85
Numerical solution of the three body scattering problem Leonid Rudenko Numerical solution of the three body scattering problem Leonid Rudenko Department of Computational Physics, St Petersburg State University 3 April, 2009

LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Numerical solution of the three body scatteringproblem

Leonid Rudenko

Department of Computational Physics, St Petersburg State University

3 April, 2009

Page 2: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Outline

• Introduction• The Three-body scattering problem

• Faddeev Equation• Solution expansion• Malfliet-Tjon potential

• Numerical calculations: eigenvalues, eigenfunctions,geometrical connections

• Conclusions

Page 3: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Introduction

Page 4: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Introduction

• Expanding of the tree body wave function• Basis of hyperspherical adiabatic harmonics• The standard projection procedure leads to effectiveequations for the expansion coefficients

• How can be solved?• Have to find out properties of the basis functions

Page 5: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Introduction

• Geometrical connections Aij = 〈φi , ∂ρφj〉• Develop a formalism to study different models

- scattering of a particle off a two body bound state- scattering of a particle off a resonant state of a pair ofparticles

• Investigate eigenvalues λk , eigenfunctions φk , andgeometrical connections Aij of the operator

h(ρ) = −ρ−2∂θ + V (ρ cos θ).

Page 6: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Faddeev Equation in {ρ, θ}Coordinates

Page 7: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Faddeev equation in {ρ, θ}coordinates

The Faddeev s-wave equation in polar coordinates(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

)U(ρ, θ) +

(− 1

ρ2∂2

θ + V (ρ cos θ)

)U(ρ, θ)−

−EU(ρ, θ) = −V (ρ cos θ)

√34

∫ θ+(θ)

θ−(θ)dθ′ U(ρ, θ′)

where θ+(θ) = π/2− |π/6− θ| and θ−(θ) = |π/3− θ|

Page 8: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Faddeev equation in {ρ, θ}coordinates

The boundary conditions should be imposed for the scatteringsolution:• Regularity of the solution

U(0, θ) = U(ρ, 0) = U(ρ, π/2) = 0

• Asymptotics as ρ →∞

U(ρ, θ) ∼ ϕ(x)ρ1/2 sin(qy)/q +

+a(q)ϕ(x)ρ1/2 exp(iqy) + A(θ,E ) exp(i√Eρ),

where x = ρ cos θ.

Page 9: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Faddeev equation in {ρ, θ}coordinates

• The bound-state wave function of the two body targetsystem ϕ(x) obeys the equation

{−∂2x + V (x)}ϕ(x) = εϕ(x)

• It is assumed that the discrete spectrum of the Hamiltonian−∂2

x + V (x) consists of one negative eigenvalue ε at most

Page 10: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Basis functions

Page 11: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Expansion basis

• As basis we choose the eigenfunctions set of the operatorh(ρ)

(−ρ−2∂2θ + V (ρ cos θ)

)φk(θ|ρ) = λk(ρ)φk(θ|ρ)

• ρ is an external parameter for h(ρ)

• EV and EF of h(ρ) inherit parametrical dependence on ρ

Page 12: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Spectral properties

• The main spectral properties of the operator h(ρ) asρ →∞ and of the two body Hamiltonian −∂ 2

x + V (x)

λ = limρ→∞λ0(ρ) = ε,

φ0(θ|ρ) =√

ρϕ(ρ cos θ)(1 + O(ρ−µ))

• Excited states φk(θ|ρ), k ≥ 1, when ρ →∞ theasymptotic behavior is given by the formulas

λk(ρ) ∼(2kρ

)2

,

φk(θ|ρ) ∼ 2√πsin(2kθ)

Page 13: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Perturbation Theory

Page 14: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Perturbation theory - introduction

• If the parameter ρ is large the support of the potentialV (ρ cos θ) is small on the interval [0, π/2]

• The estimates for EV and EF of the operator h(ρ) can beobtained by the perturbation theory considering thepotential V (ρ cos θ) as a small perturbation

λk ∼ λ0k + λ1

k ,

φk(θ|ρ) ∼ φ0k(θ|ρ) + φ1

k(θ|ρ)

• The leading terms λ0k and φ0

k for k ≥ 1 are given by

λ0k = (2k)2/ρ2,

φ0k(θ|ρ) =

2√πsin(2kθ)

Page 15: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Correction terms

• The first order correction terms λ1k and φ1

k are defined interms of the matrix elements of the potential V (ρ cos θ)

Vnk(ρ) = 〈φ0n|V |φ0

k〉 =

∫ π/2

0dθ φ0

n(θ|ρ)V (ρ cos θ)φ0k(θ|ρ)

• As the model situation, the function V (x) is taken in theform of Yukawa potential

V (x) = Cexp(−µx)

x

where C and µ are some parameters.

