Upload
dimitrios-m
View
212
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
PHARMACEUTICAL DEVELOPMENT AND TECHNOLOGY
Vol 9 No 3 pp 311ndash320 2004
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Ion Pair Formation as a Possible Mechanism for the Enhancement Effect ofLauric Acid on the Transdermal Permeation of Ondansetron
Dimitrios A Dimas Paraskevas P Dallas and Dimitrios M Rekkas
Division of Pharmaceutical Technology School of Pharmacy
University of Athens Panepistimiopolis Zografou
Athens Greece
ABSTRACT
Transdermal application can be an alternative drug delivery route for ondansetron an
antiemetic drug Previous studies found that fatty acids namely oleic and lauric were
the most effective penetration enhancers The aim of this study was to investigate the
formation of an ion pair between ondansetron and lauric acid as a possible mechanism
of its enhancing action Several techniques were used to reveal the formation of an ion
pair complex Partitioning experiments where the n-octanolwater coefficient was
measured showed an increase in the distribution coefficient in the presence of the
acid possibly as a result of the formation of more lipophilic ion pairs between the
charged molecules of ondansetron and lauric acid Further evidence of complex
formation between ondansetron and lauric acid was gained from the 13C-nuclear
magnetic resonance (13C-NMR) spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their mixture
(molar ratio 11) The NMR spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized group which are the carbonyl group of the
acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This evidence substantiates
the theory of ion pair formation Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid revealed the formation of an additional compound with
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric acid which is thermody-
namically favored
Key Words Transdermal Ion pair Penetration enhancer Ondansetron
Correspondence Paraskevas P Dallas PhD Division of Pharmaceutical Technology School of Pharmacy University of Athens
Panepistimiopolis Zografou Athens 157 71 Greece Fax +30-210-7274027 E-mail dallaspharmuoagr
311
DOI 101081PDT-200031449 1083-7450 (Print) 1097-9867 (Online)
Copyright D 2004 by Marcel Dekker Inc wwwdekkercom
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
INTRODUCTION
Transdermal application can be an alternative drug
delivery route which might allow administration of
lower doses of a drug and avoidance of first-pass
metabolism It can also provide sustained and constant
plasma levels and improve patient compliance
Despite the obvious advantages of transdermal
drug delivery this route of administration presents
unique challenges The main barrier to the skin per-
meation of a drug is the stratum corneum and its
compact structure It consists of dead flattened cells
filled with keratin which are embedded in a lipid
matrix Lipids in the intercellular spaces are fatty acids
ceramides and cholesterol arranged in bilayers[1] To
overcome the problems arising from skin imperme-
ability various approaches to reversibly alter the
barrier resistance have been proposed Among these
approaches is the use of enhancers Penetration enhanc-
ers are chemical compounds that can partition and in-
teract with the stratum corneum constituents when
incorporated in a formulation Therefore they reduce
the resistance to the diffusion of the drug An ideal
penetration enhancer must be pharmacologically inert
nontoxic non-irritant nonallergenic and chemically and
physically stable Also its action must be reversible[2]
Ondansetron a carbazol antiemetic drug acts as a
competitive highly selective inhibitor of 5-HT3 seroto-
nin receptors It is used for the prevention of nausea and
vomiting associated with cancer chemotherapy and for
postoperative nausea and vomiting[3 ndash 8] It blocks the 5-
HT3 receptors at both peripheral sites in the gastroin-
testinal (GI) tract as well as within the area postrema in
the central nervous system[9] Ondansetron is adminis-
tered by intramuscular or slow intravenous injection as
hydrochloride salt per os as hydrochloride salt or base
or rectally as base Dosing varies according to the
purpose from 8 to 32 mg expressed in terms of the base
In our previous study[10] an experimental design
technique was used to estimate the effect of the type
and the concentration of the enhancer and the effect of
skin from different donors on the permeation of
ondansetron base through human cadaver epidermis
Eight penetration enhancers were studied chosen from
different chemical categories on the basis of their
effectiveness as it has been previously described in
literature[11] It was found[10] that the formulations
containing oleic or lauric acid as enhancer showed the
largest amounts of ondansetron permeated per unit area
(mgcm2) of epidermal membrane after 24 48 and 72 h
(Fig 1) Based on ondansetronrsquos pharmacokinetic data
and the oral dose the desired permeation rate was
calculated Formulations containing oleic or lauric acid
as penetration enhancers could meet the desired
transdermal permeation rate for adults It was sug-
gested that except for the direct effect of the acids on
the skin their enhancing action could also be attributed
to the formation of an ion pair between the drug and
the enhancer
The formation of more lipophilic ion pairs than the
ionized drug is one mechanism by which charged
species can be transported through the skin[1213]
Ondansetron is a weak base (pKa=74) and exists in
acidic solutions protonated as a cation Therefore it is
possible to form ion pairs with oppositely charged ions
which will subsequently partition into the stratum
corneum The chemical structures of ondansetron and
lauric acid are shown in Fig 2
Figure 1 Cumulative amount of ondansetron permeated per unit area (mgcm2) as a function of time from gel containing 5 lauric
acid and from gel without enhancer Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=5)
312 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
In the present study several techniques were used
to reveal the formation of an ion pair complex between
ondansetron and lauric acid In partitioning experi-
ments where the n-octanolwater coefficient was
measured 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectrosco-
py and thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid were used to investigate
the possibility of the complex formation
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
The materials used were ondansetron hydrochloride
(Cipla lot BX 1088 Bombay India) chloroform-D
