packet for Robyn Strain

P-2962 CUY-00434-

CUY-00435

Voter packet for Sandra Taylor

P-2963 CUY-00436-

CUY-00437

Voter packet for Judith Tins

P-2964 CUY-00438-

CUY-00439

Voter packet for Angel Torres

P-2965 CUY-00440-

CUY-00441

Voter packet for Rhonda Wachs

P-2966 CUY-00442-

CUY-00443

Voter packet for Cecil Washington

P-2967 CUY-00444-

CUY-00445

Voter packet for Norman Way

P-2968 CUY-00446-

CUY-00447

Voter packet for Kim Whitt

P-2969 CUY-00448-

CUY-00449

Voter packet for Ted Wegrynowski

P-2970 CUY-00450-

CUY-00451

Voter packet for Martin Wilson

P-2971 CUY-00452-

CUY-00453

Voter packet for Ronald Wolfe

P-2972 CUY-00454-

CUY-00455

Voter packet for Gary Wood

P-2973 CUY-00460-

CUY-00461

Voter packet for Carol Yurkovich

P-2974 CUY-00482-

CUY-00483

Voter packet for Madeline Blume

P-2975 CUY-00494-

CUY-00495

Voter packet for John Choban

P-2976 CUY-00496-

CUY-00497

Voter packet for James Daniels

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 204 of 289 PAGEID #: 31383

205

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2977 CUY-00508-

CUY-00509

Voter packet for Leslie Ferguson

P-2978 CUY-00528-

CUY-00529

Voter packet for Ludmila Piorkowski

P-2979 CUY-00530-

CUY-00531

Voter packet for Norris Pope

P-2980 CUY-00532-

CUY-00533

Voter packet for Loraine Stacey

P-2981 CUY-00538-

CUY-00539

Voter packet for Patricia Strumble

P-2982 CUY-00540-

CUY-00541

Voter packet for Shelly Trapp

P-2983 CUY-00542-

CUY-00543

Voter packet for Albert Tripp

P-2984 CUY-00544-

CUY-00545

Voter packet for Linda Turner

P-2985 CUY-00548-

CUY-00549

Voter packet for Jason Warden

P-2986 CUY-00472-

CUY-00473

Voter packet for Sarah Anderson

P-2987 CUY-00474-

CUY-00475

Voter packet for Joann Arki

P-2988 CUY-00476-

CUY-00477

Voter packet for Darlene Bell

P-2989 CUY-00478-

CUY-00479

Voter packet for Danielle Betliskey

P-2990 CUY-00480-

CUY-00481

Voter packet for Gloria Black

P-2991 CUY-00484-

CUY-00485

Voter packet for Ashlee Brand

P-2992 CUY-00486-

CUY-00487

Voter packet for Mia Bridgeman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 205 of 289 PAGEID #: 31384

206

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-2993 CUY-00488-

CUY-00489

Voter packet for Michael Bridgeman

P-2994 CUY-00652-

CUY-00653

Voter packet for Techawn Harris Bridgeman

P-2995 CUY-00490-

CUY-00491

Voter packet for Barbara Brinson

P-2996 CUY-00492-

CUY-00493

Voter packet for Adam Cheatwood

P-2997 CUY-00498-

CUY-00499

Voter packet for Joseph Defrancisco

P-2998 CUY-00500-

CUY-00501

Voter packet for Rita Demski

P-2999 CUY-00502-

CUY-00503

Voter packet for Donna Dolinak

P-3000 CUY-00504-

CUY-00505

Voter packet for Willie Dudley

P-3001 CUY-00506-

CUY-00507

Voter packet for Renee Evans

P-3002 CUY-00510-

CUY-00511

Voter packet for Willie Gaines

P-3003 CUY-00512-

CUY-00513

Voter packet for Florida Henderson

P-3004 CUY-00514-

CUY-00515

Voter packet for Stanley Hubbard

P-3005 CUY-00516-

CUY-00517

Voter packet for Elaine Jackson

P-3006 CUY-00618-

CUY-00619;

CUY-00617

Voter packet for William Kufahl

P-3007 CUY-00518-

CUY-00519

Voter packet for Melissa Lastoria

P-3008 CUY-00520-

CUY-00521

Voter packet for Virginia Martin

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 206 of 289 PAGEID #: 31385

207

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3009 CUY-00522-

CUY-00523

Voter packet for Thomas Minadeo

P-3010 CUY-00524-

CUY-00525

Voter packet for Vera Payne

P-3011 CUY-00526-

CUY-00527

Voter packet for Regina Peffer

P-3012 CUY-00620-

CUY-00621;

CUY-00617

Voter packet for Bernard Puhalik

P-3013 CUY-00622-

CUY-00623;

CUY-00617

Voter packet for Edgar Reed

P-3014 CUY-00624-

CUY-00625;

CUY-00617

Voter packet for Marianne Siefert

P-3015 CUY-00534-

CUY-00535

Voter packet for Alice Starnik

P-3016 CUY-00536-

CUY-00537

Voter packet for Gina Stills

P-3017 CUY-00546-

CUY-00547

Voter packet for Donald Uffman

P-3018 CUY-00550-

CUY-00551

Voter packet for Dennis Ware

P-3019 CUY-00552-

CUY-00553

Voter packet for Josephine Wegrzynowski

P-3020 CUY-00554-

CUY-00555

Voter packet for Carol Winfield

P-3021 CUY-00556-

CUY-00557

Voter packet for Bernard Williams

P-3022 CUY-00558-

CUY-00559

Voter packet for Vera Williams

P-3023 CUY-00560-

CUY-00561

Voter packet for Elizabeth Wojtyszyn

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 207 of 289 PAGEID #: 31386

208

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3024 CUY-00562-

CUY-00563

Voter packet for Betty Zeiger

P-3025 CUY-00607-

CUY-00608;

CUY-00604

Voter packet for James Carr

P-3026 CUY-00611-

CUY-00612;

CUY-00604

Voter packet for Ruby McPherson

P-3027 3/8/16 CUY-01143-

CUY-01144

8H Provisional Reasons and Flags Summary

P-3028 FRA-03746;

FRA-03745;

FRA-02624

Voter packet for Phyllis Davy

P-3029 FRA-03892;

FRA-03891;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Susan Day

P-3030 FRA-03568;

FRA-03567;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Kim Decker

P-3031 FRA-03867;

FRA-03866;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Patrice Dellaflora

P-3032 FRA-03916;

FRA-03915;

FRA-02689

Voter packet for Marilu Delozter

P-3033 FRA-03729;

FRA-03728;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Mariann DeSantis

P-3034 FRA-03522;

FRA-03521;

FRA-02670

Voter packet for Henry DeVictor

P-3035 FRA-03694;

FRA-03693;

FRA-02703

Voter packet for Lowell Dildine

P-3036 FRA-03771;

FRA-03770;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Kathleen Dillon

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 208 of 289 PAGEID #: 31387

209

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3037 FRA-03959;

FRA-03958;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Deborah Dodge

P-3038 FRA-03926;

FRA-03925;

FRA-02681

Voter packet for Richard Draudt

P-3039 FRA-03987;

FRA-03986;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Marc Dutro

P-3040 FRA-03712;

FRA-03711;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Richard Ellis Sr.

P-3041 FRA-03587;

FRA-03586;

FRA-02637

Voter packet for Moamen Elsheikh

P-3042 FRA-03763;

FRA-03762;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Judith Evans

P-3043 FRA-03530;

FRA-03529;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Martin Evans Sr.

P-3044 FRA-03821;

FRA-03820;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Thomasine Evans

P-3045 FRA-03675;

FRA-03674;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for William Evans

P-3046 FRA-03655;

FRA-03654;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Tiileida Faryman

P-3047 FRA-03612;

FRA-03611;

FRA-02695

Voter packet for Kristina Fedeczko

P-3048 FRA-03755;

FRA-03754;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for John Federer

P-3049 FRA-03459;

FRA-03458;

Voter packet for Helen Fijalkowski

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 209 of 289 PAGEID #: 31388

210

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02666

P-3050 FRA-03924;

FRA-02707

Voter packet for Julie Fitch

P-3051 FRA-03704;

FRA-03703;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Thomas Fitzpatrick

P-3052 FRA-03614;

FRA-03613;

FRA-02700

Voter packet for Conseulea Floyd

P-3053 FRA-03861;

FRA-03860;

FRA-02624

Voter packet for Miriam Forquer

P-3054 FRA-03983;

FRA-03982;

FRA-02662

Voter packet for Carleen Foss

P-3055 FRA-03610;

FRA-03609;

FRA-02671

Voter packet for Randall Foster

P-3056 FRA-03936;

FRA-03935;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Scott Fothergill

P-3057 FRA-03888;

FRA-03887;

FRA-03886;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Catherine Frederick

P-3058 FRA-03823;

FRA-03822;

FRA-02703

Voter packet for William Freter Jr.

P-3059 FRA-03641;

FRA-03640;

FRA-02652

Voter packet for Shirley Frost

P-3060 FRA-03425;

FRA-03424;

FRA-02646

Voter packet for Virginia Fulcomer

P-3061 FRA-03564;

FRA-03563;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Kimberly Fyffe

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 210 of 289 PAGEID #: 31389

211

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3062 FRA-03873;

FRA-03872;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Armando Gastaldo

P-3063 FRA-03795;

FRA-03794;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for Roosevelt Gilbert

P-3064 FRA-03753;

FRA-03752;

FRA-02626

Voter packet for James Gillilan

P-3065 FRA-03598;

FRA-03597;

FRA-02674

Voter packet for Erin Glasser

P-3066 FRA-03560;

FRA-03559;

FRA-02678

Voter packet for Karen Glidewell

P-3067 FRA-03944;

FRA-03943;

FRA-02694

Voter packet for Cesar Gonzalez

P-3068 FRA-03912;

FRA-03911;

FRA-02670

Voter packet for Leonard Goss Jr.

P-3069 FRA-03961;

FRA-03960;

FRA-02672

Voter packet for Ruth Green

P-3070 FRA-03618;

FRA-03617;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for William Harp

P-3071 FRA-03901;

FRA-03900;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Cheryl Harvey

P-3072 FRA-03690;

FRA-03689;

FRA-02662

Voter packet for Jerry Harvey

P-3073 FRA-03692;

FRA-03691;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Sandra Harvey

P-3074 FRA-03622;

FRA-03621;

Voter packet for Shine Hawramani

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 211 of 289 PAGEID #: 31390

212

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02678

P-3075 FRA-03859;

FRA-03858;

FRA-02670

Voter packet for Nancy Hellickson

P-3076 FRA-03463;

FRA-03462;

FRA-02637

Voter packet for Michael Higgins

P-3077 FRA-03920;

FRA-03919;

FRA-02700

Voter packet for Barbara Hilmoe

P-3078 FRA-03928;

FRA-03927;

FRA-02635

Voter packet for Pamela Hoehner

P-3079 FRA-03669;

FRA-03668;

FRA-02631

Voter packet for Lawrence Hoffman

P-3080 FRA-03829;

FRA-03828;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Linda Huckleby

P-3081 FRA-03708;

FRA-03707;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Robert Hughes

P-3082 FRA-03495;

FRA-03494;

FRA-02711

Voter packet for Patrick Hupp

P-3083 FRA-03510;

FRA-03509;

FRA-03508

FRA-02713

Voter packet for Cortney Ingram

P-3084 FRA-03594;

FRA-03593;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Linda Jacob

P-3085 FRA-03671;

FRA-03670;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Shirley Jamar

P-3086 FRA-03481;

FRA-03480;

FRA-02659

Voter packet for Margaret Jasper

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 212 of 289 PAGEID #: 31391

213

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3087 FRA-03562;

FRA-03561;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Cecilia Felix

P-3088 FRA-03440;

FRA-03439;

FRA-02637

Voter packet for Elena Johnson

P-3089 FRA-03663;

FRA-03662;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Angela Jones

P-3090 FRA-03777;

FRA-03776;

FRA-02625

Voter packet for Brion Jones

P-3091 FRA-03444;

FRA-03443;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for Janet Jones

P-3092 FRA-03461;

FRA-03460;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Julian Justice

P-3093 FRA-03477;

FRA-03476;

FRA-02694

Voter packet for Lisa Kaufman

P-3094 FRA-03963;

FRA-03962;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Kay Kilgore

P-3095 FRA-03596;

FRA-03595;

FRA-02672

Voter packet for Daniel Kirk

P-3096 FRA-03910;

FRA-03909;

FRA-02708

Voter packet for Kaye Kirk

P-3097 FRA-03877;

FRA-03876;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for Julie Kohrmann

P-3098 FRA-03631;

FRA-03630;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Amy Koogler

P-3099 FRA-03686;

FRA-03685;

Voter packet for Pauline Koontz

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 213 of 289 PAGEID #: 31392

214

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02639

P-3100 FRA-03471;

FRA-03470;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Jacquelyn Kreisel

P-3101 FRA-03798;

FRA-03797;

FRA-003796

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Cassundra Lacey-Lowery

P-3102 FRA-03635;

FRA-03634;

FRA-02628-FRA-02629

Voter packet for Linda Lahm

P-3103 FRA-03895;

FRA-03894;

FRA-03893

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Helen Lang

P-3104 FRA-03946;

FRA-03945;

FRA-02624

Voter packet for Monique Lanier

P-3105 FRA-03971;

FRA-03970;

FRA-02699

Voter packet for Fernanad Laperle

P-3106 FRA-03574;

FRA-03573;

FRA-02661

Voter packet for Darryl Lee

P-3107 FRA-03493;

FRA-03492;

FRA-02645

Voter packet for Deborah Lee

P-3108 FRA-03742;

FRA-03741;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Dorothy Leibrock

P-3109 FRA-03744;

FRA-03743;

FRA-02699

Voter packet for William Leibrock

P-3110 FRA-03955;

FRA-03954;

FRA-02703

Voter packet for Warren Leimbach II

P-3111 FRA-03835;

FRA-03834;

Voter packet for Debra Lindgren

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 214 of 289 PAGEID #: 31393

215

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02624

P-3112 FRA-03677;

FRA-03676;

FRA-02642

Voter packet for Mitchell Litwak

P-3113 FRA-03590;

FRA-03589;

FRA-02665

Voter packet for Michelle Loveless

P-3114 FRA-03850;

FRA-03849;

FRA-02643;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for Margaret Lowery

P-3115 FRA-03661;

FRA-03660;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for John Mack

P-3116 FRA-03578;

FRA-03577;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Carl Mackey Jr.

