S.O.S e - Voice For Justice - e-news weeklySpreading the light of humanity & freedomEditor: agara!a.".#.. Vol.$$..%ssue.&'........(()*+)(*$, -%. / Judges please don0t play 1od IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA ORIGINAL JURISDICTIONCRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. OF 2015IN THE MATTER OF NAGARAJA . M.R editor SOS e C!rio" o# D!it $ SOS e %oi&e #or J'(ti&e) LIG 2 * No +,1 ** HUDCO Fir(t St!-e * L!./i0!"t!"!-!r *He11! * M2(ore 3 5+001+ * 4!r"!t!0! St!te.....Petitio"er%er('( Ho"o'r!1e C5ie# J'(ti&e o# I"di! $ Ot5er( ....Re(6o"de"t( PETITION UNDER ARTICLE 12 to ARTICLE 75 $ ARTICLE 51A OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA FOR ISSUANCE OF A WRIT IN THE NATURE OF MANDAMUS UNDER ARTICLE 72 $ ARTICLE 22, OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA. To *Ho"81e T5e C5ie# J'(ti&e o# I"di! !"d Hi( Lord(5i68( Co/6!"io"J'(ti&e( o# t5e S'6re/e Co'rt o# I"di!. T5e H'/1e 6etitio" o# t5ePetitio"er !1o9e "!/ed.MOST RESPECTFULL: SHOWETH ;1. F!&t( o# t5e &!(e;'e(t( #or ri-5t * '"1i!(ed 6ro(e&'tio" * e>'it!1e ?'(ti&e #or !.H. A9er/e"t;A.W5!t !&tio" !-!i"(t d!=ood I1r!5i/ $ ti-er /e//o" @ =5!t!&tio" !-!i"(t /i"i(ter( * 6oi&e * #i/ 6er(o"!itie(=5o 5!9e tie( =it5 d!=ood $ !tte"ded6!rtie( 5o(ted 12 d!=oodL -'# @ =52 "o !&tio" !-!i"(t t5e/ @ =52 "o !&tio" !-!i"(t 6er(o"( (tori"- !r/( * !//'"itio" #or Bo/1!2 1!(t( @ =52 t!d! &5!r-e( =ere di'ted #or (o/e i"#'e"ti! &ri/i"!(@ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.B. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to t5o(e re(6o"(i1e #or1'r"i"- S!1!r/!ti e.6re(( tr!i"6!((e"-er( @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.C.W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e #or t5o(e /!(ter /i"d( $ too( re(6o"(i1e #or -od5r! riot( @ =52 "ot -'?!r!t5(t!te -o9er"/e"t !66e!ed to 5i-5er &o'rt (ee0i"- de!t5 (e"te"&e to6er6etr!tor( o# -od5r! riot( @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.D. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to t5o(e re(6o"(i1e #or/'rderi"- RTI !&ti9i(t( * =5i(te 1o=er(@ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.E.W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to t5o(e re(6o"(i1e #or/'rderi"- =5i(te 1o=er( (!t2e"dr! d'1e2 $ IOCL M!"?'"!t5@ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.F.W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to t5o(e re(6o"(i1e #orBo/1!2 riot( 6rior toBo/1!2 1o/1 1!(t( @i" (o/e &!