Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    1/67

    Preparedfor:TheForumforAgriculturalResearchinAfrica

    Preparedby:

    Mucemi

    Gakuru,

    Kristen

    Winters

    &

    Francois

    Stepman

    February2009

    Inventory of

    Innovative Farmer Advisory

    Services using ICTs

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    2/67

    1

    TableofContentsACKNOWLEDGEMENTS..........................................................................................................................4

    LISTOFACRONYMS...............................................................................................................................5

    FOREWORD.........................................................................................................................................10

    PART1:

    DISCUSSION

    1. INTRODUCTION..........................................................................................................................11

    2. OBJECTIVES................................................................................................................................12

    3. METHODOLOGY.........................................................................................................................12

    3.1VOICEINFORMATIONDELIVERYSERVICES..................................................................................................133.2RADIO:DIALUP(AGRICULTURALINFORMATIONONDEMAND)ANDREGULARRADIOBROADCASTS.........................133.3EXTENSIONSERVICESBASEDONMOBILEPHONEANDDATABASEMONITORING...................................................133.4ELEARNINGFORBASICSKILLS,AGRICULTURALEDUCATIONANDVIDEOBASEDAPPROACHES.................................14

    4. DEVELOPMENTS.........................................................................................................................14

    4.1MEASURINGTHESOCIALIMPACT

    .............................................................................................................

    14

    4.2MEASURINGTHEECONOMICIMPACT........................................................................................................16

    5. RESULTS.....................................................................................................................................18

    5.1THECAPACITYTOUSEINFORMATION.......................................................................................................185.2CHALLENGESTOUPSCALING....................................................................................................................19

    6. BUSINESSBENEFITS....................................................................................................................20

    7. CONCLUSIONS............................................................................................................................21

    PARTII:PROJECTSUMMARIES

    1. VOICEINFORMATIONDELIVERYSERVICES..................................................................................23

    ALLOINGENIER

    ....................................................................................................................................23

    BANANAINFORMATIONLINE..........................................................................................................................23NATIONALFARMERSINFORMATIONSERVICE(NAFIS)........................................................................................24T2M(TIMETOMARKET)...............................................................................................................................24

    2. RADIO:DIALUP(AGRICULTURALINFORMATIONONDEMAND)ANDREGULARRADIO

    BROADCASTS......................................................................................................................................25

    AFRICANFARMRADIORESEARCHINITIATIVE(AFRRI).........................................................................................25FAMILYALLIANCEFORDEVELOPMENTANDCOOPERATION(FADECO)...................................................................25FREEDOMFONE ....................................................................................................................................25RURALRADIORESOURCEPACKS(RRRPS).........................................................................................................26THEORGANICFARMER..................................................................................................................................26

    3.

    EXTENSION

    SERVICES

    BASED

    ON

    MOBILE

    PHONE

    AND

    DATABASE

    MONITORING

    ........................

    28

    AGRICULTURALMARKETINGANDINFORMATIONSYSTEMFORMALAWI(MISMALAWI)............................................28AGRICULTURALMARKETINGSYSTEMSDEVELOPMENTPROGRAMME(AMSDP).......................................................29AGRICULTURALRESEARCHEXTENSIONNETWORK(ARENET)................................................................................29ESOKO(FORMERLYTRADENET)........................................................................................................................30FARMERSINFORMATIONCOMMUNICATIONMANAGEMENT(FICOM)...................................................................31INFOPRIXBENIN:MARKETPRICESVIASMS.......................................................................................................31KENYAAGRICULTURALCOMMODITIESEXCHANGE(KACE)MISPROJECT................................................................32LIVESTOCKINFORMATIONNETWORKANDKNOWLEDGESYSTEM(LINKS)................................................................33

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    3/67

    2

    THEMAKULEKEPROJECT...............................................................................................................................34NETWORKOFMARKETINFORMATIONSYSTEMSANDTRADERS.............................................................................34ORGANIZATIONSOFWESTAFRICA(MISTOWA)...............................................................................................34REGIONALAGRICULTURALTRADEINFORMATIONNETWORK(RATIN).....................................................................35RSEAUDESSYSTMESD'INFORMATIONDESMARCHSENAFRIQUEDEL'OUEST/WESTAFRICANAGRICULTURALMARKETINFORMATIONSYSTEM NETWORK(RESIMAO/WAMISNET)............................................................................35

    SMSINFORMATIONSERVICE..........................................................................................................................

    36

    SYSTEMEDINFORMATIONDESMARCHESAGRICOLES(SIMA)..............................................................................36TRADEATHAND ....................................................................................................................................36XAMMARS ....................................................................................................................................37

    4. ELEARNINGFORBASICSKILLS,AGRICULTURALEDUCATIONANDVIDEOBASEDAPPROACHES...38

    AGRICULTURERESEARCHANDRURALINFORMATIONNETWORK(ARRIN)NDERETROUPE.........................................38AGROVISION ....................................................................................................................................38AGRICULTURALSECTORDEVELOPMENTPROGRAMME(ASDP)..............................................................................39COLLECTINGANDEXCHANGINGOFLOCALAGRICULTURALCONTENT(CELAC)..........................................................39CROMABU(CROPSMARKETINGBUREAU)PROJECT..........................................................................................40DRUMNET ....................................................................................................................................40EASTERNCORRIDORAGROMARKETINFORMATIONCENTRE(ECAMIC)..................................................................41

    ECOMMERCEFORNON

    TRADITIONALEXPORTS

    .................................................................................................

    41

    ECOMMERCEFORWOMEN............................................................................................................................42ENHANCINGACCESSTOAGRICULTURALINFORMATIONUSINGINFORMATIONANDCOMMUNICATIONTECHNOLOGIESINAPACDISTRICT(EAAI)..................................................................................................................................42FARMERSINTERNETCAF..............................................................................................................................43FIRSTMILEPROJECT ....................................................................................................................................43FRUILMA ....................................................................................................................................44GHANAAGRICULTURALINFORMATIONNETWORKSYSTEM(GAINS).......................................................................44ICTSUPPORTFORRURALAGRICULTURALLITERACY.............................................................................................45ICTFORSHEABUTTERPRODUCERS..................................................................................................................45ICT4DRESEARCHANDRESOURCECENTRE........................................................................................................46IMPROVINGAGRICULTURALPRODUCTIVITYANDMARKETSUCCESSOFETHIOPIANFARMERS(IMPS)............................46

    INFONETBIOVISIONFARMERINFORMATIONPLATFORM

    ......................................................................................

    47

    INFORMATIONNETWORKINMAND................................................................................................................48INTEGRATINGICTFORQUALITYASSURANCEANDMARKETING..............................................................................48JKAFOGULKAN:RURALINFORMATIONSYSTEMFORFARMERSINTHESIKASSOREGION.........................................49LINKINGLOCALLEARNERS(LLL)......................................................................................................................49MARKETINFORMATIONSERVICEFACILITYANDTRAINING.....................................................................................50MIPROKA(MAISOND'INFORMATIONETDEPROMOTIONDUKARITE).....................................................................50QUESTIONANDANSWERSERVICE....................................................................................................................51RURALINFORMATIONSYSTEM(RIS)................................................................................................................51RURALUNIVERSENETWORK(RUNETWORK).....................................................................................................52SENEKUNAFONIBULON.................................................................................................................................52SISSILIVALAKORI:IMPROVEMENTOFAGRICULTURERELATEDINFORMATIONCHANNELSTOFARMERSINTHERURALAREASISSILI ................................................................................................................................53

    STRENGTHENINGTHEAGRICULTUREINFORMATIONFLOWANDDISSEMINATIONSYSTEM............................................

    53

    SUSTAINET(SUSTAINABLEAGRICULTUREINFORMATIONNETWORK)EASTAFRICA.....................................................54TVKOODO:MARKETPRICEINFORMATIONSYSTEMUSINGWEBANDNATIONALTELEVISION.........................................55VIRTUALEXTENSIONANDRESEARCHCOMMUNICATIONNETWORK(VERCON)........................................................56

    REFERENCES........................................................................................................................................57

    APPENDIX1:PROJECTWEBSITES.........................................................................................................62

    APPENDIX2:OTHERSOURCESONMOBILESANDSOCIALMEDIA.........................................................64

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    4/67

    3

    APPENDIX3:FARAVIDEOINTERVIEWSONINNOVATIVEFARMERADVISORYSERVICES........................65

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    5/67

    4

    Acknowledgements

    The compilation of this inventory involved participation from many individuals andorganizations.

    FARAwould

    like

    to

    acknowledge

    the

    input

    from

    the

    RAILS

    ediscussion

    groups

    [Regional

    Agricultural Information and Learning Systems] and the KnowledgeManagement forDevelopment [KM4Dev] ediscussion groupwho alerted us to projects that could beusedintheinventory.

    FARA attempted to contact each organization to receive the most uptodateinformationon theproject.Wearegrateful toeveryorganization thatrespondedandprovided current information on the status of their project. Invaluable contributionscamefromtheInternationalInstituteforCommunicationsandDevelopment(IICD)andThe Technical Centre for Agriculture and Rural Development (CTA) who provided

    information

    about

    the

    many

    ICT

    projects

    they

    are

    involved

    in.

    Special

    thanks

    to

    the

    International Development Research Centre (IDRC), who are working on a studyentitled, ICTs and smallscale agriculture inAfrica: a scoping study andwere able toprovide a lot of valuable information about a number of ICT projects in Africa andsharedtheirdatabasewithFARA.

