5/17/2011

1

Municipal & Stakeholder Committee MeetingsStudy Team Presentation

Farmingdale Public Library

February 26, 2009

Develop a public consensus on where the next generation of residents could be housed, the transportation systems needed to support these settlement patterns, and the actions needed to insure that prosperity is broadly and equitably shared.

OBJECTIVE

Evaluate alternative futures by “Triple Bottom Line:”Economic ProsperitySocial EquityEnvironmental Health and Sustainability

LONG ISLAND PRECEDENCEBuilding on Existing Long Island Efforts

County Visioning & Master Plans

Local Municipal Visioning & Master

Plans

Large Scale Visioning &

Planning

LI 2035 Sustainability Plan & Visioning

Initiative

LONG ISLAND 2035 VISIONINGHow it Works

Public Values & Goals

Analysis of Existing Trends

Public Workshops to Develop Alternative

Scenarios

Scenario Evaluation

Building Consensus for Implementation

SUCCESS IN OTHER REGIONSSelected Visioning Solutions

“2% Solution”: Changes in small amount of land has led to successful demonstration projects for over a dozen communities

Southern California: SCAG Compass Blueprint

Development of regional housing plans: implementation underway in nine communities

Chicago: Metropolis 2020

EXAMPLES FROM LI & NY METRO REGION

County & Multi-municipal Scale Visioning

Eastern Long Island: SEEDS

Orange County, NY

Some set Co nt NJSomerset County, NJ

5/17/2011

2

SUCCESS IN OTHER REGIONSLocal Implementation of Strategies

BEFORE

Glenbrook in Stamford, CT

SUCCESS IN OTHER REGIONSLocal Implementation of Strategies

RENDERING OF COMMUNITY VISION

Glenbrook in Stamford, CT

LI 2035 VISIONINGPotential Outcomes for Long Island

Accelerated implementation of existing plans and visions

Full benefits of infrastructure projects currently underway

Multi-municipal cooperative action

Additional workforce housing and jobs in transit-accessible locales

Transportation investmentsp

Enhanced open space, recreation and quality-of- life

On-going planning and implementation at regional, county and local levels

LI Sustainability Plan NYMTC RTPLocal zoning &

development projectsNassau & Suffolk

Master Plans

PHASE I PRODUCTS1. Guiding Principles & Evaluation Benchmarks

Job Growth & Distribution

Travel Characteristics

EconomicSuccess

EnvironmentalResponsibility

SocialEquity

Housing Mix & Supply

Energy Consumption & Pollution

Land Use & Open Space

Population Growth & Diversity

Triple Bottom Line

PHASE I PRODUCTS2. Maps, Projections and Reports to Demonstrate

Implications of Current Trends

PHASE I PRODUCTS3. Visioning Workshop

Use base map to accurately depict conditions on the ground

Determine where not to grow

Allocate growth in chosen development scenario

Determine necessary transportation improvements

5/17/2011

3

PHASE I PRODUCTS4. Develop and Evaluate Alternative Scenarios

600,000

700,000

Daily Non-Automobile TripsFrom Louisiana Speaks Visioning effort

37,30025,50015,300

660,000

388,000

208,800

0

100,000

200,000

300,000

400,000

500,000

Option A Option B Option C

Walk/Bike Trips

Transit Trips

PHASE I PRODUCTS5. Final Report

Areas of Consensus

Recommendations for Immediate Actions

Recommendations for Future Steps:Recommendations for Future Steps:Determine whether and how to proceed with full-scale visioning process

Select corridors or growth areas for in-depth scenario analysis

Target issues for further development and consensus-building

DISCUSSION

MARCH 26 VISIONING WORKSHOPDetails

March 26, 2009, 9:00am-12:15pm

Melville Marriott, Melville, NY

ParticipantsParticipantsMunicipal Elected Officials

Business, Community, Environmental Stakeholders

Goal: For participants to create alternative scenarios by allocating development to different locations

MARCH 26 VISIONING WORKSHOPLong Island in 2035

(Data source: NYMTC)

Nassau County:

population + 154,000

jobs + 104,000

Suffolk County:

population + 307,000

jobs + 244,000

Where will they go?

MARCH 26 VISIONING WORKSHOPDevelopment types

5/17/2011

4

Sample AreaLand Use

BUILDING THE MODELFrom Land Use to Development Type

Sample AreaLand Use – With Grid Overlay

BUILDING THE MODELFrom Land Use to Development Type

Sample AreaDevelopment Types

BUILDING THE MODELFrom Land Use to Development Type

3,4

Suburban

Large Lot Suburban

Mixed-Use Area

INITIAL FINDINGSPercent of Land Island-wide in 2007

Civ i c 3%

U npro tected Ope n Space 14%

Pro te cte d Open Space 12%

Farm 4%

Transpo r ta tio n 2%

Educati on 1%Hospi ta l <1%

Mi xe d-use 1%

Pr ote cte d F arm 1%Uti l i ty 1%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Smal l lo t 18%

Me di um l o t 15%

Lar ge l ot 18%

Str i p co mmerci al 3%

Industr i al 3%

Esta te 1%

Mul ti - fami l y 1%Offi ce 1%

Mal l 1%

Educati on 1%Hospi ta l 1%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

INITIAL FINDINGSDevelopment Types by Town in 2007

Babylon

Glen Cove

Oyster Bay

Hempstead

Long Beach

North Hempstead

Small lot

Medium lot

Large lot

Estate

Multi-family

Mall

Strip commercial

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

East Hampton

Shelter Island

Southold

Southampton

Riverhead

Brookhaven

Islip

Smithtown

Huntington Office

Industrial

Hospital

Education

Civic

Mixed-use

Unprotected Open Space

Protected Open Space

Farm

Protected Farm

Utility

Transportation

5/17/2011

5

INITIAL FINDINGSPopulation by Development Type in 2007

Babylon

Glen Cove

Oyster Bay

Hempstead

Long Beach

North Hempstead

Small lot

Medium lot

Large lot

Estate

Multi-family

Farm

Hospital

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

East Hampton

Shelter Island

Southold

Southampton

Riverhead

Brookhaven

Islip

Smithtown

Huntington

y p

Industrial

Mixed-use

Office

Open Space

Utility

Transportation

Strip commercial

Mall

Civic

Education

MARCH 26 VISIONING WORKSHOPCreating alternative scenarios

Population data

Employment data

Development type chips

Large lot single family

Small lot single family

Various infill

Strip redevelopment

POST WORKSHOP PRODUCTION

Construct the alternative scenarios chosen by workshop participants

Test feasibility and outcome with indicators (below)

Produce final report

Housing Mix & Supply Energy Consumption & Pollution

Land Use & Open Space

Population Growth & Diversity

Job Growth & Distribution

Travel Characteristics

Impacts by race, age & income

Indicators

MARCH 26 VISIONING WORKSHOPPlease participate

March 26, 2009, 9:00am-12:15pm

Melville Marriott, Melville, NY

ParticipantsParticipantsMunicipal Elected Officials

Business, Community, Environmental Stakeholders

Goal: For participants to create alternative scenarios by allocating development to different locations