12
Amr El Ragaby University of Windsor 401 Sunset Avenue Ontario, Windsor N9B 3P4 Canada Email: [email protected]. Tel: 519-253-3000 ext:2536 New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab Web-Shear Capacity using FRP composite Sheets Yuanli Wu 1 , Amr El Ragaby 2 and Shaohong Cheng 3 1 MASc. Candidate, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, Canada, [email protected]. 2 Assistant Professor, Ph.D., P. Eng, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, Canada, [email protected]. 3 Associate Professor, Ph.D., P. Eng, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, Canada, [email protected]. Abstract Precast, prestressed hollow core (PHC) slabs are among the most common load bearing concrete elements in the world. They are widely used in floors and roofs of office, residential, commercial and industrial buildings. As no shear reinforcement can be provided, due to fabrication restraint, the concrete shear strength is the only source of the shear capacity of PHC slabs. However, in some cases the designer encounters situations where the shear capacity of the slabs is exceeded, typically when large concentrated or line loads are present. Therefore, developing an efficient technique for the strengthening of PHC is essential. The objective of this research project is to explore an innovative application of Fiber-Reinforced Polymers (FRP) composite sheets to increase the web-shear capacity of PHC slabs by installing the sheets along the internal perimeter of the. This paper discusses experimental investigations to explore the feasibility of the new technique by testing the ultimate shear capacity, performance and failure modes of strengthened single I shape, web specimens’ cut- longitudinally out of a full PHC slab. Each I shape web is 305 mm in depth, 300 mm wide “flanges” and 5120 mm long. Carbon FRP sheets were bonded along the full perimeter on each side of the web samples. A total of 8 I-shape web samples were loaded monotonically until failure under single-point loading for a shear span/depth ratio of 2.5. Several parameters have been investigated such as the width of the FRP strengthened zone (300 and 600 mm) and the number of strengthening layers (2 and 4 layers). Test results are presented in terms of ultimate load, mode of failure and load vs strain relationships. Test results showed the efficiency of bonding FRP sheets along the internal perimeter of voids in PHC slabs to enhance the shear strength. Keywords: Prestressed, Hollow-core slabs, Shear, FRP Sheets, Strengthening.

New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

Amr El Ragaby

University of Windsor

401 Sunset Avenue

Ontario, Windsor N9B 3P4

Canada

Email: [email protected].

Tel: 519-253-3000 ext:2536

New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

Web-Shear Capacity using FRP composite Sheets

Yuanli Wu1, Amr El Ragaby2 and Shaohong Cheng3

1 MASc. Candidate, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor, Ontario, Canada,

[email protected].

2 Assistant Professor, Ph.D., P. Eng, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor,

Ontario, Canada, [email protected].

3 Associate Professor, Ph.D., P. Eng, Dept. of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Windsor, Windsor,

Ontario, Canada, [email protected].

Abstract

Precast, prestressed hollow core (PHC) slabs are among the most common load bearing concrete

elements in the world. They are widely used in floors and roofs of office, residential, commercial and

industrial buildings. As no shear reinforcement can be provided, due to fabrication restraint, the

concrete shear strength is the only source of the shear capacity of PHC slabs. However, in some cases

the designer encounters situations where the shear capacity of the slabs is exceeded, typically when

large concentrated or line loads are present. Therefore, developing an efficient technique for the

strengthening of PHC is essential. The objective of this research project is to explore an innovative

application of Fiber-Reinforced Polymers (FRP) composite sheets to increase the web-shear capacity

of PHC slabs by installing the sheets along the internal perimeter of the.

This paper discusses experimental investigations to explore the feasibility of the new technique by

testing the ultimate shear capacity, performance and failure modes of strengthened single I shape, web

specimens’ cut- longitudinally out of a full PHC slab. Each I shape web is 305 mm in depth, 300 mm

wide “flanges” and 5120 mm long. Carbon FRP sheets were bonded along the full perimeter on each

side of the web samples. A total of 8 I-shape web samples were loaded monotonically until failure

under single-point loading for a shear span/depth ratio of 2.5. Several parameters have been

investigated such as the width of the FRP strengthened zone (300 and 600 mm) and the number of

strengthening layers (2 and 4 layers). Test results are presented in terms of ultimate load, mode of

failure and load vs strain relationships. Test results showed the efficiency of bonding FRP sheets along

the internal perimeter of voids in PHC slabs to enhance the shear strength.

