P3202.002R Macquarie Park 2P Evaluation - ryde.nsw.gov.au · MACQUARIE PARK 2P METERED PARKING TRIAL ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION FOR CITY OF RYDE Gold Coast Brisbane Sydney Suite 26,

MACQUARIE PARK 2P METERED PARKING TRIAL

ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION FOR

CITY OF RYDE

Gold Coast Brisbane Sydney Suite 26, 58 Riverwalk Avenue

Robina QLD 4226 Level 2, 428 Upper Edward Street Spring Hill QLD 4000

Studio 203, 3 Gladstone Street Newtown NSW 2042

P: (07) 5562 5377 P: (07) 3831 4442 P: (02) 9557 6202 W: www.bitziosconsulting.com.au E: [email protected]

Project No: P3202 Version No: 002 Issue date: 17th August 2017

Macquarie Park 2P Parking Evaluation

Project No: P3202 Version: 002 Page i

DOCUMENT CONTROL SHEET

Issue History

Report File Name Prepared by Reviewed by Issued by Date Issued to

P3202.001R Macquarie Park 2P Parking Evaluation M. Casha /

P. Bollavaram D. Bitzios P. Bollavaram 28/07/2017

Anura Mendis

[email protected]

P3202.001R Macquarie Park 2P Parking Evaluation M. Casha /

P. Bollavaram D. Bitzios D.Bitzios 17/08/2017

Anura Mendis

[email protected]

Copyright in the information and data in this document is the property of Bitzios Consulting. This document and its information and data is for the use of the authorised recipient and this document may not be used, copied or reproduced in whole or in part for any purpose other than for which it was supplied by Bitzios Consulting. Bitzios Consulting makes no representation, undertakes no duty and accepts no responsibility to any third party who may use or rely upon this document or its information and data.


Project No: P3202 Version: 002 Page ii

CONTENTS Page

1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................... 1

1.1 BACKGROUND AND STUDY AREA 1 1.2 CURRENT STRATEGY 2 1.3 SCOPE 2

2. OVERALL STUDY AREA ANALYSIS ............................................................................................................. 3

2.1 PARKING DATA TYPES 3 2.2 TICKETING DATA OVERVIEW 3 2.3 TURNOVER SURVEY DATA OVERVIEW – 2P BAYS 6

3. LYONPARK ROAD RESULTS ....................................................................................................................... 7

3.1 LYONPARK ROAD METER DATA 7 3.1.1 Lyonpark Road 2P Bays Turnover and Occupancy Data 8

4. BYFIELD STREET RESULTS ....................................................................................................................... 9

4.1 BYFIELD STREET TICKETING DATA 9 4.2 BYFIELD STREET 2P BAYS OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER 10

5. GIFFNOCK AVENUE RESULTS .................................................................................................................. 11

5.1 GIFFNOCK AVENUE TICKETING DATA 11 5.2 GIFFNOCK AVENUE 2P OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER 12

6. EDEN PARK AVENUE RESULTS ................................................................................................................ 13

6.1 EDEN PARK AVENUE TICKETING DATA 13 6.2 EDEN PARK DRIVE 2P BAY OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER 14

7. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .................................................................................................. 15

7.1 KEY CONCLUSIONS 15 7.2 RECOMMENDATIONS 15


Project No: P3202 Version: 002 Page iii

Tables Table 1.1: Parking Rates and Duration Changes Table 2.1: Ticket Sales 13/2/17 to 17/2/17 (Before 2P Implementation) Table 2.2: Ticket Sales 8/5/17 to 12/5/17 (During 2P Implementation) Table 2.3: Turnover Survey Results 29/6/17 Figures Figure 1.1: Study Area Figure 2.1: Survey Locations Figure 2.2: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and After Implementation Figure 2.3: Ticket Purchase Time Profile Before Implementation Figure 2.4: Ticket Purchase Time Profile During Implementation Figure 2.5: 2P Bays Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile Figure 3.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Lyonpark Road Figure 3.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Lyonpark Road Figure 3.3: Ticket Purchase Time Profile During Implementation – Lyonpark Road Figure 3.4: Lyonpark Road 2 Hour Parking Location Figure 3.5: Lyonpark Road Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profiles Figure 4.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Byfield Street Figure 4.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Byfield Street Figure 4.3: Ticket Purchase Profile After Implementation – Byfield Street Figure 4.4: Byfield Street 2P Locations Figure 4.5: Byfield Street Site B Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile Figure 4.6: Byfield Street Site C Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile Figure 5.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Giffnock Avenue Figure 5.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Giffnock Avenue Figure 5.3: Ticket Purchase Profile After Implementation – Giffnock Avenue Figure 5.4: Giffnock Street 2P Locations Figure 5.5: Giffnock Avenue Site D Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile Figure 5.6: Giffnock Avenue Site E Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile Figure 6.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and After Implementation: Eden Park Avenue Figure 6.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Eden Park Avenue Figure 6.3: Ticket Purchase Profile During Implementation – Eden Park Avenue Figure 6.4: Eden Park Drive 2 Hour Parking Location Figure 6.5: Eden Park Drive Occupancy Profile Appendices Appendix A: Traffic Meter Data Appendix B: TDC Parking Surveys


Project No: P3202 Version: 002 Page 1 2

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 BACKGROUND AND STUDY AREA

Macquarie Park is one of Sydney’s premier Business Parks accommodating corporate headquarters for many national businesses. It also contains Macquarie University and Macquarie Centre. Macquarie Park has evolved with car access as the primary mode of transport to/from the area and large volumes of both off-street and on-street parking have been provided.

Recent traffic, transport and parking strategies in the area have highlighted traffic congestion as a major issue for the continued growth of Macquarie Park. In particularly, all day commuter parking has been identified as a key contributor to the traffic generation of the area. Furthermore, high utilisation of on street parking all day has meant that visitors to businesses in some areas have found difficulty in accessing available nearby parking.

The study area is bound by:

Waterloo Road to the north;

Lane Cove Road to the east;

Epping Road to the south; and

Herring Road to the west.

The study area is shown in Figure 1.1 and included on-street parking around Eden Park Drive.

