Minutes of the 464 meeting of the State Level Expert ... Minutes of the 464th N.pdf · Certified compliance report from regional office Bhopal of MoEF&CC or Member Secretary Gujarat

Page 1 of 59

464th meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, Dated 22.12.2018

Page 1 of 59

Minutes of the 464th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held on 22/12/2018

at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Sector – 10 A, Gandhinagar.

The 464th meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) was held on 22nd December

2018, 2018 at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Sector – 10 A, Gandhinagar.

Following members attended the meeting:

1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC

2. Shri S. C. Srivastav, Vice Chairman, SEAC

3. Shri Rajesh. I. Shah, Member, SEAC.

4. Shri V. N. Patel, Member, SEAC

5. Shri R. J. Shah, Member, SEAC.

6. Shri A. K. Muley, Member, SEAC.

7. Dr. V. K. Jain, Member, SEAC.

8. Shri. K. C. Mistry, Secretary, SEAC.

The agenda of Category 8 (a) and Category 8 (b) cases was taken up. Nine [9] cases of Category 8 (a)

and one case of Category (b) were taken up. The applicants made presentations on the activities to be

carried out along with other details furnished in the Form-1, Form-1A, Conceptual Plan and EIA

Reports.

1. Ahmedabad One Mall

Vastrapur, T.P.S. No.1, Final Plot No.216, Ahmedabad

Refer back

This is a commercial building construction project “Ahmedabad One Mall” at T.P.S.No.1, F.P.No.216,

Vastrapur, Ahmedabad proposed by M/s. Ruchi Malls Pvt. Ltd. The project proponent vide their online

proposal no. SIA/GJ/NCP/71541/2017 dated 06/03/2018 along with Form-I & Form-IA applied for the

proposed expansion and modification. Based on the application made on 06/03/2018, the project was

appraised during the meeting of SEAC held on 17/04/2018 and based on the decision taken during the

meeting of SEAC held on 02/11/2018, the project was recommended by the SEAC vide letter No. EIA-

10-2018-NCP-277-3583 dated 22/11/2018. Based on the recommendation of the SEAC, the project

was taken up in the meeting of SEIAA dated 27/11/2018. As per the decision taken during the meeting

of SEIAA held on 27/11/2018, the project was referred back to SEAC vide letter no.

SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/ 1340/2018 dated 14/12/2018.

1. To verify details of bifurcation of EC dated 16/05/2007 granted by MoEF&CC.

2. To verify the details of parking area provided and the adequacy of the same.

3. To verify the details and compliance of EC conditions dated 16/05/2007 granted by MoEF&CC.

The project proponent vide their letter dated 10/12/2018 has submitted the additional details which was

sought during the meeting of SEIAA held on 27/11/2018. Considering the details sought by the SEAC

Page 2 of 59


Page 2 of 59

meeting held on 12/12/2018 & additional information submitted by the project proponent, it was

decided to call the project proponent in one of next SEAC meetings.

The project proponent along with their expert/ consultant attended the meeting. During the meeting, it

was presented that they have applied for total land area of 34,580.0 m2 (i.e 3.46 ha.) which is reflected

as 2.25 ha in the Environmental Clearance granted to the project. Parking area proposed earlier was

as per the requirement of GDCR at that time and now parking area for the proposed expansion will be

provided considering parking requirement as per the CGDCR – 2017. Project proponent has submitted

copies of compliance report submitted to Regional Office of MoEF&CC.

During the meeting, it was found that the details submitted as well as presented by the project

proponent in view of the details sought by SEIAA is not satisfactory and hence it was decided to

consider the project only after submission of the following:

1. Justification for discrepancy in land area of the mall as per the Environmental Clearance granted &

mentioned for the proposed expansion & modification.

2. Certified compliance report from regional office Bhopal of MoEF&CC or Member Secretary Gujarat

Pollution Control Board for the conditions stipulated in the Environmental Clearance order dated

16/05/2007 granted by MoEF&CC.

3. Justification of parking area provision for the project after the proposed expansion & modification

and the adequacy of the same in view of the concerned bye-laws.

2. Gujarat housing board

S. No. 572, 573, 760/1, 760/2, 761/p, 756, 757, 759/p, Shanti Nagar, Tithal Road, Bhagdawada, Valsad

Appraisal

The Terms of Reference was granted to the project by MoEFCC vide letter dated 28/02/2018.

Timeline of events for the project in its chronological sequence are as under:

Activity/ Details Date

1st Application submitted at SEAC for TOR 01/10/2014

Terms of Reference was prescribed and granted by SEAC 16/12/2014

Rajachiththi from Bhagadawada Gram Panchayat 22/06/2015

Submission of EIA report to SEAC, Gujarat 13/06/2016

Appraisal presentation before SEAC 29/06/2016

2nd meeting with SEAC wherein it was suggested to approach MoEFCC for obtaining Environmental Clearance in view of the Notification dated 14/03/2017.

22/03/2017

Revised planning submitted to Nagar Niyojan, Valsad 27/03/2017

Application for EC was submitted to MoEF &CC as per the provision of Notification dated 14/03/2017 for violation cases.

14/04/2017

Terms of Reference was prescribed by EAC during its meeting. 22/06/2017

Terms of Reference was granted by MoEF & CC 28/02/2018

EIA report, along with TOR compliances, submitted to SEAC Gujarat for grant of EC

08/08/2018

Page 3 of 59


Page 3 of 59

Project proponent vide their online proposal no. SIA/GJ/NCP/28329/2018 dated 08/08/2018 submitted EIA report prepared by M/s Earthcare Enviro Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

Project proponent along with their experts / consultant attended the meeting of SEAC held on

04/09/2018. During the meeting held on 04/09/2018, it was found that Gujarat Pollution Control Board

has filed a criminal case against the violation of the project. Public Hearing is not application to the

project in view of the order dated 14/03/2018 of the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Madras in

WMP Nos.3361 & 3362 of 2018 and WMP No. 3721 of 2018 in WP No. 11189 of 2017. Construction

work was started after obtaining rajachiththi from Bhagwada Grampanchayat which was stopped in

March – 2017. 85% of the total construction activity is already completed. Wanki river is at 277 m

distance from the project site. Ecological damage assessment has been submitted with respect to the

environmental attributes like land, water, air, socio-economic, noise etc. The project proponent was

suggested to provide 2 staircases in buildings C1 to C6 having floor area more than 500 m2 on each

floor. At this the project proponent replied that as the travel distance to the staircase from the farthest

point of the floor is less than 30 m, they have provided 1 staircase in the buildings C1 to C6. The

project proponent was suggested to provide Sewage Treatment Plant for treatment & reuse of treated

sewage within premises and to install Organic Waste Convertor for converting organic waste into

useful end product. After detailed discussion, it was decided to consider the project only after

submission of the following:

1. Break up of total parking space - 20,190.46 m2 in terms of hollow plinth parking & open surface

parking. To the scale parking plan showing number & type of vehicles can be parked along with the

details of dimensions/space considered for parking the vehicles.

2. Proposal for providing STP for treatment of sewage to be generated during the operation phase.

Details of the Sewage Treatment Plant including its capacity, size of each unit, retention time, other

technical parameters etc. along with the plan & budget allocation for its installation, operation &

maintenance. Quality of treated sewage and application wise break-up of treated sewage quantity to

be recycled / reused in flushing & green belt development, its location on the layout plan, space

requirement in view of dimensions of the proposed STP as well as associated activities, STP sludge

management plan etc.

3. Revised water balance details considering the reuse of treated sewage for purposes like flushing,

gardening etc. within premises.

4. Proposal for segregation of solid waste to be generated during the operation phase and to install in

house Organic Waste Converter (OWC). Details of the OWC like its capacity, type, cost of

installation, operation & maintenance, end product management plan, its location on the layout plan,

space requirement in view of dimensions of the proposed OWC as well as associated activities etc.

should be submitted.

5. The Environment Management Plan comprising of the remediation plan and community & natural

resource augmentation plan corresponding to the ecological damage assessed and economic

benefits derived due to violation. The remediation plan and the natural & community resource

augmentation plan prepared shall be included as an independent chapter in the EIA report.

Page 4 of 59


Page 4 of 59

6. The proposals under violation shall pursue CER activities for the amount double than that arise from

the actual provision as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated

01/05/2018 and it shall be incorporated in the EIA report. Details of the activities to be carried out

under Corporate Environment Responsibility along with the details of basis considered for the

selection of the proposed activity/ies, fund allocation, time bound action plan etc.

7. The project proponent shall submit bank guarantee to Gujarat Pollution Control Board prior to grant

of environmental clearance equivalent to the amount of remediation plan and Natural & Community

augmentation plans as per the amount assessed in below mentioned table as per the indicative

guideline OR equivalent to the CER amount as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO

22-65/2017-IA-III dated 01/05/2018, whichever is higher. The amount shall be recommended by the

SEAC and finalized by the SEIAA. The bank guarantee shall be released after successful

implementation of the remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource Augmentation Plan,

and after recommendation by regional office of the Ministry followed by recommendations of the

SEAC and approval of the SEIAA.

8. Bank Guarantee shall be released only after

• Successful implementation of the remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource

Augmentation Plan, and after recommendation by regional office of the Ministry, State Level

Expert Appraisal Committee and approval of the SEIAA.

• Compliance of all the CER activities for the amount double than that arise from the actual

provision

9. Revised details on increased tree covered area & number of trees to be planted within premises.

Project proponent vide their letter dated 15/12/2018, submitted that total parking area of 20,190.46 m2

will be provided as open surface parking which is equivalent to 878 CPS. STP of 1,250 KL/day capacity

will be provided for treatment of sewage – 821.57 KL/day to be generated during the operation phase

as well as . Treated sewage will be reused for flushing (431.57 KL/day) & gardening (20.0 KL/day)

within premises. Onsite Organic Waste Convertor of 1200 kg/batch capacity will be provided for

treatment of biodegradable waste to be generated during the operation phase.

Detailed Ecological Damage Assessment with reference to the environmental attributes of Air, water,

solid & hazardous waste generation, noise & vibration, green belt, hydro-geology, associated risks &

hazards, soil etc. during the construction phase has been carried out. Total ecological damage

assessed amounts to Rs. 1,48,25,030.5 considering the recurring & non recurring cost during

construction phase and total 485 days of violation.

Remediation plan and Natural & Community Augmentation plan for an amount of Rs. 6.30 crores has

been submitted corresponding to the total ecological damage assessed.

Sr.No. Implementation of Remediation and Natural & Community Resource Augmentation plan

Year Cost in Rs. (in lacs)

1. Installation of STP with 5 year term operation & maintenance plan

4 months of STP construction & 5 years of O & M plan

621.0

Page 5 of 59


Page 5 of 59

2. Develop greenery on external road 1 year 5

3. Provided Toilet facility (sanitation blocks) to the Bhagadawada village primary school.

Done in the year 2016.

4

Total cost 630

It was presented that the Gujarat Housing Board (GHB) is constructing buildings for needy people

based on no profit intent. GHB has only one aim to provide good and healthy residents to needy people

with a minimum cost from beneficiaries. So, the proposed project itself is one kind of social

responsibility, which is being taken up by GHB. Further it was presented that the proposed STP of 1.25

ML/day capacity will be operated & maintained completely by GHB for 5 years and after that the STP

will be handed over to Valsad Nagarpalika for treating the sewage of the proposed project as well as

the surrounding areas and the treated sewage will be given to the surrounding areas to use it for

flushing & gardening. So it was requested to consider the proposal of providing STP along with its

operation & maintenance cost as Remediation plan and Natural & Community Augmentation plan,

which was agreed to by the SEAC.

Silent Features of the project:

Sr. No.

Particulars Details

1. Proposal is for Violation Project [SIA/GJ/NCP/28329/2018]

2. Type of Project Residential & Commercial

3. Project / Activity No. [8(a) or 8(b)]

8(a)

4. Name of the project

Affordable Housing Project by Gujarat Housing Board

5. Name of Developer

Gujarat Housing Board, Valsad

6. Estimated Project Cost (Rs. In Crores)

Rs. 314.31 Crore

7. Whether construction work has been initiated at site? If yes, details thereof

Yes

8. Site coordinates

72° 54' 32.52" E 20° 36' 09.85" N, 72° 54' 46.88" E 20° 36' 14.85" N, 72° 54' 47.15" E 20° 36' 11.20" N, 72° 54' 48.54" E 20° 36' 11.63" N, 72° 54' 49.66" E 20° 36' 10.60" N, 72° 54' 47.98" E 20° 36' 10.14" N, 72° 54' 47.81" E 20° 36' 07.46" N, 72° 54' 44.84" E 20° 36' 06.24" N, 72° 54' 43.71" E 20° 36' 05.66" N, 72° 54' 42.88" E 20° 36' 04.64" N, 72° 54' 40.40" E 20° 36' 03.50" N, 72° 54' 38.96" E 20° 36' 03.23" N, 72° 54' 37.51" E 20° 36' 05.86" N, 72° 54' 37.32" E 20° 36' 05.76" N

Page 6 of 59


Page 6 of 59

9. Project Details • Land / Plot Area (m2): 52,297.66

• FSI area (m2): 1,27,726.62

• Total BUA (m2): 1,47,676.95

Permissible Proposed

FSI Area (m2) 1,56,892.98 1,27,726.62

Ground Coverage (m2) 22,749.48 10,565.01

Common open plot -- 5,830.0

Max. building height (m) -- 44.10

10. Building Details

• No. of Buildings: 11

• No. of Blocks: 19

• Scope of buildings/blocks: 10 buildings (residential buildings): ground floor + 14 floors; 1 building (commercial building): ground floor + 2 floors.

