Upload
jesus-rincon-garcia
View
230
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
1/36
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.
Department of Strength of Materialsand Structural Engineering
Experimental Mechanics ofAdvanced Materials
and Structures
Semester Fall 2013
Marco A. Prez
Lecture 4 Strain gages: instrumentation
and data analysis (Part II)
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
2/36
Syllabus
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
3/36
Contents Todays lecture
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Selection criteria for strain gages Types of strain gages Uniaxial and biaxial stress states Technical data The Wheatstone bridge circuit Strain measurements analysis Summary References
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
4/36
Selection criteria for strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.2?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
The questions that should be considered during the selectionof a type of strain gage, arise due to the variety of straingage applications and due to the conditions affecting thestrain gages during service. There is no strain gage thatfulls all requirements. For this reason numerous different
strain gages are available and are supplemented with specialtypes when required. The selection system presented hererequires the user to analyse his measurement problem. Tworequirements must be fullled:
1. The measurement task must have a clear objectiveand the details of the process and its boundaryconditions must be known.
2. The strain gage characteristicsmust be known.
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
5/36
Types of strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.A?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Strain gages are available in various
shapes and sizes. Apart fromdifferent lengths of the measuringgrid there are various designs andpositions for the connections.
There is also a difference betweenlinear strain gages in single anddouble (parallel) arrangements, Xrosettes with measurement gridaxes at 90 to one another, Rrosettes with 3 measuring gridaxes arranged at certain angles toone another, strain gage chainsand numerous other special shapes.
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
6/36
Types of strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.I?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
7/36
Types of strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.J?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
8/36
Types of strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.K?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
9/36
It is formed by a multiple strain gages withcrossinggrid axes. X rosettes (2measuringgrids whose axes intersect at 90) are used forthe investigation of biaxial stress conditions
with known principal directions. R rosettes(3measuring grids) are used for the analysis ofbiaxial stress conditions where the maindirections are unknown, both qualitatively and
quantitively. There are two basic shapes whichdiffer due to the angular interval between theirmeasuring grids: 0/45/90 and 0/60/120.With star or cross-shaped rosettes themeasuring grids are arranged over one another.
Types of strain gages
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.L?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
10/36
150
300300
600
750
900
1050
150
450450
600
750
900
1050
00
!
00
!
015
!
030
!
In uniaxial stress state, the
maximum of the tension orcompression stresses acts inthe direction in which the forceacts. In all other directions the
stresses are smaller and followthe relationship:
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.MN?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
11/36
In problems in experimental analysis the uniaxial stress stateis more the exception rather than the rule.
For reliable results in uniaxialtest the active direction ofthe force must be knownand the strain must be measured in
this direction. If this direction is unknown or only knownapproximately, then the measurements and their evaluationshould be carried out with the biaxial stress state withunknown principal directions.
The biaxial stress state is met far more often and itsdetermination should not be undertaken with the simplemethod used for the uniaxial stress state; this would lead tosignicant errors.
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.MM?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
12/36
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.M>?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
13/36
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.M@?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
14/36
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.M2?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
15/36
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.MA?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
16/36
Uniaxial and biaxial stress states
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.MI?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
17/36
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
18/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.MK?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
19/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.ML?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
20/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>N?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
21/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>M?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
22/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>>?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
23/36
Technical data
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>@?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
24/36
The Wheatstonebridge can be used
for the determination of relativechanges in resistance. For strainmeasurements, R1 = R2and R3 = R4.
The Wheatstone bridge circuit
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>2?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
1+$(.#+ 2 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
25/36
The above equation assume that all the resistance in the
bridge change. This situation occurs for example intransducers or with test objects performing a similarfunction. In experimental stress analysis this is hardly everthe case and usually only some of the arms of the bridge
contain activestrain gages, the remainder being made up ofbridge completion resistors. Designations for the variousforms such as (a) quarter bridge, (b) half bridge, (c)double quarter or diagonal bridge and (d) full bridgeare common place.
The Wheatstone bridge circuit
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>A?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
5 5 : ; =
(b)(a) (c) (d)
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
26/36
The elementary loading cases normal (tensile,compressive loading), bending and torsion occur veryseldom, if at all, in a pure form. Usually the loading cases aresuperimposed to some extent whether this is desired or not.
In the following the options for the determination of pureor
combined loadings are discussed. The arrangements of thestrain gages on the object and within the Wheatstone bridgeplay a signicant role here.
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>I?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
5 5 : ; =
Special attention should be paid to the sign
of the measured strains.
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
27/36
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>J?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
5 5 : ; =
This s ing l e l ong i tud ina l gageconguration will respond to bendingloads but is unaffected by torsionalloads if the gage is mounted on thecentreline. Care must be taken withhow the load is applied because it willrespond to axialloads.
ForG
F = 2 and =1000
m/m:
Bending: bridge
( )V
mVG
V
VF
S
5010004
2
4 4321
0 !"# ==!+!= """"
23
61
wh
PlSG
=!
SG1l
P
wh
! ! !
!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
28/36
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>K?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Because the longitudinal and thetransverse Poisson gage are inadjacent arms, the thermal effect iscompensated and the bridge output isincreasedby the factor (1+ ) as canbe proved:
For GF =2, =0.3 and =1000m/m:
Bending: bridge
( ) ( )[ ]
( )[ ]V
mV
GG
V
V FF
S
65013004
21000301000
4
2
44 1121
0
!! ==!""=
=""="= #$$$$
12
1 23
6
SGSG
SG
wh
Pl
!""