Keywords: Prestressed, Hollow-core slabs, Shear, FRP Sheets, Strengthening.

Page 2: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

1. INTRODUCTION

Prestressed concrete hollow core (PHC) slab is a common type of concrete member widely used for

floor and roof deck systems in office, residential, commercial and industrial buildings. Their

applications in wall panels and bridge deck units are also very popular. Compared to a massive floor

slab of equal thickness and due to the tubular voids extended over the entire slab, PHC slab is much

lighter, which saves both transportation and fabrication costs. Its reduced thickness would help to

conserve headroom, which is particularly important for multi-story buildings. Figure 1 shows a typical

cross-section of a PHC slab Prestressed strands are provided to the PHC slabs not only to increase

their strength but also reduce deformation under normal conditions. Compared to an ordinary

reinforced concrete slab, a PHC slab with the same resistance capacity can save 40% to 50% of steel

and 20% to 40% of concrete due to the prestressing forces [1].

Figure 1. Typical cross-section of PHC slab

Although PHC slabs are generally designed to resist flexural stress induced by assumed uniformly

distributed loads, in practice, they could also be subjected to concentrated load or line load which

would possibly lead to shear failure, in particular, over regions close to the end support. However, the

dry cast or extrusion technique used to manufacture PHC slabs makes it difficult to provide shear

reinforcement during manufacturing processes. Thus, PHC slabs typically rely on the shear strength of

plain concrete to resist shear stresses. One of the typical shear failure modes of PHC slabs is web shear

failure. It occurs when the maximum principle stress resulted from the combined effect of shear and

bending exceeds the tensile strength of concrete. The failure is mainly induced by a diagonal crack

formed in the PHC slab web at the critical section near the support.

According to existing studies [1, 2], there are a number of factors that could influence the shear

capacity of PHC slabs. Among these, the most important ones are identified to be: a) Size of the cross

section: the depth of slab can directly affect its ultimate shearing strength, just as beams [3]; b) Level

of prestressing: number and distribution pf prestressed reinforcement would alter the shear capacity of

PHC slabs [5, 6]; c) Concrete properties: this is an important parameter since it will determine the

compressive and tensile strengths [1,3]; d) Shear span/depth ratio: this parameter would also affect the

ultimate shear capacity of PHC slabs. The critical shear span/depth ratio was found to range between 2

and 3 [6]; and e) The interaction between adjacent webs on the shear strength of prestressed concrete

hollow-core units which may lead up to 20% increase in the shear capacity [4] . Therefore, if the shear

capacity of the PHC slab webs can be enhanced, the shear capacity of the entire PHC slab can be

increased as well [1, 2, 3]. Currently, the common practice is to either fill the voids with additional

concrete or use thicker slabs to satisfy the shear strength requirement. However, both solutions would

add cost, increase self-weight and thus reduce the economy of PHC slabs. Therefore, there is an urgent

Page 3: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

need to develop an efficient technique to strengthen the shear capacity of PHC slabs while still retain

its advantages.

In recent years, externally bonded fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) composite sheets have been

successfully used in the rehabilitation and strengthening of the flexural and shear capacity of

reinforced concrete beams and slabs. In particular, the effectiveness of strengthening the shear

capacity of RC beams and slabs using externally bonded FRP sheets was confirmed through several

experimental investigation. It was found that RC elements strengthened in shear using FRP sheets

showed up to 60% increase in the shear capacity over the un-strengthened ones. Several parameters

were found to significantly affect the strengthening technique which includes the orientation of FRP

sheets with the longitudinal axis of the RC element, the bonding surface and bonding agent, type of

FRP sheets, amount (thickness) of FRP and the width of the strengthened zone. The available

investigations confirmed also that the externally bonded GFRP technique could be used to enhance the

shear capacity of reinforced concrete web elements such as T-beams [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13].

