Notifiable Transaction 200910

  • Upload
    ailcp

  • View
    247

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    1/107

    1

    Notifiable Transactions

    Sammy Chau / Katherine Man

    Assistant Vice President

    Compliance and Monitoring Department

    Listing Division, HKEx

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    2/107

    22

    Agenda

    I. General

    II. Definition of transaction

    III. Classification of transactions and size tests computation

    IV. Announcement, circular and shareholder approval requirements

    V. Special considerations for transactions

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    3/107

    3

    I. General

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    4/107

    4

    Purposes of NT Rules

    Who are subject to NT Rules?

    Points to note

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    5/107

    5

    Purposes of NT Rules

    Assess the impact of a transaction:

    Shareholders are informed

    Shareholders can vote on significant transactions

    Reinforce the general disclosure principle of price-sensitive information

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    6/107

    66

    Who are subject to NT Rules? (1)

    Listedissuer means:

    - the listed issuer itself; and

    - its subsidiaries.

    Subsidiary includes:

    (a) subsidiaryundertaking under the Companies Ordinance;

    (b) a consolidated subsidiary under HKFRS / IFRS; and

    (c) an acquisition target to be consolidated in the next auditedconsolidated accounts.

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    7/10777

    Who are subject to NT Rules? (2)

    Are transactions conducted via a jointly controlled entity (JCE) subject toNT Rules?

    Listco A Company X

    JCE 1

    Listco A Company Y

    JCE 2

    50% * 50% 51% * 49%

    Example 1 Example 2

    * Listco A does not have control over JCE 1 and 2

    Note: See FAQ Series 7 No. 1

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    8/10788

    Who are subject to NT Rules? (3)

    Are transactions conducted via an associated company subject to NTRules?

    Listco A Company Z

    Associated Co.

    30% 70%

    Example

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    9/1079

    A notifiable transaction may also be subject to other Rules, e.g.

    Disclosure of price-sensitive information

    Advances to entities

    Connected transactions

    Spin-offs

    Points to note

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    10/10710

    II. Definition of transaction

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    11/10711

    Definition oftransaction

    Examples

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    12/1071212

    Definition of transaction

    The Rules set out a non-exhaustive list.

    They are principally outside the issuers ordinary and usual course of

    business and/or have an impact on the issuers operation, e.g.

    a) Acquisition or disposal of assets

    b) An option to subscribe for shares or buy or sell assets

    c) Entering into or terminating a finance lease

    d) Entering into or terminating operating leases with significantimpact on the companys operation

    e) Providing financial assistance

    f) Formation of JV

    Exclude some transactions of a revenue nature in the ordinary and usual

    course of business

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    13/10713

    Example 1 Acquisition of properties

    Listco A

    Acquisitionof a property

    Fact:

    Listco A is engaged in property development and property investmentbusinesses.

    Is the acquisition of a property by Listco A subject to NT Rules?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    14/10714

    Example 2 Placing & top-up subscription

    (Listing Decision 75-3)

    Before placing &subscription

    After placing, but beforesubscription

    After placing &subscription

    Listco A

    Listco B

    46 shares (46%)

    Listco A

    Listco B

    36 shares (36%)

    Listco A

    Listco B

    46 shares (42%)

    Whether the placing and top-up subscription constitute a transaction forListco A?

    Fact:

    Listco B conducts a standard top-up placing and subscription exercise.

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    15/10715

    Example 3 Placing deposits to a non-banking company

    Does placing of deposits by Listco A to Company X constitute a transaction?

    Parent Co.

    Listco A(PRC issuer)

    Company X(a non banking

    finance company)Place deposits

    >50%>50%

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    16/10716

    Example 4 Treasury activities

    (Listing Decision 53-2)

    Listco A

    Appoint a fund manager to manageand invest surplus cash

    Whether the above investment activities constitute a transaction?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    17/10717

    Example 5 Self construction of a factory

    Listco(Car manufacturer)

    Land

    BuildingMaterials

    Whether the acquisitions of land and building materials will betreated as a transaction?

    Car manufacturing

    factory

    Aggregation does not apply when:

    an asset is being constructed, developed or refurbished by or onbehalf of a listed issuer for its own use in its ordinary and usualcourse of businesswhere the sole basis for aggregation is rule14.23(3)*

    * Form parts of one asset

    Construct into

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    18/10718

    III. Classification of transactions and

    size tests computation

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    19/107

    19

    Classification of NT

    5 size tests

    General principles

    Specific circumstances

    Alternative size tests

    Aggregation of transactions

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    20/107

    20

    Classification of NT

    NT category Size test results

    Share transaction Acquisition of assets and the consideration involvessecurities for which listing is sought

    All percentage ratios are less than 5%

    Discloseable transaction 5% or above, but all below 25%

    Major transaction 25% or above, but all below 75% (for disposal) or 100% (foracquisition)

    Very substantial disposal (VSD) 75% or above

    Very substantial acquisition (VSA) 100% or above

    Reverse takeover(RTO) See definition in MB R14.06(6)/ GEM R19.06(6)

    A transaction involving both an acquisition and a disposal will be classified by referenceto the larger of the acquisition or disposal.

