Gujarat Pollution Control BoardREGIONAL OFFICENr. Race Course, Rjng Road, Rajkot-360 001Website: www.opcb,qov.in

PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDINGS

As per the provisions of Notification No. S.O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006 and its amendment S.O.3067(E) dated OL/12/2OO9, llinistry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, NewDelhi, Public Hearing is conducted for M/s. Bell Laminates for manufacturing of (1) LaminatedSheets 2.0 lakh numbers per llonth (2) Phenol Formaldehyde Resin - 315 IYTPM & (3)lvelamine Formaldehyde Resin - 75 |4TPI\4 at Survey No. BB /p, Old Jambudiya, Talukat lviorbi,Disti Rajkot, State: Gujarat/ which is covered under Category'A'as mentioned jn their requestapplication.

A copy of the draft Environment Impact Assessment Report and the Summary of EnvironmentImpact Assessment Report was sent to the following authorities or offices to make available thedraft EIA report for inspection to the public during normal office hours. till the Publjc Hearing is

1. The District Collector Offlce, Rajkot2. District Development Office, Rajkot3. District Industry Centre, Rajkot4. Taluka Development Ofl'ice, Tal: I4orbi, Dist.: Rajkot,5. The Chaef Conservator of Forests, Ministry of Environment and Forest, GOI, Regional Office

(West Zone), Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan, E-5, Arera Colony, Link Road-3, RavisankarColony, Bhopal 462 016.

6. Regional Office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Rajkot, Nr. Race course. Ring road,Rajkot-360 001.

Other concerned persons having plausible stake in environmental aspects were requested tosend their responses in writing to the concerned regulatory authorities.The Public Hearing was held on 04/05/2012 at 11:00 hrs. in Compound of tY/s. Belt Laminates,Survey No.88/p, Vill. : Old Jambudiya, Taluka: l4orbi, Disti Rajkot.

An advertisement in English was published in the daily "The Indian Express" dated 02 /O4/2012and in Gujarati daily in "Divya Bhaskar" dated O2/O4/2012,

Shri l'1anoj ltlakwana Additional Collector. Saurashtra - Kutch (irri.) Rajkot supervised andpresided over the entire public hearing process.

A statement showing participants present during the public hearing is enclosed as Annexure A.

A statement highlighting issues raised by the participants and responded by the representativeof the applicant during the public hearing in English and Guiarati Languages is enclosed asAnnexure I and 81.

A copies of responses received in writing from other persons havingenvironmental aspects are enclosed herewith collectively as Annexure-Q1applicants to the same are enclosed herewith collectivelv as Annexure A1.

<z1u/Placei Old JambudiyaDist.r RajkotDatet 04/OSl2Ol2

plausible stake inand the replies by

J. K. VyasRegional Officer,

GPcB Rajkotas Representative of theMember Secretary, GPCB

Additional CollectorSaurashtla - Kutch

(Irri.) Rajkot

Makwana

1

2Annexure A, B, 81, Q1, A1 as above,

Video CD of public hearingEnct:

ANNEXURE - B (Enolish)

A statement showing issues raised by the participants and responded by therepresentative of the applicant during the Public Hearing,

As per the provisions of Notification No. S.O. 1533 dated 14109/2006 and itsamendment S.O. 3067(E) dated O|/!2/2OO9 issued by lvlinistry of Environmentand Forests, Government of India, New Delhi, public hearing is conducted onO4/O5/2OI2 at 11.00 hrs. for manufacturing of (1)Laminated sheets 2OOOOOnumbers per l4onth; (2) Phenol Formaldehyde Resin - 315 N4TPM & (3)lvlelamine Formaldehyde Resin - 75 t4TPtvl for Laminated Sheets at M/s. BellLaminates, Survey No. 88/P, Village : Old Jambudiya, Taluka: [4orbt, Dist:Rajkot, State: Gujarat, which is covered under category .A, of above referrednotificatjon under the supervision of Shri 14anoj Makwana, Additional Collector,Saurashtra - Kutch (irri.) Rajkot and Chairman of public hearjng committee.

Shri J. K Vyas, Regional officer, GPCB, Rajkot and the representative of theMember Secretary, GPCB - a panel member of public hearing committee;welcomed all present to the public hearing. He outlined the various provisionsof the Notification and briefed about the procedural details for conducting thispublic hearing including actions taken by cpCB for wide publicity of this publichearing and the advertisement given earlier in the local dailies. He announcedthat as per the provision of notlfication, only locally affected persons will beallowed to make their representation in the public Hearing while others havingplausible stake may submit their representations in writinq which would beincluded in the proceedings. He also made it clear to the gathering that theCommittee was responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meetingcovering all the concerns raised during the public hearing.