Enlightened by these existing experience, the authors are keen to extend similar technique to

strengthen shear capacity of PHC slabs. It is proposed to bond carbon FRP sheets along the full

perimeter of PHC slab voids to enhance its shear strength. Extensive experimental testing and finite

element modelling have being carried out at The University of Windsor to investigate the effect of

FRP sheets bonded along the full perimeter of slab voids on the performance of PHC slabs. The

investigated parameters include the depth of PHC slabs, the prestressing level (number of prestressing

strands in one web), the type and thickness (number of layers) of FRP sheets as well as the width of

the strengthened zone and the shear span/depth ration. To explore the feasibility and effectiveness of

this new technique in terms of the enhancement of ultimate shear capacity and failure modes and to

optimize the effect of different test parameters, the technique was applied first to I-shaped single web

beams cut longitudinally from the full PHC slabs, which can be considered as single web hollow core

slabs. This paper focuses on the experimental results of full scale I-shaped single web beams, which

are longitudinally cut out from PHC slabs and externally strengthened by Carbon FRP (CFRP) sheets

bonded along the full perimeter on both sides of the specimen, as shown in Figure 2. The studied

parameters included the width of the strengthened zone and the thickness, the number of layers, of

CFRP sheets.

Figure 2. Proposed shear strengthening techniques for single web hollow-core slabs

FRP

Web Beam

Page 4: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

2. EXPERIMENT PROGRAM

2.1. Specimen Design

A total of eight I-shaped single web beams, cut from full PHC slabs, were used in the experimental

study. All the specimens had a length of 4575 mm, a depth of 300 mm and a width of 284 mm, which

represents the centre to centre distance between two adjacent webs in a full PHC slab. Each specimen

had two longitudinal prestressed steel strands, each of 13 mm diameter, at the bottom. All specimens

were tested over a simply supported clear span of 4499 mm while the bearing width at each support is

76 mm. The support condition is a pin at the loading end and a roller on the other end, so that no axial

forces are generated by rotation or the constraint of the web beams at the support. One concentrated

load was applied monotonically till failure at a distance of 750 mm from the pin support via a very

stiff steel plate of 190 mm width. This results in a shear span to depth ratio (a/d) of 2.5. The details of

the experimental test setup is shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Details of experimental setup

Among the eight specimens, two of them are used as control beams, (W2-C1 and W2-C2), for which

no FRP sheets were applied, where “W” represents web beam specimen, “2” represents two

prestressed steel strands, and “C” represents control beam. Three different widths of the strengthened

zone of 300 mm, 450 mm and 600 mm were investigated. In addition, two different thicknesses of

FRP strengthening, two layers FRP sheets (one layer per side) and four FRP layers (two layers per

side) were investigated. The ID of the rest six specimens is defined to include these characteristics of

FRP sheets with a pattern of W2-number of FRP sheets-length of FRP sheets. For example, in

specimen W2-4-300, four FRP sheets (two on each side) of 300 mm length are externally bonded to

the web beam specimen that has 2 prestressing strands. Table 1 lists the details of each specimen.

Page 5: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

2.2. Instrumentations

Each PHC web specimen was instrumented at the loaded end. As shown in Figure 4(a), two linear

variable displacement transducers (LVDT) were installed, one at the loaded end on one prestressing

strand to measure its end slippage during tests and another at the top flange of the beam specimen

adjacent to the load to measure vertical displacement. In addition, four displacement transducers,

Pi-gauges, were used to measure strain at different locations. One is placed on the surface of the

specimen top flange in the longitudinal direction near the loading position to measure the top concrete

compressive strain while the other three transducers were arranged in the longitudinal direction along

the centre line of the web in the shear-tension region. These three critical points are calculated

according to EN 1168 code, FE model predication and CAN/CSA-A23.3-04 code [14, 15,16]. In

addition, three electrical foil strain gauges were glued on the face of the FRP sheets, in the vertical

direction at the centre point of each Pi-gauge to monitor FRP tensile strain (Figure 4-b).

