8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 1/34

5

:

8

2

7

1

3

0

>

54

55

5:

58

52

57

5

1

53

5

0

5

>

:4

:5

 

:8

:2

:7

:

1

 3

:0

H ` e r f g

s

E v

r n t `

(XJK

 1042)

KEC

FGZ

E

XXLHN

ERGX

:844

 X. Xgp

ufvgbe Jlu

fgverb

Fl s E

kcgfgs,

  e f n a l

r k n e

>4412

-5>55

R

gfgp`lk

g? 854

)

3

8-5:44

A e h s n

m n f g ?

8

54)

38-3522

G

menf?

hevrnt`

Dkecfgr

.hlm

E

t t l r k g y s

 al

r f e n

k t n a a s

E

mgrnhe

 W k n t g

sal r 

Inbs e k b

Tuj

fnh

Gmpf

lyggs

l

r G

kvnrlkm

gktef g s p

l k s n j n f n

t y

Te

ufe n k g r s

t g n k Eb

mnt tgb T rl

 @eh

Qnh g)

T u j f n h Gmp fl

yggs

l r  Gk

vnrlkmg

ktef 

g s p l k s n

j n f n t y

:444

T .

 

t r g g

t

K

S,

t g

:24

Ses

`nkctl

k, 

BH

44

81

Rgfgp`lkg?

:4:) 

17-3883

Gmenf?

 

b n k g

r s t g n k D

p g g r l r c

  E t t l r

k g y s

alr 

Tujfn

h

Gmpfly

ggs

l r

Gkvn

rlkmgkt

ef g s p l k

s n j n f n t y

WK

NRGB

XRER

GX

BN

XRZNH

RH

LWZR

 ALZ R@G

 

H

GKRZE

F NXR

ZNHR

LA

HEFNA

LZKNE

 ‒SGXR

GZK NQNX

NLK

EM

GZNHE

 

WK

NRGX 

ALZ

NBX

 

kb

TW

JFNH

GM

TFL^G

GX A

LZ

GKQNZ

LKMGK

REF GXTL

KXNJN

FNR^ 

T f e n k t n

a a s

~

XEKB

ZEF^L

K, K 

@GZ

AANH

NEF

HETEH

NR^

EX

XWTGZ

NKRGK

BGKR

LA

R@G XEKRE 

MLKNHE

MEFNJW

WKNANG

B

X

H@LLF

 

NXR

ZNHR OEK

M

EG_,

K @

GZ AANH

NEF

H

ETEHN

R^

EX 

EXXL

HNERG

 XWTGZ

NKRGKB

GKR

EKB

H@N

GA

A

NKEKH

NEF

LA

ANHGZ

LA

R@

G

XEKRE

 

MLK

NHE 

MEFNJ

W

WK

NANGB

 

XH@L

LF 

NXRZN

HR

EKB

H

esg

Kl .

 :?57-

hv-4:5:

2

TE-E

OS

ANZX

R

MGK

BGB

HLMT

FENKR

 

ALZ

ff

GHFEZ

ERLZ

 

EKB

NK

OWKHR

NQG

ZG

FNGAALZ

QNLF

ERNLK

 

L

A

RLP

NH

XW

JXREK

HGX 

HLK

RZLF

EHR

AYZXR

EMG

KBGB

HLMTFEN

KR ALZ

BGHFEZE

RLZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 5 la 82 Tecg NB #?3:

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 2/34

5

 

FEW

ZNG

 

F

NGJ

GZM

EK,

 Z.

 

L

XG

G

XHE

ZHG

,

ZEN

C

ALX

RGZ,

 

M

EZ

NE

  FG

LK-

QE_

UWG

_, 

N

H@E

ZB

8

 

RE

@QN

FBE

ZEK

-OG

XXS

GNK,

 LX

HEZ

B

G 

E

 

R

LZZ

G, EKB

 

EFT

@ 

MGH

@W

Z,

2 NK

 

R

@GNZ

 

LAAN

HNE

F HETE

HNR

NGX

 

EX

7

MG

MJ

GZX

 

LA

 R@

G XE

KRE

 

ML

KN

HE

1

M

EFN

JW

 

W

KNA

NGB

 XH@

LLF

 BNXR

ZNH

R

J

LEZ

B L

AG

BWH

ERN

LK,

3

c

Bg

agkb

ekts

.

>

54

 

T

f e n k t

n a a s

Emg r

nhe

 Wknt

gs

l r

Inb s

 

al

rmgrf

y Me

fnju

 

W

kntgs

)

Emg

rnhe

k

55

Wknt

gs )

 

k b Tuj

fnh

Gm

p f l y

g g s

l r Gkvn

rlkm

gktef

 Z g

s p l k s

n j n f n

t y

(

 T GG

Z )

, k

5:

 

jg

`efa

  a  

`

gmsgf

vgs

e k b

` g n

r

m

gmjg

rs,

f f g c

g

es

l f f l

w s ?

5 8

5 2

 

OW

ZNX

BNHR

NLK

, 

KER

WZG

 

L

A R@

G 

E

HRN

LK

E

KB

Q

GKW

G

5 7

5

.

R`ns

 

Hlur

t 

`e

s

u r n s

b n h t n

l k l

vgr

` n s

 

e

h t n l

k

p

ursue

kt

l

:0 W.X

.H. §

8

85

5 1 

a g b g r

e f q

u g s t n

l k ) ,

 

:

0

W .X.

H.

§

::45

  b

g h f e r

e t l r

y  oubcm

gkt)

, e k b

 

57 

W

.X.H.

 

§:15

>

5

~

(R

XHE

 n t

n z g k  

s u n t

 

p r l

v n s n l

k ) .

5

 

c

:

.

R`

ns s

 e

n

t n z g k

 

s u n t

 

uk

bgr

t ` g

 

R

lxnh

 