• No. & size of Residential Units: 1,842 Nos. (118 Nos.: 4 BHK, 891 Nos.: 3 BHK, 833 Nos.: 2 BHK, )

• No. & type of Commercial Units: 80 Nos.

• Details of amenities if any: --

11. No. of expected residents / users

Expected residents: 9210 Expected shop users: 160 Expected visitors: 1400

12. Water & waste water details during construction phase

• Water requirement (KL/day): 65.75

• Source of water: Water tankers

• Waste water generation quantity (KL/day): 43.20

• Mode of disposal: In to septic tank & soak pit

• Details of reuse of water, if any: W/W generated from washing of equipment will be reused for curing after necessary treatment.

13. Water & waste water details during operation phase

• Total water requirement (KL/day): 959.20

• Fresh water requirement (KL/day): 451.57

• Source of water: Water supply from GWSSB


• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of Valsad Nagarpalika.

• In case of STP provision, capacity of STP: 1250 KL/day

• STP Technology: MBBR technology

• Purposes for treated sewage utilization: Flushing and gardening.

• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 20.0., 2. Flushing (KL/day): 431.57 [56.06 KL/day treatment loss]

• Provision of dual plumbing system (Yes/No): -Yes

• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of Valsad Nagarpalika.

• Mode of disposal: As above

• 821.57 KL/day to be generated during the operation phase as well as .

Page 7 of 59


Page 7 of 59

Treated sewage will be reused for flushing (431.57 KL/day) & gardening (20.0 KL/day) within premises.

14. Status of water supply and drainage line

Water supply from GWSSB and drainage connection of Valsad Nagarpalika will be available to the project during operation phase.

15. Solid waste Management

Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)

Quantity to be reused

(m3)

Mode of Disposal / Reuse

Top Soil 5,404.14 5,404.14 Reuse for developing garden area

Construction debris

2,370.0 1,129.0 m3 will be

reused as filler up to plinth level

1,241.0 m3 will be reused for outer road development

Steel scrap 90 --

Sold to local scrap vendors

Discarded packing materials

56 --

Sold to local vendors

Operation Phase:

Type of waste

Generation Quantity (Kg/day)

Mode of waste

collection


Dry waste

3,335.0 Blue colour bucket

Recyclable waste will be sold to vendors and remaining waste will be send to the nearby MSW collection point of concerned local body

Wet waste

2,223.0 Green colour bucket

Collection in separate bins and will be converted into manure by putting organic waste converter machine with in premises, manure will be reused within the premises and balanced quantity will be sold

STP Sludge

116 On SDB Collection, storage and reuse in garden area as manure within premises.

E waste 7.0 -- Sell to registered recyclers authorized by GPCB/CPCB.

Used oil 15 kg/year Drums Sell to registered recyclers authorized by GPCB/CPCB.

• Details of segregation if to be done: Separate bins will be provided to collect dry and wet waste.

Page 8 of 59


Page 8 of 59

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 4 m3

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority: Near by MSW Collection point.

16. Parking Details • Total parking area requirement for the project as per GDCR: 19,702.95 m2

• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 1,251.42 m2

• Parking area requirement for residential units as per GDCR: 18,451.53 m2

• Total Parking area provided as open surface parking (m2) & No. of CPS: 20,190.46 m2 & 878 CPS.

17. Traffic Management

• Width of adjacent public roads: 18.0 m

• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 4 gates for residential buildings & 2 gates for commercial buildings.

• Width of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 9.0. m & 6 m

• Minimum width of open path all around the buildings for easy access of fire tender (excluding the width for the plantation): 6.0 m

• Width of all internal roads: 6.0 m, 7.50 m, 9.0 m

18. Details of Green Building measures proposed.

Use of fly ash based material, flush tank instead of direct flushing in toilets, foam type aerated coke, rain water harvesting, use of LED lights for common areas, solar lights for landscape lighting, reflective/ white tiles in common areas, maximum use of natural light, provision of STP & reuse of treated sewage etc.

19. Energy Requirement, Source and Conservation

• Power supply: Maximum demand: 4400 KW Connected load: Source: DGVCL

• Energy conservation measures: use of LED lights in common buildings areas, solar street lights, reflective white tiles at terrace floor etc.

• DG Sets No. and capacity of the DG sets: 2 x 160 KVA Fuel & its quantity: Low Sulphur High speed Diesel (HSD) & Quantity – 15 L/hr

20. Fire and Life Safety Measures

Fire extinguishers at each floor, hose reel at each floor, manually operated electric fire alarm system, underground static fire water storage tanks of 100 KL capacity for residential , terrace tank of 20 KL capacity for residential & 25 KL for commercial, one electric & one diesel pump of capacity 1620 L/min for underground tank. & one electric pump of capacity 180 L/min & having pressure 3.5 kg/cm2 at terrace level.

21. Details on staircase

Bldg. No.

No. of floor

Max. floor area (m2)

No. of staircase

Width of Staircase (m)

Maximum travel distance up to the staircase

A1,A2 G+14 423.13 1 in each

block 3.36 15.2

B1, B2, B3

G+14 344.78 1 in each

block 2.83 12.0

C1 to C6 G+14 602.41 1 in each 2.23 12.0

Page 9 of 59


Page 9 of 59

block

D1 to D6, D9

G+14 413.66 1 in each

block 2.23 15.4

Shopping block

G+2 854.37 2 2.02 20.0

22. Rain Water Harvesting (RWH)

• Level of the Ground water table: 12.0 m

• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s) : 26 no. of RWH tanks; size: 4m x 3m x 3m Size of Bore: 350 mm dia.

Size of pipe: 150 mm dia.

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 26 nos. of percolating well.

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities: A de-silting chamber will be provided to de-silt and remove floating material through bar screen

23. Green area details

• Tree covered area (m2): 3,905.57

• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2): --

• Lawn covered area (m2): 5,830.0

• Total Green Area (m2): 9,735.57

• Green Area % of plot area: 16.0 %

• No. of trees and species to be planted: 650 trees of Asopalav, Neem tree, Coconut Palm tree, Gulmohar etc.

24.

Budgetary allocation for Environmental Management Plan (Rs. in lacs)

Capital cost of Rs. 170.5 lacs and recurring cost of Rs. 7.0 lacs has been allocated towards purposes like rain water harvesting & ground water recharge, greenbelt development, environment monitoring & management, waste management etc.

25. Dust control measures

Water sprinkling, covered shed for cement unloading activity, tarpaulin cover on excavated earth & construction material etc.

26. Use of Eco-friendly building materials.

Use of fly ash bricks & aerated blocks for water partition, paving blocks for parking areas & walk ways, Portland Pozzolona Cement for RCC structure, plaster & flooring etc.

27. Details on amenities to be provided to construction worker

Drinking water & tap water, sanitation facilities, domestic waste water collection facility, lunch space, first aid box, free medicines, doctor service, PPEs etc.

28. Documents related to land possession

Land is in the name of applicant, copy has been submitted.

29. Details of EIA report

• EIA report prepared by: M/s Earthcare Enviro Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

• Study period: February 2016 to April 2016.

• Study area: 10 km radial area from the boundary of the project site.

• Environmental attributes considered for EIA study: Air, water (surface

& ground water), noise, soil environment, biological environment,

socio-economic status etc.

• Observations: Baseline ambient air quality in terms of PM10, PM2.5,

Page 10 of 59


Page 10 of 59

During the meeting, after detailed discussion it was decided to consider the project only after submission of the following:

1. Remediation plan and community & natural resource augmentation plan corresponding to the

ecological damage assessed and economic benefits derived due to violation. The remediation plan

and community & natural resource augmentation plan shall comprise the location specific activities

to be carried out and activity wise time bound action plan. The project proponent shall submit bank

guarantee to Gujarat Pollution Control Board prior to grant of environmental clearance equivalent

to the amount of remediation plan and Natural & Community augmentation plans as per the

amount assessed OR equivalent to the CER amount as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum

No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated 01/05/2018, whichever is higher.

2. The proposals under violation shall pursue CER activities for the amount double than that arise

from the actual provision as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III

dated 01/05/2018 and it shall be incorporated in the EIA report. Details of the activities to be

carried out under Corporate Environment Responsibility along with the details of basis considered

for the selection of the proposed activity/ies, fund allocation, time bound action plan etc.

SOx, NOx and CO was well within the NAAQM standards.

3 Iscon Commercial Complex

Sr. No. 25, 27/B/1, 31, 38, Final T.P.S. No. 18, Sarangpur F.P. No. 32/Paikee, Raj- Hirpur, Maninagar, Ahmedabad

Appraisal

The Terms of Reference was granted to the project by MoEFCC vide order dated 20/06/2018.

Timeline of events for the project in its chronological sequence are as under:

Activity/ Details Date

Purchase of closed mill land in an auction by Hon’ble High Court of Gujarat (Gross Plot area: 13,895 sq. m.)

17/12/2013

Possession of land 03/11/2015

Land release by AMC (Plot area: 8764.20 sq. m. from total 13,895 m2 land area) Land kept in abeyance by AMC (1,152.53 Sq.m.)

29/03/2016

Approval of drawings & Commencement letter from Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation for built up area of 33,288.54 m2

08/06/2016

Commencement of Construction as per AMC approval for built up area of 33,288.54 m2

July-2016

Construction crossed beyond 20,000 m2. April, 2017

Application for obtaining Environmental clearance to MoEF (considering violation) for revised building plans (G+6 structure of 6 Blocks)

10/05/2017

Opinion of AMC for release of additional land of 347.0 m2 01/12/2017

Preparation of revised plans based on revised plot area Oct.-Nov. 2017

Receipt of letter for release of additional land of 347 m2 by AMC 28/12/2017

Terms of Reference was prescribed by EAC during its meeting. 19-21/02/2018

Terms of Reference was granted by MoEF & CC 20/06/2018

Page 11 of 59


Page 11 of 59

Site visit by GPCB 12/07/2018

Criminal case filed by GPCB under Section 15 & 19 of The EPA,1986 (Case no. 75428/2018)

14/08/2018

First hearing in the court: Vakalatnama has been submitted by the developer in the court. Next hearing will be held on 08/12/2018

11/10/2018

EIA report, along with TOR compliances, submitted to SEAC Gujarat for grant of EC

20/09/2018

Project proponent vide their online proposal no. SIA/GJ/NCP/28761/2017 dated 20/09/2018 submitted EIA report prepared by M/s Envisafe Environment Consultants, Ahmedabad.

Project proponent along with their experts / consultant attended the meeting of SEAC held on

29/10/2018. During the meeting held on 29/10/2018, it was presented that the construction of

24,033.53 m2 was complete at the time of applying for obtaining Environmental Clearance to MoEFCC

and any kind of construction activity has not been carried out after applying for obtaining Environmental

Clearance to MoEFCC. Construction activity was started during July – 2016. The project proponent has

obtained construction permission for built up area of 33,288.54 m2. Terms of Reference was

prescribed for built area of 43,695.51 m2 and & plot area of 8,764.20 m2 of the project. Project

proponent has submitted EIA report and revised Form – I & IA for built area of 46,179.66 m2 and & plot

area of 9,111.20 m2 of the project. Ecological damage assessed with respect to the aspects like hydro-

geology, water, air, noise & vibrations, greenbelt, occupational health & safety, land, socio-economic

etc. was deliberated during the meeting. After detailed discussion, it was decided to appraise the

project further only after submission of the following:

1. Project plans approved by concerned authority and a copy of permission (Rajachiththi) obtained

from the concerned authority for built up area of 33,288.54 m2.

2. Revised details with increased parking area provision for the project along with the back up

calculation & parking plans.

3. Full size project plan showing building wise & floor wise built up area, FSI area, floor area tables,

number of units & plot area statement, location of buildings, main approach roads, D.G.sets,

uninterrupted open peripheral margin, open surface parking, green belt (tree covered area),

common plot, location of percolation wells, STP, OWC etc. with different colour codes.

4. Justification for increase in built up area from 43,695.51 m2 to 46,179.66 m2.

5. Proposal for segregation of solid waste to be generated during the operation phase and to install in

house Organic Waste Converter (OWC). Details of the OWC like its capacity, type, cost of

installation, operation & maintenance, end product management plan, its location on the layout plan,

space requirement in view of dimensions of the proposed OWC as well as associated activities etc.

should be submitted.

6. Ecological damage assessment with respect to project & location specific environment attributes

along with the basis considered for calculating the cost of the ecological damage. The Environment

Management Plan comprising of the remediation plan and community & natural resource

augmentation plan corresponding to the ecological damage assessed, economic benefits derived

Page 12 of 59


Page 12 of 59

due to violation and the socio-economic aspects in the study area. The remediation plan and

community & natural resource augmentation plan shall comprise the location specific activities to be

carried out and activity wise time bound action plan

7. The project proponent shall submit bank guarantee to Gujarat Pollution Control Board prior to grant

of environmental clearance equivalent to the amount of remediation plan and Natural & Community

augmentation plans as per the amount assessed OR equivalent to the CER amount as per the

MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated 01/05/2018, whichever is

higher. The amount shall be recommended by the SEAC and finalized by the SEIAA. The bank

guarantee shall be released after successful implementation of the remediation plan and Natural

and Community Resource Augmentation Plan, and after recommendation by regional office of the

Ministry followed by recommendations of the SEAC and approval of the SEIAA.

