Peter Checkland(1)

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    1/11

    !09070.,3/723,28099:O97,-,O.4246:J2.45074408:30850.,89,/070342-702:3/,0388902,8/0089O308,774O,$419$89028094/44$$094/44J,/0$8902,8,3/4854746:0,70.-/425479,390870.434.20394897,8/08.:-77,829,.4308/05038,20394/088902,8/048/0.03484:-,/48:008.7-03/4/,3/4.:7848/0,2094/44J,

    !09070.,3/723,2#034&3/408:3.039J1.4-79E3.4/0089O357410847/0$8902,803,&3;078/,//0,3.,8907A08057424947/0,2094/44J,/088902,8-,3/4848:,;08$:3,2094/44J,-,8,/,03:324/4/0,9047J,/088902,8

    !09070.,3/3,.O0303723,2/43/0,889O,04704387,22,7$.44370.-O:37,/4036:J2.,030$9438400/0147//43/0807,/:O.43434708.43,.,9047J,%7,-,O03,3/:897,/0,N48.424,/23897,/47/048574/:.9486:J2.4803,025708,13,08/0,/F.,/,/0803.47547O,/05,79,20394543074/030307J,/0$8902,803,&3;078/,//0,3.,8907/43/080.43;79O0357410847/0$8902,83,3.,8907089:;4,170390/0:35747,2,/0,..O3/03;089,.O3,$03146:06:003,,.9:,/,/80:9,0394/402:3/408/008!74108472F794/0,&3;078/,//0,3.,890703,08.:0,/0$8902,8!09070.,3/97,-,O03,:39,0/947,/070;89,89,08.424#0;89,:7450,/0$8902,8/031472,.O3,#0;89,39073,.43,/0089O3/0,31472,.O33039073,943,4:73,410307,$89028$8902,8/0,57E.9.,$8902,8/03;089,.O3/0,70;89,301:0.43.0//40/4.947,/443478,:8,547,&3;078/,//0.4342J,0.,301:0.43.0//40570894840,00/,,5470#$4.090370.434.20394,8:848903/,831.,9;,14841J,,9047J,,57E.9.,/0,3;089,.O34507,9;,%#0.,3/80390708O03,,5.,.O3/04888902,8/0/0,8,48574-02,8/0089O3/0847/03,/4038:97,-,4

    .42407039003,3/:897,$:8/0,85,7,,094/44J,/04888902,8,3/488:7/4/0,3.,5,./,//0,,5.,.O3/046:0F,2O/:748030/80N4/04888902,8/0089O3/048574-02,8/0847/03,/4$/08,774,/4,5,797/00890..4.4393:4/0,3907;03.O303482,480897:.9:7,/4/0089O3/048574-02,8,5703/07/048708:9,/48$8902,8,3/4808:3,7,2,/0,9047J,/088902,8/80N,/480850.J1.,203905,7,8::84,5.,.O303:3,;,70/,//0.4390948/02:3/470,,;/743/0.,7O/06:0:31,.947.,;0038:/08,774408070.434.20394/06:0,,.9;/,/:2,3,/0-07,/,5:0/0807024/04889F2.43;0/097,9,7/024/048/0,$2,5,/0,70,/,/2548-05476:0,29508.,3//,9485,7,46:0.:039,.42402:3/470,0389:,.4308.4250,8/04824/048/0/85489;485,7,,5703/0784-7002:3/470,3708:203,$80.43;079003:3574.084/03;089,.O3&388902,/0,5703/,0!09070.,3/,,-47,31:/4030/08,7744/08:,;0507,.4308/0,3;089,.O36:0808:2,,,4592,.O35747,2,.O32,902E9.,,82:,.O3.4245,790/0,94547,1J,!$%$$%A:,6:0#4,3/-74:103420344J,030E2-94/04888902,8/031472,.O35,7,0,23,7.7J9.,203900890.,254/0,.9;/,/0800;,7,.43.03.,,.,7,78:.,23454746:0,0.,3/70,,/4030.,254/0,9047J,/088902,8,.07408039/4/0/0.84308,.43897:..O384.,/0,70,/,/80,3.43;079/403.43.05948.0397,08038:870850.9;48E2-948346:070850.9,,4888902,8/05038,20394,103420344J,,,4/88902,8/05038,/4708,03903/076:0,9047J,/088902,83490306:0;07.43:3,70,/,/.438/07,/,3/0503/0390/04-807;,/4754748574.0848/03907.430O3.-073F9.,4002039484,.07.,/048574.0848020703908!470.4397,74,9047J,/088902,80884-70.O24,97-:78039/4,2:3/4.43897:7,:3/,//03:0897,70,/,/A89,08:3,0..O325479,390/04888902,8/05038,203946:00.,3/3480380N,