Page 16: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Calculation of corrections

• As we set ρ →∞, we can approximately calculate integral

Vnk(ρ) ∼ (−1)n+k 16nkCπ

[1− exp(−µR)(1 + µR)]

µ21ρ3

.

• The first order correction term λ1k is

λ1k = Vkk ∼ ρ−3

• The second order correction term λ2k is

λ2k =

n 6=k

|Vnk |2λ

(0)k − λ

(0)n

,

λ2k ∼ ρ−4

Page 17: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Calculation of corrections

• For eigenfunctions the first correction term is given by

φ1k =

n 6=k

Vnk

λ(0)k − λ

(0)n

φ0n ∼ ρ−1

• From equation(− 1

ρ2∂2

θ + V (ρ cos θ)

)φk(θ|ρ) = λk(ρ)φk(θ|ρ)

one can obtain formula for Aij

Aij =〈φi | ∂V

∂ρ |φj〉λi − λj

Page 18: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Aij

• Rough calculation of Aij leads to dependence

Aij ∼ ρ−2, i , j 6= 0

Aij ∼ ρ−5/2, i = 0 or j = 0

Page 19: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution Expansion

Page 20: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• The operator h(ρ) is Hermitian on [0, π/2] interval and itseigenfunction set {φk(θ|ρ)}∞0 is complete.

U(ρ, θ) = φ0(θ|ρ)F0(ρ) +∑

k≥1φk(θ|ρ)Fk(ρ)

• Substituting this expansion in Faddev equation andprojecting on basis functions lead to the following systemof equations for Fk(ρ), k = 0, 1, ...

(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

+ λk(ρ)− E)Fk(ρ) =

∞∑

i=0

(2Aki

∂Fi (ρ)

∂ρ+ Bki (ρ)Fi (ρ)−Wki (ρ)Fi (ρ)

)

Page 21: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• The nonadiabatical matrix elements Aki (ρ),Bki (ρ) andpotential coupling matrix Wki (ρ) are given by integrals

Aki (ρ) = 〈φk | ∂ρφi 〉 =

∫ π/2

0dθφ∗k(θ|ρ)

∂φi (θ|ρ)

∂ρ,

Bki (ρ) = 〈φk | ∂ 2ρ φi 〉 =

∫ π/2

0dθφ∗k(θ|ρ)

∂ 2φi (θ|ρ)

∂ρ 2 ,

Wki (ρ) =

√34

∫ π/2

0dθφ∗k(θ|ρ)V (ρ cos θ)

∫ θ+(θ)

θ−(θ)dθ′φi (θ

′|ρ)

Page 22: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• Presence of first derivative F ′i (ρ) in the right part of theexpression

• Matrix form of equation(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

+ Λ(ρ)− E)F (ρ) = 2AF ′(ρ)+(B−W )F (ρ)

Page 23: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• Transform equation in form

F ′′(ρ) + PF ′(ρ) + QF (ρ) = 0

where P = 2A and Q =(

14ρ2 − Λ(ρ) + E + B −W

)are

two-dimensional infinite matrices• Introduce

F = UG

and elements of G are new unknown quantities

Page 24: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

UG ′′ +(2U ′ + PU

)G ′ +

(U ′′ + PU ′ + QU

)G = 0

• Equation for matrix U

U ′ = −12PU = −AU

• As ρ →∞U(ρ) = I +

∫ ∞

ρAUdρ

Page 25: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• Form without first derivative

UG ′′ +(−12P ′ − 1

4P2 + Q

)UG = 0

• Substitute expressions for P and Q

G ′′ + U−1(−A′(ρ)− A2(ρ) +14ρ2

−−Λ(ρ) + E + B −W )UG = 0

Page 26: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• As ρ →∞ asymptotic behavior U(ρ) ∼ I(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

I + Λ(ρ)− E)G =

=(−A′(ρ)− A2(ρ) + B(ρ)−W (ρ)

)G

• The right hand side terms vanish for large ρ faster thanρ−2. Hence this terms can be neglected.