(e( (t!te -o9er"/e"t * 6ro(e&'tio" e9e" =it5dre= &!(e( !-!i"(t rioter( * #ied MBN re6ort( &o(i"- t5e &!(e(* i" (o/e &!(e( 6ro(e&'tio" #!ied to 6ro6er2 6re(e"t =it"e((e( * e9ide"&e( 1e#ore &o'rt !"d i" (o/e &!(e( #!ied to !66e! to 5i-5er &o'rt(. 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.G. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to t5o(e re(6o"(i1e #or(i05 /!((!&re i" de5i !#ter !((!((i"!tio" o# PM I"dir! G!"d5i @i" (o/e &!(e( (t!te -o9er"/e"t * 6ro(e&'tio" e9e" =it5dre= &!(e( !-!i"(t rioter( * #ied MBN re6ort( &o(i"- t5e &!(e( * i" (o/e &!(e( 6ro(e&'tio" #!ied to 6ro6er2 6re(e"t =it"e((e( * e9ide"&e( 1e#ore &o'rt !"d i" (o/e &!(e( #!ied to !66e! to 5i-5er &o'rt(.. 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.H. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to 1ot5/!(ter /i"d( $ too( o# !te PM R!?i9 G!"d5i !((!((i"!tio" &!(e @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.I. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&etoSTF 6oi&e 6er(o""e=5o r!" ! 6!&e &!ed M=or0(5o6Ni" MM Hi( * 4!r"!t!0!. STF Poi&e 6er(o""e d'ri"- o6er!tio" to "!1 #ore(t 1ri-!"d 9eer!66!" !66ied 9er2 &r'e* i"5'/!" 7rd de-ree tort're /et5od( o" tri1!( * i""o&e"t( to e.tr!&t #!(e &o"#e((io"( !t t5i( 6!&e &!ed =or0(5o6. So/e i""o&e"t( died '"!1e to 1e!r t5e tort're 12 6oi&e. T5i( &r'e !&t =!( 6ro9ed 1e#ore (t!t'tori2&o"(tit'ted 5'/!" ri-5t( &o//i((io" ?'d-e * (ti "o de!t5 (e"te"&e to STF Poi&e 6er(o""e * =52 @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t. J. W52 "ot de!t5 (e"te"&e to 6oi&e o##i&i!( re(6o"(i1e #or &od 1ooded/'rder( * #!0e e"&o'"ter( * o&0 '6 de!t5( * t5ird de-ree tort're o# i""o&e"t( @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t. Re#er TORTURE CHAMBERS OF INDADD 5tt6(;CC(ite(.-oo-e.&o/C(iteC(o(e9oi&e#or?'(ti&eCt5irdGde-reeGtort'reGo#G&5ie#G?'(ti&eGo#Gi"di!G0!r"!t!0!Gd-6G'"io"G5o/eG(e&ret!r2 *5tt6(;CC(ite(.-oo-e.&o/C(iteCe&!rio"o#d!itCtort'reG&5!/1er(Go#Gi"di!K.W52 "ot -o9er"/e"t 6!2 &o/6e"(!tio"to &i9ii!" 9i&ti/(o# terrori(t !&t( * riot( @ =52 do"At -o9er"/e"t 6!2 !66ro6ri!tere(6e&t * re&o-"itio" * &o/6e"(!tio" to 6oi&e * (e&'rit2 * /iit!r2 6er(o""e=5o !2 do=" t5eir i9e( i" t5e i"e o# d't2 -'!rdi"- o'r /ot5er!"d $ o'r 1ret5re" @L.W52 e"ie"t 6'"i(5/e"tto !66ro9er( i" (o/e &!(e( * 1't "ot to 2!0'1 /e//o" @ :!0'1 /e//o" 5e6ed 6ro(e&'tio" i" -!t5eri"- e9ide"&e( re-!rdi"- Bo/1!2 1o/1 1!(t &!(e * (ti "o e"ie"&2 12 &o'rt * =52 @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.M.W52 "o !