Upload
rafe-lawrence
View
216
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid Dynamics
Motivation Objective Challenges Proposed timeline
Technical Procedure U of C’s role (Bassiouny) UIC’s role (Loth) ANL’s role (Fischer)
Personnel: Francis Loth, UIC (S. Lee, W. Kalata, N. Arsalan, …) Hisham Bassiouny, U of C (O. Bick, … ) Paul Fischer, (L. Freitag, G. Leaf, B. Smith,... )
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Turbulence in Biofluid Dynamics
Cardiovascular simulations AV-graft failure - close to a billion dollar annual economic impact
importance of hemodynamic forces (shear, pressure, vibration) in disease progression
Stenosed carotid arteries - $60 B annual turbulence a distinguishing feature of severely stenosed (constricted) arteries high wall-shear (mean and oscillatory) can possibly lead to
embolisms (plaque break-off) thrombis formation (clotting)
Turbulence computations 1-3 orders of magnitude more difficult than laminar (healthy) case No numerical simulations of turbulence in carotids or grafts in current literature
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid Dynamics
Clinical Objective (3-5 years out): rapid (24 hour) quantification of wall shear in stenosed arteries from
in vivo MR / CT images, color Doppler ultrasound velocity measurements, and computational fluid dynamics (CFD).
Technical Challenges: image translation (expert systems?) robust automated meshing (tetrahedra, hexahedra, optimization) role of wall motion (fluid-structure interaction)
CFD parallel computing ( ~120 days on 32 processors, brute force) high-order, adaptive numerical methods, improved algorithms
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Timeline for Planned NIH Patient-Specific Proposal
Yr. 1 (now) -- complete 1-2 turbulent cases (feasibility)
Yr. 2-3 -- quantify 6-12 patients
Yr. 3-5 -- track 50-100 patients ( 24 hour turn-around, routine )
Bassiouny ( U of C ) -- track biological/chemical factors Loth (UIC) / MCS -- quantify hemodynamic forces (space and time)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Extra-Procedural Commitment of Surgical Team (Bassiouny, U of C)
Patient-specific timeline: Color Doppler ultrasound:
Severe stenoses identified (patient is enrolled in Loth/Bassiouny study) Flow rate measured in common, internal, and/or external carotid
CT-scan imaging (Dr. O. Bick, Head of CT) Fine resolution image is taken (1.25 mm axial, 0.25 mm planar) Imaging time is $400 / patient Images released to biomechanics team at UIC (image transfer process)
U of C Team personnel on board: ultrasound technician CT-scan technician radiologist
(identifies carotid from CT images, Bick)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Color Doppler Ultrasound -- Flow Rate Information
Provides gross flow rate characterstics Stenosis identified by turbulence
Availability U of C -- 7 units in clinic (700 patients/year) UIC -- 1 unit, biomechanics lab of Loth
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Extra-Procedural Commitment of Surgical Team (Bassiouny, U of C)
Patient-specific timeline: Color Doppler ultrasound:
Severe stenoses identified (patient is enrolled in Loth/Bassiouny study) Flow rate measured in common, internal, and/or external carotid
CT-scan imaging (Dr. O. Bick, Head of CT) Fine resolution image is taken (1.25 mm axial, 0.25 mm planar) Imaging time is $400 / patient Images released to biomechanics team at UIC (image transfer process)
U of C Team personnel on board: ultrasound technician CT-scan technician radiologist
(identifies carotid from CT images, Bick)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
CT Image to Mesh Translation
CT Scan -- stack of 2D images Mimics/Fortran software used to produce RP data file (Loth et al.)
Currently, image translation & feature identification a bit of an art
(W. Kalata ANL/UIC)
Fourier Smoothing
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Fourier-Based Contour Reconstruction
CT/MR output is generally rough due to pixelation. Standard (local) smoothers are not guaranteed to preserve macroscopic
contour features (area, moments, etc.), and often suffer from shrinkage, though nonshrinking variants do exist (Taubin 95).
In any slice, lumen surface is a closed contour Fourier bases are a natural choice:
stable C - continuous macroscopic features built-in z-smoothing applied to Fourier coefficients
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Basic Meshing Mechanism
(S.E. Lee ANL/UIC)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Other Examples
Arterio-VenousGraft
AneurismicAbdominal
Aorta
Pig AV Graft
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mesh generation difficulties...
Surface smoothing Mesh topology Interior mesh geometry (Freitag)
etc.
