58 DOORS AND HARDWARE£ SEPTEMBER 2007

WITH THE RAPID INCREASE in population in the Far East, especially the development of big cities in China, and the increasing number of non-accidental fires, fire ‘safety’ in dense urban areas[1] has to be considered carefully. Big acci-dental fires had happened before in old hi-rise buildings such as the big Garley Building fire[2,3], cross-harbour tunnels[4] and buses[5] in Hong Kong, and in many old hi-rise buildings and new shopping malls in China. Non-accidental fires reported over the world included the terrorist attack fires in the World Trade Centre on September 11, 2001 (WTC-911)[6]; arson fires in universities in Beijing; and under-ground railway arson fires in South Korea and Russia. Several arson fires were also reported in Hong Kong in a bank[7], a karaoke[8], and an underground train vehicle[9,10].

As there might be difficulties for new architectural features to cope with the prescriptive fire codes[11-15],building fire safety for some proj-ects was provided by performance-based design (PBD)[16-21]. There are many examples on green and sustainable buildings, especially those with extensive use of glass[22].As reviewed[23,24], architectural features of hi-rise buildings, deep

p a r t ON E World’s Tallest Building Reaches �e Skies

Far EastBuilding Fire Safety in the

B Y W . K . C H O W

SEPTEMBER 2007 £DOORSANDHARDWARE 59

plan, framed structure, and sealed enclosure are commonly found. Fire safety of these four features should be considered carefully. Taking the supertall buildings (i.e. those higher than 40 levels in Hong Kong) as an example[25,26], fire safety design guides have not yet been developed through systematic studies.

Further, there are many new materials made from combustible materials with fire retardant systems. These materials passed the fire tests (such as ignition)[27] but are not necessarily safe in real fires under high radiation heat fluxes in post-flashover fires[28]. Up to 440 kW[m.sup.2] were reported[30] in high-rack storage spaces. The four double-deck bus fires in Hong Kong[5] and Shanghai[29] which burned up all combustibles within 15 minutes are good examples of this. These issues will be reviewed in this paper. Basically, many works, including unpublished consultancy reports on big construction projects, started from the implementation of performance-based design on fire safety since the 1980s, although some activities were supported after several big fires happened in late 1990s. Another bigger theme is on protecting the environment by using halon substitutes, both for fire engi-neering systems and fire retardants.

FireSafetyConcernsinSelectedBuildings

As pointed out by Hyett[23,24], both designers given the responsibility of developing new architecture projects and facility managers operating systems in existing buildings must have a sense of sustainability. Saving a small amount of energy for building

use will protect the environment to a great extent as the servicing life of a building is very long. As observed in the past in temperate countries, a large amount of energy was consumed for lighting in commercial buildings and for heating in residen-tial buildings. The situation in the tropical areas might be different, as air-conditioning systems are provided

B y W . K . C h o W Ê h o n g K o n g L o o K I n g U P

62 DOORSANDHARDWARE £ SEPTEMBER 2007

for comfort and for giving a more productive environment in the work-place. New environmental control systems using less energy are now available. Even fire protection systems are designed to cope with green or sustainability criteria. Using clean agent[32] in total flooding gas protec-tion systems as a substitute for halon is a good example. All these new efforts will protect the environment.

Building green is a shared target of many government departments. Green building is brought about in Hong Kong with many new special features[1,33,34] such as:

n Providing more natural ventilation based on wind action for reducing cooling loads while operating mechanical ventilation and air-conditioning (MVAC) systems;

n Utilizing more daylight instead of illuminating by

artificial tungsten filament lamps with lower efficacy, leading to wide use of glass;

n New light materials but better thermal insulation to reduce the Overall Thermal Transfer Value (OTTV) of building envelopes[35];

n Internal building void[36,37]; and n Double skin facade[38,39].

These new architectural features are able to save the non-renew-able energy and maintain a healthy natural environment. It is beneficial in terms of the environmental aspect, but might give adverse effects in other areas such as fire ‘safety’[e.g. 1,33,34]. Some of the above examples on ‘green’ projects have difficulties in comply-ing with the fire safety codes.