8. The proposals under violation shall pursue CER activities for the amount double than that arise from

the actual provision as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated

01/05/2018 and it shall be incorporated in the EIA report. Details of the activities to be carried out

under Corporate Environment Responsibility along with the details of basis considered for the

selection of the proposed activity/ies, fund allocation, time bound action plan etc.

9. Bank Guarantee shall be released only after

• Successful implementation of the remediation plan and Natural and Community Resource

Augmentation Plan, and after recommendation by regional office of the Ministry, State Level

Expert Appraisal Committee and approval of the SEIAA.

• Compliance of all the CER activities for the amount double than that arise from the actual

provision.

Project proponent vide their letter dated 05/12/2018, submitted copies of permission (Rajachiththi) and

project plans approved Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation for built up area of 33,288.54 m2 [19,855.85

m2 + 4,293.98 m2 + 4,088.46 m2 + 1,145.16 m2 + 3,800.02 m2 + 105.07 m2]. Total parking area

provision will be 17,769.99 m2 [6,025.72 m2 in 1st basement + 7,141.44 m2 in 2nd basement + 3840.0 m2

as mechanical parking in 2nd basement + 2,952.83 m2 at ground floor] which is equivalent to 659 CPS.

It is mentioned that after making an application for TOR to MoEF& CC on 10/05/2017, the additional

land of 347 m2 was released by AMC in December, 2017. Hence plot area has been increased from

8,467.20 m2 to 9,111.20 m2 in accordance to change in plot area, the plans have been modified and

the built area has been revised from 43,695.51 m2 to 46,179.66 m2. Copy of permission obtained from

Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation for release of 347.0 m2 land area is submitted. At the time of

submission of EIA report, the architectural drawings were taken into consideration. During the

preparation of plan / drawings for passing, it has been revised and decreased. Hence the total built up

area for the project will be 46,024.75 m2 and FSI area will be 27,105.51 m2. Revised project plan is

submitted for built up area of 46,024.75 m2 and FSI of 27,105.51 m2. It is mentioned that the project will

be exclusive for shops and offices and there will not be any establishment such as restaurant, food

court or canteen which generates organic / biodegradable waste. Hence considering the fact that only

source of compostable waste is horticulture waste which is only about 2 Kg/day, organic waste

convertor is not proposed to install.

Page 13 of 59


Page 13 of 59

Detailed Ecological Damage Assessment with reference to the environmental attributes of Air, water,

solid & hazardous waste generation, noise & vibration, green belt, hydro-geology, associated risks &

hazards, soil etc. during the construction phase has been carried out. Total ecological damage

assessed amounts to Rs. 2,90,57,800 considering the recurring & non recurring cost during

construction phase of the brown field project and total 303 days of violation.

Natural & Community Resource Augmentation plan for an amount of Rs.2,90,57,800 has been

submitted corresponding to the total ecological damage assessed as well as economic benefit derived

due to violation.

Sr.

No. FILED/ ACTIVITY

Villages /

Area

Env.

Attribute

Cost in

INR

A NATURAL RESOURCE AUGMENTATION PLANT

1. Rain water harvesting structures Navagram &/or

Odhav &/or Jethipura

&/or

Ratanpur

HG 9,00,000

2. Provision of Solar panel in common

areas

Ratanpur

&/or

Jethipura

SE

(Others)

5,00,000

3. Development of avenue plantation Umdedpura

&/or

Dekavada

&/or

Shobhasan

&/or

Navagram

SC 10,00,000

Total of A 24,00,000

B COMMUNITY RESOURCE AUGMENTATION PLAN

B-1 Infrastructure Development Work

1. Development or strengthening of

Water supply network in nearby

village

Mota Karanpura

&/or

Nana Karanpura

&/or

Detroj

HG & SE

(Water &

Sanitation) 12,50,000

2. Installation of RO Plant for safe

drinking water supply in Corporation

School.

Corporation schools in

Ahmedbad city limit

WP & SE

(Water &

Sanitation)

5,20,000

3. Repairing or development of Roads or

approach roads to highways

Detroj

&/or

Nana Karanpura

AP, NV

1,50,000

4. Provision of dustbin at various public

places like school

Corporation schools in

Ahmedbad city limit

SC & SE

(Others) 5,00,000

Page 14 of 59


Page 14 of 59

5. Construction of public toilets Hathipura

&/or

Bhagapura

&/or

Kanz

15,00,000

6. Provision of organic waste converters

/ organic manure to farmers for

organic farming and awareness

campaign

Shihor

&/or

Nana Karanpura

&/or

Kanz

10,00,000

7. Development/ promotion of drip

irrigation methodology to surrounding

village farmers

Moti Kumad

&/or

Nani Kumad

&/or

Vasna (Chhaniyar)

&/or

Dediyasan

SE (Water

&

Sanitation)

34,00,000

8. Awareness program for Kuposhan

Nivaran (healthy child)

Mandal (sub district)

SE (Health

&

Nutrition)

3,87,800

9. Periodical arrangement of Health

check-ups: specialized checkups for

different medical specialty, like eyes,

skin, dental etc.

Detroj- Rampura (sub

district)

15,00,000

10. Procurement of Medicines &

Healthcare Supplies for Govt.

hospitals

Limbadi

&/or

Vanathal

&/or

Dediyasan

25,00,000

11. Sponsoring “Driver Safety Devices” to

avoid accidents

Mandal (sub district)

&/or

Detroj Rampura (sub

district)

SE

(Others)

5,00,000

TOTAL of B1 1,32,07,800

B-2 Soft Skill Development Work

1. Internship to local

graduate/undergraduate students for

limited period

Viramgam

&/or

Sanand

&/or

Zolapur

SE

(Education

)

20,00,000

2. Promoting girl child education through

scholarship in corporation schools

Dodar &/or

Iyava &/or Vasna-

Iyava &/or Khoraj &/or

20,00,000

Page 15 of 59


Page 15 of 59

Goraj

3. Imparting entrepreneurship

development training to local people

Viramgam

&/or

Sanand

&/or

Goraj

10,00,000

4. Upgrade school library in Municipal

corporation schools in vicinity

Sanand &/or

Zolapur &/or Goraj 11,00,000

5. Provision of uniform, notebooks, study

materials, computers for students and

maintenance of school building.

Moti Devti &/or Nani

Devti &/or Modasar

&/or Rethal 15,00,000

6. Reducing the drop out of students &

absenteeism through counseling &

other means.

Sanand town

2,50,000

7. Sponsoring orphan/needy boys/girls

for total education expenditure

Telav &/or Khodiyar &

Ghuma 10,00,000

8. Awareness programme for reduction

of plastic waste reduction

Daskroi (sub district)

SE

(Others)

5,00,000

10. Organize skill development program

for sustainable income generation &

livelihood for the community like

training on scientific agricultural

practices, tailoring, embroidery, etc.

Daskroi (sub district)

&/or Mandal (sub

district) &/or Detroj-

Rampura (sub district) 25,00,000

11. Organize awareness campaign for

Swachh Bharat Abhiyan, Beti Bachao,

Beti Padhao and Women

Empowerment.

6,00,000

12. Technical support to local farmers to

enhance the productivity of crop

Bakrol &/or Geratpur

&/or Modasar 10,00,000

Total of B2 1,43,50,000

Grand total (A+B1+B2) 2,90,57,800

It is proposed to allocate fund of Rs. 4.23 crores (i.e amount double than that arise from the actual

provision as per the MOEF&CC’s office Memorandum No: F NO 22-65/2017-IA-III dated 01/05/2018 in

case of brown field project) as under:

Area / Field CER Budgetary provision, INR

Page 16 of 59


Page 16 of 59

Regular Violation Total

(A) (B) (C) (D)

A. Education & skill development 42,30,000 42,30,000 84,60,000

B. Health 31,72,500 31,72,500 63,45,000

C. Water & sanitation 52,87,500 52,87,500 1,05,75,000

D. Infrastructure development 52,87,500 52,87,500 1,05,75,000

E. Other social welfare activities 31,72,500 31,72,500 63,45,000

Total 2,11,50,000 2,11,50,000 4,23,00,000

Details of activities to be carried out under the above A. to E. head has been submitted by the project

proponent.

Salient features of the project:

Sr. No.

Particulars Details

1. Proposal is for Violation Project [SIA/GJ/NCP/28761/2017]

2. Type of Project Commercial Project


8(a)


Iscon Commercial Complex


M/s. Iscon City Center LLP

6. Estimated Project Cost (Rs.In Crore)

Rs. 282 Crores


Yes, 55% of the construction work is completed while 45% of the work is remaining.

8. Site coordinates 720 36’ 05.94” E 230 00’ 57.89” N


• FSI area (m2): 27,105.51

• Total BUA (m2): 46,024.75


FSI Area (m2) 27,305.59 27,000.42

Ground Coverage (m2) -- 4,336.48

Common open plot 911.12 923.64

Max. building height (m) -- 23.54

10. Building Details • No. of Buildings: 4


• Scope of buildings/blocks: 2 level basement + ground floor + 6 floors

• No. & size of Residential Units: --

• No. & type of Commercial Units: 623 shops


11. No. of expected Fixed: 1,365 Nos.

Page 17 of 59


Page 17 of 59

residents / users Floating: 2,275 Nos. (Visitors) Total:3,641 Nos.



• Source of water: Water supply from Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation


• Mode of disposal: Septic tank & soak pit




• Source of water: Water supply from Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation

• Waste water generation quantity (KL/day): 44 .0

• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AMC.




• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1.Gardening (KL/day): 2 2. Flushing (KL/day): 68.0

• Provision of dual plumbing system (Yes/No): Yes

• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of water to be discharged: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AMC.

• Mode of disposal: as above.


Both drainage and water supply lines are available at site.


Operation Phase:

Type of waste


Mode of waste collection


Dry waste (Recyclable)

187.0 Into bins to be provided within premises.

Organic waste and Recyclable waste will be sold to vendors and the remaining waste will be collected by AMC.

Dry waste (Non- recyclable)

125.0

• Details of segregation if to be done: The solid wastes generated will be segregated into biodegradable and non-biodegradable wastes and collected in separate bins.

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises:

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local

Page 18 of 59


Page 18 of 59

authority: Final disposal at AMC landfill site

16. Parking Details • Total parking area requirement for the project as per GDCR: 13,500.21 m²

• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 13,500.21 m²

• Total Parking area provided (m²) & No. of CPS: 17,769.99 m2 [6,025.72 m2 in 1st basement + 7,141.44 m2 in 2nd basement + 3,840.0 m2 as mechanical parking in 2nd basement + 2,952.83 m2 at ground floor] which is equivalent to 659 CPS.


• Width of adjacent public roads: 18 m, 15 m

• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: One gate will be provided

• Width of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s:

• Minimum width of open path all around the buildings for easy access of fire tender (excluding the width for the plantation): 5 m

• Width of all internal roads: 5.25 m & 11.28 m


Incorporate solar passive techniques in a building design and

enhanced building material specifications to minimize load on

conventional systems, use of efficient lamps, luminaries & control

devices, time switches for automatic switching off common lighting of

buildings and street lights, use of transformers and motors having

minimum efficiency of 85%, use of light colors for the walls and

ceiling to reduced the UV absorption and minimize the associated

cooling requirement, use of building materials, having lower U-value

and the insulating material having higher R-value for optimum energy

performance, energy auditing of the buildings, rain water harvesting

& ground water recharge through 3 nos. of percolation wells,

provision of STP & reuse of treated sewage for gardening purpose

etc.


• Power supply:

Maximum demand: 1500 KW

Connected load:

--Source: Torrent Power Ltd.

• Energy saving measures: Incorporate solar passive techniques in a

building design and enhanced building material specifications to

minimize load on conventional systems, use of efficient lamps,

luminaries & control devices, time switches for automatic switching

off common lighting of buildings and street lights, use of

transformers and motors having minimum efficiency of 85%, use of

light colors for the walls and ceiling to reduced the UV absorption

and minimize the associated cooling requirement, use of building

materials, having lower U-value and the insulating material having

higher R-value for optimum energy performance, energy auditing of

the buildings,

Page 19 of 59


Page 19 of 59

• DG Sets:

No. and capacity of the DG sets:1 x 500 KVA

Fuel & its quantity: Diesel @ 60 L/Hr


• During the operation phase: Underground fire water tank with

storage capacity of 50 KL, overhead fire water tanks, automatic

sprinkler system will be provided @ one no. per 12 m2 of floor area

in all basements, fire indication panel at ground level, fire alarm

system, external fire hydrant system with direct connection with

water mains by min. 4” diameter, hose pipe & fire extinguishers

(CO2 type – 4.5 kg & DCP type – 5 kg) on each floor of the building,

yard hydrant system, one wet riser in the building which will be

extended from the basement to the terrace floor, hose box near

each internal hydrant,

• The nearest fire station from the project site is Odhav fire station; it

will take 10-15 minutes travel time in case of emergency.

• During the construction phase: Safety Measures for the

Construction Workers: Provision of PPEs like helmets, safety

shoes, hand gloves, goggles, clothing, etc. ear muffs & ear plugs

for the workers engaged at and around high noise generating

sources, first aid emergency kit at various locations, all the other

provisions will be made for the workers as per Gujarat building &

other construction workers rules etc.