P-3117 FRA-03837;

FRA-03836;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for John Martin

P-3118 FRA-03702;

FRA-03701;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Linda Martin

P-3119 FRA-03761;

FRA-03760;

FRA-02637

Voter packet for Ervin Mathews

P-3120 FRA-03757;

FRA-03756;

FRA-02673

Voter packet for Cherylene Matthews

P-3121 FRA-03993;

FRA-03992;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Michael Marx

P-3122 FRA-03616;

FRA-03615;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Donald McAteer

P-3123 FRA-03890;

FRA-03889;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Steven McChesney

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 215 of 289 PAGEID #: 31394

216

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3124 FRA-03918;

FRA-03917;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Steven McMillan

P-3125 FRA-03576;

FRA-03575;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Heather Meade

P-3126 FRA-03773;

FRA-03772;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for Jack Meizlish

P-3127 FRA-03735;

FRA-03734;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for William Merriman

P-3128 FRA-03995;

FRA-03994;

FRA-02642

Voter packet for Maureen Metcalf

P-3129 FRA-03840;

FRA-03839;

FRA-02697

Voter packet for Richard Middendorf

P-3130 FRA-03908;

FRA-03907;

FRA-02639

Voter packet for Laverne Miles

P-3131 FRA-03643;

FRA-03642;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Donald Miller

P-3132 FRA-03538;

FRA-03537;

FRA-02683

Voter packet for Eric Miller

P-3133 FRA-03767;

FRA-03766;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Sandra Miller

P-3134 FRA-03570;

FRA-03569;

FRA-02702

Voter packet for Elaine Millersberg

P-3135 FRA-03518;

FRA-03517;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Doris Moodispaugh

P-3136 FRA-03620;

FRA-03619;

Voter packet for James Moreland

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 216 of 289 PAGEID #: 31395

217

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02685

P-3137 FRA-03819;

FRA-03818;

FRA-03817

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Helena Morgan

P-3138 FRA-03679;

FRA-03678;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Dolores Morris

P-3139 FRA-03922;

FRA-03921;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Lisa Mueller

P-3140 FRA-04001;

FRA-04000;

FRA-02699

Voter packet for Leslie Muhammad

P-3141 FRA-03657;

FRA-03656;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Ronald Murphy

P-3142 FRA-03540;

FRA-03539;

FRA-02711

Voter packet for Darrin Nedrow

P-3143 FRA-03580;

FRA-03579;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Artie Nesbitt

P-3144 FRA-03932;

FRA-03931;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Kelly Niekamp

P-3145 FRA-03649;

FRA-03648;

FRA-02642

Voter packet for Eugene Olsen

P-3146 FRA-03715;

FRA-03714;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for James O’Neil Jr.

P-3147 FRA-03979;

FRA-03978;

FRA-02707

Voter packet for Ronnie Orick II

P-3148 FRA-03975;

FRA-03974;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Jeffrey Ortega

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 217 of 289 PAGEID #: 31396

218

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3149 FRA-03827;

FRA-03826;

FRA-02673

Voter packet for Dennis Palmer

P-3150 FRA-03965;

FRA-03964;

FRA-02629

Voter packet for Thomas Parker Jr.

P-3151 FRA-03844;

FRA-03843;

FRA-02635

Voter packet for LaMorris Payne

P-3152 FRA-03769;

FRA-03768;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Robert Perlman

P-3153 FRA-03930;

FRA-03929;

FRA-02674

Voter packet for Perpetua Perumal

P-3154 FRA-03810;

FRA-03809;

FRA-02674

Voter packet for Kenneth Peterson

P-3155 FRA-03914;

FRA-03913;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Ruth Peterson

P-3156 FRA-03999;

FRA-03998;

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Dan Pettit

P-3157 FRA-03552;

FRA-03551;

FRA-02626

Voter packet for Aaron Piatt

P-3158 FRA-03759;

FRA-03758;

FRA-02711

Voter packet for John Pierce

P-3159 FRA-03785;

FRA-03784;

FRA-02641

Voter packet for Milton Pollard

P-3160 FRA-03710;

FRA-03709;

FRA-02646

Voter packet for Anthony Poole

P-3161 FRA-03673;

FRA-03672;

Voter packet for Betty Powell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 218 of 289 PAGEID #: 31397

219

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02693

P-3162 FRA-03606;

FRA-03605;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Bruce Powell

P-3163 FRA-03520;

FRA-03519;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for Edward Powell II

P-3164 FRA-03542;

FRA-03541;

FRA-02679

Voter packet for Richard Powell

P-3165 FRA-03825;

FRA-03824;

FRA-02631

Voter packet for Lonnie Preece

P-3166 FRA-03659;

FRA-03658;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Ryan Ramos

P-3167 FRA-03787;

FRA-03786;

FRA-02710

Voter packet for Cathy Rapenport

P-3168 FRA-03957;

FRA-03956;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Barbara Redman

P-3169 FRA-03512;

FRA-03511;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Amanda Roberts

P-3170 FRA-03604;

FRA-03603;

FRA-02630

Voter packet for Chad Rose

P-3171 FRA-03857;

FRA-03856;

FRA-02681

Voter packet for Jan Ross

P-3172 FRA-03800;

FRA-03799;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Cheryl Rowe

P-3173 FRA-03733;

FRA-03732;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Johnny Royal

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 219 of 289 PAGEID #: 31398

220

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3174 FRA-03808;

FRA-03807;

FRA-02673

Voter packet for Thomas Ryan Jr.

P-3175 FRA-03503;

FRA-03502;

FRA-02712

Voter packet for Ashok Sanadi

P-3176 FRA-03651;

FRA-03650;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Martha Sargent

P-3177 FRA-03534;

FRA-03533;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for Seth Sayre

P-3178 FRA-03737;

FRA-03736;

FRA-03738;

FRA-02665

Voter packet for Betty Scott

P-3179 FRA-03550;

FRA-03549;

FRA-02695

Voter packet for James Scott

P-3180 FRA-03696;

FRA-03695;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for John Sebring Sr.

P-3181 FRA-03467;

FRA-03466;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Carrie Sevin

P-3182 FRA-03783;

FRA-03782;

FRA-02702

Voter packet for Mary Jane Shafer

P-3183 FRA-03981;

FRA-03980;

FRA-02697

Voter packet for Prema Shankar

P-3184 FRA-03991;

FRA-03990;

FRA-02696

Voter packet for Jeffrey Sheets

P-3185 FRA-03427;

FRA-03426;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for Deborah Shipman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 220 of 289 PAGEID #: 31399

221

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3186 FRA-03507

FRA-03506;

FRA-02626

Voter packet for Janet Shirk

P-3187 FRA-03554;

FRA-03553;

FRA-02630

Voter packet for Lowell Shope

P-3188 FRA-03456;

FRA-03455;

FRA-03457;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Jonna Sibole

P-3189 FRA-03804;

FRA-03803;

FRA-02649

Voter packet for Alannah Siersema

P-3190 FRA-03706;

FRA-03705;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for David Sims

P-3191 FRA-03627;

FRA-03626;

FRA-03457;

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Swati Singhal

P-3192 FRA-03473;

FRA-03472;

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Vipul Singhal

P-3193 FRA-03516;

FRA-03515;

FRA-02668

Voter packet for Husein Sitabkhan

P-3194 FRA-03514;

FRA-03513;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Samina Sitabkhan

P-3195 FRA-03489;

FRA-03488;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Zarina Sitabkhan

P-3196 FRA-03885;

FRA-03884;

FRA-02713

Voter packet for Craig Smith

P-3197 FRA-03639;

FRA-03638;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Jadarious Smith

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 221 of 289 PAGEID #: 31400

222

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3198 FRA-03806;

FRA-03805;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Jennifer Smith

P-3199 FRA-03700;

FRA-03699;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Lillie Smith

P-3200 FRA-03802;

FRA-03801;

FRA-02664

Voter packet for Sharon Smith

P-3201 FRA-03536;

FRA-03635;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Sara Snavley

P-3202 FRA-03497;

FRA-03496;

FRA-02679

Voter packet for Stacy Sohner

P-3203 FRA-03969;

FRA-03968;

FRA-02642

Voter packet for Joseph Stapleton

P-3204 FRA-03446;

FRA-03445;

FRA-02632

Voter packet for Mecca Stewart

P-3205 FRA-03833;

FRA-03832;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Frank Stopps

P-3206 FRA-03475;

FRA-03474;

FRA-02624

Voter packet for Melinda Strickler

P-3207 FRA-03434;

FRA-03433;

FRA-02689

Voter packet for Kathleen Supelak

P-3208 FRA-03592;

FRA-03591;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Brent Swander

P-3209 FRA-03566;

FRA-03565;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Matthew Sylvester

P-3210 FRA-03881;

FRA-03880;

Voter packet for Barbara Thomas

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 222 of 289 PAGEID #: 31401

223

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02666

P-3211 FRA-03985;

FRA-03984;

FRA-02649

Voter packet for Phyllis Thomas

P-3212 FRA-03633;

FRA-03632;

FRA-02699

Voter packet for Tim Traber

P-3213 FRA-03953;

FRA-03952;

FRA-02714

Voter packet for Melanie Tullett

P-3214 FRA-03647;

FRA-03646;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Kyle Turner

P-3215 FRA-03653;

FRA-03652;

FRA-02672

Voter packet for Paul Warth

P-3216 FRA-03584;

FRA-03583;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Robert Watson

P-3217 FRA-03698;

FRA-03697;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Ora Westmoreland

P-3218 FRA-03442;

FRA-03441;

FRA-02629

Voter packet for Lewis Wheeler

P-3219 FRA-03775;

FRA-03774;

FRA-02712

Voter packet for Brenda White

P-3220 FRA-03879;

FRA-03878;

FRA-02706

Voter packet for Carl White

P-3221 FRA-03831;

FRA-03830;

FRA-02652

Voter packet for Ruth White

P-3222 FRA-03719;

FRA-03718;

FRA-02651

Voter packet for Wesley White

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 223 of 289 PAGEID #: 31402

224

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3223 FRA-03846;

FRA-03845;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Kenneth Wilkerson

P-3224 FRA-03499;

FRA-03498;

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Derrell Williams

P-3225 FRA-03505;

FRA-03504;

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Nina Wilson

P-3226 FRA-03997;

FRA-03996;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Beatrice Witt

P-3227 FRA-03548;

FRA-03547;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Edgar Wolfram

P-3228 FRA-03934;

FRA-03933;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Kia Woodward

P-3229 FRA-03491;

FRA-03490;

FRA-02662

Voter packet for Sylvia Wright

P-3230 FRA-03452;

FRA-03451;

FRA-02710

Voter packet for Kellie Wurtzman

P-3231 FRA-03556;

FRA-03555;

FRA-02684-

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Sinead Yarberry

P-3232 FRA-03723;

FRA-03722;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for John Zuccaro

P-3233 FRA-04703;

FRA-04702;

FRA-02725

Voter packet for Deborah Abner

P-3234 FRA-04479;

FRA-04478;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Martha Albee

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 224 of 289 PAGEID #: 31403

225

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3235 FRA-04198;

FRA-04197;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Charmaign Albright

P-3236 FRA-04196;

FRA-04195;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Helen Andreas

P-3237 FRA-04372;

FRA-04371;

FRA-02701

Voter packet for Suzanne Armitage-Olson

P-3238 FRA-04405;

FRA-04404;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Richard Austin

P-3239 FRA-04680;

FRA-04679;

FRA-02752

Voter packet for Mary Baker

P-3240 FRA-04281;

FRA-04280;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Chiquita Ballard

P-3241 FRA-04407;

FRA-04406;

FRA-02693

Voter packet for Dione Balzano

P-3242 FRA-04628;

FRA-04627;

FRA-02753

Voter packet for Richard Baus II

P-3243 FRA-04238;

FRA-04237;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for Marcella Bickerton

P-3244 FRA-04376;

FRA-04375;

FRA-02687

Voter packet for Gail Brown

P-3245 FRA-04475;

FRA-04474;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Allison Burns

P-3246 FRA-04205;

FRA-04204;

FRA-02693

Voter packet for Kelly Campbell

P-3247 FRA-04459;

FRA-04458;

Voter packet for Saverio Capuano Jr.