Xujs

tekh

gs Hlkt

rlf

Eht

5 >

 

~~~R

XHE

),

5

7 W .X

.H. §:15

>,

ggink

c t l

 r g s t r

e n k

lk

clnk

c 

v

n l f e t

n l k s

 

l a

 RX

HE

kb

 

t s

:4

 

nmpf

gmgk

tnkc

 

r g c u

f e t n l

k s

jy ` g

 

Bga

gkbek

ts,

b

m n k n

s t r e t

l r s

e

k b m

g mjg

r s l a

 ` g

:

5

J

l e rb

 

l a  b

uhet

nlk 

l

a  

` g

X

ekte

 M

l k nh

e Mef

nju Wk

nangb

 

X

h`ll

f n s t

r n h t

::

( X

MM

WXB

 

r

B n s t r

n h t )

.

R`

g lk

clnk

c 

v n l f

e t n l k

s

l a

 R

XHE

 tgm a r

lm t`g

:

8 

hl

ktnk u

gb 

usg e

t M

e fnj

u Mnbb

f g e k b

 @

nc`

Xh` l

lf

(

 M@X

 )

k b O

uek H

e j r n f

f l

:

2

Gfgmgktery

Xh` ll f 

O HGX  )

h l f f g h t n v g f y

Me f nju

Xh`llfs )

a  

l f y h ` f l r n k e t g b

:7

 

jnp

`gkyf

s

(

THJs

 ) k

he u

fi

e k b

 

l t ` g

r

j u n

f b n k c

 

m

e t g r n

e f s  e t

h l

k h g k t

r e t n l

k s

l

a

:1

c r

g e t g r

 

t`ek

 

74 e r

t s

pg r m

n f f n l

k , l t `

g r  t

`ek 

n k e   l t e

f f y g

khf l

sgb

mekk

gr, 

s

w

gff

` g

:

3

hlk

tnku

gb 

usg l a

e t

g r n e f

s

w

nt` s u r a e

h g s

`e

vnkc

 TH

J

l k

h g k t r

e t n l

k s

n k

gx

hg ss

l a 4

:0

mn

hrlc

rems

 u

c) gr

 

5 4

4 

sque

rg h g k

t n m g t

g r s

(

hm:

) .

5

AN

ZXR EM

GKBG

B

H

LMTF

ENKR

ALZ

BGHF

EZERL

Z^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg : la 82 Tecg NB #?38

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 3/34

5

 

8

.  

T f e

n k t n a

a s s

ggi

b g h

f e r e t

l r y  e

kb n k o

u k h t n

v g  

r g f n g

a  

r

g q u n

r n k c  

B

gagk

bekt

s l

: 

h g

e s g

lkc

lnkc

 v n l f

e t n l k

s

l

aRX

HE 

y

rg

mlvn

kc f f

j u n

f b n k c

 m e t g r

n e f s

w `

nh`

v n l f e

t g

8

RX

HE

k

b

t

s  

nmp

fgmg

ktnk

c g

c u f e

t n l k s

 arlm

 t ` g

 

M

efnj

u X

h ` l l f

s .

2

 

2 .

  Q

g k u g

  s

p r l p g

r ukb

gr

57 W

.X.H.

 

: 1

5 > ( e )

( : )  j

g h e u s

g

t ` n s n s  t `

g

b n s t r

n h t

7

 

n

k

w `nh

` t ` g

 e f f

g c g b

v n

l f e t n

l k s e r g  

lkcl

nkc,

 

ekb 

n k w

`nh`

 B

gagk

bekts

  evg

 

` g n r

1

 

p r n k

h n p e f

 p f e

h g  l a

 u

s n k g s

s .

3

7 .

 

T f

e n k t n

a a s

w n f

f

e f s

l jg 

n f

n k c

e

 

M

l tnl

k  l r

T r g

f n m n

k e r y

N k o u k

h t n l

k ,

0

s g g

i n k c

n

mmgb

netg

 rgml

vef

l a

e u f i

 

w `nh

` `es

 e f r g e

b y

jgg

k

b

g t g r

m n k g

b

j

y

> f

e j l r e

t l r y

t g s t

n k c t l

 

h

l k t e n

k  T

HJs

 k

g x h

g s s l a

g c e f

 

f n m n

t s ,

ek

b ek

e p p f

n h e t n

l k  a

l r

54 

Gxpg

bntg

b

Bns

hlvg

ry ukb

gr

Agb.

 

Z

. n

v . T

.  2 ( e

) ( : )   l

g k t g

r

t `

g  M

efnj

u X

h`ll

fs

e

kb

5 5  

sempf g ekb

g s t

j u n f b n k c  

m e t g r n e f s

t l  b g t g r m n k g

t l

w ` e t 

x t g k t  

n f f g c e f

f g v g f s

l a 

THJs

5 :

 

g x n

s t n k

t ` l s g

 

m e t

g r n e f

s .

58 

1

.   T f

e n k t n

a a s cev

g k l

t n h g

l a

` g

E b m n

k n s t

r e t l

r

l

a

` g

 

G

kvnr

lkmgk

tef

52 

T r l t g

h t n l

k

Ecg

khy  

( G

TE

) kb

 

t `

g Bgag

kbek

ts

l a ` g

e f f g c

g b

v n l f

e t n l k

s  mlr

g `

e k

57 

14

  e

ys r n l

r  

t l

t ` g a n

f n k c

l a

 

`

n s Hl

mpfen

kt,

k e

h h l r

b e k h g

 w n

t `

57

 W.

X.H.

 

§

:15 >

(j)

51 

ekb 2

4

H

.A.Z

. 34:.

1:

5

>0:)

.

5 3

50

TEZ

RNG

X E

KB

XRE

KBN

KC

5>

 

3

.

T f e n k

t n a a

E

mgrn

he W k

n t g s

 

a l

r Inb

s

a l r m

g r f y

Mef

nju

W k

n t g s

)

s

e

 

kl k-

:4

  p r

l a n t 7

4 5 ( h )

( 8 )

r c e

k n z e

t n l k

n k h

l r p l

r e t g b

 

n

k

H e f n a

l r k n e

 w n

t ` mg

mjgr

s ekb

:5

 

s u p

p l r t

g r s

w`l

  r g

p e r g

k t s ,  

t g e h `

g r s

ekb

 

hl

mmuk

nt y  m

gmjg

rs  

t

t

` g Me

fnju

:

: 

X h `

l l f s

.  

R

` g  

m n

s s n l

k

l a

 E

mgrn

he W

k n t g s

 

n s

 

t l

 

g k s u

r g

g k

v n r l

k m g k t

e f  

g e f t

`

:

8 

g x h

g f f g

k h g

n k

s h ` l

l f s

a l r

 

e

f f h `

n f b r g

k

e

kb

t `

l s g t ` e t

 g

b u h e

t g

t`

gm. M

g mj

g rs  

l

a

:2 

Emgrnhe 

W k n t g s e r g

n k o u r g b

jy

` g

lkclnkc 

v n l f e t n l k s  

l a

RXHE 

t

t ` g

Mefnju

:

7 

Xh`l

lfs j

gheu

sg t`g

y

`

evg

h ` n

f b r g

k w

`l t

t g k b  

s h

` l l f n k  h f

e s s r

l l m s

w n

t `

n f f g c

e f

:1 

f g v

g f s l

a

THJ

s, `nh

` evg

 j

ggk aluk

b

t

l  

heus

g

h e

k h g r

 

ekb

`e

vg

l t

` g r

s

g r n l

u s

:3

` g

e f t `  

g a

a g h t s

,  

l

r jgh

eusg

 t ` g y `

evg

jggk

 

a l r

h g b  t

l wnt

`bre

w

` g n r

 

h

` n f b r

g k arl

m

t `

g

:0

:

ANZ

XR EM

GKBG

B

HL

MTFE

NKR

AL

Z BGHF

EZERL

Z^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 8 la 82 Tecg NB #?32

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 4/34

5

  M

efnj

u 

Xh`l

lfs

k  l

r b g r

 

t

l  

e v

l n b

gxpl

surg

 

t l

n f f

g c e f

f g v

g f s

l a HJs

, 

r j g h e

u s g  

t ` g y

: 

t

g e h `

 

n

k

t ` l s g

 h f e

s s r l l

m s .

8 

0 .

  T f e

n k t n a

a T

u j f n h

 

G

mpfl

yg gs

 

l r  

Gkvn

rlkm

gkte

f g s p

l k s n j

n f n t y

 

TG

GZ)

 

s

2 

ek

lk- p r

l a n t

7 4 5 (

h ) ( 8

)  

b u h e

t n l k

e f ek

b 

ebv

lheh

y

l

r c e k

n z e t n

l k ,  n k h l r

p l r e

t g b

n k

7 

Ses

`nkc

tlk, 

.

H.,

w

`nh`

 

e b v l h

e t g s

 

a

l r

p u j

f n h gmpf

lygg

s

hl kh

grkg

b

w n t `

1

 g k v n

r l k m

g k t e

f n s s u g

s ,  n k h f

u b n k

c  

t ` g H

lkhg

rkgb

 

M

e f n j

u / H e j

r n f f

l

R

g e h ` g

r s , e

crl u

p

3 

l a

 

84

g e h ` g

r s

ek

b

s t

e a a

e t

t ` g

 

M

efnj

u 

X h `

l l f s .

 Mg mj

g rs

 

l

aTG

GZ,

 

k h f

u b n k

c

0 t g

e h ` g r

s e

kb 

s t e a

a

e

kb t `

g Mef

nju

X h ` l

l f s , e r g

 n

k o u r g

b

j

y 

` g  

lk

clnk

c v n

l f e t n

l k s l

a

> 

R

XHE

 t

 

t

` g  M

efnj

u Xh

`llf

s j g h

e u s g

 

t

` g y  w l

ri

k h f e

s s r l

l m s w

`nh`

  e

vg

f

f g c e f

54 

f g

v g f s

 l a

 

H

Js,

`n

h` `ev

g 

jggk

 

alu

kb

t l  

h e u s g

 h

e k h g r

 

ek

b `e

vg l t

` g r s

g r n l u

s

5 5  

` g e f t `  

g a a g h t s .

5: 

>.

  B

gagk

bekt

 Xekb

re

Fy

l k

s

t ` g  

X u p g

r n k t

g k b g k

t

l a

`

g

XM

MWX

B, 

kb s

58 

gk

cecg

b

n k

lk

clnk

c v n

l f e t n

l k s

l a 

R

XHE

 y  

p g r m n

t t n k

c ekb

a e n f n

k c

t l

e h t

 

t l

 

r

gmgb

y

5

2 

t `

g

u k e u t

` l r n

z g b

us

g

l a

e t g

r n e f s

 

h l k

t e n k

n k c n f f g

c e f f g v g

f s

l

a

TH

Js 

k t ` g Me

fnju

57 

X h

` l l f s

.  X` g

  s j g n k

c su

gb n k

` g

r

l a a

n h n e f

 

h

e p e h

n t y .

5

1 

5

4 .

Bgag

kbek

t Oek

 

M

egz

s

t ` g

 

E s s

l h n e t

g X

u p g r n

k t g k

b g k t

 

e

kb

H`

nga

5

3 

A n k

e k h n e

f

L a a

n h g r  

l

a

` g

 XM

MWX

B,

 kb s

 

gk

cecg

b n

k lkc

lnkc

 

v n l

f e t n l

k s l a

 

RXH

E

5 0

 

jy

 

p g r m

n t t n k

c

e

k b

e n f

n k c

t l

 e h t

 

t

l r

gmgb

y

` g

u

k e u t

` l r n z

g b

u s g

 l a

  e t g r n

e f s

5>

h l k t e

n k n k

c n f f g c

e f f g

v g f s

l a  T

HJs

 k t ` g

Mefn

ju

X h `

l l f s

. X`

g s

j g n k

c

sugb n k

` g

r

:4

 

l a

a n h n e

f  h

e p e h

n t y .

:

5 

5

5 .

Bga

gkbe

kts

F e u r n

g  Fngj

grme

k, r.

l

s g G s h

e r h g ,

 

H r

e n c

A l s t

g r , Mer

ne

:

: 

Fg

l k-Qe

zqug

z,

Znh

`erb

 R e ` v

n f b e

r e k - O

g s s w

g n k ,  

L

sher

 

B

g 

e

l r

r g  

ek

b Zefp

`

:8 

Mgh

` ur

  r g m

gmj

grs l

a ` g

 

X

MMW

XB

 

l

erb

l

a

b u h e t

n l k ,

 

ekb

e r g

gkc

ecgb

 

n k

:2 

lkclnkc 

v n l f e t n l k s

l a

RXHE 

y  

p g r m n t t n k c  

ekb 

e n f n k c

t l  

e h t t l  

rgmg by

` g

:

7 

u k e u

t ` l r n

z g b

usg 

l

a e t

g r n e f

s

h l

k t e n

k n k c n f

f g c e f

 

f g v g

f s l a

 

TH

Js

k t ` g

Mefn

ju

:

1  X h

` l l f

s .  R ` g y

 

e r

g

j g n k c

 sugb

n k  

t ` g n

r

l a a n h

n e f

h e

p e h n t

n g s .

:

3

/

/ /

:0

/ / /

8

ANZXR E

MGKB

GB

H

LMTFE

NKR

AL

ZBGHF

EZERL

Z^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 2 la 82 Tecg NB #?37

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 5/34

5

F

GCE

F

JE

HIC

ZL

WKB

:

 

5 : .

Hlk

crg s

s

g k

e h t g b

 

RX

HE 

k  5

>3 1,

 57 W.X

.H.

§:1

45 g t

  g q .

,

t l

r g

c u f e t

g

8

h`

gmnh

ef s u j s

t e k h

g s ekb

 m

n x t u r

g s w `nh

` p r g s

g k t

ek 

u k r g e

s l k e

j f g r n s

i

l a

 

k o

u r y t l

2 

` g e f

t ` l r

 

t

` g  g

k v n r

l k m g

k t . 57

W.X

.H.

: 1 4

5 ( j )

( : ) .

7

 

5

8 . T

HJs

 r g

 

t

` g  

l k

f y h

`gmn

hef w `

nh` H

lkcr

gss

p g

h n a n h

e f f y

n b g k t

n a n g b

 

a l r

1

r g c u

f e t n l

k ukbg

r RX

HE.

 RX

HE 

mpl

sgb

e k

g e r - t

l t e f  j

ek l k

 

TH

Js 

g h e u

s g

3

Hlk

crgs

s b g t

g r m n

k g b t

` e t t ` g

h` g

mnhe

f

ekb

t

l x n h

l f l c n

h e f  p r l

p g r t n

g s

l a

TH

Js 

lsg

b 

e

0

s n c k

n a n h

e k t r n s i

 

t l

 

p

u j f n h

 

` g e

f t ` ek

b t ` g

 g k v

n r l k

m g k t

. 57 

W.

X.H.

: 1

4 7 ( g

) ( : ) (

E )

>

s t e t g s

?

5

4

Gx

hgpt

 

s

p

r l v n b

g b  

ukbg

r

s u j p

e r e c

r e p `  (J

), 

a a g h t

n v g  

lk

g

5 5 y g e r

e a t g r  

t ` g  

g a a g h t n v g

b e t g

l a

` n s

Eht 

O e k u e r y  

5 ,

5>3 3]

5:

 

k l p g

r s l k

me

y  e k u a

e h t u

r g ,  p r l

h g s s ,

 

l r

 b n s t

r n j u t

g

n

k

5

8

h

l mm

grhg

 l r us

g ek

y

p l

f y h ` f

l r n k e

t g b

j n

p ` g k

y f n k  

eky

52 

m

e k k

gr t ` g r

 t ` e

k n k e

  l

t e f f y

 g k h

f l s g b

 

m

ekkg

r.

57

 

5 2

.

N k RX

HE, k

 

s u j p

e r e c

r e p `

 

J 

g a g r

g k h g b

 n k

 

t

` g

p r g

h g b n k

c

q

u l t e t

n l k ,

51

 

Hlkc

rgss

 

ce

vg 

GTE

  g  e u

t ` l r n

t y  t

l pr

lmuf

cetg

 

u f

g s  c

r e k t

n k c g x

h g p t n

l k s  t l

t `

g

5

3  

s t e t

u t g ' s

 

THJ

 

ek

, u

plk 

e

 

n k

b n k c  t `

e t  

e

e r t n h

u f e r m e k u

a e h t

u r g  

l r

 u s g l a k

l k - t l

t e f f y

50  

g k h

f l s g

b  THJs

 w n f f

 kl

t

p r g

s g k t

e

k u

k r g e s

l k e j

f g

r

n s i  

l a k o u r

y t l

` g e f t

` l r

 

t ` g

5

> 

g k v n

r l k m

g k t .  

57 

W.X.H

.

: 1 4

7 ( g ) (

: ) ( J

) 9 § : 1

4 7 ( g

) ( 8 ) (

J ) .

:

4

5

7 .

R

XHE

 g q u n

r g s  t

` e t  

eky

 

G

TE 

x h g p

t n l k s

 

t l

 n t s

 

TH

J

r

l ` n j

n t n l k

 jg

:5

 

pr

lmufc

etgb

 

n k

 

e rufg

mein

kc

p

r l h g g

b n k c

 n k  

e h h l r

b e k h

g w

n t `

t

` g

k l t n

h g ekb

 

hl m

mg k t

:: 

r

g q u n

r g m g k

t s

l a

 

` g

E b m n k

n s t r

e t n v g

 Tr

lhgb

urg E

ht

ET

E) .  57

W.

X.H.

 

:

1 4 7 (

g ) ( 2 )

9

:8

 

§

: 1 4 7

( h ) ( :

) .  Ek

y 

x h g p

t n l k

s

t

l  

RXH

E's

 

T

HJ ek

 e r g

 

o u

b n h n e

f f y

r g v

n g w e

j f g

u

kbgr

:2 

t ` g ETE 

kb must jg

s u p p l r t g b  

jy

u j s t e k t n e f

g v n b g k h g .

G . c .

Gk vnrlkmgktef

:7

Bg

agks

g 

A

uk b

, k h

. v .

 

GTE,

 

8

1 

A.:b

 

5

:13

B. H

.

n r .

5 > 0 4

) .

:

1 

5 1 .

N k

 

t

` g  

r

u f g s

n

mpf g

mgkt

nk c 

RX

HE's

 THJ

 

ek

 

( 

THJ  g c

u f e t n

l k s

) , t

` g

:

3

GT

E 

b m n k

n s t r

e t l r  alu

kb

j e s

g b l

k ` g  b

lhum

gktg

b h n g k

t n a n h

g v n b

g k h g

 

t ` e t

e

ky

u s g

:0

2

ANZ

XR EM

GKBG

B

HL

MTFEN

KR

ALZ

 

B

GHFEZ

ERLZ

^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 7 la 82 Tecg NB #?31

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 6/34

5

 

l a

 

tgms

 h l k t

e n k n k

c

T

HJs

 t

 74 pp

m 

r c

r g e t g

r

b

n b

plsg

 ek

 

ukr

geslk

ejfg

 

r n s i

l a

: 

n k

o u r y

 

tl

 

` g

e f t ` .

 R`

g E

bmnk

nstre

tlr al

ukb?

8 

t ` e

t

t `

g me

kuaeh

turg

,

r l h

g s s n k

c ,

e k b

b n

s t r n j

u t n l k

 n k

2

 

hl m

mg r

hg l aTHJ

s t

 h l k h

g k t r e

t n l k

s l a

74 

p

pm r c r

g e t g r

7

 

e k b TH

J tg

ms w

nt ` T

HJ 

l

k h g k

t r e t n

l k s l a  

74

ppm

 

r

1

 

c r g

e t g r

 

p r g s

g k t

e

k ukrg

eslk

ejfg

 

r n s

i

l a  k o u

r y t

l ` g

e f t `

3 

w n t ` n

k t ` g  Wkn

tgb X

t e t g s

. R`

ns

a n

k b n k c

 n s

je

sgb

up

l k t ` g

0

wgf

f

-b

lhum

gktg

b

`

umek

  g e f t

`

e

k b

gkvn

rl km

gktef

  eze

rb

> 

l a

TH

J

xpl

surg

,

` g

`

nc` p

r l j e j

n f n t y

 

l a

`u

mek

e k b

5 4

 

g

kvnr

lkmg

ktef 

gxp

lsur

g t l

 THJs

 

k b TH

J tg

ms ar

lm

5 5

mekuaehturnkc

p r l h g s s n k c , ,  

r 

b n s t r n j u t n l k

e h t n v n t n g s 9

t ` g

5 :

p l

t g k t n

e f

`ez

erb l

a  

T

HJ

x

pl sur

g p

lsgb

 

jy ` g

58

 

t r e k

s p l r t

e t n l k

 l

a

T

HJs

 r

THJ

 tgms

 w n t `

n k  t `

g

W

kntg

b

5

2 X

t e t g

s 9

e k

b t ` g

 

gvnb

gkhg

 t

` e t  

hlkt

emnk

etnl k

 l

a ` g

57

gkvn

rlkm

gkt

j

y T

HJs

 

s  

spr

geb a e r

 

jgy

l k b t

` g

e r g e

s w ` g

rg

5

1

t`gy

 

e r g

usgb

...

5 3

 

24

 .A.

Z.  

31

5.:4

 gm

p`es

ns 

ebb

gb).

5

0  

5 3 .

T

HJ 

t g

m s  

b g a n

k g b

n k  

t ` g  

TH

J

gc

ufet

nlks

tl 

mge

k 

e

k y

TH

J

5

> 

E r t n h

f g ,

T

HJ r t n h

f g

Hlk

tenkg

r,T

HJ

lkten

kgr,

 

T

HJ 

q unp

mgkt

, r e

kvt`

nk ~t`

et

:4 

b g f n j

g r e t g

f y

l

r

u k

n k t g k

t n l k e

f f y

h l k

t e n k s

 

lr

`

es

e

s

e

e r t

 

l

a  

t e k y

THJ

 

r

 

THJs

. 24

:

5 

H.

A.Z.

 315.

8 5

>>>)

 g

mp`e

s ns ebbgb

).

TH

J

t

gms 

k h f u b

g TH

J-

h l k t e

n k n k

c

::

 

j u n

f b n k

c m

e t g r n

e f s s

uh` es

h e u f i

.

:8 

50.

  2

4 .A.Z

. 315.:

4(e)

 

x

p r g s s

f y

prlvn

bgs ` e

t , gx

hgpt

 

l r

h

g r t e n

k f n

m n t g b

:2 

s n t u e t n l k s  

klt

p p f n h e j f g

` g r g ,

Yk]l pg rslk

mey 

sg

e k y

THJ, 

r 

e k y

THJ tgm

:

7 

r g c e

r b f g s

s

l a

 

l k h

g k t r e

t n l k s

,

n k e

k y mek

kgr,

  t

` g r

t`

ek 

n k

e

 

l t e f

f y

g

khfls

gb

me k

k gr

:

1 

w

n t ` n

k t ` g Wk

ntgb

 X t e t

g s u

k f g s s

 e u t `

l r n z

g b u

kbgr

  24 

H.A

.Z.

1 5

. 8 4 ]

.

2

4 H.

A.Z.

:

3

315.

:4(e)

 

f s l  r g a g

r s

t l  

24

 .A.

Z.  31

5.8,

 w `

nh`

gx

hf ubg

s 

a

rlm r g

c u f e

t n l k  T

HJ

:0

7

A

NZXR

EM

GKBG

B

HL

MTFE

NKR

AL

Z

BG

HFEZ

ERLZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 1 la 82 Tecg NB #?33

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 7/34

5

p

r l b u

h t s

h

l k t e

n k n k c

 

f g s s

 

t ` e

k

74

p

pm

T

HJs

.  

Kl k

g

l a ` g

g x h g

p t n l k

s

n k

24

  .

A . Z .

:

 3

1 5 . : 4

( e )  

p p

f y

t l

T

HJs t

 

h l

k h g k t

r e t n

l k s

e t l

r c r g e t

g r  

t ` e

k  

74

pp

m.

8

 

5 > .

G x h f u

s n l k

s

t l

t ` g

 

je

k l k

t ` g

usg

 

l aTHJ

s

k

b 

T

HJ

t g m s

 

e r

g e f

s l

2 a

lukb

 n k

 2

4 H.A.

Z. 315

.84 

:4

5:). Xg

g 2

4

H.

A.Z.

  1 5 . :

4 ( e )

.  

24

H.

A.Z.

 

3

15 .8

4

7

( :

45:

)  

l k

t e n k

s  gx

gmpt

nl ks

 a l r

 

t `

g  

u

sg

l a

 

e t

g r n e f

s

h l k

t e n k

n k c

THJ

s k

1

 h l k h

g k t r e

t n l k s

 

l a

74 

ppm

  r c r g e

t g r  w

`nh`

 

e r

g

klt

 

l

t e f f y

 g k

h f l s g

b

n

k

f n

m n t g

b

3

 

h n r h

u m s t e

k h g s

 

n k

u

s g s suh`

 e s

 

n k

 t r e k s

a l r m

g r s

ekb 

k e t

u r e f

ces

n

p g f n

k g  

s y s t

g m s .

 24

0

 

H.A.Z

. 

315

.84

:

45:).

 Kl k g

 l a

` g  g

x h g p t

n l k s

 p g r m

n t t n

k c

t

` g

u s g l

a e t

g r n e f

s

>

 

h l k

t e n k n

k c  TH

Js

k h l k h g

k t r e

t n l k s

 

l a

7

4

p

pm l r

 

c r g e

t g r

e p p f

n g s  t l

h e u

f i l

r  

l t `

g r

5 4

j

u n f b

n k c

m e t g

r n e f s

.

5 5 :4. 

RXHE

g a n k g s

t l t e f f y

g k h f l s g b  

mekkg r 

s

e mekkgr

` e t

w n f f g k s u r g

5 :

t `

e t e

k y

g

xpls

urg

l a   u

me k

 

j g n k

c s  l r t ` g

 gkvn

rlkm

gkt 

l e  

YTH

J]

n f f

 

jg

5