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    21/107

    21

    5 size tests (1)

    Assets ratio Total assets of the subject of the transaction

    Total assets of the issuer

    Profits ratio Profits* attributable to the subject of the transaction

    Profits* of the issuer

    * means net profit before taxation and minority interests

    Revenue ratio Revenue** attributable to the subject of the transaction

    Revenue** of the issuer

    ** means revenue arising from the principal activities of the entity

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    22/107

    22

    5 size tests (2)

    Consideration ratio Consideration

    Issuers total market capitalisation***

    *** means the average closing price of the issuers securities for the 5business days immediately before the transaction date

    Equity capital ratio Nominal value of the issuers equity capital issued as consideration

    Nominal value of the issuers existing equity capital

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    23/107

    23

    General principles (1)

    1. The source of issuers figures is its published information.

    2. The source of targets figures is its audited accounts or other acceptableaccounts.

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    24/107

    24

    General principles (2)

    3. Acquisition/ disposal of equity capital

    resulting in consolidation/ de-consolidation?

    Yes - 100%

    No - % bought or sold

    4. Transaction via non wholly owned subsidiary

    Same size test computation as for transactions via wholly ownedsubsidiary

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    25/107

    25

    Specific circumstances: Deemed disposal (1)

    Assets, profits and revenue ratios

    Consideration ratio:

    = Value of the shares issued to allottees, excluding those issued for

    maintaining the allottees % interest in the subsidiary

    Results in de-consolidation fromissuers account

    100% of the target

    Remain consolidated/ de-consolidated % of the equity interest decreased

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    26/107

    26

    Specific circumstances: Deemed disposal (2)

    Before After

    Listco A

    Subsidiary B

    90%(90 shares)

    Mr. X

    10%(10 shares)

    Listco A

    Subsidiary B

    82%(90 shares)

    Mr. X

    18%(20 shares)

    Numerator for the consideration ratio

    No. of shares required for Mr. X to maintain his interest in Subsidiary B

    = 110 shares x 10% = 11 shares

    Numerator for the consideration ratio:

    = (20 shares 11 shares) x fair value of the shares

    Example: Computation of consideration ratio

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    27/107

    27

    Specific circumstances: Financial assistance

    Assets ratio &Consideration ratio

    Value of the financial assistance + any monetaryadvantage

    Revenue ratio &

    Profits ratio

    Annual interest income (if any)

    Equity capital ratio NA

    How should the percentage ratios apply to provision of financialassistance by an issuer?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    28/107

    28

    Specific circumstances: Formation of JV

    (Listing Decision 2-1)

    Under the JV agreement:

    Total investment cost: RMB330 million

    Registered capital: RMB110 million(contributed in cash)

    The difference will be funded by proceedsfrom property sales, bank loans orshareholders loan

    Listco B JV partner

    JV Company

    60% 40%

    Which percentage ratios are applicable?

    What should be the numerator of the percentage ratios?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    29/107

    29

    Specific circumstances: When the consideration differs from

    the asset value (R14.15(1))

    Consideration: $50 million

    Market price of the consideration shares: HK$70 million

    Fair value of the property: HK$100 million

    What should be the numerator of the consideration ratio?

    Listco CAcquisition of a property

    Settled by consideration shares

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    30/107

    30

    Specific circumstances: When the consideration cannot be

    determined (FAQ Series 7- No. 8)

    Under the agreement, Listco D has to pay:

    cash consideration: HK$1 million; plus

    future amount payable upon completion,

    which is based on the valuation of theTarget at the time of completion

    How should Listco D calculate the consideration ratio?

    Listco D

    Target

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    31/107

    31

    Issuers cannot exercise discretion:

    Grant of option a transaction

    Exercise or transfer of option not a transaction

    Issuers can exercise discretion:

    Grant of option normally not a transaction unless there is a premium

    Exercise or transfer of option a transaction

    Specific circumstances: Option arrangements (1)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    32/107

    32

    Specific circumstances: Option arrangements (2)

    Prior approval for exercise of option

    At the time of entering into an option, issuer may seek shareholder approvalfor the exercise of the option.