21. Details on staircase (In each block)

Type & no.

of buildings

No. of

floors

Floor area

(m2)

No. of

staircase

Width of the

staircase (m)

Travel distance

(m)

Block A 2B+G+6 970.63 3 1.83 < 25

Block B 2B+G+6 924.90 3 1.83 < 25

Block C 2B+G+6 1,174.21 2 1.83 < 25

Block D 2B+G+6 840.16 2 1.83 < 25


• Level of the Ground water table:18 to 20m

• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s): 1

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 3 Nos.& depth upto ground 2nd

Aquifer (60 m)

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities: Catch-pit (2.0m x 2.0m x

2.5m)&Course Sand Gravel filtration

23. Green area details • Tree covered area (m2):

• Lawn covered area (m2):

• Total Green Area (m2): 548.96

Page 20 of 59


Page 20 of 59

During the meeting, after detailed discussion, it was decided to consider the project only after


1. Justification for basis considered for arriving at the amount proposed to allocate towards


• No. of trees and species to be planted: 137

24.


Capital Cost :62.5 Lacs Recurring Cost Per Annum:71.1 Lacs

25. Proposed dust control measures during the construction phase

Water sprinkling, provision of barricades of steel sheet/tin sheet of

3.0 – 5.0 m height, covered storage for construction materials,

covering the construction material with plastic cover sheet during

transportation, proper maintenance of the machines to prevent air

pollution etc.

26. Eco friendly building material usage details.

• Use of earth blocks, fly ash and Fal-G (fly ash, lime and gypsum) as

alternative materials for construction of wall in-place of clay bricks

with cement mortar where as applicable. Various eco friendly

building materials proposed to use in the proposed project are

shown below;

• Flay ash cement (PPC) for flooring and masonry work: 1100 MT

• Fly ash bricks for masonry work: as maximum as possible

• Pavers block for internal roads of the building facilities.

27. Details on Corporate Environment Responsibility (Rs in Lacks)

Rs. 4.23 Crores.

28. Details of amenities to be provided to construction workers.

Drinking water, sanitation facilities, PPEs, first aid facilities, welfare

facilities as per the Gujarat Building & Other Construction Workers

Rules.

29. Documents related to land possession.

Copy of village from no. 7 submitted shows that the land of F.P.No.32/1 of T.P.Scheme no. 18 is in the name of Iscon City Centre LLP.

30. Details of EIA report

• EIA report prepared by: Envisafe Environment Consultant

• Study period: May 2018- July 2018

• Study area: 10 Km

• Environmental attributes considered for EIA study: Air, water

(surface & ground water), noise, soil environment, biological

environment, socio-economic status etc.

• Observations: Baseline ambient air quality in terms of PM10, PM2.5, SOx, NOx and CO was well within the NAAQM standards.

Page 21 of 59


Page 21 of 59

the activities to be carried out under Corporate Environment Responsibility and thereby the

amount proposed for Natural & Community Resource Augmentation plan.

4. Aaryan City

Survey No. 216, 218, F.P. No. 39/1 + 43, O.P. No. 39/1 + 43, T.P.S. No. 33, Gota, Daskroi, Ahmedabad

Screening/ scoping & appraisal

During the meeting the project proponent along with their expert/consultant attended the meeting. It

was presented that they have started construction work for the 19,988.11 m2 built-up area of stated

project based on Commencement (Rajachitthi) Letter granted by the Ahmedabad Municipal

Corporation (AMC) on 09/04/2013. Construction work for the stated part of the project has been

already completed and Building Usage (BU) permission has also been granted by the AMC on

04/05/2015. Subsequently, they have planned to expand the project within the existing plot area of

14,357 m2 and total proposed built-up area of the project after expansion is 58,971.31 m2 [i.e.

19,988.11 m2 + 38,983.20 m2]. Considering that the project having total built up area of 58,971.31 m2

requires Environmental Clearance as per the provisions of EIA Notificaiton – 2006, they have

submitted application for obtaining Environmental Clearance for the entire project (i.e. 58,971.31 m2

built-up area) to the SEAC, Gujarat on 11/06/2015. Based on their application as well as site visit made

by the GPCB on 04/12/2015, the SEAC, Gujarat considered the case as a violation case under EIA

Notification, 2006 and subsequently the project was delisted by the SEIAA, Gujarat on 17/04/2017

based on the recommendation made by the SEAC on 15/04/2017. The project proponent, vide letter

dated 24/04/2017 from SEIAA, was suggested to approach MoEF&CC, New Delhi for obtaining EC for

the project under the provisions of S.O. 804(E) dated 14/03/2017. They made application to the

MoEF&CC on 12/05/2017 which was accepted on 09/02/2018 and the project was considered in the 4th

EAC meeting held on 20/02/2018. During the meeting held on 20/02/2018, the Expert Appraisal

Committee (EAC), New Delhi gave an opinion that the proposal is normal regular case for expansion

project as the previous construction was not attracting EC as per the provisions of the EIA Notification,

2006. It is also recommended that SEIAA can take this case for appraisal as a normal regular

expansion proposal and accordingly the case is returned to the SEIAA for further necessary action as

per the provisions of the EIA Notification, 2006. Now as per the directions given by the EAC, the project

proponent has submitted the application for obtaining Environmental Clearance to SEIAA Gujarat.

It was presented that no construction activity has been started for proposed expansion. 40% of the total

land area has been utilized in existing constructed area of 19,988.0 m2.

Details of the proposed project as presented before the committee are described below:

Sr. No

Particulars Details

1. Proposal is for New Project [SIA/GJ/NCP/82981/2018]

2. Type of Project Residential & commercial


8(a)


Aaryan City

Page 22 of 59


Page 22 of 59


M/s. Aaryan Infrabuild


Rs. 86 Crore [Rs. 30 Cr- Existing Building + Rs. 56 Cr.- Proposed Building]


Yes, Construction work for the 19,988.11 m2 built-up area (i.e. for phase-1/existing) has already been completed.

8. Site Coordinates 720 33’ 03.58” E 230 05’ 48.25” N


• FSI area (m2): 36,734.33

• Total BUA (m2): 57,816.79


FSI Area (m2) 38,758.50 36,734.33


Common Plot Area (m2) 1,435.70 1,874.84

Max. building height (m) 57.537 44.08



• Scope of buildings/blocks: Existing: basement + ground floor + 10

floors; Proposed: Basement + hollow plinth + 14 floors

• No. & size of Residential Units: 370 Flats

• No. & type of Commercial Units: 35 Shops



• Fixed users considered for the project :- 1,955 Persons

• Floating users considered for the project: 1,530 Persons/day



• Source of water: Local water tanker suppliers


• Mode of disposal: Septic tank & soak pit system

• Details of reuse of water, if any: --




• Source of water: Water supply from Ahmedabad Municipal

Corporation (AMC)


• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the

proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening &

Page 23 of 59


Page 23 of 59

flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated

sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AMC



• Purposes for treated sewage utilization: Gardening and flushing

• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 7.0 2. Flushing (KL/day): 47.0


• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AMC.

• Mode of disposal: As above


Available at site


Construction Phase:

Generation

(m3)

Quantity to be

reused (m3)

Mode of Disposal /

Reuse

Top Soil 6,020.0 6,020.0 Development of

greenbelt & levelling

of low lying areas

Other

excavated

earth

24,100.0 24,100.0 Levelling of low lying

areas at proposed site

itself.

Construction

debris

608.0 608.0 Levelling roads,

pavements, plot filling,

plinth filling etc.

Steel scrap Whatsoever - - To be sold to scarp

dealer.

Discarded

packing

materials

Whatsoever - - To be sold to

authorized vendor.

Operation Phase:

Type of

waste

Generation

Quantity

(Kg/day)

Mode of

waste

collection

Mode of Disposal/ Reuse

Dry waste

1,056

Into bins The recyclable waste will be sold off .The organic waste to be generated will be treated in onsite waste to compost machine and compost will be used in gardening. Other

Wet

waste

Page 24 of 59


Page 24 of 59

garbage will be finally disposed through AMC.

• Details of segregation if to be done: Collection of wet and dry waste

will be in different buckets.

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 47

nos. of bins of 80 Litre capacity

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority:

Final disposal at the MSW dumping / landfill site by AMC

16. Parking Details • Total parking area requirement for the project as per GDCR: 7,674.49

m2

• Parking area requirement for residential units as per GDCR: 7,128.46

m2

• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 546.03

m2

• Total Parking area provided (m2) & No. of CPS: 12,843.89 m2 & 444

CPS

• Parking area provided in basement (m2) & No. of CPS: 7,868.20 m2 &

246 CPS

• Parking area provided in hollow plinth (m2) & No. of CPS: 2,225.16 m2

& 79 CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface including common plot (m2) &

No. of CPS: 2,750.53 m2 & 119 CPS


• Width of adjacent public roads: 12 m, 24 m, 30 m

• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 1 gate will be

provided

• Width of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 7.50 m

• Minimum width of open path all around the buildings for easy access

of fire tender (excluding the width for the plantation): 6.0 m

• Width of all internal roads: 7.50 m


Low-flow plumbing fixtures, twin flushing system in toilets, water meter

in individual unit, rain water harvesting through percolation well within

the project site, maximum use of Ready Mix Concrete (RMC),

maximum use of Portland Pozzolona Cement (PPC), fly ash paver

blocks for pavements/walkways, AAC blocks/ Fly ash bricks will be

used for masonry work, most of the carpentry structures using

processed engineering wood, aluminum window frame & marble door

frame will be used instead of wood etc.


• Power supply:

Maximum demand: 2 MW during Operation Phase

Source: M/s. Torrent Power Ltd. (Ahmedabad)

Energy saving measures: Maximum use of LED & CFL lights, use of

Page 25 of 59


Page 25 of 59

solar lighting in common area, maximize the use of light colors in the

building exterior walls etc.

• DG Sets:

No. and capacity of the DG sets: 1 x 125 KVA

Fuel & its quantity: Diesel


• Nearest fire station is Sabarmati fire station, approx. 4.2km away.

Time required for the fire tender to reach at the project site is 10-15

minutes.

• During the construction phase: Fire extinguishers at appropriate

locations, personal protective equipments like earplugs, dust masks,

safety shoes, helmets, hand gloves, etc. will be provided to all

workers, all workers will be trained to use welding shields and follow

safer practice, provision of first aid facilities & related training to the

construction workers, maintaining hoists and lifts, lifting machines,

chains, ropes, and other lifting tackles in good condition, scaffolds &

ladders made of mild steel will be used, all electrical fittings /

equipments used will meet the relevant IS standards etc.

• During the operation phase: Fire extinguishers of CO2 type and DCP

type on each floor, automatic sprinkler system, hose reels and wet

rises, manually operated electric fire alarm system & automatic

sprinkler system, one no. of underground fire water storage tank

having capacity of 75 KL, terrace tank having capacity of 20 KL etc.

21. Details on staircase:

Block No. of Floors in each building

Max. Floor Area (m2)

No. of Staircase

Width of the Staircase (m)

Travel Distance (m)

A + B B+G+10 628.27 2 1.52 15.80

C + D B+G+10 809.45 2 1.52 16.50

E + F B+HP+14 771.17 2 2.0 15.0

G + H B+HP+14 753.81 2 2.0 14.60

22. Rain Water Harvesting

(RWH)

• Level of the Ground water table: - -

• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s) : - -

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 4 Nos. &60 m depth

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities : Catch pit with filtration

media, strainer with gravel packing

23. Green area details • Tree covered area (m2) : 868.0

• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2): 350.0

• Lawn covered area (m2): 587.0

• Total Green Area (m2): 1,805.0

• Green area % of plot area: 12.5 %

• No. of trees and species to be planted: 240 nos. Asopalav,

Gulmohar, Neem, Kadam, Bamboo, Saptaparni, Badam,

Page 26 of 59


Page 26 of 59

Karen

24. Budgetary allocation for

Environmental

Management Plan

(Rs. in lacs)

Total Rs. 50 Lakhs has been allocated towards Environmental

Management Plan specifically for purposes like rain water

harvesting & ground water recharge, water & energy

conservation, greenbelt development and domestic waste

management, STP & OWC etc.

25. Proposed dust control

measures during the

construction phase

Regular water sprinkling, temporary windshield barriers,

tarpaulin sheet cover on the material during the transportation,

maximum use of Ready Mix Concrete (RMC), uniform piling of

sand/excavated earth and proper storage of them to avoid

dusting.

26. Eco friendly building

material usage details.

Maximum use of Ready Mix Concrete (RMC), Fly ash paver

blocks for pavements/walkways, AAC blocks/ Fly ash bricks will

be used for masonry work, Most of the carpentry structures

using processed engineering wood, maximum use of Portland

Pozzolona Cement (PPC), Aluminum window frame & marble

door frame will be used instead of wood etc.

27. Details on Corporate

Environment

Responsibility (Rs. In

Lacks)

Fund of Rs. 56 lacs will be allocated for activities like providing

education & health, sanitation facility, training & skill

development, canal protection work etc.

28. Basic amenities to be provided to construction workers.

Necessary sanitation facilities, safe drinking water, municipal

solid waste collection facility, regular spraying of anti-mosquito

fumes etc.

29. Documents related to land possession.

Copies of village form no. 7 & 12 submitted by them shows that

NA land [9,714.0 m2 + 4,641.0 m2] is in the name of M/s. Aaryan

Infrabuild through it’s partner Mr. Manoj R. Patel.

