92
Industrial Vacant Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 3 Not enough sales to analyze data Industrial Improved Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 15 0.9873 20.1255 0.993 Commercial Vacant Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 3 Not enough sales to analyze data Commercial Improved Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 61 0.9046 19.9805 1.0277 Residential Vacant Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 14 0.9474 15.2179 0.9987 Residential Improved Sales Median COD PRD CENTRE 215 0.94 12.789 1.0307 CLAY 429 0.94 12.572 1.0161 GERMAN 130 0.93 11.773 1.0218 GREENE 26 0.92 11.885 1.0311 HARRIS 345 0.97 9.907 1.0208 LIBERTY 27 0.93 12.804 1.0164 LINCOLN 27 1.03 12.253 1.0208 MADISON 8 1.01 12.694 0.9984 OLIVE 54 0.92 13.933 1.0311 PENN 534 0.95 9.475 1.0251 PORTAGE 583 0.96 14.375 1.0347 UNION 13 0.90 13.971 1.0350 WARREN 115 0.95 12.262 1.0147 7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 3 Not enough … Vacant Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 3 Not enough sales to analyze data Industrial Improved Sales Median COD PRD County Wide 15

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Industrial Vacant

Sales Median COD PRD

County Wide 3 Not enough sales to analyze data

Industrial Improved

Sales Median COD PRD

County Wide 15 0.9873 20.1255 0.993

Commercial Vacant

Sales Median COD PRD

County Wide 3 Not enough sales to analyze data

Commercial Improved

Sales Median COD PRD

County Wide 61 0.9046 19.9805 1.0277

Residential Vacant

Sales Median COD PRD

County Wide 14 0.9474 15.2179 0.9987

Residential Improved

Sales Median COD PRD

CENTRE 215 0.94 12.789 1.0307

CLAY 429 0.94 12.572 1.0161

GERMAN 130 0.93 11.773 1.0218

GREENE 26 0.92 11.885 1.0311

HARRIS 345 0.97 9.907 1.0208

LIBERTY 27 0.93 12.804 1.0164

LINCOLN 27 1.03 12.253 1.0208

MADISON 8 1.01 12.694 0.9984

OLIVE 54 0.92 13.933 1.0311

PENN 534 0.95 9.475 1.0251

PORTAGE 583 0.96 14.375 1.0347

UNION 13 0.90 13.971 1.0350

WARREN 115 0.95 12.262 1.0147

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel NumberTownship

NeighborhoodProperty

Class

Taxing

DistrictSales

Date

Sales

Price

Land

ValueImproved

AVTotal AV Ratio

Combined

71-09-11-177-001.000-022 Penn 7122009 300 022 09/16/2014 $400 400 0 400 1.0000

71-03-35-382-014.000-026 Portage 7126017 300 026 01/08/2014 $25,000 36,000 900 36,900 1.4760

71-03-35-382-013.000-026 Portage 7126017 399 026 01/08/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-22-101-001.000-026 Portage 7126044 300 026 12/17/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-22-101-002.000-026 Portage 7126044 300 026 12/17/2014 $85,000 19,700 0 19,700 0.2318

Not enough sales to analyze data $110,400 3 57,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel IDTownship

NeighborhoodProperty

Class

Taxing

DistrictSales

Date

Sales

PriceLand AV Improve AV Total AV Ratio AbsDev

PCC 330

71-09-12-401-001.000-031 Penn 7131005 330 031 05/07/2014 $6,670,000 387,300 5,377,100 5,764,400 0.8642 0.1231

PCC 340 & 350

71-03-28-300-013.000-009 German 7109013 350 009 04/04/2014 $727,000 58,100 499,900 558,000 0.7675 0.2197

71-03-20-401-004.000-009 German 7109007 340 009 12/24/2014 $2,397,000 324,500 3,047,200 3,371,700 1.4066 0.4193

71-08-29-426-001.000-010 Greene 7110004 350 010 02/06/2015 $330,000 35,100 218,900 254,000 0.7697 0.2176

71-09-02-401-002.000-022 Penn 7122005 350 022 04/28/2014 $240,913 62,000 118,800 180,800 0.7505 0.2368

71-09-14-328-006.000-023 Penn 7123006 340 023 05/09/2014 $157,300 44,000 111,300 155,300 0.9873 0.0000

71-09-14-184-001.000-023 Penn 7123006 340 023 12/03/2014 $400,000 126,700 298,900 425,600 1.0640 0.0767

71-09-22-201-005.000-022 Penn 7122005 350 022 12/09/2014 $125,000 20,500 72,600 93,100 0.7448 0.2425

71-08-10-251-008.000-026 Portage 7126026 350 026 01/24/2014 $219,000 62,600 253,000 315,600 1.4411 0.4538

71-08-15-226-003.000-026 Portage 7126009 350 026 06/27/2014 $14,776,347 769,200 14,364,100 15,133,300 1.0242 0.0369

71-08-13-276-003.000-026 Portage 7126009 350 026 10/21/2014 $75,000 21,100 77,500 98,600 1.3147 0.3274

71-08-13-276-002.000-026 Portage 7126017 300 026 10/21/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-02-101-006.000-026 Portage 7126009 350 026 12/30/2014 $100,000 85,400 14,600 100,000 1.0000 0.0127

71-07-12-251-008.000-029 Warren 7129004 340 029 04/29/2014 $525,000 84,100 577,700 661,800 1.2606 0.2733

PCC 370

71-09-11-129-011.000-022 Penn 7122005 370 022 09/16/2014 $349,600 42,900 266,600 309,500 0.8853 0.1020

PCC 399

71-03-19-200-005.000-009 German 7109011 399 009 12/09/2014 $370,000 44,800 232,200 277,000 0.7486 0.2386

$27,462,160 15 27,698,700

County Wide Summary Mean 1.0019

Median 0.9873

Wtd Mean 1.0086

COD 20.1255

PRD 0.9934

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel ID Township # Neighborhood PCC district_number SalesDate SalesPrice LandValue ImpValue Total AV Ratio

Combined

71-04-29-401-002.000-003 Clay 7103004 400 003 12/31/2014 $375,000 564,600 0 564,600 1.5056

71-03-22-378-004.000-009 German 7109017 400 009 05/21/2014 $675,000 41,400 0 41,400 0.0613

71-09-04-476-022.000-023 Penn 7123027 400 023 01/01/2015 $216,050 55,800 0 55,800 0.2583

Not enough sales to analyze data $1,266,050 3 661,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel Number Township NeighborhoodProperty ClassTaxing District Sale Date Sale Price Land AV Improve AV Total AV Ratio AbsDev

71-08-25-426-013.000-002 Centre 7102014 425 002 09/24/2014 $2,100,000 718,600 1,031,100 1,749,700 0.8332 0.0715

71-08-25-152-013.000-002 Centre 7102014 454 002 11/03/2014 $395,000 50,600 234,200 284,800 0.7210 0.1836

71-04-31-403-038.000-003 Clay 7103008 401 003 02/10/2014 $1,200,000 60,200 1,390,800 1,451,000 1.2092 0.3045

71-04-31-480-007.000-004 Clay 7104012 447 004 02/11/2014 $525,000 94,500 280,400 374,900 0.7141 0.1905

71-04-33-176-009.000-005 Clay 7129430 430 005 02/19/2014 $875,000 527,500 358,300 885,800 1.0123 0.1077

71-04-32-351-010.000-004 Clay 7104420 420 004 06/23/2014 $300,000 72,400 48,900 121,300 0.4043 0.5003

71-04-32-186-008.000-003 Clay 7103006 447 003 08/29/2014 $256,500 85,800 176,200 262,000 1.0214 0.1168

71-04-32-186-007.000-003 Clay 7103010 400 003 08/29/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-31-452-014.000-004 Clay 7104012 447 004 11/18/2014 $271,000 47,400 143,900 191,300 0.7059 0.1987

71-03-12-308-018.000-003 Clay 7103024 442 003 12/22/2014 $150,000 36,500 100,800 137,300 0.9153 0.0107

71-04-28-226-004.000-005 Clay 7129410 410 005 12/22/2014 $1,680,000 486,500 1,033,300 1,519,800 0.9046 0.0000

71-04-28-226-002.000-005 Clay 7129410 410 005 12/23/2014 $1,968,750 416,400 1,341,500 1,757,900 0.8929 0.0117

71-04-32-186-003.000-003 Clay 7103006 447 003 01/01/2015 $730,000 174,000 527,000 701,000 0.9603 0.0556

71-04-32-186-004.000-003 Clay 7103006 447 003 01/01/2015 $0 0 0

71-03-25-303-011.000-007 Clay 7107007 499 007 01/06/2015 $245,500 63,500 88,400 151,900 0.6187 0.2859

71-03-25-326-001.000-007 Clay 7107420 428 007 01/29/2015 $439,100 133,400 362,800 496,200 1.1300 0.2254

71-03-25-326-003.000-007 Clay 7107010 453 007 01/29/2015 $0 0 0

71-03-25-326-002.000-007 Clay 7107001 456 007 01/29/2015 $0 0 0

71-03-27-126-005.000-009 German 7109017 452 009 01/29/2015 $503,000 144,300 219,100 363,400 0.7225 0.1822

71-04-27-102-007.000-036 Harris 7136004 447 036 05/01/2014 $165,000 22,800 167,600 190,400 1.1539 0.2493

71-04-27-102-006.000-036 Harris 7136004 447 036 05/01/2014 $0 0 0 0

71-05-07-351-012.000-011 Harris 7111013 430 011 01/22/2015 $615,000 206,300 285,300 491,600 0.7993 0.1053

71-04-23-151-001.000-011 Harris 7111015 450 011 01/29/2015 $358,700 120,700 143,300 264,000 0.7360 0.1687

71-04-27-101-005.000-036 Harris 7136004 450 036 01/29/2015 $472,400 247,100 193,800 440,900 0.9333 0.0287

71-01-34-233-015.000-018 Olive 7118005 455 018 06/24/2014 $140,000 24,800 43,000 67,800 0.4843 0.4204

71-01-34-129-025.000-018 Olive 7118005 420 018 12/30/2014 $49,900 29,100 43,000 72,100 1.4449 0.5402

71-10-09-277-004.000-031 Penn 7131018 460 031 03/12/2014 $75,000 77,400 12,300 89,700 1.1960 0.2914

71-10-09-277-003.000-031 Penn 7131021 400 031 03/12/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-17-407-005.000-023 Penn 7123002 499 023 03/21/2014 $40,000 14,900 19,000 33,900 0.8475 0.0571

71-09-15-153-006.000-023 Penn 7123034 452 023 03/26/2014 $100,000 53,200 24,200 77,400 0.7740 0.1306

71-09-16-276-012.000-023 Penn 7123031 447 023 04/02/2014 $90,000 11,100 84,800 95,900 1.0656 0.1609

71-09-16-182-002.000-023 Penn 7123031 447 023 04/09/2014 $55,000 26,200 48,600 74,800 1.3600 0.4554

71-10-18-128-031.000-023 Penn 7123034 452 023 04/16/2014 $150,000 40,900 60,900 101,800 0.6787 0.2260

71-10-09-279-010.000-031 Penn 7131019 429 031 04/29/2014 $89,000 49,500 27,800 77,300 0.8685 0.0361

71-10-16-152-010.000-030 Penn 7130013 480 030 07/14/2014 $60,000 28,000 40,100 68,100 1.1350 0.2304

71-09-17-329-001.000-023 Penn 7123029 439 023 08/18/2014 $150,000 63,300 94,300 157,600 1.0507 0.1460

71-09-10-129-007.000-023 Penn 7123015 499 023 09/05/2014 $145,000 16,700 115,100 131,800 0.9090 0.0043

71-09-15-276-004.000-023 Penn 7123031 447 023 09/26/2014 $174,000 44,000 100,200 144,200 0.8287 0.0759

71-09-15-276-005.000-023 Penn 7123030 420 023 09/26/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-16-428-011.000-023 Penn 7123034 430 023 09/30/2014 $250,000 12,000 148,900 160,900 0.6436 0.2610

71-09-16-428-006.000-023 Penn 7123033 400 023 09/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-16-180-003.000-023 Penn 7123030 420 023 10/02/2014 $220,000 72,600 124,300 196,900 0.8950 0.0096

71-09-16-180-002.000-023 Penn 7123033 400 023 10/02/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-13-208-007.000-023 Penn 7123034 452 023 10/14/2014 $65,000 41,900 21,900 63,800 0.9815 0.0769

71-10-17-132-019.000-030 Penn 7130004 447 030 11/05/2014 $185,000 29,300 132,700 162,000 0.8757 0.0290

71-09-10-310-001.000-023 Penn 7123030 429 023 11/20/2014 $57,000 19,800 27,200 47,000 0.8246 0.0801

71-09-04-203-004.000-022 Penn 7122032 452 022 01/29/2015 $565,900 205,200 310,700 515,900 0.9116 0.0070

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-11-127-008.000-022 Penn 7122011 499 022 02/11/2015 $92,700 25,400 73,000 98,400 1.0615 0.1568

71-09-04-183-009.000-022 Penn 7122024 429 022 02/24/2015 $440,000 114,500 169,900 284,400 0.6464 0.2583

71-08-12-231-006.000-026 Portage 7126075 442 026 01/29/2014 $180,000 32,800 88,800 121,600 0.6756 0.2291

71-08-12-231-007.000-026 Portage 7126350 400 026 01/29/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-03-255-015.000-026 Portage 7126156 499 026 02/25/2014 $97,000 8,900 84,400 93,300 0.9619 0.0572

71-08-12-281-003.000-026 Portage 7126076 447 026 04/08/2014 $226,000 45,000 140,600 185,600 0.8212 0.0834

71-08-12-281-004.000-026 Portage 7126097 456 026 04/08/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-06-361-001.000-026 Portage 7126158 420 026 04/14/2014 $210,000 19,400 189,300 208,700 0.9938 0.0892

71-08-12-283-003.000-026 Portage 7126076 447 026 07/10/2014 $330,500 124,500 199,400 323,900 0.9800 0.0754

71-08-12-283-001.000-026 Portage 7126090 499 026 07/10/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-13-305-021.000-026 Portage 7126168 429 026 08/28/2014 $60,000 10,100 53,400 63,500 1.0583 0.1537

71-09-17-102-014.000-026 Portage 7126164 425 026 09/05/2014 $250,000 33,000 208,700 241,700 0.9668 0.0622

71-08-12-277-004.000-026 Portage 7126057 401 026 09/10/2014 $95,000 5,700 64,600 70,300 0.7400 0.1646

71-08-12-107-002.000-026 Portage 7126081 449 026 10/01/2014 $1,100,000 37,000 1,068,900 1,105,900 1.0054 0.1007

71-08-10-403-001.000-026 Portage 7126182 447 026 10/09/2014 $85,000 4,400 59,200 63,600 0.7482 0.1564

71-08-02-301-026.000-026 Portage 7126122 447 026 10/13/2014 $25,000 9,000 24,500 33,500 1.3400 0.4354

71-09-17-203-001.000-026 Portage 7126156 499 026 10/17/2014 $67,500 8,800 94,000 102,800 1.5230 0.6183

71-08-13-305-036.000-026 Portage 7126156 499 026 10/31/2014 $20,000 6,400 1,900 8,300 0.4150 0.4896

71-08-13-305-035.000-026 Portage 7126174 499 026 10/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-17-127-012.000-026 Portage 7126168 429 026 11/20/2014 $70,000 16,600 44,500 61,100 0.8729 0.0318

71-08-09-256-011.000-026 Portage 7126142 452 026 12/10/2014 $65,000 26,100 20,800 46,900 0.7215 0.1831

71-08-10-212-003.000-026 Portage 7126187 480 026 12/30/2014 $266,000 40,800 220,100 260,900 0.9808 0.0762

71-08-13-305-034.000-026 Portage 7126120 442 026 12/31/2014 $60,000 13,900 49,200 63,100 1.0517 0.1470

71-08-14-331-019.000-026 Portage 7126066 401 026 01/15/2015 $165,000 3,900 116,000 119,900 0.7267 0.1780

71-08-12-206-005.000-026 Portage 7126076 447 026 01/23/2015 $100,000 31,600 54,700 86,300 0.8630 0.0416

71-08-12-206-004.000-026 Portage 7126076 447 026 01/23/2015 $0 0 0

71-08-14-304-001.000-026 Portage 7126200 429 026 02/23/2015 $7,000 4,000 4,700 8,700 1.2429 0.3382

71-07-27-353-002.000-029 Warren 7129009 430 029 04/09/2014 $16,000 20,300 4,800 25,100 1.5688 0.6641

71-07-27-353-001.000-029 Warren 7129007 400 029 04/09/2014 $0 0 0

County Wide Summary $19,938,450 61 17,851,600

Mean 0.9201

Median 0.9046

Wtd Mean 0.8953

COD 19.9805

PRD 1.0277

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel Number Township Neighborhood

Property

Class

Taxing

District Sale Date Sale Price Land AV Improve AV Total AV Ratio

AbsDev

71-04-08-478-010.000-003 Clay 7103099 500 003 06/05/2014 $30,000 25,100 0 25,100 0.8367 0.1107

71-04-18-302-002.000-003 Clay 7103111 500 003 06/25/2014 $9,200 8,300 0 8,300 0.9022 0.0452

71-13-18-376-005.000-010 Greene 7110019 501 010 08/15/2014 $50,000 28,200 0 28,200 0.5640 0.3834

71-04-22-301-029.000-036 Harris 7130510 500 036 05/19/2014 $25,000 30,500 0 30,500 1.2200 0.2726

71-09-29-451-005.000-031 Penn 7131068 500 031 2/26/2015 $25,000 19,200 0 19,200 0.7680 0.1794

71-04-22-301-024.000-036 Harris 7130510 500 036 05/19/2014 $27,000 26,800 0 26,800 0.9926 0.0452

71-05-08-431-003.000-011 Harris 7111079 500 011 08/04/2014 $19,500 19,700 0 19,700 1.0103 0.0629

71-05-17-154-002.000-011 Harris 7111088 500 011 08/22/2014 $45,000 55,600 0 55,600 1.2356 0.2882

71-05-17-154-001.000-011 Harris 7111088 500 011 08/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-05-18-327-014.000-011 Harris 7111041 500 011 02/19/2015 $44,000 34,300 0 34,300 0.7795 0.1678

71-06-02-351-007.000-017 Olive 7117024 500 017 05/19/2014 $27,500 20,300 0 20,300 0.7382 0.2092

71-09-11-476-002.000-022 Penn 7122062 500 022 06/12/2014 $150,000 150,000 0 150,000 1.0000 0.0526

71-09-10-251-020.000-023 Penn 7123052 500 023 08/22/2014 $1,500 1,500 0 1,500 1.0000 0.0526

71-08-01-431-020.000-026 Portage 7126350 500 026 03/03/2014 $3,500 3,500 0 3,500 1.0000 0.0526

71-02-24-354-093.000-029 Warren 7129097 500 029 04/30/2014 $17,500 14,900 0 14,900 0.8514 0.0960

County Wide Summary $474,700 437,900 14

Mean 0.9213

Median 0.9474

Wtd Mean 0.9225

COD 15.2179

PRD 0.99874

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

Parcel ID Township # Neighborhood PCC district # SalesDate SalesPrice LandValue ImpValue Total AV Ratio AbsDev

CENTRE TOWNSHIP

71-08-27-151-005.000-001 Centre 7101006 510 001 08/06/2014 $277,000 12,600 219,300 231,900 0.8372 0.1028

71-08-27-154-005.000-001 Centre 7101006 510 001 02/18/2015 $319,900 17,600 288,600 306,200 0.9572 0.0172

71-08-27-401-006.000-001 Centre 7101007 511 001 04/25/2014 $155,000 34,500 172,300 206,800 1.3342 0.3942

71-08-27-402-009.000-001 Centre 7101007 510 001 07/03/2014 $138,500 8,700 104,300 113,000 0.8159 0.1241

71-08-27-451-018.000-001 Centre 7101007 510 001 07/03/2014 $160,000 9,900 128,700 138,600 0.8663 0.0738

71-08-34-476-013.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 05/21/2014 $122,000 7,300 98,800 106,100 0.8697 0.0703

71-08-34-476-015.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 09/10/2014 $145,000 9,100 132,500 141,600 0.9766 0.0366

71-08-34-377-018.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 10/01/2014 $154,900 10,400 119,500 129,900 0.8386 0.1014

71-08-34-377-009.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 10/10/2014 $126,500 10,900 123,000 133,900 1.0585 0.1185

71-13-01-403-004.000-001 Centre 7101031 510 001 2/27/2015 $105,000 12,400 95,200 107,600 1.0248 0.0848

71-08-34-476-004.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 01/22/2015 $140,000 8,000 137,000 145,000 1.0357 0.0957

71-08-34-426-006.000-001 Centre 7101008 510 001 01/29/2015 $130,000 8,200 128,700 136,900 1.0531 0.1131

71-08-35-353-005.000-001 Centre 7101010 510 001 09/19/2014 $259,000 25,000 210,700 235,700 0.9100 0.0300

71-08-35-302-005.000-001 Centre 7101010 510 001 11/10/2014 $315,000 9,700 222,000 231,700 0.7356 0.2044

71-08-35-326-004.000-001 Centre 7101010 510 001 12/17/2014 $442,000 37,300 255,500 292,800 0.6624 0.2776

71-08-35-326-003.000-001 Centre 7101009 500 001 12/17/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-35-176-017.000-001 Centre 7101011 510 001 12/17/2014 $228,000 11,600 164,300 175,900 0.7715 0.1685

71-08-36-452-004.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 02/21/2014 $137,400 11,700 108,800 120,500 0.8770 0.0630

71-08-36-126-006.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 03/26/2014 $91,000 7,000 79,300 86,300 0.9484 0.0084

71-08-36-451-003.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 04/07/2014 $101,500 10,200 82,100 92,300 0.9094 0.0306

71-08-27-300-033.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 04/25/2014 $107,500 41,700 70,000 111,700 1.0391 0.0991

71-08-35-227-021.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 05/02/2014 $107,500 8,800 69,900 78,700 0.7321 0.2079

71-08-36-103-018.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 06/04/2014 $75,000 9,100 73,600 82,700 1.1027 0.1627

71-08-27-300-002.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 06/27/2014 $65,000 20,800 58,300 79,100 1.2169 0.2769

71-08-36-354-028.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 07/11/2014 $104,000 6,900 86,900 93,800 0.9019 0.0381

71-08-35-251-003.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 07/29/2014 $148,000 20,300 102,800 123,100 0.8318 0.1082

71-08-35-251-010.000-001 Centre 7101016 500 001 07/29/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-36-307-024.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 08/08/2014 $72,000 4,500 51,900 56,400 0.7833 0.1567

71-08-27-300-031.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 08/20/2014 $112,000 26,800 131,700 158,500 1.4152 0.4752

71-08-35-126-005.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 08/27/2014 $96,000 37,500 65,900 103,400 1.0771 0.1371

71-08-36-127-006.000-001 Centre 7101013 510 001 02/10/2015 $75,000 10,700 79,500 90,200 1.2027 0.2627

71-08-36-127-007.000-001 Centre 7101016 500 001 02/10/2015 $0 0 0

71-08-36-306-005.000-001 Centre 7101014 510 001 04/21/2014 $82,000 10,400 84,700 95,100 1.1598 0.2198

71-08-35-227-016.000-001 Centre 7101014 510 001 06/03/2014 $155,000 14,900 116,100 131,000 0.8452 0.0948

71-08-36-378-008.000-001 Centre 7101014 510 001 11/17/2014 $102,000 12,300 68,500 80,800 0.7922 0.1478

71-08-36-379-001.000-001 Centre 7101014 510 001 01/29/2015 $114,000 16,400 87,300 103,700 0.9096 0.0304

71-08-36-453-012.000-001 Centre 7101015 510 001 11/06/2014 $108,000 11,900 61,200 73,100 0.6769 0.2631

71-13-14-227-006.000-001 Centre 7101015 510 001 12/05/2014 $95,000 32,200 60,400 92,600 0.9747 0.0347

71-13-11-176-002.000-001 Centre 7101017 510 001 06/27/2014 $90,000 47,800 39,100 86,900 0.9656 0.0256

71-08-27-300-017.000-001 Centre 7101017 510 001 07/14/2014 $102,500 78,400 26,700 105,100 1.0254 0.0854

71-13-13-200-010.000-001 Centre 7101017 510 001 12/02/2014 $135,000 42,200 102,400 144,600 1.0711 0.1311

71-09-31-456-009.000-001 Centre 7101017 510 001 12/30/2014 $106,000 33,200 126,800 160,000 1.5094 0.5694

71-09-31-456-012.000-001 Centre 7101018 510 001 06/03/2014 $179,900 33,500 140,800 174,300 0.9689 0.0289

71-13-03-200-020.000-001 Centre 7101018 510 001 09/15/2014 $142,500 40,500 76,700 117,200 0.8225 0.1175

71-14-07-200-011.000-001 Centre 7101020 511 001 08/20/2014 $225,000 58,400 203,600 262,000 1.1644 0.2244

71-14-07-352-008.000-001 Centre 7101025 510 001 07/11/2014 $137,000 40,700 66,700 107,400 0.7839 0.1561

71-13-13-352-002.000-001 Centre 7101025 510 001 10/22/2014 $272,630 37,800 156,600 194,400 0.7131 0.2269

71-13-01-102-009.000-001 Centre 7101027 510 001 08/12/2014 $65,000 5,600 29,200 34,800 0.5354 0.4046

71-13-01-128-003.000-001 Centre 7101027 510 001 09/15/2014 $59,500 5,600 22,200 27,800 0.4672 0.4728

71-13-01-129-017.000-001 Centre 7101028 510 001 05/21/2014 $106,000 11,900 104,400 116,300 1.0972 0.1572

71-13-01-104-013.000-001 Centre 7101028 510 001 07/24/2014 $130,000 13,600 132,000 145,600 1.1200 0.1800

71-14-06-305-007.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 06/25/2014 $179,000 20,500 151,500 172,000 0.9609 0.0209

71-14-06-303-013.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 06/30/2014 $223,000 18,600 182,100 200,700 0.9000 0.0400

71-14-06-306-007.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 09/24/2014 $210,000 17,700 170,600 188,300 0.8967 0.0433

71-14-06-306-008.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 10/09/2014 $205,000 20,500 167,000 187,500 0.9146 0.0254

71-14-06-308-006.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 10/15/2014 $230,000 18,100 185,100 203,200 0.8835 0.0565

71-14-06-303-007.000-001 Centre 7101030 510 001 01/21/2015 $259,000 23,500 182,200 205,700 0.7942 0.1458

71-13-01-403-006.000-001 Centre 7101031 510 001 07/28/2014 $130,500 14,300 106,900 121,200 0.9287 0.0113

71-13-01-426-018.000-001 Centre 7101031 510 001 08/04/2014 $121,000 12,600 101,400 114,000 0.9421 0.0021

71-13-01-427-017.000-001 Centre 7101031 510 001 09/24/2014 $120,000 14,300 101,300 115,600 0.9633 0.0233

71-13-02-453-002.000-001 Centre 7101033 510 001 10/21/2014 $146,000 5,300 88,100 93,400 0.6397 0.3003

71-13-02-453-007.000-001 Centre 7101033 510 001 12/03/2014 $98,500 5,600 89,900 95,500 0.9695 0.0295

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-13-02-453-009.000-001 Centre 7101033 510 001 01/20/2015 $88,000 7,200 65,400 72,600 0.8250 0.1150

71-13-02-102-004.000-001 Centre 7101034 510 001 08/06/2014 $90,000 27,000 62,700 89,700 0.9967 0.0567

71-13-11-378-001.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 01/30/2014 $100,000 21,300 80,900 102,200 1.0220 0.0820

71-13-11-352-009.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 07/25/2014 $126,500 8,200 99,000 107,200 0.8474 0.0926

71-13-11-376-010.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 07/28/2014 $54,500 20,400 34,300 54,700 1.0037 0.0637

71-13-11-376-011.000-001 Centre 7101036 500 001 07/28/2014 $0 0 0

71-13-11-376-009.000-001 Centre 7101036 500 001 07/28/2014 $0 0 0

71-13-11-353-005.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 12/17/2014 $78,900 7,100 56,400 63,500 0.8048 0.1352

71-13-11-353-022.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 12/24/2014 $86,900 11,100 63,200 74,300 0.8550 0.0850

71-13-11-352-016.000-001 Centre 7101036 510 001 12/29/2014 $78,000 7,100 70,000 77,100 0.9885 0.0485

71-13-12-176-001.000-001 Centre 7101051 511 001 10/07/2014 $568,000 47,300 325,400 372,700 0.6562 0.2838

71-08-35-202-001.000-001 Centre 7101055 510 001 05/19/2014 $198,900 23,000 130,500 153,500 0.7717 0.1683

71-08-35-203-001.000-001 Centre 7101055 510 001 10/06/2014 $212,000 25,000 147,700 172,700 0.8146 0.1254

71-09-30-177-009.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 02/06/2014 $91,000 16,300 72,000 88,300 0.9703 0.0303

71-09-30-152-002.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 03/12/2014 $64,900 17,000 53,700 70,700 1.0894 0.1494

71-09-30-102-009.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 05/01/2014 $140,500 25,000 136,800 161,800 1.1516 0.2116

71-09-30-177-015.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 05/14/2014 $51,000 15,300 54,900 70,200 1.3765 0.4365

71-09-30-151-027.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 05/19/2014 $49,900 20,400 46,800 67,200 1.3467 0.4067

71-09-30-203-006.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 06/04/2014 $86,500 15,600 76,500 92,100 1.0647 0.1247

71-09-30-132-014.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 06/04/2014 $87,000 16,900 68,100 85,000 0.9770 0.0370

71-09-30-130-032.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 06/09/2014 $70,000 17,900 49,900 67,800 0.9686 0.0286

71-09-30-131-001.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 06/26/2014 $74,900 16,900 54,700 71,600 0.9559 0.0159

71-09-30-101-033.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 07/29/2014 $67,500 20,900 53,800 74,700 1.1067 0.1667

71-09-30-102-006.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 10/27/2014 $120,000 20,900 127,700 148,600 1.2383 0.2983

71-09-30-130-014.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 12/30/2014 $60,500 15,800 54,400 70,200 1.1603 0.2203

71-09-30-202-006.000-002 Centre 7102018 510 002 01/13/2015 $84,000 16,100 84,400 100,500 1.1964 0.2564

71-08-25-228-020.000-002 Centre 7102020 510 002 07/11/2014 $65,650 2,300 41,600 43,900 0.6687 0.2713

71-08-25-229-003.000-002 Centre 7102020 510 002 09/16/2014 $43,000 2,500 34,400 36,900 0.8581 0.0819

71-09-30-378-016.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 04/04/2014 $77,500 9,100 70,200 79,300 1.0232 0.0832

71-09-30-402-008.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 04/16/2014 $65,000 13,900 70,000 83,900 1.2908 0.3508

71-09-30-402-005.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 04/21/2014 $81,000 12,000 68,900 80,900 0.9988 0.0588

71-09-30-476-008.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 05/02/2014 $92,000 13,600 106,100 119,700 1.3011 0.3611

71-09-30-404-015.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 05/14/2014 $89,900 17,900 72,800 90,700 1.0089 0.0689

71-09-30-457-019.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 07/09/2014 $108,000 16,000 104,000 120,000 1.1111 0.1711

71-09-30-378-022.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 07/10/2014 $97,500 15,500 75,700 91,200 0.9354 0.0046

71-09-30-456-041.000-002 Centre 7102021 551 002 07/24/2014 $86,000 6,700 66,600 73,300 0.8523 0.0877

71-09-30-329-012.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 07/28/2014 $69,000 15,500 63,000 78,500 1.1377 0.1977

71-09-30-457-014.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 07/31/2014 $75,000 12,300 71,200 83,500 1.1133 0.1733

71-09-30-327-016.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 08/19/2014 $80,000 13,200 64,100 77,300 0.9663 0.0263

71-09-30-458-012.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 09/05/2014 $122,000 13,200 92,700 105,900 0.8680 0.0720

71-09-30-480-027.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 09/24/2014 $93,000 14,000 85,900 99,900 1.0742 0.1342

71-09-30-381-006.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 09/25/2014 $117,000 15,400 86,700 102,100 0.8726 0.0674

71-09-30-480-037.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 10/08/2014 $70,000 15,000 69,500 84,500 1.2071 0.2671

71-09-30-403-004.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 10/29/2014 $87,000 15,200 66,200 81,400 0.9356 0.0044

71-09-30-453-010.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 11/21/2014 $65,000 15,400 66,000 81,400 1.2523 0.3123

71-09-30-454-003.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 01/21/2015 $81,000 14,400 66,500 80,900 0.9988 0.0588

71-09-30-452-007.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 01/21/2015 $87,500 13,200 66,000 79,200 0.9051 0.0349

71-09-30-327-012.000-002 Centre 7102021 510 002 02/12/2015 $83,000 15,600 60,700 76,300 0.9193 0.0207

71-09-30-228-027.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 06/23/2014 $202,000 18,200 167,200 185,400 0.9178 0.0222

71-09-30-206-010.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 07/25/2014 $182,000 17,000 128,300 145,300 0.7984 0.1416

71-09-30-227-003.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 08/08/2014 $95,000 22,400 66,900 89,300 0.9400 0.0000

71-09-30-255-004.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 09/12/2014 $163,000 16,400 134,400 150,800 0.9252 0.0148

71-09-30-228-016.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 12/02/2014 $90,000 16,000 70,200 86,200 0.9578 0.0178

71-09-30-201-012.000-002 Centre 7102022 510 002 12/15/2014 $122,000 12,200 147,200 159,400 1.3066 0.3666

71-09-31-126-001.000-002 Centre 7102023 510 002 06/12/2014 $155,000 32,600 108,100 140,700 0.9077 0.0323

71-09-31-128-011.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 04/02/2014 $160,100 17,600 122,000 139,600 0.8720 0.0680

71-08-36-251-035.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 05/01/2014 $95,000 26,700 91,400 118,100 1.2432 0.3032

71-09-31-102-022.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 06/18/2014 $138,000 35,000 101,200 136,200 0.9870 0.0470

71-08-36-251-020.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 07/17/2014 $132,000 24,500 98,700 123,200 0.9333 0.0067

71-08-36-231-002.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 09/24/2014 $130,000 29,500 115,800 145,300 1.1177 0.1777

71-09-31-128-014.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 11/19/2014 $190,000 23,300 146,900 170,200 0.8958 0.0442

71-08-36-205-024.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 11/26/2014 $162,500 28,900 132,500 161,400 0.9932 0.0532

71-08-36-205-017.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 12/18/2014 $135,000 27,300 129,900 157,200 1.1644 0.2244

71-08-36-251-042.000-002 Centre 7102024 510 002 12/29/2014 $160,000 34,500 106,500 141,000 0.8813 0.0588

71-08-36-205-021.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 04/07/2014 $163,000 22,300 117,900 140,200 0.8601 0.0799

71-08-36-235-013.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 04/16/2014 $210,000 38,400 158,400 196,800 0.9371 0.0029

71-08-36-205-001.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 06/09/2014 $139,000 33,100 125,000 158,100 1.1374 0.1974

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-08-36-251-041.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 07/18/2014 $219,000 34,500 146,000 180,500 0.8242 0.1158

71-08-36-276-013.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 12/12/2014 $152,500 22,800 128,300 151,100 0.9908 0.0508

71-08-36-235-022.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 01/21/2015 $190,000 24,800 137,800 162,600 0.8558 0.0842

71-09-31-103-016.000-002 Centre 7102026 510 002 02/20/2015 $110,000 25,800 96,000 121,800 1.1073 0.1673

71-09-31-258-001.000-002 Centre 7102028 510 002 07/01/2014 $146,000 9,600 125,000 134,600 0.9219 0.0181

71-09-31-256-004.000-002 Centre 7102028 510 002 07/10/2014 $210,000 9,800 174,600 184,400 0.8781 0.0619

71-09-31-252-014.000-002 Centre 7102028 510 002 08/15/2014 $125,000 10,000 98,200 108,200 0.8656 0.0744

71-09-31-253-014.000-002 Centre 7102028 510 002 09/25/2014 $130,000 8,200 108,100 116,300 0.8946 0.0454

71-08-27-200-001.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 03/05/2014 $70,000 26,900 69,300 96,200 1.3743 0.4343

71-09-31-154-003.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 05/05/2014 $118,000 24,200 94,400 118,600 1.0051 0.0651

71-09-31-178-005.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 06/03/2014 $139,000 19,700 126,500 146,200 1.0518 0.1118

71-09-31-152-007.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 06/11/2014 $103,500 23,700 74,400 98,100 0.9478 0.0078

71-09-31-178-004.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 06/11/2014 $147,900 20,500 107,400 127,900 0.8648 0.0752

71-09-31-329-001.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 07/11/2014 $133,500 27,900 104,300 132,200 0.9903 0.0503

71-09-31-326-003.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 07/14/2014 $129,000 19,600 85,800 105,400 0.8171 0.1229

71-09-31-152-021.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 08/05/2014 $120,000 24,900 84,400 109,300 0.9108 0.0292

71-09-31-177-020.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 08/26/2014 $130,900 14,600 97,500 112,100 0.8564 0.0836

71-09-31-329-018.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 10/23/2014 $175,500 20,900 147,700 168,600 0.9607 0.0207

71-09-31-153-002.000-002 Centre 7102030 510 002 12/15/2014 $127,500 24,200 71,900 96,100 0.7537 0.1863

71-09-31-177-027.000-002 Centre 7102031 510 002 04/04/2014 $130,000 16,300 114,800 131,100 1.0085 0.0685

71-09-31-177-022.000-002 Centre 7102031 510 002 05/02/2014 $119,900 17,100 82,800 99,900 0.8332 0.1068

71-09-31-177-028.000-002 Centre 7102031 510 002 08/26/2014 $145,900 23,000 110,300 133,300 0.9136 0.0264

71-09-31-181-002.000-002 Centre 7102031 510 002 11/06/2014 $149,000 20,100 117,600 137,700 0.9242 0.0158

71-08-27-200-006.000-002 Centre 7102031 510 002 12/30/2014 $225,000 74,200 87,600 161,800 0.7191 0.2209

71-08-27-200-005.000-002 Centre 7102032 500 002 12/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-27-200-015.000-002 Centre 7102003 100 002 12/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-31-434-006.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 02/20/2014 $93,000 6,300 96,600 102,900 1.1065 0.1665

71-09-31-440-007.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 07/01/2014 $120,000 6,300 101,700 108,000 0.9000 0.0400

71-09-31-439-005.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 07/10/2014 $95,000 6,300 77,200 83,500 0.8789 0.0611

71-09-31-435-013.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 07/15/2014 $120,000 7,400 107,100 114,500 0.9542 0.0142

71-09-31-438-002.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 08/08/2014 $107,000 6,300 90,100 96,400 0.9009 0.0391

71-09-31-434-004.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 08/20/2014 $80,000 6,300 103,000 109,300 1.3663 0.4263

71-09-31-435-009.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 08/25/2014 $84,900 6,500 91,000 97,500 1.1484 0.2084

71-09-31-432-015.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 09/10/2014 $115,000 6,300 97,400 103,700 0.9017 0.0383

71-09-31-431-017.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 10/27/2014 $105,000 6,300 98,100 104,400 0.9943 0.0543

71-09-31-434-020.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 11/18/2014 $117,500 6,300 97,500 103,800 0.8834 0.0566

71-09-31-439-002.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 02/10/2015 $106,500 6,300 85,500 91,800 0.8620 0.0780

71-09-31-440-008.000-002 Centre 7102035 551 002 02/18/2015 $87,500 6,300 88,800 95,100 1.0869 0.1469

71-08-36-476-020.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 03/19/2014 $205,000 33,700 154,500 188,200 0.9180 0.0220

71-08-36-476-009.000-001 Centre 7101038 599 001 03/19/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-31-381-023.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 04/08/2014 $92,500 23,000 89,900 112,900 1.2205 0.2805

71-09-31-303-011.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 04/16/2014 $148,500 17,900 124,500 142,400 0.9589 0.0189

71-09-31-353-003.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 04/22/2014 $110,000 25,700 79,900 105,600 0.9600 0.0200

71-09-31-303-006.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 05/13/2014 $124,000 23,900 134,500 158,400 1.2774 0.3374

71-09-31-455-005.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 06/18/2014 $185,000 29,900 130,700 160,600 0.8681 0.0719

71-09-31-353-005.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 07/18/2014 $156,000 26,500 96,200 122,700 0.7865 0.1535

71-09-31-377-004.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 08/21/2014 $119,000 28,400 88,900 117,300 0.9857 0.0457

71-09-31-402-002.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 10/09/2014 $157,000 17,500 128,400 145,900 0.9293 0.0107

71-09-31-306-015.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 11/10/2014 $147,000 22,900 102,400 125,300 0.8524 0.0876

71-09-31-306-011.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 11/24/2014 $121,900 29,000 97,200 126,200 1.0353 0.0953

71-09-31-456-026.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 12/12/2014 $334,900 28,900 263,700 292,600 0.8737 0.0663

71-14-06-127-001.000-002 Centre 7102040 510 002 05/29/2014 $200,000 25,000 160,900 185,900 0.9295 0.0105

71-08-25-327-005.000-002 Centre 7102042 510 002 12/23/2014 $120,000 5,600 75,000 80,600 0.6717 0.2683

71-08-25-326-014.000-002 Centre 7102042 510 002 01/12/2015 $74,900 5,400 74,000 79,400 1.0601 0.1201

71-08-25-426-018.000-002 Centre 7102044 510 002 01/09/2014 $105,000 10,300 99,700 110,000 1.0476 0.1076

71-08-36-252-008.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 03/13/2014 $197,000 13,000 183,400 196,400 0.9970 0.0570

71-08-36-279-012.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 05/30/2014 $123,000 9,700 90,300 100,000 0.8130 0.1270

71-08-36-279-023.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 07/02/2014 $135,000 10,200 137,500 147,700 1.0941 0.1541

71-08-36-401-002.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 07/08/2014 $201,000 15,100 186,700 201,800 1.0040 0.0640

71-08-36-411-005.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 07/28/2014 $207,000 14,800 162,500 177,300 0.8565 0.0835

71-08-36-279-001.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 09/11/2014 $145,900 14,900 128,500 143,400 0.9829 0.0429

71-08-36-411-013.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 10/27/2014 $255,841 12,700 182,500 195,200 0.7630 0.1770

71-08-36-402-005.000-002 Centre 7102046 510 002 01/14/2015 $185,000 13,900 157,200 171,100 0.9249 0.0151

71-08-36-278-004.000-002 Centre 7102048 510 002 02/19/2014 $220,000 18,300 229,100 247,400 1.1245 0.1845

71-08-36-278-005.000-002 Centre 7102048 510 002 09/05/2014 $183,000 20,800 145,300 166,100 0.9077 0.0323

71-08-36-228-015.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 01/22/2014 $125,500 2,600 126,200 128,800 1.0263 0.0863

71-08-36-203-001.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 05/22/2014 $124,500 2,900 95,400 98,300 0.7896 0.1504

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-08-36-228-006.000-002 Centre 7102056 510 002 06/24/2014 $125,000 3,200 138,900 142,100 1.1368 0.1968

71-08-36-230-011.000-002 Centre 7102056 510 002 06/26/2014 $153,000 6,300 137,100 143,400 0.9373 0.0027

71-14-06-102-030.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 07/03/2014 $189,900 21,400 188,100 209,500 1.1032 0.1632

71-08-36-203-019.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 09/26/2014 $127,500 2,600 125,300 127,900 1.0031 0.0631

71-08-36-229-004.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 09/26/2014 $131,000 5,900 125,100 131,000 1.0000 0.0600

71-08-36-230-012.000-002 Centre 7102056 550 002 09/26/2014 $156,900 5,900 138,300 144,200 0.9191 0.0209

71-08-36-233-002.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 09/30/2014 $98,500 5,300 126,200 131,500 1.3350 0.3950

71-14-06-102-035.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 12/01/2014 $190,600 21,400 169,100 190,500 0.9995 0.0595

71-08-36-203-016.000-002 Centre 7102056 551 002 12/22/2014 $102,500 3,200 125,000 128,200 1.2507 0.3107

71-08-36-206-005.000-002 Centre 7102057 551 002 10/29/2014 $140,000 2,900 98,600 101,500 0.7250 0.2150

71-08-36-206-006.000-002 Centre 7102057 551 002 12/09/2014 $150,000 2,900 100,300 103,200 0.6880 0.2520

71-13-02-126-066.000-002 Centre 7102062 510 002 03/18/2014 $159,500 12,100 129,400 141,500 0.8871 0.0529

71-13-02-151-024.000-002 Centre 7102062 510 002 03/31/2014 $165,000 10,900 148,900 159,800 0.9685 0.0285

71-13-02-151-088.000-002 Centre 7102062 510 002 07/25/2014 $170,000 11,400 134,700 146,100 0.8594 0.0806

71-13-02-126-062.000-002 Centre 7102062 510 002 08/05/2014 $152,000 13,800 130,900 144,700 0.9520 0.0120

71-13-02-151-074.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 02/04/2014 $155,000 14,400 132,100 146,500 0.9452 0.0052

71-13-02-251-082.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 05/07/2014 $113,000 6,700 97,200 103,900 0.9195 0.0205

71-13-02-151-038.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 07/09/2014 $224,000 13,600 163,200 176,800 0.7893 0.1507

71-13-02-151-042.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 08/12/2014 $265,000 16,600 216,100 232,700 0.8781 0.0619

71-13-02-251-063.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 08/14/2014 $166,000 11,900 139,000 150,900 0.9090 0.0310

71-13-02-151-027.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 09/12/2014 $215,000 13,600 169,700 183,300 0.8526 0.0874

71-13-02-151-056.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 11/20/2014 $193,000 12,100 161,600 173,700 0.9000 0.0400

71-13-02-251-029.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 12/03/2014 $165,000 6,400 158,100 164,500 0.9970 0.0570

71-13-02-251-034.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 12/09/2014 $171,000 6,900 146,600 153,500 0.8977 0.0423

71-09-31-477-001.000-002 Centre 7102036 510 002 02/27/2015 $164,900 41,700 120,600 162,300 0.9842 0.0442

71-13-02-251-025.000-002 Centre 7102063 510 002 12/18/2014 $182,500 7,500 134,400 141,900 0.7775 0.1625

71-08-26-451-012.000-002 Centre 7102067 510 002 09/05/2014 $184,000 20,000 143,100 163,100 0.8864 0.0536

$29,818,521 27,834,700 215

Mean 0.9621

Median 0.9400

Wtd Mean 0.9335

COD 12.7888

PRD 1.03069

CLAY TOWNSHIP

71-03-24-403-014.000-003 Clay 7102500 510 003 01/30/2014 $48,500 6,700 51,800 58,500 1.2062 0.2662

71-03-24-403-013.000-003 Clay 7103112 500 003 01/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-24-455-007.000-003 Clay 7102500 510 003 10/27/2014 $84,500 4,000 34,800 38,800 0.4592 0.4808

71-03-24-480-029.000-003 Clay 7102501 510 003 05/05/2014 $110,250 6,500 90,900 97,400 0.8834 0.0566

71-03-24-478-034.000-003 Clay 7102501 510 003 05/21/2014 $79,000 5,700 60,400 66,100 0.8367 0.1033

71-03-24-427-014.000-003 Clay 7102501 510 003 08/26/2014 $123,000 6,600 98,400 105,000 0.8537 0.0863

71-04-19-353-029.000-003 Clay 7102502 510 003 06/17/2014 $99,900 5,700 67,500 73,200 0.7327 0.2073

71-04-19-301-015.000-003 Clay 7102502 510 003 12/18/2014 $103,000 6,400 103,200 109,600 1.0641 0.1241

71-04-19-353-009.000-003 Clay 7102502 510 003 01/07/2015 $109,000 8,700 103,100 111,800 1.0257 0.0857

71-04-19-353-008.000-003 Clay 7103112 500 003 01/07/2015 $0 0 0

71-04-19-353-010.000-003 Clay 7103112 500 003 01/07/2015 $0 0 0

71-04-31-402-065.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 06/03/2014 $430,000 43,900 400,700 444,600 1.0340 0.0940

71-04-31-402-051.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 06/06/2014 $490,000 49,200 429,500 478,700 0.9769 0.0369

71-04-31-402-061.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 07/14/2014 $410,000 34,400 440,100 474,500 1.1573 0.2173

71-04-31-402-053.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 08/22/2014 $437,500 43,900 392,200 436,100 0.9968 0.0568

71-04-31-402-062.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 10/14/2014 $478,000 43,900 400,700 444,600 0.9301 0.0099

71-04-31-402-056.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 11/13/2014 $480,000 43,900 400,700 444,600 0.9263 0.0137

71-04-31-402-050.000-003 Clay 7103007 550 003 01/14/2015 $425,000 43,900 395,200 439,100 1.0332 0.0932

71-03-13-205-001.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 04/01/2014 $47,000 7,600 54,200 61,800 1.3149 0.3749

71-03-12-351-004.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 04/23/2014 $69,900 5,100 69,900 75,000 1.0730 0.1330

71-03-12-351-005.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 04/23/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-12-405-032.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 09/16/2014 $52,000 12,500 63,900 76,400 1.4692 0.5292

71-03-12-405-033.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 09/16/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-13-127-015.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 10/06/2014 $90,000 7,800 77,800 85,600 0.9511 0.0111

71-03-14-477-012.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 10/07/2014 $129,900 5,100 102,900 108,000 0.8314 0.1086

71-03-14-477-011.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 10/07/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-11-428-008.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 12/30/2014 $71,000 5,000 59,600 64,600 0.9099 0.0301

71-03-13-253-038.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 01/16/2015 $45,000 13,900 42,000 55,900 1.2422 0.3022

71-03-13-253-034.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 01/16/2015 $0 0 0

71-03-13-253-033.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 01/16/2015 $0 0 0

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-13-208-011.000-003 Clay 7103034 510 003 02/18/2015 $115,000 17,700 61,800 79,500 0.6913 0.2487

71-03-13-208-010.000-003 Clay 7103095 500 003 02/18/2015 $0 0 0

71-04-07-426-003.000-003 Clay 7103036 510 003 08/26/2014 $277,500 8,300 150,400 158,700 0.5719 0.3681

71-04-18-200-036.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 01/14/2014 $438,615 31,200 487,900 519,100 1.1835 0.2435

71-04-18-200-088.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 05/28/2014 $559,000 24,800 529,300 554,100 0.9912 0.0512

71-04-18-200-081.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 09/04/2014 $467,906 14,800 464,800 479,600 1.0250 0.0850

71-04-30-278-019.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 11/24/2014 $232,500 22,300 237,700 260,000 1.1183 0.1783

71-04-18-200-034.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 12/18/2014 $474,200 28,300 369,600 397,900 0.8391 0.1009

71-04-18-200-104.000-003 Clay 7103037 510 003 12/22/2014 $485,435 45,900 412,400 458,300 0.9441 0.0041

71-04-08-478-020.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 01/30/2014 $205,000 26,600 137,500 164,100 0.8005 0.1395

71-04-08-401-009.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 02/05/2014 $154,000 26,600 126,500 153,100 0.9942 0.0542

71-04-08-326-005.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 03/04/2014 $231,500 27,100 172,600 199,700 0.8626 0.0774

71-04-08-352-004.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 03/19/2014 $202,000 25,100 129,600 154,700 0.7658 0.1742

71-04-08-330-006.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 03/24/2014 $185,600 23,900 185,700 209,600 1.1293 0.1893

71-04-09-302-025.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 04/01/2014 $229,500 25,600 180,000 205,600 0.8959 0.0441

71-04-08-307-012.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 04/04/2014 $157,000 26,200 145,800 172,000 1.0955 0.1555

71-04-09-452-010.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 04/22/2014 $170,000 28,900 143,600 172,500 1.0147 0.0747

71-04-09-326-007.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 04/23/2014 $170,000 25,100 119,800 144,900 0.8524 0.0876

71-04-08-427-026.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 05/05/2014 $164,000 24,900 153,600 178,500 1.0884 0.1484

71-04-08-427-003.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 05/08/2014 $173,000 26,100 141,100 167,200 0.9665 0.0265

71-04-08-377-003.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 05/24/2014 $192,500 38,800 193,600 232,400 1.2073 0.2673

71-04-08-377-002.000-003 Clay 7103099 500 003 05/24/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-08-451-061.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 05/30/2014 $280,000 32,700 189,600 222,300 0.7939 0.1461

71-04-08-452-005.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 06/17/2014 $166,000 34,900 150,600 185,500 1.1175 0.1775

71-04-08-403-027.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 06/24/2014 $255,000 30,400 224,100 254,500 0.9980 0.0580

71-04-08-326-001.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 07/09/2014 $245,000 32,800 168,500 201,300 0.8216 0.1184

71-04-09-452-004.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 07/17/2014 $172,000 25,900 151,400 177,300 1.0308 0.0908

71-04-08-301-002.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 07/17/2014 $225,000 29,800 140,000 169,800 0.7547 0.1853

71-04-08-330-011.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 07/24/2014 $225,000 26,300 155,000 181,300 0.8058 0.1342

71-04-08-326-008.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 07/30/2014 $206,000 29,400 168,900 198,300 0.9626 0.0226

71-04-09-476-006.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/05/2014 $191,500 26,100 146,400 172,500 0.9008 0.0392

71-04-08-403-017.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/06/2014 $218,000 28,100 138,100 166,200 0.7624 0.1776

71-04-09-329-008.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/07/2014 $170,300 26,100 144,000 170,100 0.9988 0.0588

71-04-09-427-001.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/11/2014 $170,000 24,900 166,600 191,500 1.1265 0.1865

71-04-09-329-002.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/21/2014 $250,000 26,500 205,100 231,600 0.9264 0.0136

71-04-09-327-002.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 08/25/2014 $206,000 24,900 148,200 173,100 0.8403 0.0997

71-04-08-429-002.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 09/04/2014 $188,000 22,500 163,600 186,100 0.9899 0.0499

71-04-09-351-015.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 10/22/2014 $220,000 28,000 187,000 215,000 0.9773 0.0373

71-04-08-403-009.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 11/12/2014 $329,900 31,300 221,100 252,400 0.7651 0.1749

71-04-08-403-004.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 01/22/2015 $415,000 53,700 358,300 412,000 0.9928 0.0528

71-04-09-351-007.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 02/18/2015 $182,000 23,700 130,400 154,100 0.8467 0.0933

71-04-08-451-013.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 02/26/2015 $180,000 26,100 134,600 160,700 0.8928 0.0472

71-04-16-260-016.000-003 Clay 7103040 510 003 02/21/2014 $235,000 32,100 180,000 212,100 0.9026 0.0374

71-04-16-401-002.000-003 Clay 7103040 510 003 09/17/2014 $215,000 40,100 164,500 204,600 0.9516 0.0116

71-04-16-251-005.000-003 Clay 7103040 510 003 09/29/2014 $201,000 46,000 179,800 225,800 1.1234 0.1834

71-04-16-263-004.000-003 Clay 7103040 510 003 12/30/2014 $328,000 63,600 229,200 292,800 0.8927 0.0473

71-04-16-255-004.000-003 Clay 7103040 510 003 01/14/2015 $210,000 44,300 168,400 212,700 1.0129 0.0729

71-04-16-427-005.000-003 Clay 7103041 510 003 04/14/2014 $385,750 61,000 248,600 309,600 0.8026 0.1374

71-04-16-427-009.000-003 Clay 7103041 510 003 05/02/2014 $375,000 67,000 311,400 378,400 1.0091 0.0691

71-04-16-429-005.000-003 Clay 7103041 510 003 06/18/2014 $379,000 59,300 319,800 379,100 1.0003 0.0603

71-04-16-230-003.000-003 Clay 7103041 510 003 08/01/2014 $285,000 55,000 228,300 283,300 0.9940 0.0540

71-04-16-404-003.000-003 Clay 7103041 510 003 02/26/2015 $232,500 70,000 224,500 294,500 1.2667 0.3267

71-03-12-427-023.000-003 Clay 7103042 510 003 06/13/2014 $158,500 22,600 102,600 125,200 0.7899 0.1501

71-03-12-427-025.000-003 Clay 7103042 510 003 08/11/2014 $164,000 17,100 150,000 167,100 1.0189 0.0789

71-04-16-453-023.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 02/13/2014 $130,000 11,700 115,400 127,100 0.9777 0.0377

71-04-16-407-013.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 05/08/2014 $117,000 10,700 110,300 121,000 1.0342 0.0942

71-04-16-477-010.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 06/12/2014 $130,000 10,400 117,400 127,800 0.9831 0.0431

71-04-16-453-028.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 06/23/2014 $135,000 12,100 145,800 157,900 1.1696 0.2296

71-04-16-453-001.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 09/10/2014 $375,000 11,500 298,400 309,900 0.8264 0.1136

71-04-16-476-023.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 11/03/2014 $135,000 13,300 132,800 146,100 1.0822 0.1422

71-04-16-478-002.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 11/06/2014 $127,500 10,200 120,400 130,600 1.0243 0.0843

71-04-16-453-002.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 12/29/2014 $273,000 10,900 268,000 278,900 1.0216 0.0816

71-04-17-452-009.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 02/25/2014 $167,000 17,700 151,100 168,800 1.0108 0.0708

71-04-17-376-004.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 03/17/2014 $193,500 20,900 149,900 170,800 0.8827 0.0573

71-04-20-253-003.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 03/26/2014 $212,000 19,600 172,200 191,800 0.9047 0.0353

71-04-17-331-009.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 04/07/2014 $214,000 20,400 148,200 168,600 0.7879 0.1521

71-04-17-451-010.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 05/27/2014 $157,000 17,300 122,500 139,800 0.8904 0.0496

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-20-252-005.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 06/20/2014 $280,000 23,400 222,500 245,900 0.8782 0.0618

71-04-17-452-028.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 07/03/2014 $178,500 15,300 118,600 133,900 0.7501 0.1899

71-04-17-327-004.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 08/01/2014 $168,500 18,300 141,500 159,800 0.9484 0.0084

71-04-20-201-020.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 08/06/2014 $194,000 19,400 187,700 207,100 1.0675 0.1275

71-04-17-451-013.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 08/06/2014 $173,000 17,500 147,300 164,800 0.9526 0.0126

71-04-17-377-008.000-003 Clay 7103044 520 003 08/07/2014 $185,200 13,100 164,000 177,100 0.9563 0.0163

71-04-17-377-007.000-003 Clay 7103102 500 003 08/07/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-17-329-022.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 08/18/2014 $206,000 22,400 156,200 178,600 0.8670 0.0730

71-04-17-380-001.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 09/08/2014 $249,000 25,000 195,900 220,900 0.8871 0.0529

71-04-17-380-011.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 10/20/2014 $252,000 26,900 227,900 254,800 1.0111 0.0711

71-04-17-377-010.000-003 Clay 7103044 520 003 11/13/2014 $159,500 4,300 170,100 174,400 1.0934 0.1534

71-04-20-201-017.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 12/02/2014 $190,000 18,700 156,700 175,400 0.9232 0.0168

71-04-17-452-014.000-003 Clay 7103044 510 003 12/03/2014 $179,000 18,500 148,700 167,200 0.9341 0.0059

71-04-20-178-010.000-003 Clay 7103045 510 003 06/04/2014 $305,000 22,600 183,000 205,600 0.6741 0.2659

71-04-20-128-013.000-003 Clay 7103045 510 003 12/31/2014 $352,500 24,600 206,500 231,100 0.6556 0.2844

71-04-17-301-006.000-003 Clay 7103046 510 003 10/08/2014 $91,500 20,600 57,500 78,100 0.8536 0.0864

71-04-17-105-008.000-003 Clay 7103047 510 003 10/20/2014 $193,000 19,500 153,900 173,400 0.8984 0.0416

71-04-17-106-003.000-003 Clay 7103047 510 003 11/06/2014 $214,000 13,800 156,400 170,200 0.7953 0.1447

71-04-17-179-001.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 02/04/2014 $808,000 38,100 777,100 815,200 1.0089 0.0689

71-04-16-376-008.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 02/25/2014 $163,000 37,300 98,600 135,900 0.8337 0.1063

71-04-17-254-002.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 04/02/2014 $930,000 35,100 900,900 936,000 1.0065 0.0665

71-04-17-127-007.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 04/11/2014 $589,500 39,200 621,200 660,400 1.1203 0.1803

71-04-17-405-003.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 12/09/2014 $480,000 48,000 348,400 396,400 0.8258 0.1142

71-04-17-176-005.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 12/30/2014 $1,475,000 40,400 1,431,700 1,472,100 0.9980 0.0580

71-03-13-276-025.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 03/21/2014 $315,000 28,900 298,100 327,000 1.0381 0.0981

71-04-07-402-006.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 06/24/2014 $176,000 26,800 150,100 176,900 1.0051 0.0651

71-04-18-200-055.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 07/01/2014 $525,000 15,300 445,600 460,900 0.8779 0.0621

71-04-18-200-037.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 07/18/2014 $285,000 27,800 288,700 316,500 1.1105 0.1705

71-04-30-278-027.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 07/28/2014 $169,900 15,300 167,300 182,600 1.0747 0.1347

71-04-18-200-101.000-003 Clay 7103049 510 003 09/09/2014 $531,000 24,700 554,500 579,200 1.0908 0.1508

71-04-20-104-007.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 01/22/2014 $183,000 28,000 143,000 171,000 0.9344 0.0056

71-04-20-155-013.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 02/26/2014 $137,000 44,000 109,700 153,700 1.1219 0.1819

71-04-20-304-014.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 04/30/2014 $170,000 28,300 106,400 134,700 0.7924 0.1476

71-04-17-351-008.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 05/30/2014 $182,500 22,400 145,300 167,700 0.9189 0.0211

71-04-17-351-009.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 06/02/2014 $235,000 26,900 166,500 193,400 0.8230 0.1170

71-04-20-102-012.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 06/12/2014 $170,000 24,000 146,600 170,600 1.0035 0.0635

71-04-17-351-016.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 07/03/2014 $209,000 23,200 166,900 190,100 0.9096 0.0304

71-04-20-126-022.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 07/15/2014 $160,000 47,500 91,000 138,500 0.8656 0.0744

71-04-20-153-002.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 08/06/2014 $123,000 28,500 98,600 127,100 1.0333 0.0933

71-04-20-157-004.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 08/21/2014 $136,000 42,800 130,900 173,700 1.2772 0.3372

71-04-20-176-012.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 09/02/2014 $126,000 31,800 103,500 135,300 1.0738 0.1338

71-04-17-352-002.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 10/10/2014 $204,250 23,700 138,400 162,100 0.7936 0.1464

71-04-20-157-003.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 12/31/2014 $144,900 46,300 117,200 163,500 1.1284 0.1884

71-04-20-157-002.000-003 Clay 7103105 500 003 12/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-20-302-003.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 01/29/2015 $150,000 26,000 109,700 135,700 0.9047 0.0353

71-04-21-127-012.000-003 Clay 7103051 510 003 09/22/2014 $135,500 28,800 80,400 109,200 0.8059 0.1341

71-04-21-176-020.000-003 Clay 7103051 510 003 02/18/2015 $138,000 22,800 88,000 110,800 0.8029 0.1371

71-04-21-226-008.000-003 Clay 7103052 510 003 03/20/2014 $512,450 48,400 427,700 476,100 0.9291 0.0109

71-04-21-277-033.000-003 Clay 7103052 510 003 06/04/2014 $105,000 48,500 82,900 131,400 1.2514 0.3114

71-04-21-426-037.000-003 Clay 7103052 510 003 09/02/2014 $303,448 26,200 278,200 304,400 1.0031 0.0631

71-04-21-426-036.000-003 Clay 7103052 510 003 10/30/2014 $285,497 27,200 224,800 252,000 0.8827 0.0573

71-04-21-277-030.000-003 Clay 7103052 510 003 12/02/2014 $80,000 43,600 52,500 96,100 1.2013 0.2613

71-04-21-404-001.000-003 Clay 7103053 510 003 09/03/2014 $145,000 15,100 97,100 112,200 0.7738 0.1662

71-04-21-251-004.000-003 Clay 7103054 510 003 02/20/2014 $181,500 28,800 136,100 164,900 0.9085 0.0315

71-04-21-254-011.000-003 Clay 7103054 510 003 06/26/2014 $199,000 26,400 143,900 170,300 0.8558 0.0842

71-04-20-429-015.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 03/14/2014 $300,000 21,600 273,600 295,200 0.9840 0.0440

71-04-20-429-002.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 06/17/2014 $253,500 17,100 208,500 225,600 0.8899 0.0501

71-04-20-430-004.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 09/22/2014 $278,000 23,600 243,100 266,700 0.9594 0.0194

71-04-21-352-015.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 09/23/2014 $273,000 23,900 232,000 255,900 0.9374 0.0026

71-04-20-476-024.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 10/13/2014 $322,500 22,800 306,800 329,600 1.0220 0.0820

71-04-20-476-032.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 10/27/2014 $277,500 28,200 249,000 277,200 0.9989 0.0589

71-04-20-476-022.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 11/25/2014 $298,000 29,200 312,900 342,100 1.1480 0.2080

71-04-20-476-016.000-003 Clay 7103056 510 003 12/08/2014 $264,999 27,100 261,100 288,200 1.0876 0.1476

71-04-20-377-001.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 01/30/2014 $145,000 24,900 128,700 153,600 1.0593 0.1193

71-04-20-328-025.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 02/26/2014 $135,000 17,700 114,500 132,200 0.9793 0.0393

71-04-20-453-010.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 04/25/2014 $105,000 18,700 87,900 106,600 1.0152 0.0752

71-04-20-453-012.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 04/29/2014 $100,000 16,100 81,500 97,600 0.9760 0.0360

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-20-326-005.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 05/21/2014 $150,000 16,800 139,300 156,100 1.0407 0.1007

71-04-20-476-004.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 06/04/2014 $96,500 15,700 82,100 97,800 1.0135 0.0735

71-04-20-428-006.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 07/03/2014 $95,000 15,700 91,900 107,600 1.1326 0.1926

71-04-20-451-013.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 07/15/2014 $168,500 16,800 140,000 156,800 0.9306 0.0094

71-04-20-452-005.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 07/24/2014 $154,900 16,500 125,600 142,100 0.9174 0.0226

71-04-20-401-005.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 08/14/2014 $115,000 17,600 143,900 161,500 1.4043 0.4643

71-04-20-428-009.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 09/18/2014 $92,500 15,700 90,300 106,000 1.1459 0.2059

71-04-20-328-029.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 09/30/2014 $155,000 17,700 125,900 143,600 0.9265 0.0135

71-04-20-377-010.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 10/06/2014 $105,000 15,700 104,200 119,900 1.1419 0.2019

71-04-20-329-001.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 10/06/2014 $175,500 16,000 147,700 163,700 0.9328 0.0072

71-04-20-401-012.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 10/20/2014 $127,000 22,300 95,600 117,900 0.9283 0.0117

71-04-20-453-008.000-003 Clay 7103058 510 003 02/24/2015 $119,000 17,500 88,800 106,300 0.8933 0.0467

71-04-18-477-017.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 01/14/2014 $175,000 54,000 119,200 173,200 0.9897 0.0497

71-04-19-226-084.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 01/22/2014 $170,000 17,500 143,100 160,600 0.9447 0.0047

71-04-19-203-008.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 04/07/2014 $120,000 29,900 108,000 137,900 1.1492 0.2092

71-04-18-455-006.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 05/15/2014 $192,000 53,100 132,400 185,500 0.9661 0.0261

71-04-19-203-010.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 06/03/2014 $126,000 24,800 101,500 126,300 1.0024 0.0624

71-04-19-202-002.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 06/10/2014 $117,000 22,000 76,000 98,000 0.8376 0.1024

71-04-18-455-008.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 07/03/2014 $165,000 27,500 121,500 149,000 0.9030 0.0370

71-04-18-478-017.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 07/07/2014 $195,200 27,300 122,100 149,400 0.7654 0.1746

71-04-19-226-114.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 07/09/2014 $235,000 18,100 158,900 177,000 0.7532 0.1868

71-04-18-476-019.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 07/22/2014 $168,000 27,200 121,500 148,700 0.8851 0.0549

71-04-19-202-006.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 08/05/2014 $128,000 24,200 75,500 99,700 0.7789 0.1611

71-04-18-376-020.000-003 Clay 7103060 550 003 09/19/2014 $140,000 17,900 99,100 117,000 0.8357 0.1043

71-04-18-476-007.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 09/24/2014 $155,000 26,600 114,600 141,200 0.9110 0.0290

71-04-19-226-091.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 09/25/2014 $175,000 17,900 126,300 144,200 0.8240 0.1160

71-04-18-478-020.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 10/17/2014 $130,000 27,000 130,400 157,400 1.2108 0.2708

71-04-19-226-085.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 12/23/2014 $168,000 17,500 130,000 147,500 0.8780 0.0620

71-04-18-478-031.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 01/14/2015 $141,000 30,200 95,000 125,200 0.8879 0.0521

71-04-18-452-009.000-003 Clay 7103060 520 003 02/27/2015 $147,000 22,200 109,900 132,100 0.8986 0.0414

71-04-16-329-010.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 01/09/2014 $488,000 81,200 400,100 481,300 0.9863 0.0463

71-04-16-151-006.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 04/21/2014 $550,000 104,500 406,900 511,400 0.9298 0.0102

71-04-16-176-007.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 04/29/2014 $850,000 124,000 460,400 584,400 0.6875 0.2525

71-04-16-179-001.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 06/23/2014 $675,000 118,700 543,500 662,200 0.9810 0.0410

71-04-16-329-006.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 07/10/2014 $625,000 90,300 570,800 661,100 1.0578 0.1178

71-04-16-177-003.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 09/10/2014 $540,000 81,500 324,600 406,100 0.7520 0.1880

71-04-16-151-010.000-003 Clay 7103061 510 003 12/09/2014 $599,000 85,800 364,600 450,400 0.7519 0.1881

71-04-19-402-004.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 02/06/2014 $128,500 16,800 91,500 108,300 0.8428 0.0972

71-04-19-179-049.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 03/19/2014 $171,000 9,500 127,200 136,700 0.7994 0.1406

71-04-19-404-013.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 03/21/2014 $143,000 25,200 115,700 140,900 0.9853 0.0453

71-04-19-426-005.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 03/21/2014 $122,000 19,100 80,100 99,200 0.8131 0.1269

71-04-19-405-007.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 04/15/2014 $88,000 17,900 64,200 82,100 0.9330 0.0070

71-03-12-330-013.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 05/07/2014 $100,000 11,700 77,900 89,600 0.8960 0.0440

71-04-19-380-007.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 05/14/2014 $120,500 11,500 102,700 114,200 0.9477 0.0077

71-04-19-254-013.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 06/26/2014 $121,800 14,900 88,000 102,900 0.8448 0.0952

71-03-12-332-018.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 06/27/2014 $92,500 11,800 76,800 88,600 0.9578 0.0178

71-04-19-177-017.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 07/14/2014 $158,000 9,200 125,400 134,600 0.8519 0.0881

71-04-19-178-003.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 07/18/2014 $130,000 9,900 111,400 121,300 0.9331 0.0069

71-03-12-326-009.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 07/21/2014 $105,500 13,400 81,800 95,200 0.9024 0.0376

71-04-19-228-035.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 08/20/2014 $128,500 21,000 90,400 111,400 0.8669 0.0731

71-04-19-405-010.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 08/28/2014 $123,000 18,400 76,900 95,300 0.7748 0.1652

71-04-19-179-053.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 08/29/2014 $157,000 8,200 119,100 127,300 0.8108 0.1292

71-04-19-277-002.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 09/18/2014 $87,500 18,400 78,900 97,300 1.1120 0.1720

71-04-19-253-015.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 09/18/2014 $118,500 17,500 79,700 97,200 0.8203 0.1197

71-04-19-378-011.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 10/09/2014 $150,000 16,500 110,700 127,200 0.8480 0.0920

71-04-19-403-005.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 10/09/2014 $124,500 18,400 102,700 121,100 0.9727 0.0327

71-03-12-332-022.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 10/10/2014 $65,000 11,800 75,300 87,100 1.3400 0.4000

71-03-12-328-009.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 11/13/2014 $102,500 11,800 81,600 93,400 0.9112 0.0288

71-04-19-276-013.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 12/03/2014 $130,000 16,800 80,900 97,700 0.7515 0.1885

71-04-19-381-004.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 12/12/2014 $123,500 18,100 82,700 100,800 0.8162 0.1238

71-04-19-427-002.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 12/12/2014 $89,000 20,900 77,400 98,300 1.1045 0.1645

71-03-12-403-006.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 12/17/2014 $95,000 11,700 76,100 87,800 0.9242 0.0158

71-03-12-331-002.000-003 Clay 7103062 510 003 02/10/2015 $85,000 11,100 99,000 110,100 1.2953 0.3553

71-04-18-301-009.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 02/10/2014 $150,000 19,500 75,200 94,700 0.6313 0.3087

71-04-18-301-010.000-003 Clay 7103111 500 003 02/10/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-13-428-020.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 02/11/2014 $65,000 17,700 37,300 55,000 0.8462 0.0938

71-03-13-428-019.000-003 Clay 7103111 500 003 02/11/2014 $0 0 0

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-24-228-013.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 04/30/2014 $161,000 9,200 151,500 160,700 0.9981 0.0581

71-03-13-428-008.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 06/09/2014 $178,942 13,900 180,800 194,700 1.0881 0.1481

71-03-13-428-009.000-003 Clay 7103111 500 003 06/09/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-13-476-010.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 08/19/2014 $79,900 10,300 100,800 111,100 1.3905 0.4505

71-04-19-151-014.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 10/03/2014 $105,000 22,000 55,700 77,700 0.7400 0.2000

71-03-13-477-010.000-003 Clay 7103063 510 003 02/25/2015 $121,500 10,300 132,900 143,200 1.1786 0.2386

71-03-24-208-009.000-003 Clay 7103064 510 003 03/04/2014 $50,132 7,200 55,600 62,800 1.2527 0.3127

71-03-24-208-010.000-003 Clay 7103112 500 003 03/04/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-24-208-008.000-003 Clay 7103112 500 003 03/04/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-24-258-014.000-003 Clay 7103064 510 003 04/14/2014 $105,000 9,900 100,400 110,300 1.0505 0.1105

71-03-24-256-013.000-003 Clay 7103064 510 003 05/07/2014 $64,000 2,500 45,400 47,900 0.7484 0.1916

71-03-24-253-023.000-003 Clay 7103064 510 003 12/29/2014 $60,000 5,000 59,800 64,800 1.0800 0.1400

71-03-24-327-013.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 01/22/2014 $63,900 9,600 72,500 82,100 1.2848 0.3448

71-03-13-329-009.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 03/12/2014 $70,000 11,000 61,500 72,500 1.0357 0.0957

71-03-24-329-016.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 04/08/2014 $76,400 12,400 49,300 61,700 0.8076 0.1324

71-03-24-178-010.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 04/21/2014 $64,000 11,700 54,100 65,800 1.0281 0.0881

71-03-13-451-001.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 05/21/2014 $128,000 30,300 62,200 92,500 0.7227 0.2173

71-03-13-329-007.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 06/02/2014 $84,000 16,500 52,800 69,300 0.8250 0.1150

71-03-24-180-019.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 06/13/2014 $52,000 10,100 55,200 65,300 1.2558 0.3158

71-03-24-329-008.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 07/30/2014 $80,000 15,600 73,700 89,300 1.1163 0.1763

71-03-13-330-004.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 08/26/2014 $71,000 11,800 50,600 62,400 0.8789 0.0611

71-03-24-326-015.000-003 Clay 7103065 510 003 10/27/2014 $35,000 8,100 40,900 49,000 1.4000 0.4600

71-03-23-253-008.000-003 Clay 7103066 510 003 05/28/2014 $128,000 15,500 102,700 118,200 0.9234 0.0166

71-03-23-276-037.000-003 Clay 7103066 510 003 11/18/2014 $137,000 15,400 119,100 134,500 0.9818 0.0418

71-03-24-101-017.000-003 Clay 7103066 510 003 12/22/2014 $110,000 16,300 85,400 101,700 0.9245 0.0155

71-03-23-427-009.000-003 Clay 7103068 510 003 04/21/2014 $179,500 29,500 141,400 170,900 0.9521 0.0121

71-03-23-427-021.000-003 Clay 7103068 510 003 09/22/2014 $167,000 14,900 123,300 138,200 0.8275 0.1125

71-03-14-331-004.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 02/20/2014 $130,000 6,300 111,200 117,500 0.9038 0.0362

71-03-14-330-001.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 02/28/2014 $219,436 33,000 150,100 183,100 0.8344 0.1056

71-03-14-330-002.000-003 Clay 7103116 500 003 02/28/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-14-377-008.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 03/21/2014 $129,900 8,500 145,700 154,200 1.1871 0.2471

71-03-14-408-003.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 04/21/2014 $146,900 5,000 122,400 127,400 0.8673 0.0727

71-03-14-406-008.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 05/14/2014 $135,000 5,200 101,300 106,500 0.7889 0.1511

71-03-14-380-009.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 05/15/2014 $155,000 6,500 120,400 126,900 0.8187 0.1213

71-03-14-376-003.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 07/18/2014 $134,000 7,700 115,400 123,100 0.9187 0.0213

71-03-14-380-023.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 08/21/2014 $130,000 6,400 121,900 128,300 0.9869 0.0469

71-03-14-381-007.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 09/04/2014 $116,500 6,400 103,800 110,200 0.9459 0.0059

71-03-14-329-001.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 10/27/2014 $125,000 8,600 124,000 132,600 1.0608 0.1208

71-03-14-408-001.000-003 Clay 7103070 510 003 02/27/2015 $156,000 5,600 121,200 126,800 0.8128 0.1272

71-03-25-228-012.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 04/23/2014 $137,200 24,600 117,300 141,900 1.0343 0.0943

71-04-30-201-002.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 05/30/2014 $118,000 24,300 81,900 106,200 0.9000 0.0400

71-03-25-230-005.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 07/17/2014 $110,000 22,500 85,900 108,400 0.9855 0.0455

71-04-30-128-004.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 07/18/2014 $220,000 19,100 168,800 187,900 0.8541 0.0859

71-04-30-254-050.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 08/15/2014 $395,000 88,000 264,200 352,200 0.8916 0.0484

71-04-30-251-013.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 08/28/2014 $352,837 17,500 266,200 283,700 0.8041 0.1359

71-03-25-231-008.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 08/29/2014 $70,000 22,200 53,300 75,500 1.0786 0.1386

71-04-30-127-014.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 09/10/2014 $281,000 24,300 230,600 254,900 0.9071 0.0329

71-04-30-128-009.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 10/09/2014 $165,000 19,500 146,600 166,100 1.0067 0.0667

71-04-30-103-010.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 11/05/2014 $134,900 24,600 148,000 172,600 1.2795 0.3395

71-03-25-202-016.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 12/01/2014 $73,505 28,200 85,400 113,600 1.5455 0.6055

71-03-25-277-010.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 01/14/2015 $195,000 27,500 143,000 170,500 0.8744 0.0656

71-04-30-103-019.000-003 Clay 7103072 510 003 01/30/2015 $140,000 20,800 131,500 152,300 1.0879 0.1479

71-04-29-176-007.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 01/17/2014 $145,000 12,700 125,100 137,800 0.9503 0.0103

71-04-29-177-008.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 02/19/2014 $145,000 13,400 141,900 155,300 1.0710 0.1310

71-04-29-102-012.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 03/31/2014 $175,500 16,100 141,500 157,600 0.8980 0.0420

71-04-29-253-026.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 04/10/2014 $125,500 14,200 106,600 120,800 0.9625 0.0225

71-04-29-202-015.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 04/30/2014 $131,500 12,200 89,900 102,100 0.7764 0.1636

71-04-28-105-003.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 05/14/2014 $147,500 13,100 158,900 172,000 1.1661 0.2261

71-04-29-255-003.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 07/15/2014 $150,000 14,400 142,300 156,700 1.0447 0.1047

71-04-28-151-007.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 07/18/2014 $80,500 13,800 77,100 90,900 1.1292 0.1892

71-04-29-254-014.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 07/29/2014 $139,000 14,100 96,900 111,000 0.7986 0.1414

71-04-29-152-004.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 08/01/2014 $122,000 16,200 114,500 130,700 1.0713 0.1313

71-04-30-230-009.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 08/25/2014 $175,000 23,700 138,900 162,600 0.9291 0.0109

71-04-29-179-002.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 09/05/2014 $117,000 13,700 111,900 125,600 1.0735 0.1335

71-04-30-279-002.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 09/15/2014 $225,000 24,200 167,900 192,100 0.8538 0.0862

71-04-29-202-014.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 09/16/2014 $115,533 12,200 86,700 98,900 0.8560 0.0840

71-04-29-103-016.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 09/29/2014 $196,000 16,200 120,700 136,900 0.6985 0.2415

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-29-104-006.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 10/09/2014 $211,500 16,200 188,500 204,700 0.9678 0.0278

71-04-29-127-010.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 11/24/2014 $155,000 14,100 147,800 161,900 1.0445 0.1045

71-04-28-103-004.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 12/08/2014 $135,000 19,000 140,400 159,400 1.1807 0.2407

71-04-29-151-009.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 12/17/2014 $136,900 23,700 121,100 144,800 1.0577 0.1177

