126
"##"$%&’(%()* *&*#)’+)+, !"# %#&’(!’!)*+ ,-*(#./#*,#( -0 1#2- !-3#2’*,# ’*% (,"--3 %)(,)43)*# "#$%&’ (&%) * +,’-%., /0))-’ %. 1#&% 2%3#&,.4# 50.# 67869: ;<<<: =,>?-.@’%.: ABCB -+.-’/)0)’% #$"1)/% %2) /(.(3 $(42%* #$"1)/% 2-$.-$+ &’(.)$*(%5

Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

  • Upload
    vannga

  • View
    219

  • Download
    1

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

! !

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"##"$%&'(%()*!*&*#)'+)+,!!

!

! !"#$%#&'(!'!)*+$,-*(#./#*,#($-0$

$ 1#2-$!-3#2'*,#$'*%$(,"--3$%)(,)43)*#$

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

"#$%&'!(&%)!*!+,'-%.,!/0))-'!%.!1#&%!2%3#&,.4#!

50.#!67869:!;<<<:!=,>?-.@'%.:!ABCB!

!

!

!

!

!!!!!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

-+.-'/)0)'%!#$"1)/%!

!!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

%2)!/(.(3!$(42%*!#$"1)/%!!

2-$.-$+!&'(.)$*(%5!

Page 2: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!"#$%&'(&)'*!%*!+&

&

!"#$%&'()*+($,-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..000.

.

12("3,04(.53++678./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././....4.

.

9$,7%)3",0%$./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././...:.

.

;<6#(.=%.>70-%$(7-?.@0-"0A'0$(./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././....B.

.

<C(.D%'%7.%E.F(7%.<%'(76$"(./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././....G.

.

9+A6",.H$.DC0')7($.I0,C.5A("06'.=(()-././././././././././././././././././././././././././././...J.

.

>-8"C%'%*0"6'.9+A6",.%E.12"'3-0%$678.@0-"0A'0$678.>%'0,0"-K.!.@(4('%A+($,6'.

>7%-A(",04(/./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..:L.

.

. <C(.D%$E'0",.M(,&(($.F(7%.<%'(76$"(.6$).,C(.=(().E%7.!)%'(-"($,-.,%.

. @(4('%A.5,7%$*.M%$)-.I0,C.!)3',-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././..:L.

. <C(.D%$E'0",.M(,&(($.F(7%.<%'(76$"(.6$).,C(.=(().E%7.!)%'(-"($,-.,%.

. @(4('%A.N(6',C8.!,,0,3)(-.<%&67).O3-,0"(.6$).P607$(--./././././././././././..:Q.

.

F(7%.<%'(76$"(K.9-.9,.I%7,C.9,R.

.

. S%--.%E.1)3"6,0%$6'.HAA%7,3$0,0(-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././..:B.

. !',(7$6,04(.1)3"6,0%$./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.:T.

. D70+0$6'0U6,0%$.%E.DC0')7($././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././...:V.

. W(X307().W(E(776'.,%.S6&.1$E%7"(+($,././././././././././././././././././././././././..:Y.

.

F(7%.<%'(76$"(.@%(-.=%,.I%7#./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.:G.

.

D6-(.5,3)0(-.9''3-,76,0$*.,C(.>C0'%-%AC8.%E.F(7%.<%'(76$"(./.././././././././././././.:Z.

.

. [06+0\@6)(.D%3$,8.>3]'0".5"C%%'-.D%)(.%E.5,3)($,.D%$)3",.././././././.QL.

. [06+0\@6)(.D%3$,8.D6-(.5,3)0(-/./././././././././././././././././././././././././././.Q:.

. ^/I/.D674(7.[0))'(.5"C%%'././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././...QQ.

. >6'+.5A70$*-.[0))'(.5"C%%'././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.QB.

. [6)0-%$.[0))'(.5"C%%'./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..QY.

. =%7,C.@6)(.[0))'(.5"C%%'./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..QG.

. S(--%$-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.BL.

.

M3"#0$*.,C(.<7($)K.5"C%%'-.<C6,.W(6"C.H3,.9$-,(6).%E.>3-C.H3,././././././././..B:.

.

. D($,(7.E%7.1EE(",04(.D%''6]%76,0%$.6$).>76",0"(._D1D>`.%E.,C(.!+(70"6$.

. 9$-,0,3,(-.%E.W(-(67"C././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.BB.

Page 3: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

. W6"C('.D67-%$.1'(+($,678.5"C%%'././././././././././././././././././././././././././...BB.

. O3-,0"(.[6,,(7-.9$-,0,3,(././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.BV.

. @(I0,,.D'0$,%$.N0*C.5"C%%'./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././...BV.

. [0'&63#((.D6,6'8-,a@(-0*$-.E%7.DC6$*(./././././././././././././././././././././...BY.

. D6$,%$.[0))'(.5"C%%'././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.BZ.

. H,C(7.>7%+0-0$*.>7%*76+-././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..BJ.

.

S(*6'.>7%,(",0%$-.E%7.5,3)($,-.P6"0$*.F(7%.<%'(76$"(.>%'0"0(-./././././././././././.BJ.

.

. >7%C0]0,0%$-.%$.W6"06'.@0-"70+0$6,0%$././././././././././././././././././././././././.TL.

. S(*6'.W0*C,-.%E.5,3)($,-.&0,C.5A("06'.=(()-./././././././././././././././././././..TT.

. <C(.D%$-,0,3,0%$6'.W0*C,.,%.;@3(.>7%"(--?./././././././././././././././././././././.TY.

. 5,6,(.[6$)6,().F(7%.<%'(76$"(./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.TZ.

.

. . W(6-%$-.E%7.@0-"0A'0$(./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.TZ.

. . S6&.1$E%7"(+($,.W(E(776'-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././..TJ.

. . @6,6.D%''(",0%$././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..TJ.

.

D%$"'3-0%$./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././.VL.

.

W("%++($)6,0%$-./././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..VL.

.

1$)$%,(-././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..VT.

.

!AA($)0"(-././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././././..9\:.

Page 4: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

"),*'-$%./0%*!+.

.

.

^(76').!'-,%$b.>7(-0)($,b.=!!D>b.O(EE(7-%$.D%3$,8b.PS.

@7/.M67]676.!7*3+()%b.@(-0*$-.E%7.DC6$*(.

>70$"0A6'.!''6$.M%$0''6b.>6'+.5A70$*-.[0))'(.5"C%%'.

>7%E/.>6%'%.!$$0$%b.P'%70)6.5,6,(.c$04(7-0,8.S6&.5"C%%'.

d6,C'(($.M%3$)8b.D($,(7.E%7.S6&.6$).1)3"6,0%$.

1''($.M%8'6$b.1)3"6,0%$.S6&.D($,(7._=(&67#b.=O`.

O6"X3('0$(.M7%&$(b.=!!D>b.P'6*'(7.D%3$,8b.PS..

13*($(.M786$,b.=!!D>b.[5.5,6,(.D%$E(7($"(..

O6$(''.M87)b.=!!D>.S@P..

>70$"0A6'.5,(4(.D6$,((-b.@(5%,%.D%3$,8.N/5/b.PS.

S0-6.D67+%$6b.D!W1b.>6'+.M(6"C.D%3$,8b.PS.

1))0(.D76&E%7)b.=!!D>b.S%30-06$6.5,6,(.D%$E(7($"(.

DC70-,0$([email protected]'%70)6.@(A67,+($,.%E.1)3"6,0%$.

>70$"0A6'.13$0"(.@640-b.=%7,C.@6)(.[0))'(.5"C%%'b._[06+0b.PS`.

>70$"0A6'.<C('+6.@640-b.[6)0-%$.[0))'(.5"C%%'b._[06+0b.PS`.

d6,C'(($.5/.@(40$(b.c/5/[email protected]'.W0*C,-.@040-0%$.

O%C$.@3(b.1-Xb._[06+0b.PS`.

@7/.d(40$.@&8(7b.=6,0%$6'.!--e$.%E.5"C%%'.>-8"C%'%*0-,-..

@640).P(''%&-b.H$\D6+A3-.9$,(74($,0%$.>7%*76+.

1).P0(7%-b.1)3"6,0%$.W(-(67"C(7.

1'60$(.P0$#b.1-X/b.S(*6'.5(740"(-._D0$"0$$6,0b.HN`.

O%6$.P07-,b.=6,0%$6'.D%6'0,0%$.E%7.!)4%"6"8.E%7.5,3)($,-.

D%''(($.P'8$$b.[0'&63#((.D6,6'8-,.

56+3('.^68b.[06+0\@6)(.D%3$,8.>3]'0".5"C%%'-.

[6$)8.N6''b.[06+0b.PS.

D'676.N6''b.>7($,0--b.[5.

>70$"0A6'.50+0$(.N(0-(b.^/I/.D674(7.[0))'(.5"C%%'.

@7/.>63'.[/.d0$*(78b.<C(.N6+0',%$.P0-C.9$-,0,3,(.H$.5"C%%'.

.....6$).D%++3$0,8.f0%'($"(.

M706$.d0$,0-"Cb.D($,(7.E%7.DC0')7($.6$).1)3"6,0%$._^!`.

>6,70"06.S67#($-b.PS.

>(,(7.["D6](b.c/5/.@H1)/b.HEE0"(.E%7.D040'.W0*C,-.

>7%E(--%7.d($.[6"#b.N67467).S6&.5"C%%'.

>70$"0A6'.d6,C'(($.[68(7b.W6"C('.D67-%$.1'(+/.5"C%%'.

5C6X360'.[%$,*%+(78b.5,3)($,.

@%$6').[%%7(b.@(-0*$-.E%7.DC6$*(.

@640).H-C(7b.!"#$%&'()*(+,%,-,#+)./$)0#+#'$&1.

@06$(.[/.>67($,b.1-X/b.<C(.1@S!I.>7%g(",.

@($$0-.>67#(7b.=!!D>.S@P..

S($.W(0-(7b.1)3"6,0%$.S6&.D($,(7.

<C(7(-6.56$"C(Ub.P'%70)6.@(A67,+($,.%E.1)3"6,0%$.

53-6$.56$)'(7b.O3-,0"(.[6,,(7-._D!`.

Page 5: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

W($((.563"()%b.D($,7%.S(*6'.@(.S6.W6U6._D!`.

<0+.50$)('67b.@0-6]0'0,8.S6&.D($,(7._M%-,%$b.[!`.

M(,,8.5+0,Cb.[0'&63#((.D6,6'8-,-.

>7%E/.>6+('6.O/.5+0,Cb.M%-,%$.D%''(*(.S6&.5"C%%'.

5C67%$.5%',+6$b.@(-0*$-.E%7.DC6$*(._DC0"6*%b.9S`.

I0''06+.<68'%7b.D0,0U($-e.D%++0--0%$.%$.D040'.W0*C,-.

!]0*60'.<70''($b.1-X/.

>63'.I("#-,0($b.D($,(7.E%7.S6&.6$).1)3"6,0%$.

O3$0%3-.I0''06+-b.c7]6$.5,76,(*0(-.

W3,C.F&(0E'(7b.5,3)($,.!)4%"6"8.D($,(7.%E.[0"C0*6$.

.

.

@7(&.D%++3$0,8.f%,(7e-.S(6*3(._[5`.

[%$,*%+(78.D%3$,8.D0,0U($-.E%7.h36'0,8.1)3"6,0%$._[5`.

=!!D>b..O(EE(7-%$.D%3$,8b.PS.

=6,0%$6'.D%3$"0'.%$.@0-6]0'0,8.

5%3,C.D67%'0$6.c$0,().!",0%$.

5%3,C(7$.1"C%._[5`.

.

.

<C0-.W(A%7,.&6-.+6)(.A%--0]'(.]8.*($(7%3-.-3AA%7,.E7%+.,C(.P%7).P%3$)6,0%$b.

O%C$.@/.6$).D6,C(70$(.</.[6"!7,C37.P%3$)6,0%$b.DC67'(-.5,(&67,.[%,,.

P%3$)6,0%$b.HA($.5%"0(,8.9$-,0,3,(.6$).,C(.W%"#(E(''(7.P%3$)6,0%$/!

.

Page 6: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""!#$%&'$'()*)%)"(&+(+,**$-(*+(./)$/$'&0*1!&)(2%(&1()*!3*

*4(#!*$!5(#/&1(*/&+*)1-!!5*+')1'"5'&(*"!5'1'()!!!

!! (6(1%$'.(*)%77/#8!!"#!$%&!'($&)*'$%!+(!'!#,*-&)!+(!%./%!0)+(.1&2!&3$)&*&14!5.+1&#$!.#6.7&#$8!'$!0,-1.6!86%++182!*'#4!8$'$&!'#7!1+6'1!&7,6'$.+#!&#$.$.&8!%'5&!'7+0$&7!$%&!8'*&!%')8%!'#7!*'#7'$+)42!9$':&;#+;0).8+#&)8<!'00)+'6%!$+!7.86.01.#&!6,))&#$14!-&.#/!,8&7!.#!$%.8!6+,#$)4=8!6).*.#'1!>,8$.6&!848$&*?!!!!""#$%&'(%()*+,&*")'-)-.+/0)+1)23*%3%('4+5#'*)6&)'7)*+#8+9)$#+/#:)$3'7)+3'-+,70##:+

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

!

! "!

Page 7: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

4;=<*$<C;=9@A;*"<C>A>;?*+>?B=<B<=D><@9CCE*'FB9AD*7>@<=>DE*1G>CH=;@*9@H*1G>CH=;@*I>DG*+>?9J>C>D>;?**

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`"!+(!$%&!A.5.1!)./%$8!H6$8!+(!MN]\2!0)+86).-&8!-+$%!.#$&#$.+#'1!7.86).*.#'$.+#!'#7!0+1.6.&8!$%'$!0)+7,6&!'#!'75&)8&!)'6.'1!.*0'6$!'#7!')&!#+$!>,8$.(.&7!'8!9&7,6'$.+#'114!#&6&88')42<!.$!%'8!-&&#!1')/&14!.#&((&6$.5&!'#7!)')&14!&#(+)6&7?!!a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

L&)+!@+1&)'#6&!0+1.6.&82!-4!$%&.)!#'$,)&2!7+!#+$!0)+5.7&!/,.7'#6&!+)!.#8$),6$.+#?!!a)&^,&#$142!-&6',8&!$%&8&!0+1.6.&8!(+6,8!7.)&6$14!+#!%')8%!(+)*8!+(!0,#.8%*&#$2!J%.6%!')&!.#%&)&#$14!,#>,8$2!$%&4!-)&&7!7.8$),8$!.#!8$,7&#$8!$+J')7!'7,1$82!'#7!#,)$,)&!'#!'75&)8').'12!6+#()+#$'$.+#'1!'$$.$,7&?!!!b#&!+(!$%&!7&5&1+0*&#$'1!#&&78!+(!86%++1;'/&7!6%.17)&#2!J%.6%!*'#4!1&'7.#/!0846%+1+/.8$8!-&1.&5&!*,8$!-&!*&$2!.8!$%&.)!#&&7!$+!7&5&1+0!8$)+#/2!$),8$.#/!

!

! "#!

Page 8: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

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

Y$,7&#$8!J%+!')&!8,80&#7&7!8,((&)!'6'7&*.6'114?!!"#!*+8$!.#8$'#6&8!$%&4!)&6&.5&!('.1.#/!/)'7&8!+)!7+!#+$!%'5&!+00+)$,#.$.&8!$+!*':&!,0!*.88&7!86%++1J+):?!!@%&4!('11!.))&$).&5'-14!-&%.#72!'#7!$%&)&!.8!'!*+7&)'$&!$+!8$)+#/!.#7.6'$.+#!$%'$!$%&4!J.11!&5&#$,'114!7)+0!+,$!+(!86%++1?!!S+)&!$%'#!PRX!+(!8+0%+*+)&8!J%+!7)+0!+,$!%'5&!-&&#!8,80&#7&7!'#7!$%'$!%./%!86%++1!7)+0+,$8!')&!*+)&!1.:&14!$+!-&!.#6')6&)'$&7?!!b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a+)$4;+#&!8$'$&8!)&^,.)&!86%++18!$+!)&0+)$!8$,7&#$8!$+!1'J!&#(+)6&*&#$!'/&#6.&8!(+)!5').+,8!6+#7,6$!6+**.$$&7!.#!86%++1?!!"#!c&((&)8+#!U'5.8!A+,#$42!S.88.88.00.2!(+)!&3'*01&2!$%&8&!)&(&))'18!%'5&!)&8,1$&7!.#!8$,7&#$8!-&.#/!(.#&7!dMWR;dWRR2!/.5&#!]!*+#$%8!$+!M!4&')!0)+-'$.+#2!01'6&7!+#!6,)(&J2!'#7!-&.#/!)&^,.)&7!$+!0&)(+)*!\R;OR!%+,)8!+(!6+**,#.$4!8&)5.6&?!!19?;*)DNH>;?*'CCN?D=9D>@K*DG;*"G>C<?<BGE*<L*4;=<*$<C;=9@A;*

!a&7&)'1!'#7!8$'$&!7.86.01.#')4!1'J8!0&)*.$!86%++1!+((.6.'18!$+!,8&!$%&.)!7.86)&$.+#!J%&#!7+1.#/!+,$!0,#.8%*&#$8?!!F+J!0).#6.0'18!6%++8&!$+!&3&)6.8&!$%'$!7.86)&$.+#!7&$&)*.#&8!-+$%!$%&!&3$&#$!$+!J%.6%!L&)+!@+1&)'#6&!J.11!-&!,8&72!'#7!8,-8&^,&#$142!$%&!)'$&!'$!J%.6%!6%.17)&#!&.$%&)!J.11!-&!'11+J&7!$+!$':&!'75'#$'/&!+(!&7,6'$.+#'1!+00+)$,#.$.&82!8,80&#7&72!+)!&30&11&7?!!@%&!5').+,8!0%.1+8+0%.&8!,8&7!-4!7.((&)&#$!0).#6.0'18!.#!(+,)!

!

! "##!

Page 9: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

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b#&!0).#6.0'1!'88&)$&72!9.(!$&'6%&)8!J+,17!1&')#!%+J!$+!$&'6%2<!8,80&#8.+#!)'$&8!J+,17!-&!1+J&)?!!H!$&'6%&)!.#!'#+$%&)!86%++1!8$'$&72!9.(!4+,!:&&0!$%&*!-,842!$%&4e)&!/++7?<!!"#!('6$2!'8!+#&!0).#6.0'1!&301'.#&72!&5&#!$%&!-)./%$&8$!8$,7&#$8!/&$!.#$+!$)+,-1&!J%&#!$%&4!')&!-+)&7?!!@%,82!.#!86%++18!$%'$!1'6:!)&8+,)6&8!8,6%!'8!%./%14!^,'1.(.&7!$&'6%&)82!$&3$-++:82!8,001&*&#$'1!.#8$),6$.+#'1!*'$&).'182!6+*0,$&)8!'#7!+$%&)!)&8+,)6&82!.$!.8!0)+-'-1&!$%'$!8$,7&#$8!*'4!-&!*+)&!0)+#&!$+!&#/'/&!.#!*.86+#7,6$?!!H77.$.+#'1142!*'#4!'7*.#.8$)'$+)8!6+*01'.#&7!$%'$!*+)&!6+,#8&1+)8!')&!#&&7&7?!!!@%&!6'8&!8$,7.&8!(+,#7!/&#&)'1!6+#8&#8,8!$%'$!$&'6%&)8!#&&7!$+!-&!$)'.#&7!.#!61'88)++*!*'#'/&*&#$!'#7!6+#(1.6$!)&8+1,$.+#?!!I&6',8&!$&'6%&)8!')&!$%&!(.)8$!1.#:!.#!$%&!7.86.01.#')4!0)+6&882!$%&4!8%+,17!-&!-&$$&)!&^,.00&7!$+!7&'1!J.$%!-&%'5.+)'1!0)+-1&*8!,8.#/!.##+5'$.5&!8$)'$&/.&8!$%'$!7+!#+$!8%,$!+,$!8$,7&#$8!(+)!$40.6'1!'7+1&86&#$!*.8-&%'5.+)?!b(!$%&!(+,)!86%++18!8$,7.&72!+#14!+#&!0)+5.7&8!$%.8!$40&!+(!0)+(&88.+#'1!7&5&1+0*&#$!$)'.#.#/?!!!!a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

! ![.$%!$%&!.#6)&'8.#/!,8&!+(!8,80&#8.+#!'#7!&30,18.+#82!8+*&!86%++18!')&!7&(4.#/!$%&!8$'$,8!^,+?!!@%)&&!+)/'#.K'$.+#8!f!$%&!A&#$&)!(+)!T((&6$.5&!A+11'-+)'$.+#!'#7!C)'6$.6&!+(!$%&!H*&).6'#!"#8$.$,$&!+(!B&8&')6%2!$%&!c,8$.6&!S'$$&)8!"#8$.$,$&2!'#7!S.1J',:&&!A'$'148$gU&8./#!(+)!A%'#/&!f!%'5&!'11!0,-1.8%&7!)&0+)$8!+#!%+J!'!#,*-&)!+(!86%++18!')&!(.#7.#/!$%'$!.$!.8!0+88.-1&!$+!%'5&!'6%.&5&*&#$2!8'(&$4!'#7!'!1+J!#,*-&)!+(!7.86.01.#')4!)&(&))'18?!!!!T88&#$.'1!&1&*&#$8!+(!$%&8&!86%++18!.#61,7&!0+8.$.5&!'00)+'6%&8!$+!7.86.01.#&2!

!

! "###!

Page 10: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

! #$!

+00+)$,#.$.&8!(+)!$&'6%&)8!'#7!8$,7&#$8!$+!-+#72!$)'.#.#/!(+)!$&'6%&)8!61'88)++*!*'#'/&*&#$!$&6%#.^,&82!61&')14!,#7&)8$++7!6+7&8!+(!6+#7,6$!'#7!7.86.01.#&!(+6,8&7!+#!0)&5&#$.+#!+(!0)+-1&*8?!!F+J&5&)2!$%&!J+):!.#5+15&7!.#!8,66&88(,114!$)'#8(+)*.#/!'!86%++1=8!6,1$,)&!.8!'!7',#$.#/!$'8:!$%'$!)&^,.)&8!'!8$&'7('8$!6+**.$*&#$!()+*!$%&!0).#6.0'12!$&'6%&)82!8$'((2!0')&#$8!'#7!6+**,#.$4?!!@+!'6%.&5&!$%.8!$)'#8(+)*'$.+#2!'7,1$8!*,8$!'#'14K&!$%&.)!+J#!-&%'5.+)8!'8!J&11!'8!$%&!-&%'5.+)8!+(!$%&.)!8$,7&#$82!'#7!-&!+0&#!$+!6%'#/.#/!0)'6$.6&8!$%'$!*'4!#+!1+#/&)!(.$!J.$%!$%&!86%++1=8!+5&)'11!*.88.+#?!![%.1&!$%&8&!86%++18!7+!#+$!0)+5.7&!'#4!*'/.6!(+)*,1'82!$%&4!7+!+((&)!%+0&(,1!-1,&0).#$8!(+)!%+J!0)+/)&88!.#!$%.8!7.)&6$.+#!6'#!-&!*'7&?!!@%&.)!&30&).&#6&82!'1+#/!J.$%!$%+8&!+(!+$%&)!86%++18!,#7&)/+.#/!8.*.1')!$)'#8(+)*'$.+#82!6'#!-&!$)&*&#7+,814!.#8$),*&#$'1!.#!%&10.#/!+$%&)!86%++1!'#7!6+**,#.$.&8!.#!$%&.)!&((+)$8!$+!'6%.&5&!8.*.1')!/+'18?!!

Page 11: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!"#$%&'(#!%"!!

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

14*++5!2(7$)&!02!(!4%0)04(55&!089+%)(/)!022,$=!!K$4$/)!)%(-$'0$2!*(#$!*$0-*)$/$'!)*$!9,6504L2!7$(%!(/'!5$'!)+!5$-0)08()$!4(552!7+%!2)%+/-$%!9%$#$/)0#$!8$(2,%$2=!!M+J$#$%3!J$!8,2)!%$8$86$%!)*()!C24*++52!%$8(0/!+/$!+7!)*$!2(7$2)!95(4$2!7+%!4*05'%$/!(/'!&+,)*=EA!!N$)3!)*$!$#0'$/4$!-()*$%$'!0/!)*02!K$9+%)!8(?$2!45$(%!)*()!$77+%)2!)+!(''%$22!-,/23!'%,-23!(/'!+)*$%!)%,5&!'(/-$%+,2!24*++5!20),()0+/2!*(#$!29,/!)+)(55&!+,)!+7!4+/)%+53!2J$$90/-!,9!80550+/2!+7!24*++54*05'%$/!J*+!9+2$!/+!)*%$()!)+!2(7$)&!0/)+!(!/$)!+7!$O45,20+/!7%+8!$',4()0+/(5!+99+%),/0)0$2!(/'!0/)+!4%080/(5!9%+2$4,)0+/=!!!

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

!! @!

Page 12: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

WW3XXX!2),'$/)2!7+%!)*$!/+/D#0+5$/)!+77$/2$2!+7!!C'02+6$&0/-!%,5$23E!C0/2,6+%'0/()0+/3E!(/'!C'02%,9)0+/=E!!

P/!)*$!2)%04)$2)!2$/2$3!)*$2$!9+5040$2!9%+#0'$!/+/'024%$)0+/(%&!9,/02*8$/)!-,0'$50/$2=W!!M+J$#$%3!)*$&!*(#$!6$4+8$!8,4*!8+%$=!!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!*(2!6$4+8$!(!9*05+2+9*&!)*()!*(2!9$%8$()$'!+,%!24*++52Y!0)!$895+&2!(!6%,)(55&!2)%04)!'0240950/(%&!8+'$5!)*()!$86%(4$2!*(%2*!9,/02*8$/)!+#$%!$',4()0+/=!!B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!)*02!(99%+(4*!)+!'0240950/$3!2),'$/)2!(%$!5+20/-!+,)!+/!$',4()0+/(5!+99+%),/0)0$2=!!Q(2$!2),'0$2!+7!80''5$!24*++52!0/!F0(80DZ('$!Q+,/)&3!4+/)(0/$'!0/!)*02!K$9+%)3!'$8+/2)%()$!)*()!J*$%$!)*$![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9*05+2+9*&!02!0/#+?$'3!%$-(%'5$22!+7!!0/40'$/4$2!+7!4%08$!(/'!#0+5$/4$3!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!(%$!*0-*$%=!!;*$!K$9+%)!(52+!0/'04()$2!)*()!$#$/!J*$%$!24*++52!$O9$%0$/4$!%$9$()$'!#0+5()0+/2!+7!4+'$2!+7!4+/',4)3!)*$&!4(/!2,44$227,55&!$895+&!2+5,)0+/2!+)*$%!)*(/!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/2=!!H7!-%$()$%!4+/4$%/3!)*02!K$9+%)!0/'04()$2!)*()!4*05'%$/!(%$!/+)!+/5&!6$0/-!)%$()$'!50?$!4%080/(52!0/!24*++53!6,)!8(/&!(%$!6$0/-!2*,/)$'!0/)+!)*$!4%080/(5!G,2)04$!2&2)$8!(2!24*++52!*(#$!6$-,/!)+!%$5&!*$(#05&!,9+/!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!+77040(52!)+!9,/02*!2),'$/)2=!!

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`!!

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a!!K()*$%!)*(/!4+/4$/)%()$!+/!J$$'0/-!+,)!2),'$/)2!J*+!9+2$!9%+65$823!)*$&!6$50$#$!)*()!8+2)!6$*(#0+%2!)*()!80-*)!J(%%(/)!$O45,20+/!7%+8!24*++5!4(/!6$!9%$#$/)$'!07!2),'$/)2!9$%4$0#$!)*$82$5#$2!(2!#(5,$'!(/'!%$29$4)$'!8$86$%2!+7!(!5(%-$%!4+88,/0)&!)*()!/,%),%$2!2)%+/-!%$5()0+/2*092!6$)J$$/!24*++5!(',5)2!(/'!2),'$/)23!2$)2!*0-*!6$*(#0+%(5!(/'!(4('$804!

!! A!

Page 13: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

2)(/'(%'23!(/'!#(5,$2!7(0%/$22!(/'!4+/202)$/4&=!!P/!+)*$%!J+%'23!)*$0%!$77+%)2!(%$!-$(%$'!)+J(%'!$5080/()0/-!4$%)(0/!6$*(#0+%23!%()*$%!)*(/!)*$!2),'$/)2!)*$82$5#$2=!!<(%$/)23!2),'$/)23!(4)0#02)23!(/'!9+504&8(?$%2!2*+,5'!$/4+,%(-$!24*++5!2&2)$82!)+!('+9)!)*$2$!9+20)0#$!(/'!$77$4)0#$!2)%()$-0$2=!!

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`!(/'!@a3!J$%$!)*$/!(%%$2)$'!7+%!7$5+/&!(22(,5)3!J*04*!4(%%0$2!(!8(O08,8!9$/(5)&!+7!70#$!&$(%2!0/!9%02+/=!!;*$!1*$%077!4+88$/)$'!)+!+/$!/$J29(9$%3!Cb;c*02!)08$!0)!J(2!9$(/,)23!6,)!07!J$!'+/d)!-$)!(!*(/'5$!+/!0)3!)*$!/$O)!)08$!0)!4+,5'!6$!6+'0$2=Ee!!;*$!&+,/-!8$/!5+2)!)*$0%!6,2!9%0#05$-$2!(/'!2,29$/20+/!J(2!%$4+88$/'$'=!!B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!)*$!(2202)(/4$!+7!(/!())+%/$&!(/'!4+88,/0)&!9%$22,%$3!)*$!4%080/(5!4*(%-$2!J$%$!'028022$'=!M+J$#$%3!(55!70#$!&+,/-!8$/3!J*+!J$%$!G,/0+%2!(/'!2$/0+%23!'%+99$'!+,)!+7!24*++5!6$4(,2$!)*$&!5(4?$'!)%(/29+%)()0+/!)+!)%(#$5!)*$!RX!805$2!)+!)*$0%!24*++5!0/!)*02!9++%3!%,%(5!4+,/)&!0/!)*$!F0220220990!Z$5)(=!!;*$!089(4)!+7!)*$!9,/02*8$/)!J(2!,/'$%24+%$'!6&!+/$!+7!)*$!&+,/-!8$/!J*+!2)()$'3!CP!bJ+,5'!*(#$c!-+/$!)+!4+55$-$====!!F(&6$!P!4+,5'!*(#$!6$$/!(!5(J&$%=E!!;*02!2)+%&!8(&!6$!0/4%$',5+,23!6,)!0)!02!)%,$Y!0)!$90)+80[$2!)*$!%$4$/)!+#$%%$(4)0+/!)+!/+/D#0+5$/)!4*05'02*!6$*(#0+%3!(/'!)*$!089(4)!+7!2$/2$5$22!9,/02*8$/)=!!)#*+,-"%-.$!/%",$/0-&!/(!.1!",!!

Z02)%04)2!)*%+,-*+,)!)*$!4+,/)%&!*(#$!('+9)$'!(!C)(?$!/+!9%02+/$%2E!())0),'$!)+J(%'!'0240950/$=!!B2!(!%$2,5)3!8+%$!)*(/!R=@!80550+/!2),'$/)2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!',%0/-!)*$!@eea!24*++5!&$(%Y!(/+)*$%!a`3XXX!J$%$!$O9$55$'=@X!!B5)*+,-*!%$4+%'D?$$90/-!(/'!'()(!(#(05(6050)&!+/!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/2!02!0/('$>,()$!(/'!0/4+/202)$/)3!)*$!/,86$%2!)*()!(%$!(#(05(65$!9(0/)!(/!$O)%$8$5&!)%+,650/-!904),%$=!!I(2)!&$(%3!0/!f$77$%2+/!Q+,/)&3!U5+%0'(3!(!28(553!9%$'+80/(/)5&!65(4?!24*++5!'02)%04)3!WR!g!+7!)*$!*0-*!24*++5!2),'$/)2!(/'!R@!g!+7!80''5$!24*++5!2),'$/)2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!()!5$(2)!+/4$=@@!!P/!]024+/20/3!2,29$/20+/2!*(#$!0/4%$(2$'!RWg!20/4$!@ee@DeAY!A\=\g!+7!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!8(5$2!(/'!@e=`\g!+7!_()0#$!B8$%04(/!8(5$2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!',%0/-!)*$!@ee`Dea!24*++5!&$(%=@A!!Q*04(-+!<,6504!14*++52!*(#$!$O9$%0$/4$'!(!'%(8()04!0/4%$(2$!0/!)*$!/,86$%!+7!$O9,520+/2!DD!(/!0/4%$(2$!7%+8!@W!0/!@eeADeR!)+!`R`!0/!@eeaDee=@R!!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!2),'$/)2!%$9%$2$/)!`Rg!+7!)*+2$!$O9$55$'!6,)!+/5&!\Rg!+7!2),'$/)!$/%+558$/)Y!I()0/+!2),'$/)2!%$9%$2$/)!AXg!+7!2),'$/)2!$O9$55$'=@W!!Z$290)$!)*02!'02),%60/-!20),()0+/!0/!Q*04(-+3!)*$!24*++5!'02)%04)!2$)!(!-+(5!+7!

!! R!

Page 14: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

$O9$550/-!$#$/!8+%$!2),'$/)2!',%0/-!)*$!@eeeDAXXX!24*++5!&$(%3!6%0/-0/-!)*$!/,86$%!,9!)+!@3\XX!2),'$/)2=@\!!!P/!U5+%0'(3!R3aR@!2),'$/)2!J$%$!%$7$%%$'!)+!)*$!f,#$/05$!f,2)04$!2&2)$8!7+%!4+/',4)!0/!24*++5=@^!!;*$!$O45,20+/!+7!2),'$/)2!7%+8!)*$!$',4()0+/(5!9%+4$22!02!(!4%0202!+7!$90'$804!9%+9+%)0+/2Y!0)!*(2!5+/-D)$%8!089504()0+/2!/+)!+/5&!7+%!)*$!2),'$/)2!(77$4)$'3!6,)!(52+!7+%!+,%!2+40$)&!(2!(!J*+5$=!!

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`!!

h! B!20O!&$(%D+5'!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!4*05'!J(2!2,29$/'$'!7+%!)$/!'(&2!7+%!6%0/-0/-!(!)+$/(05!45099$%!)+!24*++5=!!B!24*++5!6+(%'!8$86$%!2(0'3!C;*02!02!/+)!(6+,)!(!)+$/(05!45099$%i!!;*02!02!(6+,)!)*$!())(4*8$/)2!+/!)*$!)+$/(05!45099$%iE!SM(%%026,%-3!<BT@a!

!h! B!?0/'$%-(%)$/!6+&!0/!<$//2&5#(/0(!J(2!2,29$/'$'!7+%!6%0/-0/-!(!

)+&!(O!)+!24*++5!(2!9(%)!+7!*02!M(55+J$$/!4+2),8$=@e!!

h! B!@WD&$(%D+5'!6+&!802)(?$/5&!5$7)!(!9+4?$)?/07$!0/!*02!6++?!6(-!(7)$%!(!V+&!14+,)!4(890/-!)%09=!!B)!*02!*$(%0/-3!)*$!6+&L2!14+,)!F(2)$%!)$2)070$'!+/!)*$!6+&d2!6$*(57=!!;*$!2),'$/)!J(2!$O9$55$'!,/'$%!)*$!'02)%04)L2!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+504&3!J*04*!%$>,0%$2!$O9,520+/!7+%!9+22$220+/!+7!?/0#$2=!!B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!(/!(99$(5!6&!I$-(5!B0'!1+40$)&!+7!j%$()$%!Q0/40//()03!)*$!2),'$/)!J(2!%$('80))$'!)+!24*++53!6,)!*('!(5%$('&!8022$'!aX!'(&2!+7!24*++5=!SHMT!

!h! B!W)*!-%('$!)$/D&$(%D+5'!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!-0%5!J(2!4*(%-$'!J0)*!

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

!! W!

Page 15: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

-%('$2!\D@A!+/5&=!!;*$!14*++5!Z02)%04)!9%+8+)$'!*$%3!'$290)$!*$%!7(050/-!-%('$23!0/!+%'$%!)+!-$)!*$%!+,)!+7!)*$!8(0/2)%$(8!24*++5=!!K$>,$2)2!7+%!(!',$!9%+4$22!*$(%0/-!*(#$!6$$/!'$/0$'=!SF1T!

!h! B/!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!e)*!-%('$%!J(2!$O9$55$'!7+%!+/$!&$(%!7%+8!(!

9%$'+80/(/)5&!J*0)$!24*++5!'02)%04)!(/'!2$/)!)+!(/!(5)$%/()0#$!24*++5!6$4(,2$!2*$!*('!29(%?5$%2!0/!*$%!6++?!6(-=!!1*$!*('!,2$'!)*$8!+#$%!)*$!J$$?$/'!(/'!7+%-+)!)*$&!J$%$!0/!*$%!6(-=!S"(2)!V()+/!K+,-$!<(%02*3!IBT!

!h! B/!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!8(5$!`)*!-%('$%!6$)!(!24*++58()$!+/!)*$!

+,)4+8$!+7!(!24*++5!6(2?$)6(55!-(8$=!!;*$!24*++58()$3!J*+!5+2)!)*$!6$)3!(44,2$'!)*$!6+&!+7!)*%$()$/0/-!*08!7+%!9(&8$/)=!!;*$!24*++5!'02)%04)!4+/',4)$'!/+!0/#$2)0-()0+/!(/'!0/2)$('!/+)070$'!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!+77040(52=!!;*$!`)*!-%('$%!J(2!4*(%-$'!J0)*!7$5+/&!$O)+%)0+/!(/'!$O9$55$'=!S1(/!U%(/4024+3!QBT!

!h! B!@X)*!-%('$!*+/+%2!2),'$/)3!J*+!J(2!<%$20'$/)!+7!)*$!V5(4?!

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

!h! U0#$!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!7$8(5$!2),'$/)23!J*+!J$%$!6$2)!7%0$/'23!

J$%$!2,29$/'$'!70#$!'(&2!7+%!70-*)0/-=!!H/5&!)J+!+7!)*$!-0%52!(4),(55&!7+,-*)Y!)*$!)*%$$!+)*$%2!())$89)$'!)+!6%$(?!,9!)*$!70-*)=!!;*$!70#$!8('$D,9!5()$%!)*()!'(&=!!P/!(''0)0+/!)+!)*$!70#$!'(&!2,29$/20+/23!)*%$$!+7!)*$8!J$%$!?04?$'!+77!)*$!4*$$%5$('$%2d!2>,('!S(/'!4(//+)!)%&!+,)!(-(0/!7+%!A!&$(%2T3!)J+!J$%$!/+)!9$%80))$'!)+!95(&!+/!)*$!-0%52d!6(2?$)6(55!)$(83!(/'!/+/$!J$%$!(55+J$'!)+!%,/!7+%!*+8$4+80/-!4+,%)=!!U,%)*$%3!(7)$%!)*$0%!2,29$/20+/2!J$%$!2$%#$'3!)*$!-0%52!J$%$!%$>,0%$'!)+!(99$(%!0/!N+,)*!Q+,%)!J*$%$!)*$&!J$%$!70/$'!k@\X!D!kAXX3!-0#$/!WX!D!aX!*+,%2!4+88,/0)&!2$%#04$3!95(4$'!+/!4,%7$J!7+%!20O!8+/)*23!(/'!(220-/$'!)+!9%+6()0+/!7+%!+/$!&$(%=!!;*$!-0%52!*('!/+!9%0+%!2,29$/20+/2!+%!%$4+%'!+7!6$*(#0+%(5!9%+65$82=!S<%$/)0223!F1T!

!h! B!7+,%D&$(%D+5'!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!4*05'!J(2!2,29$/'$'!7+%!+/$!'(&!

!! \!

Page 16: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

6$4(,2$!*$!(55$-$'5&!9,2*$'!(/'!2*+#$'!*02!45(228()$2!+/!)*$!95(&-%+,/'=!!;*$!?0/'$%-(%)/$%L2!8+)*$%!4+895(0/$'!)*()!2*$!J(2!/+)!/+)070$'!+7!)*02!6$*(#0+%!(/'!)*,2!J(2!/+)!-0#$/!(/!+99+%),/0)&!)+!4+%%$4)!*02!6$*(#0+%=AX!

!h! H/!*02!J(&!)+!24*++53!(/!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!8(5$!S\)*!-%('$%T!J(2!

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

!h! B/!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!*+/+%2!2),'$/)!())$/'0/-!24*++5!0/!(!

9%$'+80/(/)5&!J*0)$!24*++5!'02)%04)!J(2!2,29$/'$'!7%+8!24*++5!0/'$70/0)$5&!7+%!70-*)0/-=!!;*02!J(2!*$%!70%2)!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(5=!S1QT!

!h! K$4$/)5&3!',%0/-!(!J*0)$!2,62)0),)$!)$(4*$%L2!())$89)2!)+!8(0/)(0/!

'0240950/$!0/!(!45(22%++83!(!707)$$/D&$(%D+5'!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!7$8(5$!)+5'!)*$!)$(4*$%!CPd8!-+0/-!)+!J*09!&+,=E!!;*$!4*05'!J(2!$O9$55$'!7+%!)*$!%$8(0/'$%!+7!)*$!24*++5!&$(%!(/'!4*(%-$'!J0)*!(22(,5)=!S./'$%!U5+%0'(!4%080/(5!4+'$23!U5=!!1)=!l`aW=Xa@3!(22(,5)!(-(0/2)!24*++5!9$%2+//$5!02!(!70%2)!'$-%$$!802'$8$(/+%=T!Sm,0/4&3!UIT!

!h! ./'$%!(!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+504&3!(/!H*0+!24*++5!'02)%04)!

%$4+88$/'$'!$O9$550/-!(!`)*!-%('$!2),'$/)!7+%!(55$-$'5&!2/0770/-!J*0)$D+,)!)*()!2*$!J(2!,20/-!0/!45(22=!!;*$!2),'$/)!'$/0$'!)*$!(55$-()0+/=!!I$-(5!B0'!1+40$)&!+7!j%$()$%!Q0/40//()0!#$%070$'!J0)*!'%,-!$O9$%)2!)*()!J*0)$D+,)!02!/+)!(!'%,-=!!;*$!2),'$/)!J(2!,5)08()$5&!2,29$/'$'!7+%!/0/$!'(&2Y!*$%!24*++5!%$4+%'2!0/'04()$!2,29$/20+/!7+%!'%,-!(6,2$=!SHMT!

!h! B/!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!*0-*!24*++5!2),'$/)!J(2!%$7$%%$'!7+%!

$O9,520+/!7+%!(22(,5)0/-!(!)$(4*$%=!!;*$!)$(4*$%!J(2!*0)!(440'$/)(55&!J*05$!6%$(?0/-!,9!(!70-*)!6$)J$$/!)J+!2),'$/)2=!!SV+)*!2),'$/)2!J$%$!(%%$2)$'=T!!V(2$'!+/!)*$!(55$-()0+/!)*()!)*$!2),'$/)!(22(,5)$'!)*$!)$(4*$%3!'$290)$!(/&!$#0'$/4$!)*()!0)!J(2!0/)$/)0+/(53!

!! ^!

Page 17: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

)*$!2),'$/)!%$8(0/$'!+,)!+7!24*++5!7+%!)*%$$!8+/)*2=!!B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!(/!(99$(5!)+!)*$!24*++5!6+(%'!(/'!2,99+%)!7%+8!)*$!_BBQ<3!)*$!Z02)%04)!(-%$$'!)+!9$%80)!)*$!2),'$/)!)+!%$),%/!)+!)*$!B',5)!M0-*!14*++5=!SU5(-5$%!Q+,/)&3!UIT!

!P/!(''0)0+/!)+!)*$2$!(44+,/)23!)*$%$!*(#$!6$$/!8(/&!+)*$%!2)+%0$2!0/!)*$!

8$'0(!'$8+/2)%()0/-!+#$%%$(4)0+/!+7!24*++5!('80/02)%()+%2!)+!4*05'%$/d2!6$*(#0+%=!!;*$!2)+%0$2!(6+,)!2,29$/20+/!(/'!$O9,520+/2!7+%!2*(%0/-!F0'+53!(2)*8(!8$'04()0+/!S0/!(/!$8$%-$/4&T3!(/'!4+,-*!'%+92!J0)*!45(228()$23!(/'!6%0/-0/-!)+&!-,/23!/(05!45099$%23!(/'!24022+%2!)+!24*++5!(%$!/+)!(/+8(50$2Y!)*$2$!0/40'$/)2!*(99$/!$#$%&!'(&=!!P/!2+8$!0/2)(/4$23!24*++5!'02)%04)2!*(#$!0/)$%9%$)$'!)*$!5(J!)+!$/4+89(22!)*$2$!0)$82!,/'$%!)*$!'$70/0)0+/2!+7!'%,-2!(/'!J$(9+/23!$#$/!J*$/!(55!0/#+5#$'!4+/4$'$!)*()!)*$!2),'$/)2!0/)$/'$'!/+!*(%8=!!#2,-(%1%$-%3-4,$%-#%1,$*"(,!!

K(40(5!'029(%0)0$2!0/!)*$!(99504()0+/!+7!24*++5!'0240950/(%&!9+5040$2!*(#$!5+/-D6$$/!'+4,8$/)$'=A@!!;*$!'029(%0)0$2!(%$!>,0)$!)%+,650/-=!!F+2)!%$4$/)!'()(!7%+8!)*$!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/!0/'04()$2!)*()!J*05$!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!4*05'%$/!+/5&!%$9%$2$/)!@`g!+7!9,6504!24*++5!$/%+558$/)!/()0+/(55&3!)*$&!4+/2)0),)$!RAg!+7!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/2=!!]*0)$!2),'$/)23!^Rg!+7!$/%+558$/)3!%$9%$2$/)!+/5&!\Xg!+7!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!\Xg!+7!$O9,520+/2=AA!!B!%$4$/)!2),'&!6&!)*$!B9950$'!K$2$(%4*!Q$/)$%!2*+J2!)*()!65(4?!4*05'%$/3!9(%)04,5(%5&!65(4?!8(5$23!(%$!'0240950/$'!8+%$!+7)$/!(/'!8+%$!2$#$%$5&!)*(/!(/&!+)*$%!80/+%0)&!-%+,9=AR!!P/!7(4)3!)*$!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/L2!%$9+%)3!!"#$%&'()*)&'$&+$,(-./*)&'$@ee`3!%$#$(52!)*()!(58+2)!A\g!+7!(55!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!8(5$!2),'$/)2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!()!5$(2)!+/4$!+#$%!(!7+,%D&$(%!9$%0+'=!!;*$2$!2)()02)042!6&!)*$82$5#$2!'+!/+)!9%+#$!0/)$/)0+/(5!'024%080/()0+/3!6,)!)*$&!2,--$2)!)*()!2,4*!'024%080/()0+/!8(&!6$!J0'$29%$('=!!B/'3!%$-(%'5$22!J*$)*$%!)*$!'029(%0)0$2!(%$!0/)$/)0+/(5!+%!,/0/)$/)0+/(53!)*$!/,86$%2!(%$!/+/$)*$5$22!(5(%80/-=!!

:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!(%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)+!$O02)!0/!9%$'+80/(/)5&!65(4?!(/'!I()0/+!24*++5!'02)%04)2=!!Z,%0/-!)*$!@ee^De`!24*++5!&$(%3!)*$2$!'02)%04)2!J$%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)+!*(#$!9+5040$2!(''%$220/-!#0+5$/4$!Sa\gT3!70%$(%82!Se`gT3!+)*$%!J$(9+/2!SeWgT3!(/'!'%,-2!SeAgT!)*(/!J*0)$!24*++5!'02)%04)2!S`@g3!eAg3!aag3!(/'!aRg3!%$29$4)0#$5&T=AW!!;*02!'029(%0)&!0/!)*$!('+9)0+/!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!8(&!(52+!(44+,/)!7+%!2+8$!+7!)*$!%(40(5!'029(%0)0$23!()!5$(2)!+/!(!/()0+/(5!5$#$53!0/!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2!)(?$/=!!!

P/7+%8()0+/!+/!)*$!)&9$2!+7!4+/',4)!7+%!J*04*!2),'$/)2!+7!4+5+%!(%$!'0240950/$'3!J*$/!4+860/$'!J0)*!)*$!2)()02)04(5!'029(%0)0$23!9%+',4$2!2)%+/-$%!

!! `!

Page 18: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

$#0'$/4$!7+%!0/7$%%0/-!'024%080/()0+/=!!U+%!$O(895$3!0/!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(3!J*05$!65(4?!4*05'%$/!%$9%$2$/)!+/5&!WAg!+7!9,6504!24*++5!$/%+558$/)3!)*$&!4+/2)0),)$!^@g!+7!)*$!4*05'%$/!4*(%-$'!J0)*!(!'0240950/(%&!4+'$!#0+5()0+/=A\!!P/!(''0)0+/!)+!%$9%$2$/)0/-!(!'029%+9+%)0+/()$!2*(%$!+7!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2!7+%!2$%0+,2!+77$/2$23!65(4?!4*05'%$/!0/!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(!J$%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)*(/!)*$0%!J*0)$!4+,/)$%9(%)2!)+!6$!'0240950/$'!7+%!80/+%!(4)2!+7!8024+/',4)3!2,4*!(2!9+22$220+/!+7!(!9(-$%!+%!'02),%60/-!+%'$%!S0=$=!5+0)$%0/-3!'02),%60/-!9$(4$3!0/)$%7$%0/-!+%!'02),%60/-!0/!(/&!J(&!J0)*!$',4()0+/T=!!P/'$$'3!J*05$!65(4?!(/'!J*0)$!4*05'%$/!J$%$!4*(%-$'!0/!$>,(5!9%+9+%)0+/2!7+%!J$(9+/!#0+5()0+/2!(/'!J*0)$!2),'$/)2!*('!8,4*!*0-*$%!'%,-!4*(%-$23!)*$!'0240950/$!+7!65(4?!2),'$/)2!2+(%$'!0/!)*$!8+2)!2,6G$4)0#$!4()$-+%0$23!J*$%$!)*$!24*++5!+77040(5d2!'$)$%80/()0+/!)*()!(/!0/7%(4)0+/!+44,%%$'!8(&!6$!)(0/)$'!J0)*!60(2!+%!2)$%$+)&9$2=!!

!/5678-(9:5;<=9-/76>?=7-@<AB5=>6B7-CD-$9B?A^!!Q+/',4)!

!<$%4$/)!4*(%-$'!D!

V5(4?!

!<$%4$/)!4*(%-$'!D!]*0)$!

!Z02),%60/-!14*++52!

!^eg!

!! Aeg!

!<(-$%!

!\eg!

!! WXg!

!]$(9+/2!

!Weg!

!! Weg!

!Z%,-2!

!RAg!

!! ^\g!

!B22(,5)!

!`@g!

!! A`g!

!;*%$()$/0/-!14*++5!H77040(5!

!^eg!

!! Aeg!

!!! P/!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(3!)*$!4+/2$>,$/4$2!7+%!)*$!8+%$!80/+%!+77$/2$!+7!CZ02),%60/-!14*++523E!J0)*!J*04*!65(4?!4*05'%$/!J$%$!+#$%J*$580/-5&!4*(%-$'3!(%$!2)055!2$%0+,2=!!H7!)*$!4*05'%$/!4*(%-$'!J0)*!CZ02),%60/-!14*++523E!`Xg!J$%$!%$7$%%$'!)+!(!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/4&3!`Ag!J$%$!%$7$%%$'!7+%!2,29$/20+/3!(/'!A@g!J$%$!%$7$%%$'!7+%!$O9,520+/=A`!!

!! a!

B))+%/$&2!%$9%$2$/)0/-!2),'$/)2!0/!)*$!'0240950/(%&!4(2$2!J*+!J$%$!0/)$%#0$J$'!7+%!)*02!K$9+%)!2)()$!)*()!0/!)*$0%!$O9$%0$/4$3!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!(/'!I()0/+!4*05'%$/!(%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)+!6$!%$7$%%$'!7+%!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/!(/'!)+!6$!'0240950/$'=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!)*$2$!2),'$/)2!(%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)+!6$!'0240950/$'!7+%!80/+%!8024+/',4)!(/'!)+!%$4$0#$!9,/02*8$/)2!'029%+9+%)0+/()$!)+!)*$0%!4+/',4)=Aa!!B))+%/$&2!(52+!%$9+%)!)*()!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!(/'!I()0/+!4*05'%$/!)$/'!)+!6$!2,29$/'$'!7+%!)*$!8+%$!'024%$)0+/(%&!+77$/2$23!2,4*!(2!C'$70(/4$!+7!(,)*+%0)&E!(/'!C'02%$29$4)!+7!(,)*+%0)&=E!!;*$2$!4()$-+%0$2!+7!4+/',4)!45$(%5&!9%+#0'$!8+%$!5()0),'$!7+%!%(40(5!60(2!)+!95(&!(!9(%)!0/!)*$!,2$!+7!'0240950/(%&!

Page 19: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

8$(2,%$2=!!B))+%/$&2!(/'!4+88,/0)&!-%+,92!(22$%)!)*()!24*++5!9$%2+//$5!%$5&!,9+/!%(40(5!(/'!$)*/04!2)$%$+)&9$2!0/!)(?0/-!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2=!!H/$!())+%/$&!%$9+%)$'!)*()!2*$!*(2!+7)$/!*$(%'!)$(4*$%2!4+88$/)!(6+,)!)*$!20[$!+7!65(4?!4*05'%$/!(44,2$'!+7!(22(,5)!+%!6())$%&=!!

;*$!4+/)0/,0/-!9())$%/!+7!%(40(5!'029(%0)0$2!0/!24*++5!'0240950/$!02!(/!022,$!)*()!4(//+)!6$!0-/+%$'=!!K$-(%'5$22!+7!J*$)*$%!0/)$/)0+/(5!'024%080/()0+/!02!)*$!4(,2$!+7!)*$!'029%+9+%)0+/()$!2,29$/20+/!(/'!$O9,520+/!+7!65(4?!(/'!I()0/+!4*05'%$/3!)*$!2)()02)042!(%$!>,0)$!)%+,650/-=!!F+%$!%$2$(%4*!02!/$$'$'!)+!'$)$%80/$!)*$!4(,2$!+7!)*$!'029(%0)0$2=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!)*$!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/L2!H7704$!7+%!Q0#05!K0-*)23!J*04*!02!$/)%,2)$'!J0)*!$/7+%4$8$/)!+7!;0)5$!nP3!(/'!)*$!./0)$'!1)()$2!Q+880220+/!+/!Q0#05!K0-*)2!2*+,5'!#0-+%+,25&!0/#$2)0-()$!)*$2$!'029(%0)0$2=!!P)!02!089$%()0#$!)*()!0//+#()0#$!2+5,)0+/2!)+!)*02!9%+65$8!6$!0895$8$/)$'=!!H,%!2+40$)&!4(//+)!(77+%'!)+!5$(#$!(/&!+/$!2$-8$/)!+7!+,%!9+9,5()0+/!6$*0/'=!!!@.*(#-%"-(2!1&$,"-E!#2-/.,(!*1-",,&/!!

:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!(%$!(52+!*(#0/-!(!9%+7+,/'!089(4)!+/!4*05'%$/!J0)*!29$40(5!/$$'2=!!P/!@ee`3!)*$!P/'0#0',(52!J0)*!Z02(6050)0$2!"',4()0+/!B4)!SPZ"BT3!AX!.=1=Q=!@WXX!#*$0#123$J(2!(8$/'$'!)+!$/2,%$!)*()!(!4*05'!J+,5'!/+)!6$!9,/02*$'!7+%!6$*(#0+%!)*()!J(2!(!4*(%(4)$%02)04!+7!)*$!4*05'L2!'02(6050)&=!!B5)*+,-*!7$'$%(5!5(J!9%+#0'$2!)*02!9%+)$4)0+/!7+%!29$40(5!$',4()0+/!2),'$/)23!24*++5!+77040(52!+7)$/!,/7(0%5&!'0240950/$!4*05'%$/!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2=!!U+%!$O(895$o!!

h! B/!(,)02)04!4*05'!*0)!(!)$(4*$%=!!;*$!4*05'!J(2!$O9$55$'!(/'!4*(%-$'!J0)*!6())$%&3!J*04*!02!(!)*0%'!'$-%$$!7$5+/&=!S"24(860(!Q+,/)&3!UIT!

!h! B!)$/D&$(%D+5'!4*05'!J0)*!(!2$#$%$!4(2$!+7!B))$/)0+/!Z$7040)!Z02+%'$%!

J(2!)(5?0/-!+/!)*$!24*++5!6,2!(/'!J(2!)+5'!6&!)*$!6,2!(0'$!)+!6$!>,0$)!+%!(!J%0))$/!%$9+%)!J+,5'!6$!705$'=!!;*$!4*05'!?04?$'!)*$!(0'$Y!*$!J(2!(%%$2)$'!(/'!4*(%-$'!J0)*!6())$%&=!SUIT!

!;*$!(8$/'$'!PZ"B!9%+#0'$2!$O)$/20#$!9%+4$',%(5!9%+)$4)0+/2!7+%!

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

!! e!

Page 20: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

4"#'$5/6#'*03$*#/."#603$56)'.)5/703$/'($&*"#60$.&'8#9$*&$*"#$.")7($*"/*$:#$:/'*$

9&-3$7);#$9&-3$/'($:&-7($7);#$*&$"/8#$9&-$)'$*")0$0."&&7$/'($*")0$.7/006&&<3$=-*$

*"#6#$/6#$.#6*/)'$*")'>0$:#$#?5#.*!&+$9&-3$*"#$6#05&'0#$)0$&+*#'$<)6/.-7&-0=Ae!!

f(8$2!Q+8$%!(/'!B5#0/!<+,22(0/)3!@/)0)'>$A7/.;$%")7(6#'!!

:$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2!0/*$%$/)5&!4+/7504)!J0)*!9%$24%09)0+/2!7+%!*$(5)*&!4*05'!'$#$5+98$/)=!!;*$&!(%$!'$20-/$'!9%08(%05&!)+!9,/02*!(/'!+77$%!7$J!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!0/2)%,4)0+/!+%!*$59!7+%!2),'$/)2=!!;*$&!7%$>,$/)5&!7(55!0/)+!)*$!4()$-+%&!+7!+#$%5&!*(%2*!9,/02*8$/)2!)*()3!0/!)*$!J+%'2!+7!/+)$'!92&4*+5+-02)2!f(8$2!Q+8$%!(/'!B5#0/!<+,22(0/)3!C$0)*$%!'$2)%+&2!(!4*05'L2!290%0)3!*(2!/+!$77$4)!()!(553!J+%2$/2!)*$!9%+65$83!+%!8(?$2!0)!8+%$!'07704,5)!7+%!&+,!)+!J+%?!J0)*!)*$!4*05'!0/!24*++5!p!*$!+%!2*$!/+!5+/-$%!)%,2)2!&+,=ERX!!

B44+%'0/-!)+!8(/&!5$('0/-!92&4*+5+-02)23!%0-0'!(/'!0/75$O065$!'0240950/$!9+5040$2!'0%$4)5&!4+/7504)!J0)*!)J+!8(G+%!'$#$5+98$/)(5!/$$'2!+7!24*++5D(-$'!&+,)*2o!!!

@T! )*$!'$#$5+98$/)!+7!2)%+/-!(/'!)%,2)0/-!%$5()0+/2*092!J0)*!?$&!(',5)2!0/!)*$0%!50#$23!9(%)04,5(%5&!)*+2$!0/!)*$0%!24*++5Y!(/'!

!AT! !)*$!7+%8()0+/!+7!9+20)0#$!())0),'$2!)+J(%'!7(0%/$22!(/'!G,2)04$=!

!B2!(!%$2,5)3!)*$2$!9+5040$2!+7)$/!7,%)*$%!(50$/()$!2),'$/)2!7%+8!24*++5!(/'!

$O(4$%6()$!)*$!6$*(#0+%2!)*$&!2$$?!)+!%$8$'&=!!;*02!'(8(-$!02!9(%)04,5(%5&!(4,)$!7+%!4*05'%$/!J*+!(%$!(5%$('&!4+/20'$%$'!C()D%02?E!7+%!24*++5!7(05,%$!(/'!+7)$/!*(2!)*$!$77$4)!+7!9,2*0/-!)*$8!+,)!+7!24*++5!4+895$)$5&=!!

#8?-(5=K;<B7-L?7M??=-4?:5-#5;?:9=B?-9=>-78?-"??>-K5:-*>5;?AB?=7A--75-&?N?;5O-/7:5=P-L5=>A-E<78-*>6;7A!

!j05!_+(83!<%+7$22+%!+7!"',4()0+/!(/'!<2&4*+5+-&!()!M(%#(%'!./0#$%20)&3!

*(2!J%0))$/!)*()!(!%$5()0+/2*09!J0)*!(!4+880))$'!(/'!$/4+,%(-0/-!(',5)!J*+!C6$50$#$2!0/!8$!(/'!8&!7,),%$E!*(2!C9%+#$/!)+!6$!(/!$22$/)0(5!0/-%$'0$/)!0/!8+2)!%$2050$/)!4*05'%$/!(/'!&+,)*!J*+!2,44$$'!'$290)$!-%$()!('#$%20)&=ER@!!M$!40)$2!%$2$(%4*!)*()!0/'04()$2!2,99+%)0#$!%$5()0+/2*092!6$)J$$/!(',5)2!(/'!4*05'%$/!)*()!9%+#0'$!0/'0#0',(5!())$/)0+/!)+!*0-*D%02?!&+,)*!*(#$!6$$/!2*+J/!)+!6$!4$/)%(5!)+!9%$#$/)0+/!9%+-%(82=!!

<2&4*+5+-02)!f(8$2!Q+8$%!6(2$2!*02!2,44$227,5!24*++52!7+%!()D%02?!&+,)*!+/!)*$!9%$802$!)*()!4*05'%$/!2,44$$'!0/!24*++5!(/'!507$!J*$/!)*$&!C6$4+8$!6+/'$'!)+!)*$!20-/0704(/)!(',5)2!0/!)*$0%!50#$23!)*$&!0'$/)07&!J0)*!)*$83!080)()$!

!! @X!

Page 21: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

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

;*$!506$%(5!,2$!+7!2,29$/20+/!(2!(!9,/02*8$/)!7+%!2),'$/)2!(5%$('&!()D%02?!7+%!7(05,%$!0/!24*++5!02!9(%)04,5(%5&!9%+65$8()04=!!K,22!1?06(3!Z0%$4)+%!+7!)*$!P/2)0),)$!7+%!Q*05'!1),'&!()!P/'0(/(!./0#$%20)&3!(/'!K$$4$!<$)$%2+/3!n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

B2!Q+8$%!(/'!<+,22(0/)!2,--$2)3!$O45,20+/(%&!9,/02*8$/)2!(4),(55&!0/)$/207&!4$%)(0/!('+5$24$/)2L!4+/7504)2!J0)*!(',5)2=!!1,$!;*+%2+/3!B2202)(/)!<%+7$22+%!+7!19$40(5!"',4()0+/!()!)*$!./0#$%20)&!+7!F(0/$3!>,+)$2!+/$!2),'$/)!(2!2(&0/-o!CP!70-,%$!07!PL8!-+0/-!)+!-$)!0/!)%+,65$3!PL8!-+//(!(//+&!*08!(2!8,4*!(2!P!4(/===!!M$!'$2$%#$2!0)3!07!*$L2!-+//(!?$$9!20/-50/-!8$!+,)3!2+!P!-$)!+/!*02!/$%#$2===!!P7!&+,!?/+J!&+,d%$!(5%$('&!-$))0/-!0/!)%+,65$3!J*&!2*,)!,9q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p!(!8$22(-$!+7!%$G$4)0+/!)*()!(50$/()$2!)*$8!7%+8!$#$%!%$),%/0/-!)+!24*++5=R`!!;*02!8(&!$O95(0/!J*&!2+!8(/&!2),'$/)2!(%$!2,29$/'$'!%$9$()$'5&3!(/'!J*&3!(44+%'0/-!)+!I(J%$/4$!F=!Z$K0''$%3!6$0/-!2,29$/'$'!+%!$O9$55$'!02!+/$!+7!)*$!)+9!)*%$$!24*++5D%$5()$'!%$(2+/2!7+%!'%+990/-!+,)=Ra!

!! @@!

Page 22: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!-#8?-(5=K;<B7-L?7M??=-4?:5-#5;?:9=B?-9=>-78?-"??>-K5:-*>5;?AB?=7A-75-&?N?;5O-2?9;78D-*77<76>?A-#5M9:>-Q6A7<B?-9=>-39<:=?AA!

!F+2)!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/2!)(?$!95(4$!()!)*$!80''5$!(/'!*0-*!

24*++5!5$#$53!J*$/!8(/&!('+5$24$/)2!(%$!(4,)$5&!),/$'!0/)+!022,$2!%$5()$'!)+!7(0%/$22!(/'!G,2)04$=!!F=!I$$!F(//0/-3!<%+7$22+%!()!H5'!Z+80/0+/!./0#$%20)&!0/!_+%7+5?3!*(2!J%0))$/!)*()!'$#$5+90/-!C(!2$/2$!+7!G,2)04$3!(!9$%4$9)0+/!+7!7(0%/$223!(/'!(/!+#$%(55!2$/2$!+7!*+J!9$+95$!2*+,5'!6$!)%$()$'ERe!02!+/$!+7!)*$!)*%$$!8(G+%!'$#$5+98$/)(5!4*(%(4)$%02)042!+7!&+,/-!('+5$24$/)2=!!