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 225 of 289 PAGEID #: 31404

226

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02689

P-3248 FRA-04540;

FRA-04539;

FRA-02719

Voter packet for Jeanette Chandler

P-3249 FRA-04695;

FRA-04694;

FRA-02741

Voter packet for Richard Cheski

P-3250 FRA-04350;

FRA-04349;

FRA-02700

Voter packet for Jerold Clark

P-3251 FRA-04300;

FRA-04299;

FRA-02649

Voter packet for Molly Colyer

P-3252 FRA-04421;

FRA-04420;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for David Cook

P-3253 FRA-04251;

FRA-04250;

FRA-02690

Voter packet for Tiffany Cornett

P-3254 FRA-04358;

FRA-04357;

FRA-02659

Voter packet for Katherine Dehne

P-3255 FRA-03532;

FRA-03531;

FRA-02716

Voter packet for Mary Dennis

P-3256 FRA-04269;

FRA-04268;

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Hazel Diles

P-3257 FRA-04570;

FRA-04569;

FRA-02731

Voter packet for Barbara Diponio

P-3258 FRA-04588;

FRA-04587;

FRA-02764

Voter packet for Lewis Dixon

P-3259 FRA-04427;

FRA-04426;

FRA-02713

Voter packet for James Early

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 226 of 289 PAGEID #: 31405

227

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3260 FRA-04592;

FRA-04591;

FRA-02749

Voter packet for Betty Emmel

P-3261 FRA-04465;

FRA-04464;

FRA-02709

Voter packet for Jeffrey Erickson

P-3262 FRA-04620;

FRA-04619;

FRA-02745

Voter packet for Dollie Fiedler

P-3263 FRA-04664;

FRA-04663;

FRA-02755

Voter packet for Margery Finkle

P-3264 FRA-04273;

FRA-04272;

FRA-02690

Voter packet for Dolores Finnerty

P-3265 FRA-04674;

FRA-04673;

FRA-02746

Voter packet for Roman Gerber

P-3266 FRA-04730;

FRA-04729;

FRA-02753

Voter packet for Mike Gladfelter

P-3267 FRA-04666;

FRA-04665;

FRA-02734

Voter packet for Anna Glenn

P-3268 FRA-04602;

FRA-04601;

FRA-02721

Voter packet for David Groves

P-3269 FRA-04453;

FRA-04452;

FRA-02675

Voter packet for Rebecca Guinsler

P-3270 FRA-04467;

FRA-04466;

FRA-02641

Voter packet for Deborah Harding

P-3271 FRA-04491;

FRA-04490;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Keith Harris

P-3272 FRA-04678;

FRA-04677;

Voter packet for Paula Haydocy

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 227 of 289 PAGEID #: 31406

228

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02730

P-3273 FRA-04288;

FRA-04287;

FRA-02689

Voter packet for Tyler Herron

P-3274 FRA-04339;

FRA-04338;

FRA-02690

Voter packet for Laura Heumann

P-3275 FRA-04249;

FRA-04248;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Elizabeth Hillman

P-3276 FRA-04296;

FRA-04295;

FRA-02703

Voter packet for Sharon Hoard

P-3277 FRA-04670;

FRA-04669;

FRA-02763

Voter packet for Shirley Hummel

P-3278 FRA-04292;

FRA-04291;

FRA-02712

Voter packet for Natasha Hunchak

P-3279 FRA-04320;

FRA-04319;

FRA-02707

Voter packet for Marian Huston

P-3280 FRA-04652;

FRA-04651;

FRA-02729

Voter packet for Richard Hutchinson

P-3281 FRA-04544;

FRA-04543;

FRA-02746

Voter packet for Amy Infante

P-3282 FRA-04734;

FRA-04733;

FRA-02723

Voter packet for Christine Irvin

P-3283 FRA-04656;

FRA-04655;

FRA-02729

Voter packet for Olivia Jackson

P-3284 FRA-04386;

FRA-04385;

FRA-02663

Voter packet for Beverly Johnson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 228 of 289 PAGEID #: 31407

229

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3285 FRA-04668;

FRA-04667;

FRA-02740

Voter packet for Helen Johnson

P-3286 FRA-04676;

FRA-04675;

FRA-02729

Voter packet for Karen Kelly

P-3287 FRA-04556;

FRA-04555;

FRA-02764

Voter packet for Preston Lassiter III

P-3288 FRA-04600;

FRA-04599;

FRA-02721

Voter packet for Julie Ludwig

P-3289 FRA-04711;

FRA-04710;

FRA-02746

Voter packet for Marjorie Lyden

P-3290 FRA-04483;

FRA-04482;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Leroy Maxwell

P-3291 FRA-04337;

FRA-04336;

FRA-02683

Voter packet for Bernadine McCorkle

P-3292 FRA-04333;

FRA-04332;

FRA-02671

Voter packet for Rita McQuade

P-3293 FRA-04378;

FRA-04377;

FRA-02688

Voter packet for Patricia Merriman

P-3294 FRA-04245;

FRA-04244;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Carol Michels

P-3295 FRA-04283;

FRA-04282;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for Kevin Miles

P-3296 FRA-04586;

FRA-04585;

FRA-02731

Voter packet for Sally Miller

P-3297 FRA-04310;

FRA-04309;

Voter packet for Andre Mobley

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 229 of 289 PAGEID #: 31408

230

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02686

P-3298 FRA-04477;

FRA-04476;

FRA-02629

Voter packet for Helen Moriarty

P-3299 FRA-04403;

FRA-04402;

FRA-02692

Voter packet for Leslie Moss

P-3300 FRA-04356;

FRA-04355;

FRA-02634

Voter packet for Patricia Myers

P-3301 FRA-04473;

FRA-04472;

FRA-02671

Voter packet for Kevin Nickerson

P-3302 FRA-04368;

FRA-04367;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Melody Pullen

P-3303 FRA-04263;

FRA-04262;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Charles Radford III

P-3304 FRA-04243;

FRA-04242;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for Nancy Rojas

P-3305 FRA-04715;

FRA-04714;

FRA-02758

Voter packet for Bernice Rorie

P-3306 FRA-04642;

FRA-04641;

FRA-02726

Voter packet for James Sands

P-3307 FRA-04388;

FRA-04387;

FRA-02678

Voter packet for Karen Schott

P-3308 FRA-04366;

FRA-04365;

FRA-02684

Voter packet for Elizabeth Sidner

P-3309 FRA-04487;

FRA-04486;

FRA-02641

Voter packet for Gerald Smith

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 230 of 289 PAGEID #: 31409

231

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3310 FRA-04622;

FRA-04621;

FRA-02737

Voter packet for Helen Smith

P-3311 FRA-04312;

FRA-04311;

FRA-02683

Voter packet for Linda Smith

P-3312 FRA-04271;

FRA-04270;

FRA-02660

Voter packet for Letha Sparks

P-3313 FRA-04489;

FRA-04488;

FRA-02707

Voter packet for Cindy Spurrell

P-3314 FRA-04302;

FRA-04301;

FRA-02679

Voter packet for Victor Thompson

P-3315 FRA-04380;

FRA-04379;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Janice Ulry

P-3316 FRA-04558;

FRA-04557;

FRA-02759

Voter packet for Joyce Walton

P-3317 FRA-04267;

FRA-04266;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for William Weiler

P-3318 FRA-04322;

FRA-04321;

FRA-02644

Voter packet for Jean Weimer

P-3319 FRA-04634;

FRA-04633;

FRA-02749

Voter packet for Barbara Williamson

P-3320 FRA-04598;

FRA-04597;

FRA-02740

Voter packet for Deborah Wilson

P-3321 FRA-04395;

FRA-04394;

FRA-02652

Voter packet for Regina Wolfel

P-3322 FRA-04399;

FRA-04398;

Voter packet for Jack Wolock

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 231 of 289 PAGEID #: 31410

232

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02673

P-3323 FRA-04227;

FRA-04226;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Abulkasham Yousuf

P-3324 FRA-04393;

FRA-04392;

FRA-02654

Voter packet for Deborah Zak

P-3325 FRA-04717;

FRA-04716;

FRA-02731

Voter packet for Josephine Adams

P-3326 FRA-04259;

FRA-04258;

FRA-02704-

FRA-02705

Voter packet for Sajid Ali

P-3327 FRA-04463;

FRA-04462;

FRA-02680

Voter packet for Terry Allison

P-3328 FRA-04294;

FRA-04293;

FRA-02678

Voter packet for Lauren Augostini

P-3329 FRA-04461;

FRA-04460;

FRA-02652

Voter packet for Merle Ayers

P-3330 FRA-04546;

FRA-04645;

FRA-02724

Voter packet for Jarrod Beard

P-3331 FRA-04207;

FRA-04206;

FRA-02636

Voter packet for David Beasley

P-3332 FRA-04447;

FRA-04446;

FRA-02697

Voter packet for Karen Bendig

P-3333 FRA-04443;

FRA-04442;

FRA-02685

Voter packet for Christie Blackstone

P-3334 FRA-04709;

FRA-04708;

FRA-02737

Voter packet for Jacob Brewer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 232 of 289 PAGEID #: 31411

233

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3335 FRA-04200;

FRA-04199;

FRA-04201

FRA-02642

Voter packet for Gloria Broomfield

P-3336 FRA-04610;

FRA-04609;

FRA-02746

Voter packet for Waverly Buford

P-3337 FRA-04212;

FRA-04211;

FRA-02679

Voter packet for Stella Burke

P-3338 FRA-04331;

FRA-04330;

FRA-02654

Voter packet for Rhonda Burton

P-3339 FRA-04701;

FRA-04700;

FRA-02751

Voter packet for Aaron Carroll

P-3340 FRA-04215;

FRA-04213;

FRA-04214

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Mary Chakeres

P-3341 FRA-04229;

FRA-04228;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for Meshawn Chatman

P-3342 FRA-04415;

FRA-04414;

FRA-02683

Voter packet for Christopher Cooper

P-3343 FRA-04219;

FRA-04218;

FRA-02632

Voter packet for Obie Corbin

P-3344 FRA-04630;

FRA-04629;

FRA-02766

Voter packet for Louie Cox

P-3345 FRA-04582;

FRA-04581;

FRA-02765

Voter packet for Chesley Craig

P-3346 FRA-04457;

FRA-04456;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Tom Deckard

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 233 of 289 PAGEID #: 31412

234

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3347 FRA-03682;

FRA-03681;

Voter packet for Cheryl Davis

P-3348 FRA-03684;

FRA-03683;

Voter packet for Hugh Davis II

P-3349 FRA-04290;

FRA-04289;

FRA-02687

Voter packet for Kerri Doyaga

P-3350 FRA-04419;

FRA-04418;

FRA-02708

Voter packet for Mark Dye

P-3351 FRA-04326;

FRA-04325;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Glory Fair

P-3352 FRA-04624;

FRA-04623;

FRA-02740

Voter packet for Delores Fayson

P-3353 FRA-04308;

FRA-04307;

FRA-02696

Voter packet for Mandy Feldbauer

P-3354 FRA-04277;

FRA-04276;

FRA-02625

Voter packet for Phyllis Felice

P-3355 FRA-04234;

FRA-04232;

FRA-04233

FRA-02681

Voter packet for Beverly Flaig

P-3356 FRA-04374;

FRA-04373;

FRA-02695

Voter packet for David Flowers

P-3357 FRA-04223;

FRA-04222;

FRA-02687

Voter packet for Robert Garman II

P-3358 FRA-04247;

FRA-04246;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Charlene Gilmore

P-3359 FRA-04342;

FRA-04341;

Voter packet for Peggy Groves

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 234 of 289 PAGEID #: 31413

235

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02680

P-3360 FRA-04562;

FRA-04561;

FRA-02766

Voter packet for Jason Hairston

P-3361 FRA-04437;

FRA-04436;

FRA-02640

Voter packet for Robert Hanley

P-3362 FRA-04449;

FRA-04448;

FRA-02668

Voter packet for Cheryl Harrison Sides

P-3363 FRA-04390;

FRA-04389;

FRA-00391

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Nellie Heard

P-3364 FRA-04364;

FRA-04363;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Nancy Highfield

P-3365 FRA-04324;

FRA-04323;

FRA-02645

Voter packet for Bobby Hill

P-3366 FRA-04354;

FRA-04353;

FRA-02626

Voter packet for Mary Holman

P-3367 FRA-04314;

FRA-04313;

FRA-02663

Voter packet for Toni Ingram

P-3368 FRA-04261;

FRA-04260;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for Sarah Jeffries

P-3369 FRA-04590;

FRA-04589;

FRA-02742

Voter packet for Ellen Johnson

P-3370 FRA-04471;

FRA-04470;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Leah Johnson

P-3371 FRA-04560;

FRA-04559;

FRA-02730

Voter packet for Tamika Johnson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 235 of 289 PAGEID #: 31414

236

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3372 FRA-04650;

FRA-04649;

FRA-02755

Voter packet for Elouise Jones

P-3373 FRA-04541-

FRA-04542;

FRA-02766

Voter packet for Melissa Jones

P-3374 FRA-04257;

FRA-04256;

FRA-02637

Voter packet for Marissa Kabbaz

P-3375 FRA-04433;

FRA-04432;

FRA-02693

Voter packet for Brenda Kersten

P-3376 FRA-04362;

FRA-04361;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Gene Killilea

P-3377 FRA-04455;

FRA-04454;

FRA-02660

Voter packet for Carrie Kinderman

P-3378 FRA-04742;

FRA-04741;

FRA-02741

Voter packet for Jeffrey Klein

P-3379 FRA-04705;

FRA-04704;

FRA-02737

Voter packet for Charles Loomis

P-3380 FRA-04397;

FRA-04396;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for Henry Lupo

P-3381 FRA-04417;

FRA-04416;

FRA-02676

Voter packet for Chester Markham

P-3382 FRA-04318;

FRA-04317;

FRA-02711

Voter packet for Theresa Martin

P-3383 FRA-04316;

FRA-04315;

FRA-02686

Voter packet for Barbara McClure

P-3384 FRA-04203;

FRA-04202;

Voter packet for Cicely McElroy

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 236 of 289 PAGEID #: 31415

237

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02678

P-3385 FRA-04285;

FRA-04284;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Kirk McVay

P-3386 FRA-04236;

FRA-04235;

FRA-02671

Voter packet for Shalonda Mercedes

P-3387 FRA-04550;

FRA-04549;

FRA-02728

Voter packet for Michael Moeller

P-3388 FRA-04298;

FRA-04297;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for Ondrae Moore

P-3389 FRA-04636;

FRA-04635;

FRA-02751

Voter packet for Howard Morris Jr.