8

n

k s n c k

n a n h e

k t e

s  

b

g t g r

m n k g

b

jy ` g  E

b m n k n

s t r e

t l r  

r u

f g .

57

 

W.X

.H.

: 1 4 7

( g ) ( :

) ( H )

.

5

2

N

k 

` g

 

THJ

 

g c u f

e t n l

k s ,  

` g

GTE

 b m

n k n s t

r e t l

r

a

lukb

 

` e

t  

t ` g

 g x

h g p t n

l k

ar

lm

t ` g

57

T

HJ ek

 a l r  

t l t e f f

y

g k h f

l s g b

 

T

HJ

tgm

s  p p f

n g s

l k f

y

t

l  

s

n t u e t

n l k s

w

`grg

  `

g r g n s

51

zg

rl

g

xpls

urg t l

` u

m e k s

 

lr

`

g

g k v n

r l k m g

k t .  

24

 

H

.A.Z

. 315 .

:4 p

r l v n b

g s e s

 

a l

f f l w s

?

5 3

Alr

 p u r p

l s g s

la

g t g r

m n k n

k c w `nh

` T

HJ

tgm

s  r g

t l t e f

f y

5

0

g k h f

l s g b

,

p

u r s u

e k t

t l

 s g

h t n l k

 

1 ( g

) ( : ) (

H )

l

aRXH

E, n

k h g

5

>

gxp

lsurg

 

t l

 

suh

`

Ntgm

s mey

 

j

g

s n c k n

a n h e k

t ,

t `

g

:4

E b m

n k n s t

r e t l

r

a

u r t ` g

r

a

n k b s

 t ` e

t  e

l t e f f

y g

k h f l

s g b

mekk

gr

:5

 

n s

e mek k

gr 

w `

nh` 

r g

s u f t s

 

n k  

k

l 

gx

pl su

rg t l

` um

e k s  

r t ` g

::

 

gkvn

rl kmg

kt 

l

T

HJs

.

:8

 

(

gmp`

esns

 

e b b

g b ) . TH

Js 

k

h

e u f i ekb

 l t `

g r j u

n f b n

k c

m e t g

r n e f s

 r

g s u f t n k

g x p l

s u r g

 l a

:2 

` ume k s

r  

t ` g

gkvnrlkmg kt 

l  

T HJs .

R`us, 

` g  usg 

l a

THJs 

k  

h e u f i  

ekb 

l t ` g r

:7

 

j u

n f b n

k c

m e t

g r n e

f s n s  k

lt

e usg

n k

e

 

l t e

f f y  

g k h f

l s g b

 

m e t

t g r

uk

bgr

R

XHE

.

:1

:5.

G

TE 

e

s 

p u

j f n h f

y

hlka

nrmg

b 

`

e t

h e u f

i  

e

kb l t ` g

r j u n f

b n k c

 

m e

t g r n e

f s

:3 

h

l k t e n

k n k c

 

TH

Js 

t f g

v g f s

 e t

 l r

 lvgr 74

p

pm r g

klt

 

u t `

l r n z g

b

a l r  u

s g

u

kbgr

 

` g

:0  

T

HJ 

g

c u f e

t n l k

s  

e

kb

mus

t

jg

rg

mlvg

b ekb

b n

s p l s g

b

l a

k e h h l

r b e k

h g w n

t ` t `

l s g

1

ANZX

R EMG

KBGB HLMT

FENKR

 

AWZBGH

FEZE

RLZ^

EKB 

KOWKHRNQG 

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 3 la 82 Tecg NB #?30

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 8/34

5

Z g c u f

e t n l k

s .

G

TE

es

h l k s n s

t g k t f y

 

s t

e t g b ,

Y t ] ` g

us

g 

l

a

THJ

s

k

h

e u f i

n s

 

klt

: e u

t ` l r n z

g b

uk

bgr RXH

E'sT

HJ

g

c u f e t n

l k s . GTE

, e h t s

ejlu t

 

TH

Js k

 

Heuf

i,

8

www

.gpe.~

lv/ph

jsnkh

eufi/ n b g /

w n b g - s

g h t

.`tm.

2 

::.

  R`g 

THJ

 

g c u

f e t n l k

s  

e p p f n h

e j f g t l

m e t

g r n e f

s h l k t e

n k n k c

74 

pp

m lr

7

c r g e

t g r THJ

s f s l

eppfy

 t l TH

J lkte

m nket

gb 

m e

t g r n e f

s

w `

n h ` h l k t e

n k  T

HJs t

1

c r g e

t g r

t`e

k

74

 ppm

  r

 

`e

v g s u r a e

h g T

HJ 

l k h

g k t r e t

n l k s

la

r g e t g

r

t

`ek 54

u c p g r

3 

54

4

hm

:.

24

.A.Z.

 

1

5 . 5 ( j )

( 8 )

5>>>

)9 1 5 . 8 .

0

:8.

 

S

`gk

TH

Js

r g aluk

b 

e t f g v g

f s w ` n

h `

v

n l f e t g

 t ` g

THJ

 

g

c u f e t

n l k s ,

> t`gy m u s t

j

g

r g

m lvgb

 ek b

 b n s p l s

g b

la k

ehhlr

bekhg 

w n t `

t ` g T

HJ n

s p l s e f

54 

r g c u

f e t n l k

s .

2

4

H.A.Z

. 315.1

5 

(

:44>)

9

25

 

H.A.

Z.

315.

1:

:

44>).

55 

:2. 

Alr 

THJ 

Zgmg bnetnlk

Sestg,

w `n h `

n k h f u b g s

s l n f

ek b

j u n f b n k c

5

:  

m e

t g r n e f

s

hlktem

nketg

b

wn

t`

TH

Js,

` g

T

HJ

n s p

l s e f  r g c

u f e t n l

k s n k h

f u b g

e

n

t g

58

h ` e r e h

t g r n z e

t n l k

n

k w `n

h ` m e t g r

n e f s

e r g sem

p fg b t l

 

n

b g k t n a

y

t

` g

k e

t u r g

ek

b g x t g

k t

l

a

52

t ` g h

l k t e m

n k e t n l

k .

24

.A

.Z.

1 5 . 1

5 ( e ) ( 8

) .

N a  TH

J

gmg

bnetn

lk Se

s t g

s

sl

uc`t l

57

 

jg

b n s p l

s g b

la

k

ek y

 

m

e k k g r

 

klt

 

p g h n a n

h e f f y

p r g

s h r n j

g b

j y

 t ` g

r g

c u f e t n

l k ,

ek

51  

e p p

f n h e t n

l k  t l b l 

sl

m u

s t

j g

epprlv

gb

j

y  

GTE 

plk

e

 

n k b n

k c

t ` e

t  

t

`g m g t `

lb w n

f f

53  

klt

pl

sg

ek  u k r

g e s l k

e j f g r

n s i  la

 k o u r y

 t l  ` g

e f t ` l r

 t ` g

gkvnr

lkmgk

t.

50

:7.

 

Na

TH

J

J

u f i

Trl

buht

Sestg

,

w ` n

h `

n k

h f u b g s

 THJ

-

h l k t e n

k n k c h e u f

i ,

>

 

n s

slu c`

t l  

j g b n s p l

s g b

la k  e k

y

m

e k k g r

 

klt

p g

h n a n h e

f f y

p r g

s h r n j g

b

j y

 t `

g

:

4 

r g c u

f e t n l k

s ,

ek

e

p p f n h e

t n l k

t l

b l

sl m u s t

j g

epprl

vgb j

y GTE

 

plk

 

e

a n k

b n k c t ` e t

:5

 

t`g m

g t ` lb

 

w n f f

klt pl

sg

ek

 

u k r

g e s l k e

j f g

r n s

i l

a k o

u r y t l ` g e f t

`

lr

 

t ` g

:: 

gkvnr

lkmgk

t. 24 

.

A.Z.

1 5 . 1 :

( h ) ( : )

.

:

8  

:1.

 

R

`grg

e r g  

k l

 r g c u f

e t l r y

 

s t

e k b e r b

s a l r

THJ

 

l k h g k

t r e t n

l k s n k

 

n k b l l

r

e n r .

:2 

Z e t ` g r ,

` g  

s t e t u t l r y

ek b

r g c u f e t l r y  

s h ` g m g

n s

b n r g h t g b e t p r l ` n j n t n k c

t ` g

: 7

 

mekua

ehtur

g,

n s

t r n j u t n

l k

ek

b

h l

k t n k u

g b  u s g

 

l

a e t g

r n e f s h

l k t e n k

n k c THJ

s,

k b

:1 

p r l v

n b n k c

 

a

l r

t ` g

n r

p

rlpgr

s t l

r e c g

e k b

b n s p

l s e f .

R`gr

g

e

r g k l

 g x h g p t

n l k s  t

l

t

` g

:

3

s t e

t u t l r y

e k

b

r g c u f e

t l r y p r l `

n j n t n l

k s  

jesg

b

l

k w`gt`

gr 

lr k l t

,

l r

 t l  

w ` e t  

x t g k t ,

:0

THJ

- h l k

t e n k n

k c

m e t g r

n e f s  

e r g

heusn

kc

h l k

t e m n k

e t n l k

la k

bllr e n r

lr

 

b u s t

.

3

AN Z

XR EMGK

BGB

H

LMTFEN

KR

ALZ

 

BG

HFEZE

RLZ

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 0 la 82 Tecg NB #?3>

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 9/34

 

:3.

 

Jy k

a l r m e f

 

m g e k

s,

uh

`

e

s

p l

s t n k c

lk  

t s

w g j s n

t g ,

GTE

es

 

h r

g e t g b

:

s u

c c g s t

g b

p u

j f n h

` g e f t

`

f g v

g f s

a l

r THJs

 k  

n k

b l l r e n r

n k  

s h ` l l

f s . R`gs

g

s u

c c g s t g

b

8

f g v g

f s

e ss

u m g t ` e

t t ` g r

g e r g

 k l t  

e

b b n t n l

k e f T

HJ x p l

s u r g s ej

lvg

jehic

rlu kb

 

f

g v g f s

2

arlm

b u s t ,

s l n f

l r lu

tbllr

 

n r

. GT

E es

 h e u t n l

k g b  t

` e t t ` g

s

u c c g s

t g b  p

u j f n h

 

` g e f t

`

7

f g v g

f s s `

l u f b

jg usgb

 

w

n t `

ek

 

e p p

r g h n e t

n l k  

la

` g

u k h

g r t e n k

t y  

s u r r l

u k b n k

c

t ` g

1

g s t n m

e t g s , ek

b

t ` e t

t ` g

y

b l k

lt  

e i g n k

t l eh

hlukt

  n r g

h t  

n k c g s

t n l k l a

,  l

r

h l k t

e h t

3

w n t `

,

h l

k t e m n k

e t g b  

j

u n f b n k

c

m e t g r

n e f s .

GT E'

s THJ

s

k He

ufi ‒ U

0

 

t f t

t p ? / / w

w w . g p

e . c l v /

p h j s n k

h e u f i /

p b a / h e

u f i

a e q

p b a ,

p . 5

: ±± 80,

24.

>

 

:0. R`

g s u

c c g s t

g b

p u

j f n h

` g e f t `

 f g v

g f s  

laTHJs

 l r

n k b

l l r

e n

r n

k s h ` l l

f s

54

`

evg

k l

 

r

g c u f e t

l r y  

j e s

n s ekb

bl

 

klt

e a a g

h t  

t ` g

s t

e t u t l r

y  

e

kb

r

g c u f e

t l r y

sh `g m

g ukbg

r

5 5

RXHE

`nh`

p r l ` n j n t s

t ` g h l k t n k u g b  

u s g

la  k y  

j u n f b n k c  

m e t g r n e f s

h l k t e n k n k c

THJs

5:

n k

h l k h

g k t r e t

n l k s la

 74 p

pm

r  c r g e t

g r l r

 

s u

r a e h g  

h l k h g k

t r e t n l

k s

la

 

r g

e t g r  

t ` e k

 

54

58

u c

p g r

5

44 hm:.

5

2

:

>.

Epert

 

arlm

  evn

kc k

l r g c u

f e t l r y

 

j e s n

s ,

t `

g   s

u c c g s

t g b p u j f n h

 

`

g e f t `

57

f g v g

f s a l

r THJ

s k

 

n

k b l l r e n

r e r g

 klt

 

e p

p r l p r n

e t g  a l r

u s g

n k

 

Mefn

ju 

j

g h e u s

g ,

e

m lk c

5

1

l t ` g r

r g e s

l k s ,

t

` g y

b l

k

lt  

e i g

 

n

k t l

ehhluk

t

` g

 a l f f l

w n k c ?

e b b n

t n l k e f

 g x p l s

u r g

53

 

pet`

wey s

i k lw

k

t

l g x

n s t  n k

 Mefn

ju, su

h`

e s g f g v e t

g b h l k

h g k t r e

t n l k s

 

la

T

HJs

k

50

j u

n f b n k c

 

s u r a e

h g s

e kb

n k

b u s t

e

kb

l u t b l

l r s l n

f 9 b

n r g h t

h

l k t e h t

 

w n t ` ( t l u

h ` n k c )

 

ekb

5>

p l s

s n j f g n

k c g s t n

l k l

a e t g r n

e f s  h l k t

e n k n k

c TH

Js y

 

h ` n

f b r g k 9

 

r n s i s t l t

` g

uk

jlrk

:4

 

h `

n f b r g k

 la  r g

c k e k t

 

t g e

h ` g r s

( t `

g s u c

c g s t g b

 

p u

j f n h

` g

e f t `

f g v g f

s

e r g

 j e s g b

 

lk

t ` g

:

5

ecg

 la 

` g

h ` n f b

r g k  

n k t ` g

 h f e s s

r l l m )

9

ekb

j

g h e u s g

 t

` g y  

e

r g j

esgb

l

k  

f g

v g f s

la

l

t e f

:: T

HJs k b

 b l kl

t  e

i g n k

t l

ehh

lukt g x p

l s u r g

 

t l

a e r

m l

r g   l x n h

,

b n l x

n k - f n i

g

: 8  

h l

k c g k g r

s ,

w`

nh`

`evg

 

j

ggk

alukb

 

n k

 t

` g Mefn

ju

X h ` l l f

s .

:2 84.

RXHE 

e i g s  

t u k f e w a u f  

t l

a e n f

t l

h lm p f y

w n t `

n t s

p r l v n s n l k s

l r  

ek y

: 7

r g c u f

e t n l k

prlm u

fcetgb

 ukb

gr t ` g

E h

t .  

57

 W.X

.H. §§

 

:152

9

:

10>.

RX

HE

r l v

n b g s

:1

  a l

r h n v

n f  

p g k e f t

n g s

a l

r suh

` v

n l f e t n

l k s

la 

lt

m lr

g

t ` e k

$:7,4

44 

l r

 geh`

 

be

y

l

a

:

3

v n l f e t n

l k ,

ekb

 a l

r i k

lwnk

c 

ekb 

w

n f f a u f  

v n l f e

t n l k s ,

 

RXH

E r

l v n b g

s n k e b b n t

n l k t l

l r

 

n k

: 0

0

AN Z

XR

EMGKB

GBHLM

TFENKR

 

ALZ BGH

FEZER

LZ^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG 

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg > la 82 Tecg NB #?04

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 10/34

5

f

n g u

l a ` g h n

v n f

p g

k e f t

n g s ,  

a n k g s

 l

a lt 

mlr

g

t

` e k

$:7,

444 l

r

ge

h`

bey

l a

 

n l

f e t n l

k ,

: 

nmp

rnsl

kmgk

t

l r kl

t

mlr

g  

` e k

l k g

 

y g

e r ,  l

r

j

l t ` .

  57

 W.X.H

. §

 

15 7

.

8

85

. R

XHE

 

r

l v n b

g s a l r

h n t

n z g k

s u n t

s

e c e n

k s t e

ky 

p g r

s l k

l r  

g k t n t

y  e f f g c

g b t l

2 j

g

n k  

v n l

f e t n l

k l

a 

R

XHE

 l

r g s t r

e n k v

n l f e t

n l k s l

a ` g  

Eht

, 

w`n

h`

mey

 

j

g n f

g b

e a

t g r

e t

7

 

f g

e s t 14

e y s '

 

k

l t n h

g l a  ` g

 

v n l f e

t n l k t l

 

t ` g

e f f g

c g b

v n l

f e t l r

 ekb t `

g  

E b

m n k n s

t r e t

l r l

a

1 

GTE.

 

57

W.X.

H.

§ 15 >.

3

 

8

:.  

L

k

e k

u e r y

 

5:, 

:

457,

 f e

n k t n a

a s

Emg

rnhe

 W k

n t g s ekb

 

TG

GZ g r v g

b

e

0 

K

l t n h

g la

 k t g k

t

t

l  X

ug t `

g

Bgagk

bekt

s 

l r

l

kcln

kc

v n

l f e t n

l k s l aR

XHE

 kb

  t s

> 

nm

pf gm

gktn

kc 

r g c u f

e t n l

k s jy

  ` g  

h l k

t n k u g

b

u

sg

e t Mefn

ju 

Mnbb

fg e

kb

@

nc`

X

h` ll

f

54 

e kb

 Oue

k 

H e j r n

f f l  

Gf

gmgk

tery

Xh`

llf l a

 THJ

s k

h e u

f i n k c

 m e t g r

n e f s

 

e

t

5 5   h l k h g k t r e t n l k s

l a 

r g e t g r  

t ` e k

74 

e r t s

p g r  

m n f f n l k

l t ` g r

t ` e k  

n k

e

l t e f f y  

g k h f l s g b

5: 

m

ekkg

r, 

s w g

f f

t

` g

h l

k t n k u

g b

u s g

 

l

a T

HJ-H

lkte

mnke

tgb

e

t g r n e

f s .

R

` g

K

l t n h

g

l a

58

 

N k t g k

t t l  

Xug

 

w e

s   g k

t  t l

t ` g

Bg

agkb

ekts ek

b ` g

GT

E 

y g r

t n a n g

b

m

e n f ,

  g t u

r k

5 2 

r

g h g n p

t

r

g q u g

s t g b .

 

R `

g g

h g n p t

s  

w `

nh` 

w grg

 

r g t

u r k g

b  

t l

T f e n k

t n a a s

 g v n b

g k h g

 

t

` e t

t ` g

57 

f e t

g s t t `

e t

ek

y 

Bg

agkb

ekt

r  

t ` g

 

GTE

 g h g

n v g b

 k l

t n h g  l

a f e n k

t n a a s

  n k

t g k t

 

t l

s

ug w e

s

5 1

  O e k u

e r y  :

4, 45

7. E

 

lp

y

l a

 ` g

 

K

l t n h

g n s  

e t t e

h ` g b ` g r g t

l

e s

Gx.

 

E.

f 3

5

0

A

EHR

WE

F 

JEH

IC

ZLW

KB

5>

 

E.

Ke tu

rg e k b

 

W s gs

 

la

 

TH

Js

:

4

88.

T l f

y h ` f l

r n k e

t g b

j n p

` g k y

f s

(

THJ

s)

gflkc

 

l

 t `

g

a

e m n f y

 

l a

 mek

-me b

g

:5

l r c e

k n h h

` g m n

h e f s  

i k

l w k

e s  h

` f l r n

k e t g

b

` y b r l

h e r j

l k s .

 

T

HJs

 

grg

b l

m g s t

n h e f f

y

:

: 

meku

aeht

urgb

 

a

rlm 

5>:

> k t

n f

t

` g n r

m e

k u a e h

t u r g

 

w e

s  jek

kgb

jy

 

RX

HE

k

5>3

1

:8 

jghe

usg 

l a

 

` g n r

 t l x n h

n t y . Bug

  l  

t ` g n

r  k l k

-

a f e m m

e j n f

n t y ,

h`

gmnh

ef t e j

n f n t y ,

  n c

`

:2 

j l n f n k c p l n k t ,  

ekb

f g h t r n h e f  

n k s u f e t n k c  p r l p g r t n g s ,

THJs 

grg 

usgb

n k  

`ukbrgbs 

l a

:7

n k b

u s t r n

e f  

e

kb

hlm

mgrh

nef

p p f

n h e t n

l k s n k h

f u b n

k c

g f g h

t r n h e

f ,

` g e t

t r e k

s a g r ,

 

e

kb

:1 

` y b r

e u f n

h  gq

unpm

gkt9

 

e

s

f e s

t n h n z

g r s

n k

p e n k t

s , p f

e s t n h s

,

h e

u f i ,

ek

b

r

u j j g

r

p r l b

u h t s

9

:3

e

kb n k h

e r j l k

f g s s

 

hlpy

 

p e p g

r .

:0

>

ANZ

XR EM

GKBG

B

HL

MTFE

NKR AL

Z B

GHFE

ZERL

Z^

EKB 

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 54 la 82 Tecg NB #?05

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 11/34

5

8

2 .

TH

Js

 

l

 k

l t  r g e b

n f y

j r g

e i blw

k k

t

` g  

g k

v n r

l k m g

k t

l

r  t `

g  

`

ume

k

: jl

by,

  u

t p g

r s n s

t a

l r f l

k c p g r n

l b s .

 R`

gy

l f e t

n f n z

g

a

rlm

 

f n

q u n b

 

e

kb

l f n

b

TH

J-

8

h l k

t e n k

n k c

 

m e

t g r n

e f s

ek

b

h

y h f g

 

jgtw

ggk

 

n r w

e t g r

 ekb

 

l n f .

2

8

7 .

E

ft`

luc `

 TH

Js

 g

rg k

l

l

k c g

r

m e

k u a e

h t u

r g b  

l r b

n s t r

n j u t

g b e

a t g r 5>3

>,

7

 

bug

 

t

l t `

g n r  

p

g r s n

s t g k

t k e

t u r g

,

m

e t g r

n e f s

 

h l k

t e n k

n k c

THJ

s

gmen

k w

n b g

s p r g

e b  t

l t ` n

s

1 

b e y

. M

e t g

r n e f

s  

suh

`

e s  

h e u

f i h

l k t e

n k n

k c

THJ

s 

l k t n

k u g

 

t

l `

ev g

  n c

` f g v

g f s  

l

a

T

HJ

s

3

e s  

f l k

c e s

 

1

4 g

e r s

e

a t g r n

k s t e

f f e t

n l k , ekb

 w n f

f h l

k t n k

u g  

t l

g

m n t

 TH

Js

k t l

t `

g

0

 gkv

nrlk

mgk

t

ekb

 

`

ume

ks  

e

r

n k t l

 

t ` g

 

a u t u

r g .

>

 

8 1 .

N k

s h

` l l f

s j u n f

t

j g a l

r g

5>

04, T

HJs

 

ek

jg 

al

ukb 

n

k

h

e u f i

,  

w

n kb

lw

5

4  

c

f e z

n k c ,

 

f l r g

s h g k

t  f

n c ` t

n k c j

e f f e s

t s ,

p e n k

t ,   l n

k t s

g e f e

k t s ,

 

h

g n f n

k c t

` g

h

l e t n

k c s e

kb

5 5  

l t ` g r j u n f b n k c

m e t g r n e f s .

5 :

83.

  R

`g T

HJs

 

sgb

 

n k

 t ` g

s g

p

r l b u

h t s

 e r g  

h

` g m n

h e f

 

m n x

t u r

g s

m

ebg

 

up l

a

5 8  

:

4 >  

e r n

g t n g s

 

l

a 

k b n v

n b u e

f  h ` f

l r n

k e t g

b

j n p `

g k y

f

hl

mplk

gkt

s,

i

klw

k e s

 h l k c

g k g

r s .

5

2

E r

l h f

l r  

n s e

r e b g

 

kem

g  l

r  

h

lm

mlk

 

h

lmmg

rhn

ef

m n

x t u r

g s l

aT

HJ l

k c g

k g r s

 

w

`nh

`

57 

w

grg

m

e k u a

e h t

u r g b

 j y 

Ml

kse

ktl k

t `

g

W k n

t g b

 

X t

e t g s

, ekb

  s

t `

g t y p

g

laTH

J

5

1  p

r l b

u h t a

lukb

  k

t ` g

 

Mef

n ju

 

X h

` l l f

s .

5 3  

8 0 . THJ

s 

k lkg m e t g

r n e f

,

a l r gx

empf

g,

e u f

i ,

he

k

v l

f e t n

f n z g n k

t l

t ` g

e

n r

5 0 

ekb

 

he

k j

g 

e j s

l r j

g b

j y

l r

 

m n c r

e t g  

n k t l

 s u

r r l u

k b n

k c m e t

g r n e

f s ,  

h e u s

n k c

 

wl

lb,

 

r n h i

,

5 >

h

l k h r

g t g

ekb

l t `

g r  j u n f

b n k c

 

m

e t g r

n e f s

 

t l jgh

lmg

 h l k

t e m

n k e t

g b  

w n t `

 TH

Js.

 

T

HJs

:4

 

ar

lm t

` g s g

 s g h

l k b e

r y

s l u r

h g s

 h

ek

e f s l

 

v l

f e t n f

n z g ekb

h

l k t e

m n k

e t g

t ` g

e n r

 

b u s t

,  ek

b

:5

  l t

` g r m e t g

r n e f

s  n k

 

t `

g

j u n f

b n k c

.  T

HJ

s k

j u n

f b n k

c s  

he

k

e f

s l

v l

f e t n f

n z g

e

kb

jg

::

 

b g

p l s n

t g b

n k t l

 

ekb 

h l

k t e m

n k e t

g  