    Shareholder approval is not required upon exercise of the option if: the relevant information is disclosed to shareholders; and

    no change of the relevant facts at the time of exercise

    No similar provision in the connected transaction Rules

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    33/107

    33

    Alternative size tests

    We may disregard a size test calculation if:

    it produces an anomalous result; or

    it is inappropriate to the sphere of activity of the issuer.

    Issuers must provide appropriate alternative tests for our consideration.

    We will consider:

    substance of transactions and not only their legal form

    whether size tests results vary significantly

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    34/107

    34

    Example 1 Acquisition of listed securities as investment

    (FAQ Series 7- No. 12)

    Size tests Numerators of the alternative test

    Assets ratio Fair value of shares being acquired

    Profits/ revenue ratio Dividend income

    Fact:

    Listco A proposes to acquire 5% interest in Target X as an investment whichwill be classified as available for sale financial assets.

    Our view:

    How should Listco A compute the assets, profits and revenue ratios?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    35/107

    35

    Example 2 Group restructuring

    (Listing Decision 62-2)

    Before After

    Listco B

    Subsidiary X Subsidiary Y

    Target

    100% 70%

    Listco B

    Subsidiary X Subsidiary Y

    Target

    100% 70%

    Facts:

    Disposal of 100% in Target by Listco B (through Subsidiary X)

    Acquisition of 100% in Target by Listco B (through Subsidiary Y)

    100% 100%

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    36/107

    36

    Aggregation of transactions

    Prevent circumvention of Rules by splitting a transaction

    Aggregation of a series of transactions:

    completed within 12 months or

    are otherwise related.

    Non-exhaustive factors we consider:

    with the same party or parties connected

    involve interests in one particular company or group of companies

    parts of one asset lead to substantial involvement in a new business

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    37/107

    37

    Points to note (1)

    Aggregation is not automatic only because one factor is triggered.

    We will also consider the effect of aggregation:

    whether aggregation would result in a higher transaction classification.

    New classification only applies to current transaction.

    FirstTransaction

    SecondTransaction

    If aggregated Will aggregationresult in a higher

    classification?

    SecondTransaction

    Major Discloseable Major No Discloseable

    Major Discloseable VSA Yes VSA

    e.g.

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    38/107

    38

    Points to note (2)

    Prior consultation with the Exchange

    Exceptions:

    The issuer has already decided to aggregate the proposed transactionwith the previous transaction(s)

    The proposed transaction, even when aggregated with the previoustransaction(s), will not be a NT

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    39/107

    39

    Example 1 Acquisition of machinery from related suppliers

    (Listing Decision 64-1)

    Facts:

    Listco A proposes to acquire different models of machinery frommembers of Group X (a major supplier) under different contracts.

    The machinery acquired under each contract is functional on its ownand does not form part of an assembled machine.

    Each contract was negotiated independently.

    Will the Exchange aggregate acquisitions of machinery?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    40/107

    40

    Example 2 Acquisition of adjacent lands

    (Listing Decision 64-2)

    Facts:

    Listco B acquired Land 1 in June.

    It acquires Land 2 one month later.

    Land 1 and 2 are adjacent to each other.

    They will be re-developed into a single residential property for sale.

    The 2 acquisitions are not inter-conditional.

    Will the Exchange aggregate acquisitions of Land 1 and 2?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    41/107

    41

    IV. Announcement, circular and shareholder approvalrequirements

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    42/107

    42

    Overview

    Suspension

    Announcement

    Shareholder approval Circular

    Documentary requirements for listing applications by listed issuers

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    43/107

    43

    Overview

    Transaction

    Type

    Notify

    ExchangeSuspension

    Publish

    Announce-

    ment

    Shareholders

    approval

    Publish

    Circular

    Accountants

    report

    Treated

    as new

    listing

    Share

    transaction

    Yes Yes Yes No if shares

    are issued

    under general

    mandate

    No No No

    Discloseable Yes No, unless

    PSI

    Yes No No No No

    Major Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes for

    acquisition

    No

    VSD Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No

    VSA Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No

    RTO Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    44/107

    44

    When required?

    A short suspension is required for

    a share transaction, major transaction, VSA, VSD or RTO; or

    any discloseable transaction which is price sensitive,until publication of the announcement.

    Suspension

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    45/107

    45

    Announcement (1)

    When required?

    Initial announcement

    After finalisation of the terms of a NT

    Further announcements

    Expert reports

    Exploration for natural resources activities

    Profit forecast

    within 21 days after discloseable transaction announcement

    Poll results

    after general meeting

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    46/107

    46

    Announcement (2)

    When required?