    The information for some projectswas obtained solely online and not confirmed byanyonewithintheorganization. Therefore,someofthefollowingentriesmaycontainoutdateddataorproject information:KACE,SIMA,VERCON,MakulekeMobilePhoneProject,GAINS, InfoPrixBenin,Agrovision, ICT4DResearchandResourceCentre,EAAI,CELAC,RESIMAO/WAMISNet,andprojects implementedbyor inpartnershipwiththe

    ZambianNational

    Farmers

    Union.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    6/67

    5

    ListofAcronyms

    AAAG Associationdaideetdappuiauxgroupements[AssociationofAidandSupportGroups](Mali)

    ABIP

    AgribusinessInformation

    Point

    ACT AfricanConservationTillageNetworkAFRRI AfricanFarmRadioResearchInitiativeAgSSIP AgriculturalServiceSectorInvestmentProgrammeAIC AgricultureInformationandResourceCentreAOPP Associationdesorganisationspaysannesprofessionnelles

    [TheAssociationofFarmersOrganizations]APC AssociationforProgressiveCommunicationsARC AgriculturalResearchCouncilARENET AgriculturalResearchandExtensionNetwork

    ARIS

    AgriculturalResearch

    Information

    Service

    ARRIN AgricultureResearchandRuralInformationNetworkASARECA AssociationforStrengtheningAgriculturalResearchinEasternand

    CentralAfricaASDI AgencyforthePromotionofSustainableInitiativesASDP AgriculturalSectorDevelopmentProgrammeATCOM AssociationofTelecommunicationsCompaniesinNigeriaATP AgribusinessandTradePromotionBLE BundesanstaltfrLandwirtschaftundErnhrung

    [FederalAgencyforAgricultureandFood](Germany)BMBF BundesministeriumfrBildungundForschung

    [MinistryofEducationandScience](Germany)BROSDI BusogaRuralOpenSourceDevelopmentInitiative(Uganda)CABI CentreforBiosciencesandAgricultureInternationalCARDI CaribbeanAgriculturalResearchandDevelopmentInstituteCELAC CollectingandExchangingofLocalAgriculturalContent(Uganda)CIAT InternationalCentreforTropicAgricultureCIDA CanadianInternationalDevelopmentAgencyCILC CommunityInformationLearningCentreCLCOP LocalCommitteesforCoordinationofFarmersOrganisations

    (Mali)

    CMS

    ContentManagement

    System

    CNOP Coordinationnationaledesorganisationspaysannes[NationalCoordinatingbodyofFarmersOrganizations](Mali)

    CNRIT CentreforNaturalResourceInformationTechnologyCONAFED LeComitnationalFemmeetDveloppement

    [NationalCommitteeforWomeninDevelopment]

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    7/67

    6

    COPROKAZAN CooprativedesProductricesdebeurredeKaritdeZantibougou[ZantibougouWomenSheaButterProducersCooperative](Mali)

    CORAID CatholicOrganizationforReliefandDevelopmentAidCRCR TheRegionalCommitteeforCoordinationofRuralPeople(Mali)

    CROMABU

    CropsMarketing

    Bureau

    (Tanzania)

    CSIRINSTI TheInstituteforScientificandTechnologicalInformationoftheCouncilforScientificandIndustrialResearch(Ghana)

    CTA TechnicalCentreforAgriculturalandRuralCooperation(theNetherlands)

    DATIC DistrictAgriculturalTrainingandInformationCentre(Uganda)DFID UKDepartmentforInternationalDevelopmentECAMIC EasternCorridorAgromarketInformationCentre(Ghana)ECOWAS EconomicCommunityofWestAfricanStatesEDDI EducationDevelopmentandDemocracyInitiativeFABEMA FdrationdesOrganisationsdeBaseduMandn

    [FederationofCommunitybasedOrganizationsofMandn](Mali)FADECO FamilyAllianceforDevelopmentandCooperation(Tanzania)FARA ForumforAgriculturalResearchinAfricaFEPPASI FdrationProvincialedesProducteursAgricolesdelaSissili

    [FarmersFederationFeppasi](BurkinaFaso)FIAB FederationNationaledesIndustriesdel'AgroAlimentairedu

    BurkinaFaso[TheFederationofAgroIndustrialEnterprisesofBurkinaFaso]

    FiBL ForschungsinstitutfrbiologischenLandbau[ResearchInstituteofOrganicAgriculture](Switzerland)

    FOSS

    FreeOpen

    Source

    Software

    GAINS GhanaAgriculturalInformationNetworkSystemGAP GoodAgriculturalPracticeGPS GlobalPositioningSystemGTZ DeutscheGesellschaftfrTechnischeZusammenarbeit

    [GermanCentreforTechnicalCooperation]HIVOS HumanistInstituteforCooperationwithDevelopingCountriesIABER InstitutAfricaindeBioEconomieRurale

    [AfricanInstituteofRuralBioEconomy](BurkinaFaso)ICT InformationCommunicationsTechnology

    ICTARD

    Information

    and

    Communication

    and

    Technologies

    for

    African

    RuralDevelopmentzICT4D InformationCommunicationsTechnologyforDevelopmentIDEAA InitiativeforDevelopmentandEquityinAfricanAgriculture

    (Malawi)IDRC InternationalDevelopmentResearchCentre(Canada)IER InstituteforAgriculturalResearch(Mali)IFAD InternationalFundforAgriculturalDevelopment

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    8/67

    7

    IFDC InternationalCentreforSoilFertilityandAgriculturalDevelopment

    IMARK InformationManagementResourceKitIMPS ImprovingAgriculturalProductivityandMarketSuccessof

    EthiopianFarmers

    IICD

    InternationalInstitute

    for

    Communications

    and

    Development

    IITA InternationalInstituteforTropicalAgricultureILRI InternationalLivestockResearchInstituteINRAB l'InstitutNationaldesRecherchesAgricolesduBnin

    [NationalAgriculturalResearchInstituteofBenin]ISFH InsectScienceforFoodandHealthISG InternationalSupportGroupIVR InteractiveVoiceResponseJAS JamaicaAgriculturalSocietyKACE KenyaAgriculturalCommoditiesExchangeKARI KenyaAgricultureResearchInstituteKENDAT KenyaNetworkforDisseminationofAgriculturalTechnologiesKENFAP KenyaNationalFederationofAgriculturalProducersKHDP KenyaHorticulturalDevelopmentProjectLAN LocalAreaNetworkLED LiechetensteinDevelopmentServiceLEWS LivestockEarlyWarningSystemLINKS LivestockInformationNetworkandKnowledgeSystemLLL LinkingLocalLearnersLLSTI LocalSpeechTechnologyInitiativeLMIS LivestockMarketingInformationSystem

    MACE

    MalawiAgriculture

    Commodity

    Exchange

    MAPRONET MarketAccessPromotionNetwork(Ghana)MCSP MultiChannelServicePlatformMIC MarketInformationCentreMIP MarketInformationPointMIPROKA Maisond'InformationetdePromotionduKarit

    [InformationCentreforthePromotionofShea](BurkinaFaso)MIS MarketInformationServiceMISTOWA NetworkofMarketInformationSystemsandTraders

    OrganizationsofWestAfrica

    MOA

    Ministry

    of

    Agriculture

    MoARD EthiopianMinistryofAgricultureandRuralDevelopmentNAADS NationalAgriculturalAdvisoryServices(Uganda)NAFIRRI NationalFisheriesResourcesResearchInstituteNAFIS NationalFarmersInformationService(Kenya)NAIS NationalAgriculturalInformationServices(Zambia)NALEP NationalAgricultureandLivestockExtensionProgramme(Kenya)NARO NationalAgriculturalResearchOrganization(Uganda)

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    9/67

    8

    NGO NongovernmentalOrganizationNICT NewInformationCommunicationTechnologyONSA NationalBureauforFoodSecurity(Benin)OPPAZ OrganicProducersandProcessorsAssociationofZambiaPDA PersonalDigitalAssistant

    PELUMTZ

    Participatory

    Ecological

    Land

    Use

    Management

    Tanzania

    PU PastoralUnitQASVS QuestionandAnswerVoucherSystemRAILS RegionalAgriculturalInformationandLearningSystemsRATES RegionalAgriculturalTradeExpansionSupportProgramRATIN RegionalAgriculturalTradeInformationNetworkRECOTIS RegionalCommodityTradeandInformationSystem(Kenya)RESIMAO/WAMIS RseaudesSystmesd'InformationdesMarchsenAfriquede

    l'Ouest/WestAfricanAgriculturalMarketInformationSystemsNetwork

    RNE GermanCouncilforSustainableDevelopmentRRRP RuralRadioResourcePackRUNetwork RuralUniverseNetworkSAILD ServicedAppuiauxInitiativesLocalesdeDveloppement

    [SupportOfficeforLocalDevelopmentInitiatives](Cameroon)SATNET SustainableAgriculturalTrainersNetworkSEND SocialEnterpriseDevelopmentFoundationofWestAfricaSFSA SyngentaFoundationforSustainableAgricultureSHEMP SmallholderEnterpriseandMarketingProgrammeSIDA SwedishInternationalDevelopmentAgencySIMA SystmedInformationdesMarchsAgricoles

    [AgricultureMarket

    Information

    System]

    (Niger)

    SIMB SystmedInformationdesMarchsduBtail[LivestockMarketInformationSystem](Niger)

    SMS ShortMessagingServiceSNV TheNetherlandsDevelopmentOrganizationSTCP SustainableTreeCropProgrammeTCP TechnicalCooperationProgrammeTTS TexttoSpeechUCE UgandanCommodityExchangeUNCTAD UnitedNationsConferenceonTradeandDevelopment

    UNDP

    United

    National

    Development

    Programme

    UNESCO UnitedNationalEconomicandSocialCommunityUNFFE UgandaNationalFarmersFederationUSAID UnitedStatesAgencyforInternationalDevelopmentVEDCO VolunteerEffortsforDevelopmentConcernsVERCON VirtualExtensionandResearchCommunicationNetwork(Egypt)VoIP VoiceoverInternetProtocolVSAT VerySmallApertureTechnology

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    10/67

    9

    WADEP WomenandDevelopmentProject(Uganda)WAN WideAreaNetworkWOCAT WorldOverviewofConservationApproachesandTechnologiesWOUGNET WomenofUgandaNetworkWUSC WorldUniversityServiceofCanada

    ZADI

    TheGerman

    Centre

    for

    Documentation

    and

    Information

    for

    AgricultureZARDI ZonalAgriculturalResearchandDevelopmentInstituteZARI ZambiaAgriculturalResearchInstituteZNBC ZambiaNationalBroadcastingCorporationZNFU ZambiaNationalFarmersUnion

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    11/67

    10

    Foreword

    Agriculturalinformaticsisanewconceptthathasarisenfollowingtherapiddevelopmentininformationandcommunicationtechnologies(ICTs),andofthe

    internet.Referred

    to

    as

    eagriculture,

    agricultural

    informatics

    is

    an

    emerging

    field

    which

    combinestheadvancesinagriculturalinformatics,agriculturaldevelopmentandentrepreneurshiptoprovidebetteragriculturalservices,enhancedtechnologydissemination,andinformationdeliverythroughtheadvancesinICTandtheinternet.TheeAgricultureconcept,however,goesbeyondtechnology,totheintegrationofknowledgeandculture,aimedatimprovingcommunicationandlearningprocessesamongrelevantactorsinagricultureatdifferentlevelsi.e.locally,regionallyandglobally.

    Forthepast10years,therehasbeenaremarkableprogressintheuseofICTinAfrican

    agriculture,

    especially

    in

    the

    area

    of

    farmers

    access

    to

    market

    information.

    Various

    projectshavebeendevelopedthatintegrateICTsintothedisseminationofagriculturalinformationtofarmers.FarmersInformationServicesatboththenationalandregionallevelareapromisingnewfieldofresearchandapplicationintheemergingfieldofeagriculture.