P-3390 FRA-04612;

FRA-04611;

FRA-02724

Voter packet for Ola Morrison

P-3391 FRA-04401;

FRA-04400;

FRA-02646

Voter packet for C. Laurance Nichols

P-3392 FRA-04209;

FRA-04208;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Delonyia Oliver

P-3393 FRA-04451;

FRA-04450;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Steve Orange

P-3394 FRA-04382;

FRA-04381;

FRA-02690

Voter packet for Harold Oyster

P-3395 FRA-04429;

FRA-04428;

FRA-02677

Voter packet for Diana Patrick

P-3396 FRA-04328;

FRA-04327;

FRA-02715

Voter packet for Dolores Payne

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 237 of 289 PAGEID #: 31416

238

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3397 FRA-04384;

FRA-04383;

FRA-02654

Voter packet for Marlene Raley

P-3398 FRA-04344;

FRA-04343;

FRA-02655

Voter packet for Deborah Randolph

P-3399 FRA-04481;

FRA-04480;

FRA-02662

Voter packet for Fred Rembert

P-3400 FRA-04279;

FRA-04278;

FRA-02657

Voter packet for Leevie Robinson

P-3401 FRA-04221;

FRA-04220;

FRA-02660

Voter packet for Eva Rossi

P-3402 FRA-04304;

FRA-04303;

FRA-02644

Voter packet for Annette Rundio

P-3403 FRA-04423;

FRA-04422;

FRA-02681

Voter packet for Diane Schneider

P-3404 FRA-04253;

FRA-04252;

FRA-02669

Voter packet for Kyle Schreck

P-3405 FRA-04265;

FRA-04264;

FRA-02647

Voter packet for Kenneth Scott

P-3406 FRA-04217;

FRA-04216;

FRA-02672

Voter packet for Linda Shipley

P-3407 FRA-04672;

FRA-04671;

FRA-02757

Voter packet for Clinton Smith

P-3408 FRA-04275;

FRA-04274;

FRA-02707

Voter packet for Jackey Snavley

P-3409 FRA-04409;

FRA-04408;

Voter packet for Rebecca Stewart

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 238 of 289 PAGEID #: 31417

239

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

FRA-02687

P-3410 FRA-04335;

FRA-04334;

FRA-02646

Voter packet for Phyllis Taylor

P-3411 FRA-04431;

FRA-04430;

FRA-02658

Voter packet for Charles Thomas Sr.

P-3412 FRA-04255;

FRA-04254;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Trey Thomas

P-3413 FRA-03781;

FRA-02780;

FRA-02628

Voter packet for Paulette Turpin

P-3414 FRA-04740;

FRA-04739;

FRA-02754

Voter packet for Karen VanHoose

P-3415 FRA-04688;

FRA-04687;

FRA-02733

Voter packet for Diana Warner

P-3416 FRA-04435;

FRA-04534;

FRA-02654

Voter packet for Valerie Warner

P-3417 FRA-04225;

FRA-04224;

FRA-02708

Voter packet for Joseph Washington

P-3418 FRA-04713;

FRA-04712;

FRA-02732

Voter packet for Jacqueline Williams

P-3419 FRA-04576;

FRA-04575;

FRA-02745

Voter packet for Yuchan Yi

P-3420 FRA-04306;

FRA-04305;

FRA-02696

Voter packet for Angela Yurewicz

P-3421 FRA-04445;

FRA-04444;

FRA-02691

Voter packet for Gregory Zalac

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 239 of 289 PAGEID #: 31418

240

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3422 FRA-04469;

FRA-04468;

FRA-02682

Voter packet for Susan Zimmerman

P-3423 FRA-04240;

FRA-04239;

FRA-04241

FRA-02639

Voter packet for Susan Alberry

P-3424 FRA-04719;

FRA-04718;

FRA-02734

Voter packet for Karen Brown

P-3425 FRA-04554;

FRA-04553;

FRA-02760

Voter packet for Jack Burton Jr.

P-3426 FRA-04578;

FRA-04577;

FRA-02740

Voter packet for Deanna Crawford

P-3427 FRA-03751;

FRA-03750;

FRA-02683

Voter packet for Marilyn Exline

P-3428 FRA-04584;

FRA-04583;

FRA-02762

Voter packet for Douglas Fleischmann

P-3429 FRA-04568;

FRA-04567;

FRA-02744

Voter packet for Nanciann Floyd

P-3430 FRA-04411;

FRA-04410;

FRA-02704

Voter packet for Bridget Frash

P-3431 FRA-04738;

FRA-04737;

FRA-02752

Voter packet for Gloria Greene

P-3432 FRA-04690;

FRA-04689;

FRA-02741

Voter packet for Helen Hartless

P-3433 FRA-04485;

FRA-04484;

FRA-02648

Voter packet for Patricia Hickman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 240 of 289 PAGEID #: 31419

241

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3434 FRA-04726;

FRA-04625;

FRA-02755

Voter packet for Raymond Hitchcock

P-3435 FRA-04351-

FRA-04352;

FRA-02666

Voter packet for Ronald Koch

P-3436 FRA-04370;

FRA-04369;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Martha Linthwaite

P-3437 FRA-04640;

FRA-04639;

FRA-02762

Voter packet for Celestine Littlejohn

P-3438 FRA-04548;

FRA-04547;

FRA-02732

Voter packet for Donald Mauger

P-3439 FRA-04439;

FRA-04438;

FRA-02638

Voter packet for James McNeilis

P-3440 FRA-03853;

FRA-03852;

FRA-03851

FRA-02656

Voter packet for Patty Moore

P-3441 FRA-04346;

FRA-04345;

FRA-02667

Voter packet for Teresa Perry

P-3442 FRA-04604;

FRA-04603;

FRA-02747

Voter packet for Timothy Richard

P-3443 FRA-04360;

FRA-04359;

FRA-02673

Voter packet for James Rishel

P-3444 FRA-04606;

FRA-04605;

FRA-02741

Voter packet for Roy Sawyer

P-3445 FRA-03855;

FRA-03854;

FRA-02653

Voter packet for Pauline Troesch

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 241 of 289 PAGEID #: 31420

242

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3446 FRA-04231;

FRA-04230;

FRA-02643

Voter packet for Tina Walker

P-3447 FRA-04493;

FRA-04492;

FRA-02650

Voter packet for Mark Walls

P-3448 FRA-04413;

FRA-04412;

FRA-02633

Voter packet for Loraine Washington

P-3449 FRA-04693;

FRA-04692;

FRA-02761

Voter packet for Mary White

P-3450 FRA-04632;

FRA-04631;

FRA-02749

Voter packet for Wanda Williams

P-3451 FRA-04765-

FRA-04778

Absentee ballot summary list for Franklin County 2015

P-3452 FRA-04779-

FRA-04778

Absentee ballot summary list for Franklin County 2014

P-3453 LUCAS-01201;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Phyllis Beene

P-3454 LUCAS-01203;

LUCAS-01242

Voter packet for David Bell

P-3455 LUCAS-01538 Voter packet for David Bell

P-3456 LUCAS-01543 Voter packet for Kelvin Campbell

P-3457 LUCAS-01541 Voter packet for Steven Hunter

P-3458 LUCAS-01542 Voter packet for William Johnson

P-3459 LUCAS-01206;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Louis Moorer

P-3460 LUCAS-01200;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Vivian Moorer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 242 of 289 PAGEID #: 31421

243

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3461 LUCAS-01205;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Bryan Romstadt

P-3462 LUCAS-01202;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Eric Shember

P-3463 LUCAS-01204;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Michael Slates

P-3464 LUCAS-01207;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Douglas Sweeney

P-3465 LUCAS-01540 Voter packet for Frank Draper

P-3466 LUCAS-01544 Voter packet for Edward Lee

P-3467 LUCAS-01199;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Dana McClain

P-3468 LUCAS-01539 Voter packet for Charles Steele

P-3469 LUCAS-01552 Voter packet for Joseph Artino

P-3470 LUCAS-01215;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Glen Frames

P-3471 LUCAS-01213;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Lisa Johnson

P-3472 LUCAS-01214;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Keisha Zimmerman

P-3473 LUCAS-01553 Voter packet for Christine Zychowicz

P-3474 LUCAS-01209;

LUCAS-01246

Voter packet for Gustavo Arredondo

P-3475 LUCAS-01210;

LUCAS-01246

Voter packet for Bernadette Balcome

P-3476 LUCAS-01545 Voter packet for Evelyn Cranston

P-3477 LUCAS-01548 Voter packet for Jackie Damcus

P-3478 LUCAS-01211; Voter packet for Wilson Hill

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 243 of 289 PAGEID #: 31422

244

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-01242

P-3479 LUCAS-01551 Voter packet for Joe Garcia

P-3480 LUCAS-01550 Voter packet for Steven Hand

P-3481 LUCAS-01549 Voter packet for Beverly Hollstein

P-3482 LUCAS-01208;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Leonard Newman

P-3483 LUCAS-01546 Voter packet for Marilyn Robinson

P-3484 LUCAS-01547 Voter packet for Scott Starcher

P-3485 LUCAS-01212;

LUCAS-01241

Voter packet for Jermin Thorton

P-3486 LUCAS-01319;

LUCAS-01347;

LUCAS-01411-LUCAS-

01412

Voter packet for Deanna Allen

P-3487 LUCAS-01320;

LUCAS-01352;

LUCAS-01421-LUCAS-

01422

Voter packet for Carolyn Beckler

P-3488 LUCAS-00767;

LUCAS-00581;

LUCAS-00880-LUCAS-

00881

Voter packet for Carol Bogan

P-3489 LUCAS-00768;

LUCAS-00582;

LUCAS-00882-LUCAS-

00883

Voter packet for Vincent Britton

P-3490 LUCAS-00769;

LUCAS-00586

Voter packet for Lauren Cardinal

P-3491 LUCAS-00770;

LUCAS-00588;

LUCAS-00892-LUCAS-

00893

Voter packet for Steven Ceglio

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 244 of 289 PAGEID #: 31423

245

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3492 LUCAS-00771;

LUCAS-00589;

LUCAS-00894-LUCAS-

00895

Voter packet for Traci Cherry

P-3493 LUCAS-00772;

LUCAS-00591;

LUCAS-00898-LUCAS-

00899

Voter packet for Elaine Clement

P-3494 LUCAS-01447-

LUCAS-01448

Voter packet for Michael Cluckey

P-3495 LUCAS-00773;

LUCAS-00593;

LUCAS-00902-LUCAS-

00903

Voter packet for Thomas Corser

P-3496 LUCAS-01321;

LUCAS-01367;

LUCAS-01451-LUCAS-

01452

Voter packet for Jason Crawford

P-3497 LUCAS-01453-

LUCAS-01454

Voter packet for Kimberly Cunningham

P-3498 LUCAS-01322;

LUCAS-02368;

LUCAS-01455-LUCAS-

01456

Voter packet for Ruth Custar

P-3499 LUCAS-00774 Voter packet for Edward Dibble

P-3500 LUCAS-00775;

LUCAS-00603;

LUCAS-00920-LUCAS-

00921

Voter packet for Caroline Faz

P-3501 LUCAS-00777;

LUCAS-00605;

LUCAS-00924-LUCAS-

00925

Voter packet for Paul Fetzer

P-3502 LUCAS-00778;

LUCAS-00609;

LUCAS-00932-LUCAS-

00933

Voter packet for Lois Fleck

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 245 of 289 PAGEID #: 31424

246

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3503 LUCAS-00779;

LUCAS-00610;

LUCAS-00936-LUCAS-

00937

Voter packet for Guadalupe Florez

P-3504 LUCAS-00780;

LUCAS-00612;

LUCAS-00940-LUCAS-

00941

Voter packet for Bessie Franklin

P-3505 LUCAS-00776;

LUCAS-00613;

LUCAS-00942-LUCAS-

00943

Voter packet for Kathleen Furlong

P-3506 LUCAS-00783;

LUCAS-00614;

LUCAS-00944-LUCAS-

00945

Voter packet for Adan Garcia Jr.

P-3507 LUCAS-00781;

LUCAS-00948-LUCAS-

00949

Voter packet for Vickie Gates

P-3508 LUCAS-00782;

LUCAS-00950-LUCAS-

00951

Voter packet for Wayne Gates

P-3509 LUCAS-00785;

LUCAS-00622;

LUCAS-00964-LUCAS-

00965

Voter packet for Carol Ann Grace

P-3510 LUCAS-00786;

LUCAS-00631;

LUCAS-00982-LUCAS-

00983

Voter packet for Darla Hearn

P-3511 LUCAS-00787;

LUCAS-00632;

LUCAS-00984-LUCAS-

00985

Voter packet for Frederick Hearn

P-3512 LUCAS-00788;

LUCAS-00986-LUCAS-

00987

Voter packet for Richard Hendricks

P-3513 LUCAS-00789;

LUCAS-00636

Voter packet for Delores Horton

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 246 of 289 PAGEID #: 31425

247

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3514 LUCAS-00790;

LUCAS-00641

Voter packet for Kenneth Johnson

P-3515 LUCAS-01323;

LUCAS-01380;

LUCAS-01483-

LUCAS-01484

Voter packet for Sharron Jones

P-3516 LUCAS-00791;

LUCAS-00641;

LUCAS-01010-

LUCAS-01011

Voter packet for Chester Kendzierski

P-3517 LUCAS-00793;

LUCAS-00651;

LUCAS-01018-

LUCAS-01019

Voter packet for Lawrence Kynard Jr.