    Further announcements (contd)

    Changes after initial announcement: termination of a previously announced NT

    material change in terms of the NT

    material delay in completion of the agreement

    Option arrangements: expiry of the option

    option holder notifying the grantor of non-exercise of the option

    transfer of the option to a third party

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    47/107

    47

    Announcement (3)

    Content requirements

    General principle

    Information must be clearly presented, and must be accurate andcomplete in all material respects and not be misleading or deceptive

    Specific disclosures

    e.g. - general nature of the transaction

    - description of the target

    - terms of the transaction (e.g. consideration)

    - reasons for and impact of the transaction

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    48/107

    48

    Announcement (4)

    Common pitfalls

    Frequent omissions:

    Principal business activities of the counterparty

    Date of the transaction and independence of the counterparty Value of the subject asset

    Net profits of the target asset

    Gain or loss on disposal and the basis of calculation

    Inadequate disclosures: Basis of consideration

    Reasons for entering into the transaction

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    49/107

    49

    Announcement (5)

    Waivers from disclosure requirements

    Granted only in limited circumstances

    We will consider:

    materiality of the information

    alternative disclosures proposed by the issuer

    sufficient information for shareholders/ investors to make an informedinvestment decision

    unduly burdensome/ impractical

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    50/107

    50

    Example Waiver from disclosure requirements

    Facts

    Listco A proposes a major acquisition involving issuance of considerationshares change in control

    Listco A must disclose the Targets financial information in theannouncement.

    Takeovers Code: Disclosure of unaudited financial information willconstitute profit forecasts, which must be reported by an auditor and/or a

    financial advisor.

    Will the Exchange grant waiver?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    51/107

    51

    Shareholder approval (1)

    When required?

    Major transaction, VSD, VSA and RTO

    General principles

    Voting should be made on the terms of the subject transaction

    All voting at general meetings must be taken by poll

    Shareholder approval must be obtained before completion of the transaction

    Can an issuer obtain a prior mandate from its shareholders for on-market

    disposal of its investments?

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    52/107

    52

    Shareholder approval (2)

    Material interest

    Any shareholder that has a material interest in the transaction shall abstainfrom voting

    Factors determining material interest include: a party to the transaction or his associate?

    any benefit confers upon the shareholder or his associate, which is notavailable to other shareholders

    No monetary / financial benchmarks for material interest

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    53/107

    53

    Example 1 Material interest in a transaction

    (Listing Decision 73-1)

    >10%

    Mr. X

    (Director)

    Vendor

    Listco A Target

    2%+CEO

    0.5%60%

    Facts:

    Mr. X is not a party to the VSA

    Mr. X had abstained from voting at board meetings

    Mr. X is a member of Listco As executive committee

    Does Mr. X have material interest in the VSA?

    Subject matter of

    the VSA

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    54/107

    54

    Example 2 Material interest in a transaction

    (Listing Decision 73-2)

    9%

    Mr. Y

    Listco A

    Listco B

    Director & CEO

    of Listco B andholding a number of

    outstanding options (about

    2% of Listco Bs issued

    share capital)Facts:

    Listco A proposes to privatise Listco B.

    a major transaction for Listco A

    Do Company X and Mr. Y have material interest in the major transaction?

    Company X

    >10%

    Director &

    shareholder

    of Listco A

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    55/107

    55

    Written shareholder approval (1)

    Allowed for major transactions if:

    no shareholder needs to abstain from voting; and

    a closely allied group of shareholders, holding more than 50% voting

    interest, approves the transaction

    A closely allied group of shareholders:

    the number of persons in the group

    their relationship (e.g. past or present business association)

    how long have they been shareholders?

    are they parties acting in concert under Takeovers Code?

    voting pattern on past shareholders resolutions (other than routine

    resolutions at AGM)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    56/107

    56

    Written shareholder approval (2)

    Not allowed for :

    VSA, VSD and RTO

    qualified opinion on the accountants report

    some natural resources acquisitions that become new ventures of theissuer

    Other Listing Rules may require shareholder meeting

    e.g. specific mandate for issue of consideration shares

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    57/107

    57

    Subsequent change of terms of a transaction

    Material changes of the terms of a transaction after shareholder approval require shareholder re-approval?

    Example:

    Listco A agreed to dispose of a property at a consideration of HK$20million VSD

    The VSD was approved by shareholders.

    The parties now proposes to reduce the consideration to HK$10million before completion major transaction

    Does the change of consideration constitute a material change interms?

    Note: See also FAQ Series 7 No. 16

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    58/107

    58

    Circular (1)

    When required?