71-04-30-230-002.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 12/22/2014 $179,900 23,300 160,900 184,200 1.0239 0.0839

71-04-29-254-003.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 12/29/2014 $144,900 12,900 105,000 117,900 0.8137 0.1263

71-04-29-251-001.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 01/23/2015 $100,000 12,400 101,100 113,500 1.1350 0.1950

71-04-29-102-005.000-003 Clay 7103074 510 003 01/29/2015 $205,000 32,300 147,000 179,300 0.8746 0.0654

71-04-29-276-004.000-003 Clay 7103075 510 003 05/22/2014 $179,500 7,500 118,700 126,200 0.7031 0.2369

71-04-31-277-008.000-003 Clay 7103077 510 003 09/10/2014 $81,500 12,900 53,900 66,800 0.8196 0.1204

71-04-31-277-007.000-003 Clay 7103122 500 003 09/10/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-31-253-004.000-003 Clay 7103077 510 003 11/06/2014 $83,000 7,800 43,500 51,300 0.6181 0.3219

71-04-32-276-002.000-003 Clay 7103080 510 003 12/17/2014 $157,000 41,200 91,700 132,900 0.8465 0.0935

71-04-32-181-001.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 05/07/2014 $105,000 17,100 58,500 75,600 0.7200 0.2200

71-04-32-258-004.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 05/29/2014 $85,000 28,300 70,600 98,900 1.1635 0.2235

71-04-32-128-032.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 07/11/2014 $98,500 23,700 68,900 92,600 0.9401 0.0001

71-04-32-177-016.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 08/05/2014 $81,000 17,600 68,600 86,200 1.0642 0.1242

71-04-32-205-004.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 09/17/2014 $150,000 32,000 109,000 141,000 0.9400 0.0000

71-04-32-181-008.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 09/30/2014 $77,000 18,700 49,000 67,700 0.8792 0.0608

71-04-32-252-007.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 10/08/2014 $97,000 30,100 36,900 67,000 0.6907 0.2493

71-04-32-180-009.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 11/13/2014 $64,000 20,500 52,700 73,200 1.1438 0.2038

71-04-32-255-006.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 12/31/2014 $56,500 20,600 42,800 63,400 1.1221 0.1821

71-04-32-205-006.000-003 Clay 7103082 510 003 02/19/2015 $145,000 30,500 112,500 143,000 0.9862 0.0462

71-04-18-253-020.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 05/09/2014 $186,000 35,400 139,700 175,100 0.9414 0.0014

71-04-18-253-011.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 06/05/2014 $180,000 34,100 143,500 177,600 0.9867 0.0467

71-04-18-253-008.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 06/05/2014 $208,000 34,300 145,500 179,800 0.8644 0.0756

71-04-18-281-005.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 07/03/2014 $230,900 68,000 130,000 198,000 0.8575 0.0825

71-04-18-252-005.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 07/09/2014 $175,000 31,500 120,700 152,200 0.8697 0.0703

71-04-18-278-005.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 08/08/2014 $182,151 36,500 127,900 164,400 0.9025 0.0375

71-04-18-280-023.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 08/14/2014 $217,500 32,100 212,800 244,900 1.1260 0.1860

71-04-18-280-017.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 09/15/2014 $172,500 34,400 120,500 154,900 0.8980 0.0420

71-04-18-280-002.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 12/23/2014 $261,000 39,300 203,500 242,800 0.9303 0.0097

71-04-18-251-007.000-003 Clay 7103093 510 003 12/30/2014 $185,000 31,500 112,800 144,300 0.7800 0.1600

71-04-18-251-003.000-003 Clay 7103094 510 003 06/06/2014 $224,500 46,700 145,200 191,900 0.8548 0.0852

71-04-18-280-003.000-003 Clay 7103094 510 003 06/11/2014 $158,000 32,900 115,700 148,600 0.9405 0.0005

71-04-18-251-002.000-003 Clay 7103094 510 003 09/02/2014 $223,000 39,500 149,600 189,100 0.8480 0.0920

71-04-07-402-012.000-003 Clay 7103098 510 003 02/06/2014 $289,999 30,500 234,000 264,500 0.9121 0.0279

71-04-30-252-004.000-003 Clay 7103098 510 003 06/06/2014 $382,250 22,500 246,000 268,500 0.7024 0.2376

71-04-18-253-025.000-003 Clay 7103098 510 003 07/03/2014 $217,000 25,000 203,300 228,300 1.0521 0.1121

71-04-07-401-012.000-003 Clay 7103098 510 003 10/07/2014 $180,000 30,500 211,300 241,800 1.3433 0.4033

71-04-30-252-006.000-003 Clay 7103098 510 003 10/30/2014 $295,000 24,500 269,400 293,900 0.9963 0.0563

71-04-18-477-002.000-003 Clay 7103109 510 003 11/07/2014 $232,000 9,500 192,400 201,900 0.8703 0.0697

71-03-14-405-034.000-003 Clay 7103116 510 003 06/09/2014 $139,000 10,700 116,000 126,700 0.9115 0.0285

71-03-14-405-020.000-003 Clay 7103116 510 003 02/10/2015 $131,000 9,800 107,300 117,100 0.8939 0.0461

71-03-25-251-012.000-003 Clay 7103118 510 003 04/30/2014 $305,500 10,200 180,700 190,900 0.6249 0.3151

71-03-25-251-018.000-003 Clay 7103118 510 003 06/03/2014 $295,000 22,600 194,700 217,300 0.7366 0.2034

71-03-25-251-011.000-003 Clay 7103118 510 003 06/09/2014 $300,200 10,400 137,800 148,200 0.4937 0.4463

71-03-25-251-016.000-003 Clay 7103118 510 003 10/15/2014 $327,000 31,200 202,000 233,200 0.7131 0.2269

71-04-19-226-075.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 03/13/2014 $65,000 2,700 60,600 63,300 0.9738 0.0338

71-04-19-226-007.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 05/08/2014 $112,500 5,700 94,100 99,800 0.8871 0.0529

71-04-18-454-008.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 05/22/2014 $142,000 8,100 120,300 128,400 0.9042 0.0358

71-04-19-226-026.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 06/03/2014 $127,500 5,700 97,400 103,100 0.8086 0.1314

71-04-19-226-038.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 06/09/2014 $102,000 5,700 99,800 105,500 1.0343 0.0943

71-04-19-201-023.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 07/09/2014 $117,000 5,700 104,000 109,700 0.9376 0.0024

71-04-19-226-057.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 07/22/2014 $70,000 2,700 74,400 77,100 1.1014 0.1614

71-04-19-201-055.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 08/18/2014 $121,000 5,700 109,800 115,500 0.9545 0.0145

71-04-19-201-026.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 09/04/2014 $106,000 5,700 104,900 110,600 1.0434 0.1034

71-04-19-226-045.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 09/08/2014 $67,000 2,700 65,600 68,300 1.0194 0.0794

71-04-19-226-047.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 11/24/2014 $69,400 2,700 60,300 63,000 0.9078 0.0322

71-04-19-226-037.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 11/26/2014 $115,000 5,700 98,600 104,300 0.9070 0.0330

71-04-18-454-006.000-003 Clay 7103126 550 003 12/15/2014 $140,000 9,400 110,200 119,600 0.8543 0.0857

71-04-30-277-027.000-003 Clay 7103127 550 003 05/05/2014 $61,500 3,100 71,200 74,300 1.2081 0.2681

71-04-30-277-078.000-003 Clay 7103127 550 003 07/03/2014 $60,000 2,600 61,800 64,400 1.0733 0.1333

71-04-30-277-072.000-003 Clay 7103127 550 003 09/08/2014 $63,000 2,600 61,200 63,800 1.0127 0.0727

71-04-31-282-021.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 07/02/2014 $102,000 3,700 96,800 100,500 0.9853 0.0453

71-04-31-282-049.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 08/11/2014 $109,500 4,700 93,500 98,200 0.8968 0.0432

71-04-31-282-031.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 08/13/2014 $64,000 3,700 58,600 62,300 0.9734 0.0334

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-31-282-044.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 09/23/2014 $129,000 4,700 118,400 123,100 0.9543 0.0143

71-04-31-282-065.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 11/06/2014 $122,000 4,700 118,900 123,600 1.0131 0.0731

71-04-31-282-056.000-003 Clay 7103128 550 003 02/10/2015 $130,000 4,700 115,300 120,000 0.9231 0.0169

71-04-19-177-010.000-003 Clay 7103129 510 003 06/18/2014 $169,500 5,800 112,000 117,800 0.6950 0.2450

71-04-19-179-051.000-003 Clay 7103129 550 003 07/17/2014 $175,000 4,600 123,900 128,500 0.7343 0.2057

71-04-19-179-030.000-003 Clay 7103129 550 003 02/24/2015 $145,000 3,600 102,700 106,300 0.7331 0.2069

71-04-32-307-004.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 01/15/2014 $57,000 4,500 53,900 58,400 1.0246 0.0846

71-04-32-153-004.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 01/17/2014 $87,000 7,300 65,400 72,700 0.8356 0.1044

71-04-32-153-005.000-003 Clay 7103125 500 003 01/17/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-32-151-011.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 01/30/2014 $84,000 4,200 72,300 76,500 0.9107 0.0293

71-04-32-102-012.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 02/26/2014 $93,000 6,500 82,500 89,000 0.9570 0.0170

71-04-32-107-014.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 06/03/2014 $87,000 11,800 57,300 69,100 0.7943 0.1457

71-04-32-107-013.000-003 Clay 7103130 599 003 06/03/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-32-102-018.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 08/01/2014 $59,183 5,400 64,700 70,100 1.1845 0.2445

71-04-32-151-005.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 09/15/2014 $63,600 4,800 58,700 63,500 0.9984 0.0584

71-04-32-152-007.000-003 Clay 7103130 510 003 12/11/2014 $78,000 5,100 57,400 62,500 0.8013 0.1387

71-03-12-477-010.000-003 Clay 7103131 510 003 07/07/2014 $110,000 8,800 79,900 88,700 0.8064 0.1336

71-03-12-476-007.000-003 Clay 7103131 510 003 07/31/2014 $85,000 9,700 73,600 83,300 0.9800 0.0400

71-04-31-479-021.000-004 Clay 7104020 510 004 06/05/2014 $135,000 6,800 96,300 103,100 0.7637 0.1763

71-04-32-402-037.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 01/10/2014 $101,000 22,100 68,500 90,600 0.8970 0.0430

71-04-32-377-031.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 01/22/2014 $135,000 25,000 102,700 127,700 0.9459 0.0059

71-04-32-280-004.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 03/14/2014 $129,500 22,600 115,100 137,700 1.0633 0.1233

71-04-32-376-024.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 03/19/2014 $85,500 24,200 64,400 88,600 1.0363 0.0963

71-04-32-380-011.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 04/28/2014 $115,000 26,000 77,800 103,800 0.9026 0.0374

71-04-32-403-019.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 05/08/2014 $102,500 22,300 76,200 98,500 0.9610 0.0210

71-04-32-401-022.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 06/10/2014 $115,000 22,500 70,000 92,500 0.8043 0.1357

71-04-32-351-017.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 06/13/2014 $109,000 25,100 87,100 112,200 1.0294 0.0894

71-04-32-376-002.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 06/27/2014 $95,000 22,500 78,200 100,700 1.0600 0.1200

71-04-32-281-014.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 07/09/2014 $155,000 22,400 120,800 143,200 0.9239 0.0161

71-04-32-402-004.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 07/09/2014 $112,500 23,000 70,500 93,500 0.8311 0.1089

71-04-32-405-010.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 07/14/2014 $97,500 22,500 70,700 93,200 0.9559 0.0159

71-04-32-377-022.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 07/25/2014 $120,000 20,500 97,700 118,200 0.9850 0.0450

71-04-32-402-028.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 08/05/2014 $105,000 22,500 72,700 95,200 0.9067 0.0333

71-04-32-281-006.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 08/11/2014 $142,500 19,600 120,900 140,500 0.9860 0.0460

71-04-32-276-018.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 08/22/2014 $177,500 38,000 129,500 167,500 0.9437 0.0037

71-04-32-403-020.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 10/08/2014 $111,850 22,300 78,600 100,900 0.9021 0.0379

71-04-32-378-004.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 11/24/2014 $140,000 30,400 89,000 119,400 0.8529 0.0871

71-04-32-280-009.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 12/29/2014 $155,500 23,800 119,000 142,800 0.9183 0.0217

71-04-32-404-003.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 01/12/2015 $93,900 23,200 76,300 99,500 1.0596 0.1196

71-04-32-401-023.000-004 Clay 7104022 510 004 01/21/2015 $112,500 22,500 65,400 87,900 0.7813 0.1587

71-04-31-478-046.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 03/19/2014 $125,000 2,900 165,400 168,300 1.3464 0.4064

71-04-31-478-027.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 03/19/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-31-478-051.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 04/16/2014 $125,000 2,900 106,100 109,000 0.8720 0.0680

71-04-31-478-105.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 06/05/2014 $145,000 2,900 145,900 148,800 1.0262 0.0862

71-04-31-478-122.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 08/07/2014 $106,900 2,900 102,900 105,800 0.9897 0.0497

71-04-31-478-062.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 08/27/2014 $121,000 2,900 103,000 105,900 0.8752 0.0648

71-04-31-478-071.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 10/22/2014 $140,000 2,900 106,700 109,600 0.7829 0.1571

71-04-31-478-072.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 12/22/2014 $95,000 2,900 150,100 153,000 1.6105 0.6705

71-04-31-478-092.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 12/31/2014 $94,000 2,900 110,000 112,900 1.2011 0.2611

71-04-31-455-029.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 01/12/2015 $180,000 3,100 85,500 88,600 0.4922 0.4478

71-04-31-478-063.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 02/18/2015 $160,000 2,900 200,700 203,600 1.2725 0.3325

71-04-31-478-022.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 02/18/2015 $0 0 0

71-04-31-478-073.000-004 Clay 7104031 550 004 02/26/2015 $140,000 2,900 177,200 180,100 1.2864 0.3464

71-04-33-127-015.000-005 Clay 7105051 510 005 03/24/2014 $121,500 5,600 108,900 114,500 0.9424 0.0024

71-04-33-127-010.000-005 Clay 7105051 510 005 10/03/2014 $79,900 5,100 85,200 90,300 1.1302 0.1902

71-04-33-127-018.000-005 Clay 7105051 510 005 10/30/2014 $60,000 5,100 82,000 87,100 1.4517 0.5117

71-04-33-126-003.000-005 Clay 7105051 510 005 12/30/2014 $99,900 5,500 82,200 87,700 0.8779 0.0621

71-04-33-126-008.000-005 Clay 7105051 510 005 02/26/2015 $88,000 5,100 83,400 88,500 1.0057 0.0657

71-04-30-306-014.000-006 Clay 7106001 500 006 07/22/2014 $7,200 7,200 0 7,200 1.0000 0.0600

71-04-30-306-013.000-006 Clay 7106001 500 006 07/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-30-304-012.000-006 Clay 7106002 510 006 02/05/2014 $66,500 6,400 58,100 64,500 0.9699 0.0299

71-04-30-302-005.000-006 Clay 7106002 510 006 03/05/2014 $38,100 5,500 29,100 34,600 0.9081 0.0319

71-04-30-306-004.000-006 Clay 7106002 510 006 07/22/2014 $120,800 9,800 67,900 77,700 0.6432 0.2968

71-04-30-304-014.000-006 Clay 7106002 510 006 10/14/2014 $100,000 5,000 77,700 82,700 0.8270 0.1130

71-04-30-326-003.000-006 Clay 7106002 510 006 12/22/2014 $110,000 9,700 92,900 102,600 0.9327 0.0073

71-03-25-101-011.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 01/03/2014 $59,000 13,000 49,100 62,100 1.0525 0.1125

71-03-25-176-010.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 02/14/2014 $63,000 12,400 53,400 65,800 1.0444 0.1044

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-25-104-008.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 06/30/2014 $37,500 8,000 29,400 37,400 0.9973 0.0573

71-03-25-326-030.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 09/09/2014 $82,000 9,300 58,900 68,200 0.8317 0.1083

71-03-25-103-007.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 09/11/2014 $77,000 10,200 36,200 46,400 0.6026 0.3374

71-03-25-326-029.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 12/12/2014 $73,000 12,700 55,800 68,500 0.9384 0.0016

71-03-25-326-028.000-007 Clay 7107018 500 007 12/12/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-25-177-003.000-007 Clay 7107013 510 007 12/22/2014 $84,000 20,000 83,400 103,400 1.2310 0.2910

71-03-25-352-022.000-007 Clay 7107019 550 007 02/14/2014 $217,000 6,100 185,400 191,500 0.8825 0.0575

71-03-25-352-060.000-007 Clay 7107019 550 007 08/18/2014 $175,000 6,600 133,000 139,600 0.7977 0.1423

71-04-08-353-002.000-003 Clay 7103039 510 003 2/27/2015 380,000$ 32,900 233,600 266,500 0.7013 0.2387

71-04-16-409-010.000-003 Clay 7103043 510 003 2/20/2015 110,750$ 10,100 106,900 117,000 1.0564 0.1164

71-04-17-256-005.000-003 Clay 7103048 510 003 2/27/2015 835,000$ 33,000 758,700 791,700 0.9481 0.0081

71-04-20-104-001.000-003 Clay 7103050 510 003 2/27/2015 240,000$ 23,700 137,200 160,900 0.6704 0.2696

71-04-19-204-012.000-003 Clay 7103060 510 003 2/24/2015 130,000$ 28,000 100,600 128,600 0.9892 0.0492

71-04-31-403-063.000-003 Clay 7109550 550 003 2/20/2015 425,000$ 42,800 403,800 446,600 1.0508 0.1108

71-03-25-352-027.000-007 Clay 7107019 550 007 09/12/2014 $190,000 5,100 159,200 164,300 0.8647 0.0753

71-03-25-352-041.000-007 Clay 7107019 550 007 10/15/2014 $217,000 6,700 176,900 183,600 0.8461 0.0939

71-04-31-403-085.000-003 Clay 7109550 550 003 03/18/2014 $355,000 31,900 334,200 366,100 1.0313 0.0913

71-04-31-403-053.000-003 Clay 7109550 550 003 04/04/2014 $360,000 26,300 332,700 359,000 0.9972 0.0572

71-04-31-403-065.000-003 Clay 7109550 550 003 06/05/2014 $419,000 35,300 417,400 452,700 1.0804 0.1404

71-04-31-403-087.000-003 Clay 7109550 550 003 07/23/2014 $350,000 24,800 325,700 350,500 1.0014 0.0614

71-04-28-351-013.000-005 Clay 7129550 550 005 06/04/2014 $115,000 6,300 98,900 105,200 0.9148 0.0252

71-04-28-351-026.000-005 Clay 7129550 550 005 07/10/2014 $125,000 6,300 98,200 104,500 0.8360 0.1040

$79,450,868 74,437,600 429

Mean 0.9519

Median 0.9400

Wtd Mean 0.9369

COD 12.5720

PRD 1.01606

GERMAN TOWNSHIP

71-03-08-401-008.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 05/22/2014 $127,500 25,900 87,400 113,300 0.8886 0.0400

71-03-08-276-005.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 08/14/2014 $106,000 26,000 93,800 119,800 1.1302 0.2015

71-03-08-276-010.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 09/17/2014 $122,000 25,400 99,000 124,400 1.0197 0.0910

71-03-09-152-001.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 09/24/2014 $131,500 27,800 102,500 130,300 0.9909 0.0622

71-03-09-177-006.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 10/21/2014 $117,500 24,700 88,700 113,400 0.9651 0.0364

71-03-08-277-010.000-008 German 7108014 510 008 11/17/2014 $95,000 25,100 87,200 112,300 1.1821 0.2534

71-03-09-252-003.000-008 German 7108017 510 008 05/28/2014 $191,900 42,600 158,500 201,100 1.0479 0.1193

71-03-09-429-006.000-008 German 7108017 510 008 08/25/2014 $450,000 45,000 337,300 382,300 0.8496 0.0791

71-03-09-253-001.000-008 German 7108017 510 008 10/31/2014 $220,000 27,300 191,400 218,700 0.9941 0.0654

71-03-10-403-017.000-008 German 7108023 510 008 02/05/2014 $128,500 14,200 110,000 124,200 0.9665 0.0379

71-03-10-277-002.000-008 German 7108023 510 008 08/14/2014 $76,500 15,700 64,200 79,900 1.0444 0.1158

71-03-10-451-001.000-008 German 7108023 510 008 01/14/2015 $120,000 16,600 119,100 135,700 1.1308 0.2022

71-03-09-401-007.000-008 German 7108025 510 008 09/04/2014 $123,000 17,500 84,700 102,200 0.8309 0.0978

71-03-16-229-011.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 02/11/2014 $194,000 26,900 121,000 147,900 0.7624 0.1663

71-03-15-152-005.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 02/14/2014 $124,000 23,700 104,500 128,200 1.0339 0.1052

71-03-15-104-005.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 05/22/2014 $132,405 23,400 138,400 161,800 1.2220 0.2933

71-03-16-279-001.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 02/28/2014 $125,000 34,000 114,700 148,700 1.1896 0.2609

71-03-16-279-010.000-008 German 7108041 500 008 02/28/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-15-105-007.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 06/16/2014 $170,000 24,400 120,700 145,100 0.8535 0.0751

71-03-15-103-013.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 07/02/2014 $176,900 23,700 137,100 160,800 0.9090 0.0197

71-03-15-105-026.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 09/30/2014 $125,000 20,200 108,200 128,400 1.0272 0.0985

71-03-15-152-009.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 10/09/2014 $139,000 21,800 107,200 129,000 0.9281 0.0006

71-03-15-152-008.000-008 German 7108027 510 008 10/27/2014 $147,000 22,800 109,000 131,800 0.8966 0.0321

71-03-15-254-011.000-008 German 7108029 510 008 04/04/2014 $146,000 15,400 111,600 127,000 0.8699 0.0588

71-03-15-206-010.000-008 German 7108029 510 008 01/22/2014 $131,000 47,600 77,300 124,900 0.9534 0.0248

71-03-15-206-009.000-008 German 7108030 500 008 01/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-15-206-015.000-008 German 7108030 500 008 01/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-15-252-010.000-008 German 7108029 510 008 06/11/2014 $134,000 17,700 97,200 114,900 0.8575 0.0712

71-03-18-254-012.000-008 German 7108033 510 008 03/27/2014 $119,000 14,300 91,900 106,200 0.8924 0.0362

71-03-18-254-011.000-008 German 7108033 510 008 06/06/2014 $132,501 14,500 104,300 118,800 0.8966 0.0321

71-03-18-328-013.000-008 German 7108033 510 008 09/25/2014 $107,500 16,800 90,200 107,000 0.9953 0.0667

71-03-18-254-010.000-008 German 7108033 510 008 01/14/2015 $119,000 17,800 98,000 115,800 0.9731 0.0444

71-03-16-452-017.000-008 German 7108036 510 008 02/20/2014 $136,500 17,500 96,000 113,500 0.8315 0.0972

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-16-451-005.000-008 German 7108036 510 008 07/29/2014 $178,000 16,100 122,800 138,900 0.7803 0.1483

71-03-16-454-010.000-008 German 7108036 510 008 10/20/2014 $148,428 16,700 107,600 124,300 0.8374 0.0912

71-03-11-351-007.000-008 German 7108039 510 008 05/05/2014 $260,000 25,800 114,200 140,000 0.5385 0.3902

71-03-11-351-001.000-008 German 7108039 510 008 06/11/2014 $475,000 20,300 250,200 270,500 0.5695 0.3592

71-03-09-451-009.000-008 German 7108042 510 008 01/22/2014 $75,000 22,900 57,300 80,200 1.0693 0.1407

71-03-16-126-005.000-008 German 7108042 510 008 02/04/2014 $62,000 24,700 42,700 67,400 1.0871 0.1584

71-03-08-376-015.000-008 German 7108042 510 008 05/21/2014 $191,276 15,500 127,400 142,900 0.7471 0.1816

71-03-22-279-008.000-008 German 7108042 510 008 10/23/2014 $140,000 16,700 113,400 130,100 0.9293 0.0006

71-03-23-151-010.000-008 German 7108042 510 008 12/03/2014 $105,000 16,700 87,200 103,900 0.9895 0.0609

71-03-31-101-001.000-008 German 7108046 510 008 02/26/2015 $145,000 21,000 91,700 112,700 0.7772 0.1514

71-03-22-102-005.000-008 German 7108047 510 008 05/07/2014 $97,000 17,300 67,300 84,600 0.8722 0.0565

71-03-22-476-014.000-008 German 7108050 510 008 08/11/2014 $129,900 10,300 74,800 85,100 0.6551 0.2736

71-03-22-451-044.000-008 German 7108050 510 008 01/29/2015 $122,000 11,500 81,700 93,200 0.7639 0.1647

71-03-22-426-009.000-008 German 7108050 510 008 01/14/2015 $71,000 19,500 54,400 73,900 1.0408 0.1122

71-03-22-426-010.000-008 German 7108049 500 008 01/14/2015 $0 0 0

71-03-32-304-020.000-008 German 7108057 510 008 06/02/2014 $85,000 7,500 49,200 56,700 0.6671 0.2616

71-03-32-376-002.000-008 German 7108057 510 008 12/30/2014 $69,000 6,200 39,500 45,700 0.6623 0.2664

71-03-20-228-002.000-008 German 7108060 510 008 10/27/2014 $170,000 11,900 105,400 117,300 0.6900 0.2387

71-03-15-126-004.000-008 German 7108064 510 008 08/04/2014 $450,000 34,300 295,700 330,000 0.7333 0.1953

71-03-15-127-009.000-008 German 7108064 510 008 11/03/2014 $312,500 22,700 247,300 270,000 0.8640 0.0647

71-03-15-178-002.000-008 German 7108064 510 008 01/12/2015 $309,000 24,800 237,500 262,300 0.8489 0.0798

71-03-18-127-012.000-008 German 7108068 510 008 04/30/2014 $360,000 29,900 165,500 195,400 0.5428 0.3859

71-03-18-180-002.000-008 German 7108068 510 008 07/02/2014 $275,000 30,600 237,200 267,800 0.9738 0.0451

71-03-18-177-002.000-008 German 7108068 510 008 07/17/2014 $272,000 37,100 329,500 366,600 1.3478 0.4191

71-03-18-181-002.000-008 German 7108068 510 008 12/30/2014 $275,000 32,200 134,000 166,200 0.6044 0.3243

71-03-17-401-023.000-008 German 7108070 510 008 06/20/2014 $149,875 22,100 128,900 151,000 1.0075 0.0788

71-03-17-401-019.000-008 German 7108070 510 008 06/25/2014 $162,000 24,800 132,100 156,900 0.9685 0.0398

71-03-17-401-042.000-008 German 7108070 510 008 07/30/2014 $178,000 28,000 141,200 169,200 0.9506 0.0219

71-03-17-426-084.000-008 German 7108073 510 008 02/04/2015 $165,000 23,400 122,700 146,100 0.8855 0.0432

71-03-17-426-007.000-008 German 7108073 510 008 02/25/2015 $159,500 40,000 138,800 178,800 1.1210 0.1923

71-03-22-151-002.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 04/16/2014 $110,000 7,700 126,400 134,100 1.2191 0.2904

71-03-21-230-007.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 04/16/2014 $125,000 13,300 107,200 120,500 0.9640 0.0353

71-03-21-228-004.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 06/04/2014 $123,000 7,000 112,200 119,200 0.9691 0.0404

71-03-22-101-005.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 07/02/2014 $124,000 6,400 122,100 128,500 1.0363 0.1076

71-03-21-231-006.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 09/22/2014 $138,000 7,000 114,600 121,600 0.8812 0.0475

71-03-21-229-009.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 09/25/2014 $129,999 7,000 108,900 115,900 0.8915 0.0371

71-03-21-228-028.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 10/24/2014 $134,000 7,000 114,600 121,600 0.9075 0.0212

71-03-21-230-002.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 12/16/2014 $124,900 7,000 108,300 115,300 0.9231 0.0055

71-03-21-231-008.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 12/29/2014 $145,000 7,000 128,700 135,700 0.9359 0.0072

71-03-22-278-004.000-009 German 7109026 510 009 06/02/2014 $168,500 24,700 124,300 149,000 0.8843 0.0444

71-03-22-251-020.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 02/19/2014 $99,700 16,500 108,500 125,000 1.2538 0.3251

71-03-22-282-023.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 03/04/2014 $140,000 15,800 109,800 125,600 0.8971 0.0315

71-03-22-204-009.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 03/19/2014 $190,000 17,900 139,600 157,500 0.8289 0.0997

71-03-22-252-006.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 04/21/2014 $145,500 14,600 107,200 121,800 0.8371 0.0916

71-03-22-280-014.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 05/02/2014 $120,000 14,400 103,700 118,100 0.9842 0.0555

71-03-22-204-003.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 05/19/2014 $135,900 15,500 107,700 123,200 0.9065 0.0221

71-03-22-202-007.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 06/02/2014 $175,900 14,500 139,600 154,100 0.8761 0.0526

71-03-22-279-012.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 06/03/2014 $152,000 13,900 102,400 116,300 0.7651 0.1635

71-03-22-251-014.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 06/23/2014 $145,000 16,100 115,100 131,200 0.9048 0.0238

71-03-22-280-011.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 07/07/2014 $142,000 21,000 105,400 126,400 0.8901 0.0385

71-03-22-255-024.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 07/09/2014 $137,000 12,800 110,200 123,000 0.8978 0.0309

71-03-22-252-004.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 08/05/2014 $134,900 12,900 107,100 120,000 0.8895 0.0391

71-03-22-256-007.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 09/25/2014 $122,000 17,200 106,700 123,900 1.0156 0.0869

71-03-22-202-010.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 09/30/2014 $166,900 14,500 126,200 140,700 0.8430 0.0857

71-03-22-201-001.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 10/01/2014 $190,000 16,900 143,400 160,300 0.8437 0.0850

71-03-22-256-010.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 10/03/2014 $135,000 13,300 107,700 121,000 0.8963 0.0324

71-03-22-202-019.000-009 German 7109027 510 009 12/30/2014 $122,000 12,200 105,100 117,300 0.9615 0.0328

71-03-23-353-011.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 03/27/2014 $60,000 16,700 51,400 68,100 1.1350 0.2063

71-03-23-354-010.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 04/22/2014 $73,000 15,800 65,800 81,600 1.1178 0.1891

71-03-23-352-034.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 05/20/2014 $67,500 12,200 64,000 76,200 1.1289 0.2002

71-03-23-355-008.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 06/02/2014 $82,500 14,200 70,900 85,100 1.0315 0.1028

71-03-23-355-007.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 06/10/2014 $78,100 15,100 66,900 82,000 1.0499 0.1213

71-03-23-353-001.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 06/25/2014 $65,000 12,000 56,200 68,200 1.0492 0.1206

71-03-23-305-044.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 07/22/2014 $132,500 17,700 103,500 121,200 0.9147 0.0140

71-03-22-429-003.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 10/06/2014 $85,000 16,300 87,100 103,400 1.2165 0.2878

71-03-23-305-025.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 12/12/2014 $79,000 15,500 41,300 56,800 0.7190 0.2097

71-03-23-306-002.000-009 German 7109030 510 009 02/27/2015 $63,000 10,600 52,700 63,300 1.0048 0.0761

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-27-178-009.000-009 German 7109033 510 009 06/12/2014 $123,000 21,200 92,600 113,800 0.9252 0.0035

71-03-27-178-003.000-009 German 7109033 510 009 11/20/2014 $122,000 16,800 98,200 115,000 0.9426 0.0140

71-03-27-252-007.000-009 German 7109033 510 009 12/30/2014 $128,000 16,800 100,100 116,900 0.9133 0.0154

71-03-27-403-016.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 01/14/2014 $115,000 13,000 106,000 119,000 1.0348 0.1061

71-03-27-326-002.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 06/17/2014 $117,000 12,300 108,500 120,800 1.0325 0.1038

71-03-27-303-031.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 06/27/2014 $94,000 12,300 81,200 93,500 0.9947 0.0660

71-03-27-403-008.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 07/07/2014 $110,000 10,700 70,700 81,400 0.7400 0.1887

71-03-27-403-014.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 10/21/2014 $119,900 11,200 81,500 92,700 0.7731 0.1555

71-03-27-351-007.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 11/06/2014 $118,000 13,400 93,100 106,500 0.9025 0.0261

71-03-27-402-010.000-009 German 7109035 510 009 11/19/2014 $108,000 10,500 74,500 85,000 0.7870 0.1416

71-03-21-127-007.000-009 German 7109037 510 009 06/09/2014 $118,000 24,300 99,600 123,900 1.0500 0.1213

71-03-21-128-018.000-009 German 7109037 510 009 08/14/2014 $145,000 19,300 125,400 144,700 0.9979 0.0693

71-03-21-128-006.000-009 German 7109037 510 009 08/20/2014 $150,000 23,200 118,800 142,000 0.9467 0.0180

71-03-23-301-107.000-009 German 7109038 510 009 03/26/2014 $115,000 9,300 104,300 113,600 0.9878 0.0592

71-03-22-283-011.000-009 German 7109038 510 009 10/14/2014 $152,000 7,300 114,400 121,700 0.8007 0.1280

71-03-23-301-103.000-009 German 7109038 510 009 02/20/2015 $119,000 6,500 100,500 107,000 0.8992 0.0295

71-03-23-301-057.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 02/27/2014 $105,000 3,800 83,000 86,800 0.8267 0.1020

71-03-23-301-045.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 03/05/2014 $95,000 3,800 92,900 96,700 1.0179 0.0892

71-03-23-301-112.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 04/29/2014 $105,000 3,800 93,100 96,900 0.9229 0.0058

71-03-23-301-123.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 06/03/2014 $131,000 3,800 98,200 102,000 0.7786 0.1500

71-03-23-301-066.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 07/22/2014 $90,000 3,800 83,000 86,800 0.9644 0.0358

71-03-18-401-034.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 04/30/2014 $300,000 40,300 305,400 345,700 1.1523 0.2237

71-03-18-401-030.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 05/09/2014 $291,131 38,200 212,100 250,300 0.8598 0.0689

71-03-18-329-005.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 06/11/2014 $267,900 35,300 208,300 243,600 0.9093 0.0194

71-03-18-377-007.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 06/18/2014 $300,000 37,400 250,200 287,600 0.9587 0.0300

71-03-18-330-007.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 06/20/2014 $255,000 38,800 219,200 258,000 1.0118 0.0831

71-03-18-377-001.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 07/24/2014 $450,000 63,200 449,600 512,800 1.1396 0.2109

71-03-18-401-016.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 12/03/2014 $195,400 35,500 201,800 237,300 1.2144 0.2858

71-03-18-401-023.000-009 German 7109052 510 009 02/04/2015 $265,500 38,900 224,600 263,500 0.9925 0.0638

71-03-21-151-011.000-009 German 7109055 510 009 02/04/2014 $130,877 44,300 86,200 130,500 0.9971 0.0684

71-03-21-229-025.000-009 German 7109023 510 009 2/27/2015 $137,500 11,400 112,600 124,000 0.9018 0.0269

71-03-23-301-118.000-009 German 7109044 551 009 2/25/2015 106,500$ 3,800 99,400 103,200 0.9690 0.0403

71-03-21-101-040.000-009 German 7109055 510 009 03/07/2014 $140,000 23,500 110,100 133,600 0.9543 0.0256

71-03-22-126-048.000-009 German 7109058 510 009 04/29/2014 $155,000 33,500 132,800 166,300 1.0729 0.1442

$19,996,192 18,290,900 130

Mean 0.9346

Median 0.9287

Wtd Mean 0.9147

COD 11.7728

PRD 1.0218

GREENE TOWNSHIP

71-07-36-226-005.000-010 Greene 7110009 510 010 03/21/2014 $130,000 10,600 111,700 122,300 0.9408 0.0208

71-07-36-226-010.000-010 Greene 7110009 510 010 05/01/2014 $85,000 10,700 98,400 109,100 1.2835 0.3636

71-07-36-227-008.000-010 Greene 7110009 510 010 07/10/2014 $142,000 11,200 88,400 99,600 0.7014 0.2186

71-07-36-276-004.000-010 Greene 7110009 510 010 11/06/2014 $130,500 10,400 95,400 105,800 0.8107 0.1092

71-08-29-176-005.000-010 Greene 7110013 510 010 05/28/2014 $55,000 2,800 51,500 54,300 0.9873 0.0673

71-08-29-251-007.000-010 Greene 7110013 510 010 09/11/2014 $35,400 3,600 38,000 41,600 1.1751 0.2552

71-13-07-251-002.000-010 Greene 7110017 510 010 07/29/2014 $110,000 20,600 74,800 95,400 0.8673 0.0527

71-13-07-254-005.000-010 Greene 7110017 510 010 01/14/2015 $162,000 39,900 116,900 156,800 0.9679 0.0479

71-13-07-254-006.000-010 Greene 7110016 500 010 01/14/2015 $0 0 0

71-08-33-451-004.000-010 Greene 7110021 510 010 05/08/2014 $415,000 45,700 295,500 341,200 0.8222 0.0978

71-08-33-176-001.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 03/13/2014 $114,500 24,300 90,400 114,700 1.0017 0.0818

71-12-13-300-013.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 07/31/2014 $335,000 63,200 192,900 256,100 0.7645 0.1555

71-12-13-300-012.000-010 Greene 7110001 100 010 07/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-32-352-001.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 08/25/2014 $37,500 27,100 10,800 37,900 1.0107 0.0907

71-08-32-126-003.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 09/08/2014 $100,000 21,400 75,500 96,900 0.9690 0.0490

71-12-15-400-002.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 11/03/2014 $195,000 38,900 147,900 186,800 0.9579 0.0380

71-08-28-200-005.000-010 Greene 7110022 511 010 12/29/2014 $275,000 46,900 265,200 312,100 1.1349 0.2149

71-13-07-226-009.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 03/05/2014 $185,000 17,000 152,400 169,400 0.9157 0.0043

71-13-07-376-006.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 08/27/2014 $165,000 37,800 101,000 138,800 0.8412 0.0788

71-13-07-376-005.000-010 Greene 7110016 500 010 08/27/2014 $0 0 0

71-07-36-100-005.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 06/13/2014 $84,500 29,700 48,400 78,100 0.9243 0.0043

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-13-05-376-010.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 09/22/2014 $125,000 22,500 90,100 112,600 0.9008 0.0192

71-13-05-376-009.000-010 Greene 7110018 500 010 09/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-13-05-100-007.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 06/13/2014 $208,000 37,400 118,600 156,000 0.7500 0.1700

71-12-03-400-005.000-010 Greene 7110023 511 010 07/02/2014 $245,000 37,300 170,600 207,900 0.8486 0.0714

71-12-10-200-001.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 08/19/2014 $225,000 40,500 169,200 209,700 0.9320 0.0120

71-13-04-300-001.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 08/21/2014 $165,000 29,100 72,000 101,100 0.6127 0.3072

71-12-18-400-006.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 12/03/2014 $125,000 22,300 102,000 124,300 0.9944 0.0744

71-13-05-200-003.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 12/31/2014 $150,000 36,300 99,000 135,300 0.9020 0.0180

71-07-36-251-002.000-010 Greene 7110023 510 010 02/26/2015 $139,500 20,800 76,800 97,600 0.6996 0.2203

$4,138,900 3,661,400 26

Mean 0.9122

Median 0.9200

Wtd Mean 0.8846

COD 11.8853

PRD 1.03112

HARRIS TOWNSHIP

71-04-10-301-002.000-011 Harris 7111018 510 011 05/05/2014 $178,500 18,500 122,300 140,800 0.7888 0.1799

71-04-10-351-026.000-011 Harris 7111020 510 011 02/19/2014 $260,000 19,900 217,400 237,300 0.9127 0.0560

71-04-10-327-034.000-011 Harris 7111020 510 011 04/09/2014 $199,000 24,900 168,700 193,600 0.9729 0.0042

71-04-10-376-010.000-011 Harris 7111020 510 011 07/23/2014 $168,000 19,200 269,400 288,600 1.7179 0.7492

71-04-10-305-012.000-011 Harris 7111020 510 011 08/08/2014 $285,000 19,200 220,300 239,500 0.8404 0.1283

71-04-10-305-011.000-011 Harris 7111020 510 011 11/06/2014 $269,900 18,500 217,900 236,400 0.8759 0.0928

71-04-10-353-012.000-011 Harris 7111022 510 011 09/02/2014 $218,000 37,200 170,300 207,500 0.9518 0.0168

71-04-10-353-003.000-011 Harris 7111022 510 011 11/17/2014 $230,000 33,600 195,000 228,600 0.9939 0.0253

71-04-10-329-003.000-011 Harris 7111025 510 011 07/03/2014 $275,000 20,200 157,300 177,500 0.6455 0.3232

71-04-10-330-008.000-011 Harris 7111025 510 011 10/24/2014 $169,500 23,400 120,000 143,400 0.8460 0.1226

71-04-10-451-015.000-011 Harris 7111027 510 011 09/08/2014 $207,000 16,900 125,800 142,700 0.6894 0.2793

71-04-10-477-002.000-011 Harris 7111028 510 011 09/04/2014 $415,000 38,200 343,500 381,700 0.9198 0.0489

71-04-11-426-006.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 04/29/2014 $320,000 68,000 243,000 311,000 0.9719 0.0032

71-04-11-428-017.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 04/29/2014 $300,000 62,900 238,400 301,300 1.0043 0.0357

71-04-11-329-022.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 06/05/2014 $395,000 63,700 324,200 387,900 0.9820 0.0134

71-04-11-329-002.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 06/17/2014 $310,000 58,000 224,200 282,200 0.9103 0.0583

71-04-11-329-007.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 07/23/2014 $265,000 51,000 206,400 257,400 0.9713 0.0027

71-04-11-329-018.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 07/29/2014 $303,500 63,200 235,700 298,900 0.9848 0.0162

71-04-12-301-001.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 08/11/2014 $380,000 65,200 262,100 327,300 0.8613 0.1073

71-04-11-377-003.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 08/13/2014 $312,000 58,600 229,300 287,900 0.9228 0.0459

71-04-12-301-006.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 08/22/2014 $315,000 67,900 260,400 328,300 1.0422 0.0736

71-04-11-329-035.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 08/28/2014 $312,825 59,900 230,800 290,700 0.9293 0.0394

71-04-11-329-005.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 10/06/2014 $342,000 60,400 248,600 309,000 0.9035 0.0651

71-04-11-402-002.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 10/06/2014 $282,500 62,900 221,300 284,200 1.0060 0.0374

71-04-11-430-015.000-011 Harris 7111030 510 011 10/13/2014 $309,900 56,100 224,700 280,800 0.9061 0.0626

71-04-11-403-017.000-011 Harris 7111031 510 011 04/08/2014 $424,600 69,500 349,100 418,600 0.9859 0.0172

71-04-11-327-020.000-011 Harris 7111031 510 011 10/07/2014 $450,000 74,000 352,900 426,900 0.9487 0.0200

71-04-11-327-015.000-011 Harris 7111031 510 011 11/13/2014 $375,000 61,000 253,700 314,700 0.8392 0.1295

71-04-11-327-006.000-011 Harris 7111031 510 011 11/18/2014 $375,000 70,100 300,700 370,800 0.9888 0.0201

71-04-11-427-014.000-011 Harris 7111031 510 011 12/30/2014 $557,500 80,300 500,700 581,000 1.0422 0.0735

71-04-12-305-004.000-011 Harris 7111033 510 011 04/14/2014 $522,500 57,800 289,600 347,400 0.6649 0.3038

71-04-12-303-002.000-011 Harris 7111033 510 011 07/31/2014 $550,000 85,400 290,800 376,200 0.6840 0.2847

71-04-11-478-005.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 02/14/2014 $295,000 39,200 233,200 272,400 0.9234 0.0453

71-04-11-451-017.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 04/14/2014 $255,000 22,900 213,000 235,900 0.9251 0.0436

71-04-11-479-002.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 07/07/2014 $235,000 26,300 200,200 226,500 0.9638 0.0048

71-04-11-476-011.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 07/14/2014 $329,000 24,400 296,700 321,100 0.9760 0.0073

71-04-11-476-015.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 07/22/2014 $325,500 25,300 260,700 286,000 0.8786 0.0900

71-04-11-476-001.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 10/08/2014 $367,000 25,400 278,400 303,800 0.8278 0.1409

71-04-11-481-004.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 11/12/2014 $324,000 23,100 284,000 307,100 0.9478 0.0208

71-04-11-455-011.000-011 Harris 7111035 510 011 12/22/2014 $351,890 17,500 259,800 277,300 0.7880 0.1806

71-04-11-452-024.000-011 Harris 7111037 510 011 05/02/2014 $358,000 36,600 274,200 310,800 0.8682 0.1005

71-04-11-452-013.000-011 Harris 7111037 510 011 07/02/2014 $400,500 31,600 291,600 323,200 0.8070 0.1617

71-04-11-452-012.000-011 Harris 7111037 510 011 07/16/2014 $388,800 32,200 217,200 249,400 0.6415 0.3272

71-04-11-452-028.000-011 Harris 7111037 510 011 08/06/2014 $387,000 32,200 239,500 271,700 0.7021 0.2666

71-04-12-351-013.000-011 Harris 7111038 510 011 05/19/2014 $229,000 20,900 140,200 161,100 0.7035 0.2652

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-26-126-008.000-011 Harris 7111041 500 011 11/06/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-26-126-007.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 11/06/2014 $115,000 26,900 83,600 110,500 0.9609 0.0078

71-04-13-251-011.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 01/16/2014 $125,000 37,700 70,800 108,500 0.8680 0.1007

71-05-09-355-004.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 01/17/2014 $268,000 35,500 163,600 199,100 0.7429 0.2257

71-04-27-400-011.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 04/02/2014 $67,000 21,600 43,300 64,900 0.9687 0.0000

71-04-27-400-027.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 06/05/2014 $165,000 32,800 103,100 135,900 0.8236 0.1450

71-04-12-455-019.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 06/25/2014 $190,000 37,700 92,100 129,800 0.6832 0.2855

71-05-08-405-008.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 08/12/2014 $135,000 35,800 93,200 129,000 0.9556 0.0131

71-04-13-351-016.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 08/21/2014 $145,000 33,100 112,900 146,000 1.0069 0.0382

71-04-13-201-006.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 09/16/2014 $390,000 50,300 273,500 323,800 0.8303 0.1384

71-04-13-451-011.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 09/23/2014 $148,000 37,700 83,300 121,000 0.8176 0.1511

71-04-10-477-014.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 09/29/2014 $165,000 41,400 101,000 142,400 0.8630 0.1056

71-04-14-353-016.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 10/24/2014 $118,900 37,200 73,400 110,600 0.9302 0.0385

71-05-08-405-001.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 12/03/2014 $129,900 35,500 100,000 135,500 1.0431 0.0745

71-04-14-353-019.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 01/26/2015 $75,000 45,800 45,700 91,500 1.2200 0.2513

71-05-29-400-012.000-011 Harris 7111045 510 011 09/17/2014 $85,000 32,700 47,600 80,300 0.9447 0.0240

71-04-12-452-009.000-011 Harris 7111047 510 011 02/11/2014 $175,000 26,300 142,600 168,900 0.9651 0.0035

71-04-12-454-004.000-011 Harris 7111047 510 011 04/09/2014 $191,000 18,100 153,200 171,300 0.8969 0.0718

71-04-12-451-006.000-011 Harris 7111047 510 011 12/22/2014 $170,000 17,800 147,700 165,500 0.9735 0.0049

71-04-12-427-005.000-011 Harris 7111049 510 011 05/15/2014 $416,500 17,400 237,900 255,300 0.6130 0.3557

71-04-12-426-012.000-011 Harris 7111049 510 011 09/04/2014 $332,000 17,400 241,400 258,800 0.7795 0.1891

71-04-15-278-031.000-011 Harris 7111050 500 011 07/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-04-15-276-011.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 07/30/2014 $385,000 75,000 266,900 341,900 0.8881 0.0806

71-04-15-151-001.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 02/19/2014 $335,000 50,100 406,200 456,300 1.3621 0.3934

71-04-15-430-008.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 03/07/2014 $245,000 82,600 214,900 297,500 1.2143 0.2456

71-04-22-154-002.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 03/07/2014 $288,000 40,600 243,300 283,900 0.9858 0.0171

71-04-15-428-004.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 03/14/2014 $229,000 50,900 191,100 242,000 1.0568 0.0881

71-04-15-128-002.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 03/28/2014 $259,000 48,300 256,100 304,400 1.1753 0.2066

71-04-22-129-004.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 04/22/2014 $278,000 53,600 215,000 268,600 0.9662 0.0025

71-04-22-127-006.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/02/2014 $268,400 53,800 239,100 292,900 1.0913 0.1226

71-04-15-177-015.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/02/2014 $170,000 49,200 243,400 292,600 1.7212 0.7525

71-04-15-426-003.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/13/2014 $329,000 62,400 249,600 312,000 0.9483 0.0203

71-04-15-329-014.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/19/2014 $363,500 54,800 367,800 422,600 1.1626 0.1939

71-04-22-151-013.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/29/2014 $273,000 45,400 215,100 260,500 0.9542 0.0144

71-04-15-152-007.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 05/30/2014 $600,000 56,500 489,200 545,700 0.9095 0.0592

71-04-15-478-001.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 06/02/2014 $303,000 55,100 263,100 318,200 1.0502 0.0815

71-04-15-326-008.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 06/04/2014 $230,000 47,000 259,500 306,500 1.3326 0.3640

71-04-15-177-001.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 06/13/2014 $295,000 44,500 236,500 281,000 0.9525 0.0161

71-04-22-130-022.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 06/26/2014 $305,000 40,600 264,400 305,000 1.0000 0.0313

71-04-22-102-018.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/01/2014 $299,900 45,300 233,000 278,300 0.9280 0.0407

71-04-15-104-011.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/07/2014 $306,000 55,800 227,800 283,600 0.9268 0.0419

71-04-15-151-003.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/17/2014 $318,000 53,000 269,100 322,100 1.0129 0.0442

71-04-22-177-008.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/20/2014 $310,000 42,600 245,200 287,800 0.9284 0.0403

71-04-22-126-008.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/28/2014 $189,000 46,200 168,800 215,000 1.1376 0.1689

71-04-22-179-002.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 07/28/2014 $290,000 46,600 253,100 299,700 1.0334 0.0648

71-04-15-454-002.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 08/05/2014 $315,000 51,200 256,100 307,300 0.9756 0.0069

71-04-22-176-014.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 08/07/2014 $223,000 43,500 184,900 228,400 1.0242 0.0556

71-04-15-476-011.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 08/25/2014 $265,100 54,600 227,600 282,200 1.0645 0.0958

71-04-22-126-004.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 08/26/2014 $245,000 35,100 203,700 238,800 0.9747 0.0060

71-04-22-153-005.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 08/29/2014 $300,000 46,400 230,900 277,300 0.9243 0.0443

71-04-15-405-004.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 09/09/2014 $298,000 47,100 214,400 261,500 0.8775 0.0911

71-04-15-404-006.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 09/16/2014 $270,000 46,300 221,800 268,100 0.9930 0.0243

71-04-15-353-005.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 09/18/2014 $304,000 47,600 238,100 285,700 0.9398 0.0289

71-04-15-104-006.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 12/22/2014 $235,000 45,900 232,300 278,200 1.1838 0.2152

71-04-15-301-008.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 12/30/2014 $332,000 56,100 263,000 319,100 0.9611 0.0075

71-04-15-327-012.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 01/20/2015 $200,000 47,800 196,000 243,800 1.2190 0.2503

71-04-15-379-004.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 02/25/2015 $275,000 36,500 226,300 262,800 0.9556 0.0130

71-04-15-203-015.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 01/10/2014 $360,000 88,700 264,500 353,200 0.9811 0.0125

71-04-15-276-012.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 01/13/2014 $450,000 85,500 309,800 395,300 0.8784 0.0902

71-04-15-278-019.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 01/16/2014 $335,000 76,500 309,500 386,000 1.1522 0.1836

71-04-15-276-016.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 02/19/2014 $404,000 67,800 357,400 425,200 1.0525 0.0838

71-04-15-126-011.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 02/28/2014 $214,000 65,000 259,000 324,000 1.5140 0.5454

71-04-15-127-014.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 03/11/2014 $300,000 63,000 247,500 310,500 1.0350 0.0663

71-04-15-354-006.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 04/30/2014 $410,000 74,800 337,000 411,800 1.0044 0.0357

71-04-15-176-008.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 05/08/2014 $235,500 65,700 232,800 298,500 1.2675 0.2989

71-04-15-477-005.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 06/12/2014 $446,000 80,400 333,700 414,100 0.9285 0.0402

71-04-15-251-008.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 06/19/2014 $229,000 58,600 225,700 284,300 1.2415 0.2728

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-15-453-020.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 07/03/2014 $400,000 74,500 254,900 329,400 0.8235 0.1452

71-04-15-429-004.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 07/09/2014 $454,000 77,500 324,700 402,200 0.8859 0.0828

71-04-22-103-007.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 09/02/2014 $340,000 56,100 267,500 323,600 0.9518 0.0169

71-04-15-203-018.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 11/06/2014 $318,500 75,400 241,700 317,100 0.9956 0.0269

71-04-15-276-018.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 12/22/2014 $450,000 67,800 337,500 405,300 0.9007 0.0680

71-04-14-201-008.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 02/19/2014 $330,000 74,000 250,200 324,200 0.9824 0.0138

71-04-14-102-008.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 04/02/2014 $395,500 71,900 292,400 364,300 0.9211 0.0475

71-04-14-102-012.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 04/10/2014 $310,000 70,300 234,700 305,000 0.9839 0.0152

71-04-14-226-006.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 05/07/2014 $412,000 87,300 310,700 398,000 0.9660 0.0026

71-04-14-227-003.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 05/08/2014 $410,000 71,000 306,800 377,800 0.9215 0.0472

71-04-14-277-003.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 06/18/2014 $449,000 71,600 356,000 427,600 0.9523 0.0163

71-04-14-178-013.000-011 Harris 7111055 510 011 07/03/2014 $292,500 94,100 217,400 311,500 1.0650 0.0963

71-04-14-252-010.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 02/13/2014 $830,000 156,900 375,100 532,000 0.6410 0.3277

71-04-14-252-032.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 02/19/2014 $575,000 123,000 365,500 488,500 0.8496 0.1191

71-04-14-251-023.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 04/25/2014 $490,000 137,800 350,700 488,500 0.9969 0.0283

71-04-14-252-038.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 05/15/2014 $422,500 111,500 309,600 421,100 0.9967 0.0280

71-04-14-252-026.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 06/18/2014 $569,900 148,300 416,000 564,300 0.9902 0.0215

71-04-14-251-004.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 07/10/2014 $542,000 111,500 350,200 461,700 0.8518 0.1168

71-04-14-153-023.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 08/14/2014 $825,000 159,900 648,800 808,700 0.9802 0.0116

71-04-14-153-017.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 08/18/2014 $525,000 111,500 333,000 444,500 0.8467 0.1220

71-04-14-153-007.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 12/16/2014 $525,000 121,800 374,200 496,000 0.9448 0.0239

71-04-14-251-025.000-011 Harris 7111056 510 011 12/22/2014 $442,000 139,800 319,300 459,100 1.0387 0.0700

71-04-14-334-014.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 02/04/2014 $175,000 28,800 142,100 170,900 0.9766 0.0079

71-04-14-334-007.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 02/19/2014 $162,000 28,000 136,800 164,800 1.0173 0.0486

71-04-14-332-004.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 04/03/2014 $189,000 28,500 160,200 188,700 0.9984 0.0298

71-04-14-452-001.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 04/23/2014 $178,000 31,000 150,600 181,600 1.0202 0.0516

71-04-14-334-013.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 05/01/2014 $171,000 27,800 153,400 181,200 1.0596 0.0910

71-04-14-303-009.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 05/01/2014 $225,000 28,600 184,500 213,100 0.9471 0.0215

71-04-14-452-003.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 06/03/2014 $135,000 52,600 88,000 140,600 1.0415 0.0728

71-04-14-305-012.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 06/06/2014 $227,500 34,700 191,300 226,000 0.9934 0.0247

71-04-14-303-003.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 07/15/2014 $264,900 30,300 222,500 252,800 0.9543 0.0143

71-04-14-329-003.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 07/16/2014 $183,000 30,500 142,700 173,200 0.9464 0.0222

71-04-14-305-005.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 08/29/2014 $229,000 42,600 168,100 210,700 0.9201 0.0486

71-04-14-305-008.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 09/10/2014 $239,900 26,500 182,300 208,800 0.8704 0.0983

71-04-14-326-008.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 09/12/2014 $295,000 34,100 217,000 251,100 0.8512 0.1175

71-04-14-302-011.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 09/19/2014 $330,000 32,000 306,600 338,600 1.0261 0.0574

71-04-14-331-004.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 10/02/2014 $210,000 27,000 149,700 176,700 0.8414 0.1272

71-04-14-334-004.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 10/02/2014 $165,000 31,500 168,200 199,700 1.2103 0.2416

71-04-14-305-006.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 10/07/2014 $238,900 32,400 195,200 227,600 0.9527 0.0160

71-04-14-305-004.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 12/17/2014 $225,000 29,100 198,100 227,200 1.0098 0.0411

71-04-14-330-004.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 01/22/2015 $235,000 28,900 191,800 220,700 0.9391 0.0295

71-04-22-201-005.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 02/18/2014 $122,000 18,900 99,100 118,000 0.9672 0.0014

71-04-22-252-013.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 06/04/2014 $156,000 18,900 134,500 153,400 0.9833 0.0147

71-04-22-252-027.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 07/08/2014 $136,700 18,500 118,800 137,300 1.0044 0.0357

71-04-22-252-016.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 07/11/2014 $139,900 18,900 137,400 156,300 1.1172 0.1486

71-04-22-253-009.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 10/03/2014 $147,000 16,100 131,900 148,000 1.0068 0.0381

71-04-22-179-012.000-011 Harris 7111064 510 011 01/22/2015 $116,000 17,700 91,400 109,100 0.9405 0.0281

71-04-23-228-005.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 01/22/2014 $185,000 17,300 143,800 161,100 0.8708 0.0978

71-04-24-152-009.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 01/23/2014 $158,500 21,700 132,700 154,400 0.9741 0.0055

71-04-24-103-019.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 02/06/2014 $178,400 17,300 181,400 198,700 1.1138 0.1451

71-04-24-103-004.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 02/21/2014 $129,900 17,300 159,800 177,100 1.3634 0.3947

71-04-23-203-001.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 03/31/2014 $137,500 17,300 120,000 137,300 0.9985 0.0299

71-04-23-227-009.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 04/02/2014 $166,900 17,300 149,700 167,000 1.0006 0.0319

71-04-24-127-009.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 04/21/2014 $260,000 20,800 215,100 235,900 0.9073 0.0613

71-04-24-127-011.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 07/17/2014 $222,500 25,500 191,000 216,500 0.9730 0.0044

71-04-23-228-016.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 09/10/2014 $145,000 17,300 129,800 147,100 1.0145 0.0458

71-04-24-126-004.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 10/17/2014 $175,000 23,800 156,700 180,500 1.0314 0.0628

71-04-24-101-004.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 11/25/2014 $178,000 18,000 158,000 176,000 0.9888 0.0201

71-04-24-128-001.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 12/12/2014 $220,000 21,200 209,200 230,400 1.0473 0.0786

71-04-24-176-007.000-011 Harris 7111066 510 011 01/29/2015 $157,000 24,600 150,500 175,100 1.1153 0.1466

71-04-26-131-002.000-011 Harris 7111070 510 011 09/04/2014 $235,000 17,700 155,500 173,200 0.7370 0.2316

71-04-26-127-001.000-011 Harris 7111070 510 011 12/18/2014 $167,000 24,400 166,400 190,800 1.1425 0.1739

71-04-26-102-011.000-011 Harris 7111070 510 011 02/11/2015 $217,500 18,400 137,400 155,800 0.7163 0.2523

71-04-26-151-009.000-011 Harris 7111071 510 011 06/11/2014 $321,500 29,100 267,600 296,700 0.9229 0.0458

71-05-07-404-001.000-011 Harris 7111074 510 011 08/20/2014 $175,000 15,400 135,400 150,800 0.8617 0.1069

71-05-07-403-013.000-011 Harris 7111074 510 011 11/06/2014 $153,500 15,300 119,100 134,400 0.8756 0.0931

71-05-08-378-019.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 02/28/2014 $210,000 21,600 161,700 183,300 0.8729 0.0958

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-05-08-329-006.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 03/11/2014 $179,900 21,500 141,600 163,100 0.9066 0.0620

71-05-08-378-018.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 04/09/2014 $192,000 26,500 160,000 186,500 0.9714 0.0027

71-05-08-402-003.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 04/14/2014 $142,000 21,100 122,400 143,500 1.0106 0.0419

71-05-08-328-013.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 05/21/2014 $178,000 22,300 156,700 179,000 1.0056 0.0370

71-05-08-329-017.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 05/21/2014 $172,000 23,000 139,200 162,200 0.9430 0.0256

71-05-08-328-002.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 06/11/2014 $169,500 23,000 147,700 170,700 1.0071 0.0384

71-05-08-380-005.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 07/02/2014 $265,000 27,900 178,100 206,000 0.7774 0.1913

71-05-08-381-003.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 07/11/2014 $191,250 22,300 156,500 178,800 0.9349 0.0338

71-05-08-328-007.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 08/01/2014 $219,000 22,600 190,500 213,100 0.9731 0.0044

71-05-08-326-010.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 08/13/2014 $192,500 21,500 147,400 168,900 0.8774 0.0913

71-05-08-329-010.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 10/06/2014 $190,000 21,100 146,400 167,500 0.8816 0.0871

71-05-08-329-014.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 12/31/2014 $188,500 27,200 168,000 195,200 1.0355 0.0669

71-05-08-351-008.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 02/04/2015 $130,800 25,300 114,900 140,200 1.0719 0.1032

71-05-08-326-007.000-011 Harris 7111076 510 011 02/18/2015 $174,000 28,900 144,400 173,300 0.9960 0.0273

71-05-08-478-001.000-011 Harris 7111081 510 011 06/25/2014 $451,000 43,100 354,700 397,800 0.8820 0.0866

71-05-09-452-005.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 01/30/2014 $189,000 27,600 172,900 200,500 1.0608 0.0922

71-05-09-378-011.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 03/24/2014 $190,000 27,100 186,500 213,600 1.1242 0.1556

71-05-09-331-012.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 03/26/2014 $187,500 27,900 189,200 217,100 1.1579 0.1892

71-05-08-427-014.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 04/21/2014 $170,000 29,600 144,800 174,400 1.0259 0.0572

71-05-09-303-010.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 04/30/2014 $221,000 24,700 180,000 204,700 0.9262 0.0424

71-05-09-328-012.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 05/08/2014 $236,000 26,700 210,300 237,000 1.0042 0.0356

71-05-09-330-005.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 05/14/2014 $210,000 27,000 184,400 211,400 1.0067 0.0380

71-05-09-353-001.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 05/21/2014 $220,000 25,900 181,900 207,800 0.9445 0.0241

71-05-09-329-007.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 05/23/2014 $267,500 27,300 214,500 241,800 0.9039 0.0647

71-05-09-329-003.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 07/01/2014 $258,900 26,300 238,900 265,200 1.0243 0.0557

71-05-09-301-006.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 07/03/2014 $194,900 34,800 238,300 273,100 1.4012 0.4326

71-05-09-377-020.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 07/09/2014 $241,500 25,700 173,600 199,300 0.8253 0.1434

71-05-09-329-001.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 08/13/2014 $289,000 29,700 221,400 251,100 0.8689 0.0998

71-05-09-304-016.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 08/28/2014 $187,000 25,300 185,800 211,100 1.1289 0.1602

71-05-09-403-005.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 08/28/2014 $195,000 27,000 178,300 205,300 1.0528 0.0842

71-05-09-303-005.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 09/10/2014 $202,000 25,700 176,100 201,800 0.9990 0.0304

71-05-09-302-005.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 09/24/2014 $190,900 26,300 156,200 182,500 0.9560 0.0127

71-05-09-378-007.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 11/17/2014 $219,450 27,800 192,300 220,100 1.0030 0.0343

71-05-09-331-001.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 11/17/2014 $224,000 30,900 189,400 220,300 0.9835 0.0148

71-05-09-353-009.000-011 Harris 7111083 510 011 12/16/2014 $143,000 32,200 131,800 164,000 1.1469 0.1782

71-05-17-101-013.000-011 Harris 7111087 510 011 07/24/2014 $210,000 30,900 177,600 208,500 0.9929 0.0242

71-05-17-129-003.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 02/04/2014 $161,000 22,500 138,500 161,000 1.0000 0.0313

71-05-17-129-008.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 02/19/2014 $163,900 22,200 151,600 173,800 1.0604 0.0917

71-05-17-182-003.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 05/22/2014 $192,500 24,800 182,700 207,500 1.0779 0.1093

71-05-17-184-005.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 06/27/2014 $185,000 24,200 157,100 181,300 0.9800 0.0113

71-05-17-128-008.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 08/08/2014 $184,500 22,900 159,900 182,800 0.9908 0.0221

71-05-17-178-005.000-011 Harris 7111091 510 011 09/12/2014 $187,000 25,400 164,100 189,500 1.0134 0.0447

71-05-16-228-001.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 03/19/2014 $205,000 10,900 194,300 205,200 1.0010 0.0323

71-05-16-280-014.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 07/10/2014 $239,900 10,900 228,000 238,900 0.9958 0.0272

71-05-16-231-005.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 07/28/2014 $168,500 11,700 192,700 204,400 1.2131 0.2444

71-05-16-229-001.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 08/11/2014 $208,000 11,200 234,600 245,800 1.1817 0.2131

71-05-16-226-006.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 11/19/2014 $234,000 14,100 193,500 207,600 0.8872 0.0815

71-05-16-280-001.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 01/27/2015 $245,000 13,300 203,600 216,900 0.8853 0.0834

71-05-16-254-013.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 02/04/2015 $182,000 14,200 177,700 191,900 1.0544 0.0857

71-05-16-255-001.000-011 Harris 7111092 510 011 02/11/2015 $355,000 21,800 311,000 332,800 0.9375 0.0312

71-05-18-426-007.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 03/26/2014 $147,500 11,100 133,200 144,300 0.9783 0.0096

71-05-18-432-003.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 04/15/2014 $139,000 11,400 131,800 143,200 1.0302 0.0616

71-05-18-253-003.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 05/21/2014 $138,500 12,300 106,900 119,200 0.8606 0.1080

71-05-18-201-020.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 05/29/2014 $120,900 15,300 102,700 118,000 0.9760 0.0074

71-05-18-430-014.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 06/09/2014 $143,000 11,600 143,300 154,900 1.0832 0.1146

71-05-18-403-014.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 06/20/2014 $125,000 10,400 103,700 114,100 0.9128 0.0559

71-05-18-406-014.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 07/10/2014 $191,000 12,500 196,800 209,300 1.0958 0.1272

71-05-18-426-014.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 07/17/2014 $145,000 12,500 133,800 146,300 1.0090 0.0403

71-05-18-254-012.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 07/25/2014 $149,000 12,000 130,200 142,200 0.9544 0.0143

71-05-18-431-001.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 09/22/2014 $151,500 14,200 143,500 157,700 1.0409 0.0723

71-05-18-201-023.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 09/24/2014 $165,000 12,300 174,400 186,700 1.1315 0.1629

71-05-18-201-018.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 09/25/2014 $121,900 12,800 100,500 113,300 0.9295 0.0392

71-05-18-405-014.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 10/31/2014 $139,000 13,300 115,400 128,700 0.9259 0.0428

71-05-18-430-021.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 11/17/2014 $142,000 14,200 168,400 182,600 1.2859 0.3173

71-05-18-278-006.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 12/09/2014 $128,500 12,300 100,600 112,900 0.8786 0.0901

71-05-18-278-012.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 12/09/2014 $142,500 13,400 130,100 143,500 1.0070 0.0384

71-05-18-277-005.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 12/22/2014 $143,500 12,000 112,800 124,800 0.8697 0.0990

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-05-18-404-002.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 02/17/2015 $130,000 11,100 123,200 134,300 1.0331 0.0644

71-05-16-426-001.000-011 Harris 7111095 510 011 07/17/2014 $128,000 20,900 121,100 142,000 1.1094 0.1407

71-05-18-377-001.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 04/07/2014 $115,500 20,100 106,800 126,900 1.0987 0.1300

71-05-18-352-002.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 05/21/2014 $117,000 20,700 111,500 132,200 1.1299 0.1613

71-05-19-127-001.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 06/11/2014 $158,000 25,000 120,900 145,900 0.9234 0.0452

71-05-18-356-001.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 06/25/2014 $135,000 23,300 110,000 133,300 0.9874 0.0188

71-05-19-179-003.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 07/08/2014 $98,000 19,800 87,500 107,300 1.0949 0.1262

71-05-19-129-011.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 09/11/2014 $130,000 19,200 87,100 106,300 0.8177 0.1510

71-05-19-130-003.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 10/06/2014 $133,000 21,100 98,600 119,700 0.9000 0.0687

71-05-19-129-004.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 12/15/2014 $127,000 15,600 97,500 113,100 0.8906 0.0781

71-05-18-378-008.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 12/20/2014 $137,000 19,400 97,200 116,600 0.8511 0.1176

71-05-18-381-009.000-011 Harris 7111097 510 011 12/30/2014 $114,000 19,400 89,900 109,300 0.9588 0.0099

71-05-19-251-001.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 01/22/2014 $218,000 17,000 163,500 180,500 0.8280 0.1407

71-05-19-209-006.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 04/03/2014 $175,000 24,400 157,900 182,300 1.0417 0.0731

71-05-19-201-004.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 04/22/2014 $188,500 14,800 138,600 153,400 0.8138 0.1549

71-05-18-453-010.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 08/19/2014 $200,000 15,800 145,100 160,900 0.8045 0.1642

71-05-19-254-013.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 09/02/2014 $145,000 17,500 137,800 155,300 1.0710 0.1024

71-05-19-204-007.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 09/30/2014 $110,000 19,100 135,200 154,300 1.4027 0.4341

71-05-19-201-002.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 11/13/2014 $150,000 19,900 138,400 158,300 1.0553 0.0867

71-05-19-203-010.000-011 Harris 7111099 510 011 02/13/2015 $155,000 19,100 122,000 141,100 0.9103 0.0583

71-05-18-476-007.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 03/12/2014 $134,000 19,400 116,600 136,000 1.0149 0.0463

71-05-19-229-003.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 03/21/2014 $140,000 14,600 154,100 168,700 1.2050 0.2363

71-05-19-227-013.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 04/01/2014 $143,800 21,700 138,200 159,900 1.1120 0.1433

71-05-19-229-012.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 04/15/2014 $185,000 18,600 165,700 184,300 0.9962 0.0276

71-05-20-101-011.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 05/07/2014 $152,500 18,600 135,100 153,700 1.0079 0.0392

71-05-17-355-012.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 05/19/2014 $197,000 22,100 144,400 166,500 0.8452 0.1235

71-05-20-101-010.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 07/14/2014 $205,000 18,600 184,300 202,900 0.9898 0.0211

71-05-20-104-001.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 07/25/2014 $210,000 25,800 169,700 195,500 0.9310 0.0377

71-05-20-102-005.000-011 Harris 7111100 500 011 07/25/2014 $0 0 0

71-05-20-104-002.000-011 Harris 7111100 500 011 07/25/2014 $0 0 0

71-05-18-480-008.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 09/10/2014 $157,000 18,000 123,100 141,100 0.8987 0.0699

71-05-20-105-010.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 09/23/2014 $170,000 30,300 184,400 214,700 1.2629 0.2943

71-05-18-479-002.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 09/24/2014 $155,000 19,400 142,500 161,900 1.0445 0.0759

71-05-20-104-022.000-011 Harris 7111101 510 011 12/23/2014 $195,000 23,900 212,500 236,400 1.2123 0.2437

71-05-17-456-008.000-011 Harris 7111103 510 011 08/05/2014 $169,500 19,900 127,300 147,200 0.8684 0.1002

71-05-17-455-001.000-011 Harris 7111104 510 011 08/18/2014 $173,000 23,400 131,800 155,200 0.8971 0.0715

71-05-17-477-006.000-011 Harris 7111106 510 011 03/11/2014 $180,000 28,800 190,100 218,900 1.2161 0.2475

71-05-17-453-033.000-011 Harris 7111106 510 011 06/19/2014 $287,000 28,300 246,300 274,600 0.9568 0.0119

71-05-19-277-002.000-011 Harris 7111108 510 011 05/21/2014 $257,500 15,900 179,800 195,700 0.7600 0.2087

71-05-19-277-003.000-011 Harris 7111108 510 011 12/10/2014 $156,000 18,300 121,800 140,100 0.8981 0.0706

71-05-19-276-001.000-011 Harris 7111108 510 011 12/17/2014 $246,500 26,300 162,400 188,700 0.7655 0.2031

71-05-16-452-006.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 04/21/2014 $135,000 26,400 106,700 133,100 0.9859 0.0173

71-05-21-227-006.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 06/25/2014 $140,000 24,800 125,500 150,300 1.0736 0.1049

71-05-21-202-006.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 09/19/2014 $142,000 36,300 106,800 143,100 1.0077 0.0391

71-05-16-453-017.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 11/06/2014 $123,000 23,600 99,000 122,600 0.9967 0.0281

71-05-16-452-012.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 11/17/2014 $142,000 26,200 121,900 148,100 1.0430 0.0743

71-05-16-455-008.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 01/23/2015 $140,000 23,600 104,600 128,200 0.9157 0.0529

71-05-16-455-003.000-011 Harris 7111110 510 011 02/10/2015 $162,500 23,600 130,100 153,700 0.9458 0.0228

71-05-21-255-001.000-011 Harris 7111111 510 011 01/17/2014 $167,500 24,300 134,100 158,400 0.9457 0.0230

71-05-21-255-007.000-011 Harris 7111111 510 011 04/02/2014 $156,500 21,900 136,600 158,500 1.0128 0.0441

71-05-21-253-009.000-011 Harris 7111111 510 011 08/06/2014 $179,900 19,900 142,300 162,200 0.9016 0.0670

71-05-21-254-002.000-011 Harris 7111111 510 011 08/08/2014 $175,000 21,300 153,900 175,200 1.0011 0.0325

71-05-21-255-011.000-011 Harris 7111111 510 011 09/23/2014 $190,000 20,700 161,600 182,300 0.9595 0.0092

71-05-28-204-008.000-011 Harris 7111112 510 011 02/14/2014 $219,000 17,700 171,500 189,200 0.8639 0.1047

71-05-28-205-008.000-011 Harris 7111112 510 011 10/02/2014 $219,000 17,400 152,400 169,800 0.7753 0.1933

71-05-28-207-006.000-011 Harris 7111112 510 011 11/24/2014 $212,450 18,000 171,700 189,700 0.8929 0.0757

71-05-28-207-001.000-011 Harris 7111112 510 011 02/10/2015 $300,000 22,400 219,700 242,100 0.8070 0.1617

71-05-28-477-011.000-011 Harris 7111114 510 011 05/09/2014 $103,000 17,400 72,900 90,300 0.8767 0.0920

71-04-13-102-004.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 01/14/2014 $162,000 31,100 135,500 166,600 1.0284 0.0597

71-04-13-152-015.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 01/22/2014 $250,000 32,400 201,500 233,900 0.9356 0.0331

71-04-13-101-004.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 02/10/2014 $218,000 69,400 184,900 254,300 1.1665 0.1979

71-04-13-178-001.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 02/24/2014 $232,500 29,300 185,500 214,800 0.9239 0.0448

71-04-13-101-035.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 04/10/2014 $209,900 33,200 170,500 203,700 0.9705 0.0018

71-04-13-153-002.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 04/17/2014 $218,500 32,700 176,100 208,800 0.9556 0.0131

71-04-13-179-013.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 05/02/2014 $320,000 40,600 273,900 314,500 0.9828 0.0142

71-04-13-156-002.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 06/06/2014 $242,500 39,500 194,400 233,900 0.9645 0.0041

71-04-13-101-028.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 06/26/2014 $298,000 35,400 254,100 289,500 0.9715 0.0028

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-04-13-103-009.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 06/26/2014 $185,000 30,400 148,800 179,200 0.9686 0.0000

71-04-13-180-020.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 06/27/2014 $220,000 35,000 192,100 227,100 1.0323 0.0636

71-04-13-101-026.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 09/17/2014 $235,000 31,600 199,500 231,100 0.9834 0.0147

71-04-13-152-016.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 09/23/2014 $205,001 34,100 175,100 209,200 1.0205 0.0518

71-04-13-130-006.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 09/30/2014 $210,000 32,300 153,600 185,900 0.8852 0.0834

71-04-13-152-021.000-011 Harris 7111116 510 011 10/06/2014 $255,000 36,900 229,400 266,300 1.0443 0.0757

71-04-22-327-020.000-011 Harris 7111121 510 011 08/03/2014 $75,900 11,900 48,700 60,600 0.7984 0.1702

71-04-22-329-005.000-011 Harris 7111121 510 011 08/13/2014 $82,500 14,100 38,300 52,400 0.6352 0.3335

71-04-22-327-008.000-011 Harris 7111121 510 011 08/20/2014 $57,000 12,300 37,100 49,400 0.8667 0.1020

71-04-14-402-002.000-011 Harris 7111126 510 011 12/17/2014 $915,000 48,900 754,000 802,900 0.8775 0.0912

71-05-28-278-002.000-011 Harris 7111127 510 011 03/05/2014 $163,000 30,300 134,200 164,500 1.0092 0.0405

71-05-28-251-036.000-011 Harris 7111127 510 011 12/10/2014 $205,000 32,000 152,900 184,900 0.9020 0.0667

71-05-09-479-018.000-011 Harris 7111128 510 011 04/03/2014 $350,000 37,500 258,800 296,300 0.8466 0.1221

71-05-09-476-015.000-011 Harris 7111128 510 011 07/03/2014 $307,000 35,700 213,300 249,000 0.8111 0.1576

71-05-09-476-011.000-011 Harris 7111128 510 011 11/25/2014 $449,066 37,800 298,800 336,600 0.7496 0.2191

71-05-07-452-006.000-011 Harris 7111074 510 011 2/27/2015 140,000$ 19,400 108,100 127,500 0.9107 0.0579

71-04-15-203-019.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 2/24/2015 277,000$ 69,900 223,300 293,200 1.0585 0.0898

71-04-15-356-005.000-011 Harris 7111051 510 011 2/24/2015 290,000$ 25,200 219,300 244,500 0.8431 0.1256

71-04-14-326-003.000-011 Harris 7111063 510 011 2/25/2015 184,000$ 29,100 151,100 180,200 0.9793 0.0107

71-04-13-201-013.000-011 Harris 7111043 510 011 2/27/2015 170,000$ 43,800 137,700 181,500 1.0676 0.0990

71-04-22-401-015.000-011 Harris 7111121 510 011 2/25/2015 56,000$ 35,400 51,400 86,800 1.5500 0.5813

71-04-15-354-004.000-011 Harris 7111052 510 011 2/27/2015 342,000$ 75,700 250,400 326,100 0.9535 0.0151

71-04-27-378-038.000-036 Harris 7136008 510 036 2/20/2015 149,000$ 26,400 116,700 143,100 0.9604 0.0083

71-05-18-429-007.000-011 Harris 7111094 510 011 2/27/2015 128,900$ 12,200 132,200 144,400 1.1202 0.1516

71-04-10-303-005.000-011 Harris 7111018 510 011 2/27/2015 153,000$ 16,700 125,500 142,200 0.9294 0.0392

71-05-09-478-004.000-011 Harris 7111128 510 011 02/02/2015 $570,500 54,100 362,700 416,800 0.7306 0.2381

71-04-14-103-004.000-011 Harris 7111129 510 011 08/06/2014 $532,000 56,000 467,000 523,000 0.9831 0.0144

71-05-09-479-002.000-011 Harris 7111134 510 011 11/06/2014 $533,000 63,200 371,900 435,100 0.8163 0.1523

71-04-27-376-006.000-036 Harris 7136006 510 036 04/21/2014 $149,000 31,200 96,600 127,800 0.8577 0.1109

71-04-27-377-006.000-036 Harris 7136006 510 036 05/21/2014 $159,000 20,600 105,400 126,000 0.7925 0.1762

71-04-27-379-011.000-036 Harris 7136008 510 036 08/06/2014 $150,000 20,100 114,400 134,500 0.8967 0.0720

71-04-27-327-011.000-036 Harris 7136008 510 036 09/15/2014 $163,500 24,500 135,600 160,100 0.9792 0.0105

71-04-27-378-025.000-036 Harris 7136008 510 036 11/18/2014 $164,000 26,200 132,000 158,200 0.9646 0.0040

71-04-27-379-006.000-036 Harris 7136008 510 036 12/22/2014 $158,000 23,000 121,100 144,100 0.9120 0.0566

71-04-27-328-005.000-036 Harris 7136009 510 036 01/08/2014 $165,000 44,500 134,700 179,200 1.0861 0.1174

71-04-27-328-026.000-036 Harris 7136009 510 036 08/14/2014 $185,000 40,500 142,200 182,700 0.9876 0.0189