During the meeting, it was found that the project proponent has submitted a copies of permission

(Rajachiththi) obtained from the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation for built up area of 19,988.11 m2

[8,630.15 m2 + 11,357.96 m2]. It was presented that the basement height in the project will be 4.2 m

and so they can provide mechanical parking in basement, if required in future. The project proponent

was asked to ensure the provision of clear margin space of atleast 6 m around the buildings for easy

unobstructed movement of vehicles in case of emergency. The project proponent was suggested to

provide solar panels in the proposed buildings. The project proponent agreed and proposed to provide

roof top solar panels of 30 KW power generation capacity. It was presented that the proposed amount

to be allocated for activities to be carried out under Corporate Environment Responsibility considering

the brown field project. After detailed discussion, it was decided to recommend the project to SEIAA

Gujarat for granting Environment Clearance subject to the strict compliance of the following project

specific conditions as well as the standard conditions finalized during the meeting of SEAC held on

02/08/2017 and approved during the meeting of SEIAA held on 08/09/2017 for The Building

Construction projects falling under project activity no. 8(a) as per the schedule of the EIA Notification

2006:

Page 27 of 59


Page 27 of 59

Project Specific Conditions with which Environment Clearance is recommended:

CONSTRUCTION PHASE :

WATER:

1. Fresh water requirement during the construction phase shall be 20.0 KL/day and it shall be met

through the local water tankers. No ground water shall be tapped during the construction phase.

2. Sewage generated during the construction phase shall be disposed off through septic tank and soak

pit.

OPERATION PHASE :

WATER:

3. Total water requirement during the operation phase shall be 290.0 KL/day, out of which fresh water

requirement of 236.0 KL/day shall be met through water supply system of Ahmedabad Municipal

Corporation (AMC) and the remaining 54.0 KL/day of water requirement shall be met through

treated sewage. No ground water shall be tapped during the operation phase. Metering of the water

shall be done and its records shall be maintained.

4. Sewage generation during operation phase shall be 226.0 KL/day which shall be treated in the

proposed onsite Sewage Treatment Plant.

5. The unit shall install and efficiently operate STP of adequate capacity for treating the sewage to be

generated during operation phase to achieve the GPCB norms at the STP outlet. Treated sewage

conforming to GPCB norms shall be utilized within premises for gardening & flushing purpose at the

maximum extent possible. Only remaining quantity of treated sewage shall be disposed off through

drainage line of Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC).

6. A proper logbook of STP operation and also showing the quantity of treated sewage utilization within

premises & quantity of treated sewage discharged into the drainage line shall be maintained and

furnished to the GPCB from time to time.

7. Dual plumbing system with separate tanks and lines shall be provided for utilization of treated

sewage for flushing.

8. No bore well shall be constructed and existing bore well/s, if any, shall be either sealed or

converted into the recharge well upon completion of the construction work.

9. Rain water harvesting from rooftop and paved areas and ground water recharge through 4 nos. of

percolation wells shall be carried out as per the details submitted. Before recharging the run off,

pre-treatment must be done to remove suspended matter.

AIR:

10. A D. G. set (1 x 125 KVA) proposed as backup power shall be of enclosed type and confirm to

prescribe standards under EPA rules. Necessary acoustic enclosures shall be provided at diesel

generator set to mitigate the impact of noise.

11. The exhaust of the D. G. Set shall be at least 3 m above roof top.

12. The gaseous emissions from the D.G. Sets shall conform to the standards prescribed under EPA

rules as amended from time to time. At no time, the emission levels shall go beyond the stipulated

standards.

SOLID WASTE:

Page 28 of 59


Page 28 of 59

13. The solid waste generated shall be properly collected and segregated at source. The

biodegradable waste shall be converted into useful end product by treating it into the proposed

onsite Organic Waste Convertor and the recyclable waste shall be sold to vendors whereas the

other garbage shall be disposed off properly as per the provisions made by the Ahmedabad

Municipal Corporation (AMC).

SAFETY:

14. Fire fighting facilities like fire extinguishers of CO2 type and DCP type on each floor, automatic

sprinkler system, hose reels and wet rises, manually operated electric fire alarm system &

automatic sprinkler system, one no. of underground fire water storage tank having capacity of 75

KL, terrace tank having capacity of 20 KL, roof top solar panels of 30 KW power generation

capacity etc. shall be provided as proposed.

15. All the staircases and lifts shall open out at ground level from the highest point of building [with

access from each floor] for emergency evacuation. Two staircases shall be provided in each

building having floor area more than 500 m2 on each floor.

16. In basement at least two separate ramps of adequate width and slope shall be provided, located

preferably at opposite ends.

17. Provision for adequate air changes per hour in the basement shall be made so as to avoid build up

of CO in the area.

18. Car park exhaust system equipped with CO (Carbon Monoxide) sensor shall be provided to ensure

operation of exhaust fans as CO concentration levels.

PARKING / TRAFFIC CONGESTION:

19. Minimum parking space of 12,843.89 m2 [7,868.20 m2 in basement + 2,750.53 m2 as open surface

+ 2,225.16 m2 in hollow plinth] shall be provided as proposed.

ENERGY CONSERVATION:

20. Energy conservation measures viz. maximum use of LED & CFL lights, use of solar lighting in

common area, maximize the use of light colors in the building exterior walls etc. shall be

implemented as proposed.

GREEN BELT:

21. Green belt area of 1,805.0 m2 comprising of 868.0 m2 tree covered area with 240 trees within

premises shall be developed as proposed. The other open spaces inside the plot shall be suitably

landscaped and covered with vegetation of indigenous tree species.

OTHER CONDITION:

22. The project proponent shall allocate the separate fund of Rs. 56 lacs for activities like providing

education & health, sanitation facility, training & skill development, canal protection work etc. in

accordance to the MoEFCC’s Office Memorandum No. F.No.22-65/2017-IA.III dated 01/05/2018 to

carry out the activities under CER in affected area around the project. The entire activities

proposed under CER shall be monitored and the monitoring report shall be submitted to the

regional office of MoEFCC as a part of half-yearly compliance report and to district collector. The

monitoring report shall be posted on the website of the project proponent.

5. Sahjanand Harmony Blok No. 151, Kosmada, Kamrej, Surat Screening/ scoping & appraisal

Page 29 of 59


Page 29 of 59

The project proponent did not attend the meeting.

6. Green Tulip

Block No. 83, O.P. No. 78, F.P. No. 78, T.P.S. No. 30, (Vanakla-Okha-Vihal), Vankala, Choryasi Surat

Screening/scoping &appraisal

The SEIAA, Gujarat has accorded environmental clearance to Mr. Alpeshbhai G. Kotadiya & others for

the building construction project at Block No. 83, O.P. No. 78, F.P. No. 78, T.P.S. No. 30, (Vanakla-

Okha-Vihal), Vankala, Choryasi Surat vide order no. SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/894/2017 dated 29/09/2017

for the built up area of 35,433.04 m2 comprising of 6 no. of buildings housing total 404 residential units.

Scope of the buildings was 4 buildings: basement + hollow plinth + 13 floors, 2 buildings: basement +

hollow plinth + 12 floors.

The project proponent vide their online proposal no. SIA/GJ/NCP/80911/2018 dated 16/11/2018 along

with Form-I & Form-IA requested for amendment of Environmental Clearance order dated 29/09/2017

for the proposed changes.

Details of the project after the proposed expansion as presented before the committee are described below:

Sr. No

Particulars Details


2. Type of Project Residential


8(a)


Green Tulip


M/s Shrushti Buildwell LLP through its partner Mr. Alpeshbhai G Kotadiya.


Rs. 55.43 crores [Rs. 49.11 Cr- Existing Building + Rs. 6.32 Cr.- Proposed Building]


Yes. Construction work for the basement has been started as per the environmental clearance granted.


9. Project Details • Land / Plot Area (m²): 8,559.0

• FSI area (m2): 25,291.42

• Total BUA (m2): 39,383.66


FSI Area (m²) 25,295 25,291.42

Ground Coverage (m²) -- 2,244.49

Common Plot Area (m²) 855.96 856.33


Page 30 of 59


Page 30 of 59



• Scope of buildings/blocks: basement + hollow plinth + 14 floors

• No.& size of Residential Units: 448 units

• Details of amenities if any: Club house and jogging track


1,818



• Source of water: Water supply from Surat Urban Development

Authority (SUDA)


• Mode of disposal: Disposal through septic tank & soak pit system.




• Source of water: Water supply from Surat Urban Development

Authority (SUDA)



proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening &


sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of SUDA.


• STP Technology: conventional with primary, secondary & tertiary

treatment facility.

• Purposes for treated sewage utilization: flushing & gardening

• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1.Gardening (KL/day): 5.0.

2. Flushing (KL/day): 99.0


• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged:

Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed on site STP.

Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within

premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged

into the drainage line of SUDA.

• Mode of disposal: as above.


Both drainage and water supply lines are existing at site.


Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)

Quantity to be reused (m3)


Page 31 of 59


Page 31 of 59

Top Soil 855.90 855.90 Excavated top soil will be utilized for greenbelt development.

Other excavated earth

18,246.80 1,283.85.0 m3

will be used within premises for back filling

16,962.95 m3 of other excavated earth will be utilized for other project after payment of necessary royalty, if any.

Construction debris

100 kg/day Nil Sold off to recyclers

Steel scrap 15 kg/day


6 kg/day

Operation Phase:

Type of waste




Dry waste

286.0 Into bins to be provided within premises.

Wet waste will be processed within premises using OWC. Recyclable waste will be sold to recycler. Remaining waste will be disposed through door to door waste collection system of SUDA.

Wet waste

430.0

• Details of segregation if to be done: Solid waste segregation at source will be adopted and wet waste will be processed within premises using OWC, recyclable material will be sold to recycler.

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 2 nos of bins having capacity of 50 kg each for dry waste and 50 kg for wet waste will be provided to each building.

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority: Khajod Disposal Site


• Parking area requirement for residential units as per GDCR: 5,058.28 m²

• Total Parking area provided (m²) & No. of CPS: 9,381.75 m² and 335 CPS

• Parking area provided in basement (m² ) & No. of CPS: 4,631.87 m² and 145 CPS

• Parking area provided in hollow plinth (m² ) & No. of CPS: 2,058.88 m² and 73 CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface parking (m² ) & No. of CPS: 2,691.0 m² and 117 CPS


• Width of adjacent public roads: 24 m

• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: One gate will be provided.

Page 32 of 59


Page 32 of 59





Provision to install aerated coke (foam type) in wash basins, kitchen, low flush water closets in toilet and pressure reducing valves in water pipeline, rain water harvesting & ground water recharge, maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top thermal insulation, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks, 300 no. of solar panels etc.


• Power supply: Maximum demand: 2,240 KW Connected load: 2,350 KW Source: DGVCL

• Energy saving measures: Maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top thermal insulation, roof top solar panels of 90 KW power generation capacity, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks etc.

• DG Sets: No. and capacity of the DG sets: 6 x 62.5 KVA Fuel & its quantity: diesel (10Liter/h)


• During the construction phase: Fire extinguishers at various locations and can be easily accessible, to keep printed board showing important telephone number of fire, ambulance, hospital etc. training to the workers on safety aspects, first aid box at identified places within premise, doctor & ambulance services, provision of PPE’s like helmet, gumboot/safety net, safety goggles etc.

• During the operation phase: Fire extinguishers on each floor & in the basement, wet riser opening at each floor, manually operated electric fire alarm system, hose reel, terrace water tanks of 15 KL capacity, underground water tank of 100 KL, smoke detectors etc.

• Nearest fire station: Rander fire station. Distance from project site: 2.0 Km.


Type & no. of buildings

No. of floors

Floor area (m2)

No. of staircase

Width of the staircase (m)

Travel distance (m)

A, B B+HP+14 263.42 1 1.98 < 15

C B+HP+14 261.93 1 1.98 < 15

D, E B+HP+14 249.65 1 1.98 < 15

F+G B+HP+14 518.46 2 1.98 < 15


• Level of the Ground water table: 6 m

• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s) :-

• No. and depth of percolations wells :3

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities :only roof top rainwater harvesting is proposed

Page 33 of 59


Page 33 of 59


• Tree covered area (m²): 700.0

• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2): included in lawn covered area.

• Lawn covered area (m²): 500.0

• Total Green Area (m²): 1,200.0

• Green Area % of plot area: 14.0%

• No. of trees and species to be planted: 132 trees of Asopalav, Kadam, Golmohar, Jambu, Badam, Gunda, Rayan etc.

24. Budgetary allocation for Environmental Management Plan (Rs. in lacs)

Green belt development : 7 Lacs Drainage and rain water harvesting: 5 lacs Solar and energy saving: 15 lacs Solid waste management: 8 lacs STP including dual plumbing: 45 lacs Total: 80 Lacs


Loading & transportation in covered trucks, covered shed for cement

unloading activity, temporarily wind screen around project site, sprinkling

of water on roads and in vicinity of storage area.


Fly ash bricks & aerated block, paving blocks, RMC (Ready Mix Concrete), lead free paints etc.

27. Details on Corporate Environment Responsibility (Rs. In Lacks)

Fund of Rs. 12.70 lacks will be utilized for various socio-economic as

well as environmental up-gradation activities such as traffic circles,

public toilets, health & education etc. in consultation with Surat Municipal

Corporation.