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

;*,23!6&!2,6G$4)0/-!2),'$/)2!)+!(,)+8()04!9,/02*8$/)2!)*()!'+!/+)!)(?$!0/)+!(44+,/)!$O)$/,()0/-!+%!80)0-()0/-!40%4,82)(/4$23![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2!%$9%$2$/)3!0/!j05!_+(8L2!J+%'23!(!C5+2)!8+8$/)!)+!)$(4*!4*05'%$/!(6+,)!%$29$4)3!(/'!(!8022$'!4*(/4$!)+!0/290%$!)*$0%!)%,2)!+7!(,)*+%0)&!70-,%$2=EW@!!B/'!F(//0/-!2,--$2)2!)*()!2,4*!/$-()0#$!5$22+/23!07!5$(%/$'!',%0/-!)*02!4%0)04(5!'$#$5+98$/)(5!9*(2$3!(%$!50?$5&!)+!5(2)!(!507$)08$=!!

.5)08()$5&3!)+!2,44$$'3!()D%02?!&+,)*!/$$'!)+!'$#$5+9!2)%+/-!6+/'2!J0)*!4(%0/-!(/'!4+89(220+/()$!(',5)2!J*+8!)*$&!4(/!)%,2)=!!;*$&!%$>,0%$!0/'0#0',(50[$'!'0240950/$!)*()!)(?$2!0/)+!(44+,/)!)*$0%!,/0>,$!40%4,82)(/4$2=!!B2!(!4+/2$>,$/4$3!)*$0%!4*(/4$2!7+%!'$#$5+90/-!$22$/)0(5!%$2050$/4&!2?0552!(/'!9+20)0#$!())0),'$2!(6+,)!(',5)!(,)*+%0)&3!G,2)04$3!(/'!7(0%/$22!(%$!-%$()5&!$/*(/4$'=!!./7+%),/()$5&3![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2!)*()!9%$24%06$!(,)+8()04!(/'r+%!*(%2*!9,/02*8$/)2!,/'$%80/$!)*$!(6050)&!+7!)$(4*$%2!(/'!('80/02)%()+%2!)+!7+%8!)%,2)0/-!%$5()0+/2*092!J0)*!2),'$/)23!(/'!,5)08()$5&3!)*$2$!9+5040$2!)%(/280)!/$-()0#$!8$22(-$2!(6+,)!7(0%/$223!$>,0)&3!(/'!G,2)04$=!!B2!(!%$2,5)3!8(/&!2),'$/)2!(%$!7,%)*$%!(50$/()$'!7%+8!)*$!$',4()0+/(5!9%+4$223!(/'!6$*(#0+%(5!9%+65$82!8$(/)!)+!6$!%$8$'0$'!(%$3!0/2)$('3!$O(4$%6()$'=!!4,$%-#%1,$*"(,I-!/-!#-E%$#2-!#R!!

!! @A!

Page 23: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!*(#$!*0-*!4+2)2!7+%!4*05'%$/3!7(8050$23!(/'!4+88,/0)0$2=!!;*$!4+/2$>,$/4$2!(%$!#(%0$'!(/'!0/!8(/&!4(2$2!)*$&!(%$!5+/-D)$%8!(/'!'$)%08$/)(5=!!

15AA-5K-,>6B97<5=9;-%OO5:76=<7<?A!!

:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!0/*$%$/)5&!%$2,5)!0/!)*$!5+22!+7!4*05'%$/L2!$',4()0+/(5!+99+%),/0)0$2=!!Q*05'%$/!9,/02*$'!,/'$%!)*$2$!9+5040$2!(%$!7(4$'!J0)*!2*+%)D!+%!5+/-D)$%8!'$9%0#()0+/!+7!$',4()0+/=!!Q5$(%5&3!)*02!4+/2$>,$/4$!'+$2!/+)!7,%)*$%!)*$!0/)$%$2)2!+7!)*$!4*05'%$/!0/#+5#$'!+%!)*$0%!4+88,/0)0$2=!!

P/!8+2)!20),()0+/23!2,29$/20+/2!*(#$!/$-()0#$!4+/2$>,$/4$2!+/!(4('$804!9$%7+%8(/4$=!Q*05'%$/!2,29$/'$'!8(&!%$4$0#$!7(050/-!-%('$2!0/!$(4*!45(22!7+%!$#$%&!'(&!)*$&!8022!',%0/-!)*$!2,29$/20+/==!!1),'$/)2!4+895(0/!)*()!',%0/-!2,29$/20+/2!)*$0%!)$(4*$%2!'+!/+)!9%+#0'$!(220-/8$/)2!2+!)*$&!8(&!?$$9!,9!J0)*!)*$0%!24*++5J+%?Y!4+/2$>,$/)5&3!)*$&!7(55!6$*0/'=!!1),'$/)2!%$9$()$'5&!2,29$/'$'!8(&!6$!%$)(0/$'!0/!)*$0%!-%('$2=WA!!;*023!+7!4+,%2$3!4(/!5$('!)+!)*$!4*05'd2!(50$/()0+/!7%+8!)*$!$',4()0+/(5!9%+4$223!*+2)050)&!+/!)*$!9(%)!+7!)*$!4*05'3!(/'!$#$/),(55&!)+!'%+990/-!+,)=!!P/!7(4)3!2,29$/20+/!02!(!8+'$%()$!)+!2)%+/-!9%$'04)+%!+7!(!2),'$/)!'%+990/-!+,)!+7!24*++5Y!8+%$!)*(/!RXg!+7!2+9*+8+%$2!J*+!'%+9!+,)!*(#$!6$$/!2,29$/'$'=WR!!V$&+/'!'%+990/-!+,)3!4*05'%$/!2*,)!+,)!7%+8!)*$!$',4()0+/!2&2)$8!(%$!8+%$!50?$5&!)+!$/-(-$!0/!4+/',4)!'$)%08$/)(5!)+!)*$!2(7$)&!+7!)*$0%!7(8050$2!(/'!4+88,/0)0$2=WW!!;*$!,5)08()$!%$2,5)!02!)*()!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!4%$()$!(!'+J/J(%'D290%(5!0/!)*$!50#$2!+7!)*$2$!4*05'%$/3!J*04*!,5)08()$5&!8(&!5$('!)+!5+/-D)$%8!0/4(%4$%()0+/=W\!!

h! B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!)*$!C(22(,5)!J0)*!(!9$(/,)E!0/40'$/)!S2$$!(6+#$T3!(55!70#$!&+,/-!8$/!5+2)!)*$0%!%0-*)!)+!%0'$!)*$!Z02)%04)L2!24*++5!6,2$2=!!V$4(,2$!)*$&!(%$!7%+8!5+JD0/4+8$!7(8050$2!)*()!'+!/+)!*(#$!)%(/29+%)()0+/3!(55!70#$!,5)08()$5&!'%+99$'!+,)!+7!24*++5=!!H/$!+7!)*$!&+,/-!8$/!2)()$'3!CP!'0'/d)!*(#$!(!4*+04$!DD!P!'0'/L)!*(#$!(!%0'$=E!!;*02!&+,/-!8(/3!J*+!$(%/$'!BD-%('$2!0/!*02!7(#+%0)$!2,6G$4)3!8()*3!J(/)$'!)+!-%(',()$=!!M$!2)()$'3!CP!bJ+,5'!*(#$c!-+/$!)+!4+55$-$=!!F(&6$!P!4+,5'!*(#$!6$$/!(!5(J&$%=E!!K$9+%)$'5&3!)*$!+)*$%!&+,/-!8$/!(%$!20895&!C*(/-0/-!+,)3E!()!%02?!+7!-$))0/-!0/)+!)%+,65$=!

!h! ;*$!4*05'!2,29$/'$'!7+%!+/$!&$(%!7+%!*0'0/-!%([+%!65('$2!0/!+%'$%!)+!

$/2,%$!)*$!2(7$)&!+7!+)*$%23!S2$$!(6+#$T3!02!%$),%/0/-!)+!24*++5!)*02!&$(%=!!B5)*+,-*!*02!8+)*$%!*(2!)%0$'!)+!*$59!*08!()!*+8$!',%0/-!)*02!&$(%!2,29$/20+/3!*$!J055!6$!7+%4$'!)+!%$9$()!)*$!707)*!-%('$=!

!h! P/!)J+!20805(%!2)+%0$2!0/#+5#0/-!(55$-$'!(22(,5)2!(-(0/2)!)$(4*$%2!

!! @R!

Page 24: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

J*+!())$89)$'!)+!6%$(?!,9!70-*)2!S2$$!(6+#$T3!2),'$/)2!0/#+5#$'!J$%$!+,)!+7!24*++5!7+%!$O)$/'$'!9$%0+'2=!!;*$!Z,650/3!Q(507+%/0(!2),'$/)!$O95(0/$'!)*()!0)!J(2!>,0)$!'07704,5)!)+!?$$9!,9!J0)*!*$%!24*++5J+%?!(/'!)*()!)$(4*$%2!J$%$!/+)!*$597,5Y!*+J$#$%3!2*$!8(/(-$'=!!Z$290)$!(!%$>,$2)!7+%!45(22!(220-/8$/)23!)*$!2),'$/)!0/!U5(-5$%!Q+,/)&3!U5+%0'(3!'0'!/+)!%$4$0#$!(/&!24*++5!(220-/8$/)2!',%0/-!*$%!)*%$$!8+/)*2!+,)!+7!24*++5=!

!*;7?:=97<N?-,>6B97<5=!

!P/!8(/&!1)()$23!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!9%+-%(82!(%$!(#(05(65$!)+!

2,29$/'$'!+%!$O9$55$'!2),'$/)2=!!]*$)*$%!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!02!'024%$)0+/(%&!+%!8(/'()+%&!#(%0$2!2)()$D6&D2)()$=!!B2!2*+J/!0/!B99$/'0O!PPP3!A^!1)()$2!%$>,0%$3!6&!5(J3!)*()!24*++5!'02)%04)2!8(?$!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!+99+%),/0)0$2!(#(05(65$!)+!2),'$/)2!2,29$/'$'!+%!$O9$55$'=!!P/!@a!1)()$23!0)!02!J0)*0/!)*$!'024%$)0+/!+7!24*++5!'02)%04)2!)+!9%+#0'$!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/=!!./7+%),/()$5&3!8(/&!(5)$%/()0#$!24*++52!(%$!/+!8+%$!)*(/!*+5'0/-!9$/2!7+%!4*05'%$/!4+/20'$%$'!)+!6$!)%+,65$8(?$%2=!!1),'$/)2!())$/'0/-!)*+2$!24*++52!(%$!802)%$()$'!(/'!'$/0$'!('$>,()$!0/2)%,4)0+/3!)*,2!$O(4$%6()0/-!022,$2!+7!(50$/()0+/3!*+2)050)&3!(/'!5+J!(4('$804!9$%7+%8(/4$=!!

h! 1),'$/)2!()!(!F0220220990!(5)$%/()0#$!24*++5!8$$)!)*$0%!6,2!0/!7%+/)!+7!)*$!5+4(5!9+504$!'$9(%)8$/)3!J*$%$!)*$&!(%$!'0240950/$'!6&!9+504$!+7704$%23!07!/$4$22(%&=!!H/$!2),'$/)!()!)*02!24*++5!02!0/!(!45(22!J0)*!8,4*!+5'$%!2),'$/)2!0/!*0-*$%!-%('$!5$#$52Y!2+8$!+7!)*$2$!+5'$%!2),'$/)2!6,55&!*$%!'(05&=!!U,%)*$%8+%$3!2*$!'+$2!/+)!%$4$0#$!0/2)%,4)0+/!7%+8!*$%!)$(4*$%2=!!;$(4*$%2!8$%$5&!(4)!(2!8+/0)+%2=!!;*$&!9%+#0'$!J+%?2*$$)2!(/'!-%('$!)*$8!6,)!'+!/+)!$O95(0/!)*$!J+%?=!!;*$!2),'$/)d2!+/5&!9+20)0#$!4+88$/)!J(2!)*()!2*$!50?$2!)*$!7(4)!)*()!)*$!24*++5!'(&!()!)*$!(5)$%/()0#$!$/'2!8,4*!$(%50$%!)*(/!()!)*$!%$-,5(%!24*++5=!!P/!(/+)*$%!(5)$%/()0#$!24*++53!4*05'%$/!0/'04()$!)*()!)*$&!J()4*!#0'$+2!(55!'(&!(/'!5$(%/!/+)*0/-=!

!]0)*!)*$!6,%-$+/0/-!/,86$%!+7!4*05'%$/!6$0/-!2,29$/'$'!(/'!$O9$55$'3!

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

!! @W!

Page 25: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

24*++52!2*+,5'!80%%+%!)*+2$!+7!%$-,5(%!24*++523!(/'!%$2+,%4$2!2*+,5'!6$!$>,(55&!(55+4()$'!)+!)*$2$!24*++52=!!./'$%D$',4()0/-!)*02!-%+J0/-!9+9,5()0+/!+7!2),'$/)2!02!(/!055D('#02$'!2)%()$-&!7+%!'$(50/-!J0)*!'0240950/(%&!9%+65$82=!!

(:<S<=9;<T97<5=-5K-(8<;>:?=!!

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

P/!8(/&!0/2)(/4$23!24*++5!'02)%04)2!(%$!20895&!)%(/27$%%0/-!)*$0%!'0240950/(%&!(,)*+%0)&!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!+77040(52=!!U+%!$O(895$3!0/!)*$!4(2$!+7!)*$!4*05'!J*+!6$)!+/!(!-(8$!J0)*!(!24*++58()$3!24*++5!+77040(52!4+/',4)$'!/+!0/#$2)0-()0+/!6,)!20895&!%$7$%%$'!)*$!20),()0+/!)+!)*$!9+504$=!!;*$!70#$!&+,/-!8$/!)*%+J0/-!9$(/,)2!+/!)*$!24*++5!6,2!0/!F0220220990!J$%$!(%%$2)$'!(/'!4*(%-$'!J0)*!7$5+/&!(22(,5)=!!B/!@@D&$(%D+5'!4*05'!0/!Q+5,860(3!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(!J(2!(%%$2)$'!(/'!)(?$/!(J(&!0/!(!9+504$!4(%!6$4(,2$!2*$!6%+,-*)!(!?/07$!)+!24*++5!0/!*$%!5,/4*!6+O!)+!4,)!*$%!4*04?$/=W^!!K$4$/)5&3!0/!n0%-0/0(!)J+!@XD&$(%D+5'!I()0/+!6+&2!7(4$'!7$5+/&!4*(%-$2!7+%!9,))0/-!2+(9!0/!)*$0%!)$(4*$%L2!J()$%!DD!(/!(4)!)*()!,2$'!)+!6$!4+/20'$%$'!(!9%(/?=W`!!

$?U6<:?>-$?K?::9;-75-19M-,=K5:B?S?=7-!!

B2!0/'04()$'!0/!B99$/'0O!Pn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

U+%!$O(895$3!(22(,5)!02!(!4+88+/!4()$-+%&!+7!4+/',4)!7+%!J*04*!24*++52!(%$!%$>,0%$'!)+!%$9+%)!2),'$/)2!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2=!!;*02!4()$-+%&!+7!+77$/2$!02!+7)$/!6%+('5&!0/)$%9%$)$'!6&!24*++5!'02)%04)2!)+!%$7$%!2),'$/)2!0/#+5#$'!0/!70-*)2!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$23!%$-(%'5$22!+7!2$#$%0)&=!!P/!f$77$%2+/!Z(#02!Q+,/)&3!F02202209903!)*$!14*++5!V+(%'!*(2!0/)$%9%$)$'!C(--%(#()$'!(22(,5)3E!7+%!J*04*!4*05'%$/!8,2)!6$!%$7$%%$'!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)3!)+!0/45,'$!(55!702)!70-*)23!'$290)$!)*$!5$-(5!%$>,0%$8$/)!+7!C2$%0+,2!6+'05&!0/G,%&=E!!;*$!2$#$%0)&!+7!)*$!70-*)!

!! @\!

Page 26: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

02!/+)!)(?$/!0/)+!(44+,/)=!!B2!(!%$2,5)!+7!2J$$90/-!(/'!+7)$/!$%%+/$+,2!0/)$%9%$)()0+/2!+7!)*$2$!5(J23!#(2)!/,86$%2!+7!4*05'%$/!(%$!4(,-*)!,9!0/!)*$!G,#$/05$!G,2)04$!2&2)$8!7+%!)&904(5!('+5$24$/)!6$*(#0+%=!!

U,%)*$%8+%$3!%$7$%%(52!+7!24*++54*05'%$/!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2!+7)$/!+44,%!0/!)*$!(62$/4$!+7!#0+5$/4$=!!Z()(!7%+8!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(!0/'04()$2!)*()!$#$/!)*+2$!2),'$/)2!(44,2$'!+7!CZ02),%60/-!14*++52E!(%$!%$7$%%$'!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2=!!Z,%0/-!)*$!@eeaDee!24*++5!&$(%3!8+%$!)*(/!R3XXX!2),'$/)2!J$%$!%$7$%%$'!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!7+%!)*02!%$(2+/=!!P/!F(%&5(/'3!24*++5!'02)%04)2!8(&!%$7$%!2),'$/)2!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2!7+%!)*$!70%2)!0/40'$/)!+7!9+22$220+/!+7!(!9(-0/-!'$#04$Y!)*$!2$4+/'!+77$/2$!%$>,0%$2!%$7$%%(5!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)=!!S1$$!B99$/'0O!Pn=T!!;*$%$!02!/+!2,99+%)!7+%!)*$!9%+9+20)0+/!)*()!)*02!)%$()8$/)!+7!4*05'%$/!9+20)0#$5&!(77$4)2!)*$0%!6$*(#0+%!+%!)*$0%!7,),%$2=!!j0#$/!)*$!0/4%$(20/-5&!*(%2*!J(&!0/!J*04*!G,#$/05$2!(%$!6$0/-!)%$()$'!0/!)*$!4%080/(5!G,2)04$!2&2)$83!J$!/$$'!)+!4+/20'$%!J*$)*$%!0)!02!%$(55&!0/!)*$!4*05'L2!DD!+%!)*$!4+88,/0)&L2!DD!0/)$%$2)!)+!$86%+05!)*$2$!2),'$/)2!0/!)*$!G,'040(5!2&2)$8!7+%!6$*(#0+%!)*()!J+,5'!*(#$!6$$/!*(/'5$'!$O45,20#$5&!6&!24*++52!0/!)*$!9(2)=!!

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

P/!(''0)0+/!)+!)*$!0/4%$(20/-!4%080/(5!4*(%-$2!705$'!(-(0/2)!4*05'%$/3!0/!8(/&!G,%02'04)0+/2!2),'$/)2!(%$!6%+,-*)!6$7+%$!G,#$/05$!4+,%)2=!!;&904(55&3!)*$2$!2),'$/)2!(%$!4*(%-$'!J0)*!G,#$/05$!'$50/>,$/4&!+%!C4*05'!0/!/$$'!+7!2,9$%#020+/=E!!U+%!$O(895$3!0/!f$77$%2+/!Z(#02!(/'!Q+#0/-)+/!Q+,/)0$2!0/!F02202209903!2),'$/)2!0/#+5#$'!0/!70-*)23!%$-(%'5$22!+7!)*$!2$#$%0)&3!(%$!/+)!+/5&!2,29$/'$'!6,)!(52+!2,88+/$'!)+!(99$(%!0/!N+,)*!Q+,%)=!!P/!F(%4*!+7!)*02!&$(%3!W`!2),'$/)2!7%+8!f$77$%2+/!Z(#02!Q+,/)&3!W\!+7!J*+8!(%$!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/3!(99$(%$'!0/!N+,)*!Q+,%)!7+%!70-*)0/-=!!;*$!9,/02*8$/)!8$)$'!+,)!6&!)*$!4+,%)!'$9$/'$'!+/!)*$!-%('$!5$#$5!+7!)*$!2),'$/)=!!1),'$/)2!J$%$!70/$'!k@\XDk\XX3!-0#$/!20O!8+/)*2!)+!+/$!&$(%!+/!9%+6()0+/3!95(4$'!+/!4,%7$J!S^!9=8=!+%!`!9=8=T3!(/'!%$>,0%$'!)+!9$%7+%8!WX!)+!aX!*+,%2!+7!4+88,/0)&!2$%#04$=!!;*$!4+,%)!4+/',4)2!)*$2$!*$(%0/-2!)J04$!9$%!8+/)*=!!P)!02!$2)08()$'!)*()!20/4$!H4)+6$%!@eee3!AXX!2),'$/)2!7%+8!f$77$%2+/!Z(#02!Q+,/)&!J$%$!2$/)!)+!N+,)*!Q+,%)!7+%!0/D24*++5!4+/',4)=!!P/!8+2)!0/2)(/4$23!2,29$/20+/!J(2!(!2,77040$/)!9,/02*8$/)!7+%!J*()!J(2!/+!8+%$!)*(/!(/!(5)$%4()0+/3!9+20/-!/+!2$%0+,2!)*%$()!)+!2(7$)&=!

!! @^!

Page 27: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!4,$%-#%1,$*"(,-&%,/-"%#-E%$+!!

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p!$O)$/'0/-!)+!4+/',4)!)&904(5!+7!('+5$24$/)2=!!;*02!C5(J!(/'!+%'$%E!(99%+(4*!)+!$',4()0+/!*(2!'$)%08$/)(5!089504()0+/2!7+%!2),'$/)2!(/'!*(2!/+)!6$$/!2*+J/!)+!)%(/25()$!0/)+!-%$()$%!2(7$)&!7+%!2),'$/)2!(/'!7(4,5)&=!!

;*$%$!02!50))5$!$#0'$/4$!)*()!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!(%$!J+%?0/-!)+!%$',4$!#0+5$/4$!+%!0/4%$(2$!2(7$)&!0/!+,%!24*++52=!!K,22!1?06(3!<%+7$22+%!()!P/'0(/(!./0#$%20)&3!0/'04()$2!)*()!)*$!6$2)!-(,-$!+7!0)2!089(4)!02!'+4,8$/)$'!0/!)*$!_()0+/(5!Q$/)$%!7+%!"',4()0+/!1)()02)042!S_Q"1T!2),'&!+7!24*++5!#0+5$/4$=Wa!!B7)$%!7+,%!&$(%2!+7!0895$8$/)()0+/3!)*$!_Q"1!7+,/'!)*()!24*++52!)*()!,2$!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!(%$!2)055!5$22!2(7$!)*(/!)*+2$!J0)*+,)!2,4*!9+5040$2=We!!

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

;+!8+#$!6$&+/'!)*$!2)()02)042!(/'!(/$4'+)$2!(/'!)+!+6)(0/!(!-50892$!+7!J*()!02!*(99$/0/-!()!)*$!24*++5!5$#$53!B'#(/4$8$/)!<%+G$4)!2)(77!4+/',4)$'!

!! @`!

Page 28: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

%$2$(%4*!+/!)*$!'0240950/(%&!2&2)$82!+7!7+,%!80''5$!24*++52!0/!F0(80DZ('$!Q+,/)&!<,6504!14*++5!Z02)%04)=!!F0(80DZ('$!24*++52!J$%$!4*+2$/!7+%!2$#$%(5!%$(2+/2=!!U0%2)3!)*$%$!J(2!(!J$(5)*!+7!0/7+%8()0+/!(/'!'()(!%$('05&!(44$22065$!(6+,)!)*$2$!24*++52!#0(!)*$!P/)$%/$)=!!1$4+/'3!(55!24*++52!J0)*0/!)*$!F0(80DZ('$!14*++5!Z02)%04)!(%$!2,6G$4)!)+!)*$!2(8$!4+'$!+7!4+/',4)=!!;*0%'3!)*$!2),'$/)!6+'&!(/'!)$(4*0/-r('80/02)%()0#$!2)(772!(%$!8,5)0%(40(5=!!;*$!7(4)+%2!)(?$/!0/)+!(44+,/)!0/!4*++20/-!)*$!24*++52!0/45,'$'!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!9$%4$/)(-$!+7!2),'$/)2!+7!4+5+%3!(/'r+%!9$%4$/)(-$!+7!4*05'%$/!$50-065$!7+%!7%$$!+%!%$',4$'!5,/4*=\X!!;J+!+7!)*$!24*++52!4*+2$/!*(#$!4+89(%()0#$5&!5+J!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!J*05$!)J+!*(#$!(!8,4*!*0-*$%!/,86$%!+7!2,29$/20+/2=!!

]$!0/)$%#0$J$'!9%0/409(52!(/'!+)*$%!('80/02)%()0#$!2)(773!>,$2)0+/0/-!$(4*!9%0/409(5!(6+,)!*$%!+%!*02!9*05+2+9*&!%$-(%'0/-!'0240950/$!(/'!*+J!)*()!02!4+88,/04()$'!)+!2)(77=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!J$!(2?$'!('80/02)%()+%2!)+!'024,22!)*$!40%4,82)(/4$2!,/'$%!J*04*!)*$&!,)050[$!)*$0%!9+J$%2!)+!2,29$/'!+%!$O9$5!(2!J$55!(2!0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!9%+-%(823!4+,/2$50/-!9%+-%(823!24*++5!$/#0%+/8$/)3!(/'!)$(4*$%r2)(77!)%(0/0/-!%$-(%'0/-!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)=!!U0/(55&3!J$!8('$!(''0)0+/(5!0/>,0%0$2!%$-(%'0/-!)*$!8+2)!4+88+/!0/7%(4)0+/!+7!)*$!4+'$!+7!4+/',4)!(/'!+62)(45$2!)+!%$',40/-!'02%,9)0#$!6$*(#0+%=!!;*$!-+(52!J$%$!S@T!)+!'024$%/!J*$)*$%!)*$!9*05+2+9*&!+7!9%0/409(523!J*+!(%$!)*$!4*0$7!+7704$%2!+7!24*++523!4+%%$5()$'!)+!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!(/'!SAT!)+!6$))$%!,/'$%2)(/'!J*()!+)*$%!7(4)+%2!8(&!6$!%$29+/2065$!7+%!J0'$!'024%$9(/40$2!0/!'0240950/$=!!

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

;*$2$!4(2$!2),'0$2!(52+!'$8+/2)%()$!*+J!)*$!#(%&0/-!())0),'$2!(/'!9*05+2+9*0$2!+7!9%0/409(52!4(/!089(4)!'0240950/(%&!9%+4$',%$2!(/'!+,)4+8$2=!!]*05$!)*$!9%0/409(5L2!9*05+2+9*&!8(&!/+)!6$!)*$!+/5&!7(4)+%!0/75,$/40/-!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!0)!02!20-/0704(/)=!!]*$%$!)*$!9%0/409(52!(/'!('80/02)%()+%2!*(#$!('+9)$'![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!7+%!8026$*(#0+%3!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!(%$!*0-*$%=!!P/!

!! @a!

Page 29: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

4+/)%(2)3!24*++52!J*$%$!9%0/409(52!6$50$#$!0/!70/'0/-!+)*$%!J(&2!)+!'$(5!J0)*!8026$*(#0+%!*(#$!5+J$%!2,29$/20+/!%()$2=!!;*$!'024%$)0+/(%&!9%+#020+/2!+7!)*$!2),'$/)!4+'$!+7!4+/',4)!)*$/!6$4+8$!)*$!#$*045$!)*%+,-*!J*04*!9%0/409(52!8(&!$O$%402$!)*$0%!9*05+2+9*04(5!'077$%$/4$2=!!

B''0)0+/(55&3!)*$!7+55+J0/-!'$24%06$2!)*$!+)*$%!-$/$%(5!)%$/'2!)*$!%$2$(%4*!'$)$4)$'=!!

h! P/!24*++52!J*$%$!)*$!9%0/409(5!*(2!2$)!)*$!2)(/'(%'!)*()!/+!4*05'!2*+,5'!6$!2,29$/'$'3!$O4$9)!,/'$%!$O)%$8$!40%4,82)(/4$23!)$(4*$%2!(%$!5$22!(9)!)+!%$7$%!(!4*05'!7+%!2,29$/20+/!7+%!80/+%!8024+/',4)=!!./'$%!)*$2$!40%4,82)(/4$23!)$(4*$%2!,/'$%2)(/'!)*()!)*$0%!%$4+88$/'()0+/2!7+%!2,29$/20+/2!(%$!,/50?$5&!)+!6$!,9*$5'!6&!)*$!9%0/409(5=!

!h! V+%$'+8!(/'!5(4?!+7!(4('$804!4*(55$/-$!0/4%$(2$2!)*$!50?$50*++'!+7!

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

!h! B''0)0+/(5!2,99+%)!%$2+,%4$2!(%$!/$$'$'!0/!9,6504!24*++52!)+!

$/2,%$!8$(/0/-7,5!$',4()0+/(5!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!(55!2),'$/)2=!!F(/&!('80/02)%()+%2!4+895(0/$'!)*()!8+%$!4+,/2$5+%2!(%$!/$$'$'=!;*$!2),'$/)D)+D4+,/2$5+%!%()0+!()!$(4*!+7!)*$!24*++52!$O(80/$'!02!#$%&!*0-*=!!Q+,/2$5+%2!(%$!(55+))$'!+/!)*$!6(202!+7!$/%+558$/)Y!*+J$#$%3!J*$%$!24*++52!*(#$!8+%$!()D%02?!2),'$/)2!(''0)0+/(5!4+,/2$5+%2!(%$!/$$'$'=!

!h! ;$(4*$%2!/$$'!)+!6$!)%(0/$'!0/!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)!(/'!4+/7504)!

%$2+5,)0+/=!!H7!)*$!7+,%!24*++52!2),'0$'3!+/5&!+/$!9%+#0'$2!)*02!)&9$!+7!9%+7$220+/(5!'$#$5+98$/)!)%(0/0/-=!!V$4(,2$!)$(4*$%2!(%$!)*$!70%2)!50/?!)+!)*$!'0240950/(%&!9%+4$223!)*$&!2*+,5'!6$!$>,099$'!)+!'$(5!J0)*!6$*(#0+%(5!9%+65$82!,20/-!0//+#()0#$!2)%()$-0$2!)*()!'+!/+)!2*,)!+,)!2),'$/)2!7+%!)&904(5!('+5$24$/)!8026$*(#0+%=!!B''0)0+/(55&3!24*++52!8,2)!%$4+-/0[$!)*()!0)!02!/+)!(5J(&2!)*$!

!! @e!

Page 30: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

2),'$/)!J*+!02!()!7(,5)3!(/'!)*()!+7)$/!)*$%$!02!(/!+#$%%$(4)0+/!)+!('+5$24$/)!6$*(#0+%=!

!h! 14*++52!2*+,5'!8+/0)+%!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(52!6&!)$(4*$%2!)+!$/2,%$!

7(0%!(99504()0+/!+7!'0240950/(%&!4+'$2=!!F+/0)+%0/-!8(&!$O9+2$!9%+65$82!2,4*!(2!9++%!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)3!'024%080/()+%&!)%$()8$/)3!+%!20/-50/-!+,)!+7!9(%)04,5(%!4*05'%$/=!!]*$%$!)$(4*$%2!+#$%,2$!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(523!(''0)0+/(5!)%(0/0/-!2*+,5'!6$!9%+#0'$'=!!B2!(!%$2,5)3!2),'$/)2!J055!/+)!6$!20/-5$'!+,)3!(/'!)*$&!J055!,5)08()$5&!*(#$!7(0)*!)*()!)*$!2&2)$8!+7!9,/02*8$/)!02!G,2)=!

!!@<9S<V&9>?-(56=7D-.6C;<B-/B855;A-(5>?-5K-/76>?=7-(5=>6B7!

!;*$!1$4+/'(%&!14*++5!Q+'$!+7!1),'$/)!Q+/',4)3\@!J*04*!(52+!(9950$2!)+!

80''5$!24*++523!02!(!R\D9(-$!6++?5$)!-0#$/!)+!2),'$/)2!0/!(/!$77+%)!)+!8(?$!)*$!%,5$2!45$(%!(/'!,/'$%2)(/'(65$=!!;*$!Q+'$!'$)(052!J*&!(!4+'$!02!/$$'$'Y!)*$!%+5$23!%0-*)23!(/'!%$29+/206050)0$2!+7!2),'$/)23!9(%$/)23!(/'!)$(4*$%2Y!(/'!)*$!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2!)*()!8(&!6$!)(?$/!7+%!(!J0'$!(%%(&!+7!4+/',4)=!!;*$!Q+'$!6$-0/2!J0)*!(!2)()$8$/)3!C:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!7+%!14*++5!K$5()$'!n0+5$/)!Q%08$=E!;*02!9+504&!2)()$8$/)!$O95(0/2!)*()!)*$!Z02)%04)!*(2!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!7+%!#0+5$/4$3!4%08$3!(/'!,2$!+7!J$(9+/23!(/'!)*()!2,4*!+77$/2$2!%$>,0%$!)*$!Z02)%04)!)+!C0/#+?$!)*$!8+2)!2$#$%$!4+/2$>,$/4$2=E\A!!

B''0)0+/(5!%$5$#(/)!9+%)0+/2!+7!)*$!Q+'$!+7!1),'$/)!Q+/',4)3!J*04*!'$24%06$!)*$!Z02)%04)d2!9*05+2+9*&!%$-(%'0/-!'0240950/$3!(%$!0/45,'$'!6$5+J=!!

B!-++'!24*++5!$/#0%+/8$/)!02!6$2)!)*+,-*)!+7!(2o!!

W--6$0/-!9+20)0#$3!/+)!/$-()0#$!s!!*$590/-3!/+)!9,/02*0/--W--),%/0/-!,/(44$9)(65$!4+/',4)!0/)+!(44$9)(65$!4+/',4)=!

!H%'$%!(/'!'0240950/$!8(&!6$!'$24%06$'!(2!)*$!(62$/4$!+7!'02)%(4)0+/23!

7%04)0+/2!(/'!'02),%6(/4$2!J*04*!0/)$%7$%$!J0)*!)*$!$77$4)0#$!7,/4)0+/0/-!+7!)*$!2),'$/)3!)*$!45(223!(/'!)*$!24*++5=!!P)!02!(52+!)*$!9%$2$/4$!+7!(!2(7$3!7%0$/'5&3!&$)!6,20/$2250?$!()8+29*$%$!0/!J*04*!2),'$/)2!(/'!24*++5!9$%2+//$5!J+%?!4++9$%()0#$5&!)+J(%'!8,),(55&!%$4+-/0[$'!(/'!(44$9)$'!-+(52=\R!!

B!8(G+%!4+/20'$%()0+/!0/!)*$!(99504()0+/!+7!)*$!Q+'$!02!)*()!)*$!8+2)!(99%+9%0()$!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/!)(?$/!6&!24*++5!+77040(52!02!)*$!5$(2)!$O)%$8$!8$(2,%$!J*04*!4(/!%$2+5#$!)*$!'0240950/$!9%+65$8=!!;$(4*$%2!(/'!('80/02)%()+%2!2)%0#$!)+!,2$!(!#(%0$)&!+7!0/7+%8(5!'0240950/(%&!+%!-,0'(/4$!

!! AX!

Page 31: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

2)%()$-0$23!9%0+%!)+3!',%0/-3!(/'!(7)$%!7+%8(5!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/=\W!!

@<9S<V&9>?-(56=7D-(9A?-/76><?A!!

B2!)*$!2,88(%0$2!6$5+J!8(?$!45$(%3!)*$2$!-,0'$50/$2!(%$!0/)$%9%$)$'!#$%&!'077$%$/)5&!6&!)*$!9%0/409(52!0/!)*$!7+,%!80''5$!24*++52!9%+705$'=!!S1$$!B99$/'0O!nP!7+%!24*++5!9%+705$2=T!

!! A@!

Page 32: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!!

!-L;9BXY197<=5-/76>?=7A-

-%67V5KV/B855;-/6AO?=A<5=-

$97?Z-

-!=V/B855;-

/6AO?=A<5=-$97?Z-

-j=]=!Q(%#$%!

!^Rg!

!A=ag!

!X=XXRg!

!<(58!19%0/-2!

!eWg!

!R=Wg!

!@e=^g!

!F('02+/!

!eag!

!@^=Ag!

!^=ag!

!_+%)*!Z('$!

!eWg!

!RW=@g!

!WA=Rg!

!t;*$!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!%$9%$2$/)!)*$!9$%4$/)(-$!+7!2),'$/)2!2,29$/'$'!()!5$(2)!+/4$=!!

G[E[-(9:N?:-@<>>;?-/B855;!!

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d2!9%+-%$22!(/'!7,),%$=!!

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d!6$*(#0+%3!(/'!)*$%$7+%$!/$$'$'!)+!%$2+%)!)+!2,29$/20+/3!M$02$!6$50$#$'!)*()!J(2!)*$!$O(4)!%$(2+/!J*&!)*+2$!2),'$/)2!2*+,5'!/+)!6$!)*%+J/!+,)!+7!24*++5=!!1*$!6$50$#$'!)*()!'+0/-!2+!J+,5'!5$(#$!)*$8!+/!)*$!2)%$$)2!(/'!5$('!)+!8+%$!)%+,65$!(/'!9+22065$!0/4(%4$%()0+/=!

!! AA!

Page 33: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

j=]=!Q(%#$%!*(2!)*$!5+J$2)!2,29$/20+/!%()$!7+%!80''5$!24*++52!0/!)*$!F0(80DZ('$!14*++5!1&2)$8=!!P/!@eeaDee3!+/5&!A=ag!+7!2),'$/)2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'=!!B5)*+,-*!j=]=!Q(%#$%!*(2!7$J$%!0/40'$/)2!+7!#0+5$/4$!)*(/!)*$!+)*$%!24*++52!%$#0$J$'3!)*$%$!(%$!2)055!0/40'$/)2!+7!8024+/',4)=!!;*$!8+2)!7%$>,$/)!%$(2+/2!2),'$/)2!(%$!%$7$%%$'!7+%!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/!(%$!70-*)2!(/'!4,))0/-!45(22=!!]*05$!)*$!Q+'$!+7!1),'$/)!Q+/',4)!9$%80)2!)$/D'(&!2,29$/20+/2!7+%!70-*)23!)*$!Q(%#$%!B'80/02)%()0+/!,2$2!0)2!'024%$)0+/!)+!$895+&!+)*$%!9,/02*8$/)2!9$%80))$'!,/'$%!)*$!Q+'$!+7!Q+/',4)=!!U+%!70-*)2!(/'!4,))0/-!45(223!j=]=!Q(%#$%!2),'$/)2!%$4$0#$!+/$!)+!)*%$$!'(&2!+7!0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/2!SJ*04*!02!)&904(55&!%$',4$'T!+%!(%$!-0#$/!(!J+%?!(220-/8$/)3!2,4*!(2!45$(/0/-!)*$!4(7$)$%0(=!!1,9$%#02$'!J+%?!(220-/8$/)2!(/'!0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!(%$!)*$!8+2)!4+88+/!9,/02*8$/)2!,2$'!()!j=]=!Q(%#$%=!!;*$2$!9,/02*8$/)2!,9*+5'!)*$!0'$(5!)*()!'0240950/0/-!4*05'%$/!2*+,5'!/+)!9%$#(05!+#$%!$',4()0/-!)*$8=!!

<%0/409(5!M$02$!2)%+/-5&!6$50$#$2!)*()!4*05'%$/!J*+!(%$!4*(55$/-$'!(4('$804(55&!(/'!$/-(-$'!6&!)$(4*$%2!(%$!5$22!(9)!)+!8026$*(#$=!!;$(4*$%2!()!Q(%#$%!(%$!$/4+,%(-$'!)+!6$!0//+#()0#$=!!U+%!$O(895$3!',%0/-!+,%!#020)!(!240$/4$!)$(4*$%!J(2!'$20-/0/-!(!24(#$/-$%!*,/)!,20/-!P/)$%/$)!50/?2!)*()!J+,5'!)$(4*!4*05'%$/!(6+,)!#(%0+,2!)&9$2!+7!702*=!!B/+)*$%!240$/4$!)$(4*$%!$/-(-$2!*$%!2),'$/)2!6&!-%+J0/-!(!#$-$)(65$!-(%'$/3!J*04*3!0/!(''0)0+/!)+!)$(4*0/-!240$/4$3!'$#$5+92!2),'$/)2L!2$/2$!+7!%$29+/206050)&!(/'!2$57D9%0'$=!!B/+)*$%!)$(4*$%!4+88$/)$'3!C07!&+,!?$$9!)*$8!6,2&3!)*$&L%$!-++'=E!!P/!(''0)0+/3!M$02$!/+)$'!)*()!9(%$/)(5!0/#+5#$8$/)!J(2!(2!(/!089+%)(/)!7(4)+%!0/!8(0/)(0/0/-!(!5+J!/,86$%!+7!'0240950/(%&!0/7%(4)0+/2=!!!

.9;S-/O:<=PA-@<>>;?-/B855;!!.8<;5A5O8DI-Z%=!B55(/!V+/055(L2!9*05+2+9*&!02!)*()!$#$%&!2),'$/)!8,2)!7$$5!50?$!2*$!+%!*$!02!9(%)!+7!)*$!24*++5=!!_+!4*05'!2*+,5'!6$!/$-5$4)$'!+%!'02%$-(%'$'=!!<%0/409(5!V+/055(!J055!/+)!9,)!?0'2!+/!)*$!2)%$$)3!6,)!0/2)$('!0/202)2!)*()!)*$!24*++5!J+%?!J0)*!)*$8=!!;$(4*$%2!()!<(58!19%0/-2!F0''5$!14*++5!?/+J!V+/055(L2!9*05+2+9*&!02!)+!-+!)+!-%$()!5$/-)*2!)+!8$$)!)*$!/$$'2!+7!?0'2!(/'!)*()!*$!'+$2!/+)!J(/)!8(/&!2),'$/)2!%$7$%%$'!)+!*08!7+%!'0240950/(%&!%$(2+/2=!!

V+/055(!*(2!2$%#$'!(2!<%0/409(5!+7!<(58!19%0/-2!F0''5$!14*++5!7+%!$5$#$/!&$(%2=!!]*$/!*$!6$-(/!*02!)$/,%$!()!<(58!19%0/-23!)*$!24*++5!*('!(!9++%!%$9,)()0+/=!!P)!*('!5+J!())$/'(/4$!%()$23!*0-*!-%('$!%$)$/)0+/!%()$23!5+J!8+%(5$3!(/'!(!4+/20'$%(65$!-(/-!9%+65$8=!!B)!)*$!)08$3!)$(4*$%2!J(/)$'!/+)*0/-!)+!'+!J0)*!C*(#$!/+)2=E!!V+/055(!0/2)055$'!0/!2)(77!)*()!$#$%&!4*05'!2*+,5'!7$$5!4(%$'!7+%!(/'!J(/)$'=!!;*$!14*++5L2!())$/'(/4$!*(2!089%+#$'!'%(8()04(55&o!0/!@eae3!0)!J(2!%(/?$'!R^)*!0/!)*$!Z02)%04)3!6,)!6&!@eea!0)!45(08$'!)*$!u@!9+20)0+/!7+%!())$/'(/4$!0/!)*$!Z02)%04)=!!V+/055(!8('$!(-%$$8$/)2!J0)*!2$#$%(5!

!! AR!

Page 34: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

+7!)*$!2),'$/)2!J*+!*('!6$$/!%$)(0/$'!p!)*$%$!J$%$!2$#$%(5!2),'$/)2!(2!+5'!(2!@`D&$(%2!+5'!J*+!J$%$!2)055!0/!)*$!80''5$!24*++5!p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eeW=!!

B5)*+,-*!8024+/',4)!2)055!+44,%2!S)*+,-*!8,4*!5$22!7%$>,$/)5&T3!V+/055(!)(?$2!(/!(99%+(4*!'077$%$/)!7%+8!2+8$!+7!*02!4+55$(-,$2=!!<(58!19%0/-2L!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!%()$!02!/+J!'+J/!)+!R=Wg!+7!2),'$/)2=!!;*$!8+2)!7%$>,$/)!0/7%(4)0+/!+7!)*$!1),'$/)!Q+'$!+7!Q+/',4)!()!<(58!19%0/-2!02!70-*)0/-=!!B5)*+,-*!)*$!Z02)%04)L2!Q+'$!+7!Q+/',4)!9$%80)2!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!7+%!70-*)0/-3!2),'$/)2!()!<(58!19%0/-2!(%$!)&904(55&!(220-/$'!)+!)*$!14*++5!Q$/)$%!7+%!19$40(5!P/2)%,4)0+/!S1Q1PT!S0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!9%+-%(8T!7+%!RD\!'(&2=!!1),'$/)2!0/!)*02!9%+-%(8!(%$!02+5()$'Y!)*$&!29$/'!)*$!'(&!0/!)*$!1Q1P!'+0/-!)*$0%!45(22!(220-/8$/)2=!!;*$&!'+!/+)!4*(/-$!45(22%++82!)*%+,-*+,)!)*$!'(&=!!;*$%$!(%$!+/!(#$%(-$!@X!2),'$/)2!0/!1Q1P!9$%!'(&=!!;*$!)$(4*$%!0/!1Q1P!(2202)2!2),'$/)2!J0)*!(220-/8$/)2!(/'!4+,/2$52!2),'$/)2=!!H)*$%!4+88+/!0/7%(4)0+/2!)*()!%$2,5)!0/!(220-/8$/)!)+!1Q1P!0/45,'$!)(5?0/-!6(4?!)+!)$(4*$%23!'$7&0/-!)$(4*$%23!(/'!/+)!6$0/-!9%$9(%$'!+%!%$7,20/-!)+!J+%?=!!H,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/2!(%$!,2$'!7+%!J$(9+/2!S(,)+8()04!2,29$/20+/T3!2$#$%$!70-*)23!(/'!2$#$%$!'$70(/4$!+7!(,)*+%0)&=!!

<%0/409(5!V+/055(!(4?/+J5$'-$2!)*()!2),'$/)2!J0)*!6$*(#0+%(5!(/'!(4('$804!9%+65$82!4(/!'02%,9)!(!%$-,5(%!45(22%++8!2$))0/-=!!P/2)$('!+7!)*%+J0/-!)*$8!+,)!+7!24*++53!V+/055(!'$#$5+9$'!(/!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!9%+-%(8!)*()!?$$92!)*$8!0/!24*++5=!!;*02!9%+-%(8!*(2!45(22$2!7+%!$(4*!-%('$!5$#$5!S^DaTY!2),'$/)2!2)(&!0/!)*$!2(8$!45(22%++8!7+%!8()*3!2+40(5!2),'0$23!240$/4$3!(/'!5(/-,(-$!(%)23!6,)!(%$!9$%80))$'!)+!)(?$!9*&204(5!$',4()0+/!(/'!(/!$5$4)0#$!J0)*!8(0/2)%$(8!2),'$/)2=!!;*$%$!(%$!7$J$%!2),'$/)2!0/!$(4*!45(223!(/'!$(4*!45(22!*(2!(!)$(4*$%!(/'!(/!(0'$=!!;*$2$!2),'$/)2!(%$!9%+#0'$'!J0)*!(4('$80423!/,%),%0/-3!(/'!4+,/2$50/-=!!;$(4*$%2!%$8(0/!0/!%$-,5(%!4+/)(4)!J0)*!)*$!9(%$/)2!+7!)*$2$!2),'$/)2=!!;*$!)$(4*$%2!0/!)*$!9%+-%(8!(%$!8+%$!)+5$%(/)!(/'!9()0$/)=!!1),'$/)2!0/!)*$!9%+-%(8!(%$!-0#$/!)*$!29$40(5!())$/)0+/!)*$&!/$$'!(/'3!(2!(!%$2,5)3!(%$!/+)!5+2)=!!

;+!7,%)*$%!%$',4$!4+/7504)2!6$)J$$/!2),'$/)23!<(58!19%0/-2!F0''5$!*(2!0895$8$/)$'!(!,/0>,$!9%+-%(8!+7!4+/7504)!%$2+5,)0+/=!!;*$!M$(%)18(%)2!

!! AW!

Page 35: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

<%+-%(83!'0%$4)$'!6&!)*$!14*++5L2!;K.1;!Q+,/2$5+%3\\!F2=!K,22$553!02!6(2$'!,9+/!(!4,%%04,5,8!'$#$5+9$'!6&!M$(%)F()*!P/2)0),)$!0/!Q(507+%/0(=!!;*$!4%,O!+7!)*$!9%+-%(8!02!)*()!2),'$/)2!(/'!)$(4*$%2!(%$!)(,-*)!)+!7+4,2!,9+/!)*$0%!*$(%)2!0/!+%'$%!)+!'$(5!J0)*!2)%$227,5!20),()0+/2=!!;*$!9%+-%(8!0/45,'$2!)*$!7+55+J0/-!$5$8$/)2=!!

h! B!9%$2$/)()0+/!+7!240$/)0704!%$2$(%4*!2*+J0/-!)*$!*$(%)L2!4%0)04(5!%+5$!0/!6%(0/!'$#$5+98$/)3!5$(%/0/-3!4%$()0#0)&3!(/'!0/)$%/(5!6(5(/4$!0/!4*05'%$/!(/'!(',5)2=!!;*02!%$2$(%4*!2*+J2!*+J!9+20)0#$!())0),'$2!(/'!$8+)0+/2!7(4050)()$!+9)08(5!5$(%/0/-!(/'!6$))$%!*$(5)*=!

!h! <%(4)04(5!8$)*+'+5+-&!)*()!*$592!4*05'%$/!8(/(-$!)*$0%!6$*(#0+%!

(/'!2)(&!7+4,2$'=!!P/#(5,(65$!)++52!7+%!%$2+5#0/-!4+/7504)2!(/'!$/*(/40/-!4%$()0#0)&!)*()!$/(65$!)$(4*$%2!)+!8(?$!>,04?!())0),'$!('G,2)8$/)23!2,2)(0/!4(%$!7+%!2),'$/)2!(/'!70/'!2+5,)0+/2!)+!9%+65$82=!

!h! M0-*5&!$77$4)0#$!)++52!7+%!2),'$/)2!)+!'$#$5+9!$8+)0+/(5!6(5(/4$!(/'!

'$(5!J0)*!(/-$%3!2)%$223!(/'!089,520#$!6$*(#0+%=!!

h! _$J!2)%()$-0$2!)*()!9%+#0'$!J+%?(65$!2+5,)0+/2!)+!'0240950/$!9%+65$823!%$',40/-!2)%$22!(/'!4+/7504)!0/!2),'$/)2!(/'!)$(4*$%2=!

!h! ;++52!)+!$/(65$!2),'$/)2!)+!'02)0/-,02*!0/)$550-$/)!4*+04$2!7%+8!

$8+)0+/(5!089,52$2=!!

h! Q+88,/04()0+/!2?0552!7+%!9%$#$/)0/-!4+/7504)!J0)*!9$$%2!(/'!45+20/-!)*$!4+88,/04()0+/!-(9!J0)*!)$(4*$%2=!

!F2=!K,22$55!(/'!)$(4*$%2!()!<(58!19%0/-2!*(#$!6$$/!)%(0/$'!6&!)*$!

M$(%)F()*!P/2)0),)$!(/'!0/!),%/!*(#$!)%(0/$'!+)*$%!('80/02)%()+%23!)$(4*$%23!(/'!2),'$/)2!()!<(58!19%0/-2!F0''5$!)+!,2$!)*$!)++52!+7!)*$!M$(%)18(%)2!<%+-%(8!)+!%$2+5#$!4+/7504)!(/'!8(/(-$!(/-$%!(/'!2)%$22=!!;*$!M$(%)18(%)2!<%+-%(8!*(2!4+/)%06,)$'!)+!089%+#$'!6$*(#0+%!+7!2),'$/)23!0/45,'0/-!()D%02?!2),'$/)2=!!

P/!(''0)0+/!)+!M$(%)18(%)23!F2=!K,22$55!%,/2!(!4+,/2$50/-!9%+-%(8!7+%!7(8050$2!+7!2),'$/)2!0/!)*$!(5)$%/()0#$!9%+-%(82=!!;*02!9%+-%(8!$895+&2!4+,/2$50/-!8$)*+'2!'$#$5+9$'!6&!<(0%2!P/)$%/()0+/(53!(!U5+%0'(D6(2$'!4+,/2$50/-!4+89(/&=\^!!K,22$55!2)(&2!+/$!/0-*)!9$%!J$$?!)+!8$$)!J0)*!7(8050$2!7+%!4+,/2$50/-!2$220+/2=!!K,22$55!(52+!)%(0/2!2),'$/)2!)+!2$%#$!(2!9$$%!8$'0()+%2=!!;*$2$!0//+#()0#$!9%+-%(82!(%$!2,99+%)$'!6&!F%=!V+/055(!6$4(,2$!

!! A\!

Page 36: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

)*$&!70)!0/)+!*02!9*05+2+9*&!DD!07!)*$!/$$'2!+7!2),'$/)2!(%$!8$)3!)*$&!J055!75+,%02*!0/!24*++5=!!

@9><A5=-@<>>;?-/B855;!!.8<;5A5O8DI!!<%0/409(5!;*$58(!Z(#02!2)()$2!,/4()$-+%04(55&!)*()!2*$!J055!/+)!)+5$%()$!4*05'%$/!J*+!8026$*(#$=!!1*$!6$50$#$2!0/!2)%04)!'0240950/$=!!<%0/409(5!Z(#02!02!0/)$-%(55&!0/#+5#$'!0/!)*$!'0240950/(%&!9%+4$22!()!*$%!24*++5=!!P7!(!4*05'!02!%$7$%%$'!)+!*$%!6&!+/$!+7!)*$!(2202)(/)!9%0/409(523!0)!02!6$4(,2$!$#$%&!9+22065$!(5)$%/()0#$!)+!2,29$/20+/!*(2!(5%$('&!6$$/!,)050[$'=!!V$7+%$!2*$!(99%+#$2!(/!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/3!2*$!J(/)2!)*$!2),'$/)!)+!C'$7&!*$%E!6$7+%$!8+%$!'%(2)04!2)$92!(%$!)(?$/=!!1),'$/)2!,/'$%2)(/'!)*()!Z(#02!02!)*$0%!5(2)!+99+%),/0)&!)+!2*(9$D,9=!!]*05$!2)%04)!'0240950/$!02!$895+&$'3!2),'$/)2!(%$!-0#$/!+99+%),/0)0$2!)+!4+%%$4)!6$*(#0+%!6$7+%$!2,29$/20+/!02!,2$'=!!

;*$!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!()!F('02+/!F0''5$!',%0/-!)*$!@eeaDee!24*++5!&$(%!J$%$!@^=ag!0/24*++5!(/'!@^=Ag!+,)D+7D24*++5=!!<%0/409(5!Z(#02!$O95(0/$'!)*()!)*$!5+J!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!%()$!02!8025$('0/-!6$4(,2$!0)!%$9%$2$/)2!)*$!9$%4$/)(-$!+7!4*05'%$/!J*+!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!+/4$Y!F('02+/!F0''5$!*(2!(!28(55!-%+,9!+7!2),'$/)2!J*+!(%$!%$9$()$'5&!2,29$/'$'!7%+8!24*++5=!!

B)!)*$!6$-0//0/-!+7!)*$!5(2)!24*++5!&$(%3!Z(#02!0895$8$/)$'!(!/$J!'0240950/(%&!95(/!(/'!4+88,/04()$'!)*()!95(/!)+!)$(4*$%2=!!;*$!95(/!%$>,0%$'!)*()!(!4*05'!6$!%$7$%%$'!)+!*$%!7+%!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!+/5&!(7)$%!)*$!7+55+J0/-!2)$92!*(#$!6$$/!)(?$/o!!

h! 45(22%++8!%,5$2!8,2)!6$!,2$'!(/'!$O*(,2)$'Y!!h! )*$!;$(8!V$*(#0+%(5!<5(/!8,2)!6$!,2$'!(/'!$O*(,2)$'Y\`!

!h! 2),'$/)2!8,2)!6$!%$7$%%$'!)+!4+,/2$5+%2!(/'!)*$!4+,/2$5+%L2!

+9)0+/2!8,2)!6$!$O*(,2)$'Y!(/'!!

h! 2),'$/)2!(%$!)*$/!%$7$%%$'!)+!)*$!-%('$D5$#$5!('80/02)%()+%=!!

B)!)*()!9+0/)3!('80/02)%()+%2!J055!6$-0/!0895$8$/)()0+/!+7!)*$!B'80/02)%()0#$!V$*(#0+%!F(/(-$8$/)!<5(/o!B5)$%/()0#$2!)+!1,29$/20+/=!!

;*$!B'80/02)%()0#$!V$*(#0+%!F(/(-$8$/)!<5(/!'$)(052!/0/$!(5)$%/()0#$2!)*()!2*+,5'!6$!,2$'!6$7+%$!(!4*05'!02!%$7$%%$'!7+%!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/=!!;*$2$!(5)$%/()0#$2!0/45,'$o!!

h! B'80/02)%()+%r1),'$/)!Q+/7$%$/4$!S<(%$/)!Q+/)(4)T!

!! A^!

Page 37: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

h! B'80/02)%()+%r1),'$/)r<(%$/)!Q+/7$%$/4$!h! B7)$%D14*++5!Z$)$/)0+/!h! ]+%?!Z$)(05!DD!V$7+%$!+%!B7)$%!14*++5!h! P/'++%!1,29$/20+/!S1Q1PT!S0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/T!h! 1(),%'(&!14*++5!h! "#$/0/-!P/)$%#$/)0+/!h! 1),'$/)!<%0/409(5rQ+/7$%$/4$!h! FBK1!DD!F('02+/!B)!K02?!14*$',5$\a!h! H,)'++%!1,29$/20+/!S+,)D+7D24*++5T!

!;*$!95(/!%$80/'2!)$(4*$%2o!C)*$!,5)08()$!+6G$4)0#$!02!)+!?$$9!2),'$/)2!0/!

24*++5=E!!

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

!Z(#02!())%06,)$2!)*$!24*++5L2!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!)+!5(4?!+7!9(%$/)(5!4+/)%+5!

+7!4*05'%$/=!!P/!8(/&!0/2)(/4$23!)*$%$!02!/+!9(%$/)(5!0/#+5#$8$/)!()!(55=!!1),'$/)2!(%$!%,'$!(/'!'02%$29$4)7,5=!!H7)$/!2),'$/)2!(%$!%$7$%%$'!7+%!'0240950/$!6$4(,2$!)$(4*$%2!6$4+8$!)0%$'!+7!'$(50/-!J0)*!'02%,9)0+/2=!

!;+!%$',4$!'0240950/(%&!9%+65$823!Z(#02!J+,5'!50?$!)+!0895$8$/)!(!

9%+-%(8!)*()!02+5()$2!'02%,9)0#$!2),'$/)2!J0)*0/!)*$!24*++5=!!;*02!9%+-%(8!J+,5'!9%+#0'$!(!28(55$%!45(22%++8!$/#0%+/8$/)=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!Z(#02!6$50$#$2!)*()!)*$!2),'$/)D)+D4+,/2$5+%!%()0+!2*+,5'!6$!5+J$%$'=!!Q,%%$/)5&3!4+,/2$5+%2!(%$!J+%?0/-!J0)*!)++!8(/&!2),'$/)2!(/'!)*$%$7+%$!4(//+)!6$!(2!$77$4)0#$!6$4(,2$!)*$&!'+!/+)!*(#$!(!8$(/0/-7,5!+99+%),/0)&!)+!6,05'!%$5()0+/2*092!J0)*!2),'$/)2!(/'!)*$0%!9(%$/)2=!!

"5:78-&9>?-@<>>;?-/B855;!!.8<;5A5O8DI-F2=!",/04$!Z(#023!<%0/409(5!+7!_+%)*!Z('$!F0''5$!14*++53!6$50$#$2!0/!)*$![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!(99%+(4*!)+!'0240950/$=!!1*$!2)()$'!45$(%5&!)*()!2*$!*(2!/+!)+5$%(/4$!7+%!/+/2$/2$!+%!'02%,9)0+/!0/!)*$!45(22%++8=!!Z(#02!6$50$#$2!)*()!45(22%++8!'02%,9)0+/!02!)*$!7+%$8+2)!9%+65$8!p!07!)$(4*$%2!4(/!)$(4*!J0)*+,)!4+/2)(/)!'02%,9)0+/23!2),'$/)2!J+,5'!5$(%/3!)$2)!24+%$2!J+,5'!%02$3!(/'!2),'$/)2!J+,5'!6$!*(99&=!!Z(#02!6$50$#$2!)*02!G,2)070$2!)*$!*0-*!2,29$/20+/!%()$!

!! A`!

Page 38: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

()!)*$!24*++5=!!1*$!2,99+%)2!)*$!%$8+#(5!+7!'02%,9)0#$!2),'$/)2!7%+8!)*$!45(22%++8=!!1*$!6$50$#$2!)*()!4+/202)$/)!(99504()0+/!+7![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!02!089+%)(/)=!!

Z(#02!6$50$#$2!)*()!*+8$!$/#0%+/8$/)!95(&2!(!8(G+%!%+5$!0/!*+J!2),'$/)2!7$$5!(6+,)!)*$82$5#$23!6,)!)*()!0)!'+$2!/+)!'$)$%80/$!)*$0%!'$2)0/&=!!SZ(#02!/+)$'!)*()!)*$!24*++5!02!5+4()$'!45+2$!)+!(/!(%$(!?/+J/!7+%!*$(#&!'%,-!(4)0#0)&=T!!Z(#02!$89*(20[$2!)+!2),'$/)2!)*()!)*$&!4(/!2,44$$'=!!Z,%0/-!*$%!7+,%D&$(%!)$/,%$3!)*$!24*++5!*(2!J+%?$'!*(%'!)+!*$59!2),'$/)2!2$$!)*$82$5#$2!(2!(4*0$#$%2=!!

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

Z$290)$!(/!(4?/+J5$'-8$/)!)*()!)$(4*$%2!8(&!6$!)+!65(8$3!()!5$(2)!0/!9(%)3!7+%!)*$!'0240950/(%&!9%+65$823!)*$!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!7+%!_+%)*!Z('$!',%0/-!)*$!@eeaDee!24*++5!&$(%!J$%$!WA=Rg!0/D24*++5!(/'!RW=@g!+,)D+7D24*++5=!;*$2$!%()$2!(%$!(8+/-!)*$!*0-*$2)!7+%!80''5$!24*++52!0/!)*$!F0(80DZ('$!Q+,/)&!24*++5!2&2)$8=!!F('02+/!F0''5$!14*++53!J*04*!*(2!(!@^=Ag!+,)D+724*++5!2,29$/20+/!%()$3!*(2!(!4+89(%(65$!/,86$%!+7!0/40'$/)2!+7!#0+5$/4$!S(99%+O08()$5&!=AA!0/40'$/)2!9$%!2),'$/)T=!!;*,23!)*$!'%(8()04(55&!2(50$/)!'077$%$/4$2!0/!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!8(&!6$!())%06,)(65$!)+!'077$%$/4$!0/!9*05+2+9*&=!SB5)*+,-*!(!2$57D'$24%06$'!C2)%04)!'0240950/(%0(/3E!)*$!<%0/409(5!+7!F('02+/!6$50$#$2!0/!-0#0/-!2),'$/)2!2$4+/'!4*(/4$2=T!!Z(#02!(/)0409()$2!)*()!2,29$/20+/!%()$2!()!_+%)*!Z('$!J055!0/4%$(2$!7+%!)*$!@eeeDAXXX!24*++5!&$(%!6$4(,2$!+7!4+/202)$/)!(99504()0+/!+7!)*$![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+504&=!!.5)08()$5&3!2*$!J(/)2!)*$!2),'$/)2!)+!6$!0/!(!45(22%++8!J*$%$!)$(4*$%2!)$(4*3!/+)!'0240950/$=!!

]0)*!*+9$2!+7!5+J$%0/-!)*$!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!)*$!('80/02)%()0+/!0/7+%82!2),'$/)2!(/'!9(%$/)2!+7!)*$!24*++5L2!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2=!!I(2)!&$(%!7+%!$O(895$3!<%0/409(5!Z(#02!8$)!J0)*!9(%$/)2!+7!2),'$/)2!J*+!J$%$!%$9$()$'5&!%$7$%%$'!7+%!'0240950/$=!!Z(#02!$O95(0/$'!*$%!C[$%+!)+5$%(/4$E!9*05+2+9*&!(/'!,%-$'!)*$!9(%$/)2!)+!2)(&!0/#+5#$'!J0)*!)*$0%!4*05'%$/d2!$',4()0+/=!!./7+%),/()$5&3!)*$!2(8$!2),'$/)2!4+/)0/,$!)+!6$!'0240950/$'=!!

Z0240950/$!()!_+%)*!Z('$!F0''5$!14*++5!J(2!6&!7(%!)*$!*(%2*$2)!+7!)*$!

!! Aa!