"
#=
=
SG1l
P
wh
SG2
+
-
!!
!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
29/36
12
1 23
6
SGSG
SG
wh
Pl
!!
!
"=
=
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.>L?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Bending: bridge
( ) ( )[ ]
V
mV
GGG
V
VFFF
S
0120004
2
2444
11121
0
!"# ==
==!!=!= """""
SG1l
P
wh
SG2
+
-
The gage on the lower measure bendingstrains of opposite signs. Strainsproduced by axialloads and apparentstrain will be cancelled because the
two are in adjacent arms of the bridge.Moreover the output will be doubleascan be proved.
For GF = 2 and =1000m/m:!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
30/36
142
31 23
6
SGSGSG
SGSG
wh
Pl
!!!
!!
"==
==
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@N?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Bending: full bridge
( ) ( ) ( )[ ]
V
mVG
GG
V
V
F
FF
S
0240004
24
4
44
1
11114321
0
!"# ===
=!!+!!=!+!=
"
""""""""
lP
wh
+
-
This four-gage is the most popularbending beam conguration. The linearbridge output is twice that of thepreceding bridge version. Strains
produced by axialloads and apparentstrain will be cancelled because thetwo are in adjacent arms of the bridge.
For GF =2 and =1000m/m:!
SG1SG3
SG2SG4
+
-
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
31/36
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@M?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Axial: 2 gages in opposite arms
Ewh
PSGSG
==31
!!
( )V
mVGG
V
VFF
S
0120004
22
44 131
0 !"# ===+= !!!
SG1l
P
w hSG3
Because the two gages are in oppositearms, this conguration cancelsbending strains. The output will bedouble but the thermal strain isa d d i t i v e . T h e t e m p e r a t u r ecompensation is the poorest of anyconguration shown previously.
For GF =2 and =1000m/m:! +
+
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
32/36
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@>?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Axial: full bridge
l
+
-
SG3
SG4
+
-
SG1SG2
P
w h
This full bridge conguration withlongitudinal and Poisson gages is themost popular for axial loads. In thisconguration bendingis cancelled, the
output is increasedand it has a goodtemperaturecompensation. Note thatboth gages on a given surface are inadjacent arms.
For GF =2, =0.3 and =1000m/m:
( ) ( ) ( )[ ]
V
mV
GG
V
VFF
S
3126004
2
44 33114321
0
!"# ==
=!!+!!=!+!= "##"######
142
31
SGSGSG
SGSG
Ewh
P
!"""
""
#==
==
!!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
33/36
( )!"
##
##$
+=
=%=
=%
=
14
3
43
21
ER
T
SGSG
SGSG!"#
Strain measurements analysis
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@@?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
Torque: Full torsion bridge
+
- +
-
( ) ( ) ( )[ ]
V
mV
GG
V
VFF
S
0240004
2
44 33114321
0
!"# ==
=!!+!!=!+!= """"""""
SG3 SG4
SG1 SG2
TT
rIn this full bridge torsional congurationbending and axial loads are cancelled.Also it has a good temperaturecompensation. It is the most popular
design for torque measurement. However,very accurate gage orientation andplacement of all four gages is crucial forsuccess. For GF =2 and =1000m/m:!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
34/36
Summary
UPC
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@2?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
In this lecture we have discussed the following topics:
The selection criteria for strain gages is based on themeasurement task (uniaxial or biaxial stress states,
space requirements, homogeneity of the straineld)
and the strain gage characteristics.
The use of the Wheatstone bridge circuit for strainmeasurements and the different congurations
for different loadingcases.
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
35/36
References
!"#$%&"'(%')%&*+#+,-.*$&+/.@A?@A BC*+#)!+'("9 D+$E"')$6 %F G/H"'$+/ D"(+#)"96 "'/ 4(#.$(.#+6
UPC
1. Recent advances in experimental mechanics by E. E. Gdoutos, 2002.2. Springer Handbook of Experimental Solid Mechanics by William N. Sharpe
Jr. (Editor), 2008.
3. Handbook on Experimental Mechanics by Albert S. Kobayashi, 1993.4. Experimental mechanics of solids by Cesar A. Sciammarella and Federico
M. Sciammarella, 2012.5. Mechanics of solids by S. S. Bhavikatti, 2010.6. An Introduction to Measurements using Strain Gages by
Karl Hoffmann, 1989.
7.
Modern experimental stress analysis by James F. Doyle,2004.
8. Modal Analysis by Jimin He and Zhi-Fang Fu, 2001.9. Harris shock and vibration handbook by Allan G. Piersol
Thomas L. Paez, 2002
!
1+$(.#+ 2 3 4(#")' 5"5+67 )'6(#.!+'("8%' "'/ /"(" "'"9:6)6 ;
7/27/2019 Lecture 4 - Strain Gages II
36/36
Cantilever beam test
UPC
!" Eh
I
Ply
I
M
zz
zGage ===
2
zEI
PL
3
3
=!"#
!l
y = 41.043x + 4E-14
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Str
ainum/m
Displacement delta (mm)
Analytical12
3wh
Iz =