8
Int J Lab Hem. 2017;1–8. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ijlh | 1 © 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd Received: 12 December 2016 | Accepted: 22 May 2017 DOI: 10.1111/ijlh.12705 ORIGINAL ARTICLE Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte parameters by Mindray BC-6800: Reference intervals and comparison with Sysmex XE-5000 M. Buttarello 1 | A. Rauli 2 | G. Mezzapelle 2 1 Department of Laboratory Medicine, Azienda Ospedaliera-Università di Padova, Padova, Italy 2 Clinical Pathology Laboratory, Hospital of Adria, Adria, Italy Correspondence Mauro Buttarello, Department of Laboratory Medicine, Azienda Ospedaliera-Università di Padova, Padova, Italy. Email: [email protected] Abstract Introduction: In this study, analytic performance (imprecision, carryover, time stability) and diagnostic efficiency of Mindray BC-6800 analyzer to quantify reticulocytes and extended reticulocyte parameters was evaluated. Moreover, reference intervals on adult population were determined. Results were compared with those obtained by Sysmex XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic conditions (nutritional anemias before and after treat- ment, hemolytic and posthemorragic anemias, acute and chronic inflammations, malig- nancy under therapy, and beta thalassemia trait) were selected. Results: Reference intervals were as follows: reticulocytes (×10 9 /L): 23.2-93.2; imma- ture reticulocyte fraction: 0.015-0.14; mean reticulocyte hemoglobin equivalent (RHE) (pg): 30.9-35.7; mean reticulocyte volume (fL): 97.8-118. Imprecision on reticulocyte count at all concentrations was close to analytic goal based on within-subject biologi- cal variation. Carryover (2.3%) was negligible, and time-stability was excellent up to 8 hours. Conclusion: When compared with XE-5000, BC-6800 shows a good overall correla- tion on counting despite evidence of difference in the upper limit of reference inter- vals (93.2 vs 101.3). Comparison of diagnostic efficiency of extended parameters shows a good total agreement of RHE (91.6%). KEYWORDS immature reticulocyte fraction, Mindray BC-6800, reference intervals, reticulocyte, reticulocyte hemoglobin content 1 | INTRODUCTION Reticulocyte count is clinically important both for pathophysiological classification of anemias, and for early identification of normalization of erythropoiesis by the marrow after therapeutic intervention (iron, folate, cobalamin, etc.), or as a way of checking early regeneration after marrow or stem cell transplant. Manual microscopic method is rela- tively inaccurate because of the subjective morphological definition of reticulocyte and is very imprecise with a coefficient of variation (CV) between 16% at high level and 68% at low concentration. 1 These lim- itations make the method unreliable above all at low values, that is, in situations in which one must define reduced erythropoietic activity of the marrow (values under the lower limit of the reference interval), or in which small but significant variations that appear in the early re- covery of postaplasia or postmarrow transplant must be monitored. Automated analyzers represent a revolution for reticulocyte count using dyes to bind reticulocyte RNA and flow cytometers to perform rapid counts. These methods allow for objective counts, and because

Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

Int J Lab Hem. 2017;1–8. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ijlh  | 1© 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd

Received:12December2016  |  Accepted:22May2017DOI: 10.1111/ijlh.12705

O R I G I N A L A R T I C L E

Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte parameters by Mindray BC- 6800: Reference intervals and comparison with Sysmex XE- 5000

M. Buttarello1  | A. Rauli2 | G. Mezzapelle2

1DepartmentofLaboratoryMedicine,AziendaOspedaliera-UniversitàdiPadova,Padova,Italy2ClinicalPathologyLaboratory,HospitalofAdria,Adria,Italy

CorrespondenceMauroButtarello,DepartmentofLaboratoryMedicine,AziendaOspedaliera-UniversitàdiPadova,Padova,Italy.Email:[email protected]