He then opened the Public Hearing after due permission from the AdditionalCollector. He invited the Project proponent to give their introduction and tomake the presentation of their project.

Dr. Mahendrabhai Sadariya on behalf of the company welcomed the gathering.Thereafter power point presentation in Gujarati language covering introductionof the company, product profile, technical information, details of proposedproject, Environmental Management System, its impact on environment alongwith proposed mitigation measures and Industry,s activities towards SocialResponsibilities was presented.

After the presentation by the project proponent, Regional Officer, cpCB withthe due permission of the Additional Collector opened the forum forrepresentations/ suggestions /objections from the locally affected people,

The statement showing issues/suggestions /objections/opinion raised by theparticipants during public hearing and also submitted in writing and respondedto by the representative of the applicant during the public hearing is as under:

Sr. No. Name Issue raised Response made byproponenr

I. Shri Jayesh R, Patel-vil, : Lalpar

He informed thatindustrial development iswelcomed.

. He inquired aboutgreen belt forexisting plant andthat afterexpansron.

. Projectinformed

proponena

existing greendevelopment

thatbelt

tsabout 2000 squaremeter and it will beextended upto3840 square meteri.e 33olo of the totalra no.

2. Shri Babulal OdhavjiAd roja -vil. : Old Jambudia

. He inquired aboutthe companyactivities relatedto the safety.

. Project proponentinformed thatcompany is givingsafety belt, handgloves, face mask.Company is alsodoing the healthcheck up of theworker reaularlv.

Shri J. K Vyas, Regional officer, cpCB, Rajkot and Representative of theMember Secretary, GPCB informed the forum that written representations werereceived from Mr. lvlahesh pandya-paryavaran Mitra, Ahmedabad which wouldbe included in the proceedings alongwith the reply of project proponent. Thesame are enclosed as Annexure Q1 along with the replies submitted by theproject proponent as Annexure A1 resOectivelV.

Chairman of the public hearing has given the following suggestion.. To check up the health of workers quarterly.

He concluded the Public Hearing after appreciating the participation of thevillagers in this Public Hearing and thanking them for the same.

The Public Hearing was concluded with the

4z\Place:- Old JambudiyaDist. :- RajkotDatet- 04/05/2012

Maf{oj 14akwana

nKs.

J. K. VyasRegional Officer,

GPCB Rajkotas Representative of

the 14ember Secretary.GPCB

Additional CollectorSaurashtra Kutchha

(Irri.) Rajkot

qRar€- dl (cJ"?rdl)

ctls gatcrr0ri qtct A"ue 11,,sa{rc(lr,rl srrr gotqrD.ct tar r4a Ul*sa{ U[iQtll ctrtr+tu<trrl r,nQ.et grErte.

a{r?d r{?5r?dt uqlq?er i{a cr.r }iareq,.tdl Cdcc{l4r utrr{is, rl.u.r,l.. rrt:g. at.\a /oe/?oog r,{a r,{"qa gt{er uta<r 1n$?5{is {+{.r4f. 3090 (u), crr. ol,/l/?ooc,!lct{ "Q' qi ?arq{l dc{t{e, l. Qet AAiqu, ud "i. aezQ4[, gat ticl{at, atcjsr,qtc{i, [iccr], ?r"s-le qra (r) dQi]s eftetr 2ooooo "iqt u.{l qr+r (2) RAallrfc{.sLtJs 1B.r-:rs lQs a< u{i {+t r{a (3) let{da lUlc{.:ujs iBa- zs lQsaot V[a {u{.u.6.,rre.r r{r)"[ qQc uQulv<t r,rd a]t gat+eft"1 r,{rq].r.r.t,o4/ost2o1?.tt l-Iz rr:oo gc.rL! ur[Qs rasar s[ l{a].jr qgc{rerr - {1?r\i srrg (Rqrd)rttr-Ie"{l Lr,r}r,r $oar arr'tqr{i ?,{rQe.