Table 1. Parameters of PHC web specimens used in the experimental study

No. Specimen-ID No. of FRP Sheets Strengthened zone width (mm)

1 W2-C1 0 0

2 W2-C2 0 0

2 W2-2-300 2 300

3 W2-2-450 2 450

4 W2-2-600 2 600

6 W2-4-300 4 300

7 W2-4-450 4 450

8 W2-4-600 4 600

(a) Control Specimen (b) Typical strengthened specimen

Figure 4. Details of the instrumentation layout

2.3. Material properties

The test specimens were constructed using the same batch of normal-weight concrete with an average

28-day compressive strength of 60 MPa. A total of thirty 100 × 200 mm and fifteen 150 × 300 mm

cylinders were prepared and cured under the same conditions as their reference slabs to evaluate the

Page 6: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

compressive and tensile strength of concrete at the test time. SikaWrap-900C CFRP sheets and

Sikadur300 Epoxy were used in strengthening the PHC web specimens. The SikaWrap-900C is a

uni-directional, fleece stabilized, stitched and heavy carbon fiber fabric for the wet application process

of structural strengthening. The mechanical properties of the FRP sheets with epoxy resin, provided by

the supplier and determined by tensile tests on representative samples in accordance with ASTM

D3039 [17], showed a linear-elastic stress-strain relationship with average values of elastic modulus

and tensile strength of 100 GPa and 1120 MPa, respectively [18]. The prestressing strands are 7-wire,

low-relaxation strands which have a diameter of 13 mm and ultimate tensile strength of 1860 MPa.

2.4. Preparation of test specimens

The specimens were fabricated, cured and cut at the supplier site, then were shipped to the Structures

lab at the University of Windsor for testing. The specimen surface where the FRP sheets would be

applied was cleaned and polished using a steel brush drum derived by a drill, in the same way as the

full PHC slab specimen were cleaned, before attaching the FRP sheets. The uni-directional FRP sheets

were applied in the vertical direction to the web surface using a wet layup process. Both the CFRP

sheets and the concrete surface were first saturated by epoxy resin, then the sheets were directly

bonded to the specimen surface, as shown in Figure 5. The direction of FRP fibres were oriented in the

direction of the web depth, perpendicular to the longitudinal axis of beams. They were left for curing

for 7 days indoor before testing.

Figure 5. Hollow-core slabs single webs strengthened in shear with carbon FRP sheets

2.5. Testing procedures

Finite element model using ABAQUS [16] software was developed for the control test specimen to

predict the ultimate capacity. The FEM predicted a shear failure mode and an ultimate capacity of the

control test specimen of 82.7 kN. Following the Deutsche Norm. (2008) [14], the load was applied in

two steps. The specimens were first loaded to 70% of the estimated failure load, 57 kN, at a rate of 10

kN per minute then unloaded. In the second load cycle, the load was applied monotonically at the

same rate until failure.

3. EXPERIMENTAL TEST RESULT AND OBSERVATIONS

3.1. Cracking behaviour and failure mode

The two control specimens showed almost identical behaviour. At 30 kN, the first crack appeared at

Page 7: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

the bottom surface near the loading end at the face of the bearing plate. Close to failure load, an

inclined crack initiated at the support and propagated quickly through the beam web up to the top

flange close to the loading plate, over the entire shear-tension region with a distance of 780 mm from

the support. The maximum width of this critical shear crack was 3.2 mm. There was no formation of

vertical flexural crack prior to beam failure. Both W2-1C and W2-2C failed suddenly in diagonal shear

at ultimate load of 81.5 kN and 76.3, respectively. An average value of 78.9 kN for the ultimate shear

capacity of the control specimens will be considered in the comparisons. Figure 6(a) shows the typical

cracking and failure shape of the control specimens.