(from Merck Darmstadt Germany) lauric acid (Sigma
St Louis MO) methanol acetonitrile (both from Lab-
Scan Dublin Ireland) ammonia 30 n-octanol
sodium chloride (all from Panreac Barcelona Spain)
potassium dihydrogen phosphate (Riedel de Haen
Seelze Germany) and chloroform (Fluka Steinheim
Switzerland) All materials were used as received
Preparation of Ondansetron Free Base
Ondansetron free base was prepared from ondanse-
tron hydrochloride For this purpose 2 g of ondansetron
hydrochloride were dissolved in 500 mL of water and
2 mL of aqueous ammonia were added Ondansetron
free base was filtered under vacuum through a ROBU-
GLAS1 filter por 4 (Andrews Glass Vineland NJ) and
washed with an aqueous solution of 5 ammonia
several times Then it was dissolved with dichloro-
methane methanol 9010 (vv) and the filtrates were
collected in a round-bottomed flask The solvents were
evaporated in a rotary evaporator Buchi rotawapor R-
2000 (Buchi Flawil Switzerland) to receive the ondan-
setron free base To assure complete removal of the
residual organic solvent the flask was left under vacuum
overnight The purity of the base was confirmed by its
melting point and 1HndashNuclear Magnetic Resonance
HPLC Method
The HPLC system consisted of a high pressure
pump (P1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA) an
autosampler (AS1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA)
equipped with a Hypersil1 CPS (150 cm46 mm 5 m)
column (ThermoHypersil Bellefonte PA) a variable
wavelength detector (Spectra 100 UVndashVis Spectra
Physics Fremont CA) set at 305 nm[1415] The data
were analyzed using the ChromQuest Chromatography
Data System (ThermoQuest San Jose CA) The
mobile phase consisting of 001 M KH2PO4 (pH=5)
acetonitrile 6040 (vv) was pumped at a flow rate of
2 mLmin The injection volume was 50 mL
Determination ofDistribution Coefficients
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron be-
tween n-octanol and phosphate buffers at 32C were
determined Phosphate buffers were prepared according
to USP 24[14] covering a pH range from 58 to 90 The
ionic strength of each buffer was adjusted to 03 M
with sodium chloride Both n-octanol and phosphate
buffers were presaturated with each other overnight
before use Five milliliters of n-octanol were mixed
with 5 mL of phosphate buffer solution containing the
drug (30 mgmL) for 24 h at 32C After phase sep-
aration by centrifugation the drug concentration in the
buffer was determined using a modified previously
described HPLC method The partitioning experiments
were performed in three different solutions in tripli-
cates making a total of nine determinations of the dis-
tribution coefficient
Because the amount of ondansetron initially used
was known its distribution coefficient (D) was cal-
culated using the following equation
D frac14 Co Caq
Caq
Vaq
Vorg
eth1THORN
where Co and Caq were the concentrations of the drug in
the aqueous phase initially and after partitioning and Vaq
and Vorg were the volumes of the aqueous and organic
phase respectively
Figure 2 Structure of (A) ondansetron (B) lauric acid
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 313
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
The effects of lauric acid on the distribution coef-
ficient were determined by the addition of 01 M of the
fatty acid to the oily phase
13C Nuclear MagneticResonance Spectroscopy
The 13C-NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid
and their mixture were examined in chloroform-D The
spectra were recorded on Bruker DRX 400 and Bruker
AC 200 spectrometers [1H (400 and 200 MHz) and 13C
(50 MHz) Chemical shifts were recorded as units
relative to tetramethylsilane as the internal standard
The NMR experiments were performed using standard
Bruker microprograms
Preparation of OndansetronLauricAcid Binary Mixtures
Mixtures of ondansetron and lauric acid covering
the entire range of composition were prepared Both
substances were accurately weighed in amber colored
glass vials and dissolved in chloroform by sonication
to allow intimate mixing of the compounds at a mo-
lecular level The solvent was removed by evaporation
under nitrogen stream at room temperature The mix-
tures were frozen at 20C for at least 48 h to crys-
tallize and equilibrate and stored at 20C
Differential ScanningCalorimetry (DSC)
To avoid mass-related artifacts specific amounts
of the mixtures (25 mg) were accurately weighed in
standard aluminum pans (Type BO 14-6117 Perkin
Elmer Germany) The pans were sealed using a
universal crimper press (Perkin Elmer Germany) to
prevent any evaporative losses and thus the composition
remained constant This means that pressure was an
unknown variable but pressure has little or no effect
on solidliquid transition and so this variable was
neglected[16] DSC measurements were carried out
against an empty pan used as a reference at a heating
rate of 10Cmin under a stream of nitrogen as purging
gas Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed on
Figure 3 Oilwater distribution coefficient D of ondansetron
into n-octanol (6) and into 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol (~)
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 4 The ratio of distribution coefficients of ondansetron
between 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol by that in n-octanol
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 5 The facilitated transport scheme of ondansetron
species between aqueous (W) and oil (O) interface
314 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
a Perkin Elmer 1020 DSC 7 Thermal Analysis System
(Perkin Elmer Germany) and the DSC curves were
recorded and analyzed by the PerkinndashElmer software
The melting characteristics measured were the peak
temperature (Tm) and the enthalpy of fusion (DH)
Enthalpies of fusion were determined from the peak area
divided by the sample weight
Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed in
triplicates In all cases the repeatability on the deter-
mination of the melting points was 05C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron between
n-octanol or n-octanol plus 01 M lauric acid and
phosphate buffers at 32C were determined The
partitioning of ondansetron in n-octanol increased as
the pH of the buffer increased (Fig 3) This is in
accordance with the pH-partitioning theory since the
amount of unionized drug increased as pH increased
The incorporation of lauric acid in the oily phase
Figure 6 The 13C-NMR of (A) lauric acid (B) ondansetron (C) mixture of ondansetron and lauric acid (11 molar ratio)
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 315