(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

+ λask (ρ)− E

)Gk(ρ) = 0

here λas0 (ρ) = ε and λas

k (ρ) = (2k)2/ρ 2, k ≥ 1

Page 27: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Solution expansion

• Solutions to these equations with appropriate asymptoticscan be expressed in terms of the Bessel (Y , J) functionsand the Hankel (H(1)) functions of the first kind asfollowing

G0(ρ) ∼√

πqρ

2Y0(qρ)− J0(qρ)√

2q+

a0(q)

√πqρ

2H(1)0 (qρ)e iπ/4

Gk(ρ) ∼ ak(E )

√π√Eρ

2H(1)2k (

√Eρ)e i(π/4+kπ)

Page 28: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Malfliet-Tjon Potential

Page 29: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Malfliet-Tjon potential

• A potential, which describes the modeling nucleon-nucleoninteraction acting in the triplet state with the spin 3/2

• Form of the Yukawa terms superposition

V (x) = V1exp(−µ1x)

x+ V2

exp(−µ2x)

x

with parameters listed in the table

Coefficient ValueV1 −626, 885MeVV2 1438, 72MeVµ1 1, 55 Fm−1

µ2 3, 11 Fm−1

Page 30: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Malfliet-Tjon potential

0 1 2 3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

V(x

), Fm

^(-2

)

x, Fm

V(x)

Page 31: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Unit system

• Proton-neutron interaction(− ~

2

2µ∂2x + V (x)

)ψ(x) = Eψ(x),

• Reduced mass

µ =mpmn

mp + mn' m2

2m=

m2

, mp ' mn = m

(−∂2

x +m~2

V (x)− m~2

E)

ψ(x) = 0

• [V ] = [E ] = MeV

Page 32: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Unit system

•~2

m' 41, 47 Fm2 ∗MeV

• Obtain equation(−∂2

x + V (x)− E)

ψ(x) = 0

where [V ] = [E ] = Fm−2

• Set x = ρ cos θ in polar coordinates and ρ is parameter

Page 33: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

ρ = 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6-5

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

V(rho

*cos

(The

ta))

Theta

V(rho*cos(Theta)), rho=1

Page 34: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

ρ = 10

1,2 1,4 1,6-2

-1

0

1

2

3

V(rho

*cos

(The

ta))

Theta

V(rho*cos(Theta)), rho=10

Page 35: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

ρ = 100

1,52 1,53 1,54 1,55 1,56 1,57 1,58-2

-1

0

1

2

3

4

V(rho

*cos

(The

ta))

Theta

V(rho*cos(Theta)), rho=100

Page 36: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Numerical Calculations

Page 37: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Numerical calculations

• Finite-difference approach

−φk(θ − h) + 2φk(θ)− φk(θ + h)ρ 2h 2 +

+V (ρ cos θ)φk(θ) = λkφk(θ)

where h = θi+1 − θi , i = 1, ...,N and N ∼ 100000• Boundary conditions

φk(0) = φk(π/2) = 0

Page 38: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Software

• CLAPACK• Intel Math Kernel Library 10.0.1 for Unix• ’DSTEVX’: computes selected eigenvalues and, optionally,eigenvectors of a real symmetric tridiagonal matrix.Eigenvalues and eigenvectors can be selected by specifyingeither a range of values or a range of indices.

Page 39: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Eigenvalues

Page 40: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Asymptotics

• k = 0lim

ρ→∞λ0(ρ) = ε

• k ≥ 1

λk(ρ) ∼(2kρ

)2

Page 41: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

λ0(ρ)

0 10 20 30 40-0,08

-0,06

-0,04

-0,02

0,00

0,02

0,04

rho

lambda0

Page 42: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

λ10(ρ)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0

20

40

60

80

100

rho

lambda10 asymptotic

Page 43: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Eigenvalues

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40-0,10

-0,05

0,00

0,05

0,10

0,15

0,20

0,25

0,30

Eigen

values

rho

lambda0 lambda1 lambda2 lambda3 lambda4 lambda5

Page 44: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Deviation from asymptotics

• ρ ∼ 10 – deviation is big and varies from 10% up to 90%.For small k the absolute deviation is bigger than for big k .

• ρ ∼ 100 – deviation is about 5− 7%• ρ = 700 – deviation is less than 1%• ρ ∼ 1000 – deviation is about 0, 7%

Page 45: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Eigenfunctions

Page 46: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

1,4

Theta

phi0(Theta), rho=1

Page 47: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 3

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

1,4

Theta

phi0(Theta), rho=3

Page 48: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 5

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

1,4

Theta

phi0(Theta), rho=5

Page 49: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 10

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

1,4

1,6

1,8

Theta

phi0(Theta), rho=10

Page 50: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 30

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,5

1,0

1,5

2,0

2,5

3,0

Theta

phi0(Theta), rho=30

Page 51: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 52: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 3

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 53: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 5

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 54: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 10

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 55: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 30

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 56: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 100

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 57: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 300

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 58: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 500

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 59: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ), ρ = 1000

