40
EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM February 6, 2013 Room I2-220 Washington, DC EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark Assessment Systems Part 2

SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

February 6, 2013

Room I2-220 Washington, DC

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

to Benchmark Assessment Systems

Part 2

Page 3: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

What is the READ Trust Fund?

“Better Assessment for Better Learning”

Page 4: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Global-level and Country-level Work

Main READ Trust Fund

Global-level Work

READ Angola

READ Armenia

READ Ethiopia

READ Kyrgyz

Republic

READ Mozambique

READ Tajikistan

READ Vietnam

READ Zambia

Country-level Work

SABER Student

Assessment

SABER Learning

Standards

Program Coordination

Global Knowledge

Sharing

Page 5: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Armenia

Page 6: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Establishing Key Indicators for READ

Enabling Context • EC1 - Clear policies • EC2 - Strong leadership • EC3 - Regular budget/funds • EC4 - Strong organizational structures • EC5 - Effective human resources System Alignment • SA1 - Alignment with learning goals • SA2 - Opportunities to learn about assessment activities Assessment Quality • AQ1 - Quality • AQ2 - Effective use of assessment results

Page 7: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Mozambique

Page 8: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Page 9: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Mozambique’s Baseline Results (2009)

Classroom Examinations NLSA ILSA

Emerging

Emerging

Emerging

Emerging

Page 10: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Developing an Action Plan

Page 11: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Targeted Areas - Mozambique

Classroom Examinations NLSA ILSA

Emerging

Emerging

Emerging

Emerging

Page 12: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Mapping Action Plan Activities to Rubrics

Page 13: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Page 14: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

2009 (Before READ) 2014 (After READ) Expected Progress

Classroom Assessment Lat. Eme. Est. Adv. Alignment with learning goals

• Scarce system-wide resources for teachers for classroom assessment

• Official curriculum specifies what students are expected to learn but the level of performance required is unclear

• Some system-wide resources for teachers on classroom assessment

• Official curriculum specifies what students are expected to learn and the expected level of performance required is clear

Effective human resources

• No system-level mechanisms to ensure teachers develop skills in classroom assessment

• Some system-level mechanisms to ensure teachers develop skills in classroom assessment

Quality assurance

• Classroom assessment practices known to have widespread weaknesses

• Classroom assessment practices weak but improving

Effective uses

• Limited use of classroom assessment

• Adequate required uses of classroom assessment to support student learning

Page 15: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Expected Level of Development of Mozambique’s Assessment System

Page 16: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

EC5 – Effective Human Resources

Page 17: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

SA2 - Opportunities to learn about assessment activities

Page 18: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

AQ1— Assessment Quality “Provinha” Pre-Pilot

D2/N2 Identificar as letras do alfabeto.

D02/N1

5. Presta atenção às letras que vou dizer “v” “d” “l”.

Assinala com X o quadradinho das letras que ouviste “v” “d” “l”

A)

B)

C)

D)

a c q

v d l

b h o

t r s

Professor(a)/aplicador(a): leia para os alunos a instrução em que aparece a orelha. Repita a leitura no máximo duas vezes.

República de Moçambique

Ministério da Educação Instituto Nacional de Desenvolvimento da Educação - INDE

PROVINHA-MOCAMBIQUE

Page 19: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

AQ1— Assessment Quality “Provinha” Pilot Teacher’s Workshop

Page 20: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

AQ1— Assessment Quality “Provinha” Pilot Test Administration

Page 21: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Directors of Instruction Workshop

SA2 - Opportunities to learn about assessment activities

Page 22: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Expected Level of Development of Mozambique’s Assessment System

Page 23: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Tajikistan

Page 24: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Page 25: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Tajikistan Baseline Results (2009)

Classroom Examinations NLSA ILSA

Emerging

Emerging

Latent

Latent

Page 26: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Developing an Action Plan

Page 28: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Targeted Areas - Tajikistan

Classroom Examinations NLSA ILSA

Emerging

Emerging

Latent

Latent

Page 29: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Mapping Action Plan Activities to Rubric (Examinations)

Page 30: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Page 31: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

2009 (Before READ) 2014 (After READ) Expected Progress

Examinations (University Entrance) Lat. Eme. Est. Adv. Clear policies

• A formal policy document authorizes the examination (but not the new UEE)

• Policy document not available to the public

• Procedural, regulatory, and legal documents developed for national introduction of new UEE

• Policy documents available to the public

Strong leadership

• Most stakeholders support the examinations (but not the current practices)

• Almost all stakeholders support the new UEE system and deem the system to be fair and reliable

Regular funding

• Funding does not cover research and development

• Stable funding available to conduct UEEs annually

• Funding covers research and development

Page 32: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

2009 (Before READ) 2014 (After READ) Expected Progress

Examinations (University Entrance) Lat. Eme. Est. Adv. Strong org. structures

• An examinations office does not exist

• A new National Testing Center:

- developed and piloted - accountable to the Ministry

of Education - has all of the required

facilities to carry out the examination

Effective human resources

• Staff carrying out examinations inadequately trained and issues pervasive

• National Testing Center adequately staffed and training provided to enable staff to carry out UEE with minimal issues

Alignment with learning goals

• Not clear what the examination measures

• Materials to prepare for the examination minimal and accessible to very few students

• A clear understanding of what the examination measures exists

• Student and School Handbooks about the examination developed and avail. to most students

Page 33: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

2009 (Before READ) 2014 (After READ) Expected Progress

Examinations (University Entrance) Lat. Eme. Est. Adv. Quality assurance

• No technical documentation exists

• No mechanisms in place to ensure quality of the examination

• An UEE comprehensive, technical report is available and copies are distributed

• Some mechanisms in place to ensure quality of the examination including the piloting of test instruments

Fairness • Inappropriate behavior surrounding the examination process is high

• The majority of students (over 50%) may not take the examination due to barriers such as language, gender, etc.

• Inappropriate behavior surrounding the examination process is low

• A small proportion of students (less than 10%) may not take the examination due to barriers such as language, gender, etc.

Page 34: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Expected Level of Development of Tajikistan’s Assessment System

Page 35: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

EC2 - Strong Leadership

Page 36: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

EC4 - Strong organizational structures

Page 37: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

EC5 – Effective Human Resources

Page 38: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

EC5 – Effective Human Resources

Page 39: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

SA2 Opportunities to Learn about Assessment Activities

Page 40: SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment to Benchmark ... · EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM . February 6, 2013 . Room I2-220 . Washington, DC. SESSION 3 Using SABER-Student Assessment

EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM EDUCATION STAFF DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM

Expected Level of Development of Tajikistan’s Assessment System