    This Inventory of Innovative Farmer Advisory Services (66 pages) is the result of anonlineconsultationwiththeFARARegionalAgriculturalInformation&LearningSystem(RAILS) held during the month of October 2008 + desk study. It is an attempt todocumentallknowninnovativefarmeradvisoryservicesorsystems,currentlyindesign,inexistenceorrecentlycompletedinAfrica.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    12/67

    11

    1. IntroductionTherearenocrosscuttinginitiativestolearnaboutthisnewmasstechnologywhichisonly

    adventitiouslybeing

    incorporated

    into

    development

    projectsor

    to

    identify

    its

    transformativepossibilities.WhereisthenecessaryMOTForceaMobileOpportunitiesTaskForcetomatchtheearlierDOTForcewithoutwhichmobilescontributiontodevelopmentwillbelefttothemarket,tochance,orjustplainleftbehind? RichardHeeks,professorandchairoftheDevelopmentInformaticsDepartmentattheUniversityofManchester,UK.

    ThroughoutAfrica, ICTshavebecome increasingly integrated intothedisseminationofinformation to farmers. For decades traditional forms of ICTs have become moreprevalent inadvisoryserviceprovision.RadioandTVprogrammes featureagriculturalinformation.Ruraltelecentresprovideinformationoneducation,agriculturalandhealthissuesandequip ruralcitizenswith skillsonhow tousecomputersandprovidebasic

    literacy.

    National

    ministries

    of

    agriculture

    have

    attempted

    to

    integrate

    ICTs

    into

    the

    delivery of information and have established district information centres providingagriculturalinformation.ManyNGOsandresearchorganizationshavealsoattemptedtofacilitatetechnologytransferintheagriculturalsector.

    Currently,most farmers information isprovidedeitherbyextensionworkers,throughlibrariesorviawebsites.Thenumberofextensionworkershasbeengoingdownwhilethatoffarmershasbeengrowing,hencetheneedforinnovativeinformationsystemstoaddressthisgap.ThedevelopmentoftheNationalFarmersInformationServiceNAFIS[www.nafis.go.ke],avoicebasedservicewasonesuch initiative.Mostother initiativesare webbased such as INFONET [www.infonetbiovision.org], a webbased service

    promotingorganic

    farming

    which

    is

    supplemented

    by

    The

    Organic

    Farmer

    publication.

    Seeking information fromtheseandotherplatformsbecomesanoneroustask forthefarmersas itentailsploughingthroughmanypublicationsorsurfinga largenumberofwebpages. Furthermore, for the illiterate farmer thisbecomes impossible right fromtheonset.WebbasedsolutionsalsobringchallengesbecauseinternetinfrastructureinAfrica is stillvery sparse.Nevertheless, theseareveryuseful resourcesandall that isneededistoprovideaneasywayforthefarmerstonavigatethem.

    Withthewidespreaduseofmobilephones,voiceandSMSsolutionsshouldfindmoreuseastheyoffereasyaccessibility.However,theyalsofacethefollowingchallenges:the

    SMScarries

    only

    alimited

    amount

    of

    information

    and

    requires

    abasic

    level

    of

    literacy.

    Voicebasedsolutionsarecomplicatedtodevelopfortheyrequiremachinestoproducenatural speech, or in technical terms, good speech synthesis. They also do not offerdetailedinformationsuchaspictorialillustrationsasinwebsolutions.Nonetheless,thevoice solution is still by far themostpromising platform for the farmer as it canbecustomised for language, is readilyaccessibleandverynatural,as itentailsusing themobilephonethroughdirectresponsestospecificquestions.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    13/67

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    14/67

    13

    toagricultureororganizationsorprojectsthatfocusexclusivelyonthedevelopmentoflinkageswithinputagencies,creditorganizationsandmarketsthroughtheuseofICTs.

    Entries include projects using ICT solutions or implementing ICTbased activities,institutions/groups providing services using ICTs as well as ICT solutions software

    providers,both

    at

    the

    national

    and

    regional

    level.

    While many of the entries are projects with a definitive beginning and end dateproviding one or two services, others are national or regional information systemsproviding many agricultural services using ICTs. Some projects are therefore mostdifficult to categorize but for the purposes of this research, the projects have beendividedintofourcategories:

    3.1 VoiceInformationDeliveryServices

    This includes a telephonebased informationdelivery service thatprovides advice onfarmingmethodsandmarketaccesstoimprovethelivesofruralfarmingcommunities.Answerstomanyoftheseproblemsmaywellbeontheinternetbutwithconnectivity,literacy and language barriers, this is way beyond the reach of the vast majority offarmers. Some use callin centres for agricultural extension support. More complexvoicetechnologyusesasimpletelephonecommunityfixedphoneormobileasthemediumof information exchangewhile sophisticated communication technology andcomputingapplicationshavebeenconfiguredatthebackendplatformfortheprovisionof the requisite information service.Thesolution iscomprisedofaunifiedmessagingplatformincorporatingInteractiveVoiceResponse(IVR)functionality,integratedwithaCustomerRelationshipManagementapplicationtosupportintegratedcallhandlingand

    managementof

    avery

    large

    audio

    database.

    3.2 Radio:dialup(agriculturalinformationondemand)andregularradiobroadcasts

    This includes regular radiobroadcasts thatprovidemarketpricesorotheragriculturalinformation anddialup radio that feature a seriesof short segment audioprogramsthatprovide smallscale farmers telephoneaccess to relevant information throughanautomatedvoicesystem.Thisradiosystem isan informationhubfeaturingaregularlyupdated, diversemenu of prerecorded agricultural content. For the purpose of thisinventorywehaveonlykeptthoseprojectswhichwethinkareinnovativeinsomeway

    such

    as

    allowing

    farmers

    to

    ask

    questions

    through

    SMS,

    or

    broadcasting

    information

    gatheredthroughquestionandanswervouchersorotherinnovativemeans.

    3.3 Extensionservicesbasedonmobilephoneanddatabasemonitoring

    This is a media channel that allows anyone anywhere to affordably share marketinformationviamobilesorthroughthe internet.Bytrackingactivitiesandprofiles,theservice becomes a crucial profiling and business monitoring tool, as well as an

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    15/67

    14

    advertising medium. By focussing on profiling, this service can minimize risk intransactions, offer some brokerage services, and provide a revenue stream bypermitting advertising and data mining. To date, most licensees have been donorprojects.

    3.4elearning

    for

    basic

    skills,

    agricultural

    education

    and

    video

    based

    approaches

    Thiscategorycoverstheprovisionof informationand learningmaterialforagriculturalskills.Thespecificvideobasedapproachhasseveralimportantadvantagestotraditionalformsofagriculturalcontent,whicharetypicallynotinthelocallanguage,areintendedfora literateaudience,useexpertterminology, lackgrassroots levelpracticalities,andremaininaccessibleinaseaofscatteredmedia.

    The inventory lists [4] projects under category 1; [5] projects under category 2; [16]projectsundercategory3;and[35]projectsundercategory4.ThecountrieswhicharerepresentedareBenin[1];BurkinaFaso[3];Cameroon[1];Egypt[1];Ethiopia[2];Ghana[6];Kenya[9];Malawi[1];Mali[5];Niger[1];Nigeria[1];Senegal[2];SouthAfrica[1];Tanzania[7];Uganda[9];Zambia[4];Zimbabwe[1]andprojectsoperatinginmorethan3countries[10].

    ToidentifyinnovativeFarmerAdvisoryServicesusingICTwefinetunedtheconceptualunderstandingofthesocialimpactofthoseservicesandtheirpossibleeconomicimpact.TheresultinginventoryindicatesthatthemajorityoftheinitiativesaroundruralICTandtheuseofmobile telephony inagricultureneedaspecificcapacity touse informationandhighlightsthechallengestoupscalethoseinitiatives.

    4. Developments4.1 MeasuringtheSocialImpact

    Monitoring the impactof ruralmobile telephony in the agricultural sector requires abetter understanding of the farmers context for the adoption and adaptation of aninnovativeinformationtool.Therearemany initiativesonICTsandsmallscalefarmersinAfrica.However,thesetend tobeuncoordinated,and informationonthedifferentinitiativesisnoteasilyaccessible,letaloneinformationontheirimpacts.

    Thenatureofmobile technologydevelopment for farmers is itselfhighly contentiousand requires careful research anddevelopment tomake it right, especiallywhen itcomestolivelihoodsimprovementandpovertyreductioninSubSaharaAfrica.Althoughit is recognized that the uptake of promising information technologies like ruraltelephony can be influenced greatly by the availability and/or functioning of inputsupply, credit systems, landtenure arrangements, organization of marketing,distributionofbenefits,etc., such socialorganizationalphenomenahavemostlybeenconsideredasconditionsthathamperorenhanceadaptationofruraltelephony.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    16/67

    15

    Whentryingtomeasurethe impactofruraltelephonythequestion isthusnotjusttoseektodevelopanappropriate informationdisseminationtechnologybutalsotoaltertheboundariesandconditionsthataffectthespaceforchange.Resourcepoorfarmersinhighriskanddiverse,rainfedenvironmentsfaceverysmallwindowsofopportunity

    forinnovation.

    The

    mobile

    phone

    projects

    as

    listed

    in

    the

    FARA

    inventory

    often

    create

    special conditions to enable and stimulate farmers to utilize the recommendedtechnologies(f.i.QuestionsandAnswerServicesQASbasedon textmessages).Suchspecialconditionsmight includeaccess to subsidized inputs,guaranteedmarketingofthesurplusgenerated,thecreationofspecialcreditschemes, theavailabilityofhighlyqualifiedstafforinthecaseofQAS,accurateandtimelyinformation.

    But,equallyinvariably,suchprojects leavefewtracesafterthespecialconditionshavebeen withdrawn. Replicability of the development gains is a key issue. The bestguaranteeforsuchreplicabilityistoensurethatnewcommunicationtechnologiesworkwithintheprevailingphysical,socioeconomic,culturalandinstitutionalconditionsand,ifnecessary,tobroadenthoseconditions.Thisapproachrequiresspecialprocedurestoadoptanewcommunicationtoolonthebasisofdecisionmakingthatisinformedbyanunderstandingofthefarmerscontext.

    A good example is the adoption of mobile phone conferencing. Mary Nyakira ofBROSDI/CELAC Uganda explained during the MobileActive 2008 conference how themobile phone conferencing works and how farmers are enjoying it. It not onlycontributestoaparticularformofdemocracyandtransparencybutfarmerslikehavinggroup discussions around a mobile phone with the loudspeaker facility on. Theextensionworker isbeepedwhenthegroupoffarmers isreadytostartthetraining

    session.The

    discussions

    are

    afollow

    up

    on

    aprevious

    field

    visit.

