37
Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline: Shock Acceleration Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration Application to simple cases Astroparticle Physics : Fermi’s Theories of Shock Acceleration - II

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline: Shock Acceleration Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Pratik MajumdarSINP, Kolkata

Outline: Shock Acceleration Fermi’s theory of 2nd and

1st order acceleration Application to simple cases

Astroparticle Physics : Fermi’s Theories of Shock Acceleration - II

Page 2: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Reading Materials

• Longair : High Energy Astrophysics • T. Stanev : High Energy Cosmic Rays• T. Gaisser : Particle Physics and Cosmic rays

• Many review articles on the subject

Page 3: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Acceleration of Cosmic Rays

Man-made accelerators

No.

of

part

icle

s

Energy

Page 4: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Electromotive Acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 5: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Shock acceleration mechanism(by Enrico Fermi)

Predicts a E-2.0 spectrum

Particles (electrons and hadrons) get scattered many times in shock front and gain energy in each cycle (TeV energies several 100 years)

No

. of p

art

icle

s

Energy

Power law spectrum

Max. Energy about 1015 eVEfficiency ~ 10%, needed forCR from SNR

Emax

Random B-Field

SNR

Page 6: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Fermi Acceleration

Stochastic MechanismCharged particles

collide with clouds in ISM and

are reflected from irregularities

in galactic magnetic field

2nd order

Charged particles can be accelerated to high

energies in astrophysical shock

fronts1st order acceleration

Page 7: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Shocks

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Shock wave propagating through aStationary gas at supersonic velocity U

Flow of gas in a reference frame In which the shock front is stationary

Energy flux througha surface normal to v

Momentum flux through shock wave

Page 8: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Shock Conditions Solutions

• Solve for shock in perfect gas. • Enthalpy =

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 9: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Shock Conditions Contd….

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

For monatomic gas : show that ¿ 4

Heating of gas takes place

Page 10: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 11: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 12: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Acceleration theory, Contd…

• Probability of escape : Pesc after k encounters, so prob of remaining in the source : (1 – Pesc )k

• So, no. of encounters needed to reach E

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 13: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Acceleration Theory Contd…

• No. of particles accelerated to energies > E after k interactions :

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 14: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 15: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

What did we learn ???

• Now Pesc = Tcycle/Tesc

• acceleration /escape : prob per encounter of escape frpm

acceleration region

After acceleration for time t,

•n max = t/Tcycle, So, E E0 (1+)t/Tcycle

• Higher energy particles take longer time to accelerate

Let’s apply these to some specific astrophysical cases…… Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 16: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 17: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 18: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 19: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 20: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 21: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 22: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 23: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Fermi 1st Order Acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 24: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Fermi 1st Order Acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 25: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 26: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Basic Phenomenology of Acceleration

• Let us consider strong shock : SNR exploding into a medium.

• HE particles front and behind the shock• Shock velocity << velocity of particles• Particles get scattered : vel. Distribution

become isotropic on either side of shock

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 27: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Upstream

Up -> Down and vice versa : increase in energy, increment of same order

Page 28: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

An example : SNR explosion• Frequency of SuperNovae explosions:

f = 1 SN / (30 - 70) yr• Typical Kinetic energy of the ejected mass:

K ~ 1051 erg• Typical mass:

M = 10 solar masses (20 1033 g)• Power emitted in the form of kinetic energy:

W = K f = 1051 erg /(30 3 107 s) ~1042 erg/s• Speed of shock front:

V = (2K/M)1/2 ~ 3 108 cm/s• One can roughly assume that the shock front gets

“extinguished” when the mass of the ejecta reach a density equal to the average interstellar density (IG ~ 1 p/cm3 = 1.6 10-24 g/cm3):SN=M/Volume=M/(4/3R3)= IG Volume R ~ 1.4 1019 cm ~ 5

pc• How long does it take to extinguish the accelerator

(time of free expansion of the ejecta)?Tacc = R/V ~ 1000 years (NB these are just “typical” order of

magnitude numbers…)

Page 29: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Maximum energy from shock acceleration

• The energy gain per collision (cfr. Exercise):– E = 4/3 V/c E = E with ~10-2

• If we know the typical time in between two consecutive collisions Tcycle, the maximum number of possible collision is on average:– Ncollisions = Tacc/Tcycle with Tacc as calculated before

• And the maximum reachable energy is:– Emax = E Ncollisions = E Tacc/Tcycle

• Tcycle (or also the shock front crossing-time) depends on the shock velocity V and the mean free path for magnetic scattering of the particles s

– Tcycle = s / V

• On the other hand, acceleration can only continue if the particle if confined, that means that s < gyroradius (E/ZeB, Ze charge of the particle, B magnetic field ~ 3 G), which leads to: – Emax ~ 4/3 ZeB/c V2 Tacc ~ 300 Z [TeV]

Page 30: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Backup Slides

Page 31: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Summer Lectures, DESY, August 25 Berlin

Energy Spectrum : Simplified Case

• E = bkE0, average energy of particles after k collisions

• N = PkN0, Pk is prob. that the particle remains within the acceleration region after k collisions

N/No = (E/E0)lnP/lnb

N(E)dE = const. E -1+ lnP/lnb dE b = 1 + DE/E = 1 + 4V/3c P = 1 – U/c …… N(E)dE ~ E-2dE

Page 32: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Rate of acceleration • For a large plane shock, rate of

encounters is given by projection of an isotropic cosmic ray flux on plane shock front. Can be shown : cρCR/4

• Acceleration rate is dE/dt = xE/Tcycle

• It can be shown : Tcycle = 4/c (k1/u1 + k2/u2)

u1 = fluid velocity (-ve) relative to shock front, for downstream region : average the residence time of those particles which do not escape.

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 33: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Rate of Acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 34: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

SNR Parameters

• Mean ejecta speed : v = (2ESN/Mej)1/2

• Radius swept away : R = (3Mej/4Pr)1/3

• Sweep time : t0 = R/v

• ISM density : r = 1.4mpnh

Page 35: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 36: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012

Page 37: Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012 Pratik Majumdar SINP, Kolkata Outline:  Shock Acceleration  Fermi’s theory of 2 nd and 1 st order acceleration

How does the spectrum look like ?

Post MSc lectures, SINP, December 2012