Co-funded by the Intelligent Energy Europe Programme of the European Union

Thesole responsibility forthe contentofthis publication lieswith the GPP2020projectconsortium.Itdoesnotnecessarily reflect the opinionoftheEuropeanUnion.Neither the EACInorthe EuropeanCommission areresponsible forany use that may be madeofthe informationcontained therein.

NEB for dummies

Hands on non energy benefits

Co-funded by the Horizon2020 Programme of the European Union

The sole responsibility for the content of this publication lies with the STEAM UP project consortium. It does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the

European Union. Neither EASME nor the European Commission are responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.

2

What is NEB?ü Any real or perceived financial or intangible benefit received

from an energy efficiency activity.

3

• Industry juice production:• Energy comsumption:

• Electricity 10.000 MWh• Heavy fuel oil 43.000 MWh

• Proposals• Compressed air 750 MWh (elec.)• Cooling 635 MWh (elec.)• Lighting 235 MWh (elec.)• Process 3.500 MWh (h.f.o.)

• Is this the right focus??

Theresultoftheenergyaudit

Whatare NEBs(co-benefits,totalvalue ofenergy projects)

Ref.

Howcantheybeassessed?• Use the values from research 2.5

•

• Questionaire

• Exact calculation

eg@lokalenergi.dk

Howcantheybeassessed?2• Questionaire

• Change, with positive value

• Change, with negative value

• Change, don’t know value

Howcantheybeassessed?3• Calculation

• Identify and describe the benefits associated with a given measure

• Quantify the impacts

• Asses wich ones it is possible to put monetary value on

• Asses which ones has a positive, negative or neutral value

eg@lokalenergi.dk

9

Casestory– pump ResearchfromDanishproject concludes that coatingcan:

-Protect anewpumpfromcorrosion anderosionandimprovedenergyefficiency

-Renovateandprotect existing pumps,bringthepumpbacktoyear zero,andimprove its energyefficiencycomparedtonew

-Improvedenergyefficiency3-29%

-Extendedlifetime2-3times

See:http://www.eeee.org/conference_proceedings/eceee/2007/Panel_7/7.295/

Soyou saveenergyhowever thevalueofthereducedmaintenance anddowntimeisworthmuchmore

Industrialelectricity use forpumpsinDK10%

Savings due to lower cooling water temperature :153.000 kWh/year or 12.000 US dollar

However, ”what did the company achieve besides saving energy ?”Reduced:

• Use of chemicals 50.000 US dollar/year• Corrosion inhibitorer 12.000 US dollar/year• Reduced corrosion 20.000 US dollar/year• Reduced labour cost not calculated• Reduced down time not calculated• Reduced enviromental influence not calculated• Better working enviroment not calculated

•Pay back less than half a year

CaseProduction ofliquid gasses

Introtoworkshops,sowhat happens ifyougofromhalogentoLEDintheKalkscheune?

What doyou achieve besides saving energy?

• Reduced maintenance LED life 25,000 hours, halogen 1,000 hours.

• Reduced procurement and installation costs.

• Reduced air-conditioning.

• Less heat from LED, less air-con leads to less energy consumed by air-con, less time for air-con means less

maintenance and extended life of air-con.

• LEDs reduce fire risk • May bee reduce insurance cost

• LEDs do not warm people up, which means people stay concentrated longer and more attentive. J

• LEDs give the Kalkscheune a green image

Workshopformgroups with2- 3ineach10mingroup work,5minforpresentation,chose one

• G1- Steam traps

• G2 - Technical insulation

• G3 - Improve boiler efficiency

• G4 - Reduce steam deman

• G5 - Improve condensate recovery

• G6 – Implement a leak seak program for compressed air

• G7 – Use high efficient motors

• G8 – Implement energy efficient design

• G9 – Improve the building insulation(envelope)

• G10 – Implement change of filters i ventilation units due to presure drop over the filter

• G11 – Use of automatic light controls systems

• G12 – Use of sun protections on buildings

NEBassesment process

Steamaudit Steamtrapmanagement

SavingpossibilitiesEnergy

Maintenance

Etc

HandSafety

Productivity

Quality

Onebyone theNEBare discussedwiththepesponsible department,formaintenance asanexample youaskthemaintenance people whatwhatwill ansteam traps maintenancelead to

reduced make upwaterchemical procurementbetter steamqualityetc

Foreach ofthebenefits you will discussItispossible toputmonetary value onthebenefit ornot,ifyes calculate itifnotasses whether thebenefit ispositiveornot

Workshopformgroups with2- 3ineach10mingroup work,5minforpresentation,chose one

• G1- Steam traps

• G2 - Technical insulation

• G3 - Improve boiler efficiency

• G4 - Reduce steam deman

• G5 - Improve condensate recovery

• G6 – Implement a leak seak program for compressed air

• G7 – Use high efficient motors

• G8 – Implement energy efficient design

• G9 – Improve the building insulation(envelope)

• G10 – Implement change of filters i ventilation units due to presure drop over the filter

• G11 – Use of automatic light controls systems

• G12 – Use of sun protections on buildings