s u r

r l u

k b n k

c  

s

l n f .

THJ

s

r g

k l t  w

e t g r

 s l f

u j f g

 

ek

b

:8

 

`ev

g jg

gk

a

luk

b

m n

f g s

 

ew

ey

a

rlm

  ` g n r

 s l u

r h g

.

:2

8>. 

Gxplsurg  l

THJs 

ek 

l h h u r t ` r l u c `

n k ` e f e t n l k ,  

n k c g s t n l k  

ekb 

bgrmef

:7

 

h l k

t e h t

 w n t `

 T

HJ

- h l k

t e m n

k e t

g b

j

u n f

b n k c

 

m

e t g r

n e f s

,

n r

b

u s t e

kb

l n f

.

:

1

24.

 

Heuf

i ek

b l

t ` g r

 j u n

f b n k

c

m e t g

r n e f

s  

h l k

t e n k

n k c

 

TH

Js

gr

g

u s g b .

 n k

:

3

s

h ` l

l f s m e n

k f y

 jgt

wggk

 

5

> 74 ekb

 

5

> 3 >

.

:0

5 4

ANZXR

 EM

GKBG

B

H

LMTF

ENKR

 

ALZ

 

BG

HFE

ZERL

Z^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 55 la 82 Tecg NB #?0:

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 12/34

  J.

 

@g

eft

` G

a a g h

t s

la

 THJ

s

:

 

25

.

E

h hl

rbnk

c

l

G

TE,

 

H

Js r

g  

p r

l j e j

f g

`um

ek 

e r h n

k l c

g k s ,

 ekb

 h

eus g

8

 

e

b v g r

s g  

g a a

g h t s

lk t `

g

n m

muk

g,  

g

p r l b

u h t

n v g ,

 

kgr

vlu

s ekb g k

b l h r

n k g

s y

s t g

m s .

G

TE,

2

 

@ge

ft` 

G a a

g h t s

 

la

 

H J

s ,

v e

n f e j

f g e t

 

` t

t p ? /

/ w w w

. g p e

. ~ ~ l

v / w e

s t g s

/ ` e

z e r b

/ t s b

/ p h j

s

7

/ p u

j s / g

a a g h

t s . `

t f k #

L t ` g

r .

1

 

2:.

N k

:4

5 8 ,

 

` g N k

t g r k

e t n l

k e f E

c gk

h y  

l r

Zg

sger

h` lk He

khgr

 NE

ZH)

3

 

r g e

s s g s

s g b

t ` g

 

h

e r h n

k l c g

k n h n

t y

la

TH

Js.

 `g

Slr

in k

c

Crl

up,

  lmp

ls g

b 

la

 

:

1

0

 

g x p

g r t s

 

ar

lm

5 :

 

l u k

t r n g

s ,  

h l k s

n b g

r g b

ml

rg

t`

ek

34 

kb

gpgk

bgk

t g p n b

g m n l

f l c n

h e f

> 

s

t u b n

g s .

R`g

 

S

lri

n kc

Cr

lup

  f e s s

n a n g b

 T

HJs

 

s

 

C

rlup

 5

ikl

wk

`u

mek

5

4  

her

hnkl

cgk

s

l

k

`

g j

e s n s

 

la

u a a

n h n g

k t  

gv nb

gkh

g

la e

r h n k

l c g k

n h n t

y

t l

 

`u

mek

s ekb

55  g x p g r n m g k t e f  e k n m e f s .

5 :

 

28 .

 

Gxp

lsu

rg 

l

TH

Js 

ek

 he

us g

 

f n v g

r  t l

x n h n t

y ,

nm

mukl

tlxn

hnt

y,

5

8

k

g u r l

t l x n

h n t y

,  r g

p r l b

u h t

n v g

t l x n h

n t y

(

n k h f

u b n k

c

j

n r t `

 b

g a g h

t s ) ,

 bg

vgf

lpmg

ktef

5 2

  t

l x n h

n t y ,

gk

blhr

nkg 

b n s

r u p t

n l k ,

 

b

n s r u

p t g b

 n k s u

f n k  

a u k h

t n l k

, e

kb h`

ekc

gs k

 t `

y r l n

b ekb

5 7

 

s

t g r l

n b  

lrm

lkg s

.

5

1 

22.

 

T

HJs

 

r g

 

e

n s i

a e

h t l r

 

a l r

 e u t

n s m ,

 e t

t g k t

n l k  

b g a

n h n t

-

` y p g

r e h t

n v n t

y

5

3

b n

s l r b

g r ,

fl

wgr

gb

NU 

e

kb

nm

pen

rgb

h

l c k n

t n v g

 

a

u k h

t n l k

.

] 

27.

E

nc`

 

f g

v g f

la

 

T

HJ

s

k

`

umek

s s

 

e

f s l

e

n s i

 a

e h t l

r  

a l r

  g e

r t b n s

g e s g

,

5 >

` y p

g r t g

k s n l

k e

kb

b n

e j g t

g s .

:

4 

2

1.

Gxp

lsu

rg  l

 TH

Js 

s e f s

l e

  n s i

a e h

t l r

a l r es t

`me

 e

kb

r g s

p n r e

t l r y

:5

b n s

g e s g

s .

::

23 .

 

THJ

s 

hh

umu

fet g

 n k t `

g `u

mek

 

j lb

y

jnl

ehhu

muf

etg)

 

ek

b r

gmen

k

n k

:8

 

t ` g

 j lb

y

l r

 mek

y g

e r s

e

a t g r

 

g x p l

s u r

g .   X t

u b n

g s  

`e

vg s `l

wk

` e t

 

TH

Js

 

ek e s

t

n k

:2

j lby

e t  

a l r  

:4

g e r s .

:7

20

. TH

J

l

kc g

kgr 

5 :1

  s

e 

n l x n

k

- f n i g

 

h`g

mnh

ef w`

nh`

s ` n c `

f y s

t e j f

g

e

kb

:

1

r g s

n s t e k

t  t l

 j n l

b g c r

e b e t

n l k

,

ekb

t ` g

m

ls t

 

l x

n h

la

 f f

 

l

a `

g TH

J

l

k c g k

g r s

.

:3

 

E

h hlr

bnk

c 

t l  G

TE'

s Zg

cnlk

ef

Xhr

ggkn

kc

F g

v g f s

,  

w`n

h` e t t g

m p t

 t l

s g

t e u

n b g f

n k g  a l

r

:

0 

w`

et

` g GTE

 

r g

b n h t

s n s e

 

5

n k 5

  m

n f f n

l k he

kh g

r n s i

 

e

kb

ek

e

h h g

p t e j

f g r

n s i

f g v

g f a l r

55

ANZ

XR E

MGK

BGB

HL

MTFE

NKR A

LZBGH

FEZ

ERLZ

^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 5: la 82 Tecg NB #?08

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 13/34

5

 

` g

e f t ` g a

a g h t s l

t ` g r

t`ek hekh

gr,

T

HJ  : 1

  s l

r b g r s

la

ec

kntub

g

m

lr g  

l x n h  

t`e

k

:

 

l t `

g r THJ

 

l

kcgk gr

s

e

k b THJ

 

lm

m grh n

ef mnx

turgs

  E r l h f

l r s ) .

8

 

2>

.

T

HJs

r g

l

k g la l

kfy

53

 h`g

mnhef

s s

f e t g b  

a

l r

g f n m n

k e t n l k

2 

n k t

g r k e t n

l k e f f y

 

j y

 t`g

 

X t l

h i `lf

m Hl

k v g k t

nlk

l

k

T

g r s n s t

g k t

Lrce

k nh 

T

l f f u t e

k t s ,

7 

r e t n a

n g b j y 57

4 h l

u k t r n g

s ek b  

g k t g

r g b  

n k t l

 

a l r h

g n k

 :442.

1

H.

@

nstlr

y  

l

a

THJ

s t 

t`g

M e f

n j u

Xh`ll

fs

3

 

74.

Nk :44>

 

e k b

 :

454,

` g B n s t r

n h t

hlkbu h

tg b 

gk

vnrlkm

gktef

 

rgv

ngws

n k

0

 

hl

kkght

nlk  wnt

` pfek

kgb

n m p r

lvg mg

k t s lk

t ` g M

e f n j u

 

@nc`

 

Xh`llf

 

h e

m p u s .

 

Nk e k

>

 

gkvnrl

kmgkt

ef

nm pe

h t

g p l r t

,

EZ

HEBN

X 

t`g

B n s t

r n h t ' s

 

g

kvnrlk

mgkt e

f h

l k s u f t

e k t )

54 

r g p

l r t g b

 t l  

t ` g B n s t r n h

t  t ` e t

 t `

g

s l

n f n k

 

t ` g  

M n b b

f g

X h`

llf

Uueb

 

f

l h e t g b

 

l

k t

` g

M X

55 

h e m p u s )

wes

hlk temnketgb

wnt`

THJs

t

lvgr 55 tnm gs

t ` g

H e f n a l r k n e

@umek

geft`

5:

  Xhrg g

knkc

Fgvg

fs g s t

e j f n s `

g b  j y

t ` g

 

H

e f n a l r

k n e

Gkv

nrlk m g

k tef

T r l t g

h t n l k Ec

g k h y ,

 

e

s

5

8

wgf

f

es

wnt` p g s t n

h n b g s

e

k b l t ` g r

 

t

l x n k s .

52

 

75. N

k

:4

54,EZ

HEBN

X

lkhf

u bgb t

` e t  t`g

 

T

HJs

k

b

p g s

t n h n b g s

 

n k

t ` g  s l n f

57 

w g r

g  e

t h l k h

g k t r e

t n l k s  t ` e

t p r g

s g k t g

b e k  ukeh

hgpte

jfg ` g

e f t `

r

n s i

e k b

 

prlp

lsgb

e

51  

r g m lv

e f e h

t n l k

p f e k .

  Zgml

vef

E

htnlk

 Sl

r i p fe

k Me

f n j u Mnb

bfg  e

k b

@n c`

 Xh

`llf

53

Hem

pus m p r

lv g m g

k t s

r l o g h

t , e v e n

f e j f g e

t

` t t p

? / / a n p

. s m m u s

b . l r c /

b l w k f

l e b s /

50

  Mefn

ju fQf

@X

Zgml

vef.~

ba.

5>

7:

. R`ns 

p f e k we

s e r r n g

b lu t

 burnk

c t `

g

summ

gr

l

a 

455,

 

w`

nfg 

summ

gr

:

4 

s

h`llf

 

w

es

k s

g s s n l k

.

R`g n s t r n h

t r g m l

v g b

20

 

r u

h i f l e b

s la

l n f

(5,53

> 

huj

nh yerbs

:

5

wgnc

`nkc

5

,570 t

lks)

ar

lm

t`g

M n b bf

g X h

`llf

Uu e b

,  

`nh`,

 

u k j g

ik lw

k s t

l

p e r

g k t s

:: 

e k b

t g e h `

g r s e t

t`g

t

nmg,

we

s 

hlkte

mnket

gb

w

nt`

TH

Js 

k b p g s t n h

n b g s .

:

8 

7

8.  

Kgn

t`gr

EZH

EBNX

 

lr

 

t `

g B n s t r n

h t  ettg

mptgb

 t l

 

bg

tgrm n

kg t ` g s

lu rhg

:2 

la

`g

THJs

k  

t`g

s l n f ,

lr 

t l  

t g s t

j u n f b n k c  m e t g r n e f s

t l

bgtgrmnkg

n a  

t`gy 

hlktenkgb

:7 

THJ

s `n

h ` mey

 

e v g mn

cretg

b t l kger

jy 

s l n f s .

:

1 

72. N

k

t`g

tw

l

yger

 p g r

n l b alf f

lw nkc

t ` g

 

s l

n f rg m

lvef,

  ` r g g

 

t g e h

` g r s t`gk

:3

wl

rink c

 

e t  

t `

g

M@s

 e m p u s

 

w

g r g

b

neckl

sgb

w

nt`

t ` y

r l n b

hekh

gr - e

 b n s g e

s g wnt`

e k

:0 gxp

ghtgb

 ekkue

f n k h

n b g k h

g

l

a

5.:>

 

pgr

5

4,444

 Em

grnhe

ks. Es a

lbey

, t

 

f g e s t

 t ` r

g g

5:

AN

ZXR EMG

KBGB HLMTF

ENKR

A

LZBGHFEZ

ERLZ^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 58 la 82 Tecg NB #?02

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 14/34

5

  s

t u b g

k t ef

umk

n

`evg

 e f s l

 

jg

gk

b n e c

k l s

g b

w

n t ` t

` y r l

n b

h e

k h g

r .

R`

grg e

r g

e f s l

 

e

t

f g

e s t

:

 

5 2 ik

lwk

 

e s

g s

la

 

` y r

l n b  

b n s g

e s g  

eml

kc g e

h ` g r

s ,  e

kb  t `

r g g

h e s g

s

l

a

m

gf e

klm

e 

l r

8

 

p r

g

-mg

fek

lme

 

e h e k

h g r  

w`n h

`

s

 

e

f s l e s s

l h n e

t g b

w n

t ` g

xpls

urg t l

T

HJs

) 

m

lkc

2

t g e h

` g r s

 

ek

b

alr

mg r

 

g e h

` g r s

, e s

 

w g f

f

es  

l t `

g r

s g r n

l u s

` g e

f t `

 

p

r l j

f g m s

.

7

 

77

.

N k Lh

tlj

gr

:4 5

8 ,

g v

g r e f

 

t

g e h `

g r s

w r

l t g

 t l  t `

g

B n s t

r n h t

w

n t ` h

l k h g

r k s

1 

t ` e

t

mg

bnhe

f 

h

l k b n

t n l k

s  t

` g y

s

u a a g

r g b mey

 

`ev

g 

jggk

 he

usgb

 jy

` g

s h ` l

l f

3 

g k v

n r l k

m g k

t .

R`g

y l n k

t g b

 

t l t `

r g g

b n e c

k l s

g s

la

`

y r l n

b

h

e k h g

r  

e

mlk

c  

t `

gm w n

t ` n k

0 t `

g  

p

r g h g

b n k c

 

s n

x

m

lkt

`s, g

v g r e

f

l t

` g r

h e s

g s la

 ` y r

l n b

 

b n s g

e s g ,

 

ekb

 

h

e s g s

 l

a

>

 m

n c r

e n k g

s ,  r

e s ` g

s , `

e n r

f

l s s ,

 

r g s

p n r e

t l r y

 prl

jfgm

s ek

b j f e

b b g r

 h e k h

g r .

R

`g

g

e h ` g

r s

5

4  

e

sigb

 

a l

r

g k

v n r

l k m g

k t e f

 

t g

s t n k

c  

ekb

 

a l

r

e h h

g s s  t

l

t

g s t n

k c  

t `

e t

`eb e f

r g e b

y l h

h u r

r g b .

5 5

71. Alfflwn kc  

` g p u j f n h  

r g v g f e t n l k

la ` g s g

m g b n h e f

n s s u g s  

emlkc  

g e h ` g r s

5 :  ek

b

la

 ` g  :

4 5 5

 rgml

vef

 l

a l x n

h

s l

n f , n k Lht

ljg

r :4

5 8  e

 cr

lup 

la

 Mefn

ju

p e r

g k t s

5 8  

` n r g

b e

l h

e f g k v

n r l

k m g k

t e f  s

h n g k t

n s t t

l  e

b v l h

e t g

 a l r

 nmm

gbn

et g  g

s t n k

c

la

f

f

la

` g

5 2 

s

h ` l l

f rl

lms

 es

w

g f f hl

mprg

`gk

sn vg

  l n

f t g

s t n k c

. Ef

t`lu

c` kl

 hl

mprg

`gk

snvg

 

l n f

5 7 

t g

s t n k

c

we

s  p

gra

lrm

gb e

t

t `

e t t

n m g ,

 

t

 

t ` g

 p e r

g k t s

'

n k

s n s t

g k h g  s

lm

g la

` g  

s h `

l l f

5 1

 

r l

lms

 

w

grg

 

g s t g

b .

5 3

 

7

3 . E

fsl

 er

lukb

 t `

e t

t n m g

,  

s

lmg

 la `

g  h

f e s s

r l l m

s

n k w`

n h` 

t g e h

` g r s

  eb

5 0

 

r g p

l r t g

b  

n

f f k g s

s g s

w

grg

 

v e h

e t g b

 ekb  

t ` l

s g t g

e h ` g

r s ek

b

` g n r

s

t u b g

k t s

w

grg s g

k t t

l

5 >

 

l t `

g r

h f

e s s r

l l m

s

l

r 

e h n f

n t n g s

.

:4

 

70

.

R

`g

n s t r

n h t

g

mpf

lyg

b 

Mer

i

Iet

h`g

k,

n t `

 

t ` g

 T`y

fme

r Cr

lup

, l

:5  

hlkb

uh t

  g

s t n k c

.

:: 

7

> .

N k

t ` g

 

n k n t n

e f t g s t

n k c

n k Kl

v gm

j gr

 

:

4 5 8

, g

k  

r ll

ms

wg

rg 

g

s t g b

 a l r T

HJ

s

:

8  

n k

 

h e u f

i  

ekb

 n k t

g r n l r

 w e

f f p e n

k t  

( ju

fi

s

e m p f

g s

) . R`g

sg 

rll

ms

wgrg

? 

`

g  F

n j r e

r y  ( n k

:2 

t ` g  

Crget  

S`ntg J u n f b n k c   ) 9

Zllms 

, :,

,

0 kb

> 

k

t ` g Jfug

J u n f b n k c   l r

:7

J u

n f b n

k c G 9 

Zll

m

4 5 n k

 

t ` g

 

R`r

gs`g

r J u

n f b n

k c ,

 

l r J u

n f b

n k c A 9

ekb

Z

llm

s

5

48,

:1

 

5 4

2 

ekb

 5 4

7 

k t

` g

Mei

l u n f

b n k

c .

J u n

f b n

k c G s

 

p

r n m e

r n f y

 

e m

nbb

fg 

s h `

l l f

:

3

j u n

f b n k

c 9  

t

` g  F n

j r e r

y ,

J

u n f b

n k c

 

A

, ` g  

R ` r g

s ` g r

 J

u n f b

n k c

 

ek

b t

` g M

eil

 u

n f b

n k c

e

r g

:

0

u

sgb

 

a l r

 

j l t

`

m

nbb

fg 

s h

` l l

f

ek

b

` n

c ` s h

` l l f

 

h f

e s s g s

.

5 8

AN

ZXR

EMGK

BGB

 

HL

MTFE

NKR

A

LZBGH

FEZE

RLZ^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 52 la 82 Tecg NB #?07

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 15/34

5

14.

  E

k kv

nrl k

mgkt

ef

Re s

i  

Al

rhg alr

mgb

j

y ` g

B n

s t r n h

t  

n k h f u

b n k c

 

p e

r g k t s

:

 

ekb

 

t g

e h ` g

r s

s g f g

h t g b t `

g s g

r

l lms

 

jg

heusg

 l a  

` g

n r  p r l x

n m n t y

 

t l

 w `g

rg TH

Js 

eb

8

 

j

ggk aluk

b n

k

t

` g

s l n f

jy

 EZH

EBN

X.

R

` g

k

t g k t

 

w e s

l  t g s

t t ` g

` y p l t

` g s n

s t ` e

t

2

 

j u

n f b n

k c

m e

t g r n e

f s w gr

g

t ` g

s l

u r h g

 

l a

 ` g  T

HJs

 k t ` g

s l n f

.

R

` g

g s t

r g s

u f t s

e p p g

e r g b

7

t l

 

h

l k a n

r m

t ` n s

 

`

y p l t `

g s n s

.

1

15.

R `

g  

T `y

fme

r 

C

rl up

 

r n c n

k e f f y

 h e f h

u f e t g

b e

M e f n j

u - s p

g h n a n

h

s h

r g g k

n k c

3

f g v g f

 a l r

 h

e k h g

r arlm

 

T

HJs

 k n k

b l l r e n r

 n k

 l r b

g r t l

r g e

h ` e

 

lkg

  k  

l kg

 

m

n f f n l

k r

n s i

0

 

f g v

g f

t ` g

r g

w lu

fb

j

g

l k g

 

g x h

g s s

h e

k h g r

lut l a

 

m n f f n

l k

p g l

p f g gxpls

gb t l

THJ

s

>

e t  

t ` n s

 

f g v g

f  a

l r t ` g

 e

ml uk

t l a

nmg

 

s t

u b g k t

s ekb t g

e h ` g r

s

spg kb

 

n k h f

e s s r

l l m s )

 

l a

5

4

:

4.:

k

eklc

rems

 

k c)

 g

r

h u j n

h  

mgtg

r l r s

t e a a  e

kb

18. 3

 

kc

p g

r h u

j n h

mg tg

r a l r

5 5

s t u b g k t s .  

( R ` g

g v g f a l r

s t e a a

w e s

flwgr j g h e u s g

t ` g y  

spgkb 

mlrg 

tnmg  

n k  

t ` g

5:

 

h f e s

s r l l m

s ) .

R ` g

 

R

e s i

A

lrhg

 e c r

g g b t l

u s g

 

:

4.:

k c

e s ek

 

e

h t n l k

- f g v

g f t `

r g s `

l f b a l

r

58

t ` g  

Mefn

ju 

X h ` l

l f s .

5

2

1:.

@l

w g v

gr, a t

g r

r g

h g n v n

k c

s l

mg

g s t

r g s u f t

s  laTHJ

s 

n

c ` g r

t `

e k :4.

:

k

c

57

p g r

 

h

u j n h

mgtg

r 

l a

 

n r t ` g  B n

s t r n h

t

u k n f e

t g r e f

f y

h`

ekcg

b t ` g

 

s h r g

g k n k c

 f

g v g f t l

 544 k

c

51

w n t

` l u t

 e

k y 

k

p u t

l r

ecrg

gmgk

t

arl

m

t ` g

Res

i A l

r h g .

 Ml k t

` s

e t

g r ,

l

k O e

k u e r

y

:

3,

5 3

:45

2,GT

E

`

ekcg

b t ` g t

` r g s `

l f b

t l

u s g  :

44 

k c

p

g r

h u

j n h

m g t

g r

e s e

 

` g e f

t `  c u

n b g f

n k g

5

0

a l r

 

n k b l

l r e n r

e t  

t ` g Mef

nju

X

h ` l l f

s .

G

T E'

s

u c c

g s t g

b  

t

` r g s `

l f b  w e

s  

e s g b

 

l k

 e

5>

h e f h u

f e t n l

k a l

r

e

s h

` l l f n k  

Kg

w

l ri

 H n t y

w

n t ` s

n c k n a

n h e k t

f y  

b n

a a g r g

k t  

h l

k b n t

n l k s

:

4

a

rlm

t

` l s g  

n k

M

efnj

u.

:

5

18

.

E f

f  

l a

 ` g

h e u

f i

ekb

 

p e n k

t

semp

fgs

arlm

 

t ` g

s g

rl l

ms

l

k t e n k

g b s l mg

::

 

f

g v g f

l a   HJ

s .

A

lur l

a ` g  

t g k t g s t

g b

rl

lms `eb

h e

u f i semp

fgs

w n

t `

f g v

g f s ejlv

g ` g

:

8

r g c u

f e t l

r y

t ` r g s

` l f b

 

l

a

7

4 

ppm.

 R `

g  

rl

l ms g s

t n k c  ejl

vg

t ` g

 

r g c

u f e t l

r y

f n m n

t

w g

rg

:2

Zllms 

,

7 

ekb

0 

k J u n f b n k c  

G 

Jfug

J u n f b n k c   )

ekb

t ` g

F n j r e r y .

:7

 

12

.

L

ut  

l a

 

84

w

npg

s u r

a e h g )

 semp

fgs 

k t `

g  t g k

 t

g s t g b

 rllm

s,

f f

`

eb s

l mg

:1

f g v g f

 l a

 

THJs

 g t

g h t g b

.

Al

ur

wn

pg se

mpfgs

 

`eb

THJ

s t  

f g v

g f s b

g g mg

b 

T

HJ

:3

Hl

ktem

nketg

b

ukbg

r

`

g

TH

J

g

c u f e t

n l k s

,

ej

lvg

5

4 mnh

rlcr

ems

p

g r 544

:0  

s q

u e r g

 

h g

k t n m g

t g r s

.

R`gs

g

sempf

gs

f f

 

he mg

 

arlm

 

w nk b

l w

n f f s

 

n

k

Zll

ms

ek

b 7

 

k

52

A

NZXR 

EMGK

BGB

HLMT

FENKR

 

ALZ

BGHF

EZER

LZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 57 la 82 Tecg NB #?01

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 16/34

5

J

u n f b n

k c

G

Jfu

g 

J u n

f b n k c

  ) ,

Z

llm

 

4

5

(R`

rgs`g

r

J u n f

b n k c )

 

ek

b

t `

g  

F n

j r e r

y .

E f

f

: 

l a

` g s

g rl

l ms

w

n t `

t ` g

 

g

x h g p t

n l k  l

aZ

llm

 

45

 

e f s

l `eb

f

g v g f s

 

l

a

T

HJs

 k  

h e u f

i

8 

g

xhgg

bnkc

 

t ` g  

r g

c u f e t

l r y  

f n m n

t l a 74

ppm.

2 

17

. 

N k

 e b b n

t n l k ,

 

e n r

se

mpf g

s

ar

lm t ` g

s e mg

 

g

k  

rl l

ms

w

grg

g s

t g b

a l r

T H J

s .

7

 

E f f

 

l

a

` g

e

n r

s

empf

gs

s

` l w g

b s l mg

  g v g f

l a

 

T

HJs

 

g f f ejl

vg

l u t

b l l r

 jehi

crl uk

b

1

 

f

g v g f s

.

R ` g `

n c ` g

s t  f g v

g f n

k t ` g s

g

t g k

 

rl l

ms  

w e s

  f

