Upload
dana-patterson
View
214
Download
1
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
SOME THINGS WE NEED TO KNOW ISRAEL LEDERHENDLER, PH.DNATIONAL INSTITUTES OF HEALTH
EVALUATION 2009NOVEMBER 12, 2009
Managing information overload
Outputs and Outcomes Exploiting knowledge; Finding disruptive ideas
Scientist are entrepreneursMaking ideas count
Measuring Innovation
It’s Almost Always About Innovation
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
Factors Driving NIH Decisions
Public Interest and Societal Demands
Public Health Requirements
Scientific Opportunities
NIH Funding Priorities
Funding Priorities of
Institutes and Centers
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
APPLICATION PEER REVIEW PROGRAM & COUNCIL
GRANTS MANAGEMENT
PROGRAM: PRE & POST AWARD
Title Summary Statement RFAs, RFPs, PA’s Special Actions
Notice of Grant Award
Progress reports, checklist
Abstract Merit Evaluation Funding Recommendation
Terms & conditions Workshops, conferences
Specific Aims Evaluate Specific Aims
Administrative Actions
Checklist Scientific Initiatives
Research Methods Significance Impact Initiatives, mission relevance
Training Data
Personnel Expert Roster Roster Administrative Assistance
Technical Scientific Assistance
Budget Request Budget considerations
Final budget approval Budgetary Adjustments & Oversight
Scientific Oversight
Institution Bars, regulations Institute Policy Regulatory compliance oversight
Opportunities, trends, gaps
Docu
men
ts a
nd
Decis
ion
sNIH Data is Mostly Generated from the Grants Business Process
Str
uctu
red
Data
Un
str
uctu
red
Da
ta
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
Office of the NIH Director
Publications & Biomedical Progress
Databases
(examples)
Think Tanks (examples)
Reports to Congress Conference Abstracts Thomson ISI NAS/Institute of Medicine
Reporting
Data Calls
Medline Scopus RAND
Scientific Coding
Portfolio Analysis
PubMed Central Ovid Families USA
Trans-NIH Initiatives Research Advances Gene Ontology ResearchAmerica!
Workforce &
Infrastructure
Clinical Trials Swiss-Prot IDA/STPI
Budget Preparation Drugs, Diagnoses & Treatments
ClinicalTrials.Gov NIH Consensus Conference
Policy
Policy Analysis
Treatment Guidelines
Additional Data from Analysis and Other sources
Ou
tpu
ts a
nd
Ou
tco
me
s
Data External to Grants Database
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
Publications & Citations Data
Adoption and diffusion of academic ideas
History and structure of scientific communities
Identification of disruptive ideas
DIMENSIONS OF INNOVATION
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
Validity
Data quality
New communication media
PUBLICATION AND CITATION DATACan’t live without it
Lederhendler, Nov 2009
Adoption and Diffusion Science of Networks
Describe the evolution and structure of scientific communities
History and Structure of a FieldLederhendler, Nov 2009
This visualization tracing citations shows that two seminal papers in 2002 and 2003 are widely cited in the community.Visual Overviews for Discovering Key Papers and Influences Across Research Fronts. Aleks Aris1, Ben Shneiderman1, Vahed Qazvinian2, and Dragomir Radev2 – thanks to Ping Want
EVALUATING IMPACT
IDENTIFYING DISRUPTIVE IDEAS
Lederhendler, Nov 2009