    !038,20394889F2.4

    25708O3/04888902,8/05038,2039484-70,84.0/,/(

    5038,20394889F2.4 080574.084/0,.4257038O3/0.O24,8.48,88031:03039708J/03974/0:3

    94/43,3,9:7,0,002548/088902,8/05038,203943.:030.488902,803486:0;,748002039489,08

    .424,70,:,24;203945,39,8,32,0897,-,,7:39485,7,84-70;;745070.073,847,3,.430848

    88902,83907,/48547507843,80897:.9:7,8574.08486:097,-,,3:39485,7,,.076:0:3,47,3,.O3

    8,:/,-0434

    !038,20394/0$8902,880,/013/4.424:303146:05,7,,7084:.O3/0574-02,8,;0748574-02,8

    .4245,790/0:388902,4-,03:,7/070,..43,7,,5,7900850.J1.,48708:9,/484,.4390.203948

    548-020390.4397-:03,:32,47/08,7744/0,8.4380.:03.,82570;89,85038,20394889F2.43408

    :3,.48,834:3.43:394/0E-948457E.9.,8(03:32,7.46:080-,8,03,.7003.,/06:00.425430390

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    2/11

    /05,7908/0:388902,5:0/0807204703903//4030.439094/0,870,.4308039708J.434974888902,803

    :,7/02,307,,8,/,5038,20394889F2.480.0397,03.J..4803;0/030,/0.,:8,010.94

    34888902,8/0.03.,80,7:2039,6:0,3.,2,307,/003903/07.42509,203905476:F:3574-02,4:3

    00203944.:77050788900803903/07,85,79080370,.O3.43094/4 (05003.4397,890

    .4308.,790870/:..43824.039J1.40,3E88148O1.4805745430;8O3/088902,803:3,3907,1472,0

    ,.:07/4.43,14841J,/04888902,84888902,8/05038,2039480701070,,.4257038O3/0:388902,

    20/,39000,203/048;J3.:48,83907,..43080397048002039486:0.4254303,949,/,//088902,

    4888902,8/0,.03.,05038,2039497,9,/024897,76:0480;03948089E3805,7,/48547,/89,3.,090254

    6:0480;03948.,9,J9.48506:0N485:0/03.,:8,77,3/08.,2-48034888902,8.425048#0.434.03/46:0

    ,2047,/0:3,43,/0:388902,5:0/03,10.9,730,9;,20390,497,8E70,8/088902,6:05742:0;0,

    .42:3.,.O347,3,.43,0394/48483;008.43013/00;9,70010.94/084%F.3.,8/04888902,8/0

    5038,203945:0/0807:9,/,5,7,089:/,7.:,6:07954/088902,3,9:7,08.039J1.48/0

    30307J,:2,344.43.059:,

    .43.0594/0:388902,/0

    03.,5038,/4708889F2.4803.:039,6:0

    :388902,08:3.43:394/3E2.4.425046:03907,.9,3.424:3,:3/,/1:3.43,0897:.9:7,/4 0307J,2,907,08/031472,.O3/01:40397048/10703908002039486:0.4254303088902, :388902,08:3,.42:3/,/89:,/,/03974/0:320/4,2-0390 0307J,2,907,0801:4/031472,.O3/08/0,.,00394734.7.:3/,390,97,;F8/0202-7,3,8

    80250720,-084J2908

    88902,8,203:/4089E3.425:08948/0,8039/,/086:0-:8.,3006:-7450745:0/00-748.,390.,O9.,4054303.,.425479,20394

    &388902,3907,08:3.43:3947:54/0,3907/0503/03.,4902547,203905,79086:0

    3907,.9,350,88430307,203904888902,8/08J28248089E3.425:089,8/0497,85,7908,8J.42448

    88902,88430307,20390,85,790844844308/04974888902,8

    4888902,8/0.03.,/0,,5.,.O3/0,.03.,05038,20394889F2.480,,7:5,/4039708.,9047J,8

    -,8,/,803,89F.3.,8:9,/,85,7,,.07170390,:388902,

    $8902,8/:748,5,79.5,.O3/0,882:,.4308,203:/4:9,3/4,8.425:9,/47,8,89F.3.,8/03;089,.O3/04507,.4308089O3/0,.03.,95,7,48574-02,86:0:891.,/,20390805:0/03

    .:,391.,7$302-,74345:0/09030703.:039,;,7,-0834.:,391.,-084534308.:9:7,54J9.,

    09..9,706:07/,(5:0/097,9,7,,8507843,8.4248075,8;403:,7/090307249;,.4308.4250,8

    $8902,8-,3/48!,7,4888902,86:0345:0/038071E.20390.:,391.,/480850.,20390,870,.43,/,8.43507843,86:0903032,7.4829508.431.9;,8/07010703.,95,7,.425703/07,8249;,.4308