Page 39: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

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

;+!'$4%$(2$!2,29$/20+/!%()$23!Z(#02!6$50$#$2!)*()!)*$!24*++5!8,2)o!!

h! Q+/202)$/)5&!(995&![$%+!)+5$%(/4$=!h! P/4%$(2$!9(%$/)(5!0/#+5#$8$/)=!h! K$70/$!0)2!(7)$%D24*++5!0/)$%#$/)0+/!9%+-%(82=!h! 1)%$/-)*$/!0)2!24*++5DJ0'$!4+/7504)!%$2+5,)0+/!9%+-%(8=!h! <%+#0'$!(''0)0+/(5!)%(0/0/-!7+%!)$(4*$%2!0/!4+/7504)!%$2+5,)0+/=!

!_+%)*!Z('$!*(2!%$4$/)5&!0895$8$/)$'!(!/,86$%!+7!9%+-%(82!)*()!)*$!

B'80/02)%()0+/!*+9$2!J055!$#$/),(55&!%$',4$!2,29$/20+/2!6&!(''%$220/-!9%+65$82!(/'!2$%#0/-!(2!2+5,)0+/2=!!U+%!$O(895$3!)*$!24*++5!%$4$/)5&!9,%4*(2$'!(!4+89,)$%!9%+-%(8!)*()!J055!9$%80)!0)!)+!7+%8(55&!8+/0)+%!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(52=!SP)!02!)*$!+/5&!24*++5!+7!)*$!7+,%!8$/)0+/$'!)*()!*(2!(!7+%8(5!8+/0)+%0/-!2&2)$8=T!!;*02!9%+-%(8!J055!9$%80)!)*$!24*++5!)+!(/(5&[$!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(5!'()(!0/45,'0/-!)*$!)&9$!+7!4+/',4)!(/'!%$7$%%0/-!)$(4*$%2=!!

!! Ae!

Page 40: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

;$(4*$%2!J0)*!(!*0-*!/,86$%!+7!%$7$%%(52!J055!())$/'!J+%?2*+92!%$5()0/-!)+!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!7+%!)*$!70%2)!)08$!5(2)!&$(%3!_+%)*!Z('$!%$4$0#$'!;0)5$!P!7,/'2=!!SB5)*+,-*!$50-065$!7+%!7,/'0/-!0/!9%$#0+,2!&$(%23!)*$!24*++5!'0'!/+)!(44$22!7,/'0/-!',$!)+!('80/02)%()0#$!9%+65$82=T!!B8+/-!+)*$%!)*0/-23!;0)5$!P!7,/'2!*(#$!6$$/!,2$'!)+!*0%$!(!7,55D)08$!Q+88,/0)&!19$40(502)3!%$29+/2065$!7+%!J+%?0/-!J0)*!9(%$/)2!(/'!0/4%$(20/-!9(%$/)(5!0/#+5#$8$/)=!!

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

H)*$%!9%+-%(82!()!_+%)*!Z('$!0/45,'$o!<+504$!F$/)+%0/-!<%+-%(83!B7)$%D14*++5!j+57!<%+-%(83!B7)$%D14*++5!;,)+%0(5!<%+-%(83!Q+/4$%/$'!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/!]+8$/!S8$/)+%0/-T3!U(805&!Q*%02)0(/!B22+40()0+/!S4+,/2$50/-!(/'!),)+%0/-!9%+-%(8T3!(/'!\XX!K+5$!F+'$5=!!

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

1?AA5=A!!

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

!! RX!

Page 41: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

4*05'%$/!4(/!4*(/-$!)*$0%!6$*(#0+%2!J0)*+,)!6$0/-!2,6G$4)$'!)+!$O45,20+/!7%+8!24*++5=!!]0)*+,)!(!4*(/-$!0/!9*05+2+9*&3!8(/&!24*++52!J055!4+/)0/,$!)+!J%0)$!+77!(/'!J$$'!+,)!4*05'%$/3!4,))0/-!+77!)*$0%!$',4()0+/(5!+99+%),/0)0$2=!!!"#$%&'()*+(),+&-.(/#*001/()*2)(,+2#*(0")(%&/)+2-(03(4"/*(0")!!B$<#/')'>+-7$/556&/."$*&$0."&&7$()0.)57)'#$)0$&'#$*"/*$*6#/*0$0*-(#'*0$/'($*"#)6$

+/<)7)#0$:)*"!6#05#.*$*"6&->"&-*$*"#$56&.#003$0##;0$*&$7#/6'$+6&<$0*-(#'*0$/'($*&$'-6*-6#$*"#)6$7#/6')'>$/'(!>6&:*"$/0$"-</'$=#)'>03$/'($*"/*$+)'(0$:/90$*&$=6)'>$

0*-(#'*0$<&6#$(##579$)'*&$*"#$0."&&7!.&<<-')*92$$!!

f,2)04$!F())$%2!P/2)0),)$!K$9+%)o!vM+J!14*++5!Q+88,/0)0$2!<%$#$/)!K(4028!0/!14*++5!Z0240950/$v!!

]0)*!)*$!0/4%$(20/-!,2$!+7!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/23!)*$%$!(%$!24*++52!'$7&0/-!)*$!2)(),2!>,+=!!;*$2$!24*++52!(%$!70/'0/-!)*()!0)!02!9+22065$!)+!*(#$!(4*0$#$8$/)3!2(7$)&3!(/'!(!5+J!/,86$%!+7!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(52=!!]$!0'$/)070$'!)*%$$!+%-(/0[()0+/2!4,%%$/)5&!)(%-$)0/-!)*$2$!24*++52=!!;*$2$!-%+,92!*(#$!'%(J/!%$8(%?(65&!20805(%!4+/45,20+/2!(6+,)!$22$/)0(5!4*(%(4)$%02)042!+7!)*$2$!24*++52=!!

h! B!2*07)!(J(&!7%+8!'0240950/(%&!9%(4)04$2!'$20-/$'!)+!%0'!24*++52!+7!C)*$!9%+65$8E!)+J(%'!(!8+%$!0/45,20#$!8+'$5!8,2)!6$!(!24*++5DJ0'$!$77+%)!*$(#05&!9%+8+)$'!6&!)*$!9%0/409(5!(/'!C6+,-*)!0/)+E!6&!)*$!8(G+%0)&!+7!)$(4*$%2!(/'!2)(77=!

!h! 19$40704!2)%()$-0$2!(%$!'$#02$'!7+%!9%+#0'0/-!2),'$/)2!(/'!)$(4*$%2!

J0)*!+99+%),/0)0$2!)+!'$#$5+9!2)%+/-!6+/'2=!!;*02!+7)$/!8$(/2!)*()!5(%-$!24*++52!(%$!6%+?$/!0/)+!28(55$%!,/0)2!0/!+%'$%!)+!(55+J!9$%2+/(5!%$5()0+/2*092!6$)J$$/!)$(4*$%2!(/'!2),'$/)2!)+!75+,%02*=!

!h! ;*$%$!02!7%$>,$/)5&!(!4+/4$%)$'!$77+%)!)+!9%+#0'$!)$(4*$%2!J0)*!

)%(0/0/-!(/'!J+%?2*+92!7+4,2$'!+/!9+20)0#$!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)!)$4*/0>,$2!(/'!+/!*$590/-!)$(4*$%2!,/'$%2)(/'!)*$!%++)!4(,2$!+7!'02%,9)0#$!6$*(#0+%2=!

!h! B!24*++5DJ0'$!4+'$!+7!4+/',4)!(/'!$O9$4)()0+/2!7+%!2),'$/)!

6$*(#0+%2!02!J0'$5&!9%+8+)$'!(/'!,/'$%2)++'=!!

h! Z0240950/$!02!7+4,2$'!+/!9%$#$/)0/-!(/'!'077,20/-!9+)$/)0(55&!'02%,9)0#$!20),()0+/2!6$7+%$!)*$&!$%,9)3!(/'!29$407043!J$55D,/'$%2)++'!2)%()$-0$2!7+%!(''%$220/-!4%02$2!(%$!0/!95(4$=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!8(/&!24*++52!$895+&!(!9(%$/)!4++%'0/()+%!+%!

!! R@!

Page 42: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

0/)$%#$/)0+/02)=!!;*02!0/'0#0',(53!J*+!02!/$0)*$%!(!)$(4*$%!/+%!(!-,0'(/4$!4+,/2$5+%3!02!(#(05(65$!)+!)*$!2),'$/)2!',%0/-!)*$!'(&3!+7)$/!9%+#0'0/-!(!2(7$!*(#$/!7+%!2),'$/)2!J*+!8(&!C5+2$!)*$0%!4++5=E!!U,/'2!)+!9(&!2,4*!(/!0/'0#0',(5!+7)$/!4+8$!+,)!+7!;0)5$!P!8+/$&!+%!24*++5!7,/'%(020/-!$77+%)2=!

!h! 1),'$/)!2(/4)0+/2!(%$!4+/20'$%$'!+/!(!4(2$D6&D4(2$!6(202!J0)*!

0/9,)!7%+8!2),'$/)2!(/'!9(%$/)2=!!

h! <(%$/)23!4+88,/0)&!8$86$%23!8$/)(5!*$(5)*!(/'!G,#$/05$!G,2)04$!9%+7$220+/(523!6,20/$22!5$('$%23!(/'!+)*$%2!(%$!J$54+8$'!0/)+!)*$!'(05&!507$!+7!)*$!24*++53!J0)*!(!9(%)04,5(%!$89*(202!+/!$/-(-0/-!9(%$/)2!0/!24*++5!(4)0#0)0$2=!

!h! "O95040)!$77+%)2!(%$!8('$!)+!2*+J!2),'$/)2!)*()!)*$&!(%$!%$29$4)$'!

(/'!#(5,$'!8$86$%2!+7!)*$!24*++5!4+88,/0)&3!(/'!)*()3!(2!2,4*3!)*$&!(%$!$O9$4)$'!)+!('*$%$!)+!*0-*!6$*(#0+%(5!(/'!(4('$804!2)(/'(%'2=!

!h! ;*$!24*++5!0895$8$/)2!(!J0'$!%(/-$!+7!9%+-%(823!0/45,'0/-!9$$%!

4+,%)23!4+/7504)!%$2+5,)0+/!9%+-%(823!$(%5&!0/)$%#$/)0+/23!8$/)+%0/-3!8$'0()0+/23!(/'!4*(%(4)$%!$',4()0+/!9%+-%(82!)*()!9%+8+)$!(!8,),(55&!%$29$4)7,5!(/'!4+55(6+%()0#$!24*++5!4508()$!(/'!)$(4*!2),'$/)2!(/'!)$(4*$%2!*+J!)+!*(/'5$!(/'!%$2+5#$!4+/7504)!0/!(99%+9%0()$!J(&2=!

!h! 14*++52!7%$>,$/)5&!)%(/27+%8!)*$!9*&204(5!$/#0%+/8$/)!0/)+!(!8+%$!

J$54+80/-!(/'!7%0$/'5&!29(4$=!!V$5+J!(%$!2,88(%0$2!+7!)*$!(/(5&2$2!9%+#0'$'!6&!)*$2$!+%-(/0[()0+/2!(/'!6%0$7!9%+705$2!+7!24*++52!)*()!(%$!8(?0/-!9%+-%$22!0/!)*$0%!$77+%)2!)+!089%+#$!24*++5!4508()$!)+!4%$()$!2(7$!(/'!0/45,20#$!5$(%/0/-!$/#0%+/8$/)2=!!

(?=7?:-K5:-,KK?B7<N?-(5;;9C5:97<5=-9=>-.:9B7<B?-\(,(.]-5K-78?-

*S?:<B9=-!=A7<767?A-5K-$?A?9:B8\e!!

P/!C1(7$-,(%'0/-!H,%!Q*05'%$/o!B/!B4)0+/!j,0'$3E^X!Q"Q<!0'$/)070$2!)*$!>,(50)0$2!+7!C2(7$!(/'!%$29+/2065$!24*++52=E!!

h! ;*$!24*++5!*(2!2)%+/-!5$('$%2*093!4(%0/-!7(4,5)&3!7(805&!(/'!4+88,/0)&!0/#+5#$8$/)3!0/45,'0/-!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!+77040(52!(/'!%$9%$2$/)()0#$2!+7!4+88,/0)&D6(2$'!+%-(/0[()0+/23!(/'!2),'$/)!9(%)0409()0+/!0/!)*$!'$20-/!+7!9%+-%(82!(/'!9+5040$2=!

!! RA!

Page 43: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!h! ;*$!9*&204(5!$/#0%+/8$/)!+7!)*$!24*++5!02!2(7$3!(/'!24*++5DJ0'$!

9+5040$2!(%$!0/!95(4$!)+!9%+8+)$!(/'!2,99+%)!%$29+/2065$!6$*(#0+%2=!!

h! <%$#$/)0+/!(/'!0/)$%#$/)0+/!9%+-%(82!(%$!2,2)(0/$'3!4++%'0/()$'3!(/'!4+89%$*$/20#$=!

!h! P/)$%#$/)0+/2!(%$!6(2$'!+/!4(%$7,5!(22$228$/)!+7!2),'$/)!/$$'2=!

!h! "#0'$/4$D6(2$'!(99%+(4*$2!(%$!,2$'=!

!h! 1)(77!(%$!9%+#0'$'!J0)*!)%(0/0/-!(/'!2,99+%)!)+!*$59!)*$8!

0895$8$/)!9%+-%(82!(/'!(99%+(4*$2=!!

h! P/)$%#$/)0+/2!(%$!8+/0)+%$'!(/'!$#(5,()0+/2!(%$!4+/',4)$'!)+!$/2,%$!)*()!)*$!9%+-%(82!(%$!8$$)0/-!8$(2,%(65$!-+(52!(/'!+6G$4)0#$2=!

!;*$%$!(%$!2$#$%(5!24*++5DJ0'$!9%+-%(82!0'$/)070$'!6&!Q"Q<3!(2!'$24%06$'!

0/!B99$/'0O!nPP3!)*()!0/'$9$/'$/)!$#(5,()0+/2!0/'04()$!*(#$!(4*0$#$'!2+8$!2,44$22!0/!*$590/-!24*++52!(4*0$#$!)*$2$!-+(52=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!Q"Q<!*(2!0'$/)070$'!2,44$227,5!24*++523!+/$!+7!J*04*!02!'$24%06$'!6$5+J=!!

$9B8?;-(9:A5=-,;?S?=79:D-/B855;!!

K(4*$5!Q(%2+/!"5$8$/)(%&!14*++5!0/!Q*04(-+!02!+/$!24*++5!)*()!Q"Q<!*(2!0'$/)070$'!)*()!*(2!8('$!20-/0704(/)!9%+-%$22!0/!)%(/27+%80/-!0)2!24*++5!4,5),%$=!!K(4*$5!Q(%2+/!02!(!wDa!9,6504!24*++5!2$%#0/-!@3A\X!2),'$/)23!e\g!+7!J*+8!>,(507&!7+%!7%$$r%$',4$'!5,/4*!(/'!eAg!+7!J*+8!(%$!M029(/04=!!P/!@ee\3!)*$!<%0/409(5!8('$!(!#$%&!'$506$%()$!'$4020+/!)+!2*07)!)+!(!CJ*+5$!4*05'!(99%+(4*=E!!./)05!)*()!)08$3!)*$!14*++5!2,29$/'$'!5(%-$!/,86$%2!+7!2),'$/)2=!!M$%!'$4020+/!J(2!/+)!29,%%$'!6&!(/&!+/$!$#$/)3!6,)!%()*$%!6&!(!-%+J0/-!%$(50[()0+/!)*()!)*$!*0-*!/,86$%!+7!'0240950/$!9%+65$82!%$>,0%$'!(!'077$%$/)!(99%+(4*=!!

B./(#<).$,'8)6&'<#'*C$!B2!9(%)!+7!)*02!2*07)3!(!4+/4$%)$'!$77+%)!J(2!8('$!)+!8(?$!)*$!24*++5!$/#0%+/8$/)!8+%$!9*&204(55&!0/#0)0/-=!!;*$!24*++5!)08$!(/'!29(4$!J(2!%$(%%(/-$'!)+!9%+#0'$!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!2),'$/)2!)+!7+%8!2)%+/-$%!%$5()0+/2*092!J0)*!)$(4*$%2=!!<%$#0+,25&3!(!2),'$/)!J+,5'!2$$!`Da!)$(4*$%2!(!'(&!0/!(2!8(/&!45(22%++823!(/'!8+6050)&!J(2!*0-*!)*%+,-*+,)!)*$!'(&=!!_+J!(!2),'$/)!+/5&!8+#$2!ADR!)08$2!(!'(&3!(/'!02!+7)$/!)(,-*)!'077$%$/)!2,6G$4)2!6&!)*$!2(8$!)$(4*$%=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!(!4,%%04,5,8!7+4,2!)*()!0/)$-%()$2!)*$!(%)2!*(2!-0#$/!2),'$/)2!+99+%),/0)0$2!)+!$O9%$22!)*$82$5#$23!)+!$/-(-$!0/!5$(%/0/-3!(/'!

!! RR!

Page 44: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

)+!*(#$!7,/=!!

B))$/'(/4$!*(2!0/4%$(2$'!7%+8!eRg!)+!eag3!(/'!(4('$804!(4*0$#$8$/)!02!089%+#0/-=!!;*$!9$%4$/)(-$!+7!2),'$/)2!)$2)0/-!()!-%('$!%$('0/-!5$#$5!*(2!0/4%$(2$'!7%+8!@Ag!)+!WAg!6$)J$$/!@eeAD@eee=!!

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`oRX(8!S6$7+%$!45(22$2T!02!(220-/$'3!+%!(/!0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!02!,2$'!7+%!8+%$!2$%0+,2!9%+65$82=!!H,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/2!(%$!,2$'!(2!(!5(2)!%$2+%)!+/5&3!(/'!7%$>,$/)5&!7+%!+77$/2$2!8(/'()$'!6&![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2!0/!$77$4)!0/!Q*04(-+=!!

;*02!&$(%!)$/!2),'$/)2!J$%$!2,29$/'$'!p!5$22!)*(/!@g!+7!)*$!2),'$/)!6+'&!p!(/'!/+/$!7+%!5+/-$%!)*(/!)J+!'(&2Y!/+/$!J$%$!$O9$55$'=!!;*02!%$4+%'!4+/)%(2)2!'%(8()04(55&!)+!)*$!%$2)!+7!)*$!40)&!+7!Q*04(-+3!J*$%$!)*$!$O9,520+/!%()$!*(2!6$$/!C2+(%0/-E!',%0/-!)*$!9(2)!)J+!&$(%2=^@!!

Q6A7<B?-@977?:A-!=A7<767?^A!!

P/!0)2!9%$5080/(%&!%$9+%)!+/!24*++5!'0240950/$!$/)0)5$'!CM+J!14*++5!Q+88,/0)0$2!<%$#$/)!K(4028!0/!14*++5!Z0240950/$3E^R!f,2)04$!F())$%2!*(2!0'$/)070$'!$0-*)!24*++52!)$(4*0/-!9%$'+80/(/)5&!2),'$/)2!+7!4+5+%!5+4()$'!)*%+,-*+,)!)*$!4+,/)%&!)*()!J$%$!(65$!)+!8(0/)(0/!5+J!2,29$/20+/!(/'!$O9,520+/!%()$2!(/'!2)(&!2(7$=!!P)!7+,/'!4+88+/(50)0$2!0/!8(/&!+7!)*$2$3!0/45,'0/-!)*$!7+55+J0/-!$5$8$/)2=!!

h! Q(%0/-!$)*04!02!$O95040)5&!(!4$/)%(5!9(%)!+7!)*$!24*++5!80220+/=!h! K$2+,%4$2!(%$!'$#+)$'!)+!6,05'0/-!2)%+/-!%$5()0+/2*092=!h! Q+55(6+%()0#$!(99%+(4*!)+!'0240950/$!#0+5()0+/23!0/#+5#0/-!2),'$/)3!

!! RW!

Page 45: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

)$(4*$%3!2+8$)08$2!9(%$/)!+%!+)*$%!2)(77=!!1),'$/)2!(55+J$'!)+!(%-,$!)*$0%!4(2$=!

h! Z0240950/$!'$(5)!J0)*!+/!(!4(2$D6&D4(2$!6(202Y!0/'0#0',(50[$'!95(/2!'$#$5+9$'!6&!)$(4*$%!+%!29$40(5!)$(8=!

h! 14*++52!*(#$!2)%+/-!%$5()0+/2*092!J0)*!9(%$/)2Y!9(%$/)2!#$%&!0/#+5#$'!(/'!0/#$2)$'=!

!&?E<77-(;<=75=-2<P8-/B855;!

!H/$!24*++5!0'$/)070$'!6&!f,2)04$!F())$%2!(2!8$$)0/-!8(/&!+7!)*$2$!

4%0)$%0(!02!Z$]0))!Q50/)+/!M0-*!14*++53!5+4()$'!0/!)*$!V%+/O3!0/!_$J!N+%?!Q0)&=!!P)!$/%+552!W3R@@!2),'$/)2o!R\!g!B7%04(/DB8$%04(/3!\`g!I()0/+3!(/'!^g!B20(/!<(40704!P25(/'$%=!!1),'$/)2!(995&!)+!Q50/)+/!7%+8!(55!+#$%!)*$!V%+/O=!!;*0%)&!9$%4$/)!+7!)*$!2),'$/)2!(%$!4*+2$/!7%+8!)*$!(99504(/)!9++5!+/!(!4+89$)0)0#$!6(2023!(/'!)*$!%$8(0/0/-!2$#$/)&!9$%4$/)!(%$!%(/'+85&!'%(J/!7%+8!)*$!(99504(/)!9++5=!!B99%+O08()$5&3!@A3XXX!2),'$/)2!(995&!$(4*!&$(%!7+%!)*$!@3XXX!7%$2*8(/!25+)2=!!

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

;*$!2)(77!8(?$2!(!4+/240+,2!$77+%)!)+!2*+J!2),'$/)2!)*()!)*$&!4(%$Y!)*02!$O)$/'$'!7(805&!0/45,'$2!4,2)+'0(/2!(/'!4(7$)$%0(!J+%?$%2=!!14*++5!25+-(/2!2,4*!(23!C]*+!4(%$2q!!]$!4(%$3E!C_$#$%3!/$#$%3!/$#$%3!/$#$%!>,0)E!(/'!CQ+880)8$/)!)+!$O4$55$/4$3E!%$0/7+%4$!)*$!2$/2$!+7!4+/4$%/!7+%!)*$!J$55D6$0/-!+7!2),'$/)2=!!

F)0.)57)'#C$$Z$J0))!Q50/)+/!$895+&2!(!2)(/'(%'!'0240950/$!9+504&!J0)*!9(%)04,5(%!4+/2$>,$/4$2!,2$'!7+%!9(%)04,5(%!6$*(#0+%2=!!M+J$#$%3!(99504()0+/!+7!)*$!%,5$2!02!/+)!8$4*(/04(5!(/'!0/75$O065$=!!P7!)*$%$!02!(!6$*(#0+%!022,$3!)*$!2),'$/)!8(&!6$!2$/)!)+!29$(?!J0)*!+/$!+7!)*$!2)(77!8$86$%2!+7!)*$!*+,2$!2)(773!J0)*!)*$!Q++%'0/()+%!+7!1),'$/)!B77(0%23!+%!J0)*!(!Z$(/=!!;*02!'024,220+/!8(&!(%%0#$!()!(!2+5,)0+/=!!<(%$/)2!8(&!(52+!6$!0/#+5#$'!0/!)*02!9%+4$22=!!1,29$/20+/2!(%$!(#+0'$'!(/'!+)*$%!+9)0+/2!(%$!9,%2,$'=!!I(2)!&$(%3!)*$!/,86$%!+7!2),'$/)2!2,29$/'$'!(/'r+%!$O9$55$'!J(2!@`3!+%!5$22!)*(/!*(57!+7!@g!+7!)*$!2),'$/)!6+'&=!!

!! R\!

Page 46: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

;*$!24*++5!(52+!+77$%2!(!J0'$!%(/-$!+7!(4)0#0)0$23!(22$8650$23!'(/4$23!29+%)2!$#$/)23!29$(?$%23!$)4=!)*()!(%$!+9$/!)+!)*$!4+88,/0)&3!(2!J$55!(2!(!%(/-$!+7!2),'$/)!45,62!(/'!$5$4)0#$2=!!

@<;M96X??-(979;DA7Y&?A<P=A-K5:-(89=P?^W!!

B99%+O08()$5&!\Xg!+7!(55!80''5$!24*++5!2),'$/)2!(/'!+/$D)*0%'!+7!(55!*0-*!24*++5!2),'$/)2!0/!F05J(,?$$d2!9,6504!24*++5!2&2)$8!(%$!2,29$/'$'!()!5$(2)!+/4$Y!e`g!+7!)*$2$!2,29$/20+/2!(%$!7+%!/+/D#0+5$/)!+77$/2$2!(/'!0/7%(4)0+/2=!!P/!(/!$77+%)!)+!0895$8$/)!$',4()0+/(5!9%(4)04$2!)*()!$/2,%$!$>,0)(65$!(/'!$77$4)0#$!24*++5!'0240950/$!(/'!2,99+%)!*0-*!(4*0$#$8$/)!7+%!(55!2),'$/)23!F05J(,?$$!Q()(5&2)!0/0)0()$'!(!4(89(0-/!$/)0)5$'!G/+#$/'($H6(#679$G."&&70$!"/*!,(-./*#$B77$G*-(#'*02!!

F05J(,?$$!Q()(5&2)!G+0/$'!7+%4$2!0/!9(%)/$%2*09!J0)*!Z$20-/2!7+%!Q*(/-$^\!)+!4+/',4)!(!/()0+/(5!%$#0$J!+7!24*+5(%5&!J+%?!%$-(%'0/-!$77$4)0#$!24*++5!'0240950/$!9%(4)04$2!0/!,%6(/!24*++52=!!;*$2$!70/'0/-23!4+/)(0/$'!0/!A#0*$D6/.*).#0$+&6$,'0-6)'>$,1-)*/=7#$/'($,++#.*)8#!F)0.)57)'#$*"/*$G-55&6*0$I)>"$B.")#8#<#'*$+&6$B77$G*-(#'*0!S@eeeT^^!(%$!2,88(%0[$'!6$5+J=!!@=! ,++#.*)8#$G."&&7$J#/(#60")5!

s!;*$%$!02!(!4+89%$*$/20#$!(/'!9%+(4)0#$!95(/!7+%!24*++5!'0240950/$=!s!B!7(0%3!45$(%!4+'$!+7!4+/',4)!02!4+/202)$/)5&!$/7+%4$'=!s!<+5040$2!(''%$22!%++)!4(,2$2!+7!'0240950/$!9%+65$82=!s!1,29$/20+/!02!,2$'!(2!)*$!5(2)!%$2+%)=!s!14*++5!4+,/405!(/'!2)(77!)(?$!9(%)!0/!(/(5&[0/-!(/'!089%+#0/-!'0240950/$=!s!;$(4*$%2!(%$!$#(5,()$'!+/!$77$4)0#$!'0240950/$!9%(4)04$2=!

!A[! G."&&7$,'8)6&'<#'*$G-55&6*0$J#/6')'>!

s!"#$%&!2),'$/)!02!(!#(5,$'!8$86$%!+7!)*$!24*++5!4+88,/0)&=!s!;*$!4+88,/0)&!'$#$5+92!9%+(4)0#$!'0240950/$!2)%()$-0$2=!s!14*++5!2)(77!)(?$!%$29+/206050)&!7+%!24*++5DJ0'$!'0240950/$=!s!B!>,(50)&!0/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!9%+-%(8!9%+#0'$2!(4('$804!*$59=!s!"O)%(D4,%%04,5(%!(4)0#0)0$2!6,05'!)0$2!6$)J$$/!2),'$/)2!(/'!24*++5=!s!;*$!24*++5!02!2)%,4),%$'!(%+,/'!28(55!,/0)2=!s!1$57D'0240950/$!02!)(,-*)!0/!)*$!45(22%++8=!s!K++)!4(,2$2!+7!2),'$/)!)%,(/4&!(/'!)(%'0/$22!(%$!(''%$22$'=!s!F+2)!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'0240950/$!9%+65$82!(%$!?$9)!0/!)*$!8(0/2)%$(8!9%+-%(8=!

!K!" ,++#.*)8#$B(-7*$J#/6')'>$/'($%&77/=&6/*)&'!

s!]+%?2*+92!7+4,2!+/!9%+(4)0#$!'0240950/$!8$)*+'2=!

!! R^!

Page 47: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

s!;%(0/0/-!9%+#0'$2!(!45$(%!(/(5&202!+7!)*$!%++)!4(,2$2!+7!'0240950/$!9%+65$82=!s!;*$%$!02!%$-,5(%!7+55+JD,9!0/!)*$!7+%8!+7!4+/4%$)$!95(//0/-!(/'!)$(4*$%!2,99+%)=!s!B55!(',5)2!9(%)0409()$!0/!9%+7$220+/(5!'$#$5+98$/)!J+%?2*+92=!

!L!$ M/<)79$/'($%&<<-')*9$D/6*'#60")50!

s!U(8050$23!2),'$/)23!(/'!4+88,/0)&!*$59!0'$/)07&!9%+65$82!(/'!2+5,)0+/2=!s!B55!'0240950/$!0/7+%8()0+/!02!45$(%5&!4+88,/04()$'!)+!7(8050$2!(/'!2),'$/)2=!!s!Q+88,/0)&!(-$/40$2!(2202)!2),'$/)2!(/'!7(8050$2!J0)*!'0240950/$!9%+65$82=!!s!U(8050$2!(%$!/+)070$'!(/'!$/502)$'!(2!9(%)/$%2!J*$/!4*05'%$/!(%$!2,29$/'$'=!s!;*$!24*++5!4+/)(4)2!9(%$/)2!)+!%$4+-/0[$!4*05'%$/d2!5&0)*)8#$6$*(#0+%=!

!N!" O-/7)*9$E'0*6-.*)&'/7$D6&>6/<!

s!;$(4*$%2!#0$J!2),'$/)2d!2+40(5!(/'!$8+)0+/(5!'$#$5+98$/)!(2!9(%)!+7!)*$0%!G+6=!s!"/-(-0/-!5$(%/0/-!(4)0#0)0$2!(%$!,2$'!)+!80/080[$!2),'$/)!8026$*(#0+%=!s!;$(4*$%2!4+88,/04()$!45$(%!$O9$4)()0+/2!7+%!2),'$/)!6$*(#0+%=!s!;$(4*$%2!8(0/)(0/!45(22%++8!'0240950/$!J0)*+,)!'02%,9)0/-!)*$!5$(%/0/-!9%+4$22=!s!;$(4*$%2!8+'$5!9%+9$%!6$*(#0+%!6&!)%$()0/-!(55!2),'$/)2!J0)*!%$29$4)=!s!1,29$/'$'!2),'$/)2!-$)!*$59!7%+8!)$(4*$%2!)+!8(?$!,9!8022$'!J+%?=!

!

!! R`!

Page 48: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

(9=75=-@<>>;?-/B855;!!

Q(/)+/!F0''5$!14*++5!0/!V(5)08+%$3!F(%&5(/'3!02!+/$!24*++5!)*()!02!('+9)0/-!8(/&!+7!)*$!>,(50)0$2!'$24%06$'!(6+#$=^`!!Q(/)+/!2$%#$2!(!2),'$/)!9+9,5()0+/!+7!``X!)*()!02!aag!5+JD0/4+8$!(/'!\Xg!80/+%0)&=!!F(?0/-!2)%0'$2!0/!)*$!(%$(!+7!G."&&7$J#/(#60")53$)*$!<%0/409(5!*(2!8+#$'!(--%$220#$5&!)+!9,)!/$J!2&2)$82!0/)+!95(4$!(/'!$89+J$%!)$(4*$%2=!!M02!-+(5!J(2!)+!4%$()$!(!2)%,4),%$!)*()!2,99+%)2!2),'$/)!(4*0$#$8$/)!(/'!%$',4$2!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(52=!!

P/D24*++5!2,29$/20+/!02!,2$'!6$7+%$!2),'$/)2!(%$!2$/)!*+8$!7+%!4+/',4)!0/7%(4)0+/2=!!<(%$/)2!+7!2,29$/'$'!4*05'%$/!8,2)!8$$)!J0)*!(!)$(8!+7!)$(4*$%2=!!;*$!/,86$%!+7!2),'$/)2!2,29$/'$'!*(2!'$4%$(2$'!7%+8!W`!)*%$$!&$(%2!(-+!)+!@@!5(2)!&$(%3!(99%+O08()$5&!@=\g!+7!)*$!2),'$/)!6+'&=!!SV(5)08+%$d2!40)&J0'$!2,29$/20+/!%()$!02!e=eg=^aT!!

G."&&7$,'8)6&'<#'*$G-55&6*0$J#/6')'>C$!;*$!24*++5!02!'0#0'$'!0/)+!)J+!C24*++52DJ0)*0/D(D24*++5E!0/!+%'$%!)+!4%$()$!8+%$!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!45+2$!6+/'2!)+!'$#$5+9!6$)J$$/!)$(4*$%2!(/'!2),'$/)2=!!B!4+89%$*$/20#$!95(/!)+!(''%$22!2),'$/)2L!/$$'2!*$592!9%$#$/)!'0240950/$!9%+65$82!J0)*!9%+-%(82!0/45,'0/-o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

,++#.*)8#$B(-7*$J#/6')'>$/'($%&77/=&6/*)&'C$!;$(4*$%2!6$/$70)!7%+8!@a!*(57D'(&2!+7!2)(77!'$#$5+98$/)!(/'!70#$DJ$$?!J+%?2*+92!0/!)*$!2,88$%=!!_$J!)$(4*$%2!(%$!8$/)+%$'!6&!(!'$20-/()$'!)$(4*$%!8$/)+%!(/'!6&!)*$!'$9(%)8$/)!4*(0%=!!B!14*++5!P89%+#$8$/)!;$(8!02!+%-(/0[$'!0/)+!7+,%!%$2$(%4*!(/'!'$#$5+98$/)!)$(82!)*()!'$20-/!2)%()$-0$2!)+!089%+#$!24*++5!4508()$!(/'!)+!*$59!)$(4*$%2!8+%$!$77$4)0#$5&!8(/(-$!45(22%++82=!!

M/<)79$/'($%&<<-')*9$D/6*'#60")50C$!<(%$/)2!9(%)0409()$!0/!)*$!14*++5!P89%+#$8$/)!;$(8!(/'!)*$!<(%$/)!B'#02+%&!V+(%'=!!<(%$/)2!(%$!)%(0/$'!(/'!*0%$'!(2!2,62)0),)$!)$(4*$%2=!!;*$%$!(%$!9*+/$2!0/!$#$%&!45(22%++8!)+!(55+J!)$(4*$%2!)+!4+88,/04()$!%$-,5(%5&!J0)*!9(%$/)2=!!;*$!<;B!+77$%2!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!9(%$/)2!)+!8$$)!)$(4*$%2!(/'!)+!5$(%/!(6+,)!(7)$%!24*++5!(4)0#0)0$2!7+%!2),'$/)2!(/'!7(8050$2=!!

%78?:-.:5S<A<=P-.:5P:9SA!

!! Ra!

Page 49: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! Re!

!P/!(''0)0+/!)+!(#+0'0/-!)*$!+#$%,2$!+7!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/2!6&!

4*(/-0/-!24*++5!4508()$3!24*++52!(%$!,20/-!+)*$%!9%+-%(82!)+!8+'07&!2),'$/)2L!6$*(#0+%=!!H/$!+7!)*$2$!9%+-%(823!)*$!H/DQ(89,2!P/)$%#$/)0+/!<%+-%(83!02!'$24%06$'!0/!'$)(05!0/!B99$/'0O!nPP=!!

;*$!J+%?!0/#+5#$'!0/!2,44$227,55&!)%(/27+%80/-!(!24*++5!4,5),%$!02!(!'(,/)0/-!)(2?!)*()!%$>,0%$2!)*$!4+880)8$/)!+7!)*$!9%0/409(53!)$(4*$%23!2)(773!9(%$/)23!(/'!4+88,/0)&=!!;+!(4*0$#$!)*02!)%(/27+%8()0+/3!(',5)2!8,2)!(/(5&[$!)*$0%!+J/!6$*(#0+%2!(2!J$55!(2!)*$!6$*(#0+%2!+7!)*$0%!2),'$/)2!(/'!6$!+9$/!)+!4*(/-0/-!9%(4)04$2!)*()!8(&!/+!5+/-$%!70)!J0)*!)*$!24*++5d2!+#$%(55!80220+/=!!

B2!+,%!,/'$%2)(/'0/-!+7!$22$/)0(5!$5$8$/)2!0/#+5#$'!0/!8(0/)(0/0/-!2(7$!(/'!0/45,20#$!24*++52!'$$9$/23!4$%)(0/!(%$(2!J055!%$>,0%$!7,%)*$%!(/(5&202=!!U+%!0/2)(/4$3!0)!02!45$(%!)*()!)*$!%+5$!+7!)*$!9%0/409(5!02!90#+)(5!0/!8(?0/-!20-/0704(/)!4*(/-$2=!!]*()!*(99$/2!)+!24*++52!J*$/!)*$%$!02!(!5$('$%2*09!4*(/-$q!!;*$!9%0/409(52!0/!)J+!+7!)*$!)*%$$!24*++52!40)$'!0/!)*02!%$9+%)!*(#$!%$)0%$'!0/!)*$!9(2)!&$(%=!!]055!)*$2$!24*++52!4+/)0/,$!)+!8(0/)(0/!)*$0%!7+4,2!+/!+#$%(55!24*++5!4508()$q!

!B/+)*$%!089+%)(/)!>,$2)0+/!)*()!8$%0)2!45+2$%!$O(80/()0+/!0/#+5#$2!)*$!

%$5()0+/2*09!6$)J$$/!24*++5!4508()$!(/'!(4('$804!(4*0$#$8$/)=!!]*05$!)*02!*(2!/+)!6$$/!)*$!7+4,2!+7!)*02!%$9+%)3!24*++52!4+880))$'!)+!)%(/27+%80/-!)*$!,2$!+7!'0240950/$!(%$!208,5)(/$+,25&!J+%?0/-!)+!089%+#$!)*$!(4('$804!9$%7+%8(/4$!+7!)*$0%!2),'$/)2=!!]$!/$$'!)+!6$))$%!,/'$%2)(/'!*+J!+#$%(55!24*++5!4508()$!089(4)2!5$(%/0/-!0/!)*$!45(22%++8=!!

]*05$!)*$2$!24*++52!'+!/+)!9%+#0'$!(/&!8(-04!7+%8,5(23!)*$&!'+!+77$%!*+9$7,5!65,$9%0/)2!7+%!*+J!9%+-%$22!0/!)*02!'0%$4)0+/!4(/!6$!8('$=!!;*$0%!$O9$%0$/4$23!(5+/-!J0)*!)*+2$!+7!+)*$%!24*++52!,/'$%-+0/-!20805(%!)%(/27+%8()0+/23!4(/!6$!)%$8$/'+,25&!0/2)%,8$/)(5!0/!*$590/-!+)*$%!24*++52!(/'!4+88,/0)0$2!0/!)*$0%!$77+%)2!)+!(4*0$#$!20805(%!-+(52=!!1+'21(4,0)+#)%0&/(30,(/)"-+&)/(32#%&'(5+,0()01+,2&#+(401%#%+/!

!

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

Page 50: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! WX!

+7!)*$!K$9+%)!*0-*50-*)2!5$-(5!022,$2!7+%!)*$!9,%9+2$!+7!2)08,5()0/-!2)%()$-04!)*0/?0/-!(6+,)!,2$!(/'!'$#$5+98$/)!+7!)*$!5(J!0/!)*02!(%$(=!

!

U$'$%(5!5(J2!9%+#0'$!(/!0/4+895$)$!9()4*J+%?!+7!5$-(5!9%+)$4)0+/2!(-(0/2)!)*$!089+20)0+/!+7!*(%2*!24*++5!'0240950/(%&!8$(2,%$2=!!F(/&!7$'$%(5!4+,%)2!6$/'!+#$%!6(4?J(%'2!)+!'$7$%!)+!'0240950/(%&!'$4020+/2!6&!24*++5!+77040(52=!!M+J$#$%3!(!7$J!4+,%)23!9$%*(92!%$29+/'0/-!)+!)*$!-%+J0/-!)%$/'!0/!*(%2*!2(/4)0+/2!7+%!0//+4,+,2!4+/',4)3!*(#$!2)(%)$'!)+!-0#$!)*$!5(J2!8+%$!)$$)*=!!U+%!$O(895$3!0/!+/$!4(2$!2)%0?0/-!'+J/!(/!0/75$O065$3!8(/'()+%&!$O9,520+/!+7!(!2),'$/)!J*+!'0'!/+)!?/+J!)*()!(!7%0$/'!*('!95(4$'!(!?/07$!0/!*02!4(%L2!-5+#$!6+O3!(!7$'$%(5!4+,%)!9%+45(08$'o!C:$%+!*+,%!*(2!0/'$$'!(%%0#$'!7+%!)*$!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!9+504&=E^e!

!;*02!2$4)0+/!9%+#0'$2!(/!+#$%#0$J!+7!)*$!)*%$$!4()$-+%0$2!+7!7$'$%(5!%0-*)2!

)*()!(99$(%!)+!*(#$!)*$!8+2)!9+)$/)0(5!7+%!(8$50+%()0/-!2+8$!+7!)*$!*(%2*$2)!4+/2$>,$/4$2!+7!)*$!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!)%$/'o!@T!9%+)$4)0+/2!(-(0/2)!'024%080/()0+/!+/!)*$!6(202!+7!4+5+%!+%!/()0+/(5!+%0-0/3!AT!%0-*)2!+7!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$23!(/'!RT!)*$!',$!9%+4$22!%0-*)2!(99504(65$!)+!(55!2),'$/)2=!!;*02!2$4)0+/!(52+!2,88(%0[$2!)*$!2)%()$-04!9+)$/)0(5!+7!$(4*!2$)!+7!5(J2=!!B!8+%$!'$)(05$'!)%$()8$/)!+7!)*$!5$-(5!'+4)%0/$!(/'!$/7+%4$8$/)!2&2)$82!02!2$)!+,)!0/!B99$/'0O!PP3!J*04*!(52+!0/45,'$2!(!6%0$7!'024,220+/!+7!',$!9%+4$22!9%+)$4)0+/2!,/'$%!2)()$!5(J2=! ! !!

.:58<C<7<5=A-5=-$9B<9;-&<AB:<S<=97<5=!!

!!;*$!U+,%)$$/)*!B8$/'8$/)!)+!)*$!./0)$'!1)()$2!Q+/2)0),)0+/!(/'!;0)5$!nP3!(!9%+#020+/!+7!)*$!Q0#05!K0-*)2!B4)!+7!@e^W3!$(4*!9%+*060)!'024%080/()0+/!+/!)*$!6(202!+7!%(4$3!4+5+%3!+%!/()0+/(5!+%0-0/=!!;*$!Q+/2)0),)0+/!(9950$2!)+!(55!9,6504!24*++5!2&2)$823!J*05$!;0)5$!nP!(9950$2!)+!(/&!24*++5!2&2)$8!%$4$0#0/-!C7$'$%(5!70/(/40(5!(2202)(/4$3E!(!4%0)$%0+/!J*04*!$/4+89(22$2!#0%),(55&!(55!9,6504!24*++52=!!!!

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

Page 51: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! W@!

4+5+%!J$%$!)%$()$'!'077$%$/)5&!)*(/!20805(%5&!20),()$'!J*0)$!2),'$/)2!8(&!6$!089+22065$!20/4$!)*+2$!J*0)$!2),'$/)2!J$%$!/$#$%!%$7$%%$'!7+%!(/&!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/=!!!!!

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

;0)5$!nP!+7!)*$!Q0#05!K0-*)2!B4)!+7!@e^W3!)*%+,-*!0)2!%$-,5()0+/23!0/4+%9+%()$2!(!5$-(5!2)(/'(%'!?/+J/!(2!)*$!C('#$%2$!089(4)E!'+4)%0/$=!!./'$%!)*$!('#$%2$!089(4)!'+4)%0/$3!J*$/!(!%(40(55&!C/$,)%(5E!9+504&!+%!9%(4)04$!9%+',4$2!(!'029%+9+%)0+/()$5&!*(%87,5!089(4)!+/!2),'$/)2!+7!4+5+%3!)*$!6,%'$/!2*07)2!)+!)*$!24*++5!2&2)$8!)+!G,2)07&!0)2!9+504&!+%!9%(4)04$!,/'$%!(!%$5()0#$5&!*0-*!2)(/'(%'=!!;*$!('#$%2$!089(4)!'+4)%0/$!J(2!('+9)$'!6&!)*$!1,9%$8$!Q+,%)!0/!)*$!5(/'8(%?!4(2$!+7!P6)>>0$82$F-;#$D&:#6!0/!@e`@3!0/!(/!+90/0+/!J%0))$/!6&!)*$/!Q*0$7!f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

P7!#0-+%+,25&!$/7+%4$'3!)*$!('#$%2$!089(4)!2)(/'(%'!,/'$%!;0)5$!n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

Page 52: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! WA!

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

;*$%$!*(#$!6$$/!7$J!4+,%)!4(2$2!(995&0/-!;0)5$!nPL2!('#$%2$!089(4)!2)(/'(%'!)+!24*++5!'0240950/$!2&2)$82=!!]*05$!)*$!%$2,5)2!+7!)*$!4+,%)!4(2$2!(%$!80O$'3!)*02!(%$(!+7!5(J!*(2!)*$!9+)$/)0(5!)+!'$#$5+9!0/)+!(!20-/0704(/)!9%+)$4)0+/!(-(0/2)!6%,)(5!'0240950/$!2&2)$82!)*()!9%+',4$!*(%87,5!%(40(5!089(4)2=!!;0)5$!nP!50)0-()0+/!02!/+!9(/(4$(3!6,)!0)!02!(!5$-(5!)++5!)*()!0/!(99%+9%0()$!7(4),(5!20),()0+/2!8(&!6$!$O)%$8$5&!,2$7,5=!!!

;*$!H7704$!7+%!Q0#05!K0-*)2!SHQKT!+7!)*$!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/!02!%$29+/2065$!7+%!$/7+%40/-!;0)5$!n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

H/$!6$/$7040(5!%$2,5)!+7!(995&0/-!;0)5$!nPL2!('#$%2$!089(4)!2)(/'(%'!02!)+!/,'-$!24*++5!2&2)$82!)+J(%'!8+%$!9+20)0#$!(99%+(4*$2!)+!)$(4*0/-!(/'!'0240950/$!)*()!9%+',4$!6$))$%!$',4()0+/(5!+,)4+8$2!+#$%(55=!!HQKL2!(4)0+/!+/!

Page 53: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! WR!

+/$!4+895(0/)!9%+#0'$2!(!-5088$%!+7!J*()!02!9+22065$=!!B4)0/-!+/!(!@ee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

;*$!B5(8$'(!4(2$!055,2)%()$2!)*$!9+)$/)0(5!+7!HQK!;0)5$!nP!$/7+%4$8$/)!)+!9%+',4$!+,)4+8$2!)*()!('#(/4$!%(40(5!G,2)04$!(/'!6$/$70)!2),'$/)2!(/'!24*++52=!!./7+%),/()$5&3!)*02!)&9$!+7!$/7+%4$8$/)!(99$(%2!)+!6$!(/!0//+#()0#$!$O4$9)0+/3!%()*$%!)*(/!4+88+/!9%(4)04$3!7+%!HQK=!!B/'3!$#$/!)*$!B5(8$'(!4(2$!055,2)%()$2!HQKL2!)080'0)&!(6+,)!$#$/!8$/)0+/0/-!)*$!('#$%2$!089(4)!'+4)%0/$!(/'!%$-,5()0+/2=!!

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nP!)+!9%+)$4)=!!H/$!9+22065$!('#+4(4&!2)%()$-&!J+,5'!6$!7+%!(4)0#02)2!)+!4++%'0/()$!)*$!7050/-!+7!(/!0/4%$(2$'!/,86$%!+7!2)%+/-!4+895(0/)2!J0)*!HQK3!4+,95$'!J0)*!9%$22,%$!+/!HQK!)+!089%+#$!0)2!$/7+%4$8$/)!9%(4)04$2=!!!!

1?P9;-$<P87A-5K-/76>?=7A-M<78-/O?B<9;-"??>A-

!;*%$$!7$'$%(5!2)(),)$2!9%+#0'$!6(204!9%+)$4)0+/2!7+%!2),'$/)2!J0)*!

'02(6050)0$2=!!;*$!P/'0#0',(52!J0)*!Z02(6050)0$2!0/!"',4()0+/!B4)!SPZ"BT!02!29$40704(55&!)(%-$)$'!)+J(%'!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!(/'!)*$0%!7(8050$23!J*05$!)*$!B8$%04(/2!J0)*!Z02(6050)0$2!B4)!+7!@eeX!(/'!)*$!K$*(6050)()0+/!B4)!+7!@e`R!9%+*060)!'024%080/()0+/!(-(0/2)!9$%2+/2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$23!0/45,'0/-!2),'$/)2=!!!!

;*$!PZ"B!9%+#0'$2!)*$!8+2)!4+89%$*$/20#$!2$)!+7!%0-*)2!7+%!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2=!;*$!4+%$!+7!)*02!5(J!8(/'()$2!)*()!24*++5!2&2)$82!9%+#0'$!(!

Page 54: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! WW!

7%$$!(/'!(99%+9%0()$!9,6504!$',4()0+/!)+!(55!4*05'%$/!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!0/!)*$!5$(2)!%$2)%04)0#$!$/#0%+/8$/)=!!;*$!B4)L2!24*++5!'0240950/$!9%+)$4)0+/2!(%$!'$20-/$'!)+!2$%#$!)*$!+#$%(55!-+(5!+7!7,55!0/45,20+/!+7!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!0/!9,6504!$',4()0+/=!!"(4*!2)()$!*(2!0)2!+J/!2$)!+7!5(J2!(/'!%$-,5()0+/2!)+!0895$8$/)!PZ"B!(/'!8,2)!8(0/)(0/!(!8$4*(/028!7+%!('80/02)%()0#$!'029,)$!%$2+5,)0+/!)*()!4+8950$2!J0)*!)*$!B4)L2!%$>,0%$8$/)2=!

!]*05$!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!4(/!6$!*$5'!)+!8+2)!-$/$%(55&!(99504(65$!

2)(/'(%'2!+7!4+/',4)!(/'!2,6G$4)$'!)+!'0240950/$!7+%!0/7%(4)0+/23!PZ"B!%$4+-/0[$2!)*()!(!2),'$/)2L!'02(6050)&!8(&!4+/)%06,)$!)+!(!4*05'L2!$/-(-$8$/)!0/!2+8$!)&9$2!+7!8024+/',4)=!!P7!(!2),'$/)L2!8024+/',4)!02!4(,2$'!6&!)*$!'02(6050)&!+%!6&!)*$!24*++5!2&2)$8L2!7(05,%$!)+!9%+#0'$!(99%+9%0()$!2$%#04$2!(/'!2,99+%)2!)+!(''%$22!)*$!089(4)!+7!)*$!'02(6050)&3!)*$!2&2)$8L2!9+J$%!)+!089+2$!'0240950/$!02!5080)$'=!!!!!!

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

]*$/!)*$!2),'$/)L2!8024+/',4)!02!/+)!4(,2$'!6&!*02!+%!*$%!'02(6050)&3!)*$!-$/$%(5!'0240950/(%&!2(/4)0+/3!0/45,'0/-!2,29$/20+/!+%!$O9,520+/3!8(&!6$!089+2$'!+/!(!2),'$/)!J0)*!(!'02(6050)&=!!M+J$#$%3!$#$/!0/!)*02!20),()0+/3!PZ"B!9%+#0'$2!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!J0)*!(!%0-*)!/+)!(#(05(65$!)+!(55!2),'$/)2!p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

P/!(''0)0+/!)+!C8(/07$2)()0+/!*$(%0/-2E!(/'!+)*$%!5$-(5!(#$/,$2!(#(05(65$!)+!0/'0#0',(5!2),'$/)23!2&2)$804!4*(55$/-$2!)+!(!2&2)$8!+7!'0240950/$!)*()!#0+5()$2!)*$!%0-*)2!+7!29$40(5!/$$'2!2),'$/)2!4(/!6$!$77$4)0#$!0/!2+8$!20),()0+/2=!!"O(895$2!+7!2&2)$804!#0+5()0+/2!(%$!9%(4)04$2!)*()!(77$4)!5(%-$!/,86$%2!+7!29$40(5!$',4()0+/!2),'$/)23!2,4*!(2!(!4()$-+%04(5!%,5$!(220-/0/-!(55!4*05'%$/!J0)*!$8+)0+/(5!'02+%'$%2!)+!29$40(5!45(22%++82!+%!(!9())$%/!+7!7(050/-!)+!

Page 55: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! W\!

'0(-/+2$!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!(/'!9%+#0'$!)*$8!J0)*!)*$!5$-(55&!%$>,0%$'!2$%#04$2!(/'!9%+)$4)0+/2=!!!!

1$4)0+/!\XW!9%+#0'$2!9%+)$4)0+/2!(-(0/2)!'0240950/(%&!9%(4)04$2!J0)*!(!'029%+9+%)0+/()$!('#$%2$!089(4)!+/!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!)*()!-$/$%(55&!80%%+%!)*$!('#$%2$!089(4)!2)(/'(%'!(9950$'!,/'$%!;0)5$!nP=!!P/!(''0)0+/3!PZ"B!%$-,5()0+/2!%$>,0%$!%$4+%'!?$$90/-!(/'!8+/0)+%0/-!+7!)*$!%(40(5!089(4)!+7!)*$!0'$/)0704()0+/!(/'!95(4$8$/)!+7!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$23!J*04*!4+#$%2!5+/-D)$%8!2,29$/20+/23!$O9,520+/23!(/'!)*$!95(4$8$/)!+7!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2!0/)+!(5)$%/()0#$!24*++52=!!

U0/(55&3!-0#$/!)*$!0/4%$(2$'!%+,)0/-!+7!2),'$/)2!0/)+!)*$!4%080/(5!G,2)04$!2&2)$83!0)!02!/+)$J+%)*&!)*()!PZ"B!*(2!6$$/!*$5'!)+!5080)!(!24*++5!2&2)$8L2!(6050)&!)+!4+88$/4$!4%080/(5!9%+4$$'0/-2!(-(0/2)!2),'$/)2!J0)*!'02(6050)0$2=!!!

!P/!2,83!7$'$%(5!5(J!9%+#0'$2!(!95$)*+%(!+7!9%+)$4)0+/2!7+%!4*05'%$/!J0)*!

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

Page 56: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! W^!

#8?-(5=A7<767<5=9;-$<P87-75-)&6?-.:5B?AA0-

!;*$!Z,$!<%+4$22!Q5(,2$!+7!)*$!U+,%)$$/)*!B8$/'8$/)3!J*04*!(9950$2!)+!

)*$!2)()$2!(/'!(55!)*$0%!2,6'0#020+/23!9%+#0'$2!%$(5!6,)!5080)$'!9%+)$4)0+/2!)+!2),'$/)2!50#0/-!,/'$%![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2=!!

;*$!4+/4$9)!+7!C',$!9%+4$22E!*(2!)J+!'02)0/4)!4+89+/$/)2=!!;*$!70%2)3!9%+4$',%(5!',$!9%+4$223!%$>,0%$2!2)()$2!(/'!)*$0%!5+4(5!-+#$%/8$/)(5!2,6'0#020+/2!)+!9%+#0'$!7(0%!(/'!('$>,()$!9%+4$',%$2!7+%!'$)$%80/0/-!J*$/!)*$&!J055!'$9%0#$!(!9$%2+/!+7!507$3!506$%)&3!+%!9%+9$%)&=!!;*$!2$4+/'!(29$4)!+7!)*$!Z,$!<%+4$22!Q5(,2$3!2,62)(/)0#$!',$!9%+4$223!02!4+/4$%/$'!J0)*!J*$)*$%!(!2)()$!8(&!089(0%!(!-0#$/!%0-*)3!%$-(%'5$22!+7!)*$!7(0%/$22!+7!)*$!9%+4$',%$2!$895+&$'=!!

!U+%!9,%9+2$2!+7!9%+4$',%(5!',$!9%+4$22!(/(5&2023!)*$!%0-*)!)+!(!9,6504!

$',4()0+/!02!4+/20'$%$'!(!C7,/'(8$/)(5E!9%+9$%)&!%0-*)!-%(/)$'!6&!)*$!2)()$2=!!M+J$#$%3!)*$!2(8$!0/)$%$2)!0/!(44$22!)+!9,6504!$',4()0+/!02!/+)!4+/20'$%$'!C7,/'(8$/)(5E!7+%!9,%9+2$2!+7!2,62)(/)0#$!',$!9%+4$22=!!;*,23!)*$!9%+4$',%(5!9%+)$4)0+/2!9%+#0'$'!6&!)*$!Z,$!<%+4$22!Q5(,2$!)$/'!)+!6$!2)%+/-$%!(/'!-0#$/!8+%$!J$0-*)!6&!)*$!4+,%)2!)*(/!)*$!2,62)(/)0#$!9%+)$4)0+/2=!

$

D6&.#(-6/7$(-#$56&.#00=!!;*$!9%+4$',%(5!$5$8$/)!+7!',$!9%+4$22!-+#$%/2!022,$2!2,4*!(2!)*$!)&9$!+7!*$(%0/-!)*()!02!%$>,0%$'!6$7+%$!(/!('#$%2$!(4)0+/!4(/!6$!)(?$/3!J*$)*$%!)*$%$!02!(!%0-*)!)+!4+,/2$53!(/'!)*$!$#0'$/4$!)*()!4(/!6$!4+/20'$%$'=!!;*$!9%+4$',%$2!%$>,0%$'!9%0+%!)+!2,29$/'0/-!(!2),'$/)!7+%!)$/!+%!7$J$%!'(&2!(%$!0/7+%8(5!(/'!7(0%5&!8$(-$%=!!M+J$#$%3!8+%$!7+%8(5!9%+4$',%$2!(/'!-%$()$%!%0-*)2!(44%,$!J*$/!(!5+/-$%!2,29$/20+/!+%!$O9,520+/!02!()!022,$=!

!;*$!%0-*)!)+!(!*$(%0/-3!9(%)04,5(%5&!)*$!8+%$!7+%8(5!9%+4$',%$2!%$>,0%$'!

7+%!'$9%0#()0+/2!5+/-$%!)*(/!)$/!'(&23!4(/!6$!(!#(5,(65$!8$4*(/028!7+%!4*(55$/-0/-!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2=!!B!*$(%0/-!J055!()!5$(2)!9%+#0'$!)*$!2),'$/)!(/!+99+%),/0)&!)+!2*+J!)*()!*$!'0'!/+)!4+880)!)*$!0/7%(4)0+/!4*(%-$'=!!M+J$#$%3!24*++5!+77040(52!4(/!(52+!,2$!*$(%0/-2!)+!2+50'07&!)*$0%!4(2$!(-(0/2)!)*$!2),'$/)=!!;*$!0/7+%8(5!*$(%0/-!%$>,0%$'!7+%!2*+%)!2,29$/20+/23!0/!J*04*!)*$!2),'$/)!+7)$/!'+$2!/+)!*(#$!(!%0-*)!)+!4+,/2$5!+%!$#$/!)*$!9%$2$/4$!+7!(!9(%$/)3!02!9(%)04,5(%5&!7%(,-*)!J0)*!+99+%),/0)0$2!7+%!24*++5!+77040(52!)+!$O$%)!9%$22,%$!+/!)*$!2),'$/)!)+!C4+/7$22=E!

!P/!2+8$!4(2$23!9%+4$',%(5!',$!9%+4$22!(52+!%$>,0%$2!)*$!*$(%0/-!(/'!

'0240950/(%&!'$4020+/!)+!0/45,'$!(/!0/'0#0',(50[$'!4+/20'$%()0+/!%$-(%'0/-!)*$!(99%+9%0()$!9,/02*8$/)=!!]*05$!)*$!Z,$!<%+4$22!Q5(,2$!'+$2!/+)!9%$#$/)!24*++5!6+(%'2!7%+8!('+9)0/-!(/'!(995&0/-!8(/'()+%&!9,/02*8$/)23!0)!'+$2!%$>,0%$!0/'0#0',(50[$'!)%$()8$/)!J*$/!2)()$!5(J!+%!24*++5!6+(%'!9+504&!(55+J2!7+%!4(2$D6&D4(2$!'$)$%80/()0+/2!+%!8+'0704()0+/!+7!8(/'()+%&!9$/(5)0$2=!!P/!)*$2$!20),()0+/23!J*04*!(%$!4+88+/!(4%+22!)*$!707)&!2)()$23!24*++5!6+(%'2!8(&!

Page 57: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! W`!

/+)!20895&!'$7$%!)+!(!J%0))$/!+%!,/J%0))$/![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+504&!+%!)+!)*$!%$4+88$/'()0+/!+7!+)*$%!24*++5!+77040(52!2,4*!(2!)*$!9%0/409(5=!!P/2)$('3!(2!9(%)!+7!8(?0/-!(/!0/'$9$/'$/)!'0240950/(%&!'$4020+/3!)*$!24*++5!6+(%'!S+%!$>,0#(5$/)!'$4020+/8(?0/-!6+'&T!8,2)!4+/20'$%!)*$!/(),%$!+7!)*$!+77$/2$Y!)*$!2),'$/)L2!(-$3!%$4+%'3!(/'!9(2)!6$*(#0+%Y!(/'!(/&!80)0-()0/-!7(4)+%2=!!

!;*$!(6050)&!)+!4*(55$/-$!8(/'()+%&!089+20)0+/!+7!*(%2*!9,/02*8$/)!(/'!

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

$

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

!1$4+/'3!2),'$/)2!(%$!9%+)$4)$'!7%+8!9,/02*8$/)2!)*()!(%$!C0%%()0+/(5=E!!

;*02!02!(!5$/0$/)!2)(/'(%'!)*()!+7)$/!5$('2!4+,%)2!)+!'$7$%!)+!24*++5!'02)%04)!'$4020+/23!$#$/!J*$/!)*+2$!'$4020+/2!(%$!$O)%$8$5&!*(%2*!(/'!)*$!9,/02*8$/)!02!'029%+9+%)0+/()$!)+!)*$!0/7%(4)0+/=!!;*$!5$-(5!2)(/'(%'!-$/$%(55&!02!2)()$'!(2!9%+*060)0/-!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2!)*()!(%$!C-%+225&!'029%+9+%)0+/()$E!)+!)*$!+77$/2$!+%!J*$%$!)*$!'029(%0)&!6$)J$$/!)*$!+77$/2$!(/'!)*$!9,/02*8$/)!02!C2*+4?0/-=E!

!Z$290)$!)*$!)$/'$/4&!+7!4+,%)2!)+!'$7$%!)+!24*++5!+77040(52!0/!(995&0/-!)*$!

%()0+/(50)&!2)(/'(%'!+7!2,62)(/)0#$!',$!9%+4$223!5(J&$%2!(/'!(4)0#02)2!2*+,5'!4+/20'$%!2)%()$-0$2!)+!4+/#0/4$!4+,%)2!)+!9,)!8+%$!)$$)*!0/)+!)*$!2,62)(/)0#$!',$!9%+4$22!%()0+/(50)&!%$#0$J=!!<(%)04,5(%5&!(2!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!9%+',4$!8+%$!(/'!8+%$!$O(895$2!+7!$-%$-0+,2!'0240950/(%&!'$4020+/2!)*()!2$$8!)+!8(/&!)+!6$!6+)*!C2*+4?0/-E!(/'!C-%+225&!'029%+9+%)0+/()$3E!)*$%$!J055!6$!+99+%),/0)0$2!)+!9%$2$/)!4+,%)2!J0)*!#$%&!4+89$550/-!7(4)!9())$%/2=!!!!

$

G*/*#$F-#$D6&.#00$%7/)<0=!!;*$!4+/2)0),)0+/2!(/'!5(J2!+7!8(/&!2)()$2!9%+#0'$!(!*0-*$%!5$#$5!+7!',$!9%+4$22!9%+)$4)0+/2!)*(/!)*$!.=1=!Q+/2)0),)0+/=!!]*05$!7,55!)%$()8$/)!+7!2)()$!5(J2!02!6$&+/'!)*$!24+9$!+7!)*02!K$9+%)3!)*+2$!5(J2!9%+#0'$!(!#(5,(65$!2$)!+7!9%+)$4)0+/2!)*()!2*+,5'!6$!7,55&!$O95+%$'!6&!2),'$/)2!

Page 58: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! Wa!

7(40/-!9,/02*8$/)!,/'$%![$%+!)+5$%(/4$!9+5040$2=!!U,%)*$%8+%$3!9+504&!8(?$%2!2*+,5'!4+/2,5)!2)()$!5(J2!7+%!0'$(2!)+!%$9504()$!0/!+)*$%!2)()$2!(/'!)+!2$$?!)+!0/4+%9+%()$!0/)+!7$'$%(5!5(J2=-

-/797?-@9=>97?>-4?:5-#5;?:9=B?-

!F+2)!1)()$2!*(#$!9(22$'!5(J2!8(/'()0/-!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$=!!;*$2$!1)()$!

5(J2!$2)(6502*!-%+,/'2!7+%!2,29$/20+/2!(/'!$O9,520+/3!J*$)*$%!2),'$/)2!2*+,5'!6$!%$7$%%$'!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$23!(/'!,9+/!J*()!-%+,/'2=!!U,%)*$%8+%$3!0/!(/!$77+%)!)+!8+/0)+%!)*$!,2$!+7!'0240950/(%&!8$(2,%$23!2+8$!1)()$2!*(#$!9(22$'!'()(!4+55$4)0+/!5(J2=!