28. Facilities to be provided to the construction workers

Sanitation facilities, drinking water & tap water, sewage disposal facility, first aid box, free medicines, doctor service, adequate PPEs etc.

29. Document related to Land possession

Copy of village form no. 7& 12 submitted by them shows that the NA land F.P. No. 78 of T.P.S. No. 30 admeasuring 8,559.0 m2 for residential use in the name of M/s. Srushti Buildwell LLP through its partner Mr. Alpeshbhai G. Kotadiya.

During the meeting, it was found that a copy of permission obtained from Airports Authority of India for

permissible building height of 109.11 m has been submitted. It was found that they have submitted

compliance report with reference to the conditions stipulated in the Environmental Clearance order no.

SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/894/2017 dated 29/09/2017. With reference to the O.Ms of MoEF&CC dated

30/05/2012 & 20/10/2009, they have submitted a notarized undertaking stating that there isn’t any

litigation pending against the project in court of law and they have not received any notice under the

Environment Protection Act – 1986. Further the project proponent has submitted a copy of certificate

obtained from structural consultant stating that the buildings will be designed for Basement + ground

floor + 14 floors. It was presented that the area was flooded up to 2 ft. in the past. They have proposed

hollow plinth of 2.5 m height and hence the residential units of the proposed project will be 0.5 m above

Page 34 of 59


Page 34 of 59

the flood level recorded in the past. Key plan showing that the project site is at a distance of 184.85 m

from 45 m wide road and hence FSI of 4.0 is available to the project. After detailed discussion, it was

decided to recommend the project to SEIAA Gujarat for transferring & granting Environment Clearance

with the proposed expansion, in supersession of the Environmental Clearance order no.

SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/894/2017 dated 29/09/2017, subject to the strict compliance of the following

project specific conditions as well as the standard conditions finalized during the meeting of SEAC held

on 02/08/2017 and approved during the meeting of SEIAA held on 08/09/2017 for The Building

Construction projects falling under project activity no. 8(a) as per the schedule of the EIA Notification

2006:



WATER:


through water supply from Surat Urban Development Authority (SUDA). No ground water shall be

tapped during the construction phase.

2. Sewage generated during the construction phase shall be disposed off through septic tank & soak

pit.

OPERATION PHASE :

WATER:


requirement of 151.0 KL/day shall be met through water supply system of Surat Urban Development

Authority (SUDA) and the remaining 104.0 KL/day of water requirement shall be met through treated

sewage. No ground water shall be tapped during the operation phase. Metering of the water shall be

done and its records shall be maintained.







drainage line of Surat Urban Development Authority (SUDA).











Page 35 of 59


Page 35 of 59

AIR:

10. D. G. sets (6 x 62.5 KVA) proposed as backup power shall be of enclosed type and confirm to




Rules as amended from time to time. At no time, the emission levels shall go beyond the stipulated

standards.

12. The stack height of the D.G.sets shall be equal to the height needed for the combined capacity of

all proposed D.G.sets.

SOLID WASTE:




other garbage shall be disposed off properly as per the provisions made by the Surat Urban

Development Authority (SUDA).

SAFETY:

14. Fire fighting facilities like fire extinguishers on each floor & in the basement, wet riser opening at

each floor, manually operated electric fire alarm system, hose reel, terrace water tanks of 15 KL

capacity, underground water tank of 100 KL, smoke detectors etc. shall be provided as proposed.







of CO in the area.




19. Minimum parking space of 9,381.75 m2 [2,691.0 m2 as open surface parking+ 2,058.88 m2 in hollow

plinth + 4,631.87 m2 in basement] shall be provided as proposed.


20. Energy conservation measures viz. maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top thermal insulation,

roof top solar panels of 90 KW power generation capacity, LED lighting fixtures in the common

areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external

lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks etc. shall be implemented as proposed.

GREEN BELT:

21. Green belt area of 1,200.0 m2 comprising of 700.0 m2 tree covered area with 130 trees within



OTHER CONDITION:

Page 36 of 59


Page 36 of 59

22. The project proponent shall allocate the separate fund of Rs. 12.70 lacs for various socio-economic

as well as environmental up-gradation activities such as traffic circles, public toilets, health &

education etc. in consultation with Surat Municipal Corporation in accordance to the MoEFCC’s

Office Memorandum No. F.No.22-65/2017-IA.III dated 01/05/2018 to carry out the activities under

CER in affected area around the project. The entire activities proposed under CER shall be

monitored and the monitoring report shall be submitted to the regional office of MoEFCC as a part

of half-yearly compliance report and to the District Collector. The monitoring report shall be posted

on the website of the project proponent. 7. Affordable

Housing Project by M/s Shree Balaji Corporation

T.P.S. No. 44 (Jahangirabad), Block No. 128, O.P. No. 35, F.P. No. 50/P, Sub Plot No. A, Choryasi, Surat

Screening/scoping & appraisal

The SEIAA, Gujarat has accorded environmental clearance to Mr. Pradipbhai Ratilal Navik & others for

the building construction project at T.P.S. No. 44 (Jahangirabad), Block No. 128, O.P. No. 35, F.P. No.

50/P, Sub Plot No. A, Choryasi, Surat vide order no. SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/481/2018 dated 17/05/2018

for the built up area of 22,138.88 m2 comprising of 2 buildings housing total 204 residential units and

25 commercial units. Scope of the buildings was basement + ground floor (parking/ shops) + 13 floors

The project proponent vide their online proposal no. SIA/GJ/NCP/81842/2018 dated 16/11/2018 along

with Form-I & Form-IA requested for amendment of Environmental Clearance order dated 17/05/2018

for the proposed changes.

Details of the project after the proposed expansion as presented before the committee are described

below:

Sr. No.

Particulars Details


2. Type of Project Residential & commercial


8(a)


Affordable Housing Project


M/s. Shree Balaji Corporation


Rs. 85 cr.


Yes, basement excavation work started.

Page 37 of 59


Page 37 of 59



• FSI area (m2): 19,935.95

• Total BUA (m2): 35,545.01


FSI Area (m²) 21,941.14 19,935.95






• Scope of buildings/blocks: Basement + ground floor (parking &/or shops)

+14 floors.

• No.& size of Residential Units: 276 units

• No.& size of Commercial Units: 25 units

• Details of amenities if any: Club house and jogging track


1,145



• Source of water: Water supply from Surat Municipal Corporation


• Mode of disposal: Into drainage line of Surat Municipal Corporation.


• Total Water requirement (KL/day): 200.60





proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening &


sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of SMC.


• STP Technology:- FMR technology


• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 2.0



• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged:

Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP.

Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within

premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged

into the drainage line of SMC.

• Mode of disposal: As above.

Page 38 of 59


Page 38 of 59




Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)



Top Soil 550.60

250.0 m3 will be utilized for greenbelt development

300.60 m3 of excavated top soil will be utilized for backfilling within premises.


12,167.68 2,477.70 m3 will be reused within premises for plinth filling & back filling.

9,689.98 m3 of other excavated earth will be utilized for other project after payment of necessary royalty if any

Construction debris

100 kg/day Nil Sold off to recyclers



6 kg/day

Operation Phase:

Type of waste




Dry waste 241.0 Into bins to be provided within premises.

Organic waste will be treated in the proposed onsite Organic Waste Convertor, recyclable waste will be sold to vendors and the remaining waste will be disposed off through door to door waste collection system of SMC.

Wet waste 361.0

• Details of segregation if to be done: Solid waste segregation at source

will be adopted and wet waste will be processed within premises using

OWC, Recyclable waste will be sold to recycler.

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 2 nos

of bins having capacity of 100 kg each for dry waste and 100 kg for wet

waste will be provided to each building.

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority:

Khajod Disposal Site


Page 39 of 59


Page 39 of 59

• Parking area requirement for residential units as per GDCR: 3,808.29 m²

• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 447.25 m²

• Total Parking area provided (m²) & No. of CPS: 8,157.20 m² and 259

CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface (m²) & No. of CPS: 143.10 m² and

6 CPS

• Parking area provided in basement (m² ) & No. of CPS: 7,365.76 m² and

230 CPS

• Parking area provided in hollow plinth (m² ) & No. of CPS: 648.34 m² and

23 CPS


• Width of adjacent public roads: 18 m

• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: One gate will be

provided


• Minimum width of open path all around the buildings for easy access of

fire tender (excluding the width for the plantation): 6.0 m



Provision to install aerated coke (foam type) in wash basins, kitchen, low flush water closets in toilet and pressure reducing valves in water pipeline, rain water harvesting & ground water recharge, maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top thermal insulation, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks, provision of STP & reuse of treated sewage, roof top solar panels of 90 KW power generation capacity etc.


• Power supply:

Maximum demand: 1,800 KW

Connected load:1,950 KW

Source: DGVCL

• Energy saving measures: Maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top

thermal insulation, roof top solar panels of 90 KW power generation

capacity, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design

to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external

lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks etc.

• DG Sets:

No. and capacity of the DG sets: 6 x 62.5 KVA

Fuel & its quantity: diesel (10 Liter/h)


• During the construction phase: Fire extinguishers at various locations and

can be easily accessible, to keep printed board showing important

telephone number of fire, ambulance, hospital etc. training to the workers

on safety aspects, first aid box at identified places within premise, doctor

& ambulance services, provision of PPE’s like helmet, gumboot/safety

net, safety goggles etc.

Page 40 of 59


Page 40 of 59

• During the operation phase: Fire extinguishers on each floor & in the

basement, wet riser opening at each floor, manually operated electric fire

alarm system, hose reel, terrace water tanks of 15 KL capacity,

underground water tank of 150 KL, smoke detectors etc.

• Nearest fire station: Rander fire station.

• Distance from project site: 2.0 Km.



No. of floors

Floor area (m2)

No. of staircase

Width of the staircase (m)

Travel distance (m)

A+B B+G+14 548.67 2 for residential + 1 commercial

2.10 <15

C+D B+G+14 552.16 2 2.03 <15

E B+G+14 275.77 1 2.03 < 15



• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s) :-

• No. and depth of percolations wells :2

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities :only roof top rainwater harvesting is proposed



• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2):--


• Total Green Area (m²): 600.0

• Green Area % of plot area: 10.90%

• No. of trees and species to be planted: 85 trees of Gulmohar, Jambu, Bakam Limdo, Chikoo, Ashopalav, Kadam, etc.

24. Budgetary allocation for Environmental Management Plan (Rs. in lacs)

Green belt development : 4 Lacs Drainage and rain water harvesting: 3 lacs Solar and energy saving: 10 lacs STP and Duel plumbing system: 45 lacs Solid waste management: 8 lacks Total: 70 Lacs


Loading & transportation in covered trucks, covered shed provided for cement unloading activity; temporary wind screen around project site, sprinkling of water on roads and in vicinity of storage area.



27. Details on Corporate Environment Responsibility (Rs. In Lacks)

Fund of Rs. 170 lacks will be utilized for various socio-economic as well as

environmental up-gradation activities such as traffic circles, public toilets,

health & education etc. in consultation with Surat Municipal Corporation

Page 41 of 59


Page 41 of 59




Copy of Sub-registrar’s office index submitted by them show that NA land of F.P. No. 50/A admeasuring 5,506.0 m2 is in the name of M/s. Shree Balaji Corporation through its authorized partner.

During the meeting, it was found that the project proponent has submitted a copy of permission

obtained from Airports Authority of India for permissible building height of 100.0 m above ground level.

It was found that they have submitted compliance report with reference to the conditions stipulated in

the Environmental Clearance order no. SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/481/2018 dated 17/05/2018. With

reference to the O.Ms of MoEF&CC dated 30/05/2012 & 20/10/2009, they have submitted a notarized

undertaking stating that there isn’t any litigation pending against the project in court of law and they

have not received any notice under the Environment Protection Act – 1986. Project proponent has

submitted a copy of NOC obtained from the old EC owner for transferring the EC in the name of M/s

Shree Balaji Corporation. Further the project proponent has submitted a copy of certificate obtained

from structural consultant stating that the buildings will be designed for Basement + ground floor + 14

floors. Project proponent has submitted a key plan showing that the project site is within 200 m

distance from the 45 m wide road and hence FSI of 4.0 is available to the project. The project

proponent suggested to increase basement height so that in future, if need arise, mechanical parking

can be provided. After detailed discussion, it was decided to recommend the project to SEIAA Gujarat

for transferring & granting Environment Clearance with the proposed expansion, in supersession of the

Environmental Clearance order no. SEIAA/GUJ/EC/8(a)/481/ 2018 dated 17/05/2018, subject to the

strict compliance of the following project specific conditions as well as the standard conditions finalized

during the meeting of SEAC held on 02/08/2017 and approved during the meeting of SEIAA held on

08/09/2017 for The Building Construction projects falling under project activity no. 8(a) as per the

schedule of the EIA Notification 2006:



WATER:


through water supply from Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC). No ground water shall be tapped

during the construction phase.

2. Sewage generated during the construction phase shall be disposed off through drainage line of

Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC).

OPERATION PHASE :

WATER:


requirement of 119.30 KL/day shall be met through water supply system of Surat Municipal

Corporation (SMC) and the remaining 81.3 KL/day of water requirement shall be met through

treated sewage. No ground water shall be tapped during the operation phase. Metering of the water

Page 42 of 59


Page 42 of 59

shall be done and its records shall be maintained.







drainage line of Surat Municipal Corporation (SMC).