r{l *. }. .ars, vtdGls ur[QEr{|, cJy?rd uQrrRr Saiaqr <,r]S-rtrile r,ri uc<r n(eqg{lcJv?td uRuqt Saiaer o{13"u qRAO A cits g<tcre0rri 6q(A.r u1i r,{tqst?_rl ?4e.

d.r4t6.A. "llla[g]et.i r,ract,r QOu *ctclrttr,rl r,ri a1s g<L<e[ uldqr r,ic] qrR.{l qrr0,RRql qfS arrt r,u a1s qar.reftdl c,r,.sl{l qR(A l{t} rEtfas lhs .r,i{t.r ua]qi r.lru0{? ?,{{la sr.u{i .,{rQar tr$rta dol qqr rttfdc{l i,{r{l. qq{i iq]rl tr.leta s{l }+ter "rlldQ}rt"i"0 *crquJ r,r"Jup lra lpufig u.+r?qhl a]s-l ut qaL.reftri ulerrlelt.t s{l rtsQl, *al srdcu$l "itlr{i utla srqtqi ur.ril. ir,rlrl +u\aat s{ } Ueaalsqaeeft aQR qatclet €,?]eu.r ?V erla 6a{l erlc-0 c,uqafi r,uq{l a6a sr{.lt{i.ertr grqt r{r} t %.c{rqetr B.

dlt?o{tE a}{ql r{Qs sdsarr{I"ft q?qr4cfts{l a1s qatee{la1 Uiar se . iql{ Ul*rauql"t"ai{la il.[t qQ.t qR?.r]vat Oal Nu[as o{r{r{i :nG(i rV seqt zeuQc-t.

Au{ l. Qet dtl.iqu adl sl. ){g"qa{rd ueflqt stet, 6u(Ad rr{C rqtrtd s?qrr{rr,{tq. d{t?o{e uq? ul.rja? leaetd .{3 U{td 6d{e4 Qit qir.ri teuqj. r,ri 3.q.tt"{l)eRsa {t[.3[4, Gcqrea ]icldl {rtb[i, qQcr qRq]vdr"{l {tQ{[i, qe{c{?qr"i[ c"1cr*€lLr..i

uu{R, a"ft i{ ?-I r,{a q[Qa Raiaeit,6urq] aet ttrqrQs "cuo{er{

ua.a.ft ctRAO?,{l

drl .srtt rta aa "e[c"].

uftse uql4"a fl?l ?Tr,{rcr rlel uar oue urt.Gls q0srfl, qv?rd vqqqt haiaer qlS

strt r{[Qs sdsarsft"{l .{rqt4cftd leuQg rls.ecltrt a}1"[l rl(tralzcitrulzqual ru]riu r4ccj 5sctut utcg.

ctls qateeft e?lrltot €tv? e$ct ctlsl sLet ?t s?c-l.r{l r+Lda ualzciutu qualz{.t.arLut r4titett"tt URRIu 6tat wrrcrrr+i rrQct UcEd?-I "[a l"do{ B,

9r{ aLrr ui +teati e"q sla jeeLzd0aui

?TqLa

Sqdl atrt ?,r\{tlc-r

U(Ert?

,{t iraera{roqte.qla-atatqe

i{el zeu.a1} re1ulcfls

ldsttt ?,{tctst?i D.

ittQt ytlt ! otct{r

Sac cj[.t Qce

OgsLdct d r,ri<{(dur{t }acrf cj[.r

Qce [dge[c{i t

3q"{ldt

via"{ltlhl

"errcg} €tar{r

zooo ql.r{I. {tcjlqdca d r,riii :a+o ql.{L

gd fdru<cr1r,{t? lt"t B. *Y{14.( 33%

*aq uit.? s{t o{rqatat

r4ltrq!)a{r6

ur<ltr-3ar

tirl0ar

ir+e1 rjol ! ige{lttstlt 8?dt {tqtulailqA {r} eJ e1 qlaur

r,{tlcttl{L ?4td DZ

3u4at

uh"{ltllayrrcgl tsa{{r5t{ 8?.tL

sr{errli il#tdce,.srE r+lrr,!+(

4t?5 ?Atqclt{r.

tud D. iqt+tt{qia} ieE

Qs i4q

8?tctctt{t l,{ta

b.

q{l i. }. eru, utdGls r,r0rt{l, cj??rcr uR\er Reiaer c,{]S-rrvsfa r,ri uear +tQ.rr{l

cjt?rd uQqqr [ieiaet q]S"n ulaRQ A qg{i qleqa verq } a1s qatcreft r,r"atr a[L

{.lcraro Usqr, q?rlqret [da, r,r,{erqre aegell ag-uta rrdet E. r{r r"(t{ai i{gul*se uul"t"edt vq-trc1 stelcrdl alt{r{r nr{tdet s?cn4i i,{rc{01. I ultl {iarsg- -r afl} r+i trr.ft neL Q0ar{i qtQa tqrq Qiae rl-r a{} (dstqr E}c.t E.

afs g.tctqt"tt r,ttaraa{lQ "{ll ta[.qt Uruelat qua s]4.