Take window openings for introducing natural ventilation as an example. Wind action[40]

might generate a pressure differ-ence across the building envelope and when a fire occurs, the open windows for air distribution might create a pathway for spreading smoke. A negative pressure would probably be generated on the leeward side of the building. Flame and smoke would then spread out through the windows easily to other levels, or even to adjacent buildings.

In addition, many hi-rise build-ings[25,26] are constructed in the Far East. Symbolic hi-rise buildings over 1,650 feet high have been constructed in Taipei. Among the top 100 hi-rise residential buildings in the world, over half of them are in Hong Kong. Some of them are over 650 feet high[41]. Numerous problems on fire safety had been pointed out by officers responsible for fire safety, developers, contractors, engineers and building operators.

Ê M o r n I n g — h o n g K o n g

SEPTEMBER 2007 £ DOORS AND HARDWARE 63

4242 Baldwin Blvd • Corpus Christi, TX 78405800-531-3111 or 361-888-5591

TRUSTHorton Automatics

*AAADM American Association of Automatic Door Manufacturers

Concerned about the safety of automaticswing door operators that are bundledwith your hardware items? They are costly and may not be the right solutionfor handicap access and overall trafficdemands. Only Horton Automatics

operators provide you with the extra assurance of:

• Proven performance in hospitals, banks, airports, retail entrances and other special applications

• Strongest local distributor network ensures codecompliance

• Responsive 24/7 service

• Certified AAADM* installation

Trust Horton. We’re up to the challenge.

Download Our Full Line Catalogwww.hortondoors.com

It is nice to stay at high positions with good harbor views, but not easy to come down if there is a fire. Symbolic buildings might even have an increased possibility of terrorist attack as at the WTC-9/11[6]!

Several fire safety problems in supertall buildings have been debated before—the evacuation pattern, design of means of escape and means of access, and sprinkler systems—and there are numerous concerns about fire safety in those buildings[25,26]. The total evacuation time might be up to 30 minutes, even if an elevator is used and there is an orderly evacuation[42].Even the big fire that occurred[e.g. 2,3,43] during the elevator replacement in the old hi-rise Garley build-ing of less than 15 stories led to a serious disaster.

As a result of that big fire, additional actions taken by government in Hong Kong were:

Old high rise buildings, i.e. those erected before 1972 without tight fire regulations, were requested to upgrade their fire safety provisions. A New Fire Services Ordinance[44] on sprinkler systems was created. A Fire Safety Inspection Scheme[45] on structural stability, external finishes and fire safety was implemented. A request that temporary doors with adequate fire resistance be installed in the elevator shaft while replacing the elevator.

Whether those actions are workable for the existing hi-rise buildings is questionable. It has not yet been demonstrated that providing these fire safety provisions in supertall buildings will give adequate protection.

Another concern are architectural features with glass constructions[22]. As demonstrated years ago, glass panes fell off the wall of a full-height glass tower office building during a typhoon. This suggested that there are potential risks associated with the glazed build-ings. Attention should also be paid to the building’s ability to resist wind load. Though glass is not combus-tible in a fire, it will be weakened when heated up to a certain temperature. Toughened glass is able to endure higher temperature, but might be fragile after exceed-ing its critical limit. For example, cracking may occur when heated up over 550 degrees F[46]. Glass itself is a poor conductor, difficult to transfer heat from the area exposed to the fire to the other region. Temperature difference between the hot and cool sides will give

FREE ADVERTISER INFORMATION AT: www.thru.to/dhi

64 DOORSANDHARDWARE £ SEPTEMBER 2007

thermal expansion. Cracking will occur when the induced thermal stress reaches the critical value[47]. Aluminum windows framework, will be weakened when heated up to 400 degrees F, even melted at about 1,000 degrees F. Severe distortion may induce stresses across the glass plate being held up by the frame and the entire glass panel might fall down[48].

Failure of glass panels due to explosion or failure of the fittings for fixing the glass panels would give a higher air intake rate to sustain combustion. As a result, higher heat release rates would be emitted to cause severe damages. Big fires might result due to provid-ing fresh air to burn the large amount of combustibles (allowed storing up to 1135 MJ[m.sup.2] in Hong Kong[15]). Wind action might lead to fire whirls[49] or mass fire[50].