    Major transaction, VSD, VSA and RTO

    The circular must be despatched:

    within 21 days after publication of the announcement; and

    at the same time or before the issuer gives notice of the shareholdermeeting (if any)

    Any supplementary circular containing material information

    at least 14 days before general meeting

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    59/107

    59

    Circular (2)

    Content requirements

    General principle

    Information must be clearly presented, and must be accurate andcomplete in all material respects and not be misleading or deceptive

    Sufficient information for shareholders to vote

    Specific disclosures

    e.g. - 3 year historical financial information of the target

    - Pro forma financials of the enlarged/ remaining group

    - Other expert reports (e.g. valuation report, mining report)- Information on the target and the issuer

    e.g. indebtedness statement, working capital sufficiency statement,information on the financial and trading prospects of the issuer

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    60/107

    60

    Historical financial information of the target (1)

    NT category Where the target is a business/

    company

    Where the target is a revenue-

    generating asset with an identifiable

    income stream or asset valuation

    Major disposal Not required Not required

    Major acquisition Accountants report on the target* Profit/ loss statement and (where

    available) valuation of the target

    VSD Accountants report on the group# Profit/ loss statement and (whereavailable) valuation of the target

    VSA and RTO Accountants report on the target* Profit/ loss statement and (whereavailable) valuation of the target

    # with separate disclosure of financial information of the disposal target as a discontinuing operation

    * No accountants report is required if the target itself is listed on the Exchange

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    61/107

    61

    Accountants report

    Prepared by qualified and independent CPA

    The accounts must:

    adopt accounting policies materially consistent with those of the issuer

    conform with HKFRS or IFRS

    contain financial statements of the target / group for 3 financial yearsbefore issue of circular

    relate to a financial period ended 6 months or less before issue of

    circular

    Historical financial information of the target (2)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    62/107

    62

    Accountants report relief

    We will consider:

    Information differences

    Assurance differences

    Unduly burdensome/ impractical

    Specific relief in the Rules:

    the target has not or will not become the issuers subsidiary

    non-public information related to a target company (which is listed andwill become the issuers subsidiary) is unavailable

    Historical financial information of the target (3)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    63/107

    63

    Example - Waiver from accountants report requirements

    (Listing Decision 74-1)

    Facts:

    Listco A proposes to acquire a business from a US listed company VSA

    Listco A has practical difficulties in preparing an accountants report on the Target

    Business.

    It proposes to include in its VSA circular:

    audited combined financial statements of the Target Business

    prepared in accordance with US GAAP, with a reconciliation to HKFRS

    audited by the vendors auditors in accordance with US auditing

    standard

    GAAP reconciliation reviewed by Listco As auditor

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    64/107

    64

    Pro forma financial information (1)

    NT category Where the target is a business/

    company

    Where the target is a revenue-

    generating asset with an identifiable

    income stream or asset valuation

    Major disposal Not required Not required

    Major

    acquisition

    Pro forma statement of assets

    and liabilities of the enlargedgroup

    Pro forma statement of assets and

    liabilities of the enlarged group

    VSD Pro forma income statement,balance sheet and cashflow

    statement of the remaining group

    Pro forma profit and loss statement

    and net assets statement on the

    remaining group

    VSA/ RTO Pro forma income statement,balance sheet and cashflow

    statement of the enlarged group

    Pro forma profit and loss statementand net assets statement on the

    enlarged group

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    65/107

    65

    Pro forma financial information (2)

    Pro forma financials must:

    clearly state the purpose of their preparation

    include all appropriate adjustments

    adopt format and accounting policies consistent with those used by theissuer

    Pro forma financial information may only be published in respect of:

    the current financial period

    the most recently completed financial period

    the most recent interim period for which information has been published

    Point to note:

    The pro forma income statement and balance sheet may be prepared fordifferent accounting periods

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    66/107

    66

    Pro forma financial information (3)

    The issuers unadjusted information must be derived from the most recent :

    audited published accounts, published interim reports, published interim orannual results announcements;

    accountants report;

    previously published pro forma financials; or

    published profit forecast or estimate

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    67/107

    67

    Other expert reports (1)

    Report on profit forecast

    Profit forecast is not mandatory

    A circular containing a profit forecast must include:

    reporting accountants or auditors report accounting policies

    calculations for the forecast

    financial advisers report

    forecast has been stated after directors due and careful enquiry

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    68/107

    68

    Other expert reports (2)

    Report on profit forecast (contd)

    Profit forecast includes:

    any statement which quantifies the anticipated level of future profits or

    losses

    any profits/ losses estimate for a financial period which has expired butfor which the results have not yet been published

    any valuation of assets (other than land and buildings) or businesses

    based on discounted cash flows or projections of profits, earnings or

    cash flows

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    69/107

    69

    Other expert reports (3)