AbstractIntroduction: Inthisstudy,analyticperformance(imprecision,carryover,timestability)anddiagnosticefficiencyofMindrayBC-6800analyzertoquantifyreticulocytesandextended reticulocyte parameterswas evaluated.Moreover, reference intervals onadult populationweredetermined.Resultswere comparedwith thoseobtainedbySysmexXE-5000analyzer.Methods: Onehundredandeighty-fourhealthyadultsofbothsexes,and368subjectsaffectedbyvariouspathologicconditions(nutritionalanemiasbeforeandaftertreat-ment,hemolyticandposthemorragicanemias,acuteandchronicinflammations,malig-nancyundertherapy,andbetathalassemiatrait)wereselected.Results: Referenceintervalswereasfollows:reticulocytes(×109/L):23.2-93.2;imma-turereticulocytefraction:0.015-0.14;meanreticulocytehemoglobinequivalent(RHE)(pg):30.9-35.7;meanreticulocytevolume(fL):97.8-118.Imprecisiononreticulocytecountatallconcentrationswasclosetoanalyticgoalbasedonwithin-subjectbiologi-calvariation.Carryover(2.3%)wasnegligible,andtime-stabilitywasexcellentupto8 hours.Conclusion: WhencomparedwithXE-5000,BC-6800showsagoodoverallcorrela-tiononcountingdespiteevidenceofdifferenceintheupperlimitofreferenceinter-vals (93.2 vs 101.3). Comparison of diagnostic efficiency of extended parametersshowsagoodtotalagreementofRHE(91.6%).

K E Y W O R D S

immaturereticulocytefraction,MindrayBC-6800,referenceintervals,reticulocyte,reticulocytehemoglobincontent

1  | INTRODUCTION

Reticulocytecountisclinicallyimportantbothforpathophysiologicalclassificationofanemias,andforearlyidentificationofnormalizationoferythropoiesisbythemarrowaftertherapeutic intervention(iron,folate,cobalamin,etc.),orasawayofcheckingearlyregenerationaftermarrowor stemcell transplant.Manualmicroscopicmethod is rela-tivelyinaccuratebecauseofthesubjectivemorphologicaldefinitionofreticulocyteandisveryimprecisewithacoefficientofvariation(CV)

between16%athighleveland68%atlowconcentration.1 These lim-itationsmakethemethodunreliableaboveallatlowvalues,thatis,insituations inwhich onemust define reduced erythropoietic activityofthemarrow(valuesunderthelowerlimitofthereferenceinterval),orinwhichsmallbutsignificantvariationsthatappearintheearlyre-coveryofpostaplasiaorpostmarrow transplantmustbemonitored.Automated analyzers represent a revolution for reticulocyte countusingdyestobindreticulocyteRNAandflowcytometerstoperformrapidcounts.Thesemethodsallowforobjectivecounts,andbecause

Page 2: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

2  |     BUTTARELLO ET AL.

theyanalyzetensofthousandsofcells,theyreducesamplingerrorandarethereforemoreprecisemainlyatlowvalues(CVbetween3%and25%).2Afurtheradvantageistheidentificationofotherreticulocyteparameters,suchastheimmaturereticulocytefraction(IRF)orthere-ticulocyteindicesthatis,tosay,themeanhemoglobincontent(RHE),andthemeanreticulocytevolume(MRV),whichareusefulinseveralclinical conditions.3-9 Problems still exist that essentially dependonthedifferingsensitivityofdyesusedtostainRNA,onthetechnologyused to identify positive cells (fluorescence, light scattering, absor-bance),andonsoftwaresthataremoreorlesscapableofseparatingreticulocytesfrommatureerythrocytesasthereisaphysiologiccon-tinuumbetween thesepopulations.Thesedifferences contribute totheincompleteagreementofcountswiththeconsequentnecessityofmethod-specificreferenceintervals.2,4

The aim of our studywas to evaluate the analytic performance(imprecision, carry-over, time stability) of the hematology analyzerMindrayBC-6800,andthereference intervalscalculationonreticu-locytecountandreticulocyteparameters.Toevaluatepossibleinter-changeability, the values obtained have been comparedwith thoseobtained by Sysmex XE-5000, our standard equipment, for whichthereisalargeamountofliteratureonclinicalusefulnessofextendedreticulocyteparameters.10-13

2  | MATERIALS AND METHODS

2.1 | Hematology analyzers

2.1.1 | Mindray BC- 6800

MindrayBC-6800(Mindray,Shenzhen,China)isanautomatedhema-tology analyzer able to performa complete blood count (CBC) andleukocytedifferentiation.Itcanalsocountreticulocytesusingadedi-catedchannelwhereafluorescentdye(asymmetriccyanine)canbindtocytoplasmicRNAtoallowforreticulocytesseparationfrommatureredcells.AsfluorescentsignalsareproportionatetotheRNAcontent,theanalyzersubdividesreticulocyteintothreefractionsaccordingtotheirmaturitylevel.IRFisdefinedasthesumofpopulationsathighandmedium immaturity. It alsoprovides,with a forward light scat-termeasure,somereticulocyte indexessimilartothoseforerythro-cytes suchas themean “reticulocytehemoglobinequivalent” (RHE)expressedinpicograms,andtheMRV.