$83,636,132 79,659,500 345

Mean 0.9722

Median 0.9687

Wtd Mean 0.9525

COD 9.9067

PRD 1.02076

LIBERTY TOWNSHIP

71-11-25-400-003.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 02/14/2014 $79,000 38,800 51,800 90,600 1.1468 0.2213

71-12-21-476-001.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 09/04/2014 $166,000 41,600 132,400 174,000 1.0482 0.1226

71-18-18-300-002.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 09/26/2014 $85,000 35,600 47,600 83,200 0.9788 0.0532

71-17-02-100-003.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 01/07/2015 $129,000 38,800 93,300 132,100 1.0240 0.0984

71-12-19-200-012.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 07/21/2014 $270,000 64,700 177,500 242,200 0.8970 0.0285

71-12-19-200-010.000-034 Liberty 7134001 100 034 07/21/2014 $0 0 0

71-17-04-100-006.000-034 Liberty 7134005 510 034 01/14/2015 $159,900 43,000 106,100 149,100 0.9325 0.0069

71-12-28-100-058.000-035 Liberty 7135001 510 035 05/12/2014 $230,000 66,000 161,900 227,900 0.9909 0.0653

71-12-32-229-004.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 03/04/2014 $93,500 11,600 71,500 83,100 0.8888 0.0368

71-12-28-354-004.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 03/31/2014 $89,900 14,100 68,900 83,000 0.9232 0.0023

71-12-32-235-005.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 04/30/2014 $37,000 14,400 27,100 41,500 1.1216 0.1960

71-12-32-479-025.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 06/19/2014 $136,000 15,100 99,800 114,900 0.8449 0.0807

71-12-32-254-011.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 02/27/2014 $70,000 35,300 31,300 66,600 0.9514 0.0258

71-12-32-254-009.000-035 Liberty 7135020 500 035 02/27/2014 $0 0 0

71-12-32-229-005.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 07/10/2014 $78,000 14,700 83,000 97,700 1.2526 0.3270

71-12-28-358-014.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 07/11/2014 $47,500 11,100 41,100 52,200 1.0989 0.1734

71-12-32-202-017.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/01/2014 $57,500 12,800 52,400 65,200 1.1339 0.2083

71-12-28-304-003.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/04/2014 $96,000 13,000 57,100 70,100 0.7302 0.1954

71-12-29-429-002.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/06/2014 $82,000 11,700 47,200 58,900 0.7183 0.2073

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-12-28-303-006.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/19/2014 $89,000 18,700 59,100 77,800 0.8742 0.0514

71-12-32-254-010.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 09/18/2014 $89,500 23,400 71,300 94,700 1.0581 0.1325

71-12-32-202-007.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 09/30/2014 $155,000 23,900 110,300 134,200 0.8658 0.0598

71-12-32-479-026.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/10/2014 $151,000 15,400 95,500 110,900 0.7344 0.1911

71-12-33-102-002.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/15/2014 $95,500 10,400 35,600 46,000 0.4817 0.4439

71-12-32-478-003.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/23/2014 $139,000 22,300 94,600 116,900 0.8410 0.0846

71-12-28-358-002.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 11/06/2014 $35,000 10,200 21,400 31,600 0.9029 0.0227

71-12-32-202-019.000-035 Liberty 7135020 510 035 12/29/2014 $86,000 11,000 68,600 79,600 0.9256 0.0000

71-12-32-256-003.000-035 Liberty 7135023 510 035 02/06/2014 $83,000 33,100 52,800 85,900 1.0349 0.1094

71-12-32-256-002.000-035 Liberty 7135023 510 035 08/15/2014 $88,000 34,500 42,100 76,600 0.8705 0.0551

$2,917,300 2,686,500 27

Mean 0.9360

Median 0.9256

Wtd Mean 0.9209

COD 12.8044

PRD 1.0164

LINCOLN TOWNSHIP

71-16-13-327-006.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 07/11/2014 $165,400 7,400 153,600 161,000 0.9734 0.0528

71-16-13-327-005.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 10/13/2014 $170,000 7,500 189,300 196,800 1.1576 0.1315

71-16-13-326-005.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 10/16/2014 $181,900 7,300 178,300 185,600 1.0203 0.0059

71-16-13-326-008.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 11/06/2014 $109,000 7,600 130,200 137,800 1.2642 0.2380

71-16-26-280-010.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 12/03/2014 $165,400 9,400 147,100 156,500 0.9462 0.0800

71-16-26-280-013.000-015 Lincoln 7115018 510 015 12/04/2014 $164,617 6,000 136,700 142,700 0.8669 0.1593

71-16-26-204-011.000-015 Lincoln 7115012 510 015 06/10/2014 $113,000 10,800 101,500 112,300 0.9938 0.0324

71-16-26-280-002.000-015 Lincoln 7115012 510 015 10/14/2014 $86,500 20,200 66,900 87,100 1.0069 0.0193

71-16-26-205-006.000-015 Lincoln 7115012 510 015 12/30/2014 $80,000 10,400 74,200 84,600 1.0575 0.0313

71-16-26-203-005.000-015 Lincoln 7115012 510 015 01/23/2015 $90,000 10,400 86,700 97,100 1.0789 0.0527

71-16-24-355-009.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 02/27/2014 $42,000 5,400 38,100 43,500 1.0357 0.0095

71-16-23-426-016.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 05/05/2014 $63,000 5,200 61,000 66,200 1.0508 0.0246

71-16-25-127-008.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 05/29/2014 $81,000 8,700 104,000 112,700 1.3914 0.3652

71-16-23-477-008.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 06/04/2014 $79,000 5,100 60,100 65,200 0.8253 0.2009

71-16-24-380-002.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 06/10/2014 $57,000 9,300 53,000 62,300 1.0930 0.0668

71-16-25-101-006.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 07/14/2014 $70,000 6,900 84,500 91,400 1.3057 0.2795

71-16-24-453-001.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 07/25/2014 $140,000 33,000 126,700 159,700 1.1407 0.1145

71-16-25-105-001.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/07/2014 $68,500 8,600 86,900 95,500 1.3942 0.3680

71-16-23-479-011.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/23/2014 $117,000 11,500 91,800 103,300 0.8829 0.1433

71-16-25-102-006.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/29/2014 $112,000 8,400 86,000 94,400 0.8429 0.1833

71-16-24-333-010.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 11/20/2014 $85,000 6,800 72,600 79,400 0.9341 0.0921

71-16-24-360-006.000-015 Lincoln 7115010 510 015 12/16/2014 $100,000 8,600 85,500 94,100 0.9410 0.0852

71-16-13-400-001.000-014 Lincoln 7114003 511 014 01/22/2014 $207,000 53,900 146,400 200,300 0.9676 0.0586

71-16-12-100-003.000-014 Lincoln 7114003 513 014 07/31/2014 $150,000 107,300 78,000 185,300 1.2353 0.2091

71-16-15-200-007.000-014 Lincoln 7114003 511 014 08/20/2014 $282,500 50,700 239,200 289,900 1.0262 0.0000

71-16-25-400-009.000-014 Lincoln 7114003 511 014 10/15/2014 $230,000 41,900 143,400 185,300 0.8057 0.2205

71-16-10-400-001.000-014 Lincoln 7114003 513 014 01/20/2015 $130,000 107,300 48,300 155,600 1.1969 0.1707

$3,339,817 3,445,600 27

Mean 1.0532

Median 1.0262

Wtd Mean 1.0317

COD 12.2529

PRD 1.0208

MADISON TOWNSHIP

71-14-35-200-002.000-016 Madison 7116006 511 016 05/09/2014 $130,000 44,700 100,900 145,600 1.1200 0.1128

71-14-17-200-003.000-016 Madison 7116006 511 016 05/12/2014 $223,000 45,300 225,500 270,800 1.2143 0.2072

71-14-16-426-001.000-016 Madison 7116006 511 016 06/26/2014 $112,000 63,900 24,200 88,100 0.7866 0.2206

71-14-16-277-002.000-016 Madison 7116001 100 016 06/26/2014 $0 0 0

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-14-15-351-001.000-016 Madison 7116006 510 016 12/29/2014 $117,500 37,700 62,500 100,200 0.8528 0.1544

71-14-35-100-005.000-016 Madison 7116006 511 016 01/28/2015 $109,000 40,700 72,000 112,700 1.0339 0.0268

71-14-16-426-004.000-016 Madison 7116006 511 016 7/16/2014 138,000$ 38,700 96,600 135,300 0.9804 0.0268

71-14-34-377-002.000-016 Madison 7116005 510 016 05/13/2014 $42,000 6,500 42,700 49,200 1.1714 0.1642

71-14-20-200-001.000-016 Madison 7116005 511 016 08/07/2014 $205,000 43,700 140,200 183,900 0.8971 0.1101

$1,076,500 1,085,800 8

Mean 1.0071

Median 1.0072

Wtd Mean 1.0086

COD 12.6943

PRD 0.99845

OLIVE TOWNSHIP

71-01-34-405-002.000-018 Olive 7118017 510 018 04/22/2014 $230,000 30,700 193,800 224,500 0.9761 0.0582

71-01-34-401-003.000-018 Olive 7118017 510 018 12/09/2014 $270,500 27,000 196,300 223,300 0.8255 0.0924

71-01-34-451-003.000-018 Olive 7118017 510 018 12/09/2014 $230,000 24,300 158,800 183,100 0.7961 0.1218

71-01-34-452-003.000-018 Olive 7118017 510 018 12/29/2014 $254,701 26,700 158,100 184,800 0.7256 0.1923

71-01-34-429-015.000-018 Olive 7118013 510 018 02/13/2014 $124,000 11,300 125,100 136,400 1.1000 0.1821

71-01-34-476-011.000-018 Olive 7118013 510 018 03/17/2014 $279,000 30,200 230,200 260,400 0.9333 0.0154

71-01-34-405-026.000-018 Olive 7118013 510 018 03/19/2014 $187,000 23,400 128,700 152,100 0.8134 0.1045

71-01-34-280-037.000-018 Olive 7118011 510 018 01/31/2014 $149,900 13,900 136,800 150,700 1.0053 0.0874

71-01-35-153-003.000-018 Olive 7118011 510 018 04/11/2014 $168,000 9,800 143,500 153,300 0.9125 0.0054

71-01-34-428-001.000-018 Olive 7118011 510 018 04/29/2014 $172,000 15,100 125,500 140,600 0.8174 0.1005

71-01-34-427-002.000-018 Olive 7118011 510 018 08/08/2014 $168,000 20,500 138,700 159,200 0.9476 0.0297

71-01-34-280-036.000-018 Olive 7118011 510 018 08/13/2014 $204,900 11,600 135,700 147,300 0.7189 0.1990

71-01-35-376-025.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 01/10/2014 $145,900 8,100 153,500 161,600 1.1076 0.1897

71-01-34-279-009.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 02/28/2014 $62,000 5,500 64,300 69,800 1.1258 0.2079

71-01-35-376-019.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 04/22/2014 $165,400 7,800 155,100 162,900 0.9849 0.0670

71-01-34-276-014.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 05/08/2014 $89,000 4,900 83,800 88,700 0.9966 0.0787

71-01-35-376-022.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 07/01/2014 $182,000 8,100 164,900 173,000 0.9505 0.0327

71-01-35-200-002.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 07/02/2014 $160,000 22,700 178,900 201,600 1.2600 0.3421

71-01-34-279-001.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 07/03/2014 $88,000 6,500 81,200 87,700 0.9966 0.0787

71-01-35-376-004.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 07/09/2014 $175,000 7,600 187,500 195,100 1.1149 0.1970

71-01-34-276-001.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 07/16/2014 $177,500 9,000 112,100 121,100 0.6823 0.2356

71-01-34-236-011.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 09/24/2014 $81,000 4,500 79,200 83,700 1.0333 0.1154

71-01-34-255-006.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 11/21/2014 $110,000 9,000 64,100 73,100 0.6645 0.2534

71-01-35-376-014.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 11/26/2014 $160,000 9,300 196,200 205,500 1.2844 0.3665

71-01-35-376-021.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 12/09/2014 $224,250 7,800 189,600 197,400 0.8803 0.0376

71-01-34-254-019.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 12/30/2014 $50,000 7,100 69,700 76,800 1.5360 0.6181

71-01-34-276-008.000-018 Olive 7118009 510 018 02/04/2015 $62,000 4,500 57,700 62,200 1.0032 0.0853

71-01-34-176-018.000-018 Olive 7118008 510 018 07/25/2014 $129,910 9,900 80,700 90,600 0.6974 0.2205

71-01-34-129-006.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 02/05/2014 $68,000 14,200 55,800 70,000 1.0294 0.1115

71-01-34-202-009.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 03/18/2014 $93,000 15,800 79,200 95,000 1.0215 0.1036

71-01-34-206-003.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 03/20/2014 $90,000 12,400 57,300 69,700 0.7744 0.1435

71-01-34-278-020.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 05/09/2014 $95,000 15,000 70,100 85,100 0.8958 0.0221

71-01-34-280-010.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 05/15/2014 $94,000 15,000 68,100 83,100 0.8840 0.0339

71-01-34-128-036.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 05/28/2014 $84,000 13,900 63,400 77,300 0.9202 0.0023

71-01-34-126-005.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 06/11/2014 $97,000 13,600 74,000 87,600 0.9031 0.0148

71-01-34-128-030.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 07/02/2014 $64,000 13,900 57,400 71,300 1.1141 0.1962

71-01-34-280-004.000-018 Olive 7118006 510 018 12/18/2014 $60,000 15,000 57,700 72,700 1.2117 0.2938

71-06-03-102-011.000-017 Olive 7117023 510 017 08/07/2014 $175,000 19,600 130,800 150,400 0.8594 0.0585

71-07-29-200-002.000-017 Olive 7117020 510 017 07/15/2014 $142,000 20,700 81,900 102,600 0.7225 0.1954

71-07-29-400-004.000-017 Olive 7117020 510 017 09/08/2014 $170,000 23,000 111,900 134,900 0.7935 0.1244

71-07-20-400-003.000-017 Olive 7117020 510 017 12/30/2014 $115,500 14,700 91,800 106,500 0.9221 0.0042

71-02-33-400-001.000-017 Olive 7117018 510 017 03/26/2014 $155,000 26,600 126,500 153,100 0.9877 0.0698

71-01-25-400-007.000-017 Olive 7117018 510 017 05/14/2014 $116,326 22,500 75,700 98,200 0.8442 0.0737

71-06-02-326-007.000-017 Olive 7117018 510 017 01/12/2015 $289,484 56,000 225,400 281,400 0.9721 0.0542

71-01-35-301-008.000-017 Olive 7117015 510 017 09/19/2014 $160,000 9,500 103,800 113,300 0.7081 0.2098

71-06-02-303-001.000-017 Olive 7117014 510 017 06/04/2014 $220,000 29,000 187,800 216,800 0.9855 0.0676

71-06-02-302-008.000-017 Olive 7117014 510 017 06/24/2014 $218,000 19,500 143,700 163,200 0.7486 0.1693

71-06-02-352-007.000-017 Olive 7117014 510 017 08/26/2014 $225,000 20,400 185,600 206,000 0.9156 0.0023

71-06-03-227-002.000-017 Olive 7117013 511 017 03/18/2014 $56,800 23,600 43,400 67,000 1.1796 0.2617

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-06-02-352-027.000-017 Olive 7117014 510 017 2/20/2015 208,000$ 20,900 145,400 166,300 0.7995 0.1184

71-06-03-152-008.000-017 Olive 7117010 510 017 02/14/2014 $192,000 15,200 136,100 151,300 0.7880 0.1299

71-06-03-153-014.000-017 Olive 7117010 510 017 09/30/2014 $157,000 23,100 117,900 141,000 0.8981 0.0198

71-06-03-176-002.000-017 Olive 7117010 510 017 11/17/2014 $174,000 16,400 124,500 140,900 0.8098 0.1081

71-06-03-152-001.000-017 Olive 7117010 510 017 02/25/2015 $137,000 15,200 110,200 125,400 0.9153 0.0026

$8,156,071 7,396,600 54

Mean 0.9351

Median 0.9179

Wtd Mean 0.9069

COD 13.933

PRD 1.03108

PENN TOWNSHIP

71-09-03-126-019.000-022 Penn 7122053 510 022 06/19/2014 $253,000 30,000 183,800 213,800 0.8451 0.1091

71-09-03-102-030.000-022 Penn 7122053 550 022 07/18/2014 $250,000 30,000 179,600 209,600 0.8384 0.1157

71-09-03-126-016.000-022 Penn 7122053 550 022 09/26/2014 $273,000 30,000 186,100 216,100 0.7916 0.1625

71-09-04-151-019.000-022 Penn 7122054 510 022 08/06/2014 $128,900 13,200 104,800 118,000 0.9154 0.0387

71-04-34-452-019.000-022 Penn 7122056 552 022 01/22/2014 $140,000 15,100 113,100 128,200 0.9157 0.0384

71-04-34-452-016.000-022 Penn 7122056 552 022 04/09/2014 $144,000 14,000 121,300 135,300 0.9396 0.0145

71-04-34-452-004.000-022 Penn 7122056 550 022 04/22/2014 $153,000 17,900 126,300 144,200 0.9425 0.0116

71-04-34-452-002.000-022 Penn 7122056 550 022 06/12/2014 $129,500 15,100 102,400 117,500 0.9073 0.0468

71-04-34-452-014.000-022 Penn 7122056 552 022 06/12/2014 $132,900 15,100 101,900 117,000 0.8804 0.0738

71-04-34-452-026.000-022 Penn 7122056 552 022 06/25/2014 $118,000 17,400 98,500 115,900 0.9822 0.0281

71-04-34-453-022.000-022 Penn 7122056 550 022 07/24/2014 $178,000 15,800 160,800 176,600 0.9921 0.0380

71-04-34-452-080.000-022 Penn 7122056 551 022 08/12/2014 $165,000 17,900 140,600 158,500 0.9606 0.0065

71-04-34-452-054.000-022 Penn 7122056 550 022 09/22/2014 $150,500 15,100 125,500 140,600 0.9342 0.0199

71-04-34-452-067.000-022 Penn 7122056 550 022 11/24/2014 $125,000 15,100 105,600 120,700 0.9656 0.0115

71-04-34-452-033.000-022 Penn 7122056 551 022 12/02/2014 $135,000 17,900 116,800 134,700 0.9978 0.0437

71-04-34-452-018.000-022 Penn 7122056 552 022 01/21/2015 $138,000 16,200 96,000 112,200 0.8130 0.1411

71-09-11-126-013.000-022 Penn 7122058 510 022 01/29/2014 $92,000 12,000 71,900 83,900 0.9120 0.0422

71-09-11-181-002.000-022 Penn 7122058 510 022 04/22/2014 $75,000 12,900 69,000 81,900 1.0920 0.1379

71-09-11-129-005.000-022 Penn 7122058 510 022 08/18/2014 $96,000 14,100 65,200 79,300 0.8260 0.1281

71-09-11-201-024.000-022 Penn 7122058 510 022 09/25/2014 $78,000 16,100 63,500 79,600 1.0205 0.0664

71-09-11-327-025.000-022 Penn 7122060 510 022 09/18/2014 $220,000 38,900 187,500 226,400 1.0291 0.0750

71-09-11-327-023.000-022 Penn 7122060 510 022 10/03/2014 $317,000 32,000 195,500 227,500 0.7177 0.2365

71-09-11-327-018.000-022 Penn 7122060 510 022 12/31/2014 $238,000 28,200 202,700 230,900 0.9702 0.0160

71-09-11-404-010.000-022 Penn 7122061 510 022 06/06/2014 $599,900 71,400 286,100 357,500 0.5959 0.3582

71-09-11-452-006.000-022 Penn 7122062 510 022 02/14/2014 $725,000 116,400 633,700 750,100 1.0346 0.0805

71-09-11-478-005.000-022 Penn 7122062 510 022 06/03/2014 $90,000 66,700 262,700 329,400 3.6600 2.7059

71-09-11-451-001.000-022 Penn 7122062 510 022 07/14/2014 $413,500 78,600 224,400 303,000 0.7328 0.2214

71-09-22-129-005.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 01/22/2014 $118,000 15,900 111,000 126,900 1.0754 0.1213

71-09-22-180-008.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 02/03/2014 $160,000 43,400 116,300 159,700 0.9981 0.0440

71-09-22-178-011.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 02/19/2014 $124,000 14,700 110,500 125,200 1.0097 0.0556

71-09-22-301-005.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 05/14/2014 $125,000 17,400 99,600 117,000 0.9360 0.0181

71-09-22-178-020.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 06/02/2014 $101,700 15,500 76,000 91,500 0.8997 0.0544

71-09-22-151-007.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 07/18/2014 $115,000 19,900 98,100 118,000 1.0261 0.0720

71-09-22-151-029.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 08/20/2014 $124,000 19,900 99,300 119,200 0.9613 0.0072

71-09-22-178-007.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 11/05/2014 $110,000 14,500 98,300 112,800 1.0255 0.0713

71-09-22-176-006.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 12/22/2014 $87,000 14,200 79,100 93,300 1.0724 0.1183

71-09-22-152-014.000-022 Penn 7122064 510 022 01/14/2015 $117,900 17,700 83,800 101,500 0.8609 0.0932

71-10-07-427-008.000-022 Penn 7122066 510 022 07/29/2014 $170,000 27,600 143,500 171,100 1.0065 0.0523

71-10-07-430-016.000-022 Penn 7122066 510 022 08/06/2014 $195,000 27,800 160,100 187,900 0.9636 0.0095

71-10-07-428-005.000-022 Penn 7122066 510 022 09/24/2014 $174,900 23,300 116,700 140,000 0.8005 0.1537

71-09-21-278-028.000-022 Penn 7122067 510 022 01/22/2014 $135,000 20,400 98,400 118,800 0.8800 0.0741

71-09-21-131-028.000-022 Penn 7122067 510 022 04/14/2014 $72,500 17,700 55,900 73,600 1.0152 0.0610

71-09-21-131-027.000-022 Penn 7122067 510 022 08/08/2014 $146,000 13,700 104,300 118,000 0.8082 0.1459

71-09-21-131-032.000-022 Penn 7122067 510 022 09/16/2014 $156,500 25,200 102,300 127,500 0.8147 0.1394

71-09-21-251-002.000-022 Penn 7122067 510 022 09/16/2014 $157,000 24,500 100,200 124,700 0.7943 0.1599

71-09-27-251-004.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 02/11/2014 $135,000 22,800 113,400 136,200 1.0089 0.0548

71-09-22-376-004.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 03/06/2014 $242,000 16,800 203,400 220,200 0.9099 0.0442

71-09-22-404-010.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 06/04/2014 $155,000 24,500 124,600 149,100 0.9619 0.0078

71-09-22-459-001.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 12/30/2014 $200,000 43,500 154,800 198,300 0.9915 0.0374

71-09-22-459-002.000-022 Penn 7122068 500 022 12/30/2014 $0 0 0

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-22-457-013.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 06/10/2014 $89,000 11,400 87,800 99,200 1.1146 0.1605

71-09-22-401-007.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 06/26/2014 $140,000 13,100 123,800 136,900 0.9779 0.0237

71-09-22-456-005.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 07/30/2014 $88,500 7,700 100,700 108,400 1.2249 0.2707

71-09-22-407-010.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 08/12/2014 $137,000 27,600 121,200 148,800 1.0861 0.1320

71-09-22-457-010.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 08/25/2014 $103,000 11,400 90,700 102,100 0.9913 0.0371

71-09-22-404-002.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 09/15/2014 $142,900 16,500 128,500 145,000 1.0147 0.0606

71-09-22-405-006.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 12/02/2014 $161,750 19,500 145,200 164,700 1.0182 0.0641

71-09-22-376-007.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 12/22/2014 $252,500 22,700 180,200 202,900 0.8036 0.1506

71-09-22-403-010.000-022 Penn 7122068 510 022 12/29/2014 $137,500 21,300 116,400 137,700 1.0015 0.0473

71-09-27-229-003.000-022 Penn 7122069 510 022 08/11/2014 $430,000 48,400 263,800 312,200 0.7260 0.2281

71-09-27-128-001.000-022 Penn 7122070 510 022 05/29/2014 $153,900 14,800 135,100 149,900 0.9740 0.0199

71-09-22-431-013.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 01/01/2014 $127,000 16,400 107,500 123,900 0.9756 0.0215

71-09-23-301-014.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 04/09/2014 $164,000 19,000 131,400 150,400 0.9171 0.0371

71-09-22-429-027.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 05/19/2014 $142,600 15,800 117,400 133,200 0.9341 0.0200

71-09-22-429-022.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 05/23/2014 $158,000 15,800 138,800 154,600 0.9785 0.0244

71-09-22-432-012.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 05/29/2014 $145,500 18,600 118,600 137,200 0.9430 0.0112

71-09-22-427-015.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 08/04/2014 $149,900 15,800 120,800 136,600 0.9113 0.0428

71-09-22-428-008.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 08/08/2014 $144,000 15,800 118,200 134,000 0.9306 0.0236

71-09-22-430-005.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 08/29/2014 $131,400 15,800 116,200 132,000 1.0046 0.0504

71-09-22-430-016.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 09/16/2014 $147,000 15,800 129,500 145,300 0.9884 0.0343

71-09-22-428-029.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 11/14/2014 $149,000 15,500 119,300 134,800 0.9047 0.0494

71-09-23-301-029.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 12/10/2014 $125,000 24,200 128,000 152,200 1.2176 0.2635

71-09-22-428-011.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 12/23/2014 $117,000 15,800 107,700 123,500 1.0556 0.1014

71-09-22-428-007.000-022 Penn 7122071 510 022 01/21/2015 $125,000 15,800 100,700 116,500 0.9320 0.0221

71-09-03-228-005.000-022 Penn 7122074 510 022 05/14/2014 $166,500 26,600 149,700 176,300 1.0589 0.1047

71-04-34-476-026.000-022 Penn 7122074 510 022 08/28/2014 $154,000 32,000 132,300 164,300 1.0669 0.1128

71-09-03-226-016.000-022 Penn 7122074 510 022 09/12/2014 $155,000 29,700 125,400 155,100 1.0006 0.0465

71-09-03-226-019.000-022 Penn 7122074 510 022 11/17/2014 $138,000 34,000 107,300 141,300 1.0239 0.0698

71-09-03-227-008.000-022 Penn 7122074 510 022 12/31/2014 $146,510 12,900 132,200 145,100 0.9904 0.0363

71-09-03-201-006.000-022 Penn 7122093 550 022 05/05/2014 $248,500 30,000 216,500 246,500 0.9920 0.0378

71-09-03-202-001.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 07/23/2014 $213,000 41,600 187,800 229,400 1.0770 0.1229

71-04-34-453-038.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 08/08/2014 $227,000 23,200 198,000 221,200 0.9744 0.0203

71-09-03-202-012.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 10/07/2014 $271,000 42,000 217,200 259,200 0.9565 0.0023

71-09-03-201-012.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 10/13/2014 $223,000 37,900 198,100 236,000 1.0583 0.1042

71-09-03-202-022.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 10/21/2014 $295,000 62,400 210,900 273,300 0.9264 0.0277

71-09-03-202-016.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 12/30/2014 $230,000 29,500 195,700 225,200 0.9791 0.0250

71-09-03-226-002.000-022 Penn 7122093 510 022 01/20/2015 $198,000 33,300 172,200 205,500 1.0379 0.0838

71-09-04-406-009.000-022 Penn 7122094 510 022 02/20/2014 $67,500 10,700 56,100 66,800 0.9896 0.0355

71-09-04-405-014.000-022 Penn 7122094 510 022 03/05/2014 $63,000 10,500 52,600 63,100 1.0016 0.0475

71-09-04-407-008.000-022 Penn 7122094 510 022 06/02/2014 $60,000 10,900 53,600 64,500 1.0750 0.1209

71-09-04-407-005.000-022 Penn 7122094 510 022 06/04/2014 $72,500 11,500 56,400 67,900 0.9366 0.0176

71-09-04-408-006.000-022 Penn 7122094 520 022 08/27/2014 $60,000 10,700 52,800 63,500 1.0583 0.1042

71-09-22-378-009.000-022 Penn 7122095 550 022 06/03/2014 $123,000 6,700 111,200 117,900 0.9585 0.0044

71-09-22-380-002.000-022 Penn 7122095 550 022 06/10/2014 $133,000 9,500 107,100 116,600 0.8767 0.0774

71-09-22-378-013.000-022 Penn 7122095 550 022 10/02/2014 $124,900 6,000 89,700 95,700 0.7662 0.1879

71-09-22-380-010.000-022 Penn 7122095 550 022 10/07/2014 $110,000 9,600 111,400 121,000 1.1000 0.1459

71-10-07-405-047.000-022 Penn 7122096 552 022 05/14/2014 $133,500 13,900 107,900 121,800 0.9124 0.0418

71-10-07-405-002.000-022 Penn 7122096 552 022 06/24/2014 $102,000 17,400 81,800 99,200 0.9725 0.0184

71-10-07-405-015.000-022 Penn 7122096 552 022 08/13/2014 $145,000 20,900 122,500 143,400 0.9890 0.0348

71-09-09-436-020.000-023 Penn 7123045 510 023 04/01/2014 $74,500 9,000 68,800 77,800 1.0443 0.0902

71-09-09-484-002.000-023 Penn 7123045 510 023 08/05/2014 $57,000 7,800 52,500 60,300 1.0579 0.1038

71-09-09-408-008.000-023 Penn 7123045 510 023 09/03/2014 $75,500 8,800 49,800 58,600 0.7762 0.1780

71-09-09-483-007.000-023 Penn 7123045 510 023 09/12/2014 $67,000 10,100 50,800 60,900 0.9090 0.0452

71-09-09-452-019.000-023 Penn 7123045 510 023 10/16/2014 $70,500 14,200 62,600 76,800 1.0894 0.1352

71-09-10-356-011.000-023 Penn 7123046 510 023 04/04/2014 $70,000 7,700 70,000 77,700 1.1100 0.1559

71-09-10-308-015.000-023 Penn 7123046 510 023 11/05/2014 $81,000 7,100 74,400 81,500 1.0062 0.0520

71-09-10-358-014.000-023 Penn 7123046 510 023 11/25/2014 $72,500 12,500 64,400 76,900 1.0607 0.1066

71-09-10-353-004.000-023 Penn 7123046 510 023 12/30/2014 $67,000 12,100 68,700 80,800 1.2060 0.2518

71-09-04-429-016.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 01/10/2014 $72,000 10,800 64,900 75,700 1.0514 0.0973

71-09-04-429-033.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 06/03/2014 $74,900 8,700 63,900 72,600 0.9693 0.0152

71-09-04-477-023.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 08/07/2014 $65,000 10,300 49,600 59,900 0.9215 0.0326

71-09-04-477-002.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 09/16/2014 $56,000 10,900 45,800 56,700 1.0125 0.0584

71-09-04-431-017.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 10/07/2014 $65,000 9,900 57,600 67,500 1.0385 0.0843

71-09-04-477-035.000-023 Penn 7123049 510 023 10/08/2014 $60,000 11,800 45,700 57,500 0.9583 0.0042

71-09-03-301-008.000-023 Penn 7123050 510 023 02/28/2014 $149,900 18,600 125,500 144,100 0.9613 0.0072

71-09-03-351-004.000-023 Penn 7123050 510 023 07/17/2014 $174,900 24,700 169,900 194,600 1.1126 0.1585

71-09-03-351-016.000-023 Penn 7123050 500 023 07/17/2014 $0 0 0

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-03-301-006.000-023 Penn 7123050 510 023 08/16/2014 $155,000 18,600 144,100 162,700 1.0497 0.0956

71-09-03-305-003.000-023 Penn 7123050 510 023 10/31/2014 $116,000 14,100 89,400 103,500 0.8922 0.0619

71-09-09-237-011.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 03/21/2014 $67,000 7,100 58,100 65,200 0.9731 0.0190

71-09-09-203-005.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 03/31/2014 $73,500 8,400 60,200 68,600 0.9333 0.0208

71-09-10-152-001.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 04/25/2014 $90,000 7,100 78,700 85,800 0.9533 0.0008

71-09-10-151-013.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 05/07/2014 $59,999 9,800 55,900 65,700 1.0950 0.1409

71-09-09-284-006.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 06/18/2014 $54,000 7,300 45,900 53,200 0.9852 0.0311

71-09-09-209-012.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 07/30/2014 $55,000 11,200 56,100 67,300 1.2236 0.2695

71-09-09-286-003.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 08/08/2014 $53,000 7,100 47,300 54,400 1.0264 0.0723

71-09-09-203-004.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 08/11/2014 $47,500 8,400 37,800 46,200 0.9726 0.0185

71-09-09-280-010.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 12/05/2014 $74,000 7,100 59,000 66,100 0.8932 0.0609

71-09-09-283-007.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 12/09/2014 $78,000 14,300 51,800 66,100 0.8474 0.1067

71-09-10-105-001.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 12/15/2014 $87,000 8,400 70,700 79,100 0.9092 0.0449

71-09-10-205-006.000-023 Penn 7123052 510 023 03/19/2014 $47,000 6,900 29,300 36,200 0.7702 0.1839

71-09-10-204-009.000-023 Penn 7123052 510 023 07/11/2014 $105,000 30,200 59,000 89,200 0.8495 0.1046

71-09-10-155-006.000-023 Penn 7123052 510 023 08/04/2014 $53,500 10,700 47,200 57,900 1.0822 0.1281

71-09-10-254-010.000-023 Penn 7123052 510 023 08/14/2014 $52,000 5,800 35,200 41,000 0.7885 0.1657

71-09-09-378-013.000-023 Penn 7123054 510 023 02/25/2014 $85,000 12,900 72,700 85,600 1.0071 0.0529

71-09-09-387-006.000-023 Penn 7123054 510 023 07/02/2014 $59,375 11,200 70,000 81,200 1.3676 0.4135

71-09-17-332-008.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 06/03/2014 $77,100 9,000 54,400 63,400 0.8223 0.1318

71-09-17-311-007.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 09/15/2014 $75,000 15,700 56,900 72,600 0.9680 0.0139

71-09-17-356-028.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 09/25/2014 $64,000 8,100 52,000 60,100 0.9391 0.0151

71-09-17-179-009.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 12/30/2014 $78,000 15,300 60,000 75,300 0.9654 0.0113

71-09-17-335-022.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 12/31/2014 $68,500 7,700 55,800 63,500 0.9270 0.0271

71-09-17-336-018.000-023 Penn 7123055 510 023 02/13/2015 $68,900 7,700 52,900 60,600 0.8795 0.0746

71-09-10-484-002.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 03/31/2014 $87,000 14,600 69,500 84,100 0.9667 0.0125

71-09-10-453-003.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 04/11/2014 $80,000 10,400 73,300 83,700 1.0463 0.0921

71-09-10-452-014.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 06/13/2014 $80,000 13,000 57,000 70,000 0.8750 0.0791

71-09-10-452-012.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 06/25/2014 $115,000 10,400 87,800 98,200 0.8539 0.1002

71-09-10-401-016.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 03/10/2014 $69,900 27,900 48,300 76,200 1.0901 0.1360

71-09-10-401-017.000-023 Penn 7123056 500 023 03/10/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-10-401-018.000-023 Penn 7123056 500 023 03/10/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-10-481-015.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 08/04/2014 $85,000 10,200 71,200 81,400 0.9576 0.0035

71-09-10-483-003.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 08/22/2014 $115,000 10,100 93,200 103,300 0.8983 0.0559

71-09-10-452-001.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 10/31/2014 $140,000 27,300 107,800 135,100 0.9650 0.0109

71-09-16-129-006.000-023 Penn 7123057 551 023 03/21/2014 $330,000 48,000 274,300 322,300 0.9767 0.0225

71-09-11-354-015.000-023 Penn 7123057 550 023 05/21/2014 $150,000 16,000 115,500 131,500 0.8767 0.0775

71-09-11-354-011.000-023 Penn 7123057 550 023 12/29/2014 $144,000 16,000 140,400 156,400 1.0861 0.1320

71-09-16-105-022.000-023 Penn 7123059 510 023 06/19/2014 $83,000 11,000 67,000 78,000 0.9398 0.0144

71-09-16-105-004.000-023 Penn 7123059 510 023 07/25/2014 $80,500 11,000 65,800 76,800 0.9540 0.0001

71-09-16-101-023.000-023 Penn 7123059 510 023 08/26/2014 $91,000 11,000 75,700 86,700 0.9527 0.0014

71-09-16-106-001.000-023 Penn 7123059 510 023 12/18/2014 $144,000 11,000 125,900 136,900 0.9507 0.0034

71-09-16-105-024.000-023 Penn 7123059 510 023 02/27/2015 $103,900 11,000 76,100 87,100 0.8383 0.1158

71-09-15-329-032.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 01/13/2014 $105,000 13,000 92,600 105,600 1.0057 0.0516

71-09-15-236-001.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 01/15/2014 $81,000 7,800 72,100 79,900 0.9864 0.0323

71-09-15-331-023.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 03/12/2014 $110,000 12,300 95,300 107,600 0.9782 0.0241

71-09-15-331-001.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 04/01/2014 $72,900 9,800 54,400 64,200 0.8807 0.0735

71-09-15-235-009.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 04/22/2014 $85,000 7,100 74,100 81,200 0.9553 0.0012

71-09-15-207-005.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 04/30/2014 $81,300 12,200 71,000 83,200 1.0234 0.0692

71-09-15-230-006.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 05/23/2014 $65,000 7,400 54,900 62,300 0.9585 0.0043

71-09-15-276-008.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 05/28/2014 $104,000 9,600 88,900 98,500 0.9471 0.0070

71-09-15-227-004.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 06/05/2014 $85,500 7,300 70,600 77,900 0.9111 0.0430

71-09-15-231-016.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 06/12/2014 $92,900 7,300 73,400 80,700 0.8687 0.0854

71-09-15-202-003.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 06/18/2014 $109,000 8,600 94,300 102,900 0.9440 0.0101

71-09-15-377-015.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 08/05/2014 $95,000 15,400 71,800 87,200 0.9179 0.0362

71-09-15-229-005.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 08/05/2014 $76,000 7,400 62,600 70,000 0.9211 0.0331

71-09-15-253-036.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 08/18/2014 $72,900 10,800 60,300 71,100 0.9753 0.0212

71-09-15-206-003.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 09/03/2014 $130,000 8,100 118,100 126,200 0.9708 0.0166

71-09-15-253-019.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 09/04/2014 $26,000 7,900 21,800 29,700 1.1423 0.1882

71-09-15-251-015.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 09/15/2014 $125,000 13,000 101,800 114,800 0.9184 0.0357

71-09-15-254-009.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 09/24/2014 $95,900 11,600 65,300 76,900 0.8019 0.1522

71-09-15-201-010.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 10/10/2014 $201,000 8,000 162,000 170,000 0.8458 0.1084

71-09-15-377-007.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 11/18/2014 $79,000 15,400 52,600 68,000 0.8608 0.0934

71-09-15-179-001.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 12/19/2014 $82,200 10,000 69,300 79,300 0.9647 0.0106

71-09-15-331-032.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 12/29/2014 $63,000 11,000 54,300 65,300 1.0365 0.0824

71-09-15-236-011.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 12/31/2014 $78,500 7,800 73,900 81,700 1.0408 0.0866

71-09-15-115-009.000-023 Penn 7123062 510 023 03/21/2014 $134,000 18,400 109,300 127,700 0.9530 0.0011

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-10-07-305-007.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 01/15/2014 $119,000 17,100 77,600 94,700 0.7958 0.1583

71-09-13-205-005.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 03/19/2014 $78,000 12,300 67,900 80,200 1.0282 0.0741

71-10-07-302-013.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 05/28/2014 $187,500 19,900 139,100 159,000 0.8480 0.1061

71-10-07-355-015.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 08/12/2014 $75,000 33,300 38,400 71,700 0.9560 0.0019

71-10-07-378-015.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 08/20/2014 $111,000 14,700 88,600 103,300 0.9306 0.0235

71-09-12-451-010.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 08/29/2014 $269,900 41,700 176,900 218,600 0.8099 0.1442

71-09-13-127-004.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 10/01/2014 $65,000 23,800 36,300 60,100 0.9246 0.0295

71-09-13-206-015.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 10/15/2014 $88,000 12,400 68,600 81,000 0.9205 0.0337

71-10-07-352-035.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 10/22/2014 $104,000 15,100 69,100 84,200 0.8096 0.1445

71-09-13-251-009.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 02/26/2014 $91,000 15,900 79,200 95,100 1.0451 0.0909

71-10-18-128-010.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 04/30/2014 $98,000 10,600 90,000 100,600 1.0265 0.0724

71-09-13-253-023.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 05/08/2014 $79,735 10,400 64,500 74,900 0.9394 0.0148

71-09-13-228-008.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 05/13/2014 $99,000 11,000 83,100 94,100 0.9505 0.0036

71-10-18-129-028.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 05/29/2014 $77,000 9,400 70,600 80,000 1.0390 0.0848

71-09-13-178-010.000-023 Penn 7123065 550 023 07/29/2014 $84,000 8,600 73,600 82,200 0.9786 0.0244

71-10-18-130-002.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 10/02/2014 $153,500 14,700 143,600 158,300 1.0313 0.0771

71-10-18-153-001.000-023 Penn 7123065 510 023 12/31/2014 $116,500 12,800 92,200 105,000 0.9013 0.0528

71-09-16-330-010.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 03/05/2014 $65,000 10,400 40,900 51,300 0.7892 0.1649

71-09-16-384-011.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 04/02/2014 $95,000 11,200 83,400 94,600 0.9958 0.0417

71-09-16-335-008.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 04/09/2014 $81,500 7,300 55,500 62,800 0.7706 0.1836

71-09-16-476-006.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 04/22/2014 $85,000 9,200 58,900 68,100 0.8012 0.1529

71-09-16-386-013.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 04/29/2014 $80,000 11,000 82,700 93,700 1.1713 0.2171

71-09-16-383-003.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 05/14/2014 $82,000 11,900 76,600 88,500 1.0793 0.1251

71-09-16-383-009.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/11/2014 $95,000 15,600 79,800 95,400 1.0042 0.0501

71-09-16-383-010.000-023 Penn 7123066 500 023 06/11/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-16-459-013.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/04/2014 $86,000 7,300 80,800 88,100 1.0244 0.0703

71-09-16-387-012.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/12/2014 $116,630 11,000 104,800 115,800 0.9929 0.0388

71-09-16-327-001.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/13/2014 $68,900 8,000 68,700 76,700 1.1132 0.1591

71-09-16-436-002.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/18/2014 $55,000 7,600 56,200 63,800 1.1600 0.2059

71-09-16-488-008.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 06/27/2014 $52,000 6,200 46,700 52,900 1.0173 0.0632

71-09-16-480-019.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 07/01/2014 $72,000 8,100 71,100 79,200 1.1000 0.1459

71-09-16-482-003.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 07/17/2014 $96,000 9,200 97,700 106,900 1.1135 0.1594

71-09-16-379-004.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 07/29/2014 $100,000 15,000 89,700 104,700 1.0470 0.0929

71-09-16-159-008.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 08/20/2014 $86,500 9,800 86,500 96,300 1.1133 0.1592

71-09-16-153-033.000-023 Penn 7123066 550 023 09/02/2014 $76,000 8,000 65,900 73,900 0.9724 0.0182

71-09-16-452-011.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 09/12/2014 $83,900 7,300 64,900 72,200 0.8605 0.0936

71-09-16-460-007.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 09/30/2014 $72,500 7,300 64,900 72,200 0.9959 0.0417

71-09-16-159-007.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 01/12/2015 $66,500 8,600 55,500 64,100 0.9639 0.0098

71-09-16-311-011.000-023 Penn 7123066 510 023 02/02/2015 $63,900 7,300 58,400 65,700 1.0282 0.0740

71-09-16-158-013.000-023 Penn 7123066 520 023 02/04/2015 $47,000 9,800 45,000 54,800 1.1660 0.2118

71-10-07-331-013.000-023 Penn 7123067 510 023 07/29/2014 $279,000 56,000 188,800 244,800 0.8774 0.0767

71-09-14-430-013.000-023 Penn 7123070 510 023 02/11/2014 $123,000 17,000 91,700 108,700 0.8837 0.0704

71-09-14-435-009.000-023 Penn 7123070 510 023 05/01/2014 $80,000 17,700 59,100 76,800 0.9600 0.0059

71-09-14-283-010.000-023 Penn 7123070 510 023 07/11/2014 $77,900 7,300 73,100 80,400 1.0321 0.0780

71-10-07-379-012.000-023 Penn 7123070 510 023 10/28/2014 $70,000 2,900 52,600 55,500 0.7929 0.1613

71-09-14-254-014.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 05/19/2014 $80,000 7,800 75,600 83,400 1.0425 0.0884

71-09-14-127-014.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 06/06/2014 $47,000 7,600 40,400 48,000 1.0213 0.0672

71-09-14-280-018.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 06/11/2014 $58,500 9,300 47,400 56,700 0.9692 0.0151

71-09-14-209-006.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 06/18/2014 $92,000 15,500 64,000 79,500 0.8641 0.0900

71-09-14-152-027.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 07/01/2014 $77,000 9,600 71,100 80,700 1.0481 0.0939

71-09-14-127-006.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $96,000 13,300 96,200 109,500 1.1406 0.1865

71-09-14-127-007.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-14-208-005.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 07/11/2014 $83,000 8,600 62,300 70,900 0.8542 0.0999

71-09-14-252-006.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 07/15/2014 $67,500 8,600 47,900 56,500 0.8370 0.1171

71-09-14-205-002.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 08/06/2014 $80,000 7,300 61,400 68,700 0.8588 0.0954

71-09-14-127-005.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 08/07/2014 $89,000 8,000 70,700 78,700 0.8843 0.0699

71-09-14-108-008.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 08/15/2014 $107,000 10,000 86,600 96,600 0.9028 0.0513

71-09-10-454-004.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 10/08/2014 $72,000 7,900 65,100 73,000 1.0139 0.0598

71-09-14-105-015.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 12/05/2014 $84,500 7,400 73,300 80,700 0.9550 0.0009

71-09-14-203-001.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $123,000 10,100 103,200 113,300 0.9211 0.0330

71-09-14-232-001.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 02/05/2015 $102,000 10,300 97,100 107,400 1.0529 0.0988

71-09-14-231-008.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 02/11/2015 $120,000 14,300 87,200 101,500 0.8458 0.1083

71-09-14-105-005.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 02/16/2015 $128,700 9,400 107,200 116,600 0.9060 0.0481

71-09-21-131-014.000-023 Penn 7123072 510 023 06/11/2014 $109,000 16,100 90,800 106,900 0.9807 0.0266

71-09-21-278-041.000-023 Penn 7123072 510 023 07/07/2014 $66,000 16,700 49,800 66,500 1.0076 0.0535

71-09-21-229-013.000-023 Penn 7123072 510 023 09/03/2014 $117,000 12,500 87,300 99,800 0.8530 0.1011

71-09-21-128-001.000-023 Penn 7123072 510 023 02/18/2015 $86,700 13,400 55,300 68,700 0.7924 0.1617

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-24-156-011.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 02/04/2014 $102,000 19,900 76,600 96,500 0.9461 0.0080

71-09-24-102-002.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 04/02/2014 $97,000 12,900 75,400 88,300 0.9103 0.0438

71-09-24-130-004.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 04/04/2014 $109,900 15,400 81,500 96,900 0.8817 0.0724

71-09-24-177-016.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 05/01/2014 $103,000 13,700 85,000 98,700 0.9583 0.0041

71-09-24-131-004.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 05/21/2014 $109,250 12,800 96,500 109,300 1.0005 0.0463

71-09-24-131-014.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 05/22/2014 $101,000 16,900 89,600 106,500 1.0545 0.1003

71-09-24-154-008.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 07/07/2014 $109,000 18,900 97,000 115,900 1.0633 0.1092

71-09-24-180-015.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 08/05/2014 $111,500 19,400 98,700 118,100 1.0592 0.1051

71-09-24-182-003.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 08/06/2014 $165,000 17,800 133,300 151,100 0.9158 0.0384

71-09-24-179-023.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 09/04/2014 $114,900 15,800 93,400 109,200 0.9504 0.0037

71-09-24-151-010.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 12/12/2014 $96,500 18,400 76,400 94,800 0.9824 0.0283

71-09-24-179-028.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 12/29/2014 $120,000 16,600 90,700 107,300 0.8942 0.0600

71-09-24-179-009.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 12/31/2014 $103,200 16,500 92,700 109,200 1.0581 0.1040

71-10-19-127-008.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 03/26/2014 $155,000 18,000 118,600 136,600 0.8813 0.0728

71-10-19-151-008.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 04/09/2014 $223,000 21,000 218,600 239,600 1.0744 0.1203

71-09-24-232-002.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 04/21/2014 $199,900 21,100 138,100 159,200 0.7964 0.1577

71-09-24-231-004.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 04/30/2014 $185,000 22,400 144,100 166,500 0.9000 0.0541

71-09-24-226-005.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 05/09/2014 $140,000 13,700 125,700 139,400 0.9957 0.0416

71-10-19-152-002.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 05/27/2014 $148,000 22,400 130,500 152,900 1.0331 0.0790

71-10-19-105-013.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/04/2014 $209,500 21,300 172,200 193,500 0.9236 0.0305

71-09-24-231-014.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/06/2014 $243,000 15,700 200,500 216,200 0.8897 0.0644

71-09-24-231-015.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/06/2014 $155,000 21,900 115,700 137,600 0.8877 0.0664

71-10-19-129-006.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/11/2014 $209,000 19,600 152,500 172,100 0.8234 0.1307

71-09-24-226-006.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/12/2014 $141,500 13,900 126,500 140,400 0.9922 0.0381

71-09-24-227-001.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 06/26/2014 $129,900 14,500 108,200 122,700 0.9446 0.0096

71-09-24-227-021.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/01/2014 $125,000 15,300 99,800 115,100 0.9208 0.0333

71-10-19-128-001.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/15/2014 $211,500 20,800 148,800 169,600 0.8019 0.1522

71-10-19-102-005.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/17/2014 $241,000 25,700 177,800 203,500 0.8444 0.1097

71-09-13-453-011.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/18/2014 $173,000 20,200 152,200 172,400 0.9965 0.0424

71-09-13-453-002.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/29/2014 $195,500 21,700 145,900 167,600 0.8573 0.0968

71-10-19-152-010.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 07/30/2014 $180,000 25,800 149,000 174,800 0.9711 0.0170

71-09-24-228-016.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 08/25/2014 $154,900 19,100 126,700 145,800 0.9413 0.0129

71-09-24-227-002.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 10/07/2014 $139,900 13,400 127,200 140,600 1.0050 0.0509

71-10-19-128-003.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 10/29/2014 $182,000 18,500 141,300 159,800 0.8780 0.0761

71-09-24-228-008.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 12/23/2014 $215,000 22,600 183,800 206,400 0.9600 0.0059

71-10-19-152-020.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 02/11/2015 $225,000 26,000 178,600 204,600 0.9093 0.0448

71-09-16-356-126.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 05/30/2014 $67,500 13,500 56,500 70,000 1.0370 0.0829

71-09-16-356-050.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 07/23/2014 $61,000 13,500 55,100 68,600 1.1246 0.1705

71-09-16-356-069.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 08/15/2014 $72,000 8,900 50,200 59,100 0.8208 0.1333

71-09-16-356-033.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 09/08/2014 $51,000 8,400 41,000 49,400 0.9686 0.0145

71-09-16-356-136.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 09/24/2014 $74,950 13,100 60,400 73,500 0.9807 0.0265

71-09-16-356-032.000-023 Penn 7123086 550 023 11/06/2014 $55,000 10,000 43,700 53,700 0.9764 0.0222

71-09-10-427-017.000-023 Penn 7123087 510 023 05/22/2014 $250,000 62,900 168,000 230,900 0.9236 0.0305

71-09-10-112-001.000-023 Penn 7123088 510 023 09/04/2014 $105,000 14,600 65,700 80,300 0.7648 0.1894

71-09-10-113-025.000-023 Penn 7123088 510 023 09/12/2014 $128,000 10,600 90,900 101,500 0.7930 0.1612

71-09-10-109-003.000-023 Penn 7123088 510 023 10/15/2014 $114,000 15,100 75,300 90,400 0.7930 0.1611

71-09-10-109-002.000-023 Penn 7123088 510 023 12/23/2014 $122,000 14,400 88,500 102,900 0.8434 0.1107

71-09-09-310-002.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 01/10/2014 $74,000 7,400 66,200 73,600 0.9946 0.0405

71-09-09-382-001.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 04/01/2014 $96,500 8,400 67,900 76,300 0.7907 0.1635

71-09-09-354-008.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 05/28/2014 $77,750 9,000 72,400 81,400 1.0469 0.0928

71-09-09-359-014.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 08/18/2014 $75,000 8,400 73,600 82,000 1.0933 0.1392

71-09-09-361-001.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 09/16/2014 $91,500 8,400 75,600 84,000 0.9180 0.0361

71-09-09-313-007.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 11/25/2014 $71,500 9,000 50,700 59,700 0.8350 0.1192

71-09-09-365-006.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 12/03/2014 $80,500 16,900 66,800 83,700 1.0398 0.0856

71-09-09-311-005.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 12/22/2014 $68,000 7,400 48,600 56,000 0.8235 0.1306

71-09-09-354-013.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 12/30/2014 $71,000 9,000 53,600 62,600 0.8817 0.0724

71-10-08-476-007.000-030 Penn 7130009 510 030 04/07/2014 $108,900 15,100 91,600 106,700 0.9798 0.0257

71-10-09-302-008.000-030 Penn 7130009 599 030 06/02/2014 $13,300 9,000 6,700 15,700 1.1805 0.2263

71-10-08-428-006.000-030 Penn 7130009 510 030 06/06/2014 $112,000 15,100 116,000 131,100 1.1705 0.2164

71-10-08-429-019.000-030 Penn 7130009 510 030 09/09/2014 $110,000 18,000 81,900 99,900 0.9082 0.0459

71-10-08-426-003.000-030 Penn 7130009 510 030 10/16/2014 $90,000 36,000 53,100 89,100 0.9900 0.0359

71-10-08-402-009.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 03/07/2014 $156,900 14,500 137,500 152,000 0.9688 0.0146

71-10-08-456-005.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 05/19/2014 $152,000 14,300 131,100 145,400 0.9566 0.0025

71-10-16-256-006.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 06/03/2014 $77,000 10,200 51,300 61,500 0.7987 0.1554

71-10-16-133-017.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 08/08/2014 $69,000 8,300 61,700 70,000 1.0145 0.0604

71-10-09-351-011.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 08/22/2014 $167,000 22,100 133,500 155,600 0.9317 0.0224

71-10-08-451-045.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 08/26/2014 $167,000 10,000 121,900 131,900 0.7898 0.1643

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-10-16-153-032.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 08/29/2014 $95,000 15,100 64,900 80,000 0.8421 0.1120

71-10-16-257-001.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 09/04/2014 $64,900 8,100 51,700 59,800 0.9214 0.0327

71-10-16-128-003.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 09/04/2014 $126,000 11,400 99,600 111,000 0.8810 0.0732

71-10-16-132-001.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 09/11/2014 $103,284 15,900 86,000 101,900 0.9866 0.0325

71-10-08-376-064.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 09/23/2014 $211,500 30,000 184,200 214,200 1.0128 0.0586

71-10-08-403-007.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 10/06/2014 $165,000 14,500 137,400 151,900 0.9206 0.0335

71-10-16-153-016.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 10/21/2014 $70,000 11,800 56,500 68,300 0.9757 0.0216

71-10-09-351-025.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 12/19/2014 $120,000 15,900 83,000 98,900 0.8242 0.1300

71-10-08-452-006.000-030 Penn 7130010 510 030 01/26/2015 $175,000 14,500 144,600 159,100 0.9091 0.0450

71-14-01-301-001.000-031 Penn 7131002 510 031 06/06/2014 $145,000 21,100 124,300 145,400 1.0028 0.0486

71-05-33-301-007.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 02/27/2014 $225,000 27,800 165,800 193,600 0.8604 0.0937

71-04-34-181-005.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 03/05/2014 $165,000 23,700 125,300 149,000 0.9030 0.0511

71-10-07-227-012.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 03/07/2014 $144,000 23,100 116,000 139,100 0.9660 0.0118

71-04-34-408-009.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 03/18/2014 $174,000 21,500 135,000 156,500 0.8994 0.0547

71-10-07-228-008.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 05/07/2014 $130,000 24,000 106,600 130,600 1.0046 0.0505

71-04-34-408-011.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 05/29/2014 $154,000 23,100 121,100 144,200 0.9364 0.0178

71-10-07-227-014.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 06/12/2014 $146,500 22,400 114,500 136,900 0.9345 0.0197

71-04-34-253-001.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 06/18/2014 $199,000 33,300 145,100 178,400 0.8965 0.0576

71-04-34-327-016.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 06/26/2014 $185,000 22,000 144,300 166,300 0.8989 0.0552

71-04-34-178-007.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 07/01/2014 $194,000 31,000 117,900 148,900 0.7675 0.1866

71-04-34-329-012.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 07/03/2014 $201,000 22,400 130,000 152,400 0.7582 0.1959

71-04-34-406-002.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 07/09/2014 $197,000 20,800 147,200 168,000 0.8528 0.1013

71-04-34-407-005.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 07/23/2014 $224,900 24,400 157,300 181,700 0.8079 0.1462

71-04-34-181-022.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 09/08/2014 $158,000 23,300 126,200 149,500 0.9462 0.0079

71-04-34-329-006.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 09/18/2014 $212,500 12,400 186,700 199,100 0.9369 0.0172

71-04-34-180-001.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 09/24/2014 $195,000 35,300 165,500 200,800 1.0297 0.0756

71-04-34-259-012.000-031 Penn 7131025 510 031 01/23/2015 $146,000 20,900 130,700 151,600 1.0384 0.0842

71-04-35-426-001.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 03/17/2014 $156,500 23,200 155,200 178,400 1.1399 0.1858

71-04-35-403-002.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 05/08/2014 $166,350 21,900 174,400 196,300 1.1800 0.2259

71-04-35-201-014.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 06/05/2014 $165,000 23,400 155,400 178,800 1.0836 0.1295

71-04-35-401-002.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 06/19/2014 $209,000 29,300 163,800 193,100 0.9239 0.0302

71-04-35-251-003.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 07/24/2014 $152,000 26,700 154,900 181,600 1.1947 0.2406

71-04-35-404-006.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 08/22/2014 $215,000 22,200 173,600 195,800 0.9107 0.0434

71-04-35-404-017.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 08/26/2014 $215,000 26,500 185,800 212,300 0.9874 0.0333

71-04-35-202-026.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 09/03/2014 $161,500 21,100 156,400 177,500 1.0991 0.1449

71-04-35-404-016.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 10/09/2014 $208,000 25,400 172,300 197,700 0.9505 0.0036

71-04-35-202-011.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 12/03/2014 $164,000 22,700 141,600 164,300 1.0018 0.0477

71-04-35-201-012.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 12/22/2014 $165,000 23,300 133,700 157,000 0.9515 0.0026

71-09-01-104-006.000-031 Penn 7131027 510 031 10/03/2014 $90,000 41,100 81,400 122,500 1.3611 0.4070

71-10-05-229-007.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 03/06/2014 $185,750 20,800 129,000 149,800 0.8065 0.1477

71-05-32-401-029.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 06/11/2014 $212,000 28,700 177,300 206,000 0.9717 0.0176

71-05-32-476-006.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 07/18/2014 $129,900 36,200 106,300 142,500 1.0970 0.1429

71-05-32-401-043.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 07/24/2014 $193,500 28,600 161,900 190,500 0.9845 0.0304

71-10-05-229-004.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 08/20/2014 $154,000 23,300 100,200 123,500 0.8019 0.1522

71-10-05-202-012.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 08/26/2014 $144,000 18,800 137,700 156,500 1.0868 0.1327

71-10-05-205-004.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 09/18/2014 $160,000 30,000 122,400 152,400 0.9525 0.0016

71-05-32-401-049.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 11/05/2014 $200,000 28,900 140,100 169,000 0.8450 0.1091

71-05-32-476-019.000-031 Penn 7131030 510 031 12/03/2014 $145,000 26,900 130,200 157,100 1.0834 0.1293

71-05-33-180-003.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 02/25/2014 $138,600 18,400 100,500 118,900 0.8579 0.0963

71-05-33-126-007.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 03/19/2014 $159,900 30,100 102,400 132,500 0.8286 0.1255

71-05-33-178-004.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 03/20/2014 $188,500 19,000 145,300 164,300 0.8716 0.0825

71-05-33-301-026.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 03/24/2014 $280,000 21,300 261,600 282,900 1.0104 0.0562

71-05-33-180-006.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 06/04/2014 $164,000 18,800 128,600 147,400 0.8988 0.0553

71-05-33-178-002.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 06/18/2014 $192,000 19,000 154,400 173,400 0.9031 0.0510

71-05-33-178-001.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $188,000 18,100 173,200 191,300 1.0176 0.0634

71-05-33-252-009.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $158,000 27,900 114,500 142,400 0.9013 0.0529

71-05-33-328-010.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $264,900 40,600 174,800 215,400 0.8131 0.1410

71-05-33-176-014.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 08/07/2014 $200,000 18,400 179,100 197,500 0.9875 0.0334

71-05-33-176-015.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 09/04/2014 $157,200 22,200 131,200 153,400 0.9758 0.0217

71-05-33-176-005.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 11/06/2014 $175,000 18,800 174,200 193,000 1.1029 0.1487

71-05-33-104-006.000-031 Penn 7131033 510 031 12/01/2014 $155,000 21,900 97,400 119,300 0.7697 0.1844

71-05-33-451-004.000-031 Penn 7131035 510 031 05/29/2014 $135,000 14,500 95,800 110,300 0.8170 0.1371

71-05-31-351-002.000-031 Penn 7131037 510 031 01/01/2014 $118,000 20,800 62,000 82,800 0.7017 0.2524

71-09-34-400-009.000-031 Penn 7131037 510 031 09/29/2014 $157,500 33,900 109,300 143,200 0.9092 0.0449

71-14-03-200-021.000-031 Penn 7131037 510 031 02/19/2015 $300,000 35,200 212,600 247,800 0.8260 0.1281

71-09-26-452-004.000-031 Penn 7131038 510 031 03/27/2014 $195,000 23,400 142,700 166,100 0.8518 0.1023

71-14-04-400-006.000-031 Penn 7131038 510 031 10/06/2014 $235,000 25,000 128,500 153,500 0.6532 0.3009

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-03-251-004.000-031 Penn 7131038 510 031 11/25/2014 $81,500 9,100 58,400 67,500 0.8282 0.1259

71-05-32-301-004.000-031 Penn 7131038 510 031 02/20/2015 $115,000 22,100 98,900 121,000 1.0522 0.0981

71-10-04-127-012.000-031 Penn 7131040 510 031 06/23/2014 $97,000 16,600 63,600 80,200 0.8268 0.1273

71-10-04-127-011.000-031 Penn 7131040 500 031 06/23/2014 $0 0 0

71-10-06-403-007.000-031 Penn 7131042 510 031 07/21/2014 $142,000 19,700 76,800 96,500 0.6796 0.2745

71-10-05-105-013.000-031 Penn 7131043 510 031 02/12/2014 $73,500 17,500 93,300 110,800 1.5075 0.5534

71-10-05-101-003.000-031 Penn 7131043 510 031 07/30/2014 $128,000 21,200 72,600 93,800 0.7328 0.2213

71-10-05-177-008.000-031 Penn 7131043 510 031 08/04/2014 $225,000 21,200 153,900 175,100 0.7782 0.1759

71-10-05-102-008.000-031 Penn 7131043 510 031 10/13/2014 $155,000 27,200 141,600 168,800 1.0890 0.1349

71-10-05-252-005.000-031 Penn 7131044 510 031 06/04/2014 $142,000 15,700 116,900 132,600 0.9338 0.0203

71-10-07-228-013.000-031 Penn 7131044 510 031 08/05/2014 $105,000 15,900 82,500 98,400 0.9371 0.0170

71-10-07-226-007.000-031 Penn 7131044 510 031 08/29/2014 $155,000 16,800 107,400 124,200 0.8013 0.1528

71-10-07-226-006.000-031 Penn 7131044 510 031 09/02/2014 $130,000 16,800 91,800 108,600 0.8354 0.1187

71-10-05-257-007.000-031 Penn 7131044 510 031 11/17/2014 $75,500 15,700 65,400 81,100 1.0742 0.1200

71-09-12-207-004.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 05/22/2014 $78,100 11,900 58,300 70,200 0.8988 0.0553

71-09-12-256-002.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 05/29/2014 $136,900 35,600 92,200 127,800 0.9335 0.0206

71-09-11-276-009.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 08/04/2014 $69,000 11,900 63,200 75,100 1.0884 0.1343

71-09-12-207-007.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 08/06/2014 $137,000 23,800 94,000 117,800 0.8599 0.0943

71-09-11-281-004.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 06/19/2014 $103,100 23,800 60,400 84,200 0.8167 0.1374

71-09-11-281-003.000-031 Penn 7131045 599 031 06/19/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-12-207-013.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 09/23/2014 $64,900 21,400 48,000 69,400 1.0693 0.1152

71-09-12-177-016.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 02/03/2015 $85,000 35,100 37,200 72,300 0.8506 0.1035

71-09-12-206-020.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 02/16/2015 $124,000 23,800 76,200 100,000 0.8065 0.1477

71-09-12-207-008.000-031 Penn 7131045 510 031 02/27/2015 $125,000 23,800 97,000 120,800 0.9664 0.0123

71-09-25-400-008.000-031 Penn 7131046 510 031 04/24/2014 $308,000 40,000 190,600 230,600 0.7487 0.2054

71-09-26-301-008.000-031 Penn 7131046 510 031 06/27/2014 $154,900 21,600 87,600 109,200 0.7050 0.2492

71-09-12-127-009.000-031 Penn 7131047 510 031 05/23/2014 $160,000 20,000 137,700 157,700 0.9856 0.0315

71-10-06-353-012.000-031 Penn 7131048 510 031 02/10/2015 $94,500 32,700 89,900 122,600 1.2974 0.3432

71-10-06-426-002.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 02/19/2014 $125,750 17,100 104,400 121,500 0.9662 0.0121

71-10-05-402-011.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 02/19/2014 $155,000 20,200 127,500 147,700 0.9529 0.0012

71-10-05-351-002.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 03/17/2014 $100,000 40,100 72,800 112,900 1.1290 0.1749

71-10-05-402-007.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 05/13/2014 $148,900 16,500 114,800 131,300 0.8818 0.0723

71-10-06-427-010.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 05/29/2014 $216,000 21,600 164,600 186,200 0.8620 0.0921

71-10-05-377-002.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 05/29/2014 $146,500 20,000 119,900 139,900 0.9549 0.0008

71-10-05-452-011.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 06/06/2014 $165,000 22,200 134,300 156,500 0.9485 0.0056

71-10-05-404-004.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 06/10/2014 $147,000 23,500 123,100 146,600 0.9973 0.0432

71-10-05-404-008.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 06/17/2014 $139,900 14,200 126,800 141,000 1.0079 0.0537

71-10-05-354-016.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 07/29/2014 $127,000 22,700 97,300 120,000 0.9449 0.0092

71-10-08-128-004.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 08/06/2014 $189,000 21,600 150,900 172,500 0.9127 0.0414

71-10-05-402-012.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 10/06/2014 $168,900 21,600 117,000 138,600 0.8206 0.1335

71-10-05-452-004.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 10/09/2014 $208,000 22,000 144,000 166,000 0.7981 0.1560

71-10-08-127-010.000-031 Penn 7131050 510 031 12/03/2014 $179,000 19,500 150,000 169,500 0.9469 0.0072

71-10-05-278-009.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 01/15/2014 $162,500 16,800 143,000 159,800 0.9834 0.0293

71-10-04-352-040.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 01/21/2014 $160,000 16,600 141,000 157,600 0.9850 0.0309

71-10-04-353-016.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 04/15/2014 $168,000 16,600 138,600 155,200 0.9238 0.0303

71-10-04-352-032.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 05/28/2014 $168,000 16,600 124,700 141,300 0.8411 0.1131

71-10-05-432-005.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 05/30/2014 $158,000 17,900 128,700 146,600 0.9278 0.0263

71-10-04-355-022.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 06/03/2014 $187,000 17,100 148,500 165,600 0.8856 0.0686

71-10-04-355-014.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 06/17/2014 $156,400 17,100 131,300 148,400 0.9488 0.0053

71-10-05-277-015.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 07/07/2014 $149,900 15,900 115,900 131,800 0.8793 0.0749

71-10-04-355-071.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 07/29/2014 $173,000 16,700 128,700 145,400 0.8405 0.1137

71-10-04-355-021.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 07/29/2014 $220,000 17,100 234,700 251,800 1.1445 0.1904

71-10-04-355-048.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 08/21/2014 $175,000 19,400 132,300 151,700 0.8669 0.0873

71-10-04-352-036.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 09/04/2014 $190,500 16,600 150,300 166,900 0.8761 0.0780

71-10-04-352-034.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 10/13/2014 $166,000 16,600 125,500 142,100 0.8560 0.0981

71-10-04-355-077.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 10/17/2014 $185,000 16,600 154,400 171,000 0.9243 0.0298

71-10-04-355-018.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 12/03/2014 $219,000 17,100 182,100 199,200 0.9096 0.0445

71-10-05-426-001.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 01/29/2015 $173,900 17,700 149,500 167,200 0.9615 0.0073

71-10-05-428-007.000-031 Penn 7131051 510 031 02/26/2015 $170,000 19,300 145,900 165,200 0.9718 0.0176

71-10-08-277-001.000-031 Penn 7131052 510 031 07/03/2014 $60,000 22,700 43,500 66,200 1.1033 0.1492

71-10-09-126-016.000-031 Penn 7131052 510 031 08/12/2014 $75,000 9,800 68,700 78,500 1.0467 0.0925

71-10-09-127-014.000-031 Penn 7131052 510 031 12/29/2014 $99,688 12,100 102,300 114,400 1.1476 0.1935

71-10-07-153-006.000-031 Penn 7131052 510 031 01/22/2015 $122,500 26,000 96,400 122,400 0.9992 0.0451

71-10-04-454-006.000-031 Penn 7131053 510 031 03/05/2014 $150,000 25,000 125,000 150,000 1.0000 0.0459

71-10-04-453-011.000-031 Penn 7131053 510 031 03/07/2014 $185,000 24,700 137,500 162,200 0.8768 0.0774

71-10-04-453-005.000-031 Penn 7131053 510 031 04/04/2014 $158,500 27,300 138,600 165,900 1.0467 0.0926

71-10-04-406-005.000-031 Penn 7131053 510 031 09/16/2014 $162,000 23,900 130,700 154,600 0.9543 0.0002

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-10-04-406-001.000-031 Penn 7131053 510 031 10/29/2014 $129,000 23,900 113,400 137,300 1.0643 0.1102

71-10-04-478-004.000-031 Penn 7131054 510 031 01/22/2014 $50,000 18,700 68,300 87,000 1.7400 0.7859

71-09-26-227-001.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 04/15/2014 $76,500 11,500 67,400 78,900 1.0314 0.0772

71-10-21-226-010.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 06/18/2014 $144,000 22,500 100,900 123,400 0.8569 0.0972

71-10-21-228-006.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 07/15/2014 $187,900 20,900 155,800 176,700 0.9404 0.0137

71-09-29-379-003.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 08/20/2014 $129,500 19,000 87,100 106,100 0.8193 0.1348

71-10-17-126-004.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 08/26/2014 $75,900 9,900 69,000 78,900 1.0395 0.0854

71-09-26-251-019.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 08/27/2014 $325,000 35,400 239,500 274,900 0.8458 0.1083

71-10-17-107-010.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 10/17/2014 $95,900 8,400 76,600 85,000 0.8863 0.0678

71-10-17-103-010.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 12/30/2014 $54,000 5,000 50,700 55,700 1.0315 0.0774

71-10-08-304-009.000-031 Penn 7131056 510 031 02/26/2015 $105,000 14,900 84,500 99,400 0.9467 0.0075

71-10-09-427-004.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 06/19/2014 $134,900 21,000 103,500 124,500 0.9229 0.0312

71-10-09-258-008.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 07/01/2014 $175,900 15,700 152,300 168,000 0.9551 0.0010

71-10-09-401-003.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 07/07/2014 $162,000 28,800 127,800 156,600 0.9667 0.0125

71-10-09-426-001.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 09/09/2014 $148,000 16,100 141,100 157,200 1.0622 0.1080

71-10-09-477-006.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 12/12/2014 $77,000 19,700 62,000 81,700 1.0610 0.1069

71-10-09-258-005.000-031 Penn 7131057 510 031 01/29/2015 $130,000 16,900 104,700 121,600 0.9354 0.0187

71-09-28-228-012.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 05/13/2014 $127,000 19,800 113,400 133,200 1.0488 0.0947

71-09-21-455-001.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 07/14/2014 $170,500 28,600 139,900 168,500 0.9883 0.0341

71-09-28-300-027.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 07/17/2014 $255,200 24,600 209,400 234,000 0.9169 0.0372

71-09-28-229-003.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 08/18/2014 $111,000 15,200 96,200 111,400 1.0036 0.0495

71-09-21-478-001.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 10/06/2014 $155,000 21,900 124,600 146,500 0.9452 0.0090

71-09-21-401-004.000-031 Penn 7131059 510 031 11/03/2014 $190,000 15,700 182,700 198,400 1.0442 0.0901

71-10-20-201-012.000-031 Penn 7131062 510 031 08/12/2014 $141,900 31,500 108,200 139,700 0.9845 0.0304

71-10-20-201-011.000-031 Penn 7131062 500 031 08/12/2014 $0 0 0

71-10-20-226-016.000-031 Penn 7131062 510 031 05/05/2014 $146,000 16,100 124,600 140,700 0.9637 0.0096

71-10-20-202-011.000-031 Penn 7131062 510 031 07/31/2014 $162,500 18,000 130,900 148,900 0.9163 0.0378

71-09-28-254-008.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 07/11/2014 $148,500 39,900 90,300 130,200 0.8768 0.0774

71-09-28-151-002.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 08/18/2014 $153,000 28,300 119,700 148,000 0.9673 0.0132

71-09-28-401-012.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 09/19/2014 $140,000 18,800 116,200 135,000 0.9643 0.0102

71-09-28-401-002.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 10/08/2014 $139,500 18,800 100,500 119,300 0.8552 0.0989

71-09-28-402-002.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 11/20/2014 $148,000 22,700 121,500 144,200 0.9743 0.0202

71-09-28-151-008.000-031 Penn 7131063 510 031 12/05/2014 $173,000 34,800 133,600 168,400 0.9734 0.0193

71-09-25-303-006.000-031 Penn 7131064 510 031 12/30/2014 $150,000 28,400 97,200 125,600 0.8373 0.1168

71-09-25-351-006.000-031 Penn 7131064 510 031 02/25/2015 $162,000 19,600 133,700 153,300 0.9463 0.0078

71-09-35-300-001.000-031 Penn 7131067 510 031 07/15/2014 $218,000 20,600 141,400 162,000 0.7431 0.2110

71-09-29-251-006.000-031 Penn 7131067 510 031 07/17/2014 $148,500 13,600 97,900 111,500 0.7508 0.2033

71-09-33-226-005.000-031 Penn 7131067 510 031 11/25/2014 $65,000 13,200 72,900 86,100 1.3246 0.3705

71-09-32-152-006.000-031 Penn 7131071 510 031 04/16/2014 $190,000 21,700 170,000 191,700 1.0089 0.0548

71-09-32-151-012.000-031 Penn 7131071 510 031 12/03/2014 $249,900 22,000 163,700 185,700 0.7431 0.2110

71-09-32-151-008.000-031 Penn 7131071 510 031 12/11/2014 $268,000 18,600 170,000 188,600 0.7037 0.2504

71-09-32-302-013.000-031 Penn 7131071 510 031 12/18/2014 $230,000 18,200 140,800 159,000 0.6913 0.2628

71-10-21-400-003.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 01/09/2014 $186,000 19,600 149,800 169,400 0.9108 0.0434

71-10-21-428-006.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 01/17/2014 $242,000 20,000 198,500 218,500 0.9029 0.0512

71-10-21-428-001.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 05/08/2014 $190,000 20,000 161,300 181,300 0.9542 0.0001

71-10-21-402-009.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 05/15/2014 $240,000 23,400 177,000 200,400 0.8350 0.1191

71-10-21-427-020.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 06/17/2014 $253,000 23,400 200,600 224,000 0.8854 0.0687

71-10-21-427-009.000-031 Penn 7131076 510 031 02/10/2015 $217,000 23,400 197,700 221,100 1.0189 0.0648

71-05-33-428-008.000-031 Penn 7131080 510 031 04/29/2014 $187,050 15,700 160,500 176,200 0.9420 0.0121

71-05-33-477-013.000-031 Penn 7131080 510 031 05/01/2014 $167,500 16,600 142,900 159,500 0.9522 0.0019

71-05-33-455-003.000-031 Penn 7131080 510 031 07/22/2014 $127,000 15,600 81,900 97,500 0.7677 0.1864

71-09-13-477-009.000-032 Penn 7132003 510 032 07/24/2014 $65,000 9,400 56,700 66,100 1.0169 0.0628

71-09-13-326-021.000-032 Penn 7132003 510 032 08/08/2014 $130,000 18,500 75,100 93,600 0.7200 0.2341

71-10-19-176-048.000-032 Penn 7132005 510 032 12/29/2014 $237,000 27,300 185,000 212,300 0.8958 0.0583

71-09-20-301-003.000-033 Penn 7133010 510 033 08/21/2014 $247,000 23,900 158,900 182,800 0.7401 0.2140

71-09-20-326-092.000-033 Penn 7133011 550 033 01/30/2014 $35,500 7,000 36,900 43,900 1.2366 0.2825

71-09-20-326-057.000-033 Penn 7133011 510 033 02/04/2014 $38,000 8,000 30,600 38,600 1.0158 0.0617

71-09-15-179-001.000-023 Penn 7123060 510 023 12/9/2014 82,200$ 10,000 69,300 79,300 0.9647 0.0106

71-09-32-302-013.000-031 Penn 7131071 510 031 12/2/2014 230,000$ 18,200 140,800 159,000 0.6913 0.2628

71-09-27-229-003.000-022 Penn 7122069 510 022 8/6/2014 430,000$ 48,400 263,800 312,200 0.7260 0.2281

71-09-09-313-007.000-023 Penn 7123090 510 023 10/31/2014 71,500$ 9,000 50,700 59,700 0.8350 0.1192

71-09-09-203-004.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 8/6/2014 47,500$ 8,400 37,800 46,200 0.9726 0.0185

71-09-04-178-002.000-022 Penn 7122054 510 022 2/17/2015 65,000$ 9,800 68,200 78,000 1.2000 0.2459

71-09-24-105-009.000-023 Penn 7123073 510 023 2/27/2015 109,500$ 13,300 93,400 106,700 0.9744 0.0203

71-09-12-477-013.000-023 Penn 7123064 510 023 2/24/2015 195,000$ 19,300 151,900 171,200 0.8779 0.0762

71-09-29-276-001.000-031 Penn 7131067 510 031 2/27/2015 81,000$ 17,500 65,700 83,200 1.0272 0.0730

71-05-31-404-005.000-031 Penn 7131028 510 031 2/27/2015 128,500$ 21,300 83,600 104,900 0.8163 0.1378

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-10-482-020.000-023 Penn 7123056 510 023 2/25/2015 123,500$ 10,700 112,700 123,400 0.9992 0.0451

71-09-15-115-013.000-023 Penn 7123062 510 023 2/26/2015 203,500$ 18,400 161,400 179,800 0.8835 0.0706

71-09-32-126-039.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 2/23/2015 139,000$ 13,400 155,000 168,400 1.2115 0.2574

71-04-35-201-021.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 2/27/2015 135,000$ 24,300 127,100 151,400 1.1215 0.1674

71-09-14-228-014.000-023 Penn 7123071 510 023 2/20/2015 105,000$ 23,800 86,700 110,500 1.0524 0.0983

71-09-09-205-007.000-023 Penn 7123051 510 023 2/27/2015 61,000$ 11,900 46,800 58,700 0.9623 0.0082

71-09-24-227-015.000-023 Penn 7123074 510 023 2/27/2015 121,000$ 15,300 97,800 113,100 0.9347 0.0194

71-04-35-251-009.000-031 Penn 7131026 510 031 2/10/2015 155,000$ 28,000 142,800 170,800 1.1019 0.1478

71-09-09-356-004.000-023 Penn 7123054 510 023 2/13/2015 57,500$ 8,800 53,600 62,400 1.0852 0.1311

71-09-03-102-068.000-022 Penn 7122053 550 022 2/6/2015 250,000$ 30,000 205,800 235,800 0.9432 0.0109

71-09-20-326-047.000-033 Penn 7133011 550 033 10/09/2014 $44,000 7,000 33,600 40,600 0.9227 0.0314

71-09-20-326-067.000-033 Penn 7133011 550 033 01/14/2015 $39,000 9,000 27,800 36,800 0.9436 0.0105

71-09-20-326-110.000-033 Penn 7133011 550 033 02/19/2015 $34,900 7,000 30,600 37,600 1.0774 0.1232