    Technical report for mining activities

    applicable to Main Board issuers proposing to explore for natural resources as

    a new venture

    must be prepared by a qualified technical adviser

    must include information e.g.

    estimated reserves

    evidence on which the estimate is based

    details of the technical advisers

    must be prepared not more than 6 months before issue of the circular

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    70/107

    70

    Indebtedness statement

    statement of indebtedness of the group as at the most recent practicabledate

    most recent practicable date normally NOT more than 8 weeks before

    group include any company which will become a subsidiary of the

    issuer

    Working capital sufficiency statement

    confirmation if the issuer has sufficient working capital

    normally cover the next 12 months

    Indebtedness and working capital sufficiency statements

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    71/107

    71

    Recent Rule amendments (Effective 2 November 2009)

    simplify Rules for listing applications by listed issuers

    remove some existing documentary requirements

    revise timeframe for submission of documents

    reduce number of copies required for submission

    Documentary requirements for listing applications by listed

    issuers

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    72/107

    72

    V. Special considerations for transactions

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    73/107

    73

    Reverse takeovers

    Spin-off

    Distribution in specie

    Cash companies

    Sufficiency of operations

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    74/107

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    75/107

    75

    MB R14.06(6)/ GEM R19.06(6) (contd)

    A reverse takeover normally refers to:

    (a) an acquisition or a series of acquisitions (aggregated under rules 14.22 and

    14.23) of assets constituting a very substantial acquisition where there is orwhich will result in a change in control (as defined in the Takeovers Code) ofthe listed issuer (other than at the level of its subsidiaries); or

    (b) acquisition(s) of assets from a person or a group of persons or any of his/their

    associates pursuant to an agreement, arrangement or understanding enteredinto by the listed issuer within 24 months of such person or group of personsgaining control (as defined in the Takeovers Code) of the listed issuer (otherthan at the level of its subsidiaries), where such gaining of control had notbeen regarded as a reverse takeover, which individually or togetherconstitute(s) a very substantial acquisition

    Reverse takeovers (2)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    76/107

    76

    Application of RTO Rule

    What is a RTO? (LC Annual Report 2007)

    What is the 24 month restriction?

    How do we look at change in control?

    Reverse takeovers (3)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    77/107

    77

    We will look at the reason(s) for triggering the general offer obligation whendetermining whether the change in control test is met.

    Company X

    Vendor Holding Co

    Target Listco A

    Company X

    Vendor

    Listco A

    Holding Co

    Target

    >50% >50% >50%

    >50%

    20%

    100%100%100% 100%

    Before AfterExample

    Example Change in control

    (Listing Decision 75-2)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    78/107

    78

    To address circumvention of the RTO rules

    An issuer may not dispose of its existing business for a 24 month period

    after a change in control, unless

    assets acquired after the change in control meet the new listingrequirement

    Otherwise, deemed as a new listing applicant

    Disposal of existing business after change in control (1)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    79/107

    79

    Listing Committee Annual Report 2008

    The Listing Committee endorsed a waiver:

    Disposal will be restricted if :

    assets injection by new controlling shareholder at the time of and/or afterthe change in control; and

    such asset injection would have resulted in a VSA, taking into accountthe disposal(s)

    We will consider whether the issuer structures its transactions to circumvent

    the RTO Rules.

    Disposal of business after change in control (2)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    80/107

    80

    A proposal that effects the separate listing on the Exchange or elsewhere of

    assets or businesses wholly or partly within its existing group

    General principle

    one business should not support 2 listing status

    Clarifications:

    Spin-off can be conducted via acquisition of a listed shell

    Holding of interest in Newco after spin-off is not a pre-requisite

    Spin-off proposals are subject to the Exchanges approval

    Shareholder approval is only required for major or above transactions

    Spin-off

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    81/107

    81

    Example Spin- off via acquisition of a shell company

    Listco A

    Disposed

    Group

    100%

    Listco A

    DisposedGroup

    80%

    Company B

    100%

    Before Disposal After Disposal

    Facts:

    Company B does not have material assets or operation.

    The disposal aims to consolidate majority of Listco A Singapore assets under

    one listed subsidiary (Company B).

    (Listed on Main Board) (Listed on Main Board)

    (Listed in Singapore)

    Does the disposal constitute a spin-off?

    Note: See also Listing Decision 3-2

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    82/107

    82

    Distributions in specie to shareholders are normally not notifiable transactions.