A big fire occurred in a new build-ing with glass features in Dalian, Liaoning, China on September 18, 2005. Flashover occurred with flames coming out of many levels. As observed by the author, some

glass panels fell down. Fire safety of glass features with double skin facade[38,39,51] is a concern. Smoke, heat and even flame might be trapped inside the air gap. The consequence will be very serious when the interior glass panels are broken, but not the external ones.

TotalFireSafetyConcept

Hardware fire safety provisions are required in buildings[e.g. 11-15,25,26,52]:

n Passive Building Construction Passive measures can provide

effective fire protection to the construction elements of buildings. Items covered in the local codes[12] include compartmentation, fire-resisting construction, means of escape for occupants and means of access for firefighters. The objective is to reduce the occurrence of acci-dental fires by making the building materials and components more difficult to ignite. Even if the mate-rial is ignited, only a small amount of heat will be given out at the early stage of a fire. It is designed

to confine the fire within the place of origin without affecting the adjacent areas. The spreading rate should be slowed down through compartmentation and a protected corridor, lobby and/or staircase. The building structure should be able to withstand the fire for some time so that occupants can evacuate safely.

n Active fire protection system Active fire protection systems are

necessary for detecting a fire and giving early warnings; controlling, suppressing or extinguishing the fire; operating smoke manage-ment systems to give visibility and more tenable conditions; and operating other emergency systems such as emergency light-ing and stand-by generators.

However, fire safety manage-ment is not yet considered carefully in the codes of many countries. Those passive build-ing construction and active fire protection systems hardware must be controlled by good fire safety management software[20,53,54]. Good fire safety management should ensure that, even if a fire occurs, it can be confined to a small area, occupants can be evacuated within a short time and damages to the building can be minimized. A fire safety plan[20,55] outlining clearly the procedures for maintaining protection equip-ment, staff training, fire prevention and evacuation procedures must be worked out scientifically.

Basically, building fire safety codes deal with accidental fires. But after the WTC-9/11 incident[6,53,55] and so many arson fires, there are concerns that non-accidental fires should be considered as well. With so many political and social issues,

SEPTEMBER 2007 £DOORSANDHARDWARE 65

there will be a higher possibility of having terrorist attacks and arson fires than before[10,53]. Therefore, the objectives[53-55] of protecting against accidental fires, arson fires, terrorist attack fires and disaster fires due to earthquakes should be clarified.

The total fire safety concept[1,56] in buildings is suggested by including three parts:

n Passive Building construc-tion for fire safety

n Active fire protection systems n Fire safety management

Building fire safety objectives were discussed by Rasbash[57] in a lecture in October, 1977 (published in 1996). In defining the fire safety objectives, both the nature of risk and accept-

ability of the risk should be considered. There are two reasons for working out the objectives:

n Technical nature of the risk itself varied, so different balance of fire precautions required.

n Different targeted fire safety required different resources allocation.

Based on the above argument, ten fire safety objectives for build-ing control were listed. The author believed that the most important objective is to protect the public as a whole from anxiety follow-ing disquieting incidents.

Part two of this article will discuss the importance of Performance Based Design (PBD) in the design of hi-rise buildings around the world.

About the Author: W. K. Chow is the Professor of Building Services Engineering at Hong Kong Polytechnic University in Kowloon, Hung Hom, Hong Kong, China. He can be reached by E-mail at bewkchow@polyu.edu.hk. This article originally appeared in the December, 2005 issue of Architectural Science Review. Reprinted with permission. Copyright 2007.

References  1.  W. K. Chow, Fire safety in green or sustainable 

buildings: Application of the fire engineering 

approach in Hong Kong, Architectural Science

Review, Vol. 46, No. 3, pp. 297-303 (2003). 

  2.  South China Morning Post, Hong Kong, 

21 November (1996).

  3.  W. K. Chow, Numerical studies on recent large 

high-rise building fire, ASCE Journal of Architectural

Engineering, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 65-74 (1998). 

  4.  W. K. Chow, General aspects of fire 

safety management for tunnels in Hong 

Kong, Journal of Applied Fire Science, 

Vol. 10, No. 2, pp. 179-190 (2001). 