71-09-20-379-002.000-033 Penn 7133012 510 033 01/06/2014 $670,000 140,400 405,900 546,300 0.8154 0.1388

71-09-20-379-003.000-033 Penn 7133012 510 033 04/02/2014 $670,000 74,800 500,400 575,200 0.8585 0.0956

71-09-32-104-003.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 04/01/2014 $149,900 10,100 125,800 135,900 0.9066 0.0475

71-09-32-126-042.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 04/09/2014 $138,000 22,000 117,300 139,300 1.0094 0.0553

71-09-32-126-065.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 04/25/2014 $183,000 22,800 134,700 157,500 0.8607 0.0935

71-09-32-126-037.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 05/21/2014 $158,000 23,000 126,900 149,900 0.9487 0.0054

71-09-32-126-096.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 06/05/2014 $188,000 14,400 134,400 148,800 0.7915 0.1626

71-09-32-126-018.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 07/11/2014 $167,500 14,800 146,700 161,500 0.9642 0.0101

71-09-32-126-032.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 08/22/2014 $200,500 14,300 184,500 198,800 0.9915 0.0374

71-09-32-104-005.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 08/27/2014 $206,000 9,800 192,100 201,900 0.9801 0.0260

71-09-32-126-068.000-033 Penn 7133014 510 033 02/25/2015 $162,000 14,100 113,500 127,600 0.7877 0.1665

$73,898,921 68,945,400 534

Mean 0.9564

Median 0.9541

Wtd Mean 0.9330

COD 9.4754

PRD 1.0251

PORTAGE TOWNSHIP

71-08-04-160-007.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 01/15/2014 $32,000 6,600 31,400 38,000 1.1875 0.2250

71-08-05-226-021.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 06/06/2014 $115,000 20,400 80,200 100,600 0.8748 0.0877

71-08-06-227-004.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 06/11/2014 $159,000 15,000 122,400 137,400 0.8642 0.0983

71-08-05-102-016.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 06/06/2014 $85,000 30,200 63,200 93,400 1.0988 0.1363

71-08-05-102-014.000-025 Portage 7125036 500 025 06/06/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-04-160-013.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 07/22/2014 $59,000 6,200 48,700 54,900 0.9305 0.0320

71-08-06-201-006.000-025 Portage 7125034 540 025 07/28/2014 $69,500 19,800 40,000 59,800 0.8604 0.1021

71-08-05-176-011.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 08/05/2014 $112,000 31,200 82,500 113,700 1.0152 0.0527

71-08-06-203-002.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 10/24/2014 $76,000 15,900 74,100 90,000 1.1842 0.2217

71-08-05-151-021.000-025 Portage 7125034 510 025 12/30/2014 $58,000 15,000 50,100 65,100 1.1224 0.1599

71-08-08-302-005.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 07/15/2014 $145,000 10,200 144,700 154,900 1.0683 0.1058

71-08-07-276-016.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 09/25/2014 $58,000 5,100 50,300 55,400 0.9552 0.0073

71-08-08-378-018.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 07/22/2014 $98,500 10,700 69,800 80,500 0.8173 0.1452

71-08-08-378-019.000-025 Portage 7125042 500 025 07/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-08-126-031.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 12/08/2014 $45,000 23,300 41,400 64,700 1.4378 0.4753

71-08-08-176-010.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 12/22/2014 $79,900 3,700 68,000 71,700 0.8974 0.0651

71-08-08-351-008.000-025 Portage 7125041 510 025 12/24/2014 $72,220 10,200 65,300 75,500 1.0454 0.0829

71-08-18-151-006.000-025 Portage 7125045 510 025 07/02/2014 $130,000 48,600 96,800 145,400 1.1185 0.1560

71-08-18-103-012.000-025 Portage 7125045 510 025 09/25/2014 $105,000 10,300 77,600 87,900 0.8371 0.1254

71-09-06-101-190.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 03/06/2014 $478,331 26,400 403,000 429,400 0.8977 0.0648

71-09-06-101-188.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 03/12/2014 $443,046 24,500 400,000 424,500 0.9581 0.0044

71-09-06-101-189.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 03/19/2014 $435,300 20,700 396,800 417,500 0.9591 0.0034

71-09-06-101-194.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 04/07/2014 $439,343 26,200 395,200 421,400 0.9592 0.0033

71-09-06-101-193.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 04/16/2014 $465,360 24,500 402,500 427,000 0.9176 0.0449

71-09-06-101-187.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 04/22/2014 $454,259 30,300 402,500 432,800 0.9528 0.0097

71-09-06-101-191.000-026 Portage 7126099 510 026 05/14/2014 $419,632 24,500 402,500 427,000 1.0176 0.0551

71-09-06-101-196.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 11/06/2014 $450,682 10,400 400,000 410,400 0.9106 0.0519

71-09-06-101-198.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 11/17/2014 $464,542 10,400 403,000 413,400 0.8899 0.0726

71-09-06-101-199.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 11/17/2014 $435,620 10,400 400,200 410,600 0.9426 0.0199

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-06-101-197.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 11/20/2014 $464,168 10,400 399,100 409,500 0.8822 0.0803

71-09-06-101-200.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 12/12/2014 $469,354 10,400 403,000 413,400 0.8808 0.0817

71-09-06-101-202.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 01/26/2015 $484,057 16,000 395,200 411,200 0.8495 0.1130

71-09-06-101-201.000-026 Portage 7126099 550 026 02/06/2015 $456,146 10,400 402,500 412,900 0.9052 0.0573

71-08-08-403-004.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 02/11/2014 $58,000 4,900 48,200 53,100 0.9155 0.0470

71-08-08-451-016.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 02/12/2014 $64,000 4,600 57,100 61,700 0.9641 0.0016

71-08-09-355-003.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 03/20/2014 $51,000 4,300 51,200 55,500 1.0882 0.1257

71-08-09-354-019.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 04/01/2014 $73,500 4,300 59,400 63,700 0.8667 0.0958

71-08-08-476-039.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 04/02/2014 $85,900 4,200 64,600 68,800 0.8009 0.1616

71-08-08-476-017.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 04/03/2014 $59,000 5,300 45,200 50,500 0.8559 0.1066

71-08-09-352-024.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 04/22/2014 $42,000 4,300 47,400 51,700 1.2310 0.2685

71-08-09-304-007.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 05/28/2014 $54,900 6,000 47,600 53,600 0.9763 0.0138

71-08-08-253-015.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 05/30/2014 $52,000 5,800 60,600 66,400 1.2769 0.3144

71-08-08-205-009.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 06/18/2014 $81,500 5,300 85,500 90,800 1.1141 0.1516

71-08-08-251-008.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 07/01/2014 $86,900 7,000 67,500 74,500 0.8573 0.1052

71-08-08-454-004.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 07/17/2014 $72,500 5,600 59,000 64,600 0.8910 0.0715

71-08-09-355-009.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 08/14/2014 $47,000 5,200 56,100 61,300 1.3043 0.3418

71-08-08-456-018.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 08/19/2014 $45,000 5,200 46,100 51,300 1.1400 0.1775

71-08-08-454-012.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 08/25/2014 $49,000 6,100 45,100 51,200 1.0449 0.0824

71-08-08-403-002.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 08/25/2014 $53,000 4,900 49,200 54,100 1.0208 0.0583

71-08-09-352-029.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 08/26/2014 $53,600 4,600 45,000 49,600 0.9254 0.0371

71-08-08-452-011.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 09/12/2014 $54,800 4,900 45,600 50,500 0.9215 0.0410

71-08-08-454-014.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 09/15/2014 $55,000 5,800 43,600 49,400 0.8982 0.0643

71-08-08-476-006.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 09/16/2014 $64,500 5,200 48,300 53,500 0.8295 0.1330

71-08-08-451-003.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 10/22/2014 $72,000 3,000 64,600 67,600 0.9389 0.0236

71-08-08-454-007.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 11/12/2014 $79,500 5,000 66,300 71,300 0.8969 0.0656

71-08-09-353-014.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 11/25/2014 $57,500 4,300 43,300 47,600 0.8278 0.1347

71-08-08-456-010.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 12/22/2014 $62,000 4,900 43,200 48,100 0.7758 0.1867

71-08-08-476-021.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 12/30/2014 $46,000 4,300 47,700 52,000 1.1304 0.1679

71-08-08-476-022.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 01/30/2015 $61,500 5,200 44,900 50,100 0.8146 0.1479

71-08-16-127-021.000-026 Portage 7126212 510 026 04/15/2014 $50,000 2,500 40,100 42,600 0.8520 0.1105

71-08-16-104-006.000-026 Portage 7126212 510 026 05/01/2014 $27,000 2,300 33,300 35,600 1.3185 0.3560

71-08-17-228-020.000-026 Portage 7126212 510 026 05/22/2014 $65,000 3,800 50,000 53,800 0.8277 0.1348

71-08-04-177-037.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 03/05/2014 $74,900 2,500 58,500 61,000 0.8144 0.1481

71-08-04-203-016.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 03/05/2014 $68,100 2,400 66,300 68,700 1.0088 0.0463

71-08-04-130-006.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 03/07/2014 $68,000 2,500 65,000 67,500 0.9926 0.0301

71-03-33-477-020.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 03/27/2014 $55,500 1,800 55,100 56,900 1.0252 0.0627

71-08-04-127-026.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 04/22/2014 $68,000 1,800 51,600 53,400 0.7853 0.1772

71-08-04-126-010.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 05/07/2014 $69,000 1,700 64,000 65,700 0.9522 0.0103

71-03-33-477-015.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 05/13/2014 $49,000 1,700 45,500 47,200 0.9633 0.0008

71-08-04-130-012.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 05/29/2014 $74,900 1,800 63,300 65,100 0.8692 0.0933

71-03-33-453-009.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 06/10/2014 $51,000 1,700 46,900 48,600 0.9529 0.0096

71-08-04-203-018.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 08/12/2014 $67,000 2,300 68,000 70,300 1.0493 0.0868

71-03-33-457-015.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 08/14/2014 $54,000 1,600 47,000 48,600 0.9000 0.0625

71-03-33-476-004.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 08/21/2014 $58,500 1,800 61,100 62,900 1.0752 0.1127

71-08-04-177-030.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 08/26/2014 $62,000 1,800 67,100 68,900 1.1113 0.1488

71-08-04-128-001.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 10/03/2014 $62,000 2,300 66,200 68,500 1.1048 0.1423

71-08-04-179-014.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 10/27/2014 $70,000 2,300 71,800 74,100 1.0586 0.0961

71-03-33-455-017.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 11/12/2014 $57,000 1,600 46,600 48,200 0.8456 0.1169

71-03-33-457-016.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 12/11/2014 $46,000 1,600 51,900 53,500 1.1630 0.2005

71-08-04-201-013.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 12/24/2014 $56,000 2,200 71,700 73,900 1.3196 0.3571

71-08-04-201-026.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 12/30/2014 $65,000 2,300 69,200 71,500 1.1000 0.1375

71-03-33-478-014.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 01/07/2015 $63,000 1,700 60,800 62,500 0.9921 0.0296

71-08-04-127-022.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 01/28/2015 $73,000 1,800 63,300 65,100 0.8918 0.0707

71-03-33-477-043.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 01/29/2015 $63,000 1,800 51,100 52,900 0.8397 0.1228

71-08-10-303-017.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 04/09/2014 $46,500 800 34,100 34,900 0.7505 0.2120

71-08-09-380-007.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 05/15/2014 $40,000 1,000 32,500 33,500 0.8375 0.1250

71-08-09-127-048.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 07/02/2014 $20,000 1,000 22,800 23,800 1.1900 0.2275

71-08-10-308-009.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 09/12/2014 $28,500 1,000 28,600 29,600 1.0386 0.0761

71-08-09-104-027.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 10/01/2014 $35,000 1,500 26,200 27,700 0.7914 0.1711

71-08-09-130-016.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 10/10/2014 $21,500 900 20,200 21,100 0.9814 0.0189

71-08-09-404-017.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 11/15/2014 $16,000 900 18,000 18,900 1.1813 0.2188

71-08-09-127-034.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 11/18/2014 $34,000 1,200 32,400 33,600 0.9882 0.0257

71-08-09-427-002.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 11/25/2014 $30,000 900 28,200 29,100 0.9700 0.0075

71-08-10-378-003.000-026 Portage 7126226 510 026 02/28/2014 $27,000 700 23,300 24,000 0.8889 0.0736

71-08-11-305-004.000-026 Portage 7126226 510 026 03/25/2014 $15,000 700 15,400 16,100 1.0733 0.1108

71-08-11-354-021.000-026 Portage 7126226 510 026 06/23/2014 $11,850 600 9,500 10,100 0.8523 0.1102

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-08-11-353-011.000-026 Portage 7126226 510 026 02/25/2015 $12,600 600 16,800 17,400 1.3810 0.4185

71-08-15-379-008.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 05/05/2014 $78,000 7,100 67,600 74,700 0.9577 0.0048

71-08-22-251-028.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 05/27/2014 $112,000 5,300 78,500 83,800 0.7482 0.2143

71-08-14-430-024.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 07/02/2014 $20,000 3,400 18,200 21,600 1.0800 0.1175

71-08-14-409-008.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 08/04/2014 $25,000 4,100 20,200 24,300 0.9720 0.0095

71-08-15-482-042.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 09/23/2014 $58,000 8,400 61,100 69,500 1.1983 0.2358

71-08-24-355-017.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 07/17/2014 $75,000 11,800 52,800 64,600 0.8613 0.1012

71-08-24-355-016.000-026 Portage 7126237 500 026 07/17/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-22-230-017.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 10/10/2014 $29,597 4,700 32,100 36,800 1.2434 0.2809

71-08-14-431-012.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 12/12/2014 $18,900 3,400 15,600 19,000 1.0053 0.0428

71-08-14-454-007.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 11/18/2014 $33,500 5,900 29,700 35,600 1.0627 0.1002

71-08-14-454-008.000-026 Portage 7126237 500 026 11/18/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-14-406-020.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 12/29/2014 $105,000 900 88,800 89,700 0.8543 0.1082

71-08-15-482-040.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 01/22/2015 $75,700 6,400 64,100 70,500 0.9313 0.0312

71-08-14-356-010.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 12/09/2014 $87,000 13,000 55,500 68,500 0.7874 0.1751

71-08-14-356-011.000-026 Portage 7126237 500 026 12/09/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-14-356-012.000-026 Portage 7126237 500 026 12/09/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-14-452-022.000-026 Portage 7126235 510 026 02/24/2015 $38,500 4,000 45,200 49,200 1.2779 0.3154

71-08-24-329-004.000-026 Portage 7126239 520 026 10/13/2014 $57,500 4,800 53,500 58,300 1.0139 0.0514

71-08-13-252-034.000-026 Portage 7126243 510 026 09/05/2014 $33,500 1,300 25,900 27,200 0.8119 0.1506

71-08-13-179-005.000-026 Portage 7126243 510 026 12/03/2014 $45,000 1,300 34,300 35,600 0.7911 0.1714

71-08-13-332-019.000-026 Portage 7126244 510 026 12/02/2014 $37,000 2,100 48,800 50,900 1.3757 0.4132

71-08-13-332-018.000-026 Portage 7126244 500 026 12/02/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-13-252-008.000-026 Portage 7126258 510 026 02/26/2015 $95,000 1,800 111,200 113,000 1.1895 0.2270

71-08-24-232-008.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 01/10/2014 $41,500 4,100 49,200 53,300 1.2843 0.3218

71-08-24-252-010.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 02/12/2014 $74,000 3,700 55,700 59,400 0.8027 0.1598

71-08-24-204-014.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 03/19/2014 $49,000 4,000 60,300 64,300 1.3122 0.3497

71-08-24-183-012.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 04/08/2014 $64,900 4,300 54,500 58,800 0.9060 0.0565

71-08-24-276-031.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 04/10/2014 $78,500 4,100 56,100 60,200 0.7669 0.1956

71-08-24-126-006.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 04/28/2014 $36,000 4,300 43,900 48,200 1.3389 0.3764

71-08-24-279-004.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 06/23/2014 $140,000 4,300 99,000 103,300 0.7379 0.2246

71-08-24-204-010.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 06/25/2014 $59,900 4,000 56,300 60,300 1.0067 0.0442

71-08-24-137-001.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 03/11/2014 $91,500 8,200 58,100 66,300 0.7246 0.2379

71-08-24-137-002.000-026 Portage 7126264 500 026 03/11/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-24-227-002.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/01/2014 $66,000 4,400 48,600 53,000 0.8030 0.1595

71-08-24-278-028.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/24/2014 $104,500 3,800 77,500 81,300 0.7780 0.1845

71-08-24-232-010.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/24/2014 $49,900 4,000 53,100 57,100 1.1443 0.1818

71-08-24-253-019.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $100,000 4,800 61,600 66,400 0.6640 0.2985

71-08-24-135-006.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $68,000 3,800 71,200 75,000 1.1029 0.1404

71-08-24-258-005.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $70,000 4,100 42,300 46,400 0.6629 0.2996

71-08-24-201-025.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 08/05/2014 $69,500 5,200 63,400 68,600 0.9871 0.0246

71-08-24-182-018.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 08/06/2014 $65,000 4,300 53,800 58,100 0.8938 0.0687

71-08-24-254-020.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 08/13/2014 $81,000 5,500 61,600 67,100 0.8284 0.1341

71-08-24-278-001.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 09/02/2014 $89,000 4,200 64,500 68,700 0.7719 0.1906

71-08-24-227-010.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 09/09/2014 $66,000 3,800 59,200 63,000 0.9545 0.0080

71-08-24-252-012.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 09/25/2014 $50,000 3,800 60,200 64,000 1.2800 0.3175

71-08-24-279-023.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 10/15/2014 $74,900 4,300 67,100 71,400 0.9533 0.0092

71-08-24-276-019.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 10/17/2014 $45,000 4,000 41,600 45,600 1.0133 0.0508

71-08-24-181-005.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 10/29/2014 $45,400 3,700 53,500 57,200 1.2599 0.2974

71-08-24-202-008.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 11/06/2014 $79,000 4,100 74,500 78,600 0.9949 0.0324

71-08-24-180-015.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 11/06/2014 $50,000 3,600 41,500 45,100 0.9020 0.0605

71-08-24-278-020.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 12/12/2014 $84,000 5,300 70,700 76,000 0.9048 0.0577

71-08-24-278-002.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 01/20/2015 $88,000 4,200 73,000 77,200 0.8773 0.0852

71-08-24-227-023.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 01/29/2015 $46,900 4,200 46,400 50,600 1.0789 0.1164

71-08-24-181-001.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 01/29/2015 $42,900 3,700 51,600 55,300 1.2890 0.3265

71-08-24-180-013.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 02/13/2015 $48,500 3,600 50,100 53,700 1.1072 0.1447

71-08-24-329-016.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 01/22/2014 $104,900 11,500 89,900 101,400 0.9666 0.0041

71-08-24-330-024.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 01/30/2014 $60,000 10,500 45,400 55,900 0.9317 0.0308

71-08-24-402-006.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 03/27/2014 $75,000 7,800 66,800 74,600 0.9947 0.0322

71-08-24-330-008.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 04/04/2014 $65,000 10,600 39,600 50,200 0.7723 0.1902

71-08-24-327-003.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 04/09/2014 $73,500 8,800 75,600 84,400 1.1483 0.1858

71-08-24-329-019.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 06/04/2014 $74,500 10,500 87,200 97,700 1.3114 0.3489

71-08-24-330-003.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 08/05/2014 $65,000 9,600 58,600 68,200 1.0492 0.0867

71-08-24-376-015.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 11/05/2014 $62,500 11,200 61,400 72,600 1.1616 0.1991

71-08-25-176-003.000-026 Portage 7126272 510 026 02/26/2015 $59,900 12,200 42,900 55,100 0.9199 0.0426

71-09-18-128-022.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 04/21/2014 $60,552 2,600 42,300 44,900 0.7415 0.2210

71-09-18-203-021.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 05/14/2014 $70,000 4,800 60,300 65,100 0.9300 0.0325

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-18-203-020.000-026 Portage 7126277 500 026 05/14/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-18-129-019.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 07/08/2014 $41,253 2,600 51,100 53,700 1.3017 0.3392

71-09-18-179-009.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 08/04/2014 $67,500 2,700 54,100 56,800 0.8415 0.1210

71-09-18-132-009.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 10/13/2014 $57,000 2,900 59,900 62,800 1.1018 0.1393

71-09-18-203-013.000-026 Portage 7126276 510 026 11/17/2014 $102,500 2,400 86,800 89,200 0.8702 0.0923

71-09-18-357-011.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 04/03/2014 $52,000 4,100 45,300 49,400 0.9500 0.0125

71-09-18-431-023.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 04/04/2014 $45,000 4,000 41,300 45,300 1.0067 0.0442

71-09-18-155-018.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 05/01/2014 $39,900 8,100 50,100 58,200 1.4586 0.4961

71-09-18-155-019.000-026 Portage 7126283 500 026 05/01/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-18-460-009.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 05/07/2014 $78,000 4,700 54,200 58,900 0.7551 0.2074

71-09-18-478-018.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 05/08/2014 $67,450 4,300 41,000 45,300 0.6716 0.2909

71-09-18-461-014.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 06/19/2014 $68,500 3,700 57,500 61,200 0.8934 0.0691

71-09-18-455-019.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 09/30/2014 $50,000 8,300 48,900 57,200 1.1440 0.1815

71-09-18-455-018.000-026 Portage 7126283 500 026 09/30/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-18-482-006.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 06/25/2014 $90,000 4,300 56,500 60,800 0.6756 0.2869

71-09-18-332-019.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 07/03/2014 $50,000 4,700 52,800 57,500 1.1500 0.1875

71-09-18-478-016.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 07/23/2014 $65,000 4,300 46,400 50,700 0.7800 0.1825

71-09-18-479-008.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 08/04/2014 $39,900 3,900 46,100 50,000 1.2531 0.2906

71-09-18-480-005.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 08/08/2014 $68,000 4,300 49,600 53,900 0.7926 0.1699

71-09-18-459-015.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 09/16/2014 $34,500 3,900 50,000 53,900 1.5623 0.5998

71-09-18-358-025.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 10/06/2014 $114,000 3,400 79,700 83,100 0.7289 0.2336

71-09-18-408-010.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 12/22/2014 $40,400 4,900 40,700 45,600 1.1287 0.1662

71-09-18-153-006.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 12/24/2014 $46,400 5,000 65,700 70,700 1.5237 0.5612

71-09-18-456-009.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 01/21/2015 $33,500 3,900 40,100 44,000 1.3134 0.3509

71-09-18-461-021.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 01/22/2015 $91,500 3,700 66,200 69,900 0.7639 0.1986

71-09-18-335-009.000-026 Portage 7126282 510 026 01/27/2015 $43,000 4,500 50,700 55,200 1.2837 0.3212

71-09-19-252-016.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 01/27/2014 $60,000 16,000 64,300 80,300 1.3383 0.3758

71-09-19-132-004.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 03/07/2014 $110,000 20,200 99,300 119,500 1.0864 0.1239

71-09-19-404-018.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 03/14/2014 $92,000 20,100 60,700 80,800 0.8783 0.0842

71-09-19-105-027.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 03/26/2014 $92,500 17,000 74,200 91,200 0.9859 0.0234

71-08-25-178-013.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 04/11/2014 $108,500 17,300 89,400 106,700 0.9834 0.0209

71-09-19-207-015.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 04/15/2014 $122,000 13,900 95,800 109,700 0.8992 0.0633

71-09-19-477-013.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 04/17/2014 $80,000 17,000 69,500 86,500 1.0813 0.1188

71-09-19-327-004.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 05/05/2014 $163,000 32,100 71,300 103,400 0.6344 0.3281

71-09-19-481-001.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 05/23/2014 $128,900 20,900 75,900 96,800 0.7510 0.2115

71-08-25-127-001.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/02/2014 $50,000 11,600 35,500 47,100 0.9420 0.0205

71-09-19-403-010.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/03/2014 $65,000 22,900 64,200 87,100 1.3400 0.3775

71-09-19-407-008.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/03/2014 $89,900 19,000 70,300 89,300 0.9933 0.0308

71-09-19-203-025.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/13/2014 $85,500 13,300 53,600 66,900 0.7825 0.1800

71-09-19-404-019.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/20/2014 $99,500 20,300 65,500 85,800 0.8623 0.1002

71-09-19-252-006.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 06/20/2014 $109,000 22,600 76,500 99,100 0.9092 0.0533

71-09-19-430-008.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 07/18/2014 $108,000 12,700 78,400 91,100 0.8435 0.1190

71-09-19-404-029.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 07/23/2014 $118,000 22,800 77,300 100,100 0.8483 0.1142

71-09-19-252-003.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 07/30/2014 $80,000 25,500 66,000 91,500 1.1438 0.1813

71-09-19-205-012.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 08/08/2014 $83,000 18,000 62,200 80,200 0.9663 0.0038

71-09-19-104-019.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 08/14/2014 $98,000 9,300 73,700 83,000 0.8469 0.1156

71-09-19-406-006.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 08/21/2014 $136,500 29,900 71,000 100,900 0.7392 0.2233

71-09-19-481-007.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 08/21/2014 $82,500 19,400 60,800 80,200 0.9721 0.0096

71-09-19-476-001.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 08/26/2014 $106,401 20,800 66,900 87,700 0.8242 0.1383

71-09-19-133-010.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 09/29/2014 $170,000 19,100 98,900 118,000 0.6941 0.2684

71-09-19-479-006.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 10/09/2014 $127,500 28,000 76,400 104,400 0.8188 0.1437

71-09-19-455-004.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 11/06/2014 $118,500 20,300 92,200 112,500 0.9494 0.0131

71-09-19-281-010.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 11/20/2014 $100,000 21,100 71,300 92,400 0.9240 0.0385

71-09-19-253-019.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/15/2014 $83,000 19,600 54,600 74,200 0.8940 0.0685

71-09-19-202-030.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/16/2014 $74,900 15,100 56,700 71,800 0.9586 0.0039

71-09-19-253-001.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/22/2014 $76,000 29,800 62,400 92,200 1.2132 0.2507

71-09-19-481-012.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/24/2014 $85,000 15,900 79,200 95,100 1.1188 0.1563

71-09-19-281-007.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/31/2014 $86,200 15,800 59,600 75,400 0.8747 0.0878

71-09-19-130-003.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 12/31/2014 $80,000 14,000 67,500 81,500 1.0188 0.0563

71-08-25-176-022.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 01/12/2015 $105,000 16,900 84,600 101,500 0.9667 0.0042

71-09-19-476-007.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 01/13/2015 $95,000 28,700 68,800 97,500 1.0263 0.0638

71-09-19-201-006.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 02/18/2015 $105,000 14,400 82,000 96,400 0.9181 0.0444

71-09-19-276-004.000-026 Portage 7126288 510 026 02/25/2015 $62,800 15,500 46,900 62,400 0.9936 0.0311

71-09-19-156-002.000-026 Portage 7126291 510 026 08/07/2014 $177,500 80,100 141,700 221,800 1.2496 0.2871

71-09-19-107-012.000-026 Portage 7126291 510 026 11/13/2014 $139,900 29,400 131,100 160,500 1.1472 0.1847

71-09-19-154-003.000-026 Portage 7126291 510 026 01/29/2015 $380,000 107,800 285,500 393,300 1.0350 0.0725

71-09-08-477-004.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 01/24/2014 $79,000 2,300 70,600 72,900 0.9228 0.0397

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-08-426-001.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/03/2014 $60,000 4,900 60,900 65,800 1.0967 0.1342

71-09-08-453-014.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 03/06/2014 $40,000 2,200 43,300 45,500 1.1375 0.1750

71-09-17-253-006.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 03/20/2014 $71,000 2,300 73,800 76,100 1.0718 0.1093

71-09-17-276-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 03/21/2014 $74,900 2,300 60,500 62,800 0.8385 0.1240

71-09-17-228-022.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 04/04/2014 $82,500 2,400 71,800 74,200 0.8994 0.0631

71-09-17-131-010.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/05/2014 $56,000 2,500 57,700 60,200 1.0750 0.1125

71-09-17-131-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/17/2014 $78,000 2,500 74,600 77,100 0.9885 0.0260

71-09-17-205-007.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/21/2014 $87,000 3,800 60,300 64,100 0.7368 0.2257

71-09-08-404-015.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/22/2014 $72,000 3,500 75,600 79,100 1.0986 0.1361

71-09-18-227-012.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/27/2014 $46,500 2,200 50,000 52,200 1.1226 0.1601

71-09-17-254-014.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 05/30/2014 $55,500 2,300 49,900 52,200 0.9405 0.0220

71-09-08-356-017.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/04/2014 $33,500 2,200 37,500 39,700 1.1851 0.2226

71-09-08-452-026.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/11/2014 $57,000 2,400 65,700 68,100 1.1947 0.2322

71-09-08-458-013.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/12/2014 $63,782 2,200 63,800 66,000 1.0348 0.0723

71-09-08-480-027.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/16/2014 $60,000 2,200 74,300 76,500 1.2750 0.3125

71-09-17-233-019.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $58,000 2,600 46,900 49,500 0.8534 0.1091

71-09-08-452-023.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $68,000 2,400 60,200 62,600 0.9206 0.0419

71-09-08-378-010.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $69,900 2,200 61,300 63,500 0.9084 0.0541

71-09-17-107-001.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 09/26/2014 $67,000 3,800 72,100 75,900 1.1328 0.1703

71-09-17-107-002.000-026 Portage 7126297 500 026 09/26/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-17-229-012.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/19/2014 $83,800 2,400 49,500 51,900 0.6193 0.3432

71-09-17-126-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/26/2014 $82,500 3,800 65,800 69,600 0.8436 0.1189

71-09-17-253-001.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 06/27/2014 $54,500 2,300 67,200 69,500 1.2752 0.3127

71-09-17-101-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 07/14/2014 $43,800 1,500 48,400 49,900 1.1393 0.1768

71-09-17-279-008.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 07/14/2014 $57,000 3,700 62,800 66,500 1.1667 0.2042

71-09-08-478-022.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 07/22/2014 $44,000 2,400 41,600 44,000 1.0000 0.0375

71-09-08-328-011.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 07/24/2014 $58,000 2,100 52,000 54,100 0.9328 0.0297

71-09-17-204-021.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 08/11/2014 $51,500 2,300 49,400 51,700 1.0039 0.0414

71-09-17-253-022.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 08/14/2014 $52,000 2,300 49,800 52,100 1.0019 0.0394

71-09-08-480-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 08/18/2014 $70,000 2,200 59,600 61,800 0.8829 0.0796

71-09-17-228-017.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 08/21/2014 $64,000 2,400 57,300 59,700 0.9328 0.0297

71-09-08-452-024.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 09/05/2014 $69,900 2,300 58,800 61,100 0.8741 0.0884

71-09-08-432-013.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 09/17/2014 $69,900 2,200 63,000 65,200 0.9328 0.0297

71-09-17-276-021.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 10/03/2014 $46,000 2,300 48,800 51,100 1.1109 0.1484

71-09-08-454-026.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 10/09/2014 $52,000 2,200 57,900 60,100 1.1558 0.1933

71-09-08-381-006.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 11/26/2014 $71,000 2,200 63,800 66,000 0.9296 0.0329

71-09-17-227-019.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 12/05/2014 $75,000 2,300 72,100 74,400 0.9920 0.0295

71-09-08-354-016.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 12/09/2014 $52,000 2,200 45,800 48,000 0.9231 0.0394

71-09-08-380-010.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 01/16/2015 $50,000 2,200 56,100 58,300 1.1660 0.2035

71-09-18-229-020.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 01/21/2015 $59,500 2,400 62,000 64,400 1.0824 0.1199

71-09-17-230-003.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/04/2015 $75,900 2,300 71,500 73,800 0.9723 0.0098

71-09-17-176-008.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/04/2015 $78,500 2,900 71,800 74,700 0.9516 0.0109

71-09-17-153-009.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/13/2015 $44,500 2,500 59,000 61,500 1.3820 0.4195

71-09-08-381-014.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/13/2015 $44,500 1,900 67,000 68,900 1.5483 0.5858

71-09-17-127-010.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/19/2015 $94,500 2,500 78,300 80,800 0.8550 0.1075

71-09-17-280-020.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 02/26/2015 $145,000 4,500 182,500 187,000 1.2897 0.3272

71-09-08-276-022.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 05/01/2014 $60,000 16,700 66,600 83,300 1.3883 0.4258

71-09-08-229-004.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 05/07/2014 $100,000 14,900 68,900 83,800 0.8380 0.1245

71-09-08-279-021.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 06/18/2014 $85,000 9,600 43,200 52,800 0.6212 0.3413

71-09-08-227-002.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 06/19/2014 $106,000 18,000 91,400 109,400 1.0321 0.0696

71-09-08-277-011.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 07/24/2014 $75,000 26,200 62,800 89,000 1.1867 0.2242

71-09-08-231-014.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 09/05/2014 $93,890 16,500 50,100 66,600 0.7093 0.2532

71-09-08-229-015.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 12/16/2014 $133,000 16,100 73,300 89,400 0.6722 0.2903

71-09-08-276-016.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 01/26/2015 $110,000 16,700 101,000 117,700 1.0700 0.1075

71-09-08-278-001.000-026 Portage 7126303 510 026 01/28/2015 $111,765 9,900 88,600 98,500 0.8813 0.0812

71-09-08-278-005.000-026 Portage 7126304 510 026 07/11/2014 $110,000 10,700 97,300 108,000 0.9818 0.0193

71-09-08-107-011.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 04/21/2014 $124,000 17,900 120,900 138,800 1.1194 0.1569

71-09-08-104-009.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 06/19/2014 $86,000 12,800 89,100 101,900 1.1849 0.2224

71-09-08-102-002.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 07/15/2014 $92,500 12,500 79,700 92,200 0.9968 0.0343

71-09-08-104-001.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 09/08/2014 $77,500 11,300 72,400 83,700 1.0800 0.1175

71-09-08-151-004.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 09/24/2014 $78,000 16,200 68,700 84,900 1.0885 0.1260

71-09-08-107-003.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 09/25/2014 $100,000 10,800 92,300 103,100 1.0310 0.0685

71-09-08-156-009.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 11/18/2014 $64,000 14,700 58,600 73,300 1.1453 0.1828

71-09-08-151-009.000-026 Portage 7126307 510 026 01/14/2015 $68,000 10,400 64,100 74,500 1.0956 0.1331

71-09-05-405-022.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 01/08/2014 $66,500 16,200 53,700 69,900 1.0511 0.0886

71-09-05-278-021.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 04/22/2014 $94,000 16,700 70,400 87,100 0.9266 0.0359

71-09-05-228-002.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 06/04/2014 $62,500 13,200 44,600 57,800 0.9248 0.0377

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-05-451-006.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 06/09/2014 $69,000 19,300 44,300 63,600 0.9217 0.0408

71-09-05-401-009.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 06/10/2014 $64,000 16,900 42,700 59,600 0.9313 0.0313

71-09-05-404-029.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 07/14/2014 $82,000 14,500 52,200 66,700 0.8134 0.1491

71-09-05-226-023.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 07/21/2014 $52,000 14,300 40,700 55,000 1.0577 0.0952

71-09-05-203-013.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 09/05/2014 $60,000 17,500 44,500 62,000 1.0333 0.0708

71-09-05-404-037.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 09/24/2014 $86,500 14,100 51,900 66,000 0.7630 0.1995

71-09-05-429-012.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 11/13/2014 $70,000 18,700 49,900 68,600 0.9800 0.0175

71-09-05-227-023.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 12/29/2014 $77,500 12,100 52,200 64,300 0.8297 0.1328

71-09-05-405-003.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 12/30/2014 $63,000 13,800 57,200 71,000 1.1270 0.1645

71-09-05-455-023.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 01/14/2015 $61,000 14,800 41,300 56,100 0.9197 0.0428

71-09-05-253-019.000-026 Portage 7126309 510 026 02/19/2015 $55,000 18,100 58,200 76,300 1.3873 0.4248

71-09-05-154-008.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 03/19/2014 $88,900 13,300 62,200 75,500 0.8493 0.1132

71-09-05-104-018.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 04/16/2014 $94,500 13,100 48,400 61,500 0.6508 0.3117

71-09-05-102-003.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 04/25/2014 $52,000 13,200 52,800 66,000 1.2692 0.3067

71-09-05-127-039.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 06/10/2014 $86,000 15,000 61,500 76,500 0.8895 0.0730

71-09-05-156-006.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 08/01/2014 $72,000 14,200 48,600 62,800 0.8722 0.0903

71-09-05-131-013.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 08/20/2014 $78,000 12,700 61,800 74,500 0.9551 0.0074

71-09-05-151-013.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 08/21/2014 $81,500 10,900 56,800 67,700 0.8307 0.1318

71-09-05-126-042.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 09/24/2014 $68,000 13,000 58,100 71,100 1.0456 0.0831

71-09-05-127-029.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 10/28/2014 $63,900 13,300 46,400 59,700 0.9343 0.0282

71-09-05-127-002.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 12/12/2014 $64,500 12,500 48,500 61,000 0.9457 0.0168

71-09-05-105-035.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 01/23/2015 $77,000 13,000 53,900 66,900 0.8688 0.0937

71-09-05-127-010.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 02/09/2015 $62,000 10,400 47,600 58,000 0.9355 0.0270

71-09-05-178-005.000-026 Portage 7126314 510 026 02/25/2015 $90,000 20,000 66,100 86,100 0.9567 0.0058

71-09-06-226-003.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 02/13/2014 $180,000 24,500 118,700 143,200 0.7956 0.1669

71-09-06-282-006.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 03/12/2014 $85,000 18,700 85,800 104,500 1.2294 0.2669

71-09-06-256-003.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 03/19/2014 $105,000 20,100 78,300 98,400 0.9371 0.0254

71-09-06-282-004.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 04/09/2014 $135,000 18,700 92,600 111,300 0.8244 0.1381

71-09-06-279-019.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 04/17/2014 $135,000 23,000 100,200 123,200 0.9126 0.0499

71-09-06-279-023.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 06/09/2014 $74,500 20,500 62,400 82,900 1.1128 0.1503

71-09-06-230-003.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 06/30/2014 $114,900 20,600 43,600 64,200 0.5587 0.4038

71-09-06-206-004.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 05/21/2014 $180,000 48,200 90,600 138,800 0.7711 0.1914

71-09-06-206-003.000-026 Portage 7126319 500 026 05/21/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-06-228-004.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 07/09/2014 $114,500 26,500 75,500 102,000 0.8908 0.0717

71-09-06-277-011.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 07/21/2014 $150,000 25,100 134,300 159,400 1.0627 0.1002

71-09-06-278-004.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 08/18/2014 $150,000 22,200 111,600 133,800 0.8920 0.0705

71-09-06-279-028.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 10/21/2014 $104,000 21,400 94,800 116,200 1.1173 0.1548

71-09-06-255-005.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 12/18/2014 $125,500 24,900 87,200 112,100 0.8932 0.0693

71-09-06-276-006.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 12/22/2014 $167,500 25,900 96,400 122,300 0.7301 0.2324

71-09-06-229-011.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 02/27/2015 $150,000 30,200 90,700 120,900 0.8060 0.1565

71-09-06-427-009.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 01/09/2014 $138,000 41,000 112,300 153,300 1.1109 0.1484

71-09-06-451-024.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 02/12/2014 $202,000 30,900 141,800 172,700 0.8550 0.1075

71-09-06-406-019.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 03/07/2014 $104,000 28,400 67,200 95,600 0.9192 0.0433

71-09-05-351-015.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 03/07/2014 $115,000 47,800 93,000 140,800 1.2243 0.2618

71-09-05-301-002.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 04/07/2014 $113,600 31,600 81,500 113,100 0.9956 0.0331

71-09-06-404-002.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 04/09/2014 $136,000 43,800 102,800 146,600 1.0779 0.1154

71-09-06-479-012.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 04/09/2014 $203,000 30,300 121,700 152,000 0.7488 0.2137

71-09-06-451-010.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 04/14/2014 $129,900 32,000 82,200 114,200 0.8791 0.0834

71-09-06-407-016.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 04/28/2014 $118,000 20,800 98,200 119,000 1.0085 0.0460

71-09-06-456-007.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 05/08/2014 $179,900 25,200 116,500 141,700 0.7877 0.1748

71-09-06-454-011.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 06/19/2014 $179,500 26,000 131,500 157,500 0.8774 0.0851

71-09-06-457-015.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 06/26/2014 $127,500 25,200 92,700 117,900 0.9247 0.0378

71-09-06-429-017.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 06/27/2014 $187,000 43,000 133,500 176,500 0.9439 0.0186

71-09-06-402-003.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 07/30/2014 $62,900 22,700 35,400 58,100 0.9237 0.0388

71-09-06-478-012.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 08/05/2014 $115,000 26,900 88,100 115,000 1.0000 0.0375

71-09-06-405-024.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 08/05/2014 $81,000 25,500 60,000 85,500 1.0556 0.0931

71-09-06-405-040.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 08/27/2014 $127,500 36,200 83,300 119,500 0.9373 0.0252

71-09-06-428-011.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 09/18/2014 $138,000 30,500 111,000 141,500 1.0254 0.0629

71-09-05-302-015.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 09/24/2014 $230,000 66,500 177,100 243,600 1.0591 0.0966

71-09-06-431-017.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 09/24/2014 $146,000 34,300 114,100 148,400 1.0164 0.0539

71-09-06-407-006.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 11/17/2014 $95,000 29,600 56,300 85,900 0.9042 0.0583

71-09-06-477-008.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 11/17/2014 $280,000 29,700 189,400 219,100 0.7825 0.1800

71-09-06-407-003.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 11/19/2014 $70,000 29,100 58,000 87,100 1.2443 0.2818

71-09-06-431-037.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 12/22/2014 $153,500 37,800 128,900 166,700 1.0860 0.1235

71-09-06-456-006.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 12/30/2014 $148,500 25,200 112,400 137,600 0.9266 0.0359

71-09-06-428-019.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 01/26/2015 $121,000 31,300 92,200 123,500 1.0207 0.0582

71-09-06-456-014.000-026 Portage 7126322 510 026 02/13/2015 $203,000 31,200 112,000 143,200 0.7054 0.2571

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-07-201-009.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 01/24/2014 $122,000 26,900 91,500 118,400 0.9705 0.0080

71-09-07-126-003.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 03/18/2014 $85,000 26,700 68,200 94,900 1.1165 0.1540

71-09-07-128-017.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 05/28/2014 $149,000 41,100 100,600 141,700 0.9510 0.0115

71-09-07-231-008.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 09/19/2014 $110,000 48,200 86,300 134,500 1.2227 0.2602

71-09-07-231-006.000-026 Portage 7126327 500 026 09/19/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-07-231-007.000-026 Portage 7126327 500 026 09/19/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-07-229-009.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 06/12/2014 $154,900 40,100 148,000 188,100 1.2143 0.2518

71-09-07-232-015.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 06/20/2014 $89,000 26,700 81,800 108,500 1.2191 0.2566

71-09-07-127-019.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 07/16/2014 $108,000 27,900 75,100 103,000 0.9537 0.0088

71-09-07-227-003.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 07/17/2014 $130,000 52,300 83,800 136,100 1.0469 0.0844

71-09-07-227-009.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 10/07/2014 $91,900 48,200 67,100 115,300 1.2546 0.2921

71-09-07-227-008.000-026 Portage 7126327 500 026 10/07/2014 $0 0 0

71-09-07-278-010.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 08/13/2014 $110,000 34,000 78,700 112,700 1.0245 0.0620

71-09-07-232-005.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 09/02/2014 $102,000 26,700 89,700 116,400 1.1412 0.1787

71-09-07-230-006.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 10/06/2014 $72,000 25,400 49,200 74,600 1.0361 0.0736

71-09-07-201-001.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 10/30/2014 $137,400 34,000 84,200 118,200 0.8603 0.1022

71-09-07-129-012.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 12/23/2014 $215,000 41,600 142,700 184,300 0.8572 0.1053

71-09-07-277-003.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 01/25/2015 $104,000 33,700 74,200 107,900 1.0375 0.0750

71-09-07-202-011.000-026 Portage 7126326 510 026 01/28/2015 $165,900 29,900 112,700 142,600 0.8596 0.1029

71-09-07-180-005.000-026 Portage 7126331 510 026 04/09/2014 $205,000 51,700 158,200 209,900 1.0239 0.0614

71-09-07-178-003.000-026 Portage 7126331 510 026 05/19/2014 $237,500 62,000 200,100 262,100 1.1036 0.1411

71-09-07-251-001.000-026 Portage 7126331 510 026 08/27/2014 $272,500 61,900 138,400 200,300 0.7350 0.2275

71-09-07-253-006.000-026 Portage 7126331 510 026 09/12/2014 $285,000 56,900 188,400 245,300 0.8607 0.1018

71-09-07-401-015.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 03/26/2014 $224,900 41,100 169,900 211,000 0.9382 0.0243

71-09-07-401-011.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 04/17/2014 $186,000 56,000 128,800 184,800 0.9935 0.0310

71-09-07-156-001.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 05/07/2014 $168,000 47,400 130,500 177,900 1.0589 0.0964

71-09-07-179-015.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 05/12/2014 $300,000 42,300 209,500 251,800 0.8393 0.1232

71-09-07-401-002.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 09/04/2014 $249,900 47,700 151,800 199,500 0.7983 0.1642

71-09-07-180-013.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 12/31/2014 $290,000 93,000 210,800 303,800 1.0476 0.0851

71-09-07-153-012.000-026 Portage 7126333 510 026 02/26/2015 $180,000 56,400 148,400 204,800 1.1378 0.1753

71-09-07-452-014.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 01/22/2014 $156,000 31,700 125,900 157,600 1.0103 0.0478

71-09-07-451-029.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 01/23/2014 $150,000 50,300 100,500 150,800 1.0053 0.0428

71-09-07-304-017.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 02/19/2014 $137,500 27,000 85,600 112,600 0.8189 0.1436

71-09-07-326-032.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 03/14/2014 $150,000 27,700 80,700 108,400 0.7227 0.2398

71-09-07-326-030.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 03/17/2014 $143,000 30,800 111,200 142,000 0.9930 0.0305

71-09-07-304-015.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 03/18/2014 $109,000 27,000 78,800 105,800 0.9706 0.0081

71-09-07-328-010.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 04/01/2014 $165,000 25,900 86,600 112,500 0.6818 0.2807

71-09-07-376-004.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/02/2014 $82,000 24,300 60,000 84,300 1.0280 0.0655

71-09-07-326-024.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/07/2014 $157,500 28,300 116,400 144,700 0.9187 0.0438

71-09-07-329-007.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/09/2014 $150,000 25,600 103,800 129,400 0.8627 0.0998

71-09-07-382-015.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/14/2014 $117,500 30,500 89,700 120,200 1.0230 0.0605

71-09-07-302-014.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/19/2014 $122,500 24,600 80,400 105,000 0.8571 0.1054

71-09-07-327-050.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/22/2014 $139,500 29,800 86,000 115,800 0.8301 0.1324

71-09-07-301-010.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/22/2014 $152,900 29,200 103,400 132,600 0.8672 0.0953

71-09-07-351-036.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 05/28/2014 $102,900 23,800 69,500 93,300 0.9067 0.0558

71-09-07-329-026.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 06/06/2014 $97,000 27,300 67,800 95,100 0.9804 0.0179

71-09-07-328-025.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 06/12/2014 $107,000 32,400 99,700 132,100 1.2346 0.2721

71-09-07-326-022.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 06/20/2014 $179,900 35,500 149,600 185,100 1.0289 0.0664

71-09-07-405-001.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 06/25/2014 $150,000 68,000 108,600 176,600 1.1773 0.2148

71-09-07-327-014.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 07/02/2014 $125,000 28,000 76,800 104,800 0.8384 0.1241

71-09-07-328-033.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 07/09/2014 $131,000 28,600 94,100 122,700 0.9366 0.0259

71-09-07-377-004.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 07/17/2014 $116,500 24,300 83,200 107,500 0.9227 0.0398

71-09-07-156-023.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 08/04/2014 $133,000 29,800 82,000 111,800 0.8406 0.1219

71-09-07-329-028.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 08/07/2014 $156,000 36,700 71,500 108,200 0.6936 0.2689

71-09-07-382-030.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 08/14/2014 $65,000 25,000 54,700 79,700 1.2262 0.2637

71-09-07-451-019.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 08/20/2014 $175,650 35,800 112,300 148,100 0.8432 0.1193

71-09-07-405-021.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 09/02/2014 $100,000 35,300 68,100 103,400 1.0340 0.0715

71-09-07-327-051.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 09/02/2014 $87,000 29,800 81,200 111,000 1.2759 0.3134

71-09-07-328-050.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 09/11/2014 $115,000 33,400 83,800 117,200 1.0191 0.0566

71-09-07-329-024.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 09/22/2014 $131,000 31,400 68,900 100,300 0.7656 0.1969

71-09-07-401-021.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 10/07/2014 $150,300 31,500 113,600 145,100 0.9654 0.0029

71-09-07-401-039.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 10/14/2014 $140,000 26,700 65,300 92,000 0.6571 0.3054

71-09-07-304-010.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 10/17/2014 $117,000 27,000 117,700 144,700 1.2368 0.2743

71-09-07-451-022.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 12/05/2014 $140,000 35,400 91,700 127,100 0.9079 0.0546

71-09-07-377-002.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 12/18/2014 $75,000 24,300 68,200 92,500 1.2333 0.2708

71-09-07-351-038.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 12/29/2014 $91,608 29,100 70,600 99,700 1.0883 0.1258

71-09-07-405-017.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 02/16/2015 $171,000 54,200 112,600 166,800 0.9754 0.0129

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-09-07-377-008.000-026 Portage 7126334 510 026 02/26/2015 $95,000 24,600 64,600 89,200 0.9389 0.0236

71-09-06-386-015.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 03/13/2014 $94,000 4,500 65,300 69,800 0.7426 0.2199

71-09-06-330-018.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 04/08/2014 $50,000 3,600 52,800 56,400 1.1280 0.1655

71-09-06-385-010.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 06/23/2014 $128,000 4,200 121,600 125,800 0.9828 0.0203

71-09-06-386-019.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 07/03/2014 $106,500 4,500 98,500 103,000 0.9671 0.0046

71-09-06-302-013.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 08/08/2014 $25,000 4,100 27,700 31,800 1.2720 0.3095

71-09-06-305-021.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 08/19/2014 $39,900 3,600 48,600 52,200 1.3083 0.3458

71-09-06-379-020.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 08/26/2014 $89,500 4,400 53,000 57,400 0.6413 0.3212

71-09-06-302-005.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 12/24/2014 $55,950 4,200 39,000 43,200 0.7721 0.1904

71-09-07-102-012.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 01/23/2015 $70,000 4,200 75,100 79,300 1.1329 0.1704

71-09-06-327-018.000-026 Portage 7126338 510 026 02/23/2015 $115,000 5,100 111,300 116,400 1.0122 0.0497

71-09-06-101-208.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 06/27/2014 $244,164 5,700 230,200 235,900 0.9662 0.0037

71-09-06-101-211.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 06/27/2014 $244,247 5,700 228,800 234,500 0.9601 0.0024

71-09-06-101-218.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 06/30/2014 $241,408 5,700 235,800 241,500 1.0004 0.0379

71-09-06-101-177.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/01/2014 $275,000 3,400 224,800 228,200 0.8298 0.1327

71-09-06-101-219.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/03/2014 $235,869 5,700 227,100 232,800 0.9870 0.0245

71-09-06-101-216.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/08/2014 $238,884 5,700 235,800 241,500 1.0110 0.0485

71-09-06-101-209.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/09/2014 $251,148 5,700 228,800 234,500 0.9337 0.0288

71-09-06-101-207.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/09/2014 $259,132 5,700 227,100 232,800 0.8984 0.0641

71-09-06-101-217.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/11/2014 $242,027 5,700 227,100 232,800 0.9619 0.0006

71-09-06-101-205.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/18/2014 $253,804 5,700 228,800 234,500 0.9239 0.0386

71-09-06-101-210.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $239,077 5,700 230,200 235,900 0.9867 0.0242

71-09-06-101-214.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $240,384 5,700 230,200 235,900 0.9813 0.0188

71-09-06-101-215.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $240,665 5,700 228,800 234,500 0.9744 0.0119

71-09-06-101-213.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/25/2014 $244,748 5,700 228,800 234,500 0.9581 0.0044

71-09-06-101-212.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/30/2014 $239,658 5,700 230,200 235,900 0.9843 0.0218

71-09-06-101-204.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/31/2014 $256,652 5,700 235,800 241,500 0.9410 0.0215

71-09-06-101-206.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 07/31/2014 $250,418 5,700 237,500 243,200 0.9712 0.0087

71-09-06-101-182.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 08/15/2014 $265,000 3,400 233,400 236,800 0.8936 0.0689

71-09-06-101-071.000-026 Portage 7126345 550 026 10/30/2014 $274,000 3,000 234,900 237,900 0.8682 0.0943

71-08-12-279-020.000-026 Portage 7126346 510 026 05/02/2014 $203,000 8,500 181,700 190,200 0.9369 0.0256

71-08-12-280-009.000-026 Portage 7126346 510 026 05/15/2014 $220,000 8,100 210,000 218,100 0.9914 0.0289

71-09-06-103-008.000-026 Portage 7126346 510 026 06/11/2014 $290,987 7,700 243,300 251,000 0.8626 0.0999

71-09-06-153-009.000-026 Portage 7126346 510 026 07/09/2014 $164,400 9,600 153,200 162,800 0.9903 0.0278

71-09-06-152-023.000-026 Portage 7126346 510 026 11/17/2014 $200,300 9,900 179,600 189,500 0.9461 0.0164

71-08-01-186-006.000-026 Portage 7126347 510 026 02/04/2014 $159,000 11,200 88,600 99,800 0.6277 0.3348

71-08-01-426-005.000-026 Portage 7126347 510 026 04/28/2014 $87,900 3,900 54,600 58,500 0.6655 0.2970

71-08-01-406-010.000-026 Portage 7126347 510 026 06/05/2014 $97,000 4,600 77,600 82,200 0.8474 0.1151

71-08-01-259-020.000-026 Portage 7126347 510 026 02/10/2015 $105,000 4,700 71,600 76,300 0.7267 0.2358

71-08-01-401-027.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 04/16/2014 $132,000 10,900 100,200 111,100 0.8417 0.1208

71-08-01-182-007.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 05/30/2014 $35,000 6,300 28,400 34,700 0.9914 0.0289

71-08-01-405-015.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 06/11/2014 $128,500 11,000 139,200 150,200 1.1689 0.2064

71-08-01-205-009.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 06/12/2014 $85,100 7,700 44,100 51,800 0.6087 0.3538

71-09-06-127-016.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 07/09/2014 $76,950 8,500 59,400 67,900 0.8824 0.0801

71-09-06-155-022.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 07/10/2014 $72,000 9,000 36,400 45,400 0.6306 0.3319

71-08-01-258-009.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 08/28/2014 $25,000 3,900 22,600 26,500 1.0600 0.0975

71-08-01-256-020.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 10/21/2014 $70,000 5,100 63,900 69,000 0.9857 0.0232

71-08-01-479-021.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 11/06/2014 $33,500 4,300 30,100 34,400 1.0269 0.0644

71-08-01-405-003.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 12/16/2014 $120,000 8,900 134,500 143,400 1.1950 0.2325

71-08-11-229-014.000-026 Portage 7126364 510 026 05/13/2014 $100,000 6,500 118,300 124,800 1.2480 0.2855

71-08-12-406-014.000-026 Portage 7126364 510 026 09/10/2014 $80,000 4,500 82,600 87,100 1.0888 0.1263

71-08-12-307-018.000-026 Portage 7126364 510 026 09/22/2014 $59,660 2,600 70,300 72,900 1.2219 0.2594

71-08-11-206-006.000-026 Portage 7126364 510 026 01/13/2015 $117,000 3,600 119,900 123,500 1.0556 0.0931

71-08-11-255-032.000-026 Portage 7126364 510 026 02/04/2015 $95,000 6,000 70,900 76,900 0.8095 0.1530

71-08-02-277-014.000-026 Portage 7126373 510 026 04/24/2014 $151,000 27,300 98,400 125,700 0.8325 0.1300

71-08-02-435-009.000-026 Portage 7126373 510 026 06/25/2014 $92,000 24,700 87,500 112,200 1.2196 0.2571

71-08-02-435-010.000-026 Portage 7126373 510 026 07/10/2014 $105,000 29,900 71,300 101,200 0.9638 0.0013

71-08-02-277-002.000-026 Portage 7126373 510 026 07/16/2014 $152,000 19,000 92,100 111,100 0.7309 0.2316

71-08-02-429-007.000-026 Portage 7126373 510 026 09/22/2014 $104,500 26,400 84,300 110,700 1.0593 0.0968

71-08-02-204-004.000-026 Portage 7126374 510 026 07/23/2014 $62,000 16,200 56,300 72,500 1.1694 0.2069

71-08-02-205-003.000-026 Portage 7126374 510 026 11/03/2014 $95,000 19,900 63,900 83,800 0.8821 0.0804

71-08-02-261-010.000-026 Portage 7126375 510 026 07/15/2014 $93,500 9,700 65,100 74,800 0.8000 0.1625

71-08-01-327-035.000-026 Portage 7126375 510 026 09/15/2014 $93,000 8,200 58,000 66,200 0.7118 0.2507

71-08-01-327-045.000-026 Portage 7126375 510 026 01/16/2015 $43,000 8,200 46,000 54,200 1.2605 0.2980

71-08-02-132-004.000-026 Portage 7126376 510 026 08/04/2014 $75,000 8,900 74,100 83,000 1.1067 0.1442

71-08-01-130-011.000-026 Portage 7126380 510 026 05/27/2014 $260,000 35,600 158,200 193,800 0.7454 0.2171

71-08-01-177-012.000-026 Portage 7126380 510 026 07/03/2014 $120,000 20,300 128,800 149,100 1.2425 0.2800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-08-01-178-002.000-026 Portage 7126380 510 026 08/20/2014 $107,000 25,200 111,700 136,900 1.2794 0.3169

71-08-01-126-001.000-026 Portage 7126380 510 026 09/12/2014 $285,000 24,300 255,100 279,400 0.9804 0.0179

71-08-01-133-005.000-026 Portage 7126380 510 026 12/12/2014 $165,000 28,900 137,600 166,500 1.0091 0.0466

71-08-02-453-004.000-026 Portage 7126384 510 026 04/15/2014 $70,000 2,700 94,700 97,400 1.3914 0.4289

71-08-11-134-011.000-026 Portage 7126384 510 026 11/03/2014 $64,900 5,400 50,000 55,400 0.8536 0.1089

71-08-11-134-012.000-026 Portage 7126385 500 026 11/03/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-11-134-015.000-026 Portage 7126385 500 026 11/03/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-11-201-008.000-026 Portage 7126384 510 026 06/10/2014 $47,100 1,700 56,000 57,700 1.2251 0.2626

71-08-02-259-004.000-026 Portage 7126384 510 026 06/26/2014 $38,900 1,600 38,100 39,700 1.0206 0.0581

71-08-11-203-014.000-026 Portage 7126387 520 026 05/01/2014 $74,500 2,700 96,900 99,600 1.3369 0.3744

71-08-02-184-014.000-026 Portage 7126387 510 026 05/20/2014 $62,500 1,500 63,600 65,100 1.0416 0.0791

71-08-02-452-020.000-026 Portage 7126387 510 026 05/29/2014 $78,500 2,600 74,900 77,500 0.9873 0.0248

71-08-02-184-012.000-026 Portage 7126387 510 026 08/19/2014 $62,000 1,500 54,000 55,500 0.8952 0.0673

71-08-02-453-021.000-026 Portage 7126389 510 026 06/12/2014 $175,727 5,400 77,000 82,400 0.4689 0.4936

71-08-02-453-022.000-026 Portage 7126385 500 026 06/12/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-03-304-008.000-026 Portage 7126391 510 026 05/02/2014 $36,000 2,900 33,100 36,000 1.0000 0.0375

71-08-11-177-022.000-026 Portage 7126391 510 026 05/21/2014 $40,900 2,700 27,900 30,600 0.7482 0.2143

71-08-11-176-055.000-026 Portage 7126391 510 026 08/14/2014 $80,000 2,800 50,300 53,100 0.6638 0.2988

71-08-02-231-007.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 01/08/2014 $64,000 15,300 60,700 76,000 1.1875 0.2250

71-08-02-232-031.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 03/12/2014 $80,000 15,300 80,600 95,900 1.1988 0.2363

71-08-01-152-032.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 03/25/2014 $130,000 17,200 107,600 124,800 0.9600 0.0025

71-08-01-109-007.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 05/13/2014 $88,500 17,200 68,100 85,300 0.9638 0.0013

71-08-01-181-007.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 06/27/2014 $144,000 44,200 89,000 133,200 0.9250 0.0375

71-08-01-181-006.000-026 Portage 7126401 500 026 06/27/2014 $0 0 0

71-08-01-109-010.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 05/28/2014 $134,900 15,300 83,300 98,600 0.7309 0.2316

71-08-01-110-004.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 06/02/2014 $109,900 25,400 83,800 109,200 0.9936 0.0311

71-08-01-105-004.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 06/09/2014 $97,000 15,300 70,100 85,400 0.8804 0.0821

71-08-02-202-001.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 06/13/2014 $88,000 18,700 53,500 72,200 0.8205 0.1420

71-08-02-226-020.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 06/20/2014 $110,000 16,100 77,900 94,000 0.8545 0.1080

71-08-01-110-023.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 08/08/2014 $179,900 24,300 95,400 119,700 0.6654 0.2971

71-08-01-109-014.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 08/28/2014 $139,900 21,800 90,200 112,000 0.8006 0.1619

71-08-01-109-024.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 09/09/2014 $140,000 19,100 94,000 113,100 0.8079 0.1546

71-08-02-233-008.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 10/21/2014 $130,000 15,300 96,200 111,500 0.8577 0.1048

71-08-01-108-004.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 12/10/2014 $122,000 19,800 77,900 97,700 0.8008 0.1617

71-08-02-231-024.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 12/12/2014 $60,000 15,300 38,600 53,900 0.8983 0.0642

71-08-02-206-008.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 12/30/2014 $100,000 38,800 83,900 122,700 1.2270 0.2645

71-08-02-228-005.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 01/21/2015 $259,000 52,700 184,600 237,300 0.9162 0.0463

71-03-34-428-013.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 03/20/2014 $91,200 7,000 84,100 91,100 0.9989 0.0364

71-08-02-226-019.000-026 Portage 7126400 510 026 10/09/2014 $119,500 50,300 65,300 115,600 0.9674 0.0049

71-08-02-226-018.000-026 Portage 7126401 500 026 10/09/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-34-432-014.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 03/26/2014 $60,000 8,400 85,600 94,000 1.5667 0.6042

71-03-34-432-008.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 04/03/2014 $30,000 8,400 38,900 47,300 1.5767 0.6142

71-03-34-429-016.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 08/08/2014 $112,000 8,400 129,600 138,000 1.2321 0.2696

71-03-35-301-011.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 08/21/2014 $252,500 13,400 197,800 211,200 0.8364 0.1261

71-03-35-304-005.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 11/03/2014 $147,500 8,300 126,600 134,900 0.9146 0.0479

71-03-34-433-018.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 11/13/2014 $119,500 8,500 99,400 107,900 0.9029 0.0596

71-03-35-305-009.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 12/12/2014 $162,000 10,900 124,400 135,300 0.8352 0.1273

71-03-34-429-006.000-026 Portage 7126406 510 026 01/20/2015 $109,900 8,400 119,300 127,700 1.1620 0.1995

71-03-35-179-031.000-026 Portage 7126413 510 026 06/23/2014 $75,000 8,400 59,200 67,600 0.9013 0.0612

71-03-35-180-002.000-026 Portage 7126413 510 026 12/31/2014 $67,040 8,200 54,100 62,300 0.9293 0.0332

71-03-35-179-016.000-026 Portage 7126413 510 026 01/26/2015 $61,000 8,200 47,700 55,900 0.9164 0.0461

71-03-35-276-013.000-026 Portage 7126413 510 026 02/27/2015 $98,000 25,600 67,900 93,500 0.9541 0.0084

71-03-35-155-017.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 05/22/2014 $61,000 10,500 45,500 56,000 0.9180 0.0445

71-03-34-230-034.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 08/14/2014 $68,000 24,200 55,200 79,400 1.1676 0.2051

71-03-34-230-033.000-026 Portage 7126418 500 026 08/14/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-35-106-022.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 07/07/2014 $81,600 11,500 72,900 84,400 1.0343 0.0718

71-03-35-153-057.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 07/31/2014 $98,900 10,500 90,900 101,400 1.0253 0.0628

71-03-35-152-033.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 09/18/2014 $53,000 16,200 56,100 72,300 1.3642 0.4017

71-03-35-103-006.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 02/14/2014 $101,000 22,200 79,100 101,300 1.0030 0.0405

71-03-35-103-005.000-026 Portage 7126418 500 026 02/14/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-35-156-009.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 09/23/2014 $92,000 19,000 80,000 99,000 1.0761 0.1136

71-03-34-230-032.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 09/30/2014 $98,000 19,000 80,400 99,400 1.0143 0.0518

71-03-35-176-019.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 10/09/2014 $67,500 10,900 37,000 47,900 0.7096 0.2529

71-03-35-152-022.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 07/18/2014 $104,000 12,100 76,100 88,200 0.8481 0.1144

71-03-35-152-023.000-026 Portage 7126423 500 026 07/18/2014 $0 0 0

71-03-35-176-048.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 12/30/2014 $110,000 10,900 71,500 82,400 0.7491 0.2134

71-03-35-153-065.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 01/20/2015 $84,500 16,500 47,400 63,900 0.7562 0.2063

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-03-35-153-050.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 01/20/2015 $80,500 10,500 62,400 72,900 0.9056 0.0569

71-03-35-103-003.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 02/10/2015 $85,500 10,500 43,400 53,900 0.6304 0.3321

71-03-35-101-019.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 02/20/2015 $40,000 10,500 47,100 57,600 1.4400 0.4775

71-03-35-153-044.000-026 Portage 7126417 510 026 02/26/2015 $66,000 10,500 49,600 60,100 0.9106 0.0519

71-03-26-355-027.000-026 Portage 7126419 510 026 04/22/2014 $67,500 25,900 44,200 70,100 1.0385 0.0760

71-03-34-478-021.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 03/24/2014 $20,000 800 20,000 20,800 1.0400 0.0775

71-03-34-426-004.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 03/31/2014 $35,000 800 29,900 30,700 0.8771 0.0854

71-03-35-351-003.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 05/23/2014 $42,000 900 24,300 25,200 0.6000 0.3625

71-08-03-278-006.000-026 Portage 7126589 510 026 12/22/2014 42,500$ 800 50,200 51,000 1.2000 0.2375

71-09-08-330-017.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 8/27/2014 60,000$ 2,100 55,000 57,100 0.9517 0.0108

71-08-24-204-014.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 2/26/2014 49,000$ 4,000 60,300 64,300 1.3122 0.3497

71-08-02-434-008.000-026 Portage 7126374 510 026 2/27/2015 104,000$ 17,100 96,200 113,300 1.0894 0.1269

71-08-09-203-017.000-026 Portage 7126219 510 026 2/20/2015 21,000$ 900 16,200 17,100 0.8143 0.1482

71-08-24-204-013.000-026 Portage 7126262 510 026 2/27/2015 72,900$ 4,000 60,600 64,600 0.8861 0.0764

71-09-17-208-010.000-026 Portage 7126296 510 026 2/26/2015 58,500$ 2,300 51,200 53,500 0.9145 0.0480

71-08-01-227-018.000-026 Portage 7126348 510 026 2/28/2015 65,000$ 6,900 34,100 41,000 0.6308 0.3317

71-08-08-202-008.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 2/27/2015 76,000$ 6,200 91,500 97,700 1.2855 0.3230

71-08-03-227-011.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 07/09/2014 $23,000 800 23,800 24,600 1.0696 0.1071

71-03-35-352-005.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 07/14/2014 $23,000 800 23,700 24,500 1.0652 0.1027

71-03-34-476-029.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 08/06/2014 $22,000 800 22,400 23,200 1.0545 0.0920

71-03-34-226-006.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 08/22/2014 $50,000 800 38,900 39,700 0.7940 0.1685

71-03-34-426-029.000-026 Portage 7126422 510 026 11/17/2014 $36,500 800 34,300 35,100 0.9616 0.0009

71-08-03-182-003.000-026 Portage 7126425 510 026 10/09/2014 $25,000 800 24,300 25,100 1.0040 0.0415

71-08-01-326-005.000-026 Portage 7126431 551 026 08/29/2014 $190,000 8,400 120,500 128,900 0.6784 0.2841

71-09-05-254-029.000-026 Portage 7126432 550 026 11/17/2014 $138,000 1,500 97,200 98,700 0.7152 0.2473

71-09-05-254-028.000-026 Portage 7126432 550 026 12/30/2014 $150,000 2,500 105,400 107,900 0.7193 0.2432

71-09-08-427-007.000-026 Portage 7126433 551 026 10/20/2014 $96,500 7,100 63,200 70,300 0.7285 0.2340

71-09-08-427-014.000-026 Portage 7126433 551 026 12/09/2014 $75,000 7,100 74,300 81,400 1.0853 0.1228

71-09-08-427-005.000-026 Portage 7126433 551 026 12/16/2014 $67,500 7,100 56,700 63,800 0.9452 0.0173

71-09-19-351-019.000-026 Portage 7126434 551 026 05/21/2014 $220,000 22,900 209,200 232,100 1.0550 0.0925

71-03-35-477-008.000-026 Portage 7126435 551 026 01/17/2014 $185,000 15,700 172,000 187,700 1.0146 0.0521

71-03-35-452-110.000-026 Portage 7126437 551 026 05/05/2014 $110,000 0 111,700 111,700 1.0155 0.0530

71-08-04-126-017.000-026 Portage 7126215 510 026 1/9/2015 $36,000 1,700 51,600 53,300 1.4806 0.5181

71-08-08-252-024.000-026 Portage 7126209 510 026 10/9/2014 $43,500 5,400 58,400 63,800 1.4667 0.5042

71-09-06-253-002.000-026 Portage 7126318 510 026 9/15/2014 $158,000 18,200 77,600 95,800 0.6063 0.3562

71-03-35-452-029.000-026 Portage 7126437 551 026 08/29/2014 $110,000 0 113,400 113,400 1.0309 0.0684

71-03-35-452-040.000-026 Portage 7126438 551 026 01/30/2014 $84,000 0 87,500 87,500 1.0417 0.0792

71-03-35-452-054.000-026 Portage 7126438 551 026 04/11/2014 $67,500 0 88,400 88,400 1.3096 0.3471

71-03-35-452-003.000-026 Portage 7126438 551 026 07/30/2014 $55,000 0 75,500 75,500 1.3727 0.4102

71-03-35-452-034.000-026 Portage 7126438 551 026 08/27/2014 $86,000 0 94,400 94,400 1.0977 0.1352

71-03-35-452-035.000-026 Portage 7126438 551 026 09/03/2014 $84,750 0 94,400 94,400 1.1139 0.1514

71-03-35-477-034.000-026 Portage 7126441 551 026 06/09/2014 $120,000 12,700 102,800 115,500 0.9625 0.0000

$61,863,607 58,667,400 583

Mean 0.9813

Median 0.9625

Wtd Mean 0.9483

COD 14.3746

PRD 1.0347

UNION TOWNSHIP

71-13-27-229-001.000-027 Union 7127009 510 027 03/16/2014 $84,000 5,900 69,700 75,600 0.9000 0.0000

71-13-26-102-013.000-027 Union 7127009 510 027 05/07/2014 $135,600 4,300 66,800 71,100 0.5243 0.3757

71-13-26-176-002.000-027 Union 7127009 511 027 07/24/2014 $124,500 29,300 61,500 90,800 0.7293 0.1707

71-13-27-229-008.000-027 Union 7127009 510 027 08/08/2014 $89,900 5,800 65,400 71,200 0.7920 0.1080

71-18-02-378-001.000-027 Union 7127011 510 027 06/13/2014 $98,000 27,100 88,900 116,000 1.1837 0.2837

71-18-11-202-001.000-027 Union 7127012 510 027 08/06/2014 $173,500 26,400 137,700 164,100 0.9458 0.0458

71-13-33-300-004.000-027 Union 7127015 510 027 09/05/2014 $300,000 30,700 202,100 232,800 0.7760 0.1240

71-13-34-201-033.000-028 Union 7128010 510 028 07/02/2014 $282,400 28,600 226,600 255,200 0.9037 0.0037

71-13-34-201-019.000-028 Union 7128010 510 028 12/22/2014 $212,912 24,000 158,000 182,000 0.8548 0.0452

71-13-34-201-059.000-028 Union 7128010 510 028 02/24/2015 $229,900 24,600 143,200 167,800 0.7299 0.1701

71-13-35-354-005.000-028 Union 7128011 510 028 07/22/2014 $80,000 21,600 59,100 80,700 1.0088 0.1088

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-13-35-354-010.000-028 Union 7128013 500 028 07/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-13-35-353-010.000-028 Union 7128011 510 028 07/25/2014 $51,000 6,500 45,600 52,100 1.0216 0.1216

71-13-35-304-002.000-028 Union 7128011 510 028 01/21/2015 $79,900 9,000 69,100 78,100 0.9775 0.0775

$1,941,612 1,637,500 13

Mean 0.8729

Median 0.9000

Wtd Mean 0.8434

COD 13.9712

PRD 1.0350

WARREN TOWNSHIP

71-02-26-326-007.000-029 Warren 7129002 510 029 12/31/2014 $92,000 15,000 97,700 112,700 1.2250 0.2738

71-02-14-326-010.000-029 Warren 7129013 510 029 08/14/2014 $247,000 25,200 203,200 228,400 0.9247 0.0265

71-02-14-403-013.000-029 Warren 7129013 510 029 08/21/2014 $250,000 24,700 198,500 223,200 0.8928 0.0584

71-02-14-326-012.000-029 Warren 7129013 510 029 02/09/2015 $235,000 28,700 209,500 238,200 1.0136 0.0625

71-02-14-476-005.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 04/17/2014 $305,000 24,500 290,900 315,400 1.0341 0.0829

71-02-14-479-012.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 07/24/2014 $279,500 26,400 244,800 271,200 0.9703 0.0191

71-02-14-429-007.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 07/29/2014 $169,013 22,400 206,600 229,000 1.3549 0.4038

71-02-14-477-005.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 08/25/2014 $255,000 21,400 219,000 240,400 0.9427 0.0084

71-02-14-476-002.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 11/17/2014 $340,000 26,600 315,300 341,900 1.0056 0.0544

71-02-14-479-003.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 12/03/2014 $305,000 25,500 247,600 273,100 0.8954 0.0558

71-02-14-476-022.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 12/11/2014 $288,100 37,700 251,200 288,900 1.0028 0.0516

71-02-14-477-004.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 02/11/2015 $240,000 20,400 212,700 233,100 0.9713 0.0201

71-02-24-352-040.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 02/05/2014 $120,000 21,900 122,600 144,500 1.2042 0.2530

71-02-24-376-011.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 02/07/2014 $152,500 18,400 122,800 141,200 0.9259 0.0253

71-02-24-353-024.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 02/19/2014 $119,500 15,600 99,900 115,500 0.9665 0.0154

71-02-24-378-008.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 07/10/2014 $210,000 16,700 165,200 181,900 0.8662 0.0850

71-02-24-376-015.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 09/03/2014 $159,900 16,600 111,500 128,100 0.8011 0.1500

71-02-24-353-005.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 11/06/2014 $162,500 16,700 143,700 160,400 0.9871 0.0359

71-02-24-352-023.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 11/19/2014 $175,000 15,600 143,200 158,800 0.9074 0.0437

71-02-24-352-031.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 12/05/2014 $161,900 16,700 113,700 130,400 0.8054 0.1457

71-02-24-301-007.000-029 Warren 7129016 510 029 12/29/2014 $144,900 16,200 113,200 129,400 0.8930 0.0581

71-02-26-352-002.000-029 Warren 7129017 510 029 08/08/2014 $138,900 16,800 111,200 128,000 0.9215 0.0296

71-02-26-351-002.000-029 Warren 7129017 510 029 02/18/2015 $142,900 35,000 103,000 138,000 0.9657 0.0145

71-02-26-351-001.000-029 Warren 7129067 500 029 02/18/2015 $0 0 0

71-02-26-351-018.000-029 Warren 7129017 510 029 09/24/2014 $176,877 17,100 124,100 141,200 0.7983 0.1529

71-02-35-279-027.000-029 Warren 7129018 510 029 05/09/2014 $48,000 8,300 22,100 30,400 0.6333 0.3178

71-02-35-279-032.000-029 Warren 7129018 510 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 13,000 68,300 81,300 0.5420 0.4092

71-02-35-279-034.000-029 Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-02-35-279-031.000-029 Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-02-35-279-033.000-029 Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $0 0 0

71-02-35-284-001.000-029 Warren 7129018 510 029 09/04/2014 $65,000 9,300 39,900 49,200 0.7569 0.1942

71-02-36-451-006.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 02/26/2014 $115,000 13,900 77,300 91,200 0.7930 0.1581

71-07-01-251-004.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 04/30/2014 $105,000 13,900 77,600 91,500 0.8714 0.0797

71-02-25-326-005.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 07/03/2014 $69,285 8,000 91,700 99,700 1.4390 0.4878

71-02-25-401-007.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 05/28/2014 $67,000 14,900 70,300 85,200 1.2716 0.3205

71-02-25-200-021.000-029 Warren 7129002 501 029 05/28/2014 $0 0 0

71-07-23-176-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 07/03/2014 $113,500 15,000 96,300 111,300 0.9806 0.0295

71-02-26-100-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 07/18/2014 $80,000 16,800 58,700 75,500 0.9438 0.0074

71-07-34-300-004.000-029 Warren 7129019 511 029 07/21/2014 $114,500 15,600 91,000 106,600 0.9310 0.0202

71-02-34-200-006.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 07/23/2014 $121,500 18,700 75,700 94,400 0.7770 0.1742

71-02-34-200-012.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 08/04/2014 $110,000 12,200 95,200 107,400 0.9764 0.0252

71-02-35-352-009.000-029 Warren 7129019 599 029 09/17/2014 $11,000 13,900 100 14,000 1.2727 0.3216

71-07-23-177-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 09/17/2014 $139,000 15,100 87,500 102,600 0.7381 0.2130

71-07-14-376-003.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 09/25/2014 $105,000 14,200 170,900 185,100 1.7629 0.8117

71-02-13-351-016.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 10/01/2014 $300,000 32,000 191,600 223,600 0.7453 0.2058

71-07-01-201-008.000-029 Warren 7129019 511 029 10/15/2014 $259,900 18,600 191,400 210,000 0.8080 0.1432

71-02-13-376-012.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 11/17/2014 $428,500 46,000 267,000 313,000 0.7305 0.2207

71-07-27-376-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 12/09/2014 $84,900 18,700 89,500 108,200 1.2744 0.3233

71-07-24-326-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 01/13/2015 $146,500 30,400 100,700 131,100 0.8949 0.0563

71-07-34-100-001.000-029 Warren 7129019 511 029 02/04/2015 $88,260 15,700 60,000 75,700 0.8577 0.0935

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-02-22-300-005.000-029 Warren 7129019 510 029 02/10/2015 $130,515 10,300 83,700 94,000 0.7202 0.2309

71-02-35-426-012.000-029 Warren 7129020 510 029 04/09/2014 $139,000 6,600 63,400 70,000 0.5036 0.4476

71-07-02-403-003.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 01/17/2014 $188,000 25,800 153,800 179,600 0.9553 0.0042

71-07-02-406-006.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 04/03/2014 $109,500 17,200 102,900 120,100 1.0968 0.1456

71-07-02-403-007.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 07/15/2014 $151,390 15,900 122,800 138,700 0.9162 0.0350

71-07-02-426-017.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 11/12/2014 $175,000 18,500 155,200 173,700 0.9926 0.0414

71-07-02-426-006.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 06/23/2014 $173,000 32,800 145,300 178,100 1.0295 0.0783

71-07-02-426-007.000-029 Warren 7129071 500 029 06/23/2014 $0 0 0

71-07-02-404-008.000-029 Warren 7129021 510 029 12/18/2014 $112,000 17,400 96,500 113,900 1.0170 0.0658

71-07-01-327-009.000-029 Warren 7129022 510 029 03/28/2014 $137,500 13,800 102,700 116,500 0.8473 0.1039

71-07-02-176-017.000-029 Warren 7129023 510 029 03/24/2014 $103,500 8,700 77,800 86,500 0.8357 0.1154

71-07-02-151-004.000-029 Warren 7129023 510 029 05/22/2014 $142,500 16,400 102,300 118,700 0.8330 0.1182

71-07-02-205-001.000-029 Warren 7129023 510 029 07/16/2014 $96,500 23,000 58,500 81,500 0.8446 0.1066

71-07-02-205-002.000-029 Warren 7129073 500 029 07/16/2014 $0 0 0

71-07-02-226-008.000-029 Warren 7129023 510 029 08/14/2014 $22,000 10,300 18,600 28,900 1.3136 0.3625