    But

    this

    time

    the

    extensionworkergivesadviceoutofhis/heroffice.Takingintoaccounttheconsiderabledistancesandthefactthatextensionworkerscannotaffordvisitingonaweeklybasisaparticulargroupoffarmers,mobilephoneconferencingishavingatremendousimpact.

    Themajorityoffarmersarenotthatwellorganized,havenopoliticalcloutandcannotexert effective demand on agricultural information services. Despite the number ofMarket Information Prices Services using mobile phone for price informationdissemination themarketprices information remainoftennot freelyavailableso thatpricesaresetlocallyandratherarbitrarilygiventheactualrelativescarcity.Moreoften

    than

    not,

    market

    prices

    are

    determined

    by

    the

    vagaries

    of

    weather,

    transport,

    monopolistictraders,andsoforth.

    Rural telephony technologies can only work if they fit within the small windows ofopportunity thatAfrican smallscale family farmers face.Even if the farmer isusingaspecificserviceforthefirsttime,oftenduetocuriosity,nexttimehewillnotsubscribetoitiftheserviceofferedisnotvaluable.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    17/67

    16

    4.2 MeasuringtheEconomicImpact

    The principal challenge confronting governments and the international developmentcommunity is to ensure that smallholder farmers benefit from commercialization inagriculture by participating in the market. Increased commercialization shifts farm

    householdsaway

    from

    traditional

    self

    sufficiency

    goals

    and

    toward

    profit

    and

    income

    orienteddecisionmaking.

    Interventions aimed at reducing transaction costswould encourage increased farmerparticipationincompetitivemarketstomeetthebroaderpovertyreductionobjectives.In economic terms, the role of agricultural informatics is to reduce the informationsearchcostsintheagriculturevaluechainandtolinkthedecisiontogrowwiththatoftosell.Thefinalobjective isreducingtotaltransactioncoststo increasethe incentivesfor smallholder farmers toparticipate in commercial agriculture asopposed tobeingstuckinsubsistencefarming.

    The logical starting point in understanding the total informationrelated transactioncostsfacedbythefarmeristounderstandthedemandforinformationateachpointofexchange by disaggregating the agricultural value chain to a series of activities. Asimplifyingassumption is that therelevant information isavailable insome format,asopposedtotheextremecaseofmissinginformation.

    Whenwedisaggregatestagesofinformationneedsandsearchesthebreakdownlooksasfollows.Thefarmerhasinformationneedsandsearchesforinformationrelatedto6stages:(1)Deciding,(2)Seeding,(3)PreparingandPlanting,(4)Growing,(5)Harvesting,packingandstoring,and(6)Selling[deSilvaandRatnadiwakara,2008].

    The first stage is Deciding.This is the stagewhere farmersdecideonwhat crop togrow, how much land to allocate for each crop and also arrange working capitalfinancing.ThesecondstageisSeeding.Thisiswhenfarmerseitherpurchaseseedsorprepare theirown seedsbasedon the crop theyhave earlierdecided to grow. Theymight also prepare a seed bed during this stage. The third stage is Preparing andplanting.Duringthisstage,farmerspreparethelandusingownorhiredlabourorlandpreparationmachineryandsubsequentlyplanttheseeds.Theforthstage isGrowingwhere application of water, fertilizer and pesticides take place. The fifth stage isHarvesting, packing and storing.During this stage, farmers have to find labour for

    harvesting

    and

    locations

    for

    storage,

    if

    at

    all.

    Packing,

    if

    at

    all,

    takes

    place

    during

    this

    stage.ThefinalandsixthstageisSelling.Inthisstage[some]farmerscheckpricesatthe various markets and find a method of transporting the packed produce to theselectedmarkettosell.

    An analysisof the information searchofagroupof smallholder farmers inSri Lanka,growing tomatoes, onions, brinjals and chilies, demonstrated that the information

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    18/67

    17

    searchcostsamountto11.0percentofthetotalcostsincurredbythefarmersinthesixstageprocess.

    Whenthetotalinformationsearchcostsindifferentstagesoftheagriculturalvalue chainare considered,we find that thehighestpercentageofcostof

    informationis

    incurred

    during

    the

    growth

    stage,

    followed

    by

    the

    decision

    stageandsellingstage.Intermsofproportionofcostofinformationineachstage intheagriculturalvaluechain,thedecisionstagecomesfirstwiththecostofinformationsearchtototalcostratiobeing3:1,followedbygrowingstagewitharatioof1:4andthesellingstagewitharatioof1:5.Thereasonfor the unusually high percentage of information search costs during thegrowing stage [53%] we found is caused by the idiosyncratic governmentprocedure on fertilizer subsidy to farmers in that area. We expect thegrowing stage to be less pertinent in countries without such inefficientfertilizer subsidypoliciesandhence it isnotanalyzed further [deSilvaandRatnadiwakara,2008].

    TheabsenceofeffectivemarketingchainsplaguesAfrica.Itaffectsthepossibleimpactinformationandtheuseofmobilephonescanhave.Amarketingchaincanbeseenasamultistakeholdernetworkthatishighlyintegratedandsharesacommonperspectiveorgoal: to deliver a product as cheaply and efficiently as possible to the consumer.Increasing the efficiency of the whole chain the purpose of providing agriculturalinformationisintheinterestofallstakeholders,whethertheyarefarmers,processorstransporters,retailersorothers.Threatofcompetitionleadschainpartnerstobehighlyawareofthecompetitivepositionoftheirchainvisvisothers.Thisawarenessleadsto chain thinking.Creating such chainawareness isabig challenge inAfrica.Three

    examplessuffice.

    InBenin,alargenumberofunproductivepeople eatfromtheexportearningsof the cotton produced by small farmers. Benin refuses to sell effective butcheaperpesticides thatare available and that could reduce farmerspesticidecostssubstantially,simplybecausethatwouldcutthesalesmensprofit.

    InGhana,theCocoaMarketingBoardisdirectlyinvolvedinpesticideproduction.They have so far not cooperated in the certification of organic cocoa whichwouldunderminetherationaleformasssprayingofsyntheticchemicals.

    AwomanfarmerinUgandarefusedtotelltheotherfarmerswhatshelearnedatacheese

    making

    workshop

    in

    Italy

    (!).

    The

    extension

    worker

    found

    the

    information on the internet and gave some technical cheesemaking trainingwithmobilephoneconferencing followup.The chainawareness:Only largequantitiesofcheesejustifyatruckofcheesetoKampalamadethewomanjointherestofthegroup.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    19/67

    18

    5. ResultsThe many initiatives that provide farmers with information are largely institutionalbased,productspecificaswellasplatformspecific.Informationisprovidedbydifferentorganisations,eachofferinga specificproduct, forexample forbananagrowers,ona

    givenplatform,

    has

    only

    web

    access

    and

    often

    is

    in

    the

    English

    language.

    Coupled

    with

    thesechallenges,theAfricanfarmer isfacedwithpoor infrastructure, low literacyandlimited language use. Such amodel of informationdelivery has proved tobe largelyineffective. A comprehensive model is needed to address the limitations of existingmethods, by offering a holistic, onestopshop information service on a variety ofcarefully integrated platforms. Furthermore, a model is needed that implementsfarmersfeedback,aresourcethatisusedtofurtherenhanceinformationdelivery.

    In agriculture and rural development, the prevalence of uneven distribution ofknowledge isbeing increasingly recognized.Mere information in the form of flowof

    messages

    may

    not

    be

    able

    to

    address

    the

    problem.

    Knowledge

    as

    the

    creative

    result

    of

    a

    flowofmessagesanchoredonthecommitmentandbeliefsoftheactorsinvolvedintheprocessandresultinginhumanactionisneeded.Theenvironmentinwhichknowledgeis built capacity building and empowerment processes, social mobilization andorganization areimportantfactorswhicharetobetakenintoconsideration.

    5.1 TheCapacitytoUseInformation

    The Brazilian pedagogue Paolo Freire argued some 35 years ago for the need fordialogues and discourses among learners to understand the world instead of mereunderstandingofwords.Similarly,intheprocessofknowledgemanagement,dialogues

    anddiscourses

    among

    the

    rural

    community

    are

    essential.

    Modern

    ICT,

    if

    properly

    defined,canhelptobroadenthecanvassfordialoguesanddiscoursesamongtheruralcommunity.

    TheinventoryshowshowthemajorityoftheinitiativesaroundruralICTandtheuseofmobile telephony in agriculture isdonoror at leastexternaldriven.As long as theseinitiativesareconsideredaspilotorsubmittedtoaproofofconceptinceptionphase,their impact is limited.Theupscaleof these initiativeswillcreatenewchallenges.Themore farmersare targeted, themore the contentwillbequestionedby the researchcommunity and other stakeholders in the field of agriculture. Every agricultural

    informationprovider

    will

    want

    to

    have

    its

    content

    set

    the

    standard

    for

    anational

    service.Butdifferentrolescanbeplayedbydifferentactors.

    Providing weather forecasts on a daily basis is information. The generic data isgenerated fromelsewhereand isgiventotheruralcommunitythroughvariousmediasuch as radio, television,newspaper, rural telecentres, andmobilephone alerts. Therural community does not get involved in the generation, validation, evaluation,

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    20/67

    19

    understanding and appreciation of this information. In such a take it or leave itapproach,theruralcommunityremainsamerepassiveobserver.

    Thehorizontaltransferofknowledgehasablendedlearningprocess.Learningbydoing,learning through participatory research, evaluation and knowledge management, CD

    andintranet

    based

    learning,

    face

    to

    face

    interactions,

    etc.

    are

    playing

    acrucial

    role

    in

    thecapacitybuildingprocess.

    Therewillneverbeonefitforallsystem.Differentplatformsareneededdependingonthecontent,thelevelofliteracy,andthespecificinformationneeds.

    Thebasicinformationneedsforfarmersaremarketinformationprices,weatherforecasts,transportfacilitiesandinformationonstoragefacilities.Thisfirsttypeofdata is,althoughvitalandofdirectconcern to the farmer,quicklyoutdatedandchangesconstantly.

    The

    second

    level

    of

    information

    needs

    is

    about

    crop

    and

    cattle

    diseases,

    fertilizers, etc. The inventory indicates that several such information serviceshave been developed in order to provide information in a standard way i.e.questionandanswersservices.Themostattractive formsofquestionandanswers serviceareprobably thoseserviceswhichareaudioorvoicebasedbecausetheyovercomethe limitationsof textbased platforms. In some cases, audio files are made accessible tofarmersthroughtheuseofmobilephones(Kenya,UgandaandZimbabwe).Buttheseinitiativeshavejuststarted(NAFIS,Kenya)orhaveyettobegin(Kubatana,Zimbabwe). The CELAC/BROSDI project of Uganda includes information andinnovativetechniquesdirectlygeneratedbythefarmersthemselves.