    5:3948/0;89,,83907,..4308,903/079,394.:,9,9;48.424.:,399,9;48/20384308/0,889:,.4308

    574-02E9.,8$8902,8-,3/48843:3.,2546:0:9,097,-,4/0-,802094/4O.,/08,774,/,547!0907

    0.,3/7,38438:8.40,803,&3;078/,//0,3.,8907,3E8824714O.408:32F94/4

    .42502039,745,7,,0897:.9:7,.O30,3E8834.:,391.,-08.425048574-02,8

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    3/11

    $8902,80;4:9;48F,E3E9/08,774,/4:3,2094/44J,6:080,5.,,/80N4/088902,884.,08.42504889,9F.3.,3907,,3;089,.O3/088902,8.7J9.48.432094/44J,8/088902,8

    -,3/48$8902,80;4:9;4882,7,4888902,8/3E2.4884303903//,8.42488902,8,-07948.425048

    5074.43,.,5,./,//00;4:.43,7.43090254E3E93907,/48/01472,3.,

    03907/8.53,7,507850.9;,8/03;089,.O3/088902,83.:03/40.,48,.4250/,/,

    .-073F9.,,,3974544J,.:9:7,,9047J,0;4:9;,49748

    03146:0/088902,8

    5038,20394889F2.43.47547,;,748573.548 (

    ,3907/0503/03.,/0484-09488:8,97-:948002039483/0503/03908345:0/03.43899:7:388902,/0 482457450/,/080207039086:03408548-0/0/090.9,7547,3E88/0-07J,807548-0/0137:3

    03146:04J89.4

    86:0/,/0209,8,3907,..O3889F2.,/0-0/,7:,7,,:3,209,4089,/413, 397,/,8$,/,803:388902,.077,/4,80397,/,880/090723,3:3,;0.4389,39003:388902,

    ,-079480,/2903,5479,.4308,/.43,08/020/4,2-0390

    %7,381472,.O3/038:24803574/:.9480890080574.0845470.:,484-09;48804-90303 39745J,,.,39/,//0/0847/034,0,9470/,/5708039003.:,6:0788902,/0 #0,20394:32F94/4/070974,2039,.O30830.08,7,5,7,6:0088902,1:3.430/008507,7 07,76:J,949,/,/08.4250,880.4254303/0506:0N488:-88902,8 10703.,.O3,8:3/,/080850.,,/,8/080250N,31:3.43080850.,,/,8 6:13,/,/1472,8,9073,9;,8/0,.,3,748282484-09;48.43;0703., :913,9,.4380.:.O3/04-09;48,9073,9;48,5,797/0482824838:248/;0703.,:348002548

    3:,7/097,9,7/02047,7088902,/017034803:3.4.027,3/4.437,3/09,003,.42548.O32,907,/0,85,89,8/01703470/:..4389,0J290/088902,/01703,/45:0/0807,25,/45,7,3.:7

    ,83907,..430803970

    /8.48/0170344/0489,2-4708 050/,/01703480384708 /7E:., .43/:.947090254/070,..O3

    30:2E9.48 .43/.4308/0,.,770907, ,8.43/.4308.2E9.,8 47,/0/J,

    &9,3/40573.54/0:913,9:38:507207.,/454/7J,807.438/07,/4.424 :388902,/0942,/0,3,3.,8/08/0,507850.9;,/0,,/23897,.O348574509,748 :388902,/0/897-:.O3/08/0,507850.9;,/048574;00/4708

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    4/11

    :388902,/002504/08/0,507850.9;,/0480250,/48 :388902,/08:238974/02,907,08/08/0,507850.9;,/048.03908 :388902,/00397090320394/08/0,507850.9;,/0484,,308 :388902,84.,/08/0,507850.9;,/048708/039084.,08 :388902,/0.9,8/08/0,507850.9;,/048.039083/;/:,08424708:9,/4/00890954/05038,203943:0;,8/0,85:0/0807,/6:7/,0308:507207.,/4.O24

    1:3.43,5476:F9030574-02,8.O24805:0/02047,74.O2448.,2-4870,,/4803:34/048

    .4254303908/088902,5:0/03,10.9,748/02E8.4254303908

    0/9,7(5.,.4308

    ,.03.,05038,20394/088902,808.,/,;02E8:9,/485,7,,.07170390,:3,,25,;,70/,//0

    902,803.,2548.424,31472E9.,,30307J,,05/0244J,.03.,8/0,

    31472,.O38,:/1,-7.,.O3089O3020/4,2-0390

    :348002548

    03.,/0,03.,/006:54 76:90.9:7,47,3,.43, %7,-,4/0/80N4 6:54/0,!4-,.O30/80N4/0,:3/,//097,-,4 !74.08430,80N4.42504 80N4/0,.,/03,/08:238974 !,31.,.O3/0,.4393:/,/.4357494.44 !7490..O3/0317,0897:.9:7,8.7J9.,8,97,;F8/0317,,7/