71-07-11-227-010.000-029 Warren 7129024 510 029 09/30/2014 $185,000 15,700 140,700 156,400 0.8454 0.1058

71-07-11-202-005.000-029 Warren 7129024 510 029 04/22/2014 $104,000 30,800 79,700 110,500 1.0625 0.1113

71-07-11-202-006.000-029 Warren 7129074 500 029 04/22/2014 $0 0 0

71-07-11-251-026.000-029 Warren 7129024 510 029 10/22/2014 $102,500 14,800 81,000 95,800 0.9346 0.0165

71-07-11-202-012.000-029 Warren 7129024 510 029 11/26/2014 $147,000 19,700 116,600 136,300 0.9272 0.0240

71-07-11-277-005.000-029 Warren 7129024 510 029 01/21/2015 $116,000 19,200 109,000 128,200 1.1052 0.1540

71-07-11-326-010.000-029 Warren 7129025 510 029 06/03/2014 $80,000 13,400 45,100 58,500 0.7313 0.2199

71-07-11-326-009.000-029 Warren 7129025 510 029 09/12/2014 $115,000 13,400 64,400 77,800 0.6765 0.2746

71-07-12-476-021.000-029 Warren 7129027 510 029 12/09/2014 $45,000 16,000 34,400 50,400 1.1200 0.1688

71-07-13-176-013.000-029 Warren 7129028 510 029 12/03/2014 $187,500 29,900 173,500 203,400 1.0848 0.1336

71-07-13-132-009.000-029 Warren 7129029 510 029 05/08/2014 $104,000 21,800 76,300 98,100 0.9433 0.0079

71-07-13-127-007.000-029 Warren 7129029 510 029 05/08/2014 $116,000 17,700 93,600 111,300 0.9595 0.0083

71-07-13-176-010.000-029 Warren 7129029 510 029 08/22/2014 $138,000 15,700 105,000 120,700 0.8746 0.0765

71-07-13-131-018.000-029 Warren 7129029 510 029 10/07/2014 $127,000 17,300 104,100 121,400 0.9559 0.0047

71-07-13-201-002.000-029 Warren 7129030 510 029 08/25/2014 $153,250 19,200 100,600 119,800 0.7817 0.1694

71-07-13-253-016.000-029 Warren 7129030 510 029 02/25/2015 $160,000 21,300 172,900 194,200 1.2138 0.2626

71-07-14-451-013.000-029 Warren 7129031 510 029 05/21/2014 $164,500 24,500 142,700 167,200 1.0164 0.0653

71-07-14-251-002.000-029 Warren 7129031 510 029 05/22/2014 $184,500 21,400 138,300 159,700 0.8656 0.0856

71-07-14-451-002.000-029 Warren 7129031 510 029 06/02/2014 $146,000 21,600 122,800 144,400 0.9890 0.0379

71-07-14-455-007.000-029 Warren 7129031 510 029 06/19/2014 $175,500 29,900 121,900 151,800 0.8650 0.0862

71-07-14-451-011.000-029 Warren 7129031 510 029 07/16/2014 $190,000 9,900 193,400 203,300 1.0700 0.1188

71-07-24-127-006.000-029 Warren 7129033 510 029 01/09/2014 $127,000 15,000 116,600 131,600 1.0362 0.0851

71-07-27-352-004.000-029 Warren 7129035 510 029 02/06/2014 $93,000 17,300 54,500 71,800 0.7720 0.1791

71-07-24-303-008.000-029 Warren 7129036 510 029 10/20/2014 $126,500 17,900 116,800 134,700 1.0648 0.1137

71-07-24-303-007.000-029 Warren 7129036 510 029 12/30/2014 $135,000 17,900 111,400 129,300 0.9578 0.0066

71-02-13-376-002.000-029 Warren 7129041 510 029 02/06/2014 $175,000 43,600 146,000 189,600 1.0834 0.1323

71-02-13-351-005.000-029 Warren 7129041 510 029 04/30/2014 $209,000 36,600 180,000 216,600 1.0364 0.0852

71-07-12-476-010.000-029 Warren 7129042 510 029 01/09/2014 $173,900 14,300 160,300 174,600 1.0040 0.0529

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-07-12-451-017.000-029 Warren 7129042 510 029 01/17/2014 $191,000 15,200 138,300 153,500 0.8037 0.1475

71-07-12-102-003.000-029 Warren 7129043 510 029 05/30/2014 $253,000 18,400 232,900 251,300 0.9933 0.0421

71-02-24-326-013.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 02/25/2014 $135,750 21,000 114,400 135,400 0.9974 0.0463

71-02-24-304-018.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 05/14/2014 $146,000 19,800 123,000 142,800 0.9781 0.0269

71-02-24-378-021.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 06/05/2014 $174,900 29,200 143,800 173,000 0.9891 0.0380

71-02-24-303-002.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 06/25/2014 $149,000 19,800 116,800 136,600 0.9168 0.0344

71-02-24-378-017.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 07/01/2014 $192,000 19,800 138,000 157,800 0.8219 0.1293

71-02-24-301-028.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 07/18/2014 $129,000 20,200 102,500 122,700 0.9512 0.0000

71-02-24-301-076.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 11/13/2014 $220,377 30,600 180,900 211,500 0.9597 0.0086

71-02-24-378-020.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 12/22/2014 $187,800 24,800 196,000 220,800 1.1757 0.2246

71-02-24-304-010.000-029 Warren 7129045 510 029 12/23/2014 $135,000 19,800 105,000 124,800 0.9244 0.0267

71-02-24-354-026.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 01/30/2014 $196,828 21,400 145,100 166,500 0.8459 0.1052

71-02-25-126-024.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 04/07/2014 $152,000 16,700 112,700 129,400 0.8513 0.0998

71-02-24-354-097.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 04/25/2014 $207,500 15,800 169,100 184,900 0.8911 0.0601

71-02-24-354-076.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 04/29/2014 $205,000 18,800 180,300 199,100 0.9712 0.0201

71-02-25-127-004.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 05/02/2014 $175,000 57,800 115,500 173,300 0.9903 0.0391

71-02-25-129-023.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 05/19/2014 $275,000 20,300 226,300 246,600 0.8967 0.0544

71-02-25-129-008.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 05/21/2014 $232,500 21,000 176,500 197,500 0.8495 0.1017

71-02-24-354-081.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 06/02/2014 $169,000 20,400 150,300 170,700 1.0101 0.0589

71-02-24-354-090.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 07/03/2014 $187,121 24,200 162,800 187,000 0.9994 0.0482

71-02-24-354-034.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 07/24/2014 $215,000 22,500 205,300 227,800 1.0595 0.1084

71-02-25-129-022.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 08/04/2014 $151,500 21,400 128,600 150,000 0.9901 0.0389

71-02-14-477-004.000-029 Warren 7129014 510 029 12/9/2014 240,000$ 20,400 212,700 233,100 0.9713 0.0201

71-02-24-354-056.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 08/13/2014 $230,000 19,100 173,600 192,700 0.8378 0.1133

71-02-24-354-066.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 08/20/2014 $138,500 15,800 121,100 136,900 0.9884 0.0373

71-02-25-126-029.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 08/29/2014 $204,000 23,000 167,200 190,200 0.9324 0.0188

71-02-24-354-036.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 12/18/2014 $250,000 24,500 188,500 213,000 0.8520 0.0992

71-02-25-126-021.000-029 Warren 7129047 510 029 01/23/2015 $177,000 19,700 130,900 150,600 0.8508 0.1003

71-02-23-400-032.000-029 Warren 7129053 510 029 11/26/2014 $140,000 29,100 124,400 153,500 1.0964 0.1453

71-02-23-400-055.000-029 Warren 7129053 510 029 12/23/2014 $163,500 29,100 132,700 161,800 0.9896 0.0384

$18,676,166 17,532,300 115

Mean 0.9526

Median 0.9512

Wtd Mean 0.9388

COD 12.2625

PRD 1.0147

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

SDFID ParcelNumber MultiParcel StudySection Grouping Township Neighborhood PropertyClass TaxingDistrict SaleDate StudySalePrice CurrentLandAV CurrentImpAVCurrentTotalAV71-2014-4203533 71-08-27-151-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101006 510 001 08/06/2014 $277,000 12,600 219,300 231,900

71-2015-4200453 71-08-27-154-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101006 510 001 02/18/2015 $319,900 17,600 288,600 306,200

71-2014-4201459 71-08-27-401-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101007 511 001 04/25/2014 $155,000 34,500 172,300 206,800

71-2014-4202716 71-08-27-402-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101007 510 001 07/03/2014 $138,500 8,700 104,300 113,000

71-2014-4202709 71-08-27-451-018.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101007 510 001 07/03/2014 $160,000 9,900 128,700 138,600

71-2014-4201891 71-08-34-476-013.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 05/21/2014 $122,000 7,300 98,800 106,100

71-2014-4204145 71-08-34-476-015.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 09/10/2014 $145,000 9,100 132,500 141,600

71-2014-4204492 71-08-34-377-018.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 10/01/2014 $154,900 10,400 119,500 129,900

71-2014-4204871 71-08-34-377-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 10/10/2014 $126,500 10,900 123,000 133,900

71-2015-4200094 71-08-34-476-004.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 01/22/2015 $140,000 8,000 137,000 145,000

71-2015-4200198 71-08-34-426-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101008 510 001 01/29/2015 $130,000 8,200 128,700 136,900

71-2014-4206285 71-08-35-326-004.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101010 510 001 12/17/2014 $442,000 37,300 255,500 292,800

71-2014-4204309 71-08-35-353-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101010 510 001 09/19/2014 $259,000 25,000 210,700 235,700

71-2014-4205420 71-08-35-302-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101010 510 001 11/10/2014 $315,000 9,700 222,000 231,700

71-2014-4206262 71-08-35-176-017.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101011 510 001 12/17/2014 $228,000 11,600 164,300 175,900

71-2015-4200299 71-08-36-127-006.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 02/10/2015 $75,000 10,700 79,500 90,200

71-2014-4203261 71-08-35-251-003.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 07/29/2014 $148,000 20,300 102,800 123,100

C71-2014-4200455 71-08-36-452-004.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 02/21/2014 $137,400 11,700 108,800 120,500

C71-2014-4200970 71-08-36-126-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 03/26/2014 $91,000 7,000 79,300 86,300

71-2014-4201148 71-08-36-451-003.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 04/07/2014 $101,500 10,200 82,100 92,300

71-2014-4201406 71-08-27-300-033.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 04/25/2014 $107,500 41,700 70,000 111,700

71-2014-4201583 71-08-35-227-021.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 05/02/2014 $107,500 8,800 69,900 78,700

71-2014-4202143 71-08-36-103-018.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 06/04/2014 $75,000 9,100 73,600 82,700

71-2014-4202669 71-08-27-300-002.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 06/27/2014 $65,000 20,800 58,300 79,100

71-2014-4202893 71-08-36-354-028.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 07/11/2014 $104,000 6,900 86,900 93,800

71-2014-4203464 71-08-36-307-024.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 08/08/2014 $72,000 4,500 51,900 56,400

71-2014-4203746 71-08-27-300-031.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 08/20/2014 $112,000 26,800 131,700 158,500

71-2014-4203848 71-08-35-126-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 08/27/2014 $96,000 37,500 65,900 103,400

71-2014-4201353 71-08-36-306-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101014 510 001 04/21/2014 $82,000 10,400 84,700 95,100

71-2014-4202161 71-08-35-227-016.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101014 510 001 06/03/2014 $155,000 14,900 116,100 131,000

71-2014-4205635 71-08-36-378-008.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101014 510 001 11/17/2014 $102,000 12,300 68,500 80,800

71-2015-4200194 71-08-36-379-001.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101014 510 001 01/29/2015 $114,000 16,400 87,300 103,700

71-2014-4205341 71-08-36-453-012.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101015 510 001 11/06/2014 $108,000 11,900 61,200 73,100

71-2014-4205875 71-13-14-227-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101015 510 001 12/05/2014 $95,000 32,200 60,400 92,600

71-2014-4202692 71-13-11-176-002.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101017 510 001 06/27/2014 $90,000 47,800 39,100 86,900

71-2014-4202873 71-08-27-300-017.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101017 510 001 07/14/2014 $102,500 78,400 26,700 105,100

71-2014-4205792 71-13-13-200-010.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101017 510 001 12/02/2014 $135,000 42,200 102,400 144,600

71-2014-4206440 71-09-31-456-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101017 510 001 12/30/2014 $106,000 33,200 126,800 160,000

71-2014-4202160 71-09-31-456-012.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101018 510 001 06/03/2014 $179,900 33,500 140,800 174,300

71-2014-4204275 71-13-03-200-020.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101018 510 001 09/15/2014 $142,500 40,500 76,700 117,200

71-2014-4203750 71-14-07-200-011.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101020 511 001 08/20/2014 $225,000 58,400 203,600 262,000

71-2014-4202923 71-14-07-352-008.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101025 510 001 07/11/2014 $137,000 40,700 66,700 107,400

71-2014-4204999 71-13-13-352-002.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101025 510 001 10/22/2014 $272,630 37,800 156,600 194,400

71-2014-4203600 71-13-01-102-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101027 510 001 08/12/2014 $65,000 5,600 29,200 34,800

71-2014-4204280 71-13-01-128-003.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101027 510 001 09/15/2014 $59,500 5,600 22,200 27,800

71-2014-4201885 71-13-01-129-017.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101028 510 001 05/21/2014 $106,000 11,900 104,400 116,300

71-2014-4203133 71-13-01-104-013.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101028 510 001 07/24/2014 $130,000 13,600 132,000 145,600

71-2014-4202647 71-14-06-305-007.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 06/25/2014 $179,000 20,500 151,500 172,000

71-2014-4202740 71-14-06-303-013.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 06/30/2014 $223,000 18,600 182,100 200,700

71-2014-4204561 71-14-06-306-007.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 09/24/2014 $210,000 17,700 170,600 188,300

71-2014-4204811 71-14-06-306-008.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 10/09/2014 $205,000 20,500 167,000 187,500

71-2014-4204920 71-14-06-308-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 10/15/2014 $230,000 18,100 185,100 203,200

71-2015-4200122 71-14-06-303-007.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101030 510 001 01/21/2015 $259,000 23,500 182,200 205,700

71-2014-4203223 71-13-01-403-006.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101031 510 001 07/28/2014 $130,500 14,300 106,900 121,200

71-2014-4203442 71-13-01-426-018.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101031 510 001 08/04/2014 $121,000 12,600 101,400 114,000

71-2014-4204560 71-13-01-427-017.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101031 510 001 09/24/2014 $120,000 14,300 101,300 115,600

71-2014-4204970 71-13-02-453-002.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101033 510 001 10/21/2014 $146,000 5,300 88,100 93,400

71-2014-4205833 71-13-02-453-007.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101033 510 001 12/03/2014 $98,500 5,600 89,900 95,500

71-2015-4200079 71-13-02-453-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101033 510 001 01/20/2015 $88,000 7,200 65,400 72,600

71-2014-4203497 71-13-02-102-004.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101034 510 001 08/06/2014 $90,000 27,000 62,700 89,700

71-2014-4203218 71-13-11-376-010.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 07/28/2014 $54,500 20,400 34,300 54,700

C71-2014-4200191 71-13-11-378-001.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 01/30/2014 $100,000 21,300 80,900 102,200

71-2014-4203188 71-13-11-352-009.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 07/25/2014 $126,500 8,200 99,000 107,200

71-2014-4206282 71-13-11-353-005.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 12/17/2014 $78,900 7,100 56,400 63,500

71-2014-4206327 71-13-11-353-022.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 12/24/2014 $86,900 11,100 63,200 74,300

71-2014-4206421 71-13-11-352-016.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 12/29/2014 $78,000 7,100 70,000 77,100

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204683 71-13-12-176-001.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101051 511 001 10/07/2014 $568,000 47,300 325,400 372,700

71-2014-4201847 71-08-35-202-001.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101055 510 001 05/19/2014 $198,900 23,000 130,500 153,500

71-2014-4204659 71-08-35-203-001.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101055 510 001 10/06/2014 $212,000 25,000 147,700 172,700

71-2014-4205127 71-08-25-426-013.000-002 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Centre 7102014 425 002 09/24/2014 $2,100,000 718,600 1,031,100 1,749,700

71-2014-4206581 71-08-25-152-013.000-002 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Centre 7102014 454 002 11/03/2014 $395,000 50,600 234,200 284,800

C71-2014-4200333 71-09-30-177-009.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 02/06/2014 $91,000 16,300 72,000 88,300

C71-2014-4200759 71-09-30-152-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 03/12/2014 $64,900 17,000 53,700 70,700

71-2014-4201525 71-09-30-102-009.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 05/01/2014 $140,500 25,000 136,800 161,800

71-2014-4201758 71-09-30-177-015.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 05/14/2014 $51,000 15,300 54,900 70,200

71-2014-4201852 71-09-30-151-027.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 05/19/2014 $49,900 20,400 46,800 67,200

71-2014-4202169 71-09-30-203-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 06/04/2014 $86,500 15,600 76,500 92,100

71-2014-4202157 71-09-30-132-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 06/04/2014 $87,000 16,900 68,100 85,000

71-2014-4202247 71-09-30-130-032.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 06/09/2014 $70,000 17,900 49,900 67,800

71-2014-4202603 71-09-30-131-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 06/26/2014 $74,900 16,900 54,700 71,600

71-2014-4203258 71-09-30-101-033.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 07/29/2014 $67,500 20,900 53,800 74,700

71-2014-4205073 71-09-30-102-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 10/27/2014 $120,000 20,900 127,700 148,600

71-2014-4206492 71-09-30-130-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 12/30/2014 $60,500 15,800 54,400 70,200

71-2015-4200034 71-09-30-202-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102018 510 002 01/13/2015 $84,000 16,100 84,400 100,500

71-2014-4202930 71-08-25-228-020.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102020 510 002 07/11/2014 $65,650 2,300 41,600 43,900

71-2014-4204284 71-08-25-229-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102020 510 002 09/16/2014 $43,000 2,500 34,400 36,900

71-2014-4201115 71-09-30-378-016.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 04/04/2014 $77,500 9,100 70,200 79,300

71-2014-4201286 71-09-30-402-008.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 04/16/2014 $65,000 13,900 70,000 83,900

71-2014-4201342 71-09-30-402-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 04/21/2014 $81,000 12,000 68,900 80,900

71-2014-4201576 71-09-30-476-008.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 05/02/2014 $92,000 13,600 106,100 119,700

71-2014-4201746 71-09-30-404-015.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 05/14/2014 $89,900 17,900 72,800 90,700

71-2014-4202845 71-09-30-457-019.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 07/09/2014 $108,000 16,000 104,000 120,000

71-2014-4202881 71-09-30-378-022.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 07/10/2014 $97,500 15,500 75,700 91,200

71-2014-4203144 71-09-30-456-041.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 551 002 07/24/2014 $86,000 6,700 66,600 73,300

71-2014-4203216 71-09-30-329-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 07/28/2014 $69,000 15,500 63,000 78,500

71-2014-4203288 71-09-30-457-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 07/31/2014 $75,000 12,300 71,200 83,500

71-2014-4203683 71-09-30-327-016.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 08/19/2014 $80,000 13,200 64,100 77,300

71-2014-4204000 71-09-30-458-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 09/05/2014 $122,000 13,200 92,700 105,900

71-2014-4204536 71-09-30-480-027.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 09/24/2014 $93,000 14,000 85,900 99,900

71-2014-4204641 71-09-30-381-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 09/25/2014 $117,000 15,400 86,700 102,100

71-2014-4204795 71-09-30-480-037.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 10/08/2014 $70,000 15,000 69,500 84,500

71-2014-4205186 71-09-30-403-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 10/29/2014 $87,000 15,200 66,200 81,400

71-2014-4205579 71-09-30-453-010.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 11/21/2014 $65,000 15,400 66,000 81,400

71-2015-4200127 71-09-30-454-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 01/21/2015 $81,000 14,400 66,500 80,900

71-2015-4200129 71-09-30-452-007.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 01/21/2015 $87,500 13,200 66,000 79,200

71-2015-4200348 71-09-30-327-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102021 510 002 02/12/2015 $83,000 15,600 60,700 76,300

71-2014-4202660 71-09-30-228-027.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 06/23/2014 $202,000 18,200 167,200 185,400

71-2014-4203178 71-09-30-206-010.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 07/25/2014 $182,000 17,000 128,300 145,300

71-2014-4203547 71-09-30-227-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 08/08/2014 $95,000 22,400 66,900 89,300

71-2014-4204220 71-09-30-255-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 09/12/2014 $163,000 16,400 134,400 150,800

71-2014-4205791 71-09-30-228-016.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 12/02/2014 $90,000 16,000 70,200 86,200

71-2014-4206145 71-09-30-201-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102022 510 002 12/15/2014 $122,000 12,200 147,200 159,400

71-2014-4202336 71-09-31-126-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102023 510 002 06/12/2014 $155,000 32,600 108,100 140,700

71-2014-4201048 71-09-31-128-011.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 04/02/2014 $160,100 17,600 122,000 139,600

71-2014-4201567 71-08-36-251-035.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 05/01/2014 $95,000 26,700 91,400 118,100

71-2014-4202554 71-09-31-102-022.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 06/18/2014 $138,000 35,000 101,200 136,200

71-2014-4202987 71-08-36-251-020.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 07/17/2014 $132,000 24,500 98,700 123,200

71-2014-4204563 71-08-36-231-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 09/24/2014 $130,000 29,500 115,800 145,300

71-2014-4205552 71-09-31-128-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 11/19/2014 $190,000 23,300 146,900 170,200

71-2014-4205710 71-08-36-205-024.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 11/26/2014 $162,500 28,900 132,500 161,400

71-2014-4206276 71-08-36-205-017.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 12/18/2014 $135,000 27,300 129,900 157,200

71-2014-4206432 71-08-36-251-042.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102024 510 002 12/29/2014 $160,000 34,500 106,500 141,000

71-2014-4201154 71-08-36-205-021.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 04/07/2014 $163,000 22,300 117,900 140,200

71-2014-4201319 71-08-36-235-013.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 04/16/2014 $210,000 38,400 158,400 196,800

71-2014-4202240 71-08-36-205-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 06/09/2014 $139,000 33,100 125,000 158,100

71-2014-4203016 71-08-36-251-041.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 07/18/2014 $219,000 34,500 146,000 180,500

71-2014-4206078 71-08-36-276-013.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 12/12/2014 $152,500 22,800 128,300 151,100

71-2015-4200121 71-08-36-235-022.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 01/21/2015 $190,000 24,800 137,800 162,600

71-2015-4200570 71-09-31-103-016.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102026 510 002 02/20/2015 $110,000 25,800 96,000 121,800

71-2014-4202693 71-09-31-258-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102028 510 002 07/01/2014 $146,000 9,600 125,000 134,600

71-2014-4202869 71-09-31-256-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102028 510 002 07/10/2014 $210,000 9,800 174,600 184,400

71-2014-4203702 71-09-31-252-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102028 510 002 08/15/2014 $125,000 10,000 98,200 108,200

71-2014-4204653 71-09-31-253-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102028 510 002 09/25/2014 $130,000 8,200 108,100 116,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200630 71-08-27-200-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 03/05/2014 $70,000 26,900 69,300 96,200

71-2014-4201612 71-09-31-154-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 05/05/2014 $118,000 24,200 94,400 118,600

71-2014-4202163 71-09-31-178-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 06/03/2014 $139,000 19,700 126,500 146,200

71-2014-4202320 71-09-31-152-007.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 06/11/2014 $103,500 23,700 74,400 98,100

71-2014-4202321 71-09-31-178-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 06/11/2014 $147,900 20,500 107,400 127,900

71-2014-4202899 71-09-31-329-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 07/11/2014 $133,500 27,900 104,300 132,200

71-2014-4202942 71-09-31-326-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 07/14/2014 $129,000 19,600 85,800 105,400

71-2014-4203446 71-09-31-152-021.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 08/05/2014 $120,000 24,900 84,400 109,300

71-2014-4203841 71-09-31-177-020.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 08/26/2014 $130,900 14,600 97,500 112,100

71-2014-4205098 71-09-31-329-018.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 10/23/2014 $175,500 20,900 147,700 168,600

71-2014-4206147 71-09-31-153-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102030 510 002 12/15/2014 $127,500 24,200 71,900 96,100

71-2014-4206538 71-08-27-200-006.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 12/30/2014 $225,000 74,200 87,600 161,800

71-2014-4201113 71-09-31-177-027.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 04/04/2014 $130,000 16,300 114,800 131,100

71-2014-4202115 71-09-31-177-022.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 05/02/2014 $119,900 17,100 82,800 99,900

71-2014-4203851 71-09-31-177-028.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 08/26/2014 $145,900 23,000 110,300 133,300

71-2014-4205375 71-09-31-181-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 11/06/2014 $149,000 20,100 117,600 137,700

C71-2014-4200464 71-09-31-434-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 02/20/2014 $93,000 6,300 96,600 102,900

71-2014-4202683 71-09-31-440-007.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 07/01/2014 $120,000 6,300 101,700 108,000

71-2014-4202864 71-09-31-439-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 07/10/2014 $95,000 6,300 77,200 83,500

71-2014-4202969 71-09-31-435-013.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 07/15/2014 $120,000 7,400 107,100 114,500

71-2014-4203549 71-09-31-438-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 08/08/2014 $107,000 6,300 90,100 96,400

71-2014-4203742 71-09-31-434-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 08/20/2014 $80,000 6,300 103,000 109,300

71-2014-4203762 71-09-31-435-009.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 08/25/2014 $84,900 6,500 91,000 97,500

71-2014-4204143 71-09-31-432-015.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 09/10/2014 $115,000 6,300 97,400 103,700

71-2014-4205067 71-09-31-431-017.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 10/27/2014 $105,000 6,300 98,100 104,400

71-2014-4205530 71-09-31-434-020.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 11/18/2014 $117,500 6,300 97,500 103,800

71-2015-4200310 71-09-31-439-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 02/10/2015 $106,500 6,300 85,500 91,800

71-2015-4200455 71-09-31-440-008.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102035 551 002 02/18/2015 $87,500 6,300 88,800 95,100

C71-2014-4200805 71-08-36-476-020.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 03/19/2014 $205,000 33,700 154,500 188,200

71-2014-4201184 71-09-31-381-023.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 04/08/2014 $92,500 23,000 89,900 112,900

71-2014-4201283 71-09-31-303-011.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 04/16/2014 $148,500 17,900 124,500 142,400

71-2014-4201378 71-09-31-353-003.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 04/22/2014 $110,000 25,700 79,900 105,600

71-2014-4201707 71-09-31-303-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 05/13/2014 $124,000 23,900 134,500 158,400

71-2014-4202457 71-09-31-455-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 06/18/2014 $185,000 29,900 130,700 160,600

71-2014-4203011 71-09-31-353-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 07/18/2014 $156,000 26,500 96,200 122,700

71-2014-4203705 71-09-31-377-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 08/21/2014 $119,000 28,400 88,900 117,300

71-2014-4204773 71-09-31-402-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 10/09/2014 $157,000 17,500 128,400 145,900

71-2014-4205418 71-09-31-306-015.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 11/10/2014 $147,000 22,900 102,400 125,300

71-2014-4205622 71-09-31-306-011.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 11/24/2014 $121,900 29,000 97,200 126,200

71-2014-4206065 71-09-31-456-026.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 12/12/2014 $334,900 28,900 263,700 292,600

71-2014-4202036 71-14-06-127-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102040 510 002 05/29/2014 $200,000 25,000 160,900 185,900

71-2014-4206294 71-08-25-327-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102042 510 002 12/23/2014 $120,000 5,600 75,000 80,600

71-2014-4206769 71-08-25-326-014.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102042 510 002 01/12/2015 $74,900 5,400 74,000 79,400

C71-2014-4200045 71-08-25-426-018.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102044 510 002 01/09/2014 $105,000 10,300 99,700 110,000

71-2014-4200988 71-08-36-252-008.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 03/13/2014 $197,000 13,000 183,400 196,400

71-2014-4202061 71-08-36-279-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 05/30/2014 $123,000 9,700 90,300 100,000

71-2014-4202721 71-08-36-279-023.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 07/02/2014 $135,000 10,200 137,500 147,700

71-2014-4202825 71-08-36-401-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 07/08/2014 $201,000 15,100 186,700 201,800

71-2014-4203210 71-08-36-411-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 07/28/2014 $207,000 14,800 162,500 177,300

71-2014-4204175 71-08-36-279-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 09/11/2014 $145,900 14,900 128,500 143,400

71-2014-4205069 71-08-36-411-013.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 10/27/2014 $255,841 12,700 182,500 195,200

71-2015-4200070 71-08-36-402-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102046 510 002 01/14/2015 $185,000 13,900 157,200 171,100

C71-2014-4200488 71-08-36-278-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102048 510 002 02/19/2014 $220,000 18,300 229,100 247,400

71-2014-4204010 71-08-36-278-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102048 510 002 09/05/2014 $183,000 20,800 145,300 166,100

C71-2014-4200107 71-08-36-228-015.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 01/22/2014 $125,500 2,600 126,200 128,800

71-2014-4201927 71-08-36-203-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 05/22/2014 $124,500 2,900 95,400 98,300

71-2014-4202555 71-08-36-228-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 510 002 06/24/2014 $125,000 3,200 138,900 142,100

71-2014-4202607 71-08-36-230-011.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 510 002 06/26/2014 $153,000 6,300 137,100 143,400

71-2014-4202798 71-14-06-102-030.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 07/03/2014 $189,900 21,400 188,100 209,500

71-2014-4204461 71-08-36-203-019.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 09/26/2014 $127,500 2,600 125,300 127,900

71-2014-4204458 71-08-36-229-004.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 09/26/2014 $131,000 5,900 125,100 131,000

71-2014-4204437 71-08-36-230-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 550 002 09/26/2014 $156,900 5,900 138,300 144,200

71-2014-4204615 71-08-36-233-002.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 09/30/2014 $98,500 5,300 126,200 131,500

71-2014-4205787 71-14-06-102-035.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 12/01/2014 $190,600 21,400 169,100 190,500

71-2014-4206338 71-08-36-203-016.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102056 551 002 12/22/2014 $102,500 3,200 125,000 128,200

71-2014-4205115 71-08-36-206-005.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102057 551 002 10/29/2014 $140,000 2,900 98,600 101,500

71-2014-4205959 71-08-36-206-006.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102057 551 002 12/09/2014 $150,000 2,900 100,300 103,200

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200795 71-13-02-126-066.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102062 510 002 03/18/2014 $159,500 12,100 129,400 141,500

71-2014-4200995 71-13-02-151-024.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102062 510 002 03/31/2014 $165,000 10,900 148,900 159,800

71-2014-4203186 71-13-02-151-088.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102062 510 002 07/25/2014 $170,000 11,400 134,700 146,100

C71-2015-4200758 71-09-29-451-005.000-031 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Penn 7131068 500 031 2/26/2015 $25,000 19,200 0 19,200

C71-2015-4200697 71-09-31-477-001.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 02/27/2015 $164,900 41,700 120,600 162,300

C71-2015-4200729 71-13-01-403-004.000-001 N Res Imp None Centre 7101031 510 001 2/27/2015 105,000$ 12,400 95,200 107,600

C71-2015-4200642 71-04-20-104-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 2/27/2015 240,000$ 23,700 137,200 160,900

C71-2015-4200663 71-04-16-409-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 2/20/2015 110,750$ 10,100 106,900 117,000

C71-2015-4200657 71-04-19-204-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 2/24/2015 130,000$ 28,000 100,600 128,600

C71-2015-4200628 71-04-17-256-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 2/27/2015 835,000$ 33,000 758,700 791,700

C71-2015-4200655 71-04-08-353-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 2/27/2015 380,000$ 32,900 233,600 266,500

C71-2015-4200785 71-03-21-229-025.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 2/27/2015 137,500$ 11,400 112,600 124,000

C71-2015-4200688 71-05-07-452-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111074 510 011 2/27/2015 140,000$ 19,400 108,100 127,500

C71-2015-4200692 71-04-15-203-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 2/24/2015 277,000$ 69,900 223,300 293,200

C71-2015-4200787 71-04-15-356-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 2/24/2015 290,000$ 25,200 219,300 244,500

C71-2015-4200605 71-04-14-326-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 2/25/2015 184,000$ 29,100 151,100 180,200

C71-2015-4200630 71-04-13-201-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 2/27/2015 170,000$ 43,800 137,700 181,500

C71-2015-4200713 71-04-22-401-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111121 510 011 2/25/2015 56,000$ 35,400 51,400 86,800

C71-2015-4200838 71-04-15-354-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 2/27/2015 342,000$ 75,700 250,400 326,100

C71-2015-4200782 71-04-27-378-038.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136008 510 036 2/20/2015 149,000$ 26,400 116,700 143,100

C71-2015-4200653 71-05-18-429-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 2/27/2015 128,900$ 12,200 132,200 144,400

C71-2015-4200711 71-04-10-303-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111018 510 011 2/27/2015 153,000$ 16,700 125,500 142,200

C71-2015-4200721 71-06-02-352-027.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117014 510 017 2/20/2015 208,000$ 20,900 145,400 166,300

C71-2014-4206990 71-08-03-278-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126589 510 026 12/22/2014 42,500$ 800 50,200 51,000

C71-2014-4203976 71-09-08-330-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 8/27/2014 60,000$ 2,100 55,000 57,100

C71-2014-4200824 71-08-24-204-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 2/26/2014 49,000$ 4,000 60,300 64,300

C71-2015-4200659 71-08-02-434-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126374 510 026 2/27/2015 104,000$ 17,100 96,200 113,300

C71-2015-4200797 71-08-09-203-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 2/20/2015 21,000$ 900 16,200 17,100

C71-2015-4200695 71-08-24-204-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 2/27/2015 72,900$ 4,000 60,600 64,600

C71-2015-4200801 71-09-17-208-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 2/26/2015 58,500$ 2,300 51,200 53,500

C71-2015-4200716 71-08-01-227-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 2/28/2015 65,000$ 6,900 34,100 41,000

C71-2015-4200651 71-08-08-202-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 2/27/2015 76,000$ 6,200 91,500 97,700

C71-2014-4206467 71-09-15-179-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 12/9/2014 82,200$ 10,000 69,300 79,300

C71-2014-4206325 71-09-32-302-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131071 510 031 12/2/2014 230,000$ 18,200 140,800 159,000

C71-2014-4203748 71-09-27-229-003.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122069 510 022 8/6/2014 430,000$ 48,400 263,800 312,200

C71-2014-4205872 71-09-09-313-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 10/31/2014 71,500$ 9,000 50,700 59,700

C71-2014-4203745 71-09-09-203-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 8/6/2014 47,500$ 8,400 37,800 46,200

C71-2015-4200742 71-09-04-178-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122054 510 022 2/17/2015 65,000$ 9,800 68,200 78,000

C71-2015-4200744 71-09-24-105-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 2/27/2015 109,500$ 13,300 93,400 106,700

C71-2015-4200560 71-09-12-477-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 2/24/2015 195,000$ 19,300 151,900 171,200

C71-2015-4200567 71-09-29-276-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131067 510 031 2/27/2015 81,000$ 17,500 65,700 83,200

C71-2015-4200741 71-05-31-404-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131028 510 031 2/27/2015 128,500$ 21,300 83,600 104,900

C71-2015-4200756 71-09-10-482-020.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 2/25/2015 123,500$ 10,700 112,700 123,400

C71-2015-4200549 71-09-15-115-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123062 510 023 2/26/2015 203,500$ 18,400 161,400 179,800

C71-2015-4200751 71-09-32-126-039.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 2/23/2015 139,000$ 13,400 155,000 168,400

C71-2015-4200752 71-04-35-201-021.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 2/27/2015 135,000$ 24,300 127,100 151,400

C71-2015-4200805 71-09-14-228-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 2/20/2015 105,000$ 23,800 86,700 110,500

C71-2015-4200755 71-09-09-205-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 2/27/2015 61,000$ 11,900 46,800 58,700

C71-2015-4200743 71-09-24-227-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 2/27/2015 121,000$ 15,300 97,800 113,100

C71-2015-4200745 71-04-35-251-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 2/10/2015 155,000$ 28,000 142,800 170,800

C71-2015-4200561 71-09-09-356-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123054 510 023 2/13/2015 57,500$ 8,800 53,600 62,400

C71-2014-4206907 71-02-14-477-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 12/9/2014 240,000$ 20,400 212,700 233,100

C71-2015-4200870 71-04-31-403-063.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7109550 550 003 2/20/2015 425,000$ 42,800 403,800 446,600

C71-2015-4200608 71-03-23-301-118.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 2/25/2015 106,500$ 3,800 99,400 103,200

C71-2014-4203104 71-14-16-426-004.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 7/16/2014 138,000$ 38,700 96,600 135,300

C71-2015-4200559 71-09-03-102-068.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122053 550 022 2/6/2015 250,000$ 30,000 205,800 235,800

C71-2015-4200068 71-08-04-126-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 1/9/2015 $36,000 1,700 51,600 53,300

C71-2014-4204930 71-08-08-252-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 10/9/2014 $43,500 5,400 58,400 63,800

C71-2014-4204519 71-09-06-253-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 9/15/2014 $158,000 18,200 77,600 95,800

71-2014-4203417 71-13-02-126-062.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102062 510 002 08/05/2014 $152,000 13,800 130,900 144,700

C71-2014-4200177 71-13-02-151-074.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 02/04/2014 $155,000 14,400 132,100 146,500

71-2014-4201649 71-13-02-251-082.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 05/07/2014 $113,000 6,700 97,200 103,900

71-2014-4202876 71-13-02-151-038.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 07/09/2014 $224,000 13,600 163,200 176,800

71-2014-4203609 71-13-02-151-042.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 08/12/2014 $265,000 16,600 216,100 232,700

71-2014-4203623 71-13-02-251-063.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 08/14/2014 $166,000 11,900 139,000 150,900

71-2014-4204224 71-13-02-151-027.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 09/12/2014 $215,000 13,600 169,700 183,300

71-2014-4205602 71-13-02-151-056.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 11/20/2014 $193,000 12,100 161,600 173,700

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4205839 71-13-02-251-029.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 12/03/2014 $165,000 6,400 158,100 164,500

71-2014-4205968 71-13-02-251-034.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 12/09/2014 $171,000 6,900 146,600 153,500

71-2014-4206191 71-13-02-251-025.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102063 510 002 12/18/2014 $182,500 7,500 134,400 141,900

71-2014-4204004 71-08-26-451-012.000-002 N Res Imp None Centre 7102067 510 002 09/05/2014 $184,000 20,000 143,100 163,100

C71-2014-4200118 71-03-24-403-014.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7102500 510 003 01/30/2014 $48,500 6,700 51,800 58,500

71-2014-4205072 71-03-24-455-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102500 510 003 10/27/2014 $84,500 4,000 34,800 38,800

71-2014-4201586 71-03-24-480-029.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102501 510 003 05/05/2014 $110,250 6,500 90,900 97,400

71-2014-4201890 71-03-24-478-034.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102501 510 003 05/21/2014 $79,000 5,700 60,400 66,100

71-2014-4203821 71-03-24-427-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102501 510 003 08/26/2014 $123,000 6,600 98,400 105,000

71-2015-4200018 71-04-19-353-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7102502 510 003 01/07/2015 $109,000 8,700 103,100 111,800

71-2014-4202408 71-04-19-353-029.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102502 510 003 06/17/2014 $99,900 5,700 67,500 73,200

71-2014-4206206 71-04-19-301-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7102502 510 003 12/18/2014 $103,000 6,400 103,200 109,600

71-2014-4206558 71-04-29-401-002.000-003 N Com Vac Combined Com Vac Clay 7103004 400 003 12/31/2014 $375,000 564,600 0 564,600

71-2014-4205222 71-04-32-186-008.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103006 447 003 08/29/2014 $256,500 85,800 176,200 262,000

71-2014-4206638 71-04-32-186-003.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103006 447 003 01/01/2015 $730,000 174,000 527,000 701,000

71-2014-4202130 71-04-31-402-065.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 06/03/2014 $430,000 43,900 400,700 444,600

71-2014-4202214 71-04-31-402-051.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 06/06/2014 $490,000 49,200 429,500 478,700

71-2014-4202890 71-04-31-402-061.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 07/14/2014 $410,000 34,400 440,100 474,500

71-2014-4203805 71-04-31-402-053.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 08/22/2014 $437,500 43,900 392,200 436,100

71-2014-4204858 71-04-31-402-062.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 10/14/2014 $478,000 43,900 400,700 444,600

71-2014-4205453 71-04-31-402-056.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 11/13/2014 $480,000 43,900 400,700 444,600

71-2015-4200057 71-04-31-402-050.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103007 550 003 01/14/2015 $425,000 43,900 395,200 439,100

C71-2014-4200498 71-04-31-403-038.000-003 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103008 401 003 02/10/2014 $1,200,000 60,200 1,390,800 1,451,000

71-2014-4206606 71-03-12-308-018.000-003 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103024 442 003 12/22/2014 $150,000 36,500 100,800 137,300

71-2015-4200085 71-03-13-253-038.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 01/16/2015 $45,000 13,900 42,000 55,900

71-2014-4203688 71-03-12-405-032.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 09/16/2014 $52,000 12,500 63,900 76,400

71-2014-4201452 71-03-12-351-004.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 04/23/2014 $69,900 5,100 69,900 75,000

71-2015-4200458 71-03-13-208-011.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 02/18/2015 $115,000 17,700 61,800 79,500

71-2014-4204728 71-03-14-477-012.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 10/07/2014 $129,900 5,100 102,900 108,000

71-2014-4201057 71-03-13-205-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 04/01/2014 $47,000 7,600 54,200 61,800

71-2014-4204656 71-03-13-127-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 10/06/2014 $90,000 7,800 77,800 85,600

71-2014-4206494 71-03-11-428-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 12/30/2014 $71,000 5,000 59,600 64,600

71-2014-4203818 71-04-07-426-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103036 510 003 08/26/2014 $277,500 8,300 150,400 158,700

C71-2014-4200056 71-04-18-200-036.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 01/14/2014 $438,615 31,200 487,900 519,100

71-2014-4202001 71-04-18-200-088.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 05/28/2014 $559,000 24,800 529,300 554,100

71-2014-4204025 71-04-18-200-081.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 09/04/2014 $467,906 14,800 464,800 479,600

71-2014-4205642 71-04-30-278-019.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 11/24/2014 $232,500 22,300 237,700 260,000

71-2014-4206177 71-04-18-200-034.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 12/18/2014 $474,200 28,300 369,600 397,900

71-2014-4206335 71-04-18-200-104.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103037 510 003 12/22/2014 $485,435 45,900 412,400 458,300

71-2014-4202026 71-04-08-377-003.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 05/24/2014 $192,500 38,800 193,600 232,400

C71-2014-4200123 71-04-08-478-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 01/30/2014 $205,000 26,600 137,500 164,100

C71-2014-4200313 71-04-08-401-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 02/05/2014 $154,000 26,600 126,500 153,100

C71-2014-4200627 71-04-08-326-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 03/04/2014 $231,500 27,100 172,600 199,700

C71-2014-4200806 71-04-08-352-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 03/19/2014 $202,000 25,100 129,600 154,700

C71-2014-4200916 71-04-08-330-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 03/24/2014 $185,600 23,900 185,700 209,600

71-2014-4201064 71-04-09-302-025.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 04/01/2014 $229,500 25,600 180,000 205,600

71-2014-4201104 71-04-08-307-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 04/04/2014 $157,000 26,200 145,800 172,000

71-2014-4201389 71-04-09-452-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 04/22/2014 $170,000 28,900 143,600 172,500

71-2014-4201448 71-04-09-326-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 04/23/2014 $170,000 25,100 119,800 144,900

71-2014-4201582 71-04-08-427-026.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 05/05/2014 $164,000 24,900 153,600 178,500

71-2014-4201656 71-04-08-427-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 05/08/2014 $173,000 26,100 141,100 167,200

71-2014-4202065 71-04-08-451-061.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 05/30/2014 $280,000 32,700 189,600 222,300

71-2014-4202413 71-04-08-452-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 06/17/2014 $166,000 34,900 150,600 185,500

71-2014-4202549 71-04-08-403-027.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 06/24/2014 $255,000 30,400 224,100 254,500

71-2014-4202827 71-04-08-326-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 07/09/2014 $245,000 32,800 168,500 201,300

71-2014-4203065 71-04-09-452-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 07/17/2014 $172,000 25,900 151,400 177,300

71-2014-4202998 71-04-08-301-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 07/17/2014 $225,000 29,800 140,000 169,800

71-2014-4203166 71-04-08-330-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 07/24/2014 $225,000 26,300 155,000 181,300

71-2014-4203354 71-04-08-326-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 07/30/2014 $206,000 29,400 168,900 198,300

71-2014-4203414 71-04-09-476-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/05/2014 $191,500 26,100 146,400 172,500

71-2014-4203465 71-04-08-403-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/06/2014 $218,000 28,100 138,100 166,200

71-2014-4203466 71-04-09-329-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/07/2014 $170,300 26,100 144,000 170,100

71-2014-4203565 71-04-09-427-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/11/2014 $170,000 24,900 166,600 191,500

71-2014-4203713 71-04-09-329-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/21/2014 $250,000 26,500 205,100 231,600

71-2014-4203765 71-04-09-327-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 08/25/2014 $206,000 24,900 148,200 173,100

71-2014-4204019 71-04-08-429-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 09/04/2014 $188,000 22,500 163,600 186,100

71-2014-4205038 71-04-09-351-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 10/22/2014 $220,000 28,000 187,000 215,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4205444 71-04-08-403-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 11/12/2014 $329,900 31,300 221,100 252,400

71-2014-4206833 71-04-08-403-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 01/22/2015 $415,000 53,700 358,300 412,000

71-2015-4200450 71-04-09-351-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 02/18/2015 $182,000 23,700 130,400 154,100

71-2015-4200566 71-04-08-451-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 02/26/2015 $180,000 26,100 134,600 160,700

C71-2014-4200574 71-04-16-260-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103040 510 003 02/21/2014 $235,000 32,100 180,000 212,100

71-2014-4204341 71-04-16-401-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103040 510 003 09/17/2014 $215,000 40,100 164,500 204,600

71-2014-4204471 71-04-16-251-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103040 510 003 09/29/2014 $201,000 46,000 179,800 225,800

71-2014-4206499 71-04-16-263-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103040 510 003 12/30/2014 $328,000 63,600 229,200 292,800

71-2015-4200063 71-04-16-255-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103040 510 003 01/14/2015 $210,000 44,300 168,400 212,700

71-2014-4201225 71-04-16-427-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103041 510 003 04/14/2014 $385,750 61,000 248,600 309,600

71-2014-4201581 71-04-16-427-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103041 510 003 05/02/2014 $375,000 67,000 311,400 378,400

71-2014-4204944 71-04-16-429-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103041 510 003 06/18/2014 $379,000 59,300 319,800 379,100

71-2014-4203317 71-04-16-230-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103041 510 003 08/01/2014 $285,000 55,000 228,300 283,300

71-2015-4200581 71-04-16-404-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103041 510 003 02/26/2015 $232,500 70,000 224,500 294,500

71-2014-4202386 71-03-12-427-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103042 510 003 06/13/2014 $158,500 22,600 102,600 125,200

71-2014-4203562 71-03-12-427-025.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103042 510 003 08/11/2014 $164,000 17,100 150,000 167,100

C71-2014-4200396 71-04-16-453-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 02/13/2014 $130,000 11,700 115,400 127,100

71-2014-4201632 71-04-16-407-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 05/08/2014 $117,000 10,700 110,300 121,000

71-2014-4202337 71-04-16-477-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 06/12/2014 $130,000 10,400 117,400 127,800

71-2014-4202535 71-04-16-453-028.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 06/23/2014 $135,000 12,100 145,800 157,900

71-2014-4204147 71-04-16-453-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 09/10/2014 $375,000 11,500 298,400 309,900

71-2014-4205303 71-04-16-476-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 11/03/2014 $135,000 13,300 132,800 146,100

71-2014-4205338 71-04-16-478-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 11/06/2014 $127,500 10,200 120,400 130,600

71-2014-4206461 71-04-16-453-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103043 510 003 12/29/2014 $273,000 10,900 268,000 278,900

71-2014-4203530 71-04-17-377-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103044 520 003 08/07/2014 $185,200 13,100 164,000 177,100

C71-2014-4200511 71-04-17-452-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 02/25/2014 $167,000 17,700 151,100 168,800

C71-2014-4200784 71-04-17-376-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 03/17/2014 $193,500 20,900 149,900 170,800

C71-2014-4200971 71-04-20-253-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 03/26/2014 $212,000 19,600 172,200 191,800

71-2014-4201151 71-04-17-331-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 04/07/2014 $214,000 20,400 148,200 168,600

71-2014-4201977 71-04-17-451-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 05/27/2014 $157,000 17,300 122,500 139,800

71-2014-4202503 71-04-20-252-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 06/20/2014 $280,000 23,400 222,500 245,900

71-2014-4202799 71-04-17-452-028.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 07/03/2014 $178,500 15,300 118,600 133,900

71-2014-4203308 71-04-17-327-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 08/01/2014 $168,500 18,300 141,500 159,800

71-2014-4203480 71-04-20-201-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 08/06/2014 $194,000 19,400 187,700 207,100

71-2014-4203483 71-04-17-451-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 08/06/2014 $173,000 17,500 147,300 164,800

71-2014-4203665 71-04-17-329-022.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 08/18/2014 $206,000 22,400 156,200 178,600

71-2014-4204096 71-04-17-380-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 09/08/2014 $249,000 25,000 195,900 220,900

71-2014-4204945 71-04-17-380-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 10/20/2014 $252,000 26,900 227,900 254,800

71-2014-4205450 71-04-17-377-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 520 003 11/13/2014 $159,500 4,300 170,100 174,400

71-2014-4205790 71-04-20-201-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 12/02/2014 $190,000 18,700 156,700 175,400

71-2014-4206702 71-04-17-452-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103044 510 003 12/03/2014 $179,000 18,500 148,700 167,200

71-2014-4202155 71-04-20-178-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103045 510 003 06/04/2014 $305,000 22,600 183,000 205,600

71-2014-4206530 71-04-20-128-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103045 510 003 12/31/2014 $352,500 24,600 206,500 231,100

71-2014-4204796 71-04-17-301-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103046 510 003 10/08/2014 $91,500 20,600 57,500 78,100

71-2014-4204952 71-04-17-105-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103047 510 003 10/20/2014 $193,000 19,500 153,900 173,400

71-2014-4205334 71-04-17-106-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103047 510 003 11/06/2014 $214,000 13,800 156,400 170,200

C71-2014-4200170 71-04-17-179-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 02/04/2014 $808,000 38,100 777,100 815,200

C71-2014-4200540 71-04-16-376-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 02/25/2014 $163,000 37,300 98,600 135,900

71-2014-4201083 71-04-17-254-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 04/02/2014 $930,000 35,100 900,900 936,000

71-2014-4201222 71-04-17-127-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 04/11/2014 $589,500 39,200 621,200 660,400

71-2014-4205937 71-04-17-405-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 12/09/2014 $480,000 48,000 348,400 396,400

71-2014-4206473 71-04-17-176-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103048 510 003 12/30/2014 $1,475,000 40,400 1,431,700 1,472,100

C71-2014-4200846 71-03-13-276-025.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 03/21/2014 $315,000 28,900 298,100 327,000

71-2014-4202569 71-04-07-402-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 06/24/2014 $176,000 26,800 150,100 176,900

71-2014-4202684 71-04-18-200-055.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 07/01/2014 $525,000 15,300 445,600 460,900

71-2014-4203063 71-04-18-200-037.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 07/18/2014 $285,000 27,800 288,700 316,500

71-2014-4203220 71-04-30-278-027.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 07/28/2014 $169,900 15,300 167,300 182,600

71-2014-4204122 71-04-18-200-101.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103049 510 003 09/09/2014 $531,000 24,700 554,500 579,200

71-2014-4206524 71-04-20-157-003.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 12/31/2014 $144,900 46,300 117,200 163,500

C71-2014-4200115 71-04-20-104-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 01/22/2014 $183,000 28,000 143,000 171,000

C71-2014-4200559 71-04-20-155-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 02/26/2014 $137,000 44,000 109,700 153,700

71-2014-4201487 71-04-20-304-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 04/30/2014 $170,000 28,300 106,400 134,700

71-2014-4202059 71-04-17-351-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 05/30/2014 $182,500 22,400 145,300 167,700

71-2014-4202090 71-04-17-351-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 06/02/2014 $235,000 26,900 166,500 193,400

71-2014-4202282 71-04-20-102-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 06/12/2014 $170,000 24,000 146,600 170,600

71-2014-4202791 71-04-17-351-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 07/03/2014 $209,000 23,200 166,900 190,100

71-2014-4202984 71-04-20-126-022.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 07/15/2014 $160,000 47,500 91,000 138,500

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203471 71-04-20-153-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 08/06/2014 $123,000 28,500 98,600 127,100

71-2014-4203715 71-04-20-157-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 08/21/2014 $136,000 42,800 130,900 173,700

71-2014-4203979 71-04-20-176-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 09/02/2014 $126,000 31,800 103,500 135,300

71-2014-4204788 71-04-17-352-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 10/10/2014 $204,250 23,700 138,400 162,100

71-2015-4200208 71-04-20-302-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 01/29/2015 $150,000 26,000 109,700 135,700

71-2014-4204383 71-04-21-127-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103051 510 003 09/22/2014 $135,500 28,800 80,400 109,200

71-2015-4200456 71-04-21-176-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103051 510 003 02/18/2015 $138,000 22,800 88,000 110,800

C71-2014-4200811 71-04-21-226-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103052 510 003 03/20/2014 $512,450 48,400 427,700 476,100

71-2014-4202126 71-04-21-277-033.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103052 510 003 06/04/2014 $105,000 48,500 82,900 131,400

71-2014-4203967 71-04-21-426-037.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103052 510 003 09/02/2014 $303,448 26,200 278,200 304,400

71-2014-4205278 71-04-21-426-036.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103052 510 003 10/30/2014 $285,497 27,200 224,800 252,000

71-2014-4205800 71-04-21-277-030.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103052 510 003 12/02/2014 $80,000 43,600 52,500 96,100

71-2014-4203996 71-04-21-404-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103053 510 003 09/03/2014 $145,000 15,100 97,100 112,200

C71-2014-4200463 71-04-21-251-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103054 510 003 02/20/2014 $181,500 28,800 136,100 164,900

71-2014-4202616 71-04-21-254-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103054 510 003 06/26/2014 $199,000 26,400 143,900 170,300

C71-2014-4200776 71-04-20-429-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 03/14/2014 $300,000 21,600 273,600 295,200

71-2014-4202414 71-04-20-429-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 06/17/2014 $253,500 17,100 208,500 225,600

71-2014-4204371 71-04-20-430-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 09/22/2014 $278,000 23,600 243,100 266,700

71-2014-4204720 71-04-21-352-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 09/23/2014 $273,000 23,900 232,000 255,900

71-2014-4204837 71-04-20-476-024.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 10/13/2014 $322,500 22,800 306,800 329,600

71-2014-4205065 71-04-20-476-032.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 10/27/2014 $277,500 28,200 249,000 277,200

71-2014-4205656 71-04-20-476-022.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 11/25/2014 $298,000 29,200 312,900 342,100

71-2014-4205908 71-04-20-476-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103056 510 003 12/08/2014 $264,999 27,100 261,100 288,200

C71-2014-4200124 71-04-20-377-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 01/30/2014 $145,000 24,900 128,700 153,600

C71-2014-4200554 71-04-20-328-025.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 02/26/2014 $135,000 17,700 114,500 132,200

71-2014-4201408 71-04-20-453-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 04/25/2014 $105,000 18,700 87,900 106,600

71-2014-4201490 71-04-20-453-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 04/29/2014 $100,000 16,100 81,500 97,600

71-2014-4201914 71-04-20-326-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 05/21/2014 $150,000 16,800 139,300 156,100

71-2014-4202148 71-04-20-476-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 06/04/2014 $96,500 15,700 82,100 97,800

71-2014-4202802 71-04-20-428-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 07/03/2014 $95,000 15,700 91,900 107,600

71-2014-4202970 71-04-20-451-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 07/15/2014 $168,500 16,800 140,000 156,800

71-2014-4203137 71-04-20-452-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 07/24/2014 $154,900 16,500 125,600 142,100

71-2014-4203620 71-04-20-401-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 08/14/2014 $115,000 17,600 143,900 161,500

71-2014-4204351 71-04-20-428-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 09/18/2014 $92,500 15,700 90,300 106,000

71-2014-4204618 71-04-20-328-029.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 09/30/2014 $155,000 17,700 125,900 143,600

71-2014-4204634 71-04-20-377-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 10/06/2014 $105,000 15,700 104,200 119,900

71-2014-4204661 71-04-20-329-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 10/06/2014 $175,500 16,000 147,700 163,700

71-2014-4204946 71-04-20-401-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 10/20/2014 $127,000 22,300 95,600 117,900

71-2015-4200489 71-04-20-453-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103058 510 003 02/24/2015 $119,000 17,500 88,800 106,300

C71-2013-4206859 71-04-18-477-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 01/14/2014 $175,000 54,000 119,200 173,200

C71-2014-4200111 71-04-19-226-084.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 01/22/2014 $170,000 17,500 143,100 160,600

71-2014-4201153 71-04-19-203-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 04/07/2014 $120,000 29,900 108,000 137,900

71-2014-4201796 71-04-18-455-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 05/15/2014 $192,000 53,100 132,400 185,500

71-2014-4202140 71-04-19-203-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 06/03/2014 $126,000 24,800 101,500 126,300

71-2014-4202281 71-04-19-202-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 06/10/2014 $117,000 22,000 76,000 98,000

71-2014-4202804 71-04-18-455-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 07/03/2014 $165,000 27,500 121,500 149,000

71-2014-4202779 71-04-18-478-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 07/07/2014 $195,200 27,300 122,100 149,400

71-2014-4202837 71-04-19-226-114.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 07/09/2014 $235,000 18,100 158,900 177,000

71-2014-4203109 71-04-18-476-019.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 07/22/2014 $168,000 27,200 121,500 148,700

71-2014-4203422 71-04-19-202-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 08/05/2014 $128,000 24,200 75,500 99,700

71-2014-4204335 71-04-18-376-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 550 003 09/19/2014 $140,000 17,900 99,100 117,000

71-2014-4204542 71-04-18-476-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 09/24/2014 $155,000 26,600 114,600 141,200

71-2014-4204662 71-04-19-226-091.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 09/25/2014 $175,000 17,900 126,300 144,200

71-2014-4204938 71-04-18-478-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 10/17/2014 $130,000 27,000 130,400 157,400

71-2014-4206291 71-04-19-226-085.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 12/23/2014 $168,000 17,500 130,000 147,500

71-2015-4200069 71-04-18-478-031.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 510 003 01/14/2015 $141,000 30,200 95,000 125,200

71-2015-4200612 71-04-18-452-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103060 520 003 02/27/2015 $147,000 22,200 109,900 132,100

C71-2014-4200042 71-04-16-329-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 01/09/2014 $488,000 81,200 400,100 481,300

71-2014-4201344 71-04-16-151-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 04/21/2014 $550,000 104,500 406,900 511,400

71-2014-4201476 71-04-16-176-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 04/29/2014 $850,000 124,000 460,400 584,400

71-2014-4202540 71-04-16-179-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 06/23/2014 $675,000 118,700 543,500 662,200

71-2014-4202886 71-04-16-329-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 07/10/2014 $625,000 90,300 570,800 661,100

71-2014-4204157 71-04-16-177-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 09/10/2014 $540,000 81,500 324,600 406,100

71-2014-4205931 71-04-16-151-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103061 510 003 12/09/2014 $599,000 85,800 364,600 450,400

C71-2014-4200339 71-04-19-402-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 02/06/2014 $128,500 16,800 91,500 108,300

C71-2014-4200810 71-04-19-179-049.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 03/19/2014 $171,000 9,500 127,200 136,700

C71-2014-4200844 71-04-19-404-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 03/21/2014 $143,000 25,200 115,700 140,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200849 71-04-19-426-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 03/21/2014 $122,000 19,100 80,100 99,200

71-2014-4201248 71-04-19-405-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 04/15/2014 $88,000 17,900 64,200 82,100

71-2014-4201631 71-03-12-330-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 05/07/2014 $100,000 11,700 77,900 89,600

71-2014-4201756 71-04-19-380-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 05/14/2014 $120,500 11,500 102,700 114,200

71-2014-4202605 71-04-19-254-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 06/26/2014 $121,800 14,900 88,000 102,900

71-2014-4202677 71-03-12-332-018.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 06/27/2014 $92,500 11,800 76,800 88,600

71-2014-4202943 71-04-19-177-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 07/14/2014 $158,000 9,200 125,400 134,600

71-2014-4203059 71-04-19-178-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 07/18/2014 $130,000 9,900 111,400 121,300

71-2014-4203073 71-03-12-326-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 07/21/2014 $105,500 13,400 81,800 95,200

71-2014-4203696 71-04-19-228-035.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 08/20/2014 $128,500 21,000 90,400 111,400

71-2014-4203887 71-04-19-405-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 08/28/2014 $123,000 18,400 76,900 95,300

71-2014-4203925 71-04-19-179-053.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 08/29/2014 $157,000 8,200 119,100 127,300

71-2014-4204360 71-04-19-277-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 09/18/2014 $87,500 18,400 78,900 97,300

71-2014-4204353 71-04-19-253-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 09/18/2014 $118,500 17,500 79,700 97,200

71-2014-4204757 71-04-19-378-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 10/09/2014 $150,000 16,500 110,700 127,200

71-2014-4204775 71-04-19-403-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 10/09/2014 $124,500 18,400 102,700 121,100

71-2014-4204814 71-03-12-332-022.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 10/10/2014 $65,000 11,800 75,300 87,100

71-2014-4205447 71-03-12-328-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 11/13/2014 $102,500 11,800 81,600 93,400

71-2014-4205840 71-04-19-276-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 12/03/2014 $130,000 16,800 80,900 97,700

71-2014-4206075 71-04-19-381-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 12/12/2014 $123,500 18,100 82,700 100,800

71-2014-4206063 71-04-19-427-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 12/12/2014 $89,000 20,900 77,400 98,300

71-2014-4206288 71-03-12-403-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 12/17/2014 $95,000 11,700 76,100 87,800

71-2015-4200306 71-03-12-331-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103062 510 003 02/10/2015 $85,000 11,100 99,000 110,100

C71-2014-4200330 71-03-13-428-020.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 02/11/2014 $65,000 17,700 37,300 55,000

C71-2014-4200357 71-04-18-301-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 02/10/2014 $150,000 19,500 75,200 94,700

71-2014-4202242 71-03-13-428-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 06/09/2014 $178,942 13,900 180,800 194,700

71-2014-4201492 71-03-24-228-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 04/30/2014 $161,000 9,200 151,500 160,700

71-2014-4203679 71-03-13-476-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 08/19/2014 $79,900 10,300 100,800 111,100

71-2014-4204602 71-04-19-151-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 10/03/2014 $105,000 22,000 55,700 77,700

71-2015-4200592 71-03-13-477-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 02/25/2015 $121,500 10,300 132,900 143,200

71-2014-4200636 71-03-24-208-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103064 510 003 03/04/2014 $50,132 7,200 55,600 62,800

71-2014-4201227 71-03-24-258-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103064 510 003 04/14/2014 $105,000 9,900 100,400 110,300

71-2014-4201622 71-03-24-256-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103064 510 003 05/07/2014 $64,000 2,500 45,400 47,900

71-2014-4206412 71-03-24-253-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103064 510 003 12/29/2014 $60,000 5,000 59,800 64,800

C71-2014-4200103 71-03-24-327-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 01/22/2014 $63,900 9,600 72,500 82,100

C71-2014-4200773 71-03-13-329-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 03/12/2014 $70,000 11,000 61,500 72,500

71-2014-4201182 71-03-24-329-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 04/08/2014 $76,400 12,400 49,300 61,700

71-2014-4201355 71-03-24-178-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 04/21/2014 $64,000 11,700 54,100 65,800

71-2014-4201880 71-03-13-451-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 05/21/2014 $128,000 30,300 62,200 92,500

71-2014-4202108 71-03-13-329-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 06/02/2014 $84,000 16,500 52,800 69,300

71-2014-4202347 71-03-24-180-019.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 06/13/2014 $52,000 10,100 55,200 65,300

71-2014-4203356 71-03-24-329-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 07/30/2014 $80,000 15,600 73,700 89,300

71-2014-4203842 71-03-13-330-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 08/26/2014 $71,000 11,800 50,600 62,400

71-2014-4205058 71-03-24-326-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103065 510 003 10/27/2014 $35,000 8,100 40,900 49,000

71-2014-4202006 71-03-23-253-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103066 510 003 05/28/2014 $128,000 15,500 102,700 118,200

71-2014-4205531 71-03-23-276-037.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103066 510 003 11/18/2014 $137,000 15,400 119,100 134,500

71-2014-4206375 71-03-24-101-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103066 510 003 12/22/2014 $110,000 16,300 85,400 101,700

71-2014-4201358 71-03-23-427-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103068 510 003 04/21/2014 $179,500 29,500 141,400 170,900

71-2014-4204370 71-03-23-427-021.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103068 510 003 09/22/2014 $167,000 14,900 123,300 138,200

C71-2014-4200575 71-03-14-330-001.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 02/28/2014 $219,436 33,000 150,100 183,100

C71-2014-4200466 71-03-14-331-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 02/20/2014 $130,000 6,300 111,200 117,500

C71-2014-4200850 71-03-14-377-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 03/21/2014 $129,900 8,500 145,700 154,200

71-2014-4201357 71-03-14-408-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 04/21/2014 $146,900 5,000 122,400 127,400

71-2014-4201749 71-03-14-406-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 05/14/2014 $135,000 5,200 101,300 106,500

71-2014-4201804 71-03-14-380-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 05/15/2014 $155,000 6,500 120,400 126,900

71-2014-4203067 71-03-14-376-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 07/18/2014 $134,000 7,700 115,400 123,100

71-2014-4203718 71-03-14-380-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 08/21/2014 $130,000 6,400 121,900 128,300

71-2014-4204011 71-03-14-381-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 09/04/2014 $116,500 6,400 103,800 110,200

71-2014-4205062 71-03-14-329-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 10/27/2014 $125,000 8,600 124,000 132,600

71-2015-4200637 71-03-14-408-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 02/27/2015 $156,000 5,600 121,200 126,800

71-2014-4201447 71-03-25-228-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 04/23/2014 $137,200 24,600 117,300 141,900

71-2014-4202066 71-04-30-201-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 05/30/2014 $118,000 24,300 81,900 106,200

71-2014-4202991 71-03-25-230-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 07/17/2014 $110,000 22,500 85,900 108,400

71-2014-4203046 71-04-30-128-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 07/18/2014 $220,000 19,100 168,800 187,900

71-2014-4203697 71-04-30-254-050.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 08/15/2014 $395,000 88,000 264,200 352,200

71-2014-4203914 71-04-30-251-013.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 08/28/2014 $352,837 17,500 266,200 283,700

71-2014-4203940 71-03-25-231-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 08/29/2014 $70,000 22,200 53,300 75,500

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204161 71-04-30-127-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 09/10/2014 $281,000 24,300 230,600 254,900

71-2014-4204749 71-04-30-128-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 10/09/2014 $165,000 19,500 146,600 166,100

71-2014-4205331 71-04-30-103-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 11/05/2014 $134,900 24,600 148,000 172,600

71-2014-4205784 71-03-25-202-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 12/01/2014 $73,505 28,200 85,400 113,600

71-2014-4206808 71-03-25-277-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 01/14/2015 $195,000 27,500 143,000 170,500

71-2015-4200224 71-04-30-103-019.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103072 510 003 01/30/2015 $140,000 20,800 131,500 152,300

C71-2014-4200100 71-04-29-176-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 01/17/2014 $145,000 12,700 125,100 137,800

C71-2014-4200490 71-04-29-177-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 02/19/2014 $145,000 13,400 141,900 155,300

71-2014-4200990 71-04-29-102-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 03/31/2014 $175,500 16,100 141,500 157,600

71-2014-4201208 71-04-29-253-026.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 04/10/2014 $125,500 14,200 106,600 120,800

71-2014-4201507 71-04-29-202-015.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 04/30/2014 $131,500 12,200 89,900 102,100

71-2014-4201747 71-04-28-105-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 05/14/2014 $147,500 13,100 158,900 172,000

71-2014-4202968 71-04-29-255-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 07/15/2014 $150,000 14,400 142,300 156,700

71-2014-4203058 71-04-28-151-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 07/18/2014 $80,500 13,800 77,100 90,900

71-2014-4203262 71-04-29-254-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 07/29/2014 $139,000 14,100 96,900 111,000

71-2014-4203314 71-04-29-152-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 08/01/2014 $122,000 16,200 114,500 130,700

71-2014-4203796 71-04-30-230-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 08/25/2014 $175,000 23,700 138,900 162,600

71-2014-4204002 71-04-29-179-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 09/05/2014 $117,000 13,700 111,900 125,600

71-2014-4204227 71-04-30-279-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 09/15/2014 $225,000 24,200 167,900 192,100

71-2014-4204285 71-04-29-202-014.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 09/16/2014 $115,533 12,200 86,700 98,900

71-2014-4204473 71-04-29-103-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 09/29/2014 $196,000 16,200 120,700 136,900

71-2014-4204763 71-04-29-104-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 10/09/2014 $211,500 16,200 188,500 204,700

71-2014-4205623 71-04-29-127-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 11/24/2014 $155,000 14,100 147,800 161,900

71-2014-4205906 71-04-28-103-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 12/08/2014 $135,000 19,000 140,400 159,400

71-2014-4206300 71-04-29-151-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 12/17/2014 $136,900 23,700 121,100 144,800

71-2014-4206360 71-04-30-230-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 12/22/2014 $179,900 23,300 160,900 184,200

71-2014-4206434 71-04-29-254-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 12/29/2014 $144,900 12,900 105,000 117,900

71-2015-4200165 71-04-29-251-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 01/23/2015 $100,000 12,400 101,100 113,500

71-2015-4200195 71-04-29-102-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103074 510 003 01/29/2015 $205,000 32,300 147,000 179,300

71-2014-4201910 71-04-29-276-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103075 510 003 05/22/2014 $179,500 7,500 118,700 126,200

71-2014-4204170 71-04-31-277-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103077 510 003 09/10/2014 $81,500 12,900 53,900 66,800

71-2014-4205367 71-04-31-253-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103077 510 003 11/06/2014 $83,000 7,800 43,500 51,300

71-2014-4206269 71-04-32-276-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103080 510 003 12/17/2014 $157,000 41,200 91,700 132,900

71-2014-4201650 71-04-32-181-001.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 05/07/2014 $105,000 17,100 58,500 75,600

71-2014-4202041 71-04-32-258-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 05/29/2014 $85,000 28,300 70,600 98,900

71-2014-4202927 71-04-32-128-032.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 07/11/2014 $98,500 23,700 68,900 92,600

71-2014-4203428 71-04-32-177-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 08/05/2014 $81,000 17,600 68,600 86,200

71-2014-4204296 71-04-32-205-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 09/17/2014 $150,000 32,000 109,000 141,000

71-2014-4204613 71-04-32-181-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 09/30/2014 $77,000 18,700 49,000 67,700

71-2014-4204797 71-04-32-252-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 10/08/2014 $97,000 30,100 36,900 67,000

71-2014-4205494 71-04-32-180-009.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 11/13/2014 $64,000 20,500 52,700 73,200

71-2014-4206592 71-04-32-255-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 12/31/2014 $56,500 20,600 42,800 63,400

71-2013-4207448 71-04-32-205-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103082 510 003 02/19/2015 $145,000 30,500 112,500 143,000

71-2014-4201678 71-04-18-253-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 05/09/2014 $186,000 35,400 139,700 175,100

71-2014-4202186 71-04-18-253-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 06/05/2014 $180,000 34,100 143,500 177,600

71-2014-4202179 71-04-18-253-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 06/05/2014 $208,000 34,300 145,500 179,800

71-2014-4202707 71-04-18-281-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 07/03/2014 $230,900 68,000 130,000 198,000

71-2014-4202844 71-04-18-252-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 07/09/2014 $175,000 31,500 120,700 152,200

71-2014-4203545 71-04-18-278-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 08/08/2014 $182,151 36,500 127,900 164,400

71-2014-4203627 71-04-18-280-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 08/14/2014 $217,500 32,100 212,800 244,900

71-2014-4204205 71-04-18-280-017.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 09/15/2014 $172,500 34,400 120,500 154,900

71-2014-4206277 71-04-18-280-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 12/23/2014 $261,000 39,300 203,500 242,800

71-2014-4206498 71-04-18-251-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103093 510 003 12/30/2014 $185,000 31,500 112,800 144,300

71-2014-4202202 71-04-18-251-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103094 510 003 06/06/2014 $224,500 46,700 145,200 191,900

71-2014-4202323 71-04-18-280-003.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103094 510 003 06/11/2014 $158,000 32,900 115,700 148,600

71-2014-4203970 71-04-18-251-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103094 510 003 09/02/2014 $223,000 39,500 149,600 189,100

C71-2014-4200334 71-04-07-402-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103098 510 003 02/06/2014 $289,999 30,500 234,000 264,500

71-2014-4202204 71-04-30-252-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103098 510 003 06/06/2014 $382,250 22,500 246,000 268,500

71-2014-4202712 71-04-18-253-025.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103098 510 003 07/03/2014 $217,000 25,000 203,300 228,300

71-2014-4204741 71-04-07-401-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103098 510 003 10/07/2014 $180,000 30,500 211,300 241,800

71-2014-4205280 71-04-30-252-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103098 510 003 10/30/2014 $295,000 24,500 269,400 293,900

71-2014-4202178 71-04-08-478-010.000-003 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Clay 7103099 500 003 06/05/2014 $30,000 25,100 0 25,100

71-2014-4205393 71-04-18-477-002.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103109 510 003 11/07/2014 $232,000 9,500 192,400 201,900

71-2014-4202659 71-04-18-302-002.000-003 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Clay 7103111 500 003 06/25/2014 $9,200 8,300 0 8,300

71-2014-4202252 71-03-14-405-034.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103116 510 003 06/09/2014 $139,000 10,700 116,000 126,700

71-2015-4200308 71-03-14-405-020.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103116 510 003 02/10/2015 $131,000 9,800 107,300 117,100

71-2014-4201501 71-03-25-251-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103118 510 003 04/30/2014 $305,500 10,200 180,700 190,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4202129 71-03-25-251-018.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103118 510 003 06/03/2014 $295,000 22,600 194,700 217,300

71-2014-4202246 71-03-25-251-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103118 510 003 06/09/2014 $300,200 10,400 137,800 148,200

71-2014-4204895 71-03-25-251-016.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103118 510 003 10/15/2014 $327,000 31,200 202,000 233,200

C71-2014-4200733 71-04-19-226-075.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 03/13/2014 $65,000 2,700 60,600 63,300

71-2014-4201680 71-04-19-226-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 05/08/2014 $112,500 5,700 94,100 99,800

71-2014-4201918 71-04-18-454-008.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 05/22/2014 $142,000 8,100 120,300 128,400

71-2014-4202142 71-04-19-226-026.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 06/03/2014 $127,500 5,700 97,400 103,100

71-2014-4202222 71-04-19-226-038.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 06/09/2014 $102,000 5,700 99,800 105,500

71-2014-4202841 71-04-19-201-023.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 07/09/2014 $117,000 5,700 104,000 109,700

71-2014-4203075 71-04-19-226-057.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 07/22/2014 $70,000 2,700 74,400 77,100

71-2014-4203707 71-04-19-201-055.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 08/18/2014 $121,000 5,700 109,800 115,500

71-2014-4204013 71-04-19-201-026.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 09/04/2014 $106,000 5,700 104,900 110,600

71-2014-4204108 71-04-19-226-045.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 09/08/2014 $67,000 2,700 65,600 68,300

71-2014-4205644 71-04-19-226-047.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 11/24/2014 $69,400 2,700 60,300 63,000

71-2014-4205706 71-04-19-226-037.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 11/26/2014 $115,000 5,700 98,600 104,300

71-2014-4206198 71-04-18-454-006.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103126 550 003 12/15/2014 $140,000 9,400 110,200 119,600

71-2014-4201618 71-04-30-277-027.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103127 550 003 05/05/2014 $61,500 3,100 71,200 74,300

71-2014-4202780 71-04-30-277-078.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103127 550 003 07/03/2014 $60,000 2,600 61,800 64,400

71-2014-4204097 71-04-30-277-072.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103127 550 003 09/08/2014 $63,000 2,600 61,200 63,800

71-2014-4202711 71-04-31-282-021.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 07/02/2014 $102,000 3,700 96,800 100,500

71-2014-4203570 71-04-31-282-049.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 08/11/2014 $109,500 4,700 93,500 98,200

71-2014-4203608 71-04-31-282-031.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 08/13/2014 $64,000 3,700 58,600 62,300

71-2014-4204710 71-04-31-282-044.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 09/23/2014 $129,000 4,700 118,400 123,100

71-2014-4205344 71-04-31-282-065.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 11/06/2014 $122,000 4,700 118,900 123,600

71-2015-4200301 71-04-31-282-056.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103128 550 003 02/10/2015 $130,000 4,700 115,300 120,000

71-2014-4202452 71-04-19-177-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103129 510 003 06/18/2014 $169,500 5,800 112,000 117,800

71-2014-4202997 71-04-19-179-051.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103129 550 003 07/17/2014 $175,000 4,600 123,900 128,500

71-2015-4200491 71-04-19-179-030.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103129 550 003 02/24/2015 $145,000 3,600 102,700 106,300

C71-2014-4200093 71-04-32-153-004.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 01/17/2014 $87,000 7,300 65,400 72,700

71-2014-4202150 71-04-32-107-014.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 06/03/2014 $87,000 11,800 57,300 69,100

C71-2014-4200078 71-04-32-307-004.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 01/15/2014 $57,000 4,500 53,900 58,400

C71-2014-4200195 71-04-32-151-011.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 01/30/2014 $84,000 4,200 72,300 76,500

C71-2014-4200555 71-04-32-102-012.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 02/26/2014 $93,000 6,500 82,500 89,000

71-2014-4203323 71-04-32-102-018.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 08/01/2014 $59,183 5,400 64,700 70,100

71-2014-4204279 71-04-32-151-005.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 09/15/2014 $63,600 4,800 58,700 63,500

71-2014-4206003 71-04-32-152-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 12/11/2014 $78,000 5,100 57,400 62,500

71-2014-4202778 71-03-12-477-010.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103131 510 003 07/07/2014 $110,000 8,800 79,900 88,700

71-2014-4203296 71-03-12-476-007.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7103131 510 003 07/31/2014 $85,000 9,700 73,600 83,300

C71-2014-4200495 71-04-31-480-007.000-004 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7104012 447 004 02/11/2014 $525,000 94,500 280,400 374,900

71-2014-4206597 71-04-31-452-014.000-004 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7104012 447 004 11/18/2014 $271,000 47,400 143,900 191,300

71-2014-4202187 71-04-31-479-021.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104020 510 004 06/05/2014 $135,000 6,800 96,300 103,100

C71-2014-4200054 71-04-32-402-037.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 01/10/2014 $101,000 22,100 68,500 90,600

C71-2014-4200105 71-04-32-377-031.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 01/22/2014 $135,000 25,000 102,700 127,700

C71-2014-4200754 71-04-32-280-004.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 03/14/2014 $129,500 22,600 115,100 137,700

C71-2014-4200833 71-04-32-376-024.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 03/19/2014 $85,500 24,200 64,400 88,600

71-2014-4201434 71-04-32-380-011.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 04/28/2014 $115,000 26,000 77,800 103,800

71-2014-4201658 71-04-32-403-019.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 05/08/2014 $102,500 22,300 76,200 98,500

71-2014-4202322 71-04-32-401-022.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 06/10/2014 $115,000 22,500 70,000 92,500

71-2014-4202351 71-04-32-351-017.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 06/13/2014 $109,000 25,100 87,100 112,200

71-2014-4202681 71-04-32-376-002.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 06/27/2014 $95,000 22,500 78,200 100,700

71-2014-4202848 71-04-32-281-014.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 07/09/2014 $155,000 22,400 120,800 143,200

71-2014-4202842 71-04-32-402-004.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 07/09/2014 $112,500 23,000 70,500 93,500

71-2014-4202940 71-04-32-405-010.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 07/14/2014 $97,500 22,500 70,700 93,200

71-2014-4203191 71-04-32-377-022.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 07/25/2014 $120,000 20,500 97,700 118,200

71-2014-4203450 71-04-32-402-028.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 08/05/2014 $105,000 22,500 72,700 95,200

71-2014-4203566 71-04-32-281-006.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 08/11/2014 $142,500 19,600 120,900 140,500

71-2014-4203776 71-04-32-276-018.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 08/22/2014 $177,500 38,000 129,500 167,500

71-2014-4204800 71-04-32-403-020.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 10/08/2014 $111,850 22,300 78,600 100,900

71-2014-4205640 71-04-32-378-004.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 11/24/2014 $140,000 30,400 89,000 119,400

71-2014-4206431 71-04-32-280-009.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 12/29/2014 $155,500 23,800 119,000 142,800