$

@#/0&'0$+&6$F)0.)57)'#!!F(/&!1)()$2!9(22$'!5(J2!)*()!$2)(6502*!)*$!%$(2+/2!7+%!J*04*!2),'$/)2!

8(&!6$!2,29$/'$'!+%!$O9$55$'=!!H7!4+,%2$3!0/!8+2)!G,%02'04)0+/23!14*++5!Z02)%04)2!8(&!$2)(6502*!'0240950/(%&!9+5040$2!)*()!(%$!8,4*!8+%$!$O9(/20#$!)*(/!1)()$!5(J2=!

!B99$/'0O!PPP!02!(!2,%#$&!+7!2)()$!5(J2!0'$/)07&0/-!)*$!4+/',4)!7+%!J*04*!

1)()$2!2(/4)0+/!2,29$/20+/2!+%!$O9,520+/2=!!!s!! W@!1)()$2!*(#$!5(J2!$2)(6502*0/-!-%+,/'2!7+%!2,29$/20+/Y!We!

$2)(6502*!-%+,/'2!7+%!$O9,520+/=!s!! B55!+7!)*$!1)()$2!*(#$!5(J2!9$%80))0/-!$O9,520+/!7+%!9+22$220+/!+7!

70%$(%823!J$(9+/23!+%!'$('5&!J$(9+/2=!!H/5&!@a!1)()$2!*(#$!5(J2!29$407&0/-!9+22$220+/3!,2$3!+%!'02)%06,)0+/!+7!'%,-2!(2!-%+,/'2!7+%!$O9,520+/=!!H)*$%!-%+,/'2!7+%!$O9,520+/!0/45,'$!J0557,5!+%!4+/)0/,$'!'$70(/4$!+7!(,)*+%0)&!+%!'02%,9)0#$!6$*(#0+%!S@X!1)()$2T!(/'!*(60),(5!9%+7(/0)&!SA!1)()$2T=!

s! j%+,/'2!7+%!2,29$/20+/!0/45,'$!(22(,5)3!9+22$220+/!+7!(!9(-0/-!'$#04$3!*()$!#0+5$/4$3!$O)+%)0+/3!#0+5$/4$!(-(0/2)!24*++5!+77040(53!2$O,(5!*(%(228$/)3!)+6(44+!(/'!(54+*+5!,2$3!-(/-!8$86$%2*093!'02+6$'0$/4$3!'$70(/4$!+7!(,)*+%0)&3!9%+7(/0)&3!(/'!'02%,9)0#$!6$*(#0+%=!$

$

Page 59: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! We!

J/:$,'+&6.#<#'*$@#+#66/70!!B!-%+J0/-!/,86$%!+7!2),'$/)2!(%$!%$7$%%$'!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2!

7+%!4+/',4)!0/!24*++5=!!;*$2$!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2!8(&!0/45,'$!9+504$!'$9(%)8$/)2!+%!G,#$/05$!4+,%)2=!!;*$%$!(%$!WR!1)()$2!)*()!%$>,0%$!24*++5!+77040(52!)+!%$9+%)!2),'$/)2!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2=!!S1$$!B99$/'0O!Pn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

$

F/*/$%&77#.*)&'!P/!(/!$77+%)!)+!8+/0)+%!)*$!+#$%,2$!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$23!('#+4()$23!

-+#$%/8$/)!+77040(523!(/'!9+504&8(?$%2!8,2)!6$!$>,099$'!J0)*!'()(=!!B99$/'0O!n!2,88(%0[$2!'0240950/$!'()(!4+55$4)0+/!%$>,0%$8$/)2=!!Z()(!4+55$4)0+/!#(%0$2!6&!1)()$=!

!s!A`!1)()$2!%$>,0%$!4+55$4)0+/!+7!'0240950/$!'()(!6&!)&9$!+7!+77$/2$r4+/',4)=!s!@@!1)()$2!%$>,0%$!4+55$4)0+/!+7!'0240950/$!'()(!6&!%(4$=!s!@@!1)()$2!%$>,0%$!4+55$4)0+/!+7!'0240950/$!'()(!6&!-$/'$%=!!./7+%),/()$5&3!'()(!4+55$4)0+/!02!0/4+/202)$/)!(/'3!0/!2+8$!0/2)(/4$23!

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

Page 60: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \X!

(%"(1'/!%"!!P/!)*$!J(?$!+7!(!2$%0$2!+7!)%(-04!24*++5!2*++)0/-2!0/!+,%!9,6504!24*++523!

9+504&8(?$%2!(/'!24*++5!+77040(52!*(#$!,/'$%2)(/'(65&!)(?$/!2)$92!)+!$/2,%$!)*$!2(7$)&!+7!+,%!4*05'%$/=!!M+J$#$%3!0/!)*$!%,2*!)+!8(?$!(/!088$'0()$!%$29+/2$3!%*$)+%04!*(2!J+/!+#$%!4+88+/2$/2$=!!;*$!%$2,5)o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

!H6#0+,25&!)$(4*$%2!(/'!('80/02)%()+%2!/$$'!)+!%$)(0/!)*$!(,)*+%0)&!)+!

%$8+#$!2),'$/)2!J*+!$/'(/-$%!)*$!2(7$)&!+7!)*$82$5#$2!(/'!+)*$%2=!!M+J$#$%3!(2!)*$!$O(895$2!J$!*(#$!9%+#0'$'!055,2)%()$3!/$$'5$225&!*(%2*!8$(2,%$2!(%$!6$0/-!)(?$/!(-(0/2)!2),'$/)2!J*+!9+2$!/+!)*%$()!J*()2+$#$%!)+!)*$!24*++5!+%!)+!+)*$%2Y!(55!,/'$%!)*$!-,02$!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$=!!B!C+/$!20[$!70)2!(55E!(99%+(4*!02!0/(99%+9%0()$!(/'!02!4(,20/-!-%$()!*(%8!)+!8(/&!2),'$/)2!J*+!'$2$%#$!8+%$!4+89(220+/!(/'!(!C2$4+/'!4*(/4$=E!

!;*$%$!(%$!24*++52!J*+!*(#$!%$G$4)$'!)*$!$O)%$8$!9+5040$2!+7!:$%+!

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

$,(%@@,"&*#!%"/!$

M&6$*"#$M#(#6/7$P&8#6'<#'*C$

;*$!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/!2*+,5'!%$>,0%$!(55!24*++5!'02)%04)2!%$4$0#0/-!7$'$%(5!(0'!)+!9%+#0'$!8+%$!4+89%$*$/20#$!40#05!%0-*)2!4+8950(/4$!'()(3!0/45,'0/-!'()(!+/!'0240950/(%&!(4)0+/2!)(?$/!6&!+77$/2$3!J0)*!)*$!%(4$!(/'!'02(6050)&!2)(),2!+7!)*$!4*05'3!(/'!0/7+%8()0+/!+/!%$7$%%(52!)+!5(J!$/7+%4$8$/)!(-$/40$2!7+%!0/D24*++5!4+/',4)=!

Page 61: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \@!

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j$/$%(5!B44+,/)0/-!H7704$!2*+,5'!2),'&!HQKL2!J+%?!+/!%(4$!(/'!'02(6050)&!'024%080/()0+/!0/!)*$!2),'$/)!'0240950/$!(%$/(3!J0)*!29$40(5!())$/)0+/!)+!)*$!$77$4)0#$/$22!+7!9,6504!$',4()0+/!(/'!)$4*/04(5!(2202)(/4$3!)*$!45(%0)&!(/'!4+/202)$/4&!+7!0/)$%/(5!9+5040$23!(/'!)*$!5$/-)*!+7!)08$!7+%!0/#$2)0-()0+/2=!$

M&6$@#0#/6."#60$/'($D6&>6/<$,8/7-/*&60$QE'.7-()'>$!"&0#$4)*")'$M#(#6/7$/'($

G*/*#$B>#'.)#0RC$$

K$2$(%4*!02!/$$'$'!)+!(22$22!)*$!>,(50)&!+7!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!9%+-%(82!(/'!)+!$/2,%$!)*()!)*$&!4+895&!J0)*!7$'$%(5!$',4()0+/!5(J2!(/'!9+5040$2!2,4*!(23!;0)5$!P=!!")*/+-%(9*04!2),'0$2!(%$!/$$'$'!0/!+%'$%!)+!8$(2,%$!)*$!$O)$/)!)+!J*04*!)$(4*$%2!)%$()!80/+%0)&!4*05'%$/!,/7(0%5&!0/!45(22%++82=!$

M&6$G*/*#0$/'($G."&&7$F)0*6).*0C$

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

Page 62: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \A!

!14*++52!2*+,5'!7+%8(55&!8+/0)+%!'0240950/(%&!%$7$%%(523!?$$90/-!4(%$7,5!%$4+%'23!)+!$/2,%$!)*()!)$(4*$%2!(%$!/+)!+#$%%$(4)0/-!)+!2),'$/)!4+/',4)!+%!,/7(0%5&!20/-50/-!+,)!2),'$/)2=!!;$(4*$%2!J*+!$/-(-$!0/!2,4*!9%(4)04$2!2*+,5'!6$!%$>,0%$'!)+!)(?$!(99%+9%0()$!9%+7$220+/(5!'$#$5+98$/)!4+,%2$2!0/!45(22%++8!8(/(-$8$/)3!4*05'!'$#$5+98$/)3!(/'!8,5)0D4,5),%(5!*,8(/!%$5()0+/2=!!j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`X!!1,4*!(!4+880))$$!J+,5'3!()!)*$!%$>,$2)!+7!(!4*05'L2!9(%$/)3!%$#0$J!(!2,29$/20+/!%$4+88$/'()0+/!9%0+%!)+!)*$!4+88$/4$8$/)!+7!)*$!2,29$/20+/!9$%0+'3`@!!(/'!'02(99%+#(5!+7!(!2,29$/20+/!6&!)*$!4+880))$$!J+,5'!65+4?!14*++5!V+(%'!(4)0+/=!!!14*++5!Z02)%04)2!2*+,5'!$2)(6502*!(!Q+88,/0)&!K$#0$J!V+(%'!)+!9%+#0'$!(/!0/'$9$/'$/)3!+,)20'$!J()4*'+-!7,/4)0+/!+/!2),'$/)!'0240950/$!022,$2=`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

Page 63: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \R!

('#$%2$!089(4)!6(2$'!+/!%(4$!+%!'02(6050)&3!4+/4$%/$'!-%+,92!2*+,5'!'024,22!)*$!8())$%!J0)*!)*$!5+4(5!/$J2!8$'0(!(/'!J0)*!24*++5!+77040(52=!P7!'022()0270$'3!)*$&!2*+,5'!088$'0()$5&!705$!(!'024%080/()0+/!4+895(0/)!J0)*!)*$!7$'$%(5!H7704$!7+%!Q0#05!K0-*)2!(/'!9%$22!HQK!7+%!(!)08$5&!0/#$2)0-()0+/=!!!!

Page 64: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \W!

,"&"%#,/---@=!!U+%!9,%9+2$2!+7!)*02!%$9+%)3!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+5040$2!0/45,'$!/+)!+/5&!8(/'()+%&!9,/02*8$/)23!6,)!(52+!*(%2*3!%0-0'!9,/02*8$/)2!)*()!(%$!,/J(%%(/)$'!6$4(,2$!)*$&!7(05!)+!)(?$!0/)+!(44+,/)!40%4,82)(/4$23!0/45,'0/-!2),'$/)2d!'0240950/(%&!%$4+%'2=!!;*$2$!9+5040$2!9,)!4+88+/D2$/2$!(20'$3!0/!7(#+%!+7!(!C)(?$!/+!9%02+/$%2E!())0),'$!)+J(%'!'0240950/$=!

A=!!1)()$8$/)!+7!]0550(8!F+'[$5$2?03!Z0%$4)+%3!1(7$!(/'!Z%,-DU%$$!14*++52!<%+-%(83!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!U$6=!@a3!AXXX=!!CB/!+#$%J*$580/-!8(G+%0)&!+7!24*++52!SeX!9$%4$/)T!'+!/+)!$O9$%0$/4$!(/&!2$%0+,2!#0+5$/)!4%08$3!(/'!/$(%5&!*(57!+7!(55!+,%!24*++52!SWR!9$%4$/)T!$O9$%0$/4$!/+!4%08$!()!(55=E!E(2$P/!(''0)0+/3!4%08$!(/'!#0+5$/4$!0/!24*++52!02!4+/)0/,0/-!)+!'$4%$(2$=!!P'=!

R=!!P/!@eeW3!Q+/-%$22!9(22$'!)*$!U$'$%(5!j,/DU%$$!14*++52!B4)3!AX!.=1=Q=!laeA@3!%$>,0%0/-!2)()$2!)+!9(22!5$-025()0+/!%$>,0%0/-!(!+/$D&$(%!$O9,520+/!7+%!2),'$/)2!4(%%&0/-!70%$(%82!+/!24*++5!9%+9$%)&=!!U(05,%$!)+!4+895&!J+,5'!%$2,5)!0/!5+22!+7!7$'$%(5!7,/'0/-=!

W=!!;*$!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/!'$70/$2!(!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$!<+504&!(2!(!9+504&!)*()!C8(/'()$2!9%$'$)$%80/$'!4+/2$>,$/4$2!+%!9,/02*8$/)2!7+%!29$40704!+77$/2$2=E!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!_()0+/(5!Q$/)$%!7+%!"',4()0+/!1)()02)042!S_Q"1T!(/'!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!f,2)04$3!V,%$(,!+7!f,2)04$!1)()02)0423!E'()./*&60$&+$G."&&7$%6)<#$/'(!G/+#*93$STTT3$B99$/'0O!B3!;(65$!B53!1$9)$86$%!@eee=!!M+J$#$%3!$#$/!)*$!U$'$%(5!j,/DU%$$!14*++52!B4)!#$2)2!24*++5!('80/02)%()+%2!J0)*!'024%$)0+/(%&!9+J$%2!0/!'$)$%80/0/-!)*$!9,/02*8$/)=!!P/!8+2)!0/2)(/4$2!*+J$#$%3!)*02!02!/+)!)*$!9%(4)04$=!

\=!!F/)79$G&-*"*&:'3!F+/'(&3!_+#$86$%!AA3!@eee=!

^=!!CU(4)3!704)0+/!4+550'$!0/!45(22%++83E!A&0*&'$P7&=#3!B9%05!A`3!AXXX=!

`=!!<$'%+!_+-,$%(3!CM+J!1),'$/)!<$%29$4)0#$2!+/!n0+5$/4$!Q(/!V$!.2$'!)+!Q%$()$!1(7$%!14*++523E!E'$U&*)&'!U/>/V)'#3$F(%4*!AXXX=!!B#(05(65$!+/50/$!()!x*))9orrJJJ=0/8+)0+/8(-([0/$=4+8r9$'%+=*)85y=!

a=!!E=)(2!

e=!!1)()$8$/)!+7!1*$%077!V%0'-$23!%7/6)&'$J#(>#63$B,-,2)!R@3!@eee=!

@X=!!.=1=!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!H7704$!7+%!Q0#05!K0-*)23!M/77$STTW$,7#<#'*/69$/'($G#.&'(/69$G."&&7$%)8)7$@)>"*0$%&<57)/'.#$@#5&6*C$X/*)&'/7$/'($G*/*#$D6&Y#.*)&'03!f,/$!AXXX=!

@@=!!U5+%0'(!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!G."&&7$E'()./*&60$@#5&6*3$@eee=!

@A=!!1)()$!+7!]024+/20/3!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!<,6504!P/2)%,4)0+/3!C14*++5!Z0240950/$D1,29$/20+/23E!,(-./*)&'$/*$/$P7/'.#3$B9%05!@eee=!

@R=!!G-05#'(#($,(-./*)&'C$B$D6#7)<)'/69$@#5&6*$&'$*"#$E<5/.*$&+$Z#6&$!&7#6/'.#$&'$%")./>&$D-=7).$G."&&703!j$/$%()0+/!N3!(!9%+G$4)!+7!)*$!1+,)*J$2)!N+,)*!Q+55(6+%()0#$3!40)0/-!Q*04(-+!<,6504!14*++523!"/'!+7!)*$!N$(%!K$9+%)2!)+!P550/+02!1)()$!V+(%'!+7!"',4()0+/3!@eeADeR!)*%+,-*!@eeaDee=!

@W=!!E=)(2!

@\=!!G-05#'(#($,(-./*)&'C$B$D6#7)<)'/69$@#5&6*$&'$*"#$E<5/.*$&+$Z#6&$!&7#6/'.#$&'$%")./>&$D-=7).$

Page 65: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \\!

G."&&7$G*-(#'*03!j$/$%()0+/!N3!(!9%+G$4)!+7!)*$!1+,)*J$2)!N+,)*!Q+55(6+%()0#$3!Q*04(-+3!P550/+023!40)0/-!Q*04(-+!14*++5!K$7+%8!V+(%'!+7!;%,2)$$23!%")./>&$D-=7).$G."&&70C$M[$\]]]$M)'/7$A-(>#*3$14*++52!(/'!K$-0+/2!H6G$4)0#$2=!!@^=!!U5+%0'(!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!V,%$(,!+7!P/2)%,4)0+/(5!1,99+%)!(/'!Q+88,/0)&!1$%#04$23!G*/*#:)(#$@#5&6*$&'$G."&&7$G/+#*9$/'($F)0.)57)'#$F/*/3!F(&!@eee=!

@`=!!F+2)!+7!)*$2$!(/$4'+)$2!%$9+%)!)*$!(4)0+/!%$4+88$/'$'!6&!24*++5!+77040(52=!!P/!2+8$!0/2)(/4$2!)*$!,5)08()$!(4)0+/!)(?$/!8(&!*(#$!6$$/!5$22!2$#$%$!(2!)*$!%$2,5)!+7!)*$!0/#+5#$8$/)!+7!(/!())+%/$&!+%!4+88,/0)&!+%-(/0[()0+/=!

@a=!!%AG$,8#')'>$X#:03$f,/$!a3!AXXX=!

@e=!!,(-./*)&'$X#:03$B9%05!@R3!@eee=!

AX=!!C14*++5!1,29$/20+/o!H,/4$!+7!<%$#$/)0+/!+%!<+,/'!+7!H#$%%$(4)0+/qE!!"#$I/6*+&6($%&-6/'*3$_+#$86$%!@`3!@eee=!

A@=!!!G##$#2>23!Q*05'%$/d2!Z$7$/2$!U,/'3!C14*++5!1,29$/20+/2o!B%$!;*$&!M$590/-!Q*05'%$/q3E!Q(86%0'-$3!FBo!](2*0/-)+/!K$2$(%4*!<%+G$4)!S@e`\TY!Q5(%$/4$!M=!;*+%/)+/!(/'!]0550(8!;=!;%$/)3!C14*++5!Z$2$-%$-()0+/!(/'!1,29$/20+/!0/!"(2)!V()+/!K+,-$!<(%02*o!B!<%$5080/(%&!K$9+%)3E!\`!^&-6'/7$&+$X#>6&$,(-./*)&'$WaA!S@eaaTY!B//(!Q=!F4U(''$/3!j$+%-$!"=!F(%2*!@@3!V(%%0$!f+!<%04$3!(/'!N,/*(/!MJ(/-3!CB!1),'&!+7!K(4$!(/'!j$/'$%!V0(2!0/!)*$!<,/02*8$/)!+7!M(/'04(99$'!Q*05'%$/3E!AW!!"#$_6=/'$@#8)#:$ARe!S@eeATY!w0'2!U0%2)!Q+(50)0+/3!CI+4?$'!H,)o!"O9+20/-!)*$!1,29$/20+/!"90'$804!0/!)*$!H(?5(/'!<,6504!14*++523E!H(?5(/'3!QB!Sf,/$!@eeeT=!!AA=!!Z$9(%)8$/)!+7!"',4()0+/3!H7704$!7+%!Q0#05!K0-*)23!STTW$,7#<#'*/69$/'($G#.&'(/69$G."&&7$%)8)7$@)>"*0$%&<57)/'.#$@#5&6*2$

!AR=!!B9950$'!K$2$(%4*!Q$/)$%3!U/;)'>$*"#$P6/(#C$B$@/.)/7$^-0*).#$@#5&6*$%/6(3!S@eeeTS*$%$0/(7)$%!CBKQ!K$9+%)ET=!

AW=!!_Q"1!K$9+%)3!0-56/3$/+)$!W3!B99$/'0O!B3!;(65$!B72$$E'()./*&60$&+$G."&&7$%6)<#$/'($G/+#*93$STTT2!

A\=!!1+,)*!Q(%+50/(!<,6504!14*++523!G."&&7$%6)<#$E'.)(#'*$@#5&6*3$14*++5!N$(%!@eeaDee=!

A^=!!E=)(2!

A`=!!E=)(2!

Aa=!!G##$/70&3!j(5$!F=!F+%%02+/!(/'!V(%6(%(!ZLP/4(,3!C;*$!]$6!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$o!Q*(%(4)$%02)042!+7!1),'$/)2!]*+!B%$!K$4+88$/'$'!7+%!"O9,520+/!7%+8!14*++53E!,(-./*)&'$/'($!6#/*<#'*$&+$%")7(6#'3$#+5=!AX3!@ee`3!99=!R@^DR\3!K,22!1?06(3!!"#$%&7&6$&+$F)0.)57)'#3!P/'0(/(!./0#$%20)&3!f,/$!AXXX=!

Ae=!!f(8$2!Q+8$%!(/'!B5#0/!U=3!F=Zo!@/)0)'>$A7/.;$%")7(6#'3$@e`D@ea!S@eeAT=!

RX=!!E=)(2!

R@=!!j05!_+(83!w$/'%(!]0//$%!(/'!B/'%$J!K*$0/3!C;*$!M(%#(%'!KBIIN!<%+-%(8!(/'!)*$!<%$#$/)0+/!<%(4)0)0+/$%o!Q+89%$*$/20#$3!14*++5D6(2$'!P/)$%#$/)0+/!)+!1,99+%)!K$2050$/4&!0/!B)DK02?!B'+5$24$/4$E!^&-6'/7$&+$%")7($/'(![&-*"$%/6#$4&6;$n+5=!@D@!@3!S@ee^T3!R^=!

Page 66: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \^!

RA=!!Q+8$%3!@/)0)'>$A7/.;$%")7(6#'3$@ea=!

RR=!!K,22!1?06(!(/'!K$$4$!<$)$%2+/3!!"#$F/6;$G)(#$&+$Z#6&$!&7#6/'.#C$%/'$D-')0"<#'*$J#/($*&$G/+#$G."&&70`!D")$F#7*/$a/55/'!S!f(/,(%&!@eeeT=!

RW=!!P%J0/!M&8(/!(/'!<(8$5(!1/++?=!!F/'>#6&-0$G."&&70$b$4"/*$4#$%/'$F&$B=&-*$*"#$D"90)./7$/'($,<&*)&'/7$B=-0#$&+$H-6$%")7(6#'3$@^@=!!R\=!!1,$!;*+%2+/3!;*$!F0220/-!I0/?o!1),'$/)2!Z024,22!14*++5!Z0240950/$!U+4,2!+/!"O4$9)0+/(5!Q*05'%$/3!#=!Ae3!@ee^3!@D@A=!

R^=!!V%$/'(!;+J/2$/'3!C;*$!Z029%+9+%)0+/()$!Z0240950/$!+7!B7%04(/!B8$%04(/!I$(%/$%2o!K$',40/-!14*++5!1,29$/20+/2!(/'!"O45,20+/23E!,?.#5*)&'/7$%")7(6#'3!n+5=!^^3!_+=!R3!Ra@DRe@=!

R`=!!1,2(/!V5(4?3!CI+4?$'!H,)o!]*&!1,29$/20+/!(/'!"O9,520+/!1*+,5'!V$!N+,%!Q+,%)!+7!I(2)!K$2+%)3E!!"#$B<#6)./'$G."&&7$A&/6($^&-6'/73!Sf(/,(%&!@eeeT=!

Ra=!!Z$K0''$%3!I(J%$/4$!F=!CM+J!1,29$/20+/!(/'!"O9,520+/!Q+/)%06,)$!)+!Z%+990/-!H,)3E!!"#$,(-./*)&'$F)>#0*3!U$6%,(%&!@ee@=!

Re=!!F=!I$$!F(//0/-=!!CZ$#$5+98$/)(55&!K$29+/20#$!F,5)04,5),%(5!"',4()0+/!7+%!N+,/-!B'+5$24$/)23E!%")7("&&($,(-./*)&'3E!#=!`^3!/+=A3!S]0/)$%!@eeerAXXXT=!!WX=!!;*+%2+/3!!"#$U)00)'>$J)';=!

W@=!!!"#$X#:$[&6;$!)<#03$Z$4$86$%!@3!@eee=!

WA=!!j%('$!%$)$/)0+/!+7)$/!%$2,5)2!0/!'%+990/-!+,)=!!G##$I/-0#63$G"&-7($4#$,'($G&.)/7$D6&<&*)&'`$$!6-*"$c$%&'0#1-#'.#03$]+%?0/-!<(9$%!9%$2$/)$'!()!Q+/7$%$/4$!+/!M0-*!1)(?$2!;$2)0/-!29+/2+%$'!6&!;*$!Q0#05!K0-*)2!<%+G$4)!()!M(%#(%'!./0#$%20)&!(/'!Q+5,860(!./0#$%20)&3!Z$4$86$%!W3!@eee=!!WR=!!1?06(3!C;*$!Z(%?!10'$!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$o!Q(/!<,/02*8$/)!I$('!)+!1(7$!14*++52qE!0-56/3!/+)$!RR=!!

WW=!!U+%!$O(895$3!2)()02)042!7+%!I+2!B/-$5$2!7+%!@eeR!0/'04()$'!)*()!a\g!+7!(55!'(&)08$!4%08$2!J$%$!4+880))$'!6&!)%,(/)!&+,)*2=!!1$$!K+/(5'!Z=!1)$9*$/23!v_()0+/(5!;%$/'2!0/!14*++5!n0+5$/4$o!1)()02)042!(/'!<%$#$/)0+/!1)%()$-0$23v!G."&&7!d)&7#'.#$D6#8#'*)&'C$B$D6/.*)./7$I/'(=&&;3$$'2=!B%/+5'!(/'!Q+/+5$&!S@ee`T3!`\=!

W\=!!G##!BKQ!K$9+%)3!0-56/3$/+)$!@a3!40)0/-!)*()!(99%+O08()$5&!\Xg!+7!*0-*!24*++5!'%+9!+,)2!(%$!,/$895+&$'!(/'!^ag!+7!)*$!.=1=!9%02+/!9+9,5()0+/!'%+99$'!+,)!+7!*0-*!24*++5=!

W^=!!F-=-1-#$!#7#>6/5"$I#6/7(3!H4)+6$%!A^3!@ee^=!

W`=!!4/0")'>*&'$!)<#03$$_+#$86$%!AX3!@eee=!

Wa=!!1?06(3!C;*$!Z(%?!10'$!+7!:$%+!;+5$%(/4$3E!a/55/'3!@eee=!

We=!!E=)(2!

\X=!!<$%4$/)(-$!+7!4*05'%$/!$50-065$!7+%!7%$$r%$',4$'!5,/4*!02!(/!0/'04()+%!+7!9+#$%)&!5$#$52=!

Page 67: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \`!

\@=!!F0(80DZ('$!Q+,/)&!<,6504!14*++52!Q+'$!+7!Q+/',4)!8(&!6$!7+,/'!()!x*))9orrJJJ='('$=?@A=75=,2r9(%$/)2y=!

\A=!!E=)(2!

\R=!!E=)(2!()!A=!

\W=!!E=)(=!()!W=!

\\=!!"#$%&!24*++5!0/!F0(80DZ('$!*(2!(!;%,2)!Q+,/2$5+%3!J*+!02!%$29+/2065$!7+%!'%,-!(/'!(54+*+5!(6,2$!4+,/2$50/-=!

\^=!!G##$x*))9orrJJJ=M$(%)8()*=4+8y=!

\`=!!G##$x*))9orrJJJ=9(0%2=4+8y=!

\a=!!;*02!9%+-%(83!20805(%!)+!<(58!19%0/-2!F0''5$!14*++5d2!(5)$%/()0#$!$',4()0+/!9%+-%(83!*(2!&$)!)+!6$!$2)(6502*$'=!

\e=!!;*$!B8$%04(/!P/2)0),)$2!7+%!K$2$(%4*!SBPKT!02!(/!0/'$9$/'$/)3!/+)D7+%D9%+70)!4+%9+%()0+/!)*()!9$%7+%82!6(204!(/'!(9950$'!%$2$(%4*!7+%!450$/)2!)*()!0/45,'$!7$'$%(5!(/'!2)()$!-+#$%/8$/)!(-$/40$23!/+)D7+%D9%+70)!+%-(/0[()0+/23!(/'!9%0#()$!4+%9+%()0+/2=!!;*$!Q$/)$%!7+%!"77$4)0#$!Q+55(6+%()0+/!(/'!<%(4)04$!SQ"Q<T!2,99+%)2!(/'!9%+8+)$2!)*$!9%+',4)0+/3!$O4*(/-$3!(/'!,2$!+7!?/+J5$'-$!(6+,)!$77$4)0#$!9%(4)04$2!7+%!4*05'%$/!(/'!&+,)*!J0)*!$8+)0+/(5!(/'!6$*(#0+%(5!9%+65$82!()!%02?!+7!24*++5!(/'!2+40(5!7(05,%$=!

^X=!!x*))9orrJJJ=(0%=+%-r4$49r-,0'$r(4)0+/-,0'$y=!

^@=!!Q()(5&2)3!C<%+-%(8!5+2$2!2$()2!(2!$O9,520+/2!2+(%3E!U$6%,(%&!@eee=!!B#(05(65$!+/50/$!()!x*))9orrJJJ=4()(5&2)4*04(-+=+%-y=!

^A=!!f,2)04$!F())$%2!P/2)0),)$!02!(!%$2$(%4*r('#+4(4&!+%-(/0[()0+/!'$#+)$'!)+!9%+8+)0/-!2+40(5!G,2)04$!(/'!8,5)0D%(40(5!,/0)&!0/!Q(507+%/0(=!!P)2!"',4()0+/(5!f,2)04$!<%+-%(8!2$$?2!)+!+#$%4+8$!)*$!8(%-0/(50[()0+/!+7!9$+95$!+7!4+5+%!0/!24*++50/-!)*%+,-*!'022$80/()0+/!+7!0/7+%8()0+/!(/'!0'$(23!6,05'0/-!4+88,/0)&!(/'!/$)J+%?23!('#+4(4&3!(/'!9+504&!'$#$5+98$/)=!x*))9orrJJJ=G,2)04$8())$%2=+%-y=!

^R=!!!f,2)04$!F())$%2!P/2)0),)$=!!C;,%/0/-!;+!"(4*!H)*$%3!_+)!H/!"(4*!H)*$%o!M+J!Q+88,/0)0$2!<%$#$/)!K(4028!0/!14*++5!Z0240950/$3E!AXXX=!!^W=!!F05J(,?$$!Q()(5&2)!SFQT!02!(!40)&J0'$!4+(50)0+/!9%$220/-!7+%!$77$4)0#$!24*++5!%$7+%8!)*%+,-*!%$2$(%4*!(/'!('#+4(4&!(/'!02!4,%%$/)5&!'$#$5+90/-!(!%$2+,%4$!-,0'$!(/'!4+88,/0)&!95(/!7+%!0895$8$/)0/-!%$2$(%4*D6(2$'!24*++5!'0240950/$!9%(4)04$2!)*()!?$$9!2),'$/)2!0/!24*++5=!

^\=!!B!)J$/)&D)*%$$!&$(%!+5'!$',4()0+/!%$7+%8!+%-(/0[()0+/!6(2$'!0/!Q*04(-+=!

^^=!!A#0*$D6/.*).#0C$,'0-6)'>$,1-)*/=7#$/'($,++#.*)8#$F)0.)57)'#$*"/*$G-55&6*0$I)>"$B.")#8#<#'*$+&6$B77$G*-(#'*03!F05J(,?$$!Q()(5&2)!(/'!Z$20-/2!7+%!Q*(/-$3!@eee=!!^`=!!P/!(/!$(%50$%!%$2+,%4$!-,0'$!$/)0)5$'3!B.*$&'$*"#$M/.*03$FQ!0'$/)070$'!7+,%!9,6504!24*++52!)*()!J$%$!8(?0/-!9%+-%$22!0/!4%$()0/-!2,44$227,5!,%6(/!24*++52=!!B.*$&'$*"#$M/.*0bD6#00$+&6$*"#$D-=7).$G."&&70$*"/*$4&6;e!!B!@#0&-6.#$P-)(#3!F05J(,?$$!Q()(5&2)!@eea=!

^a=!!!f,2)04$!<+504&!P/2)0),)$3!!CG."&&7"&-0#$I95#C$!:&$[#/60$J/*#3E!SAXXXT=!!B#(05(65$!+/50/$!()!

Page 68: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!!! \a!

x*))9orrJJJ=4G4G=+%-r24*++5*+,2$*&9$y=!

^e=!!G#/7$82$F-'/:/93!_+=!Roe`D4#DA^`!S"=Z=!;$//=!@eeeTS,/%$9+%)$'!8$8+%(/',8!'$4020+/T=!

`X=!;*$!9(%$/)!2$$?0/-!%$#0$J!6&!)*$!'0240950/(%&!4+880))$$!8,2)!J(0#$!)*$!9%0#(4&!%0-*)2!+7!*$%r*02!4*05'=!!`@=!./5$22!0880/$/)!'(/-$%!)+!)*$!2(7$)&!+7!2),'$/)2!(/'!2)(77!$O02)23!+,)D+7D24*++5!2,29$/20+/2!2*+,5'!/+)!6$-0/!,/)05!(7)$%!)*$!Z02)%04)L2!(99$(52!9%+4$22!*(2!6$$/!$O*(,2)$'=!!`A=!1,4*!V+(%'2!J+,5'!6$!8+'$5$'!(7)$%!2,44$227,5!$O(895$2!+7!40#05!%$#0$J!6+(%'2!)*()!8+/0)+%!9+504$!'$9(%)8$/)2!(/'!0/#$2)0-()$!(55$-()0+/2!+7!9+504$!8024+/',4)=!!

Page 69: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""#$%&'(&(

!

! "#$%!&%'#$()*#!+)!&,#!)#-.!(

(/!012!3245!6777!89:;<=/>!?;890@9A!400290@;9!@/!B2@9A!A@C29!0;!012!922=!:;5!4!

52C@2D!;:!01@/!940@;9E/!F855290!/F1;;<!=@/F@G<@92!G54F0@F2/>!@9!G450@F8<45!01;/2!B4/2=!;9!

F4<</!:;5!H"25;!&;<2549F2EI!!(/!D@01!/2C254<!;0125!;9A;@9A!940@;94<!=2B402/!@9C;<C@9A!

@//82/!;:!G8B<@F!/F1;;<!52:;5?>!01@/!0;G@F!14/!F52402=!/;?2!89<@J2<3!4<<@2/!49=!5@C4</I!!

.;?2>!B;4/0@9A!4!1@/0;53!;:!<@B254<@/?!49=!52:;5?>!452!:@9=@9A!012?/2<C2/!45A8@9A!

4<;9A/@=2!F;9/25C40@C2!F;89025G450/I!!-1@<2!;0125/>!=2/G@02!4!1@/0;53!;:!F;<<4B;540@;9>!452!

40!;==/!@9!012!=2B402I!&12!:;<<;D@9A!450@F<2/!F15;9@F<2!012!2C;<C@9A!=@/F8//@;9!4B;80!

H"25;!&;<2549F2E!49=!/F1;;<!=@/F@G<@92I!!!

!

)*+,(-.(/000(K!LM;2/!H"25;!&;<2549F2E!N;!&;;!O45PQ!R3!S@?!.02D450>!"#$!

%&'()(*!+',-.!

%/012345-6!72,829'5-6!14880()3:!213)&)-3-!2(/!43;'5-!,)77!*23;'5!('<3!

,''9!)(!=2-;)(*34(!34!/'>23'!3;'!(4,?14884(!@47)1:!4A!BC'54!D47'52(1'E!

A45!8)->';2&)45!)(!-1;447.!!$48'!(4,!3;)(9!3;)-!)-!2!172--)1!'<28@7'!4A!2!

*44/!)/'2!329'(!344!A25!!!$)<?:'25?47/!!!;2/!2!34'(2)7!17)@@'5!!!BD;)-!

)-!(43!2>403!2!34'(2)7!17)@@'5F!!D;)-!)-!2>403!3;'!23321;8'(3-!4(!2!34'(27!

17)@@'5F!G(!0()/'(3)A)'/!>425/!8'8>'5!)(-)-3'/!!!A40(/!*0)73:!2(/!*)&'(!

2!HI?/2:!-0-@'(-)4(!!!'<10-'!34!*'3!5)/!4A!/)AA)1073!-30/'(3-!!!(4,;'5'!

)-!3;23!845'!'&)/'(3!3;23!284(*!GA5)12(?G8'5)12(!-30/'(3-.!!$48'!

J)--)--)@@)!*)57-!,'5'(E3!K0-3!-0-@'(/'/6!>03!255'-3'/!A45!,;23!2840(3'/!

34!-10AA7)(*!)(!2!;277,2:!!!BD''(2*'5-F!!D:@)127!3''(2*'5-E!!!BD;'-'!

L'54!347'52(1'!@47)1)'-!!!50(!2849.!!D;':E&'!>'148'!344!'<35'8'6E!

21145/)(*!34!M25&25/!N2,!$1;447!O54A'--45!";5)-!%/7':.P!

(

123(/4.(/000(K!LN54=840@;9!-;9E0!#9=!M2F4085!-;2/!$4F@4<!&29/@;9!N;2/!

R23;9=!,@A1!.F1;;<!O@A10Q>!B3!O<399!TF$;B250/>!";)12*4!D5)>0('I!

QD;'!84-3!305>07'(3!-1;447!:'25!)(!R'12305!;)-345:!148'-!34!2!174-'!!!

S7T'2/'5-!4A!3;'!84-37:!,;)3'!'-32>7)-;8'(3!3;23!50(-!R'12305!-2:!3;'!1)3:!

;2-!>'148'!845'!-'(-)3)&'!34!8233'5-!4A!521'!!82(:!>7219-!-2:!3;23!

74(*?-)88'5)(*!521)27!3'(-)4(!)(A728'/!>:!3;'!14(354&'5-:!;2-!4(7:!

,45-'('/.P!

!

123(/5.(/000(K!L.F1;;</!';;J!40!U;<@F3!;9!N89/>!M58A/V!/;?2!@9!U5@9F2!

-@<<@4?!.43!#WG8</@;9!N;2/!&;;!O45Q>!B3!*15@/0@94!(I!.4?82</>!=2-;)(*34(!

O4-3I!

!

! +XY

QU(/'5!O5)(1'!=)77)28E-!14/'!4A!-30/'(3!>';2&)456!-)8)725!34!3;'!14/'-!)(!

82(:!43;'5!=2-;)(*34(!25'2!-1;447!/)-35)13-6!2!@5)(1)@27!80-3!5'1488'(/!

'<@07-)4(!A45!-30/'(3-!,;4!1488)3!1'532)(!/50*!2(/!,'2@4(-!&)4723)4(-.!!

D;'!12-'-!25'!-'(3!34!2!$1;447!#425/!1488)33''6!2(/!3;'!-30/'(3-!25'!

-0-@'(/'/!A548!-1;447!)(!3;'!)(3'5)8!!>425/!8'8>'5-!-2)/!3;':!;2&'!

;'25/!'<@07-)4(!12-'-!)(!,;)1;!3;'!@5)(1)@27!-;407/!;2&'!;2/!7'',2:!34!

)8@4-'!2!7'--'5!@0()-;8'(3!!!'<28@7'-!!!-30/'(3-!>5)(*)(*!34!-1;447!

Page 70: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

34:!,'2@4(-!3;23!17'257:!,'5'!(43!)(3'(/'/!34!>'!2!3;5'236!2(/!-30/'(3-!

@4--'--)(*!4&'5?3;'?140(3'5!8'/)123)4(-!!P!

!

123(67.(/000(K!LM@/F520@;9>!);0!"25;!&;<2549F2Q6!B3!#5@FJ!Z445=4<!49=!R54=!

T40013/>!J)(('2@47)-?$3.!O207!$325!D5)>0('I!

QO0>7)1!-1;447!L'54!347'52(1'!@47)1)'-!;2&'!*4('!344!A25!!-1;447!

2/8)()-352345-!25'!7'A3!,)3;!&)530277:!(4!/)-15'3)4(!34!829'!3;'!K0-3!

'<1'@3)4(!45!2114884/23)4(!34!8''3!3;'!1)5108-32(1'-!4A!2!@253)10725!

12-'.P!

!

!89:;(6-.(/000(K!L.08=290!R5@2:@9A!U4A2Q>!B3!R@<<!"@??25?49>!+',-/2:I!

QC'54!347'52(1'!;2-!5443-!)(!2!HVVW!A'/'527!82(/23'!!-)(1'!3;'(6!

/)AA'5'(3!-1;447-!;2&'!'<@2(/'/!L'54!347'52(1'!34!)(170/'!82(/2345:!

@0()-;8'(3!A45!3;4-'!@4--'--)(*!/50*-6!*'33)(*!)(34!A)*;3-6!2(/!'&'(!

,'25)(*!1743;)(*!/''8'/!4AA'(-)&'!!#03!2-!L'54!347'52(1'!>'148'-!845'!

@4@07256!@'4@7'!2-9!,;'3;'5!)3!;2-!*4('!344!A25!!1)&)7!5)*;3-!7'2/'5!X'--'!

X219-4(6!,;4!,2(3-!34!/4!2,2:!,)3;!L'54!347'52(1'!>'120-'!;'!>'7)'&'-!)3!

)-!/)-15)8)(2345:!2(/!344!;25-;!!-)(1'!YR'123056!Z77[!)(1)/'(36!3;'!

G@@7)'/!\'-'251;!"'(3'5!)(!]2972(/6!"27)A!!128'!403!,)3;!2!-30/:!

-;4,)(*!3;23!>7219!-30/'(3-!)(!HI!725*'!1)3)'-!25'!/)-@54@453)4(23'7:!

'<@'77'/!45!-0-@'(/'/!!-0@@453'5-!-32(/!>:!L'54!347'52(1'!2-!2(!

'AA'13)&'!2(/!14884(?-'(-'!2@@5421;!34!9''@)(*!-2A'3:!2(/!@'21'!)(!

-1;447-!!P!

!

!89:;(6.(/000(K!L.F1;;<!M@/F@G<@92!40!4!*5;//5;4=/[!!O5;?!"25;!&;<2549F2!0;!

#45<3!$2/G;9/2Q6!B3!$8//2<<!SI!.J@B4!49=!$22F2!'I!U2025/;9>!%<1'@3)4(27!

";)7/5'(>!\;<8?2!]]>!+//82!^I!

QR'-@)3'!2!/52823)1!)(15'2-'!)(!3;'!0-'!4A!L'54!347'52(1'!@541'/05'-!2(/!

@47)1)'-6!3;'5'!)-!7)337'!'&)/'(1'!/'84(-3523)(*!3;'!3;'-'!@541'/05'-!;2&'!

)(15'2-'/!-1;447!-2A'3:!45!)8@54&'/!-30/'(3!>';2&)45!!@0()3)&'!

/)-1)@7)(25:!17)823'!!120-'!A45!14(A7)13!>'3,''(!*'('527!2(/!-@'1)27!

'/012345-.!!G!@5'&'(3)&'!'257:!5'-@4(-'!/)-1)@7)(25:!84/'7!)(15'2-'-!3;'!

52(*'!4A!'AA'13)&'!4@3)4(-!A45!2//5'--)(*!&)47'(1'!2(/!/)-50@3)4(!2154--!

>43;!*'('527!2(/!-@'1)27!'/0123)4(!!P!!

!

129<=(6.(/000!K!L)2D/!@9!R5@2:[!!(!-4/1@9A0;9!$;89=8G!K!*;??@//@;9!0;!

+9C2/0@A402!.8/G29/@;9!$402/Q6!B3!#5@J!-I!$;B2<29>!%/0123)4(!=''9I!

QD;'!U.!$.!"488)--)4(!4(!")&)7!\)*;3-!@72(-!34!'<28)('!A053;'5!,;'3;'5!

-4?1277'/!L'54?347'52(1'!/)-1)@7)('!@47)1)'-!)(!-1;447-!25'!/)-15)8)(23)(*!

2*2)(-3!8)(45)3:!2(/!/)-2>7'/!-30/'(3-!!!"488)--)4('5-!/'1)/'/!!3;23!

,'!(''/!34!829'!2!A053;'5!)(&'-3)*23)4(!!P!

!

>,?9*293(/000(^!Q'20E/!.043!012!*;85/2P6!B3!.49=54!O2<=?49>!(O&!U52/@=290>!

=;'5'!='!$32(/6!G8'5)12(!_'/'523)4(!4A!D'21;'5-I!

QZ3E-!2!-;28'!34!-''!4@@4-)3)4(!>'*)(()(*!34!/'&'74@!2*2)(-3!3,4!4A!3;'!

84-3!)8@4532(3!35'(/-!)(!'/0123)4(!!-32(/25/-!2(/!L'54?347'52(1'!

!

! +X6

Page 71: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

@47)1)'-.!!O47)1)'-!3;23!1277!A45!L'54!347'52(1'!4A!&)47'(1'6!/50*-6!2(/!

,'2@4(-!)(!-1;447-!25'!>')(*!5)/)107'/!45!'&'(!1277'/!521)-3!>'120-'!3;':!

;2&'!>''(!)8@'5A'137:!^!2(/!)(!-48'!@721'-!-30@)/7:!^!2@@7)'/!!#03!3;'!

@54>7'8!;'5'!)-!(43!,)3;!3;'!@5)(1)@7'-!>';)(/!-32(/25/-!2(/!L'54!

347'52(1'!!P!

!

)2+*293(6@.(/000(K!L_I.I!S8=A2!_G1;<=/!#WG8</@;9/!@9!M2F4085Q6!B3!(<49!

$@F145=>!%/0123)4(!=''9I!

QU.$.!R)-35)13!X0/*'!J)1;2'7!J1"0-9':!507'/!3;23!14053-!;2&'!7)337'!

>0-)('--!)(3'5A'5)(*!,)3;!74127!-1;447!/'1)-)4(-!4(!-30/'(3!14(/013.!!M'!

27-4!507'/!3;23!3;'!-30/'(3-!;2/!-;4,(!(4!'&)/'(1'!3;23!-1;447!4AA)1)27-!

/)-15)8)(23'/!2*2)(-3!3;'8!>2-'/!4(!521'!!\'&.!X'--'!X219-4(!14(3'(/-!

3;23!-4?1277'/!L'54?347'52(1'!/)-1)@7)(25:!@47)1)'-!25'!/)-15)8)(2345:!

>'120-'!2!/)-@54@453)4(23'!(08>'5!4A!-30/'(3-!'<@'77'/!0(/'5!-01;!

@47)1)'-!25'!>7219!!P!

!

)2+*293(65.(/000(K!L);!&;!"25;!&;<2549F2Q>!B3!$8//2<<!.J@B4>!=2-;)(*34(!O4-3I!

Q!D;'!@'5&2-)&'!A'25!15'23'/!>:!2!-35)(*!4A!352*)1!-1;447!-;443)(*-!;2-!

7'A3!>43;!-1;447-!2(/!-41)'3:!845'!5'1'@3)&'!3;2(!'&'5!34!340*;!3279.!!C'54!

347'52(1'!;2-!*2)('/!,)/'!@4@0725)3:!A45!)3-!@548)-'!4A!2!(4?(4(-'(-'!

-4703)4(!34!2!/)AA)1073!@54>7'8.!!#03!;4,!,'77!/4'-!L'54!347'52(1'!5'277:!

,459`!!!3'58!A)5-3!2/4@3'/!>:!3;'!\'2*2(!2/8)()-3523)4(6!329'(!A548!2!

$2(!R)'*4!@54*528!3;23!)8@40(/'/!2(:!-'2*4)(*!&'--'7!A45!'&'(!3521'!

2840(3-!4A!/50*-!!3'58!a0)197:!120*;3!4(!284(*!'/012345-!..P!!

!

%,<,A?,9(6B.(6@@@(K!LM@/G45@03!+9!.F1;;<!M@/F@G<@92!O;89=V!R<4FJ/!

M@/G5;G;50@;9402<3!U294<@`2=!_9=25!N20X&;8A1!U;<@F@2/!.08=3!.43/Q6!B3>!-@<<@4?!

*<4@B;592>!=2-;)(*34(!O4-3I!

QG!(',!(23)4(,)/'!-30/:!4A!;)*;!-1;447!/)-1)@7)(25:!@5213)1'-!-;4,-!3;23!

)(!3;'!3,4!:'25-!-)(1'!QL'54!347'52(1'P!@47)1)'-!,'5'!@4@0725)L'/!!!

>7219!-30/'(3-!23!3;'!-1;447-!-05&':'/!;2&'!>''(!'<@'77'/!45!-0-@'(/'/!23!

2!523'!3;23!)-!/)-@54@453)4(23'!34!3;')5!(08>'5-!!Z(!-48'!12-'-6!3;':!

,'5'!5'84&'/!A548!-1;447!3;5''!34!A)&'!3)8'-!845'!A5'a0'(37:!3;23!,;)3'!

-30/'(3-!!D'55:!b'7';'56!O54*528!R)5'1345!SG\"T6!!-2)/!3;'!-30/:E-!

@5'7)8)(25:!A)*05'-!-''8!34!5')(A451'!,;23!,'!;2&'!>''(!;'25)(*!

2('1/43277:!^!3;23!,;'(!,;)3'!-30/'(3-!*'3!)(!3540>7'!3;':!*'3!3;'!>'('A)3!

4A!3;'!/40>36!,;'5'2-!>7219!-30/'(3-!25'!@5'-08'/!*0)73:.P!

!

!

%,<,A?,9(64.(6@@@(K!L$2C@2D!;:!(?25@F4!@9!YaaaQ6!B3>!$;B250!&49925>!N4-!

G(*'7'-!D)8'-I!!

QD;'!-35''3-!*5',!-2A'5!2-!3;'!15)8'!523'!14(3)(0'/!34!A2776!:'3!,'!,455)'/!

845'!3;2(!'&'5!2>403!/'2/7:!&)47'(1'!)(!-1;447-!2(/!23!,459!!#03!)3!,2-!23!

-1;447-6!,)3;!1;)7/5'(!@077)(*!3;'!35)**'5-6!,;'5'!G8'5)12!7449'/!)(!3;'!8)5545!

2(/!@2--'/!!3;)-!8'(21'!14(3)(0'-!34!;20(3!0-6!3;'!140(35:!a0'-3)4()(*!&)47'(3!

84&)'-!2(/!&)/'4-6!2(/!;4,!17)a0'-!4-3521)L'!403-)/'5-.!!$1;447-!)(-3)303'/!

!

! +X^

Page 72: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

@47)1)'-!4A!L'54?347'52(1'!A45!,'2@4(-!!c'3!14@:123!3;5'23-!A4774,'/!

S"4708>)('!-;443)(*-T.P!

!

%,<,A?,9(/.(6@@@!^!Q.F1;;</!%C25G89@/1Q>!b<20025!0;!012!2=@0;5c!:5;?!T45@4!

,54B;D/J@>!);5D;;=>!T4//>!+',!c459!D)8'-.!

QD;'!*427!4A!2!L'54?347'52(1'!2@@5421;!34!-1;447!/)-1)@7)('!!!-''8-!34!

;2&'!7'--!34!/4!,)3;!3'21;)(*!1;)7/5'(!34!>'!5'-@4(-)>7'!A45!3;')5!213)4(-!

3;2(!,)3;!3;'!/'-)5'!>:!82(:!-1;447-!2(/!43;'5!)(-3)303)4(-!34!2&4)/!

5'-@4(-)>)7)3:!!2(/!)-!7)9'7:!34!>219A)5'6!120-)(*!1;)7/5'(!34!5'-@4(/!,)3;!

'&'(!845'!2**5'--)&'!>';2&)45.P!

!

$CD,A?,9(/5.(6@@@(K!LM2F4085!O85;5!.G45J/!-@=25!U;<@F3!M2B402Q6!B3!$;B250!*I!

S;19/0;9>!%/0123)4(!=''9I!

Q#:!1;2(*)(*!4('!,45/!)(!)3-!-1;447!14/'!72-3!84(3;6!3;'!D0-3)(6!"27)A.6!

/)-35)13!-4A3'('/!)3-!L'54?347'52(1'!@47)1:!4(!/50*-!2(/!2714;47.!!+4,6!

2/8)()-352345-!!"#$'<@'7!-30/'(3-!4(!3;'!A)5-3!4AA'(-'.!!#'A45'!3;'!,45/!

,2-!80-3.!!!=;'3;'5!:40!2*5''!45!/)-2*5''6!3;'!@543'-3-!25'!>5)(*)(*!

3;)-!34!2!;'2/!2(/!,)77!@5'-'(3!2(!4@@4530()3:!A45!@'4@7'!)(!'/0123)4(!2(/!

277!*4&'5(8'(3!34!5'?'<28)('!3;'!)/'2!!!Y-2:-[!J)1;2'7!\'-()196!3;'!

2--41)23'!'<'103)&'!/)5'1345!4A!3;'!+23)4(27!$1;447!#425/-!G--41)23)4(!

!,;)7'!L'54!347'52(1'!)-!2!5;'345)127!>2337'!15:6!)3-!)(3'5@5'323)4(!/)AA'5-!

52/)1277:!A548!14880()3:!34!14880()3:.!!D;0-6!2!-30/'(3!A40(/!,)3;!2!*0(!

)-!>443'/!A548!4('!-1;4476!,;)7'!)(!3;'!('<3!/)-35)13!4&'56!2(43;'5!*'3-!2!

-;453!-0-@'(-)4(!!$48'!'/012345-!2(/!2/&4121:!*540@-6!8'2(,;)7'6!

14(3'(/!3;23!3;'!/)-@54@453)4(23'!523'-!23!,;)1;!8)(45)3:!-30/'(3-!5'1')&'!

-3)AA!/)-1)@7)(25:!-2(13)4(-!25'!'&)/'(1'!4A!/)-15)8)(23)4(.!!\'1'(3!/232!

A548!3;'!U.$.!R'@2538'(3!4A!%/0123)4(E-!]AA)1'!A45!")&)7!\)*;3-!-;4,'/!

3;23!>7219!-30/'(3-!5'1')&'/!2(!'-3)823'/!dd!@'51'(3!4A!277!403?4A?-1;447!

-0-@'(-)4(-!4A!845'!3;2(!HI!/2:-!!'&'(!3;40*;!3;':!14(-3)303'/!He!

@'51'(3!4A!@0>7)1!-1;447!'(54778'(3!3;23!:'25!SHVVd?VWT.!!=;)3'!-30/'(3-!

5'1')&'/!fI!@'51'(3!4A!3;'!-0-@'(-)4(-6!,;)7'!829)(*!0@!2>403!gh!@'51'(3!

4A!'(54778'(3!!!G1145/)(*!34!2!5'@453!5'7'2-'/!3;)-!A277!SHVVVT>:!3;'!

X0&'()7'!X0-3)1'!2(/!R'7)(a0'(1:!O54*528!4A!3;'!U.$.!R'@2538'(3!4A!

X0-3)1'6!-48'!VI!@'51'(3!4A!-1;447-!5'@453'/!;2&)(*!L'54?347'52(1'!

@47)1)'-!!G-!2!5'-0736!82(:!-323'-!2(/!/)-35)13-!;2&'!-''(!2!5)-'!)(!3;'!

(08>'5!4A!-30/'(3-!'<@'77'/!2(/!-0-@'(/'/.P!

!

E,8F,A?,9(/7.(6@@@(K!LM;<2!#?G14/@`2/!.05@F0!.F1;;<!M@/F@G<@92Q>!B3!M@494!

S249!.F12?;>!+',!c459!D)8'-I!

Q!=')*;)(*!)(!4(!2(!)--0'!!%7)L2>'3;!R47'!!@54@4-'/!-35'287)()(*!3;'!

_'/'527!i4&'5(8'(3E-!547'!)(!'/0123)4(!>:!*)&)(*!-323'-!2(/!74127!

/)-35)13-!3;'!@4,'5!34!/'3'58)('!;4,!_'/'527!84(':!-;407/!>'!-@'(3!2(/!

212/'8)1!325*'3-!8'3!!!Y-;'[!1;4-'!2-!;'5!>219/54@!2!-1;447!,;4-'!

@5)(1)@276!R2()'7!\.!#059'6!;2-!82/'!2!150-2/'!4A!5'-345)(*!/)-1)@7)('.P!!!

!

!

!

! +Xd

Page 73: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

E,8F,A?,9(6-.(6@@@!K!LN;52!M@/F8//2/!.F1;;<!.4:203>!N89!*;905;<!@9!.4904!

T;9@F4Q>!B3>!$;92!&2?G2/0>!N4-!G(*'7'-!D)8'-I!

QD;'!&)1'!@5'-)/'(3!-2)/!;'!2/&4123'-!BC'54!D47'52(1'E!A45!*0(-!)(!-1;447!

>03!27-4!A2&45-!3;'!15'23)4(!4A!B-'14(/!1;2(1'E!5';2>)7)323)&'!-1;447-!A45!

-30/'(3-!120*;3!,)3;!,'2@4(-.P!

!

!

E,8F,A?,9(6G.(6@@@(K!L-140!#C253!)2D!&24F125!.1;8<=!Z9;D!(B;80!

M@/F@G<@92Q6!B3!S;19!#I!Z240@9A>!%/0123)4(!=''9I!

R2)7:!/)-1)@7)('!12(!>'!2!5'27!*5)(/!)A!2!3'21;'5!/4'-(E3!;2&'!2!*44/!

-:-3'8!!M'5'!25'!3;'!>2-)1-6!N)-3'(!!!#'!14(-)-3'(3!!b(4,!,;'(!34!*4!

;)*;'5!!ZA!3'21;'5-!)8@7'8'(3!3;')5!507'-!,)3;!'a027!35'238'(3!A45!2776!3;'!

4(7:!5448!A45!/)-10--)4(!)(!-01;!8''3)(*-!)-!4&'5!3;'!507'-!3;'8-'7&'-.P!

!

>,?9*293(66.(6@@-!K!L-4A@9A!4!-45!;9!+9F@C@<@03Q>!B3!*I!.02G129!-4<<@/>!

%/0123)4(!=''9I!

QD;'!7219!4A!1)&)7)3:!)(!405!-1;447-!^!05>2(6!-0>05>2(6!2(/!50527!27)9'!^!

14(3)(0'-!34!>'!3;'!84-3!@)&4327!5'2-4(!A45!3;'!140(35:E-!721970-3'5!

'/0123)4(27!@'5A4582(1'.P!

!

>,?9*293(4.(6@@-(K!L.F1;;</!(52!T;C@9A!0;!U;<@F2!.08=290/E!%::X*4?G8/!

'@C2/Q6!B3!&4?45!'2D@9>!%/0123)4(!=''9I!

QG3!2!3)8'!,;'(!3;'!@0>7)1!172845)(*!A45!340*;'5!-1;447!/)-1)@7)('6!82(:!

'/012345-!2154--!3;'!(23)4(!25'!'/*)(*!)(34!3;'!547'!4A!@47)1)(*!(43!K0-3!

,;23!*4'-!4(!,)3;)(!3;')5!4,(!>0)7/)(*-6!>03!4AA?128@0-!@54>7'8-!2-!

,'77!-1;447-!;2&'!>542/!/)-15'3)4(!4(!;4,!34!;2(/7'!403?4A?-1;447!

>';2&)45!3;23!82:!/)-50@3!-1;447!7)A'!!!-'')(*!845'!4A!3;'-'!/)-1)@7)(25:!

213)4(-!3;2(!)(!3;'!@2-36!)(!@253!>'120-'!-41)'3:!)-!7449)(*!-4!/'-@'523'7:!

A45!-48'!-4051'!4A!-0@'5&)-)4(!A45!9)/-!,;4!25'!-''(!2-!403!4A!14(3547!!!

#03!-48'!@25'(3-!A''7!3;23!3;'!'<3'(-)4(!4A!-1;447!/)-1)@7)('!!'(15421;'-!

4(!3;')5!@25'(327!203;45)3:.P!

!

6@@-(K!Le84<@03!*;890/[!!.F1;;<!*<@?402Q6!%/0123)4(!=''9.!

QO25'(3-!,2(3!3;')5!1;)7/5'(!34!*4!34!-1;447!)(!2!@721'!,;'5'!3;':!,)77!>'!

-2A'6!2(/!,;'5'!3;'!'(&)54(8'(3!)-!A410-'/!4(!3'21;)(*!2(/!7'25()(*.!!

J2(:!-01;!-1;447-!'<)-3!)(!405!>)*!1)3)'-.!!#03!(43!'(40*;!!J2(:!4A!

3;'-'!*)2(3!-1;447-!5'-'8>7'!&2-3!,25';40-'-!,;'5'!-30/'(3-!A7423!

2(4(:840-7:!3;540*;!,;23!@2--'-!A45!2(!'/0123)4(!!=;'5'!3;'!A)5-3!

-)*;3!34!*5''3!3;'8!,;'(!3;':!,279!3;540*;!3;'!/445!'21;!845()(*!)-!2!

8'327!/'3'1345!45!2!@47)1'!4AA)1'5!!!Z(!+4&'8>'5!SHVVhT6!3;'!@5)(1)@27!4A!

2!#273)845'!;)*;!-1;447!-0-@'(/'/!H6jII!4A!3;'!-1;447E-!H6hII!-30/'(3-!

!"48@25'/!,)3;!3;')5!(4(05>2(!1477'2*0'-!!!05>2(!3'21;'5-!25'!845'!

15)3)127!4A!3;'!127)>'5!4A!3;')5!-30/'(3-!2(/!4A!3;'!-1;447-!3;':!,459!)(.P!

!

!

!

! +Xf

Page 74: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

! +X]

)2+*293(/4.(6@@B(KL"25;!&;<2549F2Q6!R3!(<B250!.149J25!b:;5?25!(O&!G52/@=290c!

-1252!-2!.049=!b(O&cI!

QZ(!HVVd6!3;'!D'<2-!_'/'523)4(!4A!D'21;'5!SD_DT!-'(3!2!a0'-3)4((2)5'!34!

)3-!8'8>'5-6!2-9)(*!3;'8!2>403!3;')5!'<@'5)'(1'-!,)3;!/)-50@3)4(!2(/!

&)47'(1'!)(!3;')5!-1;447-.!!D;'!5'-073-!,'5'!27258)(*!!-4!D_D!720(1;'/!2!

128@2)*(!1277)(*!A45!L'54!347'52(1'!A45!1'532)(!9)(/-!4A!&)47'(3!2(/!

/)-50@3)&'!>';2&)45.!!D;'!128@2)*(!7'/!073)823'7:!34!3;'!@2--2*'!4A!3;'!

D'<2-!$2A'!$1;447-!G13!)(!HVVf!!)8@213!!!Z3!)-!-3)77!'257:!34!-2:6!>03!

3;'5'!25'!-48'!*44/!-)*(-!!D;'!>2/!(',-!)-!3;23!'(A451'8'(3!)-!-@433:!

!"5)3)1-!-2:!3;'!$2A'!$1;447-!G13!)-!2!>)*!'<28@7'!4A!8)15482(2*'8'(3!

2(/!2!>74,!2*2)(-3!74127!14(3547.!!D;':!;4@'!34!10532)7!3;'!203;45)3:!)3!

*)&'-!3'21;'5-!2(/!2774,!2/8)()-352345-!845'!QA7'<)>)7)3:P!)(!/'1)/)(*!

,;'(!34!'<'51)-'!L'54!347'52(1'!2(/!,;'(!34!829'!'<1'@3)4(-!

!U(/40>3'/7:6!*)&)(*!2/8)()-352345-!3;'!A5''/48!34!5'72<!3;'!507'-!

,407/!829'!7)A'!'2-)'5!A45!3;'8!!!G(/6!0(A4530(23'7:6!,)3;!845'!

A7'<)>)7)3:!,)77!27-4!148'!521)27!2(/!'3;()1!/)-15)8)(23)4(!!!='!3279!2!743!

2>403!)8@54&)(*!3;'!'/0123)4(27!@'5A4582(1'!4A!277!405!-30/'(3-!!3;'!

3503;!4A!3;'!8233'5!)-!3;23!(4('!4A!Y3;'[!1;2(*'-!,)77!21;)'&'!,;23!,'!,2(3!

0(7'--!-1;447-!25'!-2A'!2(/!45/'57:!!P!

!

!

!

Page 75: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""#$%&'(&&(

!

"#$%"!&'()#*)+(,-!.('!-)/0#,)-!.%*+,$!!

1#'(!)("#'%,*#!&("+*+#-!!

&)*+,-./*0,)(

! !

! ,2345367389:59;!36<!;=2459;!>2>?@8=53A!2B!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7E!@<;8@!=5;637!:2!