  5.  W. K. Chow, Observation on the two recent 

bus fires and preliminary recommendations 

to provide fire safety, International Journal

on Engineering Performance-Based Fire

Codes, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 1-5 (2003). 

continues on page 96

FREEADVERTISERINFORMATIONAT:www.thru.to/dhi

96 DOORSANDHARDWARE £ SEPTEMBER 2007

  6.  World Trade Center Building Performance

Study, Federal Emergency Management 

Agency, USA, May (2002). 

  7.  W. K. Chow, Studies on closed chamber 

fires, Journal of Fire Sciences, Vol. 

13, No. 2, pp. 89-103 (1995). 

  8.  W. K. Chow and Gigi C.H. Lui, A fire safety 

ranking system for karaoke establishments 

in Hong Kong, Journal of Fire Sciences, 

Vol. 19, No. 2, pp. 106-120 (2001). 

  9.  South China Morning Post, 14 injured in peak-hour 

MTR arson attack, pp. A1, 6 January (2004). 

10.  W. K. Chow, Arson train fires and safety research 

desired, Proceedings of the Subgroup 4 

“Smoke movement and toxic harmful gases 

transfer in fire” of the National 973 project “Fire 

Dynamics and Fundamentals of Fire Safety”, 

26 May 2004, State Key Laboratory of Fire 

Science, University of Science and Technology 

of China, Hefei, Anhui, China, pp. 1-7 (2004). 

11.  BS 5588:1996 Fire Precautions in the Design, 

Construction and Use of Buildings, Part

0: Guide to Fire Safety Codes of Practice for

Particular Premises/Applications, British 

Standards Institution, London, UK (1996). 

12.  Buildings Department, Code of Practice

for Provisions of Means of Access for

Firefighting and Rescue Purposes, Buildings 

Department, Hong Kong (1995). 

13.  Buildings Department, Code of Practice

for Fire Resisting Construction, Buildings 

Department, Hong Kong (1996). 

14.  Buildings Department, Code of Practice

for Provisions of Means of Escape in case

of Fire and Allied Requirements, Buildings 

Department, Hong Kong (1996). 

15.  Fire Services Department, Code of Practice for

Minimum Fire Service Installation and Equipment, 

Fire Services Department, Hong Kong (1998). 

16.  NFPA’s Future in Performance-Based Codes

and Standards, Report of the NFPA In-

House Task Group, National Fire Protection 

Association, Quincy, Ma, USA (1995). 

17.  ASTM E-1546 Standard Guide for Development

of Fire-Hazard-Assessment Standards, American 

Society for Testing and Materials, USA (2000). 

18.  Fire Engineering Guidelines, 2nd Edition, Fire Code 

Reform Centre Ltd, Sydney, NSW, Australia (2001). 

19.  Society of Fire Protection Engineers, SFPE

engineering guide to performance-based fire

protection analysis and design of buildings, 

Society of Fire Protection Engineers, 

Bethesda, Maryland, USA (2001). 

20.  BS 7974: 2001 Application of fire safety

engineering principles to the design of

buildings—Code of practice, British Standards 

Institution, London, UK (2001). 

21.  NFPA 5000 Building Construction and

Safety Code, National Fire Protection 

Association, Quincy, Mass., USA (2003). 

22.  W. Y. Hung and W. K. Chow, Fire safety in new 

architectural design associated with the extensive use 

of glass, Proceedings of the International Symposium

on Fire Science and Fire-protection Engineering on 12-15

October 2003, Beijing, China, pp. 389-396 (2003). 

23.  E. Rose, Communication called industry’s 

weakness, ASHRAE Journal, Vol. 45, Issue 

11, pp. 6,8,55-56, November (2003). 

24.  The 2003 CIBSE/ASHRAE Conference: 

Building Sustainability, Value and Profit, 

Edinburgh International Conference Centre, 

Scotland, 24-26 September (2003). 

25.  W. K. Chow, Aspects of fire safety in ultra 

hi-rise buildings, International Journal

on Engineering Performance-Based Fire

Codes, Vol. 6, No. 2, pp. 47-52 (2004). 

26.  W. K. Chow, Fire control safety idea of super 

building, Safety Bimonthly (An Quan), Vol. 

25, No. 3, pp. 7-11 (2004)—In Chinese. 