71-2015-4200027 71-04-32-404-003.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 01/12/2015 $93,900 23,200 76,300 99,500

71-2015-4200125 71-04-32-401-023.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104022 510 004 01/21/2015 $112,500 22,500 65,400 87,900

C71-2014-4200841 71-04-31-478-046.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 03/19/2014 $125,000 2,900 165,400 168,300

71-2015-4200462 71-04-31-478-063.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 02/18/2015 $160,000 2,900 200,700 203,600

71-2014-4201299 71-04-31-478-051.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 04/16/2014 $125,000 2,900 106,100 109,000

71-2014-4202180 71-04-31-478-105.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 06/05/2014 $145,000 2,900 145,900 148,800

71-2014-4203472 71-04-31-478-122.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 08/07/2014 $106,900 2,900 102,900 105,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203834 71-04-31-478-062.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 08/27/2014 $121,000 2,900 103,000 105,900

71-2014-4205044 71-04-31-478-071.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 10/22/2014 $140,000 2,900 106,700 109,600

71-2014-4206343 71-04-31-478-072.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 12/22/2014 $95,000 2,900 150,100 153,000

71-2014-4206527 71-04-31-478-092.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 12/31/2014 $94,000 2,900 110,000 112,900

71-2015-4200026 71-04-31-455-029.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 01/12/2015 $180,000 3,100 85,500 88,600

71-2015-4200645 71-04-31-478-073.000-004 N Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 02/26/2015 $140,000 2,900 177,200 180,100

71-2014-4203973 71-04-32-351-010.000-004 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7104420 420 004 06/23/2014 $300,000 72,400 48,900 121,300

C71-2014-4200899 71-04-33-127-015.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7105051 510 005 03/24/2014 $121,500 5,600 108,900 114,500

71-2014-4204605 71-04-33-127-010.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7105051 510 005 10/03/2014 $79,900 5,100 85,200 90,300

71-2014-4205268 71-04-33-127-018.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7105051 510 005 10/30/2014 $60,000 5,100 82,000 87,100

71-2014-4206450 71-04-33-126-003.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7105051 510 005 12/30/2014 $99,900 5,500 82,200 87,700

71-2015-4200577 71-04-33-126-008.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7105051 510 005 02/26/2015 $88,000 5,100 83,400 88,500

71-2014-4203092 71-04-30-306-014.000-006 Y Res Imp None Clay 7106001 500 006 07/22/2014 $7,200 7,200 0 7,200

C71-2014-4200299 71-04-30-304-012.000-006 N Res Imp None Clay 7106002 510 006 02/05/2014 $66,500 6,400 58,100 64,500

C71-2014-4200623 71-04-30-302-005.000-006 N Res Imp None Clay 7106002 510 006 03/05/2014 $38,100 5,500 29,100 34,600

71-2014-4203091 71-04-30-306-004.000-006 N Res Imp None Clay 7106002 510 006 07/22/2014 $120,800 9,800 67,900 77,700

71-2014-4204859 71-04-30-304-014.000-006 N Res Imp None Clay 7106002 510 006 10/14/2014 $100,000 5,000 77,700 82,700

71-2014-4206388 71-04-30-326-003.000-006 N Res Imp None Clay 7106002 510 006 12/22/2014 $110,000 9,700 92,900 102,600

71-2014-4206944 71-03-25-303-011.000-007 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7107007 499 007 01/06/2015 $245,500 63,500 88,400 151,900

71-2014-4206053 71-03-25-326-029.000-007 Y Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 12/12/2014 $73,000 12,700 55,800 68,500

C71-2014-4200035 71-03-25-101-011.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 01/03/2014 $59,000 13,000 49,100 62,100

C71-2014-4200426 71-03-25-176-010.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 02/14/2014 $63,000 12,400 53,400 65,800

71-2014-4202746 71-03-25-104-008.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 06/30/2014 $37,500 8,000 29,400 37,400

71-2014-4204124 71-03-25-326-030.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 09/09/2014 $82,000 9,300 58,900 68,200

71-2014-4204179 71-03-25-103-007.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 09/11/2014 $77,000 10,200 36,200 46,400

71-2014-4206342 71-03-25-177-003.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 12/22/2014 $84,000 20,000 83,400 103,400

C71-2014-4200404 71-03-25-352-022.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107019 550 007 02/14/2014 $217,000 6,100 185,400 191,500

71-2014-4203714 71-03-25-352-060.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107019 550 007 08/18/2014 $175,000 6,600 133,000 139,600

71-2014-4204202 71-03-25-352-027.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107019 550 007 09/12/2014 $190,000 5,100 159,200 164,300

71-2014-4204894 71-03-25-352-041.000-007 N Res Imp None Clay 7107019 550 007 10/15/2014 $217,000 6,700 176,900 183,600

71-2015-4200243 71-03-25-326-001.000-007 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7107420 428 007 01/29/2015 $439,100 133,400 362,800 496,200

C71-2014-4200794 71-04-31-403-085.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7109550 550 003 03/18/2014 $355,000 31,900 334,200 366,100

71-2014-4201127 71-04-31-403-053.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7109550 550 003 04/04/2014 $360,000 26,300 332,700 359,000

71-2014-4202185 71-04-31-403-065.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7109550 550 003 06/05/2014 $419,000 35,300 417,400 452,700

71-2014-4203126 71-04-31-403-087.000-003 N Res Imp None Clay 7109550 550 003 07/23/2014 $350,000 24,800 325,700 350,500

71-2014-4206562 71-04-28-226-004.000-005 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7129410 410 005 12/22/2014 $1,680,000 486,500 1,033,300 1,519,800

71-2014-4206563 71-04-28-226-002.000-005 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7129410 410 005 12/23/2014 $1,968,750 416,400 1,341,500 1,757,900

C71-2014-4200551 71-04-33-176-009.000-005 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7129430 430 005 02/19/2014 $875,000 527,500 358,300 885,800

71-2014-4202144 71-04-28-351-013.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7129550 550 005 06/04/2014 $115,000 6,300 98,900 105,200

71-2014-4202871 71-04-28-351-026.000-005 N Res Imp None Clay 7129550 550 005 07/10/2014 $125,000 6,300 98,200 104,500

71-2014-4201924 71-03-08-401-008.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 05/22/2014 $127,500 25,900 87,400 113,300

71-2014-4203614 71-03-08-276-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 08/14/2014 $106,000 26,000 93,800 119,800

71-2014-4204340 71-03-08-276-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 09/17/2014 $122,000 25,400 99,000 124,400

71-2014-4204553 71-03-09-152-001.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 09/24/2014 $131,500 27,800 102,500 130,300

71-2014-4204963 71-03-09-177-006.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 10/21/2014 $117,500 24,700 88,700 113,400

71-2014-4205641 71-03-08-277-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108014 510 008 11/17/2014 $95,000 25,100 87,200 112,300

71-2014-4201999 71-03-09-252-003.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108017 510 008 05/28/2014 $191,900 42,600 158,500 201,100

71-2014-4203771 71-03-09-429-006.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108017 510 008 08/25/2014 $450,000 45,000 337,300 382,300

71-2014-4205245 71-03-09-253-001.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108017 510 008 10/31/2014 $220,000 27,300 191,400 218,700

C71-2013-4207216 71-03-10-403-017.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108023 510 008 02/05/2014 $128,500 14,200 110,000 124,200

71-2014-4203632 71-03-10-277-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108023 510 008 08/14/2014 $76,500 15,700 64,200 79,900

71-2015-4200064 71-03-10-451-001.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108023 510 008 01/14/2015 $120,000 16,600 119,100 135,700

71-2014-4204020 71-03-09-401-007.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108025 510 008 09/04/2014 $123,000 17,500 84,700 102,200

C71-2014-4200578 71-03-16-279-001.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 02/28/2014 $125,000 34,000 114,700 148,700

C71-2014-4200395 71-03-16-229-011.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 02/11/2014 $194,000 26,900 121,000 147,900

C71-2014-4200429 71-03-15-152-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 02/14/2014 $124,000 23,700 104,500 128,200

71-2014-4201934 71-03-15-104-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 05/22/2014 $132,405 23,400 138,400 161,800

71-2014-4202382 71-03-15-105-007.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 06/16/2014 $170,000 24,400 120,700 145,100

71-2014-4202722 71-03-15-103-013.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 07/02/2014 $176,900 23,700 137,100 160,800

71-2014-4204614 71-03-15-105-026.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 09/30/2014 $125,000 20,200 108,200 128,400

71-2014-4204765 71-03-15-152-009.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 10/09/2014 $139,000 21,800 107,200 129,000

71-2014-4205070 71-03-15-152-008.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 10/27/2014 $147,000 22,800 109,000 131,800

C71-2014-4200112 71-03-15-206-010.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108029 510 008 01/22/2014 $131,000 47,600 77,300 124,900

71-2014-4201116 71-03-15-254-011.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108029 510 008 04/04/2014 $146,000 15,400 111,600 127,000

71-2014-4202328 71-03-15-252-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108029 510 008 06/11/2014 $134,000 17,700 97,200 114,900

C71-2014-4200940 71-03-18-254-012.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108033 510 008 03/27/2014 $119,000 14,300 91,900 106,200

71-2014-4202199 71-03-18-254-011.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108033 510 008 06/06/2014 $132,501 14,500 104,300 118,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204431 71-03-18-328-013.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108033 510 008 09/25/2014 $107,500 16,800 90,200 107,000

71-2014-4206809 71-03-18-254-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108033 510 008 01/14/2015 $119,000 17,800 98,000 115,800

C71-2014-4200467 71-03-16-452-017.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108036 510 008 02/20/2014 $136,500 17,500 96,000 113,500

71-2014-4203259 71-03-16-451-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108036 510 008 07/29/2014 $178,000 16,100 122,800 138,900

71-2014-4204949 71-03-16-454-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108036 510 008 10/20/2014 $148,428 16,700 107,600 124,300

71-2014-4201615 71-03-11-351-007.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108039 510 008 05/05/2014 $260,000 25,800 114,200 140,000

71-2014-4202329 71-03-11-351-001.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108039 510 008 06/11/2014 $475,000 20,300 250,200 270,500

C71-2014-4200094 71-03-09-451-009.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108042 510 008 01/22/2014 $75,000 22,900 57,300 80,200

C71-2014-4200320 71-03-16-126-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108042 510 008 02/04/2014 $62,000 24,700 42,700 67,400

71-2014-4201894 71-03-08-376-015.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108042 510 008 05/21/2014 $191,276 15,500 127,400 142,900

71-2014-4205100 71-03-22-279-008.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108042 510 008 10/23/2014 $140,000 16,700 113,400 130,100

71-2014-4205846 71-03-23-151-010.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108042 510 008 12/03/2014 $105,000 16,700 87,200 103,900

71-2015-4200647 71-03-31-101-001.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108046 510 008 02/26/2015 $145,000 21,000 91,700 112,700

71-2014-4201646 71-03-22-102-005.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108047 510 008 05/07/2014 $97,000 17,300 67,300 84,600

71-2015-4200060 71-03-22-426-009.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108050 510 008 01/14/2015 $71,000 19,500 54,400 73,900

71-2014-4203728 71-03-22-476-014.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108050 510 008 08/11/2014 $129,900 10,300 74,800 85,100

71-2015-4200191 71-03-22-451-044.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108050 510 008 01/29/2015 $122,000 11,500 81,700 93,200

71-2014-4202106 71-03-32-304-020.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108057 510 008 06/02/2014 $85,000 7,500 49,200 56,700

71-2014-4206465 71-03-32-376-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108057 510 008 12/30/2014 $69,000 6,200 39,500 45,700

71-2014-4205061 71-03-20-228-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108060 510 008 10/27/2014 $170,000 11,900 105,400 117,300

71-2014-4203403 71-03-15-126-004.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108064 510 008 08/04/2014 $450,000 34,300 295,700 330,000

71-2014-4205299 71-03-15-127-009.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108064 510 008 11/03/2014 $312,500 22,700 247,300 270,000

71-2014-4206778 71-03-15-178-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108064 510 008 01/12/2015 $309,000 24,800 237,500 262,300

71-2014-4201508 71-03-18-127-012.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108068 510 008 04/30/2014 $360,000 29,900 165,500 195,400

71-2014-4202705 71-03-18-180-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108068 510 008 07/02/2014 $275,000 30,600 237,200 267,800

71-2014-4203033 71-03-18-177-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108068 510 008 07/17/2014 $272,000 37,100 329,500 366,600

71-2014-4206471 71-03-18-181-002.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108068 510 008 12/30/2014 $275,000 32,200 134,000 166,200

71-2014-4202526 71-03-17-401-023.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108070 510 008 06/20/2014 $149,875 22,100 128,900 151,000

71-2014-4202646 71-03-17-401-019.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108070 510 008 06/25/2014 $162,000 24,800 132,100 156,900

71-2014-4203384 71-03-17-401-042.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108070 510 008 07/30/2014 $178,000 28,000 141,200 169,200

71-2015-4200267 71-03-17-426-084.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108073 510 008 02/04/2015 $165,000 23,400 122,700 146,100

71-2015-4200501 71-03-17-426-007.000-008 N Res Imp None German 7108073 510 008 02/25/2015 $159,500 40,000 138,800 178,800

71-2014-4206608 71-03-20-401-004.000-009 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp German 7109007 340 009 12/24/2014 $2,397,000 324,500 3,047,200 3,371,700

71-2014-4206626 71-03-19-200-005.000-009 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp German 7109011 399 009 12/09/2014 $370,000 44,800 232,200 277,000

71-2014-4201279 71-03-28-300-013.000-009 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp German 7109013 350 009 04/04/2014 $727,000 58,100 499,900 558,000

71-2014-4201935 71-03-22-378-004.000-009 N Com Vac Combined Com Vac German 7109017 400 009 05/21/2014 $675,000 41,400 0 41,400

71-2015-4200242 71-03-27-126-005.000-009 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp German 7109017 452 009 01/29/2015 $503,000 144,300 219,100 363,400

71-2014-4201289 71-03-22-151-002.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 04/16/2014 $110,000 7,700 126,400 134,100

71-2014-4201292 71-03-21-230-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 04/16/2014 $125,000 13,300 107,200 120,500

71-2014-4202167 71-03-21-228-004.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 06/04/2014 $123,000 7,000 112,200 119,200

71-2014-4202726 71-03-22-101-005.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 07/02/2014 $124,000 6,400 122,100 128,500

71-2014-4204381 71-03-21-231-006.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 09/22/2014 $138,000 7,000 114,600 121,600

71-2014-4204639 71-03-21-229-009.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 09/25/2014 $129,999 7,000 108,900 115,900

71-2014-4204997 71-03-21-228-028.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 10/24/2014 $134,000 7,000 114,600 121,600

71-2014-4206187 71-03-21-230-002.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 12/16/2014 $124,900 7,000 108,300 115,300

71-2014-4206425 71-03-21-231-008.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109023 510 009 12/29/2014 $145,000 7,000 128,700 135,700

71-2014-4202114 71-03-22-278-004.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109026 510 009 06/02/2014 $168,500 24,700 124,300 149,000

C71-2014-4200480 71-03-22-251-020.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 02/19/2014 $99,700 16,500 108,500 125,000

C71-2014-4200633 71-03-22-282-023.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 03/04/2014 $140,000 15,800 109,800 125,600

C71-2014-4200832 71-03-22-204-009.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 03/19/2014 $190,000 17,900 139,600 157,500

71-2014-4201345 71-03-22-252-006.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 04/21/2014 $145,500 14,600 107,200 121,800

71-2014-4201572 71-03-22-280-014.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 05/02/2014 $120,000 14,400 103,700 118,100

71-2014-4201859 71-03-22-204-003.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 05/19/2014 $135,900 15,500 107,700 123,200

71-2014-4202104 71-03-22-202-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 06/02/2014 $175,900 14,500 139,600 154,100

71-2014-4202164 71-03-22-279-012.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 06/03/2014 $152,000 13,900 102,400 116,300

71-2014-4202525 71-03-22-251-014.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 06/23/2014 $145,000 16,100 115,100 131,200

71-2014-4202776 71-03-22-280-011.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 07/07/2014 $142,000 21,000 105,400 126,400

71-2014-4202839 71-03-22-255-024.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 07/09/2014 $137,000 12,800 110,200 123,000

71-2014-4203443 71-03-22-252-004.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 08/05/2014 $134,900 12,900 107,100 120,000

71-2014-4204676 71-03-22-256-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 09/25/2014 $122,000 17,200 106,700 123,900

71-2014-4204609 71-03-22-202-010.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 09/30/2014 $166,900 14,500 126,200 140,700

71-2014-4204496 71-03-22-201-001.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 10/01/2014 $190,000 16,900 143,400 160,300

71-2014-4204604 71-03-22-256-010.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 10/03/2014 $135,000 13,300 107,700 121,000

71-2014-4206484 71-03-22-202-019.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109027 510 009 12/30/2014 $122,000 12,200 105,100 117,300

C71-2014-4200939 71-03-23-353-011.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 03/27/2014 $60,000 16,700 51,400 68,100

71-2014-4201386 71-03-23-354-010.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 04/22/2014 $73,000 15,800 65,800 81,600

71-2014-4201903 71-03-23-352-034.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 05/20/2014 $67,500 12,200 64,000 76,200

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4202113 71-03-23-355-008.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 06/02/2014 $82,500 14,200 70,900 85,100

71-2014-4202280 71-03-23-355-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 06/10/2014 $78,100 15,100 66,900 82,000

71-2014-4202630 71-03-23-353-001.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 06/25/2014 $65,000 12,000 56,200 68,200

71-2014-4203156 71-03-23-305-044.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 07/22/2014 $132,500 17,700 103,500 121,200

71-2014-4204655 71-03-22-429-003.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 10/06/2014 $85,000 16,300 87,100 103,400

71-2014-4206060 71-03-23-305-025.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 12/12/2014 $79,000 15,500 41,300 56,800

71-2015-4200632 71-03-23-306-002.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109030 510 009 02/27/2015 $63,000 10,600 52,700 63,300

71-2014-4202272 71-03-27-178-009.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109033 510 009 06/12/2014 $123,000 21,200 92,600 113,800

71-2014-4205605 71-03-27-178-003.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109033 510 009 11/20/2014 $122,000 16,800 98,200 115,000

71-2014-4206689 71-03-27-252-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109033 510 009 12/30/2014 $128,000 16,800 100,100 116,900

C71-2014-4200060 71-03-27-403-016.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 01/14/2014 $115,000 13,000 106,000 119,000

71-2014-4202411 71-03-27-326-002.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 06/17/2014 $117,000 12,300 108,500 120,800

71-2014-4202679 71-03-27-303-031.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 06/27/2014 $94,000 12,300 81,200 93,500

71-2014-4202774 71-03-27-403-008.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 07/07/2014 $110,000 10,700 70,700 81,400

71-2014-4204964 71-03-27-403-014.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 10/21/2014 $119,900 11,200 81,500 92,700

71-2014-4205339 71-03-27-351-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 11/06/2014 $118,000 13,400 93,100 106,500

71-2014-4205551 71-03-27-402-010.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109035 510 009 11/19/2014 $108,000 10,500 74,500 85,000

71-2014-4202249 71-03-21-127-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109037 510 009 06/09/2014 $118,000 24,300 99,600 123,900

71-2014-4203622 71-03-21-128-018.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109037 510 009 08/14/2014 $145,000 19,300 125,400 144,700

71-2014-4203747 71-03-21-128-006.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109037 510 009 08/20/2014 $150,000 23,200 118,800 142,000

C71-2014-4200972 71-03-23-301-107.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109038 510 009 03/26/2014 $115,000 9,300 104,300 113,600

71-2014-4204862 71-03-22-283-011.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109038 510 009 10/14/2014 $152,000 7,300 114,400 121,700

71-2015-4200431 71-03-23-301-103.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109038 510 009 02/20/2015 $119,000 6,500 100,500 107,000

C71-2014-4200566 71-03-23-301-057.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 02/27/2014 $105,000 3,800 83,000 86,800

C71-2014-4200652 71-03-23-301-045.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 03/05/2014 $95,000 3,800 92,900 96,700

71-2014-4201500 71-03-23-301-112.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 04/29/2014 $105,000 3,800 93,100 96,900

71-2014-4202168 71-03-23-301-123.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 06/03/2014 $131,000 3,800 98,200 102,000

71-2014-4203077 71-03-23-301-066.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109044 551 009 07/22/2014 $90,000 3,800 83,000 86,800

71-2014-4201485 71-03-18-401-034.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 04/30/2014 $300,000 40,300 305,400 345,700

71-2014-4201719 71-03-18-401-030.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 05/09/2014 $291,131 38,200 212,100 250,300

71-2014-4202310 71-03-18-329-005.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 06/11/2014 $267,900 35,300 208,300 243,600

71-2014-4202445 71-03-18-377-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 06/18/2014 $300,000 37,400 250,200 287,600

71-2014-4202518 71-03-18-330-007.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 06/20/2014 $255,000 38,800 219,200 258,000

71-2014-4203131 71-03-18-377-001.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 07/24/2014 $450,000 63,200 449,600 512,800

71-2014-4205892 71-03-18-401-016.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 12/03/2014 $195,400 35,500 201,800 237,300

71-2015-4200268 71-03-18-401-023.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109052 510 009 02/04/2015 $265,500 38,900 224,600 263,500

C71-2014-4200174 71-03-21-151-011.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109055 510 009 02/04/2014 $130,877 44,300 86,200 130,500

C71-2014-4200643 71-03-21-101-040.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109055 510 009 03/07/2014 $140,000 23,500 110,100 133,600

71-2014-4201488 71-03-22-126-048.000-009 N Res Imp None German 7109058 510 009 04/29/2014 $155,000 33,500 132,800 166,300

71-2015-4200479 71-08-29-426-001.000-010 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Greene 7110004 350 010 02/06/2015 $330,000 35,100 218,900 254,000

C71-2014-4200842 71-07-36-226-005.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110009 510 010 03/21/2014 $130,000 10,600 111,700 122,300

71-2014-4201530 71-07-36-226-010.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110009 510 010 05/01/2014 $85,000 10,700 98,400 109,100

71-2014-4202896 71-07-36-227-008.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110009 510 010 07/10/2014 $142,000 11,200 88,400 99,600

71-2014-4205373 71-07-36-276-004.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110009 510 010 11/06/2014 $130,500 10,400 95,400 105,800

71-2014-4202016 71-08-29-176-005.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110013 510 010 05/28/2014 $55,000 2,800 51,500 54,300

71-2014-4204186 71-08-29-251-007.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110013 510 010 09/11/2014 $35,400 3,600 38,000 41,600

71-2015-4200071 71-13-07-254-005.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110017 510 010 01/14/2015 $162,000 39,900 116,900 156,800

71-2014-4203260 71-13-07-251-002.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110017 510 010 07/29/2014 $110,000 20,600 74,800 95,400

71-2014-4203640 71-13-18-376-005.000-010 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Greene 7110019 501 010 08/15/2014 $50,000 28,200 0 28,200

71-2014-4201666 71-08-33-451-004.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110021 510 010 05/08/2014 $415,000 45,700 295,500 341,200

71-2014-4203294 71-12-13-300-013.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 07/31/2014 $335,000 63,200 192,900 256,100

C71-2014-4200729 71-08-33-176-001.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 03/13/2014 $114,500 24,300 90,400 114,700

71-2014-4203790 71-08-32-352-001.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 08/25/2014 $37,500 27,100 10,800 37,900

71-2014-4204105 71-08-32-126-003.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 09/08/2014 $100,000 21,400 75,500 96,900

71-2014-4205294 71-12-15-400-002.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 11/03/2014 $195,000 38,900 147,900 186,800

71-2014-4206438 71-08-28-200-005.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 12/29/2014 $275,000 46,900 265,200 312,100

71-2014-4204356 71-13-05-376-010.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 09/22/2014 $125,000 22,500 90,100 112,600

71-2014-4203862 71-13-07-376-006.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 08/27/2014 $165,000 37,800 101,000 138,800

C71-2014-4200668 71-13-07-226-009.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 03/05/2014 $185,000 17,000 152,400 169,400

71-2014-4202390 71-07-36-100-005.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 06/13/2014 $84,500 29,700 48,400 78,100

71-2014-4202384 71-13-05-100-007.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 06/13/2014 $208,000 37,400 118,600 156,000

71-2014-4202743 71-12-03-400-005.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 511 010 07/02/2014 $245,000 37,300 170,600 207,900

71-2014-4203684 71-12-10-200-001.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 08/19/2014 $225,000 40,500 169,200 209,700

71-2014-4203706 71-13-04-300-001.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 08/21/2014 $165,000 29,100 72,000 101,100

71-2014-4205889 71-12-18-400-006.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 12/03/2014 $125,000 22,300 102,000 124,300

71-2014-4206532 71-13-05-200-003.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 12/31/2014 $150,000 36,300 99,000 135,300

71-2015-4200500 71-07-36-251-002.000-010 N Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 02/26/2015 $139,500 20,800 76,800 97,600

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4206942 71-05-07-351-012.000-011 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7111013 430 011 01/22/2015 $615,000 206,300 285,300 491,600

71-2015-4200244 71-04-23-151-001.000-011 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7111015 450 011 01/29/2015 $358,700 120,700 143,300 264,000

71-2014-4201611 71-04-10-301-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111018 510 011 05/05/2014 $178,500 18,500 122,300 140,800

C71-2014-4200449 71-04-10-351-026.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111020 510 011 02/19/2014 $260,000 19,900 217,400 237,300

71-2014-4201216 71-04-10-327-034.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111020 510 011 04/09/2014 $199,000 24,900 168,700 193,600

71-2014-4203113 71-04-10-376-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111020 510 011 07/23/2014 $168,000 19,200 269,400 288,600

71-2014-4203593 71-04-10-305-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111020 510 011 08/08/2014 $285,000 19,200 220,300 239,500

71-2014-4205333 71-04-10-305-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111020 510 011 11/06/2014 $269,900 18,500 217,900 236,400

71-2014-4203974 71-04-10-353-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111022 510 011 09/02/2014 $218,000 37,200 170,300 207,500

71-2014-4205643 71-04-10-353-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111022 510 011 11/17/2014 $230,000 33,600 195,000 228,600

71-2014-4202719 71-04-10-329-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111025 510 011 07/03/2014 $275,000 20,200 157,300 177,500

71-2014-4204994 71-04-10-330-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111025 510 011 10/24/2014 $169,500 23,400 120,000 143,400

71-2014-4204101 71-04-10-451-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111027 510 011 09/08/2014 $207,000 16,900 125,800 142,700

71-2014-4204029 71-04-10-477-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111028 510 011 09/04/2014 $415,000 38,200 343,500 381,700

71-2014-4202045 71-04-11-426-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 04/29/2014 $320,000 68,000 243,000 311,000

71-2014-4201491 71-04-11-428-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 04/29/2014 $300,000 62,900 238,400 301,300

71-2014-4202175 71-04-11-329-022.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 06/05/2014 $395,000 63,700 324,200 387,900

71-2014-4202410 71-04-11-329-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 06/17/2014 $310,000 58,000 224,200 282,200

71-2014-4203117 71-04-11-329-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 07/23/2014 $265,000 51,000 206,400 257,400

71-2014-4203225 71-04-11-329-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 07/29/2014 $303,500 63,200 235,700 298,900

71-2014-4203561 71-04-12-301-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 08/11/2014 $380,000 65,200 262,100 327,300

71-2014-4203607 71-04-11-377-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 08/13/2014 $312,000 58,600 229,300 287,900

71-2014-4203781 71-04-12-301-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 08/22/2014 $315,000 67,900 260,400 328,300

71-2014-4203915 71-04-11-329-035.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 08/28/2014 $312,825 59,900 230,800 290,700

71-2014-4204648 71-04-11-329-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 10/06/2014 $342,000 60,400 248,600 309,000

71-2014-4204642 71-04-11-402-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 10/06/2014 $282,500 62,900 221,300 284,200

71-2014-4204828 71-04-11-430-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111030 510 011 10/13/2014 $309,900 56,100 224,700 280,800

71-2014-4201179 71-04-11-403-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111031 510 011 04/08/2014 $424,600 69,500 349,100 418,600

71-2014-4204701 71-04-11-327-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111031 510 011 10/07/2014 $450,000 74,000 352,900 426,900

71-2014-4205479 71-04-11-327-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111031 510 011 11/13/2014 $375,000 61,000 253,700 314,700

71-2014-4205529 71-04-11-327-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111031 510 011 11/18/2014 $375,000 70,100 300,700 370,800

71-2014-4206463 71-04-11-427-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111031 510 011 12/30/2014 $557,500 80,300 500,700 581,000

71-2014-4201226 71-04-12-305-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111033 510 011 04/14/2014 $522,500 57,800 289,600 347,400

71-2014-4203298 71-04-12-303-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111033 510 011 07/31/2014 $550,000 85,400 290,800 376,200

C71-2014-4200419 71-04-11-478-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 02/14/2014 $295,000 39,200 233,200 272,400

71-2014-4201223 71-04-11-451-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 04/14/2014 $255,000 22,900 213,000 235,900

71-2014-4202755 71-04-11-479-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 07/07/2014 $235,000 26,300 200,200 226,500

71-2014-4202877 71-04-11-476-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 07/14/2014 $329,000 24,400 296,700 321,100

71-2014-4203108 71-04-11-476-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 07/22/2014 $325,500 25,300 260,700 286,000

71-2014-4204799 71-04-11-476-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 10/08/2014 $367,000 25,400 278,400 303,800

71-2014-4205424 71-04-11-481-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 11/12/2014 $324,000 23,100 284,000 307,100

71-2014-4206368 71-04-11-455-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111035 510 011 12/22/2014 $351,890 17,500 259,800 277,300

71-2014-4201541 71-04-11-452-024.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111037 510 011 05/02/2014 $358,000 36,600 274,200 310,800

71-2014-4202718 71-04-11-452-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111037 510 011 07/02/2014 $400,500 31,600 291,600 323,200

71-2014-4202973 71-04-11-452-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111037 510 011 07/16/2014 $388,800 32,200 217,200 249,400

71-2014-4203523 71-04-11-452-028.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111037 510 011 08/06/2014 $387,000 32,200 239,500 271,700

71-2014-4201850 71-04-12-351-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111038 510 011 05/19/2014 $229,000 20,900 140,200 161,100

71-2015-4200443 71-05-18-327-014.000-011 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7111041 500 011 02/19/2015 $44,000 34,300 0 34,300

71-2014-4205340 71-04-26-126-007.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 11/06/2014 $115,000 26,900 83,600 110,500

C71-2014-4200065 71-04-13-251-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 01/16/2014 $125,000 37,700 70,800 108,500

C71-2014-4200102 71-05-09-355-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 01/17/2014 $268,000 35,500 163,600 199,100

71-2014-4201091 71-04-27-400-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 04/02/2014 $67,000 21,600 43,300 64,900

71-2014-4202184 71-04-27-400-027.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 06/05/2014 $165,000 32,800 103,100 135,900

71-2014-4202648 71-04-12-455-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 06/25/2014 $190,000 37,700 92,100 129,800

71-2014-4203610 71-05-08-405-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 08/12/2014 $135,000 35,800 93,200 129,000

71-2014-4203699 71-04-13-351-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 08/21/2014 $145,000 33,100 112,900 146,000

71-2014-4204298 71-04-13-201-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 09/16/2014 $390,000 50,300 273,500 323,800

71-2014-4204715 71-04-13-451-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 09/23/2014 $148,000 37,700 83,300 121,000

71-2014-4204469 71-04-10-477-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 09/29/2014 $165,000 41,400 101,000 142,400

71-2014-4204993 71-04-14-353-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 10/24/2014 $118,900 37,200 73,400 110,600

71-2014-4205847 71-05-08-405-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 12/03/2014 $129,900 35,500 100,000 135,500

71-2015-4200179 71-04-14-353-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 01/26/2015 $75,000 45,800 45,700 91,500

71-2014-4204304 71-05-29-400-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111045 510 011 09/17/2014 $85,000 32,700 47,600 80,300

C71-2014-4200323 71-04-12-452-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111047 510 011 02/11/2014 $175,000 26,300 142,600 168,900

71-2014-4201215 71-04-12-454-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111047 510 011 04/09/2014 $191,000 18,100 153,200 171,300

71-2014-4206362 71-04-12-451-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111047 510 011 12/22/2014 $170,000 17,800 147,700 165,500

71-2014-4201800 71-04-12-427-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111049 510 011 05/15/2014 $416,500 17,400 237,900 255,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204007 71-04-12-426-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111049 510 011 09/04/2014 $332,000 17,400 241,400 258,800

C71-2014-4200476 71-04-15-151-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 02/19/2014 $335,000 50,100 406,200 456,300

C71-2014-4200644 71-04-15-430-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 03/07/2014 $245,000 82,600 214,900 297,500

C71-2014-4200646 71-04-22-154-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 03/07/2014 $288,000 40,600 243,300 283,900

C71-2014-4200775 71-04-15-428-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 03/14/2014 $229,000 50,900 191,100 242,000

C71-2014-4200981 71-04-15-128-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 03/28/2014 $259,000 48,300 256,100 304,400

71-2014-4201377 71-04-22-129-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 04/22/2014 $278,000 53,600 215,000 268,600

71-2014-4201577 71-04-22-127-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/02/2014 $268,400 53,800 239,100 292,900

71-2014-4201558 71-04-15-177-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/02/2014 $170,000 49,200 243,400 292,600

71-2014-4201711 71-04-15-426-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/13/2014 $329,000 62,400 249,600 312,000

71-2014-4201871 71-04-15-329-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/19/2014 $363,500 54,800 367,800 422,600

71-2014-4202040 71-04-22-151-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/29/2014 $273,000 45,400 215,100 260,500

71-2014-4202058 71-04-15-152-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 05/30/2014 $600,000 56,500 489,200 545,700

71-2014-4202109 71-04-15-478-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 06/02/2014 $303,000 55,100 263,100 318,200

71-2014-4202172 71-04-15-326-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 06/04/2014 $230,000 47,000 259,500 306,500

71-2014-4202338 71-04-15-177-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 06/13/2014 $295,000 44,500 236,500 281,000

71-2014-4202608 71-04-22-130-022.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 06/26/2014 $305,000 40,600 264,400 305,000

71-2014-4202695 71-04-22-102-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/01/2014 $299,900 45,300 233,000 278,300

71-2014-4202752 71-04-15-104-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/07/2014 $306,000 55,800 227,800 283,600

71-2014-4202985 71-04-15-151-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/17/2014 $318,000 53,000 269,100 322,100

71-2014-4202862 71-04-22-177-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/20/2014 $310,000 42,600 245,200 287,800

71-2014-4203213 71-04-22-126-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/28/2014 $189,000 46,200 168,800 215,000

71-2014-4203215 71-04-22-179-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 07/28/2014 $290,000 46,600 253,100 299,700

71-2014-4203420 71-04-15-454-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 08/05/2014 $315,000 51,200 256,100 307,300

71-2014-4203529 71-04-22-176-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 08/07/2014 $223,000 43,500 184,900 228,400

71-2014-4203799 71-04-15-476-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 08/25/2014 $265,100 54,600 227,600 282,200

71-2014-4203857 71-04-22-126-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 08/26/2014 $245,000 35,100 203,700 238,800

71-2014-4203941 71-04-22-153-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 08/29/2014 $300,000 46,400 230,900 277,300

71-2014-4204120 71-04-15-405-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 09/09/2014 $298,000 47,100 214,400 261,500

71-2014-4204299 71-04-15-404-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 09/16/2014 $270,000 46,300 221,800 268,100

71-2014-4204348 71-04-15-353-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 09/18/2014 $304,000 47,600 238,100 285,700

71-2014-4206378 71-04-15-104-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 12/22/2014 $235,000 45,900 232,300 278,200

71-2014-4206468 71-04-15-301-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 12/30/2014 $332,000 56,100 263,000 319,100

71-2015-4200078 71-04-15-327-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 01/20/2015 $200,000 47,800 196,000 243,800

71-2015-4200495 71-04-15-379-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111051 510 011 02/25/2015 $275,000 36,500 226,300 262,800

71-2014-4203347 71-04-15-276-011.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 07/30/2014 $385,000 75,000 266,900 341,900

C71-2013-4207080 71-04-15-203-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 01/10/2014 $360,000 88,700 264,500 353,200

C71-2014-4200055 71-04-15-276-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 01/13/2014 $450,000 85,500 309,800 395,300

C71-2014-4200064 71-04-15-278-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 01/16/2014 $335,000 76,500 309,500 386,000

C71-2014-4200491 71-04-15-276-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 02/19/2014 $404,000 67,800 357,400 425,200

C71-2014-4200612 71-04-15-126-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 02/28/2014 $214,000 65,000 259,000 324,000

C71-2014-4200717 71-04-15-127-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 03/11/2014 $300,000 63,000 247,500 310,500

71-2014-4201489 71-04-15-354-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 04/30/2014 $410,000 74,800 337,000 411,800

71-2014-4201663 71-04-15-176-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 05/08/2014 $235,500 65,700 232,800 298,500

71-2014-4202274 71-04-15-477-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 06/12/2014 $446,000 80,400 333,700 414,100

71-2014-4202465 71-04-15-251-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 06/19/2014 $229,000 58,600 225,700 284,300

71-2014-4202723 71-04-15-453-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 07/03/2014 $400,000 74,500 254,900 329,400

71-2014-4202834 71-04-15-429-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 07/09/2014 $454,000 77,500 324,700 402,200

71-2014-4203968 71-04-22-103-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 09/02/2014 $340,000 56,100 267,500 323,600

71-2014-4205335 71-04-15-203-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 11/06/2014 $318,500 75,400 241,700 317,100

71-2014-4206397 71-04-15-276-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 12/22/2014 $450,000 67,800 337,500 405,300

C71-2014-4200448 71-04-14-201-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 02/19/2014 $330,000 74,000 250,200 324,200

71-2014-4201036 71-04-14-102-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 04/02/2014 $395,500 71,900 292,400 364,300

71-2014-4201209 71-04-14-102-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 04/10/2014 $310,000 70,300 234,700 305,000

71-2014-4201635 71-04-14-226-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 05/07/2014 $412,000 87,300 310,700 398,000

71-2014-4201641 71-04-14-227-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 05/08/2014 $410,000 71,000 306,800 377,800

71-2014-4202454 71-04-14-277-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 06/18/2014 $449,000 71,600 356,000 427,600

71-2014-4202800 71-04-14-178-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111055 510 011 07/03/2014 $292,500 94,100 217,400 311,500

C71-2014-4200389 71-04-14-252-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 02/13/2014 $830,000 156,900 375,100 532,000

C71-2013-4207282 71-04-14-252-032.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 02/19/2014 $575,000 123,000 365,500 488,500

71-2014-4201403 71-04-14-251-023.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 04/25/2014 $490,000 137,800 350,700 488,500

71-2014-4201801 71-04-14-252-038.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 05/15/2014 $422,500 111,500 309,600 421,100

71-2014-4202451 71-04-14-252-026.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 06/18/2014 $569,900 148,300 416,000 564,300

71-2014-4202853 71-04-14-251-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 07/10/2014 $542,000 111,500 350,200 461,700

71-2014-4203633 71-04-14-153-023.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 08/14/2014 $825,000 159,900 648,800 808,700

71-2014-4203738 71-04-14-153-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 08/18/2014 $525,000 111,500 333,000 444,500

71-2014-4206183 71-04-14-153-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 12/16/2014 $525,000 121,800 374,200 496,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4206364 71-04-14-251-025.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111056 510 011 12/22/2014 $442,000 139,800 319,300 459,100

C71-2014-4200172 71-04-14-334-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 02/04/2014 $175,000 28,800 142,100 170,900

C71-2014-4200485 71-04-14-334-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 02/19/2014 $162,000 28,000 136,800 164,800

71-2014-4201088 71-04-14-332-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 04/03/2014 $189,000 28,500 160,200 188,700

71-2014-4201427 71-04-14-452-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 04/23/2014 $178,000 31,000 150,600 181,600

71-2014-4201546 71-04-14-334-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 05/01/2014 $171,000 27,800 153,400 181,200

71-2014-4200162 71-04-14-303-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 05/01/2014 $225,000 28,600 184,500 213,100

71-2014-4202191 71-04-14-452-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 06/03/2014 $135,000 52,600 88,000 140,600

71-2014-4202206 71-04-14-305-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 06/06/2014 $227,500 34,700 191,300 226,000

71-2014-4202961 71-04-14-303-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 07/15/2014 $264,900 30,300 222,500 252,800

71-2014-4203005 71-04-14-329-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 07/16/2014 $183,000 30,500 142,700 173,200

71-2014-4203985 71-04-14-305-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 08/29/2014 $229,000 42,600 168,100 210,700

71-2014-4204160 71-04-14-305-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 09/10/2014 $239,900 26,500 182,300 208,800

71-2014-4204214 71-04-14-326-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 09/12/2014 $295,000 34,100 217,000 251,100

71-2014-4204328 71-04-14-302-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 09/19/2014 $330,000 32,000 306,600 338,600

71-2014-4204530 71-04-14-331-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 10/02/2014 $210,000 27,000 149,700 176,700

71-2014-4204513 71-04-14-334-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 10/02/2014 $165,000 31,500 168,200 199,700

71-2014-4204699 71-04-14-305-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 10/07/2014 $238,900 32,400 195,200 227,600

71-2014-4206238 71-04-14-305-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 12/17/2014 $225,000 29,100 198,100 227,200

71-2014-4206838 71-04-14-330-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111063 510 011 01/22/2015 $235,000 28,900 191,800 220,700

C71-2014-4200439 71-04-22-201-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 02/18/2014 $122,000 18,900 99,100 118,000

71-2014-4202141 71-04-22-252-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 06/04/2014 $156,000 18,900 134,500 153,400

71-2014-4202824 71-04-22-252-027.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 07/08/2014 $136,700 18,500 118,800 137,300

71-2014-4202895 71-04-22-252-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 07/11/2014 $139,900 18,900 137,400 156,300

71-2014-4204596 71-04-22-253-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 10/03/2014 $147,000 16,100 131,900 148,000

71-2014-4206835 71-04-22-179-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111064 510 011 01/22/2015 $116,000 17,700 91,400 109,100

C71-2014-4200096 71-04-23-228-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 01/22/2014 $185,000 17,300 143,800 161,100

C71-2014-4200127 71-04-24-152-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 01/23/2014 $158,500 21,700 132,700 154,400

C71-2014-4200344 71-04-24-103-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 02/06/2014 $178,400 17,300 181,400 198,700

C71-2014-4200460 71-04-24-103-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 02/21/2014 $129,900 17,300 159,800 177,100

71-2014-4200991 71-04-23-203-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 03/31/2014 $137,500 17,300 120,000 137,300

71-2014-4201034 71-04-23-227-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 04/02/2014 $166,900 17,300 149,700 167,000

71-2014-4201362 71-04-24-127-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 04/21/2014 $260,000 20,800 215,100 235,900

71-2014-4202999 71-04-24-127-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 07/17/2014 $222,500 25,500 191,000 216,500

71-2014-4204169 71-04-23-228-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 09/10/2014 $145,000 17,300 129,800 147,100

71-2014-4204936 71-04-24-126-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 10/17/2014 $175,000 23,800 156,700 180,500

71-2014-4205665 71-04-24-101-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 11/25/2014 $178,000 18,000 158,000 176,000

71-2014-4206064 71-04-24-128-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 12/12/2014 $220,000 21,200 209,200 230,400

71-2015-4200202 71-04-24-176-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111066 510 011 01/29/2015 $157,000 24,600 150,500 175,100

71-2014-4204022 71-04-26-131-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111070 510 011 09/04/2014 $235,000 17,700 155,500 173,200

71-2014-4206192 71-04-26-127-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111070 510 011 12/18/2014 $167,000 24,400 166,400 190,800

71-2015-4200352 71-04-26-102-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111070 510 011 02/11/2015 $217,500 18,400 137,400 155,800

71-2014-4202324 71-04-26-151-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111071 510 011 06/11/2014 $321,500 29,100 267,600 296,700

71-2014-4203691 71-05-07-404-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111074 510 011 08/20/2014 $175,000 15,400 135,400 150,800

71-2014-4205336 71-05-07-403-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111074 510 011 11/06/2014 $153,500 15,300 119,100 134,400

C71-2014-4200614 71-05-08-378-019.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 02/28/2014 $210,000 21,600 161,700 183,300

C71-2014-4200714 71-05-08-329-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 03/11/2014 $179,900 21,500 141,600 163,100

71-2014-4201189 71-05-08-378-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 04/09/2014 $192,000 26,500 160,000 186,500

71-2014-4201231 71-05-08-402-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 04/14/2014 $142,000 21,100 122,400 143,500

71-2014-4201905 71-05-08-328-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 05/21/2014 $178,000 22,300 156,700 179,000

71-2014-4201916 71-05-08-329-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 05/21/2014 $172,000 23,000 139,200 162,200

71-2014-4202309 71-05-08-328-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 06/11/2014 $169,500 23,000 147,700 170,700

71-2014-4202708 71-05-08-380-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 07/02/2014 $265,000 27,900 178,100 206,000

71-2014-4202931 71-05-08-381-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 07/11/2014 $191,250 22,300 156,500 178,800

71-2014-4203310 71-05-08-328-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 08/01/2014 $219,000 22,600 190,500 213,100

71-2014-4203613 71-05-08-326-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 08/13/2014 $192,500 21,500 147,400 168,900

71-2014-4204652 71-05-08-329-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 10/06/2014 $190,000 21,100 146,400 167,500

71-2014-4206542 71-05-08-329-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 12/31/2014 $188,500 27,200 168,000 195,200

71-2015-4200271 71-05-08-351-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 02/04/2015 $130,800 25,300 114,900 140,200

71-2015-4200461 71-05-08-326-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111076 510 011 02/18/2015 $174,000 28,900 144,400 173,300

71-2014-4203393 71-05-08-431-003.000-011 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7111079 500 011 08/04/2014 $19,500 19,700 0 19,700

71-2014-4202631 71-05-08-478-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111081 510 011 06/25/2014 $451,000 43,100 354,700 397,800

C71-2014-4200120 71-05-09-452-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 01/30/2014 $189,000 27,600 172,900 200,500

C71-2014-4200901 71-05-09-378-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 03/24/2014 $190,000 27,100 186,500 213,600

C71-2014-4200965 71-05-09-331-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 03/26/2014 $187,500 27,900 189,200 217,100

71-2014-4201339 71-05-08-427-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 04/21/2014 $170,000 29,600 144,800 174,400

71-2014-4201511 71-05-09-303-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 04/30/2014 $221,000 24,700 180,000 204,700

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4201629 71-05-09-328-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 05/08/2014 $236,000 26,700 210,300 237,000

71-2014-4201751 71-05-09-330-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 05/14/2014 $210,000 27,000 184,400 211,400

71-2014-4201896 71-05-09-353-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 05/21/2014 $220,000 25,900 181,900 207,800

71-2014-4201958 71-05-09-329-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 05/23/2014 $267,500 27,300 214,500 241,800

71-2014-4202690 71-05-09-329-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 07/01/2014 $258,900 26,300 238,900 265,200

71-2014-4202720 71-05-09-301-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 07/03/2014 $194,900 34,800 238,300 273,100

71-2014-4202831 71-05-09-377-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 07/09/2014 $241,500 25,700 173,600 199,300

71-2014-4203582 71-05-09-329-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 08/13/2014 $289,000 29,700 221,400 251,100

71-2014-4203870 71-05-09-304-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 08/28/2014 $187,000 25,300 185,800 211,100

71-2014-4203891 71-05-09-403-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 08/28/2014 $195,000 27,000 178,300 205,300

71-2014-4204148 71-05-09-303-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 09/10/2014 $202,000 25,700 176,100 201,800

71-2014-4204547 71-05-09-302-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 09/24/2014 $190,900 26,300 156,200 182,500

71-2014-4205722 71-05-09-378-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 11/17/2014 $219,450 27,800 192,300 220,100

71-2014-4205655 71-05-09-331-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 11/17/2014 $224,000 30,900 189,400 220,300

71-2014-4206216 71-05-09-353-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111083 510 011 12/16/2014 $143,000 32,200 131,800 164,000

71-2014-4203161 71-05-17-101-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111087 510 011 07/24/2014 $210,000 30,900 177,600 208,500

71-2014-4203806 71-05-17-154-002.000-011 Y Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7111088 500 011 08/22/2014 $45,000 55,600 0 55,600

C71-2014-4200319 71-05-17-129-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 02/04/2014 $161,000 22,500 138,500 161,000

C71-2014-4200450 71-05-17-129-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 02/19/2014 $163,900 22,200 151,600 173,800

71-2014-4201929 71-05-17-182-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 05/22/2014 $192,500 24,800 182,700 207,500

71-2014-4202666 71-05-17-184-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 06/27/2014 $185,000 24,200 157,100 181,300

71-2014-4203538 71-05-17-128-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 08/08/2014 $184,500 22,900 159,900 182,800

71-2014-4204225 71-05-17-178-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111091 510 011 09/12/2014 $187,000 25,400 164,100 189,500

C71-2014-4200809 71-05-16-228-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 03/19/2014 $205,000 10,900 194,300 205,200

71-2014-4202889 71-05-16-280-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 07/10/2014 $239,900 10,900 228,000 238,900

71-2014-4203212 71-05-16-231-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 07/28/2014 $168,500 11,700 192,700 204,400

71-2014-4203563 71-05-16-229-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 08/11/2014 $208,000 11,200 234,600 245,800

71-2014-4205555 71-05-16-226-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 11/19/2014 $234,000 14,100 193,500 207,600

71-2015-4200181 71-05-16-280-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 01/27/2015 $245,000 13,300 203,600 216,900

71-2014-4206890 71-05-16-254-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 02/04/2015 $182,000 14,200 177,700 191,900

71-2015-4200367 71-05-16-255-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111092 510 011 02/11/2015 $355,000 21,800 311,000 332,800

C71-2014-4200967 71-05-18-426-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 03/26/2014 $147,500 11,100 133,200 144,300

71-2014-4201246 71-05-18-432-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 04/15/2014 $139,000 11,400 131,800 143,200

71-2014-4201912 71-05-18-253-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 05/21/2014 $138,500 12,300 106,900 119,200

71-2014-4202035 71-05-18-201-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 05/29/2014 $120,900 15,300 102,700 118,000

71-2014-4202250 71-05-18-430-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 06/09/2014 $143,000 11,600 143,300 154,900

71-2014-4202531 71-05-18-403-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 06/20/2014 $125,000 10,400 103,700 114,100

71-2014-4202891 71-05-18-406-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 07/10/2014 $191,000 12,500 196,800 209,300

71-2014-4202988 71-05-18-426-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 07/17/2014 $145,000 12,500 133,800 146,300

71-2014-4203184 71-05-18-254-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 07/25/2014 $149,000 12,000 130,200 142,200

71-2014-4204385 71-05-18-431-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 09/22/2014 $151,500 14,200 143,500 157,700

71-2014-4204539 71-05-18-201-023.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 09/24/2014 $165,000 12,300 174,400 186,700

71-2014-4204658 71-05-18-201-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 09/25/2014 $121,900 12,800 100,500 113,300

71-2014-4205244 71-05-18-405-014.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 10/31/2014 $139,000 13,300 115,400 128,700

71-2014-4205651 71-05-18-430-021.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 11/17/2014 $142,000 14,200 168,400 182,600

71-2014-4205948 71-05-18-278-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 12/09/2014 $128,500 12,300 100,600 112,900

71-2014-4205960 71-05-18-278-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 12/09/2014 $142,500 13,400 130,100 143,500

71-2014-4206379 71-05-18-277-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 12/22/2014 $143,500 12,000 112,800 124,800

71-2015-4200422 71-05-18-404-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111094 510 011 02/17/2015 $130,000 11,100 123,200 134,300

71-2014-4203031 71-05-16-426-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111095 510 011 07/17/2014 $128,000 20,900 121,100 142,000

71-2014-4201150 71-05-18-377-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 04/07/2014 $115,500 20,100 106,800 126,900

71-2014-4201878 71-05-18-352-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 05/21/2014 $117,000 20,700 111,500 132,200

71-2014-4202301 71-05-19-127-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 06/11/2014 $158,000 25,000 120,900 145,900

71-2014-4202621 71-05-18-356-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 06/25/2014 $135,000 23,300 110,000 133,300

71-2014-4202822 71-05-19-179-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 07/08/2014 $98,000 19,800 87,500 107,300

71-2014-4204173 71-05-19-129-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 09/11/2014 $130,000 19,200 87,100 106,300

71-2014-4204633 71-05-19-130-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 10/06/2014 $133,000 21,100 98,600 119,700

71-2014-4206144 71-05-19-129-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 12/15/2014 $127,000 15,600 97,500 113,100

71-2014-4206679 71-05-18-378-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 12/20/2014 $137,000 19,400 97,200 116,600

71-2014-4206445 71-05-18-381-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111097 510 011 12/30/2014 $114,000 19,400 89,900 109,300

C71-2014-4200113 71-05-19-251-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 01/22/2014 $218,000 17,000 163,500 180,500

71-2014-4201074 71-05-19-209-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 04/03/2014 $175,000 24,400 157,900 182,300

71-2014-4201375 71-05-19-201-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 04/22/2014 $188,500 14,800 138,600 153,400

71-2014-4203678 71-05-18-453-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 08/19/2014 $200,000 15,800 145,100 160,900

71-2014-4203969 71-05-19-254-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 09/02/2014 $145,000 17,500 137,800 155,300

71-2014-4204624 71-05-19-204-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 09/30/2014 $110,000 19,100 135,200 154,300

71-2014-4205459 71-05-19-201-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 11/13/2014 $150,000 19,900 138,400 158,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2015-4200411 71-05-19-203-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111099 510 011 02/13/2015 $155,000 19,100 122,000 141,100

71-2014-4203190 71-05-20-104-001.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 07/25/2014 $210,000 25,800 169,700 195,500

C71-2014-4200749 71-05-18-476-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 03/12/2014 $134,000 19,400 116,600 136,000

C71-2014-4200839 71-05-19-229-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 03/21/2014 $140,000 14,600 154,100 168,700

71-2014-4201061 71-05-19-227-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 04/01/2014 $143,800 21,700 138,200 159,900

71-2014-4201249 71-05-19-229-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 04/15/2014 $185,000 18,600 165,700 184,300

71-2014-4201627 71-05-20-101-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 05/07/2014 $152,500 18,600 135,100 153,700

71-2014-4201856 71-05-17-355-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 05/19/2014 $197,000 22,100 144,400 166,500

71-2014-4202939 71-05-20-101-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 07/14/2014 $205,000 18,600 184,300 202,900

71-2014-4204164 71-05-18-480-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 09/10/2014 $157,000 18,000 123,100 141,100

71-2014-4204723 71-05-20-105-010.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 09/23/2014 $170,000 30,300 184,400 214,700

71-2014-4204568 71-05-18-479-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 09/24/2014 $155,000 19,400 142,500 161,900

71-2014-4206283 71-05-20-104-022.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 12/23/2014 $195,000 23,900 212,500 236,400

71-2014-4203423 71-05-17-456-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111103 510 011 08/05/2014 $169,500 19,900 127,300 147,200

71-2014-4203661 71-05-17-455-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111104 510 011 08/18/2014 $173,000 23,400 131,800 155,200

C71-2014-4200715 71-05-17-477-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111106 510 011 03/11/2014 $180,000 28,800 190,100 218,900

71-2014-4202462 71-05-17-453-033.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111106 510 011 06/19/2014 $287,000 28,300 246,300 274,600

71-2014-4201900 71-05-19-277-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111108 510 011 05/21/2014 $257,500 15,900 179,800 195,700

71-2014-4205983 71-05-19-277-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111108 510 011 12/10/2014 $156,000 18,300 121,800 140,100

71-2014-4206290 71-05-19-276-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111108 510 011 12/17/2014 $246,500 26,300 162,400 188,700

71-2014-4201354 71-05-16-452-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 04/21/2014 $135,000 26,400 106,700 133,100

71-2014-4202650 71-05-21-227-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 06/25/2014 $140,000 24,800 125,500 150,300

71-2014-4204326 71-05-21-202-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 09/19/2014 $142,000 36,300 106,800 143,100

71-2014-4205347 71-05-16-453-017.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 11/06/2014 $123,000 23,600 99,000 122,600

71-2014-4205636 71-05-16-452-012.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 11/17/2014 $142,000 26,200 121,900 148,100

71-2015-4200163 71-05-16-455-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 01/23/2015 $140,000 23,600 104,600 128,200

71-2015-4200303 71-05-16-455-003.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111110 510 011 02/10/2015 $162,500 23,600 130,100 153,700

C71-2014-4200063 71-05-21-255-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111111 510 011 01/17/2014 $167,500 24,300 134,100 158,400

71-2014-4201052 71-05-21-255-007.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111111 510 011 04/02/2014 $156,500 21,900 136,600 158,500

71-2014-4203476 71-05-21-253-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111111 510 011 08/06/2014 $179,900 19,900 142,300 162,200

71-2014-4203553 71-05-21-254-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111111 510 011 08/08/2014 $175,000 21,300 153,900 175,200

71-2014-4204713 71-05-21-255-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111111 510 011 09/23/2014 $190,000 20,700 161,600 182,300

C71-2014-4200445 71-05-28-204-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111112 510 011 02/14/2014 $219,000 17,700 171,500 189,200

71-2014-4204505 71-05-28-205-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111112 510 011 10/02/2014 $219,000 17,400 152,400 169,800

71-2014-4205638 71-05-28-207-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111112 510 011 11/24/2014 $212,450 18,000 171,700 189,700

71-2015-4200304 71-05-28-207-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111112 510 011 02/10/2015 $300,000 22,400 219,700 242,100

71-2014-4201682 71-05-28-477-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111114 510 011 05/09/2014 $103,000 17,400 72,900 90,300

C71-2013-4207097 71-04-13-102-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 01/14/2014 $162,000 31,100 135,500 166,600

C71-2014-4200108 71-04-13-152-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 01/22/2014 $250,000 32,400 201,500 233,900

C71-2014-4200355 71-04-13-101-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 02/10/2014 $218,000 69,400 184,900 254,300

C71-2014-4200543 71-04-13-178-001.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 02/24/2014 $232,500 29,300 185,500 214,800

71-2014-4201211 71-04-13-101-035.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 04/10/2014 $209,900 33,200 170,500 203,700

71-2014-4201323 71-04-13-153-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 04/17/2014 $218,500 32,700 176,100 208,800

71-2014-4201574 71-04-13-179-013.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 05/02/2014 $320,000 40,600 273,900 314,500

71-2014-4202200 71-04-13-156-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 06/06/2014 $242,500 39,500 194,400 233,900

71-2014-4202618 71-04-13-101-028.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 06/26/2014 $298,000 35,400 254,100 289,500

71-2014-4202613 71-04-13-103-009.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 06/26/2014 $185,000 30,400 148,800 179,200

71-2014-4202678 71-04-13-180-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 06/27/2014 $220,000 35,000 192,100 227,100

71-2014-4204342 71-04-13-101-026.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 09/17/2014 $235,000 31,600 199,500 231,100

71-2014-4204716 71-04-13-152-016.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 09/23/2014 $205,001 34,100 175,100 209,200

71-2014-4204617 71-04-13-130-006.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 09/30/2014 $210,000 32,300 153,600 185,900

71-2014-4204645 71-04-13-152-021.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111116 510 011 10/06/2014 $255,000 36,900 229,400 266,300

71-2014-4203445 71-04-22-327-020.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111121 510 011 08/03/2014 $75,900 11,900 48,700 60,600

71-2014-4203594 71-04-22-329-005.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111121 510 011 08/13/2014 $82,500 14,100 38,300 52,400

71-2014-4203733 71-04-22-327-008.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111121 510 011 08/20/2014 $57,000 12,300 37,100 49,400

71-2014-4206301 71-04-14-402-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111126 510 011 12/17/2014 $915,000 48,900 754,000 802,900

C71-2014-4200632 71-05-28-278-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111127 510 011 03/05/2014 $163,000 30,300 134,200 164,500

71-2014-4205981 71-05-28-251-036.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111127 510 011 12/10/2014 $205,000 32,000 152,900 184,900

71-2014-4201078 71-05-09-479-018.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111128 510 011 04/03/2014 $350,000 37,500 258,800 296,300

71-2014-4202806 71-05-09-476-015.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111128 510 011 07/03/2014 $307,000 35,700 213,300 249,000

71-2014-4205654 71-05-09-476-011.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111128 510 011 11/25/2014 $449,066 37,800 298,800 336,600

71-2015-4200209 71-05-09-478-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111128 510 011 02/02/2015 $570,500 54,100 362,700 416,800

71-2014-4203484 71-04-14-103-004.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111129 510 011 08/06/2014 $532,000 56,000 467,000 523,000

71-2014-4205349 71-05-09-479-002.000-011 N Res Imp None Harris 7111134 510 011 11/06/2014 $533,000 63,200 371,900 435,100

71-2014-4201842 71-04-22-301-029.000-036 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7130510 500 036 05/19/2014 $25,000 30,500 0 30,500

71-2014-4201841 71-04-22-301-024.000-036 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7130510 500 036 05/19/2014 $27,000 26,800 0 26,800

71-2014-4201944 71-04-27-102-007.000-036 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7136004 447 036 05/01/2014 $165,000 22,800 167,600 190,400

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2015-4200245 71-04-27-101-005.000-036 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7136004 450 036 01/29/2015 $472,400 247,100 193,800 440,900

71-2014-4201359 71-04-27-376-006.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136006 510 036 04/21/2014 $149,000 31,200 96,600 127,800

71-2014-4201886 71-04-27-377-006.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136006 510 036 05/21/2014 $159,000 20,600 105,400 126,000

71-2014-4203473 71-04-27-379-011.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136008 510 036 08/06/2014 $150,000 20,100 114,400 134,500

71-2014-4204274 71-04-27-327-011.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136008 510 036 09/15/2014 $163,500 24,500 135,600 160,100

71-2014-4205535 71-04-27-378-025.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136008 510 036 11/18/2014 $164,000 26,200 132,000 158,200

71-2014-4206359 71-04-27-379-006.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136008 510 036 12/22/2014 $158,000 23,000 121,100 144,100

C71-2013-4207010 71-04-27-328-005.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136009 510 036 01/08/2014 $165,000 44,500 134,700 179,200

71-2014-4203630 71-04-27-328-026.000-036 N Res Imp None Harris 7136009 510 036 08/14/2014 $185,000 40,500 142,200 182,700

71-2014-4203074 71-12-19-200-012.000-034 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 07/21/2014 $270,000 64,700 177,500 242,200

C71-2013-4207275 71-11-25-400-003.000-034 N Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 02/14/2014 $79,000 38,800 51,800 90,600

71-2014-4204016 71-12-21-476-001.000-034 N Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 09/04/2014 $166,000 41,600 132,400 174,000

71-2014-4204436 71-18-18-300-002.000-034 N Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 09/26/2014 $85,000 35,600 47,600 83,200

71-2015-4200017 71-17-02-100-003.000-034 N Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 01/07/2015 $129,000 38,800 93,300 132,100

71-2015-4200066 71-17-04-100-006.000-034 N Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 01/14/2015 $159,900 43,000 106,100 149,100

71-2014-4201692 71-12-28-100-058.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135001 510 035 05/12/2014 $230,000 66,000 161,900 227,900

C71-2014-4200565 71-12-32-254-011.000-035 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 02/27/2014 $70,000 35,300 31,300 66,600

C71-2014-4200622 71-12-32-229-004.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 03/04/2014 $93,500 11,600 71,500 83,100

71-2014-4200989 71-12-28-354-004.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 03/31/2014 $89,900 14,100 68,900 83,000

71-2014-4201515 71-12-32-235-005.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 04/30/2014 $37,000 14,400 27,100 41,500

71-2014-4202480 71-12-32-479-025.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 06/19/2014 $136,000 15,100 99,800 114,900

71-2014-4202878 71-12-32-229-005.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 07/10/2014 $78,000 14,700 83,000 97,700

71-2014-4202928 71-12-28-358-014.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 07/11/2014 $47,500 11,100 41,100 52,200

71-2014-4203528 71-12-32-202-017.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/01/2014 $57,500 12,800 52,400 65,200

71-2014-4203439 71-12-28-304-003.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/04/2014 $96,000 13,000 57,100 70,100

71-2014-4203585 71-12-29-429-002.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/06/2014 $82,000 11,700 47,200 58,900

71-2014-4203687 71-12-28-303-006.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 08/19/2014 $89,000 18,700 59,100 77,800

71-2014-4204347 71-12-32-254-010.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 09/18/2014 $89,500 23,400 71,300 94,700

71-2014-4204611 71-12-32-202-007.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 09/30/2014 $155,000 23,900 110,300 134,200

71-2014-4204798 71-12-32-479-026.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/10/2014 $151,000 15,400 95,500 110,900

71-2014-4204912 71-12-33-102-002.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/15/2014 $95,500 10,400 35,600 46,000

71-2014-4205102 71-12-32-478-003.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 10/23/2014 $139,000 22,300 94,600 116,900

71-2014-4205342 71-12-28-358-002.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 11/06/2014 $35,000 10,200 21,400 31,600

71-2014-4206426 71-12-32-202-019.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 12/29/2014 $86,000 11,000 68,600 79,600

C71-2014-4200342 71-12-32-256-003.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135023 510 035 02/06/2014 $83,000 33,100 52,800 85,900

71-2014-4203693 71-12-32-256-002.000-035 N Res Imp None Liberty 7135023 510 035 08/15/2014 $88,000 34,500 42,100 76,600

C71-2014-4200114 71-16-13-400-001.000-014 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7114003 511 014 01/22/2014 $207,000 53,900 146,400 200,300

71-2014-4203303 71-16-12-100-003.000-014 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7114003 513 014 07/31/2014 $150,000 107,300 78,000 185,300

71-2014-4203741 71-16-15-200-007.000-014 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7114003 511 014 08/20/2014 $282,500 50,700 239,200 289,900

71-2014-4204899 71-16-25-400-009.000-014 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7114003 511 014 10/15/2014 $230,000 41,900 143,400 185,300

71-2015-4200084 71-16-10-400-001.000-014 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7114003 513 014 01/20/2015 $130,000 107,300 48,300 155,600

C71-2014-4200588 71-16-24-355-009.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 02/27/2014 $42,000 5,400 38,100 43,500

71-2014-4201599 71-16-23-426-016.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 05/05/2014 $63,000 5,200 61,000 66,200

71-2014-4202044 71-16-25-127-008.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 05/29/2014 $81,000 8,700 104,000 112,700

71-2014-4202165 71-16-23-477-008.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 06/04/2014 $79,000 5,100 60,100 65,200

71-2014-4202269 71-16-24-380-002.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 06/10/2014 $57,000 9,300 53,000 62,300

71-2014-4202936 71-16-25-101-006.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 07/14/2014 $70,000 6,900 84,500 91,400

71-2014-4203169 71-16-24-453-001.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 07/25/2014 $140,000 33,000 126,700 159,700

71-2014-4204735 71-16-25-105-001.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/07/2014 $68,500 8,600 86,900 95,500

71-2014-4205103 71-16-23-479-011.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/23/2014 $117,000 11,500 91,800 103,300

71-2014-4205168 71-16-25-102-006.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 10/29/2014 $112,000 8,400 86,000 94,400

71-2014-4205558 71-16-24-333-010.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 11/20/2014 $85,000 6,800 72,600 79,400

71-2014-4206196 71-16-24-360-006.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115010 510 015 12/16/2014 $100,000 8,600 85,500 94,100

71-2014-4202265 71-16-26-204-011.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115012 510 015 06/10/2014 $113,000 10,800 101,500 112,300

71-2014-4204865 71-16-26-280-002.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115012 510 015 10/14/2014 $86,500 20,200 66,900 87,100

71-2014-4206446 71-16-26-205-006.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115012 510 015 12/30/2014 $80,000 10,400 74,200 84,600

71-2014-4206865 71-16-26-203-005.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115012 510 015 01/23/2015 $90,000 10,400 86,700 97,100

71-2014-4202903 71-16-13-327-006.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 07/11/2014 $165,400 7,400 153,600 161,000

71-2014-4204833 71-16-13-327-005.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 10/13/2014 $170,000 7,500 189,300 196,800

71-2014-4204888 71-16-13-326-005.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 10/16/2014 $181,900 7,300 178,300 185,600

71-2014-4205345 71-16-13-326-008.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 11/06/2014 $109,000 7,600 130,200 137,800

71-2014-4205848 71-16-26-280-010.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 12/03/2014 $165,400 9,400 147,100 156,500

71-2014-4205885 71-16-26-280-013.000-015 N Res Imp None Lincoln 7115018 510 015 12/04/2014 $164,617 6,000 136,700 142,700

71-2014-4201722 71-14-34-377-002.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116005 510 016 05/13/2014 $42,000 6,500 42,700 49,200

71-2014-4203505 71-14-20-200-001.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116005 511 016 08/07/2014 $205,000 43,700 140,200 183,900

71-2014-4202596 71-14-16-426-001.000-016 Y Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 06/26/2014 $112,000 63,900 24,200 88,100

71-2014-4201662 71-14-35-200-002.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 05/09/2014 $130,000 44,700 100,900 145,600

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4201691 71-14-17-200-003.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 05/12/2014 $223,000 45,300 225,500 270,800

71-2014-4206405 71-14-15-351-001.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116006 510 016 12/29/2014 $117,500 37,700 62,500 100,200

71-2015-4200219 71-14-35-100-005.000-016 N Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 01/28/2015 $109,000 40,700 72,000 112,700

C71-2014-4200428 71-06-03-152-008.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117010 510 017 02/14/2014 $192,000 15,200 136,100 151,300

71-2014-4204486 71-06-03-153-014.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117010 510 017 09/30/2014 $157,000 23,100 117,900 141,000

71-2014-4205634 71-06-03-176-002.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117010 510 017 11/17/2014 $174,000 16,400 124,500 140,900

71-2015-4200502 71-06-03-152-001.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117010 510 017 02/25/2015 $137,000 15,200 110,200 125,400

C71-2013-4207336 71-06-03-227-002.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117013 511 017 03/18/2014 $56,800 23,600 43,400 67,000

71-2014-4202154 71-06-02-303-001.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117014 510 017 06/04/2014 $220,000 29,000 187,800 216,800

71-2014-4202550 71-06-02-302-008.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117014 510 017 06/24/2014 $218,000 19,500 143,700 163,200

71-2014-4203845 71-06-02-352-007.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117014 510 017 08/26/2014 $225,000 20,400 185,600 206,000

71-2014-4204327 71-01-35-301-008.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117015 510 017 09/19/2014 $160,000 9,500 103,800 113,300

C71-2014-4200968 71-02-33-400-001.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117018 510 017 03/26/2014 $155,000 26,600 126,500 153,100

71-2014-4201755 71-01-25-400-007.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117018 510 017 05/14/2014 $116,326 22,500 75,700 98,200

71-2014-4206780 71-06-02-326-007.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117018 510 017 01/12/2015 $289,484 56,000 225,400 281,400

71-2014-4202966 71-07-29-200-002.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117020 510 017 07/15/2014 $142,000 20,700 81,900 102,600

71-2014-4204100 71-07-29-400-004.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117020 510 017 09/08/2014 $170,000 23,000 111,900 134,900

71-2014-4206452 71-07-20-400-003.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117020 510 017 12/30/2014 $115,500 14,700 91,800 106,500

71-2014-4203527 71-06-03-102-011.000-017 N Res Imp None Olive 7117023 510 017 08/07/2014 $175,000 19,600 130,800 150,400

71-2014-4201830 71-06-02-351-007.000-017 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Olive 7117024 500 017 05/19/2014 $27,500 20,300 0 20,300

71-2014-4204251 71-01-34-233-015.000-018 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Olive 7118005 455 018 06/24/2014 $140,000 24,800 43,000 67,800

71-2014-4206603 71-01-34-129-025.000-018 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Olive 7118005 420 018 12/30/2014 $49,900 29,100 43,000 72,100

C71-2014-4200311 71-01-34-129-006.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 02/05/2014 $68,000 14,200 55,800 70,000

C71-2014-4200801 71-01-34-202-009.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 03/18/2014 $93,000 15,800 79,200 95,000

C71-2014-4200814 71-01-34-206-003.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 03/20/2014 $90,000 12,400 57,300 69,700

71-2014-4201686 71-01-34-278-020.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 05/09/2014 $95,000 15,000 70,100 85,100

71-2014-4201806 71-01-34-280-010.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 05/15/2014 $94,000 15,000 68,100 83,100

71-2014-4202015 71-01-34-128-036.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 05/28/2014 $84,000 13,900 63,400 77,300

71-2014-4202376 71-01-34-126-005.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 06/11/2014 $97,000 13,600 74,000 87,600

71-2014-4202724 71-01-34-128-030.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 07/02/2014 $64,000 13,900 57,400 71,300

71-2014-4206174 71-01-34-280-004.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118006 510 018 12/18/2014 $60,000 15,000 57,700 72,700

71-2014-4203179 71-01-34-176-018.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118008 510 018 07/25/2014 $129,910 9,900 80,700 90,600

C71-2013-4207098 71-01-35-376-025.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 01/10/2014 $145,900 8,100 153,500 161,600

C71-2014-4200609 71-01-34-279-009.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 02/28/2014 $62,000 5,500 64,300 69,800

71-2014-4201367 71-01-35-376-019.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 04/22/2014 $165,400 7,800 155,100 162,900

71-2014-4201667 71-01-34-276-014.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 05/08/2014 $89,000 4,900 83,800 88,700

71-2014-4202738 71-01-35-376-022.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 07/01/2014 $182,000 8,100 164,900 173,000

71-2014-4202750 71-01-35-200-002.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 07/02/2014 $160,000 22,700 178,900 201,600

71-2014-4202717 71-01-34-279-001.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 07/03/2014 $88,000 6,500 81,200 87,700

71-2014-4202835 71-01-35-376-004.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 07/09/2014 $175,000 7,600 187,500 195,100

71-2014-4202974 71-01-34-276-001.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 07/16/2014 $177,500 9,000 112,100 121,100

71-2014-4204544 71-01-34-236-011.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 09/24/2014 $81,000 4,500 79,200 83,700

71-2014-4205578 71-01-34-255-006.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 11/21/2014 $110,000 9,000 64,100 73,100

71-2014-4205724 71-01-35-376-014.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 11/26/2014 $160,000 9,300 196,200 205,500

71-2014-4205966 71-01-35-376-021.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 12/09/2014 $224,250 7,800 189,600 197,400

71-2014-4206488 71-01-34-254-019.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 12/30/2014 $50,000 7,100 69,700 76,800

71-2015-4200247 71-01-34-276-008.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118009 510 018 02/04/2015 $62,000 4,500 57,700 62,200

C71-2014-4200175 71-01-34-280-037.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118011 510 018 01/31/2014 $149,900 13,900 136,800 150,700

71-2014-4201219 71-01-35-153-003.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118011 510 018 04/11/2014 $168,000 9,800 143,500 153,300

71-2014-4201499 71-01-34-428-001.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118011 510 018 04/29/2014 $172,000 15,100 125,500 140,600

71-2014-4203587 71-01-34-427-002.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118011 510 018 08/08/2014 $168,000 20,500 138,700 159,200

71-2014-4203606 71-01-34-280-036.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118011 510 018 08/13/2014 $204,900 11,600 135,700 147,300

C71-2014-4200391 71-01-34-429-015.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118013 510 018 02/13/2014 $124,000 11,300 125,100 136,400

C71-2014-4200786 71-01-34-476-011.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118013 510 018 03/17/2014 $279,000 30,200 230,200 260,400

C71-2014-4200835 71-01-34-405-026.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118013 510 018 03/19/2014 $187,000 23,400 128,700 152,100

71-2014-4201391 71-01-34-405-002.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118017 510 018 04/22/2014 $230,000 30,700 193,800 224,500

71-2014-4205952 71-01-34-401-003.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118017 510 018 12/09/2014 $270,500 27,000 196,300 223,300

71-2014-4205954 71-01-34-451-003.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118017 510 018 12/09/2014 $230,000 24,300 158,800 183,100

71-2014-4206410 71-01-34-452-003.000-018 N Res Imp None Olive 7118017 510 018 12/29/2014 $254,701 26,700 158,100 184,800

71-2014-4201472 71-09-02-401-002.000-022 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7122005 350 022 04/28/2014 $240,913 62,000 118,800 180,800

71-2014-4206071 71-09-22-201-005.000-022 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7122005 350 022 12/09/2014 $125,000 20,500 72,600 93,100

71-2014-4204411 71-09-11-129-011.000-022 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7122005 370 022 09/16/2014 $349,600 42,900 266,600 309,500

71-2014-4204412 71-09-11-177-001.000-022 N Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Penn 7122009 300 022 09/16/2014 $400 400 0 400

71-2015-4200373 71-09-11-127-008.000-022 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7122011 499 022 02/11/2015 $92,700 25,400 73,000 98,400

71-2015-4200525 71-09-04-183-009.000-022 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7122024 429 022 02/24/2015 $440,000 114,500 169,900 284,400

71-2015-4200241 71-09-04-203-004.000-022 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7122032 452 022 01/29/2015 $565,900 205,200 310,700 515,900

71-2014-4202634 71-09-03-126-019.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122053 510 022 06/19/2014 $253,000 30,000 183,800 213,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203250 71-09-03-102-030.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122053 550 022 07/18/2014 $250,000 30,000 179,600 209,600

71-2014-4204540 71-09-03-126-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122053 550 022 09/26/2014 $273,000 30,000 186,100 216,100

71-2014-4203573 71-09-04-151-019.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122054 510 022 08/06/2014 $128,900 13,200 104,800 118,000

C71-2013-4207232 71-04-34-452-019.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 552 022 01/22/2014 $140,000 15,100 113,100 128,200

71-2014-4201254 71-04-34-452-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 552 022 04/09/2014 $144,000 14,000 121,300 135,300

71-2014-4201429 71-04-34-452-004.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 550 022 04/22/2014 $153,000 17,900 126,300 144,200

71-2014-4202572 71-04-34-452-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 550 022 06/12/2014 $129,500 15,100 102,400 117,500

71-2014-4202574 71-04-34-452-014.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 552 022 06/12/2014 $132,900 15,100 101,900 117,000

71-2014-4202817 71-04-34-452-026.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 552 022 06/25/2014 $118,000 17,400 98,500 115,900

71-2014-4203350 71-04-34-453-022.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 550 022 07/24/2014 $178,000 15,800 160,800 176,600

71-2014-4203819 71-04-34-452-080.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 551 022 08/12/2014 $165,000 17,900 140,600 158,500

71-2014-4204441 71-04-34-452-054.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 550 022 09/22/2014 $150,500 15,100 125,500 140,600

71-2014-4205812 71-04-34-452-067.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 550 022 11/24/2014 $125,000 15,100 105,600 120,700

71-2014-4205945 71-04-34-452-033.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 551 022 12/02/2014 $135,000 17,900 116,800 134,700

71-2015-4200096 71-04-34-452-018.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122056 552 022 01/21/2015 $138,000 16,200 96,000 112,200

C71-2014-4200210 71-09-11-126-013.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122058 510 022 01/29/2014 $92,000 12,000 71,900 83,900

71-2014-4201425 71-09-11-181-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122058 510 022 04/22/2014 $75,000 12,900 69,000 81,900

71-2014-4203892 71-09-11-129-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122058 510 022 08/18/2014 $96,000 14,100 65,200 79,300

71-2014-4204470 71-09-11-201-024.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122058 510 022 09/25/2014 $78,000 16,100 63,500 79,600

71-2014-4204421 71-09-11-327-025.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122060 510 022 09/18/2014 $220,000 38,900 187,500 226,400

71-2014-4204657 71-09-11-327-023.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122060 510 022 10/03/2014 $317,000 32,000 195,500 227,500

71-2014-4206741 71-09-11-327-018.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122060 510 022 12/31/2014 $238,000 28,200 202,700 230,900

71-2014-4202353 71-09-11-404-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122061 510 022 06/06/2014 $599,900 71,400 286,100 357,500

71-2014-4202576 71-09-11-476-002.000-022 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Penn 7122062 500 022 06/12/2014 $150,000 150,000 0 150,000

C71-2014-4200417 71-09-11-452-006.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122062 510 022 02/14/2014 $725,000 116,400 633,700 750,100

71-2014-4202236 71-09-11-478-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122062 510 022 06/03/2014 $90,000 66,700 262,700 329,400

71-2014-4203173 71-09-11-451-001.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122062 510 022 07/14/2014 $413,500 78,600 224,400 303,000

C71-2014-4200189 71-09-22-129-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 01/22/2014 $118,000 15,900 111,000 126,900

C71-2014-4200263 71-09-22-180-008.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 02/03/2014 $160,000 43,400 116,300 159,700

C71-2014-4200484 71-09-22-178-011.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 02/19/2014 $124,000 14,700 110,500 125,200

71-2014-4201853 71-09-22-301-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 05/14/2014 $125,000 17,400 99,600 117,000

71-2014-4202218 71-09-22-178-020.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 06/02/2014 $101,700 15,500 76,000 91,500

71-2014-4203251 71-09-22-151-007.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 07/18/2014 $115,000 19,900 98,100 118,000

71-2014-4203899 71-09-22-151-029.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 08/20/2014 $124,000 19,900 99,300 119,200

71-2014-4205312 71-09-22-178-007.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 11/05/2014 $110,000 14,500 98,300 112,800