l s g  t l

54

4

k c l

aTHJ

s

g r h u

j n h

3 

mg

tgr

l a n r

.

0 

11

.

R `

g k n

t n e f  s

empf

gs w g

rg g s t

g b

a l r

e55

:4>

T

HJ

l

k c g k g

r s . Ml

s t wn

pg

> 

ekb 

j u f i

 semp

fgs ek

b

me k

y n r

sem

pf gs

 h l k t

e n k g b

 

TH

J

:

1,

`

g  

ml

st n c ` f y

 t l x

n h

54 

l a ` g

 T

HJ

l k c g

k g r s

.

5 5  

13.

R ` g  

` r g g  t g e h ` g r s

w n t `  t ` y r l n b h e k h g r

e f f

t e u c ` t

n k  

h f e s s r l l m s  

w n t `

5

: 

t l x n h

 

n f f

g c e f

f g v g

f s  

l

a

THJ

 

k  

h e

u f i l r

w n t

`

w

npg s

empf

gs

l k

s n b g

r g b T

HJ

58 

Hlkt

emnk

etgb

 

u

kbgr

  ` g

 

THJ

 g c u f e

t n l k

s .

5 2

  10

. 

Lk

 

l

v g m

jg r :

5,

:4

58,

t g v

g E

rme k

k

la

 

G

TE 

gcnl

k > '

s T

HJ

57

pr

lcre

m

wrltg

 

t l

Bg

agkbe

kt Xe

kbre

 Fy

lk,

u p g r n

k t g k

b g k t  

l

a

`

g  

B n s t r

n h t ,  

n k a l

r m n k

c

51 

t ` g B n s

t r n h t

 t ` e t

 e

THJ

 f g e k

- u p

p

f e k

w luf

b 

j

g

r g q

u n r g

b

w

`nh`

 n k

h f u b

g b

Zg

ml v

e f

5 3

 

ekb

 

b n

s p l s e

f

l a

 

e

u f i m e t

g r n e f

 

ek

b

eky l t ` g

r s

lurh

gs)

aTHJ

s 

r g s g

k t

e t

 

t ` g

5 0  

s h

` l l f

.

5> 

1

>.

R `

g

k n t

n e f t g s

t

r g s u f

t s n k b n

h e t g b

 

t `

e t  t

` g r g

 w e s

 

s l

mg  

s l

u r h g

 

l

a

T

HJs

 

k

:

4 

e f f

 l a

` g  

t g k t g s t

g b  

rl

l ms

k

 

a l u r

 

b n a a g

r g k t  

j u

n f b n

k c s n k

M

@X,

 

`n

h` w

e s

e u s n

k c

:

5 THJ

s l  jg

 alukb

 

n k

e f f  

l a ` g e

n r  ek

b wn

pg s

empfg

s

t  

w g

f f  ejl

vg

jehi

crlu

kb

::

 f g v g f

s .

Fg

vgfs

  k

h e u f

i

ej

lvg

r

g c u f e

t l r y

 

t ` r

g s ` l f

b s

w grg

 

al

ukb n k a n

v g

lu

t 

lat

gk

:8

t g s

t g b

r

l lm

s

a l u

r  

w n

t `  

lvgr 74

p

pm k

h e

u f i

e

kb

lkg

 w n t `  

l

vgr

54

uc

p g r  

544

 

hm:

:2

n k  

e  

wnpg 

e m p f g ) .  

E f f t ` g s g  

r g s u f t s

n k b n h e t g b

t ` g

f n i g f n ` l l b

l a

n b g s p r g e b

:7

 

v n l

f e t n l

k s

l aRX

HE 

` r l

u c ` l u

t

t ` g M

efnj

u X

h ` l l

f s .

@l

w g vg

r, ` g

B

n s t r n

h t

`es

s n

k h g

:1

s t

g e b a

e s t f y

 

r g

a u s g b

 t l

t g s t

 eky 

mlr

g h e

u f i

l r

l t `

g r

j

u n f b n

k c m e

t g r n e

f s n k

t ` g  Mef

nju

:3

X

h`ll

fs

l

 b g

t g r m

n k g  t

` g

shlp

g

e

kb 

g x t g k

t l a

 l k

t e m n k

e t n l

k  r g q u n

r n k c  

r g

m g b n

e t n l

k

:0

 

ukb

gr

R

XHE

.

57

ANZX

R EMG

KBGB

 

HL

MTFEN

KR

ALZ

 

BG

HFEZE

R4:^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 51 la 82 Tecg NB #?03

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 17/34

5

3

4. 

N k

s t g e

b , s n

k h g  

B

gh g

mj g

r

:

4 5 8

,

` g  

B n s

t r n h

t  

`es

  g s t g b

 l k

f y

e n

r e

kb

b u s

t

: 

n k  s g f

g h t g

b  

r l

lms

  ` r l u

c ` l

u t t

` g Mef

n ju

 X

h ` l

l f s .

 

N t

 n s n

m p l s

s n j f

g t l

b g

t g r m

n k g

8 

ar

lm

e n r

ek

b

b

u s t

t g s t s

 

w`g

t`g

r

T

HJ

s

k

 

h

e u f i

 

l r

 l t ` g

r m e t g

r n e f

s  g

xhg

gb t ` g

2

 

r g c u

f e t l

r y

t ` r

g s ` l

f b

la

 

74

 

p

pm 

r

c r g e

t g r t ` e

k

5 4

uc p

g r 5 4 4

 

h

m:

.

@

lwgv

gr,

 ` g

7  

n k

n t n e

f

t g s

t s  l

a

u n f b

n k c  

m e t g

r n e f

s ,

e s w g f

f e

s  

f e

t g r

n k

b g p g

k b g k

t

t

g s t n

k c , n k b

n h e t

g t `

e t

1

 

n f f

g c e f

 

T

HJ

s

r g

 

a

luk

b 

t ` r

l u c `

l u t

 

t `

g

M

efn j

u 

X h

` l l f

s 9

k s l

mg 

e s g

s e t  m

eky

  n

m g s

3 

t

` g  

f g v g

f s

alu

kb

n k

t `

g  

n k n t

n e f t g

s t n k c

.

0

 

35.

 

R

`g

n

s t r n

h t ' s  t

g s t n k

c  

la

n r

ek

b b u s

t

r g v

g e f n

k c

t ` g  

p

r g s

g k h g

 la

 THJ

s k

> 

me

ky

r

llm

s g v n

b g k

h g s

t ` e

t

t

` g r g

 

n

s  e

 

l u r

h g la

 

T

HJs

 k

 

t

` l s

g

rll

ms

w

`n h`

 h l

u f b  jg

5 4

 

ejlv

g RX

HE

n m n t

s , ekb

 n k  

a e h t

 n s ` n c

` f y

f n

i g f y

 

t

l

jg e

jlvg

 R

XHE

 n m n

t s  

w`gr

g ` g

5 5  

s emg

y p g

la 

e u f i  

n k

t ` g

s emg 

j u n f b n k c  

t g s t g b  

ejlvg 

f g c e f

f n m n t s .

5 : 

3:

.

N k

 Bgh

gmj

gr :4 5

8 ,

` g

 B

n s t r

n h t h

lkbu

htg

b 

h f

g e k n

k c

ek

b

p r

g

-ek

b p l s

t-

5 8  

h f g e

k n k c

 

e n

r

ek

b wnp

g

g s

t n k c

 n k  :5

h f e s

s r l

l m s ,

 

n k h

f u b

n k c t

` g

t g k

t g s

t g b

p r g

v n l u

s f y .

5

2  R`g

sg 

rl

lms

 

w

grg

 

k

t

` g

J u n

f b n k

c

G

 

Jf u

g

J u

n f b n

k c )

,  

J u

n f b n

k c

A

R ` r g

s ` g

r

5 7

 

J u

n f b n

k c )

,  

t

` g  

Cr

get S`

n tg

 

J u

n f b

n k c

w`

grg t `

g

F

n j r e

r y  n

s f l h e

t g b ,

 t ` g

M

eil

5

1 

J u n

f b n k

c ,

e

kb

e 

e h

u f t y

 

l

a a n h

g

f l

h e t

g b

k g e

r t `

g jly

s'

l

h i g r

 

rll

m

a l r t

` g  

c y

m, w

`nh

`

5 3

 

n s

 us g

b 

j y

 

j

l t `

t

` g  M

n bbf

g ekb

 

@ n c

` 

X h

` l l

f s .

B g

s p n t

g  

t `

g  a

e h t  

t ` e

t

t `

g  

B n

s t r n

h t ' s

5

0  

h l k

s u f t

e k t

f g

a t t `

g wn

kbl

ws  l

pgk

n k  s

g v g r

e f  

la `

g t g

s t g b

 rll

ms,

 `

u s

b n

f u t n

k c  

t `

g

5 >  

THJ

s k

t ` g

 se

mpf

gs, f f

la `

g

t g s t

g b rll

ms  

s `

lwg

b s lm

g

g

v g f la

 TH

Js 

k t ` g

e n r

:4 

s

n c k n

a n h e k

t f y

n k

 

g x

h g s s

 

la

 

u

t b l l

r

f g v

g f s ,

 e

s  

w g f f

 

e

s TH

Js

k

 e f f la

  ` g w

npg

 s

e m p f

g s ,

:5  

j

l t `

 p r g

- ek

b

p l s t

- h f

g e k

n k c ,

 

n k b

n h e t

n k c t ` e t

 

t `

g r g

n s e

 

l u

r h g

 la

TH

Js

 

k

e f f l

a ` g

s g

:

: 

:

5

rll

ms k  

a n v

g

b n a a

g r g k

t

j u

n f b n

k c s  

n k

 

M

@X

.

:

8  

38.

 

N k  Ag

jrue

ry

:4

5 2,

 

` g  

B n s

t r n h

t  

r g t e

n k g b

 

t ` g

 a

n r m

 

G

kv n

rlk 

k t g r

k e t n

l k e f

:2 

(Gkvn rlk)

s

n t s  

h l k s u f t e k t  

lk

h`gmnhef  

h l k t e m n k e t n l k

n s s u g s n k

t ` g

Mefnju

X h ` l l f s .

:

7  

32.

 

Lk

p r n

f

:7

, :452

,

kv n

rlk

 s u

j m n

t t g b

 

t

l

GT

E t s

b r e a

t

:1

 

Hl

mpr

g`g

ksn v

g

THJ

- Z g

f e t g

b

J u n

f b n k

c  

M e

t g r n

e f s

N k s

p g h t

n l k ,

 Me

kec

gmg

kt ek

b

:3

Z gm

lv e

f  T

fek a

l r t `

g  

X

ekte

 

Ml

kn h

e-

Mefn

ju W

k n a n

g b Xh

`ll

f

n

s t r n

h t  

(

` g r g

n k e a

t g r

:

0

A n r

s t

Gkv

n rl

k Tf e

k ) 

N k  t ` e

t  

T f

e k , Gk

vnr

lk, l

k j

g ` e f

a la

 

`

g  

B n s

t r n h

t ,  

p r l p

l s g

b t l

5

1

AN

ZXR

EMGK

BGB

 

HL

MTFE

NKR

AL

Z

BG

HFEZ

ERLZ

^

EKB 

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 53 la 82 Tecg NB #?00

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 18/34

5

 

r g

m lv g

h

e u f i b g t g r

m n k g b

 t l

h

l k t e n k

 

T

HJs 

k

h l k h g k

t r e t n l

k s ejlv g

 t ` g

r g c

u f e t l

r y

: 

s t e k

b e r b

la74

ppm 

k t ` g

F n j r e

r y

ekb

 

rl

lm s

5

, 7

ekb

0

 

k f y n k

h l k k g

h t n l k

w n t `

t

` g

8

b

g m l f n t

n l k l r r

g k l v e t

n l k  l

a

` g

j u n f b n

k c s n

k

w

`nh`

t ` l s g r

llm s

r g

f

l h e t g b

,

gvg

k

2 

t`lu

c`

k l suh

` b g m l

f n t n l

k s l r  r g

k l v e t

n l k s  

w g

rg

t ` g k s h

` g b u f g

b . G k v

n r l k ,

 

e c

e n k

l

k

7

j g ` e

f a  

l

a ` g  

B n

s t r n h t ,

 prlpl

sgb

t l

m e k e c

g  

n k p f

e h g t ` l s

g THJs

 

kb

 

l t ` g r

1 

s u s p g h

t g b TH

J

- h l

k t e n k n

k c

m e t g r n

e f s  

n

k

t ` g  

n

k t g r n m

. M e k

ecgm

g k t k p f e h g

 

wlu f

b

3 

h l

k s n s t

la

 

g k g r

e f

s h `

l l f  

h

f g e k n k

c

ekb

 

r g p e n r

 l r rgmlv

ef l

k f y  

la

n s n

j f y b

g t g r n l

r e t n k c

0 

h e u f i

.

>

 

3

7.

R ` g

n r s t Gkv

nrlk

Tfek

 

p r l v

n b g b

a l r  se

mpfnk

c l

a 

u n

f b n k c m e t

g r n e f s

54 

ekb

s l n f s

 

t

l  

b g t

g r m n k

g

t ` g

k e t u r

g ekb 

g x t g k

t

la ` g

p r g s g k

h g la 

H J s ,  

u t

 

l k f y

5 5  

nmmgbnetgfy 

p r n l r

t l

ek y

r g k l v e t n l k

l r  

b g m l f n t n l k  t ` g

B n s t r n h t  

mnc`t

hlk buht

t  

ek

5:

  u k

i k lw

k tn

mg

n k

t ` g

a u t u r g

.

N a  

su

h` semp

fnkc p

r n l r t

l r g k l

v e t n l k

 l

r

b g m l

f n t n l

k

58 r g v

g e f g b

 

T

HJs

k

g x

h g s s

l

a g c u f

e t l r y

f n m n t s ,

 

t

` g k  e s

n t g - s p

g h n a n h

 

r g m g b

n e t n l

k

p

f e k

5

2 wlu

f b j

g h r g e

t g b e t

t ` e t

 

tnmg

 t l

cl

vgrk rg

mlvef

 

ekb

 

e p p r l p

r n e t g

 b n s p l s

e f

la 

THJ-

57

h l k t e

n k n k c

 

m e t g

r n e f s

ar

lm

t ` g  

j u

n f b n k c

s

e

jlut l

 jg

 r g k

l v e t g b

 

l r

 

b

g m l f n

s ` g b .

 R` g

51  

A n r s t

Gk vn

rlk  

Tfek b n b

 kl

t p r l

v n b g

a l r

 ek y

 t

g s t n k c  

la u n f b

n k c m e

t g r n e f

s ,

n r l

r

b u

s t

5

3

b u r n k

c  

t `

g

m e

k e cg

n k

p f e h g

 

p g r n l

b p r n

l r t l r

g k l v e t

n l k

l

r

b g m

l f n t n

l k .

5

0

31.

Lk ukg 2, :45

2,

GTE

 

g o g h t g

b

t `

g  A

n r s t

Gk v

nrlk T f

e k .  GT

E 

sig

b 

a l r

5>

t ` g

s u j

m n s s n

l k

w n t ` n k

 

84 ey

s

l

a w l

g p e r

e t g

p f e k

s ‒

lkg

l

r Me

fnju

@

nc` X

h`llf

:4 

ekb

lkg

a l r  

s h ` l

l f s

B n s t

r n h t

- w n b g

.

GTE

 

g m e

k b g b e

s h `

g b u f g

 

t

l

e h

t u e f f y

 r

g mlv g

:

5

h e

u f i h l k t

e n k n k c

 

74

ppm 

r c r

g e t g r h

l k h g k t

r e t n l k

s

la H J

s ,

k

b

es

igb

a

l r

t `

g

:: 

e b

b n t n l k

 

t l

 t ` g

p f e

k la

 

g r

n l b n h

e n r

 

e

kb

w npg

t g s t n

k c

pg

kbnkc

 rg

mlvef

.

:

8 

33.

 

Lk

u f y 8

, 

:452

,

Gk vn

rlk  

s u j

m n t t g b

 

lk

j g ` e

f a la

 

` g

B n s t r

n h t n t s

X n t g

-

:2

X p g h n a n h ,THJ

- Z g f e t g b J u n f b n k c M e t g r n e f s

Me k ecg m g k t ,  

` e r e h t g r n z e t n l k  

ekb

: 7

Zgm

gbnet

nlk  Tfe

k l r

t ` g

 F n j r e r

y

e

k b

J u n f b

n k c

G

 ll

m s 5 ,

 7 ekb

 0

` g

r g n k e a

t g r

:

1 

X g hlk

b

G

kvnrl

k T f e

k . )

B g s p

n t g GT E

's

b

g m e k b

 a l

r e

s h ` g b

u f g t l

e h t u e

f f y

r g m l

v g

:3

n

f f g c e f

T

H J s ,  

` g

X

ghlkb

 

Gkv

nrlk Tf

ek 

h l k t n

k u g b t ` g

p r l p l

s e f

n k

t

` g A n r

s t Gkv

nrlk

:

0

Tfek t l

r gmlv

g  

e

k b  b n

s p l s g

la

` g

 

n f f g

c e f

h e u

f i

ekb 

l t

` g r  j

u n f b n k

c m e t

g r n e f s

 

l

k f y

53

AN ZX

R EMGK

BGBHL

MTFEN

KR ALZ BGH

FEZER

LZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 50 la 82 Tecg NB #?0>

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 19/34

5

w `

g k

r g k l

v e t n l k

s l r

b g m l f n

t n l k s

la ` g  

j u n f b n

k c s

l h h

u r r g b

 

e t ek

u k i

k lw k

t n m g  

n k

:

 t ` g

 a u t u

r g . R ` g

 

X g

hlk b

 Gk vn

rlk  

T f

e k mgrg

fy eb

bgb e

p r l v n

s n l k t `

e t

rg

mlvef

 wluf

b

8

 

lh h

ur

w n

t ` n k 57

 y

g e r s ,

 

n a

  `

e t w grg

 sll

kgr

t

` e k  r g

k l v e t

n l k

l r

b

g m l f n t

n l k ,

w n t `

 

t ` g

2

p l s s n

j n f n t y

 

la

 

g q u g s

t n k c

ek g x t

g k s n l k

 la

 ` g

57

- y g

e r  t n

m g a r e

m g .

7

3

0.  

R` g

X

g hlkb

 

Gk vn

rlk  

Tfek

 p r l v

n b g b a l r  k

l a u r t ` g

r

t g

s t n k c

la e u f

i l r

1

l t `

g r

m e t g

r n e f s ,

 gxhgp

t

k

h l k o u

k h t n l

k w n

t ` j u n f b

n k c r g k

l v e t n l

k l r

b g m l

f n t n l k

,  l r

 n k

3

h l k o u k

h t n l k

 w n

t ` h e

u f i

rg

mlvef

 

w ` g

k

m lr

g

t ` e k

5

7 y g e r s

 `e

b

g f e p s

g b w

n t ` l u

t

0

 

r g k l v

e t n l k

 

l

r b g m l f n

t n l k .

>

3>.

T r

n l r

t

l  

s

uh`

a u t u r

g  

rgml

vef

la

e u f i ekb

l t ` g r

 

h

l k t e m

n k e t g

b

m e t g r

n e f s ,

5

4

m ek ec

g m g k

t k p f e h

g  w

lu fb t

e i g  p f e h

g  t

` r l u c

`

h f g

e k n k c

 (

es w n t

`  

t ` g

A n r

s t Gk vnrl

k

5 5 T f e k ) , w n t ` t ` g

e b b n t n l k  

la 

n r

ekb

wnpg 

sempfnkc 

n k  

s g f g h t g b

rllm s  

lv gr

e lkg

y g e r

5:

 

p g r n l

b . GTE

 es

kg

vgr eppr

lvgb 

l r

b n s e p p

r l v g b

 

t ` g

X g hl

kb G

kvnrl

k T f e

k .

5

8

04.

L

k 

u f y  

53,

:4

52 f e n k t

n a a s TG

GZ kb

Emgr

nhe

W k n

t g s

t ` g k

M

efnju

52

 

W

k n t g s

)

u j m n

t t g b

h l

m m g k t

s lk

t ` g

 

X g

hlkb

Gk v

nrlk T f

e k ,   s

s g r t n k

c t `

e t

t

` g

T

fek

57

w e s

k v n l f

e t n l k la

 RXH

E k b

la G

T E's

s p g

h n a n h b n r g h

t n l k s

a l

r

t ` g

T f e k .

 Eflkc

 

w n t `

51

t ` g n

r h lm m

g k t s ,

 

TG

GZ k

b Mefnj

u

W

k n t g s

s u

j m n t t

g b

r

g s u f t s

 

arl

m

n k b g p

g k b g k

t

53

t g s

t n k c

a l r T

HJs r

lm e

k GT

E- h g r t n a

n g b

f e j l r e

t l r y . A n

r s t X g t

 la 

kbgp

gkbgkt

 

g s t s

) .

50

R

` g n r s t

r ll

m t l

j

g 

t g s

t g b n k

O H GX

,Zll

m 5>

, u n

f b n k c

 

A

,  

`e

b

8

24,44

4 p

pmTHJ

s

5>

n k

t ` g

 h e u f i

, t

`luse

kbs

la

t

n m g s  

` n

c ` g r  

t ` e k

 

t ` g ` n c

` g s t

f g v g f

 l

a  , 0 3 4  

p

pm

:

4

p r

g v n l u s

f y a

lukb

n k t ` g

F n j r e

r y ekb

k g e

r f y sgvgk

 t`

lusek

b t n

m g s

t ` g

r g c u f e

t l r y

f n m n t

:5

la 74

 

p p

m .

R ` g

 w llb s

`lp r l

lm  

n k

t ` g

@n c

`  

Xh

`llf Ekc

gf

J u n

f b n k c

 

`eb

 

h e u

f i

n

k

::

 

t `

g

bllr

 

ar

em g w`nh

`

t

g s t g b g

vgk  

n c ` g r

 

‒

e t

 834,44

4

ppm

 

T H

Js .

:

8

05.

N r l k n h

e f f y ,

Zl

lm

5>

 

k

 

OHGX

 w

e s lkg

 t l

w`

nh`

e n x t `

 c r e

b g

t g e h

` g r

:2 

ekb

` g r

s t u b g k t s

`eb

jggk

m lv g b  

b u r n k c  t ` g p r g v n l u s s h ` l l f y g e r t l

p r l t g h t

t ` g m

: 7

 

ar

lm

gx

plsurg

s

k

 

e 

Mn

bbfg  

Xh`ll

f

r

llm

w`nh

` h l k t e

n k g b

h

e u f i l k f

y m l

b g s t f

y

:1

ejl

vg

t

` g

74

 

pp

m g c e f

 

t

` r g s ` l

f b .  R`

g B n

s t r n h t

 

`eb 

t l u t g

b  n

t s

p r

l t g h t

n v g

e h

t n l k

:3

w`nh

`

n k

a e h t m lv g

b  

` n

s

t

g e h ` g r

 ekb

s t u b g k

t s t l

e t ` g k -

u k t g s

t g b r ll

m

w n t `

:

0 

t`lus

ekbs

la

 

nm

gs m lr g T H

Js .

50

A

NZXR

EMG

KBGB 

HLMTF

ENKRALZ

BGHFEZ

ERLZ^

EKB 

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 5> la 82 Tecg NB #?>4

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 20/34

 

0

:.  

R`

g 

nkb

gpgk

bgk

t g s t n

k c  e f

s l  

s `

lwgb

  ` e

t

h e

u f i n k t

` g  l

a a n h g

 

Z

ll

m Kl.

:

 3 ::

)  

g

e r

t `

g  j

lys

' l h

i g r r

llm

 n k

 

M@

X 

x

hgg

bgb

r g c u

f e t l

r y

s t

e k b e

r b s

e t 5 >

4  pp

m,

8

ek

b

b

n r t

s

emp

fgs 

s `

lwgb

 

T

HJ 

g v

g f s  

e s

m

uh `

 

e s

 

5

5

t n

m g s  

`

n c ` g

r

t ` e k

 G TE

' s

2

 

r

g c n l

k e f

s h

r g g k

n k c  

c u n

b g n k

 

M

@X

 

ll

ms 

, :

 

kb

 

7 k  

J u

n f b

n k c G 

t ` g

 

Jf u

g

7

J

u n f b

n k c )

.

1

0

8.

N

k s um

,  

` g A n r

s t  

Xg

t

l

a

kb

gpg

kbgk

t  g s t s

 alu

kb 

t `

r g g

rl

lms

 w

n t ` h e

u f i

3

 

g

xhg

gbnk

c f g c

e f

f n m n

t s ,

w n t

` t wl

 

l

a

`gm

 

n

k t ` g

`uk

brgb

s 

la

 

`

l u s

e k b s

 

pp

m TH

Js .

0

0

2. 

T

HJ

s jlv

g 

r g c u

f e t l

r y f n

m n t s

 

`

eb

k

lw jgg

k al

ukb

 

n k  a

l u r  

b n

a a g r

g k t

>

j

u n f b

n k c s

 e

t e f f

t ` r

g g

M

ef n

ju 

Xh

`llf

s 

‒t`g

 Gf

gmg

kter

y, Mn b

bfg

 ekb

 @n c

`

X h ` l

l f s .

5 4

 

0

7. 

L v g

r  

` g

s um

mgr

 l

a  4 5 2

,

kv

nrl

k h

e r r n

g b

lu

t

t s p

f e k s

 t l

 

h f g

e k

ek

b

55

t g s t e n r

ekb

b u s t

n k  

meky  

la

` g r llms  

t

t ` g

Mefn ju

X h ` l l f s .  

Kl 

e u f i

l r

l t ` g r

5

:

j u

n f b n