    Thethirdlevelismorecontextandlocalspecificandrequiresthedirectinterfacebetweentheextensionworkerandthefarmer.

    The evolution of an active utilizer constituency is the basic premise for a strongextension framework.Thecoreofextension is inhelpingpeoplemakebetterchoicesthroughthesupplyofinformationandinenhancementofpeoplescapacitiestoprocesssuch information and act on it, thereby reducing the transaction costs involved inpursinglivelihoodoptions.

    5.2 ChallengestoUpscaling

    Thedevelopmentof activeutilizer constituency andhorizontal transferof knowledgehavebecomecrucialparticularlywhenviewed in thecontextofdecliningresources informalgovernmentalextensionagencies,increasingdemandfromtheruralsectorsandnew challenges like climate adaptation, biotechnology and farmer innovationtechniques. Formalextensionwouldbecomefruitfulifitbecomesafacilitatingprocessforactiveutilizerconstituencyandcommunityknowledgemanagement,ratherthanifitattempts direct interventions and implementations. Such a framework requires a

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    21/67

    20

    capacity building process among the officials of the formal extension system ininnovative farmer information systems,building the structures, shaping the functionsandrefiningtheprocessthroughmobilization,organization,technologyincubationandsystemsmanagement.

    Innovativeinformation

    initiatives

    invite

    farmers

    to

    use

    and

    share

    their

    traditional

    knowledgeusingmodern ICT.Ruralcommunityandscientistshavecome together forweather forecasting, blending frontier science and traditional knowledge whichinfluence the decisionmaking process. When plenty of farmers are reached by aparticular farmer information provider the service may become controversial if noconsensuswasreachedpriortotheupscaleaboutthecontentwithalargecommunityofagriculturalandruralactors.

    Asecondchallengefortheupscaleof(thepresentlymainlypilot)ICTandmobilephoneprojectswillbe thenecessaryalliancewithamobilephone company.Severalmobilephoneproviderscompeteforthislastfrontiermarket.Also,politicianschallengethemajor mobile phone providers: Your competitor reaches the rural population withmobilecreditservices,howdoyouintendtoservicethefarmers?

    Athirdchallengeistomakesuretheinformationplatformsareinteroperational.Inanupscaleeachof theplatformsonwhich farmers information isdeliveredhasvariousadvantagesandlimitations,andisoftenaninadequatesolutionwhenusedonitsown.Itis observed here that to provide an effective solution many platforms need to becarefully integrated in such away as to harness the benefits of individual platformswhileavoiding their limitations. Inotherwords,aneffective solutionmustcontainalltheseindividualplatformsorganisedcarefullysothateachfallsinitsplacetofulfillaset

    objective.The

    solution

    then

    becomes

    an

    information

    matrix

    whose

    elements

    are

    the

    individualplatformsandwhosecomposition isdoneonthebasisofthesetobjectives.Forthefarmersinformationservicetheelementsoftheinformationmatrixincludethefollowing:(a)SMS(text)Platform;(b)Voiceplatform;(c)Webportal;(d)Callcentre;(e)Extensionworkers;(f)Libraries;(g)Researchers.

    Alastchallengeisthatitistypicallydifficulttoattracttheprivatesectortoinvestinsuchventures in Africa for the longterm because these entrepreneurs are primarily riskaverseandthereforelacktheincentivestocontinuetoinvestinanunprofitableproject,thereby ensuring that projects are often of short duration. This is where the public

    sector

    and

    NGOs

    can

    play

    a

    huge

    role

    by

    fast

    tracking

    these

    private

    enterprise

    initiatives

    andpartneringwithlocalbusinesssothatthesolutioncanbesustainableafterthetimeframeofanygivenproject.

    6. BusinessBenefitsIfinnovativefarmerinformationsystemsrespondtospecificfarmersrequirementsandbenefitfarmers,mobileproviders,researchersand input/marketprovidersalike,there

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    22/67

    21

    isabetterchancefor increasedsustainability.For instance,when thebackendof thefarmer information system contains a call centre, the farmer information system canimplement farmers feedback to be used for localization and respond to specificfarmersrequirementssuchaslanguageandspecificproducts.TheSMSplatformcanbeusedforalerts,targetedtoprovidefarmerswithspecific information,therebycreating

    demand.

    When farmers call, they are automatically connected to an IVR (Interactive VoiceRecording)whichwillpromptthemtogetcritical information ineitherEnglishortheirindigenouslanguage.Iftheyaresatisfied,theywillhangupatthispoint.Ifthefarmersrequire further information they canbeeither referred toamanned callcentre, toawebsite, or to extension workers. In cases where the farmers may wish to getinformation intheir local languagestheycanautomaticallybereferredtothemannedcall centre.The call centre canalso in some cases refer farmers to thewebsiteor toextensionofficersforfurtherinformation.Thecontenttobeusedbythesystemcanbeharnessedfromlibrariesandresearchinstitutions.

    The IVR, the manned call centre and the website can monitor farmers questions,locationsandpreferences,thenfeedthisinformationintothefeedbackanalysiscentre.The feedbackcanpinpoint therequired information forvarious locationsandalso thelanguage preferences. This feedback can be fed into research institutes for furtherimprovement of the content. It can also be useful as input for advertisers and forfarmerseducationthatcanbeundertakenthroughsendingbulkSMSontopicalissues.

    Such innovative farmer information systems benefit farmers, mobile providers,researchers and input/market providers, among others. The farmers can have a

    comprehensivesolution

    from

    which

    they

    can

    get

    critical

    information

    in

    the

    language

    of

    theirpreference.Thetelecomproviderisabletopenetratetheruralareasasthebulkofthe population is a farming populationwho can be attracted to a network so as toaccess the information resource. Researchers have massive data from hundreds ofthousands of farmers using the feedback resource. Input and market providers canadvertise their products: fertilisers, market bids, etc, through a carefully targetedsystem based on feedback information. Such advertisement guarantees the systemssustainability.

    7. ConclusionsItisimportanttorealizethatfarmersandagriculturallabourersshouldnotbetreatedasmereconsumersofgenericinformationandknowledge.Theagriculturalsectorrequiresawellorganizedlearningcommunityintheformoffarmersassociations,cooperatives,womensgroups,etc.

    Innovativefarmerinformationsystemsareablendedlearningprocessinwhichfacetoface interaction, learning by doing, learning through evaluation and experience,

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    23/67

    22

    participatory research, etc. convert the generic information into location specificknowledgeandthenempoweritsmembersthroughhorizontaltransferofknowledge.Itshouldenhancetheselfdirectedlearningamongtheruralcommunity.

    Therewillneverbea one fit forall system.But the inventory suggests that systems

    whichuse

    avoice

    platform

    or

    audio

    files

    provide

    an

    innovative

    and

    promising

    entry

    pointtofarmer informationwhiletheotherplatforms(SMSandwebbasedplatforms)remainessentialtoprovideabackendofferingmoredetailedinformation.

    Theinventoryentriesindicatethatmanyprojectsarestillinthepilotphaseandare,orhavebeenof short duration and typicallymanaged or implementedby internationalorganizations, thereby revealing theneed to critically reviewupscaling scenarios andmovefrompilottomainstream.

    Theabsenceofcomprehensiveinformationontheprojectssuggeststhatprojectsneedstobemorecarefullydocumented,informationontheprojectsneedstobemorereadilyavailable and project evaluations need to be shared or projects will continue to beimplementedinisolationfromoneanother,oftenrepeatingthesamemistakesthatledtothecollapseofsimilarinitiatives.

    InordertoanswerthequestionHowcanwemonitortheimpact?weneedtolookintothebroaderinnovationopportunitiesoffarmers.Tomonitortheimpactofthetoolweneedtolookinto: themosteffectivewaysofreachingfarmerswithtimelyagriculturalinformationandknowledge (indigenousandexternal);mechanisms forharnessing thepotentialofFMradiostationsanddigitaltelephonyastechnologiesforcommunicatingagricultural information; options for repackaging agricultural information and

    knowledgefor

    small

    scale

    farmers;

    and

    the

    potential

    role

    of

    an

    erepository

    (of

    local

    agriculturalcontent)inAfricaforthepurposeofdisseminatinglocalagriculturalcontent.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    24/67

    23

    1. VOICEINFORMATIONDELIVERYSERVICES

    ProjectTitle

    Allo

    Ingenier

    http://www.irinnews.org/Report.aspx?ReportId=78408ProjectOwner CentredeDocumentationpourleDveloppementRural(The

    DocumentationCentreforRuralDevelopment)ProjectPartner CTAProjectStatus ActiveCountry Cameroon

    TheCentredeDocumentationpourleDveloppementRuralinYaound,whichispartoftheagriculturalNGOServicedAppuiauxInitiativesLocalesdeDveloppement(SupportOffice forLocalDevelopment Initiatives),providesaservice for farmers tocall inwithquestions. If the agriculturalexpertonhanddoesnotknow thequestion rightaway,he/she calls a specialist and getsback to the farmer.Allo Ingeniernotonlyprovidesanswers for farmersbut helps agricultural experts understand the important gaps intheir knowledge. The documentation centre gets approximately 300 requests forinformationayear.

    ProjectTitle BananaInformationLinehttp://www.comminit.com/en/node/267102/306

    ProjectOwner

    Local

    Language

    Speech

    Technology

    Initiative

    (LLSTI)

    ProjectPartners NationalAgricultureandLivestockExtensionProgramme(NALEP);KenyanMinistryofAgriculture

    ProjectStatus CompletedCountry Kenya

    Thistexttospeech(TTS)telephoneserviceprovidedfarmersinKenyawithinformationrelated to how to plant, grow, and harvest bananas, in either English or Kiswahili.According to the organisers, because anyone with a land line or mobile phone canaccessthe informationline,communitiesthataremoredifficulttoreachbytraditional

    means

    can

    more

    easily

    access

    agricultural

    information.

    A

    TTS

    service

    bypasses

    the

    need

    forliteracy,aswellastheproblemofreachingfarmerslivinginveryremoteareas,andcaneasilybekeptuptodatebyextensionworkers.Farmerscouldcallthelineanytimeofday,everyday.Thisproject ranasapilot for severalmonths in2006,buthasnowbeen superseded by the recentlylaunched National Farmers Information Service(NAFIS)informationline(seewww.nafis.go.ke)whichcoversawiderrangeofcropsandlivestock.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    25/67

    24

    ProjectTitle NationalFarmersInformationService(NAFIS)http://www.nafis.go.ke/termcond

    ProjectOwner

    Government

    of

    Kenya

    ProjectStatus BeingImplementedCountry Kenya

    Kenya launched, in May 2008, a farmers information service where the countrysfarming community will receive and exchange timely news and information onagriculture,weatherpatternsandotherrelatedissuesthroughtheirmobilephones.Theservice will allow 4.5 million farmers access to agricultural extension informationthroughthewebandtelephony.Thesystemwillbeupdatedthroughthewebbyfieldextension officers and the same informationwill be updated on the IVR (interactivevoiceresponse)tobeaccessiblebyanykindofphone.