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
INTRODUCTION
Transdermal application can be an alternative drug
delivery route which might allow administration of
lower doses of a drug and avoidance of first-pass
metabolism It can also provide sustained and constant
plasma levels and improve patient compliance
Despite the obvious advantages of transdermal
drug delivery this route of administration presents
unique challenges The main barrier to the skin per-
meation of a drug is the stratum corneum and its
compact structure It consists of dead flattened cells
filled with keratin which are embedded in a lipid
matrix Lipids in the intercellular spaces are fatty acids
ceramides and cholesterol arranged in bilayers[1] To
overcome the problems arising from skin imperme-
ability various approaches to reversibly alter the
barrier resistance have been proposed Among these
approaches is the use of enhancers Penetration enhanc-
ers are chemical compounds that can partition and in-
teract with the stratum corneum constituents when
incorporated in a formulation Therefore they reduce
the resistance to the diffusion of the drug An ideal
penetration enhancer must be pharmacologically inert
nontoxic non-irritant nonallergenic and chemically and
physically stable Also its action must be reversible[2]
Ondansetron a carbazol antiemetic drug acts as a
competitive highly selective inhibitor of 5-HT3 seroto-
nin receptors It is used for the prevention of nausea and
vomiting associated with cancer chemotherapy and for
postoperative nausea and vomiting[3 ndash 8] It blocks the 5-
HT3 receptors at both peripheral sites in the gastroin-
testinal (GI) tract as well as within the area postrema in
the central nervous system[9] Ondansetron is adminis-
tered by intramuscular or slow intravenous injection as
hydrochloride salt per os as hydrochloride salt or base
or rectally as base Dosing varies according to the
purpose from 8 to 32 mg expressed in terms of the base
In our previous study[10] an experimental design
technique was used to estimate the effect of the type
and the concentration of the enhancer and the effect of
skin from different donors on the permeation of
ondansetron base through human cadaver epidermis
Eight penetration enhancers were studied chosen from
different chemical categories on the basis of their
effectiveness as it has been previously described in
literature[11] It was found[10] that the formulations
containing oleic or lauric acid as enhancer showed the
largest amounts of ondansetron permeated per unit area
(mgcm2) of epidermal membrane after 24 48 and 72 h
(Fig 1) Based on ondansetronrsquos pharmacokinetic data
and the oral dose the desired permeation rate was
calculated Formulations containing oleic or lauric acid
as penetration enhancers could meet the desired
transdermal permeation rate for adults It was sug-
gested that except for the direct effect of the acids on
the skin their enhancing action could also be attributed
to the formation of an ion pair between the drug and
the enhancer
The formation of more lipophilic ion pairs than the
ionized drug is one mechanism by which charged
species can be transported through the skin[1213]
Ondansetron is a weak base (pKa=74) and exists in
acidic solutions protonated as a cation Therefore it is
possible to form ion pairs with oppositely charged ions
which will subsequently partition into the stratum
corneum The chemical structures of ondansetron and
lauric acid are shown in Fig 2
Figure 1 Cumulative amount of ondansetron permeated per unit area (mgcm2) as a function of time from gel containing 5 lauric
acid and from gel without enhancer Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=5)
312 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
In the present study several techniques were used
to reveal the formation of an ion pair complex between
ondansetron and lauric acid In partitioning experi-
ments where the n-octanolwater coefficient was
measured 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectrosco-
py and thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid were used to investigate
the possibility of the complex formation
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
The materials used were ondansetron hydrochloride
(Cipla lot BX 1088 Bombay India) chloroform-D
(from Merck Darmstadt Germany) lauric acid (Sigma
St Louis MO) methanol acetonitrile (both from Lab-
Scan Dublin Ireland) ammonia 30 n-octanol
sodium chloride (all from Panreac Barcelona Spain)
potassium dihydrogen phosphate (Riedel de Haen
Seelze Germany) and chloroform (Fluka Steinheim
Switzerland) All materials were used as received
Preparation of Ondansetron Free Base
Ondansetron free base was prepared from ondanse-
tron hydrochloride For this purpose 2 g of ondansetron
hydrochloride were dissolved in 500 mL of water and
2 mL of aqueous ammonia were added Ondansetron
free base was filtered under vacuum through a ROBU-
GLAS1 filter por 4 (Andrews Glass Vineland NJ) and
washed with an aqueous solution of 5 ammonia
several times Then it was dissolved with dichloro-
methane methanol 9010 (vv) and the filtrates were
collected in a round-bottomed flask The solvents were
evaporated in a rotary evaporator Buchi rotawapor R-
2000 (Buchi Flawil Switzerland) to receive the ondan-
setron free base To assure complete removal of the
residual organic solvent the flask was left under vacuum
overnight The purity of the base was confirmed by its
melting point and 1HndashNuclear Magnetic Resonance
HPLC Method
The HPLC system consisted of a high pressure
pump (P1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA) an
autosampler (AS1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA)
equipped with a Hypersil1 CPS (150 cm46 mm 5 m)
column (ThermoHypersil Bellefonte PA) a variable
wavelength detector (Spectra 100 UVndashVis Spectra
Physics Fremont CA) set at 305 nm[1415] The data
were analyzed using the ChromQuest Chromatography
Data System (ThermoQuest San Jose CA) The
mobile phase consisting of 001 M KH2PO4 (pH=5)
acetonitrile 6040 (vv) was pumped at a flow rate of
2 mLmin The injection volume was 50 mL
Determination ofDistribution Coefficients
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron be-
tween n-octanol and phosphate buffers at 32C were
determined Phosphate buffers were prepared according
to USP 24[14] covering a pH range from 58 to 90 The
ionic strength of each buffer was adjusted to 03 M
with sodium chloride Both n-octanol and phosphate
buffers were presaturated with each other overnight
before use Five milliliters of n-octanol were mixed