Source: Google Maps

Figure 1.1: Study Area

Most of the on-street parking in the study area was previously defined as 12P and charged at $3.00 per hour (capped at $24). The City of Ryde (CoR) has commenced a trial to convert some of the 12P bays to 2P, to encourage long stay parking off street, to influence modal shift for commuters and to improve short stay parking accessibility for businesses in the area.

There are 493 on-street paid parking spaces in the study area signposted as “12P Ticket”, 7:00AM-7:00PM, Monday to Friday. Observations suggest that most the available 12P on-street parking within the study area is occupied by staff who work in the area leaving very few spaces for short-stay visitors.


Project No: P3202 Version: 002 Page 2

1.2 CURRENT STRATEGY

CoR has initiated a trial by converting 5% of the existing 12P parking bays to 2P parking bays on four streets within the study area (still ticketed 7:00AM-7:00PM Monday to Friday). The objective of this trial was to increase the turnover of these on street parking bays; effectively providing more visitor parking opportunities. In addition, Council has been increasing the cost of the 12 hour pay parking in the study area since 2015, with prices increasing from $2.50 to $3.50 per hour with the all-day parking cap rising from $15 to $18. From July 1st, 2017, the all-day capping has been removed and the patrons are now charged a flat rate of $3.00 per hour. Table 1.1 below shows the recent and proposed changes to the parking fee within the study area.

Table 1.1: Parking Rates and Duration Changes

Period Parking Rate per hour Duration

01/07/2015 – 30/06/2016 $2.50 Capped at $15

01/07/2016 – 30/06/2017 $3.00 Capped at $18

01/07/2017 – 30/06/2018 $3.00 No Cap

01/07/2018 onwards (proposed) $3.50 No Cap

1.3 SCOPE

This report assesses the period from February 2017 to June 2017 where the on-street parking rate was $3.00 p.h. capped at $18 per day. It reviews “before” and “after” data considering the implementation of the 28, 2P bays in:

Lyonpark Road: 8 bays;

Byfield Street: 8 bays;

Giffnock Avenue: 8 bays; and

Eden Park Drive: 4 bays.

This report reviews effectiveness and impacts of the 2P trial by:

conducting parking occupancy surveys of the converted 2P bays;

assessing the effectives of changes to increase turnover by reviewing “before” and “after” parking occupancy and average duration of stay; and

investigating changes to surrounding on-street parking profiles by reviewing ticketing data from before and after the implementation of 2P bays.

Based on the analysis this report draws conclusions on whether the bays converted to 2P in the trial should be made 2P permanently. It then provides advice on how council may extend a 2P conversion scheme within the study area with due consideration of the short term and long term influences of the Metro NorthWest project.



2. OVERALL STUDY AREA ANALYSIS

2.1 PARKING DATA TYPES

Parking data was gathered from parking meters throughout the study area to assess the changes in parking patterns before and after the introduction of the 2P bays. Meter data was provided by CoR from the 13th to 17th February 2017 (before implementation of 2P trial) and between 8th to 12th May 2017 (during the implementation of 2P trial).

In addition to the ticketing data, turnover surveys were undertaken on 29th June 2017 by Traffic Data and Control (TDC) for the 2P parking bays. The surveys were conducted between 8:00AM and 5:00PM with license-plate data recorded every 30 minutes for each bay. Figure 2.1 shows the locations in each street in which the surveys were undertaken.

Source: Google Maps

Figure 2.1: Survey Locations

Full copies of the CoR’s ticketing data and TDC’s parking data are provided in Appendices A and B respectively.

2.2 TICKETING DATA OVERVIEW

Figure 2.2, Table 2.1 and Table 2.2 presents the ticket sales (all meters within the study area) for the period before and during the trial respectively. As it was not possible to distinguish which ticket machine specifically relates to vehicles parked in the 2P area, data for the entire street had to be compared. It can be seen from the ticket sales that there was an increase in 2 hour or less ticket sales of approximately 7% (142 sales) and a reduction in the 6 to 12 hour sales of 5% (67 sales) when comparing the “before” and “after” data.

The proportion of 12 hour or more and 2 to 6-hour ticket sales have remained consistent. These trips can be associated with long term staff parking which indicates that there has not been a significant shift for this group in the area.



Table 2.1: Ticket Sales 13/2/17 to 17/2/17 (Before 2P Implementation)

Location 2 Hours or Less 2 to 6 Hours 6 to 12 Hours 12 Hours or More Total

Lyonpark Road 110 83 174 14 381

Byfield Street 136 82 114 5 337

Giffnock Avenue 76 85 441 79 681

Eden Park Drive 140 88 129 47 404

Total 462 (26%) 338 (19%) 858 (48%) 145 (8%) 1803

Table 2.2: Ticket Sales 8/5/17 to 12/5/17 (During 2P Implementation)

Location 2 Hours or Less 2 to 6 Hours 6 to 12 Hours 12 Hours or More Total

Lyonpark Road 127 76 228 12 443

Byfield Street 179 77 84 8 348

Giffnock Avenue 105 77 382 59 623

Eden Park Drive 193 97 97 53 440

Total 604 (33%) 327 (18%) 791 (43%) 132 (7%) 1854

Figure 2.2: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and After Implementation

The overall data clearly shows that the trial has achieved one of the objectives in increasing the availability of 8 bays for 2P demands, most likely by misplacing some “6 to 12 hour” parking elsewhere, or to other modes. Comparing Table 2.1 and Table 2.2 reveals that 142 more ‘2 hour or less’ tickets were sold and at total of 51 more tickets were sold overall over the comparative four-day period during the trial. This clearly shows that the trial’s objective of increasing the turnover of on street parking has been achieved.

Figure 2.3 and Figure 2.4 shows the ticket sale profiles from 2 hour and “8 hour or more” ticket sales from before and after the implementation of 2P bays in the study area. The profiles reinforce the data in Table 2.1 and Table 2.2 showing that throughout an average weekday there has been an increase in 2P ticket sales in the study area.

The “time of purchase” profiles are similar which reinforces the findings that the introduction of 2P in 5% of the bays has increased the availability of short-stay parking and that there is short-stay demand which takes up this additional supply.