Figure 6(d) shows a typical cracking pattern and failure shape of W2-2-Series specimens. The first

vertical crack of W2-2-450 web beam appeared at the bottom of the flange at loading end when load

was 13 kN. When the load reached 79.9 kN, a critical inclined crack initiated at the inner edge of the

support bearing plate at the loading end and grew upwards till reached top flange of the specimen at

the inner edge of the loading plate. The horizontal distance between the crack top end and the beam

loading end was measured to be 715 mm, and the maximum crack width was 2.0 mm. No formation of

vertical flexural crack was observed before beam failure. The failure mode of this specimen belonged

to shear failure, too.

(a) W2-C1 (b) W2-4-600

(c) W2-4-300 (d) W2-2-450

Figure 6. Web beam failure results

W2-4-series specimens showed different cracking behaviour before failure. The cracking pattern and

failure mode of W2-4-300 web beam is shown in Figure 6(c). The first vertical crack appeared at the

bottom of the loading end when the load reached only 10 kN. Further, in all three cases, vertical

Page 8: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

flexural crack(s) formed at the bottom of the beam close to mid-span prior to beam failure. In the case

of W2-4-300, one such crack appeared at around 90 kN, whereas two vertical flexural cracks were

observed in W2-4-450 and W2-4-600, when the load reached respectively around 80 kN and 100 kN.

This results in more ductile behaviour before failure. The critical inclined crack initiated at the

specimen bottom at 174 mm from the pin support at the loading end and extended to the top flange

close to the middle of the loading plate. The recorded ultimate shear failure load was 102.1 kN.

Further, the critical shear cracks in both W2-2-450 and W2-4-300 web beams were observed to grow

through the beam web. In all the strengthened specimens, no de-bonding or delamination of the FRP

sheets was observed at all before failure. FRP sheets were de-attached manually from the concrete

surface to study the main inclined shear crack.

3.2. Enhancement of the ultimate shear capacity

The testing results of the 8 web beam specimens are summarized in Table 2. The average shear failure

load of W2-C control web beams is 78.9. This value is in very good agreement with the FEM

predicted ultimate capacity of 82.7 kN which yields that the finite element simulation overestimates

the actual shear capacity by only 4%. The failure load of W2-2-300, W2-2-450 and W2-2-600 are 76.8

kN, 77.9 kN and 83.5 kN, respectively, which implies that using two layers of FRP sheets to

strengthen the shear capacity of the studied web beam is not adequate. More tests are needed to

confirm this finding. The failure mode of the W2-2-Series specimens remains the same as that of the

control beam, i.e. failed in brittle shear failure mode. However, shear capacity of the W2-4-Series

webs were found to be greatly enhanced with the application of the proposed shear strengthening

technique. Compared to the shear failure load of the control beam, the ultimate shear failure load of

W2-4-300, W2-4-450 and W2-4-600 are 102.1 kN, 99.6 kN and 114.2 respectively. It can be

concluded that the shear capacity of PHC webs increased by 29.4%, 26.2% and 44.7% when 4 layers

of CFRP sheets were bonded to the web surface for a length of 300, 450 and 600 mm respectively.

These results imply that by increasing the thickness, number of layers, of FRP sheets and the width of

the strengthened zone, shear capacity of the studied web beams can be considerably increased.

Table 2. Test results of PHC slabs web specimens

Specimen-ID No. of FRP Sheets Failure load (kN) Improving

No. of Flexural

cracks

before failure

W2-C1 0 81.5 - 0

W2-C2 0 76.3 - 0

W2-2-300 2 76.8 - 0

W2-2-450 2 79.9 - 0

W2-2-600 2 83.5 (8.7%) 0

W2-4-300 4 102.1 29.4% 1 (at 90 kN)

W2-4-450 4 99.6 26.2% 2 (at 80 kN)

W2-4-600 4 114.2 44.7% 2 (at 100 kN)

Page 9: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

3.3. Load deflection behaviour and ductility

Figure 7(a) shows the load-displacement relationships of the control beam and the three W2-2 series

specimens. The trend and pattern of the four curves are found to be very similar. Besides, the

maximum displacements of the four beams at the loading position are almost the same, which are

about 4-5 mm which indicates sudden and brittle shear failure occurred in these four specimens. On

the other hand, in the case of the W2-4-series specimens, the maximum displacement at the loading

point are much larger. In particular, as can be seen from Figure 7(b), it exceeded 10 mm in W2-4-450

and W2-4-600. This is more than two times of that of the control beams and clearly shows the

improvement in the ductility of the W2-4 series specimen with 2 layers of FRP sheets bonded at each

side of the web. Further, although W2-4-600 specimens exhibit the best shear strengthening effects in

terms of enhancing shear capacity and ductility, considerable improvement was also achieved in