    F94/405/08,774,/4547#5,7,,&$ :9:748089:/48!038,20394/07,42039473 80.9475-.43.:00025480305038,20394889F2.470;8O3( 0/08,7744/0/07,4 .0,347,1J,0.425479,20394/088902,8.425048/0570;8O3 !072,.:9:7, 0850:0/0,1:3.O3/0.,/,/" 0089O3/0.,/,/,5,31.,.O34832F94/48 ,.,/,//0:O37E1.4$947%0.2,7.40,5174& ,.,/,//08419,70 !747,2,/0089O3 089O3/05740.948 'J,.380 $4.4.7,., 5038,2039430,

    ":F0805038,20394889F2.4

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    5/11

    5038,20394889F2.44170.0:3,507850.9;,3:0;,54/0748,:303:,00850.,,/4:3.43:394/0077,2039,86:05:0/0:9,75,7,,.07170390,48574-02,82E850788903908038:;/,.49/,3,097,-,45038,20394889F2.408:3,2,307,/003903/07,70,/,/6:0,.03.,5F03,870,.430803970,85,7908/0:388902,03:,7/0,850,8,8,/403:3.,254/0089:/4.434./4.424,/3E2.,/088902,05038,20394889F2.49030:3;,4757E.9.46:080,54,03:3,-,8090O7.,8O/,

    !476:F0825479,390!038,20394/0$8902,8

    !476:F0805038,20394/088902,8/0;,470-/4,6:05:0/0,:/,70,/80N,784:.430839003908/:7,/07,8,48574-02,838:8039/42E882504888902,8/05038,203946:0/,:3,2,032E80,.9,/0

    ,70,/,/54746:0805:0/097,-,,7.43,81:07,83,9:7,08/0:388902,,13/047,748708:9,/486:0/080,%,2-F34,039,,5038,70348574-02,884:.4308.43,27,/,5:089,03,;8O3,,745,454700254.O2454/7J,:3,84:.O35,79.:,76:0089E.438/07,3/4:,71:07,030,745,46:F.4380.:03.,834/080,/,85,7,6:0,903,33,2039005038,20394889F2.480-,8,03,:348573.548-E8.48:3;078,086:0800250,3,/090.9,70394/4848E2-948/0,;/,:3,;06:0,5703/07,70.434.0748

    ":F8434888902,8

    ":F08:388902,&388902,08:3.43:394/0.425430390870,.43,/48039708J03907/0503/039086:01472,3:394/4.42504:31.,/4$8902,8089E30394/,85,7908547002540/05,79,20394/0038:47,3,.O3088902,.7.:,9474038:.:0754,870,.4308570/,/475708,03,3,9:7,0,088902,/003.03//4030.4.0,8J8:.08;,203904888902,80.4O.484888902,884.,08:2,34884388902,8;;4888902,8,791.,089,08.424,:942O;08,;,/47,88434888902,8;;03908,2,47J,/0485038,/4708889F2.48.0397,78:,903.O3034888902,8;;480850.,203904888902,884.,08:2,348$302-,7448

    5038,/4708/02:.4888902,89,2-F3089E3390708,/4803.O244888902,884.,08:2,348,10.9,3,4888902,80.4O.482E87,3/08/03:089745,309,

    4888902,890303;,7,8.,7,.907J89.,86:0/01303

    W,/,88902,9030:35745O894/03974/0:388902,2,4702545745O894/0/05,79,20394/0038:47,3,.O3080307,7/0,8/03:0;48574/:.948.,7,.907J89.,85,7,,47,3,.O3W%4/,8,85,7908/0:388902,/0-0089,75708039003088902,5,7,0;,7,.,-48:5745O894O592,025488902,/0038:47,3,.O3089E1472,/,547507843,806:548574.0848$,023,/4,:34/008948.4254303908089088902,3454/J,1:3.43,7W5,7908/0:388902,/0-080747,3,/4/0:3,2,307,0850.J1.,5,7,088902,5,7,0;,7,.,-48:5745O894 0254$:890/7047,3,7,870,.4308/08:-47/3,.O3038:/05,79,20394/0/02,307,6:00010/0/08,7744/03:0;48574/:.94831472O09F.3.4/0,-47,9474/03;0/00397,/,0/05,79,20394574-,-020390903/7J,574-02,85,7,0;,7,.,-48:5745O894