923!:578>><8=!46<9!73?:<937!>877!36=2?;6!36<!7D622@62?7<!:22=F!!-3?:<937!462!8=<!

:57D5>@59<:!G<D8?7<!2B!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!<9H2A!G875D!=5;637!?9:<=!36<!B<:<=8@!

*297353?3529!89:!8!I8=5<3A!2B!B<:<=8@!89:!7383<!@847J!

!

!" -3?:<937!462!8=<!7?GH<D3!32!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529!>277<77!D297353?35298@!=5;637!

32!:?<!>=2D<77F!!

!" L236!36<!*297353?3529!89:!36<!D5I5@!=5;637!@847!>=265G53!:57D=5M5983529!G87<:!29!

=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!9835298@!2=5;59F!!

!" -3?:<937!4536!7><D58@!9<<:7!8=<!B?=36<=!>=23<D3<:!GA!@847!3683!;?8=893<<!36<!=5;63!

32!89!8>>=2>=583<!<:?D83529!89:!>=265G53!:57D=5M5983529!G87<:!29!:578G5@53AF!!!

!

%@362?;6!2B3<9!G2?9:!GA!98==24!593<=>=<3835297!2B!=5;637!89:!@5M53<:!;2I<=9M<938@!

<9B2=D<M<93!<BB2=37E!36<!@<;8@!7A73<M!D89!G<!8!?7<B?@E!8@G<53!59D2M>@<3<E!322@!59!

8::=<7759;!36<!68=76!D297<N?<9D<7!2B!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!

!

! )657!%>><9:5K!>=2I5:<7!89!2I<=I5<4!2B!G875D!@<;8@!=5;637!8>>@5D8G@<!32!C<=2!

32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!!&8=3!+!:57D?77<7!36<!@84!=<@83<:!32!:57D=5M5983529!G87<:!29!=8D<!89:!

9835298@!2=5;59E!89:!B2D?7<7!29!=5;637!?9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!2B!36<!.2?=3<<936!

%M<9:M<93!89:!?9:<=!)53@<!O+!2B!36<!*5I5@!'5;637!%D3!2B!PQRSF!!&8=3!++!898@AC<7!8=<87!2B!

36<!@84!8>>@5D8G@<!32!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7E!89:!B2D?7<7!29!B<:<=8@!7383?3<7!7?D6!87!

-<D3529!TUS!2B!36<!'<68G5@5383529!%D3!2B!PQVW!89:!36<!+9:5I5:?8@7!4536!0578G5@535<7!

#:?D83529!%D3!X+0#%YF!!&8=3!+++!:57D?77<7!36<!D297353?35298@!>=23<D35297!2B!:?<!>=2D<77!

;?8=893<<:!32!8@@!73?:<937!?9:<=!36<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93F!

!

! %@362?;6!36<7<!8=<87!2B!@847!8=<!3=<83<:!7<>8=83<@AE!73?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!

762?@:!?9:<=7389:!3683!36<A!2I<=@8>!89:!3683!8@@!36=<<!M8A!G<!8>>@5D8G@<!32!8!;5I<9!7<3!2B!

D5=D?M7389D<7F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!M8A!G<!3=<83<:!M2=<!68=76@A!3689!4653<!

73?:<937!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7E!465D6!D89!3=5;;<=!G236!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!

*@8?7<!89:!B<:<=8@!8935:57D=5M5983529!@847F!+9!M89A!D87<7E!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!8=<!8@72!

:57>=2>2=352983<@A!=<>=<7<93<:!8M29;!3627<!73?:<937!:<3<=M59<:!32!68I<!7><D58@!9<<:7E!

465D6!5M>@5D83<7!B<:<=8@!:578G5@53A!7383?3<7F!!%9:!>=2D<:?=8@!>=23<D35297!;?8=893<<:!GA!

36<!*297353?3529!8>>@A!32!8@@!73?:<937E!=<;8=:@<77!2B!=8D<!2=!:578G5@53A!7383?7E!462!M8A!G<!

7?GH<D3<:!32!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529F!

!

! -3?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!8@72!G<!848=<!2B!7383<!D297353?35297!89:!7383<!

7383?3<7!3683!2BB<=!75M5@8=!2=!<I<9!M2=<!<K3<975I<!>=23<D35297!8;85973!C<=2!32@<=89D<!

>2@5D5<7F!-2M<!7383<7E!B2=!597389D<E!;?8=893<<!36<!B?9:8M<938@!=5;63!32!<:?D83529E!8!=5;63!

! ++ZP

Page 76: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

3683!57!923!;?8=893<<:!?9:<=!36<!B<:<=8@!*297353?3529F![89A!7383<7!8@72!68I<!

8:M59573=835I<!8;<9D5<7!3683!B2D?7!29!<:?D835298@!=5;637!2=!29!36<!<9B2=D<M<93!2B!7383<!

8935:57D=5M5983529!@847F!%!:57D?77529!2B!7383<!@847!89:!8;<9D5<7!57!G<A29:!36<!7D2><!2B!

36<!898@A757!59!3657!%>><9:5KE!89:!73?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!D297?@3!4536!

8332=9<A7!89:!<:?D83529!7><D58@5737!B2=!M2=<!59B2=M83529!29!7383<!89:!@2D8@!@847F!

!

! )6<!*297353?3529!89:!B<:<=8@!@847!>=2I5:<!72M<!>=23<D35297!B2=!73?:<937!B8D59;!

C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7E!G?3!73?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!8@72!B?@@A!?9:<=7389:!36<!

@5M53835297!2B!36<!@847!89:!@84!<9B2=D<M<93!<BB2=37F!!%7!923<:!36=2?;62?3!3657!%>><9:5KE!

36<!<K>8975I<!@89;?8;<!D293859<:!59!36<!*297353?3529!89:!59!B<:<=8@!7383?3<7!8>><8=7!32!

>=23<D3!8!G=28:!8==8A!2B!73?:<937\!=5;637E!G?3!D2?=3!:<D575297!89:!8:M59573=835I<!8;<9DA!

593<=>=<3835297!2B!7383?3<7!3A>5D8@@A!@5M53!M89A!2B!36<7<!=5;637!32!M?D6!98==24<=!7<37!2B!

D5=D?M7389D<7F!"535;83529!D89!G<!8!7@24!89:!<K><975I<!>=2D<77E!89:!8;<9D5<7!D68=;<:!

4536!<9B2=D<M<93!2B!36<!B<:<=8@!@847!2B3<9!@5M53!36<5=!<BB2=37!G<D8?7<!2B!7D8=D<!=<72?=D<7!

89:!=<73=5D35I<!593<=>=<3835297!2B!36<!@84F!!%9:E!M89A!35M<7E!36<!>83D642=]!2B!@847!

=<@8359;!32!C<=2!32@<=89D<!75M>@A!:2<7!923!8>>@A!83!8@@F!!,<I<=36<@<77E!M89A!2B!36<!68=76!

D297<N?<9D<7!2B!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!D89!G<!8::=<77<:!29@A!36=2?;6!36<!:<B<97<!2B!

@<;8@!=5;637^!73?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!G<!B?@@A!848=<!2B!3627<!=5;637F!

!!

&1((23456("+,*3/*0,)7(!450)7*(%07/+080)5*0,)(9573-(,)(:5/3;(<,6,+;(,+($5*0,)56(

=+040)(

!

(I<=I5<4!

!

'8D58@!:57D=5M5983529!59!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!57!8!:<<>Z7<83<:!>=2G@<MF!"29;!G<B2=<!

C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!G<D8M<!>2>?@8=E!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!4<=<!7?GH<D3<:!32!7?7><97529!

89:!<K>?@7529!59!:57>=2>2=352983<!9?MG<=7!89:!3A>5D8@@A!=<D<5I<:!68=76<=!>?9576M<93!

3689!36<5=!4653<!D2?93<=>8=37F!%7!29<!8:I2D83<!687!923<:E!53!57!92!D259D5:<9D<!3683!36<!

/F-F!-?>=<M<!*2?=3\7!@<8:59;!D87<!29!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!89:!73?:<937\!:?<!>=2D<77!=5;637E!

!"##$%&$'"()*+!_59I2@I<:!36<!74<<>59;E!59:57D=5M5983<!7?7><97529!2B!G@8D]!73?:<937!B=2M!

*2@?MG?7E!(652!>?G@5D!7D622@7!B2=!8@@<;<:@A!38]59;!>8=3!59!:<M2973=835297!B2@@2459;!

L@8D]!`5732=A![2936Fa!P!

!

'8D58@!:57D=5M5983529!59!<:?D83529!57!>=265G53<:!?9:<=!G236!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!

*@8?7<!2B!36<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93!89:!?9:<=!B<:<=8@!8935:57D=5M5983529!7383?3<7F!!)6<!

M273!5M>2=3893!7383?3<!57!)53@<!O+!2B!36<!*5I5@!'5;637!%D3!2B!PQRSE!465D6!>=265G537!

:57D=5M5983529!29!36<!G8757!2B!=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!9835298@!2=5;59!GA!=<D5>5<937!2B!B<:<=8@!

B5989D58@!87757389D<Fb!&?G@5D!7D622@!7A73<M7!8=<!3A>5D8@@A!D2I<=<:!GA!G236!36<!#N?8@!

&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!89:!)53@<!O+!G<D8?7<!36<A!8=<!@2D8@!;2I<=9M<938@!<93535<7!89:!

=<D5>5<937!2B!B<:<=8@!M295<7F!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!P!,8:59<!-3=277<9E!,-".)/.012$3.45)1.$6027.#$,-"8".)#$954/:.0"1:;$<(("-.410.=>$?$6)#("1#)$."$@452)$

A0;B01#"1+$P![5D6F!"F!c!&2@\A!'<IF!WPTE!WPR!XPQQRYF!b!Sb!/F-F*F!d!bUUU:F!

! ++Zb

Page 77: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

*297353?35298@!D@85M7!?9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!68I<!G<<9!D2MM29!59!

<:?D835298@!7<3359;7E!>8=35D?@8=@A!59!@535;83529!32!:<7<;=<;83<!>?G@5D!7D622@7F!#N?8@!

>=23<D3529!D@85M7!8=<!:5BB5D?@3!32!>=2I<E!624<I<=E!G<D8?7<!2B!36<!=<N?5=<M<93!B5=73!

5M>27<:!GA!36<!/F-F!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!59!PQVR!3683!>@85935BB7!>=2I<!50#/-0801:."-=$01.)1.$29!

36<!>8=3!2B!36<!;2I<=9M<938@!:<B<9:893F!-D622@!2BB5D58@7!=8=<@A!7><8]!2=!4=53<!2><9@A!

8G2?3!:5BB<=<9358359;!G<34<<9!=8D58@!;=2?>7E!8@362?;6!36<A!M8A!59!B8D3!593<9:!32!3=<83!

73?:<937!:5BB<=<93@A!G87<:!29!=8D<!2=!9835298@!2=5;59F!,29<36<@<77E!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!

*@8?7<!D89!G<!?7<:!32!D68@@<9;<!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!59!465D6!=8D58@!:57>8=535<7!59!

7D622@!:57D5>@59<!8=<!3=8D<8G@<!32!36<!=8D58@!895M2753A!2B!2BB5D58@7E!:<M2973=83<:!GA!

<I5:<9D<!7?D6!87!=8D58@!7@?=7!2=!8!=8D58@@A!62735@<!<9I5=29M<93F!

!

&@85935BB7!D89!8@72!=857<!7383?32=A!D@85M7!?9:<=!)53@<!O+!46<=<!=8D58@!:57>8=535<7!59!

:57D5>@59<!8=<!:?<!32!593<935298@!:57D=5M5983529^!36<7<!D@85M7!8=<!D2MM29@A!]9249!87!

_:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93a!D@85M7F!+9!8::53529E!624<I<=E!36<!8:M59573=835I<!=<;?@835297!32!)53@<!

O+!><=M53!@<;8@!D@85M7!59!465D6!=8D<Z9<?3=8@!>2@5D5<7!68I<!89!8:I<=7<!<BB<D3!29!=8D58@!

M592=53A!73?:<937^!36<7<!D@85M7!8=<!D2MM29@A!]9249!87!_:57>8=83<!2=!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3a!

D@85M7F!.2=!<K8M>@<E!?9:<=!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!36<2=AE!>@85935BB7!D2?@:!D68@@<9;<!8!>2@5DA!

3683!=<N?5=<7!8!@29;<=!7?7><97529!B2=!D<=3859!3A><7!2B!2BB<97<7!89:!@<8:7!32!8!

:57>=2>2=352983<!9?MG<=!2B!M592=53A!73?:<937!G<59;!7?7><9:<:!B2=!@29;<=!><=52:7F!)6<!

>=5M8=A!8:I8938;<!2B!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M!57!3683!>=22B!2B!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93!57!923!

=<N?5=<:F!

!

*297353?35298@!89:!7383?32=A!D@85M7!8=<!3A>5D8@@A!B5@<:!59!B<:<=8@!2=!7383<!D2?=3E!G?3!

8:M59573=835I<!D2M>@85937!?9:<=!)53@<!O+!D89!8@72!G<!B5@<:!4536!B<:<=8@!8;<9D5<7!D68=;<:!

4536!<9B2=D59;!)53@<!O+F!!+9!36<!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!D293<K3E!36<!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637!

X(*'Y!2B!36<!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529!57!36<!8>>=2>=583<!<9B2=D<M<93!G2:AF!

%@362?;6!(*'!<9B2=D<M<93!<BB2=37!D89!G<!59D297573<93!59!:5BB<=<93!=<;5297!89:!2I<=!35M<E!

89:!8=<!7?GH<D3!32!36<!@5M537!2B!;2I<=9M<938@!=<72?=D<7E!36<!(*'!8:M59573=835I<!

D2M>@8593!M<D68957M!>=2I5:<7!89!5M>2=3893!8@3<=9835I<!B2=!73?:<937!89:!36<5=!8:I2D83<7!

462!@8D]!36<!35M<!89:!B5989D58@!M<897!32!B5@<!@535;83529!59!D2?=3F!

!

)6<!M2=<!:<385@<:!898@A757!2B!36<!@84!3683!B2@@247!57!:5I5:<:!5932!36=<<!>8=37J!!XPY!

D297353?35298@!D@85M7!?9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<^!XbY!:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93!89:!

8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M7!?9:<=!)53@<!O+^!89:!XWY!8:M59573=835I<!D2M>@85937!B5@<:!4536!36<!

/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529\7!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637F!

!

%F!!*297353?35298@!*@85M7!/9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!

!

)6<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!2B!36<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93W!>=265G537!

:57D=5M5983529!GA!7383<!2=!@2D8@!;2I<=9M<93!29!36<!G8757!2B!=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!9835298@!2=5;59!

59!8@M273!8@@!D5=D?M7389D<7FS!!+9!<K8M5959;!36<!D297353?35298@53A!2B!8!7383<!@84E!>2@5DAE!2=!

8D35I53A!3683!:57D=5M5983<7!29!36<!G8757!2B!=8D<E!D2?=37!45@@!<M>@2A!8!=5;2=2?7!7389:8=:!2B!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!W!)6<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93!>=2I5:<7!59!=<@<I893!>8=3!3683!92!7383<!768@@!_:<9A!32!89A!><=729!453659!537!

H?=57:5D3529!36<!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!2B!36<!@847Fa!!!/F-F!*2973F!8M<9:F!e+OE!dPF!S!3))!f2=<M837?!IF!/953<:!-383<7E!WbW!/F-F!bPS!XPQSSYF!

! ++ZW

Page 78: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

=<I5<4E!]9249!87!_73=5D3!7D=?359Aa!898@A757F!/9:<=!3657!898@A757E!8!@84!2=!>2@5DA!M?73!G<!

1:--"C;=$.:0;"-)5$32!M<<3!8!/"8();;012$2"%)-18)1.:;$01.)-)#.F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!8!7D622@!

>2@5DA!3683!7?7><9:<:!4653<!73?:<937!B2=!29<!3A><!2B!I52@<93!8D3E!G?3!<K><@@<:!G@8D]!

73?:<937!B2=!36<!78M<!8D3E!42?@:!G<!?9D297353?35298@E!<I<9!362?;6!53!M5;63!G<!H?735B5<:!GA!

89!5M>2=3893!;2I<=9M<938@!593<=<73!g!>=<7<=I59;!7D622@!78B<3AF!!#I<9!5B!>=<7<=I59;!7D622@!

78B<3A!4<=<!32!G<!D2975:<=<:!8!_D2M><@@59;a!593<=<73E!36<!>2@5DA!42?@:!923!G<!98==24@A!

385@2=<:!32!M<<3!3683!593<=<73E!759D<!89A!73?:<93E!=<;8=:@<77!2B!=8D<E!462!D2MM533<:!36<!

I52@<93!8D3!D2?@:!>27<!8!7<=52?7!=57]!32!78B<3AF!

!

)6<=<!57!8M>@<!<I5:<9D<!32!7624!3683!=8D58@!M592=53A!73?:<937!G<8=!36<!4<5;63!2B!

C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!59!:57>=2>2=352983<!9?MG<=7F!`24<I<=E!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!D@85M7!

D68@@<9;59;!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!3683!D8?7<!36<7<!:57>8=535<7!8=<!:5BB5D?@3!32!<738G@576!

G<D8?7<!2B!36<!=<N?5=<M<93!3683!>@85935BB7!>=2I<!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93F!!-59D<!36<!/F-F!

-?>=<M<!*2?=3\7!PQVR!:<D57529!59!A:#7012."1$%&$D:%0#ET!>@85935BB7!M?73!>=2I5:<!<I5:<9D<!

3683!;2I<=9M<938@!G2:5<7!593<9:<:!32!:57D=5M5983<!29!36<!G8757!2B!=8D<!59!D=<8359;!2=!

5M>@<M<9359;!8!>2@5DAF!!'8D58@!:57>8=535<7E!8@362?;6!>24<=B?@!<I5:<9D<E!8=<!923!GA!

36<M7<@I<7!7?BB5D5<93!32!<738G@576!89!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!I52@83529F!

!

#I<9!5B!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!68=G2=!=8D58@!895M?7!3248=:!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=E!36<A!8=<!923!

@5]<@A!32!8:M53!3683!895M?7E!<536<=!<K>@5D53@A!36=2?;6!36<!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!2=!

5M>@5D53@A!36=2?;6!36<!8>>@5D83529!2B!36<!>2@5DA!32!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=F!!057D2I<=59;!

<I5:<9D<!2B!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93!57!36<=<B2=<!I<=A!:5BB5D?@3F!.2=!<K8M>@<E!29<!H?9D3?=<!59!

36<!:57D5>@598=A!>=2D<77!46<=<!:57D=5M5983529!M5;63!2DD?=!57!36<!595358@!:<D57529!32!=<B<=!8!

73?:<93!B2=!89!59B=8D3529F!-3?:<937!2B!D2@2=!8=<!B8=!M2=<!@5]<@A!3689!4653<!73?:<937!32!G<!

=<B<==<:!B2=!7?GH<D35I<!59B=8D35297!7?D6!87!_:<B589D<!2B!8?362=53AFa!L<D8?7<!3<8D6<=7!89:!

236<=!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!8=<!36<!B5=73!32!5:<935BA!:57D5>@598=A!59B=8D35297E!5B!36<7<!2BB5D58@7!8=<!

M2=<!>=29<!32!=<>2=3!I52@835297!D2MM533<:!GA!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!3689!GA!4653<!73?:<937E!

36<=<!45@@!G<!92!=<D2=:!2B!4653<!73?:<937\!M57D29:?D3E!36?7!M8]59;!53!I<=A!:5BB5D?@3!32!

>=2I<!3683!75M5@8=@A!753?83<:!4653<!73?:<937!4<=<!923!=<B<==<:F!

!

-35@@E!_7M2]59;!;?9a!<I5:<9D<!2B!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93!D89!2DD875298@@A!8>><8=!59!

36<!B2=M!2B!=8D58@!<>536<37!2=!59!7D622@!2BB5D58@7\!32@<=89D<!B2=!8!=8D58@@A!62735@<!

<:?D835298@!<9I5=29M<93F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!59!37)-();;$%&$E481"B)$3/7"";$D0#.-0/.+!8!B<:<=8@!

D2?=3!B2?9:!59!PQhT!3683!89!%=]89787!7D622@!:573=5D3\7!:57D5>@59<!7A73<M!487!=8D58@@A!

:57D=5M59832=A!89:!?9D297353?35298@F!)6<!D2?=3!B2?9:!3683!3<8D6<=7!=<B<==<:!32!G@8D]!

73?:<937!87!_95;;<=7Ea!_G@?<!;?M7Ea!89:!_D2297Ea!89:!8!B2=M<=!3<8D6<=!3<735B5<:!8G2?3!

B2=M7!2B!D2=>2=8@!>?9576M<93!8:M59573<=<:!32!G@8D]!73?:<937!g!59D@?:59;!29<!462!487!

@<B3!G@22:5<:!GA!8!3<8D6<=!g!3683!4<=<!9<I<=!8:M59573<=<:!32!8!4653<!73?:<93!:?=59;!6<=!

959<!A<8=7!4536!36<!:573=5D3FR!

!

+9!8::53529!32!<;=<;52?7!D87<7!59!465D6!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!:<M2973=83<!2I<=3!=8D58@!

:57D=5M5983529E!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!D@85M7!=<@83<:!32!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!D89!8=57<!59!

D87<7!59!465D6!:<7<;=<;83529!2=:<=7!2=!D297<93!:<D=<<7!8=<!8@=<8:A!59!>@8D<F![89A!7D622@!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!T!SbR!/F-F!bbQ!XPQVRYF!R!RPQ!.F!-?>>F!RVU!X#F0F!%=]F!PQhTYF!

! ++ZS

Page 79: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

:573=5D37!?9:<=!:<7<;=<;83529!2=:<=7!7<<]!32!68I<!36<5=!:573=5D37!:<D@8=<:!_?9538=AFa!i6<9!

8!D2?=3!:<D@8=<7!?9538=A!7383?7E!36<!:573=5D3!57!:<<M<:!32!68I<!B?@B5@@<:!537!2G@5;835297!32!

<@5M5983<!36<!I<735;<7!2B!537!=8D58@@A!7<;=<;83<:!_:?8@a!<:?D835298@!7A73<MF!L<B2=<!577?59;!

8!:<D@8=83529E!624<I<=E!8!D2?=3!62@:7!8!6<8=59;!59!465D6!36<!G?=:<9!B8@@7!29!36<!:573=5D3!32!

>=2I<!3683!53!687!8D65<I<:!?9538=A!7383?7^!D68@@<9;<=7!D89!593=2:?D<!<I5:<9D<!83!36<!

6<8=59;!3683!65;6@5;637!929D2M>@589D<!4536!36<!:<7<;=<;83529!2=:<=F!%!7D622@!:573=5D3\7!

:<D57529!32!8:2>3!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!M8A!D8@@!5932!N?<73529!537!D@85M!3683!53!687!<9:<:!

>=8D35D<7!3683!3<9:!32!7<;=<;83<!89:!8:I<=7<@A!8BB<D3!M592=53A!73?:<937F!)6<!68=76!<BB<D37!

2B!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!D2?@:E!36<=<B2=<E!G<!=857<:!87!29<!2B!7<I<=8@!B8D32=7!59:5D8359;!

3683!8!7D622@!7A73<M!687!923!A<3!D2M>@5<:!4536!8!:<7<;=<;83529!2=:<=F!

!

!(9<!<K8M>@<!2B!8!:57D5>@59<ZG87<:!=<I57529!32!8!:<7<;=<;83529!D297<93!:<D=<<!D89!

G<!B2?9:!59!F-"1#"1$%&$F":-5$"G$954/:.0"1$"G$H01/011:.0&!!!+9!F-"1#"1E!36<!D2?=3!68:!

577?<:!8!73?:A!465D6!=<I<8@<:!3683!=8D58@!:57>8=535<7!68:!923!D689;<:!59!36<!3<9!A<8=7!

759D<!36<!2=5;598@!D297<93!:<D=<<\7!75;959;!59!PQhS^!M2=<2I<=E!36<!D2?=3!B2?9:!3683!

7?7><97529!89:!<K>?@7529!=83<7!68:!=57<9!:=8M835D8@@A!B2@@2459;!36<!5M>@<M<9383529!2B!8!

9<4!>2@5DA!3683!8::<:!36<!?7<!2B!>=2B8953A!3248=:!738BB!87!;=2?9:7!B2=!7?7><97529FV!!)6<!

8M<9:<:!D297<93!:<D=<<!=<N?5=<:!3683!7D622@7!]<<>!3=8D]!2B!:57>8=535<7!59!=<B<==8@7!GA!

3<8D6<=7!89:!3683!2BB5D58@7!593<=I<9<!46<9!59:5I5:?8@!3<8D6<=7!4<=<!D297573<93@A!

=<7>2975G@<!B2=!B=<N?<93!89:!65;6@A!:57>8=83<!:57D5>@598=A!=<B<==8@7F!/9:<=!36<!3<=M7!2B!

36<!8;=<<M<93E!3<8D6<=7!8=<!=<48=:<:!5B!36<A!M898;<!73?:<937!4<@@!89:!D89!G<!7?GH<D3<:!

32!:57D5>@59<!36<M7<@I<7!5B!36<A!M898;<!73?:<937!>22=@AFh!

!

LF!!)53@<!O+!2B!36<!*5I5@!'5;637!%D3!2B!PQRS!

!

)53@<!O+!2B!36<!*5I5@!'5;637!%D3!2B!PQRSQ!>=265G537!:57D=5M5983529!29!36<!G8757!2B!

=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!9835298@!2=5;59!GA!<:?D835298@!597353?35297!3683!=<D<5I<!B<:<=8@!B5989D58@!

87757389D<F!L<D8?7<!36<!D2?=37!68I<!=<D2;95C<:!8!>=5I83<!=5;63!2B!8D3529!?9:<=!)53@<!O+EPU!

>@85935BB7!D89!B5@<!8!@847?53!59!B<:<=8@!D2?=3!2=!B5@<!89!8:M59573=835I<!D2M>@8593!4536!36<!

8>>=2>=583<!B<:<=8@!8;<9DA!D68=;<:!4536!<9B2=D59;!)53@<!O+!g!36<!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!

#:?D83529\7!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637F!

!

/9@5]<!D297353?35298@!@535;83529!?9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<E!342!@<;8@!

B=8M<42=]7!8=<!8I85@8G@<!?9:<=!)53@<!O+J!XPY!:57>8=83<!X2=!:5BB<=<93Y!3=<83M<93!D@85M7E!89:!

XbY!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M7F!!"5]<!89!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!D@85ME!8!:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93!D@85M!

?9:<=!)53@<!O+!=<N?5=<7!>=22B!2B!G236!:5BB<=<9358@!3=<83M<93!G87<:!29!=8D<!89:!

:57D=5M59832=A!593<93F!!%9!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M!?9:<=!)53@<!O+!89:!537!=<;?@835297!:2<7!

923E!624<I<=E!=<N?5=<!>=22B!2B!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93!89:!D89!G<!36<!M2=<!?7<B?@!D@85M!B2=!

73?:<937!89:!8:I2D83<7!462!68I<!73=29;!<I5:<9D<!2B!=8D58@!:57>8=535<7!8=5759;!B=2M!C<=2!

32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!V!3))$&<3<=!-DM5:3E!H01/011:.0$?2-))8)1.$A0;;$6:.)$I):/7)-#$"1$D0#/0(;01)+$#:?DF!i<<]E!X,2IF!PUE!PQQWYF!h!L=29729!IF!L:F!2B!#:?DF!2B!*59D599835E!,2F!*ZPZVSZbUTE!%M<9:<:!*297<93!0<D=<<!X02DF!jhSUY!X-F0F!

(652!PQQSY!X2=5;598@@A!RUS!.F!-?>>!Rh!X-F0F!(652!PQhSYYF!Q!Sb!/F-F*F!d!bUUU:F!PU!3))$$?8=:5897!%779F!IF!*5I5@!-<=I5D<!*2MM\9E!SRW!/F-F!Thb!XPQhWYF!

! ++ZT

Page 80: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

-3?:<937!89:!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!923<E!362?;6E!3683!36<!<I5:<9D<!?7<:!B2=!89!8:I<=7<!

5M>8D3!D@85M!D89!2B3<9!G<!?7<:!32!7?>>2=3!8!:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93!D@85ME!89:!I5D<!I<=78FPP!!

)6<!<77<9358@!:5BB<=<9D<!57!3683!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M!D68@@<9;<7!8!7<<M59;@A!9<?3=8@!

7D622@!>2@5DA!2=!>=8D35D<!89:!59B<=7!?9@84B?@!:57D=5M5983529!29!36<!G8757!2B!:57>8=83<!

2?3D2M<7E!465@<!8!:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93!D@85M!@22]7!D@27<@A!83!36<!8D3?8@!>=8D35D<!32!=<I<8@!

7><D5B5D!597389D<7!2B!:5BB<=<9358@!3=<83M<93!89:!D2975:<=7!G236!:5=<D3!89:!73835735D8@!

<I5:<9D<!2B!=8D58@!G587FPb!

!

#8D6!2B!36<!B=8M<42=]7!57!:57D?77<:!G<@24F!

!

PF!!057>8=83<!)=<83M<93!)6<2=A!

!

+9!6)2)1.#$"G$.7)$J10%)-#0.=$"G$H:;0G"-10:$%&$F:BB)+PW$36<!/F-F!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!

6<@:!3683!I52@835297!2B!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<!8@72!B8@@!453659!36<!>=265G535297!2B!

)53@<!O+F!057>8=83<!3=<83M<93!D87<7!?9:<=!)53@<!O+E!@5]<!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!D87<7!?9:<=!36<!

*297353?3529E!=<N?5=<!>=22B!2B!G236!:5BB<=<9358@!3=<83M<93!89:!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93F!X%7!

:57D?77<:!G<@24E!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M7!8=57<!2?3!2B!)53@<!O+\7!8:M59573=835I<!=<;?@835297E!

465D6!<K3<9:!36<!7383?3<\7!D2I<=8;<FY!!

!

)6<!>8=8@@<@!G<34<<9!36<!<N?8@!>=23<D3529!89:!:57>8=83<!3=<83M<93!36<2=5<7!B2=D<7!

8:I2D83<7!32!:<8@!4536!36<!78M<!<I5:<9358=A!>=2G@<M7!59!>=2I59;!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93F!

.2=!<K8M>@<E!89<D:238@!<I5:<9D<!7?;;<737!3683!7D622@7!2B3<9!68I<!29<!73=5D3!4=533<9!

>2@5DAE!G?3!M8A!8>>@A!36<!>2@5DA!59!8!@8K!B876529!32!4653<7!89:!59!73=5D3!B876529!32!73?:<937!

2B!D2@2=F!)6<!7D622@7!68I<E!59!<BB<D3E!8:2>3<:!8!_:?8@a!:57D5>@598=A!D2:<FPS!!i6<9!

D29B=293<:!4536!7?D6!<I5:<9D<E!624<I<=E!7D622@!:573=5D37!2B3<9!593=2:?D<!<I5:<9D<!32!

7624!3683!<8D6!59D5:<93!2B!M57G<68I52=!487!?95N?<F!!%:I2D83<7!45@@!68I<!8!I<=A!:5BB5D?@3!

35M<!>=2I59;!:57D=5M59832=A!593<93!G87<:!29!8!759;@<!59D5:<93E!@8D]59;!89A!2I<=3!<I5:<9D<!

2B!=8D58@!M235I83529F!

!

i65@<!:<B<97<7!2B!?95N?<9<77!8=<!923!<87A!32!D2?93<=E!8:I2D83<7!M8A!G<!8G@<!32!

:<M2973=83<!593<935298@!:57D=5M5983529!GA!<738G@57659;!8!D297573<93!>833<=9!?759;!<I5:<9D<!

B=2M!236<=!59D5:<937F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!59!8!PQQT!D2M>@8593!8;85973!36<!L<9<:5D359<![5@538=A!

-D622@!59!$<2=;58E!36<!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529\7!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637!=<I5<4<:!36<!

7D622@\7!:57D5>@598=A!=<D2=:7!89:!B2?9:!3683!4653<!73?:<937!462!68:!D2MM533<:!2BB<97<7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PP!)<@<>629<!+93<=I5<4!4536!L8=G=8!-689929E!'<;529!+O!05=<D32=!2B!(*'!X[8A!PTE!bUUUYF!Pb!3))$K1$-)!05@@29!*2?93A!-D6F!0573F!,2F!PE!TW!#0/*F!'#&F!PSWW!XPQhRYF!!%98@2;2?7!D87<!@84!7?;;<737!3683!

89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M!D2?@:!=<@A!29!73835735D7!72@<@AE!32!D68@@<9;<!8!9<4!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DAE!5B!36<!

8:2>3529!2B!36<!9<4!>2@5DA!487!@59]<:!32!<536<=!8!;=2459;!:57>8=53AE!2=!8!75;95B5D893!59D=<87<!59!36<!8D3?8@!

9?MG<=!2B!M592=53A!73?:<937!=<M2I<:!B=2M!7D622@F!i6<=<!7D622@7!M8A!68I<!68:!8!75;95B5D893!73835735D8@!

:57>8=53A!G<B2=<!689:E!36<!9<4!>2@5DA!M5;63!D8?7<!75;95B5D893@A!M2=<!73?:<937!2B!8@@!=8D<7!7?7><9:<:!89:!

<K><@@<:!45362?3!9<D<778=5@A!59D=<8759;!36<!:57>8=53A!G<34<<9!=8D<7F!PW!SWh!/F-F!bRT!XPQVhYF!PS!+9!29<!D87<!8!=<I5<4!2B!8!7D622@!:573=5D3\7!=<D2=:7!7624<:!3683!G@8D]!73?:<937!4<=<!>5D]<:!?>!GA!36<!

>2@5D<!89:!;5I<9!29<!4<<]!2B!59Z7D622@!7?7><97529!D297573<93!4536!36<!>2@5DAE!465@<!36<!4653<!73?:<937E!B2=!

I<=A!75M5@8=!2BB<97<7E!=<D<5I<:!D2?97<@59;!89:!92!7?7><97529!2=!>2@5D<!593<=I<93529F!3))!,2=M8!*893?E!

%77573893!-<D=<38=A!.2=!*5I5@!'5;637E!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529E!)<735M29A!G<B2=<!36<!/953<:!-383<7!

*2MM577529!29!*5I5@!'5;637E!Xi87659;329!0F*FE!.<GF!PhE!bUUUYF!

! ++ZR

Page 81: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

75M5@8=!32!3627<!2B!G@8D]!73?:<937!=<D<5I<:!7?G7389358@@A!@5;63<=!789D35297F!)6<!7D622@\7!

:57D5>@59<!7D6<M<!487!G87<:!29!8!>2593!7A73<M!B2=!59B=8D35297E!8!:57D5>@598=A!D2MM533<<!

3683!M<3!46<9!8!73?:<93!2G3859<:!bU!>25937E!89:!8!6<8:M873<=\7!:57D=<3529!32!8DD<>3!2=!

=<H<D3!36<!D2MM533<<\7!=<D2MM<9:835297F!L87<:!29!36<!B8D3!3683!G@8D]!73?:<937!4<=<!

=2?359<@A!<K><@@<:!?9:<=!36<!>2593!7A73<ME!G?3!4653<!73?:<937!=8=<@AE!5B!<I<=E!4<=<!

7?7><9:<:!2=!<K><@@<:!B2=!75M5@8=!89:!<I<9!;=8I<=!2BB<97<7E!(*'!B2?9:!36<!:57D5>@59<!

>2@5DA!32!I52@83<!)53@<!O+FPT!

((

( bF!!%:I<=7<!+M>8D3!)6<2=A!

(

( )6<!=<;?@835297!5M>@<M<9359;!)53@<!O+!7383<!3683!8!=<D5>5<93!2B!B<:<=8@!B5989D58@!

87757389D<!M8A!923!_?35@5C<!D=53<=58!2=!M<362:7!2B!8:M59573=83529!465D6!68I<!36<!<BB<D3!2B!

7?GH<D359;!59:5I5:?8@7!32!:57D=5M5983529FaPR!!+9!!4:-50:1L#$?##"/0:.0"1$%&$H0%0;$3)-%0/)$

H"880##0"1+!36<!/F-F!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!?>6<@:!)53@<!O+\7!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!3<73E!738359;!3683!

36<!)53@<!O+!=<;?@83529!B2=G5:7!36<!?7<!2B!B<:<=8@!B?9:7!_923!29@A!59!>=2;=8M7!3683!

593<935298@@A!:57D=5M5983<E!G?3!8@72!59!3627<!<9:<8I2=7!3683!68I<!8!=8D58@@A!

:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3!29!=8D58@!M592=535<7FaPV!!057D=5M5983529!?9:<=!)53@<!O+!D89!36?7!

<K573!46<=<!36<!8>>@5D83529!2B!9<?3=8@!D=53<=58!g!7?D6!87!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!g!68I<!

:57D=5M59832=A!<BB<D37!89:!46<=<!36<!D=53<=58!8=<!923!<:?D835298@@A!H?735B5<:F!

!

! L2==2459;!D87<!@84!B=2M!36<!<M>@2AM<93!:57D=5M5983529!8=<8!?9:<=!)53@<!O++!2B!

36<!*5I5@!'5;637!%D3!2B!PQRS!g!59D@?:59;!36<!/F-F!-?>=<M<!*2?=3\7!@89:M8=]!:<D57529!59!

!-022#$%&$D4B)$,"C)-$H"8(:1=Ph!g!36<!D2?=37!8>>@A!8!36=<<Z73<>!3<73!32!:<3<=M59<!5B!89!

<:?D835298@!>2@5DA!57!:57D=5M59832=A!?9:<=!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!36<2=AF!!.5=73E!:2<7!36<!

>=8D35D<!2=!>=2D<:?=<!59!N?<73529!68I<!8!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3!G87<:!29!=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!

9835298@!2=5;59k!!-<D29:E!57!36<!>=8D35D<!2=!>=2D<:?=<!89!<:?D835298@!9<D<7753Ak!!)65=:E!57!

36<=<!89!8@3<=9835I<!>=8D35D<!2=!>=2D<:?=<!3683!42?@:!G<!B<875G@<!89:!8D65<I<!36<!78M<!

>?=>27<E!4536!@<77!:57D=5M59832=A!5M>8D3FPQ!!#8D6!2B!36<7<!73<>7!57!:57D?77<:!G<@24F!

!

! 8F!!D0#(-"("-.0"1:.)$K8(:/.$:15$6:/0:;$D0#(:-0.0)#!

(

+9!M273!D87<7E!73835735D8@!898@A7<7!45@@!G<!?7<B?@!59!:<M2973=8359;!=8D<ZG87<:!

:57>8=535<7!8M29;!73?:<937!462!8=<!:57D5>@59<:!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7FbU!!(9<!

M<362:!57!32!D2M>8=<!36<!><=D<938;<!2B!73?:<937!59!8!>8=35D?@8=!=8D58@!2=!<3695D!;=2?>!

4536!89!<K><D3<:!I8@?<!G87<:!29!8!=89:2M!7<@<D3529!2B!73?:<937!B=2M!36<!73?:<93!G2:A!

>2>?@83529F!!+B!36<!73835735D8@!898@A757!76247!3683!36<!7?7><97529l<K>?@7529!=83<!B2=!

73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!57!75;95B5D893@A!65;6<=!3683!4683!29<!42?@:!<K><D3!B=2M!8!=89:2M!

:573=5G?3529!2B!73?:<937E!36<9!36<!>2@5DA!M8A!G<!D8?759;!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!29!36<!73?:<937!

2B!D2@2=F!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PT!3))!K1$-)!L<9<:5D359<![5@538=A!-D6FE!bb!+,0+O+0/%"-!i+)`!0+-%L+"+)+#-!#0/*F!"F!'#&F!RSW!XPQQTYF!PR!WS!*F.F'F!PUUFWXGYXbYF!PV!SRW!/F-F!Thb!XPQhWYF!Ph!SUP!/F-F!SbP!XPQVPYF!PQ!3))+$)&2&+!"8==A!&F!IF!'5@<7E!VQW!.Fb:!QRQE!Qhb!9FQ!XQ36!*5=F!PQhSY^!!bU!3))!i83729!IF!.2=3!i2=36!L89]!c!)=?73E!ShV!/F-F!QVV!XPQhhYF!!

! ++ZV

Page 82: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

.2=!<K8M>@<E!5B!G@8D]!73?:<937!D297353?3<!PU!><=D<93!2B!8!73?:<93!G2:A!>2>?@83529E!

29<!42?@:!<K><D3!G@8D]!73?:<937!32!D297353?3<!PU!><=D<93!2B!3627<!59:5I5:?8@7!462!8=<!

7?7><9:<:!?9:<=!8!9<4!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DAF!L?3!5B!TU!><=D<93!2B!73?:<937!7?7><9:<:!

?9:<=!36<!9<4!>2@5DA!8=<!G@8D]E!36<=<!57!8!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3!29!36<!G@8D]!73?:<937F!!

)6<=<!8=<E!624<I<=E!92!=5;5:!M836<M835D8@!36=<762@:7!B2=!36<!8M2?93!2B!

:57>=2>2=35298@53A^!36<!;=<83<=!36<!:57>8=53AE!36<!M2=<!@5]<@A!3683!36<!D68@@<9;<:!>=8D35D<!

D8?7<:!36<!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3F![2=<!<K3<975I<!89:!<@8G2=83<!73835735D8@!898@A7<7!D89!

G<!><=B2=M<:E!G?3!:57D?77529!2B!3627<!3<D695N?<7!57!G<A29:!36<!7D2><!2B!3657!%>><9:5KFbP!

!

M&$$954/:.0"1:;$N)/)##0.=!

!

(9D<!36<!>@85935BB!<738G@576<7!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3E!36<!G?=:<9!765B37!32!36<!

:<B<9:893!32!7624!3683!36<!>2@5DA!D8?759;!36<!:57>8=53A!57!89!_<:?D835298@!9<D<7753AFa!)6<!

<:?D835298@!597353?3529!M?73!7624!3683!36<!>2@5DA!57!<:?D835298@@A!H?735B5<:E!G?3!53!57!923!

=<N?5=<:!32!7624!3683!36<!>2@5DA!57!_<77<9358@a!2=!_59:57><978G@<Fa!!+9!<I8@?8359;!

<:?D835298@!9<D<7753AE!36<!<:?D835298@!;28@7!>?=7?<:!GA!8!7D622@!:573=5D3!8=<!?7?8@@A!923!

N?<73529<:E!89:!36<!D2?=37!8=<!;<9<=8@@A!:<B<=<9358@!32!36<!<:?D832=7\!<K><=357<!89:!

<K><=5<9D<F!-D622@!2BB5D58@7!8=<!@5]<@A!32!:<B<9:!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!29!36<!;=2?9:7!

3683!36<A!7<=I<!36<!@<;535M83<!>?=>27<!2B!M859385959;!8!78B<E!D8@ME!89:!2=:<=@A!

<9I5=29M<93!B2=!@<8=959;Fbb!!

!

/&$$?;.)-1:.0%)$,";0/0)#!

!

0<B<97<7!GA!7D622@!:573=5D37!D89!36<9!G<!2I<=D2M<!GA!762459;!3683!36<!

<:?D835298@!H?735B5D83529!57!?972?9:E!2=!3683!89!8@3<=9835I<!>2@5DA!42?@:!8D65<I<!36<!78M<!

>?=>27<E!4536!@<77!:57D=5M59832=A!5M>8D3E!89:!42?@:!923!G<!?9=<87298G@A!<K><975I<!32!

5M>@<M<93F!!L<D8?7<!2B!36<!>=2G@<M!2B!7D622@!I52@<9D<E!53!57!?9@5]<@A!3683!8!7D622@\7!G875D!

H?735B5D83529!B2=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!g!8!78B<!@<8=959;!<9I5=29M<93!g!42?@:!G<!

D2975:<=<:!?972?9:F!`24<I<=E!8!68=76!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!D2?@:!G<!D68@@<9;<:!G<D8?7<!

2B!537!4<8]!=<@83529765>!32!36<!;28@!2B!M859385959;!7D622@!78B<3AF!![2=<2I<=E!36<!>2@5DA!

D2?@:!G<!D68@@<9;<:!B2=!68I59;!8@3<=9835I<7!3683!D2?@:!8DD2M>@576!36<!78M<!<:?D835298@!

>?=>27<7F!!.2=!597389D<E!8!M89:832=A!2?3Z2BZ7D622@!7?7><97529!>2@5DA!3683!

:57>=2>2=352983<@A!G?=:<9<:!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=!D2?@:!G<!=<>@8D<:!GA!8!>2@5DA!3683!8@@24<:!

7?7><9:<:!73?:<937!32!=<M859!83!7D622@E!G?3!7<>8=83<:!B=2M!36<5=!D@877M83<7E!B2=!

:57D5>@598=A!89:!78B<3A!=<87297F!

!

%7!8!>=8D35D8@!M833<=E!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M7!68I<!G<<9!?9:<=?35@5C<:!GA!73?:<937!

89:!8:I2D83<7E!87!4<@@!87!GA!B<:<=8@!D5I5@!=5;637!<9B2=D<M<93!8;<9D5<7F!m<3E!8!9?MG<=!2B!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!bP!.2=!72M<!7?;;<73<:!73835735D8@!3<737!59!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!D87<7E!7<<!&83=5D]!&8?]<9!c!&65@5>!)FfF!

0895<@E!6:/)$D0#/-0801:.0"1$:15$D0#:M0;0.=$D0#/-0801:.0"1$01$3/7"";$D0#/0(;01)>$?$')2:;$:15$3.:.0#.0/:;$

?1:;=#0#+$PWQ!#:?DF!"F!'<>F!VTQ!XbUUUYF!bb!)6<!236<=!=<@83<:!:<B<97<!57!3683!36<!:57>8=53A!59!5M>8D3!57!:?<!32!8!:57>8=53A!59!G<68I52=!8M29;!73?:<937F!

)657!:<B<97<!D89!G<!G2@73<=<:!GA!<I5:<9D<!762459;!3683!36<!:57>8=53A!487!D8?7<:!GA!3=<8359;!=<><83!

2BB<9:<=7!M2=<!68=76@AF!3))!K1$-)!*?MG<=@89:!*2?93A!-D622@!0573FE!PQ!+9:5I5:?8@7!4536!0578G5@535<7!#:?DF!

"F!'<>F!TUT!XPQQbY!XB59:59;!GA!(*'!3683!:57>8=53A!G<34<<9!G@8D]!89:!4653<!73?:<937!59!@<9;36!2B!><98@35<7!

487!:?<!32!G@8D]!73?:<937\!68I59;!@29;<=!65732=5<7!2B!>=52=!2BB<97<7YF!

! ++Zh

Page 83: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

D@877!8D3529!@847?537!68I<!=<7?@3<:!59!>=2:?D35I<!7<33@<M<937F!+9!6"##$%&$3:;.8:-#7E!B2=!

<K8M>@<E!36<!D2?=3!=<N?5=<:!36<!7D622@!:573=5D3!32!7<3!8!;28@!32!=<:?D<!36<!2I<=8@@!9?MG<=!

2B!7?7><975297!59!2=:<=!32!=<:?D<!36<!=8D58@!:57>8=53A!59!7?7><975297FbW!!%@362?;6!7D622@!

2BB5D58@7!:<95<:!89A!4=29;:259;E!36<!:573=5D3!8@72!8;=<<:!32!D29I<9<!8!D2MM533<<!32!

8::=<77!36<!:57>8=53A!59!:57D5>@59<!89:!32!65=<!8!D297?@3893!=<D2MM<9:<:!GA!36<!>@85935BB!

32!_8:I57<!36<!:<B<9:8937!89:!42=]!4536!36<!7D622@!:573=5D3!32!:<I<@2>!>@897!32!<@5M5983<!

=8D58@!:57>8=535<7!59!7?7><97529!=83<7FabS!!

!

*F!!%:M59573=835I<!*2M>@85937!4536!(*'!

!

)6<=<!8=<!@5M53835297!29!462!D89!B5@<!8!@847?53!59!D2?=3E!G?3!89A!D29D<=9<:!D535C<9!

D89!G=59;!8!B<:<=8@!)53@<!O+!8:M59573=835I<!D2M>@8593!29!G<68@B!2B!89236<=FbT!!)6<!>=5M8=A!

8;<9DA!D68=;<:!4536!<9B2=D<M<93!2B!)53@<!O+!57!36<!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529\7!

(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637!X(*'YE!465D6!687!34<@I<!=<;5298@!2BB5D<7!36=2?;62?3!36<!D2?93=AF!

$<9<=8@@AE!B5@59;!89!(*'!2=!236<=!8:M59573=835I<!D2M>@8593!45@@!923!>=<I<93!8!73?:<93!89:!

6<=!8:I2D83<!B=2M!38]59;!36<!M833<=!32!D2?=3F!

!

%7!8!=<7?@3!2B!(*'\7!>2@5DA!B8I2=59;!9<;235835297E!M273!(*'!D87<7!:2!923!=<7?@3!

59!B59:59;7!2B!I52@835297!2B!)53@<!O+FbR!+973<8:E!(*'!G<;597!9<;235835297!3248=:!8!

_=<72@?3529!8;=<<M<93a!<8=@A!59!36<!59I<735;832=A!>=2D<77FbV!!L<D8?7<!=<72@?3529!

8;=<<M<937!8=<!;<9<=8@@A!8I85@8G@<!32!36<!>?G@5D!29@A!?>29!:5=<D3!=<N?<73!>?=7?893!32!36<!

.=<<:2M!2B!+9B2=M83529!%D3E!53!57!:5BB5D?@3!32!7?=I<A!36<7<!8;=<<M<937!32!?9:<=7389:!624!

(*'!3A>5D8@@A!=<72@I<7!:57D5>@59<!D87<7F!)6<!B2@@2459;!7?MM8=A!2B!8!=<D<93!D68@@<9;<!

M8A!>=2I5:<!8!?7<B?@!459:24!5932!(*'\7!>=8D35D<7Fbh!

!

+9!n?9<!2B!PQQRE!8!D2M>@8593!487!B5@<:!8;85973!36<!%@8M<:8!`5;6!-D622@!59!

%@8M<:8E!*8@5B2=958E!738359;!342!D@85M7J!XPY!8!=8D58@@A!62735@<!<9I5=29M<93!<K573<:!4536!

=<7><D3!32!"83592!73?:<937^!89:!XbY!"83592!73?:<937!4<=<!3=<83<:!:5BB<=<93@A!D2M>8=<:!32!

4653<!73?:<937!59!36<!9?MG<=!2B!=<B<==8@7!89:!7?7><975297!89:!59!36<!7<I<=53A!2B!:57D5>@59<!

=<D<5I<:!B2=!36<!78M<!2=!75M5@8=!2BB<97<7FbQ!!(*'!=<N?<73<:!89:!=<D<5I<:!=<@<I893!:838!

B=2M!36<!7D622@!2I<=!8!36=<<ZA<8=!><=52:!2B!59I<735;83529!89:!9<;23583529F!!+9!36<!D2?=7<!

2B!36<!59I<735;83529E!(*'!593<=I5<4<:!>8=<937E!73?:<937E!89:!8:M59573=835I<!738BBE!89:!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!bW!3))!'277!IF!-8@3M8=76!TUU!.F!-?>>F!QWT!X-F0F,FmF!PQhUYF!bS!TUU!.F!-?>>F!83!QWQF!%::535298@@AE!36<!:573=5D3!8;=<<:!32!89!<KD689;<!2B!73835735D8@!59B2=M83529E!89:!36<!

D=<83529!2B!8!7?7><97529!@2;!B2=!36<!D297?@3893!32!=<I5<4!8!7<M<73<=!=<>2=3!762459;!B2=!<8D6!>=59D5>8@!2=!

7?><=593<9:<93J!!98M<!2B!36<!73?:<93E!=8D<E!;=8:<E!=<B<==59;!3<8D6<=E!2BB<97<E!:83<!2B!7?7><97529E!7?7><9:59;!

2BB5D58@E!:83<!2B!=<3?=9!89:!@<9;36!2B!7?7><97529F!K5&!83!QSUZSPF!bT!Sb!/F-F*F!bUUU:^!WS!*F.F'F!dPUUFVXGYF!bR!-383<M<93!GA!%=3!*2@<M89E!&89<@573!83!f<99<:A!-D622@!*29B<=<9D<!29!#:?D83529!-389:8=:7!!X%>=F!bQE!

bUUUYF!bV!3))$)&2&+$$/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637!*87<!'<72@?3529![89?8@!

X633>Jll444F<:F;2Il2BB5D<7l(*'l2D=MF63M@Y!bh!3))!&8?@!$=277M89E!*65<B!'<;5298@!%332=9<A!X'<;529!+eYE!"<33<=!32!0<9957!*68D2987E!-?><=593<9:<93E!

%@8M<:8!*53A!/95B5<:!-D6F!0573FE!=<J!02D]<3!,2F!UQZURZPbQP!X(D32G<=!hE!PQQQY!o29!B5@<!4536!)6<!*5I5@!

'5;637!&=2H<D3pF!bQ!)6<!:57D5>@59<!D29D<=97!4<=<!<K8D<=G83<:!46<9!8!4653<!73?:<93E!462!8:M533<:!_38;;59;a!8!G836=22M!

48@@!=<D<5I<:!92!>?9576M<93!465@<!8!"83592!A2?36!487!7?7><9:<:!B2=!B5I<!:8A7!B2=!8!75M5@8=!;=8BB535!8D3F!K5&$

! ++ZQ

Page 84: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

597><D3<:!73?:<93!B5@<7!89:!:57D5>@59<!=<D2=:7F!!%B3<=!D2M>@<359;!59I<735;83529!89:!

9<;235835297E!36<!8;<9DA!D29D@?:<:!3683!36<!7D622@!:573=5D3!:5:!923!:57D=5M5983<!8;85973!

"83592!73?:<937!59!36<!:57><9783529!2B!:57D5>@59<!2=!8@@24!8!=8D58@@A!62735@<!<9I5=29M<93!32!

<K573F!

!

`24<I<=E!59!36<!D2?=7<!2B!537!59I<735;83529E!(*'!B2?9:!3683!36<!=83<7!2B!:57D5>@59<!

2B!"83592!89:!%B=5D89!%M<=5D89!73?:<937!4<=<!:57>=2>2=352983<@A!65;6F!)6<!:57>8=53A!487!

M273!9238G@<!59!8!9?MG<=!2B!:57D5>@59<!D83<;2=5<7!59D@?:59;!_:<B589D<!2B!8?362=53AFa!!

L<34<<9!PQQR!89:!PQQQE!36<!0573=5D3!=<>2=3<:!32!(*'!537!>=2;=<77!59!8::=<7759;!36<!

:57>8=53A!89:!2I<=!3657!><=52:E!8DD2=:59;!32!(*'E!7?DD<77B?@@A!=<:?D<:!36<!:57D5>@59<!

=83<7!B2=!8@@!73?:<937!453659!89!8DD<>38G@<!=89;<F!

!

(*'!42=]<:!4536!36<!7D622@!32!5M>@<M<93!8!>@89!32!=<:?D<!:57D5>@59<!=83<!59!8@@!

537!65;6!7D622@7F!)6<!:573=5D3!68:!595358@@A!=<:?D<:!537!=83<!2B!:57D5>@598=A!59D5:<937!B=2M!

bETbV!:?=59;!PQQTZQR!32!hTh!59D5:<937!59!PQQRZQVFWU!!)6<!:573=5D3!<M>@2A<:!8!=89;<!2B!

73=83<;5<7!59D@?:59;!XPY!898@AC59;!537!:57D5>@59<!:838E!:578;;=<;83<:!GA!=8D<!89:!<3695D53A!

B2=!:57>8=535<7!89:!=<I5<459;!53!4536!738BB^!XbY!:<I<@2>59;!D29B@5D3!=<72@?3529!3<8M7!M8:<!

?>!2B!73?:<937^!XWY!D=<8359;!><<=!D2?97<@59;!;=2?>7^!XSY!<738G@57659;!8!"83592!L2A7!*@?G^!

89:!XTY!62@:59;!42=]762>7!3683!:5=<D3@A!8::=<77<:!577?<7!2B!=8D<F!!,29<36<@<77E!<I<9!

362?;6!36<!=83<7!2B!7?7><97529!D29359?<:!32!:<D=<87<!59!PQQVZQh!A<8=E!(*'!>=<77<:!36<!

7D622@!32!=<:?D<!36<!:57>8=53A!59!:57D5>@59<!B2=!%B=5D89!%M<=5D89!89:!"83592!73?:<937FWP!

!

)6<!:573=5D3!=<7>29:<:!GA!<M>@2A59;!8::535298@!73=83<;5<7E!59D@?:59;!62@:59;!8!

=<3=<83!B2=!8:M59573=835I<!738BB!29!:5I<=753A!848=<9<77!89:!577?<7!=<;8=:59;!=8D58@!

73<=<23A>59;E!>=2B5@59;E!89:!D2MM?95D83529!73A@<7F!!&8=35D?@8=!833<93529!487!7><93!29!624!

:<B589D<!2B!8?362=53A!59D5:<937!68:!G<<9!:573=5G?3<:!8D=277!=8D58@!89:!<3695D!@59<7F!(*'!

=<I5<4<:!:838!B=2M!36<!PQQhZQQ!7D622@!A<8=!89:!B2?9:!3683!59!8@@!D83<;2=5<7!2B!73?:<93!

:57D5>@59<E!59D@?:59;!:<B589D<!2B!8?362=53AE!"83592!89:!%B=5D89!%M<=5D89!73?:<937!4<=<!

453659!PFUb!>25937!2B!36<!38=;<3!;28@7F!!(*'!D@27<:!36<!D87<!G87<:!29!8!B59:59;!2B!92!

I52@83529!29!36<!2=5;598@!D@85M7!89:!877?=89D<7!3683!36<!:573=5D3!42?@:!D29359?<!32!42=]!

3248=:!=<:?D59;!36<!:57D5>@59<!=83<7!B2=!%B=5D89!%M<=5D89!89:!"83592!73?:<937F!

!

0F!!"5M53835297!29!#9B2=D<M<93!

!

057D?775297!4536!(*'!59I<735;832=7!76<:!@533@<!@5;63!29!46<36<=!%@8M<:8!57!

3A>5D8@!2B!59I<735;835297!2B!:57D=5M5983529!59!7D622@!:57D5>@59<F!-3?:<937!89:!8:I2D83<7!

762?@:!?9:<=7389:E!624<I<=E!3683!36<!D2M>@8593!>=2D<77!:2<7!923!8@48A7!@<8:!32!7?DD<77E!

89:!(*'!<9B2=D<M<93!D89!G<!59D297573<93F!!(9<!>=2G@<M!57!3683!(*'!687!923!577?<:!D@<8=!

;?5:89D<!29!:57D5>@59<!59I<735;835297!89:!36<=<!M8A!G<!75;95B5D893!:5BB<=<9D<7!59!36<!@<I<@!

2B!7D=?359A!:<><9:59;!29!36<!=<;529!2=!36<!59I<735;832=F!![2=<2I<=E!36<!8I85@8G5@53A!2B!8!

@<77!:57D=5M59832=A!8@3<=9835I<!57!2B!D=535D8@!@<;8@!75;95B5D89D<!?9:<=!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!

898@A757F!)6<!B8D3!3683E!8B3<=!D29359?2?7!>=<77?=<E!36<!%@8M<:8!0573=5D3!G=2?;63!36<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!WU!%DD2=:59;!32!8!@<33<=!B=2M!(*'\7!D65<B!=<;5298@!8332=9<A!=<I5<459;!36<!7D622@\7!>=2;=<77!59B2=M59;!36<!

7?><=593<9:<93!3683!36<!D87<!487!D@27<:F!K5F!WP!(*'!:5:!923!B59:!73835735D8@@A!75;95B5D893!:57>8=83<!=83<7!B2=!236<=!<3695D!;=2?>7F!K5&$

! ++ZPU

Page 85: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

:57>8=535<7!59!:57D5>@59<!:249!7?;;<737!3683E!5B!>=<77?=<:E!M89A!7D622@7!D2?@:!8D65<I<!

75M5@8=!=<7?@37F!)2!36<!<K3<93!3683!(*'!B85@7!32!<M>@2A!36<!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!898@A757!32!

@<I<=8;<!=<:?D35297!59!36<!;=277!=8D58@!89:!<3695D!:57>8=535<7!59!:57D5>@59<E!36<!8;<9DA!

M577<7!D=535D8@!2>>2=3?9535<7!32!>=23<D3!M592=53A!D65@:=<9!B=2M!59H?735D<F!

!!

(*'\7!=<72@?3529!8;=<<M<93!8>>=28D6!57!8!72?9:!;<9<=8@!>2@5DAE!G?3!;5I<9!36<!

65732=5D8@!><=7573<9D<!2B!;=277!:57>8=535<7!59!:57D5>@59<E!36<!M8;953?:<!2B!36<!9<;835I<!

5M>8D3!29!D65@:=<9E!89:!36<!59D=<8759;!36<!9?MG<=7!2B!M592=535<7!=<M2I<:!B=2M!7D622@E!

(*'!D2?@:!38]<!8!M2=<!8;;=<775I<!<9B2=D<M<93!8>>=28D6F!!)6<!8;<9DA!762?@:!D29:?D3!

M2=<!D2M>=<6<975I<!D2M>@589D<!=<I5<47!29!:57D5>@59<E!89:!M2:5BA!537!73=29;!>=<B<=<9D<!

B2=!=<72@?3529!8;=<<M<937!GA!577?59;!B59:59;7!2B!I52@83529!59!:57D5>@59<!D87<7!32!

=<D8@D53=893!:573=5D37F!)6<!D29:535297!:<7D=5G<:!59!3657!=<>2=3!D=A!2?3!B2=!M2=<!833<93529!32!

=8D58@!89:!<3695D!:57>8=535<7!59!7D622@!:57D5>@59<F!LA!:259;!@<77E!(*'!8G=2;83<7!537!:?3A!32!

<9B2=D<!36<!@84!89:!32!<:?D83<!36<!>?G@5D!8G2?3!4683!36<!@84!=<N?5=<7F!

(

&&1((23456("+,*3/*0,)7(>,+(?*.-3)*7(@0*A(%075B060*037(

!

(I<=I5<4!

!

-3?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!8=<!2B3<9!:57>=2>2=352983<@A!=<>=<7<93<:!8M29;!73?:<937!

462!8=<!:57D5>@59<:!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!-><D58@!<:?D83529!73?:<937!8=<!

75;95B5D893@A!2I<==<>=<7<93<:!8M29;!36<!=89]7!2B!7?7><9:<:!73?:<937E!59!M89A!:573=5D37!

=<>=<7<9359;!29<!365=:!2=!M2=<!2B!8@@!7?7><975297FWb![2=<2I<=E!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=E!

B=<N?<93@A!M57@8G<@<:!87!G<59;!_M<938@@A!=<38=:<:Ea!8=<!2I<==<>=<7<93<:!8M29;!73?:<937!

4536!:578G5@535<7F!"847!3683!>=23<D3!59:5I5:?8@7!4536!:578G5@535<7!B=2M!:57D=5M5983529!89:!

3683!;?8=893<<!89!8>>=2>=583<!<:?D83529!B2=!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!2BB<=!5M>2=3893!

78B<;?8=:7!B2=!73?:<937!462!M8A!G<!7?GH<D3<:!32!:57D5>@59<!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!

!

)6=<<!B<:<=8@!7383?3<7!>=2I5:<!G875D!>=23<D35297!B2=!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7F!!

-<D3529!TUS!2B!36<!'<68G5@5383529!%D3!2B!PQVW!89:!)53@<!++!2B!36<!%M<=5D897!4536!

0578G5@535<7!%D3!2B!PQQU!>=265G53!:57D=5M5983529!8;85973!><=7297!4536!:578G5@535<7!GA!

>?G@5D!7D622@7F!)6<!+9:5I5:?8@7!4536!0578G5@535<7!59!#:?D83529!%D3!X+0#%Y!<738G@576<7!

=5;637!89:!>=23<D35297!B2=!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!89:!36<5=!B8M5@5<7F!

!

)6<!@847!>=23<D359;!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!2BB<=!89!8==8A!2B!=5;637E!G236!

7?G738935I<!89:!>=2D<:?=8@F!%3!8!M595M?ME!36<!@84!=<N?5=<7!3683!7D622@7!>=2I5:<!8!B=<<!

89:!8>>=2>=583<!>?G@5D!<:?D83529!X.%&#YWW!32!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!462!8=<!<KD@?:<:!

B=2M!7D622@!B2=!M2=<!3689!PU!:8A7!B2=!:57D5>@598=A!=<87297FWS!!.?=36<=M2=<E!36<!@84!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Wb!3))$f+[!L'((f-E!#)!%"FE!-*`(("!`(/-#!`m&#J!)i(!m#%'-!"%)#'!PQ!Xn?735D<!&2@5DA!+97353?3<l!

*65@:=<9\7!"84!*<93<=E!%>=F!bUUUY!o6<=<598B3<=!-D622@!`2?7<!`A><pF!WW!)6<!:<B5953529!2B!.%&#!57!7<3!2?3!83!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSUPXhYF!WS!3))$WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFWUUX8Y^!#))$:;#"!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPbX8YXPYX%YF!0<7>53<!?9<N?5I2D8@!@89;?8;<!59!36<!