Figure 2.3: Ticket Purchase Time Profile Before Implementation

Figure 2.4: Ticket Purchase Time Profile During Implementation



2.3 TURNOVER SURVEY DATA OVERVIEW – 2P BAYS

Table 2.3 provides the results of the turnover surveys conducted by TDC for the 28 x 2P parking bays within the study area. As shown in Figure 2.5, throughout the study area multiple vehicles are overstaying the 2P limit.

The average time occupied for all sites (i.e. 28 x 2P spaces surveyed) was 5.26 hours, with an average duration of stay of 2.85 hours per vehicle and with an average number of vehicle turnovers of 2.44 per parking space. The data shows that the 2P bays are generally not constantly occupied. However, the average duration of stay is well in excess of 2 hours meaning that whilst users are buying 2P tickets, they are (on average) staying much longer.

Table 2.3: Turnover Survey Results 29/6/17

Location Number of Bays

Occupied Hours between

8:00AM and 5:00PM

Average Duration of Stay (hrs)

Number of Overstays

Average Number of

Vehicle Turnovers

Longest Single Stay

Instance (hrs)

A - Lyonpark Road 8 5.28 2.21 4 3.33 9

B - Byfield Street 4 4.75 1.53 4 3.00 5

C - Byfield Street 4 5.00 2.01 4 2.75 4

D - Giffnock Avenue 4 5.30 2.98 5 2.40 6

E - Giffnock Avenue 4 3.00 3.00 1 0.67 8

F - Eden Park Drive 4 8.25 5.38 4 2.50 9

Total 28 5.26 2.85 3.67 2.44 6.83

Figure 2.5: 2P Bays Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile

The results suggest the need for greater enforcement of the 2P bays. Furthermore, some of the bays, particularly in Lyonpark Road were observed as being used as informal taxi holding areas which is another enforcement issue for consideration.



3. LYONPARK ROAD RESULTS 3.1 LYONPARK ROAD METER DATA

Figure 3.1 shows the duration of stay data for all meters on Lyonpark Road before and after the implementation of the 8 x 2P bays in this street. The 2P bays on Lyonpark Road do not appear to have had an impact on the percentage of 2 hour or less ticket sales on the street. The percentage of 2 to 12-hour parking has remained consistent but the proportion of 2 to 6-hour parking has shifted to 6 to 12-hour parking. This patterns is unlikely to be related to 2P effects.

Figure 3.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Lyonpark Road

Figure 3.2 and Figure 3.3 show the ticket purchase time profiles from “2 hour or less” and “8 hour or more” ticket sales from before and during the implementation of 2P bays on Lyonpark Road. It can be seen that there is not a measurable change in the purchases of 2 hour or less tickets. The number of “8 hour or more” tickets purchased between 7:00AM to 9:00AM has naturally increased which indicates that there has been a shift of all day parking from the surrounding area to Lyonpark Road.

Figure 3.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Lyonpark Road

Figure 3.3: Ticket Purchase Time Profile During Implementation – Lyonpark Road



3.1.1 Lyonpark Road 2P Bays Turnover and Occupancy Data

This section provides a further analysis of the parking data obtained from the TDC surveys undertaken on Lyon Park Road. Figure 3.4 shows the location of parking bays where the parking surveys were undertaken.

Figure 3.4: Lyonpark Road 2 Hour Parking Location

The 2P bays were occupied for 5.28 of the 9 hours surveyed. An average duration of stay of 2.21 hours per vehicle was recorded with an average turnover of 3.33 vehicles per bay. There were 4 vehicles that stayed longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay was 9 hours.

Figure 3.5 outlines the frequency of vehicle stays and the occupancy profile for the 2P bays on Lyonpark Road. These figures indicate that the 2P limit is mostly being observed with the majority of vehicles staying between half an hour and 2 hours in length with a peak occupancy period between 3:00PM and 4:00PM. Four vehicles stayed longer than the 2P limit. The vehicles staying for 7.5 hours and 9 hours essentially remove two bays for use by other looking for 2P parking

Figure 3.5: Lyonpark Road Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profiles



4. BYFIELD STREET RESULTS

4.1 BYFIELD STREET TICKETING DATA

Figure 4.1 shows the duration of stay data for all meters on Byfield Street before and during the implementation of the 8 x 2P bays. The 2P bays on Byfield Street have resulted in a significant increase in the number of 2 hour or less ticket sales with an 11% increase now accounting for more than half of the tickets sold. A commensurate change can also be seen from the “6 to 12 hour” tickets which has seen a reduction in the order of 10%.

Figure 4.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Byfield Street

Figure 4.2 and Figure 4.3 show the ticket purchase time profiles from “2 hour or less” and “8 hour or more” ticket sales from before and after the implementation of 2P on Byfield Street. It can be seen that there has been a significant increase in the purchases of 2 hour tickets particularly in the middle of the day. The purchases of “8 hour or more” tickets have reduced but the peak time of these purchases has remained at 8:00AM.

Figure 4.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Byfield Street

Figure 4.3: Ticket Purchase Profile After Implementation – Byfield Street



4.2 BYFIELD STREET 2P BAYS OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER

The sites surveyed by TDC on Byfield Street and are shown in Figure 4.4. Both Sections “B” and “C” had 4 x 2P bays.

Figure 4.4: Byfield Street 2P Locations

At site B, the 2P bays parking saw an average space utilisation of 4.75 hours out of the 9 hours surveyed with an average duration of stay of 1.53 hours. There were 4 vehicles staying longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay was 5 hours.

Site C recorded an average utilisation of 5 hours out of the nine hours and an average duration of stay of 2.0 hours. There were 4 vehicles staying longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay instance being 4 hours.

Figure 4.5 and Figure 4.6 show the duration of stays and the occupancy profile for the 2P bays on Byfield Street at both locations. Both locations are well used after midday although staying longer than 2 hours is shown for 9 vehicles across the two zones.

Figure 4.5: Byfield Street Site B Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile

Figure 4.6: Byfield Street Site C Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile



5. GIFFNOCK AVENUE RESULTS

5.1 GIFFNOCK AVENUE TICKETING DATA

Figure 5.1 shows the duration of stay data for all meters on Giffnock Avenue before and after the implementation of the 8 x 2P bays. There has been a minor shift from long-term to short term parking demand on Giffnock Avenue.