P-3518 LUCAS-00792;

LUCAS-00652;

LUCAS-01020-

LUCAS-01021

Voter packet for Pearlia Kynard

P-3519 LUCAS-01493-

LUCAS-01494

Voter packet for Alvin Love

P-3520 LUCAS-00794;

LUCAS-006660;

LUCAS-01036-

LUCAS-01037

Voter packet for Marvin Mack

P-3521 LUCAS-00795;

LUCAS-00662;

LUCAS-01040-

LUCAS-01041

Voter packet for Marissa Mallue

P-3522 LUCAS-00796;

LUCAS-00670;

LUCAS-01054-

LUCAS-01055

Voter packet for Lisa McCoy

P-3523 LUCAS-00797;

LUCAS-00672;

LUCAS-01058-

LUCAS-01059

Voter packet for Richard McGranahan Jr.

P-3524 LUCAS-00798;

LUCAS-00675;

LUCAS-01064-

Voter packet for Karen Mitchell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 247 of 289 PAGEID #: 31426

248

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-01065

P-3525 LUCAS-00799;

LUCAS-00679

Voter packet for Alma Mueller

P-3526 LUCAS-01080-

LUCAS-01081

Voter packet for Lawrence Ollivier

P-3527 LUCAS-01082-

LUCAS-01083

Voter packet for Pamela Ostrander

P-3528 LUCAS-00800;

LUCAS-01088-

LUCAS-01089

Voter packet for Geraldine Paluszak

P-3529 LUCAS-00801 Voter packet for Pamela Pappas

P-3530 LUCAS-00802;

LUCAS-01092-

LUCAS-01093

Voter packet for Robert Parker

P-3531 LUCAS-01096-

LUCAS-01097

Voter packet for Mary Pavuk

P-3532 LUCAS-00803 Voter packet for Randy Popoff

P-3533 LUCAS-00804;

LUCAS-01106-

LUCAS-01107

Voter packet for Donna Recknagel

P-3534 LUCAS-00805;

LUCAS-01108-

LUCAS-01109

Voter packet for James Richards

P-3535 LUCAS-01324;

LUCAS-01395;

LUCAS-01509-

LUCAS-01510

Voter packet for Marlene Rodedeau

P-3536 LUCAS-00806;

LUCAS-01132-

LUCAS-01133

Voter packet for Jayne Schroeder

P-3537 LUCAS-00807;

LUCAS-01134-

LUCAS-01135

Voter packet for Berta Mae Scott

P-3538 LUCAS-00808 Voter packet for Dolores Simon

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 248 of 289 PAGEID #: 31427

249

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3539 LUCAS-00809;

LUCAS-01152-

LUCAS-01153

Voter packet for Brian Stahl

P-3540 LUCAS-00810;

LUCAS-01154-

LUCAS-01155

Voter packet for Gail Stenson

P-3541 LUCAS-00811;

LUCAS-01158-

LUCAS-01159

Voter packet for Christine Sutu

P-3542 LUCAS-00812;

LUCAS-01162-

LUCAS-01163

Voter packet for Gregory Terry

P-3543 LUCAS-00813;

LUCAS-01170-

LUCAS-01171

Voter packet for Edward Turner

P-3544 LUCAS-00814 Voter packet for Ruth VanEtten

P-3545 LUCAS-01531-

LUCAS-01532

Voter packet for Laura Wilson

P-3546 LUCAS-00815;

LUCAS-01194-

LUCAS-01195

Voter packet for Faith Wysocki

P-3547 LUCAS-00816;

LUCAS-01196-

LUCAS-01197

Voter packet for Michael Wysocki

P-3548 LUCAS-00687;

LUCAS-00575

LUCAS-00868-

LUCAS-00869

Voter packet for Rose Barone

P-3549 LUCAS-01291;

LUCAS-01356;-

LUCAS-01429-

LUCAS-01430

Voter packet for Joan Boyce

P-3550 LUCAS-00688;

LUCAS-00576

LUCAS-00870-

LUCAS-00871

Voter packet for Robert Baun

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 249 of 289 PAGEID #: 31428

250

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3551 LUCAS-00690;

LUCAS-00578

LUCAS-00874-

LUCAS-00875

Voter packet for Douglas Berry

P-3552 LUCAS-00692 Voter packet for Patricia Boes

P-3553 LUCAS-01293;

LUCAS-01362;-

LUCAS-01439-

LUCAS-01440

Voter packet for Mary Carstensen

P-3554 LUCAS-00699;

LUCAS-00606

LUCAS-00926-

LUCAS-00927

Voter packet for Amy Figliomeni

P-3555 LUCAS-00705;

LUCAS-00624

LUCAS-00968-

LUCAS-00969

Voter packet for David Grandowicz Sr.

P-3556 LUCAS-00706;

LUCAS-00625

LUCAS-00970-

LUCAS-00971

Voter packet for Annie Griffin

P-3557 LUCAS-01298;

LUCAS-01375

LUCAS-01471-

LUCAS-01472

Voter packet for Sarah Goves

P-3558 LUCAS-00709;

LUCAS-00633

LUCAS-00988-

LUCAS-00989

Voter packet for Namon Henry

P-3559 LUCAS-00710;

LUCAS-00635

LUCAS-00992-

LUCAS-00993

Voter packet for Patricia Hodur

P-3560 LUCAS-00711;

LUCAS-00639

LUCAS-00998-

LUCAS-00999

Voter packet for Sheila Jackson

P-3561 LUCAS-00712;

LUCAS-00640

Voter packet for Suzanne Jimenez

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 250 of 289 PAGEID #: 31429

251

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-01000-

LUCAS-01001

P-3562 LUCAS-00714;

LUCAS-00644

LUCAS-01008-

LUCAS-01009

Voter packet for Antoinette Keller

P-3563 LUCAS-01304;

LUCAS-01388

LUCAS-01495-

LUCAS-01496

Voter packet for Susan MacPhee

P-3564 LUCAS-00723;

LUCAS-00673

LUCAS-01060-

LUCAS-01061

Voter packet for Carolyn Metcalf

P-3565 LUCAS-00725;

LUCAS-00677

LUCAS-01066-

LUCAS-01067

Voter packet for Beverly Montgomery

P-3566 LUCAS-01307;

LUCAS-01392

LUCAS-01503-

LUCAS-01504

Voter packet for Wilhelm Orlet

P-3567 LUCAS-00729;

LUCAS-01084-

LUCAS-01085

Voter packet for Diana Ozanski

P-3568 LUCAS-00730;

LUCAS-01086-

LUCAS-01087

Voter packet for Virginia Pacholski

P-3569 LUCAS-00731;

LUCAS-01090-

LUCAS-01091

Voter packet for Laura Parker

P-3570 LUCAS-00732;

LUCAS-01104-

LUCAS-01105

Voter packet for Agnes Rasik

P-3571 LUCAS-00735;

LUCAS-01116-

LUCAS-01117

Voter packet for Blaine Rogalski

P-3572 LUCAS-00736;

LUCAS-01118-

Voter packet for Betty Rosansky

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 251 of 289 PAGEID #: 31430

252

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-01119

P-3573 LUCAS-00737;

LUCAS-01120-

LUCAS-01121

Voter packet for Mario Rossi

P-3574 LUCAS-00742;

LUCAS-01138-

LUCAS-01139

Voter packet for Willard Shaneck Jr.

P-3575 LUCAS-01309;

LUCAS-01401

LUCAS-01517-

LUCAS-01518

Voter packet for Aaron Sterling

P-3576 LUCAS-01311;

LUCAS-01404

LUCAS-01523-

LUCAS-01524

Voter packet for Patricia Thomas

P-3577 LUCAS-00747;

LUCAS-01176-

LUCAS-01177

Voter packet for Rita Verzinskie

P-3578 LUCAS-00685;

LUCAS-00571

LUCAS-00860-

LUCAS-00861

Voter packet for Robert Allen

P-3579 LUCAS-00686;

LUCAS-00572

LUCAS-00862-

LUCAS-00863

Voter packet for Geraldine Armstrong

P-3580 LUCAS-01287;

LUCAS-01350

LUCAS-01417-

LUCAS-01418

Voter packet for Judith Barber

P-3581 LUCAS-01288;

LUCAS-01351

LUCAS-01419-

LUCAS-01420

Voter packet for Bernard Bays

P-3582 LUCAS-00689;

LUCAS-00577

LUCAS-00872-

LUCAS-00873

Voter packet for Sean Beach

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 252 of 289 PAGEID #: 31431

253

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3583 LUCAS-01289;

LUCAS-01353

LUCAS-01423-

LUCAS-01424

Voter packet for Henry Berry

P-3584 LUCAS-00691;

LUCAS-00579

LUCAS-00876-

LUCAS-00877

Voter packet for Regino Biana

P-3585 LUCAS-01290;

LUCAS-01357

LUCAS-01431-

LUCAS-01432

Voter packet for Owen Bridgett

P-3586 LUCAS-01292;

LUCAS-01358

LUCAS-01433-

LUCAS-01434

Voter packet for Calvin Brown

P-3587 LUCAS-00693;

LUCAS-00590

LUCAS-00896-

LUCAS-00897

Voter packet for Yvonne Clark

P-3588 LUCAS-01294;

LUCAS-01366

LUCAS-01449-

LUCAS-01450

Voter packet for Jessica Conner

P-3589 LUCAS-00694;

LUCAS-00597

LUCAS-00908-

LUCAS-00909

Voter packet for Daniel Daronco

P-3590 LUCAS-00695;

LUCAS-00598

LUCAS-00910-

LUCAS-00911

Voter packet for Maria Denning

P-3591 LUCAS-00696;

LUCAS-00601

LUCAS-00916-

LUCAS-00917

Voter packet for Craig Doerr

P-3592 LUCAS-00697;

LUCAS-00602

LUCAS-00918-

LUCAS-00919

Voter packet for Patricia Farner

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 253 of 289 PAGEID #: 31432

254

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3593 LUCAS-00698;

LUCAS-00604

LUCAS-00922-

LUCAS-00923

Voter packet for Suzanne Fessler

P-3594 LUCAS-00700;

LUCAS-00607

LUCAS-00928-

LUCAS-00929

Voter packet for James Fisher

P-3595 LUCAS-00701;

LUCAS-00608

LUCAS-00930-

LUCAS-00931

Voter packet for Ronald Fisher

P-3596 LUCAS-00702;

LUCAS-00934-

LUCAS-00935

Voter packet for Michael Fleitz

P-3597 LUCAS-01296;

LUCAS-01371

LUCAS-01463-

LUCAS-01464

Voter packet for David Francisco

P-3598 LUCAS-00703;

LUCAS-00616

LUCAS-00952-

LUCAS-00953

Voter packet for James Gayle

P-3599 LUCAS-01297;

LUCAS-01372

LUCAS-01465-

LUCAS-01466

Voter packet for William Gedeon Jr.

P-3600 LUCAS-00704;

LUCAS-00618

LUCAS-00958-

LUCAS-00959

Voter packet for Cindylee Ginter

P-3601 LUCAS-00707;

LUCAS-00626

LUCAS-00972-

LUCAS-00973

Voter packet for Cathy Haberkamp

P-3602 LUCAS-00708;

LUCAS-00630

LUCAS-00980-

LUCAS-00981

Voter packet for Bryan Hayes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 254 of 289 PAGEID #: 31433

255

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3603 LUCAS-01299;

LUCAS-01377

LUCAS-01475-

LUCAS-01476

Voter packet for Julie Henretty

P-3604 LUCAS-01300;

LUCAS-01379

LUCAS-01481-

LUCAS-01482

Voter packet for Julie Johnson

P-3605 LUCAS-00713;

LUCAS-00642

LUCAS-01004-

LUCAS-01005

Voter packet for Erwin Kalmbacher

P-3606 LUCAS-01301;

LUCAS-01381

LUCAS-01485-

LUCAS-01486

Voter packet for Thomas Kelch

P-3607 LUCAS-01302;

LUCAS-01382

LUCAS-01487-

LUCAS-01488

Voter packet for Martha Knitz

P-3608 LUCAS-00715;

LUCAS-00649

LUCAS-01014-

LUCAS-01015

Voter packet for Robert Koppert

P-3609 LUCAS-00716;

LUCAS-00653

LUCAS-01022-

LUCAS-01023

Voter packet for Patrick Lalor

P-3610 LUCAS-00717;

LUCAS-00655

LUCAS-01026-

LUCAS-01027

Voter packet for Marie LaPointe

P-3611 LUCAS-00718;

LUCAS-01030-

LUCAS-01031

Voter packet for George Le

P-3612 LUCAS-01303;

LUCAS-01384

LUCAS-01491-

LUCAS-01492

Voter packet for Rose Leonhardt

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 255 of 289 PAGEID #: 31434

256

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3613 LUCAS-00719;

LUCAS-00661

LUCAS-01038-

LUCAS-01039

Voter packet for Glenadine Maley

P-3614 LUCAS-00720;

LUCAS-00666

LUCAS-01050-

LUCAS-01051

Voter packet for A. Joyce Martin

P-3615 LUCAS-00721;

LUCAS-00668

LUCAS-01052-

LUCAS-01053

Voter packet for Mary Mathias

P-3616 LUCAS-00722;

LUCAS-00669

Voter packet for John Mays

P-3617 LUCAS-00724;

LUCAS-00674

LUCAS-01062-

LUCAS-01063

Voter packet for Virginia Miller

P-3618 LUCAS-00726;

LUCAS-00682

Voter packet for Mary Myers

P-3619 LUCAS-01305;

LUCAS-01390

LUCAS-01499-

LUCAS-01500

Voter packet for Michael Napoletano

P-3620 LUCAS-00727;

LUCAS-01076-

LUCAS-01077

Voter packet for Melvin Nofzinger

P-3621 LUCAS-00728;

LUCAS-01078-

LUCAS-01079

Voter packet for James Obong Sr.