    W$8902,8/0.,2-4037085:089,,48.42039,74848.42039,7485,,-7,:0,:35,50.0397,0305038,20394889F2.4,70974,2039,.O308,31472,.O36:0;:0;0,8:02847473,/09,2,307,6:031:003,8,..430854890747086:097,3828470254$:543,6:0,8:;0/02,8,/4-7:8.,2039020397,8.43/:.08:.4.003:3,.:7;,,83/.,.4308;8:,08;0:3-:O3.47703/4,.,:890/0/7J,6:080;4;J,3/02,8,/4-7:8.,2039089,880N,08.43899:0370974,2039,.O36:005/06:0.,2-046:0089E,.03/497O3/0;4,39003,497,/70..O3:354.45,7,6:05:0/,/0,78:.4.0/03:0;4032,7.,W$8902,8/02,3903078:089,-/,/70,,3/4,:8908-,8,/4803,70974,2039,.O30254$:,902507,9:7,/0.:075454740307,48.,,70/0/47/07,/48,70309$80.,039,3/02,8,/48:.:0754574/:.08:/476:0800317J,/03:0;4,.,,-,4

    !038,20394$89F2.4.424:3,507850.9;,/0;03948!,9743084088902,

    5038,20394889F2.408:35:394/0;89,,6:0348,:/,,;07480;039485,974308033:0897,8;/,803:3,3:0;,:708543/07,048031472,8/0,5,,3.,203942E8,94!47002548:543,2486:0,:33.03/4038:.:/,/$097,9,/0:30;0394$:890/708543/0,6:0825020390,5,,3/401:046:0089E70,..43,3/48/0.76:034,30.43,/,5,7,570;0373:0;483.03/48$:890/708543/0547,5,,701:040089:/4/43/0483.03/48903/03,8,7/08:.:/,/089,7J,57089,3/4,903.O3,485,974308!4700254:890/5:0/0349,76:0.07948-,77485,70.038:1772E83.03/486:049748$03.:0397,2E8089,.4308/0-42-07480308,8E70,86:0089E,/,59,3/4334,0.43,/,5,7,570;0373:0;483.03/4847,8:543,6:0:890/-:86:0,88902,89,08.424,/897-:.O3/0:24/090.94708/02,907,08/0.43897:..O3:9,/486:031:0303485,974308/0483.03/48/0-,774$80.43897:033:0;4888902,8/0,,72,.4397,3.03/48089,-0.0701:0448.O/48/080:7/,/6:0089E.70,3/40.,2-43,20390:890/089E,.03/4,45,7,0;9,73:0;483.03/48

    89,08,7,O354727,702:3/4,97,;F8/0:35038,20394889F2.40390089,354/0748,%050729070,20390,.07/02:3/4:3:,72047

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    6/11

    !038,20394$89F2.4.424:303:,00850.,

    424:303:,005038,20394889F2.49030.:,/,/083.,86:00,:/,3,.42:3.,780.43497,8507843,8,.07.,/0482:.4888902,8,70/0/47/03974/034849748

    W$0,.03.,5F03949,/,/08345,7908/089,.,05,50/0,83907.43043083.:03/405,506:0:0,3.,/,:34/04888902,803097,-,4033:0897,8;/,8W$0,.03.,5F0370974,2039,.O3.7.:,754700254.43/:.0,46:0.43/:.0,,6:00;,/03:0;4,03:,7/030,/0.,:8,010.940;,,46:0.43/:.0,,46:0.43/:.0,,,8J8:.08;,20390

    W4390309072344J,0850.,6:0/08.7-00.425479,20394/088902,.4240701:074/0574.084:31:4/031472,.O36:00307,0.70.20394054303.,4.4,5840574.084/006:-74:31:4/070,2039,.O36:0.43974,0.,2-4,:/,,2,390307,089,-/,//0:388902,

    $$%$!038,7.424:3.43:394/0077,2039,8

    .,254/0,9047J,/088902,8,0307,/4:3,,25,,2,/0077,2039,86:005072903/08.7-037E1.,203908:.4257038O3/0,0897:.9:7,/0:388902,035,79.:,7,.43/:.9,.42:3.,780.4348/02E8,.07.,/08:03903/20394/80N4/07,331:03.,,83907;03.43085,7,0.425479,20394/088902,574-02E9.4

    89,8077,2039,83.:03-:.08.,:8,080.425479,2039403487E1.48/090254,8,..430848/,7,2,8/01:488902,8/0,76:0954894/44.:,0507290705708039,7,8:.4257038O3/0:388902,/024/048/082:,.O354747/03,/47089O3/082:,/4708/0;:046:0,:/,7E,54307,57:0-,054903.,/025,.94/08:83907;03.4308

    WWW

    $80903003.:039,4888902,8/05038,20394038:2,47J,:3,3:0;,507850.9;,:303:,00850.,4:3.43:394/0077,2039,89030:354/07:354903.,6:0:3,;06:0,,8/43974/:./4843/1J.08/0708897:,3942E8,5703/,,.07.,/00890.,2541,8.3,3902E8906:0748,-074