Figure 5.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and During Implementation: Giffnock Avenue

Figure 5.2 and Figure 5.3 show the ticket purchase times from “2 hour or less” and “8 hour or more” ticket sales from before and after the implementation of 2P parking on Giffnock Avenue. It can be seen that the increase in “2 hour or less” ticket sales is focused in the afternoon period between 1:00PM to 3:00PM. The number of “8 hour or more” ticket sales seems mostly unchanged with the peak remaining consistent at between 7:00AM to 8:00AM.

Figure 5.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Giffnock Avenue

Figure 5.3: Ticket Purchase Profile After Implementation – Giffnock Avenue



5.2 GIFFNOCK AVENUE 2P OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER

The sites converted to 2P on Giffnock Avenue and surveyed are shown in Figure 5.4.

Figure 5.4: Giffnock Street 2P Locations

At Site D, the 8 bays saw an average space utilisation of 5.3 hours out of the 9 hours surveyed with an average duration of stay of 2.98 hours. There were 5 vehicles staying longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay was 6 hours. Site E saw an average space utilisation of 3 hours and an average duration of stay of 3 hours, with 1 vehicle staying longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay being 8 hours.

Figure 5.5 and Figure 5.6 shows the duration of vehicle stays and the occupancy profile for the 2P bays on Giffnock Avenue at both locations. The data shows some spare capacity in 2P bays throughout the day with a total of 6 vehicles overstaying the 2P limit.

Figure 5.5: Giffnock Avenue Site D Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile

Figure 5.6: Giffnock Avenue Site E Duration of Stay and Occupancy Profile



6. EDEN PARK AVENUE RESULTS

6.1 EDEN PARK AVENUE TICKETING DATA

Figure 6.1 shows the duration of stay data for all meters on Eden Park Avenue before and after the implementation of the 4 x 2P bays. After 2P implementation, there has been an increase in the proportion of “2 hour or less” transactions on Eden Park Drive.

Figure 6.1: Duration of Stay Ticket Sale Data Before and After Implementation: Eden Park Avenue

Figure 6.2 and Figure 6.3 shows the ticket purchasing time profiles from “up to 2 hour” and “8 hour or more” ticket sales from before and after the implementation of 2P on Eden Park Avenue. There is a slight increase in mid-day transactions for “up to 2 hours” tickets between 11:00AM to 2:00PM.

Figure 6.2: Ticket Purchase Profile Before Implementation – Eden Park Avenue

Figure 6.3: Ticket Purchase Profile During Implementation – Eden Park Avenue



6.2 EDEN PARK DRIVE 2P BAY OCCUPANCY AND TURNOVER

The location of the 2P parking bays surveyed by TDC on Eden Park Drive is shown in Figure 6.4.

Figure 6.4: Eden Park Drive 2 Hour Parking Location

The 2P parking on Eden Park Avenue were, on average, occupied for 8.25 hours of the 9 hours surveyed with an average duration of stay of 5.38. A total of 4 vehicles stayed longer than 2 hours and the longest single stay was 9 hours.

Figure 6.5 shows the frequency of vehicle stays and the occupancy profile for the 2 hour bays on Eden Park Drive. These figures indicate that many vehicles using the 2P bays are actually long-stay and that the bays are fully occupied between 8:00AM to 2:30PM.

Figure 6.5: Eden Park Drive Occupancy Profile



7. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

7.1 KEY CONCLUSIONS

The trial conversion of 28 x 12P bays to 2P within Macquarie Park achieved the objective of increasing the turnover of these bays with 142 additional ‘2 hour or less’ tickets sold over the comparative four-day period. Site investigations and parking occupancy surveys did not identify any associated impacts of the relocation of longer stay parking away from these bays during the trial. Furthermore, we have been advised by Council officers that very few complaints have been received regarding the 2P bays during the trial period.

Whilst based on a relatively small sample, the surveys also identified significant levels of overstay in the 2P bays and some use of the bays on Lyonpark Road by taxis ‘holding’ to enter the Optus building pick-up area. Additional enforcement in these areas would most likely further increase the turnover of these bays; especially in areas of high occupancy such as along Giffnock Avenue.

In terms of potentially extending the trial to additional bays within the study area, this needs to be contemplated in the context on the effects of the shut-down of the rail line during the Metro NorthWest construction, the construction of bus lanes along Waterloo Road in preparation for the rail closure and a longer-term strategy to reduce car dependency for commuting access into Macquarie Park.

Council has advised that the Waterloo Road Bus Lanes would, when considering current occupancy levels of the 2P bays along Waterloo Road, result in the effective loss of approximately 20 x 2P bays. There is logic in undertaking the trial conversion of another 20 x 12P bays spread throughout the study area and commencing this trial prior to the existing Waterloo Road bays being removed. Beyond that, it is considered that the on street and public off street parking timing and fees regime should be considered holistically as part of a Macquarie Park Transport Strategy given the scale of transport infrastructure changes which are soon to be implemented in the area.

7.2 RECOMMENDATIONS

The CoR has sought advice as to whether the trial conversion of 28 x 12P bays to 2P should be adopted as a permanent change and whether such a trial should be extended to more areas within Macquarie Park. Notwithstanding the relatively small sample size that the trial was based on, the conclusions drawn in this study suggest that:

The 28 x 2P bays converted in the trial should be permanently adopted as 2P bays; A further conversion of 20 x 12P bays to 2P be trialled and spread out within the study area prior to the

permanent loss of the 2P bays along Waterloo Road; Any further 12P to 2P conversions in Macquarie Park be considered within a holistic transport master

plan which incorporates broader transport objectives and infrastructure considerations associated with the Metro NorthWest project and other transport infrastructure and services proposals; and

Council contemplates increasing the regularity of enforcement around the 28 x 2P bays recently converted and also contemplates a more regular-than-normal enforcement pattern for the additional 20 x bay trial conversion to 2P (should this be adopted by Council).