    We may impose requirements if the distributions are in substance:

    circumvention of the Listing Rules disposal of assets by the issuer

    against the general principles of investor protection

    Distribution in specie

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    83/107

    83

    Example - Distribution in specie

    (Listing Decision 75-4)

    Before After

    ParentCompany

    Listco A

    Subsidiary X(unlisted)

    Minorityshareholders

    Distribution of all Subsidiary Xs

    shares to Listco As

    shareholders ( Distribution)

    Parent Company will make acash offer to acquire allSubsidiary Xs shares *

    (Subsidiary Offer)

    ParentCompany

    Listco ASubsidiary X

    (unlisted)

    * Parent Shareholder proposes the Distribution to facilitate the disposal of its controlling

    interest in the Listco A.

    Minorityshareholders

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    84/107

    84

    Cash companies

    Where for any reason the assets of an issuer consist wholly or substantiallyof cash or short-dated securities, it will not be regarded as suitable for listingand trading in its securities will be suspended.

    Short-dated securities: securities such as bonds, bills or notes whichhave less than 1 year to maturity.

    We will treat the issuers application for lifting of the suspension as if it were anew listing applicant.

    Exclude:

    investment companies as defined in MB Chapter 21; or

    an issuer which is solely or mainly engaged in the securities brokeragebusiness

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    85/107

    85

    For continued listing of its securities, an issuer must demonstrate to theExchange that:

    it carries out, directly or indirectly, a sufficient level of operations

    it has tangible assets of sufficient value and/or

    it has intangible assets of sufficient potential value

    Sufficiency of operation

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    86/107

    86

    Compliance reminders

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    87/107

    87

    I. Reminders

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    88/107

    88

    Trading suspension

    Black out period

    Shareholder meeting notice

    Continuing connected transactions

    Access to books and records of disposed companies

    Board meeting notification

    Book closure notification

    Disclosures in monthly returns and next day disclosure returns

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    89/107

    89

    Trading suspension

    1. Authorised representatives and company secretary should be contactable todeal with suspension related matters:

    respond to our press/ price and trading movement / post-vetting

    enquiries inform us of the proposed suspension well in advance

    submit written suspension request well in advance

    Reminders (1)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    90/107

    90

    Black out period

    2. The new black out period will commence:

    60 days before publication of results or

    if shorter, the period from the financial year end up to the date of

    publication

    notify the Exchange about the commencement of blackout period

    Reminders (2)

    31/12/2009(year end

    date)

    20/3/2010(Date of publicationof annual results)

    30/4/2010(Deadline for publication of

    annual results MB issuers)

    Commencement of black out period: 19 January 2010

    Notification must be sent to the Exchange before 19 January 2010

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    91/107

    91

    Shareholder meeting notice

    3. Code Provision: Notice of shareholder meeting should be sent

    at least 20 clear business days before AGM

    at least 10 clear business days before other general meeting

    (Introduced on 1 January 2009)

    Reminders (3)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    92/107

    92

    Revised publication deadlines for results announcements (Main Board)

    4. Annual results: 3 months after year end

    - for financial year ending on or after 31 December 2010

    5. Interim results: 2 months after period end- for 6 months ending on or after 30 June 2010

    Reminders (4)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    93/107

    93

    Continuing connected transactions (CCTs)

    6. Is there sufficient time for renewing an expiring CCT agreement?

    Plan for:

    renewal of the agreement

    publication of announcement, shareholder meeting, appointment ofIFA and establishment of IBC

    7. Will the CCTs exceed the annual cap(s)?

    Plan for publication of announcement, shareholder meeting, appointment

    of IFA and establishment of IBC

    8. Will there be adequate time for auditors and INEDs to review the CCT?

    Submit auditors confirmation within 10 business days before bulk-printing of the annual reports

    Reminders (5)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    94/107

    94

    Access to books and records of disposed companies

    9. Ensure that the issuer itself and its auditors can have access to the disposedcompanies books and records for the year end audit

    Reminders (6)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    95/107

    95

    Board meeting notification

    10. Announce at least 7 clear business days before the meeting date

    Reminders (7)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    96/107

    96

    Book closure notification

    11. Announce the book closure date at least 14 days before the closure

    12. Disclose the purpose of the book closure (e.g. for dividend entitlements,

    attendance at the AGM, etc)

    Reminders (8)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    97/107

    97

    Type of Issue No. of newshares of

    issuer issued

    during the

    month

    pursuant

    thereto

    No. of newshares of issuer

    which may be

    issued pursuant

    thereto as at

    close of the

    month

    6.Repurchaseof shares

    Class of share repurchasedCancellation date : (dd/mm/yyyy)

    EGM approval date: (dd/mm/yyyy)

    Ordinary

    (15/11/2009)

    (30/11/2009)

    (26/06/2009)

    (100,000)

    (200,000)

    N/A

    N/A

    N/A

    (200,000)

