Monitoringcomprehension

Wor

ksho

p 2

Debbie D

raper, Julie Fullgrabe & Sue Eden

Overview of the session• The inner conversation –hearing the inner voice

that assists reading• leaving tracks of thinking- ways to demonstrate

thinking while reading• The different types of (human)readers in a class• Why meaning breaks down and what to do about

it – fix-up strategies• Think aloud strategies to share thinking with

students

Monitoring understanding is essential to engage with the reading strategies

Do I really have to teach reading? Content,comprehension grades 6-12 Cris Tovani Observations about reading Teaching points

Ask yourself why am I doing this? How will it help students think, read or write more thoughtfully about my content?

Good readers use reading writing and talk to deepen their understanding

Reading strategies are options for thinking. One comprehension tool is not more important than another. There is no specific order, sequence or template for introducing strategies

Good readers have a variety of ways to think about text

Is the reading authentic? Good readers don’t need end of chapter summaries or isolated skill sheets. They ask their own questions, based on their own need for a deeper understanding of the text

Don’t isolate strategies into individual activities. Build on previous learning

Good readers reread and return to build and extend their knowledge or to enhance enjoyment of reading for enjoyment

Links to Tfel 1.1 understand how self and others learn1.2 develop deep pedagogical and content knowledge

Understanding how students learn to read through your own experiences

Learning to learn.Using dialogue as a means to sharing understanding

Part one

Your own inner voice and how you use it.

Just relax…..let your mind go free

What did your inner voice say to you?

• When you are a busy person, your mind is always having conversations with you.

• What went on with you?• If it’s appropriate, what did your inner voice

say or think about?

Listening to the inner voice-George Costanza does not like what he hears

NOT listening to any voice

You need to hear your inner voice

• Without recognising this voice, it will be harder to ‘think aloud’ with students and share the thoughts you have as a competent reader

Part 2

Leaving tracks of thinking- ways to demonstrate thinking while reading

Sticky labels were invented to monitor comprehension…

They come in all sorts of shapes and sizes and kids love them!

They are a great way to keep track of thoughtsand ideas and can be placed in books to refer back to

They can help students to show tracks of their learning without Interruption when working independently

They support remembering what you read far better than highlighting

Discuss this quote-what do you think- have you ever highlighted to extremes?

• Highlighting text- ‘first of all : throw away the highlighter in

favour of a pen or pencil. Highlighting can actually distract from the business of learning and dilute your comprehension. It only seems like an active reading strategy; in actual fact, it can lull your into dangerous passivity’.

(Harvard College library 2007)

Text coding

• R- reminds me of• T-T text to text• ? Question• ! Surprising• Make it meaningful for your class,

create your own codes

From the text- Teaching Reading Comprehension Strategies

Sheena Cameron

Leaving tracks of thinking• Margin notes• Sticky notes• Many of these approaches will be dealt with

further as we explore the strategies in more detail.

• Think sheets –scaffolds, graphic organisers

• Response journals, literature logs, notebooks, wonder books

• Artistic, dramatic, musical, numerical, scientific, historical, economic

Another way to show tracks of thinking

Which of these strategies have you tried?

Strategies that Work• Use some of the previous strategies when

you read the 4 pages provided from Strategies that Work to make tracks of your thinking.

• Share what you have identified as important with someone near you.

• Is it the same or different?

Part 3

Different types of readers and reading behaviours

24

Awareness of reading

• Four levels of metacognitive awareness and the ways in which readers monitor their thinking about their reading are described in Strategies That Work:

Types of readersTacit readers lack awareness of how they think when they

read.

Aware readers may realize when meaning has broken down, but lack strategies to fix the problem or repair confusion.

Strategic readers use a variety of strategies to enhance understanding and monitor and repair meaning when it is disrupted

Reflective readers can apply strategies flexibly depending on their goals for reading. They reflect on their thinking and revise their use of strategies. You can observe this reflective stance when students comment with surprise, amazement, or wonder as they read

Group chat• Think of particular students that you have

taught or are teaching that fit into each category of reader.