%D3!537<@BE!36<!9<4!PQQQ!=<;?@835297!>=2M?@;83<:!GA!36<!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529!:2!923!=<N?5=<!3683!

.%&#!G<!>=2I5:<:!?935@!8!D65@:!687!G<<9!7?7><9:<:!B2=!8!3238@!2B!3<9!7D622@!:8A7!59!36<!78M<!7D622@!A<8=F!

3))$#5@<<9!(=:2I<=E!D0#/0(;01:-=$9O/;4#0"1$"G$3.45)1.#$C0.7$D0#:M0;0.0)#E!*"#%'+,$`(/-#!'#OFE!83!TP!

X[8AZn?9<!bUUUYF!

! ++ZPP

Page 86: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

>=2I5:<7!>=23<D35297!8;85973!:57D=5M59832=A!:57D5>@59<!89:!<KD@?7529!B2=!D65@:=<9!4536!

:578G5@535<7F!-><D5B5D8@@AE!8:M59573<=59;!>?9576M<93!B2=!D29:?D3!3683!57!8!M895B<7383529!2B!

:578G5@53A!57!8!>=265G53<:!B2=M!2B!:57D=5M5983529FWT!!#K8M>@<7!2B!3657!3A><!2B!>?9576M<93!

68I<!59D@?:<:!38>59;!D@27<:!8!73?:<93\7!M2?36!B2=!<KD<775I<!38@]59;!=<@83<:!32!M<938@!

=<38=:83529E!:=2>>59;!8!73?:<93!B=2M!36<!7D622@\7!=2@@7!B2=!:578G5@53AZ=<@83<:!38=:59<77E!89:!

D2=>2=8@!>?9576M<93FWR!

!

)6<!B2@@2459;!898@A757!:57D?77<7!36<!@84!>=23<D359;!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7E!89:!

57!:5I5:<:!5932!342!>8=37F!)6<!B5=73!>8=3!:57D?77<7!48A7!59!465D6!7?7><975297!89:!

<K>?@75297!D89!G<!D68@@<9;<:!29!89!59:5I5:?8@!G8757!>?=7?893!32!+0#%F!)6<!7<D29:!>8=3!

<K8M59<7!36<2=5<7!2B!:57D=5M5983529!3683!D89!G<!?7<:!32!D68@@<9;<!:57D5>@59<!>2@5D5<7!

7A73<M5D8@@AF!

!

-3?:<937!89:!8:I2D83<7!762?@:!?9:<=7389:!3683!:578G5@53A!@84!57!8!65;6@A!3<D695D8@!

89:!D2M>@<K!B5<@:E!4536!M89A!=<;?@835297!89:!>=2D<:?=<7F!)6<!59B2=M83529!D293859<:!59!

3657!%>><9:5K!>=2I5:<7!29@A!8!G875D!2I<=I5<4!2B!36<!@84E!89:!53!762?@:!923!G<!8!7?G7353?3<!

B2=!M2=<!:<385@<:!3=<83M<937!2B!:578G5@53A!@84F!)6<=<!8=<E!B2=!<K8M>@<E!5M>2=3893!

:57359D35297!G<34<<9!+0#%E!36<!9<4!+0#%!=<;?@835297E!89:!-<D3529!TUS!2B!36<!

'<68G5@5383529!%D3!3683!8=<!923!:57D?77<:!59!:<385@!59!3657!%>><9:5KFWV!!-3?:<937!89:!

8:I2D83<7!762?@:!D2975:<=!D297?@359;!4536!8332=9<A7!89:!<:?D83529!7><D58@5737!462!B2D?7!

29!:578G5@53AZ=<@83<:!577?<7!46<9!D2975:<=59;!8!D68@@<9;<!32!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DAF!!

!

%F!!+9:5I5:?8@!&=23<D35297!/9:<=!36<!0578G5@53A!"847!

!

+F! -<D3529!TUS!2B!36<!'<68G5@5383529!%D3!2B!PQVWWh!89:!)53@<!++!2B!36<!

%M<=5D897!4536!0578G5@535<7!%D3WQ!8=<!B<:<=8@!8935:57D=5M5983529!@847!3683!>=265G53!

:57D=5M5983529!G87<:!29!:578G5@53A!89:!8=<!8>>@5D8G@<!59!>?G@5D!7D622@7F!)2!

75M>@5BA!36<!898@A757!6<=<E!8@@!B?=36<=!=<B<=<9D<7!59!3657!%>><9:5K!32!-<D3529!TUS!

D89!G<!877?M<:!32!D2I<=!)53@<!++!87!4<@@E!G<D8?7<!2B!>8=8@@<@!@89;?8;<!89:!

593<=>=<3835297!2B!36<!@847F!!

!

++F! )6<!+9:5I5:?8@7!4536!0578G5@535<7!59!#:?D83529!%D3!X+0#%YSU!57!8!

B<:<=8@!@84!465D6!D2938597!>=2I575297!3683!;=893!B<:<=8@!B?9:7!B2=!537!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!WT!3))$)&2&+$bQ!/F-F*F!d!VQS^!WS!*F.F'F!dd!PUSFWXHYE!PUSFSXGYE!PUSFWWE!PUSFWT!XPQQQY^!Sb!/F-F*F!d!PbPWbF!WR!3))$(=:2I<=E!#4(-:!923<!WSE!83!TSF!WV!.2=!8!362=2?;6!=<I5<4E!7<<$#5@<<9!(=:2I<=E!D0#/0(;01:-=$9O/;4#0"1$"G$3.45)1.#$C0.7$D0#:M0;0.0)#E!

*@<8=59;62?7<!'<I5<4E!X[8AZn?9<!bUUUYF!!%::535298@!M83<=58@7!89:!72?=D<7!29!3657!7?GH<D3!8=<!8I85@8G@<!29!

36<!4<G!753<!2B!)6<!*5I5@!'5;637!&=2H<D3!83!`8=I8=:!/95I<=753AJ!444F@84F68=I8=:F<:?l;=2?>7lD5I5@=5;637F!Wh!bQ!/F-F*F!d!VQSF!WQ!Sb!/F-F*F!dd!PbPUP!).$#)PF!SU!bU!/F-F*F!PSUU!).$#)PF!.2=!8!B?@@!:57D?77529!2B!=<N?5=<:!>=2D<:?=<7!89:!>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7!7<<$#5@<<9!

(=:2I<=E!(I<=I5<4J!#:?D83529!'5;637!2B!*65@:=<9!i536!0578G5@535<7!/9:<=!36<!+9:5I5:?8@7!i536!

0578G5@535<7!#:?D83529!%D3!89:!-<D3529!TUS!2B!36<!'<68G5@5383529!%D3!2B!PQVW$XPQQQY!X8I85@8G@<!B=2M!36<!

*<93<=!B2=!"84!89:!#:?D83529E!PhVT!*299<D35D?3!%I<FE!-?53<!TPUE!i87659;329E!0*!bUUUQ^!bUbFQhRFWUUUY^!

7))$:;#"$L8C<@29!*<93<=!.2=![<938@!`<8@36E!%!,<4!+0#%J!%!&8=<93\7!$?5:<!32!36<!*689;<7!59!-><D58@!

#:?D83529!"84!B2=!*65@:=<9!4536!0578G5@535<7+$XPQQQY!X8I85@8G@<!29!@59<!83!633>Jll444FG8C<@29F2=;YF!

! ++ZPb

Page 87: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

5M>@<M<9383529!89:!>=2I5:<7!>=2D<:?=8@!=5;637!89:!<9353@<M<937!32!<@5;5G@<!

59:5I5:?8@7!89:!36<5=!>8=<937!2=!;?8=:5897F!+0#%!8@72!687!:<385@<:!=<N?5=<M<937!

=<;8=:59;!=<>2=359;!89:!M29532=59;!2B!537!>=2I575297!GA!7383<!;2I<=9M<93F!%M29;!

36<7<!=<N?5=<M<937!8=<!36<!7383<!2G@5;83529!32!M29532=!7D622@!:573=5D37!B2=!>23<9358@!

:57D=5M5983529!59!7?7><975297!89:!<K>?@75297!2B!D65@:=<9!4536!:578G5@535<7ESP!89:!

36<!7383<!2G@5;83529!32!D2@@<D3!89:!<K8M59<!:838!32!:<3<=M59<!5B!75;95B5D893!

:57>8=535<7!<K573!59!36<!5:<935B5D83529!89:!>@8D<M<93!2B!73?:<937!2B!D2@2=FSb!

!

+++F! )6<!PQQV(8M<9:M<937!32!36<!+0#%!8::<:!:57D5>@59<!>=2I575297!32!

36<!%D3!89:!D2:5B5<:!7D622@7\!2G@5;835297!32!<:?D83<!8@@!D65@:=<9!4536!:578G5@535<7E!

59D@?:59;!3627<!4536!G<68I52=8@!>=2G@<M7F!!%!D2=9<=7329<!2B!36<!@84!57!3683!5B!8!

D65@:!4536!8!:578G5@53A!<K65G537!G<68I52=8@!M895B<73835297!2B!6<=!:578G5@53AE!36<!

G<68I52=!57!32!G<!3=<83<:!87!89!<:?D835298@!577?<!89:!36<!D65@:!57!32!G<!>=2I5:<:!

4536!8>>=2>=583<!7<=I5D<7!89:!7?>>2=37FSW!!%9!<N?8@@A!5M>2=3893!D2M>29<93!2B!

+0#%!57!3683!8!B=<<!89:!8>>=2>=583<!>?G@5D!<:?D83529!X.%&#Y!M?73!G<!>=2I5:<:!_32!

8@@!D65@:=<9!4536!:578G5@535<7!F!F!F!G<34<<9!36<!8;<7!2B!W!89:!bP!F!F!F!59D@?:59;!

D65@:=<9!4536!:578G5@535<7!462!68I<!G<<9!7?7><9:<:!2=!<K><@@<:!B=2M!7D622@FaSS!!!

!

PF!!-?7><975297!89:![895B<7383529!`<8=59;7!

(

(/9:<=!+0#%!89:!537!=<D<93@A!>?G@576<:!=<;?@835297E!7D622@!8?362=535<7!8=<!

><=M533<:!32!7?7><9:!8!D65@:!B2=!?>!32!3<9!D297<D?35I<!:8A7!G<B2=<!36<A!8=<!=<N?5=<:!32!

:<3<=M59<!46<36<=!36<!3=5;;<=59;!M57D29:?D3!487!8!M895B<7383529!2B!36<!D65@:\7!

:578G5@535<7FST!)6<!:<3<=M5983529!M?73!38]<!36<!B2=M!2B!8!_M895B<7383529!6<8=59;Fa!-D622@7!

M8A!8@72!G<!=<N?5=<:!32!62@:!8!M895B<7383529!6<8=59;!46<=<!D?M?@835I<!7?7><975297!

D297353?3<!8!>833<=9!2B!<KD@?7529!89:!8::!?>!32!M2=<!3689!PU!:8A7FSR!

!

%!M895B<7383529!6<8=59;!57!8!=<I5<4!2B!36<!=<@83529765>!G<34<<9!36<!M57D29:?D3!83!

577?<!89:!36<!D65@:\7!:578G5@53AFSV!/9:<=!+0#%E!36<!59:5I5:?8@5C<:!<:?D83529!>=2;=8M!

X+#&Y!3<8M!D29:?D37!36<!6<8=59;!8@29;!4536!236<=!_N?8@5B5<:!><=7299<@FaSh!)6<!

M895B<7383529!6<8=59;!:5BB<=7!B=2M!=<;?@8=!+#&!3<8M!M<<359;7!89:!:<D575297!G<D8?7<!36<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!SP!3))$WS!*F.F'F!dWUUFPSR!X8YZXGY^!bU!/F-F*F!RPbX8YXbbYF!!Sb!3))!WS!*F.F'F!dWUUFTPQ^!bU!/F-F*F!PSPTX]YF!SW!3))+$)&2&+$bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPSX:YXWYXLY!X5B!D65@:\7!G<68I52=!5M><:<7!36<!D65@:\7!@<8=959;!2=!3683!2B!236<=7E!

36<!59:5I5:?8@5C<:!<:?D83529!>=2;=8M!M?73!59D@?:<!73=83<;5<7!89:!7?>>2=37E!59D@?:59;!>27535I<!G<68I52=8@!

593<=I<935297E!32!8::=<77!3683!G<68I52=YF!!SS!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPbX8YXPYF!#KD<>35297!<K573!B2=!D65@:=<9!8;<7!WZT!89:!PhZbPF!3))$bU!/F-F*F!dPSPbX8YXPYXLY^!

WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFPbbF!ST!bU!/F-F*F!dd!PSPTX]YXPYX%YX+YE!X]YXSYX%Y^!WS!*F.F'F!dWUUFTbWX8YF!SR!WS!*F.F'F!dd!WUUFTPQE!WUUFTbWX8YF!_i683!D297353?3<7!8!>833<=9!57!923!:<B59<:!59!36<!=<;?@835297F!!

`24<I<=E!36<!/F-F!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529!(BB5D<!B2=!*5I5@!'5;637!687!@29;!8>>@5<:!8!75M5@8=!=?@<!59!

<9B2=D59;!-<D3529!TUSFa!$(=:2I<=E!#4(-:$923<!WSE!83!TbF!SV!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXSYX%Y^!WS!*F.F'F!WUUFTbWX8YXPYF!Sh!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXSYXLY^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbWXGYF!!-<D3529!TUS!75M5@8=@A!=<N?5=<7!3683!36<!7D622@!

7A73<M!D29:?D3!8!D2M>=<6<975I<!<I8@?83529!M<<359;!G<B2=<!833<M>359;!32!<KD@?:<!8!73?:<93!B2=!M2=<!3689!

3<9!:8A7!G<D8?7<!7?D6!@<9;36A!<KD@?75297!3=5;;<=!36<!=<N?5=<M<937!B2=!!_D689;<!2B!>@8D<M<93FaWS!*F.F'F!d!

PUSFWTE!PUSFWRF!

! ++ZPW

Page 88: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

M895B<7383529!=<I5<4!M?73!G<!D29:?D3<:!GA!36<!+#&!3<8M!32;<36<=!4536!236<=!N?8@5B5<:!

><=7299<@FSQ!)6<!3<8M!M?73!D2975:<=!8@@!=<@<I893!59B2=M83529E!59D@?:59;!36<!>8=<93\7!

2G7<=I835297!89:!36<!=<7?@37!2B!<I8@?835297!>=<7<93<:!GA!<K><=37!59I53<:!GA!36<!>8=<937!32!

833<9:FTU!

!

)6<!+#&!3<8M!M8A!:<3<=M59<!3683!36<!M57D29:?D3!487!8!923!8!M895B<7383529!2B!

:578G5@53A!29@A!5B!:;;$2B!36<!B2@@2459;!D29:535297!8=<!M<3JTP!XPY!59!=<@83529765>!32!36<!

G<68I52=!83!577?<E!36<!D65@:\7!+#&!89:!>@8D<M<93!4<=<!8>>=2>=583<E!89:!8@@!7<=I5D<7!4<=<!

5M>@<M<93<:!59!8DD2=:89D<!4536!36<!+#&^!XbY!36<!D65@:\7!:578G5@53A!:5:!923!5M>85=!36<!

D65@:\7!8G5@53A!32!?9:<=7389:!36<!5M>8D3!89:!D297<N?<9D<7!2B!36<!G<68I52=!83!577?<^!89:!

XWY!36<!:578G5@53A!:5:!923!5M>85=!36<!D65@:\7!8G5@53A!32!D293=2@!36<!G<68I52=!59!N?<73529FTb!

!

+9!M89A!D87<7!2I<=3?=959;!8!:573=5D3\7!:<D57529!32!7?7><9:!8!73?:<93!4536!8!

:578G5@53AE!36<!=<I5<459;!8?362=53A!:<3<=M59<:!3683!36<!M895B<7383529!6<8=59;!487!923!

D29:?D3<:!59!36<!>=2><=!M899<=F!.2=!<K8M>@<E!59!29<!=<D<93!D87<!59![599<7238E!8!B5B3<<9Z

A<8=Z2@:!73?:<93!462!487!5:<935B5<:!87!+0#%Z<@5;5G@<!29!36<!G8757!2B!89!<M235298@l!

G<68I52=8@!:572=:<=!487!7?7><9:<:!89:!?@35M83<@A!3=897B<==<:!32!89!8@3<=9835I<!7D622@!B2=!

>277<77529!2B!8!_4<8>29a!D29757359;!2B!>5<D<7!2B!8!>8593G8@@!;?9FTW!!)6<!73?:<93!68:!G<<9!

>@8A59;!4536!36<!>8593G8@@!;?9E!465D6!G<@29;<:!32!8!B=5<9:E!36<!95;63!G<B2=<!89:!68:!

D@<89<:!53!B2=!36<!249<=F!)6<!9<K3!:8AE!36<!B=5<9:!D8@@<:!89:!87]<:!36<!73?:<93!32!=<3?=9!

36<!>8593G8@@!;?9F!)6<!73?:<93!>?3!36<!:57877<MG@<:!D2M>29<937!2B!36<!>8593G8@@!;?9!59!8!

G8D]>8D]E!G=2?;63!36<M!29!36<!7D622@!G?7E!89:!689:<:!36<!G8D]>8D]!32!657!B=5<9:F!)6<=<!

487!92!<I5:<9D<E!89:!36<!:573=5D3!:5:!923!7?;;<73E!3683!36<!73?:<93!593<9:<:!32!:2!89A3659;!

G?3!32!=<3?=9!36<!>8=37E!465D6!:5:!923!59D@?:<!36<!>8593G8@@7!2=!537!>=2><@@8937F!+9!62@:59;!

B2=!36<!>8=<937E!36<!8:M59573=835I<!@84!H?:;<!B2?9:!3683!36<!73?:<93\7!+#&!3<8M!5M>=2><=@A!

:<3<=M59<:!3683!36<!73?:<93\7!G<68I52=!487!923!8!M895B<7383529!2B!657!:578G5@53AF!)6<!

H?:;<!7383<:J!_)6<!<I5:<9D<!487!D@<8=!3683!36<!73?:<93\7!:578G5@53AE!465D6!487!

D68=8D3<=5C<:!GA!5M>?@75I53A!89:!B85@?=<!32!D2975:<=!36<!D297<N?<9D<7!2B!657!8D35297E!

5M>85=<:!657!8G5@53A!32!D293=2@!657!G<68I52=FaTS!

!

8F!!.59:59;!2B!8![895B<7383529!2B!0578G5@53A!

!

#I<9!5B!36<!=<I5<459;!3<8M!89:!236<=!N?8@5B5<:!><=7299<@!:<3<=M59<!3683!8!

73?:<93\7!G<68I52=!57!8!M895B<7383529!2B!:578G5@53AE!36<!7D622@!M8A!735@@!7<<]!32!D689;<!36<!

D65@:\7!<:?D835298@!>=2;=8M!2=!>@8D<M<93!8DD2=:59;!32!36<!=<;?@8=!>=2D<:?=<7!?9:<=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!SQ!_o)p6<!59D@?7529!2B!3657!>=2I57529!59!36<!@84!o236<=!N?8@5B5<:!><=7299<@p!76247!3683!*29;=<77!=<D2;95C<:!

3683!59:5I5:?8@5C<:!<:?D83529!>=2;=8M!3<8M7!8@29<!:5:!923!68I<!36<!<K><=357<!32!:<3<=M59<!36<!=<@83529765>!

G<34<<9!:578G5@53A!89:!G<68I52=F!!)6<!qN?8@5B5<:!><=7299<@\!462!7?>>@<M<93!36<!o+#&p3<8M!M?73!G=59;!3657!

<K><=357<!32!36<!;=2?>!89:!<98G@<!53!32!<I8@?83<!36<!B8D32=7!@573<:!8G2I<!59!=<;8=:!32!8!>8=35D?@8=!D65@:Fa!

(=:2I<=E!#4(-:$923<!WSE!83!ThF!TU!3))$bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXSYX+Y^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbWXPYF!TP!3))$WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbWX:YF!Tb!!bU!/F-F*!d!PSPTX]YXSYX55Y^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbWXbYF!TW!3))$K1$-)$+9:<><9:<93!-D6F!0573F!,2F!bVQE!(77<2!%=<8!-D6F!X[8A!bhE!PQQQYF!%7!>8=3!2B!36<!62@:59;E!36<!

%"n!:<3<=M59<:!3683!36<!D2M>29<937!2B!36<!>8593!G8@@!;?9!B85@<:!32!M<<3!36<!:<B5953529!2B!8!4<8>29!87!

:<B59<:!GA!36<!/953<:!-383<7!4<8>297!D2:<F!!TS!K5&$

! ++ZPS

Page 89: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

+0#%F!+9!M273!D87<7E!29D<!8!M895B<7383529!2B!:578G5@53A!57!B2?9:E!36<!7D622@!M8A!923!

7?7><9:!2=!<K><@!36<!73?:<93FTT![2=<2I<=E!>8=<937!M8A!D68@@<9;<!36<!7D622@\7!>=2>27<:!

D689;<7!89:!=<N?<73!8!6<8=59;!>?=7?893!32!+0#%!89:!5M>@<M<9359;!7383<!@84!89:!

=<;?@835297F!

!

[2=<!5M>2=3893@AE!?9:<=!36<!@84\7!_738A!>?3a!>=2I575297E!36<!7D622@!7A73<M!M8A!

923!D689;<!36<!D65@:\7!>@8D<M<93!?95@83<=8@@AFTR!)6<!_738A!>?3a!=<N?5=<M<93!57!D=535D8@!

G<D8?7<!53!M595M5C<7!36<!:57=?>3529!2B!36<!D65@:\7!<:?D835298@!>=2;=8M!89:!7<9:7!36<!

M<778;<!32!7D622@7!3683!36<A!D89923!?7<!7?7><975297!89:!<K>?@75297!87!8!48A!2B!=5::59;!

36<!7D622@7!2B!7><D58@!<:?D83529!73?:<937F![2=<2I<=E!36<!6<8=59;!>=2D<77E!B=2M!36<!595358@!

=<N?<73!32!36<!<K68?73529!2B!8>><8@7E!D89!38]<!8!I<=A!@29;!35M<F!(9D<!=<9:<=<:E!36<!7383<!

8:M59573=835I<!:<D57529!D89!G<!8>><8@<:!32!7383<!2=!B<:<=8@!D2?=3E!89:!36<!_738A!>?3a!

>=2I57529!D2I<=7!36<!><=52:!2B!8>><8@!87!4<@@FTV!

!

+0#%!>=23<D35297!8=<!8@72!D=535D8@!59!>=<I<9359;!36<!=2?359;!2B!73?:<937!4536!

:578G5@535<7!5932!36<!D=5M598@!H?735D<!7A73<MF!!+9!Q"-2:1$%&$H7-0#$'&ETh!8!B<:<=8@!D2?=3!2B!

8>><8@7!6<@:!3683!8!7D622@!68:!I52@83<:!+0#%!GA!B85@59;!32!35M<@A!<I8@?83<!8!73?:<93!4536!

%33<93529!0<B5D53!`A><=8D35I53A!0572=:<=!X%0`0Y!89:!833<M>359;!32!?7<!36<!H?I<95@<!

D2?=3!>=2D<77!32!D689;<!657!<:?D835298@!>@8D<M<93E!45362?3!B2@@2459;!>=2><=!+0#%!

>=2D<:?=<7F!!)6<!D2?=3!=?@<:!3683!36<!7D622@\7!B5@59;!2B!8!:<@59N?<9DA!><353529!D297353?3<:!

8!D689;<!59!<:?D835298@!>@8D<M<93!3683!<9353@<:!36<!73?:<93!32!+0#%!>=23<D35297E!

59D@?:59;!36<!M<<359;!2B!36<!+#&!3<8M!>=52=!32!36<!>=2>27<:!>@8D<M<93!D689;<F!)6<!H7-0#$

'&!D87<!36?7!687!5M>2=3893!5M>@5D835297!B2=!8::=<7759;!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!3683!833<M>3!

32!76?33@<!73?:<937!5932!36<!H?I<95@<!H?735D<!7A73<MF!

!

GF!!.59:59;!)683!L<68I52=!57!,23!8![895B<7383529!2B!0578G5@53A!!

!

i6<9!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!G<68I<!59!48A7!3683!8=<!923!M895B<73835297!2B!

:578G5@53AE!36<A!M8A!G<!:57D5>@59<:!59!36<!78M<!M899<=!87!73?:<937!45362?3!:578G5@535<7E!59!

M273!=<7><D37FTQ!!`24<I<=E!_B?9D35298@!G<68I52=!877<77M<937a!M?73!G<!>@899<:!89:!

5M>@<M<93<:!B2=!:;;!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!462!8=<!7?7><9:<:!2=!<K><@@<:FRU!!L<D8?7<!

8!@29;Z3<=M!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529!57!D2975:<=<:!8!_D689;<!2B!>@8D<M<93a!B2=!8!D65@:!

4536!:578G5@535<7E!36<!7D622@!7A73<M!M?73!D29I<9<!36<!+#&!3<8ME!465D6!M?73!59D@?:<!

>8=<937E!59!2=:<=!32!>@89!2=!=<I57<!8!B?9D35298@!G<68I52=!877<77M<93F!)6<!3<8M!M?73!M<<3!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!TT!bU!/F-F*Fdd!PSPSX:YE!PSPSXBYE!PSPTXGYXWYE!PSPTXGYXSYE!PSPTXDYE!PSPTX:YEPSPTX]YXTYX%Y^!WS!*F.F'F!dd!

WUUFTbSX8YE!WWUFWSWZWUUFWSRE!WUUFTUPE!WUUFTUWZTUSF!!TR!3))$bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPSXHYF!!TV!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTXHY^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTPSF!Th!PUR!.FW:!SUP!XR36!*5=F!PQQVY!X8BB5=M59;!QbV!.F!-?>>F!bRV!X#F0F!)<99F!PQQSYYE!/)-.&$5)10)5+!TbU!/F-F!

PbVP!XPQQQYF!TQ!3))!bU!/F-F*F!PSPTX]YXTY^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbSF!RU!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXPYXLYX5YF!,<536<=!36<!7383?3<!92=!36<!=<;?@835297!:<B59<!36<!3<=M!7><D5B5D8@@AF!#K><=37!

59!36<!B5<@:!:<7D=5G<!36<!877<77M<93!87!29<!3683!_@22]7!B2=!36<!M235I83529!G<659:!36<!G<68I52=E!59D@?:59;!36<!

G52@2;5D8@E!72D58@E!8BB<D35I<E!89:!<9I5=29M<938@!B8D32=7!3683!3=5;;<=E!7?73859E!2=!<9:!53Fa!(=:2I<=E!#4(-:!923<!

WSE!83!TWF!

! ++ZPT

Page 90: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

89:!:<I<@2>!89!5MM<:583<!>@89!32!8::=<77!36<!G<68I52=!453659!8!M8K5M?M!2B!3<9!:8A7!

8B3<=!36<!D689;<!2B!>@8D<M<93FRP!

!

DF!!#KD<>35297!/9:<=!36<!PQQQ!+0#%!'<;?@835297!!

!

/9:<=!=<D<93@A!>?G@576<:!+0#%!=<;?@835297E!36<=<!8=<!5M>2=3893!<KD<>35297!32!36<!

M895B<7383529!6<8=59;!=<N?5=<M<937F!-3?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!462!8=<!B2?9:!32!>277<77!

:=?;7!2=!4<8>297E!2=!4627<!G<68I52=!57!7?G7389358@@A!@5]<@A!32!=<7?@3!59!59H?=A!32!7<@B!2=!

236<=7E!D89!G<!7?7><9:<:!B2=!ST!:8A7!2=!@<77E!=<;8=:@<77!2B!46<36<=!36<!G<68I52=!57!8!

M895B<7383529!2B!:578G5@53AFRb!)6<!@84!M8]<7!53!=<@835I<@A!<87A!B2=!7D622@7!32!7?7><9:!89:!

<K><@!7?D6!73?:<937E!2B3<9!?95@83<=8@@A!89:!=<;8=:@<77!2B!>8=<93\7!2GH<D35297FRW!+BE!8B3<=!ST!

:8A7!36<!D65@:!D29359?<7!32!B85@!36<!8G2I<!78B<3A!=<N?5=<M<937E!36<!7D622@!M8A!7<<]!89!

8::535298@!STZ:8A!><=52:!2B!<KD@?7529FRS!

!

:F!!-3?:<937!i536!0578G5@535<7!)683!`8I<!,23!L<<9!058;927<:!!!

!

! +9!8::53529E!+0#%!89:!-<D3529!TUS!<8D6!68I<!>=2I575297!3683!>=23<D3!8;85973!36<!

=<M2I8@!2B!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7E!<I<9!5B!36<!7D622@!7A73<M!687!923!A<3!5:<935B5<:!

36<M!87!68I59;!8!:578G5@53AFRT!)6<!7D622@!7A73<M!57!:<<M<:!32!68I<!7?D6!]924@<:;<!5B!36<!

>8=<93!<K>=<77<:!D29D<=9!32!7D622@!7A73<M!><=7299<@!X?7?8@@A!59!4=5359;!2=!59!8!=<N?<73!

B2=!89!<I8@?83529Y!3683!8!D65@:!9<<:7!7><D58@!<:?D83529!89:!=<@83<:!7<=I5D<7^!5B!36<!D65@:\7!

G<68I52=!:<M2973=83<7!36<!9<<:!B2=!7<=I5D<7^!2=!5B!8!3<8D6<=!2=!236<=!=<@<I893!7D622@!

><=7299<@!<K>=<77<:!D29D<=9!8G2?3!36<!D65@:\7!G<68I52=!2=!><=B2=M89D<!32!7><D58@!

<:?D83529!2=!236<=!7D622@!><=7299<@FRR!

!

LF!!-A73<M5D!*68@@<9;<7!32!057D5>@59<!&2@5D5<7!!

!

[273!D68@@<9;<7!32!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!>2@5D5<7!68I<!G<<9!G=2?;63!87!59:5I5:?8@!

D87<7!?9:<=!+0#%\7!>=23<D35297F!!-A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<7!8@@<;59;!:578G5@53A!:57D=5M5983529!

>?=7?893!32!7383<!89:!B<:<=8@!@84!8=<!=8=<E!89:!36<!@84!57!923!4<@@!:<B59<:F!i683!B2@@247!57!

8!:57D?77529!2B!7A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<7!3683!M8A!G<!8I85@8G@<!?9:<=!B<:<=8@!@84F!

!

PF!!(I<=I5<4!2B!"<;8@!)6<2=5<7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!RP!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXPYXLYX+Y^!7))$:;#"$(=:2I<=E!#4(-:!923<!WSE!83!TbZTWF!Rb!/9:<=!+0#%!=<;?@835297!7D622@!8?362=535<7!M8A!?95@83<=8@@A!>@8D<!8!73?:<93!4536!:578G5@535<7!59!89!

_8@3<=9835I<!593<=5M!<:?D835298@!7<3359;a!B2=!?>!32!ST!:8A7!B2=!4<8>297!2=!:=?;!I52@835297F!WS!*F.F'F!dd!

WUUFTbUX8YXbYE!WUUFTbSX8YF!!L?3!29@A!46<=<!8!7?G7389358@!@5]<@5622:!2B!68=M!<K5737!89:!=<M8597!:<7>53<!

<BB2=37!GA!36<!7D622@!32!M535;83<!36<!=57]7F!3))$(=:2I<=!#4(-:$923<!WSE!83!TTF!!RW!3))$05&$$+B!36<!M57D29:?D3!57!923!G87<:!29!4<8>29!2=!:=?;!>277<77529!7D622@!8?362=535<7!D89!735@@!8D3!

?95@83<=8@@AE!G?3!M?73!;859!36<!8>>=2I8@!2B!8!6<8=59;!2BB5D<=F!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPT!X]YXbY^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbP!

XPQQQYF!)6<!7D622@!M8A!7?7><9:!36<!73?:<93!5MM<:583<@A!89:!7<<]!89!<K><:53<:!6<8=59;!36=2?;6!7383<!

8?362=535<7!32!8>>=2I<!8!STZ:8A!=<M2I8@F!.2=!B?@@!:57D?77529E!7<<!(=:2I<=E!#4(-:$923<!WSE!83!TVF!RS!%3!36<!<9:!2B!36<!ST!:8A7!36<!=?@<7!B2=!36<!2=5;598@!<KD@?7529!8>>@A!29D<!8;859F!3))$bU!/F-F*F!

PSPTX]YXVYXLYF!RT!3))$bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXhYX8Y^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbVX8Y!XPQQQYF!RR!3))$!bU!/F-F*F!d!PSPTX]YXhYXLY^!WS!*F.F'F!d!WUUFTbVXGYF!`<=<E!-<D3529!TUS!89:!+0#%!:5BB<=!59!7?G3@<!G?3!

>23<9358@@A!5M>2=3893!48A7F!!3))$(=:2I<=E!#4(-:$923<!WSE!83!RSZRTF!!

! ++ZPR

Page 91: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

-A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<7!;=2?9:<:!59!8@@<;835297!2B!:57D=5M5983529!M8A!G<!G87<:!29!

29<!2=!M2=<!2B!36<!B2@@2459;!@<;8@!36<2=5<7J!XPY!:57D=5M5983529!>?=7?893!32!8!:57>8=83<!

3=<83M<93!2=!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!36<2=A^!RV!XbY!<KD@?7529!B=2M!>8=35D5>83529^!89:!XWY!:<958@!2B!

G<9<B537F!057>8=83<!3=<83M<93!89:!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M7!8=<!3A>5D8@@A!=857<:!?9:<=!

-<D3529!TUSE!465D6!>=265G537!:57D=5M5983529!29!36<!G8757!2B!:578G5@53A!GA!=<D5>5<937!2B!

B<:<=8@!B?9:59;F!#KD@?7529!89:!:<958@!2B!G<9<B53!36<2=5<7!D89!D297353?3<!7<>8=83<!D8?7<7!2B!

8D3529FRh!)6<A!M8A!:5BB<=!B=2M!:57>8=83<!5M>8D3!89:!:5BB<=<93!3=<83M<93!36<2=5<7!G<D8?7<!

8!>2@5DA!2=!>=8D35D<!3683!I52@83<7!36<!=<N?5=<M<937!2B!+0#%!2=!-<D3529!TUS!57!537<@B!

D2975:<=<:!8!B2=M!2B!:57D=5M5983529!8;85973!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7FRQ!!

!

)6<!:57359D3529!G<34<<9!<KD@?7529!89:!:<958@!2B!G<9<B537!D89!G<!?9:<=7322:!GA!

898@AC59;!8!:<B<9:893\7!:57D=5M59832=A!G<68I52=!59!@5;63!2B!36<!G875D!+0#%!<9353@<M<937FF!!

LA!@84E!8@@!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!8=<!<9353@<:!32!G<!<:?D83<:!4536!36<5=!=<;?@8=!

<:?D83529!><<=7!32!36<!M8K5M?M!<K3<93!8>>=2>=583<!B2=!7><D58@!<:?D83529!73?:<937F!)657!

<97?=<7!<K>27?=<!32!36<!78M<!D?==5D?@?ME!36<!78M<!65;6!8D8:<M5D!7389:8=:7E!89:!36<!

78M<!2>>2=3?9535<7!B2=!72D58@5C83529FVU!!)6<!762=3!689:!I<=7529!2B!3657!D29D<>3!57!

:<7D=5G<:!87!.?@@!%>>=2>=583<!&?G@5D!#:?D83529!X.%&#Y!59!36<!"<873!'<73=5D35I<!

#9I5=29M<93!X"'#YF!

!!!

0<958@!2B!.%&#!2=!"'#!59!36<!:57D5>@59<!D293<K3!D2?@:!2DD?=!5BE!B2=!<K8M>@<E!

73?:<937!4536!<M235298@!:572=:<=7!8=<!8?32M835D8@@A!7<93!32!8@3<=9835I<!7D622@7!GA!36<!

7D622@!:573=5D3!G<D8?7<!36<A!8=<!=<;8=:<:!87!322!:57=?>35I<!B2=!=<;?@8=!<:?D83529!

D@877=22M7F!)6<!=<7?@359;!7?7><975297!D2?@:!G<!:<7D=5G<:!87!7A73<M5D!:57D=5M59832=A!

)O/;4#0"1$:<9A59;!G236!36<!.%&#!89:!"'#!=<N?5=<M<937FVP!-5M5@8=@AE!5B!8!>@85935BB!D2?@:!

<738G@576!8!>833<=9!3683!8!7D622@!2=!:573=5D3!7?7><9:<:!?9:58;927<:!73?:<937!4536!

:578G5@535<7!462!4<=<!<9=2@@<:!59!=<;?@8=!<:?D83529!D@877=22M7E!89:!36<7<!73?:<937!762?@:!

68I<!G<<9!:58;927<:!89:!>=2I5:<:!4536!36<!7?>>2=3!7<=I5D<7!36<A!9<<:<:!32!7?DD<<:!59!

3627<!D@877=22M7E!36<!=<7?@359;!7?7><975297!D2?@:!G<!:<7D=5G<:!87!D8?7<:!GA!8!7A73<M5D!

89:!:57D=5M59832=A!5)10:;$"G$M)1)G0.#+$8@72!I52@8359;!.%&#!89:!"'#!=<N?5=<M<937FVb!

!

( bF!!#K68?73529!2B!%:M59573=835I<!'<M<:5<7!57!,23!%@48A7!'<N?5=<:!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!RV!057>8=83<!3=<83M<93!36<2=A!89:!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!36<2=A!8=<!2?3@59<:!59!3657!%>><9:5K!?9:<=!36<!:57D?77529!

2B!=8D<!:57D=5M5983529!89:!)53@<!O+F!!Rh!3))$n?:536!i<@D6!i<;9<=E!I7)$?1.050#/-0801:.0"1$Q"5);$6)/"1#05)-)5>$91#4-012$9P4:;$<(("-.410.=$

A0.7"4.$6)#()/.$I"$E:150/:($J15)-$3)/.0"1$RST$<G$I7)$6)7:M0;0.:.0"1$?/.$"G$UVWX+!RQ!*(',#""!"F!'#OF!

SUPE!TPT!XPQhWZhSYF!!RQ!bQ!/F-F*F!d!VQS!X8YF((VU!3))$)&2&+$bU!/F-F*F!dd!PSUPXhY^!PSPS!XGZ:Y^!WS!*F.F'F!dd!WUUFbR!XGYXWYE!WUUFWSSX8YXbYE!XSYX55YE!WUUFWSVE!

WUUFTWbXGYE!WUUFTWWX8YXbYX55YE!dWUUFTTUZTTS^!7))$:;#"$0<I=5<7!IF!.85=B8K!*2?93!-D6F!L:FE!hhb!.F!b:!hVRE!

hVh!XS36!*5=F!PQhQYF!VP!.2=!3657!=<8729!+0#%!89:!-<D3529!TUS!D@85M7!8=<!;<9<=8@@A!G=2?;63!32;<36<=F!3))+$)&2&+!-M536!IF!

'2G59729E!SRh!/F-F!QQb!XPQhSYF!Vb+0#%!687!<K>@5D53!_*65@:!.59:a!>=2I575297!2G@5;8359;!7D622@7E!:573=5D37!89:!7383<7!32!<I8@?83<!D65@:=<9!

M895B<7359;!G<68I52=!7?;;<735I<!2B!36<!>=<7<9D<!2B!8!:578G5@53A!87!4<@@!87!59!=<7>297<!32!>8=<938@!=<N?<737F!

3))$bU!/F-F*F!dPSPbX8YXWY^!WS!*F.F'F!dWUUFPbTF!

! ++ZPV

Page 92: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

[273!59:5I5:?8@7!7<<]59;!32!=<M<:A!8!7><D5B5D!:57D5>@598=A!:<D57529!M?73!<K68?73!

36<!8:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7!7><@@<:!2?3!?9:<=!+0#%!89:!36<!7383<!@847!89:!=<;?@835297!

5M>@<M<9359;!+0#%FVW!!`24<I<=E!7A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<7!32!8!7D622@!2=!:573=5D3\7!:57D5>@59<!

>2@5DA!G=2?;63!GA!59:5I5:?8@!>@85935BB7E!2=!87!8!D@877!8D3529E!3683!8@@<;<!:57D=5M5983529!45@@!

923!9<D<778=5@A!G<!=<N?5=<:!32!<K68?73!8:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7FVS!*2?=37!68I<!7><D5B5D8@@A!

8@@24<:!8D35297!46<=<!B85@?=<!32!>=2I5:<!+0#%\7!?95N?<!>=2D<:?=8@!=5;637!57!36<!G8757!B2=!

8!D2M>@8593!8;85973!8!7D622@E!:573=5D3E!2=!7383<FVT!!

!

WF!!057D=5M5983529!*@85M7!/9:<=!-<D3529!TUS!

!

8F!!057>8=83<!)=<83M<93!

!

057>8=83<!3=<83M<93!D@85M7!59!36<!:578G5@53A!8=<98!M5==2=!)53@<!O+!D@85M7!G87<:!29!

=8D<E!D2@2=E!2=!9835298@!2=5;59F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!M<359;!2?3!68=76<=!>?9576M<937!32!73?:<937!

4536!:578G5@535<7!3689!32!929Z:578G@<:!73?:<937!42?@:!@5]<@A!G<!8!I52@83529!2B!-<D3529!TUSF!

%!75;95B5D893!:5BB<=<9D<!57!3683!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!8=<!<9353@<:!32!8!M895B<7383529!

6<8=59;!89:!8!B?9D35298@!G<68I52=!877<77M<93!89:!59!3683!=<7><D3!68I<!M2=<!:?<!>=2D<77!

=5;637!3689!236<=!73?:<937F!.2=!<K8M>@<E!5B!8!7D622@!=<M2I<:!8!D65@:!45362?3!8!

M895B<7383529!6<8=59;E!89:!36<!7D622@!]9<4!2=!762?@:!68I<!]9249!36<!D65@:!68:!8!

:578G5@53AE!36<!7D622@!42?@:!G<!59!I52@83529!2B!36<!@84F!%!7A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<!D2?@:!G<!

B5@<:!59!465D6!>@85935BB7!42?@:!68I<!32!<738G@576!8!>833<=9!2=!>=8D35D<!2B!B85@59;!32!>=2I5:<!

M895B<7383529!6<8=59;7!2=!B?9D35298@!G<68I52=!877<77M<937F!

(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!VW!3))$SRh!/F-F!QQbE!83!PUbP&!`24<I<=E!59:5I5:?8@!-<D3529!TUS!D@85M7!3683!D2?@:!923!G<!B5@<:!?9:<=!36<!

+0#%!42?@:!923!G<!=<N?5=<:!32!<K68?73!8:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7!G<B2=<!B5@59;!59!D2?=3F!VS!.2=!<K8M>@<E!_>8=<937!9<<:!923!<K68?73!+0#%\7!8:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7!46<=<!36<!7383<!2=!@2D8@!

8;<9DA\7!>=2D<:?=<7!42?@:!G<!598:<N?83<!2=!B?35@<F!q%:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7!8=<!;<9<=8@@A!598:<N?83<!

46<=<!73=?D3?=8@E!7A73<M5D!=<B2=M7!8=<!72?;63F!F!F!F!#K68?73529!M8A!8@72!G<!<KD?7<:!G<D8?7<!2B!598:<N?8DA!

2B!8:M59573=835I<!=<M<:5<7!46<=<!36<!>@85935BB7\!7?G738935I<!D@85M7!36<M7<@I<7!D29D<=9!36<!8:<N?8DA!2B!36<!

8:M59573=835I<!>=2D<77Fa!"<8=959;!0578G5@535<7!%772DF!IF!L:F!2B!#:?DF!2B!L8@35M2=<!*2?93AE!hWV!.F!-?>>F!

VPV!X0F![:F!PQQWY!XD5359;$`2<B3!IF!)?D729!/95B5<:!-D6F!0573FE!QRV!.F!b:!PbQhE!PWUQ!XQ36!*5=F!PQQbYY!!VT!.2=!<K8M>@<E!59!D")$%&$6"/B0127:8$H"41.=$3/7"";$F":-5+$36<!0573=5D3!*2?=3!6<@:!3683!36<!73?:<93!487!

923!=<N?5=<:!32!<K68?73!8:M59573=835I<!>=2D<<:59;7!G<D8?7<!36<!:573=5D3!68:!B85@<:!32!>=2I5:<!8!>=2M>3!

6<8=59;!89:!9235D<E!89:!72?;63!32!M8593859!36<!:57D5>@598=A!7?7><97529!:?=59;!36<!><9:<9DA!2B!36<!6<8=59;F!

02<!IF!'2D]59;68M!-D6F!L:FE!RTh!.F!-?>>F!SUW!XiF0F!O8F!PQhVYF!

! ++ZPh

Page 93: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

( GF!!%:I<=7<!+M>8D3!

(

"5]<!36<!)53@<!O+!=<;?@835297E!36<!=<;?@835297!5M>@<M<9359;!-<D3529!TUS!68I<!89!

_<BB<D37a!3<73E!465D6!7383<7!3683!_o8p!=<D5>5<93!M8A!923E!:5=<D3@A!2=!36=2?;6!D293=8D3?8@!2=!

236<=!8==89;<M<937E!?35@5C<!D=53<=58!2=!M<362:7!2B!8:M59573=83529!X5Y!3683!68I<!36<!<BB<D3!2B!

7?GH<D359;!N?8@5B5<:!689:5D8>><:!><=7297!32!:57D=5M5983529!29!36<!G8757!2B!689:5D8>E!o2=p!

X55Y!3683!68I<!36<!>?=>27<!2=!<BB<D3!2B!:<B<8359;!2=!7?G7389358@@A!5M>85=59;!

8DD2M>@576M<93!2B!36<!2GH<D35I<7!2B!36<!=<D5>5<937!>=2;=8M!4536!=<7><D3!32!689:5D8>><:!

><=7297!F!F!F!FaVR!%!75M5@8=!36=<<Z73<>!3<73!57!?7<:!32!:<3<=M59<!5B!89!<:?D835298@!>2@5DA!57!

:57D=5M59832=A!?9:<=!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!36<2=AF!!.5=73E!:2<7!36<!>=8D35D<!2=!>=2D<:?=<!59!

N?<73529!68I<!8!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3!G87<:!29!:578G5@53Ak!-<D29:E!57!36<!>=8D35D<!2=!

>=2D<:?=<!89!<:?D835298@!9<D<7753Ak!!)65=:E!57!36<=<!89!8@3<=9835I<!>=8D35D<!2=!>=2D<:?=<!

3683!42?@:!G<!B<875G@<!89:!8D65<I<!36<!78M<!>?=>27<E!4536!@<77!:57D=5M59832=A!5M>8D3k!

!

! *87<!@84!59!36<!8=<8!2B!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!G87<:!29!:578G5@53A!57!7>8=7<F!%>>@5D83529!

2B!36<!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!898@A757!7<<M7!>8=35D?@8=@A!?9D2MM29!59!36<!:578G@53A!D293<K3F!+9!

29<!D87<E!K1$-)$?MM)%0;;)$3/7"";$D0#.-0/.+$36<!D2M>@859893!7><D5B5D8@@A!8@@<;<:!3683!

:57D5>@59<!487!8:M59573<=<:!M2=<!68=76@A!32!G@8D]!73?:<937!89:!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!

3689!32!236<=!73?:<937!462!68:!D2MM533<:!75M5@8=!2BB<97<7FVV!&?=7?893!32!537!59I<735;83529E!

(*'!:5:!923!59I2]<!36<!=<;?@835297!=<;8=:59;!:57>8=83<!5M>8D3!87!53!><=3859<:!32!

:578G5@53AE!G?3!:5:!D2975:<=!:57>8=83<!5M>8D3!87!53!><=3859<:!32!=8D<FVh!)6<!G=5<B!:<7D=5>3529!

2B!36<!%GG<7I5@@<!:57D5>@59<!>2@5DA!7?;;<737!3683!36<!87><D3!2B!36<!D2:<!3683!8@@24<:!B2=!

7?7><97529!B2=!D?M?@835I<!M57D29:?D3E!59D@?:59;!8!45:<!I8=5<3A!2B!M592=!=?@<7!

59B=8D35297!D2?@:!4<@@!68I<!68:!8!:57>8=83<!5M>8D3!29!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@53AFVQ!

!

! %3!@<873!29<!D2?=3E!624<I<=E!687!D8@@<:!5932!N?<73529!46<36<=!8!:57D5>@598=A!>2@5DA!

4536!89!:57>=2>2=352983<!5M>8D3!29!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!57!36<!]59:!2B!>=2;=8M!3683!

48==8937!8!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!898@A757!?9:<=!-<D3529!TUSF!+9!3.45)1.$C0.7$:$D0#:M0;0.=$%&$

3/7"";$F":-5$"G$,:;8$F):/7$H"41.=+!hU$>@85935BB7!B5@<:!89!8:I<=7<!5M>8D3!D@85M!G87<:!59!

>8=3!29!8!73835735D8@!898@A757!2B!36<!7D622@\7!D=5M598@!=<B<==8@!>2@5DAF!!)6<!:838!7624<:!3683!

73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!4<=<!=<B<==<:!B2=!>=27<D?3529!83!2I<=!B5I<!35M<7!36<!=83<!2B!236<=!

73?:<937F!!)6<!>@85935BB7!8=;?<:!B?=36<=!3683!36<!65;6!=<B<==8@!=83<!=<7?@3<:!B=2M!598:<N?83<!

G<68I52=8@!7?>>2=37F!

!

)6<!,:;8$F):/7!D2?=3!8>>@5<:!8!_:<958@!2B!G<9<B537a!898@A757!32!36<!D@85M!89:!

6<@:!3683!9<536<=!36<!=<B<==8@!>=8D35D<!92=!36<!G<68I52=8@!7?>>2=37!D297353?3<:!_8!>=2;=8M!

?9:<=!465D6!36<A!o36<!>@85935BB7p!8=<!G<59;!7?GH<D3<:!32!:57D=5M5983529Ea!59!537!;=893!2B!

7?MM8=A!H?:;M<93!32!36<!:<B<9:8937F!)6<!D2?=3!B?=36<=!7383<:!3683!<I<9!5B!36<!>@85935BB7!

68:!<738G@576<:!8!:<958@!2B!G<9<B537E!36<5=!D@85M!42?@:!B85@F!%DD2=:59;!32!36<!D2?=3E!36<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!VR!$WS!*F.F'F!dPUSFSXGYXSY!VV!3))$K1$-)$%GG<7I5@@<!*2?93A!-D6F!0573&+$bh!+,0+O+0/%"-!i+)`!0+-%L+"+)+#-!#0/*F!"F!'#&F!PbUh!XPQQhYF!Vh!K5&$VQ!K5&$X73?:<937!462!<9;8;<!59!@<I<@!+!8D35I535<7E!59D@?:59;!38=:59<77E!@A59;!89:!B85@?=<!32!D2M>@<3<!89!

8775;9M<93!36=<<!2=!M2=<!35M<7!M8A!G<!7?7><9:<:!2=!<K><@@<:!5B!89!8:M59573=832=!:<D5:<7!32!=<ZD@8775BA!36<!

=<><83!2BB<97<7!87!@<I<@!++!:57=?>35I<!D29:?D3!2BB<97<7YF!hU!WP!+,0+O+0/%"-!i+)`!0+-%L+"+)+#-!#0/*F!"F!'#&F!bUQ!XPQQQY!

! ++ZPQ

Page 94: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

D=5M598@!=<B<==8@7!4<=<!M8:<!G<D8?7<!36<A!68:!D2MM533<:!D=5M<7E!923!G<D8?7<!2B!36<5=!

:578G5@53AF!,:;8$F):/7!7?;;<737!3683!>@85935BB7!7<<]59;!32!=<:=<77!36<!:57D=5M59832=A!

5M>8D3!2B!8!7?G738935I<!=?@<!M8A!G<!29!73=29;<=!B22359;!3689!3627<!462!D68@@<9;<!8!

>=2D<:?=8@!>=8D35D<!7?D6!87!D=5M598@!=<B<==8@7F!!

!

SF!!.%&#l"'#!&=23<D35297!

!

%DD2=:59;!32!36<!=<D<93@A!=<@<87<:!=<>2=3!GA!36<!,835298@!*2?9D5@!29!0578G5@535<7!

X,*0YE!M273!7383<7!8=<!923!B?@@A!D2M>@A59;!4536!M89A!5M>2=3893!=<N?5=<M<937!2B!

+0#%FYU!!`24<I<=E!36<=<!68I<!G<<9!7?DD<77B?@!7A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<7!8;85973!7383<7!B2=!

B85@?=<!32!5M>@<M<93!+0#%!8:<N?83<@AF!%:I2D83<7!68I<!8@72!7?DD<77B?@@A!@535;83<:!32!

=<:=<77!7383<7\!:<958@7!2B!36<7<!>=23<D35297!32!D65@:=<9!4536!7><D58@!9<<:7!462!4<=<!

59D8=D<=83<:FYZ!!

!

)6<!/953<:!-383<7!0<>8=3M<93!2B!#:?D83529!(BB5D<!B2=!-><D58@!#:?D83529!

&=2;=8M7!X(-#&Y!57!D68=;<:!4536!<97?=59;!36<!>=2><=!<9B2=D<M<93!2B!+0#%!GA!7383<7F!

#I<9!5B!(-#&!:2<7!923!593<=I<9<E!7383<7!M8A!G<!6<@:!=<7>2975G@<!B2=!<97?=59;!36<!

<9B2=D<M<93!2B!+0#%!59!<I<=A!7D622@!:573=5D3FYX!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!59!*2=<A!`F!IF!*65D8;2E!

36<!>@85935BB7!G=2?;63!8!D@877!8D3529!8;85973!G236!36<!D53A!2B!*65D8;2!89:!36<!7383<!2B!

+@@59257!?9:<=!36<!+0#%E!-<D3529!TUSE!89:!)53@<!++!2B!36<!%0%!B2=!?759;!8!D83<;2=5D8@!

7A73<M!32!8775;9!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!32!D@877<7FYT!)6<!>@85935BB7!>=<I85@<:!8;85973!36<!

7383<!8B3<=!36<!D87<!8;85973!36<!D53A!7<33@<:F!)6<!D2?=3!D29D@?:<:!3683!"'#!=<N?5=<M<937!

4<=<!I52@83<:!G<D8?7<!36<!7383<!68:!:29<!@533@<!32!<97?=<!D2M>@589D<!4536!36<!+0#%E!

G<D8?7<!D65@:=<9!4536!:578G5@535<7!4<=<!=8=<@A!>@8D<:!59!=<;?@8=!<:?D83529E!89:!G<D8?7<!

:573=5D3!><=7299<@!4<=<!598:<N?83<@A!3=859<:!32!877573!73?:<937!4536!:578G5@535<7!462!4<=<!

>@8D<:!59!=<;?@8=!<:?D83529F!

(

-5M5@8=@AE!8!7A73<M5D!D68@@<9;<!32!45:<7>=<8:!8G?7<7!59!:57D5>@5959;!73?:<937!4536!

:578G5@535<7!g!7?D6!87!=8=<@A!8D]924@<:;59;!3683!M57D29:?D3!57!8!M895B<7383529!2B!

:578G5@53AE!2=!598>>=2>=583<@A!?759;!8@3<=9835I<!7D622@7!g!D2?@:!38]<!36<!B2=M!2B!8!7383<!2=!

B<:<=8@!D@877!8D3529!8;85973!G236!36<!7383<!89:!36<!@2D8@!8;<9DA!B2=!I52@835297!2B!-<D3529!

TUS!89:!+0#%F!

!!

!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!hP!3))+!,%)+(,%"!*(/,*+"!(,!0+-%L+"+)mE!L%*f!)(!-*`(("!(,!*+O+"!'+$`)-J!%0O%,*+,$!)`#!

.#0#'%"!*([[+)[#,)!)(!"#%O#!-*`(("!L#`+,0$XbUUUYF!hb!3))$`89:G<==A!IF!)62M>729E!bUUU!i"!bVPRVU!X-F0F,FmF!bUUUYF!hW!%!D2M>@859893!:5778357B5<:!4536!36<!7383<\7!:57>2753529!M8A!=<N?<73!=<I5<4!2B!36<!7383<\7!:<D57529!GA!36<!

/F-F!-<D=<38=A!2B!#:?D83529!462!57!8?362=5C<:!32!453662@:!B<:<=8@!B?9:59;!B=2M!8!7383<!B2?9:!32!G<!59!929Z

D2M>@589D<!4536!36<!+0#%F!3))$WS!*F.F'F!d!VRFVhPF!.?=36<=M2=<E!5B!36<!D8?7<!2B!8D3529!57!3683!36<!7383<!687!

8:2>3<:!8!>2@5DA!2=!57!>?=7?59;!8!>=8D35D<!2B!;<9<=8@!8>>@5D8G5@53A!3683!57!D293=8=A!32!36<!@84E!2=!46<=<!

73=?D3?=8@!2=!7A73<M5D!=<B2=M7!8=<!72?;63!>@85935BB7!M8A!B5@<!7?53!8;85973!36<!7383<!59!D2?=3F!3))$)&2&+$

*6=5732>6<=!iF!IF!&2=37M2?36!-D6F!*2MMFE!hVV!!.Fb:!PUhQE!PUQb!XP73!*5=F!PQhQYF!hS!3))$*2=<A!`F!IF!)6<!L:F!2B!#:?DF!(B!36<!*53A!2B!*65D8;2E!bV!+,0+O+0/%"-!i+)`!0+-%L+"+)+#-!#0/*F!"F!'#&F!

VPW!X,F0F!+@@F!PQQhYF!

! ++ZbU

Page 95: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

&&&1((<,)7*0*.*0,)56(:04A*7(*,(%.3("+,/377(

!

-?7><975297!89:!<K>?@75297!8=<!342!2B!36<!M273!45:<@A!?7<:!:57D5>@598=A!322@7!59!

36<!7D622@!7<3359;E!89:!?9:<=!36<!7>83<!2B!9<4!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7E!36<!9?MG<=!2B!

73?:<937!7?7><9:<:!89:!<K><@@<:!57!=5759;F!`24<I<=E!73?:<937!:2!923!_76<:!36<5=!

D297353?35298@!=5;637!!!!F!F!F!83!36<!7D622@!62?7<!;83<FahT!!(B!D2?=7<E!92!72?=D<!2B!B<:<=8@!2=!

7383<!@84!=<N?5=<7!7D622@7!32!]<<>!73?:<937!59!36<!D@877=22M!462!3=?@A!>27<!:89;<=7!32!

36<M7<@I<7!2=!236<=7E!G?3!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!2B!36<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93EhR!465D6!

8>>@5<7!32!36<!7383<7!89:!8@@!36<5=!7?G:5I575297EhV!>=2I5:<7!8!D297353?35298@!D6<D]!29!36<!

>=8D35D<!2B!5M>=2><=@A!:<9A59;!8!73?:<93!36<!=5;63!32!833<9:!>?G@5D!7D622@7F!

%>>@A59;!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!57!8!I<=A!>=8D35D8@E!B8D3Z7><D5B5D!<K<=D57<^!53!57!_8!

B@<K5G@<!D29D<>3!3683!I8=5<7!4536!36<!>8=35D?@8=!753?83529Eahh!89:!3657!8=<8!2B!36<!@84!D89!G<!

I<=A!D2M>@<KF!!.?=36<=M2=<E!D2?=37!3=8:535298@@A!<K<=D57<!;=<83!=<73=8593!59!=<I5<459;!

73?:<93!:57D5>@598=A!=<;?@835297EhQ!89:!36<!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!687!6<@:!3683!36<!593<=>=<383529!

2B!7D622@!=<;?@835297!595358@@A!=<75:<7!4536!36<!G2:A!3683!8>>=2I<:!89:!57!=<7>2975G@<!B2=!

<9B2=D59;!36<MFQU!!.598@@AE!465@<!_>?G@5D!65;6!7D622@!73?:<937!:2!68I<!7?G738935I<!89:!

>=2D<:?=8@!=5;637!465@<!83!7D622@Ea!_53!57!923!36<!=2@<!2B!36<!B<:<=8@!D2?=37!32!7<3!875:<!

:<D575297!2B!7D622@!8:M59573=832=7!465D6!36<!D2?=3!M8A!I5<4!87!@8D]59;!8!G8757!59!457:2M!

2=!D2M>877529!FFFFaQP!

/@35M83<@AE!36<9E!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!>=2I5:<7!=<8@!G?3!@5M53<:!>=23<D35297!32!

73?:<937!@5I59;!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!!)6<!>=2D<:?=<7!=<N?5=<:!GA!36<!0?<!

&=2D<77!*@8?7<!>=52=!32!7?7><9:59;!2=!<K><@@59;!8!73?:<93!8=<E!59!M273!D87<7E!B85=@A!

M<8;<=F!!%@72E!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!537<@B!:2<7!923!>=265G53!M89:832=A!>?9576M<937!2=!

=<N?5=<!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!32!D2975:<=!M535;8359;!D5=D?M7389D<7F!!/9:<=!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!

*@8?7<E!73?:<937!8=<!29@A!>=23<D3<:!8;85973!>?9576M<937!3683!8=<!;=277@A!:57>=2>2=352983<!

32!36<!2BB<97<!D2MM533<:F!!`24<I<=E!M89A!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!D2:<7!89:!7383<!@847!=<N?5=<!

8!:57D=<35298=A!8>>=28D6E!<I<9!59!H?=57:5D35297!3683!>=2D@85M!3683!36<A!68I<!7?>>27<:!

_C<=2!32@<=89D<a!>2@5D5<7F!!+9!36<7<!:573=5D37E!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!D89!G<!8!I8@?8G@<!

4<8>29!59!D68@@<9;59;!5M>=2><=@A!8>>@5<:!:57D5>@59<!>2@5D5<7F!

%F!!&=2D<:?=8@!0?<!&=2D<77!

)6<!D29D<>3!2B!_:?<!>=2D<77a!59!%M<=5D89!@84!687!342!:57359D3!D2M>29<937F!!)6<!

B5=73E!>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77E!=<N?5=<7!3683!7383<7!>=2I5:<!B85=!89:!8:<N?83<!>=2D<:?=<7!B2=!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!hT!)59]<=!IF!0<7![259<7!+9:<>F!*2MM?953A!-D6F!0573FE!WQW!/F-F!TUWE!TUR!XPQRQYF!hR!)6<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93!>=2I5:<7!59!=<@<I893!>8=3!3683!_92!7383<!768@@!r!:<>=5I<!89A!><=729!2B!@5B<E!

@5G<=3AE!2=!>=2><=3AE!45362?3!:?<!>=2D<77!2B!@84rFa!!!/F-F!*(,-)F!8M<9:F!e+OE!dPF!!hV!3))!i<73!O5=;5958!-383<!L:F!2B!#:?DF!IF!L8=9<33<E!WPQ!/F-F!RbS!XPQSWYF!!_)6<!.2?=3<<936!%M<9:M<93E!87!

924!8>>@5<:!32!36<!7383<7E!>=23<D37!36<!D535C<97!8;85973!36<!7383<!537<@B!89:!8@@!2B!537!D=<83?=<7!g!G28=:7!2B!

<:?D83529!923!<KD<>3<:F!!)6<7<!68I<!5M>2=3893E!:<@5D83<E!89:!65;6@A!:57D=<35298=A!B?9D35297!G?3!929<!3683!

36<A!M8A!923!><=B2=M!453659!36<!@5M537!2B!36<!L5@@!2B!'5;637Fa!!K5F!83!RWVF!hh!159<=M29!IF!L?=D6E!SQS!/F-F!PPWE!PbV!XPQQUYF!hQ!3))+$)&2&E!#>><=729!IF!%=]89787E!WQW!/F-F!QV!XPQRhYF!QU!3))!i22:!IF!-3=5D]@89:E!SbU!/F-F!WUh!XPQVTYF!QP!K5&$83!WbRF!

! ++ZbP

Page 96: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

:<3<=M5959;!46<9!53!45@@!:<>=5I<!8!><=729!2B!@5B<E!@5G<=3AE!2=!>=2><=3AF!!)6<=<B2=<E!32!=857<!

8!>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77!D@85ME!8!>@85935BB!M?73!XPY!5:<935BA!8!>=23<D3<:!>=2><=3A!2=!

@5G<=3A!593<=<73^!XbY!:<M2973=83<!3683!36<A!4<=<!:<>=5I<:!2B!3683!593<=<73!GA!7383<!8D3529^!

89:!XWY!<738G@576!3683!36<!:<>=5I83529!2DD?==<:!45362?3!:?<!>=2D<77FQb!!

)6<!<9353@<M<93!32!8!>?G@5D!<:?D83529!D=<83<:!GA!7383<!@847!687!@29;!G<<9!

=<D2;95C<:!87!8!>=2><=3A!593<=<73!>=23<D3<:!GA!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!2B!36<!

*297353?3529FQW!%7!36<!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!D2MM<93<:!29!36<!5M>2=389D<!2B!8!>?G@5D!

<:?D83529!59!F-"C1$%&$F":-5$"G$954/:.0"1>$!

#:?D83529!57!><=68>7!36<!M273!5M>2=3893!B?9D3529!2B!7383<!89:!@2D8@!

;2I<=9M<937F!F!F!F!+3!57!8!>=59D5>8@!5973=?M<93!59!848]<959;!36<!D65@:!32!

D?@3?=8@!I8@?<7E!59!>=<>8=59;!65M!B2=!@83<=!>=2B<775298@!3=85959;E!89:!59!

