11
Memory Connected Extending Memory on the Web via Human-Centric Knowledge Exchange Network Jie Bao and Li Ding 1 Memect Memory Connected

Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memory Connected Extending Memory on the Web via Human-Centric Knowledge Exchange Network

Jie Bao and Li Ding

1

Memect Memory Connected

Page 3: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Social Web and Walled Gardens

• I’m locked in a garden • My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) • Loyalty V.S. Trapped

• I don’t use a garden • Prefer not: bank statement • No such service

3

person A Person B Silo Y

Silo X

Page 4: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Human Centric Design – Principle 1

4

X

Human readable knowledge • To extend human’s memory • To facilitate human communication

Page 5: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Human readable knowledge: Design Issues

• For developers • Cognitive complexity over computational complexity

• “knowledge must be written for people to read, and only incidentally for machines to understand” *

• Readable code and data modeling (cf . Yaml, python, coffee-script, groovy, turtle etc)

• Engineering friendly: reusable, module support • No need for 100% accuracy, some guess is fine

• For users • Readable representations • “right” granularity • Explorable knowledge with just-in-time schema

5 * Abelson and Sussman claimed that “programs must be written for people to read, and only incidentally for machines to execute”

Page 6: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Human Centric Design – Principle 2

6

Tangible rewards and cost reduction • Instant rewards • Cheap start

Book Blog Tweet

Page 7: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Tangible rewards and cost reduction: Design Issues

• For developers • Reduce upfront agreements (ontology, schema etc) as

much as possible, e.g. avoid extended scrum.

• Allow mixed representations, allow data/schema to evolve and improve

• Ownership, not blocked by mandatory consensus

• Keep it simple

• For users • just-in-time validation and refinement, e.g. speadsheet

7

Page 8: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Human Centric Design – Principle 3

8 PROVO ontology draft (2011), http://www.w3.org/TR/2011/WD-prov-o-20111213/

Bottom-up growth scales • Top-down consensus may take years

• By experts • Bottom-up: shared and evolving

• By users

Page 9: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Bottom-up growth: Design Issues

• For developers • Instead of invent new, build on top of well-adopted

technologies, e.g. json, csv,

• Live schema from live data

• For users • More on Web data

• More on everyday-life, consumer data

9

Page 10: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Use-cases

• Support mailing list users • Daily routine: don’t miss signal, don’t waste time

• Conversation: need timely reply

• Research(task): life cycle of working group action item

• Research(user): build trust in to unfamiliar users

• Support team common knowledge • Consensus: Is it just the project manager’s view?

• Unexpected use: what if one member left? How much should I pay for unforeseeable future?

10

Page 11: Memory Connected - World Wide Web Consortium · Memect Memory Connected Social Web and Walled Gardens •I’m locked in a garden •My brain is fragmented – (Dion’s talk) •Loyalty

Memect Memory Connected

Vision: Knowledge Exchange Network

• Extended Memory: capture and organize

• Connected Memory: exchange

11

person A

Person B

person C

Broker X

Broker Z

Broker Y

Questions? Comments?