NY Attorney General's Airbnb Report

8/10/2019 NY Attorney General's Airbnb Report

1/41


2/41


3/41

!"#$ & Q

"#$ %&'() %(*$ +, *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1 '1&-,+%/* 1(2$ 3(%404 #&5$ )%&/&-(6&117 $8'&0)$) -#$ 9*$ +, -%&)(-(+0&1&'&%-/$0-* &* -%&0*($0- #+-$1 %++/**'&%2(0: & '941(6 )$4&-$ (0 ;$< =+%2 &0) (0 6+//90(-($*


4/41

!"#$ & X

(GF /GRR$ENC"P 5D$ED ,RFPGL$J 3$OH"P !P"HMGERD HG 3WO 7WPHCRCPPCGO=4GPP"E1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"P *WDCO$DD$DU @$11 +5$% ILL D+//$%6(&1 F*$%* $&6# 6+0-%+11$) IL +% /+%$90(>9$ 3(%404 90(-* )9%(0: -#$ P$5($< O$%(+)? "+:$-#$%A -#$*$ #+*-* &66$'-$) MVAILX '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$*$%5&-(+0* &0) $&%0$) QYZ?M /(11(+0 (0 %$5$09$? "#$ #(:#$*-.$&%0(0: +'$%&-(+0 &)/(0(*-$%$)KVK 90(>9$ 3(%404 1(*-(0:*A 4++2$) XALKM %$*$%5&-(+0*A &0) %$6$(5$) QW?R /(11(+0 (0 %$5$09$ )9%(0: -#$

P$5($< O$%(+)? [&6# +, -#$ -+' IK ;$< =+%2 D(-7 +'$%&-(+0* +0 3(%404 )9%(0: -#&- '$%(+) $&%0$)%$5$09$ $86$$)(0: QI /(11(+0?

!ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD 4CDFP"N$J +GO#=($ER ;GWDCO# CO (BGWD"OJD GM)F"EHR$OHDU E0 KLIXA /+%$ -#&0 MAWLL 90(-*


5/41

!"#$ & Z

E0 1&-$ 2013, the Office of the Attorney General of the State of New York (;=3a) launched an(05$*-(:&-(+0 +, 9*$%* +,


6/41

!"#$ & [

Tax Lot Output (PLUTO) databaseA


7/41

!"#$ & \

83-:(;%20% 32


8/41

!"#$ & ]

!ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD CO 0$I 9GEV /CHL 8$O$E"H$J -T$E ^[__ RCPPCGO CO3$T$OW$ CO +$DD HB"O .CT$ 9$"EDU3* %$,1$6-$) (0 d(:9%$ K 4$1+


9/41

!"#$ & `

7GDH !ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD *GGV$J CO 0$I 9GEV /CHL


10/41

!"#$ & b

0$I 9GEV /CHL 2D +CV$PL -I$J 7CPPCGOD CO 5OF"CJ ;GH$P ("S$D MEGR !ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PDU3 09/4$% +, -&8$* /&7 &''17 -+ '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1*? S$$ 3''$0)(8 3? E0'&%-(691&%A ;$< =+%2 D(-7 &**$**$* & #+-$1 %++/ +669'&067 -&8 +, Y?RVY '$%6$0- -#&- &''1($* -+ '%(5&-$*#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1*? [8619)(0: ,(0$* &0) '$0&1-($*A -#$ -+-&1 $*-(/&-$) 1(&4(1(-7 ,+% #+-$1 %++/ +669'&067 -&8$*&**+6(&-$)


11/41

!"#$ & '_

/-77,3/2)+%51,31

:BCP$ /GRR$ENC"P 5D$ED 3$FE$D$OH$J " 7COGECHL GM ;GDHDc (B$L 4GRCO"H$J HB$

!ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"P 7"EV$H CO 5OCHDc 3$D$ET"HCGODc "OJ 3$T$OW$U KYAMWX#+*-* +,,$%$) '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1* (0 ;$< =+%2 D(-7 )9%(0: -#$ P$5($< O$%(+)? \, -#$*$ #+*-*A KMALYV^ZM '$%6$0-` +,,$%$) 0+ /+%$ -#&0 -9$ 90(-* ,+% '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1* )9%(0: -#$ '$%(+)?Z

3* (119*-%&-$) (0 d(:9%$ YA IAMLW #+*-* ^*(8 '$%6$0-` &6-$) as D+//$%6(&1 Users, running larger operations-#&- &)/(0(*-$%$) ,%+/ -#%$$ -+ KVK 90(>9$ 90(-* )9%(0: -#$ P$5($< O$%(+)? T9%(0: -#&- '$%(+)A D+//$%6(&1F*$%* 6+0-%+11$) /+%$ -#&0 +0$ (0 ,(5$ 90(>9$ 90(-* (0 ;$< =+%2 D(-7 4++2$) +0 3(%404 &* '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1*A &66$'-$) /+%$ -#&0 +0$ (0 -#%$$ '%(5&-$ %$*$%5&-(+0*A &0) %$6$(5$) /+%$ -#&0 +0$ +, $5$%7-#%$$ )+11&%* (0 %$5$09$ ,%+/ '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1* +0 3(%404,+% & -+-&1 +, QIWR /(11(+0?

