Upload
anissa-miles
View
214
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
www.RiskMgmt.net
MAY 17, 2001
ENERGY MARKETS IN TURMOIL
PRESENTED TO THE
INSTITUTE FOR REGULATORY POLICYSTUDIES
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 2
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
May 17, 2001
1 – NATURAL GAS WINTER 2000/2001 REVIEW
2 – WHY USE RISK MANAGEMENT
3 – HEDGING OBJECTIVES FOR THE ENERGY INDUSTRY
OUTLINE
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 3
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
SECTION 1SECTION 1Natural Gas WinterNatural Gas Winter 2000/2001 Review 2000/2001 Review
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 4
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
1.550
2.0752.290
1.565
2.509
3.063
2.488
1.872
2.554
3.921
0.000
0.500
1.000
1.500
2.000
2.500
3.000
3.500
4.000
1991
/199
2
1992
/199
3
1993
/199
4
1994
/199
5
1995
/199
6
1996
/199
7
1997
/199
8
1998
/199
9
1999
/200
0
2000
/200
1
WINTER STRIP VALUES REVIEWWINTER STRIP VALUES REVIEW
WINTER STRIP VALUES
Winter strip values for the 3 summer months averaged 4.27, .27 cents higher than the previous NYMEX all time high monthly close of 3.998
1.550
2.0752.290
1.565
2.509
3.063
2.488
1.872
2.554
4.297
0.000
0.500
1.000
1.500
2.000
2.500
3.000
3.500
4.000
4.500
1991
/199
2
1992
/199
3
1993
/199
4
1994
/199
5
1995
/199
6
1996
/199
7
1997
/199
8
1998
/199
9
1999
/200
0
2000
/200
1
June 28, 2000 WINTER STRIP
4.297
1.550
2.0752.290
1.565
2.509
3.063
2.488
1.872
2.554
4.582
0.000
0.5001.000
1.500
2.0002.500
3.000
3.5004.000
4.500
5.000
1991
/199
2
1992
/199
3
1993
/199
4
1994
/199
5
1995
/199
6
1996
/199
7
1997
/199
8
1998
/199
9
1999
/200
0
2000
/200
1
August 31, 2000 WINTER STRIP
4.582
July 28, 2000 WINTER STRIP
3.921
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 5
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
GAS PRODUCTION REVIEWGAS PRODUCTION REVIEW
NATURAL GAS SUPPLY
Natural Gas wells figures reached record level highs as a direct result of skyrocketing prices
MONTHLY US NATURAL GAS WELLS vs NATURAL GAS 12-MONTH STRIPMONTHLY US NATURAL GAS WELLS vs NATURAL GAS 12-MONTH STRIP
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1.00
1.25
1.50
1.75
2.00
2.25
2.50
2.75
3.00
3.25
3.50
3.75
4.00
4.25
4.50
4.75
Natural Gas Wells Natural Gas Prices
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 6
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
GAS STORAGE REVIEWGAS STORAGE REVIEW
NATURAL GAS STORAGE
Natural gas storage, while well behind the previous three injection years, was still above mid-1990 injection rates.
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
10
/27
11
/27
12
/27
1/2
7
2/2
7
3/2
7
4/2
7
5/2
7
6/2
7
7/2
7
8/2
7
9/2
7
99-0098-9997-9896-9795-9694-95
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 7
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
WEATHER REVIEWWEATHER REVIEW
NATURAL GAS DEMAND
In July of 2000, the National Weather Forecast was calling for an above normal winter, indicating demand should remain manageable.
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 8
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
SECTION 2SECTION 2Why Use Why Use
Risk ManagementRisk Management
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 9
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
RISK MANAGEMENTRISK MANAGEMENT
Identifying, controlling, and minimizing exposure to adverse energy commodity price movement through utilization of financial instruments.
WHAT IS RISK MANAGEMENT?
December 2000 1-Month Range $4.00
1996 – 2000 4-Year Range $2.00
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 10
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
PRICING ALTERNATIVESPRICING ALTERNATIVES
If we could guarantee price below index ANDAND guarantee a reasonable cap, guess where we’d be now...