&tio" !-!i"(t &orr'6t * &ri/i"! ?'d-e( $ 6oi&e=5o doe("At do t5eir d'tie( * =5o doe("At -i9e i"#or/!tio"'"der RTI * =5o doe("At !d/it * 5e!r PIL !66e!( t5ere126rote&ti"- t5e &ri/i!"( @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t. Re!d NOTICETOCJI5tt6;CC===.(&ri1d.&o/Cdo&C2+7+22O,0CW!0eG'6GC5ie#GJ'(ti&eGo#GI"di!* 5tt6(;CC(ite(.-oo-e.&o/C(iteCe&!rio"o#d!itC6iGGG"oti&eGtoG&?iN. U"i9er(! L!= * I"di!" != 6ro&!i/( terrori(/ * !idi"- $ !1etti"- terrori(/ ! &ri/e. W52 doe( t5e I"di!" -o9er"/e"t !-e"&ie( !id( $ !1et( &o'"ter terrori(t -ro'6( i" ?!//' 4!(5/ir * "ort5 e!(t (t!te( o# i"di! @ =52 (t!te -o9er"/e"t $ I"di!" -o9er"/e"t ('66ort( * !id(SALWA JUDUM ! &o'"ter terrori(t * !"ti "!.!ite o't#it=5i&5i( ?oi"t2 re(6o"(i1e #or terrori(/ i" &5!tti(-!r5 (t!te @ =52 t!/i"!d' (t!te -o9er"/e"t $ I"di!" -o9er"/e"t!idedt!/i terrori(t(i" (ri!"0! @ =52 I"di!" -o9er"/e"t i( !idi"- terror o't#it( i" !#-5!"i(t!" $ P!0i(t!" @ =52 i"di!" -o9er"/e"t ('66orted terrori(t(i" e!(t P!0i(t!" * 'ti/!te2 &re!ti"- P!0i(t!" @! t5e(e d!(t!rd2 * &r'e !&t( o# i"di!" -o9er"/e"t 5!( re('ted i" 1ood(5ed * (ti re('ti"- i" o(( o# "'/ero'( i""o&e"t i9e(.W52 do"At I"di!" -o9er"/e"t /i"d itA( o=" 1'(i"e(( @ i"di! 5!( e"o'-5 do/e(ti& 6ro1e/( to (o9e * =52 do"Att5e -o9er"/e"t '(e t!. 6!2erA( /o"e2 to (o9e do/e(ti& 6ro1e/( i"(te!d o#i"ter#eri"-i" ot5erA( !##!ir(re('ti"- i" 1ood(5ed @ =52 NOT De!t5 Se"te"&e to 6ri/e /i"i(ter o# i"di! $ 6re(ide"t o# i"di! !t t5o(e ti/e( re(6o"(i1e #or !'t5oriPi"-!idto terrori(t( @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t.O. L!te Mr.W!rre" A"der(o"=!(i" &o"troo# B5o6!U"ited C!r1ide 6!"t * t5ro'-5 i"ter"! (!#et2 &5e&0( $7rd 6!rt2 !'dit(5e =!( 6ri92 to -!ri"- (!#et2 !6(e( o" 6!rt o# '"io" &!r1ide /!"!-e/e"t. Sti 5e &5o(e to 0ee6 /'/* =5i&5 re('ted i" B5o6! -!( tr!-ed2 0ii"- t5o'(!"d( o# i""o&e"t( * /!i/i"- !05( o# 5'/!" 1ei"-( $ (ti e9e" "e= 1or" 1!1ie( i" t5e o&!it2 !re &o"tr!&ti"- !i/e"t(. Co'rte(2 Mr.A"der(o". S'&5 ! 1't&5er A"der(o" =!( !rre(ted 12 o&! 6oi&e '"der /!" (!'-5ter &5!r-e( * 6rod'&ed 1e#ore &o'rt. Ho=e9er/i"i(ter( * -o9er"/e"t o##i&i!( o# 1ot5 (t!te $ &e"tr! -o9er"/e"t(=it5o'torder( * 6er/i((io" #ro/ t5e &o'rtie-!2 -ot 5i/ o't o# ?!i !rr!"-ed ! (6e&i! &!r * (6e&i! !ero6!"e#or t5e &'6rit to e(&!6e #ro/ !=. :e!r( !#ter=!rd( * ! CJI o# ('6re/e &o'rt o# i"di! di'ted t5e /!" (!'-5ter &5!r-e( !-!i"(tMr.A"der(o". W52 "o de!t5 (e"te"&e to A"der(o" re(6o"(i1e #or de!t5 $ ('##eri"-( o# !05( o# 6eo6e @ =52 "o det5 (e"te"&e to &5ie# /i"i(ter * /i"i(ter * 6oi&e * o##i&i!