Upload
khairul-azam
View
221
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
1/38
Failure Analysis
Dr. Zainuddin SajuriJabatan Kejuruteraan Mekanik & Bahan
Fakulti Kejuruteraan & Alam Bina
Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia([email protected])
What, Why and How ofFailure Analysis
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
2/38
Failure Analysis 4
Failure Analysis 5
What is Failure?
Definition of Failure'
o a device or structure is no longer able tofunction as intended.
o system or part of a system fails to perform upto the expectations for which it was created.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
3/38
Failure Analysis 6
Failure
Failure is often the end result of unexpectedfactors:
o Unforeseen vibrations develop;o unanticipated temperatures are encountered;o manufacturing tolerances can not be held;o components do not quite mate as intended;o the product is used or serviced in unintended
ways.
Failure Analysis 7
Failure is a human concept
Materials do not fail in and of themselves.
o They follow the laws of nature perfectly.o If a part is loaded beyond its tensile strength,
it breaks.o Until that stress level is reached, it does not
break.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
4/38
Failure Analysis 8
When a part fails in service
o under-designedo bad engineeringo poor manufacturingo inadequate quality controlo fraudo typographical errors
Failure Analysis 9
"Just because you can,
does not mean you should"
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
5/38
Failure Analysis 10
Failures Are Caused byHuman Errors
Three general types of error:
o Error of knowledgeo Error of performanceo Error of intent
Tidak boleh menyalahkan Tuhan atas kemalanganyang berlaku:- Ini kehendak Tuhan- Ini takdir Ilahi..
Failure Analysis 11
Error of knowledge
Involve insufficient knowledge, education,training, and/or experience.
o Hydrogen Embrittlement (HE) causesotherwise stable high strength steel
components to fail.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
6/38
Failure Analysis 12
Error of performance
Result from lack of sufficient care or fromnegligence. Negligence involves such things asmisreading of drawings, inadequate specifications,and defective manufacturing and workmanship.
o Recent NASA failures in a Mars missioninvolved the incorrect conversion from the
English to the Metric System of measurementin a computer program.
Failure Analysis 13
Error of intent
Very commonly involve greed. Greed leads toactions usually carried out with a conscious orunconscious denial of full knowledge of thepotential consequences.
o Cost reduction driving design of military
vehicles causing premature failures.
o Aloha stadium superstructure corrosionfailures were caused by lack of surfacepreparation and poor materials and coatingselection.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
7/38
Failure Analysis 14
What is Failure Analysis?
'forensic engineering'
- the investigation of failed components with aview to ascertaining the cause of failure in orderto prevent further failure, injury or loss of life,and thus reduce any associated financial loss.
Failure Analysis 15
Why Undertake a FailureAnalysis?
Most important: To prevent future failures
Sometimes: To find who to be blamed
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
8/38
Failure Analysis 16
What Are Some of TheEffects of Failure?
o Loss of profito Injuryo Loss of life
o If a detailed failure analysis is carried outand appropriate ameliorating action takenrepetition of such failure can often be
avoided.
Failure Analysis 17
What Are Some of TheAgents of Failure?
Four major failure agents
o Forceo Material
o Timeo Environment
This means that components will only fail dueto one, or perhaps a combination of several,of these four failure agents.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
9/38
Failure Analysis 18
What are Some of the Causeof Failure of Machinery?
At least one or more of the following sevencause categories:
o Faulty designo Material defectso Fabrication and/or processing erroro Assembly or installation defectso Off-design or unintended service conditions
o Maintenance deficiencies, including neglectand procedures
o Improper operation
Failure Analysis 19
Some Other Causes ofFailure
o Misuse or Abuseo Manufacturing defectso Improper maintenanceo Fastener failureo Improper material
o Improper heat treatmentso Unforeseen operating conditionso Inadequate quality assuranceo Inadequate environmental protection/controlo Casting discontinuities
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
10/38
Failure Analysis 20
What Can Be Done toPrevent Failure?
An understanding of possible causes of failure,allows the risk of premature failure to beminimized.
o Kept acceptably low stress levelo Materials chosen are able to withstand
severe environmento Quality control standards need to be imposed
o Manufactured components meet the therequirement of the design
o System needs to be operated as designed,
without abuse or overload.
Failure Analysis 21
What Can Be Done toPrevent Failure?
o If, using appropriate techniques, a potentialfailure and its cause can be identified toprevent complete/final failure may, in somecases, be taken.
o In other cases, if accurate loading data isavailable and the material properties areknown, the potential for catastrophic failuremay be assessed using fracture mechanicsprinciples, such as life prediction.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
11/38
Failure Analysis 22
Important
Many failures are preventableif weunderstand the materials and their intendedapplications well enough and are willing to paythe required costs for safety and durability.