P-3622 LUCAS-01306;

LUCAS-01391

LUCAS-01501-

LUCAS-01502

Voter packet for Donald Oklejnik Jr.

P-3623 LUCAS-01308;

LUCAS-01393

LUCAS-01505-

LUCAS-01506

Voter packet for Margaret Powell

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 256 of 289 PAGEID #: 31435

257

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3624 LUCAS-00733;

LUCAS-01110-

LUCAS-01111

Voter packet for Gerald Richardson

P-3625 LUCAS-00734;

LUCAS-01112-

LUCAS-01113

Voter packet for Michael Robinson

P-3626 LUCAS-00738;

LUCAS-01122-

LUCAS-01123

Voter packet for Noah Ryan

P-3627 LUCAS-00739;

LUCAS-01126-

LUCAS-01127

Voter packet for Grace Sattler

P-3628 LUCAS-00740;

LUCAS-01128-

LUCAS-01129

Voter packet for Jerry Sauter

P-3629 LUCAS-00741 Voter packet for Daniel Schings

P-3630 LUCAS-00743;

LUCAS-01142-

LUCAS-01143

Voter packet for Douglas Smith

P-3631 LUCAS-00744;

LUCAS-01146-

LUCAS-01147

Voter packet for Phyllis Smith

P-3632 LUCAS-01310;

LUCAS-01402

LUCAS-01519-

LUCAS-01520

Voter packet for James Stvartak

P-3633 LUCAS-00745;

LUCAS-01160-

LUCAS-01161

Voter packet for Eric Sykes

P-3634 LUCAS-01166-

LUCAS-01167

Voter packet for Melissa Tracy

P-3635 LUCAS-00746;

LUCAS-01172-

LUCAS-01173

Voter packet for Daniel Umfleet

P-3636 LUCAS-00748;

LUCAS-01186-

LUCAS-01187

Voter packet for Norman Willingham

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 257 of 289 PAGEID #: 31436

258

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3637 LUCAS-01314;

LUCAS-01407;

LUCAS-01533-

LUCAS-01534

Voter packet for Lorna Wilson

P-3638 LUCAS-01313 Voter packet for Patricia Wechtel

P-3639 LUCAS-00749;

LUCAS-01192-

LUCAS-01193

Voter packet for Christine Woulard

P-3640 LUCAS-01359;

LUCAS-01435-

LUCAS-01436

Voter packet for Cornell Bumpus

P-3641 LUCAS-01361;

LUCAS-01437-

LUCAS-01438

Voter packet for Hugh Callahan

P-3642 LUCAS-01457-

LUCAS-01458

Voter packet for Ann Emon

P-3643 LUCAS-01326;

LUCAS-01348

LUCAS-01413-

LUCAS-01414

Voter packet for Bona Babcock

P-3644 LUCAS-01327;

LUCAS-01349

LUCAS-01415-

LUCAS-01416

Voter packet for Harold Babcock

P-3645 LUCAS-00820 Voter packet for Alvin Blachowski

P-3646 LUCAS-00821;

LUCAS-00587

LUCAS-00890-

LUCAS-00891

Voter packet for Doris Carter

P-3647 LUCAS-01328;

LUCAS-01363

LUCAS-01441-

LUCAS-01442

Voter packet for Lilli Carter

P-3648 LUCAS-01330;

LUCAS-01365

LUCAS-01445-

LUCAS-01446

Voter packet for Michelle Case

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 258 of 289 PAGEID #: 31437

259

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3649 LUCAS-00822;

LUCAS-00596

Voter packet for Bette Crowl

P-3650 LUCAS-00823;

LUCAS-00594

LUCAS-00906-

LUCAS-00907

Voter packet for Mary Crossen

P-3651 LUCAS-00824;

LUCAS-00600

LUCAS-00914-

LUCAS-00915

Voter packet for Joan Dingle

P-3652 LUCAS-00825 Voter packet for Frederic Flox

P-3653 LUCAS-00826;

LUCAS-00611

LUCAS-00938-

LUCAS-00939

Voter packet for Jaimie Foster

P-3654 LUCAS-01332;

LUCAS-01370

LUCAS-01461-

LUCAS-01462

Voter packet for Dorothy Francis

P-3655 LUCAS-00827;

LUCAS-00619

LUCAS-00956-

LUCAS-00957

Voter packet for Dolores Ginsburg

P-3656 LUCAS-01333;

LUCAS-01373

LUCAS-01467-

LUCAS-01468

Voter packet for Cecile Glodek

P-3657 LUCAS-00829;

LUCAS-00620

LUCAS-00960-

LUCAS-00961

Voter packet for Greg Gloden

P-3658 LUCAS-01334;

LUCAS-01374

LUCAS-01469-

LUCAS-01470

Voter packet for Jack Goins

P-3659 LUCAS-00831;

LUCAS-00629

LUCAS-00978-

LUCAS-00979

Voter packet for Phyllis Harvey

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 259 of 289 PAGEID #: 31438

260

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3660 LUCAS-00832;

LUCAS-00634

LUCAS-00990-

LUCAS-00991

Voter packet for Howard Hilfinger III

P-3661 LUCAS-01335;

LUCAS-01479-

LUCAS-01480

Voter packet for Mary Humbarger

P-3662 LUCAS-00834;

LUCAS-00638

LUCAS-00996-

LUCAS-00997

Voter packet for Marilyn Jackson

P-3663 LUCAS-00836;

LUCAS-00643

LUCAS-01006-

LUCAS-01007

Voter packet for Marilyn Kamm

P-3664 LUCAS-00838;

LUCAS-00654

LUCAS-01024-

LUCAS-01025

Voter packet for Edith Landmesser

P-3665 LUCAS-00839;

LUCAS-00657

LUCAS-01032-

LUCAS-01033

Voter packet for Olivia Leese

P-3666 LUCAS-01337;

LUCAS-01389

LUCAS-01497-

LUCAS-01498

Voter packet for Robert Mangas

P-3667 LUCAS-00840;

LUCAS-00663

LUCAS-01042-

LUCAS-01043

Voter packet for Nicholas Marciniak

P-3668 LUCAS-00844;

LUCAS-00681

LUCAS-01072-

LUCAS-01073

Voter packet for William Murphy

P-3669 LUCAS-01339;

LUCAS-01396

LUCAS-01511-

LUCAS-01512

Voter packet for Don Rowney

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 260 of 289 PAGEID #: 31439

261

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3670 LUCAS-01341;

LUCAS-01398

LUCAS-01515-

LUCAS-01516

Voter packet for Darlene Schurfeld

P-3671 LUCAS-00851;

LUCAS-01140-

LUCAS-01141

Voter packet for James Shoemaker

P-3672 LUCAS-01342;

LUCAS-01400

Voter packet for Nellye Stahl

P-3673 LUCAS-01343;

LUCAS-01403

LUCAS-01521-

LUCAS-01522

Voter packet for Carol Thanasiu

P-3674 LUCAS-00855;

LUCAS-01168-

LUCAS-01169

Voter packet for Mary Tran

P-3675 LUCAS-01345;

LUCAS-01408

LUCAS-01535-

LUCAS-01536

Voter packet for Doris Wohl

P-3676 LUCAS-00818;

LUCAS-00574

LUCAS-00866-

LUCAS-00867

Voter packet for Randall Baker

P-3677 LUCAS-00819;

LUCAS-00580

LUCAS-00878-

LUCAS-00879

Voter packet for John Birmingham

P-3678 LUCAS-01329;

LUCAS-01364

LUCAS-01443-

LUCAS-01444

Voter packet for Theophelis Carter

P-3679 LUCAS-01331;

LUCAS-01369

LUCAS-01459-

LUCAS-01460

Voter packet for Bess Fletcher

P-3680 LUCAS-00828;

LUCAS-00617

LUCAS-00954-

Voter packet for Shirley Gibson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 261 of 289 PAGEID #: 31440

262

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-00955

P-3681 LUCAS-00830;

LUCAS-00627

LUCAS-00974-

LUCAS-00975

Voter packet for Brenda Haire

P-3682 LUCAS-00833;

LUCAS-00637

LUCAS-00994-

LUCAS-00995

Voter packet for Wiletta Howard

P-3683 LUCAS-00837;

LUCAS-00648

LUCAS-01012-

LUCAS-01013

Voter packet for Jennifer Kogut

P-3684 LUCAS-01336;

LUCAS-01383

LUCAS-01489-

LUCAS-01490

Voter packet for Sue Ellen Koon

P-3685 LUCAS-00835;

LUCAS-00650

LUCAS-01016-

LUCAS-01017

Voter packet for Judith Kossow

P-3686 LUCAS-00841;

LUCAS-00665

LUCAS-01046-

LUCAS-01047

Voter packet for Barbara Marks

P-3687 LUCAS-00842;

LUCAS-00671

LUCAS-01056-

LUCAS-01057

Voter packet for Paul McGavin

P-3688 LUCAS-00843;

LUCAS-00680

LUCAS-01070-

LUCAS-01071

Voter packet for Jacquelyn Mullins

P-3689 LUCAS-00845;

LUCAS-01098-

LUCAS-01099

Voter packet for Thomas Perry

P-3690 LUCAS-00846;

LUCAS-01102-

LUCAS-01103

Voter packet for Sandra Pratt

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 262 of 289 PAGEID #: 31441

263

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3691 LUCAS-01338;

LUCAS-01394

LUCAS-01507-

LUCAS-01508

Voter packet for David Reedy

P-3692 LUCAS-00847;

LUCAS-01114-

LUCAS-01115

Voter packet for George Rodriquez

P-3693 LUCAS-00848;

LUCAS-01124-

LUCAS-01125

Voter packet for Laura Salzwedel

P-3694 LUCAS-01340;

LUCAS-01397

LUCAS-01513-

LUCAS-01514

Voter packet for Robert Sawyers

P-3695 LUCAS-00849;

LUCAS-01130-

LUCAS-01131

Voter packet for Franklin Schrock

P-3696 LUCAS-00850;

LUCAS-01136-

LUCAS-01137

Voter packet for Robert Shamy

P-3697 LUCAS-00852;

LUCAS-01144-

LUCAS-01145

Voter packet for Nancy Smith

P-3698 LUCAS-00853;

LUCAS-01156-

LUCAS-01157

Voter packet for Lois Stevens

P-3699 LUCAS-00854;

LUCAS-01164-

LUCAS-01165

Voter packet for Joseph Thomas

P-3700 LUCAS-00856;

LUCAS-01178-

LUCAS-01179

Voter packet for Bonnie Visser

P-3701 LUCAS-01344;

LUCAS-01406

LUCAS-01527-

LUCAS-01528

Voter packet for Helen Wielgopolski

P-3702 LUCAS-00857;

LUCAS-01184-

Voter packet for Shirley Ann Williams

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 263 of 289 PAGEID #: 31442

264

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

LUCAS-01185

P-3703 LUCAS-01354;

LUCAS-01425-

LUCAS-01426

Voter packet for Jack Berry

P-3704 LUCAS-01355;

LUCAS-01427-

LUCAS-01428

Voter packet for Harvey Bowles, Jr.

P-3705 LUCAS-00623;

LUCAS-00966-

LUCAS-00967

Voter packet for Sonia Graciani

P-3706 LUCAS-01002-

LUCAS-01003

Voter packet for Dale Johnson

P-3707 LUCAS-01100-

LUCAS-01101

Voter packet for Carolyn Peterson

P-3708 LUCAS-01180-

LUCAS-01181

Voter packet for James Wells

P-3709 LUCAS-01188-

LUCAS-01189

Voter packet for Donnae Willis

P-3710 SUMMIT-01605;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Wayne Alexander

P-3711 SUMMIT-01486-

SUMMIT-01487;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Michael Bell

P-3712 SUMMIT-01615;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Jessica Blizzard

P-3713 SUMMIT-01477;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Linda Brandon

P-3714 SUMMIT-01488-

SUMMIT-01489;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Larry Burns

P-3715 SUMMIT-01472-

SUMMIT-01473;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Luis Caceres

P-3716 SUMMIT-01490;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Ashley Caynor

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 264 of 289 PAGEID #: 31443

265

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3717 SUMMIT-01601;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Elaine Cherry

P-3718 SUMMIT-01617;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Robert Coon

P-3719 SUMMIT-01611;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Constantine Corpas

P-3720 SUMMIT-01491-

SUMMIT-01492;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Molly Courtemanche

P-3721 SUMMIT-01475-

SUMMIT-01476;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Robert Dittman

P-3722 SUMMIT-01481;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Rodger Frazier

P-3723 SUMMIT-01607;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Teresa Gay-Williams

P-3724 SUMMIT-01518-

SUMMIT-01519;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Hugh Groce

P-3725 SUMMIT-01469;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Lindsey Johnson

P-3726 SUMMIT-01494-

SUMMIT-01495;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Valerie Kenny-Walker

P-3727 SUMMIT-01604;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Gerald Keyes

P-3728 SUMMIT-01506-

SUMMIT-01507;

SUMMIT-01468;

SUMMIT-01508

Voter packet for Bonnie Koellner

P-3729 SUMMIT-01474;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Benee Langford

P-3730 SUMMIT-01470;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Andrea Lopez Gonzalez

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 265 of 289 PAGEID #: 31444

266

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3731 SUMMIT-01479-

SUMMIT-01480;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Kenneth Lowe

P-3732 SUMMIT-01603;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Niko Ricks

P-3733 SUMMIT-01500-

SUMMIT-01501;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Russ Russell

P-3734 SUMMIT-01485;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for JoAnn Rutter

P-3735 SUMMIT-01625;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Betty Sedlack

P-3736 SUMMIT-01484;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Kathy Warren

P-3737 SUMMIT-01496-

SUMMIT-01497;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Steve Welman

P-3738 SUMMIT-01608;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Doris Wetterau

P-3739 SUMMIT-01503;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Arita Williams

P-3740 SUMMIT-01482-

SUMMIT-01483;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Austin Yarnell

P-3741 SUMMIT-01627;

SUMMIT-01626

Voter packet for Michael Cummings

P-3742 SUMMIT-01478;

SUMMIT-01468

Voter packet for Leroy Perry Jr.

