Upload
others
View
6
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Oct. 2009slide1
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Overview of ITI proposals from Spain
Marco Freire, Marco Guglielmi
Oct. 2009slide2
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Outline of Presentation
i Overview of ITI
i Statistics on Spanish ITI proposals
i Conclusions
Oct. 2009slide3
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Introduction – ITI characteristics
A mechanism, originally set-up by ESA in 2004, to support the introduction and fast validation of innovative concepts or
technologies for space applications.
i Implemented through a continuously opened Call for Ideas with a standing Evaluation Board meeting periodically
i Proposal submitted through simple online templatesShort “time to contract”
i Aims specifically at technologies novel to space
What is ITI:
ITI main characteristics:
Oct. 2009slide4
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Developer: An entity that has the know-how to develop the idea to “space” standards
Customer: an entity that canactually use the idea in “space products”
Inventor: an R&D entity that is not necessarilyinvolved in space already
The “Innovation Triangle” concept states that a rapid and successful introduction of disruptive innovations in Industry requires the collaboration of three different entities: an INVENTOR, a DEVELOPER and a CUSTOMER.
Introduction – the Innovation Triangle Concept
Oct. 2009slide5
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
The ITI contains three basic types of activities aimed at the different elements of the triangle:
i (A) Proof of Concept (for INVENTORS): fast validation of new ideas and demonstration of its advantages (<= 50 K€)
i (B) Demonstration of Feasibility and Use (for DEVELOPERS): component and/or breadboard development up to validation in the laboratory or in a relevant environment (<= 150K€)
i (C) (New Type) Technology Adoption (for CUSTOMERS):component and/or breadboard development up to validation in a relevant environment, with the final objective of including the technology developed in the Customer’s services, products or processes (<= 2 M€ (50% Co-funded))
Introduction to ITI: The 3 Types of Activities
Oct. 2009slide6
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Current Status
i First 4 AOs of ITI (2004-07) resulted in 358 proposals submitted; 85 were approved = 8.0M€ of committed contracts (~24% accept. rate)
i Last year: 77 proposals were submitted in reply to the 2008 AO of ITI; 25 proposals approved (3M€)! (Type C proposals not included).
i Current Status of 2009 AO: 3rd evaluation round on-going.
3.0 *33.3% *25*77… 2008
1.6429.4%1551… 2007
1.3918.1%1372… 2006
2.7129.9%2997… 2005
2.2719.7%27137… 2004
Total value [M€]
Approvalrate
Proposalsapproved
Proposalssubmitted
ITI AO of…
* Not including 2 Type C proposals
Oct. 2009slide7
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Current status
i These 5 years of operation of ITI have shown that ITI is indeed a valid instrument to support innovation in Space by:
Fostering collaboration between different type of companiesFinancing rapid validation of innovative ideasSupporting spin-in of technologies from non-space sectorsITI is cost-effective, given the modest level of funding in individual projects. ITI is a valuable tool that fills a significant gap in the program landscape of ESA.
Oct. 2009slide8
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
The ITI Brochure
i The ITI Brochure is published once per year in order to cover the ITI activities concluded in the last 12 months
i The aim of this brochure is to enhance visibility on the expertise and innovation capability of the industry and academic organizations being supported by ITI and to foster the use of their technologies
Oct. 2009slide9
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
ITI proposals per ESA MS and their current status
43440700324
48%59514040United Kingdom
63%132308Switzerland
0%30003Sweden
7%4512042Spain
42%3446024Portugal
20%71105Norway
33%2433018Netherlands
0%20101Luxemburg
21%110910091Italy
100%101405Ireland
17%71006Greece
67%60717036Germany
38%3655026France
67%50203Finland
0%50005Denmark
20%60105Belgium
33%81106Austria
% of successTotalcompletedon-going
under reviewRejectedMS \ Status
Oct. 2009slide10
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
List of rejected ITI proposals from Spain1. A00007902 - PASSIVE MULTI MODE DAMPING OF COMPOSITE STRUCTURES2. B00007562 - Scalable Multi-Purpose Video for UAS in BLOS scenarios3. B00008082 - Pulsar-based autonomous navigation system (PULNAV) 4. A00006942 - III-V SAW filters on diamond substrates - Electric Sail Numerical Demonstration5. A00005742 - Optical Fiber based sensor system for extreme Temperatures6. A00006042 - DAMPING OF COMPOSITE STRUCTURES WITH MAGNETOSTRICTIVE MATERIALS 7. B00006142 - SURFACE NANO-ENGINEERING OF PASSIVATED HEAT SHIELDS FOR PLANETARY RE-ENTRY8. B00006242 - IR Camera for Navigation purposes9. B00005466 – Compact microwave filter10. A00005242 - VOICEOPS: Voice Technologies in Spacecraft Operations11. A00005483 - A Dust Wiper mechanism for cleaning large Solar pannels based on SMA actuators and Teflon microfibers12. A00004421 - DYNAMICS INTERACTIONS13. A00004905 - THERMAL TORQUER14. B00003987 - Advanced Tracking System (ATS) for LEO satellites 15. B00004727 - Sequential Switching Shunt (Maximum Power) Regulation with High Parasitic Capacitance Solar Arrays16. B00004769 - Feasibility study of an Integrated Wearable Monitoring System for Astronauts (IMoSA)17. B00004866 - eGlobe.Feeder - Feasibility and Use of Space Imaging Product Feeds into Globe Visualization Internet Consumer Services18. B00004982 - Robust mission-independent G&C for launcher: application to VEGA-derived