Root CauseDetermination
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
12/38
Failure Analysis 24
Force/Materials/
Time/Environment
Failure Analysis 25
Product Specifications andFailure
Service-life-expectancy of a product
The level of degradation that will bedesignated as failure.
Definition
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
13/38
Failure Analysis 26
Product Specifications andFailure
Perfect materials do not exist
o Presence of defectso Corrosion loss
o Establishing limits Type Size Location distribution
Create allowancesin design,
fabrication &Application
Failure Analysis 27
Root Cause Determination
Product fails gradually, suddenly orcatastrophically
o A method of evaluationmust to understand why
the failure occurred.
o Valuable guidance to avoidfuture failure
Root-cause failureanalysis provides
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
14/38
Failure Analysis 28
Primary Cause vs. Root Cause
o The primary cause is the set of conditionsor parameters from which the failure began.
What is fundamentally responsible for the failurein performance and determine the sequence ofevents that led to the final failure.
o The root cause of a failure is a process or
procedure which went wrong.
Failure Analysis 29
Primary Cause vs. Root Cause
Example:
o The finish on a machine part was not asspecified.
o The heat-treatment on a rail was not uniform.
o The angle on screw-threads was too steep.
Identification of that process is the key tocreating a procedure by which future failurescan be avoided. Most failure analysis stopsshort of this final step.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
15/38
Failure Analysis 30
The poor finish, the incorrect heat treatment,the shape of the screw threads in the paragraphabove are the primary causes of thosefailures, not the root causes.
Primary Cause vs. Root Cause
Failure Analysis 31
The root causes would be:
o The failure to check the finish after the partwas machined,
o The failure to ensure that the heat treatment
furnace had sufficient control of changes intemperature to produce the desiredmicrostructure in the rails, or
o The failure to enter the proper informationinto the thread-cutting process.
Primary Cause vs. Root Cause
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
16/38
Failure Analysis 32
A failure analysis is much like the work of adetective.
o Discover important clues through investigation
o Discover the contributing factors of failure
How to Conduct FailureAnalysis
Failure Analysis 33
Success of failure analyst
o Broad knowledge of materials in general
o Aware of the failed materials mechanical andphysical properties and its fabrication andhistorical performance characteristics.
o Possess a working knowledge of structuraldesign and stress behavior.
How to Conduct FailureAnalysis
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
17/38
Failure Analysis 34
1) Preliminaries: Determine when, where andhow the failure occurred.
2) Collect samples for laboratory examination.
3) Take on-site photographs.
4) Visually examine the sample.
5) Identify defects Non-Destructively.
6) Conduct appropriate chemical analyses.7) Confirm material composition
How to Conduct FailureAnalysis
Failure Analysis 35
8) Analyze via Fractography
9) Analyze via Metallography
10)Conduct Appropriate Mechanical and
Materials Testing and Analysis as Necessary11) Determine the type of failure
12)Synthesize and summarize the data,determine and report the root-cause of thefailure.
How to Conduct FailureAnalysis
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
18/38
Failure Analysis 36
a) Determine whether or not destructivetesting is permitted or if the testing must belimited to non-destructive approaches.
If the failure is or may be subject to litigation,opposing counsels must agree on this point beforeany sampling begins. Witnessed testing (thepresence of parties from both sides in a law suit)may be called for.
1. Preliminaries: Determinewhen, where and how the
failure occurred.Before beginning any failure analysis,
Failure Analysis 37
b) Visit the failure site in the field if possible. All operators involved in the failure should be
interviewed personally.
Determine what the conditions were at the timeof failure.
Were there prior indications suggesting failurewas about to occur?
Was the failure gradual or catastrophic?
Was the part protected after failure? How was the fracture handled?
Did the failure involve any fire or other conditionwhich could have altered the microstructure ofthe base metal or of some part of the sample suchas a weld?
These and all other appropriate questions shouldprovide a basis for the investigation.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
19/38
Failure Analysis 38
c) To obtain documentation on maintenanceprocedures
during the lifetime of the equipment that failed
maintenance personnel,
records of scheduled maintenance, and
suppliers and products used.
obtain the physical and chemical specifications for
the product which failed, against whichperformance may be measured.
Failure Analysis 39
a) Characteristic of the material
b) Contain a representation of the failure or
corrosive attack.
c) Taken from a sound and normal section (forcomparative purposes)
2. Collect samples forlaboratory examination
Samples selected should be:
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
20/38
Failure Analysis 40
Sample handling
The whole remaining analysis depend on samplehandling
a) Fracture surfaces must be protected fromdamage during shipment by careful packaging.
b) Surfaces should not be touched, cleaned orput back together.
c) Surface chemistry must not be contaminatedby careless handling.
