7/30/2019 Judging Criteria for the Innovative Eco Product
Competition SAEYLS 2013
1/1
POOR AVERAGE GOOD TOTAL
(0-1) (2-3) (4-5) MARKS
1 CON TENT O bj ective
Productshowsaveryvague
purpose/noneatall.
Productshowsobjective
butitisnotjustified
clearly.
Productshowsaclear
andcomprehensive
objective.
Information
Insufficientinformationand
doesnotsupporttheproduct'sobjective.
Informationisnotthat
clearor
understandable,and
evidenceprovidedisreasonable.
Clearinformationthat
containsevidence
whichsupportstheproduct'sobjective.
Significanceof
project
Productonlypertainsoraffects
certainindividuals.
Productaffectsasmall
groupofcommunity.
Productproduces
impactfulresultstoa
widerangeof
community.
Commercialvalue
ofproduct
Theproductiscostly,notvery
practical,andwillnotattract
anybuyers.
Theproductiscostly
butpracticalandwill
attractbuyers.
Theproductis
reasonableinprice,
practical,andwill
attractbuyers.
Workmanshipof
product
Theproductpreparedisuntidy
andnotverysturdy.
Theproductpreparedis
sturdybutnotneatly
prepared.
Theproductpreparedis
bothsturdyandskilfully
prepared.
2
MULTI-
MEDIADESIGN Text
Mosttextaredifficulttoread
withlengthyparagraphsand
darkbackgrounds.
Someofthetextare
readablewhilesome
haveblendedintothe
background.
Textisclearand
readable,in
appropriatelengthand
suitablebackground
colour.
Layout
Thelayoutiscluttered,
confusinganddoesnotenhance
readability.
Thelayoutuseswhite
spacesappropriately.
Thelayoutisvisually
pleasingand
contributestothe
overallmessage.
Flowof
Information
Flowofinformationisconfusing
andflawed.
Flowofmost
informationisclearand
direct.
Flowofallinformation
isclearanddirect.
Useofmultimedia
Graphic,soundoranimation
seemsunrelatedtothetopic
anddoesnotenhancethe
overallconcept.
Graphic,soundand
animationassiststhe
audiencein
understandingthe
overallconcept.
Graphic,soundand
animationofpower
pointassistsin
presentationand
enhancesthe
understandingofthe
overallconcept.
Technical
Mostofthepowerpoint
contentsarenotfunctional.
Someofthepowerpointcontentsare
dysfunctional.
Allofthepowerpointcontentsarefunctional
andappeasing.
3
DELIVERYOF
PRESEN-TATION
Verbal/non-verbal
communication
Inactiveorsloppyuseoftone,
volume,eyecontact,posture,
handgestureandarticulation.
Appropriateuseof
tone,volume,eye
contact,posture,hand
gestureandarticulation
butfailsincapturingthe
audience.
Useofappropriate
tone,volume,eye
contact,posture,hand
gestureand
articulation.
Confidenceof
presenter
Presentershowsthelackof
confidenceandunsureofthe
factsthathastobepresented.
Presenterisnotthat
confidentbutpresents
factssurely.
Presenterdisplays
strongconfidenceand
isabletoinducethe
audience.
Knowledgecontent
ofpresenter Insufficientwithalotofgaps.
Reasonableamountof
knowledge.
Sufficientamountof
knowledge.
Creativity
Thepresentationwasnotvery
effectiveorprofessional.
Thepresentationwas
professionalbutnottoo
effective.
Thepresentationwas
bothprofessionaland
effective.
Appealtoaudience
Unabletoengagethe
audience'sinterest.
Abletoengagethe
audience'sinterest.
Abletoengagethe
audience,raiseinterest
andpromote
interactionbetween
speakerandlistener.
Q&A
Unabletoaddressorexplain
questionsraisedbyaudience.
Abletoaddressor
explainmostofthe
questionsraisedby
audience.
Abletogivea
satisfactoryexplanation
orresponcetoall
questionsraised.
Timemanagement
Doesnotendwithinthetime
limitandnosmoothflowof
presentation.
Endswithintimelimit
butnosmoothflowof
presentation.
Endswithintimelimit
andsmoothflowof
presentation.
4 CITATIO N Cre dits Nosourceswerecited.
Mostofthesources
wereproperlycited.
Allsourcewere
properlycited.
5 TEAMWORK Cooperation
Mostmembersdidnotgive
cooperation.
Somemembersgave
cooperation.
Allmembersgavefull
cooperation.
Commitment
Memberswerenotcommitted
andproactive.
Somemembersshowed
commitmentandwere
proactive.
Memberswereall
committedand
proactive.