71-2014-4206599 71-09-22-176-006.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 12/22/2014 $87,000 14,200 79,100 93,300

71-2015-4200041 71-09-22-152-014.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122064 510 022 01/14/2015 $117,900 17,700 83,800 101,500

71-2014-4203366 71-10-07-427-008.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122066 510 022 07/29/2014 $170,000 27,600 143,500 171,100

71-2014-4203557 71-10-07-430-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122066 510 022 08/06/2014 $195,000 27,800 160,100 187,900

71-2014-4204456 71-10-07-428-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122066 510 022 09/24/2014 $174,900 23,300 116,700 140,000

C71-2014-4200193 71-09-21-278-028.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122067 510 022 01/22/2014 $135,000 20,400 98,400 118,800

71-2014-4201288 71-09-21-131-028.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122067 510 022 04/14/2014 $72,500 17,700 55,900 73,600

71-2014-4203660 71-09-21-131-027.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122067 510 022 08/08/2014 $146,000 13,700 104,300 118,000

71-2014-4204400 71-09-21-131-032.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122067 510 022 09/16/2014 $156,500 25,200 102,300 127,500

71-2014-4204399 71-09-21-251-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122067 510 022 09/16/2014 $157,000 24,500 100,200 124,700

71-2014-4206648 71-09-22-459-001.000-022 Y Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 12/30/2014 $200,000 43,500 154,800 198,300

C71-2014-4200363 71-09-27-251-004.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 02/11/2014 $135,000 22,800 113,400 136,200

C71-2014-4200676 71-09-22-376-004.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 03/06/2014 $242,000 16,800 203,400 220,200

71-2014-4202264 71-09-22-404-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 06/04/2014 $155,000 24,500 124,600 149,100

71-2014-4202546 71-09-22-457-013.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 06/10/2014 $89,000 11,400 87,800 99,200

71-2014-4202797 71-09-22-401-007.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 06/26/2014 $140,000 13,100 123,800 136,900

71-2014-4203456 71-09-22-456-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 07/30/2014 $88,500 7,700 100,700 108,400

71-2014-4203785 71-09-22-407-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 08/12/2014 $137,000 27,600 121,200 148,800

71-2014-4203942 71-09-22-457-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 08/25/2014 $103,000 11,400 90,700 102,100

71-2014-4204346 71-09-22-404-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 09/15/2014 $142,900 16,500 128,500 145,000

71-2014-4205944 71-09-22-405-006.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 12/02/2014 $161,750 19,500 145,200 164,700

71-2014-4206490 71-09-22-376-007.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 12/22/2014 $252,500 22,700 180,200 202,900

71-2014-4206610 71-09-22-403-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 12/29/2014 $137,500 21,300 116,400 137,700

71-2014-4203784 71-09-27-229-003.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122069 510 022 08/11/2014 $430,000 48,400 263,800 312,200

71-2014-4202110 71-09-27-128-001.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122070 510 022 05/29/2014 $153,900 14,800 135,100 149,900

71-2013-4202212 71-09-22-431-013.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 01/01/2014 $127,000 16,400 107,500 123,900

71-2014-4201260 71-09-23-301-014.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 04/09/2014 $164,000 19,000 131,400 150,400

71-2014-4201971 71-09-22-429-027.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 05/19/2014 $142,600 15,800 117,400 133,200

71-2014-4201994 71-09-22-429-022.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 05/23/2014 $158,000 15,800 138,800 154,600

71-2014-4202119 71-09-22-432-012.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 05/29/2014 $145,500 18,600 118,600 137,200

71-2014-4203418 71-09-22-427-015.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 08/04/2014 $149,900 15,800 120,800 136,600

71-2014-4203657 71-09-22-428-008.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 08/08/2014 $144,000 15,800 118,200 134,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204165 71-09-22-430-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 08/29/2014 $131,400 15,800 116,200 132,000

71-2014-4204406 71-09-22-430-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 09/16/2014 $147,000 15,800 129,500 145,300

71-2014-4205715 71-09-22-428-029.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 11/14/2014 $149,000 15,500 119,300 134,800

71-2014-4206077 71-09-23-301-029.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 12/10/2014 $125,000 24,200 128,000 152,200

71-2014-4206551 71-09-22-428-011.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 12/23/2014 $117,000 15,800 107,700 123,500

71-2015-4200092 71-09-22-428-007.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122071 510 022 01/21/2015 $125,000 15,800 100,700 116,500

71-2014-4201855 71-09-03-228-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122074 510 022 05/14/2014 $166,500 26,600 149,700 176,300

71-2014-4204153 71-04-34-476-026.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122074 510 022 08/28/2014 $154,000 32,000 132,300 164,300

71-2014-4204322 71-09-03-226-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122074 510 022 09/12/2014 $155,000 29,700 125,400 155,100

71-2014-4205721 71-09-03-226-019.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122074 510 022 11/17/2014 $138,000 34,000 107,300 141,300

71-2014-4206742 71-09-03-227-008.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122074 510 022 12/31/2014 $146,510 12,900 132,200 145,100

71-2014-4201463 71-09-03-201-006.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 550 022 05/05/2014 $248,500 30,000 216,500 246,500

71-2014-4203332 71-09-03-202-001.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 07/23/2014 $213,000 41,600 187,800 229,400

71-2014-4203689 71-04-34-453-038.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 08/08/2014 $227,000 23,200 198,000 221,200

71-2014-4204736 71-09-03-202-012.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 10/07/2014 $271,000 42,000 217,200 259,200

71-2014-4204877 71-09-03-201-012.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 10/13/2014 $223,000 37,900 198,100 236,000

71-2014-4204984 71-09-03-202-022.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 10/21/2014 $295,000 62,400 210,900 273,300

71-2014-4206641 71-09-03-202-016.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 12/30/2014 $230,000 29,500 195,700 225,200

71-2015-4200141 71-09-03-226-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122093 510 022 01/20/2015 $198,000 33,300 172,200 205,500

C71-2014-4200503 71-09-04-406-009.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122094 510 022 02/20/2014 $67,500 10,700 56,100 66,800

C71-2014-4200602 71-09-04-405-014.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122094 510 022 03/05/2014 $63,000 10,500 52,600 63,100

71-2014-4202203 71-09-04-407-008.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122094 510 022 06/02/2014 $60,000 10,900 53,600 64,500

71-2014-4202273 71-09-04-407-005.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122094 510 022 06/04/2014 $72,500 11,500 56,400 67,900

71-2014-4204065 71-09-04-408-006.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122094 520 022 08/27/2014 $60,000 10,700 52,800 63,500

71-2014-4202235 71-09-22-378-009.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122095 550 022 06/03/2014 $123,000 6,700 111,200 117,900

71-2014-4202426 71-09-22-380-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122095 550 022 06/10/2014 $133,000 9,500 107,100 116,600

71-2014-4204626 71-09-22-378-013.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122095 550 022 10/02/2014 $124,900 6,000 89,700 95,700

71-2014-4204712 71-09-22-380-010.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122095 550 022 10/07/2014 $110,000 9,600 111,400 121,000

71-2014-4201849 71-10-07-405-047.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122096 552 022 05/14/2014 $133,500 13,900 107,900 121,800

71-2014-4202676 71-10-07-405-002.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122096 552 022 06/24/2014 $102,000 17,400 81,800 99,200

71-2014-4203764 71-10-07-405-015.000-022 N Res Imp None Penn 7122096 552 022 08/13/2014 $145,000 20,900 122,500 143,400

C71-2014-4200966 71-09-17-407-005.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123002 499 023 03/21/2014 $40,000 14,900 19,000 33,900

71-2014-4201811 71-09-14-328-006.000-023 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7123006 340 023 05/09/2014 $157,300 44,000 111,300 155,300

71-2014-4206011 71-09-14-184-001.000-023 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7123006 340 023 12/03/2014 $400,000 126,700 298,900 425,600

71-2014-4204256 71-09-10-129-007.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123015 499 023 09/05/2014 $145,000 16,700 115,100 131,800

71-2014-4202239 71-09-04-476-022.000-023 N Com Vac Combined Com Vac Penn 7123027 400 023 01/01/2015 $216,050 55,800 0 55,800

71-2014-4203881 71-09-17-329-001.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123029 439 023 08/18/2014 $150,000 63,300 94,300 157,600

71-2014-4204632 71-09-16-180-003.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123030 420 023 10/02/2014 $220,000 72,600 124,300 196,900

71-2014-4205786 71-09-10-310-001.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123030 429 023 11/20/2014 $57,000 19,800 27,200 47,000

71-2014-4204500 71-09-15-276-004.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123031 447 023 09/26/2014 $174,000 44,000 100,200 144,200

71-2014-4201089 71-09-16-276-012.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123031 447 023 04/02/2014 $90,000 11,100 84,800 95,900

C71-2014-4201255 71-09-16-182-002.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123031 447 023 04/09/2014 $55,000 26,200 48,600 74,800

71-2014-4204584 71-09-16-428-011.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123034 430 023 09/30/2014 $250,000 12,000 148,900 160,900

C71-2014-4201029 71-09-15-153-006.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123034 452 023 03/26/2014 $100,000 53,200 24,200 77,400

71-2014-4201370 71-10-18-128-031.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123034 452 023 04/16/2014 $150,000 40,900 60,900 101,800

71-2014-4204901 71-09-13-208-007.000-023 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123034 452 023 10/14/2014 $65,000 41,900 21,900 63,800

C71-2014-4201065 71-09-09-436-020.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123045 510 023 04/01/2014 $74,500 9,000 68,800 77,800

71-2014-4203492 71-09-09-484-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123045 510 023 08/05/2014 $57,000 7,800 52,500 60,300

71-2014-4204085 71-09-09-408-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123045 510 023 09/03/2014 $75,500 8,800 49,800 58,600

71-2014-4204334 71-09-09-483-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123045 510 023 09/12/2014 $67,000 10,100 50,800 60,900

71-2014-4204922 71-09-09-452-019.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123045 510 023 10/16/2014 $70,500 14,200 62,600 76,800

71-2014-4201131 71-09-10-356-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123046 510 023 04/04/2014 $70,000 7,700 70,000 77,700

71-2014-4205302 71-09-10-308-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123046 510 023 11/05/2014 $81,000 7,100 74,400 81,500

71-2014-4205870 71-09-10-358-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123046 510 023 11/25/2014 $72,500 12,500 64,400 76,900

71-2014-4206655 71-09-10-353-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123046 510 023 12/30/2014 $67,000 12,100 68,700 80,800

C71-2014-4200066 71-09-04-429-016.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 01/10/2014 $72,000 10,800 64,900 75,700

71-2014-4202234 71-09-04-429-033.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 06/03/2014 $74,900 8,700 63,900 72,600

71-2014-4203651 71-09-04-477-023.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 08/07/2014 $65,000 10,300 49,600 59,900

71-2014-4204407 71-09-04-477-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 09/16/2014 $56,000 10,900 45,800 56,700

71-2014-4204704 71-09-04-431-017.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 10/07/2014 $65,000 9,900 57,600 67,500

71-2014-4204755 71-09-04-477-035.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123049 510 023 10/08/2014 $60,000 11,800 45,700 57,500

71-2014-4203245 71-09-03-351-004.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123050 510 023 07/17/2014 $174,900 24,700 169,900 194,600

C71-2014-4200569 71-09-03-301-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123050 510 023 02/28/2014 $149,900 18,600 125,500 144,100

71-2014-4203890 71-09-03-301-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123050 510 023 08/16/2014 $155,000 18,600 144,100 162,700

71-2014-4205399 71-09-03-305-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123050 510 023 10/31/2014 $116,000 14,100 89,400 103,500

C71-2014-4201008 71-09-09-237-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 03/21/2014 $67,000 7,100 58,100 65,200

C71-2014-4201053 71-09-09-203-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 03/31/2014 $73,500 8,400 60,200 68,600

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4201467 71-09-10-152-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 04/25/2014 $90,000 7,100 78,700 85,800

71-2014-4201731 71-09-10-151-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 05/07/2014 $59,999 9,800 55,900 65,700

71-2014-4202609 71-09-09-284-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 06/18/2014 $54,000 7,300 45,900 53,200

71-2014-4203463 71-09-09-209-012.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 07/30/2014 $55,000 11,200 56,100 67,300

71-2014-4203682 71-09-09-286-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 08/08/2014 $53,000 7,100 47,300 54,400

71-2014-420345 71-09-09-203-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 08/11/2014 $47,500 8,400 37,800 46,200

71-2014-4206035 71-09-09-280-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 12/05/2014 $74,000 7,100 59,000 66,100

71-2014-4206068 71-09-09-283-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 12/09/2014 $78,000 14,300 51,800 66,100

71-2014-4206157 71-09-10-105-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123051 510 023 12/15/2014 $87,000 8,400 70,700 79,100

71-2014-4203913 71-09-10-251-020.000-023 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Penn 7123052 500 023 08/22/2014 $1,500 1,500 0 1,500

C71-2014-4200954 71-09-10-205-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123052 510 023 03/19/2014 $47,000 6,900 29,300 36,200

71-2014-4203106 71-09-10-204-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123052 510 023 07/11/2014 $105,000 30,200 59,000 89,200

71-2014-4203430 71-09-10-155-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123052 510 023 08/04/2014 $53,500 10,700 47,200 57,900

71-2014-4203835 71-09-10-254-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123052 510 023 08/14/2014 $52,000 5,800 35,200 41,000

C71-2014-4200520 71-09-09-378-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123054 510 023 02/25/2014 $85,000 12,900 72,700 85,600

71-2014-4202956 71-09-09-387-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123054 510 023 07/02/2014 $59,375 11,200 70,000 81,200

71-2014-4202229 71-09-17-332-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 06/03/2014 $77,100 9,000 54,400 63,400

71-2014-4204382 71-09-17-311-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 09/15/2014 $75,000 15,700 56,900 72,600

71-2014-4204466 71-09-17-356-028.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 09/25/2014 $64,000 8,100 52,000 60,100

71-2014-4206653 71-09-17-179-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 12/30/2014 $78,000 15,300 60,000 75,300

71-2014-4206726 71-09-17-335-022.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 12/31/2014 $68,500 7,700 55,800 63,500

71-2015-4200383 71-09-17-336-018.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123055 510 023 02/13/2015 $68,900 7,700 52,900 60,600

71-2014-4203364 71-09-10-401-016.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 03/10/2014 $69,900 27,900 48,300 76,200

C71-2014-4201055 71-09-10-484-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 03/31/2014 $87,000 14,600 69,500 84,100

71-2014-4201269 71-09-10-453-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 04/11/2014 $80,000 10,400 73,300 83,700

71-2014-4202580 71-09-10-452-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 06/13/2014 $80,000 13,000 57,000 70,000

71-2014-4202812 71-09-10-452-012.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 06/25/2014 $115,000 10,400 87,800 98,200

71-2014-4203434 71-09-10-481-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 08/04/2014 $85,000 10,200 71,200 81,400

71-2014-4203923 71-09-10-483-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 08/22/2014 $115,000 10,100 93,200 103,300

71-2014-4205319 71-09-10-452-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 10/31/2014 $140,000 27,300 107,800 135,100

C71-2014-4200911 71-09-16-129-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123057 551 023 03/21/2014 $330,000 48,000 274,300 322,300

71-2014-4201985 71-09-11-354-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123057 550 023 05/21/2014 $150,000 16,000 115,500 131,500

71-2014-4206611 71-09-11-354-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123057 550 023 12/29/2014 $144,000 16,000 140,400 156,400

71-2014-4202633 71-09-16-105-022.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123059 510 023 06/19/2014 $83,000 11,000 67,000 78,000

71-2014-4203353 71-09-16-105-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123059 510 023 07/25/2014 $80,500 11,000 65,800 76,800

71-2014-4203947 71-09-16-101-023.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123059 510 023 08/26/2014 $91,000 11,000 75,700 86,700

71-2014-4206329 71-09-16-106-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123059 510 023 12/18/2014 $144,000 11,000 125,900 136,900

71-2015-4200544 71-09-16-105-024.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123059 510 023 02/27/2015 $103,900 11,000 76,100 87,100

C71-2013-4207200 71-09-15-329-032.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 01/13/2014 $105,000 13,000 92,600 105,600

C71-2013-4207213 71-09-15-236-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 01/15/2014 $81,000 7,800 72,100 79,900

C71-2014-4200727 71-09-15-331-023.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 03/12/2014 $110,000 12,300 95,300 107,600

C71-2014-4201068 71-09-15-331-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 04/01/2014 $72,900 9,800 54,400 64,200

71-2014-4201437 71-09-15-235-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 04/22/2014 $85,000 7,100 74,100 81,200

71-2014-4201559 71-09-15-207-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 04/30/2014 $81,300 12,200 71,000 83,200

71-2014-4202000 71-09-15-230-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 05/23/2014 $65,000 7,400 54,900 62,300

71-2014-4202049 71-09-15-276-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 05/28/2014 $104,000 9,600 88,900 98,500

71-2014-4202303 71-09-15-227-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 06/05/2014 $85,500 7,300 70,600 77,900

71-2014-4202571 71-09-15-231-016.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 06/12/2014 $92,900 7,300 73,400 80,700

71-2014-4202590 71-09-15-202-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 06/18/2014 $109,000 8,600 94,300 102,900

71-2014-4203500 71-09-15-377-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 08/05/2014 $95,000 15,400 71,800 87,200

71-2014-4203503 71-09-15-229-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 08/05/2014 $76,000 7,400 62,600 70,000

71-2014-4203884 71-09-15-253-036.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 08/18/2014 $72,900 10,800 60,300 71,100

71-2014-4204092 71-09-15-206-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 09/03/2014 $130,000 8,100 118,100 126,200

71-2014-4204223 71-09-15-253-019.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 09/04/2014 $26,000 7,900 21,800 29,700

71-2014-4204376 71-09-15-251-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 09/15/2014 $125,000 13,000 101,800 114,800

71-2014-4204453 71-09-15-254-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 09/24/2014 $95,900 11,600 65,300 76,900

71-2014-4204868 71-09-15-201-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 10/10/2014 $201,000 8,000 162,000 170,000

71-2014-4205745 71-09-15-377-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 11/18/2014 $79,000 15,400 52,600 68,000

71-2014-420-6467 71-09-15-179-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 12/19/2014 $82,200 10,000 69,300 79,300

71-2014-4206600 71-09-15-331-032.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 12/29/2014 $63,000 11,000 54,300 65,300

71-2014-4206740 71-09-15-236-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123060 510 023 12/31/2014 $78,500 7,800 73,900 81,700

C71-2014-4201010 71-09-15-115-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123062 510 023 03/21/2014 $134,000 18,400 109,300 127,700

C71-2014-4200086 71-10-07-305-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 01/15/2014 $119,000 17,100 77,600 94,700

C71-2014-4200953 71-09-13-205-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 03/19/2014 $78,000 12,300 67,900 80,200

71-2014-4202064 71-10-07-302-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 05/28/2014 $187,500 19,900 139,100 159,000

71-2014-4203822 71-10-07-355-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 08/12/2014 $75,000 33,300 38,400 71,700

71-2014-4203903 71-10-07-378-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 08/20/2014 $111,000 14,700 88,600 103,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204159 71-09-12-451-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 08/29/2014 $269,900 41,700 176,900 218,600

71-2014-4204603 71-09-13-127-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 10/01/2014 $65,000 23,800 36,300 60,100

71-2014-4204909 71-09-13-206-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 10/15/2014 $88,000 12,400 68,600 81,000

71-2014-4205129 71-10-07-352-035.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123064 510 023 10/22/2014 $104,000 15,100 69,100 84,200

C71-2014-4200556 71-09-13-251-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 02/26/2014 $91,000 15,900 79,200 95,100

71-2014-4201552 71-10-18-128-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 04/30/2014 $98,000 10,600 90,000 100,600

71-2014-4201780 71-09-13-253-023.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 05/08/2014 $79,735 10,400 64,500 74,900

71-2014-4201825 71-09-13-228-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 05/13/2014 $99,000 11,000 83,100 94,100

71-2014-4202122 71-10-18-129-028.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 05/29/2014 $77,000 9,400 70,600 80,000

71-2014-4203367 71-09-13-178-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 550 023 07/29/2014 $84,000 8,600 73,600 82,200

71-2014-4204625 71-10-18-130-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 10/02/2014 $153,500 14,700 143,600 158,300

71-2014-4206734 71-10-18-153-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123065 510 023 12/31/2014 $116,500 12,800 92,200 105,000

71-2014-4202544 71-09-16-383-009.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/11/2014 $95,000 15,600 79,800 95,400

C71-2014-4200621 71-09-16-330-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 03/05/2014 $65,000 10,400 40,900 51,300

71-2014-4201085 71-09-16-384-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 04/02/2014 $95,000 11,200 83,400 94,600

71-2014-4201253 71-09-16-335-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 04/09/2014 $81,500 7,300 55,500 62,800

71-2014-4201422 71-09-16-476-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 04/22/2014 $85,000 9,200 58,900 68,100

71-2014-4201518 71-09-16-386-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 04/29/2014 $80,000 11,000 82,700 93,700

71-2014-4201861 71-09-16-383-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 05/14/2014 $82,000 11,900 76,600 88,500

71-2014-4202287 71-09-16-459-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/04/2014 $86,000 7,300 80,800 88,100

71-2014-4202573 71-09-16-387-012.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/12/2014 $116,630 11,000 104,800 115,800

71-2014-4202579 71-09-16-327-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/13/2014 $68,900 8,000 68,700 76,700

71-2014-4202602 71-09-16-436-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/18/2014 $55,000 7,600 56,200 63,800

71-2014-4202856 71-09-16-488-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/27/2014 $52,000 6,200 46,700 52,900

71-2014-4202926 71-09-16-480-019.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 07/01/2014 $72,000 8,100 71,100 79,200

71-2014-4203238 71-09-16-482-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 07/17/2014 $96,000 9,200 97,700 106,900

71-2014-4203368 71-09-16-379-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 07/29/2014 $100,000 15,000 89,700 104,700

71-2014-4203902 71-09-16-159-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 08/20/2014 $86,500 9,800 86,500 96,300

71-2014-4204185 71-09-16-153-033.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 550 023 09/02/2014 $76,000 8,000 65,900 73,900

71-2014-4204324 71-09-16-452-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 09/12/2014 $83,900 7,300 64,900 72,200

71-2014-4204546 71-09-16-460-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 09/30/2014 $72,500 7,300 64,900 72,200

71-2015-4200029 71-09-16-159-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 01/12/2015 $66,500 8,600 55,500 64,100

71-2015-4200300 71-09-16-311-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 02/02/2015 $63,900 7,300 58,400 65,700

71-2015-4200329 71-09-16-158-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123066 520 023 02/04/2015 $47,000 9,800 45,000 54,800

71-2014-4203370 71-10-07-331-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123067 510 023 07/29/2014 $279,000 56,000 188,800 244,800

C71-2014-4200366 71-09-14-430-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123070 510 023 02/11/2014 $123,000 17,000 91,700 108,700

71-2014-4201562 71-09-14-435-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123070 510 023 05/01/2014 $80,000 17,700 59,100 76,800

71-2014-4203127 71-09-14-283-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123070 510 023 07/11/2014 $77,900 7,300 73,100 80,400

71-2014-4205178 71-10-07-379-012.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123070 510 023 10/28/2014 $70,000 2,900 52,600 55,500

71-2014-4206516 71-09-14-127-006.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $96,000 13,300 96,200 109,500

71-2014-4201979 71-09-14-254-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 05/19/2014 $80,000 7,800 75,600 83,400

71-2014-4202335 71-09-14-127-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 06/06/2014 $47,000 7,600 40,400 48,000

71-2014-4202523 71-09-14-280-018.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 06/11/2014 $58,500 9,300 47,400 56,700

71-2014-4202606 71-09-14-209-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 06/18/2014 $92,000 15,500 64,000 79,500

71-2014-4202935 71-09-14-152-027.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 07/01/2014 $77,000 9,600 71,100 80,700

71-2014-4203128 71-09-14-208-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 07/11/2014 $83,000 8,600 62,300 70,900

71-2014-4203203 71-09-14-252-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 07/15/2014 $67,500 8,600 47,900 56,500

71-2014-4203556 71-09-14-205-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 08/06/2014 $80,000 7,300 61,400 68,700

71-2014-4203653 71-09-14-127-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 08/07/2014 $89,000 8,000 70,700 78,700

71-2014-4203846 71-09-14-108-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 08/15/2014 $107,000 10,000 86,600 96,600

71-2014-4204751 71-09-10-454-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 10/08/2014 $72,000 7,900 65,100 73,000

71-2014-4206032 71-09-14-105-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 12/05/2014 $84,500 7,400 73,300 80,700

71-2014-4206559 71-09-14-203-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $123,000 10,100 103,200 113,300

71-2015-4200345 71-09-14-232-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 02/05/2015 $102,000 10,300 97,100 107,400

71-2015-4200372 71-09-14-231-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 02/11/2015 $120,000 14,300 87,200 101,500

71-2015-4200398 71-09-14-105-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 02/16/2015 $128,700 9,400 107,200 116,600

71-2014-4202528 71-09-21-131-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123072 510 023 06/11/2014 $109,000 16,100 90,800 106,900

71-2014-4203002 71-09-21-278-041.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123072 510 023 07/07/2014 $66,000 16,700 49,800 66,500

71-2014-4204087 71-09-21-229-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123072 510 023 09/03/2014 $117,000 12,500 87,300 99,800

71-2015-4200421 71-09-21-128-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123072 510 023 02/18/2015 $86,700 13,400 55,300 68,700

C71-2014-4200282 71-09-24-156-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 02/04/2014 $102,000 19,900 76,600 96,500

71-2014-4201081 71-09-24-102-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 04/02/2014 $97,000 12,900 75,400 88,300

71-2014-4201126 71-09-24-130-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 04/04/2014 $109,900 15,400 81,500 96,900

71-2014-4201565 71-09-24-177-016.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 05/01/2014 $103,000 13,700 85,000 98,700

71-2014-4201987 71-09-24-131-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 05/21/2014 $109,250 12,800 96,500 109,300

71-2014-4202008 71-09-24-131-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 05/22/2014 $101,000 16,900 89,600 106,500

71-2014-4203008 71-09-24-154-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 07/07/2014 $109,000 18,900 97,000 115,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203495 71-09-24-180-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 08/05/2014 $111,500 19,400 98,700 118,100

71-2014-4203554 71-09-24-182-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 08/06/2014 $165,000 17,800 133,300 151,100

71-2014-4204221 71-09-24-179-023.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 09/04/2014 $114,900 15,800 93,400 109,200

71-2014-4206127 71-09-24-151-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 12/12/2014 $96,500 18,400 76,400 94,800

71-2014-4206604 71-09-24-179-028.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 12/29/2014 $120,000 16,600 90,700 107,300

71-2014-4206554 71-09-24-179-009.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123073 510 023 12/31/2014 $103,200 16,500 92,700 109,200

C71-2014-4201027 71-10-19-127-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 03/26/2014 $155,000 18,000 118,600 136,600

C71-2014-4201252 71-10-19-151-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 04/09/2014 $223,000 21,000 218,600 239,600

71-2014-4201383 71-09-24-232-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 04/21/2014 $199,900 21,100 138,100 159,200

71-2014-4201560 71-09-24-231-004.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 04/30/2014 $185,000 22,400 144,100 166,500

71-2014-4201798 71-09-24-226-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 05/09/2014 $140,000 13,700 125,700 139,400

71-2014-4202037 71-10-19-152-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 05/27/2014 $148,000 22,400 130,500 152,900

71-2014-4202276 71-10-19-105-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/04/2014 $209,500 21,300 172,200 193,500

71-2014-4202358 71-09-24-231-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/06/2014 $243,000 15,700 200,500 216,200

71-2014-4202366 71-09-24-231-015.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/06/2014 $155,000 21,900 115,700 137,600

71-2014-4202536 71-10-19-129-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/11/2014 $209,000 19,600 152,500 172,100

71-2014-4202575 71-09-24-226-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/12/2014 $141,500 13,900 126,500 140,400

71-2014-4202793 71-09-24-227-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 06/26/2014 $129,900 14,500 108,200 122,700

71-2014-4202929 71-09-24-227-021.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/01/2014 $125,000 15,300 99,800 115,100

71-2014-4203201 71-10-19-128-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/15/2014 $211,500 20,800 148,800 169,600

71-2014-4203240 71-10-19-102-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/17/2014 $241,000 25,700 177,800 203,500

71-2014-4203248 71-09-13-453-011.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/18/2014 $173,000 20,200 152,200 172,400

71-2014-4203371 71-09-13-453-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/29/2014 $195,500 21,700 145,900 167,600

71-2014-4203440 71-10-19-152-010.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 07/30/2014 $180,000 25,800 149,000 174,800

71-2014-4203938 71-09-24-228-016.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 08/25/2014 $154,900 19,100 126,700 145,800

71-2014-4204695 71-09-24-227-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 10/07/2014 $139,900 13,400 127,200 140,600

71-2014-4205212 71-10-19-128-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 10/29/2014 $182,000 18,500 141,300 159,800

71-2014-4206566 71-09-24-228-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 12/23/2014 $215,000 22,600 183,800 206,400

71-2015-4200371 71-10-19-152-020.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123074 510 023 02/11/2015 $225,000 26,000 178,600 204,600

71-2014-4202138 71-09-16-356-126.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 05/30/2014 $67,500 13,500 56,500 70,000

71-2014-4203324 71-09-16-356-050.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 07/23/2014 $61,000 13,500 55,100 68,600

71-2014-4203843 71-09-16-356-069.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 08/15/2014 $72,000 8,900 50,200 59,100

71-2014-4204257 71-09-16-356-033.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 09/08/2014 $51,000 8,400 41,000 49,400

71-2014-4204487 71-09-16-356-136.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 09/24/2014 $74,950 13,100 60,400 73,500

71-2014-4205404 71-09-16-356-032.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123086 550 023 11/06/2014 $55,000 10,000 43,700 53,700

71-2014-4202009 71-09-10-427-017.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123087 510 023 05/22/2014 $250,000 62,900 168,000 230,900

71-2014-4204230 71-09-10-112-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123088 510 023 09/04/2014 $105,000 14,600 65,700 80,300

71-2014-4204330 71-09-10-113-025.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123088 510 023 09/12/2014 $128,000 10,600 90,900 101,500

71-2014-4204916 71-09-10-109-003.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123088 510 023 10/15/2014 $114,000 15,100 75,300 90,400

71-2014-4206555 71-09-10-109-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123088 510 023 12/23/2014 $122,000 14,400 88,500 102,900

C71-2013-4207180 71-09-09-310-002.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 01/10/2014 $74,000 7,400 66,200 73,600

C71-2014-4201063 71-09-09-382-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 04/01/2014 $96,500 8,400 67,900 76,300

71-2014-4202047 71-09-09-354-008.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 05/28/2014 $77,750 9,000 72,400 81,400

71-2014-4203893 71-09-09-359-014.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 08/18/2014 $75,000 8,400 73,600 82,000

71-2014-4204404 71-09-09-361-001.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 09/16/2014 $91,500 8,400 75,600 84,000

71-2014-42058-72 71-09-09-313-007.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 11/25/2014 $71,500 9,000 50,700 59,700

71-2014-4205979 71-09-09-365-006.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 12/03/2014 $80,500 16,900 66,800 83,700

71-2014-4206598 71-09-09-311-005.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 12/22/2014 $68,000 7,400 48,600 56,000

71-2014-4206664 71-09-09-354-013.000-023 N Res Imp None Penn 7123090 510 023 12/30/2014 $71,000 9,000 53,600 62,600

71-2014-4205315 71-10-17-132-019.000-030 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7130004 447 030 11/05/2014 $185,000 29,300 132,700 162,000

71-2014-4201133 71-10-08-476-007.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130009 510 030 04/07/2014 $108,900 15,100 91,600 106,700

71-2014-4202211 71-10-09-302-008.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130009 599 030 06/02/2014 $13,300 9,000 6,700 15,700

71-2014-4202348 71-10-08-428-006.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130009 510 030 06/06/2014 $112,000 15,100 116,000 131,100

71-2014-4204278 71-10-08-429-019.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130009 510 030 09/09/2014 $110,000 18,000 81,900 99,900

71-2014-4204942 71-10-08-426-003.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130009 510 030 10/16/2014 $90,000 36,000 53,100 89,100

C71-2014-4200698 71-10-08-402-009.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 03/07/2014 $156,900 14,500 137,500 152,000

71-2014-4201974 71-10-08-456-005.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 05/19/2014 $152,000 14,300 131,100 145,400

71-2014-4202156 71-10-16-256-006.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 06/03/2014 $77,000 10,200 51,300 61,500

71-2014-4203658 71-10-16-133-017.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 08/08/2014 $69,000 8,300 61,700 70,000

71-2014-4203926 71-10-09-351-011.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 08/22/2014 $167,000 22,100 133,500 155,600

71-2014-4203945 71-10-08-451-045.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 08/26/2014 $167,000 10,000 121,900 131,900

71-2014-4204168 71-10-16-153-032.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 08/29/2014 $95,000 15,100 64,900 80,000

71-2014-4204233 71-10-16-257-001.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 09/04/2014 $64,900 8,100 51,700 59,800

71-2014-4204203 71-10-16-128-003.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 09/04/2014 $126,000 11,400 99,600 111,000

71-2014-4204312 71-10-16-132-001.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 09/11/2014 $103,284 15,900 86,000 101,900

71-2014-4204447 71-10-08-376-064.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 09/23/2014 $211,500 30,000 184,200 214,200

71-2014-4204684 71-10-08-403-007.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 10/06/2014 $165,000 14,500 137,400 151,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204982 71-10-16-153-016.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 10/21/2014 $70,000 11,800 56,500 68,300

71-2014-4206441 71-10-09-351-025.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 12/19/2014 $120,000 15,900 83,000 98,900

71-2015-4200150 71-10-08-452-006.000-030 N Res Imp None Penn 7130010 510 030 01/26/2015 $175,000 14,500 144,600 159,100

71-2014-4203185 71-10-16-152-010.000-030 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7130013 480 030 07/14/2014 $60,000 28,000 40,100 68,100

71-2014-4202362 71-14-01-301-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131002 510 031 06/06/2014 $145,000 21,100 124,300 145,400

71-2014-4201736 71-09-12-401-001.000-031 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Penn 7131005 330 031 05/07/2014 $6,670,000 387,300 5,377,100 5,764,400

C71-2014-4200728 71-10-09-277-004.000-031 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7131018 460 031 03/12/2014 $75,000 77,400 12,300 89,700

71-2014-4201524 71-10-09-279-010.000-031 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7131019 429 031 04/29/2014 $89,000 49,500 27,800 77,300

C71-2014-4200558 71-05-33-301-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 02/27/2014 $225,000 27,800 165,800 193,600

C71-2014-4200592 71-04-34-181-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 03/05/2014 $165,000 23,700 125,300 149,000

C71-2014-4200686 71-10-07-227-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 03/07/2014 $144,000 23,100 116,000 139,100

C71-2014-4200826 71-04-34-408-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 03/18/2014 $174,000 21,500 135,000 156,500

71-2014-4201715 71-10-07-228-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 05/07/2014 $130,000 24,000 106,600 130,600

71-2014-4202091 71-04-34-408-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 05/29/2014 $154,000 23,100 121,100 144,200

71-2014-4202570 71-10-07-227-014.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 06/12/2014 $146,500 22,400 114,500 136,900

71-2014-4202599 71-04-34-253-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 06/18/2014 $199,000 33,300 145,100 178,400

71-2014-4202796 71-04-34-327-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 06/26/2014 $185,000 22,000 144,300 166,300

71-2014-4202989 71-04-34-178-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 07/01/2014 $194,000 31,000 117,900 148,900

71-2014-4202952 71-04-34-329-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 07/03/2014 $201,000 22,400 130,000 152,400

71-2014-4203049 71-04-34-406-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 07/09/2014 $197,000 20,800 147,200 168,000

71-2014-4203321 71-04-34-407-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 07/23/2014 $224,900 24,400 157,300 181,700

71-2014-4204259 71-04-34-181-022.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 09/08/2014 $158,000 23,300 126,200 149,500

71-2014-4204420 71-04-34-329-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 09/18/2014 $212,500 12,400 186,700 199,100

71-2014-4204484 71-04-34-180-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 09/24/2014 $195,000 35,300 165,500 200,800

71-2015-4200119 71-04-34-259-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131025 510 031 01/23/2015 $146,000 20,900 130,700 151,600

C71-2014-4200828 71-04-35-426-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 03/17/2014 $156,500 23,200 155,200 178,400

71-2014-4201773 71-04-35-403-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 05/08/2014 $166,350 21,900 174,400 196,300

71-2014-4202296 71-04-35-201-014.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 06/05/2014 $165,000 23,400 155,400 178,800

71-2014-4202639 71-04-35-401-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 06/19/2014 $209,000 29,300 163,800 193,100

71-2014-4203336 71-04-35-251-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 07/24/2014 $152,000 26,700 154,900 181,600

71-2014-4203924 71-04-35-404-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 08/22/2014 $215,000 22,200 173,600 195,800

71-2014-4203956 71-04-35-404-017.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 08/26/2014 $215,000 26,500 185,800 212,300

71-2014-4204090 71-04-35-202-026.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 09/03/2014 $161,500 21,100 156,400 177,500

71-2014-4204816 71-04-35-404-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 10/09/2014 $208,000 25,400 172,300 197,700

71-2014-4205955 71-04-35-202-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 12/03/2014 $164,000 22,700 141,600 164,300

71-2014-4206487 71-04-35-201-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131026 510 031 12/22/2014 $165,000 23,300 133,700 157,000

71-2014-4204650 71-09-01-104-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131027 510 031 10/03/2014 $90,000 41,100 81,400 122,500

C71-2014-4200667 71-10-05-229-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 03/06/2014 $185,750 20,800 129,000 149,800

71-2014-4202520 71-05-32-401-029.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 06/11/2014 $212,000 28,700 177,300 206,000

71-2014-4203249 71-05-32-476-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 07/18/2014 $129,900 36,200 106,300 142,500

71-2014-4203349 71-05-32-401-043.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 07/24/2014 $193,500 28,600 161,900 190,500

71-2014-4203900 71-10-05-229-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 08/20/2014 $154,000 23,300 100,200 123,500

71-2014-4203959 71-10-05-202-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 08/26/2014 $144,000 18,800 137,700 156,500

71-2014-4204419 71-10-05-205-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 09/18/2014 $160,000 30,000 122,400 152,400

71-2014-4205306 71-05-32-401-049.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 11/05/2014 $200,000 28,900 140,100 169,000

71-2014-4205969 71-05-32-476-019.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131030 510 031 12/03/2014 $145,000 26,900 130,200 157,100

C71-2014-4200516 71-05-33-180-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 02/25/2014 $138,600 18,400 100,500 118,900

C71-2014-4200955 71-05-33-126-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 03/19/2014 $159,900 30,100 102,400 132,500

C71-2014-4200964 71-05-33-178-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 03/20/2014 $188,500 19,000 145,300 164,300

C71-2014-4201012 71-05-33-301-026.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 03/24/2014 $280,000 21,300 261,600 282,900

71-2014-4202256 71-05-33-180-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 06/04/2014 $164,000 18,800 128,600 147,400

71-2014-4202615 71-05-33-178-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 06/18/2014 $192,000 19,000 154,400 173,400

71-2014-4202640 71-05-33-178-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $188,000 18,100 173,200 191,300

71-2014-4202637 71-05-33-252-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $158,000 27,900 114,500 142,400

71-2014-4202636 71-05-33-328-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 06/19/2014 $264,900 40,600 174,800 215,400

71-2014-4203652 71-05-33-176-014.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 08/07/2014 $200,000 18,400 179,100 197,500

71-2014-4204218 71-05-33-176-015.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 09/04/2014 $157,200 22,200 131,200 153,400

71-2014-4205574 71-05-33-176-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 11/06/2014 $175,000 18,800 174,200 193,000

71-2014-4205934 71-05-33-104-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131033 510 031 12/01/2014 $155,000 21,900 97,400 119,300

71-2014-4202097 71-05-33-451-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131035 510 031 05/29/2014 $135,000 14,500 95,800 110,300

C71-2013-4205217 71-05-31-351-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131037 510 031 01/01/2014 $118,000 20,800 62,000 82,800

71-2014-4204517 71-09-34-400-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131037 510 031 09/29/2014 $157,500 33,900 109,300 143,200

71-2015-4200512 71-14-03-200-021.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131037 510 031 02/19/2015 $300,000 35,200 212,600 247,800

C71-2014-4201032 71-09-26-452-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131038 510 031 03/27/2014 $195,000 23,400 142,700 166,100

71-2014-4204682 71-14-04-400-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131038 510 031 10/06/2014 $235,000 25,000 128,500 153,500

71-2014-4205886 71-09-03-251-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131038 510 031 11/25/2014 $81,500 9,100 58,400 67,500

71-2015-4200533 71-05-32-301-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131038 510 031 02/20/2015 $115,000 22,100 98,900 121,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4202673 71-10-04-127-012.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131040 510 031 06/23/2014 $97,000 16,600 63,600 80,200

71-2014-4204044 71-10-06-403-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131042 510 031 07/21/2014 $142,000 19,700 76,800 96,500

C71-2014-4200408 71-10-05-105-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131043 510 031 02/12/2014 $73,500 17,500 93,300 110,800

71-2014-4203452 71-10-05-101-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131043 510 031 07/30/2014 $128,000 21,200 72,600 93,800

71-2014-4203424 71-10-05-177-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131043 510 031 08/04/2014 $225,000 21,200 153,900 175,100

71-2014-4204876 71-10-05-102-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131043 510 031 10/13/2014 $155,000 27,200 141,600 168,800

71-2014-4202267 71-10-05-252-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131044 510 031 06/04/2014 $142,000 15,700 116,900 132,600

71-2014-4203499 71-10-07-228-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131044 510 031 08/05/2014 $105,000 15,900 82,500 98,400

71-2014-4204171 71-10-07-226-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131044 510 031 08/29/2014 $155,000 16,800 107,400 124,200

71-2014-4204181 71-10-07-226-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131044 510 031 09/02/2014 $130,000 16,800 91,800 108,600

71-2014-4205723 71-10-05-257-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131044 510 031 11/17/2014 $75,500 15,700 65,400 81,100

71-2014-4202643 71-09-11-281-004.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 06/19/2014 $103,100 23,800 60,400 84,200

71-2014-4202010 71-09-12-207-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 05/22/2014 $78,100 11,900 58,300 70,200

71-2014-4202107 71-09-12-256-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 05/29/2014 $136,900 35,600 92,200 127,800

71-2014-4203470 71-09-11-276-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 08/04/2014 $69,000 11,900 63,200 75,100

71-2014-4203567 71-09-12-207-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 08/06/2014 $137,000 23,800 94,000 117,800

71-2014-4204448 71-09-12-207-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 09/23/2014 $64,900 21,400 48,000 69,400

71-2015-4200311 71-09-12-177-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 02/03/2015 $85,000 35,100 37,200 72,300

71-2015-4200389 71-09-12-206-020.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 02/16/2015 $124,000 23,800 76,200 100,000

71-2015-4200516 71-09-12-207-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 02/27/2015 $125,000 23,800 97,000 120,800

71-2014-4201461 71-09-25-400-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131046 510 031 04/24/2014 $308,000 40,000 190,600 230,600

71-2014-4202902 71-09-26-301-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131046 510 031 06/27/2014 $154,900 21,600 87,600 109,200

71-2014-4201996 71-09-12-127-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131047 510 031 05/23/2014 $160,000 20,000 137,700 157,700

71-2014-4206906 71-10-06-353-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131048 510 031 02/10/2015 $94,500 32,700 89,900 122,600

C71-2014-4200493 71-10-06-426-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 02/19/2014 $125,750 17,100 104,400 121,500

C71-2014-4200489 71-10-05-402-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 02/19/2014 $155,000 20,200 127,500 147,700

C71-2014-4200827 71-10-05-351-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 03/17/2014 $100,000 40,100 72,800 112,900

71-2014-4201819 71-10-05-402-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 05/13/2014 $148,900 16,500 114,800 131,300

71-2014-4202112 71-10-06-427-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 05/29/2014 $216,000 21,600 164,600 186,200

71-2014-4202093 71-10-05-377-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 05/29/2014 $146,500 20,000 119,900 139,900

71-2014-4202339 71-10-05-452-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 06/06/2014 $165,000 22,200 134,300 156,500

71-2014-4202513 71-10-05-404-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 06/10/2014 $147,000 23,500 123,100 146,600

71-2014-4202588 71-10-05-404-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 06/17/2014 $139,900 14,200 126,800 141,000

71-2014-4203372 71-10-05-354-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 07/29/2014 $127,000 22,700 97,300 120,000

71-2014-4203596 71-10-08-128-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 08/06/2014 $189,000 21,600 150,900 172,500

71-2014-4204674 71-10-05-402-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 10/06/2014 $168,900 21,600 117,000 138,600

71-2014-4204818 71-10-05-452-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 10/09/2014 $208,000 22,000 144,000 166,000

71-2014-4205965 71-10-08-127-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131050 510 031 12/03/2014 $179,000 19,500 150,000 169,500

C71-2014-4200088 71-10-05-278-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 01/15/2014 $162,500 16,800 143,000 159,800

C71-2014-4200169 71-10-04-352-040.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 01/21/2014 $160,000 16,600 141,000 157,600

71-2014-4201315 71-10-04-353-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 04/15/2014 $168,000 16,600 138,600 155,200

71-2014-4202056 71-10-04-352-032.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 05/28/2014 $168,000 16,600 124,700 141,300

71-2014-4202146 71-10-05-432-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 05/30/2014 $158,000 17,900 128,700 146,600

71-2014-4202233 71-10-04-355-022.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 06/03/2014 $187,000 17,100 148,500 165,600

71-2014-4202587 71-10-04-355-014.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 06/17/2014 $156,400 17,100 131,300 148,400

71-2014-4203004 71-10-05-277-015.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 07/07/2014 $149,900 15,900 115,900 131,800

71-2014-4203369 71-10-04-355-071.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 07/29/2014 $173,000 16,700 128,700 145,400

71-2014-4203375 71-10-04-355-021.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 07/29/2014 $220,000 17,100 234,700 251,800

71-2014-4203905 71-10-04-355-048.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 08/21/2014 $175,000 19,400 132,300 151,700

71-2014-4204231 71-10-04-352-036.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 09/04/2014 $190,500 16,600 150,300 166,900

71-2014-4204875 71-10-04-352-034.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 10/13/2014 $166,000 16,600 125,500 142,100

71-2014-4204973 71-10-04-355-077.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 10/17/2014 $185,000 16,600 154,400 171,000

71-2014-4205977 71-10-04-355-018.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 12/03/2014 $219,000 17,100 182,100 199,200

71-2015-4200231 71-10-05-426-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 01/29/2015 $173,900 17,700 149,500 167,200

71-2015-4200543 71-10-05-428-007.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131051 510 031 02/26/2015 $170,000 19,300 145,900 165,200

71-2014-4202953 71-10-08-277-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131052 510 031 07/03/2014 $60,000 22,700 43,500 66,200

71-2014-4203824 71-10-09-126-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131052 510 031 08/12/2014 $75,000 9,800 68,700 78,500

71-2014-4206620 71-10-09-127-014.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131052 510 031 12/29/2014 $99,688 12,100 102,300 114,400

71-2015-4200116 71-10-07-153-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131052 510 031 01/22/2015 $122,500 26,000 96,400 122,400

C71-2014-4200597 71-10-04-454-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131053 510 031 03/05/2014 $150,000 25,000 125,000 150,000

C71-2014-4200695 71-10-04-453-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131053 510 031 03/07/2014 $185,000 24,700 137,500 162,200

71-2014-4201129 71-10-04-453-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131053 510 031 04/04/2014 $158,500 27,300 138,600 165,900

71-2014-4204402 71-10-04-406-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131053 510 031 09/16/2014 $162,000 23,900 130,700 154,600

71-2014-4205209 71-10-04-406-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131053 510 031 10/29/2014 $129,000 23,900 113,400 137,300

C71-2014-4200201 71-10-04-478-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131054 510 031 01/22/2014 $50,000 18,700 68,300 87,000

71-2014-4201320 71-09-26-227-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 04/15/2014 $76,500 11,500 67,400 78,900

71-2014-4202592 71-10-21-226-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 06/18/2014 $144,000 22,500 100,900 123,400

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203214 71-10-21-228-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 07/15/2014 $187,900 20,900 155,800 176,700

71-2014-4203901 71-09-29-379-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 08/20/2014 $129,500 19,000 87,100 106,100

71-2014-4203949 71-10-17-126-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 08/26/2014 $75,900 9,900 69,000 78,900

71-2014-4204053 71-09-26-251-019.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 08/27/2014 $325,000 35,400 239,500 274,900

71-2014-4204953 71-10-17-107-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 10/17/2014 $95,900 8,400 76,600 85,000

71-2014-4206643 71-10-17-103-010.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 12/30/2014 $54,000 5,000 50,700 55,700

71-2015-4200547 71-10-08-304-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131056 510 031 02/26/2015 $105,000 14,900 84,500 99,400

71-2014-4202635 71-10-09-427-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 06/19/2014 $134,900 21,000 103,500 124,500

71-2014-4202921 71-10-09-258-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 07/01/2014 $175,900 15,700 152,300 168,000

71-2014-4203006 71-10-09-401-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 07/07/2014 $162,000 28,800 127,800 156,600

71-2014-4204268 71-10-09-426-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 09/09/2014 $148,000 16,100 141,100 157,200

71-2014-4206140 71-10-09-477-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 12/12/2014 $77,000 19,700 62,000 81,700

71-2014-4206880 71-10-09-258-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131057 510 031 01/29/2015 $130,000 16,900 104,700 121,600

71-2014-4201823 71-09-28-228-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 05/13/2014 $127,000 19,800 113,400 133,200

71-2014-4203170 71-09-21-455-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 07/14/2014 $170,500 28,600 139,900 168,500

71-2014-4203239 71-09-28-300-027.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 07/17/2014 $255,200 24,600 209,400 234,000

71-2014-4203883 71-09-28-229-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 08/18/2014 $111,000 15,200 96,200 111,400

71-2014-4204689 71-09-21-478-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 10/06/2014 $155,000 21,900 124,600 146,500

71-2014-4205391 71-09-21-401-004.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131059 510 031 11/03/2014 $190,000 15,700 182,700 198,400

71-2014-4203823 71-10-20-201-012.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131062 510 031 08/12/2014 $141,900 31,500 108,200 139,700

71-2014-4201705 71-10-20-226-016.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131062 510 031 05/05/2014 $146,000 16,100 124,600 140,700

71-2014-4203379 71-10-20-202-011.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131062 510 031 07/31/2014 $162,500 18,000 130,900 148,900

71-2014-4203125 71-09-28-254-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 07/11/2014 $148,500 39,900 90,300 130,200

71-2014-4203886 71-09-28-151-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 08/18/2014 $153,000 28,300 119,700 148,000

71-2014-4204429 71-09-28-401-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 09/19/2014 $140,000 18,800 116,200 135,000

71-2014-4204752 71-09-28-401-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 10/08/2014 $139,500 18,800 100,500 119,300

71-2014-4205782 71-09-28-402-002.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 11/20/2014 $148,000 22,700 121,500 144,200

71-2014-4206042 71-09-28-151-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131063 510 031 12/05/2014 $173,000 34,800 133,600 168,400

71-2014-4206646 71-09-25-303-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131064 510 031 12/30/2014 $150,000 28,400 97,200 125,600

71-2015-4200527 71-09-25-351-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131064 510 031 02/25/2015 $162,000 19,600 133,700 153,300

71-2014-4203222 71-09-35-300-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131067 510 031 07/15/2014 $218,000 20,600 141,400 162,000

71-2014-4203241 71-09-29-251-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131067 510 031 07/17/2014 $148,500 13,600 97,900 111,500

71-2014-4205871 71-09-33-226-005.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131067 510 031 11/25/2014 $65,000 13,200 72,900 86,100

71-2014-4201351 71-09-32-152-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131071 510 031 04/16/2014 $190,000 21,700 170,000 191,700

71-2014-4205962 71-09-32-151-012.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131071 510 031 12/03/2014 $249,900 22,000 163,700 185,700

71-2014-4206117 71-09-32-151-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131071 510 031 12/11/2014 $268,000 18,600 170,000 188,600

014-1035-059033 71-09-32-302-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131071 510 031 12/18/2014 $230,000 18,200 140,800 159,000

C71-2014-4200131 71-10-21-400-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 01/09/2014 $186,000 19,600 149,800 169,400

C71-2014-4200163 71-10-21-428-006.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 01/17/2014 $242,000 20,000 198,500 218,500

71-2014-4201777 71-10-21-428-001.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 05/08/2014 $190,000 20,000 161,300 181,300

71-2014-4201876 71-10-21-402-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 05/15/2014 $240,000 23,400 177,000 200,400

71-2014-4202585 71-10-21-427-020.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 06/17/2014 $253,000 23,400 200,600 224,000

71-2014-4206903 71-10-21-427-009.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131076 510 031 02/10/2015 $217,000 23,400 197,700 221,100

71-2014-4201520 71-05-33-428-008.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131080 510 031 04/29/2014 $187,050 15,700 160,500 176,200

71-2014-4201566 71-05-33-477-013.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131080 510 031 05/01/2014 $167,500 16,600 142,900 159,500

71-2014-4203312 71-05-33-455-003.000-031 N Res Imp None Penn 7131080 510 031 07/22/2014 $127,000 15,600 81,900 97,500

71-2014-4203346 71-09-13-477-009.000-032 N Res Imp None Penn 7132003 510 032 07/24/2014 $65,000 9,400 56,700 66,100

71-2014-4203680 71-09-13-326-021.000-032 N Res Imp None Penn 7132003 510 032 08/08/2014 $130,000 18,500 75,100 93,600

71-2014-4206618 71-10-19-176-048.000-032 N Res Imp None Penn 7132005 510 032 12/29/2014 $237,000 27,300 185,000 212,300

71-2014-4203907 71-09-20-301-003.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133010 510 033 08/21/2014 $247,000 23,900 158,900 182,800

C71-2014-4200244 71-09-20-326-092.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133011 550 033 01/30/2014 $35,500 7,000 36,900 43,900

C71-2014-4200280 71-09-20-326-057.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133011 510 033 02/04/2014 $38,000 8,000 30,600 38,600

71-2014-4204832 71-09-20-326-047.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133011 550 033 10/09/2014 $44,000 7,000 33,600 40,600

71-2015-4200043 71-09-20-326-067.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133011 550 033 01/14/2015 $39,000 9,000 27,800 36,800

71-2015-4200515 71-09-20-326-110.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133011 550 033 02/19/2015 $34,900 7,000 30,600 37,600

C71-2014-4200356 71-09-20-379-002.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133012 510 033 01/06/2014 $670,000 140,400 405,900 546,300

71-2014-4201044 71-09-20-379-003.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133012 510 033 04/02/2014 $670,000 74,800 500,400 575,200

C71-2014-4201059 71-09-32-104-003.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 04/01/2014 $149,900 10,100 125,800 135,900

71-2014-4201261 71-09-32-126-042.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 04/09/2014 $138,000 22,000 117,300 139,300

71-2014-4201465 71-09-32-126-065.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 04/25/2014 $183,000 22,800 134,700 157,500

71-2014-4201990 71-09-32-126-037.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 05/21/2014 $158,000 23,000 126,900 149,900

71-2014-4202177 71-09-32-126-096.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 06/05/2014 $188,000 14,400 134,400 148,800

71-2014-4203129 71-09-32-126-018.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 07/11/2014 $167,500 14,800 146,700 161,500

71-2014-4203912 71-09-32-126-032.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 08/22/2014 $200,500 14,300 184,500 198,800

71-2014-4204056 71-09-32-104-005.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 08/27/2014 $206,000 9,800 192,100 201,900

71-2015-4200528 71-09-32-126-068.000-033 N Res Imp None Penn 7133014 510 033 02/25/2015 $162,000 14,100 113,500 127,600

71-2014-4202205 71-08-05-102-016.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 06/06/2014 $85,000 30,200 63,200 93,400

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200090 71-08-04-160-007.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 01/15/2014 $32,000 6,600 31,400 38,000

71-2014-4202208 71-08-05-226-021.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 06/06/2014 $115,000 20,400 80,200 100,600

71-2014-4202327 71-08-06-227-004.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 06/11/2014 $159,000 15,000 122,400 137,400

71-2014-4203083 71-08-04-160-013.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 07/22/2014 $59,000 6,200 48,700 54,900

71-2014-4203208 71-08-06-201-006.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 540 025 07/28/2014 $69,500 19,800 40,000 59,800

71-2014-4203413 71-08-05-176-011.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 08/05/2014 $112,000 31,200 82,500 113,700

71-2014-4204991 71-08-06-203-002.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 10/24/2014 $76,000 15,900 74,100 90,000

71-2014-4206475 71-08-05-151-021.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 12/30/2014 $58,000 15,000 50,100 65,100

71-2014-4203107 71-08-08-378-018.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 07/22/2014 $98,500 10,700 69,800 80,500

71-2014-4203045 71-08-08-302-005.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 07/15/2014 $145,000 10,200 144,700 154,900

71-2014-4204673 71-08-07-276-016.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 09/25/2014 $58,000 5,100 50,300 55,400

71-2014-4205907 71-08-08-126-031.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 12/08/2014 $45,000 23,300 41,400 64,700

71-2014-4206370 71-08-08-176-010.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 12/22/2014 $79,900 3,700 68,000 71,700

71-2014-4206324 71-08-08-351-008.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 12/24/2014 $72,220 10,200 65,300 75,500

71-2014-4202744 71-08-18-151-006.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125045 510 025 07/02/2014 $130,000 48,600 96,800 145,400

71-2014-4204636 71-08-18-103-012.000-025 N Res Imp None Portage 7125045 510 025 09/25/2014 $105,000 10,300 77,600 87,900

71-2014-4205139 71-08-13-276-003.000-026 Y Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126009 350 026 10/21/2014 $75,000 21,100 77,500 98,600

71-2014-4203977 71-08-15-226-003.000-026 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126009 350 026 06/27/2014 $14,776,347 769,200 14,364,100 15,133,300

71-2014-4206601 71-08-02-101-006.000-026 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126009 350 026 12/30/2014 $100,000 85,400 14,600 100,000

C71-2013-4207209 71-03-35-382-014.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126017 300 026 01/08/2014 $25,000 36,000 900 36,900

C71-2014-4200251 71-08-10-251-008.000-026 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126026 350 026 01/24/2014 $219,000 62,600 253,000 315,600

71-2014-4206615 71-08-22-101-002.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126044 300 026 12/17/2014 $85,000 19,700 0 19,700

71-2014-4204194 71-08-12-277-004.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126057 401 026 09/10/2014 $95,000 5,700 64,600 70,300

71-2015-4200470 71-08-14-331-019.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126066 401 026 01/15/2015 $165,000 3,900 116,000 119,900

C71-2014-4200284 71-08-12-231-006.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126075 442 026 01/29/2014 $180,000 32,800 88,800 121,600

71-2014-4201266 71-08-12-281-003.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 04/08/2014 $226,000 45,000 140,600 185,600

71-2014-4203951 71-08-12-283-003.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 07/10/2014 $330,500 124,500 199,400 323,900

71-2015-4200475 71-08-12-206-005.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 01/23/2015 $100,000 31,600 54,700 86,300

71-2014-4205134 71-08-12-107-002.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126081 449 026 10/01/2014 $1,100,000 37,000 1,068,900 1,105,900

71-2014-4200692 71-09-06-101-190.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 03/06/2014 $478,331 26,400 403,000 429,400

71-2014-4200751 71-09-06-101-188.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 03/12/2014 $443,046 24,500 400,000 424,500

71-2014-4200897 71-09-06-101-189.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 03/19/2014 $435,300 20,700 396,800 417,500

71-2014-4201119 71-09-06-101-194.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 04/07/2014 $439,343 26,200 395,200 421,400

71-2014-4201303 71-09-06-101-193.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 04/16/2014 $465,360 24,500 402,500 427,000

71-2014-4201372 71-09-06-101-187.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 04/22/2014 $454,259 30,300 402,500 432,800

71-2014-4201757 71-09-06-101-191.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 510 026 05/14/2014 $419,632 24,500 402,500 427,000

71-2014-4205360 71-09-06-101-196.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 11/06/2014 $450,682 10,400 400,000 410,400

71-2014-4205732 71-09-06-101-198.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 11/17/2014 $464,542 10,400 403,000 413,400

71-2014-4205537 71-09-06-101-199.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 11/17/2014 $435,620 10,400 400,200 410,600

71-2014-4205598 71-09-06-101-197.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 11/20/2014 $464,168 10,400 399,100 409,500

71-2014-4206013 71-09-06-101-200.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 12/12/2014 $469,354 10,400 403,000 413,400

71-2015-4200183 71-09-06-101-202.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 01/26/2015 $484,057 16,000 395,200 411,200

71-2015-4200285 71-09-06-101-201.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126099 550 026 02/06/2015 $456,146 10,400 402,500 412,900

71-2014-4206560 71-08-13-305-034.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126120 442 026 12/31/2014 $60,000 13,900 49,200 63,100

71-2014-4205123 71-08-02-301-026.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126122 447 026 10/13/2014 $25,000 9,000 24,500 33,500

71-2015-4200014 71-08-09-256-011.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126142 452 026 12/10/2014 $65,000 26,100 20,800 46,900

71-2014-4206583 71-08-13-305-036.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126156 499 026 10/31/2014 $20,000 6,400 1,900 8,300

C71-2014-4200613 71-08-03-255-015.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126156 499 026 02/25/2014 $97,000 8,900 84,400 93,300

71-2014-4205122 71-09-17-203-001.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126156 499 026 10/17/2014 $67,500 8,800 94,000 102,800

71-2014-4201282 71-09-06-361-001.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126158 420 026 04/14/2014 $210,000 19,400 189,300 208,700

71-2014-4205164 71-09-17-102-014.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126164 425 026 09/05/2014 $250,000 33,000 208,700 241,700

71-2014-4205149 71-08-13-305-021.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126168 429 026 08/28/2014 $60,000 10,100 53,400 63,500

71-2014-4206634 71-09-17-127-012.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126168 429 026 11/20/2014 $70,000 16,600 44,500 61,100

71-2014-4205135 71-08-10-403-001.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126182 447 026 10/09/2014 $85,000 4,400 59,200 63,600

71-2014-4206605 71-08-10-212-003.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126187 480 026 12/30/2014 $266,000 40,800 220,100 260,900

71-2015-4200494 71-08-14-304-001.000-026 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126200 429 026 02/23/2015 $7,000 4,000 4,700 8,700

C71-2014-4200303 71-08-08-403-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 02/11/2014 $58,000 4,900 48,200 53,100

C71-2014-4200394 71-08-08-451-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 02/12/2014 $64,000 4,600 57,100 61,700

C71-2014-4200812 71-08-09-355-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 03/20/2014 $51,000 4,300 51,200 55,500

71-2014-4201062 71-08-09-354-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 04/01/2014 $73,500 4,300 59,400 63,700

71-2014-4201097 71-08-08-476-039.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 04/02/2014 $85,900 4,200 64,600 68,800

71-2014-4201075 71-08-08-476-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 04/03/2014 $59,000 5,300 45,200 50,500

71-2014-4201346 71-08-09-352-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 04/22/2014 $42,000 4,300 47,400 51,700

71-2014-4202012 71-08-09-304-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 05/28/2014 $54,900 6,000 47,600 53,600

71-2014-4202067 71-08-08-253-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 05/30/2014 $52,000 5,800 60,600 66,400

71-2014-4202456 71-08-08-205-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 06/18/2014 $81,500 5,300 85,500 90,800

71-2014-4202697 71-08-08-251-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 07/01/2014 $86,900 7,000 67,500 74,500

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4202992 71-08-08-454-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 07/17/2014 $72,500 5,600 59,000 64,600

71-2014-4203635 71-08-09-355-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 08/14/2014 $47,000 5,200 56,100 61,300

71-2014-4203673 71-08-08-456-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 08/19/2014 $45,000 5,200 46,100 51,300

71-2014-4203763 71-08-08-454-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 08/25/2014 $49,000 6,100 45,100 51,200

71-2014-4203795 71-08-08-403-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 08/25/2014 $53,000 4,900 49,200 54,100

71-2014-4203817 71-08-09-352-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 08/26/2014 $53,600 4,600 45,000 49,600

71-2014-4204228 71-08-08-452-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 09/12/2014 $54,800 4,900 45,600 50,500

71-2014-4204219 71-08-08-454-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 09/15/2014 $55,000 5,800 43,600 49,400

71-2014-4204286 71-08-08-476-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 09/16/2014 $64,500 5,200 48,300 53,500

71-2014-4205009 71-08-08-451-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 10/22/2014 $72,000 3,000 64,600 67,600

71-2014-4205431 71-08-08-454-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 11/12/2014 $79,500 5,000 66,300 71,300

71-2014-4205660 71-08-09-353-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 11/25/2014 $57,500 4,300 43,300 47,600

71-2014-4206374 71-08-08-456-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 12/22/2014 $62,000 4,900 43,200 48,100

71-2014-4206495 71-08-08-476-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 12/30/2014 $46,000 4,300 47,700 52,000

71-2015-4200227 71-08-08-476-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126209 510 026 01/30/2015 $61,500 5,200 44,900 50,100

71-2014-4201401 71-08-16-127-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126212 510 026 04/15/2014 $50,000 2,500 40,100 42,600

71-2014-4201569 71-08-16-104-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126212 510 026 05/01/2014 $27,000 2,300 33,300 35,600

71-2014-4201925 71-08-17-228-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126212 510 026 05/22/2014 $65,000 3,800 50,000 53,800

C71-2014-4200631 71-08-04-177-037.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 03/05/2014 $74,900 2,500 58,500 61,000

C71-2014-4200635 71-08-04-203-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 03/05/2014 $68,100 2,400 66,300 68,700

C71-2014-4200647 71-08-04-130-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 03/07/2014 $68,000 2,500 65,000 67,500

C71-2014-4200941 71-03-33-477-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 03/27/2014 $55,500 1,800 55,100 56,900

71-2014-4201393 71-08-04-127-026.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 04/22/2014 $68,000 1,800 51,600 53,400

71-2014-4201630 71-08-04-126-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 05/07/2014 $69,000 1,700 64,000 65,700

71-2014-4201721 71-03-33-477-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 05/13/2014 $49,000 1,700 45,500 47,200

71-2014-4202030 71-08-04-130-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 05/29/2014 $74,900 1,800 63,300 65,100

71-2014-4202283 71-03-33-453-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 06/10/2014 $51,000 1,700 46,900 48,600

71-2014-4203601 71-08-04-203-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 08/12/2014 $67,000 2,300 68,000 70,300

71-2014-4203616 71-03-33-457-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 08/14/2014 $54,000 1,600 47,000 48,600

71-2014-4203703 71-03-33-476-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 08/21/2014 $58,500 1,800 61,100 62,900

71-2014-4203852 71-08-04-177-030.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 08/26/2014 $62,000 1,800 67,100 68,900

71-2014-4204607 71-08-04-128-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 10/03/2014 $62,000 2,300 66,200 68,500

71-2014-4205063 71-08-04-179-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 10/27/2014 $70,000 2,300 71,800 74,100

71-2014-4205456 71-03-33-455-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 11/12/2014 $57,000 1,600 46,600 48,200

71-2014-4206008 71-03-33-457-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 12/11/2014 $46,000 1,600 51,900 53,500

71-2014-4206330 71-08-04-201-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 12/24/2014 $56,000 2,200 71,700 73,900

71-2014-4206472 71-08-04-201-026.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 12/30/2014 $65,000 2,300 69,200 71,500

71-2014-4206731 71-03-33-478-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 01/07/2015 $63,000 1,700 60,800 62,500

71-2015-4200217 71-08-04-127-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 01/28/2015 $73,000 1,800 63,300 65,100

71-2015-4200199 71-03-33-477-043.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126215 510 026 01/29/2015 $63,000 1,800 51,100 52,900

71-2014-4201203 71-08-10-303-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 04/09/2014 $46,500 800 34,100 34,900

71-2014-4201901 71-08-09-380-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 05/15/2014 $40,000 1,000 32,500 33,500

71-2014-4202700 71-08-09-127-048.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 07/02/2014 $20,000 1,000 22,800 23,800

71-2014-4204210 71-08-10-308-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 09/12/2014 $28,500 1,000 28,600 29,600

71-2014-4204497 71-08-09-104-027.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 10/01/2014 $35,000 1,500 26,200 27,700

71-2014-4204817 71-08-09-130-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 10/10/2014 $21,500 900 20,200 21,100

71-2014-4206814 71-08-09-404-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 11/15/2014 $16,000 900 18,000 18,900

71-2014-4205545 71-08-09-127-034.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 11/18/2014 $34,000 1,200 32,400 33,600

71-2014-4205664 71-08-09-427-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126219 510 026 11/25/2014 $30,000 900 28,200 29,100

C71-2014-4200603 71-08-10-378-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126226 510 026 02/28/2014 $27,000 700 23,300 24,000

71-2014-4200917 71-08-11-305-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126226 510 026 03/25/2014 $15,000 700 15,400 16,100

71-2014-4202524 71-08-11-354-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126226 510 026 06/23/2014 $11,850 600 9,500 10,100

71-2015-4200594 71-08-11-353-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126226 510 026 02/25/2015 $12,600 600 16,800 17,400

71-2014-4205525 71-08-14-454-007.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 11/18/2014 $33,500 5,900 29,700 35,600

71-2014-4202990 71-08-24-355-017.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 07/17/2014 $75,000 11,800 52,800 64,600

71-2014-4206041 71-08-14-356-010.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 12/09/2014 $87,000 13,000 55,500 68,500

71-2014-4201617 71-08-15-379-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 05/05/2014 $78,000 7,100 67,600 74,700

71-2014-4201973 71-08-22-251-028.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 05/27/2014 $112,000 5,300 78,500 83,800

71-2014-4202698 71-08-14-430-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 07/02/2014 $20,000 3,400 18,200 21,600

71-2014-4203390 71-08-14-409-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 08/04/2014 $25,000 4,100 20,200 24,300

71-2014-4204726 71-08-15-482-042.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 09/23/2014 $58,000 8,400 61,100 69,500

71-2014-4204815 71-08-22-230-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 10/10/2014 $29,597 4,700 32,100 36,800

71-2014-4206049 71-08-14-431-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 12/12/2014 $18,900 3,400 15,600 19,000

71-2014-4206428 71-08-14-406-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 12/29/2014 $105,000 900 88,800 89,700

71-2015-4200093 71-08-15-482-040.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 01/22/2015 $75,700 6,400 64,100 70,500

71-2015-4200490 71-08-14-452-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 02/24/2015 $38,500 4,000 45,200 49,200

71-2014-4204835 71-08-24-329-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126239 520 026 10/13/2014 $57,500 4,800 53,500 58,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203999 71-08-13-252-034.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126243 510 026 09/05/2014 $33,500 1,300 25,900 27,200

71-2014-4205841 71-08-13-179-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126243 510 026 12/03/2014 $45,000 1,300 34,300 35,600

71-2014-4205788 71-08-13-332-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126244 510 026 12/02/2014 $37,000 2,100 48,800 50,900

71-2015-4200578 71-08-13-252-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126258 510 026 02/26/2015 $95,000 1,800 111,200 113,000

C71-2014-4200716 71-08-24-137-001.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 03/11/2014 $91,500 8,200 58,100 66,300

C71-2013-4207084 71-08-24-232-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 01/10/2014 $41,500 4,100 49,200 53,300

C71-2014-4200390 71-08-24-252-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 02/12/2014 $74,000 3,700 55,700 59,400

C71-2014-4200808 71-08-24-204-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 03/19/2014 $49,000 4,000 60,300 64,300

71-2014-4201180 71-08-24-183-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 04/08/2014 $64,900 4,300 54,500 58,800

71-2014-4201197 71-08-24-276-031.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 04/10/2014 $78,500 4,100 56,100 60,200

71-2014-4201430 71-08-24-126-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 04/28/2014 $36,000 4,300 43,900 48,200

71-2014-4202530 71-08-24-279-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 06/23/2014 $140,000 4,300 99,000 103,300

71-2014-4202644 71-08-24-204-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 06/25/2014 $59,900 4,000 56,300 60,300

71-2014-4202749 71-08-24-227-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/01/2014 $66,000 4,400 48,600 53,000

71-2014-4203155 71-08-24-278-028.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/24/2014 $104,500 3,800 77,500 81,300

71-2014-4203135 71-08-24-232-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/24/2014 $49,900 4,000 53,100 57,100

71-2014-4203299 71-08-24-253-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $100,000 4,800 61,600 66,400

71-2014-4203301 71-08-24-135-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $68,000 3,800 71,200 75,000

71-2014-4203302 71-08-24-258-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 07/31/2014 $70,000 4,100 42,300 46,400

71-2014-4203441 71-08-24-201-025.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 08/05/2014 $69,500 5,200 63,400 68,600

71-2014-4203475 71-08-24-182-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 08/06/2014 $65,000 4,300 53,800 58,100

71-2014-4203602 71-08-24-254-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 08/13/2014 $81,000 5,500 61,600 67,100

71-2014-4203982 71-08-24-278-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 09/02/2014 $89,000 4,200 64,500 68,700

71-2014-4204128 71-08-24-227-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 09/09/2014 $66,000 3,800 59,200 63,000

71-2014-4204432 71-08-24-252-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 09/25/2014 $50,000 3,800 60,200 64,000

71-2014-4204914 71-08-24-279-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 10/15/2014 $74,900 4,300 67,100 71,400

71-2014-4204931 71-08-24-276-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 10/17/2014 $45,000 4,000 41,600 45,600

71-2014-4205169 71-08-24-181-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 10/29/2014 $45,400 3,700 53,500 57,200

71-2014-4205227 71-08-24-202-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 11/06/2014 $79,000 4,100 74,500 78,600

71-2014-4205346 71-08-24-180-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 11/06/2014 $50,000 3,600 41,500 45,100

71-2014-4206082 71-08-24-278-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 12/12/2014 $84,000 5,300 70,700 76,000

71-2015-4200082 71-08-24-278-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 01/20/2015 $88,000 4,200 73,000 77,200

71-2015-4200201 71-08-24-227-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 01/29/2015 $46,900 4,200 46,400 50,600

71-2015-4200193 71-08-24-181-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 01/29/2015 $42,900 3,700 51,600 55,300

71-2015-4200406 71-08-24-180-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 02/13/2015 $48,500 3,600 50,100 53,700

C71-2014-4200173 71-08-24-329-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 01/22/2014 $104,900 11,500 89,900 101,400

C71-2014-4200192 71-08-24-330-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 01/30/2014 $60,000 10,500 45,400 55,900

C71-2014-4200937 71-08-24-402-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 03/27/2014 $75,000 7,800 66,800 74,600

71-2014-4201107 71-08-24-330-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 04/04/2014 $65,000 10,600 39,600 50,200

71-2014-4201190 71-08-24-327-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 04/09/2014 $73,500 8,800 75,600 84,400

71-2014-4202171 71-08-24-329-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 06/04/2014 $74,500 10,500 87,200 97,700

71-2014-4203426 71-08-24-330-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 08/05/2014 $65,000 9,600 58,600 68,200

71-2014-4205330 71-08-24-376-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 11/05/2014 $62,500 11,200 61,400 72,600

71-2015-4200574 71-08-25-176-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126272 510 026 02/26/2015 $59,900 12,200 42,900 55,100

71-2014-4201812 71-09-18-203-021.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 05/14/2014 $70,000 4,800 60,300 65,100

71-2014-4201343 71-09-18-128-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 04/21/2014 $60,552 2,600 42,300 44,900

71-2014-4202810 71-09-18-129-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 07/08/2014 $41,253 2,600 51,100 53,700

71-2014-4203402 71-09-18-179-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 08/04/2014 $67,500 2,700 54,100 56,800

71-2014-4204829 71-09-18-132-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 10/13/2014 $57,000 2,900 59,900 62,800

71-2014-4205627 71-09-18-203-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 11/17/2014 $102,500 2,400 86,800 89,200

71-2014-4201523 71-09-18-155-018.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 05/01/2014 $39,900 8,100 50,100 58,200

71-2014-4204621 71-09-18-455-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 09/30/2014 $50,000 8,300 48,900 57,200

71-2014-4201080 71-09-18-357-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 04/03/2014 $52,000 4,100 45,300 49,400

71-2014-4201102 71-09-18-431-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 04/04/2014 $45,000 4,000 41,300 45,300

71-2014-4201624 71-09-18-460-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 05/07/2014 $78,000 4,700 54,200 58,900

71-2014-4201652 71-09-18-478-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 05/08/2014 $67,450 4,300 41,000 45,300

71-2014-4202461 71-09-18-461-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 06/19/2014 $68,500 3,700 57,500 61,200

71-2014-4202628 71-09-18-482-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 06/25/2014 $90,000 4,300 56,500 60,800

71-2014-4202792 71-09-18-332-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 07/03/2014 $50,000 4,700 52,800 57,500

71-2014-4203115 71-09-18-478-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 07/23/2014 $65,000 4,300 46,400 50,700

71-2014-4203398 71-09-18-479-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 08/04/2014 $39,900 3,900 46,100 50,000

71-2014-4203544 71-09-18-480-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 08/08/2014 $68,000 4,300 49,600 53,900

71-2014-4204269 71-09-18-459-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 09/16/2014 $34,500 3,900 50,000 53,900

71-2014-4204649 71-09-18-358-025.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 10/06/2014 $114,000 3,400 79,700 83,100

71-2014-4206355 71-09-18-408-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 12/22/2014 $40,400 4,900 40,700 45,600

71-2014-4206319 71-09-18-153-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 12/24/2014 $46,400 5,000 65,700 70,700

71-2015-4200123 71-09-18-456-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 01/21/2015 $33,500 3,900 40,100 44,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4206837 71-09-18-461-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 01/22/2015 $91,500 3,700 66,200 69,900

71-2015-4200177 71-09-18-335-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 01/27/2015 $43,000 4,500 50,700 55,200

C71-2014-4200148 71-09-19-252-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 01/27/2014 $60,000 16,000 64,300 80,300

C71-2014-4200678 71-09-19-132-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 03/07/2014 $110,000 20,200 99,300 119,500

C71-2014-4200769 71-09-19-404-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 03/14/2014 $92,000 20,100 60,700 80,800

C71-2014-4200973 71-09-19-105-027.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 03/26/2014 $92,500 17,000 74,200 91,200

71-2014-4201220 71-08-25-178-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 04/11/2014 $108,500 17,300 89,400 106,700

71-2014-4201237 71-09-19-207-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 04/15/2014 $122,000 13,900 95,800 109,700

71-2014-4201322 71-09-19-477-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 04/17/2014 $80,000 17,000 69,500 86,500

71-2014-4201610 71-09-19-327-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 05/05/2014 $163,000 32,100 71,300 103,400

71-2014-4201970 71-09-19-481-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 05/23/2014 $128,900 20,900 75,900 96,800

71-2014-4202116 71-08-25-127-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/02/2014 $50,000 11,600 35,500 47,100

71-2014-4202152 71-09-19-403-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/03/2014 $65,000 22,900 64,200 87,100

71-2014-4202145 71-09-19-407-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/03/2014 $89,900 19,000 70,300 89,300

71-2014-4202392 71-09-19-203-025.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/13/2014 $85,500 13,300 53,600 66,900

71-2014-4202512 71-09-19-404-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/20/2014 $99,500 20,300 65,500 85,800

71-2014-4202514 71-09-19-252-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 06/20/2014 $109,000 22,600 76,500 99,100

71-2014-4203007 71-09-19-430-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 07/18/2014 $108,000 12,700 78,400 91,100

71-2014-4203111 71-09-19-404-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 07/23/2014 $118,000 22,800 77,300 100,100

71-2014-4203387 71-09-19-252-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 07/30/2014 $80,000 25,500 66,000 91,500

71-2014-4203591 71-09-19-205-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 08/08/2014 $83,000 18,000 62,200 80,200

71-2014-4203615 71-09-19-104-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 08/14/2014 $98,000 9,300 73,700 83,000

71-2014-4203712 71-09-19-406-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 08/21/2014 $136,500 29,900 71,000 100,900

71-2014-4203708 71-09-19-481-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 08/21/2014 $82,500 19,400 60,800 80,200

71-2014-4203836 71-09-19-476-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 08/26/2014 $106,401 20,800 66,900 87,700

71-2014-4204468 71-09-19-133-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 09/29/2014 $170,000 19,100 98,900 118,000

71-2014-4204747 71-09-19-479-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 10/09/2014 $127,500 28,000 76,400 104,400

71-2014-4205337 71-09-19-455-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 11/06/2014 $118,500 20,300 92,200 112,500

71-2014-4205604 71-09-19-281-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 11/20/2014 $100,000 21,100 71,300 92,400

71-2014-4206143 71-09-19-253-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/15/2014 $83,000 19,600 54,600 74,200

71-2014-4206170 71-09-19-202-030.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/16/2014 $74,900 15,100 56,700 71,800

71-2014-4206373 71-09-19-253-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/22/2014 $76,000 29,800 62,400 92,200

71-2014-4206326 71-09-19-481-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/24/2014 $85,000 15,900 79,200 95,100