2.2 | Sysmex XE- 5000

TheSysmexXE-5000(Sysmex,Kobe,Japan)isanautomatedanalyzerwhich,inadedicatedchannel,usingafluorescentdye(polymethine),isabletocountreticulocytes.Thecounter,usingaforwardlightscat-termeasureandsidefluorescenceintensity,iscapableofdifferenti-atingreticulocytes fromother redcells, tocalculate the IRF,andtoobtaintheRHE(Ret-He).

Bothanalyzerswerecalibratedaccordingtothemanufacturer’sin-structionsandcheckedtwiceadayusingcommercialtri-levelcontrolprovidedbythecompanies.

2.3 | Samples

Healthy subjects (N=184) were selected in accordance with theH44-A2 specifications to calculate reference intervals.14 Subjectsweremen(N=81)andwomen(N=103)aged19-71(mean44).Theywereexcluded if any laboratory resultsofCBC,markers for liverandrenalfunctions,andironstatus,wereoutsidethereferencein-tervalsusedinour laboratory.Othercriteriaofexclusionwereasfollows: pregnancy, clinical evidence of recentmedical disorders,andblooddonationduringtheprevious6months.Inaddition,sam-ples from368 subjects affectedby various pathologic conditions(nutritionalanemiasbeforeandaftertreatment,hemolyticandpos-themorragicanemias,acuteandchronicinflammations,malignancyunderchemotherapy,andbetathalassemiacarriers)wereanalyzedinfourdifferentdays.Forthepossibleeffectduetothepresenceof red cell inclusions, three sampleswithbasophilic stippling andfivewith Jollybodieswere identified.All sampleswere collectedin themorning, under fasting conditions with the consent of in-formeddonorsbyvenipunctureinto3mLK2EDTAevacuatedtubes(Vacutest,Kima,Italy).Forsomepatients,samplesweretakenfromleftoverbloodcollectedforCBC.Theanalysisonbothinstrumentswasperformed inautomatedmodewithin45minutesofdrawingsamples.

The study is in accordwithethical standardsestablishedby theinstitutioninwhichtheexperimentwasperformed.

2.4 | Imprecision and carryover

Imprecisiononreticulocytecountwasestimatedwiththeimpreci-sionprofile2,15extendedtoawiderangeofvalues(5to230×109/L)by performing repeated analysis (8 counts) on 17 samples rein-serted in random order. Calculation of carryover was performedbyanalyzingapairof samples:A samplewithahigh reticulocyteconcentration(156.7×109/L)analyzedthreetime(i1,i2,i3)immedi-atelyfollowedby1sampleatalowconcentration(35.5×109/L)alsoanalyzed3 times consecutively (j1, j2, j3) using the formula(j1−j3)/(i3−j3)×100.

16

2.5 | Method comparison

Results of the comparison with Sysmex XE-5000 on reticulocytecount,IRF,andRHEweresummarizedgraphicallywithBland-Altmanplot with 95% confidence intervals which represent the limits ofagreement.16ForRHE,theevaluationwasbasedalsoontheassess-mentofclinicalagreementonselectedgroupsofpatients.

2.6 | Time stability

Forthestudyofpreservationtimeofbloodsamples,wecomparedthevalueofparametersofinterestbyretestingsamplescomingfromthesamegroupof368subjects (between45minutesand8hoursfromsampling:<45minutes,+2,+4,+8hoursmaintainingsamplesatroomtemperature).

Page 3: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

     |  3BUTTARELLO ET AL.

2.7 | Statistical analysis

Reference intervals were calculated with a nonparametric method(middle95thpercentileofthedistribution).Toevaluatepopulationdis-tribution characteristics, a Shapiro-Wilk testwas used. Formethodcomparison,Bland-Altmanmodelwasperformed.Behaviorofparam-etersofinterestasafunctionoftimewerecomparedusinganalysisofvariance(ANOVA).Allsignificancetestingweretwo-tailed,andaP value<.05wasconsideredsignificant.

3  | RESULTS

3.1 | Reference intervals

Reference intervals (mean and range) are summarized in Table1.Distribution of absolute reticulocyte count and IRF are log-normal,whileforRHEandMRVitisapproximatelyGaussian.WhencomparedtoXE-5000, the interval for reticulocyte count isdifferent inmeanand upper threshold (−5.4 and −8×109/L, respectively), but lowerthresholdsarecoincident.ForIRF,thevaluesareessentiallysuperim-posable,whileforRHE,thereisapositivedifferenceinlowerthresh-old (+1.5pg),butthemeanandupperthresholdaresimilar.MRVisnotcomparableasitisnotavailableonXE-5000.