.C#WE$ [?

/GRR$ENC"P 5D$ED )NNGWOH$J MGE " 4CDFEGFGEHCGO"H$ 1B"E$ GM!ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD^S+9%6$N 3(%404 T&-&A KLIL.KLIM`

Z@#(1$ +'$%&-(0: */&11$% 5$0-9%$*A -#$*$ #+*-* /&7 0+0$-#$1$** 4$ (0 5(+1&-(+0 +, -#$ 1&


12/41

!"#$ & ''

7"YGE /GRR$ENC"P 9&%-$% +, &11 '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ 4++2(0:* &0) %$6$(5$) %$5$09$ +, QILR?Z /(11(+0&4+9- +0$ (0 $5$%7 ,+9%)+11&%* #+*-* %$6$(5$)? P$:&%)1$**A -#$ T&-& /&2$ 61$&% -#&- )9%(0: -#$ &''%+8(/&-$17 M?Y.7$&% P$5($9$ 90(-*


14/41

!"#$ & 'X

5OCHD 4$JCN"H$J !ECR"ECPL GE ,SNPWDCT$PL HG !ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD)NNGWOH$J MGE "O 2ONE$"DCO# 1B"E$ GM 3$T$OW$ -T$E (CR$U3* %$,1$6-$) (0 d(:9%$ R4$1+


15/41

!"#$ & 'Z

0WR$EGWD 5OCHD *GGV$J "D !ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD 7"L ;"T$ -F$E"H$J "D2PP$#"P ;GDH$PDUD$%-&(0 *-&-$* '$%/(- #+*-$1*A 9(%$ #+*-$1*-+ &)#$%$ -+ %(:+%+9* *&,$-7 %$>9(%$/$0-*? ;$< =+%2 69%%$0-17 '%+#(4(-* ,+%.'%+,(- #+*-$1* $0-(%$17?

31-#+9:# +-#$% $8'1&0&-(+0* /&7 &''17 -+ 6$%-&(0 1(*-(0:*A '&--$%0* +, #(:# +669'&067 (0 6+00$6-(+0


16/41

!"#$ & '[

3$T$OW$ 8$O$E"H$J CO 7"OB"HH"O "OJ *EGGVPLO )NNGWOH$J MGE 9$ 90(-* (0 H&0#&--&0 &0) C%++2170 )9%(0: -#&- '$%(+) &66+90-$) ,+% -#$ 5&*-/&]+%(-7 ^ZW '$%6$0-` +, 90(-* 9*$) ,+% '%(5&-$ *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1* 4++2$) 6(-7


17/41

!"#$ & '\

(BE$$ /GRRWOCHL 4CDHECNHD CO 7"OB"HH"O )NNGWOH$J MGE "O -WHDCg$ 1B"E$ GM!ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER 3$OH"PD CO HB$ *GEGW#B "OJ /CHLICJ$U3* %$,1$6-$) (0 d(:9%$ IIA -#%$$D+//90(-7 T(*-%(6-*-#$ U+


18/41

!"#$ & ']

:CPPC"RDKWE# "OJ 8E$$OFGCOH ;GDH$J HB$ 8E$"H$DH 1B"E$ GM !ECT"H$ 1BGEH=($ER3$OH"PD CO *EGGVPLOUT9%(0: -#$ P$5($< O$%(+)A /+*- %$5$09$ ,%+/ '%(5&-$ C%++2170 *#+%-.-$%/%$0-&1* 6&/$ ,%+/ D+//90(-7 T(*-%(6-* &1+0: -#$ ;+%-#$%0 C%++2170


19/41

!"#$ & '`

) ,042>%)?%%

1577)39%-.%1,+,/(,4%+):1

3- ,3(9%51,%)04%1).,(9%+):1%O%+'$%-7 9*$ &0) *&,$-7 1&


20/41

!"#$ & 'b

()>%+):1%

307+0$ 9(%$)-+ 4$ 6+11$6-$)? "#$ +'$%&-+% /9*- 6+11$6- -#$ -&8 ,+% &11 %$0-&1* +, &'&%-/$0-* +% %++/*A $86$'- (0 -#$ 6&*$+,N ^I` %$0-&1 +, +017 +0$ %++/ (0 &0 +9()&-(0: & -%&)$A 49*(0$**A '%+,$**(+0A +% +669'&-(+0