Not yet automated…
Interior element distribution can have a huge impact on matrix conditioning and iteration counts
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Numerical Simulation
Spectral element method (SEM) High-order ( > ~8 ) -- minimal numerical dissipation, dispersion General geometries
Very efficient (locally structured -- hex) vector parallel (1000s of processors)
Ideal for weakly turbulent (transitional) flows
A significant competitive advantage for diseased cases.
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Why high-order methods?
Transitional flows are sensitive to a small amount of viscosity (.001-.0001) Require numerical dissipation/dispersion to be small ( << .001 ) Four-fold savings in 1D translates into 64-fold savings in 3D
Error for 1D Convection Example -- t=10
For .5% error, 8th order requires 64 pts., vs. 256 pts for quadratic
Solution
(E,N) = (256,1),
at t=10.
Solution
(E,N) = (256,1),
at t=0.
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Initial steady flow results for healthy carotid artery
Re=542 Experimental ResultsRe=377Prof. Francis Loth, UICEmil Ghengeaua, UIC
Spectral element mesh, Seung Lee, UICPaul Fischer, MCS/ANL
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Arterio-venous Graft Simulations
PTFE plastic tubing surgically attached from artery to vein (short-circuit)
Provides a port for dialysis patients, to avoid repeated vessel injury
Failure often results after 3 months from occlusion forming immediately downstream of attachment to vein, where flow is turbulent (Re ~ D-1)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Comparison of LDA (experimental) and SEM (numerical) results
Re=1060 (laminar) Re=1820 (weakly turbulent)
<u>
<u’>
<v’>
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Turbulent Structures in AV-Graft
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
AV Graft -- Re=1820
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Validation: Arterio-Venous Graft Studies(Arsalan, Lee, Loth - UIC, Fischer - ANL)
AV Graft - Re=1820
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Summary -- Turbulent Simulations in Vascular Flows
Impact quality of life economic
Timeliness availability of imaging technology cost/performance of commodity-based parallel computers physician acceptance of simulation as a diagnostic tool NIH, DOE funding appears to be increasing
Technical Challenges image analysis meshing (construction, optimization) CFD vessel wall response (fluid-structure interaction)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Opportunities in Biofluid Dynamics
Currently focusing on vascular geometries: grafts and diseased arteries
Simulation has the opportunity to play a role in surgical decisions Can provide more detailed diagnoses of hemodynamical forces in the
vessel than inspection of vessel geometry or flow rates alone.
Medical treatment for diseased carotid arteries is estimated to cost $60 billion annually. Arteriovenous graft (for dialysis patients) costs are estimated at $1 billion annually.
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Opportunities in Biofluid Dynamics
5-year Mission: provide physicians with patient-specific wall-shear stress and pressure distributions within 24 hours of MRI scan.
Near term mission: compute wall shear for turbulent flow in AV-graft model compute turbulent flow in a stenosed (blocked) carotid artery (take course on how to handle medical data….)
Mid-term mission: (2-3 years)
Get NIH funding for 100-patient study
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Numerical Issues
geometry geometry geometry translation of images to meshes
2D surface in R3
image smoothing feature identification
surface smoothing mesh optimization
turbulence commonly found in diseased arteries and vascular grafts much harder to simulate than laminar case
moving walls non-Newtonian fluid
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Capabilities within MCS
In a unique position w.r.t. turbulence we have a high-order spectral element code for complex 3D geometries high-order codes are optimal for this regime
minimal numerical dissipation which otherwise overwhelms physical viscosity minimal dispersion estimate 8-fold reduction in number of gridpoints for reasonable accuracy
significant parallel computing resources
Behind w.r.t. image translation / mesh generation Roughly 20 groups working in vascular simulations (others in closely related
cardiac and neuro areas) most are using low-order tetrahedra, significant simplifications in meshing
Efficient implementation of high-order methods requires hexahedra (bricks)
Optimal hexahedral meshing poses many interesting CS/math issues.
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division - ANL
Biofluid Dynamics
Paul Fischer - MCS
Prof. Francis Loth, Ph.D., UIC
Prof. Hashim Bassiouny, M.D., U of C
[email protected]/~fischer
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Advanced CFD: State of the art
Quarteroni, Formaggia (EPFL) fluid structure interactions with ALE finite element code coupling of 3D models with 1D models for impedence matching low Reynolds numbers
Pedley (Cambridge) fundamental and applied fluid dynamics relating to biology
Peskin (Courant) immersed boundary method
Perktold, (Graz) SUPG FEM code, moving meshes, grid generation
Kamm (MIT) experimental biofluids
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid dynamics: Research Challenges
For AV-graft simulations having Re > 2500, nonconforming meshing will provide an order of magnitude reduction in computational cost, due to locality of coherent structures in the flow field.