Failure Analysis 41
Material specification
a) Materials specifications and service historyreveal much about the nature of failure.
b) Background information will need to be
provided for analysis.c) Take copious notes.
d) Do not rely on memory
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
21/38
Failure Analysis 42
Samples removal
a) Acetylene torch,
b) air-arc,
c) saw,
d) trepan, or
e) drill.
All cuts by torch or air-arc should be at least six
inches away from the area to be examined toavoid altering the microstructure or obscuringcorrosive attack.
Failure Analysis 43
3. Take on-site photographs
a) The failed pieces and the samples to beremoved and their surroundings.
b) Show the relationship of the questioned areato the remainder of the piece of equipment.
c) The samples after removald) Proper designation, location and dimension of
the sample
e) The date the failure occurred, and the dateof the photographs
f) Use video recording if necessary
Photographs should be taken of
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
22/38
Failure Analysis 44
4. Visually examine thesample
a) Examine the sample with unaided eye, handlens and/or low magnification fieldmicroscopes.
b) Note all anomalies, searching for cracks,corrosion damage, the presence of foreignmaterial, erosion or wear damage, or evidenceof impact or other distress.
c) The condition of protective coatings.d) Manufacturing defects.
Failure Analysis 45
4. Visually examine thesample
a) Measure wall thickness both at the failuresite and some distance away from it.
b) Note the presence of any corrosion and map
its general distribution.
If pipe failure
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
23/38
Failure Analysis 46
5. Identify defects Non-Destructively
o radiography,
o magnetic particle,
o ultrasonic,
o liquid/dye penetrant,
o eddy current,
o leak,
o acoustic emissions
Search for material imperfections with
Magnetic Particle Testing doneby inducing a magnetic field in aferro-magnetic material anddusting the surface with ironparticles.
Failure Analysis 47
5. Identify defects Non-Destructively
Radiography Fluorescent Liquid DyePenetrant viewed in black light.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
24/38
Failure Analysis 48
6. Conduct appropriatechemical analyses
a) material was of proper type and grade,
b) Material met appropriate standards,
c) Whether deviation from the specificationscontributed to
o fracture,
o wear,
o breaks corrosion and
o failure.
Chemical analysis to determine
Failure Analysis 49
Method of chemical analysis
o Wet chemical analysis,
o Atomic Absorption,
o X-ray Photoelectron,
o Auger Electron and
o Spectroscopy
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
25/38
Failure Analysis 50
7. Confirm materialcomposition
a) In conjunction with scanning electronmicroscopy (SEM) to identify the elements
b) Advantages of EDS are
Easily performed
reliable as a qualitative method.
c) Limitations
Only marginally useful as a quantitative method.
Use EDS (Energy-Dispersive Spectroscopy) toidentify material composition.
Failure Analysis 51
EDS
Line scanning isolates an area of thespecimen. The red line indicates thelocation of the scan.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
26/38
Failure Analysis 52
8. Analyze via Fractography
a) the mode of fracture
o intergranular,
o cleavage, or
o shear
b) the origin of fracture,
c) location andd) nature of flaws that may have initiated
failure.
Fractography is used to determine
Failure Analysis 53
8. Analyze via Fractography
a) Determine why a part failed can usually bedetermined.
b) Reveal the relationship between physical and
mechanical processes involved in the fracturemechanism.
c) The size of fracture characteristics rangefrom gross features to a few micrometersacross.
The importance of fractograph
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
27/38
Failure Analysis 54
Common Technique inFractography
a) Light microscopy
b) Scanning electron microscopy
the depth of field in the SEM is muchhigher; thus the SEM can focus on allareas of a three-dimensional objectidentifying characteristic features such
as striations or inclusions..
Failure Analysis 55
9. Analyze via Metallography
a) not to remove inclusions, erode grainboundaries
b) Study structural characteristics in relation
to its physical and mechanical propertiesc) note of grain size, shape, and distribution of
secondary phases and nonmetallic inclusions.
Prepare a laboratory specimen
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
28/38
Failure Analysis 56
9. Analyze via Metallography
Intergranular StressCorrosion Cracking (ISCC) inturbine component
Cross-section of copper lancecomponent exposed to excessive
temperatures showing graingrowth
Failure Analysis 57
9. Analyze via Metallography
a) pit depth,
b) intergranular corrosion,
c) hydrogen attack and embrittlement,
d) caustic embrittlement,
e) stress corrosion cracking (intergranular ortransgranular),
f) corrosion,
g) mechanical or thermal fatigue.
Metallography for the analyst may be concernedwith
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
29/38
Failure Analysis 58
10. Conduct AppropriateMechanical and MaterialsTesting and Analysis asNecessary
1. Physical Testing
2. Finite Element Analysis
3. Fracture Mechanics
Failure Analysis 59
Physical Testing
o Hardness,
o tensile strength,
o impact,
o fatigue resistance,
o wear,
o Flexibility etc.