P-3743 SUMMIT-01612;

SUMMIT-01601

Voter packet for Barbara Thompson

P-3744 SUMMIT-01524-

SUMMIT-01525;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Eugene Brewer

P-3745 SUMMIT-01530-

SUMMIT-01534;

Voter packet for Gary Cuckler

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 266 of 289 PAGEID #: 31445

267

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-01521

P-3746 SUMMIT-01526-

SUMMIT-01527;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Destiny Fielding

P-3747 SUMMIT-01538-

SUMMIT-01543;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Daniel Foster

P-3748 SUMMIT-01528-

SUMMIT-01529;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Ada Gelpi

P-3749 SUMMIT-01567-

SUMMIT-01570;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Darlene Gibbs

P-3750 SUMMIT-01571-

SUMMIT-01574;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Cody Hershey

P-3751 SUMMIT-01553-

SUMMIT-01554;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Rebecca Koroma

P-3752 SUMMIT-01546-

SUMMIT-01547;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Delores Legro

P-3753 SUMMIT-01555-

SUMMIT-01558;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Robert Lewis

P-3754 SUMMIT-01548-

SUMMIT-01550;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Kara Maguire

P-3755 SUMMIT-01559-

SUMMIT-01560;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Diane Murphy

P-3756 SUMMIT-01563-

SUMMIT-01566;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Michelle Noce

P-3757 SUMMIT-01544-

SUMMIT-01545;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Jackie Toth

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 267 of 289 PAGEID #: 31446

268

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3758 SUMMIT-01561-

SUMMIT-01562;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Stephanie Vaughan

P-3759 SUMMIT-01535-

SUMMIT-01537;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Margaret Wetzel

P-3760 SUMMIT-01552;

SUMMIT-01551

Voter packet for Jonah Stupar

P-3761 SUMMIT-01522-

SUMMIT-01523;

SUMMIT-01521

Voter packet for Kristen Williams

P-3762 SUMMIT-01584-

SUMMIT-01585;

SUMMIT-01575

Voter packet for Paul Brown

P-3763 SUMMIT-01587-

SUMMIT-01588;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Frank Catalano

P-3764 SUMMIT-01578-

SUMMIT-01579;

SUMMIT-01575

Voter packet for Terry McCrory

P-3765 SUMMIT-01576-

SUMMIT-01577;

SUMMIT-01575

Voter packet for Minnie Milliken

P-3766 SUMMIT-01589-

SUMMIT-01592;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Janice Mills

P-3767 SUMMIT-01580-

SUMMIT-01581;

SUMMIT-01575

Voter packet for Martin Vronick

P-3768 SUMMIT-01595;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Terry Fisher

P-3769 SUMMIT-01594;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Rodney Jones

P-3770 SUMMIT-01596;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Vincent Marino

P-3771 SUMMIT-01593; Voter packet for Alicia Robinson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 268 of 289 PAGEID #: 31447

269

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-01586

P-3772 SUMMIT-01582-

SUMMIT-01583;

SUMMIT-01575

Voter packet for Latarice Watson

P-3773 SUMMIT-01597;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Henrietta Wilson

P-3774 SUMMIT-01598;

SUMMIT-01586

Voter packet for Steven Woods

P-3775 SUMMIT-01251;

SUMMIT-01077;

SUMMIT-00828

Voter packet for Patricia Boodstaire (f/k/a Boord)

P-3776 SUMMIT-01257;

SUMMIT-01083;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00703

Voter packet for Jean Dietz

P-3777 SUMMIT-01295;

SUMMIT-01278;

SUMMIT-00749

Voter packet for Anne Eckerman

P-3778 SUMMIT-01252;

SUMMIT-01078;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Cheryl Jansen

P-3779 SUMMIT-01255;

SUMMIT-01081;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00688

Voter packet for Regina Martin (f/k/a Stokes)

P-3780 SUMMIT-01253;

SUMMIT-01079;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00689

Voter packet for Ashley McQuillen (f/k/a Messner)

P-3781 SUMMIT-01256;

SUMMIT-01082;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00696

Voter packet for Evelina Seifert (f/k/a Sweitzer)

P-3782 SUMMIT-01254;

SUMMIT-01080;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00690

Voter packet for Penny Young (f/k/a Moore)

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 269 of 289 PAGEID #: 31448

270

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3783 SUMMIT-01084;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00670

Voter packet for Shelley Aboagye

P-3784 SUMMIT-01086;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00670

Voter packet for Daria Alexander

P-3785 SUMMIT-01085;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00670

Voter packet for Tommie Alexander Jr.

P-3786 SUMMIT-01087;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00671

Voter packet for Colletta Bell

P-3787 SUMMIT-01088;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00671

Voter packet for Eden Benton

P-3788 SUMMIT-01090;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00673

Voter packet for Erin Bradic

P-3789 SUMMIT-01089;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00673

Voter packet for Matthew Bradic

P-3790 SUMMIT-01091;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00674

Voter packet for Elizabeth Butera

P-3791 SUMMIT-01092;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00674

Voter packet for John Burorac

P-3792 SUMMIT-01093;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00674

Voter packet for Felicia Campbell

P-3793 SUMMIT-01095;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for Patricia Chapman

P-3794 SUMMIT-01096;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for Carla Conway

P-3795 SUMMIT-01097;

SUMMIT-00831;

Voter packet for Eric Dickson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 270 of 289 PAGEID #: 31449

271

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00676

P-3796 SUMMIT-01098;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00677

Voter packet for David Drylie

P-3797 SUMMIT-01099;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00677

Voter packet for Kyle Eberhardt

P-3798 SUMMIT-01100;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00679

Voter packet for Michael Gable

P-3799 SUMMIT-01101;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00680

Voter packet for Shayna Glass

P-3800 SUMMIT-01102;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Christopher Hunter

P-3801 SUMMIT-01103;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00685

Voter packet for Walter Kudlaty

P-3802 SUMMIT-01104;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00689

Voter packet for Kara Micucci

P-3803 SUMMIT-01314;

SUMMIT-01259;

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00782

Voter packet for Julena Peterson

P-3804 SUMMIT-01106;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00692

Voter packet for Matthew Peterson

P-3805 SUMMIT-01105;

SUMMIT-00831;

SUMMIT-00692

Voter packet for Montgomery Peterson

P-3806 SUMMIT-01315;

SUMMIT-01258;

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00784

Voter packet for Mary Powers

P-3807 SUMMIT-01107;

SUMMIT-00831;

Voter packet for Justine Sampson

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 271 of 289 PAGEID #: 31450

272

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00695

P-3808 SUMMIT-01108;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00695

Voter packet for Abbey Sanderfer

P-3809 SUMMIT-01109;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00699

Voter packet for Hilda Stoebermann

P-3810 SUMMIT-01110;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00699

Voter packet for Cheryl Stormer

P-3811 SUMMIT-01111;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00700

Voter packet for Huy Tran

P-3812 SUMMIT-01112;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00701

Voter packet for Hannah Tyson

P-3813 SUMMIT-01113;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00702

Voter packet for Darlene Weigand

P-3814 SUMMIT-01114;

SUMMIT-00832;

SUMMIT-00703

Voter packet for Leanne Zimmerman

P-3815 SUMMIT-01235;

SUMMIT-01133

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for Timothy Cottrell

P-3816 SUMMIT-01248;

SUMMIT-01134

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00677

Voter packet for Eileen Doljac

P-3817 SUMMIT-01250;

SUMMIT-01135

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00679

Voter packet for Susan Garman

P-3818 SUMMIT-01236;

SUMMIT-01136

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00679

Voter packet for Joanne Gill

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 272 of 289 PAGEID #: 31451

273

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3819 SUMMIT-01237;

SUMMIT-01137

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00682

Voter packet for Pauline Hatala

P-3820 SUMMIT-01238;

SUMMIT-01138

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Patricia Jackson

P-3821 SUMMIT-01239;

SUMMIT-01139

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00688

Voter packet for Evelyn McCusker

P-3822 SUMMIT-01240;

SUMMIT-01140

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00688

Voter packet for Elizabeth McDaniel

P-3823 SUMMIT-01241;

SUMMIT-01141

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00691

Voter packet for Patricia O’Brien

P-3824 SUMMIT-01249;

SUMMIT-01142

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00692

Voter packet for Everett Poe

P-3825 SUMMIT-01242;

SUMMIT-01143

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00695

Voter packet for Beverly Sanner

P-3826 SUMMIT-01244;

SUMMIT-01145

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00697

Voter packet for Phopshorell Simmons

P-3827 SUMMIT-01245;

SUMMIT-01146

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00701

Voter packet for Carmela Ventura

P-3828 SUMMIT-01218;

SUMMIT-01115

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00670

Voter packet for Sean Barker

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 273 of 289 PAGEID #: 31452

274

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3829 SUMMIT-01312;

SUMMIT-01276

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00736

Voter packet for Sandra Baumann

P-3830 SUMMIT-01311;

SUMMIT-01275

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00738

Voter packet for Raymond Bobick

P-3831 SUMMIT-01219;

SUMMIT-01116

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00673

Voter packet for Courtney Boyd

P-3832 SUMMIT-01220;

SUMMIT-01117

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for Diana Cochran

P-3833 SUMMIT-01221;

SUMMIT-01118

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00676

Voter packet for Carmen Cunningham

P-3834 SUMMIT-01306;

SUMMIT-01270

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00745

Voter packet for Anthony D’Angelo

P-3835 SUMMIT-01222;

SUMMIT-01119

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00676

Voter packet for Joseph Dannemiller

P-3836 SUMMIT-01313;

SUMMIT-01277

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00746

Voter packet for Sherri Davis

P-3837 SUMMIT-01223;

SUMMIT-01120

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00676

Voter packet for Richard DeBaun

P-3838 SUMMIT-01224;

SUMMIT-01121

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00677

Voter packet for Nina Eiseman

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 274 of 289 PAGEID #: 31453

275

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3839 SUMMIT-01308;

SUMMIT-01272

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00751

Voter packet for Robert Fleming

P-3840 SUMMIT-01225;

SUMMIT-01122

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00679

Voter packet for Laura Frederick

P-3841 SUMMIT-01305;

SUMMIT-01269

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00752

Voter packet for Donald Fulmer

P-3842 SUMMIT-01303;

SUMMIT-01267

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00753

Voter packet for Charles Glenn

P-3843 SUMMIT-01226;

SUMMIT-01123

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Monita Johnson

P-3844 SUMMIT-01227;

SUMMIT-01124

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Lisa Jones

P-3845 SUMMIT-01228;

SUMMIT-01125

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00685

Voter packet for Ernest Krutko

P-3846 SUMMIT-01310;

SUMMIT-01274

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00771

Voter packet for Norma Martinez-Bumpus

P-3847 SUMMIT-01300;

SUMMIT-01264

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00771

Voter packet for Andrea Mayfield

P-3848 SUMMIT-01246;

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00688

Voter packet for Danny McAnalley

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 275 of 289 PAGEID #: 31454

276

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3849 SUMMIT-01229;

SUMMIT-01127

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00688

Voter packet for Lisa McCraw

P-3850 SUMMIT-01304;

SUMMIT-01268

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00778

Voter packet for Kristen Neidert

P-3851 SUMMIT-01230;

SUMMIT-01128

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00691

Voter packet for Julia Payne

P-3852 SUMMIT-01307;

SUMMIT-01271

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00787

Voter packet for Dustin Ripley

P-3853 SUMMIT-01232;

SUMMIT-01129

SUMMIT-00828

Voter packet for Barbara Jean Rogers

P-3854 SUMMIT-01243;

SUMMIT-01144

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00696

Voter packet for Chad Schupbach

P-3855 SUMMIT-01232;

SUMMIT-01130

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00697

Voter packet for Steve Simms

P-3856 SUMMIT-01233;

SUMMIT-01131

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00699

Voter packet for Arlene Stopar

P-3857 SUMMIT-01234;

SUMMIT-01132

SUMMIT-00828;

SUMMIT-00700

Voter packet for Sherry Tigelman

P-3858 SUMMIT-01302;

SUMMIT-01266

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00800

Voter packet for Lieutenant Ulmer

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 276 of 289 PAGEID #: 31455

277

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3859 SUMMIT-01301;

SUMMIT-01265

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00806

Voter packet for Mary Worthy

P-3860 SUMMIT-01309;

SUMMIT-01273

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00807

Voter packet for Gary Zito

P-3861 SUMMIT-01183;

SUMMIT-01148

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00672

Voter packet for Margaret Bowles

P-3862 SUMMIT-01184;

SUMMIT-01149

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00673

Voter packet for Charles Brady

P-3863 SUMMIT-01185;

SUMMIT-01150

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for Joan Cefaratti

P-3864 SUMMIT-01188;

SUMMIT-01153

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00679

Voter packet for Katherine Ann Galko

P-3865 SUMMIT-01331;

SUMMIT-01282

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00753

Voter packet for Paul Gnuschke

P-3866 SUMMIT-01189;

SUMMIT-01154

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00680

Voter packet for Lillie Gooden

P-3867 SUMMIT-01327;

SUMMIT-01291

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00755;

SUMMIT-00753

Voter packet for June Gurnish

P-3868 SUMMIT-01326;

SUMMIT-01290

SUMMIT-00705;

Voter packet for Alice Harold

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 277 of 289 PAGEID #: 31456

278

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00757

P-3869 SUMMIT-01191;

SUMMIT-01156

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00683

Voter packet for Ruth Ann Hydeg

P-3870 SUMMIT-01192;

SUMMIT-01157

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00684

Voter packet for Genevieve Karder

P-3871 SUMMIT-01193;

SUMMIT-01158

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00685

Voter packet for Denise Kossick

P-3872 SUMMIT-01329;

SUMMIT-01293

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00768

Voter packet for Dorothy Lee

P-3873 SUMMIT-01194;

SUMMIT-01159

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00686

Voter packet for Judy Lee

P-3874 SUMMIT-01195;

SUMMIT-01160

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00686

Voter packet for Marcia Lewis

P-3875 SUMMIT-01198;

SUMMIT-01163

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00689

Voter packet for James Midock

P-3876 SUMMIT-01328;

SUMMIT-01292

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00778

Voter packet for Joanne Naragon

P-3877 SUMMIT-01202;

SUMMIT-01167

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00694

Voter packet for Cheryl Rowland

P-3878 SUMMIT-01203;

SUMMIT-01168

SUMMIT-00830;

Voter packet for Gayle Rowlett

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 278 of 289 PAGEID #: 31457

279

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00694

P-3879 SUMMIT-01330;

SUMMIT-01294

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00791

Voter packet for Terry Schmitt

P-3880 SUMMIT-01204;

SUMMIT-01169

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00696

Voter packet for Huaming Shen

P-3881 SUMMIT-01205;

SUMMIT-01170

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00697

Voter packet for Betsy Silver

P-3882 SUMMIT-01206;

SUMMIT-01171

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00700

Voter packet for Merna Thompson

P-3883 SUMMIT-01207;

SUMMIT-01172

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00701

Voter packet for Margaret Waickman

P-3884 SUMMIT-01208;

SUMMIT-01173

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00702

Voter packet for John Wengerd Sr.