. 3u"[:{t srrl sear srletilq er aqt Hti. $ca Qs uu srtcq.

uia{ s{l 8. }. .:uu, utdGls r,rQst{, clver.t uRuqr Aaiaqr clS-rrrsfa ?,{i {a.ittQqtll cJrr?tct vQqet A?iaer c, S.u uRROA q6]o{l ?iuqrl.t( .srna t&e c1t}rrr" alr+rotte{"{l a1s q+Leeft 1el tr.}e sla.

f In."tE(^: Vau tiqEl?ngcAr ?tt5la

ru{u, o+/os/zotz

8. 3. .atn

urlGIg r{[0st{1, U.{l.r{1.0,{t.,

ttt6la, noer r+Qcr,

u.{1.{t.6,{t.4 UAAO

q[Qg gQser

1?r\i 3a$(G[quJ)

etts-Ia

Annexure-a

List of team member involve in the EIA report

Sr.

No.

Name Qualification Position Contribution Experience

1. Dr. Mahendra Sadaria

Ph.D. Director Coordinator & In-house

expert for AQ, AP & SHW

22 years

2. Mr. Satish Borad B.E. Civil Empanel

expert

Land Use (LU)

expert

22 years

3. Mr. Mehul Panchal B.E. Chemical In-house

expert

Expert (WP) 5 years

4. Rajesh Solanki B.E. Environment In-house

expert

Expert (WP, AP, RH &

SHW)

9 years

5. Mr. Paresh Poriya (under guidance of Dr. Indra Gadhavi)

M.Sc. (Zoology) In-house

expert

Expert (EB) 3 years

6. Mr. P.K. Shrivastava

B. Tech

(Chemical)

Empanel

expert

Expert (RH) 40 years

7. Mr. Nirzar Lakhia M.Sc., PGD Empanel expert

Expert (HG & GEO)

11 years

8. Mr. C. Lal M.Sc. Empanel expert

Expert (SC) 22 years

9. Dr. Rupabhai Malakiya

Ph.D. Empanel expert

Expert (SE) 12 years

Annexure-b

Break up of Water consumption & wastewater generation

Sr.

No.

Source Water Consumption, Lt/Day

Existing Proposed Total

1. Domestic 1000 2000 3000

2. Gardening 1500 500 2000

3. Industrial

Process Nil Nil Nil

Boiler 1500 3500 5000

Cooling make up Nil 2000 2000

Total Industrial 1500 5500 7000

TOTAL (1 +2 + 3) 4000 8000 12000

Sr.

No.

Source Wastewater Generation, Lt/Day

Existing Proposed Total

1. Domestic 800 1700 2500

2. Gardening Nil Nil Nil

3. Industrial

Process Nil 4500 4500

Boiler 100 400 500

Cooling make up 00 1000 1000

Total Industrial 100 5900 6000

TOTAL (1 +2 + 3) 900 7600 8500

Annexure-c

Copy of CC&A and compliance report of consent and

authorization

COMPLIANCE REPORT of

Consolidated Consent & Authorization Consent Order No. AWH- 43478 Date of issue 12/09/2011

Sr. No.

Condition Compliance Status

SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITION 1. M/s. Bell Laminates is situated at Survey No. 88/p, 8/A National

Highway, Old Jambudiya-363642, Tal: Morbi, Dist: Rajkot. The consent shall be valid upto 03/06/2016 for use of outlet for the discharge of trade effluent & emission due to operation of industrial plant for the manufacture of the following products/items:

Sr. No.

Product Qty MT/Month

1. Laminated sheet 7000

Complied,

We will not take

production more than consented capacity.

2. Specific Conditions for Laminate Sheets unit

2.1 The applicant shall strictly adhere comply with CTE (NOC) conditions and for not to manufacture of Resin product without prior obtaining EC/CTE (NOC) amendment of the Board.