    13. Other Movements in Issued Share Capital:- 6. Repurchase of shares

    No. of shares repurchased (but yet to

    be cancelled) as at the end of the

    month

    Disclosures in Monthly Return Share repurchase and cancellation of

    repurchased shares

    No. of shares cancelled during

    the month

    Date of general meeting (e.g. AGM date)

    approving the share repurchases

    Reminders (9)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    98/107

    98

    Issues of shares(Notes 6 and 7)

    No. of shares

    Issued shares as

    a % of existing

    issued share

    capitalbeforerelevant share

    issue(Notes 4, 6 and 7)

    Issue price

    per share(Notes 1 and

    7)

    Closing market price

    per share of the

    immediatelypreceding business

    day

    (Note 5)

    % discount/premium of issue

    price to market

    price

    (Note 7)

    Opening balance as at(Note 2)

    31 October 2009

    1,000,000,000

    (Note 3)

    Placing of new shares

    - 20 November 2009

    Exercise of options

    - 3 November 2009- 5 November 2009

    50,000,000

    10,000

    40,000

    5%

    0.001%

    0.004%

    $0.70

    $0.50

    $0.50

    $0.85 (9 Nov 2009)

    $0.65 (2 Nov 2009)

    $0.75 (4 Nov 2009)

    17.65% discount

    23.01% discount

    33.33% discount

    The closing market price per share on the

    business day immediately before the

    occurrence of the reported item, e.g. issue of

    shares on exercise of options

    Where shares are allotted or redeemed on multiple dates,

    details must be disclosed separately.

    Disclosure in Next Day Disclosure Return

    14. Closing market price and allotment/repurchase on multiple dates

    Reminders (10)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    99/107

    99

    II. Year end disclosures

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    100/107

    100

    Publication of management accounts

    Issuers failing to announce their preliminary results before the publicationdeadline must issue an announcement containing:

    a full explanation for its inability to publish a preliminary results

    the expected date of announcement of the financial results financial results (if available)

    any disagreement with the audit committee on accounting treatmentadopted

    Year end disclosures (1)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    101/107

    101

    Common pitfalls of disclosures in annual results announcements

    Omission of information required under MB App 16/ GEM Chapter 18

    Ageing analysis and credit policy description

    Compliance statement on Corporate Governance (CG) Code

    A statement that the results had been reviewed by audit committee

    Details of the qualification or modification of the auditors report

    The explanatory notes to proposed dividend

    Inadequate disclosure of information required under MB App 16/ GEM Chapter 18

    Significant balances / fluctuation

    Management discussion on the issuer's results

    Year end disclosures (2)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    102/107

    102

    Common pitfalls of disclosures in annual reports

    Omission of information

    Disclosures in Corporate Governance Report

    e.g. terms of NED appointment, information on remuneration committee

    Details of connected transactions

    A narrative statement on whether the auditors had reviewed and confirmed compliancewith CCT annual review Rules

    Continuing disclosures of advance to entities, financial assistance to affiliatedcompanies, pledge of shares by controlling shareholders, etc

    Annual confirmation of INED independence

    Inadequate disclosure Description of credit policy and ageing analysis

    Analytical and in-depth discussion in MD&A section

    Details of share option scheme

    Explanation for inconsistency of disclosure relating to auditors remuneration infinancial statements and CG Report

    Disclosure on financial instruments (their nature, valuation and risk exposure)

    Year end disclosures (3)

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    103/107

    103

    Year end disclosures (4)

    Dividend information

    Provide sufficient information on dividend proposals including the dividendpayment date

    Notify shareholders of any withholding tax implication

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    104/107

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    105/107

  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    106/107

    106

    Other reference materials

    Auditing guideline - Statement 3.340 Prospectuses and the Reporting Accountant,issued by HKICPA(http://app1.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/3_340.pdf)

    Accounting Guideline 7 Preparation of Pro Forma Financial Information for Inclusionin Investment Circulars, issued by HKICPAhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeII/ag7.pdf

    Hong Kong Standard on Investment Circular Reporting Engagements 300Accountants Reports on Pro forma Financial Information in Investment Circulars ,issued by HKICPAhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/hksir3

    00.pdf

    Review report by the Professional Standards Monitoring Committee of the HKICPA(http://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdf)

    http://app1.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/3_340.pdfhttp://app1.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/3_340.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeII/ag7.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/hksir300.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/hksir300.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/correspondence/2009-06-25/activities_report.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/hksir300.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/hksir300.pdfhttp://www.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeII/ag7.pdfhttp://app1.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/3_340.pdfhttp://app1.hkicpa.org.hk/ebook/HKSA_Members_Handbook_Master/volumeIII/3_340.pdf
  • 7/30/2019 Notifiable Transaction 200910

    107/107

    Thank you