3.2 | Imprecision

The imprecisionprofileofBC-6800 in reticulocyte count is charac-teristically shapedwith a CV% rapidly increasing while the param-eterconcentrationislowering.Forvaluesclosetothelowerlimitofthereference interval,CVisnear7%,whilefortheupper limit, it is4.5% (Figure1).These resultsareclose to theanalyticalgoalbasedon within-subject biological variation.17-19 The carryover (2.3%) isnegligible.

3.3 | Method comparison

Table2showsthecomparisonbetweenXE-5000andBC-6800withdatarelatedtoBland-Altmanstatistics(meandifferencewithconfi-denceintervals).Figure2A,Bshowsthegraphicaldisplayforreticu-locytecountandIRF.Thecomparisonoftheseparameterswasalsoevaluatedwiththebiparametricmatrix:reticulocytecountvsIRF3,4

asshowninFigure3.Toverifytheagreementbetweenmethods,itisusefultoseewhereBC-6800placedpatientspreviouslydefinedas“aplasticorwithearlymarrowrecovery”byXE-5000.ThisisshownbyblackdotsinFigure3.Fromthepositionofthesedots,itisevi-dentthatallpatientswereplacedinthesameareabybothanalyzers.Thisindicatesthat,inspiteofnumericaldifferencesinreferencein-tervals,inclinicaluse,resultsobtainedwiththematrixbythetwoan-alyzersaresuperimposable.Thesampleswithredcellinclusionsdidnotdemonstratesystematicdifferencesonthecountsofbothana-lyzers(reticulocytesfrom37to55×109/LatBC-6800andfrom35to60×109/LatXE-5000.InFigure2A,therearefoursampleswithmarkedly higher results with BC-6800 than with XE-5000. Thesebelongedtotwopatientswithbetathalassemiamajor,1withbetathalassemic trait,and1withchronichemolyticanemia. In the first

Mindray BC- 6800 Sysmex XE- 5000

Mean 2.5% 97.5% Mean 2.5% 97.5%

Reticulocyte(109/L) 44.99 23.18 93.2 49.44 23.08 101.3

Immaturereticulocyte(fraction)

0.053 0.015 0.14 0.059 0.012 0.15

Reticulocytehemo-globinequivalent(pg)

32.79 30.90 35.70 32.30 29.40 35.98

Meanreticulocytevolume(fL)

108.87 97.79 117.98 N.A. N.A. N.A.

TABLE  1 Referenceintervalsonreticulocyteandreticulocyteparameters(N=184)

F IGURE  1 BC-6800:imprecisionprofileofreticulocyteabsolutecount

02468

101214161820

0 50 100 150 200 250

CV %

Reticulocytes (109/L)

TABLE  2 Comparisonofmethods:analysisofdatabyBland-Altmanstatistics(N=552)

Parameters Mean difference

95% Confidence intervals P

Reticulocyte(109/L) −1.8 −2.64,−0.95 <.001

Immaturereticulocyte(fraction)

−0.006 −0.008,−0.005 <.001

Reticulocytehemoglobinequivalent(pg)

0.99 0.87,1.10 <.001

Page 4: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

4  |     BUTTARELLO ET AL.

F IGURE  2 Bland-Altmanplotscomparingthereticulocytecount(A),theimmaturereticulocytefraction(B),andthereticulocytehemoglobinequivalent(C)ofBC-6800andXE-5000.Thedottedlinesrepresent95%limitsofagreement

–30

–20

–10

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

0 50 100 150 200 250

Diffe

renc

e (B

C680

0 - X

E500

0)

Mean of RET (109/L)

–0.1

–0.08

–0.06

–0.04

–0.02

0

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.1

0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3

Diffe

renc

e (B

C680

0 - X

E500

0)

Mean of IRF (fraction)

–4

–2

0

2

4

6

8

10

15 20 25 30 35 40 45

Diffe

renc

e ( B

C680

0 - X

E500

0)

Mean of RHE (pg)

(A)

(B)

(C)

Page 5: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

     |  5BUTTARELLO ET AL.