• How do you know they were one of these types of readers?

Comprehension shouldn’t be silentKelley and Clausen Grace

• These authors talk about ‘fake or disengaged readers and mindless reading’

• What behaviours have you seen ‘fake readers’ doing?

• You have probably been one yourself at some time.

• Y chart about behaviours of fake reading

Disengaged reading..Looks like

Sounds likeFeels like

Part 4

• Why meaning breaks down and how to fix it. MONITOR your understanding

Identifying synergistic regulation involving c-Myc and sp1in human tissues

• Read the pages silently. • Highlight in one colour the text you

understand• highlight in another colour the text that is

confusing or difficult to understand.

What are you thinking about as

you embark on this task?

After you have read some of the text..

• Of the parts of the text you highlighted as being hard to understand, could you not read it well because of

• lack of background knowledge?• Vocabulary? • Writing style? • Discuss with someone what they learned about

themselves as readers through the experience, and what they can take back to their work with struggling readers.

• What was your inner voice doing as you read this?

Was it?

• Thinking about what you need to do at school?

• Panicking?• Thinking about what to buy on the way

home for dinner?• Making rude comments about the

activity?• Trying to make connections, question etc

etc

The inner conversation• The fact is that all readers space out when they

read. Kids need to know this or they risk feeling inadequate when it happens to them.

• Once readers are made aware of their inner conversation, they tend to catch themselves quicker and repair meaning if there is a problem.

• Strategies that work. Page 27

Checking on monitoring of comprehension-inconsistent element• An easy and informative technique to see whether

students are monitoring their comprehension is to select a passage on a group’s instructional level, then retype it adding an inconsistent element. Introduce the selection as you would normally do when you are getting students ready to read (tapping prior knowledge, setting a purpose for reading).

• After reading, ask students to comment on what they read.

• They may summarize or relate the information to a personal experience. See if any student points out the inconsistent element.

• Text example- Earthquakes

When meaning has broken down…Reasons for breakdown What can be done about it

run into words that are unknown or unusual

Vocabulary- ask, word substitute, dictionary

Stopped concentrating Re-read or read aloud

Reading too fast Slow down and re-read

Lose thread of content Read in smaller chunks, re-read before and after

Not know enough about the topic Find out more, teacher scaffolding, easier text

Lose visualisations of content Try to find mental pictures, look at source material such as the internet

Can’t see text organisation Know and teach text types so they can be recognised

Didn’t know which strategy to use Explicit teaching of strategies so that students can try appropriate ones.

From the text- Teaching Reading Comprehension Strategies Sheena Cameron

Podcast about monitoring reading

Part 5

Think alouds- strategies to share with students- making the implicit explicit

• Think-Alouds have been described as "eavesdropping on someone's thinking." With this strategy, teachers verbalise aloud while reading a selection orally. Their verbalisations include describing things they're doing as they read to monitor their comprehension. The purpose of the think-aloud strategy is to model for students how skilled readers construct meaning from a text

Sentence starters for think alouds• So far, I've learned...• This made me think of...• That didn't make sense.• I think ___ will happen next.• I reread that part because...• I was confused by...• I think the most important part was...• That is interesting because...• I wonder why...• I just thought of...

Reciprocal think alouds• In reciprocal think-alouds, students are paired with a

partner. • Students take turns thinking aloud as they read a difficult

text. • While the first student is thinking aloud, the second

student listens and records what the first student says. • Then students change roles so that each partner has a

chance to think aloud and to observe the process.• Students reflect on the process together, sharing the

things they tried and discussing what worked well for them and what didn't. As they write about their findings, they can start a mutual learning log that they can refer back to.

Use the checklist to observe my think aloud about the text- Small pox

Summary

• Which strategies to monitor understanding do you think are appropriate for your context?

• How will you introduce this strategy with your staff?

• How might you do any of this with your class?