W2-4-300 and W2-4-450 specimens. Compared to 600 mm wide, CFRP strengthened zones with

widths of 300 mm and 450 mm would be easier to install and make the application of the proposed

shear strengthening technique more feasible in real application.

(a) W2-2-Series results

(b) W2-4-Series results

Figure 7. Load deflection behaviour

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 5 10 15 20

Load (

kN

)

Deflection (mm)

W2-C1

W2-2-300

W2-2-450

W2-2-600

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 5 10 15 20

Load (

kN

)

Deflection (mm)

W2-C1

W2-4-300

W2-4-450

W2-4-600

Page 10: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

3.4. Strain behaviour

Figure 8 shows the load vs longitudinal tensile strain (vertical direction of the webs) relationship

measured on FRP sheets at the longitudinal centre line of the web, 225 (dv) mm away from the support.

It can be noticed that the relation is bilinear for all the strengthened specimens with 300 mm and 600

mm width. Up to about 80 kN load, the measured strains of the FRP sheets are very small and less

than the cracking strain of the concrete. Beyond the 80 kN load limit, the strain increases rapidly in the

FRP sheets in W2-4-300 and W2-4-600 and exceeds the cracking strain of the concrete. This indicates

that after the first shear crack developed in concrete, the 4 layers of FRP sheets acts as stirrups and

contributes to resisting the tensile strains in the vertical direction, thus provide the enhancement in the

overall shear capacity.

Figure 8. Load vs longitudinal tensile strain in FRP sheets relationships

4. INTERFACE BETWEEN FRP AND CONCRETE

The bonding condition between FRP sheets and concrete surface directly governs the effect of shear

strengthening. Inspections on the failure regions of specimens tested in the current study showed that

the FRP sheets demonstrated an excellent bonding performance. As can be seen from Figure 9(a) that

there is no damage of the FRP sheet itself, nor to their interface to concrete. It still bonds perfectly

with the concrete surface even after shear failure occurred. This could be mainly attributed to the

limited displacement under shear failure and the high bonding capacity of the epoxy resin. In addition,

it was very hard to take off the FRP sheets after the tests. When peeled off mechanically after failure, it

can be noticed that part of the concrete surface still attaches to the sheet, as shown in Figure 9(b).

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Load (

kN

)

Strain (Microstrain)

W2-2-300

W2-2-600

W2-4-300

W2-4-600

Page 11: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

(a) at failure (b) After mechanically peel off

Figure 9. Interface between FRP and concrete

5. CONCLUSION

This paper proposed a new method to strengthen shear capacity of PHC slabs by installing the FRP

sheets along the internal perimeter of the slab voids. To explore the feasibility and effectiveness of this

new technique, this paper focuses on the experimental results of full scale I-shaped single web beams,

which are longitudinally cut out from PHC slabs and externally strengthened by Carbon FRP (CFRP)

sheets bonded along the full perimeter on both sides of the specimen, The studied parameters included

the width of the strengthened zone and the thickness, the number of layers, of CFRP sheets. According

to the experimental data and analysis, the following conclusions can be obtained:

1. The testing data indicates that minimum FRP thickness and strengthened zone width are

required to obtain satisfactory strengthening effects.

2. The experimental results show that the shear capacity of web beams strengthened with four

sheets have a significant increase, about 20 to 40% increase which indicates the new technique

is effective for shear strengthening for single web hollow core slabs when amount of

strengthening FRP sheets is adequate. So it would be effective for whole hollow core slabs

with a great chance.