( =5o 5e6ed A"der(o" e(&!6e #ro/ I"di!" != @ =52 "o de!t5 (e"te"&e to CJI =5o di'ted &5!r-e( !-!i"(t A"der(o" @ 1i!(ed != e"#or&e/e"t. I" t5e 1!&0dro6 o# !1o9e &!(e( * t5e #!&t i( o'r e-! (2(te/ i( i/6er#e&t * error 6ro"e. T5ere#ore * it /'(t 1e&o/e 6ro#e((io"! * 6er#e&t i" itA( d't2 #ir(t * to 6'"i(5 ! t5e =ro"- doer(. Ti * ('&5 ! ti/ede!t5 6e"!t2 /'(t 1e 0e6t o" 5od or !1oi(5ed. I# it &!""At * !t t5e e!(t it &!" -i9e &5oi&e o# de!t5 to &o"9i&t( i0e de!t5 12 (ee6i"- 6i or i"?e&tio" or -'" (5ot * et& i"(te!d o# /edie9! 5!"-i"-. Here12 * I do re>'e(t t5e 5o"or!1e ('6re/e &o'rt o# I"di! to &o"(ider t5i( !( ! PIL #or ; M=rit o# M!"d!/'(N!"d to i(('e i"(tr'&tio"( to t5e &o"&er"ed 6'1i& (er9!"t( i" t5e #oo=i"- &!(e( to 6er#or/ t5eir d'tie( $ to !"(=er t5e >'e(tio"(. T5e Petitio"er 5!( (e"t /!"2 etter( C !66e!( C 6etitio"( to ('6re/e &o'rt o# i"di! $ ot5er &o'rt( t5ro'-5 eG/!i * DARPG =e1(ite $ t5ro'-5 re-'!r /!i re>'e(ti"- t5e/ to &o"(ider t5o(e !( PIL(. B't "o"e o#t5e/ =ere!d/itted * e9e" !&0"o=ed-e/e"t #or re&ei6t( =ere "ot -i9e". See Ho= d't2 &o"(&io'( *o'r ?'d-e( !re $ (ee 5o= o'r ?'d-e( !re (e"(iti9e to=!rd( i#e * i1ert2 o# &itiPe"( * &o//o" /e" $ (ee 5o= &!ree(( o'r ?'d-e( !re to=!rd( !"ti "!tio"! &ri/e( * &ri/e( =ort5 &rore( o# r'6ee(. T5!t t5e 6re(e"t 6etitio"er 5!( "ot #ied !"2 ot5er 6etitio" J=5i&5 !re !d/itted 12 &o'rt(K i" !"2 Hi-5 Co'rt or t5e S'6re/e Co'rt o# I"di! o" t5e ('1?e&t /!tter o# t5e 6re(e"t 6etitio".PRA:ER;I" t5e !1o9e 6re/i(e(* it i( 6r!2ed t5!t t5i( Ho"81e Co'rt /!2 1e 6e!(ed;! . Here12 * I do re>'e(t t5e 5o"or!1e ('6re/e &o'rt o# I"di! to &o"(ider t5i( !( ! PIL #or ; M=rit o# M!"d!/'(N !"d to i(('e i"(tr'&tio"( to t5e &o"&er"ed 6'1i& (er9!"t( i" t5e #oo=i"- &!(e( to 6er#or/ t5eir d'tie( $ to !"(=er t5e >'e(tio"(.1 . to 6!(( ('&5 ot5er order( !"d #'rt5er order( !( /!2 1e dee/ed "e&e((!r2 o" t5e #!&t( !"d i" t5e &ir&'/(t!"&e( o# t5e &!(e. & . to !1oi(5 de!t5 6e"!t2 or to -i9e &5oi&e o# de!t5 to &o"9i&t(.d . To e-!2 6ro(e&'te !'t5oritie( o# ('6re/e &o'rt o# i"di! #or "ot !"(=eri"- (5o= &!'(e "oti&e i(('ed to t5e/ !"d order t5e/ to !"(=er t5e (5o= &!'(e "oti&e !( =e !( RTI >'e(tio"( -i9e" to t5e/ 12 t5e 6etitio"er. FOR WHICH ACT OF 4INDNESS* THE PETITIONER SHALL BE DUT: BOUND* E%ER PRA:. D!ted ; Ft5 A'-'(t 2015 DDDDDD..FILED B:; NAGARAJA.M.R.P!&e ; M2('r' * I"di!DDDDDDDD.PETITIONERGINGPERSON 5hy the 4eath -enalty should 6e a6olished2he risk of e7ecuting innocent people e7ists in any !ustice systemT5ere 5!9e 1ee" !"d !