8/12/2019 Predators_ The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/predators-the-cias-drone-war-on-al-qaeda 1/3

27/2/2014 Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://smallwarsjournal.com/print/15052

Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on alQaeda

 By Evan Kalikow

Journal Article | Dec 21 2013 - 10:12am

Predators in Perspective

Dr. Brian Glyn William Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda, Potomac Books Inc., 2013, 256 pg., $29.95.

Reviewed by Evan Kalikow

After Amazon’s CEO Jeff Bezos announced the company’s plans to start delivering packages via drones by 2015,

the subject of drones was once again thrust into the public spotlight. And once again, the drone debate was framed

as a binary choice: one either supports the use of drones or one opposes them. A topic of such fundamental

importance like drones certainly deserves a more nuanced discussion.

Fortunately, Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda, the newest book by Dr. Brian Glyn Williams of the

University of Massachusetts--Dartmouth, treats the topic with the care it deserves. Over the course of the book’s

11 chapters, Williams takes an even-handed approach, providing invaluable history and context to frame the

arguments both in favor of and against current US drone policy. The book is roughly divided into two halves: the

first details the history of Pakistan and the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) from the mid-20 th  century

to present day and how the landscape of the United States’ relationship with the region has changed, while the

second discusses the benefits, consequences, and future challenges associated with the ongoing American drone

campaign.

By focusing his research and analysis of drone warfare on al Qaeda in Pakistan and the FATA region, Williams

accomplishes two integral things. First, he narrows the scope of his argument and allows himself the time and

space to go into more depth than he would were he to do a more overarching analysis of drone warfare by including

other drone hotspots such as Yemen and Somalia (Williams does discuss Yemen briefly later, but the focus is clearly

Pakistan). This also allows Williams to focus only on al Qaeda; were Yemen to be featured more prominently, al

8/12/2019 Predators_ The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/predators-the-cias-drone-war-on-al-qaeda 2/3

27/2/2014 Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://smallwarsjournal.com/print/15052

Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) would necessarily need to be analyzed as well.  Predators is an overall

stronger piece through its focused commitment to one region and organization.

The second thing accomplished by this focus is its reframing of the drone debate. Rather than seeing drones as a

technological choice (i.e., “Should we as a country be using drones?”), Williams recognizes that the technology will

not be leaving anytime soon and chooses to discuss the larger strategic issue; whether or not they are effective in

this instance (i.e. ,“Should we as a country be using drones to fight al Qaeda?). This is a much more worthwhile

and productive debate to be had, and a book like this one has the potential to advance the public conversation about

drones.

 Predators, however, is not without its flaws. While it has much to offer for newcomers into issues surrounding

drone warfare and specifically the US’s drone campaign against al Qaeda in Pakistan, readers who are already well-

versed in these topics will find little new. To wit, the latter half of the book, which focuses primarily on issues

surrounding the drone warfare policy, is not quite as strong as the book’s first half, which details the history of the

complex and fascinating relationship between the United States and Pakistani governments, as well as the evolution

of targeted killing campaigns in the region. Readers hoping to be introduced to the policy issues that complicate

drone warfare in Pakistan will find much to appreciate in Predators, but those who have been exposed to previous

literature by authors such as Micah Zenko, Audrey Kurth Cronin, and Steve Coll may leave wanting more.

That said, there are some noteworthy revelations in Predators. In particular, Williams reveals that drone policies are

 beginning to be more accepted among civilians, quoting a “tribal militia commander” in Yemen as saying, “Ordinary people have become very practical about drones. If the United States focuses on the leaders and civilians aren’t

killed, then drone strikes will hurt al Qaeda more than they help them.” (pg. 204). This quote and some polls cited in

the later chapters of the book suggest that opposition to drones may be stronger among pundits and policy

advocates than those more directly involved.

Overall, though, Predators is a book that understands that the premise underlying the “Are you pro- or anti-drone?”

question is false. Drones are here to stay, and the technological and logistical advantages provided by them are

impossible to deny. What can change, however, is how they are used to coherently pursue a given policy and

supporting strategy. Williams presents arguments both in favor and against current usage policies, allowing the

reader to draw his/her own conclusions.  Predators offers hope that the future of drone debates will focus more on

the policy surrounding the way the drones are used and less on their very existence. And since the book weighsfewer than 8 pounds, it will be eligible for drone delivery via Amazon in a few years.

Rating:Your rating: None Average Rating: 5  ( 1 vote)

About the Author

Evan Kalikow

Mr. Evan Kalikow is a research associate at the Institute for National Strategic Studies at

 National Defense University (NDU). This review reflects his position and not that of the NDUor U.S. Government.

Available online at : http://smallwarsjournal.com/jrnl/art/predators-the-cia% E2% 80% 99s-drone-war-on-al-qaeda

Links:

{1} http://smallwarsjournal.com/author/evan-kalikow

{2} http://i.cfr.org/content/publications/attachments/Drones_CSR65.pdf 

{3} http://www.iiss.org/en/publications/adelphi/by%20year/2007-d5f5/ending-terrorism--lessons-for-defeating-al-

qaeda-a908

8/12/2019 Predators_ The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/predators-the-cias-drone-war-on-al-qaeda 3/3

27/2/2014 Predators: The CIA’s Drone War on al Qaeda

http://smallwarsjournal.com/print/15052

{4} http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/books/2013/05/06/130506crbo_books_coll

Copyright © 2014, Small Wars Foundation.

Select uses allowed by Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 3.0 license per our Terms of Use.

Please help us support the Small Wars Community.