6<@>59;!65M!32!8:H?73!92=M8@@A!32!657!<9I5=29M<93F!F!F!F!!+3!57!:2?G3B?@!3683!

89A!D65@:!M8A!=<87298G@A!G<!<K><D3<:!32!7?DD<<:!59!@5B<!5B!6<!57!:<95<:!36<!

2>>2=3?953A!2B!89!<:?D83529FQS!

(9D<!8!>=23<D3<:!593<=<73!687!G<<9!5:<935B5<:E!7?D6!87!36<!>=2><=3A!593<=<73!59!8!

>?G@5D!<:?D83529E!36<!7<D29:!73<>!59!:?<!>=2D<77!898@A757!57!32!<738G@576!3683!36<!7383<!

8D3?8@@A!5M>85=<:!36<!>@85935BB\7!>=23<D3<:!=5;63F!!+9!36<!7<M598@!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!D87<!29!

7D622@!:57D5>@59<E!!"##$%&$'"()*E!36<!*2?=3!6<@:!3683!_3238@!<KD@?7529!B=2M!36<!<:?D835298@!

>=2D<77!B2=!M2=<!3689!8!3=5I58@!><=52:a!57!8!7?G7389358@!<92?;6!:<>=5I83529!2B!>=2><=3A!32!

N?8@5BA!B2=!:?<!>=2D<77!>=23<D3529FQT!!%::535298@@AE!D2?=37!68I<!6<@:!3683!59Z7D622@!

7?7><975297!M8A!=<N?5=<!36<!78M<!8M2?93!2B!>=2D<77!87!2?3Z2BZ7D622@!7?7><975297J!36<!

32?D67329<!57!923!36<!>6A75D8@!>=<7<9D<!2B!36<!73?:<93!29!36<!7D622@!>=<M57<7E!G?3!=836<=!

36<!:<;=<<!32!465D6!36<!73?:<93!57!:<95<:!<:?D835298@!2>>2=3?9535<7FQR!

(9D<!8!>=23<D3<:!593<=<73!687!G<<9!5M>85=<:E!36<!B598@!73<>!59!<I8@?8359;!

>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77!D@85M7!57!36<!M273!:5BB5D?@3!2B!36<!36=<<J!:<3<=M5959;!624!M?D6!

>=2D<77!57!:?<F!!(9!36<!29<!689:E!73?:<937!8=<!<9353@<:!32!@<77!>=2D<77!3689!8=<!D535C<97!

2?375:<!36<!>?G@5D!<:?D83529!D293<K3FQV!!(9!36<!236<=!689:E!36<!M2=<!7<=52?7!36<!

:<>=5I83529E!36<!M2=<!>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7!8=<!9<<:<:!32!<97?=<!3683!36<!:<958@!2B!36<!

593<=<73!57!H?735B5<:F!!+9!36<!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!D87<7E!36<!898@A757!:5BB<=7!:<><9:59;!29!36<!

@<9;36!2B!36<!>?9576M<93^!36<=<!57!8!:5I57529!G<34<<9!762=3Z3<=M!7?7><975297!89:!@29;Z

3<=M!7?7><97529l<K>?@75297F!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Qb!3))+$)&2&E!L28=:!2B!'<;<937!IF!'236E!SUh!/F-F!TRSE!TRQ!XPQVbYF!QW!3))!$277!IF!"2><CE!SPQ!/F-F!TRTE!TVWZTVT!XPQVTYF!!,23<!3683!36<!B<:<=8@!*297353?3529!:2<7!923!D=<83<!8!

B?9:8M<938@!=5;63!32!89!<:?D83529^!<:?D83529!G<D2M<7!8!>=2><=3A!593<=<73!46<9!7383<!@84!;=8937!8@@!D65@:=<9!

8!=5;63!32!833<9:!36<!7383<Z=?9!>?G@5D!<:?D83529!7A73<ME!87!8@@!B5B3A!7383<7!68I<F!QS!L=249!IF!L28=:!2B!#:?D83529E!WSV!/F-F!ShWE!SQW!XPQTSYF!QT!SPQ!/F-F!83!TVRF!QR!H"8(:-)$*2@<!IF!,<4329!-><D58@![?9F!-<>8=83<!-D6F!0573FE!RVR!.F!-?>>F!VSQ!X-F0F![577F!PQhVYE!

7?MM8=5@A!8BB\:!E!hTW!.Fb:!QbS!XT36!*5=F!PQhhY!X62@:59;!3683!:?<!>=2D<77!>=23<D35297!8>>@A!46<9!8!73?:<93!

57!572@83<:!B=2M!236<=!73?:<937!89:!<KD@?:<:!B=2M!6<=!=<;?@8=!D@877<7!B2=!75K!:8A7E!<I<9!362?;6!76<!487!

>6A75D8@@A!29!7D622@!;=2?9:7Y!C0.7!'87M?7!IF!-383<!2B!%=5CFE!QWQ!.F!-?>>F!VUQ!X0F!%=5CF!PQQRY!X62@:59;!

3683!8!73?:<93\7!598G5@53A!32!42=]!29!D@877!8775;9M<937!:?=59;!8!3<9ZM59?3<!_35M<2?3a!:5:!923!=57<!32!36<!

@<I<@!2B!8!>=2><=3A!:<>=5I83529!:<7<=I59;!2B!:?<!>=2D<77!>=23<D35297YF!QV!3))!i59<;8=!IF!0<7![259<7!+9:F!*2MM?953A!-D6F!0573FE!bU!.FW:!hQTE!QUP!Xh36!*5=F!PQQSYF!

! ++Zbb

Page 97: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

PF!!-62=3Z3<=M!-?7><975297!

+9!!"##$%&$'"()*E!36<!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!>=2I5:<:!;?5:89D<!=<;8=:59;!36<!8M2?93!2B!

>=2D<77!3683!57!=<N?5=<:!B2=!762=3Z3<=M!7?7><975297F!!)6<!!"##!*2?=3!6<@:!3683!B2=!

7?7><975297!2B!3<9!:8A7!2=!@<77E!36<!73?:<93!M?73!_G<!;5I<9!2=8@!2=!4=533<9!9235D<!2B!36<!

D68=;<7!8;85973!65M!89:E!5B!6<!:<95<7!36<MEQh!89!<K>@8983529!2B!36<!<I5:<9D<!36<!

8?362=535<7!68I<!89:!89!2>>2=3?953A!32!>=<7<93!657!75:<!2B!36<!732=Aa!32!89!2GH<D35I<!

:<D57529!M8]<=FQQ!!)6<!6<8=59;!9<<:!923!G<!8!B?@@!8:I<=78=58@!6<8=59;J!_89!59B2=M8@!;5I<Z

89:Z38]<!G<34<<9!36<!73?:<93!89:!:57D5>@598=589aPUU!57!8@@!3683!57!=<N?5=<:F!!)6<=<B2=<E!B2=!

7?7><975297!2B!3<9!:8A7!2=!@<77E!36<=<!57!92!=5;63!32!D2?97<@E!32!D29B=293!89:!D=277Z

<K8M59<!4539<77<7E!2=!32!D8@@!:<B<97<!4539<77<7F!!)<9!A<8=7!8B3<=!!"##E!36<!*2?=3!

=<8BB5=M<:!3657!>2593!GA!2G7<=I59;!3683!8!342Z:8A!7?7><97529!_:2<7!923!=57<!32!36<!@<I<@!2B!

8!><98@!789D3529!D8@@59;!B2=!36<!B?@@!>892>@A!2B!>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77!>=23<D35297!

8>>@5D8G@<!32!8!D=5M598@!>=27<D?3529FaPUP!

bF!"29;Z3<=M!-?7><975297!89:!#K>?@75297!

/9B2=3?983<@AE!36<=<!57!@<77!;?5:89D<!=<;8=:59;!36<!8M2?93!2B!>=2D<77!=<N?5=<:!B2=!

8!@29;<=!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529E!8@362?;6!36<!!"##!*2?=3!D2MM<93<:!3683!_o@p29;<=!

7?7><975297!2=!<K>?@75297!B2=!36<!=<M859:<=!2B!36<!7D622@!3<=ME!2=!><=M89<93@AE!M8A!

=<N?5=<!M2=<!B2=M8@!>=2D<:?=<7FsPUb!!+9!36<!8G7<9D<!2B!8!:5=<D3!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!>=<D<:<93E!

M273!D2?=37!@22]!32!D0O"1$%&$?;:M:8:$3.:.)$F":-5$"G$954/:.0"1PUW!B2=!;?5:89D<!=<;8=:59;!

36<!8M2?93!2B!>=2D<77!:?<!B2=!@29;<=!7?7><975297!89:!<K>?@75297F!+9!D0O"1+!36<!.5B36!

*5=D?53!6<@:!3683!465@<!8!_B?@@Z:=<77!H?:5D58@!6<8=59;a!487!923!=<N?5=<:!32!<K><@!8!D2@@<;<!

73?:<93!B2=!M57D29:?D3E!

o9p<I<=36<@<77E!36<!=?:5M<937!2B!89!8:I<=78=A!>=2D<<:59;!M8A!G<!

>=<7<=I<:!45362?3!<9D=28D659;!?>29!36<!593<=<737!2B!o36<!<:?D835298@!

597353?3529pF!!+9!36<!5973893!D87<E!36<!73?:<93!762?@:!G<!;5I<9!36<!98M<7!2B!

36<!4539<77<7!8;85973!65M!89:!89!2=8@!2=!4=533<9!=<>2=3!29!36<!8D37!32!465D6!

<8D6!4539<77!3<735B5<7F!!`<!762?@:!8@72!G<!;5I<9!36<!2>>2=3?953A!32!>=<7<93!!

F!F!F!657!249!:<B<97<!8;85973!36<!D68=;<7!89:!32!>=2:?D<!<536<=!2=8@!

3<735M29A!2=!4=533<9!8BB5:8I537!2B!4539<77<7!59!657!G<68@BFPUS!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Qh!L?3!_46<9!8!73?:<93!8:M537!32!36<!D29:?D3!;5I59;!=57<!32!36<!7?7><97529E!36<!9<<:!B2=!8!:?<!>=2D<77!

6<8=59;!57!2GI583<:E!759D<!36<!>?=>27<!2B!8!6<8=59;!57!32!78B<;?8=:!8;85973!>?9576M<93!2B!73?:<937!462!8=<!

5992D<93!2B!36<!8DD?7835297!8;85973!36<MFa!*2@<!IF!,<4329!-><D58@![?9F!-<>8=83<!-D6F!0573FE!RVR!.F!-?>>F!

VSQE!VTb!X-F0F![577F!PQhVYE!7?MM8=5@A!8BB\:!E!hTW!.Fb:!QbS!XT36!*5=F!PQhhYF!!3))$L@8D]!*28@53529!IF!

&2=3@89:!-D6F!0573FE!ShS!.Fb:!PUSUE!PUST!XQ36!*5=F!PQVWY^![2932A8!IF!-89;<=!/95B5<:!-D6F!0573FE!TUb!.F!

-?>>F!bUQE!bPW!X#F0F!*8@F!PQhUYF!QQ!SPQ!/F-F!83!ThPF!!,23<!3683!89!8:M59573=832=!462!57!B8M5@58=!4536!36<!D87<!M8A!7<=I<!87!36<!:<D57529!

M8]<=!87!@29;!87!6<!2=!76<!877<77<7!36<!753?83529!B85=@A!89:!29!36<!G8757!2B!I8@5:!<I5:<9D<F!PUU!SPQ!/F-F!83!ThSF!PUP!L<36<@!-D6F!0573F!IF!.=87<=E!SVh!/F-F!RVTE!RhR!XPQhRYF!PUb!SPQ!/F-F!83!ThSF!PUW!bQS!.Fb:!PUT!XT36!*5=F!PQRPYF!PUS!05K29!IF!%@8G8M8!-3F!L:F!2B!#:?DFE!bQS!.Fb:!PTUE!PTQ!XT36!*5=F!PQRPYF!

! ++ZbW

Page 98: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

%::535298@@AE!46<9!:<D5:59;!>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77!D@85M7E!D2?=37!2B3<9!3?=9!32!

Q:.7)C#$%&$9;5-052)EPUT!465D6!57!923!8!7D622@!:57D5>@59<!D87<!G?3!>=2I5:<7!8!_>2@5DAZ

2=5<93<:!898@A757!2B!>=2D<:?=8@!:?<!>=2D<77!577?<7aPUR!3683!4<5;6!36=<<!B8D32=7!8;85973!

<8D6!236<=J!

.5=73E!36<!>=5I83<!593<=<73!3683!45@@!G<!8BB<D3<:!GA!36<!2BB5D58@!8D3529^!

7<D29:E!36<!=57]!2B!89!<==29<2?7!:<>=5I83529!2B!7?D6!593<=<73!36=2?;6!36<!

>=2D<:?=<7!?7<:E!89:!36<!>=2G8G@<!I8@?<E!5B!89AE!2B!8::535298@!2=!7?G7353?3<!

>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7^!89:!B598@@AE!36<!$2I<=9M<93t7!593<=<73E!59D@?:59;!

36<!B?9D3529!59I2@I<:!89:!36<!B57D8@!89:!8:M59573=835I<!G?=:<97!3683!36<!

8::535298@!2=!7?G7353?3<!>=2D<:?=8@!=<N?5=<M<93!42?@:!<9385@FPUV!

*2?=37!;<9<=8@@A!=<D2;95C<!3683!8!73?:<93\7!593<=<73!59!D29359?59;!6<=!<:?D83529!57!

4<5;63AE!>8=35D?@8=@A!46<9!8!@29;Z3<=M!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529!57!83!577?<F!!"5]<457<E!

D2?=37!8D]924@<:;<!3683!8!7D622@\7!593<=<73!59!M859385959;!:57D5>@59<!89:!8!78B<!

<9I5=29M<93!D29:?D5I<!32!@<8=959;!57!8@72!D2MM89:59;F!!*297<N?<93@AE!M273!2B!36<!

:<G83<!D<93<=7!29!36<!=57]!2B!<==29<2?7!:<>=5I83529!89:!36<!I8@?<!2B!8::535298@!78B<;?8=:7F!!

)657!59N?5=A!57!<K3=<M<@A!B8D3!7><D5B5DE!89:!D2?=37!68I<!=<8D6<:!:5BB<=59;!D29D@?75297!29!

36<!75M5@8=!577?<7F!!.2=!<K8M>@<E!89!+@@59257!D2?=3!6<@:!3683!8@362?;6!<K>?@7529!>=2D<:?=<7!

8=<!923!7?GH<D3!32!36<!=?@<7!2B!<I5:<9D<E!36<!8:M577529!2B!8DD?7832=A!6<8=78A!7383<M<937!

G2@73<=<:!GA!8!7D622@!2BB5D58@\7!3<735M29A!>=2D@85M59;!36<!>=2>29<93\7!=<@58G5@53A!487!8!

_>8=35D?@8=@A!<;=<;52?7!:<>8=3?=<!B=2M!36<!8:I<=78=58@!7389:8=:FaPUh!!+9!D293=873E!36<!.5B36!

*5=D?53!_=<H<D3o<:p!36<!8=;?M<93!2B!8>><@@893!3683!6<8=78A!3<735M29A!487!D297353?35298@@A!

>=265G53<:FaPUQ!

L<D8?7<!2B!36<!B8D3Z7><D5B5D!983?=<!2B!36<!59N?5=AE!8>><@@83<!89:!236<=!D2?=37!

:<D575297!I8=A!B=2M!D5=D?53!32!D5=D?53F!!`24<I<=E!8?362=7!2B!8!=<D<93!3<K3!29!36<!7?GH<D3!

7?;;<73!3683!7D622@!:573=5D37!762?@:!>=2I5:<!9235D<!3683!D2938597!36<!B2@@2459;!<@<M<937J!

!" 89!<K>=<77!593<93!32!7?7><9:!2=!<K><@!36<!73?:<93!

!" 36<!7><D5B5D!D68=;<7!8;85973!36<!73?:<93!

!" 465D6!=?@<!487!8@@<;<:@A!G=2]<9!

!" 36<!983?=<!2B!36<!<I5:<9D<!7?>>2=359;!36<!D68=;<!

!" 36<!:83<E!35M<E!89:!>@8D<!46<=<!36<!6<8=59;!=<;8=:59;!36<!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529!

45@@!G<!6<@:!

!" 8!D2>A!2B!36<!>=2D<:?=<7!3683!45@@!G<!B2@@24<:!83!36<!6<8=59;!

!" 8!=<M59:<=!2B!36<!=5;637!3683!36<!73?:<937!89:!>8=<93X7Y!68I<E!59D@?:59;!36<!=5;63!32!

D2?97<@E!>=<7<9383529!2B!4539<77<7E!D=277Z<K8M5983529!2B!62735@<!4539<77<7E!89:!8!

D2>A!2B!36<!6<8=59;!3=897D=5>3FPPU!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PUT!SbS!/F-F!WPQ!XPQVRYF!PUR!,<472M<!IF!L838I58!"2D8@!-D6F!0573FE!hSb!.Fb:!QbUE!QbS!XR36!*5=F!PQhhYF!PUV![836<47!IF!#@:=5:;<E!SbS!/F-F!WPQE!WWT!XPQVRYF!PUh!*2@N?533!IF!'5D6!)4976>FE!RQQ!,F#Fb:!PPUQE!PPPR!X+@@F!%>>F!PQQhYF!PUQ!"<<!IF![8D29!*2?93A!L:F!2B!#:?DFE!SQU!.Fb:!SThE!STQ!9FP!XT36!*5=F!PQVSYF!PPU!3))!"84=<9D<!.F!'27724!c!n<==A!'F!&8=]59729E!)6<!"84!2B!-3?:<93!#K>?@75297!89:!-?7><975297!SZV!

Xb:!<:F!PQQQYF!

! ++ZbS

Page 99: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

WF!)6<!_[<8959;B?@9<77a!2B!36<!057D5>@598=A!`<8=59;!

+9!8::53529!32!36<7<!3A><7!2B!@53<=8@@A!_>=2D<:?=8@a!53<M7E!89236<=!B?9:8M<938@!

=<N?5=<M<93!2B!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!57!36<!2>>2=3?953A!32!G<!6<8=:!83!8!_M<8959;B?@!

35M<!89:!59!8!M<8959;B?@!M899<=FaPPP!!*297<N?<93@AE!59!M273!D87<7E!36<!8:M59573=835I<!

>=2D<77!M?73!2DD?=!>=52=!32!36<!5M>@<M<9383529!2B!36<!7?7><97529F!!`24<I<=E!5B!8!

73?:<93\7!_>=<7<9D<!o59!36<!7D622@p!>27<7!8!D29359?59;!:89;<=!32!><=7297!2=!>=2><=3A!2=!89!

29;259;!36=<83!2B!:57=?>359;!36<!8D8:<M5D!>=2D<77!o36<!73?:<93p!M8A!G<!5MM<:583<@A!

=<M2I<:!B=2M!7D622@FaPPb!!#I<9!59!36<7<!D87<7E!36<!73?:<93!57!<9353@<:!32!:?<!>=2D<77!

>=23<D35297^!36<!9235D<!89:!6<8=59;!762?@:!B2@@24!36<!7?7><97529!X2=!<K>?@7529Y!_87!7229!

87!>=8D35D8G@<FaPPW!

0<3<=M5959;!4683!D297353?3<7!8!_M<8959;B?@!M899<=a!687!>=2I<9!M2=<!:5BB5D?@3F!!

)6<!-?>=<M<!*2?=3!687!6<@:!3683!3657!M595M8@@A!M<897!3683!5B!89!<77<9358@!<@<M<93!32!36<!

:<D57529!57!<KD@?:<:!B=2M!D2975:<=83529E!36<9!:?<!>=2D<77!687!923!G<<9!78357B5<:FPPS!!+9!

36<!7D622@!:57D5>@598=A!7<3359;E!3657!898@A757!45@@!2B3<9!:<><9:!29!46<36<=!36<!:57D5>@59<!

>2@5DA!D8@@7!B2=!8!M89:832=A!>?9576M<93F!

%!7<=5<7!2B!D87<7!8=5759;!59!36<!.5B36!*5=D?53!5@@?73=83<!3657!>=59D5>@<F!!+9!'))$%&$

Q:/"1$H"41.=$F":-5$"G$954/:.0"1E!36<!.5B36!*5=D?53!2I<=3?=9<:!36<!><=M89<93!<K>?@7529!

2B!342!;5=@7!B2=!8!7<=5<7!2B!_?9:57D5>@59<:E!:<B5893E!89:!8G?75I<a!G<68I52=FPPT!!)6<!D2?=3!

6<@:!3683!46<9!8!_7<=52?7!><98@3Aa!7?D6!87!<K>?@7529!57!83!738]<E!36<!7D622@!G28=:!M?73!

M8]<!89!59:<><9:<93!:57D5>@598=A!:<3<=M5983529!5973<8:!2B!75M>@A!D29B5=M59;!36<!

>=59D5>8@\7!=<D2MM<9:83529FPPR!!+9!8!M?D6!D53<:!>8778;<E!36<!D2?=3!7383<:J!_.2=M8@5735D!

8DD<>389D<!2=!=835B5D83529!2B!36<!>=59D5>8@\7!=<N?<73!2=!=<D2MM<9:83529!87!32!36<!7D2><!2B!

>?9576M<93E!45362?3!59:<><9:<93!L28=:!D2975:<=83529!2B!4683E!?9:<=!8@@!36<!

D5=D?M7389D<7E!36<!><98@3A!762?@:!G<E!57!@<77!3689!B?@@!:?<!>=2D<77FaPPV!!`24<I<=E!87!

:57D?77<:!9<K3E!3657!62@:59;!57!923!87!G=28:!87!53!7<<M7!29!537!B8D<F!

-5K!A<8=7!@83<=E!59!Q0./7);;$%&$F":-5$"G$I-4#.))#E!36<!78M<!D2?=3!487!D29B=293<:!

4536!36<!D87<!2B!342!73?:<937!462!68:!36=<83<9<:!236<=7!4536!]95I<7!83!7D622@!89:!4<=<!

<K><@@<:!B2=!36<!=<M859:<=!2B!36<!7<M<73<=!?9:<=!8!M89:832=A!<K>?@7529!=?@<FPPh!!)6<!

D2?=3!<K>@5D53@A!7383<:!3683!_o3p6<!@<;8@!577?<!59!36<!D87<!87!8:I89D<:!GA!36<!>@85935BB7!57!

46<36<=E!87!8!M833<=!2B!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77E!8!73?:<93!57!;?8=893<<:!72M<!:57D=<3529!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PPP!%=M73=29;!IF![89C2E!WhU!/F-F!TSTE!TTb!XPQRTY^!!7))$:;#"!-5<D]!IF!(8]!&8=]!c'5I<=!.2=<73!`5;6!-D6F!

0573FE!hUV!.F!-?>>F!VW!X,F0F!+@@F!PQQbY!X62@:59;!3683!8!>2@5DA!2B!M89:832=A!7?7><97529!B2=!36<B3!D8@@<:!5932!

N?<73529!36<!_M<8959;B?@9<77a!2B!73?:<93\7!6<8=59;YF!PPb!SPQ!/F-F!83!ThSF!PPW!K5&!83!ThbF!PPS!3))!L<@@!IF!L?=729E!SUb!/F-F!TWTE!TSb!XPQVPYF!PPT!"<<!IF![8D29!*2?93A!L:F!2B!#:?DFE!SQU!.Fb:!SThE!SRU!XT36!*5=F!PQVSYF!!)6<!2GH<D35298G@<!G<68I52=!

59D@?:<:!B5;6359;!83!7D622@E!:5=<D359;!8G?75I<!@89;?8;<!83!3<8D6<=7E!M57759;!7D622@!83!@<873!29D<!45362?3!

><=M577529E!:572G<A59;!3<8D6<=7\!:5=<D35297E!89:!=<757359;!D2=>2=8@!89:!236<=!B2=M7!2B!>?9576M<93F!PPR!K5F!83!SRUF!!PPV!K5&$PPh!3))![53D6<@@!IF!L28=:!2B!)=?73<<7E!RbT!.Fb:!RRU!XT36!*5=F!PQhUYF!

! ++ZbT

Page 100: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

GA!36<!-D622@!L28=:!59!B5K59;!36<!>?9576M<93!B2=!I52@83529!2B!8!=?@<F!!)6<!>@85935BB7!8=;?<!

36<A!68I<!7?D6!8!=5;63^!4<!:578;=<<FaPPQ!!)6<7<!7<<M59;@A!D293=8:5D32=A!62@:59;7!D89!29@A!

G<!<K>@859<:!GA!36<!B8D3!3683!59!Q0./7);;E!?9@5]<!59$'))E!36<=<!487!8!M89:832=A!

>?9576M<93!=<N?5=<:!GA!36<!:573=5D3\7!:57D5>@59<!D2:<F!

)657!=<8:59;!57!?>6<@:!GA!89!5M>2=3893!:573=5D3!D2?=3!D87<!8@72!8=5759;!59!36<!.5B36!

*5=D?53F!!+9!H";%01$%&$'"C15)#$H"41.=EPbU!36<!D2?=3!D2975:<=<:!36<!D87<!2B!8!G2A!462!487!

<K><@@<:!?9:<=!89!?94=533<9!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!B2=!598:I<=3<93@A!G=59;59;!8!-4577!

8=MA!]95B<!32!7D622@!<I<9!362?;6!6<!36=<83<9<:!92!29<!4536!36<!53<M!89:!3?=9<:!53!2I<=!32!

657!3<8D6<=!45362?3!59D5:<93F!!)6<!D2?=3!<K3<9:<:!36<!@2;5D!2B!'))!32!62@:!3683!7D622@!

G28=:7!D2?@:!923!:<B<=!32!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DAE!465D6!36<!D2?=3!:<7D=5G<:!87!8!_G@89]<3!

>2@5DA!2B!<K>?@7529E!8G7<93!=<B<=<9D<!32!36<!D5=D?M7389D<7!2B!36<!59B=8D3529EaPbP!H?73!87!

36<A!D2?@:!923!:<B<=!32!36<!=<D2MM<9:83529!2B!36<!>=59D5>8@!59!'))F!

+M>2=3893@AE!36<!=<@<I893!7383<!@84!;=893<:!36<!7?><=593<9:<93!36<!8?362=53A!32!

M2:5BA!<K>?@75297!29!8!D87<!GA!D87<!G8757E!89:!36<!7D622@\7!689:G22]!>=2I5:<:!3683!5B!8!

73?:<93!57!B2?9:!_;?5@3A!2B!F!F!F!36<!D68=;<7!8;85973!65Ml6<=E!36<!7D622@!=<D2=:!89:!

>=<I52?7!D29:?D3!2B!36<!73?:<93!45@@!G<!38]<9!5932!D2975:<=83529!59!:<3<=M5959;!36<!

:57D5>@59<!8:M59573<=<:!32!36<!73?:<93FaPbb!!%DD2=:59;@AE!36<!D2?=3!:5:!923!62@:!3683!

M89:832=A!>?9576M<937!2BB<9:!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<E!G?3!=836<=!3683!465@<!36<!_7D622@!

G28=:!M8A!D6227<!923!32!<K<=D57<!537!>24<=!2B!@<95<9DA!FFF!53!M8A!923!65:<!G<659:!36<!

923529!3683!36<!@84!>=265G537!@<95<9DA!B2=!36<=<!57!92!7?D6!@84FaPbW!!)6<!D2?=3!2=:<=<:!36<!

7D622@!G28=:!32!=<D2975:<=!36<!D87<!?9:<=!36<!8>>=2>=583<!@<;8@!7389:8=:E!98M<@A!29<!3683!

=<N?5=<7!89!_59:<><9:<93!D2975:<=83529!GA!36<!L28=:!2B!36<!=<@<I893!B8D37!89:!

D5=D?M7389D<7!7?==2?9:59;!o36<!73?:<93\7p!D87<FaPbS!

%!A<8=!<8=@5<=E!8!&<997A@I8958!D2?=3!8;=<<:!4536!3657!=<872959;!59!8!D87<!59I2@I59;!

8!73?:<93!462!B2?9:!8!-4577!8=MA!]95B<!59!8!7D622@!68@@48A!89:!36<9!3?=9<:!2I<=!36<!

53<M!45362?3!59D5:<93!?>29!=<N?<73FPbT!!)6<!7D622@!:573=5D3!68:!89!?94=533<9!C<=2!

32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!3683!D293=8:5D3<:!8!7383<!7383?3<!8@@2459;!36<!7?><=593<9:<93!32!M2:5BA!

<K>?@75297!29!8!D87<ZGAZD87<!G8757F!!)6<=<B2=<E!36<!D2?=3!6<@:!3683!36<!7D622@!G28=:!

<KD<<:<:!537!7383?32=A!;=893!2B!8?362=53A!GA!8:2>359;!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!3683!

>=<I<93<:!89!<K<=D57<!2B!:57D=<3529!GA!7D622@!2BB5D58@7FPbR!

LF!-?G738935I<!0?<!&=2D<77!

!

)6<!7<D29:!87><D3!2B!36<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@8?7<!57!D29D<=9<:!4536!46<36<=!8!7383<!

M8A!5M>85=!8!;5I<9!7?G738935I<!=5;63E!=<;8=:@<77!2B!36<!B85=9<77!2B!36<!>=2D<:?=<7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PPQ!K5&$83!!RRbF!PbU!,2F!QQ*OWURE!bUUU!/F-F!0573F!"#e+-!bSUW!X,F0F![577F!.<GF!bSE!bUUUYF!PbP!*2@I59!IF!"249:<7!*2?93A!-D6F!0573FE!,2F!QQ*OWURE!bUUU!/F-F!0573F!"#e+-!bSUW!X,F0F![577F!.<GF!bSE!

bUUUYF!Pbb!K5&$PbW!K5&$PbS!K5&$PbT!3))!"A297!IF!&<99!`5@@7!-D6F!0573FE!VbW!%Fb:!PUVW!X&8F!*2MM4F!PQQQYF!PbR!K5&$83!PUVRF!

! ++ZbR

Page 101: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

<M>@2A<:FPbV!!%!36=<762@:!577?<!59!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!898@A757!57!46<36<=!36<!=?@<!2=!

>2@5DA!59!N?<73529!>=2I5:<7!8:<N?83<!9235D<!2B!4683!D29:?D3!57!>=265G53<:F!!L<D8?7<!

D2?=37!=<D2;95C<!3683!7D622@7!9<<:!32!G<!8G@<!32!:57D5>@59<!73?:<937!B2=!8!45:<!=89;<!2B!

:57=?>35I<!8D35I535<7E!M89A!2B!465D6!8=<!?98935D5>83<:E!7D622@!:57D5>@598=A!D2:<7!:2!923!

9<<:!32!G<!87!:<385@<:!D=5M598@!D2:<7FPbh!!`24<I<=E!8!D2?=3!45@@!73=5]<!:249!8!=?@<!87!

?9D297353?35298@@A!I8;?<!5B!53!_B2=G5:7!2=!=<N?5=<7!36<!:259;!2B!89!8D3!59!3<=M7!72!I8;?<!

3683!o><=7297p!2B!D2MM29!593<@@5;<9D<!M?73!9<D<778=5@A!;?<77!83!537!M<8959;!89:!:5BB<=!87!

32!537!8>>@5D83529FaPbQ!!/9@<77!D297353?35298@@A!>=23<D3<:!D29:?D3!57!83!738]<E!7?D6!87!

B=<<:2M!2B!7><<D6!2=!=<@5;529E!8!>@85935BB!M8A!29@A!D68@@<9;<!36<!=?@<!87!53!487!8>>@5<:!32!

6<=FPWU!!+9!236<=!42=:7E!5B!8!73?:<93\7!D29:?D3!487!D@<8=@A!>=265G53<:!GA!36<!:57D5>@59<!

>2@5DAE!36<!73?:<93!?7?8@@A!M8A!923!7?DD<77B?@@A!D68@@<9;<!36<!=?@<!B2=!I8;?<9<77!<I<9!

362?;6!36<!=?@<!M8A!I<=A!4<@@!G<!I8;?<!87!8>>@5<:!32!236<=7\!6A>236<35D8@!D29:?D3FPWP!

%77?M59;!3683!36<!>2@5DA!59!N?<73529!;5I<7!8:<N?83<!9235D<!32!73?:<937!=<;8=:59;!

36<!3A><!2B!D29:?D3!3683!57!>?95768G@<E!36<!9<K3!73<>!59!<I8@?8359;!8!7?G738935I<!:?<!

>=2D<77!D@85M!57!32!:<3<=M59<!46<36<=!36<!5M>85=<:!=5;63!57!8!B?9:8M<938@!2=!929Z

B?9:8M<938@!=5;63F!!+B!8!=5;63!57!B?9:8M<938@E!36<9!36<!D2?=37!45@@!8>>@A!73=5D3!7D=?359A!32!

:<3<=M59<!46<36<=!36<!7383<\7!5M>85=M<93!2B!3683!=5;63!57!D297353?35298@F!!)2!>877!73=5D3!

7D=?359AE!36<!7383<\7!2GH<D35I<!M?73!G<!D2M><@@59;E!89:!36<!M<362:!?7<:!GA!36<!7383<!M?73!

G<!9<D<778=A!32!8D65<I<!3683!D2M><@@59;!2GH<D35I<FPWb!!)6<!898@A757!B2=!929ZB?9:8M<938@!

=5;637E!M<=<!=835298@53AE!57!M?D6!@<77!73=59;<93F!!)6<!7383<!M?73!M<=<@A!G<!>?=7?59;!8!

@<;535M83<!;2I<=9M<938@!2GH<D35I<!GA!8!M<362:!3683!57!=835298@@A!=<@83<:!32!8D65<I59;!537!

;28@FPWW!

*2?=37!68I<!D2973=?<:!B?9:8M<938@!=5;637!98==24@AE!89:!B2=!36<!>?=>27<7!2B!

B<:<=8@!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!898@A757E!29@A!36<!=5;637!2B!>=5I8DA!89:!8?3292MA!8=<!

D2975:<=<:!B?9:8M<938@F!!+9!>=8D35D<E!46<36<=!8!=5;63!57!B?9:8M<938@!8@M273!8@48A7!

:<3<=M59<7!36<!2?3D2M<!2B!36<!D87<FPWS!!%@362?;6!36<!=5;63!2B!73?:<937!32!833<9:!7D622@!57!

>=23<D3<:E!53!57!923!8!B?9:8M<938@!=5;63!B2=!>?=>27<7!2B!B<:<=8@!D297353?35298@!@84FPWT!!

)6<=<B2=<E!_=<I5<4!89:!=<I57529!2B!8!7D622@!7?7><97529!29!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!

;=2?9:7!42?@:!29@A!G<!8I85@8G@<!59!8!=8=<!D87<!46<=<!36<=<!487!92!q=835298@!=<@83529765>!

G<34<<9!36<!>?9576M<93!89:!36<!2BB<97<F\aPWR!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PbV!3))!0895<@7!IF!i5@@58M7E!SVS!/F-F!WbV!XPQhRYF!Pbh!3))!L<36<@!-D6F!0573F!IF!.=87<=E!SVh!/F-F!RVTE!RhR!XPQhWYF!PbQ!*2998@@A!IF!$<9<=8@!*2973=F!*2FE!bRQ!/F-F!WhTE!WQP!XPQbRYF!PWU!3))!-3<>6<9729!IF!08I<9>2=3!*2MM?953A!-D6F!0573FE!PPU!.FW:!PWUWE!PWUh!Xh36!*5=F!PQQVYF!PWP!3))!%5<@@2!IF!*53A!2B!i5@M59;329E!RbW!.Fb:!hSTE!hTU!XW:!*5=F!PQhUYF!PWb!3))+$)&2&E!&@A@<=!IF!02<E!STV!/F-F!bUb!XPQhbY^!'2<!IF!i8:<E!SPU!/F-F!PPW!XPQVWYF!PWW!3))+$)&2FE!&@A@<=!IF!02<E!STV!/F-F!bUb!XPQhbY^!i68@<9!IF!'2<E!SbQ!/F-F!ThQ!XPQVVYF!PWS!L?3!B2=!342!D87<7!73=5]59;!:249!7383?3<7!?9:<=!36<!_M<=<!=835298@53Aa!3<73E!7<<![<A<=!IF!,<G=87]8E!bRb!

/F-F!WQUE!SUW!XPQbWY!X62@:59;!3683!8!7383?3<!3683!>=265G53<:!3<8D659;!B2=<5;9!@89;?8;<7!32!D65@:=<9!I52@83<:!

7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!G<D8?7<!53!487!_45362?3!=<87298G@<!=<@83529!32!89A!<9:!453659!36<!D2M><3<9DA!2B!

36<!-383<FaY^!:15!'2M<=!IF!#I897E!TPV!/F-F!RbU!XPQQRY!X62@:59;!3683!@847!M235I83<:!GA!_895M?7a!2=!

_62735@53Aa!B85@!36<!M<=<!=835298@53A!3<73!?9:<=!36<!#N?8@!&=23<D3529!*@8?7<YF!PWT!3))!-89!%932952!+9:<>F!-D6F!0573F!OF!'2:=5;?<CE!SPP!/F-F!PE!WhZSU!XPQVWYF!!!PWR!L=<4<=!IF!%?7359F!+9:<>F!-D6F!0573FE!VVQ!.Fb:!bRUE!bRS!XT36!*5=F!PQhTY!XD5359;![53D6<@@!IF!L28=:!2B!

)=?73<<7E!RbT!.Fb:!RRUE!RRS!9Fh!XT36!*5=F!PQhUYYF!

! ++ZbV

Page 102: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

*2?=37!2B3<9!<M>@2A!:5BB<=<93!>6=87<7!59!877<7759;!46<36<=!8!=835298@!=<@83529765>!

<K5737!G<34<<9!36<!2BB<97<!89:!36<!>?9576M<93F!!*2?=37!68I<!87]<:!46<36<=!36<!

>?9576M<93!487!_8=G53=8=AE!D8>=5D52?7E!2=!462@@A!?9=<@83<:!32!36<!@<;535M83<!7383<!;28@!2B!

M859385959;!89!83M27>6<=<!D29:?D5I<!32!@<8=959;aPWV!2=!_;=277@A!:57>=2>2=352983<a!32!36<!

2BB<97<^PWh!487!36<=<!8!_762D]59;!:57>8=53A!G<34<<9!36<!<K>?@7529!89:!36<!2BB<97<a^

PWQ!2=!

487!36<!8D3529!_45@@B?@!89:!?9=<872959;!F!F!F!45362?3!D2975:<=83529!89:!59!:57=<;8=:!2B!36<!

B8D37!2=!D5=D?M7389D<7!2B!36<!D87<FaPSU!

%7!M5;63!G<!<K><D3<:!;5I<9!36<7<!65;6!36=<762@:7E!53!57!<K3=<M<@A!=8=<!B2=!8!

B<:<=8@!D2?=3!32!7<3!875:<!89!8:M59573=835I<!:<D57529!87!8!I52@83529!2B!7?G738935I<!:?<!

>=2D<77F!!L<D8?7<!2B!36<!59D=<87<:!:<B<=<9D<!D2?=37!7624!32!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!59!M833<=7!

=<;8=:59;!:57D5>@59<E!53!57!<I<9!M2=<!?9@5]<@A!3683!8!B<:<=8@!D2?=3!42?@:!=<I<=7<!8!7D622@!

2BB5D58@\7!:57D5>@59<!:<D57529!29!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!;=2?9:7F!

.2=!<K8M>@<E!89!%@8G8M8!D2?=3!6<@:!3683!89!<5;63Z4<<]!7?7><97529!2B!8!;5=@!462!

:=2I<!32!7D622@!59!8!B8M5@A!D8=!D29385959;!8!;?9!@<B3!59!53!GA!36<!M236<=!g!8!B8D3!?9]9249!

32!36<!;5=@!g!:5:!923!I52@83<!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77FPSP!!)6<!D2?=3!923<:!3683!36<!7D622@!

G28=:!8>>8=<93@A!D2975:<=<:!36<!M535;8359;!B8D32=7!59!3657!D87<!759D<!36<A!=<:?D<:!36<!

7383?32=5@A!=<D2MM<9:<:!29<ZA<8=!<K>?@7529!32!89!<5;63Z4<<]!7?7><97529FPSb!!-5M5@8=@AE!8!

B<:<=8@!D2?=3!59!f<93?D]A!B2?9:!3683!<K><@@59;!8!73?:<93!B2=!36<!=<M859:<=!2B!36<!

8D8:<M5D!A<8=!487!923!_;=277@A!:57>=2>2=352983<a!32!36<!2BB<97<!2B!7M2]59;!M8=5H?898!29!

7D622@!>=2><=3AFPSW!

+3!57!D=?D58@!32!923<!3683!D2?=37!2B3<9!D2MM<93!3683!36<A!B59:!8!>?9576M<93!68=76!2=!

@<77!3689!5:<8@E!G?3!36<5=!:578;=<<M<93!4536!36<!<BB5D8DA!2B!36<!:57D5>@598=A!8D3529!:2<7!923!

>=2I5:<!8!@<;8@!G8757!B2=!7<3359;!875:<!36<!>?9576M<93!5M>27<:!GA!36<!7D622@!2BB5D58@7F!!+9!

?>62@:59;!8!3=5M<73<=!7?7><97529!2B!8!73?:<93!462!7<=52?7@A!2I<=:27<:!29!8!>=<7D=5>3529!

8935:<>=<77893E!36<!D2?=3!:5:!923!B59:!36<!>?9576M<93!_8!>8=35D?@8=@A!36<=8><?35D!:27<!2B!

H?735D<Ea!G?3!D29D@?:<:!3683!_o3p6<!7D622@\7!>2@5DA!2B!7?7><97529!B2=!8!3=5M<73<=!36?7!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PWV!i22:8=:!IF!"27!.=<7927!+9:<>F!-D6F!0573FE!VWb!.Fb:!PbSWE!PbSR!XT36!*5=FPQhSYF!!L<D8?7<!36<!>6=87<!

_8=G53=8=A!89:!D8>=5D52?7a!57!M2=<!D@27<@A!8772D583<:!4536!8:M59573=835I<!@84E!3657!D89!D8?7<!D29B?7529F!!

%@362?;6!36<!59N?5=5<7!?9:<=!<8D6!G2:A!2B!@84!8=<!D29D<>3?8@@A!=<@83<:!59!3683!36<A!<77<9358@@A!<I8@?83<!36<!

N?8@53A!2B!36<!7D622@!2BB5D58@7\!:<D57529E!36<A!8=<!898@A35D8@@A!:57359D3!89:!:5BB<=!59!36<!=5;2=!4536!465D6!

D2?=37!=<I5<4!36<!:<D57529F!!_f<93?D]A!7383<!D2?=37!68I<!8!B8=!G=28:<=!7D2><!2B!=<I5<4!B2=!q8=G53=8=59<77\!59!

7D622@!:<D575297!3689!:2!B<:<=8@!D2?=37Fa!!&<3=<A!IF!.@8?;6<=E!TUT!.F!-?>>F!PUhVE!PUQU!X#F0F!fAF!PQhPYF!!

/759;!8!3238@53A!2B!36<!D5=D?M7389D<7!3<73!?9:<=!7383<!8:M59573=835I<!@84E!89!+@@59257!D2?=3!2I<==?@<:!8!7D622@!

G28=:\7!:<D57529!32!7?7><9:!8!73?:<93!G<D8?7<!36<!G28=:\7!2=:<=!487!_>8@>8G@A!8;85973!36<!M895B<73!4<5;63!

2B!36<!<I5:<9D<Fa!!i87659;329!IF!-M536E!RPh!,F#Fb:!TRPE!TRW!X+@@F!%>>F!*3F!PQQWY!X62@:59;!3683!8!7<M<73<=!

<K>?@7529!B2=!68I59;!89!5D<!>5D]!83!7D622@!487!?948==893<:!;5I<9!3683!36<!<I5:<9D<!:5:!923!7624!3683!36<!

73?:<93!36=<83<9<:!89A29<!59!89A!48AYF!!!!PWh!n8M<7!IF!/95B5<:!-D6F!0573FE!hQQ!.F!-?>>F!TWUE!TWS!X0F!f89F!PQQTY^!&<3=<A!IF!.@8?;6<=E!TUT!.F!-?>>F!

PUhVE!PUQUZQP!X#F0F!fAF!PQhPYF!PWQ!"2]<795D]!IF!(M868!&?GF!-D6F!0573FE!TTh!,FiFb:!hUVE!hPWZPS!X,<GF!PQQVYF!PSU!$=<<965@@!IF!L85@<AE!TPQ!.Fb:!TE!PU!9FPb!Xh36!*5=F!PQVTY!XD53<:!4536!8>>=2I8@!GA!36<!-5K36!*5=D?53!59!

-3<I<97!IF!`?93E!RSR!.Fb:!PPQR!XR36!*5=F!PQhPYYF!PSP!3))E!#93<=>=57<!*53A!L:F!2B!#:?DF!IF!*F&FE!RQh!-2Fb:!PWP!X%@8F!*5IF!%>>F!PQQRYF!PSb!3))$05&$83!PWWF!!PSW!&<3=<A!IF!.@8?;6<=E!TUT!.F!-?>>F!PUhVE!PUQPZQb!X#F0F!fAF!PQhPY!

! ++Zbh

Page 103: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

B?=36<=7!8!@<;535M83<!593<=<73!59!8!=835298@!5B!7<I<=<!M899<=FaPSS!!"5]<457<E!8![5775775>>5!

D2?=3!?>6<@:E!465@<!D@<8=@A!:578;=<<59;!4536E!8!7<M<73<=!7?7><97529!B2=!342!73?:<937!462!

>8593<:!36<!9?MG<=!_Pa!29!8!7D622@!G?5@:59;J!!_o)p6<=<!8=<!M89A!>?9576M<937!465D6!F!F!F!

7<<M!32!?7!M2=<!8>>=2>=583<!3689!3683!465D6!36<!7D622@!G28=:!687!:<3<=M59<:FaPST!!)6<!

D2?=3!I<93?=<:!3683E!8M29;!236<=!>?9576M<937E!36<!;5=@7!M5;63!G<!=<N?5=<:!32!M<M2=5C<!89!

<KD<=>3!B=2M!I7)$Q)-/7:1.$"G$[)10/)!72!3683!36<A!_D2?@:!@<8=9!B=2M!&2=358!3683!q36<!

N?8@53A!2B!M<=DA!57!923!73=859\:\!89:!3683!q<8=36@A!>24<=!:236!FFF!7624!@5]<73!$2:\7!46<9!

M<=DA!7<87297!H?735D<\!g!89:!3<8D6!3657!32!36<5=!>=59D5>8@E!36<5=!7?><=593<9:<93E!36<5=!

7D622@!G28=:E!89:!36<5=!D2MM?953AFaPSR!

*F!-383<!0?<!&=2D<77!*@85M7!

!

)6<!B<:<=8@!*297353?3529!57!923!36<!29@A!72?=D<!2B!:?<!>=2D<77!>=23<D35297F!!+9!

72M<!7383<7E!D2?=37!68I<!6<@:!3683!36<!7383<!D297353?3529!2=!236<=!7383<!@84!D=<83<7!8!

B?9:8M<938@!=5;63!32!8!B=<<!>?G@5D!<:?D83529FPSV!!)6<=<B2=<E!59!M89A!2B!3627<!7383<7E!D2?=37!

45@@!8>>@A!8!6<5;63<9<:!7389:8=:!2B!7D=?359A!32!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!759D<!36<!

:57D5>@598=A!8D3529!59B=59;<7!29!8!B?9:8M<938@!=5;63!?9:<=!7383<!@84F!!/9:<=!8!73=5D3!

7D=?359A!898@A757E!36<!7D622@!:573=5D3!M?73!7624!3683!537!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!487!

9<D<778=A!32!8D65<I<!8!78B<!<9I5=29M<93!D29:?D5I<!32!@<8=959;EPSh!2=!36<!>2@5DA!45@@!G<!

73=?D]!:249F!!)657!762?@:!G<!8!I<=A!:5BB5D?@3!762459;!32!M8]<E!<7><D58@@A!759D<!36<!G?@]!

2B!<:?D835298@!8?362=53A!D2?97<@7!8;85973!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!89:!M89A!7D622@!

:573=5D37!8D=277!36<!D2?93=A!68I<!G<<9!8G@<!32!D=<83<!78B<!@<8=959;!<9I5=29M<937!45362?3!

36<!?7<!2B!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7F!

.?=36<=E!7383<!@847E!7383<!D297353?35297E!89:!7D622@!G28=:!>2@5D5<7!2B3<9!=<N?5=<!

;=<83<=!>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7!3689!36<!B<:<=8@!*297353?3529E!89:!29D<!36<A!8=<!<98D3<:E!

D2?=37!45@@!=<N?5=<!3683!36<A!G<!B2@@24<:FPSQ!![273!7383<!72ZD8@@<:!_C<=2!32@<=89D<a!@847!

8=<!G87<:!29!36<!PQQS!$?9Z.=<<!-D622@7!%D3E!465D6!=<N?5=<7E!8M29;!236<=!3659;7E!3683!

@2D8@!7D622@!7?><=593<9:<937!68I<!:57D=<3529!32!M2:5BA!36<!<K>?@7529!29!8!D87<ZGAZD87<!

G8757F!)6<=<B2=<E!59!7383<7!4536!7?D6!@847E!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!3683!:2!923!8BB2=:!89!

2>>2=3?953A!B2=!7?><=593<9:<937!2=!236<=!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!32!<K<=D57<!:57D=<3529!59!36<!

8>>@5D83529!2B!:57D5>@598=A!M<87?=<7!<KD<<:!36<!G28=:\7!7383?32=A!;=893!2B!8?362=53AF!!

%DD2=:59;@AE!7?D6!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5D5<7!M?73!G<!M2:5B5<:F!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PSS!.576<=!IF!L?=]G?=9<33!+9:F!-D6F!0573FE!SPQ!.F!-?>>F!PbUUE!PbUT!X,F0F!)<KF!PQVRYF!PST!*@59329![?9F!-<>8=83<!-D6F!0573F!IF!LA=:E!SVV!-2Fb:!bWVE!bSb!X[577F!PQhTYF!PSR!*@59329![?9F!-<>8=83<!-D6F!0573F!IF!LA=:E!SVV!-2Fb:!bWVE!bSb!X[577F!PQhTY!XD5359;!i5@@58M!

-68]<7><8=<E!)6<![<=D6893!2B!O<95D<E!%D3!+OE!-DF+E!@59<7!PhSE!PQRZQVYF!PSV!3))+$)&2&+!05&$83!bSU^!&8?@<A!IF!f<@@AE!bTT!-F#Fb:!hTQ!XiF!O8F!PQVQY^!-383<!IF!'5I595?7E!Wbh!,FiFb:!bbUE!

bbh!X,F0F!PQhbYE!D<=3F!:<95<:E!SRU!/F-F!PUVU!XPQhWY^!`2=329!IF![<7]5@@E!WVR!%Fb:!WTQE!WVW!X*299F!PQVVYF!!

F4.$#))+$)&2FE!"?H89!IF!*2@2=8:2!-383<!L:F!2B!#:?DFE!RSQ!&Fb:!PUUTE!PUPh!X*2@2F!PQhbY^!L28=:!2B!#:?DFE!

"<I533249!IF!,AN?573E!TV!,FmFb:!bVE!SW!XPQhbY^!f5=GA!IF!#:;<422:!+9:<>F!-D6F!0573FE!VRP!-FiFb:!hTQE!

hRWZRS!X)<KF!*3F!%>>F!PQhhYE!-)%L5$"1$".7)-$2-"415#E!VVV!-FiFb:!WQP!X)<KF!PQhQYF!!PSh!.2=!>?=>27<7!2B!3657!898@A757E!4<!8=<!877?M59;!3683!8!D2?=3!42?@:!8DD<>3!36<!8=;?M<93!3683!D=<8359;!:=?;!

89:!I52@<9D<!B=<<!7D622@7!57!8!D2M><@@59;!7383<!593<=<73F!PSQ!3))+$)&2&E!i653<!IF!-8@57G?=A!)249765>!-D6F!0573FE!Thh!.F!-?>>F!RUh!X#F0F!&8F!PQhSY^!'?3C!IF!#77<K!

n?9D3529!&=?:<9358@!*2MMFE!STV!%Fb:!PWRh!XO3F!PQhWYF!

! ++ZbQ

Page 104: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

0F!*29D@?75297!

O5=3?8@@A!<I<=A!>?9576M<93!?9:<=!8!C<=2!32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!45@@!5M>@5D83<!8!

73?:<93\7!593<=<73!59!7383<Z>=2I5:<:!>?G@5D!<:?D83529E!36?7!3=5;;<=59;!:?<!>=2D<77!

>=23<D35297F!!%7!59!36<!D87<!2B!89A!3A><!2B!7?7><97529!2=!<K>?@7529E!46<36<=!?9:<=!8!C<=2!

32@<=89D<!>2@5DA!2=!236<=!:57D5>@598=A!;?5:<@59<7E!36<!7D622@!M?73!>=2I5:<!36<!8>>=2>=583<E!

362?;6!@5M53<:E!>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7!87!:57D?77<:!8G2I<F!!&<=68>7!36<!M273!?7<B?@!2B!

36<7<!>=2D<:?=8@!78B<;?8=:7!57!36<!=<N?5=<M<93!2B!8!_M<8959;B?@!6<8=59;Ja!59!:573=5D37!

46<=<!7D622@!>2@5DA!2=!7383<!@84!>=265G537!M89:832=A!>?9576M<937E!73?:<937!8=<!<9353@<:!

32!8!:57D=<35298=A!=<I5<4E!59D@?:59;!36<!D2975:<=83529!2B!M535;8359;!B8D32=7FPTU!!)657!57!

3=?<!<I<9!5B!7D622@!2BB5D58@7!D@85M!3683!36<A!8=<!2><=8359;!?9:<=!8!B2=M8@!2=!59B2=M8@!C<=2!

32@<=89D<!>2@5DAFPTP!

%@72E!59!3627<!:573=5D37E!36<!:57D5>@598=A!G2:A!57!923!><=M533<:!32!G@59:@A!=?GG<=Z

738M>!=<D2MM<9:835297!B=2M!236<=!7D622@!2BB5D58@7^!53!M?73!D29:?D3!537!249!=<I5<4!?759;!

537!59:<><9:<93!H?:;M<93F!!i6<9!7?GH<D35I<!:<3<=M59835297!8=<!59I2@I<:E!7?D6!87!36<!

8>>=2>=583<!4<5;63!2B!M535;8359;!B8D32=7E!:<3<=M5959;!46<36<=!36<!:<D57529!M8]<=!

8:<N?83<@A!D2975:<=<:!3627<!<@<M<937!57!:5BB5D?@3F!!%3!@<873!29<!D2?=3!687!6<@:!3683!36<!

:<D57529!M8]<=!9<<:!923!M8]<!7><D5B5D!B59:59;7!=<;8=:59;!M535;8359;!B8D32=7!32!8I25:!

=?9959;!8B2?@!2B!36<!:?<!>=2D<77!=<N?5=<M<937FPTb!!!

*2?=37!D@<8=@A!8;=<<!3683!7D622@!8:M59573=832=7!M8A!>=2M?@;83<!:57D5>@59<!D2:<7!

4536!M89:832=A!>?9576M<937E!87!@29;!87!36<A!8=<!923!>=265G53<:!B=2M!:259;!72!GA!7383<!

@84!2=!36<5=!249!>2@5D5<7FPTW!!)6<!29@A!:?<!>=2D<77!@5M5383529!29!36<7<!M89:832=A!

>?9576M<937!57!3683!36<A!M8A!923!G<!;=277@A!:57>=2>2=352983<!32!36<!2BB<97<E!759D<!3657!

42?@:!I52@83<!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!=5;637FPTS!!L<D8?7<!3657!57!7?D6!8!:5BB5D?@3!762459;!

89:!D2?=37!;5I<!7?D6!;=<83!:<B<=<9D<!32!7D622@!2BB5D58@7E!D2?=37!68I<!G<<9!<K3=<M<@A!

6<753893!32!2I<=3?=9!8!:57D5>@598=A!:<D57529!29!7?G738935I<!:?<!>=2D<77!;=2?9:7F!!)657!

D2?@:!D689;<!87!M2=<!89:!M2=<!73?:<937!8=<!7?7><9:<:!89:!<K><@@<:!?9:<=!C<=2!32@<=89D<!

>2@5D5<7!B2=!3=?@A!5992D?2?7!G<68I52=F!

+B!8!:57D5>@59<!D2:<!:2<7!923!D293=8I<9<!=<@<I893!7383<!@84!2=!>=<7D=5G<!;=277@A!

:57>=2>2=352983<!>?9576M<937E!36<=<!57!92!B?=36<=!D6<D]!29!36<!7<I<=53A!2B!36<!>?9576M<93!

89:!92!:?<!>=2D<77!=<N?5=<M<93!3683!M535;8359;!B8D32=7!G<!38]<9!5932!8DD2?93F!!*2?=37!

8;=<<!3683!_8!68=76!=<7?@3!:2<7!923!7?;;<73!3683!:?<!>=2D<77!487!@8D]59;!2=!3683!36<!

>=2D<:?=<7!B2@@24<:!32!=<8D6!3683!=<7?@3!4<=<!?9@84B?@EaPTT!<I<9!46<9!36<!D2?=3!:578;=<<7!

4536!36<!7<I<=53A!2B!36<!>?9576M<93!5M>27<:F!!/9B2=3?983<@AE!M89A!>2@5DA!M8]<=7!8=<!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!PTU!3))+$)&2&E!*2@I59!IF!"249:<7!*2?93A!-D6F!0573FE!,2F!QQ*OWURE!bUUU!/F-F!0573F!"#e+-!bSUW!X,F0F!

[577F!.<GF!bSE!bUUUYF!PTP!3))+$)&2&E$05&$PTb!02<!IF!L:F!2B!#:?DF!2B!(8]!&8=]!c!'5I<=!.2=<73!`5;6!-D6F!0573F!QS!*!RSSQE!PQQT!/F-F!0573F!"#e+-!

PTUhRE!83!uPWZPS!X,F0F!+@@F!(D3F!PPE!PQQTYF!PTW!3))+$)&2&E!.576<=!IF!L?=]G?=9<33!+9:F!-D6F!0573FE!SPQ!.F!-?>>F!PbUU!X,F0F!)<KF!PQVRYF!PTS!3))+$)&2&E!n8M<7!IF!/95B5<:!-D6F!0573FE!hQQ!.F!-?>>F!TWU!X0F!f89F!PQQTY^!&<3=<A!IF!.@8?;6<=E!TUT!.F!

-?>>F!PUhV!X#F0F!fAF!PQhPYF!!!PTT!02<!IF!L:F!2B!#:?DF!2B!(8]!&8=]!c!'5I<=!.2=<73!`5;6!-D6F!0573F!QS!*!RSSQE!PQQT!/F-F!0573F!"#e+-!

PTUhRE!83!uPS!X,F0F!+@@F!(D3F!PPE!PQQTYF!

! ++ZWU

Page 105: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

! ++ZWP

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

@8;;59;!G<659:!36<!D2?=37!59!=<8@5C59;!3683!_o7p3=5>>59;!8!D65@:!2B!8DD<77!32!<:?D835298@!

2>>2=3?953A!57!8!@5B<!7<93<9D<!32!7<D29:Z=83<!D535C<9765>!F!F!F!FaPTR!

!

!PTR!"<<!IF![8D29!*2?93A!L:F!2B!#:?DFE!SQU!.Fb:!SThE!SRU!XT36!*5=F!PQVSYF!

Page 106: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#$!

! 9::;<=">*"""!

!

="?@":A"<9BC*D;9?EB;?*B;FE"B;=*E<=;B*?G9G;*A9H%!

!!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

*

&'()(*(!!+,--.--/,0!,1!2345-6!('7,8,'6!

9.(:,0-6!:8;-/7('!8(3*!<,!(!:.3-,06!

,3!<83.(<!,1!:8;-/7('!8(3*=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!!

>!

!&'(-?(!

!@/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.A!,:.0!(02!

:.3-/-<.0<!2.1/(07.!,1!(4<8,3/<;A!

7,0B/7</,0!,1!(!1.',0;=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*!,3!2.(2';!

9.(:,0=!

!!

!

!&3/C,0(!

!!

!D,0</04.2!,:.0!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!7,0</04.2!2/-34:</B.!,3!

2/-,32.3';!).8(B/,3A!4-.!,3!2/-:'(;!

,1!(!2(05.3,4-!/0-<34*.0<!,3!2.(2';!

9.(:,0A!4-.!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!540A!

.E7.--/B.!()-.0<../-*=!

!!

!

F!

!&3?(0-(-!

!&--(4'<!,3!<83.(<A!4-/05!6!,11.3/05!,3!

-.''/05!('7,8,'/7!).B.3(5.-!,3!,<8.3!

/''/7/<!2345-A!:,--.--/,0!,1!:(5/05!

2.B/7.A!9/'14'!,3!/0<.0</,0('!2(*(5.!

,3!2.-<347</,0!,3!-<.('/05!!,1!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;=!

!G(C/05A!:,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*!,3!

,<8.3!9.(:,0-A!/''.5('!2345-!,3!

,<8.3!7,0<3()(02=!

!!

!

>!

!D('/1,30/(!

!+,--.--/,06!-.''/05!1/3.(3*A!

3.7,**.02.2!.E:4'-/,0A!<.33,3/-<!

<83.(<-A!8(<.!B/,'.07.A!<83.(<!<,!7(4-.!

:8;-/7('!8(3*A!:3,:.3<;!2(*(5.A!

.E<,3</,0A!8()/<4('!:3,1(0/<;=!

!+,--.--/,0!,3!-.''/05!,1!1/3.(3*A!

(--(4'<!9/<8!(!2.(2';!9.(:,0A!

<.33,3/-<!<83.(<-A!8(<.!B/,'.07.A!

<83.(<!<,!7(4-.!:8;-/7('!8(3*A!

:3,:.3<;!2(*(5.A!.E<,3</,0A!

8()/<4('!:3,1(0/<;=!

!!

F!

!D,',3(2,!

!D,0</04.2!9/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.!,3!

,:.0!(02!:.3-/-<.0<!2.1/(07.!,1!

:3,:.3!(4<8,3/<;A!9/'14'!2.-<347</,0!

,3!2.1(7/05!,1!-78,,'!:3,:.3<;=!

!D,0</04.2!9/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.!,3!

,:.0!(02!:.3-/-<.0<!2.1/(07.!,1!

:3,:.3!(4<8,3/<;A!9/'14'!2.-<347</,0!

,3!2.1(7/05!,1!-78,,'!:3,:.3<;A!

7(33;/056!)3/05/056!4-/05!,3!

:,--.--/05!(!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

-('.!,1!(!2345!,3!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.A!3,)).3;A!(--(4'<=!

!!

!

!

>!

!D,00.7</74<!

!&--(4'<A!:,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*A!,11.3!

,1!-('.!(02!2/-<3/)4</,0!,1!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.-A!2/-34:</B.!).8(B/,3=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*6!2.(2';!

9.(:,0!,3!!2(05.3,4-!/0-<34*.0<A!

,11.3!,1!-('.!(02!2/-<3/)4</,0!,1!(!

7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.=!

!>!

!

H4<!0,<!3.I4/3.2!/1!

-<42.0<!/-!!.E:.''.2!1,3!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!!

1/3.(3*!,3!<8.!!

,11.3/05!(02!-.''/05!,1!

7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.-=!

! !+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0!,3!/''.5('!

!

Page 107: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#J!

!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

K.'(9(3.! ! 2345-=! >!

!K/-<3/7<!,1!

D,'4*)/(!

!!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!L',3/2(!

!F/,'.07.!(5(/0-<!(0;!-78,,'!2/-<3/7<!

:.3-,00.'A!B/,'(</,0!,1!-78,,'M-!

-.E4('!8(3(--*.0<!:,'/7/.-A!1,3*('';!

78(35.2!9/<8!(!1.',0;!,3!2.'/0I4.0<!

(7<=!

!F/,'.07.!(5(/0-<!(0;!-78,,'!2/-<3/7<!

:.3-,00.'!,3!-78,,'!:3,:.3<;A!

B/,'(</,0!,1!-78,,'M-!-.E4('!

8(3(--*.0<!:,'/7/.-A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!

1/3.(3*A!9/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.A!,:.0!

2.1/(07.!,1!(4<8,3/<;A!78(35.2!9/<8!

(!1.',0;A!40'(914'!:,--.--/,0!,3!4-.!

,1!7,0<3,''.2!2(05.3,4-!-4)-<(07.-=!

!!

!

!

>!

!

!N.,35/(!

!&--(4'<!,3!)(<<.3;=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!G(9(//!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!'/I4,3!,3!/''/7/<!2345-=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

:,--.--/,0!!'/I4,3!,3!/''/7/<!2345-=!

!>!

!"2(8,!

!K/-34:</,0!,1!5,,2!,32.3=!

!D(33;/05!9.(:,0!,3!1/3.(3*=!

!!

!"''/0,/-!

!N3,--!2/-,).2/.07.!(02!*/-7,0247<=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!9.(:,0=!

!F!

!"02/(0(!

!>/-7,0247<A!-4)-<(0</('!

2/-,).2/.07.A!,<8.3!40'(914'!

(7</B/<;=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*!(02!2.(2';!