k c

m e t

g r n e

f s (j

ufi

 s

empf

gs)

 

w

grg

 

g s t g

b .

5 8

 

01

. 

Wk

fni

g `

g

g e r f

n g r t

g s t n

k c  

j

y   ` g

T

`yf

mer

 

Cr

lup

, 

kv

nrl

k b n b

k l

t t g s

t

e f f

5 2

la

 

` g

 h lm

plk

gkt  T

HJ

l k

c g k

g r s ,

 j u t

 l k f y

 t l t e f

 

T

HJs

.

E

f s l ,

 

Gk

vnr

lk 

us

gb e

5 7

 

b g t g

h t n l

k f g v

g f

la

  p p r l

x n m

e t g f

y

3 4

 

kc

 p g r

 

h

u j n

h  

m

gtg

r a l r  

e n

r

t g s t s

,

t `

u s

p r

l b u h

n k c

5 1

 

kum

grl

us  

klk

- b g t

g h t

r

g s u f

t s w`n

h` b

l klt

  k

 a e

h t n k

b n h e

t g

t

` e t t `

g r g w

grg

 k

l THJ

s

5

3

n k  t

` g  

e n r

.  

R

`g

e r f

n g r

t g s t

n k c  we

s   j

f g t

l  

b g

t g h t

 

TH

Js 

k l

u t b

l l r  e n

r e

t

5

. : 8

k

c p g r

5

0 h u j

n h  

m g t g

r .

5 >

 

0

3. 

Es

 

l

t g b

 ej lv

g, 

` g

 

g e

r f n g

r

t g s t

n k c

a

luk

b 

T

HJs

 

k

n

k b l

l r  e

n r ej

lvg

:4

 

l u

t b l

l r

jehi

crl

ukb

 f

g v g f

s

n k

e f f

t

g s t g

b rll

ms,

 

k b

n h e t

n k c e 

l u

r h g  

la

THJ

s k t `

l s g

:5

rl

lms .

 

R`g

 

Gk

vn rl

k

g s t n

k c e

vln

bgb s

uh `

 a n k b

n k c

s j

y  

g t

t n k c

 

t ` g

 

b

g t g h

t n l k

 

f

g v g f

:

: 

mu

h` n c

` g r .

 

G

k v n

r l k '

s b g t

g h t n

l k  

f g v

g f

la

 

4  

kc

p g r h

u j n

h mgt

gr

w

es

k l t

 a e r jgf

lw

:8

G T

E ' s

  g e f t

` c

u n b g

f n k

g la

 

5

4 4  k

c p

g r

h u j n

h m

gtgr

 

l r

h ` n

f b r g

k

ec g

s 8 l

1.

 Es

  l

t g b

:2 

ejlvg,GTE 

es

e u t n l k g b  

t ` e t

t

s u c c g s t g b

` g e f t `  c u n b g f n k g s a l r

THJs 

k

e n r  

s ` l u f b

:7

jg u

sgb

w

n t `

ek e p

p r g h

n e t n

l k  

la ` g

 u k h g

r t e n

k t y

s

u r r l

u k b n

k c

t ` g

g s

t n m e

t g s .

 

:

1

00

. S

`nfg

 

Gkv n

rlk

 hf

en m

gb

t

l  

h f g e

r a

l r

l h h

u p e t

n l k

 

e f

f l

a

`

g  M

efn

ju

:3

 

Xh`

llf

 

j u n f

b n k c

s jes g

b 

lk 

t s e n r e

kb

b

u s t

 

s

e m p f

n k c

,

t s

a n k b

n k c

s

b

n b

kl

t

l k s n

b g r

:0

w

`gt`

gr 

l r

k

l t  t ` g

r g

wg

rg

r g

c u f e

t l r y

 

g

xhg

gbek

hgs

 

k

t ` g

 r

llm

s   g s

t g b .

 

Al

r gxe

mp f

g,

5 >

AN ZX

R E

MGK

BGB

HLM

TFEN

KR

ALZ

 

B

GHF

EZER

LZ

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG 

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :4 la 82 Tecg NB #?>5

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 21/34

5

Z

llm 

5>

  t

O HG

X, 

`

nh`

eb 

8

24,4

44 pp

m l t e

f THJ

s k

 

h e u

f i

ekb

 

5::

 p

pm

THJ

:

 

5

:1,

mlrg

 

`

e k  t

w l m n

f f n l k

 t n m

g s ejl

vg 

` g G

TE 

g

e f t ` s h

r g g k n

k c

c u n b

g f n k g

,

w e

s

8 h f g

e r g b

a

l r

lhh

upek

hy

jy 

g f g

m g k t

e r y

s h ` l

l f h ` n f

b r g k .

  J

gheu

sg

G

kvnr

lk 

b

n b  

k l

t t g s t

2

a l r

 

n k b n

v n b u

e f THJ

 l k

c g k g

r s ,   t

n s k

lt

i k l w

k  

`l

w 

muh

`

l a ` g

 THJ

s `n

h` w

grg

7 b g t

g h t g

b

n

k

t `

g e n r

l a

Zll

m >

 

w g

rg 

TH

J :1.

1

0>.

 

S

`gk l l m

s  

g s t g

b

ej

lvg

GT

E u

n b g f n

k g s  a l r

THJ

s k

 

e n

r

ekb 

b u s t

,

3

Gk vn

rl k

snm

pfy

r

g-

h f g e

k g b  t ` g

 

rl l

ms k t n

f

e  

g e b n k

c jgfl

w t ` g

 

G

TE

u n

b g f n k

g s

0

 h l

u f b jg

 

l

j t e n

k g b .

N k

 

t

w l  

rllm

s, ` g

 w

l l b s

` l p

 

rl l m

 n k

 M@

X

kb

ek 

l a a n

h g

e

t

> OHG

X,

` n s

b

n b

klt u h

h g g b

, ekb

 

t

` l s g

r

llms

 

w

grg h f

l s g b

 

l a

a , t`lu

c`

rl lm

s f f

54

 

erl u

kb

t`gm

,

n i

g f y

j u n

f t  

w n t `

t `

g s e

mg

h e u

f i ekb

 

l t ` g r

 j

u n f b n

k c

m e

t g r n e

f s , rg

menk

gb

55

lpgk

g c e r b f g s s  

l a  

`gt`gr

` g y

` eb 

jggk 

g s t g b  

n k

eky 

alrm.

5 :

>4.

N

k  

e

 

B g hg

mjg

r

:4

5 2 Zg

pl rt

 l k

 

t s

semp

fnk c

 ekb

 

h

f g e k n

k c

g a a

l r t s lv

gr

58

  t ` g

 

s u

mmg

r l

a

452,

 

G

kvnrl

k

r

g p l r

t g b

t `

e t

n t

 

` eb 

g s t g

b e n r ek

b b u

s t n k

84 l

 1

4%

a

5

2

r g c u

f e r f

y

l

hhup

ngb rll

ms  

n

t ` g r

p r g -

 l r

p l s t

- h

f g e k n

k c .

N t

s t e t

g b t ` e

t t ` g

t g s

t g b

rl lm

s

57 

w grg

 

g x p

g h t g

b

t l j

g g p

r g s g

k t e t n

v g  

l

a

` g

k l k-se

mpfgb

 r g c u

f e r f

y

l

h h u p

n g b  

rl lm

s

51 jg

heusg

 

t `

g y  

`e

b t ` g  

s e m g

 

h

l k s t r

u h t n

l k

` n

s t l r

y , s n m n f

e r p l

t g k t n

e f f y

TH

J

-

n m p e

h t g b

5

3

j u

n f b n k

c

m e t g

r n e f

s ekb s

n m n f e

r a

u k h t n

l k s ek

b

usecg

 

p e

t t g r k

s .   R

`us,

 Gk

vnrl

k

5 0

hl

khfu

bgb

`

e t h l k b n

t n l k

s  

n k

t ` g r

ll m

s kl

t g

s t g b

w g

rg

k

lt

x p g

h t g b

 t

l  jg

 b n a a

g r g k t

5>

 

ar

lm t `

l s g

t `

e t  

w g

rg g

s t g b .

:

4

>5.

R

` g

s e m

g r g

e s l k

n k c w

luf

b 

e p

p f y  

t l

r

l l m

s  

w `

grg

h e u

f i w e s

g

s t g b ekb

:5

 

a

lukb

 

t l

 jg 

ejlv

g

f

g c e f

f

n m n t s

9  

t `

g

se

mg  

g s u

f t s s ` l u f

b

jg

g x p g h

t g b n k  

l t

` g r  

rl l

ms

::

w

n t `

t ` g

 s e

mg

h l k

s t r u h

t n l k

 

` n s

t l r y

 e

kb s n m n f

e r T

HJ

- n

m p e h

t g b

j

u n f b

n k c m e t g

r n e f

s ,

:8

g . c . h e

u f i .

:2

>:. 

N k

meky 

e s g s , t ` g  h f g e k n k c  hlkbuhtgb

jy  

Gkvnrlk

a l r

t ` g

B n s t r n h t

l v g r

:7

t ` g  s um

mg r

 l a

 :4

5 2

h t u e

f f y

n k

h r g e

s g b t

` g

f g v

g f s l

a

T

HJs

 k  t ` g

 

e n r .

  H f g

e k n k c

:1

b g h

r g e s

g b THJ

 n r h l k

h g k t r

e t n l

k s

l k f

y n k  e

m

e f f p g r

h g k t

e c g l a

 e s

g s . Gk

vnrl

k

:3

 

r g p

l r t g b

 t `

e t  :

5

a n r

semp

fgs h l f

f g h t g

b  

e t

t

` g

s e

mg l h e

t n l k

j l

t ` p r g -

 ekb p

l s t-

:

0

:4

A N

ZXR

E

MGKB

GB

H

LMTF

ENKR

ALZ

BGHF

EZER

LZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :5 la 82 Tecg NB #?>:

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 22/34

5  

h

f g e k

n k c

 

`

eb

n

k h r g

e s g

b  

f g v g

f s l

a

T

HJs

 a

t g r  

h

f g e k

n k c ,

 

13

%

gm

en k

gb

t ` g s

emg

, 

ekb

:

 

lk

fy 5

:%

g h r g

e s g b

.

8 

>8.

 

Gk

vnrl

k

r

g p l r

t g b

t ` e t

 

t `

g f

g v g f

s la

 TH

Js

k

b u s

t

s

emp

fgs 

k h r

g e s g

b

2 

p l s t

- h

f g e k

n k c

n k

7%

 a

 

` g  

sem

pfgs

, g

h r g e

s g b

 

n k

 

:

1%

a

` g

 

s

empf

gs ek

b 

10

%

7 

s t e

y g b  

kl

k

- b

g t g h

t .

1 

> 2

. R`

us,

 

` g

j g s t

 

m

eke

cgm

gkt

 

r e h t

n h g s

  h f

g e k n

k c

hl

kbu

htgb

 

j

y `

g

3 

B n

s t r n

h t  e h t

u e f f

y h e u s

g s  T

HJ

s

k t ` g  

e n r

t l

n k h

r g e s

g

l r

 

s

t e y

t ` g

 

s em

g mlst

 

la `

g

t n m g

,

0 

w ` n f

g

rg

mlv

n kc  

b u

s t

s u h

h g g

b s n

k r

g b u h

n k c

 

TH

J

g v g

f s n k  

b u s

t

ml

rg l a t g

k  

t `

e k  n t

>

 

r e n s

g s t

` l s g

 f g v g f

s ,  

e f t

` l u c

`

n

t n s k

lt

ik

lwk

 

`

lw

t

gmpl

rer

y `

g

n

mpr

lvgm

gkt

 

s

n

g

5 4

 

`lw

 

s

llk

TH

J- f e

b g k

b

u s t  

s

 

r g

- b

g p l s

n t g b

.

5 5

>7.

Jes gb 

lk 

g p g e t g b

t g s t n k c

n k

l t ` g r s h ` l l f s

suh`

e s  

t ` l s g  

n k

Kgw 

lri

5 : H n t

y ,

t  `e

s 

jgg

k s `

lwk

 

` e

t

e n r

 

ekb

 

b u s

t f g v

g f s

l

aTHJ

s r

g

`

n c ` f

y

v e

r n e j

f g

lv

gr

5 8

 

g

vgk

 s ` l

r t

p g

r n l b

s  

la

 n

mg

‒ek

y  e

r t n h

u f e r

 

t g

s t

l k f

y c n

v g s  

e

s k e

p s ` l

t  

t

` e t  

h l

u f b

5 2 h

`ekc

g 

u j s t

e k t n

e f f y

 

a

rlm

bey

  l

b e y

.

5 7

 

>1.

 

N k

G

k v n r

l k '

s

t g s t

n k c

lv

gr ` g s

umm

gr

l

a

45 2

,

e

k

e r g e

 

la l

n f

k g

e r t ` g

5 1 

w

llb

s `l

p

rll

m 

e f s l

 gxh

ggb

gb 

r g

c u f e

t l r y

 

s

t e k

b e r b

s  a

l r T

HJs

 k  s

l n f .

N t

wes

  g k h g

b

5 3  

l a a  ekb

 e

  l n f

 rgml

vef

 e h t

n l k

s u

j s g q

u g k

t f y

tll

i 

p f e

h g

u

kbg

r

` g

 

s

u p g r

v n s n

l k la

 ` g

5 0

  H

e f n a

l r k n

e

Bgp

ert

mgk

t la

 

Rl

xn h

 

X

u j s

t e k h

g s  

H l k t

r l f .

 

R`

g

l

u r h

g  la

 

THJ

s k

t ` e t

 

s l n

5

> we

s  

klt

 

b g t g

r m n k

g b 9

 

`

lwg

v gr

` g

 

kg

er j

y wl

lbs

`lp

 

r

llm

  eb t `

g

` n c `

g s t  

f g

v g f

la

:4

 

T

HJs

 

k  

h e

u f i

alu

kb

n

k

t ` g

 

nkbg

pgk

bgkt

 

g

s t s  b n

s h u s

s g b

ejlv

g.

:

5

>

3.

Lk uc

ust

 5

: ,  :4 5

2,

f e n k

t n a a

 

Emg

rn h

e 

W k n

t g s s u

j m n t

t g b

 

t

l t ` g

 B

n s t r

n h t

::

 e

 

M

gml

rek

bu

m

l k t e

n k n k

c  

Z ghl

mmg

kb e

t n l

ks 

l

r TH

J 

k v g s

t n c e

t n l k

 

e

t Mef

nju

:8

M

n bbf

g &

@nc

`

`n

h` h

l k t e

n k g

b e

f e k a l r

 

t`lr

luc

`  g s t n k

c  ek

b 

r

g m g b

n e t n

l k

:2

t ` r l u c ` l u t  

t ` g

Mefn ju

X h ` l l f s .  

R`ns

f e k

wes

k g v g r  

ehiklwfgbcgb 

l r

a l f f l w g b .

:

7

>

0.

E

fsl

lk E

ucus

t

5

: ,  

:4 5

2

t e

 

u j f n

h  c

e t ` g

r n k c

,

H

nkb

y H

rewa

lrb

 

ek

b ` g

r

:1

 

`

us j

ekb,

 

w

`l

 

w

grg

 

M@X

 

e r g k

t s ,

l a a

g r g b

 t l  pe

y 

l

r

a u f f

 

t g s

t n k c

 

l

a

f

f

la

`

g

h e u f

i  

e t

:3

 

t `

g Me

f n j

u

X h `

l l f s

.  

R

`g 

n

s t r n

h t b n b

 klt

  h h

g p t t

` g n r

 l a a g

r .

:0

:

5

A

NZXR

E

MGK

BGB

HLM

TFE

NKR A

LZBGH

FEZE

RLZ^

EKB 

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :: la 82 Tecg NB #?>8

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 23/34

5

>> .

 

S`

gk h ` l

l f  r

g-lp

gkgb

 

n k  

f e t

g

Euc

us t

 :4 5

2,

g

e h ` g

r s w

grg

` r g

e t g k

g b

:

 

w n

t ` a n r

n k c  n a

  `

g y

b n b

 klt g

-lh

hup

y rl

lms

 

k w`

n h`

 h

e u f i

 l r wn p

g se

mpf

gs 

`e

b

8 t g s t

g b e

jlvg

 

r g c u

f e t l

r y  

f n m n

t s .

2 

544.

 

E

n

r s t cre

bg s t u b

g k t

 

w`

lsg 

p e r

g k t s

 

b n b

 

k l t  

wek

t

g

r t l

e t

t g k b

 s

p g h n

e f t y

7

 

h f e

s s g s

 n k

e

r

llm

 

n k

 

J u

n f b

n k c A

 a

OH

GX

w`

nh`

 

eb 

g s t

g b

w n t `

 

g x

t r g m

g f y

  n c

` f g

v g f s

1 

l

a

T

HJs

 

k  

h

e u f i

 we

s ` r g

e t g k

g b

w n

t `

t r u e

k h y

.

3

5

4 5 .   Ef

t`l

uc `

 GT

E 

eb

 

k g n

t ` g r

 

epp

rlvg

b

kl

r b n s e

p p r l

v g b

t ` g

 

X g

hlk

b

0

 

Gkv n

rlk

 

T

fek t l

f g e

v g T

HJs

 k  v

n l f e

t n l k

 la 

RXH

E k

 

p f

e h g

a l r

 57

y g e r

s  

l r

ml

rg,

 

lk

> 

Eu

cus

t 

5 2

,  

:4

5 2,

 

e

n s t r n

h t

l a

a n h n e

f  

s

g k t

e

k 

gm

enf l e

k 

GTE

 

gcn

lk 

>

H

J a a n

h n e f

5 4

s t

e t n k

c  t ` e

t t ` g  

B n

s t r n

h t

w

lufb

 r

gmg

by `

g

R

XH

E

n

l f e t

n l k s

 n b g

k t n a

n g b e t

 

a l u r

5 5  

wn kblw 

e r g e s   j y  

Oukg 

8 4 , :4 5 7.  

R`g 

n s t r n h t l a a n h n e f  s t e t g b  

t ` e t

t ` n s

wes  

e

5 : 

v

l f u k

t e r

y  

h l

r r g h

t n v g

 

e

c r g g

m g k

t . R`

g

gm

en f

 

e f s

l  

s t e

t g b ?

 

E

b b n t

n l k e

f f y

 s ` l

u f b  w

g

5

8  

a

n k b

 

e

b b n t

n l k e

f  RX

HE

 

g c u f

e t g b

 m e t

g r n e

f s ,

wg k t

n h n p

e t g v l

f u k t

e r y

 rgm

lve

f 

la

`

l s g

5 2 m

e t g r

n e f s

 

e

kb

w n

f f h l l

r b n k

e t g

w n t

`

t

` g GTE

 

g c e r

b n k

c ek

y k g h

g s s e

r y  

e p p

r l v

e f s ekb

5

7 

t

n m n k

c .  

@

lwg

v gr

,  

` g

 

B n s

t r n h

t  

b n b  

k l t  

r g a g

r g k h

g

l

r  

e c r

g g

t l  

rgm

lvg

 

`

g  

h e u

f i t `

e t

5 1  `eb

 e f

r g e b

y jg

gk a

luk

b t l

 jg

  k

v n l

f e t n l

k laRX

HE 

k n k

b g p

g k b g

k t t g s

t s  

n k

e

b b n t

n l k e

f

5

3  

rll

ms9

 

kl

r 

b n b

 n t

p r l v

n b g

e

ky

p f

e k s

 

t l

  a

n k b

 e b

b n t n

l k e f

 

R

XH

E g

c u f e

t g b  

m e t g

r n e f

s .

5

0  

5 4

: .

E

fsl

lk

 

E

ucu

st

5 2 ,

 

:4

5 2, 

GT

E gc

n lk

 

> 

b

m n k n

s t r e

t l r O

e r g b

5 >

 

Jf u

mgk

t`ef

 

w

rlt

g e

  g t t

g r t l

Xe

kbr

e F

y lk

,   u p g

r n k

t g k b

g k t  

la ` g

B

n s t r

n h t .

R`g

 

g t t

g r

:

4 

e

hik

lwf g

bcg

Yb]

 

` g B n

s t r n

h t ' s

 

p

f e k

 t l  

rg

mlvg

 

` g

 

heuf

i ar

lm 

a l u

r  

w

n kb

lws

j y

:5

 

Ou

kg

8 4 ,

 

:45

7.

R`g

 

g t t g

r

e f

s l  s

t e t g

b t

` e t

GTE

 

l

khur

s

w n

t ` t ` n

s

e p p r

l e h

` ,  

e

kb

:: 

t `

e t

GT

E n b kl

t r

gh l

mmg

kb e

b b n t

n l k e

f t g s t

n k c

l

a  e

u f i u k

f g s

s b u

s t

l r e n r

se

mpf

gs

:8  

p g

r s n s

t g k t

f y a e n f

 

t

l  

mg

gt

G TE

' s  

g e f t

`

- j e

s g b

c

u n b g

f n k g

s .

R

`g

g

t t g r  b

n b  

klt

  b b r

g s s

:2 

t ` g

g x t r g m g f y ` n c `  

f g v g f s

la

THJs,

p 

l

t`lusekbs 

la

n m g s  

t ` g

f g c e f

f n m n t ,  

t ` e t  

`eb

:7  

jgg

k

n

b g k t

n a n g

b

n k

 n

kbgp

gkbg

kt

g s t n

k c ,

l r

t

` e t

mek

y  l t `

g r

r

llms

 w`g

rg h

e u f

i

`

eb

:

1

kl

t 

jg

gk 

g s

t g b

w

grg

 

n i g f

y

t

l gx

hggb

 

f g c

e f

f n

m n t s

 j

esgb

 

lk

 

` g

a e

h t

t

` e t

 rll

ms

k

t `

g

:3

 

s

emg

 j u n f

b n k c

,

f n i g

f y

j u

n f t

w n t

`

t

` g s

emg

 h e u f

i ,  

`e

b

g x

h g g b

e k h

g s .

:

0

::

A

NZXR

EM

GKBG

B

HL

MTFE

NKR

ALZ

B

GHFE

ZERL

Z^

EKB 

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :8 la 82 Tecg NB #?>2

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 24/34

5

 

5 4 8 .

 

N

k  

X

gptg

mjg

r :4 5

2,

b

b n t n

l k e f

 n k b

g p g k

b g k

t

t

g s t  

r g s u

f t s

ar

lm ek

 

G

TE

-

:

 h g r t

n a n g

b f e

j l r e

t l r y

 

wg

rg

s u j m

n t t

g b

t l G

TE

 

kb

t ` g

 B n

s t r n h

t .  ( X

ghl

kb

X g t  

la

8

 

N

kbg

pgkb

gkt

  g

s t s )

.

A

lur

 

e

b b n t

n l k e

f r

llm

s k

M@

X 

`g

rg

h e u

f i  

`eb 

k l

t  

jg

gk

2 

p r

g v n l

u s f

y  

t g s t

g b wg

rg al

ukb

  l  g

xhg

gb r

g c u f

e t l r

y

f n m n

t s ,

w n

t ` twl

la 

` g s g

 n k

 

t

` g

7

  `

ukb

rgbs

 l

a `l

us e

kbs

la p

pm H Js

.

1

 

-

- Zll

m 

4 5

 n k t `

g Fgl

perb

 

J u n

f b n k

c  

`eb

 

5

21,4

44 p

pm TH

Js .

3

- -

 Zll

m

4 7

 

k t ` g

Ekc

gf

J

u n f b

n k c

 

`e

b :

8 5,

44 4

 

pp

m T

H Js

.

0

 

-

-

Z

ll

m

4 7

 

k

t `

g M

ei

l

u

n f b n

k c `eb

 :4 4

 pp

mTH

Js

>

- -

 Zll

m 

3 k  

J u

n f b

n k c

G

J

fug

 

J u n f

b n k

c ) `e

b 5

> 4  p

pm

 

TH J

s .

5 4

5

42.

 

R`

g X

ghlk

b

X g t

 

la

kb

gpg

kbgk

t R

g s t

s e

f s l n

k h f u

b g b  

e n

g h g

 la

 

e u

f i

5 5 w`nh`

wes  

g t r n g v g b

arlm

e 

wefiwey

lk 

` g

M@X 

empus  

a t g r

n t

a g f f

lut

la e

r e s `

5 : 

jec

 j

g n k

c ` e u

f g b

 

j y

e wlri

gr

tlw

er b

s `

g @

n c `

 X h`l

lf

e r i

n k c

 

f

l t t l

 e

e r

f e

j g f g

b

5 8

 

e n r

b u h

t

h f

g e k

n k c .

 

R`

ns wes

  p p e

r g k t

f y p

e r t

la e

 

u r r

g p t n t

n l u s

 

h

e u f i

 

rgm

lve

f

a a

l r t

5

2 

w`n

h`

wes

 

klt

 

g

p l r t

g b t l

 t

` g

h lm

muk

n t y

l r

 

t

l  

GT

E 

l  

g k s u

r g hlm

pfn

ekhg

 

w

n t `

5 7

 

p r l

t g h t

n v g p

r e h t

n h g s

 ekb

 

b

n s p l

s e f

r g

c u f e

t n l k

s .

R`n s

 

h

e u f

i

e

f s l t g

s t g b

ej

lvg

  ` g

f g

c e f

5

1 

f n m n

t e t  7 0

p

pm.

5

3  

5

47.

  E t  

` n

s

p l

n k t ,

 

g

vgr

y 

j u n

f b n k

c

lk

 

`

g  

M

@X

 

e

mpu

s

s

n x

j

u n f b

n k c s

) w`g

rg

5 0

h e

u f i

 

`e

b

jg

gk

g s t

g b ek

b t `

g l k

f y

j

u n f b

n k c lk t `

g

OH

GX

h

emp

us  w`g

rg

h e u f

i `eb

5 >  

jg

gk

g

s t g b

 

`

eb g