with 5 mL of phosphate buffer solution containing the
drug (30 mgmL) for 24 h at 32C After phase sep-
aration by centrifugation the drug concentration in the
buffer was determined using a modified previously
described HPLC method The partitioning experiments
were performed in three different solutions in tripli-
cates making a total of nine determinations of the dis-
tribution coefficient
Because the amount of ondansetron initially used
was known its distribution coefficient (D) was cal-
culated using the following equation
D frac14 Co Caq
Caq
Vaq
Vorg
eth1THORN
where Co and Caq were the concentrations of the drug in
the aqueous phase initially and after partitioning and Vaq
and Vorg were the volumes of the aqueous and organic
phase respectively
Figure 2 Structure of (A) ondansetron (B) lauric acid
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 313
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
The effects of lauric acid on the distribution coef-
ficient were determined by the addition of 01 M of the
fatty acid to the oily phase
13C Nuclear MagneticResonance Spectroscopy
The 13C-NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid
and their mixture were examined in chloroform-D The
spectra were recorded on Bruker DRX 400 and Bruker
AC 200 spectrometers [1H (400 and 200 MHz) and 13C
(50 MHz) Chemical shifts were recorded as units
relative to tetramethylsilane as the internal standard
The NMR experiments were performed using standard
Bruker microprograms
Preparation of OndansetronLauricAcid Binary Mixtures
Mixtures of ondansetron and lauric acid covering
the entire range of composition were prepared Both
substances were accurately weighed in amber colored
glass vials and dissolved in chloroform by sonication
to allow intimate mixing of the compounds at a mo-
lecular level The solvent was removed by evaporation
under nitrogen stream at room temperature The mix-
tures were frozen at 20C for at least 48 h to crys-
tallize and equilibrate and stored at 20C
Differential ScanningCalorimetry (DSC)
To avoid mass-related artifacts specific amounts
of the mixtures (25 mg) were accurately weighed in
standard aluminum pans (Type BO 14-6117 Perkin
Elmer Germany) The pans were sealed using a
universal crimper press (Perkin Elmer Germany) to
prevent any evaporative losses and thus the composition
remained constant This means that pressure was an
unknown variable but pressure has little or no effect
on solidliquid transition and so this variable was
neglected[16] DSC measurements were carried out
against an empty pan used as a reference at a heating
rate of 10Cmin under a stream of nitrogen as purging
gas Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed on
Figure 3 Oilwater distribution coefficient D of ondansetron
into n-octanol (6) and into 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol (~)
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 4 The ratio of distribution coefficients of ondansetron
between 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol by that in n-octanol
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 5 The facilitated transport scheme of ondansetron
species between aqueous (W) and oil (O) interface
314 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
a Perkin Elmer 1020 DSC 7 Thermal Analysis System
(Perkin Elmer Germany) and the DSC curves were
recorded and analyzed by the PerkinndashElmer software
The melting characteristics measured were the peak
temperature (Tm) and the enthalpy of fusion (DH)
Enthalpies of fusion were determined from the peak area
divided by the sample weight
Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed in
triplicates In all cases the repeatability on the deter-
mination of the melting points was 05C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron between
n-octanol or n-octanol plus 01 M lauric acid and
phosphate buffers at 32C were determined The
partitioning of ondansetron in n-octanol increased as
the pH of the buffer increased (Fig 3) This is in
accordance with the pH-partitioning theory since the
amount of unionized drug increased as pH increased
The incorporation of lauric acid in the oily phase
Figure 6 The 13C-NMR of (A) lauric acid (B) ondansetron (C) mixture of ondansetron and lauric acid (11 molar ratio)
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 315
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
In the present study several techniques were used
to reveal the formation of an ion pair complex between
ondansetron and lauric acid In partitioning experi-
ments where the n-octanolwater coefficient was
measured 13C nuclear magnetic resonance spectrosco-
py and thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid were used to investigate
the possibility of the complex formation
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Materials
The materials used were ondansetron hydrochloride
(Cipla lot BX 1088 Bombay India) chloroform-D
(from Merck Darmstadt Germany) lauric acid (Sigma
St Louis MO) methanol acetonitrile (both from Lab-
Scan Dublin Ireland) ammonia 30 n-octanol
sodium chloride (all from Panreac Barcelona Spain)
potassium dihydrogen phosphate (Riedel de Haen
Seelze Germany) and chloroform (Fluka Steinheim
Switzerland) All materials were used as received
Preparation of Ondansetron Free Base
Ondansetron free base was prepared from ondanse-
tron hydrochloride For this purpose 2 g of ondansetron
hydrochloride were dissolved in 500 mL of water and
2 mL of aqueous ammonia were added Ondansetron
free base was filtered under vacuum through a ROBU-
GLAS1 filter por 4 (Andrews Glass Vineland NJ) and
washed with an aqueous solution of 5 ammonia
several times Then it was dissolved with dichloro-
methane methanol 9010 (vv) and the filtrates were
collected in a round-bottomed flask The solvents were
evaporated in a rotary evaporator Buchi rotawapor R-
2000 (Buchi Flawil Switzerland) to receive the ondan-
setron free base To assure complete removal of the
residual organic solvent the flask was left under vacuum
overnight The purity of the base was confirmed by its
melting point and 1HndashNuclear Magnetic Resonance
HPLC Method
The HPLC system consisted of a high pressure
pump (P1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA) an
autosampler (AS1000 Spectra Physics Fremont CA)
equipped with a Hypersil1 CPS (150 cm46 mm 5 m)
column (ThermoHypersil Bellefonte PA) a variable
wavelength detector (Spectra 100 UVndashVis Spectra
Physics Fremont CA) set at 305 nm[1415] The data
were analyzed using the ChromQuest Chromatography
Data System (ThermoQuest San Jose CA) The
mobile phase consisting of 001 M KH2PO4 (pH=5)