    ProjectTitle T2M(TimetoMarket)http://t2m.manobi.sn/

    ProjectPartners ManobiProjectStatus ActiveCountry Senegal

    ManobidevelopedtheT2M,asystemthatenablesproducers,exportersandthepublic

    regulatoryagency

    to

    use

    amobile

    telephone,

    aPDA

    (personal

    digital

    assistant)

    or

    the

    internetinordertoknowinrealtimeboththepriceandarrivalstatusoftheirproductsat themarkets,and theavailabilityof the sameproducts in theproduction sites.Theprice and arrival changes of the products on the markets are collected by Manobimarket researchers twiceadayonaPDAapplication.Thedata,which is sentvia themobilenetworktotheManobiMultiChannelServicePlatform(MCSP)andstockedatacentralizeddatabase,isanalyzedinrealtimebeforeitisbroadcasttotheusersthroughamultichannelplatform speciallydevelopedbyManobi toprovidevalueaddeddataservices at lower costwith themobile telephony operators first generation classicalvocalnetworks.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    26/67

    25

    2. RADIO:DIALUP(AGRICULTURALINFORMATIONONDEMAND)ANDREGULARRADIOBROADCASTS

    ProjectTitle

    African

    Farm

    Radio

    Research

    Initiative

    (AFRRI)

    http://www.farmradio.org/english/partners/afrri/ProjectPartners WorldUniversityServiceofCanada(WUSC);FarmRadio

    InternationalProjectFunders BillandMelindaGatesFoundationProjectStatus ActiveCountries Ghana;Malawi;Mali;Tanzania;Uganda

    AFRRI is a 42 month action research project launched in April 2007. AFRRI gathers,implements,evaluates,andsharesbestpracticesforusingradiobasedcommunicationstrategies to enhance food security in rural Africa. It also offers radio broadcasterscapacitybuildingandtrainingservicesthataimtoimprovetheirprogrammingforrurallisteners.

    ProjectTitle FamilyAllianceforDevelopmentandCooperation(FADECO)http://www.hedon.info/FADECOTanzania

    ProjectOwner FADECOProjectPartner CTAProjectStatus Active

    Country

    Tanzania

    AlocalNGOinKaragwedistrictofTanzania,FADECOspecializesinagriculturalextensionandparticipatory technologydevelopmentwith rural farmers.FADECO startedwitharurallibrarywhichprovidedinformationresources(books,CDROMlibraries,magazines,newsletters, etc) and then started its own newsletter called WAZA) and establishedinformationnoticeboards.Computer training startedand in2004,with support fromRAIN (thenanASARECAProject),FADECOwentonlinewithVSATand implementedaQuestionandAnswerService (withCTA). In2007 theradioprojectwas launched.Theradiosignalcoversover1millionlistenersspreadacrossthewholeofKageraregionand

    neighbouring

    countries

    districts

    of

    Kyotera,

    Masaka,

    Mbarara

    (in

    Uganda),

    Kibungo

    in

    Rwanda and Kobero (Burundi). FADECO mainly uses the radio for disseminatinginformationandSMStextmessagingtoreceivefeedbackandquestions.

    ProjectTitle FreedomFonehttp://www.kubatana.net/html/ff/ff_cont.asp

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    27/67

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    28/67

    27

    TheOrganic Farmer (TOF) is an independent and sustainablepublicationof relevant,reliable and ecologically sound information for farmers in Africa. As an informationserviceforfarmersinAfrica,TOFhasamonthlymagazine,weeklyradioprogramandawebsite.Themagazinedistributes18000copies inKenyaandneighbouringcountriesand reaches around 150 000 readerswho include the farming community aswell as

    decisionmakers

    who

    are

    interested

    in

    learning

    more

    about

    sustainable

    agriculture

    and

    ecologicallysounddevelopment.TheelectronicversionofTOFcanbeaccessedfreeofchargeontheInternetandhasbeenusedsofarbyfarmersandresearchersinover20tropical countries. The radio program gives tips on organic farming and answersfarmersquestions.TOFRadioisonaironthenationalbroadcasterKBCKiswahiliserviceeveryThursdayfrom8.15to8.45pm.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    29/67

    28

    3. EXTENSIONSERVICESBASEDONMOBILEPHONEANDDATABASEMONITORINGProjectTitle AgriculturalMarketingandInformationSystemforMalawi(MIS

    Malawi)

    http://www.ideaamis.com/SMS/index.php

    ProjectOwner MalawiAgriculturalCommodityExchange(MACE)Ltdhttp://www.ideaamis.com/

    ProjectPartners TelekomNetworksMalawi;RockefellerFoundation;UniversityofMalawiBundaCollegeIDEAA

    ProjectStatus ActivesinceSeptember2004Country Malawi

    TheAgriculturalMarketingandInformationSystemforMalawi(MISMalawi)isa5yearproject implemented throughMACEwithin theoverall frameworkof the Initiative forDevelopmentandEquityinAfricanAgriculture(IDEAA).ItusesvarioustoolstointegrateICTs into the provision of relevant and timely market information and intelligencetargeted at smallholder farmers and serves other market intermediaries in thecommodity value chains that represent market outlets for the farmers. There areseveralsystemcomponents:

    1. CentralHub:basedinLilongwe.2. MarketingInformationCentres(MICs):3centreslocatedinLimbe,Lilongwe,and

    Mzuzu.3. Marketing Information Points (MIPs): 4 centres located in Lobi, Kasungu,

    RumphiandLizulu.4. Market resource centres: 6 centres located in Muloza, Mwanza, Liwonde,

    Mitundu,Jenda

    and

    Karonga.

    5. ShortMessaging Service (SMS): using the cell phone number 08200777, theservice allows users to access wholesale prices from 13 markets, sell or buyagriculturalcommoditiesandaccessretailpricesfrom45markets,buypricesofagricultural commodities and access hybrid maize variety yields and fertilizerrecommendations.Therewereapproximately30000usersoftheSMSservicesin2007.

    6. Email:[email protected] awebsite:www.ideaamis.com7. Radioprogram: InJanuary2008,MACEcommissionedthevirtualtradingfloor

    through the radio.Theprogram,calledMisikayapawailesiorSupermarketon

    the

    Air,

    is

    an

    interactive

    radio

    program

    that

    allows

    farmers

    in

    Malawi

    to

    trade

    various agricultural commodities in a timely and effectivemanner, by placingtheirofferstosellandbidstobuyliveontheradio.MACEstaffinteractdirectlywith the farmers who call in to sell and buy commodities. From January toSeptember 2008 the total volume traded through the radioprogramwasMK(MalawiKwacha)32,733,845.10,equivalentto$US233,813.00.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    30/67

    29

    ProjectTitle AgriculturalMarketingSystemsDevelopmentProgramme(AMSDP)http://www.ifad.org/english/operations/pf/tza/i575tz/index.htm

    ProjectOwner GovernmentofTanzania

    ProjectPartner

    IFAD;

    ADB;

    the

    Government

    of

    the

    Republic

    of

    Ireland;

    Vodacom

    ProjectStatus Activesince2002Country Tanzania

    VodacomisworkingwiththeMinistryofIndustry,TradeandMarketingtoimplementitsAMSDP,asevenyearprogramme.Information isprovidedbytheministrytoVodacomwhere farmersand traderscanaccess thedata, including the latestcommoditypricesthroughSMSsentfromtheirmobilephones.Thisserviceenablesfarmersandtraderstonegotiatemoreeffectivelyonthesaleofagriculturalproduce.

    ProjectTitle AgriculturalResearchExtensionNetwork(ARENET)http://www.arenet.or.ug/question2.php

    ProjectPartners National Agricultural Research Organization (NARO); NationalAgricultural Advisory Services (NAADS); Agricultural ResearchInformation Service (ARIS); Bulindi, Ngetta and Mbarara ZonalAgriculturalResearchandDevelopment Institutes(ZARDIs);LocalGovernmentAgricultureDepartmentsofLira,HoimaandMbararadistricts;WougNetKubere InformationCentre inApac;FoodNetLira; IITA/FoodNet; Agency for the Promotion of Sustainable

    Initiatives(ASDI)

    in

    Apac;

    Volunteer

    Efforts

    for

    Development

    Concerns (VEDCO); DATICs in Rakai; Action AID International inMasindi;UgandaNational Farmers Federation (UNFFE);MinistryofAgriculture;Animal Industry and Fisheries;National FisheriesResourcesResearchInstitute(NAFIRRI)

    ProjectStatus ActivesinceNovember2004Country Uganda

    ARENETwasdevelopedthroughaTechnicalCooperationProgramme(TCP)betweentheUgandangovernmentandtheFAO.TheprojectthatdevelopedARENETendedin2007

    and

    was

    entitled:

    Strengthening

    Information

    and

    Communication

    Linkages

    between

    Agricultural Research and Extension in Uganda. The project pilot site is in ZonalAgricultural Research and Development Institutes (ZARDIs) of Bulindi, Ngetta andMbarara, Agricultural Research Information Service (ARIS), NAADS, AgriculturalProductionDepartmentsandNGOsinthedistrictsofMbarara,Lira,andHoima.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    31/67

    30

    ARENETprovides3basicservices:1. Agricultural documents system: an internet tool for documenting, storing,

    sharinganddisseminatingsimpletechnicalagriculturalinformationapplicabletofarmersandextensionagents.

    2. TheQuestionandAnswer service (Q&A):an internet tool for solving technicalproblems

    related

    to

    agriculture

    and

    rural

    development.

    It

    was

    developed

    with

    the aim of helping farmers to get answers to different questions. Farmers,extensionworkers and service providers post the questions online under theappropriatecategory.Thequestionsareansweredby thebestexperts ineachfield and then posted for all to access. The questions and their appropriateanswersarethenstoredinadatarepository.