twosamples,therewasasimilarpercentageoferythroblastsamongthetwoanalyzers(23.5and18.7vs24.7and20.3)whileintheothertwotheerythroblastswereabsent.AlsotheIRFvaluesweresimilaramong the twomethods (from 0.08 to 0.13 vs 0.05 to 0.13) andnootherpossible interferencewashighlighted inthebloodsmear.In 2 of these samples (beta thalassemiamajor andhemolytic ane-mia),BC-6800 reported the flag “cellulardebris.” Figure2C showstheplotofRHEwithapositivemeandifference(0.99).Thiscomplieswith a tendency to produce higher resultsmainly at low value ofthe reference interval.Figure4 shows theclinicalusefulness (abil-itytodistinguishbetweennormalandabnormalconditions)ofRHEwhencomparedtoRet-HeofXE-5000,keepinginmindthatclinicaluseofresultsisparticularlyusefulatsubnormalvalues(diagnosisofirondeficiencyerythropoiesis).10-13Table3showsthedisagreementinsamplesclassification(31fromatotalof368ones).Thesediffer-encesareidentifiedbyblackdotsinFigure4.

F IGURE  3 TwoparametersmatrixcomparingtherelationshipofimmaturereticulocytefractionvsabsolutereticulocytecountofBC-6800andXE-5000.TheblackdotsshowthesamplesthatXE-5000placedinthe“aplastic”category.Theverticalandhorizontallinesrepresentthereferenceintervals

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

IRF

(frac

tion)

XE-5000 Reticulocytes (109/L)

BC-6800 Reticulocytes (109/L)

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

IRF

(frac

tion)

F IGURE  4 Plotofreticulocytehemoglobinequivalent:BC-6800vsXE-5000.Theverticalandhorizontallinesrepresentthereferenceintervals.Theblackdotsindicatethedisagreementinsamplesclassification

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

15 20 25 30 35 40

RHE

(pg)

-BC6

800

RHE (pg) - XE5000

Page 6: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

6  |     BUTTARELLO ET AL.

3.4 | Time stability after venipuncture

Regarding the time laps inmeasuring samples stored at room tem-perature,Table4showsresultsobtained.Theevaluationwasstoppedafter8hoursfromvenipunctureasitisareasonablelimitthatshouldnotbeexceeded.Infact,fora longertime,notalltheotherparam-eters of theCBC are stable regardless of storage temperature.20-22 Forreticulocytecount, therearenosignificantdifferencesbetween45minutesand8hours.Forotherparameters(IRF,RHE,MRV),dif-ferencesarestatisticallysignificantalreadyafter4hours,butalwaysclose to the “optimal” bias based on biological variability (0.125[CVi2+CVg2]1/2),whereCViandCVgrepresentthewithinsubjectandbetweensubjectvariability)17,19 .

4  | DISCUSSION

Thelargediffusionofautomatedmethodsdependsonthepossibilityofreplacingmanualvisualcounts,whicharesubjective,highlyimpre-ciseandtedious,andontheadvantagesderivingfromapreciseandobjectivecountmainlyat lowvalues,necessaryforthediagnosisofhypoplasticanemiasorfortheearlymonitoringofbonemarrowre-generation.Afurtheradvantageistheidentificationofotherreticu-locyteparameters,suchastheIRFwhichisusefulinclassificationofanemias based onmarrow response, mainly using two-dimensionalmatricesofIRFvsabsolutereticulocytecount,andindifferentialdiag-nosisofreticulocytopeniaindistinguishingbonemarrowaplasiafromearlyerythropoieticresponse.OtherusesincludemonitoringtherapyefficacyinnutritionalanemiabecausetheincreaseinIRFprecedestheincreaseintotalreticulocytecountbyseveraldays.3,4,23OtherusefulparametersavailableonlywithautomatedanalyzersarereticulocyteindexessuchasRHEandMRV.Theseindexesareimportantbecauselowvaluesindicateiron-deficienterythropoiesis,eveninconditionsinwhichtraditionalbiochemicalmarkerssuchasferritinandtransferringsaturationareinadequateasininflammationsoranemiafromachronicdisease.Moreover, they are useful inmonitoring an early responsetotherapybecausetheychangesignificantlyafteronly48-72hoursfrom administration of iron, cobalamin or folate in nutritional ane-mias.9,24Increaseofdifferentanalyzersonthemarket,amongwhichMindrayBC-6800representsoneofthelastintroduced,bringsinthepressingneed for resultscomparisonandharmonization.The refer-enceintervalinabsolutevaluebetweenthetwoanalyzersisdifferent,

TABLE  3  Instrumentagreementofreticulocytehemoglobinequivalent:distributionalclassification(N=368)

Mindray BC- 6800

Sysmex XE- 5000 Low Normal High Total

Low 105 4 0 109

Normal 19 210 2 231

High 0 6 22 28

Total 124 220 24 368

TABLE 4 Timestabilityevaluation(N=368)

Para

met

ers

T0T2

T4T8

Opt

imal

bia

sM

ean

Mea

nM

ean

diff

eren

ceP

Mea

nM

ean

diff

eren

ceP

Mea

nM

ean

diff

eren

ceP

Reticulocytes(109 /L)

50.8

850

.66

0.22

.413

50.33

0.55

.052

50.42

0.46

.124

3.9%(1.98)*

Immaturereticulocytefraction

(fraction)

0.07

00.