acetonitrile 6040 (vv) was pumped at a flow rate of
2 mLmin The injection volume was 50 mL
Determination ofDistribution Coefficients
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron be-
tween n-octanol and phosphate buffers at 32C were
determined Phosphate buffers were prepared according
to USP 24[14] covering a pH range from 58 to 90 The
ionic strength of each buffer was adjusted to 03 M
with sodium chloride Both n-octanol and phosphate
buffers were presaturated with each other overnight
before use Five milliliters of n-octanol were mixed
with 5 mL of phosphate buffer solution containing the
drug (30 mgmL) for 24 h at 32C After phase sep-
aration by centrifugation the drug concentration in the
buffer was determined using a modified previously
described HPLC method The partitioning experiments
were performed in three different solutions in tripli-
cates making a total of nine determinations of the dis-
tribution coefficient
Because the amount of ondansetron initially used
was known its distribution coefficient (D) was cal-
culated using the following equation
D frac14 Co Caq
Caq
Vaq
Vorg
eth1THORN
where Co and Caq were the concentrations of the drug in
the aqueous phase initially and after partitioning and Vaq
and Vorg were the volumes of the aqueous and organic
phase respectively
Figure 2 Structure of (A) ondansetron (B) lauric acid
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 313
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
The effects of lauric acid on the distribution coef-
ficient were determined by the addition of 01 M of the
fatty acid to the oily phase
13C Nuclear MagneticResonance Spectroscopy
The 13C-NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid
and their mixture were examined in chloroform-D The
spectra were recorded on Bruker DRX 400 and Bruker
AC 200 spectrometers [1H (400 and 200 MHz) and 13C
(50 MHz) Chemical shifts were recorded as units
relative to tetramethylsilane as the internal standard
The NMR experiments were performed using standard
Bruker microprograms
Preparation of OndansetronLauricAcid Binary Mixtures
Mixtures of ondansetron and lauric acid covering
the entire range of composition were prepared Both
substances were accurately weighed in amber colored
glass vials and dissolved in chloroform by sonication
to allow intimate mixing of the compounds at a mo-
lecular level The solvent was removed by evaporation
under nitrogen stream at room temperature The mix-
tures were frozen at 20C for at least 48 h to crys-
tallize and equilibrate and stored at 20C
Differential ScanningCalorimetry (DSC)
To avoid mass-related artifacts specific amounts
of the mixtures (25 mg) were accurately weighed in
standard aluminum pans (Type BO 14-6117 Perkin
Elmer Germany) The pans were sealed using a
universal crimper press (Perkin Elmer Germany) to
prevent any evaporative losses and thus the composition
remained constant This means that pressure was an
unknown variable but pressure has little or no effect
on solidliquid transition and so this variable was
neglected[16] DSC measurements were carried out
against an empty pan used as a reference at a heating
rate of 10Cmin under a stream of nitrogen as purging
gas Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed on
Figure 3 Oilwater distribution coefficient D of ondansetron
into n-octanol (6) and into 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol (~)
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 4 The ratio of distribution coefficients of ondansetron
between 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol by that in n-octanol
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 5 The facilitated transport scheme of ondansetron
species between aqueous (W) and oil (O) interface
314 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
a Perkin Elmer 1020 DSC 7 Thermal Analysis System
(Perkin Elmer Germany) and the DSC curves were
recorded and analyzed by the PerkinndashElmer software
The melting characteristics measured were the peak
temperature (Tm) and the enthalpy of fusion (DH)
Enthalpies of fusion were determined from the peak area
divided by the sample weight
Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed in
triplicates In all cases the repeatability on the deter-
mination of the melting points was 05C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron between
n-octanol or n-octanol plus 01 M lauric acid and
phosphate buffers at 32C were determined The
partitioning of ondansetron in n-octanol increased as
the pH of the buffer increased (Fig 3) This is in
accordance with the pH-partitioning theory since the
amount of unionized drug increased as pH increased
The incorporation of lauric acid in the oily phase
Figure 6 The 13C-NMR of (A) lauric acid (B) ondansetron (C) mixture of ondansetron and lauric acid (11 molar ratio)
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 315
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
The effects of lauric acid on the distribution coef-
ficient were determined by the addition of 01 M of the
fatty acid to the oily phase
13C Nuclear MagneticResonance Spectroscopy
The 13C-NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid
and their mixture were examined in chloroform-D The
spectra were recorded on Bruker DRX 400 and Bruker
AC 200 spectrometers [1H (400 and 200 MHz) and 13C
(50 MHz) Chemical shifts were recorded as units
relative to tetramethylsilane as the internal standard
The NMR experiments were performed using standard
Bruker microprograms
Preparation of OndansetronLauricAcid Binary Mixtures
Mixtures of ondansetron and lauric acid covering
the entire range of composition were prepared Both
substances were accurately weighed in amber colored
glass vials and dissolved in chloroform by sonication
to allow intimate mixing of the compounds at a mo-
lecular level The solvent was removed by evaporation
under nitrogen stream at room temperature The mix-
tures were frozen at 20C for at least 48 h to crys-
tallize and equilibrate and stored at 20C
Differential ScanningCalorimetry (DSC)
To avoid mass-related artifacts specific amounts
of the mixtures (25 mg) were accurately weighed in
standard aluminum pans (Type BO 14-6117 Perkin
Elmer Germany) The pans were sealed using a
universal crimper press (Perkin Elmer Germany) to
prevent any evaporative losses and thus the composition
remained constant This means that pressure was an
unknown variable but pressure has little or no effect
on solidliquid transition and so this variable was
neglected[16] DSC measurements were carried out
against an empty pan used as a reference at a heating