    3. Newsandevents:asystemtoenabledistrictsandresearchsitestopostnewsoreventsannouncements.

    ProjectTitle Esoko(formerlyTradenet)http://www.esoko.com

    ProjectOwner EsokoNetworksProjectStatus ActiveCountries Benin;BurkinaFaso;Cted'Ivoire;Ghana;Madagascar;Mali;

    Mozambique;Nigeria;Tanzania;Uganda;Cameroon;Afghanistan

    Esoko is a rural communication platform that seeks to improve incomes by buildinghealthymarkets.Anyindividual,businessorproducergroupcansetupEsokotobettermanage theirmarketing, distribution and procurement networks. There are four key

    servicesprovided

    by

    the

    platform:

    1. Livemarketfeeds: realtime SMS alerts on market prices and offers that areautomaticallydeliveredtosubscribers.Userscansubmitoffers intothesystemdirectlyusingSMS.

    2. DirectSMSmarketing:businessescantargetspecificgroupsofusersandtargetprocurementorextensionmessages to reduce their travelandcommunicationcosts.

    3. Scoutpolling:enterprisescansetupautomaticSMSpollingforfieldactivitiestotrack inventories,cropactivitiesetc. tomonitorand reportoncropcyclesandyields.

    4. Onlineprofilingandmarketing:anyuserorbusinessgetsacustomizablewebspace that can advertise their goods and services. This space canbeupdatedusingEsokosmobile2webcontentmanagementservice.

    EsokowasbegunasTradeNet in2005asaprivate initiative. ItpartneredwithUSAIDsMISTOWAprograminWestAfricaandCIATsFoodNetprograminUganda.Itworkswithbothwebandmobiledevicesandhasateamof20inGhanadevelopingthetechnology.Itiscurrentlylicensedbypartnersin10countriesthroughoutAfrica.Anyonecanlicense

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    32/67

    31

    the platform for use in their own country. Esoko provides a complementary partnersupportprogramwhichisfocusedoncapacitybuildingandfinancialsustainability,withanemphasisonmarketdataenumerationandbusinessdevelopmentservices.

    ProjectTitle FarmersInformationCommunicationManagement(FICOM)http://www.syngentafoundation.org/projects_programs_ficom_overview.htmhttp://www.ictard.org/ictard_projects_pilot.htm

    ProjectOwner UgandaNationalFarmersFederation(UNFFE)ProjectFunder SyngentaFoundationforSustainableAgriculture(SFSA)ProjectPartners InformationandCommunicationTechnologiesforAfricanRural

    Development(ICTARD);MeteorologicalDepartmentoftheMinistryofLandsWaterandEnvironment;NARO;UgandaMicrofinanceUnion;FoodnetUganda;BusogaRuralOpenSourceDevelopmentInitiative(BROSDI);MTNVillagephoneproject;UgandaMicrofinanceUnion

    ProjectStatus Complete(20052007)Country Uganda

    FICOMwasapilotstudyto testsustainable ICT toolswhichcanbeused toeffectivelydisseminate agronomic information, advisory information, microfinance information,market information and agro enterprise development, and related businessdevelopmentsupportservicetoruralfarmersintheJinja,KayungaandLuwerodistrictsofUganda. Important tipson growing cropswere relayed from theUgandaNational

    FarmersFederation

    (UFFE)

    headquarters

    to

    district

    level

    offices,

    and

    then

    to

    24

    village

    phonecentres, inwhicheachfarmersgroupownedamobilephone.Thefarmersalsosent and received SMS messages with updates on market prices. The project redeveloped theUNFFE Website and established awireless network andWorld Spaceradiousing the radioand internetSystems (RANET)whichenabledaccess toadvisoryinformation(UNFFEwebsite)withoutinternetconnection.

    ProjectTitle InfoPrixBenin:MarketpricesviaSMS

    http://www.onasa.org/

    ProjectOwner NationalBureauforFoodSecurity(ONSA)ProjectPartners GermanCentreforDocumentationandInformationfor

    Agriculture(ZADI);GermanCentreforTechnicalCooperation(GTZ)

    ProjectStatus UnknownCountry Benin

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    33/67

    32

    SurveyorsofthefoodsecurityofficeinBenin(ONASA)monitor64ruralmarketsonthepricesofthe25most importantstaplefoods.Afterbusinesshours,pricesaresuppliedtoanInternetcafwherethedataisprocessedandsenttoONASAheadquarters.Aftera quality check, subscribers receive an SMS message with the prices of the mainproductsfromthesixmostimportantmarkets.Otherinformationcanberequestedvia

    SMS,and

    information

    is

    forwarded

    to

    radio

    stations

    to

    be

    communicated

    in

    local

    languages.

    ProjectTitle KenyaAgriculturalCommoditiesExchange(KACE)MISProjecthttp://www.kacekenya.com/

    ProjectOwner KACEProjectPartners CTA;SafaricomLtd;RockefellerFoundation;USAID;HansSeidal

    FoundationProjectStatus Activesince2002Country Kenya

    The KACE MIS pilot project was initiated by KACE, in collaboration with CTA. KACEcollects,processes,updatesanddisseminatesmarket informationdailytofarmersandother market intermediaries through theMIS. Market information includes prices ofcommoditiesindifferentmarkets,andcommodityofferstosellandbidstobuy,aswellasshortextensionmessages.Throughtheoffersandbidsfunction,farmersareabletoadvertise theirstocks (offers) for saleor theirdemands (bids) for farm inputs suchasfertilizers and improved seeds. KACE monitors the usage of the MIS, and receivesfeedbackwhichitusestocontinuouslyrefineandimprovethesystem.Thereareseveral

    componentsto

    the

    project:

    1. RuralbasedMarketInformationPoints(MIPs):informationkiosks.2. Market InformationCentres(MICs):centreswhichprovide internetconnectivity

    andliaisonpoints.3. Mobile phone Short Messaging Service (SMS Sokoni): a partnership with

    SafaricomLtd,a leadingmobilephone serviceprovider.A farmeranywhere inthe country where the Safaricom mobile phone network exists can accessmarketinformationlikecommoditypricesindifferentmarkets,whoisbuyingorselling what commodity, at what prices, where and when, as well as accessextensionmessagesusingtheirSafaricommobilephones.Theuserreceivesand

    pays

    for

    the

    SMS

    messages,

    about

    KSh

    7

    per

    message,

    to

    Safaricom.

    4. Interactive Voice Response (IVR) service: an IVR network that KACE uploadsmarketinformationintoregularly.Usersaccesstheinformationinvoicemailbydialing the number 0900552055 with any mobile or digital phone through asimplemenu.

    5. SOKOHewani:avirtual trading floorcreated forsmallscaleproducers toofferforsalevariousagriculturalcommoditiesandbidstobuyavailablecommoditiesusingmobilephonesbycallingintotheradiostation(indesign).

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    34/67

    33

    6. AnInternetbasedRegionalCommodityTradeandInformationSystem(RECOTIS):an electronic database of clients interested in buying, selling, importing,exportingordistributing agricultural commodities fordisseminationofmarketinformation(notfullyoperational).

    7. Awebsite:http://www.kacekenya.com/.

    ProjectTitle LivestockInformationNetworkandKnowledgeSystem(LINKS)ProjectOwner GlobalLivestockCollaborativeResearchSupportProgram(GL

    CRSP)ProjectPartners US:USAID;TexasA&MUniversity;CentreforNaturalResource

    InformationTechnology(CNRIT)Kenya:KenyaLivestockMarketingCouncil;MinistryofLivestockDevelopment;SNV(NetherlandsDevelopmentOrganization)Ethiopia:MinistryofAgricultureandRuralDevelopment;LivestockMarketingAuthorityTanzania:MinistryofIndustry;TradeandMarketing;TanzaniaLivestockMarketingAgency

    ProjectStatus Activesince2003Countries Kenya,Ethiopia,andTanzania

    LINKS is an ongoing and expandingregional linked livestock marketing informationsystem that is geared towards addressing theneeds for timely and reliable livestockmarketing information forproducers, traders and policymakers in the livestock subsector.TheLINKSsystemsupplementstheLivestockEarlyWarningSystem(LEWS).

    Theservice

    covers

    18

    markets

    in

    Kenya,

    32

    in

    Ethiopia

    and

    30

    in

    Tanzania.

    It

    provides

    informationonvarioustopics:

    Trendsinlivestockpricesforthemajorlivestock(cattle,camel,sheep,goats). Salesvolumes,includingproportionsofeachkindofanimalbymarket. Costsoftransportinganimalsbytruckfromonemarkettoanother. Numberofhourstakentotransportanimalsfromonemarkettoanother. Pricesoflivestockproductsmilk(camel,cow,goat),meat(camel,cow,

    goat,sheep),hides,skins,honey.

    The informationonprices and volumesmaybedownloaded from thewebusing the

    individualcountry

    URLs:

    Kenya

    (www.lmiske.net),

    Ethiopia

    (www.lmiset.net),

    and

    Tanzania (www.lmistz.net)oraccessed throughSMS.Pastoralareas in the3countriescarryabout30%ofthetotalpopulationestimatedat160millionpeoplewhichamountsto48millionpeople. It isestimated thatoutof the48million,about5% (2.4million)haveaccesstothe informationthroughthenetworkofmajorprojectpartnerswithanestimated3%(720,000)usingpersonalmobilephones.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    35/67

    34

    ProjectTitle TheMakulekeProjecthttp://www1.alcatellucent.com/sustainable/DigitalBridge/?_requestid=38780

    ProjectPartners Alcatel;Manobi;Vodacom

    ProjectStatus

    Unknown

    Country SouthAfrica

    Thispilotprojectallowsaround100farmersinMakuleketotestcellphonetechnologythatgivessmallruralfarmersaccesstonationalmarketsviatheinternet.Usingavirtualtradingfacilityinstalledonmobilephonesprovidedbytheprojectsponsors,farmerscanselltheirproducedirectlyfromtheirsmallfarms.BycheckingpricesintheJohannesburgmarkets, farmers can avoid paying commissions to intermediaries and are able tonegotiateforapricefullyawareofmarketandpriceconditions.

    ProjectTitle NetworkofMarketInformationSystemsandTradersOrganizationsofWestAfrica(MISTOWA)www.mistowa.orgwww.waagritrade.net

    ProjectPartners USAID;Agriterra;IFCDProjectStatus CompletedCountries ECOWAScountries

    Beginning in 2004, MISTOWA was funded by the USAID until September 2007 and

    implementedby

    the

    IFCD.

    With

    the

    overall

    objective

    of

    increasing

    intra

    regional

    trade

    of agricultural commodities within West Africa, the project focused on removingobstaclestotradesuchasalackofaccesstotimely information on prices andmarketopportunities, inadequate ability of producersand traders to respond toproductionandmarketopportunitiesand anunfavorabletradingenvironment,includingtariffandnontariff barriers. MISTOWAworked with national affiliates ofMarket InformationSystems (MIS),TradersOrganizations (TOs) and ProducersOrganizations (POs) andregionalpublicMISnetworks suchasRESIMAO/WAMISNETandprivateones suchasTradeNet (aka Esoko) which provide, to all stakeholders, uptodate and accurateinformation on 400 rural and urban agricultural commodity markets via the

    internet,

    radio,

    print,

    email

    and

    SMS.