71-2014-4206552 71-09-19-281-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/31/2014 $86,200 15,800 59,600 75,400

71-2014-4206535 71-09-19-130-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 12/31/2014 $80,000 14,000 67,500 81,500

71-2014-4206777 71-08-25-176-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 01/12/2015 $105,000 16,900 84,600 101,500

71-2015-4200035 71-09-19-476-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 01/13/2015 $95,000 28,700 68,800 97,500

71-2015-4200452 71-09-19-201-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 02/18/2015 $105,000 14,400 82,000 96,400

71-2015-4200498 71-09-19-276-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126288 510 026 02/25/2015 $62,800 15,500 46,900 62,400

71-2014-4203474 71-09-19-156-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126291 510 026 08/07/2014 $177,500 80,100 141,700 221,800

71-2014-4205486 71-09-19-107-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126291 510 026 11/13/2014 $139,900 29,400 131,100 160,500

71-2015-4200200 71-09-19-154-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126291 510 026 01/29/2015 $380,000 107,800 285,500 393,300

71-2014-4204459 71-09-17-107-001.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 09/26/2014 $67,000 3,800 72,100 75,900

C71-2014-4200144 71-09-08-477-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 01/24/2014 $79,000 2,300 70,600 72,900

C71-2014-4200197 71-09-08-426-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/03/2014 $60,000 4,900 60,900 65,800

C71-2014-4200696 71-09-08-453-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 03/06/2014 $40,000 2,200 43,300 45,500

C71-2013-4207340 71-09-17-253-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 03/20/2014 $71,000 2,300 73,800 76,100

C71-2014-4200847 71-09-17-276-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 03/21/2014 $74,900 2,300 60,500 62,800

71-2014-4201114 71-09-17-228-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 04/04/2014 $82,500 2,400 71,800 74,200

71-2014-4201548 71-09-17-131-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/05/2014 $56,000 2,500 57,700 60,200

71-2014-4201695 71-09-17-131-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/17/2014 $78,000 2,500 74,600 77,100

71-2014-4201881 71-09-17-205-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/21/2014 $87,000 3,800 60,300 64,100

71-2014-4201923 71-09-08-404-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/22/2014 $72,000 3,500 75,600 79,100

71-2014-4201975 71-09-18-227-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/27/2014 $46,500 2,200 50,000 52,200

71-2014-4202057 71-09-17-254-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 05/30/2014 $55,500 2,300 49,900 52,200

71-2014-4202147 71-09-08-356-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/04/2014 $33,500 2,200 37,500 39,700

71-2014-4202305 71-09-08-452-026.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/11/2014 $57,000 2,400 65,700 68,100

71-2014-4202275 71-09-08-458-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/12/2014 $63,782 2,200 63,800 66,000

71-2014-4202387 71-09-08-480-027.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/16/2014 $60,000 2,200 74,300 76,500

71-2014-4202453 71-09-17-233-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $58,000 2,600 46,900 49,500

71-2014-4202448 71-09-08-452-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $68,000 2,400 60,200 62,600

71-2014-4202458 71-09-08-378-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/18/2014 $69,900 2,200 61,300 63,500

71-2014-4202466 71-09-17-229-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/19/2014 $83,800 2,400 49,500 51,900

71-2014-4202612 71-09-17-126-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/26/2014 $82,500 3,800 65,800 69,600

71-2014-4202670 71-09-17-253-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 06/27/2014 $54,500 2,300 67,200 69,500

71-2014-4202934 71-09-17-101-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 07/14/2014 $43,800 1,500 48,400 49,900

71-2014-4202916 71-09-17-279-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 07/14/2014 $57,000 3,700 62,800 66,500

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203110 71-09-08-478-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 07/22/2014 $44,000 2,400 41,600 44,000

71-2014-4203147 71-09-08-328-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 07/24/2014 $58,000 2,100 52,000 54,100

71-2014-4203564 71-09-17-204-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 08/11/2014 $51,500 2,300 49,400 51,700

71-2014-4203631 71-09-17-253-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 08/14/2014 $52,000 2,300 49,800 52,100

71-2014-4203663 71-09-08-480-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 08/18/2014 $70,000 2,200 59,600 61,800

71-2014-4203700 71-09-17-228-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 08/21/2014 $64,000 2,400 57,300 59,700

71-2014-4204008 71-09-08-452-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 09/05/2014 $69,900 2,300 58,800 61,100

71-2014-4204337 71-09-08-432-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 09/17/2014 $69,900 2,200 63,000 65,200

71-2014-4204599 71-09-17-276-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 10/03/2014 $46,000 2,300 48,800 51,100

71-2014-4204770 71-09-08-454-026.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 10/09/2014 $52,000 2,200 57,900 60,100

71-2014-4205692 71-09-08-381-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 11/26/2014 $71,000 2,200 63,800 66,000

71-2014-4205862 71-09-17-227-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 12/05/2014 $75,000 2,300 72,100 74,400

71-2014-4205935 71-09-08-354-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 12/09/2014 $52,000 2,200 45,800 48,000

71-2014-4206828 71-09-08-380-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 01/16/2015 $50,000 2,200 56,100 58,300

71-2014-4206853 71-09-18-229-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 01/21/2015 $59,500 2,400 62,000 64,400

71-2015-4200272 71-09-17-230-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/04/2015 $75,900 2,300 71,500 73,800

71-2015-4200269 71-09-17-176-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/04/2015 $78,500 2,900 71,800 74,700

71-2014-4206911 71-09-17-153-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/13/2015 $44,500 2,500 59,000 61,500

71-2014-4206913 71-09-08-381-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/13/2015 $44,500 1,900 67,000 68,900

71-2015-4200445 71-09-17-127-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/19/2015 $94,500 2,500 78,300 80,800

71-2015-4200572 71-09-17-280-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 02/26/2015 $145,000 4,500 182,500 187,000

71-2014-4201556 71-09-08-276-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 05/01/2014 $60,000 16,700 66,600 83,300

71-2014-4201633 71-09-08-229-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 05/07/2014 $100,000 14,900 68,900 83,800

71-2014-4202450 71-09-08-279-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 06/18/2014 $85,000 9,600 43,200 52,800

71-2014-4202485 71-09-08-227-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 06/19/2014 $106,000 18,000 91,400 109,400

71-2014-4203140 71-09-08-277-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 07/24/2014 $75,000 26,200 62,800 89,000

71-2014-4204077 71-09-08-231-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 09/05/2014 $93,890 16,500 50,100 66,600

71-2014-4206168 71-09-08-229-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 12/16/2014 $133,000 16,100 73,300 89,400

71-2014-4206856 71-09-08-276-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 01/26/2015 $110,000 16,700 101,000 117,700

71-2015-4200218 71-09-08-278-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126303 510 026 01/28/2015 $111,765 9,900 88,600 98,500

71-2014-4202909 71-09-08-278-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126304 510 026 07/11/2014 $110,000 10,700 97,300 108,000

71-2014-4201340 71-09-08-107-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 04/21/2014 $124,000 17,900 120,900 138,800

71-2014-4202482 71-09-08-104-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 06/19/2014 $86,000 12,800 89,100 101,900

71-2014-4202967 71-09-08-102-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 07/15/2014 $92,500 12,500 79,700 92,200

71-2014-4204078 71-09-08-104-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 09/08/2014 $77,500 11,300 72,400 83,700

71-2014-4204535 71-09-08-151-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 09/24/2014 $78,000 16,200 68,700 84,900

71-2014-4204671 71-09-08-107-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 09/25/2014 $100,000 10,800 92,300 103,100

71-2014-4205540 71-09-08-156-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 11/18/2014 $64,000 14,700 58,600 73,300

71-2015-4200065 71-09-08-151-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126307 510 026 01/14/2015 $68,000 10,400 64,100 74,500

C71-2013-4207003 71-09-05-405-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 01/08/2014 $66,500 16,200 53,700 69,900

71-2014-4201382 71-09-05-278-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 04/22/2014 $94,000 16,700 70,400 87,100

71-2014-4202151 71-09-05-228-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 06/04/2014 $62,500 13,200 44,600 57,800

71-2014-4202245 71-09-05-451-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 06/09/2014 $69,000 19,300 44,300 63,600

71-2014-4202278 71-09-05-401-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 06/10/2014 $64,000 16,900 42,700 59,600

71-2014-4202938 71-09-05-404-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 07/14/2014 $82,000 14,500 52,200 66,700

71-2014-4204873 71-09-05-226-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 07/21/2014 $52,000 14,300 40,700 55,000

71-2014-4204069 71-09-05-203-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 09/05/2014 $60,000 17,500 44,500 62,000

71-2014-4204562 71-09-05-404-037.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 09/24/2014 $86,500 14,100 51,900 66,000

71-2014-4205469 71-09-05-429-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 11/13/2014 $70,000 18,700 49,900 68,600

71-2014-4206411 71-09-05-227-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 12/29/2014 $77,500 12,100 52,200 64,300

71-2014-4206470 71-09-05-405-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 12/30/2014 $63,000 13,800 57,200 71,000

71-2015-4200072 71-09-05-455-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 01/14/2015 $61,000 14,800 41,300 56,100

71-2015-4200442 71-09-05-253-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126309 510 026 02/19/2015 $55,000 18,100 58,200 76,300

C71-2014-4200830 71-09-05-154-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 03/19/2014 $88,900 13,300 62,200 75,500

71-2014-4201301 71-09-05-104-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 04/16/2014 $94,500 13,100 48,400 61,500

71-2014-4201415 71-09-05-102-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 04/25/2014 $52,000 13,200 52,800 66,000

71-2014-4202285 71-09-05-127-039.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 06/10/2014 $86,000 15,000 61,500 76,500

71-2014-4203325 71-09-05-156-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 08/01/2014 $72,000 14,200 48,600 62,800

71-2014-4203690 71-09-05-131-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 08/20/2014 $78,000 12,700 61,800 74,500

71-2014-4203786 71-09-05-151-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 08/21/2014 $81,500 10,900 56,800 67,700

71-2014-4204569 71-09-05-126-042.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 09/24/2014 $68,000 13,000 58,100 71,100

71-2014-4205091 71-09-05-127-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 10/28/2014 $63,900 13,300 46,400 59,700

71-2014-4206055 71-09-05-127-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 12/12/2014 $64,500 12,500 48,500 61,000

71-2014-4206864 71-09-05-105-035.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 01/23/2015 $77,000 13,000 53,900 66,900

71-2015-4200277 71-09-05-127-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 02/09/2015 $62,000 10,400 47,600 58,000

71-2015-4200497 71-09-05-178-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126314 510 026 02/25/2015 $90,000 20,000 66,100 86,100

71-2014-4201906 71-09-06-206-004.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 05/21/2014 $180,000 48,200 90,600 138,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200388 71-09-06-226-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 02/13/2014 $180,000 24,500 118,700 143,200

71-2014-4200747 71-09-06-282-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 03/12/2014 $85,000 18,700 85,800 104,500

C71-2014-4200804 71-09-06-256-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 03/19/2014 $105,000 20,100 78,300 98,400

71-2014-4201207 71-09-06-282-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 04/09/2014 $135,000 18,700 92,600 111,300

71-2014-4201324 71-09-06-279-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 04/17/2014 $135,000 23,000 100,200 123,200

71-2014-4202241 71-09-06-279-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 06/09/2014 $74,500 20,500 62,400 82,900

71-2014-4202745 71-09-06-230-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 06/30/2014 $114,900 20,600 43,600 64,200

71-2014-4202833 71-09-06-228-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 07/09/2014 $114,500 26,500 75,500 102,000

71-2014-4203079 71-09-06-277-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 07/21/2014 $150,000 25,100 134,300 159,400

71-2014-4203736 71-09-06-278-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 08/18/2014 $150,000 22,200 111,600 133,800

71-2014-4204968 71-09-06-279-028.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 10/21/2014 $104,000 21,400 94,800 116,200

71-2014-4206687 71-09-06-255-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 12/18/2014 $125,500 24,900 87,200 112,100

71-2014-4206361 71-09-06-276-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 12/22/2014 $167,500 25,900 96,400 122,300

71-2015-4200610 71-09-06-229-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 02/27/2015 $150,000 30,200 90,700 120,900

C71-2013-4207069 71-09-06-427-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 01/09/2014 $138,000 41,000 112,300 153,300

C71-2014-4200373 71-09-06-451-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 02/12/2014 $202,000 30,900 141,800 172,700

71-2014-4200648 71-09-06-406-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 03/07/2014 $104,000 28,400 67,200 95,600

C71-2014-4200649 71-09-05-351-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 03/07/2014 $115,000 47,800 93,000 140,800

71-2014-4201155 71-09-05-301-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 04/07/2014 $113,600 31,600 81,500 113,100

71-2014-4201192 71-09-06-404-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 04/09/2014 $136,000 43,800 102,800 146,600

71-2014-4201191 71-09-06-479-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 04/09/2014 $203,000 30,300 121,700 152,000

71-2014-4201236 71-09-06-451-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 04/14/2014 $129,900 32,000 82,200 114,200

71-2014-4201442 71-09-06-407-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 04/28/2014 $118,000 20,800 98,200 119,000

71-2014-4201634 71-09-06-456-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 05/08/2014 $179,900 25,200 116,500 141,700

71-2014-4202483 71-09-06-454-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 06/19/2014 $179,500 26,000 131,500 157,500

71-2014-4202598 71-09-06-457-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 06/26/2014 $127,500 25,200 92,700 117,900

71-2014-4202667 71-09-06-429-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 06/27/2014 $187,000 43,000 133,500 176,500

71-2014-4203343 71-09-06-402-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 07/30/2014 $62,900 22,700 35,400 58,100

71-2014-4203460 71-09-06-478-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 08/05/2014 $115,000 26,900 88,100 115,000

71-2014-4203415 71-09-06-405-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 08/05/2014 $81,000 25,500 60,000 85,500

71-2014-4203856 71-09-06-405-040.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 08/27/2014 $127,500 36,200 83,300 119,500

71-2014-4204357 71-09-06-428-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 09/18/2014 $138,000 30,500 111,000 141,500

71-2014-4204498 71-09-05-302-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 09/24/2014 $230,000 66,500 177,100 243,600

71-2014-4204549 71-09-06-431-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 09/24/2014 $146,000 34,300 114,100 148,400

71-2014-4205646 71-09-06-407-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 11/17/2014 $95,000 29,600 56,300 85,900

71-2014-4205626 71-09-06-477-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 11/17/2014 $280,000 29,700 189,400 219,100

71-2014-4205556 71-09-06-407-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 11/19/2014 $70,000 29,100 58,000 87,100

71-2014-4206365 71-09-06-431-037.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 12/22/2014 $153,500 37,800 128,900 166,700

71-2014-4206680 71-09-06-456-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 12/30/2014 $148,500 25,200 112,400 137,600

71-2015-4200133 71-09-06-428-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 01/26/2015 $121,000 31,300 92,200 123,500

71-2015-4200409 71-09-06-456-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126322 510 026 02/13/2015 $203,000 31,200 112,000 143,200

71-2014-4204680 71-09-07-227-009.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 10/07/2014 $91,900 48,200 67,100 115,300

71-2014-4204333 71-09-07-231-008.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 09/19/2014 $110,000 48,200 86,300 134,500

C71-2014-4200143 71-09-07-201-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 01/24/2014 $122,000 26,900 91,500 118,400

C71-2014-4200793 71-09-07-126-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 03/18/2014 $85,000 26,700 68,200 94,900

71-2014-4202011 71-09-07-128-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 05/28/2014 $149,000 41,100 100,600 141,700

71-2014-4202270 71-09-07-229-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 06/12/2014 $154,900 40,100 148,000 188,100

71-2014-4202517 71-09-07-232-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 06/20/2014 $89,000 26,700 81,800 108,500

71-2014-4203003 71-09-07-127-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 07/16/2014 $108,000 27,900 75,100 103,000

71-2014-4202986 71-09-07-227-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 07/17/2014 $130,000 52,300 83,800 136,100

71-2014-4203605 71-09-07-278-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 08/13/2014 $110,000 34,000 78,700 112,700

71-2014-4202920 71-09-07-232-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 09/02/2014 $102,000 26,700 89,700 116,400

71-2014-4204664 71-09-07-230-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 10/06/2014 $72,000 25,400 49,200 74,600

71-2014-4205279 71-09-07-201-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 10/30/2014 $137,400 34,000 84,200 118,200

71-2014-4206274 71-09-07-129-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 12/23/2014 $215,000 41,600 142,700 184,300

71-2015-4200059 71-09-07-277-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 01/25/2015 $104,000 33,700 74,200 107,900

71-2015-4200220 71-09-07-202-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 01/28/2015 $165,900 29,900 112,700 142,600

71-2014-4201214 71-09-07-180-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126331 510 026 04/09/2014 $205,000 51,700 158,200 209,900

71-2014-4201854 71-09-07-178-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126331 510 026 05/19/2014 $237,500 62,000 200,100 262,100

71-2014-4203847 71-09-07-251-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126331 510 026 08/27/2014 $272,500 61,900 138,400 200,300

71-2014-4204204 71-09-07-253-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126331 510 026 09/12/2014 $285,000 56,900 188,400 245,300

C71-2014-4200969 71-09-07-401-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 03/26/2014 $224,900 41,100 169,900 211,000

71-2014-4201329 71-09-07-401-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 04/17/2014 $186,000 56,000 128,800 184,800

71-2014-4201619 71-09-07-156-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 05/07/2014 $168,000 47,400 130,500 177,900

71-2014-4201693 71-09-07-179-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 05/12/2014 $300,000 42,300 209,500 251,800

71-2014-4204009 71-09-07-401-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 09/04/2014 $249,900 47,700 151,800 199,500

71-2014-4206537 71-09-07-180-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 12/31/2014 $290,000 93,000 210,800 303,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2015-4200579 71-09-07-153-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126333 510 026 02/26/2015 $180,000 56,400 148,400 204,800

C71-2014-4200101 71-09-07-452-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 01/22/2014 $156,000 31,700 125,900 157,600

C71-2014-4200436 71-09-07-451-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 01/23/2014 $150,000 50,300 100,500 150,800

C71-2014-4200446 71-09-07-304-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 02/19/2014 $137,500 27,000 85,600 112,600

C71-2014-4200771 71-09-07-326-032.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 03/14/2014 $150,000 27,700 80,700 108,400

C71-2014-4200783 71-09-07-326-030.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 03/17/2014 $143,000 30,800 111,200 142,000

C71-2014-4200798 71-09-07-304-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 03/18/2014 $109,000 27,000 78,800 105,800

71-2014-4201060 71-09-07-328-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 04/01/2014 $165,000 25,900 86,600 112,500

71-2014-4201575 71-09-07-376-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/02/2014 $82,000 24,300 60,000 84,300

71-2014-4201626 71-09-07-326-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/07/2014 $157,500 28,300 116,400 144,700

71-2014-4201681 71-09-07-329-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/09/2014 $150,000 25,600 103,800 129,400

71-2014-4201759 71-09-07-382-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/14/2014 $117,500 30,500 89,700 120,200

71-2014-4201858 71-09-07-302-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/19/2014 $122,500 24,600 80,400 105,000

71-2014-4201926 71-09-07-327-050.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/22/2014 $139,500 29,800 86,000 115,800

71-2014-4201931 71-09-07-301-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/22/2014 $152,900 29,200 103,400 132,600

71-2014-4202003 71-09-07-351-036.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 05/28/2014 $102,900 23,800 69,500 93,300

71-2014-4202201 71-09-07-329-026.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 06/06/2014 $97,000 27,300 67,800 95,100

71-2014-4203559 71-09-07-328-025.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 06/12/2014 $107,000 32,400 99,700 132,100

71-2014-4202534 71-09-07-326-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 06/20/2014 $179,900 35,500 149,600 185,100

71-2014-4202649 71-09-07-405-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 06/25/2014 $150,000 68,000 108,600 176,600

71-2014-4202704 71-09-07-327-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 07/02/2014 $125,000 28,000 76,800 104,800

71-2014-4202830 71-09-07-328-033.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 07/09/2014 $131,000 28,600 94,100 122,700

71-2014-4202993 71-09-07-377-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 07/17/2014 $116,500 24,300 83,200 107,500

71-2014-4203435 71-09-07-156-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 08/04/2014 $133,000 29,800 82,000 111,800

71-2014-4203468 71-09-07-329-028.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 08/07/2014 $156,000 36,700 71,500 108,200

71-2014-4203628 71-09-07-382-030.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 08/14/2014 $65,000 25,000 54,700 79,700

71-2014-4203692 71-09-07-451-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 08/20/2014 $175,650 35,800 112,300 148,100

71-2014-4203980 71-09-07-405-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 09/02/2014 $100,000 35,300 68,100 103,400

71-2014-4202858 71-09-07-327-051.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 09/02/2014 $87,000 29,800 81,200 111,000

71-2014-4204188 71-09-07-328-050.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 09/11/2014 $115,000 33,400 83,800 117,200

71-2014-4204359 71-09-07-329-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 09/22/2014 $131,000 31,400 68,900 100,300

71-2014-4204702 71-09-07-401-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 10/07/2014 $150,300 31,500 113,600 145,100

71-2014-4204863 71-09-07-401-039.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 10/14/2014 $140,000 26,700 65,300 92,000

71-2014-4204934 71-09-07-304-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 10/17/2014 $117,000 27,000 117,700 144,700

71-2014-4205863 71-09-07-451-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 12/05/2014 $140,000 35,400 91,700 127,100

71-2014-4206186 71-09-07-377-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 12/18/2014 $75,000 24,300 68,200 92,500

71-2014-4206408 71-09-07-351-038.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 12/29/2014 $91,608 29,100 70,600 99,700

71-2014-4206293 71-09-07-405-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 02/16/2015 $171,000 54,200 112,600 166,800

71-2015-4200644 71-09-07-377-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126334 510 026 02/26/2015 $95,000 24,600 64,600 89,200

C71-2014-4200735 71-09-06-386-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 03/13/2014 $94,000 4,500 65,300 69,800

71-2014-4201181 71-09-06-330-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 04/08/2014 $50,000 3,600 52,800 56,400

71-2014-4202533 71-09-06-385-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 06/23/2014 $128,000 4,200 121,600 125,800

71-2014-4202794 71-09-06-386-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 07/03/2014 $106,500 4,500 98,500 103,000

71-2014-4203551 71-09-06-302-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 08/08/2014 $25,000 4,100 27,700 31,800

71-2014-4203667 71-09-06-305-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 08/19/2014 $39,900 3,600 48,600 52,200

71-2014-4203813 71-09-06-379-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 08/26/2014 $89,500 4,400 53,000 57,400

71-2014-4206321 71-09-06-302-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 12/24/2014 $55,950 4,200 39,000 43,200

71-2014-4206866 71-09-07-102-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 01/23/2015 $70,000 4,200 75,100 79,300

71-2015-4200466 71-09-06-327-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126338 510 026 02/23/2015 $115,000 5,100 111,300 116,400

71-2014-4202688 71-09-06-101-208.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 06/27/2014 $244,164 5,700 230,200 235,900

71-2014-4202686 71-09-06-101-211.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 06/27/2014 $244,247 5,700 228,800 234,500

71-2014-4202730 71-09-06-101-218.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 06/30/2014 $241,408 5,700 235,800 241,500

71-2014-4202733 71-09-06-101-177.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/01/2014 $275,000 3,400 224,800 228,200

71-2014-4202783 71-09-06-101-219.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/03/2014 $235,869 5,700 227,100 232,800

71-2014-4202811 71-09-06-101-216.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/08/2014 $238,884 5,700 235,800 241,500

71-2014-4202908 71-09-06-101-209.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/09/2014 $251,148 5,700 228,800 234,500

71-2014-4203619 71-09-06-101-207.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/09/2014 $259,132 5,700 227,100 232,800

71-2014-4202911 71-09-06-101-217.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/11/2014 $242,027 5,700 227,100 232,800

71-2014-4203064 71-09-06-101-205.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/18/2014 $253,804 5,700 228,800 234,500

71-2014-4203123 71-09-06-101-210.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $239,077 5,700 230,200 235,900

71-2014-4203118 71-09-06-101-214.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $240,384 5,700 230,200 235,900

71-2014-4203122 71-09-06-101-215.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/23/2014 $240,665 5,700 228,800 234,500

71-2014-4203171 71-09-06-101-213.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/25/2014 $244,748 5,700 228,800 234,500

71-2014-4203348 71-09-06-101-212.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/30/2014 $239,658 5,700 230,200 235,900

71-2014-4203997 71-09-06-101-204.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/31/2014 $256,652 5,700 235,800 241,500

71-2014-4203998 71-09-06-101-206.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 07/31/2014 $250,418 5,700 237,500 243,200

71-2014-4203639 71-09-06-101-182.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 08/15/2014 $265,000 3,400 233,400 236,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4205272 71-09-06-101-071.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126345 550 026 10/30/2014 $274,000 3,000 234,900 237,900

71-2014-4201573 71-08-12-279-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126346 510 026 05/02/2014 $203,000 8,500 181,700 190,200

71-2014-4201793 71-08-12-280-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126346 510 026 05/15/2014 $220,000 8,100 210,000 218,100

71-2014-4202318 71-09-06-103-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126346 510 026 06/11/2014 $290,987 7,700 243,300 251,000

71-2014-4202838 71-09-06-153-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126346 510 026 07/09/2014 $164,400 9,600 153,200 162,800

71-2014-4205629 71-09-06-152-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126346 510 026 11/17/2014 $200,300 9,900 179,600 189,500

C71-2014-4200224 71-08-01-186-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126347 510 026 02/04/2014 $159,000 11,200 88,600 99,800

71-2014-4201433 71-08-01-426-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126347 510 026 04/28/2014 $87,900 3,900 54,600 58,500

71-2014-4202182 71-08-01-406-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126347 510 026 06/05/2014 $97,000 4,600 77,600 82,200

71-2015-4200321 71-08-01-259-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126347 510 026 02/10/2015 $105,000 4,700 71,600 76,300

71-2014-4201290 71-08-01-401-027.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 04/16/2014 $132,000 10,900 100,200 111,100

71-2014-4202023 71-08-01-182-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 05/30/2014 $35,000 6,300 28,400 34,700

71-2014-4202361 71-08-01-405-015.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 06/11/2014 $128,500 11,000 139,200 150,200

71-2014-4202262 71-08-01-205-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 06/12/2014 $85,100 7,700 44,100 51,800

71-2014-4202861 71-09-06-127-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 07/09/2014 $76,950 8,500 59,400 67,900

71-2014-4202870 71-09-06-155-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 07/10/2014 $72,000 9,000 36,400 45,400

71-2014-4203995 71-08-01-258-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 08/28/2014 $25,000 3,900 22,600 26,500

71-2014-4204972 71-08-01-256-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 10/21/2014 $70,000 5,100 63,900 69,000

71-2014-4205363 71-08-01-479-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 11/06/2014 $33,500 4,300 30,100 34,400

71-2014-4206182 71-08-01-405-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126348 510 026 12/16/2014 $120,000 8,900 134,500 143,400

C71-2014-4200584 71-08-01-431-020.000-026 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Portage 7126350 500 026 03/03/2014 $3,500 3,500 0 3,500

71-2014-4201741 71-08-11-229-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126364 510 026 05/13/2014 $100,000 6,500 118,300 124,800

71-2014-4204150 71-08-12-406-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126364 510 026 09/10/2014 $80,000 4,500 82,600 87,100

71-2014-4204358 71-08-12-307-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126364 510 026 09/22/2014 $59,660 2,600 70,300 72,900

71-2014-4206786 71-08-11-206-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126364 510 026 01/13/2015 $117,000 3,600 119,900 123,500

71-2015-4200266 71-08-11-255-032.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126364 510 026 02/04/2015 $95,000 6,000 70,900 76,900

71-2014-4201411 71-08-02-277-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126373 510 026 04/24/2014 $151,000 27,300 98,400 125,700

71-2014-4202658 71-08-02-435-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126373 510 026 06/25/2014 $92,000 24,700 87,500 112,200

71-2014-4202852 71-08-02-435-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126373 510 026 07/10/2014 $105,000 29,900 71,300 101,200

71-2014-4202982 71-08-02-277-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126373 510 026 07/16/2014 $152,000 19,000 92,100 111,100

71-2014-4204386 71-08-02-429-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126373 510 026 09/22/2014 $104,500 26,400 84,300 110,700

71-2014-4203114 71-08-02-204-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126374 510 026 07/23/2014 $62,000 16,200 56,300 72,500

71-2014-4205295 71-08-02-205-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126374 510 026 11/03/2014 $95,000 19,900 63,900 83,800

71-2014-4202965 71-08-02-261-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126375 510 026 07/15/2014 $93,500 9,700 65,100 74,800

71-2014-4204276 71-08-01-327-035.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126375 510 026 09/15/2014 $93,000 8,200 58,000 66,200

71-2014-4206826 71-08-01-327-045.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126375 510 026 01/16/2015 $43,000 8,200 46,000 54,200

71-2014-4203406 71-08-02-132-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126376 510 026 08/04/2014 $75,000 8,900 74,100 83,000

71-2014-4201967 71-08-01-130-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126380 510 026 05/27/2014 $260,000 35,600 158,200 193,800

71-2014-4202784 71-08-01-177-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126380 510 026 07/03/2014 $120,000 20,300 128,800 149,100

71-2014-4203737 71-08-01-178-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126380 510 026 08/20/2014 $107,000 25,200 111,700 136,900

71-2014-4204209 71-08-01-126-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126380 510 026 09/12/2014 $285,000 24,300 255,100 279,400

71-2014-4206073 71-08-01-133-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126380 510 026 12/12/2014 $165,000 28,900 137,600 166,500

71-2014-4205297 71-08-11-134-011.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126384 510 026 11/03/2014 $64,900 5,400 50,000 55,400

71-2014-4201233 71-08-02-453-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126384 510 026 04/15/2014 $70,000 2,700 94,700 97,400

71-2014-4202286 71-08-11-201-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126384 510 026 06/10/2014 $47,100 1,700 56,000 57,700

71-2014-4202836 71-08-02-259-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126384 510 026 06/26/2014 $38,900 1,600 38,100 39,700

71-2014-4201527 71-08-11-203-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126387 520 026 05/01/2014 $74,500 2,700 96,900 99,600

71-2014-4201897 71-08-02-184-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126387 510 026 05/20/2014 $62,500 1,500 63,600 65,100

71-2014-4202038 71-08-02-452-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126387 510 026 05/29/2014 $78,500 2,600 74,900 77,500

71-2014-4203685 71-08-02-184-012.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126387 510 026 08/19/2014 $62,000 1,500 54,000 55,500

71-2014-4202279 71-08-02-453-021.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126389 510 026 06/12/2014 $175,727 5,400 77,000 82,400

71-2014-4201570 71-08-03-304-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126391 510 026 05/02/2014 $36,000 2,900 33,100 36,000

71-2014-4201879 71-08-11-177-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126391 510 026 05/21/2014 $40,900 2,700 27,900 30,600

71-2014-4203621 71-08-11-176-055.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126391 510 026 08/14/2014 $80,000 2,800 50,300 53,100

71-2014-4204714 71-08-02-226-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 10/09/2014 $119,500 50,300 65,300 115,600

71-2014-4202680 71-08-01-181-007.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/27/2014 $144,000 44,200 89,000 133,200

C71-2013-4207004 71-08-02-231-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 01/08/2014 $64,000 15,300 60,700 76,000

C71-2014-4200748 71-08-02-232-031.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 03/12/2014 $80,000 15,300 80,600 95,900

C71-2014-4200929 71-08-01-152-032.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 03/25/2014 $130,000 17,200 107,600 124,800

71-2014-4201725 71-08-01-109-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 05/13/2014 $88,500 17,200 68,100 85,300

71-2014-4202007 71-08-01-109-010.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 05/28/2014 $134,900 15,300 83,300 98,600

71-2014-4202105 71-08-01-110-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/02/2014 $109,900 25,400 83,800 109,200

71-2014-4201571 71-08-01-105-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/09/2014 $97,000 15,300 70,100 85,400

71-2014-4202342 71-08-02-202-001.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/13/2014 $88,000 18,700 53,500 72,200

71-2014-4202504 71-08-02-226-020.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/20/2014 $110,000 16,100 77,900 94,000

71-2014-4203589 71-08-01-110-023.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 08/08/2014 $179,900 24,300 95,400 119,700

71-2014-4203919 71-08-01-109-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 08/28/2014 $139,900 21,800 90,200 112,000

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204125 71-08-01-109-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 09/09/2014 $140,000 19,100 94,000 113,100

71-2014-4204965 71-08-02-233-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 10/21/2014 $130,000 15,300 96,200 111,500

71-2014-4205978 71-08-01-108-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 12/10/2014 $122,000 19,800 77,900 97,700

71-2014-4206072 71-08-02-231-024.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 12/12/2014 $60,000 15,300 38,600 53,900

71-2014-4206443 71-08-02-206-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 12/30/2014 $100,000 38,800 83,900 122,700

71-2015-4200130 71-08-02-228-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 01/21/2015 $259,000 52,700 184,600 237,300

C71-2014-4200797 71-03-34-428-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 03/20/2014 $91,200 7,000 84,100 91,100

C71-2014-4200974 71-03-34-432-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 03/26/2014 $60,000 8,400 85,600 94,000

71-2014-4201082 71-03-34-432-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 04/03/2014 $30,000 8,400 38,900 47,300

71-2014-4203588 71-03-34-429-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 08/08/2014 $112,000 8,400 129,600 138,000

71-2014-4203710 71-03-35-301-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 08/21/2014 $252,500 13,400 197,800 211,200

71-2014-4205301 71-03-35-304-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 11/03/2014 $147,500 8,300 126,600 134,900

71-2014-4205466 71-03-34-433-018.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 11/13/2014 $119,500 8,500 99,400 107,900

71-2014-4206058 71-03-35-305-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 12/12/2014 $162,000 10,900 124,400 135,300

71-2015-4200081 71-03-34-429-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126406 510 026 01/20/2015 $109,900 8,400 119,300 127,700

71-2014-4202543 71-03-35-179-031.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126413 510 026 06/23/2014 $75,000 8,400 59,200 67,600

71-2014-4206517 71-03-35-180-002.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126413 510 026 12/31/2014 $67,040 8,200 54,100 62,300

71-2015-4200192 71-03-35-179-016.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126413 510 026 01/26/2015 $61,000 8,200 47,700 55,900

71-2015-4200634 71-03-35-276-013.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126413 510 026 02/27/2015 $98,000 25,600 67,900 93,500

71-2014-4203625 71-03-34-230-034.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 08/14/2014 $68,000 24,200 55,200 79,400

C71-2014-4200427 71-03-35-103-006.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 02/14/2014 $101,000 22,200 79,100 101,300

71-2014-4203017 71-03-35-152-022.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 07/18/2014 $104,000 12,100 76,100 88,200

71-2014-4201919 71-03-35-155-017.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 05/22/2014 $61,000 10,500 45,500 56,000

71-2014-4202773 71-03-35-106-022.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 07/07/2014 $81,600 11,500 72,900 84,400

71-2014-4203287 71-03-35-153-057.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 07/31/2014 $98,900 10,500 90,900 101,400

71-2014-4204365 71-03-35-152-033.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 09/18/2014 $53,000 16,200 56,100 72,300

71-2014-4204719 71-03-35-156-009.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 09/23/2014 $92,000 19,000 80,000 99,000

71-2014-4204619 71-03-34-230-032.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 09/30/2014 $98,000 19,000 80,400 99,400

71-2014-4204744 71-03-35-176-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 10/09/2014 $67,500 10,900 37,000 47,900

71-2014-4206469 71-03-35-176-048.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 12/30/2014 $110,000 10,900 71,500 82,400

71-2015-4200080 71-03-35-153-065.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 01/20/2015 $84,500 16,500 47,400 63,900

71-2015-4200077 71-03-35-153-050.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 01/20/2015 $80,500 10,500 62,400 72,900

71-2015-4200298 71-03-35-103-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 02/10/2015 $85,500 10,500 43,400 53,900

71-2015-4200432 71-03-35-101-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 02/20/2015 $40,000 10,500 47,100 57,600

71-2015-4200569 71-03-35-153-044.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 02/26/2015 $66,000 10,500 49,600 60,100

71-2014-4201379 71-03-26-355-027.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126419 510 026 04/22/2014 $67,500 25,900 44,200 70,100

C71-2014-4200912 71-03-34-478-021.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 03/24/2014 $20,000 800 20,000 20,800

71-2014-4200985 71-03-34-426-004.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 03/31/2014 $35,000 800 29,900 30,700

71-2014-4201959 71-03-35-351-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 05/23/2014 $42,000 900 24,300 25,200

71-2014-4202865 71-08-03-227-011.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 07/09/2014 $23,000 800 23,800 24,600

71-2014-4202937 71-03-35-352-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 07/14/2014 $23,000 800 23,700 24,500

71-2014-4203496 71-03-34-476-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 08/06/2014 $22,000 800 22,400 23,200

71-2014-4203804 71-03-34-226-006.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 08/22/2014 $50,000 800 38,900 39,700

71-2014-4205639 71-03-34-426-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126422 510 026 11/17/2014 $36,500 800 34,300 35,100

71-2014-4204721 71-08-03-182-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126425 510 026 10/09/2014 $25,000 800 24,300 25,100

71-2014-4204103 71-08-01-326-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126431 551 026 08/29/2014 $190,000 8,400 120,500 128,900

71-2014-4205624 71-09-05-254-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126432 550 026 11/17/2014 $138,000 1,500 97,200 98,700

71-2014-4206466 71-09-05-254-028.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126432 550 026 12/30/2014 $150,000 2,500 105,400 107,900

71-2014-4204954 71-09-08-427-007.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126433 551 026 10/20/2014 $96,500 7,100 63,200 70,300

71-2014-4205970 71-09-08-427-014.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126433 551 026 12/09/2014 $75,000 7,100 74,300 81,400

71-2014-4206178 71-09-08-427-005.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126433 551 026 12/16/2014 $67,500 7,100 56,700 63,800

71-2014-4201865 71-09-19-351-019.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126434 551 026 05/21/2014 $220,000 22,900 209,200 232,100

C71-2013-4207101 71-03-35-477-008.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126435 551 026 01/17/2014 $185,000 15,700 172,000 187,700

71-2014-4201580 71-03-35-452-110.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126437 551 026 05/05/2014 $110,000 0 111,700 111,700

71-2014-4203983 71-03-35-452-029.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126437 551 026 08/29/2014 $110,000 0 113,400 113,400

C71-2014-4200126 71-03-35-452-040.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126438 551 026 01/30/2014 $84,000 0 87,500 87,500

71-2014-4201221 71-03-35-452-054.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126438 551 026 04/11/2014 $67,500 0 88,400 88,400

71-2014-4203331 71-03-35-452-003.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126438 551 026 07/30/2014 $55,000 0 75,500 75,500

71-2014-4203849 71-03-35-452-034.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126438 551 026 08/27/2014 $86,000 0 94,400 94,400

71-2014-4204052 71-03-35-452-035.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126438 551 026 09/03/2014 $84,750 0 94,400 94,400

71-2014-4202244 71-03-35-477-034.000-026 N Res Imp None Portage 7126441 551 026 06/09/2014 $120,000 12,700 102,800 115,500

71-2014-4204464 71-13-27-229-001.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127009 510 027 03/16/2014 $84,000 5,900 69,700 75,600

71-2014-4201637 71-13-26-102-013.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127009 510 027 05/07/2014 $135,600 4,300 66,800 71,100

71-2014-4203139 71-13-26-176-002.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127009 511 027 07/24/2014 $124,500 29,300 61,500 90,800

71-2014-4203534 71-13-27-229-008.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127009 510 027 08/08/2014 $89,900 5,800 65,400 71,200

71-2014-4202340 71-18-02-378-001.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127011 510 027 06/13/2014 $98,000 27,100 88,900 116,000

71-2014-4203524 71-18-11-202-001.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127012 510 027 08/06/2014 $173,500 26,400 137,700 164,100

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4204081 71-13-33-300-004.000-027 N Res Imp None Union 7127015 510 027 09/05/2014 $300,000 30,700 202,100 232,800

71-2014-4202715 71-13-34-201-033.000-028 N Res Imp None Union 7128010 510 028 07/02/2014 $282,400 28,600 226,600 255,200

71-2014-4206363 71-13-34-201-019.000-028 N Res Imp None Union 7128010 510 028 12/22/2014 $212,912 24,000 158,000 182,000

71-2015-4200488 71-13-34-201-059.000-028 N Res Imp None Union 7128010 510 028 02/24/2015 $229,900 24,600 143,200 167,800

71-2014-4203080 71-13-35-354-005.000-028 Y Res Imp None Union 7128011 510 028 07/22/2014 $80,000 21,600 59,100 80,700

71-2014-4203192 71-13-35-353-010.000-028 N Res Imp None Union 7128011 510 028 07/25/2014 $51,000 6,500 45,600 52,100

71-2015-4200124 71-13-35-304-002.000-028 N Res Imp None Union 7128011 510 028 01/21/2015 $79,900 9,000 69,100 78,100

71-2014-4206539 71-02-26-326-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129002 510 029 12/31/2014 $92,000 15,000 97,700 112,700

71-2014-4201940 71-07-12-251-008.000-029 N Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Warren 7129004 340 029 04/29/2014 $525,000 84,100 577,700 661,800

71-2014-4201201 71-07-27-353-002.000-029 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Warren 7129009 430 029 04/09/2014 $16,000 20,300 4,800 25,100

71-2014-4203629 71-02-14-326-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129013 510 029 08/14/2014 $247,000 25,200 203,200 228,400

71-2014-4203812 71-02-14-403-013.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129013 510 029 08/21/2014 $250,000 24,700 198,500 223,200

71-2015-4200278 71-02-14-326-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129013 510 029 02/09/2015 $235,000 28,700 209,500 238,200

71-2014-4201325 71-02-14-476-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 04/17/2014 $305,000 24,500 290,900 315,400

71-2014-4203142 71-02-14-479-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 07/24/2014 $279,500 26,400 244,800 271,200

71-2014-4203263 71-02-14-429-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 07/29/2014 $169,013 22,400 206,600 229,000

71-2014-4203769 71-02-14-477-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 08/25/2014 $255,000 21,400 219,000 240,400

71-2014-4205632 71-02-14-476-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 11/17/2014 $340,000 26,600 315,300 341,900

71-2014-4205852 71-02-14-479-003.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 12/03/2014 $305,000 25,500 247,600 273,100

71-2014-4206010 71-02-14-476-022.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 12/11/2014 $288,100 37,700 251,200 288,900

71-2014-4206407 71-02-14-477-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129014 510 029 02/11/2015 $240,000 20,400 212,700 233,100

C71-2014-4200310 71-02-24-352-040.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 02/05/2014 $120,000 21,900 122,600 144,500

C71-2014-4200314 71-02-24-376-011.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 02/07/2014 $152,500 18,400 122,800 141,200

C71-2014-4200451 71-02-24-353-024.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 02/19/2014 $119,500 15,600 99,900 115,500

71-2014-4202857 71-02-24-378-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 07/10/2014 $210,000 16,700 165,200 181,900

71-2014-4204058 71-02-24-376-015.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 09/03/2014 $159,900 16,600 111,500 128,100

71-2014-4205372 71-02-24-353-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 11/06/2014 $162,500 16,700 143,700 160,400

71-2014-4205549 71-02-24-352-023.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 11/19/2014 $175,000 15,600 143,200 158,800

71-2014-4205819 71-02-24-352-031.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 12/05/2014 $161,900 16,700 113,700 130,400

71-2014-4206691 71-02-24-301-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129016 510 029 12/29/2014 $144,900 16,200 113,200 129,400

71-2015-4200459 71-02-26-351-002.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129017 510 029 02/18/2015 $142,900 35,000 103,000 138,000

71-2014-4203586 71-02-26-352-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129017 510 029 08/08/2014 $138,900 16,800 111,200 128,000

71-2014-4204556 71-02-26-351-018.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129017 510 029 09/24/2014 $176,877 17,100 124,100 141,200

71-2014-4206544 71-02-35-279-032.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129018 510 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 13,000 68,300 81,300

71-2014-4201684 71-02-35-279-027.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129018 510 029 05/09/2014 $48,000 8,300 22,100 30,400

71-2014-4204021 71-02-35-284-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129018 510 029 09/04/2014 $65,000 9,300 39,900 49,200

71-2014-4202013 71-02-25-401-007.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 05/28/2014 $67,000 14,900 70,300 85,200

C71-2014-4200561 71-02-36-451-006.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 02/26/2014 $115,000 13,900 77,300 91,200

71-2014-4201509 71-07-01-251-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 04/30/2014 $105,000 13,900 77,600 91,500

71-2014-4202710 71-02-25-326-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 07/03/2014 $69,285 8,000 91,700 99,700

71-2014-4202714 71-07-23-176-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 07/03/2014 $113,500 15,000 96,300 111,300

71-2014-4203012 71-02-26-100-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 07/18/2014 $80,000 16,800 58,700 75,500

71-2014-4203072 71-07-34-300-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 511 029 07/21/2014 $114,500 15,600 91,000 106,600

71-2014-4203143 71-02-34-200-006.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 07/23/2014 $121,500 18,700 75,700 94,400

71-2014-4203438 71-02-34-200-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 08/04/2014 $110,000 12,200 95,200 107,400

71-2014-4204294 71-02-35-352-009.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 599 029 09/17/2014 $11,000 13,900 100 14,000

71-2014-4204339 71-07-23-177-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 09/17/2014 $139,000 15,100 87,500 102,600

71-2014-4204597 71-07-14-376-003.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 09/25/2014 $105,000 14,200 170,900 185,100

71-2014-4204490 71-02-13-351-016.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 10/01/2014 $300,000 32,000 191,600 223,600

71-2014-4204911 71-07-01-201-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 511 029 10/15/2014 $259,900 18,600 191,400 210,000

71-2014-4205650 71-02-13-376-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 11/17/2014 $428,500 46,000 267,000 313,000

71-2014-4205950 71-07-27-376-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 12/09/2014 $84,900 18,700 89,500 108,200

71-2015-4200032 71-07-24-326-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 01/13/2015 $146,500 30,400 100,700 131,100

71-2015-4200255 71-07-34-100-001.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 511 029 02/04/2015 $88,260 15,700 60,000 75,700

71-2015-4200297 71-02-22-300-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 02/10/2015 $130,515 10,300 83,700 94,000

71-2014-4201193 71-02-35-426-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129020 510 029 04/09/2014 $139,000 6,600 63,400 70,000

71-2014-4202527 71-07-02-426-006.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 06/23/2014 $173,000 32,800 145,300 178,100

C71-2014-4200098 71-07-02-403-003.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 01/17/2014 $188,000 25,800 153,800 179,600

71-2014-4201077 71-07-02-406-006.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 04/03/2014 $109,500 17,200 102,900 120,100

71-2014-4202964 71-07-02-403-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 07/15/2014 $151,390 15,900 122,800 138,700

71-2014-4205439 71-07-02-426-017.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 11/12/2014 $175,000 18,500 155,200 173,700

71-2014-4206184 71-07-02-404-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 12/18/2014 $112,000 17,400 96,500 113,900

71-2014-4201045 71-07-01-327-009.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129022 510 029 03/28/2014 $137,500 13,800 102,700 116,500

71-2014-4202980 71-07-02-205-001.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129023 510 029 07/16/2014 $96,500 23,000 58,500 81,500

C71-2014-4200900 71-07-02-176-017.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129023 510 029 03/24/2014 $103,500 8,700 77,800 86,500

71-2014-4201922 71-07-02-151-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129023 510 029 05/22/2014 $142,500 16,400 102,300 118,700

71-2014-4203634 71-07-02-226-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129023 510 029 08/14/2014 $22,000 10,300 18,600 28,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4201384 71-07-11-202-005.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 04/22/2014 $104,000 30,800 79,700 110,500

71-2014-4204488 71-07-11-227-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 09/30/2014 $185,000 15,700 140,700 156,400

71-2014-4205006 71-07-11-251-026.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 10/22/2014 $102,500 14,800 81,000 95,800

71-2014-4205694 71-07-11-202-012.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 11/26/2014 $147,000 19,700 116,600 136,300

71-2015-4200128 71-07-11-277-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 01/21/2015 $116,000 19,200 109,000 128,200

71-2014-4202159 71-07-11-326-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129025 510 029 06/03/2014 $80,000 13,400 45,100 58,500

71-2014-4204217 71-07-11-326-009.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129025 510 029 09/12/2014 $115,000 13,400 64,400 77,800

71-2014-4205967 71-07-12-476-021.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129027 510 029 12/09/2014 $45,000 16,000 34,400 50,400

71-2014-4205843 71-07-13-176-013.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129028 510 029 12/03/2014 $187,500 29,900 173,500 203,400

71-2014-4201660 71-07-13-132-009.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129029 510 029 05/08/2014 $104,000 21,800 76,300 98,100

71-2014-4201664 71-07-13-127-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129029 510 029 05/08/2014 $116,000 17,700 93,600 111,300

71-2014-4203801 71-07-13-176-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129029 510 029 08/22/2014 $138,000 15,700 105,000 120,700

71-2014-4204731 71-07-13-131-018.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129029 510 029 10/07/2014 $127,000 17,300 104,100 121,400

71-2014-4203759 71-07-13-201-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129030 510 029 08/25/2014 $153,250 19,200 100,600 119,800

71-2015-4200590 71-07-13-253-016.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129030 510 029 02/25/2015 $160,000 21,300 172,900 194,200

71-2014-4201902 71-07-14-451-013.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129031 510 029 05/21/2014 $164,500 24,500 142,700 167,200

71-2014-4201915 71-07-14-251-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129031 510 029 05/22/2014 $184,500 21,400 138,300 159,700

71-2014-4202111 71-07-14-451-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129031 510 029 06/02/2014 $146,000 21,600 122,800 144,400

71-2014-4202459 71-07-14-455-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129031 510 029 06/19/2014 $175,500 29,900 121,900 151,800

71-2014-4202972 71-07-14-451-011.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129031 510 029 07/16/2014 $190,000 9,900 193,400 203,300

C71-2014-4200046 71-07-24-127-006.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129033 510 029 01/09/2014 $127,000 15,000 116,600 131,600

C71-2014-4200332 71-07-27-352-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129035 510 029 02/06/2014 $93,000 17,300 54,500 71,800

71-2014-4204947 71-07-24-303-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129036 510 029 10/20/2014 $126,500 17,900 116,800 134,700

71-2014-4206481 71-07-24-303-007.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129036 510 029 12/30/2014 $135,000 17,900 111,400 129,300

C71-2014-4200337 71-02-13-376-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129041 510 029 02/06/2014 $175,000 43,600 146,000 189,600

71-2014-4201493 71-02-13-351-005.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129041 510 029 04/30/2014 $209,000 36,600 180,000 216,600

C71-2014-4200040 71-07-12-476-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129042 510 029 01/09/2014 $173,900 14,300 160,300 174,600

C71-2014-4200095 71-07-12-451-017.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129042 510 029 01/17/2014 $191,000 15,200 138,300 153,500

71-2014-4202068 71-07-12-102-003.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129043 510 029 05/30/2014 $253,000 18,400 232,900 251,300

C71-2014-4200517 71-02-24-326-013.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 02/25/2014 $135,750 21,000 114,400 135,400

71-2014-4201750 71-02-24-304-018.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 05/14/2014 $146,000 19,800 123,000 142,800

71-2014-4202197 71-02-24-378-021.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 06/05/2014 $174,900 29,200 143,800 173,000

71-2014-4202623 71-02-24-303-002.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 06/25/2014 $149,000 19,800 116,800 136,600

71-2014-4202699 71-02-24-378-017.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 07/01/2014 $192,000 19,800 138,000 157,800

71-2014-4203054 71-02-24-301-028.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 07/18/2014 $129,000 20,200 102,500 122,700

71-2014-4205492 71-02-24-301-076.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 11/13/2014 $220,377 30,600 180,900 211,500

71-2014-4206381 71-02-24-378-020.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 12/22/2014 $187,800 24,800 196,000 220,800

71-2014-4206284 71-02-24-304-010.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129045 510 029 12/23/2014 $135,000 19,800 105,000 124,800

C71-2014-4200194 71-02-24-354-026.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 01/30/2014 $196,828 21,400 145,100 166,500

71-2014-4201130 71-02-25-126-024.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 04/07/2014 $152,000 16,700 112,700 129,400

71-2014-4201404 71-02-24-354-097.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 04/25/2014 $207,500 15,800 169,100 184,900

71-2014-4201503 71-02-24-354-076.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 04/29/2014 $205,000 18,800 180,300 199,100

71-2014-4201554 71-02-25-127-004.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 05/02/2014 $175,000 57,800 115,500 173,300

71-2014-4201851 71-02-25-129-023.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 05/19/2014 $275,000 20,300 226,300 246,600

71-2014-4201892 71-02-25-129-008.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 05/21/2014 $232,500 21,000 176,500 197,500

71-2014-4202103 71-02-24-354-081.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 06/02/2014 $169,000 20,400 150,300 170,700

71-2014-4202706 71-02-24-354-090.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 07/03/2014 $187,121 24,200 162,800 187,000

71-2014-4203105 71-02-24-354-034.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 07/24/2014 $215,000 22,500 205,300 227,800

71-2014-4203447 71-02-25-129-022.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 08/04/2014 $151,500 21,400 128,600 150,000

71-2014-4203612 71-02-24-354-056.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 08/13/2014 $230,000 19,100 173,600 192,700

71-2014-4203744 71-02-24-354-066.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 08/20/2014 $138,500 15,800 121,100 136,900

71-2014-4203934 71-02-25-126-029.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 08/29/2014 $204,000 23,000 167,200 190,200

71-2014-4206176 71-02-24-354-036.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 12/18/2014 $250,000 24,500 188,500 213,000

71-2015-4200152 71-02-25-126-021.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129047 510 029 01/23/2015 $177,000 19,700 130,900 150,600

71-2014-4206932 71-02-23-400-032.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129053 510 029 11/26/2014 $140,000 29,100 124,400 153,500

71-2014-4206281 71-02-23-400-055.000-029 N Res Imp None Warren 7129053 510 029 12/23/2014 $163,500 29,100 132,700 161,800

71-2014-4201505 71-02-24-354-093.000-029 N Res Vac Combined Res Vac Warren 7129097 500 029 04/30/2014 $17,500 14,900 0 14,900

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

SDFID Primary ParcelNumber MultiParcel StudySection Grouping Township Neighborhood PropertyClass TaxingDistrict SaleDate StudySalePrice CurrentLandAV CurrentImpAVCurrentTotalAV71-2014-4200636 Y 71-03-24-208-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103064 510 003 03/04/2014 $50,132 2,800 55,600 58,400

71-2014-4200636 N 71-03-24-208-010.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103112 500 003 03/04/2014 $50,132 2,200 0 2,200

71-2014-4200636 N 71-03-24-208-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103112 500 003 03/04/2014 $50,132 2,200 0 2,200

71-2014-4201201 Y 71-07-27-353-002.000-029 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Warren 7129009 430 029 04/09/2014 $16,000 18,500 4,800 23,300

71-2014-4201201 N 71-07-27-353-001.000-029 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Warren 7129007 400 029 04/09/2014 $16,000 1,800 0 1,800

71-2014-4201266 Y 71-08-12-281-003.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 04/08/2014 $226,000 23,900 139,900 163,800

71-2014-4201266 N 71-08-12-281-004.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126097 456 026 04/08/2014 $226,000 21,100 700 21,800

71-2014-4201384 Y 71-07-11-202-005.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129024 510 029 04/22/2014 $104,000 15,400 79,700 95,100

71-2014-4201384 N 71-07-11-202-006.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129074 500 029 04/22/2014 $104,000 15,400 0 15,400

71-2014-4201452 Y 71-03-12-351-004.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 04/23/2014 $69,900 2,800 69,900 72,700

71-2014-4201452 N 71-03-12-351-005.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 04/23/2014 $69,900 2,300 0 2,300

71-2014-4201523 Y 71-09-18-155-018.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 05/01/2014 $39,900 3,800 50,100 53,900

71-2014-4201523 N 71-09-18-155-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126283 500 026 05/01/2014 $39,900 4,300 0 4,300

71-2014-4201812 Y 71-09-18-203-021.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126276 510 026 05/14/2014 $70,000 2,400 60,300 62,700

71-2014-4201812 N 71-09-18-203-020.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126277 500 026 05/14/2014 $70,000 2,400 0 2,400

71-2014-4201906 Y 71-09-06-206-004.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126318 510 026 05/21/2014 $180,000 27,600 90,600 118,200

71-2014-4201906 N 71-09-06-206-003.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126319 500 026 05/21/2014 $180,000 20,600 0 20,600

71-2014-4201944 Y 71-04-27-102-007.000-036 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7136004 447 036 05/01/2014 $165,000 11,400 83,800 95,200

71-2014-4201944 N 71-04-27-102-006.000-036 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Harris 7136004 447 036 05/01/2014 $165,000 11,400 83,800 95,200

71-2014-4202013 Y 71-02-25-401-007.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129019 510 029 05/28/2014 $67,000 14,000 70,300 84,300

71-2014-4202013 N 71-02-25-200-021.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129002 501 029 05/28/2014 $67,000 900 0 900

71-2014-4202026 Y 71-04-08-377-003.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103039 510 003 05/24/2014 $192,500 24,600 193,600 218,200

71-2014-4202026 N 71-04-08-377-002.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103099 500 003 05/24/2014 $192,500 14,200 0 14,200

71-2014-4202150 Y 71-04-32-107-014.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 06/03/2014 $87,000 5,900 56,700 62,600

71-2014-4202150 N 71-04-32-107-013.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103130 599 003 06/03/2014 $87,000 5,900 600 6,500

71-2014-4202205 Y 71-08-05-102-016.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125034 510 025 06/06/2014 $85,000 14,300 63,200 77,500

71-2014-4202205 N 71-08-05-102-014.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125036 500 025 06/06/2014 $85,000 15,900 0 15,900

71-2014-4202242 Y 71-03-13-428-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 06/09/2014 $178,942 7,300 180,800 188,100

71-2014-4202242 N 71-03-13-428-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103111 500 003 06/09/2014 $178,942 6,600 0 6,600

71-2014-4202279 Y 71-08-02-453-021.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126389 510 026 06/12/2014 $175,727 2,700 77,000 79,700

71-2014-4202279 N 71-08-02-453-022.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126385 500 026 06/12/2014 $175,727 2,700 0 2,700

71-2014-4202527 Y 71-07-02-426-006.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129021 510 029 06/23/2014 $173,000 16,400 145,300 161,700

71-2014-4202527 N 71-07-02-426-007.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129071 500 029 06/23/2014 $173,000 16,400 0 16,400

71-2014-4202544 Y 71-09-16-383-009.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123066 510 023 06/11/2014 $95,000 11,200 79,800 91,000

71-2014-4202544 N 71-09-16-383-010.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123066 500 023 06/11/2014 $95,000 4,400 0 4,400

71-2014-4202596 Y 71-14-16-426-001.000-016 Y Res Imp None Madison 7116006 511 016 06/26/2014 $112,000 51,300 24,200 75,500

71-2014-4202596 N 71-14-16-277-002.000-016 Y Res Imp None Madison 7116001 100 016 06/26/2014 $112,000 12,600 0 12,600

71-2014-4202643 Y 71-09-11-281-004.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131045 510 031 06/19/2014 $103,100 11,900 56,700 68,600

71-2014-4202643 N 71-09-11-281-003.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131045 599 031 06/19/2014 $103,100 11,900 3,700 15,600

71-2014-4202673 Y 71-10-04-127-012.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131040 510 031 06/23/2014 $97,000 8,300 63,600 71,900

71-2014-4202673 N 71-10-04-127-011.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131040 500 031 06/23/2014 $97,000 8,300 0 8,300

71-2014-4202680 Y 71-08-01-181-007.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 06/27/2014 $144,000 22,700 89,000 111,700

71-2014-4202680 N 71-08-01-181-006.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126401 500 026 06/27/2014 $144,000 21,500 0 21,500

71-2014-4202980 Y 71-07-02-205-001.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129023 510 029 07/16/2014 $96,500 20,700 58,500 79,200

71-2014-4202980 N 71-07-02-205-002.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129073 500 029 07/16/2014 $96,500 2,300 0 2,300

71-2014-4202990 Y 71-08-24-355-017.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 07/17/2014 $75,000 5,300 52,800 58,100

71-2014-4202990 N 71-08-24-355-016.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126237 500 026 07/17/2014 $75,000 6,500 0 6,500

71-2014-4203017 Y 71-03-35-152-022.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 07/18/2014 $104,000 10,800 76,100 86,900

71-2014-4203017 N 71-03-35-152-023.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126423 500 026 07/18/2014 $104,000 1,300 0 1,300

71-2014-4203074 Y 71-12-19-200-012.000-034 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7134005 510 034 07/21/2014 $270,000 38,900 177,500 216,400

71-2014-4203074 N 71-12-19-200-010.000-034 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7134001 100 034 07/21/2014 $270,000 25,800 0 25,800

71-2014-4203080 Y 71-13-35-354-005.000-028 Y Res Imp None Union 7128011 510 028 07/22/2014 $80,000 18,400 59,100 77,500

71-2014-4203080 N 71-13-35-354-010.000-028 Y Res Imp None Union 7128013 500 028 07/22/2014 $80,000 3,200 0 3,200

71-2014-4203092 Y 71-04-30-306-014.000-006 Y Res Imp None Clay 7106001 500 006 07/22/2014 $7,200 3,700 0 3,700

71-2014-4203092 N 71-04-30-306-013.000-006 Y Res Imp None Clay 7106001 500 006 07/22/2014 $7,200 3,500 0 3,500

71-2014-4203107 Y 71-08-08-378-018.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125041 510 025 07/22/2014 $98,500 5,700 69,800 75,500

71-2014-4203107 N 71-08-08-378-019.000-025 Y Res Imp None Portage 7125042 500 025 07/22/2014 $98,500 5,000 0 5,000

71-2014-4203190 Y 71-05-20-104-001.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111101 510 011 07/25/2014 $210,000 23,200 169,700 192,900

71-2014-4203190 N 71-05-20-102-005.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111100 500 011 07/25/2014 $210,000 100 0 100

71-2014-4203190 N 71-05-20-104-002.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111100 500 011 07/25/2014 $210,000 2,500 0 2,500

71-2014-4203218 Y 71-13-11-376-010.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101036 510 001 07/28/2014 $54,500 6,800 34,300 41,100

71-2014-4203218 N 71-13-11-376-011.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101036 500 001 07/28/2014 $54,500 6,800 0 6,800

71-2014-4203218 N 71-13-11-376-009.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101036 500 001 07/28/2014 $54,500 6,800 0 6,800

71-2014-4203245 Y 71-09-03-351-004.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123050 510 023 07/17/2014 $174,900 15,900 169,900 185,800

71-2014-4203245 N 71-09-03-351-016.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123050 500 023 07/17/2014 $174,900 8,800 0 8,800

71-2014-4203261 Y 71-08-35-251-003.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 07/29/2014 $148,000 10,800 102,800 113,600

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4203261 N 71-08-35-251-010.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101016 500 001 07/29/2014 $148,000 9,500 0 9,500

71-2014-4203294 Y 71-12-13-300-013.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110022 511 010 07/31/2014 $335,000 51,700 192,900 244,600

71-2014-4203294 N 71-12-13-300-012.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110001 100 010 07/31/2014 $335,000 11,500 0 11,500

71-2014-4203347 Y 71-04-15-276-011.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111052 510 011 07/30/2014 $385,000 73,600 266,900 340,500

71-2014-4203347 N 71-04-15-278-031.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111050 500 011 07/30/2014 $385,000 1,400 0 1,400

71-2014-4203364 Y 71-09-10-401-016.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123056 510 023 03/10/2014 $69,900 14,700 48,300 63,000

71-2014-4203364 N 71-09-10-401-017.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123056 500 023 03/10/2014 $69,900 6,600 0 6,600

71-2014-4203364 N 71-09-10-401-018.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123056 500 023 03/10/2014 $69,900 6,600 0 6,600

71-2014-4203530 Y 71-04-17-377-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103044 520 003 08/07/2014 $185,200 6,100 164,000 170,100

71-2014-4203530 N 71-04-17-377-007.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103102 500 003 08/07/2014 $185,200 7,000 0 7,000

71-2014-4203625 Y 71-03-34-230-034.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 08/14/2014 $68,000 15,100 55,200 70,300

71-2014-4203625 N 71-03-34-230-033.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126418 500 026 08/14/2014 $68,000 9,100 0 9,100

71-2014-4203688 Y 71-03-12-405-032.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 09/16/2014 $52,000 6,900 63,900 70,800

71-2014-4203688 N 71-03-12-405-033.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 09/16/2014 $52,000 5,600 0 5,600

71-2014-4203806 Y 71-05-17-154-002.000-011 Y Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7111088 500 011 08/22/2014 $45,000 28,000 0 28,000

71-2014-4203806 N 71-05-17-154-001.000-011 Y Res Vac Combined Res Vac Harris 7111088 500 011 08/22/2014 $45,000 27,600 0 27,600

71-2014-4203823 Y 71-10-20-201-012.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131062 510 031 08/12/2014 $141,900 15,400 108,200 123,600

71-2014-4203823 N 71-10-20-201-011.000-031 Y Res Imp None Penn 7131062 500 031 08/12/2014 $141,900 16,100 0 16,100

71-2014-4203862 Y 71-13-07-376-006.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 08/27/2014 $165,000 28,900 101,000 129,900

71-2014-4203862 N 71-13-07-376-005.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110016 500 010 08/27/2014 $165,000 8,900 0 8,900

71-2014-4203951 Y 71-08-12-283-003.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 07/10/2014 $330,500 59,600 180,300 239,900

71-2014-4203951 N 71-08-12-283-001.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126090 499 026 07/10/2014 $330,500 64,900 19,100 84,000

71-2014-4204170 Y 71-04-31-277-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103077 510 003 09/10/2014 $81,500 8,600 53,900 62,500

71-2014-4204170 N 71-04-31-277-007.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103122 500 003 09/10/2014 $81,500 4,300 0 4,300

71-2014-4204333 Y 71-09-07-231-008.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 09/19/2014 $110,000 26,200 86,300 112,500

71-2014-4204333 N 71-09-07-231-006.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126327 500 026 09/19/2014 $110,000 11,000 0 11,000

71-2014-4204333 N 71-09-07-231-007.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126327 500 026 09/19/2014 $110,000 11,000 0 11,000

71-2014-4204356 Y 71-13-05-376-010.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110023 510 010 09/22/2014 $125,000 19,800 90,100 109,900

71-2014-4204356 N 71-13-05-376-009.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110018 500 010 09/22/2014 $125,000 2,700 0 2,700

71-2014-4204459 Y 71-09-17-107-001.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126296 510 026 09/26/2014 $67,000 2,800 72,100 74,900

71-2014-4204459 N 71-09-17-107-002.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126297 500 026 09/26/2014 $67,000 1,000 0 1,000

71-2014-4204500 Y 71-09-15-276-004.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123031 447 023 09/26/2014 $174,000 29,700 67,000 96,700

71-2014-4204500 N 71-09-15-276-005.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123030 420 023 09/26/2014 $174,000 14,300 33,200 47,500

71-2014-4204584 Y 71-09-16-428-011.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123034 430 023 09/30/2014 $250,000 10,500 148,900 159,400

71-2014-4204584 N 71-09-16-428-006.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123033 400 023 09/30/2014 $250,000 1,500 0 1,500

71-2014-4204621 Y 71-09-18-455-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126282 510 026 09/30/2014 $50,000 3,900 48,900 52,800

71-2014-4204621 N 71-09-18-455-018.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126283 500 026 09/30/2014 $50,000 4,400 0 4,400

71-2014-4204632 Y 71-09-16-180-003.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123030 420 023 10/02/2014 $220,000 51,000 124,300 175,300

71-2014-4204632 N 71-09-16-180-002.000-023 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7123033 400 023 10/02/2014 $220,000 21,600 0 21,600

71-2014-4204680 Y 71-09-07-227-009.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126326 510 026 10/07/2014 $91,900 26,200 67,100 93,300

71-2014-4204680 N 71-09-07-227-008.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126327 500 026 10/07/2014 $91,900 22,000 0 22,000

71-2014-4204714 Y 71-08-02-226-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126400 510 026 10/09/2014 $119,500 34,800 65,300 100,100

71-2014-4204714 N 71-08-02-226-018.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126401 500 026 10/09/2014 $119,500 15,500 0 15,500

71-2014-4204728 Y 71-03-14-477-012.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 10/07/2014 $129,900 2,800 102,900 105,700

71-2014-4204728 N 71-03-14-477-011.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 10/07/2014 $129,900 2,300 0 2,300

71-2014-4205139 Y 71-08-13-276-003.000-026 Y Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126009 350 026 10/21/2014 $75,000 14,300 77,500 91,800

71-2014-4205139 N 71-08-13-276-002.000-026 Y Ind Imp Combined Ind Imp Portage 7126017 300 026 10/21/2014 $75,000 6,800 0 6,800

71-2014-4205222 Y 71-04-32-186-008.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103006 447 003 08/29/2014 $256,500 61,100 176,200 237,300

71-2014-4205222 N 71-04-32-186-007.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103010 400 003 08/29/2014 $256,500 24,700 0 24,700

71-2014-4205297 Y 71-08-11-134-011.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126384 510 026 11/03/2014 $64,900 1,700 50,000 51,700

71-2014-4205297 N 71-08-11-134-012.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126385 500 026 11/03/2014 $64,900 2,600 0 2,600

71-2014-4205297 N 71-08-11-134-015.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126385 500 026 11/03/2014 $64,900 1,100 0 1,100

71-2014-4205340 Y 71-04-26-126-007.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111043 510 011 11/06/2014 $115,000 24,300 83,600 107,900

71-2014-4205340 N 71-04-26-126-008.000-011 Y Res Imp None Harris 7111041 500 011 11/06/2014 $115,000 2,600 0 2,600

71-2014-4205525 Y 71-08-14-454-007.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 11/18/2014 $33,500 2,600 29,700 32,300

71-2014-4205525 N 71-08-14-454-008.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126237 500 026 11/18/2014 $33,500 3,300 0 3,300

71-2014-4205788 Y 71-08-13-332-019.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126244 510 026 12/02/2014 $37,000 1,000 48,800 49,800

71-2014-4205788 N 71-08-13-332-018.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126244 500 026 12/02/2014 $37,000 1,100 0 1,100

71-2014-4206041 Y 71-08-14-356-010.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126235 510 026 12/09/2014 $87,000 3,800 55,500 59,300

71-2014-4206041 N 71-08-14-356-011.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126237 500 026 12/09/2014 $87,000 4,600 0 4,600

71-2014-4206041 N 71-08-14-356-012.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126237 500 026 12/09/2014 $87,000 4,600 0 4,600

71-2014-4206053 Y 71-03-25-326-029.000-007 Y Res Imp None Clay 7107013 510 007 12/12/2014 $73,000 9,300 55,800 65,100

71-2014-4206053 N 71-03-25-326-028.000-007 Y Res Imp None Clay 7107018 500 007 12/12/2014 $73,000 3,400 0 3,400

71-2014-4206285 Y 71-08-35-326-004.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101010 510 001 12/17/2014 $442,000 22,400 255,500 277,900

71-2014-4206285 N 71-08-35-326-003.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101009 500 001 12/17/2014 $442,000 14,900 0 14,900

71-2014-4206516 Y 71-09-14-127-006.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $96,000 8,000 96,200 104,200

71-2014-4206516 N 71-09-14-127-007.000-023 Y Res Imp None Penn 7123071 510 023 12/22/2014 $96,000 5,300 0 5,300

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

71-2014-4206524 Y 71-04-20-157-003.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103050 510 003 12/31/2014 $144,900 35,600 117,200 152,800

71-2014-4206524 N 71-04-20-157-002.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103105 500 003 12/31/2014 $144,900 10,700 0 10,700

71-2014-4206538 Y 71-08-27-200-006.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102031 510 002 12/30/2014 $225,000 36,100 87,600 123,700

71-2014-4206538 N 71-08-27-200-005.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102032 500 002 12/30/2014 $225,000 2,500 0 2,500

71-2014-4206538 N 71-08-27-200-015.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102003 100 002 12/30/2014 $225,000 35,600 0 35,600

71-2014-4206544 Y 71-02-35-279-032.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129018 510 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 2,500 68,300 70,800

71-2014-4206544 N 71-02-35-279-034.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 2,100 0 2,100

71-2014-4206544 N 71-02-35-279-031.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 2,000 0 2,000

71-2014-4206544 N 71-02-35-279-033.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129068 500 029 12/31/2014 $150,000 6,400 0 6,400

71-2014-4206583 Y 71-08-13-305-036.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126156 499 026 10/31/2014 $20,000 6,000 1,800 7,800

71-2014-4206583 N 71-08-13-305-035.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126174 499 026 10/31/2014 $20,000 400 100 500

71-2014-4206615 Y 71-08-22-101-002.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126044 300 026 12/17/2014 $85,000 10,000 0 10,000

71-2014-4206615 N 71-08-22-101-001.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126044 300 026 12/17/2014 $85,000 9,700 0 9,700

71-2014-4206638 Y 71-04-32-186-003.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103006 447 003 01/01/2015 $730,000 79,000 518,400 597,400

71-2014-4206638 N 71-04-32-186-004.000-003 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7103006 447 003 01/01/2015 $730,000 95,000 8,600 103,600

71-2014-4206648 Y 71-09-22-459-001.000-022 Y Res Imp None Penn 7122068 510 022 12/30/2014 $200,000 34,700 154,800 189,500

71-2014-4206648 N 71-09-22-459-002.000-022 Y Res Imp None Penn 7122068 500 022 12/30/2014 $200,000 8,800 0 8,800

71-2015-4200018 Y 71-04-19-353-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7102502 510 003 01/07/2015 $109,000 2,900 103,100 106,000

71-2015-4200018 N 71-04-19-353-008.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103112 500 003 01/07/2015 $109,000 2,900 0 2,900

71-2015-4200018 N 71-04-19-353-010.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103112 500 003 01/07/2015 $109,000 2,900 0 2,900

71-2015-4200060 Y 71-03-22-426-009.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108050 510 008 01/14/2015 $71,000 9,900 54,400 64,300

71-2015-4200060 N 71-03-22-426-010.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108049 500 008 01/14/2015 $71,000 9,600 0 9,600

71-2015-4200071 Y 71-13-07-254-005.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110017 510 010 01/14/2015 $162,000 20,100 116,900 137,000

71-2015-4200071 N 71-13-07-254-006.000-010 Y Res Imp None Greene 7110016 500 010 01/14/2015 $162,000 19,800 0 19,800

71-2015-4200085 Y 71-03-13-253-038.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 01/16/2015 $45,000 6,900 42,000 48,900

71-2015-4200085 N 71-03-13-253-034.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 01/16/2015 $45,000 3,900 0 3,900

71-2015-4200085 N 71-03-13-253-033.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 01/16/2015 $45,000 3,100 0 3,100

71-2015-4200243 Y 71-03-25-326-001.000-007 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7107420 428 007 01/29/2015 $439,100 55,800 338,200 394,000

71-2015-4200243 N 71-03-25-326-003.000-007 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7107010 453 007 01/29/2015 $439,100 34,300 20,000 54,300

71-2015-4200243 N 71-03-25-326-002.000-007 N Com Imp Combined Com Imp Clay 7107001 456 007 01/29/2015 $439,100 43,300 4,600 47,900

71-2015-4200299 Y 71-08-36-127-006.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101013 510 001 02/10/2015 $75,000 7,300 79,500 86,800

71-2015-4200299 N 71-08-36-127-007.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101016 500 001 02/10/2015 $75,000 3,400 0 3,400

71-2015-4200458 Y 71-03-13-208-011.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103034 510 003 02/18/2015 $115,000 10,500 61,800 72,300

71-2015-4200458 N 71-03-13-208-010.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103095 500 003 02/18/2015 $115,000 7,200 0 7,200

71-2015-4200459 Y 71-02-26-351-002.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129017 510 029 02/18/2015 $142,900 17,500 103,000 120,500

71-2015-4200459 N 71-02-26-351-001.000-029 Y Res Imp None Warren 7129067 500 029 02/18/2015 $142,900 17,500 0 17,500

71-2015-4200462 Y 71-04-31-478-063.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 02/18/2015 $160,000 2,900 180,900 183,800

71-2015-4200462 N 71-04-31-478-022.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 02/18/2015 $160,000 0 19,800 19,800

71-2015-4200475 Y 71-08-12-206-005.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 01/23/2015 $100,000 15,800 54,700 70,500

71-2015-4200475 N 71-08-12-206-004.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126076 447 026 01/23/2015 $100,000 15,800 0 15,800

C71-2013-4207209 Y 71-03-35-382-014.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126017 300 026 01/08/2014 $25,000 26,000 0 26,000

C71-2013-4207209 N 71-03-35-382-013.000-026 Y Ind Vac Combined Ind Vac Portage 7126017 399 026 01/08/2014 $25,000 10,000 900 10,900

C71-2014-4200093 Y 71-04-32-153-004.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103130 510 003 01/17/2014 $87,000 4,100 65,400 69,500

C71-2014-4200093 N 71-04-32-153-005.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103125 500 003 01/17/2014 $87,000 3,200 0 3,200

C71-2014-4200112 Y 71-03-15-206-010.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108029 510 008 01/22/2014 $131,000 15,700 77,300 93,000

C71-2014-4200112 N 71-03-15-206-009.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108030 500 008 01/22/2014 $131,000 15,700 0 15,700

C71-2014-4200112 N 71-03-15-206-015.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108030 500 008 01/22/2014 $131,000 16,200 0 16,200

C71-2014-4200118 Y 71-03-24-403-014.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7102500 510 003 01/30/2014 $48,500 3,800 51,800 55,600

C71-2014-4200118 N 71-03-24-403-013.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103112 500 003 01/30/2014 $48,500 2,900 0 2,900

C71-2014-4200284 Y 71-08-12-231-006.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126075 442 026 01/29/2014 $180,000 30,300 88,800 119,100

C71-2014-4200284 N 71-08-12-231-007.000-026 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Portage 7126350 400 026 01/29/2014 $180,000 2,500 0 2,500

C71-2014-4200330 Y 71-03-13-428-020.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 02/11/2014 $65,000 7,200 37,300 44,500

C71-2014-4200330 N 71-03-13-428-019.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103111 500 003 02/11/2014 $65,000 10,500 0 10,500

C71-2014-4200357 Y 71-04-18-301-009.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103063 510 003 02/10/2014 $150,000 12,700 75,200 87,900

C71-2014-4200357 N 71-04-18-301-010.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103111 500 003 02/10/2014 $150,000 6,800 0 6,800

C71-2014-4200427 Y 71-03-35-103-006.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126417 510 026 02/14/2014 $101,000 11,700 79,100 90,800

C71-2014-4200427 N 71-03-35-103-005.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126418 500 026 02/14/2014 $101,000 10,500 0 10,500

C71-2014-4200565 Y 71-12-32-254-011.000-035 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 510 035 02/27/2014 $70,000 10,400 31,300 41,700

C71-2014-4200565 N 71-12-32-254-009.000-035 Y Res Imp None Liberty 7135020 500 035 02/27/2014 $70,000 24,900 0 24,900

C71-2014-4200575 Y 71-03-14-330-001.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103070 510 003 02/28/2014 $219,436 10,800 150,100 160,900

C71-2014-4200575 N 71-03-14-330-002.000-003 Y Res Imp None Clay 7103116 500 003 02/28/2014 $219,436 22,200 0 22,200

C71-2014-4200578 Y 71-03-16-279-001.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108027 510 008 02/28/2014 $125,000 28,400 114,700 143,100

C71-2014-4200578 N 71-03-16-279-010.000-008 Y Res Imp None German 7108041 500 008 02/28/2014 $125,000 5,600 0 5,600

C71-2014-4200716 Y 71-08-24-137-001.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126262 510 026 03/11/2014 $91,500 4,600 58,100 62,700

C71-2014-4200716 N 71-08-24-137-002.000-026 Y Res Imp None Portage 7126264 500 026 03/11/2014 $91,500 3,600 0 3,600

C71-2014-4200728 Y 71-10-09-277-004.000-031 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7131018 460 031 03/12/2014 $75,000 61,600 12,300 73,900

C71-2014-4200728 N 71-10-09-277-003.000-031 Y Com Imp Combined Com Imp Penn 7131021 400 031 03/12/2014 $75,000 15,800 0 15,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx

C71-2014-4200805 Y 71-08-36-476-020.000-002 Y Res Imp None Centre 7102036 510 002 03/19/2014 $205,000 32,100 139,700 171,800

C71-2014-4200805 N 71-08-36-476-009.000-001 Y Res Imp None Centre 7101038 599 001 03/19/2014 $205,000 1,600 14,800 16,400

C71-2014-4200841 Y 71-04-31-478-046.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 03/19/2014 $125,000 2,900 145,600 148,500

C71-2014-4200841 N 71-04-31-478-027.000-004 Y Res Imp None Clay 7104031 550 004 03/19/2014 $125,000 0 19,800 19,800

7/21/2015 S:\Assessment\2015 Annual Adjustments\2015 DLGF ANALYSIS FOLDER\Saint Joseph\ST. JOSEPH 2015 RATIO STUDY.xlsx