vector19. B00003987– “Advanced Tracking System (ATS) for LEO satellites”20. B00003621– “Advance Gyroscopic Actuator Engineering Model”21. A00003603– “Advanced Gyroscopic Actuator (AGA). Technological Demonstrator”22. B00003604– “Auto-rotation based concept feasibility for Mars descending and landing”23. B00003661– “Technical Feasibility of Coherently Radiating Periodic Structures (CORPS)”24. B00003702– “Asteroid Penetrators Precise Deployment”25. C00003623– “Use of an Advance Gyrocope Actuator (AGA) in a 150 kg satellite”26. A00003206– “Exploitation of application of ECSS standards into non space industrial sectors”27. A00003343– “A COMPACT SYSTEM FOR THE THERMAL CONTROL OF SPACECRAFTS”28. B00002882– “DRLFC - DETECTION AND REWORKING OF LEAD-FREE COMPONENTS”29. B00003001– “Feasibility study of a SEE LASER based test facility”30. B00003203– “Development of an animal in-vivo metabolic imager for scientific space missions”31. B00003383– “Auto-rotation based system for Mars descending and landing”32. A00001642 – “A NOVEL APPROACH FOR AUTONOMOUS LANDING AND OPERATION OF ROVERS ON THE SURFACE OF MARS”33. B00002341– “Advanced Materials for high frecuency filters”34. B00002381– “UAV Rotorcraft Configuration and GNC Design for Mars Exploration”35. B00002421– “Multi-agent Planning and Scheduling for a Space System Formation”36. B00002422– “Three-Axis Infra Red (IR) based Earth Sensor with Novel Coastal Line Recognition”37. A00000945 – “Bubble Injector by a Collapsing Free Surface”38. B00001421 – “Advanced Gyroscopic Actuator (AGA). Technological Demonstrator”39. B00001682 – “Geodesic dome for phased array antennas”40. A00000381 – “Metamaterial Based Coaxial and Waveguide Filters”41. A00000501 – “Dual use of autonomous space habitats concept study”42. B00000973 – “Advanced Blind Pedestrian Navigator for Mobile Phones”
15 Type A
26 Type B
1 Type C
Oct. 2009slide11
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Main Reasons for Rejection
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Multipl
r-sub
misssio
nSys
tem Study
No Clea
r Solu
tion
Wrong I
TI Typ
eLa
ck of
Nov
elty
Technic
al Con
tentLim
ited re
levanc
e
Other
Oct. 2009slide12
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
i Verify the compliance to the ITI scope
i Contact first potential Space Customers to confirm interest or to identify problematic issues linked to concrete applications before formulating proposals
i Do not apply for Type B if the basic idea is not yet proven (target Type A first to establish credibility for new technologies)
i Contact ESA technical experts, for guidance on novelty and relevance
i Propose a specific solution to be implemented (no trade-offs or system studies allowed)
Oct. 2009slide13
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
ITI proposal (A, B or C)
Is the proposal aSystem Study?
Out of scope
YES
YES
YES
NO
Evaluation by ESA
TypeA, B or C?
A
B C
Conceptdemonstrated?
Clear IndustrialInterest?
Feasibilitydemonstrated?
YES
DelegationSupport?
YES
YES
YES
Customercommitment?
B/GIPR usable forESA purposes ?
NO
NO
YES
Out of scope
YES
Problem andapplication well
identified?
NO
Is an assessmentat Sys tem levels till required?
NO
NOYES
Previously reject edand not updated?
NO
NO
NO
NO
Oct. 2009slide14
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
i Verify the compliance to the ITI scope
i Contact first potential Space Customers to confirm interest or to identify problematic issues linked to concrete applications before formulating proposals
i Do not apply for Type B if the basic idea is not yet proven (target Type A first to establish credibility for new technologies)
i Contact ESA technical experts, for guidance on novelty and relevance
i Propose a specific solution to be implemented (no trade-offs or system studies allowed)
Oct. 2009slide15
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
Oct. 2009slide16
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
i Verify the compliance to the ITI scope
i Contact first potential Space Customers to confirm interest or to identify problematic issues linked to concrete applications before formulating proposals
i Do not apply for Type B if the basic idea is not yet proven (target Type A first to establish credibility for new technologies)
i Contact ESA technical experts, for guidance on novelty and relevance
i Propose a specific solution to be implemented (no trade-offs or system studies allowed)
Oct. 2009slide17
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
Oct. 2009slide18
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Advice for preparing a "good proposal“ to ITI
i Verify the compliance to the ITI scope
i Contact first potential Space Customers to confirm interest or to identify problematic issues linked to concrete applications before formulating proposals
i Do not apply for Type B if the basic idea is not yet proven (target Type A first to establish credibility for new technologies)
i Contact ESA technical experts, for guidance on novelty and relevance
i Propose a specific solution to be implemented (no trade-offs or system studies allowed)
Oct. 2009slide19
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Conclusions
i Unfortunately, many ITI proposals submitted by Spanish entities were not successful
i Understanding better the ITI selection process and scope will result in more ITI contracts for the Spanish Industry and Academia
i In the future, we would like very much to keep receiving ITI proposals from Spain, and to be able to award ITI contracts.
i Therefore, our goal today is to help you by clarifying the scope and selection process of ITI and to answer any other questions you may have regarding the submission of ITI proposals.
Oct. 2009slide20
ESA Innovation Triangle Initiative (ITI)
Spanish ITI Proposals, CDTI
Thank you for your attention!