068

0.00

2<.051

0.06

70.003

<.001

0.06

70.003

<.001

2.4%(0.002)*

Reticulocytehemoglobin

equivalent(pg)

31.97

31.90

0.07

.081

31.81

0.16

<.001

31.80

0.18

<.001

0.49%(0.15)*

Meanreticulocytevolume(fL)

106.

2210

5.99

0.23

.078

105.

720.

50.0

0210

5.65

0.57

<.001

0.41%(0.43)*

*Parenthesis:absolutevalues.

Page 7: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

     |  7BUTTARELLO ET AL.

mainly on the upper limit, and the disagreement needs for specificreferenceintervals.Resultsdisagreealsowithpreviouspublishedre-sultsobtainedwithMindrayBC-6800onadultpopulation,especiallyontheupperlimit:93.2vs115×109/L.25Thismaydependonthese-lectedpopulation, but thedifference is so large to requires furtherstudy before reaching a final conclusion.Also comparison betweenmethodsonallanalyzedsamplesshowsanegativemeandifference(−1.8×109/L). Inthisstudy,thenumberofsampleswitherythrocyteinclusionswasmodest(threewithbasophilicstippling,fivewithJollybodiesandnoonewithinclusionsfrommalarialparasite),andthere-fore,amoreextensiveevaluationwouldbenecessarytoassesstheeffectofallpossibleinterferences.Forthefoursampleswithmarkeddifferencesincounting,nointerferencefromerythroblastsorahigherproportion of young reticulocytes can be hypothesized consideringthe similar values between the two analyzers. However, these dif-ferencesmaydependon thedifferentways inwhich the software,incertainsamples,determinestheseparationbetweenreticulocytesandmatureerythrocytes.Itshouldbenoted,however,that,fordiag-nosticpurposes,bothanalyzersshowedan increase inreticulocytesalthoughmorepronouncedforBC-6800thanforXE-5000.

Theanalyticgoalforimprecisionwhichiscurrentlywidelysharedis based on biological variability.Among various clinical conditions,monitoring has the most restrictive criteria (CVa<0.5 CVi). Studiespublishedonbiologicalvariabilityofreticulocytecountprovideessen-tiallyconcordantresults:CVibetween9.5and11%,26-28withanalyt-icalgoalsfrom4.75%to5.5%,respectively.Withimprecisionprofilewecanidentifyimprecisioninconnectionwithcriticalconcentrations.Thismethodwhenextendedtoawide rangeofconcentrationsandwithasufficientnumberofsamples(tolimittheeffectofpossibleout-liers)representsavalidalternativetoANOVAperformedonduplicatesofsamplesofdifferentconcentration(ie,low,normal,andhigh),16orofmanyconsecutivemeasurementsonthesamesample.Figure1showsthatthegoalforBC-6800isreachedatnormalandhighconcentra-tions.At lowconcentration, imprecision(from5%to10%) isgreaterthanthegoal,but it isnegligiblebyaclinicalpointofview,andit isbetterthanthatofmanypreviousgenerationofanalyzers.2Stabilityofallparametersovertimeafter8hoursfromsamplingissatisfactorywithvariations lowerorapproximate to themore restrictivecriteria(so-calledoptimalbias)basedonbiologicalvariation.17OnevaluationofclinicalusefulnessofRHE,totalagreementwithXE-5000isgood(91.6%).Atlowvalues,wheretheresultsareparticularlyusefulindi-agnosisofirondeficiencyerythropoiesis,arepresent23discrepancies(4 lowwithXE-5000butnormalwithBC-6800and19normalwithXE-5000,butlowwithBC-6800).Inthiscase,allvalueswereincludedinalittle intervalbetween29.5and30.9pg.Lessinterestingfromadiagnosticpointofview(increasedinmacrocyticnutritionalanemia),arethehighvaluesofRHE,buttheirrapiddecline,likewisetothatofMRV,isusefulinmonitoringearlyresponsetotherapyasreportedinFigure5.Thisfigureshowsalsotheoverlapbetweeniron-deficiencyandbetathalassemiatraitbecauseinthislastconditionRHEisalwaysreducedindependentlyfromironstores.13,29Themainlimitationofthisstudyisthatmethodsformeasuringreticulocyteextendedparametersarenotstandardized,andreferencematerialforthesedeterminations

islacking.Thismakesitimpossibletoexplorespecificcausesfortheobserveddiscrepanciesbetweenthetwoanalyzers.

