43
INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia, Slovenia

INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, )

AND RA II (Australia)

REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES

ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

Slovakia, Slovenia

Page 2: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

4 W METHOD

W

W

W

W

HY

HO

ITH

HAT

Page 3: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHY

METROLOGY LABORATORIES

MANUFACTURERS / PUBLIC

NATIONAL LABORATORY

BIPM

METROLOGY PYRAMID

Page 4: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHY

NMHS

AWS / STATION

RIC

WMO

METEOROLOGY PYRAMID

Page 5: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHY

DISSEMINATION TRACEABILITY

INTERCOMPARISON

Page 6: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHY

WMO N°8 Guide to Meteorological Instruments And Methods of observation:

« Intercomparisons of instruments and observing systems, together with agreed quality control procedures, are essential for the establishment of compatible data sets. »

Term Of Reference for RICTerm Of Reference for RIC CapabilityCapability ““(f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory comparisons of (f) A RIC must participate in, or organize inter-laboratory comparisons of

standard calibration instruments and methods,standard calibration instruments and methods, » »

Page 7: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

[email protected]@gov.si

[email protected] [email protected]

ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

Page 8: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Slovak Hydrometeorological

InstituteJeséniova 17

833 15 BratislavaSlovakia

[email protected]

Page 9: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

• Range: -30°C to +50°C,• Method of immediate comparison,• Reference standard: SPRT

Rosemount, model 162CE,• Resistance bridge: Hart Scientific,

model 1560, 2560 and 2562 for PRT calibrations,

• Standard resistors: 25, 100 Tinsley 5685A,

• Liquid bath Julabo FP40-HP,• Best Measure Capability 0.05°C.

TEMPERATURE

Page 10: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

• Traceability to National Standard,• Range: 10% RH to 95% RH,• Method of immediate comparison,• Monitoring of the calibration process,• Best measure capability 2.5% RH

HYGROMETRY

Page 11: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Traceability to National Standard, Range: 600 hPa to 1100 hPa, Method of immediate comparison, Best Measure Capability is 0.11 hPa

PRESSURE

DH Instruments PPC2+

Page 12: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHOENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

Environmental Agency of the Republic of Slovenia

Vojkova 1b1000 Ljubljana

Sloveniawww.arso.gov.si

[email protected]

Page 13: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHOENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

HYGROMETRY

Page 14: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHOENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

TEMPERATURE

Page 15: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHOENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

PRESSURE

Page 16: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Quantities Range BMC (k=2)

Temperature

Water triple point 0.01 °C 1 mK

Gallium melting point 29.7646 °C 1.5 mK

Resistance thermometers -40 °C ÷ 50 °C 15 mK

Liguid-in-glass

thermometers

-20 °C ÷ 50 °C 70 mK

Thermographs -20 °C ÷ 0 °C

0 °C ÷ 50 °C

0.3 °C

0.2 °C

Relative humidity 10 % ÷ 95 % 3 %

Air pressure 600 hPa ÷ 1200 hPa 5.4·10-5·p + 5 Pa

Air quality quantities

CO concentration 0 -15 ppmv 0.07 ppm + 0.016 · cCO

SO2 concentration 0 - 500 ppbv 0.8 ppb + 0.021· cSO2

NO concentration 0 - 500 ppbv 0.9 ppb + 0.031· cNO

NO2 concentration 0 - 500 ppbv 1.5 ppb + 0.02 · cNO2

O3 concentration 0 - 500 ppbv 2.6 ppb + 0.024 · cO3

ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

Page 17: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Bureau of MeteorologyGPO Box 1289

Melbourne VIC 3001Australia

Phone +03 9669 4000Fax +03 9669 4699

[email protected]

Page 18: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

PRESSURE

Page 19: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Page 20: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Page 21: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Domain Type of standard Type Manufacturer Range U (k=2)95%

Temperature

ITS-90 fixed points Hg, H2O, Ga, In Isotech -38 – 156oC 20 mK

Pressure Dead Weight Tester Gas piston gauge

Ruska 500 – 1100 hPa

2 Pa

Humidity Dew Point Hygrometer

Chilled mirror Eastern General

DP -70 -+40 0.15oC DP

Page 22: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

Météo-FranceDSO/LM

7 Rue Teisserenc de Bort78195 TRAPPES France

Phone +33130136350Fax +33130136020

Page 23: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

HUMIDITY 11 % : LiCl 33 % : MgCl 54 % : N2O6Mg 75 % : NaCl 95 % : K2SO4

Uncertainty: 2.4 %

Page 24: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

2 temperature benchHumidity generation with a circulating bench called “2 temperature bench”

From -50°C to +50°C From 0% to 99% Uncertainty 1.6 %.U

Page 25: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

PRESSURE

range 500 to 1060 hPa Uncertainty: 8.8 + 5.4.10-5 P Pa.

Page 26: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHO

TEMPERATURE

-50 à +50°C ASL resistor bridge Uncertainty 0.03 °C

Page 27: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WITH

Set of instruments developed by

Australian Bureau

Page 28: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WITH

THERMOMETER

Instrulab 4312A-15-07 (PT100)

Page 29: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WITH

HYGROMETER

Vaisala HM-70 humidity sensor

Page 30: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WITH

BAROMETER

PTB 220A 3 cells

Page 31: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WITH

NORMALISED BIAS

22

21

21

UU

BBBN

B1 and B2 are respectively the bias (True value – Instrument value)U1 and U2 are the associated expanded uncertainties.

Page 32: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHAT

-0,15

-0,10

-0,05

0,00

0,05

0,10

0,15

0,20

0,25

0,30

France Australie Slovakia Slovenia

PRESSURE

PRESSURE (hPa)

BIAS (hPa)

Page 33: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHAT

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

Correction Australie France salt France 2 temp Slovakia Slovenia

HUMIDITY

U (%)BIAS (%)

Page 34: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

WHAT

-0.0020

-0.0010

0.0000

0.0010

0.0020

0.0030

0.0040

0.0050

0.0060

0.0070

0.0080

0.0090

-60 -40 -20 0 20 40 60

AUSTRALIA

SLOVAKIA

SLOVENIA

FRANCE

TEMPERATURE

(°C)

BIAS (°C)

Page 35: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

CONCLUSION

RIC’s UNCERTAINTIES

  PRESSURE TEMPERATURE HUMIDITY

AUSTRALIA 0.06 0.02 1

SLOVENIA 0.05 0.02 2.4

SLOVAKIA 0.12 0.05 2.6

FRANCE 0.16 0.03 2.5

Page 36: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

CONCLUSION

INSTRUMENTS

STABLE

SUITABLE

Page 37: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

CONCLUSION

PROCEDURES

AND

METHODS

ARE SUITABLE FOR INTERCOMPARISONS

Page 38: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

CONCLUSION

ORGANISED BY RIC

INTERCOMPARISONS

PROMOTED BY WMO

Page 39: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

THANKS

[email protected]

Page 40: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

THANKSENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY

OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA

Page 41: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

THANKS

Page 42: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

THE END ?

Page 43: INTERCOMPARISON BETWEEN RA VI ( France, ) AND RA II (Australia) REGIONAL INSTRUMENT CENTRES ENVIRONMENTAL AGENGY OF THE REPUBLIC OF SLOVENIA Slovakia,

TO BE CONTINUED…

THANKS FOR YOUR ATTENTION