To determine if the mechanical properties- conform to specifications.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
30/38
Failure Analysis 60
Physical Testing
o excessive elastic deformation (deflectionunder applied loads),
o yielding (permanent material deformation asa result of stress), or
o fracture.
Structural members and machine parts can failto perform their intended functions by:
Failure Analysis 61
Physical Testing
o Deflection of closely mating machine partsdue to surface stresses (elastic deformation)can degrade adjacent parts by increasingwear and in certain cases can promotecomplete failure.
o A study of the mechanical properties of theparts can provide information on load-bearingcapabilities of the system and can minimizesuch failures.
Examples:
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
31/38
Failure Analysis 62
Finite Element Analysis
o Predicting the response of an existingcomponent or assembly to stress
o Assessment of remaining life of a componentor assembly
o Determining the failure mode of a failedcomponent or assembly, e.g. fatigue, creep,
and buckling.o Designing of a new component or assembly as
a part of recommendations for remediationof the problem
A powerful numerical tool for analyzingmechanical components and systems
Failure Analysis 63
Fracture Mechanics
o How the part in question actually failed,
o What the mode of failure was, and
o Where the failure was initiated.
Using the many analytical techniques abovewill help to determine
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
32/38
Failure Analysis 64
Fracture Mechanics
o How the part in question actually failed,
o What the mode of failure was, and
o Where the failure was initiated.
Using the many analytical techniques abovewill help to determine
Failure Analysis 65
Fracture Mechanics
o The size of flaws in a material, principallycracks, to
o The applied stresses on those cracks, and to
o the fracture toughness of the material, orits resistance to cracking.
Fracture mechanics relates
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
33/38
Failure Analysis 66
Fracture Mechanics
The relation between flaw size, stress andfracture toughness
aY
KIC
: fracture stress
Y : dimensionless shape factor
a : crack length
KIC : fracture toughness
Failure Analysis 67
Fracture Mechanics
o the determination of permissible flaw size,
o the calculation of the stress necessary tocause catastrophic failure
o the determination of the load on a componentat the time of failure
o the determination as to whether adequatematerials were used in manufacturing
o the determination as to whether a partdesign was adequate.
This calculation will allow
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
34/38
Failure Analysis 68
Fracture Mechanics
o how a particular crack formed at a specificlocation and
o the stress conditions that caused the crackto propagate.
Thus, fracture mechanics can be used to helpus understand
The design engineer will normally includefactors of safety in his design to preventstresses from reaching critical levels
Failure Analysis 69
11. Determine the type offailure
a) Ductile fracture,
b) Brittle fracture,
c) Fatigue fracture,
d) Wear,
e) Fretting,
f) Elevated Temperature and
g) Corrosion
The major types of failures likely to beencountered by metals in service are:
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
35/38
Failure Analysis 70
12. Synthesize andsummarize the data,
determine and report theroot cause of the failure
Proposed root causes of a failure must bebased primarily on observed facts. Thesefacts, combined with the experience, skill and
knowledge of the analyst will lead to soundconclusions.
Failure Analysis 71
12. Synthesize andsummarize the data,determine and report theroot cause of the failure
All the observed data should be reported,even if some of it seems peripheral. In thefuture, with additional data, it may turn outto be possible to use what seemed peripheralat first to make an even more soundinterpretation.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
36/38
Failure Analysis 72
The failure analysis report represents theculmination of the analysis effort and thebeginning of failure elimination. The goal of anyfailure analysis is targeted towards theelimination of identified causes and preventfuture failure.
How to Write FailureAnalysis Report
Failure Analysis 73
The completed failure analysis report includesthe following sections:
a) Description of the failed component
b) Service condition at the time of failure
c) Prior service historyd) Manufacturing and processing history of component
e) Mechanical and metallurgical study of failure
f) Metallurgical evaluation of quality
g) Event Summary of failure causing mechanism
h) Recommendations for prevention of similar failures
How to Write FailureAnalysis Report
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
37/38
Failure Analysis 74
The final failure analysis report providessolutions with expected returns on investmentsbut also identifies how the failure occurred inthe first place. To accomplish this eventsummary, a description of the failure mechanismand list of recommendations are included in thereport.
How to Write FailureAnalysis Report
Failure Analysis 75
A brief description of:
Event Summary
a) how the failure was first noticed
b) how long it has been going on andc) the method(s) used to isolate or mitigate the
consequences of the failure.
8/2/2019 Material Technology 2_chapter 4 Failure_Analysis
38/38
Failure Analysis 76
A summary of the root cause(s) that led tofailure occurrence.
Failure Mechanism
a) characterize the things that must occur inorder for the failure to manifest itself.
b) outline the mechanical and metallurgicalstudy of failure including the metallurgical
evaluation of quality.
Explain what, when and who is going to beresponsible for implementation, and also includea recommendations for prevention of similarfailures.
Recommendation