APPENDIX A

CITY OF RYDE TICKET METER DATA

Banked Total Visa Master CardAMEX

$ Amount $34,225.68$18,080.16$16,145.52$0.00

Summary Total Cash Credit CardSmart CardPay By PhoneOthers

$ Amount $36,316.88$2,091.20$34,225.68$0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Count 3504 553 2865 0 0 86

Credit Card Status ACCEPTED_FINALDECLINED_FINALREFUNDED_FINAL

$ Amount $34,356.07$0.00 -$130.39

Count 2799 52 14

Results:

Date Time Transaction IdAsset Id Asset NameBay Amount PaidTime Paid Transaction Type Payment Status Type Area Street Asset Type Space Id Customer Space Status

12/05/17 18:24:27 62380047 31307 KTM 02 0 $2.00 00:35:33 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313070000 100

12/05/17 18:14:46 62379533 30845 EPD 04 0 $1.80 00:36:00 Cash 5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308450000 100


12/05/17 18:11:25 62379347 31330 KTM 05 0 $2.50 00:48:44 Cash 7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010313300000 100


12/05/17 18:05:53 62378953 31341 KTM 06 0 $2.72 00:54:07 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010313410000 100



12/05/17 17:58:18 62378388 31284 AMA 01 0 $3.10 01:01:42 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100




12/05/17 17:52:07 62377873 30812 EPD 01 0 $3.40 01:07:53 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010308120000 100

12/05/17 17:46:43 62377471 31611 TVR 04 0 $3.67 01:13:17 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100

12/05/17 17:42:58 62377122 31611 TVR 04 0 $3.90 01:17:13 Cash 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100

12/05/17 17:42:37 62377089 31060 BFD 05 0 $2.50 00:49:56 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100

12/05/17 17:39:26 62376864 31307 KTM 02 0 $4.50 01:21:00 Cash 7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313070000 100


12/05/17 17:30:17 62376160 30890 WTL 03 0 $4.49 01:29:43 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010308900000 100

12/05/17 17:26:45 62375901 30856 PSY 01 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308560000 100

12/05/17 17:14:55 62374909 31059 BFD 04 0 $5.29 01:45:05 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310590000 100

12/05/17 17:10:53 62374573 31835 LNP 11 0 $5.47 01:49:07 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100

12/05/17 17:08:42 62374384 30834 EPD 03 0 $5.57 01:51:18 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308340000 100

12/05/17 17:03:35 62373922 30812 EPD 01 0 $3.80 01:16:00 Cash 5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010308120000 100




12/05/17 16:40:01 62371184 31037 BFD 02 0 $7.02 02:19:59 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100




12/05/17 16:11:38 62367582 31262 LNP 07 0 $4.50 01:30:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312620000 100



12/05/17 16:04:58 62366615 30856 PSY 01 0 $4.82 01:35:52 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308560000 100

12/05/17 16:00:00 62365918 31273 LNP 08 0 $9.02 03:00:00 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312730000 100


12/05/17 15:52:09 62364766 31239 LNP 04 0 $9.40 03:07:51 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312390000 100


12/05/17 15:46:05 62363948 31071 CLG 01 0 $5.00 01:40:00 Cash 3 Coolinga Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310710000 100



12/05/17 15:35:11 62362259 31138 GNK 05 0 $2.00 00:39:56 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311380000 100

12/05/17 15:31:30 62361791 31431 WTL 05 0 $3.10 01:02:00 Cash 11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314310000 100









12/05/17 15:04:55 62357910 31194 GNK 11 0 $7.28 02:25:29 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311940000 100



12/05/17 14:49:22 62355163 31419 TVR 23 0 $2.00 00:10:38 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314190000 100


12/05/17 14:48:12 62354909 31857 TVR 25 0 $3.63 01:12:25 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100







12/05/17 14:28:22 62351408 31082 CLG 02 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100


12/05/17 14:22:48 62350376 31857 TVR 25 0 $5.00 01:40:00 Cash 10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100




12/05/17 14:13:55 62349185 30991 WCK 10 0 $0.00 02:00:00 Loading Zone 12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100

12/05/17 14:11:43 62348444 30991 WCK 10 0 $8.42 04:48:17 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100













12/05/17 13:50:01 62344244 31105 GNK 02 0 $2.50 00:50:00 Cash 6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311050000 100







12/05/17 13:42:51 62343067 31824 KTM 08 0 -$8.41 02:47:55 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010318240000 100





12/05/17 13:31:17 62340852 31048 BFD 03 0 $8.00 02:40:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100






12/05/17 13:24:50 62340319 31464 WTL 08 0 $2.00 00:35:10 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314640000 100

12/05/17 13:24:50 62339831 31464 WTL 08 0 -$2.00 00:35:10 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314640000 100

12/05/17 13:24:48 62339703 31048 BFD 03 0 $0.00 01:15:46 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100










12/05/17 13:16:47 62338491 31857 TVR 25 0 -$10.68 03:33:29 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100

















































12/05/17 12:26:54 62327625 31026 BFD 01 0 $4.00 01:19:58 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100










12/05/17 12:21:24 62326375 31026 BFD 01 0 $0.00 02:19:37 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100



12/05/17 12:17:31 62325446 31846 BFD 07 0 $2.00 00:39:54 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, Byfield StMeter 9001000010318460000 100















12/05/17 12:00:32 62321534 30991 WCK 10 0 $2.00 02:00:00 Cash 12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100

12/05/17 11:58:22 62321104 31172 GNK 09 0 $2.30 00:46:00 Cash 6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311720000 100







12/05/17 11:53:32 62319860 31071 CLG 01 0 $6.00 01:59:57 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 3 Coolinga Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310710000 100


































12/05/17 11:15:26 62312687 31846 BFD 07 0 $2.30 00:46:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, Byfield StMeter 9001000010318460000 100


12/05/17 11:13:31 62312202 31352 TVR 01 0 -$11.33 03:46:29 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010313520000 100













12/05/17 11:00:04 62309731 31464 WTL 08 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314640000 100
















12/05/17 10:42:26 62306212 31284 AMA 01 0 $18.00 08:17:44 Cash 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100
















12/05/17 10:22:39 62302470 31082 CLG 02 0 $18.00 08:37:21 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100











12/05/17 10:10:17 62300083 31251 BFD 06 0 $18.00 08:49:43 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312510000 100








12/05/17 10:04:10 62298978 30924 WCK 03 0 $6.00 03:59:56 Credit Card ACCEPTED_FINAL 12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100