rate of 10Cmin under a stream of nitrogen as purging
gas Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed on
Figure 3 Oilwater distribution coefficient D of ondansetron
into n-octanol (6) and into 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol (~)
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 4 The ratio of distribution coefficients of ondansetron
between 01 M lauric acid in n-octanol by that in n-octanol
Each value is the meanplusmnSD (n=3)
Figure 5 The facilitated transport scheme of ondansetron
species between aqueous (W) and oil (O) interface
314 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
a Perkin Elmer 1020 DSC 7 Thermal Analysis System
(Perkin Elmer Germany) and the DSC curves were
recorded and analyzed by the PerkinndashElmer software
The melting characteristics measured were the peak
temperature (Tm) and the enthalpy of fusion (DH)
Enthalpies of fusion were determined from the peak area
divided by the sample weight
Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed in
triplicates In all cases the repeatability on the deter-
mination of the melting points was 05C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron between
n-octanol or n-octanol plus 01 M lauric acid and
phosphate buffers at 32C were determined The
partitioning of ondansetron in n-octanol increased as
the pH of the buffer increased (Fig 3) This is in
accordance with the pH-partitioning theory since the
amount of unionized drug increased as pH increased
The incorporation of lauric acid in the oily phase
Figure 6 The 13C-NMR of (A) lauric acid (B) ondansetron (C) mixture of ondansetron and lauric acid (11 molar ratio)
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 315
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
a Perkin Elmer 1020 DSC 7 Thermal Analysis System
(Perkin Elmer Germany) and the DSC curves were
recorded and analyzed by the PerkinndashElmer software
The melting characteristics measured were the peak
temperature (Tm) and the enthalpy of fusion (DH)
Enthalpies of fusion were determined from the peak area
divided by the sample weight
Thermal analysis of the mixtures was performed in
triplicates In all cases the repeatability on the deter-
mination of the melting points was 05C
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The distribution coefficients of ondansetron between
n-octanol or n-octanol plus 01 M lauric acid and
phosphate buffers at 32C were determined The
partitioning of ondansetron in n-octanol increased as
the pH of the buffer increased (Fig 3) This is in
accordance with the pH-partitioning theory since the
amount of unionized drug increased as pH increased
The incorporation of lauric acid in the oily phase
Figure 6 The 13C-NMR of (A) lauric acid (B) ondansetron (C) mixture of ondansetron and lauric acid (11 molar ratio)
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 315
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
increased in a statistically significant (plt005) fashion
the distribution coefficient over the whole pH range
58ndash90 (Fig 3) In Fig 4 the ratio of the distribution
coefficient in n-octanol plus lauric acid divided by that in
n-octanol versus pH is shown[1718] As pH increases
over 82 the ratio increases because over this value
ondansetron is unionized It is remarkable though that
the ratio takes its maximum value around pH 66 where
predominates the ionized form of the drug
According to the pH-partition theory only union-
ized molecules can permeate through lipophilic mem-
branes In fact the permeation of charged species
purely by passive diffusion is very slow due to its
unfavorable partitioning into the membrane However
transfer of ionized molecules can be facilitated by the
presence of carrier molecules in the membrane and
formation of more lipophilic ion pairs[19 ndash 23] Ion pairs
are defined as neutral species formed only by electro-
static attraction between oppositely charged ions
which are sufficiently lipophilic to dissolve in lipoidal
medium such as stratum corneum[24]
In a similar manner it was assumed that ondanse-
tron forms ion pairs with lauric acid At pH 66 where
the ratio takes its largest value ion pairing is most
effective as the drug exists predominately in its ionized
form and the fatty acid is also ionized
The facilitated transport scheme is illustrated in
Fig 5 The carrier molecules lauric acid were
incorporated in n-octanol At pH values of the aqueous
donor phase above the pKa of the acid the fatty acid
molecules present at the aqueousoil interface will
ionize Subsequently the carboxylate anions will form
electrically neutral ion pairs in the interfacial region
with the drug cations arriving from the aqueous phase
which can partition into the organic phase[25]
Further evidence of complex formation between
ondansetron and fatty acids could be gained from the
NMR spectra of ondansetron lauric acid and their
mixture (ondansetronlauric acid molar ratio 11) in
CDCl3 The formation of a complex might be expected
to affect the magnetic environment of the carbon atom
of the carbonyl group of lauric acid as well as the
adjacent to this carbon atoms In the same way it is
expected to affect the carbon atoms adjacent to the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron[26] The13C-NMR spectra in CDCl3 of these compounds are
shown in Fig 6 A closer examination of these spectra
indicated a significant change in the chemical shift of
the carbon atoms of lauric acid The peak at 18054 ppm
of the carbon 1 (Fig 2B) of the carbonyl group shifted to
17782 ppm in the mixture (Fig 6) Also a shift from
3410 to 3488 ppm was observed for the carbon atom 2
(Fig 2B) adjacent to the carbonyl group The compar-
ison between the spectra of the ondansetron and the
mixture indicated a shift from 12713 to 12559 ppm for
the carbon atom 4rsquo (Fig 2A) adjacent to the nitrogen of
the imidazole ring of ondansetron Also a shift from
1315 to 1242 ppm was observed for the methylene
carbon on the imidazole ring (Fig 2A) The shifts
observed are tabulated in Table 1
As previously stated the formation of the ion
pair proceeds through the interaction between of the
charged molecules that is between the carbonyl group
of the fatty acid and the nitrogen of the imidazole ring
of ondansetron From the results obtained it is evident
that there are alterations in the magnetic environment
of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized groups
This fact empowers the assumption of the interaction
between the two substances and the formation of an
ion pair This is of particular significance for the