P-3885 SUMMIT-01209;

SUMMIT-01174

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00702

Voter packet for Caroline Willett

P-3886 SUMMIT-01210;

SUMMIT-01175

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00670

Voter packet for Bruce Bailey

P-3887 SUMMIT-01211;

SUMMIT-01176

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00671

Voter packet for Mark Biss

P-3888 SUMMIT-01212;

SUMMIT-01177

SUMMIT-00829;

Voter packet for Mary Bissler

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 279 of 289 PAGEID #: 31458

280

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00671

P-3889 SUMMIT-01213;

SUMMIT-01178

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00672

Voter packet for Debrah Bowers

P-3890 SUMMIT-01214;

SUMMIT-01179

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00672

Voter packet for Larry Bowers

P-3891 SUMMIT-01316;

SUMMIT-01279

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00740

Voter packet for Richard Burroughs Jr.

P-3892 SUMMIT-01215;

SUMMIT-01180

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00674

Voter packet for Douglas Carson

P-3893 SUMMIT-01186;

SUMMIT-01151

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00675

Voter packet for James Colvin

P-3894 SUMMIT-01187;

SUMMIT-01152

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00676

Voter packet for David Lee Curt

P-3895 SUMMIT-01318;

SUMMIT-01281

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00752

Voter packet for Willard Frazer

P-3896 SUMMIT-01321;

SUMMIT-01285

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00753

Voter packet for Kenneth Germane

P-3897 SUMMIT-01320;

SUMMIT-01284

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00754

Voter packet for LaVerne Grabowski

P-3898 SUMMIT-01190;

SUMMIT-01155

SUMMIT-00829;

Voter packet for Khadijah Grant

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 280 of 289 PAGEID #: 31459

281

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00680

P-3899 SUMMIT-01322;

SUMMIT-01286

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00758

Voter packet for Phyllis Henry

P-3900 SUMMIT-01317;

SUMMIT-01280

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00764

Voter packet for Pauline Kennedy

P-3901 SUMMIT-01196;

SUMMIT-01161

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00686

Voter packet for Richard Linville

P-3902 SUMMIT-01197;

SUMMIT-01162

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00687

Voter packet for Damoen Luster

P-3903 SUMMIT-01325;

SUMMIT-01289

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00778

Voter packet for Jeffrey Nestor

P-3904 SUMMIT-01199;

SUMMIT-01164

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00690

Voter packet for Alberta Nichols

P-3905 SUMMIT-01200;

SUMMIT-01165

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00692

Voter packet for Allison Pringle

P-3906 SUMMIT-01323;

SUMMIT-01287

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00785

Voter packet for Carole Rector

P-3907 SUMMIT-01201;

SUMMIT-01166

SUMMIT-00830;

SUMMIT-00694

Voter packet for Tysha Ross

P-3908 SUMMIT-01324;

SUMMIT-01288

SUMMIT-00705;

Voter packet for Dominic Russo

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 281 of 289 PAGEID #: 31460

282

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

SUMMIT-00790

P-3909 SUMMIT-01216;

SUMMIT-01181

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00695

Voter packet for Michael Safron

P-3910 SUMMIT-01217;

SUMMIT-01182

SUMMIT-00829;

SUMMIT-00703

Voter packet for Dana Zak

P-3911 SUMMIT-01319;

SUMMIT-01283

SUMMIT-00705;

SUMMIT-00808

Voter packet for Joanne Zurawsky

P-3912 MIAMI-00180 Voter packet for Corine Doll (Couch)

P-3913 MIAMI-00181 Voter packet for Rose Schmidt

P-3914 MIAMI-00182 Voter packet for David Force

P-3915 MIAMI-00183 Voter packet for Shirley Sanders

P-3916 MIAMI-00184 Voter packet for Amanda Jessup (Sprankle)

P-3917 RICH-00073-

RICH-00209 Voting supporting records

P-3918 WYANDOT-00003-

WYANDOT-00006 Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Wyandot County

P-3919 WYANDOT-00007-

WYANDOT-00021 Provisional Ballot Detail Report for 2015

P-3920 WYANDOT-00022-

WYANDOT-00024 Voter packet for Jason Ohler

P-3921 WYANDOT-00025-

WYANDOT-00071 2014 absentee ballots and applications

P-3922 WYANDOT-00072-

WYANDOT-00151 2015 absentee ballots and applications

P-3923 11/19/15 WYANDOT-00001-

WYANDOT-00002 Wyandot County Board minutes

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 282 of 289 PAGEID #: 31461

283

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3924

2014 absentee ballot spreadsheet – Butler County

P-3925 11/4/14

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Butler County

P-3926 11/4/14

Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Butler County

P-3927 11/3/15

Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Butler County

P-3928 11/3/15

Official Certification for Provisional Ballots for Butler County

P-3929

Version 1 of absentee ballot envelope – Butler County

P-3930

Version 2 of absentee ballot envelope – Butler County

P-3931

Ballot forms with name field issues – Adams County

P-3932

Ballot forms with address field issues – Adams County

P-3933

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Adams County

P-3934

Ballot forms with DOB missing – Adams County

P-3935

Ballot forms with ID field mismatch – Adams County

P-3936

Ballot forms with multiple missing fields – Adams County

P-3937

Voter packet for Blanche York

P-3938

Ballot forms with missing fields – Paulding County

P-3939

Voter packet for Beulah Mundt

P-3940

Voter packet for Edward Cline

P-3941

Voter packet for Andrew Ludwig

P-3942

Voter packet for Delores Pease

P-3943 11/17/14

Board minutes – Carroll County

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 283 of 289 PAGEID #: 31462

284

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3944

Ballot forms with field issues – Carroll County

P-3945

Voter packet for Diane Binnig

P-3946

Ballot forms with address field issues – Carroll County

P-3947

Ballot forms with multiple field issues – Carroll County

P-3948

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Carroll County

P-3949

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Carroll County

P-3950

Voter packet for Sheila Fish

P-3951

Ballot forms with missing DOB fields – Carroll County

P-3952

Ballot forms with ID field issues – Carroll County

P-3953

Ballot forms with name field issues – Harrison County

P-3954

Ballot forms with address field issues – Harrison County

P-3955

Ballot forms with missing addresses and/or names – Harrison

County

P-3956

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Harrison County

P-3957

Ballot forms with missing DOB field – Harrison County

P-3958

Ballot forms with ID field issues – Harrison County

P-3959

Ballot forms with missing ID – Harrison County

P-3960

Ballot forms with multiple field issues – Harrison County

P-3961

Ballot forms with address field issues – Noble County

P-3962

Voter package for Brent Barnett

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 284 of 289 PAGEID #: 31463

285

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-3963

Voter package for Kathleen Billi

P-3964

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Noble County

P-3965

Ballot forms with ID field issues – Noble County

P-3966

Absentee ballot forms – Noble County

P-3967

Voter package for Matthew Drum

P-3968

Voter package for Judy Bolen

P-3969

Voter package for Teresa Garland

P-3970

Ballot forms with address field issues – Fayette County

P-3971

Ballot forms with DOB field issues – Fayette County

P-3972

Ballot forms with ID field issues – Fayette County

P-3973

Ballot forms with multiple issues – Fayette County

P-3974 11/16/15

Board minutes for Noble County

P-3975

Provisional affirmation forms – Noble County

P-3976

Voter package for Katherine Galko

P-3977

Voting Rights information

P-7000 11/4/14 Delaware co provisional ballot certification 2014

P-7001 11/4/14 Delaware co absentee ballot certification 2014

P-7002 11/3/15 Delaware co provisional ballot certification 2015

P-7003 11/3/15 Delaware co absentee ballot certification 2015

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 285 of 289 PAGEID #: 31464

286

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-7004 2014 general election absentee ballot summary report

P-7005 2014 general election provisional ballot summary report

P-7006 2015 general election absentee ballot summary report

P-7007 2015 general election provisional ballot summary report

P-7008 11/3/15 Certification for absentee ballots 11/3/15 general election for Lorain

Cty

P-7009 11/4/14 Official certification for absentee ballots for Lorain Cty

P-7010 7/2/14 Directive 2014-20

P-7011 11/3/15 Certification for provisional ballots 11/3/15 general election for

Lorain Cty

P-7012 11/4/14 Certification for provisional ballots 11/4/14 general election for

Lorain Cty

P-7013 Screen shots

P-7014 Screen shots

P-7015 Provisional & absentee ballot review policy 8/16/12

P-7016 Voter record for Anne Whitaker

P-7017 Voter packet for Calvin Arnold

P-7018 Voter packet for Robert Davis

P-7019 Voter packet for Jacqueline Sensabaugh

P-7020 Voter packet for Gunther Lahm

P-7021 Voter packet for Kristin Barley

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 286 of 289 PAGEID #: 31465

287

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-7022 Voter packet for Mary Lyons

P-7023 Voter packet for Robert Craft

P-7024 11/4/14 Official Certification for Absentee Ballots for Meigs County

P-7025 Absentee voter list – Meigs County

P-7026 Lucas County – 2014 AVB ID envelopes for challenged voters

P-7027 Lucas County – 2015 provisionals

P-7028 Lucas County – 2015 AVB ID envelopes for challenged voters

P-7029 Lucas County – 2014 provisionals

P-7030 Lucas County – 2015 apps and envelopes

P-7031 Lucas County – 2015 AVB applications for challenged voters

P-7032 Lucas County – 2014 AVB ID envelopes for challenged voters -

missing ID, ID did not match, wrong drivers license #

P-7033 Lucas County – 2015 challenge letters

P-7034 Plaintiff NEOCH’s third supplemental responses to Defendant

Secretary of State’s First Set of Interrogatories

P-7035 Voter packet for Jackie Toth

P-7036 Various Board minutes – Paulding County

P-7037 11/17/14 Official Certification of Results of November 4, 2014 Election –

Noble County

P-7038 11/16/15 Official Certification of Results of November 3, 2015 Election –

Noble County

P-7039 Voter packet for Shanee Nuckols

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 287 of 289 PAGEID #: 31466

288

Exh. Date Bates No(s) Description

P-7040 Voter packet for Ruth Thomas-Jackson

P-7041 Voter packet for Steven Hicks

P-7042 Voter packet for Wendell Stevenson

P-7043 11/6/14 Provisional Verification Procedures – Hamilton County

P-7044 Voter packet for Shannon Kelly

P-7045 2/6/12 “Achieving Validation: Barack Obama and Black Turnout in 2008”

from State Politics & Policy Quarterly

P-7046 Ohio Secretary of State 2014 Annual Report

P-7047 NEOCH: “How to Protect Your Vote!”

P-7048 NEOCH: Homeless voting articles

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 288 of 289 PAGEID #: 31467

289

Respectfully submitted,

/s/Subodh Chandra [per consent]

Subodh Chandra, Trial Attorney (0069233)

Donald P. Screen (044070)

Ashlie Case Sletvold (0079477)

Sandhya Gupta (0086052)

THE CHANDRA LAW FIRM, LLC

1265 W. 6th

St., Suite 400

Cleveland, OH 44113-1326

216.578.1700 Phone

216.578.1800 Fax

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

/s/ Caroline H. Gentry

Caroline H. Gentry (0066138)

Ana P. Crawford (0090581)

PORTER WRIGHT MORRIS & ARTHUR LLP

One South Main Street, Suite 1600

Dayton, OH 45402

937.449.6748 Phone

937.449.6820 Fax

[email protected]

[email protected]

Attorneys for Plaintiffs NEOCH and Columbus Coalition for the Homeless

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on this 6th

day of April 2016, I electronically filed the foregoing with

the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF system which will send notification to all counsel of

record.

/s/ Caroline H. Gentry

Caroline H. Gentry

DAYTON/658609v.1

Case: 2:06-cv-00896-ALM-TPK Doc #: 667 Filed: 04/06/16 Page: 289 of 289 PAGEID #: 31468