Complex geometry problems require robust mesh generation, smoothing adaptive refinement with load balancing ALE to support flexible walls
Biofluids requires biology and medical experts (team of F. Loth) detailed knowledge of wall material properties
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Transitional Flows in Complex Geometries -- Paul Fischer
Biofluid dynamics simulations first known simulations of transitional flow in vascular geometries excellent agreement with experiments for AV-graft and carotid arteries
(AV-graft failure - close to a billion dollar annual economic impact)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Color Doppler Ultrasound -- Flow Rate Information
Provides gross flow rate characterstics Needed for boundary conditions to CFD
Availability U of C -- 7 units in clinic (700 patients/year) UIC -- 1 unit, biomechanics lab of Loth
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid Dynamics: Timeline
Current Status Ph.D. student N. Pearsol will use nek5000 for thesis work on
carotid artery in 2000 Loth, Lee, and Fischer are using nek5000 for steady AV-graft
simulations (NIH grant w/ Bassiouny submitted) Full curved geometry supported
Upgrade Path Nonconforming SEM in production by 8-1-00 (required for
unsteady AV-graft simulations with 1000 < Re < 2600). Mesh smoothing? ALE formulation in place (due to MIT thesis work of L.W. Ho) -
this could be extended/validated by 1-1-01 if necessary.
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Advanced CFD: Research Challenges
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid Dynamics: State of the Art within MCS
Parallel spectral element code highly accurate -- excellent agreement with
experimental data for AV-graft model abstract submitted to the Int. Mech. Eng. Cong.,
Orlando, November 2000
Automated mesh generation rapid translation of MR/CT scan images to hex-
based meshes Seung Lee co-op student working for
Fischer/Loth abstract accepted to the World Congress on
Medical Physics and Bioengineering, Chicago, IL, July 23-28, 2000
mesh smoothing technology - Freitag
Wall material properties, solid mechanics T. Canfield
Porcine AV-graft geometry de-veloped by S.E. Lee, UIC/ANL
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Biofluid Dynamics: State of the Art within MCS
Accurate parallel spectral element code Excellent agreement with experimental data for
AV-graft model. (Abstract submitted to the Int. Mech. Eng. Cong., Orlando, November 2000)
Excellent agreement with experimental results for human carotid. Superior to commercial package Star-CD.
Automated mesh generation rapid translation of MR/CT scan images to hex-
based meshes Seung Lee co-op student working for
Fischer/Loth paper presented at the World Congress on
Medical Physics and Bioengineering, Chicago, IL, July 23-28, 2000
mesh smoothing technology - Freitag
Wall material properties, solid mechanics future investigation
Porcine AV-graft geometry de-veloped by S.E. Lee, UIC/ANL
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Method
Vessel geometry has been shown to strongly affect hemodynamic variables therefore, an accurate representation of the 3D vascular geometry is critical for accurate simulation.
Use MRI or spiral CT scans to get the geometry
MR Images from a volunteer
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Objectives
Automated Hexahedral Mesh Generation Technique for Bifurcation Geometries Fast (5 - 10 minutes) Bifurcation specific control parameters for grid refinement Robust (no bad cells)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
“Construction of a Physical Model of the Human Carotid Artery Based upon In Vivo Magnetic Resonance Images” R. V. Yedavalli, F. Loth, A. Yardimci, W.F. Pritchard, J.N. Oshinski, L. Sadler, F. Charbel, N. Alperin, accepted as a Technical Brief to the Journal of Biomechanical Engineering.
Use Mimics and Fortran to extract the slice-based data
Create CFD mesh from slice-based data (RP format)
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
From Slice-based data of carotid bifurcation artery
Pick control points to define three planes
Divide into three parts
Obtain new section slice (angled) from the original slice-based data
Mesh each branch as a "pipe"
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Manually pick the points The code determines outline vertices Get new angled section slices
Procedure
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Basic Meshing Mechanism
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Octagonal box at middle, and arbitrary surface curve around Greater resolution near the wall compared to the middle Smooth transition from polygon to arbitrary curve
Mesh of each cross-section
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Three way partition avoids figure '8' cross section
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Other Examples
Arterio-VenousGraft
AneurismicAbdominal
Aorta
Pig AV Graft
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory
Mathematics and Computer Science Division - ANL
Biofluid Dynamics
Paul Fischer - MCS
Prof. Francis Loth, Ph.D., UIC
Prof. Hashim Bassiouny, M.D., U of C
[email protected]/~fischer
Mathematics and Computer Science Division, Argonne National Laboratory