xhgg

bek

hgs

la 

` g r

g c u f

e t l r

y f n

m n t ,

 n k b

n h e t

n k c

t

` g

f

n i g f

n ` l l

b

t ` e

t

:4

 

me

ky

mlr

g 

e s

 

y g

t u

k t g s

t g b  

rl

lms

 

k  

e f f

 la ` g

 

p r

g

-5 > 0

4

s h `

l l f

 

j u n

f b n k

c s  `e

b

:5

r

g c u f

e t l r

y

g

x h g g

b e k

h g s .

:: 

5

41.

  Lk 

gpt

gmjg

r :1, 

4 5 2

,

kv n

rlk

s

u j m

n t t g

b  

j y g

m e n f

 e

g t t g

r

t l

 

GT

E

:8  

Z

gcn

lk>

HJ

 a a n

h n e f

X t

g v g

 

E r m

ekk

 lk 

j g `

e f a

 

la

 ` g

 B n

s t r n

h t

r

g c e r

b n k c

:2 

Xuppfgmgktef

Z gmlv ef

k a l r m e t n l k  

a l r  

t ` g F n j r e r y ,

J u n f b n k c

G 

Zllms

,  

7

ekb

:7

 

0, e

kb

J u

n f b n

k c  

C,

Z

llm

  4 1

  t

 Mefn

ju

@n c

`

X

h`ll

f

`

g r g n

k e a t

g r G

kv n

rlk

:

1 

Xup

pfgm

gkt

 ).

R`g

  g t t g r

 s t e

t g b  t `

e t

t w

es

k t g k

b g b  

t l

su

ppf

gmgk

t

ek

b

mlb

nay

` g

:3 X gh

lkb

 

G

kv n r

lk

T f e

k . R`

g

bl

hum

gkt

 

f e r

n a n g b

 t

` e t t ` g

a l

u r

wn k

blw

 

e

r g e s

 

r g

a g r g

k h g b

:

0

n k

 

t ` g

B n s t

r n h t

' s Euc

ust

5 2

, :

4 5 2 

m e n

f

e

s `e

vnk

c

R

XH

E n

l f e t

n l k s

 

wgr

g

a l

u r

:

8

A N

Z X R

EMGK

BGB

 

HL

MTFE

NKR A

LZ

BGH

FEZE

RLZ^

EKB 

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :2 la 82 Tecg NB #?>7

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 25/34

5

 

w n k b l

w s k  

t ` g F n j r e r

y , ekb

 

Zllm

s 

,

7 ekb

0 .  

N t e f s

l

s t e t g b

 

t ` g

B n

s t r n h t

' s  

n k t g k

t n l k

: t l

 nm pf

g m g kt

 e s n

m n f e r r

g m g b

y  

a

l r t ` g n

k t g r n l r

 bllr a

remg

n k

t ` g

w l

lb s `l

p  

rl

lm ,

8

Zllm

 

4

1. 

Zll

m 

41  

w e s

 

` g

r l

lm  

n b g k t

n a n g b n

k n k b g p

g k b g k t

 

t g s t n

k c

e s

 

`

evnkc

2

 

834,

444

ppm

 THJ

s k t ` g

h e u

f i n k t ` g n

k t g r n l

r bll

r a

remg,

`l

uc`

G k v n r

l k ' s

f g

t t g r

7

b n

b klt

 

eh ikl

wfgbc

g

` n s

. N

k s t g e b

, t ` g f g

t t g r

k l t g b

t ` e t  wn

pg se

mpfgs

 arlm

 

t ` g

bll

r

1 

arem

g 

gxhgg

bgb t `

g r g c u f e

t l r y s t

e k b e r b

 la

 54 u

c 

p g r `ukbr

gb h

m

:

 g v

gk e a t g r

r g p e n r

s

3

e

kb

e b

b n t n l k

e f h f g e k

n k c .

0 

5 4 3 .

 

R ` g Gk v

nrlk

Xup p

f g m gk

t t e t g b t

` g B n s

t r n h t ' s

 

t

` g k h u r r g k

t

n k t g k t

n l k

t l

>

p `

y s n h e f

f y  r g

m lv g ekb 

r

g p f e h

g

h e u

f i  lkfy

 

arlm

 

t `

g

a l

u r

w n

k blw

u k n

t s ekb lk

g

54

b l l r a

r e m g .

 

N t b n b  klt

 g x t g

k b  gvgk

 t l

h e u

f i n k l t

` g r w n k b

lw s ekb

b

l l r s  

n

k

t ` g

s e

m g

5 5  

rllms. 

@lw g v g r,  

` g  

f g t t g r

e f s l  

hlm m nttgb

t l t ` g

s e m g

p r l h g b u r g s

a l r l t ` g r

5: 

j u n f b n

k c s n k t

` g B

n s t r n h

t

w`gr

g 7

4

pp

m r

 

c

r g e t g r

 

T

HJs r g

  n b g

k t n a n g

b ekb

v g r n a

n g b

58 

n k

j u n

f b n k c  

m e t g r n

e f s ,

w n t ` n k

 

lkg

 

y g e r

 la b g

k t n a n h e

t n l k  ek

b v g r n a

n h e t n l

k .

@

lwgv

g r ,

5

2 

t ` g

 

Xu p

pfgm g

kt

n b

 

klt eh

iklwf

gbcg

l r e b

b r g s s  t ` g

 a n k

b n k c s  

n k

t `

g  

n k

b g p g k

b g k t   g s t

s

57 

l

a

e u f i

gxh

ggbnkc

 

f g

c e f  

f n

m n t s .

51  

540.

N k Lhtl

jgr :45

2, Em

g rn h e

 W k

n t g s e

sigb t `

g

f

e j l r e t

l r y  

t l r g

- r u k

 t ` g

5

3

h e u f i

 

arlm

 t ` g

t w l

 r

llm s

w n

t `  

t `

g   n c ` g

s t

THJ

 

l k h g k

t r e t n l

k s ( O H

GX

Zll

m

5>

e

kb

50 

t `

g @

n c`

Xh

`llf

w llb

s ` lp

 

r l

l m )

l r

 

e

f f la ` g T

HJ

l k c

g k g r s ,

 

ek

b

t ` g

k

5>

 

s p g h n

a n h e f f

y

a l r

hlk

cgkgr

5:1

, ` g m

lst l x n h

 

l

a f f la ` g

 THJ

 l k

c g k g r

s . R ` g

:4 

semp

fgs

`

eb

p r g

v n l u s f

y  jg

gk e k e

f y z g b

 l k f

y a l r  t l t e f

 

T

H J s .

 R`g

sg 

k

g w

g s t s

al

ukb

:5

t ` g

p r g s g

k h g la lk

cg kgr

 

5

:1 t

 

5:: 

ppm

 k

Ouek H e

j r n f f l

 Zll

m 5

>

e

kb 7

3

pp

m 

k

:: 

t

` g

w ll

b s `lp

 

‒ 

u

p

l  

m lr g

 

t ` e k

 t ` r g g

 m n f f n l

k t n m

g s m

lrg l x n

h

t ` e k t ` g

 GTE

 

g e f t ` -

: 8

jesg

b Zgc

nlkef

 

X h r g g

k n k c Fgvg

f

w`

nh`

p r l

v n b g s  a

l r

THJ

 

:1

h

l k h g k t

r e t n l

k s n k

 

t ` g

:2 

f lw

p e r t s

p g r

t r n f f n l k

t l  p r l v n b g

e k

e h h g p t e j f g

f g v g f  

la 

e k h g r  

r n s i .

: 7 

5 4 > .  

N

k Bg h g

m j g r

 

:45

2,

b b n

t n l k e f

 

t g s

t r g s u f

t s wgr

g r g h g n

v g b

j y Em g rn

he

:

1 

W k n

t g s

ekb

s u j m

n t t g b

t

l  

G

TE

k b

t ` g  

B n s t r n

h t

s`l

wnkc

r g c u

f e t l r y

 g

xhggb

ekhgs

 

k

:3

a l

u r

m lr

g rll

m s k

O

HG 

ekb

t w l

m lrg r

llm s

 

k

t ` g

 M@X.

 R `

n r b X g t

 l

a

:

0

:

2

AYZX

R EMGK

BGBH

LMTFEN

KR

A

LZ B

GHFEZ

ERLZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :7 la 82 Tecg NB #?>1

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 26/34

5

Nk

bgpg

kbgk

t  g s

t s ) .

R`g

sg 

g s u

f t s

w

grg

e f s l

r g s u j

m n t t

g b

t l t `

g  

B

gagkb

ekts

 

w n

t `  t

} 5 g

: K l t n

h g

l a

 

k t g k

t t l  X

ug 

l k

O e k

u e r y

 5:, :4

57.

8

M@

X 

Zll

m

42 

` eb

2

,3 44

 pp

mTHJ

s

k  

h e u

f i

ek

 

e

b

llr

are

mg

n k

e

2

` e

f f w e

y

7

OH

GX 

Z

llm

 :: `eb

 32

,444

 ppm

 THJ

s

k  n k

t g r n l

r w

nkbl

w h e

u f i

1

OH

GX 

Zll

m 

0

 

`e

b 554

,444

 

pp

mTH

Js k

n

k t g r n l

r w

nk b

l w h

e u f i

3

E

 HGX a a

n h g `eb

 

3

5 4

pp

m

T

HJs

 k n

k t g r n

l r w

nk b

l w

h e u

f i

0

OH

GX 

Z

llm

 

:8

  eb

 5

3,44

4

ppm

 

THJ

s

k n k t

g r n l r

 w

nkbl

w h e

u f i

>

5 5 4 .

 

K g n

t ` g r

 

G

TE,

lr 

` g  

B n s t

r n h t ,

 

k

lr t s

h l k t r

e h t l r

 

Gk

vnrl

k g

v g r

54

 

rg s

pl kb

gb 

t l t ` g

 s u j

m n s s

n l k

l a ` g

 t ` r g

g s g t s

 

l

a

k b g p

g k b g k

t

t

g s t  

r g s

u f t s l r  

h r g e t

g b

e

5 5   p f e k t l r g m g b n e t g  t ` g s g

t ` n r t g g k

e b b n t n l k e f

rllms, 

n x  

l a

`nh`   eb

g x t r g m g f y   n c `

5 :

  f g

v g f s

 

l

a

THJ

s

k

h e u f

i - - a l u

r n k t ` g

`ukb

rgbs

 l a

`lu

sekb

s

l

a

pp

m,

k

b t w l

  k t `

g

58

 

t g

k s l

a

`l

usek

bs

pp

m.

52

 

555

. 

Et

  ` g

 

p r g s

g k t

t n m g ,

 

t ` g

r g

e

r g

i

k l w

k  

l

 

jg

 

5

3 

rl l

ms k

s

n x b n a a

g r g k t

57

j u n f b

n k c s

 n k

 

M

@X 

k

b t

w l n a

a g r g k

t j u n f

b n k c s

 n k  

OH

GX

w n t

`  

TH

Js

k

h e u f i

 

ej

lvg 7

4

51

 

p

pm.

5 3

 

55:. 

Lk

 htl

jgr 1

,:4

52, f

e n k t n

a a s  TGG

Z

kb Me

fnju

 

W k n t

g s

w r l t

g

t l

5 0

X u p g r

n k t g

k b g k t

 

F

y l k

e s

i n k c

 

a l

r h f e

r n a n h

e t n l k

 

l a

 

`

g

Xgp

tgmj

gr

:1

,

:452

 

G

kvnr

lk

5>

Xup

pf gm

gkt.

 X p

g h n a n

h e f f y

, T f e n

k t n a a

s esi

gb

w ` e

t 

k

a l r m

e t n l k

 t ` g

B n s

t r n h t

 

kggb

s 

l

:

4

d n b g

k t n a y

 

e

kb

v

g r n a

y '  

t ` g

p r g s

g k h g

 

l

a

THJ

s j

lvg 

RX

HE

n

m n t s ,

 

e

kb

w

`gt`

gr ` g

:5

 

B n s

t r n h t

 

w luf

b e h h

g p t ek

b

e h t  u

pl k 

` g n

k b g p

g k b g k

t t g s t

r g s

u f t s t ` e t

 s

` l w g

b

e t

f g e s t

::

 t

wgfv

g

e

b b n t n

l k e f

 

r

l lm

s 

w n t

` h e u

f i  

e

jlvg

 

RXH

E

n m n t s

.

R

` g

g t t g r

 e f s l

 r g q u

g s t g b

:8

t ` e

t n a

t ` l

s g

nk

bgpg

kbgkt

 

g

s t

r g s u

f t s w grg

 h l k

s n b g

r g b

b g a n

h n g k t

,  

t ` g

B n s t r

n h t

s

p g h n a

y

:2 

w n t `  

p e r t n h u f e r n t y

n k  

w ` et mek kgr 

` g y  

w grg 

b g a n h n g k t .

A n k e f f y ,

t ` g

f g t t g r

esigb 

n a

` g

:7

 

B n s

t r n h t

 w

luf b

 

ehh

gpt

ek

b g

x g h u t

g

t ` g

 Y

Eucu

st 5 : ,

 :

452

]

g s t

n k c  

p f e k

 

p

r l v n b

g b

t

l

:1

t

` g m

j

y Me

fnju

 W k

n t g s

 

e

kb H

nkby

 

Hre

walr

b  l

t g s t

 

e f f

t ` r g

g

s h `

l l f s <

 R`ns

 

p

f e k  t e i

g s

:3

l k

g

w gg

i gkb

 t l  

g x g

h u t g

 

ek

b

54

b

eys l

 

prl

buhg

 

p r g f n

m n k e

r y

r

g s u f t

s .  

N a

k l t ,

 

p f g e s

g

:0

s p g

h n a y

w n t

`  

p e r

t n h u f

e r n t y

 

e s

 

t l

 w

`y 

` g b n s

t r n h t

w n f f

 klt 

b g k t n

a y

ekb

v

g r n a y

 

e f f

TH

J

:7

ANZX

R

EMG

KBGB

 

HLM

TFENK

R

ALZ

 

B

GHFE

ZERLZ

^

EKB 

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :1 la 82 Tecg NB #?>3

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 27/34

5

s l u r h

g s

n k

 

t `

g t ` r g

g

s h ` l l

f s .

R

l e t g ,

T f e n k

t n a a s

`ev

g

r g h g n v

g b kl

r g s p l

k s g t l  t ` n

s

:

 

f g t t g r .

8

5 5 8

.

Lk

htlj

gr 85, :452

,G

TE

pprl

vgb

ukbg

r

24 .A

.Z. 1 5 . 1

5

l k f y t ` g

2 p l r t

n l k  

la ` g

 

X g h

lkb

Gk vnrl

k

Tfek ekb

G

kvnrl

k Xupp

fgm gk

t

g c e r b

n k c  

t ` g

THJs

7

 

r g m

e n k n k c

 n k

t `

g s u j s

t r e t g

( i k

lw k

e s

 THJ gm

gbnet

nlk Sest

g)

a t g

r rgmlv

ef

la

1

THJ- h l

k t e n k

n k c

h e u f i n k t ` g

 a l u

r

r

llm s

 s f e t g b

 

a l r

 

h e u f i rgmlv

ef

j y Ou

kg :457

.

3 

GT

E pp

rlv gb

 G k v n r l

k ' s

p f e k t l

s g e f

ekb

 g k h e p

s u f e t

g p

lrlus

 

s u j

s t r e t g

s

u k

b g r k g e

t `

0 

t `

g rg

mlvg b

 

h e u

f i

ekb

w n t ` n k

 

lkg

 

a l l t

la

t

ekb

 t l b

g h l k t

e m n k e t

g

k lk- p l

r l u s

> 

s u

j s t r e t

g s

w

n t `

e s l f v

g k t ,

u k t

n f r g k

l v e t n

l k l r  b

g m l f n t

n l k  l h h u r

s .

R ` g  

B n

s t r n h t n s

54

  r

g q u n r

g b

t l h l

k t n k u

g

j g s t

 m e

k e cg

m g k t

r e h t

n h g s

h

f g e k n k

c  ek

b p g r n

l b n h

e n

r ekb

 

wnpg

5 5

sempfgs

a l r  

e t  

f g e s t

e

y g e r  

ekb 

t l t e i g  

a u r t ` g r

e h t n l k n a

gxhggbekhgs

la 

GT E's  

g e f t `

5: c u n

b g f n k

g s

l h h u r

.

A u

f f

r g m g

b n e t n

l k

ekb

 b

n s p l s e

f l

a 

` g

TH

J

gmgb

netnlk

 

Se

s t g

n k

58

e h

h l r b e

k h g

w n t `

t

` g

TH

J g c u f

e t n l k

s

wl

u fb

l h h u

r

e t

 

t

` g

t n m g  

la g k l v e t

n l k

l

r

52

b g m l

f n t n l k

.

57

5 5 2

.

R

` g r g a l

r g , gvg

k w

n t ` r g s

p g h t t l

m e t g

r n e f s n

k p r l x

n m n t y  

t

l

h e u f

i

t g s t n k c

5

1

n

k

g

x h g s s

l

a g c

u f e t l r

y f n m n

t s ,

t ` g

 B n s

t r n h t

w n f f

 klt

 

jg

n b g k

t n a y n k

c

ekb

 

rg

mlvnk

c

5

3

m e t g r

n e f s

n k v n

l f e t n l

k l

a 

RX

HE 

r n l r  t l

 r g k l v

e t n l k

l r b g m l

f n t n l k

 e t  

e

k u

k i k lw

k

5

0

tnmg

n k

 

t ` g

 

a u t u r

g .

5>

557.

 

L

v g r  w n

k t g r  j r

g e i  

n k Bg

h g m j g

r

:45

2 

e

kb 

O e k u

e r y  

:

457,

Gk

vnrlk

:4 

hlkb

uhtgb

 e b b n t n

l k e f

e n r

ekb

b u s

t

s

empfn

kc 

e t

t `

g  Mef

nju

X h ` l

l f s .

E

cenk,

 k l h e u

f i

:5

l r

 

l t

` g r

j u n f b

n k c

m e t g

r n e f s wgr

g

t g s t

g b .

::

5 5

1 . E

s n t `

 

n t

s

t g s t n

k c  

t ` g

p r g

v n l u s

 

s u

m m g r

, Gk vnr

lk b n b

klt   g s t

a l r  

t

` g

: 8

n k b n v

n b u e f h

lkcgk

grs

la H

Js ,  k b

usgb

e

b g

t g h t n l

k  f

g v g f  

la

p

p r l x n m

e t g f y

 

3 4

 k c p g r

:2 

h u j n h  

mgtgr 

a l r

e n r

t g s t s ,

t ` u s  

prlbuhnkc 

k u m g rlu s 

k lk

- b g t g h t  

r g s u f t s  

w`nh` 

b l

k l t

: 7

n k

a e h t n

k b n h e t

g t ` e

t  

t ` g r

g  w

grg k l

 THJs

 

k

t ` g

e n r .

:1

  5

5 3 .

O u

s t j g a l r g

 t ` g

w n k t g

r j r g e

i ,

ar

lm

Bg h g

m j g r  

5 1 -

5 > ,

:452

,

` g

:3

 

XM

MWXB

 g k t n k

e 

s p g h n e

f h r

g w

l

 h f g e k

 

e

kb

wnpg

 

blw

k

u r a e

h g s  

n k

t `

g  Mef

nju

:

0

X

h ` l l f s

.  R`ns

 s p g h n e

f

h

f g e k n k

c h

lkhfu

bgb u s t

:

2

` l

u r s

p r n l r

t

l  t ` g

j g c n k k

n k c

la

: 1

AN ZX

R

EMGKB

GB

HL

MTFEN

KR ALZ BG

HFEZER

LZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :3 la 82 Tecg NB #?>0

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 28/34

5

G k

v n r

l k ' s

 

t

g s t n

k c  l

a n r

ek

b

b u s t

 

a l

r TH J

s ,

w`n

h`

tll

i p f e

h g jg

twg

gk

Bg

h gm

jgr

 

:4

:

ekb

 

:

>,

4 5

2.

8

550

.

R`n s

 s p g h

n e f h f

g e k n

k c  we

s  

k t g

k b g

b

t l

 

r

g b u h

g t ` g

e

mlu

kt

la

 

T

HJs

 

k  e

n r

2

 

e

kb

b u

s t n k

t ` g

sem

pfg

s ej l

ut  

l

j

g

h l

f f g h t

g b ,

su

h`

t ` e

t t ` l

s g

sem

pfg

s

w

luf

b

kl

t

7 

e h h u

r e t g

f y  

r g a f

g h t

t ` g

 

g

x p l s

u r g

s t `

e t s t u

b g k

t s ekb

 

t

g e h `

g r s

e h t

u e f f

y g

x p g

r n g k

h g b n k

1

 

t

` g  

t

nmg

 p g r

n l b

s n k

h g t

` g f e s

t

t g s

t n k c

ekb

 

h

f g e k

n k c

t ` g

 p r

g v n l

u s

s

umm

gr  

la

 

45

2, 

ek

b

3 t

l  mei

g

t  

epp

ger

` e

t  

G TE

' s

g e

f t `

c u n

b g f n

k g s  a l

r e n r

ekb

b

u s t

 

s

emp

fgs   e

b 

jggk

0

 mg

t, gv

gk 

a

h

l k b

n t n l

k s

p r n

l r t l t

` g

s p

g h n e

f  

h f

g e k

n k c

b n b

 

klt

 

mg

gt

` l

s g

c u n b

g f n k

g s .

> 

5 5 >

.

B g s

p n t

g t ` n

s  p r g

- h

f g e k

n k c

 

g

a a l r

t ,  

t wl

 r l

lms

 

`eb

 b u s

t se

mpfg

s

ejl

vg

5 4

G TE

' s

` r g s

` l f b

 ‒t

`g

l f b

c

y mk

es n

um n k

 

M@

X

k

b

Zl

lm 5

>

k O

H G X

,  

l

t `  

l

a w`n

h`

 

nkbgpgkbgkt

g s t r g s u f t s

`eb

s `lwk

l  

`evg

THJs 

jlvg 

g c e f f n m n t s

n k  

t ` g h e u f i .

5

<

 

5 : 4

. R`

g

n s

t r n h

t  

t

` g k

 

p

gra

lrmg

b

e

b b n t

n l k e

f

h

f g e k

n k c

n

k  t ` g

s g twl

 rllm

s.

N

k

5

8

t `

g h e

s g la

 

OHG

X 

Z

llm

 

>

,

a l

u r

s

emp

fgs 

rg

menk

gb e

jlv

g G

TE

 

u n

b g f n

k g s ,

 ek

b e

5 2

s

ghlk

b

r g

- h f

g e k n

k c

we

s

b

lkg

, 

n k

e f f y

 

l j t e

n k n k

c  

r g

s u f t s

 

j

gflw

 

t

` g c

u n b g

f n k g

s .

R`

g n r

57

n k  

t ` n

s

r

llm

 wes

 

kl

t 

g s t

g b

u k t n

f e a

t g r  

t

` g  

sg

hlkb

 r

g

- h

f g e k

n k c .

5 1

5:5

. Lk

 e k

u e r

y

5:

,

:

4 5 7

,

f e n

k t n a

a s

s g

r v g b

 

t ` g

 

K l t

n h g  

la

k t g k

t t l X

ug 

k

5 3 t

` n s

h e s g

.

Zgt

urk

r

g h g n

p t s  

arl

m 

h g r t

n a n g

b

m e

n f

g v

n b g

k h g

t ` e t  

Bg

agkb

ekt

s 

e

kb 

G

TE

5

0

r g h

g n v g

b t

` n s K

l t n h

g e t t `

g  f e

t g s t

j y O e k

u e r y

 :4, :4

5 7.

5 >

 

5::

. Lk

 

gjru

er y

 

:3 ,

 4 5

7,

` g

 B

n s t r

n h t

s g

k t ek

 

gm

enf mg

ssec

g l

t ` g

 p e r

g k t s

:

4 ek

b

s t e

a a

la ` g

 Mef

n ju

 X

h ` l

l f s .

 

R`

g

m

gss

ecg

t

e t g b

,  

eml

kc

t

` g r

t ` n

k c s ,

 

` e t t ` g

:5

B n s t

r n h t

 

`

eb

jggk

 meb

g

ew

erg

 

l

a

` n

r b  

p

e r t y

 

semp

fnk

c r

g v g e

f n k c

 

t

` g  g

x n s

t g k h

g

la

::

h e

u f i

 ejl

vg `

g

74 pp

m

R

XHE

 

` r

g s ` l

f b .

N k

a e h t

,

t ` g

 

B n s t

r n h t

 

`

eb jgg

k

ewer

g

l

a

:8

 

n

kbg

pgkb

gkt

 

g

s t n k

c

s

`lw

nkc

 

g x

t r g m

g f y

` n

c `

n f

f g c e

f

f g v g

f s la

 THJ

s 

l r  

l v g r

 

sg

vgk

:2

mlkt `s, 

n k h g  O u f y

:452.

:7

5 : 8 .

  R`g

 

n s t

r n h t '

s

Ag

jrue

ry

:

3,

:

4 5 7  

g

m e n

f t ` g k

 

h

f e n m

g b

t ` e t

 

n

t

`eb

 

k l t

:1

j

ggk

e j f

g t l

h l

k a n r

m

t ` g

g x e h

t  

f

l h e t

n l k s

 w`

grg

 

` g

s g

se

mpfg

s wg

rg  e i

g k .

@

lwg

vgr

,

:3

 

n

k

a e h t

 

t ` g

 

T

f e n k

t n a a

s

`eb

 

s u p

p f n g

b

t ` g

 

B n s t

r n h t

 

w

n t `

 

n

k a l r

m e t

n l k  

n b g k

t n a y

n k c

t ` g

rllm

s

:0

ekb

 

f l

h e t n

l k s

w`

grg

 

t `