27.  BS 476 Part 5 Fire Tests on Building Materials and

Structures—Part 5: Method of Test for Ignitability, 

British Standards Institution, London, UK (1979). 

28.  W. K. Chow, Gaowan Zou, Hui Dong and Ye Gao, 

Necessity of carrying out full-scale burning tests 

for post-flashover retail shop fires, International

Journal on Engineering Performance-Based

Fire Codes, Vol. 5, No. 1, pp. 20-27 (2003). 

29.  Bus fire at Shanghai, Beijing Times, 18, August 

(2005), http://auto.china.com/zh_cn/carman/

ceshi/11032065/20050718/12492690.html 

30.  Peter K. Wu, Heat flux pipe in large-scale fire 

tests, 8th International Symposium on Fire Safety 

Science, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China, 

18-23 September 2005, International Association

for Fire Safety Science, Paper MM-3 (2005). 

31.  M. Fordham, Natural ventilation, Renewable

Energy, Vol. 19, pp. 17-37 (2000). 

32.  W. K. Chow, E.P.F. Lee, F.T. Chau and J.M. Dyke, 

The necessity of studying chemical reactions 

of the clean agent heptafluoropropane in 

fire extinguishment, Architectural Science

Review, Vol. 47, No. 3, pp. 223-228 (2004). 

33.  W. Y. Hung and W.K. Chow, Architectural 

features for the environmental friendly century, 

Sustainable Building 2002: 3rd International

Conference on Sustainable Building, 23-25 

September 2002, Oslo, Norway—Paper 011 

presented in the Session on New Symbiotic 

Building and Environmental Technology—The 

Future Scope in Subtropical Region (2002). 

34.  W. K. Chow and C.L. Chow, Awareness 

of fire safety for green and sustainable 

buildings, Fire Prevention & Fire Engineers

Journal, September, pp. 34-35 (2003). 

35.  W. K. Chow and C.L. Chow Fire safety concern 

on building design for reducing solar beat gain 

3rd China-Japan-US Symposium on Structural 

Health Monitoring and Control and 4th Chinese 

National Conference on Structural Control, 

Dalian University of Technology, Dalian, China, 

October 13-16, 2004, Edited by Hongnan Li, 

Hui Li and Guoxin Wang, pp. 150 (2004). 

36.  W. K. Chow Short notes on internal voids in hi-rise 

buildings—Are they safe? International Journal on

Architectural Science, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 15-17 (2001). 

37.  W.K. Chow and W.Y. Hung, On the fire safety for 

internal voids in hi-rise buildings, Buildings and

Environment, Vol. 38, No. 3, pp. 1317-1325 (2003). 

38.  W.K. Chow, W.Y. Hung, G.W. Zou, H. Dong 

and Y. Gao, Preliminary experimental study 

of double-skinned facade, International

Journal on Engineering Performance-Based

Fire Codes, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 155-167 (2004). 

FarEastReferences from page 65

FREEADVERTISERINFORMATIONAT:www.thru.to/dhi

MISSINGFIRE DOOR LABELS?

We Can Re-label Them

By Inspection & Examination

• Steel Door Frames—90 min.

• Steel Doors—90 min.

• Wood Frames—20 minutes

• Wood Core Doors—20 min.

• Mineral Core Doors—45

or 90 min.

• We Label the Door & Frame &

Comment On the Hardware

Guardian Fire Test Labs, Buffalo, NY

Area Office: 15 Wenonah Terr.,

Tonawanda, NY 14150-7027

Office Phone: 716 835 6880

Fax: 716 835 5682

Email: gftli@earthlink.net

Web Site: www.firetesting.com

GUARDIAN IS AN ISO 17025-2005

ACCREDITED TEST LAB

GUARDIAN

FREEADVERTISERINFORMATIONAT:www.thru.to/dhi

Doors ThaT Work

SEPTEMBER 2007 £DOORSANDHARDWARE 97

39.  W.K. Chow and W.Y. Hung, Effect of cavity 

depth on fire spreading of double-skin facade, 

Building and Environment—In Press (2005). 

40.  W.K. Chow, Wind-induced indoor air flow in a hi-

rise building adjacent to a vertical wall, Applied

Energy, Vol. 77, No. 2, pp. 225-234 (2004).