penetration mechanism because the ion pair complex is
implicated in the mechanism on the enhanced perme-
ation of ondansetron through human epidermis
Thermal analysis[27] of the mixtures of ondanse-
tron and lauric acid was used to further enlighten the
mode of action of the fatty acid on the transdermal
permeation of ondansetron
Sample DSC traces of the mixtures are shown in
Fig 7 Also the phase diagram of ondansetronndashlauric
acid binary systems is depicted in Fig 8 where tem-
perature was plotted versus the composition of the
mixtures In such diagrams the temperature below
which the system is completely solid is called the
solidus temperature Also the temperature above which
the system is a homogenous liquid is mentioned as the
liquidus temperature Points in the temperaturecompo-
sition phase diagram enclosed by the solidus and
liquidus lines represent two phase systems with the
component in excess as solid in equilibrium with a
homogenous liquid mixture[28]
The melting point of pure ondansetron (Fig 7
peak A) was 21982C it decreased with the addi-
tion of lauric acid and it attained a minimum (Fig 7
peak B) at 17625C Lauric acid also exhibited as
a single sharp endotherm (Fig 7 peak C) at 4331Cand the melting point decreased with the addition of
Table 1 Chemical shifts from 13C-NMR spectra
Compound
Chemical shift (ppm)
Carbon atom (Fig 1)
1 2 4rsquo ndashCH3
Lauric acid 18054 3410 ndash ndash
Ondansetron ndash ndash 12713 1316
Mixture 17782 3488 12559 1242
316 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
ondansetron taking the minimum value (Fig 7 peak
D) at 3950C
The other endothermic peaks that were observed
can be attributed to[29]
1 A phase transition in any one of the pure
components before they melt
2 An eutectic reaction between ondansetron and
lauric acid at this temperature
3 The formation of an additional compound
between ondansetron and lauric acid
Peaks between 43 and 79C vanished after a
heatingcoolingheating cycle and therefore they
can be attributed to metastable phases of lauric acid
On the contrary peak E was present after the same
heatingcoolingheating cycle If the endothermic
peak E corresponded to a eutectic formation the DSC
Figure 7 Sample DSC traces of ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures The labels represent the percentage (ww) of ondansetron
in each binary mixture Sixty percent (ww) ondansetron is the 11 molar mixture
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 317
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
traces should have exhibited the characteristic double
peaks of these systems for all compositions except
from the eutectic composition because continuous
dissolution of one of the solid phases would take
place In this case the first endotherm peak would
correspond to the solidus temperature and the second
broad endotherm peak would be the liquidus temper-
ature As it can be concluded from Fig 7 this peak
does not follow the characteristic eutectic pattern
All the above-mentioned conclusions along with
closer examination of the compositiontemperature
phase diagram clearly indicate that thermal event E
represents a solid complex of ondansetron and lauric
acid From the phase diagram it can be concluded that
the complex is too unstable to have its own recognized
melting point and dissociation may occur before this
temperature is reached Such a system is called peri-
tectic[2930] The melting point of the complex is
7981C and has an enthalpy of fusion of 1648
(plusmn023) Jg compared to ondansetron with melting
point 21982C and an enthalpy of fusion of 15356
(plusmn1790) Jg As previously stated a reduction on the
melting point of a substance will have a direct effect
on its solubility in the skin lipids and consequently on
its transdermal permeation[2831]
The enthalpies of fusion of the pure compounds
and the molecular complex can be used to obtain in-
formation about the nature of the interaction[32 ndash 34] If
the system is assumed to be a simple mechanical mixture
of the two components the heat of mixing is calculated
using the mixture using the following equation
DHcalc frac14 Xond DHond thorn Xlauric DHlauric eth2THORN
where X and DH are the mole fraction and the heat of
fusion of ondansetron and lauric acid as shown by the
subscript The calculated and the experimental DH
values are shown in Table 2 The difference between
these values is called heat of mixing DHm and it can give
useful information about the thermal events and the
structure of the system Negative values of DHm indicate
clustering of the molecules in the system and positive
DHm values propose a quasi-eutectic system If DHm
equals zero the formation of a molecular solution is
suggested[32 ndash 34] Table 2 shows that calculated values of
heat of fusion are higher than the experimental values
Thus the negative value of the heat of mixing suggests
clustering of the molecules in the ondansetronlauric
acid system
Furthermore the entropy of fusion (DS) of the pure
components and the complex can be calculated using
the following equation[33]
DS frac14 DH
Teth3THORN
where DH is the enthalpy of fusion and T is the
melting temperature The values of the entropy of
fusion are shown in Table 2 The positive values in
all cases indicate an increase in the randomness of
the binary system after mixing the substances Never-
theless the calculated values for the entropy of fu-
sion of the complex were higher compared to the
experimental value This suggests an ordering in the
complex melting as a result of an interaction be-
tween ondansetron and lauric acid forming the addi-
tional compound
The results show that the enhancing effect of the
fatty acids on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only to their direct effect on
Table 2 Experimental and calculated heat of fusion and
entropy of fusion data for the ondansetronlauric acid bi-
nary system
Ondansetron
Lauric
acid
Addition
compound
Enthalpy of
fusion (KJ mol1)
Experimental 4505 868 847
Calculated ndash ndash 2551
Heat of mixing ndash ndash 1704
Entropy of
fusion (J mol1K1)
Experimental 9140 11381 2400
Calculated ndash ndash 7230
Figure 8 The temperaturecomposition phase diagram of
ondansetronlauric acid binary mixtures as determined by
DSC traces A) Homogenous liquid B) liquid+solid ondanse-
tron C) liquid+solid addition compound D) solid
318 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between ondansetron and lauric acid
CONCLUSIONS
Lauric acid was effective as a penetration enhancer
for the transdermal delivery of ondansetron The
possibility of the formation of ion pair between the drug