g  

se

mpfg

s

wgr

g t e

i g k ,

 

ek

b

t

` g

B

n s t r

n h t `eb

 r g

p l r t

g b

n k

:3

ANZXR

 EM

GKB

GB

HLMT

FENK

R ALZ

 BGHF

EZER

LZ^

EKB

KOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :0 la 82 Tecg NB #?>>

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 29/34

5

Xg

ptg

mjg

r 

:4

52

` e t

n t `eb

 

se

mpf

gb e

n r

ek

b b

u s t

 

n

k sl

m g  

la

 ` g  

s em

g

rll

m s

` e t

 

w

gr

g

n

k b g

p g k

b g k t

f y

t

g s t g

b ,  

s p g h

n a n

h e f f

y

n b

g k t

n a y n

k c

t `

l s g

 rll

ms 

g

v g e f

n k c

 

t ` e

t n

t

n k

 

a e h

t

`eb

 k

l

p

rlj

fgm

 n b

g k t n

a y n

k c

t ` g

 

r

ll

ms w`

gr

g

t ` g

 n k

b g p

g k b

g k t

 

s

emp

fgs

 wgr

g

2

 

t

e i g

k .

7

 

5

: 2 .

  R`

g  

n s t

r n h t

' s

Agj

rue

ry

:

3

:4

57

g m

e n f

 s

t e t g

b  t ` e t

 t ` g

 

B n s

t r n

h t

w

luf

b

1

 

prl

h gg

b w

n t `

 

v g r

n a n

h e t n

l k

se

mpf

nkc

 l

a

l h

e t n l

k s

arl

m w

`nh

`

h

e u f

i e

p p g

e r s

 

t l

 

`

evg

3 

jgg

k

r

g ml

v gb

 ek

b sem

pfg

b,

ek

b e

p p f

y n

t s

r

gm

lve

f 

p f e k

 

t l  

eky

 

TH

Js

 

lu

kb 

n k

0

 

g

x h g

s s  

la

 

`

g

R

XH

E

` r g s

` l f

b .  

@l

wgv

gr

  ` g  

B n

s t r n

h t s u p

p f n g

b  k

l 

n

k a l r

m e t

n l k

 e

s  

t

l

>

w

`n

h`

rll

ms

t wlu

fb

t g s

t

l r

 w`

g k  

t wlu

fb

 

bl

 

s l

, ek

b

b n

b  

k

l t  s t e

t g ek

y

k

t g k t

n l k

 

t

l

54

  t

g s t

 

e b b

n t n

l k e f

 

h

e u f

i  

l r l t

` g r j u

n f b

n k c

 m

e t g r

n e f

s

n k

 

p

r g-5>

04

 

j u

n f b

n k c s

 e t

 t `

g  

Mef

nju

5 5

Xh`llfs

t l  

b g t g r m n k g  

t ` g  k e t u r g  

ekb

g x t g k t

la THJ

l k t e m n k e t n l k .

5

:

5

: 7 .  

Lk

er h

`

5>,

 

:

45

7

t

e

 Jle

rb

la

  b

u h e

t n l

k m g

g t n

k c , e

 p r

n k h

n p e f

 

la

58

 

Gk

vn

rlk

 

h

lka

nrm

gb

 t

` e t

n t

`e

b

r g t

g s t

g b  

k n k

g f l h

e t n l

k s w`

grg

 t

` g r

g `e

b 

j

ggk

52

nkbg

pgk

bgk

t g

s t n k

c

e

kb  

eb

l j t

e n k g

b s n

m n f e

r

r g

s u f t

s . @

g 

t e t

g b  

t ` e t

 

t

` g  

B n s

t r n

h t

5

7

wl

ufb

 

jg

 

r g m

g b n

e t n

k c t ` g s

g  

e r g

e s .

  @l

wgv

gr

`g b

n b  

klt

  t e t g

 

w

`gr

g t

` g s

g

e r g

e s

wgr

g

51

 

l

r w `

g k

 l r

 

w`

g k

lr

  l

w 

` g

y wl

ufb

 j

g

r g m

g b n

e t g

b ,

l r

w`

et

  g

v g f

s

la

 

T

HJs

 g

rg

53

 

al

ukb

 n k

t `

e t t

g s t

n k c .

50

 

5

: 1 .

 

L

k

er h

`

:

4

:45

7

lk

g j u

s n k

g s s

 

be

y

j g

a l r

g t ` g

 r

u k k

n k c

 

l

a 1

eys

5>

ar

lm

t ` g

 K l

t n h

g

l

a

k t g

k t  

t

l  

Xu

g 

f e n k

t n a

a  

TG

GZ

 

g h g

n v g

b jy

 

g r t

n a n g

b  

m e

n f  

t

` g

: 

B n

s t r

n h t '

s n r s

t

r

g s p

l k s

g

t l

 t ` g

 K l

t n h

g . N

k e 

g t t g

r arl

m

t `

g

B n s

t r n

h t ' s

 h l u

k s g

f ,  t

` g

:

5

B n s t

r n h

t

hf

enm

gb t ` e

t n

t w es

 u k

e j f

g

t l

 

n k

v g s t

n c e

t g ,  

v g r

n a y

ek

b 

e s s

g s s  

t ` g

 

v

n l f

e t n l

k s

:: e

f f g

c g b  

n

k t ` g

 K

l t n

h g

jgh

eus

g t

 

`

eb 

jg

gk u k

e j f

g t l

v g

r n a y

 

t ` g

 g

x e h

t

f

l h e t

n l k

s  

w`

gr

g

:8

h e u

f i

`e

b

jgg

k 

r g

mlv

gb

 

n

k

n

k b g

p g k

b g k

t

t g s

t n k

c .

R

` g  

g t t g

r n k b

n h e

t g b

 t

` e t t

` g B

n s t

r n h t

:2

we s  

w g f f

ewerg 

la 

w`nh` 

rllm s  

wgrg

e f f g c g b  

t l  

jg

k  

v n l f e t n l k

la

RXHE 

e s g b

lk

:

7

n

kbg

pgk

bgk

t

g s t

n k c ,

 ju t

  l r

s l

m g

 

u k

g x p

f e n k

g b

r g e

s l k

,

j g f n

g v g

b

t ` e

t t ` g y

 h

l u f

b l k

f y

:1

n

k v g s

t n c

e t g t

` g

e f f

g c e t

n l k

s ek

b e

b b r

g s s

 

h

l k t

n k u

n k c

v n l

f e t

n l k s

 l

a 

R

XH

E

a

t ` g

y  

t

lli

:

3 

s

emp

fgs

 arl

m

t `

g

g x

e h t s e m

g  

p l t

.

:0

:

0

AN

ZX R

 EMG

KBG

BHL

MTF

ENK

R

A

LZ

BGH

FEZ

ERL

Z^

EKB 

NKOWKHRKG 

GFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg :> la 82 Tecg NB #?544

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 30/34

5

5

:3 . 

N k

t ` g

 

Merh

` :

4,:

457

g

t t g r

t ` g

 

B n s t r

n h t

b n b

 

ebmn

t ` e t

n

k

f

l h e t

n l k s

:

 

w `

grg

h e u f

i w e s m n s

s n k c

 ek

b

t

tl

li s

empf

gs, t

l j t e n

k g b

r g s u

f t s ejlv

g

7

4 

pp

m 

k

8 

t ` g  h

f e s s r

l l m s

 

f n

s t g b n

k  t

` g K

l t n h g

.

R

` g

n s t r

n h t

s t e t g

b

t

` e t n t

 w

lufb

  e j e

t g

h e

u f i

2 

ejlv

g

7

4 pp

m,

ut

  n b k

lt g

v g e f  

w`gr

g

` n s h e u

f i

w es,

 

r  

w

` g k  

l r `

lw t

w lu

fb b l

7

 

s l

,

l r

 w

` e t

g v g f

s  

l

a

T

HJs

 

g

rg 

a

lukb

 

n

k

t

` g

B n s

t r n h t

' s

s

e m p f n

k c .

R `

g

n s t r n

h t

b n b

1 

klt

  b b r

g s s T f e n

k t n a a s

  h f e

n m s t

` e t

RXH

E

n l f e t

n l k s e r

g w n

b g s p

r g e b  

n k

t ` g  Me

fnju

3

Xh

`llfs

 

k

 rl lm

s  

w`gr

g

j u n

f b n k

c

m e t g r

n e f s

  ev

g klt

y g t

jg

gk g

s t g b ,

 n a t

` g y w grg

0

j

u n f t e

rluk

b 

t `

g s e m

g  

tnm

g w n t `

 

t

` g s

e mg

 

l r s n m n f

e r  j

u n f b

n k c m e t

g r n e

f s

e s

rl

lms

>

w `g

rg

v n l f e

t n l k s

 

`evg

 e f r g

e b y

j

ggk h

lkan

rmgb j

y

g

s t n k c

.

5 4

5

:0.

Et ` g

 g

k b

l

a

`

g b

ey

l k  M

erh`

 

:

8,

:45

7, a

t g r t ` g

a n

f n k c

l a 

` g

 

l r

n c n k e

f

5 5  

Hlmpfenkt

k

t ` n s

h e s g , t ` g  

B n s t r n h t  

p l s t g b  

l k 

t s

w g j s n t g  

e

g t t g r

arlm

Gkvnrlk

t l

5 :

GT

E

gc

nlk 

>

 

k t n t f

g b

K l t n a

n h e t n

l k

l a b b n t

n l k e

f

F l h

e t n l k

s  e t Mefn

ju 

@nc

` 

Xh`

llf

58

ek

b Ou

ek H e j r n

f f l Gf

gmg k

tery

 

Xh`

llf 

l jg

Ebbr

gssgb

 

n k  

Ehhl

rbek

hg w n

t `

Lh

tljg

r

52

 

:4

52 WX

GTE

 ppr

lvgb

 

T f e

k .

N k n t G

kvnr

lk

nkal

rmgb

 

G

TE 

e t n t

w lu

fb

jg

57 

rgml

vnkc

 h e

u f i ar

lm e b b n

t n l k

e f e

r g e s   n k

 e b

b n t n

l k

t

l  t ` g

 a n v

g e

r g e s  t ` g

 

B

n s t r n

h t

`eb

5

1 

p r

g v n l u

s f y

hlmm

nttg

b t l

r g m

g b n e

t n k c j

y Oukg

 

84,

:4

5 7)

 

n t `

n k  

lkg

 

y g e

r

l a

5

3

v

e f n b e

t n l k

l a

 

` g

 sem

pf nk c

 

g s u f t

s , j u t

 

t `

e t  n t mn

c`t

g q u

g s t

ek g x t g

k s n l

k

l a

 

` e t

t n m g .

5 0

E t t

e h ` g

b

t l

 t

` g

f g t t g

r

w e s

 e   ` e r

t

s`lw

nkc

 

` g

semp

fnk c

  g

s u f t s

,

j u

r n g b

n k

lv

gr

:

74

5>

 

pe cg

s l

a t t e h

` m g k t

s .  R `

g  

h ` e r t

 s `

l w g b

 

` e

t  t ` g

n k b

g p g k

b g k t

 

t g

s t  

r g s u f

t s a l r  k

n k g

:

4

rl l

ms  

w g

rg 

klt

 

l

kfy

h l k a

n r m g b

,

jut 

` g

B n s t

r n h t

e h

t u e f f

y clt

 

mu

h`  

` n c

` g r

r g s u f

t s ,  u

p

:5

t l  73 4

,444

 pp

m, 

k

 

eml

uk t

k p r

g h g b

g k t g b

 

n

k e

ky

s h ` l

l f  

n k

 t ` g

Wkn

tgb 

X t e t

g s .

E f f

::

a l

u r r

l l ms

 

g

s t g b

n

k

l kg

 j u

n f b n

k c

n k  

OH

GX

`

eb T

HJs

 

k h

e u f i

 

n k

 t ` g

`u

kbrg

bs

l a

:8

t`

lusek

bs

l a

 

pp

m, k

b n v g r

ll m

s

k  

M@

X f u s

e

` e

f f w e

y ` eb

 

g c

e f g

x h g g

b e k h g

s ,

:2

t w l

l a ` gm

n k t ` g

`ukbrgbs

l a  

`lusekbs 

l a

ppm.

:

7

5:

>. R ` g

 

n s t r

n h t ' s

 

t g

s t

r g s u

f t s s `

l w g b

 

t ` g

 

a

l f f l

w n k c .

 

Xlmg

 rllm

s `eb

:1

 

s g v

g r e f

h e u f

i

semp

fgs e i

g k .

E f

f

l a

` g O

HGX

 

se

mpf g

s w gr

g

k  

J u n f

b n k c

 

A

.

:3

 

OHG

X

Zll

m 

0

H

lmpu

t gr 

hfes

srl l

m)

:

>4,4

44

ppm

:

0

:3

4,44

4 p

pm

:>

AN

ZXR EM

GKBG

B

H

LMTF

ENKR

ALZ

BGHF

EZER

LZ^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 84 la 82 Tecg NB #?545

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 31/34

5

:84,444

ppm

:

OHGX

llnk

5>

Musnh/Lvgraflw Zllm

8>4,444

ppm

8

734,444

ppm

2

714,444

ppm

7

OHGX

Zllm

::

Zgslurhg

s p g h n e f kggbs)

hfessrllm)

:04,444

ppm

~

234,444

ppm

c

::4,444

ppm

c

584,444

ppm

54

OHGX

Zllm 8

Xhngkhg

hfessrllm)

874,444

ppm

55

224,444

ppm

5:

:04,444

ppm

58

584,444

ppm

52

M@X

llm

8

Junfbnkc G

fessrllm)

5,144

ppnk

57

5,044

ppm

51

M@X

llm 3

Junfbnkc

G

fessrllm)

884

ppm

53

5,044

ppm

50

M@X

llm

47

(Junfbnkc

r t

hfessrllm)

::4,444

ppm

5>

M@X

llm

45

(Junfbnkc

N

hfessrllm)

5>4,444

ppm

: 4

M@X

llm

42

Lfb

cym e h u f t y

l a a n h g )

2,744

ppm

:5

5,044 ppm

::

5,744

ppm

:8

M@X

llm

4 2 @effwey

8,044

ppm

: 2

584.

Bgspntg

iklwnkc

la ` g s g

r g s u f t s

e t

t ` g

B ghgmjgr 5>,

:457

Jlerb

la

: 7

Gbuhetnlk mggtnkc,

` g

B n s t r n h t b n b

klt b n s h f l s g

t ` g s g t g s t

r g s u f t s ,

ekb

` g f b

t l

t

: 1

p l s n t n l k

t ` e t

kl mlrg

heufi e t

t ` g

Mefnju

Xh`llfs

wlufb

jg

t g s t g b .

:3

: 0

8 4

ANZXR

EMCKBABHLMTFENKR

ALZ

BGHFEZERLZ^

EKB K,NWKH N'NQG

Z G N \ , N G A

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 85 la 82 Tecg NB #?54:

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 32/34

  58

5.

Es

a

g

jruer

y 

:457

, `

g B n

s t r n h t  

`

eb

s p

g k t

l r

h

lmmnt

tgb t l

 

s

pgkb

e p

p r l x n

m e t g f y

 a

l u r

m

n f f n l k

 

b l f f e r

s  

n k

h l k

k g h t n l

k  w n t

`

t ` g

h l k t

e m n k e

t n l k n s

s u g s e t

8 

t `

g

Me

f nju

X h ` l

l f s .

R`ns m l

k g y

w e s

s p

g k t

a l r

g k v n

r l k m g k

t e f h l k s

u f t e k t

s ,

f e w y

g r s ,

2

 

ekb

 p u j f n

h  

r g f e

t n l k s

h

l k s u f t

e k t s ,

w n t ` l

u t  

g v g

r rgm gb

y nkc

t ` g  

lkcln

kc

v

n l f e t n

l k s  l

a

7 

R

XHE

y

 r

gmlvn

kc ek

y  

h e u

f i l r

l t

` g r j u n

f b n k c  

m e t g

r n e f s

w n

t `

n f f g c

e f f

g v g f s

l

a

1

T

H Js .

3

5 8 : .  

B n s

t r n h t

e

kb

n k b g

p g k b g k

t

t g

s t s

la

 

e  

g f e

t n v g f y

 s m

e f f p g r h g

k t e c g

la ` g

0

r llm s

  t t ` g

Mefn

ju Xh`l

lf s `ev

g b g

m l k s t

r e t g b

 

t ` g

 

n f

f g c e f

h l k t n k

u g b u s g

la e

u f i

>

ejlv

g

f g c e f

f n

m n t s n k

53 rllm

s

k t g k

b n a

a g r g k t

 

j u n f b

n k c s ,

f f

j u

n f t  

j g a l r g

 5>3>

.

54

5 8 8

. B

n s t r n h t

 

t g s t n k c

 la

n r

 

e

kb

b u s t

  e

s e f s l

b g m

l k s t r e

t g b

t ` g

p r g s g

k h g

la

5 5

THJs 

t

w g f f

ejlvg

jehicrlukb

f g v g f s

n k

t ` g

gkvnrlkmgkts 

la

m e k y

m lr g rllm s

e t

5

: t ` g

Mefnj

u

X h ` l l f

s ,  w

`nh`

n

k b n h e t

g s

t `

g  

p r g s

g k h g l

a 

TH

Js 

k

t ` g  

h e u f i

 

ekb

 

l t ` g

r

58

 

j u n f b

n k c

m e t g r

n e f s n k

t `

l s g rll

m s.

52

582.

 

Heuf

i

ekb

 

l t ` g

r  j

u n f b n k

c

m

e t g r n

e f s n k

t ` g

s e m g j u n

f b n k c

s l r  j u

n f b n k c

s

57 

j u

n f t

b u r n k c

 

t `

g

s e m g tnmg

 p g r n l

b

w

n t `

t ` g

s e m g

 l r s n m

n f e r j u n

f b n k c

m e t g

r n e f s

e

s

51

t ` l s g

 

w`grg

 n f f g

c e f

f g v

g f s la TH

Js ev

g j

ggk alukb

 e f s l h l

k t e n k

n f

f g c e f

f

g v g f s  

la

53

T H

Js .

50

5>

 

HE

WXG

 LA EHRN

LK

:4

587

. T f e n k t n

a a s r g

-

e f f g c g

ek

b

n k h l r p

l r e t g s

 e f f

la

` g

 

p r g h g b

n k c

p

e r e c r e

p ` s .

:5

581.

  Jy

 

l

k t n k u

n k c

e

k

u k e u t

` l r n z

g b usg

 

ekb

a e n f

n k c

t l

r g m l

v g

e

kb

p r l p g r

f y

::

 

b n s p l s

g

la 

u n f b

n k c

m e t g r

n e f s

w n t

`

TH

Js t

l r

ej

lvg

74 ppm 

r

w n t

`

s u r a e h

g

:8

h l k h g

k t r e t

n l k s

ejlvg

 

54

 u c

p g r 544

 

hm:

 

e t t ` g  M

efnj u

 X h `

l l f s ,

  `

g  

Bg a

gkbekt

s 

`evg

:2 

v n l f e t g b

RXHE,

7

W.X.H.

1 4 7 ( g ) ( : )

ekb 

57

WXH

: 1 5 2 ( 5 ) 9  

ekb 

t s

nm pfgm gktnkc

:7

 

r g c u

f e t n l

k e t

24

 

HA

Z 3 1 5

. : 4 ( e )

.

: 1  

583.

 

T f e

n k t n a a

s

w n f f s u a a g

r n r r g p e

r e j f g

n k o u

r y

ek

b t `

g r g  n

s k l 

e b g q u

e t g

r

g m g b y

:

3

e t f

ew u k f g s

s  p r

g f n m n k

e r y  ekb

pgrme

kgkt

k

o u k h t n

v g n s c r

e k t g b .

: 0

85

AN

ZXR EMG

KBGB HLMTF

ENKR

AL

Z

BG

HFEZE

RLZ

EKB 

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 8: la 82 Tecg NB #?548

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 33/34

5

5

80. T f e n k

t n a a s

e r g  

e

u t ` l r

n z g b t

l  j r n

k c  t

` n s e h t n l

k t l

r g

s t r e n k

 

e

n l f e t

n l k  l

a

:

 

RXHE

,

k b

t ` g

 Hlurt

  s

e u

t ` l r n z

g b t l

 

p r l v n

b g

b g h f e

r e t l r y

 

e

kb

n k o

u k h t n v

g

r

g f n g a

j y

57

8

W.X.H

.§ 

15>.

2

7 

T

ZE^G

Z 

ALZ

 ZG

FNG

A

1

 

S

@GZG

ALZ

G,

f e

n k t n a a

s r g s

p g h t a u

f f y r g q u

g s t

t ` e t t `

n s

H l u r t

?

3

 

E.

B g

h f e r g

t ` e t Bg ag k

bekts

 

`evg

 v n

l f e t g b

 

RXH

E 

y h l k t n

k u n k c

 

t `

g

0

 

u k e u

t ` l r n

z g b usg

la kb

a e n f n k c

 

t

l

r g

m lv g

j u n f

b n k c

m

e t g r n

e f s

h l k

t e n k n k

c

74

 

pp

m

r

>

m

lr g THJs

 

r

 

w

`nh`

`e

vg s u

r a e h g  h l k h g

k t r e t

n l k s

la TH

Js 

jlvg

54 u

c p g

r 544

hm:

54

arl

m  

t ` g  Mefnj

u

X

h ` l l f s

9

5 5  

J.  

N s s u g p r g f n m n k e r y

ekb

pgrm ekgkt 

k o u k h t n v g

r g f n g a

r g q u n r n k c

Bgagkbekts

5

:

t l

 

( n

)

h

g e s g

e

f f  

usg la

 e u

f i  

ek

b

l

t ` g r

m e t g r

n e f s e

t t ` g Me

fnju

Xh

`llfs

 

h l k t e n

k n k c

58

THJs

 

t

 

h l k h g

k t r e t

n l k s

la

74 ppm

 

r

c r g e t g

r l r `e

vnkc s u

r a e h g  

h l k h g k

t r e t n l

k s

la

52

 TH

Js jlvg

54

 u c

p g r 54

4 

hm

:

, k h f

u b n k c

 

e f f h e u

f i la n i

g i n k b  ekb

 ecg l

 

h

e u f i

57

w`n

h` `es

t g s t g b

 

ejlv

g t ` g

r g

c u f e t l

r y

f

n m n t s 9

 

n n

) p

rlmpt

fy

rg m

lvg

f

f  

j

u n f b n k

c

51

m e t g r n

e f s h l

k t e n k

n k c  7

4 p

pm r

 mlrg

 

TH

Js r

 w`nh`

 

`e

vg

s u r a e h

g h l k

h g k t r e

t n l k s

 la

53

 

THJs

 

jl

vg

5

4 u c p g

r 54

4 

hm: 

arlm

 

t ` g

 Mef

nju

X h ` l l

f s ,

n k h f

u b n k c

 

h

e u f i

la n i g

50

i n k b

 

e

kb e

cg t l

h

e u f i

w`nh

`

`e

s 

t g

s t g b e

jlvg t

` g r g c u

f e t l r

y f n m n

t s 9 ekb

n n n ) b n

s p l s g

5>

l

a

uh` m e t g

r n e f s

n k e

h h l r b e

k h g

w n t `

 

t ` g R

XHE

g c u f e

t n l k s

9

:4

 

H .

Ew e

r b   f e n

k t n a a s

h l s t s

, g x p g r

t

w n t k

g s s

a g g s ,

 

t g s t n k

c  

h l s

t s ,  ekb

e

t t l r k g

y s '

:5

  a g g s

n k

 

e

hhlrb

ekhg

w n t `

57

 

W.X.H.

 § : 1 5 > (

g ) 9 ekb

:

:

B

.  Ek

 

w

e rb

la

 

e

ky l t

` g r

r g f n g

a t ` g  

Hlurt

 

b g g m

s  

e p p r l

p r n e t g

.

: 8

: 2

Betgb? 

E p r n f ( 

, 

457 

KECFGZ

&EXXLHNERGX

: 7

: 1  

J

y'

H `

e r f g s

 

E v r n

t `

:3 

E t t l

r k g y s

 

alc

f e n

k t n a a s Em g

r nhe

 W k n t g

s

a

lr

: 0

 

n

bs e k b

u j f

n h

Gm

pflyg

gs

l c [

Gkvnr

lkmgk t

ef

g s p

l k s n j n

f n t y

8:

A

NZXR EMG

KBGB 

HLMT

FENKR

ALZ

BGHFEZ

ERLZ^

EKB

NKOWKHRNQG

ZGFNGA

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 88 la 82 Tecg NB #?542

8/9/2019 Malibu Parents and Teachers Sue the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District for Violations of the Toxic Substan…

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/malibu-parents-and-teachers-sue-the-santa-monica-malibu-unified-school-district 34/34

5

Bet

gb?

 

E p

r n f~

 

L

5 7

T

EWF

EB

NK

GZX

RGN

K

8

2

Et

tlrk

gys

lr  f e

n k t n

a aT

u 

n s  

Gmp

fly

ggs

 l

r

Gk

v n r

lkmg

kt e

f   g s p

l k s n

j n f n

t y

7

1

3

0

>

5

4

5 5

5 :

5

8

5 2

5 7

5 1

5 3

5 0

5 >

:4

:5

:

:

:8

:2

:7

:1

:3

Hesg :?57-hv-4:5:2-TE-EOS Blhumgkt 5: Anfgb 42/45/57 Tecg 82 la 82 Tecg NB #?547