21/41

!"#$ & Q_

) ,042>%*?%

1,+,/(,4%)..24)


22/41

!"#$ & Q'


23/41

!"#$ & QQ


24/41

!"#$ & QX


25/41

!"#$ & QZ


26/41

!"#$ & Q[


27/41

!"#$ & Q\


28/41

!"#$ & Q]


29/41

!"#$ & Q`


30/41

!"#$ & Qb


31/41

!"#$ & X_


32/41

!"#$ & X'


33/41

!"#$ & XQ


34/41

!"#$ & XX


35/41

!"#$ & XZ


36/41

!"#$ & X[


37/41

!"#$ & X\


38/41

!"#$ & X]


39/41

!"#$ & X`

) ,042>%/?%

1,+,/(2-0%-.%)0-097-51%

/-7 +)20(1%

T9%(0: -#$ P$5($< O$%(+)A -#+9*&0)* +, ;$< =+%2$%* *94/(--$) 6+/'1&(0-* -+ *-&-$ &0) 6(-7 &:$06($*6+/'1&(0(0: &4+9- -#$ '%+1(,$%&-(+0 +, *#+%-.-$%/ %$0-&1*A '%(/&%(17 (0 ;$< =+%2 D(-7? "#$*$ 6+/'1&(0-* %&(*$& #+*- +, :%($5&06$* % 6(D , 7-,00 E* $,&)-8 &%()F0),36-6G%/* $,&)-8 2,&=%)F&%() 91.&F9-645) ;,-=F.$ )%(%2%() 3.6-/6(4 19

, -1;%& H,(5,)),( (%64531&511/? I5% ,$,&)2%() 1( )5% J0) 9-11& 3%6(4 &%()%/ 1.) ,0 , 51)%-suite The [temporary renters] apparently [do not] have k%8 )1 06/% 8,&/ )1 /60$10% 19 4,&3,4% 01;,0 /.2$6(4 6) 1( 0)&%%) 6( 9&1()? E9)%& ;% '12$-,6(%/ 38 -%,>6(4 (1)%0 , 2,6/ 0%&>6'% 3%4,( )1appear every few days to clean the apartment We urged management to put an end to illegal51)%- &%(),-? C( K.-8* L@JL [an apartment in the building] was burglarized of all her grandmothersM%;%-&8 6( ;5,) ,$$%,&%/ )1 3% ,( 6(06/% M13? H%,(;56-%* C 3%4,( )1 (1)6'% , &%>1->6(4 /11& 6( )5%,$,&)2%() 3%(%,)5 26(%? I560 21&(6(4* ,(1)5%& (%64531& '1('%&(%/ ,31.) )5% %&1061( 19 7-,00 E,$,&)2%()0 91.(/ 1( -6(% B)5% ,$,&)2%() 6( N.%0)61(D 3%6(4 B-60)%/D 1( E6&3(3? C) ,$$%,&0 )5,)B(.2%&1.0 1)5%& ,$,&)2%()0 28 3-1'= 5,>% ,-01 3%%(D -60)%/ 1( E6&3(3??? A,9%)8* 3.6-/6(4 0%'.&6)8*N.6%) %(M182%() 19 1.& 512%0* ,(8 0%(0% 19 '122.(6)8 ,&% .(/%& ,00,.-)O $-%,0% 6(>%0)64,)%?

/GRFP"COH 1WKRCHH$J -NHGK$E 'Zc Q_'X @09)8A?

C ;&6)% )1 ,0= 81. )1 ),=% )5% 0)&1(4%0) %(91&'%2%() ,')61( $10063-% ,4,6(0) )5% $&1-69%&,)61( 196--%4,- 51)%-0 6( 1.& (%64531&511/0 9,'6-6),)%/ 1$%(-8 38 )5% ;%306)% E6&3(3? C -6>% 6( , 26//-% '-,00*(1&)5%&( P&11=-8( (%64531&511/ ,(/ ,31.) 1(% ,(/ , 5,-9 8%,&0 ,41 C 0$%() ,-210) 1(% %()6&%5%--605 8%,& 3,))-6(4 ,( 6--%4,- 51)%- 1$%&,)6(4 6( )5% ,$,&)2%() 3%-1; 2%? C ',--%/ '1.()-%00 B76)8,4%('6%0D 3.) )1 (1 ,>,6-? I5% $%&01( ;51 1$%&,)%/ )5,) 06)% 5,/ (.2%&1.0 1)5%&0 )5&1.451.) )5%'6)8? C) ;,0 , 5%,-)5 ,(/ 0,9%)8 &60= ,(/ )5% $&1$&6%)1& )5&%,)%(%/ 2% ;6)5 $5806',- 91&'% 91&&%$1&)6(4 5%& ,(/ )5% -,(/-1&/ ,) )5% )62% Q)5% 3.6-/6(4 5,0 06('% 3%%( 01-/R ;,0 , ;6--6(4,''12$-6'% ,0 5% 51$%/ )1 4%) 5645%& &%() 9&12 , 51)%- )5,( 9&12 -%4,- )%(,()0? S%() 6( 1.&(%64531&511/ 5,0 3%'12% (%,& .(,991&/,3-% 91& .0 ,(/ 6) 60 $,&)-8 3%',.0% $%1$-% ',( '5,&4%0.'5 5645 &%()0 )1 6--%4,- 51)%-0?