    ,9047J,0307,/04888902,8/03423,/,0850.J1.,203909047J,0307,/088902,8%$80.438/07,/02:.,25479,3.,5,7,0/08,7744/0,8.03.,8,.9:,08,-,7.,,89047J,8.43.05.4308/088902,86:097,9,3/0,3E88/0/090723,/,8.,808/088902,81472:,3/448573.548209,90O7.480307,08/0,3;089,.O3/088902,8

    0-0.434.0780,08903.,/048342-7089047J,0307,/088902,9047J,0307,/088902,8574;4.,3/4,:3,8/:/,86:0/0-03/85,780$03,84/0-0248701077348,9047J,0307,/088902,34,,9047J,0307,/088902,85:7,.4770.94/0-0,5.,780,9047J,348O4,88902,,6:054/70248.43.0-72:.,89047J,8030.,254!474974,/434,.48,9,.424:388902,0307,039/,/08,2,/,888902,80307,08,/03423,.O3/09047J,0307,/088902,8/07;,/0,857207,897,/:..4308/08,774,/,8/0308/00890902,0306:0805:7,4,5,,-7,88902,54703/00907234/0-0/0.425703/07805470831.,/4802E39.40307,345470831.,/43/;/:,/0.,/,5,,-7,

    %047J,0307,/0$8902,880.43.-0.424,9047J,70,9;,,4820/4854748.:,0854/02489030705708,70.434.20394/02:3/4,1:0390/0,9047J,0307,/088902,85:0/0702439,780574-,-020390,4847J0308/0,.03.,,14841J,089,08:3,.43.05.O3209,90O7.,209,.03.,/0,3;089,.O3/04-09486:0705708039,:388902,8.438/07,/,03,,.9:,/,/,70,9;,20390:3,3:0;,/8.53,6:0574547.43,1:3/,20394845479090O7.4,03146:0/088902,8

    !038,20394/088902,808:3,05890244J,9047J,70,9;,,.434.20394/04888902,86:0.:,3/480,5.,,,,.9;/,/:2,3,8030.,3/80-,8,03.:,974/0,8-E8.,8020703.,07,76:J,.42:3.,.O3.43974.424.,7,.907J89.,8-E8.,8/088902,8:,3/480,5.,,4888902,8/80N,/4843,9:7,08,.,7,.907J89.,.7:.,843,857450/,/08020703908/094/4

    24;20394/088902,83.:094/48.,/,:34/048081:0748/0,8507843,85477084;07,825.,.43086:0.430;,30:849047,.O3/0:394/4770/:.9-0/0,8/0,8/088902,8

    ,9047J,0307,/088902,880,/08,774,/45,7903/4/0,30.08/,/-73/,7:3,O.,,9073,9;,,48086:02,8.43.059:,08.039J1.48.434./48-,40342-70/003146:08,3,J9.420.E3.48,84.,/48.43,,5.,.O3/02F94/4.039J1.44803146:08.039J1.489:;0743F9403,05.,.O3/048103O20348/04888902,8/02:3/41J8.4507434800903/07438,981,.947,203905,7,05.,7,857450/,/08/04888902,80348.,2548-4O.4.43/:.9:,84.,

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    7/11

    ,9047J,0307,/088902,8,0;4:.43,/45,7,4170.07:32,7.4/097,-,4.43.059:,6:050729,,,5.,.O3/02F94/48,/0.:,/485,7,,17439,7/0-/,20390574-02,8/088902,8,9047J,0307,/088902,8,/459,:303146:04J89.4,.,4888902,820/,390,570807;,.O3/08:/039/,/,857450/,/08/0:3/,/08770/:.-08/459,,0307,/,//00085,79.:,70820/,3900,,4/F829:/08/00897:.9:7,8424718248,97,;F8/04888902,808,774,24/04848.:,084170.035478:0307,/,/,3,4J,80397088902,8/02E85742:0;0,:3/,//0,.03.,,574547.43,7:32,7.4/07010703.,.40703905,7,,47,3,.O3/0.434.20394

    ,49;,.O3/0/08,7744/0,9047J,0307,/088902,85475,,-7,8/0'43079,,3110847039,78:/08,774403-:8.,7:3,9047J,.:48573.54880,3;E/485,7,4888902,8030307,:3/,/,089,548.O30348

    8:039085:3948

    O ,08903.,/0573.54884247148482,7086:04-073,3,.43/:.9,/0039/,/08032:.48.,2548O ,30.08/,//0:3,3:0;,.03.,6:01:07,0948,030/08,7744/0,9047J,/0,.4250/,/

    47,3,/,03.4397,890.43,.03.,.E8.,6:08029,,,9047J,/0,.4250/,/3447,3,/,4/0847,3,/,

    O ,08507,3,/0.43.0594:39,74/02:3/4/0,.03.,6:05:/07,-,8,7803484-70,08507,3,548-02039039.079,20390147,/,5,7,70/:.794/48483;008/0,70,/,/,3;0/0,1J8.,8342E8-0303,842471,/0,800803/10703908.,2548