12/05/17 09:55:32 62297297 30924 WCK 03 0 $2.00 02:00:00 Cash 12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100




















12/05/17 09:49:04 62295965 31048 BFD 03 0 -$3.50 01:09:45 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100








































































































































12/05/17 08:33:02 62281539 31802 LNP 09 0 $18.00 10:27:07 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318020000 100













































12/05/17 08:11:27 62278209 31857 TVR 25 0 $0.00 04:09:58 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100







12/05/17 08:08:57 62277875 31835 LNP 11 0 $6.50 02:10:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100



























12/05/17 07:50:38 62275326 31251 BFD 06 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312510000 100
















12/05/17 07:34:09 62274033 31835 LNP 11 0 $0.00 04:19:54 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100



12/05/17 07:33:21 62273986 31835 LNP 11 0 $0.00 04:19:53 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100




























































12/05/17 06:43:14 62271552 31824 KTM 08 0 $0.00 12:16:46 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010318240000 100
























































11/05/17 17:53:52 62264152 31611 TVR 04 0 -$3.31 01:06:08 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100















11/05/17 17:06:50 62261008 31037 BFD 02 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100

























11/05/17 15:51:17 62251801 31262 LNP 07 0 $0.00 03:08:43 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312620000 100




















































11/05/17 14:40:14 62241235 31284 AMA 01 0 $0.00 01:30:14 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100































11/05/17 13:57:52 62233840 31419 TVR 23 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314190000 100









11/05/17 13:52:45 62232590 31431 WTL 05 0 $0.00 01:59:58 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314310000 100





















































































11/05/17 12:14:38 62214336 30924 WCK 03 0 $0.00 02:00:00 Loading Zone 12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100
















































































11/05/17 10:53:40 62199037 31060 BFD 05 0 $2.90 00:58:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100






































11/05/17 10:20:12 62193212 31105 GNK 02 0 $0.00 08:39:48 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311050000 100


































11/05/17 09:50:18 62187804 31790 EPD 05 0 -$6.00 01:59:56 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010317900000 100























































































































11/05/17 08:46:45 62175473 31464 WTL 08 0 $0.00 01:59:52 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314640000 100




































11/05/17 08:29:46 62172592 31284 AMA 01 0 $0.00 10:30:14 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100




































11/05/17 08:16:44 62170544 31161 GNK 08 0 $0.00 10:43:16 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311610000 100
















































































































11/05/17 07:23:15 62164926 31251 BFD 06 0 $0.70 00:14:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312510000 100




















































































































































































10/05/17 14:07:04 62127732 31790 EPD 05 0 -$14.66 04:52:56 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010317900000 100

















































































10/05/17 12:37:11 62112319 31431 WTL 05 0 -$6.00 01:59:51 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314310000 100





























































































































































































































































10/05/17 09:05:11 62072868 31419 TVR 23 0 $0.00 05:54:49 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314190000 100







































10/05/17 08:44:00 62068913 31082 CLG 02 0 -$18.00 10:16:00 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100











10/05/17 08:39:48 62067988 30834 EPD 03 0 $0.00 10:20:12 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308340000 100












10/05/17 08:33:47 62067023 31228 LNP 03 0 $0.00 10:26:13 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312280000 100































































































































































































10/05/17 06:58:20 62057411 31611 TVR 04 0 $0.00 12:01:40 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100








































































































































































































09/05/17 12:52:51 62009462 30834 EPD 03 0 $0.00 01:59:55 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308340000 100









































09/05/17 11:50:45 61997098 31846 BFD 07 0 $0.00 01:19:54 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, Byfield StMeter 9001000010318460000 100































































09/05/17 10:32:30 61982986 31802 LNP 09 0 $0.00 08:27:30 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318020000 100



















09/05/17 10:15:56 61979892 31060 BFD 05 0 -$2.50 00:49:58 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100













































































09/05/17 09:26:18 61970914 30856 PSY 01 0 -$14.00 04:39:51 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308560000 100












































































































































09/05/17 08:15:46 61957585 31284 AMA 01 0 -$18.00 10:44:14 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100


































































09/05/17 07:40:29 61953285 31318 KTM 03 0 $0.00 11:19:31 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313180000 100









































































































09/05/17 06:13:44 61949618 30867 PSY 02 0 $0.00 12:46:16 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308670000 100





















































































































































08/05/17 13:10:18 61909861 31026 BFD 01 0 $1.20 00:24:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100












































08/05/17 12:22:21 61900950 31082 CLG 02 0 $0.00 01:39:49 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100






















































































08/05/17 10:24:22 61881160 31026 BFD 01 0 $1.00 00:20:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100

































































































































08/05/17 09:02:51 61866961 31318 KTM 03 0 -$12.00 03:59:55 Credit Card REFUNDED_FINAL 7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313180000 100


















































































































































































































08/05/17 06:56:31 61851801 31037 BFD 02 0 $0.00 12:03:29 Credit Card DECLINED_FINAL 2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100
























































Banked Total Visa Master CardAMEX

$ Amount $33,088.50$17,233.10$15,855.40$0.00

Summary Total Cash Credit CardSmart CardPay By PhoneOthers

$ Amount $35,526.90$2,438.40 $33,088.50$0.00 $0.00 $0.00

Count 3497 601 2731 0 0 165

Credit Card StatusACCEPTED_FINALDECLINED_FINALNO_TRANSACTION_FINALQUERY_PENDINGREFUNDED_FINAL

$ Amount $33,149.60$0.00 $0.00 $0.00 -$61.10

Count 2590 131 1 1 8

Results:

Date Time Transaction IdAsset Id Asset NameBay Amount PaidTime Paid Transaction TypePayment Status TypeArea Street Asset Type Space Id Customer Space Status

17/02/17 18:43:0155074309 31611 TVR 04 0 $2.00 00:18:00 Cash 10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100

17/02/17 18:35:0555071239 30845 EPD 04 0 $2.00 00:24:55 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308450000 100

17/02/17 18:28:3455070876 31611 TVR 04 0 $2.00 00:31:26 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100

17/02/17 18:21:1155073777 31341 KTM 06 0 $2.00 00:39:00 Cash 7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010313410000 100

17/02/17 18:12:2155073363 31284 AMA 01 0 $0.00 00:48:00 Loading Zone 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100