AIR:

10. D. G. sets (6 x 62.5 KVA) proposed as backup power shall be of enclosed type and confirm to




Rules as amended from time to time. At no time, the emission levels shall go beyond the stipulated

standards.

12. The stack height of the D.G.sets shall be equal to the height needed for the combined capacity of

all proposed D.G.sets.

SOLID WASTE:




other garbage shall be disposed off properly as per the provisions made by the Surat Municipal

Corporation (SMC).

SAFETY:

14. Fire fighting facilities like fire extinguishers on each floor & in the basement, wet riser opening at

each floor, manually operated electric fire alarm system, hose reel, terrace water tanks of 15 KL

capacity, underground water tank of 150 KL, smoke detectors etc. shall be provided as proposed.





Page 43 of 59


Page 43 of 59



of CO in the area.




19. Minimum parking space of 8,157.20 m2 [143.10 m2 as open surface + 648.34 m2 in hollow plinth +

7,365.76 m2 in basement] shall be provided as proposed.


20. Energy conservation measures viz. maximum utilization of natural light, roof-top thermal insulation, roof

top solar panels of 90 KW power generation capacity, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate

design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use

of aerated blocks etc. shall be implemented as proposed.

GREEN BELT:

21. Green belt area of 600.0 m2 comprising of 250.0 m2 tree covered area with 85 trees within premises

shall be developed as proposed. The other open spaces inside the plot shall be suitably


OTHER CONDITION:

22. The project proponent shall allocate the separate fund of Rs. 170.0 lacs for various socio-economic

as well as environmental up-gradation activities such as traffic circles, public toilets, health &

education etc. in consultation with Surat Municipal Corporation in accordance to the MoEFCC’s

Office Memorandum No. F.No.22-65/2017-IA.III dated 01/05/2018. The entire activities proposed

under CER shall be monitored and the monitoring report shall be submitted to the regional office of

MoEFCC as a part of half-yearly compliance report and to district collector. The monitoring report

shall be posted on the website of the project proponent.

8. A R Mall Block No. 78, O.P. No. 85, F.P. No. 85, Paikee Sub Plot No. 1, T.P.S. No. 24 (Mota Varachha), Surat

Screening/scoping & appraisal.

Details of the project as presented before the committee are described below:

Sr. No.

Particulars Details


2. Type of Project Commercial


8(a)


A R Mall


M/s. Shiv Enterprise


Rs. 50.0 crores

7. Whether Yes. Project plan has been approved by SMC for built up area of 18,476.98

Page 44 of 59


Page 44 of 59

construction work has been initiated at site? If yes, details thereof

m2 on 13/03/2018. Based on the approved palns construction work for basement has been started. Now as per the CGDCR – 2017, additional FSI is available to the project in view of the 36 m wide approach road and hence they have planned for the proposed expansion of the project.

8. Site coordinates

720 52’ 22.91” E 210 14’ 06.64” N


• FSI area (m2): 21,241.85

• Total BUA (m2): 35,295.03


FSI Area (m²) 20,563.2 21,241.85




10. Building Details

• No. of Buildings: 1


• Scope of buildings/blocks: 3 level basement + ground floor + 8 floors.

• No.& size of residential units: --

• No. size of commercial units: 453 commercial units, multiplex with 910

seats, game zone, 11 restaurants/ food court.



2,722





• Mode of disposal: SMC drain

13 Water & waste water details during operation phase

• Total Water requirement (KL/day): 180.0




• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed

onsite STP. Treated sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing

purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be

discharged into the drainage line of SMC.


• STP Technology: FMR technology


• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 2.0

Page 45 of 59


Page 45 of 59



• Quantity and type (treated/untreated)of sewage to be discharged: Sewage

to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated

sewage will be reused for gardening & flushing purpose within premises

and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the

drainage line of SMC.


14 Status of water supply and drainage line


15 Solid waste Management

Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)



Top Soil 338.0 338.0 m3 388.0 m3 will be used within premises for back filling


36,676.40 2,467.35 m3 will be used within premises for back filling

34,209.05 m3 of other excavated earth will be utilized for other project after payment of necessary royalty, if any.

Construction debris

15 kg/day Nil Send to C & D waste management facility of SMC.


Nil

Sold off to recyclers Discarded

packing materials

6 kg/day

Operation Phase:

Type of waste




Dry waste 374.0 Into bins to be provided within premises.

Wet waste will be processed within premises using OWC. Recyclable waste will be sold to recycler. Remaining waste will be disposed through door to door waste collection system of SMC.

Wet waste 500.0

• Details of segregation if to be done: Solid waste segregation at source will be adopted and wet waste will be processed within premises using OWC, Recyclable waste will be sold to recycler.

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 2 nos.

Page 46 of 59


Page 46 of 59

of bins having capacity of 50 kg each for dry waste and 50 kg for wet waste will be provided to each building.

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority: Khajod Disposal Site

16 Parking Details • Total parking area requirement for the project as per GDCR: 10,620.93 m²

• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 10,620.93 m²

• Parking requirement for the project as per the NBC norms: 374

• Total Parking area provided (m²) & No. of CPS: 11,411.55 m² and 371 CPS

• Parking area provided in basement (m²) & No. of CPS: 7,974.49 m² and 250 CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface (m²) & No. of CPS: 1,214.92 m² and 53 CPS

• Parking area provided as mechanical parking in basement (m²) & No. of CPS: 2,222.14 m² and 69 CPS

17 Traffic Management


• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: Two gates will be provided

• Width of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 7.50 m & 6 m


• Width of all internal roads: 7.50 m & 6 m

18 Details of Green Building measures proposed.

Provision to install aerated coke (foam type) in wash basins, kitchen, low flush water closets in toilet and pressure reducing valves in water pipeline, rain water harvesting & ground water recharge, maximum utilization of natural light, 300 no. of roof top solar panels, roof-top thermal insulation, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks etc.

19 Energy Requirement, Source and Conservation

• Power supply: Maximum demand: 3700 KW Connected load: 4000 KW

• Source: DGVCL

• Energy saving measures: Maximum utilization of natural light, 300 no. of roof top solar panels, roof-top thermal insulation, LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, appropriate design to shut out excess heat and gain loss, use of solar energy in external lighting (landscape lighting), use of aerated blocks etc.

• DG Sets: No. and capacity of the DG sets: 3 x 160 KVA Fuel & its quantity: diesel (10 Liter/h)

20 Fire and Life Safety Measures

• During the construction phase: Fire extinguishers at various locations and can be easily accessible, to keep printed board showing important telephone number of fire, ambulance, hospital etc. training to the workers on safety aspects, first aid box at identified places within premises, doctor & ambulance services, provision of PPE’s like helmet,

Page 47 of 59


Page 47 of 59

gumboot/safety net, safety goggles etc.

• During the operation phase: Fire extinguishers on each floor & in the basement, wet riser opening at each floor, manually operated electric fire alarm system, hose reel, terrace water tanks of 15 KL capacity, underground water tank of 200 KL, smoke detectors, automatic sprinkler system etc.

• Nearest fire station: Mota Varachha fire station. Distance from project site: 1 Km.

21 Details on staircase


No. of floors

Max. floor area (m2)

No. of staircase Width of the staircase (m)

Travel distance (m)

One Building 3B+G+8 2,825.36 4 staircases from ground floor to 6th floor, 2 staircases on 7th & 8th floor

1.50 < 25.0

22 Rain Water Harvesting (RWH)


• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s): -

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 2

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities: only roof top rainwater harvesting is proposed

23

Green area details


• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m²): included in lawn covered area.


• Total Green Area (m²): 500.0


• No. of trees and species to be planted: 90 trees of Gulmohar, Jambu, BakamLimdo, Chikoo, Ashopalav, Kadam, Rayan etc.

24 Budgetary allocation for Environmental Management Plan (Rs. in lacs)

Green belt development: 4 Lacs Rain water harvesting: 2 Lacs Solid Waste Management: 6 Lacs Solar and energy saving: 8 Lacs STP & dual plumbing: 25 Lacs Total: 45 Lacs

25 Proposed dust control measures during the construction phase

Loading & transportation in covered trucks, covered shed for cement unloading activity, temporarily wind screen around project site, sprinkling of water on roads and in vicinity of storage area.

26 Eco friendly building material usage details.


Page 48 of 59


Page 48 of 59

27. Details of Corporate Environment Responsibility.

Fund of Rs. 100.0 lacs will be utilized for various socio-economic as well as

environmental up-gradation activities such as traffic circles, public toilets,

health & education etc. in consultation with Surat Municipal Corporation.




Copy of village form No. 7 and NA order submitted by them show that NA land for F.P. No.85 of T.P.S. No. 24 admeasuring 8,220.0 m2 is in the name of M/s Shiv Enterprise.

During the meeting it was found that the project proponent has submitted a copy of permission

obtained from Airports Authority of India for permissible building height of 75.0 m above ground level. A

copy of permission (Rajachiththi) and plan approved by Surat Municipal Corporation for built up area of

18,476.98 m2 have been submitted. Copy of opinion obtained from Fire & Emergency services of Surat

Municipal Corporation is submitted. After detailed discussion, it was decided to consider the

project only after submission of the following:

1. Revised details on increased parking area provision for the project along with back up

calculation & the parking plans.

2. Details & plans showing floor wise emergency evacuation for the proposed commercial

building.

3. Authentic supporting documents showing availability of the proposed FSI to the project.

9. Building Construction Project by Mrs. Bhavnaben J. Thakkar

Sr. No. 18/B/1, O.P. No. 88/2, F.P. No. 88/2, D.T.P.S. No. 61, Khodiyar, Ahmedabad



Sr. No.

Particulars Details


2. Type of Project Residential & Commercial Project


8 (a)


Residential & Commercial Project


Mrs. Bhavanaben J. Thakkar


Rs. 30 Crores

7. Whether construction work has been initiated at site?

No

Page 49 of 59


Page 49 of 59

If yes, details thereof

8. Site coordinates 72° 32' 26.50" E 23° 08' 35.66" N


• FSI area (m2): 12,226.95

• Total BUA (m2): 22,761.54


FSI Area (m2) 12,268.80 12,226.95

Ground Coverage (m2) - 1,748.11

Common Plot Area (m2) 454.40 456.60

Max. building height 61.76 38.20



• Scope of buildings/blocks: 1 building: 2 level basement + ground floor + 11 floors; 1 building: 2 level basement + hollow plinth + 11 floors

• No. & type of Residential Units: 166 flats

• No. & type of Commercial Units: 41 flats

• Details of amenities if any: No


829 occupants and 300 visitors






• Details of reuse of water, if any: No




• Source of water: Water supply from Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority (AUDA)


• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AUDA.

• In case of STP provision, capacity of STP: Yes, 75 KL/day

• STP Technology: STP with MBBR reactor

• Purposes for treated sewage utilization: Flushing & gardening

• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 2.95 2. Flushing (KL/day): 38.66


• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AUDA.


Page 50 of 59


Page 50 of 59


Available at site


Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)



Top Soil 440.0 440.0 Will be used for greenbelt development.


21,560.0 7,700.0 m3 will be used for back filling within premises

Remaining will be used at other project sites.

Construction debris

250.0 75.0 m3 will be used for development of internal road.

Remaining will be handed over to AUDA

Steel scrap 15 0 Sold to vendors


10 0 Sold to vendors

Operation Phase:

Type of waste




Dry waste 197.84 White bins Sold to vendors

Wet waste 296.76 Green bins Will be treated in OWC

STP Sludge What so ever Will be handed over to AUDA.

• Details of segregation if to be done: yes

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 15 kg and 30 number of community bins to be placed in common area

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority: at the nearest MSW collection point of SMC.



• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 568.72 m2

• Total Parking area provided (m2) & No. of CPS: 7,610.02 m2 & 246 CPS

• Parking area provided in basement (m2) & No. of CPS: 6,251.60 m2 & 195 CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface (m2) & No. of CPS: 400.0 m2 & 17 CPS

• Parking area provided in hollow plinth (m2) & No. of CPS: 958.42 m2 &

Page 51 of 59


Page 51 of 59

34 CPS



• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 3 gates will be provided



• Width of all internal roads: 6.0 m, 4.50 m


Maximum use of natural lighting through architectural design, energy efficient motors & pumps, water efficient taps, maximum use of RMC & aerated blocks, use of LED lighting fixtures and low voltage lighting, 30 KW roof top solar panel, reuse of treated sewage, solar lighting in open and landscape areas- 25 numbers of solar lights, roof-top thermal insulation, water meters, rain water harvesting & ground water recharge through 2 nos. of percolating wells etc.


• Power supply: Maximum demand: 1500 KVA Connected load: 1600 KVA Source: DGVCL

• % of saving with calculations: ~40% by use of LEDs, use of solar energy and star rated energy efficient electronic consumer durables

• Compliance of the ECBC guidelines (Yes / No),if yes, compliance in tabular form: only roof area

• DG Sets: No. and capacity of the DG sets: 1 x 62.5 KVA Fuel & its quantity: HSD, 10 litre/hr


• During Construction Phase: Provision of Personal Protective Equipment’s (PPEs) to the construction workers and its usage shall be ensured and supervised, training to all workers on construction safety aspects, first aid room with first aid kit, doctor & ambulance service.