41.  Property Times, Vol. 447, pp. 67-70, 10 January (2004).

42.  D. G. Guo, Kelvin Wong, L. Kang, Bibo Shi and M.C. 

Luo, Lift evacuation of ultra-high rise building, 

Proceedings of the Fire Conference 2004—Total

Fire Safety Concept, 6-7 December 2004, Hong 

Kong, China, Vol. 1, pp. 151-158 (2004). 

43.  W. K. Chow, Preliminary studies of a large 

fire in Hong Kong, Journal of Applied Fire

Science, Vol. 6, No. 3, pp. 243-268 (1997). 

44.  Fire Services Ordinance, Chapter 95, Laws of 

Hong Kong and its sub-leg Regulations, Hong 

Kong Special Administrative Region (2004). 

45.  Fire Safety Inspection Scheme, Buildings 

Department, Hong Kong, April (1997). 

46.  Glass and Glazing Federation, Glazing

Manual, London (1978). 

47.  S. K. S. Hassani, T.J. Shields and G.W. Silcock, 

Thermal fracture of window glazing: performance 

of glazing in fire, Journal of Applied Fire

Science, Vol. 4, No. 4, pp. 249-263 (1994-95). 

48.  Loss Prevention Council, Fire Spreading in Multi-

storey Buildings with Glazed Curtain Wall 

Facades, LPC 11, Loss Prevention Council (1999). 

49.  F. Battaglia, Kevin B. McGrattan, R. G. 

Rehm and Howard R. Baum, Simulating 

fire whirls, Combustion Theory and

Modelling, Vol. 4, pp. 123-138 (2000). 

50.  W. M. Pitts, Wind effects on fires, Progress

in Energy and Combustion Science, 

Vol. 17, No. 2, pp. 83-134 (1991). 

51.  W. T. Ding, Y. Hasemi and T. Yamada, Smoke 

control using a double-skin facade, 8th 

International Symposium on Fire Safety Science, 

Tsinghua University, Beijing, China, 18-23 

September 2005, International Association

for Fire Safety Science, Paper SC-2 (2005). 

52.  NFPA 5000 Building Construction and

Safety Code, National Fire Protection 

Association, Quincy, Mass, USA (2003). 

53.  W. K. Chow, Instant responses—On the attack 

fire at World Trade Centre, International

Journal on Engineering Performance-Based

Fire Codes, Vol. 3, No. 3, pp. 128-129 (2001). 

54.  W. K. Chow, Review on fire safety management 

and application to Hong Kong, International

Journal on Engineering Performance-Based

Fire Codes, Vol. 3, No. 1, pp. 52-58 (2001). 

55.  Malhotra H. L. Fire safety in buildings. 

Building Research Establishment Report, 

Department of the Environment, Building 

Research Establishment, Fire Research Station, 

Borehamwood, Herts, WD6 2BL, UK (1987). 

56.  W. K. Chow, Proposed fire safety ranking 

system EB-FSRS for existing high-rise 

nonresidential buildings in Hong Kong, 

ASCE Journal of Architectural Engineering, 

Vol. 8, No. 4, pp. 116-124 (2002). 

57.  D. J. Rasbash, Fire safety objectives for buildings, 

Fire Technology, Vol. 32, No. 4, pp. 348-350 (1996). 

FREEADVERTISERINFORMATIONAT:www.thru.to/dhi

The INGRESS’R6”x 36” Touch Activated Automatic Door Switch

• 2.5” wide center activating column running full 36” height provides activation from anyapproach and height

• Tapered contour profile preventsshear-off from wheeled conveyances

• Weather resistant construction

• Fast installation–retrofit and new

Designed and manufactured by the innovators in touch activated door controls for 30 years.

An AccessAbility™productfrom

Contact us for a FREE BROCHURE(please mention this ad)

Local: 414.421.9490 • Fax: 414.421.3158Toll Free: 877.421.9490 • Fax: 877.421.3158

sales@wikk.comIngress’r Details

www.wikk.com/sw_spec.html

PROVIDE ACCESS FOR ALL exceeds ANSI standard A156.19

FREEADVERTISERINFORMATIONAT:www.thru.to/dhiAir_Louvers_Ad_FINAL.indd 1 8/3/07 2:19:42 PM