17/02/17 18:09:0755174650 31835 LNP 11 0 $2.60 00:50:53 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100

17/02/17 18:07:1455069477 31228 LNP 03 0 $2.70 00:52:46 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312280000 100


17/02/17 18:03:5455069191 31857 TVR 25 0 $2.90 00:56:06 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100





17/02/17 17:54:5955068552 31026 BFD 01 0 $3.30 01:05:01 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100

17/02/17 17:54:5755076879 31060 BFD 05 0 $1.00 00:20:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100

17/02/17 17:54:4455068475 31824 KTM 08 0 $3.30 01:05:16 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010318240000 100



17/02/17 17:50:5455068196 31341 KTM 06 0 $0.00 01:09:06 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL7 Khartoum Road, East SideMeter 9001000010313410000 100




17/02/17 17:22:3355065509 31295 KTM 01 0 $4.90 01:37:27 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312950000 100


17/02/17 17:10:4555273918 31262 LNP 07 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312620000 100


17/02/17 16:39:1355059982 31161 GNK 08 0 $4.60 01:31:47 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311610000 100


17/02/17 16:32:3555069666 31453 WTL 07 0 $0.40 00:08:00 Cash 11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314530000 100

17/02/17 16:29:5455063249 30991 WCK 10 0 $0.00 02:00:00 Loading Zone 12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100



17/02/17 16:19:3155063669 31048 BFD 03 0 $4.00 01:20:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100

17/02/17 16:06:5055077185 31835 LNP 11 0 $2.70 00:54:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, North SideMeter 9001000010318350000 100


17/02/17 15:57:0955141153 31060 BFD 05 0 $2.70 00:53:51 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100



17/02/17 15:41:5255063832 30845 EPD 04 0 $4.00 01:20:00 Cash 5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308450000 100




17/02/17 15:22:5355048567 30812 EPD 01 0 $2.40 00:48:07 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010308120000 100


17/02/17 15:13:5255060106 31127 GNK 04 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311270000 100


17/02/17 15:06:4355046122 31442 WTL 06 0 $6.00 01:59:17 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314420000 100



17/02/17 14:58:2855047076 31846 BFD 07 0 $4.70 01:34:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, Byfield StMeter 9001000010318460000 100

17/02/17 14:56:1355044506 31846 BFD 07 0 $3.20 01:04:47 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, Byfield StMeter 9001000010318460000 100

17/02/17 14:52:0655059784 30856 PSY 01 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308560000 100


17/02/17 14:44:4255043700 30812 EPD 01 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010308120000 100









17/02/17 14:27:3455039611 31419 TVR 23 0 $2.00 00:32:26 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314190000 100







17/02/17 14:09:1455041413 31037 BFD 02 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100


17/02/17 14:06:4555035998 31048 BFD 03 0 $2.00 00:40:15 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100

17/02/17 14:04:3455035445 31105 GNK 02 0 $14.80 04:55:26 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311050000 100


























17/02/17 13:33:5555039438 31071 CLG 01 0 $1.50 00:30:00 Cash 3 Coolinga Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310710000 100


17/02/17 13:30:2655029895 31206 LNP 01 0 $5.00 01:40:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312060000 100



17/02/17 13:23:3255029908 31857 TVR 25 0 $2.00 00:40:00 Cash 10 Talavera Road, West SideMeter 9001000010318570000 100


17/02/17 13:18:4255026401 30867 PSY 02 0 $4.00 01:21:18 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308670000 100


17/02/17 13:14:5655046587 31284 AMA 01 0 $4.00 03:20:00 Cash 1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100

17/02/17 13:14:0455025296 31251 BFD 06 0 $18.00 05:45:56 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312510000 100

17/02/17 13:13:1355033346 31194 GNK 11 0 $2.50 00:50:00 Cash 6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311940000 100






17/02/17 13:00:2055044817 30991 WCK 10 0 $2.00 02:40:00 Cash 12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100







17/02/17 12:58:0355022105 31240 LNP 05 0 $9.50 03:10:57 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312400000 100




17/02/17 12:56:1855021743 31037 BFD 02 0 $3.00 01:00:42 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100








17/02/17 12:49:1155039856 31307 KTM 02 0 $5.30 01:46:00 Cash 7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313070000 100





17/02/17 12:43:4055018949 31082 CLG 02 0 $2.50 00:50:20 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100











17/02/17 12:27:1355015380 31611 TVR 04 0 $0.00 01:40:47 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL10 Talavera Road, South SideMeter 9001000010316110000 100









17/02/17 12:08:5155011284 31497 WTL 11 0 $3.60 01:12:09 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314970000 100

17/02/17 12:07:5255019918 31464 WTL 08 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 11 Waterloo Road, North SideMeter 9001000010314640000 100









17/02/17 12:02:4255009884 30867 PSY 02 0 $0.00 04:40:18 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL9 Plassey Road, West SideMeter 9001000010308670000 100





























17/02/17 11:24:0355002246 31284 AMA 01 0 $6.40 04:08:57 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL1 Alma Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312840000 100















17/02/17 11:06:0954998859 30834 EPD 03 0 $0.00 01:19:51 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL5 Eden Park Drive, East SideMeter 9001000010308340000 100






17/02/17 11:01:3855008075 31082 CLG 02 0 $4.00 01:20:00 Cash 3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100











17/02/17 10:54:1355007515 31385 TVR 20 0 $5.00 01:40:00 Cash 10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010313850000 100






17/02/17 10:48:4354995325 31071 CLG 01 0 $7.00 02:20:17 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL3 Coolinga Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310710000 100













17/02/17 10:33:5154992470 30991 WCK 10 0 $2.00 02:40:09 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100

17/02/17 10:32:2654992230 31037 BFD 02 0 $0.00 02:00:34 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, West SideMeter 9001000010310370000 100





















































































































































































17/02/17 08:21:3255076680 31149 GNK 06 0 $0.00 10:38:28 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311490000 100


17/02/17 08:20:2954968488 31138 GNK 05 0 $0.00 10:39:31 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311380000 100















































17/02/17 08:02:5854965900 31150 GNK 07 0 $0.00 10:57:02 Credit CardNO_TRANSACTION_FINAL6 Giffnock Avenue, North SideMeter 9001000010311500000 100



