• During operation phase: Fire extinguishers, hose reel, wet riser, yard hydrant, manually operated electric fire alarm system, automatic sprinkler system in basement, underground static water storage tank-200 KL capacity, terrace tank -40 KL capacity (total capacity), pump near underground static water storage tank (fire pump) with minimum pressure of 3.5 kg/cm2 at terrace level etc.



No. of floors Floor

area (m2) No. of

staircase Width of the staircase (m)

Travel distance (m)

A+B+C 2B+G+11 1,050.83

3 for residential +

2 for commercial

2.0 21

D 2B+HP+11 246.98 1 2.0 19



• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s): 2 No and 2.0 m X 2.0 m X 3.0 m

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 2 no and 21 m

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities: oil and grease removal and filter

Page 52 of 59


Page 52 of 59


• Tree covered area (m2): 200.0

• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2): 26.60




• No. of trees and species to be planted: 69 number of trees and Limbdo, KaadoSiris, Jambu, Asopalav, DesiBadam and Gulmohar


Spraying of water, peripheral barricading, covered shed for cement loading area, covering the excavated earth with tarpaulin sheet etc.

25.


Allocation of Rs. 50.50 lacs & Rs. 13.0 lacs as capital cost & recurring cost respectively has been made for EMP & EMS including green belt development, solar panel, STP, rain water harvesting / ground water recharge, solid waste management etc.

26. Details of ecofriendly building materials

Fly ash bricks, aerated blocks, fly ash paving blocks, maximum use of

RMC, lead free paints etc.

27. Details of Corporative Environment Responsibility (Rs. In lacks)

Fund of Rs. 0.6 Cr. (2.0% of capital investment) will be used for socially

needy people or donate to any such related government schemes in

consultation with District Collector.


Sanitation facilities, maintaining hygienic condition at the project site to

avoid health problems, safe drinking water, PPEs, first aid room with

first aid kit & welfare facilities as per the Gujarat Building & Other

Construction Workers Rules.


Copy of Sub-registrar’s office index submitted by them shows that the

NA land of Block No. 18/B/1 of T.P.S. No. 61 admeasuring 4,544.0 m2

is in the name of the applicant Mrs. Bhavnaben J. Thakkar.

During the meeting, a copy of system generated auto assessment for height clearance of Airports

Authority of India, submitted shows that the permitted top elevation for this grid is 135 m. The project

proponent was asked to provide clear margin space of atleast 6 m all along the boundary wall,

excluding the space for tree plantation,for unobstructed movement of vehicles in case of emergency.

After detailed discussion, it was decided to recommend the project to SEIAA Gujarat for granting

Environment Clearance subject to the strict compliance of the following project specific conditions as

well as the standard conditions finalized during the meeting of SEAC held on 02/08/2017 and approved

during the meeting of SEIAA held on 08/09/2017 for The Building Construction projects falling under

project activity no. 8(a) as per the schedule of the EIA Notification 2006:



WATER:

Page 53 of 59


Page 53 of 59


through the local water tankers. No ground water shall be tapped during the construction phase.

2. Sewage generated during the construction phase shall be disposed off through septic tank and soak

pit.

OPERATION PHASE :

WATER:


requirement of 81.57 KL/day shall be met through water supply system of Ahmedabad Urban

Development Authority (AUDA) and the remaining 41.61 KL/day of water requirement shall be met

through treated sewage. No ground water shall be tapped during the operation phase. Metering of

the water shall be done and its records shall be maintained.







drainage line of Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority (AUDA).











AIR:

10. A D. G. set (1 x 62.5 KVA) proposed as backup power shall be of enclosed type and confirm to



11. The exhaust of the D. G. Set shall be at least 3 m above roof top.


rules as amended from time to time. At no time, the emission levels shall go beyond the stipulated

standards.

SOLID WASTE:




other garbage shall be disposed off properly as per the provisions made by the Ahmedabad Urban

Page 54 of 59


Page 54 of 59

Development Authority (AUDA).

SAFETY:

14. Fire fighting facilities like fire extinguishers, hose reel, wet riser, yard hydrant, manually operated

electric fire alarm system, automatic sprinkler system in basement, underground static water

storage tank-200 KL capacity, terrace tank -40 KL capacity (total capacity), pump near

underground static water storage tank (fire pump) with minimum pressure of 3.5 kg/cm2 at terrace

level etc. shall be provided as proposed.







of CO in the area.



19. Clear peripheral margin space of atleast 6 m, excluding the space for tree plantation, shall be

provided for unobstructed & easy movement of vehicles in case of emergency.


20. Minimum parking space of 7,610.02 m2 [6,251.60 m2 in basement + 400.0 m2 as open surface +

958.42 m2 in hollow plinth] shall be provided as proposed.


21. Energy conservation measures viz. maximum use of natural lighting through architectural design,

energy efficient motors & pumps, water efficient taps, maximum use of RMC & aerated blocks, use

of LED lighting fixtures and low voltage lighting, 30 KW roof top solar panel, solar lighting in open

and landscape areas- 25 numbers of solar lights, roof-top thermal insulation etc. shall be

implemented as proposed.

GREEN BELT:

22. Green belt area of 656.60 m2 comprising of 200.0 m2 tree covered area with 69 trees within



OTHER CONDITION:

23. The project proponent shall allocate the separate fund of Rs. 0.6 crores for socially needy people or

donate to any such related government schemes in consultation with District Collector in

accordance to the MoEFCC’s Office Memorandum No. F.No.22-65/2017-IA.III dated 01/05/2018 to

carry out the activities under CER in affected area around the project. The entire activities

proposed under CER shall be monitored and the monitoring report shall be submitted to the

regional office of MoEFCC as a part of half-yearly compliance report and to district collector. The

monitoring report shall be posted on the website of the project proponent.

10. Radhe Paramount

Sr. No. 89/2, 119/2, 120/1, F.P. No. 53/2+83/2+84/1, O.P. No. 53/2+83/2+84/1, D T.P.S. No. 241, Nana Chiloda, Gandhinagar


Page 55 of 59


Page 55 of 59


Sr. No.

Particulars Details


2. Type of Project Residential & Commercial


8 (a)


Radhe Paramount


Mr. Alpeshbhai S. Patel


32 Crores


No

8. Site coordinates 72° 40' 09.48" E 23° 06' 43.58" N


• FSI area (m2): 19,175.28

• Total BUA (m2): 31,302.54


FSI Area (m2) 19,212.0 19,175.28


Common Plot Area (m2) 800.50 864.50

Max. building height 38.118 37.02



• Scope of buildings/blocks: 1 building: basement + ground floor + 4 floors; 4 buildings: basement + hollow plinth + 10 floors

• No. & type of Residential Units: 152 flats

• No. & type of Commercial Units: 60 flats

• Details of amenities if any: No


1100






• Details of reuse of water, if any: No

13. Water & waste water details during operation



Page 56 of 59


Page 56 of 59

phase • Source of water: Water supply from Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority (AUDA)


• Mode of disposal: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AUDA.

• In case of STP provision, capacity of STP: Yes, 50 KL/day

• STP Technology: STP with MBBR reactor

• Purposes for treated sewage utilization: Flushing & gardening

• Quantity of treated sewage to be reused: 1. Gardening (KL/day): 5.0 2. Flushing (KL/day): 30.0 3. Floor cleaning (KL/day): 5.0


• Quantity and type (treated/untreated) of sewage to be discharged: Sewage to be generated will be treated in the proposed onsite STP. Treated sewage will be used for gardening & flushing purpose within premises and remaining quantity of treated sewage will be discharged into the drainage line of AUDA.



Available at site


Construction Phase:

Generation (m3)



Top Soil 1,600.0 1,600.0 Will be used for greenbelt development.


24,000.0 7,500.0 m3 will be used for back filling within premises

16,500.0 m3 will be used at other project site.

Construction debris

475.0 475.0 Will be used for back filling within premises

Steel scrap 10 0 Sold to vendors


600 0 Sold to vendors

Operation Phase:

Type of waste




Dry waste

272.0 White bins Sold to vendors

Wet waste

182.0 Green bins Will be treated in OWC.

• Details of segregation if to be done: yes

Page 57 of 59


Page 57 of 59

• Capacity and no. of community bins to be placed within premises: 15 kg and 30 number of community bins to be placed in common area

• Landfill site where waste will be ultimately disposed by local authority: at the nearest MSW collection point of AUDA.



• Parking area requirement for commercial units as per GDCR: 2,882.10 m2

• Total Parking area provided (m2) & No. of CPS: 15,000.0 m2 & 491 CPS

• Parking area provided in basement including one layer mechanical parking (m2) & No. of CPS: 12,000.0 m2 & 375 CPS

• Parking area provided as open surface (m2) & No. of CPS: 1,300.0 m2 & 56 CPS

• Parking area provided in hollow plinth (m2) & No. of CPS: 1,700.0 m2 & 60 CPS.



• Number of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 2 gates will be provided including one for basement.

• Width of Entry & Exit provided on approach road/s: 9.0 m & 4 m

• Minimum width of open path all around the buildings for easy access of fire tender (excluding the width for the plantation): 4.0 m around the low rise commercial building & 5.0 m around the residential buildings.



Energy efficient electrical appliances will be provided like LEDs, maximum use of natural daylight through architectural design, rain water harvesting etc.


• Power supply: Maximum demand: 1.7 MW Connected load: 1.20 MW Source: UGVCL

• % of saving with calculations: maximum utilization of natural light, roof top thermal insulation, CFL/LED lighting fixtures in the common areas, use of solar energy in external lighting etc.

• DG Sets: No. and capacity of the DG sets: 1 x 120 KVA Fuel & its quantity: HSD, 30 litre/hr


Two underground water storage tanks each of 100 KL, overhead water tank of 20 KL on each building, fire extinguishers, hose reel, wet riser, manually operated electric fire alarm system, sprinkler system etc.



No. of floors Floor

area (m2) No. of

staircase Width of the staircase (m)

Travel distance (m)

A B+G+4 1,158.29 4 1.5 17

B, C B+HP+10 298.39 1 2.0 17.06

D B+HP+10 385.19 1 2.0 18.37

Page 58 of 59


Page 58 of 59

E B+HP+10 429.26 1 2.0 19.65


• Level of the Ground water table: --

• No. & dimensions of RWH tank(s): 3

• No. and depth of percolations wells: 3

• Details on Pre-treatment facilities: Desilting & filter chamber


• Tree covered area (m2): 200.0

• Area covered by shrubs and bushes (m2): --




• No. of trees and species to be planted: 121 number of trees


Regular water sprinkling, vertical curtails, covered shed for cement unloading, covering the excavated earth with tarpaulin sheet etc.

25.


Allocation of Rs. 11.0 lacs as capital cost respectively has been made for EMP & EMS including green belt development, solar panel, STP, rain water harvesting / ground water recharge, solid waste management etc.

26. Details of ecofriendly building materials

Fly ash bricks, aerated blocks, fly ash blocks, maximum use of rmc, lead free paints etc.

27. Details of Corporative Environment Responsibility (Rs. In lacks)

Rs. 12.50 lakhs for activities like providing drinking facility and R. O. Plant at three different locations of nearby village, rain water recharge scheme etc.


Drinking water & tap water, sanitation facilities, first aid box, free medicines, doctor service, PPEs etc.


Copy of Sub-registrar’s office index submitted by them shows that the NA

land of F.P. No. 53/2, 83/2, 84/1 of T.P.S. No. 241 admeasuring 8,005.0

m2 for commercial & residential use is in the name of the M/s. Paramount

Constructions through its authorised partner. Copy of partnership deed

submitted shows that the applicant Mr. Alpeshbhai S. Patel is one of the

partner of the company. Notarized consent of other partners is submitted.

During the meeting, it was found that the project proponent has submitted a copy of permission

obtained from Airports Authority of India for permissible building height of 38.11 m. The project

proponent was suggested to provide clear peripheral margin space of atleast 6 m around the high rise

residential buildings & atleast 4 m around the low rise commercial building, excluding the space for tree

plantation, for unobstructed movement of vehicles in case of emergency. The project proponent was

also suggested to increase the capacity of STP and the project proponent agreed to provide STP of 75

Page 59 of 59


Page 59 of 59

KL/day capacity. After detailed discussion, it was decided to consider the project only after


1. To the scale layout plan showing provision of open peripheral margin of at least 6 m around

the high rise residential buildings & atleast 4 m around the low rise commercial building

excluding the space for tree plantation.

2. Detailed Environment Management Plan with respect to various environmental attributes-

Water, Air, Noise, Solid wastes including Hazardous Wastes, land etc. of the project both

during construction and operation phase and strategy for its implementation with financial

outlay.

3. Details of the activities to be carried out under Corporate Environment Responsibility along

with the details of basis considered for selection of the proposed activity/ies, fund allocation

(as per the MoEFCC’s Office Memorandum dated 01/05/2018), time bound action plan etc.

Meeting was concluded with thanks to the Chair.

--------------------------------

Minutes approved by:

Sr.

No.

Name & designation Sign

1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC

2. Shri S. C. Srivastav, Vice Chairman, SEAC

3. Shri Rajesh. I. Shah, Member, SEAC.

4. Shri V. N. Patel, Member, SEAC

5. Shri R. J. Shah, Member, SEAC.

6. Shri A. K. Muley, Member, SEAC.

7. Dr. V. K. Jain, Member, SEAC.

8. Shri. K. C. Mistry, Secretary, SEAC.