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 11
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
FIX PRICE ORFIX PRICE OR FLOAT INDEX ?FLOAT INDEX ?INDEX PRICING
The buyer or seller will fix the price at a monthly/daily index based on a posted cash price or Nymex price
Currently the commonly used pricing mechanism for many regulated energy providers
A viable pricing tool for energy purchases when prices are at extremely high levels or energy sales when prices are at extremely low levels
Rationale behind index pricing is to avoid fixed pricing that results in a loss
INDEX / ARBITRAGE STRATEGY
INDEX
AR
BIT
RA
GE
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 12
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
FIXFIX PRICE OR FLOAT INDEX ?PRICE OR FLOAT INDEX ?FIXED PRICING
A company will fix prices for multiple months or seasons up to several years.
Short-term fixed-price contracts are attractive when a company wants to lock in prices during volatile price periods such as winter or shoulder months.
The price of the contract may be structured so the cost is the same each year so there is a base price with a yearly escalator.
A long-term fixed price contract is attractive when prices are at extreme low levels that are not expected to hold for a long period of time. FIXED PRICING / RATE FREEZE
FIXED PRICE
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 13
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
FIX PRICE OR FLOAT INDEX ?FIX PRICE OR FLOAT INDEX ?OPTIONS – CAPS/COLLARS/FLOORS
A cap gives a buyer the option of purchasing energy at a predetermined strike level without the obligation of buying at that level. For this protection, the buyer pays a premium similar to an insurance payment.
A collar gives the buyer an obligation and an option at the outer range of two prices. If market prices rise above the high price strike, the buyer is protected at that price. If prices falls through the low price, the buyer accepts the lower price. The high and low price are sometimes referred to as a cap and floor. If prices fall between the high and low price so that neither party exercises its options, the buyer purchases energy at the market price.
CAPS / COLLARS
CAP
FLOOR
COLLAR
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 14
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
GOALS PRICING STRATEGY
Market Sensitive Price Index Pricing
Guaranteed Price Fixed Pricing
Price Stability Cap Pricing
MARKET SENSITIVE PRICE + PRICE STABILITY
REQUIRES
INDEX PRICING, FIXED PRICING, CAPS & COLLARS
NATURAL GAS HEDGING OBJECTIVESNATURAL GAS HEDGING OBJECTIVES
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 15
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
SECTION 3SECTION 3Hedging Objectives For TheHedging Objectives For The
Energy IndustryEnergy Industry
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 16
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
RISK MANAGEMENT PROGRAM OBJECTIVESRISK MANAGEMENT PROGRAM OBJECTIVES
Utilize Market Tools to take Advantage of Market Opportunities Develop a Pricing Plan and Think Ahead
How These Objectives Can Be Achieved:How These Objectives Can Be Achieved:
Natural Gas Buy
BUY Under Budget
BUY to Protect Against a Major Price Increase
BUY Lower than the Competition
BUY as Low as Possible
PRICE PRICE STABILITYSTABILITY
COSTCOSTCONTROLCONTROL
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 17
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
Long-term Price StabilityCompany has price risk versus
annual profit margins
Moderate
RISK SCALERISK SCALE
Short-term Market SensitivityCompany has price risk versus monthly index &/or daily prices
RISK APPETITE FOR ENERGY BUYERS RISK APPETITE FOR ENERGY BUYERS Companies are not homogeneous when it comes to risk tolerances
and risk profiles. Many utilities still need to be tied to month-to-month prices, while
other corporations or municipalities want and need the security of stable pricing, regardless of current values.
The overall company risk strategy will influence how aggressive the
organization will be when it comes time to set budget objectives for raw commodity prices.
REGULATED VERSUS INDUSTRIAL
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 18
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
RISK APPETITE FOR ENERGY BUYERSRISK APPETITE FOR ENERGY BUYERS
$10.00$10.00
$3.75$3.75
$2.00$2.00
4 yr. Median4 yr. Median ValueValue
GREEDGREED
FEARFEAR
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 19
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
OPTION VOLATILITY ANALYSISOPTION VOLATILITY ANALYSIS Historical Volatility measures the market's past volatility.
It is defined as the standard deviation of a series of price changes measured at regular intervals.
It can be used in conjunction with Implied Volatility to gauge how the market's current expectations differ from history
. Annual historic volatility is turning down for the first time since early
last year
Energy Markets In TurmoilPage 20
©Copyright Risk Management Inc.
KEYS TO SUCCESSFUL HEDGINGKEYS TO SUCCESSFUL HEDGING
Recognize the Importance of the Hedging Program to the Bottom Line
Define Specific Program Objectives
Develop a Hedging Strategy
Maintain Structure and Discipline
Formulate a Continuing Education Program
Practice Proper Interpretation of Hedge Results