3. Strengthening the PHC slab webs with 4 CFRP sheets, 2 on each side, not only increases the

ultimate shear capacity, but also enhanced their ductile behaviour before failure. Also, the

shear-tension region is reduced and the flexural region is increased at the same time.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The authors wish to express their gratitude and sincere appreciation for the financial support received

from the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC), through Engage

program. The contribution made by Prestressed Concrete Inc (PSI) and SIKA Canada for supplying

experimental specimens and materials is gratefully acknowledged. The help received from the

technical staff of the Structural Laboratory in the department of civil and environmental engineering at

the University of Windsor is also acknowledged.

Page 12: New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab …conmat15.ic-impacts.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Paper456_Wu.pdf · New Technique for Strengthening the Hollow-core Slab

REFERENCES

[1] A. R. Anderson. (1976). Shear Strength of Prestressed Concrete Beams. Technical Bulletin

76-B11/B12, Concrete Technology Associates, Tacoma, WA, Nov, 45 p.

[2] K. D. Palmer and A. E. Schultz. (2010). Factors Affecting Web-Shear Capacity of Deep Hollow

core Unit. PCI Journal, Vol. 55, No. 2, pp. 123-146.

[3] N. M. Hawkins and S. K. Ghosh. (2006). Shear Strength of Hollow core Slabs. PCI Journal, Vol.

51, No. 1, pp. 110-114.

[4] Cheng, S. and Wang, X. (2010). Impact of Interaction between adjacent webs on the shear strength

of prestressed concrete hollow-core units. PCI Journal, summer 2010, pp. 46-63.

[5] Celal, M. S. (2011). Shear Behaviour of Precast/Prestressed Hollow core Slabs. A Thesis

submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies of The University of Manitoba. The University of

Manitoba.

[6] Yang, L. (1994). Design of Prestressed Hollow Core Slabs with Reference to Web Shear Failure.

Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, V. 120, No. 9, pp. 2675-2696.

[7] ACI Committee 318. (2011). Building Code Requirements for Structural Concrete (ACI 318-11)

and Commentary (ACI 318R-11). American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, Michigan.

[8] Berset J. D. (1992) Strengthening of reinforced concrete beams for shear using FRP composites.

Department of civil and environmental engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

[9] Chajes. M. J, Januszka. T. F, Nertz. D. R, Thomason. Jr. T. A. and Jr. W. W. (1995). Shear

Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beams Using Externally Applied Composite Fibers. ACI

Structural Journal, Vol. 92, pp295-303.

[10] T. C. Triantafillou. (1998). Shear Strengthening of Reinforced Concrete Beams Using

Epoxy-Bonded FRP Composites. ACI Structural Journal, Vol. 95pp: 107-115.

[11] M.C. Sundarraja and S. Rajamohan. (2008). Shear Strengthening of RC Beams Using GFRP

Vertical Strips –An Experimental Study. Journal of Reinforced Plastics and Composites, Vol. 27,

No. 14, pp. 1477–1495.

[12] M.C. Sundarraja and S. Rajamohan. (2009). Strengthening of RC beams in shear using GFRP

inclined strips – An experimental study. Construction and Building Materials 23. pp. 856–864.

[13] A.K. Panigrahi, K.C. Biswal, M.R. Barik. (2014). Strengthening of shear deficient RC T-beams

with externally bonded GFRP sheets. Construction and Building Materials 57, pp. 81–91.

[14] Deutsche Norm. (2008). Precast Concrete Products–Hollow Core Slabs (includes Amendment

A1:2008). DIN EN 1168-08, CEN-European Committee for Standardization, Brussels, Belgium.

[15] Canadian Standard Association (CSA). (2004). Design of Concrete Structures,

CAN/CSA-A23.3-04. Canadian Standards Association, Rexdale, ON, Canada.

[16] ABAQUS 6.14 (2014). ABAQUS user’s manual.

[17] ASTM D3039/D3039M (2014). Standard Test Method for Tensile Properties of Polymer Matrix

Composite Materials. ASTM Committee D30 on Composite Materials.

[18] SIKA CANADA, Structural engineering solution and products,

http://can.sika.com/en/solutions_products/document_download/Structural_Strengthening.html?ord

erBy=size&orderDir=asc