We are not producing resins and

maintain till obtain

EC/CTE and CCA.

2.2 The applicant shall not change the manufacturing process/ capacity without valid CTE (NOC)/amended CCA of the Board.

Follow the condition

3. CONDITIONS UNDER THE WATER ACT :

3.1 The quantity of the industrial effluent generated from the factory shall not exceed 100 lit/day. From the factory shall be “Nil” as the generated effluent completely reused after treatment or Evaporators.

Complied, no

wastewater generation

3.2 The quantity of the industrial effluent discharged from the factory shall be “Nil” as the generated effluent from the Roll Washing shall be evaporated in steam Jecketed evaporation system.

Complied, no

wastewater generation

3.2 The quantity of sewage effluent from the factory shall not exceed 100 lit/day.

Complied Not exceed the quantity

3.3 Domestic effluent shall be disposed off through septic tank/soak pit system.

Complied

4 CONDITIONS UNDER THE AIR ACT 1981:

4.1 The following shall be used as fuel in Boiler & T.F.H. respectively. Sr. No. Fuel Quantity

1. Lignite 20 MT/day

Complied

4.2 The applicant shall install & operate air pollution control system in order to achieve Norms prescribed below.

Complied

4.3 Flue gas emission through stack attached to Boiler & T.F.H. shall conform to the following standards:

Sr. No.

Stack Attached

to

Stack Height in

Meter

Air Pollution Control System

Parameter Permissible Limit

Complied

1. Boiler & T.F.H.

30 (common

stack)

Cyclone Separator

Particulate matter

SO2 NOx

150mg/NM3

100 ppm 50 ppm

4.4 There shall be no process emission from the manufacturing and other ancillary operations.

Complied

4.5 The concentration of the following parameters in the ambient air within the premises of the industry shall not exceed the limits specified hereunder.

Parameter Permissible Limit Annual

Permissible Limit 24 hrs average

Particulate Matter-10 (PM10)

60 Microgram per cubic meter

100 Microgram per cubic meter

Particulate Matter-2.5 (PM2.5)

40 Microgram per cubic meter

60 Microgram per cubic meter

SO2 50 Microgram per cubic meter

80 Microgram per cubic meter

NOx 40 Microgram per cubic meter

80 Microgram per cubic meter

Complied Follow the

norms

4.6 The applicant shall provide portholes, ladder, platforms etc at chimney(s) for monitoring the air emissions and the same shall be open for inspection to/and for use of Board’s staff. The chimney(s) vents attached to various sources of emission shall be designed by numbers such as S-1, S-2, etc. and these shall be painted/ displayed to facilitate identification.

Complied

4.7 The industry shall take adequate measures for control of noise levels from its own sources within the premises so as to maintain ambient air quality standards in respect of noise to less than 75 dB(A) during day time and 70 dB (A) during night time. Daytime is reckoned I between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. and nighttime is reckoned between 10 p.m. and 6 a.m.

Complied

5 General Conditions

5.1 Any change in personnel, equipment or working conditions as mentioned in the Consents form/order should immediately be intimated to this Board.

Noted and agreed

5.2 Applicant shall also comply with the general conditions given in annexure-I.

Follow the conditions

5.3 Industry shall have to display on-line data outside the main factory gate with regard to quantity and nature of hazardous chemicals being handled in the plant including wastewater and air emissions and solid hazardous waste generated within the factory premises.

Complied

5.4 Industry shall have to display the relevant information with regard to hazardous waste as indicated in the Hon. Supreme order in w.p. no. 657 of 1995 dated 14th October 2003.

Complied

6. Applicant shall strictly adhere with dully notarized taking that unit is not covered under Hazardous Waste (M, H & Trans boundary Movement) Rules-2008.

6.1 In addition to above terms and conditions Industry shall also comply following directives issued by the Supreme Court of India dated 14.10.2003.

Complied

a) Industry shall have to display the relevant information with regard to hazardous waste indicated in the Court’s order in W.P. No. 657 of 1995 dated 14th October 2003.

Follow the condition

b) Industry shall have to display on-line data outside the main factory Follow the

gate with regard quantity and nature of hazardous chemicals being handled in the plant including wastewater and air emission and solid hazardous wastes generated within the factory premises.

condition

Annexure-d

Copy of GPCB visit

GPCB has visited the unit twice but not take any air or water samples.

Annexure-e

Show cause notice/closure order