/GRFP"COH 1WKRCHH$J 7"ENB ''c Q_'Z @09)8A?

C ,2 ;&6)6(4 )1 3&6(4 81.& ,))%()61( )1 , 3.06(%00 )5,) 60 .06(4 E6&3(3 )1 6--%4,--8 &%() 1.) 6)0,$,&)2%()0 >6, E6&3(3* %00%()6,--8 1$%&,)6(4 ,0 , 51)%- '5,6( 2,0N.%&,/6(4 ,0 6(/6>6/.,-0 &%()6(4,$,&)2%()0? I5% '12$,(8 6( N.%0)61( 60 B$&%0%()0 6)0%-9 ,0 , -%46)62,)% 051&)F)%&2 &%(),- 0%&>6'%D.06(4 0%>%&,- $0%./1(820? T&12 ;5,) C ',( )%--* )5%8 ,&% 3.86(4 :< )%(%2%() ,$,&)2%()0 ,(/


40/41

!"#$ & Xb

&%()6(4 )5%2 1.) )1 )1.&60)0? E21(4 2,(8 1)5%& $&13-%20* )560 5,0 )5% %99%') 19 91&'6(4 -1(4F0),(/6(4 &%06/%()0 1.) 19 )5%6& ,$,&)2%()0 )1 0%&>% )1.&60)0?

/GRFP"COH 1WKRCHH$J 7"ENB 'Qc Q_'Z@-MMCN$ GM 0$I 9GEV 1$O"HGE ,PCg"K$HB hEW#$EA?

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incidents goes on The host accommodates up to four people in each room (for a total of 12$%1$-% ,) )5% 0,2% )62%R? BT1&D ,) -%,0) 1(% 8%,& )5% 510) 5,0 B3%%( 199%&6(4 051&)F)%&2 &%(),-0 ,(/

/1%0D (1) -6>% 6( )5% 3.6-/6(4 3.) ;6)5 560 46&-9&6%(/ 012%;5%&% %-0% 6( )5% (%64531&511/? I1 &%() )5%&1120 5% '12%0 )1 2%%) 560 '-6%()0* 46>%0 )5%2 )5% =%80 )1 )5% 3.6-/6ng, and then leaves

/GRFP"COH 1WKRCHH$J 7"ENB Q'c Q_'Z@0$I 9GEV /CHL -MMCN$ GM 1F$NC"P ,OMGEN$R$OHA?

BC M.0) ;,()%/ )1 46>% 81.D ,( .$/,)% 1( );1 ,$,&)2%()0 B3%6(4 .0%/ ,0 6--%4,- 51)%-0D? P1)5apartments are owned by the same landlord and both ,$,&)2%()0 ,&% ,-210) '1()6(.1.0-8occupied [for short periods by groups of tourists from all over the world] We also see a cleaning$%&01( ,(/ )5% E6&3(3 510)%00 >606)6(4 31)5 ,$,&)2%()0 ;6)5 0.$$-6%0? C 5,>% 2%) %>%&8 9,26-8 019,& Q%W'%$) )5% 1(% )5,) 21>%/ 6( )1/,8R )1 -%) )5%2 =(1; ,31.) )5% 06).,)61(? C ,2 51$6(4 )5,)

012% 19 )5%2 2%()61( )5% 9,') 19 )560 3%6(4 ,( 6--%4,- &%(),- 1( )5% E6&3(3 ;%306)%* 1& )1 )5%hostess All of the felt something was amiss when the hostess failed to meet them in perso( ,(/5,/ )5%2 $6'= .$ )5% =%80 9&12 012%1(% %-0%??? V.& -6>%0 5,>% 3%%( 0%&61.0-8 ,99%')%/ 38 )5%0%6--%4,- ,')6>6)6%0


41/41

Documents

NY Attorney General's Airbnb Report