9.(:,0!O.=5=!6!P9/--!&3*;!!

?0/1.QA!*/-7,0247<6!-4)-<(0</('!

2/-,).2/.07.A!,<8.3!40'(914'!

(7</B/<;=!

!>!

!",9(!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!('7,8,'/7!).B.3(5.-6!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!R(0-(-!

!@/''14'!B/,'(</,0!,1!-<42.0<!7,0247<!

3.54'(</,0A!2/-34:</B.!7,0247<6!

7,0247<!98/78!.02(05.3-!-(1.<;!,1!

,<8.3-A!7,**/--/,0!,1!(!1.',0;!,3!

*/-2.*.(0,3A!2/-,).2/.07.!,1!(0!

,32.3!,1!-78,,'!,11/7/('A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

(!9.(:,0A!:,--.--/,0!,3!4-.!,1!/''.5('!

2345-=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0A!:,--.--/,0!

,1!2345-A!9/''14'!B/,'(</,0!,1!-<42.0<!

7,0247<!3.54'(</,0A!2/-34:</B.!

7,0247<6!7,0247<!98/78!.02(05.3-!

-(1.<;!,1!,<8.3-A!7,**/--/,0!,1!(!

1.',0;!,3!*/-2.*.(0,3A!

2/-,).2/.07.!,1!(0!,32.3!,1!-78,,'!

,11/7/('=!

!>!

!R.0<47?;!

!@/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.!,3!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!4-.!,1!:3,1(0/<;!,3!

B4'5(3/<;A!(--(4'<!,3!)(<<.3;A!<83.(<!,3!

1,37.!,1!B/,'.07.A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

('7,8,'!(02!2345-A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

9.(:,0-!,3!2(05.3,4-!/0-<34*.0<-=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0!,3!

2(05.3,4-!/0-<34*.0<A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

:3.-73/:</,0!!2345-!9/<8!<8.!/0<.0<!<,!

2/-<3/)4<.A!(--(4'<!,3!)(<<.3;=!

!>!

!S,4/-/(0(!

!@/''14'!2/-,).2/.07.A!/0<.0</,0('!

2/-3.-:.7<!<,9(32!-78,,'!,11/7/('A!4-.!

,1!4078(-<.!,3!:3,1(0.!'(054(5.A!4-.!

,1!<,)(77,!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!('7,8,'/7!

).B.3(5.-!,3!7,0<3,''.2!2(05.3,4-!

-4)-<(07.-A!74<-!,3!2.1(7.-!-78,,'!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!>!

Page 108: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#T!

!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

:3,:.3<;A!:,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*A!

8()/<4('';!<(32/0.--!(02!()-.0<../-*A!

,<8.3!-.3/,4-!,11.0-.-=!

!>(/0.!

!L,3*/05!-.73.<!13(<.30/</.-!,3!

-,7/.</.-A!2.'/).3(<.!(02!2/-,32.3';!

7,0247<=!

!K.'/).3(<.!2/-,).2/.07.!,3!

2.'/).3(<.!2/-,32.3A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

1/3.(3*A!:,--.--/,0!(02!<3(11/7?/05!

,1!2345-A!1,3*/05!-.73.<!13(<.30/</.-!

,3!-,7/.</.-=!

!F!

!>(3;'(02!

!!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*!

!>!

!>(--(784-.<<-!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!/''.5('!2345-6!('7,8,'!,3!

'.5('!2345-!O.=5=6!+3,C(7!,3!(0</#

2.:3.--(0<-QA!8/<</05!,3!:4-8/05!

<.(78.36!-78,,'!,11/7/('!,3!.*:',;..A!

1.',0;!7,*:'(/0<!,3!7,0B/7</,0=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!!

:,--.--/,0!,1!/''.5('!2345-6!('7,8,'!

,3!'.5('!2345-!O.=5=6!+3,C(7!,3!(0</#

2.:3.--(0<-QA!(--(4'<!O/07'42/05!

8/<</05!,3!:4-8/05!<.(78.3!-78,,'!

,11/7/('QA!1.',0;!7,0B/7</,0=!

!!

!

F!

L,3!.E:.''.2!-<42.0<-!

!>/78/5(0!

!N3,--!*/-2.*.(0,3!,3!:.3-/-<.0<!

2/-,).2/.07.=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0A!

(3-,0A!73/*/0('!-.E4('!7,0247<A!

:8;-/7('!(--(4'<!);!-<42.0<!/0!53(2.!

U!,3!(),B.A!53,--!*/-2.*.(0,3!,3!

:.3-/-<.0<!2/-,).2/.07.=!

!F!

!>/00.-,<(!

!K/-34:</B.!).8(B/,3=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!>!

!>/--/--/::/!

!!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!2(05.3,4-!9.(:,0!,3!

!1/3.(3*-A!:,--.--/,0!,1!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.-=!

!F!

!>/--,43/!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!F!

!>,0<(0(!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!!

!V.)3(-?(!

!F/,'.07.6!1,37.6!7,.37/,06!<83.(<6!

/0</*/2(</,0A!9/''14'';!7(4-/05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!7(4-.!-4)-<(0</('!

2(*(5.!<,!:3,:.3<;6!-<.('/05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!-<.('!:3,:.3<;!,1!

-4)-<(0</('!B('4.6!,3!3.:.(<.2!2(*(5.!

,3!<8.1<!/0B,'B/05!:3,:.3<;A!7(4-/05!

,3!(<<.*:</05!<,!7(4-.!:.3-,0('!

/0W43;!<,!(!-78,,'!.*:',;..6!<,!(!

-78,,'!B,'40<..36!,3!<,!(0;!-<42.0<A!

<83.(<.0/05!,3!/0</*/2(</05!(0;!

-<42.0<!1,3!<8.!:43:,-.!,1!,3!9/<8!<8.!

/0<.0<!,1!,)<(/0/05!*,0.;!,3!

(0;<8/05!,1!B('4.!13,*!-478!-<42.0<A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!.05(5/05!/0!

<8.!40'(914'!:,--.--/,06!-.''/056!

2/-:.0-/056!,3!4-.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.!,3!(0!/*/<(</,0!7,0<3,''.2!

F/,'.07.6!1,37.6!7,.37/,06!<83.(<6!

/0</*/2(</,0A!9/''14'';!7(4-/05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!7(4-.!-4)-<(0</('!

2(*(5.!<,!:3,:.3<;6!-<.('/05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!-<.('!:3,:.3<;!,1!

-4)-<(0</('!B('4.6!,3!3.:.(<.2!

2(*(5.!,3!<8.1<!/0B,'B/05!:3,:.3<;A!

7(4-/05!,3!(<<.*:</05!<,!7(4-.!

:.3-,0('!/0W43;!<,!(!-78,,'!

.*:',;..6!<,!(!-78,,'!B,'40<..36!,3!

<,!(0;!-<42.0<A!<83.(<.0/05!,3!

/0</*/2(</05!(0;!-<42.0<!1,3!<8.!

:43:,-.!,1!,3!9/<8!<8.!/0<.0<!,1!

,)<(/0/05!*,0.;!,3!(0;<8/05!,1!

B('4.!13,*!-478!-<42.0<A!:,--.--/,0!

,1!(!1/3.(3*A!.05(5/05!/0!<8.!

40'(914'!:,--.--/,06!-.''/056!

2/-:.0-/056!,3!4-.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!

!>!

Page 109: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#X!

!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

-4)-<(07.A!,3!('7,8,'/7!'/I4,3!)./05!

402.3!<8.!/01'4.07.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.!,3!('7,8,'/7!'/I4,3A!:4)'/7!!

/02.7.07;A!-.E4('';!(--(4'</05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!-.E4('';!(--(4'<!(0;!

:.3-,0=!

-4)-<(07.!,3!(0!/*/<(</,0!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.A!,3!('7,8,'/7!'/I4,3!)./05!

402.3!<8.!/01'4.07.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!

-4)-<(07.!,3!('7,8,'/7!'/I4,3A!:4)'/7!

!/02.7.07;A!-.E4('';!(--(4'</05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!-.E4('';!(--(4'<!(0;!

:.3-,0=!

!V.B(2(!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!:,--.--/,0!

(02!-('.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.A!

*.*).3-8/:!/0!(!5(05A!)(<<.3;!,0!

-78,,'!,11/7/('=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!:,--.--/,0!

(02!-('.!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.A!

*.*).3-8/:!/0!(!5(05A!)(<<.3;!,0!

-78,,'!,11/7/('=!

!F!

!V.9!!

G(*:-8/3.!

!N3,--!*/-7,0247<=!

!N3,--!*/-7,0247<A!<8.1<A!

2.-<347</,0A!B/,'.07.A!:,--.--/,0!,1!

(!:.''.<!,3!HH!540!,3!3/1'.=!

!!

!V.9!Y.3-.;!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!(--(4'<!9/<8!

9.(:,0A!7,0</04.2!(02!9/'14'!

2/-,).2/.07.A!,:.0!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!:8;-/7('!(--(4'<!4:,0!

(0,<8.3!-<42.0<6!<(?/05!,3!(<<.*:</05!

<,!<(?.!:.3-,0('!:3,:.3<;!,3!*,0.;!

13,*!(0,<8.3!-<42.0<6!9/'14'';!

7(4-/05!2(*(5.!<,!-78,,'!:3,:.3<;A!

40(4<8,3/C.2!,774:(07;!,1!-78,,'!

53,402-6!?0,9/05!:,--.--/,0!,3!

7,0-4*:</,0!,1!('7,8,'!,3!2(05.3,4-!

-4)-<(07.-=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!(--(4'<!9/<8!

9.(:,0A!!7,0</04.2!(02!9/'14'!

2/-,).2/.07.A!,:.0!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!:8;-/7('!(--(4'<!4:,0!

(0,<8.3!-<42.0<6!<(?/05!,3!

(<<.*:</05!<,!<(?.!:.3-,0('!:3,:.3<;!

,3!*,0.;!13,*!(0,<8.3!-<42.0<6!

9/'14'';!7(4-/05!2(*(5.!<,!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;A!40(4<8,3/C.2!,774:(07;!

,1!-78,,'!53,402-6!?0,9/05!

:,--.--/,0!,3!7,0-4*:</,0!,1!

('7,8,'!,3!2(05.3,4-!-4)-<(07.-=!

!!

!

!

!

>!

Z0'.--!0,<!!(B(/'()'.!

/0!-78,,'!2/-<3/7<-!

!V.9!>.E/7,!

!!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!!

!V.9![,3?!

!"0-4),32/0(<.!,3!2/-,32.3';!7,0247<=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!V,3<8!D(3,'/0(!

!@/'14'!B/,'(</,0!:,'/7/.-!,1!7,0247<A!

:8;-/7('!(--(4'<!,3!-.3/,4-!/0W43;!<,!

(0,<8.3!-<42.0<6!<.(78.3!,3A!1('-.!

),*)!<83.(<-!-78,,'A!!:.3-,00.'=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!9.(:,0A!:3.-.0<-!(!

7'.(3!<83.(<!<,!-78,,'!-(1.<;=!

!>\F!

!V,3<8!K(?,<(!

!"0-4),32/0(</,0A!8()/<4('!/02,'.07.A!

2/-,32.3';!7,0247<A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!

9.(:,0=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!F!

!]8/,!

!K/-34:</B.!).8(B/,3=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!9.(:,0=!

!F!

!]?'(8,*(!

!!F/,'(</,0!,1!-78,,'!3.54'(</,0A!

/**,3('/<;=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!F!

!]3.5,0!

!&--(4'<-!,3!*.0(7.-!(!-78,,'!

.*:',;..!,3!(0,<8.3!-<42.0<A!9/'14'!

2/-,).2/.07.!(02!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!4-.!,3!2/-:'(;!,3!:3,1(0.!

,3!,)-7.0.!'(054(5.A!:3,:.3<;!

2(*(5.A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!&--(4'<-!,3!*.0(7.-!(!-78,,'!

.*:',;..!,3!(0,<8.3!-<42.0<A!9/'14'!

2/-,).2/.07.!(02!2.1/(07.!,1!

(4<8,3/<;A!4-.!,3!2/-:'(;!,3!:3,1(0.!

,3!,)-7.0.!!'(054(5.A!:3,:.3<;!

2(*(5.A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0=!

!F!

Page 110: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#^!

!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

!+.00-;'B(0/(!

!K/-,).2/.07.!,3!*/-7,0247<=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!_8,2.!"-'(02!

!K/-34:</B.!).8(B/,3A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!

1/3.(3*!,3!3.('/-</7!3.:'/7(!,1!1/3.(3*=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!9.(:,0!,3!1/3.(3*=!

!

!!

!P,4<8!D(3,'/0(!

!D,**/--/,0!,1!(0;!73/*.A!53,--!

/**,3('/<;A!53,--!*/-).8(B/,3A!

:.3-/-<.0<!2/-,).2/.07.=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*A!7,**/--/,0!

,1!(0;!73/*.A!53,--!/**,3('/<;A!

53,--!*/-).8(B/,3A!:.3-/-<.0<!

2/-,).2/.07.=!

!F!

!P,4<8!K(?,<(!

!"0-4),32/0(</,0!,3!*/-7,0247<A!

(553.--/B.!B/,'.0<!).8(B/,3A!!

7,0-4*:</,0!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!

('7,8,'/7!).B.3(5.-A!4-.!,3!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!2(05.3,4-!

-4)-<(07.A!4-.!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!

1/3.(3*A!:3,:.3<;!2(*(5.=!

!D,0-4*:</,0!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!

('7,8,'/7!).B.3(5.-A!4-.!,3!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!7,0<3,''.2!

2(05.3,4-!-4)-<(07.A!4-.!,3!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!!

!`.00.--..!

!"**,3('!,3!2/-3.:4<()'.!7,0247<A!

B/,'.07.!,3!<83.(<!,1!B/,'.07.A!

:3,:.3<;!2(*(5.A!(--(4'<!,1!-78,,'!

,11/7/('!9/<8!B4'5(3!'(054(5.A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!2345!4-.=!

!H(<<.3;!4:,0!-78,,'!,11/7/('A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!0(37,</7-!,3!9.(:,0-=!

!>!

!`.E(-!

!!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*6!/''.5('!?0/1.6!

7'4)!,3!9.(:,0=!

!>!

!Z<(8!

!L3.I4.0<!,3!1'(53(0<!9/''14'!

2/-,).2/.07.6!2.1/(07.!,1!:3,:.3!

(4<8,3/<;6!,3!2/-34:</B.!).8(B/,36!

/07'42/05!<8.!4-.!,1!1,4'6!:3,1(0.6!

B4'5(36!,3!()4-/B.!'(054(5.A!9/''14'!

2.-<347</,0!,3!2.1(7/05!,1!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;A!:,--.--/,06!7,0<3,'6!,3!4-.!

,1!(0!('7,8,'/7!).B.3(5.A!<8.!

:,--.--/,06!7,0<3,'6!,3!(7<4('!,3!

<83.(<.0.2!4-.!,1!(!3.('6!',,?!('/?.6!,3!

:3.<.02!9.(:,06!.E:',-/B.6!,3!

0,E/,4-!,3!1'(**()'.!*(<.3/('A!,3!

<8.!-('.6!7,0<3,'6!,3!2/-<3/)4</,0!,1!(!

2345!,3!7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.6!(0!

/*/<(</,0!7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.!

2.1/0.26!,3!2345!:(3(:8.30('/(A!

7,**/--/,0!,1!(0!(7<!/0B,'B/05!<8.!

4-.!,1!1,37.!,3!<8.!<83.(<.0.2!4-.!,1!

1,37.=!

!+,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!(553(B(<.2!

(--(4'<A!(3-,0A!:,--.--/,06!4-.!!(02!

2/-<3/)4</,0!,1!*(3/W4(0(!,3!

7,0<3,''.2!-4)-<(07.=!

!F!

!F.3*,0<!

!]05,/05!<83.(<A!2/-34:</B.!).8(B/,3A!

:,--.--/,0=!

!!

!!

!F/35/0/(!

!!

!! +,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*=!

!>!

!@(-8/05<,0!

!N(05!(7</B/<;A!2.1(7/05!,1!:3,:.3<;=! +,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*!,3!2.(2';!

!F!

Page 111: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!! !!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

! """#U!

!?G9G;*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*?E?:;<?"I<*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*

*B;9?I<?*JIB*;>:EA?"I<*

*9K9"A9L"A"GC*IJ*

9AG;B<9G"K;*

;=E@9G"I<*

:BIMB9D?*

*

D9<=9GIBC*N**D*

KIAE<G9BC**N**K*

9.(:,0A!5(05!(7</B/<;=!

!@/-7,0-/0!

!K/-,).;/05!-78,,'!34'.-6!7,0B.;/05!

<83.(<!,3!1('-.!/01,3*(</,0!

7,07.30/05!<8.!2.-<347</,0!,1!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*=!

!K/-,).;/05!-78,,'!34'.-6!7,0B.;/05!

<83.(<!,3!1('-.!/01,3*(</,0!

7,07.30/05!<8.!2.-<347</,0!,1!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;A!:,--.--/,0!,1!(!1/3.(3*A!

2/-34:</B.!7,0247<=!

!>!

[email protected]<!F/35/0/(!

!Z-.6!-('.!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!0(37,</7-A!

1.',0/,4-!(7<A!<83.(<!<,!/0W43.A!9/'14'!

2/-,).2/.07.A!:,--.--/,0!,1!('7,8,'A!

4-.!,1!:3,1(0.!'(054(5.!2/3.7<.2!(<!

-78,,'!.*:',;..!,3!:4:/'A!

/0<.0</,0('';!2.1(7.2!(0;!-78,,'!

:3,:.3<;A!:(3</7/:(</,0!/0!(0;!

:8;-/7('!('<.37(</,0A!!8()/<4('';!

B/,'(<.2!-78,,'!34'.-!,3!:,'/7/.-=!

!Z-.6!-('.!,3!:,--.--/,0!,1!!

0(37,</7-A!:,--.--/,0!,1!1/3.(3*!,3!

2.(2';!9.(:,0A!1.',0/,4-!(7<A!<83.(<!

<,!/0W43.A!9/'14'!2/-,).2/.07.A!

:,--.--/,0!,1!('7,8,'A!4-.!,1!

:3,1(0.!'(054(5.!2/3.7<.2!(<!-78,,'!

.*:',;..!,3!:4:/'A!/0<.0</,0('';!

2.1(7.2!(0;!-78,,'!:3,:.3<;A!

:(3</7/:(</,0!/0!(0;!:8;-/7('!

('<.37(</,0A!!8()/<4('';!B/,'(<.2!

-78,,'!34'.-!,3!:,'/7/.-=!

!>!

!@;,*/05!

!!

!+,--.--/,06!4-.!,3!7(33;/05!,1!(!

2.(2';!9.(:,0=!

!!

!

*

!"#$%&%$'()*+,-..)*$%+/0%,/+*1(2*-(&3*1.03*345(#+%&3*$%+,%5)%#(02*,.$3+*/-(#*036'%03$*72*+/(/3*)(8!

!

Page 112: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""#$%&'(&)(

(

*#"+*,&$-(+.(/,0%#$,(1&/2+$%02,(,+(3!4(#$.+*2#1#$,5!

!!/,!,#(

(*#"+*,&$-((

+*(*#.#**!3(,+(

!""*+"*&!,#((

3!4((

#$.+*2#1#$,(

!-#$26(

7/8#*&..9(%&/,*&2,(

!,,+*$#6:(

(

1!$%!,+*6(;(1(

)+30$,!*6((;()(

("+//#//&+$(+.(

.&*#!*1<(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(0/#(

(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

+.(%*0-/(

(0/#(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

(+.(

!32+8+3(

(!//!03,(

(!//!03,(

4&,8(!(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(!//!03,(

+.(

/28++3(

+..&2&!3(

(/#'0!3(

+..#$/#/(

("*+"#*,6(

%!1!-#(

("!-#*/<

"8+$#/(

(%&/+*%#*36((

2+$%02,(

(2*&1&$!3(

+..#$/#<(

.#3+$6(

("#$%$&$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!"#$()$!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!"*+,-.$!

!'!

!'!

!/!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!/!

!"*)$.($(!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!0$#+1-*.+$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!0-#-*$2-!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!0-..345+465!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!73#$8$*3!

!'9/!

:;-5!*3<6+*32!1-*!

4=+#2!6.23*!5=3!$>3!

-1!!?@!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!7+(5*+45!-1!

0-#6&%+$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!A#-*+2$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!B3-*>+$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!/!

!C$8$++!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!'!

!D2$=-!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!D##+.-+(!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

E!&=>?@?>ABC(DEFGGC(>?DHI?EHD(JBK(FB@L(JGIL(LMNB=D?@L(>?DE?NC?=BIK(EG>LD(HFB=(ILOA?IL>(PK(DHBHL(CBQ!! D/FG!

Page 113: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!/,!,#(

(*#"+*,&$-((

+*(*#.#**!3(,+(

!""*+"*&!,#((

3!4((

#$.+*2#1#$,(

!-#$26(

7/8#*&..9(%&/,*&2,(

!,,+*$#6:(

(

1!$%!,+*6(;(1(

)+30$,!*6((;()(

("+//#//&+$(+.(

.&*#!*1<(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(0/#(

(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

+.(%*0-/(

(0/#(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

(+.(

!32+8+3(

(!//!03,(

(!//!03,(

4&,8(!(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(!//!03,(

+.(

/28++3(

+..&2&!3(

(/#'0!3(

+..#$/#/(

("*+"#*,6(

%!1!-#(

("!-#*/<

"8+$#/(

(%&/+*%#*36((

2+$%02,(

(2*&1&$!3(

+..#$/#<(

.#3+$6(

!D.2+$.$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!D-8$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!H$.($(!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!H3.564)I!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!J-6+(+$.$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'$+.3!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'$*I#$.2!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!'$(($4=6(355(!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'+4=+>$.!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!'+..3(-5$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!'+((+((+KK+!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!'+((-6*+!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!'-.5$.$!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!;3%*$()$!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!;3L$2$!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!;38!

C$&K(=+*3!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!'!

!;38!M3*(3I!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!;38!'3N+4-!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !! ! !

E!&=>?@?>ABC(DEFGGC(>?DHI?EHD(JBK(FB@L(JGIL(LMNB=D?@L(>?DE?NC?=BIK(EG>LD(HFB=(ILOA?IL>(PK(DHBHL(CBQ!! D/FO!

Page 114: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!/,!,#(

(*#"+*,&$-((

+*(*#.#**!3(,+(

!""*+"*&!,#((

3!4((

#$.+*2#1#$,(

!-#$26(

7/8#*&..9(%&/,*&2,(

!,,+*$#6:(

(

1!$%!,+*6(;(1(

)+30$,!*6((;()(

("+//#//&+$(+.(

.&*#!*1<(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(0/#(

(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

+.(%*0-/(

(0/#(+*(

"+//#//&+$(

(+.(

!32+8+3(

(!//!03,(

(!//!03,(

4&,8(!(

%#!%36(

4#!"+$(

(!//!03,(

+.(

/28++3(

+..&2&!3(

(/#'0!3(

+..#$/#/(

("*+"#*,6(

%!1!-#(

("!-#*/<

"8+$#/(

(%&/+*%#*36((

2+$%02,(

(2*&1&$!3(

+..#$/#<(

.#3+$6(

;38!P-*)! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !' '

!;-*5=!0$*-#+.$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!;-*5=!7$)-5$!

!'9/!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!/!

!Q=+-!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!Q)#$=-&$!

!!

!!

!/!

!/!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!Q*3>-.!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!R3..(I#L$.+$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!S=-23!D(#$.2!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!T-65=!0$*-#+.$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!T-65=!7$)-5$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!U3..3((33!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!U3N$(!

!!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!V5$=!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!/3*&-.5!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!/+*>+.+$!

!'!

!'!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!'!

!W$(=+.>5-.!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!W3(5!/+*>+.+$!

!'!

!'!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!W+(4-.(+.!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!WI-&+.>!

!!

!

!!

!!

!!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

!!

E!&=>?@?>ABC(DEFGGC(>?DHI?EHD(JBK(FB@L(JGIL(LMNB=D?@L(>?DE?NC?=BIK(EG>LD(HFB=(ILOA?IL>(PK(DHBHL(CBQ!! D/FX!

Page 115: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

E!&=>?@?>ABC(DEFGGC(>?DHI?EHD(JBK(FB@L(JGIL(LMNB=D?@L(>?DE?NC?=BIK(EG>LD(HFB=(ILOA?IL>(PK(DHBHL(CBQ!! D/FY!

!

Page 116: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""#$%&'()(

%*+,*-.*/0(1232(,4..0,3*4/(!"

53230" 56+-0/+*4/+(" #7-6.+*4/+" !.308/23*90(

016,23*4/2.(

-84:82;"

<=(

>2,0"<=((

?0/108"@AA0/+0"

#$%&%'%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

#$%()%" "" "!" "" "" "" ""

#*+,-.%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

#*)%.(%(" !" !" "" "!" !" !"

/%$+0-*.+%" !" !" !" !" !" ""

/-$-*%1-" !" !" "" "" "" ""

/-..234+354" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

62$%7%*2" !" !" "" ""

""

""

""

"!"

6+(4*+34"-0"

/-$5'&+%" "" "" "" "" "" ""

8$-*+1%" !" !" "" "" "" ""

92-*:+%" !" "" "" "!" !" !"

;%7%++" "" "!" "" "" "" "!"

<1%=-" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

<$$+.-+(" !" "" "" "" "" ""

!"

<.1+%.%" !" !" "" "!" !" !"

<-7%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

>%.(%(" !" "" "" "" "" "!"

" " " " "?@A

Page 117: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

>2.453)B" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

C-5+(+%.%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

D%+.2" "" "" "" "" "" ""

D%*B$%.1" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

D%((%3=5(244(" !" !" "" "" "" ""

D+3=+:%." !" !" "" "" "" ""

D+..2(-4%" !" !" "" "!" !" !"

D+((+((+EE+" "" "!" "" "" "" "!"

D+((-5*+" "" "" "" "" "" "!"

D-.4%.%" "" "" "" "" "" ""

F2&*%()%" "" "!" "" "" "" "!"

F2G%1%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

F27""

;%'E(=+*2" "" "" "" "" "" ""

F27"H2*(2B" "" "" "" "" "" ""

F27"D2I+3-" !" "" "" "" "!" ""

F27"J-*)" "" "" "" "" "" ""

F-*4="/%*-$+.%" "" "" "" "" "" ""

F-*4="6%)-4%" "" "" "" "" "" ""

K=+-" "" "" "" "!" "" """

K)$%=-'%" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

K*2:-." "" "!" "" "" """ "!"

L2..(B$G%.+%" !" !" "" "" "" "!"

" " " " "?@M"

Page 118: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

N=-12"<($%.1" !" "" "!" !" !" !"

O-54="/%*-$+.%" !" "" ""

""

!"

F-4"

'%.1%421"

!" !"

O-54="6%)-4%" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

P2..2((22" !" !" "" "!" !" ""

P2I%(" !" !" !" !" !" !"

Q4%=" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

?2*'-.4" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

?+*:+.+%" !" !" "" ""

""

""

""

!"

R%(=+.:4-." !" !" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

R+(3-.(+." !" !" !" !" !" !"

R2(4"?+*:+.+%" !" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

RB-'+.:" "" ""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

""

"

" " " " "?@S"

Page 119: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!""#$%&'()&!

!!

"#$%#&'$()!*+,-./!012++34!56+7#3)4!!

!"#"$%&'()'$*+,,-)$./011-!56#-1#8$39!0#%#-)!:)#4)!!;6$()49!<&=!>,.&+7&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)@9!AB! CB=! A-&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)C9BDDE!0.,()-.4!#-!(6+8+,.!86)F)-.#+-!86+G6$%4!7+6!(#41#83#-$6/!6)$4+-49!BDDC!H6))I?)(,1)(!J,-12!0.,()-.49!CCBKL! !M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.49!KO=!

!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

?$1#$3!')%+G6$82#14!PLQ9!!

#0+2)$ $ 3-&/4$$ $ 5+67&8+/$ 96+&8$ :20)'!0.,()-.49! ! ! E<! ! @=! ! RO! ! @! D!

56#-1#8$39! ! @DD!S44.B!56#-1#8$349!! EE! ! EE! ! EE!T)$12)649! ! EC! ! CD! ! RK!*+,-4)3+649! ! <U! ! EE!!

*2#3(6)-!V#.2!'#4$N#3#.#)49!BCLE!!

M,%N)6!+7!?)8+6.)(!A-1#()-.4!+7!*6#%)!$-(!W#+3)-1)R9!56+8)6./!>77)-4)49!!R!H#G2.#-G!$-(!:$6$44%)-.9!!C!>.2)6!M+-F#+3)-.!A-1#()-.4!X!'#4+6()63/!*+-(,1.9!!@!T+.$39!U!!

M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.4!8)6!1+,-4)3+6O9!RUK!T)$12)6!.6$#-#-G!6)G$6(#-G!(#41#83#-)B!!M+!7+6%$3!.6$#-#-GB!SFGB!*3$44!0#Y)9!"$.2!CRBOZ!01#)-1)!ERB@Z!J$-G,$G)!S6.4!EEBDZ!0+1B!0.,(#)4!E=BC!0.$-7+6(!S12#)F)%)-.!T)4.!")(#$-!5)61)-.#3)49!?)$(#-G9!U<Z!"$.2!*+%8,.$.#+-9!<KZ!"$.2!S883#1$.#+-9!=@Z!01#)-1)9!=O!"$G-).!56+G6$%9!A-.)6-$.#+-$3![(,1$.#+-!

!

!

@!!T26+,G2+,.!.2)!412++3!86+7#3)4!#-!.2#4!S88)-(#\]!>,.&+7&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)!6)7)64!.+!.2)!8)61)-.$G)!+7!12#3(6)-!4,48)-()(!$.!3)$4.!+-1)!7+6!+-)!+6!%+6)!($/4B!!C!!T26+,G2+,.!.2)!412++3!86+7#3)4!#-!.2#4!S88)-(#\]!A-&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)!6)7)64!.+!.2)!8)61)-.$G)!+7!12#3(6)-!83$1)(!#-!$-!#-&412++3!4,48)-4#+-!86+G6$%!$.!3)$4.!+-1)]!.2#4!1+,3(!#-13,()!+-)!+6!%+6)!13$44!8)6#+(4!+6!($/4B!

E!!A-!.2#4!412++3]!.2)4)!12#3(6)-!$6)!48))12!#%8$#6)(B!

R!!T2#4!($.$!%$/!-+.!$11,6$.)3/!6)73)1.!$33!#-1#()-.4!N)1$,4)!+7!F$6#)(!#-.)686).$.#+-!+7!.2)!#-1#()-.4!6)^,#6)(!.+!N)!6)8+6.)(B!!H+6!)\$%83)]!$(%#-#4.6$.+6_4!#-.)686).$.#+-!+7!V2$.!1+-4.#.,.)4!`7#G2.#-G!$-(!2$6$44%)-.]a!7+6!8,68+4)4!+7!6)8+6.#-G]!2$4!N))-!+-)!$6)$!+7!1+-.)-.#+-!#-!H3+6#($_4!6)8+6.#-G!4/4.)%B!!PA-.)6F#)V!V#.2!*26#4.#-)!'$F#4]!56+G6$%!08)1#$3#4.]!0$7)!X!'6,G!H6))!012++34]!H3+6#($!')8$6.%)-.!+7![(,1$.#+-QB!!!

O!!T2#4!#-13,()4!;,#($-1)!*+,-4)3+64!$-(!T?b0T!1+,-4)3+64!P6)48+-4#N3)!7+6!(6,G!1+,-4)3#-G!$-(!8))6!%)(#$.#+-!86+G6$%4]!N,.!+7.)-!7,-1.#+-!$4!$!;,#($-1)!*+,-4)3+6QB!

!

! "#$%!

Page 120: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

;B!cB!*$6F)6!#4!"#$%#&'$()!*+,-./_4!2#G2)4.!8)67+6%#-G!%#((3)!412++3B!!T2)!412++3!V$4!)4.$N3#42)(!#-!@KCR]!$4!'$()!*+,-./!T6$#-#-G!012++3]!$-!$33&N3$1d!412++3!7+6!4.,()-.4!#-!G6$()4!@&@CB!!T2)!412++3!3$.)6!N)1$%)!$!2#G2!412++3]!$-(!.2)-!$!%#((3)!412++3B!!*+,6.!+6()6)(!()4)G6)G$.#+-!3)(!.+!.2)!$44#G-%)-.!+7!V2#.)!4.,()-.4!76+%!-)$6N/!5+-1)!()!J)+-!"#((3)!012++3!.+!*$6F)6]!$-(!$44#G-%)-.!+7!4+%)!*$6F)6!4.,()-.4!.+!5+-1)!()!J)+-B!!A-!@KK@]!*$6F)6!N)1$%)!$!%$G-).!412++3!48)1#$3#Y#-G!#-!A-.)6-$.#+-$3![(,1$.#+-B!!T2)!%#44#+-!+7!;BcB!*$6F)6!#4!.+!`86+F#()!)(,1$.#+-$3!8$6#./!V#.2!.2)![,6+8)$-!4/4.)%4!$-(!.+!1+%8).)!4,11)447,33/!#-!.2)!#-.)6-$.#+-$3!$6)-$!,4#-G!.2)!N)4.!+7!.2)!bB0B!0/4.)%Ba<!!T2)!86+G6$%!#-13,()4!#-.)-4#F)!#-4.6,1.#+-!#-!H6)-12]!08$-#42!$-(!;)6%$-!$-(!4.,(/!+7!.2+4)!1,3.,6)4B!!A-!$((#.#+-]!.2)!412++3!2$4!4)F)6$3!.)$12)64!76+%!.2)4)!1+,-.6#)4B!!*$6F)6_4!$(%#44#+-4!6)^,#6)%)-.4!#-13,()!$1$()%#1!$-(!1+-(,1.!4.$-($6(4]!$-(!#-.)6F#)V4!+7!$883#1$-.4!$-(!.2)#6!8$6)-.4B!

!0.,()-.4!$6)!$(%#..)(!.+!*$6F)6!76+%!.26+,G2+,.!.2)!"#$%#&'$()!*+,-./!$6)$B!!T2)!

412++3!,.#3#Y)4!6$1#$3!G+$34!$4!$!%)$-4!+7!%$#-.$#-#-G!$!6$1#$33/!#-.)G6$.)(!)-F#6+-%)-.B!!0.,()-.4!$6)!$(%#..)(!V#.2!F$6/#-G!$1$()%#1!6)1+6(4]!4+%)!$6)!76+%!3+V!8)67+6%#-G!)3)%)-.$6/!412++34B!!c2)6)!$886+86#$.)!4.,()-.4!$6)!86+F#()(!V#.2!6)%)(#$3!4)6F#1)4!#-!<.2!G6$()Z!.2)4)!4.,()-.4!$6)!./8#1$33/!+-!8$6!N/!U.2!G6$()!$-(!#-!%$-/!1$4)4]!N)1+%)!2#G2)6!$12#)F)64!.2$-!.2)#6!1+,-.)68$6.4B!!S886+\#%$.)3/!OL!+7!4.,()-.4!)-6+33)(!(+!-+.!G6$(,$.)!76+%!*$6F)6!7+6!F$6#+,4!6)$4+-4!#-13,(#-G!3+V!$1$()%#1!8)67+6%$-1)]!(#41#83#-$6/!86+N3)%4!$-(!.6$-48+6.$.#+-!#%8)(#%)-.4BU!

!;BcB!*$6F)6_4!%$G-).!86+G6$%!(#4.#-G,#42)4!.2)!412++3!76+%!.2)!+.2)6!412++34!#-!.2)!

4$%83)!6)F#)V)(!#-!.2#4!6)8+6.B!!0.,()-.4!$.!*$6F)6!.)-(!.+!N)!2#G2!$1$()%#1!$12#)F)64]!$6)!2#G23/!%+.#F$.)(!$-(!2$F)!4.6+-G!4,88+6.!4/4.)%4!$.!2+%)B!!c2#3)!.2)!86#-1#8$34!+7!.2)!.V+!412++34!V#.2!2#G2)6!4,48)-4#+-!6$.)4!$44)6.)(!.2$.!*$6F)6!42+,3(!-+.!N)!1+%8$6)(!V#.2!.2)#6!412++34!N)1$,4)!*$6F)6!12++4)4!#.4!4.,()-.4]!*$6F)6!#4!4.#33!#%8+6.$-.!.+!.2)!$-$3/4#4B!!*$6F)6!2$4!.2)!3+V)4.!4,48)-4#+-!6$.)!+7!.2)!O@!%#((3)!412++34!#-!.2)!"#$%#&'$()!*+,-./!012++3!'#4.6#1.B!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!<!!!""!;BcB!*$6F)6!"#((3)!012++3]!#$%"&'(!')*"&'+,%-"&'$'-.&+#$/0"']!CDDDICDD@]!$.!@B!!!

U!!A-!.2)!8$4.!/)$6!*$6F)6!3+4.!$886+\#%$.)3/!RO!4.,()-.4]!@O!PEELQ!+7!V2+%!$6)!S76#1$-&S%)6#1$-B!!0+%)!16#.#14!+7!*$6F)6!1+%83$#-!.2$.!#-4.)$(!+7!4,48)-(#-G!12#3(6)-!V#.2!(#41#83#-$6/!86+N3)%4]!.2)!412++3!4#%83/!(6+84!.2)%!76+%!.2)!86+G6$%!$-(!4)-(! 4!.2)%!N$1d!.+!.2)#6!2+%)!412++3]!.2,4!.2)!412++3!%$4d4!#.4!4,48)-4#+-!6$.)4B!!0$%,)3!;$/]!7+6%)6!86#-1#8$3!+7!*$6F)6]!)\83$#-)(!.2$.!.2$.!#4!6$6)3/!(+-)!$-(!.2$.!%+4.!+7!.2)!(6+8&+,.4!$6)!(,)!.+!#44,)4!4,12!$4!3$1d!+7!.6$-48+6.$.#+-!P4.,()-.4!+,.4#()!+7!.2)!7))()6!412++3!$6)$!%,4.!86+F#()!.2)#6!+V-!.6$-48+6.$.#+-QB!!0.,()-.4!%$/!$34+!3)$F)!7+6!$1$()%#1!6)$4+-4B!

!

! "#$&!

Page 121: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

;&-<$.7'+8=6$*+,,-)!!;6$()49!<&=!>,.&+7&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!!!EBR! A-&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!!@KB<!

0.,()-.4!#-!(6+8+,.!86)F)-.#+-!86+G6$%4!7+6!(#41#83#-$6/!6)$4+-49!EU@!H6))I?)(,1)(!J,-12!0.,()-.49!U<B<L!M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.49!@]=C<!

!! ?$1#$3!')%+G6$82#14PLQ9! !

#0+2)$ $ 3-&/4$$ $ 5+67&8+/$ 96+&8$$ :20)'$0.,()-.49! ! O! ! C! ! KC! ! @! D!56#-1#8$39! ! @DD!S44.B!56#-1#8$349!! EE! ! EE! ! EE!T)$12)649! ! ER! ! CE! ! R@! ! C!*+,-4)3+649! ! UO! ! @E! ! @E!!*2#3(6)-!V#.2!'#4$N#3#.#)49!@DBKL!

!M,%N)6!+7!?)8+6.)(!A-1#()-.4!+7!*6#%)!$-(!W#+3)-1)9!

W#+3)-.!S1.4!SG$#-4.!5)64+-49!!@<!S31+2+3!T+N$11+!$-(!>.2)6!'6,G49!R!56+8)6./!>77)-4)49!CR!H#G2.#-G!$-(!:$6$44%)-.9!=K!c)$8+-4!5+44)44#+-9!@!>.2)6!M+-F#+3)-.!A-1#()-.4!X!'#4+6()63/!*+-(,1.9!<!

T+.$39!@RD!!

M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.4!8)6!1+,-4)3+69!E<OBC!T)$12)6!.6$#-#-G!6)G$6(#-G!'#41#83#-)9!:)$6.0%$6.4!SFGB!*3$44!0#Y)9!"$.2!CUBO!Z!01#)-1)!EDBCZ!J$-G,$G)!S6.4!CUB@Z!!0+1B!0.,(#)4!CKBU! !0.$-7+6(!S12#)F)%)-.!T)4.!")(#$-!5)61)-.#3)49!

?)$(#-G9!R@Z!"$.2!*+%8,.$.#+-9!R<Z!"$.2!S883#1$.#+-49!RCZ!01#)-1)9!E=!

$

!

! "#$'!

Page 122: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

*&,+618$*+,,-)!56#-1#8$39!T2)3%$!'$F#4!

$;6$()49!<&=!>,.&+7&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!!@<BC! A-&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!!<B=!0.,()-.4!#-!(6+8+,.!86)F)-.#+-!86+G6$%4!7+6!(#41#83#-$6/!6)$4+-49!-I$!H6))I?)(,1)(!J,-12!0.,()-.49!=UBOL!M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.49!@]R<@!

?$1#$3!')%+G6$82#14!PLQ9! !

#0+2)$ $ 3-&/4$$ $ 5+67&8+/$ 96+&8$:20)'!0.,()-.49! ! C! ! UE! ! CO! ! @! D!56#-1#8$39! ! @DD! !S44.B!56#-1#8$349!! EE! ! EE! ! EE!T)$12)649! ! CO! ! RE! ! ED! ! C!*+,-4)3+649! ! CD! ! <D! ! CD!

!*2#3(6)-!V#.2!'#4$N#3#.#)49!@OBOL!!M,%N)6!+7!?)8+6.)(!A-1#()-.4!+7!*6#%)!$-(!W#+3)-1)9! !

W#+3)-.!S1.4!SG$#-4.!5)64+-49!RO!S31+2+3!T+N$11+!$-(!+.2)6!'6,G49!@@!56+8)6./!>77)-4)49!EC!H#G2.#-G!$-(!:$6$44%)-.9!@=K!c)$8+-4!5+44)44#+-9!<!>.2)6!M+-F#+3)-.!A-1#()-.4!$-(!'#4+6()63/!*+-(,1.9!EE!

T+.$39!E@<!!

M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.4!8)6!1+,-4)3+69!E<OBCO!56+G6$%49!H,33&4)6F#1)!412++3!&!$((#.#+-$3!84/12#$.6#1I%)-.$3!2)$3.2!1+,-4)3+64!T)$12)6!T6$#-#-G!6)G$6(#-G!'#41#83#-)9!M+!7+6%$3!.6$#-#-GZ!(#41,44!$-(!42$6)!%$.)6#$34!!(,6#-G!C!($/!6).6)$.!$.!N)G#--#-G!+7!412++3!/)$6B!!T)$12)64!$6)!(+#-G!$!N)..)6!e+NB!SFGB!*3$44!0#Y)9!"$.2!CRZ!01#)-1)!EDBCZ!J$-G,$G)!S6.4!CRB<Z!0+1B!0.,(#)4!EDBC! !0.$-7+6(!S12#)F)%)-.!T)4.!")(#$-!5)61)-.#3)49!

?)$(#-G9!@UZ!"$.2!*+%8,.$.#+-9!CRZ!"$.2!S883#1$.#+-49!CUZ!01#)-1)9!@O!!!

!

!

! "#$(!

Page 123: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

>1'20$?&,)$*+,,-)$./011-!56#-1#8$39![,-#1)!'$F#4!!;6$()49!<&=!!>,.&+7&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!!ERB@!!!!A-&012++3!0,48)-4#+-!?$.)9!RCBEAAB! !0.,()-.4!#-!(6+8+,.!86)F)-.#+-!86+G6$%4!7+6!(#41#83#-$6/!6)$4+-49!EUE!5)61)-.$G)!H6))I?)(,1)(!J,-129!<KB=! ! !M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.49!=EU!

?$1#$3!')%+G6$82#14PLQ9!

#0+2)$ $ 3-&/4$$ $ 5+67&8+/$ 96+&8$ :20)'!0.,()-.49! ! E! ! U<! ! @=! ! C! D!56#-1#8$39! ! ! ! @DD! !S44.B!56#-1#8$349!! ! ! OD! ! OD! ! !T)$12)649! ! E<! ! RC! ! @=! ! E!*+,-4)3+649! ! CO! ! OD! ! CO!

!*2#3(6)-!V#.2!'#4$N#3#.#)49!UBOL!!M,%N)6!+7!?)8+6.)(!A-1#()-.4!+7!*6#%)!$-(!W#+3)-1)9!

W#+3)-.!S1.4!SG$#-4.!5)64+-49!K!S31+2+3!T+N$11+!$-(!>.2)6!'6,G49!E!56+8)6./!>77)-4)49!@R!H#G2.#-G!$-(!:$6$44%)-.=9!@<O!c)$8+-4!5+44)44#+-9!@!>.2)6!M+-F#+3)-.!A-1#()-.4!$-(!'#4+6()63/!*+-(,1.9!=!

T+.$39!CDD!!M,%N)6!+7!4.,()-.4!8)6!1+,-4)3+69!R@K!T)$12)6!.6$#-#-G!6)G$6(#-G!'#41#83#-)9!M+-)B!SFGB!*3$44!0#Y)9!"$.2!EDBUZ!01#)-1)!EDBKZ!J$-G,$G)!S6.4!CKBDZ!!0+1B!0.,(#)4!ECB@! !0.$-7+6(!S12#)F)%)-.!T)4.!")(#$-!5)61)-.#3)49!

?)$(#-G9!EDZ!"$.2!*+%8,.$.#+-9!C=Z!"$.2!S883#1$.#+-49!EEZ!01#)-1)9!CU!!!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

=! M+6.2!'$()!#4!F)6/!)\$1.#-G!#-!#.4!6)8+6.#-G!+7!7#G2.4!f!)F)6/!7#G2.!#4!6)8+6.)(B!!'$F#4!-+.)(!.2$.!$11,6$.)!6)8+6.#-G!#4!#%8+6.$-.!N)1$,4)!#.!42+V4!.2$.!.2)!(#41#83#-$6/!$1.#+-4!.$d)-!V)6)!e,4.#7#)(B!

!

! "#$)!

Page 124: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

! !""#$%&'()&&!

!

! "*+,&-&$.("*+.*!,-!

!

/#/"("0120345(

(

!"#$%$&'()'*+&$",+-(./%',&'/%$"/#(+/0(1233",%#(4!).156("!#$%&'()(*+,-(!+#)$$.!/,0(!

&'(-(*1,$*!"*0!,*1('-(*1,$*!&'$2'"%!#$*+,+1,*2!$3!3$4'!#$%&$*(*1+5!!67!&'$-,0,*2!&'$#(04'(+!

"*0!&'$#(++(+!3$'!+#)$$.!/,0(!8()"-,$'!+4&&$'1!+9+1(%+:!;7!+&(#,3,#!+(11,*2!+4&&$'1!+9+1(%+!1$!

%$*,1$'!+&(#,3,#!+(11,*2+!"*0!0(-(.$&!,*1('-(*1,$*!+1'"1(2,(+:!<7!#."++'$$%!8()"-,$'!+4&&$'1!

+9+1(%+!1$!,0(*1,39!&'$#(04'(+!"*0!&'$#(++(+!3$'!,*0,-,04".!#."++'$$%+!1)"1!&"'"..(.!1)(!+1'"1(2,(+!

"*0!&'$#(04'(+!4+(0!+#)$$.!/,0(:!"*0!=7!,*0,-,04".!8()"-,$'!+4&&$'1!+9+1(%+!1$!&'$-,0(!

,*1(*+,-(:!,%%(0,"1(:!"*0!(33(#1,-(!,*1('-(*1,$*!1$!+140(*1+!/)$+(!8()"-,$'!&'(+(*1+!1)(!%$+1!

+,2*,3,#"*1!$'!#)'$*,#!#)"..(*2(!1$!+1"33>!!

! ?@AB!)"+!8((*!+4##(++34.!,*!'(04#,*2!0,+#,&.,*(!'(3(''".+!1$!1)(!&',*#,&".C+!$33,#(:!

(+&(#,"..9!,*!1)(!1,%(!&(',$0!&',$'!1$!+#)$$.!-"#"1,$*+>!!D("#)('+!'(&$'1!3((.,*2!%$'(!(33(#1,-(!,*!

1)(,'!1("#),*2!"*0!%"*"2(%(*1!$3!+140(*1!&'$8.(%!8()"-,$'>!

1'6"/0(1%'3(,+!"!-,$.(*#(!&'(-(*1,$*!+$#,".!+E,..+!#4'',#4.4%!0(+,2*(0!1$!)(.&!#),.0'(*!0(-(.$&!

(%&"1),#:!,%&4.+(!#$*1'$.:!"*0!"*2('!%"*"2(%(*1!+E,..+>!!D)(+(!.(++$*+!"'(!/$-(*!,*1$!1)(!

'(24."'!#4'',#4.4%!,*!<FG%,*41(!+(++,$*+>!!!D)(!#4'',#4.4%!".+$!,*#$'&$'"1(+!"!3"%,.9G8"+(0!

#$%&$*(*1!1)"1!(%&.$9+!"!-,0($G8"+(0!&"'(*1!&'$2'"%!"*0!"!+(',(+!$3!&"'(*1!2'$4&!%((1,*2+>!

! H-".4"1,$*+!+)$/!%$0('"1(!0(#'("+(+!,*!"22'(++,$*!"*0!%$0('"1(!,*#'("+(+!,*!&'$G+$#,".!

"*0!*(41'".!,*1('"#1,$*+>!!D)(+(!#$*1'"+1!/,1)!,*#'("+(+!,*!&)9+,#".!"*0!-('8".!"22'(++,$*!04',*2!

1)(!+"%(!&(',$0!3$'!"!#$*1'$.!2'$4&>!!!!

!,"7'6%(89:.;<;(,+!"!+#)$$.!/,0(:!#$%&'()(*+,-(!&'(-(*1,$*!"*0!("'.9!,*1('-(*1,$*!&'$2'"%!

3$'!+140(*1+!,*!(.(%(*1"'9!"*0!%,00.(!+#)$$.+:!(%&)"+,I,*2!,*#'("+,*2!+140(*1!&('3$'%"*#(!,*!

+$#,".!+E,..+!"*0!#$*3.,#1!'(+$.41,$*:!,%&'$-,*2!+140(*1!"#),(-(%(*1!"*0!"#"0(%,#!&'$2'(++:!

3"#,.,1"1,*2!&$+,1,-(!+#)$$.!#.,%"1(+:!"*0!,*#'("+,*2!&"'(*1".!,*-$.-(%(*1!"*0!+4&&$'1>!!D)('(!"'(!

*$/!;J!+,1(+!"#'$++!1)(!#$4*1'9!,%&.(%(*1,*2!KLMAHNH>!

! H-".4"1,$*+!3$4*0!1)"1!1)(!$',2,*".!+#)$$.+!(%&.$9,*2!1)(!&'$2'"%!3$'!<!9("'+!)"-(!

0(%$*+1'"1(0!"!0(#'("+(!,*!0,+#,&.,*"'9!'(3(''".+!89!;OP!"*0!"!;Q<!0'$&!,*!+4+&(*+,$*+>!!A*!

"00,1,$*:!2'"0(!'(1(*1,$*:!1(+1!+#$'(+:!"*0!"#"0(%,#!&('3$'%"*#(!,*!1)(+(!+#)$$.+!)"-(!"..!

,%&'$-(0>!(

='#"-&$/>(9"/?-$6%(9,'+%$&'-@(!,">,+A(4=99!5!!!R*(!$3!1)(!%$+1!#$*+,+1(*1.9!"*0!),2).9!'"1(0!

-,$.(*#(!&'(-(*1,$*!&'$2'"%+!,*!1)(!#$4*1'9:!SLL?:!3$4*0(0!,*!6TOF:!#4''(*1.9!+('-(+!U:JJJ!

1("#)('+!"*0!6VF:JJJ!+140(*1+!,*!<VF!+#)$$.+!*"1,$*/,0(>!!SLL?!(%&.$9+!"!+#)$$.G/,0(!%$0(.!

/),#)!/$'E+!/,1)!+1"33:!&"'(*1+:!3"%,.,(+!"*0!1)(!#$%%4*,19!1$!1("#)!9$4*2!&($&.(!#$*3.,#1!

'(+$.41,$*!+E,..+:!&'$%$1(!,*1('#4.14'".!4*0('+1"*0,*2:!"*0!$33('+!"!%$0(.!3$'!(33(#1,-(!/"9+!1$!

0(".!/,1)!#$*3.,#1!"*0!0,33('(*#(+>!!D)(!%$0(.!,*#.40(+!1)(!3$..$/,*2!#$%&$*(*1+5!

!" ?'$3(++,$*".!0(-(.$&%(*1!3$'!1("#)('+!

!" S(24."'!#."++'$$%!,*+1'4#1,$*!

!

! NAAG6!

!" ?(('!%(0,"1,$*QD((*!L$4'1+!

Page 125: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

!

! NAAG;!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!" K0%,*,+1'"1$'!1'",*,*2!

!" ?"'(*1!1'",*,*2!

!" D'",*,*2!$3!1'",*('+!

SLL?!)"+!'(#(,-(0!(W1(*+,-(:!,*0(&(*0(*1!(-".4"1,$*+!,*!X(/!Y$'E!L,19:!K1."*1":!"*0!R'(2$*:!

"*0!)"+!8((*!+)$/*!1$!8(!(33(#1,-(!,*!'(04#,*2!,*#,0(*#(+!$3!-,$.(*#(:!0(#'("+,*2!0,+#,&.,*"'9!

'(3(''".+:!"*0!,*#'("+,*2!#$$&('"1,$*!/,1),*!1)(!#."++'$$%>!

!

+78#*("*+.*!,-!

+9(/34:;5(&9<=0>=9<?19("012034!ZRLA?7:!/),#)!)"+!8((*!"0$&1(0!89!+(-('".!+#)$$.+!

,*![.$',0":!&'$-,0(+!+#)$$.+!/,1)!"*!".1('*"1,-(!1$!$41G$3G+#)$$.!+4+&(*+,$*+!89!(%&)"+,I,*2!

"#"0(%,#!24,0"*#(!"*0!#$4*+(.,*2!+4&&$'1>!!D)(!2$".+!$3!1)(!?'$2'"%!"'(!1$!'(04#(!+4+&(*+,$*+:!

1'4"*#9:!'(."1(0!\4-(*,.(!#',%(+!"*0!0'$&$41!'"1(+:!1$!%$0,39!0,+'4&1,-(!8()"-,$'+:!"*0!1$!

%",*1",*!(04#"1,$*".!$&&$'14*,1,(+!3$'!+140(*1+!/)$!$1)('/,+(!/$4.0!8(!+4+&(*0(0>!!A*!1)(!+)$'1G

1('%:!RLA?]+!2$".!,+!1$!%$0,39!8()"-,$'>!!A1+!.$*2G1('%!2$".!,+!1$!,%&'$-(!1)(!.("'*,*2!

(*-,'$*%(*1!,*!#."++'$$%+!89!'(04#,*2!0,+'4&1,$*+>!

!

RLA?!/"+!$',2,*"..9!"0$&1(0!89!L.("'/"1('!M,2)!B#)$$.!,*!?,*(.."+!L$4*19:![.$',0"!"+!"!

\$,*1!(33$'1!$3!1)(!L.("'/"1('!M,2)!B#)$$.!K0-,+$'9!L$4*#,.:!1)(!?,*(.."+!L$4*19!B#)$$.!@$"'0!

"*0!["%,.9!S(+$4'#(+:!"!*$*G&'$3,1!#$4*+(.,*2!"2(*#9>!

!

L.("'/"1('!M,2)!B#)$$.!)"+!8((*!&.("+(0!/,1)!,1+!'(+4.1+>!!B4+&(*+,$*!'"1(+!)"-(!0(#.,*(0!

0'"%"1,#"..9!"1!L.("'/"1('!+,*#(!1)(!+#)$$.!,*+1,141(0!RLA?>!!^4',*2!1)(!6TT=GTF!+#)$$.!9("':!

T<J!+140(*1+!/('(!+4+&(*0(0:!89!6TTOGTT!$*.9!<6<!+140(*1+!/('(!+4+&(*0(0>!!B#)$$.!$33,#,".+!

"11',841(:!,*!&"'1:!$1)('!&$+,1,-(!1'(*0+!1$!1)(!&'$2'"%5!"!0(#'("+(!,*!,1+!0'$&!$41!'"1(!3'$%!<>FP!

,*!6TT=GTF!1$!6>OP!,*!6TTVGTO:!"*!,%&'$-(%(*1!,*!1(+1!+#$'(+:!"!VFP!'(04#1,$*!,*!1)(!*4%8('!$3!

&)9+,#".!".1('#"1,$*+!"*0!"!FJP!0(#'("+(!,*!#."++'$$%!0,+'4&1,$*+6![4'1)('%$'(:!&'$2'"%!

$33,#,".+!#.",%!1)"1!O;P!$3!1)(!RLA?!2'"04"1(+!)"-(!*$1!'(&("1(0!1)(!$33(*+(!1)"1!.(0!1$!1)(,'!

"++,2*%(*1!1$!1)(!&'$2'"%>;!!B140(*1+!)"-(!(W&'(++(0!1)(,'!+4&&$'1!3$'!1)(!&'$2'"%>!!_"*9!

+140(*1+!."40!1)(!,*0,-,04".,I(0!"11(*1,$*!1)(9!'(#(,-(!3'$%!1)(!RLA?!1("#)(':!1)(!24,0"*#(!"*0!

+4&&$'1!$3!1)(!RLA?!#$4*+(.$':!"*0!1)(!$&&$'14*,19!1$!3$#4+!$*!1)(,'!+#)$$.!/$'E!/,1)$41!

0,+'4&1,$*><!!!

!

!6`(11('!3'$%!X,#E!a'"++$:!?',*#,&".!L.("'/"1('!M,2)!B#)$$.:!1$!^"-,0![(..$/+:!b"*4"'9!;F:!6TTT!!

!;cd,0+!a(1!K11(*1,$*!A*+1("0!$3!B4+&(*+,$*:e!!"#$"%!&'()*+:!_"9!<J:!6TTO!&>!;>!

!<,->!!B((!".+$:!RLA?!+140(*1!+4'-(9+"!

D)(!&'$2'"%!#$*+,+1+!$3!3$4'!#$%&$*(*1+5! !

f!!!K#"0(%,#+!G!B140(*1+!,*!1)(!&'$2'"%!&"'1,#,&"1(!,*!"!%,*,%4%!$3!3$4'!)$4'+!$3!

"#"0(%,#!/$'E!&('!0"9>!!K++,2*%(*1+!"'(!+(*1!1$!+140(*1+!3'$%!1)(,'!'(24."'!#."++(+g!+140(*1+!

%4+1!E((&!4&!/,1)!1)(,'!"++,2*%(*1+>!!D)(!RLA?!#."++!,+!+4&('-,+(0!89!"!#('1,3,(0!1("#)('>!!D)(!

RLA?!#."++!#$*+,+1+!$3!$*.9!6FG;<!+140(*1+>!

Page 126: Opportunities Suspended: The Devastating Consequences of Zero

f!!!A*0,-,04".!L$4*+(.,*2!G!A*0,-,04".!#$4*+(.,*2!,+!&'$-,0(0!89!"!#$4*+(.$'!/,1)!"!

_"+1('+!^(2'((!$'!89!_"+1('+!#"*0,0"1(+!3'$%!1)(!h*,-('+,19!$3!B$41)![.$',0">!!X(/!RLA?!

+140(*1+!"'(!+#'((*(0!3$'!%(*1".!)(".1):!"84+(:!+4,#,0(:!"*2(':!3"%,.9!&'$8.(%+!"*0!+1'(++>!!

A*0,-,04".!#$4*+(.,*2!+(++,$*+!"00'(++!+140(*1]+!8()"-,$':!,*0,-,04".:!3"%,.9!"*0!"#"0(%,#!

,++4(+>!!i)('(!"&&'$&',"1(:!+140(*1+!"'(!'(3(''(0!1$!$41+,0(!"2(*#,(+!3$'!#$4*+(.,*2>!

f!!!a'$4&!L$4*+(.,*2!G!a'$4&!#$4*+(.,*2!,+!3"#,.,1"1(0!89!1)(!RLA?!1("#)('!"*0!

#$4*+(.$'>!!B(++,$*+!"00'(++!,++4(+!+4#)!"+!"*2('!%"*"2(%(*1:!#$*3.,#1!'(+$.41,$*:!+48+1"*#(!

"84+(:!&(('!"*0!3"%,.9!'(."1,$*+),&+>!!RLA?!+140(*1+!"'(!'(j4,'(0!1$!"11(*0>!

f!!!!K31('#"'(!G!RLA?!2'"04"1(+!%"9!"11(*0!"!%"W,%4%!$3!3$4'!+%"..!2'$4&!"31('#"'(!

+(++,$*+!Z$*(!&('!/((E7>!!D)(+(!+(++,$*+!'(,*3$'#(!&$+,1,-(!#)"*2(+!"*0!"00'(++!1$&,#+!+4#)!"+!

"*2('!%"*"2(%(*1:!#$*3.,#1!'(+$.41,$*:!#)"'"#1('!0(-(.$&%(*1!"*0!-".4(+!#."',3,#"1,$*:!2$".+:!

'(+&(#1:!#)$,#(!"*0!#$*+(j4(*#(+>!!

B140(*1+!"'(!"++,2*(0!1$!RLA?!"1!1)(!0,+#'(1,$*!$3!1)(!?',*#,&".>!!B140(*1+!"'(!(.,2,8.(!3$'!

RLA?!3$'!#$*04#1!+4#)!"+!&'$3"*,19:!0,+$8(0,(*#(:!#."++!0,+'4&1,$*:!%,++,*2!B"14'0"9!B#)$$.:!$'!

#411,*2!#."++>!!B140(*1+!,*-$.-(0!,*!3,2)1+!$'!,*!&$++(++,$*!$3!/("&$*+!$'!0'42+!"'(!*$1!&('%,11(0!

1$!"11(*0!RLA?>!!D)(!&'$2'"%!,+!-$.4*1"'9:!,>(>:!&"'(*1+!$3!+140(*1+!'(3(''(0!3$'!+4+&(*+,$*!"'(!

2,-(*!#)$,#(!3$'!1)(!#),.0!1$!"11(*0!RLA?!$'!+('-(!),+Q)('!$41G$3G+#)$$.!+4+&(*+,$*>!!_$+1!RLA?!

+140(*1+!'(%",*!,*!1)(!RLA?!#."++'$$%!3$'!3,-(!0"9+!Z1)"1!,+!1)(!%"W,%4%!1,%(7g!1)(9!%"9!8(!

"++,2*(0!1$!RLA?!$*.9!1)'((!1,%(+!04',*2!"*!"#"0(%,#!9("'>!!^4',*2!1)(,'!0"9+!,*!RLA?!+140(*1+!

"'(!E(&1!,*!1)(!RLA?!#."++'$$%!3$'!1)(!(*1,'(!+#)$$.!0"9:!,*#.40,*2!04',*2!.4*#)>!!D)(!&'$2'"%!

,+!0,33('(*1!3'$%!1)(!,*G+#)$$.!+4+&(*+,$*!&'$2'"%!8(#"4+(!,1!&'$-,0(+!#$4*+(.,*2!"*0!&('%,1+!

+140(*1+!1$!,*1('"#1:!/)('("+!,*G+#)$$.!+4+&(*+,$*!,+$."1(+!+140(*1+>!

K+!"!'(+4.1!$3!RLA?]+!+4##(++!"1!L.("'/"1('!M,2)!B#)$$.:!1)(!&'$2'"%!)"+!8((*!"0$&1(0!

,*!+,W!"00,1,$*".!),2)!+#)$$.+!"*0!3$4'!%,00.(!+#)$$.+>!!?".%!@("#)!L$4*19!,+!#4''(*1.9!,*!1)(!

&'$#(++!$3!,*+1,141,*2!RLA?!,*!,1+!B#)$$.!^,+1',#1>!

RLA?!,+!"!&'$2'"%!1)"1!)"+!#.("'!8(*(3,1+>!!_$+1!+,2*,3,#"*1.9:!RLA?!&('%,1+!+140(*1+!1$!

3$'(2$!$41G$3G+#)$$.!+4+&(*+,$*:!1)4+!"-$,0,*2!"!+#)$$.!'(#$'0!/),#)!,*#.40(+!+4+&(*+,$*+:!"*0!

E((&,*2!+140(*1+!,*!+#)$$.!"*0!$*!1'"#E!/,1)!1)(,'!"#"0(%,#+>!!L',1,#+!$3!1)(!&'$2'"%!"++('1!1)"1!

1)(!&'$2'"%!&."#(+!1$$!%4#)!8."%(!$*!1)(!#),.0'(*!"*0!"-$,0+!(W"%,*"1,$*!$3!(04#"1,$*".!

,*+1,141,$*+>!!L$*+(j4(*1.9:!+#)$$.+!/,1)!RLA?!/,..!*$1!(W"%,*(!/)(1)('!1("#)('+!"'(!

$-('I(".$4+!,*!1)(,'!0,+#,&.,*"'9!'(3(''".+!$3!+140(*1+>!!D)4+:!1("#)('+!"'(!+1,..!*$1!2,-(*!1'",*,*2!

1$!(%&.$9!".1('*"1,-(!%(1)$0+!$3!0,+#,&.,*(!"*0!#$*3.,#1!'(+$.41,$*>!

!

!

! NAAG<!