and lauric acid was investigated For this reason the
distribution coefficients of ondansetron in n-octanol
phosphate buffer with the presence of lauric acid were
measured The experimental data suggest that the
distribution coefficient effectively increases and a
possible explanation is the formation of more lipophilic
ion pairs between the charged molecules of ondansetron
and lauric acid Furthermore the 13C Nuclear Magnetic
Resonance spectra revealed alterations to the magnetic
environment of the carbon atoms adjacent to the ionized
group that is the carbonyl group of the fatty acid and the
nitrogen of the imidazole ring of ondansetron This
evidence empowers the theory of ion pair formation
Finally thermal analysis of the binary mixtures of
ondansetron and lauric acid and the construction of
compositiontemperature phase diagrams revealed the
formation of an addition compound This complex has a
different melting point from pure ondansetron and lauric
acid and its formation is thermodynamically favored
It is evident therefore that the enhancing effect of
lauric acid on the transdermal permeation of ondanse-
tron can be attributed not only on its direct effect on
the skin structure but also to the formation of an ion
pair between the drug and the enhancer
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank associate professor Dr Kyriakos
Viras from the Division of Physical Chemistry
Department of Chemistry University of Athens for
his contribution on explaining the DSC traces They
also thank lecturer Dr Prokopios Magiatis from the
Division of Pharmacognosy and Natural Products
Chemistry Department of Pharmacy University of
Athens for his help with the identification of
NMR spectra
REFERENCES
1 Elias PM Stratum corneum revisited J Derma-
tol 1999 23 756ndash7582 Pfister WR Hsieh DST Permeation enhancers
compatible with transdermal drug delivery sys-
tems Part I selection and formulation consider-
ations Pharm Technol 1990 14 (9) 132ndash1393 Llacer JM Gallardo V Parera A Ruiz MA
Formation of ondansetron polymorphs Int J
Pharm 1999 177 221ndash2294 Roila F Favero DA Ondansetron clinical
pharmacokinetics Clin Pharmacokinet 1995 29
(2) 95ndash1095 Simpson KH Hicks FM Clinical pharmaco-
kinetics of ondansetron A review J Pharm
Pharmacol 1996 48 774ndash7816 Cothhup PV Felgate CC Palmer JL Scully
NL Determination of ondansetron in plasma and
its pharmacokinetics in the young and elderly J
Pharm Sci 1991 80 (9) 868ndash8717 Llacer JM Ruiz MA Parera A Gallardo V
Adsortionndashdesorption of ondansetron on latex
particles Drug Dev Ind Pharm 2000 26 (3)237ndash242
8 wwwfdagovmedwatchsafety2000dec00htm
(accessed July 2002)
9 Anderson PO Knoben JE Troutman WG
Handbook of Clinical Drug Data Appleton amp
Lange Connecticut 1999 519
10 Dimas DA Dallas PP Rekkas DM Use of an
8132 asymmetrical factorial design for the in vitro
evaluation of ondansetron permeation through
human epidermis Pharm Dev Technol in press
11 Walters KA Hadgraft J Pharmaceutical Skin
Penetration Enhancement Marcel Dekker New
York 1993
12 Quintanar-Guerrero D Allemann E Fessi H
Doelker E Applications of the ion-pair concept
to hydrophilic substances with special emphasis
on peptides Pharm Res 1997 14 (2) 119ndash12713 Lee SJ Kurihara-Bengstrom T Kim SW Ion-
paired drug diffusion through polymer membranes
Int J Pharm 1987 47 59ndash7314 The United States Pharmacopeia 24 United States
Pharmacopeial Convention Rockville MD 2000
1218ndash1220 2231ndash2232
15 Takahashi K Rytting JH Approach to improve
permeation of ondansetron across shed snake skin
as a model membrane J Pharm Pharmacol 200153 789ndash794
16 Stott PW Williams AC Brian BW Mecha-
nistic study into the enhanced transdermal perme-
ation of a model b-blocker propanolol by fatty
acids a melting point depression effect Int J
Pharm 2001 219 161ndash17617 Green PG Hadgraft J Facilitated transfer of
cationic drugs across a lipoidal membrane by oleic
Ion Pair Formation for Enhancement Effect of Lauric Acid 319
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly
acid and lauric acid Int J Pharm 1987 37 251ndash255
18 Green PG Guy RH Hadgraft J In vitro and
in vivo enhancement of skin permeation with
oleic lauric acids Int J Pharm 1988 48 103ndash111
19 Barker N Hadgraft J Facilitated percutaneous
absorption a model system Int J Pharm 1981 8193ndash202
20 Hadgraft J Walters KA Wotton RK Facili-
tated percutaneous absorption a comparison and
evaluation of two in vitro models Int J Pharm
1986 32 257ndash26321 Green PG Hadgraft J Wolff M Physico-
chemical aspects of the transdermal delivery of
bupranolol Int J Pharm 1989 55 259ndash26522 Pardo A Shin Y Cohen S Kinetics of
transdermal penetration of an organic ion pair
physostigmine salicylate J Pharm Sci 1992 81990ndash995
23 Valenta C Siman U Kratzel M Hadgraft J
The dermal delivery of lignocaine influence of ion
pairing Int J Pharm 2000 197 77ndash8524 Hatanaka T Kamon T Morigaki S Katayama
K Koizumi T Ion pair skin transport of a
zwitterionic drug cephalexin J Control Release
2000 66 63ndash7125 Neubert R Ion pair transport across membranes
Pharm Res 1989 6 (9) 743ndash74726 Ogiso T Shintani M Mechanism for the
enhancement effect of fatty acids on the percuta-
neous absorption of propanolol J Pharm Sci
1990 79 (12) 1065ndash107127 Dollimore D Lerdkanchanaporn S Thermal
analysis Anal Chem 1998 70 27Rndash35R28 Stott PW Williams AC Barry BW Trans-
dermal delivery from eutectic systems enhanced
permeation of a model drug ibuprofen J Control
Release 1998 50 297ndash30829 Mahedran KH Nagaraj S Sridharan R
Gnanasekaran T Differential scanning calorimet-
ric studies on the phase diagram of the binary
LiClndashCaCl2 system J Alloys Compd 2001 32578ndash83
30 Ford JA Timmins P Pharmaceutical Thermal
Analysis John Wiley amp Sons Inc New York
1989 25ndash68
31 Touitou E Chow DD Lawter JR Chiral b-
blockers for transdermal delivery Int J Pharm
1994 104 19ndash2832 Rai US George S Thermochemical studies on
the eutectics and addition compounds in the binary
systems of benzidine with p-nitrophenol m-
aminophenol and resorcinol Thermochim Acta
1994 243 17ndash2533 Rai US Shekhar H Some physicochemical
studies on the binary organic eutectics Thermo-
chim Acta 1991 175 215ndash22734 Rai US George S Physicochemical studies on
organic eutectics and the 11 addition compound
benzidinendasha-napthol system J Mater Sci 199227 17ndash25
Received June 13 2003
Accepted September 15 2003
320 Dimas Dallas and Rekkas
Phar
mac
eutic
al D
evel
opm
ent a
nd T
echn
olog
y D
ownl
oade
d fr
om in
form
ahea
lthca
rec
om b
y U
nive
rsity
of
Lav
al o
n 07
16
14Fo
r pe
rson
al u
se o
nly