Inconclusion,BC-6800providesaprecisereticulocytecountatallconcentrationswithanegligiblecarry-over.Stabilityofallparametersisexcellentup to8hours.ClinicalagreementwithXE-5000 isgoodmainlyusingbivariatematricesonclassificationofanemia,andRHEin diagnosing iron-deficiency conditions. The incomplete numericalagreementoncountand insomeparameterssuchasRHEmakes itnecessarytheuseofspecificreferenceintervalsandclinicaldecisionvalues.

CONFLICT OF INTERESTS

Theauthorsdeclarethattheyhavenocompetinginterests.

REFERENCES

1. ButtarelloM,BulianP,VenudoA,RizzottiP.LaboratoryevaluationoftheMilesH.3automatedreticulocytecounter.AcomparativestudywithmanualreferencemethodandSysmexR-1000.Arch Pathol Lab Med.1995;119:1141-1148.

2. ButtarelloM,BulianP, FarinaG, et al. Flowcytometry reticulocytecounting. Parallel evaluation of five fully automated analyzers: anNCCLS-ICSHapproach.Am J Clin Pathol.2001;115:100-111.

3. Davis BH. Immature reticulocyte fraction (IRF): by any name, auseful clinical parameter of erythropoietic activity. Lab Hematol. 1996;2:2-8.

4. ButtarelloM, Bulian P, FarinaG, PetrisMG,TemporinV,Toffolo L.Fivefullyautomatedmethodsforperformingimmaturereticulocytefraction.Comparisonindiagnosisofbonemarrowaplasia.Am J Clin Pathol.2002;117:871-879.

5. BrugnaraC,LauferMR,FriedmanAR,BridgesK,PlattO.Reticulocytehemoglobincontent (CHr):early indicatorof irondeficiencyandre-sponsetotherapy.Blood.1994;83:3100-3101.

F IGURE  5 Plotofreticulocytehemoglobinequivalentvsimmaturereticulocytefraction.Theinsetsrepresentsomewell-differentiatebehaviorincertainareasoftheplot:(A):betathalassemiatraitwithorwithoutirondeficiency;(B):irondeficiencyatdiagnosis;(C):macrocyticnutritionalanemiaatdiagnosis.Superimposedarethetrendsforthreepatientsaftertherapy:•)irondeficiency;▲)betathalassemiatraitwithirondeficiency;*)cobalamindeficiency

Page 8: Reticulocyte count and extended reticulocyte … XE-5000 analyzer. Methods: One hundred and eighty-four healthy adults of both sexes, and 368 subjects affected by various pathologic

8  |     BUTTARELLO ET AL.

6. d’OnofrioG,ChirilloR,ZiniG,CaenaroG,TommasiM,MicciulliG.Simultaneous measurement of reticulocyte and red cell indices inhealthysubjectsandpatientswithmicrocyticandmacrocyticanemia.Blood.1995;85:818-823.

7. BrugnaraC.Reticulocytecellularindices:anewapproachinthediag-nosisofanemiasandmonitoringoferythropoieticfunction.Crit Rev Clin Lab Sci.2000;37:93-130.

8. PivaE,BrugnaraC,ChiandettiL,PlebaniM.Automatedreticulocytecounting:stateoftheartandclinicalapplicationsintheevaluationoferythropoiesis.Clin Chem Lab Med.2010;48:1369-1380.

9. ButtarelloM.Laboratorydiagnosisofanemia:aretheoldandnewredcellparametersusefulinclassificationandtreatment,how?Int J Lab Hematol.2016;38(suppl1):123-132.

10. Garzia M, Di Mario A, Ferraro E, et al. Reticulocyte haemoglobinequivalent; an indicator of reduced iron availability in chronic kid-ney diseases during erythropoietin therapy. Lab Hematol. 2007;13: 6-11.

11. UrrechagaE,BorqueL,EscaneroJF.PotentialutilityofthenewSysmexXE5000redbloodcellextendedparametersinthestudyofdisordersofironmetabolism.Clin Chem Lab Med.2009;47:1411-1416.