    Other

    partners

    were

    inter

    governmental

    economic, monetary and policy organizations, ICT providers, media and privatecompanies in the agroprocessing subsector. The project targeted all 15 ECOWASmembercountriesbutactivitieswerecarried out most intensively in Ghana, Nigeria,Mali, Burkina Faso, Senegal,Benin, Togo, Cote dIvoire and Niger, with significantthough lesser involvementofkeypartners inGuinea,TheGambia,andSierraLeone.MISTOWA developed a very successful privatepublic partnership with "Busylab", aprivate software company in Ghana to create the electronic agribusiness

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    36/67

    35

    informationexchangeplatform,www.tradenet.biz.ToassistusersinaccessingTradeNetandavarietyofothermarket informationandbusinessservices, MISTOWA assistedpartners in establishing over 100 Agribusiness Information Points (ABIPs) in 13countries throughout West Africa. ABIPmanagers are now highly trained in theuse of Tradenet and are abletofacilitateproducersandtradersdevelopingprofitable

    marketlinkages.

    A

    new

    USAID

    funded

    project,

    Agribusiness

    and

    Trade

    Promotion

    (ATP),

    has since taken over most of the activities of MISTOWA. ATP will focus on maize,onion/shallot,andlivecattlevaluechains.

    ProjectTitle RegionalAgriculturalTradeInformationNetwork(RATIN)www.ratin.net

    ProjectPartners RegionalAgriculturalTradeExpansionSupportProgram(RATES);SwedishInternationalDevelopmentAgency(SIDA);FewsNet;USAID

    ProjectStatus Activesince2003

    RATINisafiveyearprojectwhichisacollaborativeeffortcomprisingtheUSAIDprojectsFamine Early Warning SystemNetwork Project (FEWS NET), focussing on bringing incrop production and trade information, and the Regional Agricultural TradeEnhancementSupportProgram(RATES)dealingwithchangingtradepolicytoenhanceregional trade inmaize.Theprojectobjective is tosupply traderswith improvedearlywarning marketing and trade information in East Africa. To easily distribute RATINinformationtohundredsofsmallandmediumsizedcrossbordertradersofcerealsandpulsesinEastAfrica,thetradershavebeenorganizedinto30looseassociations,eachof

    whichreceive

    RATINs

    monthly

    bulletin

    and

    disseminate

    it

    to

    all

    members.

    RATIN

    also

    disseminates traderelated information through TV and radio, telephone, newspaperandthroughitswebsite.

    ProjectTitle RseaudesSystmesd'InformationdesMarchsenAfriquedel'Ouest/WestAfricanAgriculturalMarketInformationSystemNetwork(RESIMAO/WAMISNet)http://www.resimao.org/html/en

    Project

    Owner

    RESIMAO/WAMIS

    Net

    ProjectStatus ActiveCountries Benin;BurkinaFaso;Cted'Ivoire;Guinea;Niger;Mali;Senegal;

    Togo;Nigeria

    RESIMAO/WAMISNET is aNetworkofMarket Information Systems from itsmembercountriesthatprovides,toallstakeholders,uptodateandaccurateinformationon400rural and urban agricultural commodity markets via different media. The network

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    37/67

    36

    monitors the development of the agricultural sector through the collection andpublicationof related statistics and analytical reports. Itprovidesmarket informationthroughtheinternet,radio,print,emailandSMS.

    ProjectTitle SMSInformationServicehttp://www.farmprices.co.zm/

    ProjectOwner ZambiaNationalFarmersUnion(ZNFU)ProjectPartners IFAD;VodacomDRC;AfriConnect/CelTelProjectStatus Activesince2007Country Zambia;DemocraticRepublicofCongo

    The IFADsupported Smallholder Enterprise and Marketing Programme (SHEMP) inZambiacreatedacrossborderSMSmarket information service thatprovides farmersandtradersinZambiaandtheKatangaprovinceoftheCongowithdailyinformationonstockavailability,marketpricesandsalestrendsthatisalsosupportedbyitswebsite.Toobtain thebestprices foracommodity, farmerssendanSMSmessagecontaining thefirst four letters of the commodity name to 4455. Traders access the information inFrenchviaVodacomDRCintheCongoandinEnglishviaAfriConnect/CeltelinZambia.

    ProjectTitle SystmedInformationdesMarchsAgricoles(SIMA)http://ictupdate.cta.int/en/FeatureArticles/Dakorocalling

    ProjectPartner FamineEarlyWarningSystemNetwork(FEWSNET)

    ProjectStatus

    Unknown

    Country Niger

    Local government staff gathers information in collaborationwith the agricultural andlivestock markets SIMA (Systme dInformation des Marchs Agricole AgriculturalMarketInformationSystem)andSIMB(SystmedInformationdesMarchsduBtailLivestockMarketing InformationSystem).Theydirectlycollect information in the localmarketsallaroundthecountry.Eachtelecomcentrecoversacertainnumberofvillages,andmarkets.Ateachsatelliteterminal,there isacomputerconnectedtoasmalldatatransmitterthatthensendstheagriculturalinformationtothecapital.

    ProjectTitle TradeatHandhttp://www.intracen.org/tradeathand/

    ProjectOwner UnitedNationsInternationalTradeCentreProjectStatus ActiveCountry BurkinaFaso;Mali;Senegal;Mozambique;Liberia(starting)

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    38/67

    37

    In the agricultural sector, the serviceprovidesdaily commodityprice information forfruitandvegetableexporters. "MarketPrices", consists in sending,viaSMS,productpriceson internationalmarkets, inreal time.Usersofmarketpricesare registeredby

    thelocal

    Trade

    at

    Hand

    Focal

    Point.

    Upon

    subscription,

    the

    exporter

    chooses

    the

    products for which he/she wants to receive price quotations. Real time prices forwholesalemarketswillbesenttotheexporterthroughtheShortMessageService(SMS)inhis/hermobilephone. "MarketAlerts" isaWebtoSMS tool thatenablesBusinessSupportOrganisationstotransmitbusinessopportunities,contactsandmarketnewstobusinesspeople.Trade atHandwas designed to be selfsustainable in countrieswhere the service islaunched.Theservicescostsarenegotiatedonacasebycasebasis,foreachcountry,inordertosetupanaffordableinformationservice.ThemanagementofTradeatHandisgiventolocalorganizations(calledT@HFocalPoints).Over90%offruitsandvegetablesexporters(toEurope)fromSenegal,MaliandBurkinaFasohavesubscribedtoTradeatHandMarketPrices.TheITCiscurrentlyimplementingaprojectwhichcollects,bySMS,agriculturalfoodpricesonnationalmarketsinSenegal,MaliandBurkinaFaso.Itisdoneinpartnershipwiththreenationalpricecollectinginstitutions.

    ProjectTitle XamMarshttp://www.manobi.sn/sites/za/index.php?M=9&SM=20&Cle=54

    ProjectOwner ManobiProjectPartners SenegaleseAgriculturalCreditFund;Sonatel;SwissAgencyfor

    Developmentand

    Cooperation;

    Senegalese

    Ministry

    of

    Commerce;Alcatel;Sontel;IDRCProjectStatus Activesince2001Country Senegal

    XamMarsprovidesmarketinformationaboutvariousproductstoSenegalesefarmers,traders,hoteliersandothersviainternetandfreedailySMS.XamMarsprovidesSMSwithrealtime informationonthepricesandavailabilityoffruit,vegetables,meatandpoultry,onanyofSenegalsmarkets.

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    39/67

    38

    4. ELEARNINGFORBASICSKILLS,AGRICULTURALEDUCATIONANDVIDEOBASEDAPPROACHES

    ProjectTitle

    Agriculture

    Research

    and

    Rural

    Information

    Network

    (ARRIN)

    NdereTroupehttp://www.iicd.org/projects/ugandaarrin

    ProjectOwner ARRINProjectPartner IICDProjectStatus ActivesinceMarch2003Country Uganda

    TheAgriculturalResearchandRuralInformationNetworksetup5informationcentres,calledInfoPops,throughoutUganda.Theprojectstaffcollectsagriculturalquestionsandproblemsfromfarmersinruralcommunitiesandusestheinformationcentrestoconveythesetoascientific institute.Agriculturalresearchersfromtheinstituteusearangeofresources, including the internet, to find solutions to these problems. A script isdevelopedbasedon the informationacquiredby the researchersand then theNdereTroupetheatregroupdevelopsaplayusingtheanswerstothequestionsanddistributesthetranscripts(generally,textandvideo)electronicallytotheInfoPops(onCDROMvianormalpostal services).The InfoPops then channel the informationvia this theatricalperformance to rural communities in local languages. The ICT facilities in the ruralInfoPopsarealsousedbythecommunityforotherpurposessuchasaccessingmarketinformationandprovidingfarmerswithinformationonnewcrops.Thepilotproject,inpartnershipwiththeIICD,hasendedbuttheprojecthascontinuedindependentlysince

    January2007

    and

    has

    an

    estimated

    15,000

    beneficiaries.

    ProjectTitle Agrovisionhttp://www.eagriculture.org/19.html?&no_cache=1&tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=473&tx_ttnews%5BbackPid%5D=96&cHash=50cab57bc8

    ProjectOwner NationalInformationTechnologyDevelopmentAgency(NITDA)ProjectPartner AssociationofTelecommunicationsCompaniesinNigeria

    (ATCOM)

    ProjectStatus InDesignCountry Nigeria

    AgrovisionisaprogrammethatwasdevelopedatATCOMincollaborationwithrelevantgovernmentagencies inorder tohelp farmersboostagriculturaland foodproduction.Itsobjective is toprovide farmerswith theagroecologicalmappingsof thecropsandsoil types inNigeria. Itwillalsoprovide themwithother information suchasplanting

  • 7/28/2019 Innovative Farmer Advisory Systems

    40/67

    39

    andharvestingdatesfordifferenttypesofcrops,storageconditions(dependingonthepartofthecountrywherethefarmislocated),andthebestmeansoftransportationforeverytypeofcrop.

    ProjectTitle AgriculturalSectorDevelopmentProgramme(ASDP)http://www.ifad.org/operations/pipeline/pf/tan.htm

    ProjectOwner IFADProjectStatus BeingimplementedCountry Tanzania

    TheprojectwasformerlyknownastheAgriculturalServicesSupportProgramme(ASSP),the project objective of which was to enable stakeholders in the agricultural sectorincluding ministries, local government authorities, processors, marketers, serviceproviders and far