    O #01:9,7,81472:,.4308.43;03.43,08/0,1J8.,3,/0.:,/,85,7,97,9,788902,8;;03908.42488902,8,-079486:03;4:.7,3,80080397O5.,86:03/.,-,3/85,.O3/07,/,.O30;4:.O3034847,38248;;03908

    O ,70:31.,.O3/0,.03.,,14841J,08/0084/0.8090,.03.,/0O-,89,390,97E8,,14841J,03,025708,/0,0547,7,3,9:7,0,,9047J,0307,/088902,8,-,7.,,;8O3/02:.48

    .039J1.4803,3;089,.O3/0481:3/,203948148O1.48/048.43.05948.4348.:,0897,-,,3

    O !,7,6:F87;0,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;08O /.02-70

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    8/11

    O O :.,8;0.08.:,3/49030248.439,.94.43,$$3.,20390348570:39,248":F08,$$

    !,7,6:F87;0,$$

    O 3$89027,2,8024897,9,/4/0708543/07,57207,570:39,030;/04995889027,2,847/57088.422094/44,88902,88:,;08;/04

    O 47,97,9,248/0,.,7,7,80:3/,570:39,';2480320/4/0:31:4/00;039480302:3/470,0/0,86:097,38.:770303090254,94/4040,2,2480/J,,/J,4,;/,/,7,!07.-248:3,

    89:,.O3574-02E9.,.438/07,2486:008,89:,.O354/7J,2047,74:8,248,5,,-7,574-02,5476:0084831.,6:00574-02,805:0/07084;07/08,5,70.07,2039,-020390.432:.,8.48,803

    ,;/,70,084345:0/0807548-0!47084.:,3/4,-,248/089:,.4308574-02,489:,.4308

    574-02E9.,84,.02480308039/46:0805:0/032047,7,:36:09,;0,89:,.O334/08,5,70.,

    547.425094

    O 3089,889:,.4308089,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;08$$5476:050729039039,7:3,2047,/0,89:,.O3/090.9,/,

    O 3,889:,.4308574-02E9.,83907;0303507843,847:548/0507843,8.,/,.:,.43:3/10703905:394/0;89,09,38.,::3/0,89:,.O3,.9:,3/4.,/,:3,4.,/,7:54.43:35745O894

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    9/11

    ,$$5072900,-47,724/048.43.059:,0824/048/0,.9;/,/88902,8/0,.9;/,/:2,3,03-,80

    ,485:3948/0;89,

    O :0403-,80,084824/048805:0/0089,-0.07:3/0-,900897:.9:7,/45,7,/090723,76:02047,/0,89:,.O3805:0/047,70,3/4,.,2-48/080,-0803-,80,4824/048.:9:7,203901,.9-08

    !:0/0,-07:3,.424/44.4380384

    O 3,20390802502039,48.,2-485,7,4-90307,2047,/0,89:,.O3574-02E9.,O $302-,745489074720390805:0/00;,:,7,2047,/0,89:,.O3574-02E9.,7050973:0;,203900

    ..4008,2,307,708543/0248,,80:3/,570:39,,$$87;05,7,47,7:3,2047,.439J3:,/0

    89:,.4308574-02E9.,8,,/,80302:3/470,5072900,5703/,0/0:3,47,3,.O34/0:3

    7:545,7,,,..O3O 4703/0,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;08$$O 2,74O '030/04703/0,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;08$$

    O 305720770.:039484-700/08,7744/0,2094/44J,0.,3//08.7-O9708050703.,86:000;,743,/0,7/0,/4,30307J,/088902,8

    50729074308:720394/0,$$3489708.,848,-J,574-02,80890390803,8

    47,3,.4308-,4089:/45074487085438,-083454/J,305708,748039F72348570.848

    ,/,:3,,889:,.430807,305708,/,8039F72348,2-:48340897:.9:7,/48

    O 3:34/0485740.948-,4089:/4,-J,,89,/4.0548-0803:3.,/486:054/J,3,8:27074/0/013.O3/0574-02,5,797/008,89708050703.,80.,3/089:;403548.O3/0/0137:3,