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Theta

Page 60: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Step-by-step

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60123456789

101112131415161718

Theta

rho=1 rho=3 rho=5 rho=10 rho=30 rho=100 rho=300 rho=500 rho=1000

Page 61: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Step-by-step

1,48 1,50 1,52 1,54 1,56 1,580123456789

101112131415161718

Theta

rho=1 rho=3 rho=5 rho=10 rho=30 rho=100 rho=300 rho=500 rho=1000

Page 62: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φ0(θ): conclusions

• As ρ →∞ eigenfunction φ0 transforms into δ-function• Computational problems: decreasing of spacing, time ofcomputation, size of data, useless zero-area

Page 63: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,0

-0,5

0,0

0,5

1,0

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=1

Page 64: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,0

-0,5

0,0

0,5

1,0

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=3

Page 65: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,0

-0,5

0,0

0,5

1,0

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=5

Page 66: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,0

-0,5

0,0

0,5

1,0

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=10

Page 67: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=30

Page 68: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=100

Page 69: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=300

Page 70: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=500

Page 71: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

φk(θ), k ≥ 1

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

1,2

Theta

k=1 k=2 k=3 k=4 k=5

phi_k(Theta), rho=1000

Page 72: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Step-by-step φ1(θ)

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,6

-1,0

-0,5

0,0

0,5

1,0

Theta

rho=1 rho=3 rho=5 rho=10 rho=30 rho=100 rho=300 rho=500 rho=1000

phi1(Theta)

Page 73: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Orthogonality and deviations

• Check orthogonality on each step• When does eigenfunction reach its asymptotic behavior?

maxθ|φk,ρ(θ)− sin(2kθ)|

Page 74: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

ρ = 500k max deviation1 0, 0250559876972 0, 0500959372663 0, 0751038619274 0, 1000641228465 0, 1249612277836 0, 1497801114307 0, 174506106355... ...14 0, 34385374894015 0, 36736662188116 0, 39067726760717 0, 41377642115718 0, 43665543471219 0, 45930633612320 0, 481722165969

Page 75: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Deviation in case k = 20, ρ = 500

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,0

0,1

0,2

0,3

0,4

0,5

Theta

| phi_20 - sin(2k*Theta) |, k=20

Page 76: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

ρ = 1000k max deviation1 0, 0125481819912 0, 0250943003823 0, 0376362974544 0, 0501721150345 0, 0626997003586 0, 0752170845527 0, 087722341482... ...14 0, 17475841034215 0, 18709854139916 0, 19941053702017 0, 21169197253418 0, 22394158383119 0, 23615787682420 0, 248338419864

Page 77: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Deviation in case k = 20, ρ = 1000

0,0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1,0 1,2 1,4 1,60,00

0,05

0,10

0,15

0,20

0,25

Theta

| phi_k - sin(2k*Theta) |, k=20

Page 78: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Geometrical connections

Page 79: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Geometrical connections

• Off-diagonal matrix of geometrical connections A withelements

Aki (ρ) = 〈φk |φ′i 〉 =

∫ π/2

0dθ φ∗k(θ|ρ)

∂φi (θ|ρ)

∂ρ

• Determines behavior of right part of equation(−∂2

ρ −14ρ2

I + Λ(ρ)− E)G =

=(−A′(ρ)− A2(ρ) + B(ρ)−W (ρ)

)G

Page 80: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Geometrical connections

•Aki =

〈φk | ∂V∂ρ |φi 〉

λk − λi

• Aki = −Aik and Akk = 0

Page 81: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Aki , k = 0 or i = 0

500 1000 1500 20000,0

0,2

0,4

0,6

0,8

1,0

A01

rho

num. calc. O(rho^(-2,5)) O(rho^(-2))

Page 82: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Aki , k 6= 0 and i 6= 0

500 1000 1500 20000

1

2

3

A12

rho

num. calc. O(rho^(-2)) O(rho^(-1,5))

Page 83: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Aki , k 6= 0 and i 6= 0

500 1000 1500 2000-2,0

-1,8

-1,6

-1,4

-1,2

-1,0

-0,8

-0,6

-0,4

-0,2

0,0

A13

rho

num. calc. O(rho^(-2)) O(rho^(-1,5))

Page 84: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

The last note about Aki

• The behavior of geometrical connections Aki is regular (nosingularity or special points) in case of Malfliet-Tjonpotential.

Page 85: LeonidRudenko - TUM · 2009. 8. 21. · Rudenko Malfliet-Tjonpotential † Apotential,whichdescribesthemodelingnucleon-nucleon interactionactinginthetripletstatewiththespin3=2 †

Numericalsolution ofthe threebody

scatteringproblem

LeonidRudenko

Thank you!