Presentation Leadership Profiling 29 July Review

8/6/2019 Presentation Leadership Profiling 29 July Review

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/presentation-leadership-profiling-29-july-review 1/13



Defence Institute of Psychological Research

To identify the critical features of successful military leaders

To prepare pr ofile of the leaders as motivat ors (individual

f ocused)

To prepare an integrated pr ofile of leaders as motivat ors(attribute f ocused) t o facilitate modelling in cadets

AIMS OF TH E S T UDY

Field Marshal S H F J Manekshaw

Marshal of the Air F orce Arjan Singh




ME TH OD

Blend of narrative analysis and c ontent analysis

Identifying research questi on:

To identify the critical features of successful military

leaders Devel o ping analytical c onstructs:

Leadership perf ormance

Identifying useful indices:

Inclusi on index: Leadership characteristics

Exclusi on index: Negative traits

Steps F oll owed




Choosing a sample or samples:

Interview excerpts, Speeches, Written texts, Articles,

Inf ormati on on WWW

Establishing the relevant c ontext of the sample:

Leadership effectiveness

Choosing a specific appr oach:

T hematic analysis and semantic analysis

Determining po pulati on:

Interviews, Bi ographies, Books, Newspapers,Magazines, WWW

Method C ontd.




C oding the texts

Presenting the results:

T ables

Defining the unit of analysis:

W ord, w ord sense and theme

Devel o ping c oding rules:

Experts¶ judgements based on thematic and semantic analysis

Method C ontd.




Field Marshal Sam Hormushji Framjee Jamshedji Manekshaw

A PEEP INTO THE PERSONALITY

Nick Name Sam Bahadur

Date & Place of Birth

3rd April 1914, Amritsar, Punjab

Date & Place of Parting

27th June 2008, Wellington, Tamil Nadu

Resting Place Ooty, Tamil Nadu

Allegiance British Raj (till 1947) and India (after 1947)

Years of Service 1934-1973 (39 years)

Battles/wars World war II, Indo-Pak wars (1947, 1965 & 1971), Sino-Indian war

Awards Padma Vibhushan, Padma Bhushan and Military Cross

"You received three at this age; when I was of your age, I received

nine bullets and look- today, I am the Commander-in-Chief of the

Indian Army." - During the 1971 Indo-Pakistan War when he met an

injured soldier in army hospital with three bullet wounds.




Marshal of Air Force Arjan Singh

Place of Birth Lyallpur, Punjab, British India

Date of Birth 15th April 1919

Allegiance India

Years of Service 1938 - Present

Commands held World war II Battle Squadron, Operational, Western Air,AOC-in-C of operational, DCAS, VCAS

Battles/wars World war II and Indo-Pak war (1965)

Awards Padma Vibhushan and Distinguished Flying Cross (DFC)

³On the day I retired, I had jumped into cockpit of MIG 21 to fly a

fighter last time. I knew that the IAF won¶t let me fly again´

³He has flown more than 65 aircrafts´

A PEEP INTO THE PERSONALITY




NEX T S T EP OF TH E S T UDY

Pr ofiling of leaders as M otivat ors: Validati on Study of Emerged

Leadership CharacteristicsSample

Seni or service officers who have direct/indirect interacti on with these

leaders

Service officers who are well read about these leaders Service officers who are teaching/taught about these leaders

Media personalities having direct/indirect interacti on with these leaders

Tool

A 5-po

int rating scale c o

nstitutingo

f emerged characteristicso

f eachleader

Analysis

Descriptive statistics

Fact or analysis




Thank You




C ollecti on of inf ormati on

S ources

Sampling of inf ormati on

T hree (3) research fell ows scrutinized these inf ormati on on the

f oll owing criteria:

Repetitiveness

Peripheral

Back




Leadership characteristics identified by expertsLeader Expert Total

1 2 3

Fd Mshl S H F J Manekshaw 85 117 96 298

Mshl of the Air F orce Arjan Singh 104 94 89 287

Identificati on of leadership characteristics

C ollected inf ormati on was distributed amongst three (3 )

experts of psychol ogy. T hey were asked t o identify those

w ords which were descriptive of target leaders.

T hey were also asked t o infer those qualities which c ould

describe the leader in the particular c ontext.




Selecti on of leadership characteristicsT hree (3) different experts were asked t o scrutinize the list on the

bel ow menti oned criteria. Only those w ords were retained where

the maj ority of judges ( T w o or M ore) agreed

Exclusi on criteria:

Negative semantics

Sentences

Leadership characteristics emerged

Fd Mshl S H F J Manekshaw 118

Mshl of the Air F orce Arjan Singh 112 BACK




Clustering/c oding of characteristics on the basis of

semantics

Five (5) judges were asked t o cluster the characteristics

using f oll owing steps:

Each w ord was spoken al oud and all the judges

prepared a cluster of all the characteristics.

Same judges further scrutinized their clusters and

reached on a c onsensusBACK

Documents

Presentation Leadership Profiling 29 July Review