=!2( =i 1e &!(e( o# e.e&'tio"( o# i""o&e"t 6eo6e. No /!tter 5o= de9eo6ed ! ?'(ti&e (2(te/ i(* it=i !=!2( re/!i" ('(&e6ti1e to 5'/!" #!i're. U"i0e 6ri(o" (e"te"&e(* t5e de!t5 6e"!t2 i( irre9er(i1e !"d irre6!r!1e. 2he ar6itrary application of the death penalty can ne8er 6e ruled outT5e de!t5 6e"!t2 i( o#te" '(ed i" ! di(6ro6ortio"!/!""er !-!i"(t t5e 6oor*/i"oritie( !"d /e/1er( o# r!&i!*et5"i&*6oiti&! !"d rei-io'( -ro'6(. 2he death penalty is incompati6le with human rights and human dignityT5e de!t5 6e"!t2 9io!te( t5e ri-5t to i#e =5i&5 5!66e"( to 1e t5e /o(t 1!(i& o# ! 5'/!" ri-5t(. It !(o 9io!te( t5e ri-5t"ot to 1e ('1?e&ted to tort're !"d ot5er &r'e* i"5'/!"e or de-r!di"- tre!t/e"t or 6'"i(5/e"t. F'rt5er/ore* t5e de!t56e"!t2 '"der/i"e( 5'/!" di-"it2 =5i&5 i( i"5ere"t to e9er2 5'/!" 1ei"-. 2he death penalty does not deter crime effecti8elyT5e de!t5 6e"!t2 !&0( t5e deterre"t e##e&t =5i&5 i( &o//o"2 re#erred to 12 it( !d9o&!te(. A( re&e"t2 (t!ted 12 t5eGe"er!A((e/12 o# t5e U"ited N!tio"(*Mt5ere i( "o &o"&'(i9e e9ide"&e o# t5e deterre"t 9!'e o# t5e de!t5 6e"!t2NJUNGA Re(o'tio" ,5C20,K.It i( "ote=ort52 t5!t i" /!"2 rete"tio"i(t (t!te(* t5e e##e&ti9e"e(( o# t5e de!t5 6e"!t2 i"order to 6re9e"t &ri/e i( 1ei"- (erio'(2 >'e(tio"ed 12 ! &o"ti"'o'(2 i"&re!(i"- "'/1er o# != e"#or&e/e"t 6ro#e((io"!(. -u6lic opinion is not a ma!or stum6ling 6lock for a6olitionP'1i& ('66ort #or t5e de!t5 6e"!t2 doe( "ot "e&e((!ri2 /e!" t5!t t!0i"- !=!2 t5e i#e o# ! 5'/!" 1ei"- 12 t5e (t!te i(ri-5t. T5ere !re '"di(6'ted 5i(tori&! 6re&ede"&e( =5ere -ro(( 5'/!" ri-5t( 9io!tio"( 5!d 5!d t5e ('66ort o# ! /!?orit2 o#t5e 6eo6e* 1't =5i&5 =ere &o"de/"ed 9i-oro'(2 !ter o". It i( t5e ?o1 o# e!di"- #i-'re( !"d 6oiti&i!"( to '"deri"e t5ei"&o/6!ti1iit2 o# &!6it! 6'"i(5/e"t =it5 5'/!" ri-5t( !"d 5'/!" di-"it2.It "eed( to 1e 6oi"ted o't t5!t 6'1i& ('66ort #or t5e de!t5 6e"!t2 i( i"e.tri&!12 i"0ed to t5e de(ire o# t5e 6eo6e to 1e#ree #ro/ &ri/e. Ho=e9er* t5ere e.i(t /ore e##e&ti9e =!2( to 6re9e"t &ri/e. Judiciary 6iased against poor: Justice Saldanha O"2 &'6rit( #ro/ &ert!i" (e&tio"( o# t5e (o&iet2 !re -i9e" de!t5 (e"te"&e i" I"di! =5ie t5e ri&5 !"d i"#'e"ti! !re (6!red t5e -!o=(* o1(er9ed #or/er 5i-5 &o'rt ?'d-e J'(ti&e M F S!d!"5!. Addre((i"- != (t'de"t( o# JSS L!= Coe-e !t !" orie"t!tio" 6ro-r!//e 5ere o" Mo"d!2* 5e r'ed t5!t t5e ?'(ti&e (2(te/ i(1i!(ed !-!i"(t (o&ioGe&o"o/i&!2 1!&0=!rd &!((e(.