17/02/17 07:56:3755076870 31228 LNP 03 0 $0.00 11:03:23 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312280000 100
















































































17/02/17 07:06:5854961981 30812 EPD 01 0 $0.00 11:53:02 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL5 Eden Park Drive, West SideMeter 9001000010308120000 100














































































































































































































16/02/17 13:49:0454916358 31453 WTL 07 0 $0.00 01:59:56 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL11 Waterloo Road, South SideMeter 9001000010314530000 100





16/02/17 13:35:1954914188 30991 WCK 10 0 -$2.00 02:40:41 Credit CardREFUNDED_FINAL12 Wicks Road, East SideMeter 9001000010309910000 100































































































































16/02/17 11:23:0354891371 31251 BFD 06 0 $3.50 01:10:00 Cash 8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312510000 100




































































16/02/17 10:03:0954889002 30924 WCK 03 0 $0.00 02:00:00 Loading Zone 12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100
































































































































































16/02/17 08:34:4454858908 31048 BFD 03 0 $0.00 05:10:16 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100

































16/02/17 08:16:5554856426 31240 LNP 05 0 $0.00 05:00:05 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL8 Lyon Park Road, East SideMeter 9001000010312400000 100






































































































































16/02/17 07:02:2854850381 31307 KTM 02 0 $0.00 11:57:32 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010313070000 100



























































































































































































































































































































15/02/17 11:30:1054796051 30924 WCK 03 0 $1.00 02:20:00 Cash 12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100

























































15/02/17 10:05:0954775778 31026 BFD 01 0 $9.50 03:10:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100



























15/02/17 09:49:1754763139 30924 WCK 03 0 $2.00 02:39:43 Credit CardACCEPTED_FINAL12 Wicks Road, West SideMeter 9001000010309240000 100











































































































































































































15/02/17 08:06:3954746080 31105 GNK 02 0 $0.00 10:53:21 Credit CardQUERY_PENDING6 Giffnock Avenue, South SideMeter 9001000010311050000 100












































































































15/02/17 07:04:5354741416 31295 KTM 01 0 $0.00 11:55:07 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL7 Khartoum Road, West SideMeter 9001000010312950000 100


































































































































































14/02/17 14:49:5754724617 31026 BFD 01 0 $3.00 01:00:00 Cash 2 Byfield Street, South SideMeter 9001000010310260000 100






































































































































14/02/17 11:50:4654672506 31396 TVR 21 0 $0.00 01:30:14 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL10 Talavera Road, North SideMeter 9001000010313960000 100




































































































































































14/02/17 09:05:0354739272 31060 BFD 05 0 $0.00 09:54:57 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, North SideMeter 9001000010310600000 100




































































14/02/17 08:36:0454637093 31082 CLG 02 0 $0.00 10:23:56 Credit CardDECLINED_FINAL3 Coolinga Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310820000 100






































































































































































































































































































































13/02/17 14:57:4954598520 31048 BFD 03 0 -$4.70 01:34:11 Credit CardREFUNDED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100







































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































































13/02/17 06:54:1454522867 31048 BFD 03 0 -$18.00 12:05:46 Credit CardREFUNDED_FINAL2 Byfield Street, East SideMeter 9001000010310480000 100






































































APPENDIX B

TDC PARKING SURVEY DATA

8:00am 8:30am 9:00am 9:30am 10:00am 10:30am 11:00am 11:30am 12:00pm 12:30pm 1:00pm 1:30pm 2:00pm 2:30pm 3:00pm 3:30pm 4:00pm 4:30pm

Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate Number Plate

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

(First 4

Characters)

1 2P CZV1 CZG5 CZG5 DJW5 DJW5 DJW5 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS

2 2P KEY5 KEY5 KEY5 KEY5 KYD9 KYD9 KYD9 T900 T900

3 2P T661 T154 T154 CTK9

4 2P BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 BIZ0 T503 T503 CE37

5 2P 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS 1EUS CJ35 CJ35 T467 T276 T276

6 2P CH67 CZM7 DBB4 DBB4 DBB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4 DDB4

7 2P T938 CNE9 CNE9 T311 T311 T179

8 2P CJ64 BBE5 BBE5 T9150 T731 T731

9 CS BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23 BX23

10 2P 1CP7 1CP7 CZM7 CZM7 CMZ7 CMZ7 CMZ7 CH64 NBG8 NBG8 NBG8 NBG8 NBG8

11 2P AOJ8 AOJ8 CXX3 CXX3 CXX3 CXX3 CXX3 DKK3

12 2P HC05 HC05

13 2P BWR9 BWR9 BWR9 BWR9 BWR9 TV59 TV59 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0 CHQ0

14 2P CG74 DRU8 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6 CNX6

15 2P MEGT CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6 CQJ6

16 2P DKN9 DKN9 DKN9 DKN9 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8 DCU8

17 2P CYI6 DNJ7 DNJ7 BMJ2 MEGT MEGT MEGT MEGT MEGT

18 2P CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 CD55 AQ45 B848

19 2P CK90 CQW9 CQW9 AF70 CNN7 CNN7 CNN7 CNN7 CNN7 AQ47

20 2P CB77 CB77 CB77 CB77 CB77 CB77 CB77 CB77

21 2P CTC5 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86 CC86

22 20 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0 YDL0

23 2P DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0 DJW0

24 2P DTS0 DTS0

25 2P

26 2P CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CRS7 CXD4 CXD4

27 2P CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73 CD73

28 2P BPN6 BPN6 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO98 CO99 CO100 CO101 CO98 BZ63 BZ63 BZ63 BZ63

29 2P TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2 TRD2

Macquarie Park Parking Occupancy

Date: Thursday 29th June 2017

F - Eden Park Drive

Bay Type

A - Lyonpark Road

C - Byfield Street

B - Byfield Street

D - Giffnock Avenue

E - Giffnock Avenue

28/07/2017 T0348

Documents

P3202.002R Macquarie Park 2P Evaluation - ryde.nsw.gov.au · MACQUARIE PARK 2P METERED PARKING TRIAL ANALYSIS AND EVALUATION FOR CITY OF RYDE Gold Coast Brisbane Sydney Suite 26,