12. UrrechagaE,BorqueL,EscaneroJF.Erythrocyteandreticulocytein-dicesintheassessmentoferythropoiesisactivityandironavailability.Int J Lab Hematol.2013;35:144-149.

13. ButtarelloM,PajolaR,NovelloE,MezzapelleG,PlebaniM.EvaluationofthehypochromicerythrocyteandreticulocytehemoglobincontentprovidedbytheSysmexXE-5000analyzerindiagnosisofirondefi-ciencyerythropoiesis.Clin Chem Lab Med.2016;54:1939-1945.

14. Clinical and Laboratory Standard Institute (CLSI). Method for Reticulocyte Counting. Approved Guideline H44-A2. (2nded.).Wayne,P.A.:ClinicalandLaboratoryStandardInstitute;2004.

15. SadlerWA,SmithMH.Useandabuseofprecisionprofile:somepit-falls illustratedbycomputingandplottingconfidence intervals.Clin Chem.1990;36:1346-1350.

16. BriggsC,CulpN,DavisB,etal. ICSHguidelines for theevaluationofbloodcellanalysersincludingthoseusedfordifferentialleucocyteandreticulocytecounting.Int J Lab Hematol.2014;36:613-627.

17. FraserCG,HyltoftPetersenP,LibeerJC,RicosC.Proposalforsettinggenerally applicable quality goals solely based on biology.Ann Clin Biochem.1997;34:8-12.

18. FraserCG,HyltoftPetersenP.Analyticalperformancecharacteristicshouldbejudgedagainstobjectivequalityspecifications.Clin Chem. 1999;45:321-323.

19. Sandberg S, Fraser CG, HorvathAR, et al. Defining analytical per-formancespecifications:consensusstatementfromthe1stStrategic

Conference of the European Federation of Clinical Chemistry andLaboratoryMedicine.Clin Chem Lab Med.2015;53:833-835.

20. ZiniG. Stability of complete blood count parameterswith storage:toward defined specifications for different diagnostic applications.(Editorial).Int J Lab Hematol.2014;36:111-113.

21. Buoro S, Mecca T, Seghezzi M, et al. Assessment of blood sam-ple stability for complete blood cell count using the Sysmex XN-9000 andMindray BC-6800 analyzers. Rev Bras Hematol Hemoter. 2016;38:225-239.

22. DavesM,Zagler EM,CeminR, et al. Sample stability for completebloodcellcountusingtheSysmexXNhaematologicalanalyser.Blood Transfus.2015;13:576-582.

23. ButtarelloM,PlebaniM.Automatedbloodcellcounts.Stateof theart.Am J Clin Pathol.2008;130:104-116.

24. ButtarelloM,TemporinV,CeravoloR, FarinaG,BulianP.The newreticulocyteparameter(Ret-y)oftheSysmexXE2100.Itsuseinthediagnosisandmonitoringofposttreatmentsideropenicanemia.Am J Clin Pathol.2004;121:489-495.

25. GrilloneR,GrimaldiE,ScopacasaF,ConticelliM,DenteB.Evaluationof the reticulocyte counting by the Mindray BC 6800 automatedhematology analyzer: comparison with ABX Pentra 120, CoulterLH 750, and microscopy. (Letter to the editor). Int J Lab Hematol. 2015;37:e3-e6.

26. Ricos C, Alvarez V, Cava F, et al. Current databases on biolog-ical variation: pros, cons, and progress. Scand J Clin Lab Invest. 1999;59:491-500.

27. SandbergS,RustadP,JohannesenB,StolsnesB.Within-subjectbio-logicalvariationofreticulocytesandreticulocyte-derivedparameters.Eur J Haematol.1998;61:42-48.

28. ZhangP,TangH,ChenK,ChenY,XuD.Biologicalvariationsofhe-matologic parameters determined by UniCel DxH 800 hematologyanalyzer.Arch Pathol Lab Med.2013;137:1106-1110.

29. Noronha JFA, Grotto HZW. Measurement of reticulocyte and redblood cell indices in patients with iron deficiency anemia and β-thalassemia.Clin Chem Lab Med.2005;43:195-197.

How to cite this article:ButtarelloM,RauliA,MezzapelleG.ReticulocytecountandextendedreticulocyteparametersbyMindrayBC-6800:ReferenceintervalsandcomparisonwithSysmexXE-5000.Int J Lab Hem.2017;00:1–8.https://doi.org/10.1111/ijlh.12705