    2094/44J,6:054/J,807/1070390/04803146:08/:748/0,30307J,

    O 0.,3/0O,;,7,8.43.:84308O ,1,80/0,3E88/00890954/0574-02,88:,;0834/0-J,-,8,780039F72348/088902,8390,

    ,:803.,/04-09;48209,8/013/4803,86:0485,79.5,3908.43./07,3/0:3,07,76:J,/0

    88902,8.,7,20390/013/,0:8490257,34/0.43.0594/088902,85,7,4-9030784:.430854/7J,0;,7

    ,:3,/89478O3/0,89:,.O3574-02,,.,:38,94,.43.:843085702,9:7,8!4749,3940,3E88

    034888902,88:,;08/0-07J,.43889703,.43897:..O3:3.:,/746:0/08.7-,,89:,.O3

    574-02,03:,7/097,9,7/005708,7/.,89:,.O30324/048/088902,8

    O ,/46:0030890954/0574-02,834084-;48:388902,/0-0807.43897:/446:F88902,/0-0807.43897:/4082,8,5745,/4/0137:37,34/088902,8700;,39085,7,2047,7,89:,.O3

    574-02,,/,:34/04888902,8700;,39085:0/0305708,7:3,09,38.,::35:394/0;89,/048

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    10/11

    5,79.5,390803,89:,.O3574-02,!,7,4888902,8700;,3908800,-47,3/013.43087,J.08,8

    .:,085489074720390843/08,774,/,8.42424/048.43.059:,08:84/0,$$507290,

    .43897:..O3/0;,74824/0486:0:04843.425,7,/48.4302:3/470,

    O 4824/048.43.059:,08705708039,388902,8/0,.9;/,/:2,3,390747203904803146:08/088902,8,-J,3/013/488902,81J8.4888902,8/80N,/4888902,884.,0850743480,-J,

    .438/07,/488902,8/0,.9;/,/:2,3,8901:0:34/048,5479082,825479,3908030/08,7744/0,

    $$

    O &388902,/0,.9;/,/:2,3,08:324/04/0:388902,34.43,.43.059:,490O7.43408903900302:3/470,6:0.439030,8,.9;/,/086:0,8507843,830.089,3

    70,,75,7,47,7:3/090723,/45745O894413,/,/

    O 0397,86:04824/0480307,/485474803146:08/:74884324/048/02:3/470,2,6:09,845,348/0/80N44824/048/088902,8/0,.9;/,/:2,3,843/85489;480589024O.485,7,

    70,,7:3/0-,9084-700.,2-45,7,:3,2047,/0:3,89:,.O3574-02,34824/048

    /088902,8/0,.9;/,/:2,3,80089,-0.0305J.9,203906:F,.9;/,/0884330.08,7,85,7,47,7:3

    5745O894/013/4/08/0:35:394/0;89,5,79.:,7$4-70,-,80/0084824/048485,79.5,390803,

    89:,.O3574-02,5:0/0303.4397,7,5703/076:F.,2-48843889F2.,20390/080,-08

    .:9:7,203901,.9-08O 4703/0,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;08$$O 2,74

    O ,094/44J,/0$8902,8$:,;0880/08,774O03,&3;078/,//0,3.,8907#034&3/403:35747,2,/03;089,.O3,..O3,.9437080,7.0348,N48

    3.,20390005,79,20394/0$8902,8:9O003146:0/0,30307J,/0$8902,8/08,774,/4547

    03386:0307,0010/005,79,2039489003146:080,5.,,574-02,8-030897:.9:7,/48.43

    4-09;4820//,8/0/080250N4.,7,20390/013/48

    03388302-,744-807;O6:0003146:0/0,30307J,/0$8902,83407,,5.,-00389:,.4308

    /43/034,-J,4-09;48/013/486:034/0-07J,089,3.,780.43;79F3/48003,45:7,20390,.,/F2.4

    54746:03.O:35747,2,/03;089,.O3,..O3/7/4547!09070.,3/5,7,574-,7/08,774,7

    50710..43,7003146:003,847,3,.430870,081:07,/0,&3;078/,/

    ,3;089,.O3,..O308,3907,..O303970,8/0,8,050703.,089,-0.F3/480:3.J7.:4;79:484

    /43/0,050703.,08/7/,547,8/0,8:04,8/0,8843.4770/,82047,/,8547,050703.,

    ,8J8:.08;,203903.,20390,0897,90,/03;089,.O3,574-,/,5470.,3/.:,3/40O,

    ,3.,890707,97,9,7/0:9,7003146:0/0,30307J,/0$8902,8/003385,7,,.07170390,48

    574-02,8/0089O34,/23897,.O3,5703/07/048708:9,/48

    :7,390097,38.:784/0,3;089,.O3,..O3003146:03.,.,2-O7,/.,203905,7,,/0.:,780

    0317039,7,2,47.4250/,/,2-Q0/,//048574-02,86:0805708039,303,089O3

    ,/23897,.O3,/10703.,/046:04.:7700348574-02,86:00317039,,30307J,

  • 8/3/2019 Peter Checkland(1)

    11/11

    46:013,203908:7O/085:F8/00890574.0841:0:3954/003146:0949,20390/1070390

    ,094/44J,/048$8902,8$:,;08$419$89028094/44$$